<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Mr. Alias Moniker - Musings of a Young Old Man on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Mr. Alias Moniker - Musings of a Young Old Man on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 00:42:12 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Inner World Of Agents: The ‘Deep OODA Loop’ Model]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/neo-cybernetics/the-inner-world-of-agents-the-deep-ooda-loop-model-c949e7eb5afa?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c949e7eb5afa</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[agency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[subjectivity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ooda-loop]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mr. Alias Moniker - Musings of a Young Old Man]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 22 Sep 2024 12:14:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-22T12:14:37.871Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Getting Beyond the Black Box of Subjectivity</h4><p>The next big hill I have been climbing has been about the process of Learning. Of course, this ties together with my explorations of AI, consciousness, and the Ego Model I have been working on.</p><p>But I wanted a more nuanced tool to examine the process an agent is undergoing as they confront complexity in the universe. I ended up finding this model called the OODA Loop very helpful and insightful to that end.</p><p>The OODA Loop was a model originally developed by a military pilot named John Boyd but since its conception, it has found its way into many other applications as well. If you want a pure rendition of his work, great summaries exist all over Youtube which I found helpful for dipping the toe in.</p><p>However, this essay will be pushing this model into my world of Complexity, Cybernetics, &amp; Information and showing some critical observations that I don’t think I’ve heard anyone talk about in regards to our inner processes. Let’s just jump right into it.</p><h4>The Inner World of Agents</h4><p>Consider the process of getting an Agent to achieve a goal. We know already that the basic feedback mechanism to achieve this consists of Actions out of the agent (into the environment) and Perceived States into the agent (from that environment). Perception and Output.</p><p>But when we have an Agent that is doing something, the agent is doing something to achieve a Goal. And a Goal, at least to the agent, is really a particular State sustained for an indefinite amount of time. Homeostasis.</p><p>Your body keeps a particular temperature State, for example. If you get too cold, you start to shiver. If you get too hot, you start to sweat. Likewise, your body keeps a certain energy intake State. If you’re too low on energy, you feel hunger. If you’re too high on energy, you store it as fat.</p><p>With goals where success requires more investment, like to build some non-existent structure, this same homeostatic process is being applied to collect materials, organize the parts, and build the structure up.</p><p>How can we deduce this?</p><p>Because <strong>the end State, the goal, is always a small set of States in comparison to all the Possible States that could exist.</strong> <em>If one has the goal to build a tree house, there are only a certain amount of States of the environment that an Agent can consider a Successful tree house build</em>. And because of this, one can tell if they are getting ‘closer’ or farther from that goal. One can sense or deduce that they have gathered too much wood or not enough, for example.</p><p><strong>Goal achievement and reaching homeostasis, is thus a kind of “collapse” into the intended End State or States</strong>. One can visualize a sea of possible configurations of reality and in the center, there is only one or a small bubble of states that are the intended State Space for success.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tLdw1WtFIlWfFVcK1DK_NQ@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>But this model is taking a 3rd person view of the process of Goal achievement — looking at all the possible states and looking objectively at the Agent. For a sufficiently complex agent (ie. one which can ‘experience’), who is forced to take specific singular actions and decisions in time, it does not experience its journey as an “Area” of states but a Line. There is the ‘present moment’ State it sees in front of its sensors , there is the Singular best Action it could come up with to achieve the end, then there is the State after the Actions has been done.</p><p>There is a kind of split here for the Agent. While it may be able to fathom a spread of possible actions it can take to reach its goal (suggesting some ‘mental’ or ‘inner’ awareness of an Area of States), at the end of the day, it still must linearly pick and respond to the feed it is given.</p><p>As such not only is this a linear process but a hazy, blind, fuzzy Linear process, where the Agent can’t necessarily see the State that will emerge out from the aether and into the Present Moment, until it gets there. And yet, it must reach its Goal in this noise.</p><p>What this means is that a sufficiently complex Agent, tasked with a sufficiently complex Goal, is engaged in a Process of:</p><ol><li><strong>constant Hypothesis and Prediction</strong>, but also</li><li><strong>Collapsing these predictions into Singular committed actions</strong>.</li></ol><p>So our Agent, tasked with its directive to “achieve homeostasis”, given its input of sensory data (States from the environment), and given means of output (action), has within it a great challenge and confusion.</p><p>It must take these Sensory inputs and somehow bring forth the Area of Possible States that surround it (an array of Predictions). And then once it does this, it needs to deduce which of these States is the most advantageous to itself and commit completely to bringing it about in action.</p><p>“Achieve Homeostasis” did not ever capture the complexity of this inner task.</p><p><strong><em>If it did not generate predictions, then we cannot say that the Agent is truly ‘choosing’ a particular outcome. It is nothing more than code following a set of steps.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>And yet, if it did not pick a particular action, it would be paralyzed with choices and unable to take any steps. Nothing more than a spreadsheet.</em></strong></p><p>We tend to hesitate on examining the Black Box of the inner world of agents because of the inherent untestability. However, without even an attempt at what these inner states could be, we miss out on crucial components of the entire process of agency itself.</p><p>But there is a way of analyzing these hidden inner steps, as well as gain a deeper insight into the meaning of Perception and Action in relation to the Agent…</p><h4>OODA Loops</h4><p>The OODA stands for:</p><ol><li>Observe</li><li>Orient</li><li>Decide</li><li>Act</li></ol><p>For our purposes (and as a spoiler for this entire section), the OODA Loop is really the essence of the <strong>Agency Process</strong>, in my view — the process by which any agent moves through an uncertain and chaotic environment towards a particular goal state.</p><p>For example, consider an army. You have a recon group that examines the lay of the land and the enemy position. This info goes to central command which orients the information by contextualizing what it means at a macro scale for the army, the weaknesses and vulnerabilities of the enemy, etc. Once the entire ‘situation’ has been seen, they must contend with the options they have available to them and decide which should be done. Then when that decision is made, the chain of command works its magic to execute the order throughout the army.</p><p>Pretty obvious process there. But there are critical components of the process of agency embedded in that cycle.</p><p>To get a clearer vision of this, we should examine each of these steps in depth. But before we do, I wish to note a 5th step (implied in the word ‘Loop’).</p><p>5. Repeat until Observe = Win/Lose (Success/Failure)</p><p>That means, that when the army launches an attack, new observations are taken which can be used to repeat the process. And this loop would repeat until the war is won or lost.</p><p>Now, as I was studying the OODA Loop, I fount this point fascinating because it connected instantly to a critical point in my “On Ego” essay:</p><p><em>Agency only emerges in a state where Goals are Uncertain. Certain Failure OR Certain Success will not produce any agency unless the Ego can replace the Goal with a new Goal.</em></p><p>It is because of this phenomena that we see self aware Ego entities begin to Explode into sporadic behavior or Implode into inaction/meaninglessness as they approach Certain Success or Failure of their Goal. Here is the essay below if you wish to look further into it:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/neo-cybernetics/on-ego-a-fledgling-theory-on-everything-b60c3efe4f04">On Ego: A Fledgling Theory on Everything</a></p><p>The repetition being hinged on success or failure told me that this model and process overlaps perfectly with the Agency ‘Pole’ of the Ego Structure. But I digress. We will return to this repetition thing later.</p><h3>Part 1: What Does It Mean to ‘See’?</h3><p>To answer this question, we will be engaging with the first two steps of the OODA Loop, Observe and Orient. However, to start we will actually begin with the Orient step first.</p><p>To Orient means to <em>‘find one’s bearings’ or establish one’s location</em>. The word here delineates some association with a <strong>Map</strong>. And that’s because this is exactly what Orienting one’s self is. <strong>Putting one’s self in Context. Placing one’s self and one’s experience in a Map.</strong></p><p>And a Map is nothing more than a Model. A world view. One question we may ask ourselves is “why this would be a step that matters at all? Doesn’t reality itself already give us the ‘map’ we need to operate?”</p><p>Not quite. One would think that our perception is an objective intake of reality by the fact that reality is present, enduring, and self validating. However, our perception is a bias rendition of what reality really is. <em>Does reality have colors and qualia?</em> Well, not really. Red, Blue, and Green is ‘Our’ thing, not reality’s thing.</p><p>All the info that we perceive is constrained by this very distinction, even if we are seeing a “reality correlate,” so to speak. Because of this, we can consider reality — our environment — as a sea of complexity — uncertainty.<strong><em> Our perception is the result of scooping up this uncertain chaos soup and essentially ‘syncing up’ our own labels, symbols, signals, and qualia with this chaos</em></strong>.</p><p>An <strong><em>Imitation</em></strong></p><p>The reason why models matter, then, is because this ‘synced up’ signal is:</p><ol><li>Not reality (hence we can’t be completely certain of its accuracy)</li><li>Still very chaotic &amp; fleeting information</li></ol><p>Take a baby, for example. When you hide your face behind your hand, the baby believes that you have genuinely disappeared. It’s perception tells it that your face signals are no longer present and hence, you have gone. But when it develops ‘<strong>object permanence,’ what it is really developing is a MODEL</strong>. A map <strong>allows the baby to assume the presence of an object even if their senses say that the object is not present</strong>.</p><p>And very critically this Model is a lot like the first instance of <strong>Memory — <em>the capacity to remember and recognize a particular pattern and signal as a Feature rather than just chaos</em></strong>.</p><p>Imagine looking at the world and being unable to discern that a plate is a plate or a bag is a bag or that either of these are any different from the air in the background. All particular objects would just come across as a messy sea of signals.</p><p>This is what perception without a model looks like.</p><p>This is important to reiterate. <strong>Despite the fact that our Perception has fundamentally reduced the uncertain complex noise of reality into signals for us to perceive with distinctions, even this far less complex sea of messy signals is just Noise and chaos once again, at a higher level of cognizance</strong>. John Boyd said it best:</p><blockquote>“Progress is just Confusion at a Higher Level” — John Boyd <a href="https://youtu.be/Rbb48uUOkqQ?si=Nr8Jzb8V-0sZIrnc">link</a></blockquote><p><em>The process the agent is undertaking is fundamentally a process of continuously squeezing out this complexity over and over until certainty is the only thing left. But every layer of certainty is just complexity at a higher level.</em></p><p>You can thus think of the capacity to perceive an object as an enduring ‘thing’ and the capacity to assume things about its behaviors, all as another ‘layer of perception’ on top of the first ‘raw’ perception we get of everything.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Nnum3GOWDJKf4n3r4fG1tQ@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>This is what Models do. <strong>Just like how the first raw perception is ‘syncing up’ with the chaos of reality, our models are syncing up with the chaos of our raw perception. It is a Mirroring Process over and over into greater clarity &amp; certainty.</strong></p><p>So we just used the essence of what the Orient Phase is, really, to show how perception is far more complicated than just what it seems to be. With all this firmly established, we can go into the Observe Phase with the proper eye to the process we are truly engaging in. We will return to the Orient Phase after making clear what Observation truly is in light of this.</p><h4>The Observe Phase</h4><p>In some sense, this phase is feeding all the informational ‘food’ that the other phases will be digesting.</p><p>When we talk about the Observe Phase of the OODA Loop, we could be just talking about the pure perception at the base of all perception. However, as can be deduced from the previous section, for agents with a higher complexity, these base-level perceptions tend to mix part and parcel with higher order perceptions as well, like seeing and knowing an object.</p><p>In other words, a smart enough agent would very quickly link a pure perception to its object correlates of what that object is, as well as many other datapoints of info. And given that we are such an agent, it is hard to discern between Observe and other Phases in the Loop.</p><p>So instead of a direct definition, we want to get the broad sweeping generalizations that captures the totality of what we ‘see’.</p><p>In the Observe Phase, we are collecting information.</p><p>What kinds of information do we collect without Orienting, Deciding, or Acting?</p><p>There are 2 basic types:</p><ol><li>The State of the Environment. This is a snapshot of the current sensed states of reality.</li><li>The State of the Self. This is a snapshot of the current sensed states of the self.</li></ol><p>But the State of the Environment and the Self are really both just <strong>capturing the Present Moment of a being, the Current State</strong>. Since Observing is at the very ‘front’ of this complexity process, there is this <em>visceral realness </em>to experience, noticeable when you truly consider what ‘pre-perception’ would feel like, in contrast.</p><p><em>Imagine what it felt like before you were born.</em></p><p>You will find it impossible to do so (unless you have a very interesting story you should be sharing in the comments) because what does ‘non-being’ feel like? What do you sense in non-existence? It is a paradoxical request.</p><p><strong><em>Nothingness is Contradictory to Perception because to ‘Perceive’ is also to ‘perceive Something’;</em></strong> To Mirror some real thing ‘out there’. Even our closest rendition of Nothing is a perceived something, maybe an infinite blackness or whiteness that is yet still black or white — a something. ‘<strong><em>Nothing’ is a non-sensation that we have never felt before</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p>I say this to say, we do not know what pre-perception is because Perception (and hence the Observing Process) is a fundamentally <strong>Grounding/Anchoring experience</strong>. <strong>It is and always will be very intense in comparison with anything we could consider ‘nothing’</strong>. So intense that even the most ‘nothing-like’ thing we can imagine is far more viscerally Factual and “Something-like” than True Nothingness.</p><p>While the chaos of reality is not nothing, without Observation it genuinely would be, <strong>for our subjectivity</strong>. <em>Uncertainty and the Unknown is a lot like that Nothingness</em>. The saying “You don’t know what you don’t know” is apt here because we perceive to counteract this very issue. <em>Gathering facts, any facts, not only gives us things to know but also gives us something for which we can contrast against Nothingness</em>.</p><p>When perception isn’t on, like in sleep, we don’t just lose our senses but core things like Time and Space itself, instantly teleporting into the next day like being born into the visceral world once again (absent of any dreams or Visions).</p><p><strong><em>Our consciousness skips over True Nothingness. But it is that State which the Observation Phase is pulling us out of, in favor of the Current State;</em></strong></p><p><strong>From that Void of Unknowability into the Sea of Known Things.</strong></p><h4>Return to Orient</h4><p>With that True Nothingness broken out of to have ‘Something’, we are then tasked with turning this sea of knowns into a map or model of knowns. In this task we have 2 key components:</p><ol><li>Features — enduring Patterns in reality. Objects and Things.</li><li>Importance — the sense of significance assigned to these Features.</li></ol><p>Features and Importance make up the entirety of what a Map is.</p><p>Features are pretty obvious in meaning. They are a clear continuation of this Complexity (Uncertainty) Reduction process that we started in Observation. Enduring ‘things’ are very obviously what models are made of.</p><p>However, Importance is very strange in their relationship to a model.</p><p>Where does Importance or significance come from? It, like color, is not part of the chaos soup. But it also is not part of the Facts of raw Perception.</p><p>Well, importance is equivalent to ‘Weights’ in Neural Networks. Importance and Weights are both intimately tied with <strong>Relevance.</strong></p><p>But Relevance to what?</p><p><em>We determine the importance — the relevance — of things in our Map based on </em><strong><em>the Goal that we have</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p>The Goal we have is what makes the variables that we see relevant or irrelevant to us. Even in a literal map, the roads that have ‘weight’ will be the ones that pertain to your objective of going from point A to point B. The other roads have less weight unless they serve as alternative routes to point B.</p><p>We have actually stumbled on something very important.</p><p>At no point in the OODA Loop is there a “Decide the Goal” step. It is implied that the Goal is already present. As such,<strong> relevance is NEW content</strong> emerging as a result of:</p><p>A. comparing one’s current state with one’s Goal State and</p><p>B. seeing how relevant the Features in the Model are to unifying with that Goal State</p><p><strong>This New content is actually producing MORE Complexity. So we see that the Building Up of an inner Model that we do in the Orient Phase is a <em>Complexity Generating Process</em>. We are imbuing each Feature with a <em>Prediction</em> of the relevance it has to our Goal.</strong></p><p>But since this complexity is not coming from the perception of reality, nor are there new Features we are discerning out of this Reality, this is like an entirely separate aspect of reality that is almost entirely attached to goals alone.</p><p>There are thus, <strong>two different types of Models being Produced in this Orient Phase:</strong></p><ol><li><strong>The Objective Model</strong> of the world. <em>The persistently True Variables and Properties and causal dynamics of </em><strong><em>Features</em></strong></li><li><strong>The Goal-Oriented Model</strong> of the world. <em>The weights, importance, and relevances that emerge in the relationship Features have with a Goal</em></li></ol><p>These are both predictions but of entirely different domains. It is actually the union of these two Models that allows the creation of the “Area of States” that we mentioned at the beginning of this essay. It is a spread of the Possible ‘worlds’ that could be created based on the objective model and their relationship to the desired outcome.</p><p>Without the Goal-Oriented Model, the production of an Area of States would be so granular in the possible things to be generate, that the Area of States would be infinite in scope. One would be able to predict countless variations in reality and there would be <em>no way of deducing which predictions matter more than others</em></p><ol><li><strong>The Goal-Oriented Model confines ALL possibilities down to RELEVANT possibilities</strong>.</li></ol><p>Because of this, the agent, without a Goal, would either <strong>produce all possibilities</strong> or <strong>none</strong> during this phase. And of the two, it would be pointless to even consider any of the possibilities outside of the present moment because they would have <strong>no relevance</strong>. Absent of an objective, there is no reason to spend such energy.</p><p><strong>2. The Goal-Oriented Model is thus also giving the cause to spend the cost/energy to perceive more predictions in the first place</strong>.</p><p>The Objective Model is the one that is bringing in the expectations of the Features — the objects in the environment. It models the ways these objects tend to interact with space and time. These are the enduring Certainties of the Model. We can see now that these certainties are being expanded out wildly into whole new set of predictions and relationships producing uncertainty.</p><p>It makes sense that the Orient Phase would actually generate a ton of uncertainty because <strong><em>we are building an entire Model of reality within ourselves to mirror Reality itself</em></strong>. <em>We are drawing up a new ‘Inner World’ to be a </em><strong><em>hypothesis</em></strong><em> of the real world</em>.</p><p>Part of the reason why these weights are calculable or perceivable is because this Inner Model is Self Generated. One can make guesses about relevance to an end goal because they are the creators of the entire world itself. Even if the guess is inaccurate or unclear, the <em>capacity</em> to guess is possible due to the fact that <strong>the Inner Model is always ‘Closed’ — not ‘missing’ anything — to the subject</strong>. There is an implied and assumed <em>Completeness</em>. <strong><em>The Goal acts on the many pathways like a period acts on a sentence, resolving the ‘validity’ to all the weights</em></strong><em>, at least until the model is further corrected.</em></p><p>By the end, you have a full contextualize view of self and environment in relation to a goal, as well as the Current State, the Present moment.</p><h4>A Not-So-Brief Tangent with Important Insights</h4><p>There are some interesting observations that come from this.</p><p>If the Orient Phase is a Complexity Generating Process and the Observe Phase is Anchoring, then the importance of the Observe Phase for the Orient Phase actually makes sense. <strong>Without the Observe Phase, this Model Building would be <em>Total Hallucination</em></strong>.</p><p>There would be no Certainties to anchor this Production of Possibilities to something stable. <strong>We can think of this Orient Phase as a Process of Hallucinating a prediction of reality.</strong></p><p><strong>We hallucinate the pot we leave out of sight on the stove. We hallucinate the corner of the room we can’t see. We hallucinate our sense of selfhood. We hallucinate what others are thinking and feeling. We hallucinate history, and countries, and geopolitics. We hallucinate our relationships with others. We hallucinate all stories and narratives we get caught up in.</strong></p><p><strong><em>We hallucinate our entire world view.</em></strong></p><p>It is just that the hallucinations are made valid by successful predictions of what reality is really doing, thanks to the anchor of perception.</p><p>It is very possible that this is where <strong>Dreams</strong> come from. It is the effect of complete detachment from the Observe Phase info and anchoring.</p><p>This is also likely what <strong>Imagination</strong> is and why it has an almost infinite potential to create whatever we wish to create at a moments notice.</p><p>What this could mean about the contents of dreams, imagination, or other such phenomena, I do not know, but some potential connections may emerge in the latter section on emotion (though I will not expand on these explicitly, in this essay).</p><p>However, the point is that at peak ‘Expansiveness’ of complexity in the Orient Phase, one can generate anything one wishes, if they can successfully detach from the powerful Anchoring effect of the Observing Process.</p><p>Another critical insight is yielded when we think back to the Goal-Oriented Model. <strong>Its foundation for where it places importance is based entirely on the Goal an agent has — </strong>the state it is trying to sustain homeostasis over.</p><p>However, this would also mean that a <strong><em>Different goal would have an entirely different Goal-Oriented Model.</em></strong></p><p>It is thus possible that the Goal-Oriented Model can have not one, but potentially countless different objectives overlayed at once all factoring into the overall weights at play, in the ‘final product’. For example, one may want to go from point A to both point B and point C, and the combination of these two goals creates two separate Goal-Oriented models that ‘phase’ together as one.</p><p>So if <strong>Different Goals will Produce entirely different models</strong>, one would think that the emergence of a new goal would create a dramatic distortion in reality in some major way. However, this is not entirely the case because the Objective Model does not shift or respond to varied goals.</p><p>So what then properly reflects this ‘shifting’ model within us without also changing our entire inner reality as we know it?</p><h4><strong><em>Emotion</em></strong></h4><p>Emotion is something that can shift our interpretation of an interaction with an object without actually changing the objective state of the model as we have it.</p><p>If emotions are indeed a human example of this Goal shifting potential, this implies that <strong><em>Different</em></strong> <strong><em>Emotions are actually tied to different Goals.</em></strong></p><p>One could imagine then that, <em>the fight or flight response is more like a manifestation of two separate terminal goals running at the same time</em>. As reality feeds information about the leverage and positioning of the agent in relation to a threat, <strong>the ‘opportunity’ to fight or the ‘opportunity’ to flight is shown in the snapshot of the moment</strong>. But the goal in a stressful situation is, in some sense, ‘both’ to fight and to flight. They both exist as “deep goals” that likely are ‘<strong><em>implied</em></strong>’ so often in different situations that we don’t notice it.</p><p>But humans hop between emotions all the time. How does one switch from one to another in this context?</p><p>My guess is that, <strong>all the Goals are ‘on’ all at once</strong>. It is <em>actually the environment that has imbedded in it, the relevance to different goals</em>. <strong>The opportunity to succeed in some goal presents itself from reality, not from us</strong>.</p><p>This means, complex agents are running with an assortment of goals <strong>waiting for the Environment to tell them that an opportunity has presented itself for the achieving of a goal</strong>. It is as if we simply have so many goals — even contradictory ones — running at once that there is <em>very rarely</em> <em>a time</em> <em>when the environment is</em> <em>completely devoid of weights, importance, and relevance</em>.</p><p>One sees that <strong>the environment is, from the Goal-Oriented Model’s point of view,</strong> <strong><em>a sea of Opportunities, rather than a sea of possibilities alone. </em></strong>It is actually the perception of the opportunity for the achievement of some goal that brings forward the relevance, importance, and weights in and of itself.</p><p><strong>In other words, someone with Arachnophobia sees an “<em>opportunity</em>” to flee from a spider upon its perception rather than just being afraid of the spider<em>. The fear emotions are the weights emerging to respond to the perception of a GOAL of “run from spiders”.</em></strong></p><p>When the opportunity is not present in the environment (or held in focus; we will return to this), then <em>the Goal and its requisite weights return to a kind of </em><strong><em>latent state</em></strong><em>, waiting for the opportunity to arise again</em>.</p><p>Finally, the <strong>anxiety</strong> about an encounter with a spider that <em>isn’t</em> present, would be a kind of pathological “seeking” for the opportunity to run from it.</p><p>This may explain many other pathological behaviors we see in humans and larger organizing systems, especially if properly connected to the Ego Theory. But for now, think of this more like a strong untested suspicion to be explored on another day.</p><p>Further exploration on this, I would think, could follow the lines of the work of Jaak Panksepp and Lucy Biven and their <strong>7 Primal Emotions theory</strong>. I shall write another essay on it and its connection when I get there.</p><p>Let us return back to our OODA Loop and complete the latter half.</p><h3>Part 2: Collapse and Selfhood</h3><p>In the first part, we managed to show how an agent achieves one of its objectives to create hypotheses and predictions that allow it the capacity to <em>choose</em> an outcome.</p><p>In this part, we will explore the nature of this choosing process; how the Agent manages to take this big sea of option, choices, and ‘grounded complexity’ and turn it into momentum for a particular direction.</p><h4>The Decide Phase</h4><p>By the end of the Orient Phase, we would have a fully expanded Inner Replica of the world we perceive in the Observe Phase. This Replica would not just consist of Features — objects with static properties — but also relevant weights of importance these objects would have in relation to a goal (or goals).</p><p>On top of that, in an environment with multiple features that could be useful to a goal, there would be multiple predictions of value imbedded or implied in the weights.</p><p>The Decide Phase is tasked with taking all these variables and compressing them down into one course of action. This, we can conclude, is a <strong><em>Complexity Reducing Process</em></strong>.</p><p>In the Observe Phase, I talked about the agent seeing both the State of the Environment and the State of the Self. However, this was a lie of sorts, for the sake of simplicity.</p><p>How does one determine “Self” from Environment?</p><p>Well, of the things to be perceived, there are things that we can consider as “Other”. The common denominator of these things is that they are separate from the ‘flow’ of our will. ‘Self stuff’ are things you can impose your Will through.</p><p>Your “Self” is thus defined by <strong>where your</strong> <strong>Action can emanate from</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Q1sdliGlrvvAV9eWlVwKBg@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>Through this definition, we can see that something like a tool would be an extension of the Self for the time you can use it to do Actions with. Your Will flows through it. When you put it back down, it returns to being a part of the environment.</p><p>If you are playing a game like chess, all the pieces that you have the capacity to <strong>exert your Will</strong> <strong><em>through</em></strong> are your ‘Self’ in that context. The other pieces, the spaces, or the pieces that you no longer have the capacity to move (captured pieces) are not ‘Self’.</p><p>This overlaps with the concept of Will &amp; Testimony, I discussed in the On Ego essay, but I will return to this later.</p><p>So we can see that the line between Self and Environment is drawn by <strong>where the Agent holds the means of outputting causality into the world</strong> <strong>and where it does not</strong>. But we can also see that this line is quite blurred even if it is clear in some instances.</p><p>Instead of thinking of this Self as a clearly and perfectly defined container, we can think of the <strong>Self as the Agent’s entire Action Matrix — the spread of all action available to the Agent</strong>. This is more of a spectrum or gradient of Action and can be applied in the present, past, and future depending on the lens.</p><p>It is this Action Matrix that the Decide Phase is compressing down to singular decisive operations. This compressing is what I call <strong>Focus</strong>.</p><p>Like the Observe Phase, this Focus can be ‘high resolution’ like moving an index finger or ‘low resolution’ like an overarching theme to ‘do more research’. But the essence is that <em>all available action is reduced to a specific ‘cone’ or ‘arrow’ of momentum contained by this Focus</em>.</p><p>There are 3 main variables that go into ‘Focusing’ this singular operation.</p><p>To start, consider a regular map (presumably produced in some orient phase) and a Goal to get from point A to point B as fast as possible.</p><p>A dead end road that has no pathway to B would have less weight (importance/relevance) given to it than a road that is going temporarily in the opposite direction. This is because the dead end road stops all concept of progress towards the objective B, while a road going the wrong way could still lead to B. And yet, if there was a road directly from A to B, that would clearly be the best choice and extremely relevant.</p><p>In a similar fashion:</p><ol><li><strong><em>all Actions have a spectrum of relevance to whatever goal an agent has</em></strong>,</li></ol><p><em>some of which would register as completely pointless — a dead end — while others appear completely &amp; obviously relevant</em>. Those super obvious, relevant actions can be so clear that the Decision is made instantly simply upon seeing it. But the point is that between these two weights is a spectrum one can assign to a course of action.</p><p>Let’s return to that same map and goal. It can be conceived that other means of transportation exist that achieve the objective way faster than by road. One could fly to point B and not need roads all together. One could teleport to point B using some secret technology. One could scoop point B out of the earth and place it right next to point A. But these options for actions are likely not implementable. They are not <em>possible</em> actions.</p><p>In spite of being able to conceive of these options,</p><p>2. <strong><em>an Agent naturally constrains their Action by the Actions actually Possible to the Agent, in analysis.</em></strong></p><p>“But”, you interject, “isn’t it technically possible to achieve any of these things? How would the agent know based on its model that something truly is ‘not possible’?”</p><p>Great question. The answer is <strong><em>Cost.</em></strong></p><p>There is a certain threshold for any conceived Action where <strong><em>the cost of doing the action is so high that agents naturally write off these possibilities as “impossible”</em></strong>.</p><p>One can say that <strong>“Impossible”</strong> is usually just shorthand for <strong>Too Expensive to Enact</strong>. And yes, <em>if the cost to Enact something is ‘</em><strong><em>infinity</em></strong><em>’ — meaning ‘no finite amount of effort would cause it to occur’ — then it could be said to be literally impossible</em>, but it is still measured by the same unit: <strong>Cost</strong>.</p><p>This might have something to do with the emotion ideal mentioned earlier. There is a Goal in the Agent to Self Preservation and any other goal that crosses the energy/cost threshold that threatens this would be rejected. But more reflection is required on the topic. We continue.</p><p>Okay, but what about possibilities that are within a range the agent <em>would</em> consider a Cost worth undertaking and that could be of great relevance?</p><p>Say for example, that on the way from point A to point B, one sees a possible dirt path that wasn’t on the map. It could be a dead end, it could be a shortcut route, or it could go completely the wrong way.</p><p>In this case, the agent is now wrestling with <strong>certainty and uncertainty</strong> embedded in its own model. <em>The quality of the Action, ‘take the dirt path’, is fractured into 3 different weights that are all within the realm of possibility.</em></p><p>In other words,</p><p><strong><em>3. Uncertainty causes Actions to ‘lose focus’ and fracture into multiple higher and lower value Actions</em></strong></p><p>This is the hardest form of action to compress down into focus, for many reasons, that are somewhat intuitive. This is often where reflection on past experiences, deduction, induction, and mental effort is required to squeeze out more certainty out of the information, if not an outright leap of faith based on the info available.</p><p>With these 3 variables of Focus, we can clean up the contents of Focus a little bit.</p><p>For starters, we already said that Actions unavailable to the agent can be considered as ‘not Self’. So “Impossible” actions — actions that cost too much — can also be put into this category. The agent writes off impossible actions as non-actions.</p><p>Thus, from the agent’s point of view, All of its perceived actions will be “Possible Actions”. These are synonyms, so to speak.</p><p>In addition, each Possible Action, will be relevant to the goal (or goals) the agent is trying to achieve. So the entire spread of Actions available to the agent in its eyes will consist of both ‘Possible-ness’ and Importance.</p><p>We can call these:</p><p><strong><em>Action-Importance Pairs</em></strong></p><p>Action, because impossible actions are non-actions to the agent.</p><p>These Action-Importance Pairs are the ‘unit’ that the Decide Phase is working with.</p><p><strong><em>Certainty </em></strong>is another variable that <strong><em>Splits</em></strong> these Action-Importance Pairs into multiple iterations of itself.</p><p>Importantly, we know that the Action-Importance pairs are real because <strong><em>these splits always happen along the lines of relevance</em></strong>.</p><p>There could be 30 different ways to fail at getting to an objective, but if all the failures cost you about the same amount of effort, then we usually bunch them up.</p><p>Confessing your feelings to a romantic interest could be ‘bad’ if they let you down gently. But no matter all the ways they could let you down gently, the confession itself on your part is the same cost and hence all gentle rejections are ‘bad’. However, if there is a chance that confessing those feelings results in them reacting very badly to your feelings that would be in an entirely different category — “very bad”.</p><p><strong><em>The probability we measure is not each particular outcome</em></strong>, say a 1.2% chance they say a particular form of rejection, <strong><em>but rather the sum of all outcomes of similar cost &amp; importance</em></strong> — the 30% chance of rejection that is ‘bad’ and the 10% that is ‘very bad’. Same of course with good outcomes.</p><p>So we know that the Actions are intuitively being linked to Importance because they move <em>with</em> the fractures of uncertainty.</p><p>Past this point, <em>the agent is juggling risk (uncertainty) with reward (importance) based on its own biases towards certainty, reward, and bias</em>. So we have our 2 ‘objects’ of Focus:</p><ol><li>Action-Importance Pairs</li><li>Certainty</li></ol><p>This ‘juggling into focus’ compresses the Uncertainty down to the best possible specific action the agent sees with the most certainty and reward. With a clear decision made, both models (Objective &amp; Goal-Oriented) are now sufficiently compressed into a focus to re-enter into reality in the form of action.</p><h4>The Role of Time as Resource</h4><p>It should be said briefly that <strong><em>Time is a kind of baseline cost to the agent</em></strong>. It is one of those core ‘currencies’ by which it assesses the cost of all other things. When an agent has more time to engage this focus process, then it can invest that time into further compression to make better guesses and predictions.</p><p>However, often, <strong>the constraint of Time is something that forces an decision to do the best action that can be seen, if the agent can’t come to a conclusion</strong>.</p><p>In a negotiation between two agents (or between an agent and reality), the one with more time almost always wins in the negotiation. They can say ‘no’ for longer and eventually force the agent with less time to Decide on terms more suitable. There are many more negotiation, power, and interaction principles latent in specifically this Decide phase because this is the point of power for all agents. However, I will save such explorations for a separate essay.</p><p>I just briefly say here that Time eventually will always force a choice if the agent is hyper-fixated on the Focusing Process of the Decide Phase.</p><h4>The Act Phase</h4><p>This final phase is somewhat self explanatory. The agent follows through on the Decision it has made in execution. However, there are some ‘loose ends’ to tie here about the Loop as a whole.</p><p>For starters, like the Orient Phase, you can say that there is a <em>visceral realness</em> to acting in the world.</p><p>One is very aware of their selfhood being projected out of the mental model and into the world.</p><p>However, unlike the Orient Phase, action is a <strong><em>Complexity Generating Process.</em></strong></p><p>I never explicitly said that Orient Phase was a Complexity Reducing Process, but now that we are at the end of the loop we will make sense of both of these claims.</p><p>I have a draft of this essay,</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/the-complexity-is-everything-and-more-3df4a5237bea">The Complexity is Everything and More</a></p><p>that was twice as long as the one posted. The reason why I cut it down was because I was struggling with a seeming paradox between subjectivity and complexity. Because of this OODA Loop essay, that paradox has been resolved.</p><p>The process of acting in the world causes change, complexity, in the world. If you are a bear, simply walking, breathing, and doing bear things, in the woods will leave behind complexity in the form of footprints, fur, dung, and the like.</p><p>Technically, all of the Testimony of the Bear’s existence is leaving behind noise and hence complexity for anything else in the environment. <strong>There is always going to be rippling evidence of our existence in every act.</strong></p><p>However, the problem I was encountering was that while this complexity generation is clearly no different from the ‘complexity soup’ we mentioned earlier, <em>another bear in the woods would see this testimony as Information!</em> These residual effects tell the rival bear that someone is in its territory, for example.</p><p>How could something that is producing complexity also reduce complexity? Is an action producing Information or is it producing Chaos?</p><p>The answer is that <strong>it depends on which end of this agency process we are looking at: Observe or Act?</strong></p><p>When we consider an agent acting out in the world, what it is really doing is causing change, chaos. It is akin to throwing a pebble into an ocean and producing ripples of chaos.</p><p><strong>This churning of reality by agents is then ‘<em>re-perceivable</em>’ to that agent or other agents as <em>information</em>, IF it is in their range of relevance.</strong></p><p>Like I said in the linked essay, an amoeba has no perception of weather. It is outside of its range of relevance. But we do, because it is relevant to us.</p><p>Now, if we perceive information, <strong><em>the very fact that it is ‘Something’ means that complexity has been reduced</em></strong>. Because the pure chaos that is ‘out there’ has become observable signals on our senses. <em>The Orient and Decide phases are the ‘Black Box’ of the Agent Subjectivity</em>. These phases turn this information into predictions &amp; decision that then create Actions that the agent takes.</p><p><em>But all Action is </em><strong><em>Complexity Generating</em></strong><em> for the very fact that it causes change. And all Perception is </em><strong><em>Complexity Reducing</em></strong><em> for the very fact that it absorbs change.</em></p><p>The inner process of the agent which happens in the Orient &amp; Decide Phases was the missing piece to understanding this. Because those <strong>two phases are the difference between <em>Uncertainty and Information</em>.</strong></p><p>Both,</p><ol><li>Hypothesis &amp; Prediction and</li><li>Collapse into intention</li></ol><p>is done in these phases and <em>they turn uncertainty into information relevant to an agent, because the uncertainty is producing both choices and decisions rather than more noise from that agent’s point of view.</em></p><p>As such, the Act phase can be seen as <strong><em>Testing a hypothesis</em></strong> produced by the previous phases. From the point of view, of the agent, it is the effects of these actions that will produce more uncertainty (which is really information for the agent) to create better hypotheses about reality.</p><h4>A Few Closing Impressions</h4><p>Now if you have been paying attention, you may have noticed an interesting pattern with this OODA Loop.</p><p>Observe -&gt; Complexity Reducing<br>Orient -&gt; Complexity Generating<br>Decide -&gt; Complexity Reducing<br>Act -&gt; Complexity Generating</p><p>A pulsating process, like breathing or a heartbeat. Compression and Expansion in a circular pattern again and again.</p><p>If nothing else, I find it pretty. But It could also be of great importance going forward into the future. I suspect, for example, that differences in personality might just be where we focus our own attention in this cycle.</p><p>For example, the difference between a person who is most ‘conscious’ about looking at the very beginning of the orient phase would see very raw (but still hallucinatory) data and would be fixated on the intuitive first impressions that they get from reality. Meanwhile, someone who feels conscious attention placed at the very end of the Orient phase would see the world has a very flexible and a potentially ‘timeless’ system that has archetypal consistency only. But both people would be intuitive, just in different ways.</p><p>For a future essay of course.</p><p>Returning to that hidden step 5 — Repeat until Success/Failure — placing all this together presents you with the last question for this essay:</p><p><em>What happens when a Goal certainly &amp; permanently succeeds or fails?</em></p><p><strong><em>Dead Weights</em></strong></p><p>That is my name for them (a double entendre I am proud of) but they capture exactly how I suspect these ‘objects’ to behave.</p><p>Since a goal is the anchor to all the other relevance and weights in the system, a successful or failed goal would obviously have rippling effects on all the weights and Action-Importance Pairs associated with it.</p><p>I suspect this to likely be some kind of <em>paradoxical state where the weights are present and pertain to the Goal but the “</em><strong><em>charge</em></strong><em>” is completely gone or Always present</em>. Kinda like having a signal or neuron that is in a constant state of firing with no refractory period.</p><p>Discernment in weight comes from having different weights depending on a different circumstance. That is how you can tell you are getting ‘hotter’ or ‘colder’ in your striving towards a goal. However, <strong><em>if you are in a state of unceasing success or failure, the signal is always on or always off no matter what you do</em></strong>.</p><p>The weights that pertain to that Goal just don’t light or are cooked; Overstimulated and hence become no different from noise. <strong>A permanent “On” or “Off” signal might as well be background Noise.</strong></p><p>The more goals get roped in, the more this “searing effect” tacts on to all the Features — objects — in the Model related to that goal. Hence, they literally become <strong>Dead Weights.</strong> Phantom weights that add significance or dim significance to things for a Goal that no longer matter.</p><p>In theory, the only way to resolve this would be then to <strong>detach from those goals entirely and replace them</strong>. Otherwise, the entire Goal-Orient Model becomes a wasteland of zombies weights that are so Loud that they actually BLOCK out other weights from giving signals to other goals.</p><p>I suspect that this might be why humans may have evolved for this goal imitation of each other I talked about in the On Ego essay. It is our attempt to quickly detach and replace our weights with those unattained and uncertain goals of those around us.</p><p>Of course, there will be a future essay on this as well. Likely connecting Jacques Lacan’s concepts of Jouissance to this Searing Effect and Dead Weights; Compulsive repeating actions against one’s own homeostatic loop.</p><h4>Closing</h4><p>Thank you very much for reading this far if you did. This was a very time consuming essay to write and research for but there were many great observations and insights that emerged from it. The nature of decision making, the inner process of and their feedback loop, how one transforms complexity into information and back again and more.</p><p>Even great speculative ventures like on Goals and their connection to emotion and the concept of Dead Weights as the cause for that Ego Explosion or Implosion that occurs when we have success or failure.</p><p>I look forward to writing more on the back of this work and to hear your thoughts in the comments.</p><p><em>Please be sure to clap and comment your thoughts, questions, or feedback! Everything helps a ton! If you wish to support my work financially, donate to </em><a href="https://ko-fi.com/nigelh"><em>my kofi page linked here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>Thanks Again!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c949e7eb5afa" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/neo-cybernetics/the-inner-world-of-agents-the-deep-ooda-loop-model-c949e7eb5afa">The Inner World Of Agents: The ‘Deep OODA Loop’ Model</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/neo-cybernetics">Neo-Cybernetics</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Plan vs Prediction Problem]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-snippet">When someone tells you something will happen and it does, did they give you their prediction or their plan?</p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/the-prediction-vs-plan-problem-the-greatest-deception-in-town-6470a95d70da?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2">Continue reading on Medium »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/the-prediction-vs-plan-problem-the-greatest-deception-in-town-6470a95d70da?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6470a95d70da</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[power]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[image]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mr. Alias Moniker - Musings of a Young Old Man]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Aug 2024 13:06:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-23T15:35:23.529Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Knowledge, Power, and the Abstracting of War]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-snippet">Knowledge and Power are very similar in how they are applied today. I would just draw one clear distinction.</p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/knowledge-power-and-the-abstracting-of-war-c0f912889339?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2">Continue reading on Medium »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/knowledge-power-and-the-abstracting-of-war-c0f912889339?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c0f912889339</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[power]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reflections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[knowledge]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mr. Alias Moniker - Musings of a Young Old Man]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Aug 2024 17:26:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-20T17:26:04.118Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Chicken Or The Egg: Paradoxes are the Source of Selfhood]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-image"><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/the-chicken-or-the-egg-paradoxes-are-the-source-of-selfhood-93f962b050ef?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2"><img src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/2600/0*-Yd0dFM9qpLaJWFk" width="6000"></a></p><p class="medium-feed-snippet">Which came first? The chicken or the Egg?</p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/the-chicken-or-the-egg-paradoxes-are-the-source-of-selfhood-93f962b050ef?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2">Continue reading on Medium »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/the-chicken-or-the-egg-paradoxes-are-the-source-of-selfhood-93f962b050ef?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/93f962b050ef</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[prose]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thoughts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mr. Alias Moniker - Musings of a Young Old Man]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 04 Jun 2024 07:47:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-04T07:47:40.140Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is Anxiety Really? The Core Emotion of Modernity]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-snippet">In short, Anxiety is a complexity problem. It is the feeling that there is TOO much potential for surprises that are out of your control&#x2026;</p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/what-is-anxiety-really-the-core-emotion-of-modernity-7d3dc4b4742a?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2">Continue reading on Medium »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/what-is-anxiety-really-the-core-emotion-of-modernity-7d3dc4b4742a?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7d3dc4b4742a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anxiety]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[modern-life]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mr. Alias Moniker - Musings of a Young Old Man]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 Mar 2024 12:02:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-27T12:02:30.068Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Most Men & Women Are Romantically Hopeless: The Role of Monoliths, the Issue of Complexity, and…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/most-men-women-are-romantically-hopeless-the-role-of-monoliths-the-issue-of-complexity-and-f449f47f6008?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f449f47f6008</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[men]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mr. Alias Moniker - Musings of a Young Old Man]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 05 Mar 2024 18:32:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-05T18:32:08.543Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2>Most Men &amp; Women Are Romantically Hopeless: The Role of Monoliths, the Issue of Complexity, and Empathy Destruction</h2><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NWLvDMZkCF6Dy2Y9emvtYA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo on Pexels by Quang Nguyen Vinh <a href="https://www.pexels.com/photo/asian-women-with-lanterns-against-men-in-boats-on-river-6710902/">link</a></figcaption></figure><p>At heart, I am a researcher. I study people’s world-views and try to engineer them back to their source so I could feel how they would genuinely feel and see how they genuinely see. I have explored the minds of all kinds of people, including those I vehemently distain and I do so from a place of curiosity. I have always been that way. And I always saw it as something constructive.</p><p>The first time that it ever crossed my mind that this could ever <em>not</em> be a good thing was in college. I was having a conversation with a white guy from the city and asking him questions from a project two friends were working on in class. I wanted to see how he saw the housing programs for minorities on campus. As I got him to open up and share, he talked about how he grew up and what school was like for him. I don’t recall most of what he said as it has been years ago but I recall drawing the connection for him that the way he saw the multi-cultural housing program was as something like a ‘disabled students’ housing. And he agreed that it was exactly like that. He didn’t have a problem with it existing or anything but he didn’t understand the need and was himself curious.</p><p>I could see where he was coming from. Implied in a self-imposed segregation is a need — one that the rest of the campus does not have, and yet must be supported and specialized based on race. The only piece of the puzzle he was missing was that the need was simply a basic sense of commonality, something that I imagine he would have related too. I had lived in that housing, not from a sense of being disabled but just because I figured I’d get along more with people from many different cultures than otherwise.</p><p>But I saw why he saw it the way he did because to him, particularly because he was a city kid, his race has never felt like something that brought him camaraderie with other white people. So in his mind, ‘maybe there was something particular about their racial experience as minorities on campus that he had that they didn’t, even if it didn’t feel that way’. Hence, a lot like someone disabled in a wheelchair has a very unique experience and challenges that others wouldn’t immediately recognize unless they were in their shoes. To me, it was an empathetic view.</p><p>But the two friends I was with were apparently ripping apart at the seams in silence. When he left, the two women, one black and the other white, turned to me and asked “How could you sit through that mess?!”</p><p>I was surprised, personally. I didn’t feel all that stressed. I explained to them that I just don’t really get frustrated with how people see things, I guess. I followed up saying that I feel like I have to understand the other point of view before I could be sure what to even be upset about. They kinda stared at me blankly for a moment and then ranted about the things he said and him, as a person.</p><p>I felt bad for the guy because it was my forthrightness in tone and genuinely open vibe that made him comfortable enough to speak without policing how he came off, but now these two friends were judging him really hard because they couldn’t see where he was coming from.</p><p>They were finding offense from their own point of view rather than trying to emotionally deduce his lack of offense from his point of view. And because I didn’t factor that in, I made this guy sound as though he was saying that being a minority was literally being disabled.</p><p>I was bridging the gap for people who were not ready to cross it.</p><h4>Monoliths and Monads</h4><p>I find myself in a similar situation when it comes to the tension between Men and Women. I have spent a lot of time breaking down the biases, assumptions, values, and needs that undergird the behaviors and perspectives of Men and Women in the world as well as my own infrastructures to see how we really see it.</p><p>Now, when I say ‘Men’ and ‘Women’, not only am I NOT talking about All men or all women, but I literally can’t be talking about all men or all women because, obviously, I haven’t see or talked to all men or all women. If you are reading this, I likely haven’t talked to you with sufficient depth, so whatever I could say about ALL Men or Women would, at the very least, be based on incomplete information.</p><p>So what am I talking about? In fact, what is anyone talking about when they say “Men are xyz” or “Women are xyz”?</p><p>Well, it is my understanding that when anyone talks about “Men” or “Women” they are referring to <strong>the Monolith in their head</strong>. One could almost always substitute “Men” and “Women” with “<em>My net information on Men/Women.</em>” For many people, this would include the information gathered from their own anecdotes, from studies they have clearly not personally done or checked themselves, and most importantly <strong><em>the story they have weaved together using all of these disparate data points.</em></strong></p><p>Why Story? Well, because stories are the core human innovation that allows us to compress context and meaning. Two people can tell you the same facts but when woven together, paints an entirely different story.</p><p>For example:</p><p>Person A says, “I went to my friends house and borrowed some tools he gave me”</p><p>Person B says, “Someone came to my house and took some tools I was showing him”</p><p><em>The chain of events are the same. But Person A and B and filling those events with </em><strong><em>INTENTIONS and INTERPRETATIONS</em></strong>. <strong>And what is a story but a ‘Network of Intentions &amp; Interpretations’</strong>?</p><p>Which gets me to Monoliths.</p><blockquote>Monolith noun</blockquote><blockquote><strong>1. : </strong>a single great stone often in the form of an obelisk or column</blockquote><blockquote><strong>2. : </strong>a massive structure</blockquote><blockquote><strong>3. : an organized whole that acts as a single unified powerful or influential force</strong></blockquote><blockquote>- Merriam-Webster <a href="https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/monolith">link</a></blockquote><p>You have likely heard at some point the phrase that “Women are not a Monolith”, a statement meant to mean that women are not a collective hive-mind or singular body that acts in the world. That they are individuals — monads that cannot be generalized. Implied in that statement as well would be that “Men are not a Monolith,” similarly impossible to categorize in any real sense.</p><p>On principle, and in essence, I would agree with such a statement. On first glance, there is no collective entity of any man or woman for the same reason I can’t speak on All Men or All Women. For such a collective entity to exist, all men and all women would need to actually know and conspire together to enact a certain mode of being, something I am sure has not happened (unless of course I haven’t been invited). So long as there is not active cohesion to make such a group ‘whole’ and singular in action, then such a Monolith is seemingly impossible.</p><p>However, by digging down into the statement, we can see what underlying meaning of Monoliths in the Human psyche. I’ll do this is 4 points:</p><p>A. <strong>The foundation of the concept of Patriarchy is built on Men being a Monolithic entity. The foundation of the concept of Feminism is built on Women being a Monolithic entity.</strong></p><p>Regardless of how you feel about either of these things, this is necessary because one can’t collectively hurt, disempower, help, or empower any group without the assumption that any member of that group can or should receive the intended effect. To even discuss, compare, and measure the differences in the treatment &amp; experience between men and women requires the observation and consideration of each as a monolithic entity.</p><p>However, how could we even reasonably do this if All men and All women have never conspired together to synchronize their actions? Only a small number of men or women ever get a voice, much less a discussion, on the motion, direction, and definition of the Monolith and what ‘Men’ or ‘Women’ should do in society. Well…</p><p>B. <strong>You don’t need to communicate or be represented as an individual to be a part of Monolithic entities.</strong></p><p>Society itself is a monolithic entity, despite the fact that we each are part of it with very different points of view. Your body is a monolithic entity, despite your cells being very different individual monads. In most monoliths, the majority of the individuals only share a few identifying traits that show they are part of that entity. However, from that collection of individuals comes a spectrum of behaviors, any one of which can be considered the ‘doing’ of the monolithic entity.</p><p>For example, John, a man, does a crime. John is part of the “Men” monolith. Hence, “Men” do crime. And this would be true. Just like if your hand picks up a pencil, “You”, too, pick up a pencil. Pushed even further, if “You” pick up the pencil, is not your foot also technically complicit in the action?</p><p><strong><em>The Monolith takes ownership of the actions of ALL individuals who are a part of it, no matter how thin the association BUT so long as the monolith exists, all individuals are made responsible or associated with the actions of any and all other members.</em></strong></p><p>The principle behind why this happens is the same as those described here:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/neo-cybernetics/in-hierarchy-power-floats-up-responsibility-sinks-down-7712830a8de">In Hierarchy, Power Floats Up &amp; Responsibility Sinks Down</a></p><p>This is why assessing or engaging with Monoliths are so tempestuous. This poses an issue. Both the Monoliths of Men and Women have done almost everything the other has done at least once. As a result, there is always an exception and an example of someone who contradicts whatever one could say about the Monolith of Men or Women. If that is true, then where exactly do we get the impetus to ever say anything about either Monolith?</p><p>C. <strong>Monoliths are made distinct by Comparison to other Monoliths, not by themselves.</strong></p><p>The only legitimate way we can even define the Monolith of Men and the Monolith of Women is by <strong><em>COMPARISON</em></strong>, seeing who does more or less of any particular thing.</p><p>This is why statistics always get thrown around in contentious (and often still fruitless) discussions on the issues of Men and Women. They are just about the only way people can say anything at all about the Monoliths. Men and Women, the Monoliths, have people who do crime. But statistically, Men do <em>more</em> crime, which means, to an observing bystander, that Men, the Monolith, is inherently more crime ridden than Women, the monolith! The implication?</p><p>Men, all men whom fit into the monolith of Men, are now also, 30% criminal (arbitrary number), even if they themselves have never done anything like that. <strong>The Story and intent of men is 30% criminal.</strong></p><p>But “not all Men!”, the individuals who are also roped into the monolith say. And this is true. They don’t consider themselves men because of a criminalistic urge but because they have a penis. But now, they are being lumped in with qualities that have nothing to do with them.</p><p>Worse for those guys, now that the trend has been noticed, a subset of people feel a need to know why it is exactly that Men, the monolith, has 30% more criminalistic lust within them. They look at other male traits and find testosterone which, statistically, women also have way less of. The Implication?</p><p>Men’s Testosterone makes them 80% more aggressive (arbitrary number) than Women, the monolith, resulting in 30% more criminalistic lust!</p><p>But “not all Men!”, they chant again. And on and on. Same with women.</p><p>But what prompted the question?</p><p><strong>The Difference between the Men and Women Monoliths.</strong> Comparison. This in spite of the fact that both Men and Women have (and could) do crime. If it is true that both could do it, then there would be some common denominator cause for why it happens at all for either group. Otherwise it would be a 100% Men / 0% Women phenomenon. It is not a Rule. But we act on these things as if they are.</p><p>This, I suspect, leads to narratives and stories about Men or Women, the monolith, that are ‘true’ and yet also irrelevant to addressing the action being examined. Most of us, on a day to day, do not interact with men’s testosterone and most of us rarely ever change anyone’s mind. So these instantly place you in a powerless situation. Most of these narratives build themselves up from either <strong>Biological Pressure</strong> or <strong>Societal Pressure</strong> theories. This is because biology and sociology are fields where we can pull <strong>statistics</strong> out of to make our stories more legitimate <em>in comparison to another monolith</em>. <em>The observations of the statistic is relative to another entity</em>.</p><p>However, the compelling nature of the narrative is NOT the same as a true, first principle, CAUSE. To get to the First-Principle cause for why any behavior happens in a human being, it will never suffice to pull from JUST the external pressures.</p><p>This is because the only way to get to ‘First-principles’ for any human decision making behavior is basically just pure <strong>Empathy</strong>. The ability to viscerally experience the incentives that drive a person to act in a certain way. For many parents, having a child of the opposite sex is the first time the experiences, demands, and considerations of the other side ever actually come into view, no matter how educated or experienced they are. We don’t think of empathy as a genuinely valid and effective tool for knowledge acquisition but there are some domains of knowledge that are literally inaccessible otherwise.</p><p>Incentives, will, and intent are the infrastructure that underly decisions. Biological and Societal pressures <em>only explain the fact that incentives</em> could exist. <strong>But only one’s own story explains why any one individual does anything or submits themselves to said incentive</strong>. With our statistical foundation of facts, we place the first chess-move of our story, finishing the rest of the story with “because they are Evil or Stupid Devils”, a principle I explain here:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/the-devil-evil-or-stupid-9d0df0cb4ba0">The Devil: Evil or Stupid?</a></p><p>We use one of these two explanations for just about every agent’s behavior that we can’t relate to or dislike.</p><p>However, the data required to be accurate in such a thing is so much more vast and obscure that it could never be captured accurately at scale under these Monoliths. We are not all being measured and even still, we are incentivized to share or hide information that will alter the data. In fact, some studies — both officially in scientific processes, and anecdotally in the very lives of the people around us — <strong>might not happen simply because it does not cross anyone’s mind to ask the question</strong>.</p><p>This leads me to my final point:</p><p>D. <strong>The Monoliths that people refer to and the statistics they compile to reinforce them will themselves be influenced by Stories they are compelled to tell.</strong></p><p>None of us can put ourself in the shoes of a Monolith because we are restricted to the complexity of one human being. <strong>We empathize with other People, not Groups of people</strong>. This was the purpose of such a statement as “women are not a monolith.” However, as we can see, our very capacity to Label &amp; distinct differences is the source of all monoliths. To claim that a woman/man is not a monolith is true in reality but wrong for how all of us perceive reality as human beings. It is really saying “Women are not a category.”</p><p>But they are... Categories are one of the ways in which we process information in our minds.</p><p>What any one person’s mental monolith of Men or Women looks like will be dependent on what their own environment, circumstances, and incentives are. <strong><em>When someone discusses “Men” or “Women”, they are thus, fundamentally, never talking about just reality but also about their own perception. And yet at the same time, that perception bases itself in a real portion of reality.</em></strong></p><p>Seriously. When a man and a woman says ‘Men’, they are both, more than not, referring to two very different entities build up by their own models, expectations, wants, and desires pertaining to that entity. Those factors are just as much mixed into what was likely real perceptions for the both of them that are accurate and valid. And same of course, vice versa.</p><p>Here we get the the crux of the issue. The projection of whole (as opposed to part or fractional) entities is critical to how we even think about anything in the world. In other words, <strong>we NEED assumptions to even think about anything.</strong> That means, strangely enough, that the Monolith does exist and does have a real effect on our actions and life. But only because <em>that “single unified force” is enacting its will right into our brain and our decisions by extension</em>. We have made full beings ourselves to be the monolith that acts on us. All it took was having the label exist for it to now have influence our thought, action, and perception in the world to some degree or another. Put simply, <strong>we are reacting to the Monoliths in our own minds.</strong></p><p>This also means that any consensus that we create on the properties of these Monoliths amongst each other, represent the thin degrees of similarities of experience that we as individuals believe and agree with, not just reality. Meaning that our consensus of interpretation is far more likely to be decided by the consensus of incentives, instead of reality itself. <strong><em>We never just believe and agree with things. We WANT/DON’T WANT to believe and agree with things.</em></strong> And so long as that is true, we will naturally be drawn to the aspects of the Monolith that align with our incentives and stories, confusing them for reality and acting based on that perception.</p><p>Okay, exhausting. You can think of that entire explanation as the ultimate disclaimer and trigger warning for this topic forever into the future — an unfortunate need for our times due to the tremendous lack of trust I see these days. When someone says “Men” or “Women” anything, you should just auto-correct it to “My story of Men/Women,” including your (and other’s) own inevitable rebuttal or support in the comments. They literally can’t help it, and neither can you. And yet neither of you are right OR wrong. Each of you are both right and wrong, every time, all the time.</p><p>Makes the discussion seem kind of pointless right? Well, thats because it <em>is</em> pointless… UNLESS, you are bridging the gap between what either of you mean by any of the word you each are slugging around at each other.</p><p>An image that comes to mind: <em>Two ships in the ocean need to actually dock onto each other to exchange cargo. If they are shooting cargo at each other from afar, it’s probably just a cannon ball, not cargo.</em></p><p>The bridge and means to dock is the Empathy.</p><p>So with all that said, I want to come back to that First Principles that undergird the mechanics of Monoliths because to me, that is the reason why we are collectively doomed, more than anything else I hear people talk about. Since they come from our own minds, the only way to understand causally what the heck Men or Women are, is to do what I already said cannot be done:</p><p>Empathize with the Monolith.</p><p>Have you ever noticed that individual people are far kinder and greater than “Humanity” tends to be? Or how often you hear people say they hate humans but they love people?</p><p>To me, this is because we are fundamentally disposed to relate to a being on our own level. However, the entity of Humanity is filled with the best and worst of our behaviors and we have a good spread.</p><p><strong>When someone is in front of you, are you looking at the Monolith of which they are a part or are you looking at THEM? To see THEM is to keep them ‘Undefined’ and flexible</strong>.</p><p>When we interact with people, with bodies, and faces, and more so when we see them simply ‘be’ in the world without considering them as a category, we inevitably see something beautiful in them. In contrast, online it is almost necessary to think of every comment, post, essay, article, tweet (or uh… x?), as basically a part Monolithic entity. These packets of data are not people or individuals but pure ‘thought’ emanating from a philosophy or psychology. And those philosophies and psychologies become patterns that we must navigate to maintain our story of ourselves and our world. What we see online is deep digging into the make up of a Monolith. Different ‘communities’ are monoliths. Even the people who gather in a particular comment section is a little monolith of ‘types’ that converge on certain content.</p><p>And the problem, I find, is that people then slowly build a lot of hyper-detailed and thorough monoliths to apply to just about every action a person can do who very likely is NOT even living in the same universe as you, mentally. Even if they are acting ‘right’ in accordance with the monolith, there is a complete failure to see THEM and why they are acting that way.</p><p>This whole seeing THEM thing is well explained in this essay I wrote here:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/what-even-is-respect-6c6fee617ee7">What Even is Respect?</a></p><p>So why is it so easy to lose sight of personhood today?</p><p>Because words can’t surprise you. But people do, if you look at them long enough.</p><p>These entities are basically stereotypes. And the reason we love them so much is because of one main thing:</p><h4>Complexity &amp; Overwhelm</h4><p>In the essay below, I give a more thorough explanation of what I mean by complexity:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/the-complexity-is-everything-and-more-3df4a5237bea">The Complexity is Everything and More</a></p><p>The world today is too complex. We have too many variables to consider and access to literally a global point of view has simply outclassed the amount of information we need to process to stay on top of everything going on that could effect us. What we are really doing with these Monoliths is trying to reduce the complexity of people down to something manageable &amp; control. Uncertainty is what we are really trying to muscle out of people when we interact with them because we are so used to that uncertainty being the very think that kicks our ass in some way.</p><p>However, in the effort to bring the complexity down, we have turned people increasingly into simplified characters that are more and more elaborate and difficult to break out from (at least on their own). People are quick to throw others in monolith jail and once they are in, they aren’t really given the chance to get out. Like a spider’s web, everything they say and do only further enmeshes them into the complexity net, until they are nothing more than a ‘typical Man’ or ‘basic Woman’ — simple, explainable, and predictable to the point of not even needing to see the rest of the story — their OWN story.</p><p>Worse still, the ‘rest of the story’ more often than not is a story build into the relationship the individual has with the Monolith itself. The patterns that repeat with “Men” or “Women” are patterns that that person repeats with the Monolith, not just with any one person. They are playing chess against an adversary they have already faced multiple times and lost to. Believing they have learned from it, gotten stronger against it, or healed from it is forgetting the core issue underlying how they got into the situation in the first place.</p><p>They still have the Monolith… and they still can’t empathize with it or see it as manifestations of themselves. It has not changed.</p><p>All they ever learned was even more elaborate maneuvers to increase the stakes of the game and escalate against the entity. All they ever got stronger in was in the endurance to play the chess for longer and in harsher conditions. All they ever healed was the trauma of being stripped from a hope of victory.</p><p>But they have not rid themselves of the very entity that follows them along to the next “Man” or “Woman” they engage with. And they cannot be rid of the entity because it turns into more than a tool for reducing complexity.</p><p>It becomes a tool of Othering. Scapegoating. Sacrifice.</p><h4>The Big Other</h4><p>The biggest benefit of the customized Monolith that people create is that you truly can’t completely relate to it. It is not human, and as such, if you leave it alone, <strong>everything that you don’t want to claim as part of yourself, you can place into the Monolith</strong>.</p><p>Like we mentioned earlier, if an examined quality or action exists that both men and women have the capacity to do, that means that those actions and qualities do not emanate from man or woman traits. Any Exception to the Monolith (or expressions of the Monolith not coming exclusively from those within it), break the Monolith’s reality, regardless of the life experience pointing towards a trend. It is because we intuitively know that this is true that people hate being reminded that “Not all xyz are like that.” It shows the exception and hence that we are living in our own Model, not Reality.</p><p>So the real question is “what purpose does this focus on the Monolith serve?”</p><p>There are only two purposes I have seen for emotionally charged fixations on certain aspects of a Monolith:</p><ol><li>To Create Distance by Othering</li><li>As a Vent or Receptacle of Hostility/Resentment</li></ol><p>No matter how much an individual might wholeheartedly protest and genuinely feel hurt by your actions, distancing, or stereotyping of them, if you are looking at the Monolith talking instead of the person, your empathy will be rationalized away because you are NOT designed to empathize with a Monolith. It is too different from being ‘human’ at all.</p><p>So this makes the Monolith a perfect candidate for storing things you’d rather not see about yourself and then ‘accurately’ blaming that quality of monolith. It is always an entity that deserves all the hurt and abuse you give it.</p><p>I touched on this dynamic for the first time, here:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/scapegoating-why-personality-type-matters-bd50d8a72e7f">Scapegoating: Why Personality Type Matters</a></p><p>This explains why it is that in most ‘groupings’ we usually see the worst things. Politics is large scale Monoliths that absorb the hatred of the other side like a sponge. Culture Wars, Gender Wars, Religious Wars, and literal Nation vs Nation Wars, all are this projection. And I am certain of it because of the ‘War’ part.</p><p>In order to beat an opponent, <strong>you must actually match their complexity</strong>. You have to be able to respond and react to what they do in a way that <strong>‘beats’ them at their own game</strong>. And the only way to do that is always to <strong><em>become more and more like your enemy</em></strong>. The women end up acting a lot like ‘narcissistic assholes’ they hate and the men act a lot like ‘perpetual victims’ they hate and it’s because that both are right and they both have been hiding those qualities in the Monolith of the big other.</p><p>Ironically, as the warring parties start to look more similar, they will find more subtle and arbitrary ways to prove they are different. This is the fate for every Monolith and every person that blindly clings to the ‘fighting’. The more one fights to show they are not part of the Monolith they are instantiating to keep the parts of themselves they don’t like, the more it seems to find a way back home, so to speak. But then again, it need not do that because the it was always home. <strong>The Monolith can only be brought about by the individual’s story itself. The fact that they can create it and its qualities in their mind is the proof that it is part of themselves and their own mind. <em>They wrestle with themselves.</em></strong></p><p>So what to do about all this? It’s a lot to take in. And what is my point anyway?</p><p>Well, my point is really captured by this:</p><p>This whole essay was one obnoxiously long way of saying “I’m throwing in the towel”, before I even started. I spend a lot of time studying specifically to try and make a bridge across the Monolithic structures in our minds. And I have actually found critical insights like the ones I have shared and so much more, including about what I think we mean by Masculine and Feminine, in essence.</p><p>But while I would love to write down and share all of the useful insights, analogies, and observations that I have found about the points of view of the Monoliths themselves, <strong><em>I have also realized that most people never actually wanted the bridge in the first place.</em></strong></p><p>We stereotype, and other, and brutalize the monolith at the expense of the people we trap in them to cope with our miserable, confusing, and tragic existence itself. Me clearing out the illusions and obstruction will take away what essentially amounts to humanity’s pacifier and I do not have a clear and obvious replacement yet. We don’t actually want to understand each other because it will directly threaten our sense of self. And If we ever did realize that we were truly the same and that the barriers between ourselves and another is illusory, I think it might actually cause us to go more insane than we already have. And I promise you, if you feel like one of the people that truly understand the other side, you are already wrong. Because the mystery of each other is perpetually unfolding. There is no solid and final end state of ‘I completely understand’ without a box that stops understanding.</p><p>A lack of empathy is actually what keeps us ‘functional’ to whatever degree you can call our way of being on a daily basis function. And I sure as hell am not gonna be the one that all sides agree is a ‘Trojan Horse of the enemy’. True Peace will always look like that, buddy. Regardless, that lines me up as a candidate for actual sacrifice (another concept I didn’t talk about here).</p><p>This leaves me with a bitter taste in my mouth. <strong>For all the deplorable behaviors I see humanity — the monolith — engaged in, the worst one to me, is the preference to sacrifice our fellow human (and really nature &amp; reality itself) in the name of feeling good about ourselves — ego.</strong></p><p><em>And I genuinely don’t know how to stop…</em></p><p>so I don’t know what to do about it.</p><p>But I know for sure that Men and Women are damn near hopeless. Imagine trying to love something while also never actually understanding it on its own terms. Imagine trying to connect with something while keeping it away. Imagine having expectations for something without ever knowing what it is. And then imagine trying to lie to yourself that your own ignorance justifies your spiteful hatred or even distain. Masking the same brutal barbaric bloodlust your ancestors had under the guise of ‘reason’ or stats or safety or other perpetual fascinations.</p><p>Its like pressing a name tag with the name “Devil” on someone, then kicking them for the name you gave them, and then looking at how they break down in response to your energy as evidence that they are what you called them. Its idiotic, yet completely ‘logical’. It is Sad, yet utterly unimpressive. It is the easiest &amp; yet most hopeless mission ever — to try and help someone who chooses that over sanity. Hopeless because no amount of discussion or patience changes the mind of a sadistic asshole. But easy because they feel helped by hearing any story that justifies their hatred.</p><p>And it literally does help them. Sacrificing and abusing their fellow human being is how they cope with their own likely abuse of themselves or from others. Maybe that’s why the old english romance tragedies were written like they were. We can WANT to love as deeply and fancifully as the clouds yearn to return to the ocean. But we Love ourselves too much to ever actually do what it really takes and be truly respectful of another person’s world as well as our own, at the same time.</p><p>Once more, humanity disappoints.</p><p>When I look at society, I see a bunch of people who agree on &gt; 90% of stuff with the &lt;10% differences being the biases towards our strategies of achieving the exact same desired end states. Some of those differences being needed for the other party’s strategy to even work.</p><p>It just insane. And what am I but insane, to open my own mind to that insanity in the hopes that it will become sense? I refuse to sacrifice my sanity to it or humble myself beneath it anymore. I will just share what I see honestly, and I’m just gonna assume that the people who want a different point of view will already be the one’s seeking it out. If my insights bother anyone and I don’t see them ‘docking’ with me on it — offering me the same vulnerability &amp; empathy I extend by talking about my own world and ideas — I have to assume they are just one of the people wasting my time, and their own, shooting a cannon ball for no reason.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f449f47f6008" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Ego: A Fledgling Theory on Everything]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-image"><a href="https://medium.com/neo-cybernetics/on-ego-a-fledgling-theory-on-everything-b60c3efe4f04?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2"><img src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xSQTgk9QTN-DJh9h" width="1024"></a></p><p class="medium-feed-snippet">An Explanation of Why Humans &amp; Societies are so Weird</p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://medium.com/neo-cybernetics/on-ego-a-fledgling-theory-on-everything-b60c3efe4f04?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2">Continue reading on Neo-Cybernetics »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://medium.com/neo-cybernetics/on-ego-a-fledgling-theory-on-everything-b60c3efe4f04?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b60c3efe4f04</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mr. Alias Moniker - Musings of a Young Old Man]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 Mar 2024 15:56:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-06T17:55:06.628Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Wrapping my Head around Inflation & the Relationship between Businesses & Consumers]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-image"><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/wrapping-my-head-around-inflation-the-relationship-between-businesses-consumers-abdf8edc55b3?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2"><img src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/2600/1*oj0eoZ-pmR15RENJ-RMoLw@2x.jpeg" width="4032"></a></p><p class="medium-feed-snippet">When we think of Inflation, we usually think of the price of everything increasing at once.</p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/wrapping-my-head-around-inflation-the-relationship-between-businesses-consumers-abdf8edc55b3?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2">Continue reading on Medium »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/wrapping-my-head-around-inflation-the-relationship-between-businesses-consumers-abdf8edc55b3?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/abdf8edc55b3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[money]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[price]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[inflation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mr. Alias Moniker - Musings of a Young Old Man]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 29 Feb 2024 17:02:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-29T17:02:06.294Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Deserve”]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-image"><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/deserve-6b3397de6cca?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2"><img src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/2600/1*NXPGHIG_CGX2tb8gWl3G0A@2x.jpeg" width="4032"></a></p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/deserve-6b3397de6cca?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2">Continue reading on Medium »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/deserve-6b3397de6cca?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6b3397de6cca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thoughts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meaning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life-lessons]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mr. Alias Moniker - Musings of a Young Old Man]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 06 Jan 2024 13:02:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-06T13:02:25.350Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Slavery: Crossing the Boundaries of My Mind]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-image"><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/on-slavery-crossing-the-boundaries-of-my-mind-f6b24faf3e68?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2"><img src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/2600/1*zZ3ud3jNCFNHd0eIqMpWSQ@2x.jpeg" width="4032"></a></p><p class="medium-feed-snippet">Escaping My Perfectionists Hell pt 2</p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/on-slavery-crossing-the-boundaries-of-my-mind-f6b24faf3e68?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2">Continue reading on Medium »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://medium.com/@MusingsofaYOM/on-slavery-crossing-the-boundaries-of-my-mind-f6b24faf3e68?source=rss-2a3ccc51d1b5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f6b24faf3e68</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindfulness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mr. Alias Moniker - Musings of a Young Old Man]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 05 Nov 2023 12:48:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-05T13:23:07.707Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>