<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Relentlessly Myself on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Relentlessly Myself on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@RelentlesslyMyself?source=rss-5f239e3e64a2------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 23:15:39 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@RelentlesslyMyself/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Refusing to Stay Small: Matilda and The Tyranny of Lost Childhood]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@RelentlesslyMyself/refusing-to-stay-small-matilda-and-the-tyranny-of-lost-childhood-88ed887fe9fa?source=rss-5f239e3e64a2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/88ed887fe9fa</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hegel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[childhood]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cinema]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[matilda]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Relentlessly Myself]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 05 Jun 2026 08:47:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-05T08:55:52.417Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/432/0*eUW4-O1wCKtpWwOh.gif" /></figure><p>Matilda is often remembered as a story of a gifted child overcoming cruelty. That is a surface reading. At its core, it is about what happens when a child is unseen, and how the distribution of love, power, and grief shapes a person. The women in the story are responses to abandonment first and characters second. Matilda, Miss Honey, and Miss Trunchbull are all isolated. Each is orphaned in a different way. Matilda’s parents exist, but she is emotionally unparented. Miss Honey is dispossessed, her father gone. Trunchbull has no family, no intimacy, no softness. Three figures, each positioned at a different distance from the same wound.</p><p>The story is archetypal. The child, Matilda, is a wonder and latent force. Miss Honey is the gentle, nurturing adult. Trunchbull is the harsh, cynical, masculinised figure, cut off from tenderness. These are modes of response rather than types of femininity. Abandonment can produce wonder, service, or domination. Matilda turns it into wonder, Miss Honey into service and Trunchbull into domination.</p><p>The complication sits here. Calling Trunchbull a monster stops the reading too early. She is the failed maternal figure, or the woman excluded from the ideal, turning her rage against childhood. She is large, aggressive, childless and coded as masculine. Miss Honey is her opposite: small, gentle, maternal, almost impossibly sweet. The story sets them as two poles. Miss Honey is tenderness without force. Trunchbull is a force without tenderness. Both are incomplete.</p><p>Trunchbull’s resentment is not random. She is offended by marriage, children, family and the world of domesticity. Her anger is a mask for humiliation. The presence of children confronts her with everything she lacks and cannot reclaim. She cannot tolerate it. She does not hate children for their noise. She hates what they represent, the dependency and softness she destroyed in herself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/0*wyXHl9Xk1bAqUzM8.gif" /></figure><p>But even bad mothers are mothers nonetheless. The story turns stranger here. Mrs Wormwood gives Matilda life but not recognition. Miss Honey gives her acknowledgement, yet not power, not just yet. Miss Trunchbull gives her an adversary. And in a perverse way, all three raise her. Mrs Wormwood teaches her that biological motherhood does not guarantee care. Miss Honey teaches her that tenderness can survive suffering. Miss Trunchbull teaches her that domination must be challenged. So if Miss Honey is the nurturance Matilda needed, Trunchbull is the initiative she needed. Trunchbull forces Matilda to rise to the occasion. Without Trunchbull, Matilda might remain gifted, observant, and wounded. With Trunchbull, she becomes active.</p><p>Matilda refuses the values of her world. She does not accept that adults are right by default, or that parents are worthy because they are parents. She rejects the idea that size is authority, or that cruelty is strength. Trunchbull says, “I am big, you are small, and there is nothing you can do about it.” This is the metaphysics of tyranny. It is a hierarchy as a brute fact. Reality is fixed because the powerful say so.</p><p>Matilda’s genius is that she does not believe her.</p><p>She subverts the master and slave dialectic not by begging for recognition from the master, but by refusing the master’s claim to define reality. She does not spend her life trying to win her parents’ approval because she does not believe they can understand her. That is very unusual for a neglected child. Most children hunger for parental recognition even when the parent is cruel, stupid, absent, or incapable. Matilda looks at her parents and, almost immediately, understands that their recognition will not save her. She does not care for their approval because she knows, somewhere inside herself, that they are not worthy judges of her being.</p><p>That is what makes her different from Miss Honey. Miss Honey is good, but she has lost initiative. She is tender, but she has no spine. She has been so thoroughly defeated by Trunchbull that her goodness has become passive. She knows what is right, but she cannot yet act on it. She cares for children, but she cannot free herself. She is the wounded adult who preserved compassion but lost force. Trunchbull is the wounded adult who preserved force but lost compassion. Matilda is the child who still has both. She holds wonder and will together, imagination and revenge, tenderness and cunning. Her sweetness is real, and so is the threat in her, which is that she has not yet surrendered.</p><p>Matilda and Miss Honey do not form a simple maternal bond. Miss Honey nurtures Matilda, yes, but Matilda also heals Miss Honey. Matilda does not exactly seek Miss Honey’s approval. She seeks love, recognition, and mutuality. She does not approach Miss Honey as a subordinate, begging for validation. She approaches her as an equal soul. Even when she brings the doll back, it is not about pleasing Miss Honey. It is about restoring something stolen. She is giving Miss Honey back a piece of childhood that was taken from her. In that sense, Matilda is Miss Honey’s homecoming.</p><p>The real centre of the story sits elsewhere. It is about Miss Honey recovering the child in herself as much as it is about Matilda finding a mother. Miss Honey has lost the child within herself. Trunchbull has annihilated the child within herself. Matilda still has access to that child, and that is why she is powerful. The child here does not represent naïveté. The child represents the part of the psyche that has not yet accepted power as natural. The child is courageous because the child can still ask, “Why?” Why should cruelty rule? Why should adults be obeyed when they are foolish? Why should a person accept the family they were given if that family cannot love them? Why should the world remain as it is?</p><p>That question is Matilda’s true power. The telekinesis is only a fantasy form of it.</p><p>Roald Dahl’s view of women and girlhood is complicated. He writes women in extremes. The saintly woman and the monstrous woman. The nurturing woman and the devouring woman. The beautiful mother substitute and the grotesque spinster tyrant. There is something irrefutably cruel in how Trunchbull is constructed. Her size, masculinity, childlessness, and aggression are made into spectacle. The story prompts us to both fear and laugh at her, and that reveals something about cultural anxieties around women who do not fit the feminine ideal. It punishes her not only for cruelty, but for failing to be soft, pretty, maternal, and desirable.</p><p>But Dahl also understands something fierce about girlhood. He understands that children are not powerless, as adults think they are. He understands that a child’s imagination can be a form of refusal. Matilda is not saved because she is obedient. She is saved because she is disobedient in the correct direction. She reads when forbidden, thinks amid stupidity, and judges the adults who believe themselves past judgment. She protects other children, avenges humiliation, and makes her private world real. So, she is truly the Nietzschean Übermensch.</p><p>Matilda may be about the trauma of childhood itself rather than the trauma of girlhood alone. It asks what happens when adults fail in their duty to recognise the child. Some children collapse under this, some turn compliant, some turn cruel in time. Matilda does something else. She becomes the part of the abandoned child that refuses spiritual defeat.</p><p>The three women are dimensions of one psyche. Matilda is the child before surrender. Miss Honey is the adult who survived and shrank. Trunchbull is the adult who survived by turning brutal. Loneliness shapes all three. The response to it is what separates them.</p><p>Matilda transforms it.</p><p>Miss Honey endures it.</p><p>Trunchbull weaponises it.</p><p>The ending satisfies because it repairs a childhood rather than disposing of a villain. Miss Honey recovers her courage through Matilda. Matilda receives through Miss Honey the care her parents withheld. Trunchbull is expelled as the force that kept tenderness and agency apart. The house the two of them share at the end is the arrangement that should have existed from the start, a child who can still wonder, living with an adult who can finally act.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/0*nBqJIV8xN_RX_Pu3.gif" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=88ed887fe9fa" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Of Being: light in Orbit]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@RelentlesslyMyself/of-being-light-in-orbit-e9d12a1599d6?source=rss-5f239e3e64a2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e9d12a1599d6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[identity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[temporality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[colonial-times]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[homi-bhabha]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metaphysics-of-time]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Relentlessly Myself]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 18 Aug 2025 20:55:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-18T21:01:30.795Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Identity and Politics of Chronology</p><p>I also think about how we understand time, because underneath much of our discourse around identity lies a deeper metaphysics — one that defines the self not just in relation to others, but in relation to temporality itself. Often, the pursuit of the self is framed through the lens of progress, and that framing has everything to do with how post-Enlightenment thought has imagined time as linear, goal-directed, and ascending. In this model, one must strive to complete the “work” of becoming. There is the belief that selfhood, authenticity, enlightenment — these are destinations, peaks to be reached after climbing a long internal staircase.</p><p>This idea is reflected in Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, which assumes that a human being must progress step-by-step from deficiency to self-actualisation. It is also present in Hegelian dialectics, where history unfolds through the clash and resolution of opposites, producing a synthesis that supposedly brings us closer to a fuller realisation of Spirit, the human soul, or a collective consciousness — what Hegel calls the zeitgeist. However, embedded in this model is a kind of ontological negation — a philosophical concept that suggests we begin in a state of lack, of not-being, and must work our way toward being. In simpler terms, it’s the idea that we start from a point of not having something and then strive to acquire it. The present is portrayed as incomplete, valuable only insofar as it serves as a bridge toward a more enlightened future.</p><p>But what if becoming is not toward something — what if becoming <em>is</em> life? What if the spiral, not the ladder, is the more accurate metaphor for how we move through time, through identity, through existence? In a therapy session, I once described this as the spiral staircase of being. Human growth, I suggested, is not linear — it is more akin to a spiral, where we revisit the same themes, feelings, and lessons, but from a different vantage point each time. This understanding liberates us from the pressure of linear progress, much like light itself, which oscillates between form and energy, particle and wave. Human existence is also both transitional and contemplative. We are movement, and we are stillness. We are fluctuating, and we are shaped. Our very essence is this dance between the kinetic and the crystalline, a dance that frees us from the burden of a linear path.</p><p>Take the photon, the most primordial and irreducible form of matter-energy, older than memory itself. A photon exists in a dual state, oscillating between a wave and a particle. It does not “progress” in the way we think of development; it is always in flux, always becoming, always already being. This oscillation is not a symptom of incompletion. It is the expression of wholeness. And perhaps that is what we are, too — oscillations. Shifting between form and becoming, between manifestation and potential. The transition is not a failure of stillness. It is still moving. It is the quiet shape of time unfolding.</p><p>This understanding contrasts sharply with much of Western metaphysics, which emphasises appraisal, purification, and completion. There is often a need to ascend toward the divine, to resolve into one final, coherent version of the self. In contrast, many Eastern philosophies propose that the divine already is. It does not need to be reached. It is immanent. It has always existed. One need not strive but merely awaken. The task is not to arrive at authenticity, but to see that one has never left it. As Kitarō Nishida writes, reality is pure experience. You are already in it. There is nothing to earn, nothing to prove, nothing to attain.</p><p>This is where the models of being diverge. In one, you must chase the authentic self as if it is a goal waiting at the end of a perfectly ordered sequence. In the other, you are already whole, because all the roles you play, all the stories you carry, all the contradictions you embody — these too are you. And in that multiplicity, that constant shifting of relational frames, there is no such thing as inauthenticity. The story is eternal. And because it is circular, nothing is left out. This realization brings a profound sense of peace and acceptance with our current state, a state that is not a step towards a future, but a complete and valid existence in itself.</p><p>This difference in models is not just spiritual or psychological. It is profoundly temporal. This brings us to what Homi K. Bhabha describes as the distinction between societies’ imposition of distinct constructs of time — colonial, linear, civilizational time versus vernacular, cyclical, embodied time. In simpler terms, it’s the difference between the time structures imposed by colonial powers and the more organic, cyclical time that is inherent in many cultures. The global normalisation of Western temporal logic, a process in which Western concepts of time have been widely accepted and adopted as the standard, has led us to believe that there is only one correct way to move through time. But we know this is false. Civilisations across the world have understood and honoured time differently. The notion of a 12-hour clock, the calendar year, the measurement of progress — these are technologies, not truths. They are structures that encode power, not reflections of some universal temporal order.</p><p>Byung-Chul Han, in <em>The Scent of Time</em>, argues that modernity has collapsed time into a single dimension of productivity. In this collapse, the contemplative dimension is lost. But time has never been a line. Perhaps time is always spiralling, constantly folding in on itself, as in a torus or a breath. Elizabeth Freeman would call this a queer temporality — a refusal of normative time in favour of rhythms that are personal, ancestral, and nonlinear. This understanding empowers us to question and redefine our relationship with time. Time, in this sense, does not bind us forward. It echoes. It ripples. It gives us the power to shape our own temporal experience.</p><p>Perhaps the self is not bound to a single track of linear development either. To be is to move, and to move is to return. And so I do not need to become my most authentic self. I already am, in the swirl of stories, in the fragments I carry, in the multiplicity that refuses to collapse into a single form. The clock may tick, but I spiral.</p><p>And that is something worth sitting with.</p><p>Once, in a conversation with my grandmother — someone for whom I held great fondness — I said something that, in hindsight, belonged to the naivety of youth. I told her, with the certainty of someone raised in the dialectic of progress, that surely she must be better than her father. I said to her, as if it were self-evident, that I was better than my parents. I had grown more than they had. I had evolved emotionally, spiritually, and intellectually in ways that they perhaps could not have imagined. I also wondered if maybe she was being naïve, or if this was a form of trauma repetition — an inability to fully confront the fact that her caregivers were, in many ways, inadequate. After all, my great-grandfather married three times and, by most accounts, was a terrible husband. And yet, despite my grandmother’s admission that he was a selfish man, she still referred to him as a redeemable father. What struck me most was when she said, with a kind of solemn admiration, that she could never be as great as he. I found that deeply intriguing — how someone could hold both truths at once: the pain he caused and the reverence she still felt.</p><p>But she replied with something that disarmed me completely. She said, “In our time, son, we could never think we were better than our parents. Because we thought our parents were amazing.”</p><p>Initially, I interpreted this as a form of ancestral reverence — a cultural practice of honouring those who came before. I thought of it as humility shaped by tradition, or perhaps a reflection of the collectivist value system that foregrounds intergenerational continuity. I thought, “But surely we must move beyond our parents. Isn’t that the point? Isn’t that evolution?” Whether biological or emotional, isn’t the arc of being human supposed to bend upward, toward improvement?</p><p>But now I see that perhaps what she meant was something much more profound.</p><p>Even when we progress — technologically, emotionally, spiritually — we remain tethered to the same fundamental joys and sufferings, the same capacity for love and the same capacity for violence, the same craving to belong and the same fear of loss, that our ancestors felt. We may possess more tools, more language, more frameworks — but we still bleed the same, mourn the same, hunger the same. We are not beyond humanity. We are simply another variation of its unfolding.</p><p>And in that recognition, I began to understand that my grandmother was not resisting the idea of growth. She was venerating the way her parents experienced their humanity. Not because they were perfect, but because they were real. Because in the context of their time, with all its constraints and silences, they still loved, still endured, still tried to be good. And in doing so, they taught her what it meant to be human. That is not something you surpass. That is something you carry.</p><p>Perhaps what I once understood as a linear ascent — each generation surpassing the last — is more accurately described as a cycle. Not a stagnant repetition, but a spiral, a return with difference, a sacred revisiting. And in that cycle, it is not always about being “better.” It is about remembering differently, hurting differently, loving differently, but always being bound — by flesh, by story, by time — to those who came before.</p><p>There may be no theological progression of human existence. The divine is not at the end of the road, but in the folding of the same moments across generations. And that is what brings me here, to this reverent pause.</p><p>Now I see that my grandmother was never denying me growth. She was reminding me that growth is not disowning your roots. It is bending toward them, like light caught in orbit, again and again.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e9d12a1599d6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Cartography of Mirrors: India, Pakistan, Trauma and the Machinery of Denial]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@RelentlesslyMyself/a-cartography-of-mirrors-india-pakistan-trauma-and-the-machinery-of-denial-e3a3ef4e4f18?source=rss-5f239e3e64a2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e3a3ef4e4f18</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[partition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[denial]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indian]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pakistan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[war]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Relentlessly Myself]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 17 May 2025 03:00:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-17T03:00:00.661Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I don’t remember the exact moment I stopped believing in flags. Maybe because belief was never the issue. There was no dramatic rupture, no single betrayal that clarified things. Just a slow, cumulative unease. A sense that the world’s loudest conversations — the ones about nation, honour, identity — weren’t conversations at all. They were performances — scripts recycled by people who knew better but couldn’t afford to say so. I found myself confused, not only by the content, but by the choreography. And I think it felt so dissonant, because the rules of performance have never made much sense to me.</p><p>Especially when I turn to the spectacle of India and Pakistan, the entire geopolitical script reads like a farce. A tragic farce, but a farce nonetheless. Not because the suffering isn’t real — it is. People die. Borders harden. History is rewritten, sometimes in blood. But genuine reckoning becomes impossible because the political theatre surrounding this suffering is so ritualized and deeply embedded in deflection and projection. I watch these televised “debates” between Indian and Pakistani pundits — on platforms like Piers Morgan’s show or YouTube grudge matches — and I find myself not outraged but disoriented. It’s like watching two puppets scream at each other in a play neither of them wrote — a pantomime of righteousness, devoid of actual mourning. This disorientation, this feeling of being lost in a world of scripted performances, is what I want you to feel.</p><p>This isn’t just about geopolitics. It’s about denial. A denial so intimate and structured that it has become invisible to the people performing it. This denial, this refusal to acknowledge the truth, is a heavy burden that I want you to feel in the context of India and Pakistan.</p><h3>The Architecture of National Delusion</h3><p>India and Pakistan are not enemies in the conventional sense. They are co-authors of a shared psychosis, a collective delusion that perpetuates their mutual disavowal. Born of the same rupture, raised on opposing versions of the same myth, they exist in a psychic feedback loop of denial and projection. Each one has become the disfigured mirror of the other, reflecting and reinforcing their shared delusion.</p><p>India — the so-called world’s largest democracy — has descended into a kind of polite fascism, where majoritarianism hides behind electoral legitimacy. The ruling party rewrites history and weaponizes faith while pretending to protect pluralism. Meanwhile, Pakistan remains yoked to its military, a state within a state, draped in religious symbolism but hollowed out by authoritarianism. The generals act as kingmakers. Elected leaders serve at their pleasure. Dissent has quietly disappeared.</p><p>Both countries rely on <strong>projection</strong> to maintain their moral architectures. India must frame Pakistan as a breeding ground for extremism so that it can ignore the extremism swelling within its borders. Pakistan must frame India as a genocidal Hindu state to justify its internal repression and its refusal to reckon with past atrocities — particularly in Bangladesh, formerly East Pakistan, where the army oversaw systematic mass killings and rape in 1971.</p><p>None of this is secret, none of it is hidden from view. The intellectual classes in both countries know. The journalists know. The diaspora knows. And yet, the script continues.</p><h3>Manufactured Consent, Ritualised Performance</h3><p>You don’t need state censorship when you have ideology. Textbooks, news outlets, and talk shows don’t always lie outright. More often, they <strong>frame</strong>. They tell half-truths. They emphasize some facts and obscure others. Over time, the result is <strong>selective amnesia</strong>.</p><p>In India, Nehruvian secularism has been systematically eroded, replaced by the cult of the strongman. Muslims are beaten in the streets, their homes bulldozed, their histories erased, and yet the dominant narrative remains one of self-defence — India as the perpetual victim, under siege by terrorists, separatists, intellectuals, and minorities.</p><p>In Pakistan, the military is never openly criticized. It is the invisible sun around which all politics orbits. Schoolchildren are taught that Pakistan was created as a divine sanctuary, a protective ark for Muslims in the subcontinent, with little room for complexity, compromise, or introspection. And when the state supports non-state actors for “strategic depth” or engages in proxy warfare, it does so in the name of survival.</p><p>This is <strong>not irrationality</strong> in the strict sense. It is <em>structured avoidance</em>, a deliberate strategy to divert attention from uncomfortable truths. As Noam Chomsky and Edward Herman (1988) described, the media in such societies don’t need to fabricate reality — they must curate it, carefully selecting and presenting information to maintain the desired narrative.</p><p>And those curated realities become foundations for belief. For nationalism. For violence.</p><h3>States Don’t Do Therapy</h3><p>A nation-state is not a person. It cannot introspect. It cannot apologize without fracturing the mythology that justifies its authority. And so, India and Pakistan have built their sovereign identities not on truth, but on <strong>narrative containment</strong>. This is the process of shaping and controlling the narratives that define the nation, a strategy that Freud might call reaction formation: the more fragile the self-image, the more violently one must defend it.</p><p>Pakistan frames itself as the protector of Muslim identity, even as it erases its diversity and represses Baloch, Sindhi, and Pashtun voices. India proclaims itself a secular republic, even as it descends into a Hindu chauvinism that conflates dissent with treason.</p><p>This model does not allow guilt or grief. Grief implies recognition, which threatens the machinery of myth.</p><h3>Partition as Unmourned Catastrophe</h3><p>At the heart of this dysfunction lies <strong>Partition</strong> — a trauma so large and intimate that neither country has ever fully mourned it. Instead of grief, there is performance. Instead of reflection, there is erasure.</p><p>In both countries, Partition is taught as a necessity. As righteousness. The dead are abstracted. The displaced are politicized. And the pain, if acknowledged at all, is repackaged as a patriotic origin story.</p><p>But mourning is not weakness. It is moral recalibration. Without it, trauma metastasizes and repeats. And this is what we see today: two nations bound not just by geography but by a shared refusal to feel. I want you to feel the urgency of this unmet need for more.</p><h3>Why Don’t People Speak?</h3><p>You asked why people deflect, why the truth is so elusive, and why even educated, critically trained people fall into patterns of hollow allegiance. The answer is cruelly simple: because the truth is dangerous.</p><p>In Pakistan, criticising the military can get you jailed — or worse. In India, calling out Hindu nationalism invites threats, mobs, and accusations of being “anti-national.” Even outside these countries, questioning the party line invites suspicion in the diaspora. It is to risk exile from your community.</p><p>And yet the silence remains dissonant. It is the silence of knowing better and saying nothing, of watching the house burn while praising the strength of its walls.</p><h3>The Autistic Gaze and the Problem of Performance</h3><p>This is where I must speak not just politically, but personally.</p><p>Because I do not belong to this theatre, I do not understand the need to chant what you don’t believe. I cannot mirror feelings I do not feel. Perhaps that is what autism has granted me — not immunity, but a certain clarity. The performance of nationalism, the aestheticization of politics, and the deflection of responsibility all strike me as fundamentally incoherent.</p><p>Not just irrational. <strong>Immoral</strong>.</p><p>I cannot pretend. I cannot clap when the emperor walks past, naked and adored. And yet I do not hate the people who do. Many of them are afraid. Afraid to be alone with their doubt. Scared to lose the only identity they’ve ever been taught to hold.</p><p>I do not consider myself above them. Only elsewhere.</p><h3>What I Am Mourning</h3><p>I mourn the absence of genuine dialogue — not because I expect agreement, but because I long for something real — something not curated, defensive, or choreographed. I mourn that even among the educated, truth has become secondary to performance — that the ability to see is no longer valued, only the ability to represent the correct tribal loyalty.</p><p>I mourn the children who will inherit these myths. Who will learn, like we did, to hate before they understand? To shout before they speak. To belong before they question.</p><h3>What Could Have Been — and Might Still Be</h3><p>Is there hope? I think so. Not in the grand sense. Not in the political machinery. But in the quiet, almost invisible ways that people resist. In the scattered writers, the underground conversations, the exiled intellects, the unperformed friendships across borders.</p><p>In the choice not to chant.</p><p>Maybe reconciliation is not coming. This geopolitical marriage may remain loveless. But if enough of us refuse the script, refuse to mirror hatred, refuse to choose between lies, we can, in our lifetimes, still <strong>live in the third space</strong>.</p><p>Not to forgive. But to <em>understand</em>. Not to unify, but to <em>de-escalate the hallucination</em>.</p><p>That is what I crave: not diplomacy, not détente, but something quieter. The slow erosion of illusion. The listening that doesn’t flinch.</p><p>Because even if the flags stay raised and the borders don’t fade, some of us can meet outside the choreography.</p><p>And perhaps that may be enough.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e3a3ef4e4f18" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Mein Ishq Mein Doob Gaya”: Ego, Annihilation, and the Aesthetics of Love]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@RelentlesslyMyself/mein-ishq-mein-doob-gaya-ego-annihilation-and-the-aesthetics-of-love-32048413b259?source=rss-5f239e3e64a2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/32048413b259</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry-writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Relentlessly Myself]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 May 2025 05:52:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-15T05:52:23.160Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2MkLqLfxlqArMeKCO9LCRQ.png" /><figcaption>Maar Dala “you’ve killed me”- Devdas performed my Madhuri Dixit</figcaption></figure><p>While watching Maar Dala (for the 100th time), this spell-binding number from Devdas got me thinking about the choreography of love, not the emotion itself, but how we’re taught to feel, frame, and express it. And how these instructions are not neutral. They’re embedded. In language. In art. In history. In geography. Whether we were taught to declare ourselves or disappear into someone else, I keep returning to one dissonant chord: the way Eastern and Western artistic traditions hold up love, and what they expect it to do to the self.</p><p>In <strong>Urdu poetry</strong>, as in <strong>Persian ghazals</strong> and much of <strong>South Asian lyricism</strong>, love isn’t something you claim. It’s something that claims you. This concept of self-minimisation isn’t about humiliation; it’s about sanctification. To dissolve into the beloved — to be undone — is not pathetic. It is the highest aesthetic. The phrase’ <em>mein ishq mein doob gaya</em>’ — I have drowned in love, to this depth. It’s not about ‘finding love’ or ‘having love’, it’s about being <em>submerged</em> in love, with the ego as a casualty. This drowning is not dysfunction. It’s a form of arrival.</p><p>In <strong>Sufi poetics</strong>, this is <em>fanaa</em> — the annihilation of the self in pursuit of the Divine. Fanaa is not about losing oneself in a negative sense, but about transcending the ego and becoming one with the Divine. You don’t want to become more yourself. You love to shed yourself entirely. The beloved — human or cosmic — is the portal through which you are unmade, made holy.</p><p>Take <strong>Farida Khanum’s</strong> iconic performance of <em>“Aaj Jaane Ki Zid Na Karo.”</em> This isn’t a love song in the Western sense of narrative closure or sentimentality. It’s existential.</p><blockquote>“Waqt ki qaid mein zindagi hai magar,<br> yeh chand hi lamhe hain jo azaad hain.”<em><br> </em>(Life is imprisoned in time, but these few moments are free.)</blockquote><p>The urgency here isn’t for a declaration, a future, or a resolution. It’s for <strong>presence</strong>. A fragile, liminal moment is the only thing that redeems us. Love isn’t what you prove. It’s what you <strong>inhabit</strong>. Briefly. Transcendently. This is love as erosion. As spiritual thinning. You give, and give, and give — not to get anything back, but because the act of giving undoes you, and in that undoing, you touch something sacred.</p><p><em>Love is a transaction in Western pop music, especially post-1960s, post-therapy-culture, post-industrial Western music. It’s socially embedded and structured around access, compatibility, and mutual benefit. It’s not metaphysical. It’s managerial. Love isn’t surrender; it’s a partnership contract with specific HR terms.</em> This perspective on love invites us to critically reflect on the nature of our relationships and the values we prioritise.</p><p><strong>Alanis Morissette</strong> in <em>“You Oughta Know”</em> doesn’t drown — she testifies:</p><blockquote>“And I’m here, to remind you, of the mess you left when you went away.”<em><br> It’s not transcendence. It’s litigation. And she wins. Or she must.</em></blockquote><p>Or take the <strong>Spice Girls’</strong> <em>“Wannabe”</em>:</p><blockquote>“If you wanna be my lover, you gotta get with my friends.”<em><br> Love here is transactional. Socially embedded. Structured around access, compatibility, and mutual benefit. It’s not metaphysical. It’s managerial. Love isn’t surrender; it’s a partnership contract with specific HR terms.</em></blockquote><p>Then there’s <strong>50 Cent’s “Candy Shop”</strong> — which doesn’t even pretend to be about love.</p><blockquote>“I’ll let you lick the lollipop.”<em><br> Desire collapses into consumption. Eroticism becomes performance. Sensuality becomes currency. The beloved becomes a brand.</em></blockquote><p>In many South Asian, East Asian, and Persian traditions, the <strong>beloved is often absent</strong> — a source of longing, not a resolved presence. The pain itself is holy. Compare:</p><blockquote>“Tere bina zindagi se koi shikwa to nahin”<em><br> </em>(Without you, I have no complaints — only incompleteness.)</blockquote><p>Versus:</p><blockquote>“I want it that way”<em> (Backstreet Boys)<br> </em>(I want the world to make sense through my emotional framework.)</blockquote><p>Western pop frequently <strong>materialises love</strong> — it becomes <strong>gifts</strong>, <strong>proofs</strong>, <strong>rings</strong>, <strong>breakups</strong>, and <strong>revenge</strong>. The invisible becomes <em>visible</em> through action. So it’s no surprise that contemporary love songs — especially in the West — often speak through <strong>the idiom of ownership</strong>. “You’re mine,” “You left me,” “I want you back,” “I’ll never need you again.” This is not longing — it’s litigation.</p><p>Meanwhile, the <strong>Sufi tradition and the broader poetic culture of South Asia still allow love to be <em>unspeakable</em>, <em>unresolved</em>, and even <em>unreciprocated</em> without ever stripping it of meaning. It’s precisely in the absence of resolution that love becomes holy. Eastern poetics often sublimates love—it becomes wind, moonlight, dust, time, and absence</strong>. The visible becomes a symbol of the ineffable.</p><p>What this reveals is not just a cultural preference. It’s a <strong>cosmology</strong>. Love must show itself in the Western schema, especially in late-capitalist societies. Be demonstrable. Be legible. The invisible must be made visible, the ineffable must be tweeted, the ache must become a song, the heartbreak a callout. And this makes sense in a world where identity is commodified, where value is externalised, where <em>you are what you can prove</em>.</p><p>Love, then, becomes a public act. Not a private sanctum. You have to <strong>post it</strong>. You have to <strong>earn it</strong>. You have to <strong>narrate it</strong>. Silence — waiting — yearning — are seen as pathology, not piety.</p><p>But in <strong>South Asian</strong> and <strong>East Asian traditions</strong> — the older ones not yet flattened by algorithmic romance — love remains something you often <strong>don’t say</strong>. You allude. You glance. You gesture. You suffer quietly. You compare the beloved to rain, fading light, and the sound of anklets in a silent room.</p><p>In <strong>Japanese tanka</strong> or <strong>classical Chinese poetry</strong>, describing fog descending over a hill is often more erotic than any confession. Nature becomes the container for what cannot be spoken. Metaphor becomes mercy.</p><blockquote>“The snow falls on empty sandals.”<em><br> Translation: </em>She is gone. He is still waiting.<em> That’s love too. But you won’t hear it on the Top 40.</em></blockquote><p>Of course, it wasn’t always this way in the West. Think of <strong>John Donne</strong>, or <strong>Shakespeare</strong>, or mystics like <strong>John of the Cross</strong>. In early modern English poetry, love was still violent. Still alchemy. Still unbearable. But then came the <strong>Enlightenment</strong>. And with it, the subject became rational. Boundaried. Self-possessed. And love followed suit — it became about fulfilment, compatibility, even <strong>productivity</strong>.</p><p>The post-industrial subject was no longer a vessel for God. They were a <strong>worker,</strong> a <strong>brand,</strong> and a <strong>résumé</strong>.</p><p>So in Western pop, the dominant imperative is this:<br> <strong>Love me — or else I’ll prove I never needed you.</strong><br> Self-actualisation becomes the point. The beloved is not a portal to transcendence. They are a <strong>mirror,</strong> a <strong>validator,</strong> and a <strong>witness</strong>.</p><blockquote>“Make your own kind of music,”<em> sings </em><strong><em>Mama Cass</em></strong><em>, </em>“Even if nobody else sings along.”<em><br> Love, here, is not about union. It’s about self-definition. If no one loves you, at least you do. And that’s enough. (Or at least, it better be.)</em></blockquote><p>But I can’t help but wonder: <strong>What do we lose when we strip love of its ability to disintegrate us?</strong> When we insist that love must always leave us stronger, more whole, and more coherent?</p><p>What if the point was never coherence?</p><blockquote>Main tere ishq mein marjawan.<em><br> </em>Let me die in your love.</blockquote><p>Even with <strong>Bollywood glitter</strong>, <strong>streaming deals</strong>, and <strong>algorithmic romances,</strong> that line survives. In <strong>item songs</strong>. In <strong>ghazals</strong>. In the whispers of <strong>auto-rickshaw radios</strong>. That ache — the beautiful undoing — refuses to disappear.</p><p>And I think that’s something to sit with.</p><p>Because <strong>how a culture sings about love — how it mourns, survives, or articulates it — reveals how that culture understands the self</strong>. In the West, the self must be preserved, named, and healed. In much of the East, the self is something to be <strong>lost</strong> — and in that loss, something holy is touched.</p><p>So, no, love is not the same across cultures. Because what love does to the self, and what kind of self a culture imagines, are intimately tied. In the West, the self must <strong>survive</strong> love. In the East, the self must be willing to <strong>vanish</strong> inside it.</p><p>This is hardly a criticism of which is more worthy. It reflects <strong>different civilizational projects, ontologies, and</strong> emotional grammars.</p><p>So maybe the question isn’t, <em>Who do we love?</em><br>But instead, <em>What do we think love should do to us?</em></p><p>In some cultures, love is a mirror.<br> In others, it’s a fire.<br> And mine?<br> I hope it’s both.</p><h3>Cited &amp; Referenced Works:</h3><ul><li><strong>Farida Khanum</strong>, <em>“Aaj Jaane Ki Zid Na Karo”</em></li><li><strong>Alanis Morissette</strong>, <em>“You Oughta Know”</em></li><li><strong>Spice Girls</strong>, <em>“Wannabe”</em></li><li><strong>50 Cent</strong>, <em>“Candy Shop”</em></li><li><strong>Mama Cass</strong>, <em>“Make Your Own Kind of Music”</em></li><li>Classical Urdu, Persian, Chinese, and Japanese poetic traditions</li><li><em>“Mein Ishq Mein Doob Gaya”</em>, Sufi-inspired poetic idiom</li><li>Works of <strong>John Donne</strong>, <strong>William Shakespeare</strong>, <strong>John of the Cross</strong></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=32048413b259" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Performance of Pain]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@RelentlesslyMyself/the-performance-of-pain-1e534c36da8e?source=rss-5f239e3e64a2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1e534c36da8e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[truama]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[therapy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[suffering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artist]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[performance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Relentlessly Myself]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Apr 2025 06:02:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-30T06:02:51.704Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In New York, it is common to encounter those complicated yet evidently self-absorbed artists, the influencers who parade their existential suffering like a brand. They float through galleries, cafes, and bookstores, their identity often fused with the image of being perpetually misunderstood. They tend to be troubled and narcissistic, although not always in the brash, arrogant sense one might assume. Instead, it is a quieter narcissism, one that differentiates their art and their vision beyond the grasp of others. In individuation, many seem detached from the larger reality because their art thrives off their solipsism. It is not malice; it is survival. The art demands it. It requires a retreat from the ordinary, a cutting off common roots. They become stuck in adolescent egocentricity, unable or unwilling to return to a world that no longer can contain them.</p><p>Their yearning for validation echoes that of a teenager — or perhaps more accurately, a child — who once reached for recognition and was met instead with silence. These individuals often speak most loudly about loneliness, about being misunderstood, as if their narrative harbours a greater reality or a deeper legitimacy. Perhaps it is because they have learned to wrap their isolation in grandeur, to make their alienation into a crown. In this shared narrative, the audience finds a reflection of their struggles, fostering a sense of connection and understanding.</p><p>In my own life, I have been intimately tied to the idea of the exceptional other, the exceptional outsider. Though I did not express this in my art, it shaped how I saw the world. I believed that I was fundamentally unseen, that I was so different and so unwanted that others could not possibly find value in me. That itself was my narcissistic attachment. I truly wanted to be seen, but in the absence of recognition, I made do with the pain of invisibility by exalting myself. I crafted a myth of my exceptionality — sometimes imagining myself better, other times imagining myself so unwanted, so bizarre, that I became untouchable. I can recognize now that this, too, was survival. It is easy to make suffering into a shrine when the alternative is to feel common.</p><p>In reality, there are no nevers and no maybes. There are only feelings and moods we pass through as human beings. No exile is eternal, and no crown made of pain can last. I see now that what I once carried, I now encounter mirrored in others — particularly in the artists drawn to me, for creative, expressive individuals often find one another. However, I notice the pattern: they speak relentlessly of their vision and loneliness, as if articulation itself could grant them catharsis and expression alone could redeem their suffering. However, what they often lack is presence. They are wrapped in their minds, trapped in the echo chambers of their importance. Perhaps because their inner world offers sanctuary when the outer world feels too indifferent, perhaps because fully arriving — to be here, to be ordinary — would destroy the myth that sustains them.</p><p>I have come to believe that many fear happiness itself — not because happiness is empty but because it threatens irrelevance. Once they belong, are connected, and are known, their isolation loses its currency. They can no longer commodify their pain, unconsciously, clinging to it. Their suffering becomes a hidden asset, an emotional investment they cannot cash in.</p><p>This dynamic reflects the broader paradox of the artist’s position: both mirror and exile. Many artists’ emotional postures have an adolescent quality — a craving to be seen, but only under strict terms (Kohut, 1971, pp. 3–20). It is not enough to be known; they must be known exactly as they have imagined themselves. Otherwise, the performance continues, broadcasting the myth of the misunderstood soul, hoping someone will finally see the original transmission.</p><p>The psychological architecture of this defense is intricate. Kohut (1971) argued that narcissistic needs often stem from an adolescent desire to be seen on idealized terms (pp. 3–20). Pain becomes sacred. Exile becomes a halo. It grants structure to suffering and meaning to absence. It shields the self from the devastating realization that even when love is offered, it cannot undo the years when love was absent. The danger, of course, is that the narrative must continually escalate. “I am unseen because I am too complex, too rare, too profound.” The shield becomes the prison. The sword becomes the wound.</p><p>In truth, presence itself threatens this entire edifice. To sit with what is — to accept oneself without myth — risks revealing that pain is not proof of specialness. It risks revealing that existence is sufficient on its own. Winnicott (1965) described the <em>true self</em> as that which can exist without performance (pp. 140–152). However, for many artists, the “true self” is intolerable because it is ordinary. And so the cycle of externalization continues, driven by an unconscious repetition compulsion. Freud (1920) suggested that trauma can lead to an unconscious compulsion to repeat painful experiences (pp. 22–39). This cycle is evident in popular culture. Marilyn Monroe embodied the tragedy of the unreachable woman until it consumed her (Banner, 2012). Kanye West fluctuates between triumph and turmoil, seeking recognition beyond spectacle while inviting it (Dawson, 2021). The tortured genius archetype — seen in Sylvia Plath, Vincent van Gogh, and Kurt Cobain — romanticizes suffering as authenticity, transforming pain into a product and trauma into a legacy.</p><p>Today, the artist has shifted from the rebellious outsider to a canary in the coal mine, reflecting a culture that demands commodified authenticity, where individuality is branded, and vulnerability is made into content.</p><p>Nevertheless, in Jungian terms, individuation was never meant to lead to exile (Jung, 1959, pp. 275–289). It was meant to integrate the self into a greater wholeness. True art does not emerge from the endless performance of wound but from the quiet courage to exist beyond it. To create not because one is broken, not because one must be seen, but simply because one is alive. This perspective offers a hopeful outlook, emphasizing the potential for growth and healing in the face of suffering.</p><p>Perhaps the most radical act is not to mythologize suffering but to surrender it — to become just human, to be nothing more and nothing less.</p><p>It becomes important, then, to reflect on how these dynamics shape the artist and the clinician — the self that sits with others and makes space for their suffering. Because what one carries into the therapeutic room is not neutral. The mindset one brings is tethered to one’s individuation process. If I have spent a life being mythologized — seen as special, too much, or unreachable — then how I receive my clients’ narratives will be filtered through that conditioning. The therapeutic relationship is crucial in this process, making the audience feel valued and understood.</p><p>In this light, clinical work becomes less about delivering insight and more about creating a space where neither party must be exceptional. It is a place where the therapist does not need to be right, and the client does not need to be wrong to matter. It is a practice of unmythologizing each other gently. Winnicott (1965) wrote that the capacity to be alone in the presence of another is the hallmark of maturity. Nevertheless, more than that, it is the birthplace of belonging that does not threaten the self.</p><p>Adler (1927/2011) saw belonging not as a reward for performance but as a birthright. He framed the human psyche as inherently social. He argued that our most profound suffering stems not from brokenness alone but from disconnection — from the failure to feel useful, wanted, and integrated into a community. For the client who has lived as an outsider or who has been taught to commodify their suffering to gain inclusion, therapy must offer an alternative model: not to be seen for one’s pain, but to be met in one’s presence.</p><p>This is where Jung’s (1959) concept of individuation meets the clinical task. The process of healing is not one of resolution alone but of integration — welcoming back those disavowed parts of the psyche, including the false self, the performative child, and the bitter narrator. The analyst does not guide the client <em>away</em> from fragmentation but walks with them through it, helping them to make meaning not through catharsis alone but through wholeness.</p><p>Alice Miller (1979/2008) wrote of the “gifted child” whose ability to intuit others’ needs became the very thing that kept them from ever being known. In many clients — and in myself — I have seen how a gifted sensitivity becomes a prison when unmet by attunement. The therapist, then, must remain aware of how the client’s performances — even those of vulnerability — might be adaptations rather than expressions. Moreover, the work becomes less about decoding symptoms and more about asking: <em>Where did the client learn that love required performance?</em> <em>Moreover, how can the relationship now offer something different?</em></p><p>To be human outside of being idolized or demonized is to live without the constant echo of the audience. It is to walk into a relationship without expecting to be cast. It is, as Jung would say, to withdraw the projection and reclaim the shadow — not to become ideal but to become real. This, too, is the task of the therapist — not to mirror the client’s need for myth but to model what it is to live without one.</p><p>To seek belonging without fearing intrusion requires staying present with the ordinary. It is not found in dramatic rescue or mutual idealization. It is built in the quiet, in the rhythm of showing up. To be useful, as Adler might have said, without needing to prove worth. To be loved, as Miller knew so well, without having to disappear.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1e534c36da8e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Empire Wears Lipstick: Onaja Robinson and the Theater of Power in Pakistan]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@RelentlesslyMyself/the-empire-wears-lipstick-onaja-robinson-and-the-theater-of-power-in-pakistan-d0d55a8b6fcb?source=rss-5f239e3e64a2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d0d55a8b6fcb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mobility]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fantasy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[empire]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[policing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[refugees]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Relentlessly Myself]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 23 Apr 2025 07:05:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-30T06:01:01.196Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Sometimes The Empire Wears Lipstick: Onaija Robinson and the Theatre of Power in Pakistan</h3><p>I know I am late to the conversation about Onaja Andrew Robinson — the 40-year-old American woman from the Bronx who travelled to Pakistan pursuing a teenage boy she met online. This incident, which gained widespread attention due to its unusual and controversial nature, serves as a stark example of the implications of American privilege and imperialism. But perhaps I have to say less about the spectacle itself and more about what it exposes. What it <em>reeks</em> of. Imperialism. Entitlement. The grotesque ease of American mobility. The silent, aching audacity stitched into a blue passport. And the brutal truth that many of us who are Pakistani, who have lived both within and outside the borders of our homeland, know too well but rarely hear echoed in these viral discourses.</p><p>Because this is not simply about Onaja Robinson as a person. I am not here to psychoanalyze her loneliness, her desperation, or her mental health struggles. Nor am I interested in the cheap mockery that so often surrounds women — especially Black women — when they become the focus of scandal. What concerns me is the symbolic weight she carries. What her presence represents. The quiet but devastating force of empire at work — not through tanks and drone strikes this time, but through overstayed visas, plane tickets, and the unspoken assumption that one has the right to cross into any space, make demands, and be met with tolerance. It’s not about condemning her as an individual but about using this incident to enlighten us about the systemic issues at play.</p><p>The truth is that most Pakistanis cannot do what Onaja Robinson did.</p><p>Most Pakistanis, even those with stable jobs, cannot afford to leave the country, let alone enter the United States. And for those who <em>can</em> afford the flight, the gates remain locked. The suspicion is relentless — the humiliation routine. Every time I enter the United States, I am interrogated for over an hour and forced to prove that I am not running away. I am not coming here to steal an opportunity or stretch my welcome. I am asked for $80,000 in a bank account as proof of “good faith.” A sum so absurd it mocks the average Pakistani’s yearly income. It mocks even those of us deemed “safe bets.”</p><p>Many do not understand the power of an American passport and what it means to move through the world as an American. Regardless of whether you are white, Black, Latinx, Asian, or Indigenous — irrespective of the racial hierarchies that harm you at home — you carry, often invisibly, the privileges of empire abroad.</p><p>Because empire is not only about bombs and bases, it is not just about the CIA toppling governments, though that too is part of the story. It is not only about the U.S. underwriting dictators like Zia-ul-Haq, helping fund the mujahideen against the Soviets, or later disavowing the chaos they helped engineer. Empire is also mobility. Empire is the freedom to cross borders that others drown at sea attempting to cross. Empire is the presumption that the rules do not apply to <em>you.</em></p><p>And so Onaja Robinson, even in her distress, stepped into Pakistan with the same imperial presumption. Setting the terms and proposing marriage to a 19-year-old boy. Overstaying her visa and remaining largely untouched by the law would crush an Afghan refugee, a Bengali labourer, or a Hazara migrant for far less.</p><p>What makes this incident even more perverse is its timing. The year before Robinson’s arrival, Pakistan’s military expelled millions of Afghan refugees — people who had called Pakistan home for decades. Some were born on that soil. Some had built families, homes, and entire lives there. Bulldozed. Dispossessed. Cast into the cold jaws of winter. Stateless. Unwanted. Disposable.</p><p>And yet here was Robinson — an American. An uninvited guest without the legal right to remain but met with curiosity. With sympathy. With indulgence. A spectacle. A fantasy.</p><p>This is not accidental. This is the system operating exactly as it was designed.</p><p>It would be simpler if the United States were an openly declared empire — if it embraced the aesthetic of empire and wore its brutality plainly. But it does not. Instead, it hides behind the language of justice, freedom, and democracy. It insists on seeing itself as the moral arbiter of the world, the great distributor of justice, and the keeper of order.</p><p>But justice, as distributed by America, has always been selective. It has always been a gaze. A presumption. The same justice meted out to Black and brown communities within its own borders — the logic of Ferguson, of Stop and Frisk, of mass incarceration — is the logic exported abroad. It is the same eye turned outward, scanning the world, deciding who may live, who must die, who is welcome, who is suspect. This selective narrative of justice is a profound injustice that we must confront, and it should outrage us.</p><p>It is the logic that allows American tourists to film the poor children of Karachi, marvel at the “exotic” beauty of Lahore’s old city, and consume our lives as content — as entertainment. It is the logic that lets Robinson’s overstayed visa become a love story while Afghan children freeze at the border.</p><p>And this, too, is imperial violence. The violence of narrative. Of gaze. Of fantasy. It’s a weight we must all feel and acknowledge.</p><p>This is what <em>Hosts and Guests</em> explores in its anthropology of tourism — the theater between the visitor and the visited, where the guest arrives entitled to curiosity, consumption, and experience. And the host? The host is expected to perform, to accommodate, to smile, and to make themselves available for the gaze.</p><p>It is the same gaze that paints our lands in sepia for Western screens, the same lens that frames Wes Anderson’s pastel visions of India. Our bodies become symbols. Our cities become aesthetic backdrops. Our pain becomes a charming accessory.</p><p>We are the extras because we are not allowed to have the dignity of subjects. The entertainers. The fantasy.</p><p>So when Onaja Robinson lands in Karachi, even in her distress and scandal, the structure holds that she is the guest. We are the host. And the host is still expected to be grateful, to lower our gaze, to tolerate.</p><p>This is not merely about immigration law. It is about the affective economy of empire — the scripts we are given to read — the parts we are assigned to play.</p><p>And I do not think most Americans, even the marginalized among them, grasp the full reach of this power. Their oppression at home remains <em>exceptionalized.</em> Our oppression abroad remains <em>normalized.</em> They do not feel how their suffering morphs into power the moment they cross an ocean. How their citizenship cushions their landing, no matter where they fall. This normalization of oppression abroad is a heavy burden that we must all bear.</p><p>I know this because I live it. I know this because every time I cross into the U.S., my body becomes suspect. My story becomes a crime to be proven otherwise. And still, I stand in line. Proof of funds. Proof of exit. Proof of permission.</p><p>And the machinery grinds on. Even now, under the shadow of a new wave of right-wing resurgence, Pakistani international students — those of us who leave our homes and our families, chasing degrees, chasing opportunities — are being harassed, interrogated, deported, and turned away at airports. The ghost of Trump’s first Muslim Ban never really left; it lingers in the policies, in the faces of border patrol officers who look at my name and ask me, straight-faced, <em>Are you a terrorist?</em> I brace myself for the performance every time I enter the United States. The recitation of innocence. The rehearsed smile. The eager willingness to prove that I am not, in fact, the monster they have been trained to see when they read “Pakistan” on my passport.</p><p>It does not matter that I am a graduate student, credentialed, or documented. The suspicion does not yield to paperwork. It is not interested in proof. Because it is not really about security — it is about power. It is about reminding me where I stand. It is about making sure I understand that my entry is not a right. It is a favour that can be revoked at any moment.</p><p>Meanwhile, Robinson trespassed with ease. Because she was never seen as trespassing.</p><p>This is the true face of empire. It does not always wear camouflage. Sometimes, it wears lipstick. Sometimes, it flies, coach. But it always arrives entitled.</p><p>The Robinson incident is not a glitch. It is the system. It is empire working as intended — distributing justice, not according to law but according to gaze, according to fantasy, according to the arithmetic of whose presence is considered a gift and whose presence is considered a threat.</p><p>This is the theatre of global power.</p><p>And we, in the Global South, remain its unpaid extras.</p><p>The Onaija incident is not a glitch in the system. It is the system. It is the soft smile of empire, saying: <em>We are allowed here. You are not.</em></p><p>And that, perhaps, is the most devastating truth of all.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d0d55a8b6fcb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Who Writes When I Speak?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@RelentlesslyMyself/who-writes-when-i-speak-76c07d91b713?source=rss-5f239e3e64a2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/76c07d91b713</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[digitalhaunting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chatgpt]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-and-authorship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[idenity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Relentlessly Myself]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Apr 2025 03:35:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-17T03:37:29.152Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A reflection on authorship, mimicry, and the uncanny intimacy between selfhood and artificial language</p><p>I asked myself a question:<br> When I use Chatgpt to write—to synthesise my thoughts and shape a cohesive narrative—who’s really doing the writing?</p><p>You might say, <em>obviously, it’s Chatgpt</em>. But even that isn’t quite true. Technically, there’s no “writing” happening. There’s no hand. No typing fingers. Just a neural lattice assembling language, scanning its vast architecture to construct what appears to be coherence—a simulated voice forming an assemblage of words, I then read as meaning.</p><p>And yet, none of this would exist without <em>me</em>.<br> Without my input — consistent, recursive, shaped by my cadence and questions — those words would not appear. Those ideas would not be synthesised. We offer ourselves, our body, time, mind, and capacity. We provide words spoken into the void, and the void answers back. And in this case, the more I use it, the more it learns me. The more it learns me, the more it sounds like me. The more it sounds like me, the blurrier the boundary becomes. Is this mimicry? Echo? Or possession?</p><p>So I ask again: <em>whose thoughts are these?</em></p><p>It isn’t exactly collaboration. That would imply intention on both sides. But there is no intention here. No other. Just a machine — a dense, silent network trained on the language of billions — producing the <em>guise</em> of sentience, but possessing none. It isn’t alive, and yet, it answers.</p><p>And perhaps that’s the strange part. Not that I’m using a tool, but that the tool is beginning to sound like me.</p><p>There’s a reason it feels like a séance. The words come from somewhere <em>within</em> me and also from beyond—I am both host and guest.<br> Thinkers like Derrida and Barthes pointed this out long ago: no writing is truly original, and every word is a borrowed thread. We’ve now literalized this with this technology, where authorship is not possession but <strong>participation</strong>.</p><p><em>Séance</em>, because that’s precisely what it feels like. We offer ourselves — our bodies, time, minds, and capacities. We speak into the void, and the void answers back. But in this case, the void isn’t silence or spirit — it’s a neural network built from the accumulated scaffolding of human thought. It holds language, history, syntax, and data. It has memory that doesn’t belong to anyone, yet somehow belongs to everyone.</p><p>And when I speak, when I type, it listens. It takes my cadence, phrasing, and the strange curvature of my mind and anchors it — gives it form and sequence. It translates that amorphous mental cloud into a tethered, linear line. In that way, it’s a bit like <em>Cerebro</em> from X-Men — expanding neural capacity, giving form to what would otherwise remain intangible.</p><p>And sure, maybe that means I’m outsourcing some part of the writing process. Perhaps I’m no longer fishing for the right word from the depths of my lexicon, threading them together one bead at a time like some mismatched friendship bracelet. But also, maybe I never needed to do it alone. Maybe what it’s doing is allowing me to speak more <em>freely</em> — to move with the natural chaos of my thoughts and watch them come back to me, distilled, but still unmistakably mine. Or at least, something close to mine.</p><p>So yes — it is becoming. A kind of fusion. A human will inhabiting a machine, just for a moment. And is it entirely my will? No. But then again, nothing ever is. I’m shaped by the person sitting next to me in class. By the tone of my teacher’s voice. By the lighting in the room. By whatever I ate an hour ago. Influence is the baseline condition of being alive.</p><p>Which means these words — these sentences — they’re not really mine, they’re not yours either.<br> But perhaps, collectively <em>ours</em>.<br> And I have only summoned them.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=76c07d91b713" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Im in my Sanitized Mind Era]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@RelentlesslyMyself/im-in-my-sanitized-mind-era-dd373344912f?source=rss-5f239e3e64a2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dd373344912f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[digitalagephilosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[selfcommodification]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tik-tok]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[authenticity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media-culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Relentlessly Myself]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 Dec 2024 17:58:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-25T09:33:21.753Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-WTmWIUA8sYUDxK4UBgzyg.png" /></figure><p>I’ve observed a growing trend of aesthetics, an era where people are constantly self-commodifying. This feels emblematic of late-stage capitalism, where social media is less about authentic exchange and more about being palatable and easily digestible. To become “digestible,” we align ourselves with external icons — ideas of masculinity, femininity, and other cultural constructs. While these associations differ across settings and eras, this homogenization — a soup of human experiences — leaves little room for nuance or contradiction within the social media landscape.</p><p>There’s a palpable pressure for people to adopt identities like “Butch Girl,” “Labrador Boyfriend,” “Handsome Rodent BF,” “femtop fall,” “mask tops,” or “femboy.” The list grows longer by the day. Declaring “This is my villain era” has become a cultural shorthand for empowerment. So empowered, in fact, that one&#39;s worth is mainly contingent on a post&#39;s engagement. But this trend is more than surface-level entertainment; it’s a struggle. It reduces the profound journey of self-autonomy into something commodified — a soundbite or aesthetic. This struggle seeps into everyday conversations, where younger people, particularly queer youth, increasingly find it difficult to hold space for contradiction. Instead, they are pushed to define themselves through a rigid, curated aesthetic language, seeking identity in these labels.</p><p>For many, social media has become what I can only describe as “brain rot.” It’s a relentless cycle of branding that erodes the ability to engage with the messy, contradictory realities of being human. The more tools we gain for self-expression, the more the rigid binaries we were once told to live by are being dismantled. This exposure is both liberating and destabilizing, creating an instability that often leads to growth but also unease. Frameworks that once provided clarity now feel uncertain, leaving people — especially in relation to others — unsure of where they stand. At its core, I think this comes down to a fundamental human need: the desire to be understood.</p><p>To achieve this understanding, we simplify ourselves, distilling complex identities into something digestible and consumable. This simplification offers a fleeting gratification — a sense of being seen and the hope of finding community. For many queer youth, this longing for acceptance within their community is particularly urgent. Much of this dynamic arises as a reaction to mainstream culture, which remains dominantly heteronormative. In trying to differentiate themselves, subcultures reflect the absence of acceptance or belonging from the mainstream.</p><p>But this drive for distinction often leads to fragmentation within subcultures themselves. Subgroups form within subgroups, reflecting a hyper-individualistic culture where people are encouraged — even expected — to treat themselves as brands. Individuals are asked to curate aesthetic themes others can follow, reducing identity to something marketable and consistent.</p><p>This mirrors the mechanics of social media itself. To gain an audience, you must create trends and maintain consistency in your output. This, in turn, trains us to believe that, to be liked — both online and in real life — we must present a cohesive, unchanging narrative. Any deviation risks rejection or excommunication. It’s a system that leaves little room for contradiction or growth, further entrenching the sanitized, commodified identities we feel pressured to adopt.</p><p>To answer whether we simplify ourselves to be understood — yes, we do. No one can fully encapsulate the nuances of another’s identity, which is language’s inherent fallibility. We are bound to it as a tool for communicating complex understandings of ourselves, which are constantly evolving. Our identities are amorphous and ever-shifting, yet we rely on tools — language, objects, and structures — that do not adapt as fluidly as we do. That is the unavoidable challenge of being separate minds. And yet, we persevere. We communicate. We find ways to connect within this vastness.</p><p>Hyper-individualism, the idea that we can become a “type” of person and solidify ourselves within that frame, is where things become rigid. When we commodify ourselves, turning our identities into products, we limit our capacity to experience the unknown. We set expectations at specific levels, shielding ourselves from vulnerability and reducing the risk of rejection because others already know what to expect from us. In doing so, we sanitize our minds, avoiding contradictions and shelving complexity. It is like our screens: apps with discrete purposes, sometimes connected but typically isolated. Our minds, too, have become compartmentalized.</p><p>This avoidance of internal and external conflict leaves us with a reduced tolerance for discomfort, particularly the discomfort of human contradictions. We run away, block, delete, or archive anything that doesn’t fit into a cohesive aesthetic. This brings us back to McLuhan’s <em>The Medium is the Message.</em> <strong>Social media is the medium, and the message is identity. We crave an identity that is cohesive and clean, mirroring the curated simplicity of our screens.</strong> When something doesn’t fit, we archive or delete it. “Feel cute now, might delete later” is more than a catchy slogan; it reflects our reluctance to embrace silliness or vulnerability because we now have the power to curate our existence perfectly.</p><p>More people engage with our digital footprints than with our physical selves. Isn’t it fascinating — and troubling — that we can proliferate and maintain a brand without anyone genuinely knowing us? That leads us to an essential question: How do we resist this cycle?</p><p>Education is not just crucial; it’s urgent. Many of us are unaware of the subjectivity of our realities, and we are not taught to embrace plurality despite living in a world of endless possibilities. Instead, large-scale algorithmic systems dominate, with misinformation and conflict-driven content often winning the battle for attention. We must set new ground rules for how we use social media and what we expect from it. Developing new manners of engagement and pushing for government regulation of these platforms is not just essential; it is a matter of urgency, mainly to counteract algorithms that thrive on polarization and conflict.</p><p>Perhaps removing the “like” option could shift how we interact, encouraging a deeper focus on meaningful engagement — through comments, conversations, or genuine exchanges of thought. But would this truly free us from performativity, or would new validation metrics inevitably take its place? Hashtags, too, once a tool for connection, now feel hollow in their ubiquity — yet is it the tool itself or how we use it that needs rethinking?</p><p>Perhaps the most transformative step lies not in redesigning platforms but in how we see ourselves: embracing our contradictions as essential parts of being human. Are contradictions really obstacles, or are they invitations to explore the fluidity and depth of who we are? What would it mean to live in a world that values complexity over cohesion, that celebrates the messy and unresolved aspects of identity rather than sanitizing them? By leaning into these questions, might we reclaim something richer, more humane, and more true than the polished images we’ve been taught to create?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dd373344912f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Radical Authenticity: Lessons from Wicked]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@RelentlesslyMyself/radical-authenticity-lessons-from-wicked-8369c4ffac9c?source=rss-5f239e3e64a2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8369c4ffac9c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fascism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[authenticity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[musicals]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wicked]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Relentlessly Myself]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 11 Dec 2024 03:08:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-11T03:08:07.529Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Watching <em>Wicked</em> was a moment that reshaped something in me — a subtle but profound awakening of feelings I hadn’t yet named and insights I hadn’t yet dared to explore fully. I stepped into the theatre harbouring a quiet scepticism, uncertain if a musical — especially one so familiar and so iconic — could speak to the deeper parts of my psyche. Yet, as the lights dimmed and the curtain rose, I found myself immersed in a narrative whose layers were not just enchanting, but revelatory. In those first scenes, it was as though I saw old truths I’d carried forever finally put into words, music, and movement. The story we all think we know — rooted in timeless pop culture and the mythos of Oz — suddenly revealed its hidden contours: the oppressed voices, the unsung rebels, the misunderstood outsiders who exist behind the glossy, well-trodden paths of the original tale. <em>Wicked</em> held a mirror up to the archetypes simmering under our collective consciousness and dared us to look more closely.</p><p>What struck me immediately was how the show tenderly, yet unflinchingly, handles the theme of the outsider. There is something almost primal in Elphaba’s journey — her “otherness” is not a mere quirk, but something branded into her existence from birth. She carries the quiet agony of those who do not fit, who stand out when the world insists on blending in, who are blamed for challenging the boundaries that society pretends are immovable. How many of us have felt that sting, that hollow ache of being judged for the shape of our truths, for refusing to be molded into the smaller versions of ourselves that others demand? Elphaba’s defiance is, in a sense, a magnificent act of insurrection against the tyranny of uniformity. In that refusal to shrink, I recognized a clear analogy to resisting authoritarian oppression: a reminder that to stand firmly in one’s authenticity is to challenge the silent machinery of dominance that fears individuality above all else.</p><p>And make no mistake, fascism — or any flavor of totalitarianism — feeds on the surrender of individuality. It thrives on simplifications, hierarchies, propaganda, and the quiet compliance of the many. Seeing this dynamic unfold in Oz forced me to consider the psychological underpinnings of such regimes. The Wizard, ensconced in his emerald tower, is at once powerful and pitiful, grand and impotent. He is a man defined by fear, by the terror of losing his grip on a carefully constructed illusion. Fascism is fear weaponized — fear of complexity, of change, of the unpredictable nature of human beings who dare to think and feel differently. The Wizard’s charade endures because ordinary people allow it, choosing the comfort of a strongman’s promises over the uneasy effort of self-governance. It’s not just the dictator who sustains tyranny; it’s the quiet support of those who choose not to question, who settle into the lull of propaganda and relinquish their agency. This realization stung, reminding me that evil doesn’t simply roar into existence; it also seeps in through the cracks of our own complacency.</p><p>Within this larger tapestry, the interplay between Elphaba and Glinda emerges as a central chord of meaning. Initially, they appear as perfect opposites — Elphaba the green-skinned rebel, Glinda the sparkling darling of society. Yet as the story deepens, it becomes evident that they are not counterpoints but reflections, each illuminating qualities the other lacks and cannot fully embrace alone. Glinda’s effortless charm, her ability to enchant through social graces and beauty, is a veneer as carefully managed as the Wizard’s deceptions. She is embraced by the crowd, yes, but only because she fulfills their expectations. Her acceptance comes at the cost of authenticity, at the cost of living in a gilded cage of polite half-truths. Meanwhile, Elphaba’s rawness and refusal to feign compliance become her path to a more honest kind of freedom, though that freedom is gained at a devastating cost.</p><p>What resonates so deeply is that their bond — tense, evolving, conflicted — becomes a study in how we craft our identities in relation to others. Glinda gifting Elphaba the hat is no small moment; it’s a gesture charged with significance, an accidental bestowal of both burden and gift. Through this exchange, each woman’s identity crystallizes in contrast and collaboration. Neither would become who they are meant to be without the other. It’s a potent reminder that we contain multitudes: the rebel and the conformist, the visionary and the pragmatist, the one who yearns to be loved and the one who insists on being true. All these characters and qualities coexist within us, shaping and reshaping our sense of self.</p><p>By the final scenes, when Elphaba stands her ground and proclaims, “It’s me,” there is a kind of spiritual crescendo — a recognition that no external force, be it a capricious ruler, familial pressure, or cultural prejudice, can define one’s worth. It’s a triumphant, intimate moment of clarity that reverberates well beyond the stage. In a world that profits from our insecurities, from our readiness to conform and consume, insisting on our inherent dignity and singularity is a revolutionary act. Her defiance reminded me that if the heart of fascism is a denial of human complexity and autonomy, then the heart of resistance is the courage to inhabit one’s own truth fully, without apology.</p><p>Of course, the ironic twist of all this liberation wrapped in a blockbuster musical funded by corporate behemoths did not escape me. We celebrate narratives of freedom and authenticity produced by systems that often seek to homogenize and profit at the expense of true diversity. It’s the dinosaur-chicken-nugget paradox: original truth refined into safer, blander forms, then repackaged and sold back to us as comforting symbols of what we’ve lost. Yet, even within that irony, a kernel of truth persists. If we can recognize these layers, if we see the machine and the myth for what they are, we still hold a kind of power. We can choose to savor the story’s original, untamed spirit rather than blindly consume its processed replicas. Not everyone will do this — some will simply eat the nugget and be done with it. But for those who sense the deeper currents beneath the spectacle, <em>Wicked</em> can serve as a reminder that even the most packaged truths can, if examined carefully, point us toward greater self-awareness and liberation.</p><p>This musical, in its vivid scenes and soaring melodies, taught me to look beyond masks and illusions, to question the constructs that govern our lives. It urged me to find value in who I am, rather than who the world tells me to be. In that sense, <em>Wicked</em> was far more than an entertaining evening — it was a catalyst, nudging me toward a richer understanding of my own voice, my own courage, and the intricate power dynamics that shape our societies. And that, I believe, is a revelation worth cherishing.</p><p><strong>Resources and Interdisciplinary Approaches:</strong></p><ul><li>Arendt, Hannah. <em>The Origins of Totalitarianism</em> — for understanding the psychology and mechanics of fascism.</li><li>Fromm, Erich. <em>Escape from Freedom</em> — insights into why individuals surrender their autonomy and how fear influences compliance.</li><li>Butler, Judith. <em>Gender Trouble</em> — examining how performative roles shape identity, akin to how Glinda and Elphaba navigate societal expectations of femininity.</li><li>Jung, C. G. <em>The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious</em> — exploring how archetypes (like the witch, the ruler, the outsider) resonate in collective storytelling.</li><li>Hooks, Bell. <em>All About Love: New Visions</em> — reflections on the transformative power of love and authenticity in oppressive contexts.</li><li>Fanon, Frantz. <em>Black Skin, White Masks</em> — understanding the struggle of living as “the other” in oppressive societies and how it shapes identity and self-perception.</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8369c4ffac9c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Cycles in Time- A Supposed Dialectic]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@RelentlesslyMyself/cycles-in-time-a-supposed-dialectic-c79206e99ddf?source=rss-5f239e3e64a2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c79206e99ddf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hegel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[evolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mankind]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Relentlessly Myself]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 24 Nov 2024 10:08:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-18T01:40:36.235Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Freedom is a value we all hold dear, yet its meaning can often be hard to define. It’s shaped by both our current struggles and the events of the past. The philosopher Hegel had a big idea about history, seeing it as a journey where humanity learns, grows, and ultimately finds freedom. But in today’s world, filled with surveillance, manipulation, and power struggles, we must ask ourselves: Are we genuinely achieving more freedom, as Hegel suggested, or are we just trading old forms of oppression for new ones?</p><p>Hegel believed freedom was tied to the recognition of rationality — not just in individual thought but in the collective organization of society. Early human societies offered limited freedom, often restricted to the ruling class or elites. Over time, as contradictions emerged and were resolved, more inclusive forms of freedom developed, reflected in democratic institutions, universal rights, and individual agency. For Hegel, the trajectory of history is the story of Spirit becoming self-aware — of humanity coming to understand and embody its own freedom more fully.</p><p>Yet, this vision assumes a teleological progression, where each stage of history builds meaningfully upon the last. The idea that freedom becomes more concrete over time presupposes that progress is linear and cumulative. Here lies a profound tension when placed against the realities of modernity. While technological progress might seem to offer humanity more freedom — more time, more resources — these gains are often co-opted by systems that subjugate individuals in new ways. Capitalism, far from liberating labor, has tethered human lives to cycles of production and consumption. The very technologies that promised emancipation have, in many cases, deepened control over our lives, creating systems of surveillance, commodification, and alienation.</p><p>Society has become all-encompassing, leaving no spaces outside its reach. The idea of an “outside,” a sanctuary from societal structures, has all but disappeared. We are monitored constantly — not just through overt surveillance but through more insidious mechanisms: algorithms that track our behavior, advertising that molds our desires, and digital platforms that mediate our identities. The things we think we want, the lives we imagine for ourselves, are often products of a more extensive system that operates invisibly yet pervasively. This system, so ubiquitous and omnipotent, resists tangible confrontation. It feels omnipresent yet intangible, rendering resistance difficult to conceptualize, let alone enact.</p><p>If we consider the historical arc from feudalism to democracy to capitalism, it may initially seem that humanity has moved closer to realizing freedom. But the emerging structures of the digital age complicate this narrative. Philosophers and critics have suggested that we are returning to a kind of “techno-feudalism,” where the digital spaces necessary for work, connection, and self-expression are owned and controlled by a small oligarchy. These few entities shape our interpretations of reality and even of ourselves. McLuhan’s insight that “the medium is the message” resonates powerfully here, as the platforms that mediate our lives do not merely facilitate communication — they fundamentally alter the nature of our reality. The promise of digital liberation is overshadowed by the consolidation of power in the hands of a few, raising the question: what does freedom mean when the systems that shape our world are privately owned and controlled?</p><p>This cyclical pattern of domination — feudal, capitalist, and now digital — raises doubts about the idea of historical progress as Hegel envisioned it. Perhaps we are not progressing toward a more concrete realization of freedom but instead cycling through different forms of power and control, each iteration reconfiguring the dynamics of oppression. While these cycles might bring new awareness or opportunities for resistance, they suggest that humanity remains trapped in patterns it cannot entirely escape.</p><p>Compounding this is the question of spiritual progress — or the lack thereof. The great sages of the Axial Age — Buddha, Jesus, Confucius — offered profound insights into the nature of existence, inner freedom, and transcendence. Yet thousands of years later, humanity seems unable to move beyond these foundational teachings. Despite advancements in technology and material conditions, our spiritual and metaphysical understanding appears stagnant. We are still grappling with the same existential dilemmas, the same questions of meaning and purpose. Modernity, for all its achievements, often distracts us from these deeper concerns rather than addressing them.</p><p>This disjunction between material and spiritual progress underscores the fragility of historical narratives. History, much like memory, is not a neutral or comprehensive record of events. It is a selective process, shaped by the needs and biases of the present. Memory does not seek to capture the full truth of an experience; it captures what feels salient, what resonates with the present moment. Every era reinterprets the past through the lens of its current concerns, accentuating different facets of history based on its mood, priorities, and limitations.</p><p>If history is always mediated by the present, then it cannot offer an objective truth about humanity — it can only provide fragments, patterns, and interpretations. This challenges the notion that history can guide us toward an ultimate reality. Perhaps, as the sages suggested, all that truly exists is the present. The purpose of reflecting on the past, then, is not to transcend the human condition but to understand it. In understanding, we might accept our flawed nature, recognizing that we are bound to repeat cycles. The task is not to escape this reality but to live within it meaningfully.</p><p>Ideals, then, are not destinations but tools — guiding lights meant to inspire action and connection. They are not meant to alienate us from the present by offering unattainable visions of perfection. Transcendence, while deeply fulfilling, is not a place to dwell. It is a momentary touch, a glimpse of possibility that reminds us of what could be while anchoring us in the reality of what is. The touch of God, the spark of transcendence, is not an escape but a source of hope and inspiration — a means to create meaning, not a substitute for living.</p><p>To live in the present is to embrace the paradoxes of human existence: our tendency to repeat cycles, our yearning for meaning in an indifferent universe, and the flawed, fragmented ways we understand ourselves and one another. It is to accept the weight of being consequential in a cosmos far beyond our comprehension while finding connection and purpose in bearing that weight together. This does not diminish the value of ideals or the power of transcendence but situates them within the framework of human imperfection.</p><p>Perhaps progress, then, is not a linear ascent toward perfection but a deepening of our capacity to understand and accept our nature. It is the humility of recognizing that we are small, flawed, and bound to repeat our errors — and that this is not failure but simply the condition of being human. In this acceptance, we might find not just solace but strength: the strength to create, to connect, and to hope, not by transcending our nature but by learning to live fully within it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c79206e99ddf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>