<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ninety9 on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ninety9 on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@Ninety92000?source=rss-08d192ef8aff------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 05:11:51 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@Ninety92000/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Monanarcy and Polyanarchy : Rethinking Forms of Government]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Ninety92000/monanarcy-and-polyanarchy-rethinking-forms-of-government-b55d966878c4?source=rss-08d192ef8aff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b55d966878c4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ninety9]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Sep 2025 11:53:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-08T12:19:07.780Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Monanarcy and Polyanarchy : Rethinking Forms of Government</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mOR79Emh_yDfNaYwst_EDQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>For Hobbes, the state of nature was nothing but a war of all against all — life of an individual was “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.” If we see Indian Tradition of thought, we find similar ideas of Kautilya. For him, it was <em>matsyanyaya </em>— the law of the fish — where, without the danda (Authority or Fear of Punishment), the big fish devours the small. Both saw human beings as trapped in a raw struggle, and both agreed that only authority could prevent collapse into anarchy. However, either it is Hobbes, Locke, Kautilya, Rousseau or any other contractarian thinker, the State of nature and Social contract is an Hypothetical condition, based on speculation which seeks to answer origin of state through logic and not through historical and scientific evidence. So for the rest of the text, I will also carry forward the idea of state of nature and social contract, and for me, as similar to Hobbes and Kautilya, the innate human nature was greedy, brutish, nasty, violent, mean.</p><p>So I will try to examine, here, that does the origin of state and the formation of governance systems like monarchy or democracy literally solved the problem or just took another face? So, here lies the problem- authority itself does not escape this primal law — it merely reshapes it. Whether a king in a monarchy or the people’s representatives in a democracy, rulers are guided by same innate human nature as it was before formation of state, and what we call “order” is only a managed outer shell or mask over anarchy. It is this reality I call <strong>Monanarchy</strong> and <strong>Polyanarchy</strong>-two faces of institutionalized anarchy misinterpreted or misunderstood as monarchy and democracy.</p><p><strong>Myth of Escaping State Of Nature</strong></p><p>Hobbes believed that only a sovereign power could lift humankind out of the war of all against all. Similarly, Kautilya argued that without the danda (Authority of the fear of punishment), society would collapse into <em>matsyanyaya</em>.</p><p>But both Hobbes and Kautilya still presupposed that rulers could <em>transcend</em> this primal law. They forgot that Nature itself do not possess Justice, the nature works on the laws of might is right. My idea differs with Kautilya or Hobbes; I think rulers are themselves products of the same condition. For Hobbes or Plato, if we see, the idea of the absolute king is derived from presupposition that “He who does not desire power is fit to hold it.” But they imagined an utopia, a person may or may not be attracted towards power, until he/she possesses it. But what after they possess power? The history tells us that power corrupted every ruler, either in one way or another. They are not guardians of order, but predators who have monopolized the power to devour. What changes is not the end of anarchy, but its scale and appearance.</p><p>In monarchy, one sovereign consolidates the anarchic impulse of domination. In democracy, multiple groups compete to impose their anarchic interests in the name of law.</p><p>Thus, the <em>state of nature</em> does not end with political order but it converts into institutionalized forms.</p><p><strong>Monanarchy</strong></p><p>Monarchy is traditionally described as the rule of one. But in reality, monarchy is better described as <strong>monanarchy </strong>— a concentration of anarchy in the person of the sovereign.</p><p>The monarch is not neutral or divine, despite claims of divine right. His laws and rules are shaped by his survival, interests, and biases. His justice is selective. What appears as order is merely the <strong>codification of one person’s anarchic will</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*77eSKcOLsbN4SQ5bQNlIkw.png" /></figure><p>Thus, monarchy does not abolish <em>matsyanyaya</em>-it simply centralizes it. The king becomes the “biggest fish,” devouring all others legally, and the codified legal document becomes the <em>Amrit</em> (a holy drink to become immortal as per Hindu tradition of thought) for that big fish.</p><p><strong>Polyanarchy</strong></p><p>Democracy is often imagined as the opposite of monarchy where rule of the people, collective self-governance exists, Yet, beneath the chants of popular sovereignty lies what I call <strong>polyanarchy</strong>.</p><p>In democracy, multiple groups- parties, interest groups, corporations, media houses, caste groups ,religious factions -compete to impose their version of order. Laws become outcomes of bargaining, lobbying, and compromise. Elections are mere a toy to keep the general masses in delusion that they are in control but Elections themselves are battles of manipulation, money, and muscle, especially the manipulation of human mind was not this easy earlier as it is in this age of this A.I. and Techno-feudal powers.</p><p>Historically, if we see, The medieval Italian communes — Florence, Venice, Genoa — resisted emperor and pope by ruling themselves through rotating civic councils. But what followed was not lasting stability. Endless rivalries, factional disputes, and family feuds revealed the weakness of decentralized authority. Without a stable unifying center, communes hung between short bursts of republican vitality and long stretches of oligarchic dominance or violent collapse.</p><p>Thus, democracy is not pure order but <strong>managed conflict</strong>, an institutionalized war of factions. What Hobbes called the “state of war” continues inside parliament, courts, and streets-only ritualized, proceduralized, and legitimized.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*0qhgnLms92p0FVSL_IptDg.jpeg" /></figure><p>For instance, if we take example of Post 2014 India- In every sphere — policing, elections, administration, the economy and the media- reputable reports show a recurring pattern formal rules and institutions exist, but enforcement is highly fragmented. The use of UAPA and PMLA act clearly shows how authorities silence dissenters, Agencies meant to be neutral are frequently wielded by the ruling party against opponents, and key posts are filled with ideological loyalists. This fragmentation of power accords with the idea of <em>polyanarchy</em> — multiple competing centers of influence rather than a single, impartial legal order. As per the reports of reputed sources such as Reuters, the wire, scroll, and the Guardian, academic analyses, and watchdogs document these cases. Some other day I will present the facts that will tell that how the India- hailed as mother of democracy is nothing more that what I call Poly-anarchy. Lets continue to our topic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JMaA-wg2WfXReSkyp5xY6g.png" /></figure><p><strong>Hollow Sense of Order</strong></p><p>Why then do people believe they live under order, not anarchy? Because order is an illusion maintained through symbols, flags, institutions, and fear.</p><p>Police, courts, constitutions, parliaments -these create a <em>false sense of order</em>. Education, propaganda, and ideology train people to accept rules as if they are natural and justified. Fear of punishment suppresses rebellion.</p><p>But beneath this thin surface; corruption, selective enforcement, and arbitrary power persist. Order is thus a <strong>hollow shell</strong>, easily cracked during crises. When legitimacy collapses-through economic failure, social unrest, or moral bankruptcy-the illusion vanishes, and the anarchic foundation reappears.</p><p><strong>The Cycle</strong></p><p>History shows this repeatedly. Ancient empires fell into civil wars, democracies slided into demagoguery, modern states collapse into coups. Each collapse is not a new phenomenon but simply the resurfacing of the primal <em>matsyanyaya</em>.</p><p>Political systems oscillate between <strong>illusion of order</strong> and <strong>exposure of anarchy</strong> — <em>State of Nature &gt; Hollow Order (Monanarchy/Polyanarchy) &gt; Collapse &gt; Re-invented Hollow Order.</em></p><p>The cycle never ends, because the fundamental law of power-the strong devouring the weak-remains unchanged.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/646/1*Jw1BgdjWqC1sRa7Ve2osGQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Theorem Building</strong></p><p>As Hobbes was fascinated with domain of Geometry, so I am , hence I will apply the above definitions and arguments to the real world.</p><p>So, If all authority is just a re-organization of anarchy, what does this mean for political philosophy?</p><p>The state is not a rational contract but a continuation of conflict. Consent is secondary; coercion primary. History is not linear progress from barbarism to civilization, but cyclcal reorganization of power and anarchy. Real order cannot come from rulers, because rulers are themselves anarchic. If order is possible, it must come from <em>within individuals</em>-through self-discipline, dharma, or ethical self-governance.</p><p>Here, Indian traditions like Buddhism and Jainism resonate, here we find the champions of positive liberalism, here resonates the Stoics, Rousseau and the ideas of Gandhi — that order is not external, but internal.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>Political philosophy has long imagined authority as the cure to anarchy. But what if authority itself is only an <em>anarch in camouflage</em>? Monarchy is not the rule of one, but <strong>monanarchy</strong> — the anarchic will of one sovereign. Democracy is not rule of the people, but <strong>polyanarchy</strong> — the anarchic conflict of many interests. And for me among these two the democracy is the worst form, we are giving suffrage rights to those who are pitty, self interested, nasty, and the worst of all animals. I do believe that the general masses are not matured enough to see the actual good for themselves, in this case, Monarchy or what I say Monanarchy can said to be the better form than democracy as long as the sovereign is wise — similar to Plato’s idea of Philosopher King.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b55d966878c4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Contexts: In Context of Political thoughts and ideas]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Ninety92000/contexts-in-context-of-political-thoughts-and-ideas-0fbc21d72f53?source=rss-08d192ef8aff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0fbc21d72f53</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cambridge]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[context]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ninety9]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Aug 2025 16:20:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-05T13:09:23.096Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>What do you feel or think when you see people waving red flags, blue flags, green, saffron and yellow flags in the wind like ritualistic traditional victory celebration? You hear slogans: “Down with Capitalism!”, “Laal salaam”, “Buddham Sharnam Gachhami”, “Jai Bhim”, “Jai shree Ram”, “Longlive labours”, “Labours of the world unite”, and countless other slogans.</p><p>You must have thought, maybe you wondered Do they really know what they’re chanting? Do they know what these flags once meant? Or whay these thinkers were fighting when they wrote?</p><blockquote>This article is not an academic chapter or a theoretical dissertation. It is a common-sensical argument against political chauvinism and ritualism. This is to ask What problem was this idea originally trying to solve? Because if we don’t ask that, then we aren’t thinking. We’re just performing.</blockquote><h3>Political science and Contextual Process:</h3><p>In political science, context refers to the historical, social, economic, Political and institutional conditions in which a political idea was born. “NO thinker writes in a VACUUM.” Every idea is a response to power, to injustice, to hope, or to fear or to simply praise or justify the different societal Structures of that time. This is the core insight of the Cambridge School, particularly Quentin Skinner, who insisted that we must understand what a thinker was trying to do with their words and not just what the words say.</p><p>This is called the contextual approach. “It stands opposed to textualism”, which reads a thinker’s words as if they were timeless truths meant to apply to all ages, all societies, all people. The tragedy of our times is this: we quote the text but forget the battle. And when we do that, we reduce living ideas into dead dogmas</p><h3>Finding the Contexts of Different Thinkers.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1GYSP3ODA9yk11Vqzp8_1Q.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote>In this segment I will try to give examples of some of the greatest political thinkers to back my statement. To show the reason behind their works through the situations they were fighting.</blockquote><p><em>John Locke, Adam Smith, and David Ricardo</em></p><p>These thinkers are often seen as champions of capitalism, property, and individual liberty. But to understand their ideas, we must understand what they were reacting against the Feudal Europe, where monarchs and landlords colluded with the Church to oppress common people. The vicious nexus between the three to snatch free will, property rights, even thinking of their subjects, i.e. very people of the society in Europe. Therefore, Europe’s mediaeval period is also known as Dark Mediaeval Ages of Europe, where owning land was a privilege of the aristocracy, and “individual liberty” didn’t exist for the masses.</p><p>So, when Locke spoke of natural rights, and Smith defended private property, they were not celebrating billionaires. They were demanding basic human dignity in a time of absolute subjugation. They were speaking for a rising middle class, artisans, and merchants crushed under aristocratic boots.</p><p>Now come to <em>Karl Marx </em>and Early Industrial Capitalism, Marx is often quoted today as if he was watching iPhones, data harvesting, and Tariff wars, But his fight was against the raw, brutal face of 19th-century capitalism. What was that? Come on class 11th history!! The Child labour, 14-hour workdays, no safety laws, hazardous works without safety gears, spreading of diseases , Workers living in slums in an inhuman condition - while factory owners became kings and built their castles.</p><p>So, from this Point of view, his critique was urgent and necessary for that era, just as a new critique must rise for ours. Quoting Marx without confronting today’s exploiters — Big Tech, surveillance capitalism, data colonisation — is not revolution. It’s nostalgia and ritualism. It is nothing different from reading aayat or chanting hanuman chalisa.</p><p>We are being ignorant when we compare the early liberals like smith, Locke, Ricardo and the socialist thinker Marx. It is fine, to an extent, for academic purposes, to comparing them side by side. But ideological war is just no more than bullshit, because, as i explained they lived in a different time and spaces.. problems of feudalism led of liberal thought and the dark age of mediaeval Europe gave the fire to the thoughts of Thinkers of the enlightenment period. Similarly, Marx’s thoughts were a reaction to an exploitative force of that time — capitalism.</p><p>Here’s the great example of <em>Plato</em>. especially in these times when Plato’s thoughts on Democracy are misinterpreted by both, the right wing, and the left wing.</p><p>I recently faced some idiotic arguments against democracy, one of them was spread by Right wing WhatsApp warriors and Online trollers, which quote “Plato too hated democracy.” But do they know why? The left wing or the intellectual section of society argue that the masses of the society cannot choose the best in democracy, this stream of thought even found flaws in democratic process, the general masses always make win figures like Hitler, hence it is necessary, for good of the society, that there should be a philosopher king or something similar. The both sections downplay democracy, however their reasons vary, but they both lacks the understanding of context that Plato’s beloved teacher, ideal, his great master philosopher Socrates, was sentenced to death by a democratic jury in Athens. That wasn’t the representative democracy we know today but a direct democracy, where a misinformed majority could kill a dissenter.</p><p>Plato feared the mob, not the principle of self-governance, federalism, constitution made by the representatives of whole society, the feeling of constitutionalism. The sight of Plato was narrow on Democracy that time, He may not have imagined an idea of Representative democracy, women vote, universal adult franchise, constitutionalism (in His work, the republic), “So he imagined the Philosopher-King as a thought experiment, not a political blueprint.” He didn’t say “install dictatorship”- he said, “imagine if rulers were guided by wisdom.”</p><p>The regarded propounder of Textual approach to Interpretation of political thought, Leo Strauss, where readers must “read between the lines” of classical texts. why did he do this?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/924/1*tXCc48S-PZn9pZVdvHkufQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Leo Strauss</figcaption></figure><p>Because in 1930s Germany, Hitler rose to power through liberal democratic elections. Strauss, a Jew, fled the country. His disillusionment with liberal democracy wasn’t theoretical, it was personal, existential.</p><p>To him, democracy had failed to protect truth, and this liberal democracy is of no value , it is unable to solve problems of that time. Maybe he was also of thought that The Hitler Did what he did because he misinterpreted the writings of Nietzsche. That’s why he returned to Plato and others, not out of nostalgia, but out of despair. When we read Strauss today, without knowing his trauma, we misuse his warning as a justification for elitism.</p><blockquote>So, now we can conclude that, when ideas are pulled out of their soil and shouted in the streets, they lose their power to liberate. They become ornaments-intellectual jewellery worn for identity, not for action. This is the core danger of decontextualized politics.</blockquote><p>Most people today don’t read Adam Smith, Marx, or Plato. They repeat fragments of what they’ve heard, ripped from memes, WhatsApp forwards, or political influencers. And the tragedy is, even those in elite spaces, college campuses, political rallies, even faculty meetings, staff room debates, are often engaged not in thinking, but in echoing, someone will echo Savarkar, other Gandhi, Someone will shout Jai Bhim, someone will argue in Favour of Birsa Munda and the list goes on. But how far are we going to play on someone else’s pitch? We have our own ground and pitch, we have problems of our times- climate change, data hegemony of large corporations like Apple, Google, Microsoft, Meta, which can be used to manipulate our choices, minds, appeals, and even Voting behaviour, it can manipulate our neurochemistry of brain, The problems of Nuclear weapons, the unprecedented growth leading to deforestation and biodiversity loss, Increasing income disparities, Neo-Fascism, Hyper-Nationalism, and the list goes on. But what we are doing to solve these problems? Do Marx come to JNU to solve the problems of institutional attacks by fascist government? Or will Gandhi come to teach a lesson on Greed to those capitalist powers? Or will Foucault give class to Governments and Corporations in all over the world about surveillance?</p><p>You will find college students in Che Guevara t-shirts chanting “Down with capitalism!” while livestreaming it on an iPhone made in a Foxconn factory (China) under exploitative labor. They defend Marxist revolution without realizing that today’s capitalism does not just exploit bodies — it hacks minds.</p><p>In Marx’s time, capitalism stole labor. In ours, it steals attention. Our browsing history, our likes, our emotional weaknesses — they are now commodified, predicted, sold. Marx did not have to face this. You do.</p><p>So, quoting Marx without upgrading his lens is like carrying a AK47 into a cyberwar.</p><p>Too many people are borrowing the flags of past revolutions without understanding the fires behind them. They wave the red flag, but won’t organize workers or fight with a <em>Rikshawala </em>(Auto, A Three-Wheeler Public Transport) regarding for a demand of some extra money due to night time. They chant “Jai Bhim,” but will not fight caste within their own families. They invoke Ambedkar, but do not give property rights to women within their families.</p><p>You will see many people - especially some radical Hindutva mobs or social media nationalist - raging against “Western liberal democracy” and defending authoritarian power in the name of Indian pride, Culture and Modi’s diversion towards cultural nationalism. They say “Democracy is a Western concept, not fit for Bharat.”</p><p>They shout “Bharat Mata ki Jai” in Nike jerseys stitched by underpaid workers in Bangladesh, quoting Savarkar, Hedgewar or Golwalkar to defend Indian government that calls itself anti-West, while doing it all through American-owned apps running on servers of “Meta” and “X”.</p><p>If you are not understanding the context of an idea, you are not thinking, you are imitating, you are chanting, you are conducting a ritual, you are echoing. The purpose of political thought is not to wave old flags, but to build new paths to solve problems of your time and space. How can an idea be implemented in your time and space which was originated hundreds or thousands of years ago in different time and space on a different Soil.</p><blockquote>Quoting Marx without understanding data colonialism, Quoting Plato without confronting authoritarianism , Quoting Locke without talking about caste and capital - is total useless and idiotic.</blockquote><blockquote>And i want to remind all of us that, If we are not solving the problem of our own time, we will be not regarded as thinker in the future, the history will not be kind to us. We will remain a priest, pandit or a maulvi, not a religious one but an ideological one.</blockquote><blockquote>So, the next time you raise a flag or chant a slogan. pause. And ask - Whose battle am I really fighting?</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0fbc21d72f53" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How To Survive in MODI’S INDIA : Not an Answer.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Ninety92000/how-to-survive-in-modis-india-not-an-answer-1cc93071fea4?source=rss-08d192ef8aff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1cc93071fea4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[rss]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[narendra-modi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bjp]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ninety9]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Jul 2025 06:50:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-08T10:51:24.885Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>How To Survive in MODI’S INDIA : Not an Answer.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/516/1*ha_Ui3XZrl8XX974P535Hw.png" /><figcaption>MODI-TLER</figcaption></figure><p><strong>A QUESTION.</strong></p><p>My personal, political and social frustration, anxiety, depression led me to thought process of Kafka, Nietzsche, Jung, Freud, Schopenhauer.. i don’t want to explain my point to anyone i just want to read learn gain knowledge write my ideas and make my own corner in this world, like an ocean all the people are on surface and i am trying finding a corner at the deepest ends of the ocean, i am in the mid,, hence unable to breathe, i.e. in confusion, frustration and existential crisis.</p><p>But Wait, is the corner in the ocean, or even the comlete ocean, the India itself, even sustainable anymore? It is our today’s point to discussion — How to survive in this RSS backed Modi’s neo fascist india, with indian masses replicating the german citizens of 1930s, ignoring professors, sleeper cells of Nagpur based organization in every sector of society, People blidly bending in front of dictators, religious absurdity, raping womens and all wrong doings in name of ram or in kanvad yatra or any such B***hit, this was not my INDIA, in which i was born. Earlier on International stages when the name India was called, the people thought of traditions, rich culture, festivals like holi diwali, cuisine, dresses, great epics, upnishads, yoga and what not, it made indians pride, but <strong><em>today this totalitarian government backed by terrorist fascist organisation had broken the very soul and soil of india</em></strong>. How to survive here ? How to ignore the youth in colleges, roads, metros who is carrying overconfidence in misinformation, or how to ignore the uncles in busses, footpaths, teastalls, carrying propaganda of a party?? Or some sleeper cell professors of that organization? Can i even live in this ocean is this not completely polluted, can i even make my corner here? I feel like a mid-sea diver, suffocating not due to lack of air, but because the very <strong>ocean of India is toxic now, </strong>ideologically poisoned.</p><p>This is not just frustration of family, relationship, bureaucracy, politics and society but It is <strong>existential</strong>. It is the cry of someone who still <em>loves</em> India, not the cardboard cutout in BJP rallies, not the fictional Akhand Bharat of WhatsApp warriors, but <strong>the soul of India</strong>: the India of Raja Ram mohan roy, of Kabir, of Ambedkar, of Bhagat Singh, of Gauri Lankesh, of Gandhi and of Sufi music echoing in masjids and bhajans in homes side by side. So, How do I and people like me Survive here?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/160/1*MWsjdD7gkkvZYJGRh2Enzg@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>AN ANSWER ??</strong></p><h3>“What happened to my India?”</h3><p>And i am borrowing the great explaination of Mr. Javed Akhtar to the quetion that how the indians became suddenly, so intolerant and foot soldiers of a party, so he answers, what happened, is that <strong>the shadow part of India</strong>, which always existed, has taken control. India was <em>never</em> pure. But it had a balance. The <strong>light</strong> (classical culture, syncretism, intellectualism) and the <strong>shadow</strong> (caste, patriarchy, communalism) fought silently inside it.</p><p>We can also understand this with Carl Jung’s idea of Unconciousness, the Unconciousness takes the control if illtreated. We might go deep into this, but it takes us away from our topic, So, Now the shadow has taken the mic and made itself the <strong>entire stage</strong>. A day will come that again this shadow part will udergo the actual soul of INDIA. The RSS ideology isn’t foreign, it is the <strong>unconscious India</strong> that remained unaddressed.</p><p>So, we can say that the the shadow part is describing the rules of game, For Now, From mythology to majoritarianism, From “Unity in Diversity” to “Uniformity by Division, From <em>Upanishads</em> to <em>WhatsApp forwards. </em>This is not a new India. This is <strong>India’s repressed id</strong> ,the unconscious hatred and insecurity, now drunk on power.</p><p>So we, some like minded people are still able to see it and we are not mad for seeing it, but are sane in an insane society.</p><h3>HOW TO SURVIVE?</h3><p>Suppose yourself to be Kafka in Nazi Germany, Albert Camus in colonial Algeria, Tagore in a burning Bengal. The major question isn’t about<em>“How to avoid the madness?” but, </em>The question is “How do I remain myself while living among the mad?” Suppose, You’re in an occupied country. Suppose YOU ARE GRAMSCI. Don’t walk like a civilian. Think like a revolutionary. So,</p><p>Every time a chaiwala uncle spits propaganda, don’t argue, Treat them as infected minds. Observe their language like a linguistic disease. Control your information diet like food.<br> There are many scholars all over and beyond india, there is many content on internet, many books, writings of louis althuser, Hannah Arendt, George Orwell, Antonio Gramsci, Paulo friere, Laurence Rees, and endless resources, read the banned or ignored voices. JUST READ As a quote i have read, “Reading cures Fascism and travelling cures Racism.” This is the only weapon we have my fellows, Read as much as you can, Write, Reflect, Observe, LOOP. Live among the crowd like a ghost of truth, unseen, but aware. Don’t reveal your intellect to every idiot. Reserve it like a sword. Most people want confirmation, not discussion. <em>Let them win arguments. You win the war by staying awake.</em><strong> BUT</strong><em> </em>DON’T MAKE THIS CORNER, A SYMBOL for Your escapism. Treat it like a launchpad. It is our mental underground printing press. and trust me,, they fear minds like us more than armies. Because dictators can kill people, but not <em>ideas</em> that are deeply rooted in pain and clarity. As you can also find <strong>in the Mussolini’s Italy, when prosecutor said, and i am quoting it, “For twenty years we must stop this brain from functioning,” regarding Antonio Gramsci.</strong></p><p>SO, Don’t fall into despair. That’s what they want. They want the thinking ones to burn out, isolate, or emigrate. We surviving here with clarity, mind, silence, which is itself a revolutionary act.</p><h3>Our Role us Like minded people?</h3><p>Hey fellow beings we are not just a victim of this system, but are one of the few sensitive instruments who can record this madness truthfully, not in shallow protest, but in eternal literature, politics, philosophy, film, or silent whispers in a room full of wrong voices. WE ARE NOT made to scream on news panels. WE ARE made to outlive this time, and when the tide turns, WE will be a founder of the India after fascism.</p><h3>A COMMON COUNTERARGUMENT</h3><p>One might argue, “India is not a totalitarian state. We still vote. The Parliament still functions. There is dissent. We have courts, media, and constitutional checks and balances. Surely, this isn’t fascism?” And yet, such arguments feel like the polished lies we tell ourselves to avoid looking into the cracked mirror of our democracy.</p><p>To those making these claims, I have one humble request — <strong>stop consuming your nation through TV news channels that act as the regime’s cheerleaders, stop forwarding WhatsApp forwards that manufacture hate, and stop scrolling reels that dress your ignorance as patriotism.</strong> These are not signs of a functioning democracy; they are symptoms of a carefully engineered illusion.</p><p>Democracy is not a ritual of voting every five years. It is the <strong>daily lived experience of justice, dignity, and truth </strong>especially for the last person in line. Ask yourself: do Dalits feel safe in this democracy? Do Muslims? Do journalists? Do students? Do the poor, the tribal, the protestor?</p><p>The real soul of India does not reside in sanitized manifestos or Republic Day tableaus — it lives in <strong>villages, bastis, forest hamlets, protest sites</strong>, and jail cells. To understand that soul, we must start reading those who chronicle it. Read not to win debates, but to recognize patterns. Once you do, you will begin to see the outlines of a <strong>deep nexus </strong>between religious cults and political power, between police violence and media narratives, between bureaucracy and silent caste complicity. You will start asking deeper questions, Why does the state celebrate Ambedkar and jail his intellectual descendants? Why are dissenters called anti-nationals, while hate-spewing godmen are called “national treasures”? Why is a Rahul Gandhi mocked but Umar Khalid imprisoned? Why is a Stan Swamy handcuffed in death, but no riot-mongering MP from a governing party is ever arrested?</p><p>This is not dissent it is <strong>selective tolerance dressed as pluralism</strong>. When dissent comes from the elite, it is called ‘spirited debate’. When it comes from the margins, it is silenced with UAPA, bullets, and erasure. Even I, as I write this, must ask myself, <strong>am I not relatively privileged?</strong> I can write, read, access the internet. But the <strong>adivasi child in Bastar, the Dalit mother in Banda, the worker in Gurugram, or the disabled professor in Nagpur, </strong>can they write? Can they raise their voices without losing their homes, lives, or dignity?</p><p><em>We mourn democracy only when it stops working for us. But for most Indians, it never really started working. For them, freedom is not eroding, it was never fully granted.</em></p><p>We speak of Trump and China as if our house is in order. But what use is a democracy where <strong>we know more about the US elections than about the displacement of tribals in Chhattisgarh, or the hunger deaths in Odisha, or the police violence in Streets of Haryana, Gujrat, Bihar, Madhya Pradesh</strong>? A nation that forgets its margins, who constitute the major soul and popution of India, will one day find itself ruled by its worst instincts. And that’s where we are.</p><p>But here lies the most saddening part: the sidelined, outcaste sections I am talking about have voluntarily given up their dissent to the government. They are being, as Gramsci explains, consensually hegemonized. In hegemonized democracies like ours, people <strong>love their captors</strong> — they cheer for their chains. That those who should be the torchbearers of resistance have been offered just enough illusion, of what? of faith, of nationalism, of pride. They forget their hunger, their humiliation, their history. So on the one hand the very section of the society neither dissent nor focus on its basic needs, but a endless pride in its Flawed Nation and chilling Vishwaguru Vibes. It is consensually hegemonization. If one tries to study India in 2025, one will feel burn out, left alone, anxious, confused and depressed. One will see a parallel between Germans of 1930s and Indians. So, we are living both at a time, Orwell and Haxley. The control through fear and coercion and also by pleasure and distraction.</p><p><strong>CRITIQUING MYSELF.</strong></p><p>I said Reject debate, as most people want confirmation, not discussion. Let them win arguments. You win the war by staying awake. But what if i feel, if i leave them to win their hate will propagate, they will feel their hate was right and on the other hand i argues we are their weakness we should fight. This is a Dichotomy where i Live currently, and maybe i found a way out.</p><p>Here lies the answer, i can fight with the establishment, but i cannot fight with a nation of 150 crore people Bowing to a Maniac, i should explain how, so again, take example of Nazi Germany, when the Germany was under Hitler all people were in blind faith, walked on the path of hate and hell, bowed in front of him but one man, the August Landmesser, he stood folding his arms however, cannot revolt because Hitler was not his problem but the very people was, so he chose to stay silent, on the contrary Bhagat singh was pure revolting soul, a revolutionary, because he was only fighting against establishment not the very people of his own (exception to some ideological conflicts with other leaders) so i and we are Landmesser not the Bhagat in this situation.</p><p>So this dichotomy leads us the the very question we have started, this conversation with — HOW TO SURVIVE IN MODI’S INDIA?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ErV2bL_yzbTruRDlCJ7MWw.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1cc93071fea4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Utopia and Power]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Ninety92000/utopia-and-power-fa004c3d0f69?source=rss-08d192ef8aff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fa004c3d0f69</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thoughts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-behavior]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ninety9]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 15 Jul 2025 01:37:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-05T13:18:05.245Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>WHAT IS UTOPIA?</p><p>The word <em>Utopia</em> originates from Sir Thomas More’s 1516 book “Utopia,” a political satire that depicted an ideal society on a fictional island. The term itself is a play on Greek words: <em>ou-topos</em> meaning “no place” and <em>eu-topos</em> meaning “good place” — suggesting both a perfect society and the impossibility of its existence. Since then, the idea of utopia has evolved across disciplines, from political philosophy and literature to religious thought and revolutionary ideology.</p><p>In political theory, a utopia is commonly defined as an ideal society marked by perfect justice, equality, harmony, and freedom. Scholars like Karl Mannheim described utopias as “orientations transcending the present state of affairs” that challenge existing social orders. Meanwhile, critics have warned of their dangers — from Isaiah Berlin who feared the coercive side of utopias, to Friedrich Hayek who saw them as the breeding ground for totalitarianism.</p><p>Historical attempts at utopia offer a sobering perspective such as Marxist states like the Soviet Union and Maoist China attempted to implement classless, egalitarian societies. But efforts to remake human consciousness often led to mass surveillance, purges, and authoritarianism. Anarchist experiments in Spain during the 1930s tried to eliminate private property and hierarchy but were suppressed violently, these examples show that when utopias are enforced too strictly or rapidly, they can spiral into dystopias.</p><p><strong>UTOPIA AND POWER</strong></p><p>“Utopia is just an idea that hasn’t been backed by power, Every radical idea is called utopia, until it is uttered from the mouth of power. Power doesn’t just enforce laws. It defines what ideas are allowed to exist.”</p><p>In the light of above statement it can be said that, Every idea, no matter how rational or just, remains utopic and normative as long as it exists solely in the mind of the powerless — the citizen, the philosopher, the thinkers. Without institutional backing or recognition by power structures, the idea lacks legitimacy and is dismissed as fantasy. It is only when the same idea is spoken by someone in authority — a policymaker, a religious leader, a corporate head that it acquires the weight of ‘realism’. In this sense, power is not merely the enforcer of ideas but the certifier of what counts as truth.</p><p>So, was Marx wrong when he said that the ideas of the ruling class are the ruling ideas, when Gramsci said that state(ruling class) not just rules through law, police but through media, education, culture, ideas, institutions like family, etc, was Foucault mistaken when he said that one who drives the discourse, drives the truth, or was Althusser exaggerating when he emphasized that state does not solely relies on repressive and coercive methods of control but also ideological state apparatuses. They were revealing an uncomfortable truth that “<strong>power legitimizes thought”</strong>. Without power, even the most brilliant idea floats in abstraction. With power, even an irrational belief can become institutional dogma.</p><p>So is it not the selective realism of dominant power structures. When a poor or marginalised person imagines a just society, their vision is labelled idealistic. But when the ruling elite promotes policies that serve its interests, it is seen as pragmatic or realistic. Power determines the viability of an idea.</p><p><strong>WHY SOME UTOPIAS ARE LITERALLY UTOPIAS</strong></p><p>To make a better assessment and deliver structural &amp; critical argument, I want to propose a classification of utopia. So, we can categorize Utopia into three categories, namely, Radical, Moderate and Possible. Below are their explanation.</p><p><strong>Radical : </strong>Barely possible because they require transformation of human instincts.</p><blockquote>Examples: Stateless communism, anarchism, spiritual anarchies, Kabir’s idea of Begumpura.</blockquote><p><strong>Moderate Utopias</strong> — Possible with extreme alignment of values, resources, and political will.</p><blockquote>Examples: Scandinavian social democracies, cooperatives, ecological governance.</blockquote><p><strong>Possible Utopias</strong>— Achievable through political reform, only blocked by resistance from current powers. (The Particular terminology “Possible Utopias” might seem ironic but we, here, are not talking utopia in a literal sense but as a metaphor for dream to achieve)</p><blockquote>Examples: Universal basic income, healthcare access, caste census, police reform.</blockquote><p><em>So you might be thinking that why does this classification not available elsewhere and what is even the need of above classification, so answer to the former query is very simple, the above classification lacks any presence on internet because I articulated it for my understanding and theory building.</em></p><p><em>And it is very needful to classify it in such a way because this typology helps us distinguish between what is utopic due to lack of power, and what is utopic because it defies human psychological patterns</em>.</p><p>“I earlier said that every idea is utopic only because it lacks the backing of power.” But as 1 out of classified three -Radical Utopia- <strong>directly challenge deep human instincts</strong> like greed, ego, desire for control. Maybe they aren’t just ‘unrealised due to powerlessness’ — maybe they’re utopic because they go <em>against human nature itself, it challenges human psycological patterns.”</em></p><blockquote>One can argue that Yes, there are instincts: greed, ego, lust but they do not operate in vacuum as human history shows <em>transformation is possible</em>- slow, generational, painful- but possible. People once believed that Women can’t vote (now they can), Caste is divinely sanctioned (now it’s legally abolished, though socially alive), Slavery is normal (now it’s criminalised), LGBTQ+ rights are unnatural (now they’re protected in many countries).</blockquote><p><em>But if we observe the above argument, it clearly shows a pattern that these are either cultural, social, political or economic practices, which we can affect with use of Power(Authority + Legitimacy), that is what happened, and thus it can be said to be in the other two classifications -Moderate and Possible.</em></p><p><em>But the Ideas under the Radical Utopia such as Stateless communism, Gandhian swaraj without violence or central power, Kabir’s Begumpura (a society without grief, class, pain, hierarchy), Absolute anarchism or voluntary collectives — challenges the very idea of human nature, psychology, neuroscience and evolution — </em><strong><em>Greed</em></strong><em> (accumulation of resources), </em><strong><em>Power-lust</em></strong><em> (domination or status over others), </em><strong><em>Anger and Violence</em></strong><em> (territorial or emotional reactions), </em><strong><em>Lust</em></strong><em> (biological drive for reproduction or pleasure), </em><strong><em>Comparison/Jealousy</em></strong><em> (evolutionary tool for survival advantage). These are not just cultural. These are tied to </em><strong><em>Evolutionary biology</em></strong><em> and </em><strong><em>Neurochemistry</em></strong><em> (dopamine, testosterone, cortisol).</em></p><p>Some <em>major thinkers</em> <em>like Buddha, Gandhi, Rousseau were of thought that these very instincts of human nature can be reshaped or transformed- for good</em>. But here’s the question arises: were they of thought that such a large population of the world can be shifted from their natural instincts and most importantly neurochemical workings of brain? Does this not seems to be Unrealistic. Can they answer the questions arises from the inquiry of human nature by Hobbes, Machiavelli or Nietzche? From an evolutionary perspective, instincts like greed, aggression, and competition were crucial for survival in resource-scarce environments. Evolutionary biologists argue that such behaviours were selected over generations because they increased reproductive success. Neuroscientific research also shows that brain systems responsible for reward, dominance, and fear are deeply embedded in our neurobiology. While culture and education can influence behaviour, the biological roots of many human impulses are difficult to fully extinguish.</p><p>There are some challenges to Radical Utopians:</p><p>Human instincts</p><p>Societal norms can change faster than psychology.</p><p>8 billion minds can’t be purified like a hard drive.</p><p>Radical utopias that ignore human psychology often turn totalitarian.</p><p>Now if I look at both Moderate and Possible utopias, I see that these are not fantasies like communism or anarchism. Moderate utopias are those rare dreams that can work, but only if everyone agrees on the basics like public good, fairness, collective benefit, which, let’s be honest, is rare in a world full of egos and self-interest. It’s like a fragile glass- workable, but one political shock or greedy leader and it breaks. And Possible utopias? These are reforms like free healthcare or basic income that we already <em>can</em> do — we have the tech, we have the money — but still they are blocked. Not because they’re too ideal, but because they threaten the few who enjoy the current mess. So these aren’t utopias because they’re impossible — they’re utopias because the powerful don’t want them to be real. That’s the tragedy. Which redirects us to our main argument that Ideas of the Ruling class are the Ruling ideas.</p><p><strong>SENSIBLE SOLUTION</strong></p><p>The solution is to design systems that are realistic about human flaws,<br> but encourage their better expression — through education, environment, and slow cultural evolution. channelising human instincts into collective growth. We should not forget that Politics and Political Science exists because there are many questions and conflicts in political, social, cultural and economic arena, If we ignore the basic understanding of Human behaviour, Neurochemical workings in the brain or Natural Traits &amp; instincts in humans and just run over to achieve a society without considering above mentioned flaws, it will turned out to be either Totalitarian or Destructive.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fa004c3d0f69" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is this not terrorism too ?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Ninety92000/is-this-not-terrorism-too-37ff549ded47?source=rss-08d192ef8aff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/37ff549ded47</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[terrorism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[violence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ninety9]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 23 Apr 2025 19:12:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-24T08:20:24.057Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/679/1*ZBW9zKxsJisanzGyToPJHQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>People are talking about the #PahalgamTerroristAttack — everyone is posting statuses and stories. Condemning an act of violence is important. But let’s pause and ask: what do we really mean by terrorism?<br>By basic definition, terrorism is the use of violence to create fear and control, often guided by extremist ideologies. So yes, condemning the Pahalgam attack is necessary. But what about the violence that is normalized in our everyday lives in India?<br>Dalits are burnt alive. So called upper caste urinates on their face, Women are raped and killed as if they are not human beings, but objects. Rapists are garlanded. Saffron-scarf mobs beat up minorities in broad daylight, and the state remains silent. What do we call this? We all know since 2014 the RSS backed saffron mobs lynchings got normal, they can beat anyone, The so called Buldozer Baba, buldozing the homes of poor.. is this not the act of creating fear and terror, is the Sangh backed BJP not promoting State sponsored terrorism ??</p><p>Thousands of years of caste oppression. Vandalizing homes and studios because someone spoke against the ideology. Threats to speech and freedom. Using religion to divide. Turning the state itself intolerant. Isn’t this also violence? Doesn’t it also create fear?<br>Is it only called terrorism when there is a bomb blast or a mass killing, Massacre? <br>What about the day-to-day lynchings of Muslims, assaulting a dalit or a women for entering temples or drinking water from common sources? the stoning of Dalit youth, the silencing of women journalists? Isn’t that terror too?</p><p>Media covering that PM cut short his foreign visit and came back to India midnight. But for what ? To visit the family of victims on a red carpet? For giving election speeches in Bihar? Where was Mr. Modi when Manipur was burning? Does any BJPian or any mainstream media channel covered manipur violence? it was one of the biggest terror situations and biggest failure of Law and order.. where was P.M. ?<br>How many people posts these things? Why only a large scale Massacre is considered as an act of terrorism but not the daily life of structural terrorism and state sponsored terrorism? , Why people only feel sad for maximum of 2–3 days and then forget as nothing happened? why people of this country have such double standards?<br>I have so much points that no one can even come to my range in argument, and debate, neither sanghi university professors nor any of my relatives but i choose to stay quiet because i feel and see that most of the people near me are just party or religion workers, they do not see a Nation -- India. my silence doesn’t mean i have nothing to say but i left speech less after seeing their level of stupidity and their uncultivated mind. They do not see that everyone is trying to divide us to rule accordingly. To those, i recommend a book to read -- The pedagogy of oppressed. No one is literally talking of India, everyone is trying to set a Meta Narrative.</p><p>I please every reader who reads my article -- please develop a rational mindset, develop a scientific temper, condemn each and every act of terror, don’t just put status when a Massacre happens.</p><p>If terrorism is about creating fear and controlling lives — then why is everyday structural violence invisible? If terrorism is the act of spreading fear and suppressing lives, then why is our daily casteism, patriarchy, religious hate, and police silence not called terrorism? Why is structural violence still invisible to us?</p><p>reference:</p><p><a href="https://x.com/ambedkariteIND/status/1912002328397308389?t=TKAhHpVYoHOWAtZV1FeLRg&amp;s=19">https://x.com/ambedkariteIND/status/1912002328397308389?t=TKAhHpVYoHOWAtZV1FeLRg&amp;s=19</a></p><p><a href="https://x.com/RoshanKrRaii/status/1914752859167707341?t=THtQG5-_YlAyO1Oj5-4g5A&amp;s=09">https://x.com/RoshanKrRaii/status/1914752859167707341?t=THtQG5-_YlAyO1Oj5-4g5A&amp;s=09</a></p><p><a href="https://x.com/bole_bharat/status/1914954979489829341?t=tUu-cBLKIONGYdfJU0EJoA&amp;s=09">https://x.com/bole_bharat/status/1914954979489829341?t=tUu-cBLKIONGYdfJU0EJoA&amp;s=09</a></p><p><a href="https://x.com/mshahi0024/status/1915043730341716187?t=c6GVouRhjjf8AhEOQGlVzw&amp;s=09">https://x.com/mshahi0024/status/1915043730341716187?t=c6GVouRhjjf8AhEOQGlVzw&amp;s=09</a></p><p><a href="https://x.com/SidKeVichaar/status/1914767414845399229?t=h4IXDj1rVkt8Kg6Q0Q3ncQ&amp;s=09">https://x.com/SidKeVichaar/status/1914767414845399229?t=h4IXDj1rVkt8Kg6Q0Q3ncQ&amp;s=09</a></p><p><a href="https://x.com/RoshanKrRaii/status/1914934811141308432?t=fVPsf1cDlNgruQBH_laNRg&amp;s=09">https://x.com/RoshanKrRaii/status/1914934811141308432?t=fVPsf1cDlNgruQBH_laNRg&amp;s=09</a></p><p><a href="https://x.com/CaptainGzb/status/1914921419265421567?t=Nff-nemyfMiYOwBQu-vwlA&amp;s=09">https://x.com/CaptainGzb/status/1914921419265421567?t=Nff-nemyfMiYOwBQu-vwlA&amp;s=09</a></p><p><a href="https://x.com/Highonchoorma/status/1915085018948628873?t=hlc06d64sZEnxdAqV4NVBA&amp;s=09">https://x.com/Highonchoorma/status/1915085018948628873?t=hlc06d64sZEnxdAqV4NVBA&amp;s=09</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=37ff549ded47" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Restlessness: Thoughts Of A Political Prisoner In A Free Nation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Ninety92000/restlessness-thoughts-of-a-political-prisoner-in-a-free-nation-035108360247?source=rss-08d192ef8aff------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/035108360247</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[youth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fascism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ninety9]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 Apr 2025 20:08:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-08T10:18:54.109Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/683/1*ACpFQ_0J9jDB9DGVY03ZOQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>A balcony in my sister’s house, surrounded by saffronized fascist views and uncultivated minds.</p><p>It’s Birthday of my sister’s son. I didn’t came here to write. I came to breathe—to distract myself from the suffocation of truth in a room filled with people who’ve mistaken propaganda for patriotism, and I had hoped that perhaps, just for today, I could set aside the questions. That maybe, for once, I wouldn’t be provoked by relatives who casually joke about violence, who speak of executions as if it’s just politics, who chant slogans while knowing nothing about their history, their religion, or their own humanity. But here I am. Alone. Standing in a balcony. And the questions won’t leave me.</p><p>What happens when you live in a country where asking a question is a crime, where dissent is treason, where criticism of the ruling power is met with jail, ED, CBI, or a lynch mob in saffron scarves? What happens when your classrooms are silent, your professors complicit, your media obedient, your judiciary politicized, and your society hypnotized?</p><p>You get fascism. Not declared. Not marching with swastikas. But quiet, casual, disguised as cultural pride. You get a nation where speaking truth feels like betrayal. You get the India I see today.</p><p>I have read the history. I have studied fascism—not as a chapter, but as a warning. Watched the Nuremberg Trials, read Laurence Rees, Hannah Arendt, Gramsci, Orwell and traced the arc from nationalism to genocide. The line is never straight. It always starts with slogans. With the glorification of the leader. With the silencing of artists. The criminalization of critics. The creation of an enemy within. With turning Ram into a warrior instead of a seeker. And when I draw side-by-side comparisons—between Hitler’s Germany and Modi’s India, between Mussolini’s Blackshirts and the goons in orange today—I don’t even need to label the columns. People can’t tell the difference. That’s how close we’ve come.</p><p>Hindutva is not Hinduism. Let that be said loudly and clearly. Hinduism, the real one, is a flowing river of ideas, inquiry, pluralism, philosophy. It&#39;s the calm of the Upanishads, the rebellion of the Bhakti poets, the tolerance of Ashok, the curiousity of the Geeta. It is not chants used to drown screams. It is not slogans shouted before a mob rape. It is not hate painted in saffron. Hindutva is Savarkar’s rage, not Shankara’s wisdom. It is a political project of control, not a spiritual journey of truth. And when you tie your politics to your gods, when your nationalism demands obedience and not love—you are not defending dharma. You are destroying it.</p><p>I know I am alone. My classmates do not speak. My professors nod at the power &amp; speaks the words of establishment. My relatives mock me, call me naive, overthinking, or worse—anti-national. But what is nationalism, if not caring enough to hold your nation accountable? I don’t hate my country. I mourn it. And mourning, I believe, is a political act.</p><p>So this is my manifesto—not of rage, but of reflection. I will write. I will resist. I will study more, read deeper, speak clearer. I will build a body of knowledge so sharp that no propaganda can pierce it. I will become the professor, the thinker, the tutor who teaches truth in a time of lies. I will create a curriculum of courage. I will mentor others who feel this same despair, this same burning clarity. I will not quit. I will not surrender. I will not self-destruct—because they would love that. Instead, I will become more dangerous: an educated voice, calm and precise. And if tonight, I stand in a lonely balcony—so be it. History always begins in places like this. Because one day, someone will read this diary. And they will know that even in the darkest moment of Indian democracy, someone was watching. Someone was writing. Someone remembered.</p><p>And that, perhaps, will be the beginning of something better.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/458/1*L1gZgQTYIyX2AF5XvxolEg.jpeg" /></figure><p>A Letter to the Darkness: Today, alone, standing in a balcony, party is going on inside, Feeling surrounded with provoking fascist voices.</p><p>You can surround me with noise, but you cannot silence my clarity.<br>You can gather around me with saffron chants, but you cannot touch the sacred fire of my Questions.</p><p>You wear the mask of nationalism, but I see the fear in your eyes— fear of the student who reads, of the thinker who resists, of the poet who refuses to rhyme with lies.</p><p>You have done to my Hinduism, what ISIS did to Islam long ago.</p><p>You have broken the, social fabric and the very emotional, cultural bond of diversed communities in india and converted it into communal hatred, hate mongering, violence, and what not.</p><p>You have taken temples and turned them into fortresses.<br>You have taken gods and turned them into swords.<br>But you will never understand, that real dharma does not need a trishul to stand tall.<br>It needs courage.<br>It needs truth.<br>And yes, it needs people like me— lonely in balconies, broken but burning with clarity.</p><p>You called me anti-national. But I am the nation.<br>Not the border, not the flag, not the state—<br>but the soul that asks, the voice that critiques,<br>the hand that writes, even when trembling.</p><p>You say I am alone.<br>Yes. Just like Bhagat was, Just like Galileo was, Just like every torchbearer is in the beginning— surrounded by people laughing at the fire because they have never seen the sun. But make no mistake— my silence tonight is not surrender. It is the calm before the pen begins to write. It is the moment the idea takes root in the soil of suffering.<br>It is the breath before a thousand essays, protests, poems bloom. So go ahead— Mock me. Misunderstand me. Call me or other voices names in WhatsApp forwards and TV debates.</p><p>But know this tha, every time you chant &quot;Jai Shree Ram&quot; with blood on your hands, you do not win. You betray Ram. You betray India. You betray humanity. And I will not let you do it quietly. I am the resistance born in silence. I am the last question in a hall of empty answers. I am the student who reads Savarkar and sees Mussolini. I am the Indian who believes patriotism means holding power accountable. Tonight, I am in a balcony. Tomorrow, I will be in books, in classrooms, in conversations, in the trembling hearts of those who begin to see.</p><p>This is not my end. This is my beginning.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=035108360247" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>