<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Gillian Kratzer on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Gillian Kratzer on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@PoliticsMom?source=rss-6ce8f9dc2c6e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 13:07:04 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@PoliticsMom/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Rethinking Rethinking ADHD]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@PoliticsMom/rethinking-rethinking-adhd-cca521809ccd?source=rss-6ce8f9dc2c6e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cca521809ccd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[adhd-in-women]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[adhd]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[adhd-treatment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Gillian Kratzer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 Apr 2025 18:59:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-13T20:57:28.637Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Now that I’m sitting at my laptop, I’m unsure how to start. Let’s start with how I got here to my desk at 12:41pm on a Sunday.</p><p>I went to the gym late this morning. For the last year I’ve been going to the gym about four times a week with very little interruption. I usually go Monday, Tuesday, Thursday and Friday but Monday didn’t work so I added Sunday.¹ Instead of my usual music, I was listening to an article from the New York Times called <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2025/04/13/magazine/adhd-medication-treatment-research.html?unlocked_article_code=1._U4.7hgb.AqzEhnCyXt-0&amp;smid=url-share">Have We Been Thinking About ADHD All Wrong</a> by Paul Tough.</p><p>My friend had warned that it might be a triggering article and wow, is that an understatement. In fact had I simply been reading it instead of listening while I worked out, I probably would have rage quit after the first few paragraphs.²</p><p>Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (from now on ADHD) is a disorder that encompasses a wide range of behaviors and experiences which can be both good and bad situationally, but is named after the two major ways that we annoy our parents and teachers. Read that last sentence and then read it again because it’s going to make a lot of things more understandable from the perspective of a person with ADHD.</p><p>I wasn’t diagnosed with ADHD until I was 43 years old. A disorder that is readily recognized as genetically inheritable, doctors still don’t ask to screen undiagnosed parents when they bring their children in for screening. My daughter had been taking Adderall for several years at the point that I finally got the courage to ask for a screening and it was another few years after that when I was finally diagnosed.</p><p>My experience, <a href="https://abcnews.go.com/Health/women-diagnosed-adhd-adults-open-life-changing-event/story?id=111841436">and the experience many other women in their 30s, 40s, and even beyond</a>, was completely absent in the article. In fact, the disparity of diagnosis between boys and girls and the lack of study of girls with ADHD was also completely absent. This is particularly interesting because at this point in history <a href="https://bmcpsychiatry.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12888-020-02707-9#Sec3">the disparity of diagnosis between boys and girls is basically accepted fact at this point</a>. In part this can likely be ascribed to differences in presentation and socialization, <a href="https://adhdgirlsandwomen.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/Hinshaw_2021_Review.pdf">oh and incidentally that like so many other areas of medicine, that until recent years women and girls were left almost entirely out of ADHD studies</a>.</p><p>I surpressed the strong urge throughout listening to the article to yell about various conclusions the author comes to based on the studies of mostly male doctors who have studied mostly male patients. If I didn’t have working out to center my physical self, I guarantee I would not have made it through the article.³</p><p>The few times a “she” was reference that was not one of the researchers noted, it was the passage below and the experience of a haridresser with ADHD who describes her symptoms as minimizing or disappearing once she found her passion in life and an ability to focus primarily on that.</p><blockquote>If a child who experienced early trauma now can’t sit still or stay organized, should she be treated for A.D.H.D.? What about a child with an anxiety disorder who is constantly distracted by her worries? Does she have A.D.H.D., or just A.D.H.D.-like symptoms caused by her anxiety? — Paul Tough, Have We Been Thinking About ADHD All Wrong</blockquote><p>Setting the gender situation aside for a moment, the article focuses largely on the efficacy or lack thereof when it comes to stimulant medication for ADHD, which is and always has been the primary medical treatment for the disorder.</p><p>So have we been thinking about ADHD all wrong? Frankly, my answer is yes which is why this article is so profoundly frustrating. At every turn I found the author and/or the researchers and doctors he cited get so close to getting it and then failing utterly to reach the conclusion that many people with ADHD would understand innately. A lot of it is framing.</p><p>Tough notes thats for some people an ADHD diagnosis can be an extraordinary relief while for others it can feel very stigmatizing. God, Paul, I wonder why the <em>bleep⁴ </em>that is. Hey, remember before when I mentioned that ADHD is named after the two biggest ways people diagnosed with ADHD annoy their parents and teachers? You <em>bleeping </em>think that could have something to do with it guys?</p><p>Speaking for myself, but also as one of many women diagnosed as adults, the diagnosis alone made me experience a kind of relief I don’t know that I’ve ever felt before or since. It was like a weight was lifted off of me. It was someone telling me after decades and decades of feeling stupid and unworthy that I wasn’t doing it on purpose. There are probably a lot of people who know me, even people who know me well, that would find it surprising to hear, but I spent the vast majority of my life feeling like a failure for not being able to live up to my POTENTIAL⁵.</p><p>Things I heard too often as a child:</p><ul><li>You’re smarter than that</li><li>Why can’t you <em>just </em>do it</li><li>This isn’t that hard</li><li>If so and so can do it, you should be able to</li><li>We didn’t raise you to &lt;insert thing&gt;</li></ul><p>I want to be very clear, for my parents and other parents of kids with undiagnosed ADHD: I’m not mad at you. Yes, I certainly have moments of resentment, but as an adult I can recognize that you were working with the information you had with a child whose brain you didn’t understand even at the times when their behaviors mirrored yours to a fairly uncanny extent. I know that because I have a child with ADHD and I know that if I had been diagnosed sooner there are a lot of things I’d have done differently when she was little. Again, however, we know a lot now about creating a better environment for kids and adults with ADHD than we knew when I was younger, not to mention that I’m a woman and I didn’t present as a disruptive child.</p><p>The disruptive child part is huge. It, in fact, cannot possibly be understated. It’s a thought barrier that the author, and frankly all the researchers he notes, seem to run into constantly. There is indeed an entire section devoted to how inexplicable it was that taking medication for ADHD may help things like focus but it doesn’t seem to improve performance in school. To which I can only say: No <em>bleep</em>, Sherlock.</p><p>Multiple times in the article the refrain rings out: they can focus now, why aren’t they doing better on tests?</p><p>Well here’s a thought, perhaps attention and intelligence are not actually the same thing. Mistaking attention for intelligence is how my diagnosis became almost a footnote in my screening the first time I saw a psychiatrist. While we were going through the sort of get-to-know-you phase, he asked about my education level. I told him that I had a BA in Political Science and he immediately began to move on until I stopped him to add that I have a Masters in Political Management. He stopped dead and said, “oh, you have a Masters, well then you can’t have ADHD.” I bet you can imagine the confidence this inspired in me vis a vis his diagnosis. He did do a screening but told me that I had anxiety and depression and, probably to appease me, he added to his notes that I maybe had a little ADHD. I never went back to him.</p><p>He was right about the anxiety and depression. Anxiety and depression are comorbidities of a lot of folks with ADHD, even more so in women diagnosed later in life. Can you guess why? Scroll back up to the things that I heard so often as a kid.</p><p>Imagine yourself as a bright kid who sometimes has trouble focusing and sometimes is intensely focused for a long period of time but not on the thing that your parents or teachers or whatever adult want you to be focused on. It’s not that you don’t understand that you should be doing this thing but you’re doing that thing or that you should be doing this thing but are refusing consciously to do the other thing. When a person with ADHD is having difficulty focusing on a task they need to get done there is a profound mental barrier. When I say that I can’t do it, I mean that literally. Sometimes even when I desperately want to do whatever the thing is, I simply cannot bring myself to do it. Hey look, there’s the depression. If you don’t know what that feeling is like, I am genuinely incredibly happy for you because I would never wish it on anyone. Most especially when you don’t understand why it’s happening you will almost inevitably feel like you must be lazy or maybe stupid and probably both.</p><p>The anxiety is a variation on this theme. Women are generally socialized much more to want to be socially acceptable and to rely on external validation, to be a Good Girl. ADHD creates varying degrees of difficulty in fulfilling those expectations that many girls and women deal with by monitoring themselves constantly and aggressively. It manifests as perfectionism and overachieving, but also flakiness, over-promising and other less appealing traits. Nearly a year into taking stimulant medication, my anxiety is not remotely as bad as it used to be. I still experience anxiety, but for the most part it’s a reaction to the hellscape timeline we’re living in less so much anything internal to me.</p><p>My therapist has noted more times than I can count how self-aware I am. He’s right. It’s because for the overwhelming majority of my life I have thought nearly constantly about how what I say is being perceived or whether I am fulfilling someone’s expectation of me or whether I’m going to disappoint someone by doing or not doing whatever thing. The major personal work of my last several years has been attempting to unlearn some of those things. Anxiety, however, is kind of hard to kick because at this point in my life some of the thoughts and feelings that go along with it have become hardwired.</p><p>This is of course not to mention the role that trauma plays in the life of person with ADHD. Many symptoms of ADHD can also be caused by trauma. Unfortunately, as others have observed before me, that’s hard to tease out because our society essentially only produced traumtized people with ADHD (and the same goes for Autism, among other things).</p><p>When I was finally diagnosed with ADHD, it was by a woman. In addition to observation and the sorts of questions about whether you experience difficulty at home and work, etc, she also used the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Test_of_Variables_of_Attention">Test of Variables of Attention (TOVA)</a>. I don’t purport to know everything or even a preponderance of what there is to know about ADHD testing. I do know that what seems to be most common is the variety where you answer a battery of questions. The TOVA test that I took is a computer game (which is very boring) wherein you are supposed to click when you see or hear the number one. Sometimes the test would show the number 2 while saying the number 1, to give you a sense of what was happening. It seems actually super easing when I was hearing the instructions, but it was — for me — incredibly difficult. A few weeks later I had my diagnosis — combination type ADHD.</p><p>Incidentally, combination type ADHD (characterized by roughly equal parts attention deficit and hyperactivity), was not mentioned at all in Mr. Tough’s article. I do not know why.</p><p>Taking Adderall (the generic version, dextroamphetamine) for the first time was nothing less than life-changing. Without it, you can bet that at any moment there is a cacophony in my brain that may include of some combination of or all of the following likely non-complete list:</p><ul><li>Reliving a previous conversation</li><li>Practing an upcominh conversation</li><li>Thinking of ways that previous conversation could have been better and wondering if I was misunderstood</li><li>Worrying that someone is mad at me</li><li>Hearing a song replay on loop</li><li>Hearing lines from a TV show or movie also on loop</li><li>Talking myself through something I’m actively trying to do</li><li>The kind of negative self talk that would make you wonder how I survived</li></ul><p>That last one I have managed largely to curb thanks to a better understanding of how my brain works.</p><p>In any case, as all these things were going on (hyperativity in women is often internal not external), I had to go about my day like I am fine and everything is super normal.</p><p>As Tough and researchers point out multiple times in his article, ADHD is difficult to pin down because so many of the pieces of it are things that everyone experiences to one extent or another throughout their life. The difference is that most people don’t experience them all at once and nearly all the time.</p><p>He also points out that — and I hope you’re sitting down because this is a big reveal — that when people with ADHD are in an evironment more suited to their way of thinking and that involves something they’re intersted in their symptoms can seem to disappear. Allow me to draw your attention back to the beginning again.</p><p>Hyperfocus is just as much a sign of ADHD as the inability to focus. So yes, if I am very interested in something I can hyperfocus. Hyperfocus, by the way, can also cause problems. Many people with “inattentive” type ADHD also know that they can focus on something they’re interested in, often to the exlusion of anything else including physical necessities like eating and going to the bathroom. We’re not purposely starving ourselves or peeing ourselves. The focus becomes so overwhelming that the feeling of hunger or the sense of needing to use the toilet become a sort of background noise and before you know it, you’ve been typing a response to a really <em>bleeping </em>stupid article about ADHD for two hours — for example.</p><p>Sometimes the hyperfocus is great — societally speaking. If you can manage to be hyperfocused about a thing you’re supposed to do for work people will treat you like some kind of superhero. Nevermind that you haven’t eaten in six hours and you just noticed and now the hyperfocus is wearing off and your body is about to make you pay for it. This, by the way, is why I <em>bleeping </em>hate when people refer to the more positively viewed traits of ADHD as a superpower. Those traits come at a cost and it’s easy to think it’s really cool when you aren’t the person that has to pay the cost, which is mostly invisible to neurotypical people. When the cost is visible, it’s can be simply another way that we’re bothersome.</p><p>I understand ADHD being hard to pin down. The bits and pieces that come along with it are almost numberless and also overlap with other things. <a href="https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/24099-rejection-sensitive-dysphoria-rsd">Rejection Sensitive Dysphoria</a> is an official term and a feeling that people with ADHD often experience. I’m sure most people have some level of trepidation about rejection, but when I think that you’re mad at me it causes me a mental anguish that comes close to physical pain. It’s something that bothers me less now that I understand what it is, because I can talk myself through it and I have a support network of people that understand that I experience it and aren’t — at least noticeably — really annoyed with me when I get myself to clarify how they’re feeling about something in order to assauge the fear that they suddenly hate me because I forgot to text them back⁶. If there were one part of ADHD I could get rid of immediately it would be this without question.</p><p>People with ADHD can also experience <a href="https://www.healthline.com/health/adhd/demand-avoidance-adhd">Pathological Demand Avoidance (or just Demand Avoidance)</a>. PDA⁷ is also common in people on the Autism spectrum, which I may or may not also be on and is a whole other conversation. Put simply, it is a desperate need to NOT DO a particular thing that someone wants you to do and in fact even sometimes a thing that you yourself want to do. This is why I often describe my brain as if it’s two different people: me and the ADHD. I want to do this you or I want me to do, but I also do not want to do the thing and in fact cannot now do the thing because my brain simply refuses to do the thing because it’s a thing that I <em>have to</em> do.</p><p>Those are only two of <a href="https://www.additudemag.com/when-its-not-just-adhd/?srsltid=AfmBOor241BAYZ_dtw0Z2IghIfpdFs11o1wyZipTGku3kz-_f1cmKB3x">literally dozens of weird little quirks of ADHD</a>⁸ that I could list out for you. This is also not to mention the sorts of comorbidities that can seem extremely odd because they seem so unrelated to the things we do that annoy you⁹. People with ADHD are highly likely to have <a href="https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/link-between-adhd-and-hypermobility#connection">hypermobility</a>. Do your knees bend backwards? Mine do. <a href="https://soniclearning.com.au/auditory-processing-disorder-and-adhd/">Auditory processing issues</a> are also common in people with ADHD. There are a bunch of other things that have a high correlation to ADHD. For the most part there’s not a good understanding of why or how. I get that I have a hard time paying attention sometimes but that doesn’t really explain entirely why when I am paying attention you might ask me a question to which I will respond “what?” and then before you can repeat yourself I’ll answer because my brain figured out what you just said.</p><p>I’m going to have to bring this to an end eventually so let’s bring it home.¹⁰</p><p>What Mr. Tough and his cited researchers need, in my opinion, is a few sociology classes. The standards for our behavior are created by our society, and I do mean created. In the US, it’s very normal to smile at someone on the street just as an acknowledgement, but that’s seen as really weird in a number of other countries. Our societies are all built on our histories and experiences as a collective and that changes over time and it varies by the group you’re talking about.</p><p>Please apply this to ADHD for a moment. The people with ADHD (or Autism, etc) have brains that are not wired for the society in which we live. Or at the very least not wired to do a lot of the things that a neurotypical would find very easy/mundane. There are any numbers of theories around this. Maybe people with ADHD show traits that humans have mostly evolved out of or whatever. I personally don’t really care. What I know is the way that I think is not always convenient in a capitalist society that is influenced heavily by English Puritans who thought being poor was a reflection of your moral character¹¹. In order to function as a member of society my only option until I was diagnosed was to berate myself and/or self-medicate¹² myself into an acceptable state.</p><p>So yeah, stimulant medication isn’t the whole answer. After all, there are times in <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10751335/">women’s menstrual cycles when stimulent medication is actually less effective</a>.¹³ So believe me, Paul¹⁴, I know that stimulants are an incomplete answer. They are really and truly just a way to make us more acceptable to a society that mostly doesn’t care how our brains work. The answer is pretty obviously that if we want to dispense with stimulant medication that society needs to about face pretty <em>bleeping </em>quickly, but I don’t see that happening in the short term or even the longterm, do you?</p><p>I have no doubt that there are a lot of other points that I’m missing and maybe I’m mad enough that I’ll write more, but now I’m going to try to do the several things that my brain demanded that I put on hold until I finished going off on this.</p><p>Footnotes</p><p>¹I know this is probably unnecessary information. You may get a lot of that, but I’m not adjusting myself to neurotypical storytelling expectations right now so you’re just going to have to deal with it or quit reading. Take or leave the footnotes, but for me these side thoughts and more thorough explanations feel necessary, though I recogize that some people may not understand why or how.</p><p>²Which incidentally is when I decided to just start listening to it.</p><p>³We’ll also remember this later, I would imagine.</p><p>⁴While I will control my urge to swear prolifically, I will occasionally bleep myself for the purposes of accurately representing my tone of voice.</p><p>⁵If you’re a former gifted kid, especially who was later diagnosed, you will understand the capitalization because it is representative of the massive weight that potential is to many of us.</p><p>⁶Real example.</p><p>⁷Not that kind, I know you thought of it too, don’t lie.</p><p>⁸I describe them as “weird little quirks” but do please read that as debilitating parts of my life.</p><p>⁹Not you specifically. I’m sure you’re very nice and patient, but I’m using the universal you and yes this is to ward of Rejection Sensitive Dysphoria.</p><p>¹⁰There was no rough draft or outline for this response because the concept of creating an unfinished product is completely alien to me. I will occasionally run something I write by someone, mostly for professional reasons, but I fundamentally cannot wrap my head around creating a rough draft and outlines give me no end of difficulties.</p><p>¹¹Yes, Katie, that is an oversimplification.</p><p>¹²Substance abuse is incredibly common in people with ADHD</p><p>¹³<a href="https://www.berkshirehealthcare.nhs.uk/media/109514308/4-adhd-guide-menopause.pdf">And do not even get me started on the effect perimenopause on the experience of having ADHD</a>.</p><p>¹⁴And the researchers he cites although frankly I would have to read their bodies of work to know if Mr. Tough’s biases have affected my relationship with their work.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cca521809ccd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>