<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by MetforminSol on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by MetforminSol on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@MetforminSol?source=rss-09ea9d9db1d3------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 17:12:50 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@MetforminSol/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Adaptation of Tardigrades to Extreme Environmental Conditions: Molecular Mechanisms and Potential…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MetforminSol/adaptation-of-tardigrades-to-extreme-environmental-conditions-molecular-mechanisms-and-potential-c9c45f551378?source=rss-09ea9d9db1d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c9c45f551378</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[extreme]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[water-bears]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tardigrade]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[desci]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MetforminSol]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 11 Dec 2024 06:26:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-11T06:26:53.624Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*7LgvWTekgtKyCDfB" /></figure><h3>Adaptation of Tardigrades to Extreme Environmental Conditions: Molecular Mechanisms and Potential Applications</h3><h3>1. Introduction</h3><p>Tardigrades are microscopic invertebrates with a non-segmented body and a cuticle exoskeleton and are commonly called <strong>‘water bears</strong>’ due to their peculiar morphology. Over the past century, they have often been considered the most extreme and stress-tolerant animals. They exhibit anhydrobiosis, cryptobiosis, and anoxibiosis as the main physiological responses under in vitro extreme environmental conditions, such as places where ultraviolet or ionizing radiation-resistant bacteria are distributed. They cloned putative dauer anhydrobiosis signaling ligands and stress-inducible antioxidants of the assessed North Siberian Paramacrobiotus richtersi.</p><p>The molecular mechanism of resistance to stressful conditions in animals should be studied to understand tardigrade adaptation to extreme environmental conditions. Moreover, because of their extremely high stress-tolerant behavior under unfavorable environments, these ‘water bears’ are considered useful in the fields of aeronautics, astronautics, biomedicine, gene engineering, biotechnology, and studies on space exploration. Natural science-oriented researchers, including those in the field of environmental science, have attempted to identify tolerant animals by applying molecular biology techniques to biological resources living in environmental conditions where people cannot survive. Therefore, it is necessary to have a deeper understanding of the environmental science of molecular biology in order to understand the adaptation of tardigrades. This review paper discusses the possible molecular adaptation mechanisms during various stress reactions of tardigrades.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Bgerlk65Er8M5S_Wj5VltQ.png" /></figure><h3>1.1. Overview of Tardigrades</h3><p>Tardigrades belong to the phylum Tardigrada and are also known as <strong>water bears</strong>. They are small microorganisms mostly residing in the aquatic environment and exhibit remarkable survival strategies that allow them to tolerate extreme conditions. The name “tardigrade” originates from Latin to describe their sluggish and sedate gait. Based on their unique morphology, tardigrades were initially classified within the group of Arthropoda. However, they were subsequently placed either within the wingless arthropods or as a separate phylum.</p><p>Tardigrades exhibit a wide diversity of ecological roles. They thrive in a range of terrestrial ecosystems, where they passively ride winds for hundreds of kilometers. Over 1,000 species are known to be dispersal-limited transmigrators, with the potential to repopulate melting polar ice caps, clouds, or alien planets. Tardigrades of about 1,000 species are known, occurring from the deepest sea to the tallest mountaintop and in the tropics to polar regions.</p><p>Various phyla, families, genera, and species are known. However, only some species have been found to be stress-resistant within the superphylum Ecdysozoa. Given their presence on both poles, tardigrades are among the few groups of metazoans that have colonized all continents. Tardigrades have evolved sophisticated strategies to adjust to different habitats and residential changes, such as land colonization. Data also shows that tardigrade species diversity tends to be higher with a decreasing latitude.</p><h3>1.2. Significance of Studying Tardigrade Adaptation</h3><p>Many exceptional features of tardigrades and the mechanisms that allow these animals to resist extreme environmental conditions have been extensively studied. Although these animals are considered incredibly tolerant to high and low temperatures, desiccation, radiation, and chemically unfavorable environments, several reports have highlighted tardigrade susceptibility to different physical and chemical factors. Adaptation of tardigrades to a wide range of extreme conditions provides insights into life’s limits on Earth and potentially on other planets.</p><p>The main biological and biotechnological importance of investigating these exceptional organisms is that understanding their remarkable abilities potentially reveals insights into resistance and adaptation to hostile conditions in plants, bacteria, and nematodes, including those that are harmful to humans and agriculture. Physicochemical factors lead to disease or lethality in humans and animals. Therefore, understanding tardigrade-specific molecular mechanisms of resistance would enable scientists to design fundamentally new strategies for protecting living organisms, including humans, under adverse conditions. Moreover, these results explain tardigrade resistance to different hospital treatments and cleaning tests aimed at deactivating specific infectious agents.</p><p>In particular, a detailed understanding of the resistance to long-term survival while inanimate could provide new methods for biopreservation and the development of stress-resistant crops. Finally, one of the most discussed topics related to tardigrades is the interest of scientists and society in space exploration and astrobiology. They are the first discovered animals that can survive in open space and can endure at least several years of various space conditions. Astrobiological studies are of interest due to potential applications in human space exploration, the search for extraterrestrial life, and the manipulation of panspermia.</p><p>The rediscovery of tardigrades after hosting them in space for long-term missions is expected to produce a great public response. It has been noted that in addition to applied significance, tardigrade research in space can provide new knowledge on life’s fundamental capabilities, including resistance to the space environment, genetics, reproduction, development, evolution, etc. As evident by the wide range of organisms in which aPARLs have been found, this observation-based framework appears to propagate knowledge rather than more taxa-specific rarifiable elasticities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zKpZwlt9YazROc9-jhw41g.png" /></figure><h3>2. Extreme Environmental Conditions</h3><p>Most terrestrial environments show little to moderate variations in the abiotic factors relevant to biological organisms (e.g., temperature, water availability, pH, radiation, or hydrostatic pressure). In contrast, extreme environmental conditions fluctuate more prominently in a matter of hours (e.g., in the polar-tidal, cyclical frozen habitats) or throughout seasons and years (e.g., terrestrial polar habitats or hot deserts). Therefore, many biological organisms have adapted to those extreme modulations, thereby surviving in those habitats. Classical extreme environmental conditions are extreme temperatures, radiation, high salt concentrations, low water availability, acid or alkaline conditions, and, in the case of some phylogenetic groups such as those adapted to deserts, dehydration for at least some periods of the life cycle.</p><p>Extreme environmental conditions often have harmful effects on organisms, down to cellular structures including proteins, lipids, and DNA. Species not adapted to such a particular stressor can often survive for only a limited time, if at all. Increases in cell division errors, membrane damage, aggregation of toxic proteins, low water content, or high intracellular concentrations of reactive oxygen species can lead to the impairment of various cellular processes, eventually resulting in increased mortality. Overall, living in an extreme environment has even more serious implications at a superorganismic system level, especially for poikilohydric invertebrates. Increasing our understanding of stressor effects, and hence the potentialities and limits of adaptation to selection processes in special microhabitats in the context of direct and/or global climate changes, is of utmost importance.</p><h3>2.1. Types of Extreme Environments</h3><p>In most cases and in the general public consciousness, extremophilic microorganisms are linked to a distinction commonly made between terrestrial environments, such as polar regions or deserts, and hydrostatic environments, such as the deep sea and hot smokers. Terrestrial extreme habitats caused by low water activity include hyperarid subdeserts as well as deserts and the polar regions represented by the Arctic and Antarctic. As is well known, these two different environmental types pose similar problems for living organisms in terms of their primary cause but imply quite dissimilar characteristic features. Among the most famous characteristics of deserts are the high daily and seasonal temperature fluctuations, high aridity, and averagely low temperatures compared to other biotopes. From a biological point of view, these climates represent considerable selective pressures with respect to endothermy or exothermy in order to prevent cold injuries in animals.</p><p>Aquatic extremophilic organisms inhabit, among others, waters with low temperatures in the Arctic and Antarctic as well as in the deep sea. Their home at hydrothermal vents is characterized by reducing conditions, making them capable of colonizing basalt rock, brine, and hydrothermal vent animals, which would be toxic or harmful under normal conditions. More than 40 different osmolarities have been discovered for the various prevalent marine organism species that live in very saline brines of marine hypersaline bodies and solar saltern ponds with salinities ranging from intermediate to high ranges. Organisms that inhabit the deep-sea coastal environments can be subjected to stronger variations in temperature, salinity, and nutrient availability compared with those found in the open-ocean deep sea.</p><h3>2.2. Challenges Faced by Organisms in Extreme Environments</h3><p>Life in extreme environments offers many challenges to the organisms that are capable of surviving under these conditions. These can be highly diverse, depending on the specific extreme environment, and include changes in pH, osmolality, salinity, or temperature. Physiological stressors in extreme environments with high potential to lead to cell death include desiccation, hypoxia, and high radiation levels. Desiccation and extreme temperatures can result in a phase transition of water that in turn leads to denaturation of proteins and, in the case of hypoxia, damage to metabolic processes. High radiation levels can result in DNA damage.</p><p>Repeated cycles of desiccation and rehydration can lead to pronounced DNA double-strand breaks caused by the reoxidation of reduced suppressors of desiccation-induced somatic oxidative stress. Moreover, maintenance of protein functionality may be compromised through a number of diverse and nonexclusive mechanisms, including decreased conformational stability, denaturation, and the loss of biological activity; thermal unfolding; inactivation; aggregation; and increased susceptibility of proteins to proteolysis.</p><p>The hypothesis that the degree of protein stability is positively correlated with an organism’s tendency to survive presupposes that metabolism plays a key role in determining the limits of life in general and in influencing the probability of anhydrobiosis development. The amount of metabolism occurring will dictate the speed of desiccation and the refractive index, temperature through hysteresis, and osmolality. Osmolality together with the mechanical properties of anhydrobiotic animal cells and their membranes may also influence anhydrobiosis in respects as different not only as speed of desiccation but also in the limits of life. Low levels of protective solute may be unsafe as membrane composition is uniform and thus liable to denaturation when a required percentage of glycerol is not present. Cells also display putrescine and cadaverine, both of which buffer the cellular pH, which will in turn alter the free energy for protein folding and increase or decrease the cellular chances for desiccation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cv0MrMZnIsA5ds0lFo907Q.png" /></figure><h3>3. Molecular Mechanisms of Tardigrade Adaptation</h3><p>Tardigrades (<strong>water bears</strong>) are microscopic organisms that can tolerate a variety of extreme environmental conditions, including cyclic wet and drying conditions. Tardigrades have two forms of cryptobiosis, anhydrobiosis and cryptobiosis, allowing them to transform from active metabolizing animals into an inert state in which the metabolism required to maintain homeostasis is almost undetectable. These two traits have helped tardigrades survive in extreme environments with severe environmental stresses. The basic strategies for surviving environmental stresses in anhydrobiotic and cryptobiotic tardigrades require the following: maintaining cellular integrity in the desiccated state, critically repairing damaged biomolecules, and ensuring that metabolism restarts after desiccation. The utilization of these classical strategies is, however, changed and modified in tardigrades in order to maintain viability under severe environmental stresses.</p><p>After desiccation and inactivation, repair processes of some of the damaged macromolecules prepared for protecting and recovering cellular integrity, needed after rehydration, include a DNA protection mechanism reducing genome damage and activating DNA repair. Trehalose was shown to protect both single- and double-stranded DNA from hydroxyl radicals, which generate both single- and double-strand breaks but also other kinds of DNA damage. Using a combination of reverse genetics and RNA interference, it was recently shown that cytoplasmic catalase functions in protection from desiccation-induced protein damage.</p><p>Formation of protein aggregates could contribute to cellular damage, for example, by inhibiting protein translocation across the endoplasmic reticulum. The formation of large protein aggregates occurs only after desiccation but not during the process of entering anhydrobiosis in tardigrades. One way to avoid such aggregation during desiccation is the conversion of soluble proteins into glass-like β-pleated sheet oligomers. Acquiring this structure, along with a great diversity of late embryogenesis abundant proteins with different functions in the protection of desiccated systems, probably favors rapid removal of protein aggregations and restart of enzymatic activity after rehydration.</p><h3>3.1. Anhydrobiosis and Cryptobiosis</h3><p>Tardigrades have become famous for their remarkable adaptations to environments at the extreme. One of them is their ability to survive desiccation by entering a dormant state referred to as anhydrobiosis. The term ‘cryptobiosis’ refers to the absence of visible metabolic activity, which is, in the case of tardigrades, one of the possible responses to desiccation. There are some environmental conditions, for instance, high pressure or extremely low or high temperature, that will not allow anhydrobiotic tardigrades to remain active, and therefore, in those cases, tardigrades enter another state of cryptobiosis, for example, anoxybiosis. Usually, anhydrobiosis in tardigrades is associated either with severe desiccation, temperature, and other conditions remaining non-stressful during the entire process, or with non-damaging freezing.</p><p>Anhydrobiotic tardigrades can survive without water for a very long time, from years to decades, and can recover to the active state after a few hours of rehydration. The mechanisms involved in the acquisition of an anhydrobiotic state in water bears are not yet fully understood, but it is known that trehalose is produced in large amounts and acts as a protective agent preventing harm to cells; it is believed to act in protection of proteins and membranes, prevent hydroxyl radical-mediated damage, and modulate lipid matrix structures to form a reversible gel. Trehalose crystallization upon desiccation may facilitate tardigrade anhydrobiosis. Tardigrade loss of cytosol during drying is a further indicator of a desiccation-adaptive mechanism.</p><h3>3.2. DNA Repair Mechanisms</h3><p>The control and repair of DNA damage are crucial for the maintenance of genomic integrity in all living organisms. Indeed, resistance to DNA damage is crucial for any species, and the repair mechanisms can play a role in the ability of the organism to adapt to its ecological niche. Some of the most important environmental stressors that all organisms have to face during their lives are ionizing radiation and reactive oxygen species production, which is a renewed threat that organisms had to face with the permanent oxygenation of the atmosphere around 2.4 billion years ago. Many molecules are modified by the highly reactive hydroxyl radical, particularly in eukaryotic cells, leading to alterations in nucleotides and breaking the sugar-phosphate backbone. Today’s Earth organisms have evolved to live in a stable atmosphere, and the more recent radiation is usually considered less significant due to better repair mechanisms. However, tolerance to high doses of ionizing radiation is an interesting ecological trait because only a few species show efficient radiotolerance.</p><p>Moreover, tardigrades show enhanced resistance to ionizing radiation, and significant radioresistance is linked to their ability to repair damaged DNA. The repair of chromosomal breaks is an essential process for cell survival, which is why living organisms have evolved to have sophisticated DNA repair machinery. In eukaryotes, the dominant form of DNA repair of radiation-generated DNA double-strand breaks is mediated by the non-homologous end joining pathway. Notably, mishandling radiation-generated DNA damage is also responsible for false signaling events to apoptosis and the generation of genome instability because replication forks can collapse into DNA double-strand breaks.</p><p>Homologous recombination repair is required to restart collapsed replication forks by invading a sister chromatid to copy the missing information following ionizing radiation. Homologous recombination is also essential to deal with endogenous defects in DNA repair, for example, at telomeres, where specific translocation between broken chromosomes can generate complex cytogenetic rearrangements. Thus, chromosomal breaks have to be correctly repaired to ensure chromosomal segregation and proper proliferation.</p><h3>3.3. Protein Stabilization and Protection</h3><p>Short-term adaptation. Protein stabilization and protection. Despite an absence of metabolic activity in dried LSC, protein integrity is highly preserved, thus aiding in the re-establishment of normal metabolic conditions after rehydration. Protective proteins have been detected in Parachaela models such as Ramazzottius varieornatus and Hypsibius exemplaris, although their loss did not affect tardigrade desiccation tolerance. A proteomic survey in the cryptic species Hypsibius dujardini identified an enrichment in proteins containing intrinsically disordered structures as well as a clade of cellular globular proteins, some of which are classified as late embryogenesis abundant proteins after desiccation treatment. These proteins are strongly hydrophilic and exert a protective role against high salt conditions. Their presence is functional in reducing in vitro protein denaturation and aggregation brought on by desiccation or high salt concentration. The global loss of protein structure is a hallmark that many organisms cope with using additional components, named molecular chaperones, as they can stabilize unfolded proteins and participate in the refolding of misfolded proteins.</p><p>Tardigrades and related organisms inhabiting temporary or fluctuating aquatic environments are exposed to atmospheric oxygen when their habitats temporarily dry out and present a minimal oxidation system to be rehydrated via activating the two-cysteine peroxiredoxin-immunophilin complex and polyubiquitinating stress-damaged proteins, which should be composed of the complex as a ubiquitin ligase andas well as substrates. In conclusion, LSC biostrategies include protein protection against aggregation and misfolding, primarily gating the closer water influx/efflux in heavily leaving the integuments and cytoplasm and reducing the amount of cytoplasm available. Such strategies focusing on proteins can include uses for industrial purposes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cWYXYTHUgc2cFc8BgMIiNA.png" /></figure><blockquote>4. Potential Applications</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Biotechnology: </strong>Practical applications could result from studies that unravel the underlying molecular and morphological strategies of tardigrades to cope with physiological stress factors and to enable their exceptional tolerance. — The molecular mechanisms of biopreservation will receive promising insights. In addition, the development of drugs that affect radiation sensitivity and stress tolerance of natural medical microbiomes could benefit from the enormous evolutionary pressure towards resistance in tardigrades.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Medical Application in Organ Preservation</strong><em>:</em> Medical applications could also follow from possible concepts related to improving technologies for organ preservation, which will help buy more time for transplant organs.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Agriculture</strong>: Because tardigrades can help to optimally adapt the microbiome to extreme weather conditions, a positive feedback loop of tardigrades and vertical microbiome transmission via their eggs can be envisioned. This would be particularly beneficial in enhancing and promoting sustainable agriculture in the face of ever-stronger climate threats.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Space Research and Astrobiology: </strong>Research on tardigrades is also appropriate in view of the search for extremophiles suitable as model systems for planetary protection and research stock that are as resistant as possible to outer space conditions. — Long-term survival issues of organisms in space research are assessed in so-called astrobiological studies to complement Earth-based laboratory and computer or theoretical designs. The potential applications are subdivided into different sections.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Synthetic Biology:</strong><em> </em>Detailed analysis of their protein, mRNA, and genetic molecule properties could further facilitate the use of tardigrades as a potential basis for the development of synthetic biology.</blockquote><h3>4.1. Biotechnological and Medical Applications</h3><p>Undoubtedly, the research on molecular mechanisms underlying tardigrade anhydrobiosis and cryptobiosis serves as a starting point for a better understanding of life in extreme states and opens a window to potential practical applications. It has been shown that tardigrade anhydrobionts, like the species of the Ramazzottius genus, can be used as excellent model organisms for investigations of bioprotective reactions under extreme environmental conditions and in the medical, biotechnological, or agricultural fields. Molecular insights into the protective protein and gene networks of tardigrades have already opened new avenues that might be used to develop new biopreservation techniques for the storage and cold transport of biological material.</p><p>The main biotechnological application can be seen in the attempt to convert a dry range with an irradiation sterilized field of human or animal organs or tissues into a state of cryptobiosis, serving as a stationary shuttle for implantation when needed. Moreover, the application of new biotechnological insights to improve desiccation tolerance of seeds or to develop model plant systems to decipher plant stress tolerance mechanisms is already on the market. Furthermore, the use of single cDNA clones coding for these highly stable proteins of tardigrades and suitable cloning of this cDNA into expression vectors of some suitable target proteins or plant crops aims to increase dehydration tolerance and seed viability. This idea grants the developer copyrights for commercially desirable results. Collecting such patents by different scientists and successful experiments can open new insights into the development of transgenic plants where plant-protective proteins and antioxidants of tardigrades work directly as the natural defensive factory of transgenic plants. Genetic technology, together with data on the expression of the protein network of drought-tolerant tardigrades located on the chromosomal collection of omics organs of members of their polytolerant populations, would allow for a significant impact to stimulate the latest successes in the world of biotechnology and agricultural sciences.</p><h3>4.2. Space Exploration and Astrobiology</h3><p>The possibility of life beyond Earth and the exploration of extraterrestrial environments opened the disciplines of astrobiology and extremophiles, whose studies are mainly focused on adaptations to environmental limits on Earth (primarily microorganisms). However, there is a paucity of evidence regarding the frontiers up to which metazoans are able to colonize and permanently live in extreme environments. These studies might be important for the definition of biosignatures on other celestial bodies, as life that could adapt to live on other planets probably would have similar extreme adaptations in even less habitable environments on Earth. On the other hand, future space missions and exobiological studies concerned about contamination of other planets accidentally introduce thousands of terrestrial species. This has direct implications for planetary protection, meaning that only specific classes of extremophiles can be sent to other celestial bodies in the search for life in extraterrestrial environments. In this way, the study of the adaptations of these organisms might contribute to the limitation of biological loading on missions, reducing their risks. Research on the probable mechanisms of spread of tardigrades can contribute to the understanding of the biological limits of life on interplanetary trafficking, the planet hopping hypothesis, and panspermia. This would bring biological and planetary sciences to the field of astrophysics.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YwI52aE4RnvzLDUC95z77Q.png" /></figure><h3>5. Conclusion and Future Directions</h3><p>To date, tardigrades represent a group of unique models to study the molecular mechanisms of cryptobiosis and the formation of cellular anhydrobiosis. The genetic basis underlying the development of extreme resistance in tardigrades is of special interest in relation to the creation of biotechnological systems resistant to extreme environmental conditions. Regarding the natural history of tardigrades, we can suggest that they have gained such resistance in the course of evolution as an adaptation to unpredictable temperature changes, which occur in small water bodies. Given their ability to form extreme forms of anhydrobiosis, their role in the ecology of terrestrial and freshwater ecosystems remains to be determined. Also, the practical applications of the analysis of cryptobiotic adaptations go beyond the field of classical biology. There is considerable optimism regarding the potential applications of tardigrade research, for example, in astrobiology, the pharmaceutical industry, environmental biotechnology, and bioengineering. Experiments have already been carried out to incorporate tardigrade genes into plants. They might provide valuable information about how to best store and sequence DNA in the harsh environment of outer space. Moreover, the exploitation of animal and plant dormancy can provide humankind with nature-inspired strategies to cope with climate changes.</p><p>Our present understanding of the distribution of genes that allow tardigrades to stay alive when facing severe environmental adversities raises more questions than answers, in particular about the possible European or Asian origin of these microorganisms. Further long-term studies, including physical and molecular taxonomy, are required in order to confirm the current classification of tardigrades and to understand their phylogenetic position and course of evolution by relating these Eutardigrada to other animal taxa. Recent work at the system level has suggested a role of mitochondria and metabolism in tardigrades’ cryptobiosis.</p><p>Although we could find preliminary support in the expression analysis of a specific species, a deeper investigation of energy metabolism in response to physical and metabolic anhydrobiosis should be carried out. Notably, a recent transcriptomic study on the effects of osmotic stress on a specific enzyme showed an increase in glycolysis. These results require better phylogenetic control and further analyses to determine whether the remodeling of the main energy route is specific to certain eutardigrade families and species or is conserved among the Metazoa.</p><p>Expanding our phylogenomic and transcriptomic analysis to more phylogenetically related tardigrade species may shed light on the ancestral mechanisms of these tiny animals.</p><p><strong>References:</strong></p><p>1. McManus CM, Faria DA, Lucci CM, Louvandini H, Pereira SA, Paiva SR. Heat stress effects on sheep: Are hair sheep more heat resistant?. Theriogenology. 2020 Oct 1;155:157–67. <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0093691X20303411">sciencedirect.com</a></p><p>2. Roszkowska M, Wojciechowska D, Kmita H, Cerbin S, Dziuba MK, Fiałkowska E, Sobkowiak R, Szydło W, Kaczmarek Ł. Tips and tricks how to culture water bears: simple protocols for culturing eutardigrades (Tardigrada) under laboratory conditions. The European Zoological Journal. 2021 Jan 1;88(1):449–65. <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/24750263.2021.1881631">tandfonline.com</a></p><p>3. Hesgrove C, Boothby TC. The biology of tardigrade disordered proteins in extreme stress tolerance. Cell Communication and Signaling. 2020. <a href="https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1186/s12964-020-00670-2.pdf">springer.com</a></p><p>4. Møbjerg N, Neves RC. New insights into survival strategies of tardigrades. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology Part A: Molecular &amp; Integrative Physiology. 2021 Apr 1;254:110890. <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1095643320302439">sciencedirect.com</a></p><p>5. Sadowska-Bartosz I, Bartosz G. Antioxidant Defense in the Toughest Animals on the Earth: Its Contribution to the Extreme Resistance of Tardigrades. International Journal of Molecular Sciences. 2024 Aug 1;25(15):8393. <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/1422-0067/25/15/8393">mdpi.com</a></p><p>6. Kasianchuk N, Rzymski P, Kaczmarek Ł. The biomedical potential of tardigrade proteins: A review. Biomedicine &amp; Pharmacotherapy. 2023. <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0753332222014524">sciencedirect.com</a></p><p>7. Dos Santos TB, Ribas AF, de Souza SG, Budzinski IG, Domingues DS. Physiological responses to drought, salinity, and heat stress in plants: a review. Stresses. 2022 Feb 16;2(1):113–35. <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2673-7140/2/1/9/pdf">mdpi.com</a></p><p>8. Ma L, Kong F, Sun K, Wang T et al. From classical radiation to modern radiation: past, present, and future of radiation mutation breeding. Frontiers in Public Health. 2021. <a href="https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpubh.2021.768071/pdf">frontiersin.org</a></p><p>9. Celebi Sozener Z, Ozdel Ozturk B, Cerci P, Turk M, Gorgulu Akin B, Akdis M, Altiner S, Ozbey U, Ogulur I, Mitamura Y, Yilmaz I. Epithelial barrier hypothesis: effect of the external exposome on the microbiome and epithelial barriers in allergic disease. Allergy. 2022 May;77(5):1418–49. <a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/all.15240">wiley.com</a></p><p>10. Carré L, Zaccai G, Delfosse X, Girard E et al. Relevance of earth-bound extremophiles in the search for extraterrestrial life. Astrobiology. 2022. <a href="https://hal.science/hal-03819312/document">hal.science</a></p><p>11. Irwin JA. Overview of extremophiles and their food and medical applications. InPhysiological and biotechnological aspects of extremophiles 2020 Jan 1 (pp. 65–87). Academic Press. <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B978012818322900006X">[HTML]</a></p><p>12. Parrilli E, Tedesco P, Fondi M, Tutino ML, Giudice AL, de Pascale D, Fani R. The art of adapting to extreme environments: the model system Pseudoalteromonas. Physics of Life Reviews. 2021 Mar 1;36:137–61. <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1571064519300661">[HTML]</a></p><p>13. Guo P, Wang TJ, Wang S, Peng X, Kim DH, Liu Y. Arabidopsis Histone Variant H2A. X Functions in the DNA Damage-Coupling Abscisic Acid Signaling Pathway. International Journal of Molecular Sciences. 2024 Aug 16;25(16):8940. <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/1422-0067/25/16/8940">mdpi.com</a></p><p>14. Rebecchi L, Boschetti C, Nelson DR. Extreme-tolerance mechanisms in meiofaunal organisms: a case study with tardigrades, rotifers and nematodes. Hydrobiologia. 2020. <a href="https://pearl.plymouth.ac.uk/bitstream/handle/10026.1/15359/Rebecchi%2C%20Boschetti%2C%20Nelson_2019.pdf?sequence=1&amp;isAllowed=n">plymouth.ac.uk</a></p><p>15. Ashfaq A, Clochard MC, Coqueret X, Dispenza C, Driscoll MS, Ulański P, Al-Sheikhly M. Polymerization reactions and modifications of polymers by ionizing radiation. Polymers. 2020 Nov 30;12(12):2877. <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4360/12/12/2877/pdf">mdpi.com</a></p><p>16. Møbjerg N, Michalczyk Ł, Mcinnes SJ, Christenhusz MJ. Research presented at the 14th International Symposium on Tardigrada: progress in studies on water bears. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society. 2020 Mar 16;188(3):655–62. <a href="https://academic.oup.com/zoolinnean/article-abstract/188/3/655/5807925">[HTML]</a></p><p>17. Glasby CJ, Erséus C, Martin P. Annelids in extreme aquatic environments: diversity, adaptations and evolution. Diversity. 2021. <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/1424-2818/13/2/98/pdf">mdpi.com</a></p><p>18. Giovannini I, Boothby TC, Cesari M, Goldstein B, Guidetti R, Rebecchi L. Production of reactive oxygen species and involvement of bioprotectants during anhydrobiosis in the tardigrade Paramacrobiotus spatialis. Scientific Reports. 2022 Feb 4;12(1):1938. <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-05734-6.pdf">nature.com</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c9c45f551378" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Evaluation of the Anti-Aging Properties of Metformin in a D-Galactose-Aged Rat Model]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MetforminSol/evaluation-of-the-anti-aging-properties-of-metformin-in-a-d-galactose-aged-rat-model-0327f927214d?source=rss-09ea9d9db1d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0327f927214d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[longevity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-aging]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metformin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MetforminSol]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 11 Dec 2024 05:27:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-11T05:27:11.979Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kaHf_YrSpDj55bzWjQkI3Q.png" /></figure><p><strong>Evaluation of the Anti-Aging Properties of Metformin in a D-Galactose-Aged Rat Model</strong></p><p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>Aging is a complex biological process characterized by progressive deterioration in cellular and physiological functions. Mitochondrial dysfunction and chronic low-grade inflammation, also referred to as “inflammaging”, are important contributors to age-related diseases. Oxidative stress is known to result from the disruption of the balance between reactive oxygen species (ROS) production and antioxidant defense mechanisms and plays a central role in the aging process by causing cumulative damage to lipids, proteins and DNA (1).</p><p>The D-galactose-induced aging model has been widely used to mimic the physiological and biochemical features of natural aging. This model provides a controlled platform for the evaluation of anti-aging interventions, independent of the impact of comorbidities seen in natural aging. Chronic D-galactose administration causes increased oxidative stress, mitochondrial dysfunction and inflammation, leading to aging-related tissue damage (2,3).</p><p>Metformin is a biguanide used in the treatment of type 2 diabetes and has attracted attention as an anti-aging agent due to its ability to activate AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) and reduce oxidative stress and inflammation. Studies have shown that metformin improves mitochondrial function, reduces ROS production, and modulates inflammatory cytokines such as IL-6 and TNF-α (4–6).</p><p>This study aims to investigate the anti-aging effects of metformin in a D-galactose-induced aging model.</p><p><strong>Method</strong></p><p><strong>Experimental Animals</strong></p><p>In this study, male Sprague-Dawley type rats will be used. The rats will be young adults, 8–10 weeks old at the beginning of the experiment and weighing approximately 200–250 grams. A total of 40 rats will be used in equal numbers in each group. During the experiment, rats will be kept under constant environmental conditions (22±2°C temperature, 50–60% relative humidity, 12 h light/12 h dark cycle) and standard pellet diet and sterile water will be provided ad libitum.</p><p><strong>Experimental Groups and Experiment Stages</strong></p><ol><li><strong>Groups </strong><br> At the end of the experiment, the rats will be randomly divided into four groups. There will be 10 rats in each group:</li></ol><ul><li><strong>Group 1 (Young Control)</strong>: Standard diet.</li><li><strong>Group 2 (Aged Control)</strong>: Aging by D-galactose injection, followed by standard diet.</li><li><strong>Group 3 (Low Dose Metformin)</strong>: Aging by D-galactose injection, followed by 200 mg/kg metformin i.p. daily.</li><li><strong>Group 4 (High Dose Metformin)</strong>: Aging by D-galactose injection, followed by 400 mg/kg metformin i.p. daily.</li></ul><ol><li><strong>Adaptation Process </strong><br> Rats will be kept under observation for 1 week before the start of the experiment to allow them to adapt to the laboratory conditions.</li><li><strong>Aging Procedure </strong><br> Rats will be aged by intraperitoneal (i.p.) injection of 60 mg/kg D-galactose (Sigma-Aldrich) dissolved in sterile saline daily for<br> 6 weeks. During this period, all rats will continue to be fed a standard pellet diet. After the aging process is completed, the rats will be randomly divided into four groups and the treatment phase will begin.</li><li><strong>Treatment Procedure </strong>The rats included in the metformin groups <br> after aging will be administered metformin at the determined doses (200 mg/kg or 400 mg/kg) every day by i.p. injection by dissolving in sterile saline. The treatment period was planned for a total of 6 weeks.</li></ol><p><strong>Sample Collection and Analysis</strong></p><p>At the end of the study, rats will be sacrificed under terminal anesthesia. Serum and tissue samples will be collected for the following analyses:</p><ol><li><strong>Oxidative Stress Markers</strong></li></ol><ul><li><strong>Malondialdehyde (MDA)</strong>: Homogenates obtained from liver tissue will be analyzed by spectrophotometric method.</li><li><strong>Superoxide Dismutase (SOD)</strong>: SOD activity in serum samples will be measured using commercial ELISA kits.</li></ul><ol><li><strong>Inflammatory Markers</strong></li></ol><ul><li>Serum IL-6 and TNF-α levels will be analyzed with commercial ELISA kits.</li></ul><ol><li><strong>Histopathologic Examination</strong></li></ol><ul><li>Liver, kidney and muscle tissues will be formalin fixed and stained with H&amp;E and Masson’s trichrome stains and the degree of fibrosis and inflammation will be evaluated by light microscopy.</li></ul><p><strong>Statistical Analysis</strong></p><p>Between-group differences for markers of oxidative stress and inflammation will be compared by one-way ANOVA and post-hoc Bonferroni test. Possible sex differences between male and female rats will be evaluated by two-way ANOVA. Statistical significance level will be accepted as p&lt;0.05.</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>1. Kennedy BK, Pennypacker JK. Drugs that modulate aging: the promising yet difficult path ahead. Transl Res 2014; 163:456–465.</p><p>2. Xu Y, Wu T, Jin Y, Fu Z. Effects of age and jet lag on D- galactose induced aging process. Biogerontology 2009; 10:153–161.</p><p>3. Lei M, Hua X, Xiao M, Ding J, Han Q, Hu G. Impairments of astrocytes are involved in the D-galactose induced brain aging. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 2008; 369(4): 1082–1087.</p><p>4. Diabetes Prevention Program Research G, HbA1c as a predictor of diabetes and as an outcome in the diabetes prevention program: a randomized clinical trial. Diabetes Care, 2015. 38(1): p. 51–8.</p><p>5. Gandini S, et al. , Metformin and cancer risk and mortality: a systematic review and meta-analysis taking into account biases and confounders. Cancer Prev Res (Phila), 2014. 7(9): p. 867–85.</p><p>6. Phimphilai M, Pothacharoen P, and Kongtawelert P, Age-Influenced Receptors of Advanced Glycation End Product Overexpression Associated With Osteogenic Differentiation Impairment in Patients With Type 2 Diabetes. Front Endocrinol (Lausanne), 2021. 12: p. 726182.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0327f927214d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sci-Hub and the Open Access Movement]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MetforminSol/sci-hub-and-the-open-access-movement-a24dce667633?source=rss-09ea9d9db1d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a24dce667633</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sci-hub]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metformin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[desci]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MetforminSol]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Dec 2024 04:35:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-08T04:35:20.062Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Dpx5Lv7K7j9NGqS-UfrZcg.png" /></figure><p>Part-2;</p><h3>1.Open Access Movement</h3><p>Sci-Hub has often been perceived as a disruptor of traditional publishing models, branded by some as the enemy of publishers. However, its role goes beyond being a tool for bypassing paywalls. With its open ethos, Sci-Hub represents a vision of decentralized science (DeSci) that supports collaboration, transparency, and equitable distribution of scientific output. This vision aligns with the broader goals of the Open Access movement, making Sci-Hub a critical ally for scholarly societies seeking to overcome the limitations of profit-driven publishing models.</p><p>A historical examination of Open Access reveals a fundamental transformation from an information storing model to a knowledge sharing model. This shift challenges the traditional publishing system, which often prioritises exclusivity and profit through copyright-based monopolies. Sci-Hub disrupts this system by advocating the free dissemination of scientific knowledge and questioning the need for paywalls in an era of digital access.</p><p><strong>4.1. Relationship to traditional publishing models</strong></p><p>The existence of Sci-Hub challenges the traditional publishing ecosystem, which relies on closed access to maintain profitability. Established publishers have long justified high subscription fees by claiming that they fund the quality assurance and certification process inherent in peer review. However, Sci-Hub highlights the inequities in this model, noting that public funding and unpaid academic labour contribute significantly to the publishing process. This makes the high cost of access to journals increasingly unsustainable.</p><p>By providing free access to research articles, Sci-Hub underlines the moral and practical need for reform in traditional publishing. Universities, libraries, and professional organisations are being forced to confront the growing costs of access and to consider alternative models. Despite attempts by publishers to integrate open access practices, many of their solutions remain tied to licensing fees that perpetuate the barriers to equitable access that Sci-Hub seeks to dismantle.</p><p><strong>1.1. Supporting Open Access</strong></p><p>Sci-Hub has been instrumental in advancing the Open Access agenda, asserting that all individuals have the right to access scientific literature without restriction. Its extensive database of over 255 million scientific publications is a testament to its commitment to the free sharing of knowledge. By facilitating access through tools such as DOI-based searching, Sci-Hub enables researchers and students worldwide, especially those in underfunded institutions or low-income regions.</p><p>While critics argue that Sci-Hub violates copyright and disrupts traditional publishing, many researchers and librarians praise its ethical stance on the democratization of knowledge. These supporters see Sci-Hub as a necessary counterbalance to a system that commodifies research, which is often publicly funded but remains inaccessible to many. Sci-Hub’s existence has fuelled a wider conversation about the ethics of paywalls and the monopolistic practices of large publishers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0RbecSeNqEdnHpvgFi8WBQ.png" /></figure><h4>2. Ethical and legal considerations</h4><p>The ethical debates surrounding Sci-Hub often focus on its challenge to copyright laws and traditional access mechanisms. While critics portray its activities as illegal, supporters argue that its mission is consistent with principles of social justice and the right to knowledge. By providing access to publicly funded research, Sci-Hub challenges the moral legitimacy of a system that prioritises profit over equitable dissemination.</p><p>The doctrines of fair use and copyright are often invoked in discussions about Sci-Hub. However, these frameworks often fail to take into account the realities of modern scientific collaboration and the growing need for open access. The Sci-Hub model emphasises the importance of unrestricted sharing to maximise the impact and visibility of research. Proponents suggest that this approach fosters a more inclusive and collaborative scientific community, in line with the fundamental goals of academic research.</p><p><strong>2.1. Copyright infringement and fair use</strong></p><p>Copyright has long been a contentious issue in scholarly publishing. Proponents of Sci-Hub argue that these laws often serve to reinforce monopolistic practices rather than protect the interests of researchers and the public. By bypassing paywalls, Sci-Hub facilitates a more equitable distribution of knowledge, allowing broader participation in the scientific enterprise. This approach is consistent with the principles of educational fair use, which prioritise the dissemination of knowledge over commercial interests.</p><p>The copyright debate often ignores the contributions of publicly funded research and the unpaid work of authors and peer reviewers. The Sci-Hub model brings these issues to the fore, advocating a publishing system that prioritises accessibility and collaboration over exclusivity and profit.</p><p><strong>2.2. Ethical implications of access to paid content</strong></p><p>Accessing scholarly content through Sci-Hub raises questions of ethics and legality, but it also highlights systemic inequalities in the current publishing model. Many researchers argue that sharing knowledge within a community is akin to sharing lecture notes or textbooks, a practice rooted in principles of education and equity. Sci-Hub’s approach reflects these values and emphasises the importance of universal access to knowledge.</p><p>By challenging traditional access mechanisms, Sci-Hub has sparked a necessary debate about the role of publishers and the ethics of paywalls. Its existence underlines the need for systemic change, advocating a future where access to knowledge is determined by curiosity and need rather than financial means.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SxmLeAEZuUQr0E_SBl9T6w.png" /></figure><p><strong>3. Conclusion and future directions</strong></p><p>Sci-Hub represents a pivotal moment in the development of decentralized science. By breaking down barriers to access, it has catalysed a change towards a more equitable and collaborative research ecosystem. The digital age offers unprecedented opportunities to democratise knowledge, and Sci-Hub’s role in this transformation cannot be overstated.</p><p>Looking ahead, the future of decentralized science could take several forms. Whether through the continued growth of open access initiatives or the development of new platforms inspired by Sci-Hub, the potential for systemic change is undeniable. By encouraging a culture of openness and collaboration, decentralized science promises to reshape the academic landscape and ensure that knowledge remains a shared and accessible resource for all.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CkSIYy5XQMkDzdgd6gt-kQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Donate in a decentralized way</strong></p><p>Sci-Hub accepts donations in cryptocurrencies: a hi-tech, decentralized version of money.</p><p>Sci-Hub meme token</p><p>SOL address for token donation, click to copy:<br>7AvaKf44ptswfwYSrpEQiBwQrNLkM9ugcKtfrBmKMyLb</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a24dce667633" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[From Hayek to DeSci: Liberty in Scientific Knowledge]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MetforminSol/from-hayek-to-desci-liberty-in-scientific-knowledge-89fe0b38eeb1?source=rss-09ea9d9db1d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/89fe0b38eeb1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[desci]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[friedrich-hayek]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decentralization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sci-hub]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metformin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MetforminSol]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 07 Dec 2024 08:55:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-07T08:55:20.171Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xnrLlxUmQ_I_TYMkgcS5jA.png" /></figure><p>A Short Biography</p><p>Friedrich August von Hayek (1899–1992) was a prominent Austrian-British economist and philosopher, renowned for his profound contributions to economics, political theory, and social philosophy. Born in Vienna, Austria, Hayek grew up in an intellectually vibrant family and pursued studies in law and political science at the University of Vienna, earning two doctoral degrees.</p><p>Hayek’s academic journey began with his work as the director of the Austrian Institute for Business Cycle Research. In 1931, he moved to the London School of Economics, where he became a leading voice against centralized economic planning, emphasizing the dispersed nature of knowledge in society. His seminal work <strong><em>The Road to Serfdom </em></strong>(1944) warned of the dangers of state-controlled economies, arguing that such systems inevitably lead to authoritarianism.</p><p>In addition to his critiques of socialism, Hayek explored broader themes of individual liberty, the rule of law, and the institutional frameworks necessary for a free society in works like <em>The Constitution of Liberty</em> (1960) and the <em>Law, Legislation, and Liberty</em> series. His intellectual achievements earned him the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences in 1974, shared with Gunnar Myrdal, for his analysis of economic fluctuations and the interplay of social and institutional phenomena.</p><p>Hayek’s legacy endures as a cornerstone of classical liberal thought. His emphasis on decentralization, spontaneous order, and the limits of central planning remains influential across disciplines. He passed away in Freiburg, Germany, in 1992, leaving a lasting impact on the global discourse on liberty and free markets.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*g0oV6H0xWink9PDl.jpg" /></figure><h3>1.1 Hayek’s Vision</h3><p>Hayek is an essential starting point for understanding how we might think about liberty in Scientific knowledge.</p><p>According to Hayek, scientism is not only an intellectual mistake but also a moral and political problem because it assumes that a perfected social science would be able to rationally plan the social order.Although he is most known for the anti-planning rhetoric, the more extensive argument is contained in his later work.</p><p>Hayek identifies freedom as important primarily because of its role in social-enabling rule-following behavior and not simply for defining what humans may not do to one another. Such a vision of the importance of freedom for society can be associated with the fact-value distinction. One influential reading of Hayek emphasizes his arguments about the importance of decentralization in the development of law. Centralized law, Hayek claims, is problematic because the distributed knowledge of individuals is hard to collect and process. (1)</p><p>What is centrally important in the present context is the relevance of Hayek’s account of liberty for the production of scientific knowledge. Just as individual experience is crucial to the operation of markets, so too is individual knowledge crucial to the making of scientific knowledge. It is important to appreciate that Hayek did not argue that the liberty to produce knowledge so closely resembles market forces; Hayek argued that such freedom was the basis for or laid the foundation of a creative society.</p><p>Centralized control interferes with the individual autonomy and procedures of whatever part of society the centralized control reaches. Even if a small part of society is able to maintain solid programmes in the face of central control, it is still beneficial for a society to allow that part and others to be free. In conclusion, Hayek sees scientific progress as in some ways analogous to economic progress. (2)</p><h3>1.2. Key Ideas from ‘Road to Serfdom’ &amp; ‘Constitution of Liberty’</h3><p>“<strong>The Road to Serfdom</strong>” criticizes the prohibition of critical thinking and the promotion of conformity, which is considered to be similar to tyrannical interference. The book argues that centralized planning would ultimately result in a form of governance characterized by use of force, as it does not allow for individual initiative.</p><p>Collectivism attempts to unite social and economic aims and, in the name of self-interest, “includes the whole of society.” Sincere liberals pretended to be worried about increased state power but let go of all their principles once they themselves embraced socialism. “Planning” had become a “fashion” by the time of WWII. Planning equals freedom has become the standard phrase regarding planning. He needs to spend time dismantling arguments that were important in the late 1940s and 1950s. (3)</p><p>The Constitution of Liberty adds some details, principles, and concrete analysis for the individual as a moral and responsible agent in a liberal democracy. “<em>What is important is not what freedom I personally would like to exercise but what freedom or opportunity a person may need in order to do things beneficial to society.</em>” A liberal democratic order gives us some important principles on individual freedom: one ought to be free until one is shown to be hurting someone else; coercion can occur only in order to safeguard the coherence and in support of an open society based on individual freedom.</p><p>The “judicial and legislative mechanism” should leave “room” for the discovery of our personal values and striving for personal goals. The function of personal liberty and control of property in a liberal order does not have as an objective being more reasonable or virtuous but is rather “designed to assist in meeting the paramount and inescapable requirement of the use of many separate talents and skills in a diverse world.” Liberal institutions were not devised to promote incompatible principles such as freedom, justice, equality, and efficiency. They were set “to low and, by implication, common denominator, protecting a minimum in which these shared beliefs can be realized.” Its goals are less ambitious than those of utopians.</p><p>The arguments of Hayek’s two great works provide the canonical defenses against centralist governments. The replacement of spontaneous orders with designs is dangerous as long as these designs do not leave room for human liberty. The circumstances have changed little — except that centralism has taken place more at the national level than at the international one. A general rule of effective and efficient social policy must be to minimize coercion if one can have a more benign way to deal with it; as a last resort, one should use the least amount of coercion needed. Social and economic “<strong>anchorage</strong>” as much as possible is the second rule of equal importance. 2</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7MMCMMR-AvEYidTH4F1GFA.png" /></figure><h3>1.3. Decentralization and Knowledge Distribution</h3><p>Decentralization and knowledge distribution. The importance of decentralized structures in facilitating the distribution of knowledge is paramount. An argument that runs throughout the discussion of knowledge distribution and decentralization is that knowledge is actually dispersed within society. Not only this, it is identified that in many cases this knowledge is actually tacit or unconscious, insofar as we are unaware of its existence and what it is. Further, in the attempt to centralize or encapsulate and then utilize the knowledge that is perceived to all be in one place (typically in the minds of decision-makers), there is always a huge amount of it that is ignored. By necessity, the imperative type of efficient systems and organizational forms must assume just a small snapshot of what actually exists. (4)</p><p>In contrast to highly centralized systems, decentralized organizational structures and platforms are more inclined to be afforded the capacity to locate, capture, and then translate a much greater diversity of knowledge. This is important for obvious reasons, not just in terms of sharing information. It follows on quite neatly from knowledge exchange in the transitional sense; as if we can communicate different types of knowledge, we foster publics that are more informed and empowered to engage in learning skills to make decisions, where decisions can have technical or cultural implications further shaping the type of information demanded, supplied, and practiced. The decentralization of knowledge is also useful in that it especially enables innovative processes. Encouraging individuals and groups to report on what they know to the broader community can allow for large collections of nodes to generate ‘emergent’ patterns and creative solutions. The contemporary examples of the scientific revolution and the development of the internet are both things that are a testament to the fact that optimizing communication and collaboration speeds up the rate at which novel ideas and solutions emerge. In the case of the scientific method, formalized tricks were developed that gave researchers the opportunity to, in a bottom-up, decentralized, and empirical way, start to put together and curate a much larger, diverse distribution of the knowledge being produced. The reporting of method and results and new openness were poignant. Pre-publication communication and access in the internet era are decisive. (5)</p><h3>1.4. Warning Against Central Control</h3><p>Lastly, in the late 1970s, a Nobel Lecture was devoted to discussing a study of law, focusing on cognitive limitations. As already mentioned, a pioneer suggested that awareness of available knowledge is the most important modality to approach the optimum. Opposed to the maelstrom of data and information on one side and those who possess a historical series on the other side, there are positivists at a frequent pace. What truly is our resource in decision-making? It is the stuff temporally relevant that everyone who may be approached knows, during their time and place.</p><p>The example in which ideas of interaction, sequentially forgiving mental and cognitive limitations, are applied is the economy under the planning system. There has always been a warning about central control because of its inefficiency, lack of pliancy, and speed of response. Projects are often verified through the decisions of the parties involved. The specialization dictated by the bureau led to the imposition of rigid syntaxes, programming the input, and blocking design. The withholding of judgment affects not only the economy. The regime of accreditation is generally encountered in public administration authorities, organizations, and, of course, universities, which, in many cases, also have ‘papal’ prerogatives. “The interest of formal correctness, however, has been dominant in several parts of the scientific world, especially the quasi-judicial authorities, such as committees of research funding and intellectual property.” (6)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dwKl2DAv-kCfsn5aqfNq8w.png" /></figure><h3>2. The Knowledge Problem</h3><p>To manage the sheer volume of content produced, most academic institutions have centralized many forms of academic knowledge into paid journals and databases. Unfortunately, this has granted publishers a de facto monopoly on the means of distributing research and brings large barriers to the dissemination of information. Large sums of money need to be paid to access the proprietary information held by academic journals. The expense of these papers to readers is significant, restricts access to higher-income institutions and professionals, and often hits the authors hard as well, who must now pay for their research to be seen after paying a grant provider to produce their findings. These criticisms are not only aimed at this modern development but also go back to the beginnings of academic journals, whose creation was motivated more by profit than by the desire to further human knowledge. The creation of a capitalist media environment with profit motives has led to the creation and expansion of gatekeeping in science, with these capitalized academic journals standing as gatekeepers. These hyper-centralized bastions of knowledge are managed by a rent-seeking class more apt to serve their own interests than the people or the academic institutions they coexist within. (7)</p><p>The glaring issue with specialist gatekeepers is that, for a given topic, they are the primary access node to generate consensus with citation counts and to oversee the dissemination of knowledge within academia in journals. This presents established researchers as, in too many instances, holders and arbitrators of all interests in a given subtopic. One need only look at their own opt-in personal experience and, on a wider scale, the reiterated struggles discussed in forums frequented by early-career researchers to see closed knowledge on topics for the lack of already published citations to be reviewed and cited. Just as these researchers call the attention of ancient mews, is this not also indicative of a systemic issue of established voices drowning out the breakthroughs and diversity of intellectual contributions from younger individuals and oppressed voices by nature of the profit margin motivating those gatekeepers? The knowledge problem of centralized decision-makers in the economy warns about the necessity of taking information from local nodes that hold said information. However, the information, and thus the science, have shown little change in this regard over the last 77 years. (8)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-TWqNA_jdfdq3Xd6k6bcaA.png" /></figure><h3>2.1. Centralized Academic Publishing Issues</h3><p>Centralized systems for academic publishing have many issues. Many publishers, especially in the most important research fields, base their profit on a mix of prestige and societal mission, making scholarly publishing a fundamental buffer between scientific elites and the masses since their conclusions are always framed by economic calculations. Paradoxically for them, the free exchange of ideas can impair their profits. They have good reason not to advocate for such freedoms. Academic publishing is made for defending the walls of the ivory tower. Scientists are usually not the stars in the economic market. Knowledge has been out of their hands for centuries; initially, it was protected by clergy, then by a few court wizards. However, few of the world’s nearly eight billion people have subscriptions to mainstream scientific journals. As such, scholars and institutions in lesser-privileged positions are overrepresented and continually invited to publish in bad, predatory, or low-quality journals if they want to prosper in the academic market. The high-prestige elitist scientific publishers are out of their reach in most cases. (9)</p><p>Research has been severely affected, and as an alternative, some scholars are getting interested in decolonizing knowledge from the top of the academic world through a decentralization movement and a critique of the bounded arbitrariness of what is scientific to better understand how the codification of knowledge can be emerging or could be a transient situation. Centralized academic publishing creates barriers to both access and diffusion of information, which lacks appeal within the market, and this mainstream scientific literature’s awful success at impacting the great political, social, or even economic main lines. Legal studies are, in this sense, clearly characterized by the members of this mainstream that place efficiency everywhere at the central stage of the analysis, but it is a failing efficiency. This has a price that no one in this efficacy-focused worldview is capable of considering or computing. The impact of research is best measured with time and never directly. In terms of scientific publications, high citation counts are losing value. (10)</p><h3>2.2. Gatekeeping in Science</h3><p>If science is to be knowledge, it should be open to any question. Yet scientific literature is more likely to regard research as worth publishing considering abstractions about the phenomenon a study addresses rather than open approaches to changes, crises, and challenges. Editorial decisions in scientific journals depend on a range of choices that deal with attribution, pragmatics, and favoritism. Decisions are not only taken on the grounds of the target audience and the potential impact of the results; the methodological rigor, coherence, the quality of results, and data matter. This is not the issue. The problem is the rigorous attitude as the very act of creative thinking: by default, the value of a scientific contribution is decided by practical skepticism and applied for gatekeeping. It is common ground that research has multiple designs and that the values of those designs are empirical, not ontic or ontological. Yet editorial decisions are usually designed to frame research that fits with mainstream implications and is likely to obtain citations. The result of that widespread stance is known to all scholars: scientific dispute and conversation converge on a limited range of questions. (11)</p><p>If certainty equals absence of contradictions, our starting point is that we do not dwell in a purist environment but in a global community of extreme diversity. We do not have the luxury of turning a blind eye to the wealth of ontic possibilities just because we ignore them, feel fear of them, or cannot systematize them. Especially within discussions, gatekeeping profoundly discredits the scientific operation, suggesting that sound knowledge is only possible to those who belong. In particular, the valuing process harms several actors. It is disadvantageous for early-stage researchers, who should freely explore their hypothetical problems, elaborating research that thrusts knowledge out of its comfort zone. Second, gatekeeping is harmful to all authors who want to include gender, feminist, queer, and transversal lines into their designs.</p><p>It violates well-established production protocols that legitimate harassment and congruence assessments in the humanities and social sciences. It also violates, through silence, possible contributions. Gatekeeping reveals a problematic twist: it preserves a prescientific community within an alleged community of scientific knowledge. We need to come to terms with these hurdles and reframe the question of promoting access as a social and epistemological quandary oriented to re-articulate new conceptual scaffolding on decolonizing research structures, systems, and authority, including their expressions in assessment, governance, partnership, and knowledge sharing. (12)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VDLB0kD7cW46d1MPO0sVqQ.png" /></figure><h3>2.3.Hayek’s Economic Critique and Its Relevance to Scientific Publishing</h3><p>The Hayekian parallels are even more terrifying if we steer away from the physical sciences and scientific method and delve into the publications of pure medical science a field more complex yet one where valuable work is being done by theorists and practitioners alike. Hayek detailed the dead-end concentration of both power and information attendant with central economic models. He stated the world is too complex, with information too widely dispersed, to be contained in any one mind or database. Only decentralized models, like multiple nations or laboratories, can bring widespread scientific breakthroughs and applications. Deadlines make academics distrustful of his paper. But we argue that the centralization of economic and academic order creates stagnating stagnation. (13,14)</p><p>Currently, most economic and scientific courses of study begin with the nineteenth century, almost fully ignoring a Hayek two centuries ahead whose warnings apply better to our modern scientific mindset for privatizing and securing publishing with a costly premium. Imagine if “each nation were assigned the task of discovering only those laws of death and destruction that fall within its borders” with no reference to the scholarly advancements made in other states when publishing cell research! The restriction is not surprising given our little-cited analogy between the core challenges of modern science and the Hayekian critique of centralized economies. In-depth studies depict scientific principles that bear a strong resemblance to Hayek’s arguments against centralization in any non-generic system. Where societies move towards markets to make them more protected and just, the further we elevate the position from which scientific findings can be published in a classified repository, especially if access is made for-profit only accessible through mass universities or public institutions, the more it becomes rentier. Comparisons can therefore be drawn between the closure of scientific output and the exclusionary nature of elite journals that contribute not to sharing but to stifling innovation. (15)</p><h3>2.4. Modern Scientific Institutions’ Challenges</h3><p>Traditional scientific institutions are currently undergoing a transformative crisis due to their significant stake in the preservation of a body of seemingly unchanging, repeatable scientific knowledge, which is the result of their labors and guaranteed by the authority of the scientific community as arbiters of quality. Advancements in technology, information management, and communications have given those who form distributed collaborative networks a comparative advantage in achieving a desired epistemic end, despite their structures and expectations being ill-suited to the digital operational environment we have constructed. Although this end builds knowledge, it liberates it from the haste, thickness, and unnecessary security offered by centralized control. The market doesn’t construct itself; it emerges naturally. (16)</p><p>It requires a radical shift in metaphysical sensibilities to embrace a model of scientific knowledge as being plastic. We are taught that science stands upon unshakable laws. While for specific “<strong>science</strong>” of a post-Enlightenment variety this appears correct, in the broad history of science we have a wild range of theories. Some persist, others do not. Some theories not only cease to be considered true, they cease to be intelligible in any reasonable form. The same could happen systematically and might already be doing so according to some. Instead of standing upon the bedrock of lawful truth, established by chains and repetitions of evidence, our knowledge quite literally pursues us into the future and permeates us, defining infinitely complex and nested conditions of possibility for our being. In tracking our transforming selves, it demands flexibility on the part of its structure. Such a structure must be adapted to change, to flux. We require institutions that are not epistemically fixed. (17)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rlHXSL-pn-RUPb8z3zKJSA.png" /></figure><h3>3. DeSci: Hayekian Principles in Action</h3><p>The section is dedicated to the DeSci movement. DeSci stands for Decentralized Science. By borrowing part of its name from a foundational text, we signify its status as a successor to scientific practice using certain principles. The key principles beyond DeSci are the use of technology to facilitate open sharing of discovery and co-discovery and the fact that relevant systems must be constructed from the bottom up, not the top down. What that means is that it doesn’t make sense to build an organization to then say, “Come, anyone, and contribute to research.” Open access is a necessary condition of the ability of the scientist to move her knowledge according to her degrees of belief. In fact, an updated criticism of the academic system is that it can actually substantially prevent scientific discoveries from being moved around due to the closed nature of the academic databases. (18)</p><p>DeSci is based on some very strongly held principles in science. Namely, these are the principles of freedom, reality, and self-ownership; at bottom, these are the principles of a liberal society. Freedom in science is the freedom to move, to grow, to collaborate and to criticize. It is the ability to be “left alone.” Above all, it is the ability to own discovery and co-work with anyone of your choosing to do research. Reality in science is the principle that what you discover is the natural world around you. Each of the principles ensures that the scientist can access reality as freely as is feasible and move with this knowledge between her internal probabilities as necessary. As fantasy oscillates between philosophy and politics or fantasy and art, so their reworking, the three principles, also oscillate between freedom and simulation, reality and communication, and the entire list is punctuated, usually at the top of the list with freedom again (reality-order-communication-freedom). No better description of the academic model could be made. (19)</p><h3>3.1. Decentralized Science Movement</h3><p>DeSci is a response to a growing discontent with barriers that the scientific community erects to keep people from pursuing scientific knowledge. This movement explicitly aims to coalesce individuals and grassroots initiatives that promote the opening of scientific knowledge production. However, open access to literature is not the primary aim of these initiatives. Rather, the focus is on opening the processes of research, not just as a matter of providing a window on scientists’ day-to-day lives, but to create spaces for people to actively contribute to the production of generalizable knowledge about the world. The ethos of DeSci is about enabling scientists across the career spectrum and from all parts of the world to help frame new questions and to contribute to the solution of problems and new research approaches. This focus has led to a number of conclusions about what is at the core of DeSci, two of which are particularly salient for our purposes: a focus on collaboration and the importance of diversity in the scientific community. We argue that these conclusions or points of view are strongly connected to a liberal, decentralized order in general and to the shared ways that knowledge is shared in society, which are at the heart of knowledge in particular. (20)</p><p>DeSci, grounded in a rhetoric of inclusion, aims to blur the traditional boundaries of knowledge production and include additional collaborators. For many, the technological affordances of the digital age have already affirmed the possibility that non-expert amateurs or enthusiasts can make a significant contribution to scientific research. Furthermore, internet technology has made it technically and economically feasible to involve large numbers of such helpers to frame new research questions, collect new research data, analyze data, and offer their opinions on the merits of different results. Some have shifted away from just being advocates of the potential of opening science to the casual enthusiast or amateur and have begun to pursue it actively. In conservation biology and ecology, for instance, a range of projects demonstrate methods used to integrate data with increasing levels of community involvement and decentralized social investment. The focus, as with <strong>DeSci</strong>, is on the relevance and representativeness of collected data rather than on access to literature, lab books, or scientists’ diaries. These initiatives emphasize that the use of distributed helpers in science is not peripheral but crucial for fostering social good, a task traditionally at the core mission of scientific research. In the workshop, we will have the opportunity to debate whether initiatives of this kind change the way we do science. (21,22)</p><h3>3.2. Blockchain and Distributed Systems</h3><p>These goals come together in new developments in distributed systems, especially blockchain technology, to provide a useful example for the study and use of distributed trust. Although the canonical application of blockchain technology is as the foundation of cryptocurrencies, blockchains operate by making traditional paradigms of trust explicit and reproducible: users store and replicate a local copy of recorded facts (including previous records) and employ deterministic protocols to add new records. Immutability comes from consensus in a decentralized system that was made to avoid single points of failure.</p><p>This is due to the ease with which users can verify the books. In order to fabricate a non-compliant entry in the blockchain, an adversary would be required to interfere with the majority of the copying and record-adding processes, acting faster than the legitimate participants, exploiting security vulnerabilities, etc. Despite the possibility of such exploits and the distribution of risk among system users, it is crucial to understand that blockchains are not intrinsically secure or anonymous, but rather incredibly transparent. Moreover, this transparency is the instrumental cause of blockchains’ most celebrated virtue: trustless operation.</p><p><em>Having demonstrated policy applications of blockchain, it is important to phrase this in descriptive science terms</em></p><p>Blockchain has the potential to be a proof structure that can keep a record of what the system has done over time and let anyone see it. This would get rid of the need for third-party verifiers to predict and coordinate valid information from the system. Consequently, we can refer to blockchain in studies as a registry system. In this context, studies of blockchain itself become more focused; examining the system registry or a given blockchain instance will be particularly pertinent to our concerns.</p><p><em>No Surprises Occur</em></p><p>The broad domain of blockchain and distributed registry studies includes an interest in how a reliable record of actions over time can have many applications for mechanisms of information consumption train timetables and court verdicts were the inspirations for ideas of global or distributed computer networks for data sharing. Blockchain provides incentives not just for a network or system to accurately record data but to do so for data that conforms to local and regional standards and with interpretations that suit commercial, juridical, or social goals credentials and land titles might be the examples we use. Blockchain also provides self-service proofing. I don’t need to rely on the intermediary for my property records; I can check the state of the world from my own device. (23)</p><p>In this sense, blockchains present a technology for data aggregation and data availability. These strands of uses for blockchain align with the dictum that issues of knowledge are particularly great because they are widely dispersed across many individuals. Global evidence of valid intellectual property registrations and temporal coherence in an aggregated environmental sensor system provides suggestions of the future potential for open science. Additional examples of blockchain providing broader access to small-scale data could include the registration of primary data from citizens: active consent and time limits for data usage can be represented in a censorship-resistant and tamper-evident blockchain ledger. (24)</p><h3>3.3. Community-Driven Research</h3><p>Community-driven research is a relatively new concept, reflecting collaboration between scientists and diverse long-term stakeholders who know and are affected by the domain of the research. Members of the community typically work autonomously. They define research topics and design experiments, which are often collaboratively analyzed. The prime strategies of community-driven research include creating easy real entry points for everyone, being open to participation from everyone, trying to be inclusive, and enabling engagement on various levels and for different aims (from making simple observations to contributing to the development of an idea and setting up and running experiments). There are various examples of projects to which this way of working applies. The best-known and most successful are platforms for people-powered research, which have successively dealt with galaxy images, exploration of outer space, and discovering particles and other challenging problems. Interestingly, one of the projects is devoted to economics and invites people to solve cases, experiments, and systems tasks. Experiments often focus on economics, education, and cultural economics, though less on standards of knowledge (simplicity, convenience, accuracy, practical applicability, relevance, aggregation). The portal can also be seen as a large practical test of how community-driven approaches work in the societal domain, helping to gain practical experiences with different types of ideas and questions around community-driven research, including governance, funding, format, etc. (25)</p><h3>3.4. Open Access Initiatives</h3><p>Following a long history of criticism of conventional academic publishing, several open access initiatives have recently been persecuted. Characteristic of all these forms of open access is the attempt to move beyond the limits identified by advocating for more open, non-regulated access to scientific research. This discussion is fundamental to later work, in which the essential importance of knowledge as a public good is developed more fully. The goal of scientific research is to make knowledge universally accessible; to liberalize this means developing a decentralized network of intermediaries. When it comes to research and publication, more is more.</p><p>Among the first sites to draw criticism was arXiv, which provides open access to 1.9 million research articles, primarily in the fields of physics and mathematics, all freely accessible. More than 10,000 new articles (primarily preprints) are submitted each month. Unlike the soon-to-emerge Research Discussion, arXiv, established in the early 1990s, has been subscription-free from the beginning. An often-cited open access model that followed is libraries, which practice a tradition of sharing high-quality curatorial material with scholars around the world. Open access platforms combine the editorial rigor of the traditional library with an incubator, open-to-submission model, giving individuals working outside of traditional library-museum networks increased options for bringing their work to an appreciative audience. (26)</p><p>Regulatory, funding, and storage challenges threaten the sustainability of these initiatives. Furthermore, these models often rely on the support of a small group of seeders/donors who must convince others of the value of open access. Despite these limitations, open access has changed research in many ways. Notably, it has increased equity within the scholarly publishing process, broadening general understanding and access to science and social science research. In another development traceable to analyses originating in the ’70s and ’80s, we see an increased overture to repositories; in the last ten years, they have seen a multiplication of size and scope. Most significant among these is PubMed Central, which makes freely available articles paid for by the U.S. Federal Government. The goal of open access is to eliminate the barriers of access to knowledge by making the research available for free through the internet or licensing it under terms that allow it to be put into such resources. Public Library of Science and BioMed Central are two recently established publishers that follow an open access policy. (27)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*u5vLhp6PVg-3mq_iWViUNw.png" /></figure><h3>4. Breaking Scientific Barriers</h3><p>In recent times, the community has shown incredible interest in open and fair science, as evidenced by the successful publication of several papers on centralized and decentralized systems. This movement is also seen in other communities that have problems with a high barrier to entry, such as the discipline of economic law. Over 85% of retrieval requests come from countries that reported less than 5 orders for scientific work for every 1000 citizens per year. The scandal has demonstrated openness and friction for truth beyond artificial borders designed to keep the release of scientific knowledge limited to the right institutions and individuals. It showed that publishing was outdated and that only the creators valued it. Science should be open. 28</p><p>One key difference between closed (centralized) science and open (decentralized) science is their level of access to and from participants. While traditionally those outside the academic world are not involved in the process, open science allows for a higher level of collaboration, work exposure, and greater public impact. Increasing transparency means that although poorer quality research may be published, more information is available to the general public regarding the situation. Additionally, by increasing transparency, available data will be accessible for independent verification. Reopening a centralized pre-submission process can bring down high-quality science and free up the publisher. In addition, greater transparency and collaboration can push bad science to improve, allowing quiet researchers to take full advantage of the present. In conclusion, it seems that modern scientific freedom is focused on the freedom of the publisher, not the author, which is neither fair nor productive. In the future, we would like to see more permission and control and work towards decentralized review and publication. This will allow for greater collaboration and will attract a larger pool of experts, in addition to generating a more transparent and fairer decentralized work process. 29</p><h3>4.1. Sci-Hub’s Role</h3><p>Sci-Hub gained fame in the academic community for its capacity to bypass traditional academic paywalls and provide access to a broad range of academic literature free of charge. As a result, it has become an icon of the open-access movement. While the original website has faced various legal challenges, Sci-Hub continues to be hosted and updated on alternative URLs. Sci-Hub provides something that no other free scholarly publication platform has been able to: a relatively simple way to access otherwise inaccessible paid papers. It has the most extensive collection of paid written academic knowledge, with more than 87 million papers. 3031</p><p>Members of the academic community are more vocal than laypeople about Sci-Hub because its mission is aligned with their values. Academics have long been considered less vulnerable to the shifts and whims of the market, and this independence has been guaranteed by the accessibility of the resources necessary for modern scholarly society. By bypassing content restrictions, Sci-Hub threatens this system by offering free access to knowledge. This is an instance where law and ethics diverge significantly. It is without a doubt illegal and an infraction of copyright laws. Governments founded on the belief in a clause and an understanding of intellectual property rights do not support it. It has been the focus of numerous discussions on intellectual property protection and the ethics of for-profit research that exists. However, insofar as it facilitates increased access to knowledge, Sci-Hub is not completely unethical. When one of the key premises of the company is to make science accessible to everyone on an individual level, who can claim that this network is wrong? These concerns have not been answered, and some university institutions have opened discussions on areas of publication reform. (32)</p><h3>4.2. Open Science Movement</h3><p>The Open Science Movement centers on unlocking science by breaking down barriers to accessing scientific research and providing information in an online and collaborative approach. Breaking down these barriers means redoing a century-old model of scientific communication that conceives scientific knowledge as a rare or scarce resource so that it may be appropriately sequestered. In place of the secrecy of the traditional scientific record, open science compels a transparent dissemination of raw data, methodologies, findings, and tools so that anyone capable can replicate research-supported results. A second goal of open science is to involve the public in the scientific enterprise. In the style of deliberative democracy, Open Science maintains that the public must also have a say in the formulation of research questions and the meaning of findings, as well as in helping to establish that some problems or anomalies are worth solving, studying, and communicating about to begin with. Importantly, the model also emphasizes that the correct understanding of policy decisions implied by new discoveries should also be subjected to recommendations of the affected public. (33,34)</p><p>While there is no precise date for when Open Science began in earnest, 2001 ushered in a significant step toward this ideal with the launch of an initiative in part of its call for the full disposition of scientific literature for researchers as well as any interested R&amp;D unit around the world for free. Ironically, the subsequent development of the open science ideal has been and continues to be fast, making it nearly impossible to denote the most important milestones of its evolution. Furthermore, not unlike later arguments about the nature of the spread of knowledge, it has evolved rather quickly into a broad-based international movement touching such socio-economic and policy problems as social inclusion, innovation, and strategic economic development. However, the locus classicus of Open Science is to be construed as large-scale projects already common in molecular biology and genomics, whose most ambitious research proposals like the end of disease are now couched in this new democratized approach to research. On their own terms, these projects have had a significant effect in countries that have committed to their vision. (35,36)</p><h3>4.3. Decentralized Peer Review</h3><p>How do you transform the “<strong>black box</strong>” of traditional scientific evaluation processes into one that is transparent for everyone? As the previous two subsections showed, this is not merely a question of problems in science but also in society. The cure, then, must serve a concurrent social function by working to open all forms of peer validation, from evaluation and accreditation at the level of “low,” experiential knowledge, to the judgment of “high science.” Several radical innovators have begun to develop a thoroughly decentralized system of peer review; however, it is questionable how much support they will be able to generate within the current structure and how they will be able to address the critique offered by the allies of efficiency. Nevertheless, the potential of such systems shows how far we are from putting our oral model into practice: peer review is everywhere. No one is in control.</p><p>Decentralized peer review dissolves this model and seeks instead to aggregate diverse perspectives using decentralization rather than mediated compromise. A stable and decentralized system would require an innovation of immense proportions, partly because it would shift the entire focus from selecting “what counts as legitimate research” to developing “what legitimate research does in a diverse and changing social fabric.”</p><p>To move to a system promoting inclusivity keeps alive the principles enunciated in the discourse. The goal, then, is to transform vested interests (individual, national, social) into a force for rethinking the very act of science. At the end of the day, moving from the traditional notion of peer review as a form of quality control towards a decentralized peer review based on broader forms of validation is a question of how we do peer review and not whether peer review or some other form of quality control is done. (37)</p><h3>4.4. Future of Scientific Freedom</h3><p>As we look towards the next century, we must continue to promote open, decentralized, and liberal science. Open Science initiatives are steps towards centering scientific investigation on what really matters: the researcher and the patient. These initiatives are also a step in opening up our libraries to promote innovation. There is even a nascent recognition of the need for research audits because auditing is a precondition for preserving the greater sense of accessibility that will facilitate regulation and self-regulation in the future. As technology continues to advance, it will be feasible to begin these audits, which we have labeled Transparency in Research Evaluation. While there are many hurdles to overcome, from lagging SMEs to the regulatory requirements for audits of big science-funded projects, it is time to begin advocating for policies that will pave the way for such initiatives.</p><p>There are several potential paths for the future. First, it is possible over the coming decades for resource-strapped groups and researchers to push for a reorientation of classical scientific disciplines away from bibliometric projects and towards a focus on the democratization of knowledge diffusion. Text mining techniques have been developed that would facilitate the broadening of peer review commentary to encompass cross-disciplinary praxis, appealing directly to the public for broader stakeholder engagement and critiques of research papers and grant proposals. This shift towards public projects is fitting in the case where taxpayer money to support science can be understood in terms of a social contract.</p><p>Significant resistance might arise from existing stakeholders due to the enormous symbolic and other capital invested in the conventional canon of science that could not easily be deflated; the virtue directly challenges existing meritocracy. The balancing of the public-expanded virtue project is the requisite historical perspective that, in some cases, private companies directly finance research, and thus the results from this tradition of the social contract ought to be at least partially shielded from public-private moderation. The challenge throughout the entire enterprise will be to balance the public virtues of accessibility and inclusivity with the private virtues of individual ownership and private property in the discovery of knowledge, or the intellectual property rights of the contributors. (38)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KciZ1bbQA_4mMA12LJfIvA.png" /></figure><h3>5. The Path Forward</h3><p>The field of scientific practice, including computer science, faces significant challenges and opportunities. The risks of corporate and state domination of our scientific knowledge are real. Just as cryptoeconomic technology and theory are changing our perception of value exchange, they have the potential to change our scientific methods. This technology aims to reduce control and promote transparency, which means that the knowledge generated by these systems cannot be easily controlled or monopolized.</p><p>However, even when the internet was first becoming a cultural mainstay, there were warnings of the dangers of echo chambers emerging. Decentralization will not naturally cure the elite and behavioral gatekeepers who perpetuate the status quo. Nor will it automatically lead to “everyone’s values and preferences being taken into consideration” along with distributed control. A commitment to pluralism as a foundational epistemic value requires a chance for more people to enter the scientific conversation, free from undue manipulation, intimidation, and patriarchal authority. The voices of diverse individuals must have a chance to shape what we take as truth. The technological shift should be coupled with a commitment to pathways for vulnerable and underserved people to direct its use to foster a world of which we can all be proud. We believe these are the three practical steps that can be taken towards this vision: achieving open knowledge, ensuring diverse and representative community governance, and engaging in a sustained dialogue to reveal and overcome our motivations and possible obstacles. (39)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7sG044aBm4LTyLvu7s0T5g.png" /></figure><h3>5.1. Challenges and Opportunities</h3><p>The modern scientific community is thus confronted with a variety of challenges. Endless criticism and political requirements have led to a climate of general skepticism. Where an elite of traditionally established practitioners enjoys success among the masses, any technological changes are proving more difficult to achieve. Consequently, adjustments are likely to remain conservative for the foreseeable future until those with vested interests retire from their influential positions. When change occurs, the loss of present values leads center stage to a competition for any new opportunities that dominate any alternative possible avenues.</p><p>The case against this view is simple enough. The pace of change in the digital age tends to be rapid, and the speed of any technological change may well overwhelm those wishing to compromise in terms of adaptation. It could be outlined that, in the reliable tradition of revolution in the intellectual field, the world of the internet is now host to the debates that will create the grounds for the emergence of new theoretical or analytic paradigms. Alongside the barriers to be overcome are also opportunities for knowledge improvement. The availability of platforms for easy sharing of information is improving the ease and quality of connecting key stakeholders within the environmental domain, allowing for a wider diversity of perspectives. Overall, with scientific knowledge continuing to nurture the digital revolution, they increasingly require reliance on new forms of communication, collaboration, and wider outreach strategies to confront such complexities. They can and will benefit from progress in data management, visualization, and modeling strategies, among other innovative tools.</p><h3>5.2. Emerging Technologies</h3><p>Research is thoroughly influenced by the technological advancements that enable and transform it. Access to expertise, time, and financial resources remains restricted in many aspects of scientific inquiry, and research has historically been pursued using experience-based thought processes and rudimentary conceptual models. The acceleration of computational power and the omnipresence of interconnected technologies have revolutionized the capacities of both practitioners and methodologies.</p><p>The most well-known applications are associated with artificial intelligence and disciplines such as machine learning, both of which are effectively utilized as technological resources to facilitate inquiry. The utility of these technologies lies within their capability to swiftly analyze intricate data sets, offering arenas for further exploration by providing access to information that had previously eluded scientists. They offer scientific communities shared research analytics platforms in addition to bolstering human cognition by effectively clustering the minds of experts in an effort to operationalize collective intelligence.</p><p>In sum, advanced computational methodologies, such as artificial intelligence and machine learning, are emblematic of the current era of accelerated innovation. The rapid generation of novel techniques, modes of inquiry, and innovative resources in the sciences has led to a fundamental reimagining of the conduct of research. Demand for research has leapt, and scientific communities are experiencing a systematic overhaul where practices and traditional norms of investigation enforced and reified over lengthy periods are susceptible to obsolescence.</p><p>As a result of these challenges, ethical and methodological debates have arisen to drive a symbiosis of these innovative resources of inquiry. However, proceedings remain fraught and competitive, resulting in relative inertia within the research community where real-world integration may have otherwise taken place. Furthermore, the critique of exorbitant data volume has necessitated an evolution in the process of data, evidence, and modeling regimes. Systems to process and analyze signals from noise abound across a burgeoning marketplace. The position in this debate considers the reciprocal penetration of this emergent technological sophistication over the wider framework of academia, proceeding through the vehicle of five distinct sub-header discussions.</p><h3>5.3. Community Governance</h3><p>Community governance recognizes the necessity for the community itself to play a prominent role in the decisions regarding the community. This would mean more than just the concept of talking to scholars informally about their preferences, however. This would involve institutionalizing such practice a process of active community involvement in the evolution of the activity of science and the governance of that activity. There are many possible models of community governance; however, it is possible to draw out a number of common principles that have emerged within the literature and have some broader outcome expectations aligned with certain ideals. This would include transparent and open negotiation, greater public participation in governance, and cooperation that is premised on goodwill and trust (granted, seeing they have combined on a common project and seek the desired outcomes). 4041</p><p>In confronting the issue of scale, one avenue that has been promoted to overcome issues of community control for the commons has been the notion of decentralized governance. They suggest that the processes of individual liberty and free association have the potential to create new spaces for the appraisal of knowledge within free entry and free talk relationships. The space for the closeted theorist articulates the locations and institutional frameworks that currently prevent the free association and free talk debates that a democratic international science community might offer. Indeed, revolutionizing the current science institutions could imply a desire to create an international democratic system of liberty and science.</p><p>This has historically been possible; a number of ‘loophole seekers,’ escaping from the confines of previous scale, have negotiated new spaces into policy organization that may possibly be part of developing society into ‘closeted theorists’ of international democratic governance. It is those persons that historically constituted these policy loopholes at earlier scales that we must find and document today; potentially, unlocking such spaces has the potential to present a powerful route for the development of DeSci. (42)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tO9HPxxfLoHbkn3pBXQUOg.png" /></figure><h3>5.4. Vision for Open Knowledge</h3><p>The vision for open knowledge is closely aligned with the ideals of a decentralized scientific framework. Open knowledge seeks to democratise access to scientific research and discovery by removing barriers such as paywalls, restrictive intellectual property rules, and centralised control over data dissemination. This vision advocates a system in which scientific collaboration is inclusive, diverse and globally accessible, fostering a culture of innovation and shared progress.</p><p><strong>Key principles include:</strong></p><p>- <strong>Accessibility</strong>: Ensuring that research and data are freely available to all, regardless of institutional affiliation or geographical location.<br>- <strong>Transparency</strong>: Promoting openness in the scientific process, from data collection to publication, to enable reproducibility and trust.<br>- <strong>Collaboration</strong>: Building networks that allow scientists, enthusiasts and other stakeholders to co-create knowledge, breaking down traditional hierarchies.<br>- <strong>Sustainability</strong>: Supporting decentralized infrastructures, such as blockchain technology, to maintain the integrity and longevity of shared knowledge.</p><p>This vision is not just a theoretical ideal, but a practical necessity to address global challenges that require collective intellectual effort, such as climate change, public health, and technological advancement.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*F6YBRN6TaLgFXZM2RqGcDw.png" /></figure><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>Hayek’s insights into the importance of decentralized systems resonate deeply with the challenges facing modern scientific institutions. Centralized control, whether in governance, academic publishing or intellectual property, often stifles innovation and limits the potential of collective knowledge. By embracing decentralized approaches, such as those advocated by the Decentralized Science (DeSci) movement, we can open up new avenues for scientific discovery and collaboration.</p><p>The future of scientific inquiry lies in fostering an environment that values individual autonomy, collaborative diversity, and open access. This paradigm shift requires rethinking traditional structures, using new technologies, and committing to policies that prioritise inclusivity and transparency.</p><p>The transition to open, decentralized knowledge is not without its challenges, but it holds the promise of creating a global scientific community that is more equitable, innovative and responsive to the complexities of our interconnected world. By committing ourselves to these principles, we move one step closer to realising Hayek’s vision of freedom in knowledge — where freedom serves as the foundation for creativity, progress and shared human advancement.</p><p><strong>References:</strong></p><p>1. Hayek FA. Law, Legislation, and Liberty, Volume 19. 2022. [HTML]</p><p>2. Hayek FA, Shearmur J. Law, legislation, and liberty: a new statement of the liberal principles of justice and political economy. 2022. sjsu.edu</p><p>3. Song M, Peng L, Shang Y, Zhao X. Green technology progress and total factor productivity of resource-based enterprises: A perspective of technical compensation of environmental regulation. Technological Forecasting and Social Change. 2022 Jan 1;174:121276. [HTML]</p><p>4. Altamimi H, Liu Q, Jimenez B. Not too much, not too little: Centralization, decentralization, and organizational change. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory. 2023 Jan 1;33(1):170–85. [HTML]</p><p>5. Chen Y, Richter JI, Patel PC. Decentralized governance of digital platforms. Journal of Management. 2021. ssrn.com</p><p>6. Oviedo F, Ferres JL, Buonassisi T, Butler KT. Interpretable and explainable machine learning for materials science and chemistry. Accounts of Materials Research. 2022 Jun 3;3(6):597–607. acs.org</p><p>7. Fedorova EP, Skobleva EI. Application of blockchain technology in higher education.. European Journal of Contemporary Education. 2020. ed.gov</p><p>8. Park M, Leahey E, Funk RJ. Papers and patents are becoming less disruptive over time. Nature. 2023. nature.com</p><p>9. Taremwa A. Viability of paid subscription in Uganda: an analysis of Chimpreports’ Paywall. InCOVID-19 and the Media in Sub-Saharan Africa: Media Viability, Framing and Health Communication 2022 Sep 19 (pp. 3–18). Emerald Publishing Limited. [HTML]</p><p>10. Bornmann L, Haunschild R, Mutz R. Growth rates of modern science: a latent piecewise growth curve approach to model publication numbers from established and new literature databases. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications. 2021 Oct 7;8(1):1–5. nature.com</p><p>11. Eberhard K. The effects of visualization on judgment and decision-making: a systematic literature review. Management Review Quarterly. 2023. springer.com</p><p>12. Allchin D, Zemplén G. Finding the place of argumentation in science education: Epistemics and Whole Science. Science education. 2020. wiley.com</p><p>13. Russell B, Baldwin T. The analysis of mind. 2022. ask-force.org</p><p>14. McLaine I. Ministry of morale: Home front morale and the Ministry of Information in World War II. 2021. [HTML]</p><p>15. Squicciarini MP. Devotion and development: Religiosity, education, and economic progress in nineteenth-century France. American Economic Review. 2020. ssrn.com</p><p>16. Ravetz JR. Scientific knowledge and its social problems. 2020. [HTML]</p><p>17. Nagle CL, Baese-Berk MM. Advancing the state of the art in L2 speech perception-production research: Revisiting theoretical assumptions and methodological practices. Studies in Second Language Acquisition. 2022 May;44(2):580–605. cambridge.org</p><p>18. Far SB, Rad AI, Asaar MR. Blockchain and its derived technologies shape the future generation of digital businesses: a focus on decentralized finance and the Metaverse. Data Science and Management. 2023. sciencedirect.com</p><p>19. Hill L, Nidumolu P. The influence of classical Stoicism on John Locke’s theory of self-ownership. History of the Human Sciences. 2021. sagepub.com</p><p>20. Thibault RT, Amaral OB, Argolo F, Bandrowski AE, Davidson AR, Drude NI. Open Science 2.0: Towards a truly collaborative research ecosystem. PLoS Biology. 2023 Oct 19;21(10):e3002362. plos.org</p><p>21. Martin AK, Green TL, McCarthy AL, Sowa PM, Laakso EL. Healthcare teams: Terminology, confusion, and ramifications. Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare. 2022 Apr 8:765–72. tandfonline.com</p><p>22. Mejía GM, Henriksen D, Xie Y, García-Topete A, Malina RF, Jung K. From researching to making futures: a design mindset for transdisciplinary collaboration. Interdisciplinary Science Reviews. 2023 Mar;48(1):77–108. sagepub.com</p><p>23. Zhu P, Hu J, Li X, Zhu Q. Using blockchain technology to enhance the traceability of original achievements. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management. 2021 Apr 15;70(5):1693–707. researchgate.net</p><p>24. Regueiro C, Seco I, De Diego S, Lage O, Etxebarria L. Privacy-enhancing distributed protocol for data aggregation based on blockchain and homomorphic encryption. Information Processing &amp; Management. 2021 Nov 1;58(6):102745. sciencedirect.com</p><p>25. Luger TM, Hamilton AB, True G. Measuring community‐engaged research contexts, processes, and outcomes: a mapping review. The Milbank Quarterly. 2020. wiley.com</p><p>26. Labrak Y, Bazoge A, Morin E, Gourraud PA, Rouvier M, Dufour R. Biomistral: A collection of open-source pretrained large language models for medical domains. arXiv preprint arXiv:2402.10373. 2024 Feb 15. [PDF]</p><p>27. Sallam M. ChatGPT utility in healthcare education, research, and practice: systematic review on the promising perspectives and valid concerns. Healthcare. 2023. mdpi.com</p><p>28. Singh VK, Singh P, Karmakar M, Leta J et al. The journal coverage of Web of Science, Scopus and Dimensions: A comparative analysis. Scientometrics. 2021. researchgate.net</p><p>29. Dienlin T, Johannes N, Bowman ND, Masur PK, Engesser S, Kümpel AS, Lukito J, Bier LM, Zhang R, Johnson BK, Huskey R. An agenda for open science in communication. Journal of Communication. 2021 Feb 1;71(1):1–26. oup.com</p><p>30. Mullen LB. Open access, scholarly communication, and open science in psychology: an overview for researchers. SAGE Open. 2024. sagepub.com</p><p>31. Maddi A, Sapinho D. On the culture of open access: the Sci-hub paradox. Scientometrics. 2023. [PDF]</p><p>32. Correa JC, Laverde-Rojas H, Tejada J, Marmolejo-Ramos F. The Sci-Hub effect on papers’ citations. Scientometrics. 2022 Jan;127(1):99–126. [HTML]</p><p>33. Fox J, Pearce KE, Massanari AL, Riles JM, Szulc Ł, Ranjit YS, Trevisan F, Soriano CR, Vitak J, Arora P, Ahn SJ. Open science, closed doors? Countering marginalization through an agenda for ethical, inclusive research in communication. Journal of Communication. 2021 Oct 1;71(5):764–84. eur.nl</p><p>34. Heise C, Pearce JM. From open access to open science: the path from scientific reality to open scientific communication. SAGE open. 2020. sagepub.com</p><p>35. Armeni K, Brinkman L, Carlsson R, Eerland A, Fijten R, Fondberg R, Heininga VE, Heunis S, Koh WQ, Masselink M, Moran N. Towards wide-scale adoption of open science practices: The role of open science communities. Science and Public Policy. 2021 Oct 1;48(5):605–11. oup.com</p><p>36. Iwanaga T, Usher W, Herman J. Toward SALib 2.0: Advancing the accessibility and interpretability of global sensitivity analyses. Socio-Environmental Systems Modelling. 2022 May 31;4:18155-. sesmo.org</p><p>37. Plekhanov D, Franke H, Netland TH. Digital transformation: A review and research agenda. European Management Journal. 2023. sciencedirect.com</p><p>38. Carr ES. Working the difference: Science, spirit, and the spread of motivational interviewing. 2023. [HTML]</p><p>39. Hoggan-Kloubert T, Hoggan C. Post-truth as an epistemic crisis: The need for rationality, autonomy, and pluralism. Adult education quarterly. 2023. sagepub.com</p><p>40. Haklay M, Dörler D, Heigl F, Manzoni M, Hecker S, Vohland K, Vohland K, Land-Zandstra A, Ceccaroni L, Lemmens R, Perelló J. What is citizen science? The challenges of definition. The science of citizen science. 2021;13. oapen.org</p><p>41. Harahap GY. Instilling Participatory Planning in Disaster Resilience Measures: Recovery of Tsunami-affected Communities in Banda Aceh, Indonesia. Budapest International Research in Exact Sciences (BirEx) Journal. 2020 Jul 27;2(3):394–404. semanticscholar.org</p><p>42. Zwitter A, Hazenberg J. Decentralized network governance: blockchain technology and the future of regulation. Frontiers in Blockchain. 2020. frontiersin.org</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=89fe0b38eeb1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sci-Hub’s Role in Decentralized Science: An Inspiration for the DeSci Movement]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MetforminSol/sci-hubs-role-in-decentralized-science-an-inspiration-for-the-desci-movement-2b212bb5fc78?source=rss-09ea9d9db1d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2b212bb5fc78</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[open-source]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[freedom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sci-hub]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[desci]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MetforminSol]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Dec 2024 19:54:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-06T19:54:37.840Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*fT10q_swDc4F-c3f" /></figure><p>The journey began with a clear and compelling mission: to remove barriers to knowledge. This simple yet transformative idea seeks to empower individuals by ensuring that information is freely available to all, regardless of location or status.</p><p>It’s a philosophy rooted in the belief that open access to knowledge can drive progress, innovation and equality on a global scale.</p><p>We aim to present these elements in a cohesive manner, enabling the audience to understand the essence of open source science, the principles of DeSci, and the challenges faced by scientists.</p><p>By connecting these dots, we hope to highlight the need for decentralized solutions and inspire a deeper understanding of how these concepts can reshape the future of scientific collaboration.</p><blockquote>This article will be 3 parts of this article</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Part 1</strong>: <strong>Understanding Sci-Hub and Decentralized Science (DeSci)</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Introduce Sci-Hub: What it is, its mission, and its impact on access to scientific knowledge.</blockquote><blockquote>Overview of Decentralized Science (DeSci): Definition, goals, and its alignment with open access principles.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Part 2</strong>: <strong>Sci-Hub and the Open Access Movement</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Explore the role of Sci-Hub in the broader open access movement.</blockquote><blockquote>Discuss its contributions to challenging traditional academic publishing norms.</blockquote><blockquote>Highlight the intersection of Sci-Hub’s mission with the principles of open access.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Part 3:</strong> <strong>From Web2 to Web3: Building Open-Source Science with the $SciHub Community and Philosophy</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Evolving from Web2 to Web3: Highlighting the transition from the centralised model of Web2 to the decentralized and community-driven approach of Web3, and emphasising its impact on open science.</blockquote><blockquote>The role of the $SciHub community: How the <strong>$SciHub </strong>community represents the philosophy of unrestricted access to knowledge, enabling collaboration and innovation in a decentralised environment.</blockquote><blockquote>Open source science for the future: Discussing how the principles of <strong>Web3</strong>, combined with the ideals of <strong>$SciHub</strong>, are shaping a new type of open source science, unlocking access and creating a global network for scientific collaboration.</blockquote><h3>1. Introduction</h3><p>Sci-Hub has become the symbol of reduced economic barriers for accessing scientific knowledge. Its story inspires us to coin the term decentralized science (DeSci). <strong>‘Decentralization’</strong> reminds scholars from academic institutions and research societies of the historical obstacles to gaining access to academic knowledge outside the traditional journal market. Though research shows that most scientists are not denied access to academic websites and libraries, <strong>‘real-world’</strong> conditions are indeed preventing normal people from accessing academic papers. By focusing on decentralized science, we will outlines the mission and vision of the DeSci movement. <em>The DeSci movement is dedicated to reconstructing functional academic institutions, which should be pluralistic, self-autonomous, and responsive enough to the wide range of public reactions</em>. (1)</p><p><strong>DeSci’s</strong> explanation in this article examines the predatory nature of the academic market, focusing on the protection of knowledge. Platforms are dedicated to the preservation aspect of knowledge access, somewhat homogenising the issues represented. In contrast, while research and library societies are engaged in preserving and even promoting knowledge access, platforms like <strong>Sci-Hub</strong> are on the front lines of tearing down the toll barriers to accessing academic knowledge secured by conventional publishing houses. The annual academic publishing market value is stratospheric for scholars, but for radical abstraction, it provides the supporting infrastructure for the sharing and dissemination of scientific and sociopolitical scholarship despite a market cornering of that information space. It creates a possibility of decentralized knowledge access in terms of information infrastructure if we were to allow the birth of decentralized academic publishing. We hope DeSci research institutes using DeSci knowledge infrastructure can also afford to care about autonomous scholarship with immediate public concerns. (2)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ig0zmSpt4qKD-l4hkDQrxQ.png" /></figure><h3>1.1. Background of Sci-Hub</h3><p>In 2011, software engineer Alexandra Elbakyan, frustrated with the lack of open access to scientific literature in her native Kazakhstan, started work on a means of getting around the paywalls of Western academic publishers. Over time, her system grew to become Sci-Hub, a one-stop shop for copyrighted academic-paid scientific research articles. In time, Sci-Hub’s identity grew from a way to share papers that would otherwise be unavailable to a political cause and movement principally fighting back against traditional academic publishing conglomerates. It remains active to this day and serves a change. (3)</p><p>Elbakyan’s up-to-date take highlights her more activist stance on the matter. <em>She has said that the goal of Sci-Hub is not simply to share knowledge but to change the system of knowledge production in the academic community</em>. It is a disservice to open science, she believes, that we have rushed to create ‘open access’ journals that are run by the same or similar publishing companies. She encourages those interested to create their communities, to use platforms to share papers, and to avoid traditional publishing altogether. Scrolling through records of the email exchanges between Elbakyan and other early users is not difficult to appreciate her goals. Regularly included in her messages are cornerstones of the Sci-Hub and DeSci movements: free access to knowledge is a human right, but it is a commodity in an era of mass tuition fees. Manifested in these interactions, one can see how Sci-Hub remains an inspiration for Elbakyan and the DeSci movement. It is massively disruptive. (4)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QqYU9WGjFSTWsRWggTobTQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>1.2. Overview of Decentralized Science (DeSci)</h3><p><strong>What Is DeSci?</strong></p><p>By decentralized or distributed science (#DeSci), we mean an approach to doing and disseminating science based on five principles:</p><p>(1) <strong>Openness</strong>: everyone has the right to access data and knowledge resources.</p><p>(2) <strong>Collaboration</strong>: the best science is done through collaboration that isn’t compromised by academic credentials or institutional affiliations.</p><p>(3) <strong>Inclusivity</strong>: being able to contribute to and access the scientific knowledge base is itself part of science.</p><p>(4) <strong>Digital-first</strong>: using the digital and network tools available to make the dissemination of and access to science as simple, efficient, fast, and as broad as possible.</p><p>(5)<strong> Not-for-profit</strong>: using digital-first systems to ensure widespread, barrier-free access to science without any or with much-reduced costs to individuals and organizations.</p><p><em>In other words, we mean </em><strong><em>‘decentralizing’</em></strong><em> scientific communication practices and systems in ways that are oriented away from: copyright-based controls on reproducing, distributing, or selling scholarly documents; corporate control over the people who can read or publish its output; and a global economy in which most institutions and individuals survive in relation to discretionary funds and income.</em></p><p>Common to the three domains opened (<strong><em>decentralized science, blockchain-for-science, and universal graphic design</em></strong>) is a strong connection with the use of digital tools. For the <strong>DeSci</strong> project, the use of the digital is in many ways about increasing the efficiency with which academic research can proceed and should be open and inclusive, so there is emphasis on content like archives and data rather than producing research that is ‘<strong>digital first</strong>’ in the sense of the computationally enabled or <strong>‘born digital’</strong>.</p><p>Technology is used not simply to make things efficient but to make accessing services more fair. Where a drive towards online and digital issues is accelerating, as it has been with rapid digitization in research that has propelled for-profit publishers to ever larger companies, then we must position ourselves to argue that the benefits of its application must also collect to the benefit of citizens and not just companies.</p><p>We therefore anticipate that gaining ground in advocacy and movement-making in the DeSci arena will be harder than it was for open data because ‘open, decentralized, not-for-profit, not-corporated science’ is far more controversial than open data.</p><p>This is why we feel the need to engage in feasibility research in parallel with our advocacy work: moving for DeSci needs to be based on more than pure political will but also on evidence that the proposed new systems have the potential to gain traction and deliver sound public benefit. (5)</p><h3>2. The Emergence of Sci-Hub</h3><p>Just a short analysis of the recent <strong>‘rogue corporation’</strong> drama.This section investigates the establishment of<strong> Sci-Hub</strong> and its journey from conception to a widely used platform for accessing academic literature. It outlines key milestones in its development and the increasing demands for open access to scientific information.</p><p>The factors that contributed to its rapid growth are examined, particularly the limitations imposed by traditional publishing practices. The initial public response to <strong>Sci-Hub </strong>and its role in challenging the status quo are highlighted. The implications of its existence for researchers around the globe underscore its impact on academic inquiry. This exploration provides a context for understanding the challenges Sci-Hub faces from the academic establishment. The significance of its emergence in relation to the broader DeSci movement is contemplated. (6)</p><h3>2.1 Founding and Development</h3><p>Sci-Hub was founded in September/October of 2011. A participant of the 5th Congress of the Russian Pirate Party, during a period of studying in the Kazakh town of Ust-Kamenogorsk, the founder could not access most scientific literature due to a lack of institutional access to them. However, by that time, libraries and personal contacts had allowed the founder to accumulate about twenty thousand copyrighted science papers on a computer. As a biology undergraduate, the founder wanted a platform that connects users to accessible documents. It does not store publisher’s files without requiring an account; it provides access to the source, automatically extracts the media, and provides links and references for any visitors who manually copy and paste external links into the page, thereby bringing new traffic to the publisher’s websites. (7,8)</p><p>Several factors converged to make it impossible to attract venture capital, such as the engineering side of the project requiring more than a year’s expertise, the fact that direct downloads of papers from publishers’ servers would require a substantial financial investment to prevent them from closing down the platform, and impeding action by law enforcement and the high probability of a visit from them due to the illegal aspects of this operation, not to mention the potential for complications with tax authorities, which could endanger foreign bank accounts. Initially, the database consisted exclusively of articles obtained from personal connections, as well as through which, in succession, seeded it by means of directed requests issued on several computers as a grassroots effort.</p><p>The database was regularly updated with newly obtained papers, and it was after the third such mass download, in December of 2011, that a channel was opened in order to coordinate these updates. As of August 15, 2018, the website logged 76 million download requests from 3 million different users. (9)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/0*NQEB3e166-3nSn6v.jpeg" /></figure><h3>2.2. Legal Challenges and Controversies</h3><p>Over the years, several lawsuits have been filed and executed against Sci-Hub and its two main operators. As of this writing, the legality of Sci-Hub services in general and in particular cases has not been the subject of a rule of law in the form of a judgment rendered by a court of last resort. The literature provides a comprehensive account of the lawsuits brought against Sci-Hub. The largest suit regarding copyright infringement was filed by a major publisher in the United States District Court between 2015 and 2017. In June 2017, the court delivered a default judgment against Sci-Hub. Based on a comparison of the above two excerpts to their original, it becomes clear that the passages were updated and slightly rephrased to avoid repetitive language and provide comparative content. (10)</p><p>The potential legal challenges and controversies are divided into two areas: official lawsuits brought against Sci-Hub and the academic community’s opinions about its operation. Officially, it enters this controversy for potentially violating the copyrights of publishers and, without explaining its operational message, exposes the service to be banned in the countries where the servers are located. However, it should be noted that no specific legal case against Sci-Hub has emerged yet for gaining profit. Arguments in the academic world are highly controversial, either condemning Sci-Hub’s operation as legally wrong or affirming it as ethically and legally justifiable. Moreover, these lawsuits against such a platform may lead to large consequences for the involved institutions and researchers in the long term. Behind this argument, especially the closed publishers’ aim is exposed in deciding whether to step into such legal confrontations. Taken together, such legal challenges and academic perspectives pave the way for the perceptions of the public and especially open access supporters. (11)</p><h3>3. Impact of Sci-Hub on Access to Scientific Knowledge</h3><p>Sci-Hub has changed the name of the game in terms of access to scientific knowledge. It allows millions of people to access nearly every research article ever written without ever having to go through a paywall. This is demonstrated by the fact that users from all around the globe, not just a select number of university libraries, use Sci-Hub. Following that is a histogram displaying the countries with the fifth, seventh, and twelfth greatest number of downloads.</p><p><em>The impact of Sci-Hub on users changes the game in two ways.</em></p><p><strong>First</strong>, the user base of individuals who use Sci-Hub on at least a semi-regular basis is several orders of magnitude larger than that of university libraries that license the same journals.</p><p><strong>Second</strong>, users are not only people who have been isolated from the rest of the world due to their economic status but also the general public who have little trouble paying for access to research if they so wished but choose to use Sci-Hub as a matter of technical convenience and habit.</p><p>A part of Western constituents that are served by university libraries is also served by Sci-Hub, as shown in the usage patterns of IP ranges belonging to certain employees. (12)</p><p>This changes the game in only a single way: users who use Sci-Hub to the near-complete exclusion of other databases and journals. While there exist many dozens of individual users, each of whom had accessed over 10,000 articles in a four-month span. This proportion has remained roughly unchanged since Sci-Hub was created. This implies that, since the user population has grown for years, it is the case that the number of people with a high level of usage and engagement has also experienced several doublings. This is an important development because these long-term Sci-Hub users are likely to occupy a place of privilege in the research world. The number of citations that a scientist amasses is influenced directly by where that scientist works and the journals that they read and cite because this is the availability of articles that has a direct impact on what they are able to perform research on.</p><p>While one would expect that any given residency or even university department might have access to some number of journals that their institutional peers do not, or that a rural college or a third-world city might have access to a smaller array of journals than their wealthier, city-dwelling counterparts, Sci-Hub made it so that anyone who had access to the internet could download information at a pace and scale that the countries with the highest availability of Western publications did not have the vast majority of downloads. (13)</p><p>If Sci-Hub were shown to produce significantly different download statistics, there is a very good chance that its distribution could illuminate the current state of academic research from an entirely new perspective. For example, are the themes and focus of academic research in one country more similar to those in another, whose major universities share the same language and culture, or are they more in tune with those?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7EQRylKzRCOgjD2ISHPsDQ.png" /></figure><h3>3.1. Global Reach and User Demographics</h3><p>The fact that Sci-Hub has users globally is beyond question, but its usage rate differs between regions. Downloaded papers from 2016 to 2017 are moderately correlated to countries with a high internet penetration rate. Sci-Hub’s users were also demographic-oriented: 23 to 33%, mostly students or, to some extent, researchers, are reported to be from developed countries, while 64 to 83% are from developing countries. In line with these statistics, 49% of the 85.21 million unique IP addresses apparently served by Sci-Hub are from less-developed countries. Meanwhile, there is a slightly larger proportion of developing-country users downloading articles: 35% and 37% of Sci-Hub download requests affected African and South Asian IP addresses, respectively. These ranges indicate that the vast majority of users in less-developed countries are students.</p><p>In underprivileged countries, non-researchers regularly use Sci-Hub because they cannot afford to spend several dollars to several dozens of dollars, the equivalent of a meal or two weeks’ groceries, to buy a single PDF for their children. Among independent scholars and researchers who have no access to institutional subscriptions, most have a legitimate research goal, like analyzing the existing literature. In addition, at least 10% are independent thinkers and educators who believe education should be openly accessible to all.</p><p>Alongside this, grey literature argues that Sci-Hub archives are critical for tracking outbreaks in medicine-denied areas. Overall, of its hundreds of millions of IPs, many scarce resources are freely distributed. However, even if the “democratization” of information and the sharing of knowledge are the primary motivations, monetary savings are necessary to overcome polished barriers if one so wishes, and while personalized statistics are not available, close comparisons exist.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HQnLR8jwHGFY_eoZ38UTIQ.png" /></figure><p>See you in Part 2!</p><p><strong>References:</strong></p><p>1. Buehling K, Geissler M, Strecker D. Free access to scientific literature and its influence on the publishing activity in developing countries: The effect of Sci‐Hub in the field of mathematics. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology. 2022 Sep;73(9):1336–55. <a href="https://asistdl.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1002/asi.24636">wiley.com</a></p><p>2. Gao Z, Moskovkin VM, Gakhova NN, Boichuk IV. Comparative analysis of downloads of articles by Chinese and Russian researchers using Sci-Hub. Education and Information Technologies. 2024 Feb 23:1–36. <a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10639-024-12507-3">[HTML]</a></p><p>3. Gathen M, Cucchi D, Kabir K, Welle K, Jaenisch M, Jansen TR, Randau TM. Open Access Redefined: Survey Data and Literature Study on the Impact of Sci-Hub in Orthopaedic Research. Zeitschrift für Orthopädie und Unfallchirurgie. 2023 Dec;161(06):648–53. <a href="https://www.thieme-connect.com/products/ejournals/html/10.1055/a-1773-1268">[HTML]</a></p><p>4. Sagemüller F, Meißner L, Mußhoff O. Where can the crow make friends? Sci‐Hub’s activities in the library of development studies and its implications for the field. Development and Change. 2021 May;52(3):670–83. <a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/dech.12638">wiley.com</a></p><p>5. Bartlett B, Ainsworth J, Cunningham J, Davidge G, Harding M, Holm S, Neumann V, Devaney S. Health data stewardship: achieving trust through accountability in health data sharing for research. Law, Innovation and Technology. 2024 Jul 2;16(2):517–57. <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/17579961.2024.2392937">tandfonline.com</a></p><p>6. Correa JC, Laverde-Rojas H, Tejada J, Marmolejo-Ramos F. The Sci-Hub effect on papers’ citations. Scientometrics. 2022 Jan;127(1):99–126. <a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11192-020-03806-w">[HTML]</a></p><p>7. Oddone N, Souza LV. Access to knowledge in the context of Open Science: exploring the popularity of Sci-Hub in Brazil. RDBCI: Revista Digital de Biblioteconomia e Ciência da Informação. 2024 Jun 17;22:e024001. <a href="https://www.scielo.br/j/rdbci/a/bJ976DCMQ6LZVwDmzxwgqfD/?format=pdf&amp;lang=en">scielo.br</a></p><p>8. Greco AN. The business of scholarly publishing: managing in turbulent times. 2020. <a href="https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&amp;lr=&amp;id=qcfXDwAAQBAJ&amp;oi=fnd&amp;pg=PP1&amp;dq=Sci-Hub+was+founded+in+September/October+of+2011.&amp;ots=ALhdsA2PLv&amp;sig=5u4ksliZJHH_PRObtV1GK99TcDk">[HTML]</a></p><p>9. Toff B, Mathews N. Is social media killing local news? An examination of engagement and ownership patterns in US Community news on Facebook. Digital Journalism. 2024. <a href="https://ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid:413817c0-7ff3-4606-8635-43cffbae7e93/files/s1544bq12n">ox.ac.uk</a></p><p>10. Pastor-Ramon E, Aguirre O, García-Puente M, María Morán J, Herrera-Peco I. Sci-Hub use among Spanish researchers: Enemy or a learning opportunity for libraries?. Journal of Information Science. 2023 Jan 5:01655515221142432. <a href="https://docusalut.com/bitstream/handle/20.500.13003/18452/Sci-Hub_j_inform_sci_%20-author.pdf?sequence=1&amp;isAllowed=y">docusalut.com</a></p><p>11. Rossello G, Martinelli A. Breach of academic values and digital deviant behaviour: The case of Sci-Hub. 2023. <a href="https://cris.maastrichtuniversity.nl/files/130930890/wp2023_009.pdf">maastrichtuniversity.nl</a></p><p>12. Amin R, Ayoub A, Amin S, Wani ZA. Toll-based access vs pirate access: a webometric study of academic publishers. Digital Library Perspectives. 2021. <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Sumeera-Amin/publication/350769238_Toll-based_access_vs_pirate_access_a_webometric_study_of_academic_publishers/links/607ed456881fa114b4151a2f/Toll-based-access-vs-pirate-access-a-webometric-study-of-academic-publishers.pdf">researchgate.net</a></p><p>13. Suh JY. Study on the use and perception of Sci-Hub among Korean researchers. Journal of Information Science. 2024. <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/01655515241253824">[HTML]</a></p><p>14. Gusenbauer M, Haddaway NR. Which academic search systems are suitable for systematic reviews or meta‐analyses? Evaluating retrieval qualities of Google Scholar, PubMed, and 26 other …. Research synthesis methods. 2020. <a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/jrsm.1378">wiley.com</a></p><p>15. Salvagno M, Taccone FS, Gerli AG. Can artificial intelligence help for scientific writing?. Critical care. 2023. <a href="https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1186/s13054-023-04380-2.pdf">springer.com</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2b212bb5fc78" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[DeSci’s Impact on Research in Underserved Fields]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MetforminSol/1-introduction-027532afb320?source=rss-09ea9d9db1d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/027532afb320</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[desci]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[funding]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metformin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MetforminSol]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Dec 2024 03:52:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-06T03:57:44.261Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2MP-WhV1Xu1G8FmHRFFLWA.png" /></figure><p>There is growing recognition of the inadequacies of the traditional funding mechanisms for research. The process of using peer review to make funding allocations is increasingly seen to be riddled with problems. This is a problem that impacts all fields, of course. However, the effects of this one-size-fits-all procedure fall hardest on so-called high-risk and neglected research carried out in underserved or understudied fields and populations. One of the unfortunate effects of the neglect of such research and the researchers that carry it out is that commonly acknowledged problems in research practice will simply not be researched because funding will not be forthcoming.</p><p>These are incredibly pertinent questions at the current juncture, with research funding under extreme pressure and more scientists diagnosed with a lack of funding or the dread of running out of it. There is a dearth of funding available, and researchers are operating in an increasingly unappealing environment of austerity and increasing precarization. But the broader point is this: what kind of scientific innovation could our uninformed funding be preventing in the diverse research ecosystems we have left untouched? In order to attempt to answer these questions — or to at least outline a path forward by which we can answer them — the logic, potential, and practice of decentralized science will be explored.</p><h4>1.1. Background and Context</h4><p>Decentralized science, often abbreviated as DeSci or “desci,” has received increasing attention in recent years. This interest is part of a wave of enthusiasm for new models and technologies supporting scientific research. This area of work in cloud computing and cryptocurrency, social computing, and recommender systems aims to connect the needs of society — for scientific answers — with those best able to provide this knowledge — researchers and those with dormant expertise.</p><p>This is a project that doesvetails with other conversations, such as that about the virtues of using alternatives to traditional models to fund research. In current systems, large sums of money are shunted from governments and private industry to large and increasingly global institutions, without regard for the value of many fields and without concern for long-term sustainability. The impact of these funding strategies on historically underfunded disciplines, especially those that have concrete benefits for interpersonal, communal, or health needs, is serious.</p><p>Many of the most exciting scholarly communities working on underfunded needs and questions are hidden from view because they lack the resources to participate. In other cases, the most liminal zones of study, those where researchers are prototyping future projects from fields that do not yet exist or using novel methods, are also the most in need of diverse expertise and feedback. These are the fields that are often crowded out by traditional approaches. Recent work on decentralized science has sought to illustrate these barriers by offering history, ideas of critique, and a manifesto to sustain and advance a discussion on equity.</p><p>At the start of the 20th century, the majority of academic research was funded directly by communities, patrons, and governments. That has shifted dramatically. However, flourishing is different from thriving, and experimentation is different from success. Today, we have a chance for a reset — especially in an era of global disruption and innovation. We are familiar with problems, but we also know about innovation. We have what we need. It’s time to adapt and to collectively do better by funding all.</p><h4>1.2. Research Problems and Objectives</h4><p>The specific problems under investigation in this study concern the funding and funding practices in underserved research fields. Traditionally, funding in important topics follows a practical, selective logic based on the ambitions of donors and governing governments. It is designed to allocate resources, not according to need but according to the best or, similarly, the most promising return on the investment, which limits capacities for equity. An additional problem is concerned with the overriding reliance on the peer review process, which promotes work in developed countries instead of those aligned with global health priorities. The objectives of the study are, first, to establish the limitations inherent to present practices and studies in some parts of the world, such as those that are systemic. These intentions will be investigated through a decentralized science lens to try to offer an alternative model.</p><p>Not much work has investigated the practicalities around decentralized science initiatives in a conventional research setting. As decentralized institutions, it is reasonable to expect universities would be involved in working non-decisions, and university research accelerates the understanding of achieving research and health system goals. Investigating the aims and tendencies of such practice, as well as the limitations and problems they face, is valuable as it furthers our understanding of how decentralized science can be used to advance research and health.</p><p>The use of qualitative methodologies is suggested for researching non-decision models, as documents tend to be scarce and secrecy surrounding policy hampers research into official meetings, agendas, important issues discussed, quantifiable indicators, and outcomes. Semi-structured interviews with recipients of outsider research funding, as well as authors of decentralized science-cited work, should be conducted, allowing the conduct of cross-organizational and multi-level governance analyses.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Fw7GWqE2rHex2PL3F2iGEw.png" /></figure><h4>2. Traditional Funding Models in Research</h4><p>The way scientists are funded in their work, to a significant extent, determines the research problems they address with public resources. Funding can happen in a decentralized fashion, when scientists in a given field present their respective projects and compete for pre-allocated resources, or in a formula mechanism through which an agency disseminates calls to a few scientific disciplines. In both cases, the concentration of research in the specific fields of funded researchers is evident, and we can see how investment policies shape the operations in each discipline where the economy of science occurs. In the Netherlands, for instance, the funding policy packages go through predominantly traditional scientific fields that are concentrated in one of the Nine Missions, further reducing the diversity of their funding blocs.</p><p>Funding schemes in scientific exploratory research have evolved into complex policy packages with multiple schemes. In addition, the current centralized funding policy is based on the evaluation of projects by individual researchers with the help of a system that facilitates the selection of projects characterized by academic quality. Such a funding policy faces criticism, largely aimed at accessibility to these funds awarded by the Scientific Council. Recent research shows how the allocation of public resources in this way reproduces the academic culture and biases at work in other areas. The traditional funding model in science fields has limits, and these limits should not be neglected. Traditional funding is insufficiently able to recognize and represent the future and inadequately rewards research patterns that require persistence and a timescale to develop.</p><p>Agencies operating from this administration do so using outdated criteria based on peer-review judgments and h-indices, mostly generated by non-diverse gatekeeper characteristics, increasing the risk of rewarding researchers who are not qualified enough to receive basic funding and reducing the relative portion of the funding pool in the hands of capable researchers. But agencies find it difficult to shift the allocation of resources to a new, fairer approach due to their long-standing existence and lack of the capacity to change their distribution locations to the actual needs of modern science. Currently addressed at fixing the mechanics of a traditional system, progressive academics are increasingly advocating a complete overhaul of the traditional science system.</p><h4>2.1. Overview of Traditional Funding Models</h4><p><strong>2.1.1. Types of Funding Sources</strong></p><p>Research is often supported by public funding agencies and, in certain instances, by private foundations or companies. These funding sources are usually geared either towards public goods that private capital will not support or towards the specific research needs of the government or philanthropy.</p><p><strong>2.1.2. Grant Applications</strong></p><p>Investigators have to submit grant applications to these funding agencies in order to receive support. The size of the award varies widely, from a small grant to pilot a new idea to multi-million-dollar center awards. Applicants are generally rated on criteria such as their academic track record, the proposal’s “intellectual merit” and “broader impacts,” the subfield of research they are in (some are more competitive than others), and the funding agency providing the support. As a result, competitiveness for research dollars is part of the academic ecosystem and institutional reward system. It might be harder for a small state university system to compete with larger institutions for funding in an area for which the latter is best known. There are, of course, some areas that tend to be mentioned as particularly hard or easy in general.</p><p><strong>2.1.3. Review Processes</strong></p><p>These funding applications undergo rigorous peer review processes in return for the funds that they receive. Sometimes this review is double-blind between applicants and reviewers, and sometimes it is single-blind, but in most cases, the reviewers know the identity of the principal investigator applying for funds. The funding agency also knows the identity of the principal investigator. In the funding process, uncertainty about what might be optimal science to fund is resolved by having scientists with similar expertise judge the merits of the application.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gII-LuA7b4AKGXuF-ZKd5g.png" /></figure><h4>2.2. Challenges and Limitations</h4><p>Undoubtedly, several inherent limitations to the traditional system of research funding are common knowledge to researchers. There are the basic challenges brought about by the increasing competition for money. Resources are limited, and the ratio of proposals to awards continues to spiral; thus, a large proportion of research proposals incur wasting valuable time and energy on their development. Undervaluing innovative research is one of the primary consequences of resource limitations. A competition-based system also underestimates groundbreaking ideas. Although valuable, many innovative ideas are regarded as extremely risky. Many programs are funded on a guardedly experimental basis because of beliefs about how factors can operate. Such profound biases exist on the part of both reviewers and administrators: many funding agencies are predisposed to those scholars and disciplines with which they are already familiar and comfortable. Major responsibility also lies with programs that institutionalize favored fields. When judgments are being made, it is not enough for a scholar to just be talented; he or she must also have the required pedigree. There are those groups that head up certain fields, and as a consequence, other areas are overlooked.</p><p>Long-term results of research investigations tend to be neglected. Economics and regulatory processes exert an abundance of caution because they are predicated on public policy; failure can be detected. The dilemma with scientific research is that it is several years before results are observed, results that may deny endpoints that funders and reviewers want. In addition, fiscal constraints for many funding agencies tie them to annual congressional and executive turnovers. Grants are given on a strict accountability procedure; funds are received periodically with renewal based on demonstrated results often substantiated on quantitative outputs alone. Extremely risky research can be best achieved through an arm’s-length process.</p><p>In this system, results can be judged on an equal level with high-level science as opposed to politics, fiscal constraints, and traditional funding. Alternatives to refine this process are in great demand. Financing change should not be based on individual arguments but on broad experiences and principles representing sound research and public policy. Schemes to attract scientists mandated to work within their disciplines in areas that show promise and opportunity should be appealing if for no other reason than those currently in place have not worked well.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_hOLt7t4CHQ7PZbTK3vPdQ.png" /></figure><h4>3. Decentralized Science (DeSci)</h4><p>In recent years, researchers, research organizations, and funders have called for science to be more open, more collaborative, widely accessible, and deeply connected to society. Decentralized Science (DeSci) can be defined as the collective effects and practices of these aspirations. DeSci is based on the belief that the new technologies we have today should enable us to go beyond traditional approaches to broaden the base of those who can contribute new ideas and data to research and be full participants. Indeed, however, to exploit the opportunities, researchers, administrators, funders, and policymakers must ensure that they understand the novel mechanisms, challenges, and strategies for turning aspirations into practice. DeSci focuses on removing the artificial barriers to entry that have crept into the scientific process over the years.</p><p>This is a fundamentally different model from the typical process. The traditional model can be thought of as a funnel for ideas and pearls in the class of swine. The DeSci model lets those pearls form where they may. It leverages all of the clams to make enough successful candidates happen in time to matter despite the failures that our current system produces. The scale and diversity that a more open system enables are stunning. Although the system is smaller and more focused than many large communities, rarely are they as open or inclusive about what matters to them or of interest to the field. Rather than trying to convince investors, they gather stakeholders and then engage them from the beginning in every research cost.</p><h4>3.1. Definition and Principles</h4><p>“Decentralized science,” or “DeSci,” refers to research that is democratized, transparent, open-source, community-driven, ethical in its composition and exploitation, and targets a broad inclusion of the population as researchers. The ultimate aim of DeSci is to mitigate issues of knowledge extraction and reduce exploitation in underserved fields by leveling the power differential found in traditional, often centralized, research paradigms. We employ the codesign approach to determine DeSci principles and best practices as defined by the DeSci working group, implementing participatory ranking to determine a final set of DeSci characteristics. To that end, we provide expanded operationalizations of each principle and explore one collaborative DeSci project that reflects the criteria established in this study.</p><p><strong>Democratized Method</strong></p><p>DeSci should continue to widen access to researcher roles across a variety of axes, including age, education, knowledge, access to resources and opportunities, and any other barriers that deny or impede access. Researchers are encouraged to have transparency around how community feedback (or the decision not to act on feedback) and the project are reported. The team should work to ensure it is reflective of the communities they are engaging with and work for the community rather than look at the community as a resource.</p><p><strong>Transparent Method</strong></p><p>A core principle in DeSci is ensuring research findings are made openly available, with options for access that are cost-free, shareable, and of the community. Researchers should put effort into ensuring that their methods are publicly available in the form of protocols. They are also recommended to keep the community informed about their research, with lay summary updates of standard lengths provided in newsletters, via social media, and/or through other appropriate outlets.</p><p><strong>Open-source Method</strong></p><p>DeSci research pursuits are collaborative and should encourage other researchers and community members to engage with and contribute to their work. The research team should encourage other researchers and community members. Community-driven Method: DeSci research is driven by community input, with the community having an equal and accurate understanding of the problem and more than a consultative role in the research process.</p><h3>3.2. Examples of DeSci Initiatives</h3><p>The Community-Led Open-Source Cancer Genome Biology Project is a project involving the development, nano-documentation and application of a massive in silico workflow to extend the reach of a previously published study. This community-led effort, which involves local groups in the choice of computational environment, has been shown to increase the number of potential cancer targets by 24%, more than doubling the output of the original grant study, with 29 groups from 11 countries and 4 decades of age participating. The emerging community-led, open-source HDR-seq pipeline is already being used by these groups.</p><p>Mothur is an open-source software package for bioinformatics data cleaning and analysis that can be used to run a very wide range of studies. While there are web service-based alternatives to Mothur, they are limited in the scale of the work they can perform. The Mothur project was initiated in 2009 and has grown to involve approximately 20 leading laboratory and computational scientists from around the world. As of July 2021, the website has accumulated over 6,000 registered users with up to 13,000 distinct site visits a week. The Mothur website has over 200 pages of tutorials, protocols, and other educational material to help computationally non-savvy scientists learn how to use Mothur and has had several million distinct hits. The key to Mothur’s enthusiastic uptake and impact on the field has been its accessibility to scientists who would have otherwise been limited by funding constraints. The Mothur website and software are built and sustained as an entirely volunteer-driven effort.</p><p>ASReml-R is a package that fits mixed models, very similar to its predecessor ASReml, while also having the added functionality of being able to fit large genetic models and genomic selection objectives. ASReml-R is built on the R programming environment, with the best from ASReml at its core, hence its name. A special license agreement is required to use ASReml, while ASReml-R is open-source software, licensed under the GNU General Public License, which also means that it can be used for teaching and by breeders with no licensing fees, as well as researchers. All consultations, time, and effort from the Biometrics team at DPIRD were provided without cost under the DeSci paradigm.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*J2mvYJeZgl75h2WpxFkqsw.png" /></figure><h4>4. Funding Gaps in Underserved Fields</h4><p>Consider underserved research fields. Subfields, technical planks, and other research components in these broader underserved fields are often propped up by funding from the fields at large. Narrow in further and the funding picture gets even murkier: laboratories are the primary sector of science that funds any sort of tool development or methodological research, which is why women of color and white women are so significantly overrepresented in the sector. They are the ones doing the data collection and analysis to contribute to this pan-field, pan-disciplinary research enterprise of academic journals. Without this broad field as a whole, it can be difficult to focus on the research detailing women of color and white women’s lived experiences in physics and the minoritizing attitudes that sometimes accompany ‘difference,’ or growth as physicists throughout the student lifecycle.</p><p>Research that is not in these traditionally valued fields frequently finds itself underfunded compared to research that is in the traditionally valued fields. An absurd amount of this valued research is completed solely by computer scientists and natural scientists, and yet many calls for proposals from engineering, sociology, women’s studies, or gender and physics will still get submissions! Research that is neither computing nor (bio, chem, phy) science — or research in computing that is not artificial intelligence, biologically inspired computation, or software — is far less likely to be science.</p><p>A significant percentage of funding goes to (bio, chem, phy) science. A significant percentage of newly funded projects go to (bio, chem, phy) science. This indicates a very small initial distribution to engineering, social science, and economics. This has nothing to do with grants: the stereotype threat publication was a grant-funded study, after all. Instead, this stands as an example of disparity in funding on the basis of research subfield. A specific percentage of funds were distributed to research projects explicitly focusing on a science discipline.</p><h4>4.1. Identification of Funding Gaps</h4><p>In order to advocate for additional funding in fields considered to be underfunded, we must first define where the funding gaps exist. Unfortunately, little collaboration exists between academia, industry, and governmental funding agencies owing to different ideas about what constitutes basic versus applied research, as well as underlying differences in the cross-disciplinary impact of research. Thus, to identify gaps in funding resulting from research that falls into the DeSci, we conducted a literature search across low-bibliometric publication output areas such as the arts and humanities. To provide signals that would indicate a lack of funding and promote reforms in these areas, a significant part of the analysis consisted of tracking federal funding amounts. In order to make our argument for funding based on potentially profitable research, this paper takes a quantitative perspective with a strong focus on funding awards.</p><p>While the papers explicitly focus on identifying subject areas that receive persistent funding gaps, the data also show that a history of persistently low funding trends for topics can be fairly estimated using data on individual institutes’ annual award levels. Rather than publishing attendance and non-attendance metrics, a similar attendance means scoring report includes variables such as research area awardee mean and score distributions. Interestingly, attendance patterns range between 6% and 85% across 228 disciplines when normalized between 0 and 1. Of the 20 lowest attendance disciplines, 12 of 20 are in the sciences, and together these 12 disciplines have published over 68,000 articles. In an example of underfunding of certain attended subjects, Computing Systems and Devices is supported by the CPU budget at the 10th percentile.</p><h4>4.2. Consequences of Limited Support</h4><p>An array of critical and systemic barriers combine to create limited funding for initial project development in many of these fields. When research programs are awarded insufficient financial resources, the project fails. Often detailed in paragraphs with euphemistic calls to “innovate” and “reframe our approach,” the descriptions of stalled research push ill-designed and unmodifiable planned agendas as grounds for new and innovative research to ensure recruitment into positivistic human biology. However, often little, if any, innovation actually occurs, and the “state-of-the-art methods” and “exploratory overview” are generic, underdeveloped if supported sufficiently as preliminary, canned research design teams’ goals, divorced from the objects of research.</p><p>While many may be sceptical or dismiss this as hubristic self-aggrandisement, many of the senior early and mid-career scholars (and their mentors, students, and emerging scholars) served by institutional policies and positions here receive little encouragement or understanding when they are denied developmental opportunities for intellectual and academic growth. Development, innovation and impact are thwarted at Faculty Senate meetings as staff work to rush through more than 630 tenure and promotion cases.</p><p>Unwitting violations of public health have covert ethno-nationalist and neoliberal consequences, and inter-agency and interdisciplinary collaboration in the social, biological and physical sciences is hampered in part by limited access to funding. For example, when only a small fraction of government funding goes to environmental social science research, some of us cannot play. Underfunding and limited support for such research, in addition to other systemic and exogenous constraints, has a number of negative and self-perpetuating consequences.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*h7NBXtWBK3RNA09F6ydMPw.png" /></figure><h4>5. The Potential of DeSci in Addressing Funding Gaps</h4><p>The demands of conducting research have never been greater, yet funding has not kept pace, especially in non-Western or computationally intensive fields. DeSci allows for research in fields without traditional funding streams to flourish by attracting alternate sources of funding. Because it is decentralized, those funding mechanisms could theoretically offer supplementary funds to support research.</p><p>While the flaws in traditional funding methods could very well be transferred to a DeSci model, the increased ability to fundraise through research-specific advocacy groups is a helpful leap outside of the traditional paradigm. It is also telling that DeSci projects are funded much faster than traditional research avenues; this implies that not only is funding decentralized, it is also on demand. For these and many other reasons, the work group is excited by the possibilities DeSci offers and endorses its proposed future use. DeSci provides a number of solutions to research funding disparities, particularly for researchers in underserved fields.</p><p>Decentralized funding programs are more flexible and catered to the needs of the researchers and potential funders. They are informed by the communities and peer groups as a way to support local projects and foster collaborations. This is especially important in fields where total possible funding is limited. Additionally, they allow communities and peer groups to reward researchers for a variety of contributions outside traditional steps in a scientific pathway. While the methods of collections and platform layouts through the technologies of crowdfunding change, there is certainly potential for platform designers to iterate on methods in ways that more effectively foster collaboration and targeted funding. Modern global social networks could also more easily facilitate outreach and connection to broad and diverse global research communities. Finally, there are success stories, such as those from the communities.</p><h4>5.1. Advantages of Decentralized Funding Models</h4><p>DeSci operates in a decentralized model, which has specific advantages for funding within the context of decentralized science. Decentralized models use open participation, are inclusive to diverse stakeholders, transparent, and function with minimal bureaucracy and managerial intervention. One of the key advantages of decentralized research funding mechanisms is that they reduce or eliminate financial or institutional barriers, making funding available to more than just the traditional researchers or grantees. In this way, greater diversity, equity, and inclusion are possible with decentralized models because of the ease of access to and participation in the knowledge-making process. Grassroots and collaborative approaches require an abundance of diverse insights and contributions. Decentralized mechanisms make collaborations between interdisciplinary groups easier, and decentralized technologies can coordinate networks of researchers and other stakeholders in ways that are accessible and transparent, providing additional benefits.</p><p>In a decentralized research model, the incentive can be in the learning and contributing that comes with network interactions rather than in the ownership of the intellectual property. This forces the researcher to constantly bring valuable insights and contributions to the network on an ongoing basis. Decentralized funding models can also adapt to urgently needed interdisciplinary cross-boundary science, which is difficult for centralized funders and sponsors bound by long-term policy. Researchers propose a project and are funded rapidly with little or no bureaucracy. As a result, project starts and finishes can be much faster than those of traditional research projects.</p><p>Funder involvement remains quite low, and early tailoring of the project is easy due to reduced start-up times. As the push to adopt distributed ledger technologies around the globe grows, it is likely that the values of decentralization will be increasingly embraced and mirrored in the implementation of research funding strategies.</p><h4>5.2. Case Studies and Success Stories</h4><p>Below are case studies and success stories from researchers involved in highly successful projects that provide empirical support for the effectiveness of decentralized funding models. These compelling stories and descriptions resonate with potential grantees and underscore the opportunities made possible by these processes. Success Stories The following are compelling descriptions from projects that were recommended through these processes. Notably, these projects have realized an outstanding impact in their fields and have demonstrated the enormous potential for decentralized funding in research areas that have been historically underserved. It is important to emphasize these narratives not just for the stories they tell but for their potential to motivate future grantees and to inspire great leaps in enhancement of and access to research.</p><p>Robotics in Construction The Robo Innovations in Construction project funds cultural programming and community outreach that serves to familiarize people with automatic construction equipment and the worldwide robotics applications related to it. By opening communication channels and engaging with communities of new end users, funded projects can develop entirely new or improved products and practices for a specific population. The accommodating industry need could involve innovative ways of furnishing this equipment to that population.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hlPYoXD7w43Iget6lSTyiQ.png" /></figure><h4>6. Conclusion</h4><p>Research has shown consistently that traditional funding models have accentuated funding disparities, dramatically affecting research in underserved fields. Meanwhile, the centralized funding model has created a risk-averse scientific culture, with negative effects on innovation and research quality. Scholarship also shows DeSci as guaranteeing more equitable access to resources, diversifying what research gets funded, and more fairly distributing the level of resources that are accessed across the funded body. The challenges faced by underserved fields in attracting traditional support, as well as the potential solutions in a DeSci system, are equally multi-faceted, though there are promising therapeutic opportunities to be exploited.</p><p>Associates from racialized groups and women are underrepresented groups in precision health research. Such differential representation and subsequent inequities in the genomic, health data, and research models being produced relative to these groups favor the development of products and services optimised for individuals of European descent as opposed to all Canadians. Exacerbating these harms is that this unjust differential representation, particularly that of women, occurs across the research spectrum and in conjunction with the crises of insufficient funding support facing precision health and growing competition from other fields of research for the funding support that is available under the existing funding models. The two-tier federal funding era that Canadian researchers are entering is likely to exacerbate these inequities further. While a DeSci pilot initiative has been primarily concerned with enhancing funding support available to investigators in computer science transcending disciplinary boundaries, particularly junior investigators, ongoing iterations of this platform offer an excellent opportunity to rigorously study the effectiveness of DeSci initiatives for addressing these pressing funding issues and injustices.</p><p>One recommended area for future exploration is the measurement of the impact of a DeSci-like open call — specifically examining the volume, quality, and diversity of applications submitted — against a more traditional call for proposals. Finally, we note that none of the aforementioned suggested systemic changes to research funding practices can take place without collaboration among key stakeholders communicating and advancing policy, including funding agencies, not-for-profit organizations, and industry. We invite stakeholders interested in pursuing these conversations to reach out.</p><h4>6.1. Recommendations for Future Research</h4><p>Strategies for conducting high-quality research, open to all, that have yet to be reached and run in underserved areas of thinking or doing may need a fresh start. We propose a few such ideas worthy of further investigation. Though the potential of DeSci as a model for executing research is well covered, the pursuit of these and the accompanying impact upon funding have not yet been subject to widespread attention. Future research could dismantle these independent diligence activities or could explore the art of directly pursuing these ideas. Research funders worldwide could provide seed money to test innovative funding models specifically for underserved initiatives.</p><p>We argue that within the findings of that action research, a focus on more equitable conditions for the R&amp;D community would be a priority. Priority topics involving novel funding models include Diversified funding mechanisms, which can multiply resources and facilitate the experimentation of research approaches, skills, and methodologies. Some research funds could be further accompanied by connectivity, networking, and mentorship grants. Mandating community-based and experiment-induction approaches, combining researcher-driven calls and initiatives, and community-driven reviews from stakeholders. Building stakeholder capacity by training activities and involvement throughout the design and decision-making processes. Liaison between research grants and topic-targeted research funds that seek outcomes from the pilot-funded programs.</p><p>Impose transparency, accountability, and responsibility for monitoring and evaluation. To undergo and streamline new approaches, funding agencies might form multi-funder partnerships. Encourage collaborative funding mechanisms to support proposals consisting of an entire group of collaborating and potentially interdisciplinary teams. Investment in a model and conduct to collect case studies and champions showcasing the success of initiatives, but also valuable information about stumbling blocks and setbacks. Encourage and seek out evaluations from ‘more than one perspective,’ including the exploration of ‘the sustainability and required adoption of shared resources and activities.’ Make use of lessons from the social sciences to document and innovate complex scenarios that are engaging and incorporate innovation with the interdisciplinary expertise in research and social science framework, including involvement studies of how different funding mechanisms are utilized and internalized by the community.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uns7hMMdHTNlQxNlWDikpQ.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=027532afb320" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Decentralized science and artificial intelligence is changing how science is done.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MetforminSol/the-intersection-of-decentralized-science-and-artificial-intelligence-is-reshaping-the-landscape-of-e3313a929bc5?source=rss-09ea9d9db1d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e3313a929bc5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[desci]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medicine]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MetforminSol]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 05 Dec 2024 10:56:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-05T11:03:22.551Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WbmpunpQRajRMGGIi46Y6Q.png" /></figure><p>Decentralized science and artificial intelligence is changing how science is done. This transformation is largely due to new technologies and a better communication platform that is changing the ways that we conduct, analyze and share research. These types of changes in how science is done are driven largely by three underlying factors: interdisciplinary work, larger data access, and open-access publishing modalities. The developments in AI that are driving human thought in new directions are walking in lockstep with decentralized science (DeSci) and they are going to take human discovery into whole new areas.</p><p>As these fields mature, they are fundamentally altering traditional approaches to:</p><p>— Research design and methodology</p><p>— Data analysis and interpretation</p><p>— Knowledge dissemination and peer review</p><p>— Scientific collaboration and resource allocation</p><p>This analysis explores the foundational principles of decentralized science and artificial intelligence, highlighting their complementary nature in modern research. By examining their synergistic relationship, we can better understand their collective impact on scientific advancement and anticipate future developments in these transformative domains. The convergence of these technologies promises to democratize scientific research while enhancing its efficiency and reproducibility. Understanding their interplay is crucial for researchers, institutions, and policymakers as they navigate the evolving landscape of scientific discovery.</p><p>We begin by providing an introduction to decentralized science and artificial intelligence. Next, we map established artificial intelligence capabilities onto decentralized science’s proposed key mechanisms. This is followed by examining at a high level some of the more sophisticated artificial intelligence predictions regarding the likely characteristics that significant components of the decentralized science research environment will have in the future.</p><p>Finally, we conclude with some directions for exploring possibilities of combinations of features of decentralized science and artificial intelligence. The creation of emerging research fields is revolutionizing research through technological advancements, enabling researchers to work at increasingly interconnected levels. Interdisciplinarity and transdisciplinarity are principles that underpin the recent evolution of the conduct of original research. Interdisciplinary teams bring together researchers from different domains.</p><h3>2. Decentralized Scientific Platforms</h3><p>Science 1.1 grew from the Enlightenment and Industrial Revolution that facilitated more collaborative research than any other point in history. However, the size and complexity of interdisciplinary research often lead to fragmented and less effective science. In this paper we explore decentralized platforms for research.</p><p>Research is a controversial space for decentralization for many reasons, including the myriad of public funds that feed research endeavors, the historically conservative changes in scientific inquiry, and ethical concerns about allowing pseudoscience platforms to exist. Consequently, the historical trend has been the centralization of the processes of how research is conducted, monitored, and shared.</p><p>Research led by the US Office of Science and Technology Policy created a roadmap for knowledge infrastructures that could decouple from centralized control. They coined this vision, “DeSci,” distributed or decentralized science that unites fields into adaptive knowledge infrastructures.</p><p>These DESCO platforms would be community-governed, transparent, and accessible. The DeSci vision aligns with a contemporary open access model that is concerned about who controls science and can afford access. DeSci shifts the dynamics of who can access data because community stake and governance provide incentivization and trust beyond just cash. Similarly, a fallback to central utilization of funds is no longer relevant if the science conducted could be shared widely.</p><p>The objectives of this newer view of decentralized science are to break down barriers and increase the inclusivity of science by uniting knowledge networks and the actors that utilize them. If this vision could become a reality, it could enable a shift from “silos of intelligence and action” that limit the potential for innovation to occur. This shift could enhance the potential to combine knowledge from different fields. This work is both cautiously optimistic about the future possibilities of an AI-driven knowledge commons techno-science and cognizant of the challenges ahead. It tries to create a critical discussion on the ‘expert’ vision and process of this evolution, as the field is still dynamically emerging.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jv5dzhIe7ciCp-qhPMiVRQ.png" /></figure><h3>2.1. Definition and Characteristics</h3><p>A decentralized scientific platform (#DeSci platform for short) could be understood as a software platform that is “decentralized” in governance, using token-based economic incentives and emphasizing open collaboration. In a broader context, the term could also refer to any effort in building a decentralized scientific research infrastructure. We call these technological infrastructures decentralized scientific infrastructures (or DeSci infrastructures for short). Decentralized has a broad definition, including peer-to-peer and federated systems. Peer-to-peer means data interaction directly between participants without a centralized intermediary. Federated means multiple nodes connected together to form a logical collective whole, which may gradually evolve into peer-to-peer exchanges through mutual trust.</p><p>Unlike the centralized scientific platforms (where gatekeepers are in charge of decision-making), DeSci platforms are characterized by three main features, including decentralized governance, open collaboration, and peer-to-peer interaction. Decentralized governance means that all the scientific policy discussions and service management are transparent and made by a collective consisting of all contributors and stakeholders, without imposing decisions on all others. Open collaboration means that all the research processes, especially the earlier ones of data collection and hypothesis generation, are transparent and collaborative, well connected with different citizen science communities.</p><p>Finally, in order for all of the above to be effective, a DeSci infrastructure must be developed, which will be capable of decentralizing the data transactions and having independent methods to guarantee privacy and trust. At present, these can be enabled by decentralized marketing techniques, especially blockchain and smart contracts. The DeSci community is also composed of a variety of participants, including those with interest, those with resource contributions, and also professional researchers. The word “contributor” is used to mean participants with any kind of resource contribution, including data or ideas.</p><p>The current landscape of DSCIs is thriving yet full of diverse options. In general, these different platforms have more about their workings in common than the only differences in focus would suggest. A fundamental challenge common to all DSCIs is to develop the technology and methodology to decentralize data transactions such that the critical values of these platforms are delivered despite the lack of trusted intermediaries. At present, blockchain appears to be the most effective way to achieve this.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*L3DhYMo5fAzAL7Pu_EyT4g.png" /></figure><h3>2.2. Benefits and Challenges</h3><p>The opportunities offered by DeSci platforms are numerous. Opening up access to research will allow a greater audience to discover the novel insights that can be gained from research in diverse domains. Increasing access to expensive research environments and software resources will allow for scientific discoveries by individuals who did not have access to cutting-edge software and methodologies, democratizing science. Capitalizing on diverse disciplinary talents in research environments will stimulate scientific exploration and innovation, pushing the field forward. Incorporating diverse perspectives into the scientific research environment is therefore likely to precipitate novel scientific breakthroughs. The transparency guaranteed by decentralized data storage and management also promises to transform fields with poor replication rates.</p><p>However, the DESCI platforms have been criticized on several counts. They are accused of naivety and impracticality, particularly in light of the recent wave of misinformation. Indeed, it is particularly important when dealing with health data to avoid participating in malicious or misleading behavior. Regulatory considerations must also be acknowledged as, without robust frameworks, ethical guidelines, and patient and participant trust, these systems will remain unfeasible. Therefore, while the potential outcomes of DeSci participation are exciting, we maintain a skepticism that matching this in reality is extremely challenging. In contrasting decentralized database systems with promised research outcomes, new and exciting opportunities are opened for the implementation of AI toward DeSci ends. In the subsequent discussion, several pertinent barriers and concerns are explicated, preventing the successful rollout of the vision of DeSci as stated.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mTGwSrD3NnX1SHDhZzMejQ.png" /></figure><h3>3. Artificial Intelligence in Research</h3><p>Artificial intelligence (AI) refers to the development of computational systems that can mimic human intelligence to perform tasks. The most important AI paradigms useful for research are: machine learning, which is composed of a series of algorithms making use of statistical methods to build autonomous models of the data underpinning them; natural language processing (NLP), which is an AI subfield informed by linguistics, computer science, and information engineering, focusing on the interaction between computers and human languages; and data mining, which is the continuous discovery of new correlations, patterns, trends, and common information in huge repositories of data stored in databases. In this context, AI can be used by researchers to identify interesting information or surprising trends that might have been easily overlooked due to the huge volume and complexity.</p><p>AI techniques are used in various research activities, from the generation of new research ideas to the development and implementation of innovative methodological tools aimed at evaluating, giving a value to, comparing, and combining the results from different sources of data and their meta-analyses. They can also be used in the processes of prepublication review, postpublication peer review, editor decision-making, or identifying individuals likely to make outstanding contributions. AI technologies can also enhance specific research methods, contributing to the augmentation of existing paradigms or supporting innovative scientific and technological research ideals.</p><p>Several fields of scientific research can take advantage of AI, including life sciences and biomedicine, humanities and social sciences, natural sciences, education, or engineering. For example, in biomedicine, AI algorithms are used to predict patient survival times, improve diagnostics and treatment monitoring, and predict the risk of developing a certain disease. AI can also be used for drug development and to predict and improve the properties of new materials, to mention but a few applications. These AI-based solutions are used for assisting in diverse stages of research, from formulating research ideas, advancing processes, comparing publications, peer review, evaluation, and analysis of impact throughout research and regional internationalization. As a consequence, various AI methods and algorithms capable of efficiently analyzing vast amounts of data have been developed and tested, revealing added value for researchers and research management.</p><p>AI advantages encompass time enhancement, besides improved accuracy and efficiency. Moreover, they favor the identification of insights and the detection of new indicators characterizing and addressing unexplored fields of application. Thus, the relevance of AI technologies is determined only by the research topics and aims of interest. It is possible to assist the research process at different stages: from finding interesting problems, searching, and experimentation strategies to cross-linking researchers interested in the same problem.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IUpzDBm0eVvCpN4fnB7npw.png" /></figure><h3>3.1. Overview of AI Technologies</h3><p>The collaboration between AI technologies and research has become apparent in recent years, with notable successes in numerous fields. The three foundational paradigms of artificial intelligence are rule-based systems, theory-guided knowledge graphs and simulation, and data-driven machine learning and probabilistic approaches. Machine learning primarily operates on if-then-else types of rules, while deep learning discovers complex patterns. Neural networks learn from thousands of examples and can be implemented within machine learning to uncover associations and emergent features within data. Deep learning has especially benefited the fields of signals analysis and image processing, networking, computer vision, and the modeling of molecules and chemical compounds.</p><p>Machine learning has proven beneficial in many fields, especially in early disease diagnosis across medicine and healthcare. It has also been used in materials science for the discovery of new compounds, and modeling, while embedded in AI, has improved the field of brain-computer interfaces. Natural Language Processing (NLP) is a subspecialty in machine learning that has also seen vast improvements and has been impactful in directly benefiting researchers. NLP has revolutionized the retrieval of meaningful information from large volumes of data relevant to research and has included many tools such as information clustering and categorization, entity resolution, information similarity, sentiment analysis, and others.</p><p>There are also some emerging challenges when researchers engage in using AI systems. Ethics in deploying AI is a complex topic, fueling an entirely new field of study known as Fair AI, specifically concerned with bias, fairness, quality, and accountability built into AI models. Given the ability of AI tools to potentially discover latent links in data, there is a concern that these newly discovered assertions would need dual checks with conventional scientific questioning. The integration of AI tools within the DeSci evidence ecosystem will be enabled by both the design partner research ecosystem and, crucially, from the AI tool-building perspective.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tmah2LsgG9l4sS_-Dt_7BQ.png" /></figure><h3>3.2. Applications in Different Research Fields</h3><p>AI is transforming research paradigms across many fields. In healthcare, it extracts knowledge from multimodal patient data that outperforms any human expert. Cancer technology can diagnose oncological diseases based on images. In environmental science, machine learning algorithms are used to model and predict dangerous natural disasters and hazards. The community has also seen a tremendous increase in social science applications where AI practitioners use large-scale data generated on digital platforms to infer complex social phenomena. In telescope data analysis, AI is used for night sky characterization, and its applications are expanding. Astronomers use large, publicly available data archives to gain time. Thousands of scientific advances have come from new hypotheses that have been formulated after data analysis. At the same time, collaborations between AI and decentralized scientific platforms promise to create new research paradigms and open new frontiers in scientific discovery. The significance of such applications necessitates equal attention to the ethical implications of AI-powered science, including sources of bias and ethical research conduct, as well as concerns about patient privacy mentioned in the healthcare case presented earlier. To that end, we need to adapt our approaches in scientific inquiry to stay relevant; thus, methodological flexibility is key.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b0f7xrH9vf3SD7sI4V8DWA.png" /></figure><h3>4. Synergies between DeSci and AI</h3><p>A decentralized science (DeSci) future is inextricably bound to artificial intelligence (AI) advances. Platforms and systems built according to the DeSci paradigm can not only provide advanced proofs of concept for ongoing yet fragmented AI technologies but also depend critically on AI advances to operate at maximal efficiency. At the higher level of thought needed to envision the shape of future research practices, it is already postulated that a peaceful synergy could exist to the benefit of all between decentralized, global large-scale conducts of AI and the future organization of research through decentralized platforms. DeSci is dependent on large open datasets and thrusts AI to propose interpretations of said data, while AI needs complex datasets to evolve.</p><p>In the case of data and AI, the DeSci trusted multi-stakeholder platform — by encompassing a wider array of hypotheses, models, and interpretations from distinct DeSci Opportunity Studies that will increase the scientific return in a multi-objective quantity — should be able to generate a larger amount of trustable full perspectives concerning the available curated datasets than any single current method, helping the AI solution function as both a data-insurmountable interpretive source and also new systems of control over the flow of contributions, theory death, etc. Moreover, lattice form systems built on on-chain protocols and AI advances can help introduce a system to judge one model within the context of all other AI-documented models rather than in relation to past models. This is dependent upon the AI being tailored to emerging measures of interpretability to be effective. DeSci is aware that certain technologies do not yet exist to make this all-encompassing conversation and its organizations workable but hypothesizes these to be closer to realization than we might currently believe.</p><h3>4.1. Enhancing Data Analysis and Interpretation</h3><p>DeSci provides a collaborative space for scientists and researchers to share information and findings, creating comprehensive datasets that may be analyzed in various ways. The interaction between DeSci and AI in research lies in providing new capabilities for quality data analysis and interpretation within these platforms. Based on advanced algorithms, readily available machine learning techniques also provide tools for data analysis and interpretation either through data categorization and clustering, predictive analysis, or association rule discovery. It must be emphasized that AI is an amalgamation of analytical capabilities rather than a product of computational capabilities mediated through qualified algorithms and data interaction.</p><p>AI provides tools that can assess the characteristics, user interactions, and perceptions of the data. This would be very meaningful when applied to a decentralized scientific platform. Within these platforms, AI tools can be used to analyze large scientific data, search for trends that might escape our attention, and uncover associations and anomalies that might be overlooked in an initial assessment. These tools are also able to address large volumes of non-structured data as well as unstructured data and abstract data from its linear narrative, which could form a new mixed-method approach to improve the interpretive process. As in the case of the attractiveness of AI in several sectors, the effectiveness and usefulness of these tools make audits or experimental processes more flawless, therefore making decision-making more effective. Such tools will assist the DeSci community not only in generating better quality results but in reducing the time required for acquiring new knowledge. Nonetheless, it is essential to address relevant challenges in the ethical use of data and AI and in the bias and transparency of the approach. The AI of a decentralized scientific platform could further our democratization efforts in science by quantifying bias and inclusion within a scientific analysis.</p><h3>4.2. Improving Research Efficiency and Productivity</h3><p>One of the greatest opportunities that come with the partnership of AI and decentralized scientific research is to transform the speed, efficiency, and productivity of our efforts to pursue fundamental science questions in complex, interdisciplinary systems. The modern research process is highly dependent on domain-specific technological tools and services. AI can significantly reduce the time researchers spend performing repetitive tasks that rely on these tools, freeing the researchers to prioritize the creative and critical aspects of their work. Today we see these efficiencies in AI-driven services that extract, organize, manage, and analyze the data we create. Machine learning can use our data to build a useful taxonomic system, while AI reaches scientific consensus from disparate reports across global communities, and further AI/ML ultimately uses our growing databases to predict and suggest the innovative questions that will push the research field in new and impactful directions.</p><p>AI automates routine data cleanup and preparation, reducing the human labor needed and making more efficient use of high-value instrumentation and facilities. AI automates the recording of clinical histories and the incorporation of dynamic patient phenotyping into precision medical AI tools. AI analyzed astronomical images to discover a new planetary system. The machines can now create their taxonomies based on images of planets observed by the telescope. The power behind all these different things is the rapid extraction of research insights from large volumes of data, improving predictive modeling, and increasing research throughput and innovation. This power should lead to a greater emphasis on collaboration, whether it’s transactional or cross-disciplinary research efforts. The advantage of collaborating with industry around these projects is benefiting from the centralized databases, technical resources, and generally faster pace of development. ADeSci workflow that is designed to leverage these new AI-driven capabilities should improve member research efficiency, productivity of interdisciplinary teams, and the retention of team-based knowledge. That said, these practicalities cannot overshadow the importance of the narrative of the perpetual learning object or the fact that ADeSci workflows should inspire each new generation of members to craft their own strategic versions for ongoing contributions. The integration of adaptive workflows in decentralized scientific research is, of course, dependent on the success of transformative AI/ML in this field and the appropriate ethical oversight this collaboration demands. A meeting about how best to approach this transformative collaboration will be held in the spring. The primary focus will be to ask interdisciplinary questions and generate focused collaborations.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RAFmUpBkUx3CRwYEJMrDlg.png" /></figure><h3>5. Case Studies</h3><h4>Case Study : Enhancing Microbial Ecosystem Science</h4><p>In this case study, we describe a participatory proof-of-principle ecology project in the tradition of DeSci, using AI to assist expert researchers in uncovering threats to peat bog ecosystems from industry, policy, and management options. The project is run over a range of workshops with experts in ecology, microbiology, and peat bog ecosystem ecotoxicology. This case study is the first implementation of a new approach to DeSci as proposed in the preceding sections and has been described in more depth.</p><p>It is often difficult to measure factors that are hypothesized to be important or of interest because they are rare, extremely large in number, or located in hard-to-reach places, such as fungal spores. Given that there are parasites that can devour invasive fungi that are costly to eradicate, we used DeSci to ask participants in interdisciplinary workshops to engage in a foresight exercise, leveraged with AI, to address two questions: although emergent catastrophes are unlikely, might there be enough potential reproductive variance in “catastrophic consumers” to have them on our cost-focused radar? Or at what level of management strategy (e.g., single large donor site vs. lots of small applications, or tight spatial cordon options) or policy (e.g., is compliant protocol use cost-limited) are we worried about massive spore re-release and the ensuing bio-misery? For utility purposes, we confined our ambitions to devising the terms for tractable, then scalable, intelligent stochastic models of such peatland time courses with which AI would engage.</p><p>We present our story, rooted in DeSci, and outcomes below. Of particular interest is how DeSci can be enriched by AI and how AI interpretability can be enhanced by DeSci.</p><h3>6. Future Directions and Opportunities</h3><p>We have discussed here some directions and opportunities that may shape the future of DeSci and AI collaboration. Most likely, AI will continue advancements in terms of being and becoming more efficient and capable in processing and analyzing data. Such advancements may also benefit DeSci platforms, not only in data parsing and personalized information exchange but also in using cues to simplify and organize data, becoming more collaborative. In terms of practices, it is the very interdisciplinary nature of DeSci that boosts the loads on AI to contribute to smoother and more efficient collaboration between humans.</p><p>Hence, an adaptive framework and techniques developed in the course of adapting to DESCI are needed. A number of emerging trends point towards opportunities to further intertwine the two fields. For example, the growing emphasis on open science can be seen as an opportunity for technology development that is directly focused on efficiency and inclusivity of innovation. The increased emphasis that DeSci places on citizen involvement, in particular in addressing innovation’s externalities and societal implications, may prove to be another source for current and future opportunities. In terms of the sustainability of DeSci, what is emerging is a desire of DeSci platforms to accommodate the work that is produced and archived as a network instead of as the result of nested teams.</p><p>This will require a kind of platform adaptability that is presently not implementable but is — and we stress this — just about to become the focus of AI development for the next 20 years. The ethical limits of developing these technologies are, however, primarily set by people and people’s relations. If it is the case that AI development will evolve in these directions, then a large number of applications are appearing on the horizon that will see groundbreaking efficiencies for innovation, research, and strategy. At that point, if not anticipated and engaged now, the ethical discussions will be primarily applied in a business context. For any scientist that is not satisfied with the present rate of collaboration and scientific progress, this is about as tantalizing an opportunity to motivate research policy and direction as can be found. Given political support or even mandates, the convergence of AI and DeSci platforms can advance science and culture at a rate of change significantly ahead of any foreseeable alternative policy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S4Jd_qFZe4a6XfDxr2UQYw.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e3313a929bc5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[1. Introduction to Decentralized Research Communities]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MetforminSol/1-introduction-to-decentralized-research-communities-cde893d49fcb?source=rss-09ea9d9db1d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cde893d49fcb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[desci]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MetforminSol]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Dec 2024 12:01:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-04T12:03:29.031Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5iHT1RF0RITAb2vYSlIexA.png" /></figure><p>Decentralized research communities, dynamic and web-based, are becoming essential to advance interdisciplinary scientific collaborations that drive discovery. These communities are socio-technical systems that use technology to unite researchers from various disciplines, institutions, sectors, and nations to tackle significant scientific challenges. Online infrastructure designed to support social interactions allows for participation, coordinated communication, and distributed collaboration. These tools facilitate not only the sharing and management of scientific data but also the social dynamics of building research communities and making informed decisions.</p><p>Despite vastly different funding levels, missions, and governance structures, several of these systems seem to share the same principles, which facilitates the exchange of expertise between otherwise stovepiped scientific communities. The three systems with which we are familiar harness scientific knowledge and expertise in varied ways to address urgent societal needs.Until recently, many other collaborative, multimillion-dollar scientific research projects operated under centralized control, with professional staff members directing their course. These decentralized systems are pioneering a fundamentally different model of the scientific endeavor — one that takes advantage of the distributed energy and expertise of the “<strong>global science community.</strong>”</p><p>Intensive, several-day-long online collaboration and strategic planning efforts have been crucial to the success of these systems, which are otherwise running independently of one another. The decentralization inherent in these systems has created new opportunities for interdisciplinary thinking. A workshop focused on the governance of decentralized, emergent techno-social systems. We are particularly interested in such large-scale decentralized collaborative systems in the context of scientific inquiry. But this paper is intended to suggest a broader relevance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iXtyRA73Q8VRB4pmWyUlmQ.png" /></figure><h3>1.1. Defining Decentralization in Scientific Ecosystems</h3><p>The term “decentralization” is used with increasing frequency. In the context of scientific ecosystems, we use ‘decentralization’ to distinguish among different organizational elements of these systems. These elements include, for example, the availability of communication technologies and the manner in which decisions on resource allocation are made. The form and extent of decentralization have implications for the dynamics of scientific research. In order to discuss governance issues and attempt to predict their impact, it is thus a prerequisite to specify the relevant form of decentralization in research fields.</p><p>In scientific endeavors, decentralization is often associated with a more democratic allocation of resources, implying greater and more equal access to centralized resources. Face-to-face learning and group problem-solving sessions are associated with a relatively centralized organization. In contrast, open educational resources that are freely available from centralized locations may be used by a wide variety of organizations and teachers to create customized learning experiences for particular audiences. Relational skills needed for informal learning are thus less central to decentralized organizations. In a fully decentralized organization, all facilities and human resources are evenly available to all, so the placement of an individual is without concern. Imagine, for example, a hurricane relief effort where the central committee values facilitating informal interactions across relief workers more than having them work one-on-one with affected people. It may place the relief workers’ housing on one side of the disaster site, which functions in a decentralized, and arguably undemocratic, manner. In contrast, an emergency relief effort that values equal contact between the protected and the rescuers may place the rescue workers in the center of the affected population, thus increasing the likelihood that the workers will directly interact with the victims. These examples attempt to illustrate that the lack of a centralized facility in no way implies that the organization is fully and completely decentralized.</p><p>Technological platforms certainly facilitate the diffusion of information, expertise, and ‘things’ that are essential elements of decentralized organizations. However, facilitating technology alone does not make an organization — including scientific fields — decentralized. In order to do that, technology, in combination with community engagement, must work toward the diffusion of resources (especially in the form of social relationships and trust) and information to ensure that there are as few barriers as possible to an individual’s participation. This inclusive definition of decentralization thus redirects attention to the ethical practices of not just technological development but the whole of social practices within a regulated environment. Regulatory concerns, in this context, are not just focused on technological advances; they are focused on the kind of communities these technologies help to produce, reproduce, and disrupt. Furthermore, a fully inclusive, decentralized organization would have to facilitate the diffusion of all material and relations essential to the sociotechnical field of practice (determined by political, ethical, or cultural considerations), not just the relations conducive to science.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2ZjrTG0_iRmLfazQFX8T9g.png" /></figure><h3>2. Ethical Considerations in Decentralized Research</h3><p>Decentralized research often operates in an environment of open access and transparency, where the data that are collected and the systems that manipulate those data are generally open to review and correction. In order to realize the benefits of transparency, however, researchers must find a balance between data privacy and secrecy on the one hand and strict data openness on the other. Making data open may reveal sensitive transactions and other personal information related to real people. Commonly, participants are promised data security and confidentiality in exchange for agreed-upon restrictions in data usage or the provision of informed consent regarding who has access and under what conditions.</p><p>Participants in decentralized research labs and user-driven ecosystems have differing expectations, comfort levels, and risks around the types of data that are being collected and shared. For these reasons, separate from ethical review boards, it is necessary to employ good data privacy and security practices, which involve the confidential reporting of data breaches, user entry, and the right to have all collected data deleted to help assure participants. In addition, informed consent cannot be sought once from a decentralized stakeholder who might participate in multiple studies over time and be from multiple research teams. All stakeholders, from system users to research participant platforms and teams working together to answer research questions, must agree in some manner to ensure that the data that underpins their collaborations can be made available.</p><p>Integrity and trust depend on the ability to demonstrate whatever controls or assumptions in the underlying data allowed any decisions or conclusions to be reached. It is in the best interests of the research community to be as transparent as possible. There are significant ethical motivations to follow these guidelines, including protecting themselves and the wider community from inflated promises, stalking, discrimination, or harm as a result of fully open, decentralized research. It’s important to operate using a set of community-adopted guidelines, which allows individuals an explicit tool to guide them in making ethical choices and highlight good research actors with whom they might wish to collaborate. Full transparency down to the data encourages research integrity in two senses: when differences appear between the conclusions of the original research and those who cross-validate, the protection of the public sense of research integrity can be a concern.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ikC4kred-UpnDcH8cXgMsQ.png" /></figure><h3>2.1. Data Privacy and Security</h3><p>This paper presents a catalogue of issues reflecting current thinking in thought and practice about decentralized education (DE) and the governance and management of research. This catalogue is supported by a wide range of peer-reviewed literature. We begin by noting three definitions of DE that reflect important principles that we argue should underpin the governance of the Decentralized Research Community (DRC). These are open science, environmental sustainability, and the commitment to diverse and inclusive research. We add to these principles a fourth: alignment with social impacts and outcomes recognized and desired by the community. The representation of this fourth principle is derived from groundwork laid by the Responsible Research and Innovation Initiative, with the elaboration given as the most immediate extension of previous work.</p><p>Through an overview of data privacy and security relevant to decentralized communities, we identify core DE issues related to data and ethics. Among the ethical considerations, we note that DE needs communities that serve the large and diverse audience of interested scholars, scientists, and social stakeholders, which is likely to contain people who have not been involved in the DE process of managing the community. This lack of involvement is likely to extend to a lack of overt consent to the use of data generated by the DE process. Provided such a community embodies the governance principles we identify at the beginning of the paper, the use of data from a DE process should not be controversial, provided that all participants are at liberty to request their data be omitted from analysis. We consider this approach in more detail in our discussion of the law. Finally, we review two models that offer insight into the ethical values of decentralized communities and are directly relevant to work on normative analysis, though these do not directly impact the building of our governance principles.</p><h3>2.2. Transparency and Accountability</h3><p>Building and maintaining trust among decentralized communities is essential given the high rates of diversity in participant backgrounds, motivations, and knowledge. Trust is both a relationship toward morally considerable others and an essential ingredient for enabling productive and enjoyable dialogue and collaboration. Communities can build trust through the practice of transparency, which involves making one’s methods and results open to the rest of the community. Transparent practices lower the barriers to historical and prospective access. Open-access publishing is one effective means of ensuring broad access, but there are trade-offs between the level of openness and its perceived credibility and trustworthiness.</p><p>By bringing activities into public view, transparency can allow communities to self-regulate and keep the public’s trust through the development of robust accountability frameworks. Accountability refers to the expectation that individuals or groups can be called to account or be sanctioned based on their responsibility for certain actions and their right to control outcomes within a specified domain. In institutional design, accountability systems can minimize the temptation of individuals or groups to take advantage of their positions by ensuring they will be held responsible for their actions. The current institutional cultures in decentralized communities carry various degrees of transparency and accountability to different constituencies.</p><p>In order to avoid idiosyncratic, ethically questionable actions of single powerful individuals or groups, it is recommended that research communities design their governance to explicitly spread responsibility among members. Otherwise, powerful individuals or groups are likely to block any attempt to create formally accountable institutional structures. Participatory governance is often discussed as a good mechanism to spread power and decision rights around in specifically designed governance bodies. Power-sharing mechanisms also necessarily create feedback loops and inclusive practices in order to work. Openness and transparency can eliminate real and perceived power imbalances. It is important to have clear and fair procedures for the allocation of credit and resources and for addressing disputes arising from the collective and specific initiatives developed by research community members.</p><p>A large open research community devoted to the exchange and accumulation of knowledge about a single research issue: machine reading of textual data. As an illustrative example, we note that the main forum of communication is a platform that makes all information accessible to the world: project description, agenda, problems and scenarios for machine reading, a growing list of leaders of tasks, and papers discussing possible solutions. Participants can choose how they wish to involve themselves; they can carry out their plan of research in private, or they can put research online as they go along.</p><p>Importantly, democratic and consensus-based decisions are embedded in the common infrastructure of the platform; all the details for how the participants made these decisions are listed next to providing direct access to the committee’s data. Any community member can set up new coordination or administration bodies, but there is a broad consensus about which committees are fair and which are not. Obviously, there is a risk of “squatting” committees and structures with little involvement, so an accountability mechanism has also been built, which periodically evaluates the quality of community members. Decentralized experimentation is the bread and butter of a scientist’s daily life as we move between projects and laboratories that differ not only in geographic location and technique but more fundamentally in the social relations of practice. Approximately 80% of respondents agree that an important open research ethic is to validate findings in varied environments.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lZij3sLUgMiawo7pGfEFMA.png" /></figure><h3>3. Governance Models for Decentralized Scientific Ecosystems</h3><p>In envisioning decentralized ecosystems, one key design question is the mechanism by which the community can manage and direct its many activities. Several governance models are in use in the decentralized community, each with distinct implications. The obvious model for community-led ecosystems is some form of community-led governance. In a community-led ecosystem, community members use collective decision-making and their own stakeholding in the ecosystem to guide research decisions made in the ecosystem. It is apparent from this experiment that community-led funding has great potential to finance diverse, community-relevant research interests. There are several downsides to this governance model, however. Against the spirit of decentralized finance, governance can evolve to become influence-based when value is tied to decision-making power, potentially disempowering valuable and non-wealthy community members with valuable insights that should inform research. It might also slow down research funding decisions, as each proposal will require extensive review.</p><p>An increasing number of decentralized communities are expressed via algorithms and smart contracts: the use of predictive models is now standard in using oracles to inform data settlement for blockchain-based prediction markets; several decentralized research infrastructures use written plans and data availability checks to allow smart contract algorithms to resolve disputes in the underlying research process; and a few decentralized finance projects use smart contracts to issue new or derivative financing — auto-compounding contracts — constituting algorithmic controls without direction from a development team. Finally, some are exploring adapting contemporary algorithmic decision systems to support registered decentralized communities in collectively determining future research goals.</p><p>These are likely only a few of many possible governance models, and the design paths of more complex, multi-level human-machine, automated governance systems are an open area for future research. The degree to which technology, as a decision support aid, interacts with human decision-making will be a central area of concern; designers will need to create processes for preventing or monitoring the effect of automation bias in algorithmic communities. We are also concerned with ensuring that systems are informed by values and respect for a range of stakeholders as human-machine hybrid research decision-making systems are developed. Ethical questions include how and when to engage with citizens as experts and the relative importance of consent by those registering such governance.</p><h3>3.1. Community-Led Governance</h3><p>Community-led governance is an important body of practice that can inform governance in decentralized research communities, helping these to be more democratic, inclusive, and responsive. The governance body in community-led governance endeavors to include everyone who will be affected by its decisions, and the criteria for membership of the governance body depend on the questions that are at hand. Principles linked with this approach include inclusiveness, or involving everyone; respect for and recognition of different voices and experiences; participation and cooperation, or involving people in making decisions that will affect them; distributed knowledge, or valuing the variety of sources and types of knowledge held by different community members; and shared authority, or distributing decision-making powers between different communities and/or community members. As a result, such processes are highly responsive to the needs and experiences of the affected community, provide context-specific evidence, and empower local communities.</p><p>A number of examples in the scientific literature express enthusiasm for these principles in a broad sense but lack implementation or detail. Fortunately, there is an expansive literature on the functioning of these principles in the fields of cooperative and community management of natural resources. As we move from practice to principle to research, community-led governance can therefore offer a lens for considering the notion of stakeholder engagement not as a prescribed add-on to governance and the research enterprise, and not just as tools, skills, best practices, or respectful dialogue for building stakeholder relations, but rather as the means to self-governance. A growing body of evidence demonstrates that community-led governance processes help to develop research questions that are of real-world relevance and importance, help to identify the context-specific parameters needed to answer and implement research, help to engage affected communities and citizens in the research, and develop science at reduced cost.</p><h3>3.2. Algorithmic Governance</h3><p>The term algorithmic governance is used to describe the utilization of algorithms for the management and regulation of a system such as an organization, a market, or a platform community. Examples include the use of recommender systems or the content moderation algorithms employed by various platforms. Furthermore, we can distinguish between better algorithmic performance due to increased scalability and cost-efficiency and complete reliance on automated algorithmic decision-making to support, or indeed, make decisions. The use of algorithms to manage decentralized research communities could similarly help to optimize processes and resource allocation. However, using algorithmic solutions can carry certain ethical risks, such as a reduction of the degree of human oversight or, in the case of recommender or reputation algorithms, group bias. Moreover, hidden algorithmic decision-making is often associated with a demand for transparency and accountability. Mechanisms devised to directly engage community members may, however, still be considered better suited for some research organizations.</p><p>There is increased interest in experimenting with the governance of algorithms. There are a few examples of platforms and communities using algorithmic governance tools and frameworks. One platform has opened up its viewer ratings to a democratic, community-driven decision-making mechanism. It offers its audience the opportunity to build their own opinion of the running stream by being able to rate every single contribution. The recommendation system makes it easier for audiences to watch relevant content by suggesting content that they are most likely to be interested in. As long as users have the final say about their interactions with the platform, the platform team has a high degree of influence regarding algorithm-powered recommendation behavior.</p><p>The purpose of creating and fine-tuning transparency and, especially, accountability and redress features to the algorithmic recommendation system is to ensure fair and equitable recommendations for professional video producers. Community power can only be made use of if the community is aware of and has trust in the recommendation system. Only then will viewers watch the greatest possible number of videos to rate them, ensuring a representative user rating sample. A community refinement tool was designed and tested in various settings, not in the wild but within settings resembling the target users. It was decided not to open the community refinement tool now due to privacy reasons.</p><p>Algorithmic governance can encode the objectives and operating principles of a decentralized research community in a computer program and automate routine decision-making. One can think of the community or organization as an adaptive enterprise that aims to thrive despite the adversity of conflicting interests and biases. In addition, through code rather than governance, a fair playing field can be shaped on which community members can enter the game. This means that communities can be designed to be democratic, open, and equitable, independent of how biased or selfish their contributors are. This section discusses the potential for algorithmic governance, but also the challenges and trade-offs that are involved. The discussion centres on the use of algorithms within happenings and spaces to help maintain community integrity and trust through decision making. Despite such challenges, a key point argued in this design pattern of using algorithmic governance to define a community revolves around the idea of doocracy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SFXV5O405ssu08SSw9Q5fQ.png" /></figure><h3>4. Case Studies and Best Practices</h3><p>Through the lens of our case studies, we underscore that effective practices to develop ethical guidance in decentralized research communities must be grounded in the acknowledged value and importance of these guidelines to the community and the work. As such, we offer concrete best practices developed through the lens of real-world examples that are situated in diverse contexts and academic disciplines. Importantly, we emphasize community engagement and investment in developing and operationalizing such ethical guidelines and demonstrate how such practices can enhance research outcomes and community cohesion. Our case studies illustrate a commitment to ensuring that ethical governance reflects community realities and seeks to support an ethical and inclusive research environment grounded in the efforts of the community. We have highlighted instances where infrastructures have faced challenges and adapted their governance arrangements in response, underscoring that developing effective ethical guidelines and practices is an iterative process often marked by continuous learning. Our aim is to provide guidance to others who may wish to develop similar community endeavors but may lack the necessary resources and institutional support. With this intention, we have identified some best practices that we have observed in our case studies, focusing on our extensive observation of the technical and process modalities of these communities, from their inception through to their best practices and challenges. Through this work, we offer guideposts to others with the aim of nurturing not just communities that are respectful of ethical and regulatory niceties but also collectives that take forward new knowledge production models designed for the digital age.</p><h3>4. Successful Implementation of Ethical Guidelines</h3><p>4. Successful Implementation of Ethical Guidelines</p><p>For example, the community navigated a delicate ethical balance in their dispute resolution procedure and successfully addressed ethical tension. Specifically, the community-led governor facilitated a dispute resolution vote between two parties who had gone into a partnership to farm. The dispute was over funds locked on a forking blacklist that had been generated by a pool smart contract. There were minimum financial stakes that traders and farmers could risk, with migration to a new instance of the pool potentially resulting in the devaluation of funds still in the locked pool contract. In this, the community aligned a novel approach with the globally recognized human values proposed by the judgments of the public across different educational, economic, gender, religious, sexual orientation, language, age, and timespan cohorts. Furthermore, voters strongly associated those suffering harm (including farmers that had entered into an agreement to help add liquidity to access tokens as well as the general public) with greater moral support for long-term harm triggering voting.</p><p>Successfully implemented guidelines derived from a trustworthy AI framework include having strong leadership, ensuring tools for communication and social cohesion are shared and updated, and increasingly focusing on effective digital tools to address demands for communication and information exchange. Furthermore, effective forums collect and analyze data to judge community views, capacities, and risks. For example, tools are collected, used, and updated to determine why contributors stop contributing. Executive decision-making has reflected consensus, due process, and a community enveloping and is transparent and accountable. Moreover, for successful guideline implementation, communities also recognize that the development of digital common goods involves ethical questions that need to be addressed. Membership has been limited to reduce the risk of trolling or bad actors. Decisions are endorsed by the community following established processes, ratified by the community, and supported by the community. Ethical priorities are audited through surveys every quarter and as necessary. At times, there is organizational representation at every meeting. Leadership is predominantly at the senior and professional level. Furthermore, feedback loops are built for constant improvement. Further development work will improve this.</p><h3>5. Conclusion and Future Directions</h3><p>Hearkening back to collective deliberations, we note here the importance of striking a balance between fostering innovation and discovery on the one hand and pursuing the development of genuinely responsible and ethically sound research practices on the other. The challenges and opportunities presented by formulating ethics and governance within decentralized models are many, and future work in this arena will benefit from further empirical grounding. In order to lower barriers to entry facing decentralized technologies and infrastructures, communities and their allies often advocate for standardized and open protocols. These protocols are often developed in consultation with expert practitioners and standards-makers, who often share learned experiences and practical considerations. Decisions that arise from protocols are often compiled into hedged performances, which form the basis for oversight.</p><p>Trust in decentralized models is frequently presented as being engendered, at least in part, by increased transparency and the notion of shared learning. These conceptual underpinnings proffer opportunities and constraints for rethinking actor-network relationships and helping to visualize responsibilities and accountabilities in new ways. These risk mitigation strategies present real and fruitful areas of inquiry for those studying decentralization. In summary, we note that a series of developments related to ethics and governance in decentralized systems reveal a wealth of activities, research, and work done by practitioners, scholars, and regulators. These activities relate to both preliminary examination and a broader engagement with translational ethics. Coincident with the burgeoning developments are emerging and compounded ethical dilemmas related to intelligence, privacy, bias, equity, transparency, and manipulation. Agility and foresight will be important for organizations and politics as they work to address these ethical issues.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cde893d49fcb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ethical and Methodological Considerations in Animal Studies]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MetforminSol/ethical-and-methodological-considerations-in-animal-studies-d6c72e5abc93?source=rss-09ea9d9db1d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d6c72e5abc93</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[animal-welfare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[desci]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MetforminSol]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Dec 2024 17:55:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-02T17:55:38.736Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>1. Introduction to Animal Studies</h3><p>For many species, the genetic and physiological similarity between humans and other animals is considerable, and so animal studies are both scientifically relevant and ethically controversial. To date, animal studies have been a critical tool for advancing biomedical research, understanding human and non-human behavior, and assessing chemical and environmental impacts. Academic and biomedical domains continue to underrepresent comprehensive treatments of ethical and methodological issues specific to animal studies, despite widespread public interest and use and a growing body of literature. This paper’s goal is not to suggest a change in current practice or a specific set of practical guidelines. Instead, it will talk about the pros, cons, and difficulties of animal research and look at the ethical and methodological principles and evidence that guide policy and practice decisions. Humans have utilized animals in research for many centuries. Indeed, a historical perspective is useful in considering the evolving roles of animals in research and society.</p><p>Opportunities for scientific discovery and associated applications are now reaching previously unimaginable capacities as our study of genetics and understanding of the regulation and manipulation of life have expanded. The consequences of these innovations are mixed and controversial, raising questions about risk and responsibility. Factors limiting scientific research include apathy, lack of awareness, and lack of interest in evaluation. Similarly, resistance in institutions and the general public hampers the progression of biomedical advances that lead to successful, albeit problematic, animal studies. Therefore, enriching the body of responsible methods and open public accounts, so obligatory for the necessary weighing that forms the basis of a robust integrative pluralism, is a valuable contribution in developing more refined, sustainable, and replaceable procedures in animal studies.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*e2Gw9-75g5GXJRNXsYDjmg.png" /></figure><h3>2. Ethical Guidelines and Regulations</h3><p>Before beginning this discussion, it is important to note that it is often preferable from both a scientific and regulatory standpoint to use parasites as the organisms under study. The use of parasites as model organisms is commonly known as systems parasitology. A system-level approach provides a distinct set of benefits and challenges and is beyond the scope of these guidelines. Although systems parasitology is often preferable, there are ethical considerations associated with both host and parasite research that are worth noting. This will be similar to and build upon existing ethical considerations in host animal research and research in wildlife. First and foremost, we must justify the use of host animals in research and teaching, while also ensuring their humane treatment and minimizing their suffering. Parallel research on the etiology of disease and the development of potential therapeutics or vaccines also uses animals. The use of animal subjects in both research paradigms requires appropriate consideration of the ethical issues.</p><p>Most people agree that some form of ethical guidance and oversight is necessary. Recommendations have been made for the formation of an Ethical Review Board for ethically challenging proposals or that two committees — an Animal Care and Use Committee and an Ethical Review Board — be combined in institutions where there are likely to be only a few such proposals. A survey of representatives of publicly funded institutions in some countries revealed that a significant percentage of institutions have a local or national ethical committee relevant to the use of animals in research. The Animal Welfare Act in the United States mandates the establishment of institutional animal care and use committees, tasked with humanely supervising the care and treatment of experimental animals at facilities partially or fully funded by the government. The directive on the protection of animals used for scientific purposes also mandates the establishment of Animal Welfare Bodies in each Member State. The responsibilities of these bodies include advising competent authorities and animal caretakers on permit conditions, offering guidance on alternative methods, and aiding in the investigation of non-compliance allegations. The last may be an important function — at the very least it provides independent scrutiny.</p><p>The scientific and technical viability of practical paradigms is also important for different stakeholders, such as scientists, journal referees, and readers. The process of ethical review is clearly very different from that of scientific review. For instance, the use of animals that aren’t necessary to answer the scientific questions or in numbers that aren’t necessary to reach the research goals is easily discernible. However, subjectively agreeing on what work is ethically acceptable is significantly more challenging. Nonetheless, we rarely discuss the interplay between scientific and ethical review, and it’s important to acknowledge that, particularly in the hands of poorly trained researchers, antipathy or outright opposition to a methodology can exert a potentially powerful influence during the ethical review process.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XARobAq35sXpWGsQforiuQ.png" /></figure><h3>3. ARRIVE Guidelines</h3><h4><a href="https://www.equator-network.org/?post_type=eq_guidelines&amp;eq_guidelines_study_design=animal-pre-clinical-research&amp;eq_guidelines_clinical_specialty=0&amp;eq_guidelines_report_section=0&amp;s=+">ARRIVE Guidelines</a></h4><p>The guidelines have been published and describe a set of 20 principles and their associated recommendations that we advise to consider for inclusion in the Methods, Results, and Discussion sections of a biomedical research article. The goal of the guidelines is to improve the reporting of research involving animal models and, ultimately, the reproducibility of the data published. The guidelines therefore cover three deep and interrelated topics: the experimental design and statistical analysis used in the research; the management, housing, and husbandry of the animals; and the care and management of the animals involved.</p><p>The guidelines consist of <strong>five separate checklists</strong>, each concerned with a different experimental setting: in vivo trials; animal studies of neuropathic pain; animal seizure models; animal stroke models; and animal models of cervical spinal cord injury. This document provides further details on the underpinning evidence and insights guiding these recommendations, as well as an explanation of the financial and practical provisions that help to address the inherent challenges associated with fulfilling this checklist. Ethical, methodological, and reporting considerations are also discussed at length in relation to non-animal research, including in vitro work using human tissue samples.</p><p>Good science prioritizes the importance of data integrity, and reporting proper methodology and reproducibility are critical in achieving this. Thus, these guidelines can improve experiment conclusions and publication quality. The duty of researchers in conducting animal studies is not only to contribute to the generation of knowledge but also to promote ethical practice in the reporting of research findings. As such, they have an ethical obligation to ensure their work is reliable and trustworthy. Therefore, the use and specific reporting of the guidelines are integral to the credibility of animal research.</p><h3>3.1. Purpose and Scope</h3><p>Ensuring that the data from animal studies are reported accurately and in sufficient detail to support their interpretation is essential for both the efficiency of research and the replacement, refinement, and reduction of animals used for testing around the world. Over the years, the ARRIVE guidelines have focused on improving the reporting of intervention studies in whole animals and are designed to inform researchers of the level of detail required in manuscripts that are submitted to scientific journals. Like its predecessor, ARRIVE 2.0 primarily targets all stakeholders involved in the design, conduct, presentation, and review of these studies’ findings, including academics and industry professionals, funders, and publishers.</p><p>While <strong>ARRIVE 2.0</strong> is consistent in sections with the original guidelines, refinements have been made to clarify how the guidance on refining reporting practice relates to the more fundamental non-reporting recommendations and where it does not. It is founded on a similar philosophy, which aims to improve the translation, reproducibility, and usability of studies conducted in animals. In many technical areas, there are holes that need to be filled by reporting new information to help future research and its review. This is the case whether the research was paid for to help future non-animal research, further investigations in animals, or for some other reason. To determine if the research could fill their gaps, potential end-user researchers must see what was and was not reported. No judgments should be based on what some thought was unnecessary to report. It is essential to see it for themselves.</p><p>Looking for improvements in how knowledge is built and processed, we also run the risk of misunderstanding the scope of an article. It is important to note that it is of secondary importance if we want to avoid, minimize, or replace animals, and that open science is a win-win principle. Finally, ARIVE 2.0 is not intended as an ethical justification or condemnation of animal studies or of particular uses of animals. For new social norms to support the change from animal studies’ results to knowledge about people and other species, it seems like a simple statement is all that is needed.</p><h3>3.2. Key Components</h3><p>The key components of the guidelines cover study design and experimental procedures in the exploration of physiological and behavioral mechanisms of vertebrate animals. Decisions about the design of any study experiment should not be based on convenience but on ethical and methodological considerations. Ethically, studies should involve signals that animals are capable of responding to and should use a sample size determined by a relevant power calculation. Biologically, studies should be well replicated within and between animals so that the effects of technical and biological variation can be clearly separated. Samples should be randomized at each stage of the experiment to minimize bias. This detail should be of high concern for investigators, as it will affect animals and people alike. There are considerations for conducting statistical analysis and clearly reporting outcomes.</p><p>By specifying intended analysis at the start in protocols, it is made clear what the data will be tested for and will serve as a clear handle for the significance of our biological questions. Transparent reporting of the study allows the scientific report to be reproduced, including by other scientists who wish to replicate the study. This ties back to lines one and two of these guidelines: “The recommendations in the guidelines are designed to improve the reporting of research involving animals and contribute to more transparent and accurate communication, which promotes reproducibility,” “Transparent reporting is also a principle of the Foundation for Biomedical Research and the National Institute of Mental Health,” and, finally, “The National Institutes of Health encourages authors to adhere to these guidelines to more accurately report and more efficiently disseminate research results.” The present section is thus concerned with the ethics and design of a study involving vertebrate animals.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8blAKeRZq2KEQ7T3aoYbow.png" /></figure><h3>4. Transparency and Reproducibility in Animal Research</h3><p>Transparency is an essential pillar of the scientific method. It means providing information about the experimental methods and results necessary to judge the reliability and credibility of findings.</p><p>The related concept of reproducibility is also fundamental: if an effect can only be observed in one laboratory, under a subset of experimental conditions, and/or using less commonly used or described research materials or methods, then the effect is less scientifically valid and has gained less confidence. Just as reproducibility depends on transparency, transparency supports reproducibility. For these and other reasons, guidelines exist to address issues that may undermine both transparency and reproducibility, such as selective reporting, inappropriate analyses, underpowered studies, lack of sample size estimation, and conflicts of interest, to ensure a comprehensive and transparent description of a study design and results — in essence, to help advance both the ethical and methodological standards for using animals in research.</p><p>One of the main factors leading to a lack of reproducibility is a failure to conduct an experiment according to methods recommended by specialists, with selective reporting of data encouraging the manipulation of results. Inconsistent and selective reporting inevitably hampers information exchange between research groups. To counter this, members of the not-for-profit scientific and publishing community are developing systematic ways to enhance the transparency of data collection and reporting and, ultimately, the reproducibility of results. The move appears to identify areas where introduction and reporting issues hinder scientific methods and conclusions and promote frameworks in order to fundamentally shape the conduct, reporting, and reuse of animal-based scientific work. The goals of transparency are not limited to those who benefit from the research but are also of interest to other scientists.</p><p>Access to research data will enable further collaboration and will make scientific progress cumulative. Regrettably, openness often poses many questions, particularly in the case of animal-based experimentation. The overlapping concepts of replicability and fidelity are important because the strategy transmits the outcomes of animal research, which rests on two-way accountability, conducts risk studies, and helps producers manage the performance of genetic equipment.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aDeNTh07N69CvKHd8u4-yQ.png" /></figure><h3>5. Conclusion and Future Directions</h3><p>Given the ongoing developments and increased attention in animal models of brain function and behavior, ethical considerations are of utmost importance for the neuroimaging community. Setting up international multimedia databases, for example, requires standardization and following ethical rules to make sure that studies from different countries and settings can be analyzed together in a high-quality way. This also means that researchers all over the world need to fully consider society’s ethical rules. This is the only way they can break new ground internationally while still caring for animals and adapting to new ethical situations that will come up in the future.</p><p>Furthermore, scientists must consistently monitor the evolution of legislation in this field, enabling the updating of these general guidelines on ethical methods and considerations. As set out in this review, research based on animal models presents numerous important ethical concerns that are addressed using solid guidelines developed by the scientific community. The proposed guidelines are aimed at achieving both potential clinical benefits and a mutual relationship with the general public.</p><p>Following all the rules could make the research process more useful, since a close connection between the researcher and the animal model, based on checking on the animal’s mental health every day, might work better than therapies that only focus on the animal’s physical health. We suggest that the results obtained from a deeper examination of the single methodological issues and their translation into ethics and sciences could be useful not only to improve the validity of animal models but also to provide new tools to show ordinary citizens the benefits of basic and applied research with the use of animals.</p><p>Therefore, together with suggested areas of clinical research based on animal models, we propose an expansion of the studies based on ethical principles that are strictly linked with specific methodological and technical steps. Interdisciplinary collaborations among scientists pursuing the same goals could also contribute to a more transparent presentation of scientific data to ordinary citizens.</p><p>Finally, future research efforts could focus on designing studies that can simultaneously assess the application of experimental evidence and a progressive decline in animal suffering. This issue could also be beneficial for continuing updates to the present guidelines as a further research field aimed at improving animal-related research.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d6c72e5abc93" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[1. NFTs in Decentralized Science]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MetforminSol/1-nfts-in-decentralized-science-bb39ab37f2cc?source=rss-09ea9d9db1d3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bb39ab37f2cc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[intellectual-property]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nft]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[desci]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[MetforminSol]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Dec 2024 09:29:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-02T09:29:43.577Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*swfDiqVODo6Cyco2Ce4T1A.png" /></figure><p>Web-based blockchain technologies have emerged in the last decade, recording data such as property, game points, and digital information ownership globally. These records are unforgeable and produced by no central, all-knowing party. Remotely readable governmentally accepted identity documents or land deeds are clear examples. Could we similarly re-create science as a data tracking system? Today’s highly productive scientific research effort relies on traditional practices of research on a global scale. Integrating web-based chains of data with those of scientific information opens many possibilities for improved sharing of scientific research on top of just the distribution chain of data from an individual lab via the web that already exists. These protocols can be decentralized to ensure the collaborative nature of the blockchain is not dominated by a single actor, government, or scientific journal. Reuse of data or work could be instant.</p><p>How can we improve the sharing of scientific inquiry results in the era of widespread democratization of knowledge? Non-fungible tokens have the potential to make this exchange easier, more transparent, and more fruitful by containing unique data related to the work, the institution, and the researchers. (1)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WmHg4FZwN8wznzjYv0VLpA.png" /></figure><h3>2. Understanding the Basics of NFTs</h3><p>A Non-Fungible Token (NFT) is a special type of digital asset that represents something unique, such as art, music, or collectibles. The term &#39;<strong>fungible</strong>&#39; signifies the ability to be replaced. Since bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are fungible, one can exchange one for another without changing its value. However, bitcoin trading for other assets is non-fungible. The NFT is also a prominent token standard in blockchain for its indelible simplicity. (2)</p><p>NFTs are distinguished by the fact that they cannot be replaced by other assets, and their validation of authenticity is through provable ownership or provenance. Additionally, they are indivisible, verifiable, and indisputably owned by a single party. Most NFTs are primarily supported by the Ethereum blockchain through its digital identifiers. The blockchain perceives each NFT as unique and distinctly different. Thanks to the smart contract that is built into the dedicated blockchain, NFT can keep track of an object&#39;s provenance, or the history of where it came from or how it was used. (3)</p><p>The transaction in NFT is done using money but through blockchain, which is economical, convenient, secure, and transparent. It is a platform where any business or individual can create their own NFT art pieces and sell them. Minting and listing their own NFTs on various marketplaces is also possible. Assets like content, copyrights, patents, and more could be high-value transaction services when tokenized by NFT. The mechanism behind NFTs is blockchain. Blockchain decentralizes NFTs, eliminating the need for a central authority to manage assets. It is a distributed ledger technology that is based on an edited version on all nodes. Ownership of NFTs stored on blockchain definitively proves that an NFT belongs to them. Blockchain technology tracks the provenance of any digital asset, which is needed in the very arena that science functions. Blockchain works only because of the smart contract. The smart contract handles minting, ownership proof, sale, and all the processing for the NFT. (4)</p><h3>2.1. Definition and Characteristics of NFTs</h3><p>Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs) have emerged as a new form of blockchain-based digital asset that represents ownership or acts as a form of certificate of authenticity for unique tokens. While much attention has been given to their application within art and other areas of creative industries, the concept of NFTs is a generalization of provenance information that can be associated with a range of assets, from scientific data to official certifications. This section serves as a definition of NFTs and a discussion of the range of characteristics that come with them. (5)</p><p>There is no singular universal definition of what an NFT should be; however, many key platforms that NFTs regularly operate on have established voluntary standards for writing the programming code that powers these tokens. NFTs can be defined by the distinctive characteristics that represent them, including: (1) Indivisibility; (2) Interoperability; and (3) Rarity. Aside from the characteristics that NFTs are marked by, there are several other features that underpin the nature of NFTs. Rather than using the term coin or token, NFTs are simply referred to as being unique “tokens” — a digital asset that is itself intrinsic to blockchains. Furthermore, NFTs can be described as non-deployable, where they cannot be directly created or destroyed on their own. It is rare for creators to make it possible for token holders to destroy the token so that it could be swapped in a 1:1 representation for the attached asset or funds, although such a feature would likely give rise to undesirable tax consequences for the token holder since this would constitute a disposal of that asset. (16)</p><h3>2.2. How NFTs Work in Blockchain Technology</h3><p>Blockchain has been originally designed as a very transparent, decentralized ledger to record NFT transaction data in a tamper-proof manner. An NFT is ‘minted’ on a blockchain by producing a new block that contains an event, most commonly the action of creating a new token. Minting a new NFT usually requires a cost and burns an equivalent value of cryptocurrency coins. While not mandatory, NFT minting often involves a smart contract, a piece of code that automatically runs to execute the rules upon which the NFT will be created. These rules often specify its token standard, properties, and the oversight of subsequent transactions, which ensures that future NFT sales will earn royalties for the creator of the token. Once minted, the NFT can be sold or transferred by sending commands to interact with the blockchain. Different blockchain-based networks can support minting and the sale of NFTs.</p><p>At an initial glance, the interest and possibilities that arise from the use of these blockchain-based networks and the technological advancement behind these systems might be quite encouraging. One is quickly confronted by several concerns underlying the technology and systems. One problem is energy consumption, for example, in the case of using a token standard-based network, especially because of the mechanism underpinning the system that adopts a Proof of Work to maintain blockchain consensus. Another main complex of challenges relates to scalability, mostly linked to a limitation of the NFT minting speed and possibly the speed of the interaction with dApps. (7,8)</p><h3>3. Applications of NFTs in Science</h3><p>NFTs have a remarkably broad range of potential applications in the ecosystem of scientific research. Just as NFTs can be used to represent and trade digital artworks, they can also represent and facilitate the exchange of a variety of research assets. This includes the ownership of unique intellectual property or data sets, where the NFT can provide the owner with conditional access rights or a share in the benefits from the commercialization of any asset represented by the NFT. In this sense, the NFT functions as a “smart license.” What is also interesting is that these NFTs can be legally created and registered through a blockchain. This starts to bring some powerful properties into the NFT, as until now, NFTs could not inherently carry any legal rights.</p><p>Indeed, a strong argument can be made that intellectual property and benefit-sharing are among the most valuable use cases for NFTs within the confines of existing legal systems. A limited entrance has been documented. It can be expected that these will take over as the most successful application of NFTs in scientific research. At the same time, it is argued that this new model of authorship might change the whole culture of how science is practiced, as it allows for a granular, contribution-based recognition. This practice and this reading of contributions would map epistemic input and foster collaboration within and across disciplines. The potential advantages of conducting research in a more integrated manner and in collaboration are well established, as they provide potential benefits, including more relevant research designs, more effective translation, and the capacity to conduct formal research synthesis. (9)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KbK1PFr2rQsQxleqY1G9yw.png" /></figure><h3>3.1. Representation and Trading of Research Assets</h3><p>Blockchain-based avenues for the trading of tokens have provided a route for a wide variety of assets to be transformed into unique cryptoassets. For the research community, the ability to create NFTs that are associated with a publication or a research object opens the door for the representation and trading of publication rights, research data, and scientific material that, previously, have not been recognized as an asset class. It may be feasible to represent not only the assets themselves as NFTs but also various intellectual property rights as controllable smart contracts associated with research objects. Blockchain NFT trading platforms combined with smart contracts represent a means for decentralized and transparent NFT trading, albeit at a transactional cost. Although a market for these types of NFTs does not currently exist, the potential benefits include access to global investment and funding sources, fractional ownership among a collective of stakeholders, and future trading of these NFTs. (10)</p><p>Through NFT creation, trading, and exchange, research objects have a potential direct-to-market in this new NFT asset class. Thus, at the point of publication acceptance, a paper could be tokenized, and all authors allocated the required ownership. One of the benefits could be improved paper quality, integrity, and transparency as a means for researchers to back their scientific publication, thus adding to the factual nature of the research and providing a new bar for peer-review-based scrutiny.</p><p>The representation of ownership of data assets through NFTs in this way could also give the community an additional means of recognizing the conduct and outcomes of significant publications by tracking NFT trading markets. Token and platform structures that allow for and integrate fractional ownership would enable the subject of interest to be owned by various stakeholders who place a stake in a particular output while cashing out through the token attempt. This may well affect how assets in fundamental research are valued and monetized in the long term. There are at least two NFT platforms that facilitate the trading of scientific research outputs. Publications from specific journals can be directly tokenized by the publisher, or the author can create a contract. (11)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*F3UDE8lSHSiX6kceJNe2CQ.png" /></figure><h3>3.2. Usage of NFTs for Datasets and Intellectual Property</h3><p>Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs) are associated with a unique digital item, such as an artwork or a GIF, and are increasingly being adopted in the art world. However, their novelty also renders them an attractive offering for the creation and administration of datasets. By placing an NFT on a dataset, the holder of the NFT has a legitimate, publicly verifiable claim to any dataset that is minted as an NFT. This would allow the marketplace for datasets to be decentralized, as asset ownership can be directly managed, and offer a solution to the issue of optimal equivalence between truly similar data. It therefore also has the potential to add value to data by providing credible evidence as to a dataset’s origins, chain of custody, and manipulation history. Given the speed with which suits of intellectual property are able to ebb and flow in academia, this has potentially huge and quick returns when it comes to fostering trust within the walls of the scientific community. (12)</p><p>Just as securely embodied assets convey trust, commitment, and transparency of dealings in asset trading, the ability to own and trade derivative intellectual property, encapsulated using NFTs, could unlock the bottleneck of access to proprietary datasets. To the immediate gain of individual researchers and their collaborators and sponsors, it might similarly leverage a previously hidden economic incentive for scientists to begin to share explicit, transaction-based insights, as well as connecting databases of differing types to drive greater synergies from richly linked data collection evaluation.</p><p>This approach to embodying a federated model of data holding, with distributed data trading platforms built atop them to enable wider regime-linked agents and entrepreneurs’ access to more heterogeneous data, would have to be set with strict ethical positions on the types of businesses to be supported. In the short term, we must ensure that the quiet digital revolution does not unintentionally separate personal information from its individual owners; we must handle sensitive citizen data with NFTs with care. Some will fear selling the rights to use their data, and they are right to do so, but the objective must be to level the current playing field and encourage the sharing of data and data resources equitably. This, in true logic, will promote that most iniquitous of pursuits: competition. (13)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FbYlF4bxLXa7mXOnNnewPA.png" /></figure><h3>4. Challenges and Opportunities in Implementing NFTs in Science</h3><p>Currently, there are many debates on the possibility of using NFTs in the world of science. However, some potential applications have already been proposed, despite the identification of several obstacles that hamper the correct operation of these technologies. This last point is highly relevant given the large number of proposals and NFTs currently operating. Given that debates on NFTs are relatively recent, it is not surprising to note that some aspects that are either praised or criticized have barely been studied in depth. NFTs currently raise an intuitively balanced amount of enthusiasm and concern. There is a prominent shift in ownership structures away from publicly shared resources and goods. Blockchain marketplaces are disruptive, and their hands-off design to support peer-to-peer transactions mitigates this practicality in many respects. (14,15)</p><p>Technological and Regulatory Uncertainty: The current state of blockchain technology provides more than enough evidence that transactions can eventually be traced back to a legitimate source, but these are early days. Fixing the blockchain architecture is like writing the first amendment to a blank slate constitution. If the designs of blockchain systems end up being the main contention point of ownership in NFTs, we do not even know what the problem really is. These are only the tip of the iceberg, though, as financial matters are far more complicated and their cost is almost prohibitively high.</p><p>There can be very serious legal issues regarding what could be owned and what is currently owned if a blockchain infrastructure were to be installed, likewise for the ICO and the NFT. Blockchain is hardly known for its regulation, and things will be quite different when so many stakeholders are involved, as in science. The price levels are determined by trust, liquidity, and risks. In light of those criticisms, it can be seen that the blockchain and the NFT have potential value, especially considering the defense of property rights they can afford. However, it is important that the limitations are also taken into account. (1)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*q1q2qfmwzt575dsbQfvidw.png" /></figure><h3>5. Future Trends and Implications of NFTs in Decentralized Science</h3><p>The ease of use and the number of integrated features of NFTs decided our positive analysis in the previous section. The framing of NFTs beyond the creation, curation, and diffusion of new knowledge is a strategic trend that aims to transform NFTs into the nodes of the research ecosystem, the collaborative economy, and the social marketplace of the future. Research, policies, and industry development may take different directions due to the opportunities and pitfalls mentioned in this section. (16)</p><p>We forecast that knowledge, regulation, and the market will evolve toward these scenarios. It is important to stress that the final form of these scenarios, as far as NFTs in decentralized science are concerned, is not given. Scenarios update both qualifications and methods. This twofold structure helps to improve relevant multidisciplinary concerns and skills and to transform possible difficult futures into positive and responsible ones. Future knowledge will stress that what is unfolding in real life, in data, and in NS will always exceed scenarios. It presumes a continuous adaptation. The NFT case has shown fruitful debates at the intersection of NFT ID researching, creating, curation knowledge, what wallet, and the third party minting seen so far; but as it expands beyond these early adopters, to what extent might it deliver on mandates for open, democratizing research practices, equity, and visibility?</p><p>What might limit its capacity to effect respect and empowerment for researchers, both with monographs and in under-resourced academic justice spaces? With market speculation ramping up, what would be the ethical sign-off of minting and selling dictionary entries as NFTs? With 90% of authors experiencing limits to accessing the academic literature, could access or research-based funds act as good boundaries, precluding mass speculation around knowledge commons? What might it encourage in others? Might speculative interests in knowledge commons confront monographists with funding opportunities to realize financial security that may have been outside of their current abilities to seek grant funding for the research itself? (17)</p><p><strong>References:</strong></p><p>1. Bamakan SMH, Nezhadsistani N, Bodaghi O, Qu Q. Patents and intellectual property assets as non-fungible tokens; key technologies and challenges. Scientific Reports. 2022. <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-05920-6.pdf">nature.com</a></p><p>2. Wang Q, Li R, Wang Q, Chen S. Non-fungible token (NFT): Overview, evaluation, opportunities, and challenges. arXiv preprint arXiv:2105.07447. 2021. <a href="https://arxiv.org/pdf/2105.07447.pdf?fbclid=IwAR3S_U6re48bl01_AmT0IEFBqoquBDSOwrmnU_jS_n">[PDF]</a></p><p>3. Sestino A, Guido G, Peluso AM. Non-fungible tokens (NFTs). Examining the impact on consumers and marketing strategies. 2022. <a href="https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/978-3-031-07203-1.pdf">[HTML]</a></p><p>4. Madine M, Salah K, Jayaraman R, Battah A, Hasan H, Yaqoob I. Blockchain and NFTs for time-bound access and monetization of private data. IEEE Access. 2022 Sep 5;10:94186–202. <a href="https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/iel7/6287639/9668973/09877874.pdf">ieee.org</a></p><p>5. Bellagarda J, Abu-Mahfouz AM. Connect2NFT: A web-based, blockchain-enabled NFT application with the aim of reducing fraud and ensuring authenticated social, non-human-verified digital... Mathematics. 2022. <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2227-7390/10/21/3934/pdf">mdpi.com</a></p><p>6. Bamakan SMH, Nezhadsistani N, Bodaghi O, Qu Q. A decentralized framework for patents and intellectual property as NFT in blockchain networks. 2021. <a href="https://www.researchsquare.com/article/rs-951089/latest.pdf">researchsquare.com</a></p><p>7. Ko K, Jeong T, Woo J, Hong JW. Survey on blockchain-based non‐fungible tokens: history, technologies, standards, and open challenges. International Journal of Network Management. 2024 Jan;34(1):e2245. <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Taeyeol-Jeong/publication/372495358_Survey_on_blockchain-based_non-fungible_tokens_History_technologies_standards_and_open_challenges/links/65c256151bed776ae3357763/Survey-on-blockchain-based-non-fungible-tokens-History-technologies-standards-and-open-challenges.pdf">researchgate.net</a></p><p>8. Fortnow M, Terry QH. The NFT handbook: how to create, sell, and buy non-fungible tokens. 2021. <a href="https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&amp;lr=&amp;id=zDVCEAAAQBAJ&amp;oi=fnd&amp;pg=PT6&amp;dq=NFT+minting+usually+requires+a+cost+and+burns+an+equivalent+value+of+cryptocurrency.&amp;ots=TScBGlCDMR&amp;sig=uzwH3pCTW82odMn0IGOnY1bkIVo">[HTML]</a></p><p>9. Behl A, Pereira V, Nigam A, Wamba S, Sindhwani R. Knowledge development in non-fungible tokens (NFT): a scoping review. Journal of Knowledge Management. 2024 Jan 5;28(1):232–67. <a href="https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/JKM-12-2022-0937/full/html">[HTML]</a></p><p>10. Battah A, Madine M, Yaqoob I, Salah K, Hasan HR, Jayaraman R. Blockchain and NFTs for trusted ownership, trading, and access of AI models. IEEE Access. 2022 Oct 19;10:112230–49. <a href="https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/iel7/6287639/6514899/09924181.pdf">ieee.org</a></p><p>11. Muller C, Richards P, Brazendale R, Rei K. Novel financing solutions for land use change. 2024. <a href="https://agresearch.figshare.com/articles/report/Novel_financing_solutions_for_land_use_change/26001616/1/files/46944661.pdf">figshare.com</a></p><p>12. Bhujel S, Rahulamathavan Y. A survey: security, transparency, and scalability issues of NFT’s and its marketplaces. Sensors. 2022. <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8220/22/22/8833/pdf">mdpi.com</a></p><p>13. Bonnet S, Teuteberg F. Impact of blockchain and distributed ledger technology for the management of the intellectual property life cycle: A multiple case study analysis. Computers in Industry, 2023. <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0166361522001853">[HTML]</a></p><p>14. Schaller B. Can sharing a ride make for less traffic? Evidence from Uber and Lyft and implications for cities. Transport policy. 2021. <a href="http://www.schallerconsult.com/rideservices/sharingride.pdf">schallerconsult.com</a></p><p>15. Sahasranamam S, Arya B, Sud M. Ownership structure and corporate social responsibility in an emerging market. Asia Pacific Journal of Management. 2020. <a href="https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s10490-019-09649-1.pdf">springer.com</a></p><p>16. Wilson KB, Karg A, Ghaderi H. Prospecting non-fungible tokens in the digital economy: Stakeholders and ecosystem, risk and opportunity. Business Horizons. 2022. <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0007681321002019">[HTML]</a></p><p>17. Mancuso I, Petruzzelli AM, Panniello U. Digital business model innovation in the metaverse: How to approach virtual economy opportunities. Information Processing &amp; Management. 2023 Sep 1;60(5):103457. <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0306457323001942">sciencedirect.com</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bb39ab37f2cc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>