<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Mark Pelta on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Mark Pelta on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@PeltaRepublic?source=rss-6391bfb02960------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 22:37:00 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@PeltaRepublic/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Facts About George Floyd That Don’t Care About Conservatives’ Feelings, No Matter How Many Youtube…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PeltaRepublic/facts-about-george-floyd-that-dont-care-about-conservatives-feelings-no-matter-how-many-youtube-6bab552d40df?source=rss-6391bfb02960------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6bab552d40df</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Pelta]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Jun 2020 05:55:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-06T07:31:01.784Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Facts About George Floyd That Don’t Care About Conservatives’ Feelings</h3><p>It’s amazing to me that somebody like Candace Owens will make a video slandering George Floyd’s character and then my fellow liberals will uncomfortably wring their hands and respond from within the context she presents with phrases like “even if that’s true…” and “while I’m sure George Floyd wasn’t a nice guy…”, thus ceding the narrative to the conservatives.</p><p>George Floyd, they love to smugly point out, went to prison a number of times, the last time for a serious aggravated assault he committed in 2007 (conservatives say the victim was pregnant but I’ve looked and seen no evidence of that). They therefore call him a ‘violent criminal til the end,’ the “worst” of the black community.</p><p>2007 was 13 years ago. If we’re defining people by who they were in 2007, when I die you can write “Ohr David yeshiva boy Baruch Pelta” on my tombstone. He was paroled in 2013, so why are conservatives who are so intimately familiar with Floyd’s pre-prison life so mum about what happened to George Floyd after 2013? All they seem to know is that he had meth and fentanyl in his system and for all we know, he had a prescription for one or the other. What Owens says looked to be a bag of cocaine, the apparent basis for her claim that he had drugs on him at the time of his arrest, actually <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XrSkazmCpKw">appears</a> to have been a piece of trash on the ground; the cops themselves haven’t said otherwise.</p><p>After Floyd got out of jail, he returned to his home in Houston’s Third Ward. What did he do?</p><p>“When Tiffany Cofield, then a teacher at Hope Academy charter school in the Third Ward, struggled to connect with her most troubled students, she turned to Floyd for help. Floyd, who was 40 at the time, was disarmingly soft-spoken and listened to Cofield’s complaints and aspirations for the kids, she said.</p><p>More importantly, her students listened to Floyd. One boy was a talented football player struggling to keep his grades up. After Cofield recruited Floyd to talk to him, the student’s grades suddenly improved. He graduated high school and went on to play football at a junior college, Cofield said.</p><p>‘There were times he had more of an impact than their own parents,’ she said of Floyd’s relationship with her students. ‘They didn’t want to disappoint him.’”</p><p>What else did he do? Well, he joined up with a Christian group coming from outside trying to help kids in the Ward and gave them legitimacy.</p><p>“He said, ‘I love what you’re doing. The neighborhood need it, the community need it, and if y’all about God’s business, then that’s my business,’ said Corey Paul Davis, a Christian hip-hop artist who attended Resurrection Houston. ‘He said, ‘Whatever y’all need, wherever y’all need to go, tell ’em Floyd said y’all good. I got y’all.’”</p><p>He would help them by carrying the baptism pool and chairs to the basketball court.</p><p>Floyd then moved to Minnesota. He was involved with a Christian program with a history of taking men from the Third Ward to Minnesota to help them get a fresh start. He worked at Salvation Army’s Harbor Light Center, a downtown homeless shelter and transitional housing facility. A spokesperson for the Salvation Army of Minnesota says Floyd often walked staff to their cars after their shifts to make sure they got home safely. Floyd would still visit with staff and guests even after he stopped working at the Harbor Light Center. He also answered a job listing to work for Conga Latin Bistro as a bouncer. He tried to master salsa dancing, albeit it didn’t work out. He was known around the community as a gentle giant.</p><p>And then one fateful day he went to a store and used a $20 bill that was flagged as potentially counterfeit by a money counting machine. It was at a store he was a regular at and had no issues at previously. The owner of the store has said “most of the time when people present a counterfeit bill, they don’t even know it’s fake.” He said he would’ve handled the issue internally. But the clerk on shift was new and called the cops.</p><p>That’s what happened. That’s who he was, not a ‘violent criminal til the end.’ These people who pretend to love redemption and religion have a story here which involved both, but conservatives stick with the oldest, and baseless slander is older than both redemption and religion.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6bab552d40df" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Interview with Professor Lawrence Kaplan]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PeltaRepublic/interview-with-professor-lawrence-kaplan-cd05ff6935ce?source=rss-6391bfb02960------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cd05ff6935ce</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Pelta]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 31 May 2020 19:46:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-01T06:43:09.093Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Interview with Professor Lawrence Kaplan</strong></p><p><em>Conducted by Baruch Pelta on December 22, 2008 at the 40th Association for Jewish Studies Conference</em></p><p><em>Transcribed Using the Services of Olivia Wiznitzer</em></p><p><em>Co-edited by Lawrence Kaplan and Baruch Pelta</em></p><p><em>Lawrence Kaplan received his BA from Yeshiva College, his MA and PhD from Harvard University, and his rabbinical ordination from Rabbi Isaac Elchanan Theological Seminary. He has taught at McGill University since 1972, and is currently Professor of Rabbinics and Jewish Philosophy in its Department of Jewish Studies. In the spring of 2004 he held a Harry Starr Fellowship at the Center for Jewish Studies of Harvard.</em> <em>Baruch Pelta is a senior at Touro College South majoring in Jewish Studies.</em> <em>Olivia Wiznitzer is the Editor-in-Chief of “The Observer,” the Stern College for Women and Sy Syms undergraduate student newspaper. Olivia may be reached at </em><a href="/service/mailto:chanawiz@gmail.com"><em>chanawiz@gmail.com</em></a><em> for those interested in contacting her.</em> <strong><em>I have conducted two semi-formal interviews with Dr. Kaplan. While both interviews were conducted simply out of personal interest, I believe the latter will be of interest to Judaic Studies scholars, especially those who are interested in how Orthodoxy has developed. What follows is an edited transcript of said interview with footnotes. Although I meant to focus this conversation around his scholarly opinions about the rise of Daas Torah in Orthodoxy, we were able to discuss other topics within Dr. Kaplan’s realm of expertise as well.</em></strong> <strong><em>–BP</em></strong></p><p><strong>Baruch Pelta: </strong>I guess my first question has to be if you changed your position since writing your famous essay on <em>Daas Torah</em> [1] and also, has <em>Daas Torah</em> evolved as a conception since then?</p><p><strong>Lawrence Kaplan: </strong>It’s an interesting question. I pretty much stumbled upon the subject- here’s a little prehistory. When Rav Hutner’s article on the Holocaust appeared in the <em>Jewish Observer</em>, it upset me greatly [2]. Oftentimes, things that get you angry turn out to be productive (similar to my being upset with Rabbi Meiselman’s article on the Rav [3] which led to my writing “Revisionism and the Rav” [4]). Most of my article in <em>Tradition</em> was really a critique of Rav Hutner’s basic position on the Holocaust…mainly a historical critique, but also somewhat of a theological critique [5]. While Rav Hutner himself did not refer to his article as a <em>Daas Torah</em> perspective on the Holocaust, the editors of the <em>Jewish Observer</em> did. So just at the very end of my <em>Tradition</em> article, I decided to raise some issues about <em>Daas Torah</em> in a somewhat critical vein. Despite the rather tentative and preliminary nature of my remarks on the subject, it seems they received a fair amount of attention. Therefore, when YU was having a symposium on “Rabbinic Authority and Personal Autonomy,” the very first Orthodox Forum, the organizors asked me to give a full-blown talk on the subject, which obviously required a good deal of work on my part. And, actually, I have a later Hebrew version of the article, where I elaborate upon some things I write in my English version, correct a few errors of mine — something I attributed to the Meiri was not really by the Meiri — and update a few comments here and there [6]. But what I want to emphasize is that, as I explicitly state in my article, I wasn’t putting forward my own positive view of rabbinic authority. I was more criticizing the idea of <em>Daas Torah</em> as I think it’s popularly presented in the Haredi world. Some people might have misunderstood me to mean that I believe that all rabbis should speak only about pots and pans and should not have any say on communal matters. I never said that. And the other point which I made in my article is that I’m not sure if there’s necessarily throughout Jewish history one view of the limits and scope of rabbinic authority. Moreoever, I acknowledged the traditional rabbinic authority accorded to the rabbi who is the rav of the <em>kehillah</em> — actually I may have done this more in my Hebrew article, based on a reference that Professor Marc Shapiro pointed out to me — where the rav of the <em>kehillah</em>, by virtue of being rav of the <em>kehillah</em>, is granted a good deal of extra-halakhic authority on general communal issues. But even with respect to the rav of a <em>kehillah</em>, it’s not so clear…If you look at the <em>Vaad Arba Aratzot</em>, the laypeople oftentimes kept the rabbis on a short leash. If you look at the community in Amsterdam, it was the lay figures who put Spinoza in Cherem. Not the rabbis. Even though there were some prominent rabbis there at the time.</p><p>To repeat, a lot of times, even in term of rabbis of communities — certainly in the Middle Ages and early modern times — lay leaders played quite a great role. Now the Rashba, on the other hand –but again, he was the official head of the community — obviously played a major role in the Maimonidean Controversy. But it should be pointed out that other people weren’t afraid to disagree with him, even though they admitted his preeminent stature. Other figures weren’t afraid to take issue with him, obviously respectfully, but they weren’t afraid to take issue with him.</p><p>The idea of <em>Daas Torah</em>, as a charismatic notion of rabbinic authority, is something different. It doesn’t come out of nowhere, so it’s not <em>yeish me-ayin</em>. But, as I and others see it, it is an expanded view of traditional conceptions of rabbinic authority, precisely because of greater challenges in the modern period to rabbinic authority. And the classical sources which have been cited as support for it don’t seem to prove the larger claims made on its behalf. One such source is the notion of <em>Emunas Chachamim</em>. But it must be said that the phrase is very general; what it means is not so clear. The meaning attributed to it by the exponents of <em>Daas</em> <em>Torah</em> seems to be a late nineteenth century development, imported from the Hasidic view of the Rebbe. The source cited most often in support of the notion of <em>Daas Torah</em>, and which I focused on most in my article, is <em>Lo Sasur</em>. As I pointed out, according to most authorities it applies only to the <em>Beis Din Hagadol</em>. I further pointed out that the view of <em>Afilu</em> <em>omrin lekha al yemin shehu semol</em> is that of the <em>Sifre</em>. The <em>Yerushalmi</em> is the other way, that <em>only </em>if they say <em>yemin</em> is <em>yemin</em> and <em>semol</em> is <em>semol</em> do you have to listen to them. In my article, particularly the Hebrew version, I went through all the different ways how different scholars try to reconcile the two sources. The authority who seems to be the key figure for the exponents of <em>Daas Torah</em> is the <em>Sefer HaChinuch</em>…He’s the one who applies the <em>Sifre</em> generally to <em>Chachmei HaDor</em>. But the <em>Sefer HaChinuch</em>’s view is more of a practical view; you have to submit to the authority of <em>Chachmei HaDor</em> not because they necessarily have such great understanding, but just because otherwise you’re going to have chaos and anarchy. So it’s a more practical view. So what I suggested is that the modern view of <em>Daas Torah</em> — again, I’m not saying it was made out of whole cloth — is arrived at by taking the idea of the <em>Sefer HaChinuch</em> applying <em>Lo Sasur</em> to all <em>Chachmei HaDor</em> and combining that with the view of the Ramban who talks about the <em>Beis Din Hagadol’s</em> great understanding and how God will protect them from error, etc [7].</p><p>Part of the problem in writing a critique of the concept of <em>Daas Torah</em> is that it is a moving target; people keep on defining it differently. When people are oftentimes defending it, they define it more modestly: it’s a limited notion, we’re not saying the “<em>gedolim</em>” are infallible, maybe there’s a plurality of views that are <em>Daas Torah</em>, but obviously rabbis should have some say on broader communal issues, etc. There was an exchange in <em>The Journal of Halacha and Contemporary Society</em> between me and Rabbi Alfred Cohen, where if I understood him correctly, he proposed this type of scaled-down notion of <em>Daas Torah</em> [8]. And if that is all that is meant by it, I’m not sure if I would necessarily disagree that much. But what I find is that when it’s actually used in the rhetoric of the Haredi world, it’s used to make rather extreme claims. First of all, despite the idea of the plurality of <em>Daas Torah</em>, it’s pretty clear to me that originally within the Agudah circles, it was used to legitimate the Haredi world and to delegitimate the Modern Orthodox.</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>You’re saying now or back then?</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>Certainly there was no pluralism in Rav Shach‘s use of <em>Daas Torah</em> in his harsh critique of Rav Soloveitchik [9], and I think that’s the way it’s still generally used. And the second thing is that it really is used to stifle dissent and any type of criticism. I think the example of Rabbi Slifkin is the key example. It’s really clear to me that initially many prominent American Roshei Yeshiva were upset at the way he was treated. I just reread the original ban on Rabbi Slifkin [10] and was struck by the extremity of the language, almost the violence of the language…<em>Kefirah, minus, afrah le-pumei</em>, it’s just such a terrible book, etc. Then the banners claimed that the rabbonim who had given the book <em>haskamos</em> supposedly hadn’t really read the book, but they heard it was being used for <em>kiruv</em> so they wrote <em>haskamos</em>. But, of course, they all retracted their <em>haskamos</em> once the terrible <em>kefirah</em> in the books was called to their attention. We know all that is not really true, and it is also clear that the way he was treated, without giving him any time to present his case, was extremely unfair and unjust [11]…</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>Can I interject right there, though? The story is that a lot of <em>askanim</em> had a lot to do with this ban [12]. So what’s the difference between those askanim and the Spinoza case?</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>The difference is that in the Spinoza case the lay leaders were the ones who officially in the name of the community banned Spinoza. Here supposedly the <em>askanim</em> were there just to advise or inform the <em>gedolim</em>, but ultimately the idea is that the <em>gedolim</em> are the ones who make the final decision based on their good judgment. Of course, the question is often raised as to what extent are these <em>askanim</em> really limiting the flow of information and shading it and presenting it in ways in which they will get the conclusions they want to get, and I think that’s a serious question.</p><p>But getting back to the point, it seems to me pretty clear that to begin with the American <em>Roshei Yeshiva</em> were not happy with the ban, certainly with its language. I think they were upset and felt they would be looked upon by the general world as some type of primitives. But the bottom line was that there was no public criticism. They all fell into line. There can’t be any type of dissent. How can you disagree with the <em>Gedolim</em>, with <em>Daas Torah</em>? There was no one who actually publicly criticized the ban — supposedly, Rav Aharon Feldman originally supported Rabbi Slifkin– that’s the word. But then he too fell into line and came out with a public attack on him [13].</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>Maybe Rav Kamenetsky or Rav Belsky…They seem to have dissented from everybody else; they never retracted their <em>haskamos</em>.</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>They never retracted their <em>haskamos</em>; that’s true. Then there was Rav Aryeh Carmell who continued to support Rabbi Slifkin [14]. But no one would actually criticize the actual banning of Rabbi Slifkin’s books.</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>I think Rav Kamenetsky said they’ll have to answer for it after the Resurrection [15]. It could be he’s an exception to the rule.</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>Okay; perhaps he’s an exception. I wonder though if he made the statement publicly.</p><p>To return to the general issue of <em>Daas Torah</em> and to your original question as to what extent am I rethinking things. Dr. Benny Brown wrote about <em>Daas Torah</em> in an article, I think, in <em>Mechkerai Yerushalayim</em> [16]. His general point is that scholars like Professor Jacob Katz, his students, and others who were influenced by his approach — including myself among those others — overemphasize, maybe, the break between Orthodoxy in the modern era and pre-Modern traditional Judaism. Brown also sees stages in development in the idea of <em>Daas Torah</em>. His more specific point is that people who wrote about the idea of <em>Daas Torah</em> — Jacob Katz, Gershon Bacon, myself — ignored the idea of <em>d’kula ba</em>, that everything somehow is contained, hinted at, or alluded to in the Torah, as one source for the idea of <em>Daas Torah</em>. But from my reading of the sources Brown cites, it seems to me that <em>d‘kula ba</em> was traditionally used not so much in the modern communal and political <em>Daas Torah</em> sense…That is, <em>d’kula ba</em> gives the right to great rabbinic scholars to make authoritative and final decisions on matters of policy. It was generally used in more of a non-political sense, that is, you study the Torah and you get a great insight into nature and reality and history. The one who first used <em>de–kula ba</em> in the modern <em>Daas Torah</em> sense was Rav Elchanon Wasserman, I think at the Agudah convention in 1937. Here Brown criticized me, and he was right.</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>Because you said Rav Elchonon Wasserman never mentions it.</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>Yes, so I was wrong on that. I mean, based on the writings of Rav Elchonon I had read, I said that Rav Elchonon only speaks about <em>de’ot torah</em>, but doesn’t really speak about <em>Daas Torah</em> in the sense of this idea of special knowledge given to great Rabbis enabling them to make a final authoritative decision on public policy. There I was simply wrong, and I overlooked this talk of Rav Elchonon at the Agudah convention. But my present view is that this political communal twist to <em>de–kula ba</em> was actually Rav Elchonon’s own innovation, and here I would disagree with Brown. Brown pushes it back to the Chafetz Chaim. As Brown pointed out, the Chafetz Chaim speaks about <em>de–kula ba</em> extensively. In my article I quote a text of the Chafetz Chaim…Or rather an oral <em>shemuah </em>attributed to the Chafetz Chaim by Rabbi Greineman. And I say there that I’m not sure whether the Chafetz Chaim said this or not, because it’s an oral <em>shemuah</em>. I’m not saying Rabbi Greineman was dishonest, but people remember things how they remember them; we have that all the time. That’s why we have to check the archives.</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>Did you see Yoel Finkelman’s recent article [17]? It’s very relevant to what you’re saying.</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>I responded to Toby Katz’s comment on Hirhurim about it [18]. Her view was that either something is 100% objective or it’s manipulation. In my view, good scholars try to be honest and present all the relevant evidence and different ways of interpreting it. Of course, you have your own interpretation and cannot be completely objective, but still you try to give all the evidence, whether it supports your view or calls it into question, and try to be as fair as possible to opposing views. So I think it’s a false dichotomy she was drawing there.</p><p>Anyway, getting back to what I was saying. Someone was writing a memoir and remembered a conversation he had with Roosevelt on the day that Pearl Harbor was attacked. And he remembered the meeting so clearly that he even remembered the chairs in which he and Roosevelt sat! And then he checked his diary, and he wasn’t in Washington that day! So he wasn’t there! He checked his diary or his journal of appointments, and realized he must have conflated different meetings.</p><p>So, how is this relevant to the Chafetz Chayyim’s view regarding <em>de-kula ba</em>? The point of the <em>shemuah</em> of the Chafetz Chaim that was attributed to him by Rabbi Greineman was [Dr. Kaplan opens up my copy of <em>Rabbinic Authority and Personal Autonomy</em> and finds page 8]…“The person whose view is the view of Torah can solve all worldly problems, both specific and general. However, there is one condition attached: the <em>Daas Torah</em> must be pure, without any interest or bias. However, if a person possesses <em>Daas Torah</em> but it is intermingled even slightly with other views of the marketplace,” then that’s not real <em>Daas Torah</em>. That’s a good example of <em>Daas Torah</em> delegitimating the more modern type of rabbis. Now Benny in his article was willing to attribute more authenticity to this statement of the Chafetz Chaim than I was. And what he found in his research were many other statements of the Chafetz Chaim in the area of <em>d’kula ba</em> that I didn’t know about. But it seems to me at least, and I discussed this with him, that none of the other statements of the Chafetz Chayyim that Benny cited actually made the point made by the statement attributed to him by Rabbi Greineman. All the other statements of the Chafetz Chaim were more general statements that a person who studies Torah is given insight into reality, can understand many things, etc. But the more political and delegitimating emphases of the statement attributed to him by Rabbi Greinman are not found in his other statements. The point, then, that I made to Benny was that the statements he cites from actual texts of the Chafetz Chaim himself do not really go as far as the oral <em>shemuah</em>. So my assumption is that Rabbi Greineman perhaps heard other statements of the Chafetz Chaim regarding <em>d’kula ba</em>, statements presenting the old, non-political version of <em>de-kula ba</em>, and he honestly misremembered them and inadvertatly conflated them with Rav Elchonon’s version of <em>de-kula ba</em>.</p><p>Again, I don’t think I ever said that the notion of <em>Daas Torah</em> was invented out of whole cloth; I do try to speak of a certain type of development. And perhaps Benny is right, and it has somewhat deeper roots than I or Gershon Bacon were willing to acknowledge. But this is a matter of degree; I still maintain that in its current form maybe it’s drawing upon certain sources, but it’s pushing them and extending them in a more extreme direction.</p><p>You asked me to look at ten statements and sources that Rabbi Dovid Gottlieb had cited in support of the concept of <em>Daas Torah</em> [19]. I have to say I was very unimpressed.</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>But there was one that a lot of people I asked didn’t know why it wasn’t <em>Daas Torah</em>, where there was a <em>pesak</em> in the <em>mahloket</em> between Beit Shamai and Beit Hillel about…</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>Oh yes, that was the <em>gemara</em> in Eruvin about whether <em>noach lo l’adam she’nivra o she’lo nivra</em> [20]. And because <em>nimnu ve-gamru (</em>whatever that means), that <em>noach lo l’adam she’lo nivra mi she-nivra…</em>Does that mean that you have to believe that? Is that an authoritative <em>hashkafic</em> <em>pesak</em>, as it were? I mean, does the Rambam ever quote that? The Rambam obviously believes all existence is good, so does he believe it would have been better for man not to be created? Actually, the Rambam says that in matters of <em>aggadah</em> there is no <em>pesak</em>. There’s also another quote where I think Rabbi Gottlieb was simply wrong. Supposedly in <em>Hilkhos Mamrim</em> the Rambam attributes authority to <em>Beis Din HaGadol</em> in matters of <em>hashkafah</em>. But the Rambam doesn’t talk about that there. He speaks about three types of law: <em>Peirushim mekubalim mi’pi ha’shmuah</em>, laws derived through interpretation — that is, through the use of the 13 <em>Middos</em> — and Takanot and Gezeirot. I don’t see him speaking there about issues of <em>hashkafah</em>. Now, there are mitzvos that deal with <em>emunah</em>. That’s something else.</p><p>Returning to the larger isue: There are issues of public policy, which is one thing, and then there are issues of <em>hashkafah</em>. I think the issue of Rabbi Slifkin is more a matter of the limits of <em>hashkafah</em>. I firmly believe that there’s a great deal of room for plural views on matters of <em>hashkfah</em>, and equally firmly reject the idea that only the views I accept are legitimate, while the other views are illegitimate. Rabbi Slifkin also said that if the Haredi <em>gedolim</em> had said that they don’t want his books in their communities…Okay, that their right, it’s their communities. But to issue general bans is a different story [21].</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>But to return to the <em>gemara</em> Rabbi Gottlieb cites about whether it would have been better for man ot be created or not…how would you deal with that one?</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>It’s a very strange thing, but I didn’t really check it carefully. My knowledge of the Rambam, which is pretty good, is that the Rambam doesn’t agree with the supposed <em>pesak</em> that it would have been better for man not to have been created…Maybe others do. You can do some type of computer search through the Bar Ilan program or one of the other programs, check all of the 5000 books on file. Actually, Maimonides says it’s the other way around; Maimonides attacks, for example, Razi — in the <em>Guide</em> 3:12 I think it was–where Razi claims there’s more evil than good in the world. So it’s very hard to imagine how the Rambam would agree with that. In his letter on astrology to the Sages of Montpellier, when discussing <em>maamarei Hazal</em> apparently disagreeing with his position, he says there are three possibilities. Either it was a <em>daas yachid</em>, or maybe the rabbi was saying it for his particular audience, sort of like <em>de’ot hechrachiyot</em> –necessary beliefs — or maybe the rabbi didn’t mean it literally but intended some type of metaphorical interpretation. And in this connection, what exactly does <em>noach lo l’adam she’lo nivra mi she-nivra</em> mean? Perhaps the Rambam would give it a metaphorical interpretation.</p><p>But it certainly seems to me that traditionally — obviously, there have been debates about these issues — but traditionally there has been a sort of general consensus that within matters of <em>hashkafah</em> there are certain very broad boundaries, but there’s lots of room for differences within those boundaries, and we’re not really dealing with some type of <em>pesak</em>. Attempts to limit or narrow those boundaries, I find troubling. Particularly, getting back to Rabbi Slifkin, when it seems that the majority of rishonim actually agree with his position. Someone had this long list- I mean, a very long list of rishonim who support his position [22]. So you want to say it was good for them, it’s not good for us, OK. You want to say that we don’t accept Rabbi Slifkin’s position, fine. But to call it <em>kefira</em>, <em>minus</em>, etc.– that’s pretty bad.</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>I guess the question that a Haredi person would ask is okay, let’s say that’s all true. But why not have the rabbis as the ultimate authorities? In other words, let’s say we err. Like I want to be a good mitzvah-observing <em>yid</em> and if I err and the rabbis tell me what to do and I decide not to do it, right, so I’m erring, I’m going against the rabbis. But if I do what the rabbis say, I’m going to heaven on Rav Elyashiv’s coattails.</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>But I think you have a certain responsibility to use your…</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>To use your mind. But there’s a long anti-rationalist tradition within Judaism. So <em>l’chora</em> that’s the safe side, so why not just go with that? Because there you don’t have to think; you can do what they say to do and there’s long Jewish roots for such a tradition.</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>Yes, but there’s the issue of whether you believe that what they say is really true. And is the anti-rationalist side so safe? This relates to some famous criticisms of Pascal’s Wager. First, Pascal is just assuming the issue is choosing between Christianity and Atheism. But what about Hinduism or Islam? But the other criticism is what happens if we get to Heaven and sure enough there is a God, but He says, “All those people who played it safe? I don’t like those types. The ones who used their own judgement, even if it led them not to believe in Me, them I like.” So how do you know that when you get to heaven, and you say to God that you latched on to Rav Elyashiv’s coattails, that God won’t reply, “Hey, c’mon, why didn’t you start thinking on your own? Obviously you should respect Rav Elyashiv’s view, of course take it seriously, study it, don’t just dismiss it out of hand. But who says I want you just to swallow it whole, particularly since there are other views out there. So why just him, and why did you assume that all the other views are illegitimate?” And of course, the truth of the matter is we know that within the Agudah’s circles there’s been a breakdown of the old unity. Rav Shach and others broke with the Agudah. It would be a worthwhile thing to read the <em>Jewish Observer</em> and see if they ever allude to the fundamental break when Rav Shach broke with the Agudah and founded his own party.</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>The impression I get from the Haredi world is that even in their rhetoric there’s a certain allowance for limited pluralism. Kimmy Caplan and Nurit Stadler had an article in the <em>AJS Perspectives</em> on Haredim. So they emphasized in that article how this is a heterogenous community [23]. So I mean I think people say you have your <em>Gadol</em>, I have my <em>Gadol</em> and nobody can have Rav Soloveitchik because he’s <em>treif</em>. But I’m saying, that’s the impression I get. Is that what it is, is that how it’s always been? Or not really?</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>It’s a complicated question. My impression is that there are two levels. When they’re explaining the idea of <em>Daas Torah</em>, they explain it in a more pluralistic way. But in practice, Rav Elyashiv says something and everybody falls into place.</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>Here’s another topic: You wrote your article about Rav Hutner, then you wrote your article about <em>Daas Torah</em>, and you also wrote to the Novominsker Rebbe about how he misunderstood Rabbi Lamm [24]. And so I was wondering if there were any consequences to that…Did anyone talk to you, did you get emails, did you get letters…?</p><p><strong>LK:</strong> I remember ages ago when my article on Rav Hutner appeared, somebody came up to me — he is now a very noted scholar-–and he told me oh how brave I was. But I don’t live in New York, I don’t live in Boro Park, I don’t live in a yeshivishe community, I don’t owe my <em>parnassah</em> to them. I live in Montreal and teach at McGill. I don’t think it required any particular bravery on my part. I know my article on <em>Daas Torah</em> has acquired a certain amount of fame –some might say notoriety– but I would say that from my standpoint, I always thought my most important article, which I wish were better known, is my article on the <em>Shemoneh Perakim</em> [25].</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>That’s your real scholarship.</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>Real scholarship, and I feel that it’s an important article, really a basic essay on the Rambam. I think I got to the heart of the <em>Shemoneh Perakim</em>, and various people who have studied the <em>Shemoneh Perakim</em> and then read my article tend to agree. I remember that I was once asked by a student what I thought was my most important article, and I answered the one on the <em>Shemoneh Perakim</em>. He said, “What about your article on <em>Daas Torah</em>?“ But from a scholarly point of view I think my article on the <em>Shemoneh Perakim</em> is more important. Not that there isn’t any scholarship in my <em>Daas Torah</em> article. Sometimes I feel bad because people assume it’s more of a critique or polemic, so they overlook the scholarly discussion. Like my discussion of <em>Lo Sasur</em>. As I said before, I explore in a systematic way — actually, I probably do this more in my Hebrew article than my English one — all the different ways in which both medieval and modern rabbinic scholars and commentators have tried to deal with the issue of the apparent contradiction between the <em>Sifre</em>, as quoted by Rashi, and the <em>Yerushalmi</em>. I went through all the ways they either tried to harmonize the apparently conflicting views, as well as looked at those who say, as does Rav David Zvi Hoffman, that maybe the <em>Sifre</em> and the <em>Yerushalmi</em> simply disagree. So I think that there are certain discussions of <em>Lo Sasur</em> in more strictly scholarly articles which don’t quote me, when I feel they should have quoted me. Professor Moshe Halbertal in his book on the Ramban makes a point that there are two ways of reading the Ramban on <em>Lo Sasur</em>, a soft reading of the Ramban and a hard reading of the Ramban [26]. When the Ramban says that <em>Torah nitna al daatam shel Hakhmei ha-Torah</em>, does it mean that the Sages could be wrong in their ruling, but they’re given the authority to rule, so you can’t disagree with them? Or does it mean that the meaning of the Torah is indeterminate, and the Sages determine its meaning, in which case they can’t be wrong? Already in my article, I show how Avi Sagi opts for the soft reading and Aaron Kirschenbaum for the hard reading…Or is it vice-versa, I don’t remember. So Halbertal mentions these possibilities; he refers to some scholars who have discussed this; but he doesn’t refer to me, although I had already anticipated his point, because I don’t think he thought of looking at my article, since it’s considered more of a polemical work than a work of scholarship. And the truth is that it is both, and I say so in the article. I say, look, my article is not a strictly scholarly article, but I would like to believe that it’s based on sound historical rabbinic scholarship, but obviously it has a certain ideological <em>tendenz</em>. Anyway, I gather a lot of people have read it. It’s always nice when you write something and you find out people have read it and even appreciated it. Sometimes I feel I write articles and who knows who reads them. Perhaps they sunk like a stone into oblivion.This past summer I was at a conference in Frankfurt, and a young scholar said to me, “I was very influenced by your article on Maimonides and Mendelssohn [27].” So I said “Really?” He replied that he liked my idea of looking at the roots of Mendelssohn‘s thought, of showing how Mendelssohn used Maimonides, and the article influenced his way of looking at things.</p><p>But again, even though I obviously have my own take on things, I try to be as objective and scholarly as possible. Someone actually once wrote — which I took as a compliment — that they feel that Kaplan has no agenda, particularly in terms of his interpretation of the works of Rav Soloveitchik. I try to see things how they are. Well, everyone thinks that’s what they are trying to do.</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>Speaking of the Rav, maybe we could briefly discuss “Revisionism and the Rav.” So you took on the left, took on the right…</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>More the right.</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>Would you take issue with anybody more towards the center?</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>The way it seems to me is that there are issues about Rav Soloveitchik which are really open to interpretation, and I might have a different interpretation of these issues than others. I wasn’t really speaking about that; I was speaking about clear cases of ideological revisionism, where I think the Rav’s position on the issues in question is pretty clear, but scholars try to deny the obvious for ideological reasons.</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>In general, you don’t see revisionism from the center.</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>No, I don’t see revisionism from there. People have different opinions, both legitimate. For example, I disagree with Professor Dov Schwartz. Schwartz sees a very sharp difference between the figure of halakhic man in <em>Ish Hahalakha</em> and the figure of <em>ha-Ish Elokim</em> in <em>U-Vikashtem Misham</em>, while I see them as much more similar [28]. That’s a matter of interpretation; that’s not a matter of revisionism. Even with regard to secular studies, there are aspects of this issue where the Rav was vague, and there’s room for disagreement. In a forthcoming essay, I take issue with Professor David Shatz’s reading of <em>The Lonely Man of Faith</em>. Overall, I think his article is a great article, but I think he had a bit too much of a positive take of the Rav’s portrait of Adam 1 in <em>The Lonely Man of Faith</em> [29]. He said that Adam 1 in imitating God’s creativity fulfills the comand of <em>v’halakhta b’drachav</em>; but the Rav, when he speaks about Adam 1’s creativity, never quotes <em>v’halakhta b’drachav</em>. I also note that the term <em>Hesed</em> is only applied to Adam 2. Adam 1 attains dignity and responsibility, but only Adam 2 is motivated by a sense of <em>Hesed</em>. My feeling is — and I state this in my article — that David’s essay would have been stronger had he focused more on the concrete man of faith who is both Adam 1 and Adam 2. So there are legitimate issues of interpretation. Another issue open to disagreement is how you relate <em>The Lonely Man of Faith</em> to <em>Ish Hahalakha</em> or to other essays.Yet another is the Rav’s view about evolution, and the import of his statement about it in the beginning of <em>The Lonely Man of Faith</em>. All these matters are open to interpretation. I might have my reading and have my reasons for thinking it is the most convincing reading, but I don’t think those who have other readings and disagree with me are engaging in revisionism. There are also many similar questions about how to interpret Rav Kook.</p><p>In general, only now with the publication by the Toras Horav Foundation of many of the unpublished manuscripts of the Rav are we beginning to get a clearer picture of his thought. For example, the volume <em>The Emergence of Ethical Man</em>, edited by Dr. Michael Berger, sheds new light, in my view, on the Rav’s view concerning evolution.</p><p>I want to add something even if it’s off the topic. <em>The Emergence of Ethical Man</em> quotes Buber extensively, particularly Buber’s <em>Moses</em>. And not only does the Rav quote from it, but also, interestingly, the Rav’s idea that Avraham in leaving Mesopotamia behind to go to the land of Canaan was leaving the city behind for a more pastoral form of life is taken from Buber. You probably could find <em>meforshim</em>, maybe Abarbanel, who might say something similar, but the Rav’s way of phrasing the matter — the pastoral mode of life as opposed to the urban mode of life–- reflects the influence of Buber, whom, again, he explicitly cites. It seems he had read <em>Moses</em> at about the time he was writing his essay, and obviously those views of Buber which are not Orthodox he leaves out, but other, “kosher“ views of Buber, as it were, he feels free to cite and make use of.</p><p>I was thinking when I get around to it I’d like to write a review essay of that volume. But, then again, I often tell my students I have two lists. I have a list of articles I’ve written, and another list of articles I haven’t written, but hope to get around to writing someday. And the second list is much longer and also probably much more interesting than the first list.</p><p><strong>BP: </strong>What are you looking at writing?</p><p><strong>LK: </strong>Well, I have this paper I gave yesterday which I am in the middle of writing up on the Rambam’s <em>Hakdamah</em> to the <em>Peirush Ha–Mishnah</em>. There are also essays I’ve already written which haven’t appeared yet, but are forthcoming…one of these days! I have an article about the concept of faith in Rabbi Azriel of Gerona, where I take issue with Mordechai Pachter’s article on the subject, and offer a very different reading [30].Then I just mentioned my critique of David Shatz. It is part of a long article, which is taking forever to appear, on <em>The Lonely Man of Faith</em> and contemporary modern Orthodox Jewish thought. Most of the article is about Rabbi David Hartman’s readings of <em>The Lonely Man of Faith</em>. Another article which I wrote — but is sitting in limbo, and I have no idea when it will appear — is on Rav Hutner’s implicit theology of the Holocaust. I looked at a <em>maamer</em> in <em>Pachad Yitzchak</em>, <em>Maamer Daled</em> in the volume on Rosh Hashanah, where he speaks about <em>Geon Yaakov</em>. What does it mean when we use the phrase “<em>Geon Yaakov</em>“ on Rosh Hashana? My argument there is — the <em>maamar</em>, by the way, is a very fascinating maamar — that even though Rav Hutner in the <em>maamar</em> never mentions the Holocaust, I can’t imagine — and most people I discussed this with tended to agree with me — that in light of several radical and daring points he makes in the <em>maamar</em>, that the Holocaust wasn’t on his mind when he wrote it. So these essays should be appearing eventually. Ironically, one article, which I completed after all of these, but which will most probably be appearing before all of them — it should be out fairly soon — is an essay on the relationship between Rabbi Emanuel Rackman and the Rav, in which I show that they had a close working relationship in the 1950s and that Rabbi Rackman basically — and with the Rav’s approval — assumed the role of his intellectual lieutenant. For people who only know about the Rav’s famous public attack in 1975 on Rabbi Rackman, it should prove to be an eye opener. So, stay tuned!</p><p>Getting back to future projects, people tell me that I should collect my essays on the Rav and make a book of them, and do the same for my essays on the Rambam. But I still have more essays to write on the Rambam and the Rav. As I just mentioned, I am in the middle of writing a long, and — at least I would like to believe– very important essay on the Rambam’s <em>Hakdamah</em> to the <em>Peirush Ha–Mishnah</em>. I’ve pretty written up the first half, but I have to do the second half and then the footnotes. And I don’t know if you heard the paper of Dr. Mordechai Cohen this morning on <em>Ein Mikrah Yotzei Midei Peshuto</em> in the Rambam. I have had an ongoing discussion with him about this, we’ve been exchanging emails; I have a different take on the subject, and one of these days I would like to write about this as well. There are a number of review essays I would like to write as well. First a review essay on some of the recent literature on the Ramban, then another review essay on some of the recent literature on Halevi. Finally, I’d like to write a review essay on the third volume in Toras HoRav, the one on mourning, death, and suffering, <em>Out of the Whirlwind. </em>This review will be different from my review essay of <em>Worship of the Heart</em> in <em>Hakirah</em>, where I was quite hard on its editor, Rabbi Shalom Carmy [31]. Parenthetically, while I still believe that my criticisms of the editing were correct, and, as far as I can tell, they remain unrefuted, in retrospect it seems to me that I might have softened somewhat a harsh phrase or two, and I regret that I did not do so. Be this as it may, I thought the editors of <em>Out of the Whirlwind</em> did a very good job of editing. There are a few points here or there where certain things could be a little clearer; they could have given a few more references here or there, but on the whole they did a very good job, and I will be happy to say so. Contrary to what some people seem to believe, I do not take particular pleasure in writing negative reviews. And then in the review essay, assuming I will ever get around to writing it, I will discuss the Rav’s views on <em>aveilus</em> and how one should respond to evil and suffering, and, with reference to <em>aveilus</em>, take issue with the Rav about some matters…His reading of a comment of Rashi and his understanding of certain aspects of the Rambam on the subject. I checked my ideas out in a phone conversation with Rav Elyakim Koenigsberg, who is a Rosh Yeshiva of YU who edited a volume of the Rav’s torah on <em>aveilus</em> [32]. That is a more lomdishe volume than <em>Out of the Whirlwind</em>. So I ran my criticisms by him, and he said okay. He’s not saying that he agrees with my criticisms, but I’m not off the wall. So if he says I’m not off the wall, you can agree, disagree, but it sounds okay to him, that’s good enough for me to go ahead. I feel safe in putting them forward, and that no one will say “Kaplan, you’re such an <em>am haaretz</em>, how can you even say such things?”</p><p>Things always take longer than you expect. My daughter-in-law was recently joking that she can see me 50 years from now still writing [Dr. Kaplan scribbles on piece of paper in mock anger], “This guy got it all wrong.”</p><p>Actually, I told people that I’m not going to write any more negative reviews, like my review of David Sorkin’s book [33]. From now on, I will review a book only if I can honestly say that it is a good book. Then, of course, I can proceed to discuss the issues the book raises, disagree with the author’s intepretation, you read the evidence this way and I read it that way, etc. Not that I don’t think it’s not important to write harsh reviews sometimes. You have to maintain standards and scare people, so people should know that you should write about things you know about and not write about things you don’t know about, do your homework, and don’t assume that you can write something sloppy and you’re not going to be called on it. Someone may sit down and rip you to pieces, so be careful! But I’ve written my share –some may say more than my share –of such reviews, and from now on I’ll leave that necessary, but unpleasant job to other people.</p><p>[1] Lawrence Kaplan, “Daas Torah: A Modern Conception of Rabbinic Authority,” in <em>Rabbinic Authority and Personal Autonomy</em>, ed. Moshe Z. Sokol (Northvale: Jason Aronson, 1992), 1–60</p><p>[2] Yitzchok Hutner, “Holocaust — A Study of the Term, and the Epoch It Is Meant to Describe” trans. and ed. Yaakov Feitman and Chaim Feurman, <em>Jewish Observer</em>, October 1977: 6–12</p><p>[3] Moshe Meiselman, “The Rav, Feminism, and Public Policy: An Insider’s Overview,” <em>Tradition </em>33.1 (1998): 5–30</p><p>[4] Kaplan, “<a href="http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0411/is_3_48/ai_64507449/">Revisionism and the Rav: The Struggle for the Soul of Modern Orthodoxy</a>,” <em>Judaism</em> 48, no. 3 (Summer 1999): 290–311(accessed July 29, 2009).</p><p>[5] Kaplan, “Rabbi Isaac Hutner’s ‘Daat Torah Perspective’ on the Holocaust: A Critical Perspective,” <em>Tradition</em> 18, no. 3 (Fall 1980): 235–248</p><p>[6] Kaplan, “Daat Torah: A Modern View of Rabbinic Authority,” in Zev Safrai and Avi Sagi, eds., <em>Between Authority and Autonomy in Jewish Tradition</em>, 105–145. Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuhad, 1997 [Hebrew].</p><p>[7] For the location of all of these sources and explication on how Dr. Kaplan interprets them, see “Daas Torah.”</p><p>[8] See Alfred Cohen, “Daat Torah,” <em>Journal of Halacha and Contemporary Society</em> 45 (Spring 2003): 67–105 and the ensuing correspondence between Rabbi Cohen and Dr. Kaplan in idem. 46 (Fall 2003): 110–123.</p><p>[9] Eliezer Menachem Man Shach, <em>Michtavim U’Maamarim Mi</em><strong><em>‘</em></strong><em>maran Ha</em><strong><em>‘</em></strong><em>gaon</em> <em>Rabbi Elazar Menachem Man Shach</em> 4:320</p><p>[10] Michel Yehuda Lefkovitz, Yitzchak Shiner, and Yisrael Elya Veintraub, “<a href="http://zootorah.com/controversy/cherem.pdf">Giluy Daat</a>,”Zoo Torah, (accessed July 28, 2009) [Hebrew]</p><p>[11] For an example of an article which promulgated the rumor that rabbis who gave their haskama to the book retracted, see the cached version of G. Safran, “<a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20050119020659/http://chareidi.shemayisrael.com/aslifkin.htm">Gedolei Yisrael Ban Rabbi Nosson Slifkin’s Books</a>,” <em>Yated Ne’eman</em>, January 12, 2005, (accessed July 28, 2009). The <em>Yated</em>’s website later “updated” this article correcting this error while neither the <em>Yated</em> nor the website issued an official retraction of the claim. See G. Safran, “<a href="http://chareidi.shemayisrael.com/archives5765/bo/aslifkin.htm">Gedolei Yisrael Ban Rabbi Nosson Slifkin’s Books</a>,” <em>Yated Ne’eman</em>, January 12, 2005, (accessed July 28, 2009). For Rabbi Slifkin’s account of how his books were banned and he was not given a chance to present his case, see Natan Slifkin, “<a href="http://zootorah.com/controversy/account.html">Account of Events</a>,” Zoo Torah, (accessed July 28, 2009).</p><p>[12] “Account”</p><p>[13] See idem. on Rabbi Feldman’s original support for Rabbi Slifkin. Rabbi Feldman later wrote an essay attacking the positions espoused by Rabbi Slifkin. See Aharon Feldman, “<a href="http://zootorah.com/controversy/slifkinarticle.doc">The Slifkin Affair — Issues and Perspectives</a>,” Zoo Torah, (accessed July 29, 2009).</p><p>[14] Rav Aryeh Carmell gave a <em>haskamah</em> and, when the ban came out, reiterated his support for Rabbi Slifkin. See <a href="http://www.zootorah.com/books/RavCarmell.pdf">Aryeh Carmell</a>, Zoo Torah, (accessed July 28, 2009) and Aryeh Carmell, “<a href="http://zootorah.com/controversy/RavCarmellReiteration.jpg">Re: ‘The Science of the Torah’ by Rabbi Nosson Slifkin</a>” Zoo Torah, (accessed July 27, 2009).</p><p>[15] Daniel Eidensohn, “<a href="http://hirhurim.blogspot.com/2006/06/age-of-universe.html">Age of the Universe</a>,” Hirhurim, entry posted June 20, 2006, (accessed July 28, 2009). There have been a few other Haredi dissenters: See Toby Katz, “<a href="http://www.cross-currents.com/archives/2005/01/24/my-300-page-book-on-the-slifkin-affair/">My 300-Page Book on the Slifkin Affair</a>,” Cross Currents, (accessed September 9, 2009); Rav Chaim Malinowitz’s letter of support for Rabbi Slifkin available at <a href="http://zootorah.com/controversy/RavMalinowitz.jpg">Zoo Torah</a> (accessed September 9, 2009); and Marvin Schick, “<a href="http://www.cross-currents.com/archives/2005/01/27/rachok-karovim/">Richuk Karovim</a>,” Cross Currents, (accessed September 9, 2009)</p><p>[16] Binyamin Brown, “The Da’at Torah Doctrine: Three Stages,” <em>Jerusalem Studies in Jewish Thought</em> 19 (2005): 537–600 [Hebrew]</p><p>[17] Yoel Finkelman, “Nostalgia, Inspiration, Ambivalence: Eastern Europe, Immigration, and the Construction of Collective Memory in Contemporary American Haredi Historiography” <em>Jewish History</em> 23, no. 1 (March 2009): 57–82</p><p>[18] The original comment by Mrs. Katz reads as follows:</p><p>…I have news for you. EVERYONE manipulates history, everyone. Have you read any history textbook lately, and compared it to any history textbook of thirty or forty years ago? Women are much more prominent, Indians are noble and pure and one with nature, yada yada. No matter who writes the book, there is an agenda. Everybody has an agenda. Everybody. The myth of pure, dispassionate research — “just the facts, ma’am” — is just that, a myth. And academics are just as guilty of selective memory and revisionism as ArtScroll hagiographers, if not more so.</p><p>See Toby Katz, <a href="http://www.haloscan.com/comments/hirhurim/8492574167650922432/">comment</a> on “Nostalgia as History,” Hirhurim, comment posted December 17, 2008, #604322 (accessed July 27, 2009).</p><p>[19] Dovid Gottlieb, “<a href="http://www.dovidgottlieb.com/comments/daastorah.htm">Sources for Daas Torah</a>,” DovidGottlieb.com, (accessed July 27, 2009)</p><p>[20] Eruvin 13b</p><p>[21] Rabbi Slifkin discusses this view in various articles on his website. See for example Slifkin, “<a href="http://zootorah.com/controversy/InDefenseOfMyOpponents.pdf">In Defense of My Opponents</a>” Zoo Torah, (accessed July 29, 2009).</p><p>[22] DES, “<a href="http://torahandscience.blogspot.com/2006/04/sources-indicating-that-chazal-did-not.html">Sources Indicating That Chazal Did Not Possess Perfect Scientific Knowledge</a>,” Torah, Science, Et Al., entry posted April 30, 2006, (accessed June 27, 2009)</p><p>[23] Kimmy Caplan and Nurit Stadler, “Haredim and the Study of Haredim in Israel: Reflections on a Recent Conference,” <em>AJS Perspectives</em>, Spring 2008, 32</p><p>[24] Kaplan, “Modernity vs. Eternity” <em>Jewish Observer</em>, April 1994: 13</p><p>[25] Kaplan, “An Introduction to Maimonides’ ‘Eight Chapters,’” <em>The Edah Journal</em> 2, no. 2 (June-July 2002): 2–23</p><p>[26] Moshe Halbertal, <em>Al derekh ha-emet : ha-Ramban ṿi-yetsiratah shel masoret</em> (Jerusalem: Mekhon Shalom Hartman, 2006) [Hebrew]</p><p>[27] Kaplan, “Maimonides and Mendelssohn on the Election of Israel, the Origins of Idolatry and the Oral Law” in <em>Perspectives on Jewish Thought and Mysticism</em>, edited by Alfred L. Ivry, Elliot R. Wolfson, and Allan Arkush (Amsterdam: Harwood, 1998), 423–445</p><p>[28] Dov Schwartz, <em>Religion or Halakha: The Philosophy of Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik</em>, Trans. Batya Stein (Leiden: Brill, 2007)</p><p>[29] David Shatz, “Practical Endeavor and the Torah u-Madda Debate,” <em>Torah U-Madda Journal</em> 3: 98–149. See also Kaplan, “<a href="http://www.vanleer.org.il/Data/UploadedFiles/video/105/e_session12.htm">Rabbi Soloveitchik’s Lonely Man of Faith in Contemporary Modern Orthodox Thought</a>” (Lecture, Studies Exploring the Influence of Rabbi J. B. Soloveitchik on Culture, Education and Jewish Thought: An International Conference Commemorating the Centenary of his Birth, Van Leer Jerusalem Institute, December 31, 2003), Van Leer Jerusalem Institute, (accessed July 29, 2009).</p><p>[30] Mordechai Pachter, “The Root of Faith is the Root of Heresy,” in <em>Roots of Faith and Devequt</em>: <em>Studies in the History of Kabbalistic Ideas</em> (Los Angeles: Cherub Press, 2004), 13–51.</p><p>[31] Kaplan, review of <em>Worship of the Heart: Essays on Prayer</em>, by Shalom Carmy. <em>Hakirah</em> 5 (Fall 2007): 79–114.</p><p>[32] Elyakim Koenigsberg, <em>Shiuirei ha-Rav `al Inyenei Aveilus ve-Tisha be-Av</em> (Jerusalem: Mesorah,1999)</p><p>[33] Kaplan, review of <em>Moses Mendelssohn and the Religious Enlightenment</em>, by David Sorkin. <em>AJS Review</em> 23, no. 2 (1998): 300–307.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cd05ff6935ce" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Conservatism, Depression, and the Scandal of Leftist Indifference]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PeltaRepublic/conservatism-depression-and-the-scandal-of-leftist-indifference-80cf8560ae54?source=rss-6391bfb02960------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/80cf8560ae54</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Pelta]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 03 Mar 2019 02:59:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-14T05:39:57.821Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Current Affairs</em> editor Nathan J. Robinson wrote an <a href="https://www.currentaffairs.org/2018/12/dear-lobsters-there-is-a-better-way">article</a> at the end of 2018 inspired by his reading of the <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/enoughpetersonspam/comments/7u6he1/exlobsters_tank_special_rules_apply/">Ex-Lobsters Tank</a> thread on the <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/enoughpetersonspam/">r/enoughpetersonspam subreddit</a>, a forum in which former Jordan Peterson acolytes (“lobsters”, as they’re sometimes referred to for reasons relating to Peterson’s particular theology) discuss their disillusionment with their former leader. Robinson notes that the ex-lobsters often talk about having come across Peterson during a period of depression and uses that fact as a springboard to discuss the phenomenon of depressed guys falling in behind right-wing thinkers generally.</p><p>Robinson thinks “ these men seem like they just needed to discover <a href="https://www.currentaffairs.org/2018/12/lessons-from-chomsky">Chomsky</a> rather than Peterson.” He thinks the solutions to the problems they have lie on the left, and he makes the following heartfelt plea to those who might’ve been attracted to Peterson, right-wing youtubers, Ben Shapiro, or similar personalities that ordinary folks get redpilled by*:</p><blockquote>Depression and anxiety are widespread among young people today, and it’s not because they haven’t bothered to stand up straight and clean their rooms. It’s because we live in a scary, lonely world, one where support networks have eroded and people in our generation face increasingly precarious futures.</blockquote><blockquote>Nobody on the right has any answers for this. If you don’t believe me, ask them. They don’t have solutions for climate change. They just either deny it or pretend it won’t be so bad. They don’t have solutions for health care — they have no plausible plan for making it so an ambulance ride costs less than $1000. They don’t care if your boss treats you like shit, or you get laid off and lose your insurance, or you can’t afford your rent. They’re not thinking about how to make it so you can afford an education and decent housing, or how to rebuild community bonds. The right are the ones that traffic in “shame” — everything is your fault if you fail. If you suffer, it’s probably because you deserved it. Should have worked harder. On the left, we don’t buy that crap. We know that when problems affect millions of people, it’s not helpful to simply blame their individual defects. We’ve got to work together and help each other out. In some ways, the left is quite Christian: Love thy neighbor.</blockquote><p>I would note that conservatives can be quite kind and helpful on a personal level when their friends are in trouble and that indeed the right does have answers for your suffering beyond “you deserved it;” those answers consist of finger-pointing at feminists, affirmative action, and “cultural Marxists” for your problems. So the quote above is something of a caricature but those qualifiers aside, I agree with the general thrust of the point: The right-wing’s indeed rather bereft of serious ideas for seriously addressing any of the problems Robinson mentions on a systemic level.</p><p>But Robinson then attempts to sell the left to those who have bought into conservative public intellectuals, and here I think he goes astray. Robinson’s own long form <a href="https://www.currentaffairs.org/2018/03/the-intellectual-we-deserve">critique</a> of Peterson recognizes that the latter is able to sell so well precisely because academia and the left haven’t provided a competing vision; he notes the lack of “other professors with accessible and compelling YouTube channels, with books of helpful advice and long Q&amp;A sessions with the public”, thus leaving a void that Peterson fills. But here in this article he fails to recognize other similar voids that the left is leaving that the right is filling, and I want to address those.</p><p>Nathan writes:</p><blockquote>…I think there’s a misconception — people think that “the left” only empathizes selectively, and is therefore merely trying to “signal virtue.”…This might be true of some leftists, but not the kind I identify with. Most of us are pretty consistent. We don’t like oppression and injustice no matter where it’s found…</blockquote><blockquote>We also care about you.</blockquote><p>Do you though? Do you care about the issues that affect me and the people I know?</p><p>I decided to ask my friends who are involved in various causes. One raises awareness of child abuse and how to address it in the Orthodox Jewish community. He also lobbies for legislation in Albany, and has been particularly focused on passing the Child Victims Act in the State of New York. What would the CVA <a href="https://buffalonews.com/2018/11/08/child-victims-act-likely-to-move-ahead-with-new-ny-senate-majority/">do?</a> “Current law gives victims until age 23 to file civil cases or seek criminal charges. Under the act, victims could file civil suits until age 50 and seek criminal charges until age 28. The bill would also create a one-year window allowing victims to file civil lawsuits for alleged abuse now barred by the existing statute of limitations.” Conservatives held control of the New York State Senate until this year and have been blocking the CVA. After Democrats took control, it’s now the law.</p><p>Now, the CVA was not originally a bill universally endorsed by Democrats. The Catholic Church and some in the teachers’ unions weren’t exactly thrilled with a bill that might extend liability. It took time, lobbying, <a href="https://www.nydailynews.com/news/politics/child-victims-act-supporters-prepare-brooklyn-bridge-march-article-1.2650579">marching</a>, protesting, and sustained heavy journalistic coverage on the issue. There have been lots of folks from all walks of life involved in this cause: From Orthodox Jews like my friend to folks from the Universal Zulu Nation to the journalists at The New York Daily News who kept the heat on Albany to Gary Greenberg who started the <a href="https://protectnykids.org/">Fighting for Children PAC</a> to support pro-CVA candidates. It eventually even received the spotlight of a national comedy show when Sam Bee covered the issue on her <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SNKPVAlp_jc&amp;t=3s">show</a>.</p><p>The CVA is only the beginning of what many victims are asking for: They want the state of New York to implement reforms to ensure (as most other states do) that kids are educated about abuse, they want an assistance fund for survivors of abuse, and they want to strengthen the CVA by extending or eliminating the criminal statute of limitations. There was a lot of activism (full disclosure: some of which I was myself involved in qua activist) done in order to get just the CVA on the Democratic agenda. But one would think that The Left would’ve wanted to be involved at least in solidarity and certainly in wanting to strengthen what the victims should be recompensed with.</p><p>I wondered if the left was more involved in these causes than I’d previously been aware. I asked my friend what the role of leftists was regarding CVA advocacy. His response? “It doesn’t rank for them.” The Democratic Socialists of America were focused on big political proposals like Medicare for All, but child abuse issues simply did not seem to be on their radar. My friend recalled a singular DSA member attending a protest with him and getting triggered by the word “rape;” otherwise, leftists have been mostly AWOL from the cause. If the left is all about intersectionality and solidarity, I wondered, why weren’t they involved with the cause of the least of these my brothers? It’s political, it involves restitution/reparations for victims, it‘s a fight against conservative defenders of the status quo for doing what appears to me to be the obvious right thing...It should check all of the left’s boxes. If they care, the big leftist organizations have to send delegations or at least issue googleable public statements pushing for this sort of legislation, right? If anybody has been damaged by “oppression and injustice,” and needs support, it has to be a child abuse victim.</p><p>“Okay, well, maybe I’m missing something. Robinson said the left is <em>pretty </em>consistent about caring about people. There’s always an exception to the rule and one example of the left <em>appearing </em>to drop the ball doesn’t mean they don’t <em>generally</em> care about everybody consistently,” I thought to myself. So I then turned to another friend to see if his experiences with the left were different.</p><p>This friend, Naftuli Moster, leads <a href="https://www.yaffed.org/">Yaffed</a>, an advocacy organization that is involved in trying to ensure that yeshivas in the state of New York teach kids the basics for functioning in a civil society, things like math and history. These schools were required by New York State law to give kids a substantially equivalent education to the public schools but failed to do so. “I don’t know anyone from the DSA movement who took on the cause,” he told me.</p><p>The truth is this wasn’t a surprise to me. I went to a therapeutic boarding school in the North Georgia mountains that was verbally and emotionally abusive; the State of Georgia’s Office of Residential Child Care has long admitted that “multiple regulatory violations including insufficient staffing, medications not administered accurately, failure to provide protective care and oversight and failure to report incidents. Often there were multiple and repeated citations for the same deficiency…. ORCC failed to follow through to ensure that the documented deficiencies were ultimately remedied and the children confined there were protected from harm.” Before I went there, Nancy Reagan and Princess Di promoted Straight Inc., which before it was cool to put kids in cages, <a href="https://www.huffpost.com/entry/straight-inc_n_5c76a914e4b062b30eba021e?fbclid=IwAR06xK6yN6WKa11WV2njgzi3JBEZexkeCILzzuhtWLZc3x6LHzEeAN14xvg">put kids in warehouses</a>. There are still behavioral modification scams conning parents throughout the country and folks who are paid by their parents to kidnap kids in the middle of the night and drag them to these places (I know of one who is a Bernie supporter!). The only place in the world which administers a shock treatment that the former UN Special Rapporteur on Torture has called for <a href="http://healthland.time.com/2013/03/06/u-n-report-suggests-some-autism-addiction-treatments-are-akin-to-torture/">banning</a>, is in Massachusetts. There’s a Democratic bill, The Stop Child Abuse in Residential Programs for Teens Act, which would regulate these institutions better. It has been stalled since I was a child. The Left seems to have done nothing.</p><p>All three of the causes I referred to above — those of child abuse survivors, of education reform, and the troubled teen industry — involve the most vulnerable of populations, children. <em>The left</em> has failed to take up their cause. The left has left a vacuum in these areas that create depression and anxiety over a lifetime. While it’s true that the right’s individualist ethos of “suck it up and get over it” is counterproductive, the left has failed to provide an effective, rationally-based counternarrative.</p><p>But perhaps I was being unfair judging The Left from the perspective of a writer. Robinson recommended going to a DSA meeting:</p><blockquote>Do not listen to the lies, whether it’s from conservatives talking about “SJWs” or neoliberal pundits condemning “BernieBros.” If you are feeling sad and hopeless, you need a community of good people who care about you. You won’t find that community in the bitter world of right-wing YouTube. You’ll find it in a labor union, or at a <a href="https://www.dsausa.org/">Democratic Socialists of America</a> meeting. Don’t allow yourself to be tricked by hucksters who don’t actually care about what happens to you.. Then come and join the left. Experience the <a href="https://www.currentaffairs.org/2018/07/the-joys-of-solidarity">joys of solidarity</a>. A better world is possible.</blockquote><p>So I went with a friend to a local DSA New Member Orientation to see what all the buzz was about. It just so happened my friend is an ex-lobster; he found the individualist messaging of <em>Twelve Rules for Life</em> to be profound and inspiring but was disappointed by much of the meshugas in Peterson’s speeches and twitter feed.</p><p>At the meeting, we got a hard sell about how we should join the DSA because we’d get a vote in this organization. Somebody who used to be part of the leadership chatted us up about the importance of Medicare-for-All; I mentioned my activism surrounding childrens’ rights issues, which she hadn’t been aware of. One of the leaders of the group gave a speech in which he talked about the importance of volunteering once in awhile to knock on our neighbors’ doors to help DSA with its housing agenda in NY, how the organization would be rallying behind Bernie once his campaign revved up, how if we joined the organization we’d have a vote for the DSA agenda, and how cool that was. I mentioned to somebody how an acquaintance of mine wanted help regarding starting a union; I was referred to the “union guy” who had a good chat with me about it and took down my contact information but he never got back to me (said acquaintance later tried contacting a union, which never got back to him either).</p><p>I sat down with my ex-lobster friend for pizza. Both of us felt like we were getting a hard sell for helping out the DSA, but nothing particularly inspired us. It felt to me and I think to him like the meeting was asking for our help but not offering to help us in any meaningful way, like we were being asked to care about the plights of others but nobody was particularly expressing interest in our stories. Ironically, for such a non-conservative place, it was just another place in America where we were being encouraged to shell out money (dues) in order to join an organization which would ostensibly help us with our struggles in the modern world but seemed more focused on how we could give more of ourselves in a world that’s already asking so much of us to help other people.</p><p>I don’t mean to critique the DSA per se here; my sympathies generally tend to be on the left, I think DSA’s doing good work, and I wish them the best. But it’s not for me and frankly, I don’t see it doing much for many ex-lobsters. I give of myself in a lot of ways (including in my job in social services) but I’m frankly more likely to find folks who are interested in me and my story in a right-wing Orthodox Jewish synagogue (which are often quite populist in their approach; cholent and free Shabbos meals are responsible for creating a lot of Republican Jews) than a DSA meeting.</p><p>The left has clearly failed in recent years. The centre-right parties have taken power in the vast majority of the top countries in the Human Development Index. Depression and anxiety often have roots in the vulnerable state of childhood, and a left that continues to fail to speak up for the plight of all children will I think continue to fail to create a community which is empathetic and inclusive enough to consistently defeat the right. To wit: Depression and anxiety are scourges of the modern world but the left hasn’t really created populist public intellectuals and literature to address this phenomenon from a leftist perspective.</p><p>Robinson is correct to note that people struggling with depression and anxiety are indeed turning to the right-wing public intellectuals with their irresponsible faux populism. But the left hasn’t provided a community that offers a counternarrative of communal support for these people before they fall for the siren song of conservatism. Of course, some folks will always go for the right-wing, but we could sure siphon a lot of that support if we were creating communities that were more inclusive of and empathetic toward stories of folks from different walks of life.</p><p>*Robinson also includes a dig at Sam Harris, but I’m not sure the critiques that Robinson makes of the right here apply to him per se.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=80cf8560ae54" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Revisionism and the Radical: The Struggle for Political Sanity]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PeltaRepublic/revisionism-and-the-radical-the-struggle-for-political-sanity-ba4def2b6684?source=rss-6391bfb02960------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ba4def2b6684</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Pelta]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 27 Jan 2019 14:28:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-10T06:59:01.982Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I never thought this was a sentence I’d write but…</p><p>An academic whose work I have long respected linked to a Piers Morgan opinion piece in The Daily Mail and so I feel the need to address it.</p><p>In said <a href="https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6632157/PIERS-MORGAN-Alexandria-Ocasio-Cortez-glossy-socialist-version-Donald-Trump-pricey-heels.html?ito=facebook_share_fbia-top&amp;fbclid=IwAR31EZ0CU5l8CqIkmFGYXXsCHNG0QV_0hoNRboQ9aIZTtiwlIgIpMmZetFQ">article</a>, Piers Morgan compares AOC to Trump.</p><p>Some people put encouraging post-it notes up on AOC’s office plaque telling her how much they admire what she’s doing. She wrote a tweet saying, “‘I’ll keep these up as long as they stick.” Morgan argues this means she “bows to nobody in self-adoration, even it means creating a shrine to her own magnificence on her office door.” But actually, if somebody was posting encouraging post-its to my cubicle, it wouldn’t mean I adore myself. Rather, I’d take it as a sign of support and I’d keep them up in order to encourage myself more.</p><p>Morgan backs up his argument that she’s egotistical by writing that she “even compared her New York election victory to America’s 1969 Moon landing and the 1964 Civil Rights Act.” You can watch the <a href="https://www.facebook.com/sunrisemvmt/videos/1916719775112164/">video </a>where she does this.</p><p>The comparison she makes is movements doing things that others thought impossible in order to bring the country back from the brink of the abyss. She notes that her campaign started with 5 people and ended with thousands, and says this is how movements get going. When a politician says something like that, you might be tempted to say that it shows how egotistical they are, but like the post it notes, it’s really just mussar: We’re building movements and following in the footsteps of greater movements, we can do this.</p><p>He then claims anecdotally that AOC’s supporters came after him with a competition on how he should die. He says her supporters being terrible is because of her virtue signaling. I don’t know what happened there because Piers provides no links; if it’s true that AOC supporters said mean things about him (and as Piers’s friends would happily point out I’m sure, they’re Innocent Until Proven Guilty, right?), I concede though that that’s really wrong. (Incidentally there seems to be something of a double standard here: Nobody holds Jordan Peterson responsible for everything his commenters write. And they write disgusting stuff all over the Internet).</p><p>“‘The world is going to end in 12 years if we don’t address climate change,’ she announced dramatically this week, a statement that is just as preposterous as Trump’s insistence that climate change is fake news.”</p><p>She did say that during a back-and-forth discussion with Ta Nehisi Coates. She later retweeted Michael Mann’s agreement with the following tweet from Polisci321062:</p><p>“@AOC Doesn’t literally mean that the world will end in 12 years. She’s saying we have a very limited carbon budget and are walking into a mine field @MichaelEMann analogy the more we burn CO2 the worse drought, wildfire, coral bleaching, record temps, rising sea level etc. become”</p><p>That’s a pretty reasonable backtrack and par for the course for politicians. So actually, no, she doesn’t believe the world is ending in 12 years. (It should be noted that this is not akin to Trump, who if he magically transformed into a leftist, would’ve just doubled down and told you that “many people” are saying that the world’s ending in 12 years, “totally true, I saw the scientists saying it on TV, believe me.” Also, conservatives don’t believe climate change is a problem we can do anything about so kinda weird for ’em to complain about ignorance on the topic…but I digress).</p><p>He slams her for wanting “to slap a 70% tax rate for the wealthiest Americans,” It’s actually a marginal tax rate for people making above 10 million dollars a year. Debatable! But top economists are advocating for a 73% tax rate. Most Americans like that idea.</p><p>Morgan then complains about her wearing expensive clothes ($4000ish). He does not inform you this was done for a photoshoot and the clothing borrowed by the magazine. Imagine that! A politician who is expected to dress formally wanting to look elegant for a photoshoot! Oh the humanity!</p><p>He gets upset at her lamenting the closure of a restaurant she once worked at, saying the owner (actually, co-owner) blames the minimum wage hike. The minimum wage did contribute to the place closing, as did the absurd rent increases. Here’s what else he said:</p><p>“‘I do think it’s going to leave a hole of some sort in Manhattan; I don’t know when there will be another. But then, there’s always the next one,’ he said. ‘I’ve been joking with my friends that everyone is crying now but 30 days from now people will have moved on. That’s what we do in New York. In New York we move on. It’s a moving, changing city and there will be other things that come up and The Coffee Shop just be a great memory.’”</p><p>Paradigms shift, people get new jobs, new places open. One can be saddened that an old restaurant with great memories is closing as well as think it’s important that people be able to live on their salaries.</p><p>He also accuses Ocasio Cortez of being critical of Uber while her campaign used Uber. Nu nu. I bet Piers buys sneakers from companies that make ’em in conditions he’s against.</p><p>He then points out several “lies” she’s said that were actually gaffes where she later clarified her position on twitter. Now, it’s true that she almost never admits to being wrong (like most politicians), but she does usually correct her false statements (unlike Trump!). He snarks at her for the infamous 60 minutes interview remarks:</p><p>“When she was challenged….on 60 Minutes, she responded: ‘I think there’s a lot of people more concerned about being precisely, factually and semantically correct than about being morally right.’</p><p>Ah, I see. So facts don’t really matter… so long as it’s AOC who’s the one making stuff up!”</p><p>Piers doesn’t include the next part of the interview:</p><p>“Anderson Cooper: But being factually correct is important —</p><p>Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez: It’s absolutely important. And whenever I make a mistake. I say, “Okay, this was clumsy.” and then I restate what my point was. But it’s — it’s not the same thing as — as the president lying about immigrants. It’s not the same thing, at all.”</p><p>Weird that he wouldn’t include that! Kinda undercuts his entire point!</p><p>Finally, Piers Morgan points out that AOC’s policy proposals are pie-in-the-sky, unaffordable stuff. He cries out about how “nonsensical” it all is, pointing to the pricing. He cites a Vox article on this point. I looked up the article. It calculated that according to even liberal estimates, “America would need to match, or even surpass, Europe’s enormous tax burden on the middle class.” True, and that’s a debate we’re not having yet because it’s a very inconvenient truth. But it’s the direction we need to head in and that’s the point. Piers ponders, “would it also be good to live under a socialist President?” Dude, you’re British. Y’all have been living with high taxes and better entitlements. Your country doesn’t wanna get rid of it. And well they shouldn’t want to.</p><p>Morgan’s conclusion is that “AOC is Donald Trump in high heels: a fast-talking, shoot-from-the-hip, fact-mangling, narcissistic, Twitter-addicted, aggressive, ruthlessly ambitious New Yorker.”</p><p>He fails to make this point. AOC has backed down from false claims (also: isn’t a criminal! didn’t say she can grab anybody by the dick! etc.). If my friend the academic who posted this piece had seen articles making arguments this bad about theology or history, I’m sure he would’ve skewered ’em. Actually, that’s not a hypothetical; he has skewered ‘em.</p><p>I hope my modest attempt at a rebuttal here might show him and other rationalist-minded people that while the both-sidesist trap might be tempting, one doesn’t have to agree with AOC on every aspect of policy to see how ludicrous much of the criticism of her is.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ba4def2b6684" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Captain Morgan is Right: Let Under-35's Run for President]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PeltaRepublic/captain-morgan-is-right-let-under-35s-run-for-president-d6a391c58c3?source=rss-6391bfb02960------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d6a391c58c3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[constitution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2016-election]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ageism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Pelta]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 28 Nov 2016 19:28:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-28T19:43:04.434Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The rum producer Captain Morgan put together a <a href="http://adage.com/article/cmo-strategy/captain-morgan-lower-presidential-age-limit/305023/">PR campaign</a> in July which made the political case that we ought to amend the Constitution in order that under-35&#39;s should be allowed to be president. Let me just say that as somebody who has not yet had the opportunity to taste his alcohol, I do stand with the Captain on this issue. In fact, I believe all age requirements in the Constitution are ageist and ought to be abolished.</p><p>First of all, we used to not be so technical about laws in this country; people used to run for president on third party tickets without being 35 years old and Henry Clay joined the Senate before he had reached that body’s age requirement.</p><p>Secondly, we ought to objectively look at how the reasoning people gave for the age requirements for high office is clearly antiquated. Continental Congress delegate Tench Coxe <a href="https://books.google.com/books?id=tQuJCgAAQBAJ&amp;pg=PT26&amp;lpg=PT26&amp;dq=he+cannot+be+an+idiot,+probably+not+a+knave+or+a+tyrant,+for+those+whom+nature+makes+so,+discover+it+before+the+age+of+thirty-five,+until+which+period+he+cannot+be+elected&amp;source=bl&amp;ots=tz0czBc21m&amp;sig=k9WsfmByare2Xd7dLXa5T7f0a4o&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ved=0ahUKEwiSyOTFh8zQAhUGjVQKHbbhDEQQ6AEIHTAA#v=onepage&amp;q=he%20cannot%20be%20an%20idiot%2C%20probably%20not%20a%20knave%20or%20a%20tyrant%2C%20for%20those%20whom%20nature%20makes%20so%2C%20discover%20it%20before%20the%20age%20of%20thirty-five%2C%20until%20which%20period%20he%20cannot%20be%20elected&amp;f=false">argued</a>:</p><p>“[The president] cannot be an idiot, probably not a knave or a tyrant, for those whom nature makes so, discover it before the age of thirty-five, until which period he cannot be elected.”</p><p>Considering our current president elect, it is clear that the president can indeed be an idiot, probably a knave, and perhaps even tyrannical. Age requirements clearly do nothing to stop bad or stupid people from obtaining high office.</p><p>The founding father George Mason successfully argued for the inclusion in the constitution of an age requirement of 25 for membership in the House of Representatives. He <a href="http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-bloggers/2738128/posts">maintained</a> that “ every man carried with him in his own experience a scale for measuring the deficiency of young politicians; since he would if interrogated be obliged to declare that his political opinions at the age of 21. were too crude &amp; erroneous to merit an influence on public measures.” Considering the <a href="http://www.forbes.com/sites/niallmccarthy/2016/11/09/the-2016-elections-generation-gap-infographic/#7c16ac37404d">politics</a> of baby boomers, <a href="http://www.cbsnews.com/news/more-donald-trump-tapes-surface-from-howard-stern-show/">crudeness</a> and <a href="http://www.politifact.com/personalities/donald-trump/">erroneousness</a> are clearly not considered too problematic for them. Another founder, John Wilson, dissented with the age requirement: he argued at the time that the “motion tended to damp the efforts of genius, and of laudable ambition. There was no more reason for incapacitating youth than age, where the requisite qualifications were found.” He noted that “many instances might be mentioned of signal services rendered in high stations to the public before the age of 25,” citing the parliamentarians George St John and William Pitt the Younger (both whom joined the House of Commons at the age of 21, with the latter going on to become Chancellor of the Exchequer at 23 and Prime Minister at 24) as examples. We now have the benefit of the hindsight of history and know that Pitt in particular was a great politician and in the conservative Times’s relatively nonpartisan ranking of prime ministers, he is <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_rankings_of_Prime_Ministers_of_the_United_Kingdom">given</a> high marks by all their correspondents. Older politicians have not always fared so well when history has looked back on them; James Buchanan was our 3rd oldest president (will be the 4th after Trump is sworn in) and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_rankings_of_Presidents_of_the_United_States#Notable_scholar_surveys">consistently</a> is considered among our worst.</p><p>George Mason — as he was wrong on many issues and as the school bearing his name <a href="http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/George_Mason_University">continues</a> that legacy to this day — was wrong. John Wilson and Captain Morgan are right. It’s time we amend the constitution to give the latter founder and the pirate rum mascot the respect their opinion deserves. If Donald Trump can be president, I see no reason somebody the same age as William Pitt the Younger cannot run for any office the public deems him fit for.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d6a391c58c3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Toward a New Narrative of Strength: One Ingredient in Stopping the Right]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PeltaRepublic/toward-a-new-narrative-of-strength-one-ingredient-in-stopping-the-right-d2dc16c7b815?source=rss-6391bfb02960------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d2dc16c7b815</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2016-election]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Pelta]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 23 Nov 2016 05:07:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-23T05:07:53.055Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Right now, we’re in the middle of an international rise of the right wing.</p><p>The response of many of my friends on the left is to say we need to kick the mainstream establishment of our party out of leadership, empower left-wing leaders, make noises about embracing policies that help people out in yehupitzville.</p><p>I’m somewhat skeptical of these proposals as the sole correctives. It’s impossible to know if Bernie would have won the election, but I have my doubts. Jeremy Corbyn is doing all these things, is losing in the polls, and losing badly. Corbyn voters don’t lie about who they’re gonna vote for at the same rate as folks who voted for Trump; there’s not going to be a surprise present for Corbyn like Trump got in Wisconsin.</p><p>There’s not one panacea but we can look at what the right has been doing to be successful for some potential ingredients for greater success. One might be working on our narrative. Rhetoric isn’t everything, but it is something.</p><p>The libertarian-leaning hard right has been furious at the government Doing Things particularly since the 40&#39;s (more on this in a forthcoming post I have been working on) and they have become the dominant faction in the GOP. This has attracted people with real problems who don’t know what is causing their pain but are attracted to conservatives yelling and screaming that The Government is the Problem. This further feeds into the populism of folks like Donald Trump who are yelling and screaming that what is needed to fix things is a businessman who won’t put up with Insider Nonsense. He projects strength and that is what they mean when they constantly whine about how the country is lacking “leadership:” They want an image of strength.</p><p>They are “against political correctness” because they feel their opinions have been stifled, but <em>don’t seem to know what they want to say</em>. As Michelle Goldberg <a href="http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/politics/2016/11/democratic_politics_have_to_be_identity_politics.html">put it</a> after interviewing dozens of Trump supporters at rallies around the country:</p><p><em>Again and again, people told me how much they resented not being able to speak their minds, though none of them wanted to articulate what exactly they were holding in. They said they hated being shamed on social media, though they usually didn’t want to say what they had been shamed for.</em></p><p>Let’s be straightforward about what’s happening here: People aren’t upset they’re being silenced. They resent that their opinions aren’t considered respectable anymore and are too cowardly to express their real views using their real names.</p><p>Let me repeat that: <em>Too cowardly</em>. That’s from people who want to project strength and leadership.</p><p>For many of these people, there is no short term hope for us. They lived in evangelical or Orthodox Jewish communities and believe whatever the Right tells them through their authority figures. They will protest that they are “open-minded” and “independents, not Republicans” but if you’re talking to my Orthodox Jewish friends down in Miami for example, you won’t get anywhere because they’ve been told the Democrats hate the Jews, maybe Obama wasn’t born in the US, etc. It’s more potentially fruitful to discuss religion with some of these folks as opposed to politics as the latter is really a symptom of the former for them.</p><p>But some people aren’t extremely ideological but are looking for strength and see Obama and the Democrats as “weak.” We ought to point out that actually it’s the right-wingers who can’t bring themselves to express their true views, who stay in their little fundamentalist communities teaching their kids nonsense, and can’t deliver on their vague mutterings about how somehow they’ll make everything as great as it used to be because they’re so stuck in the past they can’t deal with the reality of the present. In other words, they’re not just wrong: They’re “haters and losers.” Diversity doesn’t represent the “pussification” of America as some would have it, but the building of a wall of strength, people standing together expressing their rugged individuality, going through hell to achieve happiness against the weak forces of the 20th century who can’t even deal with getting out of their little communities’ comfort zones. We on the other hand are happy to talk with conservatives about their views — hell, I was one for years — and look at statistics and facts.</p><p>This of course requires us to be open to true conversation with the right about everything that’s popular in their circles and to be able to look at all the sources. Some might not like that idea but I think that confronting all views — even bigoted ones — gives tolerance and egalitarianism the upper hand because people getting along is better for the world. That’s not to say that conversation should happen everywhere; people promoting neo-Naziism, to take one example of many, should be shunned and not welcomed into lecture halls. Similarly, people who promote racial resegregation. But we should explore the appeal of this stuff for people on the right and explore the reasons it’s wrong. If we understand what’s wrong with their views and can talk comfortably about their errors while all they can do is mutter something about political correctness but can’t even be bothered to say what’s on their mind, we can take back the narrative of strength and leadership.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d2dc16c7b815" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“They Go Low, We Go High” Didn’t Work: Put Merrick Garland on the Supreme Court]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PeltaRepublic/they-go-low-we-go-high-didnt-work-put-merrick-garland-on-the-supreme-court-e6cd584b3b6?source=rss-6391bfb02960------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e6cd584b3b6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[supreme-court]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Pelta]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 19 Nov 2016 14:30:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-19T14:33:56.631Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>I suspect many very serious people who I usually agree with may not particularly like this essay due to its embrace of a sort of radical legislative tactic that goes against precedent. But I urge them to reconsider their thinking in light of the fact that on this issue, we are forced to consider that Republicans played particularly dirty, and there is a way to ensure they aren’t rewarded for it if we play our cards right.</em></p><p>The language of the Constitution is clear regarding how a Supreme Court justice is supposed to be appointed: The president has the power to appoint a Supreme Court justice. The job of the Senate is to give Advice and Consent on said appointment.</p><p>Merrick Garland was chosen by the president. The Senate chose not to give Advice and Consent but instead to pretend that when the Constitution said “the president” has such powers, it only meant “a president who isn’t in his last year or so of service whose views we don’t share.” In other words, they didn’t do their job because of pure partisan politics. And now they’re going to fill try to put a conservative in there.</p><p>So what should Democrats do? David Dayen of The New Republic <a href="https://newrepublic.com/article/138787/obama-can-put-merrick-garland-supreme-court">notes</a> that Obama has one final card he can play; he can, thru legislative maneuvering, on January 3rd technically fill the Supreme Court vacancy during the Senate recess until December. But then Garland would leave and Trump would get whoever he wants as a replacement. Obama shouldn’t do this. He should leave on a high note of a president who tried bipartisan cooperation, even if he was rebuffed.</p><p>I suggest a different, somewhat more radical approach:</p><p>Happily indicate our willingness to work with Trump — if he’s serious about being a president for all the people — on bipartisan infrastructure legislation, fixing inner cities, maternity leave, and helping rural Americans get jobs. But unless Donald Trump’s nominee is named Merrick Garland, filibuster the hell out of whoever he puts up for the Supreme Court, again and again. Remember when Senator McConnell took what Biden said about SCOTUS nominees <a href="http://www.mediaite.com/online/heres-why-the-biden-rule-is-complete-crap/">out of context</a> and justified Republican obstructionism based on the lie that that was precedent, calling it The Biden Rule? Let’s call this the McConnell-Trump rule. McConnell <a href="http://www.npr.org/2016/11/09/501476919/gop-strategy-paved-way-for-trump-to-nominate-supreme-court-justice">said</a> he considered “it best that the American people decide who” appoints the SCOTUS nominee. But to quote the <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2016/08/02/in-2012-donald-trump-suggested-that-the-result-was-rigged-he-warned-of-the-same-thing-this-week/">wise words</a> of our president-elect in 2012, “the phoney electoral college made a laughing stock out of our nation.” We acknowledge that he will be president and therefore gets to do what a president does, but the majority of the American people as opposed to the electoral college voted for President Obama and against Mr. Trump; therefore, accepting the combined reasoning of McConnell and Trump, we will only accept President Obama’s nominee for the SCOTUS unless the American people decide on a different candidate in 4 years. This might feel dirty to some, but they want to use their obstructionism from President Obama’s days to steal a SCOTUS justice from us. We have a way to stop them and in voting a Republican majority into the legislative and executive branches, the nation has indicated it’s okay with some obstructionism, so now is not the time to play nice. They wanna use the nuclear option and end the filibuster of SCOTUS justices, let ’em; the long term trends are against them and we have nothing left to lose.</p><p>In the event that the Democratic minority in the Senate cannot hold up the GOP’s SCOTUS nominees, there is another possibility: There is no stipulation in the Constitution that there must be 9 justices. In fact, initially there were 6, but the numbers went up and down in the 19th century, eventually settling on 9 with The Judiciary Act of 1869, one for each judicial circuit at the time. Considering the growth of the population, we ought to — when a Democrat is re-elected — return to an even number as the founders intended. And what better number than the traditional number for a quorum as cited in the ancient Jewish legal tome, the Talmud, that the late Justice Scalia so loved to quote — that number being 10 (see Megillah 23b)— which also would happen to give us the justice who should’ve had a hearing? Or if people can’t stomach the idea of returning to an even number of justices, then we should update the court for the current number of regional circuit courts, 11.</p><p>I admit it’s a radical “eye for an eye” proposal. I myself tend to be skeptical of such radical measures. I’m not in favor of court-packing and would be against any proposal to a priori reject Trump filling any other SCOTUS vacancies that might occur during his term. But I don’t think McConnell in cheating the spirit of the constitutional system has left us a better choice and the Dems could do worse than showing they have a spine.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e6cd584b3b6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Art of Conversation: A Tip on Talking with Conservatives]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PeltaRepublic/the-art-of-conversation-a-tip-on-talking-with-conservatives-9ce7784dc499?source=rss-6391bfb02960------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9ce7784dc499</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Pelta]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 18 Nov 2016 07:47:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-18T07:47:40.155Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There’s a lot of talk now about how liberals should be talking with and listening to people with different perspectives than us. As wide and as deep as the chasm between us and conservatives may be and as insane as the conversation may drive us, having the conversation is important; after all, they might not hear us, but the kids might. After my <a href="https://medium.com/@PeltaRepublic/how-democrats-can-make-political-incorrectness-great-again-in-the-age-of-trump-75cda1be0f34#.91mw40ga6">post</a> the other day in which I suggested liberals ought to take on right-wing political correctness by being willing to discuss topics they consider uncomfortable, some people expressed curiosity about how to go about having this discourse with people when the ideological chasm seems so wide. As somebody who went through a born-again religious conservative phase myself, I have engaged in a lot of conversations with conservatives over the years and have taken one particular lesson that I have found useful, if sometimes tough to follow:</p><p><strong>Listen With Empathy But Don’t Believe With Credulity<br></strong>This is a tough balance to strike, but it’s an extremely important rule as far as I’m concerned. If you don’t address the nuances of what a conservative is saying and instead just yell at him, you come across as an overbearing and overzealous extremist. It’s important to hear what he’s saying so you can address it. Don’t conflate him with Sean Hannity or Rush Limbaugh; sure, his beliefs are probably extremely similar to guys like that, but it’s important to realize he has tempered conservatism to a temperature he finds comfortable and will often believe himself to be a little more nuanced than guys like that. Hell, he might be right about some things and you wrong; you can learn from people you disagree with. That being said, I have come across a fair share of disingenuous folks in recent years, so it’s important to be aware that stories told might not be entirely true and folks might play coy with answering your questions about their perspective. Note that while you appreciate their perspective and the perspective of people who have religious miracle stories, for you to accept anything as a real argument, you need evidence. Not a youtube video. Data, hard evidence, facts. If we can’t agree on the facts, we can’t agree on anything.</p><p>Skeptical that your friends would be disingenuous to your face? I submit that you’re being naive. There’s a reason that the polls all missed Trump winning Wisconsin and it’s called “people lying.” I have had three right-wing friends tell me they “aren’t really interested in politics,” I suspect because that makes them sound like they can be objective since they have no agenda, but if you look on their facebook walls, they have posted about politics on quite a regular basis. People will say they’re not on the right while doing nothing but complaining about and attacking the left and then turn around and say they see “nothing to fear” from Trump. People will tell you not to talk about politics, but welcome the conversation when their right wing friends bring it up.</p><p>Conversation is important. Listening and trying to keep things focused on evidence and facts as opposed to making it personal allows us to have a respectful conversation. But also disingenuousness is currently a feature of our politics and don’t be fooled by folksy friendly demeanors or calm tones into being lulled into a false sense of security; always keep the conversation focused on the issues and proving your point about the arguments as opposed to the person (others watching can draw out the correct labels for the person based on said arguments), and keep your skeptical guard up.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9ce7784dc499" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Before Trump Grabbed ’Em, Conservatives Denied ’Em the Right to Vote: A 19th Century Satire of…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PeltaRepublic/before-trump-grabbed-em-conservatives-denied-em-the-right-to-vote-a-19th-century-satire-of-the-5f5bc2592c7c?source=rss-6391bfb02960------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5f5bc2592c7c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conservatism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Pelta]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Nov 2016 05:09:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-17T05:10:44.788Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Before Trump Grabbed ’Em, Conservatives Denied ’Em the Right to Vote: A 19th Century Satire of Anti-Suffragism</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/220/1*yeDUMEdd3zxaLtGhmOfftg.jpeg" /><figcaption>David Ross Locke (1833–1888)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>The Republican Party is often called “The Party of Lincoln” after its most eminent historical member. Citizens today argue over whether or not the party has fundamentally changed since its founding by abolitionists in 1854. Some Republicans say that their party was always a fundamentally conservative party, and in their narrative, they follow this tradition. Others disagree and maintain that the Republican Party has evolved into a conservative party today, but in the 19th century promoted different values.</p><p>Reading the works of <strong>David Ross Locke (1833–1888)</strong> sheds some light on the matter. Locke was editor and later publisher of the <em>Toledo Blade</em> newspaper. He is most famous for inventing and writing from the perspective of the satirical character Petroleum V. Nasby, a lazy and semi-literate Democrat who championed the cause of the Confederacy; Locke’s utilizing a fictional absurdist alter-ego to lampoon those on the other side has led to him being called the “<a href="http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/06/11/the-stephen-colbert-of-the-civil-war-2/">Stephen Colbert of the Civil War</a>.” Lincoln was a big fan of Locke’s work, and would read it for comic relief when he struggled with his emotions during the war; indeed, at his last dinner before his fated trip to Ford’s Theatre, Lincoln <a href="http://books.google.com/books?id=HGEiAQAAIAAJ&amp;pg=PA954&amp;dq=lincoln+nasby+dinner&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ei=0YuvUMa_GYaH0QGmxYGgDw&amp;ved=0CDEQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&amp;q=lincoln%20nasby%20dinner&amp;f=false">reportedly</a> read aloud four chapters of one of Nasby’s screeds for entertainment.</p><p>Locke remained a steadfast Republican throughout his life. Even when his colleague Thomas Nast, the cartoonist who had without a doubt been the most famous satirist of the Civil War, would join a group of reformist Republicans (called <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mugwump">mugwumps</a>) disenchanted with the 1884 Republican presidential candidate James Blaine’s reputation for corruption in supporting the Democrat Grover Cleveland in 1884, Locke’s paper strongly <a href="http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1350&amp;dat=19611130&amp;id=k55OAAAAIBAJ&amp;sjid=EwEEAAAAIBAJ&amp;pg=7479,4633713">endorsed</a> the former.</p><p>After the Civil War, Locke went on the lecture circuit delivering speeches; the one which follows mostly adopts a satirical tone in order to ridicule conservatives for their traditional views on women. Locke switches from satire to seriousness in order make his point explicitly at the end. He there interestingly addresses well-off women at the time who were satisfied with their status and did not desire the ballot, having accepted the billiard room talk of the time (if you will) which in his view consigned them to relatively pleasant lives with jewelry and beautiful surroundings, but little ability to think critically. It was a popular speech and would be reviewed by Mark Twain himself in the <em>Buffalo Express </em>in 1870.</p><p>For those using this text in the classroom, I would ask the students to identify Locke’s critiques of conservatism and write an essay about whether or not his critiques of their thinking processes could be applied today to modern conservatives, even if the position itself is mostly (<a href="http://www.salon.com/2014/06/12/5_conservatives_who_are_still_mad_women_have_the_right_to_vote_partner/">albeit not entirely</a>) rejected by them as obsolete today. If so, explain how; if not, explain how conservatives today fundamentally differ in their worldview from the conservatives in Locke’s day.</p><p><strong>The Struggles of a Conservative with the Woman Question (1868)</strong></p><p>by David Ross Locke</p><p>I AM by nature a conservative, for I was born one. In my infancy I was rocked in an old-fashioned cradle, for my parents would have nothing whatever to do with new-fashioned gumcracks on springs. Whatever they used must be that which had the sanction of years. When my infantile stomach was agonized, I was soothed with <a href="http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/45/6/1011.abstract">Godfrey’s Cordial</a>. At the beginning, <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paregoric">paregoric</a> was the favorite <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anodyne">anodyne</a>; but my mother one day happening to discover in a household book that her grandmother used Godfrey’s Cordial, that was immediately substituted as being undoubtedly the best. Godfrey’s Cordial was counted the most efficacious, because the bottles which contained it were quaint and old-fashioned, and the labels were printed in the characters and upon the paper used a century ago. It was good enough for the stomachs of my ancestors, and why not for mine? It has ever since been a rule in our family that it is better for babies to die with Godfrey’s Cordial than to live with any other remedy. One brother of mine, whose head differed in shape from the others of the family, in being largest in front of the ears, suggested that the world had progressed since Godfrey’s day, and that possibly science had produced a better combination. He was ordered to leave the house instantly. As a rebuke to him, my infant sister was given a double dose of Godfrey, and my father prayed earnestly against innovators and presumptuous men, and erased his name from the family Bible. The little sister died before morning; my brother went away and invented an improvement in steam engines, thus fiendishly inflicting a stab at the horse interest. But I cannot dwell upon family matters. I have much to say, and life is short and uncertain. I know that’s so, for a life insurance man told me so yesterday.</p><p>I grew up with reverence for everything old. I am not the man who caught hold of the coat-tail of Progress, and yelled, “Whoa!” I do not believe there ever was such a man. Progress does not wear a coat; he rushes by in his shirt sleeves; and, besides, your true Conservative, of whom I am which, never gets awake in time to see Progress whistle by.</p><p>I never think, for there’s no necessity in thinking. All the trouble the world has ever seen has proceeded from the pestiferous thinkers. I am content that men who departed this life some centuries ago, and were decently buried, and had their obituaries published in the newspapers, and their tombstones erected, with as many virtues cut upon them as their administrators had money to pay for — I am content that these men, deceased as they are, should do my thinking for me. I study these men, and take their action as safe precedent to follow. With such men as I am, the thing that has been done is the right thing to do; and the thing that has never been done, must therefore never be done.</p><p>We have a poor opinion of ourselves. We, of the United States, believe that all the wisdom of the country died with the last member of the Continental Congress, and that our only hope is in following closely in the footsteps of the members of that body. Therefore we <a href="http://www.law.uga.edu/dwilkes_more/his29_racism.html">opposed</a> the abolition of slavery, because they left us slavery. We <a href="http://projects.vassar.edu/1896/prohibition.html">opposed</a> all attempts to suppress intemperance, because intemperance was; and such of us as professed Christianity, <a href="http://www.gameo.org/encyclopedia/contents/S8437ME.html">opposed</a> Sunday schools, because Paul was not a superintendent of one, and we could nowhere find it recorded that Luke had a Bible, or Martha an infant class.</p><p>Irreverent men, it is true, puzzle our Christian Conservatives, by insisting that if all <em>old</em> things are <em>good</em> things, then we all must rush into murder, that cheerful vice being almost contemporary with creation.</p><p>But we do not allow that to shake us. Conservatives are not, as a rule, logicians. They have an anchor in precedent, which holds them fast, while logic is a ship that sails out into unexplored seas. By doing only that which has been done, we hold fast to our ancestors; and if they were not respectable people, who were?</p><p>I adore woman. I recognize the importance of the sex, and lay at its feet my humble tribute. But for woman, where would we have been? Who in our infancy washed our faces, fed us soothing syrup, and taught us <a href="http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Against_Idleness_and_Mischief">“How doth the little busy bee?”</a> Woman! To whom did we give red apples in our boyhood? <em>for whom</em> did we part our hair behind, and wear №7 boots when №10’s would have been much more comfortable? and WITH WHOM did we sit up nights, in the hair-oil period of our existence? And finally, whom did we marry? But for woman what would the novelists have done? What would have become of <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sylvanus_Cobb,_Jr.">Sylvanus Cobb, Jr.</a>, if he had had no women to make heroines of? And without Sylvanus Cobb, <a href="https://sites.google.com/site/rameltontidytowns1/robert-bonner">Bonner</a> could not have made the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Ledger">Ledger</a> a success; <a href="http://www.mountvernon.org/educational-resources/encyclopedia/edward-everett">Everett</a> would be remembered not as the man who wrote for the Ledger, but merely as an orator and statesman; <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_Ward_Beecher">Beecher</a> never would have written <a href="http://books.google.com/books/about/Norwood_or_Village_life_in_New_England.html?id=pqATAAAAIAAJ">Norwood</a>, and <a href="http://www.spho-nh.net/10199.html">Dexter</a> might to-day have been chafing under the collar in a dray! But for woman, <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Washington">George Washington</a> would not have been the father of his country, the Sunday school teachers would have been short the affecting story of the little hatchet and the cherry tree, and half the babies in the country would have been named after some one else. Possibly they might have all been smiths. But for woman <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Johnson">Andrew Johnson</a> never would have been, and future generations would have lost the most awful example of depravity the world has ever seen. I adore woman, but I want her to keep her place. I don’t want woman to be the coming man!</p><p>In considering this woman question, I occupy the Conservative standpoint. I find that from the most gray-headed times one half of the human race have lived and moved by the grace and favor of the other half. From the beginning woman has occupied a dependent position, and has been only what man has made her. The Turks, logical fellows, denied her a soul, and <a href="http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/islam/history/slavery_1.shtml#section_7">made of her an object of barter and sale</a>; the American Indians made of her a <a href="http://digitalcommons.calpoly.edu/comssp/11/">beast of burden</a>. In America, since we extended the area of civilization by butchering the Indians, we have copied both. In the higher walks of life she is a toy to be played with, and is bought and sold; in the lower strata, she bears the burdens and does the drudgery of servants, without the ameliorating conditions that make other servitude tolerable and possible to be borne. But I am sure that her <a href="http://womeninushistory.tripod.com/">present condition</a> is her proper condition, for it always has been so.</p><p>Adam subjugated Eve at the beginning, and following precedent Cain subjugated his wife. Mrs. Cain, not being an original thinker, imitated her mother-in-law, who probably lived with them, and made it warm for her. I reject with scorn the idea advanced by a schoolmistress, that Eve was an inferior woman, and therefore submitted; and that Eve’s being an inferior woman was no reason for classing all her daughters with her. “Had I been Eve,” she remarked, “I would have made a different precedent!” and I rather think she would.</p><p>The first record we have of man and woman is in the first chapter of Genesis. “So God created man in his own image. And he made man of the dust of the earth.” In the second chapter, we have a record of the making of woman by taking a rib from man. Man, it will be observed, was created first, showing conclusively that he was intended to take precedence of woman. This woman, to whom I referred to a moment since, denied the correctness of the conclusion. Man was made first, woman afterwards, — isn’t it reasonable to suppose that the last creation was the best? “If there is anything in being first,” she continued, “man must acknowledge the supremacy of the goose, for the fowl is first mentioned.” And she argued further: “Man was made of the <em>dust</em> of the earth, the lowest form of matter; woman was made of man, the highest and most perfect form. It is clear that women must be the better, for she was made of better material!” But, of course, I look upon this as mere sophistry.</p><p>I attempted to trace the relative condition of the sexes from the creation down to the fall of man, but the Bible is silent upon the subject, and the files of the newspapers of the period were doubtless all destroyed in the flood. I have not been able to find that any have been preserved in the public libraries of the country. But it is to be presumed that they lived upon precisely the terms that they do now. I shall assume that Eve was merely the domestic servant of Adam — that she rose in the morning, careful not to disturb his slumbers — that she cooked his breakfast, called him affectionately when it was quite ready, waiting upon him at table, arranged his shaving implements ready to his hand, saw him properly dressed — after which she washed the dishes, and amused herself darning his torn fig leaves till the time arrived to prepare dinner, and so on till nightfall, after which time she improved her mind, and, before master Cain was born, slept. She did not even keep a kitchen girl; at least I find no record of anything of the kind. Probably at that time the emigration from Ireland was setting in other directions, and help was hard to get. That she was a good wife and a contented one I do not doubt. I find no record in the Scriptures of her throwing tea-pots, or chairs, or brooms, or anything of the sort at Adam’s head, nor is it put down that at any time she intimated a desire for a divorce, which proves conclusively that the Garden of Eden was not located in the State of <a href="http://www.connerprairie.org/learn-and-do/indiana-history/america-1800-1860/women-and-the-law-in-early-19th-century.aspx">Indiana</a>. But I judge that Adam was a good, kind husband. He did not go to his club at night for, as near as I can learn, he had no club. His son Cain had one, however, as his other son, Abel, discovered.</p><p>I am certain that he did not insist on smoking cigars in the back parlor, making the curtains smell. I do not know that these things are so; but as mankind does to day what mankind did centuries ago, it is reasonable to assume, when we don’t know anything about it, that what is done to-day was done centuries ago. The bulk of mankind have learned nothing since Adam’s time. Eve’s duties were not as trying as those piled upon her daughters. As compared with the fashionable women of to-day, her lot was less perplexing. Society was not so exacting in her time. She had no calls to make, or parties to give and attend. Her toilet was much simpler, and did not require the entire resources of her intellect. If her situation is compared with that of the wives of poorer men, it will be found to be better. They had no meat to dress, four to knead, or bread to bake. The trees bore fruit, which were to be had for the picking; and as they were strict vegetarians, it sufficed. I have wished that her taste in fruit had been more easily satisfied, for her unfortunate craving after one particular variety brought me into trouble. But I have forgiven her. I shall never reproach her for this. She is dead, alas! and let her one fault lie dead in the grave with her. It is well that Eve died when she did. It would have broken her heart to see how the most of her family turned out.</p><p>I insist, however, that what labor of a domestic nature was done, she did. She picked the fruit, pared it and stewed it, like a dutiful wife. She was no strong-minded female, and never got out of her legitimate sphere. I insist, however, that what labor of a domestic nature was done, she did. She picked the fruit, pared it and stewed it, like a dutiful wife. She was no strong-minded female, and never got out of her legitimate sphere. I have searched the book of Genesis faithfully, and I defy any one to find it recorded therein that Eve ever made a public speech, or expressed any desire to preach, practice law or medicine, or sit in the legislature of her native State. What a crushing, withering, scathing, blasting rebuke to the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emily_Dickinson">Dickinsons</a>, <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabeth_Cady_Stanton">Stantons</a>, <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabeth_Blackwell">Blackwells</a> and <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Susan_B._Anthony">Anthonys</a> of this degenerate day.</p><p>I find in the Bible many arguments against the equality of woman with man in point of intellectual power. The serpent tempted Eve, not Adam. Why did he select Eve? Ah, why, indeed! Whatever else may be said of Satan, no one will, I think, question his ability! I do not stand here as his champion or even apologist; in fact, I am willing to admit that in many instances his behavior has been ungentlemanly, but no one will deny that he is a most consummate judge of character, and that he has never failed to select for his work the most fitting instruments. In this, as in all other respects, save ability, Johnson was very like him. When America was to be betrayed the first time, Satan selected <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benedict_Arnold">Arnold</a>; when the second betrayal of America was determined upon, he knew where <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jefferson_Davis">Jefferson Davis</a>, <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Buchanan">Buchanan</a>, and <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_B._Floyd">Floyd</a> lived; and when he had other dirty work to do, with unfailing instinct, he clapped his claw on the shoulders of Chief Justice <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salmon_P._Chase">Chase</a>, as he had before drafted <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_H._Seward">Seward</a> and <a href="http://www.wisconsinhistory.org/wmh/archives/search.aspx?area=browse&amp;volume=18&amp;articleID=28653">Doolittle</a>. When there is a fearful piece of jobbery to get through Congress or the New York legislature, he never fails to select precisely the right persons for the villainy. Possibly he is not entitled to credit for discrimination in these last-mentioned bodies, for he could not very well go wrong. He could find instruments in either, with both hands tied and blindfolded. But this is a digression. Why did Satan select Eve? Because he knew that Eve the woman, was weaker than Adam the man, and therefore best for his purpose. This reckless female insisted that Satan approached Eve first, because he knew that woman was not afraid of the devil; but I reject this explanation as irrelevant.</p><p>At this point, however, we must stop. Should we go on, we would find that Eve, the weak woman, tempted Adam, the strong man, with distinguished success, which would leave us in this predicament: Satan, stronger than Eve, tempted her to indulge in fruit. Eve’s weakness was demonstrated by her falling victim to temptation. Eve tempted Adam; Adam yielded to Eve; therefore, if Eve was weak in yielding to Satan, how much weaker was Adam in yielding to Eve? If Satan had been considerate of the feelings of the conservatives, his best friends, by the way, in all ages, he would have tempted Adam first, and caused Adam to tempt Eve. This would have afforded us the edifying spectacle of the strong man leading the weak woman, which would be in accordance with our idea of the eternal fitness of things. But now that I look at it again, this wouldn’t do; for it is necessary to our argument that the woman should be tempted first, to prove that she was the weaker of the two. I shall dismiss Adam and Eve with the remark, that notwithstanding the respect that one ought always to feel for his ancestors, those whose blood is the same as that running in his veins, I cannot but say that Adam’s conduct in this transaction was weak. If Adam’s spirit is listening to me to-night, I can’t help it. I presume he will feel badly to hear me say it, but truth is truth. Instead of saying boldly, “I ate!” he attempted to clear his skirts by skulking behind those of his wife’s. “The woman thou gavest me tempted me and I did eat,” he said, which was paltry. Had Adam been stronger minded he would have refused the tempting bite, and then only woman would have been amenable to the death penalty that followed. This would have killed the legal profession in Chicago, for what man who was to live forever would get a divorce from his wife who could live but eighty or ninety years at best?</p><p>As a conservative, I must say that woman is the inferior of man. This fact is recognized in all civilized countries and in most heathen nations. The Hindoos, it is true, in one of their practices, acknowledge a superiority of woman. In <a href="http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Hindostan">Hindostan</a>, when a man dies, his widow is immediately <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sati_(practice)">burned</a>, that she may follow him, — an acknowledgment that woman is as necessary to him in the next world as in this. As men are never burned when their wives die, it may be taken as admitting that women are abundantly able to get along alone; or, perchance, it may be because men in that country, as in this, can get new wives easier than women can get new husbands.</p><p>The inferiority of the sex is easy of demonstration. It has been said that the mother forms the character of the man so long, that the propo- sition has become axiomatic. If this be true, we can crush those who prate of the equality of women, by holding up to the gaze of the world the inferior men she has formed. Look at the Congress of the United States. Look at <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garrett_Davis">Garret Davis</a>. By their works ye shall know them. It won’t do to cite me to the mothers of the good and great men whose names adorn American history. The number is too small. There’s George Washington, <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wendell_Phillips">Wendell Phillips</a>, <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abraham_Lincoln">Abraham Lincoln</a>, and one other, whose name all the tortures of the Inquisition could not make me reveal. Modesty forbids me.</p><p>Those who clamor for the extension of the sphere of woman, point to the names of women illustrious in history, sacred and profane. I find, to my discomfiture, that some of the sex really excelled the sterner. There was Mrs. Jezebel Ahab, for instance. Ahab wanted the vineyard of Kaboth, which Naboth refused to sell, owing to a prejudice he had against disposing of real estate which he had inherited. Ahab, who was not an ornament to his sex, went home sick and took to his bed like a girl, and turned away his face, and would eat no bread. Mrs. Ahab was made of sterner stuff. ”Arise,” said Mrs. A.; “be merry. I will give thee the vineyard of Naboth the Jezreelite.” And she did it. She trapped him as neatly as David did Uriah. She suborned two sons of Belial (by the way Belial has had a large family, and the stock has not run out yet) to bear false witness against him, saying that he had blasphemed God and the king, and they took him out and stoned him. Ahab got the vineyard. It is true this lady came to a miserable end, but she accomplished what she desired.</p><p>Miss <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pocahontas">Pocahontas</a> has been held up as a sample of female strength of mind. I don’t deny that she displayed some decision of character, but it was fearfully unwomanly. When her <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chief_Powhatan">father</a> raised his club over the head of the astonished <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Smith_(explorer)">Smith</a>, instead of rushing in so recklessly, she should have said, “Please pa, don’t.” Her recklessness was immense. Suppose Pocahontas had been unable to stay the blow, where would our Miss have been then? She never would have married <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Rolfe">Rolfe</a>; and what would the first families of Virginia have done for somebody to descend from? When we remember that all the people of that proud State claim this woman as their mother, we shudder, or ought to, when we contemplate the possible consequences of her rashness.</p><p>Delilah, whose other name is not recorded, overcame Samson, the first and most successful conundrum maker of his age, and Jael, it will be remembered, silenced Sisera forever. <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joan_of_Arc">Joan of Arc</a> conquered the English after the French leaders failed, and <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabeth_I_of_England">Elizabeth of England</a> was the greatest of English rulers. I acknowledge all this, but then these women had opportunities beyond those of women in general. They had as many opportunities as the men of their respective periods had, and consequently, if they were mentally as great as men, — no, that isn’t what I mean to say, — if the men of the period were no greater, mentally, than they — no — if the circumstances which surrounded them gave them opportunities, which being mentally as great as men — I have this thing mixed up somehow, and it don’t result as it ought to — but this is true; Delilah, Elizabeth, Joan of Arc — all and singular, unsexed themselves, and did things unbecoming ladies of refinement and cultivation. Joan’s place was spinning flax in her father’s hut and not at the head of armies. Had she followed the natural mode of feminine life, she would not have been burned at the stake, and the English would not have been interrupted in their work of reducing France to the condition of an English province. Had I lived in France, I should have said, “Down with her! Let us perish under a man rather than be saved by a woman!” Joan should have been ashamed of herself — I blush for her. Had Elizabeth been content to entrust her kingdom to the hands of her cabinet, she would have left it in the happy condition of the United States at the close of Buchanan’s administration, but she would have been true to our idea of the womanly life.</p><p>There is, in the feminine character, a decisive promptness which we must admire. Eve ate the apple without a moment’s hesitation, and the characteristic is more beautifully illustrated in the touching and well reported account of the courtship and marriage of Rebekah with Isaac. Abraham’s servant was sent, it will be remembered, by such of you as have read the Bible, to negotiate for a wife for young Isaac among his kindred, as he had as intense a prejudice against the Canaanites as have the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_Party_(United_States)">Democracy</a> of the present day. This servant, whom we will call Smith, as his name, unfortunately, has not been preserved, and Laban, the brother of Rebekah, had almost arranged the matter. The servant desired to return with the young lady at once, but the mother and brother desired her to remain some days, contrary to modern practice, in that the parents now desire the young lady to get settled in her own house and off their hands as soon as possible. The servant insisted, whereupon the mother remarked, “We will call the damsel and inquire at her mouth.” They called Rebekah and asked, “Wilt thou go with this man?”</p><p>It is related of a damsel in Pike county, Missouri, who was being wedded to the man whose choice she was, when the minister officiating asked the usual question, “Wilt thou have this man to be thy wedded husband?” that, dropping her long eyelashes, she promptly answered, “You bet!” Even so with Rebekah. She neither fainted, simpered, or blushed. She did not say that she hadn’t a thing fit to put on — that her clothes weren’t home from the dressmaker’s. No! Using the Hebrew equivalent for “you bet!” — for Rebekah was a smart girl, and young as she was, had learned to speak Hebrew — when the question was put to her, “Wilt thou go with this man?” she answered, “I will,” — and she went. I don’t know that this proves anything, unless it be that women of that day took as great risks for husbands as they do now. Miss Rebekah had scarcely been introduced to her future husband. I will say, however, that she was a mistress of duplicity. To get the blessing of her husband for her pet son Jacob, she put false hair upon him to deceive the old gentleman, and did it. From that day to this, women in every place but this, have deceived men, young as well as old, with false hair.</p><p>The feminine habit of thought is not such as to entitle them to privileges beyond those they now enjoy. No woman was ever a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drayman">drayman</a>; no woman ever carried a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brick_hod">hod</a>; no woman ever drove horses on the canals of the country; and what is more to the point, no woman ever shoveled a single wheel-barrow of earth on the public works. I triumphantly ask, Did any woman assist in preparing the road bed of the Pacific Railway? did any woman drive a spike in that magnificent structure? No woman is employed in the forging department of any shop in which is made the locomotives that climb the Sierra Nevada, whose head-lights beam on the valleys of the Pacific coast — the suns of our commercial system.</p><p>Just as I had this arranged in my mind, this disturbing female, of whom I have spoken once or twice, asked me whether carrying hods, driving horses on canals, or shoveling dirt on railways, had been, in the past, considered the best training for intelligent participation in political privileges? She remarked, that, judging from the character of most of the legislation of which she had knowledge, these had been the schools in which Legislators had been trained, but she hardly believed that I would acknowledge it. “Make these the qualifications,” said she, “and where would you be, my friend, who have neither driven a spike, driven a horse, or shoveled dirt? It would cut out all of my class (she was a teacher) — indeed I know of but two women in America who would be admitted. The two women I refer to fought a prize fight in Connecticut recently, observing all the rules of the English ring, and they displayed as much gameness as was ever shown by that muscular lawmaker, the Hon. <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Morrissey">John Morrissey</a>. These women ought to vote, and if, in the good time coming, women distribute honors as men have done, they may go to Congress.</p><p>I answered, that these classes had always voted, and therefore it was right that they should always vote.</p><p>“Certainly they have,” returned she, “and as I have heard them addressed a score of times as the embodied virtue, honesty, and intelligence of the country, I have come to the conclusion that there must be something in the labor they do which fits them peculiarly for the duties of law-making.”</p><p>My friend is learned. She has a tolerable knowledge of Greek, is an excellent Latin scholar, and as she has read the Constitution of the United States, she excels in political lore the great majority of our representatives in Congress. But nevertheless I protest against her voting for several reasons.</p><p>1. She cannot sing bass! Her voice, as <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horace_Bushnell">Dr. Bushnell</a> justly observes in his blessed <a href="http://archive.org/details/womenssuffragere00bushrich">book</a>, is pitched higher than the male voice, which indicates feminine weakness of mind.</p><p>2. Her form is graceful rather than strong.</p><p>3. She delights in <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hatmaking">millinery</a> goods.</p><p>4. She can’t grow whiskers.</p><p>In all of these points nature has made a distinction between the sexes which cannot be overlooked.</p><p>To all of these she plead guilty. She confessed that she had not the strength necessary to the splitting of rails; she confessed that she could neither grow a beard or sing bass. She wished she could grow a beard, as she knew so many men whose only title to intellect was their whiskers. But she said she took courage when she observed that the same disparity was noticeable in men. Within the range of her acquaintance she knew men who had struggled with mustaches with a perseverance worthy of a better cause, and whose existence had been blighted by the consciousness that they could not. Life was to them, in consequence, a failure. Others she knew who had no more strength than a girl, and others whose voices were pitched in childish treble. If beards, heavy voices, and physical strength were the qualifications for the ballot, she would at once betake herself to razors, hair invigorators, and gymnasiums. She went on thus: —</p><p>“In many respects,” she said, “the sexes are alike. Both are encumbered with stomachs and heads, and both have bodies to clothe. So far as physical existence is concerned they are very like. Both are affected by laws made and enacted, and both are popularly supposed to have minds capable of weighing the effect of the laws. How, thrust into the world as I am, with a stomach to fill and limbs to clothe, with both hands tied, am I to live, to say nothing of fulfilling any other end?”</p><p>“Woman,” I replied, “is man’s angel.”</p><p>“Stuff and nonsense,” was her impolite reply. “I am no angel. I am a woman. Angels, according to our idea of angels, have no use for clothing. Either their wings are enough to cover their bodies, or they are so constituted as not to be affected by heat or cold. Neither do they require food. I cannot imagine a feminine angel with <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoop_skirt">hoop skirts</a>, <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grecian_bend">Grecian bend</a>, <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaiters">gaiters</a> and <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bonnet_(headgear)">bonnet</a>; or a masculine angel in tight pantaloons, with a cane and silk hat. Angels do not cook dinners, but women do. Why do you say angels to us? It creates angel tastes, without the possibility of their ever satisfying those tastes. The bird was made to soar in the upper air, and was therefore provided with hollow bones, wings, &amp;c. Imagine an elephant or a rhinoceros possessed with a longing to soar into the infinite ethereal. Could an elephant, with his physical structure, be possessed with such a longing, the elephant would be miserable, because he could not. He would be as miserable as <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Fisk_(financier)">James Fisk, Jr.*,</a> is with an ungobbled railroad; as Bonner would be if Dexter were the property of another man; and as Salmon P. Chase** is <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_presidential_election,_1868">with the Presidency before him</a>. It would be well enough to make angels of us, if you could keep us in a semi-angelic state; but the few thus kept only make the misery of those not so fortunate the more intense. No; treat us rather as human beings, with all the appetites, wants, and necessities of human beings, for we are forced to provide for those wants, necessities, and appetites.</p><p>I acknowledge the correctness of her position. They must live; not that they are of very much account in and of themselves, but that the nobler sex may be perpetuated to bless and adorn the earth. Without woman it would take less than a century to wind up man, and then what would the world do? This difficulty is obviated by marriage. All that we have to do is marry each man to one woman, and demand of each man that he care for and cherish one woman, and the difficulty is got along with. And got along with too, leaving things as we desire them, namely, with the woman dependent upon the man. We proceed upon the proposition that there are just as many men as there are women in the world; that all men will do their duty in this particular, and at the right time; that every Jack will get precisely the right Jill, and that every Jill will be not only willing, but anxious, to take the Jack the Lord sends her, asking no questions.</p><p>If there be one woman more than there are men, it’s bad for that woman. I don’t know what she can do, unless she makes shirts for the odd man, at twelve and a half cents each, and lives gorgeously on the proceeds of her toil. If one man concludes that he won’t marry at all, it’s bad for another woman, unless some man’s wife dies and he marries again. That might equalize it, but for two reasons: It compels the woman to wait for a husband till she possibly concludes it isn’t worth while; and furthermore, husbands die as fast as wives, which brings a new element into the field — widows; and pray what chance has an inexperienced man against a widow determined upon a second husband?</p><p>I admit, that if there were as many men as women, and if they should all marry, and the matter all properly fixed up at the start, that our present system is still bad for some of them. She, whose husband gets to invent flying machines, or running for office, or any of those foolish or discreditable employments, would be in a bad situation. Or, when the husband neglects his duty, and refuses to care for his wife at all; or, to state a case which no one ever witnessed, suppose one not only refuses to care for his wife, but refuses to care for himself! Or, suppose he contracts the injudicious habit of returning to his home at night in a state of inebriation, and of breaking chairs, and crockery, and his wife’s head, and other trifles — in such a case I must admit that her position would be, to say the least, unpleasant, particularly as she couldn’t help herself. She can’t very well take care of herself; for to make woman purely a domestic creature, to ornament our homes, we have never permitted them to think for themselves, act for themselves, or do for themselves. We insist upon her being a tender ivy clinging to the rugged oak — if the oak she clings to happens to be bass-wood, and rotten at that, it’s not our fault. In these cases it’s her duty to keep on clinging, and to finally go down with it in pious resignation. The fault is in the system, and as those who made the system are dead, and as six thousand brief summers have passed over their tombs, it would be sacrilege in us to disturb it.</p><p>Let each woman marry, and marry as soon as possible. Then she is provided for. Then the ivy has her oak. Then if her husband is a good man, a kind man, an honest man, a sober man, a <a href="http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/liberal">liberal</a> man, an industrious man, a managing man, and if he has a good business and drives it, and meets with no misfortunes, and never yields to temptations, why, then, the maid promoted to be his wife, will be tolerably certain to, at least, have all that she can eat, and all that she can wear, as long as he continues so.</p><p>This disturbing woman, of whom I have spoken once or twice, remarked that she did not care for those who were married happily, but she wanted something done for those who were not married at all, and those who were married unfortunately. She liked the ivy and oak-tree idea, but she wanted the ivy — woman — to have a stiffening of intelligence and opportunity, that she might stand alone in case the oak was not competent to sustain it. She demanded, in short, employment at anything she was capable of doing, and pay precisely the same that men receive for the same labor, provided she does it as well.</p><p>This is a clear flying in the face of Providence. It is utterly impossible that any woman can do any work as well as men. Nature has decreed it otherwise. Nature did not give them the strength. Ask the clerks at Washington, whose muscular frames, whose hardened sinews, are employed at from twelve hundred to three thousand dollars per annum, in the arduous and exhausting labor of writing in books, and counting money, and cutting out extracts from newspapers, and indorsing papers and filling them, what they think of that? Ask the brawny young men whose manly forms are wasted away in the wearing occupation of measuring tape and exhibiting silks, what they think of it? Are women, frail as they are, to fill positions in the government offices? I asked her sternly, “Are you willing to go to war? Did you shoulder a musket in the late unpleasantness?”</p><p>This did not settle her. She merely asked me if <em>I</em> carried a musket in the late war. Certainly I did not. I had too much presence of mind to volunteer. Nor did the majority of those holding official position. Like Job’s charger, they snuffed the battle afar off — some hundreds of miles — and slew the haughty <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southron">Southron</a> on the stump, or by <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enrollment_Act#Substitution">substitute</a>. But there is this difference: we could have gone, while women could not. And it is better that it is so. In the event of another bloody war, — one so desperate as to require all the patriotism of the country to show itself, — I do not want my wife to go to the tented field, even though she have the requisite physical strength. No, indeed! I want her to stay at home — with me!</p><p>In the matter of wages, I do not see how it is to be helped. The woman who teaches a school, receives, if she has thoroughly mastered the requirements of the position, say six hundred dollars per year, while a man occupying the same position, filling it with equal ability, receives twice that amount and possibly three times. But what is this to me? As a man of business, my duty to myself is to get my children educated at the least possible expense. As there are but very few things women are permitted to do, and as for every vacant place there are a hundred women eager for it, as a matter of course, their pay is brought down to a very fine point. As I said some minutes ago, if the men born into the world would marry at twenty-one, each a maiden of eighteen, and take care of her properly, and never get drunk, or sick, or anything of that inconvenient sort, and both would be taken at precisely the same time with consumption, yellow fever, cholera, or any one of those cheerful ailments, and employ the same physician, that they might go out of the world at the same moment, and become angels with wings and long white robes, it would be well enough. The men would then take care of the women, except those who marry milliners, in which case the women take care of the men, which amounts to the same thing, as the one dependent upon somebody else is taken care of. But it don’t so happen. Men do not marry as they ought at twenty-one; they put it off to twenty-five, thirty, or forty, and many of them are wicked enough not to marry at all; and of those who do marry there will always be a certain per cent. who will be dissipated or worthless. What then? I can’t deny that there will be women left out in the cold. There are those who don’t marry, and those who cannot. Possibly the number thus situated would be lessened if we permitted women to rush in and seize men, and marry them, <a href="http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/nolens_volens"><em>nolens volens</em></a>, but the superior animal will not brook that familiarity. He must do the wooing — he must ask the woman in his lordly way. Compelled to wait to be asked, and forced to marry that they may have the wherewithal to eat and be clothed, very many of them take fearful chances. They dare not, as a rule, refuse to marry. Man must, as the superior being, have the choice of occupations, and it is a singular fact that, superior as he is by virtue of his strength, he rushes invariably to the occupations that least require strength, and which woman might fill to advantage. They monopolize all the occupations– the married man has his family to take care of — the single man has his back hair to support; what is to become of these unfortunate single women — maids and widows? Live they must. They have all the necessities of life to supply, and nothing to supply them with. What shall they do? Why, work of course. But say they, “We are willing to work, but we must have wages.” Granted. But how shall we get at the wages? What shall be the standard? I must get my work done as cheaply as possible. Now if three women — a widow, we will say, with five children to support; a girl who has to work or do worse; and a wife with an invalid husband to feed, clothe, and find medicine for — if these three come to my door, clamoring for the love of God for something to do, what shall I, as a prudent man, do in the matter? There are immutable laws governing all these things — the law of supply and demand. Christ, whose mission was with the poor, made other laws but Christ is not allowed to have anything to do with business. Selfishness is older than Christ and we Conservatives stick close to the oldest. What do I do? Why, as a man of business, I naturally ascertain which of the three is burdened with the most crushing responsibilities and necessities. I ascertain to a mouthful the amount of food necessary to keep each, and then the one who will do my work for the price nearest starvation rates gets it to do. If the poor girl prefers the pittance I offer her to a life of shame, she gets it. If the wife is willing to work her fingers nearer the bone than the others, rather than abandon her husband, she gets it; and speculating on the love the mother bears her children, I see how much of her life the widow will give to save theirs, and decide accordingly. I know very well that these poor creatures cannot saw wood, wield the hammer, or roll barrels on the docks. I know that custom bars them out of many employments, and that the more manly vocations of handling ribbon, manipulating telegraphic instruments, &amp;c., are monopolized by men. Confined as they are to a few vocations, and there being so many hundreds of thousands of men who will not each provide for one, there are necessarily ten applicants for every vacancy; and there being more virtue in the sex than the world has ever given them credit for, of course they accept, not what their labor is worth to me and the world, but what I and the world choose to give for it. It is bad, I grant, but it is the fault of the system. It is a misfortune, we think, that there are so many women, and we weep over it. I am willing to shed any amount of tears over this mistake of nature.</p><p>But women are themselves to blame for a great part of the distress they experience. There is work for more of them, if they would only do it. The kitchens of the country are not half supplied with intelligent labor, and therein is a refuge for all women in distress.</p><p>I assert that nothing but foolish pride keeps the daughters of insolvent wealth out of kitchens, where they may have happy underground homes and three dollars per week, by merely doing six hours per day more labor than hod-carriers average.</p><p>This is what they would do were it not for pride, which is sinful. They should strip the jewels off their fingers, the laces off their shoulders; they should make a <a href="http://www.thefreedictionary.com/holocaust">holocaust</a> of their music and drawings, and, accepting the inevitable, sink with dignity to the washing of dishes, the scrubbing of floors, and the wash-tub. This their brothers do, and why haven’t they their strength of mind? Young men delicately nurtured and reared in the lap of luxury, never refuse the sacrifice when their papas fail in business. They always throw to the wind their cigars; they abjure canes and gloves, and mount drays, and shoulder <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sawbuck">saw-bucks</a> — anything for an honest living. I never saw one of these degenerate into a sponge upon society rather than labor with his hands! Did you? I never saw one of this class get to be a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faro_(card_game)">faro dealer</a>, a <a href="http://boards.ancestry.com.au/topics.occupations.occupations/1581/mb.ashx">billiard marker</a>, a borrower of small sums of money, a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_lunch#The_Free_Lunch_Fiend">lunch-fiend</a>, a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confidence_trick">confidence-man</a>, or anything of the sort. Not they! Giving the go-by to everything in the shape of luxuries, they invariably descend to the lowest grades of manual labor rather than degenerate into vicious and immoral courses. <a href="http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=673218">Failing the kitchen, women may canvass for books, though that occupation, like a few others equally profitable, and which also brings them into continual contact with the lords of creation, has a drawback in the fact that some men leer into the face of every woman who strives to do business for herself as though she were a moral leper; and failing all these, she may at least take to the needle.</a> At this last occupation she is certain of meeting no competition, save from her own sex. In all my experience, and it has been extensive, I never yet saw a man making pantaloons at twelve and a half cents per pair. But they will not all submit. Refusing to acknowledge the position in life nature fixed for them they rebel and unpleasantnesses take place. An incident which fell under my observation recently illustrates this beautifully. A young lady, named Jane Evans, I believe, had sustained the loss of both her parents. The elder Evanses had been convinced by typhoid fever that this was a cold world and, piloted by two doctors, has sailed out in search of a better one. Jane had a brother, a manly lad of twenty, who, rather than disgrace the ancient lineage of the Evanses by manual labor, took up the profession of bar-tender. Jane was less proud, and as her brother did nothing for her, she purchased some needles, and renting a room in the uppermost part of a building in a secluded part of New York City, commenced a playful effort to live by making shirts at eighteen cents each, for a gentleman named Isaacs. She was situated, I need not say, pleasantly for one of her class. Her room was not large, it is true, but as she had no cooking-stove or bedstead, what did she want of a large room? She had a window which didn’t open, but as there was no glass in it, she had no occasion to open it. This building commanded a beautiful view of other buildings similar in appearance, and the sash kept out a portion of the smell. Had that sash not been in that window-frame, I do not suppose that she could have staid on account of the smell; at least I heard her say that she got just as much of it as she could endure. And in this delightful retreat she sat and sat, and sewed and sewed. Sometimes in her zeal she would sew till late in the night, and she always was at her work very early in the morning. She paid rent promptly, for the genial old gentleman of whom she leased her room had a sportive habit of kicking girls into the street who did not pay properly, and she managed every now and then, did this economical girl, to purchase a loaf of bread, which she ate.</p><p>One Saturday night she took her bundle of work to the delightful Mr. Isaacs. Jane had labored sixteen hours per day on them, and she had determined, as Sunday was close at hand, to have for her breakfast, in addition to her bread, a small piece of <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamb_and_mutton">mutton</a>. Mutton! Luxurious living destroyed ancient Rome! But Mr. Isaacs found fault with the making of these shirts. They were not properly sewed, he said, and he could not in consequence pay her the eighteen cents each for making, which was the regular price. Jane then injudiciously cried about it. Now, Mr. Isaacs, was, and is, possessed of a tender heart. He has a great regard for his feelings, and as he could not bear to see a woman cry, he forthwith kicked her out of his store into the snow.</p><p>What did this wicked girl do? Did she go back and ask pardon of the good, kind, tender-hearted Mr. Isaacs? Not she! On the contrary she clenched her hands, and passing by a baker’s shop, stole a loaf of bread, and, brazen thing that she was, in pure bravado, she ate it in front of the shop. She said she was hungry, when it was subsequently proven she had eaten within forty hours. Justice was swift upon the heels of the desperate wretch — it always is, by the way, close behind the friendless. She was arrested by a policeman, who was opportunely there, as there was a riot in progress in the next street at the time, which was providential, for had there been no riot in the next street, the policeman would have been in that street, and Jane Evans might have got away with her plunder. She was conveyed to the city prison; was herded in a cell in which there were other women who had progressed farther than she had; was afterwards arraigned for petty larceny; and sent to prison for sixty days. Now she how surely evildoers come to bad ends. The wretched Jane, — this fearfully depraved Jane, — unable after such a manifestation of depravity to hold up her head, fell into bad ways. Remorse for the stealing of that loaf of bread so preyed upon her that she wandered about the streets of the city five days, asking for work, and finally threw herself off a wharf. O, how her brother, the bar-tender, was shocked at this act! Had she continued working cheerily for Mr. Isaacs, accepting the situation like a Christian, taking life, as she found it, would she have thrown herself off a dock? Never! So you see women who do not want to steal bread, and be arrested, and go off wharves, must take Mr. Isaacs’ pay as he offers it, and must work cheerily sixteen hours a day, whether they get anything to eat or not. Had this wretched girl gone back contentedly to her room, and starved to death cheerfully, she would not have stolen bread, she would not have lacerated the feelings of her brother the bar-tender, and would have saved the city of New York the expense and trouble of fishing her out of the dock. Such women always make trouble.</p><p>The women who fancy they are oppressed, demand, first, the ballot, that they may have power to better themselves; and second, the change of custom and education, that they may have free access to whatever employment they have the strength and capacity to fill, and to which their inclination leads them.</p><p>Most emphatically I object to giving them the ballot. It would overturn the whole social fabric. The social fabric has been overturned a great many times, it is true — so many times indeed that it seems to rather like it; but I doubt whether it would be strong enough to endure this. I have too great, too high, too exalted an opinion of woman. I insist that she shall not dabble in the dirty pool of politics; that she shall keep herself sacred to her family, whether she has one or not; and under no consideration shall she go beyond the domestic circle of which she is the centre and the ornament. There are those who have an insane yearning to do something beyond the drudgery necessary to supply the commonest wants of life, and others who have all of these, who would like to round up their lives with something beyond dress and the unsatisfactory trifles of fashionable life. There may be women turning night into day over the needle, for bread that keeps them just this side of <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potter&#39;s_field">potter’s field</a>, who are unreasonable enough to repine at the system that compels them to this; and they may, possibly, in secret wish that they had the power in their hands that would make men court their influence, as the hod-carrier’s is courted, for the vote he casts. The seamstress, toiling for a pittance that would starve a dog, no doubt prays for the power that would compel lawmakers to be as careful of her interests as they are of the interests of the well-paid male laborers in the dock-yards, who, finding ten hours a day too much for them, were permitted by act of Congress to draw ten hours’ pay for eight hours’ work. The starved colorer of lithographs, the pale, emaciated tailoress, balancing death and virtue; drawing stitches with the picture of the luxurious brothel held up by the devil before her, where there is light, and warmth, and food, and clothing, and where death is, at least, farther off; no doubt this girl wishes at times that she could have that potent bit of paper between her fingers that would compel blatant demagogues to talk of the rights of workingwomen as well as of workingmen.</p><p>But woman would lose her self-respect if she mixed with politicians. Most men do; and how could woman hope to escape. Think you that any pure woman could be a member of the New York, New Jersey, or Pennsylvania legislatures, and remain pure? For the sake of the generations to come, I desire that one sex, at least, shall remain uncontaminated. Imagine your wife or your sister accepting a bribe from a family member! Imagine your wife or your sister working a corrupt measure through the legislature, and becoming gloriously elevated upon champagne in exultation over the result! No! I insist that these things shall be confined to man, and man alone.</p><p>The mixing of women in politics, as all the writers on the subject have justly remarked, would lower the character of the woman without elevating that of the man. Imagine, O my hearers, a woman aspiring for office as men do! Imagine her <a href="http://www.thefreedictionary.com/buttonholing">button-holing</a> voters, as men do! Imagine her lying glibly and without scruple, as men do! Imagine her drinking with the lower classes, as men do! of succeeding by the grossest fraud, as men do! of stealing public money when elected, as men do! and finally of sinking into the lowest habits, the vilest practices, as Dr. Bushnell, in several places in his blessed book on the subject, asserts that men do! You see that to make the argument good, that women would immediately fall to a very deep depth of degradation the moment they vote, we must show that the act of voting compels men to this evil; at least that is what Dr. Bushnell proves, if he proves anything. We must show that the holding of an office by a man is proof positive that he has committed crime enough to entitle him to a cell in penitentiary, and that he who votes is in a fair way thereto. Before reading the doctor’s book, I was weak enough to suppose that there were in the United States some hundreds of thousands of very excellent men, whose long service in church and state was sufficient guarantee of their excellence; whose characters were above suspicion, and who had lived, and would die, honest, reputable citizens. But as all male citizens <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twenty-sixth_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution">over the age of twenty-one</a> vote, and as voting necessarily produces these results, why, then we are all drunkards, tricksters, thieves, and plunderers.</p><p>This disturbing woman, to whom I read Dr. Bushnell’s book, remarked that if voting tended to so demoralize men, and as they had always voted, it would be well enough for all the women to vote just once, that they might all go to <a href="http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/perdition">perdition</a> together. I am compelled to the opinion that the doctor is mistaken. I know a quite a number of men who go to the polls unmolested, who vote their principles quietly, and go home the better for having exercised the right. I believe that, before and after Johnson’s administration, there have been honest men in office. But no woman could do these things in this way. It would unsex her, just as it does when a woman labors for herself alone.</p><p>Again. I object to giving the ballot to woman, because we want peace. We don’t want divided opinion in our families. As it is, we must have a delightful unanimity. An individual cannot possibly quarrel with himself. As it is now arranged, man and wife are one, and the man is that one. In all matters outside the house the wife has no voice, and consequently there can be no differences. O, what a blessed thing it would be if the same rule could obtain among men! Had the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radical_Republican">Radicals</a> had no votes or voices, there would have been no war, for the Democracy, having in all their own way, there would have been nothing to quarrel about. It was opposition that forced Jefferson Davis to appeal to arms. True, the following of this idea would dwarf the Republicans into pygmies and exalt the Democracy into giants. My misguided friend, Wendell Phillips, would shrink into a commonplace man, possibly he would lose all manhood, had he been compelled to agree with <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franklin_Pierce">Franklin Pierce</a> or hold his tongue. It would be bad for Wendell, but there would have been a calm as profound as stagnation itself. Our present system may be bad for women, but we, the men, have our own way — and peace. Our wives and daughters are, I know, driven, from sheer lack of something greater, to take refuge is disjointed gabble of bonnets, cloaks, and dresses, and things of that nature, their souls are dwarfed as well as their bodies, their minds are diluted — but we have peace.</p><p>Once more. It would unbalance society. Starting upon the assumption that women have no minds of their own, and would always be controlled by men, we can show wherein the privilege would work incalculable mischief. Imagine <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brigham_Young">Brigham Young</a> marching to the polls at the head of a procession of wives one hundred and seventy-three, all of them with such ballots in their hands as he selects for them! Put Brigham and his family in a close congressional district and he would swamp it. Then, again, if they should think for themselves, and vote as they pleased, they would overthrow Brigham. In either case the effect would be terrible.</p><p>What shall we do with the woman question? It is upon us, and must be met. I have tried for an hour to be conservative, but it won’t do. Like poor <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calico_(textile)">calico</a>, it won’t wash. There are in the United States some millions of women who desire something better than the lives they and their mothers have been living. There are millions of women who have minds and souls, and who yearn for something to develop their minds and souls. There are millions of women who desire to have something to think about, to assume responsibilities, that they may strengthen their moral natures, as the gymnast lifts weights to strengthen his physical nature. There are hundreds of thousands of women who have suffered in silence worse evils by far than the slaves on the South, who, like the slaves of the South, have no power to redress their wrongs, no voice so potent the public must hear. In the parlor, inanity and frivolity; in the cottage, hopeless servitude, unceasing toil; a dark life, with a darker ending. This is the condition of woman in the world to-day. Thousands starving physically for want of something to do, with a world calling for labor; thousands starving mentally, with an unexplored world before them. One half of humanity is a burden on the other half.</p><p>I know, O, ye daughters of luxury, that you do not desire a change. There is no need of it for you. Your silks could not be more costly, your jewels could not flash more brightly, nor your surroundings be more luxurious. Your life is pleasant enough. But I would compel you to think, and thinking, act. I would put upon your shoulders responsibilities that would make rational beings of you. I would make you useful to humanity and to yourselves. I would give the daughters of the poor, as I have helped to give the sons of the poor, the power in their hands to right their own wrongs.</p><p>There is nothing unreasonable in this demand. The change is not so great as those the world has endured time and again without damage. To give the ballot to the women of America to-day, would not be so fearful a thing as it was ten years ago to give it to the negro, or as it was a hundred years ago to give it to the people.</p><p>I would give it, and take the chances. The theory of <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republicanism_in_the_United_States">Republicanism</a> is, that the governing power must rest in the hands of the governed. There is no danger in truth. If the woman is governed, she has a right to a voice in the making of laws. To withhold it is to dwarf her, and to dwarf woman is to dwarf the race.</p><p>I would the ballot to woman for her own sake, for I would enlarge the borders of her mind. I would give it to her for the sake of humanity. I would make her of more use to humanity by making her more fit to mould humanity. I would strengthen her, and through her the race. The ballot of itself would be of direct use to but few, but indirectly its effects would reach through all eternity. It would compel a different life. It would compel woman to an interest in life, would fit her to struggle successfully against its mischances, and prepare her for a keener, higher, brighter appreciation of its blessings. Humanity is now one-sided. There is strength on the one side and weakness on the other. I would have the two sides equal in strength, equally symmetrical; differing only as nature made them, not as man and custom have distorted them. In this do we outrage custom? Why, we have been overturning customs six thousand years, and there are yet enough hideous enormities encumbering the earth to take six thousand more years to kill. In the beginning, when force was the law, there were kings. The world tired of kings. There were false religions. Jesus of Nazareth overturned them. <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Luther">Luther</a>wrecked a venerable system when he struck the church of Rome with his iron hand; your fathers and mine stabbed a hoary iniquity when they overturned kingcraft on this continent, and <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elijah_Parish_Lovejoy">Lovejoy</a>, <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Lloyd_Garrison">Garrison</a>, and Phillips struck an institution which ages had sanctioned when they assaulted slavery. The old is not always the best.</p><p>I would have your daughters fitted to grapple with life alone, for no matter how you may leave them, you know not what fate may have in store for them. I would make them none the less women, but stronger women, better women. Let us do this much towards making humanity what the Creator intended it to be, –like Himself.</p><p>*Elsewhere, <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jay_Gould">Jay Gould</a>.</p><p>**Elsewhere, <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_G._Blaine">James G. Blaine</a>, referring to his <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_presidential_election,_1884">loss</a> to Grover Cleveland in the election of 1884.</p><p><strong>citations:</strong></p><p>Locke, D.R. “Nasby’s Lecture on the Woman Question.” <em>Wise, Witty, Eloquent Kings of the Platform and Pulpit</em>. ed. Melville De Lancey Landon. Chicago: F. C. Smedley &amp; Co, 1891. 100–120.</p><p>Locke, David Ross. “The Struggles of a Conservative with the Woman Question.” <em>The Struggles (Social, Financial, and Political) of Petroleum V. Nasby…</em>. Boston: L. N. Richardson &amp; Company, 1868. 660–686.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5f5bc2592c7c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Democrats Can Make Political Incorrectness Great Again in the Age of Trump]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PeltaRepublic/how-democrats-can-make-political-incorrectness-great-again-in-the-age-of-trump-75cda1be0f34?source=rss-6391bfb02960------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/75cda1be0f34</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[2016-election]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-correctness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Mark Pelta]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 16 Nov 2016 20:30:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-17T00:46:35.695Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“I think the big problem this country has is being politically correct. I’ve been challenged by so many people and I don’t, frankly, have time for total political correctness. And to be honest with you, this country doesn’t have time, either.”<br> — President-elect Donald Trump, <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-politics/wp/2015/08/06/annotated-transcript-the-aug-6-gop-debate/">8/6/15 FOX Republican Debate</a></p><p>Your friends who didn’t support Hillary Clinton assure you, when pressed, that they of course don’t agree with some of the things President-elect Donald Trump said. Well, maybe less so when regarding a ban on Muslims entering the country or a Muslim registry (Seriously? Seriously. Because we’re Americans and Americans make decisions about national security and which groups to be inclusive of based on inaccurate Skittles analogies). But some of them (and again I have to emphasize this, <em>when pressed</em>) will express discomfort at some of the stuff he said: A judge‘s decision (which legal experts say is totally legit) is so unfair that it can only be explained by reference to his parents being Mexican? Saying he only likes veterans who weren’t captured? The current president is maybe not legitimate? When you’re famous you can do anything, including nonconsensually kissing women (which he and many women said he did) and grabbing a woman’s pussy? Women should be evaluated, whether they be beauty pageant contestants or Carly Fiorina, on the basis of their looks? “Certain sections” of swing states were committing voter fraud on a scale to potentially effect the election? It’s fair to passionately describe illegal immigrants as generally criminals, drug dealers, and rapists, with only an aside about “some” who are good people?</p><p>Well, of course these things are terrible, they empathize. But at least he isn’t afraid to say what he thinks (at any given moment, even if it contradicts what he said earlier in the sentence). How refreshing! A leader of the free world who would say anything without fear of opprobrium! And look, the stuff he said was bad, but it wasn’t enough for them to make Donald Trump any less qualified for the White House than Clinton. Despite all the noise about some giant#nevertrump movement waiting in the wings of the GOP, a lesson I learned a long time ago is that one should never rely on a conservative to do a liberal’s job; they may make noise about how independent and differently-thinking they are, but they ultimately rally behind authority as seen in the fact that <a href="http://www.cbsnews.com/news/cbs-news-exit-polls-how-donald-trump-won-the-us-presidency/">89% of Republicans voted for him</a>. They now defend Trump’s choice of Steve Bannon for a senior position in the White House.</p><p>So he is now the president-elect and his supporters are exuberant about the potential to <a href="http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/no-more-political-correctness-for-trump-supporters/">stamp out political correctness</a>. PBS quotes one such person as giving a take which I’m sure you have often heard: Political correctness “takes away your freedom of speech, pretty much. You can’t say anything.” What should the response of Democrats be to the Republicans wanting to discuss uncomfortable topics without fear of censure?</p><p><strong>Take them up on it.</strong></p><p>Yes, I think we should agree with them that there are certainly colleges, particularly out in California, that have engaged in ridiculously not letting conservatives speak on campus. Yes, we should be willing to not be partisan and admit such things. But now, we need to demand they get out of their comfort zones and talk about topics they too often fear putting under the microscope of objective, rigorous analysis.</p><p>Here’s a topic: <strong>Religion</strong>. Religion largely correlates with a more conservative worldview in this country. Conservatives say that they are only after the facts and they’re so sorry if their honest objective search for truth hurts your pretty widdle feelings and takes you out of your comfort zone. Okay, let’s have an honest conversation about your alleged proofs for your theologies and why you believe those religions lead to a conservative worldview. But I think it’s only fair that atheist and liberal religious perspectives be given to counteract the idea that only conservative fundamentalists can talk about religion. Let’s talk about your standard of evidence for believing what the rabbi, priest, imam, or conservative talk show host tells you. Is it peer reviewed?</p><p>And you know what, if you’re tired of kids being “brainwashed” with a “left wing agenda” in the public schools, let’s talk about your <strong>Schools.</strong> Yes, including your private fundamentalist institutions. After all, if you can complain about private “mainstream media” companies, sports organizations, or food delivery companies (e.g. Grubhub), I can talk about the sort of education I think kids ought to have in this country; an uneducated populace, as recently demonstrated, makes for a broken democracy. You value education? What do your kids think about the Confederate flag? Do they think Lincoln was a conservative? How about climate change and evolution? Why is it necessary to teach fake history and science in order to keep them in line? Why not just give them the facts? You value open-mindedness and tolerance? I want to talk about what the teachers are telling your kids in their schools. I want to discuss what your school tells your kids to do if they’re LGBT. I want to understand what they tell your kids it means if they dare disagree with your political or religious worldview and go in a different direction. I want to know what speakers and teachers come in to give an alternative perspective so they aren’t brainwashed.</p><p>I want to talk about<strong> the prevalence of conspiracy theories on the right</strong>. After all, we now have the birther-in-chief in charge of our country. Why did y’all fan the flames that allowed such things to fester? Why did you allow him to become your leader? I mean, somebody who believes whatever he reads from World Net Daily isn’t really qualified for high office, right? How can you believe such a person will fix things? Why do you have no sense of skepticism?</p><p>These are just a few examples. Are these uncomfortable conversations for you? Do you think it’s impolite to discuss such things? I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to infringe on your safe space, precious. Why are you so offended because people are asking questions and disagreeing with your point of view? Maybe I could use less confrontational language, but hey, it’s certainly not disqualifying me from polite society to say such things; hell, you’d vote for me for president, right? And I’m not saying anything worse than the stuff the chief executive has said with abandon. Your being offended does not particularly concern me anymore. If you didn’t want to open up such conversations, maybe your crew shouldn’t have sent the message that you’re done with political correctness.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=75cda1be0f34" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>