<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Bruno Dias on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Bruno Dias on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@NotBrunoAgain?source=rss-84ce589de753------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 11:31:29 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@NotBrunoAgain/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Anatomy of a Bad Take]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@NotBrunoAgain/anatomy-of-a-bad-take-a7c7abdc4e57?source=rss-84ce589de753------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a7c7abdc4e57</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-of-thrones]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[right-wing-nonsense]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bad-takes]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bruno Dias]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 13 Jul 2017 03:24:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-07-13T03:24:15.473Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4zsmWG4f-BwQubXLDfTQDw.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Let’s dissect a piece of malicious clickbait and see how it ticks</h4><h4>1. The Dias Scale of Bad Take Intensity</h4><p>This is the Dias Scale of Bad Take Intensity, a model for categorizing bad takes by the depth of their badness.</p><p>A <strong>Category 1</strong> bad take is an error in judgement. It’s an argument that’s not quite airtight, a column that misses some key facts, an opinion that’s not quite calibrated to reality. We all have our personal blindspots and bugbears; we all have some Cat-1s in us, and the only thing really standing between me and publishing one is that I’m fortunate to work with exceptional editors. There but for the grace of God go I.</p><p>A <strong>Category 2 </strong>bad take is an error in judgement so grave it reflects poorly on the writer. It leaves the reader to wonder, awestruck, at how the author functions in the world with such a dramatic misapprehension of it. For some writers, a Cat-2 would be a career-terminating mistake. For guys like David Brooks, a Cat-2 is Tuesday.</p><p>A <strong>Category 3 </strong>bad take is an error in judgement that reflects poorly on the publication and its editors, maybe even more so than the author. Cat-3s are weak thinking allied to malicious sensationalism. A Cat-3 isn’t trying to make a good argument and failing; it’s trying to make a bad argument to see how many hate-clicks you can get.</p><p>A Cat-1 needed more time in the oven. A Cat-2 needed severe rewrites, or should have been rejected. A Cat-3 should never have been pitched.</p><h4>2. That Fucking Game of Thrones Column</h4><p><a href="https://theweek.com/articles/710374/game-thrones-bad--bad">That Fucking Game of Thrones Column</a>, TFGoTC or “tah-fuggahthuck” for short, is a gods damned Category III if I have ever seen one.</p><p>Now, obviously, this piece is written to elicit hate and rage from readers and thus give The Week a flood of attention from people who don’t read The Week. That’s a pretty trite point to make, blah blah blah, don’t read the take if it’s bad, we all know the drill.</p><p>But I thought it would be instructive to analyze <em>how</em> it does that; there’s a calculation at work here that’s frankly pretty despicable. So let’s open this sucker up and get our hands dirty.</p><blockquote><em>Game of Thrones</em> is unquestionably the most acclaimed and beloved show on television.</blockquote><p>Here we see the first clear indication that this is a Category 3 Bad Take. Any decent line editor doing their job would have nuked this statement from orbit. It’s just not true that Game of Thrones is “unquestionably” the most acclaimed and beloved show on television. In raw viewership numbers, Netflix original content and CBS procedurals do better. In terms of critical acclaim, there is a litany of other shows that are similarly well-regarded. It’s a premium cable show that does exceptionally well by the standards of premium cable, and which critics generally like. But writing something measured like that doesn’t tee up the bad take.</p><p>This may seen like nitpicking, but for me it really highlights a bad habit that people develop in culture writing: puffing up the importance of what you’re writing about before writing about it. This is a bad look especially when writing about things that <em>are</em> big and influential, like Game of Thrones. You don’t <em>need</em> to exaggerate here, but you still did. Things don’t have to be important to be worth writing about; a lot of the best writing about games out there is about games that didn’t really find an audience and weren’t all that influential. But if you have nothing really to say about something, making it seem like it’s the mainline of the monoculture will inflate the apparent importance and validity of your nonargument:</p><blockquote>What does it say about our culture and the state of the souls of millions who participate in it that anyone could find any of this even mildly diverting[…]?</blockquote><p>You see how the earlier false statement — Game of Thrones is the most important television show — feeds into the later argument about how its content is reflected in the entire culture.</p><blockquote>Two decades ago, watching it would have gotten you shoved into a locker.</blockquote><blockquote>They met, by their own admission, while playing a <em>Lord of the Rings</em>-based roleplaying game on the internet. Imagine that!</blockquote><blockquote>Popular culture in the English-speaking world is in the grips of a downward nerd-driven death spiral.</blockquote><blockquote>The average video game player is more than 30 years old.</blockquote><p>This is where it gets truly bad. “It’s a sign of our moral degeneration that <em>Game of Thrones</em> aren’t shoved into lockers.” Having a relationship that started in an online game is shameful or laughable. Playing video games past the age of 30 is pathetic. Those are transparently bad ideas, notions that have no real currency in the culture any more.</p><p>Nerds aren’t oppressed! There is no vast injustice against people who like <em>Warhammer 40K</em> miniatures, there is no systemic discrimination against <em>Magic: the Gathering</em> players. What <em>does</em> exist, though, is a contingent of men with little perspective and bad judgement who <em>do </em>think that they are oppressed for their hobbies and media taste, and those guys have been making gaming, comics, and other related pursuits unpleasant for the rest of us for a long time. By embodying the bugbear of the elitist nerdophobe, the author is tapping into that deep well of resentment to get attention, and in turn, feeding on how that resentment harms actual people trying to exist in those spaces. That’s pretty bad.</p><p>But more importantly: The thrust of his argument is that “nerd culture” has infected and overtaken the mainstream, consumed it. At the same time, the only language he has for the people who participate in that culture is that of condescending disparagement: nerds are weak, pathetic, laughable.</p><p>So the thing to understand about this dissonance, first of all, is that the author (Matthew Walther) is a rightwing hack.</p><p>I went and got the receipts. He also writes for the National Review, a publication so revolting they were publishing pro-apartheid screeds <a href="http://www.nationalreview.com/article/398136/end-south-africa-josh-gelernter">in 2015</a>. He’s also worked as an editor on the American Spectator, a rabidly conservative Catholic outlet. There, Walther wrote and published a 2014 piece about Chelsea Manning that is so vile in its aggressive transphobia that I won’t link to it.</p><p>What clued me in at first was that he’s deploying a standard tactic of rightwing discourse: liberals are weak, stupid, and fragile cowards, and they’re also an all-consuming conspiracy that is taking over the culture and threatens Western Civilization; <em>cf</em> how condescending “safe space” and “snowflake” discourse can coexist with rabid calls to buy guns and defend western civilization from islamo-antifa fifth columnists. Nerds are a novel target for this trick, but it dates back to the fascistic rhetorical antecedents of American movement conservatism.</p><p>And, of course, Walther’s empty moralizing is transparently hypocritical in view of his past writing; he’s willing to go and attack a real person in a way that generates real harm, but now he’s here clutching his pearls at a television show.</p><blockquote>There is a deeper sense in which the old problems that were the hallmark of realist fiction and drama — <strong>the old stand-bys of morals, manners, marriage, and money</strong> — are simply not interesting to people who are not emotionally mature enough to engage with them.</blockquote><p>Emphasis mine. This is a fantastically stupid sentence, because Game of Thrones is about morals; questions of morality, and the value of morality in a world where the structures don’t support morality, are central to the show. This doesn’t mean that it’s well-executed, but it’s absolutely operating in a thematic tradition with long antecedents in Western fiction.</p><p>Walther is again making a badly thought out argument that conflates the fantastical with the frivolous; Game of Thrones has dragons in it, so it can’t possibly have anything to say about conventionally important dramatic themes. This same standard would rule out a bunch of Shakespeare plays, the Iliad, and Animal Farm too.</p><p>I could go on, but here’s the thing: Game of Thrones isn’t necessarily good. There are points to be made about how Game of Thrones’ depictions of sex, violence, and particularly sexual violence are exploitative. There are a myriad criticisms to make. That Game of Thrones is good, or even defensible, is not a hill I plan to die on.</p><p>What makes this bad take a bad take, then, is not the general thrust of its ideas but the tactics that it deploys in supporting those ideas.</p><p>You start out by exaggerating the import of what you’re writing. A typical culture writer has restraint, sometimes even timidity; you are careful not to overstate your case, not to make a grand sweeping argument about the culture as a whole, or even about a genre or medium as a whole. Because those big sweeping arguments end up with holes you could drive a semi through. Writing a grandiose piece like that demands research, care, and the attention of a great editor. The hack, on the other hand, writes a narrow and obtuse piece and then starts it out by grossly overstating how much its subject matters.</p><p>Then, you insult your own audience. Who’s gonna click on a headline titled “Game of Thrones is Bad?” Game of Thrones fans. The rest of humanity doesn’t care enough. You <em>know </em>this, and you use it to your advantage. It’s not enough to criticize a thing: You have to make it known that the people who like it are dweebs and losers.</p><p>Again, notice the dissonance. Game of Thrones fans are pathetic and also they’re overtaking the culture because Game of Thrones is the most beloved and acclaimed show on television.</p><p>Those internal contradictions are key to the dubious art of the bad take. Not everyone has my particular issues; not everyone is going to sit and analyze this bad take to death. But people aren’t stupid; on a subconscious level, you can tell when something doesn’t make any real sense. And that’ll make you mad, because it’s frustrating when things don’t make sense, because it’s upsetting to get the sensation that you’re being lied to. A category 3 bad take is designed to elicit anger in the same way a horror movie is designed to elicit dread.</p><p>Arguably, the only right response is to ignore those people. When it comes to bad pop culture takes — sure, okay. But though those columns are born out of malice, it’s pretty harmless malice, and frankly, if we’re being honest, a lot of us get a perverse enjoyment out of hate-reading very stupid opinions.</p><p>The reality is that bad takes propagate not because we hate them, but because we love them. We love their stupid incoherent arguments, we love their painfully out of touch ideas, we love their ignorant affirmations. I think a cynical observer would say that it’s because it makes us feel superior. You might feel kind of foolish sometimes, but at least you’re not the guy who thinks stracciatella is the reason poor kids can’t get into college.</p><p>But I don’t think that’s it at all; I think it’s the anger itself that appeals. Bad are an invitation to catharsis. Because our frustration at a bad pop culture take can be resolved in a way that many of our day-to-day frustrations really can’t. You can Get Mad Online and explain, at length, why that guy who writes for The Week is so painfully wrong about everything. And then, having been right about something, you can have the satisfaction of righteous rage realized into action.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a7c7abdc4e57" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Videogames Are Better Without Mechanics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@NotBrunoAgain/videogames-are-better-without-mechanics-25061fa734d7?source=rss-84ce589de753------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/25061fa734d7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[retro-gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[satire]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bruno Dias]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 26 Apr 2017 03:32:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-04-26T04:16:13.289Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This is a transcript of an article that appeared originally in the November-December 1992 issue of </em>PC Prospect<em> magazine, a relatively obscure microcomputing/gaming publication that published only two years of bimonthly issues before it went bankrupt in 1993. Brian Iagos, the original author, retained the copyright and gave me permission (through a mutual friend) to resurface it now, though he refuses categorically to be contacted by anyone else or to use the internet. This piece is provided for historical interest only; all opinions expressed here are Brian’s.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/1*61CJ_w2b_BnaiqgcmF4YqQ.png" /><figcaption>The cover of the 1992 November-December issue of PC Prospect.</figcaption></figure><p>A longstanding dream: Videogames will become complex systems of interactions adding up to a complete simulation of a real (or imagined) world. The history of hobby gaming, through wargaming, miniatures games, Dungeons &amp; Dragons and its descendants, is a march towards ever increased precision in representing a world. The current version of D&amp;D, Advanced Dungeons &amp; Dragons 2nd Edition, features rules and tables to calculate the gross national income of medieval kingdoms, the growth rate of dragon hoards, the amount of time a dwarf can survive after losing a leg, or how long an archetypal adventuring party (fighter, magic user, thief, and cleric) would take to dig a trench.</p><p>Perfect simulation of the natural world, of course, is an impossible bar to reach. So instead, game designers have approached this by developing <em>game mechanics;</em> rules that when put together, form a simplistic representation of how the world works.</p><p>The early arcade game, Pong, was a representation of the real-world activity of ping pong. But the limited graphical capabilities of early Pong machines meant that you couldn’t display something that looked like a ping pong ball, let alone a paddle. The “paddles” are bars of white light; the “ball” is a dot, which is in fact rendered as a square.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*AKUxU9W-80YQKkfHyuz3OQ.png" /><figcaption>Pong (1972)</figcaption></figure><p>To properly represent ping-pong, the designers of Pong were forced to make it clear that the square dot was a ping-pong ball, by making it behave like a ping-pong ball. The ball in Pong bounces in a mechanistic approximation of how a real-world ball behaves. And so, even though it’s square and not round, and it’s a two-dimensional image on a screen instead of a three-dimensional object in physical space, the square dot becomes a ball. In other words, the earliest video games had interaction so that they could be understood.</p><p>This approach raises many questions. Is a simulation truly a simulation if its rules are simplifications of the real thing? Are videogames really simulations, when they are actually a type of electronic film? And most of all, are those simulations better than actually playing ping-pong, or actually trekking through a jungle (as opposed to playing <em>Pitfall)?</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/1*brKP6HiNmcr0Nj1UvIo1RQ.png" /><figcaption>King’s Quest III, one of the first games to use EGA graphics.</figcaption></figure><p>This early assumption, that games need interaction to represent the world, quickly became infrastructural, and was forgotten. Games continued to incorporate mechanics even though, with the advent of advances such as CGA and EGA graphics, they could now represent the world with enough fidelity to make objects, and even characters, recognizable.</p><p>Transmedia approaches, too, transformed the issue of representing reality in games: Thanks to the text parser interface, games such as <em>Zork</em> (1980) realized that they could import and incorporate literary conventions into videogames. This led to the emergence of <em>story,</em> videogames’ obvious true vocation as a medium.</p><p>Should a modern Pong still simulate the motion of a ping pong ball, given that it’s so much easier now to just draw a recognizable image of a ping pong ball? With today’s 320x200 VGA video adapters, you could even show the manufacturer’s logo on the ball!</p><p>The very idea of video game simulation implies that the player should be able to do anything in the simulated world and see wide-ranging effects of his actions. The only serious effort at all-encompassing simulation was specifically (and solely) <em>SimEarth,</em> a sophisticated environmental simulation released by Maxis in 1990.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*JhTtglgex1JISCvAeGPvtQ.png" /><figcaption>SimEarth; the only real attempt at comprehensive mechanics in games.</figcaption></figure><p>SimEarth worked remarkably well — for a videogame. But it was still easily undermined. One player, for example, chose to repeatedly hit their simulated planet with asteroids, until they got bored because life refused to develop on their planet.</p><p>Shooting games offer a solution to this problem. Instead of trying to simulate sophisticated emergent systems, the genre gives up on both, focusing exclusively on shooting enemies with a gun. <em>Wolfenstein 3D, </em>for example, is composed of nothing but shooting enemies with a gun. The payoff, if it can be called that, takes place when the player kills a mechanized version of Hitler armed with twin miniguns.</p><p>In <em>Wolfenstein 3D</em>, the game simulates bullet trajectories using a novel technique known as <em>ray-casting.</em> This allows the game to evaluate whether your shots are hitting the game’s enemies, portrayed as hordes of nazi soldiers. The game also simulates the state of the player character’s health, in a simplistic way, as a single number from 100 to 0. But it doesn’t simulate at all the player character’s morale or psychic state; there is no mechanic to simulate the trauma of mowing down dozens of enemy soldiers. Enemies, too, simply collapse when shot; there’s no mechanic for talking them down or having a discussion about the merits of Nazism as an ideology.</p><p><em>Wolfenstein 3D </em>was praised for its shooting action, which I compare to a state fair shooting gallery. Hardly anything to be ashamed of, but maybe nothing much nothing to praise, either. If the ultimate bar for visceral grip in video games is set at fairground games, then perhaps videogames will remain stuck as children’s toys even if they escape the stereotypical suburban tract home den. Other paths are possible, and perhaps the most promising ones will bypass gaming’s pointless urge towards simulation.</p><p><em>Night Trap</em>, released in October of this year, both adopts and improves upon this model of simple, direct interaction. Instead of <em>shooting</em> enemies, you <em>trap</em> them, but this is basically equivalent to the shooting in <em>Wolfenstein 3D. </em>You see an enemy (in this case, vampires known as <em>augers</em> in the game’s fiction) and then you trap it. It simplifies this methodology even further in that you don’t have to aim in order to trap enemies, demonstrating how unnecessary the aiming controls in <em>Wolfenstein 3D </em>really are.</p><p>It’s set in a mansion during a slumber party, viewed through a set of CCTV cameras; to display this setting, it uses novel FMV (full-motion video) technology.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/256/1*SMoImM0eicXF8gYRZoXbzw.gif" /><figcaption>Night Trap on the Sega CD.</figcaption></figure><p>Because of its extreme simplicity, the mechanics are good, which is uncommon for videogames. It’s an effective version of the shooter. Yet, it leaves us with a question: Why is this experience tied down by mechanics at all?</p><p>The whole way through, I found myself wondering why I couldn’t experience <em>Night Trap </em>without having to trap enemies. What if enemies automatically trapped themselves, and I could simply watch the story unfold? After all, the setting, characters, and story are what I’m really here for, and they’re what is unique to <em>video</em>games, now that the medium has advanced to incorporate FMV. Trapping enemies only gets in the way of experiencing the story.</p><p>One answer could be sports envy. The games industry has long dreamed of supplanting sports as a form of mass entertainment, leading to such fanciful notions as “electronic sports” that would be played with joysticks instead of balls. A more compelling (though still bad) answer is that by using interactivity, <em>Night Trap </em>makes the player complicit in the story. If you don’t trap a vampire in time, one of the girls having a slumber party might be attacked by them!</p><p>That is a remarkable achievement, but it’s not really an achievement of gameplay or mechanics at all. Rather, it is a novel expression of the ability to use affect combined with full motion video to tell sophisticated stories. <em>Night Trap </em>is a trap-em-up arcade game in the vein of <em>Lode Runner,</em> sure, but first and foremost it’s an electronic, multiplexing, digital, advanced form of television.</p><p>Think of a medium as the aesthetic form of common materials. Poetry aestheticizes mouth noises. Painting aestheticizes picture frames. Photography does so for celebrities. Film, for celluloid grain and Dolby Surround. Architecture, for acoustics and real estate development. Cable television, for time and coaxial cables. Sure, yes, those media can and do contain interactivity: staring at a painting, adjusting the volume on your television set. But that interactivity comes later, after the aesthetic.</p><p>What are games good for, then? Players and creators have been mistaken in thinking videogames can match the interactivity of shooting real deer in a real forest, or playing with the graphical equalizer on your stereo. Instead, games are the aesthetic form of electronic data, put to the job of representing real-world narratives and objects.</p><p>The true achievement of <em>Night Trap </em>is that it invites players to finally abandon the fantasy of simulation and systems in games, and instead replaces them with pure call-and-response interaction in a storytelling mode. Yes, you can make a game that simulates the real world, but what’s the point when the real world already exists. A greater ambition, and which games accomplish more effectively anyway, would be to use games to tell stories, supplanting films and novels as narrative media.</p><p>The wargamer’s dream of simulation is just a complication of actually doing things, and doing things has been thoroughly revealed as pointless in postmodernity. If there is a future in games, let alone a future where they are anything other than toys for children, they must embrace what they are already so good at: using full-motion video to tell stories.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=25061fa734d7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mastodon: the Obligatory Explainer]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@NotBrunoAgain/mastodon-the-obligatory-explainer-3c8a63467828?source=rss-84ce589de753------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3c8a63467828</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mastodon]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bruno Dias]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 17 Apr 2017 20:58:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-04-17T20:58:24.180Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Mastodon has been experiencing a huge spike of growth in the last few weeks; as of this writing, over 330,000 users; up from around 20,000 at the end of last year. It’s also getting a decent amount of media attention, including a <a href="https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/mastodon-is-like-twitter-without-nazis-so-why-are-we-not-using-it">great piece by Sarah Jeong</a> (full disclosure: Motherboard is operated by Vice and so is Waypoint, a website I have written for) and some not-so-great hot takes from tech journalists.</p><p>Mastodon has a <a href="https://github.com/tootsuite/documentation/blob/master/Using-Mastodon/User-guide.md">user guide</a> buried in its documentation, but it’s written more to be comprehensive than comprehensible; it also has a small explanation for new users which is very good, but by necessity short, and it doesn’t help people trying to understand the whole “instance” thing before they join. This is an attempt at putting together a shorter guide that explains some of the salient things that confuse people about the platform, and puts things into context.</p><h3>I just want to try this thing, I’ll come back for the details later</h3><p>If you’d like to just jump into Mastodon and check it out: Mastodon has different servers you can choose from; <a href="http://mastodon.social/">mastodon.social</a>, <a href="http://mastodon.cloud/">mastodon.cloud</a>, and <a href="http://octodon.social/">octodon.social</a> are three good, large ones. There you can make an account that you can use to follow people and try out the service.</p><h3>What is Mastodon, exactly?</h3><p>Mastodon refers to two things:</p><ol><li>Software that runs on a server that provides a microblogging service similar to (but distinct from) Twitter;</li><li>A community of people who use those servers as a social network.</li></ol><p>There is no single Mastodon, but rather any number of servers running Mastodon on different domains; as of this writing, nearly a thousand. For historical reasons (more on this later), Mastodon servers are usually referred to as “instances.” You can think of them as being a lot like email hosts.</p><p>Like with email hosts, users of a Mastodon server aren’t restricted to talking with users on their own instance. I have an old personal email address on gmail.com, and a newer email address on a domain I own, voyageur.space; both can send and receive email to any email address anywhere on the internet. Similarly, Mastodon users can share posts and follow users on other Mastodon servers.</p><p>Also like email, your Mastodon client (your web browser or a mobile app — more on those later) isn’t talking directly to any server other than your own instance; the instances propagate posts and events among themselves, sending and receiving on behalf of their users. This concept is what is known as <em>federation. </em>When I make a post from my account on mastodon.social, that server sends it out to everyone else on mastodon.social that follows me; but it also sends it out to other instances that “follow” me because one of their users does.</p><p>Mastodon is open-source software; anyone can install it on their own server and run their own instance, whether that’s just for themselves and their friends, or for whoever wants to join. Similar to email, Mastodon accounts are named in a @user@host.tld format; for instance, I am @brunodias@mastodon.social; the initial @ distinguishes it from an email address. But users on the same instance can refer to each other by just their usernames, so you can mention me on mastodon.social by just using “@brunodias.”</p><p>The universe of servers talking to each other is collectively known as “the federation” or (again, for historical reasons) “the fediverse.” Despite what that terminology might imply, there is no centralized control of the federation; servers are totally independent from one another, and relationships between them are one-to-one, without some kind of central broker between them. It’s really more of a <em>confederation</em>.</p><p>mastodon.social, specifically, is the “flagship” instance operated by Eugen “Gargron” Rochko, who is also Mastodon’s primary (but not sole) developer.</p><h3>Why would I want to be on it?</h3><p>Depending on your social circle, you might already be getting dragged on Mastodon by your friends for not being on Mastodon.</p><p>More probably, you might be sick of Twitter’s constant tampering with the user interface, their shady use of algorithms to drive “engagement”, the sheer volume of advertising (I just scrolled down the last 20 minutes of activity on my Twitter feed, and Twitter inserted five ads into it), and the presence of fascists, harassers, and other asswipes on their service.</p><p>On a software level, Mastodon has:</p><ul><li>Per-post privacy options;</li><li>500 characters per post, instead of a measly 140;</li><li>A built-in content warning feature that lets users hide post contents behind a “see more” button;</li><li>A public timeline of posts, which can be useful to discover users worth following or just to see cool shit;</li><li>Decentralization.</li></ul><p>That last point is important: different Mastodon servers can act as independent, autonomous communities with their own rules, which can be responsive to user needs. Problem users can be banned; if they’re on another instance, their posts can be blocked. If an entire instance of bad users crops up, other instances can “defederate” (block) it. Instances that are particularly concerned about user safety or creating a certain experience can work on a whitelist model, federating only with selected other instances.</p><p>And beyond the safety/privacy implications of decentralization, separate instances can also develop independent user cultures. You may find that the general vibe and habits in a particular instance suit you better; I like being in the big center-of-the-universe mastodon.social instance, but other users have a much better experience on smaller instances.</p><p>But Mastodon is more than the software; mastodon.social, and many other instances, were basically populated by some mix of furries, queer people, and radical leftists. Instances have since then popped up to serve various different communities and groups. In a lot of ways, Mastodon is less about mapping your existing social life onto an online space, and more about engaging with a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_place">third place</a>.</p><h3>How do I get on it?</h3><p>Back when Mastodon was young, and mastodon.social had but 10,000 users, most people got on Mastodon by joining mastodon.social, and thus never had to think about “federation” or “instances.”</p><p>Currently, you can sometimes do exactly that: join <a href="https://mastodon.social/">mastodon.social</a> through the form on the front page of that. But as demand outstrips the server capacity of a given instance, they might close for new registrations, as mastodon.social often is. Besides that, mastodon.social is <em>huge,</em> and so the public timelines on it are not as useful/relevant as they are on other instances. Other large, popular English-language instances include <a href="https://mastodon.cloud/">mastodon.cloud</a> and <a href="https://octodon.social/">octodon.social</a></p><p>So, you can shop around instead for an instance. <a href="https://instances.mastodon.xyz/">instances.mastodon.xyz</a> provides a fairly comprehensive list of instances, and it will also give you a random sampling of available instances to choose from, prioritizing ones that have open registrations and a good stability/security record.</p><p>Alternatively, I’ve curated a non-comprehensive list of instances with English-language users with specific/interesting rules and communities, see the end of this article.</p><h3>Toots? Federated timeline? What am I looking at?</h3><p>Most everything about Mastodon’s interface is more or less self-explanatory, but a few things seem to confuse or evade notice. So here are a few notes on that.</p><h4>What the hell is a toot?</h4><p>The noise a mastodon makes. On mastodon.social and as a default on other mastodon instances, posts are known as “toots” after a suggestion by an early Patreon supporter; hence the bright blue “TOOT” button. You might think reposting someone’s toot is known as “retooting,” but it’s actually called boosting.</p><h4>The Public Timeline</h4><p>Mastodon has a public timeline, so you can see a scrolling timeline of posts by all users. This is split into two timelines: the <strong>local timeline</strong> shows all public posts from users on your instance, while the <strong>federated timeline</strong> shows all public posts your instance knows about. For the most part, the latter means people on your instance, and people who have followers on your instance. It’s not a “global view” of the entire confederation (that doesn’t exist); it’s still curated by the users on your instance, though some instances use bots that automatically follow people to populate their federated timelines.</p><p>If you don’t want your posts to appear on the public timeline, you can set them as <strong>unlisted.</strong></p><h4>Post Privacy Options</h4><p>The globe icon underneath the toot box lets you set privacy options for your post:</p><ul><li>Public toots show up on the public timeline and are visible to everyone</li><li>Unlisted toots are visible to everyone, but only your followers will get them on their home feed; they won’t show up on the public timeline</li><li>Private toots will only be seen by your followers</li><li>Direct toots will only be seen by people mentioned in them</li></ul><p>A few things to note about these: You can set your account to be private, which requires you to manually approve followers and is the main use case for private toots.</p><p>Also, please don’t take these as absolute or perfectly secure, especially if you’re on a bigger instance. Not all instances in the confederation run Mastodon (the software), and so not all of them respect privacy options in the same way; and the software is still evolving to live up to those options. You can think of those as affecting how discoverable posts are, not as a strict control on who has access to them. Please don’t treat Mastodon as a secure channel for private communication, in particular.</p><h4>Content Warnings &amp; NSFW Tagging</h4><p>Mastodon lets you tag media you include in your posts as NSFW; this will hide it behind a click-through. Most instances ask that you do this if you’re going to be posting hardcore pornography or just something that might be disturbing to some, like that gif of the guy’s head exploding from Scanners.</p><p>The <em>content warning</em> feature, available by clicking on the little “CW” icon under the toot box, essentially splits your toot into two parts: an “above-the-fold” warning and the content of the toot, which users have to click through to see. Warning about potentially disturbing or personal content is the nominal reason for this, but in reality it has many uses. People use it to setup jokes, or to hide the body of very long toots. On mastodon.social, and therefore on many other instances, there’s a social expectation that users hide toots about current events, politics, or potentially anxiety-inducing topics behind a CW. Socially this is more or less equivalent to lowering your voice so that only interested people can hear what you’re saying.</p><h4>Other Privacy &amp; Safety Features</h4><p>Mastodon doesn’t feature quote-retweeting nor keyword search.</p><p>Quote-retweeting has often been seen as a very straightforward way for assholes with a lot of twitter followers to sic their personal hate mob on someone; often, people with large followings do this <em>unintentionally. </em>Keyword search can facilitate someone going after anyone who tweets a certain word or phrase.</p><p>Does this mean it’s impossible for malicious users to use their followers as a harassment brigade, or that single-issue wonks can’t trawl through the public timeline and harass anyone talking about a certain topic? No, but the UI doesn’t go out of its way to facilitate it either.</p><p>If you include a hashtag in a toot, that will make it searchable by that hashtag; otherwise, there is no built-in search for toots. This doesn’t mean that hashtag-less toots are effectively buried; people can, and have, built third-party search engines that crawl Mastodon instances.</p><p>Mastodon is built with awareness of Twitter’s long and bloody history of harassment and consideration of these issues, but it’s not perfect and no piece of social software is ever going to be totally immune to malicious use. Being on an instance with available, friendly, and vigilant administrators helps a lot.</p><h4>Wrinkles of Federation</h4><p>Your instance doesn’t know about every single post and user in the entire confederation. This means that your federated timeline is in some way curated by the user base on your instance, and doesn’t represent the whole universe. But you can still follow users that your instance doesn’t know about by searching for their fully qualified user name (in the @user@hostname.tld format).</p><p>However, if you’re the first user on your instance to follow someone, you may not see their posts immediately as your instance works to fetch their posts and display them.</p><p>Overall, a thing to know about the confederation is that it’s a landscape, and you can’t see all points in it from the same vantage point, no matter where you stand. Power users who want to get a broader view might want to make more than one account on different instances.</p><h4>Mobile Apps</h4><p>Yes, there are mobile apps, <a href="https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/amaroq-for-mastodon/id1214116200">Amaroq</a> for iOS, and <a href="https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.keylesspalace.tusky">Tusky</a> for Android.</p><h3>Appendix A: Historical and Technical Notes for Nerds</h3><p>Mastodon is a new implementation, written in 2016, of a standard called OStatus. OStatus itself is really a pile of other Web standards which, when brought together, enable the creation of federated social media services. GNUSocial is the older, traditional implementation of that standard, which harkens back to identi.ca, a social networking service that launched in 2008 and has since migrated away from GNUSocial as its back end.</p><p>GNUSocial and Mastodon instances can talk to each other, and indeed, the confederation as it exists now is made up of both kinds of instances. GNUSocial however has a very different user culture, being populated mostly by developers and free software enthusiasts. And, of course, several GNUSocial instances are populated with members of various internet hate and fascist groups, either because those instances were set up explicitly for this purpose, or because said users set up shop and were never asked to leave. Several major Mastodon instances have now suspended those instances.</p><p>However, Mastodon currently dwarfs the old extant GNUSocial network; there are about 140 GNUSocial instances in operation, while Mastodon has nearly a thousand instances. As of this writing, in most ways that count, Mastodon <em>is</em> the confederation.</p><h3>Appendix B: A Brief and Incomplete List of Notable Instances, in No Particular Order</h3><ul><li>mastodon.social is the original, “flagship” instance, and as such much of the culture on other English-language instances (such as their code of conduct) is descended from its culture.</li><li>awoo.space is the original “whitelist model” instance; it federates only with a selected group of other instances chosen by hand.</li><li>mastodon.cloud and octodon.social are other large, English-language instances that take after mastodon.social’s general vibe.</li><li>mstdn.jp and pawoo.net are, in fact, the two largest Mastodon instances, having overtaken the flagship instance this week with a combined population of over 120,000 users; Mastodon has seen a significant influx of Japanese users. Pawoo.net is run by Pixiv, a company that is essentially the Japanese equivalent of DeviantArt but which westerners mostly know as a sort of wellspring of anime porn. Due to the occasional posting of “loli” content on there (drawn images of sexualized minors, which are legal in Japan), pawoo has been blocked by a number of large instances in the West, for legal reasons if nothing else. By now some of that has been deescalated to silencing them from the public timeline and not caching their media uploads, a feature that wasn’t available last week when pawoo.net launched.</li><li>witches.town is a French/English-language instance populated by, well, witches. Registrations open daily at 8pm, French time, for a “witching hour.”</li><li>cybre.space is like witches.town, but for hackers and cyberpunk.</li><li>oulipo.social forbids posts with that fifth Latin symbol, most common in normal Anglo writing.</li><li>dolphin.town eeeeee eeee eee eeeee e ee ee eeee.</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3c8a63467828" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[We Need to Talk About Fascism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@NotBrunoAgain/we-need-to-talk-about-fascism-ebd91c2d9772?source=rss-84ce589de753------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ebd91c2d9772</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[social-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[online-spaces]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bruno Dias]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Jan 2017 18:28:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-17T19:41:46.926Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is not a post that I want to be writing. But we have to face the fact that fascism, the genocidal 20th century ideology that preaches the elimination of “undesirables”, the destruction of civil liberties, and the annihilation of the individual, is not only still present but globally resurgent. It’s not hyperbole to call this a dire threat to human civilization. And so it behooves each and every one of us to think about how to react and resist that, as individuals and as communities, in the many roles we play throughout our lives.</p><p>This means, for me, that as someone who works on nurturing online communities, there are things that I must consider.</p><p>First, we have to acknowledge the breadth of fascism as it exists now. Trumpism is fascism, predicated as it is on erecting ethno-religious barriers to freedom of movement, citizenship, and survival. Fascist, too, are the various “nationalist” political movements cropping up elsewhere in the world: Jobbik, Ukip, the Front National, Kelly Leitch’s wing of the Canadian conservatives, and so on. Outside of party politics, we’ve seen the rise of “neoreaction” and the “alt-right”, two distinct wings of a broader movement of internet fascism; one, monarchist and elitist; the other perhaps the most dedicated participants in the fascist practice of disrupting and attacking discourse.</p><p>It’s a difficult and grey question to ask how widespread the rot is within right-wing political groupings in general, but it’s impossible to deny now the ongoing mainstreaming of fascist ideas and discourses. And this creates a severe concern for people who maintain online communities, one that is distinct from other forms of hate and extremism.</p><p><strong>Fascism isn’t merely a bad idea,</strong> that can be argued away, or which is self-evidently abhorrent. Fascism is a political praxis based on the disruption of discourse; fascists remove the possibility for debate and understanding in hopes of creating an environment of fear and mob mentality, into which their appeals to base racial fearmongering can be thrown. Nowhere is this more evident than on the internet, where the conditions of discourse already facilitate it. People have enough trouble having good faith discussions online when all people involved are actually acting in good faith.</p><p>But the key thing is, <em>fascists are not acting in good faith.</em> Bad faith is core to their ideology. Lying, dissembling, and abusing the facts are a reflexive tactic. And the reality is that modern internet fascism has its own system for backing false claims. The fascists have a whole news site (Breitbart) that cultivates a deranged view of reality. “Fake news” isn’t just spread by people on Facebook who don’t know better; fascists are happy to use any source, no matter how ridiculous, that will back their ideas. Fascists don’t participate in discourses to learn, or to teach, or even to convince others. Fascists participate in discourse to sabotage it, to destroy the possibility of discourse, because they win when everyone is operating in their world of base feelings. They accomplish this by confusing the fence-sitters and exhausting, or intimidating, their opponents.</p><p>Fascists lie constantly, almost as a reflex. Milo Yannopoulos’ reaction to having his talk cancelled at UC Davis is a pretty trivial example: He immediately took to twitter to claim that there had been people with hammers and broken windows, and that campus security at Davis couldn’t guarantee people’s safety. Said campus police was on twitter that same night to say that no, there was nobody with a hammer and no windows were broken at the protest. Fascists pepper their statements with small trivial lies because general confusion and distrust is their aim.</p><p>And, frankly, it works. Most people <em>don’t</em> expect someone to be lying near-constantly; it’s exhausting keeping up with the nonstop fabrications, and things slip through the cracks. We assume that trivial details (which invariably further the worldview the fascist is promoting) are true. If one tries to argue against the barrage of lies, one is then quickly caught in the net of having to argue every minutia of the fascist’s argument. On the internet, those arguments are often backed by articles in propaganda sites that masquerade as real news outlets. This is by design: Any argument with fascists will end in debating the validity of news.whitegenocide.info as a news source. Fascists want you to fact-check them. They want you to spew a long list of why they’re wrong, to add to the disorienting barrage of conflicting information out there. They know that only people who already trust you more than the fascist will take your fact-checking on face value; they know that people are not conditioned to assume someone is a complete liar. And, most of all, they know that creating an environment of doubt only helps them in the long run.</p><p>Fascism aims to monopolize certainty; to make the world so uncertain, constantly variable, and impossible to comprehend, that shocked bystanders will gravitate to their singular and dogmatic supply of ready-made and easily digestible truths. They prey on people’s preexisting prejudices, hoping to nurture and amplify them. Those who would oppose fascists, they attack in hopes of driving away or intimidating.</p><p>For online spaces, this creates a dire problem. Because online spaces are often primarily spaces for discourse, fascism presents a sometimes-organized threat against the very function of those spaces, on top of the threat presented by any hate or bigotry. And I do think we have an ethical obligation not to normalize or provide a platform to hateful or bigoted speech. Most people doing community leadership stuff (at least, most people worth talking to) will agree with that basic premise. Delete the bigoted comments, ban the perpetrators, move on.</p><p>Except, it gets murkier with fascists. Because fascists will not always go out and say “I’m a bigot, ban me.” They’ll often participate in what seems to be good faith. But, given what they believe, one can never actually be sure that it is good faith; and part of the job here is realizing we all have blind spots and can’t necessarily judge that all the time, or see everything that goes on. As such: Any fascist should be regarded as potentially unsafe, for the space and its users.</p><p><strong>“But my community isn’t political.”</strong> That won’t save you. If anything, it makes the problem worse. The neoreaction movement recruited heavily from online tech communities, particularly in open-source; the “alt-right” has deep ties to gaming — most of us heard of Breitbart originally through their involvement with gamergate. 4chan’s /pol/ isn’t populated with news junkies who read DC blogs; it’s populated with the denizens of its nerdy-interest boards such as /a/ and /vg/. Reddit did, at one point, get invaded with white supremacists; but the “homegrown” movement of reddit fascists is now much, much bigger.</p><p>The end result of this is that communities which aren’t about politics end up acting as recruiting grounds for fascist groups. By gleefully taking the side of abusers and attackers during gamergate, Breitbart was able to position itself, to people who were invested in that whole mess, as a source of truth.</p><p><strong>“But the free discourse!”</strong> I think a lot of people have concerns about limiting or clamping down on speech in communities they moderate or lead. But the reality with fascist discourse is that it aims to disrupt and drive off opposing discourses. It does that by sheer exhaustion, by arguing in bad faith, by harassment and attacks, by making people feel unwelcome. We have to consider the ability of those most vulnerable in this environment to participate in discourse themselves; it’s their freedom, too, at risk. And allowing fascism to dominate spaces, as it wants to do, will not help anyone who isn’t a fascist.</p><p>So… what do we do about this? I don’t have a complete prescription. Not a general solution for every community, anyway. Me? I’m likely going to be summarily banning people that I know for sure support fascist groups. I highly doubt their ability to contribute anything, and it’s my view at this point that nothing will be gained by “dialogue” with them. But it’s important to stop and confront this, and note that just because fascists have obtained a measure of power and a veneer of respectability, we don’t have to normalize them. Part of this is ass-covering, too — saying this now makes this stance clear and transparent going forward.</p><p>What is clear to me is that we need to understand and attack fascism using a different framework than the ones we’ve been using. Fascists are not low-intensity bad users that can be ignored, they’re not trolls that we can feed enough rope until they justify their own bans, and they’re not <em>just</em> harassers and abusers (though they are often both of those things). They’re something different which demands the evolution of new responses to safeguard spaces that are vulnerable to their tactics. And I believe taking explicit, forthright anti-fascist stances — with the clarity that this includes modern fascists such as Trumpists — is a necessary first step.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ebd91c2d9772" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A few things to keep in mind]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@NotBrunoAgain/a-few-things-to-keep-in-mind-c16eff4a59b?source=rss-84ce589de753------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c16eff4a59b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bruno Dias]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 Nov 2016 05:57:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-09T06:02:24.919Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’ve been rolling this post around in my head over and over for the last week or so; it’s my coping mechanism. I didn’t think I was going to have to write it.</p><p>But there’s a sort of (long, and simplified, and maybe more symbolic than true) story I keep going back to.</p><p>Sometime around 1750, the big colonial powers — Britain, France, and Spain— seemed infallible and inevitable, threatened only by each other, unassailable in their control of the world. Like Ursula K. LeGuin likes to point out, the divine right of kings seemed untouchable.</p><p>Then they all took turns losing badly in increasingly improbable-seeming wars.</p><p>Washington’s army wasn’t the ragtag bunch of plucky misfits that it gets portrayed as, necessarily, but a big contingent of it was gentleman farmers and urban professionals. Coddled guys who maybe knew how to shoot deer, but not how to be soldiers. They spent the vast majority of their campaigning running away. It took a lot of French money and guns, but they won eventually.</p><p>Toussaint Louverture’s army was made out largely of former slaves. Many of them would never have been allowed near a gun before. He was a contemporary of Napoleon. Napoleon rolled undeterred through most of western Europe, but once Haiti was out of French hands, nothing could bring it back.</p><p>Simón Bolívar led a bunch of different types of people in his several-years-long on-and-off struggle to remove modern Colombia and Venezuela from the Spanish empire. He was exiled several times, lost a couple of attempted rebellions, nearly died. Most of all he spent a lot of time on the saddle, enduring a degree of physical hardship that someone of his social class would never have been expected to.</p><p>The point of bringing all this up is not necessarily to aggrandize the flawed, limited revolutions of 200 years ago. It’s to highlight how inadequate, terrified, and unlikely the best-intentioned people in all of them must all have felt at times. A Republic in France was absurd, and then it wasn’t. Simón Bolívar was going to live a thoroughly comfortable life as a large landowner in Venezuela, and then he didn’t.</p><p>The point of all this is to say two things: First, nothing is inevitable, or impossible, until it happens. That is probably the greatest source of both fear and comfort in the world.</p><p>Second: There is never any telling where revolt, resistance, and possibilities for survival come from. Or how strong they are, what they will accomplish, and where they end up.</p><p><em>To be clear, since a lot of people are probably a little on edge right now: This is a metaphor and a parable; I’m not calling on anyone to go “grab their musket” next week. But the need to think about, and build up, structures of resistance is very real — then again, however, it has always been.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c16eff4a59b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the Difference between Being Nice and Being Kind]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@NotBrunoAgain/on-the-difference-between-being-nice-and-being-kind-21609f179995?source=rss-84ce589de753------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/21609f179995</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[social-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[commentary]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bruno Dias]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Aug 2016 17:37:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-01T18:02:32.895Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I have spend a pretty unreasonable amount of time, in my life, moderating and maintaining a handful of online spaces. I don’t claim to have been perfect at this; if anything, I am pretty ill-suited to it. But I’ve learned a few things, and I’ve been thinking a lot about one particular issue lately: Babies, you’ve got to be kind. <em>But kind is not the same thing as nice.</em></p><p>By <em>nice</em>, I mean specifically civil and agreeable; I mean a set of behavioral boundaries that apply directly to how you interact with others on a one-to-one basis. By <em>kind</em>, I mean a deeper consideration for others; I mean a regard for the feelings and context of others that can’t be reduced to simple rules of discourse or behavior. <em>Niceness</em> is a behavioral judgment. <em>Kindness</em> is an ethical one.</p><p>And this is a distinction that gets lost very easily. I used to help moderate a large space that heavily emphasized civility, and nowadays I think civility is a very weak standard to apply. Because the reality is that you can be hurtful, you can be unkind, without being uncivil. And people do this all the time, and moderation policies centered around civility have enormous trouble managing this.</p><p>And that same focus on civility makes the damage caused by unkindness invisible. In spaces with civility-oriented codes of conduct, or rulesets that consider “personal attacks” as the basic standard of bad behavior, it’s all but impossible to criticize someone for derailing, for monopolizing space, for making hurtful (but impersonal) remarks, because all criticism must be couched in the language of polite disagreement. So people tend to leave silently or breed resentment instead.</p><p>And the thorny issue is: <em>Callouts are mostly bad.</em> Criticizing someone else’s behavior has enormous costs in terms of social friction, and even though I think <em>I</em> don’t do such a thing lightly, others might, and others might not judge my own behavior as kindly. To me, this means that there is an onus on moderators to head off those kinds of situations. And the standard of civility — asking users to be nice — is insufficient to achieve this.</p><p>Because the standard of “civil discourse” is inherently one that makes it easy to talk about facts (however false) and opinions (however loathsome), but not feelings and experiences. It makes it easy to talk in dispassionate terms about distant issues and difficult to talk about things that affect one personally. In short, it is a standard of discourse that privileges the discourse of the privileged, and devalues the discourse of the aggrieved, the oppressed, and the marginalized. This is not to say that loud, unfiltered anger is right or appropriate for every space — it isn’t; but it is very easy to apply this standard of civility in a way that creates the illusion of an open forum in a place that is actually a walled garden. Often, what civility really is enforcing is the ability to perform the correct rituals and express the correct signifiers to have one’s speech viewed as polite discourse. I should note that the ability to participate on those terms, to navigate the social rules of polite discourse — born as they are out of early tech and academic communities on the internet, with their own biases and unrepresentative membership — is itself classed, gendered, racialized. English speakers often are unaware that their language has registers; and the understanding of “polite discourse” demands a specific register, a register that is more natural to some than others.</p><p>Furthermore, by being decontextualized and rigid, the standard of civility is very trivial for bad actors to game, and it is <em>constantly</em> gamed by bad actors. I have seen more users than I can count, across multiple spaces both asynchronous and real-time, that abused this system of moderation in ways that created negative outcomes, most frequently the silent exit of valuable users.</p><p>Those bad users often fit a particular mold — male, white, educated; equipped, in short, to navigate the social world of “civil discourse”. They’re armed with insufficient kindness, some nasty opinions or a tendency to derail, and a dispassionate point of view that allows them to constantly hold the implicit high ground given to the person who cares the least.</p><p>This is the classic example of civility standards being a problem, a situation that should be familiar if you’ve tried to apply that standard as a moderator: User A politely expresses an outrageous, bigoted opinion; user B reacts negatively to what they identify as an attack on their identity or humanity. When the civility standard is applied, it is applied against user B. User B got mad; user B got upset; user B made accusations (racist, bigot, transphobe, asshole). User B “lost” the rhetorical game of staying dispassionate and civil, and the cost of losing is <em>at least</em> disregard for their broader societal grievance against bigoted speech, and often also moderator sanctions.</p><p>This is exacerbated by the fact that user A can be gaming the system. They might view this interaction as scoring points against political correctness, they might view it as a refined form of trolling, they might view it as getting rid of someone they dislike or disapprove of. It’s further exacerbated by the fact that civility standards often have no concept of derailing, and as a result this interaction can crop up anywhere, turning every discussion into a potential trigger point for the pet issues or calculated attacks of malicious users. The endpoint is that aggrieved users (“user B”) will leave; sympathetic users who see this interaction will leave. It is very dangerous to apply civility standards in that way; one risks creating a “playground rule” that whoever gets mad first, loses. Creating that dynamic is like giving out candy to a certain class of troll. It gamefies bad behavior: How many people can you push into being sanctioned by moderators without being sanctioned yourself?</p><p>Civility standards are well-intentioned; they’re a good idea, perhaps. They prevent blatant and loud abuse from happening out in the open, and that’s a laudable goal. But it’s very insufficient. It weeds out blatant trolls while leaving the door open to other forms of negative behavior, and many spaces that implement those standards have an invisible list of people who have chosen to leave them instead of engage on skewed terms.</p><p>How do you move past enforcing niceness towards building kind spaces, in practice? I think we need to excise the words “civility” and “personal attack” from codes of conduct, and instead consider <em>fighting words.</em> “You’re an asshole” falls under that umbrella, but so does “respectfully, I don’t think your assertion that you’re a woman is valid” or “my understanding is that BLM protesters are often just criminals looking for excuses.” Inciting a negative situation is not just a matter of tone but of content. And incitement has to be considered when negative interactions happen.</p><p>The obvious problem, of course, is that considering content and not just tone requires one to make judgment calls based on ethical considerations. It requires that moderators go into the thicket of politics, society, and social movements and extract from them standards about what is and isn’t acceptable, what is and isn’t exclusionary, that are predicated on identifying hateful speech and not just <em>angry</em> or <em>rude</em> speech. And a lot of people are, justifiably, afraid of this. But we have to move past notions of neutrality, or ideas that there are universal standards of discourse that can be applied everywhere with positive results.</p><p>Yes, this sometimes will come down to silencing or removing people for their sincerely held political beliefs, which I am sure some of you reading this abhor. But every time the words “free speech” come up, you should scream back: For whom? Sometimes, a productive exchange of views can be had between different positions in a contentious issue. Often, it can’t. And oftentimes a dynamic arises where people in marginalized communities are frequently asked to justify themselves, their identities, and their communities in the arena of “polite discourse.” In civility-centric spaces, free speech exists for members of privileged groups who dismiss or question assertions about oppression, but not for people who are making observations about perceived oppression. The reality of our polarizing times is that you cannot amplify all voices equally; if you’re not making a conscious choice about which voices most need to be heard, then that choice is being made for you. And much like the guy holding up an “all lives matter” sign, you’re choosing in favor of the dominant social forces.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=21609f179995" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Emily is Away: A Review]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/mammon-machine-zeal/emily-is-away-a-review-4e609247ca91?source=rss-84ce589de753------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4e609247ca91</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bruno Dias]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2015 18:23:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-11-20T18:23:51.858Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>[This essay was funded through Patreon under the ZEAL project. ZEAL aims to provide high quality criticism of rarely discussed games and comics, and showcase the talents of exciting new writers and artists. For details and information on how to donate, please check out our </em><a href="http://patreon.com/mammonmachine"><em>Patreon</em></a><em>!]</em></p><p><a href="http://kyleseeley23.itch.io/emilyisaway"><em>Emily is Away</em></a> (Kyle Seeley) is a former entry in the 2015 Interactive Fiction Competition, a simple choice-based narrative presented through an interface that mimics AOL instant messenger circa 2002. Though I also entered a game into the competition this year, <em>Emily is Away</em>’s withdrawal means that I can write about it without a conflict of interest. This review was originally drafted in mid-October. Since that coincided with the game’s withdrawal and with some harsh feelings towards it and Seleey from the IF author community, I decided it would be best to publish it in a general gaming outlet, rather than from within the interactive fiction community; ZEAL has graciously agreed to take it off my hands.</p><p>Emily is Away has, in the intervening time, attracted some attention from the games press for its use of early-aughts imagery — so far it’s been covered on <a href="http://www.wired.com/2015/10/emily-is-away/">Wired</a> and <a href="http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2015/10/07/emily-is-away-chat-client-game/">Rock, Paper, Shotgun</a>; it recently passed through <a href="http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=530961734">Steam Greenlight</a>. But there’s a severe gap in its coverage; besides <a href="https://emshort.wordpress.com/2015/10/16/no-longer-if-comp-2015-emily-is-away/">Emily Short</a>, nobody has taken the game’s actual content to task for what it contains.</p><p>This article contains spoilers; I don’t recommend playing the game in a real sense, but you may want to do so (it’s fairly short) for the sake of context. Reading Emily Short’s review will also give you a quick summary of what I am responding to here.</p><p><em>Emily is Away</em> is, structurally, a very simple multiple-choice story with delayed branching in the <a href="https://www.choiceofgames.com/">Choice of Games</a> mould, though it’s much smaller and less sophisticated than those games are. Its main distinguishing feature is the UI design: it’s a mostly faithful recreation of a Windows XP machine running AOL Instant Messenger. The entire story is told through several IM conversations between the viewpoint character and Emily, his high school friend and crush. The game, in fact, goes as far as requiring the player to mash their keyboard to mimic typing whichever dialogue option they chose.</p><p>(You can choose the name of the protagonist, and so theoretically their gender, but <em>Emily is Away</em> really isn’t written to encompass the possibility of a queer relationship; a lot of squinting is required to read it as anything but the story of a boy’s crush on a girl.)</p><p>On this overarching UI gimmick, I have to make two remarks. The first is that my reaction here is not so much the intended sense of nostalgia but rather a sort of protracted full-body cringe, which will soon be compounded by the actual contents of the piece. I have, at best, an ambiguous relationship with the past; at worst, a downright unpleasant one. Until my recent let’s-see-what-the-fuss-is-all-about moment, I actively avoided <em>Emily is Away</em> because the aughts are not a time I’m very interested in revisiting.</p><p>The second remark is that I’m immediately struck by one thing that the various reviews didn’t highlight — the game is rendered in a low-res, pixel art style, rather than the straightforward reconstruction of a Windows XP desktop that I had somehow assumed.</p><p>Pixel art, of course, has become the game equivalent of soft focus, a rosy tint seemingly meant to suggest: weren’t things simpler then? In this, it has become at times uncomfortable — think of <em>Spelunky</em>’s helpless buxom girls meant to be carried around like a robbed cultural artefact by the player character, one stroke of low-resolution imagery single-handedly airbrushing away both patriarchy and colonialism.</p><p>And of course: No, things weren’t simpler, let alone better, in the past. I can’t dissociate from the fact that this game is, in a small way, romanticizing an era where so many of the seeds of our presently damaged world were being planted, nor can I ignore my own half-lost recollections of that time. Maybe this is all a matter of execution; maybe I could have bought into a better-designed romantic vision of the past — I surely enjoyed <em>Gone Home</em> more than my fair share — but I didn’t. So instead I look at a blocky rendition of the <em>Kill Bill</em> logo and rattle unpleasantly on my chair, trying to squirm away from this game.</p><p>I’m a few years too young to be exactly the generation that this is laser-targeted at, but I still felt more pandered to than anything. This is not to say it’s a cloying paean to the era it’s depicting. If anything, that might have been preferable to what we actually get: a game about the early aughts with no point of view on that time at all. It doesn’t have the warmth and awareness that <em>Gone Home</em> had about its own nostalgia trip. In many ways, it doesn’t have anything in particular to <em>say </em>about the era; I could just as well have been mashing my keyboard into a pixel-art imitation of Facebook messaging, and not much would change.</p><p>Compare <em>Emily is Away</em> to <a href="http://nomediakings.org/games/guilded-youth-a-text-game-with-ascii-animation.html"><em>Guilded Youth</em></a>, Jim Munroe’s touching recreation of BBS culture. <em>Guilded Youth</em> has actual writing in it; actual characters that have actual voices: ways of thinking and talking and acting, in and out of a BBS. It speaks to people like me who have never come close to a BBS, in a way that <em>Emily is Away</em> will never speak to people who weren’t using AIM around 2002. While I don’t want to invalidate <em>Emily is Away</em>’s use of UI design to tell a story, I do think that there’s just not enough depth to the story it’s telling.</p><p>Ultimately, I don’t think the period trappings <em>matter</em> a whole lot to this piece, which is a clever turn from the developer because they suck so much attention in on themselves that they distract from the severe problems with the writing and story.</p><p><em>Emily is Away</em> suffers from the fact that nobody in it has much in the way of a personality. The two principal characters, Emily and the protagonist, are defined mostly by their relationships to others rather than by their own attitudes. At the end of the story, I would be hard pressed to make any statements about Emily — is she petty? Kind? Repressed? Open? Cheerful? Depressive? Emily is a complete cypher, which is a huge problem when the game’s entire story revolves around the player character’s crush on her. The writing doesn’t really convey emotional depth in the limiting format of instant messaging. Subtext is a luxury in <em>Emily is Away</em>; you’re lucky that the conversations have text.</p><p>If Emily and the player character are one-dimensional characters, the various tertiary characters are more like props. Emily ends up with some guy from high school — in my first playthrough, “Brad”. Brad exists only to be the Jerk to the protagonist’s Nice Guy; he has, otherwise, no identifying characteristics. We don’t know if Brad is a jock, if he has a history of bullying the protagonist, if he walked into Emily’s life on a trail of broken hearts, if he’s actually a completely decent guy whom the protagonist is just projecting onto. We don’t learn anything real about him at all, except that he and Emily seem to argue a lot, and maybe that’s an abusive relationship, or maybe that’s just our protagonist reading too much into things — and at this point I don’t really trust the game’s writing enough to think it might be trying to suggest the latter.</p><p>Similarly, the protagonist’s own college girlfriend, Emma, doesn’t have much in the way of definition. She gets all of one point of distinctive characterization: You can pick whether she’s really kind, really funny, or really hot. Which is to say: The second female character in this story is defined entirely by what a man thinks of her, and in entirely generic terms at that.</p><p>Emily herself isn’t fortunate enough to get even that much characterization. If you’ve ever had a crush, you know that crushes have <em>specificity </em>to them; that people’s feelings reflect something they appreciate in one another — or, if you’re feeling cynical, some idealised feature they imagine one another to possess. The protagonist’s feelings for Emily seems less related to who she is, or even to whom the player character imagines her to be, than to the simple fact that she is there.</p><p>Emily is not someone with enough personality that someone might have a crush on her. And simultaneously, the protagonist does not have enough personality to have a crush on someone. And so their relationship is just vacuous; it doesn’t even rise to the height of pointless teenage infatuation. The story is clearly trying for wistfulness about their unrealized feelings, but it’s hard to be wistful for something so amorphous. A lot of care is given to the details of the period, but barely any thought is given to defining these characters.</p><p>Indeed, it doesn’t seem like those characters develop at all. In the final chapter, they hardly seem different from their high school selves; only their relationship has changed. It would feel like a shaggy dog story, if it wasn’t so short: Things happened and then very little at all was learned.</p><p>And then there’s the whole slippery question of how this game treats consent.</p><p>One of the story branches results in a worrying, dubiously consensual encounter with Emily — depending on player choice, either involving alcohol or just a potentially skeevy abuse of someone’s emotional vulnerability. This is, of course, troubling; and while the story clearly acknowledges that Emily is hurt, it doesn’t really deal with the magnitude or cause of the hurt — or do much to acknowledge that, in the worst case scenario, what took place goes very far beyond “hurt feelings” and is pretty unambiguously rape.</p><p>But here’s the thing: There is no path through this game that doesn’t make me at least somewhat uncomfortable. At no point did I think the player character’s feelings were healthy. From the first conversation, he evinces a sense of entitlement and a desire to control towards Emily that is at least worrying; any man that she dates is instantly labelled a jerk and put under his scrutiny. And because of the flat, direct way the piece delivers its story, it’s hard to sense that it contains a critique of those attitudes.</p><p>It’s really hard not to see this whole thing through the lens of the toxic masculine entitlement that leads to unironic usage of terms like “the friendzone.” We’re asked to empathise with a protagonist whose only real feature is this selfsame masculine entitlement; every substantive position he has amounts to versions of the same old saw: “All those other men are terrible; I’m a Nice Guy, and not only would I be good for you, you’re obligated to choose me over them.”</p><p>And we never reach a conclusion, or a denunciation, or a critique, or some form of catharsis about this; instead, the protagonist’s controlling attitudes towards Emily are just allowed to linger on like a rancid smell over the whole thing. The pixel-art nostalgia tinge, the ham-fisted attempts at producing wistfulness, the flat delivery of every line of text in the game, the heavy (physical!) identification of the player with this loathsome player character: All give me the impression that this game is not just unaware, but tacitly supportive of this kind of masculine behaviour.</p><p>Why, then, has the reception of it by some been so positive, all but rapturous?</p><p>There’s a real disconnect in how this game is talked about. There are two components to how <em>Emily is Away</em> tells its story: The UI design, and the writing. Those two halves work in concert: One sets up the piece’s emotional environment (wistful, nostalgic) and the other supplies the narrative arc and referential content that are supposed to play on those feelings. This doesn’t <em>actually </em>work; taken out of the context of the UI, the writing is bland and vaguely creepy at best, and so it doesn’t really support those themes and ideas.</p><p>But one is privileged over the other so enormously, that it highlights a fault line in how we perceive games: Because the presentation is doing so much work to sell this feeling of nostalgia, this is taken as the overall effect and content of the piece. Reviewers seem to barely read the lines of text popping out of the fake chat window, let alone read between them.</p><p>Consistently, we privilege effect, form, and presentation over story content, when we consider story at all. “Yeah, the story is nonsense, but that’s not really the point” has become a familiar refrain, nearly a cliché, in video game reviews. In some cases, this is comical — <em>Shadow of Mordor</em> involves a billion-dollar franchise, dozens of characters, <a href="http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3330488/?ref_=fn_al_tt_2">nearly every big-name voice actor</a>. All in service of writing that barely rises to the the level of bad fanfiction. This writing is then the object of maybe half a paragraph in reviews from the mainstream press. In what other medium do we barely notice such vast gulfs between expenditure and quality of outcome? Or between resources spent and attention paid?</p><p>And what attention is paid to storytelling in games, is disproportionately paid to presentation. How much ink has been spilled trying to decide whether Kevin Spacey’s face in <em>Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare</em> is a technological achievement or a disturbing gift from the uncanny valley? How much less ink has been spilled contextualising or analysing the things that face is actually saying?</p><p>You might think: “What’s wrong with game reviewers having different priorities than you?”</p><p>I might think: But what are those priorities leaving by the wayside?</p><p>Female characters in video games are frequently just props for a man’s character arc. <em>Shadow of Mordor</em>’s murdered wife; <em>Spelunky</em>’s object in distress; <em>Braid</em>’s not-even-a-person-just-a-metaphor-for-nukes; <em>Emily is Away</em>’s blank recipient for male feelings. This point has become <em>tiresome</em> to make, given the richness of examples and the unceasing nature of the problem. But those are the exact same reasons that make it so necessary to point it out.</p><p>Our reflex is to ask: how did this make me feel? How did this present itself? What did this achieve, technologically? How do the actors come off? How do the animations look?</p><p>Our reflex is emphatically not to ask: What are the ideological underpinnings of this thing?</p><p>And on one level, I get it. Textual analysis is a violent, dangerous process, one that should not be undertaken without care, especially not alone. But stories in games keep repeating the same patterns over and over again. And those patterns are sometimes toxic. Whether mass-produced or handcrafted, big or small, pixel art or performance capture, they march out of bedrooms and media empires alike, to the drumbeat of the same refrain: “Sure, the story isn’t great, but that’s not really what it’s about.” And the number of voices willing to sit down and do the painful work of baring the ideas that ground those works is small. And the number of spaces willing to give those voices a platform is smaller yet.</p><p>It cuts both ways, too: How often do the positive reviews of <em>80 Days</em> highlight its gentle yet pointed deconstruction of colonialist narratives? We don’t take toxic ideas to task any more than we cultivate progressive voices. The fact that there are game writers who are producing real, successful efforts that challenge those ideas— from Inkle (<em>80 Days</em>), to Failbetter (<em>Sunless Sea</em>), to Fullbright (<em>Gone Home</em>), to the many IF authors who submitted games to the IF Competition but didn’t achieve the same visibility that <em>Emily is Away</em> did — hasn’t really made much of a dent in how we treat those texts.</p><p>How much of the criticism of a Bioware game is a box-checking exercise where games are graded on whether they produce the right feelings at the right time? Do you know what it took to get people to talk about the subtext of one of those games? What it took was the camera in <em>Mass Effect 2 </em>being so insistent on putting Miranda’s ass right in front of the player’s face that even the most oblivious reviewer had to take notice. Before someone analysed a text beyond simply noting what it explicitly says or giving an experiential report of what it was like to play, said text had to bash players upside the head with the male gaze. Of course that the camera’s positioning and focus is deliberate and meaningful; but for it to be looked at, it had to be used in the most crass, unsubtle way possible. I imagine that prose, to be noticed, would have to be equally loud and boorish.</p><p><em>Braid,</em> for one game, contains a significant amount of non-essential prose that it uses as its primary storytelling device. Remember those? The lines of books you had to wade through to get to the levels? Remember how many conversations revolved around that game’s mechanics? Remember how virtually no conversations at all revolved around those books, and the story they told, and the way it was yet another iteration of a woman existing just as the catalyst for a man’s emotional arc?</p><p>I can speculate on how this critical standard evolved, on the evolutionary pressures that forced it to arise — the prevalence, for a long time, of outright bad storytelling in games as the norm; the violent reactions of the audience to having things they like dissected like that. But it has a blindspot, and I don’t like the things that wriggle their way through that blindspot. Game critics love to talk about a game’s ability to transport us to another place, then disregard the ideas those places are built on. They lead us into the palace, pointing out that the doors work and the wallpaper is beautiful, failing to mention the rotting foundation.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4e609247ca91" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/mammon-machine-zeal/emily-is-away-a-review-4e609247ca91">Emily is Away: A Review</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/mammon-machine-zeal">ZEAL</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is Selfie the most regressive primetime pilot of the year?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@NotBrunoAgain/is-selfie-the-most-regressive-primetime-pilot-of-the-year-75e0c97210a0?source=rss-84ce589de753------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/75e0c97210a0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bruno Dias]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 02 Oct 2014 00:30:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-10-02T00:30:58.073Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Okay, so the clickbait title is just my personal revenge against the show’s hatred of everything related to the internet. But still, it probably is.</p><p>If you haven’t seen it, Selfie is nominally a contemporary reimagining of classic classist musical My Fair Lady. Only this time, instead of a man fixing a woman’s unfortunate case of the cockneys, it’s a man fixing a woman’s unfortunate case of the social medias.</p><p>This premise has not aged well in the least. At one point in the pilot, Eliza (Karen Gillan with an American accent and numerous dated references to the internet) walks into Henry’s (John Cho) office and tells him:</p><blockquote>“I’m Eliza, I work in sales, and it recently came to my attention that I need a man to fix me.”</blockquote><p>Only with more words and less clarity. For the first half of the pilot, this is a show that delights in demeaning its protagonist, while using her as a proxy for an entire class of people. The instigating incident of the entire plot is that Eliza finds out her new boyfriend happens to be married, and then vomits on a plane. And when her sick bag bursts all over her, this is supposed to be a deserved comeuppance for her, a moment we’re to laugh at and she is to learn from.</p><p>Rather than, you know, a woman being devastated because a man misled her. The reveal is shown by the tan line on his ring finger — ie, this bloke has taken off his wedding ring so as to not advertise that he’s married; and yet, the tone suggests that this is all her fault, and that <em>she </em>needs to come to some personal reexamination. The undercurrent of slutshaming in this scene is staggering.</p><p>The key difference between this show and the original My Fair Lady is this: Eliza is supposed to be a bad person. Her crimes involve having too much and/or the wrong kind of sex; and participating in social media. This has left her completely friendless because:</p><blockquote>Being friended is not the same as having friends.</blockquote><p>This is a verbatim quote. That’s the trenchant criticism of today’s kids and their social media-obsessed culture we’re getting. If screens had ejector seats I would have decoupled mine at that point.</p><p>For a good two-minute stretch, Karen Gillan speaks entirely in vaguely millenialesque lingo, throwing out references that are so jumbled in their time frame and point of origin that it’s unclear what kind of internet denizen Eliza is supposed to be, exactly. Is she a tween that never grew up? Is she a parody of people with insufferably dull Instagrams? Is she on 4chan?</p><blockquote>I was praying the whole company had forgotten about my epic fail. Or at least that I could make like Elsa and let it go.</blockquote><p>I have to point out those two references are <em>seven years</em> apart and come from totally different places in the culture. This is not critique from within. This is a crotchety eye turned towards a (not so young) youth culture that the writers only seem to view in glimpses. The jokes here are going to seem trite to anyone who has ever been on the internet. At one point someone remarks that Eliza Instagrams her food, which I guess is topical by the standards of network television.</p><p>For the second half of the pilot, of course, everything starts to turn around for Eliza, because a man has come into her life to tell her how to think and act. We are then properly introduced to the other two female characters in Selfie: Eliza’s neighbour Bryn (Allyn Rachel) and the receptionist at her office, Charmonique (Da’Vine Joy Randolph). Bryn puts the lie to the idea that this is a show with contempt for a character and not for a whole class of people. She is presented as the antithesis to Eliza, but is herself another tired millennial stereotype, the hipster. Similarly obsessed with trends and social media, Bryn is herself a vehicle for trite jokes. At one point, one of her feminist book club friends (Names: Thistle, Wren, Prue and Eyelet) pulls out an ukulele as part of an impromptu Lady Gaga chorus performance.</p><p>Charmonique, for her part, is a competent and empathetic black woman, and at this point, I no longer trust this show to do something with that other than what you probably already expect. Towards the end of the pilot she is there to deliver an epiphany and a high-five to Eliza.</p><p>Here’s the thing though: Selfie is a competently written show performed by some very game actors. It’s not unmitigated garbage, and that makes it so much harder to slam the show, because clearly the people behind it do believe in it and want it to be good. Gillan and Cho have real chemistry with one another, and the dialog is full of charming grace notes — when it’s not sinking into poorly made references, at least. And yet.</p><p><em>And yet.</em></p><p>It’s just so mean-spirited, and so out of touch, and so hateful in its attitudes. The target audience for Selfie seems to be made up of MRAs who long for an imagined past when people were “classy.” The mean-spiritedness of the script is not so much a product of a generational gap as a sort of fundamental crotchetyness.</p><p>The pilot for Selfie appears as a tragic misstep because it’s unwilling to evaluate the ugliness of its premise, or to offer empathy to its protagonist — until said protagonist listens to and obeys to a man’s advice, thus becoming empathy-worthy. It is downright uncomfortable to watch.</p><p>Maybe the rest of this season is about Selfie clawing its way out of its own premise to become a watchable show. But if so, it’ll do that with that albatross of a pilot hanging ‘round its neck.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=75e0c97210a0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Let’s Drop Everything and Take a Day Trip to Carcosa]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@NotBrunoAgain/lets-drop-everything-and-take-a-day-trip-to-carcosa-8aae4aefbcea?source=rss-84ce589de753------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8aae4aefbcea</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Bruno Dias]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 09 Mar 2014 04:49:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-03-09T19:45:51.096Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>True Detective, speculation, and why it isn’t (and is) about the mythology.</h4><p>Here’s what I hope will happen in the finale to True Detective: Turns out Carcosa and the Yellow King are totally for real. Hastur enters our reality from some nether realm of madness to consume everything. Marty Hart gets his sanity blasted. Rust Cohle just barely escapes with his life after using his hitherto-unmentioned Koine Greek skills to read a passage from the Necronomicon to banish the entity. The season ends as the odd couple of detectives moves back to Alaska so Rust can spend the rest of his days caring for the incapacitated Marty.</p><p>Here’s what I expect will happen: All of the people who became intimately invested in the mythology, at the expense of what the show is putting front and centre, will be sorely disappointed.</p><h3>A Brief History of Internet Speculation</h3><p>“Mythology.” Remember when Lost kept throwing stuff at the screen? Obscure references the prime time network audience wasn’t really supposed to get? Made-up places, people, and names? This is the pattern for mythology on television.</p><p>The effect is textural if anything. Shows want to suggest a wider world—often one of oddness and fantasy—without having to actually show it. It’s about building a mystique without having to spend time on the mystical. Over the last ten years, television audiences have been acclimated to this; we’ve learned to believe that weird, provocative sights are intended as coded messages directly from the showrunner’s brain. Big Pussy’s postmortem appearances on The Sopranos come to mind.</p><p>The Internet has become a petri dish for obsession. Whereas before your private, stoned speculation about a television show used to be insulated from the wider world by the limitations of the circle of people we actually interact with in our real lives, now people who have elaborate theories about fiction can find other people with similarly elaborate theories, and then rub those elaborate theories together until their misshapen babies emerge.</p><p>This was novel back in the mists of time (ie, 2004) when Lost was freshly on the air and, for the first time, a television show seemed to be mostly about the conversation going on around it on the Internet. Now it seems all but mandatory on genre shows. Backstories have to be cryptic and elaborate targets for speculation, now, presumably because Twitter buzz is the lifeblood of television ratings. Consider Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D, which felt compelled to give its everyman protagonist a cryptic backstory not just to explain why he’s running around after being stuffed into a fridge in the movie, but also to provide the limp genre series with an overarching mystery.</p><p>We have been trained, as a television audience, to treat genre shows like they’re the hook to an alternate-reality game. American Horror Story, for one thing, is so incoherent and absurd—In an enjoyable way!—that any attempt at following the plot and figuring out where the threads are going is futile, because some new thing is going to come out of left field next episode anyway. And yet, it seems designed to engender that exact type of watching, with its gimp-suited ghosts and Hogwartian wizardly powers playing the part of cryptic clue.</p><p>In a way, it reflects a curious change in the way producers and writers approach the relationship between television and audiences. The goal, now, is to be part of a conversation, to create deep engagement between viewer and programme. To keep people thinking about a television show. Now I can only speculate why this is so commonplace now —clearly, it has antecedents in in The X-Files and Twin Peaks, and older fare still such as The Prisoner. But it’s gone from being an odd, authorial point of view to being the template. And why?</p><p>Perhaps it encourages live watching. Fans of Scandal seem to enjoy the show partly because it seems created specifically to be live-tweeted. Now, Scandal isn’t about the kind of mythologising I’m talking about here, but maybe the mythologising is a competing strategy. Networks want live eyeballs; they’re better than time-delay ones. Creating some sort of deep involvement is one way of convincing viewers to actually tune in.</p><p>But that’s only really half of an explanation. It’s worth theorising about—this shift is about the Internet, and about time-delayed watching. It’s about the drive towards sprawling transmedia ‘franchises.’ It’s about viewer expectations and, perhaps initially, trying to recapture <em>Lost</em>’s lightning in a bottle (Which gave us such abortive attempts as <em>Heroes</em>—a show that NBC is ‘rebooting,’ now, in miniseries form.) It’s presumably not a singular reason that has caused this visible change in genre television across the spectrum; whatever it is, we’re living with it now.</p><h3>What in the Hell is a Carcosa, Anyway?</h3><p>Back to True Detective: Now, I’m going to assume series creator/showrunner/Nietzschean ubermensch Nic Pizzolatto isn’t outright lying to us in all his interviews. And what he says in those interviews is really the opposite of trying to be coy and suggestive. It’s clear, from his encounters with the media, that Pizzolatto views the mythological elements as a sort of seasoning, a grace note.</p><p>But since I’d have to hand in my poststructuralist card if I worried too much about what the author is saying, let’s look at the text itself: True Detective has always kept the weirdness in the edges of the frame. The Yellow King started out as a glimpse in a hand-written flyer that was on screen for a moment, before becoming such a looming presence. We’ve spent more time on Marty Hart’s home troubles than on the intricate details of the murder-abuse ring’s paraphiliac practices. This, of course, has led to wild speculation around all details of said home life. After all, to the dot-connectors, this show is about the mythology; and therefore, what are those two kids doing playing with a <em>crown,</em> huh? Must be a clue to something.</p><p>Now I don’t doubt details like the plastic crown are provocative, and deliberately so—but that’s just what they are, a provocation. True Detective, like so much genre television these days, wants to get into your head and turn the wheels in there while you’re going about your business. So you keep coming back, and tweeting about it, and taking to the internet.</p><p>I’m not trying to claim this is somehow nefarious. Coming up with wild theories can be great sport. But the mythological is decorative. In this show, the emotional arcs of the characters are the load-bearing material.</p><p>What True Detective is interested in exploring is not the initially obscure, but straightforward story of a satanic cult and its victims; but the story of two men who become obsessed with the mystery, and self-destruct when they can’t see beyond the allure of the strange and the lurid. In this way, the fandom mirrors Hart and Cohle—distracted by the spirals and stick figures, they overlook the real puzzlebox at the heart of the show, which is the two characters’ own heads.</p><p>I do not, ultimately, think Nic Pizzolato has been Sixth Sensing us all along.</p><p>The people who expect some bizarre twist—those who think all the knots of this mythos around the Carcosa cult, which has been scribbled on the margins of the story so far, will be tied up neatly in the finale—are likely to be disappointed, to confront an anticlimax, when the show winds into a mundane conclusion, proves itself to be structured as the crime story it always presented itself as. It is, of course, an incredibly well-done crime story. True Detective is not deficient for not diving head-first into the cyclopean weirdness.</p><p>But of course, at this point in the story, just before the final chapter, Hart and Cohle seem to expect to find a great beast to slay, a mythological enemy to confront, defeat, and through that fix everything that is wrong with them and their lives—or at least Hart may feel that way; Cohle probably knows better. But what they’re likely to find at the end of that chase is a bumpkinish groundskeeper, or a corrupt churchman. Not a dragon or a king of shreds and patches. Their disappointment might very well mirror the disappointment in a segment of the audience—and wouldn’t that be terribly appropriate? Nic Pizzolato is probably not Sixth Sensing us, but he might be Cachéing us.</p><p>Me, I’m still holding out hope for the Lovecraftian horror ending. I can, after all, hope.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8aae4aefbcea" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>