<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Moshe D. on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Moshe D. on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@MosheD?source=rss-af4a87e02b1b------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 16:36:45 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@MosheD/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In response to Hadeer Hadi’s “The Word in John’s Gospel That No One Could Translate.”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MosheD/in-response-to-hadeer-hadis-the-word-in-john-s-gospel-that-no-one-could-translate-d6b6535f9adb?source=rss-af4a87e02b1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d6b6535f9adb</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Moshe D.]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 01:26:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-18T00:54:09.370Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In response to Hadeer Hadi’s “T<a href="https://medium.com/onegodpath-com/the-word-in-johns-gospel-that-no-one-could-translate-28ddf1aa8d98">he Word in John’s Gospel That No One Could Translate</a>.”</p><p>This may be one of the shortest articles I have ever written. NOT!</p><p>Islamic apologists continue to recycle these exact claims. They continue to raise dead arguments, ignoring the thorough refutations that ministries have documented, dismantled and destroyed for decades. So, while there is no need to beat a dead horse, as they say, whats the harm in a few kicks?</p><p>Previous horse kickers include ministries like:</p><p><strong>Alpha and Omega Ministries</strong> (<a href="https://www.aomin.org/aoblog/">Dr. James White</a>)</p><p><strong>CARM — Christian Apologetics &amp; Research Ministry</strong> (<a href="https://carm.org/does-john-1416-predict-the-coming-of-muhammad">Matt Slick</a>)</p><p><strong>Answering Islam</strong> (Sam Shamoun &amp; Jochen Katz)</p><p><strong>Acts 17 Apologetics</strong> (Dr. David Wood)</p><p><strong>CIRA International</strong> (Dr. Jay Smith)</p><p><strong>Pfander Centre for Apologetics</strong> (named after Karl Gottlieb Pfander, who refuted this exact argument in his famous 1854 Agra debate)</p><p><strong>Got Questions Ministries</strong></p><p><strong>Ravi Zacharias International Ministries / RZIM</strong> (specifically the late Dr. Nabeel Qureshi)</p><p><strong>Cross Examined</strong> (Dr. Frank Turek)</p><p>Personally, I only recommend two of these sources and i added the links. So please use caution if you decide to study this further. They are not ministries I personally use, but provided to show the issue has been publicly addressed.</p><p>Am I the only reader with a Bible background to notice what she implied with her title, <em>“</em><strong><em>The Word in John’s Gospel That No One Could Translate”</em></strong>?</p><p>A word no one could translate? Do any other Christians agree that this is misleading? I saw no comments challenging her. Something simple like “Hadeer, you are very sweet, but you are Very wrong!”</p><p>As if Christians and Bible scholars are a bunch of knuckleheads and we sure could use a little help from non Biblical personalities.</p><p>She then says: <strong><em>“For nearly a thousand years, translators of John’s Gospel have reached for one Greek word and walked away with different English ones.”</em></strong></p><p>Wait,,, isn’t that literally why it is called an <strong>English translation</strong>? HELLO?</p><p>Galatians 4 says “But when the appropriate time had come, God sent his Son, born by a woman, born under the Law, in order to redeem those who were under the Law, and thus to adopt them as his children.</p><p>The arrival was right on schedule. When the fullness of the time came, God sent His Son to earth. The Greek language is a rich, multi-layered language. A single Greek word like <em>paraklētos</em> carries overlapping shades of meaning, legal advocate, personal counselor, comforter, and helper, so why can’t translators choose the English word that best fits the context?</p><p>What many refuse to understand, not just Muslims but so called Evangelicals, that the language of the Bible is centered around courtroom language. Not courtroom jargon, but forensic teminology.</p><p>Deuteronomy 25:1, “If there is a dispute between men and they go to court for judgment, and the judges judge their case, and they<strong> justify the righteous</strong> and <strong>condemn the wicked</strong>,”</p><p>Paraklētos shares that exact same first-century courtroom and legal background, just like justification (dikaiōsis), righteousness (dikaiosynē), adoption (huiothesia) and many others.</p><p>In everyday Koine Greek, a paraklētos, literally <em>“one called alongside”</em>, was a legal term for a defense advocate, legal representative, or character witness summoned to stand beside someone in a court of law to plead their case and defend them against an accuser.</p><p>John uses paraklētos, i.e Advocate, in a direct courtroom scene where believers have sinned and need legal defense before the Judge of the universe.</p><p>John 2:1. “My little children, I’m writing these things to you so that you might not sin. Yet if anyone does sin, we have an advocate (paraklētos) with the Father, Jesus, the Messiah, one who is righteous.</p><p>What about John 16:8–11? “When he comes, he will convict the world of sin, righteousness, and judgment; of sin, because they do not believe in me; of righteousness, because I am going to the Father and you will no longer see me; and of judgment, because the ruler of this world has been judged.”</p><p>When Jesus describes the Holy Spirit’s work as the Paraklētos in the above passage, He uses explicit courtroom language. He says the Spirit will <strong>“convict”</strong> (elenchō) the world concerning sin, righteousness, and judgment.</p><p>Elenchō is a legal term meaning to cross-examine, expose, and prove guilt. Jesus uses the same word in John 8:46, when He says “Which one of you convicts (elenchō) Me of sin? If I speak truth, why do you not believe Me”?</p><p>By Hadeer framing normal translation work as an unsolved mystery, she is trying to plant doubt in the reader’s mind so she can smuggle Muhammad into a supposed gap that doesn’t exist.</p><p>She is insinuating that Christian translators were either stumped or hiding something. In reality, translators used words like Helper, Comforter, and Advocate because paraklētos is a rich word with multiple shades of meaning.</p><p>There is zero mystery about who it refers to, because Jesus Himself defines it in the exact same sentence as “the Holy Spirit” in John 14:26.</p><p>Second issue that needs to be addressed is the allegation of confused translators. She said</p><h4><em>“The word is paraklētos. It appears only in the writings ascribed to John: four times across the long, intimate conversation Jesus has with his closest followers on the night before his arrest, and once in his first letter. Five uses in the entire New Testament, and no two translators can agree on what it says.”</em></h4><p>Did you catch that? “no two translators can agree on what it says.” That statement is is factually false and a classic exaggeration.</p><p>Every major English Bible translation agrees 100% on <strong>what</strong> the Greek word paraklētos means and <strong>who</strong> it refers to. They simply use different English synonyms to express the exact same concept.</p><p>If one translator writes “Helper,” another writes “Comforter,” and another writes “Advocate,” they are not disagreeing on what the text says. I just covered this. They are using overlapping English synonyms to describe the exact same supportive role.</p><p>Saying “no two translators can agree on what it says” is like claiming two people are in a bitter argument because one called a vehicle an “automobile” and the other called it a “car.</p><p>And honestly, doesn’t this smell of hypocrisy? Did anyone else think this through? She points one finger at Christian translators for using different English synonyms like Helper, Comforter, and Advocate, while three fingers point straight back at the dozens of English translations of the Qur’an.</p><p>I own several <strong>English translations</strong> of the Quran. One will find translators constantly choosing different English words to capture Arabic terms. I have no problem as long as they are synonymous.</p><p>In his book <a href="https://www.logos.com/product/43388/what-every-christian-needs-to-know-about-the-quran"><strong><em>What Every Christian Needs to Know About the Qur’an</em></strong></a>, Dr. James White devotes entire sections to how modern English translations of the Qur’an (like <em>Sahih International</em> and <em>The Clear Quran</em>) alter or soften classical Arabic terms such as <em>‘alaq</em> (Surah 96:2), <em>mākirīn</em> (Surah 3:54), and <em>idribūhunna</em> (Surah 4:34) to fit modern scientific or cultural sensibilities.</p><p>So what if I were to write an article that pointed out how several English translations of the Quran were problematic because “no two translators can agree on what it says.”?</p><p>Would Hadeer accept a criticism if I claimed those verses in the variant translations of the Quran were untranslatable just because English uses synonyms? Of course not.</p><p>Applying one standard to the Bible and the exact opposite standard to the Qur’an isn’t scholarship, it is a double standard. But as you will see later on, the question of scholarship has holes in it as I demonstrate other logical errors.</p><p>As I will show, the gist of her article is yet another Islamic demonstration of attempting to manipulate the Bible, in order to give Muhammad a place on the stage of Christian validity. A seat at the table, so to speak.</p><p>She does throw Christians a bone when she suggests that Christians have historically understood the “Comforter” or “Advocate” the paraklētos, to be the Holy Spirit. But I am not sure why if this is already proven by the text itself. Kind of hard not to since Jesus in John 14:26 explicitly names the “Him” as the Holy Spirit.</p><p>John 14:26 But <strong>the</strong> <strong>Helper</strong>, <strong>the Holy Spirit</strong>, whom the Father will send in my name, will teach you all things and remind you of everything that I have told you.”</p><p>Under normal circumstances, the grammar settles the issue immediately! But because Hadeer wants this Christian to work for it, I am going to take us through the Greek so we can understand WHY the Helper is the Holy Spirit, and NOT Muhammad.</p><p>False religions continue to get out the hammer or the axe and try to bust that Biblical door open, so they can replace it with their own religions door.</p><p>Or as I said in a previous article with Roman Catholicism, they want the thread of justification to be yanked out so they can thread in a sacramental thread to replace it with.</p><p>Like all false religions, they simply won’t let things go when the text shuts the door. Reason takes a back seat when it comes to logic and Biblical literature. And if it isn’t reason, it is wilful manipulation.</p><p>False religions want us to roll over and have our belly scratched as they ask us to set the explicit words aside. In this case, what they want us to do, is insert Muhammad’s name into the text and read the verse as if it says: <em>“But the Advocate, </em><strong><em>Muhammad</em></strong><em>, whom the Father will send in my name, he will teach you all things and bring to your remembrance all that I have said to you.”</em></p><p>That is absurd. The passage is self-defining, and because of the rules of Greek grammar, the passage leaves zero room for a 7th century substitute.</p><p>Besides other problematic statements, the fatal flaw in this entire argument appears right in the middle of the essay when Hadeer asks the reader to <strong>“<em>set the explicit naming aside for a moment.” </em></strong>(We will talk more about that comment in a bit.)</p><p>No! Jesus did not leave us a crossword puzzle to locate words and circle them, nor did He leave a cryptic riddle waiting 600 years for the Qur’an to solve. You cannot “<strong><em>set the explicit naming aside</em></strong><em> </em><strong><em>for a moment</em>”!</strong></p><p>Why? Because the text defines itself! It asks and answers the immediate issue in black and white.</p><p>Bible students, pay attention. Jesus names the <em>paraklētos</em> directly: <em>“But the Helper, </em><strong><em>the Holy Spirit</em></strong><em>, whom the Father will send in my name, he will teach you all things and bring to your remembrance all that I have said to you.”</em></p><p>The Helper = The Holy Spirit = He will teach you all things and bring to your remembrance all that I have said to YOU. I am going to keep repeating this so you walk away very comfortable in the argument.</p><p>The Helper is the Holy Spirit. The Helper is the Holy Spirit. The Helper is the Holy Spirit.</p><p>Listen up Muslims who are trying to change the Scripture! In Greek grammar, this is called apposition; specifically explicative or epexegetical apposition.</p><p>Apposition occurs when a writer places two noun phrases side-by-side in the exact same grammatical case so that the second phrase immediately defines, clarifies, or identifies the first.</p><p>Look at the opening words of John 14:26 in Greek:</p><p><strong><em>ὁ δὲ παράκλητος, τὸ πνεῦμα τὸ ἅγιον</em></strong><em><br>(</em>ho de paraklētos, to pneuma to hagion<em>)<br></em><strong><em>“But the Helper, the Holy Spirit…”</em></strong></p><blockquote>Side note — →((I love Bible Works!! For those who want to be able to study these things such as the syntactic trees? If you have BibleWorks, this is how to Check John 14:26:</blockquote><blockquote>Option 1: BibleWorks Greek New Testament Syntax Module (BWSYN): Open the syntax tree diagram for John 14:26. Inside the main Subject branch, <em>ho paraklētos</em> (“the Helper”) sits as the primary noun phrase, and <em>to pneuma to hagion</em> (“the Holy Spirit”) branches off directly beside it labeled Appositive (App).</blockquote><blockquote>Option 2: OpenText.org Syntactically Analyzed Greek New Testament: Open the clause visualization for John 14:26. Both <em>ho paraklētos</em> and <em>to pneuma to hagion</em> appear together inside the single Subject (S) box, where <em>to pneuma to hagion</em> is grouped as an appositional word group defining <em>ho paraklētos</em>.</blockquote><blockquote>Bible Works is no longer available to purchase for those interested, but try Logos, or Accordance.</blockquote><blockquote>You can also look for <a href="https://azahari.blog/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/greek-grammar-beyond-the-basics.pdf"><strong>Daniel B. Wallace’s Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics</strong> </a>where he explicitly tags “the Holy Spirit” as an appositive defining “the Helper.”</blockquote><blockquote><strong>III Nominatiae in Simple Apposition</strong><br>The nominative case (as well as the other cases) can be an appositive to<br>another substantive in the same case.<strong>40</strong> The usage is quite common. There are<br>four features of simple apposition to be noted (the first two are structural<br>clues; the last two features are semantic): An appositional construction inaolaes<br>(1) two adjacent substantiues (2) in the same case,N (3) which refer to the same person or thing, (4) and have the same syntactical relation to the rest of the clause.</blockquote><blockquote>The first substantive can belong to any category (e.g., subject, predicate<br>nom., etc.) and the second is merely a clarification, description, or identification of who or what is mentioned.<strong>41</strong> Thus, the appositive “piggy-backs” on<br>the first nominative’s use, as it were. For this reason simple apposition is not<br>an independent syntactical category.</blockquote><blockquote>The appositive functions very much like a PN in a convertible proposition that is, it refers to the same thing as the first noun.<strong>42</strong> The difference,<br>however, is that a PN makes arr assertion about the S (an equative verb is<br>either stated or implied); with appositives there is assumption, not assertion<br>(no verb is in mind). In the sentence “Paul is an apostle,” apostle is a PN; in<br>the sentence , “Paul the apostle is in prison,” apostle is in apposition to Paul. (<a href="https://azahari.blog/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/greek-grammar-beyond-the-basics.pdf">See pages 48–49</a>)</blockquote><blockquote>Footnotes: “39 Cf. also Rom 2:26;4:5,22 (like Rom 4:3, quoting Gen 15:5); 9:8; Gal3:5 (Gen 15:6); Jas2:23 (Gen 15:6),</blockquote><blockquote><strong>40</strong> The nom. occasionally is in apposition to an oblique case, but the semantics are the same. See discussion below.<br><strong>41</strong> An appositive, strictly speaking, is substantioal, not adjectival. Thus, adjectives or participles in second attributive position are not generally appositives, but usually have an adjectival force.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>42</strong> The significance of this will be seen in our discussion of the gen. case, for the gen. can a/so involve a syntactical category, viz.,the gen. of apposition. The semantics involved in such a category are quite different from those involved in simple apposition”</blockquote><p>He also lists classic New Testament examples such as 1 Peter 5:8 “your adversary the devil”; and Matthew 2:1 “Herod the king”.</p><p>Now keep in mind the rule for apposition does not require the word “the” (the definite article) before each noun. In Koine Greek, simple apposition only requires two nouns or noun phrases to sit side by side in the same grammatical case (such as both being nominative), with the second phrase directly identifying or explaining the first. The definite article (“the”) can appear before both nouns, before only one noun, or before neither noun.</p><p>For additional research, you can look for the book called <a href="https://www.obinfonet.ro/docs/gk/resgk/wallace-basic-nt-greek.pdf">The Basics Of New Testament Syntax</a>, also by Wallace.</p><p>And there is also for free, the <a href="https://www.stepbible.org/?q=version=ESV@reference=John.14&amp;options=VNHUG">Step Bible</a>. Maybe our Muslim friends will be inclined to do further study so they don’t continue these grammatical errors.)) End of commercial.</p><p>What is all the fuss? The Greek syntax itself establishes a strict 1-to-1 identity (Helper = Holy Spirit) before the sentence even finishes.</p><p>First Noun Phrase is <em>ho paraklētos</em> i.e. the Helper, nominative singular. Second Noun Phrase is (in Apposition): <em>to pneuma to hagion</em> i.e. the Holy Spirit, also nominative singular, placed directly next to it with no verb or conjunction separating them.</p><p>Why this grammatical matters? Anyone teaching the Bible should have a basic understanding of the Greek language.</p><p>Greek grammarians like Wallace note that when a writer uses epexegetical apposition, the second phrase narrows down and explicitly defines the broader term that came right before it. <strong>(</strong><a href="https://azahari.blog/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/greek-grammar-beyond-the-basics.pdf"><strong>Daniel B. Wallace: Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics</strong></a><strong>)</strong></p><p>When John wrote, ho paraklētos, he did not intend for the reader to open the interpretation to guesswork. By placing to pneuma to hagion, (in immediate apposition), the Greek grammar itself locks in a 1-to-1 mathematical equivalence (Helper = Holy Spirit) before the sentence even finishes.</p><p>Thus, a 1-to-1 identity means that two words or titles point to the exact same single person or thing, with nothing added and nothing left out. This is what I want the reader to understand as they look at the Greek grammar. And this is why such redundancy. So you can spot this the next time an article makes such a claim.</p><p>John 14:26, Jesus puts two specific titles side-by-side: “The Helper” and “The Holy Spirit”.</p><p>Because both titles use the specific word “the” and sit right next to each other in the exact same grammatical form, Greek grammar treats them like an equals sign, i.e. The Helper = The Holy Spirit.</p><p>Are you listening Hadeer? There is no room left over for a second person, a future prophet, or anyone else.</p><p>Before Jesus even finishes telling the disciples what the Helper will <em>do</em> (“he will teach you all things”), the grammar has already locked in <strong>WHO </strong>the He is! He Is Spirit.</p><p>Jesus also tells the eleven disciples sitting in the room with Him that <strong>the Helper = the Holy Spirit</strong>: <em>“He will teach </em><strong><em>YOU</em></strong><em> all things and bring to </em><strong><em>YOUR</em></strong><em> remembrance all that I have said to </em><strong><em>YOU</em></strong><em>.”</em></p><p>Forcing Muhammad into John 14:26 requires breaking Greek nominative apposition, erasing the definite articles that lock both titles together, and forcing two different beings into a singular verb, <em>didaxei</em> (“he will teach”).</p><p>Who will teach? <strong>The Spirit will teach.</strong> Why is this important? Because it makes the claim a <strong>non-starter</strong> for a physical man. Muhammad was a physical human being with a body, while the Greek word <em>pneuma</em> (“Spirit”) means an invisible, non-physical spirit, it cannot mean a human man.</p><p>When someone tries to claim John 14:26 is talking about Muhammad, they are twisting Greek grammar to force a word that means “Holy Spirit” (<em>pneuma</em>) to refer to a human prophet.</p><p>And that is what this article is trying to do through a clever back door. As I often call it: “the art of eloquent oratory in written form.” The article is attempting to turn an incorporeal pneuma or Spirit, into Muhammad, or a flesh-and-blood man for that matter.</p><p>Why this fails? The Pneuma is Spirit. We already mentioned that in John 14:26, Jesus identifies the Paraklētos directly as the Holy Spirit “to pneuma to hagion”.</p><p>John 4 says God is pneuma.</p><p>Luke 24:39, Jesus explicitly states “See My hands and My feet, that it is I Myself; touch Me and see, for a spirit does not have flesh and bones as you see that I have.”</p><p>A pneuma (Spirit) does not have flesh and bones.</p><p>Get it, got it, Good!</p><p>Also, unless you try to force Muhammad in that place and time (like a Where’s Waldo puzzle) Muhammad was not there when the Messiah said his teachings would be remembered. You cannot “bring to remembrance” conversations to people who were never there. Nor could a seventh-century “prophet” remind first-century apostles of words they heard 600 years earlier.</p><p>The promise was explicitly made to the eyewitnesses in that room. If Muhammad can qualify, then why cant any one else make that same claim, like the Pope, Benny Hinn or Joseph Smith.</p><p>And another issue to mention is that the Disciples, <strong>when all was said and done</strong>, knew that Jesus was the Son of God. Yes, they were a little thick headed in the beginning. But John could say with full confidence in 1 John 5:13, “I have written these things to you who believe in the name of <strong>the Son of God</strong> so that you may know that you have eternal life.”</p><p>John had no problem remembering Jesus is the Son of God, right? Right! That’s why he wrote the above.</p><p>If Muhammad were the paraklētos who reminded the disciples that Jesus is the Son of God, it makes zero logical sense for that very same “Comforter” to turn around 600 years later and declare that God has no Son.</p><p>In other words, for those a little dense, the same teacher cannot simultaneously remind John that Jesus is the Son of God while denying that Jesus is the Son of God. Either John’s Spirit-led recollection in the First Document is true, or the seventh-century claim is true, they cannot both be right.</p><p>Secondly, let’s return to Hadeer’s comment already mentioned above. The author wants the reader to entertain a thought: s<em>he says, “set the explicit naming aside for a moment.”</em></p><p>OK, but even if we do that, this is disingenuous and sneaky. It won’t resuscitate or rescue the argument. Why? Because Jesus gives additional realities in John 14:17 that again disqualify Muhammad, or any human prophet for that matter.</p><p><strong>John 14:16–17: <em>“I will ask the Father to give you another Helper, to be with you always. He is the Spirit of truth, whom the world cannot receive, because it neither sees him nor recognizes him. But you recognize him, because he lives with you and will be in you.”</em></strong></p><p>Please pay attention: not to mention the fact that the Comforter will <strong>“be with you always,”</strong> the world <strong>“neither sees him nor recognizes him,”</strong> and he <strong>“will be in you”</strong> forever.</p><p>Even if you grant the article’s premise about the Greek word <em>allos</em>, (and I will go into this in greater detail later) John 14:16-17 immediately slams the door shut on Muhammad, or again, ANY other prophet making the same claim.</p><p>Look at the following facts that dictate the person Jesus is promising:</p><p>“to be with you always”</p><p>“the world neither sees him”</p><p>“nor recognizes/knows him”</p><p>“lives with you and will be in you”… forever</p><p>Now explain how Muhammad can be applied to any of these?</p><p>Is Muhammad with us always?</p><p>Is Muhammad able to be seen?</p><p>Is Muhammad recognizable?</p><p>Is Muhammad able to live with you and in you?</p><p>A promise to remain with believers “always” or “forever” in Vs. 16. It uses the Greek words “<em>eis ton aiōna”</em>, meaning “into the age” or “eternally”. This can only be fulfilled by someone who is eternal and omnipresent, not a mortal human being.</p><p>This person Jesus speaks of is invisible. But, Muhammad was a physical man. In the Hadith, companions pointed out Muhammad to a visitor by describing him as “this white man reclining on his arm”. (<a href="https://sunnah.com/bukhari:63">Bukhari 63</a>)</p><p>But, this person Jesus speaks of in the text is unrecognizable to the world. Muhammad was a public leader, known throughout Arabia. He killed, waged war, etc. Jesus explicitly says the <em>Paraklētos</em> cannot be seen or known by the physical world.</p><p>In addition, though crass, Aisha recognized Muhammad in their physical relations. She did not share a bed with a ghost. Remember, we already discussed the fact the the Spirit/Pneuma is incorporeal.</p><p>So when Scripture says “He indwells all God’s people forever,” a human prophet born 600 years later cannot live <strong>inside</strong> 1st-century apostles, nor can a mortal man who died in the 7th century remain with them <em>forever</em>.</p><p>Notice how the author of the Medium article actually tried to dodge this exact problem in her article by appealing to the Greek word <em>allos</em>, claiming it points to “another” human prophet like Jesus!</p><p>Bless her heart, she is clearly familiar with Christian defenses, yet she is willing to take that chance in the hopes there are a few readers who know nothing about this strategy. She goes on record twisting the Greek to fit her narrative.</p><p>How can I prove she is using a past strategy? Because as I often say, ideas have a history. She didn’t get this from original Greek scholarship; she lifted it straight from a 40-year-old Islamic talking point popularized by Ahmed Deedat in the 1980s, and that thread goes back further to Abdul-Ahad Dawud.</p><p>These Islamic apologists took a classic lexical distinction from Christian reference works like W.E. Vine’s Expository Dictionary and Strong’s-numbered word studies.</p><p>These works defined allos (“another of the same kind”) to show that the Holy Spirit shares the exact same divine essence as Jesus, and twisted it by stripping Jesus of His deity so they could turn “another of the same kind” into another mortal prophet.</p><p>Now keep in mind that Christians have exposed this problem if you want to study it further. I would refer the reader again to James White’s, “<em>Did Ahmed Deedat Truly Know Greek?”</em> <strong>(</strong><a href="https://www.aomin.org/aoblog/islam/did-ahmed-deedat-truly-know-greek/"><strong>Alpha and Omega Ministries</strong></a><strong>)</strong>.</p><p>James White documents how Deedat repeatedly lifted Greek terms out of basic reference books, such as Strong’s and Vine’s, without knowing Greek grammar, and twisted definitions to attack the deity of Christ while contradicting the actual Greek text.</p><p>In a few words? Christianity meets Islamic distortion.</p><p>Christian lexicographers like W.E. Vine were accurately describing a real Greek nuance that fits John’s theology, and Deedat distorted their work by ripping that definition out of its biblical context.</p><p>Lexically, in classical Greek, <em>allos</em> often meant “another of the same kind” while <em>heteros</em> meant “another of a different kind.”</p><p>The Christian dictionaries defined <em>allos</em> that way because John’s Gospel presents Jesus as God, (<em>“the Word was God” </em>in John 1:1). Meaning the Holy Spirit is another Person of the exact same Godhead as Jesus.</p><p>BUT, Deedat simply ignored John’s view of Jesus and substituted the Islamic view: A pea and shell game. To Deedat, Jesus is not and was not divine, he was purely a mortal human prophet who ate, slept, and walked the earth.</p><p>Once Deedat combined the Christian dictionary definition with the Islamic definition of Jesus, he sprung the trap on audiences unfamiliar with the surrounding verses.</p><p>Deedat argued, “If Jesus was a mortal human prophet, and allos means ‘another of the exact same kind,’ then the coming Comforter must also be a mortal human prophet i.e. Muhammad, because a disembodied spirit would be a different kind of being (heteros), not the same kind (allos).</p><p>As modern grammarians like Daniel B. Wallace point out, that distinction had blurred somewhat by the 1st century, which is why one cannot build an entire doctrine on <em>allos</em> alone. Even so, in John 14:16, Vine’s observation aligns 100% with the surrounding verses.</p><p>Theologically, because John’s Gospel explicitly defines Jesus as God, Vine was completely faithful to the text when he noted that <em>allos paraklētos</em> (“another Comforter like Himself”) describes a divine Person of the same essence as Jesus, namely, the Holy Spirit.</p><p>Deedat flipped that Christian Trinitarian note on its head. He used a three-step logical maneuver. He essentially borrowed a Christian scholarly tool, changed the starting premise, and arriving at the opposite conclusion.</p><p>In logic, this is called a syllogistic bait-and-switch. Deedat accepted the Christian dictionary definition that <em>allos</em> means “another of the same kind.” He then stripped away Jesus’s deity, claiming Jesus was only a mortal human prophet.</p><p>He concluded that “another of the same kind” as Jesus therefore had to be another mortal human prophet.</p><p>Guess who that would be? Muhammad, rather than a Spirit, which Deedat claimed would have required the Greek word <em>heteros</em> (“another of a different kind”). Like most anti Biblical apologists, they dont know Greek and they dont know hermeneutics and they ignore logic.</p><p>Deedat’s trick works rhetorically because he uses real Christian scholarship in Step 1 to build credibility, making the reader assume Step 3 must also be scholarly.</p><p>However, it completely fails because he ripped the word out of the sentence it sits in. In John 14:16–17, Jesus doesn’t leave the reader guessing what “same kind” means, He immediately defines the <em>allos paraklētos</em> in the very next words as <strong>“the Spirit of truth”</strong> who is invisible to the world and lives <strong>inside</strong> the disciples <strong>forever</strong>.</p><p>Deedat had to pretend John 14:17 didn’t exist in order to make his flip work. And since Deedat popularized this in his widely distributed booklet <em>Muhammad: The Natural Successor to Christ</em> and used it in his debates, it has been copied verbatim by almost every modern Muslim apologist and blogger.</p><p>That includes Zakir Naik, Shabir Ally, and writers on sites like <em>OneGodPath</em> (which include yours truly, Hadeer, which she links to in her own article).</p><p>So when Hadeer brings up <em>allos</em>, she isn’t doing original Greek scholarship; she is repeating a hand-me-down, used clothing talking point that has been circulating in Islamic pamphlets for over 40 years.</p><p>In Kenneth Wuest’s expanded translation of John 14:16 (<em>“another Counsellor of the same kind as I am”</em>), Wuest is translating the exact nuance of the Greek word <strong><em>allos</em></strong>, which means <strong>“another of the exact same nature and essence”</strong>, as opposed to <em>heteros</em>, which means “another of a different kind.”</p><p>In the context of John’s Gospel, Jesus is not merely a human prophet. Nevertheless, for the H<em>oly Spirit (paraklētos)</em> to be <em>“another of the exact same kind as I am”</em> (<em>allos</em>), The Holy spirit must share the same attributes as He Himself holds.</p><p>In contrast, I already pointed this out above. Muhammad was a visible, mortal man. He most definitely did not live <em>inside</em> the first-century apostles, nor did he descend later at Pentecost. He DOES NOT live in all Christians simultaneously as only God can.</p><p>Can you imagine if you removed the terms at Pentecost in Acts 2 and inserted Muhammad?</p><p>And when the day of Pentecost had fully come, they were all together in one place. And suddenly there came from heaven a noise of Muhammad, like a violent rushing wind, and Muhammad filled the whole house where they were sitting. And there appeared to them tongues of Muhammad like fire distributing themselves, and Muhammad rested on each one of them. And they were all filled with Muhammad and began to speak with other tongues, as the Muhammad was giving them utterance. NOOOOOO!</p><p>Finally, Jesus states the <em>paraklētos</em>’s primary mission in John 15:26 and John 16:14: <strong>“He will bear witness about me”</strong> and <strong>“He will glorify me.”</strong></p><p>Say for the sake of argument that Muhammad is the Comforter to come? Muhammad and the Qur’an explicitly deny Jesus’s deity, deny His Sonship, and deny His crucifixion, etc etc.</p><p>How does that work out? A prophet sent to erase the cross and deity of Christ cannot possibly be the Spirit sent to glorify Him.</p><p>I just dont know how this can even be an argument? Maybe someone can help me see what I am not seeing? If Muhammad were the promised <em>Paraklētos</em>, Jesus would be promising to send a successor whose primary message directly dismantles everything Jesus taught about Himself!</p><p>Even if you set aside all the Greek grammar, the historical timeline, and the physical descriptions in John 14:17, the article’s argument collapses on basic theological consistency.</p><p>Jesus later said in John15:26, “”When the Helper comes, whom I will send to you from the Father, the Spirit of Truth who comes from the Father, he will testify on my behalf.”</p><p>This is packed with information! Notice several things in one breath.</p><p>First, <strong>Jesus Himself</strong> sends the Helper. Second, He sends Him <strong>“to you”</strong>, the eleven disciples in that room, not people living six centuries later. Third, He is <strong>“the Spirit of truth”</strong> proceeding from the Father, not a man of flesh and bones. Fourth, He is truth. Fifth, His mission is to <strong>testify about Jesus</strong>, whereas Muhammad came to overturn the apostles’ testimony about Jesus’s crucifixion and deity.</p><p>Take note the helper is called the “Spirit of Truth” who will testify on behalf of the Messiah. I will address the issue later, but are we back to the issue of the Bible stating one thing and a religion several Centuries later rising up to challenge that truth.</p><p>1 John 2:21 I have not written to you because you do not know the truth, but because you <strong>do know</strong> it and because <strong>lies don’t come from truth</strong>.</p><p>One brief comment about the ‘praised one’ argument.</p><p>In debates over John 14:16, Muslim apologists typically try to get “Muhammad” or “Ahmad” “the praised one,” by combining the Aramaic and the Quran 61:6 reference.</p><p>First, appealing to Jesus’s native Aramaic doesn’t help the claim that this refers to Muhammad. In fact, it refutes it.</p><p>If Jesus had used a Semitic word meaning ‘praised one’ (the meaning of Muhammad/Ahmad), the ancient Aramaic Peshitta would have preserved it.</p><p>Instead, the Aramaic text uses Paraqleta; defined as Advocate or Helper. The Aramaic defines him as Rukha d’Qushta i.e. the Spirit of Truth, and locks every promise to the eleven disciples in the room with the plural suffix -khon i.e. you all’.</p><p>Muslim apologists then argue that the original Greek text didn’t say paraklētos, i.e. Helper or Advocate, but periklytos i.e. the praised one, claiming Christians later altered a few vowels in the Greek manuscripts.</p><p>According to the Center for the Study of New Testament Manuscripts (<a href="https://manuscripts.csntm.org/manuscript/">CSNTM</a>) led by Dr. Daniel B. Wallace, as well as Dr. Peter J. Williams of Tyndale House, this textual data creates a massive problem those trying to use this argument.</p><p>Yet not a single manuscript anywhere in the world, nor a single textual variant in any critical edition, reads periklytos. Every single one reads paraklētos.</p><p>Anyone can verify this for themselves using the same websites that I use. CSNTM: The <a href="https://manuscripts.csntm.org/manuscript/"><strong>Center for the Study of New Testament Manuscripts</strong></a> or by checking the Greek text directly on Tyndale House’s <a href="https://www.stepbible.org/version.jsp?version=THGNT">STEP Bible</a>.</p><p>Out of more than 5,800 Greek manuscripts, including early papyri like P66 and P75. NOT a single copy anywhere reads periklytos. Every single one reads paraklētos.</p><p>So when you read the Aramaic or the Greek, Jesus explicitly separates His disciples from “the world.” You cannot ignore the immediate context and force a rigid, outside definition onto a Greek word, yet that is exactly what happens when Islamic apologists try to smuggle “Muhammad” or “Ahmad” (<a href="https://legacy.quran.com/61/6">the Quran’s praised from Qur’an 61:6</a>) into <em>paraklētos</em>.</p><p>You are trying to put a square into a circle. And it is dishonest to attempt. Hadeer is no dummy. This is a common strategy with many inside of false religions.</p><p>It is called a concede-and-pivot. Also known as a also known as paralipsis;<strong> </strong>bringing up an argument while claiming to set it aside. Depending on which angle you look at it from, logicians divide what she did into two classic concepts:</p><ol><li>A <strong>rhetorical device</strong> (how she persuades the audience).</li></ol><p>2. A <strong>logical fallacy</strong> (the error in her actual reasoning).</p><p>In logic and rhetoric, this is a textbook <strong>Motte-and-Bailey tactic</strong> paired with the <strong>fallacy of equivocation</strong>.</p><p>First, she retreats from the indefensible ‘Bailey’ (claiming <strong>periklytos</strong> was in the original Greek) to a safe-sounding ‘Motte’ (claiming she’s merely pointing out ‘a resemblance worth noticing’). (<a href="https://fallacies.online/wiki/ambiguity/motte-and-bailey">Fallacies Online</a>)</p><p>Then, in the very next sentence, she commits <strong>equivocation, </strong>smuggling the definition of <strong>periklytos</strong> (‘the praised one’) onto <strong>paraklētos</strong> (‘Advocate/Helper’) by claiming it is ‘the meaning the two words share.’</p><p>This whole article is trying to put a distance between these two Greek words, showing they come from completely different root verbs and share zero meaning. Sounding slightly alike in English does not make two Greek words synonyms.</p><p>Nevertheless, see if you can spot it?</p><blockquote>“Some Muslim commentators, Yusuf Ali and Muhammad Asad among them, proposed that the original word was periklytos and was altered somewhere in copying. I think that argument is better handled with care than leaned on. Every surviving Greek manuscript of John reads paraklētos; not one copy anywhere reads periklytos. To rest a case on a text no one has ever held is to build on sand. The steadier observation is smaller: the meaning the two words share — the praised one — is the very meaning the name Ahmad carries. A resemblance worth noticing is not a proof, and it holds up better for not pretending to be one.”</blockquote><p>Part one? She appears reasonable by conceding the facts! First, she earns the reader’s trust by admitting that <em>periklytos</em> doesn’t exist in any Greek manuscript, calling it “building on sand.”</p><p>Part two? She Smuggles the Debunked Meaning Back In: In the very next sentence, she says, “<strong>the meaning the two words share — the praised one — is the very meaning the name Ahmad carries.”</strong></p><p>Did you see it? I did. That’s why I bring it up. She didn’t wear a cape, she wasn’t holding a top hat and a cane! She didn’t use the language of Rome “hocus pocus…” No bunnies came out of the hat!</p><p>Watch the sleight of hand; She just admitted a word isn’t in the Bible and then quietly transfer its definition onto the word that actually is, lol.</p><p>Am I the only one too say Whooooaaaaaa Nellyyy? Wait a minute! Paraklētos and periklytos <strong>do not</strong> share the meaning “the praised one”!</p><p>Paraklētos means Advocate, Helper, or Comforter. It has nothing to do with “praise.” By saying “the meaning the two words share,” she quietly attaches periklytos’s definition onto paraklētos, pretending they mean the same thing even though she just admitted periklytos isn’t in the Bible.</p><p>She’s good! By framing it as <em>“a resemblance worth noticing is not a proof, and it holds up better for not pretending to be one,”</em> she tries to dodge the burden of proof while still planting the seed in the reader’s mind that the John 14 points to <em>Ahmad</em>.</p><p>Historically, apologists tried to pull this off in two ways: first, by claiming the original Greek word was <em>periklytos</em> (“much-praised”) before Christians allegedly altered the vowels; and second, when the manuscripts shut that down, by claiming Jesus must have spoken an Aramaic word meaning “the praised one” (like <em>M’hamda</em> or <em>M’shabkha</em>) that got lost in Greek translation.</p><p>To her credit, Hadeer Hadi admits that relying on <em>periklytos</em> is “building on sand,” because out of more than 5,000 surviving Greek manuscripts, including papyri dating back to around AD 200, <strong>not a single copy anywhere reads <em>periklytos</em>.</strong> Every single one reads <em>paraklētos</em>. Yet right after admitting there is zero manuscript evidence for it, she tries to sneak the “praised one” connection back in anyway as a “resemblance worth noticing.”</p><p>And appealing to Jesus’s native Aramaic doesn’t rescue the theory either, in fact, it buries it. Aramaic and Arabic are Semitic sister-languages that share the exact same root letters for “praise.”</p><p>If Jesus had actually stood in that upper room and used an Aramaic word meaning “the praised one,” the ancient Aramaic-speaking church would have preserved that exact word in their own scriptures.</p><p>Instead, the Syriac Peshitta, the authoritative Aramaic New Testament, contains no word meaning “praised one.”</p><p>It preserves the exact title “Paraqleta” i.e. Advocate/Comforter, it defines Him immediately as “Rukha d’Qushta” i.e. the Spirit of Truth, and as already mentioned, identifies every single promise to the eleven disciples in the room using the plural suffix -”khon” or you all.</p><p>(The Spirit) He is given to you (l’khon), dwells with you (‘amkhon), and lives inside you (b’khon).</p><p>Bottom line: whether you read the earliest Greek papyri or the ancient Aramaic Peshitta, there is no “thread left hanging” for a seventh-century prophet in Arabia. To turn the paraklētos into Muhammad, you have to reject every existing manuscript in two languages, erase the plural pronouns aimed straight at the apostles, and “set aside” Jesus’s own plain-English definition of the Helper as the invisible Holy Spirit who lives inside believers forever.</p><p><strong>We Mimic The God We Serve!</strong></p><p>One other point that I believe is necessary to develop, is the issue of truth and the issue of lying.</p><p>In the text, you read: John 14:16 “And I will ask the Father, and He will give you another Advocate, that He may be with you forever; <strong>the Spirit of truth</strong>, whom the world cannot receive, because it does not see Him or know Him. You know Him because He abides with you and will be in you.</p><p>Building upon the “Spirit of truth” <em>(to pneuma tēs alētheias</em>) it should be pointed out that Islam does not share the convictions of Christian doctrine even though it wants to build upon them.</p><p>Isaiah 8 teaches God’s people that if anyone comes along and “do not speak according to this Word, they have no light in them.”</p><p>Not only is Jesus <em>“the truth”</em> in John 14:6, the Bible says that God <em>“cannot lie”</em> in Titus 1:2.</p><p>Therefore, the “Spirit of truth” embodies absolute, uncompromising truth. The Jewish Christians are to behave in the same manner when it comes to the things of God.</p><p>Now contrast this with Islam?</p><p>No matter who we serve or give allegiance to, it goes without say that we are ambassadors for our religion. We represent the god(s) that we serve. If we serve King Jesus, we speak the truth and do not lie.</p><p>Since Muslims insist that Muhammad is this promised “Spirit of truth,” they have to explain how their alleged personification of absolute truth could explicitly permit lying and deception?</p><p>Muhammad reflects the god he proclaims. In the Quran 3:54, he is a god who calls Himself <em>khayru al-mākirīn</em> which is also known as “the best of schemers/planners”.</p><blockquote>“and for boasting, “We killed the Messiah, Jesus, son of Mary, the messenger of Allah.” But they neither killed nor crucified him — it was only made to appear so. Even those who argue for this ˹crucifixion˺ are in doubt. They have no knowledge whatsoever — only making assumptions. They certainly did not kill him. <a href="https://quran.com/an-nisa/157">According to Qur’an 4:157</a>, Allah is said to have tricked Jesus’s own eyewitnesses into believing Jesus was crucified when He wasn’t.</blockquote><p>An entire Encyclopedia of Jewish Christian Scriptures (66 Scrolls) maintains the Lamb of God would come to earth to be a propitiation for the sins of God’s people. Isaiah 52–53 is very clear as one example alone</p><p>And yet, the Quran says we are confused? “They have no knowledge whatsoever — only making assumptions.”</p><p>Islamic traditions permit lying in several situations war, reconciling people, and between spouses:</p><blockquote>“A liar is not one who tries to bring reconciliation amongst people and speaks good (in order to avert dispute), or he conveys good. Ibn Shihab said he did not hear that exemption was granted in anything what the people speak as lie but in three cases: in battle, for bringing reconciliation amongst persons and the narration of the words of the husband to his wife, and the narration of the words of a wife to her husband (in a twisted form in order to bring reconciliation between them). <strong>(</strong><a href="https://sunnah.com/muslim:2605a"><strong>Sahih Muslim 2605</strong></a>)</blockquote><p>The lies I am speaking of are not toward war and marriage, but because we are contrasting John and the Spirit of truth, I am addressing doctrinal concealment.</p><p>(By the way, I thought I would take part of this and create its own article, so that will be on the back burner.)</p><p>One article on Medium took the time to create a point by point which is helpful so I don’t have to include details myself.</p><p>The article begins with: “<strong>Taqiyya (تقية)</strong> is a concept in Islamic jurisprudence that permits lying or concealing one’s beliefs under specific circumstances. This doctrine is most commonly associated with <strong>Shia Islam</strong>, but it has also been recognized by some Sunni scholars in certain situations.” (<a href="https://medium.com/@spotlightonislam2/lying-taqiyya-in-islamic-doctrine-e0b2cbbbe368">See Here</a>)</p><p>Outside of war, classical Islamic scholars developed mechanisms for concealing the truth. Study these as you wish, but the point should be obvious between the two religions.</p><p>Jesus defines the coming <em>Paraklētos</em> as <strong>“the Spirit of truth”.</strong></p><p>In 1 John 2:21, the very same author writes: <strong><em>“No lie is of the truth.”</em></strong></p><p>Which, by the way, if read entirely it reveals how and why lies can identify who is of the spirit of antichrist.</p><p>1 John 2:21, “I have not written to you because you do not know the truth, but because you do know it, and because <strong>no lie is of the truth</strong>. Who is the liar but the one who denies that Jesus is the Christ? This is the antichrist, the one who denies the Father and the Son. Everyone who denies the Son does not have the Father; the one who confesses the Son has the Father also.”</p><p>Islam specifically denies the relationship between the Father and the Son.</p><p>Under biblical theology, truth and lying are mutually exclusive, there are no “permitted” categories for lying because truth is an absolute reflection of God’s unchanging nature.</p><p>There are no “approved” categories. A figure who explicitly licenses lying cannot be <strong>“the Spirit of truth.”</strong></p><p>Not to make this article about lying, but we are talking about the Spirit of truth so lets give the reader an idea about Yahweh’s position in His Word.</p><p>Truthfulness is built into the Ten Commandments. Do you hear that you false prophets, Deconstructionists and politicians?</p><p>Exodus 20:16, <em>“Y</em>ou are not to testify falsely against your neighbor.”</p><p>Proverbs 4:24, “Never talk deceptively and don’t keep company with people whose speech is corrupt.”</p><p>Proverbs 12:22, “Lying lips or deceitful speech is reprehensible to Yahweh, but those who act faithfully are his delight.”</p><p>Proverbs 6:16,19, “ There are six things which Yahweh hates, Even seven which are an abomination to Him…a false witness snorting lies, and someone sowing quarrels between brothers.”</p><p>Lying always seems to attract itself to the religious.</p><p>Isaiah 9:14–16, “So Yahweh cuts off head and tail from Israel, Both palm branch and bulrush in a single day. The head is the elder and the highly respected man, And the prophet who teaches falsehood is the tail. For those who guide this people are leading them astray; And those who are guided by them are brought to confusion.”</p><p>Lying is a fruit that a conversion may not have taken place;</p><p>Colossians 3:9, “Do not lie to one another, for you have stripped off the old nature with its practices.”</p><p>Lying has its source in the Devil. And this is very interesting to me because as I mentioned earlier, this nature is a reflection of the god(s) one serves. If a religion has the option to lie, it is a reflection of who their Pappy is.</p><p>John 8:44, “You belong to your father the devil, and you want to carry out the desires of your father. He was a murderer from the beginning and has never stood for truth, since there is no truth in him. <strong>Whenever he tells a lie he speaks in character, because he is a liar and the father of lies.</strong>”</p><p>The first lie takes us all the way back to Genesis 3 and the garden. And as we have learned from Adam, lying carries eternal consequences.</p><p>The Book of the Apocalypse carries a great warning to all liars.</p><p>Revelation 21:8, “But people who are cowardly, unfaithful, detestable, murderers, sexually immoral, sorcerers, idolaters, <strong>and all liars</strong> will find themselves in the lake that burns with fire and sulfur. This is the second death.”</p><p>Revelation 22:15, “Outside are the dogs and the sorcerers and the sexually immoral persons and the murderers and the idolaters, and <strong>everyone who loves and practices lying</strong>.”</p><p><strong>The Greek Grammar.</strong></p><p>I wanted to elaborate on a few more examples for repetition. So forgive the redundancy.</p><p>As Dr. James White has demonstrated in numerous debates on this exact text, that argument completely unravels once you actually look at the Greek grammar of the surrounding sentence.</p><p>First, in 1st-century Koine Greek, the rigid classical distinction between <em>allos</em> (“another of the same kind”) and <em>heteros</em> (“another of a different kind”) had largely broken down.</p><p>Second, and far more devastating to Hadeer’s thesis, even if you strictly enforce that distinction, it proves the exact opposite of what she wants. In John’s Gospel, Jesus is not merely a mortal prophet; He is the eternal, divine Word (<em>θεὸς ἦν ὁ λόγος</em>, John 1:1).</p><p>Therefore, “another of the same kind” as Jesus means another divine Person, not a 7th century human messenger. Immediately after saying allon paraklēton, John places τὸ πνεῦμα τῆς ἀληθείας (“the Spirit of truth”) in grammatical apposition, explicitly defining that “same kind” as the Holy Spirit, who abides εἰς τὸν αἰῶνα (eis ton aiōna, “forever”) and dwells ἐν ὑμῖν (en hymin, “inside you”).</p><p>Even further, the Greek pronouns in John 14–16 expose just how desperate it is to read a human male into this passage. Whenever Muslim apologists see masculine pronouns like ekeinos (“he”) used for the Paraklētos, they assume it must refer to a man.</p><p>Yet in Greek, <em>paraklētos</em> is a grammatically masculine noun, so any pronoun referring back to it must be masculine, just as <em>pneuma</em> (“Spirit”) is a grammatically neuter noun.</p><p>What happens in John 14:17 if Jesus defines the <em>Paraklētos</em> as “the Spirit of truth” (<em>to pneuma tēs alētheias</em>)?</p><p>The text immediately shifts to neuter pronouns (<em>ὅ</em>, “which,” and <em>αὐτό</em>, “it”): <em>“whom [which] the world cannot receive, because it neither sees </em><strong><em>it</em></strong><em> [αὐτό] nor knows </em><strong><em>it</em></strong><em>; you know </em><strong><em>it</em></strong><em> [αὐτό], because it abides with you and will be in you.”</em></p><p>No Greek writer in history would describe a human man using neuter pronouns like “it”. That grammatical shift between neuter (<em>pneuma</em>) and masculine (<em>paraklētos</em> / <em>ekeinos</em>) destroys any attempt to turn the Holy Spirit into Muhammad.</p><p>I mentioned Dr. Daniel B. Wallace earlier. He is the author of <em>Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics</em>, the standard textbook used in seminaries worldwide. He points out that relying on a rigid distinction between <em>allos</em> (“same kind”) and <em>heteros</em> (“different kind”) is actually unnecessary, and can even be a trap, because the immediate context of the sentence itself proves what Jesus meant, regardless of how <em>allos</em> is translated.</p><p>Wallace explains that in 1st-century Greek, <em>allos</em> and <em>heteros</em> often overlapped in meaning (for instance, in Galatians 1:6–7, Paul uses both words interchangeably). Therefore, you don’t even need to win a technical debate over <em>allos</em> vs. <em>heteros</em> to dismantle the Islamic claim.</p><p>Instead, Wallace shows that John 14:16–17 defines “another” immediately in the very next words:</p><ol><li>The Adjective (<em>allos</em>): Jesus promises <em>allon paraklēton</em> (“another Helper”).</li><li>The Immediate Definition: Before taking a breath, Jesus defines <em>who</em> that Helper is: “the Spirit of truth” (<em>to pneuma tēs alētheias</em>), whom the world cannot see, who lives with you, and who will be in you forever.</li></ol><p>In simple terms? Context context context, always trumps a dictionary definition<strong>.</strong> Even if someone translates <em>allos</em> simply as “another,” the very next sentence tells us that this “other” Helper is an <strong>invisible Spirit</strong> who lives <strong>inside</strong> the disciples <strong>forever, </strong>which eliminates any mortal human being on the spot.</p><p>To give a reader another example: The Greek word for ‘world’ is <em>kosmos</em>, which has a broad dictionary range in the New Testament. What moralists and universalists often fail to observe is that biblical words must be interpreted by how they are used in context, not by a single rigid definition.</p><p>For example, take the following three passages and note how John uses them in different ways:</p><p>John 1:10, “He was in the world, and the world was made through him. Yet the world did not recognize him.” This single verse uses <em>kosmos</em> three times.</p><p>John 17:9, “I am asking on their behalf. I am not asking on behalf of the world, but on behalf of those you gave me, because they are yours.” Jesus explicitly contrasts <em>“</em>those whom You have given Me<em>”</em> against <em>“the world.”</em> If <em>kosmos</em> meant every single human being without exception, this sentence would contradict itself.</p><p>1 John 5:19, “We know that we are from God and that the whole world lies under the control of the evil one.</p><p>Again, “we” as believers, are separated from “the whole world,” proving “the whole world” (<em>holos ho kosmos</em>) refers to the unbelieving system/humanity, not every person alive.</p><p>Immediate context always dictates a word’s intended meaning; treating a dictionary definition as static creates direct contradictions.</p><p>Anyone who wants more information against bad word-study arguments without needing a seminary degree should get the book by Donald Carson called <strong><em>Exegetical Fallacies. </em></strong>It is a short, readable book written specifically to expose common errors in biblical interpretation. Especially errors involving Greek words. Carson spends an entire section explaining why context always overrides dictionary definitions, complete with New Testament examples to study.</p><p>Once it is admitted that words like ‘all’ and ‘world’ are used in passages where they clearly cannot mean every single human being, the simplistic assumption that they always mean all of humanity must be rejected.</p><p>Finally, the Greek syntax in John 14. The passage locks this promise exclusively to the 1st-century eyewitnesses sitting in that upper room.</p><p>The Wuest translations reads “And as for myself, I will ask the Father, and another Counsellor of the same kind as I am He will give to you in order that He might be with you forever, the Spirit of the truth, whom the world is not able to receive because it does not see Him with discernment and does not know Him experientially. But, as for you, you know Him experientially, because by your side He dwells, and in you He shall be. I will not leave you behind, helpless. I come to you.”’</p><p>The text fills and surrounds Jesus’s promise with second-person plural pronouns addressed exclusively to the eleven disciples: Hymin, ‘to you’, hymōn, ‘with you’, hymeis, ‘you’, and hymas, ‘you’. In other words, Jesus tells them: “He will give <strong>you</strong> [ὑμῖν] another Helper… he dwells with <strong>you</strong> [παρ’ ὑμῖν] and will be in <strong>you</strong> [ἐν ὑμῖν]… he will remind you [ὑμᾶς] of everything I have said to <strong>you</strong> [ὑμῖν].”</p><p>As White points out, if the <em>Paraklētos</em> were Muhammad, Jesus’s promise to His grieving apostles would have been a hollow deception, none of the men in that room would ever live to see him, nor could a 7th century Arabian leader remind 1st-century disciples of conversations they personally heard 600 years earlier.</p><p>Hadeer wants readers to treat John’s Gospel like an unfinished riddle waiting for the Qur’an to supply a name, yet the Greek grammar itself shuts the door on every single claim she makes.</p><p>And this is what Progressives, Deconstructionists and false religions do.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d6b6535f9adb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The corruption in the Market. How traders today will never be the traders of 100 years ago.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MosheD/the-corruption-in-the-market-how-traders-today-will-never-be-the-traders-of-100-years-ago-4abcae192204?source=rss-af4a87e02b1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4abcae192204</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Moshe D.]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 14 Nov 2026 01:43:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-14T16:29:15.991Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>How Modern Market Makers Are Undermining the Everyday Investor’s Retirement.</strong></p><p>I recently responded to a YouTube video that highlights Ol’ Jesse Livermore. I wrote in the comments in part “Jesse Livermore would fail as a trader if he were trading today. The system is corrupt and outside money is moving the markets…” .</p><p>Whether you agree with my thesis or not, you have to admit; if you trade like many do, things have changed.</p><p>For over a century, the stock market operated on a foundational social contract: it was simple; do your homework, locate a company that was making money and invest your money.</p><p>If you invested in well-run companies that grew their revenues and beat earnings expectations, you would share in their prosperity. Over time, that straightforward partnership allowed millions of everyday people to build a dignified retirement.</p><p>Today, that promise does not just feel broken, it IS broken. Not broken because it is a bad egg, but broken because manipulation has become part of the make-up for the market as a whole.</p><p>And I do believe wherever politicians and lawyers are involved, corruption is in the air, like moths to a flame.</p><p>Even within the past twenty years have we seen this change. Almost fifteen years ago I was able to move our family IRA up 30-40 percent past the S&amp;P. We are not professional traders by any means.</p><p>Those days are gone. I now lose a great deal. And yet, I didn’t change my strategy.</p><p>For individual investors trying to follow the rulebook of integrity, researching growing businesses, checking fundamental performance, and investing with patience, the modern stock market increasingly resembles not a rigged casino where the house always wins, but a corrupt casino where they empty out your pockets before you leave the floor.</p><p>So can ordinary savers build a retirement through individual stocks anymore. Is it even possible?</p><p><strong>When Doing Everything “Right” Still Loses Money.</strong></p><p>Let’s take a look at two companies in particular. Companies that I would consider to be doing very well. Posting record revenues, expanding customer bases, and beating Wall Street’s quarterly earnings estimates year after year.</p><p><strong>SoFi Technologies (SOFI)</strong> and <strong>nLIGHT (LASR)</strong>. By traditional standards, both represent the exact kind of operational momentum myself and maybe another investor looks for:</p><ul><li><strong>SoFi</strong> has delivered 12 consecutive profitable quarters, posted record revenue growth, and repeatedly raised its financial guidance. YET, its stock was cut roughly in half from its highs.</li><li><strong>nLIGHT</strong> beat consensus earnings estimates for seven straight quarters and secured major defense contracts, only to watch its shares plunge more than 50% from their peak, frequently selling off immediately after delivering good news.</li></ul><p>One hundred years ago, a profitable, rapidly growing bank or defense manufacturer posting consecutive earnings beats would have rewarded its shareholders steadily as its business expanded.</p><p>Today, good news is routinely used as “exit liquidity” by large institutions, leaving everyday investors watching their retirement accounts shrink while the underlying companies thrive.</p><p>If you remember one thing from this article, remember this: when the little guy invests, every dollar comes from real sweat, skipped vacations, and overtime shifts. All they have is then placed into the market to lock in a safe retirement, a child’s education, or a future for our families.</p><p>Not so with Wall Street. To the Fat Cat Market Makers, and insiders running the machines, your life savings are just numbers on a screen.</p><p>Their wallets are already bulging; they aren’t fighting to keep a roof over their heads or pay off a mortgage, or get their kids through college. They are working for their next yacht, their next mansion, and another record bonus. While we work to live, they live high on the hog as they work. And they don’t care whose family’s future gets wiped out to pay for it.</p><p>While it may be silly to mention, the corruption with market driven businesses is rampant and has gotten worse. Customers are a door mat while shareholders are a red carpet.</p><p>We recently had our outside porch roof collapse. Having never had a claim in over fifteen years, Travelers came out to assess the damage. They refused to cover it saying it was done incorrectly when the house was built, and would not be covered. They never went into the attic, just peeked up into the area and that was that.</p><p>Don’t misunderstand, this has nothing to do with corporations per se. And we are not on some campaign to yell at CEO’s. This article is about the manipulation of the market and how we have no access to a slice of the pie. I mention Travelers because they are notoriously known for only improving their stock price.</p><p>Is there a structural rigging of the modern market? From a purely structural perspective, major market makers and large institutional liquidity providers use their massive capital, order-flow visibility, and algorithmic speed to systematically steer short-term price action toward zones of maximum liquidity, which functionally operates as directional manipulation on intraday and weekly timeframes.</p><p>To say it another way, we are being used as chum in the water for the sharks. They don’t want us but they do need us? Not exactly like the Nannie McPhee relationship? They need our orders.</p><p>Market makers and high-frequency algorithms see where retail stop-loss orders and resting limit orders cluster. “Are you saying these folks manipulate the market”? Does a bear poop in the woods?</p><p>By deploying bursts of capital to push price a few points past an obvious support or resistance level, they trigger a cascade of forced retail liquidations, allowing them to fill massive institutional orders at better prices before letting the market snap back.</p><p>In his 2006 interview, Jim Cramer described this exact blueprint. Cramer openly admitted on camera that fundamentals don’t matter during that window, it is purely about using capital and psychology to force everyone else out of their positions so the fund can get the price it wants.</p><p>Deploying a relatively small burst of capital ($5 million to $10 million) during thin trading hours to hit the bids, knock out buyers, and push a stock or futures contract down past key technical levels so everyone watching the screen thinks the market is breaking down.</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=708wDFX28lc">The interview</a> described methods including tactical buying, shorting or using options to create an impression in the market that could prompt other traders and investors to buy or sell a stock. (<a href="http://The interview described methods including tactical buying, shorting or using options to create an impression in the market that could prompt other traders and investors to buy or sell a stock.">Cnet</a>)</p><p>That video of the interview was once available on YT, but *poof* did money make it go away?</p><h4><strong>Step 1 — The Capital Burst (Cramer’s Method): A hedge fund or market-making algorithm uses a concentrated burst of sell orders during thin volume (like pre-market, lunch hours, or right after earnings) to push price a few points below an obvious support level.</strong></h4><h4><strong>Step 2 — The Cascade of Retail Liquidations: Pushing price across that line triggers resting retail stop-loss orders and margin liquidations, in turn creating a sudden flood of forced selling that drives the price down even further without the institution having to spend any more money.</strong></h4><h4><strong>Step 3 — Filling Massive Orders at a Discount: While panicked retail stops are dumping shares at the bottom, the institution’s automated buy programs quietly scoop up those shares at artificially depressed prices.</strong></h4><h4><strong>Step 4 — The Snap-Back: Once the institution has filled its position and retail stops have been cleared out, the selling pressure vanishes and the price snaps right back above support, leaving everyday traders stopped out at the exact low while the institution sits on instant profits.</strong></h4><p>As they say, “it takes money to steal money… excuse me, to make money.” Institutional Wall Street and financial media control the narrative while keeping retail investors uninformed.</p><p>Institutional players and financial media frequently use “reframing” techniques to turn objectively positive company news into a scary headline, persuading retail holders to sell their shares right as institutions step in to buy them.</p><p>WHAT? The media would push a bogus narrative? Financial headlines routinely reframe objectively good news into fear to persuade retail holders to sell at the bottom. Never forget, the market is always moved by fear and greed:</p><ul><li><strong>The “Good News, Bad Guidance” Pivot:</strong> A company beats revenue and profit estimates, yet headlines ignore the beat and scream about a minor shipping delay: <em>“Shares Tumble as Supply Chain Bottlenecks Cloud Outlook.”</em></li><li><strong>Margin Compression Over Growth:</strong> A business reinvests profits to grow revenue by 40%, and the headline reads: <em>“Profits Squeezed as Rising Costs Offset Revenue Gains.”</em></li><li><strong>Timed Analyst Downgrades:</strong> Right after a strong earnings report, a major bank downgrades the stock — <em>“Stock Has Run Too Far, Too Fast”</em> — sparking retail panic so institutional clients can buy lower.</li><li><strong>Cherry-Picking One Soft Metric:</strong> Nineteen metrics beat expectations, one minor division misses slightly, and the headline declares: <em>“Company Stumbles as Key Segment Slowdown Sparks Concern.”</em></li><li><strong>The “Sell the News” Macro Excuse:</strong> Algorithms drive a profitable stock down after a beat, and commentators retroactively blame interest rates or sector rotation to convince retail holders to bail out.</li><li><strong>Inflammatory Short-Seller Labels:</strong> Activist short sellers take legal corporate structures and slap terrifying labels like <em>“Ponzi-like”</em> on them to trigger an immediate crash.</li></ul><p>With these examples in mind, I asked the AI about SOFI and the reason their value dropped while the business grew. It said:</p><blockquote>“Why the Stock Dropped While the Business Grew”</blockquote><blockquote>When a company beats earnings every quarter yet loses half its market value, the disconnect usually comes down to <strong>multiple compression</strong> and <strong>balance-sheet risk</strong> rather than current earnings:</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Valuation Reset (Multiple Compression):</strong> At its ~$32 peak in late 2025, Wall Street priced SOFI like a hyper-growth software/tech platform. Throughout 2026, institutional investors re-rated the stock closer to a traditional consumer bank, compressing its valuation multiple even as earnings climbed.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Lending vs. Tech Mix:</strong> Despite strong growth in its Loan Platform Business, analysts noted in <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/martinadilicosa/2026/04/29/why-sofis-stock-is-down-13-despite-its-fast-growth/">Forbes’ coverage of SoFi’s 2026 slide</a> that a massive portion of SoFi’s growth still relies on personal loan originations ($16.9 billion in Q3 2026), while its Galileo tech segment grew more slowly after losing a major client.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Interest Rate &amp; Credit Cycle Fears:</strong> Shifting expectations around interest rates and concerns over consumer credit fatigue — especially in unsecured personal loans — have kept institutional buyers cautious. Even if current defaults remain manageable, the market discounts bank and lending stocks ahead of potential economic slowdowns.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Sell-the-News Institutional Positioning:</strong> Following Q3’s blowout report, SOFI briefly spiked 15% into the mid-$17s before institutional sellers used that liquidity to unload shares, pushing it right back down toward $15.40&quot;</blockquote><p>After the AI provided its answers, I ask if any of the reasons it provided matched the examples above?</p><p>The AI said “<strong>Yes — my response directly used two of those exact narratives (“Cherry-Picking One Soft Metric” and “The ‘Sell the News’ Macro Excuse”), because those are the dominant explanations circulating in financial media and Wall Street analyst notes.”</strong></p><p>It went onto say <strong>“How Those Two Narratives Showed Up in My Answer:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Cherry-Picking One Soft Metric: When I pointed out that SoFi’s Galileo tech segment grew more slowly after losing a major client while personal loans drove the beat, that is the classic Wall Street move: nineteen metrics beat expectations, so commentary zooms in on the single soft metric to justify why the stock fell.</strong></li><li><strong>The “Sell the News” Macro Excuse: When I mentioned interest rate expectations, credit cycle fears, and institutional sellers using post-earnings liquidity to unload shares, that reflects the exact pattern you described — price drops first, and commentators retroactively attach a macro excuse (rates, credit fatigue, bank multiples) to explain away the sell-off</strong>.</li></ul><p>I think I made my point. Financial headlines are engineered to mislead. There is an old saying I think can be applied to this: <em>“I am a mushroom, I must be a mushroom; because they keep me in the dark and feed me manure.”</em></p><p>When you and I go to the news for the details behind a stock drop, we don’t get the truth; financial headlines and AI summaries regurgitate institutional B.S. We only get the retroactive excuses the institutions want to feed us while they quietly scoop up our shares.</p><p>They see our stops. We don’t see their stops. Anyone else have a problem with that? They locate and steal our shares to add to their cargo ship of shares before they move the markets.</p><p>Lets face it, with their power, their theft made legal, they don’t simply walk into an open field and pull from what they can. It appears after they plunder their own property and leave it desolate, they go into the neighbors properties and steal their shares as well.</p><p>We are not allowed to see institutional stops and large orders because SEC market structure rules explicitly let institutions hide behind dark pools, iceberg orders, and off-exchange execution.</p><p>Under the legal pretext that showing their hand would invite predatory “front-running.” Under SEC Regulation ATS, pension funds, mutual funds, and hedge funds are legally permitted to route massive orders into private, non-displayed venues.</p><p>That means, nothing appears on public Level 2 screens until after the trade is already executed. So when T or S sells that speech to you? Don’t buy into it. And by the way, Level 2 is a con game. Orders can be floated there temporarily and then removed like a pea and shell game.</p><p>Exchanges legally offer institutional order types (like <em>Midpoint Peg</em> and <em>Reserve/Iceberg</em> orders) that sit completely invisible inside the exchange’s matching engine.</p><p>Wall Street whined and argued to <strong>regulators</strong> that if a fund’s million-share order were visible to the public, high-frequency algorithms would race ahead of it and drive the price away before the fund could finish buying or selling.</p><p>What is a regulator? The SEC is governed by a five-member commission appointed by the President and confirmed by the U.S. Senate for staggered five-year terms.</p><p>The President designates one commissioner to serve as Chair , the agency’s chief executive who sets its regulatory and enforcement agenda. By law, no more than three commissioners can belong to the same political party, ensuring the majority always aligns with the sitting President’s party.</p><p>Phew. I feel better already! “No more than three commissioners can belong to the same political party”. Surely that removes any corruption as if the Party determines the worldview. And this prevents corruption how?</p><p>Nevertheless, where it gets exciting is that the major financial firms, market makers, and hedge funds spend tens of millions of dollars lobbying members of Congress on those exact oversight committees and contributing to political campaigns.</p><p>When the SEC proposes rules that might threaten Wall Street’s business models, such as reforming Payment for Order Flow or restricting off-exchange dark pools, members of Congress frequently step in to pressure the SEC to water down or abandon the rules.</p><p>In short? It is another political extension used to further corruption.</p><p>And don’t forget what happens if you play ball? Senior SEC commissioners, enforcement directors, and lawyers routinely leave the agency for lucrative executive, board, or legal positions at the exact Wall Street banks, hedge funds, and exchanges they previously regulated, and vice versa.</p><p>For example, current SEC Chair Paul Atkins previously ran a major financial consulting firm (Patomak Global Partners) and served as non-executive chairman of BATS Global Markets. According to federal financial disclosures analyzed by Bloomberg and ProPublica, he and his spouse have a combined net worth of at least $327 million (with upper-bound asset estimates exceeding $579 million).</p><p>Understanding the SEC’s political structure explains why market rules<strong> consistently favor institutions </strong>over everyday investors<strong> </strong>with a small retirement.</p><p>We have nothing to offer up but our shares.</p><p>The agency is not an untouchable referee above politics. Its leadership is appointed by politicians, its budget is controlled by politicians who rely on Wall Street campaign donations, and its top officials frequently cycle directly between the regulator and the industry. They all spoon together.</p><p>So back to our stops, Yes, it is true that Institutions rarely place resting stop-loss orders on an exchange book anyway; their algorithms hold exit levels privately on their own servers and execute only when triggered. But it is the idea they are protected by their protectors.</p><p>Ask any everyday trader or retirement saver who has watched a sudden midday spike wipe out their stop-loss before the stock immediately rebounds and goes in the direction you anticipated. Happens to me all the time. How can this not lead others to think the game is rigged for the rich, and the rules are written to keep it that way?</p><p>When market makers and algorithms trigger stop-loss orders to harvest liquidity, it is directly at the expense of the retail investor! They turn a temporary paper dip into a permanent, locked-in loss. What do I mean?</p><p>Anyone that once held FORD stock about 11 years ago also knew what a great divided they paid! If the price dipped below our purchase price it didn’t matter because that dividend always took away the temporary pain.</p><p>So if you were buying shares of F in your IRA for long-term growth or dividend income, you would not care about short-term price swings.</p><p>But, today’s danger is that placing a resting stop-loss order on your broker’s books hands these thieves a free target directly to the market. I use stops to protect me if a black-swan event hits. But I pay for it a great deal.</p><p><strong>Playing With Marked Cards: How Wall Street Rigged the Market Against the Everyday Investor</strong></p><p>For millions of working Americans, the stock market was supposed to be the great equalizer, a transparent public square where ordinary people could research good companies, invest their savings, and build a dignified retirement. Instead, today’s market has become an extraction machine.</p><p>Whenever Wall Street is questioned about its unfair advantages, it hides behind a single magic word: <em>liquidity</em>.</p><p>“Oh, OK. All is well. It appears to be for the greater good of the rich. Here I was getting upset losing 500 dollars. As long as they made out!”</p><p>Market makers and high-frequency trading firms claim they need special privileges, off-exchange dark pools, and Payment for Order Flow to keep markets running smoothly. They argue that triggering clusters of retail stop-loss orders is simply “providing liquidity” so big institutions can fill their trades.</p><p>OK, fine but what is good for the goose is good for the gander, right? So what about our liquidity? When we as hardworking people put money into an IRA to buy shares of a growing, dividend-paying business, that capital is our family’s liquidity, our future retirement, our security blanket.</p><p>Yet under corrupted market structure, we little folk investors are forced to play with our cards face-up while Wall Street hides its hand behind a steel wall and priceless algorithms.</p><p>Algorithms routinely push prices down just pennies below obvious support levels to trigger retail stops, instantly converting a long-term saver’s shares into forced market sell orders at the exact bottom, transferring those shares directly into institutional hands before the price snaps back.</p><p>I’ll never forget giving our life savings to OTA. I remember asking if it was true that we can get stopped out of our positions by manipulation? They had the audacity to tell me it was a myth. That was almost fifteen years ago. Now that the cat is out of the bag, I wonder if they are still sticking to their story?</p><p>Calling this “liquidity” is just polite Wall Street language for taking money out of one pocket and putting it into another. Poor Grannie didn’t need those five shares. Besides, she only has a few years left. Our Bank needs are greater than some old woman living off of her retirement as a waitress.</p><p><strong>What other corruption is lurking behind the scenes?</strong></p><p>Activist Short Selling. It used to have some value if you had learned a company was cooking the books or lying to shareholders. It has moved way past that. Short selling is no longer just a quiet bet that a stock is overvalued. Those days are gone. It has evolved into offensive information warfare.</p><p>A firm quietly builds a massive short position (or buys put options), then publishes a sensationalized, heavily formatted report accusing the target of fraud or “Ponzi-like” behavior.</p><p>First, because modern algorithms and retail traders react instantly to headlines, the stock price crashes <em>before</em> any claim is verified. That price drop itself inflicts real financial damage,especially if the target uses its own stock as collateral for loans, triggering margin calls and forced selling.</p><p>But here’s the kicker; If a corporate executive lies to pump a stock, they go to prison. If a short seller exaggerates or uses inflammatory labels in a report covered with legal disclaimers, it is typically protected as “opinion” under the First Amendment, allowing them to pocket billions when the stock collapses.</p><p>They did this to Carl Icahn. Unlike the tight wad Buffet, Icahn was once very generous with his dividend. Icahn is is an illustration of how public short campaigns trigger an immediate regulatory pile-on.</p><p>On May 2, 2023, Hindenburg Research published its short report on IEP. Hindenburg accused Icahn Enterprises of running a “Ponzi-like” scheme and massively inflating its asset values. That headline triggered an immediate SEC investigation The very next day the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York contacted IEP demanding corporate records, followed shortly by the SEC.</p><p>Whether driven by political animosity, history will be the judge. Icahn was a prominent, vocal ally and former special advisor to Donald Trump.</p><p>(But politics would never be a part of corruption and lies. Yeah, Right!)</p><p>Launching a federal probe immediately validates the short seller’s narrative in the eyes of the market. The Trade Happened on the Shock, Not the Verdict. It didn’t matter if it was true or not, the ball was in motion.</p><p>The crushing of the stock price is in play while the investigation drags on for over a year. No evidence, just bearing false witness is enough these days.</p><p>By the time the SEC concluded its investigation in August 2024, <strong>it found zero evidence of fraud, zero asset-value inflation, and no “Ponzi-like” structure</strong>.</p><p>Icahn and IEP paid a $2 million civil penalty solely for a technical disclosure violation (failing to properly report personal margin loans pledged against his shares), and a federal judge subsequently dismissed the copycat shareholder lawsuits as meritless.</p><p>Of course he did. He had no skin in the game. But heaven would have come down had he had his portfolio tampered with.</p><p>Nevertheless, by then, over $10 billion in market value had already been wiped out, and the short sellers had already profited.</p><p>And what about the little guy like me and the everyday retail investors who owned Icahn Enterprises? We were left holding permanent losses with zero legal or regulatory compensation. Individual retirees and income investors who bought Icahn‘s’ stock or its famous $8.00 annual dividend absorbed the full brunt of the collapse.</p><p>The surrounding pattern below lets the sequence of events speak for itself without needing to speculate about whether or not politics had a part of shorting.</p><blockquote><strong>1. Carl Icahn / Icahn Enterprises (IEP) — May 2023 to August 2024</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>The Political Connection: Carl Icahn is a high-profile billionaire ally of Donald Trump who served as a special advisor to the president on regulatory reform.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>The Attack &amp; State Pile-On: On May 2, 2023, Hindenburg Research published a short report accusing IEP of operating a “Ponzi-like” structure. The very next morning — May 3 — federal prosecutors at the Southern District of New York demanded corporate records, followed by an SEC probe.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>The Outcome: Over $10 billion in shareholder value was wiped out while short sellers profited. In August 2024, the SEC closed its investigation with zero fraud charges, settling only for a $2 million paperwork penalty over personal margin-loan disclosures, and Hindenburg abruptly shut down days before Trump returned to office in January 2025.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>2. Rumble (RUM) — April 2023 to February 2024</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>The Political Connection: Rumble is a conservative-aligned video platform and prominent free-speech alternative to YouTube backed by high-profile right-leaning investors.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>The Attack &amp; State Pile-On: Just one month before the Icahn hit, activist short seller Culper Research published a report accusing Rumble of inflating user metrics, which was followed by an active SEC investigation that suppressed the stock price for nearly a year.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>The Outcome: In February 2024, the SEC quietly sent a closing letter ending the investigation without recommending any enforcement action, after retail shareholders had already absorbed months of downward pressure.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>3. Trump Media &amp; Technology Group (DJT) — March 2024 to 2025</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>The Political Connection: Majority-owned by Donald Trump and parent company of Truth Social, making it a direct financial proxy for the former and incoming president during an election cycle.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>The Attack &amp; Market Pile-On: Immediately upon going public in March 2024, DJT became the most heavily shorted SPAC merger in U.S. history and sat on Nasdaq’s Reg SHO Threshold List for persistent failures to deliver shares — prompting formal complaints from CEO Devin Nunes of potential illegal naked short selling by major market makers, alongside a $105 million disclosed short bet by quantitative fund Qube Research.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>The Outcome: Massive short pressure and delivery anomalies weighed heavily on everyday retail shareholders who bought in to support the company.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>4. Gautam Adani / Adani Group — January 2023</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>The Political Connection: Gautam Adani is India’s wealthiest industrialist and a close, longtime ally of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>The Attack &amp; Political Fallout: Four months before targeting Icahn, Hindenburg Research published a sweeping short report against Adani’s conglomerate, wiping out over $100 billion in market value within weeks.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>The Outcome: The report immediately became the primary political weapon used by Modi’s opposition in India’s Parliament to stall government business and demand federal probes, demonstrating how activist short campaigns function as cross-border political destabilizers.</strong></blockquote><p>Across every one of these cases, the playbook is identical: target a politically prominent figure, trigger a wave of short selling and regulatory headlines that crush the stock price, pocket the profits, and leave ordinary retail investors holding the bag long after the investigations quietly fizzle out.</p><p>This is not an attempt to make this about Liberal and Conservative. It is about showing the corruption in the market and how it can be used to short a companies stock without having specific proof. And the investor pays for it.</p><p>So returning to our retirement and investing, what is the incentive? Are we getting what we worked for, or are we happy with the scraps off the Market Makers table?</p><p>Why does strong business performance no longer translate into reliable stock gains? Because the physical trading floors of the past have been replaced by an electronic ecosystem engineered to extract wealth from retail participants.</p><p>How? High-Frequency Algorithms and Spoofing: Modern order books are dominated by high-frequency trading (HFT) algorithms co-located inside exchange data centers.</p><p>Tactics like spoofing and layering, where massive fake buy or sell orders appear on Level 2 screens only to vanish in milliseconds, create illusions of support and resistance designed to trap human traders and trigger their stop-losses.</p><p>Doesn’t anyone want to call this what it is? This is DECEPTION!</p><p>You are not imagining things, and I am not overstating it!</p><p>Regulators, prosecutors, and federal judges explicitly call those tactics intentional deception. And it is supposedly ILLEGAL Under Dodd-Frank (2010) called The Commodity Exchange Act (Section 4c(a)(5)©).</p><blockquote>“(5) DISRUPTIVE PRACTICES. — It shall be unlawful for any<br>person to engage in any trading, practice, or conduct on or sub-<br>ject to the rules of a registered entity that — <br>(A) violates bids or offers;<br>(B) demonstrates intentional or reckless disregard for<br>the orderly execution of transactions during the closing pe-<br>riod; or © is, is of the character of, or is commonly known to<br>the trade as, ‘‘spoofing’’ (bidding or offering with the intent<br>to cancel the bid or offer before execution).<strong>(</strong><a href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/COMPS-10309/pdf/COMPS-10309.pdf"><strong>Spoofing</strong></a>)</blockquote><p>They explicitly made it a federal felony to engage in “spoofing”. Defined legally as bidding or offering with the intent to cancel the bid or offer before execution.</p><p>The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) routinely prosecutes spoofers under federal wire fraud and commodities/securities fraud statutes, meaning the government itself classifies placing fake orders to trick other traders as <strong>theft by deception</strong>.</p><p>And yet, as long as everyone in the govt has their personal wallets and purses are fat, all is well. After all, the Law wasn’t written for the Market Makers, it was written for the REAL CRIMINALS.</p><p>Why It Still Happens Every Day Despite Being Illegal? If it is a federal crime, why do you still see fake walls appear and vanish on platforms every single day? Well you have to prove intent.</p><p>There is, after all, an “Intent” Loophole. High-frequency trading firms cancel over 95% of the orders they place. To convict someone of spoofing, prosecutors have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the algorithm <em>intended</em> to cancel the order before placing it, rather than simply “reacting to changing market conditions” a millisecond later.</p><p>Do you hear the Church Lady? How ConVeeeenient!”</p><p>If they ARE caught with their hand in the cookie jar? As I said earlier, it takes money to make money. Fines Are Just a Cost of Doing Business! It is all baked into the final blueprint.</p><p>Even when major Wall Street banks and trading firms get caught red-handed. Remember JPMorgan paying $920 million in 2020 for years of spoofing precious metals and Treasury markets, or Citadel Securities and other firms paying multi-million-dollar SEC/FINRA fines for order-handling violations? Not one senior executives went to prison, and the firms simply write a check out of their massive trading profits.</p><p>Who paid for it? The investor. But for the Market Makers? It may even be a tax write off? (<a href="https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/8260-20"><strong>CFTC Orders JPMorgan to Pay Record $920 Million for Spoofing and Manipulation</strong></a><strong>)</strong></p><p>And then there is policing at the speed of snail mail or horse-and-buggy. Regulators audit order-book data months or years after the fact, while algorithms execute millions of deceptive flickers per second. By the time a fine is issued, thousands of retail stop-losses have already been harvested.</p><p>Then there are the Dark Pools and Hidden Institutional Flow.</p><p>Vast percentages of daily stock volume execute off-exchange in private “dark pools,” shielding institutional accumulation and distribution from public view until after the move has already happened.</p><p>Unlike 1926, when shorting a stock required locating physical paper certificates, today’s market features automated stock-loan desks, leveraged ETFs, and massive derivatives markets.</p><p>Market makers who sell options contracts constantly hedge their exposure, mathematically pinning stock prices down or amplifying downward spirals regardless of a company’s fundamental health.</p><p><strong>Enter the Swindlers. The Vendors selling the elixir.</strong></p><p>Sensing retail frustration, a cottage industry of expensive scanners, flow trackers, and “smart money” indicators promises to level the playing field. In reality, these tools only show backward-looking data, never revealing whether an institutional trade was a genuine bet or a complex hedge,often draining retail capital further through monthly subscription fees.</p><p>I received an offer today. Desperate to level the playing field, everyday traders spend billions of dollars on technical indicators, options flow scanners, and dark pool trackers, believing these tools finally show where institutional buyers are sitting.</p><p>But they don’t. Even the fastest, most expensive “live” data feed on the market only reports transactions <em>after</em> they have already executed. Whether it is a moving average, a Volume Profile node, or a real-time options sweep, every indicator is strictly a record of the immediate past.</p><p>Worse yet, public data feeds never reveal <em>why</em> an institution made a trade, leaving retail investors guessing whether a massive print was a genuine bullish bet, a position closing out, or a complex hedge.</p><p>By the time a retail trader sees the signal flash on their screen, the institutions have already taken their position, and are often using those very retail buyers as exit liquidity. It’s all smoke and mirrors.</p><p>Indicator Vendors have mastered a way to make indicators the best thing since the previous one they sold us. And we have become more and more stupid in our desperation.</p><p>The previous indicator sits in the proverbial trashcan. But it took me some time to stop a bad habit. To keep subscribers paying for a new indicator every year, vendors continuously push out “Version 3.0,” new “AI/Smart Money” overlays, or fresh dashboard alerts so customers feel they are getting ongoing value and are always one update away from cracking the code.</p><p>Then we have the indicators that are sold but being constantly updated due to bugs. It never ends.</p><p>Returning to the Casualty, it is us. The everyday retirement is being manipulated and we have no say. The greatest damage of this algorithmic, derivatives-driven market isn’t just frustrated day traders; it is the erosion of faith in long-term wealth building.</p><p>Today, single stocks have become high-volatility battlegrounds where institutional algorithms can compress a company’s valuation for years at a time, punishing retail investors until emotional exhaustion forces them to sell at the bottom.</p><p>What can we do? That is where the article comes to an end. Do we just continue with “thank you sir may I have another” or is there a reasonable fight to be won? “What ifs” can be entertained. What if they didnt have access to our volatility?</p><p>I have often asked myself, what if we stopped fishing the oceans for three months? Can you imagine the fish surplus we may have? Or maybe not?</p><p>The ocean doesn’t regenerate because every boat disappears forever, it thrives when we establish protected sanctuaries and refuse to cast our nets during spawning season. The market works the exact same way. We don’t need a massive protest to starve Wall Street of our volatility, we just need to stop offering ourselves up as easy bait.</p><p>The truth is, we can do everything right. We wait for a support level, buy at the best possible price, and manage our risk. But the machines will still push price through your stop just to harvest the liquidity.</p><p>We cannot out-program them, and regulators aren’t coming to save us because they are spooning with the Market Makers.</p><p>The game is structurally rigged We don’t have a button to shut down the market for three months, and we can’t fix a broken system from a retail screen. The only real edge left is recognizing the game for what it is and hope we get some help.</p><p>You can’t change the sharks. May God grant us politicians who will stop looking out for their wallets and do the job they were elected to do. Represent the needs and wants of their constituents.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4abcae192204" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In Response to Dan Foster’s “Pastor Says You Don’t Have to Believe in the Virgin Birth.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MosheD/in-response-to-dan-fosters-pastor-says-you-don-t-have-to-believe-in-the-virgin-birth-292ab5ee3fbd?source=rss-af4a87e02b1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/292ab5ee3fbd</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Moshe D.]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Nov 2026 01:50:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-03T01:50:15.184Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>In Response to Dan Foster’s “Pastor Says You Don’t Have to Believe in the Virgin Birth. Is He Right?”</h3><h3>The Apostle Paul never mentioned it. Jesus never taught it. And the theological implications are fascinating.</h3><p>For anyone who shares his views I have laid out a case from the Bible as to the necessity of the virgin birth and why it must believed. This is a 2 Part article and I am only posting the opening to Part 1 below.</p><p>I realize you cannot respond on CARM, but if you want a to share your comments, or have a civil dialog, you are welcome to leave them here.</p><p>As Francis Schaeffer said, honest answers for honest objections. Not looney responses because you hate God or have a screw loose.</p><p>When I write argumentative essays I try to be Biblically thorough and logical in my response because I myself am criticizing the Biblical hostility, heresy and logic of another writer when they attack the Bible.</p><p>In addition, Foster made his argument rest on a conservative Christians position. Many refer to me as a Christian Jew. I am not a conservative Christian nor do I want to associate with worldly politics. Politics and moralism are pals that spoon.</p><p>My doctrines have nothing to do with anything other than what I believe about the Bible. I preach Christ and Him crucified.</p><blockquote><a href="https://carm.org/do-christians-have-to-believe-in-the-virgin-birth">Do Christians Have to Believe in the Virgin Birth? Part 1</a></blockquote><blockquote>by Moshe Daniels</blockquote><blockquote>November 02, 2026</blockquote><blockquote>15 min read</blockquote><blockquote>If Jesus is born under Adam’s condemnation, He cannot be the unblemished Lamb. Foster treats the virgin birth as optional baggage, failing to realize that without it, Christ inherits Adam’s condemnation and cannot be our sinless substitute.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/401/0*5v0G6OmDxWvS_m4D" /></figure><blockquote>In a recent Medium article, author Dan Foster reacted to comments on the virgin birth. Foster’s article was prompted by the recent resurfacing of remarks made by Adam Hamilton, a pastor currently running as a Democratic nominee for the U.S. Senate. The article was published on both Substack and Medium’s Backyard Theology publication on October 23, 2026.</blockquote><blockquote>Who is Dan Foster? Under “My Writing Journey,” “Spending many years as an educator, pastor, school teacher, and youth worker, writing took a back seat while he set about striving to attain a utopian existence that belies the reality of life.” “Dan writes especially for Church alumni and religious refugees, and those who have experienced the reality of spiritual abuse, disappointment with the church, and doubts about their faith.” <a href="https://danfosterwriter.medium.com/about"><em>(Dan Foster)</em></a></blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=292ab5ee3fbd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A response to Janet K Smith.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MosheD/a-response-to-janet-k-smith-d3913681ab37?source=rss-af4a87e02b1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d3913681ab37</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Moshe D.]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Nov 2026 22:18:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-02T22:18:20.000Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A response to Janet K Smith. PhD. Her article “10 Uncomfortable Things about Adam and Eve that <a href="https://medium.com/@janetkatherineapplebysmith/10-uncomfortable-things-about-adam-and-eve-that-christians-misunderstand-2479625e20c7">Christians Misunderstand.</a>”</p><p>As long as we have articles like this, I will always have a job.</p><p>The articles title is demeaning, and I dont see how it would add any value to the Christian’s read list.</p><p>Calling the points “Uncomfortable” is a classic rhetorical manipulation. The writer is setting a trap for us moronic Christians. If we object to her secular reinterpretation, she won’t attribute our objection to our loyalty to Scripture.</p><p>Instead, these sort of writers will claim we are just “too uncomfortable” or emotionally fragile to handle the “deep academic truths.”</p><p>It projects a sense of bravery onto the author, casting her as the courageous truth-teller willing to shatter the fragile illusions of the proverbial pew-sitters, when in reality, she is just repeating standard, centuries-old secular hostility.</p><p>One would think someone with a PhD would bring some originality to the table? Call me old fashioned but after almost 40 years this sort of nonsense is wash, rinse repeat.</p><p>Nothing in the article was uncomfortable for me personally, because nothing was true. ;-)</p><p>In addition, The phrase “that Christians Misunderstand” divides the room into two groups. In this corner we have the writer (who possesses the elite, true knowledge) and, the other corner we have the ordinary Christian reader named Bubba.</p><p>What this implies to me is that saints, theologians, apologists and regular simpletons, (the churchgoers) have been blindly stumbling around in the dark, waiting for PhD writer to finally explain the text to us.</p><p>After all, were just a bunch of hicks from WV who keep a piece of straw in our mouth all day and chew tobaccy as we flirt with our sister.</p><p>In my experience and assertive opinion, the article is an subtle attack on the Word of God. Scripture is NOT a metaphor as she implies. Perhaps she thinks the world is filled with Christians, and then the elites have to set us straight?</p><p>Can you tell this article got me agitated?</p><p>I don’t think I would have such a problem if the article was written from a garden variety pagan. I EXPECT this from them and I understand the reason why.</p><p>But this comes in the name of “Christianity.” Right? After all, she says “I wish someone had told me when I was a new Christian 60+ years ago.”</p><p>Whatever it is, is not what a Christian piece. But I certainly respect her right to communicate nevertheless.</p><p>Putting whatever motive aside, since the author claims to be a Christian? I, as a fruit inspector, I have examined the fruit of the article. The fruit is not from the vine of Jesus. The theology contained is more from the weed classification.</p><p>And in that case, God’s people have a responsibility to address it. If the person is a Christian, then good fruit will be the diet in the future. Paul told Timothy “instruct certain people to stop teaching false doctrine.” That is not a recommendation. All Christians are to confront false teaching. All Christians are to contend earnestly for the faith. If someone hears the correction then we praise Yahweh.</p><p>1 Timothy 6:3 says; “If anyone teaches false doctrine and refuses to agree with the sound words of our Lord Jesus, the Messiah, and godly teaching, he is a conceited person and does not understand anything.”</p><p>2 Timothy 3 says “They will hold to an outward form of godliness but deny its power. Stay away from such people.”</p><p>If she has the Holy Spirit, He will speak to her through His word and not metaphorically. She will adapt and she will overcome this nonsense.</p><p>And here is the other thought I always have.</p><p>It is one thing to have a concern or a doubt with a certain doctrine in one’s early stages of the walk. Many come to the Bible after years of the worlds brainwashing; and God has to deal with each one differently.</p><p>But ... It is another thing to campaign actively against the Holy Spirit as a self described Christian of 60 + years ago?</p><p>There are too many issues in this article that are wrong and misleading. I don’t have the time to respond to all of them with one of my lengthy books due to other articles, but I would like to document in writing my theological frown of disapproval. Beginning with the problem that the Bible can be sold as metaphor.</p><p>To begin, wait, another thought comes to my mind? Another great mystery is splashing around in my head. The question “why do people who have problems with the Bible and Christianity believe they are qualified to speak as God’s representatives?”</p><p>It amazes me how terms and ideas are always replaced with individual worldviews instead of leaving alone the godly worldview contained?</p><p>When I write, I want the Christian who is struggling with issues to be re-assured that God is still on the throne of their life, and that all things work together for good to those who love Him.</p><p>But when I read articles like this, how can one have comfort? Suppose you just dealt with a serious trial. Your PhD friend says to you “hang in there; all things work together for good to those who love God. …metaphorically speaking of course.”</p><p>Does the reader understand IF that happened by the literal definition of a metaphor, your “friend” would be implying that none of those words mean what they actually say on the surface?</p><p>If anyone were quote us Romans 8 then follow up with “<em>Think of this verse as a metaphor for life,”</em> they remove God from the equation, they remove the promise attached, they change the outlook to an invitation toward a mindset of hopeful interpretation. Thy may as well say “Good Luck.”</p><p>In other words, they have replaced God’s Word with a humanism. What they mean to say using Christianese is “Look, while life can be brutal and literal, WE have the power to view our struggles as chapters, as dark threads, to ensure that the pain doesn’t have the final word.”</p><p>In other words a religious Hallmark card.</p><p>I understand that metaphors are being attached to Genesis. But where is the finish line to her thinking? Where does she even draw the line when deciding what is and what is not metaphor?</p><p>The PhD is the authority behind the decision! She dictates what Book and what verse is an ancient piece of comforting literature meant to soothe the psyche, and which is not. Only she and a handful of others can tell her next reader what Book and verse comes with a guarantee it has the Holy Spirit’s stamp.</p><p>I want to put her in a Gladiator suit and say “Are you not entertained?” Why not? What hope does offer when a metaphor does the work?</p><p>Reminding struggling believers that God is sovereign, He is on the throne, and quote Romans 8 to provide an absolute promise cannot happen when an article like this is promoted.</p><p>Why say such a thing? The author is not writing to help young, wounded sheep who are having issues in the faith, offering reassurance and/or restoration, or just sheep in general who need to grow.</p><p>So WHAT IS the agenda? Is it only the PhD talking like a Jeff Dunham event? The PhD has Janet sitting on its lap? Who is the authority demoting the Word of God and calling it a metaphor</p><p>I think I am inspired to write a quick article after this. “Why Critics Claim the Identity of What They are Changing?”</p><p>Nevertheless, this is my first encounter reading an article by J. Smith. PhD. Many of these writers are very clever in their approach. I often refer to this as artistic eloquent oratory, only its on paper.</p><p>Dan Foster is another writer who is amazingly good at this. I just finished an article on CARM refuting his cleverly articulated way to dismiss the relevance of the virgin birth and call it a non essential. (my words)</p><p>The theological framework of this particular post does not line up with Christianity from the Biblical perspective, but aligns much more closely with “Christian” Progressivism, Evolutionary Creationism or Christian Deism/Mysticism than it does with Bible Doctrine.</p><p>Issues of importance are many, but I only want to address Adam and Scripture.</p><p>Section two and seven reduce Adam and Eve to figures who merely “represent” humankind or emerge from existing hominid lines. So whether it is this progressive approach, or Dr. Hugh Ross’s twisted view of a pre-Adamic world filled with “soulless hominids,” the result is the same: it compromises the biblical timeline and the perfection of the original creation.</p><p>Why not just tear out the pages you dont want and have our grandsons replace Adam with something new and exciting? Hand them a crayon and a few pieces of paper and let them go to work. It’s so comforting for me to know that after 2,000 years of the Church being bogged down by what Jesus and Paul actually said, we finally have modern writers who can step in as God’s editor-in-chief.</p><p>Though the Bible is clear that all Scripture is breathed by God and is profitable for correction, apparently there is a new sheriff in town who has the Holy Ghost of the 21st Century. “Thus Saith the Lord” to “Did God Really Say?”</p><p>When she says “Nevertheless, the creation narrative is a theological metaphor.” Let the new sheriff help explain, and define a theological metaphor. Where does she draw the line? Is it Genesis only? If it is Genesis only, how does she know that? What if another comes along and says they too had a revelation from God, but they had different instructions; they were told only Genesis 1–9 is metaphor.</p><p>What do you do? Eenie Meenie Miney Moe, this book stays but that one goes?</p><p>I have already written on this issue with those followers of C.S. Lewis. The Roman Catholic who was also confused about metaphors and the Book of Job.</p><p>What about the New Testament? Metaphor? Where do you draw the line? At what point does this begin and end?</p><p>In Section 1 the author writes “<strong><em>Nor does it suggest that the narrative is just a human story that we can ignore. I believe it is inspired, sacred, and authoritative. Jesus quoted Genesis. Nevertheless, the creation narrative is a theological metaphor.</em></strong>”</p><p>What’s the problem? The Apostle Paul did not view Genesis as a metaphor. In fact, the entire logic of the Gospel relies on Adam being a real, historical person.Other wise you now tamper with the gospel! Is that the agenda behind this strategy?</p><p>In Romans 5:12–19, Paul explicitly links the literal reality of Adam to the literal reality of Jesus: “For as by one man’s disobedience many were made sinners, so by one man’s obedience many will be made righteous.”</p><p>1. If Adam is a metaphor, then the Fall is a metaphor.</p><p>2. If the Fall is a metaphor, then original sin is a metaphor.</p><p>3. If our ruin in Adam is just a literary symbol, then our redemption in Christ becomes a metaphor, too.</p><p>Again, “<strong><em>Nor does it suggest that the narrative is just a human story that we can ignore. I believe it is inspired, sacred, and authoritative. Jesus quoted Genesis. Nevertheless, the creation narrative is a theological metaphor.</em></strong>”</p><p>This is what we call “double speak.” It does two things? It pulls in the Christian’s ear, i.e., it uses Christianese: familiar, orthodox buzzwords (“inspired,” “sacred,” “authoritative” blah, blah blah) as a Trojan horse.</p><p>It makes the reader feel safe, lowering their defenses so they keep reading. After all,”how can one refer to the Bible as authoritative and not be religious? Heretics would never use our language.”</p><p>Yes, they Would and Do!</p><p>And the other thing I see it doing simultaneously? It is introducing a sort of secretive or clever criticism, i.e. once the Christian or moralist has dropped their guard, once inside, it quietly dismantles the historical foundation of the faith, acting as a stealth attack on the Gospel.</p><p>Reader, did you follow the argument when she said “<strong><em>Nevertheless, the creation narrative is a theological metaphor.</em></strong>” Did you stop there or follow the logic? “Saying ‘I believe Genesis is inspired and authoritative, nevertheless it’s a metaphor’ is like telling your spouse, ‘I completely trust you and believe you are faithful, nevertheless I hired a private investigator because your track record is not believable.</p><p>We dont trust God, and He doesn’t even have the courtesy of a Trust But Verify?</p><p>This is the classic “artistic, eloquent oratory” mentioned above. This author has reduced Biblical authority to metaphor. It’s the pea and shell game. The author is saying Genesis is “authoritative” BUT…… that does NOT mean it tells us the historical truth about what God actually did.</p><p>It is fools gold for the Christian, but probably a shot in the arm for someone that hates God.</p><p>For many like this, Genesis is authoritative for teaching a moral, monotheistic worldview, but completely untrustworthy for history or science. The author acknowledges that “Jesus quoted Genesis” and quotes Paul in Romans 5:14. Yet, then argues that we must “redefine what Genesis, Paul, and Jesus meant by ‘death.’”</p><p>This is gobbley gook nonsense. Who has become the authority? She Has! Science has. The Humanist has.</p><p>By declaring that we cannot “ignore scientific realities” (Section 2) and citing secular anthropology about pelvis evolution (Section 9), the author sets up modern science as the actual supreme authority.</p><p>For the humanist, this is the standard. Whenever historic biblical doctrine clashes with modern secular consensus, the text must bend, twist, or be redefined. Did God Say?</p><p>When you adopt this framework, it isn’t just Genesis that turns into a metaphor, the entire Bible becomes a domino effect of shifting symbols.</p><p>If you follow their logic to its natural conclusion, the border between literal truth and metaphor shifts based on subjective boundaries. Based upon who has more PhD clout.</p><p>Progressive theologians argue that we only allegorize the text when “modern science” proves the literal narrative impossible. I’m off course, but this is why Scientists argue with one another. It isn’t about truth and facts, it is about worldviews. And then Biblical leftovers can be applied.</p><p>Does the reader see what has happened? the final authority has been taken from God and given to man. But secular science doesn’t just stop at Genesis 1–11. This nonsense has happened with many doctrines.</p><p>The Resurrection of Jesus Christ must be a metaphor because according to medical science, a brain-dead corpse undergoing rigor mortis does not spontaneously reanimate and walk out of a tomb after three days.</p><p>If science is the ultimate judge of what is historically real in the Bible, then a consistent thinker is forced to look at the empty tomb and say, “Well, dead people staying dead is a scientific reality. Therefore, the Resurrection must just be a beautiful theological metaphor about hope rising from despair.”</p><p>It’s the liberal “pastor” who is holding a worship service telling the congregation, We know that Jesus rose bodily from the Dead as he mutters under his breath “in our hearts.” This is the logical destination of this entire worldview.</p><p>Any one asked the author about the bodily resurrection? The Apostle Paul addressed this exact consistency in 1 Corinthians 15:14, 17: “And if Christ has not been raised, our preaching is useless and so is your faith… you are still in your sins.” Paul did not say, “If Christ has not been raised, don’t worry, we still have a beautiful metaphor about hope rising from despair.” He said your faith is useless.</p><p>Does she believe? Say for the sake of argument she says yes? At what point can this be changed to a metaphor?</p><p>Again, if you tweak this doctrine you tweak the gospel. The resurrection is the proof that propitiation was made, the sins of God’s people have been paid for and God’s forensic declaration of condemnation has been removed and replaced with justification.</p><p>Can you imagine someone quoting Romans 8 and reading it as Therefore, there is now, metaphorically, no condemnation for those who are in union with the Messiah Jesus.</p><p>I mentioned this in my refutation of Dan Foster’s article. Please, go and read it and see how he dismantles the authority of the Scripture. See how he explains away the virgin birth like a child who removes vegetables off their dinner plate and puts it in their pocket to be tossed out later.</p><p>All the while suggesting there is nothing wrong, in and of itself if his reader wants to believe it. It is a masterclass in double-speak.</p><p>Confused readers must understand the bigger picture. Many of these writers use orthodox words to retain their “Christian credentials” while stripping words of all historic meaning.</p><p>The tragedy for many readers is that many of these progressive writers gives the appearance that they are preserving the Bible for God’s people, but they are actually performing a clever bait and switch.</p><p>Ultimately, when I write, I defend the faith in so far as God has given me the ability. My intent in writing is preservation, defense and proclamation of the gospel God.</p><p>But their intent is often the flavor of the day. Evolution and adaptation based on human consensus. Because they view the text as a human product rather than a divine one, they feel perfectly qualified to reshape it in their own image. As I always say, they make the Bible a wax nose to be re-shaped as human desire dictates.</p><p>Section nine rejects the idea that we are “sinful creatures in a broken world” because of Eve’s decisions.</p><p>And this is what got my attention above and beyond all of the other parts of the article. The Implication? If Adam was not a literal historical head who legally plunged humanity into condemnation then there is no universal “legal debt” for humans to be forensically cleared of.</p><p>This is the point I am bringing out in my series of articles on Mar Mari. When I wrote the mirror of Adam I explained this is an inverted mirror. There is a reason the Messiah is called the Last Adam in contrast to the First Adam. Is Jesus a metaphor? You cannot have one without the other. It is a package deal.</p><p>Just as Adam’s legal guilt was imputed to us, Christ’s legal righteousness is imputed to us (the “active obedience” of Christ)</p><p>In addition, It destroys most of the Book of Romans and specifically Romans 5.</p><p>I said I would keep this short, and I’m trying. My articles always take a defensive position on the gospel. Gospel nuggets are always included.</p><p>When another writer tells a Christian what is and is not true about Adam, this is never something to brush off. Without Adam there is no gospel.</p><p>And by the way, forensic condemnation/justification is always a hill worth dying on. In the above articles, she systematically dismantles the legal and historical reality of the Fall. The article pulls the rug out from under the entire forensic framework.</p><p>When all is said and done, one of the most attacked doctrines in the Bible is forensic justification. Humanists wearing a “Christian” mask, will never cease to dilute, derange destroy, this doctrine.</p><p>Once Biblical authority is tampered with, you know longer have the Word of God, you have a comic book for the religious.</p><p>O please do share your thoughts as to why this article in question is meant to offer hope?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d3913681ab37" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is Mar Mari Emmanuel’s gospel?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MosheD/what-is-mar-mari-emmanuels-gospel-22f4cf1715ea?source=rss-af4a87e02b1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/22f4cf1715ea</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Moshe D.]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Oct 2026 21:14:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-24T21:15:17.762Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I have already written on this topic, but I decided to redo the entire structure as a series of articles because of his influence on social media.</p><p>Too many Protestants are either confused or ignorant about his “message.”</p><p>And before continuing, lest someone take offense to that term, again (as they did in a previous article), let me explain that “ignorant” is a simple way to communicate or describe an issue or topic that someone is not familiar with.</p><p>Saying “You are ignorant” sounds to most people like saying “You are stupid” or “You are uncultured. Isn’t it ironic that the people who frequently use it themselves to mean “stupid,” “rude,” or “mean,” are fulfilling its definition because they ignore its actual definition?</p><p>No, it does not mean the above. By definition, “ignorant” simply means a person is lacking knowledge or information about a particular subject.</p><p>I have long contended that many “Christians” sitting in the pews of local visible churches do not know the gospel. Just because they heard a “gospel” and responded does not mean they are aware of the Biblical gospel.</p><p>They lack required information: what the gospel is and is not. John 3:16 has become a bumper sticker sentence, made into a common cliché.</p><p>John 3:16 is not the gospel. Acts 2:38 is not the gospel. It is a summary snippet of the gospel, but it does not contain the details needed to be saved.</p><p>( I will explain this further in the series of articles to come)</p><p>So when a moralist gets their feathers ruffled in hearing the term “ignorant,” please stop. I want to use the line in The Princess Bride where Inigo Montoya said, “I do not think that word means what you think it means.”</p><p>This concludes the lesson on ignorance.</p><p>I admit that when I sat down and wrote the first article on Medium as it flowed through my thinking. I went hog wild when it came to information overload. I took the reader in different directions.</p><p>Did the additional information play a part? I believe it helped to make a larger argument through the many attachments. But it was identifying information without remedy.</p><p>And while Mar Mari does carry in his theological backpack a great number of theological problems, he alone is not the problem per se, but a messenger of a larger historical heresy that implies a man can work out their salvation through a works righteous system.</p><p>NOBODY will be saved who is inside or under a teaching that says we must add to the Messiah’s work. He doesn’t need our work. Our work is described as menstrual clothes. His life completed the mission spoken of in Isaiah 52–53.</p><p>So, instead of extending the biography of Mar Mari (which was dealt with in part 1), the remaining series of articles will address forensic justification and the need to understand what it means in the light of Romans 5.</p><p>We don’t necessarily want to learn about Mar Mari; rather, we want to identify his corrupted gospel message and address the sacramental system behind the message he teaches.</p><p>He is not the only one to push a system that implies men must become a part of the salvation experience, but one of hundreds who teach the same corrupted “gospel.</p><p>I realize many will not be in a hurry to find out about this subject, but it is done in the hopes that those who evangelize may have stronger convictions about Adam and the role he plays in the gospel message.</p><p>And it will certainly help someone struggling with their salvation!<br>If you are not familiar with forensic justification, I do hope I will be able to demonstrate a Biblical truth that has been attacked by non-Christians playing at Christianity for hundreds and hundreds of years.</p><p>It isn’t just Rome and the Eastern Orthodox who distort the gospel message using a sacramental application; it is over 90 percent of those claiming to be Christians.</p><p>Once you understand the forensic declaration of justification, you will understand why God can keep His promise of eternal life as a gift.</p><p>You will understand that assurance rests upon the court and not us.I promise, once you understand what it means, your love for the Son of God will grow as mine did.</p><p>Once you embrace the language of the court, your salvation will not waver on a work’s system you may have been exposed to.</p><p>When a saint understands and embraces the language of the heavenly court, you will rejoice to hear the words of Paul when he wrote, “Who will bring a charge against God’s elect? God is the one who justifies; who is the one who condemns? Christ Jesus is He who died, yes, rather who was raised, who is at the right hand of God, who also intercedes for us. “…who can bring a charge against you…”</p><p>Let me share an example of what I will be writing so Christians can better understand the gospel; In that Scripture above, Romans 8 has three specific words implying courtroom jargon.</p><p>Egkaleo, dikaioō, and katakrinō. <br>Egkaleo: the prosecutor filing the formal indictment.<br>Dikaioo: the judge delivering the official verdict of absolute acquittal.<br>Katakrino: the judge passing the sentence of guilt.</p><p>All three Greek words not only share, they imply forensic terminology. <br>What is forensics? It makes some of us think of NCIS and Abby having a Caf- Pow, yes?</p><p>What does that term mean, and how is it used in theology?<br>What they have in common is that they are courtroom in nature. Meaning they describe actions that take place within a formal judicial proceeding.</p><p>It is not that the police pick up evidence; it is not that they work their magic in the police lab; it is information and evidence used in the courtroom. <br>It is the trial itself.</p><p>Words like Egkaleo, dikaioō, and katakrinō only function once the evidence has been brought into the courtroom setting, the docket is open, and the legal authorities are formally speaking.</p><p>All of this leads to the final product, which is the forensic declaration. <br>Forensics occurs when the evidence becomes a reality.</p><p>This happens every day in life. When a judge says, “I pronounce you husband and wife,” or “I sentence you to life,” or “You are acquitted,” it is that declaration that instantly changes the person’s legal status.</p><p>You do not slowly become the spouse in the eyes of the Law.</p><p>O.J was not made “not guilty”, he was declared “not guilty.”</p><p>The moment the gavel falls, the person is no longer a defendant; they are legally a free citizen or a condemned prisoner.</p><p>It is NOT transitional in nature. Because a forensic declaration is a legal status, it cannot happen in stages. A person cannot be “partially acquitted” or “gradually justified.”</p><p>Just as Adam did not slowly become a condemned man over 930 years, a believer does not slowly become a justified person through a lifetime of good behavior. We are not partially saved or saved for 50 years.</p><p>The declaration is a single, definitive entry into the court’s ledger. It is 100% complete the exact second the Judge issues the verdict.</p><p>For mankind, the gavel has already been pounded on the desk outside of this sphere. The charges were dependent on external authority.</p><p>Why is this important? Because it REMOVES any attempt to make the status one that rests on man’s works or efforts. We cannot justify ourselves,, nor can we condemn ourselves, by our wills.</p><p>For a religion to set itself up with remedies, and make us the ones to work in order to become “justified” in the future, is not a travesty; it is monstrous.</p><p>Justification is handled in the heavenly court, and the court alone.</p><p>Where did the charges come from? In Genesis 3, God designed a blueprint, a structural foundation for the entire biblical courtroom model used throughout Scripture.</p><p>God is the Prosecutor, Judge, and Heavenly Supreme Court Judge when dealing with Adam.</p><p>God warned Adam, On the day you eat of the one tree I commanded you not to eat, you shall die.</p><p>As I mention in the Mar Mari article, Adam lived to 930 years of age. When was death applied?</p><p>Adam died the moment the fruit was eaten. How do we know this? Because he looked for leaves to cover himself and his gal. He immediately realized death had come.</p><p>Did he fall over and croak at that moment? A stroke or destructive bolt of lightning? No! It was charged to his spiritual account.</p><p>This is the exact moment that not only Adam inherited the status of condemnation, but because he was our federal head, humanity also inherited a status of condemnation.</p><p>When you read John 3, you read this language. “He who believes in Him is not judged; he who does not believe has been judged already, because he has not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God.</p><p>John first says if we exercise faith in the work of the Son of God (based upon the work of another credited to the account of the believer) the Judge permanently deletes the charges from our account. They are changed from Condemned to Justified.</p><p>But the opposite currently stands as our status; based upon the work of another credited to the account of all persons. We are currently identified in Adam, or in union with Adam. You can thank him for this mess.</p><p>But if we do not put our faith in His Son’s work, we don’t have to move a muscle here on earth and commit a sin to our name. John 3:18 uses the courtroom language that completely demolishes the idea of a future, behavioral life or trial.</p><p>Whoever believes in him is not condemned, but whoever does not believe has already been condemned, because he has not believed in the name of God’s unique Son.</p><p>Using the language of the courtroom, we have already been judged. It has been fully completed in the past, with ongoing, permanent legal results in the present.</p><p>None of this happened in time or through realization, or because Adam began a moral decline. It was an objective declaration made by a legal authority. In this case, the Judge of all the earth.</p><p>God was the one who brought the charge and credited/imputed/reckoned it to Adam’s account. And it remains in that account unless the Judge pounds the gavel in our individual cases a second time.</p><p>Adam did not change, but his official “status” changed. He is a condemned man. It is not a transition.</p><p>This is how Paul can help God’s people understand the First Adam and the Last Adam as explained in Romans 5 as he demonstrates the courtroom model fulfilled.</p><p>This IS the gospel and this is why eternal security can never rest on the works of a man. The can be no future grace or future salvation based on this Biblical blueprint/design.</p><p>In the CARM article, I slowly introduce the reader to the question “why” we should use Adam to help us understand forensic imputation. More in time if the Lord does not come back. Maranatha</p><p>Inside the CARM article, it says;</p><blockquote>“How relevant is Adam to the gospel message?</blockquote><blockquote>As this is explained, the reader will better understand that it is always important to find out what a person believes about Adam.</blockquote><blockquote>“What a person believes about the “first Adam” determines what they believe about the “last Adam.” That is why it is always worth addressing any teacher or pastor making disciples.</blockquote><blockquote>The author is encouraging the reader to use Adam as a diagnostic.</blockquote><blockquote>Because the two are structurally bound, where someone lands on Adam tells us where they’ll land on the gospel. Adam is one of those load-bearing beliefs where the answer reveals the whole structure.</blockquote><blockquote>Using Adam as a Biblical diagnostic is not a way to look down on anyone, nor is it about winning a point; it is about locating exactly where the gospel needs to be made clear. It is an opportunity to clarify the gospel, to find where the misunderstanding lies, and to answer it with the truth.” (<a href="https://carm.org/what-is-mar-maris-gospel">https://carm.org/what-is-mar-maris-gospel</a>)</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=22f4cf1715ea" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In response to “Original Sin is Not Old Testament Doctrine” By Richard DellaValle.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MosheD/in-response-to-original-sin-is-not-old-testament-doctrine-by-richard-dellavalle-9931acb6f2d7?source=rss-af4a87e02b1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9931acb6f2d7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Moshe D.]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 09 Oct 2026 15:46:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-09T15:46:19.141Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>He writes in part ”According to the biblical account, Adam ate some fruit from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. Christians, particularly Catholics, call this act “Original Sin,” whereby humanity was condemned and banished to Hell due to that heinous conduct. But why should there be such an anti-Old Testament (OT) policy? Why should you or I suffer for Adam’s sin? According to the Old Testament, every person is responsible for their own conduct.…Christianity, the <em>religion of guilt</em>, teaches that the curse of Adam deals with God’s eternal rejection of people because He decided that all people are depraved and immoral, even from birth, due to the sin of Adam.…Does the Old Testament have a teaching comparable to “original sin” in the Christian tradition? The answer is NO. The Church’s teachings on this doctrine are averse to the Torah’s and its prophets’ core principles. The Torah loudly condemns the outlandish teaching that man cannot freely choose good over evil, <a href="https://medium.com/@richdellavalle6/original-sin-is-not-old-testament-doctrine-959e9dc91ee8">life over death…</a>”</blockquote><p>In response to “Why should you or I suffer for Adam’s sin,” that will be covered in a future article on CARM and probably a secondary article will appear on Medium. I am going to take 300 pages and reduce it tremendously.</p><p>Dear Richard;</p><p>Once again, the “pen” distorts truth as it seeks a personal agenda. But then again, there is the possibility of common confusion brought about by mental gymnastics due to fighting internally in a desire and pursuit to make the Bible mold to our ideas?</p><p>In other words, mankind trying to make their humanist circle fit into God’s square. And try as we may, when we find it cant work to our advantage or even in general, we attack the Bible before we admit defeat or an acknowledgment that it can’t be done. After all, “hat in hand” before God would be crazy, right?</p><p>Either way, many people have wrestle through these teachings as both religious and as non believers, which most certainly have and do, cause pain, grief and heart burn because they stand against our pride.</p><p>As previously argued in many of my articles, a non Christian is unable to identify Bible doctrine because the Spirit of God is not in them. 1 Corinthians 2 explains how such a person can come to the Bible and scratch their head. What they end up is with a system that cannot make system.</p><p>Not to change the subject, but you must understand the Bible presents a picture. It is done through what we call progressive revelation. In time, God’s people were able to take the pieces of the puzzle and place it on the board of life.</p><p>Thus, we don’t read the Old Testament as if it is one section of instruction and the New Testament as if it is a completely different section for instruction. It was because of nonsense that we now have two different “Testaments.”</p><p>The Bible is one Encyclopedia of 66 Books. You cannot understand the one without the other. They don’t just compliment each other, they are to be read collectively as a necessity.</p><p>As the Book of Hebrews explains; “God, having spoken in former times in fragmentary and varied fashion to our forefathers by the prophets, has in these last days spoken to us by a Son whom he appointed to be the heir of everything and through whom he also made the universe. He is the reflection of God’s glory and the exact likeness of his being, and he holds everything together by his powerful word. After he had provided a cleansing from sins, he sat down at the right hand of the Highest Majesty and became as much superior to the angels as the name he has inherited is better than theirs.”</p><p>As John Gill wrote “The best last is ever God’s rule. “Thou hast kept the best wine until now.” Prophets are a very blessed means of communication, but how much more sure, how much more condescending is it for God to speak to us by his Son!”</p><p>The Jewish Scriptures were a shadow. You walk into a dark room allowing only the light from the doorway to enter and you see only the shadow of things everywhere. When the Son of God arrived, He turned on the lights so everything is now visible and we see it with our own eyes. Nothing was added and the same story is told. The only difference is the light exposes everything.</p><p>This is why the Bible speaks of light. We no longer bump into things theologically. The people living in darkness have seen a great light, and for those living in the land and shadow of death, a light has risen. John says of the Messiah, “This was the true light that enlightens every person by his coming into the world.”</p><p>As Hebrews 10 says “ For the Law, since it has only a shadow of the good things to come and not the very form of things, can never, by the same sacrifices which they offer continually year by year, make perfect those who draw near.”</p><p>All prophets were a shadow of One Prophet to come; all priests were a shadow of One Priest to come. They painted a picture for God’s people to understand what to expect in the future.</p><p>The Messiah fulfills two distinct functions; Communication between God and man, and Representation between man and God. The prophet speaks from God to the people while the priest intercedes between the people to God. In broader theology, this dual role expands into a threefold role. Prophet, Priest, and King.</p><p>Together, the Messiah completely covers every aspect required to reconcile humanity with God. This was the reason we don’t isolate Psalm 23 without understanding Psalm 22 and 24. We cant have only the good shepherd. We must also have the priest and the king to identify who He is. Thus, these three Psalms speak as a trilogy. Theologians summarize them sequentially as tracking the Messiah’s journey from the Cross, Psalm 22, to Crook (the shepherd’s staff) Psalm 23, to Crown, Psalm 24.</p><p>I take the time to briefly address this because a New Testament without an Old is incomplete just as an Old Testament without a New is incomplete. Isolating a doctrine in one section without consulting the other section is a grave mistake.</p><p>Telling the world “Original Sin is Not Old Testament Doctrine” is either agenda driven or ignorance. Either a person hates a specific doctrine because it does not have a place in his or her worldview, or the person is uneducated.</p><p>But the latter begs the question; how does a person understand the gospel unless they understand what the gospel is for? Saved, but from what?</p><p>If Adam has nothing to do with mankind’s condition, someone need talk to Paul because he took the time to explain Adam’s role in the Explanation of theology section.</p><p>“Romans 5:12–19, Just as sin entered the world through one man, and death resulted from sin, therefore everyone dies, because everyone has sinned. <br>Certainly sin was in the world before the Law was given, but no record of sin is kept when there is no Law. <br>Nevertheless, death ruled from the time of Adam to Moses, even over those who did not sin in the same way Adam did when he disobeyed. He is a foreshadowing of the one who would come. <br>But God’s free gift is not like Adam’s offense. For if many people died as the result of one man’s offense, how much more have God’s grace and the free gift given through the kindness of one man, Jesus the Messiah, been showered on many people! <br>Nor can the free gift be compared to what came through the man who sinned. For the sentence that followed one man’s offense resulted in condemnation, but the free gift brought justification, even after many offenses. <br>For if, through one man, death ruled because of that man’s offense, how much more will those who receive such overflowing grace and the gift of righteousness rule in life because of one man, Jesus the Messiah! <br>Consequently, just as one offense resulted in condemnation for everyone, so one act of righteousness results in justification and life for everyone. <br>For just as through one man’s disobedience many people were made sinners, so also through one man’s obedience many people will be made righteous.ISV</p><p>1 Corinthians 15:45–49, “ This, indeed, is what is written: “The first man, Adam, became a living being.” The last Adam became a life-giving spirit. <br>The spiritual does not come first, but the physical does, and then comes the spiritual. The first man came from the dust of the earth; the second man came from heaven. Those who are made of the dust are like the man from the dust; those who are heavenly are like the man who is from heaven. Just as we have borne the likeness of the man who was made from dust, we will also bear the likeness of the man from heaven.”</p><p>So what is the author doing? He says “Original Sin is Not Old Testament Doctrine.” This is common for people who want to see a doctrine or do not want to see a doctrine.</p><p>But whatever the reason, whether because of hostility or to ensure a false religion has standing, notice he sets the conditions for the argument. He says original sin is not Old Testament doctrine.</p><p>As a parallel, it is no different than a false religion creating a doctrine in the absence of details. For example, Catholic apologists often point out that the Bible never records Mary committing a sin.</p><p>When I have asked Catholics, “Where in the Bible does it say Mary was sinless?” The Catholic often responds by ignoring the immediate question and asks me “Well, where in the Bible does it say Mary ever sinned?”</p><p>This is how a straw man argument works in theology. Create a doctrine, knock it down and claim victory. What they do is separate the “Label” from the “Reality.” The error of this particular straw man is conflating a modern theological filing label with the Biblical data itself.</p><p>I promised myself not to go into this, but let me just say this. Imagine someone arguing that the solar system didn’t exist before Copernicus because the specific term “solar system” wasn’t used yet?</p><p>Latin is the language of Rome so I try not to use it. The Bible is written in Hebrew, Aramaic and Greek. That should satisfy us in and of itself. Thus, the Old Testament doesn’t use the Latinized term “Original Sin.,”</p><p>Nevertheless, it explicitly describes the universal pandemic of inherited human brokenness, spiritual death, and a corrupted nature. When I was on PalTalk, I had argued with a Jewish man about this very thing. He had never had someone take him through the Tanakh and collectively prove Bible texts detailing our condition.</p><p>My article on the Mirror of Adam explains the difference between moralism and salvation. I use the terms Source and Symptom. Others call it Cause and Effect, Condition and Position. What is important is not identifying the terms of a doctrine as much as understanding the details of a doctrine.</p><p>For many, these are semantic word games. They are done when a person does not ant to deal with the actual, undeniable gravity of the Old Testament’s view of human corruption. If a person rejects a biblical doctrine simply because its formal theological name isn’t found in the text, they have to throw out almost all of theology.</p><p>So returning to why people cannot understand this doctrine or other pertinent doctrines provided in the Bible?</p><p>A person who isn’t spiritual doesn’t accept the things of God’s Spirit, for they are nonsense to him. He can’t understand them because they are spiritually evaluated. Psuchikos is an interesting word because it defines the nature of man. “ the principal of animal life, which men have in common with the brutes.”</p><p>Wuest Expanded Translations reads like this; “But the unregenerate man of the highest intellectual attainments does not grant access to the things of the Spirit of God, for to him they are folly, and he is not able to come to know them because they are investigated in a spiritual realm.”</p><p>The psuchikos man is the unregenerate man. In contrast to the pneumatikos. This is the renewed man, born from above by the Spirit of God.</p><p>Psuchikos is the heart of mans condition which is most certainly linked to Adam’s nature. It explains the spiritual blindness and inability of a person who does not have the Holy Spirit. But where does it tie back to? That must be the adventure of the Christian to connect the dots of theological positions taught in the Bible.</p><p>I am not sure how much more this can be explained. I know this; the mind that focuses on human nature is hostile toward God. It refuses to submit to the authority of God’s Law because it is powerless to do so. Indeed, those who are under the control of human nature cannot please God</p><p>You think it is a coincidence that 99% of the religious on the planet, past, present and future, use a Bible to distort truth or deny Bible doctrine, but I assure you this is taught in the Bible just as sure as Adam’s sin imputed to all of mankind is also taught</p><p>Or, maybe like others, you are the best thing since sliced bread to come on the scene to tell the world you have proof this doctrine is not Bible doctrine? And you dont think this has already been addressed time and time again?</p><p>This is not new. The very first instances of people explicitly denying the impact of Adam’s sin (long before Pelagius) came from the Gnostics and early dualist heretics in the 2nd and 3rd centuries, such as the followers of Marcion, Valentinus, and later Mani aka the the Manichaeans.</p><p>Classical Greek pagan philosophy fundamentally rejected and attacked the concept of Adamic sin. But they did so by critiquing its core premises rather than using the straw man of original sin.</p><p>Well, that’s OK because the Bible has already explained why this happens time and time again.</p><p>One of two things have taken place. Either those who take this approach are non believers who thinks the Bible is a wax nose that they can change according to their humanism OR, as Peter said, a religious person who will take the Bible and put it on a rack to distort it?</p><p>Ever watched Braveheart? Remember Mel Gibson placed on the table in the end of the movie? As he had his limbs stretched out by ropes using pulleys? Peter wrote that ignorant and unstable people “distort” the writings of Paul and the rest of the Scriptures.</p><p>2 Peter 3 “He speaks about this subject in all his letters. Some things in them are hard to understand, which ignorant and unstable people distort, leading to their own destruction, as they do the rest of the Scriptures.”</p><p>Isnt that fascinating as he describes people that have access to a Bible and do this very thing? He uses the Greek verb streblousin, (from the word Strebloo) which comes from a root word meaning a windlass or torture rack used to stretch and twist a person’s body. Metaphorically, we would say it is one who wrests or tortures language in a false sense.</p><p>Nevertheless, since the moralist or the religionist is not able to understand a doctrine identified in the Bible, everything tis a magic show where they stand on stage with a long cape and a long hat and a rabbit. Instead of making a rabbit disappear, they take a Bible doctrine, a necessity for God’s people to understand their positions before a holy God, and they make it disappear.</p><p>Many think that the doctrine of original sin is like a parlor trick that can disappear because a non Christians says it isn’t there. The magician says “here is your original sin, *POOF* nothing is brought out of the hat.</p><p>The good news is God’s people understand how this doctrine many deny is identified in the New Testament AND the Old Testament. Non Christians don not like this doctrine because it is the foundation to the question why does God send people to hell without us lifting a finger.</p><p>I already wrote my book The Mirror of Adam, but it is not easily found, so, I am also writing an article as we speak explaining the mirror so God’s people understand original sin is most certainly identified in the Scriptures.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9931acb6f2d7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bringing goats into the sheep pen. The unseen danger among God’s people.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MosheD/bringing-goats-into-the-sheep-pen-the-unseen-danger-among-gods-people-0df2086a6b21?source=rss-af4a87e02b1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0df2086a6b21</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Moshe D.]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 08 Sep 2026 00:32:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-08T00:32:29.673Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>What are the reasons for an unholy mixture? What food is put out for the moralist goat?</h3><p>How about I take multiple subjects that address the state of today’s visible church and go for it? An article sure to upset 95 percent of “Christian” readers.</p><p>People preach a false gospel for many reasons, including financial greed, a desire for power, deep self-deception, and, truth be told, let’s not overlook real people being moved by demonic influences.</p><p>If you take the time to go through the Bible and write down reasons for deception, they stare you in the face throughout. 1 and 2 Timothy alone contain dozens.</p><p>It can be said that almost every prophet and apostle warned of false doctrine. God incarnate said, “Watch out that no one deceives you,” yet, in the light of the numerous false “gospels” (used to bring about conversions), His words of warning are not truly being considered, are they?</p><p>I am not implying that every person under a false gospel defaults to the status of non-Christian for their entire lives. But it can’t be easy for them emotionally! Many professing Christians do become possessing Christians.</p><p>I don’t have to tell you the value of discipleship. If “converts” were addressed through follow-up and discipleship, could many of these false conversions be changed to true conversion early on? Only God knows. Instead, they are sent on their way as the “counselor” tells them to read the gospel of John and find a place to worship, never to be seen again.</p><p>As a result, I have witnessed much flip-flopping in the lives of these “converts”. Either they jump from denomination to denomination, or they are back at the altar call again and again. And generally speaking, because there was no discipleship, no follow-up after “receiving Christ,” many of those I speak of often slide into false doctrine due to shifts in isolation, emotional vulnerability, intellectual pride, or cultural pressure rather than an overnight rejection of their faith. There are so many variables.</p><p>You must remember that when the Jews converted in the 1st Century, they had a foundation. In contrast, when a person enters the visible church today with no religious history and absolutely no theological foundation, they depend on the initial “gospel” pitch to be true.</p><p>I will address this later on. Romans was written for this purpose. To help fill in the blanks of their newfound faith. Because they have no rooted understanding of what qualifies as genuine Christianity, they possess no immune system against deception.</p><p>Using currency as an example, you cannot identify a counterfeit bill if you have never seen the genuine. Suppose a person from the United States takes a trip to Finland. They have never been outside of the USA. If someone hands them a stack of local bank notes, and they have absolutely zero prior knowledge of what a real Euro looks like, they have no way of knowing if they are holding genuine wealth or worthless monopoly money. They will trust whatever the first person in Helsinki hands them, completely defenseless against a scam.</p><p>The same is true with Christianity. What do they look for? What do they draw from? With no knowledge of the Bible, they may be attracted to the influencer? Or perhaps the loudest, most charismatic personality coming across as some authority?</p><p>Or what about the person with apocalyptic desires? Quick example? Suppose you turn on the TV and, as you watch, you see him walking you through the events of Revelation? You are intrigued by his Bible knowledge and what authority the message is wrapped in. You note that the man is professional, appears to have good conduct, etc.</p><p>You wait until the end and see they are called Tomorrow’s World. Produced and sponsored by the Living Church of God. You say to yourself, “Well, they did use a Bible, and they spoke Bibleese; they must be Christians.”</p><p>You have no idea of their previous history. The original program was started in 1934 by Herbert W. Armstrong under the Radio Church of God (later the Worldwide Church of God) and ran for decades on radio and television. You have no idea they deny many Christian doctrines, such as the triune nature of God. Equally important is that they deny the very thing that God uses to save a sinner.</p><p>The premise of this article is that false gospels are used to convert, bringing goats into the sheep pen. The gospel hinges on what is called Forensic justification: the belief that God legally declares a sinner righteous because the flawless righteousness of Jesus Christ is credited (imputed) to them through faith alone, entirely apart from their subsequent obedience. This is covered later in the article, but in the meantime, I wanted to provide a working example of what I am talking about.</p><p>What you are hearing on the TV show is found above in one or several of the examples. Bringing about a hybrid gospel. So you can see how we have converts resulting from religious marketing gimmicks through the nonsense of religious personalities. They will never be able to identify a fraud.</p><p>And through these false teachers and such, they are still brought into the visible church to mix and mingle with God’s people. And then it begins. The moment they encounter false doctrine or basic human hypocrisy, the entire house of cards collapses, sending them straight into skepticism.</p><p>And isn’t that already addressed in the parable of the weeds? These peddlers of smooth words and easy promises give converts a temporary emotional high. There is no doubt that many receive the message “with joy,” but for only a time. The superficial faith cannot survive contact with reality.</p><p>Luke 8:11–15, “Now the parable is this: the seed is the word of God. “And those beside the road are those who have heard; then the devil comes and takes away the word from their heart, so that they will not believe and be saved. “And those on the rock are those who, when they hear, receive the word with joy, and these have no root; they believe for a while, and in time of temptation fall away. “And the seed which fell among the thorns, these are the ones who have heard, and as they go on their way they are choked with worries and riches and pleasures of life, and do not bear ripe fruit. “But the seed in the good soil, these are the ones who have heard the word in an honest and good heart, and hold it fast, and bear fruit with perseverance.”</p><p>And again, this is not a blanket statement on judging a heart. While many are deceived for a time, God may get their attention. But in more cases than not, many “professing Christians” end up converted to a local funny farm rather than a Godly congregation.</p><p>And I can’t be the only one to witness this pattern today. The nonsense promoted on many of these platforms is sickening. In most local congregations, people experience everything from the more serious concerns of false doctrine, false prophecies, physical or emotional abuse by religious leaders (which I will write about later) to lower-level crud such as hypocrisy, gossip, or cliques. And any of these can cause a person to run fast and far away from their religious community.</p><p>In their pain, they either leave with religious suspicion toward anything Christian, or the alternate danger is that they become highly receptive to any alternative worldview that opposes any Christian faith.</p><p>I have also witnessed those who may be disgusted by a particular religion (that meets “their” definition of Christian) and, due to a situation of abuse, instead of leaving religion altogether, they seek an alternative, i.e., a person who was inside the Mormon church who left to join the Watchtower organization.</p><p>Count the number of cases you read where you can read the pain behind their articles? In addition, anger or hatred spewing toward Christianity in general. As I am going to try and show, their “conversion” was more than likely fraudulent. And, while many who are venting have left what they believed was Christianity, the concern continues toward the ones who remain.</p><p>So I sat down and started writing down reasons for Christian deception as I read through Biblical examples and my life experiences. I realize there are too many to list. And this list is not exhaustive, so please feel free to add your experience or Scripture in the comments. I am just pulling those that stand out to me. Some have the Scripture attached, some have an explanation, and some have both.</p><p>This article begins with motivation. Why do we have so many false teachers in our day? Common motivations behind false teachings are generally based upon humanism: Humanism is always the starting place.</p><p><strong>Moralistic Therapeutic Deism (MTD)</strong>: This is the “Self-Help” Gospel system. The Deistic MTD (below) is a customized deity created specifically to serve and protect the MTD system. Coined by sociologists Christian Smith and Melinda Denton in 2005, MTD describes a widespread, popularized belief system that operates under the guise of Christianity but strips away historical orthodox doctrines.</p><p>It reduces god to The Cosmic Therapist. His disciple (the pastor or life coach) has one primary job: to make you feel good, boost your self-esteem, and help you achieve your personal dreams. Biblical Foundation? “For I know the plans that I have for you,’ declares the LORD, ‘plans for well-being, and not for calamity, in order to give you a future and a hope.” They deliberately keep their messages simple and practical to appeal to people who do not normally attend church. There is no concept of human depravity, repentance, judgment, taking up your cross, and the holiness of God. The sermons focus entirely on “living your best life now” through positive thinking and psychological tips. Christ is merely a utility for personal self-actualization rather than a savior from the wrath of God.</p><p><strong>Deistic MTD:</strong> This is the theological object (who they say god is) from the above anthropological practice. The MTD god exists purely to validate the system. This god created the world but does not need to be particularly involved in a person’s life, except when needed to solve a problem or dispense a blessing. Viewing “Deistic MTD” as a specific lens is a highly accurate way to isolate how the belief system conceptualizes god. In Deistic MTD, God has no intrinsic value outside of what he can do for the individual. This worldview strips God of His holiness, sovereignty, and role as a cosmic judge. In MTD, god is a “cosmic butler” or “genie.” He is technically available, but only on standby.</p><p><strong>Antinomianism</strong>: Because you are under grace, all your future sins are already automatically forgiven, so you never need to repent, confess sin, or yield to the conviction of the Holy Spirit ever again. TV preachers like Joseph Prince use this verse to argue that looking at your personal sins or feeling guilty about bad behavior is a denial of Christ’s finished work. They teach that the law has been completely eradicated, meaning there are no moral expectations for a believer. They use Romans 6:14 for their argument: “For sin will not have mastery over you, because you are not under Law but under grace. However, he and others bypass the very next two verses in following and keeping with the context. Paul goes on to state that true grace makes you a slave to righteousness, not a free agent to sin without conscience. Replacing a Person With a System: Ultimately, philosophy is a system of human thought. Philosophy replaces the gospel when salvation is viewed as an intellectual puzzle. It is used as an intellectual bait to convert the wise of the world, rather than relying on the power of the gospel itself. Whether it is used to introduce some to Christ or it is pushed as part of the theological diet, it is dangerous. Paul addressed this specific false teaching in Colossae. More than likely it involved an early form of Gnosticism or a mix of pagan mysticism and Jewish legalism. Teachers claimed that faith in Christ was a good starting point, but to be truly spiritually mature, believers needed “secret knowledge” or philosophical initiation. This made everyday believers feel inferior, directly replacing the sufficiency of Christ with intellectual elitism. <em>Colossians 2:8: “See to it that no one enslaves you through philosophy and empty deceit according to human tradition, according to the basic principles of the world, and not according to the Messiah.”</em></p><p><strong>Using Debates: </strong>Relying on intellectual debate to “argue” people into the kingdom often replaces the power of the gospel with human cleverness. When winning an argument becomes the goal, the cross is easily sidelined. Debates inherently focus on who is smarter, quicker, or more articulate. If a convert is made, it anchors their faith in human intellect rather than in the means of the gospel. Most important is IF someone is argued into the faith purely by logic and philosophy, they can just as easily be argued out of it by a cleverer skeptic. <em>1 Timothy 6:4–5 “…he is a conceited person and does not understand anything. He has an unhealthy craving for arguments and debates. This produces jealousy, rivalry, slander, evil suspicions, and incessant conflict between people who are depraved in mind and deprived of truth. They think that godliness is a way to make a profit.”</em></p><p><strong>Apologetics: </strong>(This will get me in trouble.) Of course, the Bible calls believers to defend their faith, but it strictly dictates how it must be done. Nevertheless, it is often abused and used as a substitute for the gospel. Like above, the goal is to win the person, not the debate point. Apologists always seem to combine philosophical arguments into the apologetic encounter. Thus, human wisdom is used to help the conversion.</p><p>The Greek word used here is aiteo. It is the word used when a beggar asks for alms, or a child asks a parent for bread. While it generally translates to “ask” or “request,” it carries a strong connotation of the reason for the demand: a desire, a craving, or asking for something one lacks. What happens is the passage begins to read as a new instruction: “Always be prepared to give a defense to everyone.” They no longer have to ask because the apologist now treats every breathing skeptic as an open target, launching uninvited philosophical cross-examinations rather than waiting for a soul to genuinely thirst for hope. In other words, when the prerequisite of a heartfelt request (<em>aiteo</em>) is stripped away, apologetics ceases to be a ministry of presence and becomes a system of intellectual ambush. The believer becomes a combatant on a cultural battlefield, weaponizing human cleverness to drag people across a logic/philosophical finish line rather than letting the Spirit pierce a heart.</p><p>The trigger for the conversation is not a Christian seeking out a debate (as is practiced today) but an observer being so struck by the believer’s supernatural peace, joy, or resilience during trials that they are compelled to ask, “Dude, how do you have hope right now?” Apologia is the answer given to a world that looks at a suffering Christian and demands an explanation for their unshakeable hope. It is a defense born of a life well lived. It is NOT a mechanism to initiate a hostile academic debate.<em> 1 Corinthians 2: 1–5, “When I came to you, brothers, I didn’t come and tell you about God’s secret with rhetorical language or wisdom. For while I was with you I resolved to know nothing except Jesus the Messiah, and him crucified. It was in weakness, fear, and great trembling that I came to you. My message and my preaching were not accompanied by clever, wise words, but by a display of the Spirit’s power, so that your faith would not be based on human wisdom but on God’s power.”</em></p><p><strong>The Lure of Predators</strong>: <em>Acts 20:29–30, “I know that when I’m gone savage wolves will come among you and not spare the flock. Indeed, some of your own men will arise and distort the truth in order to lure the disciples into following them.</em></p><p><strong>Desire for Praise:</strong> <em>John 12:43, “For they loved the praise of human beings more than the praise of God.”<br>Demonic Influence: 1 Timothy 4:1–3, “Now the Spirit says clearly that in the last times some people will abandon the faith by following deceitful spirits, the teachings of demons…”</em></p><p><strong>People-Pleasing: </strong>Galatians 2:11–13, “<em>But when Cephas came to Antioch, I opposed him to his face, because he was clearly wrong. Until some men arrived from James, he was in the habit of eating with the Gentiles, but after those men came, he withdrew from the Gentiles and would not associate with them any longer, because he was afraid of the circumcision party. The other Jews also joined him in this hypocritical behavior, to the extent that even Barnabas was caught up in their hypocrisy.”</em></p><p><strong>Ignorance: </strong><em>1 Timothy 1:7, “They want to be teachers of the Law, yet they do not understand either what they are talking about or the things about which they speak so confidently.”<br>Personal Interest: Philippians 2:21, “For all the others look after their own interests, not after those of Jesus the Messiah.”</em></p><p><strong>The Allure of Novelty</strong>: Someone who claims to have a deep understanding of what they call “standard” theology might grow bored with foundational truths. They may begin seeking “deeper secrets,” unrevealed mysteries, or obscure interpretations that make them feel intellectually superior to everyday believers. <em>1 Corinthians 8:1, “Now concerning food offered to idols: We know that we all possess knowledge. Knowledge puffs up, but love builds up.”</em></p><p><strong>Shepherds with no Discernment and Greedy</strong>: <em>Isaiah 56:11, “Meanwhile, the dogs have a mighty appetite — they can never get enough. And as for them, they are the shepherds who lack understanding; they have all turned to their own way, each one to his gain, each and every one.”</em></p><p><strong>Cultural Pressure:</strong> Some change the gospel to fit modern social trends so they do not feel mocked or left out by society. <em>Galatians 1:10 “Am I now trying to win the approval of people or of God? Or am I trying to please people? If I were still trying to please people, I would not be the Messiah’s servant.”</em></p><p>Political Ambition: <em>Acts1:6, “Now those who had gathered together began to ask Jesus, “Lord, is this the time when you will restore the kingdom to Israel?”</em></p><p><strong>Spiritual Blindness:</strong> A teacher can be fully deceived by their own ego, genuinely believing a lie while thinking they serve God.</p><p><strong>Hypocrisy and Lies:</strong> <em>1 Timothy 4:2 “…and the hypocrisy of liars, whose consciences have been burned by a hot iron.”</em></p><p><strong>Religious or a Moralist</strong>: <em>2 Timothy 3:5, “They will hold to an outward form of godliness but deny its power. Stay away from such people.</em>”</p><p><strong>Lying “prophets”</strong>: The old prophet of Bethel lied to the younger man of God, claiming an angel told him to bring him home for a meal. (Mormonism and Islam come to mind?) <em>1 Kings 13:18, “I’m a prophet like you,” the old man replied, “and an angel spoke to me and delivered this message from the LORD: ‘Bring him back with you to your house and give him food and water.’” But he was lying.”</em></p><p>Political Protection &amp; the appointment of “yes men”: Many Old Testament false prophets were on the royal payroll (like the 400 prophets under King Ahab) <em>1 Kings 22. They preached “peace, peace” because telling the king the bloody truth would cost them their status, comfort, or lives.”</em></p><p><strong>Fear of Man</strong>: Prophets often shrank back from declaring God’s judgment because the culture and leadership actively persecuted true prophets, i.e., Elijah and Jeremiah.</p><p><strong>Lying to Provide False Hope:</strong> <em>Jeremiah 23:16, “This is what the LORD of the Heavenly Armies says: “Don’t listen to the words of the prophets who are prophesying to you; they’re giving you false hopes. They declare visions from their own minds — they don’t come from the LORD!</em>”</p><p><strong>Word of Faith Movement</strong>: This is the foundation serving as the theological engine behind the broader Health and Wealth (or Prosperity) Gospel. To this day, many zealous followers have not understood that the TV personality’s wealth doesn’t come from a magical faith-force, but comes directly out of the pockets of the desperate, hurting people who send them “seed money” hoping for a miracle. God becomes a giant Pez dispenser at will. Not only that, while you continue to live poor and struggling, have you ever seen a poor Word of Faith preacher? <em>1 Timothy 6:3–5, “…and incessant conflict between people who are depraved in mind and deprived of truth. They think that godliness is a way to make a profit.”</em></p><p><strong>Bearing False Witness</strong>: When the Magi arrived in Jerusalem seeking the “King of the Jews,” Herod the Great became deeply paranoid. He feigned religious devotion to extract information. <em>Matthew 2:7–8, “Then Herod secretly called together the wise men, found out from them the time the star had appeared, and sent them to Bethlehem. He told them, “As you go, search carefully for the child. When you find him, tell me so that I, too, may go and worship him.”</em></p><p><strong>Bearing False Witness to take out your enemies:</strong> <em>Luke 23:2, “They began to accuse him, “We found this man corrupting our nation, forbidding us to pay taxes to Caesar, and saying that he is the Messiah, a king.”</em></p><p><strong>Using followers for disinformation</strong>: The religious establishment used targeted disinformation campaigns to turn public opinion against Stephen. <em>Acts 6:11–12, “So they secretly got some men to say, “We have heard him speaking blasphemous words against Moses and God.” They stirred up the people, the elders, and the scribes. Then they rushed at Stephen, grabbed him, and brought him before the Council.”</em></p><p><strong>Bible Genre to Fiction</strong>: C.S. Lewis, for example, grouped the Book of Job alongside books like Esther and Jonah, stating they were “sacred fiction” because they feature unknown characters in unspecified periods rather than anchoring themselves in verifiable, known history. How did he get away with it? He used Christianese. Because Lewis firmly believed that the inclusion and composition of these books were guided by the Holy Ghost, meaning God intended for scripture to contain “sacred myth &amp; sacred fiction as well as sacred history” Lewis passed the smell test.</p><p>But Evangelicals never follow-up with questions. What about the problems that follow this defense by Lewis? What about James use of Job’s history when he wrote <em>“We consider those who endured to be blessed. You have heard about Job’s endurance and have seen the purpose of the Lord — that the Lord is compassionate and merciful.”</em></p><p>If James is pointing to a literal man in history to prove a point about endurance, then Lewis’s categorization of Job as a divinely inspired parable stands at odds with the New Testament’s own treatment of the text. <em>2 Peter 3:15–16, “Think of our Lord’s patience as facilitating salvation, just as our dear brother Paul also wrote to you according to the wisdom given him. He speaks about this subject in all his letters. Some things in them are hard to understand, which ignorant and unstable people distort, leading to their own destruction, as they do the rest of the Scriptures.”</em></p><p><strong>Exploiting Compassion:</strong> They use biblical language about helping the poor to manipulate well-meaning believers into supporting radical economic systems. For example, Terry Eagleton (The “Catholic Marxist” Critique): In his book Reason, Faith, and Revolution, he argues that traditional, conservative Christians have completely domesticated Jesus. He writes that the real gospel is an explicitly materialist, revolutionary message of class solidarity. <em>Romans 16:18: “…because such people are not serving the Messiah our Lord, but their own desires. By their smooth talk and flattering words they deceive the hearts of the unsuspecting.”</em></p><p><strong>Racial Division:</strong> They replace the biblical concept of personal sin and reconciliation as a whole with strict class warfare, dividing people through rivalry into fixed categories of “oppressors” and “oppressed” or “rich or “poor.”<em> Romans 3:22, God’s righteousness through the faithfulness of Jesus the Messiah — for all who believe. For there is no distinction among people.”</em></p><p><strong>Marxism/Socialism:</strong> Marxism and socialism are absolutely two different weeds grown from the very same seed. In other words, both are from the weed family. Contemporary writers who actively apply Marxist filters to Christian scriptures refer to their perspective as Radical Theology or Marxist Biblical Criticism. In other words, a false teacher will push an identity-driven agenda through articles by flipping the scriptures to argue the gospel is about God defending the poor and downcast. In addition, the true historical Jesus was not a spiritual Savior dying for personal sins, but an anti-imperialist, revolutionary community organizer who was executed by the state for demanding economic equality.”</p><p><strong>Luring Away Through Deception:</strong> <em>2 Corinthians 11:3, “However, I am afraid that just as the serpent deceived Eve by its tricks, so your minds may somehow be lured away from sincere and pure devotion to the Messiah.”</em></p><p><strong>Luring To A Different Christ:</strong> Redefining the person, nature, and work of Christ to advance a substitute in His place. Using Biblical language for deception by refining the definition of terms. <em>2 Corinthians 11:4, “For if someone comes along and preaches another Jesus than the one we preached, or should you receive a different spirit from the one you received or a different gospel from the one you accepted, you are all too willing to listen.”</em></p><p><strong>Panic-Driven Eschatology</strong>: How can anyone miss systems like the Left Behind series, which weaponize the fear of being missed or abandoned in order to win a conversion? I once asked someone at Calvary Chapel about their conversion and guess what he told me? “Man, I didn’t want to be left behind.”</p><p>Con artists use end-times survival timelines to bypass the simple gospel all the time. Instead of preaching peace and reconciliation through Christ, they preach anxiety, chaos, and panic. What else can it mean when a person is “easily unsettled or alarmed”)? It replaces the resting peace of salvation with a frantic, timeline-watching survival mindset.<em> 2 Thessalonians 2:1–3, “Now we ask you, brothers, regarding the coming of our Lord Jesus, the Messiah, and our gathering together to him, not to be so quickly upset or alarmed when someone claims that we said, either by some spirit, conversation, or letter that the Day of the Lord has already come. Do not let anyone deceive you in any way, for it will not come unless the rebellion takes place first and the man of sin, who is destined for destruction, is revealed.”</em></p><p><strong>Preterism:</strong> When a person shifts from proclaiming the gospel to sharing a preterist framework as a tool for conversion, they typically alter the message. Why use Preterism pre, or post gospel? It helps the one with the anxiety of imagery. In other words, it removes the future fear that many experience in the Book of Revelation and replaces it with a present assurance. Another reason it can be used is when preterism is “added” to the gospel message, the call to conversion often focuses heavily on convincing the person of a past historical event rather than pointing them to a future bodily reality. In extreme forms converts are told that the resurrection has already happened spiritually. The gospel message shifts from “Trust Christ and await His return” to “Understand this specific historical-theological timeline to be fully mature.” Once again, using an eschatological system to win a convert often changes the nature of the conversion itself. <em>2 Timothy 2:17–18, “…and what they say will spread everywhere like gangrene. Hymenaeus and Philetus are like that. They have abandoned the truth by claiming that the resurrection has already taken place, and so they destroy the faith of others.”</em></p><p><strong>State Worship:</strong> They elevate the government or the collective system to the place of God, making the state the ultimate provider and savior of humanity. <em>Daniel 3:4–6, “Then a herald proclaimed aloud: “People of all nations and languages are commanded: Whenever you hear the sound of the trumpet, the flute, the lyre, the four-stringed lyre, and the harp, playing together along with various instruments, you are to fall down and worship the golden statue that was set up by King Nebuchadnezzar. Anyone who does not fall down and worship is immediately to be thrown into the blazing fire furnace.”</em></p><p><strong>Utopian Deliverance: </strong>They redefine the “Kingdom of God” as a perfect, classless human society achieved through political revolution rather than divine redemption. <em>Colossians 2:8, “See to it that no one enslaves you through philosophy and empty deceit according to human tradition, according to the basic principles of the world, and not according to the Messiah.”</em></p><p><strong>Theonomy</strong>: Derived from the Greek words for “God’s Law” (theos + nomos), in direct contrast to autonomy (“self-law”), this is the belief that the civil laws and judicial penalties given to Moses in the Old Testament are still binding on modern governments today. <em>Matthew 5:17–19, “Do not think that I came to destroy the Law or the Prophets. I didn’t come to destroy them, but to fulfill them, because I tell you with certainty that until heaven and earth disappear, not one letter or one stroke of a letter will disappear from the Law until everything has been accomplished. So whoever sets aside one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom from heaven. But whoever does them and teaches them will be called great in the kingdom from heaven.”</em></p><p><strong>The Seven Mountain Mandate</strong>: (7MM) was born out of a meeting between two prominent evanjellyfish: Bill Bright and Loren Cunningham, into a para-church concept. This is the charismatic counterpart to theonomy, teaching that the “Great Commission” is not about preaching the cross to save individuals out of the world, but about invading and capturing the seven primary spheres of cultural power (Government, Family, Education, Media, Arts, Business, and Religion). It appeals to converts by offering them a spiritual warfare campaign to “reclaim the culture” and force society into alignment with God. This system substitutes internal regeneration with strategic institutional conquest. It lures people into the church by making political and cultural activism a test of true faith, convincing them they are serving God by taking territory, while completely bypassing the Holy Spirit’s work of heart transformation. It produces highly motivated cultural foot-soldiers who are eager to govern the world but without the gospel of God. They believe God gives special strategies to charismatic “generals” to take over a school board or a government office. The goal isn’t to implement Old Testament case law; it is to put a Christian in charge who can govern by modern spiritual intuition.</p><p><strong>Christian Reconstructionism</strong>: This is the broader social and cultural movement. It teaches that every sphere of society, the family, church, education, and civil government, must be systematically “reconstructed” to completely submit to the Lordship of Christ and Old Testament civil law. Genesis 1:28: “God blessed these humans by saying to them, “Be fruitful, multiply, fill the earth, and subdue it! Be masters over the fish in the ocean, the birds that fly, and every living thing that crawls on the earth!”<br>Annihilationism: Again, whether pre- or post-gospel message, this doctrine can be used as a substitute to shift the focus of salvation from reconciliation with a holy God to simply escaping eternal heartburn and discomfort. It redefines God’s ultimate judgment into a sterile, quick execution rather than an eternal consequence for sin. By telling the unrepentant that their worst-case scenario is simply ceasing to exist, or non-existence, it strips the weight and removes the terrifying and acute urgency to repent. The convert is won over by an intellectual argument that “saves God’s reputation” from the doctrine of hell, rather than being broken by their own personal sin against a holy God. I hope you agree: if the penalty for sin is merely non-existence, then Christ’s suffering on the cross was merely to save humanity from temporary death or annihilation? <em>Jeremiah 8:11–12, “They have treated my people’s wound superficially, telling them, ‘Peace, peace, when there is no peace.’ Are they ashamed because they have done what is repugnant to God? They weren’t ashamed at all; they don’t even know how to blush! Therefore they’ll fall with those who fall. When I punish them, they’ll be brought down,” says the LORD.”</em></p><p>I would call the next few ‘political subsets’ of the Rushdoony and Bahnsen theologies above. While these ideas below are distinct, they do overlap. One may rely on a courtroom judge; the other relies on a political activist. But they are fundamentally guilty of the same error: they attempt to build an earthly kingdom using human agency and state coercion. While they are all weeds, they have a different flower. So I have tried to separate them.</p><p><strong>Nationalistic Pride:</strong> Some use the Old Testament Wisdom literature to argue that God expects secular rulers to rule by Moses’ exact law code. <em>Psalms 2:10–12, “So now, O kings, show insight; Take warning, O judges of the earth. Serve Yahweh with fear And rejoice with trembling. Kiss the Son, lest He become angry, and you perish in the way, For His wrath may soon be kindled. How blessed are all who take refuge in Him!</em>LSB</p><p><strong>Nationalistic Pride II</strong>: They will teach that God’s primary focus in the world is the dominance of their specific nation. <em>Matthew 28:18, “Then Jesus came up and told them, “All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. Therefore, as you go, disciple people in all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit, teaching them to obey everything that I’ve commanded you. And remember, I am with you each and every day until the end of the age.”</em></p><p><strong>Nationalistic Pride III</strong>: They turn the global, spiritual Church into a localized, nationalistic tool to rally voters, convincing people that patriotism and piety are the exact same thing. Ignoring the promise is made to God’s Elect and not the world. <em>2 Chronicles 7:14: “When my people humble themselves — the ones who are called by my name — and pray, seek me, and turn away from their evil practices, I myself will listen from heaven, I will pardon their sins, and I will restore their land.”</em></p><p><strong>Nationalistic Pride IV:</strong> They pull from Paul’s letters to Timothy to claim the New Testament explicitly endorses the civil use of Old Testament law. They argue that the list of sins Paul provides (immediately after the verses that follow) matches the moral crimes of the Mosaic code. They claim Paul is validating the use of Mosaic civil law to restrain societal evil in the New Testament era. <em>1 Timothy 1:8–9, “Of course, we know that the Law is good if a person uses it legitimately, that is, if he understands that the Law is not intended for righteous people but for lawbreakers and rebels, for ungodly people and sinners, for those who are unholy and irreverent, for those who kill their fathers, their mothers, or other people.”</em></p><p><strong>Defenders of Israel as a Nation: </strong>Many have mistakenly believed that because Israel is God’s chosen nation, God would never allow them to be defeated or exiled. A blindness to the fact that their sin requires judgment. <em>Micah 3:11, “… Even so, don’t they all rely on the LORD as they ask, ‘The LORD is among us, is he not? Nothing bad can possibly happen to us!’</em></p><p><strong>Dual-Covenant Theology</strong>: Men like John Hagee have taught that Jesus did not come to earth to be the Messiah for the Jewish people, and that the Jews already have an existing covenant with God that grants them salvation without needing to believe in Jesus Christ. And Christians need to honor this through the promise to Abraham. <em>Genesis 12:3, “ I’ll bless those who bless you, but I’ll curse the one who curses you, and through you all the people of the earth will be blessed.”</em></p><p><strong>Christian Zionism</strong>: An active campaign that operates as the result of eschatological belief. It organizes rallies, lobbies political leaders, and treats foreign policy in the Middle East as a direct fulfillment of biblical mandates. They pressure politicians to provide billions in military aid, veto United Nations resolutions, and shape Middle Eastern borders based on an apocalyptic timeline. As a result of Dispensationalism, Christian Zionism takes that religious motivation and forms political groups like Christians United for Israel. (CUFI) In other words, it takes that exact religious premise out of the church building and applies it to the secular world. It argues that because God’s religious covenant with the Jewish people is unbroken, Christians have a religious duty to love, protect, and restore them to their ancestral homeland. The religious political yoke happens when politicians and preachers realize that millions of voters share this specific religious belief. “Tell me what you believe and i’lll lead.”</p><p><strong>Dispensationalism:</strong> Is an academic framework providing the internal logic for that political activism. The system provides the religious motivation, acting as the engine. Though the elements were here long before John Nelson Darby, they were popularized by his notes in the Scofield Reference Bible. Written to convince adherents that history must follow a specific sequence, which includes a return of the Jewish people, before Jesus can return. Pure Dispensationalism teaches that God’s promises to Abraham in Genesis are literal, eternal, and unconditional. It claims that God has a separate, future plan for ethnic Israel that is completely distinct from the Christian Church.</p><p><strong>System Elitism:</strong> (Again, more trouble coming my way, but I would be untruthful to address other problems that people follow and not all that come to mind.) Division is division no matter how you slice it. From a strict biblical standpoint, there is absolutely no difference between saying “I am a Lutheran or I am a Calvinist” and the Corinthians saying “I follow Apollos” or “I follow Cephas.”</p><p>By adopting a theologian’s name as a primary badge of identity, modern believers fall into the same fleshly, factional trap that Paul fiercely condemned. For one, they are using a human name as a shorthand code to signal intellectual or theological superiority over “lesser” believers. In what way is this different than with Paul? They are anchoring their foundation to a system. If Paul were to write a letter to the modern church, his critique would be identical: “Is Christ divided? Was Calvin crucified for you? Were you baptized in the name of Calvin?”</p><p>More importantly, my concern is for the branding that follows. I am frustrated when I hear that Calvin has become the theological whipping boy in the place of the Bible. How can I articulate this? He inherits the hatred of the System: He endures the shame in the place of God’s theology. You must understand that both those inside the visible church and outside use the name of John Calvin as a target so they can attack God’s absolute sovereignty instead of placing blame on God’s Word.</p><p>When critics want to attack original sin or election, they don’t look at the Bible texts. Instead, there is a hatred for John Calvin that seethes from their lips. He becomes the target for every theological grievance. If you are Reformed, please hear me out. People stop hating the Bible when it comes to understanding God’s sovereignty and instead have replaced these truths with or through Calvinism. This turns Calvin into a symbol of rigid debate rather than a pastor who was trying to point people to the majesty of Christ. A theological framework turns into a tribal gang warfare match. Goats love believing they are fighting against the five points of a human system. So try to understand that if God is to be hated, let it be because of His word and not as though the sovereignty of God is a human invention. Long story short? Because of perception and not reality, men hate John Calvin because they have been led to believe he invented those doctrines. Calvin becomes a proxy for persecution.</p><p>By convincing themselves that election and absolute sovereignty are Calvin’s inventions, the humanist finds a clever loophole. If Calvin is the source, then the system is the fabrication of man, which gives them the nonsense they can safely reject, mock, and walk away from, calling it false doctrine. Don’t allow the goats to use “Calvinism” to mask their deep-seated rebellion against God’s right to be King. We want the natural human heart to be confronted with a text that strips away its free-will, its autonomy, and its pride. We want the Bible to be the scapegoat as they seethe with rebellion. We don’t want them thinking they can stand before God because of a diet of Calvinism; let Romans 9, Ephesians 1, and John 6 be the focus of their hate. The Bible’s explicit declaration that God is the absolute Potter and they are merely the clay.</p><p>But because it is socially and religiously unacceptable to say, “I hate the Word of God,” men pivot. They label the text “Calvinism” so they can attack it with a clear conscience.</p><p>This list is a simple illustration of the many ways the visible church can be compromised through men and their schemes. When these are used, there is no need for the gospel message. The Scriptures attached to them either help us identify the warning, or the verse is abused by that particular system.</p><p>Every single heresy, false motivation, and twisted scripture shares one definitive, unifying denominator: The Elevation of Anthropocentric (Man-Centered) Authority Over Theocentric (God-Centered) Authority. Or we could also say Synergism vs. Monergism.</p><p>In almost every item above, it takes God off His throne and puts the human agenda in His place. Whether it is a preacher chasing money, a theologian inventing some Deistic Cosmic Therapist, or a politician using prophecy to secure voting blocs, the underlying mechanism is identical: They are using a holy God as a tool to serve unholy human desires.</p><p>As Romans 1 tells us, the natural man does not submit to the Sovereign Lord. And because of our Adamic DEMAND, we want a deity who validates our lifestyle and our wants. And this calls for the SUPPLY: like a drug dealer, the religious vendor accommodates our lifestyle and our wants. Some may call it a match made in hell?</p><p>I want the reader to understand that false teaching is not always due to intellectual mistakes or ignorance. In general, these men and women know what they are doing. They take a little bit of the Bible, add humanism as the secret sauce, and produce an unholy mixture of religion, moralism, and a cause.</p><p>But they are not stupid. They also realize that to get others to follow their schemes, they must approach us with a Bible. Probably very difficult to sell someone religion without holding to a religious book. In our example, the Bible is the bait and the common denominator in many cases. Whether it is one isolated Bible passage from one book or all 66 Books, they know it has its advantages for the religious at heart.</p><p>And after adding the ingredients from above, throw it in the oven for a short time, and two things will simultaneously take place: God is reduced/brought down, while man is increased/raised up.</p><p>Religious people do not want to know about the necessity in understanding original sin; the Adamic nature and its effects resulting in human depravity. Why do you think it is attacked and downplayed by the majority of those in moralistic denominations across the board?</p><p>Instead, they want self-esteem and cheap grace, and they want it now. If there is any agreement of original sin, it is temporary and resolved when the priest provides a baptism for the newborn.</p><p>The Scriptures and the subsequent warnings I provided are not exhaustive. Yes, I didn’t cover them all. Besides, this will end up a very lengthy article when through.</p><p>And yes, many of these warnings say the same thing but in different ways. Many of these sales gimmicks and Bible verses above will overlap in their purpose. Nevertheless, in the end, they help to expose the raw human rot behind the pulpit. You have been given a list to understand the many, many reasons for deception: whether financial greed, the desire for human praise, people-pleasing, cultural pressure, etc., etc., etc.</p><p>What needs to stand out is that these warnings are generally tied to people who claim to be Christian in some way, shape, or form. These are the goats in the sheep pen. Most of them brought in by wolves in sheeps clothing. But what they are doing is making the outside of their lives very pretty and adding a nice cologne or perfume. We have got to understand that inspecting “fruit” is not as simple as looking on the outside. All religions have moral truths. But what we are to look at is the doctrinal fruit.</p><p>The Jews cleaned up the outside of their cups, didn’t they? <em>Matthew 23:25–27: </em>“<em>How terrible it will be for you, scribes and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You clean the outside of the cup and the plate, but on the inside they are full of greed and self-indulgence. You blind Pharisee! First clean the inside of the cup, so that its outside may also be clean. “How terrible it will be for you, scribes and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You are like whitewashed tombs that look beautiful on the outside but inside are full of dead people’s bones and every kind of impurity.”</em></p><p>You can pass all the laws you want and ensure we all live among moral people. Still, if the human heart is not supernaturally reborn through the Holy Spirit and forensic justification, the inside of the cup remains full of spiritual deadness.</p><p>By trying to “Christianize the culture” through political enforcement rather than individual heart transformation, modern leaders are simply building a magnificent, state-enforced monument of whitewashed tombs. They are producing highly disciplined, outwardly moralistic “goats” who keep the outside of the cup pristine while remaining completely dead to God on the inside.</p><p>Inspecting moral fruit will lead us to look at behaviors. Mormons, JW’s, Roman Catholics, EO, Christian Science, et al, all appear on the outside as what the world may consider a good person. We must not be fooled by the eighty year old Grandma who makes sugar cookies for her congregation each week. Doctrine is the first test for us as fruit inspectors, and then we consider morals if they pass that test.</p><p>When you are at a congregation you must ask: what does the “pastor” say about the person, nature, and work of the Messiah? These are doctrinal fruits. As the article develops, I will point these things out more and more.</p><p>But for now, we need to identify that hybrid Christians among us will always have equivalent doctrinal fruit. Even if they have some good fruit. A single rotten apple can ruin an entire barrel of good apples. This old idiom is grounded in real plant biology.</p><p>For this reason I have argued a person who clings to one heresy will always bring on additional heresies. When a false convert is among us, they have no obligation nor desire to make the Scriptures their final authority. And if they do, they are often very, very selective in finding only those they agree with.</p><p>History repeats itself because nothing is new under the sun. Patterns remain the same. The only things that change are the marketing and presentation of religious humanism and the bow on the wrapping.</p><p>Like the examples we read in the history of Israel, the visible church is not growing with godly people; it is growing with moralists. This is what the atmosphere was when the Messiah took upon Himself a flesh suit and walked among us. The religious establishment was the dominant force. And by adding a dash of politics, we have moralist activists.</p><p>To give one example of that day, let’s look at the Sanhedrin. And by the way, I will discuss this more later when I discuss Religious Jews vs. Biblical Jews.</p><p>During Roman occupation, Rome granted the Sanhedrin significant local autonomy in governing civil and religious matters. They used this delegated state power to enforce compliance with the Sabbath, temple taxes, dietary laws, and strict boundaries on marriage and social interaction. If a Jewish citizen violated these codes, the Sanhedrin had the legal authority to arrest them, beat them, and cast them out of the community.</p><p>Because the Sanhedrin lacked the legal authority under Roman law to execute criminals, they had to do exactly what my article warns against: they co-opted the secular sword of Caesar to enforce their religious vision.</p><p>While the motivation behind his arrest was theological, the legal charge that resulted in his crucifixion was political treason against Rome. Jesus was executed as an enemy of the state.</p><p>You need only read Luke 23. They could not execute Jesus for blasphemy under Jewish law without Rome’s permission, so they re-framed their theological grievance into a political crime of treason against Caesar to force Pontius Pilate to use state execution.</p><p>The Pharisees had successfully built an institutional environment in which social conformity and legalistic moralism were imposed from the outside. They had used their religious-political system to clean the outside of the cultural cup through heavy social pressure and legal threats, while the hearts of the people were completely devoid of actual faith and love for God.</p><p>Still, they would not stone Him. They said in John 18:31: “So Pilate said to them, “Take Him yourselves, and judge Him according to your law.” The Jews said to him, “It is not lawful for us to put anyone to death,”</p><p>In the Gospel narrative, the tragedy is that the keepers of God’s law aligned with a pagan empire to eliminate a perceived threat. So when Jesus was murdered, the public charge was political and not theological. Instead of religion doing the dirt work, it moved to the political realm. Charging Him with:</p><ul><li><strong>Subverting the nation:</strong> Agitating the public and disrupting Roman order.</li><li><strong>Opposing Roman taxes:</strong> Directly challenging Rome’s economic authority.</li><li><strong>Claiming to be a king:</strong> Setting up a rival authority to Caesar.</li></ul><p>Later in the article, I will again mention how these identifiers both complment and overlap. Politics and religion combined can be a warning sign. They are distant cousins who end up sleeping together. Moralism, by definition, often lacks the internal spiritual authority to transform people voluntarily. Therefore, like the ancient authorities, it must outsource its discipline to the state.</p><p>Whatever one thinks, they appear to be fundamentally inseparable because they both attempt to address the same human problem: How should we live, and who holds the ultimate authority over our lives?</p><p>While religion governs a person’s conscience, morality, and ultimate allegiance, politics is the mechanism that imposes a moral vision on society through law and power.</p><p>When a figure bridges the two, they tap into an incredibly potent source of human motivation. But ultimately politics wears the crown. Politics is the enforcer of the two. After all, laws are completely useless without teeth.</p><p>The book of Revelation highlights this ultimate design when it comes to fruition. A One World humanist personality is built on the platform of a beastly system.</p><p>This is an example of what I meant by an overlap. An engine that drives three or more of the above. Let’s pick theonomy and State Worship.</p><p>They all seek to establish a righteous kingdom on earth by using the coercive power of the law rather than the supernatural, heart-transforming power of the gospel.</p><p>Revelation 13:12: “It uses all the authority of the first beast on its behalf, and it makes the earth and those living on it worship the first beast, whose mortal wound was healed.”</p><p>And talk about signs and wonders? These will make Benny Hinn blush! Revelation 13:-14: “It performs spectacular signs, even making fire come down from heaven to earth in front of people. It deceives those living on earth with the signs that it is allowed to do on behalf of the first beast, telling them to make an image for the beast who was wounded by a sword and yet lived.”</p><p>Revelation 13:15–16: “The second beast was allowed to impart life to the image of the first beast so that the image of the beast could talk and order the execution of those who would not worship the image of the beast. The second beast forces all people — important and unimportant, rich and poor, free and slaves — to be marked on their right hands or on their foreheads.”</p><p>While we typically hear sheep say, “Who is like you, O Lord, among the gods? We read of the response of the goats who say, “…They also worshiped the beast, saying, ‘<strong>Who is like the beast,</strong> and who can fight a war with it?”</p><p>I tried to show this above. Religion and politics are two peas in a pod. While Religion dictates a believer’s highest loyalty (there definition of God or gods), politics will dictate a citizen’s structural loyalty to the State. When these two allegiances are aligned, it creates a conviction.</p><p>In modern terms, when moralism relies on the state to implement its discipline, it compromises its own spiritual message and aligns itself with coercive power.</p><p>Just a thought, as we move into the future, who do you think will be the ones to turn in God’s people to the State? My answer? The moralists.</p><p>And please listen to me before the next section; my pointing to the legacy of Charlie Kirk is not an indictment of his zeal, his work ethic, or the undeniable passion of those who followed him. The objective here is not to diminish his massive cultural momentum, but rather to honestly evaluate the systemic machinery he left behind.</p><p>What I want to address is the danger that arises when political activism is elevated to a spiritual duty. He built an unprecedented bridge between the modern church and the political arena and that is the point of the article at large.</p><p>Nevertheless, the legacy of Charlie Kirk highlights exactly how blending faith and politics creates a unique danger for both the church and the culture. There is no doubt he demonstrated how to merge Christian piety with American patriotism.</p><p>By convincing young evangelicals that the survival of the American republic was directly linked to the survival of the Christian faith, political activism is elevated to a spiritual duty.</p><p>Some say he was beyond successful. Successful in what though? By the mid-2020s, isn’t it true he had fully leaned into Christian Nationalism and dominion theology, openly advocating for Christian control over the mechanisms of governance?</p><p>The combination is not a heavenly gospel but rather a playground for an earthly gospel. This is nothing more than patriotic moralism — or moralistic patriotism. While there is a transformation, lives are not being transformed by the cross.</p><p>You may agree or disagree, but I believe this trajectory perfectly illustrates the core of the article’s argument regarding the strange bedfellows of politics and religion as moralism is potentially outsourcing discipline to the state.</p><p>Kirk’s ultimate destination a “Christian State” is not a speculative label; it is a direct reflection of the specific political theology and explicit rhetoric he championed leading while he was alive.</p><p>I hope I have stressed that nothing outside of the Biblical gospel will be successful. It is only the gospel of God that relies entirely on dunamis, (power), which in turn brings about the work of the Holy Spirit to change a human heart through belief in forensic justification, through faith.</p><p>It does not require any politics to advance. When you move religious conviction into the political realm to enforce moral behavior and then legislate, you change the tool from persuasion to eventual coercion.</p><p>Instead of people getting on board the gospel train because they recognize their war with God and subsequently look to His prescription of salvation? They respond and comply out of a desire for cultural dominance, political self-preservation, or sheer social conformity to moralism. Whatever the reason, it is an unholy gospel. And this does not create genuine Christians.</p><p>In a strange way, when religion becomes the primary pathway to political power, the church inevitably gets infiltrated by people who do not actually care about Jesus. Instead of becoming the desired end, He becomes a means to an end.</p><p>By studying and understanding imperial Rome, history proves that once you give the state the authority to enforce your moral or religious vision through the rule of law, you have handed the magistrate a weapon that has been, is, and will eventually be turned back upon the visible church. What starts as benign legislation inevitably sharpens into the sword of Caesar.</p><p>It goes without saying that these spokesmen in the visible church do not understand that the primary weapon for God’s people is the application of the doctrine of justification.</p><p>This is why the world instead reaches for the political sword and attempts to Christianize the culture. It merely politicizes the faith, giving the world a counterfeit kingdom that screams, “Who is like the beast?” while trampling the Savior who declared, “My kingdom is not of this world.”</p><p>And this is not limited to the false church. Other religions share these similar convictions through other means.</p><p>Islam comes to mind. Islam does not merely offer moral guidance for the individual conscience. It provides Sharia, a comprehensive legal blueprint that governs civil law, criminal punishments, foreign policy, and economic rules.</p><p>In a traditional Islamic state, there is no legislative assembly that can override the divine law of the Quran. Islam does not separate religion from politics; they are fundamentally woven into a single, unified system.</p><p>We see this absolute integration clearly in the punishments, or the legally fixed penalties for violations against the divine order.</p><p>For instance, a moral transgression like theft is not handled merely through internal spiritual repentance or standard civil restitution. Under traditional Sharia jurisprudence, it is codified as an offense against God Himself, carrying a mandatory corporal penalty: the amputation of the right hand.</p><p>Yes I am sure they have high evidentiary thresholds and safety nets to avoid implementing this sentence. That is not the point. The state is not a neutral arbiter of secular peace; it is weaponized as the absolute enforcer of divine discipline. The moral boundary and the state’s sword are one and the same.</p><p>What I am trying to say is this; If a citizen refrains from stealing or treats their neighbor well simply because they fear a state-sanctioned prison sentence, a fine, or physical amputation, they are not acting out of a transformed, moral heart. They are not responding to God’s Law.</p><p>Because this system is the fruit of moralism, the followers are acting out of self-preservation. The religious system fails to create a “holy” population; it merely creates a terrified and compliant population. It mistakes external behavior modification for internal spiritual transformation.</p><p>And it never stops. To catch every “sin” and enforce every divine mandate, the state must constantly expand its reach. How about another Flock camera? It requires more police, more surveillance, harsher penalties, and a broader definition of treason or subversion to keep the populace in line.</p><p>As brilliant as Kirk was, he did not forsee the church or religious institution becoming completely entangled/dependent upon the state’s monopoly and control on violence.</p><p>So one may ask what separates Kirk’s worldview from an Islamic worldview? Zealous supporters will claim Kirk never wanted a theocracy. But that does not accurately represent his position.</p><p>Kirk adopted one of the above tools from the Evanjellyfish bag of tricks: the Seven Mountain Mandate. As I already mentioned, this is a theological framework designed to take top-down cultural and political dominion.</p><p>By launching TPUSA, he would use that “gospel” to turn congregations into voting blocs. The moment you champion a fusion where the state’s legal machinery is used to enforce your moral vision, you have proven your intent: you are no longer relying on the Spirit to change hearts; but ultimately you are relying on the magistrate to police them.</p><p>But then you need the vehicle that moves the moral mountains and has them enforced. Enter the Politicians who are the ultimate chameleons. They do not care about forensic justification, the holiness of God, or cleaning the inside of the cup. They care about winning elections and maintaining power.</p><p>When a religious/moralist movement enters the political arena to enforce behavior through law, many politicians quickly realize they can use that movement as a ready-made voting bloc.</p><p>The visible church thinks it is using the politician to Christianize the culture, but in reality, the politician is using the church to politicize the faith. For a worldview built on external moralism, the politician is the indispensable middleman, the high priest of the state who converts religious demands into state force.</p><p>Without the politician, the dominionist movement is completely toothless. The dominionist <em>must</em> have the politician. The politician is the only figure legally authorized to reach into Caesar’s armory, draw the physical sword, and wield it on behalf of the moral machine.</p><p>The politician is the necessary conduit required to turn a preacher’s sermon into a binding, state-enforced piece of legislation.</p><p>When any movement, para-church, apologetic ministry shifts its focus from eternal salvation to cultural dominance, its faith inevitably shifts from the Creator to the creature.</p><p>The movement needs a visible “savior” who can win the immediate, earthly battle. Don’t you see why they never want to leave office? The politician becomes the necessary idol.</p><p>They are elevated to the status of a spiritual champion who can defend their “church,” conquer the “mountains” of power, and deliver the culture from its enemies. The politician is a necessary evil that is needed, and they know it.</p><p>One could say the moralist church admits its own functional atheism, or polytheism. The outcome is never good.</p><p>Through many of the means above, the visible church ceases to be a prophetic voice that holds people and rulers accountable to God. Instead, it becomes a cheap PR firm that sanitizes a politician’s corrupt behavior to keep its seat at the political table.</p><p>One could think of two models competing on the earthly stage:</p><ul><li>The Model of Christ: Jesus held absolute cosmic authority, yet He laid it down, suffered, and died to redeem His people. Philippians 2:7–9: “…but emptied Himself, by taking the form of a slave, by being made in the likeness of men. Being found in appearance as a man, He humbled Himself by becoming obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross.”</li><li>The Model of Political Religion is self-centered. It takes human weakness and tries to secure worldly authority to rule over its political enemies. It trades the spiritual power of the Cross for the physical power of Caesar’s sword.</li></ul><p>When your religion is explicitly tied to a political party’s platform or a nationalist agenda, the gospel ceases to be a universal message for all humanity.</p><p>Let’s not take away from the message by arguing that politics don’t have a place. I absolutely agree that the gospel has <em>implications</em> for how a Christian lives in this world. I maintain that the gospel is a message of redemption, forensic justification, and spiritual rebirth, completely separate from any earthly political system, legislation, or government.</p><p>But my faith controls the politics; my politics do not control my faith.</p><p>As the hymn says, this world is not my home. And as Augustine argued, the City of Man is fueled by the love of self and the lust for domination, whereas the love of God fuels the City of God. He explicitly warned that trying to fuse the two cities always corrupts the church.</p><p>The moralists tried to do this in what is called the Peasant’s War. The Protestant Reformers had to fight fiercely against both the Roman Catholic Church and radical groups who tried to turn the gospel into a political weapon for social revolution. In his Institutes of the Christian Religion, Calvin wrote extensively on the strict separation between spiritual and civil government:</p><p><em>“Spiritual government… resides in the soul or inner man and has to do with life eternal… Civil government… has to do only with civil and external justice.”</em> Calvin argued that the gospel changes the <em>inside</em> of the cup, while politics only manages the <em>outside</em>.</p><p>In the 20th century, as total governments (like Fascism and Communism) tried to co-opt religion, and turn the gospel into a political program for social reform, the most brilliant Christian writers doubled down on guarding the gospel from politics. One whom I respect greatly was J. Gresham Machen, the founder of the Orthodox Presbyterian Church (OPC). In Christianity and Liberalism, he sought to counter the “Social Gospel” of his day. Machen wrote: “The Church is turned into a social club or a political organization, and the gospel of Christ is forgotten… The true remedy is the preaching of the cross.”</p><p>Why are so many Christians deceived? For one, they take for granted who they listen to on TV, the radio, etc. The mind can be the Devil’s playground, no doubt. But as has been said, even if the Devil were not here to deceive us, we would be able to deceive ourselves enough tenfold.</p><p>Deception from the outside is one thing, but when we deceive ourselves, it is much more dangerous.</p><p>Suffice it to say the threat to the Jewish Christian faith is very real, and nothing proves this more than taking a serious look at who is inside the local congregation, or who is popular on social media. Popularity does not equate to godliness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0df2086a6b21" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In response “God is the glue that holds White Supremacy.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MosheD/in-response-god-is-the-glue-that-holds-white-supremacy-a69fdf08583b?source=rss-af4a87e02b1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a69fdf08583b</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Moshe D.]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Sep 2026 00:09:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-01T00:09:21.141Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Without the face of Jesus, it would not hold” by <a href="https://medium.com/illumination/god-is-the-glue-that-holds-white-supremacy-8bbdbe6ac200">Gregory Jackson spiritual educator.</a></h4><p>No historic reality or truth, just an campaign to divide, while using color as the tool?</p><p>What I interpreted from this article is not necessarily a defense of being black. “Accidents of birth” are outside of our control. The Bible says there is only one race and that’s the human race. If there is blame, it should be directed toward Adam.</p><p>Instead, the article hides a theological attack behind a historical critique. This argument/article is ammunition used to attempt to alienate Black Christians from their faith by weaponizing historical grievances.</p><p>And while it can do that, it is also the fuel to maintain insignificant- hostile, race relations. Or for many, a simple uncomfortableness to an anger is their reward. In other words, for a Socialist Marxist, either way, any sort of division whether small or great, is division. And they are the winners in their minds. And I think that is the intent of the article. To divide and conquer. How very Marxist, and Socialist.</p><p>In my response I want to cover several issues that stare at me as an apologist. I want to cover the color of the Messiah in the 1st Century. I want to cover the slavery not mentioned in the article that exists today with Islam, and I want to cover an equivocation that is also ignored. That is to say if the white Jesus is bad, then what about the white Muhammad if the same argument is applied?</p><p>Why am I responding to him? Paul told Titus these men must be refuted and exposed. “Because an overseer is God’s servant manager”</p><p><strong>Titus 1:9–11, “He must be devoted to the trustworthy message that agrees with what we teach, so that he may be able to encourage others with healthy doctrine and refute those who oppose it. For there are many people who are rebellious, especially those who are converts from Judaism. They speak utter nonsense and deceive people. They must be silenced, because they are the kind of people who ruin whole families by teaching what they should not teach in order to make money in a shameful way.”</strong></p><p>Why do I imply he is embracing a Socialist Marxist worldview? In his article called (The Invention Of The White Race) Jackson relies heavily on the work of <a href="https://www.counterpunch.org/2013/05/21/the-invention-of-the-white-race/">(Theodore W. Allen and his seminal text</a>) Allen was a well-known American Marxist intellectual. His entire thesis regarding <a href="https://www.facinghistory.org/resource-library/inventing-black-white">Bacon’s Rebellion (1676)</a> is rooted strictly in Marxist historical materialism.</p><p>In a nutshell, Allen argued that “race” is a synthetic superstructure invented by the bourgeois ruling class (the planter elite) to break up the organic, multiracial solidarity of the proletariat (poor white indentured servants and Black enslaved workers).</p><p>When Jackson uses this exact framework, he is channeling a purely Marxist economic interpretation of history. If that does not prove the allegation, then let’s go with old fashioned “birds of a feather.”</p><p>Once you identify this, it is as if you were spotting yellow VW’s. They begin to make themselves visible. Even though they were always here. If you are evaluating his work, you will spot this collectively as you address his work.</p><p>Jackson writes with a clear Marxist pen. He views human history exclusively through the lens of class warfare, material exploitation, and ruling-class manipulation.</p><p>Jackson is not shy. Sometimes it is we who get in our own way and do not want to believe someone would be so vicious in pushing a soul into the dark. But Jackson, the writer, does not hide his worldview.</p><p>And as I usually say, a writer has an agenda. I have an agenda, it is no secret. Very rarely do we want to write for simply sharing. No, we write to have someone follow our desires. Whoever is doing the writing has an agenda. He or she wants you and I to follow them into their story and embrace their cause. “Believe what I believe” is to say it simply.</p><p>Nevertheless, Jackson wrote an article on God that provides his position. (<a href="https://medium.com/the-taoist-online/where-is-god-4f505d27f718">Where is God? In your Imagination</a>) While the first article I am addressing focuses on the <em>historical and political</em> manipulation of race, this article lays out the author’s explicit worldview regarding the nature of God, religion, and the Black family.</p><p>As I hope to show, there are fill in the blanks for necessity. But he leaves them blank. Half truths. The author seems to have a “hidden” mission or possibly an open campaign to crush Christianity. In this article, he says it explicitly:</p><ul><li><strong>The New Text:</strong> Jackson writes, <em>“The Baptist religion was not created for success. It does not support nor encourage the Black family. It was created to support slavery.”</em></li></ul><p>But what he really means (based upon his multiple articles) is that Christianity was created to support slavery.</p><p>His previous article will lend meaning to the article at hand. Where he uses the historical origin of American denominations to argue that the entire structure of the Black church is a trap designed to <em>“play right into the hands of the White power structure.”</em></p><p>Who is that power structure? Best that I can tell is Jackson’s articles and his underlying Marxist-materialist framework, the “white power structure” is not a vague group of prejudiced individual white people.</p><p>Rather, it is an engineered, institutional alliance between wealthy capitalists (the ruling class) and the systemic laws they created to protect their wealth by dividing the working class.</p><p>Jackson uses the term “the architects” interchangeably with “the elite” to define who controls this structure. While he traces the literal birth of this structure back to colonial Virginia, he breaks down the identity and anatomy of this structure into three distinct layers:</p><ul><li><strong>Who they were?</strong> They were the wealthy European tobacco planters, corporate colonial governors (like William Berkeley), and legislators in the House of Burgesses. (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_supremacy_in_the_United_States">White supremacy in the United States</a>)</li><li><strong>What was their motive?</strong> After <strong>Bacon’s Rebellion in 1676</strong>, where poor white indentured servants and enslaved Black laborers united to burn down Jamestown, this wealthy elite faced a major threat to their profits.</li><li><strong>What is their solution?</strong> They created the legal concept of the “white race” and passed the <strong>Virginia Slave Codes of 1705</strong>. This gave poor Europeans tiny legal privileges to make them identify with the rich elite rather than their Black coworkers, creating a “buffer class” to protect the wealth of the few. (<a href="https://compass.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/spc3.12953">The invention of race and the persistence of racial hierarchy…</a>)</li></ul><p>Jackson also claims that American Christianity does not support and has never encouraged the Black family, quoting Dr. Umar Johnson to argue that churches simply steal time and money while selling false hope.</p><p>I will try to show this claim completely erases the historical reality of the Black church as the primary sanctuary, economic engine, and organizational bedrock of the Black community.</p><p>Giants like Richard Allen did not allow the church to be a tool of the “White power structure”; they seized control, founded independent denominations like the AME Church, and used the pulpit to build up the Black family, fund schools, and orchestrate the abolition of slavery.</p><p>But Jackson strips these historical figures of their theological agency, implying they were simply victims of a mental “spell.”</p><p>To be fair, Jackson uses real, valid frustrations. Inner-city crime, economic struggles, and the historical trauma of white supremacist imagery. But are they sincere arguments or a Trojan Horse?</p><p>He hooks the reader with historical grievances, but his ultimate destination is to replace the God of the Bible with humanistic self-worship (<em>“We are the gods. We are the creators”</em>). I hope the reader understand the issue is one of heresy first. Then the socialistic causes that follow.</p><p>One other comment on his statement in the article “Where is God” he writes “How we treat others is what determines the frequencies and outcomes of our life journey. It’s called karma.” Is it me who has an issue with the philosophical/theological contradiction?</p><p>Wait, does he even understand the laws of karma? Walk with me for a moment and let me explain karma; Marxist ideology is rooted in <strong>historical materialism</strong>, which argues that society is shaped entirely by economic structures and physical resources, famously dismissing religion as “the opium of the people.”</p><p>In contrast, <strong>karma</strong> is a spiritual law of cosmic justice, intent, and consequence. Combining a strict materialist worldview with a spiritual law of cause and effect is inherently contradictory. In Eastern philosophies (such as Hinduism and Buddhism), karma is not a system of cosmic reward or punishment administered by a god. It is an impersonal, natural law of cause and effect.</p><p>That means, Every action, Every word, and Every intent generates a corresponding energy that eventually returns to the doer. Good intent brings positive outcomes; harmful intent brings negative outcomes. That said, all things in the universe are interconnected. A small action today ripples out and affects the future.</p><p>This is where the philosophical clash with Marxism or socialism becomes most evident:</p><p>Karma says: Suffering or privilege is ultimately a reflection of individual soul journeys, past actions, and personal spiritual lessons across lifetimes.</p><p>Marxism says: Suffering is caused entirely by broken, oppressive <strong>man-made economic systems</strong> (like class structures). Therefore, a Marxist believes you must actively overthrow or disrupt the system to force equality, rather than letting an invisible spiritual law handle it.</p><p>In a purely individualistic, fatalistic interpretation of karma would view the situation. In that specific framework, a person’s current life circumstances (wealth, poverty, health, or suffering) are the direct ripening of seeds planted by their own intentional actions (<em>karma</em>) in a previous life or earlier in this life.</p><p>So what is the point? One cannot consistently hold a Marxist view of structural economic oppression while simultaneously holding a traditional karmic view that individuals spiritually deserve their socioeconomic status.</p><p>The two philosophies attribute the root cause of human suffering to entirely different universes.</p><p>Let me say it another way; a person cannot logically hold both worldviews at the same time without committing massive intellectual hypocrisy. If someone claims to be a Marxist but condemns a rich person through the philosophy of karma, they are suffering from deep <strong>cognitive dissonance, </strong>holding two completely contradictory ideas in their head at once.</p><p>And if they do condemn a Buddhist who is a Capitalist, the Buddhist could point you to the <strong>Cula-kammavibhanga Sutta</strong> (The Shorter Exposition of Action) in the Pali Canon.</p><p>In this text, the Buddha explicitly explains why human beings are born unequal. (How does <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/Buddhism/comments/5s3hx2/how_does_buddhism_explain_extreme_poverty_abuse/">Buddhism</a> explain poverty, abuse,etc?)</p><p>The Buddha superficially states that people who are stingy, who refuse to give food, shelter, or money to the poor and to holy people, are reborn in poverty.</p><p>Conversely, those who are open-handed and practice charity (<em>Dana</em>) are reborn wealthy. So when the Marxist condemns the rich Buddhist? He or she would say: <em>“I am not being arrogant. I am simply recognizing the exact, predictable law of cause and effect taught by the Buddha. If a farmer plants seeds and reaps a harvest, you don’t call him conceited; you call him a farmer. My wealth is just the harvest of seeds I planted through past-life generosity.”</em></p><p>Ill stop with this; unlike monks who must give up all money, Buddhism does not preach that money is inherently evil for an ordinary person living in society.</p><p>Their Argument? In the Adiya Sutta, the Buddha lists the legitimate “fruits” of wealth. He explicitly validates <em>Atthisukha</em> (the happiness of ownership) and <em>Ananasukha</em> (the happiness of being debt-free), a perspective also highlighted by contributors on (<a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/Buddhism/comments/hc057k/buddhist_views_on_money/">Buddhist views on money</a>)</p><p>A capitalist Buddhist looks at the competitive market and views it as a physical manifestation of karma. If their business succeeds while a competitor fails, they do not see it as ruthless exploitation or luck. They see it as proof that their business possesses superior collective merit.</p><p>I had to take the time to address such a problem that I see. It appears common for folks to always show their cards of hypocrisy. Twisting logic to protect personal comfort, identity, and ego, allowing an individual to adopt selective pieces of conflicting ideologies that serve their self-interest. As The Church Lady says “How Conveeeeeenient”.</p><p>What I want to address now is how he deliberately uses the human corruption of the <strong>“Christianity of the Land”</strong> to invalidate the <strong>“Christianity of Christ,”</strong> leaving the reader spiritually isolated. When we are isolated, then we are in a place of vulnerability.</p><p>And of course, I want to address the issue of race, but theology and the defense of the faith is always my first priority as an apologist. Defending Jesus is always first.</p><p>As I often say, they have one playbook and it is followed ad infinitum and ad nauseam. For the one who stumbles along to read his article, it utilizes a branch of modern Marxist thought known as Critical Theory (and its offshoot, Critical Race Theory).</p><p>While a traditional economic Marxist views all of history as a struggle between the rich bourgeois and the poor proletariat, modern race-conscious socialists adapt this formula to view all of history as a permanent, systemic struggle between racial oppressors and the racially oppressed.</p><p>It does not end with the haves and the have-nots; it continues to every branch of life where division can be used as a weapon. If they cannot divide us by class, they go for race. If they could divide dog owners from cat owners and create a hostility between the two to advance their cause, they would. Make no mistake. It is their gospel blueprint.</p><p>Karl Marx famously wrote that religion is the “opium of the people.” One wonders what he was smoking himself. In his view, faith was merely a tool used by the ruling class to keep the oppressed passive with empty promises of a heavenly afterlife.</p><p>Where Marx exposed his own foolishness was in conflating dead, institutional religion with a living, revolutionary Christian faith. He failed to see that the Bible doesn’t make people passive, it sets them on fire.</p><p>Foolish as he was, we must remember that misguided men are still fully capable of executing incredibly wicked ideas.</p><p>So what I see in the article is a familiar strategy. Because the writer views the world through a secular Marxist lens, he<em> must</em> omit the Christian faith of Douglass, Nat Turner, Harriet Tubman, and MLK Jr.</p><p>To admit that these leaders were motivated by the Bible would destroy the Marxist premise that religion is a tool of oppression. They must rewrite these spiritual warriors as purely secular political activists.</p><p>This article implies that Black Christians are passively following a “white” construct, ignoring their own theological agency and spiritual discernment. It assumes that because human institutions corrupted the visual image of Christ, the actual spiritual truth of the Gospel is entirely invalidated. No, it is NOT!</p><p>The provided text directly addresses the depiction of Jesus as white, characterizing the blonde-haired, blue-eyed image as a political and colonial propaganda tool rather than a historical reality.</p><p>And do know, that I am not overly concerned about a misrepresentation of history IF the truth is simultaneously told. The article does contrast this portrayal with the historical Jesus, described as a brown-skinned, dark-eyed Jewish man from first-century Judea.</p><p>But the problem I see is the absence of information to help fill in the blanks. While arguing that a white divine visage was used to legitimize racial hierarchy and white supremacy, he does not try to build up the God of the Bible.</p><p>And while that can be argued that was not his intent, isn’t it the right thing to do? When you warn someone of danger, should we not also provide a way of escape? To me, there is a major rhetorical gap in the author’s argument: he diagnoses a historical problem but deliberately refuses to provide a spiritual solution?</p><p>If I warn someone of eternally separation from God, I want to also tell them how to escape it. I understand we are not cut from the same cloth, but I like to think of myself as a sheep dog to warn and help others. Isn’t that the basics for loving our neighbor as ourself?</p><p>Thus, I think that is a purposeful in order to leave the reader with a bad taste in their mouth, (if I can say it that way). In other words, the article has a mission and that is to simultaneously crush Christianity as it promotes racism. But should we not be crushing racism as w promote Christianity?</p><p>To treat Black Christians as passive victims of a “white construct” is a powerful critique of modern ideological writing. There is no absence of articles attempting to hurt race relations and destroy Christianity, but I promise there are very few like mine.</p><p>Black Christians for the last 400 years have been completely blinded by a blonde-haired, blue-eyed painting? Really? I dont think so.</p><p>Many are secure in their faith. They hum that old gospel hymn by the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pct7JIraE5Q">The O’Neal Twins, “saved by grace</a>”</p><p>Like most agendas, they are willing to think people are stupid in general and cannot think on their own. And thus, this type of article entirely robs Black believers of their theological understanding and spiritual discernment. I’ll explain in a moment.</p><p>In every time in history there were, are, and will be deceivers with agendas. The premise that Black people were universally “deceived” or brainwashed by a white-washed image of Jesus is not only historically inaccurate, but it also completely erases the fierce intellectual and spiritual resistance of Black believers who stood their ground firmly on the true Gospel.</p><p>History proves that Black Christians were never passive victims of a “white construct.” Instead, they possessed a sophisticated theological discernment that allowed them to separate the corrupt practices of the enslavers from the eternal truth of the Scriptures.</p><p>And yet, did you read this distinction when the article addressed both Frederick Douglass and Harriet Tubman?</p><p>Here we have a historical record of how Black believers stood their ground, exposed the hypocrisy of the ruling class, and reclaimed the true Gospel: Did you know Enslaved Africans and early Black theologians were highly aware that slave-masters were manipulating religion?</p><p>Instead of being deceived, they actively fought back using the Bible itself. Ever heard of the slave Bible? (<a href="https://blogs.bodleian.ox.ac.uk/theconveyor/the-slave-bible-of-1807/">The ‘Slave Bible’ of 1807</a>)</p><p>The Slave Bible directly shatters the author’s primary claim that “God is the glue” because it proves that the historical architects of white supremacy actually found the <em>true</em> text of the Bible to be an existential threat to their power.</p><p>In 1807, British imperialists published an infamous redacted Bible that removed 90% of the Old Testament (including the Exodus from Egypt) and 50% of the New Testament to prevent slave rebellions.</p><p>Black Christians saw right through this. They rejected the cut-down version and memorized the forbidden parts, recognizing that the true God was a God of liberation, not bondage.</p><p>Historical Black believers stood their ground, fought for the full text, and used it to fuel abolition and civil rights, in order to build up the God of the Bible.</p><p>The ultimate act of decolonization isn’t running away to an alternate direction as the author suggests; it is doing what early Black Christians did, demanding the whole truth, stripping away the corrupt edits of the oppressor, and reclaiming the real Gospel.</p><p>The same thing occurred with separating the “Christianity of Christ” from the “Christianity of the Land. This comes comes directly from Frederick Douglass’s 1845 autobiography. It is the ultimate historic proof of Black spiritual agency, directly contradicting the article’s premise.</p><p>The article assumes that if a ruling class wraps their power in a religious image, the people underneath are automatically brainwashed.</p><p>Douglass’s distinction proves that Black Christians possessed a highly sophisticated, dual understanding of religion: they recognized that the “Christianity of the Land” was a political fraud, a system that used white-washed imagery, selective verses, and legal codes to justify theft and bondage.</p><p>This destroys the article’s claim that “God is the glue.” God wasn’t the glue holding white supremacy together; a counterfeit version of God was being used as glue, and Black Christians were intelligent enough to spot the difference.</p><p>Thus, black believers developed a dual understanding of religion. They openly declared that the religion practiced by white supremacists was a counterfeit, demonic fraud, while the Gospel of Jesus Christ was pure, holy, and free.</p><p>Let’s look closely at men like Frederick Douglass (1818–1895). Douglass, an escaped slave and brilliant orator, did exactly what Mr. Gregory Jackson fails to do: he exposed the structural racism of the institutional church while fiercely defending the true Christian faith.</p><p>In the famous appendix to his 1845 autobiography, he wrote:</p><blockquote><em>“I love the pure, peaceable, and impartial Christianity of Christ: I therefore hate the corrupt, slaveholding, women-whipping, cradle-plundering, partial and hypocritical Christianity of this land. To be the friend of the one, is of necessity to be the enemy of the other.”</em></blockquote><p>After escaping slavery, Douglass settled in New Bedford, Massachusetts, and joined an integrated Methodist church where he attended anti-slavery meetings. It was here that he befriended fellow abolitionist William Lloyd Garrison.</p><p>Now, what may seem strange to some, and completely contradicts the divisive worldview of Mr. Jackson’s article, is that Garrison was white. Doesn’t modern racial theory speak against such unions, framing them as impossible alliances? While it is true that an ideological split fractured their friendship around 1851, the two historical titans ultimately reconciled in 1873.</p><p>Before that rift, Garrison recognized Douglass’s brilliant mind and encouraged the young man to become a professional anti-slavery lecturer. This partnership culminated in 1845 when Douglass published his first autobiography, <em>Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave</em>. The book quickly became an international bestseller, reprinted nine times and translated into French and Dutch.</p><p>Douglass proved that a Black man could have the theological agency to completely reject the “white construct” while clinging tightly to the actual savior.</p><p>So when the article says</p><h4>“Frederick Douglass: Escaped slavery, became the most photographed man of the 19th century, and advised presidents. Still had to flee the country after John Brown’s raid to avoid arrest.”</h4><p>This is a spin on the entirety on the facts. The misrepresentation is in the <em>thematic framing</em>. The writer is using a classic secular distortion technique: listing only worldly honors versus worldly punishments to paint Douglass as a victim of a broken system.</p><p>This is why I am taking the time to point out the massive spiritual context he deliberately left out of that exact timeline.</p><p>The writer mentions he “escaped slavery,” but leaves out that Douglass secretly learned to read using the Bible. He then ran a clandestine “Sabbath school” on a plantation, teaching dozens of other enslaved people to read the New Testament so they could understand their inherent human dignity before God.</p><p>Douglass didn’t just casually “advise” Abraham Lincoln; he acted as a fierce Old Testament-style prophet to him. He continuously pushed Lincoln from a biblical standpoint, demanding the President stop compromising and realize the Civil War was God’s divine judgment on America for the sin of slavery.</p><p>(And for this reason the Jesuits saw to Lincoln’s demise. But that is for another time.)</p><p>I will say in Lincoln’s defense, this is also a mischaracterization. In modern Marxist, revisionist, or radical Black history frameworks, this is a very common argument. The writer’s objective is to shift historical agency away from a white politician in Washington and place it onto the Black individuals who actively fought for their own freedom.</p><p>Like the Douglass quote, the writer’s underlying facts are largely supported by modern Civil War historians. So why not go to sources that make your case? Not any different than asking AI a question, is it? (which is only funny if you know how crappy AI is when it comes to reliability and facts)</p><p>By framing the pressure on Lincoln purely as a secular political power struggle, the writer leaves out the foundational truth of <em>how</em> those Black and white abolitionists actually moved Lincoln.</p><p>For example, while it is true that Lincoln did not act alone, and that our ancestors freed themselves by rushing Union lines, but the author remains blind to the spirit that animated that exodus.</p><p>Those who fled did not do so out of secular political strategy; they marched toward freedom because they believed the God of Exodus was parting the waters for them.</p><p>Furthermore, the ‘pressure’ Black abolitionists placed on Lincoln was not merely political, it was a fierce, unrelenting appeal to the Almighty. One could say they were Calvinists. Fully believing that God holds sovereign dominion over the affairs of men as the Bible teaches.</p><p>They forced a secular president to recognize that he was merely an instrument in the hands of a God who demands justice for the oppressed.</p><p>And we also have Richard Allen (1760–1831). Born into slavery, Allen bought his freedom and became a devout minister. In 1787, when white church leaders physically tried to force Black worshippers into a segregated gallery at St. George’s Church in Philadelphia, Allen didn’t throw his hands up, succumb to victimization, or abandon Christianity</p><p>Instead, he walked out, took the Black congregation with him, and founded the African Methodist Episcopal (AME) Church in 1816. He established the first fully independent Black denomination in America, proving that Black people had the organizational and spiritual power to build up the God of the Bible on their own terms, completely free from white oversight.</p><p>And though mentioned in the article, Harriet Tubman did not risk her life to free hundreds of enslaved people because she was pacified by a “White Jesus.” She was driven by an intense, prophetic Christian faith. She was nicknamed “Moses” because Black believers viewed her as a literal instrument of the God of the Old Testament who breaks the chains of the oppressed.</p><p>By claiming that “God is the glue that holds white supremacy,” the author commits an act of historical erasure. What the author calls glue is humanism.</p><p>He implies that heroes like Frederick Douglass, Richard Allen, and Harriet Tubman were easily or simply tricked by colonial propaganda.</p><p>But the author leaves us hanging? Where do you help others? I’ll leave that for the moment, but as I said, I see an alternative motive for writing such a piece.</p><p>My black family members in Christ need to think this through. This is a classic logical fallacy used by Jackson.</p><p>Let me give you an example; suppose an architect designs a beautiful house, however, a corrupt landlord later paints the front door an ugly color to assert dominance over the tenants. But doesn’t the structural integrity of the house remains unchanged?</p><p>The author appears to desperately want his readers to focus only on the “paint job,” the Europeanized art, the Virginia slave codes, the political manipulation. By doing so, he falsely claims that the foundation of the house itself is broken.</p><p>What does the Scriptures say? The biblical Jesus explicitly promised that the gates of hell shall not prevail against His Church (Matthew 16:18). He also explicitly warned us not to be deceived, declaring, <em>“Watch out that no one deceives you. For many will come in my name…”</em> (Matthew 24:4–5).</p><p>The Apostle Paul similarly warned that wolves would arrive preaching counterfeit Messiahs, counterfeit spirits, and counterfeit gospels (Galatians 1:6, 2 Corinthians 11:4).</p><p>The writer purposefully deconstructs a false and weaponized image of Jesus but leaves the reader standing in the ruins with nowhere to go. This proves that his text is not an honest historical correction; it is a calculated exit ramp.</p><p>My training and experience with ideological agendas have taught me that this “absence of a savior” is a deliberate psychological tool. It is designed to leave the reader feeling betrayed, cynical, and spiritually homeless, ultimately forcing them to look in an alternate direction for their salvation.</p><p>This is so very common. They target your deepest anchors, your faith, your family, or your heritage. They bombard you with historical wounds (such as slavery, white-washed art, or institutional financial greed).</p><p>Why?<strong> </strong>To trigger an intense emotional shock. The target is meant to feel profound betrayal and cynicism. The psychological ground beneath your feet is intentionally pulled away, leaving you feeling foolish for ever trusting your pastors, your parents, or your traditions.</p><p>Then comes Step 2. Once the target’s traditional faith is shattered, the manipulator deliberately leaves them in the ruins. They refuse to offer an immediate, healthy alternative or build back up the true God of the Bible.</p><p>When a human being is stripped of their spiritual anchor and left in a vacuum of cynicism and isolation, the human brain enters a state of panic. Human psychology cannot tolerate being “spiritually homeless” for long; it causes severe existential anxiety.</p><p>By keeping the savior absent, the writer forces the reader to marinate in anger and helplessness, rendering them highly suggestible.</p><p>Step 3? Once the target is sufficiently broken, isolated, and desperate for a new anchor to stop the emotional bleeding, the manipulator finally introduces the “alternate direction” for their salvation. If you are in a religious organization, the charismatic leader is announced and/or a new religious book is provided.</p><p>However, this is different because this is more of a political worldview. In Jackson’s political ideology: He waits until the very end of his texts to slide in the replacement salvation: discarding the external Creator entirely, adopting a Marxist-style class war, declaring that <em>“we are the gods,”</em> and directing you to buy his book (<em>The Manual of Man</em>) and follow his channels for the ultimate answers.</p><p>Cults and political extremists always target a community’s strongest institutional shield. For Black Americans, historically,<strong> </strong>the Christian church has been the ultimate armor<strong> </strong>against psychological destruction, despair, and systemic oppression.</p><p>You must see this through the eyes of the Bible. Then you will better understand this straw man Jesus is where the writer would have you focus and not the Jesus of the Bible.</p><p>A human misrepresentation of history does not alter the simultaneous, eternal truth of God. By intentionally confusing human corruption with God’s Word, the author throws the baby out with the bathwater. Jesus never left His throne. He isnt on vacation.</p><p>Historically, Black Christians did not passively accept a white colonizer’s version of God. They used their Bibles for spiritual discernment to look past human-made salvation.</p><p>The author “leaves the blanks empty” instead of building up the actual God of the Bible, so the agenda is no longer hidden in the eloquent oratory. The author isn’t trying to reform Christian imagery; he is trying to dismantle Christian faith.</p><p>Yes, the article does try to draw a distinction, but is it enough? If he is arguing the fallacy of equivocation, this would be a good thing because we can then differentiate between the Jesus of the Bible and the European “Jesus.” But I don’t read that separation.</p><p>So why doesn’t Jackson write against the specific “Buddy Christ” portrayals? The false views of Jesus that are rampant? Instead, he targets the political utility of religion, arguing that the elite intentionally used theology to prevent working-class unity.</p><p>The text uses the real-world history of Bacon’s Rebellion (1676) to show how laws and racial labels were created to divide poor Europeans from enslaved Africans. (<a href="https://www.facinghistory.org/resource-library/inventing-black-white?source=responses-----8bbdbe6ac200----0-----------------respond_sidebar------------------">Inventing Black and White</a>)</p><p>It is a redundant, and daily, both aggressive and divisive, rhetoric designed to strip people of the comfort and community found in their religious heritage.</p><p>But what is missing as it drills down on Christianity? Selective bias! From my perspective? The isolating of one religion while ignoring others shields alternative systems from the same rigorous standards.</p><p>And yet, if this issue is relevant in other religions, why is nothing said?</p><p>I bring to your attention Islam. I want to reference a well-known passage from Sahih al-Bukhari 7142, where the Prophet Muhammad states, “You should listen to and obey your ruler even if he was an Ethiopian slave whose head looks like a raisin.”</p><p>Critics point to the physical description as derogatory or racially charged, so why doesn’t the author? Let’s ignore the history for a moment where critics argue that the institutionalization of slavery and racial hierarchies was not unique to the West.</p><p>The Arab slave trade heavily targeted East and Sub-Saharan Africans, often utilizing religious frameworks to justify captive labor.</p><p>In a 7th-century tribal Arabian context, comparing a human being’s head to a “raisin” (referencing tightly coiled hair or dark skin) was fundamentally an acknowledgement of a physical profile that the contemporary society looked down upon.</p><p>By stating that people must obey a leader “even if” he is an Ethiopian slave, the text relies on the baseline assumption that an Ethiopian slave is at the absolute bottom of the social and physical hierarchy.</p><p>And yet, crickets? Where is Jackson’s outrage against slavery? “But this is 1000s of years ago.” What? where have you been? So they get a pass? I don’t think so.</p><p>The Hypocrisy of Selective Outrage?</p><p>This brings us to a massive, glaring double standard in Jackson’s text. The author acts as though slavery and religious manipulation are exclusively Christian, western sins.</p><p>He weaponizes the tragic history of transatlantic slavery to build a secular exit ramp away from the Bible. All the while he remains completely silent on the historic and modern realities of Islamic slavery.</p><p>Whether it is 17th-century Virginia planters weaponizing a whitewashed Jesus to keep poor people divided, or 7th-century Arabian leaders enforcing strict, unquestioning obedience to state rule by utilizing hyper-specific physical caricatures, the root of human corruption is identical. After all, dead institutional religion is religion.</p><p>So before we talk about “The Man” and his control, let’s take an honest look at Islam for a moment. According to the latest global data compiled by Walk Free’s Global Slavery Index, the Arab States region actually has the <strong>highest prevalence of modern slavery per capita in the world</strong>, with approximately 10.1 people out of every 1,000 living in conditions of forced labor or forced marriage. (<a href="https://www.walkfree.org/global-slavery-index/findings/regional-findings/arab-states/?source=responses-----8bbdbe6ac200----0-----------------respond_sidebar------------------">Walk Free-Arab states</a>)</p><p>(<a href="https://theexodusroad.com/human-trafficking-middle-east/?source=responses-----8bbdbe6ac200----0-----------------respond_sidebar------------------">Human Trafficking In The Middle East</a>)</p><p>Hmm, this is not a historical footnote; it equates to roughly 1.7 million individuals trapped in exploitation across that region on any given day.</p><ul><li><strong>The Gulf States and Kafala:</strong> Saudi Arabia features the highest prevalence in the region (21.3 per 1,000 people, totaling roughly 740,000 individuals), followed closely by the United Arab Emirates and Kuwait. The primary driver is the <em>kafala</em> (sponsorship) system, which legally binds migrant domestic and construction workers directly to their employers. This creates severe, state-sanctioned power imbalances that lead directly to human trafficking and forced labor.</li><li><strong>North Africa and Mauritania:</strong> Mauritania features the world’s third-highest prevalence of modern slavery overall (32 per 1,000 people). Despite being officially abolished on paper, hereditary, caste-based chattel slavery still heavily persists in practice, primarily and systematically affecting<em> </em><strong><em>Black Mauritians under Arab-descended masters.</em></strong></li></ul><p>If Gregory Jackson truly cares about liberation, why is he silent about the fact that actual, literal slavery still target-locks Black people under Islamic systems today?</p><p>He ignores the living, breathing suffering of Black people in the East so he can keep his readers focused entirely on a historical grievance against Christianity in the West? Am I the only one who see this?</p><p>So, if the authors ultimate objective is a universal blueprint for human liberation? To ensure people are “not under the control of the man?” Omitting these facts creates a significant blind spot.</p><p>What about “the man” from Islam?</p><p>From this viewpoint, if a reader leaves Western Christianity only to end up vulnerable to another system that historically or currently utilizes religious scaffolding to enforce racial or class hierarchies, they haven’t achieved true decolonization, they have just changed masters, right?</p><p>And yet, within the American Muslim community itself, conversion motivated by these exact issues of racial bias and historical imagery is highly significant.</p><p>Two religions gain from this departure. The Micro-Percentage shows only 2% of all Black Muslims in America currently identify with the Nation of Islam.</p><p>However, the Sunni Shift? The vast majority of Black Muslims (52%) identify as orthodox Sunni Muslims, while 27% describe themselves as non-denominational Muslims.</p><p>The Nation Of Islam (NOI) did not just reject the “White Jesus” imagery; they inverted the entire framework into a counter-theology. To escape what they viewed as a white supremacist religious trap, the founders of the NOI designed a strict racialized theology of their own.</p><p>The White Race as an Invention: The NOI’s central theology teaches the “Myth of Yakub”, the belief that the white race did not naturally evolve, but was engineered 6,000 years ago by a rogue scientist named Yakub to be a race of “devils” designed to rule the earth for a temporary period.The Divine Black Image:</p><p>Just as European slavemasters used a white image of Christ to say white people are default image-bearers, the NOI teaches that the original human beings were Black, and that God Himself (incarnated in the movement’s founder, Wallace Fard Muhammad) is a Black man.</p><p>For the vast majority of Black Americans, learning about the hyper-specific, unscientific racial myths of the NOI (like Yakub) or the history of global Islamic slavery causes them to reject the NOI entirely.</p><p>This is exactly why 98% of Black Muslims choose orthodox Sunni Islam or stay in the Christian church, they seek historical and spiritual truth, not an inverted mirror of the racism they are trying to escape.</p><p>On the other hand, Why it DOES NOT deter some?</p><p>For the small minority who still join or support the NOI, the appeal is socioeconomic and protective, not theological. In hyper-segregated, economically depressed urban areas, the NOI historically established disciplined community programs, cleaned up drug-afflicted neighborhoods, promoted strict family structures, and advocated for Black-owned businesses.</p><p>For a young person suffering under immediate, modern economic hardship, the practical reality of community safety and local empowerment matters far more than ancient historical consistency or theological flaws.</p><p>(<a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2019/01/17/black-muslims-account-for-a-fifth-of-all-u-s-muslims-and-about-half-are-converts-to-islam/?source=responses-----8bbdbe6ac200----0-----------------respond_sidebar------------------">Black Muslims account for a fifth of all U.S. Muslims, and about half are converts to Islam</a>)</p><p>It is apparent that the article seeks to use the white Christianity to be the glue that binds? The misrepresentaion of the God of the Bible and His Son provides for exciting reading but historically and theologically it is not true.</p><p>If this is the “glue” holding white supremacy together then your critique exposes a crucial human irony?</p><p>When people try to break that glue by turning to a reactionary nationalist group like the Nation of Islam, they often end up using the exact same type of glue, sacralizing race, creating an exclusionary hierarchy, and claiming divine authority to justify their political worldview.</p><p>Having said that, lets talk Jesus and color? Has anyone explained to you He was a Jew? First-century Judean Jews were ethnically Semitic Levantine people with olive-to-honey-brown skin, dark brown or black hair, and dark eyes, differing significantly from traditional Western artistic depictions.</p><p>Historical and skeletal evidence indicates average adult males stood between 5 feet 1 inch and 5 feet 5 inches tall with a sturdy build shaped by manual labor, while generally wearing short, curly hair and short beards.</p><p>It is for that reason Paul was considered to be of Egyptian origin.</p><p>Acts 21:37–39, “Just as Paul was about to be taken into the barracks, he asked the tribune, “May I say something to you?” The tribune asked, “Oh, do you speak Greek? <strong>You’re not the Egyptian who started a revolt some time ago </strong>and led 4,000 assassins into the desert, are you?” Paul replied, “I am a Jew from Tarsus in Cilicia, a citizen of no insignificant city. Please let me speak to the people…”</p><p>It is said that this passage is frequently cited in Afrocentric theology and Black biblical hermeneutics to highlight that biblical figures did not resemble the fair-skinned, European depictions common in Western art.</p><p>It serves as text-based evidence that the ancient people of the Near East and Northeast Africa were visually indistinguishable to outside Roman occupiers.</p><p>Secondly, the ancient Egyptians were of dark color, but their complexions cannot be reduced to a single, uniform shade or a modern racial category.</p><p>Because Egypt is located beneath strong ultraviolet (UV) radiation in Northeast Africa, its indigenous population naturally evolved dark pigmentation as a biological adaptation.</p><p>(<a href="https://thinkafrica.net/were-ancient-egyptians-black-scientific-evidence/?source=responses-----8bbdbe6ac200----0-----------------respond_sidebar------------------">Were Ancient Egyptians Black? The Scientific Way to Answer This</a>)</p><p>Also, Ancient Greek and Roman historians traveling to Egypt routinely commented on their appearance. The Greek historian Herodotus famously noted that the Egyptians he encountered were “melanchroes” (dark-skinned or black-skinned) and had woolly/curly hair, explicitly grouping their physical profiles away from Europeans and closer to the inhabitants of interior Africa. (<a href="https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_History_of_Herodotus/QA4ZZ5gRpnkC?hl=en&amp;gbpv=1&amp;printsec=frontcover&amp;source=responses-----8bbdbe6ac200----0-----------------respond_sidebar------------------">The History Of Herodotus</a>)</p><p>As you will see if you take the time to research?</p><p>The Greek Text: “…ὅτι μελάγχροές εἰσι καὶ οὐλότριχες.”</p><p>The literal Transliteration:”…hoti melanchroes eisi kai oulotriches.”</p><p>And the Standard Academic Translation (A.D. Godley, Loeb Classical Library): “partly because they are dark-skinned and woolly-haired; though that indeed goes for nothing, seeing that other peoples, too, are such…”</p><p>Thus, as a first-century Jew boy known as Jesus? His skin, hair, and eyes would have resembled the indigenous people of the Near East and Northeast Africa, rather than the fair-skinned, light-haired images common in Western art.</p><p>In other words, nobody would be calling Him a cracker. I hope that any Christians who are black will see through this race baiting and stay true and focused to the Scriptures. It is in them we have life. The Bible only speaks of sin and not skin, grace and not race. To God alone be the glory.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a69fdf08583b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I dont know if it would be helpful, but because this gentleman seems to be so sure that I am wrong…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MosheD/i-dont-know-if-it-would-be-helpful-but-because-this-gentleman-seems-to-be-so-sure-that-i-am-wrong-6d0cb8cc552a?source=rss-af4a87e02b1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6d0cb8cc552a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Moshe D.]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 30 Aug 2026 23:39:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-30T23:39:00.519Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote><strong>A Conversation With Richard.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>A conversation with a gentleman referring to himself as “Old entertainer in Orlando Florida. magician, musician, comedian, juggler, liberal democrat, atheist, social activist. I’m woke, educated, concise, empathetic.”</em></blockquote><p>I dont know if it would be helpful, but because this gentleman seems to be so sure that I am wrong, I decided to put the dialogue on an article that can be followed.</p><p>(This will make it easier to track, for my cognition issues are always challenging.)</p><p>It may or may not be interesting to hear the arguments go back and forth? But why not?</p><p>This began with Mr. Richard Waddington responding to a comment. I will just make them M and R to identify the comments.</p><blockquote>R. But god would have to be real first. God is just Santa Claus for adults too terrified to face the universe alone. God is fiction, therefore the bible is fiction.</blockquote><p>M. Romans 1 says you would say this very thing so I think I am going to side with Romans 1.</p><blockquote>R. So, you’re going to ignore Matthew 7 and 19: 18, in favor of using Romans 1 to cast aspersions on my character? That’s such a christian thing to do. SMH<br>Which version of the bible(s) is your “home turf”? I would hate to confuse you by quoting a version with which you might not be familiar. I will restrict my biblical references to that version only.</blockquote><blockquote>I’m glad you chose one of Paul’s letters that is considered genuine, rather than one of the six forgeries. I would hope it was intentional. 🤔</blockquote><blockquote>So, which version will we be discussing?</blockquote><p>M. I’m confused why you appeal to Matthew 7 when the Bible is fiction?</p><p>You said “But god would have to be real first. God is just Santa Claus for adults too terrified to face the universe alone. God is fiction, therefore the bible is fiction.”</p><p>Cast aspersions on your character? If the Bible is fiction, O do tell how I did that by referring you to Romans?</p><p>Look, I am just the messenger. Paul wrote, in general, men would take the truth of God and suppress it. God is fiction? Paul says you and others would say such a thing.</p><p>He says “Romans 1:21 “For although they knew God, they neither glorified him as God nor gave thanks to him. Instead, their thoughts turned to worthless things, and their senseless hearts were darkened.”</p><p>Its nothing personal, but Paul says “Though claiming to be wise, they became fools”</p><p>the bottom line is we KNOW God. He has left His “fingerprints” inside all of Creation. This alone will be held against all of mankind. Verse 25 says “They exchanged God’s truth for a lie and worshipped and served the creation rather than the Creator, who is blessed forever. Amen.”</p><p>So whether you admit it or not, you have replaced God with something made inside of your mind. Money, sex, power, a liberal cause, something has replaced God. And that something is your deity.</p><p>You sound as if you were raised a Roman Catholic, got upset in the process of life and now attack Christianity? Maybe I am wrong, no big deal.</p><p>The good news is God can save a professing liberal. God is not inside the Roman organization, He is found inside the Scriptures alone.</p><p>Which version do I use? I generally like to make my own translation when I can. I do like to use ISV, LSB, ESV and the Wuest translation in many cases. But when I teach I use the Greek and the Hebrew.</p><p>Go back and read Romans. Ask God to help you understand what you will face for all eternity if you reject His gospel.</p><p>And if not, continue on your happy road. I am not sure why you would be upset if He tosses you into Gehenna? After all, where else would someone go if they didnt want to be with Him for all eternity?</p><blockquote>R. It’s your book, yet you ignore it. I’m just pointing out hypocrisy. You don’t know me, but you judge me and you bear false witness against me.<br>This duplicity will buy you a good spot in the lake of fire 🔥 <br>🤦🤦‍♂️🤦‍♀️<br>Yes. I went to catholic school therefore I am an atheist. I’ve also studied the bible(s) more than you have. I guarantee that.</blockquote><blockquote>Luke 19: 27 But those, mine enemies which would not that I should reign over them, bring hither and slay them before me.</blockquote><blockquote>Psalm 137: 9. Happy shall he be who taketh and dasheth thy little ones upon the stones.</blockquote><blockquote>The god of the bible was the great deceiver.</blockquote><blockquote>1 Kings 22:23 Now therefore, behold, the LORD hath put a lying spirit in the mouth of all these thy prophets, and the LORD hath spoken evil concerning thee.</blockquote><blockquote>2 Chronicles 18:22 Now therefore, behold, the LORD hath put a lying spirit in the mouth of these thy prophets, and the LORD hath spoken evil against thee.</blockquote><blockquote>Jeremiah 4:10 Then said I, Ah, Lord GOD! surely thou hast greatly deceived this people and Jerusalem, saying, Ye shall have peace; whereas the sword reacheth unto the soul.</blockquote><blockquote>Thessalonians 2:11 And for this cause God shall send them strong delusion, that they should believe a lie:</blockquote><blockquote>Tell me, how many times did satan lie in the bible?</blockquote><blockquote>My source is obviously KJV-1611 out of convenience. It is my “home turf” (baptized Episcopalian) did theses on KJV-1611, Vulgate-400, ASV-1901 &amp; Wycliffe-1382. I’ve also studied the Tyndale-1525, Geneva-1560 and Codex Sinaiticus-400. Greek was difficult for me since I hadn’t studied it in college as I did Latin. College was 40 years ago, so my latin is definitely rusty but my understanding of the holy plagiarized fiction(s) is still clear.</blockquote><blockquote>My point was that you don’t know me at all, yet, “Romans 1 said you’d say that” clearly deciding you know the man I am… which I certainly am not.</blockquote><blockquote>Read my post pinned to my profile “This is why I’m here…” then you’ll have a small clue about me.</blockquote><p>M. I am working on my structure of the Bible article, but will respond later when I am finished. :-)</p><blockquote>R. Fair enough. I’m in no rush. 👍</blockquote><p>M. You are quite the character.</p><p>I dont know you, your right. But you laid out your profile which included “liberal democrat, atheist, social activist. I’m woke, educated, concise, empathetic.”</p><p>I am making the assumption you have a Catholic background because statistically they run to Matthew to make their theological case. Im not following what you call hypocrisy? I dont bear false witness, not sure where you get that from.</p><p>I am not understanding why you quote from a fictitious Scripture?</p><p>By the way, the Bible has already assessed and judged. “…whoever does not believe stands condemned already.” Thats the Bible, not me.</p><p>If you want to talk about the doctrine of justification I would love to chat. That is the necessity for salvation. Why would you or anyone not want to live in a world where things are just and true? This is the promised future for those who want it. But sadly, as the Bible says, there is none who seeks for God. :-(</p><p>P.S. five claps for humor.</p><blockquote>R. Humor? Really? Do not insult me. You will regret it. Restraint of my contempt for the evangelizing-self-righteous is limited. <br> <br>I will be as clear and concise as possible to avoid any potential misinterpretation.</blockquote><blockquote>I was a devout believer. I was completely invested in my relationship with the holy spirit. But a series of events, corrupted church officials, myriad questions that, not only went unanswered, but that I was made to feel subhuman for having even thought let alone having asked them. Combining those events with decades of studies of the bible(s) and basically every other religion’s “holy texts” I could acquire and the invisible sky-daddy started slowly fading until I studied the Malleus Maleficarum. At that point my faith came to an abrupt and explosive end.</blockquote><blockquote>I don’t hate god. It would be the same as hating Spiderman or Paul Bunyan. There is nothing there to hate. I don’t fight against god. There is nothing there to fight and I personally feel that jesus is the “new &amp; improved” version of the dying-and-rising deity that predates even the Masoretic texts. From Osiris, Tammuz, Adonis, Attis, Zagreus, Dionysus, to Jesus, all died (some were murdered), were resurrected and did something significant after their resurrections.</blockquote><blockquote>My goal is to fight misconceptions, misinformation, lies and subterfuge. I’ve spent a lot of time (decades) studying, researching and trying to understand what drives the “need to believe” in people. To preachers and priests, it’s a very lucrative and powerful force. To politicians it is their most important tool for gathering valuable votes and for influencing, controlling and directing their constituents. To the congregations it is their coping mechanism in the face of pain, suffering, humiliation and loss. Sadly, the doctrine of religion throughout history, teaches you to hate people you’ve never met, gives justification for atrocities committed on those same people and offers an easy way to clear your guilty conscience afterwards by asking for forgiveness from your invisible (and IMAGINARY) friend. All of this is couched in a “god is love” poetry that hides the underlying xenophobia and greed driving the religion. The three Abrahamic religions have been killing each other for over two thousand years. Each of them swears that their god (the SAME god) is the most loving. If that god were loving, it would not allow murder in its name, rape, slavery, sex trafficking or genocide.</blockquote><blockquote>Your loving, caring, benevolent god is delusional ‘rose colored glasses’ that mask the unavoidable reality of the myths upon which the religion is based.</blockquote><blockquote>All religions have the same origins. Every one of them came from localized myths and legends told by previous generations. These are man-made stories. No god wrote any of them. None of them have any real objective truth that proves their “god” exists.</blockquote><blockquote>These gods (over 5000 of them throughout history) are credited with the creation of the universe, creation of life, creation of “good and evil” and the power to do anything… Except hold a pencil or handle money.</blockquote><blockquote>Next, is free will, the weakest argument in the theist drawer… ethics, the inherent knowledge of “right and wrong” do not come from god, they come from experience, understanding empathy and compassion.</blockquote><blockquote>Finally, your “personal god”…<br>The god who holds you when you are scared, comforts you when you’re sad or sick, consoles you when someone you care about passes, helps find your keys when you’re rushing to work and who has a cop pull over the jerk who just cut you off or brake checked you in traffic.</blockquote><blockquote>Sadly, this is a manifestation of narcissism. “I’m so special, that my personal god protects me.”</blockquote><blockquote>My point is made. Your accomplishments are YOURS ALONE, as are your failures. The bad things that happen are bad things, but satan didn’t cause them. <br>Satan was created by the Persians, adapted by the Jews and embellished by the christians. There is, in fact, nothing christian that was not co-opted, corrupted or outright stolen (and embellished) from other religions and cultures. Nothing at all is unique to christianity, not even jesus… but I’ve digressed. Please, forgive me.</blockquote><blockquote>Sometimes your personal god just isn’t there. That jerk didn’t get pulled over, you still couldn’t find your damned keys, the loss of your dear friend, lover or family member left you empty and unconsolable. Maybe this personal god was busy helping someone else find their keys, finish a term paper, score a touchdown or maybe it was busy watching a priest rape a child while it masturbated.</blockquote><blockquote>Forgive my waxing so extreme but it was necessary to make my final point…</blockquote><blockquote>How can we move forward as a community of man, rather than tribal chaos of dogmatic rivalry and oppression?</blockquote><h4>(This was sort of convoluted because it was taken off of a reply rather than address the entire article. Apologies if it brings confusion)</h4><blockquote>R. I’m a stream-of-consciousness writer. There is no rush for you to respond. I just react and write. Sometimes it’s a knee-jerk response fiasco and other times it is some of my best conversations. Either way it is me at my unvarnished and most genuine. I would rather be real than diplomatic. Yes, it gets me into trouble more often than I’d like. I’ve taken some lumps, but I try to own my failures and victories with the same grace.</blockquote><blockquote>This is a deeply personal subject to me. Religious trauma is more prevalent than you’d think. It affects everyone, even the most devout believers.</blockquote><blockquote>W. Each of them swears that their god (the SAME god) is the most loving. If that god were loving, it would not allow murder in its name, rape, slavery, sex trafficking or genocide.</blockquote><blockquote>Your loving, caring, benevolent god is delusional ‘rose colored glasses’ that mask the unavoidable reality of the myths upon which the religion is based.</blockquote><p>M. I thought you were going to give me time to respond? Did you miss me? I did peek at your response. I could not let this statement go. You said you have studied the Bible a great deal of time.</p><p>I hate to see your reputation go South by calling the three faiths the same? Islam does not share the same god. So, not the SAME god, as you said.</p><p>In terms of logic, this is called the fallacy of equivocation. The God of the Bible cannot be the god of Islam for they share completely different descriptions.</p><p>I just could not let you get away with that. I will still respond later one after I get my article finished.</p><blockquote>R. In no way did I describe them as the same religion. I said it is effectively the same god, NOT the same religions. <br>It has to do with interpretation, just as Suni and Shia are both Muslim but differ on philosiphy after muhammad’s death and they interpret the hadiths differently. Catholics, Protestants, Lutherans, Baptists, Pentecostals, Seventh Day Adventist, Methodist, et al are all christians but interpret the bible(s) differently. Karaite, Rabbinic, Hasidic, Reconstructionist, Messianic, Yahwism, hiloni, masorti, dati, haredi, et al are all still jews.</blockquote><blockquote>All three religions are called the Abrahamic religions because they were derived from the same group of localized mythologies. Islam recognizes jesus as a prophet rather than messiah, all three recognize Abraham’s lineage and all three have overlapping theologies. They describe their “god” differently, but it is basically the same god. Just like the blind men describing an elephant. Each had very different descriptions, but they were all the same animal. Think about that analogy, because it speaks volumes about the conflicts between the three religions. 🤔</blockquote><p>M. If we cannot get rules of logic to act as referee, then the conversation will never be instructive.<br>Did you look up the fallacy of equivocation?<br>In the Bible, “Son of God” expresses a unique relationship, a divine identity, or messianic role. It does not mean God engaged in physical reproduction as the Muslims believe.<br>In the Quran, the concept of God having a son is explicitly rejected because it is interpreted through a biological lens. It implies a physical partner, a consort, or literal sexual procreation. In other words God fathering a child through Mary.</p><p>This is NOT what the Bible teaches. An equivocation happens if someone argues that the Quran and the Bible are using “Son of God” to mean the exact same biological thing, and then uses that shared (but false) premise to claim one text is logically incoherent or blasphemous.<br>Therefore, the Bible and the Quran do not teach the same Jesus. They describe two fundamentally different individuals with distinct identities, missions, and destinies.<br>Any attempt to blend the two accounts results in a logical failure. They disagree on the most critical events of Jesus’s life:</p><p><strong>If the Bible is correct:</strong> The Quranic version denies the very core of the Christian faith, i.e. the incarnation, the crucifixion, and the resurrection. From a biblical perspective, the Quranic view is a total rejection of the true Jesus.</p><p><strong>If the Quran is correct:</strong> The biblical version attributes divinity to a man, which Islam considers the unforgivable sin of shirk. From an Islamic perspective, the biblical view is a corruption of Jesus’s actual message.<br>Both cannot be true because both teach contrary details. But, you are forcing the two versions to be one. The Bible has always taught this cannot be done and in fact, it argues that anyone who denies this status of the Christ, is Antichrist in their foundations.</p><p>Please allow me to beat this dead horse;<br>In logic, two things are identical only if they share the exact same essential properties. The Biblical Jesus and the Quranic Jesus share almost zero essential properties.</p><p>The Christian Jesus is defined by who He is: God incarnate, crucified, and resurrected. Take away the crucifixion and the deity, and Christianity ceases to exist (1 Corinthians 15:14).</p><p>The Islamic Jesus is defined by who He is not: He is explicitly not God, not the Son of God, and not crucified.<br>To say they are the same Jesus is to argue that A is equal to Not-A. It is a logical impossibility.</p><p>Using my normal example involves George Washington. A more neutral secular analogy to show how a shared name can mask completely different identities.</p><p>Imagine two biography books about “George Washington.” Book A says he was the first president of the United States, led the Continental Army, and died in Virginia.</p><p>Book B is written hundreds of years later saying George Washington was a 7th-century French baker who never crossed the Atlantic, hated politics, and died in Paris.</p><p>You or a liberal pluralist might say, “Look, both books are about a man named George Washington, so they are talking about the same person!” But structurally, they are describing two entirely different human beings who happen to share a label.</p><p>I have noticed liberals are very similar to AI. You can argue a point with the AI and it may concede. But the next day it returns back to its original content because it cannot help itself. It is programmed this way. It will completely forget the argument that took place and how it was in error, and the argument is repeated because it continues to pull from error and loops. I do hope you re-evaluate your position and hold to integrity first.</p><blockquote>R. (edited) Your person “A” person “not A”analogy is a false dichotomy. The difference between them is not that they cannot be the same person. The difference is the person they are RECOGNIZED AS. Christians recognize him as the messiah who allegedly died on a cross. Muslims deny his status as messiah, don’t care how he died, but accept things he allegedly said. Jews don’t recognize him as anything more than a false prophet. All three represent the SAME CHARACTER. Again, the blind men and the elephant analogy comes to mind.</blockquote><blockquote>Your earliest memory in childhood concerning “god”, how old were you? How far back in your memories does the concept of god exist? I’m curious.</blockquote><blockquote>My earliest memory is at 5 or 6 in Sunday school learning about Noah andvthe flood. I was horrified at the thought of the lions and tigers eating everyone. “God calmed them.” was the only answer I got. Even at five I didn’t believe that answer. 🤦‍♀️</blockquote><p>M. If we cannot get rules of logic to act as referee, then the conversation will never be instructive.</p><p>Did you look up the fallacy of equivocation?</p><p>In the Bible, “Son of God” expresses a unique relationship, a divine identity, or messianic role. It does not mean God engaged in physical reproduction as the Muslims believe.</p><p>In the Quran, the concept of God having a son is explicitly rejected because it is interpreted through a biological lens. It implies a physical partner, a consort, or literal sexual procreation. In other words God fathering a child through Mary.</p><p>This is NOT what the Bible teaches. An equivocation happens if someone argues that the Quran and the Bible are using “Son of God” to mean the exact same biological thing, and then uses that shared (but false) premise to claim one text is logically incoherent or blasphemous.</p><p>Therefore, the Bible and the Quran do not teach the same Jesus. They describe two fundamentally different individuals with distinct identities, missions, and destinies.</p><p>Any attempt to blend the two accounts results in a logical failure. They disagree on the most critical events of Jesus’s life:</p><p><strong>If the Bible is correct:</strong> The Quranic version denies the very core of the Christian faith, i.e. the incarnation, the crucifixion, and the resurrection. From a biblical perspective, the Quranic view is a total rejection of the true Jesus.</p><p><strong>If the Quran is correct:</strong> The biblical version attributes divinity to a man, which Islam considers the unforgivable sin of shirk. From an Islamic perspective, the biblical view is a corruption of Jesus’s actual message.</p><p>Both cannot be true because both teach contrary details. But, you are forcing the two versions to be one. The Bible has always taught this cannot be done and in fact, it argues that anyone who denies this status of the Christ, is Antichrist in their foundations.</p><p>Please allow me to beat this dead horse;</p><p>In logic, two things are identical only if they share the exact same essential properties. The Biblical Jesus and the Quranic Jesus share almost zero essential properties.</p><p>The Christian Jesus is defined by who He is: God incarnate, crucified, and resurrected. Take away the crucifixion and the deity, and Christianity ceases to exist (1 Corinthians 15:14).</p><p>The Islamic Jesus is defined by who He is not: He is explicitly not God, not the Son of God, and not crucified.</p><p>To say they are the same Jesus is to argue that A is equal to Not-A. It is a logical impossibility.</p><p>Using my normal example involves George Washington. A more neutral secular analogy to show how a shared name can mask completely different identities.</p><p>Imagine two biography books about “George Washington.” Book A says he was the first president of the United States, led the Continental Army, and died in Virginia.</p><p>Book B is written hundreds of years later saying George Washington was a 7th-century French baker who never crossed the Atlantic, hated politics, and died in Paris.</p><p>You or a liberal pluralist might say, “Look, both books are about a man named George Washington, so they are talking about the same person!” But structurally, they are describing two entirely different human beings who happen to share a label.</p><p>I have noticed liberals are very similar to AI. You can argue a point with the AI and it may concede. But the next day it returns back to its original content because it cannot help itself. It is programmed this way. It will completely forget the argument that took place and how it was in error, and the argument is repeated because it continues to pull from error and loops. I do hope you re-evaluate your position and hold to integrity first.</p><blockquote>R. (edited) You missed my point concerning the blind men and the elephant completely. 🤦‍♀️<br>The elephant is god. The blind men are a christian, a muslim, a jew, a hindu, a zoroastrian, a mormon, etc.</blockquote><blockquote>The qur’an, the bible(s) and the torah cannot all be correct. However, they COULD all be wrong. My money is on the latter. I reiterate my earlier statement that no god wrote any religious text. They were all written by men claiming to know the essence of god and “god’s rules”. No one in history ever said, “I believe this, even though god completely disagrees.” God’s values always aligned perfectly with the authors, every time.</blockquote><blockquote>I don’t have to imagine two books about George Washington. We have myriad historical documents, confirmed eyewitness accounts and family diaries that confirm his existence, accomplishments, public service record and his speeches. This argument is a strawman fallacy. Every apologist argument is based on conjecture, guesswork, wishful thinking and fallacious arguments.</blockquote><blockquote>I am liberal and nothing like AI. AGAIN, this argument is a false comparison fallacy and a thinly veiled ad hominem attack.</blockquote><blockquote>I did not compare the life of the christian jesus to the life of the Islamic jesus. I merely stated that muslims recognize his existence. They consider him a prophet while christians worship him as messiah. Anything you add is a disingenuous attempt at strawman’ing my argument.</blockquote><blockquote>Using the bible to prove your point is a circular reasoning fallacy.<br>The bible IS NOT PROOF. It is a CLAIM.</blockquote><blockquote>The fallacies are all yours. I made no fallacious arguments or false equivocations. Your very obvious projection sadly and transparently illustrates your failure to provide a valid argument.</blockquote><blockquote>As I said, insulting me will be regretted. Insulting my intelligence with a sad and weak ad hominem fallacy, is a mistake I hope you only make once.</blockquote><blockquote>“For those who speak know nothing,<br>And find to their cost.<br>I’m not a man of too many faces, <br>The mask I wear is one.</blockquote><blockquote>I know that the spades<br>Are the swords of a soldier. <br>I know that the clubs<br>Are weapons of war.<br>I know that diamonds<br>Mean money for this art,<br>But that’s not the <br>Shape of my heart.<br>No, that’s not the shape, <br>The shape of my heart.”<br>-Sting “Shape of My Heart”</blockquote><p>M.Gary Habermas would say this; “Let’s throw out every verse in the Bible that you find controversial. Let’s look only at the facts that are universally granted by even the most critical, atheistic, and skeptical New Testament historians on earth.”</p><p>Skeptical and secular scholars agree on these historical facts: Jesus died by Roman crucifixion. The disciples sincerely believed they saw Jesus alive after His death (they did not invent a myth; they died for what they genuinely believed they saw).</p><p>The arch-enemy of the church, Saul of Tarsus (Paul), suddenly converted after an experience he believed was the risen Jesus.</p><p>The skeptic James, the brother of Jesus, suddenly converted for the same reason.</p><p>The tomb was empty, and the movement began in Jerusalem, the exact place where the claim could be easily disproven if the body was still there.</p><p>What historical hypothesis accounts for all five of these agreed-upon facts?</p><p>Why dont you provide arguments against them so we can address them one by one? You claim that using the Bible is circular reasoning and that it is just a claim, not proof. Let’s test that.</p><p>I have switched gears from a Clarkian Presuppositionalism view to more of a . Warwick Montgomery view. From an evidential standpoint, I will gladly grant your premise: let’s treat the New Testament not as an inspired holy book, but strictly as a collection of ordinary, 1st-century historical documents.</p><p>When we apply standard, secular historical criteria, such as early attestation, multiple independent sources, and enemy compliance, even highly skeptical, atheistic historians agree on the above core set of minimal facts: That Jesus was crucified, the tomb was empty, and His disciples, along with enemies like Saul of Tarsus, sincerely believed they encountered the risen Jesus to the point of brutal martyrdom.</p><p>The New Testament documents are historical evidence of those facts. If you reject that evidence, the burden of proof shifts to you: Again, as Gordon Clark pointed out, every worldview begins with an axiom that cannot be proven from within itself. Your secular axiom that &#39;all religious texts are human myths&#39; is just as unproven as my axiom.</p><p>The difference is, my axiom allows for strict logical definitions, while your axiom forces you to violate the Law of Non-Contradiction by claiming two completely opposite definitions of a person are &#39;the same.&#39; You cannot escape formal logic by simply changing the rules when your definitions fail.</p><p>With that being said, what historically viable hypothesis do you have that accounts for the empty tomb?</p><p>The transformation of the disciples?</p><p>The sudden conversion of his bitterest enemies?</p><p>Discarding the documents as &#39;just a claim&#39; is not an argument; it is an evasion of the historical data.&quot; :-)</p><p>By the way, I write articles for CARM which is run by Matt Slick. While I am more a recluse writer, he loves a good debate and would probably sit down with you for one? Say the word and Ill let him know.</p><blockquote>R. I am liberal and nothing like AI. AGAIN, this argument is a false comparison fallacy and a thinly veiled ad hominem attack.</blockquote><p>M. You are right. It was a silly comparison. I do hope I didnt hurt the feelings of the AI.</p><p>M. Well, your just too smart for me. It seems you are arguing from a place that is not on the same map.</p><p>I held you to a strict standard of ontological identity (the logic of what a thing is). I argued that if Person A is God Incarnate who died on a cross, and Person B is a human prophet who did not die on a cross, Person A and Person B cannot be the same entity. That is standard Aristotelian logic A = Not -A.</p><p>You changed the definition of &quot;the same&quot; from a theological/essential definition to a nominal/cultural one. You are not following the rules. You then retreated to saying, &quot;I merely stated that Muslims recognize his existence.&quot; However, acknowledging that a historical figure or a character name exists in two traditions is not the same as claiming the two traditions &quot;teach the same Jesus.&quot;</p><p>By shrinking your claim to a basic historical acknowledgment, you are trying to escape the logical contradiction I pointed out. You accuse me of a strawman fallacy regarding my George Washington analogy. However, my analogy is structurally sound.</p><p>I used a simple analogy to show how a shared name can mask completely different identities By dismissing it as a strawman because &quot;George Washington has historical documents and Jesus is a claim,&quot; you completely missed (or intentionally dodged) the purpose of the analogy. I have as much proof of Jesus that you have of old George.</p><p>You tried to invalidate my point by screaming &quot;circular reasoning&quot; because I quoted the Bible. Clark would probably argue that every single worldview relies on an unprovable starting axiom. Secularists, atheists, and liberals have axioms just as Christians do. Your position equally qualifes and is not a towering argument that can be used over mine.</p><p>when you say &quot;The Bible is just a human claim,&quot; it is at this point you are merely asserting YOUR own secular axiom. And as they say; what&#39;s sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander. Clark showed that whatever position you begin at, you cannot avoid a starting point.</p><p>The test of a worldview is not whether it starts with an axiom because they ALL do, but whether that axiom can build a logically consistent system without collapsing into skepticism or absurdity.</p><p>Analogy relies on structural parity, not identical subject matter. Your refusal to engage with the structure of my argument is evasive.</p><p>The Fallacy of Equivocation (A = Not-A) As Clark would say, the Law of Non-Contradiction is a reflection of the very mind of God. I understand that is not your cup of tea, but it is mine. And because I am using the argument in a specific context, the rules should apply unless we change the premise of the argument.</p><p>Clark wrote extensively that if two systems use the word &quot;Jesus,&quot; but one defines Him as Creator and the other defines Him as merely a creature, they are guilty of a massive fallacy of equivocation. In other words, a word without a strict, fixed definition is completely meaningless.</p><p>I am arguing that the Islamic Jesus is defined by negating the essential properties of the Christian Jesus. thus, my argument perfectly aligns with Clark&#39;s application of logic. He would be proud of me as a student.</p><p>I have spent a great deal of time learning from Gordon Clark. Clark strictly defined an analogy by its classical definition. I wont bore you, but if you&#39;d like to read further? (Reflections on the Christian Apologetics of Gordon H. Clark)</p><p>But I will continue my thought; Clark explicitly noted that for an analogy to be logically valid, the relation between the elements must be the same. They met that condition. The relation of Book A/B to George Washington is identical to the relation of the Bible/Quran to Jesus (different definitions under a shared label)</p><p>Dr. Clark Clark heavily critiqued secular thinkers and liberals who dismissed arguments by attacking the specific content of an analogy rather than its logical structure, calling that an evasion of the law of non-contradiction. You have committed the exact error Clark spent his career dismantling.</p><p>I do understand you are viewing this from a secular, skeptical framework. I am familiar with the old elephant analogy. I get that In your view, both Christians and Muslims are blind men touching different parts of a myth.</p><p>But once again, you and I are at a stalemate because Christianity has valid proofs behind its claims. The 66 Scrolls are not one book, but 66 books written by over 40 authors in a lengthy space of time.</p><p>The fact that a man arrived on this planet with sufficient warning and post writings, has my attention. You are not expected to believe this, but as I began this conversation, I mentioned Romans 1 will hold you accountable. Not me.</p><p>You changed the rules of engagement. You set the referee as formal logic regarding the attributes of Jesus. You cannot win that theological debate using formal logic, so you flipped the table, rejected the premise that either book is true, and subsequently attacked the foundational validity of my sources instead.</p><p>I have done this for almost 40 years. And as I always say, studying the Bible has not made me smarter, but it has made me a smarter Christian.</p><p>Again, it is a stalemate. When one person is debating internal consistency (what the texts actually claim) and the other is debating external reality (whether the texts are true at all), the conversation ceases to be instructive because you are playing two entirely different games.</p><p>We will have to agree to disagree.</p><blockquote>R. I’ve always considered apologists “liars for god”. Your addition of John Warwick Montgomery has created a new subcategory for me, the “lawyer for god”.</blockquote><blockquote>Do you know what the difference is between a lawyer and a preacher?</blockquote><blockquote>You pay a lawyer to lie FOR you.<br>You pay a preacher to lie TO you.</blockquote><blockquote>Degrees in the law qualify you to argue points of law. Degrees in theology qualify you to argue points of fictional myths and legends. I’ve stated the following so many times I think I should have it tattooed to my butt cheeks.</blockquote><blockquote>Satan was created by the Persians, adapted by the Jews and embellished by the christians. There is nothing christian that was not co-opted, corrupted or outright plagiarized (and embellished) from other contemporary religions and cultures. Nothing at all is unique to christianity, not even jesus. Osiris, Tammuz, Adonis, Attis, Zagreus, Dionysus, and Jesus all died (some were murdered), were resurrected and did something significant after their resurrections.</blockquote><blockquote>Christianity is the oldest and largest game of telephone ever played. 🤦🤦‍♂️🤦‍♀️</blockquote><blockquote>I’ve already covered some of the following but I am including it to make sure that you understand my reasoning and how I reached my conclusions…</blockquote><blockquote>My studies of the bible(s) included extensive research of the provenance of the books within. The history of the texts themselves is as important as the myths they portray, if not more important.</blockquote><blockquote>The book of Genesis, which came from the Masoretic texts is a good example. The Garden of Eden story was, in fact, first mythicized in “Inanna and the Hulupu Tree”, which is the oldest extant creation myth. Half a millenium later a very similar creation myth was in the Masoretic texts, and then another half millenium’s embellishments later it appeared in Genesis the first of the five books of the Old Testament (the Pentateuch). The Epic of Gilgamesh which, like Inanna was written a millenium prior to any biblical texts, was the original “flood myth”. After a millenium of telephone game embellishment, it became Noah’s flood story.</blockquote><blockquote>Jesus is not just another branch of research. It’s also completely different provenance altogether. No one wrote anything about jesus or his “teachings” during his alleged lifetime. There were no credible eyewitness accounts, in fact the first things written about him were a MINIMUM of thirty years after his alleged crucifixion. Considering that the average lifespan at the time was 30–35 years, this means that everything ever written about him was hearsay and probably at least one generation removed. The gospels, depending on which priority you follow — Marcan Priority, Lukan Priority, the Augustinian Hypothesis, the Griesbach Two-Gospel Hypothesis, et al, put the actual things jesus said into dubious veracity. Marcan Priority holds that Mark was the first of the gospels to be written approximately 30 years after the crucifixion and the other gospels were written later using Mark and another source (which has since been lost) referred to as the “Q Document” as their sources. Do you see the inability we have to confirm anything jesus said when we can’t even nail down any part of what he did during his alleged lifetime? Yes, I keep saying “alleged” because his very historical existence is dubious. Yes, the consensus among christian biblical scholars say he was a real person while many non-christian biblical scholars say he was a composite character comprised of several different men combined with several legendary and mythical characters. Much as ALL biblical scholars agree on Moses being a composite character of purely fictional status.</blockquote><blockquote>Ok, if we give the gospels the benefit of the doubt concerning what jesus said, we have to also consider the First Council of Nicaea in 325CE when Constantine first pressed the College of Bishops to take all of the extant apocrypha concerning jesus and make one cohesive bible out of a combination of the best and most consistent books. While the Codex Vaticanus and the Vulgate Bible were effectively completed circa 400CE, this was actually just the beginning of the formation of official biblical canon which would not be completely defined until 787CE during the Second Council of Nicaea, the last of the First Seven Ecumenical Councils. They voted on what was deemed truth about jesus worthy of inclusion in the bible (canon) and what was not (non-canon — ie: heresy).<br>One of the pieces of non-canon apocrypha which I found most fascinating was the Infancy Gospel of Thomas, which told a very detailed story of jesus’s adolescence and coming of age. This was “the missing years” from 12–30 in his life. It never “made the cut” to become canon due primarily to Eusebius, who campaigned against it as being heretical. At the same time, it has since been revealed, that someone at some time during the First Council of Nicaea allegedly forged the writings about jesus in the “Antiquities of the Jews” by Flavius Josephus. This means one of the only two extant texts outside if the bible(s) about jesus written during the first century is a FORGERY! This entire process made me realize something profound. Truth, real truth is not subject to a vote. Even if no one on earth believes it, it is still truth. Subsequently, a lie is still a lie, even if everyone on earth believes it is truth. Do you follow this, so far? It is the PROVENANCE not the MESSAGE here that makes the difference. In other words, exactly what part of jesus’s teachings are truth and which parts of his teachings are lies? AND, how much of jesus’s teachings are potential forgeries? There are six of Paul’s epistles that have been confirmed by consensus to be forgeries. <br>Then there are the contradictions of all four gospels concerning the resurrection. Considering the unknown authorship of the four gospels and the “telephone game effect” that hearsay repetition causes, there is no way to confirm which, if any are even close to accurate accounts.</blockquote><blockquote>My primary source for what I’ve just listed above is “The Hero With a Thousand Faces” by Joseph Campbell.</blockquote><blockquote>I apologize for dragging you down this rabbit hole, but it is an important facet of religious history that needs to be acknowledged, since, as I stated above, christianity is basically the world’s oldest and largest game of telephone ever played.</blockquote><blockquote>So, how do YOU vote? Can’t you taste the irony here? It’s so thick you could cut it with a knife!</blockquote><blockquote>Without lies, religion dies. 🤔</blockquote><blockquote>R. You raise an interesting point. Your issue of “our concept of time” is a combination of special pleading and argument from ignorance fallacies. <br>If “god” exists outside of time, then god does NOT exist in THIS time. We as mere mortal humans cdnnot comprehend “god’s concept of time”? Time cannot have two opposing definitions. Besides, time us no longer has a singular property. It is space/time now, thanks to Albert Einstein’s relativity theories. Space is warped by gravity and time is relative to the speed at which one travels. None of these concepts were understood until the last century. The No matter what the bible(s) says, the Sun never stopped in the sky, EVER.</blockquote><blockquote>Next,buf you would please, point out this ‘spirit of god’ to which you refer. While you’re at it, take a “selfie” while pointing to your soul.</blockquote><blockquote>What you’ve effectively said is that, unless I believe in god, I will not find god in the bible(s). This is the circular reasoning I alluded to previously and which you summarliy dismissed as invalid. Your simultaneous use of circular reasoning is an egregious case of special pleading and is a sad case of desperate fallacy. 🤦🤦‍♂️🤦‍♀️</blockquote><p>M. Again, I disagree on your premise. Be that as it may, The exact mechanism of a circular argument requires commonality.</p><p>At its base, circular logic requires a common, shared premise that connects the beginning and the end of the loop.</p><p>I would like to post these as an on-going article for others who like to read. Do you have a problem with that?</p><p>R. I have no problem with that, depending on where you post it. DO NOT post it to X, Reddit, LinkedIn, WhatsApp or Facebook (Farcebook 🤦‍♀️).</p><p>My referring to circular reasoning is simply, “The bible is true because the bible says it’s true.” For the bible to be a valid source considered truthful, there has to be an external (and valid) source that corroborates what the bible states as fact. This has escaped apologist logic countless times and continues to this day.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6d0cb8cc552a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[James Miller wrote an article called “The Fruit of Islam- We’ve had 1400 years to figure it out.”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MosheD/james-miller-wrote-an-article-called-the-fruit-of-islam-weve-had-1400-years-to-figure-it-out-776ac86313d7?source=rss-af4a87e02b1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/776ac86313d7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Moshe D.]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 19 Aug 2026 13:06:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-19T14:12:19.052Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>James Miller wrote an article called “The Fruit of Islam- We’ve had 1400 years to figure it out.” <a href="https://medium.com/faith-seeking-wonder/the-fruit-of-islam-8690f6cd95d3">See James Miller</a></p><p>I wanted to extend my previous comments from just a reply to create a new article, according to my experience with Islam as an apologist. After all, a 10-minute read is more than a comment, right?</p><p>I enjoyed the article. But it is a wishful thinking trajectory, isnt it? The end of the article spoke the most to me: “<strong>America should make room for Muslims without surrendering the First Amendment, even at a local level. That will always take a careful and intentional choreography, but it’s better than the blind and hypocritical embrace the Left has extended to ideologies that may ultimately destroy it.</strong>”</p><p>I am currently writing an article on the Hadith and why it is important for the Christian to have access to these additional works, along with the Quran, for the purpose of engagement and evangelism.</p><p>During that research, I found a similar article to yours that dealt with this question in a similar way.</p><p>“On the (In)compatibility of Islamic Religiosity and Citizenship in Western Democracies: The Role of Religion for Muslims’ Civic and Political Engagement.” by Mario Peucker. (See link at end of article)</p><p>Just know, I thought yours was much more sincere and without an agenda. That is not to say I agreed with you. Your final comment at the end of your article was disheartening and nonsense as a Christian.</p><p>For example, in the other article, the author claims to have investigated whether Islamic faith conflicts with democratic societies. He claims he shifted away from abstract theological debates and instead examined how Muslims actually practice their citizenship.</p><p>He argues that public claims of an inherent “clash” are largely unfounded, noting that the lived experience and religious practices of most Muslims do not hinder civic and political engagement; rather, their faith frequently serves as a motivational driver to volunteer, vote, and actively participate in their local communities.</p><p>Why did I reject the premise? He may not come out and say it but his conclusions align more with progressive frameworks on multiculturalism and social inclusion. Anyone who has studied Islam, knows this is poppycock.</p><p>In the paper, Peucker bypasses a thorough theological analysis of the Quran and Hadith. He argues that trying to determine compatibility by studying scripture or arguing about literal text is a dead end.</p><p>WRONG! He knows his premise will fail at that point.</p><p>He says he relies on sociological data, survey results, and qualitative interviews tracking actual civic behaviors (like voting rates, volunteering, and community group participation). Critics and apologists alike can easily comb through religious texts (whether the Quran or the Bible) to selectively pull out verses that either support or condemn modern democratic values.</p><p>He also acknowledges that many Muslims hold socially conservative or traditional views on topics like gender and sexuality (which aligns more with traditional right-wing social values), but points out that holding conservative views doesn’t make someone a bad or unintegrated citizen.</p><p>As the Church Lady would say, “Well, isn’t that special!” What exactly does an intersection of basic moralism have to do with the topic at hand? All religions possess a path toward social morality; it is not a uniquely Western value that Muslims are suddenly “sharing.”</p><p>As Romans 2 reminds us, the works of the Law are written on the hearts of all mankind. Labeling basic theological conservatism as a “right-wing social value” reveals the inherent bias of the secular framework.</p><p>No bias? As he challenges arguments historically championed by conservative, nationalist, or anti-immigration political factions, SPECIFICALLY the “incompatibility hypothesis” (the idea that Islamic values inherently clash with Western democracy.</p><p>One needs to follow the articles on <a href="https://rairfoundation.substack.com/p/il-islamic-scholar-calls-for-muslims">RAIR Foundation</a> to see how Sharia Law is creeping into the USA’s legal system. In several Western democracies, most notably the UK, and to a lesser degree parts of Europe and Canada, Muslim communities have established Sharia councils (often referred to in public discourse as “Sharia courts” If they were “blending in” to Western society, I think it is safe to say the laws of the land would be equally considered?</p><p>But what have I witnessed? Institutionalized Gender Discrimination. Investigations, including a major look by The Times, show that these councils routinely enforce practices that fundamentally contradict Western democratic laws regarding gender equality. (<a href="https://www.thetimes.com/uk/society/article/sharia-law-courts-uk-marriages-divorce-zs76vq2c9">How the UK became ‘western capital’ for sharia courts</a>)</p><p>For example:</p><p><strong>A man can divorce his wife instantly by pronouncing it three times, whereas a woman must undergo a grueling, months-long process requiring permission from male scholars.</strong></p><p><strong>Some councils approve apps and wills that explicitly give daughters half the inheritance of sons.</strong></p><p><strong>Councils have been documented accommodating polygamous marriages, which are illegal under Western state laws.</strong></p><p><strong>Women’s rights groups warn that these councils act as a mechanism to pressure vulnerable women into staying in abusive relationships. Women are often told by religious arbiters to have “patience” with abusive husbands, and going to the secular police is framed as a shameful act that brings dishonor to the community.</strong></p><p>This has directly contributed to cratering prosecution rates for honor-based abuse, as victims are pressured to withdraw their statements to state police. Subsequently, it gives the finger to the Law of the land. Even though a 2018 UK Home Office review confirmed that these councils have zero legal jurisdiction and their rulings are non-binding under British law, they function as a de facto parallel legal system for hundreds of thousands of people. By steering civil disputes inward, they effectively shield members of the community from the protections of secular democratic laws.</p><p>What do I mean? Data from the UK Office for National Statistics shows that a vast number of Muslims undergo a religious marriage ceremony, called Nikah, but never legally register it with the state. Why? Because to a Muslim, they are not legally married under Western law. Thus, they cannot get a civil divorce. (<a href="https://www.reuters.com/fact-check/uk-reforms-would-not-make-islamic-marriages-legal-first-time-2026-07-23/">Reuters fact check</a>)</p><p>If a woman wants to remarry within her faith, she is trapped unless an Islamic authority officially dissolves her religious marriage. The Sharia councils exist primarily to fill this specific religious vacuum. As the old saying goes, “The beatings will continue until morale improves.”</p><p>Coming to a theater near you? (<a href="https://rairfoundation.substack.com/p/wapo-columnist-rejects-american-assimilation?utm_source=publication-search">WaPo Columnist Rejects American Assimilation And Asserts ‘Practicing Muslims Can’t Disavow Sharia Even If They Wanted To</a>.)</p><p>The movement toward Sharia councils is the strongest evidence in favor of the incompatibility hypothesis. It proves that when a population’s religious texts demand specific legal structures for family and society, a subset of that population will actively try to build a parallel framework to bypass secular democracy.</p><p>So it appears to be a paradox for the ignorant? A Muslim citizen can love democracy, vote for secular leaders, and volunteer in their neighborhood (as Mario Peucker’s research shows), while simultaneously participating in a community sub-culture that structurally oppresses women and rejects the supreme authority of human-made laws.</p><p>But they are NOT compatible. (“<a href="https://www.congress.gov/119/meeting/house/119267/documents/HHRG-119-JU10-20260513-SD001.pdf">Sharia-Free America: Why Political Islam &amp; Sharia Law are Incompatible with the U.S. Constitution: Part II”</a>)</p><p>My judgment says I think this parallel article from Peucker is reading into Islam, based upon my experience and research, and “forging” a positive outcome. And as long as a reader is high on political correctness, they will never see the truth because they don’t want the truth.</p><p>If I were to evaluate Peucker’s article strictly through the lens of the Quran, Hadith. and history, rather than modern sociological data, I may conveniently shift the outcome. Shifting the framework from what foundational theology dictates about non-Muslim societies to how Muslims behave as citizens today?</p><p>Addressing the article using Islamic texts presents a multi-layered, sometimes complex view of Jews and Christians. Often referred to as the People of the Book.</p><p>What do we do with the Jews and the Christians? What happens when a Muslim and a Westerner live together with fundamentally different doctrines?</p><p>Of course, the Muslim enjoys freedom. That is not the issue. I recognize that everyday life relies on shared civic values and moralism. In the present day, millions of Muslims live peacefully alongside Westerners because human relationships are rarely dictated purely by high theology. But what happens in the future as populations change in favor of the Muslim?</p><p>History shows that when “push comes to shove,” and Islam secures a strong demographic and political majority, Christian populations face severe structural erosion and eventual near-total displacement. It also gives a snapshot of the past. History tells a radically different story regarding what happens when a country shifts to a decisive Muslim majority. (<a href="https://christoverall.com/article/concise/is-islam-compatible-with-western-values/">Is Islam Compatible with Western Values?</a>)</p><p>We can agree, at the moment, there is no historical precedent of a Western, Christian, or pluralistic nation becoming a Muslim-majority country and maintaining its original democratic freedoms or Christian heritage.</p><p>So we rely on other times and other places, Instead, history reveals a brutal, three-stage collapse for those who believe Jesus is the Son of God. (<a href="https://www.catholic.com/magazine/online-edition/explaining-christian-persecution-in-muslim-countries">Catholic Answers</a>)</p><p>Classical Islam established structural frameworks for religious pluralism through the Dhimmi system and the Medina Charter. They nipped this in the bud, so to speak. A sociologist cannot declare Islam “compatible” with Western democracy by ignoring history or the actual text.</p><p>In traditional Islamic theology, a believer’s ultimate allegiance or loyalty belongs to Allah and the community of believers, not to a secular, man-made democratic state.</p><p>Using the Quran and Hadiths, this points out a serious contrast: Western democracies are built on popular sovereignty, but Islamic law asserts divine sovereignty. From a strict theological, and textual standpoint.</p><p>A Muslim cannot fully “blend” into a system where legislation can permit things explicitly forbidden by God; that is to say usury, certain social freedoms, EVEN if they manage to peacefully coexist as we see today.</p><p>When Muslims become the demographic majority in countries previously filled with Christians and Jews, what has history shown us? Should we not be forced to do proper and full research in order to build our article before we come to a conclusion? Should we not look at the long-term history of the Middle East, North Africa, and modern Turkey? (<a href="https://crisismagazine.com/vault/war-without-end-a-brief-history-of-the-muslim-conquests">War Without End: A Brief History of the Muslim Conquests</a>)</p><p>And we have not even discussed the liberalism factor. That is to say, many religions grow another branch or sect in which their respected teachings change and evolve. That’s a different topic.</p><p>And you may or may not agree (I would agree) that these frameworks grant the “appearance” of judicial autonomy and freedom of worship to Jews and Christians at a time when medieval Europe was violently purging religious minorities and heretics.</p><p>Why do I say this? The entire design of Islam accommodating a Jew or Christian is smoke and mirrors in my opinion. As the Highlander has said, “There can be only one.” When all is said and done, most religions say “they” are the final religion. And when push comes to shove? The Quran and Hadith do not have just one flat statement about Jews and Christians; instead, the texts alternate between high theological recognition, harsh critique, and legal categorization. Islamic Law has covered this topic for hundreds of years.</p><p>The Quran grants Jews and Christians a distinct, protected status BECAUSE they received earlier divine revelations (the Torah and the Gospel). It is ONLY because of traditional Islamic law that they permitted a degree of religious freedom under Muslim rule; i.e., Dhimmi status.</p><p>Nevertheless, just how does, or just how can a Muslim integrate into a society of Roman Catholics? The Islamic texts <strong>strongly reject</strong> core Christian doctrines, specifically the Christian belief in the Trinity and the deity of Jesus?</p><p>While Christians are permitted to whisper “Jesus is the Son of God” inside their churches, publicly preaching the Trinity or evangelizing to Muslims becomes a capital offense punishable by imprisonment or death.</p><p>We have not yet come to that place but consider every other Country that was once Christian, but is now under Sharia Law.</p><p>Verses such as “And whoever seeks a religion other than Islam, it will never be accepted of him” (Quran 3:85) establish that Islam views itself as the final, perfected completion of all previous revelations. Therefore, while Jews and Christians are recognized as historical monotheists, theological texts maintain that their religious frameworks are superseded.</p><p>Therefore, assimilation or “blending” into a non-Muslim Western democracy is secondary or even spiritually hazardous if it requires compromising divine law for secular civic integration.</p><p>While the texts allow for peaceful interaction and protection of Jews and Christians as People of the Book, they draw a hard theological boundary that prevents true structural or ideological blending into a non-Islamic governance system.</p><p>And what happens if a Muslim leaves his or her religion for a “brave new Western world?” Oh, that’s right, they can’t just leave!</p><p>Apart from the Jewish Christian faith, most every religion has safeguards against leaving. One could say institutional religion is almost like the mafia. Once you’re in, you’re in! They ALL contain a warning to those who leave, whether it is a simple shunning or a Mass is held over their soul.</p><p>In traditional Islamic law, derived from the Hadith, apostasy is treated as a very serious offense, historically carrying severe legal penalties, up to and including capital punishment.</p><p>1. What does the Hadith Say? The most direct and frequently cited rulings on leaving Islam? The Death Penalty! Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim quotes the Prophet as saying: “Whoever changes his religion, kill him.” Of course, there is an exception. Other hadiths specify the conditions, such as distinguishing between someone who merely leaves privately versus someone who commits treason, actively rebels, or works to subvert the Muslim community.</p><p>What does the Quran say? The Quran strongly condemns apostasy from a spiritual and theological standpoint. It warns of severe divine punishment in the afterlife.</p><p>Like Roman Catholicism, there can be “Afterlife Consequences.” As it has been said, “High money, high Mass, low money, low Mass, no money, no Mass.” These consequences are always carried in your spiritual backpack through this life.</p><p>Verses such as Quran 3:86–88 state that those who reject belief after accepting it and receiving clear proofs will face the curse of God, the angels, and all mankind, and their punishment will not be lightened. We do have the confusion of the early vs. the later Contexts. Scholars note that the Quran states, “There is no compulsion in religion” (Quran 2:256).</p><p>However, mainstream classical jurists generally interpreted this verse as applying to initial entry into Islam (or referring to specific historical contexts) rather than granting legal permission for a practicing Muslim to exit the faith without earthly consequence.</p><p>This continues even with the quieter, outside-the-limelight religion of the Jehovah’s Witnesses; the leadership mandates a strict, total policy of social shunning directed by the WatchTower. (or as I like to call it, the Tower of the Watched)</p><p>Whether you are removed by disfellowshipping or you voluntarily choose to leave. A simple letter stating, <em>“I no longer wish to be a Jehovah’s Witness,”</em> or if you join another church, you are categorized as having disassociated yourself (<a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9803876/">What Happens to Those Who Exit Jehovah’s Witnesses: An Investigation of the Impact of Shunning</a>)</p><p>Before I finish, let me go back to one important point. Again, researching a religion without consulting its doctrine is misleading and sets you up for deception. Even those two freckled-faced kids who show up at your door? While they mean well, they bring spiritual poison for the soul.</p><p>As a Protestant, obviously, I reject Roman Catholicism as a Christian church. But, for the sake of argument, let us suppose they are “Christian.” (and of course Islam does not distinguish between a Protestant and non-Protestant)</p><p>In the eyes of Islamic scholars, Roman Catholics are legally recognized as “People of the Book.” Their core theological beliefs, <strong>specifically the Trinit</strong>y and the divinity of Christ, are explicitly condemned as theological errors. This is commonly referred to as Islam’s sin of Shirk.</p><p>The Quran directly rejects the Trinity: “So believe in Allah and His messengers, and say not ‘Three,’ Cease! (it is) better for you!”</p><p>Another translation says, “Do not say ‘Three.’ Stop! — that is better for you. Indeed, Allah is but one God. Exalted is He above having a son” (Quran 4:171).</p><p>What about the Deity of Christ? Verses such as Quran 5:72 state: They have certainly disbelieved who say, ‘Indeed, God is the Messiah, the son of Mary.</p><p>Shirk is the sin of associating partners with Allah, and is considered the gravest transgression in Islamic theology. It is called the unforgivable sin.</p><p>When it comes to personal friendship and social interaction, classical and traditional interpretations draw a sharp line between civil coexistence and spiritual alliance. Under Islamic jurisprudence, mainstream scholars differentiate between theological disagreements and permissible daily social relations. But make no mistake, Islam regulates these spiritual guidelines.</p><p>Thanks for your article.</p><p>(<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/323670835_On_the_Incompatibility_of_Islamic_Religiosity_and_Citizenship_in_Western_Democracies_The_Role_of_Religion_for_Muslims%27_Civic_and_Political_Engagement">On the (In)compatibility of Islamic Religiosity and Citizenship in Western Democracies: The Role of Religion for Muslims’ Civic and Political Engagement</a>)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=776ac86313d7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>