<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by The Rambler on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by The Rambler on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@TheRamblerReviews?source=rss-369e2eb4f425------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 11:09:48 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@TheRamblerReviews/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Scene Tamil Movie Review]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TheRamblerReviews/scene-tamil-movie-review-d00216b9d28f?source=rss-369e2eb4f425------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d00216b9d28f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[suriya]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tamil]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-reviews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cinema]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-review]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Rambler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 09 Nov 2026 17:38:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-09T17:38:52.039Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>5/10</strong></p><p>Ultimately, this was a very average movie. And what makes it particularly disappointing isn’t necessarily that it’s a terrible film, because it isn’t. It’s that, given the people involved, the industry it’s coming from, and the expectations surrounding it, it should have been so much more.</p><p>If you look at this movie completely in isolation, without considering anything else, you could argue that it’s fine. Maybe even good. But that’s not how movies exist in the real world. In the real world, context matters. And that context can vary depending on the country, the film industry, the filmmakers involved, and the expectations that naturally come with them.</p><h3>The Director and the Disappointing Filmmaking</h3><p>First of all, we’re talking about a superstar here: Suriya.</p><p>Now, that doesn’t automatically mean the movie has to be an action film, have an enormous budget, or feature massive set pieces. There’s absolutely no rule saying that a superstar must only make a particular kind of movie.</p><p>In fact, when I looked at Wikipedia and saw that the budget was supposedly around ₹30 crore, I initially thought it was a mistake. But thinking about it, that figure could actually be accurate. There isn’t a huge amount of action, there aren’t particularly elaborate set pieces, and the film doesn’t seem to rely heavily on expensive visual effects. On top of that, Suriya is also involved in producing the movie, so he doesn’t necessarily have to take a conventional acting salary.</p><p>But that’s not really the issue. Suriya can obviously make whatever kind of movie he wants. If he wants to do something smaller, more grounded, or less commercially conventional, that’s perfectly fine. I’d actually encourage that. There is no reason why major stars should constantly restrict themselves to the same formula of action, spectacle, and mass entertainment. When other actors keep doing that, it can become incredibly repetitive, tiring, and annoying.</p><p>The real problem here is the director.</p><p>Again, there’s no rule saying a director has to make films filled with huge action sequences or expensive spectacle. But when you have a filmmaker whose previous work demonstrated a much more creative, cinematic approach, and that filmmaker gets the opportunity to work with a major star in a bigger industry where action-oriented entertainment is relatively normal, it’s reasonable to expect something more ambitious. Especially when the movie itself was marketed as something cool, slick, and stylish, with action elements.</p><p>That’s what makes this so disappointing.</p><p>Just go back and watch some clips from the director’s previous movie. There was considerably more cinematic flair, creativity, and visual imagination. You had interesting ideas, such as an old man fighting, which was memorable precisely because it was something different. You also had martial arts that actually looked like martial arts, rather than the typical masala nonsense where people defy gravity, fly across rooms, and perform completely ridiculous stunts.</p><p>There was a certain level of creativity and excitement in that film that simply doesn’t come through here.</p><p>One example is that this movie actually has a character with a martial arts background who gets to demonstrate those abilities. Yet the resulting fight doesn’t even look particularly convincing as martial arts. It looks like a fairly average, obviously choreographed fight scene. The movements don’t have the authenticity, impact, or physical credibility that they could have had. It’s unrealistic and unconvincing, but not in an entertaining, exaggerated, cinematic way either.</p><p>It’s almost the worst of both worlds.</p><p>Now, once again, the movie doesn’t have to be action-heavy. It could have been a full-blown thriller, with the tension, mystery, and writing doing most of the heavy lifting. But the problem is that the thriller elements are also incredibly average.</p><p>The writing feels rushed, convenient, and, at times, just plain weird. It feels as though the filmmakers wanted to send the main characters on a particular adventure and then quickly cooked up some random nonsense to justify it. Rather than constructing a genuinely compelling, sensible narrative that naturally leads the characters into these situations, the story often seems to exist purely as an excuse to make certain scenes happen.</p><p>And that becomes a recurring problem throughout the movie.</p><p>The filmmaking itself is another major disappointment. The cinematography, visual presentation, and general cinematic quality are all painfully average. The movie simply doesn’t look as modern, stylish, or visually accomplished as it should.</p><p>And to me, that’s unacceptable.</p><p>We’re living in a period where Indian cinema is evolving, with filmmakers across different industries experimenting with more ambitious visuals, techniques, action choreography, and storytelling. Yet some filmmakers continue to make movies that feel as though they’re going backwards.</p><p>This is especially frustrating when the same director has already demonstrated that he can make something visually interesting and cinematic. His previous film looked good. It had a distinct personality. It had moments that actually felt exciting and inventive.</p><p>So why does this one feel so mundane?</p><p>It isn’t simply a question of money. You don’t need an enormous budget to create memorable visuals, interesting compositions, convincing action, or genuinely engaging filmmaking. You need creativity, effort, and a willingness to push things further.</p><p>And this movie rarely seems interested in doing that.</p><h3>The Wasted Potential</h3><p>When you bring together a proven director and a major star, two people whose combined appeal can generate an even larger and relatively predictable box-office draw, (which this movie is currently demonstrating by the way) then I think there should be some responsibility to use that advantage to make something bigger and more ambitious.</p><p>Especially at a time when we’re seeing so many enormous-budget movies that turn out to be absolute rubbish, making audiences cringe, laugh at how terrible they are, or become genuinely angry at the amount of money and talent wasted on them.</p><p>When two proven box-office draws come together, the least they could do is recognise the commercial opportunity they have. Their combined popularity can help justify a much larger budget, allowing them to attempt something truly spectacular without taking the same level of financial risk as filmmakers who don’t have that kind of established audience.</p><p>And I’m not saying they should just throw money at the screen for the sake of it. We’ve already seen countless examples of that approach failing miserably. I’m saying they should use their commercial advantage to create something genuinely ambitious. Something that combines excellent filmmaking with the kind of scale, creativity, action, and spectacle that audiences rarely get to experience.</p><p>In fact, I genuinely believe that a film like this could have grossed over ₹1,000 crore.</p><p>And no, I’m not joking. Just look at the Indian movies that have actually crossed that figure, or even come close to it.</p><p>Plenty of movies have attempted to reach those heights with enormous budgets, massive stars, extravagant marketing campaigns. Suriya’s own Kanguva, for example. Yet they didn’t come anywhere close to achieving the kind of box-office success its scale might have suggested.</p><p>Meanwhile, many of the movies that actually achieve extraordinary box-office numbers are successful because they’re genuinely liked by audiences in the first place, or because they’re sequels to movies that audiences already loved.</p><p>In other words, a massive budget doesn’t automatically create a massive hit. But a genuinely good movie, with the right commercial appeal, can become one.</p><p>And Malayalam cinema is a particularly interesting example of this. Look at the films that have crossed ₹100 crore, ₹200 crore, or even ₹300 crore. Most of the time they aren’t the biggest-budget productions, filled with the biggest stars, that were designed from the beginning to achieve those numbers.</p><p>Quite often, they’re comparatively modest movies that succeed because audiences actually enjoy them. They connect with people, generate positive word of mouth, and attract viewers far beyond what their budgets or initial expectations might have suggested. Some don’t even have major stars.</p><p>And that’s precisely my point.</p><p>If Malayalam cinema can produce enormous box-office successes with relatively small films, then imagine what could happen if you took a filmmaker who has already demonstrated that kind of creative and commercial potential, gave him a major Tamil superstar, and actually encouraged him to push his filmmaking to another level.</p><p>That’s why I’m completely serious when I say that a Jithu Madhavan film starring Suriya could potentially have grossed ₹1,000 crore.</p><p>Is that an ambitious prediction? Of course. But is it some completely ridiculous, impossible idea? I don’t think so.</p><p>We’re living in a time when Malayalam cinema can produce a ₹300-crore hit with a relatively small, mundane, fairly average romantic comedy, or a ₹200-crore success with a clichéd, high school-based film that doesn’t even rely on major stars.</p><p>And on the Tamil side, we’re seeing films like Jailer 2 approach the ₹1,000-crore conversation despite, in my opinion, being fairly average and annoying, with similar problems to this movie: not enough ambition, not enough genuinely impressive action, and nowhere near the level of cinematic spectacle that could have been achieved.</p><p>So why should the idea of Jithu Madhavan and Suriya delivering a ₹1,000-crore movie be considered so outrageous? Especially when Jithu has already demonstrated an ability to make something creative, entertaining, stylish, and commercially appealing without needing an enormous budget or a superstar.</p><p>Now imagine taking those strengths and combining them with Suriya’s star power, a substantially larger budget, more elaborate action choreography, greater production resources, and a genuine commitment to making something visually extraordinary.</p><p>They could have taken everything that worked about Aavesham and pushed it to an entirely different level.</p><p>They could have made Aavesham on steroids.</p><p>Not simply a bigger version of the same movie, but something that took its creativity, energy, humour, unusual characters, inventive action, and cinematic personality, and amplified all of those elements with the resources and star power available to them.</p><p>Imagine the kind of action sequences they could have created. The elaborate set pieces, the stylish cinematography, the inventive choreography, the music, the humour, and the sheer cinematic scale. And importantly, imagine all of that being built around genuinely good writing and entertaining characters rather than the usual expensive, brainless masala nonsense.</p><p>That’s the difference.</p><p>I don’t want filmmakers to spend ₹500 crore making something that looks expensive but is fundamentally terrible. I want them to make something genuinely excellent and use that money to push the experience as far as possible.</p><p>And when you have a director like Jithu Madhavan and a star like Suriya coming together, I think that kind of ambition is entirely reasonable. Instead of making something merely acceptable, they could have attempted a genuine event movie.</p><p>Something audiences would talk about for years. Something that could attract viewers across different languages and industries. Something that justified its commercial potential through actual quality rather than simply relying on star power and marketing.</p><p>The point is that they had the talent, the audience appeal, and the opportunity to at least attempt something on that level.</p><p>And even if the movie hadn’t reached ₹1,000 crore, imagine if we’d at least got an extraordinary cinematic experience out of it.</p><p>Instead, we got something so painfully average that it barely feels as though the filmmakers tried to maximise the opportunity in front of them.</p><h3>Spoilers Ahead</h3><h3>The Action and Missed Opportunities</h3><p>Let’s talk about that fight scene I mentioned earlier. This is probably one of the clearest examples of everything wrong with the movie.</p><p>The fight could have been much more convincing, both in terms of the choreography and the writing. For example, the character could have used weapons, improvised objects, or some kind of practical strategy to deal with the situation. Instead, the filmmakers go for one of the most clichéd approaches imaginable: one person simply beating up a bunch of people.</p><p>But the problem isn’t even limited to how unrealistic or poorly executed the fight looks. It’s also the fact that the people getting beaten up don’t actually deserve it.</p><p>Why couldn’t they have been proper bad guys? Yes, that would have been a cliché too, but at least it would have made some sense. At least there would have been a reasonable justification for the violence.</p><p>Instead, we get what are essentially innocent people being beaten up, seemingly because the filmmakers decided that the movie needed an action sequence.</p><p>“We haven’t had enough action yet, so let’s just cram a fight in here.”</p><p>And that’s exactly how it feels.</p><p>This one scene practically encapsulates the entire movie. It’s unnecessary, unconvincing, unrealistic, and average. It isn’t as good as it could have been in terms of either the practical execution or the writing.</p><p>The whole thing feels like something somebody thought up on the spot, without giving it much consideration. Either that, or it’s just lazy filmmaking.</p><p>And that’s what makes it even more irritating. The director had approximately two years to come up with this movie, and this is the best he could manage?</p><p>That’s absolutely ridiculous.</p><p>What’s even worse is what happens towards the end. When the villain is inside the apartment, Nazriya’s character is tied up and has already been beaten.</p><p>But hang on a minute. We already know that she can fight. The movie itself has established that she is capable of physically defending herself and taking on multiple men.</p><p>So why on earth wouldn’t you show us the fight between her and the villain? At the very least, that could have been an opportunity to create another exciting sequence in a movie that desperately lacks them.</p><p>Instead, the film simply skips over it. And I suspect the reason is that the filmmakers didn’t want to show a woman losing a fight against a man.</p><p>They’re perfectly happy to show a woman beating up men, but apparently showing the reverse is something they wanted to avoid. And if that really was the thinking, it’s ridiculous, because it comes at the expense of the movie itself.</p><p>You’ve established that this character can fight. You’ve created a dangerous villain. You’ve put the two of them in the same location. And then you don’t even bother showing the confrontation.</p><p>What a wasted opportunity.</p><p>Then we get the final fight, which is better. But even that isn’t the biggest issue.</p><h3>The Writing, Acting and Comedy</h3><p>Another thing that really annoyed me was the whole business with Nazriya’s father doing drugs. What exactly was the point of that?</p><p>I recently watched a review of another movie that came out on the same day, and the reviewers were asking whether some of these new-generation filmmakers are trying to promote drug use or whether they genuinely think all young people are constantly taking drugs.</p><p>And I was reminded of that here.</p><p>Now, Nazriya’s father isn’t presented as some struggling drug addict or junkie. He’s seemingly just a normal guy. And then, out of nowhere, he’s sniffing white powder through a rolled-up banknote.</p><p>Apparently, the filmmakers think that’s funny. But why? What does it add to the character? What does it add to the story? Why is it even there?</p><p>It’s not particularly clever, funny, or interesting. It’s just another random element thrown into a movie that already feels full of random ideas.</p><p>The acting</p><p>It is fine. That’s really all I can say about it. Nobody is giving some extraordinary, mind-blowing performance that elevates the material into something special.</p><p>Suriya playing a blind man could have been an opportunity for a truly exceptional performance. There’s plenty of potential there for subtlety, physical detail, emotional complexity, and a genuinely memorable portrayal.</p><p>But it’s just good. It isn’t extraordinary. It isn’t some incredible performance that makes you forget about the film’s other weaknesses.</p><p>And then there’s another ridiculous writing decision involving Nazriya’s father. There’s a scene where he suddenly passes out while driving.</p><p>Why? Because the script needs him to.</p><p>That’s genuinely how it feels. There isn’t enough convincing preparation or development to make that moment believable. He simply loses consciousness at precisely the moment the story requires him to.</p><p>This is the kind of lazy, convenient writing that should be criticised much more harshly.</p><p>In fact, some of these decisions are so poor that I would expect the movie to receive terrible reviews. Yet, for some reason, that doesn’t seem to be happening to the extent I would expect.</p><p>I’ve also noticed that people who give the movie negative reviews are receiving plenty of dislikes, abusive comments, and even swearing directed at them. And that’s ridiculous. People should be allowed to criticise a movie, especially when there are legitimate reasons to do so.</p><p>Now, I can understand why somebody might have fun watching this in a theatre. Maybe the atmosphere, the audience reactions, and the general experience make it more enjoyable.</p><p>That’s fine.</p><p>But even if we’re judging it as a fun comedy, I don’t think it succeeds particularly well.</p><p>Here’s the thing: if a movie doesn’t have much action, doesn’t have exciting set pieces, and doesn’t have particularly impressive cinematography, that’s absolutely fine. It can compensate for those things by being genuinely hilarious.</p><p>If the comedy is consistently excellent, if the characters are entertaining, and if the writing is sharp, then who cares about the lack of spectacle?</p><p>But this movie isn’t hilarious. It’s not even consistently very funny. The comedy is just average, like almost everything else.</p><p>And that’s the recurring problem. It’s average in practically every department.</p><p>Even the costumes seem to have received very little attention. Why does everything look so ordinary?</p><p>And before somebody misunderstands that criticism, I’m not saying the characters need to walk around dressed as though they’re attending a fashion show. Of course not. You can have grounded, realistic costumes that still show creativity, personality, and care.</p><p>But here, everything just feels so mundane. The costumes, the cinematography, the action, the comedy, the overall visual presentation — none of it really stands out.</p><p>And that’s such a shame, especially considering the industry we’re talking about.</p><p>Tamil cinema has an enormous amount of talent and potential. There are so many capable actors, technicians, composers, and filmmakers working within it. Yet I keep seeing movies that fail to make the most of those resources.</p><p>Instead of pushing forward and maximising what they can achieve, too many filmmakers seem content with doing the same average things, or even going backwards.</p><p>Of course, there are exceptions. Some filmmakers genuinely push the boundaries, experiment, and produce ambitious work. And when they succeed, the results can be fantastic. But too many others seem satisfied with mediocrity.</p><p>And that’s why this particular collaboration was so interesting in the first place. You have a filmmaker coming from Malayalam, suggesting a more trailblazing and inventive approach.</p><p>Naturally, you might expect him to bring some of those strengths into Tamil cinema. Perhaps he could combine the best qualities of both industries.</p><p>Take the creativity, grounded action, and progressive filmmaking associated with Malayalam, and combine them with the scale, resources, star power, and cinematic possibilities of Tamil cinema.</p><p>That could have been something genuinely exciting.</p><p>Instead, it feels as though the movie combines the wrong elements from both. And even then, it doesn’t fully commit to them. It doesn’t go all the way in either direction.</p><p>It’s neither a particularly strong Malayalam-style film nor an especially exciting Tamil-style commercial entertainer.</p><p>Now, to be clear, there’s absolutely no requirement for it to be either of those things. It doesn’t have to follow some specific industry formula.</p><p>But regardless of which direction the filmmakers wanted to take, they could and should have pushed the writing, visuals, action, characterisation, and overall filmmaking much further.</p><p>Instead, almost everything is executed in an average, mundane way.</p><h3>The Villain and the Weak Writing</h3><p>The villain is another major problem. And what’s frustrating is that there was clearly potential for something interesting here.</p><p>At first, he seems like some kind of serial killer. But then we discover that he’s actually a contract killer who deliberately makes his murders resemble the work of a serial killer in order to confuse the police.</p><p>Now, that idea itself is perfectly fine. There’s nothing inherently wrong with that concept. But the execution is strange.</p><p>The character behaves as though he’s some kind of deranged psychopath, and the movie seems to want the atmosphere of a serial-killer thriller while also having him function as a professional contract killer.</p><p>Those two things aren’t necessarily incompatible, but the film doesn’t do enough to make the combination convincing.</p><p>Why is he like this? Why does he behave in such a bizarre, seemingly crazy manner? And, most importantly, what is his actual motivation?</p><p>Why did he decide to become a contract killer at such a young age? We’re talking about somebody who was already murdering people before entering college. He apparently wanted to pursue this profession from an extremely young age.</p><p>But why? What happened to make him that way?</p><p>There’s a scene where he’s being beaten up by a group of goons, and he tells them about his ambitions to be a criminal. But that raises even more questions.</p><p>Why would those goons listen to him? He’s literally a child. Why would they take him seriously? And why would a child even want to do something like this in the first place?</p><p>The movie also reveals that he murdered his own father. Again, why?</p><p>You can’t just throw in something like that and expect it to automatically make a character compelling. If anything, that makes the need for proper character development even greater.</p><p>There should have been a much more convincing explanation for his behaviour, his psychology, and his decision to become a killer. Instead, the movie seems to think that simply making him strange, violent, and unpredictable is enough.</p><p>It isn’t.</p><p>The actor does a good job with the material. That’s not the issue. But a good performance doesn’t automatically make a well-written villain.</p><p>For comparison, look at Vijay Sethupathi’s character in Master. That is one of the best villains I’ve seen in Indian cinema.</p><p>He had a proper background, a clear motivation, and a genuinely sympathetic element to his story. You could understand how he became the person he was.</p><p>He had gone far too deep into his crimes and cruelty for his background to excuse what he had become. That’s what made him so effective.</p><p>He was a terrible person, but he was also a properly developed character. And that’s the kind of depth this movie could have given its villain.</p><p>It didn’t necessarily have to copy Master or create the same kind of sympathetic backstory. But it needed something substantial. Something that made his behaviour understandable, even if it wasn’t justifiable.</p><p>Instead, we get this strange character who’s somewhere between a contract killer and a serial killer, without the film fully exploring either aspect.</p><p>And to make matters worse, the contract-killer element isn’t even made particularly clear until later. So for a significant portion of the movie, the audience is left trying to understand exactly what kind of villain this is supposed to be.</p><p>And not in a particularly clever or intriguing way. It’s just confusing.</p><p>Then there are the two helpers working with him. What exactly is going on with those characters?</p><p>Do they know what he’s doing? Do they know the full extent of his crimes? Why are they helping him? What are they getting out of this arrangement?</p><p>The movie doesn’t establish these things convincingly. They simply seem to go along with whatever he says.</p><p>And then, unsurprisingly, he kills both of them. The 1st gets killed and the 2nd one starts becoming frightened, wondering whether he’s going to be killed too.</p><p>Well, why didn’t you think about that earlier? You’re working with a dangerous, unpredictable murderer, being an accessory to murder.</p><p>Surely you’d have considered the possibility that he might eventually turn on you. Why didn’t either of these characters have some kind of protection, contingency plan, or insurance policy?</p><p>Why would they blindly follow this kid and place themselves completely at his mercy? Again, it feels as though these characters exist purely to serve the plot rather than behaving like believable human beings.</p><p>the 1st helper gets killed by having Nalen getting her to swallow a SIM card that has apparently been laced with poison. As she’s dying, she points towards him.</p><p>Suriya and Nazriya somehow conclude that the person she pointed at must be the killer. But how would they know that?</p><p>Why would pointing in a particular direction automatically establish that the person there was responsible? She could have been pointing at any number of things or people. There are multiple possible interpretations.</p><p>Yet the movie treats the conclusion as though it’s obvious.</p><p>And that’s exactly what I mean when I talk about weak writing and weak reasoning. The characters seem to arrive at conclusions because the script needs them to, not because the available evidence logically supports those conclusions.</p><p>And the movie repeatedly expects the audience to just accept it.</p><p>There’s another scene involving the villain’s drone that really illustrates how contrived the writing can be.</p><p>The villain flies a drone, and at one point Suriya, who is blind, looks up in its direction. The villain later reasons that Suriya shouldn’t have been able to see the drone from where he was standing, because the villain himself had previously walked along the same route.</p><p>That observation helps him realise that Suriya is blind and that Nazriya is effectively acting as his eyes, guiding him and telling him where to walk.</p><p>Now, on paper, that could have been a clever reveal. The problem is the way the movie constructs the flashback.</p><p>When we see the villain retracing the route, he’s shown crossing over to the other side of the road and looking up. And that is incredibly convenient.</p><p>As Nazriya is the one guiding Suriya. She is observing the surroundings and giving him instructions based on what she can see. Her perspective is from the other side of the road.</p><p>So the villain’s deduction relies on him having previously gone to that same position. But why would he have done that?</p><p>When he was originally testing the drone, he had no reason to anticipate that somebody would later be standing on the other side of the road, using another person’s vision to navigate.</p><p>He wasn’t travelling through time. He couldn’t have known that this exact situation would eventually occur.</p><p>Yet the flashback conveniently shows him doing precisely what the script needs him to have done. It’s such a retrospective piece of writing.</p><p>Rather than establishing a believable sequence of events and allowing the villain to make an intelligent deduction from them, the filmmakers appear to have constructed the earlier event backwards to justify the later revelation.</p><p>And that makes the supposed cleverness feel completely artificial. It’s not genuinely intelligent writing if the circumstances have to be manipulated so conveniently for the deduction to work.</p><p>It’s just bad writing.</p><h3>Random Character Details That Go Nowhere</h3><p>Then we have the bizarre character details involving the parents.</p><p>As I mentioned earlier, Nazriya’s father is shown sniffing white powder through a rolled-up banknote. And Suriya’s mother is apparently a drunk.</p><p>But why? What is the actual purpose of establishing these characteristics?</p><p>With Suriya’s mother, we’re told or shown that she drinks excessively, but the film doesn’t really explore the consequences of that. There isn’t a particularly meaningful storyline about her drinking.</p><p>We don’t see the kind of serious problems that excessive alcohol consumption could create. It’s just another characteristic thrown in there.</p><p>She’s a drunk, and that’s apparently enough. But it doesn’t go anywhere.</p><p>And excessive drinking can have serious health consequences, so there was certainly potential to do something more meaningful with it.</p><p>The same applies to Suriya’s father, who has memory problems. Again, that’s a potentially interesting detail.</p><p>Memory problems can create all kinds of complications, particularly in a thriller where timing, information, and decision-making are important.</p><p>The filmmakers could have used that condition to create a genuinely tense or consequential moment. Imagine if his memory failed him at precisely the wrong time, in a situation where remembering something was critically important.</p><p>That could have been effective.</p><p>These are essentially two Chekhov’s guns that the movie introduces but never properly fires. The filmmakers establish these potentially significant weaknesses and then fail to make meaningful use of them.</p><p>Meanwhile, Nazriya’s father suddenly passes out while driving, in a scene that feels far less convincing.</p><p>Now, you could argue that his drug use might explain why he lost consciousness. But the movie doesn’t establish that connection convincingly.</p><p>He isn’t shown being particularly unstable, visibly intoxicated, or obviously affected in a way that would prepare us for what happens. He simply passes out.</p><p>And even if that isn’t convenient lazy writing, as they intended on him being high at that moment, it is bad filmmaking as that didn’t translate from paper to screen as they didn’t do enough visual storytelling to showcase that.</p><p>That’s the frustrating thing. The film already had other character details that could have been used to create more organic complications.</p><p>Instead, it relies on this clumsy, contrived incident. It’s yet another example of a potentially interesting idea being introduced without enough thought being given to its execution.</p><h3>Music</h3><p>And then there’s Sushin Shyam. This is a composer who has demonstrated genuinely exceptional talent.</p><p>He’s innovative, creative, and capable of producing music that feels fresh, distinctive, and world-class. His tunes can be extraordinary.</p><p>He has the ability to create music that doesn’t just accompany a movie but actually elevates it, gives it personality, and makes particular moments unforgettable.</p><p>So naturally, when somebody like him is involved, I expect something special.</p><p>But here? The music is largely forgettable. It isn’t particularly memorable, inventive, or exciting.</p><p>It’s just average.</p><p>Now, if this were some random composer delivering an average soundtrack, I might not think much of it. But this is Sushin Shyam.</p><p>And for somebody with his level of ability, delivering something this unremarkable feels like a sin.</p><p>It’s another wasted opportunity in a movie absolutely full of them.</p><h3>Final Thoughts</h3><p>At the end of the day, this isn’t a movie that’s completely unwatchable. It’s not necessarily boring. You can sit through it without feeling as though you’re enduring some unbearable experience.</p><p>There are moments that work, the acting is generally fine, and the movie is watchable enough. But that’s about it.</p><p>It’s ultimately a completely nothing movie. And I think that’s almost more frustrating than a film that’s outright terrible.</p><p>At least a terrible movie might fail spectacularly. It might try something genuinely ambitious and fall apart in the process. Here, so much of the movie feels as though it never even attempts to reach the level it could have reached.</p><p>The action is average. The thriller elements are average. The writing is weak and frequently contrived. The cinematography is mundane. The comedy isn’t particularly funny. The costumes are unremarkable. The music is forgettable. The performances are fine, but nothing extraordinary.</p><p>And the villain, despite having a potentially interesting concept and a good actor, is nowhere near as compelling or well-developed as he should have been.</p><p>Almost every aspect of the film feels like a missed opportunity. And the context makes that disappointment significantly worse.</p><p>We’re talking about a major Tamil superstar, a director whose previous work showed real creativity and cinematic ambition, a talented composer, and an industry with enormous potential.</p><p>This combination should have produced something much more memorable.</p><p>It didn’t have to be an enormous action spectacle. It didn’t have to be a conventional mass entertainer. It didn’t have to be a full thriller either. It could have been something entirely different.</p><p>But whatever it chose to be, it needed to be much better at actually being that thing.</p><p>Instead, the filmmakers seem to have settled for the bare minimum in far too many areas. And that’s why I find the movie so disappointing.</p><p>As it could have been a lot more. It should have been a lot more.</p><p>But it wasn’t.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d00216b9d28f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Jailer 2 Review]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TheRamblerReviews/jailer-2-review-eb06af8ffd83?source=rss-369e2eb4f425------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eb06af8ffd83</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mohanlal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rajinikanth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tamil-movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jailer-2]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Rambler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 Oct 2026 21:25:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-18T08:51:57.670Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>6/10</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Fo8bxOVng6k1bhBUVyZrqA.png" /></figure><h4>Spoilers throughout.</h4><h3>Overall: Enjoyable, but Ultimately a Waste of a Movie</h3><p>It is weird because, overall, <em>Jailer 2</em> was an enjoyable experience. However, there are multiple elements that, taken together, make the movie feel like a waste of its own potential. There are so many opportunities for a much better, more exciting and more interesting film, but the makers squander them through confusing writing, repetitive storytelling, underused characters and a disappointing lack of ambition in the execution.</p><p>The biggest problem is the structure. The first half is too long, too mundane and too confusing, whereas the second half is where the real action should have been. The movie should have shortened the first half, established the major conflicts earlier and used that time to build the drama that needed to be resolved. Then, in the second half, Rajinikanth could have gone on a proper rampage, with the other characters also getting substantial action sequences and opportunities to shine.</p><p>Instead, the first half is filled with annoying, unnecessary situations. There are some fun moments, but there are also too many scenes that do not justify the amount of time they receive. By the time the second half arrives, there is not enough room for the rampage that should have been the main attraction. The filmmakers also have to squeeze in dramatic developments that should have been established much earlier, making the entire movie feel poorly structured.</p><p>For example, the revelation that Rajinikanth’s son has been killed should have happened much earlier, rather than in the final quarter of the movie. The family being kidnapped should also have happened in the first half. These developments could have established the emotional stakes and given Rajinikanth a convincing reason to go on a rampage. The second half could then have concentrated on the consequences, the action and the escalating conflict.</p><p>The stolen statues should also have been central to the story. The villians want the statues, and Rajinikanth still has three truckloads of them, yet this is barely explored. That should have been the main focus of the plot, alongside the threat to his family.</p><p>Instead, the film spends far too much time on mundane situations, confusing subplots and repetitive setups before finally getting to the material that should have driven the story from the beginning.</p><p>This is what makes the film so frustrating. It is not as though the makers lacked the ingredients for a great sequel. They had Rajinikanth, an established team, returning characters, major cameos, a potentially interesting villain, the stolen statues, the threat to the family and the opportunity to deliver a much larger action spectacle. There was so much they could have done with all of this, yet they failed to put these elements together into one cohesive story.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xEoZROxr5GTPwliJ.jpg" /><figcaption>Jailer 2 Promotional Video Still</figcaption></figure><h3>The Writing Is Confusing, Repetitive and Often Lazy</h3><p>One of the cardinal sins of Indian cinema, as well as other film industries, is failing to understand why an original movie worked and then copying its recognisable elements without understanding what made them effective in the first place.</p><p>The problem affects the film’s wider storytelling. The writers seem to think that because the audience has seen the first movie, we will automatically accept everything in the sequel. We remember that Rajinikanth has contacts, that he has a team and that he is capable of planning elaborate operations and especially have snipers waiting. But that does not mean the filmmakers can simply assume that everything will work without explaining it.</p><p>Every movie needs to establish its own context. A sequel can build on what came before, but it still needs to explain its characters’ motivations, show how the plot progresses and give the audience a convincing reason to care about what happens.</p><p>Instead, <em>Jailer 2</em> often feels as though the makers are reminding us of the first movie rather than making a proper sequel.</p><p>One repeated element in this film is a family gets kidnapped, Rajinikanth tries to help them, another gets kidnapped, and he has to help them again. The movie repeats this pattern multiple times without developing it enough to justify the repetition.</p><p>There are also repeated inconsistencies, for example, the film establishes that a tracker or another method of tracking someone is being used. At other times, characters simply find people without any explanation.</p><p>For example, S. J. Suryah finds Rajinikanth and his family so that he can reveal what happened to the son in the first movie. The revelation itself is important, but the way the scene is constructed is not convincing. There is no properly established tracker. S. J. Suryah finds Rajinikanth without any difficulty. The whole scene seems to exist so that the information about the son can be revealed, rather than because the events leading up to it make sense.</p><p>The scene could have worked if the filmmakers had established a convincing way for S. J. Suryah to locate Rajinikanth. Instead, there is no real drama or believable explanation for how he finds him.</p><p>The writing also struggles to distinguish between genuinely clever planning and a series of coincidences. Characters conveniently encounter one another, information is revealed when the plot requires it, and people appear or disappear without enough explanation. The film seems to believe it is being clever, but the pieces have not been put together properly.</p><p>This is particularly irritating because the underlying ideas are not necessarily bad. The stolen statues, Rajinikanth’s network, the threat to his family and the larger criminal organisation could all have formed the basis of a compelling story. The problem is the execution.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*6N6gxueOnehOihSN.jpg" /><figcaption>Jailer 2 Promotional Poster</figcaption></figure><h3>The Son’s Death, Vidya Balan’s Speech and the Wasted Potential of the Character</h3><p>One of the clearest examples of the film’s poor writing is the storyline involving Rajinikanth’s son.</p><p>Already stated is that the revelation that his son has been killed should have happened much earlier. Leaving it until the final quarter wastes an opportunity to give the story a stronger emotional foundation and provide a convincing motivation for Rajinikanth’s actions.</p><p>More importantly, the way the family reacts to the revelation is handled terribly.</p><p>When the family discovers that Rajinikanth killed his son, they are understandably upset. They turn against him and even have him arrested. This should have been a major conflict, creating a genuine divide between Rajinikanth and the people he is trying to protect.</p><p>However, approximately two minutes later, the entire situation is resolved through Vidya Balan’s speech.</p><p>The problem is that the speech is poorly constructed, and the resolution feels completely unearned. Vidya Balan’s character is a villain who hates Rajinikanth, yet the speech effectively becomes a way of praising him and making the family understand him again. The speech was not to be intended as straightforward praise, but that is effectively what it becomes.</p><p>The writers use this speech as a shortcut to get the family back on Rajinikanth’s side without properly developing the conflict or allowing the family to work through what they have discovered.</p><p>The family had just found out something serious enough to turn against him and have him arrested. That is not a minor disagreement that can be resolved almost immediately through a convenient speech. The film needed to explore the consequences of the revelation and give the characters a convincing reason to change their minds.</p><p>Instead, the writers introduce a dramatic conflict and then dispose of it almost immediately because they need to get back to the action.</p><p>Vidya Balan’s explanation of what Rajinikanth’s son was really like is also horrible in its own right. She claims that he would have killed the family, but that makes absolutely no sense. He loved the family. He would not have killed them. His motivation was money, and he wanted to join forces with Varman. Those motivations do not automatically mean he would have murdered his own family.</p><p>The speech therefore misrepresents the character and uses an unconvincing claim to justify what has happened.</p><p>This problem also connects to one of my biggest criticisms of the first <em>Jailer part 1</em>.</p><p><em>The son was kidnapped by the villain, but then he revealed that he would not actually join forces with him. The way this was handled was incredibly stupid because the villain had literally kidnapped him and kept him locked up. The writers seemed desperate to make the son a bad guy quickly, so they resorted to a revelation that felt amateurish.</em></p><p><em>It was like something written by a child, or a scene from Threat Level Midnight in The Office. It had that same level of absurdity: the character suddenly announces that he is actually a bad guy, without the story doing enough work to make that revelation convincing.</em></p><p><em>If the son was supposed to be a villain, the writers should have developed that idea properly. Alternatively, he could have remained a good guy. Either option could have worked, but the execution needed to be much better.</em></p><p><em>Most importantly, he should not have been killed.</em></p><p><em>He should have been locked up in jail rather than killed by his own father. That decision was stupid for several reasons, not least because Rajinikanth had already used that killing move multiple times before. The last scene with the son shoudl have been different and the sequel could have developed the relationship between the two characters further rather than closing off the possibility of doing anything interesting with the son.</em></p><p><em>The actor is genuinely good. He is a promising performer, and the industry needs to use him properly. Otherwise, it risks wasting his potential.</em></p><p><em>This industry has a problem with ageing actors and the need to find new stars who can carry major films. One of its biggest actors has now become Chief Minister, leaving an even greater need for the industry to develop other leading performers. A director such as Nelson, Lokesh Kanagaraj or Karthik Subbaraj could help establish a new star if they used this actor properly.</em></p><p><em>Nelson had the opportunity to do precisely that by making him Rajinikanth’s son. But instead, he made him a villain, and not even a particularly good villain. Why should Rajinikanth’s son have to be a pansy villain?</em></p><p><em>There is nothing wrong with making a character flawed. In fact, having him make mistakes could have made him more human and interesting. But there is a difference between a flawed character and a character whose actions are so poorly developed that the audience struggles to understand why he behaves as he does.</em></p><p><em>The second movie makes this even more frustrating. Rajinikanth could have got his son out of jail to help him with the fight, in a setup that could have allowed the two characters to work together. Instead, the son is killed off in the worst way possible.</em></p><p><em>Nelson could have given him the opportunity to join forces with Rajinikanth, much like Vijay Sethupathi’s role in Karthik Subbaraj’s Petta (2019). That would have provided an opportunity to explore the character, develop his relationship with Rajinikanth and give the audience a reason to care about what happened to him.</em></p><p><em>Instead, the filmmakers wasted him in the first movie and then wasted the possibilities of bringing him back in the sequel.</em></p><p>This is exactly the kind of backward, nonsensical emotional lazy writing that a director like Nelson should avoid like the plague. One of his strengths is his ability to approach familiar commercial-film conventions with an irreverent sensibility, using dark comedy, unexpected character behaviour and distinctive staging to make his films feel different from the usual formula. <em>Doctor</em> and the first <em>Jailer</em> showed glimpses of that strength, and it demonstrates how easily Nelson’s distinctive instincts can be swallowed by the very Tamil/Telugu commercial-cinema conventions he should be challenging.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*emiQWI8_eQvMaSz2.png" /><figcaption>Jailer (2023) Still</figcaption></figure><h3>An Unnecessarily Confusing Subplot</h3><p>One of the most irritating aspects of the first half is Yogi Babu’s character, because it is never made sufficiently clear whether he is supposed to be playing the same character from the first movie or a different one.</p><p>At times, he seems to be playing the same character. At other times, he appears to be an entirely different person. The film never properly explains the situation, and the way the characters interact with one another only makes the confusion worse.</p><p>In the first movie, Yogi Babu was part of Rajinikanth’s crew when they were taking down Varman. In the sequel, however, he appears to be introduced as someone who works for the same organisation involved in stealing statues.</p><p>The problem is that when Rajinikanth and Yogi Babu talk to each other, their interactions do not make it seem as though Yogi Babu is undercover or that Rajinikanth has deliberately placed him in that organisation to steal the statues.</p><p>If that is what is happening, the film needs to establish it properly.</p><p>Instead, their conversations make it seem as though Yogi Babu is a different person altogether. Then, in other scenes, he seems to be the same character from the first movie.</p><p>This is extremely irritating because the audience is left trying to work out what the film actually intends. Is he the same person? Is he undercover? Has Rajinikanth put him in this position as part of a larger plan? Or is the sequel simply treating him as a different character whenever it is convenient?</p><p>The film does not provide enough clarity.</p><p>One of the early bits in the first half involves the water-main worker wanting revenge on Rajinikanth because Rajinikanth beat his nephew, or someone connected to him. He tries to get revenge by interfering with the water supply.</p><p>Rajinikanth subsequently fixes the problem and beats the water employee. The worker then wants revenge on Rajinikanth, so he calls his local gangster contact.</p><p>That gangster then makes Rajini a part of his crew, forcing him to drive for him for free and become one of his henchmen.</p><p>All of this is extremely confusing because the film gives no convincing indication that any of these events are part of Rajinikanth’s plan.</p><p>The gangster seems like an idiot, and Rajinikanth somehow manages to turn him into part of a larger plan that will eventually lead him to Varman’s partner, played by Suraj.</p><p>But how?</p><p>There is no proper explanation of how Rajinikanth intends to use this person, how the various events are connected, or whether he has anticipated any of what happens. It simply looks as though Rajinikanth is laying low and pretending to be an ordinary person, while a series of coincidences gradually brings him into contact with the people he needs to reach, aka Suraj.</p><p>The water-main worker’s actions then lead to him getting beaten and then Rajini is threatened by the local gangster, and he goes along with the situation because he is pretending to be a normal person.</p><p>Then Yogi Babu coincidentally runs into Rajinikanth in his car.</p><p>Yogi Babu does not seem to recognise him, even though they worked together in the first movie.</p><p>That makes the situation even more confusing. Is he undercover? Is Rajinikanth deliberately using him as part of the plan? If they are working together, why do their interactions not make that clear?</p><p>And then there is the statue.</p><p>Yogi Babu is running around with a statue that is connected to Varman’s partner Suraj. That is another extraordinary coincidence. Unless Rajinikanth has deliberately arranged for Yogi Babu to be undercover and steal the statue as part of his operation, the entire situation seems ridiculously contrived.</p><p>But that is not properly explained either.</p><p>The film leaves the audience to fill in the gaps and assume that all these coincidences must somehow be part of Rajinikanth’s plan.</p><p>The confusion continues because the film does suggest that Yogi Babu discovers the water-main worker is working for Rajinikanth. However, there is still no clear explanation of how that arrangement came about.</p><p>You might assume that the worker starts working for Rajinikanth after Rajinikanth beats him. But the worker initially wants revenge on Rajinikanth, and he calls the local gangster to threaten him remember.</p><p>At what point does the worker become part of Rajinikanth’s operation? Was that always the plan, or did Rajinikanth simply take advantage of a situation that happened by chance?</p><p>The film never makes this sufficiently clear.</p><p>The whole thing is so confusing and annoying because it involves several characters whose motivations and relationships are not properly established. The water-main worker, the local gangster, Yogi Babu, Rajinikanth and Varman’s partner Suraj are all connected through a series of events, but the movie does not convincingly explain how these events fit together.</p><p>Instead of feeling like an intelligent plan, it feels like a series of coincidences that the writers expect the audience to accept.</p><p>This subplot is also far too long for what it contributes to the movie. It takes up a substantial amount of the first half, yet it does not provide the clear, engaging setup that the sequel needs.</p><p>The filmmakers could have made this storyline work if they had established Rajinikanth’s intentions earlier, explained Yogi Babu’s role and shown how the water-main worker was being manipulated. They could have made it clear that Rajinikanth was deliberately allowing certain events to unfold so that he could get closer to Varman’s partner.</p><p>But the film does not do that.</p><p>Instead, we are left wondering whether the characters are supposed to be the same people from the first movie, whether they are undercover, whether Rajinikanth is in control of the situation, and why so many things happen by coincidence.</p><p>It is an extremely irritating example of a movie that seems to think it is being clever but has not put the pieces together properly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qqxQXTt0r7y0kYGc.jpg" /><figcaption>Suraj Venjaramoodu in Jailer 2 Promotional Video</figcaption></figure><h3>Suraj’s Character Is a Repetitive Copy of Varman</h3><p>Suraj does a good job in the role, but the character is unnecessary and repetitive. By the time the second half begins, the film has already spent so much time establishing this character and his operation that the transition to S. J. Suryah as the main villain makes the movie feel like two separate films.</p><p>Suraj’s character is killed at the beginning of the second half, and S. J. Suryah is introduced more prominently.</p><p>The movie spends a substantial amount of time building up one villain, only to get rid of him and shift its attention to another.</p><p>Why?</p><p>S. J. Suryah should have been the main villain from the beginning. There was no need to spend so much time on a lesser villain who essentially repeats what Varman did in the first movie.</p><p>Suraj performs well, but the character adds very little that is genuinely new. The filmmakers should have concentrated on S. J. Suryah and built the story around him, rather than repeating the same kind of villain setup before moving on to the actual main antagonist.</p><p>There is also a problem with the way the villains are presented. Varman was a relatively low-class villain despite supposedly having access to millions of rupees. Suraj’s character is similarly presented as a low-class villain, dressing like a hobo despite supposedly having millions.</p><p>The first half spends too much time on these low-class setups, even though the sequel should have moved beyond them.</p><p>We have already seen this kind of villain in the first movie. The sequel should have progressed to something more sophisticated, more ambitious and more high-class from the beginning.</p><p>The film does eventually introduce a higher-class villain. But that is precisely why it is frustrating that so much time is spent on the same old setup first.</p><p>The low-class characters are working for a high-class villain anyway, so why not introduce the high-class villain from the beginning and build the story around them?</p><p>The movie could still have had henchmen, criminal organisations and smaller antagonists, but they should have served the larger story rather than repeating the structure of the first film.</p><h3>The Cameos: Hrithik Roshan and Mohanlal Should Have Been Far More Important</h3><p>The cameos are another major problem. They are not substantial enough, and they appear at convenient, often predictable moments rather than being integrated meaningfully into the story.</p><p>The issue is not simply that the cameos are short. A cameo can be brief and still be memorable if it has a strong purpose, a great action sequence or a meaningful relationship with the main character. The problem here is that the film repeatedly introduces major actors without making sufficient use of them.</p><h4>Hrithik Roshan</h4><p>Hrithik Roshan’s cameo should have been one of the best and most substantial parts of the movie. It should have been much closer to Mohanlal’s contribution in the previous film, with Hrithik being a complete, larger-than-life ass-kicker who makes a genuine difference to the story.</p><p>Instead, he barely does anything.</p><p>He has a really cool look, and the character has the potential to be extremely memorable. But the filmmakers do not give him enough to do. The result is a cameo that feels like a box-ticking exercise rather than a proper showcase for a major star.</p><p>Why bring in an actor of Hrithik Roshan’s calibre if you are not going to give him a substantial action sequence?</p><p>He should have been the one driving the car and taking down the plane at the end of the movie. His character had already been established as someone associated with muscle cars, and he was literally present at the Goa building with his girls. It therefore would have made sense for him to arrive with a car and play a major role in the action.</p><p>Mohanlal had not been established as being in Goa. This is another example of the movie making characters appear or disappear whenever it is convenient for the plot, rather than building the action around what has actually been established.</p><p>Hrithik should also have fought the other major characters in the cameos. In particular, he should have had a proper fight with S. J. Suryah. That could have been an epic confrontation, especially given the actors involved and the opportunity to build a memorable action sequence around them.</p><p>Instead, Hrithik’s main cameo amounts to two scenes, and in the second, he brings his girls, who are the ones doing the fighting.</p><p>That scene is terrible, clichéd, unrealistic and unconvincing. We have all these trained male soldiers who we know can fight, yet they barely manage to land a hit on the women. It feels as though the filmmakers simply wanted to get the clichéd scene out of the way, regardless of whether it made sense.</p><p>And Hrithik himself barely does anything!</p><p>Why not let him fight? Why not give him a proper action sequence against S. J. Suryah? Why not use his physical presence, screen persona and established action-star image to deliver something genuinely exciting?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/690/0*2csL5deMwudEp_tD" /><figcaption>Mohanlal in Jailer 2 Promotional Video</figcaption></figure><h4>Mohanlal</h4><p>The same criticism applies to Mohanlal. He is one of the coolest characters in this franchise, but he is barely present. He should have been given a substantial role in the action, including an epic fight with S. J. Suryah, Suraj or another major opponent. There were several ways to make his appearance count, yet the film barely uses him.</p><p>Hrithik Roshan and Mohanlal should not simply appear, deliver a few lines and disappear. They should be integral to the action, with proper fights, meaningful interactions and enough screen time to make their presence worthwhile.</p><p>There should have been much more extensive fighting and other action involving both actors. One of the best things about the first <em>Jailer</em> was that Rajini did not have to do everything himself. The supporting characters and his contacts could carry out the physical action while he instructed them and orchestrated the larger plan.</p><p>That was part of what made the first movie work.</p><p>But in <em>Jailer 2</em>, even the other characters barely do enough. We have multiple cameos, yet these characters are not given the action sequences they should have had.</p><p>What happened here? Was it a contract issue, a budget issue or a payment issue? I do not know. But the least the filmmakers could have done was give Hrithik at least one genuinely great scene. Instead, we get two mediocre scenes.</p><p>These are major actors who could have elevated the movie considerably, yet the filmmakers barely use them.</p><p>The film had so many opportunities to deliver memorable action sequences, but it squandered them. What is the point of bringing in such big actors if you are not going to do anything substantial with them?</p><h3>The wider problem with the cameos</h3><p>Beyond Hrithik and Mohanlal specifically, the wider problem is that the appearances are not developed properly.</p><p>The characters tend to arrive at very convenient moments, often when the plot needs someone to help resolve a situation. This makes the cameos predictable and raises questions about why these characters appear at certain times but not at others.</p><p>If Rajinikanth has these contacts, why does he not call them when he genuinely needs help? Why do they only appear when the story requires them to?</p><p>The film does not establish a convincing pattern for how or when these contacts are used. Instead, they appear to have been inserted because the filmmakers know the audience enjoyed the cameos in the first movie and expect the sequel to recreate that excitement.</p><p>But merely bringing back the same concept is not enough.</p><p>The filmmakers needed to give these appearances a proper purpose, establish why the characters were there and allow them to contribute meaningfully to the story.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Xj7NAaxTu827nWZX" /><figcaption>Shivarajkumar in Jailer (2023)</figcaption></figure><h3>The Returning Team Is Underused, and the Henchmen Are Unmemorable</h3><p>The first movie established a team with particular skills and abilities. The sequel should have built on that foundation, showing Rajinikanth working with his contacts, planning his moves and making use of their individual abilities.</p><p>Instead, the movie seems to assume that because we have already seen the first film, these guys are always there to help.</p><p>We see Shiva Rajkumar taken down, yet Rajinikanth still apparently has snipers available for some reason. But we do not even see the snipers properly. We do not see the four characters, and we do not get a convincing explanation for what has happened to them.</p><p>The same applies to the little person who was part of the team in the first movie. He is a really good ass-kicker, and he was one of the best parts of the Vendhu Thanindhathu Kaadu. Yet he barely does anything in <em>Jailer 2</em>.</p><p>Why bring back these characters if you are not going to use them properly?</p><p>There is no indication that Rajinikanth has worked particularly hard to maintain his contacts or bring more people into his network. We are simply expected to assume that all these people are still around and available whenever the plot requires them.</p><p>At the same time, the sequel’s interval scene seems to give Rajinikanth even more henchmen who we never see again after the interval.</p><p>It looks bad because the film asks us to accept that Rajinikanth has a substantial network of people, yet it does not make that network feel interesting, distinctive or particularly well organised.</p><p>The interval scene is a particularly good example. We see a huge group of men in Suraj’s warehouse while the characters reveal themselves and shoot his goons. First of all, there are too many of them. Secondly, they all look like ordinary people wearing ordinary clothes, including lungis, without anything particularly distinctive about their appearance.</p><p>The problem is not simply that their costumes are ordinary. It is that the film makes so little effort to give these characters any visual identity.</p><p>They look like random people who have been gathered together, and most of them are not memorable enough for the audience to distinguish them from one another. We barely see them again, either.</p><p>The makers do not need to make every minor character as memorable as someone in a Michael Bay movie, but they should at least put more care into the costumes and visual design.</p><p>A little effort would go a long way.</p><p>This also applies to Rajinikanth’s own appearance. The reason his character is dressed the way he is in <em>Jailer 2</em> seems to be that the previous movie established a particular look, and the makers feel they have to repeat it.</p><p>But they do not necessarily have to.</p><p>The sequel could have developed the character’s appearance in a way that felt appropriate to the new story. Instead, he often looks unnecessarily average, and there is very little about the appearance that makes it especially memorable.</p><p>The problem is not that Rajinikanth needs to wear something extravagant in every scene. It is that the film seems to have repeated a look without considering whether it actually serves this particular movie.</p><p>The villian henchmen too. They look interchangeable, and there is very little effort put into making them distinctive.</p><p>Nelson seems to struggle with villains in this respect. In the first <em>Jailer</em>, Varman was presented through a fairly clichéd local-goon setup, with the usual clothes and mannerisms.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ezcGX0wNVsDqO5N0v3ck0A.png" /><figcaption>Still from Doctor (2021)</figcaption></figure><h3>The Copying of Doctor and the Lack of Originality</h3><p>The way the villains are presented also highlights another problem: the film borrows heavily from Nelson’s own <em>Doctor</em>.</p><p>In <em>Doctor</em>, the villain is based in Goa, has a large mansion or chateau, and operates out of an underground lair. The main villain also has a father.</p><p><em>Jailer 2</em> uses many of the same ideas.</p><p>I do not know why Nelson decided to copy so much from his own earlier film, but I am not particularly surprised.</p><p>The problem is that when he moves away from the low-class villain setup of the first <em>Jailer</em> and introduces a higher-class villain, he seems to fall back on elements that he has already used elsewhere.</p><p>There is nothing inherently wrong with a villain having a large mansion, an underground lair or a father. Any one of these elements could work perfectly well in the right story. The problem is the accumulation of familiar ideas without enough originality or refinement to make them feel fresh.</p><p>The film also contains several contrived technological elements that feel as though they have been borrowed from other kinds of cinema without being thought through properly.</p><p>For example, Hrithik Roshan’s character has a retina scanner S. J. Suryah’s character has a handprint scanner alongside a revolving door and a trapdoor or floor door that leads to an underground lair.</p><p>There are so many unnecessary bits of nonsense like this that it becomes difficult to understand what the filmmakers are trying to achieve.</p><p>These elements feel less like intelligent world-building and more like things taken from old-school comic-book films, old James Bond films and other old movies.</p><p>This is supposed to be a modern, fresh film. Yet it frequently relies on contrived devices and familiar setups that do not make the story more convincing or interesting.</p><p>A director who has established himself as a fresh voice should be doing more than recycling the same kinds of ideas, especially when he has already shown that he can make distinctive films.</p><p>The problem is not influence. Every filmmaker takes inspiration from other films. The problem is when the influences are so obvious and the individual elements are so poorly integrated that the finished product feels derivative rather than original.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*bnXDVHDNioIPYLfb" /><figcaption>Upendra in Coolie (2025)</figcaption></figure><h3>The wider problem with inspirations</h3><p>This is also why <em>Coolie</em> (2025) is a useful comparison.</p><p>That film extensively borrowed from previous movies, incorporating familiar elements into a new story without always making them feel properly integrated. The hyena, the casting of another Kannada actor and the very presence of that character were all criticised for being derivative, including because they recalled elements from <em>Jailer</em>.</p><p>The issue is not that films cannot reference or borrow from other films. They can. But the filmmakers need to understand how those elements fit into the story and why they should be there.</p><p>The same applies to <em>Jailer 2</em>. The first movie had its snipers, its team, its contacts and its particular way of presenting Rajinikanth as someone who was always several steps ahead of his opponents.</p><p>The sequel repeats those elements, but it does not explain them properly.</p><p>In the first film, we saw Rajinikanth building his team. We saw him go to his old contacts and assemble the people he needed to take down Varman and find his son. That gave the team a clear purpose within the story.</p><p>In the sequel, the team already exists, but the filmmakers do not show enough of Rajinikanth working with them or using their individual abilities. Instead, we are expected to accept that the team is there because we saw it in the first movie.</p><p>The same is true of the cameos. The audience remembers the cameos from the original, so the sequel assumes that bringing back famous actors will automatically recreate the same excitement.</p><p>But that is not how it works.</p><p>Every film needs to establish its own context. The audience may remember what happened in the previous movie, but the new film still needs to explain why the characters are here, what they are doing and how their actions contribute to the story.</p><p>The sequel cannot simply rely on the audience remembering that Rajinikanth has contacts and assuming that everything will work out.</p><p>It needs to show us.</p><h3>Nelson’s Strengths Were Clear in the First Jailer, but the Sequel Looks Worse</h3><p>To understand why all of this is so frustrating, it is important to remember what worked in the first <em>Jailer</em>.</p><p>Nelson is a genuinely fresh filmmaker. His directing has a distinctive style, and the first <em>Jailer</em> demonstrated that he could combine commercial star elements with interesting visual choices, black comedy and a surprisingly robust sense of style.</p><p>The cinematography was one of the best parts of the film. The shots, the overall look and feel, and the visual presentation were genuinely impressive. There was a particular style to the way scenes were framed and presented, and the film had some of the best-looking shots I have seen in this industry.</p><p>The Latin American inspired look and feel, the <em>Breaking Bad</em>-like influences and the black-comedy elements all contributed to a distinctive atmosphere. Nelson seemed to understand how to make the film visually interesting while balancing the larger-than-life elements associated with Rajinikanth.</p><p>That is why the first <em>Jailer</em> was such a mixed but ultimately enjoyable experience. It was not perfect, and it had several weaknesses, but it was fresh in many areas. It felt robust, surprising and visually distinctive.</p><p>The sequel should have built on those strengths.</p><p>Instead, the cinematography, production design, colour palette and general visual presentation are all inferior to the first movie.</p><p>The first <em>Jailer</em> had some of the best shots I have seen in Indian cinema. The sequel, by comparison, often looks average.</p><p>This is particularly disappointing because Nelson and his cinematographer are clearly capable of doing this kind of work. They demonstrated it in the first film, so why does the sequel feel so much less impressive?</p><p>The makers should have worked hard to create another visually distinctive movie, perhaps even using a different leading actor if that would have allowed them to allocate more of the budget to the filmmaking itself.</p><p>Instead, we get a movie with a weaker visual identity and a much less convincing plot.</p><p>It is not simply a case of the sequel failing to surpass the original. Sequels do not always need to be bigger or better in every respect. But they should at least demonstrate that the filmmakers have learned from the previous film and are trying to develop its strongest qualities.</p><p>Here, the opposite often seems to be happening.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*3vjwL_dXyr1XE_1b.jpg" /><figcaption>Jailer (2021) Promotional Image</figcaption></figure><h3>The Production Values and CGI</h3><p>For a film of this supposed scale, there should have been more practical effects and greater attention to the quality of the visual effects.</p><p>Some of the CGI is extremely obvious. There are moments when the effects look so artificial that they take you out of the movie.</p><p>I understand that not every scene can be achieved through practical effects, and there are things that filmmakers simply cannot afford to do in a particular way. That is fine. But when the film can apparently afford to use CGI for things that should be relatively straightforward to achieve practically, it becomes difficult to understand where the money has gone.</p><p>For example, there are curtains falling down that are presented through CGI, and the effect looks incredibly artificial. Why use CGI for something like that when it should be possible to achieve a more convincing result through practical means?</p><p>The problem is not simply that the effects are imperfect. It is that the film’s overall production values do not match its ambitions.</p><p>The first <em>Jailer</em> grossed around ₹600 crore, and the sequel has an even higher budget. This is supposed to be a major commercial production with the potential to gross ₹1,000 crore.</p><p>But to reach that level, the filmmakers need to make the movie look like an event that audiences across the country should experience. They need to demonstrate that the scale, action, visual effects and production design justify the investment and the hype.</p><p>Instead, much of the film looks as though it was shot in an ordinary field somewhere.</p><p>There are not enough high-level visual elements to make the film feel like the large-scale spectacle it is supposed to be. The production design is too average, the CGI is too obvious, and the overall presentation lacks the polish that the budget should have allowed.</p><p>If the filmmakers want audiences across India to turn up for a film of this scale, they need to make it look and feel worth watching on the big screen.</p><p>As it stands, the movie does not consistently achieve that.</p><h3>The Item Songs</h3><p>There are two item dances in the movie, and the one featuring Nora is particularly horrible.</p><p>Why are we still doing this crap?</p><p>Why is Nelson, who is supposed to be a higher-level, fresher director, going backwards with this kind of material?</p><p>It makes no sense.</p><p>The first <em>Jailer</em> had a song involving a movie set, which at least gave the scene a particular context.</p><p>But <em>Jailer 2</em> does not repeat the same kind of thing. The item dances are unnecessary, and both of them are annoying.</p><p>The first item dance was less sexually explicit than the second, but neither adds enough to justify its inclusion. I wanted to fast-forward through them.</p><p>The songs themselves are also average. They are not particularly enjoyable to listen to, and they do not have the impact that the filmmakers presumably wanted.</p><p>More importantly, the songs and music videos feel like attempts to recreate elements from the first movie without understanding why they worked.</p><p>They are essentially reminders of things we have seen before, only worse.</p><p>It feels as though the makers are working extremely hard to capture the magic of the original again, but they simply cannot do it.</p><p>So these songs showcase the problem with the movie as a whole.</p><p>The result is a sequel that repeatedly reminds you of the original without delivering the same level of excitement.</p><p>And this is a problem with many modern films. They assume that audiences will respond positively to familiar elements simply because they worked previously. But familiarity is not enough. The filmmakers need to understand why those elements worked and develop them in a way that makes sense for the new story.</p><p>Otherwise, they are simply repeating themselves.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*B2XOBUCH6m1Zwg7T.jpg" /><figcaption>Still from Beast (2022)</figcaption></figure><h3>The Wider Problem With Indian Cinema: Star Vehicles and the Decline in Quality</h3><p>This brings me to the wider problem with Indian cinema, particularly the way large-scale commercial films are being made.</p><p>The issue is not restricted to <em>Jailer 2</em>. There are plenty of examples of filmmakers who have had success with one movie and then struggled to reproduce that success in their later work.</p><p>The core problem is that the public expects something great, and the filmmakers also want to create something great, but they do not always have enough new ideas or the discipline to make those ideas work.</p><p>They end up repeating familiar elements, relying on nostalgia and assuming that audiences will be satisfied because they recognise something from an earlier film.</p><p>But that is not enough.</p><p>A new film should ideally be more refined, more intelligent and more ambitious than what came before. That does not mean every new movie must be bigger or more expensive, but filmmakers should be learning from their previous work and developing their craft.</p><p>That is how cinema should progress.</p><p>Indian cinema did seem to be moving in that direction for a while. I remember seeing genuinely good, high-level work in 2016, ten years ago. There has been plenty of excellent filmmaking since then, especially in smaller-scale productions and particularly from Kerala.</p><p>But there has also been a lot of bad filmmaking, including from Kerala, and the larger industries have struggled in different ways.</p><p>Tamil cinema, in particular, has struggled to deliver the kind of ambitious, large-scale pan-Indian franchises that Telugu and Kannada cinema have attempted with their ₹1,000-crore films and major commercial franchises.</p><p>Tamil cinema has barely tried to operate at that level. If I remember correctly, <em>Kanguva</em> was one of the few films that really attempted it. Other films, such as <em>Leo</em>, did not seem to make the same level of effort in terms of a proper pan-Indian release, and the first <em>Jailer</em> also did not fully pursue that kind of nationwide strategy.</p><p>With <em>Jailer 2</em>, you would have assumed that the filmmakers would make a much bigger effort to reach audiences across India. But the film still does not seem to have the level of ambition, polish and execution required to justify that expectation.</p><p>The problem is not simply the size of the budget or the scale of the marketing. It is the quality of the filmmaking.</p><p>If you want to make a pan-Indian blockbuster, you need to deliver a film that looks and feels like a major event. The story needs to be convincing, the action needs to be memorable, the characters need to be interesting, and the production values need to justify the scale.</p><p>You cannot simply assemble a large cast, add cameos, include familiar commercial elements and expect the audience to do the rest.</p><p>That is precisely what frustrates me about <em>Jailer 2</em>. It has so many of the ingredients that should make it a major commercial success, but it does not put them together properly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YfCz3eht5Se2KblGtLauzw.png" /><figcaption>Still from Doctor (2021)</figcaption></figure><h3>Nelson is at his best when he has no compromises</h3><p>I think Nelson is at his peak when he is allowed to work without compromising his ideas to accommodate a superstar’s image.</p><p>When he has to make compromises for a superstar such as Vijay, the results can be terrible. There are promising, fresh elements in his work, but those elements can be overwhelmed by the weaker commercial conventions that the film feels obliged to include.</p><p><em>Beast</em> is an example of this problem.</p><p>There were interesting ideas and potentially good elements, but they were undermined by the way the film handled its star vehicle, action and other commercial requirements.</p><p>By contrast, <em>Doctor</em> was a much better example of Nelson working with a more coherent vision. It felt as though the film’s central concept was allowed to guide the story rather than being repeatedly interrupted by the need to accommodate a superstar’s image.</p><p>That is not to say <em>Doctor</em> was perfect.</p><p>There is still romance in the movie, but it is connected to the arranged-marriage premise rather than being a typical romantic subplot. There are also songs, although only one really functions as a substantial, distracting music-video sequence. The film has some of the usual sentimental material that does not necessarily fit perfectly with a black comedy.</p><p>But those elements are more manageable because the film has a clearer identity. It feels like an all-rounder designed for Indian audiences, while still retaining a distinctive central concept.</p><p>The problem with these star-led movies is that the commercial requirements can overwhelm the director’s strengths.</p><p>The filmmaker may have fresh ideas, but then the film has to accommodate the superstar’s image, conventional action scenes, songs, sentimental moments and other familiar elements. The result can be a movie that contains some good ideas but fails to make them work together.</p><p><em>Jailer 2</em> suffers from a similar problem. There are flashes of Nelson’s strengths, but too much of the film feels like an attempt to recreate the commercial success of the first movie without understanding what made it effective.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*zZTvf_zhtpM1CSXq" /><figcaption>Kabali (2016) Promotional Image</figcaption></figure><h3>P. A. Ranjith has shown that star vehicles can be better</h3><p>This is why I find P. A. Ranjith’s approach to star-led filmmaking so interesting.</p><p>His two movies with Rajinikanth are not simply conventional star vehicles that do everything possible to make the leading actor look invincible. They still contain star elements, but those elements are used more sparingly and in ways that fit the overall film.</p><p>The movies are convincing because the director challenges the concept of the star vehicle rather than simply accepting every convention associated with it.</p><p>And he was doing this ten years ago.</p><p>If P. A. Ranjith can challenge the formula and make it work, why does the industry seem to be getting worse rather than better?</p><p>Why are filmmakers continuing to rely on the same tired ideas when they have already seen that it is possible to make more interesting, intelligent and distinctive films around major stars?</p><p>The same applies to other industries. The only direction cinema should be moving in is towards better filmmaking, more refined storytelling and more thoughtful use of commercial elements.</p><p>Of course, there will always be good films and bad films. Not every experiment will succeed, and not every filmmaker will produce their best work every time.</p><p>But when an industry repeatedly makes the same mistakes, especially after demonstrating that it can do better, it becomes frustrating.</p><p><em>Jailer 2</em> is a particularly disappointing example because Nelson has already shown that he can make a fresh, visually distinctive commercial film. The first <em>Jailer</em> had many strengths, even though it also had weaknesses.</p><p>The sequel should have built on those strengths, improved the weaker elements and delivered something more ambitious.</p><p>Instead, it often feels as though the makers are simply repeating what worked before without understanding why it worked.</p><p>Too many filmmakers seem to be moving backwards, recycling ideas and relying on familiar commercial conventions rather than refining their storytelling and improving their craft.</p><h3>What the Film Should Have Done Differently</h3><p>The solution was not particularly complicated.</p><p>The film should have shortened the first half, established the major conflicts earlier and made the threat to Rajinikanth’s family the driving force of the story. The stolen statues and the larger criminal organisation should have been central to the plot, rather than being underexplored elements buried beneath a series of mundane situations.</p><p>Suraj’s character should have been reduced or removed, with S. J. Suryah established as the main villain from the beginning. This would have avoided the repetitive Varman-style setup and allowed the film to develop one substantial antagonist rather than spending so much time on one villain before replacing him with another.</p><p>The revelation about Rajinikanth’s son should have happened earlier, and the consequences should have been explored properly. The family should not have turned against him and then returned to his side almost immediately because of Vidya Balan’s speech. The conflict needed to be developed rather than rushed through.</p><p>Yogi Babu’s role should have been clearly established. If he was undercover, the film should have explained how and why. If he was playing the same character from the first movie, his interactions with Rajinikanth should have reflected that. The water-main worker, the local gangster and the statue-stealing operation should have been integrated into a coherent plan rather than being connected through a series of coincidences.</p><p>The returning team members should also have been used properly. The four snipers and the little person from the first movie should have had meaningful roles, with Rajinikanth shown working with his contacts and deploying them intelligently.</p><p>Hrithik Roshan and Mohanlal should have been given substantial action sequences, including proper fights against the major villains. Hrithik should have driven the Mustang and played a more significant role in taking down the plane, while both actors should have had memorable scenes that justified their inclusion.</p><p>The costumes and production design needed more care. Rajinikanth’s appearance should have been developed rather than repeated without thought, and the henchmen should have had more distinctive visual identities. The CGI should have been more convincing, the practical effects should have been used more effectively, and the cinematography and colour palette should have matched or surpassed the quality of the first movie.</p><p>Finally, the songs and item dances should have been removed. The film did not need to repeat the same commercial elements simply because they were present in the original.</p><p>These changes could have transformed the sequel into a much more focused and exciting film. They would have allowed the makers to preserve what worked about the first <em>Jailer</em> while developing the story, characters and action in a meaningful way.</p><p><strong>A much better movie was sitting right there, but the makers squandered it.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eb06af8ffd83" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bethlehem Kudumba Unit Movie Review]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TheRamblerReviews/bethlehem-kudumba-unit-movie-review-cdc7b2cbfee0?source=rss-369e2eb4f425------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cdc7b2cbfee0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-cinema]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nivin-pauly]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[malayalam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-reviews]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Rambler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 11 Oct 2026 17:05:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-11T17:05:03.671Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>6/10</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*mxt6bKOwiRzAJO7n.jpeg" /><figcaption>Bethlehem Kudumba Unit Movie still</figcaption></figure><p>Thankfully, it wasn&#39;t as insulting as Premalu.</p><p>Girish has included some of those low-effort elements here and there, but thankfully, they’re not nearly as bad this time around.</p><p>However, that doesn’t mean everything else is strong. The whole movie as a whole is just weak. I heard a YouTuber call it average, and honestly, that’s exactly what it is. It’s a very average movie.</p><p>Still, it’s extremely understandable why this movie became the highest-grossing Malayalam movie ever. It’s very relatable and identifiable.</p><p>It’s not realistic. That’s fine, though. The Indian audience doesn’t necessarily want realism, and that includes the Kerala audience. People seem to think the Kerala audience is somehow more realistic in its tastes, but I’ve said this before: the majority of the audience doesn’t particularly care about the award-level movies that come out of the state, enter festivals, and go viral among certain circles. They like this kind of movie, and that’s exactly why this became the highest-grossing Malayalam movie ever.</p><p>I mean, <em>Vaazha</em> 2 also became one of the highest-grossing movies, grossing over ₹200 crore. That’s not a surprise either, because <em>Vaazha</em> and <em>Vaazha 2</em> are both extremely easygoing, relatable, and identifiable movies. They’re not realistic, groundbreaking, over-the-top spectacles, or examples of epic writing. They’re not trying to be any of those things. They’re exactly what they look like on the tin.</p><p>This is also why the Nivin starrer <em>Premam</em> grossed ₹65 crore in 2015.</p><p>The point is that audiences don’t necessarily need a movie to be realistic or groundbreaking to enjoy it. Sometimes, they just want something familiar, accessible, and easy to connect with. There’s nothing inherently wrong with that. The problem is when people confuse a movie’s popularity with its quality or assume that because something is relatable, it must also be well-written. Those are two different things.</p><p>This movie has a lot of weaknesses, particularly when it comes to scenes that simply aren’t fully developed. Certain parts feel as though they were put together in a hurry, almost like a first draft script that was never properly revised. You have an idea in mind when writing a first draft, but you haven’t fully fleshed it out yet. You know what you want to happen, but you haven’t worked out the details, motivations, or connections that would make it convincing. That’s how several parts of this movie feel.</p><p>Other movies, including previous movies from this director, have fleshed out their scenes much better. The problem isn’t necessarily that the ideas here are bad. It’s that they’re often introduced without being developed properly, leaving scenes that feel incomplete or as though the filmmakers haven’t thought through what they’re doing.</p><p>The overall look and feel of the filmmaking also don’t seem as good as in <em>Premalu</em>. That movie looked more high-quality, whereas this one just looks average. The difference is noticeable, and it makes this movie feel less polished overall.</p><p>The fights aren’t very good either. That doesn’t mean they should have gone over the top or made them more heavily choreographed. Of course not! If you’re trying to be realistic, the fights have to be more grounded. That’s perfectly understandable.</p><p>The problem is that these fights simply don’t feel good at all. They feel flimsy, but not in the way realistic fights can be flimsy because real people aren’t necessarily good at fighting. The fights feel flimsy in the sense that the filmmakers don’t seem to have put much effort into making them work. They don’t feel convincingly staged, and they don’t have the impact they should. There’s a difference between deliberately making a fight look unpolished to reflect reality and making it look unpolished because the filmmaking itself feels underdeveloped.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*iAB1pnlafPzp_igP.jpg" /><figcaption>Bethlehem Kudumba Unit Movie still</figcaption></figure><h3>The Usual Clown Nonsense</h3><p>Speaking of low effort, we still get the usual clown nonsense from this director.</p><p>In the previous movie, it was insane. It was also rampant in <em>Lokah: Chapter One</em>, although Girish didn’t direct that movie. It almost seemed as though he had possessed that director, because the nonsense was horrific to watch. I wrote about that in my review.</p><p>We get some of that here, just not as much. The problem is that it still doesn’t make sense.</p><p>We’ve had comedy movies from this industry and other industries for decades. Comedy isn’t some new concept that filmmakers are only just learning how to write. For some reason, though, modern filmmakers have become really lazy about it. They make characters say or do extremely forced, unnatural, unrealistic, and unconvincing things for no reason other than that the writer or director came up with the idea and thought it was cool.</p><p>The exact same thing happened in <em>Premalu</em>.</p><p>Everything is toned down here, of course. However, I don’t think Girish toned it down because he received backlash for the previous movie. I think he toned it down because he was trying to create a more realistic, standard Kerala family setting, with realistic names, realistic costumes, and so on. That is different from <em>Premalu</em>, which was trying to be more urban and youth-focused.</p><p>Still, there are scenes that make absolutely no sense.</p><p>Take the scene where, spoiler alert, Joel comes home and talks crap about Justin after finding out that Justin is in a relationship with Ashley.</p><p>For some reason, when Justin walks up behind Joel, the father tells him to beat Joel. Why?</p><p>It’s there purely for comedy. It doesn’t make any sense within the situation. Joel is behaving like the usual comedic clown throughout, and his girlfriend is also a clown. Why?</p><p>The problem isn’t that characters shouldn’t behave comically. It’s that their behaviour should still make sense within the context of the story. If a character does something ridiculous, there needs to be some reason for it, whether it’s a believable personality trait, an understandable reaction, or a situation that naturally lends itself to comedy. Simply making someone behave like an idiot because the director thinks it’ll be funny isn’t good writing.</p><p>There are also unnecessary references. For example, there’s a reference to a film. That movie had terrible, cringeworthy scenes that went viral, and Joel’s girlfriend re-enacts a scene from it as if it is serious and she is practicing her lines for a film/play she is going to do. Why bring that into this movie? What purpose does it serve? Do these people have no sense?</p><p>Then there’s the <em>Kantara</em> reference, which again makes no sense because this character isn’t supernatural. Where did he get supernatural powers from?</p><p>The character is a theatre actor, yet, for some reason, he suddenly gets <em>Kantara</em> powers. Those powers are then used for about a minute before he falls into a well.</p><p>The problem is that this entire sequence is completely useless to the movie. Everything in a movie or story should connect to something and serve a purpose. A scene can be funny, dramatic, or completely absurd, but it should still contribute something to the overall story. It should develop a character, advance the story, establish something that becomes relevant later, or at least deliver comedy that works within the scene.</p><p>Instead, they just put this in because they thought it would be funny. It doesn’t make any sense, and it’s dumb, really low-quality filmmaking.</p><p>This director’s previous movie made over ₹150 crore, so he was practically guaranteed to make money with his next one if he did something similar. That’s exactly what he did. For some reason, though, he either couldn’t get a higher budget or simply didn’t bother trying to do anything more ambitious, as the said Kantara scene is also flimsy and not Kantara level. Kantara cost only 15 crores to make by the way.</p><p>The whole thing just doesn’t seem to be put together properly.</p><p>Another problem is that we’re expected to take it for granted that people will be upset about Ashley and Justin getting together, even though there’s no real indication of that at all. We’re simply told that its a bad idea.</p><p>That’s a cardinal sin of filmmaking. Always show, don’t tell. Don’t just tell us that people will be upset. Show us why they would be upset, establish those feelings through the characters and their actions, and give us a reason to believe that this is a genuine problem.</p><p>If the filmmakers want us to believe that the relationship will cause serious problems within the family, they need to establish those problems properly. We should understand the family’s attitudes, see how those attitudes affect the characters, and witness the consequences of the relationship developing. Otherwise, the conflict feels manufactured simply because the story needs one.</p><p>This is a recurring issue with the movie. It introduces situations that could have been interesting, but it doesn’t do enough to establish them convincingly. Instead, we’re expected to accept whatever the movie tells us, even when the characters’ behaviour and the events on screen don’t give us much reason to believe it.</p><h3>The Family Dynamics Make No Sense</h3><p>For some reason, Ashley’s Father is barely shown after the love affair is discovered. Ashley’s brother also barely appears, if at all, during this part of the story. The same applies to Justin’s mother.</p><p>Ashley’s mother is shown, and she’s angry. She’s beating Ashley and eventually locking her up in her grandparents’ house. The grandparents are also portrayed as clowns, behaving in an unrealistic manner when they could have been more supportive or, at the very least, caring.</p><p>They should have been fleshed-out characters with their own personalities, motivations, and ways of dealing with the situation. Instead, they’re turned into cartoons.</p><p>The mother is against the relationship simply for the sake of it, with no convincing reason.</p><p>I understand that this country and this state aren’t fully at a Western level in terms of social attitudes. That’s fine. I’m not expecting every family to have modern, liberal attitudes towards relationships. However, the scene in which Ashley is forced to promise that she will marry someone she’s told to marry makes no sense in this particular family setting.</p><p>Why are we going backwards to the 1970s?</p><p>Even in the modern age, arranged marriages generally involve the consent of the people getting married. They have to agree, and they have to have the final say. An arranged marriage is essentially just a different kind of dating. You find someone you like through a website or through your family, but then you still have to get to know that person and decide whether they’re the right one for you.</p><p>You aren’t supposed to be told to marry someone simply because your parents have pointed them out.</p><p>I’m not going to claim that this kind of situation doesn’t exist at all. It might exist in certain kinds of families, and I’m not denying that there are parents who try to control their children’s marriages. However, this is a normal-looking family in which everything else seems relatively normal. The way the family is portrayed doesn’t make the mother’s behaviour convincing.</p><p>The issue is that the movie doesn’t properly establish why this family would behave in such an extreme manner. If the mother is supposed to be so controlling, we need some indication of where that attitude comes from and why she’s so determined to oppose the relationship. Otherwise, it feels as though she’s behaving this way simply because the plot requires an obstacle.</p><p>The ending itself proves this point. When Ashley and Justin finally get together, nothing happens. The father holds the mother back from beating Ashley and gives her a speech.</p><p>Where the hell was he all this time?</p><p>Why was he barely involved when the situation was actually developing, only to suddenly appear at the end, give a speech, and have the entire situation resolved?</p><p>Why does the mother suddenly change her attitude after that speech? What has actually changed in her thinking? The movie doesn’t properly establish any of this.</p><p>If the father had been involved throughout the conflict, perhaps his intervention at the end would have felt like the culmination of his character arc. If the mother had been shown reconsidering her position, perhaps her change of heart would have felt earned. Instead, the father is barely present during the important developments, and then suddenly his words are enough to resolve everything.</p><p>That’s lazy writing. You can’t establish a major conflict, leave the relevant characters underdeveloped, and then resolve everything with a conveniently timed speech.</p><p>The same problem applies to Joel’s girlfriend’s brother. He is against the marriage, and he’s the one who turns into the <em>Kantara</em> character. For some reason, though, he’s suddenly okay with the marriage.</p><p>Why?</p><p>What changed his mind? Did he have some sort of character development that I missed? The movie doesn’t make that clear.</p><p>Another strange decision is that Ashley’s parents want to attend Joel’s wedding, even though the wedding is for Justin’s brother. Justin got together with their daughter which they hated.</p><p>Why would they simply go to this wedding?</p><p>If they were genuinely opposed to the relationship and had such a problem with the family, why would they suddenly be comfortable attending the wedding? The movie doesn’t properly explain the change in attitude. It simply moves forward as though the earlier conflict no longer matters.</p><p>This is very <em>Balan</em>-esque. People praised and loved that movie, but it had multiple unanswered questions that didn’t make any sense. It felt as though the filmmakers were simply too lazy to work out the answers or didn’t know what to do with their own story.</p><p>The same problem exists here. The filmmakers introduce conflicts, establish certain attitudes, and then conveniently abandon them when the plot needs to move forward or vice versa. They don’t properly resolve these issues through character development. They just move on and expect us to accept everything.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*D5Qd420V3dAQIKQ9" /><figcaption>Nivin Pauly and Mamitha Biaju with Director Girish A.D</figcaption></figure><h3>Clown Mania</h3><p>Joel’s girlfriend’s brother is also a clown, and the actor played essentially the same character in <em>Premalu</em>.</p><p>Ashwunth Kok, in his <em>Toxic</em> review, said towards the end that a bunch of clowns come in. That’s exactly what happened in <em>Premalu</em>.</p><p>This actor brought in a bunch of clowns at the end to beat up Mamitha and Naslen. He ended up playing essentially the same kind of character again: the love-conflict clown who appears and does things for no reason other than that the director thinks they’re funny.</p><p>In the previous movie, he was her boss. Here, we’re going backwards, and he’s the girlfriend’s brother. The brother who doesn’t want his sister to have a boyfriend. How original.</p><p>For some reason, Joel’s girlfriend’s mother is fine with Joel dating her. When Justin and Joel go to talk to the brother, the mother says something along the lines of, “Hey, he’s not here. Quickly, get out of here with the girl.”</p><p>So the mother is fine with this?</p><p>The movie doesn’t seem to know what it wants these characters to think or how it wants them to behave. Their attitudes change depending on what the scene requires, rather than being based on any consistent characterisation.</p><p>There’s another issue with the brother. He says that they’re from a family of artists, yet they refuse to let the girl participate in the short film.</p><p>Why?</p><p>They even make a joke about how they’re not making an explicit movie; they’re making a normal short film. Despite that, for some reason, he doesn’t think it’s a good idea for her to participate.</p><p>A short film could potentially help her develop her acting career. Surely a family that supposedly consists of artists would understand that.</p><p>The characters just say things without providing any real reasoning behind their decisions.</p><p>That’s the problem with this character. The movie doesn’t establish why he would object to something that could help someone in his own family pursue acting. If there’s a legitimate reason for his opposition, the filmmakers need to give it to us. If there isn’t, then why is he behaving this way?</p><p>Instead, we’re left with another character who seems to exist purely to create an obstacle or deliver a joke. He’s not a convincing person with a coherent set of motivations. He’s just another clown.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*CSPs5qQqL44R15_U.jpg" /><figcaption>Bethlehem Kudumba Unit Movie still</figcaption></figure><h3>The Usual Misandry and Clowning on Men</h3><p>Of course, we also get the usual nonsense from Girish A.D., where he has female characters put men down by clowning on them for no reason.</p><p><em>Premalu</em> was full of this. It was basically bullying and castration. In <em>Lokah: Chapter One</em>, it was rampant sexism.</p><p>Thankfully, it’s much lighter here, but it’s still present.</p><p>Take Justin. He’s supposed to be a closed-off, tough, mature guy with nice masculine energy. He’s a nice person, and he’s presented as someone who has a certain level of masculinity and self-control. Yet Ashley repeatedly insults him for no reason other than that the filmmakers think it’s funny.</p><p>What exactly is the point of this?</p><p>Men and masculinity, and anything associated with them, is portrayed in a negative light.</p><p>That’s why his female characters repeatedly crap on men and undermine whatever strength they might display. They keep pushing the male characters down, often for the sake of comedy.</p><p>Usually, Naslen is the one who does these kinds of characters. He did it in <em>Super Sharanya</em>, too. Girish recycled a lot of <em>Super Sharanya</em> into <em>Premalu</em>.</p><p>Thankfully, the recycling wasn’t as rampant in this movie, but it’s still present, and it’s not good at all. Whenever it happens, it’s extremely annoying.</p><p>The problem is that the director repeatedly seems to treat male characters’ strength, composure, and masculinity as things that need to be undermined or mocked.</p><p>A male character can be strong, mature, reserved, or stoic, but the movie seems to feel the need to make him look like a clown sooner or later. The female characters then insult him or put them down, and we’re expected to find the whole thing funny.</p><p>That’s not particularly clever comedy. It becomes repetitive, predictable, and irritating.</p><p>The female characters also barely get anything back from the men, as Girish seems too scared to show that happening. Maybe he will get a strong email from the WCC.</p><p>That’s another part of the problem. If the comedy is supposed to come from the characters’ personalities and their interactions, why does it so often seem to work in only one direction? Why are the men repeatedly made to look foolish while the women are allowed to insult them without receiving the same treatment in return?</p><p>Strength doesn’t mean having girls forcefully dunk on men and men stand there like they have selective hearing loss making monkey sounds. The writing repeatedly makes male characters the target of humiliation while expecting the audience to accept it as comedy. It starts feeling less like natural character interaction and more like the filmmaker has an agenda that he wants to push through these scenes.</p><p>This is especially frustrating when the male character is otherwise presented as a decent person. Justin is supposed to be mature, reserved, and tough, yet the movie repeatedly undermines those qualities for cheap laughs. Rather than exploring his personality, it keeps finding ways to make him look foolish.</p><h3>Character Issues and Missing Points</h3><p>Ashley herself is barely a character. Justin, on the other hand, has a nice character, but his backstory is barely explored. I would have loved to see much more of his background and to have him developed into a genuinely fleshed-out character.</p><p>Instead, the movie spends so much time thinking it is in a circus neglects the opportunity to explore him as a person.</p><p>His reserved nature, his maturity, and the way he handles situations could have been explored much more deeply. Those qualities could have made him a genuinely compelling romantic lead, especially if the movie had allowed us to understand what he was thinking and feeling.</p><p>Ashley, meanwhile, has to move house at the beginning like Meiyazhagan. She’s upset about it, and, for some reason, they apparently can’t bring all their belongings with them.</p><p>Is the new house rented or bought? We don’t know.</p><p>We’re told that they have financial issues, yet they still send her to Ireland. Usually, it’s the youngsters who want to go abroad for further studies or other opportunities, while the parents are more reluctant. Here, the parents themselves seem to be encouraging the trip.</p><p>They essentially tell her that they’ve sold the property, her Ireland trip is ready, and she should get going.</p><p>The whole thing feels strangely disconnected from the financial difficulties we’re supposedly meant to believe the family is experiencing.</p><p>This is another example of how the movie introduces details without properly developing them. The family has financial issues, Ashley has to move house, and they apparently can’t take all their belongings with them and that also doesn’t get a reason.</p><p>How does all of that fit together?</p><p>The movie doesn’t seem particularly interested in answering these questions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9totnr6dSl8-EVK2.jpg" /><figcaption>Bethlehem Kudumba Unit Movie still</figcaption></figure><h3>Ashley and Justin’s Romance Is Not Convincing</h3><p>Ashley looks at Justin and seems interested in him, but there’s no real evidence of love beyond what we’re shown through a few looks, if anyone notices. We know she likes him but no one else would see this as she barely does anything. This is what I meant by how this feels like a first draft vs an actual fleshed out film. As the idea is there but they forgot to make the movie.</p><p>Just because we, as the audience, can see her looking at him doesn’t mean the other characters can automatically interpret those looks correctly.</p><p>For some reason, a nun picks up on Ashley looking at Justin and tells her that she knows her secret. Ashley then apparently spills the beans.</p><p>Why? How did the nun pick up on this? We barely saw anything that would justify such a conclusion. The nun actually starts looking at Ashley even before she sees Ashley looking at Justin. So was the nun interested in Ashley?</p><p>The movie expects us to accept that the nun has somehow figured out Ashley’s feelings, even though the evidence is barely there. It feels like another contrived moment that exists to move the plot forward rather than something that develops naturally from the characters’ behaviour.</p><p>Why can’t Ashley simply say, “No, I don’t,” when confronted?</p><p>Then the nun tells Justin.</p><p>Justin subsequently speaks to Ashley and gives her the usual speech about how the relationship may cause problems, even though he’s interested in her. Ashley immediately starts yelling at him, despite the fact that he hasn’t done anything wrong.</p><p>Why couldn’t she simply be nicer to him?</p><p>The excuse here might be that she knows he’s going to say no and is therefore trying to protect herself emotionally. Fine, that’s understandable. However, the movie doesn’t handle the situation in a particularly convincing way.</p><p>When they’re in the car, Justin tells her that he didn’t say no. Yet, instead of becoming nicer to him, she starts being rude again.</p><p>Then, when he finally says yes, she doesn’t react with happiness in the way Naslen did in <em>Premalu</em>. Instead, she continues being rude to him, asking why he made a show back there.</p><p>Even though he didn’t do anything wrong!</p><p>The movie then turns him into a weak clown character by having him say something along the lines of, “Oh, it’s just… I’m just pulling something.”</p><p>Why?</p><p>Romantic partners should generally be nice and kind to each other. That’s one of the things people want in a relationship, alongside physical attraction. They want someone with a good personality, someone who treats them well, and someone who makes them feel valued.</p><p>The movie doesn’t seem to understand this. Or is Girish simply dunking on men because he thinks feminism means women being nasty to men.</p><p>That’s what it starts to feel like when you look at the way these scenes are written. Ashley doesn’t have to be perfect, and she doesn’t have to behave nicely in every single situation. Characters can be flawed, rude, awkward, and difficult. The problem is that the movie repeatedly makes her behaviour towards Justin unpleasant without giving us enough positive moments to balance it out.</p><p>We barely see any genuinely good moments between Ashley and Justin. We’re expected to assume that those moments happen off-screen or during sequences where they’re talking while a song plays in the background, as they travel somewhere together, for example.</p><p>However, every single time they actually talk to each other, Ashley is hurting him, insulting him, or clowning on him.</p><p>Where is the romance?</p><p>What are we supposed to find appealing about this relationship?</p><p>A romance doesn’t become convincing simply because the filmmakers tell us that two people are in love. We need to see why they like each other, what they appreciate about each other, and what makes their relationship special.</p><p>We need to see them enjoying each other’s company, supporting each other, or sharing moments that help us understand why they want to be together. They don’t need to be constantly affectionate, and they don’t need to agree on everything. However, there should be something between them that makes the relationship believable and appealing.</p><p>Instead, we’re shown a guy who seems genuinely interested in a girl who repeatedly treats him like her ugly stepchild.</p><p>That’s the problem. The movie expects us to invest in their romance without giving us enough convincing evidence that the relationship is actually good for either of them.</p><p>Also, when Justin couldn’t reach Ashley in time for their meeting, she behaves like a child and ghosts/blocks him while continuing to speak to another guy, Glickson. Instead of taking the story in the correct direction; showing that Ashley is young and inexperienced, and that her immaturity leads her to behave unreasonably, the film makes Justin look like the bad guy and treats her rude behaviour as justified.</p><p>When he comes to pick her up, her face isn’t very happy to see him, even though he is trying to be nice to her. How does that make any sense? Why does he have to keep being nice to her? Why couldn’t he simply refuse to speak to her?</p><p>He is the one whose heart was shattered when his previous girlfriend died. He closed himself off emotionally until Ashley came along and opened him up again. Given that, Ashley should show some responsibility and respect for his feelings. Instead, she behaves like an asshole when he can’t make it to a meeting and doesn’t even apologise?</p><p>The film should have handled this differently. Ashley could have tried to contact Justin, only to discover that he had blocked her. When she eventually gets the chance to speak to him, he could explain why her behaviour was wrong, allowing her to recognise her mistake, regret her actions, learn from the experience and repent before they move on. That would highlight her childishness and lack of experience while giving her some meaningful character development.</p><p>Instead, Justin simply ends up carrying her bags, and they move on as though nothing happened.</p><h3>The Guy Ashley Leads On</h3><p>Then we get one of the worst problems in the movie, where Justin is made a fool of. What the hell is going on here?</p><p>Another clown, Glickson, likes Ashley. Instead of simply telling him that she doesn’t like him, she does the opposite.</p><p>When he comes to see her guitar show, we get another reference to another movie as he watches her show and eggs her on.</p><p>Ashley then calls Justin and tells him that this guy was giving her some looks, so she gave him some looks back.</p><p>Justin responds with something that I’m not surprised came out of this director’s mind.</p><p>He essentially says, “Oh, Glickson. Yeah, that’s fine. Let that continue.”</p><p>Seriously?</p><p>If a guy looks at another girl while he’s in a relationship, the girlfriend will often go nuts. We see this sort of thing all over the internet. People constantly discuss their boyfriends looking at other women and girlfriends getting upset about it.</p><p>Yet here, Justin is literally telling his girlfriend that it’s fine for her to continue exchanging looks with another guy.</p><p>What exactly is the director trying to say?</p><p>He’s acting as though this is some sort of feminist statement. If a girl looks at another guy and leads him on, that’s fine. If she’s dating someone else but exchanges looks with another guy, that’s fine, too. If a guy did the same thing, it would be a problem, but if a girl does it, it’s perfectly fine.</p><p>Why?</p><p>You might argue that this isn’t technically cheating, but that’s not the point. Even if you don’t consider it cheating, it’s still not a particularly nice thing to do to your partner. It’s also unfair to Glickson himself, who is being encouraged to believe that Ashley might be interested in him when she apparently isn’t.</p><p>The double standard is ridiculous.</p><p>Glickson another clown character. Why is he behaving like such a clown and saying stupid crap throughout the movie?</p><p>Take the scene in the movie theatre. He asks Ashley whether she wants to use a toilet, and she’s uncomfortable.</p><p>Again, this is one of those moments where the director probably thought of something funny in the moment and decided to put it into the movie without considering whether it made any sense.</p><p>Just because something might sound funny in the moment doesn’t mean it works in the context of the story.</p><p>What young man would say something like that to a girl he likes, especially when he’s trying to become her boyfriend?</p><p>He likes her and wants to be with her. Why the hell would he deliberately make her uncomfortable or disgust her by bringing up a toilet in that manner?</p><p>It’s so stupid.</p><p>The filmmakers make him into a clown, but they also have Ashley play him for a fool. That’s literally what’s happening.</p><p>She doesn’t like him. She’s already in a relationship with someone else, yet she’s allowing this situation to continue for no apparent reason.</p><p>Why can’t she just tell him, “I don’t like you. I’m sorry, but I’m in a relationship with someone else”?</p><p>She doesn’t even have to mention her relationship if she thinks that will get her into trouble. She could simply say that her parents are strict and would be furious if they found out, so she’s not going to pursue anything with him.</p><p>She could tell him that she loves her parents and that she’s only going to have an arranged marriage.</p><p>That part is true, by the way, as we see when they discover Justin and Ashley’s relationship.</p><p>There are plenty of ways to write this situation without making the guy look subhuman. Instead, the movie chooses to make him behave like an idiot while Ashley continues to lead him on.</p><p>Why?</p><p>What is the purpose of all this nonsense?</p><p>If Ashley isn’t interested in Glickson, she should have a reason for allowing the situation to continue. Perhaps she enjoys the attention, perhaps she’s uncomfortable rejecting him, or perhaps there’s another motivation. Any of those could be used to develop her character. The movie doesn’t need to make her a perfect person, but it does need to establish why she’s behaving this way.</p><p>Likewise, Glickson could have been written as a believable young man who develops feelings for someone who doesn’t reciprocate them. Instead, he becomes another character who says and does stupid things simply to generate comedy.</p><p>The result is that neither character is particularly convincing, and the whole situation feels unnecessarily contrived.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/845/0*ISXDDR0WA1Et4ol5" /><figcaption>Bethlehem Kudumba Unit Movie still</figcaption></figure><h3>The Uncle Is Another Unnecessary Character</h3><p>Why is he such a clown?</p><p>Why does he have such a strong say in this girl’s life?</p><p>Do the filmmakers genuinely think that a young girl in the modern world is going to allow some random man to have such a strong influence over her life, potentially even more than her own father?</p><p>Why is he even there, and why does he have such a strong hold over the situation?</p><p>Again, as I mentioned earlier, the father is barely shown in the second half. He’s shown in the first half, but he practically disappears once everything is discovered.</p><p>Why?</p><p>This is one of the most important developments in the story, yet the father is barely involved in the aftermath. The movie seems completely uninterested in exploring his response to the situation.</p><p>Then, at the end, he suddenly appears, delivers a speech to the mother, and the situation is resolved.</p><p>It’s lazy writing.</p><p>If the uncle is supposed to be an important authority figure within the family, then show us that relationship. Establish why the family listens to him and why Ashley is expected to follow his instructions. Otherwise, he feels like another character who has been inserted into the story simply to create conflict.</p><p>The same goes for the father. His absence during the main conflict and sudden appearance at the end make the family dynamics feel inconsistent. The movie keeps introducing people who supposedly have authority over Ashley, but it doesn’t properly explore how that authority works or why the characters accept it.</p><h3>The Ending Makes Very Little Sense</h3><p>Ashley comes back from Ireland for a holiday after two years and attends Joel’s wedding. With literally just minutes left in the movie, she sits at the table with Justin and his friends and family.</p><p>Once again, Justin is turned into a clown. Ashley keeps yelling at him and being rude to him, as usual.</p><p>Then she says that she still loves him and that she only wants him.</p><p>Justin simply walks out to his car.</p><p>He then comes back inside and says that he loves her, too. Apparently, he had gone to the car to get some rest because all these idiots were shouting, and he couldn’t think properly.</p><p>I guess that’s somewhat realistic and somewhat funny. People can become overwhelmed by a noisy environment, and stepping away for a moment is understandable.</p><p>The problem is that the whole thing doesn’t mesh with the rest of the movie.</p><p>All these idiots are sitting around the table shouting. Justin can’t think properly, so he walks away. He then returns and declares his love for Ashley, despite everything that happened between them and the conflict that caused them to stop being a couple.</p><p>Seriously?</p><p>They hug, the mother tries to hit Ashley, the father pulls her back, gives her a speech, and the whole thing ends.</p><p>The entire sequence feels disconnected from the rest of the story.</p><p>How did we get here?</p><p>Why have the characters behaved the way they have throughout the movie, only for everything to be resolved so conveniently at the last minute?</p><p>The movie doesn’t properly earn this ending. It simply rushes towards a conclusion and expects us to accept it.</p><p>The issue isn’t that Ashley and Justin end up together. That could have been a perfectly reasonable conclusion. The problem is that the movie doesn’t adequately develop their relationship or resolve the conflicts that have kept them apart.</p><p>We’re expected to accept this as the culmination of their romance, but the movie hasn’t done enough to make it convincing.</p><p>The shouting at the table might be somewhat funny, and Justin’s decision to leave because he can’t think properly is understandable. That part, taken in isolation, isn’t necessarily a problem. The issue is how abruptly everything changes. The movie moves from a messy, unresolved situation to a happy ending without properly connecting the two.</p><p>It’s the same issue that runs throughout the story: conflicts are introduced, but they aren’t properly developed or resolved. The filmmakers simply decide when it’s time to move on, and the characters suddenly behave in whatever way is necessary to get to the ending.</p><p>Ashley also clowns on Justin for apparently looking at her Instagram profile picture. But how does she know he’s been looking at it? As far as I know, Instagram doesn’t notify people simply because someone views their profile or profile picture. The film doesn’t establish how Ashley found out, yet she uses it as another opportunity to make fun of him.</p><p>Then we get an even more ridiculous detail: Justin supposedly has a spy in Ireland who keeps an eye on Ashley and reports back to him. This person has never been properly established, and the film suddenly expects us to accept that Justin has someone monitoring Ashley from abroad, miunutes before the film ends.</p><p>But Ashley herself says that she knows about this supposed spy. <strong>How?</strong> There are two possibilities, and neither makes sense as the film presents it.</p><p>Either the spy has somehow revealed the arrangement, effectively betraying Justin for no apparent reason, or Ashley has independently figured out that someone is spying on her. If it’s the former, what kind of spy gives away the very secret he’s supposed to keep? If it’s the latter, how did Ashley discover him? She’s in Ireland, studying and dealing with her own problems, yet we’re expected to believe she somehow uncovered this arrangement. The film shows us neither possibility, explains neither, and doesn’t even seem interested in addressing the obvious questions.</p><p>Girish casually throws this information at us and moves on.</p><p>This is precisely the kind of lazy writing that frustrates me. Girish seems to have come up with a detail that he thought would be funny without considering its implications. He doesn’t establish who this person is, why they’re spying on Ashley, how Justin arranged it, how the arrangement was exposed, or how Ashley found out. He simply assumes that mentioning a spy in Ireland is enough to make the scene work.</p><p>Of course, Justin could plausibly know someone in Ireland. People from Kerala live all over the world, so having a friend there who occasionally shares information about Ashley wouldn’t be far-fetched in itself. But that isn’t the problem. The problem is that the film turns this potentially plausible connection into a supposed spying arrangement and then has Ashley reveal that she knows about it, without establishing how or why.</p><p>This isn’t about demanding that every minor detail in a comedy be explained at length. It’s about expecting the writer to think through the basic logic of a scene before putting it on screen. A joke doesn’t become good writing simply because the director thinks it sounds funny. The characters’ actions and the information they supposedly know still need to make sense within the story.</p><p>Instead, we’re left filling in the gaps ourselves because the film hasn’t bothered to do the work. It’s another example of Girish introducing an idea for a quick laugh without thinking through its implications. That isn’t clever or concise filmmaking; it’s an underdeveloped idea presented as though it were a finished joke.</p><p>Seriously, this movie is so transparent.</p><p>The least a modern filmmaker can do is avoid being this transparent. Give us a good, concise movie with a coherent story, where the characters’ actions make sense and the comedy emerges naturally from the situations. Don’t shove your politics down people’s throats, but Girish can’t seem to help himself.</p><p>The same applies to his crass comedy. He seems so determined to include these moments that he doesn’t stop to consider whether they actually work within the story.</p><p>That’s what makes this so frustrating. The problem isn’t that the movie includes comedy, references, or exaggerated characters. Those things can work perfectly well when they’re written properly. The problem is that too many of these moments feel as though they were included simply because the director thought they were funny, without any real consideration for logic, characterisation, or how the story fits together.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Qo4hkE4EnhJS6EEP.jpg" /><figcaption>Bethlehem Kudumba Unit characters</figcaption></figure><h3>The Supporting Characters Are Barely Developed</h3><p>Justin’s friends are also not fleshed out.</p><p>For a movie that’s full of references, it barely makes any references to the Convincing Star. These guys are just there. They’re barely shown, and they’re barely developed as characters.</p><p>They seem to exist primarily to shove the usual clown nonsense down our throats.</p><p>The movie doesn’t give them enough personality or depth to make them feel like real people. They show up when the story needs them, contribute to the comedy, and then disappear again.</p><p>The problem is that their comedy doesn’t feel particularly natural or convincing. It feels as though the filmmakers have created these characters simply to make people act stupid and deliver jokes.</p><p>The movie has a lot of references and plenty of characters, but having characters appear on screen doesn’t automatically make them well-written. They need to contribute something meaningful to the story, have personalities of their own, and behave in ways that make sense.</p><p>Unfortunately, these guys don’t get that treatment.</p><p>The frustrating thing is that the movie clearly has room for a larger supporting cast, but it doesn’t do enough to make these characters memorable or meaningful. They could have provided more insight into Justin’s personality, helped establish his background, or contributed to the development of his relationship with Ashley. Instead, they mostly exist to create silly situations and deliver jokes.</p><p>This is particularly disappointing because Justin himself is one of the characters who could have benefited most from having better-developed friends. If the movie had explored his friendships properly, we might have learned more about him through the way he interacts with other people. We could have seen how he behaves when he’s comfortable, what he values in his friendships, and what kind of person he is outside his romantic relationship.</p><p>That would have made him feel like a more complete character.</p><p>Instead, the movie barely develops these friendships, just as it barely develops Justin’s backstory. It gives us a collection of characters and paragraphs who are present in the story but aren’t used to their full potential.</p><p>Ultimately, that’s one of the movie’s biggest problems. It has plenty of ideas, references, characters, and comedic situations, but too many of them feel underdeveloped. Rather than bringing everything together into a coherent story, the movie repeatedly relies on contrived jokes, inconsistent characterisation, and conflicts that are resolved without proper development.</p><p>The result is a movie that’s relatable and easygoing enough to appeal to a wide audience, but far too average in its writing and execution to be particularly impressive.</p><p>That’s why, despite understanding its popularity, I can’t say that I think it’s a particularly good movie.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cdc7b2cbfee0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Jailer 2 Trailer Review]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TheRamblerReviews/jailer-2-trailer-review-287fe09cc8d0?source=rss-369e2eb4f425------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/287fe09cc8d0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tamil]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tamil-movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-cinema]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rajinikanth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jailer-2]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Rambler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 05 Oct 2026 15:34:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-05T15:34:42.191Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>5/10</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/0*b4JWRlOVx-KcAYs9" /><figcaption>Jailer 2 Promotional image</figcaption></figure><h3>Overall Impression</h3><p>I’m disappointed.</p><p>The only saving grace is the fact that a trailer sometimes doesn’t show you the full feel of a movie. So maybe there is a lot more, but that is not a rule. There is no proof. I’m just saying we sometimes see it, but most of the time we don’t. For example, <em>Dorothy</em>, we got a lot more, but for <em>Sardar 2</em>, we didn’t.</p><p>I’m not talking about the content, obviously. You cannot show everything; you cannot show all the twists and turns. I’m talking about the <strong>feel and the scale</strong>. A trailer can give you an idea of how big the movie feels, how the world feels, how the filmmaking feels, and whether it feels like an actual progression from the previous movie.</p><p>This obviously had some large elements, but it was nothing new in the modern Indian landscape, as well as the fact that it didn’t even feel that big.</p><h3>The Cinematography and Visual Feel</h3><p>The <strong>feel of it</strong>, like the texture and the cinematography, is one of the biggest problems for me. For some reason, it looked worse than the original <em>Jailer</em>. The original had some of the best cinematography I’ve ever seen, look-wise. Nelson and his DOP can work magic, and they really perfected their craft for <em>Jailer 1</em>. However, for some reason, here it looks on the same level, if not worse in some areas.</p><p>The colouring, the grain, and just the feel in some areas didn’t look that good. There was something about the original that made every frame feel deliberate. Even when it was doing something ridiculous or exaggerated, it still had a visual identity. Here, I don’t get that same feeling.</p><h3>The Villains and the Lack of Progression</h3><p>Then there is the <strong>repetitive and derivative content</strong>, and that’s just very annoying.</p><p>The last one had a local goon, Varman, but then you think that it’s going to get bigger in the second one. For some reason, Suraj is just another version of Varman: another local-goon type. Just because it worked in the first one doesn’t mean it will work in this one too.</p><p>We need more high-class villains and a bigger world. That’s the point of a sequel: <strong>to build the world bigger</strong>.</p><p>So S. J. Suryah should have been the main villain, and his high-class stuff is what we should have seen. Tge wtory is that Rajini is challenged more as he opened pandora’s box in the forst movie. For some reason, S. J. Suryah is only shown a little bit.</p><p>I’m hoping he is actually the main villain and maybe he and Suraj work together. Maybe Suraj is related to Varman, and so Suraj calls S. J. Suryah or gets him involved somehow, rather than S. J. Suryah just randomly coming across Rajini.</p><h3>Not Enough Big-Scale Material</h3><p>There is also the fact that we’re just not shown enough <strong>action or big details</strong>.</p><p>The first trailer for the first movie had a freaking rocket launcher sending a missile toward a car blowing it up. That’s the high-level stuff that we needed. In this one, we don’t get that.</p><p>We also get just such terrible, backwards, unrealistic, unconvincing nonsense with cliché foreign goons and half-naked girls with swords.</p><p>Seriously, that’s the type of crap that we expect from really low-level, lazy Telugu movies and Kannada movies.</p><p>People might say, “Well, Tamil does that too.” Of course it does. There is a hierarchy, though. Nelson is supposed to be one of the higher-level filmmakers. For some reason, he’s doing that crap here, especially in a movie that didn’t do that in the original.</p><p>The original movie had more realistic and convincing people and goons. Even though the movie itself was obviously exaggerated and unrealistic, the people within that world felt more convincing.</p><p>When it comes to the scantily clad women, the first one had an item song, but that was part of a movie set the characters went to. In this one, that might exist too, but I’m not talking about something that’s part of a song or that kind of scene. I’m talking about something that’s <strong>part of the world</strong> of the movie.</p><p>Unrealistic is not the issue because the first one was unrealistic. All movies are unrealistic. That’s not the problem.</p><p>The problem is being 1. <strong>unconvincing</strong>, and 2. <strong>being derivative</strong>.</p><h3>The Derivative Elements</h3><p>Someone like Nelson should be highly innovative. For some reason, he’s just seemingly copying others. He had more than two years to write this and direct it, and this is the best he can come up with?</p><p>It’s not that he needed to show Hrithik Roshan or the other cameos. But he could have shown something more.</p><p>When it comes to the other cameos, a couple of them were shown, but only for a little bit. <strong>Show them a lot more.</strong> Give us something to get excited about.</p><p>Then there’s the explosion at the end where the CGI was just very bad, and the shot was too long. It’s just showing him walking towards us, towards the camera, but it looked really bad.</p><p>This whole thing looked as if it could have been an AI or fan-made trailer, except for some higher-quality areas.</p><p>It just felt wrong.</p><h3>What a Sequel Like This Should Be</h3><p>This wasn’t what we needed to get from the sequel to one of the highest-grossing Tamil movies ever, as well as one of the highest-grossing Indian movies ever.</p><p>A movie that could well gross over ₹1,000 crore and be the highest-grossing Tamil movie ever, and potentially the first movie to cross ₹1,000 crore.</p><p>This just cannot be it yet.</p><p>The issue isn’t just that it won’t gross enough or that it won’t entertain. It probably will. I’m talking about <strong>what it needs to be and what it should have done</strong>.</p><p>The point is progression, as what we keep on seeing in Indian cinema is stagnation or regression.</p><p>I keep saying the same thing: I know that the audience likes X, Y and Z, but X, Y and Z is too old, too derivative, or just too low-class. You can’t just keep on doing that.</p><p>I’m not saying go full international level, like <em>Empuraan</em> or anything, because that’s not relatable for the Indian audience, especially the Tamil audience. The local stuff is fine.</p><p>Nelson is a person who is able to integrate the local culture with high-class filmmaking. Karthik Subbaraj is another example of someone who can do that.</p><p>That’s what I wanted here.</p><p>For some reason, though, it’s just kind of staying in one lane, or it’s just not going above a certain threshold. That puts the whole feel of it off.</p><p>There’s not enough stuff.</p><p>You’re not supposed to show everything. Just show <strong>something more</strong> to get us excited.</p><h3>The Action and Casting</h3><p>We don’t need Rajini to fight or kick ass, because he did not do that in the first one, and that was one of the better elements of the first movie.</p><p>But here we have a bunch of confusing-looking elements, such as a bunch of people killing, but we have no context.</p><p>We also have some people who are unconvincing-looking for those roles. One guy in particular kills someone with a knife, but when he turned around, he looked like Vinay Forrt. They could have cast way more appropriate-looking people for those roles, especially the people who are slicing people and killing people.</p><p>It just seemed like a mishmash of stuff that you would expect in this kind of movie, but it wasn’t being put together well.</p><p>For example, if a student does a university essay, where they follow all the steps and they tick off every guideline, but when then they get 50% marks they complain.</p><p>They’re saying, “I did everything. Why am I not getting the good marks?”</p><p>The teacher tells them, “Well, you have everything, but you’ve barely connected it, and I don’t know what you’re trying to explain here.”</p><p>That’s exactly how this trailer felt.</p><p>That doesn’t mean spoil the story. Obviously not.</p><p>That means give us<strong> a </strong>story or something more in the trailer itself. Give us something we can sink our teeth into versus just giving us the same crap that we’ve seen before, as well as showing us <em>Jailer 1</em> again.</p><h3>Predictability</h3><p>This movie also has a very predictable thing, which introduces a really backwards element for trailers.</p><p>The trailer shows some serious stuff, and then shows good, happy-go-lucky, nice moments with nice music, and then goes back to serious again. That’s something that we see in the lowest of the low Telugu movie trailers.</p><p>Here, in this high-level, modern, new-generation Tamil movie by Nelson, we’re getting that in his trailer. That’s unacceptable.</p><p>There is also the fact that that happy-go-lucky, nice thing we’re seeing is Rajini working as a driver, with everyone treating him badly.</p><p>The problem is that it’s predictable, as we know that the animal is going to be unleashed halfway through the movie or something, and these guys are all going to get scared. The ones who made fun of him are all going to turn into clowns by the midpoint or after.</p><h3>Rajini Needed to Show More</h3><p>Of course, we’ve barely got to see the main character do anything.</p><p>In the last one, he did not fight, but he did a lot of stuff in the movie. In this one, we needed to see him do a lot of dramartic action in this trailer, because it’s not a spoiler. <strong>We already know who he is.</strong></p><p>So show some substance.</p><p>The only thing that we really got is him going to see Vidya Balan’s character. That’s him doing some politics or some drama. That’s fine but<strong> we need more.</strong></p><p>That’s the biggest problem I have with this trailer.</p><h3>What I Wanted From the Sequel</h3><p>I’m not asking them to reveal the entire movie. I’m not asking them to show every cameo, every twist, every action scene, or every villain.</p><p>I’m asking them to give us a <strong>sense of progression</strong>.</p><p>Give us a bigger world.</p><p>Give us a bigger threat.</p><p>Give us something that feels like the natural next step after <em>Jailer</em>.</p><p>Give us something that makes me think, “Okay, this is why we needed a sequel.”</p><p>Right now, I don’t get that feeling.</p><p>I get the feeling that they’re taking elements that worked in the first movie, putting some new actors and new locations around them, making things bigger in certain areas, and calling it <em>Jailer 2</em>.</p><p>And that’s not enough.</p><h3>Why the First One Worked</h3><p>The first <em>Jailer</em> felt like Nelson had a very specific vision of what he wanted to do. It took the local, mass, ridiculous elements and presented them with a level of filmmaking and visual style that made them feel fresh.</p><p>That’s what made it work.</p><p>For <em>Jailer 2</em>, I expected that same mentality but on a bigger scale.</p><p>Not necessarily bigger in the sense of throwing random international-looking people, half-naked girls with swords, explosions and CGI at the screen.</p><p>Bigger in terms of <strong>world-building, villains, scale, filmmaking, characters, and ideas</strong>.</p><p>That’s what a sequel should be.</p><p>From this trailer, I just don’t see enough of it yet.</p><p>Maybe the actual movie will prove me wrong. That’s the one thing I’m holding onto, as a trailer doesn’t always show you the full feel of a movie.</p><p>But based purely on what we’ve been shown, I’m disappointed.</p><p>I expected much more.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=287fe09cc8d0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I’m Game Trailer Review]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TheRamblerReviews/im-game-trailer-review-d088db7a56c4?source=rss-369e2eb4f425------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d088db7a56c4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dulquer-salmaan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-trailers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[malayalam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-cinema]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Rambler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 06 Aug 2026 16:17:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-06T16:17:19.041Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I am disappointed.</p><p>But should I be? What exactly was I expecting? The fact that people from different industries are in this was already a sign that it was going to be more pan-Indian slop. I thought we learned our lesson in the past with King of Kotha (this is not Gandhigramam, this is Kotha), but here we’re getting the same sort of nonsense again.</p><p>I was so excited for this movie, but the way Dulquer is first shown in the trailer is horrible. It feels like the makers took a page out of <strong>Alpha</strong>, where the way Alia was acting in the trailer made everyone cringe, like her saying “haha” and doing that horse impersonation. That type of very amateurish nonsense is exactly what this intro looks like. But it’s even worse because, even if he didn’t pull those expressions, his face just wasn’t looking like the face of the protagonist of a movie like this.</p><p>Then there’s multiple other areas of overacting, so it’s not just that moment. I didn’t think it was going to get worse, but then, when he’s covered in blood and was calling the doctor, the overacting was insane. And then there are several other bits just like that.</p><p>As well as the dialogue. The dialogue is horrible, backwards, and cliché. Why is it like this? This is not the DCEU with <strong>Black Adam</strong>. This is supposed to be a brand-new, big-budget, hyped movie from the industry that brought you <em>Kumbalangi Nights</em>. Now, of course, those are not the same people making this, and that’s fine, but it’s being made by the person who directed <em>RDX</em>, which was a very good movie, very well done, and very convincing.</p><p>Then there’s the fact that it has such an overuse of CGI. I mean, this is one of the biggest complaints in the country, or even around the world, where CGI looks fake and corny, whereas real locations are more cinematic, grand, cheaper and more convincing. Of course, they’re also more of a headache and more complex. But that’s corporate talk. Corporate filmmaking creates such audience angering issues by spending more money on green screens and CGI to reduce headaches. So it’s not as simple as saying the director is stupid for thinking more visual effects are better. No. A lot of the time it’s the producer’s fault. But here, the producer is supposed to be more intelligent, right? More creative, right? And the director should also have a say. But the whole thing… I don’t even know what to say.</p><p>The next thing I’m going to say might make people think I’m from a different universe because they’ll say, “Well, obviously you need those things. It’s cinema.” But there are no rules lke that. Such thining holds the industry back.</p><p>What I’m saying is that every new movie (that isn’t typical backwards slop) should at least try something different. Try something new. Don’t do the same old clichés.</p><p>But this has singing and dancing, which isn’t needed. This has non-serious, backwards cringe. This has an overuse of CGI. This has unrealistic action. It has mediocre action in fact, mediocre car stuff, and unconvincing, over-the-top hero moments.</p><p>I mean… just so disappointing.</p><p>I shouldn’t have expected anything better; for example there’s also that one poster that came out, which had foreign people pointing guns at the main character. Again, just backwards, cliché, cringe, and unconvincing. It’s the <strong>Lucifer</strong> school of filmmaking, where they assume putting foreign people in automatically makes something feel bigger and better.</p><p>International level does not mean adding a bunch of foreigners and expecting people to comment, “Wow, international level.” International level just means refinement. If you want to be Hollywood level, be refined, sensible, and serious instead of taking the easy way out and making assumptions. Like Manjummel Boys, Kumbalangi Nights, Kammara Sambhavam etc.</p><p>I really don’t know what to think when the film hits theatres.</p><p>Obviously, anything is possible, and the film itself can still be good. The story could work, and the directing of actors outside of what we saw here could be good. But the rest of the directing; action, hero moments, whatever romance there may be, I have much less hope for.</p><p>We didn’t really see much drama directing in the trailer, so let’s hope all of that is good. But the stuff I did see makes it feel as though, even if the drama directing is good, it won’t matter. There are so many bad movies with good drama directing and good performances that ultimately fail because everything else lets them down.</p><p>So who knows? Maybe this could be like that, or maybe not.</p><p>It also just feels like the story doesn’t have much strength based on what we saw in the trailer. But hopefully we didn’t see enough. Hopefully the trailer only showed isolated moments.</p><p>Even though the trailer seemed to be trying to tell a story, with the main character doing a voice-over, it doesn’t feel like the story has much strength behind it.</p><p>India insists every big movie has to be an action film, it feels like they may have just shoved action scenes into it because they think that’s what it needs to work in theatres.</p><p>I agree that big movies in India usually needs to be action films to work in Indian theatres. But that means the script itself must organically be an action movie. It must not be a drama or thriller with random action scenes forced into it. That’s a completely different thing.</p><p>As this whole gambling storyline, where he crosses the wrong people and they’re after him, can absolutely work. But that doesn’t automatically mean he can suddenly do all this fighting unless his character has a believable reason.</p><p>If he were a former officer or former agent who later became a casino businessman, and then gets caught up in the wrong deals, now he has to use his old skills, that makes sense.</p><p>But that’s just not how Indian films usually writes these characters. They’ll have almost everything I just described except the ex-officer or ex-agent part. They’ll simply have the main character suddenly able to do incredible action for no reason, making the whole thing feel unconvincing.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d088db7a56c4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Balan: The Boy Review]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TheRamblerReviews/balan-the-boy-review-81a9c2188afb?source=rss-369e2eb4f425------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/81a9c2188afb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[malayalam-movie]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[malayalam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-reviews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-cinema]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Rambler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 Jul 2026 08:47:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-17T08:47:58.618Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>6/10</strong></p><p>It’s a somewhat good film, but I was really expecting something exceptional after the first two films from Chidambaram, this wave of Malayalam New Gen cinema, the crew involved such as DOP Shyju Khalid, and the gret reviews this film got. But it was not that.</p><p>That’s unfortunate because of all the things mentioned above. If this were some random film, it would be different. But this needed to be an 8 or above, but it is only a 6.</p><p>Is Jithu the writer the problem? Jan.E.Man was written by Chidambaram, Ganapathi, and Sapnesh Varachal, while Manjummel Boys was written by Chidambaram and based on true events.</p><p>But Jithu Madhavan is not very good as a writer in my opinion, as I stated in my Aavesham review. Aavesham was a very easy and lazy film writing wise, but he excelled in the direction, and that’s fine. Film is a director’s medium. But the writing was just too easy.</p><p>I remember one review for Aavesham had “male fantasy pro max” in its thumbnail. For them to say something like that, the film had to be insane. And it was, you can say.</p><p>Here, the story isn’t insane, but there are multiple forced and unconvincing elements that ruined it.</p><p>That’s it really. A good film, and a good concept, ruined by forced elements.</p><p>The cinematography is excellent, and the acting is very good. That’s all fine. But that is to be expected from a film like this. Again, not some random film.</p><p>So let’s get to the <strong>spoilers</strong>, because there is really nothing more for me to say without spoiling the film.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*CaejLFhrQ1dakiIO.jpg" /><figcaption>Balan: The Boy still</figcaption></figure><p>At the start of the film, after being released from prison, the mother throws away the contact details for the NGO that was going to help her get work. Terrible cliché film nonsense. You think she actually has a plan, or that she’s some kind of gangster, or that there is something bigger going on. But there isn’t. She chooses the harder route for no reason. Just walking around to random places and trying to get daily wage jobs.</p><p>They show her going to a tea shop and asking for work, but she lies about her name and her son’s name. Why? It’s never explained. Again, you think there is going to be some reason. Maybe she’s a gangster. Maybe she has a plan. Maybe someone is after her. But like I said, none of that is the case.</p><p>She gets a job there, but then leaves in secret after the owner tells her not to live alone anymore because it’s dangerous and that she can stay in his house. There are obviously issues with that, so she doesn’t want it, so she leaves.</p><p>Then one of the worst parts of the movie happens. We get a montage of her going to a place, working with a fake name, leaving, and then repeating the same thing over and over again.</p><p>But that doesn’t make sense. Not every single place is going to be exactly like the tea shop where some guy asks her to live with him. Every place she goes, she just finds another reason to leave, even though the reason is never strong enough. It’s extremely coincidental and way too unconvincing. One after another after another. And at every place she lies about her name.</p><p>At one place, a woman says, “Let’s find you a man through an arranged marriage.” But arranged marriage is not that easy. You need prospects. These are random people doing daily wage jobs. It is not something that would happen that easily.</p><p>Then at another place, a guy asks if he can marry her and says he’ll look after her. Again, there is nothing inherently wrong with that. She could at least try to make it work and see where it goes. She cares about her son, so surely she wants him to have a good life.</p><p>Or she could have just joined the NGO and done the job they offered her from the start. But she didn’t at least try something.</p><p>Then there’s another scene where the guy from the tea shop sees her later at a construction site and starts fishing for information about her in front of another worker. He keeps saying things like, “I know her. What’s your name again?” and just keeps asking question after question.</p><p>The whole thing is so unrealistic and unconvincing that it feels like the film forgets it’s supposed to be a serious drama and suddenly turns into some absurd comedy. It feels like a clown or joker character has walked into this serious movie. That’s genuinely what it felt like. It was horrible.</p><p>Again, what’s the reason for lying? What’s the point?</p><p>As there is no big secret. Nobody is coming after her. The family of the person she killed isn’t hunting her down. There is no reveal that justifies any of this.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Nh-g3Zaqp0FuxnT_.jpeg" /><figcaption>Balan: The Boy still</figcaption></figure><p>Her second-to-last job is as a servant in a house with a small kid. Then the film cheats and has the kid get killed in an accident.</p><p>Why?</p><p>She didn’t need that to escape. She was already going to leave. But now that tragedy gets piled onto her story as well.</p><p>And was it due to something she did?</p><p>No.</p><p>It’s completely random. In movies the protgonist or antagonist causing these things to happen adds strength. But random occurrences, especially repeatedly, is unforgivable.</p><p>Then later she gets a job as a home nurse for an old lady. But how did this old lady survive all this time? There was seemingly nobody there looking after her until she arrived.</p><p>When she is there, the old lady’s son calls from London. He is rude on the phone, which is terrible. Why is he rude? He needs the nurse’s help. She is the home nurse, yet the son is strangely rude to her for no reason. It doesn’t make much sense.</p><p>Then in a later phone call, he is suddenly much nicer. Why?</p><p>The old lady says that she and her husband were freedom fighters, that they were tortured by the British, and that they never said a word when they were tortured for information. But as her son now works in the UK, she claims to hate him.</p><p>And she just believes her. She goes along with everything. What!?</p><p>The old lady says, “If I die, just bury me out here in the front,” and she just goes with it.</p><p>I mean, the old lady is clearly eccentric, maybe even crazy. But the old lady herself says that half the things she says are lies. So why believe her?</p><p>Why believe her when she says she hates her son?</p><p>This whole thing felt extremely lazily written and forced because they are doing that cliché storyline where the protagonist finds some eccentric person and forms a connection with them. You know the type. An old lady with a gun living alone on a hilltop.</p><p>But also, instead of actually exploring that storyline, the old lady dies.</p><p>And she dies in such a horrible and unconvincing way.</p><p>Earlier in the film, we see her having some sort of asthma attack or breathing problem, and the she gives her the inhaler.</p><p>This time she has a similar attack. She gives her the inhaler, but the old lady throws it away. Then she starts saying things like, “I told you not to leave. You can stay here.” in a very unconvincing scene. This happens right at the moment she yells at her kid saying they are leaving, so the old lady heard all of that and decided to die?</p><p>Then she just dies.</p><p>There are two problems with this.</p><p>The first is that it seems like if she had simply used the inhaler, she would have survived. If that’s the case, then her death feels completely unacceptable and manufactured.</p><p>But the second problem is even worse.</p><p>Not getting your inhaler for two seconds is not going to kill you.</p><p>So it feels like she was actually dying anyway, and the inhaler wasn’t really the issue.</p><p>But if that’s the case, then what are the chances?</p><p>Right at the exact moment she is about to leave, the old lady suddenly dies.</p><p>That is an unbelievable coincidence.</p><p>It almost feels like the old lady decided to die at exactly the right time so she could say what the script needed her to say and leave behind what the story needed her to leave behind.</p><p>It’s like Jedi characters in Star Wars who conveniently die and disappear at exactly the right moment for the plot.</p><p>This was horrible.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*N8vU4sDTxUHGxncR" /><figcaption>Balan: The Boy still</figcaption></figure><p>But like I mentioned above, she just goes along with everything the old lady says.</p><p>She buries her, lies to the son, and lies to the person who got her the job.</p><p>Why?</p><p>She can’t stay there forever. People know the old lady. People are eventually going to visit, ask questions, and find out what happened.</p><p>So what exactly was the plan? Did she just assume she was safe?</p><p>But what makes it even worse is that she thinks it’s appropriate to completely screw over the old lady’s son just because of what this eccentric, crazy old lady told her.</p><p>He deserves to bury his mother.</p><p>He deserves to know that she died.</p><p>Her family deserves to know.</p><p>Why is she so awful here?</p><p>She is a mother herself. She has a son. So wouldn’t she want her own son to know if she died?</p><p>Wouldn’t she want him to be informed? Wouldn’t she want him to have the chance to bury her and say goodbye?</p><p>The film seems to think this is some emotional or noble decision, but it was incredibly selfish.</p><p>All she has done is deny a family the opportunity to mourn their mother properly, based entirely on the words of a woman who had already admitted that half the things she says are lies.</p><p>None of it felt justified.</p><p>Now, there is also something in between all of this that I actually thought was great.</p><p>A powerful prisoner from the jail where she was imprisoned comes back into the story. While they were in prison, she gave the her her number, but she clearly didn’t like her and wanted nothing to do with her.</p><p>The problem is that after getting out of prison, they just coincidentally bump into each other.</p><p>That’s unacceptable. You can’t do that.</p><p>She should have found her actively. There should have been effort involved. Instead, they just randomly meet.</p><p>But after that, I actually liked where the story went.</p><p>The woman basically implies, “Come work for me,” and is about to take her away. It’s obvious she is a pimp and wants to push her into prostitution.</p><p>But she runs away, which I thought was great.</p><p>I love the film going against that. As a lot of modern movies will support this. A lot of modern movies have quite a political take when it comes to women and this kind of thing. But the woman in this film strongly opposed it, and that was great.</p><p>Later, the pimp finds her at the old lady’s house, and then she shoots her dead, which was great.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2DQLlbZQZW6NftM5.jpeg" /><figcaption>Balan: The Boy still</figcaption></figure><p>But then the film just keeps getting worse.</p><p>As the old lady’s family arrives unexpectedly where she cleans the blood from the pimp but then decides to murder them to escape, instead of you know, just running away. As there is no proof that she is there as she is there with a fake ID.</p><p>The kid comes back from school, and when the bus stops, he waits there as earlier his mother told him, no matter what wait here and I will definitely come here to pick you up.</p><p>But she doesn’t.</p><p>She doesn’t come for a very long time.</p><p>And no reason is given.</p><p>You might think there is a reason, but there isn’t, as the film later shows that there wasn’t.</p><p>So there is literally no reason why she didn’t pick him up.</p><p>The boy stands there for ages until the police are called, and the police officer played by Lal Jr. comes to help him.</p><p>Then he notices that the boy is only in his underwear.</p><p>Apparently, the boy took off his clothes, put them in his bag, and threw them away.</p><p>This made no sense and was horrible.</p><p>Now, I understand the film’s explanation. The boy threw away his clothes because his mother told him to stay away from the police, and removing his clothes reduced the chances of being identified.</p><p>And when the man watching him went for a cigarette, the boy didn’t run away because his mother had told him to stay there no matter what.</p><p>I understand all of that.</p><p>But I have already explained why all of that is also rubbish.</p><p>Having the guy conveniently go for a cigarette and look away is also such lazy writing.</p><p>The problem is that doing things this way is also too easy.</p><p>The entire sequence only works because everybody suddenly becomes incompetent.</p><p>The police officer is standing there asking everyone where the boy’s clothes are.</p><p>The guy says, “Well, I went for a cigarette, and when I came back they were gone.”</p><p>But it’s obvious the clothes cannot be far away.</p><p>The kid is a small child. He clearly didn’t walk miles away and hide them somewhere. They have to be nearby.</p><p>Yet nobody bothers looking.</p><p>I was so irritated. Guys, just look for them. They’re clearly there.</p><p>Instead, they take the kid to the police station and then eventually to Lal Jr’s house.</p><p>Then the next day, Lal Jr. and the kid return to the same place looking for evidence, and immediately find the bag with the clothes.</p><p>I mean, that’s just stupid.</p><p>And on top of that, the kid refuses to say a word.</p><p>Yes, his mother told him not to speak.</p><p>But his level of obedience becomes ridiculous.</p><p>There are so many things he could easily say.</p><p>The film has him speak when it wants him to speak and stay silent when it doesn’t want the plot moving forward.</p><p>That is one of the most forced and artificial aspects of the entire movie.</p><p>It’s cheating.</p><p>The film constantly has characters behave unrealistically whenever the plot would otherwise become too easy to resolve. And that, more than anything, is my biggest problem with the writing.</p><p>Everything is too easy.</p><p>Every obstacle is solved through coincidence, characters acting irrationally, or people suddenly becoming incompetent whenever the plot needs them to.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9oBFY8TzSxeVUyFp.jpg" /><figcaption>Balan: The Boy still</figcaption></figure><p>And from there, he gets taken to the police station again, and then he is left with Lal Jr’s girlfriend but still manages to run away.</p><p>After that, the film tries to make it seem like Lal Jr a bad guy by saying, “Well, I didn’t lose the kid”, implying it was his girlfriend. But saying that makes her break up with him right there.</p><p>And then she’s like, “So many people told me you’re a bad guy, but now I believe it.”</p><p>Even though he is shown to be bad from the beginning, and the way he’s shown as a bad guy by the way, is that he tried to murder someone with a truck. So why would this girl not believe that? She’s a freaking police officer. She should have broken up with him in the first place. But no, she stays with him.</p><p>And she only breaks up with him when he shouts, “Hey, I didn’t lose the kid.” But that’s all he said. He didn’t say, “Hey, she lost the kid.”</p><p>Then after that, he goes up to her to apologise, and that’s when she breaks up with him.</p><p>It’s terrible because the film is trying to say he showed his true colours, but he didn’t. He would only show his true colours by actively saying her name in court, or actively writing a complaint, or writing something down that would hurt her.</p><p>So if he’s the villain, then show him as a villain. Show him as a bad guy.</p><p>But he isn’t shown as a bad guy. He’s shown as complicated, or just a guy. In fact, he barely does anything. But the film is assuming little bits are enough. Not good enough. Her not listening and just turning on him like someone flipped a switch is a lazy film cliche. In real life she would listen and understand.</p><p>Also, in between this, there was news of a bank robbery. It was shown slightly, and that means it is a Chekhov’s gun. We think it is the mother, or something related to her, but no. It is nothing.</p><p>Again, it’s a lazy insert to have the police be distracted so the plot can happen.</p><p>The kid escapes and is away for several years. Then, for some reason, instead of being an active protagonist and trying to find his way back to his mother, the film jumps ahead six or seven years. He’s now a teenager on a bus journey, and that bus randomly pulls into the exact same town.</p><p>HOOOWWWW!!!??</p><p>They pull into the same bus stop, and that’s when he decides to get off and look for his mother.</p><p>He goes back to the police station and asks Lal Jr for help. This is where the film becomes even more frustrating because it relies on one of the most irritating movie clichés: characters refusing to speak properly.</p><p>They never give enough information. They say a couple of words, and you’re left thinking, “What the hell? Say more.” The people they’re talking to clearly don’t understand them, so they need to provide some context.</p><p>The film only moves because people refuse to communicate like normal human beings.</p><p>You assume these scenes are happening because the other characters don’t have enough information, but then you wonder why nobody is asking questions. Why isn’t anyone saying, “Give me more information”? Why aren’t they asking ten follow-up questions? That’s what people do in real life.</p><p>Then, much later, the film reveals that these characters already knew the context all along. So when someone only says the bare minimum, you think they’re not saying enough, but apparently they are, because the other person already knows what they’re talking about.</p><p>It’s an extremely irritating way to write a story.</p><p>It’s also completely unconvincing because there is no reason these people should have had that information in the first place.</p><p>How did they know that woman was his mother? When they found him as a child, he didn’t give them any information. They just found a random kid on the street. Yes, there had recently been a double murder, but nobody would automatically conclude that this child belonged to that woman. They would never assume she was his mother.</p><p>Yet when he comes back years later and keeps saying, “My mum, my mum, my mum,” they already know exactly who he’s talking about. Not only do they know now, but the film implies they knew years ago.</p><p>That means Lal Junior somehow discovered she was his mother, went to the mental hospital where she was being held, and essentially got her released by claiming to be her brother.</p><p>Would that actually work?</p><p>If a random person walked into a mental hospital and said, “I’m her brother,” would they really just hand her over?</p><p>That’s extreme cheating by the script.</p><p>Then for some reason, he keeps her in another mental hospital, even though both mental hospitals are effectively the same.</p><p>It makes no difference.</p><p>Lal Jr doing this and not showing her to him is presented as revenge. But how?</p><p>The kid who escaped from the police station was a completely innocent child, so why would Lal Jr have any ill will towards him in the first place?</p><p>Not only that, the film says the kid caused his relationship to break up. But if that’s the case, why is he taking revenge on the kid’s mother and using her as a weapon?</p><p>He would have to be paying to keep her in that mental hospital. The kid is gone. The only way she can be used as a weapon against him is if he eventually returns, but there is no reason to think he ever will.</p><p>And when the kid does return, Lal Jr doesn’t even treat it as some huge moment. He smiles at first and then immediately tells him to piss off. He keeps saying he won’t show him his mother and repeatedly tells him to get out.</p><p>What kind of revenge is this?</p><p>Again, nothing happened to Lal Jr, yet he decides to kidnap a mentally ill woman in order to hurt a child who did nothing wrong to him.</p><p>At the end, we find out that the woman he kidnapped was actually someone else. His real mother only got a job as a home nurse after she randomly found a mentally ill woman at a bus stop, saw from her ID that she was a nurse, took the ID, phoned about the job, and instantly got hired (which is also too easy).</p><p>Later, she takes the mentally ill woman in because she feels sorry for her. But when the old woman’s family comes to visit, she decides to give the mentally ill woman a gun and manipulate her into shooting and murdering innocent people.</p><p>Why?</p><p>If the goal was simply to escape, then why not just leave the mentally ill woman there and run away?</p><p>No guns involved. No murders involved.</p><p>The same plot points still happen. The family arrives and finds a mentally ill woman in the house, but no elderly woman. Remember, she has been posing as the real nurse Sherly and has the nurse’s ID, so everyone would assume she was genuine. They would find the mentally ill woman there, discover the elderly woman is missing, and take the mentally ill woman into custody while the real woman escapes.</p><p>Simple.</p><p>Everyone would still assume it was the boy’s mother, including the boy himself.</p><p>But for some reason, the film decides that two innocent people need to be murdered.</p><p>Also, the shotgun can only hold two rounds. She fires one shot and misses, meaning only one round remains.</p><p>Yet the film states that she killed two people.</p><p>How?</p><p>It’s absolute cheating. Horrible writing and complete cheating.</p><p>Lal Jr, for some reason, tells him, “Fine, I’ll show her to you,” but says he won’t actually give her back. So he takes him to see her, and the boy realises it isn’t his mother at all. It’s the mentally ill woman. He then runs away, goes back to the bus stop, and within seconds, or at most a few minutes, his actual mother appears.</p><p>Now, it is a nice touch that her clothing shows she has been working on a plantation all this time rather than running away. That visual storytelling is good. The problem is that an international audience watching a Malayalam film is not necessarily going to understand what that clothing signifies unless it is made clearer.</p><p>I also like the fact that she doesn’t need a second to realise it’s him. Now, yes, that is the filmmakers being a little pretentious, but it comes from a place of heart, so I can accept it.</p><p>However, she walks up to him and, instead of discussing everything that has happened, he just repeats the same line he said as a child: “Where do we go now?” or something along those lines.</p><p>The filmmakers clearly thought, “Oh, that’s a cool callback.” But being cool is not the same thing as being convincing.</p><p>Then she gives the exact same response she gave him when he was younger: “I told you. No matter how long it takes, wait here. I’ll be back.”</p><p>But that’s stupid.</p><p>First of all, he did wait. He waited a very long time and even came back years later.</p><p>Secondly, waiting there is dangerous. The police are obviously going to be called. In fact, they were called.</p><p>So what exactly was her plan?</p><p>Like I stated, she wasn&#39;t caught by the police for murder, it was the mentally ill woman. So she was safe and cold have come to the bus stop to collect him. But she didn&#39;t. She abandoned her son, even though she was safe.</p><p>No one has seen her or knows her, so she can easily come there. No one knew she was the nurse. So after handing the mentally ill woman the gun, she ran out of the house and would have gone straight to the bus stop. but she didn&#39;t.</p><p>The whole point is that she wants to avoid the police. Why? Her imprisonment is over. She no longer has any reason to be afraid of them.</p><p>If anything, she should have told him, “If I don’t come back, go to the police.”</p><p>Instead, her entire plan is still, “Just wait here.”</p><p>Then, after finally seeing him again after all those years, she repeats that same stupid line, and the filmmakers seem to think they’re being incredibly clever by bringing it back.</p><p>They’re not.</p><p>Waiting there achieved nothing.</p><p>Why doesn’t she ask where he has been? Seriously.</p><p>She is out of prison. She could have built a life for herself, but instead she keeps running.</p><p>If the film had shown that she was mentally ill, then fine. That would at least explain her behaviour.</p><p>But it doesn’t.</p><p>Her backstory is also far too easy. When she tells the old woman her story, the old woman immediately believes her. Why do filmmakers keep relying on tired tropes and lazy writing while assuming the audience will simply accept it?</p><p>The answer is that audiences often do accept it.</p><p>It reminds me of Guruvayoor Ambalanadayil, where there were multiple lazy plot points. Basil and Nikhila are supposedly in conflict because he spread rumours, but that is neither strong enough nor properly shown. We are simply told that it is a major issue and expected to go along with it.</p><p>Then there is the idea that Prithviraj caused a huge ruckus because of a letter and Nikhila leaves. We are just told this and expected to believe it. But when he causes a ruckus later, Nikhila stays with him? Even before that, his parents hid the fact that Nikhila and Basil had been together because they thought he was too emotionally weak to handle the truth. No he isn’t. As that is just basic life.</p><p>Things like that get revealed in real life. They are not sustainable secrets. People do not successfully hide information like that forever. And when this was revealed, Prithviraj want just fine and he saved the day. So what the hell was this plot?</p><p>It was unbelievably stupid, and the filmmakers seemed to think the audience would just go with the flow.</p><p>I don’t want to go with the flow. I want tight reasoning. I want character-driven writing.</p><p>I don’t want plot-driven writing where events happen because the script needs them to happen. And I definitely don’t want filmmaker-driven writing where the writers think something is cool, emotional, or “good enough,” so they force it into the story regardless of whether it makes sense.</p><p>No. It has to be strong.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=81a9c2188afb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Drishyam 3 Review]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TheRamblerReviews/drishyam-3-review-86ef1c28f288?source=rss-369e2eb4f425------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/86ef1c28f288</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film-reviews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[malayalam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[drishyam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mohanlal]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Rambler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 17 Jun 2026 19:22:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-17T19:22:14.212Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>7.5/10</p><p>This is my long ass review of the third film in Malayalam’s defining series.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/0*7UyzOktwdk1tXLlq" /><figcaption>Drishyam 3 still</figcaption></figure><h4>Where It Stands in the Series</h4><p>This movie is very good on its own. But it is not the best of the series, which has to be part 1 obviously. That is not a problem at all, because the first film set the standard for the series, however, it is the best for slightly different reasons. There is no rule saying that the first part of any series has to be the best simply because it started the whole thing. There are plenty of sequels that are better than the original. That is not what is happening here because of what <em>Drishyam</em> actually is.</p><p>The Drishyam duality is something I already explained in one of my articles. The whole point of it is the dual nature. I explained that great movies, even though they do not have to do this, can fully succeed and come full circle when they do.</p><p>I talked about how the movie The Brutalist was criticized for being “boring” and “brutalist,” even though that is the entire point. If they had simply made a conventional movie about a man making brutalist architecture, that would have been the worst possible approach. Instead, they baked the theme of the movie into the filmmaking itself. So it is not just the characters who feel the theme, but the audience as well. They do not just see it. They feel it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*7VssFKA2qFF_7bfi.jpg" /><figcaption>The Brutalist (2024)</figcaption></figure><p>The same applies to Part 1 of Drishyam, where everyone assumed it was just going to be a quiet family drama. Mohanlal had done films like that many times before, so people assumed this would simply be another one of those. But then audiences got the shock of their lifetimes when they realized this was not merely a drama. It was a drama-thriller, and not just a straightforward one either.</p><p>That was the mistake other industries made, particularly Hindi cinema. They assumed it was only a thriller. They mocked all the additional elements, saying the film had weird or unnecessary material and that it should all be removed to make it more straightforward. But that completely destroyed the point of the movie.</p><p>The entire point of the film is its dual nature. You spend so much time with the family, getting to know them, liking them, and understanding all their personal drama. Then suddenly this incident happens and everyone is shocked.</p><p>The police were shocked by what Georgekutty was doing because they underestimated him. They saw him as a normal simpleton, while in reality he had been playing them all along.</p><p>The same thing happened with the audience. We assumed this was just a simple drama about a small-town family. But in reality, the director Jeethu Joseph had been playing the audience all along, and that is what makes the movie great. That simply cannot be replicated here in part 3.</p><p>But that’s fine, because as stated above<em>, </em>we spent so much time with the family as a drama, we genuinely care about them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/744/0*s2clSb88SXFoFmNA.jpg" /><figcaption>Drishyam part 1</figcaption></figure><h4>The “Drishyam” DNA and Why Sequels Work Differently</h4><p>The sequels were made primarily for the Malayalam audience. The Malayalam audience has seen the original countless times. They know it by heart. They know the family, the house, the characters, the dialogue, and everything that happened. They love this family.</p><p>People once again complained about part 2 having long, supposedly unnecessary sections. But they aren’t unnecessary.</p><p>First, those scenes are setting up the thrills that come later. You need some patience and a bit of common sense to understand that not everything can be climatic. There has to be setup first. Many of these complaints simply don’t make sense.</p><p>Second, <em>Drishyam 2</em> was made during COVID, largely as a morale boost. There was never any original intention to make a sequel by the way (as far as I know). You can see some of the compromises in part 2 due to the restrictive and quick making. The focus was more on the writing than on the directing and staging. As a result, some scenes do have a slightly soap-opera feel to them. That’s obvious.</p><p>But most of us forgave those flaws because we understood the <strong>context</strong>.</p><p>The film was made with the assumption that we already knew this family, this house, these characters, and everything they had been through. We weren’t meeting them for the first time. We were revisiting people we already knew extremely well.</p><p>Meanwhile, audiences from other parts of the country and the world would watch it and say, “This feels like a soap opera,” or “This is weird,” or “This is stupid.” Some of these people never even saw part 1. They saw the Hindi part 1 and assumed they can go into the Malayalam part 2, without understanding that both films are completely different, as discussed above.</p><p>Those criticisms often ignore the context in which the sequel was made.</p><p><strong>I promise I will go into the review, but all of this is a part of the 3 review as people will have similar issues with 3 too, so I am explaining the context.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*xKhrlr0pM-QzWqyn.jpg" /><figcaption>Drishyam part 2</figcaption></figure><h4>Context Is Everything: Why the Sequel Language Matters</h4><p>The context of a movie matters. Sometimes it is essential to understanding what the movie is trying to do.</p><p>That is true of a lot of films, especially Indian films. When foreign audiences watch them and complain about certain things, sometimes they are absolutely correct. But other times they are missing cultural or historical context. They are told that understanding that context might change their perspective, and many of them scoff at the idea.</p><p>But that’s often how it works.</p><p>I’ve seen plenty of foreign reviewers revisit films years later after gaining that context. Suddenly they enjoy the movie and openly admit, “If I had watched this at the beginning of my channel, I would have hated it. But now that I understand the background, I appreciate it for completely different reasons.”</p><p>Context doesn’t automatically make a movie good. But sometimes it allows you to understand what the movie is actually trying to achieve in the first place.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*mCyTclUWSaGbef9e.jpg" /><figcaption>Drishyam 3 set</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Drishyam 3</strong></h4><p>This film comes from the same DNA as Parts 1 and 2. However, it is noticeably more cinematic than Part 2. There are no obvious restrictions this time, no compromises. The film was a guaranteed hit, and it feels like it was made with that confidence. Everything is more rounded, more polished, and more cinematic.</p><p>However, that doesn’t mean it goes completely off the rails or abandons what made the series special.</p><p>It is still <em>Drishyam</em>. It still comes from the same school. It is still fundamentally the same kind of story, and that’s a good thing.</p><p>Most importantly, it is still made for the same audience.</p><p>You absolutely need to have watched Parts 1 and 2 before watching this. In fact, I would go further and say that Parts 1 and 2 are films that benefit from multiple viewings. The director clearly understands that a large portion of the audience has watched them several times already.</p><p>Because of that, characters from both films can return without lengthy reintroductions. References, callbacks, bits of information, and small details all land naturally because the audience already has that knowledge.</p><p>But more than anything else, it’s the feeling that carries over.</p><p>You cannot simply jump into Part 3 without watching the previous ones or only watching the Hindi ones. It would make very little sense. You would spend the entire movie questioning things in a negative way because you would be missing the emotional and narrative foundation that the film assumes you already have.</p><p>The film understands that audiences are already invested in these people, so it continues building on that relationship rather than starting from scratch.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ftdUHpXri7ErVdE5.jpg" /><figcaption>Drishyam 3 poster image</figcaption></figure><h4>The First Half</h4><p>The first half contains a lot of setup. That’s obvious. In fact, it’s so obvious that some people will probably complain about it. But it is also packed with drama, and that’s what makes it work.</p><p>Some viewers will inevitably say that parts of it are unnecessary, slow, or weird. But that’s kind of the point. The film is killing two birds with one stone.</p><p>On one hand, it is setting up what comes later. On the other, it is giving us more time with a family that many of us already love.</p><p>I loved the first half. I genuinely enjoyed just sitting there and spending time with these characters again.</p><p>This goes back to the importance of context.</p><p>You cannot do this with just any random movie. You can’t simply fill a film with family drama involving characters the audience barely knows and expect people to care. It only works when the audience already has a strong relationship with those characters.</p><p>And in this case, the context is perfect for it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/801/0*WmUblcF-EIu8J-AE" /><figcaption>Mohanlal as Georgekutty from Drishyam 3</figcaption></figure><h4>Georgekutty’s Shift: From Mastermind to Reactive Protagonist</h4><p>In Parts 1 and 2, we were mostly observers of Georgekutty. He was always working in the background, making plans, manipulating situations, and doing things we often didn’t fully understand until later.</p><p>Here, we get much closer to his psyche.</p><p>He has conversations about his fears, his concerns, the consequences of his actions, and how his family might eventually see him. We spend more time with the emotional burden he carries.</p><p>There are moments where he says things that might seem obvious. For example, he talks about how hard he has worked because he loves his family and simply wants to spend more time with them.</p><p>On paper, that’s hardly a revelation. We already knew that.</p><p>But the fact that he actually said it matters.</p><p>In the previous films, the focus was largely on what Georgekutty was doing to save his family. We understood that he loved them because of his actions. The films didn’t need to spell it out.</p><p>This time, however, we get more of the emotional side of it. We hear him express things that were previously implied. That makes the character feel more vulnerable, more heartfelt, and ultimately more human.</p><p>Georgekutty is presented much more as a person here than as a mastermind.</p><p>One of the common criticisms of Part 2 was that some viewers felt Georgekutty had become too untouchable, almost as if he had won the world’s biggest lottery and could never lose. No matter what happened, he always seemed to stay ten steps ahead.</p><p>Here, not only does he feel more human, but he spends much more of the film reacting to situations rather than controlling them. Things happen to him and his family that are outside his control, and he has to deal with the consequences as they unfold.</p><p>This time, other people are making moves against Georgekutty and his family. He is no longer the person controlling every situation from the shadows. Instead, he has to fight back, react, and figure things out as events unfold like a more traditional protagonist.</p><p>Rather than being a classic criminal mastermind who is always ten steps ahead, he is often discovering information at the same time that we are. Sometimes we even learn things before he does, and then we watch him uncover those same truths and respond to them.</p><p>Because of that, Georgekutty becomes the true point-of-view character of the film. In the earlier movies, especially the first one, much of the audience perspective came through the family. There was a mystery to him. We didn’t always know what he was planning, and the film deliberately kept us in the dark.</p><p>Here, we experience much more of the story alongside Georgekutty. We learn things with him, worry with him, and watch him process events as they happen. He is no longer playing everyone, including the audience, from the background.</p><p>And I think that’s a great change.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*P5ZDP7a4AH0OP7g8.jpg" /><figcaption>Drishyam 3 poster image</figcaption></figure><h4>The Second Half</h4><p>The second half is where the thriller elements really begin to take over. Then, during the latter part of the second half, the film shifts into full gear.</p><p>This is where the movie becomes more divisive.</p><p>You can absolutely debate whether some of the creative decisions were the right ones. In fact, I think that’s the main reason the film is receiving more mixed-positive reactions rather than universal praise.</p><p>The choices made here are not necessarily bad, but they are definitely questionable. They are the kind of decisions that will work for some viewers and completely lose others.</p><p>But I think the main reason this film is getting mixed-positive reviews comes down to a more fundamental question: <strong>what is the point of the movie?</strong></p><p>People often say that every story should have a reason to exist. Every movie should have a point.</p><p>If I’m being completely honest, neither this film or even part 2 needed to exist.</p><p>The sequel existed for a COVID morale boost as stated before. This one exists because it was always going to make money, I suppose. To be fair, the director has said that he had this story in mind while making part 2, so it wasn’t purely a cash grab. He clearly wanted to tell it.</p><p>But if I had to sum up my feelings about this film in one sentence, it would be this:</p><p><strong>For most of its runtime, <em>Drishyam 3</em> feels like an alternative version of <em>Drishyam 2</em>. This could have happened instead of what we saw in 2.</strong></p><p>Obviously, there are characters, plot developments, and pieces of information from part 2 that are needed for this story. But a lot of those elements could have been rewritten or replaced without fundamentally changing the core narrative.</p><p>That’s why I see it as more of an alternate path than a completely necessary continuation.</p><p>When people say the movie is average, or that there isn’t really much new here, I actually understand what they mean. In a broad sense, they’re correct.</p><p>But the specific context changes everything.</p><p>This is not just any movie. This is the <em>Drishyam</em> family.</p><p>Because of that, I don’t think the usual criticism applies in quite the same way.</p><p><strong>Was I entertained?</strong> The answer is <strong>yes</strong>.</p><p>I enjoyed spending time with these characters again. I enjoyed seeing how the events of the previous films continued to affect them. I enjoyed watching them navigate new situations.</p><p>That has value in itself.</p><p>If this were a completely unrelated film with brand-new characters, I would probably be much harder on it. But it isn’t. It is a continuation of a family that audiences have spent years with.</p><p>That changes the equation.</p><p>And to be clear, I am not saying that nothing happens in the movie. Quite a lot happens, and there are important developments that significantly affect the story and the characters.</p><p>It only sounds as if there isn&#39;t when described from a distance.</p><p>For some people, that will be disappointing.</p><p>For me, it wasn’t.</p><p>Now, at the end of the movie, they do leave the door open for another sequel. Maybe it will happen, maybe it won’t. I have no idea.</p><p>The problem is that if they make a Part 4, repetition becomes an even bigger issue. In fact, Part 4 could be the point where everything finally falls apart.</p><p>I say that because this movie doesn’t have the huge, earth-shattering shocks of Part 1 or Part 2. Some people have complained about that.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*RhhBz9OeeVROlscT" /><figcaption>Jeethu Joseph and Mohanlal</figcaption></figure><h4>Expectations vs Reality: The Problem With Audience Reactions</h4><p>The problem with those complaints is that the director literally said beforehand that this movie was not going to have those kinds of twists.</p><p>However, some people argue that this isn’t a valid defence. Their point is that audiences will still expect it regardless of what the director says.</p><p><strong>I disagree.</strong></p><p>At some point, audience expectations become the audience’s responsibility.</p><p>Who told people to go in expecting the most shocking film of all time?</p><p>By this stage, everyone should know what this series is. If you watched Part 2, you should already understand that <em>Drishyam</em> cannot keep moving forward indefinitely without some degree of repetition. That is simply the reality of continuing this story.</p><p>So why assume that Part 3 was suddenly going to go completely insane and reinvent itself?</p><p>Nothing about the series suggested that.</p><p>As I’ve said throughout this review, the film comes from the same DNA as the first two movies. It moves differently. It is more cinematic. It occasionally takes bigger swings. But fundamentally, it is still recognisably <em>Drishyam</em>.</p><p>Some viewers seem to be disappointed because the film didn’t completely transform into something else.</p><p>But that’s exactly my point.</p><p>The only way to fully satisfy those expectations would have been for the movie to abandon its identity and go completely off the rails.</p><p>A good comparison is the <em>Fast &amp; Furious</em> franchise. It started as a street-racing crime series and eventually turned into something closer to <em>Mission: Impossible</em>. Whether you like those later films or not, the franchise undeniably lost much of its original DNA.</p><p>That is the danger facing <em>Drishyam</em>.</p><p>Ironically, this movie already flirts with that danger in a few places. There are moments where it goes slightly off the rails, and honestly, I don’t think those were the strongest parts of the film.</p><p>I actually think it should have remained more restrained.</p><p>Most of the movie works precisely because it stays grounded and reserved, just like the first two films. That restraint is part of the series’ identity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/0*L_Y2v1WkG3RBm442.jpg" /><figcaption>Mohanlal, Antony Perumbavoor and Jeethu Joseph</figcaption></figure><p>Another criticism I’ve seen is that the director cannot simply tell audiences what to expect because he created such an impactful franchise. The argument is that people are naturally going to expect every sequel to deliver the same level of shock, regardless of what he says beforehand.</p><p>But that logic makes no sense to me.</p><p>He’s the director.</p><p>If the person making the movie tells you that it isn’t going to be a giant shock-fest full of insane twists, why would you ignore that and then get angry when the movie turns out exactly as he described it?</p><p>Who are you to overrule the person who actually made the film?</p><p>If the director says, “This isn’t that kind of movie,” and you still convince yourself that it will be, then disappointment is a predictable outcome.</p><p>Personally, I didn’t even know he had said any of this.</p><p>I went into the movie completely blind.</p><p>I watched the teaser once and the trailer once. I didn’t rush to watch them when they came out. In fact, I think I waited about a week before I even bothered. Despite loving this series and having watched the previous films countless times, I simply wasn’t obsessing over the marketing.</p><p>I just showed up on day one and watched the movie.</p><p>And what I got was more or less exactly what I expected.</p><p>It was <em>Drishyam</em>.</p><p>Just a little more cinematic, a little bigger, a little more ambitious, and perhaps a little more willing to embrace movie-style unreality than the previous entries.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qrHye6Jal-iq9yDw.jpg" /><figcaption>Drishyam 3 set</figcaption></figure><h4>Earned Moments and Audience Reaction</h4><p>Speaking of that, the moments that lean in that direction are actually earned, and they received exactly the reaction they deserved.</p><p>The audience I watched it with didn’t clap or cheer during the first half. They didn’t cheer when characters appeared. They didn’t cheer at callbacks or references either.</p><p>And honestly, I was glad.</p><p>This isn’t that kind of movie.</p><p><em>Drishyam</em> has never been built around crowd-pleasing entrances, hero worship, or people erupting every five minutes because a familiar face walked onto the screen.</p><p>But near the end of the film, during the latter part of the second half, certain things happen, and people did cheer.</p><p>The difference is that those reactions felt earned.</p><p>People weren’t cheering because the movie told them to. They were cheering because they felt it.</p><p>For three movies now, we have watched this man and his family go through absolute hell.</p><p>We have watched people come after them again and again.</p><p>We have watched them suffer.</p><p>And throughout all of it, Georgekutty has remained surprisingly restrained.</p><p>Even when he was fighting back, he was never presented as some unstoppable larger-than-life hero. He was usually cautious, reserved, and often <strong>apologetic</strong>.</p><p>Even in the previous films, there was always an understanding that another family had lost a son. Georgekutty wasn’t celebrating what happened. He wasn’t acting as if he had won some great victory.</p><p>His attitude was more along the lines of: “I have to do what I have to do to protect my family, but I understand the pain this has caused. I’m sorry.”</p><p>That humanity was always there.</p><p>Throughout the series, he gets beaten down, pressured, cornered, and forced into impossible situations. Yet he remains remarkably grounded.</p><p>This time, however, the film allows him to move slightly in the other direction.</p><p>Not fully. Not in the way some people might assume.</p><p>But there are certain lines, certain actions, and certain moments where he starts playing the game on his opponents’ terms a little more than before.</p><p>And the audience loved it.</p><p>Not because it was flashy.</p><p>Not because it was loud.</p><p>But because it felt deserved.</p><p>After three movies of being pushed to the edge, after years of watching people refuse to leave him and his family alone, there is a feeling that Georgekutty has finally reached a point where enough is enough.</p><p>He may have always kept one eye open and remained cautious, but everyone else largely assumed the story was over.</p><p>The problem is that people kept coming after him.</p><p>So when he finally pushes back in a slightly different way and starts playing their game, the reaction from the audience is incredibly satisfying.</p><p>Not because it is shocking.</p><p>Because it is earned.</p><p>The payoff comes from three films’ worth of history, suffering, patience, and emotional investment.</p><p>That’s why those moments work.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/680/0*tcvxN9vNC_3iDJqM.jpg" /><figcaption>Drishyam 3 poster</figcaption></figure><p>The acting is great across the board. Honestly, I don’t know what else I’m supposed to say about it. Nobody stands out in a bad way, and everyone understands exactly what kind of movie they’re in.</p><p>As for the writing, there are moments that might initially feel confusing or questionable. But in most cases, the film eventually addresses them.</p><p>There were a few points while watching where I thought, “That doesn’t work.”</p><p>Then later, the movie explained it.</p><p>For example, there is a scene where a character beats up an elderly man and a young woman to get information. My immediate reaction was that this felt excessive and that there should be consequences.</p><p>But the film actually follows through on that.</p><p>The police use it against him. They threaten legal action, they discuss charges, and they make it clear that what happened cannot simply be ignored.</p><p>In other words, the story goes where it should go.</p><p>It feels as though the director anticipated the audience’s questions and understood that some viewers would immediately challenge the realism of certain actions. Because of that, he makes sure there is follow-up and justification if a character is not ultimately punished in the way people might expect.</p><p>That attention to detail is something I appreciated.</p><p>There is, however, one issue that I had with the film.</p><p>Without spoiling anything, a certain character ends up going to jail near the end of the movie.</p><p>My problem isn’t that the character goes to jail.</p><p>My problem is that it felt as though the character didn’t actually need to.</p><p>From what the movie presents, it seemed like there were ways that person could have avoided that outcome. Instead, the decision happens very quickly, and the film moves on.</p><p>For such a significant development, I think it needed more time.</p><p>It needed a longer scene, more explanation, and a clearer understanding of why that character made that choice.</p><p>As it stands, the moment felt strangely rushed.</p><p>In fact, while watching it, I found myself thinking, “Wait, did they actually go to jail? I need more information here.”</p><p>That’s probably the one major point where I felt the movie moved too quickly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/967/0*G4ifkkwwr_hn-4s3.gif" /><figcaption>Drishyam 3 poster</figcaption></figure><h4>Final Verdict: A Worthy but Not Definitive Sequel</h4><p>Overall, though, this is a very good film.</p><p>It isn’t the best entry in the series. It doesn’t have the groundbreaking impact of the original, and I still prefer Part 2. But it remains a worthy continuation of the story.</p><p>More importantly, it understands what <em>Drishyam</em> is.</p><p>It understands the family.</p><p>It understands the audience.</p><p>And it understands that the real strength of this series was never just the twists. It was the people at the centre of them.</p><p>This is a very good movie from the house of Jeethu Joseph and from the family of <em>Drishyam</em>.</p><p>If you made it to the end, then you’ve basically sat through a trilogy-length argument about why sitting through a trilogy still matters.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=86ef1c28f288" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Patriot Malayalam Movie Review]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TheRamblerReviews/patriot-malayalam-movie-review-b5c0f62d8e91?source=rss-369e2eb4f425------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b5c0f62d8e91</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mohanlal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mammootty]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-cinema]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-reviews]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Rambler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 May 2026 20:16:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-04T20:16:48.571Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>6/10</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k5R_dJgHnZVyDFpfmx9tVg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Patriot (2026) Movie Still</figcaption></figure><p>This is mostly a non-spoiler review until near the end. I will be discussing some criticisms of certain scenes, but those points, such as CGI issues, will not spoil anything. I might briefly describe elements in a scene, like mentioning an airplane, but that does not give any real context about what happens or how it connects to the story.</p><h4>The Good</h4><p>To start with is what we all expected and the marketing already made this clear. We knew it even before the trailers came out. The film looks and feels high level with great production value, refinement (rare for Indian cinema) and international level, for the most part. The high production value really stands out, with no sense of compromise and a very smooth overall presentation. Everything from the visuals to the staging feels carefully put together. It doesn’t feel like other films such as <em>Empuraan</em>, where things felt stretched out, almost like they were trying too hard to show off. I already discussed those issues in my <em>Khalifa</em> glimpse review. Unlike those films, this one feels more grounded, serious, and mature.</p><p>It is refined which is a word that always note unfortunately lacks in Indian cinema but here, before going into the film, there was a feel that it would be well refined and knowingly crafted. Which it was.</p><h4>The Not So Good</h4><p>There were some issues with CGI, but that is to be expected. No one explicitly said this was fully international level, as far as I know, so there is no strict obligation for it to reach that standard. That said, there were also a few filmmaking issues, including some continuity errors. For example, there is a shot of a military jet landing and deploying its parachute, but in the very next shot, the parachute is missing. It felt like the parachute deployment was done with a CGI plane, and then the next shot used a real plane.</p><p>Another example comes from a car chase sequence. The chasing car swerves in front of the car being pursued, so you expect it to be right ahead. But in the next moment, they appear to be around 500 yards apart, seemingly just to set up a high speed standoff where they drive toward each other.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8jPZl2S0EUlHhO7gw2VKPw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Patriot (2026) Movie Still</figcaption></figure><h4>Performances</h4><p>The performances were all good and solid overall.</p><p>All the characters were convincing and generally well acted, with only a few issues. <strong>Mammootty</strong> was very good and delivered exactly what was needed, as he usually does in his own style. <strong>Mohanlal</strong> was similarly reliable, bringing his usual screen presence in his own way. <strong>Kunchacko Boban</strong> also did well, though there is not much more to say about his role.</p><p><strong>Fahadh Faasil</strong>, however, was a bit more mixed. He had some strong moments, especially near the end during the phone conversation with his father, but for the most part it felt like the usual overly eccentric performance we have seen from him in similar roles before. At times, his dialogue was too on the nose and leaned heavily into exposition.</p><p>It almost felt like parts of his performance were reminiscent of Joshua Carlton, but the issue is not entirely his fault. It comes down more to the way the character is written. And because of that, the director, Mahesh Narayanan, could have approached the role differently or given it a different treatment. Alternatively, casting someone like Tovino Thomas might have brought a fresher feel to the character.</p><p>There were some unnecessary characters and elements in the film. One example is Nayanthara’s character. She wasn’t just unnecessary, she was also quite annoying. It felt like she was trying to play something that doesn’t really suit her, even though it is a type of role we have seen from her in Malayalam films before.</p><p>For example, she came across as similarly irritating in <em>Love Action Drama</em>, which was made by someone who didn&#39;t know what he was doing, leaning too heavily into clichés and going all out for a romcom style without much depth. Even more recently, in a Nivin Pauly film promotion, we saw her leaning into that same kind of overly deep voiced tamil serious persona again. It comes off as repetitive and a bit lazy, especially in a film like this where you expect something more grounded and refined. Instead, it feels like the same character all over again, which becomes frustrating.</p><p>There is also a scene near the end set in a courtroom that really stood out for the wrong reasons. Her character behaves in a very unrealistic way, arguing directly against the opposing lawyer, talking down to him, insulting him, and telling him to shut up as if his voice doesn’t matter. That is not how a courtroom works. He raises an objection, and the judge does not respond until she starts arguing and insulting him. Only then does the judge react, which makes no sense.</p><p>In reality, the judge should have immediately stepped in and told her to stop. This is a courtroom, not a place for that kind of behavior. But because she is positioned as one of the “good” characters and the opposing lawyer is framed as the “bad” one, the film seems to expect the audience to cheer this on. It feels like the filmmakers assume viewers will find it cool, but it just comes across as unrealistic and poorly handled. This doesnt even belong in Telugu.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eePsSFHuGNY4uz1PUm5ixA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Patriot (2026) Movie Still</figcaption></figure><h4>The rest of the problems</h4><p>There’s a scene where one character sends Morse code to another character where he is on a random fishing boat. He plucks a couple of pieces of metal off the boat and then uses a radio to send Morse code. However, the person receiving it receives it via their outdoor streetlight. Their outdoor street light was flashing accordingly, which made no sense. How was the morse code transmitter connected to the street light? And to make it somehow worse than this, I don’t know how you can get worse than this, but the receiver character uses his machine to send Morse code back to the original sender somehow. He is on this random boat that rescued him, and he is able to receive this reply, which made no sense.</p><p>Another one is a scene where two different entities are shown trying to track people using the CCTV footage and find information on where they are and where they went. But the way the second entity, a company based in India, gets that information just feels less likely, because this is information from another country, so they can’t just hack into that system that easily.</p><p>But vice versa, you have people in that country trying to get information on exactly who some kidnappers were. They see these four guys on CCTV at that country’s airport, but for some reason they are able to get their exact details, like saying they were graduates of XYZ, they work for A, B and C, and even get their ID photos. It wasn&#39;t just convenient, it was silly.</p><p>But when it comes to <strong>convenience</strong>, there are multiple characters who are too useful and they don’t turn on our main characters. When in trouble, they are getting help from these other people who seemingly have more power than they should, but even if they don&#39;t, they are just willingly helping and have no issues, and they can be fully trusted.</p><p>Multiple <strong>technological elements</strong> being explained in the movie by Mammootty and other characters does not make any sense, and is just false. I mean, it’s cliché, but it’s also too much. It’s ridiculous. If they were saying it in a different context, it might be true, but they don’t explain that context. It just sounds like an old man not knowing what he’s talking about. But people might say, well obviously he means it in a different context, but that needs to be explained.</p><p>It’s just so obvious that multiple of these hacking and spyware elements shown in the movie are not true. This is not me saying that hacking and privacy issues don’t happen. I’m just saying the way they present it in the movie, and try to be so serious with it, and expect the audience to just be on board, is silly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CpqRjcDSemNhsgS57Wq3Ow.jpeg" /><figcaption>Patriot (2026) Movie Still</figcaption></figure><p>There is also a clarity issue in the first half. It is very unclear and confusing. They seem to go too far in taking the audience for granted. In the opposite direction, as usually audiences are treated as if they are dumb by Indian filmmakers. Whereas Malayalam cinema usually does a better job. But here, it feels like they go a bit too far the other way.</p><p>Yes, I said the movie is mostly international level with no compromise. It is very high budget, they go to all sorts of places and do all sorts of things with ease. It is mostly practical effects, with CGI only really noticeable for the airplane. But even with that, there are still some compromises with the <strong>foreign actors</strong>. There are not too many of them, but when they do pop up and speak or act, it still feels a bit compromised, which is the norm in Indian cinema unfortunately.</p><p>This movie does not really look like it is made by Indians at all in terms of its technical quality, filmmaking, and overall feel. It feels like it is on another level, made very expertly. Even elements like computers and CCTV systems feel more convincing and well handled. But there are still some compromises.</p><h4>Mohanlal</h4><p>This is not a <em>Twenty20</em> (2008) level movie. It was never meant to be. Mohanlal is an actor and he himself has said, “my job is done.” People are upset that their favourite actor is in this movie and not doing as much as they wanted him to. It was made extremely clear that it was a cameo, and we all knew that he had an amputation in this movie, so he couldn’t walk without a stick. And yet we knew he was going to have action scenes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tuVscitzjBKqhtfTu9rdLQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Twenty:20 (2008) Malayalam Movie</figcaption></figure><p>One reviewer was like, “Mohanlal was cheated”. He then sarcastically said, “it’s not that kind of movie”, and went on to say, “well, what’s the point of bringing Mohanlal then?” It’s as if he needed to be in a full mass movie like <em>Bha Bha Bha</em>, where they go all in with his mass utilisation. But this is not a mass movie. That has been made very clear. It is a class movie.</p><p>Even with that, there are still some mass elements, such as the fights and action scenes with Mohanlal and Mammootty’ as well as the feel of it all. Meaning there is an underlying expectation that these guys are going to kick ass and aren&#39;t normal.</p><p>Mammootty&#39;s character is not explicitly explained as a former military man. I still don’t know if he is or not. He should have been. This is still an issue in Indian cinema, where normal people are made to do things like this without proper setup, and it continues in this movie too, which is not great.</p><p>Mohanlal is military, but with Mammootty, we don’t know. Yet there are still mass elements in the movie. You can’t say there aren’t, especially with the action scenes, but thankfully they don’t take it too far.</p><p>But this other reviewer was complaining about “elevation moments.” These things ruin Indian cinema. If you want Indian cinema to be taken seriously, there needs to be less of this kind of overdone mass crap.</p><p>Complaining that Mohanlal did not have a bigger role or more substance does not really make sense because he is not the lead actor, he is a guest. He has done many guest roles like this before, and there is nothing to complain about. He is a great performer, but actor first. He does what the script and director needs. He does not need to do what fans expect him to do all the time. He will do that occasionally, but that is not the point of his presence here.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KzYBEWuCLt1wpkm8E748og.jpeg" /><figcaption>Patriot (2026) Movie Still</figcaption></figure><p>The point of bringing both him and Mammootty together is also for the mass appeal. Even though he was not needed in a traditional sense, he is still there. Their real-life friendship is also slightly hinted at in the film. It is not just random people coming together, it is two people who have known each other for years coming together on screen.</p><p>So these elements are hinted at, their friendship, the fact that there are fights, the fact that they are heroes, and the fact that they are good guys who are not corruptible is mass enough in its own way. This is an evolution, a new kind of approach, and it is Malayalam cinema doing something different.</p><p>So saying there is no “Telugu mass” element or saying that Mohanlal was cheated is not really fair. No, he was not cheated. He starred in his friend’s movie, which is also a very big and important film for the industry. That alone is meaningful.</p><p>So that is exactly what this movie was doing. And again, I knew this going in because all the marketing, as well as who the director is, it all hinted at this kind of approach, and it delivered on that promise.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/690/1*MldJU47tecPuKtEc6Qd5Jw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Patriot (2026) Trailer Still</figcaption></figure><p>The issue with the movie is the other elements I explained earlier, but also one more thing, which is that it’s <strong>not that entertaining</strong>. I don’t know if it’s because it’s too serious, but I didn’t really feel it. It’s just not that entertaining and not that gripping. It’s kind of looser than it should have been. The film does move fast, which is great, but there are multiple confusing elements as well as loose and unconvincing parts in the story.</p><p>Along with all the other issues I explained, such as dialogue and the technical, hacking and computer stuff, it just makes it not the best watch. Not the best it could have been. It’s a one-time watch unfortunately.</p><p>Mammootty in an interview apparently said that this movie is not something that will happen or has happened, and that it shouldn’t happen. In a way, that actually fits, because the story only works as fiction since it is highly unconvincing.</p><p>So maybe it is just simply a combination of all of this. I did not assume that this movie was going to be mass fun from the start. I also did not think it was going to be high-level entertainment either. I mean, I got exactly what I expected, but I came out disappointed with the elements that were glaring and bad. So it was technically worse than I expected.</p><p>I mean I was excited to see it, because it’s this kind of movie. I don’t like typical backwards Indian movies. I like this kind of thing. I’ve been begging for this kind of approach from India, especially from Tamil and Malayalam, for a long time and we have got bits and pieces over the years. But in the modern Malayalam age, I wasn&#39;t really surprised that they did this.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/686/0*92QbuGLx_345yzin" /><figcaption>Dubai (2001) Malayalam Movie</figcaption></figure><p>Malayalam cinema has done this kind of thing before where it is big, all-Indian encapsulating, and even starring Mammootty, such as the movie <em>Dubai</em>. I love that movie. Its big, and the opening moments have the all Indian national political feel. It is such an amazing experience watching a Malayalam film from that era that is so big yet still so convincing.</p><p>When the other industries go international, it is not always as convincing and goes into silly territory.</p><p>Many times their big films are still mostly set in India and focused on Indian issues, which is how it should be. I have explained before that going to foreign countries does not automatically make something feel more “international.” That approach failed in films like <em>Empuraan</em> and other newer movies where they go for foreign settings and foreign actors thinking it will feel high level, but it ends up looking silly. If you do the same thing with strong technical quality but set it in India, it often works better and feels more grounded.</p><p>This film does not feel silly in that way. It only goes to foreign locations when it makes sense, and it barely uses foreign actors. It feels like an all-India encapsulating movie dealing with Delhi politics, state government politics, and national-level issues, similar to what we used to see more often in 90s Malayalam cinema. A lot of people might assume Malayalam only does small village stories, but that is not true. In the 90s, Malayalam cinema was a powerhouse for large-scale storytelling as well.</p><p>But because we are in the pan-Indian era now, this movie is not as surprising as it might have been a few years ago. Back then, I would have been much more excited for this kind of thing. There have been some films like this in recent years, but it still does not feel as special anymore because the idea of “big Indian cinema” has become more common.</p><p>Even though the feel of it is somewhat similar to those 90s and 2000s Malayalam films, like the work of director Joshiy, it does not feel as unique now. In today’s pan-Indian landscape, where everything is already expected to be big or global in scope, this kind of approach is no longer as shocking. And films like <em>Empuraan</em> have already shown that.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ym6y5l5XlvLFsVR_" /><figcaption>Empuraan (2025) Malayalam Movie</figcaption></figure><h3>Spoilers</h3><p>The main plot issues involve below poverty line people getting free laptops, and the villain’s company signing an agreement with the government to supply these laptops, which then start spying on the people using them. But the problem is, in the trailer and early part of the movie, <strong>social score</strong> is mentioned by Mammootty’s character. But for some reason that is barely even mentioned afterwards. There is no real social score system in the film. It’s not like China or anything like a proper dystopian setup. People say this is a movie and a story that’s been done before, and that’s true, but this version just doesn’t handle it well.</p><p>The film is very serious and high level in tone and presentation, but this part of the story really falls flat, and near the climax it just gets much worse.</p><p>An element of the movie, where they hype up two teenagers as being affected by the spyware is not fully explained. All we know is that they got affected by the spyware because they were among the poor students. We only focus on one of the girls in the second half of the movie, but it is not even a full focus. I was wondering where the other girl was.</p><p>When it comes to being affected, the thing they say, again without fully explaining in the first half, is that their nudes got leaked, but they don’t explain it properly. For example, at one point Mammootty’s character says that this girl was selling her nudes to someone in another country or something, and then the father committed suicide. It is not fully explained whether if it was actually leaked by a hacker, or that she was selling it, which we all assume she wasn&#39;t.</p><p>But the bigger issue is that even if it was leaked, it is not explained how it happened. As the software is on her laptop, and all the laptops have this software on them, since that is what the company does. So we have to wait until the end for the explanation, and when it finally comes, it is extremely dumb.</p><p>Basically, they spy on these poor people below the poverty line, see their family problems, and then use that information to give them loans, and more loans, so they can earn interest. Then they take the nudes of their children and use that to threaten them into paying back the loans.</p><p>This is extremely dumb. First of all, what planet does this happen on? People will find out. A company just cannot do this without people finding out. Conspiracies don’t exist at that scale because it requires too many people. This is why things like moon landing faking theories, flat Earth, or Illuminati theories don’t make sense, because it requires too many people to stay silent.</p><p>So it’s just unconvincing and stupid.</p><p>Then there is the fact that even if it is possible, they are not living in a country where something like this could happen for any meaningful time. They are living in India, which is a very open and transparent place with a lot of corruption, yes, and a lot of issues, but that does not mean it is not open. There is a level of scrutiny, and especially a level of support that poor people can get. It doesn’t mean they always get it, and they should get more, but something like this, or even anything similar to this, would literally cause chaos and raise hell.</p><p>But the problem is the other human beings working in that company have to do this. You have young men and women who are seemingly part of this system, and they are barely shown, and their moral issues with this are barely explored. But they simply will not do this without any leaks.</p><p>Then there is the fact that, again, it is not explained properly, so it is unclear how the nudes were leaked. My assumption was maybe some rogue employee was leaking them, but no, the whole company was taking the nudes on purpose to threaten the families into paying the loans back.</p><p>But if they don’t have the money to pay the loans back, how are they supposed to pay it? It does not matter how much you threaten them. If they don’t have the money, then how? It literally makes no sense. They are just going to end up killing themselves, which is exactly what happens in the movie.</p><p>How do you give loans expecting to make more money from people who you know don’t have it? Why wasn’t the movie more fresh and using middle class or rich people instead? They are people too, and with good writing and directing you can build sympathy.</p><p>Anyway an overall good movie, let down by some glaring mistakes and a lack of entertainment.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b5c0f62d8e91" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dhurandhar: The Revenge Review]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TheRamblerReviews/dhurandhar-the-revenge-review-4df968be9627?source=rss-369e2eb4f425------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4df968be9627</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ranveer-singh]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bollywood]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dhurandhar]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Rambler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 Mar 2026 22:32:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-19T20:56:39.272Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>6.5/10</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xsTGDdpzzmu_hARm.jpg" /><figcaption>Ranveer Singh in Dhurandhar: The Revenge</figcaption></figure><h3>Overall Filmmaking &amp; Acting</h3><p>The film is really well made. Just like the previous one. When it comes to the actual filmmaking, I’ve already talked about that with the first film, and this one maintains that same general level. The direction is very good, the production value is grand and immersive, and it clearly had the same level of effort behind it.</p><p>The directing and directing of actors is excellent in most cases. Such as the opening with Ranveer and the girl (you know if you have seen the film). Him and her do an exceptional job but you don&#39;t get that level throughout the film though.</p><p>The positives in this are pretty much the same as Part 1 I would say.</p><p>However, the VFX in certain areas, it’s bad and feels unfinished. It’s not that there’s too much of it, it’s that some of it looks like it wasn’t properly completed. That pulls you out of the film, especially in moments that are supposed to feel intense or grounded.</p><p>There are also tactical and action scenes that could have been better or expanded. They’re not terrible, but they feel like missed opportunities. Either they needed more detail, or more time, or just better execution.</p><p>The acting, though, is really good. Ranveer is better here than in the first film. In the first one, he was strong and did what he needed to do. But here, he gets more time to shine, more emotional range, and more presence. And he actually uses that. He was amazing in this one and is easily one of the best parts of the film.</p><h3>Not as Good as the First Film</h3><p>This is the biggest issue.</p><p>The first film felt grand, complete, and impactful. But this felt underwhelming at times but good in other times. Never boring but not fully engaging as the first one.</p><p>The score and songs are underwhelming. Not memorable like the first one, which had multiple songs and scores that were great and memorable.</p><p>The film as a whole actually, in parts, doesn’t feel like it was shot back to back. It feels like it was shot years later, where it takes parts and points from the first and works off them, rather than actually filming at the same time. Of course, this was filmed back to back, but I feel the editing may have changed in response to the first film. What should have actually happened is to make a massive 7-hour movie and simply split it in half; don’t change anything.</p><p>Even for other elements such as action and violence; the first one had more memorable elements than this. This had more gore and they wanted to clearly show more and shock people, but it just wasn’t as memorable and some was forced.</p><p>There were also an overuse of title cards and mass slow motion, which didn’t belong as much for a film like this. A better movie than the usual Indian commercial cinema, but does minor copying of that style. Not a big deal, but can make the film feel too pretentious.</p><p>There are multiple scripting choices and editing choices that drag the film down. It feels messier, less controlled, and at times like it’s trying too hard to be bigger instead of being better.</p><p>There is a large downgrade in terms of interpersonal connections. In Part 1 there is a lot more and here we barely have any. Hamza and Uzair. This should have been the Hamza and Rehman of this film but that went up the swanny. As well as the father in law and of course, his wife. As well as Major Iqbal. The supposed main villain. Hamza and the Major didn’t <em>need</em> to have more interactions in this, as that may not be that realistic, but it would have been nice, and better than nothing.</p><p>In the first film, one of the biggest problems was the love interest. In this film, there are multiple elements that give that same feeling. I’m using that as a reference point. What you felt with the love interest there is what I felt here in several parts of this film. That same frustration, that same sense of something not working.</p><p>The rest of this is just going to be <strong>spoilers</strong> on elements that didn’t work</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ZqUMHg7wytXlBqB_.jpg" /><figcaption>Dhurandhar: The Revenge Movie Still</figcaption></figure><h3>Opening, Backstory &amp; The Land Dispute Problem</h3><p>Right from the beginning, the film makes a major mistake with Ranveer’s backstory.</p><p>There was an expectation that his past would tie into something bigger, like Khalistani terrorism or some larger ideological conflict. That would have immediately given his character more weight. But instead, it turns out to just be a land dispute.</p><p>Even that feels underdeveloped. It almost feels like it may have originally been written as something bigger and then changed later, because what we get feels weaker than what it could have been.</p><p>What actually happens is: his father is killed, one sister is assaulted and killed, another sister is assaulted and kidnapped, and his mother survives.</p><p>That is heavy material. That should have been one of the most emotionally powerful parts of the entire film. But it isn’t. As the film doesn’t show it properly. It doesn’t spend enough time on it. It doesn’t build it up.</p><p>Instead, we first see him going on a violent rampage and keep shouting where is my sister. We don’t have a clue what is happening. There is a lot of brutality but it isn&#39;t earned, it’s confusing. You’re sitting there thinking what is happening, why is he doing this. Only later does the film explain it through flashbacks. That completely weakens the impact.</p><p>They should have shown everything in order: the dispute, the killings, the assault, and then the rampage.</p><p>Not only that, but this entire family angle should have been far more fleshed out. This is the foundation of his character. This is the reason for everything he does.</p><p>And yet, in a film that is nearly three and a half hours long, this part feels rushed.</p><p>That’s a recurring issue in the film. Important elements are too short and not explored properly, while other parts are given too much time.</p><h3>Structure Problems, Flashbacks &amp; Confusion</h3><p>This problem continues throughout the film.</p><p>It keeps showing things first and explaining them later such as the revenge scene for Jaskirat above.</p><p>Instead of creating intrigue, it creates confusion. You’re not asking interesting questions, you’re just annoyed.</p><p>And when the explanation finally comes, it doesn’t feel rewarding. It feels like the film is correcting itself.</p><p>Some time jumps are also handled very poorly.</p><p>His wife is pregnant, then suddenly the baby is one year old. Then suddenly the child is much older, for example.</p><p>We miss huge parts of emotional development, such as his relationship with his wife, his bond with his child, and his internal conflict.</p><p>Again, this is a very long film. It has the time to show all of this, but it doesn’t.</p><p>It feels like the film is skipping important moments just to reach certain plot points. That breaks immersion completely. That’s not good storytelling.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*DIWpeZdgsXA327uQ.jpg" /><figcaption>Dhurandhar: The Revenge Trailer Still</figcaption></figure><h3>Missing Development</h3><p>There is also a scene that showcases multiple deaths and a lot of carnage, with Ranveer and co. killing enemy gangsters very brutally, essentially torturing them to death instead of giving them quick deaths.</p><p>One strength of <em>Dhurandhar 1</em> (mostly, not always) was that the spy elements lurked in the background. It wasn’t just an action crime film. We knew who Ranveer was, so when he killed the Apple guy from the first film, we understood why he didn’t have remorse. When he attacked the servant, we knew why he was being brutal. In other scenes, he showed the right expressions and emotions, ones we would expect Jaskirat/Hamza to display in such moments.</p><p>But here, he was being unfairly brutal to people who weren’t terrorists. If he had done that to terrorists, it would have made sense. But here, he should have taken it easier on these gangsters, who are not innocent, but still more innocent than terrorists. There’s nothing in his face or actions shown to justify this, no indication that he’s putting on a front, or that these are secretly terrorists, etc.</p><p>People might say he was just acting, but he didn’t need to. He could have killed them quickly, like in the last film. The way they killed Arshad Pappu and his gang here just felt strange.</p><p>Another theory could be that he has gone too far and is no longer Jaskirat Singh Rangi, but again, that isn’t shown after those killings. We don’t see him struggling or feeling depressed about having to commit such heinous acts.</p><p>It happens in this one scene and barely comes up again.</p><h3>The Film’s Messaging &amp; Propaganda Feel</h3><p>There are multiple scenes, lines of dialogue, and character decisions throughout the film that make it very easy to call this propaganda.</p><p>Again, the issue is not just realism. It’s not about whether something like this <em>could</em> exist. The real problem is that it’s not convincing.</p><p>The film is very clearly trying to push specific ideas, and it does it in a very blunt and forced way. In Part 1 it even implies that Pakistan were connected to 9/11. There is a difference in attacking India, vs a Pakistani ally like the United States. That was just pathetic.</p><p>This film basically presents the Pakistani side, especially people in power, as individuals who just hate Indians for no reason. Not because of ideology that’s properly explained, not because of personal experiences that we understand, but just pure, constant hatred. They just want to torture, kill, and hurt Indians for the sake of it.</p><p>And that idea is repeated again and again through the dialogue. That’s where it starts to fall apart.</p><p>As instead of feeling natural, the dialogue feels written to push that message as directly as possible. Characters don’t speak like real people. They speak like they are delivering statements.</p><p>Everything becomes very one-note,<br>Every line is about hate,<br>Every line is about violence,<br>Every line is about wanting to hurt Indians.</p><p>There’s no variation in tone. There’s no subtlety. There’s no moment where you feel like these are actual people speaking from a real place. It just feels forced.</p><p>For example, when a Major Iqbal says the reason he is on the phone to terrorists not to guide them but to hear “infidels scream”. It doesn’t come across as chilling or powerful. It comes across as exaggerated and artificial. It feels like the film is trying too hard to make the audience feel a certain way instead of letting the moment speak for itself. And this happens repeatedly.</p><p>The dialogue keeps pushing the same idea in slightly different ways, but it never adds anything new. It doesn’t build character. It doesn’t deepen the story. It just reinforces that same message over and over again.</p><p>Due to that, it actually starts to lose impact.</p><p>When every character speaks with the same kind of hatred, it stops feeling intense and starts feeling repetitive. And more importantly, it stops being believable.</p><p>Even in films that are very patriotic or one-sided, the characters still need to feel like individuals. They need to have their own voice, their own reasoning, their own personality. Here, that is missing.</p><p>Instead, it feels like the film has one voice, and every character on that side is speaking through it. That’s what makes it feel like propaganda.</p><p>It’s not just what the film is saying, it’s how it’s saying it. The lack of nuance, the repetition in dialogue, and the constant push of the same idea without variation makes everything feel forced and unnatural.</p><p>And in the end, that doesn’t make the film more powerful.</p><p>It actually weakens it, because instead of feeling real and grounded, it feels exaggerated and constructed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/850/0*endEBKsAYdFmZQd_.jpeg" /><figcaption>Arjun Rampal in Dhurandhar: The Revenge</figcaption></figure><h3>Major Iqbal &amp; His Father</h3><p>Major Iqbal is one of the clearest examples of where the film goes wrong with its writing.</p><p>He is written as someone who just constantly hates. That is basically his entire character. Everything he says is about killing Indians, torturing them, or expressing hatred towards them. There is no variation in his personality, no different sides to him, no moments where he feels like an actual human being. He is just hate, all the time.</p><p>And because of that, he doesn’t come across as a strong villain. He comes across as a forced one.</p><p>There is a scene where he burns an innocent couple alive just because they are Indian. Not spies. Not enemies. Just Indian. That’s not character depth. That’s shock value.</p><p>And again, because the film keeps doing things like this without proper buildup or reasoning, it stops being impactful. It just becomes another example of the film pushing the same idea in an exaggerated way.</p><p>Now, the film does try to explain why he is like this through his father.</p><p>His father is a former brigadier, and he is shown as a completely horrible person. He constantly insults his own son, belittles him at every opportunity, and openly talks about the fact that he assaulted women in Bangladesh. He carries that same level of hatred and brutality, and the film is clearly trying to show that Major Iqbal grew up in that environment.</p><p>So the idea is obvious:<br>His father was like this,<br>He grew up around that mindset,<br>And that’s why he turned out this way.</p><p>But the execution doesn’t work.</p><p>It feels too extreme and not properly developed. These moments are just thrown in without enough depth or buildup. We don’t actually see how this shaped him over time. We’re just told, in a very blunt way, that this is his background.</p><p>Because of that, it doesn’t feel like a real psychological explanation. It feels like a shortcut. And that’s the difference between something being <em>shown</em> and something just being <em>told</em>.</p><p>Compare that to something like The Family Man Season 2. In that show, the Samantha’s trauma is actually explored. You see what happened to her by the Sinhala soldiers, you see how it affected her, and you understand how it connects to her actions in the present. Even when she does extreme things, you can see the logic behind it.</p><p>Here, that connection is missing. Major Iqbal needed to have Indians kill his family and friends or something like that. But Indians are only shown in a good light.</p><p>We are told that Major Iqbal comes from a brutal background, but we don’t feel it. We don’t see it properly develop. It doesn’t translate into a layered character.</p><p>So instead of feeling like a product of his environment, he just feels like a character who exists to hate. And that’s the main problem.</p><p>A villain like this needed depth, needed nuance, needed some level of internal logic. But instead, he is written in the most one-dimensional way possible. And because of that, he never feels as convincing as he need to be or as much as Part 1, no matter how extreme his actions are.</p><h3>Gangsters, Dawood Ibrahim, &amp; Loss of Nuance</h3><p>One of the biggest problems in this film is how it completely erases the nuance that made the first movie’s criminal world compelling. In the original film, gangsters, politicians, and intelligence agencies were separate, and that separation mattered. Gangsters like Rehman Baloch were driven by money and power. They were violent and dangerous, but not full on ideological terrorists. The ISI interacted with them primarily to buy weapons or gain access to networks. Gangsters were suppliers, not ideologues. That separation allowed for a layered, morally ambiguous world where motivations felt believable and tension felt earned.</p><p>In this sequel, all of that subtlety is gone. The film repeatedly signals that gangsters are no longer criminals first and pragmatic second; they are terrorists first, and loyalty to the ideological cause comes before profit or personal interest. The world is simplified into a black-and-white moral structure: criminal equals terrorist, and anyone who wants to rise in the system must conform. This removes all the tension and complexity that made the first film engaging.</p><p>The film reinforces this point through the mysterious figure known as Bade Sahb, who is revealed to be none other than Dawood Ibrahim. In real life, Dawood is a former gangster involved in the 1993 Mumbai train blasts and a highly wanted criminal. Here, the film elevates him to the role of a key figure orchestrating terror networks in Pakistan, which is a major creative liberty but adds intrigue. Importantly, Dawood even says a line to Ranveer that underscores the idea the film is trying to push: he tells Ranveer that gangsters like Rehman Baloch were loyal to this cause, and that anyone wanting to succeed in this world must align with the same ideology. It crystallises the narrative the film is implicitly promoting: gangsters are terrorists first.</p><p>This approach reduces what was once a multi-layered, morally complex world into a simplified, one-dimensional story. Gangsters are no longer nuanced figures navigating a system for survival or profit, but are fully ideological actors, and Dawood Ibrahim’s brief line merely echoes and reinforces that idea. The richness and realism of the criminal ecosystem from the first film is lost, leaving a world that feels flatter, less believable, and over-simplified.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ZQxfagTGRnPhXlLi.jpg" /><figcaption>Sanjay Dutt in Dhurandhar: The Revenge</figcaption></figure><h3>SP Chaudhary Aslam &amp; Character Inconsistency</h3><p>This is continued with SP Chaudhary Aslam. He was one of the most frustrating parts of this film.</p><p>In the first movie, he was interesting, compelling, and exciting to watch — a police officer navigating gangs with sharp instincts, clear motivations, and a strong presence. His scenes were tense, engaging, and grounded in the criminal-political world he operated in, making him one of the most memorable characters.</p><p>In this sequel, that foundation is completely mishandled. The film takes the same logic it applied to gangsters — that they are terrorists loyal to an ideology — and applies it to SP and his second-in-command.</p><p>He watches Major Iqbal burn the Indian couple alive, but the fact that they were talking like colleagues in the first place is itself weird. SP tells the Major that he hated Rehman as he wronged Bade Sahib. Not that he was a police officer going after criminals like he is supposed to. He shouldn&#39;t be involved with the ISI and especially not jihad.</p><p>After the SP dies, his second-in-command takes over, and the film also treats him almost like he is part of the terrorist/ISI system. He references the godfather-style scene where multiple terrorists are killed and astonishingly calls them “our men,” implying loyalty to the very people he should oppose. He immediately suspects Ranveer of being an Indian agent, escalates by threatening his wife and child, and somehow has the ability to contact Major Iqbal to tell him that Hamza is an agent, all of which makes zero sense for a police officer.</p><p>SP Chaudhary and his second-in-command are still police officers, operating in a political-law-enforcement context, yet the film forces them into behaviour that aligns with the extremist, terror-driven logic it applies to gangsters. They act like quasi-terrorists, involved in matters they should have no access to, and the audience is left questioning how and why this is even possible. SP is reduced to a tool of the story’s forced logic, and his second-in-command is an even worse example of character inconsistency.</p><p>This treatment highlights one of the film’s major flaws: it strips away nuance and credibility from characters who were already established, replacing them with actions that feel forced, illogical, and designed only to serve the “Pakistani = terrorists” narrative. The result is frustration and disbelief — a once compelling character becomes implausible.</p><h3>The Killing Sequence &amp; Missing Impact</h3><p>The sequence where multiple high-ranking terrorists are killed should have been a major, impactful part of the film. This could have carried serious tension, drama, and stakes. Instead, the film crams nearly all of it into one stretch, as if it’s a montage meant to tick boxes rather than tell a story. It feels rushed, confusing, and ultimately underwhelming.</p><p>To make matters worse, the people carrying out these killings are <strong>two masked men on bikes</strong>, and the film never explains who they are. Are they Indian agents? Pakistani gangsters? Are they some rogue force? If Pakistani, why would they kill men they revere? We never know. They simply exist to serve the plot, and the audience is left to fill in the blanks. There is no buildup, no context, no reasoning, no human connection to these deaths. They just happen.</p><p>This is especially frustrating because the film is over three hours long — there was more than enough runtime to space out these kills, give each one weight, show the planning, the tension, and the consequences. Instead, we get a crammed sequence that makes it feel like the story is skipping important beats, rushing through a crucial narrative point. It’s visually striking for a moment, but it doesn’t feel earned.</p><p>The lack of explanation for the masked killers and the compressed nature of the sequence also undermines the rest of the narrative. The whole sequence demonstrates one of the film’s recurring issues: <strong>it cheats and doesn&#39;t prioritise clarity, and narrative weight</strong>, leaving the audience frustrated rather than impressed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/0*s4fqnJn4obUdN2uy.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ranveer Singh in Dhurandhar 2</figcaption></figure><h3>The Arrest, Interrogation &amp; Plot Logic</h3><p>One of the biggest problems in this film is the way Ranveer gets caught after the climax. This entire sequence feels completely unnecessary and forced. After defeating Major Iqbal, Ranveer clearly has the opportunity to escape, especially since his team, along with the Baloch people he has allied with, are on his side. There is no narrative reason for him to stay behind and get captured, yet the film forces him into this situation as if tension must be manufactured at any cost.</p><p>During this period, the film tries to make it feel like there are real stakes, but the tension falls flat because the story gives no logical motivation for his capture. He calls his wife on the phone as if it’s their last conversation ever, creating an artificial sense of drama. It’s meant to feel emotional, but doesn’t as he could have escaped and seen her and his son again.</p><p>He gets caught and is tortured where SP’s second in command is there for some reason. After he arrests him, he should hand him over to the ISI but this police officer is at an ISI site beating Hamza, with the ISI Director General watching as he gets beaten.</p><p>The escape itself relies on an absurdly convenient plot device. Madhavan suddenly arrives with information that blackmails the ISI Director General, revealing his supposed trading of secrets to Israel. This comes completely out of nowhere. There is no earlier foreshadowing or setup, no hint that this was possible, and yet the film treats it as a dramatic climax. It’s lazy storytelling: Ranveer didn’t need to be captured at all in the first place, and the way he is released feels like a cheat rather than a satisfying payoff.</p><p>The reliance on forced drama and contrived plot mechanics instead of allowing the story to unfold naturally. Ranveer’s capture, phone call, blackmail, and eventual escape could have been thrilling and emotionally powerful, but here it comes across as arbitrary, overlong, and frustrating. It’s a clear example of the film trying to manufacture tension at the expense of logic, character consistency, and audience engagement.</p><h3>Ending, Family &amp; Emotional Disconnect</h3><p>The ending of the film is extremely frustrating and emotionally unsatisfying. Ranveer finally returns to India after all the chaos in Pakistan, after all the danger, after all the sacrifices, and what does he do? He sees his mother and sister from afar — and then just <strong>stops</strong>. He doesn’t go in. There’s no reason for this hesitation. His mother and sister are completely safe in India, living in the same house as before, unharmed, yet the film treats this pause as if it’s meaningful. It isn’t. It’s arbitrary and breaks the narrative logic.</p><p>The situation with his wife and child is even more illogical. They are still in Pakistan, and the film insists he must “forget them,” but there is no real obstacle. His wife is rich and the daughter of a politician, so she has the means and freedom to leave Pakistan. Ranveer himself is safe back in India, and he would also be safe abroad. He had even originally planned to move them to Canada. There is no reason they cannot be reunited. Yet the film artificially enforces separation, creating tension that doesn’t actually exist.</p><p>The filmmakers’ handling of these relationships undermines what should have been the emotional core of the story. Moments that could have been deeply satisfying — reuniting with his mother and sister in India, seeing his wife and child safe and secure, potentially abroad — are instead hollow. The tension and “stakes” the film tries to create are manufactured rather than earned.</p><p>By arbitrarily forcing Ranveer to hesitate in India and forbidding him from seeing his wife and child, despite all the practical means for them to be safely together, the film prioritizes contrived drama over logical storytelling and emotional payoff. The result is an ending that feels manipulative, disconnected, and deeply disappointing, especially compared to the more coherent and satisfying resolution of the first film.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/850/0*AkIxC8SNEgpjirUl.jpeg" /><figcaption>R. Madhavan in Dhurandhar: The Revenge</figcaption></figure><h3>Missed Opportunity — Baloch Storyline &amp; Love Interest</h3><p>The Baloch storyline in this film could have added real emotional depth and meaningful stakes, but the filmmakers completely miss the mark. Ranveer is shown undercover as part of a Baloch tribe, befriending the community and gaining their trust. They take up arms alongside him against the ISI and the terrorist networks oppressing them.</p><p>This sets up a perfect opportunity for the love interest to come organically from within that community — a woman whose life is directly affected by the conflict, whose loyalty to Ranveer is earned, and whose personal stakes are tied to the central narrative. Instead, the film gives him a rich politician’s daughter.</p><p>This choice creates a disconnect. Rich Pakistanis are far less likely to be personally affected or emotionally invested in the killing of Indians by jihadis. She is insulated from the very conflicts Ranveer is risking everything to fight. Her wealth and status make her almost irrelevant to the stakes of the story, and yet the film leans on the tired trope of a poorer hero winning the heart of a rich girl. In reality, a Baloch woman — someone on Ranveer’s level in terms of exposure to risk and oppression — would have made far more narrative sense, both emotionally and thematically.</p><p>The film also mishandles the consequences of Ranveer’s actions on this character. In both Part 1 and Part 2, he essentially “ruins her life” by marrying and impregnating her while she becomes unwittingly complicit in his mission as an Indian agent. The story does not explain why he chooses her, why she must be involved at all, or why this should happen at all. When she asks him about the impact of his actions, he dismissively responds that he is only targeting terrorists, not her, yet he provides no justification for the profound personal cost she endures. This leaves a major emotional and ethical gap: the audience is expected to accept that she is sacrificed for the mission without any real narrative or emotional grounding.</p><p>By ignoring the Baloch angle and failing to integrate the love interest into the community and conflict, the film loses a chance to explore nuanced relationships, ethical dilemmas, and personal stakes. A Baloch woman would have strengthened the emotional core of the story, aligned naturally with the plot of tribal support and uprising, and created a genuine reason for audience investment. Instead, we are left with a rich politician’s daughter whose involvement feels arbitrary, a hero whose romantic choices are disconnected from his mission, and a missed opportunity to make the Baloch storyline resonate meaningfully.</p><p>As well as this, something that was set up in Part 1 was the ISI hiring the Balochs and here there is a payoff. But a lot more time should have been spent on them.</p><h3>Length vs Execution</h3><p>The film clocks in at around three and a half hours, which should have been more than enough time to properly develop all the major storylines, characters, and emotional beats. In theory, with that runtime, there is room to fully explore Ranveer’s family tragedy, the land dispute, the love interest, the Baloch uprising, the gangsters and their interactions with terrorism, Major Iqbal’s motivations, SP Chaudhary’s arc, the second-in-command’s actions, and the climactic action sequences.</p><p>Instead, the execution is uneven and frustrating. Important parts of the story are rushed or barely touched, leaving the audience confused or disconnected. The land dispute and Ranveer’s family loss, for example, could have been given far more emotional weight, showing the full impact on his father, sisters, and his own psyche — yet these scenes are brief and fragmented. Key character motivations, like why his love interest must be involved in his mission or why the Baloch community allies with him, are skimmed over, leaving narrative and emotional gaps.</p><p>At the same time, other sequences are unnecessarily stretched. Action scenes or filler moments drag on without adding meaningful tension or depth, which throws off the overall rhythm of the film. The massacre of high-ranking terrorists, for example, is crammed into one godfather-style montage that is chaotic and underwhelming, despite having huge potential for impact. Similarly, Ranveer’s escape, capture, and eventual resolution feel arbitrarily elongated in some places while skipping over key logical steps or motivations in others.</p><p>Overall, the film’s runtime creates the expectation of epic storytelling, but the balance between action, character development, and narrative cohesion is badly off. The audience is left with sections that feel overstuffed, underdeveloped, or illogical — a frustrating combination given that the time was there to do it right. This mismatch between length and execution contributes heavily to the sense that, despite being long, the film ultimately falls short of its potential.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*e9SiXRx6fWkM5gn2" /><figcaption>Dhurandhar: The Revenge Movie Still</figcaption></figure><h3>Final Thoughts</h3><p>Overall, the film is good, but it is a disappointment compared to the first.</p><p>It has strong performances, especially from Ranveer. It has scale and action.</p><p>But the writing, structure, and character handling bring it down.</p><p>The first film felt great. This one not so great.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4df968be9627" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What People Don’t Understand About Drishyam]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TheRamblerReviews/what-people-dont-understand-about-drishyam-8bf2cd43559b?source=rss-369e2eb4f425------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8bf2cd43559b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bollywood]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[malayalam-movie]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mohanlal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[drishyam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-cinema]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The Rambler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 15 Feb 2026 20:21:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-19T21:05:12.309Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*8_vjMtHgNBFFKe2J.jpg" /><figcaption>Drishyam Malayalam Movie Still</figcaption></figure><p>People have fundamental misunderstandings about what the story <em>Drishyam</em> is. I say “story” and not “movie,” as there are multiple movies and multiple versions.</p><p>The main argument you often hear is this: whenever the Hindi <em>Drishyam</em> comes up, people immediately compare it to the original Malayalam film. Some say, “Watch the original, it’s far superior.” Others argue the Hindi version is better. Among those who say the Malayalam Original is worse, have common complaints that say it had unnecessary elements, overlong runtime, and bloated storytelling.</p><p>But that, right there, is the fundamental misunderstanding.</p><p>As great cinema does, it operates on levels that a lot of casual viewers haven’t even thought about.</p><p>Now, casual viewers are not wrong. Many people watch movies purely for surface-level entertainment. I don’t blame them. If you don’t care about cinema as an art form and have more important things to do, that’s fine. Movies are meant to be enjoyed, after all. But there’s a distinction between casual viewing and cinematic craft.</p><p>The finer rules of filmmaking, the rules that give a film longevity, depth, and emotional resonance, are what make a movie evergreen. Many films that succeed commercially fail after the first watch or fade from memory after a few years. But great cinema lives on. Context, culture, and audience expectations matter, but the core idea remains: exceptional movies are designed on multiple levels, often manipulating expectations, emotions, and even perception itself.</p><p>The general audience does not usually know these rules, but the filmmakers should, or at least aspire to. When even filmmakers fail at this, that’s when problems arise.</p><p>There’s no point in “educating” casual viewers, they know they don’t know, and often, they don’t care. But filmmakers must understand these rules.</p><p>It is that great cinema is made in a way that reflects its story and themes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2p3Q-HMLuX2BKahQ" /><figcaption>The Brutalist (2024)</figcaption></figure><p>For example, if you have heard of a movie called <em>The Brutalist</em>, the reason people call it “boring” or “brutalist” is because that was the point. The film is about a particular architectural style: brutalism. Brutalist architecture is functional, straightforward, and often criticized as cold or monotonous. It emerged post-World War II to meet social and economic demands, it was utilitarian, efficient, and unadorned. It’s not meant to be flashy or emotionally manipulative.</p><p>The movie <em>The Brutalist</em> intentionally bakes this aesthetic into its filmmaking. Its pacing, tone, and atmosphere mirror the style of architecture it depicts: deliberate, methodical, and austere. If the filmmakers had simply told a story about a brutalist architect in a conventional, entertaining way; fast cuts, dramatic reveals, melodrama, you would have missed the point. You might even feel disconnected from the characters, because the experience wouldn’t reflect the very essence of what the story is about. The film is less about plot mechanics and more about immersion into a world shaped by the principles of brutalist design.</p><p>That’s what <em>Drishyam</em> does too, but in a very different way.</p><p>You don’t have to do this. There are plenty of great films that succeed purely on character, writing, acting, or emotional depth. But when a filmmaker goes a step further and bakes the story into the very making of the film itself, using pacing, tone, framing, editing, and even audience expectation to reflect the narrative, then that is pure cinema. It’s when form and content are inseparable, when watching the film is not just observing a story but experiencing it on multiple levels.</p><p>So, what is the story of <em>Drishyam</em>? What does “Drishyam” (visual) refer to? On the surface, it’s the fake visuals the protagonist, Georgekutty, constructs to mislead the police. But most people completely miss a deeper layer: the audience, especially the original Malayalam audience, also plays the role similar to that of the police.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*oXx3xttyHSKAT6z0.jpg" /><figcaption>Drishyam Malayalam Movie Still</figcaption></figure><p>The Malayalam audience initially thought it was a family drama. Marketing didn’t hint at murder or thriller elements. The movie manipulated expectations in a way that mirrored how Georgekutty manipulates the police. From the very first scene, it signals a quiet, ordinary family drama: Georgekutty is a loving husband, a devoted father, and a responsible, law-abiding man. His family seems wholesome, his life mundane, and the narrative encourages the audience to settle into comfort.</p><p>As the story progresses, viewers are gently nudged into assumptions. When the crime happens, the audience is just as blind as the police. They suspect, theorize, and even convince themselves they might know where the body is — because the film lays subtle breadcrumbs, almost like misdirection in magic. The camera lingers on Georgekutty’s nervous behavior, the way he interacts with neighbors, and the seemingly “innocuous” conversations he has — but all of this is designed to mislead. Every detail feels significant, yet nothing is truly what it seems.</p><p>By the time the police investigation intensifies, the audience is fully invested, desperately trying to anticipate the next move. Some viewers even pride themselves on guessing the solution, believing they know Georgekutty’s secret. The film encourages this false sense of mastery, letting the audience feel one step ahead. And then, slowly, meticulously, the truth is revealed: Georgekutty has been orchestrating a perfect illusion the entire time. The body’s location, the false timelines, the carefully planted “evidence” — all of it was a cinematic sleight of hand.</p><p>But so was Jeetu and team. They fooled the audience and so mirrored the story in real life.</p><p>The impact is profound. Viewers experience the same shock and awe as the police officers on screen. For many, it’s not just a thriller — it’s a lesson in how easily perception can be manipulated when every piece of information is carefully curated. And the result? The film didn’t just become a talking point — it became a cultural phenomenon, grossing around 70 crores in 2013. For a Malayalam film at that time, this was nothing short of extraordinary, equivalent to a Hindi blockbuster earning 300–500 crores. The audience didn’t just watch Georgekutty — they <em>lived</em> the experience, complicit in the manipulation, and completely blindsided by the revelation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*r09zl4m-QLo7PS_m" /><figcaption>Drishyam Hindi Miovie Still</figcaption></figure><p>Now compare this to the Hindi <em>Drishyam</em>, which made roughly 100–150 crores in an industry 5–10 times larger. Even with a bigger potential audience, it couldn’t even double the Malayalam film’s success.</p><p>Imagine if the Hindi remake had been marketed like the Malayalam film: as a family drama, revealing its thriller elements slowly, letting the audience be shocked organically. It could have been monumental.</p><p>Some argue: “The Hindi audience would have known it was a thriller anyway.” I disagree. Back then (even now), most Hindi viewers didn’t follow non-Hindi cinema closely. They might have heard it was a thriller, but they weren’t expecting the narrative to manipulate perception the way the Malayalam version did.</p><p>The problem lies with the makers. Hindi filmmakers, in general, don’t trust their audience to sit with subtle storytelling. Malayalam filmmakers often do. If the Hindi <em>Drishyam</em> had followed the Malayalam approach, it could have maintained the tension, surprises, and immersive experience. Instead, it took the simpler, more conventional route, giving early thrills at the cost of narrative depth.</p><p>But it feels worse, as it seems as if they simply didn’t know what they were remaking, rather than truly understanding and appreciating the original but choosing to make a worse version because they think that makes them money. Both seem bad, but the former is worse.</p><p>The Hindi audience still loves <em>Drishyam</em>, proudly recommending it to international viewers alongside <em>3 Idiots</em> and <em>RRR</em>. But in doing so, they miss a huge part of what made the original special. The Hindi remake is fine on its own, but it could have been transcendent. It’s a good product — but not the best it could have been. That frustration is real.</p><p>As this film, in particular, could easily have had a better version, the problem is that a better version <em>does</em> exist — but most international viewers simply won’t watch non-Hindi films early on, with a few exceptions like Rajamouli’s big hits.</p><p>The Malayalam version, despite its brilliance, often gets dismissed by the Hindi audience as “weird” or “not straight to the point.” People expect everything to be fast, obvious, and neatly packaged. They miss the subtlety, the patience, and the way the story manipulates perception, so they don’t appreciate the craftsmanship that makes it extraordinary.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*sQXtR9OWx1Bjzve5.jpg" /><figcaption>Drishyam 2 Malayalam Movie cast with the director Jeethu Joseph</figcaption></figure><p>Jeethu Joseph, the director, repeated this narrative mastery in <em>Drishyam 2</em>. Again, it was marketed as a simple family drama, with little emphasis on suspense. And once again, the audience was surprised by twists and tension — proof of his skill at layering story and experience.</p><p>The Hindi sequel remake again opted for the simpler route, missing the chance to elevate the story fully.</p><p>The point of Drishyam is this; the story is the experience — the dual narrative. One story unfolds on screen. The other plays in the mind of the audience. That’s what makes the original Malayalam film pure cinema.</p><p>The reason the Hindi <em>Drishyam</em> isn’t truly a great movie isn’t because it’s a remake. The issue lies in context. It’s a remake, yes, but it isn’t an adaptation. It’s a straight, almost literal reproduction of the original story, stripped of the nuances that made the Malayalam version brilliant. Instead of understanding <em>why</em> the original worked — the careful pacing, the audience manipulation, the trust in viewers to sit with subtle tension — the Hindi version tried to cash in on the idea with the safest, most conventional approach.</p><p>The better version was right there, clearly visible in the original. All it required was patience, subtlety, and a willingness to let the audience experience the story rather than rushing for thrills. But the makers chose not to do it, either from ignorance, a lack of trust in the audience, or fear of taking a “risk.”</p><p>When a product works on its own terms but could have been easily elevated into something extraordinary, and yet isn’t, that is a failure. It’s not outright bad, but it’s <em>frustrating</em>. It’s competent, sure, but it leaves you staring at what <em>could have been</em>, aware that a better, more complete version existed the entire time. That’s what makes it disappointing.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8bf2cd43559b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>