<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Dr Tom Quinn on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Dr Tom Quinn on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ThomasJ_Quinn?source=rss-556f17ee0ef8------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 22:47:25 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ThomasJ_Quinn/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lab-grown meat isn’t the solution]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ThomasJ_Quinn/lab-grown-meat-isnt-the-solution-096571255724?source=rss-556f17ee0ef8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/096571255724</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dr Tom Quinn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 25 Oct 2023 19:00:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-25T12:46:45.687Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Why growing meat in a lab can’t solve the ethical or environmental problems with our food system</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yq9c4W0re3SZfNQ3lSvgSg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Richard Dawkins wants to eat you.</p><p>No, really. It’s no secret: <a href="https://twitter.com/richarddawkins/status/969939225180364805?lang=en">he tweeted about it last year</a>. ‘I’ve long been looking forward to this’, he wrote, ‘Could we overcome our taboo against cannibalism?’ Don’t worry, though. He’s not really into eating actual people — just eating human meat grown from someone’s stem cells in a lab. Nobody gets hurt, so it’s fine and not weird at all. Right?</p><p>Dawkins was commenting on an article that predicted lab-grown meat would hit the supermarket shelves in 2018. Lab grown animal meat, by the way, not human meat — Dawkins was just taking it a bit too far, as he tends to do. Lab-grown meat didn’t turn up in the shops last year, but it’s definitely on its way at some point: <a href="https://www.atkearney.com/retail/article/?%2Fa%2Fhow-will-cultured-meat-and-meat-alternatives-disrupt-the-agricultural-and-food-industry=">a report last week</a> predicted 35% of our meat would be lab-grown by 2040.</p><p>Growing lumps of meat in a lab instead of having to farm and slaughter animals is often hailed as the solution to all the ethical and environmental problems with our carnivorous diets. Less damaging to the environment, less suffering for animals, and delicious meat for humans to eat. Win-win-win. It’s even got the backing of animal advocate and utilitarian philosopher <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Singer#Animal_liberation_and_veganism">Peter Singer</a>.</p><p>But is lab-grown meat really the silver bullet it’s made out to be? I’m not so sure. On a closer look, it doesn’t seem likely to solve the problems with eating meat — ethical or environmental.</p><h3>Lab-grown meat could turn us into ‘moral weaklings’</h3><p>Peter Singer may be unconcerned about lab-grown meat, but that’s because he’s a proponent of consequentialist ethics: a view on which what matters ethically are the consequences of our actions, the actual outcomes. Whichever outcome on balance produces the most happiness or least suffering is the right one. For Singer, it’s a no-brainer: fewer animals are being hurt and people are still able to eat meat. Nobody’s being harmed, so what could be wrong with it?</p><p>Others, like <a href="https://www.tcd.ie/news_events/articles/lab-grown-meat-could-let-humanity-ignore-a-serious-moral-failing/">philosopher Ben Bramble</a>, are more worried. It’s not the immediate consequences of lab-grown meat that are troubling, but the moral attitudes lab-grown meat promotes. It could promote a lack of respect for animals, and a lack of moral virtue in humans.</p><p>Let’s look at the problem. Our current food system is pretty terrible. Billions of animals live their lives in horrific conditions, huge areas of land are wasted to grow crops to feed them, and the emissions from this process are a big contributor to climate change. Some people have responded to the problem by choosing to buy meat from smaller, ethical producers or becoming vegan and vegetarian. But most still buy whatever is on the supermarket shelves — that’s why the system remains so profitable.</p><p>Lab-grown meat is meant to solve this problem by giving people an easy alternative. You don’t have to research the farms your meat comes from, or stop eating meat altogether. You can just carry on exactly as you did before, except the burger you buy from the shop will have come from a petri dish rather than a cow. But is this solution too easy? It doesn’t require us to change our behaviour at all in response to what we know is a damaging problem. We’re not having to flex our moral muscles and make any kind of change — instead we’re just finding another way to carry on behaving as we always have.</p><p>To see the problem, let’s think about a slightly different case. Imagine that the government found a new way to stop burglaries happening: instead of having to actually steal things, would-be thieves could just note down the things they want to steal and the government would provide them for free. It’s a very effective way to stop burglaries happening, because nobody has to change their behaviour. They just get what they want without anyone else being harmed. But it still seems a less than ideal solution, precisely because nobody has had to rethink their urge to steal — instead it’s just a new way to satisfy that urge. It’s the same with lab-grown meat: we haven’t had to change our behaviour in response to an ethical problem, we’ve just had the problem solved for us.</p><p>Perhaps a staunch consequentialist would say this doesn’t matter at all — it’s the outcome that matters. But this sense that something’s not quite right seems to suggest that there’s more to acting morally than just the consequences.</p><p>Eating lab-grown meat is fine, but the lack of moral effort we’ve had to put in may come back to bite us later when we face an ethical problem where there is no easy solution. We may find ourselves less able to change our behaviour in the future if we’re used to waiting for some new technology to solve the problem for us.</p><h3>What’s wrong with eating lab-grown human meat?</h3><p>Back to Richard Dawkins’ cannibalistic fantasy: the rise of lab-grown meat could actually make it a reality.</p><p>Once we can easily create slabs of meat from stem cells, we’re faced with a choice. One the one hand, we could just use it to create meat from the animals we’re used to eating: pigs, chickens and cows. But this seems a bit speciesist, doesn’t it? If we can create blobs of muscle from any source we want, with no pain or suffering for the thing being eaten, why only create meat from the animals we currently farm? Rather than taking the opportunity to repair our relationship with animals, we’re continuing to see them as the kind of things that are for eating.</p><p>On the other hand, if we wanted to be totally fair about the whole thing, we could create meat not just from animals, but from humans too. That’s true equality. After all, nobody would be getting hurt: it’s just grown in a lab from a bunch of stem cells.</p><p>There’s a catch: overcoming our ‘taboo against cannibalism’ might not be something we necessarily want to do. Once we’re all happy to munch away on our human burgers, will we be able to stop thinking of people as meaty snacks? Will we be eyeing up our work colleagues, wondering what they’d taste like in a sausage? And what if the meat labs close down — will we be so hooked on human meat that we end up killing and eating each other?</p><p>All speculation, but Dawkins should be careful what he wishes for.</p><h3>Will lab-grown meat actually help the environment?</h3><p>In 2013 two food experts sat down in a brightly lit television studio and ate a burger. A live studio audience watched their every move — they gingerly cut off tiny chunks of pink meat, sniffed them with frowning expressions, and chewed each mouthful with intense concentration. Their meal was broadcast on news bulletins around the world.</p><p>This was the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9XqcIkbxxBw">first taste-test of a lab grown burger</a>, which cost $330,000 and took two years to make. The experts’ verdict: a little dry and lacking in flavour.</p><p>The technology has developed since then, but it’s still not certain that lab-grown burgers will be able to perfectly replicate the meat we’re used to eating now. So what’s the point of investing all this money, resource and energy into developing them? We already have passable plant-based meat imitations — I’ve had a <a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/food-and-drink/meatless-bleeding-burger-uk-launch-b12-taste-vegan-veggie-moving-mountains-a8220901.html">B12 burger</a> and it wasn’t dry or flavourless. What problem is lab-grown meat meant to be solving that can’t also be solved by plant-based ‘burgers’?</p><p>Lab-grown meat is supposed to solve the environmental problems caused by our meat consumption: the emissions from beef farming, as well as the huge amounts of land being used up growing feed for livestock. But a <a href="https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fsufs.2019.00005/full">number of</a> <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26383898">studies</a> have raised questions about this — arguing that, in fact, the process could emit enough CO2 to make global warming worse than if we carried on with our current meat-eating habits. Switching to plant-based burgers would do a much better job at reducing emissions.</p><p>The main reason lab-grown meat is touted as a brilliant solution, is that it won’t require people to change their habits at all. Switching to a plant-based diet is a bit of a departure, even if you stick to vegan burgers and sausages that taste pretty meaty. But with lab-grown meat, you can carry on eating just the same as you always did — it’s just that your hotdog or Sunday roast will have come from a lab.</p><p>This argument doesn’t fly either. As we’ve seen, it isn’t a given that lab-grown meat really will taste exactly the same as the real thing. If you’re going to eat a slightly-different imitation, might as well eat the plant one that doesn’t cost millions of dollars to develop.</p><p>And there’s a bigger obstacle to people making an easy switch to lab-grown meat: the ‘yuck’ factor of eating food grown in a lab through a technological process. People are reluctant to try foods that are perceived as artificial or ‘unnatural’, and to many the idea of blobs of muscle grown in a lab sounds revolting. Switching to eating burgers made from plants doesn’t seem to much of a stretch in comparison.</p><h3>We can’t wait for technology to solve all our problems</h3><p>Lab-grown meat has been on the horizon for a long time, promised again and again by headlines but always tantalisingly out of reach. This constant promise of an easy solution to our problems in the near future may discourage us from changing our habits today. We can’t afford to wait — we need to take action right now if we want to avoid the worst effects of climate breakdown.</p><p>Luckily, we don’t have to wait: if we want to eat meat substitutes we can just go down to the shops and choose from a huge range of plant-based foods right now. No need to hold out for lab-grown meat — just start eating plants instead.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://bwydcath.github.io/medium-import/backdate.html"><em>https://bwydcath.github.io</em></a><em> on October 25, 2023.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=096571255724" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Are we too irrational to stop climate breakdown?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ThomasJ_Quinn/are-we-too-irrational-to-stop-climate-breakdown-1e0d2bbce169?source=rss-556f17ee0ef8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1e0d2bbce169</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dr Tom Quinn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 12 Aug 2023 18:32:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-25T12:13:17.995Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The human mind isn’t made for long-term thinking. Is this why it’s so difficult to get action on climate change?</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YxI-tpofSlW0NQDbfVapkg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>I’m going to have back problems in a few years, and it’ll be entirely self-inflicted.</strong></p><p>I know what’ll cause it. It’s all the hours hunched over my laptop, all the weekends hauling too-heavy bags of compost across my veg patch. But even though I know it’ll lead to pain in the future, I just can’t be bothered to change the way I do things.</p><p>Every so often I get a sharp twinge in my lower back, as if my muscles are being plucked like guitar strings. That’s when I promise myself I’ll correct my posture, I’ll start lifting things properly. But as soon as the pain’s gone I’m back to my usual habits.</p><p>What’s this got to do with climate change? Worryingly, my attitude to my health is an example of a deep-seated irrationality within all of us: we just don’t care that much about the future. Many people think this <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507160736/https://bigthink.com/praxis/two-flaws-of-human-rationality-may-make-it-impossible-to-solve-the-climate-crisis">could make the climate crisis impossible to solve</a> — we humans just aren’t built to solve this kind of problem.</p><p>We should be optimistic, though: if we know how we’re irrational we can find ways to work around it. So let’s look more closely at the quirks of human thinking that make action on climate change so difficult.</p><h4>Humans care less about future experiences</h4><p>Our reasoning has a quirk known as ‘near bias’. And this quirk means we care less about experiences the further they are in the future.</p><p>An example of this is the famous <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507160736/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rwxf1BTyKz4">marshmallow test</a>. Children are presented with a marshmallow on a plate. They can either eat it immediately or wait five minutes and receive two marshmallows. Most of them eat the single marshmallow straight away — they just don’t see the value of having something better in the future when they could have something slightly worse now. Their future experience doesn’t matter as much to them as their present one.</p><p>But we grow out of it, right? Not exactly. Adults are slightly better at delaying gratification, but our near bias is still there. It’s why we don’t save enough for our pensions, why we put off doing unpleasant jobs, and why I keep failing to sort out my back problems even though I know it’s going to cause me pain further down the line.</p><p>Philosophers have written pages and pages about why it’s irrational to care more about things the closer they are to the present time. Political philosopher John Rawls <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507160736/https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=vcVEPc30ut0C&amp;lpg=PP1&amp;pg=PP1#v=onepage&amp;q&amp;f=false">wrote</a>:</p><p><em>“Rationality requires an impartial concern for all parts of our life. The mere difference of location in time, of something’s being earlier or later, is not a rational ground for having more or less regard for it.”</em></p><p>And philosopher <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507160736/https://lucian.uchicago.edu/blogs/elucidations/2017/06/11/episode-97-meghan-sullivan-discusses-time-biases/">Meghan Sullivan</a> recently <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507160736/https://ndpr.nd.edu/news/time-biases-a-theory-of-rational-planning-and-personal-persistence/">wrote a whole book</a> about why our near bias is irrational. (As well as arguing that it’s irrational to care about the future more than the past — but that’s another story).</p><h4>Does this really mean we can’t stop climate change?</h4><p>This is why some people argue humans just aren’t built to deal with climate breakdown. Climate change requires concerted collective action over a long period of time — and one where the worst effects will be felt years into the future. Since we care about near experiences so much more than future ones, we just aren’t motivated to radically change our behaviour. Even if we think we’re going to have a terrible time in ten years, we just aren’t motivated to change our behaviour now.</p><p>So should we be pessimistic about climate change? Is it really a problem we’re inherently ill-equipped to deal with because we just don’t care about the future? I’m not so sure. There is a quirk of human rationality that’s preventing us acting on climate change, but it’s got nothing to do with time — and it’s something we can easily solve.</p><h4>Our irrationality about the future isn’t the problem</h4><p>We find it difficult to care about the long term, and this is a fundamental part of the way we think. But this particular irrationality can’t be the reason we’re failing to act on climate change.</p><p>That’s because the effects of climate change aren’t consigned to the far-off future. They’re already here. Droughts and record heatwaves in India and Europe, huge losses of biodiversity, raging wildfires and islands swallowed up by rising seas: it’s happening now. Our ‘near bias’ can’t explain why we’re able to so easily ignore these effects. So what’s the real reason we find it so difficult to act on climate change?</p><p>The culprit is another piece of human irrationality: we find it easier to care about things that are happening to us or those we know. When we can feel the effects of climate change, we care more about it — but as soon as the effects disappear our concern disappears too.</p><p>Just look at how the UK public’s concern about the environment <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507160736/https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/jun/05/greta-thunberg-effect-public-concern-over-environment-reaches-record-high">reached its second highest level ever</a> in 2014, following winter storms and flooding in the South East of England. Tellingly, it went straight back down again when the weather returned to normal.</p><h4>Saving the drowning child</h4><p>Philosopher Peter Singer came up with a <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507160736/https://www.utilitarian.net/singer/by/199704--.htm">thought experiment</a> that illustrates this quirk of human psychology.</p><p>Imagine on your way to work you cut through a park and find a young child drowning in a pond. You could easily wade in and save her, but as you’re running towards the water you realise you’ll be late for work and miss an important meeting. Is this a reason not to save the girl? Of course not — being late for work is just a minor inconvenience, and we’re talking about saving someone’s life.</p><p>Now imagine that it’s not a girl drowning in front of you, but a child dying on the other side of the world. You can still save her with only minor inconvenience to you — logging on to a website and donating a few pounds. Do you still have the same moral obligation to save the child?</p><p>Many of us feel there’s a less strong obligation to the second child. Imagine how we’d treat someone who left a child to drown because they didn’t want to be late for work, compared to someone who failed to donate to a charity appeal to provide food for starving children in another country. We’d see the first person as some kind of monster, but could imagine ourselves getting along fine with the second person — in fact, many of us are that second person.</p><p>Singer wants to show us we’re inconsistent in our actions. The only real difference in the two cases is the distance of the child from you — and that shouldn’t make a difference to our moral obligations.</p><p>Singer’s example also demonstrates exactly the part of human psychology that makes it difficult to act on climate change. Things just seem less urgent when they’re happening elsewhere. A child dying in front of us requires us to act, while a child dying in another country doesn’t inspire the same reaction.</p><p>We only feel an urgency to act when something is happening right in front of us — so while the worst effects of climate change only seem to be happening elsewhere, those of us who aren’t seeing the effects aren’t so urgently motivated.</p><h4>What can we do?</h4><p>It’s not our lack of concern about the future that stops urgent action on climate change. It’s our lack of concern about things that are happening to other people, in other places. So how do we overcome this irrational aspect of human psychology?</p><p>The effects of climate change are becoming more and more obvious — just this week <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507160736/https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-48795264">deadly heatwaves are hitting the UK and France</a>. This may put climate change front and centre in our minds for now, but as soon as the heatwaves are over we’ll be back to caring less — just like what happened after the storms in 2014. Of course, if we wait a few years the effects of climate change will be staring us in the face constantly — but that’s not an option. We need to find ways to beat this irrationality before that becomes a reality.</p><p>What we can do is change the way we see the world around us, so that we notice what we’re doing to the planet on an everyday basis. Even when the devastating climate-induced events aren’t happening, there are constant signs that the world around us is changing because of climate breakdown.</p><p>We can make a good start by finding more opportunities to notice nature — to see the changes happening year on year, to see the effects we’re having on the environment. It’s not about having in-depth knowledge of nature — in fact, <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507160736/https://findingnature.org.uk/2017/05/10/beyond-knowing-nature/">studies have shown</a> that knowing facts about nature doesn’t correlate with connectedness to nature. Rather, it’s about taking time to notice what’s going on around us.</p><p>Most of us live in towns and cities, but there’s still a lot of nature to notice. How many butterflies are there compared to last year? What time of year do the swifts first appear? When are the spring bulbs starting to push through the soil? Twitter is full of people noticing little things like this that would never be reported otherwise — they’re all little indicators that add up to a bigger picture.</p><p>When we start to notice the little things we don’t need to wait for the huge devastating events to spur us to action. We see that climate change is something that’s happening here and now, and that we need to act.</p><p>We humans are irrational. But so long as we understand the reasons why, it shouldn’t stop us taking action to stop climate breakdown.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1e0d2bbce169" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What’s wrong with cutting down ancient trees?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ThomasJ_Quinn/whats-wrong-with-cutting-down-ancient-trees-b1e90865667b?source=rss-556f17ee0ef8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b1e90865667b</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dr Tom Quinn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 17 Jun 2023 18:50:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-25T12:23:24.120Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>We protect old buildings for their historical and cultural value. Are old trees the same, or is there something more to them?</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7TRN3PyvOUxXmrmpGkrYMg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Every few years, six strangers with axes arrive at the Portuguese village of Marateca. The villagers know what they are here to do: these strangers will soon be hacking away at the village’s most famous resident.</strong></p><p>The resident in question is 231 years old: an ancient cork oak whose branches spread and twist around Marateca’s outskirts. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sobreiro_Monumental">Nicknamed ‘the Whistler’</a> for the cacophony of birds nesting among its dense leaves, the tree is so large that its crown covers a fifth of an acre, and three people would struggle to circle its trunk with outstretched arms.</p><p>The Whistler is an integral part of life in the village: children shelter in the cool shade of its trunk, families picnic beside it and couples spend romantic nights gazing up at the stars through its shimmering canopy. No wonder people are worried when the axemen turn up to harvest the outer bark for cork. One misplaced cut could be a mortal wound for this old giant.</p><p>Luckily, the workers are skilled. They strip the tree with delicate precision to leave it standing for many more years to come. This is good, because surely it would be wrong to cut down a magnificent old tree like the Whistler. But why exactly is it wrong? This question is a lot more difficult to answer than it seems.</p><h3>What’s so fascinating about ancient trees?</h3><p>Like the Whistler, many old trees are important historical and cultural landmarks — and most of the reasons commonly given for valuing and looking after them are based on this fact. Old trees become fascinating symbols with stories and lives of their own: 5,000 year old churchyard yews still thick with the illicit air of ancient druidic religion, massive hollow oaks that served as village dining halls and animal pens. They’re important markers of how the land was divided in ancient times, or the last remnants of wildwoods that colonised landscapes thousands of years ago.</p><p>These are all good reasons to take care of ancient trees, but there’s a problem. These are also good reasons to take care of ancient buildings, or historical artefacts. It looks like the value of ancient trees isn’t actually anything to do with them being trees — it’s just that they’re historic or cultural objects.</p><p>What’s wrong with this? Well, there’s one really important difference between old trees and old buildings: trees are living things. They haven’t just been around for a long time, they’ve lived for a long time. It seems like this should make a difference — when we’re cutting down an old tree, we’re not just destroying an object: we’re ending a life that’s been lived for hundreds, sometimes even thousands of years.</p><h3>Are ancient trees worth more than ancient buildings?</h3><p>An old building doesn’t have value separate from people. Historic value, cultural value — these all depend on people being around to appreciate them. If there were no people left in the universe there would be nothing wrong with these buildings being destroyed. But old trees are different. Maybe, just maybe, living things have value in themselves, independent of human interests.</p><p>Of course the lives of people have value in themselves, and so do the lives of animals who can think and feel. Trees don’t seem to be conscious in the same way, but they’re definitely alive. So the question is: is being alive enough to make a difference? Does being alive give some special moral value that isn’t possessed by objects like old buildings?</p><p>It’s controversial. Immanuel Kant put plants in the same moral category as things like crystal formations — things that should be preserved for their aesthetic value, but which don’t have any value in themselves. For him, being alive didn’t make any difference at all to something’s moral status.</p><p>Today there are some philosophers who do think being alive confers intrinsic value on things — a view known as ‘biocentrism’. The view goes back to the Nobel Prize-winning humanitarian and medical doctor Albert Schweitzer, <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507102207/https://books.google.co.uk/books/about/The_Philosophy_of_Civilization.html?id=5UhxAAAAMAAJ&amp;source=kp_book_description&amp;redir_esc=y">who in 1923 wrote</a>: “True philosophy must start from the most immediate and comprehensive fact of consciousness: ‘I am life that wants to live, in the midst of life that wants to live.’” But in the absence of any thoughts or feelings, it’s difficult to say exactly why being alive is an automatic ticket to having moral value.</p><p>As I’ve discussed in earlier blogs, one argument is that our moral duties should be based around helping organisms meet their interests, whether these involve consciousness or not. If something is alive, then its interests include staying alive. In the case of a tree, its interests might include having enough access to light and water, finding enough energy to produce seeds, and that sort of thing.</p><p>This idea is a bit dubious, though. Because when we talk about interests in this way, couldn’t we also attribute interests to objects? Does a car engine have interests in all its parts working, so that we have a duty to keep it in working order to help it meet its interests? If not, why not? Don’t say it’s because an engine isn’t alive, because then we’re right back where we started. Doesn’t an old building have interests in staying standing, being free from damp and woodworm? Again, old trees are starting to seem a lot like old buildings.</p><h3>Are trees as individual as people?</h3><p>Maybe what separates ancient trees from old buildings is their uniqueness, their individuality. Like the Marateca Whistler oak, old trees have been around for so long that people get to know them very well — their shape, their features, the way they change over the seasons. When we think about trees in general we might think of rows of identical saplings, each much the same as one another. But ancient trees are different — we see them as individuals.</p><p>So far, so much the same as old buildings. An old Tudor mansion could definitely be described as unique, too. But this is a case where trees’ being alive takes their individuality to another level. An old tree is truly individual in the sense that once that particular life is gone, it’s gone forever — there’s no getting it back. You can restore an old building, rebuild it brick by historically accurate brick, and it’d still be there. But there’s no chance of restoring or reconstruction an ancient tree. Once it’s gone, it’s gone forever.</p><p>What allows us to appreciate value of ancient trees is their uniqueness and individuality. But what gives them their value is the fact they’re alive. Being alive gives something an individuality that the most precious object can never have.</p><p>Individuality is something we come to appreciate in living things by getting to know them. So maybe if we got to know all trees better, we’d come to value them all in this way.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://bwydcath.github.io/medium-import/backdateJUN.html"><em>https://bwydcath.github.io</em></a><em> on June 17, 2023.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b1e90865667b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Should we kill some animals to save others?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ThomasJ_Quinn/should-we-kill-some-animals-to-save-others-525fc930cbc4?source=rss-556f17ee0ef8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/525fc930cbc4</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dr Tom Quinn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 May 2023 18:51:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-25T12:34:27.881Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>What squirrels and a runaway train can teach us about the conflict between conservation and animal rights.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4rNymXtNnbI0nC6FONNXsw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>You see a runaway train rush past you towards a fork in the track, and you’re standing right next to a lever that can change its direction. But if you send the train off to the right it’ll hit five innocent squirrels playing on the tracks. And if you send it off to the left there are… another five squirrels. Which direction should you choose? Which five squirrels should you save?</strong></p><p>Yes, it’s another ridiculous version of the trolley problem, the <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507052550/https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/the-trolley-problem">internet’s favourite thought experiment</a>. But there is a serious point here.</p><p>You might struggle to decide which direction you’d send the train. Or you might think it doesn’t even matter — five squirrels will die either way. But what if you can see that the squirrels on the left track are grey squirrels invasive and all too common in the UK, and the squirrels on the right are native red squirrels, endangered in the UK. Does that make a difference to your decision?</p><p>Conservationists deal with this kind of dilemma every day. Their aim is to conserve habitats and species, and sometimes that means getting rid of non-native species that threaten to overturn the balance.</p><p>In the UK, the <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507052550/https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/08/08/rspb-members-protest-controversial-crow-cull/">RSPB culls crows</a> to protect the endangered Eurasian curlew. In the Galapagos Islands, <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507052550/https://allthatsinteresting.com/project-isabela">sharpshooters in helicopters</a> killed 250,000 non-native goats to stop the decline of giant tortoises. They wouldn’t hesitate let the runaway train squish a few grey squirrels if it meant saving endangered animals.</p><p>But this practice is becoming more and more controversial. Some people think it’s just wrong to kill animals at all, no matter whether they’re common or endangered, native or non-native. This raises ethical questions that run through the heart of the conservation movement. Are some animals’ lives more valuable than others? Should we kill some animals to save others?</p><p>Let’s take a look.</p><h3>Animal rights vs. conservation</h3><p>If you want to look after nature and protect wildlife, what’s the best way to do it?</p><p>One way is to try and inspire more respect for animals. You could show people that animals aren’t so different from humans — they can have emotion, feel pain, suffer. You could campaign for animals to be given certain rights, to be treated with care, to be protected from unnecessary harm. You could raise awareness of humans’ terrible treatment of animals to show why we need to change.</p><p>Another way is to try and look after nature so humans’ destructive influence doesn’t upset the balance of nature. You could raise awareness of devastating biodiversity loss that we’re causing. You could intervene and manage habitats to give species the chance to thrive. You could campaign against destructive activity like logging and pesticide use that are driving species to extinction.</p><p>These two different approaches share many of the same concerns about humans dominating nature. And they target a lot of the same enemies: corporations polluting the air and sea, governments tearing down ancient woodlands to build roads, industrial agriculture crowding the land with livestock and pesticides.</p><p>So it might come as a surprise to find these two ways of looking after animals built on two completely incompatible ethical frameworks. They’re actively opposed to each other.</p><h3>Two ethical frameworks</h3><p>The first approach sees individual animals as the bearers of value. It takes the rights, feelings and experiences of animals as a guide to how we should act. On this view, it’s always wrong to kill animals — because it’s always wrong to violate these rights.</p><p>The second approach focuses not on individuals but on groups — populations, species or ecosystems. The goal here is to make sure these groups continue to exist, not the individual animals within them. The lives of individual animals don’t have as much value as the ‘life’ of the group. On this approach, it’s justified to kill some individual animals to make sure that the collective, the species, survives.</p><p>Environmental organisations emphasise this inconsistency. Take this example from US organisation <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507052550/https://wildlife.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/SP_AnimalRights.pdf">The Wildlife Society</a>:</p><p><em>The animal rights focused emphasis on individual animals fails to recognize the inter-relatedness of wildlife communities within functioning ecosystems and holds that protecting individual animals is more important than conserving populations, species, or ecosystems. The philosophy of animal rights is incompatible with science-based conservation and management of wildlife.</em></p><p>This is strange, because this conflict isn’t something that many of us really think about. Lots of people are members of organisations that take opposing sides on this question — plenty of people support both <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507052550/https://www.peta.org/">PETA </a>and <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507052550/https://www.wwf.org.uk/">WWF</a>.</p><p>So which is the right answer to this ethical question? Either we kill animals, or we let species die out. What should we do?</p><h3>Compassionate conservation</h3><p>There’s a movement trying to resolve the conflict and bring the two sides together: the compassionate conservation movement. <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507052550/http://compassionateconservation.net/about/principles/">Compassionate conservationists</a> try to protect species without killing or harming any ‘undesirable’ animals in the process. They want to show that you can protect habitats and species without disregarding the moral rights of individual animals.</p><p>So what do you do when you’ve got a non-native species about to wipe out a native population? You get creative.</p><p>When foxes on Australia’s Middle Island began devouring fairy penguins, the obvious way of protecting the colony would have been to kill the foxes. But there was a better solution. A local farmer suggested <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507052550/https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-35039105">using sheepdogs to guard the birds from predators</a>. The dogs kept the foxes at bay without any animals needing to be killed — and provided the opportunity for hundreds of cute photos.</p><p>That’s one of the cool solutions — but compassionate conservation mostly involves introducing some predators to kill whatever’s threatening the native or endangered wildlife. In Australia there’s a big movement to <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507052550/https://www.dingobiodiversity.com/">reintroduce dingoes</a> so they can kill the smaller non-native predators (including feral cats) that are threatening native wildlife.</p><h3>Tough questions for compassionate conservationists</h3><p>This is all well and good, but there isn’t always a win-win solution like this. Sometimes there really is no other choice but for humans to kill one species to save another. Compassionate conservation doesn’t provide an answer to what we should do in this situation. Are compassionate conservationists really so committed to their principles that they’d let a species of rare seabird go extinct to save the lives of a bunch of rats?</p><p>Then there’s the other big question facing compassionate conservationists: why is it wrong for humans to kill animals, but right for other animals to kill animals? By introducing predators you’re just taking yourself one step away from the action. You’re getting someone else to do the dirty work for you. Does that really make much of a moral difference? The same animals are still dying, even if you’re not killing them yourself.</p><p>Compassionate conservationists are putting humans on a pedestal. When animals kill other animals it’s ‘natural’, but when humans do so, it isn’t. They’re seeing humans as separate from nature, somehow above it and acting on it. By seeing a moral difference between humans killing animals and animals killing animals, they’re viewing human actions as fundamentally different from the actions of every other living being on the planet.</p><p>Compassionate conservation isn’t so bad, in practical terms. It forces people to think of other solutions to conservation problems beyond killing, and this leads to better, more sustainable solutions in the long run. Instead of relying on human intervention to rebalance ecosystems, we can introduce animals who’ll do it for us and sustain that balance without us constantly interfering.</p><p>But it still hasn’t dealt with that ethical problem: should we be killing some animals to save others?</p><h3>A practical answer to the dilemma</h3><p>There’s no easy answer to the question. It comes down to how we should relate to animals — as individuals, or as abstract groups? Many of us relate to animals differently in different areas of our lives. We see our pets as individuals with individual moral status because we come into contact with them in a personal, concrete way. But when it comes to thinking about endangered species, animals we’ve maybe never even seen, we relate to them more abstractly. We worry about the groups rather than the individuals.</p><p>But maybe we needn’t worry. In real life, it’s very rare that there’d be a situation where we can actually choose between killing animals to save others, or avoiding killing and taking no responsibility for what happens. That’s because most of the time the battle between non-native species and endangered species is our fault. We’ve unbalanced the ecosystem ourselves, whether by destroying habitats and forcing animals together, or by introducing species like rats or domestic cats to places that have never seen animals like this before.</p><p>So, in effect, we’re killing animals either way — even if indirectly. Whether we actively hunt down the non-native species, or let them destroy native populations, the blood is ultimately on our hands. In this situation it seems like we have a responsibility to act.</p><p>So maybe if one species is endangered that just gives us a way to make our choice. If animals are going to die because of us anyway, we might as well make sure it’s not the ones that are rare and ecologically important.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=525fc930cbc4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Could plants really be conscious, and why does it matter?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ThomasJ_Quinn/could-plants-really-be-conscious-and-why-does-it-matter-d6f6c518000e?source=rss-556f17ee0ef8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d6f6c518000e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dr Tom Quinn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 04 Mar 2023 19:50:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-25T12:42:15.649Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The fierce debate over plant consciousness isn’t really about the minds of plants: it’s about our relationship with nature itself.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oAfk__uxgS2UdDkxO_F6IQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>What makes a plant biologist angry?</strong></p><p>Well, probably a lot of things — from the <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507161616/https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/jun/10/frightening-number-of-plant-extinctions-found-in-global-survey">rising rate of plant extinction</a> to most students saying <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507161616/https://nph.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ppp3.51">they’d prefer to learn about animals than plants</a>. But now there’s something new ruffling feathers (or leaves?): the idea that plants have consciousness.</p><p>Research into whether plants can think has been going on for over a decade, but this month a group of plant biologists decided they’d finally had enough. They wrote in a strongly-worded open letter that: “There is no evidence that plants require, and thus have evolved, energy-expensive mental faculties, such as consciousness, feelings, and intentionality, to survive or to reproduce.”</p><p>But this isn’t a case of science vs spooky nonsense. There’s serious research into whether plants can think, and it’s turned up with some compelling results — with papers claiming that plants <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507161616/https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00442-017-4029-7">have memories</a> and that they can <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507161616/https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.1365-3040.2008.01913.x">communicate with their peers</a>.</p><p>So why is plant consciousness such a touchy subject? Why is it making some people so angry? That’s because consciousness is such a loaded issue. The question of whether plants can think is actually about way more than that — the debate raises deep questions about our relationship with nature as a whole, and our moral duties to protect it.</p><h3>What is consciousness?</h3><p>Consciousness is used by different people to mean different things, from being self-aware to being sentient. But there’s one really interesting sense of ‘consciousness’ that’s key to the furore over the minds of plants. That’s when it’s used to refer to our internal, subjective experiences of the world.</p><p>In this sense, to be conscious is to have sensations — to see colours, feel hunger, hear music, smell flowers. If you’re conscious, then there’s something it’s like to be you. You’re a subject who is experiencing the world. It doesn’t matter how complex your thoughts are — if you’re capable of having sensations and experiences then you’re conscious.</p><p>As well as pleasant sensations, being conscious means we’re subject to unpleasant ones too — including the feeling of pain. And it’s this sensation of pain that makes discussions about consciousness so loaded.</p><p>Pain is bad, right? So bad that we have a moral duty not to inflict it on others, and to prevent it where we can. In fact, on many ethical theories — like utilitarianism — the duty to reduce the amount of pain is the foundation of our whole system of morality. Ultimately, our actions are good if they mean that this unpleasant experience is felt as little as possible.</p><p>Now we see why plant consciousness is such a loaded issue. If plants are conscious, then they can probably feel pain. And if they can feel pain, then we have some kind of moral duty towards them — a duty to reduce their pain as much as possible. Maybe that’d involve not cutting down trees or stripping their bark, maybe that’d involve not plucking flowers from the grass to make daisy chains.</p><p>Whatever it is, we’d have to accept there’s a whole world of living things out there that have value and moral standing, and that we need to think about their conscious experiences. That’d be huge.</p><h3>Why does it matter?</h3><p>One of the letter-writers acknowledged this link between consciousness and morality in an interview — he thinks the search for plant consciousness is wishful thinking on the part of scientists who want us to treat plants better: “They want to raise people’s consciousness about plants as living organisms and reach them on an emotional level. I’m very sympathetic to the motivations, but it is clouding their objectivity. They have to be prepared for the fact that plants may not have consciousness.”</p><p>Pretty much the same criticism was levelled at the study of animal consciousness in the not too recent past. In the sixties an obsession with ‘objectivity’ swept animal studies — scientists were only meant to describe animal behaviour in strictly ‘objective’ terms, which meant only describing their physical behaviours. Any attempt to attribute behaviours to thoughts, feelings or emotions — any attempt to suggest that animals have some sort of internal mental life — led to accusations of anthropomosphism and being overly sentimental.</p><p>But, as with today’s debate about plants, the debate about animals wasn’t really about objectivity — it was about what our duties to animals are. If they really can feel pain, how can we justify treating them so badly? Once again, research into consciousness turns out to be loaded with judgements on value and morality.</p><h3>Do we need to treat plants with respect?</h3><p>So the debate about plant consciousness is being clouded by ethical issues. If the moral standing of plants depends on them having consciousness, then the debate is about a whole lot more than just what’s going on in their minds.</p><p>But we can avoid the debate being skewed, if we stop placing so much emphasis on consciousness, and the experience of pain, in ethics. Several environmental philosophers have tried to argue that plants and other organisms have moral value even if they aren’t conscious.</p><p>Philosopher <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507161616/https://philpapers.org/rec/GOOOBM">Kenneth Goodpaster </a>argued that consciousness is just a biological adaptation that helps some organisms meet their interests — and so it’s a strange thing to base morality on. Instead, our moral duties should be based around helping organisms meet their interests, whether these involve consciousness or not. And all it takes to have interests is to be alive: a plant’s interests are in having environmental conditions where they can grow as well as possible, finding enough energy to reproduce, and that sort of thing.</p><p>There are a lot of ways to base morality on something other than consciousness, but the point is that consciousness isn’t necessarily the be all and end all. We don’t need plants to be conscious to explain why we should treat them with respect. As philosopher <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20200507161616/https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=X29KY3O8nocC&amp;pg=PA75&amp;lpg=PA75&amp;dq=%E2%80%9C+I+need+only+to+stand+in+the+midst+of+a+clear-cut+forest,+a+strip-mined+hillside,+a+defoliated+jungle,+or+a+dammed+canyon+to+feel+uneasy+with+assumptions+that+could+yield&amp;source=bl&amp;ots=EabQMQIqMa&amp;sig=ACfU3U2Jk8E3CJVRYWA0L9I6tVkEv3ssmA&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ved=2ahUKEwinyZyEgNjjAhVhs3EKHffTBfUQ6AEwAnoECAgQAQ#v=onepage&amp;q=%E2%80%9C%20I%20need%20only%20to%20stand%20in%20the%20midst%20of%20a%20clear-cut%20forest%2C%20a%20strip-mined%20hillside%2C%20a%20defoliated%20jungle%2C%20or%20a%20dammed%20canyon%20to%20feel%20uneasy%20with%20assumptions%20that%20could%20yield&amp;f=false">John Rodman</a> wrote: “ I need only to stand in the midst of a clear-cut forest, a strip-mined hillside, a defoliated jungle, or a dammed canyon to feel uneasy with assumptions that could yield the conclusion that no human action can make any difference to the welfare of anything but sentient animals.”</p><p>So maybe we can start to separate the debate about plant consciousness from the debate about the ethical standing of plants. There’s no need to get riled up and accuse other researchers of having ulterior motives. Let’s just let them get on with it, and wait to see what they find.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d6f6c518000e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Can we ever replace nature?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ThomasJ_Quinn/can-we-ever-replace-nature-273710a64d8a?source=rss-556f17ee0ef8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/273710a64d8a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dr Tom Quinn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 19 Jan 2023 19:43:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-25T12:44:55.346Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Can a new, human-created landscape ever be as valuable as the original?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*C45NjNNpMbdQBpfHSNvPKg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Your heart sinks when you see the plaque, half-hidden under a pile of dead leaves. You wish you hadn’t noticed it, that you’d just walked past the unassuming bump in the ground.</p><p>But now you have, and it’s changed everything.</p><p>It’s hours since you stepped off the train into the cold morning mist, your rucksack heavy with supplies for a day’s hike. Soon the tarmac underfoot turned to soft leaf litter and you’d felt relaxed almost immediately. You’d breathed in the leafy, sour smell of the forest and noticed the tangle of lives around you, the oaks and holly and birch and rowan jostling for space, the white bell flowers knocking together silently on the forest floor, flycatchers bounding through the branches above.</p><p>That’s when you’d seen the glint of metal beneath a tree, and you’d uncovered the plaque riveted to a block of concrete.</p><p>Now you stand reading it for the fourth time. <em>This forest was created in June 2016 to replace the woodland destroyed by the new dual carriageway.</em></p><p>This forest, these trees, aren’t what you thought. They were just put here a couple of years ago, shoved into holes made by diggers. You’d come out here to enjoy nature — but now you’re not so sure that this forest is natural at all.</p><p>Are you right to feel disappointed? Is this human-created forest any less valuable than the one that was destroyed by the new road? What exactly is it that’s been lost — and can it ever be recreated?</p><h3>Replacing nature is like forging a painting</h3><p>This story isn’t so far-fetched. They probably wouldn’t commemorate it with a plaque, but plenty of development projects compensate for destroying natural places by promising to create new ones elsewhere. HS2, the UK’s new high-speed railway, will cut through 111 local wildlife sites and 19 ancient woodlands — but it will also <a href="https://www.gov.uk/government/news/mother-nature-given-helping-hand-by-hs2s-green-corridor">create a new ‘green corridor’</a> to replace and restore nature along the route.</p><p>But can new human-created landscapes ever truly make up for the loss of natural landscapes? Is it even possible to ‘restore’ nature — or are we just destroying it and creating an imitation in its place?</p><p>Philosopher <a href="https://philpapers.org/rec/ELLFN">Robert Elliott</a> likened man-made landscapes to forged paintings. If I discover that the Vermeer I’m looking at is actually a forgery painted a week ago I’ll be disappointed to say the least. The forgery may be indistinguishable from the original, but it’s just not as valuable. What makes the original so significant and important isn’t just the way it looks, but also its history, the fact it was created by the artist himself in the 17th century. That history is something that can’t be recreated.</p><p>Maybe something similar applies to nature. What we value isn’t just what’s there, but how it came about. Just like in the story, people spend time in nature for an escape from the human-created environment of cities and villages. Part of the wonder and beauty of natural places is their independence from us, the fact that these complex, varied tangles of lives came about on their own. In fact, for many people, that’s just what it is to be ‘natural’ — not created or reliant on human activity.</p><p>If this is right, then the landscapes created by people to make up for destroying the original aren’t natural at all. A human-created forest might look exactly the same as one that came about by itself, but it will still owe its existence to our actions and decisions. Just like a forged painting, it’s less valuable than an original because it was created in a different way.</p><p>This would mean it’s <em>impossible </em>to fully replace forests, wetlands or grasslands once they’ve been destroyed by roads or factories. Anything we try to create to make up for this loss won’t be truly natural — just like a forged painting, it will be a less valuable imitation.</p><h3>The myths that make nature seem irreplaceable</h3><p>We’d feel disappointed if we found out that a ‘natural’ woodland was actually designed and created by people. And comparing restored nature to a forged painting gives us a way to justify these feelings.</p><p>But all of this thinking is based on a couple of myths about nature. When we dispel these myths we can see that nature isn’t irreplaceable at all. A human-created forest can be just as valuable as one that’s ‘natural’.</p><p>The big myth is that being natural means being independent of people. If that’s the criteria we’re using, then there’s probably nothing natural left to worry about. In the UK, the patchwork landscape of fields, hills and hedgerows has been shaped by thousands of years of human interference. Even a dense old oak forest like the one in the story would certainly have been coppiced, the wood turned to charcoal to smelt iron.</p><p>That’s just for starters — when you look at it, there’s nowhere that hasn’t already been changed by our presence: we’ve polluted the air, altered the chemical composition of rivers and changed the global climate. Nothing is ‘natural’ if that means being independent of human intervention. If even the original forests were marked by our interference, what’s so bad about the replacement ones also bearing our fingerprints?</p><p>There’s also something a bit self-centred about our preference for ‘untouched’ nature. It’s only us humans who even notice whether a forest is ‘natural’ or human-created. The birds and insects, the trees and flowers, don’t care how the forest came about. So long as it’s the same in all the important ways, it’s still a valuable habitat.</p><p>But the biggest problem with our worship of ‘untouched’ nature is that it can stop us from taking action to protect the natural world. If ‘natural’ means free from human intervention, then there’s no way for us to actively help nature. As soon as we intervene, whatever we were trying to save can no longer count as natural. We devalue it by getting involved. This would mean the only thing we can do to help nature is take a hands-off approach and let it get on by itself.</p><p>You might think it’d be a positive thing for humans to stop interfering with nature. If we’re just going to end up doing more harm than good, then it’d be better to stay out of it. But this seems like a cop-out. It lets us off the hook, absolves us of any responsibility for trying to find solutions for the problems we cause. It prevents us taking any real action to tackle the environmental crisis we helped to create.</p><p>So let’s not get hung up on the idea that nature can never be restored or replaced, that its naturalness is destroyed whenever humans get involved. Sometimes nature needs a helping hand to overcome the problems we’ve caused. If we can help to restore habitats and ecosystems, we should do it wherever we can. Who cares if the forests we create aren’t pristine and free from human intervention? The birds and trees and insects certainly don’t.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://bwydcath.github.io/medium-import/backdateJAN.html"><em>https://bwydcath.github.io</em></a><em> on January 19, 2023.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=273710a64d8a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>