<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Thomas Covington Dyer on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Thomas Covington Dyer on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@TommyDyer?source=rss-3304f0f0d87a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 20:00:31 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@TommyDyer/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Decentralist Papers]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TommyDyer/the-decentralist-papers-5493c83bc0f6?source=rss-3304f0f0d87a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5493c83bc0f6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ego]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decentralization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Covington Dyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 13 Oct 2018 13:29:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-13T13:29:26.519Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Individual</h3><p>What constitutes a “center” when it comes to an individual? What constitutes a “circumference?”</p><h4>Center</h4><p>An individual’s center, my center, is my “ego”. My arbitrary set of programs, values, beliefs, etc. that my “self” has accumulated over the course of my lifetime. An analogy I’ve been thinking about recently is of a colander submersed in water. The colander is the “self.” The water is life, beauty, abundance, love, etc. The ego is the set of programs that works day and night to keep all the little colander/self holes plugged up to keep the goodness of the water out. It works against. It resists by definition. It pushes back. It is mindlessness. It is the ego as center.</p><h4>Circumference</h4><p>Mindfulness of the set of programs, values, beliefs, etc. that make up the ego could constitute a circumference when it comes to the individual. Ego not running things arbitrarily. Ego not pushing back and resisting all that might flood in to and through the self if it were allowed to flow. Resistanceless. Controllessness. Letting go of control. Letting go of resistance. Allowing that which can emerge from the depths of the individual or flow through the individual might constitute what it’d be like to live as an individual run by the circumference as opposed to the center.</p><h3>Group/Team/Organization</h3><p>What constitutes a “center” when it comes to a Group/Team/Organization? What constitutes a “circumference?”</p><h4>Center</h4><p>As within, so without. The analog to the ego for a group/team/organization , the center could be the “head”. The boss. The “leader”. The founder. The arbitrary system of values, beliefs, and artifacts that make up the answer to the “culture” question. It’s “how we do things around here.” The center is the leader, or their controlling proxy, the culture. More often than not at this point in history, most groups/teams/organizations have “heads” that strive to command and control as much as possible.</p><h4>Circumference</h4><p>Autonomy is a group/team/organization without a center. Each and every individual that is a part of the group/team/organization acts without fear, or coercion. There is no leverage or means of control. Individuals act unencumbered by outside or central pressure. Individuals create what needs to be created to accomplish the mission they set out to accomplish when they signed up to join the group/team/organization.</p><h3>Society</h3><p>What constitutes a “center” when it comes to a Society? What constitutes a “circumference?”</p><h4>Center</h4><p>Power centers. The attractor patterns that get bigger and bigger and stronger and stronger and attract (read: suck) energy and resources into themselves without society’s explicit consent. Think government, finance, military, and increasingly, lately, big tech companies sitting on piles of data about consumers (society).</p><h4>Circumference</h4><p>Individuals are free. Clusters of power do not and cannot remove or restrict the freedoms of individuals. Law rules instead of an arbitrary person, group, socioeconomic class, organization or sector.</p><h3>Power and Copernicus</h3><p>In all of the above the topic of focus is power. What is power? How does it come to be? From where does it originate? What’s it doing here? What’s its purpose? Is there an analogue to power in nature? Is there something inherent about human beings that makes power necessary? Centrality necessary? That makes command and control the only way to organize a person, group or society?</p><p>It seems to me many problems stem from “centered” systems. Seeing the problems of these centered systems makes me think of Copernicus sitting in a room in Poland trying to make sense of hair-brained Ptolemaic astronomy. And then, out of perplexity and frustration, he’s like. Wait a second. This could be so much simpler if it were just decentered…</p><p>And like the power of that realization what if we equally saw the power of looking at ourselves, our groups/teams/organizations and our societies through the lens of decentralization?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5493c83bc0f6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[De-Colonization of the Mind]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TommyDyer/de-colonization-of-the-mind-8a03b6390560?source=rss-3304f0f0d87a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8a03b6390560</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[colonialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[us-v-them]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Covington Dyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 13 Oct 2018 13:16:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-13T16:02:42.874Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Something I’ve been thinking about is the following:</p><p>Colonization has been a thing since Mesopotamia cradled “civilization”. Domination of one group over another in the form of colonization is fairly common in history. This domination has effects that lengthily outlast their formal existence. Untrue and unfounded superiority/inferiority patterns abound in the aftermath. The process of “de-colonization” deals with the aftermath but could be improved as a process. How do people formerly dominated/colonized by another group de-colonize themselves? Not just de-colonize their political systems or the lands that comprise their countries. How do they de-colonize their minds, their “selves”? What tools do people have for this work? What spaces do they have? Do both groups, the dominators and the dominated have de-colonization work to do? Do the tools for each group differ? Do the spaces for the work have different needs?</p><p>I’ve been fascinated by change at the individual, group, organizational and societal levels for a long time. It was my main mission/question upon entering grad school for social psyche. Looking at people, intergroup relations, etc. through the lens of colonialism opens up a whole world. The colonizer and the colonized have long histories in many contexts. 9 times out of 10, I’m pretty sure, the colonizer has perpetrated terrible crimes against the humanity of the colonized. Similar to the Stanford prisoner experiment, those in power in a toxic culture wield that power and do so in a way that might not be what they’d do if you’d asked them ahead of time in a chill situation, what would you do if you were a prison guard, say.</p><p>In addition to using the power dynamics to victimize and be victimized whole groups of people must have internalized patterns of thinking and feelings about themselves. Those patterns are what they are. Morally bad, or generally ineffective, maybe just plain nauseating. Whatever they are, they are old AF but still around and deeply ingrained and therefore deeply at work every breath any of us on either side of this us-v-them anyone is on.</p><p>How then can we either shed these old colonial ways of thinking? Or, how can we internalize new feelings about ourselves? How might we de-colonize our minds? Is it an activity that has to happen alone? Is it fundamentally a group or social activity? Additionally, how do we change ourselves and the groups we’re apart of (by choice or not) without recreating the old colonial power dynamics? How do we take power apart and smell its entrails. Inhale what in its innards and acknowledge it smells terrible? And acknowledge that we need not stay mired in such a smell every waking moment of our lives/generations?</p><p>Some people talk about neo-colonialism. I’m not sure it’s the most useful phrase when it comes to a social-psyche change effort. Colonialism might not even be a great word for what it is. It’s really a benign euphemism. Establishing a colony somewhere where no other human being lives is a pretty regular part of human history. Humans spread throughout the world “colonizing” new lands. I bet early humans found many of the beautiful as shit. At least the first humans that felt the first beauty. Colonialism that we mean when we use the word today is the total conquering of other peoples starting around the 1400s. It is a total and complete “power-over” of one group over another.</p><p>Thus, instead of talking about de-colonizing our minds, we could talk about de-conquering our minds. Or de-dominating our minds and selves. We might talk about ending the control of one center, or ego, or group over another. And as we get stuck in the trap of defining terms via negation, the aporia starts to open the mind up a crack. Let a bit of light in. What does a world look like in which I don’t dominate and control myself, I don’t dominate and control others as their boss, colleague or friend (manipulation) and my group (straight, able-bodied, white, not-bald-yet-but-probably-soon, cis-genered males) not dominate and conquer each day and control any other group or individual. What are the words? What are the opposites of dominate? Oppress? Control?</p><p>I’ve been stuck on one for a few years: “Let go.” And by slight extension, “surrender.” “Empower” makes me want to throwupinmymouth. Allow. Open-up. Allow in. Remove walls. Welcome. Accept. Love. Unconditionally any of the above. Com-pash (why isn’t there a clear and easy verb of compassion I wonder? “Colonize” and “dominate” are so easy).</p><p>Having a direction there is interesting. Seeing some of the possibilities that we associate with those words is nice. The how is still elusive. After all these years. I only ever circle back to mediation and mindfulness. While I do still believe the magic we seek is in practices like those I still feel there is more that eludes when it comes to the how question. The how of change. Of human change. Of changing myself and my tribe.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8a03b6390560" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Humpty Dumpty]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TommyDyer/humpty-dumpty-2d3ddad5faab?source=rss-3304f0f0d87a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2d3ddad5faab</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[presence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lanaguage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wholeness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[oneness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Covington Dyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 23 Sep 2018 18:31:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-09-23T18:31:34.882Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Humpty Dumpty</p><p>In the beginning of the Bible one of the first things the first human does is name everything. Names and words and language are great. They give us phenomenal cosmic power. They also break everything apart.</p><p>We live everyday of our lives in the world of and the world wrought by language. A broken up/broken apart world.</p><p>Out with a friend last week, sitting at a bar in Bushwick he carpented (why isn’t that a word?) a few years back, he talked about the above perspective. And he offered up an anecdote describing how he thinks we put Humpty back together again.</p><p>It was the 80s in NYC and he was at a Zen meditation studio in Manhattan. He was meditating. He got to a place in which he felt like he was almost tilting sideways. He opens one eye and peaks out. It turns out he’s not actually tilting sideways. He’s just in a strange and new stage of his meditation. He falls even deeper in. And heads home and realizes he’s floating the whole way. He gets home and his soon to be father-in-law says to his wife, “At least he happy.” He was in a different state of mind. No-mind.</p><p>One. Unbroken. Whole. It was this experience that pointed him towards the bunch that putting Humpty back together again has to do with wordlessness. Being. Presence. Continuous attending to the present moment.</p><p>I like and think it’s good for myself and all to spend a little more time continuously putting Humpty back together again.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2d3ddad5faab" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Having, Doing, Being]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TommyDyer/having-doing-being-31df94c5379d?source=rss-3304f0f0d87a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/31df94c5379d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[presence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[being]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peace]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Covington Dyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 15 Sep 2018 16:03:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-09-15T16:03:59.381Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Below are incoherent musings on a lens through which I sometimes look at myself and the world around me.</p><h3>Having</h3><p>I focus/attend to what I have. Money, relationships, apartments, clothes, shoes, points.</p><p>It’s also focus/attention on what I don’t have. (It’s mostly this.) Money, relationships, apartments, free time, clothes, shoes, points.</p><p>I define myself by all these “havings.” Not by much else. One big one that was immensely salient for a while was a career.</p><h3>Doing</h3><p>I focus/attend to all the things I have to do! Sometimes it’s I can do it! I can do them all! Even the hard things! I can do it! Sometimes I focus on my helplessness and how I can’t do the hard things or I have way too much to do. Work. Side projects. Travels. Routines. Workouts. Runs. Culture or not taking advantage of culture. Weddings (never my own).</p><p>When I’m really deep in a loop of defining myself by all my doings or non-doings (I think this correlates), I experience a lot of tension in my chest and throat and behind my eyes. It’s no bueno.</p><p>The funniest doing I get stuck on is my “doings” of mediation. How many minutes did I meditate today? This morning? Did I focus on my breath much or not really at all? Did I focus on the tension behind my eyes or in my throat or all this weird energy sitting on the right side of my neck that literally turns my head sideways? Did I basically rant and rave about work to some projection of a person the whole time instead of focusing on any one thing? It’s crazy ironic.</p><h3>Being</h3><p>I have a bias towards “Being”. I assume or I might say I believe that the more I “be” the healthier I get, the better my life goes and the less tense my body is. I don’t know if this is the case. I don’t “be” a whole lot though I “try” to. I find there aren’t easy ways to talk about being. It’s a verb and we have very verb-centric languages for the most part. When I talk about being I almost always have to talk about it as a “Doing”. All kinds of analogies are useful, but to really get at the idea, you have to transcend all “doing”-related thinking. It’s really hard to do.</p><p>Currently, I “try”, I intend, I do this thing where I attend to my breathing. Not each breath, but my breathing. The unbroken, continuous, integral (or is is derivative) of the act of breathing. Heartbeat would probs work too but for some reason I feel like my heartbeat isn’t easy to focus on. Breathing in this context is used as a doorway to being. Being and breathing have nothing to do with one another <em>really</em>. Sometimes I’ll go for a few moments, a handful of breaths attending to them all constantly. For the most part I’m unsuccessful. I don’t actually do it. I don’t meditate “right.” But therein lies the paradox. Back to the doing of thinking instead of the feeling/attending to the breathing in the body.</p><p>Thinking about and writing about being is a silly thing to do, but I think having the contrast to having and doing helps to point in the direction of being. Tips a seeker off to the fact that there might be this other thing. There is a door to a different “mode” in which we’re not on the merry-go-round of thinking about all our “havings” and “doings” all day long.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=31df94c5379d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Paperboy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TommyDyer/years-ago-as-a-paperboy-with-a-seventeen-mile-bicycle-route-in-rural-wisconsin-on-a-dark-winters-d9e8d42d4f50?source=rss-3304f0f0d87a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d9e8d42d4f50</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[presence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fear]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[timelessness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[death]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[awareness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Covington Dyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 15 Sep 2018 15:30:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-01T17:45:45.266Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>From the About the Author in the book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Letting-David-Hawkins-M-D-Ph-D/dp/1401945015/ref=sr_1_1?gclid=CjwKCAiApfeQBhAUEiwA7K_UHyNsQDXUd0a7RRoePTLji6w-yPwMF0U6jyjXwm5T-3-QJCkjoWohHBoCruEQAvD_BwE&amp;hvadid=241620604454&amp;hvdev=c&amp;hvlocphy=9067609&amp;hvnetw=g&amp;hvqmt=e&amp;hvrand=928618360839836303&amp;hvtargid=kwd-5755691675&amp;hydadcr=22534_10353871&amp;keywords=letting+go+book&amp;qid=1646156720&amp;sr=8-1">Letting Go by David Hawkins</a></p><p>Years ago, as a paperboy with a seventeen-mile bicycle route in rural Wisconsin, on a dark winter’s night I was caught miles from home in a twenty-below-zero blizzard. The bicycle fell over on the ice and the fierce wind ripped the newspapers out of the handlebar basket, blowing them across the ice-covered snowy field. There were tears of frustration and exhaustion and my clothes were frozen stiff.</p><p>To get out of the wind, I broke through the icy crust of a high snow bank, dug out a space, and crawled into it. Soon the shivering stopped and there was a delicious warmth, and then a state of peace beyond all description. This was accompanied by a suffusion of light and a presence of infinite love that had no beginning and no end and was undifferentiated from my own essence. The physical body and surroundings faded as my awareness was fused with this all-present, illuminated state. The mind grew silent; all thought stopped. An infinite Presence was all that was or could be, beyond all time or description.</p><p>After that timelessness there was suddenly an awareness of someone shaking my knee; then my father’s anxious face appeared. There was great reluctance to return to the body and all that that entailed, but because my father’s love and anguish, the Spirit nurtured and reactivated the body. There was compassion for his fear of death, although, at the same time, the concept of death seemed absurd.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d9e8d42d4f50" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Com + Passion]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TommyDyer/com-passion-77ad56d34a8b?source=rss-3304f0f0d87a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/77ad56d34a8b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[presence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-love]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[compassion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[acceptance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Covington Dyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 05 Sep 2018 12:54:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-09-08T18:06:22.294Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I was reading a book last night in which the author mentioned the following,</p><blockquote>The only way to enhance one’s power in the world is by increasing ones integrity, understanding and capacity for compassion.</blockquote><p>It made me wonder. Compassion. What the hell is compassion? And more specifically, what is the <em>how</em> of compassion?</p><p>I like <a href="https://www.etymonline.com/">etymologies</a> and so I usually start there assuming that there is some wisdom in the first people who felt like they needed a word for this kind of thing. Compassion’s <a href="https://www.etymonline.com/word/compassion#etymonline_v_17258">etymology</a> isn’t a complicated one. It derives from Latin. The “co” slash “com” that’s <em>com</em>mon in a lot of words means “together” or “with.” Passion, which colloquially means something different to us in everyday speaking originally meant “to suffer.”</p><p>Compassion, then is suffering together. Writ a bit more generally, I see it as a “feeling” together. And writ even a bit more largely, I see it as experiencing together. Where does that leave us if compassion is experiencing/feeling/suffering together? More specifically, if the compassion that’s needed is for our own selfs?</p><p>We’d need to experience, feel, suffer with ourselves? That doesn’t make a whole lot of sense. Our self needs to co-experience, co-feel, co-suffer with our… self? We know how this makes sense to us. Something about it rings true. But. It is pretty confusing. It’s confusing because there are not two of us. Compassion is easier to understand when we’re speaking about “doing” it for or with other people/living things. But when it comes to ourselves what does it mean? How do we do it?</p><p>For me the answer lies in transcending the plane of doing altogether. If you assume a paradigm of focus on three planes, having, doing and being then the how of self-compassion is in being. You start to think about phrases like, presence, actually feeling your feelings, actually experiencing moment to moment… experience. These phrases point to other associations like, breathing, focusing on one’s sensations, “meditating”, stretching.</p><p>These are all great and, I think, 100% necessary for self-compassion. However, there is a spirit of it that is somehow missing. At least in terms of what we typically mean these days when we talk about compassion. One subtle way of capturing it is by saying whatever we’re experiencing is OK. There is a total unconditional acceptance of the experience, feeling or suffering. It’s OK. When we talk about compassion there is meant to be a lack of judgement. A lack of pushing the experience, the feeling, the suffering away. Resisting it. The how of compassion for your self lies somewhere, then in actually experiencing any given experience <em>and</em> just letting it be without any judgement or resistance to it.</p><p>Compassion sounds hard.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=77ad56d34a8b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tangled]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TommyDyer/tangled-ad7abb6bfa0f?source=rss-3304f0f0d87a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ad7abb6bfa0f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bob-dylan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[short-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing-exercise]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[prose]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Covington Dyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 May 2018 21:19:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-13T21:19:42.149Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Note: A piece of short fiction I wrote inspired by Dylan’s <em>Tangled Up in Blue</em></p><p>###</p><p>It was a question of change. But it was also a question of, not a question of, but a feeling of, longing, of the residue of attachment. Of wanting more. Of wondering if something more could be possible. What if it were? What if she knocked on my door later today? What if she knocked on it tangled up in a blue shawl with blue eyes under darkened from red, but with the red color glaring through the dark masking it, hair. I know I want her to. I know that I have wanted her to turn up around every corner I’ve turned, every corner I’ve passed by, for so long. Charlie would never do that. She always moved forward. I seemed to always move backward. If not in my mind at least. What came next in my life always surprised me. Suddenly I was always doing it.</p><p>I rolled out of bed. My feet hit the floor but nothing else did what it was supposed to do. I didn’t really even sit up. Now I was just hunched over. My headache surprised me. It was pungent and powerful. And nauseating. I bet she changed. Man, I tell you everyone changes. If I could open my eyes and look in the mirror I’d see nothing but change. Not that I could tell you how I look right now. I have no idea. I can remember what I look like in certain photographs. Those are all old. Long hair in some of them. Short hair in some of them. I could tell you that based on the different photos. The different times of life. Maybe I had darkened skin, maybe I was pasty. Sometimes I smiled for real, because I forced a fake laugh and sometimes I smiled with sad boredom behind it. I could always tell in the photo. I don’t think most people looking at the photos noticed. I don’t think they looked long enough. I barely looked long enough. I could probably describe those three aspects about myself based on various photos. But right now. I don’t think I’ve seen much sun and I don’t think it’s seen much of me. God knows I’m not smiling. I’m not even about to open my eyes. I don’t even know why I am trying to sit up this early.</p><p>Work.</p><p>Right.</p><p>I didn’t need to finish it just because it was almost done. I wish I hadn’t. I know now I didn’t need anymore.</p><p>Not work. It is Monday. I don’t work today. I didn’t shut the curtains. I can see the sun penetrating my brain, cooking it through translucent eyelids. That is why I’m alive and wondering about Charlie. Colored hair. Moving forward. Not standing on my doorstep. Not knocking. She wouldn’t be knocking. If she knew it were my place, which she wouldn’t, because she would never take the time to track me down, she would just walk in. No questions asked. She’d know she was welcome. Avenue or no. Sidestreet as it was.</p><p>I feel horrible. I think I will never open my eyes again. Who needs them. Seeing is old news. A waste. Of time.</p><p>###</p><p>They didn’t believe in us. I didn’t believe in us. She wasn’t believing much of anything. She needed a change of scenery. They wanted her to never find a change of scenery. They wanted her to always be their scenery. I did too. Everything was wrong. Nothing was right. All wrong. Nothing right. What I was didn’t matter a thing. Who I was even less. I was lucky to be named here and there. It was their loss and the world’s gain. Not mine. Not a surprise to me. It wasn’t oil and water so much as just not even seeing. It was a looking past. A blindness to. They would say things. They didn’t mean them. Passing judgements on clothes passed limp lips that stared. Darts sans target festooned with rhythm. It was nice but, well, where was it to be got? Mmmmm. Rare indeed. Knowing looks all around except at the center. Somehow they knew about every single possession that was owned by me, my father, and my mother. Both of them knew this information so well that they didn’t need to know it. Charlie didn’t agree. She didn’t disagree. Another option might have been just as welcome. Again, it was a matter of scenery. Always a part of it v. some new. Staying v. going. A simple tug-of-war. Momma’s dress and every single one of our possessions was just caught in the middle. The amount of all of our ownings. Wasn’t relevant. It wasn’t the question at hand. It never was. No one cares about things like that. Especially not her folks. It is going to be rough. You too know that, right? Yessss Dad…. Sir. Ok. Yes. We know. Can anyone in the world imagine two people, saying, Hmmm, you know pops? You are right. Not only do we agree that it is going to be rough. It is going to be too rough to even give it a go. We rated our feelings for each other. We really talked things over and we just, well, we just think that you’re right. We are not gonna go through with it. Me, Harry, I, I’m going to go back to school… after I finish school, maybe. And Charlie is going to learn a craft. If we want to still see each other after those specific five years, then, well, we will check back, circle back, and see if this is what we want. Thanks a lot for the level-headed warning. Sensible thinking. Nothing they said meant anything that they wanted or wanted to say. They just wanted their daughter to stay their daughter a little bit longer. That was never going to happen no matter who she was gonna tote along. They just didn’t want to let go. Who invites mourning? Who relishes loss? Who guns for it? I get it. But man what they said really effed us up. It was just words and fear and imminent loss in their world, but to us, well, to me, it was the beginning of the end. It was a while ago now. A while ago for a young man. I just wonder if she’s changed. She must have changed. Her hair will always be red to me though. Maybe even brighter than it ever was.</p><p>###</p><p>We weren’t that far off either. But man was that rain bad. She was driving. I was sleeping. I had driven 15 hours. We switched off. We didn’t talk much. She slept when she wasn’t driving. I can still picture her. Beautiful. Not the most beautiful. But very beautiful. I always drove until I started to fall asleep. Then I’d draw a line somewhere around then those first few dozes and I’d say only three more hours. I wanted those times when I was driving and I could just see her there sleeping to never end. Occasionally she would wake up and smoke. Smile over at me here and there. She’d rest her hand on my headrest and sometimes it’d migrate to the curls on the back of my head. It wasn’t sexual. It wasn’t motherly. It wasn’t anything at all. It was almost devoid of meaning. But it was pure bliss. She would even leave her hand there and doze off. I knew the faster we drove the faster we’d get there. I wasn’t so sure that I wanted to get there. That I wanted to end this trip. It seemed safe here in the car. Lord knows I’ve never been so fucking far away from St. Louis. I’d never dreamed of ever passing through Wheeling. Who did? I know she’d never. Not even a little bit. She knew what road we were on. The highways and stateroads were easy. She’d wake me up if she wasn’t sure where to go. She didn’t know much geography. Neither of us were exactly sure which state we were in most of the time when we were in the dark. We never talked much. It was nice and relaxed. Nobody pressured anyone. We just hung out. Some of the scenery was real pretty. Mostly the weather was rain. It was wet everywhere. The car had that wet, that moist, kind of smell. Without fail. It was like those monsoons that they got in other parts of the world. The drops would hit the windshield, the roof. They would dim the lights. They would dim my eyes. I’d hear a rhythm with the wipers and the shissshh of the tires on the wet road and the cars passing by. Shissshh, Shissshhh! Too close. Passing us. Across the way. Two lane roads. Four lane roads. No barricade. Barricade. Potholes. You avoid them as best as you can. It isn’t easy to do and not wake her up. I was concentrated at the time. It made me even more sleepy. Sometimes I’d miss them. Sometimes I’d hit one that surprised me and I’d look over at her to see if it had woke her up. Sometimes she stirred. She never came to completely though. We eventually hit a big one. It woke both of us up. Most telling was the sound of the flat. Defeat. Rainy defeat. I silently pull over. I open the door. No cars. No nothing. Just flat rain. I got it. I do the do. But I can’t. I give it everything I have. She must have thought it was taking too long. It was. The wrench was tiny. It was slippery. The jack was even smaller. She tried what I had tried. Stomping on it. I told her I had tried all of that. She didn’t think I was a complete idiot did she? That, with a slippery wrench I wouldn’t try pushing on it with all of what god gave me? Strange to me even now. We needed to think. Not play games. I tried to think. The rain came down. I told her to get in the car. She was going to get sick. The rain wasn’t cold. But it was thorough. Complete. Almost. She was drenched as she stood up and got back in the car. I finished the job up. I broke it. But we were so close. Just a little bit longer. She had loosened it, I think. Stronger than she looks I guess. I got back in and said thanks.</p><p>###</p><p>I don’t know why I even butted in. What compelled me to go? I was way too scared. I was no hero. I had tried time after time to save myself. It always came up the same. Same shit every time. It never worked. Back on track this time. There was something in her scream. Her howls. Her sob. Maybe I just saw one tear too many. Maybe it wasn’t even the quality of it. Night after night. It would grate on anyone. I couldn’t figure why she stayed. I think I even remember crying once just listening. It was months of cowardice. I had my own shit going on. What the fuck was I thinking about someone else for? Just a big old mess of red. No. It wasn’t the quantity. It wasn’t the months on end. It wasn’t even me or my shit or my depths. It wasn’t even the filth that I was living in at the time. There are no pictures of me then. I know what I looked like. The only time I really looked in the mirror for real. You know. And remembered what I saw. Good god. Just a big hairy piece of shit. It wasn’t even all of that. It wasn’t even looking at myself in the mirror. It was Jesus or Vishnu, or rage, or something mystical. Something holy like the primality of being about to throw up. You know people have been throwing up since before they birthed the gods. Ancient like time. Unthinking. Sad. I heard this one little pebble, this corner in her voice. A second dimension. Everything went silent and holy from there. I walked down the hall sober as the day I was born in a new kind of way and all I remember is buzzzzzzzz… I was there. I wasn’t there. He was there. He wasn’t there. Then there was just a big mess of red.</p><p>Someone must have called the cops. The buzz never really turned into the sirens. It did turn into tears. They matched hers maybe. Tears triggered by tears. By fear. What the fuck was I thinking? She was in the corner I think. I couldn’t hear the sirens. I knew about them. I welcomed them. I was sitting in a big smelly chair. I couldn’t smell it though. I think I might have been looking at her. She didn’t know I was there.</p><p>It was some jam. And we were so young. How did we end up in that same hell hole of a place? Maybe her parents didn’t want me involved. But damn if they only fucking knew. Thank god they don’t. I don’t even know if she knows anymore. I doubt she remembers her screams. I know I remember them. I remember them and I can hear them through the ears of every single one of the people in that building. Each one was the end of the world. Everyone was the end of the marriage. I didn’t really do anything. The choice wasn’t mine. It was just wild. I’m nauseous now just thinking about all the red splashes in that place. She stayed with me for a while after that. I guess that is when we started to know each other.</p><p>###</p><p>How we made it that far I have no idea. We made it so far. Way beyond anyone would have thought given a fateful start. She knew it. She saw it in her own eyes. Lord knows I knew it. I felt it deep down. It had been a couple days. That town was the smallest I’d ever seen. They only make towns that small in no name western states. They even made movies about them with horses and guns but they stayed smaller than ever. Garages. Gas stations. Pissing places. Sometimes that is all they had. Those things and a house for the family that worked the place. It wasn’t the perfect place. But it was as far as we got. There is nothing darker than a town like that. I’ll never go back to a town like that. Nothing but dark. Clouds. Dust. Blacks out the sun most days. It did at least everyday we were there. Granted it wasn’t long. We made it a little bit farther than that town. We agreed to not abandon that sad car right in front of everyone. We drove it down the road some.</p><p>I don’t know how she did it. She convinced me of it. She knew I was no idiot. But somehow she almost had me figured better than I did. And somehow we weren’t young anymore either. Everything mixed together. And that was it. We had reached the end of the road. The jig was up. She called it quits with me. We together said, OK. But I didn’t feel it. I knew it. I knew she knew it and I knew she felt it. But I didn’t feel it. It wasn’t so sad a night for her that night. One thing we both knew and felt was that I was the embodiment of that last night for her. For us. Me too. The buzz never went away. The sirens never went away. The red never went away. It was all just a little farther in the mirror but it was like a horizon that just kept expanding. The moon never actually set back there. It was back there and you could see it. But you could always see it. No matter how far you drove.</p><p>We couldn’t shake that night. I wanted to. There wasn’t anything I wanted more. Like I said, I’d never be able to save myself. But man it felt like I actually succeeded when I barged in to her life that night. Those first nights together I felt like I had it figured. Shit made a bit more sense. I couldn’t figure out what I had been thinking, but I could figure that seeing her everyday made more sense than looking at myself doubtfully in the mirror all alone. We made it from that mirror where I had put up a picture of she and I, her in a short dress, all the way East and nearly all the way West. But we never really stopped anywhere. We never sat down. We never found that place. That buzzing never stopped for me. It replaced the hole and her half smiles replaced my long lonely stares, but eventually we had to call it quits in a one room town. That sad car was done too. Shit just comes and goes I guess.</p><p>###</p><p>She walked one way. I walked another. She was gonna hitchhike. I was gonna stay one more night. I’d guessed she’d head west. Keep on in the same direction. I couldn’t head there with her. Behind her. I could follow her in a few days when I didn’t know where she’d be or what she would be doing. I wasn’t going to stalk her, track her down. I wasn’t silly like that. Besides I had agreed to it too. The buzzing was still there as I walked down the road. It was way back there in my head at that point. It almost receded a bit as I walked. I knew when I agreed I was agreeing to something like relief. Something like silence.</p><p>I can’t believe she finally had anything to say. Did she want to meet again? No. I really didn’t think so. I didn’t think I wanted to either. I wanted her. She was mine. But we had agreed. There wasn’t anything to it really. I kept walking. I kept my head forward. I kept my face stuck. I made my arms stop moving. I put my feet on the ground. Each one. A car drove by. Someday. And why not now? Cause of time. It goes in all of these circles. These imperfect loops. Looping back to tangents that are totally different than the ones they were before. New rivers. Nothing twice. I lit a cigarette. I hadn’t tasted one in a long time. There it was. I tasted it. It was different.</p><p>Just like me. I kept my head up. Almost like I was gazing at the stars. Foot. Feet. Steps. Dark. Breaths of smoke. That is how I could tell I was still breathing. She was going to go on. Keep heading west or south. I could see the sun in her red blue eyes. It always reflected. I went back to where we stayed. She headed on to Santa Fe. Maybe even Reno. Who knows. Hitchhike with someone even more off than I am. Maybe even hairier. They’d smoke together for hours and he’d never make her drive. She’d sleep and watch the sun do its thing across the sky. I’ll go back and finish that bottle. It’ll be empty for this feeling and this buzzing…</p><p>###</p><p>It was the farthest north I’d ever been. I didn’t even want to go. I didn’t want to go that far north and I didn’t want to go that far west. I didn’t want to go that far at all. When you’re not your own driver you don’t have much choice. No car. No change. You go where the wind of the land blows you. Land sailing. You end up in swirls and eddies and circle back to the same places. Some you love. Some you just don’t. I just didn’t dig it up there. Why do people even live that far up north? I’d never been. I won’t go back. Usually when you hitchhike you have an idea of where you’re going and you talk about it with the driver. It is in all kinds of movies. “You going to Rapid City?” “Even farther, hop in.” A two line interchange. If they happen to be talkers or more than one person, if there is more than one you almost always have to talk, then you have to talk even more. But if they aren’t. Those two lines at the start and the two lines when you part are all you need. You might as well speak different languages. Sometimes, you can get lucky, you don’t have to talk because no one makes you talk and so you sit there in silence for hours on end. But if it is a good person. Like a deeply good person. You still share plenty. Maybe it is one laugh at someone passing and both of you get it. Maybe it is some of the colors in the sky or the trees at the end of the day. And you just happen to both not be lost in thought as you pass them by and you both just happen to see them and appreciate them at the same time. And you know the other person is there with you and thinks they are beautiful too and you know they know you think so and they think so too. And they too, know you think so. Round and round it goes in a spiral that relates you two together. Not in any real or spoken way. Just in a real and deep and silent kind of way. Those were the only kinds of people I wanted to be around then. Quiet ones that still shared with you. Quiet ones that you still understood and that understood moments with you. Well I rode north with one of them like that. Don’t even know his name. Don’t want to know it. I slept. We ate. We went far. I didn’t want to go that far, but I had no reason not to. Once I could feel I had overstayed my welcome I headed on on my own. I just walked that last part of the way. Trees everywhere. Roads like tunnels. It wasn’t for me but it sure was beautiful. I’m not that opposed to the place.</p><p>Off the road, backing up to a small river there was this all wood spot that had a sign saying “EATS”. I thought it’d said “EAST” at first glance. Where I kinda wanted to be going really, but just didn’t have the courage to so I went in. It was a dirty and simple place. A real place. I knew it right away. It had cushiony, fabric-backed, checkered tablecloths. I sat down at a table and “Angela” dropped a menu at my table with a near smile. I propped myself up on the table. I didn’t open the menu. My feet were tangled up under the table. She came over and poured me a coffee I hadn’t asked for. I looked like I’d needed it I’m sure. It had been a haul. She gazed outside. Her eyebrows raised wondering how I’d gotten there. I nodded to her. She and I both knew how I’d gotten there. I ordered some toast and she scurried off. I slowly moved my elbows forward and half buried my head in them. Like when you’re swimming and your nose is just above water. No one was there. A radio played. It was peaceful but creepy. A space meant for people with no one in it. Maybe it was late or early.</p><p>When I finished the toast and the coffee I asked her for a job. She asked me if I did drugs and I said no. I was just tired and I had been traveling. She asked me when I could start and I said in a few minutes. She said, it sounded like I could have made my own toast. I made a lot of toast after that. I reckon it might have been a year I was there cooking. Toast. Eggs. Hamburgers. The same shit on the same grill. Everything smelled the same as it was cooking. Everything tasted the same when it was cooked. Sometimes I’d see through my little window the same people come in day after day. Ange would chat and talk and blither and blather away. She hated me. I think from when I showed up till when I left. I can’t explain it but I really think she did. It doesn’t matter. She was crazy the whole time. I’d do exactly as asked and she’d really give it to me the whole time thinking that she was out of earshot of the eaters. She never was. Nothing in ten miles was out of earshot of that voice. One day I told her to just stop. That was the day I walked out of there. It didn’t go over well. I barely broke even.</p><p>###</p><p>Sometimes guys would dock at the back of the place and then eat and head down river or back up home. They’d disappear behind the thick trees and be gone in a minute. I could see them from the kitchen window. Regular guys it seemed. I had no idea where they came from or where they were going. Maybe it was far. Which was my plan. Get far. When I walked out of there I walked down the road. But I circled back because I’d decided it was the best and most interesting way to get anywhere. I didn’t really know where I was and I didn’t really know which way the river would go. I went back there anyways and just sat. I was watching the waters and every so often someone would come on down and untie and head off or they’d dock and head in. I picked one that seemed more or less harmless. He had on no shoes and a shirt unbuttoned completely. He said he’d take me down river a ways since I didn’t know my way or where I wanted to go. He didn’t know and couldn’t understand that I was heading farther than he could dream. Father than he had ever thought. Days passed before he said he wasn’t going to go any farther. I was ready anyways. He wasn’t the kind of person who got things. Just dim. Just zero. Another guy helped me keep on going. Another guy after that. Some Jims. Some Hucks. All solo. All loving the company and hating it. Not knowing what to do with it. I wasn’t really company anyways. I didn’t care. Just sat there thinking and watching the river go by most days. The rivers just kept getting bigger it seemed. Wider. Faster. Busier. Then you got to start to seeing ships. Almost actual sea ships. Not small at all. They’d stare at us and not understand us. We were irrelevant. I was.</p><p>You could smell New Orleans before you could see it. It wasn’t no ordinary place. It drawed us in. We could see it. Highfalutin’ people walking on wood. Couples. We just let it go by. We were right on time. We stopped at a dock and I said I was thankful and that I’d be moving on. He just nodded. Easy. Breezes floated by and the New Orleans smell dissipated. I put my back to the dock and walked. I found myself around millions of boats and fishermen. I asked a couple if they were fishermen. Some of them said yes. Some of them said no. I kept moving through them until one made sense to me. I asked someone on the boat if they were hiring. We shoved off every morning earlier than hell. I slept whenever I could. Worked long days. I stayed just near the boat. There wasn’t much more than a shack. We ate some of what we caught. The Captain cooked it. Some smaller guy shoveled the bits of fish on a plate with some other critters. Not much happened. Quiet place. Good place. Not an inch of cold to bother you by. Better that way.</p><p>###</p><p>It seemed it had been a long time since. I had known some others since. Mostly on leave around New Orleans. Never made me do much. Never made me think much. I just felt it more. One named Cat sat around on her porch smoking a big funky water pipe. A real elaborate thing. Had music on all the time. Sat there splayed out smoking, taking sun. For hours. We met at the unofficial bar she ran in the backyard. After midnight hours some of the boys headed there. They all wanted her. No idea how I ended up staying there as much as I did. Just an easier place to crash I guess. Sometimes I’d sit out there on the porch with her. I’d try not to look at her. Try not to watch her. I always just wondered what she was thinking. Not much passed between us. I never felt more solo than I did on that porch of hers. I felt like I was in a distant land and that we could be communicating only by letters. Letters that traveled weeks before arriving. She wasn’t beautiful. She’d draw you in and then always left you there hanging. At the perfect distance. That was where you found the silence. Your silence. You’d sit there in your mind and slowly, slowly, numbly poke around. I almost found nothing in those days. It had been a while since. Somehow, I always fucking found her though. That fucking mess of red. She’d be curled up somehow. Somewhere. I’d be sitting there with a nothing kind of silence and then there she’d be, around the corner. Quietlike. She’d smile halfly like she knew my thoughts. Seeing herself there in my head. Maybe we were still connected in some way. Maybe she still thought of me. Of course she thought of me. But maybe she didn’t think much of me. Just like I didn’t. Maybe she thought of me blankly. Weakly. I wondered where she was. I wondered if I still loved her. People would pass the porch on the street and I’d think they’d seen her before. I wanted to ask them if I still loved her. Maybe they knew. Maybe they’d seen the answer in her eyes. They’d think I was crazy, but maybe, just maybe they’d know. ’Cause I wasn’t sure.</p><p>###</p><p>Somebody at the house went there often. He talked about all the girls. A little too loudly. Always a little too loudly. He knew some of them by name. He’d go with some of the regulars and they’d come back late, drunk and rearing to go. I could always hear them. Sometimes I’d stay just above the bar there on a mattress on the ground that smelled like tar. A lot of the time I couldn’t sleep so I’d lay there smoking and looking out over some of the buildings. You could see stars fairly well for having a city nearby. You could see a lot of planes flying in and out full of tourists. I’d just breathe and watch it and vaguely listen to the hooligans out back. That was when I heard him talking about her. I knew it was her before he’d said her name. I don’t know what it was. Preemptive. He was talking about her hair, but lots of women have hair like hers. Kind of.</p><p>I showed up one night. She was there. Working when I walked in. She didn’t see me. I had a couple beers and sat there on the side. It was busy. I bet she made good money. She looked the part. Played the part. She was dead behind the eyes. Passed out awake. Done. I couldn’t believe I could see her there. Right before me. The light caught her face. I stared. I saw what she was doing but it was lost on me. I remembered too many things. So much flooded back. She was beautiful. I slumped in my chair. Leaned my head against the wall. I just surrendered completely. She danced slowly. Deliberately. I wondered where she’d picked up these moves. This gig. She must need it bad. I bet she lives nearby too. I wonder if I’ve seen her. If she’s passed me on the street and didn’t say anything. Maybe. I’d have said something. What I would have said I don’t know. God save me if I have to come up with something to say to her. We never did talk all that much.</p><p>###</p><p>I started thinking that I had nothing to say to her. I think about her every day for what felt like forever. And now I’m done. I’ve seen it all. I watched a few other girls dance. They were pros. Dead behind the eyes too. One of them was a long way gone. She knew the steps well though. Got a lot from the boys at the front. A seasoned pro. I paid a little attention. I came and went. Sometimes just watching my bottle get emptier and emptier. I’d look at my hands too weathered for me take the beer to my lips. I don’t know why I was there then. I’d seen her. I’d had my reaction. Inertia I guess. That point in the circle, in the pendulum that looks like it could be at rest, like it could be there forever. But it’s nowhere for long. No motion. Just the hair on my hands. Emptier bottles of beer. Her. It was late. It was getting near morning. She didn’t come on the floor again. Guys started to leave. My inertia stayed me. I was there but I wasn’t. I wanted to go too. I didn’t want to go back to the bar. Not to my shack. Not to the boat. I wasn’t hungry. I wasn’t homeless. I wasn’t lost. I wasn’t anywhere. And I had nowhere to be. Nowhere to go. So that is where I went. Nowhere was fine with me. Walk. Move. Forward. Breathe. I was ready.</p><p>My feet moved. My knees bent. I lifted myself off the seat with the table, the back of my chair and my hands and arms. It was an effort. I weighed a thousand pounds. My feet were heavy. I reached for my cigarettes resuming an old habit when I heard her. When was the last time she’d said anything to me? Something about an avenue? No idea. Her talking to me was back again. Echoing through years of what ifs. I could see every second of my wonder about her in discrete blocks piling up. Spilling over. Yeah. It’s me I say. When was the last time I’d talked to her. Did I ever? I lit my cigarette. My hands shook. No good reason. But it was just too surreal. Too not real at all. Halfsmiles all around. Another drink at another bar. We both looking ahead. Wondering if we’d changed much. Thinking about nights on the road. Dark goodbyes. Old smells. My hands stopped shaking a little. I noticed when I lit another cigarette. I looked over at her. She was staring straight ahead saying something about how she got so far south. She was as calm as the day was long. She was lost in what she was saying. The light shone off her face. Beautiful. So. Beautiful. My hands weren’t shaking but somewhere towards my center and closer to my elbows too, I was still shaking. I’d been that way since I’d decided to come. I didn’t have any idea. I was so tired of it.</p><p>###</p><p>She finished and I said something I don’t know what and half-smiled. She nodded. She looked at me. I am almost completely sure that she had never done so before that moment. She looked relaxed as she looked at me in the face like someone looks someone up and down. Maybe she even saw me in my eyes. In fact. No one had ever looked at me and saw me in my eyes. Not that I cared much. I was there and side by side and present with people. That was always calm. But I never saw. I was never seen. That shaking down closer to my elbows, to my middle gave way. I couldn’t tell if I was shaking so completely that I just stopped. But something changed. It wasn’t easy to experience. I know what my face looked like then. Lined, grey, sleepless, sunned, taught, with an almost mean, skeptical look. I must have looked constipated. I tell you I was lost in the moment. The bar was closed. She was done looking at me. And the fact is, the whole time she looked at me, saw me, I could not for the life of me look back. See her back. I did, but it didn’t register. I was too busy not knowing the hell was happening. I was too unsettled by this incredibly strange first. It was too much and we unlocked. A few feet apart. We both looked down. Still breathing. We both saw my laces untied. I was immediately embarrassed. She didn’t notice. She just tied them. Both of them.</p><p>###</p><p>We never decided to go to her place. We were talking, silent in fits and starts. We were there and sitting in her kitchen. I could sit at her kitchen table and put my feet up on her countertop. I did. I had sobered up by now. She pulled this beaded chain on an out-of-place green lamp on the kitchen table. We both were suffused though it was barely on.</p><p>She was talking to me about this joint she had worked in after the last time I saw her. She was a cocktail waitress. She loved it. It was her first job apparently. She’d never done anything on her own. It made me feel good for some reason. I didn’t know she was doing well after we parted ways, but I had met her at her lowest of lows and after we left, she was on solid ground. Made me realize I hadn’t been on solid ground since… I don’t know when. If I’m truthful, maybe I never was.</p><p>I started to breathe more slowly. Things slowed down for me. I started to feel a relaxation that was strange. She took out a match, flicked the burner on and lit it then let a pipe that she handed to me. It was damp and smooth and easy. I handed it back to her. She wondered aloud to me, about me, if I was gonna say hello or just stay silent. She kept talking but I started daydreaming. I wondered myself. I think I was ready to see her and just walk off. Close the loop. Close the loop and let go. What would talking/reconnecting do? What would it add? How can I wonder this while I am sitting here listening to her and smoking? Never say hello? I never actually did say hello. I just turned around in my chair to the sound of her voice.</p><p>The sound that lulled and listed in my ears at the moment.</p><p>Turns out it adds a lot.</p><p>###</p><p>It wasn’t easy paying attention to what she was saying. She never checked to see if I was paying attention. She wasn’t paying attention to my paying attention. I guess I could tell. And then, of course, she did. She said, you know? And I said, what do you mean? She grew ever so slightly frustrated. She was clearly trying to get some idea across. There was a bit of passion underneath the frustration. What the hell was she trying to say? Why? She doesn’t care that I don’t get it. She is more just trying to say some very specific thing. The antidote. The silver bullet. The one true answer was on the tip of her tongue. The fire was in her eyes. And she was trying to tell it to me. But. Not.</p><p>Finally she ran away. Past me. Behind me. Over my shoulder. Around the corner. Into her bedroom. Ruffled around in some things. Made some inaudible sounds. Breathed loudly. Scampered back to our table. Plopped down with a sigh. Underneath the light of the green lamp she open up this book towards me. All I could see was the green light. All I could smell was the age of the book through the smoke.</p><p>I blinked my eyes a few times to try to begin to read. I thought I’d humor her and start paying attention. I wasn’t figuring anything out on my own. The brambles in my mind lead nowhere. On one page it was Italian. On the other it was English. I started reading, mouthing the words that started by where her finger pressed the page. I read immensely slowly. My silence and my speed were clearly not OK with her. She turned the book towards her and started reading aloud. Beautifully. Words ringing. Off of every page. She didn’t read too softly, too slowly. Perfectly.</p><p>###</p><p>Infernal noises from her refrigerator were the only ties I had to something real and mundane while she read to me. Most else seemed to melt away. Numbed away. I think I was sipping some tea. Maybe the tea was hers. A bachic muse. She read afire. She might not even have been reading. It is possible that she had written the lines. Memorized them, at least. Loved them, definitely. This was love. That was clear. I could see the relief she was experiencing finally being able to communicate what she’d been trying to just moments before.</p><p>I couldn’t tell you what she was trying to say. She couldn’t either these days. That much is for sure. Whatever it was, it was true. Bright and true. So clear to me. It was like a little taste of Buddhic enlightenment. I remember a feeling of truly knowing something. A really intense relaxation came with it. Through this buzzing in the back of my head that buzzed my entire life, I heard a bit of silence. What she was reading was so deeply true. Not only did I get it, but I got what she had been saying when I wasn’t paying attention just before. Through the fog of memory, there it was. I could see what lit her up so much. What she was trying to say.</p><p>But she wasn’t trying to say anything to me. That is what got me. It wasn’t intimate. It was isolated. Governed by the laws of the universe we floated around each other like planets. In relationship but totally and completely separate and not one. Trains passing in the night. Dying alone after a 50 year marriage. Men as islands. I had been to this place before and it always, always brought an intolerable sadness with it. But this time, I was seeing it in a greenly lit light. It was clear to me that it wasn’t sad. It was true. And it was beautiful. This wasn’t what she was saying or reading to me. Like I said, I don’t remember that anymore. But I am certain that knowing this was what illuminated her before she read to me and as she read whatever she read. It poured. It rained. And it was burned into my soul. That floating whatnot of mine. From hers to mine. Across an impossibly real chasm.</p><p>###</p><p>It took some time. A strange series of events. No need to go into them. She and I stayed connected. Not in the old way. In a sidenote kind of way. She moved and I joined. She had a roommate and I joined. It was all new to me. It was all where I had been heading, been trying to get to but didn’t know. It was the street. A perfect place of wild fetid imperfection. Greats played down the street. Sounds wafted out of windows and doors. In many ways the scene was the same as it was in every other spot I landed for a time. I’d sit there at the window smoking. Sometimes I’d have a chair. Other times a mattress. Most of the time nothing. But the sounds this close to the East River, the buildings of Walt’s early life, it all fit, hinged together with my burning flame resting on the window.</p><p>They were never there. I didn’t even leave that often. Too enchanted by what I always saw out. My beard grew long. The winter set in. I warmed myself with nothing. There was nothing that worked. We were below the street. Not even the sun shone down to warm my pale hands. Maybe the music warmed me.</p><p>I didn’t leave too, because, a bit was going on in those days. People weren’t happy with each other. She always had a lot to say about it. He did too. I didn’t think they were wrong. Just too passionate. Not real passion either. Using the passion. Whatever was in the air they used it to cover over their shit. I saw it and knew it well. I don’t know why I didn’t try to ever cover over my shit. The revolution sounded fun. I could never muster much for it in the end. They would perform their tirades at ever higher pitches cause they knew I was in earshot. What I thought mattered to them. Just not in any real way. I don’t know what I thought. If I’d have met someone that really cared, maybe that would have changed things for me. Who knows though.</p><p>###</p><p>Like I suspected though, he wasn’t right inside. Long ass fucking trips to nowhere. She’d bite her nails the whole time he was gone. He’d have endless money on short ass visits. We’d go up to the street and blow all of it in less than a weekend. They’d stopped covering their shit with politics. Not a lick of revolution concerned them those years. Just booze and drugs and death. A dark dearth in his eyes; a sad dim light in hers. I watched it all, took it all in. He had wild stories. Boars. Wars. Diseases and wild peoples. I could never look at him. Turned my stomach. I grew numb to him. A dark dearth of life. Bloodless. Completely bloodless is what I pictured. What I knew.</p><p>His visits grew more and more infrequent. I’d remember occasionally that he was due to come back every so often and I’d cringe. Nobody wants to go to a cafe with a dead man. Thing was. He usually brought months and months of rent when he did show. And we needed it. Without, we struggled. She started selling shit she had accumulated over her decades. We’d be sitting there smoking and she’d start wistfully telling me about this random object of hers. Some of her shit was actually fascinating. How she came to have it. Worth a lot too. Then we’d drift off talking about the old days. Nostalgia begat nostalgia. I’d forget about it. Then I’d inevitably never see it again. Her shit dwindled. I’d never see it again but it never really registered. I knew it was how we got rent. But man, I just didn’t pay attention really.</p><p>Because at some point we didn’t have no more rent. I realized that was it. She had nothing left. Dead of winter. I had little to add to the mix. He never showed again. No word. No visits. She rarely left. I knew some people nearby that we used to know. They helped for a bit. But no one wanted any part of her. Like they wanted no part of the winter that year. Colder than it had ever been. She barely registered it. She was used to it before it came.</p><p>###</p><p>At some point. Some miraculous moment, I heard some birds chirping. They must have been some cold ass birds. But they were a sign. The firsts of the firsts. Sunlight came a bit later. Easier to smoke out the window. In silence.</p><p>With the sun she went out more. Came back less. Her face never seemed to change except for a weak smile of a greeting. A really, really beautiful sad smile. I sometimes wonder if she ever saw herself. Saw her like I saw her in those in between moments. I wonder if she ever felt it. It’s possible.</p><p>With the sun and the bird chirps came actual human beings doing things and in the streets. There was no telling when it was all gonna finalize. When the shoe would drop. I spent months worried about it. All through the dark and cold and smoke. And the tears she seemed to forget to cry.</p><p>It had been days since I’d seen her. Everytime she was gone for days I assumed I’d never see her again. One day when I was out I came back to our beds on the street and bags of trash and commercial locks on chains on the doors. I leaned against the wall outside the apartment. Finished my cigarette. Felt the sunlight on my face. I scratched at my beard. It was warming up but the chill of the winter was still deep inside me. It was a feeling that I’d never get warm again. I camped out by that place for a few nights. She never popped back.</p><p>I started walking after those nights. No hard feelings. None of it was easy. I’d seen her in the most unlikely places. Time goes in those circles like that. I knew I had to get somewhere hot. Somewhere sweaty. And just keep going.</p><p>###</p><p>It was a question of necessity. That hapless mother of invention. Mother of motion. Force. No choice. Centrifugal motion. I’m sitting in paradise. Easiest fucking place to sit. Alice doesn’t notice me. Gazes past me like I’m a post holding up the ceiling. Been there for years like she has. Too easy. Nothing acts on you. The sun melts your brains and ambitions. Not that I ever had any.</p><p>Except for one.</p><p>I can’t not. We used to know millions of people. We’d meet people here and there. They’d know us inside and out. We’d have stories that never ended. Revolutions came and went. Pains and issues came and went. We’d party. We’d travel. We’d been everywhere, if not together, at least one or the both of us had been there. Seen it. Knew it. I can remember it in spite of the sunny mush that the Keys had made of my brain. If I had wanted to I could write a history of us longer than Rome’s. People and places and ups and downs. Names and dates. All of it. Dense. Deep time. Not a lot of it, but time passed deeply for us. Maybe that was why I knew the necessity of it. Or maybe it was because I could write it all down, tees crossed, i’s dotted but every single person still seemed like an illusion to me. Vague. They were players playing the same age old roles. The ones that history repeats because history is lazy. History or all of us. Godknows I am.</p><p>It was different when it was she and I in the same room. The same space. It was different when we were in each other’s stories at the moment. It wasn’t even like time slowed down. It was just bigger. Had more force. More élan. It went subterranean. I had to get back to that. Yeah to her, but to that. The one that wasn’t an illusion. Maybe it wasn’t a question of necessity, maybe it was a question of reality. I know it was all reality. Everyone had their own stories. I ran through them. My arc touched theirs tangentially. But my arc ran right through hers and I didn’t even want it to. And I could feel it heading right through hers again watson and crick style. I had to get back. Not back in time. Back somehow. Back in a way no one ever had gotten back before. I needed to get back inside it all. So now I’m going to.</p><p>###</p><p>Maybe the illusions of people were more important than I give them credit for. Maybe they were necessary. Maybe they were reality. Maybe they all knew that. That they were a part of our dance through time, at least at that moment. They were all kinds of people. They did all the same things that people do with their lives and have done with their lives since the beginning. Since they wrote books about them that were called “Book”. They begat gods and laws of gods’ domains. They can’t be doing the same things they have always done. But what else could they be doing. They are not, were not ghosts. They mattered. All of those people from our pasts, our stories. They had to matter. They had to still be going.</p><p>I wonder what they do. I wonder what they think. Can it be different from what I think? If I am the same, and I must be, of necessity. I am me, the same one since we met and before we met. So it must be with all the others that passed through, that passed us by on their ways. I wonder if they are still even living. I wonder if some of them are even dying. Anything goes. Alice has been here in this bar since time began circling and still stares out of the windows toward the water. But not everyone stays put like Alice. But maybe inside they do. Maybe they just change place and Alice is the exception.</p><p>Why are we moving around at all? I’ve been so many places with Charlie, inside and out. What if we just sat there in silence or talking and just breathed and knew that that was it? Maybe we’d look back and know it wasn’t ever all that bad, that we never needed to go so far so often.</p><p>Alice tops me off. I see her and her hand through the smoke and the now dimmed light. The sun setting, she waits until the very dark before she turns the lights on. I’m the only one here and so it doesn’t matter. Neither does her silence. I’m just passing through. We both know that. Everyone is just passing through the Keys even if it lasts years and years. The south beyond the south. We seem to all be looking north. Feeling like everyone up there remembers us vaguely while we want to be remembered for real. Seen again. Seen through the smoke. Seen in the pitch dark. Seen as real.</p><p>###</p><p>I drink half that drink. I flick my cigarette. I need to. Something inside has clicked. The switch has been flipped. Half the drink I leave for the illusions. A libation to the gods. To lives well-lived. Nights well-loved. A gesture to the constant rotations. The least I can do.</p><p>It will protect me on my road back. It needs to. It’s got to. On to another joint.</p><p>I know exactly where I am going. So does Alice. So does Charlie. She knows the hour has struck on our deep clock. The hand has whipped around again. Somehow I’ll run into her again. I know it. I will keep moving. So will she. It is a dance strung out over a thousand miles and ten thousand years. A waltz or something. Our hands and arms and fingers entangled in a way we don’t understand like action at a distance. Magnetism in our veins.</p><p>It was right when it was right and was right when it was wrong. We always felt that and knew that. And knew the other knew that and felt that. We wanted to dance the dance regardless. Pour the libation regardless of whether we wanted the rest of the drink or not. Better that way. We saw that. And we saw that differently. We both saw a million ways to honor that. She had her own way. I had mine. Hers constantly moving forward, mine, well, I punched through the depths backwards on the same arc. Totally different directions. But our tangents always kissed. And that always brought life to our lives. We always needed that life. Something clicked, and I got to get back to that. Maybe she does too.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ad7abb6bfa0f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Convo]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/a-conversation-about-conversation/tangled-885ac8f24aa0?source=rss-3304f0f0d87a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/885ac8f24aa0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[conversations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[how-to]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[exploratory]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Covington Dyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 May 2018 21:18:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-13T21:22:29.976Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>PK: What have you been thinking about lately?</p><p>PB: Conversation. Really, to be honest, I’ve been thinking about conversation and reading books about conversation for a really long time. Maybe since 2009? Maybe even 2008… But really maybe even earlier than that. When I was in high school and liking the classes that were conversational and bored by the classes that weren’t, it was probably on my mind. And then I chose to go to an undergrad that only had classes that were conversational. So I must have had it on my mind as a thing since then. So really, back to 2002. But that first conversational class started in 1999. I’m pretty sure I have those years right.</p><p>PK: You’re telling me you’ve been thinking about conversation nonstop for 16 or 17 years?</p><p>PB: Yeah. But. My thinking about it became a bit more focused around a year and half ago. It went from being in the background. Or maybe even not yet articulated as an interest or topic until then. Although. Maybe I should take that back. One of my favorite books I’ve read in the last ten years is a book called Dialogue: The Art of Thinking Together. That book has been a pretty big influence on my thinking. It really opened things up. And the first time I read that was maybe 2008? Maybe 2009?</p><p>PK: So you became aware of conversation as a thing around 2000. 2008 you read a book about dialogue, which I’m assuming is the same thing as conversation to you? And then in 2015 you started thinking about it in a more focused way? Do I have that right?</p><p>PB: That’s right. It’s been a journey. SO many thoughts.</p><p>PK: You know. I think about conversation too.</p><p>PB: Yeah? What do you think about conversation?</p><p>PK: I don’t know. That I like conversation. Conversing that there are a lot of conversations. That I like some people because of the conversations we have. That I really wonder if certain people can even have good conversations at all. And then I feel bad after I wonder that…</p><p>PB: What if there were a whole group of people. A whole type out there. People that just had a gene that kept them from having great conversations? That’d be crazy, right?</p><p>PK: I don’t think… well. I don’t know. Sometimes I really wonder about some people. But then I also wonder how biased I am.</p><p>PB: You have a mental model of what a good conversation is and you assume that some people don’t have that kind of conversation. Right? That’s your bias?</p><p>PK: Right. Maybe they have conversations that they think are good. Good. Great. Bad. Poor. Meh. They’re all subjective judgements.</p><p>PB: They are. And that is what changed for me and my thinking about conversation more recently. I asked a couple of friends, “What’s the best conversation you’ve ever had?” Ultimately, it’s a weirdly worded question, but you get the intention. It really got me daydreaming. What if you sat down for an hour with, say, 10,000 people. People across tons of cultures, classes, races, ages, genders, sexes, lifestyles, whatever, and you asked them a better worded version of that question? Say, “Describe for me a really great conversation you’ve had. Maybe it’s the best ever, but it doesn’t have to be. Just try and describe for me one that you really loved. That wowed you.” And then what if all of those people had perfect memories and actually could answer the question and provide lots of objective and subjective details…. What patterns would you find? What would be the common thread among all of these subjectively-judged “great conversations”. And not only that, what would be the commonalities in various clusters? Would certain ages see a different “great”? Would certain economic classes end up describing the same kinds of conversations? Asking those friends that question got me going on this thought experiment…</p><p>PK: I would love to do that. Listen to a ton of people talk about conversations that they loved.</p><p>PB: Me too! So that’s what I started doing. I was in between jobs so I started asking people if they’d sit down with me for a recorded conversation exploring this question. I convinced 12 friends and acquaintances to spend around an hour with me on average. Then I transcribed the conversations. Then I took notes. Now I’m trying to digest them and read up on other research on the topic. I’m not finding a lot though. I might be a terrible researcher but I also might be asking a strange enough question that it’s not been explored that much yet. That’d be hard to believe, though.</p><p>PK: It’s true. “There is nothing new under the sun,” as the Good Book says. But, how’d these conversations go? What’d you learn? What were the patterns or themes?</p><p>PB: I don’t know. I mean at the end of the day it was really just 12 people. A small sample size. Not the 10,000 that I’d love to have done. But that would take a lifetime. And really, even after so few, some interesting points did come up.</p><p>PK: Like what?</p><p>PB: Like what the hell is a conversation anyways? Hahaha</p><p>PK: Ha! That’s probably a good thing to cover. As you go down this path.</p><p>PB: No kidding.</p><p>PK: So what’s the answer then? You must have some sort of stance at this point.</p><p>PB: I’ve started developing one. But it takes a while to get it all out…</p><p>PK: Well, I’ve got nothing but time…</p><p>PB: Ha, right. Well, one way I’ve been thinking about the question, “What’s a conversation anyways?” is what isn’t a conversation. There’s this medieval Jewish theologian and philosopher that’s famous for defining God by what He is not as opposed to what he is. I think it’s a fun game to play.</p><p>PK: OK. So what isn’t a conversation then?</p><p>PB: You get into a bit of semantics with this question. Lexical semantics apparently. I just had to look it up.</p><p>PK: I’m not familiar.</p><p>PB: It’s a branch that studies word meanings and word relations. I say you get into it here because you get into a lot of subjective back and forths. For example, I think that some things might be “conversational” but not a conversation. Probably a thin distinction to make. Also, talking, speaking, and communicating are related to conversation; they might happen in conversation. But just because they’re going on, that doesn’t necessarily mean you’ve entered into a conversation.</p><p>PK: OK. You’ll have to explain some of that for me to get what you mean. Which I’m sure you will…</p><p>PB: Indeed. Then there are a bunch of kinds of conversation, maybe I’d call them conversational in nature, that come up or that come to mind, when we think of conversations that aren’t really conversations. Therapy came up every so often. So that becomes a question. Is therapy a conversation? I see therapy as a conversation with yourself. So if you’re asking if you’re having a conversation with the therapist and you’re saying it’s good, say, maybe because of the topics that you’re covering, maybe because it’s very personal, I’d say, no matter what you’re not having a conversation qua conversation. You’re in a clinical, conversational situation. Some semblance of a conversation is being used as a tool to gain insights that may or may not lead to mental-emotional healing.</p><p>PK: Sounds kind of like you’re nitpicking.</p><p>PB: Right. I am. When you feel that way that’s a sign we’ve arrived at arguing about lexical semantics. But this is why I’m nitpicking with this. Traditionally, and this varies depending on the school of thought of the therapist, but most therapists share and are trained to share very little of their own thoughts and feelings, or more generally, themselves. So that means in this conversational space there is a purposeful imbalance in contribution to the conversation. You might feel like it’s a “deep conversation” because you are talking out loud about very deep personal topics like a past heartache or the loss of a loved one that you don’t usually talk about with other people. But at the end of the day, the person you’re talking to isn’t in an equal state of sharing. That creates a big difference between the conversation that I’m asking about in my original question and what you’re experiencing in therapy. Know what I mean?</p><p>PK: I do know what you mean. It’s an interesting distinction. What would you name that imbalance? Both people are not sharing equally. Both people don’t have the same amount of power. Both people don’t have the same purpose. Somehow, both people are present in different ways I guess.</p><p>PB: I haven’t put my finger on it yet but those are definitely some ways I’ve been thinking about it.</p><p>PK: What else isn’t a conversation?</p><p>PB: Interviews.</p><p>PK: Ha! That’s ironic, no? You’re interviewing people about their conversation lives but you’re not having conversations about their conversation lives.</p><p>PB: I don’t think so. Job interviews, interviews on the TV or radio, interviews like the ones I’ve been having for the project have something similar going on as therapy does. There’s no intention of healing going on of course. That’s an obvious difference. But they do have this imbalance thing going on. As an interviewer I share less, if anything, about my own thoughts and answers to the questions I’m asking. Charlie Rose doesn’t answer his own questions. Oprah might drop an opinion here and there but it’s not her answers that are the point of the “interview.” Terri Gross studies up on her interviewee for hours before starting the talk. The point of the interview is to extract, to liberate the information that is inside the interviewee. And so, within that purpose, because of that purpose, you do create this imbalance. This lack of equality.</p><p>PK: I see what you’re saying. There is something different there.</p><p>PB: The last example along these lines is a meeting. At work or school, when we sit down to get something done we use conversation, rather, in my opinion, we use communication, as a tool to accomplish the task. Often there is an agenda that accompanies a meeting. That means there’s this purpose. Everyone is expected to share only what is relevant to the purpose everyone present has for being there. No more, and no less. And, really, in reality, since you’re at work or school, your “performance” in this conversational space is rated or graded or evaluated and very obviously judged. And not only that, you’re judged possibly by someone there in the room. That someone, say, a boss, judges whether you’re doing a good job in the meeting or the conversational space, or not. Thus enters a power dynamic that is stable. The boss has the power and the direct report does not. And everyone knows that and everyone has signed on for that and everyone’s behavior and sharing and input is influenced by that stable power dynamic.</p><p>PK: There’s a lot in there. I think you’re rambling. You’re talking about power, purpose, performance, judgement, all things that are definitely part of a meeting. But they also all sound like they’d also be present in those great conversations that you’re asking people about. Right?</p><p>PB: True. That means they’re all common dimensions, but the degree to which they’re present matters. More or less judgement. Clarified agenda and purpose or ambiguous agenda and purpose or none at all. Formal or informal, expected or unexpected judgement. By exploring these conversational spaces and seeing them as different from what I meant when I asked that question the first time about a best conversation you start to uncover all of these dimensions. All of these aspects of a conversation and can start to see them, each of them, on a spectrum. And, honestly, that was the whole point from the beginning. By asking 10,000 people about a great conversation they’ve had you start to uncover an unconscious rating system or way of judging a conversation. You can begin to describe what a great conversation looks like to lots and lots of people and maybe, just maybe, you can move a little bit farther down the path of creating more great conversations in your life.</p><p>PK: Is that what this thing is all about? What asking this question is all about?</p><p>PB: I don’t know. Maybe. That’d be worthwhile, don’t you think? Creating more great convos?</p><p>PK: Yes, I think it would be worthwhile. Reminds me of how I wonder about people’s ability to have good conversations at all. Sounds like you’re saying anyone can have a great conversation…</p><p>PB: Everything is relative. I can ask each and every person alive what their best is. It is a comparative question. I wonder if in asking that question I get anywhere at all. I’d not really be getting the actual answer from people, but I would be getting their perspective on conversation quality. So your wondering really comes down to whether people can have a kind of conversation that you think is a good one. But in reality there may be a real variety of definitions of good. Which is why asking everyone is so fun.</p><p>PK: You’re assuming that I have a definition of good though. That everyone does.</p><p>PB: Not exactly. I can ask the question. Whatever comes up, whatever comes to mind, comes to mind. And I’m assuming that unarticulated in people’s answers, buried in there is some beginning of a definition. What’s amazing about the asking is, if you’re right about the fact that people haven’t articulated a definition of a great conversation then by asking the question, asking people about it, you participate in the definition. You co-create it together. It’s a really fun thing to do. By asking, by having the conversation about it, you bring it into the world.</p><p>PK: But then, isn’t it less “true?”</p><p>PB: What do you mean by true my friend?</p><p>PK: Ha…</p><p>PB: This is where you get into a social science version of Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle in which he proves a limit of knowledge in physics. He points out that you can’t objectively know the position and the velocity of an electron at any given moment in time. You can objectively know the one or the other at a given moment but not both.</p><p>PK: Interesting. Why not?</p><p>PB: Because in order to measure the position of it you have to hit it with a photon so the photon can bounce off of it and hit you in the eye, thus objectively telling you where it is in spacetime. By observing it you change the thing measured, the photon will move the electron when it hits it. By asking the question at all, which I can’t not do in an exploration of this kind, I end up influencing the resultant definition. But. That is kind of why I just want to have conversations about conversation that people have loved having. Conversations that come to people’s minds when I say, “Describe for me a really great conversations you’ve had in your life.” Quality will always be an elusive thing.</p><p>PK: I’m thinking of Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance. He makes such a big deal about quality qua quality in the later part of the book.</p><p>PB: He does. He thinks it strangely sits in this amazing space between the subjective, that amorphous inkling of a notion/judgement that this conversation that comes to mind is somehow of a high quality, and that notion we have that the thing spoken or the pattern that is observed in the billion things spoken is “true”. Objectively true in some way. Quality somehow is part of both of these domains.</p><p>PK: It’s weird. I want to try and deny that there is some objective thing out there called quality. Especially that it is unchanging once you’ve uncovered a pattern of quality judgements. But I can’t deny that some conversations I’ve had in my life are better than others I’ve had. Conversation quality is really something that exists. I wouldn’t say that it is one thing, or the same for everyone, but you’re right in saying that if you ask people about high quality conversations, some conversations come to mind and others don’t. Now the kinds of conversations might very well come to mind because they think those are the ones that society thinks should come to mind. This long conversation or that political conversation. There’s likely a socially constructed pressure to see conversation quality in one particular way. Don’t you think?</p><p>PB: Yeah. I really do think. Everything is socially constructed. Co-created. Sitting back there in the collective unconscious. Waiting to be spoken. Dormant. Latent.</p><p>PK: It doesn’t seem, then, like it will be easy to put your finger on anything. So far, it sounds like you’re talking about what a conversation is not. Or rather, you’re clarifying exactly what kind of conversation you’re asking people about. Not therapeutic conversation, not conversation with yourself, not interviews and not meetings. I can accept that all of those things; that those social acts, are conversational and that they’re not what you’re most interested in asking people about.</p><p>PB: Those are other explorations. Don’t get me wrong, exploring what makes for a high quality session of therapy is a really fun idea for a study. One I’m sure that’s been done a bajillion times by millions of PhD psyche students. I’d also dig understanding what makes for a great interview and what the influences are for great meetings. There lots and lots of opinions about these kinds of conversational spaces but not a lot of science. Though there’s considerably more science about meetings than any of the others for what it’s worth.</p><p>PK: I still haven’t quite put my finger on what conversation is then. By that I mean the conversation you are actually looking to explore.</p><p>PB: Yeah. Me either. But to get at it a little bit, let me go back to the dimensions that came out of talking about the “nots.”</p><p>PK: OK, yeah. I think I’ve forgotten them all by now.</p><p>PB: Same, but I know one was the whole sharing thing. Is the conversation one where you expect one person to share more of their thoughts, feelings, perspectives than the other? If it’s expected to roughly be equal then it’ll likely fit the bill. I know another was power dynamics. If power in the conversation is one that flows around and isn’t stuck with one person, like a therapist, an interviewer or a boss, then it’ll likely fit the bill. And another was purpose or agenda. If the conversation is expected to have a purpose that begins and ends and can be accomplished in the period set for the conversation it’s likely a meeting as opposed to a conversation.</p><p>PK: That’s a good quick review but here’s a weird thought. Does a conversation need to involve words/speaking?</p><p>PB: Nope. Personally, I don’t think so at least. One, kind of harisplitty example is sign language. So, I’d say that communication, acts of communicating, have to be occurring. But that communicating can be happening through one’s hands, facial expressions, body language, and in the case of sex, through touch. Really, to be real, sex is only one specific situation in which touch and body is communicating in conversation. Touch, embrace, there are a lot of nonsexual ways that wordless communication can occur and therefore that wordless conversation can occur. You could even easily make the case that movement in the form of dance is also a conversation.</p><p>PK: I think I agree with that. It’s kind of a fun thought. To really expand the definition like that. Makes conversation a bit more interesting to me.</p><p>PB: To me as well. “Describe for me a wordless conversation that you’ve had recently that you really loved; that you thought was really quite beautiful.” That’s a whole other study. Or maybe it will end up being a common response in these conversations I’m having now. What’s maybe most interesting about this more expanded definition is how stuck we are with the mental model of wordful conversation. I don’t think wordless conversations easily come to mind when I’m asked about a recent great conversational experience.</p><p>PK: Certainly not. It takes a long time and a lot of conversation to get there like it just did for me… So you’ve got these dimensions. You’ve got a narrower idea of what a conversation is and a more expanded one. What then is a good conversation?</p><p>PB: A “deep” one.</p><p>PK: What’s that mean?</p><p>PB: It’s one of my first “findings,” or patterns that I noticed. It doesn’t really say much about conversation or the great conversations themselves. But it is a strange common theme. Writ a bit more generally, it means that we use spatial metaphors when we describe the quality of a conversation. I don’t really know why. I wonder if it just got started one day and kept going.</p><p>PK: What is an example of a spatial metaphor that describes quality conversation?</p><p>PB: Depth like I said. Poor quality conversations are often described as shallow. High quality conversations are often described as deep. It evokes, for me, an image of the ocean. You can be swimming on the surface and you can go very very far, over 7 oceans and even more seas and up rivers all while traveling on the surface at sea-level. But you can also go very deep and find all kinds of things. And it seems to be that deeper is harder just like in the ocean metaphor where the water pressure increases and it’s just harder to be at the bottom of the ocean. Unless, of course, you’re built for that kind of environment. Maybe there’s a parallel to your wondering about people not being able to “go there” with you.</p><p>PK: That sounds like another spatial metaphor.</p><p>PB: Definitely. “We really got somewhere.” “This conversation is going nowhere.” “We’re talking in circles.” “I shared what was inside.” “I really let him/her in.” All spatial. But the latter couple are more psychological but very much bleed into conversation descriptions. Places, movement, journeys together. I keep calling these conversations about conversation “explorations” which applies to more abstract situations but also is most used in the physical world.</p><p>PK: There’s an interesting thought there in that conversation description versus psychological descriptions. You’ve got intrapersonal psychology and interpersonal psychology. If you assume that the psyche doesn’t exist in space, in the physical world like most other physical objects that occupy space, then you have this tendency for people to speak about a nonphysical thing, observation, experience using the realm that they understand, the physical and spatial. So both kinds of psychology, because that is basically what you’re looking at here, positive interpersonal psychology, will manifest or borrow language and analogies from the physical world.</p><p>PB: Exactly. But here’s my thing about the spatial metaphors. Why deep? Is that just because of the “deep inside me” notion? That we bury certain thoughts, emotions, experiences, memories deep inside? And then a conversation is deep if we share those things that occupy that metaphorical place? I say this because I can picture a scenario in which words like “high” and “sky” or “above it all” or “the conversation was high-flying” or “heavenly” describe great conversation. Know what I mean? Why doesn’t a high quality conversation when described in a spatial way evoke the above? Why low or deep? When people talk about a deep conversation, I think about two people literally digging a hole in the ground together.</p><p>PK: Maybe that is the best analogy for a conversation. As we dig a hole together we take or dig up our inner stuff, like the dirt of the ground inside the hole, and together, take turns shovelling it out of the hole, outside of ourselves. And when you talk about therapy, you’re not digging a hole together. Just one of you is digging and the other is like coaching or managing or advising as you dig. And that’s why it’s not a conversation like you say. It’s too one-sided.</p><p>PB: Yeah I like that image. Conversation as co-excavation of our insides. Digging though. Such a strange image for describing a great conversation. Kinda funny. I also like that it points out something that I think is true about conversation. It’s not easy. To dig a great hole you have to work. One step/shovelful at a time.</p><p>PK: The vulnerability that it takes to have a great conversation is something I’ve thought a lot about since reading a book by Brene Brown. I think she’s mostly talking about the need to do this and that doing this “co-digging” is lacking in society. But she walks the walk by owning the difficulty and naming that the difficulty is only getting harder due to societal pressures. So I think it’s good she’s spreading word like she is. But it leaves open to me the question how best to dig with someone?</p><p>PB: That’s something I really wonder about and would like lots of these conversations to shed light on. Generally though I think that there has to be an art to it. Just because you can lift a shovel or shovel some dirt doesn’t mean you’re going about it in the best way possible or that you have any wisdom about how to do so. I’ve used a jazz analogy a lot recently. I can put my lips to a trumpet and I can blow the air out of my lungs too. That doesn’t mean there is very little difference between me and Miles Davis. There is a HUGE difference between me and Miles Davis. Huge. Not only that. Let’s say I practiced playing all of Miles’ songs and I could play them note for note. That doesn’t mean that I can push the state of my artform forward like Miles did. This analogy points out a lot of things before it begins to break down I think. One, is the whole practice thing. No one practices conversation. Another, is how some artists, like, maybe some conversationalists, are better than others. BUT, also buried in there is that one can learn to get better, through practice. Also, you’ve got this idea of excellence, of those at the forefront of an artform who know everything about it and push and pull and disrupt and teach and learn and steal and borrow and experiment and envision newness and a future of the art. All fascinating ideas to relate to the “art” of conversation.</p><p>PK: Overall you’re saying just because I can speak a language that doesn’t make me a masterful conversationalist?</p><p>PB: I’m saying that’s what that analogy implies. And I think it’s true. What I don’t like about what the analogy implies is that my understanding of art, high art at least, is that there are gatekeepers and tastemakers that speak for the art and control and dictate for the art what the artform looks like in it’s highest form. I don’t think that’s an amazing way to look at conversation. But the notion that while one is a good enough listener or say, painter, and can improve through practice and learning and the help of others, is powerful.</p><p>PK: It’s a fascinating way of looking at it. I’ve never seen conversation in that way before. It’s kind of this monolithic thing. Either you’re having a conversation or not. Either it happens to be good or not. And in theory it means you can learn to get better at the art of conversation.</p><p>PB: Why not…</p><p>PK: Well, I wonder what would happen if the world saw conversation that way. I wonder what would get lost.</p><p>PB: What do you mean?</p><p>PK: I’m not sure yet. I’m picturing people practicing conversation in order to get famous like some people do in sports and music and the like…</p><p>PB: Ah, interesting. It gets back to that thing where meetings have purposes and that makes them different in kind than the conversations I’m trying to look at. The intention at the heart of the practice or the heart of the conversation matters. That’s true in anything. But you bring up an interesting point. We can think of conversation as the result of a choice.</p><p>PK: Actually that would be an amazing thing to find out. It’s probably deeply complicated, but what is the full list of reasons why people these days choose to have conversations?</p><p>PB: Yes, that’d be an amazing data set. The problem is you’d have to ask people and I’m not sure of the exact study to point to, probably something in Thinking Fast and Slow by Daniel Kahneman or in one of Dan Ariely’s books, but people are the worst people to ask about intentions like that. You’d undoubtedly have to ask people anonymously. But that “method” problem aside, what you’re saying reminds me of Aristotle. I want to say this distinction he makes is in a few of his works but I think the one about friendship is in his Nicomachean Ethics. He talks about teleology in human relationships. And that’s exactly what we’re talking about here, teleology. He has more categories but the only ones I can remember right now, and the ones I think parallel what the point you’re bringing up are, one, friendship for utility and friendship for the sake of itself. Like you said, the reason why people choose to have conversations. Telos in Ancient Greek meant “end” implying purpose or reason for being…</p><p>PK: So now we’re talking about the teleology of conversation?</p><p>PB: Yeah. How do you feel about that?</p><p>PK: I think I’m OK with it…</p><p>PB: This is good because it helps me to clarify in a more positive way the whole “what conversation is” versus talking in terms of “what conversation is not.”</p><p>PK: That’s confusing. Say that again?</p><p>PB: Well, I went through all of those things that aren’t conversation. Therapy, meetings, interviews. In reality they are all conversations or “conversational” at the very least. But at that point I couldn’t say, or, I couldn’t describe the conversation that I wanted to look at. Borrowing a bit of Aristotelian teleology, now I can say I want to talk to people about the conversations that are had for the sake of themselves, not for the sake of anything in particular. Know what I mean?</p><p>PK: Again in another way maybe…?</p><p>PB: I can have a conversation with you for the sake of curing my boredom. Right?</p><p>PK: Of course… but that doesn’t sound very cool. You’re just using me.</p><p>PB: Exactly. And, sad to say, I’ve done this a lot…. But I can also have a conversation for the sake of, or, with the purpose of getting to know you. How does that sound?</p><p>PK: Better, I guess.</p><p>PB: Cool. I think so too. So there you have two teleoi or teloses? Not sure the plural of telos in Ancient Greek anymore. But you have two “ends” or reasons for conversing, so to speak. And you’ve already judged them. One’s better than the other. So that makes me start to place them on a spectrum in my mind. Because there are certainly other reasons for choosing to have a conversation with someone. On one side of your spectrum you’ve got this selfish reason. I’m choosing to have a conversation with you in order to cure my boredom and on the other side you have my choosing to converse with you in order to get to know you. On one side you’ve got selfish reasons and on the other you’ve got selfless reasons. And from there you can take that list that you were wondering about, the full list of people’s reasons for choosing to have a conversation with someone and begin to place them on that selfish/selfless spectrum. You end up with something like this:</p><p>Selfish Reason ← — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — -&gt; Selfless Reason</p><p>Right?</p><p>PK: OK…</p><p>PB: OK. Now to my point. Picture this same spectrum, but with an annex. An extra credit section like this:</p><p>Selfish Reason ← — -&gt; Selfless Reason ← — — — — -&gt; No Reason at All</p><p>Make sense?</p><p>PK: I think so. Conversation for the sake of itself. You’re trying to add that kind of conversation to this spectrum.</p><p>PB: Specifically this spectrum that illustrates the quality of a conversation. When we were talking about meetings I was talking about having an agenda and that not being the kind of conversation I was interested in. But the fact is, we’re humans and we have intentions, motives, neuroses and so we probably always have an agenda or purpose when choosing to have a conversation with someone. But the reason why I’m interested in this spectrum is it points to this whole other world of conversation and one that I have a hunch has something to do with the highest quality conversation.</p><p>PK: Makes sense to me. So if you could, like if people understood what you meant, you’d like to ask people, “Can you describe for me a conversation you’ve had that was for the sake of itself?”</p><p>PB: Exactly! But I can’t ask that. That makes sense to not a single person. Barely to me and I’m the one wanting to ask it…</p><p>PK: And in these things you always want to ask around the topic anyways… If you ask too directly you end up hinting at the kind of answer you want and people then tend to give you what they think you want.</p><p>PB: Precisely. So you begin to hope that the conversations about conversation, will happen to be about conversations that are for the sake of themselves. But most of the time you end up with conversations having little to do with that extra extension of the spectrum.</p><p>PK: I’m wondering now, do you think anyone ever in all of human history has had a conversation for the sake of itself?</p><p>PB: I’m not sure. I’m also not sure that matters. We’re talking not about absolutes but about relatives. That means you have conversations that are more for the sake of themselves than not or than are for the sake of some specific purpose. This might be a way of thinking about it… Explicit and implicit or conscious and unconscious. Sometimes you have a conversation and you and the other person have explicitly set out your purpose. Like often I’ll say hey let’s get a coffee so I can pick your brain about, whatever, working at the company you’re working at. Or I can stumble into a conversation with a roommate and we might not have set out an explicit purpose but there might be an unspoken one so that’d be more on the side of the conversation for the sake of itself on the “conversation quality spectrum.” Maybe in that one it’s implicit that we’re having a conversation to talk about how our days have been. Along similar lines, I could consciously start a conversation with a potential love interest in which I know my purpose, but the purpose is implied. She kind of knows or can assume my intention, maybe through body language or facial expression but we didn’t set out that purpose explicitly. Then I can choose to start a conversation in which I’m not aware yet of my purpose, but like you’re implying, have some unconscious ulterior motive, maybe to suss out if you’re angry with me. This is interesting. Now I’m not only picturing that spectrum, but two spectrums at opposing axes that imply quadrants and therefore 4 categories of conversation. The purpose is implicit and unconscious. Also the purpose is implicit and conscious. You have the unspoken purpose to have a conversation for the sake of itself and you have made the conscious choice to have this conversation.</p><p>PK: Hmm… this just got confusing. I think I need that table you’re talking about to really see what you’re saying.</p><p>PB: Yeah, I’m confused now too. But what I guess I’m realizing is that you can have conversations for the sake of themselves consciously or unconsciously. You can choose to have a conversation of this quality or you can accidentally stumble into it. And really when I’m talking about the art of conversation and practicing conversing I mean having the ability to consciously choose to enter into conversations of this quality.</p><p>PK: That’s interesting because I definitely saw you meaning something else.</p><p>PB: Like what?</p><p>PK: Like once you’re in that kind of conversation, you need to master the elements that keep it alive and well. I think you’d mentioned listening. So I can picture having practiced listening deeply like having practiced playing scales on your trumpet and doing so improves the quality of that consciously chosen conversation for the sake of itself.</p><p>PB: I see. That makes sense. That really is the art. For sure. But there is something so unique about the idea of two people intentionally, consciously sitting down to have a conversation with no telos. Regardless of whether or not there are subconscious machinations at work, that does sound conceivable to me. Also, I think the best artists and athletes, desire to practice their art or sport for no reason at all. Or, at the very least, they’re into their craft not for fame and fortune like maybe a dilettantish amateur might think.</p><p>PK: I think that’s right. So many people, especially the generation coming up overuse the word passion. It’s become a meaningless word that people use and have never really thought about what it means. What is passion really? Is it a feeling? Like fire? Like falling in love? I’m not sure that’s what everyone is trying to experience at their day job all day long. It sounds exhausting to me. But I can picture people wanting to practice their craft or wanting to pursue a career simply for the sake of itself. Sure money or other perks are a nice byproduct, but you can want to do work for no other reason than just wanting to do that work. I forget where I heard this but I remember reading about authors that write because they can’t not write.</p><p>PB: That gets a little confusing when you apply it to this situation though… We’re talking about practicing conversing or listening like you say, I like that example, of comparing listening deeply to playing the scales, for the sake of itself. And we’re talking about being in conversations for no reason at all. And that that kind of conversation is the best, the highest quality or the purest kind of conversation. It’s weird. You know what I mean? Because if you’re in a conversation in order to practice, then you’re having a conversation not for the sake of itself but for the sake of practice. But… maybe you love doing so and so that motive is good enough, pure enough. Or maybe it doesn’t matter… and I’m really nitpicking here.</p><p>PK: I do see what you’re saying in terms of the weirdness. There’s some sort of contradiction in there somewhere. But what do we have now? What’s new here? I’m thinking it’s this strange new kind of conversation. Consciously choosing to converse just to converse. For no other reason. That just seems like the strangest notion.</p><p>PB: You think? On a regular basis I’ll ask a friend to have lunch to “catch-up”. Let’s get drinks and catch-up! It’s been ages, I’ll say. “Catch-up” is a weak purpose. Hardly an agenda. There is a kind of format for it. Ish. You go over the big or little things going on in your life that I might not know about and vice versa. But there’s a point in these conversations in my experience in which the catch-up transitions to conversation for the sake of itself. There’s no real reason for it. So I think getting drinks, getting lunch, going for brunch, that kind of thing is a placeholder for having conversations for the sake of themselves. Or at least, having conversations that are closer to that side of the spectrum. Often, especially in New York City, brunch is very much not like a meeting. There’s most definitely not an agenda. Not even remotely. Sometimes it’s meant synonymously with “party”. Other times it’s just another name for conversing sans explicit purpose.</p><p>PK: I agree with that. Kids will have playdates and the parents will “just chat.” Most of the time mealtime is very much this kind of conversation, or like you say, closer to it than others.</p><p>PB: Agreed.</p><p>PK: But that’s a thing. People talk a lot about families not sitting down to dinner as often nowadays.</p><p>PB: Yeah, I have a group of friends that has family dinners once or twice a month. That’s not very often. But that’s interesting to see groups of friends “familifying” themselves and recreating those social acts, i.e. creating conversation spaces for conversations like the kind we’re talking about here, that, as has been true traditionally, involve food.</p><p>PK: It doesn’t seem like that familifying happens often enough. I feel like I see headlines all the time saying that our social isolation is killing us. I haven’t read it, but Putnam’s Bowling Alone is all about this state of affairs. It sounds like you should read it.</p><p>PB: I should. To be honest, I’ve been meaning to read it for a while. There’s another one called Alone Together by Sherry Turkle that I’ve also been meaning to read along the same lines. I did however read her book Reclaiming Conversation: The Power of Talk in a Digital Age. She brings up the case of parents emailing on their phones at the dinner table and how that distraction can ruin the potential of that conversational space.</p><p>PK: Yep. No phones at the dinner table in my house.</p><p>PB: Naturally. But have you ever thought about why you shouldn’t allow phones at the dinner table?</p><p>PK: Um. I mean. Just that it makes sense. You want everyone paying attention to one another. To the conversation.</p><p>PB: For sure. Attention is key. But there’s something more there. More to it that I mean.</p><p>PK: More to the no phones rule at the dinner table?</p><p>PB: Yeah. I was at work a while back and I interrupted some people I work with who were in a meeting and I noticed something. They weren’t done yet.</p><p>PK: What do you mean by “done”?</p><p>PB: They weren’t done with their conversation yet and they didn’t know it but they knew it. Rather, they didn’t know it but they were acting like it. Hm. Not sure how to explain this. Have you ever had a long open-ended conversation that came to an end?</p><p>PK: What do you mean by open-ended?</p><p>PB: Like you had no “hard stop”. Like I mean you didn’t have somewhere to be after an hour of having the conversation.</p><p>PK: Oh. Well. Yes. I think so. I mean, of course I have. But I feel like maybe it’s been a while… Hrm. Maybe it’s been a really long while. Wow. That kind of makes me a little sad.</p><p>PB: Yeah. I think it’s pretty rare. And I think something really interesting happens and/or is possibly allowed to happen when you have that time situation.</p><p>PK: Like what?</p><p>PB: Like a conversation can grow. It’s like a potted plant in a bigger pot. It’s got room to grow. And it does. In theory it’s possible to start a conversation that never ends. And maybe another name for that is marriage. Not sure as I’ve never been married. But really, conversations do end. And when you reach the end you know it. You sense it. I also think that sometimes that “end” is really a lull or a pause and there’s more or another chapter. Like you can picture the situation that one of the people I interviewed related about backpacking with an old friend on a very long trail for several days. There are pauses and it’s hard to discern when one conversation ends and the next one begins. But the point is that we have some sense that there is a time to pause and let the recent interchanges marinate for a bit before the next conversation.</p><p>PK: I think I see what you’re saying. I think…</p><p>PB: Maybe I’ll try it this way. Are you familiar with the German word “gestalt”?</p><p>PK: I’ve heard it before. It’s one of those words that you have a sense about and have heard here and there but definitely can’t define or explain to someone.</p><p>PB: Same here. I feel like I look the word up on Wikipedia every few months or so for a refresher. I think it means “shape” or “whole”. I think it’s similar to a Platonic “form” or “eidos”. But that’s exactly what I’m trying to point out. When you start a conversation, a gestalt comes into being and we sense that and behave like it.</p><p>PK: OK. But give me an example of a gestalt. I think that’ll help.</p><p>PB: Well, strictly speaking, gestalt theory started as a visual thing. You have this idea that the whole has a reality of it’s own. Independent of the parts. In this case, the words, interlocutors, exchanges, back and forths, topics. Points made. That kind of thing. The best example of what I mean might be music or a song. A friend of mine told me about her brother who likes to “song bomb” people. He’ll stand next to someone, say at work, and whistle or sing a really familiar song or melody. Let’s say the Star Wars theme. But he stops short of completing the whole melody. 9 times out of 10 the person, not even knowingly will finish the melody and then it will be “stuck in their head” for the rest of the day.</p><p>PK: Huh. “Song bombing.” That’s a pretty funny thing. Does it really work?</p><p>PB: I think so. But there’s an assumption that it’s the stopping short that makes the song get stuck in the person’s head. That might not be the case. It might just be the simple hearing of the song. Who knows. But there is something very true about the completion part that clarifies the point about gestalts and conversation that I’m trying to make. You sense that the musical sentence is not complete. So you complete it. Like if you were to sing a scale, fa so la tee da. If you stop short you’re aware that you’re not “done” yet. You’re left with the urge to complete it.</p><p>PK: OK. I can definitely see that. There is a wholeness when it comes to musical pieces. We can sense completion of the whole. And what you’re saying is that when you interrupt the meeting the people you work with are having then you cut into or slice apart the wholeness of their conversation.</p><p>PB: Yes. Exactly. These things, when we start them, take on a life of their own. If we don’t see that and honor that then we just say, OK. Time is up. I have to go pick up the kids from school and therefore the conversation is finished. But that might not be the case. The conversation might still have more gas in the tank. Some unfinished business…</p><p>PK: But what does that mean? Like, why does that matter?</p><p>PB: Well, first of all it means we’re missing out on a lot of conversation. Possibly the real part of the conversation or the deep part of the conversation or the highest quality part of the conversation.</p><p>PK: Ah ha. I see. That’s fair.</p><p>PB: And the point I’m bringing up here is that phones at the table not only distract already frayed attentions but they slice into the potential whole that was created when the family sat down to dinner. Related to the attention point that you make is that if we’re distracted then we don’t sense this doneness or not. The conversation that we’re in, for it to be seen as done comes down to an arbitrary unit of time or whether we’ve covered the topics that we think we were trying to cover. Not this mysterious wholeness that we’re calling a “conversation.” It takes paying attention to participate in a whole conversation.</p><p>PK: Gosh this is so strange. I’m now trying to think about the family at the proverbial dinner table. In my mind before, it was just the kids who’re supposed to be talking to each other or telling their parents about their day at school. It’s a check off the box kind of information exchange. But what you’re talking about here is a conversation. It’s something different completely than what I thought of when I pictured the family at the table. It makes me think now that I’ve never had a conversation with my kids.</p><p>PB: A complete conversation you mean. You’ve had plenty of conversations with them. Partial conversations maybe.</p><p>PK: It’s a cool idea. Maybe a little saddening though. I want that. To have a conversation. A high quality conversation. With the people around me. Everyday I want that. But it’s not even on my radar.</p><p>PB: I don’t think it’s really on anyone’s radar. I think that’s a bit why it’s fun, maybe even liberating, to think about conversation as an explicit pastime of it’s own.</p><p>PK: An art. A form of art alongside many many other forms of art and pastimes.</p><p>PB: At the same time that that is a fun thing to think about, it also misses a really important point.</p><p>PK: What point is that?</p><p>PB: The one that you were just making. Why do you want to have these conversations with the people in your life everyday? Rather, why do you want to have high quality, whole conversations with the people in your life?</p><p>PK: Because I care about them. Why wouldn’t I want that? Why else have people in your life? You have relationships to relate to people. Right?</p><p>PB: I agree. And that is what thinking of conversation as artform misses out on. That conversing is one and the same as relating. I’m thinking of that line in Louis Armstrong’s “What a Wonderful World.” “I see friends shaking hands, saying how do you do, they’re really saying I love you.” When we do these things and when we converse and touch and work together we’re relating to others. We’re socializing as social animals. We’re doing that thing, that act that is core to who we are as humans. We’re spreading the love.</p><p>PK: I agree with that completely. But now I’m a little lost. We’re not saying that when I am at the dinner table with my family and there are phones and distractions and we cut the conversations short when we’re done eating that we’re not loving and relating and socializing as social animals. Right?</p><p>PB: Right. Everything is still happening. You’re just missing out on depth and breadth of er,… you’re missing deeper and broader loving and relating and conversing and socializing. Which is fine, but….</p><p>PK: But what?</p><p>PB: I don’t know. Maybe it’s being greedy, but isn’t life that much higher in quality when you have that broader deeper experience of the people you care about most?</p><p>PK: Certainly. I wouldn’t say no to that. I guess what you’re saying is, “there’s more.”</p><p>PB: There’s more and why not be aware that there’s more and open yourself up to it. Open the door.</p><p>PK: The way you say that, “Open yourself up to it” is weird. Makes me wonder if it’s a passive or an active thing…</p><p>PB: Yeah. I wonder that a lot. In a lot of the interviews people only talked about high quality conversations as accidents. Gifts from fickle gods on high like a lightning bolt thrown down at you. “OK! Today you may have a great conversation. But only because you’ve been good and it’s been a really long time since I gifted you suchly!” That’s how it seemed people thought about their great conversations and it really made me wonder about the “how.” And the active/passive question you just posed.</p><p>PK: And what’s the verdict? Based on all your time thinking about these things and interviewing people, can we actively choose to have great conversations?</p><p>PB: Generally, my knee jerk response is, yes, absolutely. But I’d add a caveat. One I’ll get to later. First, however, I think there’s a more complex answer than a jovial, “Yes, absolutely!” “Greatness” depends on so many things, so many variables. Obviously. But you need to say more about what greatness looks like. Because saying there is a high qualityness that all great conversations have, a common denominator is risky. Possibly unlikely.</p><p>PK: Are you saying it depends on the kind of conversation you’re having?</p><p>PB: I do mean that. Well I assume that. But who knows. What I’m thinking here is using this guy Isaacs’ framework. I don’t think it’s got a name but a colleague of his calls something similar to it, “Theory U.” I think they’re onto something very general that applies to a lot of different kinds of conversations, be they political, among friends, or a catch-up, one on one, or maybe a couple having a “fight”.</p><p>PK: Having a high quality fight. I like that idea.</p><p>PB: I feel like what all this points to is that possibility. We’d assume that you can have lots of different types and kinds of conversations and they can be of varying degrees of quality. Nothing too crazy buried in that assumption I don’t think. “Varying degrees of quality” implies some sort of spectrum so that on one end you have poor quality and on the other end you have high quality. And since fairly often we have some sort of verbiage around depth, let’s make this spectrum run North-South if you will. Poor quality is like at the surface of the ocean and high quality is like being at the bottom of the ocean. Got that safely there situated in your mind’s eye?</p><p>PK: I’m just picturing one of those textbook cross sections of the ocean.</p><p>PB: Good. Perfect. Now divide that cross section into let’s say four layers or sections. And now let’s steal a bit from Isaacs. In that section nearer the top you’ve got the shallowest conversations. These conversations are transactional. Conversations in this part of the spectrum I’m picturing are small-talk at a party, ordering a coffee from your baristo with a bit of banter, and, you know, maybe you can plop all those other conversations that we were talking about as conversational but not a pure conversation, those things like meetings, where you’re trying to get something done, or therapy where you have someone midwifing new, healing insights from you or an interview for a job where an interviewer needs to get certain facts and figures out of you for their vetting process.</p><p>PK: OK. I can see all those conversations there in that first of four sections. Makes me wonder what these middle sections are going to hold.</p><p>PB: Well it is a pretty arbitrary choice. Four sections or five or three. Three could work too, but let’s stick with Isaacs’ four for now. In the next quality category of conversations you’ve got “Debatey” conversations and you’ve also got “Discussions”. Debates are not bad. Just like transactional conversations there is a time and a place for them. There are better and worse ones. You can be there fully for each of these kinds or you can be fairly distracted and thus barely present for them.</p><p>PK: Debate/Discussion, huh. Not what I expected…</p><p>PB: If you look at the word de-bate you see that we also get words like bat, to beat down, batter or assault and battery. We trumpet debates as these bastions of democracy but really, compared to other kinds of conversation that we’ll look at next they’re nothing special. The same is true for the word “discussion” which relates to words like percussion or concussion. In discussions you don’t beat down as much but you hit words and statements back and forth like you’re playing ping-pong. In these kinds of conversations, ones filled with unquestioned, staid opinions, you can beat the person or people you’re talking to or you cannot beat down their opinions/statements. Strangely the expectation is that these are productive social acts. Important for the survival of democracy. But Thomas Jefferson was quoted as saying, “I never saw an instance of one or two disputants convincing the other by argument.” And it makes me want to ask, if you’re like Jefferson; have you ever witnessed someone change their opinion as a result of a debate or discussion, or more specifically, as a result of having their self or their opinion batted down or battered or hit back at them?</p><p>PK: I mean, when you put it like that the answer is of course no. But it’s a really interesting point that I’d not really thought of before but is super obvious. The harder you push either against someone else’s opinions or push your own on them the greater the resistance. Almost as a rule. Like an equal and opposite reaction kind of thing in physics but for human conversation. I guess my question to you then is, like the previous type of conversations, are debate-like conversations conversations?</p><p>PB: Yeah, it’s a good question. I don’t know. I suppose so. Conversing is going on, so yeah, probably. But there’s something not ideal about debating, but if it happens naturally, organically it really is likely that it’s a conversation.</p><p>PK: Kinda sounds like you’re going against your earlier statements on conversation and what is and what isn’t a conversation but I see what you’re saying.</p><p>PB: True. But that was more an exploration that was useful for learning about the different dimensions of conversation. Maybe we can revisit those or like I was just suggesting, maybe roll them up into this first chunk of lower quality conversations. I don’t know, we’ll have to see. But either way, so far so good? We’ve got surface-y transactional conversations in tier one and debates with batting either down or back and forth in tier two. Savvy?</p><p>PK: OK.</p><p>PB: Cool. So then on to dialectic.</p><p>PK: Yes on to dialectic. Another one of those words that I’ve heard before but not one I could ever tell you the meaning of or give you an example of.</p><p>PB: Same here. It feels really grand and esoteric. Reminds me of all kinds of things from Plato that I’d love to remember but don’t. Interestingly the word in ancient Greek just means conversation or discourse. But the word has come to mean a lot more than that. In contrast to debate or even rhetoric, it isn’t about emotional conversation or convincing or persuasion. In it’s earliest form of this contrast to debate you have Socrates saying, “Let’s get at the truth because the truth is the greatest good.” But he didn’t see debate or argument as a means to get there. He’d take someone’s opinion or hypothesis and play it out as rationally as possible and then if the two of them arrived at a contradiction, an irrationality, then the jig was up.</p><p>PK: This is the Socratic Method, right?</p><p>PB: Right.</p><p>PK: One of those things that’s there in the back of your mind and you think you know what it is but probably no one ever really does.</p><p>PB: Exactly. I wonder if we love debate a little too much to bother with dialectic. But maybe not. I’m just making sweeping generalizations but debate has more violence in it. Clashing. It’s more like American Football and Jason Bourne movies. And that’s fine. Like we said before there is a time and a place for that. But dialectic is more about the unity of opposites. If you go back to its very earliest. The moment something even resembling dialectic as we know it today entered human consciousness it was through (though probably he was just the one that wrote it down) Heraclitus. He was all about opposites and contradictions and paradoxes and the mysterious mix of all of these together. He pointed out that they all come from and sublimate back into one another and that is the point of dialectic. Not to beat someone or their stance/opinion down but to work with it through reasoned conversation until you arrive, having thought through the question together, at a deeper understanding of the various stances and opinions… or people.</p><p>PK: Huh. That is so different. I’m wondering when the last time I experienced something like that. Kinda sounds fun. I like to think things through out loud. Talk things through. It sounds like dialectic is more my thing. Because I’m also not very much into argument, conflict, that sort of thing.</p><p>PB: Sounds about right. But like we’ve said, there’s a time and a place for all of these kinds of conversation. If you feel like your cashier gave you the wrong change you’ll want to have a transactional conversation not an epic dialectic. I think you’ll also not want to have a debate, though I think some people default to that sometimes.</p><p>PK: I can kind of see your point, but is there really ever a time you’d want to have debate?</p><p>PB: Yeah. Debate doesn’t always have to be offensive or uncivil… or 100% irrational as it often is these days. You can have a calm debate; it can be used as a tool to combat groupthink. The classic example of groupthink is JFK’s cabinet. A bunch of straight, white, males all educated in almost exactly the same way at the same place could have used debate to get the various opposing views or options out on the table. Not, of course, at the 11th hour of the Cuban missile crisis, but at some point, it could have been used to work through groupthink. I think it could be a good way to prep for a rich dialectic. Have a bunch of the people debate and rep several different sides of a question, maybe different positions and play them out not necessarily to their “logical” conclusion, but to a conclusion. Then you go off and practice dialectic. You be reasonable. You unify the stances and opposites and play them out to their logical or illogical conclusions. So yeah, I think there’s a time and a place for all of them.</p><p>PK: OK. I can see that. Sounds reasonable to me. What doesn’t sound reasonable is people doing that. Taking off their debate hat and putting on their dialectic hat. I don’t think people do that nor are very likely to.</p><p>PB: I agree with that. But people can’t do a lot of things not yet on their radar or they’ve never been taught. And they can do a lot of things, say, like algebra that were put on their radar; that they were taught. I agree, but with that asterisk. I think we should teach dialectic.</p><p>PK: I would like to see kids taught dialectic. But I think it’d still be over my head just like half the stuff they’re learning today. C++ when I was a kid was a really mediocre grade on book report. I doubt kids even do book reports now. Now they “code”.</p><p>PB: But that’s not exactly true. We just haven’t talked a lot about dialectic and you’ve likely not experienced this social act of dialectic much.</p><p>PK: That’s fair. But maybe we can get into that later. I’m really curious what the farthest side of this spectrum looks like. We have transactional, debate, dialectic and now what? Cause Dialectic sounds fine. It’s sounds fairly high quality.</p><p>PB: OK. Back to dialectic in a second. And maybe I’ll try and describe both of these in contrast to one another. With dialectic you’re talking about opinions, topics, subjects, stances on an issue. All of this stuff is there and you’re fine-tuning your understanding about the topic with another person or a group of people. For the most part all of this content exists in some form or another in the world. And that is great. There is so much I don’t understand about various issues or topics. I have no idea what the nuances are to bullying or education reform or programming languages like Om.next. But if someone were to be willing to have a dialectic with me to explore those topics that’d be amazing. In my mind, we get into the next level when we create newness.</p><p>PK: Newness is the dividing line.</p><p>PB: Yes. I think so.</p><p>PK: Reminds me of this Inside the Actors Studio I watched a long time ago. James Lipton is interviewing Robin Williams and the interview goes from Robin Williams sitting and playing along, answering the questions genuinely to performing what is basically improv comedy for the audience and then back again. And what’s amazing about him going back again is that he comments on what he’s doing when he’s in improv mode. At one point he says, “People like to be a part of creating something new.” That always struck me as so true. Extremes aside, we like to be a part of creating new life when we have sex and have families. So many people seem to be pursuing creative endeavors. Art is held up as an ideal. Passion and creativity and creating something new and novel seem to be the way to be in the world. And we hold artists and creators up on a pedestal. And Robin Williams has to be right. That’s got to be why people like him are so magical. They let you sit there and feel like you’re a part of something brand new and unique. Something that will never happen again and never has happened. And was never planned. So I think I agree with you that there’s something about newness.</p><p>PB: Yeah. I think back on some of the best conversations I’ve had in my life and one, this can be something else to talk about, I can feel it in my body, I’ll literally tremble. But, two, I’d usually have some sort of ah ha moment. And those are also all the rage these days. Epiphanies, learning something new, sitting there and being like wow, I never thought about things like that. Or maybe not even in an intellectual way, you have a moment where you’re like, wow, you have experienced THAT? Whatever it might be. You lost a loved one so young, or you lived in some interesting place for a long time. Whatever it may be, there is something new created, generated, brand new. And that’s the word that Isaacs uses. “Generative Dialogue.”</p><p>PK: Huh. Interesting. Two things. One is that when you said learning something about someone I started thinking about the newness that’s created in that moment but also the compassion that is inherent in that act, in that moment. The other thing is, and I didn’t realize this until now, but in order for Robin Williams to let you be a part of creating something new with him or in his presence he needs to be open in a way that is, kind of astounding. And by open I think I mean, vulnerable. But there’s also something else there. I’m not sure what it is. Maybe it’s the opposite of being vulnerable, which is a word I’m not sure I can explain very well. But the opposite of being vulnerable in this situation, in this conversational situation where there are opinions flying around and being held and discussed and there are “stances”, you have to… I don’t know, not hold on to them so tightly. You have to open yourself up to possibly being hurt or being wrong or straight up failing. Which I guess is what it means to be vulnerable.</p><p>PB: Yeah I think it literally means “able to be wounded” which is what you’re saying. Most people can’t do what Robin Williams could do. And similarly, most people have never tried to have conversations in a similar way. It’s as though, evolutionarily, or maybe it’s just our society, just hasn’t seen much of conversations beyond transaction and debate. We’re too stuck. I think that’s what I was thinking you were getting at with the opposite of vulnerability piece. That, to have a generative conversation, you have to be unstuck. You have to be open-minded when it comes to your opinions and stances. You have to wonder and want to learn. You have to be open to having that epiphany about anything. And in reality most people hold their opinions very very tightly. The thought that’s in their heads, that have happened to show up there, or that were shared by people close to them in their tribe or family are somehow immediately seen as core to who they are.</p><p>PK: To their ego.</p><p>PB: Aye. And that’s totally fine. But the beauty of it is that that means for a lot of people there’s this whole other world. This promised land of human interaction and conversation.</p><p>PK: Very lofty.</p><p>PB: True. Very lofty. So let’s bring it back down to earth. What do you say?</p><p>PK: OK…</p><p>PB: What is a relationship?</p><p>PK: Ugh. I don’t know. That sounds lofty too.</p><p>PB: True, but it gets at the heart of everything we’re talking about…</p><p>PK: I know, but definitions… Definitions of noun-ified verbs. The. Worst.</p><p>PB: What do you mean?</p><p>PK: I mean the possibly, and I haven’t thought about this yet, better or easier question to ask is what is relating? I think it’s easier to work with verbs. We’re a moving animal not just a social animal. Or I should say we’re an animal that socializes.</p><p>PB: OK let’s roll with that then. It makes sense to me. So then we have the question, what is relating to another person or what is socializing?</p><p>PK: First, I know you said that this is at the heart of what we’re talking about, but why are you asking this now?</p><p>PB: Because it’s this old Aristotelian truism that we’re social animals. That core to who we are is other people. You’ve got the common idea that no man is an island. I run into quotes on a regular basis stating that nowadays people are thirsting for meaning, which, I assume, is due to a lack of good social experiences. We mentioned Sherry Turkel’s books about people unintentionally isolating themselves through their use of technology. So something is awry and all the while, we’re here talking about being open to genuine, generative conversation and I just feel like where we’ve arrived in this conversation has to have something to do with what’s “wrong” with society. But it’s not a far away society thing. It’s a right here you and me talking to each other thing. If it’s out there in the broader world and it has to do with people being with each other and talking to each other and relating to each other then whatever you and I are doing here and now has to partake in that.</p><p>PK: That sounds right to me. So then you’re asking what it means to relate to people because you want to know what relationships and socializing have to do with generative conversation?</p><p>PB: Right. My thing is, and there are limits to this, but the content of socializing, the activity of relating is nothing more and nothing less than conversation. They are one and the same. So if you’re talking about a rare kind of conversation then you’re talking about a rare kind of relationship or moment in a relationship, or as you say, when relating. And, mind you, I mean relationship loosely. We have work relationships. That is, we relate to and socialize with people at work. And on the daily commute. And by reading people’s articles in the newspaper etc.</p><p>PK: If you have a loose definition of conversation, one that includes unspoken communication but still involves back and forth, then I’d agree with what you’re saying about conversing being relating and relating be conversing.</p><p>PB: Right. You put it more succinctly. Thanks.</p><p>PK: No problem. But let me ask you something. Do you have a lot of generative conversations?</p><p>PB: Good question. I don’t know. I like to think so. I hope so. I just don’t know. I’d have to sit down and take stock of the conversations I’ve had over the past few months. You know. Count them up. I think I have them occasionally. Why do you ask?</p><p>PK: Because I’m picturing conversations on this side of the spectrum. And I think you’re right to point out that these kinds of conversations are great or at least greater than others and that having more of them would have a positive impact on people’s social lives. And I know how to have more of the other kinds of conversations. But I’m not sure I can picture how to have more Robin Williams-like conversations.</p><p>PB: I’ve been thinking about the same thing. They’re a little bit of a black box. A little magical. I think they’re on a different plane and that means we ourselves need to be on a bit of a different plane too. We also need to be kind of magical. Here’s a quote from Bill Isaacs that makes me think this, “One of the more important ideas about dialogue that we have discovered in recent years is the notion that the process of movement through different fields or spaces of conversation is much more important than trying to produce a particular outcome.” (loc. 3642). There are a few things in this. One is the trying. I don’t think if we want to have this we’ll get there by trying. But, and I don’t know what the distinction is here, I do think we intend. We set out on the journey to have a generative conversation. Another thing is when you start talking about “spaces” and “fields” you know you’re in some mysterious territory. Just like when we talk about an “electromagnetic field” we don’t actually know what’s going on. But I guess the biggest thing is: What is the difference between moving through spaces of conversation and producing an outcome? I think it has something to do with the whole purpose thing we were talking about when we were saying meetings and interviews aren’t conversations. They are conversations. They’re just transactional ones that try to produce a particular outcome. This case of generative dialogue you have to intend to move through conversational spaces as opposed to intending to or trying to produce a specific outcome.</p><p>PK: What’s a conversational space? What’s it look like?</p><p>PB: Honestly, and this is silly and absolutely not true. But I picture conversation by candlelight. Actually. Or by firelight. Strictly speaking a conversational space is anywhere and everywhere. Places and spaces in which people are. I was about to say places and spaces where you have two people gathered but that sounds a bit too New Testament to me. I also think you have be in a conversational space with yourself. Solo probably works.</p><p>PK: But why candlelight or firelight?</p><p>PB: I don’t know. It’s funny because I don’t know if I’ve had a good conversation by either. Regardless, there’s something to the space that the light does. And by space, I guess I don’t mean the physical space. Now I’m a little lost so let me back up to where I was earlier. Let me spell out two scenes to compare and contrast. One is the one we were talking about earlier of a family at suppertime. Table, TV on, phones on, food, etc. Another conceivable version of that is sitting in a circle around an actual fire just listening to one’s thoughts inside, the sounds surrounding and the crackle of the fire. That’s a bit extreme, but you could remove phones from the table and a blaring TV from the scene. You can also light candles. You can book a time for supper. You can clarify that it will likely be from one point in time to another. And when everyone sits down, you can just settle in for the duration.</p><p>PK: Those are all very different scenes.</p><p>PB: Indeed.</p><p>PK: I realize as you paint those pictures that, one, I have candles in my home but I don’t think I’ve ever used them for that, and two, if you think about it, humans have eaten in groups together by candlelight for probably several hundred years depending on the culture and by firelight, also depending on the culture, for much much longer. Then a hundred years ago you get radio in the home and an “evening program.”</p><p>PB: Aye. And then TV. Then smartphones. Concentration is increasingly frayed and we’re not equipped to cope with it.</p><p>PK: We’re only equipped for the conversation by firelight because that’s what we adapted to over millions of years.</p><p>PB: Right. But this way that we’re talking right now is fairly apathetic. It assumes that we choose nothing in our lives. You can choose to light a candle. I can choose to light a fire. I mean. Not in my Brooklyn apartment of course. But… You know what I mean. I can choose to invite people in my life to sit down for the purpose of gathering around food and drink and candlelight, all, mind you, in a non-romantic way. To just settle in. Especially in the winter.</p><p>PK: Yes. You can do that. So can I. My question now is why do we not do that? Choose that?</p><p>PB: Dunno. Distractions? Shit’s just moving too fast? It feels silly? I think that might be a block for me. But I guess it doesn’t have to be. You just send a text and say hey, have dinner at my place with me and some food, drink and candlelight. And let’s see what comes up in conversation. It might not be generative dialogue. But it might be. And who cares if it is or not.</p><p>PK: That’s the thing that worried me about this whole search for quality of yours. Studies find that when you start to measure people’s performance or pay for their improved performance it becomes a “job” for people. They no longer work from a source of passion, or as they call it, “intrinsic motivation.” The motivating force changes. But not only that. If you force it, kind of like you were saying earlier, the whole thing doesn’t work. You have to, how did you put it? Be intentional about it? Intend to sit down and be present with friends by candlelight?</p><p>PB: Yeah. I think that’s right. But now I’m kind of doubting things. Do you agree with the specifics there? Isn’t there something about my upbringing, being brought up in my culture that I lean towards candles and fireplaces? It seems very northern european and makes me think of coziness while cold is outside. That’s not the case for other cultures from different climes. I’ve traveled through some where you have these Hemingway-esque old-timers sitting outside cafes on boardwalks, malecons or corniches sipping tea and talking for literally hours on end.</p><p>PK: Yes. I don’t think everyone needs fire. I think that’s where it comes down to the intention to create a conversational space with people. To reasonably remove distractions… but there is something to the fire… And I think it’s this. I think it’s ritual. If you’re an anthropologist you acknowledge that there are rites and rituals that vary across cultures in terms of the actual thing they do whether it’s lighting a candle or lighting a bonfire or pouring libations or saying grace. The thing itself shouldn’t matter, but whoever is being intentional is going to probably want to do something that signifies it’s distractionless conversation time.</p><p>PB: Yeah. I think you’re right. These academics I’ve read call it “charging the space.” Like charging something with static electricity. You imbue the space with the intention to be together and to listen.</p><p>PK: So now I’m thinking this is all nice and good. You’ve got your dinner and your candles…</p><p>PB: …And?</p><p>PK: And then politics comes up. And then things get heated. And the group becomes mired in debate. What then?</p><p>PB: Yeah. I don’t know. There’s something to this about knowing what you’re doing. But not. There is an art to it like we were saying when we were comparing me and my trumpet skills to Miles Davis. But to be honest there’s something X-factor-y, spiritual-y going on here too. There’s something about calling people together for this purpose, with this intention and then being present. Being present and listening hard.</p><p>PK: What do you mean?</p><p>PB: I think I mean something about unconditionality. Isaacs has this quote, “I have been surprised to discover that in confrontational and dangerous situations,” and he means in conversation here, “people really want engagement not withdrawal.” (loc 5424) You suddenly have a debate on your hands? OK. Engage. Be present unconditionally. No matter what. I think that’s what I mean by “listen hard.” It’s hard to do and you have to listen to what’s going on behind the scenes or between the lines. Why debate? Why that particular stance in the debate? Why a stance at all? Is there an emotion behind it? A reason? A history? If you’re not there to learn about that kind of stuff then why light candles in order to dive deep together? To sit and chat?</p><p>PK: I agree that it’s got to be about the hard stuff. But really it is so hard. Especially with family. Things get so heated. It’s not all jokes and fun times and lovingkindness.</p><p>PB: You’re right. And that’s the somewhat liberating thing about seeing this whole thing as a practice. It’s hard in the beginning. But just like playing the trumpet, it’s possible for you to improve from barely playing the scales to playing a whole song to inventing new branches of the artform, let alone writing songs themselves.</p><p>PK: Everything new is hard in the beginning. It’s just so strange though. Conversation seems like the one thing that we all think isn’t hard, and shouldn’t be hard and then when it is, we’re like, I’m never doing this again. We go into a state of avoidance either of those particular people that we had a too hard conversation with or the subject itself. But then you just end up isolated with your device and a TV in the background munching on food. So, hard or not, not doing it isn’t an improvement. Avoiding it isn’t worth it. It’s not life.</p><p>PB: There are probably plenty of people that avoid certain people, avoid closeness, avoid certain conversation topics, avoid all this that we’re talking about, because of a bad experience. But for every one of those people there have to be several that aren’t even aware that there is something more out there. In fact, I kind of have this condescending hunch that there’s an even broader lack of awareness.</p><p>PK: About what?</p><p>PB: Cultivation. When we talk about the practice of conversation and getting ever so slowly and slightly better at conversing; and when we talk about charging a space I feel like we’re talking about cultivation. It is a slow process. I can send a text message or I can light a candle and make dinner and intend to have a connected, generative conversation. One is the press of a button. The other is hard. Someone needs to make you aware of it. That it’s something in the world that you can do. I’m just thinking that, guessing that, people don’t take the slow road nowadays. But now I’m making sweeping generalizations about whole populations. I bet I sound very, very out of touch.</p><p>PK: You do. You sound like teachers talking about their students… but every generation of teachers talking about every generation of students. It’s a similar pattern always. I do think you have a point with the cultivation thing. This is silly, but I can’t remember the last time I planted a seed. Planted a seed let alone cultivated that seed. But really, what I think is important to realize from that metaphor is you don’t cultivate a seed. You don’t do anything to the seed itself if you’re hoping to grow the seed into a fully grown plant or tree. And the same is true for a conversation. There is no conversation to poke and prod and say, hey, grow into a real, healthy, generative dialogue. Do it. Instead, you cultivate that which is around the seed… or in our case, conversation. You bathe both in light, but the right amount and kind of light. You feed the people and the soil. And you make sure drink is there for the people and the soil. Make sure everything in the situation doesn’t have too much or too little moisture.</p><p>PB: You hear about people having green thumbs and it makes me think that there’s an art, a practice, to gardening. Always more to learn about the whole subject and about how to handle different situations and different types of plants. The same is true for our social interactions. You have people that are better and worse at, and getting better or worse at, cultivating certain kinds of conversations. And not only that, you’re also right about the direct, indirect thing. I think that’s a really important point that a lot of people miss when it comes to this genre of activity. People wonder how to “get” someone to do something. “How do I get my team to perform better?” “How do I get my daughter to talk to me more.” “How do I get my friends to not look at their phones so we can have a generative conversation?” I don’t think you get a seed to grow. I, too, haven’t planted a seed in a while. But I’m pretty sure there is no micromanagement of a seed, no manhandling of the seed itself, that you can engage in to “get” it to grow. But, like you say, you can cultivate the surroundings. And that’s a key realization to have when it comes to your social life and your relationships and conversations.</p><p>PK: It’s huge. And it’s so small and it’s so old. And it’s so obvious. Obviously I can’t make anyone do anything. Ever. And even if I could, it’d probably turn out the same as if I were to do that to a seed I’m hoping grows into a tree.</p><p>PB: Yeah. I think that’s where you start to run into violence and just general dysfunction. Things just not working. Or working for a bit until they break down cause the “getting” or the “making”, the force isn’t usually sustainable.</p><p>PK: I’m really interested in this cultivation thing now. Especially the whole indirect piece. We’ve talked about the kind of setting the scene. You’ve got food, drink, quiet, specific lighting and maybe you’ve got some non-romantic but soothing background music. Just like you’ve got the healthy soil, the right amounts of sunlight and water and probably lots of other things I don’t know about but are helpful and important for a seedling to grow into a tree. But what about the cultivation in the conversation. I mean, maybe those are all you need and it’s magic every time. I don’t know, I’ve never really set a scene like that with that intention. I also don’t know what I’m trying to ask here but it’s something about the inner workings of the conversation. As someone who’s practicing the art of conversation in this situation…. Hm not sure how to ask it, but it’s something like, what are the musical notes I need to learn? What are the theories about scales and improvisation and rhythm that I need to study and pay attention to when it comes to conversation that Miles Davis would be paying attention to as he learns to play jazz?</p><p>PB: Yeah. That’s a good question. One, because I think there are lots of answers and, two, because that analogy of Miles Davis makes me realize, er, maybe, guess, that he learned what he learned two different ways. He listened to a lot of music, not just jazz, he hung out with musicians and he played a lot. But that wasn’t all he did. He also went to Juilliard and learned the inner workings of music and techniques of old composers and studied the subject. I think I remember reading that he was a fan of Rachmaninoff. So, similarly, you’d have conversations and learn by doing but there are some things to be thinking about, to be aware of. If you were trying to pick up jazz as a trumpeter and you were completely unaware of even the concept of rhythm you wouldn’t get very far on your adventure. I think there’s probably something similar for, say, being aware that all listening isn’t the same. That you can hear what someone is saying and you can also listen deeply and you can also listen to the silence after someone speaks and you can absorb their body language and let it all settle like a newly poured soda water until you let your own response bubble to the surface. There’s a mystery in that that is on par with the mystery of something like syncopation. You know what I mean?</p><p>PK: Yes. That’s what I’m talking about. Listening would be the inner workings of the conversation that also need tending. That can aid in the cultivation. So you’ve got more to look at than just the soil which is like the surrounding sounds, lighting and food, etc.</p><p>PB: There’s definitely more to be aware of to cultivate. Isaacs has four things. Listening, respecting, suspending, and voicing. I’m sure there’s tons more. But that’d be a place to start.</p><p>PK: Let’s start with listening then. I like that idea.</p><p>PB: Works for me. Where should we start?</p><p>PK: I don’t know. I thought you were the one doing all this reading and exploring…</p><p>PB: I have been, but what do you want to know about listening? On second thought, maybe we can start with this question: Do you listen?</p><p>PK: Ha! Of course I listen!</p><p>PB: Cool. Then how do you know?</p><p>PK: I mean I have conversations with people. I hear what they say. Then I talk. I try to respond to what they say.</p><p>PB: OK. Perfect. We’ve got “listening” and we’ve got “hearing.” What is the difference between listening and hearing? In your mind? If there is one.</p><p>PK: I’m not sure there is a difference. I don’t really know what you mean.</p><p>PB: I think I can hear your voice. Your words, your accent, your tone. I can understand your logic, your grammar. But there’s a difference between hearing those aspects of your communication and gathering together your meaning.</p><p>PK: I see. Right. Well…</p><p>PB: What?</p><p>PK: Maybe I don’t really get you. I kind of see the difference.</p><p>PB: OK. Here’s a simpler, more surface level listening theme. Some see it as a skill to practice: paraphrasing. I’ve seen people use paraphrasing to accomplish two things. The first, is a bit off topic and it’s to draw out more information from someone in the style of a therapist that believes in “the talking cure.” This isn’t an example of paraphrasing, but it’s like when someone says, “say more about that…” and because you’re in the flow, you keep trying to get what you mean out. The second way is to make sure they understood what you’re saying. This usually sounds a little awkward. To me at least. It’ll go something like —</p><p>PK: “What I’m hearing you say is… you’ve seen people use paraphrasing in two ways.”</p><p>PB: Ha! Yes. Perfect. You get what I’m saying. And that’s a perfect example, because I’m more sure that you’ve gotten what I’m saying than if you hadn’t said that. I’m just assuming that you’ve heard my words and interpreted my meaning exactly as I’ve intended.</p><p>PK: It’s not always a safe assumption.</p><p>PB: Right. That’s conventional wisdom around communication. Never assume. But. Have you ever thought about why that is?</p><p>PK: You mean people miscommunicate? I’ve thought about it a bit. Certainly not extensively. Why? Have you?</p><p>PB: More and more. And to be honest, this is where I think the topic of listening gets really juicy. I’m just going to hope it’s not too out there for you.</p><p>PK: OK. We’ll see. Run it by me. Why do you think that people miscommunicate?</p><p>PB: I have no idea.</p><p>PK: Hahahaa. Glad you’re honest.</p><p>PB: I’m struggling to come up with a model or an analogy to describe what I want to say here. I guess I want you to picture the most complex thing in the universe. Maybe that thing looks like a Jackson Pollack painting. And then picture two paintings like that facing each other. They’re both massively complex and 100% different. They just share a similar color palate, let’s say.</p><p>PK: OK. I can picture that. Not exactly the most complex thing in the universe but I’ve at least got the paintings in my mind’s eye.</p><p>PB: Now let’s say that the paintings both “look” together at one little part of one of the paintings. And let’s say they both will perceive that piece. In doing so, they might fail to see how that piece is part of the whole fabric of the splatter painting and there is simply no way that the piece can be understood or appreciated separate from every other line and color. The gestalt that is the whole painting. But regardless, because the two (personified as strange as that is) paintings can’t look at the whole paintings in one fell swoop they can’t “get” even the piece. Does that make sense at all?</p><p>PK: Nope.</p><p>PB: Not even a little bit?</p><p>PK: Well, you’re saying that… you’re saying that we’re myopic.</p><p>PB: That’s not the nicest way to put that but it’s not far off. I guess it’s a question of what the effects of being myopic are. More often than not we don’t have the capacity, the wherewithal to intuit everything that is going on, all parts of a person, everything that is meant and could possibly be being meant. We’re limited. We can’t see the whole Pollack at once. We can rarely take it in all in one fell swoop. If ever.</p><p>PK: It sounds like you’re saying that if we were able to take in everything we wouldn’t miscommunicate ever again. Is that what you’re saying?</p><p>PB: Yes. I think so.</p><p>PK: But would we even need to communicate at all if that were the case?</p><p>PB: Probably not…</p><p>PK: Probably not. It is interesting to think about. If we assumed, just for conversation’s sake, that we had that innate capacity to intuit the all encompassing mass of meaning of a person and what they’re saying in a given interchange, but we can at the same time, safely assume that we cannot do so and do not do so on a regular basis, then what’s our problem? What causes us to not access our max capacity?</p><p>PB: What do you think?</p><p>PK: I don’t know. I just have this silly picture in my head of two people sitting together silently but in complete knowingness of what the other is thinking, feeling, knowing, having and being.</p><p>PB: Like a kind of oneness…</p><p>PK: Yeah. So you have another spectrum for thinking about conversations now. On one side you’ve got absolute complete communication. Something like oneness. And on the other you’ve got complete disconnect?</p><p>PB: Hrm. I’m not sure what’d be on the other side of that spectrum. Doesn’t seem like your standard miscommunication would really suffice given one side is absolute communicative oneness.</p><p>PK: But regardless of what’s on the other side, the question I’m more interested in exploring is what stands in the way? Why all the imperfect communication?</p><p>PB: Have you ever experienced something along those lines? Close to the complete communication side?</p><p>PK: To be honest, I don’t really think so…</p><p>PB: Yeah but there still has to be the best, no? Even if it doesn’t really hold a candle to the ideal…</p><p>PK: Nothing really comes to mind. What does come to mind as far as these questions go is the main reason why we never get close to that ideal is because we have too many thoughts flying around in our heads. Too much noise.</p><p>PB: That’s exactly it. Too much noise and not enough signal. This guy I keep talking about, Bill Isaacs, was heavily influenced by the Physicist David Bohm, as I think I’ve mentioned before. Late in his life, Bohm, a physicist, mind you, a guy whose PhD dissertation was used by Oppenheimer in his work on the Manhattan Project, we’re talking a scientist of the first degree, was heavily influenced by a guy by the name of Jiddu Krisnamurti who was selected early in his life to be the next World Teacher by the Theosophy organization. An influential physicist of Einstein’s mileu and a guy dubbed “World Teacher” (whatever that means), had dialogues late in their lives. Super interesting stuff. Anyways, I highly recommend reading anything by either of these guys, but I digress. My point in bringing Krishnamurti up is an awesome quote of his about listening. Take a read:</p><p>PK: “If we try to listen we find it extraordinarily difficult, because we are always projecting our opinions and ideas, our prejudices, our background, our inclinations, our impulses; when they dominate, we hardly listen at all to what is being said. In that state there is no value at all. One listens and therefore one learns, only in a state of attention, a state of silence, in which this whole background is in abeyance, is quiet; then it seems to me it is possible to communicate.”</p><p>PB: Usually the concept of “Noise” is juxtaposed with “Signal”. But you make a much better point that we’ve got a lot of noise swishing around in our minds and that’s what Krisnamurti is pointing to here. It’s impossible to really listen with all that going on.</p><p>PK: Ugh. So that’s really great and all. When I hear something like that I know it’s true. But it makes me feel totally hopeless. What the hell am I supposed to do now? Assuming I’d really like to have better conversations and connections with my loved ones, it means I need some sort of overhaul of my entire inner world. I just think there has to be a middle ground.</p><p>PB: Certainly. There’s an old old quote about the journey of ten thousand steps beginning with one. If getting to the kind of listening that Krishnamurti is talking about isn’t a journey of ten thousand steps then I don’t know what is. So, what I hear you asking is how do you begin? What’s the first step to move in the direction of experiencing a conversation where “the whole background is in abeyance?”</p><p>PK: Yes. How to get started always seems to be the question. Any ideas?</p><p>PB: Not really. You?</p><p>PK: Seems like everyone says meditation is the magic potion. I really struggle with it though…</p><p>PB: Yeah. I guess that makes sense to me. Krishnamurti is saying, silence is what will make it possible to listen and therefore to truly communicate. So, as with a lot of things, the beginning probably has some element of faking it until you make it. In this case you fake the experience of silence inside and outside of your mindbody for 9,900 steps and then as your journey of 10,000 steps comes to a close, the fake silence has happened to have grown into something truthier. That kind of approach makes sense to me.</p><p>PK: Just takes a lot of patience. And I want to have better conversations tomorrow. Not 10,000 steps from now. But regardless, I think I agree. The silence that Krishnamurti is talking about is sine qua non and there is no way for it to descend upon you overnight. Setting out with the expectation that it’s a journey of 10,000 steps runs counter to our culture of instant gratification, but, I think it’s truer. It gets back to cultivation really. I don’t feel like you’re trying to sell me something when you explain that it’s going to be so friggin hard… I just wish it weren’t…</p><p>PB: So hard. Aye. Nothing’s easy.</p><p>PK: You know what also isn’t easy?</p><p>PB: What?</p><p>PK: Silence in conversation. Like, we’re talking about silence within. And that’s an important piece of the puzzle but there’s also a time and a place for silence in a conversation itself.</p><p>PB: True. Reminds me of this notion of “reloading”. I do it a lot.</p><p>PK: You do what?</p><p>PB: Instead of listening I reload.</p><p>PK: What do you mean by reload?</p><p>PB: I come up with what I’m going to say next.</p><p>PK: Ah. Yes. Doesn’t everyone do that?</p><p>PB: Probably.</p><p>PK: What is not doing that you think?</p><p>PB: That’s a good question. I have some ideas about that. But first, think about this. You’re having a regular old everyday conversation. The person you’re talking to finishes what they’re saying. You let the thing that’s come to mind, that you’ve rehearsed and you want to say bubble up to the surface of your mind and then you’ve let it pass like an uncomfortable gas bubble in your tummy. You let what they’ve just said sink in. Wash over you. You see what else comes to mind. Really, when you think about it, whatever you were just going to say, that thing that had bubbled up to the surface, isn’t and couldn’t have been a response to what the person just said, because you came up with it as they were speaking so it couldn’t be. What do you think would happen if that was how you normally existed in conversation?</p><p>PK: I think it’d all be very different. I also think it’d be a slower, quieter conversation.</p><p>PB: That’s definitely true. While you’re letting what they’re saying wash over you, if they have truly finished what they’re saying, then you’ve got some silence right in the middle of your conversation.</p><p>PK: Exactly. And that’s really interesting to think about. Is that a good thing or a bad thing?</p><p>PB: I think there’s a time and a place for it. Similar to what we were saying about debate and discussion. There is a time to reload in conversation. When you’re having fun and bantering and have momentum. It’s a certain kind of conversation. But it’s not the only kind of conversation. If you’ve never had this more expansive version ever before, it might be worth trying occasionally.</p><p>PK: A time and a place. Fair. But what do you say? How do you know when the silence is done? And also, silence in conversation is almost always awkward. Isn’t it? Is that just me?</p><p>PB: I think it’s more common for it to be awkward than not awkward. I’ve certainly experienced non-awkward silences but I think you can get used to anything, especially silence in conversation.</p><p>PK: Part of me what’s to be like, this is a dumb idea. I resist this whole line of thinking. And part of me is like, “If you never do this, there is actually no conversation whatsoever.” You never actually hear what the other person is saying. You end up with a conversation in which no one is listening or connecting. Two people are just talking at each other in the same vicinity. And occasionally, some word will slip through the chatter flying around in a mind and that word will trigger what that person starts “reloading.” So, I guess what I’m saying is I get it…</p><p>PB: Yeah, you’ve just got trains passing in the night otherwise.</p><p>PK: There’s still something I’m not quite getting though. At what point, or how do you know when to give yourself license to break the silence?</p><p>PB: I think that’s where, if you do it enough, you train your conversational sixth sense. You begin to be able to listen to the conversation itself. What does the conversation need to have voiced? Not just me and what I need to voice. Not just whatever first popped into my mind. But what does the gestalt need have voiced next. You start to serve something larger than you.</p><p>PK: The conversation itself. I guess that’s true. There’s never going to be a good rule of thumb. It’s just not that kind of thing. You just know when the cookies are fully baked. You just know when the silence has communicated to the both of you what it needed to communicate.</p><p>PB: I really like that. It’s true. Silence can have something to say. You have silence sometimes that is heavy and sometimes it’s not. Sometimes it seems to say something. Full, heavy, pregnant. Silence can carry meaning. And meaning that is different altogether from the meaning the that words and sounds on either side of it carry. Pretty strange when you think about it. But also, maybe not if you consider it as similar to negative space in a painting. Any visual artist knows the power of negative space… So that makes the question in my mind, what would be the effect on our conversation lives of having a deeper understanding and appreciation for the negative space of conversation? Would it improve things or degrade them? And also, how could you share that appreciation of silence/negative conversational space with others? How would you teach it to a kid? Simply say, wait a few seconds after your interlocutor is done to begin saying what you want to say next?</p><p>PK: Something tells me that could work. That’s a decent place to start at least. It’d be an interesting experiment.</p><p>PB: I also think there’d be significant resistance. I think the urge to fill silence is more common than the other kind of urge. I might be biased by the availability of examples in New York City. Maybe there are other cultures that are slower to respond. I know for certain that there are some cultures and even genders that find simultaneous talking to be the way to go. So who knows if this is a saving grace.</p><p>PK: You’re right, I do think it’s more common to fill silence than otherwise. I guess what’s interesting about the point you bring up is that that might not be a bad thing.</p><p>PB: Agreed. I still wonder what’s lost in conversations without silence. Especially certain kinds of conversations.</p><p>PK: Like what kinds?</p><p>PB: Serious ones. Emotional ones. A friend of mine posted a good little animated video about empathy. When a friend comes to you with some overwhelming emotion that they’re experiencing at that moment, the best response usually isn’t saying the first thing that comes to mind. It’s better to provide space for the overwhelm to expand into. It’s more about sharing the burden in the form of listening than it is about responding per se. I’m pretty fascinated by the idea that silence has efficacy. The absence of something has the power to do, to accomplish, to effect. Isn’t that kind of weird?</p><p>PK: It is. It’s kind of a fun thought. I get that it’s true in a lot of other contexts. I’m picturing something in physics like “dark matter”, that kind of thing.</p><p>PB: That’s such a good point. “The Efficacy of Nothingness: A Memoir in Three Parts.”</p><p>PK: Hahaha. Not sure if I’d read it but, if I walked by the title I’d certainly pause and wonder…</p><p>PB: Ha! Same.</p><p>PK: You know, that kind of serious, emotional conversation isn’t the only time when silence and listening can be powerful.</p><p>PB: What are you thinking?</p><p>PK: I think it’s hard to talk about hard things. I’m thinking about a discussion over the holidays with family. It was about religion and the conversation got very heated. There are conversations where someone is feeling low and that empathy is key. But there are also conversations where people seem to have a lot on the line. The emotions they’re experiencing are very intense. I think silence and patience and listening deeply are called for in those moments as well. And they might even be more important.</p><p>PB: Yes. That leads us into the second conversational practice. Respect. If you think of act of listening as opening the door then the act of respecting is actively welcoming whatever might walk through the door, unconditionally.</p><p>PK: Huh, that’s an interesting analogy. I kind of like it. Doesn’t sound very easy though.</p><p>PB: Not in conversation. Not at all. If you also look at conversational behavior through the lens of mindfulness/mindlessness then listening prepares you to be more mindful of what you’re hearing and experiencing inside and out. But it’s very very easy to be mindless and by that I mean, reactive, especially with family. Though, to be honest, I’m not exactly sure why that’s the case.</p><p>PK: But it certainly is.</p><p>PB: It certainly is.</p><p>PK: So can we unpack this whole respecting thing then?</p><p>PB: Yes. Let’s.</p><p>PK: I’ve used the word without thinking about it my entire life. Now I’m wondering what the “respect” actually means.</p><p>PB: Love that question. I’ve thought a lot about it for many years. Like you already know, I get really stuck on etymologies. The core root of the word is “spect”, like “spectator,” or “perspective.” When you spectate you view, you look at, watch, perceive, take in. And then the “re-” like in “remember” or “return” or “rewind” simply gets you the “againiness” or “in return” or “back again.”</p><p>PK: So it’s a “looking back again” a “viewing in return”? Not sure that makes any more sense.</p><p>PB: I know. That’s what I’ve always struggled with. But it’s got to make sense somehow. It’s such a big word. It gets used so so much. It means so much to so many people. It’s this major major ego thing. You hear egos walking around saying, “You’re not respecting me!” I had a big falling out with an employer when I told her I didn’t feel respected. “Don’t respect you!” She roared and was very offended. So, it has to make sense somehow.</p><p>PK: I guess at the end of the day, the etymology doesn’t really matter. You understand what people mean when they say they don’t feel respected. But if the etymology helps you understand that experience more then that’s great.</p><p>PB: I think that’s right. I feel the same way. But in that way, I feel like that etymology points me to a deeper understanding. Another way to get out of the pie in the sky abstraction of respect is to say, am I respecting you right in the here and now. And if I’m not, how do we know?</p><p>PK: That’s interesting. You’re right that respect is very abstract even though it’s used so heavily in our culture. But I don’t feel like I have the intellectual heft to see respect going down in the here and now. It’s like I know what it is but as soon as I go and look for it unfolding now I can’t find anything. It’s almost like you only notice respect when it’s lacking. And when it’s lacking you just know it.</p><p>PB: Fair point. You know it when you see it. It’s just easier to see the absence as opposed to the presence. But that means we should be able to back into the positive meaning. If we don’t feel disrespected right now then we can assume that we’re respecting each other right now. Right?</p><p>PK: I think so…</p><p>PB: Same. So. How do you know we’re not disrespecting each other right now? That there’s no lack of respect in this conversation?</p><p>PK: I don’t know. But let me throw this out there. You’re accepting everything I’m saying. No. That’s close, but not what I was trying to say.</p><p>PB: I would say we’re looking back at each other. “Seeing each other.” I see you. You are seeing me. Maybe not the whole Jackson Pollack complex gestalt of me, but you are actively respecting me. There’s something to that “seeing.”</p><p>PK: Yes. There is.</p><p>PB: Isaacs has this great quote about respect that’s similar to this way of understanding it. “To respect someone is to look for the springs that feed the pool of their experience.” (loc 1701)</p><p>PK: I like that. That’s the problem with the Pollack painting example. The paintings are finished. They’re not dynamic. But a spring. A spring is evernew, evergreen, everfresh.</p><p>PB: Yes! So the mutual looking back at each other isn’t obviously a visual thing. And it’s not just hearing your words and taking them in in spite of the noise that’s flying around inside our heads. It’s almost something more active, more inquisitive. “OK you just said this, where does that come from?” “Where are you coming from as you say this?” “What brought this up for you?” In conflict mediation trainings they train you to always be thinking, “What’s really going on here?” So, basically, to respect, then you look for the source, the core, the origin story.</p><p>PK: That sounds really hard.</p><p>PB: Yeah. Like we’ve been saying about conversation as a whole. It’s an art. You can practice the scales, or one note or riff. Over and over and over. And always, when you start out it’s really hard. But then it gets easier. This has to be the same. But what’s interesting to me is why you think it’s so hard, cause I think you’re right.</p><p>PK: I think it’s hard because that frame isn’t what comes to mind first. What comes to mind first is… well, to say whatever comes to mind first.</p><p>PB: Exactly! I mean if whatever comes to mind first is relevant and honors that spring, moves in that direction that’s probably in the ballpark of respect.</p><p>PK: I think it’s also hard, like I was alluding to earlier, when the topic is intense. When opinions are strong. When emotions, as they say, are “riding high.”</p><p>PB: In those moments, respect is most certainly hardest to maintain. Isaacs talks about, “listening while noticing resistance,” and says, “In these moments you face the challenge of simply watching what comes up.” I have experienced doing this a little bit and not doing this a lot a lot. I also like to pretend I’m a little radical when it comes to interpreting that experience.</p><p>PK: Radical in what way?</p><p>PB: Well, I was reading something earlier and Jung and the “shadow” side of the consciousness came up. I tend to agree that that’s a helpful conception of consciousness. But it’s rare that people think that and accept that about themselves. And that’s fine. But what that notion leaves me with, along with my observations of myself in those moments of strong resistance to what someone is saying, is that there is some serious negative emotion going down in that moment.</p><p>PK: What negative emotion?</p><p>PB: Anger, fear… Hmm. Maybe that’s all of them… but that’s still meaningful, because I really struggle to differentiate between simply experiencing those emotions, experiencing the resistance to what someone is saying bubbling up to the surface, and violence. It’s the making of acting on the impulse to destroy or violate another. This notion that we have all of human potential sitting dormant inside us is a powerful one. It’s also humbling because it jives in no way with the narratives we so readily, so happily spin, about ourselves. And I think resisting them, refusing to acknowledge them, ignoring them, not claiming them in these moments, perpetuates them. Burns that fire more strongly. And that’s no bueno.</p><p>PK: I’m a little lost. You’re saying that when I’m at the family Thanksgiving dinner table and my Aunt starts droning on and on about her veiled, unacknowledged prejudices that happen to relate to my husband, that when I get the urge to scream at her and jump across the table and lay my hands and fingers around her neck, that I’m resisting something? Not acknowledging my Jungian “shadow” side?</p><p>PB: Hahahah. Yes? I guess what I’m saying is, when “emotions run high” as I think you put it earlier, what you just described is essentially what we’re wanting to express, but we tell ourselves, especially after the fact that we’re much better than we actually are. That we’re just nice, lovely people that are always kind and compassionate.</p><p>PK: So you’re saying we’re lying to ourselves about what’s really going on when we have heated conversations?</p><p>PB: OK, OK. That’s a much more succinct way to put it. Thanks. But, yes. I think that’s what I’m saying.</p><p>PK: So what?</p><p>PB: I think people avoid conversation to avoid seeing this part of themselves. I think there is a fear that this emotion might break the relationships at the table. And most important of all, I think that if we “simply watch what comes up,” I guess we’re getting into mindfulness here again, that our relationships and our heated conversations will improve. I think it will also allow us to more genuinely do that really hard thing we were just talking about.</p><p>PK: Which of the 10,000 hard things is that?</p><p>PB: Ha, to ask that question, though maybe not in so many words, “where are you coming from when you say that?”</p><p>PK: Right that hard thing. “Auntie, what’s really going on here underneath these veiled accusations that my husband is a bad father because he’s from _____ia?”</p><p>PB: Yup. That’s what I’m saying. Let that anger and fear and desire for complete and utter Shiva-like destruction wash over you without resisting it and the hard, difficult, intense, conversations at the family dinner table will transform before your eyes. That’s my little personal theory here. But what’s crazy given how packed up it is, but that whole perspective is packaged into the word respect. This is what you’re bringing to the table, to this moment in this conversation. This is where you’re at like it or not. This is what’s come up for you right here and right now. OK. I respect it. I look back at it. I see it again. I view it like a spectator. And as I do what washes over me in terms of my emotions and crazed reaction, I respect that too. I look at it and accept it for what it is.</p><p>PK: Not easy to do.</p><p>PB: Not at all. In fact, we’re now blending into Isaacs’ third conversational practice: Suspending.</p><p>PK: So we’ve got Listening, Respecting and Suspending? There’s one more, right?</p><p>PB: Aye. Voicing. I was forgetting about Suspending so I think I started blending the two quite a bit.</p><p>PK: What is it then?</p><p>PB: Basically what we were just talking about. When that knee-jerk reaction washes over you what do you do about it? But even more minutely, there is a rational side to it too. Not just this emotional one. And this is the piece of the puzzle I think I love most because it involves mystery and origination.</p><p>PK: Your favorite eh?</p><p>PB: Sure, why not. I think suspending is pretty powerful. Let’s go back to your Auntie talking about your husband.</p><p>PK: OK. Or maybe another example? Better to not hit so close to home…</p><p>PB: Fair. Let’s say you’re in a meeting. At work. And let’s say someone expresses an opinion that the company should do something in particular. Buy something or sell something. Or fire someone or hire someone. The way I think about it is, what are all the possible things someone in the meeting can do next?</p><p>PK: Well, what first comes to mind is they can express their own opinion. They can say nothing… Hmm. I’m trying to think… Are there others?</p><p>PB: Yeah. The heart of the work that is suspending. Wanna keep thinking?</p><p>PK: Let me break it down for a second. Either they can say something or say nothing. If they say something they can make a statement or ask a question. If they make a statement they can opine, think out loud. And if they ask a question the question could push in the same direction or a completely new one.</p><p>PB: Awesome. Solid break down. I think it’s fair to say that probably no matter what people in that meeting choose to do, there’s going to be the “next thought”. It might not be a good one a bad one or even a relevant one. This is what I think of more simply as a “reaction”. I think it’s extremely rare for someone to hear something in a meeting and not have a next thought or seven.</p><p>PK: I think that’s right.</p><p>PB: So I think of suspension as inquiring. He uses the word suspension because it means “to hang”. So you take the thing that was just said, you hang it up and you look at it. I always picture literally putting it on a closet hanger. Hang it up and just look at it. And really that’s it. That is all of suspension. But I think the best practice is to inquire into that thing’s origin story. Like I was saying earlier with respecting. “Where are you coming from when you say that?” Also, how did that opinion that you just expressed come to be? What is really meant? And that’s where you get into the mystery. For some reason, that’s hard to perceive for a regular old human, sometimes clouds will just precipitate. Where there was no raindrop in that cloud, where there was just water vapor floating and not being pulled to the center of the earth by gravity, suddenly there is a raindrop and it is falling. Similarly, there in the brain where there is no next thought or opinion suddenly there is one and it is being expressed. Why did that thought/word/opinion precipitate right then and there? And what’s cool about inquiry, or suspending like this, is it’s best to do it both for what you’ve just heard and your reaction to what you just heard. Or really, just whatever is floating around in your head.</p><p>PK: OK. I can see how that’s interesting. I think I can also see how it’d probably make conversation better by making it more reflective. I wonder how reasonable it is to expect people to do it often… or ever.</p><p>PB: True. I think I’ve maybe done it once. Well… maybe. I feel like I’ve been successful in doing it more often lately. But I agree, it’s hard to do and very unusual. Possibly even unnatural. Which is interesting to think about.</p><p>PK: So, I think I get it, but I’m not quite sure. Like I don’t think I could explain it to someone else. I feel like even if I did, they’d be like what’s the point of suspending, and I wouldn’t be sure of the answer.</p><p>PB: Hm. True. Now that I think about it, it sounds kind of pedantic. Ridiculously purist in a way. I think I thought about it in this conversation when you were talking about your reaction to hard family conversation at the dinner table. So let’s go back to that.</p><p>PK: OK.</p><p>PB: What are all of your possible reactions?</p><p>PK: To what?</p><p>PB: To hard moments in conversation with family. Those times when you’d prefer not to react in a certain way.</p><p>PK: I could scream and yell at her.</p><p>PB: OK. You could react with anger.</p><p>PK: Right. I could be silent and respond in no way whatsoever.</p><p>PB: Apathy… Fair.</p><p>PK: I could accept it. Agree with her, in order words. Even if I don’t.</p><p>PB: Accept her. Avoid engaging honestly.</p><p>PK: That’s harsh…</p><p>PB: Well it’s one of the possibilities…</p><p>PK: True. Let’s see. I could… I don’t know what else. I could either say something or say nothing.</p><p>PB: Yeah. You could say something on subject or change the subject.</p><p>PK: Ooh good point.</p><p>PB: You could mindlessly respond on subject or mindfully respond on subject. The same if you’re changing the subject.</p><p>PK: Interesting way to put it.</p><p>PB: On subject, mindfully or mindlessly, you could make a statement or ask a question. Also the same if you’re changing the subject.</p><p>PK: Here’s a thought. What you decide to do next conversationally, in theory, though probably pretty rarely, would depend on what you’re trying to accomplish in the conversation. What your purpose is…</p><p>PB: That seems very true to me. Very good point. What’s the purpose of your conversations then, when you’re at the dinner table with the family?</p><p>PK: Hmm. I feel like the answer to this should be obvious but I’m not quite so sure. All that comes to mind are trite truisms: to spend time together. To better get to know each other. To simply be a family. To be present with each other. To understand each other. To love each other. I really have no idea. It kinda gets back to that idea around utility. Maybe it’s just conversation for the sake of itself.</p><p>PB: Interesting thought. If there is a time for conversation for the sake of itself, it does seem like it’d be at the dinner table with family.</p><p>PK: Agreed. But now that doesn’t seem to help with the whole, what to do next question.</p><p>PB: I suppose not. What about the quality angle?</p><p>PK: As in which of all these possible options would bring about the highest quality conversation?</p><p>PB: Mmmhhmmm.</p><p>PK: Well. I think we’re on to something here, but I will say, what comes to mind is that we’ve been pretty biased. I was just thinking of this personality test I took recently and I kinda think that if you’re this very particular personality type, you’re going to have a very different opinion about what makes for a high quality conversation. So we should bookmark that for the future.</p><p>PB: That’s a good point. Mental note.</p><p>PK: So back to the family thing then. Let’s say I assume saying something on subject and doing so mindfully is best case scenario.</p><p>PB: OK. What do you do? What do you say in that scenario?</p><p>PK: I’m thinking I’d ask a question.</p><p>PB: Why?</p><p>PK: Because… I don’t know. Because I want to know my family member better. Things just got hard, intense, emotional. What’s going on? Why are emotions starting to run high all of a sudden? I might as well find out.</p><p>PB: And you’d find out by asking a question. Makes sense to me. Fairly simple and obvious. What if you decide to or need to go the statement route. What’s that path look like?</p><p>PK: Hm. I’m not sure. “Thank you for sharing”?</p><p>PB: Maybe. Isaacs talks about suspending in certain moments as “displaying your thinking” which I love. Just like you can inquire into the origin story of someone else’s thought/way of thinking/opinion you can kind of inquire out loud about your own.</p><p>PK: Oh, that reminds me, I forgot about paraphrasing. I think that’s kind of similar. Someone says something in an intense moment at the dinner table and you can paraphrase or you can display as you’re saying your reaction or thinking. I like that too.</p><p>PB: Yeah, it’s like, I suddenly have this opinion, but I’m not going to get super attached to it. So let’s you and I both examine it and see what it’s about. What it’s doing there.</p><p>PK: That strikes me as super rare and hard to do. I guess I keep saying that though. So who cares if it’s hard to do… It’s certainly something you can do.</p><p>PB: Right. Hard or not you can always choose to attach yourself or not to some opinion that’s popped into your head.</p><p>PK: That sounds like you’re simplifying it. Though. Some opinions are pretty longstanding. And I’d assume the longerstanding the harder to choose not to attach yourself.</p><p>PB: No, you’re absolutely right. None of this is all that simple. Like you’re saying it is very very hard to do. But that doesn’t mean it’s not a very cool and interesting way to go or approach to experiment with to see what happens.</p><p>PK: You ever done it?</p><p>PB: Ha. I doubt it. Nice thought though. Suspend your thought. Display your thinking. Unattach yourself to your opinions. Be superhuman. Yadda yadda yadda.</p><p>PK: I’m beginning to wonder if we all intuit this stuff and know it’s hard so we just don’t bother. I really can’t imagine a world where everyone is suspending at all times. I have a hunch it’d be a wildly different world. I bet miscommunication would cease and conversation would be much more creative.</p><p>PB: Or generative like in the fourth conversational type that Isaacs talks about…</p><p>PK: Right. Or generative. Well, actually, how would that happen? We’re having this intense conversation as a family at the dinner table. And miraculously I manage to display my thinking or ask my auntie to display hers. “This just occurred to me and I think this is maybe how it occurred to me. What do you think about that Auntie of mine?” How do we get from debate or discussion or whatever to generation or generating newness?</p><p>PB: Do you see? That question opens a door. It’s an invitation into a new room. There’s your newness. There’s this colleague of Isaacs’ by the name Scharmer, Otto Scharmer and he has his own understanding of conversational spaces. The one that corresponds to Isaacs’ transactional type of conversation is “Downloading.” It’s when you’re in conversation and everything that people are saying are things that they’ve already thought, known, understood, said or heard before. In the downloading space you’re just passing along what’s already been created. No newness. And like we keep saying “Downloading” isn’t bad. It’s just not the only conversational mode to enjoy conversation in.</p><p>PK: You’re saying when people suspend they pose questions that make it more likely that something entirely new will get said or thought or discovered in the conversation.</p><p>PB: Oui. That’s what I’m saying. What do you think?</p><p>PK: Are you suspending on me right now?</p><p>PB: Hrm. I don’t think so. But really what do you think?</p><p>PK: I think it’s an interesting proposition. I’ve been in conversations like that. I think when it’s heated it’s even less likely that they’ll be productive… Productive. That’s an interesting way to put it. Like generative. So I guess I’ve experienced that. Downloading is just talking in circles. I express my opinion and then you express yours and then we say the same things in slightly different ways. We bat it back and forth. Ping pong it out. But we’re stuck. In a loop. I guess the whole suspending thing makes sense in that you’re saying it’s a doorway into newness. It’s an invitation to get out of the loop. To not be stuck anymore. Instead we can start to respect the polarizations. We can stop trying to fix them or oppose them. I guess getting back to respecting we can also stop requiring the other to change too. (loc 1957)</p><p>PB: A lot of the time we’re talking in circles and we don’t know that there is a way to get off that little merry-go-round.</p><p>PK: It’s starting to make more sense to me. Still sounds comically hard though.</p><p>PB: Yeah. I think it is. But I’ve felt that way anytime I was learning something new until I have this moment in which I’m like, I’ve gotten a lot better! This is awesome! So it being hard can’t be the end all be all here. Just a facet of it.</p><p>PK: So you’ve got listening, respecting and suspending. What I think is funny about these is that when I think of conversation I think of talking and I think for the most part, none of these explicitly have anything to do with talking. With speaking words out loud. Does this book of yours talk about talking at all?</p><p>PB: Indeed it does! That’s the fourth practice. What do you think it is?</p><p>PK: Talking?</p><p>PB: More or less. He calls it “voicing.” And as you’d expect it goes a lot deeper than simply saying words.</p><p>PK: Of course it does…</p><p>PB: Let’s start here. When you’re having a conversation with someone, how do you know what to say?</p><p>PK: Ugh, I have no idea. I will say, sometimes I overthink it. Sometimes I just blurt stuff out. In those moments I don’t know what I’m going to say before I say it. At least I don’t know the exact words. I might have a quick notion of the meaning I want to get across but I haven’t written it out in my mind and then rehearsed it and then said it.</p><p>PB: It’s funny. That might be at the root of my interest in conversation. I used to rehearse everything I was going to say. And I ended up a quiet kid as a result. By the time I had everything rehearsed it wasn’t even remotely relevant to say what I had just finished rehearsing. And I feel like I can say with almost absolute certainty that conversations in which I try to only say what I’ve sort of, pre-recorded, so to speak, are just plain poor conversations. And that’s saying something. I rarely feel like I can say something with that much certainty.</p><p>PK: Generally, I think you’re right. I wonder why we do that though? I wonder if other people do that too?</p><p>PB: I honestly don’t know, but I doubt we’re that unique. Regardless, I like that question. Do you know why you rehearse what you’re going to say before you say it? I know why I used to.</p><p>PK: I’m not sure. You go first.</p><p>PB: I’m pretty sure it was, actually, I probably do it now, so also, is, because I’m afraid that I’ll get to a point in what I’m saying and completely forget my point. Aaaaaand then I’ll look stupid. And I don’t want to look or sound stupid. Which I suppose isn’t unique either.</p><p>PK: Hm. I think I might do it for that reason, but I might also do it because I want to say exactly what I’m trying to say. I want to get my meaning right. I guess I’m still thinking of the dinner table. I suppose that if I were with new people I’d do it in order to not look stupid like you’re saying.</p><p>PB: You’re right. The context is important for answering this one. But when you’re trying to get your meaning right, how do you know what the exact meaning is that you’re trying to get across? And how do you know when it’s ready? When it’s just right?</p><p>PK: I don’t know. I guess it just kinda comes to mind and then I know… I think.</p><p>PB: Fair point. That’s a hard question to answer. Let me ask you this. What do you do when you’re at your most authentic? When you’re being the most genuine? I ask because I bet you’re aware of a difference. Especially when it comes to other people.</p><p>PK: Hm. That’s a really good question. I certainly don’t want to admit to myself or to you that I’m sometimes authentic and sometimes not…</p><p>PB: I suppose I don’t either.</p><p>PK: Does anyone? Do you really think anyone can break down their own authenticity?</p><p>PB: I think people have thoughts on it. I think they’re probably biased, but I feel like I’ve had conversations about this. Maybe not breaking it down so much. But I think a common response is identifying a difference between being with friends and smalltalking with strangers, say, at a cocktail party. In one you’re sharing your “real” self and in another you’re trying to portray a certain, maybe more polished version of yourself. Or maybe more simply like we were saying, just trying hard not to look stupid.</p><p>PK: Well when you put it like that. That’s obvious. But in the context of what we were just talking about, that’s a whole other thing. It’s like in that question you’re asking for some sort of litmus test for how I know when something I’m about to say is going to come across as authentic. That’s a crazy question to ask. There’s no way anyone knows anything about that. That’s got to be unconscious. That does make me think that you lose authenticity when you over think.</p><p>PB: Why is that?</p><p>PK: I don’t know. Isn’t that a kind of truism in our culture? Don’t overthink shooting the basketball? Don’t overthink your answer to the multiple choice test? The minute you do you’re sunk? Isn’t that the narrative we live in?</p><p>PB: I think you’re right, but what I’m asking is what’s going on in the mind that makes that so? Especially when it comes to speaking authentically…</p><p>PK: Maybe it has something to do with the “thinking”. When you overthink what you want to say next, what are you actually doing?</p><p>PB: Ha! I think I’m talking to myself. And probably debating what I should or shouldn’t say, or how I should or shouldn’t say it.</p><p>PK: You debate. That’s funny. You don’t have a dialectic or a generative dialogue with yourself about what to say?</p><p>PB: Hahaha, I guess not. What about you?</p><p>PK: I don’t know. I suppose I do do the same sometimes. I certainly talk to myself.</p><p>PB: In your head or out loud?</p><p>PK: Both…</p><p>PB: Same.</p><p>PK: Conversations within conversations about what to say next in the conversation. Pretty silly.</p><p>PB: Humans are funny beings.</p><p>PK: Indeed.</p><p>PB: Maybe that’s the thing about authenticity. In a more authentic conversation, that conversation within your head is had out loud. Whoever you’re talking to is included in your thinking.</p><p>PK: That’s true for me in some conversations. Probably the better ones come to think of it. The thing is. You can’t share all of it. There just isn’t enough time and aren’t enough words to get it all out. Also, the people you’re talking to would never have the chance to get a word in edgewise.</p><p>PB: True. So maybe it’s a spectrum thing. Never perfectly authentic, but there is certainly more and less authentic and there are things you can do to move up and down that spectrum.</p><p>PK: Could be…</p><p>PB: I guess this whole voicing/authenticity thing really comes down to the filter. The filter that kind of controls what stays in and what gets out. It strikes me that it’s like improvisation. There’s an art to it. It’s learned. Whether you’re aware of the learning or not. I’m pretty sure in jazz you play around musically with a chunk of music, play variations of a riff. That’s the method to the art, to the madness. We probably have similar unspoken rules around voicing as well. Even if we can’t say what they are…</p><p>PK: That sounds right to me.</p><p>PB: What if we turn it around for a sec? It can be hard to reflect on our own inner processes. So tell me this, when you sense someone is genuine/authentic what’s going on there? And vice versa, what triggers your “bullshit meter?”</p><p>PK: Yeah that’s an easier way to go about it. Well, actually, it’s still hard. I’m still not sure. You just know. Right? It’s tone of voice. It’s face and body language. Sometimes someone is talking in a way that you’ve seen before so they’re clearly mimicking someone else as opposed to speaking more naturally. Huh. I don’t know. I’m just rambling…</p><p>PB: It’s not easy. It strikes me that voicing is a lot about you, about the person speaking but it’s also about the conversation itself. Back to that whole gestalt thing. You have speaking in a way that is natural to you. You have saying something that is unfiltered and honest. And you also have saying what the conversation needs to have said next. You’re an authentic channel for the conversation itself. So the conversation can be authentic. And to do that I think you need to really be present and listening deeply to what’s coming up inside you. When you say something, as you prepare it, you take in all possible ingredients, your past experience, your emotions, your “reason”, all of your influences and you synthesize them all together to make what you’re going to say next. It’s kind of amazing really. And, if you’re doing all of that when, speaking, it makes sense that not overthinking it is important. Cause if you’re thinking about it, then that’s extra work to do. And, I suppose, in theory, your system is already built for doing that work. For making meaning in conversation with other human beings. It’s been doing that for millions years.</p><p>PK: True. Powerful stuff. I get a little lost though. I think I keep saying that. But whatever. I start thinking, OK. You keep bringing up this notion of conversation. And speaking, almost on behalf of conversation. That’s a nice and interesting take on it. But I lose sight of what the point of conversation is. Isn’t it to express myself? Or rather, the point of speaking. I’m supposed to say/express the thoughts and feelings flying around in my head. Or am I way off?</p><p>PB: No. You’re way on. I think like we’ve said about transactional conversations and debate and discussion there’s a time and a place for all of it. And again we’re on a spectrum. I’m just kind of wondering out loud what if this way of speaking, when you’re not overthinking and you’re expressing not just the next thought that comes to mind but what the conversation is seeking to express, or some hybrid of the two, it might describe another kind of conversation, one that’s off the typical conversational map and might be a great quality conversation. If you’re in therapy or you just need to get something off your chest as you’re telling your mate about your day, then yes, of course, the point of your conversation is probably to express yourself and the next thought in your head.</p><p>PK: Right good point.</p><p>PB: I think the point I’m trying to make and doing a poor job of it, or beating around the proverbial bush of it is that, in high quality conversation we’re creating, we’re making meaning. We’re not just unloading or downloading. Conversation is rarely acknowledged as a creative act, or an act of creation. But I think not acknowledging that it is an act of creation limits us. It robs us of one of the great human experiences. When we speak we create. We bring meaning into existence. As human beings we’re meaning makers and that’s cool. And I guess the last point is that some spaces and practices and attitudes bring that aspect of our humanness out more than others. And articulating what those are is pretty cool too.</p><p>PK: That is definitely true. There is much more power in that attitude and maybe just more truth.</p><p>PB: Aye.</p><p>PK: So what meaning have we created here over these past few hours?</p><p>PB: Huh. I don’t know. My first inclination is to say that the real answer to that is a bit of a mystery. That it’s complex enough given that you experience all this differently than I do makes answering that question an impossible task.</p><p>PK: I also think while I understand what you mean when you say that we’re meaning making beings, or however you put it, I really have no clue what that means. But I still get it. But I don’t.</p><p>PB: I think that’s why my mind immediately wanders towards the explanation that it’s all a mystery; the meaning we’ve made in this chat.</p><p>PK: It’s funny. Some of the analogies we used earlier on were so simple. You have a seed, soil, sunlight and water. But it’s true. I guess when you get right down to it, there is still a lot of mystery in understanding how all of those elements come together into a fully-fledged, say, weeping willow tree. It’s kind of amazing when you think about it.</p><p>PB: Yeah. Especially when you think how many barren cubic miles there are in the universe, there happen to be these things on our nearby cubic miles called “weeping willow” trees and they started as wee seeds.</p><p>PK: The meaning we create like the tree that all those elements create, mysteries.</p><p>PB: Damn beautiful mysteries at that too.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=885ac8f24aa0" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/a-conversation-about-conversation/tangled-885ac8f24aa0">The Convo</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/a-conversation-about-conversation">A Conversation about Conversation</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[resources: requests/limits]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TommyDyer/resources-requests-limits-1aa6fded50e6?source=rss-3304f0f0d87a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1aa6fded50e6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[docker]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pods]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kubernetes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[devops]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Covington Dyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 04 May 2018 13:30:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-04T13:30:27.978Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>noob asks:</strong> what are best practices for setting resource requests/limits for a given pod?</p><p><strong>mentor says:</strong> biggest thing about resource requests is alway setting them, otherwise the scheduler can’t bin pack effectively. workloads without resource requests and limits use unpredictable resources so the scheduler can’t easily match up multiple workloads that can fit on a single host, for example.</p><p>depending on the app, but for most stateless apps, it’s good to be conservative with resource limits and scale up with replicas if the app can tolerate it, but if you are running things at scale generally it’s an optimization question for the app itself.</p><p>e.g. is it cpu bound? if so match its requests and schedule it on nodes that match its requirements to avoid unscheduleable resources on a node</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1aa6fded50e6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Organizational Culture Basics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TommyDyer/organizational-culture-basics-4c79175dd18f?source=rss-3304f0f0d87a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4c79175dd18f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[organizational-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Covington Dyer]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Jan 2016 15:34:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-01-22T15:34:21.286Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Organizational Culture Basics</strong></p><p>In a previous post on organizational culture basics I shared Schein’s three levels of culture and told you that he coined the term “corporate culture”. That’s a great start. Artifacts → Beliefs/Values → Assumptions. Great.</p><p>What I skipped over completely, however, was a formal definition of culture. Schein provides one. I’m working on my own. I encourage you to do the same. But let’s hear his first:</p><p>“… a pattern of shared basic assumptions learned by a group as it solved its problems of external adaptation and internal integration, which has worked well enough to be considered valid and therefore, to be taught to new members as the correct way to perceive, think and feel in relation to those problems.” (loc. 589)</p><p>I think this is a brilliant definition, but, taken out of context like it is here causes a bit of confusion. Let me explain a couple things first.</p><ul><li>“problem of external adaptation” — What on earth does this mean? If you really, really want to know, read the book. If you want a quicker understanding here and now think about this. As your group or organization lives and breathes in the world, like any living creature, it needs to take in energy from the environment and put out waste. In other words, it needs to have a balanced, give-and-take relationship with the “external environment.” We all know that that is common sense. An example of external adaptation in a company is Zappos.com adapting early in its life to the fact that they could not deliver fantastic customer service to customers that purchased drop-shipped items from their site. They adapted to this external environment problem by putting all their weight behind inventoried product ; product that they could deliver with fantastic customer service.</li><li>“internal integration” — This is a concept that deals with group dynamics. As people enter the group, questions arise, consciously or unconsciously, spoken or unspoken, like: who is really in power? will anyone like me? will conflict be pushed beneath the surface or be voiced and dealt with immediately? In truth the questions are almost infinite. Once they are answered, as inevitably they are (whether we know it or not, or want those answers or not), they fall back into the background and become basic assumptions that, as Schien says in the definition above, are learned and passed on to all future group members.</li></ul><p>Schein, with this definition, makes culture a dynamic, living process in constant flux and deep in the unconscious of the group or organization as a whole. To him, “culture is to a group as personality or character is to an individual,” (loc. 519). It is deep and behind the scenes; not just the artifacts that surround the group nor the ways the group has fun. It is the strongest force there is in organizational life.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4c79175dd18f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>