<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Thulani Dlamini on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Thulani Dlamini on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@Thulani_Dlamini?source=rss-df30b10f2204------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 11:13:25 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@Thulani_Dlamini/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Conspiracy Theories and Anti-vaxxers in the Era of COVID-19: A South African perspective]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Thulani_Dlamini/conspiracy-theories-and-anti-vaxxers-in-the-era-of-covid-19-a-south-african-perspective-84f62e90f890?source=rss-df30b10f2204------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/84f62e90f890</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[south-africa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[post-truth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[antivaxx]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conspiracy-theories]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thulani Dlamini]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Feb 2021 09:59:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-03T13:39:57.885Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_VhNaziFAzuH9jXhx11Dmw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>(Artist: Drew Sheneman. </strong><a href="https://www.nj.com/opinion/2020/12/the-government-is-not-trying-to-inject-you-with-a-microchip-sheneman.html"><strong>SOURCE</strong></a><strong>)</strong></figcaption></figure><p>In an <a href="https://www.google.co.za/amp/s/www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2020/10/22/president-trump-is-averaging-more-than-50-false-or-misleading-claims-day/%3foutputType=amp">article</a> published by the Washington Post, it is alleged that Donald Trump made around 50 false or misleading statements per day during his term of Office. In a 20 January <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/politics/trump-claims-database/?itid=lk_inline_manual_4&amp;_gl=1*orp43e*_ga*Nk1fbXNCd1FaUjE1TWZpZGRyRko4WlN0Z0dDUXZ3YzBLLTYtRVZtTjJRNFZEZndJVXVqS3ZPMnZGSXRQNHhzaw..">update</a> to their tally, the final total was 30 573 false or misleading claims made by Trump over his presidential term. This astonishing volume of lies is indicative of the post-truth era in which we live. In this piece, I will explore the proliferation of conspiracy theories in South Africa during the Coronavirus pandemic, with a particular focus on theories around vaccines.</p><p>John Keane, writing for <a href="https://theconversation.com/post-truth-politics-and-why-the-antidote-isnt-simply-fact-checking-and-truth-87364">The Conversation</a>, posits that post-truth politics is a politics in which an appeal is made not to the truth but what may feel like the truth. This appeal may be as simple as a lie about minute details of an event which may have been forgotten by the majority, or it may be a grand narrative that is at odds with the truth but has elements used to ‘attract and distract public attention and to interrupt the background noise of conventional politics and public life’. A claim that Cyril Ramaphosa became ‘President’ in 2017 in a conversation about Government’s efforts to stabilise the economy seems plausible but it would be not be entirely true. This statement appears to be true because Ramaphosa did, in fact, become a president in 2017 — but that would be <a href="https://www.timeslive.co.za/politics/2017-12-20-in-full--cyril-ramaphosas-first-speech-as-anc-president/">President of the ANC</a>. He <a href="https://www.timeslive.co.za/politics/2018-02-15-watch--president-cyril-ramaphosa-addresses-parliament-for-the-first-time/">became the country’s president</a> in 2018 following Jacob Zuma’s ‘<a href="https://www.timeslive.co.za/politics/2018-02-13-anc-confirms-it-has-recalled-jacob-zuma/">recall</a>’ and subsequent <a href="https://www.news24.com/news24/SouthAfrica/News/jacob-zuma-resigns-as-president-of-south-africa-20180214">resignation</a> from the highest office in the land. The above example shows how post-truth reasoning may be used to obfuscate, mislead, and drive a certain agenda without the receivers of the lie being alerted to the absence of truth.</p><p>The anti-vaxxer movement is a decades old movement that usually speaks out against the vaccination of children. Anti-vaxxers, a term used primarily online for those opposing vaccines, are often people who themselves were vaccinated in childhood and have been spared the suffering caused by diseases such as smallpox, diptheria, and polio. That they should not want their children spared from such suffering is bewildering, however, the focus of this piece is not to simply highlight the ironies present in the anti-vaccine campaign.</p><p>A Google image search for ‘<a href="https://www.google.com/search?q=anti-vaxxer&amp;client=safari&amp;rls=en&amp;sxsrf=ALeKk03jGELRUlYh__cynzgWNuW7DkyqlA:1611406118314&amp;source=lnms&amp;tbm=isch&amp;sa=X&amp;ved=2ahUKEwiQ_JTKi7LuAhUdThUIHY4qA1kQ_AUoAXoECAMQAw&amp;biw=1440&amp;bih=767">anti-vaxxer</a>’ brings up many pictures of people carrying signs speaking about the ‘dangers’ of vaccines. What is common to many of these pictures is that the subjects are, almost as a rule, suburban white American women. The American identity of this group is primarily due to the term ‘anti-vaxxer’ being more popular there than anywhere else. How then do we explain the fact that many of these people in the images are women? The simple answer is that they are mothers and mothers are often the ones tasked with child-rearing and bear the responsibility of taking a child for vaccinations and early childhood checkups. It is mothers who are left with the decision to vaccinate their children or not and it is them who would, as a result of this responsibility, be the ones most vocal in opposition to vaccines if they are already dubious of them.</p><p>The most well-known claim made by anti-vaxxers is that vaccines cause autism in children. According to the <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/vaccinesafety/concerns/autism.html">Centers for Disease Control and Prevention</a> (CDC) website, multiple studies have shown that there is no link between vaccination and the development of autism spectrum disorder in children. The consistent refutation by the scientific community of links between vaccines and autism has done little to curb the growth of the anti-vaxxer movement. Why is this the case? Well, because that is how conspiracy theories and myths function.</p><p>The <a href="https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/definition/english/conspiracy-theory?q=conspiracy+theory">Oxford online dictionary</a> defines ‘conspiracy theory’ as ‘the belief that a secret but powerful organization is responsible for an event’. The coronavirus pandemic and the development of vaccines to combat it has presented many adults with a choice to make for themselves regarding vaccines for the first time in their lives. It is now up to them to decide whether they should be vaccinated or not. Adults, unlike young children, have almost limitless access to information thanks to the internet and smartphones. That you can now access information about anything in the palm of your hand is a wonderful step forward in humanity’s ongoing attempt to understand, interrogate, and create the world around us. But, as Spider-Man tells us, ‘with great power comes great responsibility’. The onus is on the publishers of information to produce information that is true and verifiable. The receivers of this information, typically visitors to news sites and users of various social media platforms, are not without responsibility. It is their duty to be discerning in what they read, share, and, in many instances, publish.</p><p>The <a href="https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201409/a19-96.pdf">National Youth Commission Act of 1996</a> defines ‘youth’ as ‘persons between the ages of 14 and 35’. The older members of this group of South Africans would have grown up as the popularity and accessibility of smartphones grew. They would have been the ones using <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mxit">Mxit</a> to keep in touch after school and on weekends. They also would have been the ones forwarding often hilarious chain messages to each other. Mxit, as many of us youths can confirm, was a playground for pretence and lies. It was not uncommon for people to pretend to be celebrities such as Rihanna or Usher and ask others for airtime. It made no difference to many that these ‘celebrities’ wud type lyk dis. It was here that false and sometimes malicious rumours about fellow scholars or public figures such as Ciara would spread like wildfire and people would accept them uncritically. A lot has changed since Mxit was popular, but a lot has also remained the same.</p><p>Many of us have parents who now use WhatsApp as their primary means of communication with us, their friends, and other relatives. What WhatsApp is to them is what Mxit was to us, with very similar trappings. The power of information to spread rapidly via WhatsApp to our parents and tech-savvy grandparents was on full display in the days building up to 5 April 2020. SABC 3 had decided to air Contagion on the 5th, during their primetime Sunday night movie slot. The 2011 movie, as the title suggests, is about a virus spreading through the world and causing a pandemic. This choice of film was not coincidental to the times we found, and still find, ourselves in. It was a deliberate decision to gain viewership — the aim was not the benign spreading of information. WhatsApp messages were flying around between parents and their children about the importance of the film and the manner in which ‘it explains exactly what we are experiencing’. One could have easily believed that the film was a documentary if one relied on nothing but WhatsApp as a their primary source of pandemic-related information. The sentiment that the film explained our reality is an unfortunate one because the film is fictional and exercises artistic license in portraying the fight against a pandemic. Furthermore, and perhaps most crucially, the virus in the film may have been a bioweapon.</p><p>It is not my goal to insult the intelligence of people. I do believe that people are able to critically examine the information they are presented with and formulate their own opinions. However, these opinions are often pre-formulated and are immune to contradictory information. Contagion is a work of fiction but its pull relies on the element of possibility. What Contagion does is not dissimilar to what many conspiracy theories do — twist facts and present the absurd as plausible. This plausibility is the reasonable doubt that enables the COVID-19-era anti-vaxxers to attempt to refute the science. To be completely fair, the scientists do not know everything there is to know about the SARS-CoV-2 virus and its multiple variants, but they are working daily to learn how to manage and eradicate it. This lack of complete knowledge is one of the points of attack for conspiracy theorists.</p><p>GPRS. EDGE. 3G. 4G/LTE. 5G. These letters and numbers represent the evolution of broadband cellular network standards. Each has been an advancement on the last in terms of speed and bandwidth. Each has been the subject of controversy and conspiracy theories. A theory common to a few of them is that the towers used to access the network spread cancer-causing radio waves. The <a href="https://www.cancer.org/cancer/cancer-causes/radiation-exposure/cellular-phone-towers.html">American Cancer Society</a> states that there is no clear evidence that these towers cause cancer in people residing near them, but they do concede that this exposure to the waves has not been proven to be completely safe. 2020, and the pandemic brought rumours that 5G towers were being used to spread the novel coronavirus. That the spread of 5G occurred almost simultaneously with the spread of the virus, at least temporally but also spatially in some cases, was all the proof required by some to show that correlation does, in fact, equal causation in this case. This is what led to the torching and destruction of network towers in the <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/attacks-cellphone-towers-coronavirus-5g-conspiracy-2020-4?IR=T">UK</a>, the <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/dhs-to-advise-telecom-firms-on-preventing-5g-cell-tower-attacks-linked-to-coronavirus-conspiracy-theories/2020/05/13/6aa9eaa6-951f-11ea-82b4-c8db161ff6e5_story.html">US</a>, and in <a href="https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2021-01-07-torching-of-three-cellphone-towers-linked-to-5g-and-covid-conspiracies/">Kwazulu Nata</a>l. To their credit, our Government officials have spoken out against such misinformation and vandalism.</p><p>Conspiracy theories thrive in the grey area between verifiable truth and plausible information. An example of this is the video which went viral in April of last year. <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-53579773">In the video</a>, Dr Stella Immanuel, a Black African woman (this is important for reasons outlined below), speaks about her ‘success’ with hydroxychloroquine as a COVID-19 cure. Dr Stella, in the video, is flanked by fellow medics from America’s Frontline Doctors — a group which is ‘critical of the scientific consensus around the Covid-19 pandemic’. America’s Frontline Doctors were nothing more than a front to support the lack of measures taken by the Trump administration in the fairly early stages of the pandemic in the USA. Is the claim in the preceding sentence a conspiracy theory? Perhaps, but there is an overwhelming collection of verifiable information to support the claim, unlike in the claims made against 5G and the claim in favour of hydroxychloroquine as an effective remedy.</p><p>Stella Immanuel’s identity as a Black African woman is important because in the age of social media and freedom of access to information, who you are is often just as important as what you say. Following centuries of negation and non-recognition of the humanity of Africans, successes in fields such as medicine by Africans are, and always should be, widely celebrated. This need to celebrate each other is what, I believe, led many South Africans to share Immanuel’s video not merely as news but also as a triumph. The apparent success of ‘one of our own’ is what may have made many watch and share the video and not ascertain its source or underlying purpose. The need to see Africa not just succeed but lead, as well, is what also magnified, and garnered support for, the ‘<a href="https://www.voanews.com/covid-19-pandemic/madagascars-covid-19-cure-raises-pride-health-concerns-and-political-risks">Madagascar cure</a>’. It is also what drives the touting of <a href="https://www.timeslive.co.za/politics/2020-05-27-take-your-umhlonyane-but-no-evidence-it-can-cure-covid-19-mkhize/">umhlonyane as a COVID-19 cure</a>.</p><p>Source and purpose are crucial elements of information verification in the age of social media but the two are often neglected or paid minimal attention. The word ‘research’ has found itself doing a lot of work in the spread of misinformation lately. Those who do not believe conspiracy theories are told to do their research. After doing so and returning with the results, they are questioned about why they trust the sources they used as these sources are ‘mere tools of the mainstream media’. Misinformation is received and passed on rapidly via sites such as Facebook or Twitter and applications such as Whatsapp because of the manner in which it is presented. The information is always veiled in what appears to be legitimacy and/or urgency so as to have the recipient share it without interrogating it. What this does is extend the lifespan of the misinformation as it is allowed to spread exponentially with only a few critical people acting as misinformation dead ends. The sources of misinformation and their goals or purpose often remain hidden and anonymous to the spreaders. Another crucial element of the spread of misinformation via chain messages is the fact that we tend to trust those we share our contact information with and whom we converse with regularly. It is the belief that my friend or cousin, sister or uncle would never mislead me that allows unverified information to spread. Unfortunately, many are misled every day, even if the misleading is done unintentionally.</p><p>Vaccines, as is often repeated by epidemiologists, are our best hope in controlling and ending pandemics. Many vaccines developed in the 20th century have now become uncontroversial shots administered to children. These vaccines took many years to develop, in the 20th century. Technology and the field of medicine have advanced in leaps and bounds since the early years of vaccinology in the 19th century. The effort to develop COVID-19 vaccines has been a tremendous feat of global solidarity and has allowed for the rapid development of a few viable vaccine candidates — some of which have begun to be rolled out in numerous countries. That this global solidarity has not effectively moved from the development stage to the rollout stage is an issue for a separate article and another day. A figure who has financially supported and championed the administration of vaccines to children in poor nations and conflict zones (read: Africa) is Bill Gates through the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. His efforts have been linked by many a conspiracy theorist to an agenda of <a href="https://factcheck.afp.com/anti-vaccine-video-falsely-claims-expose-purported-bill-gates-plan-depopulate-africa">global depopulation</a>, starting with Africa. These rumours have followed Gates for years and the Coronavirus pandemic has only added fuel to the fire. That COVID-19 <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-53181555">mortality figures in Africa </a>lag behind those of the Americas and Europe is ignored when the depopulation agenda is pushed.</p><p>Bill gates is a Harvard dropout who became a billionaire after co-founding Microsoft. He has worked in tech. He is also a strong advocate for vaccines. The preceding sentences are the basis of the claim that Bill Gates wants to insert microchips into people using COVID-19 vaccines. Like the other claims in this article, there is <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/52847648">no factual basis supporting it</a>.</p><p>Perhaps some people are predisposed to be suspicious of information in general. This suspicion is useful when one wants to ensure that they are being told the truth. However, this suspicion may also be detrimental when one is not prepared to act on this suspicion in an attempt to verify the veracity of the information. In the face of overwhelming evidence, scientific and experiential, a person committed to a particular view, opinion, or belief may remain unmoved. It is this steadfastness that allows for conspiracy theories to take hold in an individual and spread. Am I arguing that we should uncritically believe all that is presented by the ‘mainstream media’? Absolutely not. I am making a case for a critical analysis of the information fed to us and a willingness to accept that in some instances, our beliefs may be wrong.</p><p>The distrust of governments, billionaires, corporations, and the media is not without merit. There have been many instances in history of governments poisoning their own people, as is the case of the <a href="https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2020/06/30/fact-check-u-s-government-poisoned-some-alcohol-during-prohibition/3283701001/">US government taking steps to have toxic chemicals introduced into industrial alcohol during the era of prohibition</a>. It is also the case that governments in countries where racial oppression was the law conducted unethical experiments on members of the oppressed race, such as in the Tuskegee Syphilis Experiments. This distrust is what fuels many conspiracy theories and it is up to the very same governments, billionaires, corporations, and media to allay the fears people may have through transparency and public information campaigns.</p><p>Misinformation, myths, and conspiracy theories will never go away. What must happen, though, is a countering of them through the provision of verifiable information. An appeal to science is not always enough as science has often been used as a tool of oppression and cannot be seen as a value-free endeavour or tool. There are a multitude of websites available, such as <a href="https://africacheck.org/">Africa Check</a>, which are dedicated to checking the claims made by public figures and refuting misinformation that spreads via the internet.</p><p>Unfortunately for me (maybe? I don’t know.), this article may be seen by conspiracy theorists as nothing more than an attempt to further hidden agendas and as a display of the very ignorance I wish to root out. To these claims, I have no response. Perhaps this is the allure of conspiracy theories. Those ‘in the know’ or the ‘free thinkers’ see themselves as the critical few whilst the many are the sheep misled by those charged with governing them.</p><p>The anti-vaxxer sentiments in South Africa are not unique to us, but they are founded upon a nexus of experiences and information that may be uniquely South African. In working to stop and undo the proliferation of misinformation and unfounded conspiracy theories, it is important that we look at the conditions which have allowed them to spread in the first place. It is my hope that this article spurs us on to be more critical recipients and spreaders of all information. This article is my contribution in furtherance of a public which is not easily misled and one which allows for the rigorous interrogation of all information that we encounter in various facets of life, whether it be in lectures or in family WhatsApp groups. I look forward to the day we close the chapter on the post-truth era in which we live.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=84f62e90f890" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Disease, Race, and Privilege]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Thulani_Dlamini/disease-race-and-privilege-4761e4fcc021?source=rss-df30b10f2204------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4761e4fcc021</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[south-africa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coronavirus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disease]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thulani Dlamini]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Mar 2020 09:00:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-27T09:00:01.731Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IMGFOhpSf__r65TU0H0dvg.png" /><figcaption>Image source: <a href="https://www.state.gov/coronavirus/">https://www.state.gov/coronavirus/</a></figcaption></figure><p>I have recently started jogging. This may seem like an odd introduction, however, it is in this setting that the idea which gave rise to this piece came to me. At 05:30, I had just left my apartment and begun my 5km run, my last for the foreseeable future. This run was not something I had to do. It was something I chose to do.</p><p>In this piece, I explore the relationship between race, disease, and privilege in order to extract an understanding of how the spread of COVID-19 through South Africa and the response to this spread need to be looked at through more than just a quantitative lens.</p><p>Choice, as a concept, is elusive. Often, it appears that we do not have it at all. At other times, we have so many options that making a decision becomes difficult. As part of the efforts to contain the spread of the novel coronavirus, which causes the disease named COVID-19, the South African government has declared a 21-day lockdown of the country. This lockdown limits the amount of choices we can make in our everyday lives through restrictions conceived by Ministers and their advisors. This limitation of choice is necessary, claims the government, to save lives — a stance I agree with.</p><p>Within the context of the lockdown, we have what have been termed “essential services”. These are services which the government deems necessary to continue during the lockdown period to keep the country functioning, to an extent. These are services provided by people in sectors such as health, power generation, and the like.</p><p>Back to my run. This run was strange because I only came across two other joggers along my usual route. A noticeable dip from the numerous faces I’ve come to recognise in the minutes before dawn. However, what struck me most was the lack of change in the number of people getting off taxis to walk the rest of the way to their places of employment, and those who had already walked from places afar. The difference between myself, my fellow joggers, and the people on their way to put in a day’s work is choice.</p><p>You may be wondering why I’ve made it this far having only mentioned one part of the title of this piece — disease. Do not be misled. I have already elucidated on the other elements of the title but I have lumped them into the concept of choice. What makes my fellow joggers different from the people on their way to work before the break of dawn? Race. What makes me different to the those same people? Privilege.</p><p>In July 2019, a class action suit was settled between the Occupational Lung Disease Working Group and the class representatives representing miners who had contracted silicosis as a result of poor health and safety measures underground. This suit represents, starkly, the relationship between race, class, and disease. The miners, a majority of whom are Black, inhaled silica dust causing silicosis — a lung disease. Mining, to a large extent, has been declared an essential service for the duration of the lockdown.</p><p>Essential services, it must be noted, are just that, essential. What makes them essential does not have to be the same for all of them. Some are necessary to ensure the health and safety of citizens, whilst others are deemed essential in order to protect the economic wellbeing of the country.</p><p>Without going into much detail, I want to point out that there is a history of associating race with cleanliness and as a result, disease. This association, although primarily racist in nature, is reified by the socio-economic conditions which are extant in South African society at large. The ‘dirtiest’ jobs are reserved for people who look a certain way or belong to a certain class. The white-collar jobs, similarly, tend to be occupied by people from a specific racial and class background, although there is more racial representation in this area. My claim that the association between disease and race is reified is buttressed by the exposure people who do certain work have to disease throughout their daily lives. These people overwhelmingly belong to the same race.</p><p>COVID-19 is spread person-to-person during close contact through respiratory droplets produced when one sneezes or coughs without taking the necessary measures to contain these droplets. How, then, does a country contain the spread of this disease? If I had a proper answer, there would be no pandemic. However, there are measures people and governments have taken, such as ‘social distancing’ as an attempt to decrease the the chance of transmission. How then are these measures implemented in a time of lockdown? The simple answer to this is that they are implemented thoroughly, swiftly, and, if necessary, forcefully. The lockdown necessitates the ‘employment’ of the SANDF to assist the SAPS in ensuring that people observe the temporary measures and restrictions of their rights in order to ‘flatten the curve’.</p><p>Naturally, I am in support of taking the necessary measures to avoid a catastrophic spread of the disease throughout our country. South Africa has a population which includes many individuals living with HIV, TB, and other illnesses which render them more vulnerable than others. Once again, those who are vulnerable are more than likely to come from specific racial and class backgrounds. This is not a claim that the aforementioned illnesses affect people solely along racial lines, rather, it is a claim encompassing the demographics of our society and the logical expectation that the majority would have the majority of cases. The claim that I have made through this piece, perhaps too subtly, is that there is a correlation between race and exposure, followed by infection, to disease, and that this correlation is socio-economic in nature.</p><p>Those rendering essential services during our lockdown are likely to have relied on various forms of public transport during the time before the pandemic, and this remains the case now. Their exposure to disease is thus reduced but not to the same extent as those who are able to remain home. In fact, some people, such as nurses and other healthcare employees, will have their exposure increased.</p><p>We know that South Africa has a healthcare system that is bifurcated along financial lines. The majority of people can only afford access to public healthcare services, whilst few have the resources available to access private healthcare. This distinction is brought into stark relief whenever we hear or read stories of hospitals not having enough beds for the number of patients passing through their doors. We simply do not have the resources, as a country, to manage or mitigate an outbreak on the scale of those seen in European countries such as Italy and Spain.</p><p>I have perhaps neglected the privilege aspect of the this piece in favour of the other aspects. Privilege is found in questions about whether dogs can be walked through the streets, or whether jogs through parks will be permitted. It is found in the ability to wake up, get in your car, drive to your nearest Woolworths and back home without having to come close to any other human. Privilege affords those who have it a layer of insulation from infection. This pandemic, and the threat it poses, is not the same for all of us. How it affects us is mediated through a variety of socio-economic lenses. The search for loopholes in the gazetted regulations may, and in some instances must, be seen as an attempt to other oneself and increase the gap between oneself and those who find themselves positioned lower on the societal ladder. It is crucial that in this time we acknowledge the privileges we have in relation to others and ensure that our behaviour does not unnecessarily endanger those without the added insulation of privilege. I am talking primarily to you, the employers who do not render essential services yet blatantly lie on forms in order to ensure your staff continues working through this period. There are many other facets of life in which privilege will play a determining role in how we’re affected by this pandemic but I leave their consideration to the reader.</p><p>It has not been my aim to share new knowledge in this piece. I write on the assumption that all that I have stated is known. What this is an attempt to do is locate this knowledge within the present context and to draw from the situation we find ourselves in. It is an attempt to highlight the gross injustices that existed, and continue to exist, in our society. I aim to make clear that for many, even a global pandemic is something which privilege affords them the choice to opt out of.</p><p>Stay home. Do not take unnecessary risks. Do not endanger others. I believe that if we all make a bona fide attempt to abide by the rules implemented by our government, the worst scenarios may be averted and we will meet on the other side. Stay safe.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4761e4fcc021" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the South African electoral system: A proposed change]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Thulani_Dlamini/on-the-south-african-electoral-system-a-proposed-change-35fa3acf11a1?source=rss-df30b10f2204------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/35fa3acf11a1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[south-africa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parliament]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thulani Dlamini]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 06 Apr 2019 09:59:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-06T09:59:27.821Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/512/1*qTVwPNZvAJZpEmL6yjlP4g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image: Rodger Bosch / Pool / AFP (<a href="https://www.timeslive.co.za/politics/2018-02-15-the-oath-is-sealed-ramaphosa-is-officially-the-president-of-south-africa/">Source</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>Part 1: <a href="https://medium.com/@Thulani_Dlamini/on-the-south-african-electoral-system-how-much-power-do-ordinary-citizens-actually-have-78074a61b054">https://medium.com/@Thulani_Dlamini/on-the-south-african-electoral-system-how-much-power-do-ordinary-citizens-actually-have-78074a61b054</a></p><p>Matamela Cyril Ramaphosa became the fifth democratically elected President of the Republic of South Africa on 15 February 2018. What was seemingly extraordinary about his ascension to the presidency — the absence of a vote by the public — was, in fact, the norm. As discussed in Part 1, ordinary South Africans have almost no say in who is elected to lead as President; this responsibility is left to the National Assembly which, at full capacity, consists of 400 members(MPs). The Constitution states “ At its first sitting after its election, and whenever necessary to fill a vacancy, the National Assembly must elect a woman or a man from among its members to be the President”.</p><p>The election of Ramaphosa brought a close to months of speculation and anxiety over the position of former President Jacob Zuma. After surviving multiple motions of no confidence in Parliament, it had fallen to the African National Congress to demand that he resign or have his party turn on him and support a proposed, and potentially final, motion of no confidence. Throughout the final stages of the Zuma presidency, South Africans could do little else but watch as the saga unfolded. We were spectators as our political future appeared to be hanging in the balance. This inability to act, or intervene, in a critical matter is the direct result of the electoral system (and political system at large) that is operative in South Africa. In the piece preceding this, I have made the point that ordinary citizens seem to only matter to political parties in election years. 2019 happens to be one such year and we find ourselves once more inundated with campaigns full of promises.</p><p>In this piece I aim to propose changes to our electoral system that will allow ordinary citizens — those who are not members of Parliament — to have a greater say in how their supposed representatives are elected and how they may be held accountable. However, this will not be a thorough critique of the current system in use. The focus will be on the National Assembly, the lower house of Parliament. Other legislative and representative structures will be referred to but will not be the primary concern of this piece.</p><p>The cornerstone of any democracy must be the mechanisms of accountability that have been put into place. In South Africa, if we are not happy with how our elected representatives “represent” us, we may choose to vote for another party in the next election, local or general, and hope that they are replaced. It remains out of our hands to choose who takes up a seat in Parliament.</p><p>Our electoral system is a closed-list proportional representation system. Briefly, what this means is that the results of the national ballot are used to determine how many seats each party has in the National Assembly — this is the proportional aspect of the system. What the closed-list aspect means is that the each party must submit a ranked list of candidates to the Independent Electoral Commission (IEC). This list is then used to allocate members to seats; the higher up on the list a candidate is, the more likely they are to become an MP.</p><p>You may wonder what, then, is the fundamental issue I have with this system? It is that voters have no say direct say in who sits in Parliament as their representative.</p><p>The American electoral system can, at times, appear convoluted but it does offer something that ours does not – it gives voters the opportunity to choose who will represent them and who will lead the country. This is an oversimplification of the system but it does bring to light an aspect of the American democracy that ours is missing.</p><p>For a country that is often seen as the bastion of democracy, it might be somewhat surprising that the current President of the United States of America, did not, in fact, win most of the votes in the presidential election. Donald Trump squared off against Hillary Clinton for the top job in 2016. In the popular vote, Clinton received 2 868 686 more votes than Trump – a clear loss. However, the popular vote only determines the manner in which members of the Electoral College will vote.</p><p>The Electoral College is the body that elects the President. Its members are given a mandate, in the form of the result of the popular vote in the state they represent, to vote for a specific candidate. There are 538 presidential electors and the Presidential candidate who receives an absolute majority is declared the President-Elect.</p><blockquote><a href="https://www.archives.gov/federal-register/electoral-college/allocation.html">“Every state is allocated a number of votes equal to the number of senators and representatives in its U.S. Congressional delegation – two votes for its senators in the U.S. Senate plus a number of votes equal to the number of its members in the U. S. House of Representatives.”</a></blockquote><p>The Electoral College system is not perfect, but it does seem to offer more of a say to voters in electing their President than our system does. A couple of major flaws in the system are that:</p><ul><li>electors do not always vote as directed by their states</li><li>it goes against the principle of “one person, one vote”</li></ul><p>The American government, like ours, consists of three branches of government. I will now shift my focus to its legislative branch.</p><p>Our legislative branch is a bicameral Parliament consisting of the National Assembly, the lower house, and the National Council of Provinces, the upper house. The American legislature is also a bicameral system with an upper and a lower chamber, which are the Senate and the House of Representatives, respectively.</p><p>Members of either chamber of Congress are elected by direct vote. Senators are elected in a state-wide election and Members of Congress are elected by people casting their votes in congressional districts. Senators serve 6-year terms and Members of Congress serve 2-year terms.</p><p>The American way of electing people to political office offers some level of direct election – Congress – and a less direct method – election of a President.</p><p>For the sake of comparison, it seems only natural to consider a country that functions as the closest thing to a direct democracy we can find in the present day – Switzerland.</p><p>Switzerland’s federal government consists of a grand total of seven people that make up the Federal Council. Switzerland has a bicameral legislative branch — the Federal Assembly — which is formed by a 200-seat National Council and a 46-seat Council of States. Apart from its primary legislative purpose, the Federal Assembly elects members of the Federal Council that serve 4-year terms with no limit on the number of terms that they may serve. All this seems quite run-of-the-mill for a political system but this system is anything but that.</p><p>Switzerland has 26 cantons (which may be seen as the equivalent of our provinces) and each canton is apportioned a specific number of seats in the Federal Council, dependent on its population size. Each canton is entitled to at least one seat.</p><p>When voting for the Swiss National Council, voters are granted as many votes as there are seats apportioned to the canton in which they reside. They may vote twice for the same candidate if they so wish. There is, however, still a party element to this system. Parties submit lists of candidates and for every vote received by a party’s candidate, the party receives a single vote. The Swiss system is a bit more complex than this but we do not need to delve into the details to see the potential that lies therein for voters to have a greater say in who represents them.</p><p>I now turn the focus of this piece to the primary goal – proposing an alternative for the South African electoral system.</p><p>I hope that by highlighting the shortcomings of our current electoral system, I will lead the reader to a specific conclusion – that change is needed. Some amongst us have witnessed, and participated in, five general, and democratic, elections while some of us (myself included) are now eligible to participate for the first time in such an election.</p><p>Often, there is a sense of apathy that comes with participating in elections because we believe that it will just be more of the same. This apathy, I believe, largely stems from the protection offered to underperforming public representatives by the Constitution and the electoral system therein prescribed. We, as ordinary citizens, have no say as to who sits in the Parliament that supposedly represents the people. Those “representatives” are often placed on the candidates list as a reward for their loyalty to a party. Malusi Gigaba, for example, is proof of this. Gigaba resigned, in shame, from his position as Minister of Home Affairs and as a Member of Parliament, but has been included on the ANC’s list for the coming election.</p><p>What recourse then do citizens have to hold recalcitrant representatives to account? To be quite frank – hardly any.</p><p>Believe it or not, every MP has a constituency to which they are supposed to be accountable. Our National Assembly has 400 members – what stops the IEC from carving up the country into 400 separate voting districts in which parties could field candidates? This would allow people to know exactly who they are voting for and would, hopefully, strengthen the link between people on the ground and MPs. Parties would no longer be free to rely on loyalty from the electorate to deploy whomever they want to Parliament. Instead, parties would have to field candidates who would have to compete directly against candidates from other parties for each specific voting district, with the winner then receiving a seat in the National Assembly.</p><p>This seemingly uncomplicated move would require an amendment of the Constitution which, as we have seen in the case of the amendments proposed with regard to Section 25, tends to be a tedious process that is informed as much by whims and agendas as it is by necessity.</p><p>The closed-list approach serves to disempower voters in favour of political parties. Although the lists are made in consultation with branch members of the party concerned, they do not always reflect the wishes of the majority of the party’s supporters. Doing away with the list system in favour of a system in which candidates compete for specific voting districts would allow for us, as regular citizens, to have a say in who represents us in the National Assembly.</p><p>An overhaul of our voting system is, in my opinion, something that is required in order to give effect to the values of democracy and accountability that the Constitution holds dearly. In seeking to create the society envisioned by the authors of the South African Constitution, it is important to realise that the original values therein were not perfect and that some aspects of this supreme law of the Republic may require a rethink. We have now come to see that they allow for misuse and abuse of the system.</p><p>In comparison to the American and Swiss electoral systems, we seem to have very little choice over who our representatives will be. We are restricted to voting for a party and allowing its leadership to select who it decides would serve our interests best — even if they’ve shown that their self-interest far outweighs our interests.</p><p>In advancing the argument I have made here, I seek not to win wide support for my view but, rather, I seek to encourage an increased level of scrutiny of how our country’s electoral system functions. This proposal should not be seen as what I believe to be the panacea to the problems we face. Rather, it should be seen as an attempt to offer a solution to what I consider to be a flaw in our country’s political system. I hope that you, as the reader, will take from this essay, if nothing else, a deepened understanding of the roots of the lack of accountability that we so often complain about.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=35fa3acf11a1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the South African electoral system: how much power do ordinary citizens actually have?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Thulani_Dlamini/on-the-south-african-electoral-system-how-much-power-do-ordinary-citizens-actually-have-78074a61b054?source=rss-df30b10f2204------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/78074a61b054</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[south-africa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thulani Dlamini]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 07 Jul 2018 16:25:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-06T13:35:58.029Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*IYPhQVz5AJCX5EyGulcq3g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image: Esa Alexander. <a href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&amp;rct=j&amp;q=&amp;esrc=s&amp;source=images&amp;cd=&amp;ved=2ahUKEwilhqv0sY3cAhWDzxQKHcRuAWkQjRx6BAgBEAU&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.timeslive.co.za%2Fpolitics%2F2018-02-27-national-assembly-adopts-eff-motion-on-land-expropriation%2F&amp;psig=AOvVaw2XPa791whhS1yfNRGmeqvq&amp;ust=1531066649977399">Source</a></figcaption></figure><p>In the general election of 2014, South Africa had 33 parties competing for seats in the National Assembly. The National Assembly (NA) has a total of 400 seats and these are shared using an allocatory method of proportional representation through a closed list approach. What this essentially means is that we, as citizens, have little to no say over which individuals are elected to represent us in the NA. In this essay I will argue that the present electoral system urgently needs to be rethought and reformed. The system, as it is today, is open to a multitude of abuses by political parties and cannot be seen to be useful tool for representation and accountability. I will support my argument by considering cases that highlight its weakness. In an attempt to be fair, I will also highlight its strengths. The focus will be on the National Assembly.</p><p>If you head to the polls in 2019 you will be presented with two ballot papers — one will be for the national legislature and the other will be for the legislature of the province in which you reside. On these ballot papers you will see political party logos. It is not wholly unreasonable to think that a voter may make their decision solely on the preference for the colours of one party over those of another. This is where we encounter the first, and perhaps most considerable, flaw of our electoral system. Voters know what they are voting for but not who they are voting for.</p><p>Our country uses a system of proportional representation to share the 400 available seats in the NA amongst the parties who contest elections. This method of allocating seats allows even the smallest parties to stand a chance of forming a part of Parliament. The African People’s Convention, a party founded in 2007, received 30,676 votes which was 0.17% of the total. This very low figure translated into 1 seat in the National Assembly. On the other hand, the African National Congress received 11,436,921 votes — 62.15% of the total — which translated into 249 seats in the National Assembly.</p><p>The closed list approach used in our electoral system requires that parties, by a set date, submit a complete list of members who will stand for seats in the aforementioned legislatures. These party lists are often drafted without consultation of the public and are handled as party business and may be the result of internal discussions, or may be decided upon by virtue of seniority within a party.</p><p>As you may have gathered from what’s been written above, Members of Parliament (MPs) are not selected by the people they claim to represent but are chosen, as candidates, by whichever internal selection mechanisms their parties employ. The general public is almost solely responsible for determining how many people off a party list are rewarded with a seat in Parliament.</p><p>Parliamentary terms last for five years, yet it is not guaranteed that an MP will serve a full term. This lack of security of tenure may be viewed as a flaw or as a positive aspect of our political system.Performing MPs may serve multiple terms, however, underperforming MPs may do likewise. They may also be removed on a whim by their party. Traditionally, the first name on a party’s list will be that party’s nominee for presidential office. The ANC’s party lists in 2009 and 2014 were topped by one Jacob Gedleyihlekisa Zuma, who was elected president of the African National Congress in 2007 at the hotly contested Polokwane Elective Conference. The first member of parliament, barring any unexpected events, to lose their seat is the member who is entrusted with the position of President of the Republic by the National Assembly. The President, upon being elected by the House, resigns as an MP and is then tasked with forming their cabinet, the Executive. The party from which the President is elected is then allowed to deploy to the National Assembly a member to take up the seat vacated by the President.</p><p>The philosophy of Trias Politica and the doctrine of separation of powers, as espoused by Locke and Montesquieu, are what our system of government is based on. The Trias Politica advocates for a system of government in which there are three separate branches: the executive, the legislature, and the judiciary. The separation of powers is implemented to decentralise power in order for the different branches to operate independently, to some extent, and to exercise oversight over one another’s functions. Although South Africa employs the doctrine of separation of powers, it does not follow it strictly. The legislature has some say over who forms the executive; the executive has some say over who forms the judiciary; and the judiciary has some interpretative powers over the work of the legislature. The false, or incomplete, separation of powers is supposed to work in the interests of accountability yet this opens the entire political system to interferences with one branch’s work by another.</p><p>The ability to hold people accountable usually rests in the power of recall. There is much debate over who, in the South African system of government, can recall who. It is intuitive that citizens may recall those who are supposed to represent them — Members of Parliament— yet we are granted the opportunity to exercise this power only once every five years through the general election. The President may be recalled by Parliament through the passing of a motion of no confidence in the President and the entire executive. The President must remove a sitting judge after a resolution to remove said judge has been adopted by two thirds of the National Assembly. Judges are granted security of tenure prescribed by Section 176 of the Constitution of the Republic. It cannot be ignored that Members of Parliament are seemingly immune to the possibility of being removed by those they represent.</p><p>The last sentence of the above paragraph may be looked at in two ways: Members of Parliament represent the people who voted for the party; or they represent the party which nominated them for a seat in Parliament according to the party list submitted to the Electoral Commission of South Africa (IEC). The first interpretation seems to be the most common one amongst the MPs, and the second interpretation holds sway amongst the general population.</p><p>The past four or so years have brought the issue of political representation to the fore. Proportional representation is an effective and fair way of granting seats to parties in Parliament, yet the fairness it offers to citizens is questionable. Citizens may be the most disempowered cogs within the political machine which governs their lives at multiple levels. Citizens, through freedom of association, may choose to become card-carrying members of a political party of their choosing but even then are not trusted with much power.</p><p>In October 2017, the office of the Secretary General of the ANC released a <a href="https://www.enca.com/south-africa/anc-allocates-delegate-numbers-for-elective-conference">document</a> outlining the number of delegates that each province would be permitted at the Elective Conference which was held in December of that year. The total number of delegates was 4723. These 4723 delegates carried mandates from their branches and provincial bodies to vote in a particular way. These 4723 delegates were, at that conference, the most powerful citizens in the country bar those who held positions in any sphere of government. It must be noted, however, that among those delegates may have been members of the ANC who already held positions in government. What emerged from this conference was a new leadership of the ANC — the top 6 — and a new National Executive Committee, which is the highest decision making body of the ANC between conferences. These 4723 delegates comprise the entirety of those who have some say over who will represent “the people” as deployees of the African National Congress.</p><p>These deployees are, first and foremost, accountable to the party which has deployed them into any office of authority. This, it goes without saying, includes those deployed by their party to Parliament. Political parties reserve the right to remove any of their deployees to the National Assembly as they see fit. This then brings us back to the question of who MPs really represent.</p><p>MPs, under threat of recall, toe the party line more often than note when it comes to making decisions in Parliament. In an ideal scenario, Members of Parliament would vote on motions according to their conscience — assuming that their conscience aligns with the stance of the party they represent in the House. This, however, is not always the case. Elected officials, just like the ordinary citizen, often need to consider the full ramifications of whichever decision they wish to make. This is colloquially termed “politics of the stomach” because one needs to ensure that one will be able to eat in future. Thus, as history has proven multiple times, it is unlikely for a political party in South Africa to recall, through a motion of no confidence, an individual it has deployed to the position of President.</p><p>In an attempt to be fair to the ruling party, it must be noted that they are not the only ones who sometimes find themselves in tricky positions regarding the party line and the consciences of party officials in various spheres of governance. The Democratic Alliance has attempted to deal, albeit disastrously, with people voting with their consciences in support of motions against the <a href="http://ewn.co.za/2018/06/07/it-s-a-coup-says-da-wc-leader-after-knysna-mayor-voted-out-of-office">party’s deployees</a>.</p><p>In July 2017, six Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) councillors disobeyed instructions from the EFF’s Central Command Team and attended a budget vote for the <a href="https://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/eff-expels-6-mogale-city-councillors-for-voting-with-anc-20171008">Mogale City Municipality</a>. The official instruction from the top was to be absent so as to not allow the ANC to pass the budget due to quorum not being reached. The six councillors, in defiance, attended the meeting and went as far as voting with the ANC to pass the budget. One can reach different conclusions about what drove the councillors to break ranks — their consciences may have played a major role.</p><p>When former President Thabo Mbeki resigned from his position in 2008, he did so of his own accord and was not removed as a result of a motion of no confidence being passed against him and his cabinet. He did, however, lose the confidence of the National Executive Committee of the ANC. This case brings into stark relief the issue of loyalty to the party versus loyalty to the people — the two are not always clearly divisible, however. The Mbeki resignation should have been a precursor to how the removal of former President Jacob Zuma would unfold.</p><p>Facing massive backlash from the public, which was arguably strongly influence by the media, the ANC eventually came to the decision to remove another sitting President. Zuma, prior to his resignation as President of the Republic, had been at pains to ensure that the Constitution was abided by to the letter. Put simply, he felt it unjust for a political party to attempt to remove him from Office because they had not put him in that position. Zuma was right. He was elected by Parliament to the highest office in the land and he was right to argue that only Parliament could remove him. A survivor of many attempts by opposition parties to remove him, Zuma had become accustomed to navigating motions of no confidence conducted openly or through secret ballots. One could spend days discussing the fall of Jacob Zuma but that is not our aim here.</p><p>The relationship between Members of Parliament and us, their constituents, is governed by a middleman — the party — and this creates an imbalance of power which is ignored to our disadvantage. Most South Africans who are fairly aware of political happenings in the country do not know who their Member of Parliament is. This is a failure on behalf of Parliament insofar as it has not made the information easily accessible. The failure is not Parliaments alone though. Much of the blame must be placed on the system of proportional representation chosen instead of a primarily constituency-based electoral system which would allow us, the people, to select our representatives. The present system leaves far too much power in the hands of political parties which, constitutionally, are <a href="https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/opinionista/2017-04-20-how-south-africas-electoral-system-effectively-disenfranchises-voters/#.Wz_dNy17HOQ">extra-parliamentary</a> bodies.</p><p>As things stand, we have little say, as citizens, over who is chosen to lead the country as President. This can quite easily, and justifiably, be characterised as an undemocratic feature of our political system. One may argue that this is simply not the case and that all have a chance to have their say over who a party chooses as its presidential candidate. This is a valid argument but elective conferences of parties are not known for their transparency as many agreements are made at the last minute behind closed doors. Figures such as the current Deputy President of the ANC and the Republic, DD Mabuza, may find themselves wielding power as a result of strategic decision-making and long-term planning.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>In this piece I have attempted to show the minimal role played by the general population in electing public officials, whether they are Members of Parliament or the President. I have shown how the doctrine of separation of powers is imperfectly implemented in our political system in an attempt to create mechanisms of accountability. What is most striking about the aforementioned accountability is that it is assumed that it is accountability to citizens but, in practice, it is accountability to the party. South Africans are left at a disadvantage because they have no effective means of holding public officials accountable other than elections and even then they can only hold parties accountable. “Selected” officials owe their positions to their party and not strictly to those who gave the party power to deploy them. This is something that needs to be thought about and engaged with as a topic in our public discourse.</p><p>In a future piece, I will propose an alternative electoral system that will seek to empower citizens by implementing stronger methods of holding public officials accountable.</p><p>*<a href="https://link.medium.com/TghFlw9pFV">Part 2</a>*</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=78074a61b054" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Making sense of class and solidarity: a personal reflection]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Thulani_Dlamini/making-sense-of-class-and-solidarity-a-personal-reflection-6b1fc8a1ada6?source=rss-df30b10f2204------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6b1fc8a1ada6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[solidarity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[protest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[class]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thulani Dlamini]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 May 2018 16:08:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-03T16:08:47.634Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/621/1*mbLoG8GMgaMmTFdyGgnVQg@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>On the 25th of April multiple marches and protests occurred all across South Africa. The majority of these had been organised by the South African Federation of Trade Unions, commonly referred to as SAFTU. SAFTU, like COSATU, is an umbrella body of trade unions, referred to as affiliates in the common parlance of this sector of society. This piece is a reflection of my experiences at the Cape Town SAFTU march and the thoughts I had during and after the event. As this is is a reflection, there will be no attempt to make a grand argument.</p><p>My introduction to the culture of protest coincided with my entrance to the university sphere and, as a result of this, I’ve been an active participant of the culture. I’ve also been able to analyse the culture in a more academic light due to my selection of majors — Politics and Sociology. It would not be incorrect to claim that much of the learning I have done at the University of Cape Town stems not from the lecture venues but from activities related to protesting, including the act itself.</p><p>A major facet of protest is solidarity. Solidarity is what many call for when actively protesting but many often ignore this call. Solidarity is the reason I found myself in the city centre on the 25th instead of being in my Politics lecture. This was an attempt at practising my politics. The workers (a term I hesitate in using but cannot find a suitable and descriptive alternative for) at UCT have, on numerous occasions, thrown in their lot with students in the many struggles that have been waged on this campus and it seems right and just, almost required, that we, as students, thrown in our lot with them as they try to advance their struggles at their place of employment and within the national context. This solidarity between workers and students tends to be one-sided as oftentimes workers may be seen as tools to advance our aims. Kant’s argument of seeing people as an end and not as a means to an end bears reference at this point. The sacrifices that workers are willing to, and at times do, make often outweigh the contribution students are prepared to make towards the advancement of their cause. This should be seen as a criticism of the student-worker relations at UCT alone and not as a general criticism as I am only privy to this specific relationship.</p><p>Comradeship in struggle relies on individuals acting together with the intention of bringing about some sort of change. This change may benefit some more than others but all should agree, within the struggle, that the change is necessary and should actively, in a multitude of ways, to ensure that this change does occur. Unfortunately this is not always the case. With the advent of the #___MustFall protests there has been a wide-scale adoption of the framework of intersectionality as the tool of analysis to be used. This framework is regularly used to advocate for a multi-pronged approach to protest wherein multiple issues are tackled at once; and there exists a strong emphasis on the acknowledgement of the manner in which multiple privileges and oppressions exist and act on each individual and the necessity of cognisance of one’s positionality and that of others — one’s comrades. Once one is aware of their own positionality in relation to a struggle or a movement, one should pay careful attention, at all times, of the role that they play. Those who may not be directly affected by that which is being protested for, or against, may choose to align themselves as allies. As much as the working-class struggle in this country can be viewed as a Black issue, this reductionism is not wholly beneficial. This reductionism, in this instance may lead to those not of the working-class attempting to use the struggle for their personal aims and gain. It is in this context that I found my role in the working-class struggle at the university and in the national context — as an ally.</p><p>Whilst walking through the streets of Cape Town, surrounded by a mass of red SAFTU shirts that had the demand of a living, not minimum, wage printed on them, a thought struck me — as a university student, I am actively working to ensure that I am not a part of the class to which those around me belong. My attempts to disregard this thought were in vain and it has plagued me ever since. The consolation I find is within the idea that I am at least not working to ensure that those I marched with remained oppressed by the capitalist system we find ourselves functioning within today. I found more consolation in the appreciation shown to myself and other UCT students by workers employed by the university who found us at the march.</p><p>Issues of class are often ignored because of the tendency of South Africans, in general, to focus on race as the primary category of analysis and oppression, and give it priority over all other categories of identity. Class dynamics within the Black community are often ignored in spaces of protest because “we’re all Black and go through the same things”. This homogenisation of Blackness dismisses nuances of identity and allows for the aforementioned class dynamics to be disregarded by those who carry the privilege to do so. If one is unaware of the differences between the self and others, it becomes difficult to be truly sympathetic and empathetic since one assumes common lived-experiences which may not, in fact, exist. In struggle, there is often a clamour to find commonalities in order to build unity, and this may occur at the expense of acknowledging differences within the group that could potentially lead to unresolvable clashes of opinion and ideology because people do not fully appreciate their position in relation to one other. The disregard of difference can be seen as a form of wilful ignorance from which little or no good can be derived. It is from the acknowledgement of difference that unity can be built with empathy and understanding as a foundation.</p><p>My experiences at the march raised a few questions that I have been grappling with since but, also, brought to the fore others that I have mulled over. Does true altruism exist on a fundamental level or are all our actions done with some level of self-interest? This question fits within my questioning of ideas, and acts, of solidarity. Was I at the march as an act of true solidarity or was I there in order to “practise my personal politics” and stay true to my beliefs in order to reaffirm my conception of myself as an empathetic being? Are the two mutually exclusive? Unfortunately I do not have an forthright answer to this question. Was I there to maintain an image of myself that I believe others perceive as being my true self? One could also question if I was there simply to support those who have been there to support a cause which I perhaps felt more directly affected by. If this is the case then could my act of solidarity simply not be viewed as me paying a metaphorical debt? This view, ultimately, reduces the idea of support in struggle to an almost transactional relationship wherein I do something for you in the belief that, in my time of need, you shall return the favour. As pessimistic as this view of human nature may be, it is not without its benefits insofar as that the required support can be called upon, even if it may be akin to coercion.</p><p>Class and solidarity deserve more attention than I have afforded them here and, indubitably, require a more in-depth analysis than that which I have undertaken. It has been my intention simply to put my thoughts into the world in order to encourage engagement around the topics I have touched on here. I have barely scratched the surface but I do hope, in future, to explore my thoughts further and to build arguments which will hopefully be subjected to rigorous scrutiny.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6b1fc8a1ada6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>