<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Patrick Jones on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Patrick Jones on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@PatrickJones09?source=rss-2e528064a994------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 15:09:42 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@PatrickJones09/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Souls and Bodies”: A Novel of Liberal Catholicism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PatrickJones09/souls-and-bodies-a-novel-of-liberal-catholicism-48182ee725a3?source=rss-2e528064a994------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/48182ee725a3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Patrick Jones]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 Jun 2016 03:00:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-06-23T19:10:57.225Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>“Souls and Bodies”: A Novel of Liberal Catholicism</strong></p><p>I just finished reading David Lodge’s “Souls and Bodies.” Lodge came recommended by a good friend with the forewarning that he might make me depressed. Turns out, he is a more obscure member of a great English pedigree: a Catholic novelist with a gift for satire. Indeed, two characters in his book are literature students at the University of London with respective preferences for Graham Greene and Evelyn Waugh, two great patriarchs of those traditions.</p><p>Lodge is well known for his satirical works on academic and literary life. His “Campus Trilogy” deals with the realities of conferences, professional literary theory and criticism, and life inside a modern department while ironically engaging theories of the meta-novel through deliberately self-conscious formal artifices.</p><p>These blatant artifices also exist in “Souls and Bodies,” where Lodge intermittently chimes in as the novelist, expressing his own intentions in the creation of characters and story lines.</p><p>Remembering my late grandfather, lifelong English professor and prolific novelist in his later years, I wonder if he was a fan of Lodge. I can only imagine he would have appreciated a facetious and honest take on the world of literary academia. What he may have also appreciated, but I appreciate all the more, is Lodge’s telling of the story of the modern Catholic Church.</p><p>In a brief preface to his “Sword of Honor” trilogy, Evelyn Waugh recapitulates the great theme of his masterpiece: “Brideshead Revisited”. That novel tells the story of the last days of English aristocracy, an institution so deeply ingrained in the history of his own island civilization that its disappearance would mark the beginning of troubling age. What Waugh did not expect were changes in the Catholic Church as he knew it, the one institution which had the best chance of maintaining itself against the tides of modernity by virtue of its proclamation of eternal truth, enshrined in sacred tradition. But as Waugh completed his last great series of novels, Vatican II occurred. Among the English, both Waugh and Tolkien were known for their dogged protest to the work of the Council.</p><p>The Catholics among us are likely well acquainted with these delicious personalities, rebellious in their faithfulness. We all can also all map the symbolisms inlaid in “The Lord of the Rings” (despite Tolkien’s direct injunction not to do so) and are moved by Waugh’s tales of an exile Church among the ruins. But Lodge offers something I haven’t yet encountered: the story of the modern Church from the perspective of the modernizers. And it is a story which focuses quite candidly on that great pre-occupation of our times and thus of Catholics both “liberal” and “conservative”: sex.</p><p>The story begins in the 50’s, when the Mass was attended breviary-in-hand, English translations at the ready, and call and response between the priest and the laity was considered an innovation and a fad. The young people in the pews on this weekday morning come to Church with different pre-occupations. Lodge describes the variety of their upbringings and levels of piety, all under the aspect of their relationship to sex. Almost all of them are virgins, so he first distinguishes between masturbators and non-masturbators. Some are more fixated than others, some more austere, and some naive. One character in particular wrestles with late adolescent lust in a sympathetically desperate form. He is obsessed with breasts but, unable to avail himself of the total exposure of contemporary pornography, he walks the streets to eye mannequins and searches for bra adds. With no actual sexual experience, his fixation on breasts relies on imagination and inference. The more hidden female organ is utterly beyond the powers of his fantasy. Unable to resist his constant sexual urges, the poor boy considers himself unable to receive communion. Afraid to speak his private shame in the confessional but nevertheless seeking absolution, he invents doctrinal doubts. Rather than admitting that he cannot stop masturbating, he claims that he no longer believes in Papal Infallibility or Transubstantiation.</p><p>To describe the Catholic life, Lodge employs the image of “spiritual snakes and ladders”. The life of grace is a game in which one seeks to avoid sin, which usually is anything that feels good, and pursue virtue, which is usually those things which are dull or hard. The soul (and body) are bound to fall at some point as they advance up the ladder. But not to worry: the means for resetting are always at hand in the form of the Sacrament of Penance. Lodge describes the “system” of the sacraments and the moral life with the precision of a weary former believer who has known it all from the inside. Indeed, Lodge described himself as such.</p><p>The game of snakes and ladders for these young souls hinges mostly on their sexuality. The question for them all is “how far can you go?” This fun phrase is actually the original title of the novel, changed to “Souls and Bodies” for its American release. It is a question they are constantly asking themselves as as they pursue courtships in their college years and carries them through the arc of the story.</p><p>The novel follows the normal stages on life’s way (youth, courtship, marriage, career, children), but within the exciting societal and ecclesiastical changes of the mid 20th century. The characters are just old enough that they are starting to have families by the time the 60s roll around. While the liberalizing spirit of those times is persuasive for most of them, they are not quite young enough to be hippies. They are living fairly traditional lives in comparison to their slightly younger contemporaries. They have marriages, children, and jobs. For them the great issue of the moment, at least in the story Lodge tells of them, is the debate over <em>Humanae Vitae. </em>They are all (except for the most conservative of them, who happens to also be the only homosexual) opposed to the teaching, and had expected the verdict to fall the opposite way. Their reaction to <em>Humanae Vitae </em>turns inevitably into more than a rejection of a single teaching but to the idea of the Magisterium, of Papal and Episcopal Authority, and eventually to the bedrock of traditional Catholic moral and theological claims.</p><p>The genius and novelty of Lodge’s story lies in its portrayal not of radical transformations from traditional morality and family structure to bohemianism, but of the protracted spiritual crisis of a generation who cannot let go of their faith, or rather of their Church, but cannot bring themselves to accept its Old Ways. Each character, save one sexy, fast-living young woman who marries a hedonistic TV producer, wants to remain Catholic. To many, the options would be quite simple: join a more open Protestant Church or abandon their Christian faith entirely. But to Lodge’s characters, the answer is a certain vision of Reform.</p><p>The characters we first encounter in the solemn, gothic atmosphere of pre-Vatican II Catholicism eventually form their own lay movement, the Coalition of an Open Church. The same priest who had ministered to them in college becomes both their spiritual guide and charity case. Persuaded toward a demythologized interpretation of the Scriptures in the course of higher studies, Fr. Austin Brierley is also a study in the question “how far can you go?”. For him, it pertains to the limits of what can be believed. How many of the claims of Scripture and Theology can be taken more as metaphor than reality, and just how much can one demythologize while still considering oneself a Christian? Placed on probation for his vocal opposition to <em>Humanae Vitae</em>, his old friends raise money to support him as they laud him for his heroic defiance of Church autocracy and clericalism.</p><p>Their little society begins hosting small household gatherings, where a symbolic re-enactment of the Paschal meal of Bread and Wine takes place before the sharing of a communal supper. They call these celebrations of Christian community “Agapes” and are pleased to identify them with early Christian love-feasts. While so-called conservatives might smirk when reading Lodge’s descriptions of the many inventions of these characters as they try to maintain their faith amidst a host of doubts, should we not also pause to recognize the awful sincerity of their attempts? True to life, some characters are more attached than others to the religious significance of their new-found rituals and beliefs, while others ultimately discover unbelief or apathy as the old forms dissolve around them. And in the end, just like Lodge himself, their Catholicism slips away along with the stability of their sexual and marital lives.</p><p>I relish the last chapter of this novel, where a documentary film crew (maybe we would even call it a reality TV crew) comes to produce a special report on the new movement. In the form of a script, each of our characters articulates their views on the Big Questions haunting 1970’s Catholicism. Some of their sentiments exude the all-too-familiar praise of religiosity over actual religion. Some seem more militant in their continuing struggle to overthrow the hackneyed system of Catholic doctrine and authority. One character, despite his persistent involvement with this crowd, just can’t let go of his belief in Transubstantion and in miracles. He remains, aside from our traditionally minded, homosexual Oxford don, the only character who can’t let go of elements his friends and family are inching ever more away from. At the very end, we are told of a young couple, children of our baby boomer protagonists, who return to the Old Ways and pursue the chaste courtship that so troubled and confused their parents.</p><p>In the end, Lodge’s story is one of loose ends and tangled knots. Not only is it’s portrayal of the struggles of sexuality and the, shall I say, un-romaticized realities of Catholic life cathartically true, but the lack of final resolution captures the feelings of hopelessness experienced both by those seeking to maintain their faith in its fullness and those struggling to rebuild the Church according to their own vision. The novel ends with the election of John Paul II, a man who combined populist charisma with a deep theological conservatism. Lodge seems to see a paradox in this new figure on the scene and is interested to see in what direction the Church will move. The questions Lodge raises are, at least in the domain of history and events, still churning within the Body of the Church. Lodge insinuates that the spirit of his characters may be on the wane as the 70’s end, but that as in all temporal things, the future is unknown. And as in all ages of our exile, not a one of us can bring about the coming of Kingdom for which we hope.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=48182ee725a3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Education Ruined Me]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PatrickJones09/how-education-ruined-me-6be7e45d73fe?source=rss-2e528064a994------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6be7e45d73fe</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Patrick Jones]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Apr 2016 21:03:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-11T21:03:06.402Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>How Education Ruined Me</strong></p><p>This post will be something of a sequel to my earlier post on liberal education. There, charged with enthusiasm and wishing to carry the standard of a noble and nearly lost tradition, I tried to tell of the deepest virtue of a Socratic education. I still cling to that standard and wish to be its herald. I even wish to cling to it to the point of folly! I want to be the Quixote of learning! I want to strive against the leveling, utilitarian tides of technical culture to the point of folly!</p><p>Maybe you are rolling your eyes at me right now. After all, you should be. These grandiose imaginings are all taking place in a messy room of a lonely boy who has no job and spends his days alternately writing cover letter after cover letter and reading books on the Jesuits. But herein lies the point.</p><p>Education has ruined me.</p><p>As I pointed out in my earlier post, I did not go to college for a career’s sake. And I took that as a point of pride. I was escaping the vulgarity of common life to join the Republic of Letters. I was recovering lost wisdom, striving to understand the greatest ideas (Plato) and to uncover the dark and contradictory roots of modern culture (Nietzsche). I was singing Gregorian Chant, getting outrageously drunk often, and singing the St. Matthew Passion while in that state. It was glorious.</p><p>All the while, I was maintaining my high and mighty disdain for the world. The world I had fought so hard to reject and subvert by means of adolescent rebellion. The world I had kicked in the face by dropping out of high school and going straight to a Great Books college. I loved to tell people that we did not have newspapers delivered to campus and that our greatest technological asset was a metal ring fixed on a concrete block that measured the course of the sun. I relished ancient terra-centric astronomy.</p><p>Now, six years out, I am a wanderer. My attempts at further formal studies haven’t been completed. I have clung desperately to the commitment never to go into a normal job or career, to my detriment. I have never been able to pay my bills without assistance for more than a year. I have moved to Texas, South Carolina, Massachusetts, Washington, and New York, and have found each adventure confusing and not completely successful. Now, at 26, it’s finally dawning on me that I have to somehow find gainful employment. I’m facing, later than others due to my bourgeois background, the humbling common struggles of life.</p><p>Now, this does not prove a universal point. Others of my former colleagues in learning have done well for themselves, or at least found a stable path. This is my personal story which involves my personal circumstances and features of my own character. Nevertheless, liberal education has exacerbated and fueled proclivities that churned inside of me my whole life.</p><p>I’ll compare myself as a teenager with the middle-aged Don Quixote. Both of us lived basically idle and boring lives. But then, we started reading books. His books were chivalric novels. Mine were Homer, Plato, and Aristotle. Specifically Plato. I found the example of the philosopher king and of the city ordered on philosophic principles romantic. The philosophic life was heroic, just as the chivalric life was for Don Quixote. I had something to strive for! A grand idea! Of course, no-one outside of my cohort would understand it. I would be set apart from the world. I would even defy the world and all of it’s evils! I would vanquish those knaves who would destroy my Beautiful Lady, Philosophy.</p><p>And I persisted in this conviction. I became, in my way, a reactionary. And I am still one to this day. And perhaps the chastening that has come through my broken experience of the world outside the Republic of Letters has only fueled that spirit within me.</p><p>Recently I have been reading “The Magic Mountain”. This is one of those books people are always talking about, that precious few have read in its entirety. No doubt this has to do with its dense prose and long stretches of nothing really happening. This style is intentional, of course. It imitates the experience of the main character as he relegates himself to a form of secular monasticism, high up in the rarified airs of the Alps.</p><p>Reading this novel couldn’t have come at a better time. I am currently immersed in a months long stretch of listlessness, out of a job and daily struggling with my deep antipathy toward getting one. Mann’s protagonist, Hans Castorp, is about to be gainfully employed as an engineer when he makes a visit to the alpine TB clinic to visit his cousin. He had to find a stable career out of financial necessity, but while he liked thinking about building ships, he found actual work draining and unappetizing.</p><p>Once Hans gets up the mountain, he begins to philosophize. This is not an experience he is familiar with. He is described as average. Brighter than a dummy, but certainly no shining star. But once he is far away from the “lowlands”, from the goings-on of a mercantile city and the duties of life in the world, he is overcome by a spirit of reflection. His cousin, who only longs to break out of this inactivity and get back to his military post, finds his musings on the nature of time irrelevant.</p><p>I thought I wouldn’t ever finish the book until a certain character appeared. Leo Naptha is a Jesuit, a convert from Judaism, and a gadfly. He is constantly contradicting the values of the bourgeois humanist Settembrini who adores progress, democratization, the world economy, the overcoming of religious superstition, and the alleviation of suffering through science. I was vaguely attracted to Settembrini as a man of letters, though I found his ideology distasteful. Naptha, in his darkness, was a breath of fresh air. Naptha, like everyone else on the mountain, lives a life of seclusion. Unable to be ordained due to his illness, he spends his days in his cheap but delicately decorated apartment, reading and conversing with his friend and antagonist Settembrini.</p><p>The secluded, reflective, rarified life of Naptha and the other patients reminds me of the life of Nietzsche. A wanderer who travelled through Switzerland and Italy. Switching locations depending on his health and mood, he lived amongst fashionable society while privately developing sinister criticisms of his times and indeed, of the previous 18 and a half centuries.</p><p>Montaigne, a more peaceable figure than Nietzsche, retired from official duties to live on his estate, ride his horses, take advantage of his private library, and examine himself. Rousseau, problem child that he was, eventually sought refuge from unnatural society, desiring only to have his reveries without the oppressive interference of priests, governors, lovers, friends, and enemies. Pascal, a boy genius, took refuge in the Jansenist convent of Port-Royal to catalogue his thoughts and seek God. Hume, free from the burdens of absolute ideas and duties, ate, drank, and played boardgames. He had the happiest fate.</p><p>And one more lesser known example: Nicolas Gomez Davila, Don Colacho. I have never read about someone whose life I so sorely envied. Don Colacho came from a wealthy Colombian family, never finished college due to illness, married at 20, and immediately retired to his family home. He raised three children, collected 30,000 books, read constantly, enjoyed the company of friends, and wrote for its own sake. He was a self-described reactionary, who criticized almost every aspect of the modern age. BUT-through originality of thought, genuine erudition, a sense of nuance, and an aversion to fixed ideas, he avoids some of the crass bigotry of conservative critics. At the very least, he is interesting. His books are not published in English, but there is a blog with his complete aphoristic works here: <a href="http://don-colacho.blogspot.com/">http://don-colacho.blogspot.com/</a></p><p>But to return to Leo Naptha, the dark Jesuit. The same friend who recommended and lent me “The Magic Mountain” took me to task for my exaltation of that character. He is, so my friend said, a nihilist and a paradigmatic case of <em>ressentiment</em>. Indeed, while Settembrini the humanist tries to cast out from young Castorp’s mind a pre-occupation with the superiority of illness and death over health and life, Naphtha continually uses the most offensive rhetoric to argue a case for suffering and even torture. Suffering, which Settembrini wishes to alleviate for good through the use of science both technical and social, is for Naptha man’s pathway out of nature toward his supernatural fulfillment.</p><p>To thoroughly parse the arguments of these two interlocutors would reveal many twists and turns of logic. Many contradictions of previous assertions for the purpose of the moment. Indeed, Mann points out that these two are lost in their own paradoxes. Naphtha in particular. This goes hand in hand with his statements that scientific or “objective” truth is a fiction, and that any knowing in fact proceeds from faith-from an act of the will. In his Nietzscheanism, Naphtha is empowered to adapt his truth-claims to the purposes of iconoclasm. And this is exactly what he does to his rationalist partner in debate.</p><p>Hans Castorp stands between the two as they argue, now and again throwing in some abstruse <em>pensee</em>. He never takes sides, but wanders in abstract reflection and its accompanying indecision. Unlike Naphtha, whose illness consigns him to his brooding and charges his contrarianism, and unlike Settembrini, who expresses a desire for action while never actually acting, Castorp is content to sit on his balcony, behold the mountains and the trees and “play king” of his own world.</p><p>Towards the end of the novel, Hans begins to be haunted by a dreadful feeling. He encounters a demon called Stupor. The demon that walks the halls of the mountain retreat, swallowing all the unfortunates who have become trapped in this rarified life. It’s as if, all of a sudden, Hans has experienced a deep change in his attitude towards seclusion. At this point, though, he feels that he cannot get out. There is an atmosphere of doom.</p><p>When a gramophone is introduced, he begins to obsessively listen to music and even commandeers the machine and albums for himself. He falls in love with <em>Carmen</em>. I’ll quote some important lines that Mann gives us from a chorus of that opera:</p><p>“Oh, follow the mountains fair/The hills and crags and purest air/To roam and walk with happy pride?Your fatherland, the world so wide!/You shall obey your will alone./A gift more rare than precious stone/Is freedom, freedom, ’tis your own”</p><p>I couldn’t help but think of Nietzsche’s song of Prinz Vogelfrei, Prince Free-as-a-Bird. It’s Nietzsche’s song of the free spirit, who dwells in high mountains tops (Aus Hohen Bergen is another of his songs) and when his body and his mission declare it, descends to the “lowlands”. This he can only do after fortifying himself with his own freedom. For Nietzsche, the height of faithfulness is the commitment to fight against any extraneous influence, anything that does not serve the purpose of self-overcoming and cultivation of the ego. The only idol is the cause or the idea that inhibits the progress beyond good and evil.</p><p>I have been interested for a while in examining the appearance of secular monasteries in early modern literature, the foremost example of which comes at the end of <em>Gargantua</em>. This monastery is founded by a rogue Franciscan priest, is for women and men, and strives against the influence of the schools. It’s motto: “do what thou wilt”. It is the secularization of the Pauline concept “love and do what thou wilt”. The inhabitants of the monastery devote themselves to humanistic and naturalistic studies.</p><p>At the end of <em>Candide</em>, a famous critique of theodicy, Voltaire espouses his commandment, or rather his ethical truism: “one must cultivate his own garden”. In the face of the chaos of the world, in the face of its disorder and lack of higher justice, one can live most authentically by tending to one’s own affairs. Free will can be best exercised by limiting itself to the task of creating the closest approximation to a personal Eden.</p><p>All of these ideas appeal to the frustrated philosophical wanderer. I have always had a form of monastic instinct, and have consequently found inspiration in the various examples of philosophers throughout the ages who have cloistered themselves, each in his own way, for the pursuit of self-examination and freedom. Ah, precious freedom. But how many of this great and noble and free spirits did not collapse? Nietzsche came to his notorious and tragic end. Rousseau ended his life frustrated, paranoid, and obsessed. Pascal died early and in angst. Montaigne seemed content in his healthy acceptance of the loose ends of life. And Hume, convinced of ultimate uncertainty, could happily relieve himself of melancholy with the reliefs of common people: eating, drinking, playing games.</p><p>St. Anthony of the Desert always stands as a confounder of my bookish pride. Moved to the bottom of his being by the words “Go, give all you have to the poor, and follow me”, he immediately abandoned his precious books and ran to the desert. When asked how he could pursue truth without the help of his volumes he replied “I have the entire book of nature before me!” St. Augustine speaks of those who are so permeated by faith, hope, and love that they don’t even have to read the Scriptures anymore. I find it interesting Hans Castorp does not read any books during his philosophical long retreat.</p><p>I’m not sure how to conclude the winding road that is this post. Obviously, my education has imparted to me a heavy degree of windbagedness. My initial character, Don Quixote, suffers as well from this defect. After reading his romantic novels, he lapses into long, inspired, ridiculous speeches. His family can only shake their heads, roll their eyes, and hope that maybe if the right medication is found, this perversion of the brain can be fixed. Eventually it is through the intervention of a priest and the sacrament of penance that Quixote is cured of his absurd quest and retires back to his quiet and boring life. St. Anthony took his pursuit to the desert. Augustine, former founder of a small philosophical/sexual community, turned to the life of penance and prayer and the right-headedness of an intellectual life ordered by Catholic authority. As for me, one of “life’s problem children”, confused, frayed, and disordered by education, where will my story end? That’s a crazy question. I’m only 26. But I pray to God to deliver me from the Stupor of this dazzling but sick mountain. Of course, I pray in the way Augustine famously prays for chastity: “give me order and sense and duty, but not yet”. Surely, by some garden-moment, or perhaps through the collapse that terminates an unsustainable journey, I will be brought low and then raised. But I pray as well that I will not meet Quixote’s fate: that an intervening authority will not lock my books away. Rather, may the Spirit speak to me through a child’s voice: “Take, read”. And may this unbaptized education be finally vindicated and turned to some good use before it is the death of me.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6be7e45d73fe" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Man And Woman in The Movies of Terrence Malick and Lars Von Trier]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PatrickJones09/man-and-woman-in-the-movies-of-terrence-malick-and-lars-von-trier-4536568c821c?source=rss-2e528064a994------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4536568c821c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Patrick Jones]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 26 Mar 2016 02:40:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-03-26T02:40:23.355Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Man And Woman in The Movies of Terrence Malick and Lars Von Trier</strong></p><p>I went to see the new Terrence Malick movie “Knight of Cups” last week. Let me be clear from the outset, I will be using the word “movie” and not the word “film” for the entirety of this article. I object to people like me using the word “film” because it connotes a real artistic connection to the cinema that I do not have. I am a pedestrian moviegoer who happens to have found my way into the work of several artistic directors. Malick is one of them.</p><p>I’ve seen all of his movies except for one (“Badlands”). I acquired a taste for them over about a year while studying philosophy in college. I have been a big fan of his recent run of releases from 2011 to present: “Tree of Life”, “To the Wonder”, “Knight of Cups”. He has always had strong religious themes, but these last three really make him a great explorer of the topic. I don’t want to pigeonhole him as a Christian, but rather to see him as in the vein of Dostoevsky. He takes up these deeply significant questions in a spirit that is non-apologetical and universally meaningful. Fan of Dostoevsky that he is, he might not be offended.</p><p>Another artsy director I have been into for several years is Lars Von Trier. I discovered him when I went to see “Melancholia” in 2011. I was blown away. This remains possibly my favorite movie. I was lucky enough to have just come out of a bad emotional episode when I saw it, so I could really connect. If you’ve seen it, remember the scene where Kirsten Dunst tries to eat her favorite meal but spits it all out because it tastes like ash? It doesn’t get any better than that. Interestingly, Von Trier is also influenced by Christianity. He converted to Catholicism many years ago, though apparently only to piss off his Protestant step-father. Nevertheless, if you watch some of his Cannes interviews (I highly recommend it), you will see him go on long rants about Christianity. He loves to highlight how the Roman Catholic Church is the “Church of the Crucifixion” while the Eastern Orthodox Church is the “Church of the Holy Spirit”. He explains this distinction to a perplexed journalist. It’s priceless.</p><p>“Knight of Cups” was an Augustinian movie, except that it did not end in a conversion. The character does not, in the end, discover “beauty ever ancient, ever new” though he does start to sense that it is there, hidden and forgotten. This movie focuses on forgetting and on the journey back home. It opens with the first lines of “Pilgrim’s Progress”. The protagonist then remembers a parable about a Prince who is promised a great treasure by his father but eventually forgets about it. Christian Bale’s character wallows in his carnality and in his deficient loves, sensitive enough to know that he is lost, confused enough that he does not know how to escape.</p><p>The story is told through his relationship with several women. There is an ex-wife, a stripper, a woman who may be a prostitute, and a married woman that is in love with him. These are all very different people and very different relationships, but each of these women can pierce through his skin. Each one sees him for what he is, much better than he can see himself. The prostitute and stripper are the most oracular in their assessments, while the ex wife and the married woman, more wounded due to the depth of their love for him, can hardly have enough indifference to sum him up so tersely.</p><p>One line stood out to me in this movie. The ambiguous prostitute, whom he claims to love, tells him that he does not want love but only the experience of love. Hard not to remember St. Augustine’s words: “I was in love with love”. It is impossible for this man to truly accept love or to love truly. He is looking for it. But he always makes promises he can’t keep because he grasps at the shade, the image of the real thing.</p><p>Kate Blanchett plays the ex-wife. She is beautiful in her statuesque, angular, intriguing Kate Blanchett way. She is a nurse and there are many scenes of her touching and healing extremely disfigured people. She is a saint among the lepers. She tells the man that all she wanted was to love him and make him happy but that he was always half in, half out of the relationship. He is always in this in between state with love.</p><p>It’s been a while since I saw “To the Wonder”, but I remember one episode in the movie very distinctly. The main characters are involved in a re-union after a romantic relationship that began in France. They are married in a civil ceremony, and the female character decides she wants to have her intrauterine device removed so she can have children. The male is very hesitant. He is half in, half out. He marries her in the church as per her request, but the relationship only devolves.</p><p>In Malick’s movies, women are not only deeply connected to love and life through children (cf. “Tree of Life), they have intuitive insight into unseen things. All the women in “Knight of Cups” know the man much better than he knows himself. Each wants his love, but sees that he is unable to hand it to them. The female in “To the Wonder” struggles with an extremely detached, aloof male partner. She is close to God, though, much like the mother of the dead child in “Tree of Life.” The things that are hidden from the “wise” and known to the humble are right before their eyes, albeit still mysteriously. The secrets can still only be seen through a glass darkly. But they are able to love and to feel the complexities of the heart. One sees parallels to the New Testament, where Jesus’ most faithful disciples are women. His mother Mary who allowed God’s will to be done through her, Mary Magdalene who anointed Jesus with precious oils, Veronica who offers to wipe His face while he carries the cross, the women of Jerusalem who weep for Him as he is shamefully marched to a shameful death.</p><p>Jesus is not aloof. Jesus loves to the end and promises that the Good Shepherd will leave his entire flock to search for just one sheep who is lost. His 12 male apostles, the ones who will be charged with preaching the Gospel throughout the world, are confused, cowardly, and violent. Peter makes promises he cannot keep: “I will go die with you”. The Sons of Thunder ask Jesus if they can call down fire from heaven to punish those who reject him. Even though Jesus has repeatedly told Peter that He must be betrayed and must meet his death, Peter desperately lunges at the high priest’s slave with a sword. He attempts to control the situation in an impotent act of violence. And, of course, Peter denies him three times.</p><p>When Jesus is resurrected, he appears first to women. He sends them as messengers to the apostles. They are the witnesses, who receive Jesus with open arms rather than with doubt, confusion, or fear. And throughout the entire Gospel, Jesus is attacked by society for associating with prostitutes and those who are considered unclean. Well, in Malick’s story, the stripper and prostitute (?), easily judged as incapable of a spiritually rich understanding of love, are far more connected to the heart than the male character.</p><p>On to Lars Von Trier. Lars has been attacked for his portrayal of women, which is not surprising. Especially if you’re talking about “Antichrist”. Charlotte Gainsbourg’s character, unmanageably traumatized by the death of her child, becomes obsessed with a research project involving medieval witch hunts. She begins to tell her husband that these women deserved their fate. Basically, she starts saying that women are evil.</p><p>The child in “Antichrist” dies because the couple are having sex. They aren’t paying attention and their baby crawls out of a window. This is so Lars Von Trier. He immediately causally links the life-giving act of sex with the destruction of its own fruits. Life is death. Again, it reminds of St. Augustine, who draws attention to the sexual act as the source of the communication of original sin. The husband in “Antichrist” (Willem DeFoe) is unbearable, if you ask me. Faced with this absolutely catastrophic situation, he tries to keep calm and carry on. He very obviously prides himself on his composure. And, a professional therapist, he pulls out all his handy therapist tricks on his wife. He coolly explains to her the stages of grief. I believe nowadays we call this “mansplaining”. He decides she needs a retreat.</p><p>Long story short, going into nature does not bring her peace. In fact, it only brings her closer to the conviction that life is evil. “Nature is Satan’s church”, she proclaims. In one of the movies most beloved scenes, a fox tells her “Chaos reigns”. Her husband is unable to accept chaos. He is unable to accept evil. Everything can be rationally controlled by a method.</p><p>Incorrect.</p><p>Shattered by her realizations, Charlotte Gainsbourg follows a very primitive copulation session with genital mutilation. She destroys his testicles, which store the seed. And she removes her clitoris, which is the source of her pleasure. Life is evil. Pleasure is evil.</p><p>“Melancholia” doesn’t take things to this insanely gruesome level. But it has some similar features. It begins with Kirsten Dunst’s marriage. Her sister and brother in law own an enormous manor that they rent out as a hotel. The wedding takes place there. There is a charming scene that opens the movie where the soon to be married couple have to push their limo out of a rut. Giggling and pecking all the while. It’s the kind of story your parents would like to tell about their wedding.</p><p>But it’s not long before we see that something is very wrong. Kirsten can’t deal with the situation. She runs away and throws herself on a bed. It’s an experience close to home for anyone who has suffered from depression or despair. Keiffer, the movie’s main douchebag, comes to her room to tell her to pull herself together. Does she realize how much money he’s spending on this? Well she tries. And she can’t. She runs away, impulsively and aggressively fucks a golf caddy (I use that dirty word because it is the correct word here) and then breaks a whole bunch of stuff.</p><p>The first part of the movie ends with the groom, a very dapper and seemingly grounded man, leaving. “What did you expect?” says Kirsten. Apparently, she has had struggles before and was hoping she could finally pull it together. This is a long movie, so I’ll try not to summarize too much. Basically, the planet Melancholia is on a collision course with Earth. Kieffer Sutherland is obsessed with tracking it. Through the use of observation and careful rational calculation, he assures himself and his extremely anxious wife that they are safe. Just like the husband in “Antichrist”, the husband in “Melancholia” tries to suppress his wife’s fears through a trusty method.</p><p>But Kirsten Dunst, who has been living with them as she recovers from a disabling bout of depression, knows the truth. She knows that Melancholia will in fact hit Earth and destroy everything. It even turns out that she literally has oracular powers. She knows things it’s impossible to know, and Von Trier delightfully doesn’t say any more about it. It’s good that Earth will be destroyed, says Dunst, because life is evil. It is the wisdom of Silenus, the ancient satyr: “Oh man, it is better that you had never been born”. Kirsten Dunst’s sister, played by Charlotte Gainsbourg, can’t handle the thought of apocalypse. Mainly because of her fear of death and her love for her son. And Kirsten is downright cold to her. Face the facts. The world is evil. It’s best for us all to die. When Keiffer Sutherland realizes that Melancholia definitely will hit Earth, he abandons his family by committing suicide. He is the true coward, while his wife stays with her son so that he won’t die alone.</p><p>Both of these directors deal with life and death, heaven and hell, and sex. They each have religion woven deeply into their stories, though it could be said that “Melancholia” is so thoroughly influenced by Romanticism that it leaves Christianity behind. It has a pessimism that belongs to 19th century German philosophers and poets. Nevertheless, this very aesthetic and philosophic movement had its origins in an attempt to redeem the world of Christianity with its false hopes, its delusions toward nature, and it’s inability to accept either unconditional free will or the total denial of free will. Von Trier very consciously modeled this movie on the Romantic aesthetic, using the Overture to “Tristan and Isolde” as the movie’s only soundtrack. Let’s not forget that the Romantic movement strove to return to something more primal than Christianity. To return to nature.</p><p>In both Malick’s and Von Trier’s movies, women are closer to nature and one could say, closer to the truth. Malick’s male protagonists-Sean Penn in “Tree of Life”, Ben Affleck in “To the Wonder”, and Christian Bale in “Knight of Cups”-are deeply dissatisfied but inextricably lost in their own vanity. They do not love their careerism, their pursuit of power, or money, or women, but they have no idea how to get out. They are isolated from each other, from women, and from their parents. The women in his movies take the brunt of these men’s faults. Looking especially at the ex wife in “Knight of Cups”, we see somebody who has a lot of love to give, a lot of strength of soul, a lot of fortitude and understanding. But it can’t be received. The mother in “Tree of Life” copes with her child’s death through an agonizing and deep struggle with God in prayer. The father becomes angry and abusive. The surviving son becomes alienated and banal, feeling that there is something beautiful and important that he is forgetting.</p><p>Von Trier’s vision is darker in it’s affirmation of evil as the root of all things. Von Trier is wrestling with the deep theological problem of the corruption of nature. As John the Evangelist likes to remind us, the “world” is under the dominion of Satan. The female in “Antichrist” becomes horrifyingly aware of this. The self-satisfied rationalism and the detachment of the male character cause his downfall. Isn’t it therefore a tragedy in the most ancient sense?</p><p>Likewise with the male character in “Melancholia”. Keiffer Sutherland is materialistic, excellent at keeping up appearances, obsessed with being right, and unable to relinquish control. He treats his wife with a degree of contempt and his sister-in-law with even more. If you’ve been through depression, you’ve probably encountered people like the characters in “Melancholia”. Charlotte Gainsbourg is caring, but always trying to suggest ways to get Kirsten Dunst to snap out of it. Keiffer Sutherland thinks it’s bullshit and she needs to grow up. But Kirsten Dunst ends up being capable of receiving revelations, of knowing unknowable things. Likewise, Charlotte Gainsbourg in “Antichrist” receives a message from a talking fox explaining the deepest truth of the universe. These are miracles. Contortions and suspensions of the laws of nature that actually explain nature. In “Antichrist”, nature is evil. In “Melancholia” the universe is evil and above all, accidental.</p><p>Looking at all these movies, we detect a trend in both directors to see women as more in touch with deep things. They suffer for it. And men suffer from their tendency to distance themselves. Malick’s male characters become sad and pathetic. Von Trier’s meet tragic ends, having been proven themselves hubristic in their rationality. Perhaps it’s fitting to recall Adam’s betrayal of Eve in the garden. When God asks him why he ate the forbidden fruit, Adam does not admit that he did it of his own free will. Instead, he blames Eve. He blames the very person he is most in need of, who is there with him because it was not good that he should be alone. And while Eve was the first one to take the forbidden fruit, the Original Sin is swiftly followed by a Prophecy anticipating the destruction of Satan at the hands of woman. God says to the serpent:</p><p>Because you have done this, cursed are you among all animals and among all wild creatures; upon your belly you shall go, and dust you shall eat all the days of your life.<br>I will put enmity between you and the woman, and between your offspring and hers; he will strike your head, and you will strike his heel.</p><p>While it is the male offspring who will crush the serpent, God specifically ordains that the enmity will be between woman and Satan. As the saga of salvation unfolds through the mystery of the Incarnation, we find that redemption can only occur through the free consent of a woman. Her husband plays the ancillary role of protector of the pregnancy. This reflection on Mary and Joseph leads nicely into the themes of Malick’s movies. This is the redeemed couple, tragically absent in but suggested by Malick’s stories.</p><p>And Von Trier’s movies also play on the Genesis story. In his films, it is the woman who has met Satan, who has plucked the fruit from the tree of the knowledge of Good and Evil. She is the keeper of the horrible secrets. And man, a second hand recipient of the dark mysteries, cannot help but struggle to keep them at bay with everything he has. He is also guilty, but incapable of coming face to face with his guilt. Kirsten Dunst’s character in “Melancholia” opposes Mary’s Yes with a No. The world is evil. There is nothing to redeem and no reason to redeem it and even if there were there is no-one to redeem it. Nature is Satan’s church. Chaos reigns.</p><p>Simone de Beauvoir criticizes the exaltation of the female by the male in “The Second Sex”. She sees it as just another form of breaking in on woman’s autonomy through assigning her an essence only relative to the male.</p><p>Beauvoir’s ethics are dictated by her metaphysics. She is committed to the existentialist credo that the world has no form other than what free-will can compose and enforce. The aim of moral life is to become radically self-determined. I’ll admit that I find this philosophy a little boring, while also admitting that I’m no expert in her thought. I read her book and liked it, even if I thought the constant existentialist refrain was tiresome. And she articulated well a basic outlook not only towards sex, but toward life. But what appears so predominantly in Malick’s and Von Trier’s movie is something quite different. Free will, though it may aspire to radical self-determination, is hampered. In Malick’s case, the will is both activated by and impedes itself in the search for the beautiful. There is an image and likeness in humanity that is faintly visible and so difficult to restore. For Von Trier, the quest for self-determination or self-actualization is naive and pointless. This noble quest of elevating yourself to a position of power is all in vain. It is hubris and will be punished. And for both artists, women understand these truths better than men. It is through the female that redemption comes. Or it is she who knows that it will never come.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4536568c821c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Watch Movies, Learn Mercy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PatrickJones09/watch-movies-learn-mercy-b8c594bee4f8?source=rss-2e528064a994------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b8c594bee4f8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Patrick Jones]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 20 Mar 2016 17:20:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-08T17:37:33.958Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Watch Movies, Learn Mercy</strong></p><p>The last three or four days I’ve been living as a shut in. I have the blinds drawn in my room and I spend most of the day not talking. As shut-ins do, I’ve been watching movies. But fear not, sigh not for me. My movie selections have been salutary. The first movie I had intended to watch for a long time and finally got around to it, thanks to Amazon having movies now. “Of Gods and Men” is the story of a small community of Trappist monks who lived near and ministered to a village in Algeria before they were killed by extremists in 1996. Amazon most kindly directed me to my next choice: “The Mission”. “The Mission” is a modern classic starring Robert DeNiro, Liam Neeson, and Jeremy Irons. It tells the story of a Jesuit priest in South America in the mid 18th century who ministered to indigenous peoples deep in the jungles, eventually coming into conflict with the colonial powers who sought to enslave them. While based on true events in the 17th and 18th centuries, the movie itself is a fictional narrative which focuses on the conflict between righteous peace and righteous war.</p><p>Both of these stories carry a message of peace. Both of them tell the story of people suffering from the violence of oppressors and of those who have tried to help them or to stand in solidarity with them. Both ask whether it is better to fight back or to be martyred. Is it right to stand with the persecuted and to risk great danger either through taking up arms or offering oneself as a victim, or is it justifiable to seek safety and to behave prudently given the situation?</p><p>“Of Gods and Men” has many virtues as a movie. First off, the director manages to capture Trappist life so realistically that you wonder whether the characters are played by hired Trappists rather than actors. There are beautiful scenes of the monks praying the Divine Office (Psalms sung at different times of the day) in their small and humble chapel. There is a scene where the monks eat their dinner in silence while they are read to from a spiritual book. One of the younger, hunkier monks works the fields and he is repeatedly shown tilling and irrigating the earth. The movie captures the atmosphere of a monastery better than any I’ve seen other than the one and only “Into Great Silence”.</p><p>Their community is small, just like the actual monastery I’m most familiar with. The monks are humble, quiet, peaceful, yet rich in personality. We see each man’s character come out as the drama of a life and death decision unfolds. The Trappist life is silent, cloistered, and contemplative. Farming is a traditional trade for Trappists, and it is through farming and pastoral care that a Trappist community comes into contact with the people who live nearby. These monks live near a small village. They tend to the sick, sell the honey that they make in market, and assist the townspeople in whatever way they can. The town is Muslim and the monks are very near to the religion and spirituality of their neighbors.</p><p>The drama begins when Islamist extremists begin committing acts of violence against foreigners as well as the Muslim population. A group of Croatian volunteers is murdered. A young woman is stabbed on a bus for not wearing a hijab. The monks read the newspapers and find out about bombings in the capital city. The army is deployed to fight the terrorists. The government tries to insist that the monks accept army protection given the high level of risk. The abbott refuses, telling his brothers that the monastery is a place of peace and that he will not allow them to be protected by the armed forces of a corrupt government.</p><p>As the situation escalates and the threat grows ever greater, the monks have to face the decision of whether to leave or to stay. Br. Christian has been elected by this community as its head, and in that position he makes the call that they will not leave. His brothers are upset with him and accuse him of having overestimated his own prerogative. He should have consulted everybody before deciding their collective fate.</p><p>This small community, tied together so tightly by an ancient monastic rule, the simplicity of life, celibacy, and the renunciation of private property still has its disputes. The mind of the monastery is split. The youngest monk, the farmer, is most upset by the abbott’s decision. He explodes in anger at one point. He is an excitable, hot blooded man and his character goes to show just how many types of people can be found under the plain habit of a monk. He is no sweet, innocent, dreamy mystic. He is angry, afraid, and annoyed.</p><p>Eventually after some time of consideration, the monks hold a vote. They unanimously decide to stay, each recognizing in his own way that his vocation, his life, ties him to the place. They can go elsewhere but, as one monk says, it would lead nowhere. When the young monk voices his fears to Fr. Christian, he is reminded that he already gave away his life by deciding to become a monk. The outstanding thing in this movie is that the monks are not plainly and simply brave. The youngest monk is openly scared. Others are reluctant to decide to stay or go. They are genuinely indecisive until they reach their agreement. Even the abbott in all his calmness shows signs of anxiety and desperate hope that it will not come down to death. The only monk who seems to utterly accept his fate, perhaps even gladly, is Br. Luc. Br. Luc is the doctor to the entire town. He is old and is himself very sick. But as he tells the abbott: “I am not afraid of death, I am a free man.”</p><p>Well, to cut this summary short, the monks are eventually martyred. They are abducted in the middle of the night and taken to an unknown location. We are informed at the end of the movie that to this day nobody knows exactly who killed them or how, except that their heads were discovered a month after their deaths.</p><p>“The Mission” tells the story of a Jesuit priest (Jeremy Irons) who goes deep into the jungles of South America in an area contested by Spanish and Portuguese colonial power to evangelize the natives. It occurs to me that Jeremy Irons has a good list of Catholic characters under his belt. From “Brideshead Revisited”’s Charles Ryder, “The Mission”’s Father Gabriel, to Cesare Borgia in the HBO series “The Borgias.” You could say he has played the spectrum of virtue and vice. Cesare Borgia is a manipulative, adulterous, murderous wolf in sheep’s clothing. One of those Renaissance Popes we all love to hate. Charles Ryder is a mediocre man, though not a dull one. His story is one of longing and of the struggle to find what is truly lovable. It is not a heroic saga, but an ambiguous mixture of comedy and tragedy chronicling the failure of all the pretty things to satisfy. It is the story of being hunted by the Hound of Heaven, of being pulled by A Twitch Upon The Thread.</p><p>Fr. Gabriel is, from the beginning, a heroic figure. We see him undertake a Bear Grills-like journey into the wilderness to find the natives. Once he finds them he keeps his cool even when he is surrounded on all sides by painted warriors with sharpened spears. Fr. Gabriel is a Jesuit, and so it is no surprise that he lives his vocation with a martial, athletic spirit. The founder of the Society of Jesus, St. Ignatius of Loyola, was himself a soldier and reportedly a rather lusty fellow before an injury sustained in battle confined him to a sickbed for months. Restless soul that he was, he became desperately bored and asked for books. His family had no good romance or knight novels, but only the Bible and lives of the Saints. He was disappointed but it was better than nothing. If Netflix had existed in Ignatius’ day, there would be one less Saint and one less major religious order.</p><p>Ignatius experienced a conversion while cooped up in his room waiting for his leg to heal. By the time he was ship shape again, he did not want to return to war but instead to make a pilgrimage to the Holy Land. He set out on a journey across Spain that is recounted in his Autobiography and has become an established part of his nation’s cultural memory. Eventually, while a student at the University of Salamanca, he decided to found the Society of Jesus. The Society soon achieved canonical status and came to be known as the Jesuits. Much the opposite of the Trappists, the Jesuits are in a sense individualists. A Jesuit priest is expected to travel on his own anywhere he is needed. St. Ignatius’ vision for his order was for it to become the Pope’s army, ready and willing to go where the Holy Father needed them for the sake of spreading Jesus Christ and re-evangelizing those who had come under the influence of heresies.</p><p>When Jesuits live together, it is not under a permanent vow. They do not, like Trappists, pledge themselves to stay in one place for the rest of their lives. Much the opposite, they are used to traveling and to finding new posts. While a Trappist lives out his vocation through community life, through his bond to his brothers and his particular monastery, a Jesuit is a member of a worldwide Society, which tasks him with a mission. Jesuits have long been known for their eclecticism, derived from their traveller’s spirit and their intellectual tenacity to understand not only their own faith, but the faiths and philosophies of the world. They have also been known for their political influence, and indeed the term “Jesuitry” has at times been a slur for any conniving, power-courting behavior. In certain times and places, Jesuits have been seen as two-faced deceivers, as men with crafty tongues and plotting hearts. Men to be recognized and avoided and perhaps even put to death. Indeed, many Jesuits met their martyrdom under Queen Elizabeth I for disobeying the ban on the Catholic faith. In the England of the Penal Times, Jesuits really were like spies.</p><p>The incidents fictionally represented in “The Mission” involve the prelude to one of the most significant events in the history of the Society of Jesus. Because the Jesuits represented the natives against the Portuguese and made a point of publicly decrying the cruelty and inhumanity of slavery and genocide, the monarch of Portugal had Jesuits banned from his Kingdom. Eventually more and more European kingdoms started to complain about the Jesuits. After Pope Clement XIII, who had resisted pressures to suppress the Jesuits died, the conclave elected a cardinal who proved more movable on the anti-Jesuit issue. The Jesuits had enemies on many sides. And very powerful ones at that. Not only theologians and fellow clerics, but more importantly, kings, dukes, and ministers.</p><p>“The Mission” counterposes two heroic figures. First, there is Fr. Gabriel, who journeys to the jungle to spread the Word of God to the natives and once there, begins to recognize the dark intentions of the colonial powers toward them. Then, there is Rodrigo, played by Robert DeNiro. A man of the sword, Rodrigo loses his soul when he kills his brother for sleeping with a woman he loved. He has to flee and takes refuge with Fr. Gabriel and the natives. There, he decides that he wants to give himself to God and to serve the people just as Fr. Gabriel does. He is inducted into the Society of Jesus by Fr. Gabriel and begins to serve as an assistant to him. A crux of the story comes when a Bishop visits the colony and Gabriel and Rodrigo try to persuade him that the natives are children of God with equal dignity to themselves who possess many spiritual riches by virtue of their ancient culture. A Spanish official is outraged. He claims that the natives are savage by nature and can only be redeemed by the whip and the use of their labor to the ends of colonization. The Bishop is rather persuaded by the Jesuits, but nevertheless is forced to bow to the powers of this Earth. He comes and visits the natives, is affected and moved by his experience, but in the end is powerless to prevent the colonial powers from attacking them in a last attempt to drive them out of their land and enslave them.</p><p>With the final battle at hand, Rodrigo decides that he cannot stand by and watch the people he loves be murdered and forced into slavery. A man of the sword he was, and a man of the sword he shall be again. Fr. Gabriel urges him to understand that to love as God loves, to follow Jesus, means to renounce violence. It means being willing to die at the hands of those who do violence, but never surrendering to the forces of darkness by shedding blood by your own hands. But Rodrigo renounces his vows to the order and, without losing respect or affection for Fr. Gabriel, decides that he must fight.</p><p>When the Spanish force comes into the jungle, Rodrigo and his army are waiting for them. Through ambush, surprise, and even the crafting of makeshift cannon, they manage to kill a portion of the Spanish party. They chase them back to the mission where Fr. Gabriel is celebrating Mass with the people. There is a poignant scene when the Spanish soldiers are arraying themselves in order of battle across a stream from the mission church, ready to attack. Fr. Gabriel has just finished celebrating Mass and is fixing a consecrated Host into a Monstrance. As you probably know, Catholics believe that the bread and wine offered during the Mass are really transformed into the Body and Blood of Jesus Christ through the act of Consecration. Recognizing that once a Host is consecrated, the Lord Jesus is truly present in it, it is customary to present the Host in a shiny, circular frame so the faithful can adore their Lord. The soldiers see the Crucifix, the vestments, and the consecrated Host in the Monstrance and all kneel and cross themselves. Some of them look very uneasy about the fact that they are about to attack a church, a priest, and even Jesus Christ himself. When one of the soldiers complains about their target, the commander tells him that he doesn’t care. He has flaming arrows shot at the Church and begins attacking the mission with cannon and rifles.</p><p>The natives, with Rodrigo, go out to fight the Spanish. They run bravely into gunfire armed with spears and knives. Rodrigo is about to fire one of the make-shift cannons when he is riddled with a volley of bullets ordered by the commander of the Spanish forces. Close by, Fr. Gabriel is leading his flock in a procession, holding the Host in the Monstrance as a beacon. The crowd is fired upon, and he falls down dead. The Spanish presumably destroy the village and enslave all of its inhabitants. Our two heroes have met heroes deaths. The two men end up suffering the same fate, albeit through a totally different logic. Fr. Gabriel saw his commitment to Christ as a commitment to non-violence. A consequence of this commitment is the possibility of being killed. But no servant is greater than his Master, and just as Christ entered willingly into His suffering, so must His servants.</p><p>Rodrigo lived and died by the sword. But his relationship to violence changed significantly as his life was re-oriented by living with Fr. Gabriel and the natives. He had to leave civilization because he murdered his own brother out of envy and lust. He had repeated the sin of Cain. As he seeks forgiveness and redemption, he discovers brotherhood with people that are far from being his blood. So distantly related to him that many of his countrymen consider them naturally inferior. And when he recognizes the plans evil men are hatching to destroy them, he is compelled by his sense of justice and of divine law to resist. In the case of Rodrigo, Jesus’ admonishing words “he will lives by the sword shall die by the sword” factually obtain. At the same time that we recognize the honor of Rodrigo’s cause and the nobility of his sacrifice, we wonder if he has chosen the better part. And to be just, Fr. Gabriel, though he did not live by the sword, also died by the sword. As a side note, it is interesting to me that when Peter wounds Malchus, the servant of the high priest, he acts ignorantly for two reasons. First, he does not understand that the Son of Man must suffer and die and that Caiaphas has been appointed by Providence to fulfill this prophecy. Secondly, he does not realize that by wounding the servant of Caiaphas, he is striking the wrong person. His desire to win justice by violence only leads to the wounding of an innocent. In all war, this is true. Even the soldiers of the other side are often conscripted “servants.” Even if they are servants by will, they are often compelled by many forces to serve their cause, however unjust. It was not Malchus’ idea to arrest Jesus. The blood was only circumstantially on his hands.</p><p>It’s not hard to see the relevance of both these stories to our times. Especially “Of Gods and Men”. We are faced with the complex and ever more disturbing expansion of Islamist militias. The persecution of Christians and the murder of Muslims deemed neglectful of the law has expanded to a total war of extermination. Various opposition forces have arisen to combat ISIS, and our own country is in a situation of compliance with forces that are beyond our understanding and control. We may be lending aid or making allies of wolves rather than sheep. And we are not absolved of guilt. We are not the innocent do-gooders who are just trying to fix the problem. I do not doubt the genuine desire of many Americans to do good in other countries. There are many who believe in Kennedy’s formulation of democracy as “the last best hope of mankind”. But the circle of violence repeats itself. Through brute force we seek peace. But I will not put my trust in some presidential candidate or another to solve the problem. An empire fights on its borders. An empire desperately seeks self-preservation. And if we follow Jesus, if we follow the example of Fr. Gabriel and of the Trappist martyrs, we may accept the painful truth that by not accommodating ourselves to the world we accept dire consequences. In the final scene of “The Mission”, the Bishop who made concessions to the governments of the Spanish and Portuguese, discusses his regrets with theSpanish commander. That latter says something along the lines of “So be it. It is the way of the world”. The Bishop, with a faraway stare replies “only because we have made it so”.</p><p>Let us turn to the lessons of Pope Francis. When four Missionaries of Charity were murdered this month in Yemen, the Pope appeared at St. Peter’s Square and urged the world to pray for the victims, to admire their sacrifice, and to also pray for the aggressors that they may reconcile themselves to their neighbors and lay down their arms. When he visited Mexico, he minced no words in recognizing the deeply distressing situation of immigrants trying to cross the US-Mexico border. When refugees began to flee Syria in astounding numbers, the Pope urged the world to seek peace and to be guided by mercy in addressing the situation. Like the Guarani natives in “The Mission” or the Muslims who lived near the Trappists in Algeria, these suffering people are brothers and sisters despite divisions of race, religion, poverty, or wealth. Mr. Trump’s disturbing rhetoric concerning Muslims and Mexicans plays off the tendency of the human heart to protect itself against threats. To provide itself with a idee fixe to explain it’s tribulations, in the form of an alien people. Mr. Trump’s callous disregard for the Pope’s reasonable statements reflects the wickedness of the Spanish official who dressed down the clerics for defending the dignity of the natives. Trump’s remarks dishonestly play off of the core American conviction that a person’s freedom of religious conscience should not be persecuted. “No man should be able to say whether I’m Christian or not. Especially a religious leader.” Astounding logic.</p><p>Pope Francis, a Jesuit just like Fr. Gabriel, has declared a Jubilee Year of Mercy. The Jubilee year goes all the way back to the Mosaic law. Among the fruits of the Jubilee were the loosing of bonds. Slaves could be freed. Servants were given privileges. St. Paul declares that we are all free in Christ. The covenant that he preaches, we might say, proclaims Jubilee until Christ comes again. There is nothing new under the sun. There is wickedness in the human heart. There are its selfish cravings, and there is the liturgy of violence. And far be it from me to proclaim any innocence or to preach with too much confidence. But until the Lord comes again, let us watch movies. Let us learn Mercy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b8c594bee4f8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Critical Thinking and the Cave]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PatrickJones09/critical-thinking-and-the-cave-37c6d2d157e6?source=rss-2e528064a994------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/37c6d2d157e6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Patrick Jones]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 18 Mar 2016 01:46:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-04-08T14:56:57.595Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Critical Thinking and the Cave</strong></p><p>I’ve spent a lot of time recently thinking about liberal arts education and its value. Having received a degree in liberal arts from a college that takes that idea very seriously and has some specific ideas about what it means, I am quite personally convinced of that education’s importance. I wouldn’t trade my college experience for anything and am happy to have had the opportunity to learn many things that are hard to learn in today’s academic environment. That said, the farther I get from college and the more involved in the “real world” I become, the more I realize just what everyone was talking about when they warned about the inutility of a liberal arts education. To be fair, I didn’t go into it for a career’s sake. I wasn’t doing to set myself up for a future profession. I did it because I wanted to read good books and learn about important ideas. I wanted an education that was philosophical in nature.</p><p>If I hadn’t have chosen the Great Books program at St. John’s and had had to pick a major, I would have studied history, literature, or philosophy at another small college. But, choosing St. John’s, I had the good fortune of being able to study both “left brain” and “right brain” disciplines together and realize their essential relevance to each other. It’s one of the valuable things about that program, in my estimation. But during my college experience and after, I have always reacted with an inward sneer or a roll of the eyes when I hear justifications of liberal arts programs that seem trite or shallow. One of the lamest justifications for an education in the Western tradition is the claim that it is enriching or simply interesting. I wouldn’t disagree. But why would you spend four years and a lot of money basically to learn a hobby? And why would people over centuries have studied these things if they were only ornamental? And who wants an education that doesn’t achieve a purpose? This does not preclude the idea that some things are worth studying for their own sake, but I want to assert that the “enrichment” argument does not do justice to any of the things I had the opportunity to study or to the thinkers I read.</p><p>The second platitudinous justification, and the one I want to focus on here, is that the value of the education lies in the imparting of “critical thinking” skills. Now, this phrase, “critical thinking”, smacks of the same ambiguity and artificiality as contemporary primary and secondary school class names such as “language arts” and “social studies”. Like these, it is not entirely senseless. We get what is meant. But isn’t language that seems obvious the most deceptive? Aren’t names that elicit an immediate sense of comprehension the most distracting? I feel its hard to put my finger on exactly what is meant by “critical thinking.” And I think many of us would be at pains to nail it down. Does it mean the skill of parsing an argument or making sense of an idea or interpreting the relationship between two ideas? Those all seem like aspects of what we mean by critical thinking. And if that is what we mean, then yes-reading Plato does help with that. And so does reading Euclid’s geometry. But don’t practical studies also achieve this? Doesn’t an engineer, a carpenter, a biologist, or a mechanic have to think critically? Perhaps they are not dealing with philosophical ideas, but aren’t all of the aforementioned traits of critical thinking at play when one has to build a bridge, to choose the right support for a table, to understand myosis and mytosis, or to diagnose a problem with an engine? Let’s remember that Plato’s Socrates constantly makes reference to the practical arts when he is trying to get at what speech making and dialectic are.</p><p>We could focus more intensely on the meaning of “critical”. In contemporary academia (pardon me if I’m not spot on), “criticism” is highly valued as a means to placing ideas or texts within a context in order to get behind them. Criticism does not take things at face value, but sees ideas and texts as hiding all sorts of latent influences or causes that are not obvious. There may even be prejudices behind an idea or a text that should be well understood before we go making judgements about it. I bring this up because it gives us some insight into how critical thinking transcends basic ratiocination. Sure, you need the skills of division and synthesis to think at all about anything. But criticism goes to the “meta” level. When we are critical, we are not stopping at grasping an argument, but want to ask “where does this come from?” “What kind of person is writing this?” “What is this responding to?” “What is the agenda?”</p><p>Often, attempts to analyze something based on context involve speculations we have to take with a grain of salt. Take, for example, historical-critical examinations of the New Testament. Historical research and the development of possible theories of the historical Jesus or the beginnings of the Christian Church are valid. But in the end, we are left with a lot of conjecture. That doesn’t mean don’t be critical, but simply know your limits. This is what Kant meant by criticism. At my college, an emphasis was placed on avoiding too much context. Arguments can certainly be made that this approach shouldn’t be taken too dogmatically. I would agree. The non-contextual approach, I think, serves largely as a pedagogical tool. The idea is that it’s more important to get students to take a claim seriously and to use reason to dissect it and point out its strengths and weaknesses, it’s sense or nonsense, than to train them to think of a super-original, super-sophisticated theory of why someone says what they say.</p><p>As students go on to further studies, they hopefully supplement the reasoning skills imparted by the naive method of reading with a strong historical, cultural, and psychological sense. But all this is to say, “critical thinking” seeks to engage things on a more transcendental level. I’m inadvertently using Kant’s own critical language. But the “naive” approach is also critical because while it takes an argument at face value, it wants to compare it to other arguments, ask how its claims effect other philosophical claims, and decide where it leads in terms of its conclusions. And if you think of the examples of Plato’s myths-even a “naive” reading necessarily becomes a critical reading! Since Socrates uses the images to make realities intelligible, we have to ask ourselves what is really behind the image, what is really the connection between the image and the reality, why would Socrates choose this particular image, and what could the image mean within the context of the particular conversation presented in any given dialogue.</p><p>But to get to the question that motivated this entire reflection, and to continue in a Platonic vein I want to ask this question: what is the difference between “critical thinking” and the ascent from the cave as described in Plato’s “Republic”? The cave allegory comes right after the section of the book where Socrates and his interlocutors take up the question of philosophy in earnest. Who are the philosophers? Are philosophers good or bad? What do philosophers do and what place do they have in society? In Book VI, Socrates gives a defense of philosophers against the accusation that they are lazy, deceptive, and corrupting. It’s not that philosophy itself is any of these things, he argues, it’s rather that men who call themselves philosophers can be these things. What they do is not actually philosophy.</p><p>But Socrates does not in the end deny a tension between philosophy and politics. While he argues that since philosophers are the ones who are looking for the Good and politics should be ordered by the Good, philosophers ought to be rulers, he also admits that they appear strange and set apart. They have an education which hinders them from going along with public opinion or following the various idols of their city. They strike a dissonant note when they find themselves in the public square. Socrates uses the image of a cave to describe the situation of living in a city. The inhabitants of the cave live far from the surface of the earth, which they don’t know exists. They don’t know because they’re fastened in place watching a parade of shadows on the cave’s wall. The shadows are produced by people who carry shapes in front of a fire that is behind them and they are forced to look only in one direction. Because of their lack of freedom, these prisoners are physically incapable of seeing actual things. They don’t know that the shadows are images of images.</p><p>But if one person breaks free, Socrates says, he will see the shapes and the fire and escape the cave and go to the surface, where he will see real beings such as trees. And once his eyes can take it, he sees the sun. The sun is the image of the Good, the unified vision of which the philosopher is always seeking. The trees are the beings, which are knowable insofar as they are illuminated by the sun. The fire in the cave is a false sun, created by men and used to manufacture illusion. The shadows on the cave wall, images of images, are created by people to fool other people. The trapped prisoners’ perception of the shadows as reality signifies opinion, which takes for knowledge what is not knowledge. Were the man who ascended from the cave to return back and tell what he saw, Socrates says, he would be crucified. After the cave allegory, Socrates goes on to lay down a highly specific course of education for those souls in the city who might have what it takes to become philosophers. The basic thinking skills that are necessary for any kind of rationality whatsoever come first. The neophytes ascend from arithmetic to astronomy, recognizing the intelligible through the visible. Eventually they are able to learn dialectics, the art of distinguishing the beings. Education is a ladder, and most importantly, it is a form of conversion.</p><p>This is the basic point I want to make: by focusing on the value of “critical thinking skills,” we miss the fact that the value of a liberal education is not just in learning how to think clearly, it is in the conversion that occurs when a student recognizes that her “knowledge” is really opinion, that she has been taught to think that many things are that maybe aren’t or are but in a different way. It involves being freed. And to perfect your reasoning is not just to become more rigorously logical, it is to encounter the ambiguities of reality, to recognize that the intelligible world is actually full of un-intelligibilities. Is it paradoxical that freedom comes not in having full confidence in one’s knowledge but rather in recognizing that one’s knowledge is fundamentally incomplete? That the philosophical soul is constantly trying to separate knowledge from opinion, and constantly striving with much difficulty to really know what the beings are? That philosophy means being always in limbo?</p><p>I do agree that reading difficult texts, including mathematical texts, inculcates strong rational skills. Serious and lively discussion makes students capable of raising and solving problems. These qualities are frankly very practical. They will come in handy in one’s career and in one’s life. But the fundamental value of a liberal education goes beyond skills. It is, as I said before, a conversion. It is understanding that there are shadows before our eyes that we should not be misled by. It is the turning away from the prison of the cave and the setting out on the arduous assent to the surface. The Latin verb “educare” means to lead out. The very word we use carries within it the meaning of Socrates’ allegory. There are practical arts, there are techniques, there are skills. These are all learnable things. But to truly educate is to set someone on the path upward. It is to assist in a conversion. Or to use Socrates’ image, to assist in a birth.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=37c6d2d157e6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tyrant or Prince? A Review of Andrew Roberts’ “Napoleon”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PatrickJones09/tyrant-or-prince-a-review-of-andrew-roberts-napoleon-eaceaf412195?source=rss-2e528064a994------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eaceaf412195</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Patrick Jones]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Jan 2016 14:34:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-01-22T14:39:40.463Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Tyrant or Prince? A Review of Andrew Roberts’ “Napoleon”</strong></p><p>The figure of Napoleon looms large in history. For almost twenty years, the combined forces of Europe fought a series of wars against him. He was a scandalous figure both to monarchists and liberals, having seized control of a society de-stabilized by revolution only to make himself absolute ruler. For the Orthodox in Russia, he was officially labeled Anti-Christ.</p><p>In his new biography, Andrew Roberts argues for Napoleon’s virtues. In the introduction, he claims that ever since the end of World War II Napoleon has too often been placed in the same category as Hitler. Both common and scholarly opinion, Roberts claims, tend to view Napoleon as a megalomaniacal tyrant bent on world domination to satisfy his own greed and ambition. Negative views of Napoleon are particularly prevalent in Roberts’ native Britain, the nation that Napoleon hated most and defamed as “a nation of shopkeepers”.</p><p>But Roberts wants to argue that Napoleon’s gifts to modernity should not go unappreciated. He claims that unlike Hitler, Napoleon had real liberal convictions. He was deeply committed to equal protection under the law, embodied in the Napoleonic Code. He was a man of the Enlightenment, who saw authority based on reason as the just replacement for monarchist dynasties, feudal systems of ownership, and political subordination to religious authority. Even his conquests, Roberts argues, need to be understood as defensive measures against powers that posed a huge threat to the new French Republic if they went unchecked. Additionally, Napoleon brought a chaotic political situation to order, allowed people displaced by the Revolution to return to France, and extended tolerance and protection to the Catholic Church.</p><p>Roberts also praises Napoleon’s charisma. He was able to make ordinary people feel that they were doing extraordinary things. This is undeniably true, especially for the Army which was the largest ever assembled in Europe and successful on the scale of Caesar’s and Alexander’s. But the ability to inspire mass enthusiasm by no means indicates goodness, either moral or political. Edmund Burke actually predicted that a “popular general” would end up the master of the democratic institutions the Revolution had striven to create. The triumph of such a man would be the symptom of political crisis and the reversal of the Revolution’s aims.</p><p>Roberts admits Napoleon’s manifold abuses of human rights, an idea so integral to Enlightenment political philosophy. In the Napoleonic code women were at a harsh disadvantage, in the Middle East Napoleon’s troops ravaged Jaffa, and in all the countries that he occupied he dealt ruthlessly with native opposition. He infamously captured and executed the Duc d’Enghien, whom he suspected of a plot against his life, after a mock trial.</p><p>Napoleon is often a romantic figure in literature and philosophy. Stendhal’s ambitious male protagonists worship him. Tolstoy’s Pierre believes his greatness justifies his transgression of justice. Hegel admired him as a great world spirit, signifying the progress of history. It is easy to be inspired by the more dramatic moments in Napoleon’s life and the sheer magnitude of his accomplishments. But the question that pervades the study of his life is whether his seizure of power and constant war-making was truly for the sake of the greater good, or was driven by the pursuit of glory that characterizes a tyrant. Comparing revolutionary France to revolutionary America, we see that the political turbulence generated by the former does not prove that a revolution can only cause disorder. A change in regimes does not always necessitate despotism. Instead of praising Napoleon for bringing order to a chaotic situation, perhaps we should take the fulfillment of Burke’s prediction as a political lesson. And as for Roberts claim that Napoleon contributed greatly to the establishment of the modern state as a protector of universal rights, it’s fair to say that the enmity Napoleon bred between France and Germany had no small part to play in the struggles that gripped those two nations in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.</p><p>Roberts’ biography is excellently researched and driven by a serious passion on the part of the author. He should by no means be accused of forwarding propaganda or an ideology under the guise of history. Furthermore, it is useful to hear an argument in Napoleon’s favor. But at the end of the day, we should learn from the problems that engendered Napoleon’s rise to power. We should be able to admire leaders whose prudence and personal strengths work to the advantage of their nation, but beware of those whose rise to power also drives them on a quest to conquer.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eaceaf412195" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Well, Sometimes It’s Hard]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PatrickJones09/i-d-like-to-begin-my-blogging-life-with-a-personal-story-that-i-feel-i-ve-never-adequately-told-c201067f0669?source=rss-2e528064a994------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c201067f0669</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[depression]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Patrick Jones]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 Jan 2016 22:29:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-01-04T22:36:42.254Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Well, Sometimes It’s Hard</strong></p><p>I’d like to begin my blogging life with a personal story that I feel I’ve never adequately told. Hopefully it will be of some interest to an audience and help me to reflect on my own life.</p><p>I’m not alone in having experienced the adolescent duldrums. That time where it seems nothing is happening and you are held in place by a toxic combination of estranging institutions (school, after-school activities, family vacation) and lack of self-determination. I have met people who felt engaged with their lives in that period, but I can only truly sympathize with those who felt disconnected, turned-off, and perpetually upset.</p><p>What exactly we mean by the word “depression” in common usage is ambiguous. It can refer to a passing mood caused by a bad day at work or a problem in a relationship. It can signify an object-less feeling of hopelessness and lostness: a forlorn rather than sublime response to life’s oceanic feeling. It can also be used in a technical sense. Major depressive disorder is a diagnosable condition with observable and identifiable symptoms.</p><p>The former connotations could adequately describe the feelings of a struggling adolescent. In fact, they could describe components of the common human struggle. The latter defines a psychological state that, in conventional theory, requires medical intervention.</p><p>When I was in high school, I was placed on anti-depressants. In that I was not alone in my family or my peer group. I went to see a psychiatrist who provided this medication as well as weekly therapy. That was the inception of what has become a relatively stable aspect of my life. I can’t remember what we discussed. I can only imagine that I was less than forthcoming and may have even tried to subvert the help she was offering me. But I have only positive memories of her character and professional quality.</p><p>When I went to college at the age of 16 after a turbulent and disorganized experience of high school, I removed myself from the medications and stopped going to a therapist. I remember deciding I was done with them when my dad arrived on campus to pick me up for an appointment in the midst of an awesome all-weekend party with unlimited free booze and cigarettes. We had to drive 45 minutes so I could meet for 15 minutes with a different, boring psychiatrist at her hospital office to adjust my dose of Prozac.</p><p>Once I began the practice of neglect, I didn’t think much about professional help over the next four years. I experienced regular, months-long bouts of what I feel safe calling depression. Each year a cycle would occur where positive and energetic feeling would devolve into feelings of morbidity, anger, and sadness. Still, I made it through these cycles trusting that they were just a natural part of life, as indeed changes of mood are.</p><p>The crisis that tipped the scale and would prove to seriously effect the next five years of my life began at the end of my senior year of college. Towards the end of winter, I started to experience that same low feeling; this time mixed with intense restlessness and anxiety. I began to lose sleep. A lot of sleep. Chronically. I slept zero to three hours a night for months. I would lay in bed alternately struggling to force myself into rest and panicking that I was running out of time to sleep. My schoolwork and life began to suffer. My thoughts were disorganized. Reading was impossible. I wondered what it was like to feel normal. I yearned for the regular range of feelings I imagined most of my peers enjoyed.</p><p>At some point I began frequently calling my parents in the middle of the night to panic out loud. They admirably and faithfully talked with me and tried to help me. After a while though, it became clear that there was nothing they could really do to help or change the situation. One night I called again, complaining that I couldn’t take it any more. My parents got in the car, drove to my college, and took me to the emergency room. A doctor offered me klonopin as an anti-anxiety drug and sleeping aid and told me not to worry. I was young and would live a long, happy life, he said. That re-assurance, though practically ineffective at the time, moved me then and remains with me now.</p><p>Over the summer I recovered. I went on a trip to Spain and “walked it off”. I was headed for a PhD program in the fall and the future seemed full of promise. I started that PhD program in September and was enthusiastic about my classes. I was the youngest in the program by a significantly greater measure than in college and couldn’t even drink with my peers at bars. I was living in a suburban area where it was impossible to get by without a car. I was living in a nice apartment, alone.</p><p>Very quickly the situation degenerated. I began to suffer from a nervous depression with a primary symptom being chronic insomnia. The late night (or early morning) calls to my parents ensued. The feeling of panic and dislocation intensified. Eventually, I called my parents and threatened suicide. Again, I had reached a breaking point. My mom told me that if I didn’t have myself taken to a hospital, she would call the police to come and take me. So I went, and after a visit to the emergency room was transferred to an inpatient facility. I have actually visited a state prison before, but this was my closest experience to being forced into one. The staff took my belt, shoelaces, and wallet and assigned me a room with a roommate. When I saw my roommate I realized I was dealing with a truly disturbed individual. If I had seen him on the street, I would have briskly walked away. I was sincerely afraid he was going to hurt me. The people in this facility seemed violent and irrational. I was frankly terrified.</p><p>Very quickly they realized that I was out of place here and sent me to the other ward where most people were recovering from painkiller addictions. This place was calm and comfortably furnished. The people seemed normal. I watched football on TV for the first time in my life. I met one man in his thirties who had been addicted to oxycontin and was anxious to get home to his wife and kid. He was very kind. I met another man in his late twenties who was physically intimidating. He looked like a bodybuilder, but once we started talking he was very polite and conversational. He had been an Army sniper in Iraq and Afghanistan as well as a machine gunner in a Humvee. He had been hit by an AK-47 round in a firefight and gotten addicted to painkillers during his recovery. He had met his wife while oversees, lost his best friend in action, and said that he wanted to go back because life at home was boring.</p><p>I also met a certified kleptomaniac who stole and hid my copy of Moby Dick. I got it back.</p><p>I eventually got out of this facility and left graduate school at the beginning of the semester. To make a long story short, the emotional breakdown re-occurred the next year, this time leading to a week long stay in the Psych ward of Georgetown University Hospital and a month and a half long outpatient therapy program. Though I was skeptical on arrival, that experienced proved to by one of the most interesting of my life. I’m grateful I had health insurance and was able to do it. That episode caused a second withdrawal from graduate school, this time from a masters program. Eventually I went back to that program, stayed for a year, and withdrew again. Though the problems were less severe that time, my emotional and psychological life once again got the better of me.</p><p>Now I’m a few years removed from all that. I spent the two years after my second withdrawal from the masters program working a stable service job that I happened to actually like. But I wasn’t happy during those years. My emotions felt dulled. I was getting by but felt, in the words of BB King, that the thrill was gone. It felt like a drawn out depression along the same lines as high school. Eventually I was convinced to go back on medication. I’ve tried so many over the years. I had never felt like I had much success with any of them. A certain class, used to combat hypomanic symptoms, had caused a condition called tardive dyskinesia where I experienced uncontrollable body spasms and contortions and felt an inner restlessness that was quite unbearable. It’s hard to describe, but imagine feeling intense pain staying still for a minute.</p><p>Finally I’m on a medication regimen that seems to work. I have experienced improvement of symptoms and I feel a basic stability. Even a basic happiness. I am aware that this is not the end, and that I will rely on psychiatric care for the foreseeable future. But I feel no deep dread of life, and no painful disorganization of the mind.</p><p>I struggle on a daily basis, though, with a resentment that my life since college has been unstable. That I haven’t finished anything that I started. That my ambitions were frustrated, and that I felt consistently defeated. I have, on the one hand, gained some experience in pain and hard things which will potentially help me later in life or make me useful to someone else who is going through their own struggle. On the other hand, I feel like I have been set back and that the course of my life was confused. Deciding the next stage is my current struggle. I combat hopelessness and confusion often. It’s hard to feel like you can’t do anything. For someone just starting their adult life to be de-railed time and again understandably causes a weariness and temptation to abandon ambition. As long as I feel ok, I sometimes think, I have all I can hope for. After all I’m not really suited to high pressure pursuits. And after all, I can rationalize my stasis as a rebellious act of refusal to take part in the inauthentic world of careers and success. But as the earth continues to turn, I realize that I must find my way, which is not straightforward and not a given. Anxieties about my future and an obsession with not screwing up doubtlessly played a large part in touching off my mood episodes. I have hopefully grown not only more confident, but also more tranquil and accepting of the imperfections in myself, in life, and in the world around me. At the same time, I want to take up my sword and my banner and go forward. I want to live with reason and with passion. I want to raise water from my inner well and give birth to whatever worthy things grow in my heart. I want to live.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c201067f0669" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I am a beginning blogger, and this is my first post.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PatrickJones09/i-am-a-beginning-blogger-and-this-is-my-first-post-903241781b46?source=rss-2e528064a994------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/903241781b46</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blogging]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Patrick Jones]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 Jan 2016 20:47:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-01-04T20:47:11.433Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I am a beginning blogger, and this is my first post. I suppose I have worried that blogging would degenerate into a form of navel gazing, or a mere outlet for prejudices, half-baked opinions, and personal stories. I have aspirations of writing things that are meaningful, analytic, and in a somewhat academic vein. At the same time, I believe that thought and life are not, or should not be, too distinguishable. My intention in writing a blog is simple: to gain experience writing and to hold myself accountable for my thoughts in front of a large audience. Indeed, the largest audience of all-the Internet. So I here convoke my journey into the world of cyber-opinion and amateur editorial. May we find ourselves friends and peers in the great quest of the modern age.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=903241781b46" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>