<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Andrzej Lukowski on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Andrzej Lukowski on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@MrLukowski?source=rss-edb7297c7a65------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 16:26:51 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@MrLukowski/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Oh, Sokovia!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MrLukowski/oh-sokovia-f8e57682d137?source=rss-edb7297c7a65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f8e57682d137</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[marvel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[russia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eastern-europe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marvel-cinematic-universe]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrzej Lukowski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 29 Aug 2022 22:56:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-30T06:36:22.557Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Eastern Europe and Russia in the Marvel Cinematic Universe</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*PtRSHDgIt00wjapZ3KT8jg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Sokovian flag, allegedly</figcaption></figure><p>The Marvel Cinematic Universe also known as the MCU has become more inclusive recently. Which is a good thing.</p><p>Famously, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MQ8n-NJsVD0">the iconic original Avengers line-up</a> consisted of five white guys plus Scarlett Johansson, and though there have been <a href="https://marvelcinematicuniverse.fandom.com/wiki/War_Machine">supporting Black American</a> <a href="https://marvelcinematicuniverse.fandom.com/wiki/Nick_Fury">characters</a> knocking around since the series launched in 2008, it wasn’t until Black Panther (2018) that the MCU made a serious effort to diversify in an overtly inclusive sense, which it has subsequently done with aplomb (see: Shang Chi, Moonknight, Ms Marvel and more).</p><p>But what about diversity in an, uh, <em>non-inclusive</em> sense?</p><p>One region of the world has been of pivotal importance to the MCU while also being treated with a blithe absence of cultural sensitivity. I am of course talking about Eastern Europe and Russia and I am not saying they’ve been treated intentionally insensitively. But by the current standards of the series, there’s a glaring absence of appreciation, enthusiasm or interest in these cultures, despite their being baked into the series. As the MCU pointedly broadens its cultural palette beyond mainstream America, its depiction of Eastern Europe and Russia feels increasingly dissonant.</p><p>Though there’s overlap, Eastern Europe and Russia are of course two quite different things. I’ll zip through Russia, because let’s be honest, this would be a spectacularly weird moment in history to be calling for more sympathetic treatment of Russians. However: there are, unavoidably, quite a lot of them in the MCU.</p><p>Most notably there’s Scarlett Johannson’s Natasha Romanov, who stars in nine films. We know she’s Russian because everybody says she’s Russian, but to all intents and purposes, she’s American: American accent, American idioms, no allusion to a culturally different past to the American characters. The film Black Widow, which is her very last appearance in the series, makes some effort to explain this (she grew up in the States, undercover) although it doesn’t really make <em>much</em> sense (she was there for three years). Beyond references to her traumatic training as an elite assassin in Russia, no actual attempt is made to make her appear Russian in any meaningful way. Not for the last time, Eastern European/Russian cultural identity is shown as something that can be lightly discarded. (Russia itself, meanwhile, is essentially boiled down to a lot of snow, <a href="https://marvelcinematicuniverse.fandom.com/wiki/Escape_from_the_Seventh_Circle_Prison">a ‘lively’ prison</a>, <a href="https://marvelcinematicuniverse.fandom.com/wiki/Red_Room_Academy">an evil flying fortress</a>, and Rachel Weisz’s admittedly pleasant dacha).</p><p>I won’t get bogged down in the other Russian characters from Black Widow — who all at least attempted Russian accents (even <a href="https://screenrant.com/black-widow-dreykov-villain-ray-winstone-casting-weird/">Ray Winstone FFS</a>). But the <em>other</em> major Russian character in the MCU outside of the immediate Black Widow universe is Mickey Rourke’s Ivan Vanko — aka Whiplash — the antagonist of Iron Man 2. The character wasn’t actually Russian in the source comics, but making him so sort of makes sense (a vague link to the Cold War origins of the characters, plus you can’t make <a href="https://marvelcinematicuniverse.fandom.com/wiki/Iron_Monger">every Iron Man</a> <a href="https://marvelcinematicuniverse.fandom.com/wiki/Mysterio">bad guy</a> a disgruntled Stark employee). Rourke apparently researched the role by literally spending time hanging out in Russian prisons, which feels a bit full on, but what always struck me is how much the character feels like a straight-up manifestation of US Cold War paranoia about Russia. Vanko is basically an animal, living an existence that we’d call miserable and impoverished, and yet he’s also a genius: almost in the same league as Robert Downey Jr’s Tony Stark, a rung or three up the ladder to Stark’s bitter rival Justin Hammer. Just as the USSR was an equal to the US militarily while its citizens enjoyed a vastly lower quality of life, so it goes with Vanko and Stark. It’s a stereotype, albeit probably not intended as an insulting one. (Iron Man 2 is also the film that introduces Natasha, ie it has two major Russian characters, one who presents as Russian and one as American — I don’t believe they ever talk to each other, which is… probably for the best).</p><p>Anyway: Eastern Europe!</p><p>The ‘real’ Eastern Europe doesn’t actually appear that much in the MCU: Budapest and Bucharest are there a couple of times but really just as neutral backdrops and FWIW I think wartime Poland may technically be in the first Captain America film.</p><p>In fact, the first <em>mention </em>of an Eastern European country comes right at the beginning of the whole series, in Iron Man: it’s noted that the Ten Rings terrorist organisation has Bulgarian members, a reference that would seem to establish it as being more diverse than, basically, Al-Qaida and thus stressing that the bad guys aren’t just 2D War on Terror-era villainous Arabs (bear in mind George W Bush was still the president when the film came out).</p><p>The Ten Rings goes through quite a shift by the time we get to 2021’s Shang-Chi, when it’s become a largely East Asian organisation (its immortal Chinese boss Wenwu had conveniently temporarily retired for a bit during the Iron Man era), but Eastern European representation remains part of it: there’s an <a href="https://marvelcinematicuniverse.fandom.com/wiki/Razor_Fist">extremely fruity Romanian lieutenant</a> named Razor Fist.</p><p>I think it’s fair to say in these contexts and others, Eastern Europeans constitute a sort of exotic white other, a ‘they’re from <em>where?</em>’ element that’s potentially deemed impolitic with global majority actors. You can read too much into it. But it’s there on some level with a character like Razor Fist, not dissimilar to Vanko’s techno-barbarian.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*3lI-7n4v8FrJ1JXDSoVAkQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sokovia, actually looking quite nice</figcaption></figure><p>However, by far the most significant Eastern European country in the MCU is Sokovia, an entirely made-up place that is introduced and substantially destroyed in Avengers: Age of Ultron.</p><p><em>Is </em>Sokovia in Eastern Europe? Its exact location is ambiguous and there’s some suggestion it might be part of the former Yugoslavia, ie potentially Central Europe or the Balkans (the fact it was supposed wracked by constant civil wars is also vaguely suggestive of the Balkans, where various comic book characters reassigned to Sokovia originally originated).</p><p>However: Sokovia’s capital is called Novi Grad and they use a version of the Cyrillic alphabet (Соковиja!<strong>)</strong>. It <em>is</em> Eastern European, regardless of where it’s supposed to be. Belarus would seem like a decent equivalent, or Moldova or perhaps an oblast that had splintered from Ukraine.</p><p>Telling is <a href="https://marvelcinematicuniverse.fandom.com/wiki/Maria_Hill">Maria Hill</a>’s summary of it as ‘nowhere special but it’s on the way to everywhere special’, a bland description that nonetheless implicitly places it on the East European plain, the extremely flat two million square miles of land that has caused untold grief over the centuries because of the lack of any meaningful geographical barrier between Europe and Russia/Asia.</p><p>It’s also a description that sets it up as entirely disposable. Would she actually say that about a real country? It would be pretty damn impolitic. You can see what the screenwriters — and whoever else in the Marvel hierarchy might need to be consulted to create a country — were doing here. Sokovia is a post-Iron Curtain country that doesn’t actually exist, so could be destroyed without offending the inhabitants of an actual country, while also somewhat playing on the audience’s likely haziness of knowledge about that part of the world (it sounds ‘unrealistic’ to say there’s an extra country nobody has heard of in Western Europe or North America, but for Eastern Europe — or for that matter <a href="https://marvelcinematicuniverse.fandom.com/wiki/Wakanda">East Africa</a> or a <a href="https://marvelcinematicuniverse.fandom.com/wiki/Madripoor">Southeast Asian island</a> — yeah, totally checks out).</p><p>We never learn much about Sokovia culturally, politically etc — certainly much less than we learn about Madripoor and Wakanda, the other two fictional countries in the MCU thus far. Nonetheless, choosing to be vague about a shithole imaginary Eastern European country is itself a choice.</p><p>Three major characters come from there: Wanda and Pietro Maximoff, and Helmut Zemo.</p><p>The most convincing — and shortest lived — is Aaron Taylor-Wood’s Pietro. He does a very decent generic Eastern European accent and deadpan humour, and while his frosted hair and tracksuit vibe is absolutely not a flattering stereotype, at least it’s clear what he was going for.</p><p>Helmut Zemo is a German character in the comics, and is portrayed by the German actor Daniel Brühl in the MCU. He plays the role with a German accent. Zemo is meant to be a Sokovian special forces soldier (late retconned to noble) hellbent on ridding the world of genetically enhanced humans as revenge for the deaths of his family in the events of Age of Ultron. But clearly nobody said ‘can you do the accent Aaron Taylor-Wood did?’ A Western audience is unlikely to really notice, but there’s a note of ‘will this do?’ to it — I don’t think the equivalent would be allowed with a character from Wakanda.</p><p>Speaking of accents… In her first few appearances, most especially her debut in Age of Ultron, Elizabeth Olsen’s Wanda Maximoff speaks with some sort of accent. It’s definitely not the one Taylor-Wood does, or the one Brühl does; if anything it sounds a bit more Southeastern European. A few films down the line and she has ditched it entirely, and speaks in Elizabeth Olsen’s voice. The in-universe explanation for this is… <a href="https://collider.com/wandavision-accent-explained-elizabeth-olsen/">vague and unconvincing</a>.</p><p>The real-world explanation is presumably the same as Scarlett Johansson: either Elizabeth Olsen is bad at accents, or Marvel didn’t ultimately want one of its recognisable American stars speaking with a foreign accent. Nonetheless, the message is similar: for a true hero — or at least, Main Character — your identity as coming from a shithole part of the world can be discarded. Even accepting a prosaic explanation for the accent change, the fact that Wanda rapidly becomes obsessed with the idea of a US-style nuclear family is very bloody telling (apparently she really liked classic American sitcoms when she was growing up — fair enough but it seems they made a bigger impression on her than literally everything else that ever happened to her up until the age of 25?)</p><p>Sokovia is disposable. Pietro, the most Sokovian Sokovian, dies at the end of the first film he’s in. Zemo and Wanda have nothing intrinsically Sokovian to their characters. And Sokovia is <em>literally </em>disposable: not only does a substantial proportion of Novi Grad get destroyed by Ultron, but we learn in The Falcon and the Winter Soldier that Sokovia no longers exists in the year 2024, having effectively given up the will to exist and simply absorbed into the surrounding countries.</p><p>There is admittedly little precedent for a real country having its capital blown up by an army of killer robots intent on wiping out all human life. Nonetheless, the idea that a sovereign nation that had apparently weathered Quite A Lot would just give up because…repairing the capital city from a disaster that was substantially the fault of a fantastically wealthy American citizen seemed like too much effort… is pretty hard to swallow.</p><p>Countries do disappear. But the inference that everyone in Sokovia felt it wasn’t worth persisting with feels at least vaguely insulting to the countries Sokovia is tangentially based upon. Tony Stark is essentially allowed to not feel particularly bad about being personally responsible for its disappearance because it was such a terrible place. Zemo is the only person bothered about doing more about it than forming an oversight committee. And even he describes it as a ‘failed state’.</p><p>As the MCU diversifies, it is saddled with the legacy of this. There are still <a href="https://marvelcinematicuniverse.fandom.com/wiki/Yelena_Belova">multiple</a> <a href="https://marvelcinematicuniverse.fandom.com/wiki/Red_Guardian">Russian</a> <a href="https://marvelcinematicuniverse.fandom.com/wiki/Melina_Vostokoff">characters</a> at large. Eastern Europe is likely to continue to be represented by <a href="https://collider.com/characters-upcoming-thunderbolts-movie/">a German who sounds German</a> and <a href="https://thedirect.com/article/doctor-strange-2-wanda-dead-not-photos">an American who sounds American</a>. And that’s just what’s there already.</p><p>Just as Zemo’s nationality was changed, so you’d imagine Sokovia will continue to exert a form of gravity over any depictions of that part of the world. A hypothetical new Polish character would probably have to be somewhat informed by the fact a neighbouring country got blown up and (possibly) partly absorbed into Poland. Maybe it would make it easier to just make the character Sokovian. Probably the imminent Fantastic Four film will feature their nemesis Doctor Doom, and perhaps he’ll be from Sokovia instead of the amusingly named <a href="https://marvel.fandom.com/wiki/Latveria">Latveria</a>, the made up Eastern European country he’s from in the comics.</p><p>I’m not here to say the MCU is actively prejudiced against Russians and Eastern Europeans. Sokovia is clearly at least as much the result of a series of relatively pragmatic decisions that stem from the original comics’ roots in World War 2 and the Cold War as actual prejudice. And you also have to consider the possibility that some of the above is rooted in America’s long history of Eastern European immigrants seeking to escape their pasts.</p><p>However. Ultimately Eastern Europe in the MCU is chiefly represented by a country so shit that everyone abandoned ship after an attack from a killer robot that was Robert Downey Jnr’s fault, and those that survived hatred it did much they ditched their accents. In Captain America: Civil War, Tony Stark is confronted not by the mother of a Sokovian, but by an American volunteer worker who died in Ultron’s attack — the sort of role that hasn’t been available in a European country for decades. It’s American suffering that ultimately moves Stark, and his guilt is stoked by Zemo, the devious Sokovian.</p><p>To <a href="https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/you-break-the-rules-and-become-the-hero-that-doesnt-seem-fair">paraphrase</a> noted Eastern European Wanda Maximoff, it doesn’t seem fair that other non-mainstream Western cultures get their moment in the spotlight and it’s like ‘woo, inclusive’ when at best Eastern Europe has been treated with a blithe, stereotype-bound indifference. The MCU is smart enough to redress this if it really wants to. But is the will there? Will we ever know the real Sokovia?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f8e57682d137" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Belarus Free Theatre’s The Master Had a Talking Sparrow + more from Minsk 2017]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MrLukowski/minsk-2017-the-master-had-a-talking-sparrow-by-belarus-free-theatre-is-one-of-the-greatest-pieces-88fc1f23e681?source=rss-edb7297c7a65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/88fc1f23e681</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[minsk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[belarus-free-theatre]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrzej Lukowski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Apr 2022 12:46:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-22T20:58:40.720Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*tV1Rms8fWMeanrQVJ4i07Q.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>April 2022: a couple of years ago I deleted my entire old blogger blog in a fit of existential bleh about what to actually do with it in the modern era, a decision I’m still reasonably happy with but there were probably a couple of actually good bits on there including the below piece from 2017 on my first visit to see Belarus Free Theatre. Anyway, I don’t think there’s very much English-language writing on these shows, and as The Master Had A Talking Sparrow – hands down one of my favourite pieces of theatre ever – has just announced its first London dates I thought I might as well dust this off for the ol’ Medium account. If you’re at all familiar with Belarus Free Theatre you’ll know they’re exiled now and the ‘scene’ I’m describing doesn’t exist anymore, but I hope The Master retains some of its power as it makes the obviously complicated transposition to a London audience.</em></p><p>—</p><p>Five nights a week, behind the door of an anonymous building in suburban Minsk that is supposed to be a garage, some theatre shows happen.</p><p>The shows are free, and announced on the afternoon of performance by WhatsApp message, with places — anything from 30 to 55 — allocated on a first-come, first-served basis to those who dial a burner phone manned by Nadia from Belarus Free Theatre, who jots the names down on a paper list.</p><p>Belarus Free Theatre are outlawed in their home country, though maybe it’s more complicated than that sounds to us. On an admittedly glancing first visit it would seem like a mistake to imagine Belarus as some sort of Stalinist throwback. Instead it is what it is: a poor Eastern European country with a democratic deficit and a heavy Russian influence.</p><p>Belarus Free Theatre were last clamped down on in March, and a couple of years back the KGB — they still have the actual KGB in Belarus — forced them to leave their previous headquarters-cum-performance space. None of this would be likely to happen in the West. But with founders Nikolai Khalezin and Natalia Koliada exiled to London — Nikolai had to miss his father’s funeral because he doesn’t dare risk a return until he has obtained a British passport — and the company something of an international cause célèbre, it doesn’t feel like crushing Belarus Free Theatre is President Lukashenko’s actual number one priority. The company are pretty sure the KGB know they’re here, pretty sure the odd spook has come to see a show, and pretty sure they’ll be made to move on at some point. But not right now.</p><p>I have reviewed a couple of Belarus Free Theatre’s London shows and always found them a bit frustrating — spirited but dated agit prop designed to tell comfortable Western audiences about the bad things that are happening elsewhere. In Minsk both the shows and the context feel radically different.</p><p>For starters there is a genuine, undeniable, tacky thrill to opening a boring door and stepping into a sweaty, illicit theatre audience. Out here as a foreign observer to do a feature on a new London night Belarus Free Theatre is starting, there is clearly no actual danger to me. But to see theatre outside of a designated, government-sponsored building, staged on the most DIY of lines — a couple of portable lights and a projector operated by a woman on a precariously-balanced laptop — is pretty remarkable.</p><p>It reminds me — perhaps banally, but oh the thrill — of the best ATP chalet parties, makes me think how much the iconography of anti-establishmentarianism has been co-opted by music in the punk era and after. But was punk really anything more than one generation exercising its privilege to tell another generation to fuck off? Was rave really much more than hedonism? Were they causes of change or were they symptoms?</p><p>I don’t think there is a vast amount of counter-culture in Belarus, but this is definitely it: young people, queer people, disabled people, the inevitable vegans… they’re here because theatre is the thing most palpably pricking the system. Theatre, of all things! Imagine what most Western theatre writers would give to be able to say that. It’d be like after years of playing Dungeons &amp; Dragons suddenly discovering you could actually summon a magic missile.</p><p>The first show I see, House No 5, is a darkly humorous series of skits about disability (made with a mix of disabled and able-bodied performers). It is a bit hit-and-miss (I follow along on a translated script). But it is the only real forum in the country for this stuff to get talked about. I think we fret a lot about diversity in the West precisely because we have a monolithic, well-funded, well-intentioned framework that is meant to allow every voice to be heard, and we rage that it doesn’t work as ought. But there is something immensely powerful in saying ‘fuck that, we’re going off grid’. It is easy for me to sit here and fantasise about how British theatre makers who have a problem with British theatre might just up sticks and put radically different stuff on in an unlicensed shed somewhere. But it’s a thought.</p><p>The second show I see is The Master Had a Talking Sparrow. I suppose you’d call it immersive theatre: the garage is turned into a Belarusian living room in what I’m assuming is the late ‘70s/early ’80s (Boney M play on the radio). We are gathered for a traditional meal, with heavy plates of smoked meats and boiled vegetables on the table, plus copious amounts of actual moonshine (it is perhaps one complication of Belarus Free Theatre that a free show in which the audience gets a full meal would surely not be possible without the outside funding they receive, though they’re hardly a western construct).</p><p>The show — based on a compendium of interviews conducted by journalist Zmitser Bartosik — is basically a reminiscence on civilian life in Belarus during the Second World War conducted over the dinner table. Though passions run high at times, there is barely any dramatic structure: the meal happens, people talk, we’re all a bit drunker by the end, but there’s no big revelation or sudden twist, and the whole thing is baggy enough to allow fairly robust interjection from the audience.</p><p>What’s radical is that the equivalent to this conversation — which might have happened word for word in the period it’s set — would be profoundly unlikely to happen today. That’s because the national discourse over the war has been studiously sculpted in present-day Belarus.</p><p>The atrocities committed by the Soviets during the first half of the war have been played down to almost nothing, because this is an increasingly awkward narrative. Earlier in the day I am taken to the <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170924161927/https://belarusdigest.com/story/kurapaty-memorial-in-danger-business-versus-historical-memory/">Kurapaty woods</a>, one the most haunting and horrible places I have ever been, a few acres of woodland just outside Minsk where the trees are intermingled with hundreds of wooden crosses marking the hundred thousand-plus people executed here by the Soviets. It is an official memorial, visited by President Clinton in 1994. But in the Putin era the government prefers to ignore it, and there are periodic attempts to tear down the crosses and desecrate the memorials. It is huge and stunning and significant, but it isn’t even in my guidebook, rather damningly.</p><p>There were also atrocities committed — on a smaller scale — by the Belarusian partisans who fought, among others, the Nazis, now venerated as an entirely heroic, patriotic movement.</p><p>And of course there were the Nazis themselves, who committed terrible atrocities — and these are the only ones the state really cares to remember.</p><p>The Master Had a Talking Sparrow is defined by its reasonableness — it’s a bunch of people chatting about what the war was like, and acknowledging that the partisans, in particular, did bad things too, in some cases because they’d been pushed over the edge by the occupations, in some cases because if you give a man a gun and say he can do what he likes, the first thing he’ll probably do is shoot his annoying neighbours.</p><p>In its reasonableness the show is a radical attempt to protect the past from revisionism as these events move out of living memory. It is a time capsule, and it has more genuine *purpose* to it than perhaps any other theatre show I have ever seen, and despite the interactive niceties, it is utterly untainted by the frivolity of plot — it has a mission and nothing gets in the way of it.</p><p>I think it affected me so much in part because I’ve been thinking recently about the British difficulty in coming to terms with ‘our’ own past (as a half-Pole I obviously have another ‘our’ at least as problematic). One difficulty, maybe, is that rather than suppress the truth about what happened on our own soil, we outsourced most of our atrocities and are now content to view them as distant foreign events (<a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170924161927/https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2012/apr/18/britain-destroyed-records-colonial-crimes">though I believe there was suppression too</a>).</p><p>I thought Tanika Gupta’s recent <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170924161927/https://www.timeout.com/london/theatre/lions-and-tigers-review">Lions and Tigers</a> at the Globe did a pretty good job of explaining how Indians probably viewed the British in the pre-independence era and why it is that the British Empire was not universally beloved. But ultimately I thought it was a bit grounded in the conventions of being a play, all subplots and climaxes. But it does strike me that in the blah blah Brexit era British theatre maybe has a responsibility to talk about British past in a way that goes beyond pieces of entertainment with a couple of painful truths tossed in. We know Amritsar happened — why don’t we give a shit, really? It should be huge, 9/11 with us as the bad guys. Instead it’s just ‘history’. Why do we persist in mythologising Winston Churchill but missing out the bad stuff? Can theatre fulfil the social function of keeping our unwanted past alive? Or do we shrug and hope somebody makes a hit film? (Mike Leigh’s imminent Peterloo flick looks important).</p><p>Anyway. Context is everything. I was just a foreign journalist, invited out to write what were clearly expected to be positive things about the company. There couldn’t really be a British equivalent to Belarus Free Theatre; undoubtedly many British theatres would be viewed as too radical for Minsk in their way. It is probably more important to have the right to free speech and not get it quite right than it is to not have the right but illegally get it correct to an audience of 30 (in a country of nine million). But so much of our theatre feels based on the idea that radical things are possible by sticking within the boundaries of a government-sponsored entertainment industry and perhaps tweaking the audience mix a little. And I wonder if that absolutely has to be the case.</p><p><em>NB this is clearly not the article I went out to write, about Belarus Free Theatre’s Kitchen Revolution — that’ll follow in October and be essentially London focussed with this as a backdrop. If you are a big money commissioning editor stunned by these words and would like them bashed into something less indulgent, we can talk. We can always talk.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=88fc1f23e681" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is it weird that four men and three women playing a tiger won best supporting actor at this year’s…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MrLukowski/is-it-weird-that-four-men-and-three-women-playing-a-tiger-won-the-best-supporting-actor-at-this-f8a927e0ce28?source=rss-edb7297c7a65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f8a927e0ce28</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[theatre]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life-of-pi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[west-end-theatre]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[olivier-awards]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrzej Lukowski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 13 Apr 2022 07:37:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-13T09:01:40.553Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Is it weird that four men and three women playing a tiger won best supporting actor at this year’s Olivier Awards?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MS-h540KLmGA5dHD1SJrYw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo: Johan Persson</figcaption></figure><p>On the face of it, the joint win for Fred Davis, Daisy Franks, Tom Stacy, Romina Hytten, Scarlet Wilderink, Tom Larkin and Habib Nasib Nader for their extremely impressive shared turn as the puppet tiger Richard Parker in the West End’s Life of Pi seems perfectly reasonable: it was a bloody good tiger, the role <em>is</em> a supporting one, and it’s difficult to see how it wins any sort of award unless you bend the rules a bit.</p><p>There’s also the fact that, just as Chekhov’s gun needs to be fired, once you’ve put seven guys playing a tiger on the best supporting actor shortlist, it would be supremely anticlimatic if a regular actor won it and the seven tiger guys were simply never mentioned again. Of <em>course</em> they would win. (Side note: multiple actors sharing a nomination at a theatre awards ceremony almost always win. Actors from the same show separately nominated in the same category almost always both lose – see, for instance, Danny Lee Wynter and Dino Fetscher from The Normal Heart, both shortlisted for the best supporting actor at the 2022 Olivier Awards).</p><p>However. After the seven tiger guys’ win early in the night, a number of queries about this kept popping up over the course of the evening, notably a) how had such an eccentric nomination come to be? and b) why had the best supporting actor category been landed on as the vehicle for this particular triumph?</p><p>Despite being on holiday this week, I had a whimsical idea of bashing out a cute <em>Vulture-s</em>tyle Q&amp;A on the subject for <em>Time Out</em> and duly emailed both Life of Pi and SOLT’s PRs first thing Monday morning (SOLT = Society of London Theatre, who run the awards), but the answers I got back were so terse and confusing that clearly that I gave up on this plan. Having not written anything for <em>The Stage</em> since 2020 I pitched something on the subject to them, and they were very gracious but said they had no slots in time. So I’ve turned to my lesser spotted Medium page, reasoning that while probably nobody would stop me writing a deep dive on an obscure awards ceremony decision on <em>Time Out</em>, then in fact I should probably be the one to stop me.</p><p>Anyway, in answer to the question of how the nomination had come to be, both Pi’s PR and SOLT’s PR suggested the other organisation would know the answer (Pi said it was a question for SOLT; SOLT said it would have been Pi’s producers who put the actors forward as a group). I could doubtless have pushed the tired and probably sadly not even hungover PRs further, but instead I read <a href="https://officiallondontheatre.com/olivier-awards/choosing-the-winners/">the actual rules</a> to the Oliviers, which I thought I understood but in fact I’m pretty sure I’d just been going off my interpretation of a conversation I had with <a href="https://twitter.com/matttrueman">Matt Trueman</a> about seven years ago.</p><p>It seems fairly apparent that Pi were right and SOLT were wrong as the road to this most unusual of victories would have begun with the, er, SOLT-drawn up theatre panel deciding the seven actors as a tiger were a thing. As I understand it they’re ten ish members of public who change each year (only the <a href="https://officiallondontheatre.com/olivier-awards/choosing-the-winners/">2020 panel</a> seems to be listed at the moment, I’m not sure if that’s a typo or not but it doesn’t really matter who they are specifically).</p><p>Anyway, the panel’s first responsibility re: the eventual selection of winners is to draw up a longlist for SOLT members to vote into a shortlist. And as a fun piece of trivia, SOLT members are free to ignore the longlist when they vote in other categories, but actually have to abide by it for best supporting actor and actress categories (because there are deemed to be too many eligible individuals otherwise, ie basically anybody in a show who isn’t the lead). So clearly the panel met, decided to put the seven actors forward as a single actor, and voting SOLT members agreed in numbers.</p><p>I’m intrigued as to the process for this, although not enough to bother SOLT’s PR more given the understandably bemused reaction to my initial query. But my queries if I thought I’d get the actual answers would be 1. did the panel need to get this signed off specifically or was it just accepted as the judgment of the panel and therefore fine 2. was there ever any wider discussion as to whether the awards might need to do anything differently to accommodate Life of Pi, which didn’t seem to obviously conform to a lot of the awards categories as strictly defined?</p><p>If you’re an absolute pedant for these things (which I am!) then the decision to give the seven actors playing the tiger the best supporting <em>actor</em> as opposed to best supporting <em>actress</em> is also intriguing. Life of Pi’s PR said to me that the reason was ‘because it’s Richard Parker’, ie the tiger is male. But, for instance, Cush Jumbo played Hamlet as man and was nominated for best actress; off the top of my head Bertie Carvel won the best actor Olivier back in the day for playing Mrs Trunchbull, a woman. I’m sure there are other examples.</p><p>There is a certain base logic that a narrow majority of the seven performers are male, but it does raise the question as to whether swapping a single male performer out and a single female performer in would have flipped the nomination to best supporting actress. There’s probably a fun wider hypothetical question as to what they’d do if a man and a woman were both nominated for alternating a pair of roles. But I can’t help but feel that the nomination probably occurred here because it ‘felt right’ — the panel wanted to give an option for Pi to win awards for its puppetry despite there not really being the appropriate categories, and whimsically putting all seven actors forward eye-catchingly paved the way for SOLT members to vote for a popular show that, crucially, a lot of them had seen.</p><p>I’m not sure if any of this is actually very important: despite their surface grandeur, the Olivier are basically The West End Awards, and ultimately nobody really takes them so seriously that anybody has really questioned this decision (apart from me, and I’m more intrigued than outraged). It is worth at least considering that if the best supporting actor <em>Oscar</em> was given to seven actors of varying sexes playing a puppet tiger it would surely cause quite a hullabaloo.</p><p>Maybe that is the point though: gutting as this must be for the three real actors shortlisted for the award, and questionable as it is what having a best supporting actor gong will actually mean in the future for the seven actual winners (tbf it’s a funny story and a stamp of reliability for future puppet work), I can’t help but feel that what this really underscores is the fact the Oliviers are fundamentally not that serious, in a very British way. Obviously by any sensible measure the award for best supporting actor should have gone to a single actor for conventional acting and some other way should have been found to big up the puppet performers. It seems ultimately odd that the awards managed to honour the seven tiger guys (some of whom only play the tiger for a few minutes, as I recall), but not find anything for puppetry and movement director Finn Caldwell, who as I understand it would be much more specifically responsible for the seven tiger guys’ performance than seven tiger guys themselves (or than a director would normally be for the specific details of an actor’s performance).</p><p>But the Oliviers are the type of place where the rules will ultimately permit an act of whimsy like seven actors of both sexes winning the best supporting actor award for playing a puppet tiger and I guess there are both good things and bad things about that!!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f8a927e0ce28" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Monster and me, me and the monster]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MrLukowski/monster-and-me-me-and-the-monster-b3907ee0e1b4?source=rss-edb7297c7a65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b3907ee0e1b4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[emr]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrzej Lukowski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 21 Aug 2020 21:22:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-22T09:29:50.937Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Me, Monster, Monster and I</h3><p>This chunk of prose began, probably sometime around Christmas, as an attempt to write a review of the twenty-fifth-anniversary reissue of R.E.M.’s misunderstood 1994 masterpiece Monster. It had been a great pleasure to review the previous eight R.E.M. reissues for indie music website Drowned in Sound, where I was reviews editor for a decade, and with the internet being a thing, there was nothing really stopping me just writing about Monster. I wanted to write about Monster.</p><p>The thing is, though, that I haven’t written about music since DiS shut up shop editorially in 2019 (not really a sob story, I just had other stuff on), and while I should just be able to write a review of an album that purely exists as me writing a review of an album because I want to write a review of an album, this is not how it panned out.</p><p>I’m not sure this really fits the bill of imposter syndrome, but depending on what it is then if I’ve not been commissioned to write something by someone I often feel a bit silly doing so, and with my not having fallen into any music writing post-DiS, the ‘review’ essentially turned into a lengthy justification of my right to write, even though it was clear that the only person I was discussing this with was me.</p><p>It went like this:</p><p><em>I used to be a music journalist you know.</em></p><p><em>Sort of.</em></p><p><em>More accurately, I did music journalism alongside other journalism and was never quite ‘a music journalist’, but I was quite close for a while, and there were certainly times when there was more music journalism than not music journalism.</em></p><p><em>My first published article was in </em><a href="http://digital.library.leeds.ac.uk/15536/"><em>Leeds Student newspaper on Friday October 13 2000</em></a><em> (I co-reviewed the week’s singles!). My last published article was my final bit of writing as reviews editor of Drowned in Sound, a February 12 2019 review of the last Mercury Rev album that nobody else wanted to do. I would like to do more: but I also haven’t, for various reasons (that somewhat boil down to not exactly being fighting off offers).</em></p><p><em>But! In some ways I only attempted music journalism because I wanted to write about the band R.E.M.; I started writing about the twenty-fifth-anniversary reissues of R.E.M.’s albums for DiS a decade ago, and I guess I don’t want to stop, and nobody’s stopping me, and the internet is a thing, so here is the continuation: I’ve written on Murmur, Reckoning, Fables of the Reconstruction, Lifes Rich Pageant, Document, Green, Out of Time, Automatic for the People, now a mere ten months and one pandemic after it was re-released, here comes Monster.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4ICr950NFBCpSyNtkScBkw.png" /></figure><p>The thing is, after all that I can’t just jump into a po-faced review of Monster now, can I? Well maybe I can, or maybe I make it all about me. Maybe that’s what Monster was, an album all about ‘me’ (Michael Stipe, writing songs that occasionally seemed to credibly be about Michael Stipe for the first time). Maybe I could draw a parallel between Monster, the daring leftfield musical turn from the biggest band in the world at the time, and me deciding to write a music review. Maybe.</p><p>Anyway, let’s try, no italics this time, though we’re about to segue into something I wrote months ago. SEGUE a thing about how we see the past is that things we didn’t experience seem more distant than those we did. I didn’t get into music (its history its trivia its characters etcetera) in a meaningful sense until I was maybe 15, and so all the records and artists that had passed me by even recently felt buried in deep time. In 1996, the first Suede album felt as distant as The Beatles; The Smiths and The Stone Roses felt no nearer or further than The Velvet Underground or The Stooges; The Stones or Bowie felt more present and approachable than, say, Hüsker Dü, because they were just there, often mugging away on 90s breakfast telly.</p><p>Monster was the last R.E.M. album to come out before I was a fan of R.E.M., and by the time I was a fan of R.E.M. I knew it only by its negative reputation. For a while I was content to leave it buried in the murky past (of two years previously). I bought all nine of R.E.M.’s other albums, loved all of them, and for some time never questioned the idea that Monster was a bad record, although I wearily assented to buy it last. Music was very expensive in the mid-Nineties, especially when you were at school and didn’t technically have an income.</p><p>Ironically, Monster was in fact quite cheap, probably £4.99, being a staple of that most ’90s receptacle, the CD bargain bin.</p><p>In the mid-to-late-’90s the question of *why* Monster had sold a lot of copies that were subsequently returned was not really something I was equipped to deal with or, indeed, at all interested in: I just vaguely deferred to the idea of the wisdom of the crowd.</p><p>Now that I am old and saggy enough to care, I would say Monster fell into a threefold bind: it freaked out the Out of Time/Automatic for the People fans who thought R.E.M. were an all-acoustic alt. rock ballads act; it somewhat freaked older fans expecting a return to the big ’80s singles; and it was heavily misinterpreted as an attempt by the band to ‘stay current’ by writing a grunge record, despite not really sounding like one. In the pre-streaming era it felt, if not desirable, at least inevitable that a large number of people would listen to Monster, conclude it was not for them, and return it.</p><p>I think its bad rep has largely passed, broadly speaking because its <em>rep</em> has passed — R.E.M.’s superstardom now feels very distant, but they’re consequently cooler, if only because they’re less famous. They’re an indie band from the past, who for whatever reason don’t really sound like anyone else.</p><p>And while within that a lot of the records sound related to <em>each other</em>, Monster doesn’t really. It is Monster.</p><p>It is still feels steeped in that strange foreboding I felt about it before I’d even listened to it. That initial unease was misplaced, and yet somehow bled into its feverish metallic weirdness. I think I first heard a lot of its songs via the concert film Road Movie, which I think to this day I’ve only seen once, actually on the literal telly when I was 16, and remember as a wired scarlet fever pummel that somewhat freaked me out and also further informed how I felt about it.</p><p>A sort of avant-glam record somewhat related to Raw Power, Daydream Nation and Electric Warrior, it is about sex, and longing, and obsession, and crushes, and youth, and death, and perhaps above all jadedness. It’s jadedness that makes lead single and opener What’s the Frequency Kenneth? feel like it has something to say — whatever (if anything) it may literally *mean*, each line feels deeply *important*: ‘withdrawal in disgust is not the same as apathy’. If Nirvana’s cynicism manifested itself as snarling nihilism, R.E.M.’s cynicism sounds like the wisdom of elders. What’s the Frequency Kenneth? expresses a wish to be removed from the world informed by neither despair nor romance, but a clear-eyed awareness of what the world was. And the music is… different… slow and springly, bright and heavy, with an incredibly odd guitar solo.</p><p>Elsewhere Michael Stipe sings about sex and obsession with a knowingness that an innocent simply could not — the half lascivious/half-processed sex-crunch of ‘King of Comedy’ feels like a wilful subversion of the previous ten years; it’s a great song that would have utterly ruined Automatic for the People if it was on it, let alone Murmur or Reckoning.</p><p>Perhaps above all the record is a sound and a colour, a glittering orange fug of effects, coruscating and weird, a band that had previously eschewed studio trickery going absolutely nuts. It is heady and feverish and disorientating, and ends with an astounding trio of songs that feel like being physically euphoic and emotionally destroyed: Let Me In, a song about the passing of Kurt Cobain that’s almost indecipherable, the lyrics drowned in a billowing nebula of guitar, but desperately, desperately sad. Circus Envy is pure processed sound, a guitar that sounds like a pneumatic drill, warring with an ominous, muttering Stipe. You is apocalyptic and screaming, an unknowable, mystic peal of pain.</p><p>The deep orange throb of the art has always felt entirely definitive of the record, which is maybe for me the most headfuck about this reissue: it trades the orange for a burning blue. I’m not totally sure why, but it seems reflective of the big curiosity of its twenty-fifth-anniversary edition: alongside the original, we have the entire album remixed by its producer Scott Litt. It generaly sounds a lot ‘nicer’, and is clearly on one level enormously flattering to Stipe, who is promoted from another roar in the mix to the lead singer of R.E.M. It’s not the same, though — not I suppose is it meant to be, but although it’s interesting, it feels like it’s lost some sort of profound strangeness. I mean that’s not the whole story: King of Comedy ditches the guitars in favour of synths that switch between glacial and ravey and tantalisingly hints at the fact they could probably have done a fascinating electronic record (something Stipe’s frustratingly sporadic solo career strongly suggests). It’s fine, and I’ll listen to it every now and again, but can anyone prefer it to the original? It seems somewhat random that Litt asked and the band agreed, but it confirmed that Monster isn’t just some songs: it’s a feeling, a mood, a madness.</p><p>But but but who am I saying this to? In the ordered confines of a commissioned music review I’m offering a consumer guide of sorts. Here I suppose I’m just writing for me, with no imagined you, beyond a small sub-section of my social media followers. Which is okay, but part of the reason I’ve found this such a monster is that a dialogue with yourself feels terrifyingly unconstrained — why stick to the topic of Monster when this has in certainly obviously plague-related been the most tumultuous year of my life? Why limit my reflections to my music writing career when this could be an outlet to talk about my how being a full-time parent for the last five months has been a brutal drain on the ol’ writing? What about my worries about finding the freelance work to top up my now part-time job? What about talking about how the jig was almost up for me at Time Out and wondering who I would be if not Theatre Guy? Heck, why not talk about how I’d pondered if the gall of writing this review as if anybody might care is expression of white privilege? And why not try and tie these things onto R.E.M.’s most abrasive and transformative record.</p><p>These are all terrible ideas that I drafted and could have published, and still could publish, and still might publish, because with no editor this never really has to stop. But maybe this can serve as a sort of catharsis, an expression of — or at least, allusion to – doubts about writing that are always there, but I can surely only feel inclined to write about them so many times. Ultimately, I can write whatever I want, just as people can paint what they want, or cook what they want, or (am I really doing this) make the misunderstood avant-glam masterpiece they want. I have been given the freedom to do as I see fit.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b3907ee0e1b4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[It’s the Worthys: Glastonbury 2019, rated by Drowned in Sound]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/drowned-in-sound/its-the-worthys-glastonbury-2019-rated-by-drowned-in-sound-c7bed18e4600?source=rss-edb7297c7a65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c7bed18e4600</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stormzy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[glastonbury-festival]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[glastonbury]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrzej Lukowski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Jul 2019 10:38:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-08T19:51:08.862Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="https://twitter.com/muldoon">Mark Muldoon</a> and <a href="https://twitter.com/albion1981">David Edwards</a> went to Glastonbury and here’s what they thought. Photos by <a href="https://iso400photoblog.wordpress.com/">Mike Burnell</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zJEcT7DS5mb2C6x1rhbTGQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Glastonbury has sort of got into a rhythm of being consistently astonishing now, hasn’t it? Every year the nuts-and-bolts organisation behind it gets a little better and every year the crowd tangibly seems to respond with a kind of perpetual elation that they are the people that actually get to be there.</p><p>A less welcome return though, for The Worthys — DiS’s tired Glastonbury awards format somehow returning for a third year. Here’s DiS’s Dave Edwards and Mark Muldoon to garland everything on site that remotely deserved it.</p><p><strong>Most triumphant set: Stormzy</strong></p><p>We’re used to having a bit of a backlash to headliner announcements by now of course. It’s probably reasonable to say that this announcement back in November generated its fair share of ‘online comment’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*76vk4dUzdmxTZTEMMTLiOQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>In fairness, Stormzy does feel like something of an incongruous booking, when — quite apart from anything else — he’s playing a stage that otherwise tends to be pretty resolutely Radio 2-leaning. On the Friday, warming up the Pyramid Stage for Stormzy are a not exactly confrontational rollcall of acts including George Ezra, Tom Odell, Sheryl Crow and an ABBA tribute band.</p><p>There’s no doubt a backlash can make for a more exciting set, mind. With so much to prove, then, it’s clear that this show has had one hell of a lot of thought put into it. Staging, messaging, crowd-pleasing covers/samples, artful touches from <a href="https://twitter.com/jeremycorbyn/status/1144744809539743749">ballet</a> to <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2019/06/29/entertainment/stormzy-glastonbury-scli-gbr-intl/index.html]">Banksy</a> and seemingly a warehouse full of pyrotechnics all combine to make a show where it’s difficult to think how he could’ve tried any harder.</p><p>In a weekend when you’re somewhat bombarded by musicians telling you how it’s their dream to be performing here, you really, really felt that Stormzy was enjoying the peak of his career so far. Some special guests are also wheeled out to join the party, but nothing to overshadow the fact that this is his moment. He’s proving he can do this on his own. And now we know: without question he can.</p><p><strong>Best scene: UK hip hop</strong></p><p>It’s a weekend that more generally shows the breadth and talent of UK hip hop right now — and there’s an enormous amount of fun to be had exploring it. So as well as Stormzy, you may well have seen the widely circulated clip of #AlexFromGlasto being picked out the crowd by <strong>Dave</strong> to join him rapping on stage (if you haven’t, it’s one for the Glasto hall of fame. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e1vlLJCr9Lo">Full uncensored clip here</a>). The crowd hadn’t generally clocked that to be invited on stage he’d already demonstrated knowing the words to a fairly impressive extent. Everybody around us was braced for an awkward moment. He turned out to be fantastic and in response we completely erupted.</p><p><strong>Loyle Carner</strong>, meanwhile, got two mates up on stage during his set to celebrate it being their first ever Glastonbury, before the actual reason becomes apparent: a very nicely orchestrated marriage proposal in front of 15,000 odd people. Which makes it <a href="http://drownedinsound.com/in_depth/4151133-the-worthys--dis-does-glastonbury-2017">two Glastonburys in a row now</a> that Carner has made me cry during his set.</p><p>Carner also pops out during <strong>Slowthai</strong>’s (ridiculously fun) set to join in one of the regular moshpits the Northampton rapper’s performance attracts. His hypeman is arguably braver — one of the most arresting visuals of the weekend is him stood alone at the centre of a massive circle, before 150 odd people simultaneously charge straight into him from every direction. An alarmingly brutal sight but naturally, everybody involved appears to be thoroughly enjoying themselves.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VuIwrXF4dIPoLUW4dvLeZA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Best headlining strategy: play the hits</strong></p><p><strong>The Killers’</strong> set feels like quite a close relation to — and near equal of — Blur’s legendary 2009 headline performance. It follows the obvious blueprint for how to nail your Glastonbury show: have a real arsenal of hits and don’t be tight about playing them all.</p><p>Alongside similar crowd-pleasing sets from <strong>Kylie</strong> and <strong>The Cure</strong>, you do get the impression that this vital message has been successfully disseminated around the headliner community. Which is absolutely ideal news.</p><p><strong>Most supercool music reviewers: <em>Drowned in Sound</em>’s reviewers</strong></p><p>Hey Dave, we’re not going to mention in the review that the only set both you and I watched together all weekend was Keane, right? DiS has got an 18-year long reputation to uphold, here.</p><p>Drowned in Sound is now on hiatus for the foreseeable future. Please follow us on social media (<a href="http://twitter.com/drownedinsound">Twitter</a>, <a href="http://facebook.com/drownedinsounduk">Facebook</a> or <a href="http://instagram.com/drownedinsound">Instagram</a>) or <a href="http://community.drownedinsound.com/">join or forums</a> for further updates.</p><iframe src="https://www.instagram.com/p/BzSWXc2nLWP/embed/?cr=1&amp;amp;rd=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.instagram.com" width="658" height="882" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/fbec6d009917e5c3f77a86e71aca8725/href">https://medium.com/media/fbec6d009917e5c3f77a86e71aca8725/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c7bed18e4600" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/drowned-in-sound/its-the-worthys-glastonbury-2019-rated-by-drowned-in-sound-c7bed18e4600">It’s the Worthys: Glastonbury 2019, rated by Drowned in Sound</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/drowned-in-sound">Drowned in Sound</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A love letter to Glastonbury 2019]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/drowned-in-sound/a-love-lglastonbury-2019-b6ff6df23d31?source=rss-edb7297c7a65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b6ff6df23d31</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[glastonbury-festival]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kylie-minogue]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[glastonbury]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrzej Lukowski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Jul 2019 10:25:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-08T19:52:34.031Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Words <a href="https://twitter.com/albion1981">David Edwards</a>. Photo <a href="https://iso400photoblog.wordpress.com/">Mike Burnell</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iramgk9iGoNCy3D1fZNU4g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Kylie Minogue</figcaption></figure><p>I first went to <strong>Glastonbury Festival</strong> in 2007. I was 25, and though something of a late starter I have been to every single subsequent event at Worthy Farm. In the back of my mind there has always been the feeling that one day, I will walk away from the festival thinking ‘that’s enough’. So every single time I step foot into the enormous city that grows out of the ground — as if by the design of some Arthurian Wizard — on Worthy Farm, I’m acutely aware that this could be the year I finally tire of the size, the scale, the exhaustion and the ever-growing stiffness in my knees.</p><p>So what do we say to the god of Glastonbury disappointment? Not this year. No bloody way…</p><p>Over three astonishing and sun-scorched days at Glastonbury, there was barely a moment where you weren’t overwhelmed by the sheer quality and diversity of the music on show. This was one of the finest musical weekends of my life, and that comes from someone who didn’t even get to see <strong>Stormzy</strong>’s astounding Friday headliner, or see <strong>The Cure</strong> make one of the toughest stages in the world into their absolute own.</p><p><strong>Friday</strong></p><p>Every good celebration needs a good opening dance. And satirical ABBA tribute act <strong>Björn Again</strong> are precisely the sort of daft thing that makes the festival so unpretentious and their commitment to their roles is commendable, right down to era-appropriate costume changes and calling each other by their aliases on stage. But in terms of the music, you simply cannot go wrong with arguably the finest pure-pop songbook in the history of music. We get all the greatest hits plus a somewhat bizarre cover version of Van Halen’s ‘Jump’ thrown in for good measure.</p><p><strong>Goat Girl</strong>’s brilliantly slanted psych-rock remains bafflingly under-rated and it is a real shame that their John Peel performance is so scantly attended, but they turn in a terrific performance in spite of this.</p><p>I had my first kiss to a <strong>Sheryl Crow</strong> song. And she obliges me by playing said song — ‘If it Makes You Happy’ as the opener. It’s perfect mid-afternoon Pyramid Stage fayre — she looks as if she is thoroughly enjoying herself in the sunshine, the sun is beaming and her band and the sound are strong and loud. It’s a fantastic moment with an act that many people wouldn’t see otherwise (me included) who have happy memories of the mid-to-late 90s. Her enthusiasm and good grace is admirable as she stalks the side ramparts and comes down to meet fans at the front. And by the time she brings out ‘Soak Up the Sun’ (a track that cannot fail on a day like this) and a closing ‘Everyday is a Winding Road’ we are all sent happily on our way.</p><p>Enthusiasm isn’t really a word one would necessarily associate with <strong>Ms Lauryn Hill</strong> though. And nor should we probably expect it, given her variable history of tricky behaviour in the live arena. But to be fair, she does her absolute best today — she sings and raps perfectly, she seems genuinely willing to try and give her all and with songs as flawless as the ones she plays from her classic &lt;i&gt;The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill&lt;/i&gt; record, she has a captive crowd. The set is besieged by unfortunate sound issues, but she does pull it round with an absolutely towering closing trio of ‘To Zion’, a monumental ‘Doo Wop (That Thing)’ complete with some quite brilliant rapping and a mass sing-along of The Fugees ‘Killing Me Softly’ that the whole crowd continues singing long after she has left the stage. I’ve seen some reviews being very unfair on her set and I think that is overly harsh. It was ok, it just occasionally fluttered when it could and should have soared.</p><p>Cider is refilled, food is bought. The sun finally dips and we get some respite from the searing heat. And there are serious choices to be made. One of the issues this year is the sheer scale of the headline clashes — today we face a choice between Stormzy, Interpol, Jon Hopkins and Tame Impala. We eventually plump for the latter and make our way over to the Other Stage where I am hugely impressed and pleasantly surprised by how good the last few songs of <strong>Two Door Cinema Club</strong> are. They combine rhythm and melodicism into a colourful package of joy and prove an unexpected delight as the Other Stage is bathed in a glorious sunset.</p><p>Back in 2013, <strong>Tame Impala</strong> played The Other Stage in the middle of the afternoon to a huge crowd, fresh on the success of <em>Lonerism</em>. Whilst may might have expected that to be the height of their success, In the six years since, they have truly gone stratospheric. Despite the appeal of Stormzy on the Pyramid Stage, the stage is absolutely packed as they come on to an extended, woozy version of ‘Let it Happen’. The lysergic symmetry of the music and the kaleidoscopic visuals prove a worthy addition to the electronic history of the stage, yet there is a harder edge always underneath — Kevin Parker’s guitar and the willingness to rock out — especially during a storming version of ‘Mind Mischief’ complete with the ‘Sestri Levante’ jam at the end. ‘Yes, I’m Changing’, ‘Feels Like We Only Go Backwards’ and ‘Why Won’t You Make Up Your Mind’ overflow with Beatles-esque psychedelic swirl; ‘Led Zeppelin’ and ‘Apocalypse Dreams’ stomp and shake. And of course, ‘Elephant’ brings the house down. By the time they close with a stirring, anthemic rendition of ‘New Person, Same Old Mistakes’ as laser lights and strobes sweep the field like a series of fractured searchlight beams, they have confirmed their ability to command the biggest of bills and as a band of truly unique powers and dynamics. Stunning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Fr7cD28k3oogeE5auLaBTw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Saturday</strong></p><p>As we start making our way into the arena, all the talk on Saturday morning is about Stomzy’s mesmeric set the other night (see Mark’s review for more details). It is another sizzling day and the mercury has already hit 28 degrees by the time I take my place in the front section of The Pyramid Stage for <strong>The Proclaimers</strong>. As an opening act on the stage, they can pretty much relax knowing that their simple, honest and energetic songs are bound to win everyone over. And certainly, they do just that. It is easy to pigeonhole The Proclaimers but to witness one of their live sets is to be struck by the sheer number of memorable and straight-from-the-heart anthems that they have.</p><p>It’s over from the old to the new as we walk to a baking John Peel Stage for <strong>She Drew the Gun</strong>, who once again prove that they have a serious claim to be the best up-and-coming band in Britain today. From the opening power of ‘Resister’, the glorious tilt and sway of ‘Something for the Pain’ they seem absolutely at home at the festival where they first made their breakthrough with the Emerging Talent Prize in 2016.</p><p>A glorious surprise awaits whilst strolling through West Holts on a mission for a Brothers Pear Cider to slake the thirst. And that surprise is <strong>Ezra Collective</strong>. Jazzy and funky, sparse and melodic, hugely entertaining and brilliantly connecting with the audience — they are exactly the kind of communal experience you need mid-afternoon with the sun baking down. They bring on <strong>Jorja Smith</strong> for one track and then a tremendous cameo turn from <strong>Loyle Carner</strong> with a freestyle rap. The whole thing is one joyous celebration of music, life and being finding your happiness. Thoroughly recommended.</p><p>As indeed are Oxford’s <strong>The Low Island </strong>who we find on the Greenpeace Stage, in amongst skaters, sun casualties and urgent messages about the state of the planet. They do a lovely and enthralling line in sparse, minimalist electronica tucked into the silhouette of an indie band, at times almost coming across like a more guitar-interested LCD Soundsystem.</p><p>We then come to the weekend’s worst clash. With the news that Foals are confirmed for the secret set at The Park, we have a horrendous choice between them, Johnny Marr, Lizzo and <strong>Janet Jackson</strong>. It’s an agonising choice to make, but eventually we decide to head to the Pyramid Stage for Janet, largely on the grounds that we are likely to see (or have seen) the rest on plenty of other occasions, whereas seeing a bona-fide legend in Janet Jackson is unlikely to happen anytime soon. And just like Lauryn Hill, there is good and bad. She lip-syncs, but given the sheer energy and power of her dancing and the way she prowls and storms round the stage, that doesn’t overly bother me. So why is it that the set — though thoroughly entertaining and supremely crafted — never quite gets beyond the 8/10 level? In the end, it is possibly the latter thing. The dancing is PHENOMENALLY tight and choreographed to absolute precision, but there is something almost too clinical and machine-tooled about both the show and much of the accompanying audience interaction. But that isn’t to detract from a remarkable run of songs including ‘What Have You Done for Me Lately’, ‘Nasty’, ‘That’s the Way Love Goes’ and a joyous rendition of her 1992 collaboration with Luther Vandross ‘The Best Things in Life Are Free’. And the closing ‘Rhythm Nation’ is tremendous, though it is notable that she pays tribute to ‘my family, The Jacksons’ as opposed to any reference to Michael solely.</p><p>The last time <strong>Liam Gallagher</strong> graced the Pyramid Stage was back with Oasis in 2004, and the result was a sprawling, scowling, unfocused and uninterested shambles that frankly shamed both the band and their frontman. It was the moment I gave up on Oasis after a decade of them soundtracking my life. So Liam has a point to prove today, and he rises admirably to the challenge. He really does now have his mojo back — strutting the stage, shaking his maracas, looking every bit the iconic frontman of his early years. It’s true that the voice occasionally strains and it is also true that the weight of his solo material struggles to breathe against the power of the Oasis songs, but the swagger and charm carries the day, as does the continued excellence of the likes of ‘Morning Glory, ‘Rock ’n’ Roll Star’, ‘Cigarettes and Alcohol’ and a barnstorming ‘Columbia’. Welcome back Real Liam. You have been missed.</p><p>Move ahead to the next paragraph <strong>Keane</strong> haters, because you’re going to be frothing at the mouth. Because in all honesty, their Acoustic Stage show was an absolute joy. I have long supported the East Sussex band through 15 years of sneers and scorn because regardless of how ‘posh’ people think they are, the songs they put out over their first three albums still stand up. And my word, do they stand up tonight. To a packed tent (the band, and Tom Chaplin in particular are absolutely blown away by the size of the crowd) they just give us brilliant song after brilliant song. Opener ‘Bend and Break’ is magnificent. ‘Nothing in my Way’ still sounds effortlessly yearning — full of emotion and weariness. ‘Spiralling’ still sounds like a band reaching out of their comfort zone and succeeding admirably. And when it comes to the hits — ‘Somewhere Only We Know’, a magnificent ‘Everybody’s Changing’ and a soaring ‘This is the Last Time’ — you wonder just how songs of this simple, honest beauty have been lost in time, and unfairly marginalised. One of the sets of the weekend, from a band who genuinely deserve a reappraisal.</p><p>Again, we struggle to decide on who to see next. As we walk down, The Killers kick off with a storming ‘Jenny Was a Friend of Mine’ but we are swayed by the promise of <strong>The Chemical Brothers</strong> on The Other Stage. However, it doesn’t fully connect tonight in the way that previous shows of theirs have. Not because of the band and their setlist, which is typically brilliant and showing off their superb new album <em>No Geography</em>, especially a superb ‘Got to Keep On’ and a stomping ‘MAH’. And their visuals are as mind-bending as ever. No, it’s not them — it is the fact that their reputation precedes them and The Other Stage is absolutely packed, with room only at the very back. As such, the power of the music and the sheer retina-blast of the visuals is hugely diminished.</p><p>After half the show we end up heading to see <strong>Hot Chip</strong> at The Park. And we are so glad we do. The sound is bouncing and strong and they really cannot do any wrong. ‘Over and Over’ prompts an enormous wave of bouncing and pogoing, ‘And I Was a Boy From School’ shimmers and sparkles and ‘Ready for the Floor’ remains their enduring masterpiece. They even throw in their usual esoteric covers — tonight we get an abridged version of The Eurythmics’ ‘Love is a Stranger’ during ‘Spell’ and they then bring out Four Tet for a truly unexpected and storming version of The Beastie Boys ‘Sabotage’.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kmuE0BOMPp7oi2QC_K3ePg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Sunday</strong></p><p>After staying awake until 5am listening to Detroit techno and watching an S&amp;M-influenced dance troupe in Block 9, getting up is hard work. But the sun has taken a brief respite and there are bands to see — there is no time for rest. Certainly not when we are in the presence of greatness on the Pyramid Stage at midday for the one and only <strong>Mavis Staples</strong>. It’s a slow-paced and languid set, as befitting an artist approaching her 80th birthday but that deep, trembling soulful voice still resonates across the crowd — still retaining its power and singularity. It’s the ideal set at an early hour, and as she is helped off stage to huge applause, you are aware how fortunate you are to have seen a living legend.</p><p>The legs are starting to get weary but we decide to head on over to West Holts to see Jeff Goldblum and The Mildred Snitzer Orchestra, that is until someone in the press area mentions that Sir David Attenboroug<strong>h</strong> is appearing on The Pyramid Stage at 2.30pm. So we change tack and head over to an already-rammed Pyramid Stage where <strong>Years &amp; Years</strong> are performing. Musically, it is standard electro-pop fayre with outward prettiness but little interior substance. That said, the stage show and the dancers are impressive and any criticism is immediately forgiven when Olly Alexander gives a remarkable and deeply moving five-minute monologue about the prejudice he has faced as an openly gay man, the deep and urgent importance of gay rights and the legacy of the Stonewall Riots fifty years ago.</p><p>After a brief, but vital statement from <strong>Sir David Attenborough</strong> thanking Glastonbury for banning single-use plastics (the site is so much clearer and cleaner this year — definitely a vital and welcome move from the festival) and a stunning preview of the new BBC nature series <em>Seven Worlds, One Planet</em> we find ourselves right at the front of the Pyramid Stage — squashed but excited — for <strong>Kylie Minogue</strong>. It is unquestionably the biggest crowd of the weekend and when she emerges for the opening ‘Love at First Sight’ — smiling and resplendent in a gold dress — the roar that greets her is almost physically powerful in its resonance. What follows is essentially the perfect Glastonbury pop set. She makes the bold but correct decision not to snub the ‘80s Stock, Aitken and Waterman pop era, with the likes of ‘I Should Be So Lucky’, ‘The Locomotion’, ‘Hand on Your Heart’, ‘Especially for You’ and ‘Better the Devil You Know’ being joyous, celebratory and unpretentious singalongs. Fresh red roses are handed out to the front of the crowd as she brings out <strong>Nick Cave</strong> for ‘Where the Wild Roses Grow’ — the first time she has played it in her own set since 1995. Then we get the electro ‘00s comeback hits — a mashup of ‘Slow’ and David Bowie’s ‘Fashion’ that works much better than it has any right to, and a riotous ‘Kids’, though she does nearly blow it with a well-meaning but ultimately unnecessary cameo by Chris Martin that reduces the start of ‘Can’t Get You Out of My Head’ to a dreary busker ballad (though once the beat kicks in midway through, all is forgiven). And of course, a swirling, woozy ‘Confide in Me’ — a track that remains by far her finest moment.</p><p>There is a stop-off to see <strong>The Bootleg Beatles</strong> in the Acoustic Stage who give us a typically joyous hour of some of music’s most sublime songs, before we head back to the Pyramid Stage for Vampire Weekend. Though in doing this, we catch the closing moments of <strong>Miley Cyrus</strong>’s astonishing performance on the same stage. When we walk in she is dressed as her Ashley O character from her recent Black Mirror episode, performing ‘On a Roll’ from that show, morphing it into Nine Inch Nails’ ‘Head Like a Hole’ from which it is based. She finishes with a stunning ‘Wrecking Ball’ and her whole stage demeanour, voice and sheer energy is astounding. As much as I love The Beatles, I’m chalking this one up as an error — staggeringly good.</p><p><strong>Vampire Weekend</strong> really do have a free hit here. And they do not miss. At four albums in now, they can afford to chop and change but the likes of ‘Cape Cod Kwassa Kwassa’, ‘Cousins’ and ‘Diane Young’ are near flawless examples of indie world-pop. The band — as expected — are sublime, with special mention to new touring guitarist Brian Robert Jones who is a frankly ridiculous talent. Most impressive is the response to the likes of ‘Harmony Hall’ and ‘This Life’ which already sound like classics and fit seamlessly into the set only a few weeks after being revealed to the world. ‘Oxford Comma’ still sounds magnificently sly, bookish and witty and the closing ‘Jerusalem, New York, Berlin’ ends the set on a wistful, melancholic but oddly moving note. It may not have been the storming and energetic set on the same stage in 2013 but it was another reminder of just how unique, melodic and sensitive this band are under the preppy exterior, and how lucky we are to have them.</p><p>Again, clashes abound as we reach the culmination of the festival. At any other time, the opportunity to see The Cure on the Pyramid, Janelle Monae on West Holts or Christine and the Queens at The Other Stage would have been too tempting to ignore. But I have unfinished business over at John Peel. See, <strong>The Streets</strong> have a deep and dear place in my heart with their first two albums. Back between 2001 and 2005, Mike Skinner and his songs meant the world to me at a key point in my life with so many of those early songs providing accompaniment to so many important moments for me. So it therefore broke my heart when the final two Streets albums became increasingly self-parodic and the live shows descended into an aimless mess — eschewing everything that they used to stand for. But having been blown away by their Parklife set the other week, I make the call to let Mike Skinner bring things home and to finally put to rest my sadness.</p><p>And they deliver. Boy, do they deliver. In an utterly rammed tent (it is so packed inside and outside that you can barely move at first) Mike Skinner decides to play it absolutely straight and just give us the hits. The opening trio of ‘Turn the Page’, ‘Has it Come to This?’, ‘Sharp Darts’ and ‘Geezers Need Excitement’ take us right back to the days of <em>Original Pirate Material</em> and still sound unique, fresh and barely date. From there, the energy never stops flowing. Mike Skinner is on superb form — pogoing for England, funny and communicative with the crowd and looking genuinely blown away by the amount of people here for this show. The likes of ‘Dry Your Eyes’ and ‘It’s Too Late’ remind you just how sensitive and delicate Skinner’s songs can be and how they acted as a necessary foil to his tales of beer, brandy and lairy japes. It may be hard to see where a new album can come from that doesn’t detract from the newly-recalled legacy (the new tracks still sound something of an afterthought rather than having and true weight) but for now, that doesn’t matter. As we leave the tent, people passing us are shocked that we didn’t see The Cure. I love The Cure, I really do. But I’m not sad or sorry. As a way to finish everything off, that was simply blinding.</p><p>So once again, I stagger away from the Worthy Farm gates the next morning to my car and begin the familiar and long drive home. After a while, you see less and less Glastonbury parking stickers on cars until it just becomes the odd one on the motorway, then none as I reach the outskirts of Manchester and return to a normal life of showers, walls, comfortable beds and (less welcomingly) a full day of work the next day. But already I am thinking about 2020 and the 50th anniversary. As ever, Glastonbury 2019 delivered on every single level — a festival genuinely like no other, which year-on-year rises to the challenge it sets itself and remains truly diverse, political and of absolute cultural relevance to the fabric of this country.</p><p><a href="http://drownedinsound.com/"><em>Drowned in Sound</em></a><em> is now on hiatus for the foreseeable future. Please follow us on social media (</em><a href="http://twitter.com/drownedinsound"><em>Twitter</em></a><em>, </em><a href="http://facebook.com/drownedinsounduk"><em>Facebook</em></a><em> or </em><a href="http://instagram.com/drownedinsound"><em>Instagram</em></a><em>) or </em><a href="http://community.drownedinsound.com/"><em>join or forums</em></a><em> for further updates.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b6ff6df23d31" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/drowned-in-sound/a-love-lglastonbury-2019-b6ff6df23d31">A love letter to Glastonbury 2019</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/drowned-in-sound">Drowned in Sound</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ten years of DiS (a playlist)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MrLukowski/ten-years-of-dis-a-playlist-41a51785920f?source=rss-edb7297c7a65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/41a51785920f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrzej Lukowski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Apr 2019 21:34:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-24T21:36:51.490Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0Qfr7izuxrfWQQbcvqR1uQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>A Shadow in Time</figcaption></figure><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fopen.spotify.com%2Fembed%2Fplaylist%2F3PDWCBVbHSJGA69XVqlecB&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fopen.spotify.com%2Fuser%2Fmrlukowski%2Fplaylist%2F3PDWCBVbHSJGA69XVqlecB&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fmosaic.scdn.co%2F300%2F3e9632a9123d77f5b11d93f1caeb86c0b8f620eb60698e338d19a36a981fa934d9067a42ad00860283c4f90ba6a0fcff09f5b8abb1c9120adec26321bc2226badb30dfa8699cbd45e15246dac87d50d7&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=spotify" width="300" height="380" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/1a9f3901267a706287d19ab2e04cc418/href">https://medium.com/media/1a9f3901267a706287d19ab2e04cc418/href</a></iframe><p>It’s totally indulgent to do this, but it’s the Internet, right? These songs are songs I’ll always associate with DiS, as a sort of more fun companion piece to <a href="https://medium.com/@MrLukowski/dis-is-the-end-9ddaf8dbea70">this</a>.</p><p><strong>1. </strong>Y<strong>eah Yeah Yeahs — Zero</strong>. I <em>really</em> associate this song with moving to London. YYYs headlined the 2009 Camden Crawl, when it was pretty much as its zenith, and clearly I saw them at I think the Shepherd’s Bush Empire and interviewed them (bit of a tough one tbh) around the time. Zero is just an absolutely colossal banger, I think maybe it gets a bit forgotten about because as a rule people slightly give up on them after the second album. But you mustn’t forget Zero.</p><p><strong>2. Women — Eyesore</strong>. I was so obsessed with this song I wrote my <a href="http://drownedinsound.com/releases/15612/reviews/4140843">review</a> of the album about how obsessed I was with this song, and how much it was distracting me from the rest of the album. It is still completely extraordinary, the last three minutes are absolutely stupendous, music beyond sense and definition and feeling. I think probably it is one of the greatest songs ever written and the band is gone, forever.</p><p><strong>3. Animal Collective — In the Flowers</strong>. Three things: the rush when the drums and the bass kick in always floors me, for some reason it has never, ever palled even slightly. It really reminds me of backpacking in 2009, because I listened to it incessantly. And it has possibly the only line from one of my own <a href="http://drownedinsound.com/releases/13913/reviews/4136043">reviews</a> that I actually remember: ‘the rush of joy; joy unbounded’ is a totally pretentious thing to write but I think ‘start glib, finished emotionally’ has probably been the essential core of my writing style since.</p><p><strong>4. Blur — Go Out. </strong>I got to see a reunited Blur multiple times as a result of DiS and it was just the greatest privilege. And I really do think The Magic Whip was a genuinely incredible record. I feel like watching the Blur story end happily was just a really cool thing to do as a music journalist.</p><p><strong>5. David Bowie — Blackstar. </strong>It was great to have a platform that would just publish anything I wrote to let me blather about my feelings through his return, his new music, and then his death. The fact that all of this happened in under three years is weird and sad. I think <a href="http://drownedinsound.com/releases/19160/reviews/4149680">I reviewed Blackstar</a> off a stream I got less than a week before release and I might easily have not had the review ready until after his death; it’s a weird thing to have written a piece that talked about his mysteries and disappearances simply not knowing.</p><p><strong>6. The Height of Summer — The Knife. </strong>This album (Tomorrow, in a Year) was so difficult and all consuming and brilliant that I think the time when I was listening to it incessantly to try and work out <a href="http://drownedinsound.com/releases/15134/reviews/4139188">what the fuck to say</a> has always stayed in my head. I also interviewed Olaf, and found him one of the happiest and most interesting music interviews I did.It’s maybe a cop out to go for the one bouncy pop track, but almost nothing else from the record makes any sense outside of the context of the record.</p><p><strong>7. Little Hells — Marissa Nadler. </strong>Somebody me and Sean both really liked, I was maybe a bit more up and down with which of her records I was a fan of but I think Little Hells (the album) and July are masterpieces. I like Little Hells (the song) because it’s weird and a bit unrepresentative and hazy and nostalgic; it could have been something off July but I guess again Little Hells really reminds me of backpacking, I am sentimental that way.</p><p><strong>8. Sufjan Stevens</strong> <strong>— Fourth of July. </strong>Another ‘DiS favourite’, it is remarkable that he only put out two ‘proper’ records in the entire time I was working for the site. Carrie &amp; Lowell is just a record that got very under my skin, I think possibly it is quite an underrated album, it’s such a strange record about sex and memory and mortality.</p><p><strong>9. R.E.M. — Carnival of Sorts (Box Cars) (live from Nottingham Rock City). </strong>R.E.M. are my favourite band of all time by a very long margin, and DiS has been a bit of a platform to indulge that — they only released a single album while I was writing for the site: Collapse Into Now, which I fondly gave a 6/10 to. But reviewing the reissues of their first eight albums has been a true indulgence and in a sense my only regret if I never write about music again would be if I didn’t get to at least write about the remainder of the band’s ’90s output. Anyway, Live at the BBC is a completely separate thing to any of that but I remember it fondly as the last DiS <a href="http://drownedinsound.com/releases/20465/reviews/4152091">review</a> where the music was an all-consuming thing for me (the record is six hours long and I listened to it repeatedly for weeks). I think the Glastonbury 1999 performance is amazing but it’s the 1984 Nottingham disc that’s completely exceptional. They sound wild and other, an entity from outside time. It is extraordinary.</p><p><strong>10. Sharon van Etten — Serpents. </strong>Another ‘DiS fave’; and this is my favourite song. My reasons for including her are a bit weirder than that, though — she once emailed me back when she was working for Badabing Records in New York chasing up some review of something or other and we had a little email conversation and she was genuinely taken aback that I’d heard of her and hilariously I’m one of a relatively limited number of people she follows on Twitter, which suggests she almost certainly doesn’t really use it.</p><p><strong>11. Dirty Projectors — Stillness is the Move.</strong> I remember a couple of my reviews going down really well; one was of <a href="http://drownedinsound.com/releases/18239/reviews/4147768">Coldplay’s Ghost Stories</a>, and album I don’t especially like; the other was the <a href="http://drownedinsound.com/releases/14438/reviews/4137038-dirty-projectors-bitte-orca">Dirty Projectors’ Bitte Orca</a>, which I intensely admired but struggled with in some ways. There’s only so far I’m realistically prepared to analyse my own writing, but I think I am quite good at conveying ambivalence interestingly, which I think I did here. I used to be a casual web acquaintance of the music journalist Laura Snapes, who went on to much bigger things than me and it always pleased me that she liked the review (or did back in the day).</p><p><strong>12. William Basinski — For David Robert Jones.</strong> This is an incredible piece of music that I only discovered because of a really lovely <a href="http://drownedinsound.com/releases/19791/reviews/4150744">review</a> a writer did of it for DiS. It is a sort of weird, vaporised tribute to Bowie and to his Berlin period. It sounds like a fog covering everything. I could live in it. Maybe I could drown in its, ah, sound. Maybe.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=41a51785920f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[DiS is the end…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MrLukowski/dis-is-the-end-9ddaf8dbea70?source=rss-edb7297c7a65------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9ddaf8dbea70</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrzej Lukowski]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Apr 2019 21:05:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-25T07:18:30.972Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/604/1*skSQWezFnx1t3tfBKM3qMw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The retrospectively hilarious thing about my time as albums editor of Drowned in Sound is that when it started I felt like I was coming in to help out as it wound down. Maybe I was. But the ‘glory days’ — which I essentially missed — actually only really lasted a few years, while the wind down lasted over a decade. That’s good going.</p><p>DiS had evolved from a music blog called The Last Resort that Sean Adams had founded in the late ’90s. It had grown massively during the great indie boom of the ’00s, which had culminated (as I understand it) in a deal with BSkyB to basically be its music site, but (as I understand etc) in the summer of 2008 BSkyB got cold feet and took up an option to back out, which pulled almost of DiS’s funding. An office of people was made redundant and there wouldn’t be another office. But this wasn’t entirely apparent to outsiders, and the digital infrastructure and reach of the site remained fairly massive, not least because of the popular forums.</p><p>In the summer of 2008 I was living in Bristol, in my fourth year at Metro and had resolved that I would soon ‘go freelance’. I wanted to do some longer form writing and had got in touch with DiS. I remember very little about the limited about of time I wrote for it before the BSkyB ‘incident’, or the period immediately after, but by the time I’d left Metro and gone backpacking at the start of 2009 I appear to have inveigled my way into what was left of the DiS ranks; sometime around my return and move to London in April (let’s call it ten years ago precisely) I was offered a sort-of-job: two day’s work a week as albums editor. I think I’d vaguely hoped there might be enough money for me to have an ‘actual’ job. But if I’d been given one it I suppose it would have paid an absolute pittance and I’d have just quit when I was hired by Time Out at the end of 2009 and that would have been that.</p><p>Instead I lurked around for a decade. At the beginning I poured a completely insane amount of time and effort into it, completely out of whack with what I was being paid, not because Sean was expecting me to, but because I didn’t have much better to do with my time and given I had DiS’s clout at my disposal it was just infinitely more fun to indulge that than trying to hustle up more freelance. I’d moved to London able to go to pretty much any festival or gig I wanted. I went on the Camden Crawl when it was popular and sat in some VIP room where I immediately saw Noel Fielding, which was very exciting in 2009. I went to a festival in Iceland, where I caught a fish, saw the northern lights, and our guide literally phoned the airport and had our international flight held for us after we came off the road on the drive back. I missed my flight to a festival in France, and they sorted it out. I went to Glastonbury. I went to Poland. I went to Holland. I went to ATP pretty much any weekend I wasn’t at another festival. I didn’t have any actual money but <em>aside from that small point</em> DiS was pretty much my dream job for a while, and certainly helped me get most of my rock journalist fantasies out of the way. It was amazing.</p><p>By the end I had far far far less time to commit, so I suppose in a weird way I had given myself a pay rise by incrementally ramping down the amount of actual work I was doing. But I think throughout I brought essentially the same thing to the table: I was organised enough to maintain a group of writers and get a steady stream of content out of them that kept the site fairly dynamic. I think DiS would probably have been just fine without me, but I’m proud that I recruited a lot of the new blood that sustained it over the years and proud that so many of those people went on to be ‘proper’ music journalists, and I’m proud of most of the ones who didn’t.</p><p>I slightly struggle to remember exactly what happened when and with whom, but I suppose for me the peak DiS era was maybe 2012-ish… Loosely when Cate, Luke and Gary were doing features, news and photos, Wendy doing singles, and Sean had much more time for the site. The rest of us were good at writing and logistics, but Sean was the ideas person, really — aside from being a really good writer, his <em>instincts</em> as a music journalist were superb. I’m sure he had some bad ideas, but I can’t remember them. I really loved the band takeover weeks we did — Grizzly Bear was a particular favourite, you should check it out — and when they stopped coming then I suppose that’s when you get the feeling DiS was running out of steam a bit. It was sort of ridiculous that a small group of very unfulltime people who barely ever saw each other should be able to run a successful music website in a way approximately equivalent to what it had been when it had a number of actual employees. But we pretty much did.</p><p>What changed? Quite a lot, slowly. Prosaically the big problem is that Facebook and Google have ruined web advertising for everyone. But I think you would struggle to look at the site in early 2019 and the site in, say, 2011 and conclude that there hadn’t been a decline in volume of articles published and site personality. We did some great stuff to commemorative the awful passing of our writer Dan Lucas in 2017… that’s about the last time I remember the site getting collectively stuck into something.</p><p>Most of the reason for that is that people drifted away, or were unable to put the same amount of time into it. I went part time at Time Out, then full time, then became a parent, twice. Sean became a band manager, then worked for 6Music. One member of staff became a successful musician. We stopped having a photos editor for reasons that I never fully understood (Gary left, somebody was lined up to replace him, but he wasn’t given a staff email..?). Several staff left and weren’t replaced, sometimes because of money. In the end it was just me and Derek Robertson doing features, and for the most part we kept it ticking over, but didn’t really have the time to give it a sense of direction. We didn’t necessarily feel we had the authority, either. Sean was generally the opposite of dictatorial (he’d sometimes express his displeasure if you slagged off somebody he liked) but I don’t think either me or Derek felt like we should simply be moulding DiS into a reflection of our own tastes, so it became ‘a bit of everything’, there was no real editorial policy.</p><p>I guess also for contributors and potential contributors, unpaid writing about indie music was becoming less appealing. Guitar-based indie was very popular at the end of the ’00s and much less popular just a few years later. And in 2009, there was still a sense that music was worth something: Spotify only launched in October 2008. When I started at DiS you were effectively being paid the price of a CD plus exclusive access to music. By 2019 you were not. And a couple of things unfortunately happened to strain relations with the writers: a fallout over their lack of input into the 2017 albums of the year list, and the publication of a very inappropriate review (my fault) a few months later. People still wanted to write, but it was less appealing, I think.</p><p>This isn’t a moan — I’m just trying to rationalise the end of something that was a part of my life for over a decade.</p><p>I actually don’t think it’s really the end for DiS: the open not-even-a-secret is that the forums account for much of the traffic; the divergence between them and the editorial content has been apparent for years, something underscored when they literally went on to different platforms. They will continue and I believe there is a plan to do some editorial via the medium of Medium (which I suppose I’ve used here not because I expect DiS to use it but because Sean’s impressed me that it’s a better platform that my dilapidated old Blogspot). I’m not sure I see how it’ll really regain a genuine sense of momentum unless Sean — or somebody he hands over to — can make the time to plan and execute some sort of (*voms*) <em>content strategy</em>. Even so, the idea that DiS has ‘ended’ is at the very least a bit complicated. There is a site and there is a lively social media presence (run by Sean) and I can imagine that he’s reasonably happy with this state of affairs — DiS is ‘his’ again, and is inherently aligned with his tastes (the fact it often wasn’t in its later years was clearly a bit of a headache for him).</p><p>I am, it should be clear, absolutely fine – I have a job writing about theatre. I would like to keep writing about music in some way, though I’m not sure exactly how I’ll do that. Maybe… pitch? Somewhat self-parodically, my main goal for now is to write something for someone on the twenty-fifth anniversary reissue of R.E.M.’s Monster, which is due in October. That’s it for now. DiS was a good thing and ten years after the golden age is pretty impressive. I think it is quite possible that in some form or other there may be ten more. But probably not with me.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9ddaf8dbea70" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>