<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Kala Sanggurdi on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Kala Sanggurdi on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@PalakieNevermore?source=rss-5ce11b14808b------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 01:43:33 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@PalakieNevermore/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[To Classify Intelligence]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PalakieNevermore/to-classify-intelligence-2e1987b58b76?source=rss-5ce11b14808b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2e1987b58b76</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kala Sanggurdi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 Jun 2026 10:53:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-07T10:53:41.774Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In its essence, intelligence is an organism’s capacity to <strong><em>adapt</em></strong> and <strong><em>solve problems</em></strong>. Specifically, given an environment and a goal, intelligence is the capacity to reach said goal in said environment.</p><p>For example, intelligence is the capacity of a fish to capture oxygen using its gills in aquatic environment, to reach its goal to survive another second. Intelligence is <em>also</em> the capacity of a fish to <em>realize</em> that its gills can‘t capture oxygen if it’s on the land, thus it should get the heck away from land at all cost. Intelligence also means the capacity of a fish to <em>realize</em> that it gills can’t capture food, thus it should not ingest food through its gills. Thus, consequently, intelligence also includes the capacity <em>to know which environment won’t work</em> to reach certain goals, and the capacity<em> to know which instrument</em> (tools, actions, behavior, etc.) <em>won’t work</em> to reach certain goals. This will be important later on.</p><p>I’ve met a lot of smart people, and I’ve met a lot of people who are wiser than me — honestly, wisdom is a better, more OP stat than intelligence — , and trying to put everyone into a set of ordinal classes was something I endeavor to do all my life in order to understand people better — and because stereotyping people is a fun vice to do!</p><p>Now, this is a very rough classification in accordance to IQ points. Don’t take it seriously — these are just my brain farts. But I will try my best to put some wisdom into this, so that I can share how one may strive to be more intelligent.</p><p><strong><em>Below 90 IQ</em></strong></p><p>These people, to be brutally honest, are people most fit for turning big rocks into little rocks. <strong><em>Ooga-boogas</em></strong>. You can’t reason with them because they barely use any reason in their life. And truthfully speaking, this is their plus point.</p><p>You have to realize that, there are organisms with way fewer IQs than these mofos, and they survived. We even sometimes say that these organisms are intelligent, like that of cats, dogs, chimps, etc. Thus, you have to at least give some credits to these people because they survive <em>just fine</em> despite their… <em>cognitive challenges</em>. And the reason they survive just fine and manage to reproduce just fine is that they operate on the minimum requirement for humans. They’re <strong><em>intellectually efficient</em></strong>.</p><p>These people rely on the physicality aspect of intelligence. They respond to their environments, they respond to (bare minimum of) social cues, and they respond to instincts. These people make lots of babies, not because they have the capacity to financially, psychologically, emotionally, and physically cater to 12 babies at once. These people make lots of babies because that’s what evolutionarily most optimal way for their genes to survive. And after making all those 12 babies? They make do. And you know what? They’ll thrive anyway even though the whole damn media and society tell you that children are expensive.</p><p>Hence, you ought to respect our biological makeup, because when you can’t think, can’t reason, and can’t create rationales, your natural biology already do that for you. Low IQ people will naturally prefer meat than vegetables, without having to know that meat is nutritionally denser and less natural-pesticide-toxic than vegetables. Low IQ people will naturally prefer walking and doing physical things, without having to know that physical exercise maintains the muscles and creates a whole shebang of hormonal cocktails that turns you into a better and healthier person. Low IQ people will naturally gravitate towards jobs that they can do to get food, without being told that they have to go to certain colleges and having certain courses and certain certificates in order to get certain jobs with certain incomes that will guarantee certain lifestyles with certain foods.</p><p>What smarter people usually don’t get when dealing with intellectually challenged people is that, <em>you can’t change them directly</em>. What you have to change is <strong><em>the environment</em></strong><em> </em>and <strong><em>the goal</em></strong>. They can’t understand when you tell them the reason why they shouldn’t litter, but they sure as heck will understand a knuckle sandwich coming towards their face when they try to even think to litter. That’s an <em>immediate change in environmental reaction</em>. Or, more positively, they may not understand the reason why they should make way for an ambulance, but they will do, once you give them a chocolate croissant if they do. That’s a <em>change in goal</em>, making chocolate croissant <em>a proxy goal</em> for making way for an ambulance.</p><p>Even from the lowest of the low, you will still learn a lot of things. The mere fact that they survive for eons, generations to generations, while smarter people died younger (and usually childless) or even by their own doing, is enough that they’re not useless. They show us the extent of human will to survive, reproduce, and thrive can be, in spite of difficulties in understanding the world and themselves. Thus, <strong>there are values in not thinking</strong>. <strong>There are values in not rationalizing</strong>. There are values in acting without thoughts or well-thought plans. Your life can be just fine without it, and you can thrive just fine without it.</p><p><strong><em>Between 90 to 115 IQ</em></strong></p><p>These are <strong><em>the normies</em></strong>. The common folk. The default template. Smart enough to think, smart enough to understand abstract concepts, and most importantly, smart enough to understand that <em>intelligence is not their forte</em>. Hence, these people are the best people to have if you are a no-bullcrap leader who needs things done. However, these people are the worst people to have if you are a leader who manages other leaders. If a normie becomes a middle manager, you better make sure they’re wiser than they are intelligent.</p><p>And here’s the thing about normies: they know that their forte is not intelligence. Thus, they know that <em>there are limits to their knowledge</em>, limits to their capacities, and <em>they respect these limits</em>. If they don’t know how to sew a dress, they will reach for someone who does instead of teaching themselves. If they don’t know how to count, they will look for an accountant. <strong><em>They know how to delegate intelligence</em></strong>.</p><p>This is exactly the reason why civilization was possible. Most people are normies, and most normies know they can’t do most things. But due to their vast numbers, most things can be done by specific, specialized, and experienced normies while the rest do different things. They know how to back up other people, and they know they need other people to back them up. The collective works well because normies are everywhere, hence specializations and teamwork become the norm. You don’t even need to be extremely good at things to be a help to others, because the very fact that you can do something that others can’t is good enough to maintain civilizations.</p><p>And the pitfall for smarter people when they see normies is just that: <strong>normies are the norm, and you are the anomalies</strong>. You can’t expect a normie specialized in being a cashier to also be good at spreadsheet, even though you are smart enough to realize spreadsheets can be a great tool for cashiers, because normies have limited slots for supplementary knowledge from the start and they thrive from being cooperative. And <strong><em>cooperation is a skill most intelligent people lack</em></strong> because most intelligent people know multiple differentiated skills enough for them to need less cooperation. <strong><em>Individuation derived from intelligence can be the death of intelligent people</em></strong> merely from the fact that <strong><em>humans aren’t individuated species</em></strong>, but a near-euspecies organism that absolutely need each other to survive.</p><p>So, normies know how to delegate, know that their knowledge is limited simply by fate alone, and know that they need other people to thrive. And so should you. You need to delegate despite having better knowledge and skills in comparison to the people you delegate to, not to mess up the result, but because it will save you from the torment of both doing everything everywhere all at once, and normies outcasting you socially due to you being a prick. After all, cooperating with normies is way more preferable than cooperating with anyone from other categories in this list.</p><p><strong><em>Between 115 to 130 IQ</em></strong></p><p>This is where you are. No, really. If you manage to read up to this point, know me, and regard me as some sort of authority of intellectual discourse, then this is where you are. And congratulations! You’re a <strong><em>midwit</em></strong>.</p><p>Now, there’s nothing wrong with being a midwit. In fact, it may be the reason why you are where you are right now: cushy college, cushy job, or cushy school if you’re still young. You are intellectually better than the normies, meaning that you have more accumulated skills than normies with 10 years more experience. Because of that, you are <em>more individuated</em>, and <em>can do more things on your own</em> compared to normies. And that’s the danger: <strong><em>you are, by definition, a more selfish and egocentric person</em></strong>.</p><p>Yet, you know that you’re not the top dog. You have that kind of feeling. Normies aren’t smart enough to realize that <em>there are smarter smart people</em>. But you are. You’re smart enough to realize that there are way scarier, smarter people out there with knowledge far vaster than you do. These people usually are your inspirations. Your Einstein, your Harari, your Sagan, your Hawking. Or you’re smart enough to realize that <em>there are collections of people with vast collective knowledge</em> who have already mapped out everything for you, if and only if, you are smart and determined enough to read their books, articles, or research. Your WHO, your AHA, your whatever-NGO-of-your-choosings. And you love these people and institutions because they provide you with immense knowledge that you can read, and can blow your mind.</p><p>And that’s where your pitfall is. <em>You are smart enough to absorb knowledge like sponges, but you are not smart enough to map them yourself</em>. You need some sort of <em>intellectual oasis</em> to function as an intellectual. You need some sort of guidance on how to think the right way. You rely on this so much that you may forget common sense, not contextually map critical or missing red threads, or even dismiss the opinions of normies or ooga-boogas just because you see what they don’t see. You may also be specialized so much on things that you may be compelled to think that, either your opinion becomes valid because you are smart enough to have such a privilege, or your opinion on things other than your specializations becomes useless and you rely heavily on the notion that someone else’s opinion matters more than you if they have the intellectual authority over the subject. <strong><em>Midwits is the place in which innovations and simple discourses die</em></strong>, solely because <strong><em>it’s an echo chamber of collective intelligence</em></strong>. Extremists are mostly midwits, simply because they prefer certain authorities when it comes to knowledge.</p><p>Midwits should realize that they reside in this “<em>intellectual uncanny valley</em>”: you are so close to being an independent intellectual, but not quite.<strong> <em>You still need some sort of authority over your knowledge</em></strong>, and you have to realize that <strong><em>over-reliance to certain sets of authoritative intellectual figures is your unique weakness</em></strong>. Thus the thing you need to do most is to listen to everyone, including the normies and the ooga-boogas. Remember that despite being dumber than chimps, some humans can still survive and thrive. If you can’t even thrive as a smarter person than normies and ooga-boogas, then who’s the intellectual then?</p><p><strong><em>Between 130–145 IQ</em></strong></p><p>The second layer of intellectual standard deviation, these people are <strong><em>proper smart people</em></strong>. They’re very individuated, and have <strong>mad egos</strong>. Usually, these people excel without even trying, so one definite trait most of them have is <strong><em>laziness towards anything that disinterests them</em></strong>. If something interests them, then by God, they’ll destroy everyone who tries to compete. But if it ain’t interesting, they’ll forget it faster than they learn new things. Hence, the other trait they have is <strong><em>super-specialization</em></strong>.</p><p>Now, while it is true that these people super-specialize, the other crucial component of intelligence that is available to people on this level is <strong><em>the capacity to map their own knowledge</em></strong>. Without relying on specific authorities or institutions, these people usually already have some sort of capacity to map the crucial missing context of information they need. This is the reason why people of this category, despite being super-specialized heart surgeons, somehow also know that certain Taylor Swift’s songs have 91 BPM with 4/4 beats while a Scriabin’s piano prelude have 112 BPM with 5/8 beats because apparently the Swift songs represent normal heartbeat while the Scriabin prelude represent arrhythmia or something. Crucially, <em>they map this out themselves, without ever referencing people first</em>. And even if someone else had mapped the knowledge out for them, the most they’d do is maybe saying “Ah yeah of course, someone had found them out already”, to then proceed with doing their own thing or taking notes on what they might miss from the predecessors. These people are also the laziest to reference other authorities simply because they have mad egos and know that they can map the knowledge themselves — they just weren’t as early as the smartasses inventing the knowledge.</p><p>Essentially, <strong><em>the higher level your intelligence is, the less people can learn from you </em></strong>—it’s a shocker and very counter-intuitive, because lots of people think that they learned a lot from smarter people. What they truly did was <strong><em>they get way more information from smart people</em></strong> than the normies or the ooga-boogas, but <strong><em>to actually use those information to good use, you need either more brain capacities or more life experience </em></strong>— something a normie with decades of experience can do just as well, if not better, than smart people.</p><p>A lot of people can learn from the ooga-boogas, while fewer can learn from the normies. Even fewer can learn from midwits, because the only people who should learn from midwits are in this category or higher. And what these proper smart people should learn is the <strong><em>fervour</em></strong> the midwits have in their ambition and their passion, and also <strong><em>the capacity to trust other smart people or institutions</em></strong>. Mad egos make these people either intolerable, or simply can’t coexist with anyone even amongst themselves. And sometimes, the knowledge you map on your own may be full of holes (surprising, I know), and you should have proper references as comparisons.</p><p><strong><em>Between 145–160 IQ</em></strong></p><p>The third standard deviation. The <strong><em>geniuses</em></strong>. And the defining difference between them and the proper smart people is <strong><em>they can map the map</em></strong>. Smartasses <em>map knowledge from different fields</em> easily, while geniuses <em>map different knowledge maps</em> of these smartasses and compile them into a <strong><em>metamap </em></strong>— one map to rule them all.</p><p>Egotistical doesn’t even define them; they literally see themselves as Gods amongst men. Unmatched ego, manipulative, and a wide capacity to do so. You might be tempted to think that these people think 10 steps ahead from you, and you’d be wrong. <strong><em>Geniuses think 10 steps ahead from themselves</em></strong>, and they barely can even explain their thoughts for themselves. Hence <strong><em>they excel in foresight and hindsight</em></strong>, and that’s the majority of things they actually do.</p><p>As an example, geniuses usually already have some sort of a forethought before any process, all from the maps of knowledge they’ve collected from institutions and people, and instead of planning it out in a proper manner like normies and midwits usually do, they already did the planning process on their head (without realizing it to a conscious process) and go straight to decisions. This will flabbergast most people, especially when that decision turns out to be an amazing decision. But mind you, the geniuses don’t even read the plan in their head when they make the decision; they only read the plan after the decision as a hindsight for them. If done by normies or midwits, that kind of behavior can result in a colossal disaster — as you may know, not consciously thinking about the decision you’re about to make can be regarded as downright stupid. But for geniuses, thanks to the map of maps they have inside their head, most of those decisions go, if not amazing, then good enough for everyone involved.</p><p>But everyone makes mistakes, including these geniuses. And over-reliance on these foresights and hindsights, just because you have the one map to rule them all, will eventually result in a bad decision. With an ego of a God and overall error rate of less than 5%, <strong><em>a genius making a mistake usually doesn’t learn from it</em></strong>. It will be considered as an anomaly, a glitch in the matrix, or a result of incompetent people. And that’s the greatest pitfall of them all: <strong><em>geniuses oftentimes blame others for their own mistakes</em></strong>, relying on the complex machinations of times, places, events, and people involved. And the darndest thing geniuses do is the fact that <strong><em>they blame others as a hindsight</em></strong>, meaning that it is right up their alley when they do it, and it will convince people easily because geniuses are masters of foresight and hindsight.</p><p>Also, one of the things geniuses barely learn in life is <strong><em>hard work</em></strong>. All they do is essentially play, because without even trying to do anything, they will excel, and they will excel at a level that is good enough for people to be comfortable to reward. Networking is their safety net, and they have the capacity to excel at it in the first place, but only for so long before everyone realizes how megalomaniacal and Machiavellian they can be.</p><p>Later on in their old age, these geniuses will be overshadowed by younger people simply due to trends and everyone getting bored at seeing the same person on the top over and over again . And frankly speaking, geniuses need the attention way more than they need to maintain the mechanical platform in which their intelligence resides: their body. The over-reliance on ingenuity alone and the fact that dropping their IQ by 10 points still makes them sharper than almost everyone means that <strong><em>vices are geniuses’ worst enemies</em></strong>. Drinking, drugs, sex, smoking, and many other vices are common amongst geniuses, and will forever be as long as their main capital is still needed by their networks — be it as a commodity or as a party trick. After all, Tesla and Einstein didn’t die happy. They died alone, with everyone leaving them behind as their intelligence became less and less relevant when younger, more eager, and cheaper geniuses replaced them.</p><p>It’s a sad ending for the geniuses, really, and the only thing they ought to learn from the next level of intelligence below is something these geniuses may never truly accept.</p><p><strong><em>Beyond 160 IQ</em></strong></p><p>We are entering the apex intelligence area. There are very few people in this category , and for a good reason. This category consists of people with an IQ so high that they… go all the way back to ooga-booga? <strong><em>Neo ooga-boogas</em></strong>.</p><p>Yes. When you expect that these apex intellects would dominate the dominators, creating a meta-metamaps or thinking a million steps ahead of everyone else, these people just… don’t do those. They just… kind of, vibe, I guess? Most of them live life like normies or the ooga-boogas instead of marionetting an entire nation using their intelligence. Some don’t even consider their intelligence to be of value. But don’t get me wrong; they still are extreme people, but the way they show their extremity may not be the way people wishing for omniscience would expect.</p><p>You might have heard about system 1 and system 2 thinking. <strong>System 1</strong> is the gun, the heuristics, the thought process you use for immediate actions and decisions, born from pattern recognition and repeated training. It’s how you ride a bicycle without thinking of body coordination, and how you can immediately answer 1 + 1 as 2 (or 11 if you’re intellectually challenged). <strong>System 2</strong> is the computer, the analysis, the thought process you use to chew down on information. It’s when you take a minute to solve 313 × 18 manually, or when you have to learn about foot coordination for manual cars for the first time. <em>System 2 exists as the mind’s way of processing information and threading the red thread</em>, while <em>system 1 is the system you use when system 2 already mastered the info and the mapping</em>.</p><p>Now imagine that <strong><em>your system 2 is as fast as your system 1</em></strong>. Imagine that it takes little to no time to learn anything at all. Imagine that you don’t even perceive your thought process because it goes so fast that even trying to understand it will take days or even years. Imagine touching the guitar for the first time, learn the first fingering lessons, then you just can play the guitar immediately. And you can’t explain how because there’s just either too much going on and you don’t know where to start, or the information map is so complex that you don’t even know how to best perceive it. Once you learn the concept of fingering, you instantly realized what it implies, the motor control needed, the songs you’ve heard and the correlation between their melodies and the guitar… you’re not even sure you can explain that in a matter of minutes, let alone seconds, to normies or even midwits. A psychological phenomenon in which a brain is split between its right and left showed that while the left side can speak, the right side can’t. But when the right side did something the left side don’t realize, the left side tried to rationalize the right side’s action as its own. And this thing happens inside the minds of these neo ooga-boogas. A mind working so fast that <strong><em>the conscious mind can only rationalize its mechanism after a thought or an action is produced</em></strong>. Imagine not knowing why you don’t like a person, but you do, and there’s no rational reason why. Imagine knowing what to do in a situation, what to decide, how to act, but you can’t explain why you know what you know. <em>And you’re always right 90–99% of the time</em>. This is, in normies’ term, <strong><em>intuition</em></strong>. A phenomenon in which <em>the mind work so fast and so efficient, that it produces an output without a perceived process</em>.</p><p>The neo ooga-boogas live with intelligence so effective that it knows that it ain’t crap compared to efficiency. We all have seen how, despite having nuclear weapons or other weapons of mass-destruction, a simple drone would be enough to wreck havoc. We all have seen how, despite being poor quality products, products from China are the norm because it’s so cheap and efficient. We all have seen how, despite advanced technologies to go to the deepest trenches of the ocean, we still can’t fully explore it. Efficiency beats effectiveness all the time. The goddamn jellyfish survived for eons without a single brain amongst them because they’re so efficient. The horseshoe crab’s brain (or honestly, a collective tissues <em>resembling</em> a brain) has yet to be changed structurally for the last hecking 300 million years for God’s sake. Thus, neo ooga-boogas, people who for all intents and purposes are omniscient, use their omniscience to decide that the best way to live is <strong><em>living by using intelligence as little as possible</em></strong>.</p><p>Because what’s there to achieve? World domination? Becoming God? Having the resource of a nation in your hand? Those takes efforts. Intellectual efforts. You might have an endless amount of intellectual potential, but the same calorie you burn for forming a thought can be used to metabolize a lovely cake instead. Since a thriving life can be achieved by the ooga-boogas themselves without forming a single thought, then why should anyone desire more? If the dopamine hit you get from eating a random 10k IDR chocolate bread is roughly the same amount of dopamine hit you would get from eating a 200k IDR chocolate croissant from a fancy 5-star restaurant on top of the highest building in Jakarta, then why bother? The experience? The taste? The aroma? The environment? All takes efforts: motoric, palate, olfactory, vision, auditory, finance, temporal, spatial, etc. Even if the neo ooga-boogas have found the meaning of it all, and they sure have with their immense ingenuity, turned out the meaning of it all is just to survive, reproduce, and thrive. And the most efficient and effective way to do so is to use the least amount of energy and calorie while doing that: <strong><em>living a simple life</em></strong>.</p><p>And this is what’s missing from the geniuses. Geniuses are people who have nuclear weapons and aren’t afraid to use them if needs be. Geniuses are people who have immense intellectual resources and aim to amass immense amount of other resources to basically caters to their intellect. They are bound by the visions and the missions made by the billions of tiny cells inside their craniums, as if they are the very reason humanity evolves into what they are now. Truly, the reason why there’s a brain in the first place is because it is near the input point of nutrition: the mouth. The brain evolves near the mouth because a lot of actions are needed to amass nutrition. That’s all it is: a tool to enable better nutrition intake. In humanity’s case, the brain evolves into the size that it is now simply because our guts shrank because we delegate nutrition metabolism to fire, but we ought to have the brain capacity to make one, which requires exceptional motor functions, which require social behaviors, etc., and it turned out we need a big brain to compensate all the things making us able to input nutrition into the body. That’s what we are, essentially. <strong><em>The consciousness we have is derived from the basic needs to get nutrition</em></strong>. What else, then, to gain in this life, in a biological and evolutionary sense, if not food and sex? And what else, then, if you can get both, with little to no effort, thanks to the immense intelligence you have, and thanks to you not indulging your intelligence’s desire to be overclocked?</p><p><strong><em>Reflections</em></strong></p><p>Intelligence, among all tools humanity needs to survive and thrive, is usually put on a pedestal. And it has been for the longest time. People romanticizes intelligence, lots becoming <em>sapiosexual</em> for it, or even creates classism out of it — exactly what I’m doing right now lol. However, as fancy as it is, it is <strong><em>not</em></strong> the most essential tool to survive and thrive. It is a good tool, and it certainly a tool you need most to correct errors and mistakes, not to mention to adapt and to solve problems. But a substantial amount of it is not truly needed, and in fact, might go against your will to survive and thrive.</p><p>And it should be the norm to regard intelligence as merely, a tool. You may have a hammer, or you may have Subnautica-level futuristic hypertech multitool as a hammer. But both, at the end of the day are used to nail nails or to beat the heck out of people. You may think that the greatest weapon of all, the nuclear weapon, is enough to erase millions of people, until you realize that the humble malaria have killed half of humanity since the dawn of time. That is the difference between an effective intelligence and an efficient one.</p><p>So be intellectually efficient. Ooga-boogas might have no choice but to be efficient, but you do. Think less, and you will see that the meaning of life becomes far simpler than what your intelligence trying to envision.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2e1987b58b76" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[God as an Adjective]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PalakieNevermore/god-as-an-adjective-116280d739e0?source=rss-5ce11b14808b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/116280d739e0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kala Sanggurdi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 May 2026 07:02:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-19T07:02:43.916Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“Does God exist?” is an elementary ontological question anyone would ever ask at least once in their lives, and the answer can be an immediate “yes” or a long, pondering thought with neither yes nor no as the answer. That is, until you meet an atheist and the answer is usually an immediate “no”. While people may argue over who’s right, the atheist or the believer, fewer people did argue over the question: are we asking the right question?</p><p>And the thing about God is, it’s rather difficult to discuss God with a clear head. The believers may take offense when God is put down into a mundane humane discussion about existence, or God-forbid (<em>pun-intended</em>), ontology. And the atheists, while they vehemently believe that they’re not the emotional one in this discussion, sure put a lot of vigor when discussing the <em>non-existence</em> of God and the <em>whys — </em>especially if the God in question is not the ontological God, but God(s) of certain religions. Both sides, unfortunately, gets riled up when it comes to the discussion of God, and unfortunately, sooner or later, whether you’re a believer or an atheist, will soon realize how futile and pointless it is to change each other’s mind. The wiser of you will go on believing (or disbelieving) what you want to believe (or disbelieve) and stop the useless argument of God’s existence (or non-existence) against the other team. And honestly, that’s the right decision. I would stop the God discussion here and now just for the sake of choosing to be the wiser guy, but of course, I am now gonna cause ontological havocs for fun and giggles just because I can (and because I’m not that wise lol).</p><p>Now, now, at my current age of 31, I had been a believer for about as long as I have been a disbeliever. Give or take, each phase lasted about 15–17 years. If you ask me, right now, do I believe in the existence of God, my immediate answer would be <em>“What the heck kind of question is that?”</em>. But if you see me on a daily basis, you would immediately see that I am not living my life like someone who believe in God(s) of any religion. I’ve been living this way for about half of my life and I am not intending to change my <em>philosophical</em> lifestyle anytime soon. Yet, if you ask me 10 years ago? I would immediately laugh at you if you ever even showed signs of believing in a higher power. I was a militant atheist back then. Today, I am a <em>spiritual</em> atheist.</p><p>“Wait, what? <em>Spiritual</em> atheist? What the heck is that?!” says you, with gawked face and wide eyes.</p><p>So, yes, there is such a thing as a <em>spiritual</em> atheist, because in actual, scientific, operational definition, spirituality is separate from both divinity and religiosity. <strong>Spirituality is the subjective experience of connection to something considered sacred, transcendent, meaningful, or greater than the self</strong>. That connection can be anything. It can be God, it can be the cosmos, it can be the community you’re in, and heck, it can be ice cream if you really, <em>really</em>, love ice cream. So, <em>technically</em>, there is such a thing as a spiritual atheist, because the disbelief in the existence of God does not immediately rid you of your capacity to be spiritual.</p><p>In fact, your capacity to be spiritual is so ingrained in your biology, that even all atheists will replace their spiritual connection to God with something else entirely: science, community, love, the cosmos, knowledge, etc. Because we, as a species, are closer to a <strong><em>eusocial species</em></strong> than an asocial one. And when a species is eusocial, whatever the heck they do in their lives, they do it for the greater good of the species. Perfect eusocial species like ants and bees live their lives without having <em>any</em> personality, and live their lives in accordance to the role given at birth. Worker ants work, soldier ants soldier, and none of them would even question <em>why</em> the worker ants can only work and not soldier. They do all of that for the sake of the colony (frankly speaking, for the sake of the queen. But even the queen is queening for the sake of the colony; the queen is as personality-less and as inevitable as the soldier ant). And the biological makeup for the ants to be able to work together <em>THAT</em> cohesively requires the ants to recognize that the colony is <em>greater</em> than themselves… that the colony <em>is</em> the <em>meaning of life</em>, that the colony <em>transcends</em> them, that the colony’s wellbeing is more <em>sacred</em> than their own. Hence, ants and bees are arguably the most spiritual animals out there. They are the perfect example of spirituality.</p><p>Humans are not a perfect eusocial species. We are social, sure, and we are <em>very</em> social so much so that we literally cannot survive by our lonesome in the wild, and so much so that our babies literally cannot even survive their first day like other animals without the help of their parents, and cannot survive on their own for the first 10–15 years of their lives without parental supervision. That same neurological makeup for pain and suffering non-social animals have whenever they get physically hurt? We have it as well, and it will activate when the wrong words are said to us from other humans. Let me repeat that to you: <em>the wrong words said (or typed) by other humans will hurt you just as much as a jaguar getting its paw bitten by a crocodile</em>. That’s how social we are. And if we are to infer that spirituality positively correlates with sociality, then we are also a very spiritual animal, very nearly on the level of ants and bees.</p><p>The thing is, we have no <em>queen bee</em>. The closest thing to a figure that transcends us is our kings and queens, but even they aren’t as absolute as the queen ants. Yet our biosocial makeup requires us to have some sort of thing that is greater than ourselves, more sacred than ourselves, transcends us, and is the epitome of meaning for our lives. We can’t say that the <em>human species</em> as our queen bee because there is no persona there; it’s an abstract idea, and queen bee is the literal personification of the bee species that the species relies on for survival and reproduction. Thus we have to personify our queen bee. Kings and queens were close enough, so were our tribal chieftains, our prophets, our popes, our caliphates, or our group leaders. But with enough number of humans, enough number of kingdoms, even kings and queens lose their absolution. Something else, personified, should be there, transcending even kings and queens, giving meanings to the whole human species, transcends humanity… God.</p><p>God is the absolution humans need as a consequence of being a near-eusocial species. That’s why we can <em>lose our ways</em> when we leave God and <em>be back on the righteous path</em> when we repent to God. That’s why the God’s discussion is so sensitive, aggressive, and can even be the causes of wars. Because, well, discrediting God has the same ring as discrediting the survival of the human species. Taking the Lord’s name in vain, in bee-style, is the same as tea-bagging the queen bee. Or in ant-style, it’s the same as forcing the queen ant to look at some worker ants’ TikTok dance. Not only that it’s distasteful, it also turns both the worker ants’ and the queen ant’s focus away from their jobs in the colony. Making sure that each ant does their job without personalized decisions that are out-of-context for the colony is an upmost importance for the ants, <em>because</em> those personalized decisions will work <em>against</em> the colony’s survival. So when an atheist says <em>“Ackchually”</em> to a believer and argue that God doesn’t exist, it is like a worker ant saying to a soldier ant that the queen bee doesn’t exist. And if the queen bee doesn’t exist? Then the colony is for naught, nothing the soldier ant does matter anymore, and they might as well just die or spend their remaining life biting some poor human’s ankle.</p><p>And mind you, that same trick also works towards atheists! Just say that the earth is flat, or that even science agrees that God does exist. It’s the same as saying to a worker ant that the queen ant is actually a non-egg-laying transgender ant, or that even the queen ant agrees that there is such a thing as a <em>queen</em> queen ant. That’s gonna trigger the heck out of that worker ant lol.</p><p>Thus, when we go back to the question, “Does God exist?”, are we <em>truly</em>, asking the right question?</p><p>I would argue that, no, we’re asking the wrong question.</p><p>The reason why it’s the wrong question is because, there is literally no <em>queen bee</em> amongst the human species, yet we work, and can only work as a species, when we behave <em>as if</em> we have one. Then the nature of our <em>queen bee</em> is not that of a personification, but that of a <strong><em>trait</em></strong>.</p><p>Let me give you an example.</p><p><em>When you see something awesome, like the vastness of the universe, the might of Niagara falls, the utmost kindness of a mother to her child, humans being kind to other humans, how would you describe such things?</em></p><p>Believers may say that it is the work of God, while atheist may say that it is the work of the universe itself. But both may agree that all of them are <strong><em>godly</em></strong> or <strong><em>godlike. </em></strong>Atheists may disagree with the use of the word God to describe them, but they would agree that it is the closest thing to describe them all neatly in one basket. Here lies the one thing putting both believers and atheist in common: both will agree that there are things that are awesome, transcendent, meaningful, sacred, and greater than themselves. <strong><em>Both can be spiritual</em></strong>, in each of their own separate way.</p><p>Yet the only ontological semantic that can be used to unite both believers and atheists is the adjective form of God. While the personified, object form of “God”, will be debated until the end of time, the trait-based, adjective form of “godly” or “godlike” doesn’t. People may debate whether or not unicorns exist, but people won’t debate whether or not “unicorn-like” exists <em>as a trait</em>. Because the debate is not about the trait’s existence, but about the trait’s existence <em>in the object</em>. People don’t debate whether or not rhinoceros exists because it actually exists; people debate whether or not rhinoceros is unicorn-like. And people don’t debate whether or not “unicorn-like” is an existing trait, the same way people don’t debate whether or not “kind” is a trait actually existing in the world.</p><p>If it gets even more confusing, let me break it down further.</p><p><em>Does kindness exist? What does it look like? Does it have a cubical form? Does it have lungs? Is it composed of hydrocarbons? How was it formed?</em></p><p>Doesn’t make a lot of sense, does it? Because when someone asks you to prove the existence of kindness, you would give an example of people <strong><em>being</em></strong> kind. You do not present the existence of kindness as an object; you present the existence of kindness as an adjective. And when it doesn’t exist in its adjective form, it doesn’t mean that the trait itself doesn’t exist. It means that the trait doesn’t exist <em>in</em> the object being discussed. A trait can exist with or without an object. Yet an object cannot exist without some sort of a trait.</p><p>Hydrogen cannot exist without having the trait of having only one proton and one electron, and when the trait changes, hydrogen also changes to deuterium or something else in accordance to the changing of the trait. But there is no such a thing as a hydrogen without any trait whatsoever. Yet, the trait of having only one proton and electron exists, regardless the existence of hydrogen. At the times before the discovery of hydrogen, one could imagine such a trait. And when hydrogen was finally discovered, that trait becomes one with the hydrogen. People might confuse that that trait can only exist if hydrogen exists, but if hydrogen really doesn’t exist, people still can imagine such a trait existing regardless of the existence of such an object. Like an electron having the trait of positive charge, while there is no electron with a positive charge, one can imagine, hypothesize, and scientifically model a positively-charged electron — and even if there’s no real positively-charged electron out there, it doesn’t mean that “positively-charged”, as a trait, doesn’t exist.</p><p>As convoluted as it is, this is where the disconnect between believers and atheists lies: When atheists tried to prove the non-existence of God, they are putting God in the semantic category of <em>object</em>. Meanwhile, when believers tried to prove the existence of God, they are putting God in the semantic category of <em>adjective</em>. That’s why atheists see believers as out of their minds, for believing unicorns exist. While believers see atheists as absolute buffoons, for asking whether or not kindness has a kidney.</p><p>So, which is it? Is God an object, or an adjective?</p><p>I say, it’s the later.</p><p>When you put God as an adjective, everything starts to make sense. Instead of arguing whether or not kindness exists, now you argue whether or not something is kind. Instead of arguing whether or not God exist, now you argue whether or not something is godly or godlike.</p><p>And it’s easy for anyone to recognize something to be godly or godlike, as per the operational definition of spirituality, if something is greater than you, if something is sacred, if something transcends you, and if something gives you meaning, then that something is godly. The universe is greater than you, so that it’s godly — or that, your community is something greater than you, thus your community is godly. Kindness is sacred for you, thus it is godly — or that, safe space is sacred for you, thus it is godly. Humanity transcends you, hence it is godly — or that, your helps to give alms to the needy transcends you, hence it is godly. Learning gives you meaning, then it’s godly — or that, your children give you meaning, then they’re godly. You have that evolutionary, biological wiring to quickly recognize what things are godly, exactly because you are a highly social species, and a more social a species, the more spiritual they become.</p><p>Suddenly, all the parables and the fables make sense as well when God becomes an adjective:</p><ol><li><strong>Heaven and hell </strong>stop being places which existence need to be proved by building rockets to fly beyond the clouds or digging until the earth’s core. They become states: heavenly and hellish. As you behave godly, you will get closer and closer to a heavenly state of being. And as you behave ungodly, you will get closer and closer to a hellish state of being. The more an ant follows the will of the colony, the more the colony thrives, and the more the an thrives as well — and vice versa.</li><li><strong>Virtue and sin</strong> stop being tokens which conceptually can be regarded as behaving economically. It suddenly doesn’t matter if praying at the mosque is 27 times more virtuous than praying at home, or that if you pay for the church’s indulgences, you will be rid of sins and won’t be put into the purgatory. They become states: virtuous and sinful. Behaviors can be virtuous and sinful. Virtuous behaviors are behaviors bringing you closer to the heavenly state, while sinful behaviors are the ones bringing you closer to the hellish state. Some virtue are more virtuous than others, and some sins are more sinful than others — to each their own spectrum.</li><li><strong>Prayers</strong> stop being mantras that will be heard by God so that your wishes can become true. They no longer means asking for objects, but for adjectives or states. One who prays for health is not asking for some sort of panacea pills to rid them of all illness, but merely to be healthy. One who prays for a Ferrari will sound dumb as heck, sure, but if they pray for wealth, then we know it’s a sound prayer. Suddenly, there’s a right way to pray. And suddenly, you, as an atheist, can just pray for happiness. <em>Pray to who</em>? That’s not the right question, because you’ll be putting God back as an object. Since God is now an adjective, when you pray, you aren’t praying <em>to</em>, but praying <em>for</em>. You are praying for yourself. And turned out, even in modern research, people who talk to oneself are happier and more emotionally regulated. And what are prayers if not talking to, nay, <em>for </em>oneself?</li><li><strong>Biblical stories</strong> stop being nonsensical stories with dumb illogical plots full of plot holes. When you are reading the Quran or the Bible with God as an adjective in mind, now you are reading <em>what kind of adjective</em> <em>does the story tell</em>? The story of Samson collecting a hundred foreskins stops being an outrageous one, but a story to make you ponder: what are the symbolizations, what are the adjectives being talked about, etc. The foreskins (the object) no longer matter, but what they imply matters. Samson (the object) no longer matters, but what he implies matters. Of course you wouldn’t question why a wolf can talk like a human and has enough brainpower to comprehend human language and culture enough to wear grandma’s clothes and try to fool the little red riding hood. But you would ponder what the story implies.</li></ol><p>The distinction between God as an objective and an adjective matters, because it represents what’s missing (or even dismissed) from the discussion: spirituality. The less belief someone has in God, doesn’t mean the less spiritual they become. It is — even in psychological research — another thing entirely. It sure correlates positively with religiosity, but it doesn’t mean spirituality stops existing once someone stops believing in God. In fact, for most people who stopped believing in the conventional God(s) of the modern world (Jesus, Allah, etc.), they usually replace the belief with new age stuffs such as astrology, tarot reading, pagan religions, and arguably, science. Yet, they still have the same animosity towards disbelievers, the same vigor towards their value-system, and the same content one would have for believing in the right thing. These are all aspects of spirituality, which cannot be negated because <strong><em>we are biologically, inherently, spiritual</em></strong>.</p><p>And when we deny our spiritual nature, bad things happen. You become a worker ant disconnected from the colony. Sure, you can stop working and start doing whatever the heck you like. But your very being was made, and only made, to work for the colony. Thus, anything you do, as pleasurable as they are, becomes meaningless. You’re no longer working for something bigger than yourself, but for your own sake only. Nothing transcends you anymore, and everything is either in your control or not your problem. And nothing is sacred anymore, except yourself and your will. A person stripped down of their spirituality becomes a disconnected, self-centered, shell of their former self. The disconnection can also be so unbearable that you will naturally gravitate to seek for some semblance of a colony: a community of like-minded people, a meaningful relationship with a partner, etc. But, again, these are objects. They can exist, and they can also not exist. They can come into existence, and they can cease to exist. So these semblances of a colony won’t last long, and with enough migrations between these pseudo-colonies, hopelessness will arise once you realize nothing lasts forever. Only adjective can exist regardless the existence of objects retaining it, as long as one can imagine it. Hence, the reason why atheists can return into believing in God — no longer as an object, but as an adjective.</p><p>Now, for those of you who are believers, putting God as an adjective will enrich your faith and make you a better person instead of a fatalist extremist who takes everything literally.</p><p>And for those of you who are atheists, putting God as an adjective will make you understand why people believe in God and respect their decisions. While, maybe, also utilizing your innate spirituality to regain your role in the colony of humanity — without arguing whether or not the queen bee exists, because existing or not, your survival and prosperity depends on how faithful you are in playing your role in the colony.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=116280d739e0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Problem with Scientific Research]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PalakieNevermore/the-problem-with-scientific-research-e8e462537823?source=rss-5ce11b14808b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e8e462537823</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Kala Sanggurdi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 09 May 2026 06:57:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-09T07:17:03.772Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Admittedly, it’s been a while since I did any job in research. The last time I did was probably teaching college students multivariate multiple regressions. Or maybe that one strange involvement with the ministry of education, culture, research, and technology — basically the <em>government</em> — about conducting a psychological study regarding museum visits and whatnot. The point is, I am quite familiar with scientific research, specifically <em>social</em> scientific research. I know my <em>alpha</em>, my <em>ANOVA</em>, my <em>G*Power</em>, and, of course, the <em>scientific method</em>. So I think it is suffice to say that I am very, <strong><em>very</em></strong>, familiar with the fundamental problem of scientific research: it’s just guessing with extra steps.</p><p>Now, a disclaimer: I will be talking specifically about quantitative research. Even more specifically, about quantitative research in psychology and (quite surprisingly) nutrition science. I won’t be talking about qualitative research because, frankly speaking, it’s even worse than quantitative. And I won’t be talking about STEM research because they are way more rigorous when it comes to research (that is until you dive into the rabbit hole of engineering and applied science), and mistakes in their “guessing game” have immediate and loud consequences. Also, keep in mind that, as psychology straddles between the line dividing “natural” and “social” science (if you include that one course about action potential in neurons in your early year of psychology study), I think psychology can represent other social science more nicely. So a lot of what I’m talking about will also be applied to other social science like anthropology, sociology, communication science, politics, etc.</p><p>Firstly, regarding the scientific method, the observe-question-hypothesis-analyze-report (or any other iteration), should work as long as your research is transparent, replicable, generalizable, manipulatable, and most importantly in this context, falsifiable. Immediately, we face the first hurdle of social science research: how would you, <strong><em>exactly</em></strong>, <em>falsify</em> a social / psychological phenomenon?</p><p>Say that you want to research depression. You observe depressed people, question why they’re depressed, then make a hypothesis. Unfortunately for you, because you chose to major in psychology, you may know <em>nothing</em> about biological nuances in a human body. You may never have sufficient insights about cell communications, biological operational function of dopamine or serotonin, whether the functions (or malfunctions) causing human depression can be manipulated to emulate simian depression, bovine depression, feline depression, or heck, <em>bacterial</em> depression. You don’t have that nuanced thought-system of a biologist, a physicist, or a mechanical engineer, but you sure do have the thought-system of a social scientist. Hence, your hypothesis would hover <strong><em>around</em></strong> social or psychological phenomena. Maybe because these depressed people behave in such and such way, surrounded by such and such people, interacting in such and such way with such and such environment and such and such people, or have such and such psychological development over the years. You may never develop the thought that, maybe, depressed people are depressed because they’re missing certain minerals, exposed to certain chemicals, or, iunno, have the wrong amount of water in their system that caused the 2.678 Debye of dipole moment when it should have been 2.418 Debye?</p><p>And that’s the thing: because you are a social scientist, your hypothesis will hover around social phenomena. And social phenomena are, for a lack of better words, <strong><em>unfalsifiable</em></strong>. Take a look at the operational definition of depression in DSM-5, for example. Well? There is what they call Major Depressive Disorder, or MDD for short. They don’t exactly define MDD like how regular folks define MDD, but they sure say a lot of things that, if you really think about it, they’re essentially unfalsifiable. Depressed mood, for example. How do you falsify it? Subjective report like feeling sad, empty, or hopeless? Observation from others like, maybe, the depressed people look tearful or down? Or look at the laughably oxymoronic symptom of depression: insomnia <strong><em>or</em></strong> hypersomnia, with a “<strong><em>nearly</em></strong>” everyday clause as the cherry on top. What counts as “<strong><em>nearly</em></strong>”? Is it 6 out of 7 days of the week? Or, as DSM-5 say that the symptom should stay for at least 2 weeks, 13 out of 14 days of the biweek? What do you mean by “or” in that insomnia-hypersomnia? How do you operationally define that “or”? Can they coexist? And on, and on, and on. You can claim that you are depressed with your subjective report. You can claim that you have insomnia. You can claim that you’re thinking about death a lot. You can claim that you feel worthless. But these claims are unfalsifiable. No good scientist can work from these things. But they did, and boy they did find a way to justify using subjective reports as data: the statistical methods.</p><p>Don’t get me wrong; the statistical methods are some of the most beautiful thing that has ever been invented by humanity. It has been a very useful tool to engineer the heck out of research. The learning curve for basic statistics are so low that common folks even (mostly) understand things such as “average”, and with extra steps, “generally”. But when it comes to the next steps, even an average researcher will have a hard time understanding basic statistical jargons like “standard deviation”, “Z-score”, or “p-value”. Let alone the next step like “ANOVA”, or “r squared”, or “effect size”. So almost nobody, and I mean, almost <strong><em>NOBODY</em></strong>, have an idea about how do common statistical methods in research work.</p><p>Let’s explore the most commonly used statistical method used in social science research: STD, statistically-transmitted disease — just kidding, <strong><em>Standard Deviation</em></strong>.</p><p>So common folks usually face statistics and stop at <strong>average</strong>, or in statistical jargon, the <strong><em>mean</em></strong>, <em>x̄,</em> or <em>μ. </em>Put 100 men into a group, measure their heights, and divide the sum of all their heights with the number of men you put into a group, <em>et voila</em>! You get a mean. <strong>Standard deviation</strong> comes when you see what the value of the mean, and measure how far away, <em>in average</em>, the men’s heights are from that value. Say that the mean is 170cm and there’s a midget in that 100 men whose height is 120cm, then his height differs 50cm away from the mean. Then you sum all 100 differences from the mean, divide them with the total number of men, <em>et voila</em>! You <em>haven’t</em> got standard deviation. What you got there is <em>a kind of</em> <strong><em>variance</em></strong>, standard deviation’s retarded little brother (not <em>actual</em> variance, but let’s not prolong this article).</p><p>Any intellectually-average-but-sane person would stop there, but an intellectually-gifted-but-insane person would see an immediate problem: what if, a man’s height is 165cm and another is 175cm, that would mean their difference is -5cm and 5cm respectively, and when summed, they would cancel each other? Yep, that’s why variance is the <em>retarded</em> little brother. If a set of data is <em>homogenous</em> or <em>normal</em> enough (statistical jargon which I won’t be explaining due to this article being long enough), you’d get a value so close to zero that it won’t <em>represent</em> anything significant. Hence, we need to remove those negative -5cm, -8cm, -12cm values. Mathematically, we do that by squaring the values and then rooting them back, thus -5cm becomes 25cm² and then becomes 5cm, ready to be used mathematically.</p><p>Sike! Just kidding. After squaring all the differences, we can’t immediately root them back to their original, non-negative values. We have to sum them all, divide them with the number of men, and then we get to root them back. This is because we are trying to calculate the <em>average</em> difference-from-the-mean. Rooting them before dividing them with the number of men would be <em>geometrically </em>incorrect. Think of it like this: we are trying to calculate the average difference-from-the-mean of 100 square’s <em>length</em>. If we do the same procedure of summing all lengths and measure their squared difference from the mean, then root them before dividing them by 100, what we get is the root of the length of the <em>gigantic</em> square we produced by putting all those 100 squares together. <em>Not</em> the actual average difference-from-the-mean. So geometry matters, order of operation matters, and both you and all the statisticians in the world absolutely hate math for that.</p><p>Alright. We have squared all the differences from the mean, sum them all, divide them by the total number of men (which is 100 if you forgot already), and then, <em>finally</em>, we get to root them. Now we get the actual, pristine, beautiful, <strong>standard deviation</strong>. Or do we?</p><p>Of course not! We have to subtract 1 from that 100! So instead of dividing the sum of squared differences with 100, we divide them with 99 instead.</p><p>Why?</p><p>Here’s where the problem lies: <strong><em>because you would underestimate the true variability of a population</em></strong>.</p><p>So, when you perform a research on society, it’s laughably impossible to expect that you can research the <em>entire</em> society. When we measure the average height of 100 men, that doesn’t mean that there’s only 100 men in this entire world. Even if you do endeavor to measure the height of all 4 billion men, you would miss one because this and that, or a brand new boy is just born a second after you’ve done counting, etc. It’s just impossible to put everyone, the whole <strong><em>population</em></strong>, into your research. You can only take some as a <strong><em>sample</em></strong>. And when we take a sample, their average may not represent the <em>actual</em> population average. It may be the case that your sample’s average is bigger than the population’s average, or smaller. The same goes for your standard deviation. Maybe the population’s standard deviation is wider, or tighter, who knows.</p><p>This is core, fundamental, problem of statistics. Someone named Bessel see this as a problem: sampling a population and get a number out of that sample may not correctly represent the whole population. Which, admittedly, makes sense. What <em>doesn’t</em> make sense is how Bessel corrected it: by subtracting one from the total number of data. Nowadays, this minus-one-from-total-data is called <strong><em>degree of freedom</em></strong>, or <em>df</em> for short. It is used to <em>artificially</em> <em>increase</em> the value of the standard deviation. And THAT’s the problem. Bessel’s correction only accommodates for cases in which the population’s standard deviation is <em>smaller</em> than the standard deviations of <em>all</em> samples of that population.</p><p>What Bessel did there is what you would call <em>engineering the heck out of statistics</em>. It’s the exact same behavior of a mechanical engineer rounding pi into 3. Because frankly, it works! If it’s stupid but it works, then it’s not stupid! You would assume that the bigger the population, the more <em>average</em> the population would be, and the <em>smaller</em> its variability. When you take only a 100 men’s heights, you would assume their standard deviation would be 10cm from their average. When you take the whole 4 billion men’s heights, you would assume the gigantic number would crunch down the standard deviation to be 5cm, 1cm, or heck, 1mm away from the average height.</p><p>This assumption would be fine… if we’re talking about physics and chemistry. Because, you would expect that a hydrogen on earth would behave the same way as a hydrogen on the star Vega. You would expect that if you give carbon oxygen, you would get carbon dioxide, no matter if you’re on earth or on Uranus. But we’re talking about social science. We’re talking about the jumbled mess we call society. There’s bound to be shenanigans such as a population having a standard deviation that is actually wider than any of the samples taken from it.</p><p>And we’re only talking about <strong><em>standard deviation</em></strong>.</p><p>Standard deviation is, like, the 2nd step of learning statistics after learning the average. There are more, scarier things. Z-score, t-test, ANOVA, linear regression, and so on. But in almost all of them, the shaky foundation of standard deviation exists.</p><p>And even in each of those things I said, there are more shaky, engineer-shenanigans-related , foundations. For example, when performing one-way ANOVA, famously the most frequently used statistical methods for social science research, you would have to calculate the G*Power before doing your research so you’d know how many samples you have to take from the population. This involves, in one of them, finding the value of <strong><em>effect size</em></strong>, or in one-way ANOVA, <strong><em>Cohen’s f</em></strong>. And how exactly do researchers get the value of <em>f</em>? That’s right, from the result of previous researches! What if there’s no previous research? Then you may do a pilot research first and take the value of <em>f</em> from the samplings you get (this is just previous research with extra steps). What if you can’t do a pilot research due to budget constraints or deadlines or whatnot? You use Cohen’s conventions! That’s right! <strong><em>Conventions</em></strong>! A value of <em>f</em> you get from <em>assumptions</em>! What if you don’t want to use Cohen’s conventions? Then you use your <em>own</em> conventions by defining <em>minimum meaningful difference</em>! See the problem? Even if you rely on the previous research, how would you think the previous research found their <em>f</em>? From previous, previous research? Then how did they get their <em>f</em>? That’s a chicken-and-egg problem. And frankly speaking, earlier research have way more assumptions and less rigorous research practices. The earlier, the worse.</p><p>This is the house of cards upon which <strong><em>ALL </em></strong>modern social science resides. Every social science research involving numbers are bound to have both of falsifiability problem of social phenomena, and numerical assumption problems from statistical methods made to tackle universal natural phenomena. Your psychology, your anthropology, your sociology, your political science, your <em>entire</em> knowledge regarding social sciences, are based on statistical tomfoolery.</p><p><strong>So, what to do?</strong></p><p>With this in mind, whenever I’m dealing with social science, I would alternate between these two options:</p><ol><li><strong>Fall back to a more natural science. </strong>When it comes to learning psychology, for example, I would never assume something in psychology is true if it’s unexplainable by biology, geography, chemistry, or other science. When talking about depression, I won’t use definitions provided by DSM-5, but rather, use neurological, chemical, or biological definitions of depression. So far, I’ve defined depression as general inflammatory disease in which the body thinks that it’s currently sick so it rises up its defense until the body becomes generally inflamed. Since this kind of behavior is almost universal beyond human species, I’ll buy it instead of the common DSM-5 definition.</li><li><strong>Double down on the assumptions</strong>. Since <em>any</em> research on social science is founded on assumptive statistical tomfoolery, then just double down on assumptions as long as it makes sense to me. Because social phenomena are inherently unfalsifiable by default, then I should default on assuming that two opposing truths can still be both true. Men can be both good and evil. Women can be both gentle and vicious. “There is such a thing as racial differences” is true, and so is “there is no such thing as racial differences”. If it helps me understand the world better, if it helps me better navigate the social phenomena around me, even if they’re all assumptions, then I’ll buy it. So any definition of depression, from the ones I get from DSM-5 or a random Instagram reels, if it makes sense, then I’ll buy it.</li></ol><p>Does this mean that social science is useless? Bullcrap? Of course not. Remember that even though the statistical methods are assumptions of the engineers of statistics, you would still trust an engineer even if they round up pi to 3. If it’s stupid but it works, then it works. Doubling down on my own assumptions sound stupid, but it works for me. So does reading countless articles of depression, dozens of thesis about astrology reading, and actually reading neurological results of neurotransmitter interactions inside certain regions of the brain. They are still useful and still relevant, but their usefulness and relevance are only applicable if they do actually help you navigate the society better — or even yourself better.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e8e462537823" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>