<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Oyetayo Said Agboluaje on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Oyetayo Said Agboluaje on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@Oyetayo.Agboluaje?source=rss-aa70fd0b0153------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 11:28:51 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@Oyetayo.Agboluaje/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Regulation Dilemma: Lesson from Prior Mistakes]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Oyetayo.Agboluaje/regulation-dilemma-lesson-from-prior-mistakes-439e1550879c?source=rss-aa70fd0b0153------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/439e1550879c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Oyetayo Said Agboluaje]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 30 Dec 2016 11:57:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-12-30T11:57:12.094Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The financial sector is critical for generating investment funds, household lending and providing liquidity to help generate consumption and factors that influences aggregate demand. A highly controversial sector, which continues to polarise opinion since the financial crisis of 2007–2008. Yet, still an important sector of the economy in Western Europe and America. With the financial sector accounting for roughly 6million jobs (Select USA), and some 8.4 per cent toward GDP (Wall Street Journal) in USA and relatively similar pattern in Europe, for example, more than 2.2million labour force in UK operates in the UK financial sector (TheCityUK) with contributory growth of 10 per cent to the GDP but a minimal 3 per cent in Germany (Monagham 2014). Thus, symbolise the significance of the financial sector as a vital growth factor within the major economies.</p><p>For some, deregulation of the financial sector has been to the detriment of the banks and persistent meddling makes it inevitable that government of respective state had to bail out their banks at the zenith of financial crisis of 2008.</p><p>Prominent advocate of free-market such as Michael Munger and Richard Epstein endeavouring to advance the thought and principle of Hayek sees it as crossroad between the battle of the “good and bad guy” that the role of government should not be more than just a ‘referee’. By doing so, argues Munger and Epstein, the government therefore, unshackle itself from the plight of rent-seeking that distort the free market system. However, for Robert Skidelsky, Peter Dicken, Paul Krugman, alongside other interventionist, the only way to achieve full utilisation of public resources is through the state being fully engaged with the market. Discussing the role of government in a market economy, Robert Skidelsky (2013) in a symposium organised by Liberty Fund: <em>Capitalism, Government and the Good Society expresses some of his thought as follows:</em></p><p><em>…Even if a perfectly competitive market does exist without any distortion you still need an economic role for the state in stabilisation because you will not get full utilisation of resources under a freely competitive market system because of severe information problem.</em></p><p>The above proposition is in line with one of the four roles of the state pondered on by Dicken (2011). For Dicken, the state acts as container, competitor, collaborator and regulator. Therefore, recognising that countries continue to differ, as ‘containers’ of distinctive structures and practices is important in emphasising that we do not live in a homogenised world. In other words, states do not merely intervene in markets; they underpin and help to constitute their very existence.</p><p>There are discrete views connected with the importance of nation-state. Despite the contrary opinions on what should be the established role of the government, there is unanimity that government ought to refrain from being ‘active’ participant in a market-based system.</p><p>For the purpose of this paper, a pattern would be established which is not to distinguish between government and the concept of nation-state as that will divert the paper towards political spectrum as oppose to the functional role of government in the financial sector. So, the unelected actors and elected representatives of discussed nation-states would be categorised under the umbrella of state actors and government. It is worth acknowledging that respective democratic states have functioning institutions with degree of independence from the government and elected politicians. However, recent development in the world has blur the distinction between the regulators and elected politicians whom supposed administrative objective is long-term utilisation of public resources.</p><p>Over the course of the following section, this paper shall be directed towards analysing and evaluating the role of nation-state in the financial sector of the two major financial markets; the United State of America and Western Europe with supplementary analysis looking at less significant financial sector. The analysis centres on the role of government in influencing production, but in the case of the financial sector, this will address the services offered, trade components, FDI and consumption and regulation.</p><p><strong>Influence of nation-state</strong></p><p>The role of nation-state has evolved over time, and event dictates which power the government eventually delegate to the private sector without intervening. It is evidential that numerous Western governments has allot significant amount of power to the market, but such policy turn out to be challenged in time of chaos; for example, the financial crisis of 2008 augmented the debate on market liberalisation and misconception of self-regulation.</p><p>Without question, the most profound transformation of the nature of the governing structure in place came somewhat later in the twentieth century. The collapse of the Berlin Wall in 1989 followed by reunification of East and West Germany in 1990. The abrupt collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991 was acclaimed as triumph of capitalism. The demise of the Soviet Union in the later part of the twentieth century has enhanced different strand of debate within liberals about the role of nation-state in economic realm.</p><p>A more decentralised government, goes the argument, would advance adequate functioning of the market, but various government progressively accrue more power in influencing the role of their respective nations on the global market as it is believed that the essential role of the state stretch beyond just being referee but agent of stabilisation, regulator and provider of public goods which market would not provide for the obvious reason that its contradict the idea of profit maximisation objective of private enterprise.</p><p><strong>Production (Services)</strong></p><p>Major deregulation of the financial sector in all major developed economies, especially in the US, where series of reform from the 1970s has eased the entry of foreign banks into the domestic market and facilitated the expansion of US banks overseas, as well allowing banks to become involved in a whole variety of financial services and to operate nationwide branding network (Dicken 2011) brought a new dimension to the services provided by banks. Newly developed financial role of the existing financial institutions has allowed the creation of dynamic products now traded by banks. For example, the 1999 abolishment of the Glass-Steagall Act in latter part of the 20th century helped in the creation of the too “big to fail”.</p><p>Through the deregulation and crumbling of the wall bridging the gap between product supplied by investment banks which simply engage in securities and equity management with commercial banks managing current account thus blemish the risk of spill over. The Merging of both commercial banks and investment banks in effect meant current account, loans and credit card are effectively tied to the money market.</p><p><strong>Trade and FDI</strong></p><p>The principal task of the financial is to improve the efficiency of the financial management of their corporate systems by means of facilitating the flow of funds among various entities of a corporate system; providing consumers credit , investing surplus funds as profitability as possible (Aharoni and Nachum 2000). Bank lending was heavily encouraged across Europe and US pre-2008, by setting low liquidity standard. Speaking on the BBC Hardtalk, Lord Turner highlighted some of the substantial error that contributed towards the financial crisis in the form of relaxed liquidity standard. “Substantiating the role of government in influencing trade and FDI in the form of expansion of banks, lending done by banking systems in the advanced economies was 15 per cent of their generated funds which went into capital investment” (Lord Turner 2015).</p><p><strong>Consumption</strong></p><p>Finally, consumption is an important component of any economy and this is often fuelled either by borrowing or through welfare. According to the Bank of England report on household debt, the level of household debt has risen substantially over the past five years from 95 to 125 per cent of household’s post tax income (Hancock and Wood 2004). Elements of this debt were financed through banks borrowing and credit cards as a result of government relaxation on bank lending. Greece’s evidence is a very good case study of structural debt overhang. for instance, In the 1950s, private debt — both companies and households together as percentage of gross domestic product (GDP) across all the advanced economy was 50 percent and by 2007 it had peaked at around 170 per cent. This evidence explains why almost a decade after the financial crisis the world, especially Europe, is still struggling with economic dip and low inflation (Lord Turner 2015).</p><p><strong>CRITIQUES OF THE ROLE OF GOVERNMENT</strong></p><p>The problem of amoral banking still remains one of the major public discourse. Central to achieving the kind reform needed to help prevent further crisis such as the one witnessed in 2008, government across the globe will need to take a decisive policy approach and this could best be achieved regionally rather than unilaterally.</p><p>Government has always intervened to regulate the financial services industry, but change of administrations on both sides of the Atlantic in the 1980s change the dynamics of the market system, therefore a fundamental shift towards less regulation by many governments, resulting in deregulation of financial institutions (Pilbeam 2010). The repeal of the Glass-Steagall Act in 1999 indeed played a major role in reshaping the US banks. Light-touch regulation of the financial institutions under the administration of Prime Minister Thatcher reshaped the role and functions of finance and banking in the UK.</p><p>The Glass-Steagall Act of 1933, which separate the role and functions of banks before 1999 has been fundamental to the functioning of the USA financial institutions. Before 1999, the legislation had forced banks to choose between being commercial banks responsible for managing deposits and loans and investment banks that conducted securities transactions (Crawford 2011). Rightly before the repeal of the Act in 1999 the risk of financial market was limited to the stock market, therefore mitigating the risk of spill over. But understanding the way the US political system operates is just as essential for understanding what led to financial crash of 2008.</p><p>Like many advanced democracies, the US political system function primarily through lobbying. A system which advocates of free market believes enhance rent-seeking. Rent seeking, argues Peter Lewis (2007) creates substantial inefficiencies within the private sector, as businesses devote resources to securing extra-market benefits rather than improving competitiveness or investing in value-creating activities. The unavoidable defeat of the Glass-Steagall Act occurred when CitiCorp and Travelers, an insurance company, announced intent to merge, a corporate disobedience behaviour under the Banking Holding Act, however, the merger was granted as CitiCorp co-chairs and swarms of industry executives and lobbyists trammelled the halls of Congress to make sure the deal was cut, which was subsequently granted in 1999, after considerable deliberations (Weissman 2009).</p><p>However, the repeal of the Glass-Steagall Act did not cause the financial crash of 2008. By allowing for innovative system within the banking sectors could have better prepared the banks for the crisis of 2008. Central to any market system is information, and things private market do best is the introduction of intermediates that enables various kind of exchange entities and the theory is that if they have enough information they can basically organise both side of the market (Epstein 2013). Fundamentally, evaluating the American financial crisis, the answer it produces is similar to literature analysis of government failure. Various banks and financial institution lack the essential tools to weather the storm right towards the financial crash as they were short on liquidity. A key element of the newly approach taken by banks is ensuring they have enough capital reserve to prevent approaching the government for bail out in days of mishap.</p><p>Narrative on the UK and the European regulatory approach was far more reactionary than US. The Parliamentary report on Banking Supervision and Regulation (2009) produced a damning report on the existing regulatory structure, suggesting series of radical reforms to the entire banking systems. First on the list of recommendation is the implementation of series of drastic reforms covering the whole banking system, supervisor and regulators should subject bank risk model to much more rigorous stress-testing, credit default swaps should be reported and centrally cleared and authority oversight should be overhauled, by regulating liquidity, remove agency ratings from regulations, giving ratings agencies an economic interest in the accuracy of their ratings. The globalisation of the financial services has made it difficult to unilaterally adopt the proposed policies. One major example is threat by major banks to move their headquarters from the UK to other region or continent all together. An illustrative example is the persistent threat of HSBC to move headquarter as a result of stringent regulation imposed on the City of London which diminishes its competitiveness on global stage (Arnold, Oakley and Hughes 2015).</p><p>The inability to achieve global financial market regulation thus symbolise the regulatory capture within the industry, one of the key element of any ill managed capitalism.</p><p><strong>CONCLUSION</strong></p><p>To summarise, after examining the role and function of nation-state in the financial sector, one assumption sprung to mind, developing adequate policy in line with target and timeframe for every activity and transaction could aid in structuring the banks to be a functional tool for economic development rather than blemish on capitalism.</p><p>The predicament of irresponsible banking and lending is marginal part of the story in understanding the quintessential role and functions of banks. They also play an important role in sharing risk in the economy by diversifying and smoothing fluctuations over time. These are some of the stated positive role of banks in modern capitalism (Allen and Carletti 2008). Therefore, capital control which was long viewed as a relic of a more regulated era, particularly in an attempt to stem capital flow (The Economist) would be the wrong idea at the present time. What the market need is further deregulation which bolsters the function of the financial institutions and their capability in capital control.</p><p>Likely consequences of such approach is a far more conscious lending strategy by banks and more positive investment as government gradually withdraw its influence on the market, which consequently does not make it become guarantee of last resort in time of ill-advised investment which was emblematic of the 2008 financial crisis.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=439e1550879c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Pouvoir et l’obligation: Government vs. Freedom: The Right to Rule and Duty to Obey]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Oyetayo.Agboluaje/pouvoir-et-lobligation-government-vs-freedom-the-right-to-rule-and-duty-to-obey-b7453e3f51e2?source=rss-aa70fd0b0153------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b7453e3f51e2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anarchism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Oyetayo Said Agboluaje]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Sep 2016 15:35:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-09-22T15:35:28.315Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>Pouvoir et l’obligation</em></strong><em>: </em>Government vs. Freedom: The Right to Rule and Duty to Obey</p><p><strong><em>Foreword:</em></strong> It is only right to rewrite and adjust this paper fitting the current state of our society. It is quintessential as citizens to understand the premise upon which authority and the rule of law ought to be obeyed, without being coerced. The core basis of this writing stemmed from the principle of anarchism, but a very different strain of anarchism- Philosophical anarchism. Therefore, one ought to read this in the light of how authority and rule of law should be implemented and obeyed within the right jurisdiction.</p><p><strong><em>‘Anarchism: the name given to a principle or a theory of life and conduct under which a society is conceived without government — harmony in such a society being obtained, not by submission to law or by obedience to any authority, but by free agreements concluded between the various groups, territorial and professional, freely constituted for the sake of production and consumption, as also for the satisfaction of the infinite variety of needs and aspiration of a civilised being’.</em></strong> these are the words of Peter Kropotkin (1905) often referred to as the ‘anarchist prince.’</p><p>It is not without hesitation that anarchism has been one of the most challenged ideologies. Routinely, political publications synonymies anarchism with violence and return to the dark days of lawlessness, however, with the recent challenges to the predominant traditional ideologies- socialism, capitalism and the ‘third-way’- anarchism has been able to revive itself as an alternative ideology. Anarchism has been able to achieve this as a result of political challenges to the traditional ideologies on the taut of economic and political challenges. With this revival, nonetheless, anarchism still remains controversial and would not be taken serious unless certain questions are addressed; <em>1) Can human being live in an anarchistic society? 2) Who protect vulnerable member of society against the state of nature and 3) who enforce or assure that basic human needs are met.</em> These are some of the challenges for political anarchism, hence, for this reason it shall not be given considerable analysis in this writing.</p><p>Those who are persuaded that anarchism is a collection of vision relating to the future and an unconscious striving towards the obliteration of our present society are still very numerous and to clear the group of such prejudices I should perhaps enter into details on what philosophical anarchism represent, which will be arduous to embody in a single essay, however, I hope at the end of this essay I am able to dismantle the doubts about the impeccable intellectual pedigree of philosophical anarchism.</p><p>Central to anarchist values is the view that all existing states are illicit. This thesis is the central claim of all anarchists. Philosophical anarchism, as a body of anarchism, holds a firm stance on state illegitimacy, however, on this issue political anarchists can be distinguished from philosophical anarchists. Many anarchists are both political and philosophical, but philosophical anarchists are not necessarily political anarchists. What distinguishes philosophical anarchist from political anarchists are their ideals about state illegitimacy. Perhaps the simplest division between philosophical anarchists is on ‘<em>priori or posterior’</em> ground. Priori anarchists are those in favour of abolishing the state, because it contradicts the essence of human autonomy. Posteriori anarchism, on the other hand, maintains that while existing states are illegitimate, this is not because it is impossible for there to be legitimate state. Nothing in the definition of state precludes it legitimacy. Rather, existing states are condemned as illegitimate by the virtue of their contingent character.</p><p>It is of vital importance to mention that this essay is largely concerned with theoretical aspect of philosophical anarchism. So, I shall proceed on undertaking the task of explaining and analysing the epitome of philosophical anarchism by examining the writing of philosophical anarchists such as Robert Paul Wolff and Joseph Raz. It may be possible that at the end of this writing I may have arrived at constructing a case for ‘posteriori’ anarchism (then proceeds to consider a possible argument regarding why it is more favourable than priori anarchism) this, however, is not a problem because the goal of this paper is to critically examine philosophical anarchism and if, it is in principle convincing , which I shall argue explicitly that it is. At least, that a posteriori anarchism is.</p><p><strong><em>Priori Philosophical Anarchism</em></strong></p><p>Wolff, often regarded as a priori anarchist, was able to construct a powerful critique on the notion of legitimate authority. To counter Wolff’s argument, I shall highlight some of the weaknesses in Wolff’s proposition against legitimate authority. Raz a posterior anarchist, however, presents an opposing argument to Wolff idea in support of why moral legitimacy may be compatible with moral autonomy, which I shall explore further shortly.</p><p>At the heart of Wolff’s case for anarchism lies deep rooted detestation of authority. A state of autonomy, according to Wolff, could only be achieved in a stateless society. Wolff is an adherent to ‘Kantian’ theory which involves a priori argument. <em>The Kantian theory stresses the importance of an abstract duty of moral autonomy. On the Kantian theory the authority’s right to the citizens’ obedience necessarily conflict with the citizens’ duty to be morally autonomous. </em>Like Kant, Wolff engages in a priori dialectical reasoning to show that in principle, it is problematic to formulate a concept of authority that will not conflict with individual moral autonomy. According to Wolff, an autonomous person is one who reserves to himself the right to decide what is right and what is wrong, what he should do and what he should not. He issues his own commands and obeys only himself. To have authority, is to have right to issue binding commands thus, the autonomy of the individual and the authority of the state are mutually exclusive. There can be no such thing as legitimate state. This reasoning is very important to priori anarchist because the authority that the state must exercise (in order to be state) is inconsistent with the autonomy of the individual that any legitimate state would have to respect.</p><p>In addition, Wolff expands on the concept of authority and autonomy. He defines legitimate authority as authority that has the right to command. I diverge, in a different writing on authority; <em>Hannah Arendt</em> in her essay <em>“What is Authority?”</em> explains what being in position of authority entails. According to Hannah authority precludes the use of external means of coercion….And is incompatible with persuasion which presupposes equality and work through a process of argumentation. Under the circumstance where the use of force and persuasion are excluded from executing a command a legitimate authority is established because the autonomous individual have chosen to comply with the command of the state, but he will do this because he independently judge the action commanded to be the right thing to do, and not merely because it was commanded. In a such condition, where both moral autonomy and submission to authority becomes compatible, the willingness to accept the order of the state is an act of respect for social order rather than being compelled by the law, which Wolff’s considers to be the contingent character of the current state and unlikely to be sacrificed</p><p>Furthermore, the concept of autonomy; moral autonomy, according to Wolff is the submission to law which one has made for oneself. The fundamental of being an autonomous being in this sense is that an individual is culpable for their actions and therefore capable of ultimately arbitrating the moral implications of my actions irrespective of whether punishment is imminent if he has done something ‘wrong’.</p><p>After an insightful explanation on autonomy and authority, Wolff proceed to distinguish between two different types of authority; <em>de facto and de jure authority. De jure authority is a “prescriptive statements about what people or institutions have a right to be obeyed. To state that X has de jure authority over Y in area C is to state that Y has a duty to obey X’s commands in C. The duty to obey is intrinsically linked with the right to command”. De facto authority, </em>on the other hand, is a <em>‘descriptive statements about the internal point of view of the citizens conforming to existing political and legal authorities.’ </em>In the context of Wolff’s writing, I assume him to be saying no government have <em>de jure </em>authority in which there could be “<em>a right to command and whose subjects have a binding obligation to obey”. </em>Since anti-statism is central to Wolff’s argument it will be a worthless exercise to try and harmonise the view of authority with an agent moral autonomy since it is logical that it undermines it by not encompassing the right to rule or the moral obligation of the subjects to obey with the authority body’s commands.</p><p>From Wolff’s priori philosophical anarchism we could deduce two major points. First, legitimate authority and an obligation to submit to authority are incompatible with moral autonomy because for Wolff the defining mark of the state is authority, the right to rule. The primary obligation of man is autonomy, the refusal to be ruled. Also, there is no such thing as legitimate authority (<em>de jure) </em>because it will always clash with the subjects’ moral autonomy.</p><p>Wolff consistently worked through his argument against legitimate authority and whilst Wolff might be right to highlight the point that to have an authority is to have a binding command which might be incompatible with the moral autonomy the agent, however, in the light of severe challenges Wolff’s argument falls into disarray. These are fundamental flaws in Wolff’s priori philosophical anarchism. Wolff presumes autonomy being the prime obligation of man; such conception fails to take into account the consequences of living in a stateless society. In a stateless society, where there is no binding law we have to rely on an “<em>optimistic view of human nature, since we are being asked to believe that individuals can coexist without any form of hierarchical rule”. </em>Also, it is worth taking into account that an anarchic state such as that envisaged by Wolff, there will be those who will violate another individual’s right and as consequence of these flaws, life in a society where personal autonomy supersedes the law it will be <em>“very unsafe, and very insecure”.</em></p><p>In addition, there are no reason to accept the claims that authority and autonomy are incompatible as there is nothing inherently wrongful in accepting the command of those in authority if those issuing the command are in the best position of arriving at the best judgment, as a result, just as they have the moral duty to issue the command we equally have the moral obligation to accept it. Lastly, due to the way in which Wolff rejects political authority it becomes unclear how is conception does not also reject contracts and promises as illegitimate constraints on one’s autonomy because an agent is bound by some constraint which cannot be breached without negative consequences.</p><p><strong><em>A Posteriori Philosophical Anarchism</em></strong></p><p>In his book<em> The Morality of Freedom,</em> Joseph Raz presents a contrary approach to the incompatibility of autonomy and authority. A Posteriori anarchist such Raz holds that <em>‘nothing in the definition of the state precludes its legitimacy’ </em>however current states are illegitimate or unlikely to meet the standards of legitimacy required to have legitimate authority because they hold more than which the normal justification thesis supported. Posterior anarchists are of course not very sanguine about soon realisation of such an ideal state.</p><p>Raz broadly expatiate on way in which authority could be justified. One of the characteristic way and perhaps the most intrinsic point of posterior anarchism, and in line with the normal justification thesis, is that, one could establish that a person has legitimate authority over another person by showing that the ‘<em>alleged is likely better to comply with reasons which apply to him (other than alleged authoritative directives) if he accepts the directives of the alleged authority as authoritatively binding and tries to follow, rather than by trying to follow the reasons which apply to him directly’ </em>from a Razian perspective, I could say Raz is asserting that the only way of justifying legitimate authority is if those in positions of issuing the command have the best chance at arriving at the correct solution to the present problems. Even though sometimes it may issue an unseemly and inadequate authoritative directives, the fact that the likelihood of choosing to do the right thing is in its favour justifies following the order irrespective of its correctness.</p><p>Furthermore, Raz emphasises that an authority has to guide its actions according to the reasons that independently apply to the subject, because the authority has to decide on certain reason (the one that applies to the subjects), the submitting party, thus must stop relying on their reasons and rely only on the authoritative directive. The commands issued by the authority are exclusionary in nature, meaning they replace the initial reason in fostering action. If all necessary conditions are met, the authoritative body will prove the most efficient agent in solving social and individual predicament. Now, there seems to be practical reasons to submit ones autonomy to an authority in different circumstances. In light of this argument, the right to rule correlate with a duty to obey have arisen from the simple pragmatic reason stated above. If by submitting one’s autonomy to an authority directive maximise the prospect of doing the right thing, then it would be logical to engage in that submission.</p><p>Indeed, Raz’s sense of the factual possibility of legitimate authority proves to be one of the strength of his argument. For example, take a case between a doctor and the medical council on the issue of euthanasia. Whilst Wolff asserts without any reluctance that there can never be legitimate authority, we could apply Raz’s proposition here. On issue such as euthanasia, regarded as illegal in the UK, the medical council ethics committee holds an illegitimate authority at current state, however, nothing preclude it from being legitimate, because if in the process of administering their policy, they have the chances of having the right answer to the case of euthanasia, the doctor in this case have the moral duty to submit to the medical council command. Based on this example, we could verify the justification for submitting to an authority order. In the light of this argument, I find it easy to adhere with posteriori anarchism on the practicalities which proves that in principle it is logically possible for moral autonomy to be compatible with authority.</p><p>The second quality of posteriori anarchism is its pragmatism. Unlike priori anarchists, a posteriori anarchist hold a more logical and practical approach to authority, and more focused on ‘<em>balance of reason’ </em>when authoritative directives are issued. I hold a posteriori philosophical anarchism to be favourable compared to priori anarchism based on practicality and theoretical value. Why does this matter to this essay? It is important because, the essence of posteriori anarchism is to establish a case upon which the legitimate authority of the state could be embraced, rather than abolish it- which seems inconceivable in the present climate.</p><p>To summarise, what is important that we could comprehend from this essay is that, all philosophical anarchists reject the present state as illegitimate; alternatively, one branch of philosophical anarchism has helped uncover important practical circumstance upon which accepting authoritative order could be compatible with an agent moral autonomy. And as result, posteriori approach aid in highlighting a method for which we could accurately construct a coherent legitimate authority.</p><p><strong><em>Conclusion</em></strong></p><p>As Wolff asserted, moral autonomy is central and fundamental concept in understanding philosophical anarchism and any political or institutional constraints could not be compatible with moral autonomy because of their very definition. However, as we would have seen in the argument presented by Raz, we could avoid the rigidity of Wolff’s concept of autonomy based on the circumstances at hand. Raz’s approach offered philosophical anarchism some credibility by modifying priori anarchism through a diverse approach which uncovered an important practical circumstance which accepting authority might be legitimate. I don’t hold back that some of the point I presented in this essay could subsequently be subjected to criticism themselves, however, in the end, the force of the practical and instrumental value of authority cannot be repudiated.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b7453e3f51e2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>