<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Tylor on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Tylor on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@TylorLovins?source=rss-58c7b9ab08b0------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 20:11:39 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@TylorLovins/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the Courage to Speak of God]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christianity-now/on-the-courage-to-speak-of-god-bfa8d36616a3?source=rss-58c7b9ab08b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bfa8d36616a3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dogs]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 Sep 2017 15:06:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-09-27T15:06:11.590Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>May 1, 2017/in <a href="http://christianity-now.com/category/christianity/">Christianity</a> /by <a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/tylor/">Tylor Lovins</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l1s-wBySjHGo0RpL7q1Zhw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Most of us know people who aren’t inclined to speak for themselves. People who, when asked where they’d like to eat, what they’d like to do, or what they’re interested in, respond by deferring to either group opinion or a kind of verbally confused pantomime. They don’t want to step on anyone’s feet, and they’re very polite. All this comes from a good mix of civility and conscientiousness, but we’ve also seen when it can work against them. Their significant others or siblings walk all over them, or we, ourselves, knowing their proclivity to defer, manipulate them in ways we wouldn’t others.</p><p>I’ve noticed I’m this person sometimes. I can sink into a swamp of uncomfortable silence, produced by my inability to speak courageously — to question the authoritarian assertions of others, especially when these deal with God. I want to be sympathetic to the deeply held beliefs people I talk with understand themselves by, although I can’t help thinking there is tremendous moral and spiritual value in following one’s beliefs to their logical ends. These logical ends are rarely found in the wilderness of the psyche, though. There are moments I think back to shameful experiences that keep me trapped, stultifying any ambition to be someone other than who I have been. In these instances, overwhelmed by emotion and passions that are irreducible to any rational systematizing, the thought of “logical ends” is nonexistent.</p><p>And so my awareness of my own faults makes me wonder: what if, at bottom, when I’ve explored my faith to its deepest level, I find nothing more than a well-intentioned six-year old version of myself yearning for acceptance — from my friends, my parents, and the gods of my small world. It frightens me to consider, but is all this talk about God no more than seemingly self-effacing statements about loving others, statements perniciously motivated by a selfish quest for self-transcendence?</p><p>If we say with Nietzsche that the sky is empty, then what use is there in being clear about what we mean when we talk about God? Isn’t it better to leave divinity in the ineffable and inarticulate realm of the emotional? There are many things we experience that we can’t really articulate or define, like the smell of a cup of coffee. But this doesn’t make the experience less real. Perhaps it is here, deep within our inner selves, that we experience, maybe just for a moment, a transcendence pervading and exceeding everything about which we may speak.</p><p>We find ourselves living in what is called “postmodernity.” Postmodernity is, to a certain extent, defined by its opposition to claims of ultimacy, manifested in the forms of pluralism, feminism, and other such movements. This has its place, being a well-warranted critique of our propensity towards systems of oppression and domination. There are side effects, though, and they may not be readily apparent. Postmodernism has a subtle tendency to harbor in some a fatalistic denial of clear expressions of self, making it difficult to distinguish who we are and what we want, of what we understand our intentions to be and what they really are. We have become justifiably fearful about standing on ground that is too firm. But when rationality is seen as nothing more than a symbol of oppressiveness, our experiences lose the significant element of critical reflection and become too groundless, too fluid to be grasped at all.</p><p>A discussion on the concept of God seems, in part, impossible for those of us living in a postmodern age. We are wary of strictly rational inquiry, fearful of its domineering gestures, finding any claims to objectivity senseless, for who can see anything — let alone the divine — from all angles? To be everything for every person, to be omniscient, is the demand made upon claims of truth in our day. But maybe this isn’t the kind of articulation appropriate for communicating the meaning of God. Maybe, to harken back to the first centuries of the movement, the meaning of God is closely associated with personal testimony.</p><p>On my pantheon of theological heroes sits, above all others, Rudolf Bultmann. His work involved articulating the Christian faith to the modern world, without recourse to metaphysics or supernaturalism — the very mission of Christianity Now. When Bultmann encountered soldiers returning from World War I, he discovered traditional ways of talking about God and the Gospel were inadequate to the realities World War I brought to pass, not only for the soldiers he met but the German intellectual scene in general. He developed the project of<a href="http://www.oxfordbiblicalstudies.com/article/opr/t94/e512">demythologizing</a> to open a pathway where theology could avoid the Christian message’s traditional dependence on Greek philosophical concepts. Jettisoning this first century worldview which no longer held, he proposed relying more firmly upon modern ways of understanding ourselves and the universe. He intended to place Christian thought in its appropriate context of modern thought.</p><p>By aiming to disabuse all who believed that thinking about God in general, logical statements was the only way in which thinking about God should, or could, occur, Bultmann placed the lived experience of faith as both central to the theological project and our talk about God. He does this, in large part, by leveraging the insights of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rudolf_Otto">Rudolf Otto</a>: religious experience encounters the divine as that which is uncontrollable and omnipotent. This means that we cannot bend the divine to human purposes, cannot rationally conceive of the divine, nor can we live outside the divine’s reach. It follows, argues Bultmann, that traditional logical conceptions of God which attempt to grasp God’s reality through arguments and proofs are both sacrilegious and nonsense. We must turn to lived experience to understand God.</p><p>To talk <em>about </em>anything is to objectify that which we talk about, because talking <em>about </em>something involves making observations, standing on the outside of what we speak, and identifying the object of speech with the descriptions we give. Compare talking <em>about</em> love and <em>being in</em> love. Describing the chemical processes that occur while one is said to be “in love” is different from the experience of being in love. In other words you won’t find love in scientific textbooks.</p><p>Similarly, the objectifying way of speaking about God isn’t the same thing as encountering the divine, Bultmann says, because the concept of omnipotence, of the uncontrollable, for religious people precludes any attempt to escape the divine’s grasp or reach. The person who believes in God cannot stand outside God, cannot exist outside God’s power, and talk about God as some <em>thing </em>other, an object apart from one’s lived experience. Objectifying ways of speaking, ultimately, reduce the sacred to the profane, either morphing the unapproachable, uncontrollable reality of the divine into a supernatural super-human being, or sterilizing the depths of experience with bland, bloodless generalities.</p><p>The path Bultmann forged some half century ago still holds significance today for those thinking about the Christian message in light of the progress of science, changes in culture, and the postmodern turn in philosophy. If part of the essence of the divine is that it is inescapable, then we don’t have to project beyond ourselves or look for general logical truths to reflect on its reality or meaning. We must instead critically and rationally reflect on our experiences, the good and the bad.</p><p>We are no longer in the stronghold of claims to ultimacy. But this doesn’t nullify our responsibility to be clear and honest with ourselves. Conceivably, if I go deep enough into my experiences, beliefs, and frames of reference, I might discover that the God I’ve testified to for so long is no more than a reflection of myself. And yet, through this jarring realization, I’ll be free for the first time to destroy that idol, opening myself up to new ways of thinking and experiencing, and, if I’m fortunate enough, attain liberation from my own self-imposed purgatories. Only when we stand on the grounds of honesty and sincerity are we able to testify to the God that is real beyond our concepts of God — a God that is truly transcendent, inescapable, and liberating.</p><p>The extreme rigidity and totalizing character that rationality can sometimes take fails to speak to the reality of the divine. Likewise, the anti-rational stance that too often accompanies postmodern attitudes debilitates and destabilizes us to such an extent that we are unable to become aware of, and question, our desires to speak of the divine in the first place, keeping us from the very confrontation we must have in order to authentically speak of God at all. If, with Bultmann and the demands of the modern world, we cease claiming ultimate truth for our conceptions of the divine, we must learn how to <em>testify</em> to our experiences, to give voice to our liberations and struggles, to our ways of being and ways of thinking. And this involves questioning who we are at our deepest levels: to stand under question.</p><p>Beginning the conversation about what it means to say “God” will require the courage to reflect critically about our experiences and ideas, and courage it will take to be open enough to consider alternative perspectives and to speak for oneself, even though we may always be wrong. If we cannot journey into the wilderness of our psyches to make our best attempt at understanding God, ourselves, and others, calling ourselves into question under the demands of clarity and love, then we’ll be devoured by our unconscious motivations, and our talk about God will be empty and idle.</p><p>[i] Rudolf Bultmann. “What it means to speak of God,” 1923.</p><p>[ii] Ibid.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/tylor/">Tylor Lovins</a></p><p>Founder | Content Coordinator at <a href="http://christianity-now.com/courage-speak-god/Christianity-Now.com">Christianity Now</a></p><p>Tylor studied philosophy at Anderson University, concentrating in the philosophical works of Martin Heidegger and Ludwig Wittgenstein. He also <br>studied the theological and religious works of Rudolf Bultmann and D. Z. Phillips.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bfa8d36616a3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now/on-the-courage-to-speak-of-god-bfa8d36616a3">On the Courage to Speak of God</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now">Christianity Now</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[No More Martyrs]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christianity-now/no-more-martyrs-2cec6a4d1604?source=rss-58c7b9ab08b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2cec6a4d1604</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[faith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blacklivesmatter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 10 Sep 2017 18:57:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-09-10T18:57:10.179Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>September 4, 2017/in <a href="http://christianity-now.com/category/christianity/">Christianity</a> /by <a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/bentapper/">Ben Tapper</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BP-Dq6mDJr41g7LVsVwFZQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>We don’t need another martyr. This thought first came to mind as I listened to a spoken word performance by a friend of mine, Manon Bullock. She was referencing the death of Rekia Boyd in Chicago, a Black woman shot dead by an off-duty white police officer in 2012. She said if we could have chosen any outcome for Rekia Boyd, martyrdom would not have been included in the calculation. This struck a chord deep within me — a chord of dissonance. Growing up in the evangelical Christian church instilled within me many positive associations with martyrdom. One could show no greater commitment to a cause than to be willing to die for it. I thought martyrdom was honorable, selfless, and typically served to bolster whatever cause the martyr was willing to die for. The greatest example of the glory of martyrdom was believed to be Jesus. Some understand that Jesus willingly allowed himself to be crucified so that we could have access to God’s forgiveness. I once believed these things, but life experience has a strange way of challenging assumptions.</p><p>In the gospel of John, the High Priest Caiaphas is quoted as saying, “You do not understand that it is better for you to have one man die for the people than to have the whole nation destroyed” (John 11:50 NRSV). The author of the gospel then adds an explanation. “He did not say this on his own, but being high priest that year he prophesied that Jesus was about to die for the nation, and not for the nation only, but to gather into one the dispersed children of God” (John 11:51–52 NRSV). We have two separate myths at play here: the myth of martyrdom and the myth of the sacrificial lamb. Readers might imagine the author of the gospel wants them to believe Caiaphas felt Jesus would eventually cause such a problem that the Romans would send in their army and destroy Jerusalem. It would therefore be a social good for Jesus to die so the people would be spared. Caiaphas seemed to believe, by killing Jesus, the Jewish leadership could ward off a Roman invasion. Jesus then becomes the sacrificial lamb.</p><p>While Caiaphas seems to view Jesus as a lamb to be sacrificed, the author of the gospel of John is operating with the myth of Jesus as the martyr. “No one has greater love than this, to lay down one’s life for one’s friends. You are my friends if you do what I command you” (John 15:13–14 NRSV). Here the author purports that Jesus is hinting at his death. The words “lay down one’s life” connote a voluntary sacrifice. When Jesus is arrested in the garden of Gethsemane, he willingly asks who the soldiers were looking for and steps forward. This paints a picture of Jesus as voluntarily choosing to die for a greater cause. The author suggests Jesus, by giving his life, will bring together God’s children.</p><p>Both myths are driven by our propensity to discover something positive in bad situations, or to justify actions with unintended or evil consequences. To frame assassinations and martyrdoms as anything else than the tragedies they are is an easy, and almost natural, thing to do. We seek to attach greater meanings to deaths in order to make the loss more palatable, but the deaths of Jesus, Martin Luther King Jr., Mahatma Ghandi and many others were not part of God’s plan, nor were they preordained moments required to realize freedom, peace or stability. How could the God who is synonymous with love create a plan that involves the brutal murders of her children?</p><p>The myths of martyrdom and the sacrificial lamb have allowed the church to support ideas which run counter to the love of God. If we believe the crucifixion was a necessary precursor to the glory of the resurrection or ascension, it becomes easier to understand, for example, Dr. King’s assassination as a necessary precursor to increased Civil Rights protections for African Americans. It wasn’t. In fact, the most monumental legislative victories of the Civil Rights movement, the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965, were accomplished while Dr. King was still alive, motivated by the protests he led in Birmingham and Selma respectively. Progress is possible without murders and assassinations. If we can glorify and even celebrate the crucifixion, or any assassination, as outcomes of God’s will, then the deaths of Mesha Caldwell, Rekia Boyd, Pedro Villanueva, John Wallace III, and countless others become easier to stomach as necessary events on a path to social and legal reform. As a result, by idealizing death, we become numb to the reality of the losses we’re experiencing.</p><p>This myth that murder inevitably leads to progress is problematic for those who believe in social justice because we can tell ourselves these deaths, while tragic, will help advance the movement. Although in reality, we’re losing the talent, energy, and perspective of those who are murdered. It is preposterous to think we can improve as individuals or as a society if we have fewer people dedicating their unique talents, energies, and perspectives to the fight. As leaders such as Medgar Evers, Fred Hampton, Malcolm X, and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., were assassinated for their work and beliefs, the Civil Rights movement was weakened significantly. By the 1970s, most of the legislative momentum and unity had waned. The recent white supremacist attack in Charlottesville, VA, served as evidence of the fact that the fights for civil rights is as necessary today as it was in the 1960s. But rather than moving toward the ultimate good we seek, these myths help to keep us caught in the same cycles we’re trying to break free from.</p><p>In the fight against white supremacy, for instance, it only benefits the white supremacists to have more martyrs and sacrificial lambs. White supremacy does not want minorities and their sympathizers to survive and thrive. In a news report by <em>Vice</em>, one white supremacist stated he expects more people to die before their agenda is realized. If we continue to accept the beliefs that martyrs and sacrificial lambs can help us take steps forward, we will keep playing into the hands of those who wish to halt progress. It’s inconceivable that more holidays with our loved ones and fewer hashtags in their memory would hinder social progress. Young men and women shouldn’t have to exchange careers for caskets, for progress to be achieved. Progress doesn’t require martyrs, nor does it necessitate sacrificial lambs. As my friend Manon said, we didn’t need another martyr, Rekia. In fact, maybe we never needed any to begin with.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/bentapper/">Ben Tapper</a></p><p>Contributor at <a href="http://christianity-now.com/">Christianity Now</a></p><p>Ben has a BA in Political Science from Manchester University, an MA in Public Affairs from Indiana University, and is currently pursuing a Master of Divinity from Christian Theological Seminary. He serves as the Faith Formation Coordinator for First Mennonite Church in Indianapolis, IN, and is actively involved in community engagement. Ben has a passion for issues of justice and liberation for oppressed people.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2cec6a4d1604" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now/no-more-martyrs-2cec6a4d1604">No More Martyrs</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now">Christianity Now</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Brief Overview of Identity Politics: A Liberal Struggles for Perspective]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TylorLovins/a-brief-overview-of-identity-politics-a-liberal-struggles-for-perspective-837a2fc8a96d?source=rss-58c7b9ab08b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/837a2fc8a96d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[identity-politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Sep 2017 21:01:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-09-08T21:01:01.359Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A follow-up to <a href="https://medium.com/@modernchristianthought/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion-c87c987a239d">“How the rise of identity politics indicates the decline of religion”</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Uw29S9TIfGYxDTsxolMOzQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>I recently wrote a <a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/">polemical on identity politics</a>, specifically to criticize the motives behind the spate of campus protests occurring over the last few years. Many took me to be flippantly disregarding the goals of identity politics or blatantly mischaracterizing it. As with any polemical, my goal was to present a coherent, singular vision for a critique of identity politics, without necessarily engaging in balancing acts required by demands of objectivity. Polemics are useful nonetheless, I think, for opening space in discourses where no space is given. Many readers assumed I wasn’t a liberal, for instance. It seems, yet, there still is no space for questioning identity politics.</p><p>There are many more issues with identity politics that I don’t have the space to outline here, especially in its delegitimizing of the individual, championing of authoritarian tactics, and anti-free speech elements. In my follow-up article, on the Christian insight that it disregards, I will address these issues more fully. Here I plan to look at identity politics in general, outline what it’s about, and offer more critiques from my point of view as a liberal.</p><h3>What Is Identity Politics?</h3><p>Identity politics, recently becoming a buzzword after the infamous Google Memos and Charlottesville,<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> has been blamed for many sins and praised for at least an equal number of blessings. What is it exactly? The best definition I have found is in<a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/identity-politics/"> Stanford’s Encyclopedia of Philosophy:</a> “Rather than organizing solely around belief systems, programmatic manifestos, or party affiliation, identity political formations typically aim to secure the political freedom of a specific constituency marginalized within its larger context. Members of that constituency assert or reclaim ways of understanding their distinctiveness that challenge dominant oppressive characterizations, with the goal of greater self-determination.”</p><p>As some like Rob Hoffman from <em>Politico </em>would argue: <a href="http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2016/11/how-the-left-created-donald-trump-214472">identity politics created Trump;</a> whereas others like <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/the-recent-spate-of-anti-identity-politics-hand-wringing_us_5851ea52e4b0865ab9d4e910">Michael Darer, writing for the Huffington Post</a>, would claim “identity politics,” rather than a legitimate description of a distinct way of doing politics, is a term used by racists wearing masks of civility:</p><blockquote>‘‘identity politics’ is a dismissive and euphemistic way to address a political agenda that emphasizes and values the identities of non-white, non-male, non-straight, non-cisgender voters….it’s little more than a term that allows white males to denounce political agendas that focus heavily on civil rights advances without appearing to be bigots.</blockquote><p>The argument, as Darer gives it, is that when people criticize identity politics, they’re necessarily criticizing the idea that political discourse should take place in a non-white-centric universe. He continues:</p><blockquote>More or less, it’s the smarmy pseudo-intellectual sibling of complaining about black Americans making everything about race, employing transparently condescending rhetoric about fighting division and coming together as one body, where that one body is organized around the agenda and the voice with which its white wranglers are most comfortable.</blockquote><p>I quote Darer at length, perhaps the most cynical and least sophisticated apologist for identity politics I have read, because similar sentiments from many on the left are given in various think pieces and lectures, and he encapsulates the general mood of advocates well. This isn’t to say people like Darer don’t understand something fundamentally true about our political climate or don’t in fact make sense in their judgements of white privilege. There are many who see identity politics in the way he describes, and not without reason.</p><p>Other apologists wouldn’t see identity politics in quite the same anti-white, anti-male, anti-straight, anti-cis terms as Darer, who is ironically <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/michaeldarer">a white man</a> himself.<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a> Joan E. Dowlin, also writing for the <em>HuffPost</em>, says all politics are identity politics:</p><blockquote>Identity politics is not new and the truth is that all politics are identity politics. Name me any politician and I will tell you their identity and the subsequent group of voters they may attract. It doesn’t matter if they are right, left, centrist, or from outer space, all candidates practice Identity Politics.</blockquote><p>The main thrust of her argument is that identity is based on interest, and everyone votes, and should vote, based on their interests; therefore nothing new or controversial has come about as a consequence of identity politics. This understanding seems innocuous enough, even if it might redefine the terms.</p><h3>3 Levels of Analysis</h3><p>From what I’ve read, there seems to be at least 3 ways of defining identity politics, from the most specific to the most general. And I think they all begin from different traditions of thought.</p><p>(1) Identity politics is a movement meant to empower marginalized groups, pronouncing and representing their interests to the public, moving toward equality and justice for these groups specifically on terms that these groups provide.</p><p>(2) Identity politics is a way of doing politics that emphasizes group identity and interest as opposed to the commonalities between groups and the achievement of mutually beneficial goals.</p><p>(3) Identity politics is the way politics has always been done. Group interest is, and has always been, the central concern of political movements. We just don’t default to a white-centric interest any longer.</p><p>I think these levels of analysis are typically associated with specific traditions of politics. Level (1) belongs to feminist and civil rights movements; (2) belongs to classical liberalism; and (3) belongs to libertarians. These are generalizations, of course, and don’t necessarily represent the viewpoints of every person in each tradition. They can all be held by the same person at once without contradiction, because they are different levels of analysis. I’ve found it a helpful heuristic for navigating the very different perspective on identity politics. And this helps me understand why people think about the criticisms of identity politics differently.</p><p>For instance, if you are criticizing identity politics for its focus on group interests, and a person from (1) picks up on it, they’ll likely think you’re against the interests of marginalized groups; and a person from (2) will likely take as the implication that you’re probably going to argue for the primacy of common interests and not specific group interests as the language of political discourse; and a person from (3) will think you haven’t really understood what has historically driven political movements, because they’re all about the interests of individuals that eventually form to create group interest.</p><p>I know it’s somewhat convoluted, but this analysis has made sense of the literature I’ve come across. We’ve heard viewpoints from (1) and (3), now I want to turn to (2) and put it in dialogue with the rest. This clashing viewpoints of (1) and (2) is a prevailing conflict within the left.</p><h3>The 2nd Analysis</h3><p>I think Mark Lillanov represents a critique from the second level of analysis,<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a> faulting identity politics for its divisiveness:</p><blockquote>But it is at the level of electoral politics that identity liberalism has failed most spectacularly, as we have just seen. National politics in healthy periods is not about “difference,” it is about commonality. And it will be dominated by whoever best captures Americans’ imaginations about our shared destiny. Ronald Reagan did that very skillfully, whatever one may think of his vision. So did Bill Clinton, who took a page from Reagan’s playbook. He seized the Democratic Party away from its identity-conscious wing, concentrated his energies on domestic programs that would benefit everyone (like national health insurance) and defined America’s role in the post-1989 world. By remaining in office for two terms, he was then able to accomplish much for different groups in the Democratic coalition. Identity politics, by contrast, is largely expressive, not persuasive. Which is why it never wins elections — but can lose them.</blockquote><p>When I read that, I could hear <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/the-recent-spate-of-anti-identity-politics-hand-wringing_us_5851ea52e4b0865ab9d4e910">Michael Darer respond,</a> “the notion that we should keep having to reframe equality so that it appeals to the sensibilities and desires of the majority is absurd.” And Molly Roberts in her article for the <em>Washington Post </em><a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/post-partisan/wp/2017/08/14/stop-blaming-charlottesville-on-identity-politics/?utm_term=.5f9e4fa2d3ef">“Stop Blaming Charlottesville on Identity Politics,”</a> further critiques this position, and the idea that identity politics is the politics of white supremacists but in different terms:</p><blockquote>White supremacy is not a response to identity politics; identity politics are a response to white supremacy. They’re a response to life in a country that built itself on the theory that “all men are created equal” but a reality where the opposite was true. And they’re a response not just to the outright racism that survives on websites such as Stormfront and at Confederate flag rallies but also to the stubborn structural barriers that still hold back people with darker skin.</blockquote><p>As many have pointed out, whites have identity politics, too. We just call it “politics.”</p><p>And this seems exactly right, in many ways. In what was a sort-of eye-opening article for me, Laila Lalami points out that white people have played identity politics, but they’ve just called it “politics,” and the rise of movements that are ostensibly driven by group identity is just indicative of the fact that the political power and unity of white demographics is simply waning, and no longer a political default:</p><blockquote>If whiteness is no longer the default and is to be treated as an identity — even, soon, a “minority” — then perhaps it is time white people considered the disadvantages of being a race. The next time a white man bombs an abortion clinic or goes on a shooting rampage on a college campus, white people might have to be lectured on religious tolerance and called upon to denounce the violent extremists in their midst. The opioid epidemic in today’s white communities could be treated the way we once treated the crack epidemic in black ones — not as a failure of the government to take care of its people but as a failure of the race. The fact that this has not happened, nor is it likely to, only serves as evidence that white Americans can still escape race.</blockquote><p>This is, in my mind, a devastating critique and an accurate reversal of historical norms. It’s a truthful examination as far as I can see. But I do struggle at this point. Lalami’s indictment of whiteness at the societal level is true, but does it follow that those who practice identity politics can as a result confer intentionality grounded in this whiteness to individual white persons? Have my discussions revolving around liberty and justice for all been unconsciously motivated by a desire to secure whiteness? Has my silence on “whiteness,” in both my thoughts and actions, contributed to its presence, pervasiveness, and power in my life? I cannot say yet, because I’m not sure what it would look like, or even if it’s legitimate to think about the construct of race in such a way — as an invisible motivating force like an instinct but nefarious, totalizing, and hegemonic. This isn’t self-evident to me and it doesn’t make sense philosophically or, from what I’ve read of the literature, scientifically. But if I’m wrong, I’d certainly like to know how. And if I’m wrong, this of course has earth-shattering political implications.</p><h3>A Rudimentary Evaluation</h3><p>Against Darer, the goal of the second level of analysis, at least as I understand it, is not to replace identity politics, what can be understood as a politics from the perspective of the marginalized, with majoritarian politics, or politics from the perspective of the greatest number. The import of the classical liberal critique is in the terms we use to further political agendas. The strongest criticism one levels in identity politics is to position opponents as racist, sexist, misogynist, homophobic, and the like: as anti- x-group. For me, the failure to perceive these issues as anti-equality, anti-liberty, and anti-justice is indicative of the larger issue of identity politics. It seems to equivocate between (1) the moral good with (2) who benefits from a moral decision.</p><p>From my conversations with liberals, my own self-understanding, and the literature I’ve read, it appears that many of the political choices on the left are motivated by altruism, whereas those on the right are motivated by individualism. This of course is a generalization, again, but it’s a helpful tool for understanding the perspectival differences between the two. One issue with a completely altruistic understanding of morality, especially when it begins to infiltrate our political discourses, is that an action is moral so far as it involves self-sacrifice for the benefit of another person. There is no conception of a moral individual, left alone to pursue his or her own aims. Rather, a person is a moral individual so long as he or she improves the situation of others, without regard for self.</p><p>This is a problem because the rhetoric of dehumanization is the logical extension for people who oppose the interests of the group you identify with: by extension, these people are unwilling to give up their privilege, to help out other people. They are not moral human beings, cannot be, and therefore are non-human. This explains <a href="https://www.thenation.com/article/feminisms-toxic-twitter-wars/">Twitter callout culture that has developed within the identity politics movement</a>, and the incessant charges of racism, misogyny, homophobia, etc., of opponents of identity politics causes: not just the general aims, but the specific solutions they seek. Consider the labeling of James Damore’s now infamous Google Memo as “anti-diversity” because he sought to understand the differences in job representation between genders by reference to<a href="http://gizmodo.com/exclusive-heres-the-full-10-page-anti-diversity-screed-1797564320"> “population level differences.”</a> Is asking whether there are biological roots to the reasons men and women choose different jobs or are represented differently in different industries a sexist, anti-diversity question? It would appear so.</p><p>Another problem with altruism in the political realm is it relativizes values. Which group should one self-sacrifice for? Is it possible for white lower class workers to be oppressed? Or does an arbitrary race heuristic label every white person as oppressor, as benefiting from white privilege?</p><p>A typical argument I’ve heard from people on the far left is we have a moral obligation to balance the scales of justice in favor of the marginalized because of the reality of historical injustice — not only injustice that occurred in the past, but injustice that has endured from the past into the present. Therefore policies that rightfully rid the world of benefits people receive based on protected classes like race is not the goal of identity politics. Just the opposite: identity politics aims to administer new benefits, but this time to historically marginalized groups. I think this is a problem. The idea of balancing the scales of justice has lost its grounding as a metaphor. Lady Justice is blind to signify impartiality. Ideally, under law everyone is treated equally, no matter status, wealth, race, religion, etc. The scales are balanced when everyone is playing by the same rules, when the form of political argument is the same among various groups, though the content of the claims may differ. Balancing the scales by introducing a new form of political argument — the primacy of group identity and interest — introduces a factor of group arbitrariness and hegemony as a legitimate political enterprise. This is exactly what impartiality is established to protect against. The ideal of impartiality is not about the outcomes of political movements. Indeed, some movements are more just than others. The notion of impartiality is about a way of proceeding, a way of doing law and politics. If the law is partial, then the reasons for implementing any change will necessarily be arbitrary (by definition). The function of the ideal of impartiality is to establish a way of doing politics that bridges differences between groups of people to find common ground in unifying ideals because everyone must work according to the same rules of procedure that are general enough by design to be the grounds on which any political movement can be based while at the same time benefiting the common good.</p><p>The balancing of the scales I am speaking of here has been discussed in terms of the differences between equality of outcome and equality of opportunity. If our aim is to achieve a 50%-%50 ratio of male to female in jobs, for instance, then we are aiming for equality of outcome, and, ironically, must work against discrimination with discriminatory logic. If we are aiming for no obstacles to be placed in front of anyone because of their race, gender, religion, etc., then we are aiming at equality of opportunity.</p><p>In my estimation, political policies should aim at equality of opportunity. And, by extension, those who have been disadvantaged because of their race or gender should have the obstacles of injustice removed from their paths. Let us strive for equality because that is the best way to relate to one another. Let us do it because it is in the interest of everyone, for injustice to one person is injustice to all. And let us fight alongside the marginalized to achieve it.</p><p>Doing so in the name of a specific group interest is no way to do politics; and doing so to advantage one group over another will not make the common causes of holding millionaires and billionaires responsible for tax evasion, increasing minimum wage, fighting gerrymandering, saving the planet from oil mongols, and the like. Our only argument cannot be “because it is in the interest of x group or y group.”</p><p>For political change, we must construct rigorous arguments in the name of and for the sake of equality and justice, not in the name of or for the sake of any specific group of people.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Though the term has been used <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identity_politics">since at least the 1970s.</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> To be fair, Darer uses the terms “non-white, non-male, non-straight, non-cis…” but the dismissive and cynical tone used to characterize detractors makes me suspicious his idea of identity politics isn’t entirely neutrally “non-anything.” I could be wrong. But the army of white, heterosexual males who specifically couch the terms of identity politics in anti-white, heterosexual male terms is an interesting phenomena that I do not claim to understand.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> See the view represented in its entirety by Mark Lilla on <em>Slate</em>: <a href="http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/interrogation/2017/08/mark_lilla_thinks_identity_politics_are_destroying_the_democratic_party.html">http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/interrogation/2017/08/mark_lilla_thinks_identity_politics_are_destroying_the_democratic_party.html</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=837a2fc8a96d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How the rise of identity politics indicates the decline of religion]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@TylorLovins/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion-c87c987a239d?source=rss-58c7b9ab08b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c87c987a239d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[identity-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Sep 2017 21:01:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-09-08T21:01:01.232Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>August 17, 2017/in <a href="http://christianity-now.com/category/religion-and-secularism/">Religion and Secularism</a> /by <a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/tylor/">Tylor Lovins</a></p><p><em>See my follow-up article here: </em><a href="https://medium.com/@modernchristianthought/a-brief-overview-of-identity-politics-a-liberal-struggles-for-perspective-837a2fc8a96d"><em>https://medium.com/@modernchristianthought/a-brief-overview-of-identity-politics-a-liberal-struggles-for-perspective-837a2fc8a96d</em></a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*p33E44bM-EW2dSvuaQKeqA.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote><em>“…to be a citizen has come to mean something else, it means to be an </em>outsider<em>….the relation itself [between people] is on its last legs inasmuch as they do not essentially relate to each other in the relation, but the relation itself has become a problem in which the parties like rivals in a game watch each other instead of relating to each other, and count, as it is said, each other’s verbal avowals of relation as a substitute for resolute mutual giving in the relation.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Soren Kierkegaard, “Two Ages: The Age of Revolution and the Present Age — A Literary Review.” March 30, 1864.</em></blockquote><p>The rise of the worst kind of identity politics,<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn1">[1]</a> motivated by group-think, is not a shocking development, given the confluence of Marxist ideology in the social sciences, the pervasion of postmodern philosophy in everything from film to literature, from religion to the concepts of truth and the good, and, finally, the apparent powerlessness of the populace to effect change against known immanent crises like global warming, overpopulation, income inequality, and the like. Most in the electorate feel impotent, considering there seems no route to rouse career politicians to vote on something that doesn’t, in the end, contribute to the lining of their suits or the thickening of party lines. It is the youngest groups that receive the largest blow. So social change must be manufactured. On the most general level of analysis, doesn’t it make intuitive sense that social change can be achieved by sheer numbers, and that the outcomes we desire must be taken, and cannot be given, from the present order?</p><p>What may be more surprising to some readers is this development, though with seemingly benevolent intentions,<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn2">[2]</a> ultimately reflects the direction of history set in motion around the time of the Greeks: nihilism. As an equalizing force, flattening all idiosyncrasies to simple, sanitized ideological order, nihilism is the characteristic movement of thought underlying our age. The list of prophets proclaiming this coming order reaches back to Kierkegaard and Nietzsche, though they are by no means the only two. Both attempted to overcome nihilism by appealing to the individual. This last fortress they recovered by reaching backwards in history and deep into the inner workings of language, for the fossils of this concept date to vestigial conceptions of the world as understood by religion.<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn3">[3]</a></p><p>The nihilism manifested in our secular age finds the Savior not in a God-man incarnate, which signified within Christianity the importance of the individual, but finds the savior of humankind in group power and identification. By replacing the near-infinite complexity of individual personhood with one or two group-based traits, identity politics, in its most extreme forms, aims at both the loss of individual liberty for group directives and the annihilation of individual identity for group belonging. This is a problem. As the religiously affiliated vanish, it is no accident that group-power fills the void religion leaves behind, for the power of suffering is still evident to all. And it is no accident violent protests at universities against free speech, and no-platforming against scientists and conservative speakers, have become commonplace, for the social sciences have told us we can change anything when we work together. The question remains whether by sheer willpower we can change the the realities science reveals in its methods. Although some higher education institutions are stepping up to the challenges these recent developments pose, others have capitulated. It appears even Google has deferred to the ideological order when challenged with scientific viewpoints.<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn4">[4]</a> Why? Listen to any of the multitude of protests, conducted by so called “Social Justice Warriors,”<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn5">[5]</a> filmed and uploaded on YouTube typically by the protestors themselves.<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn6">[6]</a> You’ll find a harrowing reality, where no evidence is given for assertions, virtue-signalling is the only virtue, and logic and reason are received from opposing parties as weapons of violence. In fact, speech itself is understood as violence.<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn7">[7]</a> This is a strange new world, yet hardly brave. We should be wary of the attempts of identity politics to place our value as persons in the attainment of group traits, in the assertion that mere belonging to a group bestows epistemic or moral superiority. We should be wary, that is to say, of any wisdom we haven’t earned.<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn8">[8]</a></p><p>The observant viewer might suspect postmodernists are playing an old game, and I think this suspicion is mostly correct. As nihilism flattens the dimensions of selfhood, identity-politics has made us forget our history, while dooming us to repeat it. We must not forget the power of ideology that ruled the centuries before the Enlightenment during which religious violence ravaged Europe, and we must not take for granted the miraculous gift of rationality that followed. The rise of scientific rationality displaced the more primitive strains of religious logic as the speech in which disparate systems of beliefs may come together to debate, change, and compromise.<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn9">[9]</a> All the same, the gift is never guaranteed. Postmodernists may mean well, but if they cannot dialogue with those who oppose them they simply replay this scene from history, except in reverse. This time it is the abstract language of science that has written the creeds, and the social sciences that play the role of Inquisitors. The language which emerged to save us from the tribalisms of the past has created a new tribe, and this ostensibly uniworld rationality has materialized a new kind of terror. This is the problem secularism, a world without religion, poses. When we forget religion, will we lose our souls? When you watch the videos, you’ll look upon a pseudo-congregation of activists chanting, wailing, gnashing their teeth. They’re like a priestly class exorcising the world of evil.<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn10">[10]</a> But these priests are of a different order for they haven’t read their Bibles. They don’t understand that just because they believe in God doesn’t mean they’re not demons.<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn11">[11]</a></p><h3>On the Worlds of Science and Religion</h3><p>There is a distinction to be made between the domain in which science works and articulates the world, in which abstract thinking has its efficacy, and the domain in which religion<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn13">[13]</a> works and articulates the world and mythology has its efficacy. Jordan B. Peterson makes it this way: Science resides in the world of objects, where things that occupy space and time, distinct among each other, establish the domain of the world. Objects occupying space and time are the constitutive reality. Religion operates in the world as the domain of action, the realm of being (not objects), where the most fundamental reality is suffering. The two have different logics, different conceptions of reality, and different ways of interacting with the phenomena they encounter. The problems of science, establishing cause and effect relationships, are not the problems of religion, where the question of perennial importance is the question of what we do with suffering.<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn14">[14]</a> Whereas theories of science tell us how we’ve gotten here, the culmination of religious teaching seems to be something like this: being (or existence) can be declared good despite suffering. Religious beliefs tell us what we might do to navigate the chaos of the unknown when it manifests itself in forms of suffering or disillusionment. The world of science gives us data; the world of religion gives us meaning. These two categorically distinct ways of living and viewing the world — the scientific and the religious — exist at this point in history in an enigmatic union.</p><p>The social science political ideologies are about the closest thing to religion without religion, because they do offer some sort of account for navigating the world as a forum for action where suffering is a fundamental reality. These accounts are altogether insufficient nevertheless because they do not have a theory of good and evil reckoning with the complexity of individuality. They declare evil is a social phenomena and simply the result of propaganda. Change the propaganda and change the world: the mind of the individual is a vessel waiting to be filled.<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn15">[15]</a> Evil, for political ideologies, is manifest as the opposition, as the opposing group.<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn16">[16]</a>This appears to explain why postmodernists have an antipathy toward discussing ideas with people they disagree with. You might hear things like, “If they can’t recognize that is racist, I can’t help them.” Evil, both in its origin and manifestation, is entirely a social phenomenon.</p><p>What do we lose if we lose religion? We lose one of its fundamental insights: evil doesn’t derive from the public realm, it is only manifested there, and the line between good and evil runs down the middle of every soul. In Christianity this is the teaching of original sin. We’re not entirely rational. This claim is why religion settled the question of whether establishing the perfect state order would bring about the good life for everyone by ultimately deferring the question to the individual. This is the victory of grace over law in the New Testament. A perfect world order won’t heal the blind man, no love or hope or law, but faith will.</p><p>And yet another insight dissipates. Kierkegaard prophesied that our present age is one of “leveling,” where the disparities between things and people are not resolved within their relations to each other, and personal, intimate relations are replaced by relations of abstraction. Everything is held as it is, by their appearances, in abstractions: this is the way one should relate to the world and others. We no longer relate to each other as persons, but as white or black, male or female, Jew or Gentile, oppressor or oppressed. The hero of the religious is nearly extinct, the one who, by an inner peace and satisfaction before God, has gained the knowledge of his or herself and attempts to be ruler over carnal desires and passions instead of others, and, with all mustered vitality, embodies the truths discovered within the personal struggle to overcome suffering into the events of the world. The hero of today, when attaining the social aims the monstrous “public”<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn12">[12]</a> sets before him or her, is to become so educated, to become so consistent in abstracting, that the he or she is flattened to the level of the crowd in complete, brazen equality. To be a hero today is to remain completely within the definitions of a particular group, to have the same history, the same sufferings, the same enemies, and the same thoughts. Another insight of religion that disappears by the leveling of nihilism is the idea that the constitution of the self is not entirely social, but at least partly subjective, and there are things that can constitute the self that are not retrievable in public, and may never be brought to the gradations of abstraction. The religious insight instructs us that the ability to lead a rich inward life requires taking on the sufferings you’ve experienced and declare victory by the way you live. Nobody can achieve this victory for you. And if the battle against inner demons isn’t fought, history has shown us we project these demons to the outside world, onto others.</p><p>Religion tells us evil dwells in the self. It gives us the diametrical separation between the public and private sphere, and in so doing creates an infinitely complex notion of the individual. It tells us there are experiences and choices nobody can touch, that nobody can experience or decide about, except for the individual. This is part of the import of religious expressions such as “hearing God,” “feeling the love of God,” “knowing the will of God,” and the like. For thinkers like Kierkegaard, the movement of faith is entirely individualistic. Secularism, as it’s grounded in empiricism and atheism, forgets this distinction, though not necessarily. The residue of religion is rotting in the carcass of culture, and its remnants, ruined as they might appear, still provide some sustenance to our values for the time being. Empiricism and atheism themselves have been grounded historically in religious values (like the immutable value of the self, free will, moral demands on the self, among others).<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn17">[17]</a> Only in the void religion leaves behind, which grows by the day, can secularism be possessed by something like the political ideology I am discussing here. And it’s characteristic of our age to, in our forgetting of the religious distinction between self and society, argue that feelings are as valid and public as rational arguments. The mere voicing that one feels oppressed has displaced the requirement for the provision of evidence.</p><h3>Who’s in Charge?</h3><p>An old expression that both the philosopher Martin Heidegger and the psychologist Carl Jung used helps us understand the loss of religion more precisely: We don’t think thoughts, rather, thoughts have us, they occur to us. The average person has as much power over what kind of thoughts occur to them as they have the power to summon dreams and determine what happens in them. They are, “Historical and linguistic inevitabilities.”<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn18">[18]</a> This is a terrifying thought. From Freud onward, it has become clear: pictures and images are something like a precursor to abstract thought. Before humankind could objectify its emotional experiences, it had to project these emotions onto the world. Thus it discovered gods. For much of history gods abstractly symbolized the emotions and values of cultures. The historian of religions Mircea Eliade points out that, as disparate societies met and integrated with one another, over a few decades, a battle of the gods would appear in their mythology. This, of course, on an abstract level, is a merging of values between two societies, something like democratic dialogue before we had the concept of democratic dialogue. So it would happen that the victorious deity would not be one god from one culture, but a combination of gods from both cultures.</p><p>As may be clear from the rise and fall of communism in the Soviet Union, and the failure of propaganda to change the basic desires of persons involved in the revolution and the leadership that governed it, it’s not self-evident that, if given the chance, our good intentions to diminish suffering in the world won’t lead to an innocent and accidental opening of the Pandora’s box. As Jung has pointed out, humans are more than rational creatures, and, in fact, our minds might be more accurately construed as a dim candle of reason surrounded by whirlwinds of collective unconscious motivation, perpetually under the threat of eradication by primal forces it can neither articulate nor control. Instead of losing religion to the ether of thoughtlessness, by equivocating religion with fundamentalism (a form of nihilism itself), it might be in our best interest to first understand it and explore whether it has chained up or transformed indomitable beasts not unleashed in the world since the chaos that gave rise to culture.</p><p>Religion has given us images to reconcile, especially in the concept of God,<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn19">[19]</a> our unconscious motivations with our tragically limited abstract understanding of ourselves, others, and the world. Secularism doesn’t appear to be in possession of a functionally equivalent concept to the religious concept of God, and this may spell our doom if we don’t understand the import of the religious concept in the first place. We may be blindly walking into battle with omnipotent dragons, armed with swords of straw. What if religion saves us from ourselves? What if the hundreds of thousands of years humanity survived by telling religious stories is actually the Darwinian solution to the problem of the reconciliation of the collective unconscious to the conscious mind and the solution to the problem of suffering?<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn20">[20]</a></p><p>I hear often from people who think it’s immoral to have children, that humankind is like a cancer on the world. Jordan B. Peterson reminds us that we better be careful which metaphors we use when we’re talking about ourselves and the world, because it’s not obvious whether we’re in control of them or they control us. If we lose religion then we lose the symbolic grounding for our understandings of ourselves, and the conceptions we’ve inherited from religious traditions will float in the air, without the unifying power of mythical symbols and narrative to unite them with our experiences of suffering. Ironically, as we are seeing now, the movements of religion will appear again, but in a much less sophisticated form. Instead of projecting the unspeakable phenomena of suffering from the collective unconscious onto the gods, we will do so on to other people. To harken to a quote from the television series <em>Fargo</em>, just because dragons aren’t on the map anymore doesn’t mean they don’t exist.</p><p>We have seen the power of the collective unconscious in the ideological possession that has become common among the most irreligious section of the population: young people.<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn21">[21]</a> “We’ve done away with stories of hell so we had to make one on Earth.”<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn22">[22]</a> It is even suggested by the philosopher Hannah Arendt that our capacity to do evil is limited only to the extent that we <em>think</em>, the ability which makes us <em>individuals</em>. From times long before antiquity, thinking was the meaning and consequence of the divine spark that created the individual in a strike of lightning.<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn23">[23]</a> Controversially, when Arendt coined the phrase “banality of evil,” reporting on the trial of Adolf Eichmann and his use of cliches, bureaucratic language, and stock phrases in defense of himself, it was this inability which gave rise to the banality, the effect of leveling, the movement of nihilism. “Could the activity of thinking as such, the habit of examining whatever happens to come to pass or to attract attention, regardless of results and specific content, could this activity be among the conditions that make men abstain from evil-doing?”<a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftn24">[24]</a> Eichmann’s identity had been swallowed up by propaganda and he had become a mere member of a group. We’re children of history, and we’re not so mature as to have outgrown the collective memories and powers that gave rise to the dark period of WWII.</p><p>The sea of secularism hasn’t yet swallowed the world. We still have a somewhat functional concept of God, though the functionality seems to be diminishing by the day. Jung pointed out the concept signified the process of individuation, the process by which individuality is formed. This idea is worth thinking about, should we think about nothing else relating to religion. We may have all the abstract and technological prowess in the universe, but if we lack soul, we’ll lose the spark of divinity, and perhaps ourselves. Religious conceptions just might be the key to resolving the disparities between groups and individuals while safeguarding the distinction between the two.</p><h3>Videos of Protests and Protesters</h3><p>With Jordan B. Peterson:</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZP3mSamRbYA">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZP3mSamRbYA</a></p><p>At Evergreen College:</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bO1agIlLlhg">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bO1agIlLlhg</a></p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LTnDpoQLNaY">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LTnDpoQLNaY</a></p><p>Middlebury College:</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a6EASuhefeI">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a6EASuhefeI</a></p><p>UC Berkeley:</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=unnrYfCe4bM">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=unnrYfCe4bM</a></p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kku5MX7SFZ8">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kku5MX7SFZ8</a></p><h3>Endnotes</h3><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref1">[1]</a> I want to be clear that I am not talking about feminism in general, or the Black Lives Matter movement in general, or even progressive initiatives in general. I consider myself an adherent to classical liberalism in many ways. I am in fact on the left, and I am pointing out a blind spot to many who I work and agree with on many issues. I am speaking here of a very specific movement that claims the same ends as these just causes-the end of misogyny, racism, sexism, homophobia, inequality, and the like. The movement I am critiquing takes the form of the blind power of herd mentality and the renunciation of reason as the grounds for the general improvement of unjust conditions. Two very specific motives undergird this movement: (1) instead of eliminating inequality by removing obstacles to success people encounter because of their sex, gender, or race, they intend to place obstacles in front of the “privileged,” and, in an ironic bait-and-switch, privilege historically disadvantaged groups; and (2) instead of aiming at equality of opportunity, this movement aims at equality of outcome.</p><p>Please see the YouTube links above to witness the kind of groups I am speaking of here.</p><p>And see these recent criticisms of identity politics for more perspective:</p><p><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/12/opinion/sunday/identity-politics-white-men.html">https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/12/opinion/sunday/identity-politics-white-men.html</a></p><p><a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-poison-of-identity-politics-1502661521">https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-poison-of-identity-politics-1502661521</a></p><p><a href="https://www.vox.com/2017/8/15/16089286/identity-politics-liberalism-republicans-democrats-trump-clinton">https://www.vox.com/2017/8/15/16089286/identity-politics-liberalism-republicans-democrats-trump-clinton</a></p><p>And one I highly recommend by Michael Shermer:</p><p><a href="https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-unfortunate-fallout-of-campus-postmodernism/">https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-unfortunate-fallout-of-campus-postmodernism/</a></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref2">[2]</a> Jean-Jacques Rousseau distinguished between “good” and “virtuous” in his <em>Reveries of the Solitary Walker</em>, and it’s worth noting here: he thinks humankind exists in a natural state of good, which means that we initially have no desire to harm one another. To be good is to do nothing to anyone, to remain in this “natural state.” But a virtuous person must <em>earn </em>virtue, for it implies a conscious good-will toward others, which is only possible once social relations, language, rationality, and morality have developed. I wonder whether the many who fold-over to the “good intentions” of the postmodernists haven’t yet considered benevolent intentions often are not aligned with benevolent outcomes, and it takes a bit of calculation and compromise, a bit of other-orientation, to conceive of a way of relating to others which isn’t constituted by a master/slave relationship, where one group is always the tyrant and the other the slave.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref3">[3]</a> By “religion,” I will be referring to the fundamental conception of the world that is “religious,” and I take as my starting point that each religious tradition is a response to this (namely, the world as constituted by the reality of suffering). My intellectual leanings are with the Christian tradition, however, and you will see the specifically Christian contributions painted in the broad strokes of “religion.” I use the word “religion” instead of “Christianity” because I want to refer to the conception of the world that is specifically religious, albeit instantiated in this article as Christian insights.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref4">[4]</a> <a href="http://gizmodo.com/exclusive-heres-the-full-10-page-anti-diversity-screed-1797564320">http://gizmodo.com/exclusive-heres-the-full-10-page-anti-diversity-screed-1797564320</a></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref5">[5]</a> To avoid unnecessary animus, I refer to this specific group as “postmodernists” from here on out.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref6">[6]</a> See more videos at the end of the article below.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref7">[7]</a> See Jonathan Haidt’s wonderful analysis: <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/07/why-its-a-bad-idea-to-tell-students-words-are-violence/533970/?utm_content=bufferb0bba&amp;utm_medium=social&amp;utm_source=twitter.com&amp;utm_campaign=buffer">https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/07/why-its-a-bad-idea-to-tell-students-words-are-violence/533970/?utm_content=bufferb0bba&amp;utm_medium=social&amp;utm_source=twitter.com&amp;utm_campaign=buffer</a></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref8">[8]</a> “What is my wisdom, if even the fools can dictate to me? What is my freedom, if all creatures, even the botched and the impotent, are my masters? What is my life, if I am but to bow, to agree and to obey?”</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref9">[9]</a> See Jeffrey Stout’s wonderful book <em>Flight from Authority</em>.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref10">[10]</a> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5_Pv0A-xjE">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5_Pv0A-xjE</a></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref11">[11]</a> This is the point of James 2.19: “You believe that there is one God. Good! Even the demons believe that — and shudder.” (NIV). Believing in a single good that solves the problem of suffering (like, for instance, the elimination of economic classes), is the attempt of secular society to establish something like a functionally equivalent concept to the concept of God. But it is not functionally equivalent because it misses another key insight of religion: sometimes you do everything right and you suffer anyway. Suffering is a basic element of life. Just because we aim at the good does not mean we won’t bring Hell on Earth in our attempts to attain it.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref12">[12]</a> “…the public is a monstrous nonentity….Only when there is no strong communal life to give substance to the concretion [of individuality] will the press create the abstraction ‘the public,’ made up of unsubstantial individuals who are never united or never can be united in the simultaneity of any situation or organization and yet are claimed to be a whole.” Kierkegaard, “On the Present Age.”</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref13">[13]</a> By religion I don’t merely mean what is referred to by “organized religion,” in today’s parlance. I am referring to the totality of the religious sphere: the myths, the experiences of the divine, and the social organizations</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref14">[14]</a> See Karen Armstrong’s <em>A History of God</em>, and, of course, Jordan B. Peterson’s work.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref15">[15]</a> I refer you here to <em>The Communist Manifesto </em>written by Karl Marx.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref16">[16]</a> George Orwell implored the social party to organize themselves under the labels of “oppressed” and the opposition as ”oppressors” in <em>The Road to Wigan Pier</em>.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref17">[17]</a> A glance at the history of ideas proves this true, and because suffering is what essentially establishes subjectivity (we hear this in the popular psychoanalysts today), it’s not a surprise religion posits the notion of the individual. Most notable see Larry Siedentop’s<em> Inventing the Individual: The Origins of Western Liberalism</em>, or the more recent work of Nick Spencer in <em>The Evolution of the West: How Christianity Has Shaped Our Values</em>.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref18">[18]</a> Martin Heidegger’s <em>Poetry, Language, Thought.</em></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref19">[19]</a> I’m using “the concept of God” here to also mean the concepts of “the sacred,” “the holy,” “the transcendent,” and/or “the divine.”</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref20">[20]</a> “How is it that complex and admirable ancient civilizations could have developed and flourished, initially, if they were predicated upon nonsense? (If a culture survives, and grows, does that not indicate in some profound way that the ideas it is based upon are valid? If myths are mere superstitious proto-theories, why did they work? Why were they remembered?….)</p><p>Is it not more likely that we just do not know how it could be that traditional notions are right, given their appearance of extreme rationality?</p><p>Is it not likely that this indicates modern philosophical ignorance, rather than ancestral philosophical error?</p><p>We have made the great mistake of assuming that the ‘world of spirit’ described by those who preceded us was the modern ‘world of matter,’ primitively conceptualized.”</p><p>Jordan B. Peterson, <em>Maps of Meaning,</em> 8.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref21">[21]</a> <a href="http://www.pewforum.org/religious-landscape-study/age-distribution/">http://www.pewforum.org/religious-landscape-study/age-distribution/</a></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref22">[22]</a> Jordan Peterson in an online lecture.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref23">[23]</a> Carl Jung, “A study in the process of individuation,” 1950.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/#_ftnref24">[24]</a> Hannah Arendt, <em>The Life of the Mind</em>, 1978.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/tylor/">Tylor Lovins</a></p><p>Founder | Content Coordinator at <a href="http://christianity-now.com/how-the-rise-of-identity-politics-indicates-the-decline-of-religion/Christianity-Now.com">Christianity Now</a></p><p>Tylor studied philosophy at Anderson University, concentrating in the philosophical works of Martin Heidegger and Ludwig Wittgenstein. He also <br>studied the theological and religious works of Rudolf Bultmann and D. Z. Phillips.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c87c987a239d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Jonah and the Story of White American Christianity]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christianity-now/jonah-and-the-story-of-white-american-christianity-2bfe37c4b103?source=rss-58c7b9ab08b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2bfe37c4b103</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dogs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blacklivesmatter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[faith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 Sep 2017 23:25:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-09-06T23:25:52.438Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>September 4, 2017/in <a href="http://christianity-now.com/category/christianity/">Christianity</a>, <a href="http://christianity-now.com/category/featured/">Featured</a> /by <a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/chasetibbs/">Chase Tibbs</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Y85zwsf-FkCYHrZghbZokA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Who from us sins that soil our souls does hide,</em><br><em>To save the wretched remnants of his pride.”</em><br><em>And tearful thus they pled til Jonah said, “Tis I!</em><br><em>I’ve sinned against my God and now deserve to die.</em></p><p><em>Away from you, cast me you must. God’s anger flies at me alone.</em><br><em>The sinless must not precious lives give up to sinner’s deeds atone!”</em></p><p>Inspired by a literalist and fundamentalist interpretation of the Bible, we have often reduced the story of Jonah to a historical event in which God magically makes a “great fish” swallow a stubborn prophet and spit him out three days later. Running from God’s call to proselytize to the evil people of Nineveh, Jonah ends up caught on a ship in a storm caused by God, and, as the sailors toss him overboard, God sends a fish to gobble him up and turn him around.</p><p>This common telling primarily focuses on the supernatural event of a human being surviving days in the belly of a fish — assumed to be a whale — and on the more practical question of how God will correct us when we do not behave. Perhaps, even more, this particular telling of the Jonah story has been used by Christians to suggest that those who are not Christian are inherently immoral, while those who are, the ones with the right beliefs, are good.</p><p>Although, I must wonder, could the book of Jonah have anything to say beyond supernatural phenomena and Christian colonization of cultures and religions?</p><p>While many may not perceive the character of Jonah as potentially speaking to the reality of white Christianity’s tolerance of, and participation in, the oppression and subjugation of black and brown persons, I hear a story of a prophet’s refusal to live in faithful solidarity — his failure to be deeply concerned for, and committed to, the wellbeing of others.</p><p>When understood in the writing’s historical context, Jonah is a Jewish prophet, a religious and ethnic minority, called by God to witness to Nineveh, the empire that once colonized and exploited the people of Israel. In this regard, white Christians living in the United States are unable to identify with Jonah in his cultural and religious oppression. In fact, regarding colonization and exploitation, white American Christianity could be more directly associated with the dominating privilege and power of Nineveh — the capital of ancient Assyria.</p><p>However, there is a part of Jonah’s story that does find commonality with the story of white Christianity in the United States. Although white Christians do not readily comprehend Jonah’s experience of religious and ethnic discrimination, his passionate reluctance to care for the wellbeing of all God’s creation is something more familiar, uncomfortably so.</p><p>In this light, the story of Jonah is the story of white American Christianity.</p><p>The question the book of Jonah leaves me wrestling with is this: How committed am I to the salvation of all God’s creation?</p><p>Now when I talk about salvation, I am not talking about being saved from eternal punishment dealt out by a vengeful God on the basis of whether or not one holds the right beliefs about God, Jesus, and the nature of existence. Soteriology that is measured by correct beliefs is idolatrous because it makes God’s love dependent upon the human intellect. Our relationship with God and others should not be rooted in the fear of some punitive act of divine violence that awaits us if we do not act a certain way. The understanding of salvation I want to suggest is concerned with relational wellbeing, the individual and communal wholeness of all of God’s creation.</p><p>As Jonah does not want anything to do with the wellbeing and wholeness of the people and animals of Nineveh, white Christians in the United States have continually refused to live in solidarity with people of color in their dehumanization and suffering. From slavery, the Black Codes, and the Jim Crow laws, to more recent, additional destruction brought on by the War on Crime, the War on Drugs, mass incarceration, and over-policing, white Christian communities have fallen short of the love for justice and mercy required to confront and subvert the systems sustained by an ideology of black and brown inferiority — all of which taken together become the monstrous, and amorphous, power that is white supremacy.</p><p>As the prophet is asked to demonstrate God’s care and concern for Nineveh in his embodying of the Torah, we as white Christians, in our seeking to imitate Christ, are asked to embody what Liberation theologian, Gustavo Gutiérrez, calls <em>Christian poverty</em>. “If the ultimate cause of human exploitation and alienation is selfishness, the deepest reason for voluntary poverty is love of neighbor. Christian poverty has meaning only as a commitment of solidarity with the poor, with those who suffer misery and injustice.” He continues, “Christian poverty, as an expression of love” is, first and foremost, “solidarity <em>with the poor </em>and is a protest <em>against poverty</em>.”<a href="http://christianity-now.com/jonah-and-the-story-of-white-american-christianity/#_ftn1">[1]</a> According to Gutiérrez, the radical idea of love of neighbor cannot be understood apart from the embodiment of both solidarity with those who suffer from, and protest against, injustice, dehumanization, and exploitation.</p><p>In a letter written to friends remaining in Germany during the reign of the Nazi regime, Dietrich Bonhoeffer said that “if we want to be Christians we must participate in Christ’s own magnanimous heart by engaging in responsible action that seizes the hour in complete freedom, facing the danger. And we should do so in genuine solidarity with suffering flowing forth, not from fear, but from the liberating and redeeming love of Christ toward all who suffer. Inactive ‘waiting-and-seeing’ or impassive ‘standing-by’ are not Christian attitudes. Christians are prompted to action and suffering in solidarity not just by personal bodily experience, but by the experience incurred by their fellows for whose sake Christ himself suffered.”<a href="http://christianity-now.com/jonah-and-the-story-of-white-american-christianity/#_ftn2">[2]</a> Here, Bonhoeffer articulates a Christian life that is rooted in active and intentional solidarity with the oppressed. And as Jonah is to live into his calling as a Jewish Prophet, <em>if we want to be Christians</em> we must incarnate the heart of God, the heart that mourns for, and suffers with, the world.</p><p>Yet Jonah chooses to do otherwise.</p><p>Jonah, running from God’s command to go and participate in the salvation, the relational healing and restoration, of Nineveh, chooses to deny others the love of God by refusing to care for their wellbeing. This is the sin of Jonah.</p><p>Jonah is found unwilling to incarnate the grace and justice of God for others and, instead, excuses and defends his lack of concern. Indifferent toward their wellbeing, he fails to embody the Torah, which is fundamentally concerned with living in holistic relationship alongside neighbors and creation. Rather than receiving God’s command to turn toward Nineveh in compassion, Jonah shows Nineveh his back. And while white American Christians cannot fully relate to the reasons why someone like Jonah — in his experience of religious and ethnic oppression — is unwilling to passionately care for the redemption of the empire of Nineveh, we <em>can</em> identify with his essential reluctance.</p><p>Paralleling the reluctance of the prophet, white Christians have failed throughout the history of the United States to live, first, in solidarity with black and brown human beings and, second, in protest against the systemic racism that perpetuates and justifies their daily oppression. Rather than utilizing one’s power, privilege, and resources to dismantle and deconstruct the demonic discrimination that systemically harms the physical, mental, and emotional health of individuals and communities of color, many white Christian communities have remained untouched by the loss of life and by the outcry of black and brown human beings.</p><p>In the final chapter of the short narrative, the angry Jonah resents God’s compassion and love for Nineveh, so God, testing Jonah’s heart, provides him shade underneath a shrub, then quickly takes it away. In agony, Jonah melodramatically contests, “It’s better for me to die than to live.” The story ends with God wondering how Jonah could be so concerned with his personal shade under a shrub, yet incredibly calloused towards the holistic redemption of human beings made in the image of God, as well as the rest of the natural world.</p><p>If white Christians are to participate in the decolonization of our Christian communities, we must repent from our indifference, our lack of care and concern for black and brown lives, and turn toward God’s creation, which we are called to seek relational wellbeing with. This will take nothing less than an intentional decolonizing of our embedded ideologies of black-inferiority, our theologies that fail to confront and disrupt the sin of racism, and our day to day ways of being in the world as beneficiaries of white privilege.</p><p>According to the Apostle Paul, Jesus became the Christ, not because he was powerful, or because he was in a particular political party — he certainly did not identify with those who used their weapons to terrorize the most vulnerable to subjugation; rather, Jesus of Nazareth became the Christ in his relentless faithfulness to the actualization of the Realm of God — as demonstrated in his willingness to stand with, “to the point of death,” those whose lives the empire had deemed worthless. The crucifixion of Jesus is his final testimony that, even in the face of such brutal violence, he believed witnessing to the truth that <em>oppressed lives</em> really do<em>matter</em> was more essential to his Jewish faith than dismissing their suffering with a quip that “All Lives Matter.”</p><p>Let us refrain from “inactive ‘waiting-and-seeing’ or impassive ‘standing-by.’” Today and every day, white Christians ought to emerge with a renewed commitment to, and understanding of, the salvation of all God’s creation — including our own. We must choose solidarity over defensiveness, poverty over privilege, mutuality and interdependence over a messiah complex, because the salvation of this world is interconnected and inseparable. Returning to the words of Gutiérrez and Bonhoeffer, if white Christians truly want to be known by our “Christian poverty” that, essentially, is “an expression of love,” we will begin to “seize the hour in complete freedom, facing the danger,” and willingly choose to “participate in Christ’s own magnanimous heart” for dismantling the demonic powers of racism.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/jonah-and-the-story-of-white-american-christianity/#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Gutierrez, Gustavo. <em>A Theology of Liberation</em>. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books, 172.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/jonah-and-the-story-of-white-american-christianity/#_ftnref2">[2]</a> Bonhoeffer, Dietrich, Manfred Weber, and Douglas W. Stott. <em>Meditations on the cross. </em>Louisville, KY: Westminister John Knox Press, 26.</p><p>This article originally appeared on <em>Christianity Now </em>under <a href="http://christianity-now.com/jonah-and-the-story-of-white-american-christianity/">Jonah and the Story of White American Christianity.</a></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/jonah-and-the-story-of-white-american-christianity/">Jonah and the Story of White American Christianity | Christianity Now</a></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/chasetibbs/">Chase Tibbs</a></p><p>Contributor at <a href="http://christianity-now.com/jonah-and-the-story-of-white-american-christianity/christianity-now.com">Christianity Now</a></p><p>Chase is currently a student at Christian Theological Seminary in Indianapolis, Indiana. Pursuing an MDiv and MTS, his interests lie in reimagining faith for persons of faith in postmodern contexts. He is influenced by the Holiness movement, process philosophy, existentialism, liberation theology, and postcolonialism.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2bfe37c4b103" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now/jonah-and-the-story-of-white-american-christianity-2bfe37c4b103">Jonah and the Story of White American Christianity</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now">Christianity Now</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The New (Old) Good News: Fulfillment is Crap]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christianity-now/the-new-old-good-news-fulfillment-is-crap-fbb6634381db?source=rss-58c7b9ab08b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fbb6634381db</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bible]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jesus]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Aug 2017 13:01:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-30T13:01:39.650Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>April 3, 2017/in <a href="http://christianity-now.com/category/christianity/">Christianity</a> /by <a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/ben/">Ben Whitehead</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*hZqxZr8avX_mA4Zmlwrd9g.jpeg" /></figure><p>What do you do when you feel within yourself a kind of existential lacking? Where do you turn? What systems or narratives help make sense of what you’re feeling?</p><p>For a long time, I have been pretty tuned in to a kind of lack, a deficiency, in my being. For some of us, sentiments of this nature possess within themselves no positive elements, and are forgotten, if ever recognized. And yet, there are others who, quite contrarily, have been aware of this lack from an early age. This was part of my religious experience.</p><p>Traditionally conservative Christian communities, who believe the Christ is the one who propitiates a debt, need a very real iniquity to be present. And, at eight years old, I knew that my occasional outbursts of anger when my brother would cheat at hide-and-go-seek were adding to a debt impossible to pay.</p><p>Of course, like any person with something to say, I have somewhat arbitrarily set up these two positions (the one that is skeptical of absolute human depravity, and the one that needs it desperately) as opposing forces. Regardless of which position you might identify with, both fall short of my actual lived experience and I suspect yours, too.</p><p>Humor me, for a brief moment of philosophical and psychoanalytic rambling. The great French psychoanalyst, Jacques Lacan, famously introduced what he called “the mirror phase” in 1936. The mirror phase posits that infants, sometime between the age of six and eighteen months, awaken to their own, very real, subjectivity.</p><p>Infants, Lacan’s now widely accepted theory asserts, do not come out of the womb aware of the difference between themselves and their mothers. All their sensations of hunger, pain, warmth, and fear have been directly tied (quite literally) to their carrying mothers. This attachment doesn’t cease until sometime between six and eighteen months. And, as you can imagine, the rupture is rather traumatic. Carl Jung remarked, “There is no coming to consciousness without pain.”</p><p>The birth of consciousness has within itself a deep fissure that manifests in a feeling of essential lacking. The infant, now aware of itself as subject, painfully wishes to reattach to the mother, to feel and crave and need within the same body. This craving to reconnect, as a confession of one’s own lacking, is one way that we might, religiously, talk about <strong>sin.</strong></p><h3>On Sin</h3><p>The problem of sin in our current context, whose prevailing paradigms of opposition either deny its existence (some exaggerated form of humanism?) or purge its existence (atoning Jesus), induces a deep shame that only begets more shame, and ultimately leads to unhealthy ways of dealing with one’s own lack. If, like me, you were raised to believe that Jesus was some kind of atonement for your sin, then you might have momentarily celebrated a sensation of freedom. “No longer am I bound by my own capacity for destruction.” But days, hours, even minutes later, those feelings give way to those of an essential lacking we thought Jesus purged.</p><p>Either my prayer didn’t work, or Jesus is not as good at forgiving as my pastor said. Either way, the experience induces a shame that debilitates me even further.</p><p>If, unlike me, you come from a community that affirms the wholeness of humanity, you might briefly celebrate the ecstasy of human utopias. Beauty, truth, and goodness embodied within the human is something worth celebrating, sure. Yet again, those feelings subside when we walk away from those communities and are reminded, once again, of just how much we long to be someone who we are not; to imagine a world that is not; to hope for a divinity that somehow seems not, altogether.</p><p>Imagine the shame of carrying that essential lack within yourself, all the while participating in communities that say, “We do not believe any kind of lacking exists within you.” How ostracizing. How shameful.</p><p>The truth of my very human experience is that pain, lack, brokenness, sin are what make me essentially human. “There is no coming to consciousness without pain.” There is no subjectivity without the desire to un-see oneself as subject. Humanity, in this view, is the wish to eliminate oneself, for the ultimate goal of becoming God. Sound like Genesis to you?</p><p>Though we often read the story of the Garden to be some kind of heaven on earth, harmonious and free of sin, Adam and Eve are already very aware of their lacking. There would be no desire to eat the fruit and become like God if Adam and Eve were already whole. The desire to become that which they were not was a testimony to the lack they felt in themselves.</p><p>And, of course, eating the fruit does not satisfy their wish for fulfillment. Instead, Adam and Eve feel more existentially broken than ever before. That’s how church often works for us, today. There are promises of fulfillment made by pastors who genuinely want us not to hurt like we do. But frankly, we do, and no amount of prayer will change that. Trust me, I have tried.</p><h3>The Good News</h3><p>So then what about Jesus? If Jesus is not the one to save us from our lacking, to fulfill the lack that constitutes our human condition, then what the gehenna (hell) was he for? Is it possible that Jesus’ death was not a canceling of a spiritual debt, but the canceling of the search for fulfillment? Stay with me, because I think there is a difference here.</p><p>Jesus’ life and death, specifically in the tearing of the Temple curtain, reveal to us just how desperate we are to rid ourselves of our own existential lacking, and thus, our own humanity. <strong>The good news of Jesus is not that life is now somehow great, praise God. The good news of Jesus is that life is skubalon (shit), praise God.</strong></p><p>And in revealing to us that the search for fulfillment only deprives us of fulfillment, we are invited into a new way of living, one that earnestly seeks to call out our lacking and construct healthy ways of dealing with it. In tearing the curtain, Jesus shows us the truth: that everything we thought was capable of bringing fulfillment is merely a figment of our imagination. The presence of God was never contained behind the curtain in the same way that money was never the key to happiness, prestige was never the door between making it and not, and ecstasy was never the chemical of everlasting joy.</p><p>If you are discouraged about this reading of Jesus, then you get what I mean all too well. The truth of the matter is, “I am not trying to make you depressed. I am trying to tell you that you are already depressed”, yet somehow you’ve denied yourself that truth. Seriously though, if you hate this idea, no worries. Call, email, or text me. Let’s talk about it.</p><p>In the meantime, I’d recommend catching up on HBO’s Westworld, as it more poignantly captures the nature of consciousness, and its relationship to pain, than I am capable of doing. Without giving anything away, I wonder if Westworld is not so different than our world. Though perhaps not androids, we are just as aware of our suffering as Delores (one of the main characters). For some, if not all, that awareness has been internalized into some kind of shame. But more pointedly, it is our suffering, our lack, that makes us human.</p><p>There is no subjectivity without lack. The solution is not a world where we cannot lose, as the makers of Westworld thought. Instead, it is in this world, where we can and do lose, that we find meaning and beauty. It is because of death that we find meaning in life. It is because of rejection that we celebrate acceptance. It is because, and not in spite of, our primordial lacking, that we might stumble upon love.</p><p>This article originally appeared on <em>Christianity Now </em>under <a href="http://christianity-now.com/new-old-good-news-fulfillment-crap/">The New (Old) Good News: Fulfillment is Crap.</a></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/new-old-good-news-fulfillment-crap/">On the Gospel</a></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/ben/">Ben Whitehead</a></p><p>Contributor at <a href="http://christianity-now.com/new-old-good-news-fulfillment-crap/christianity-now.com">Christianity Now</a></p><p>Ben is a graduate of Vanderbilt Divinity School and resides in Nashville, TN, with his wife Rachel. His primary interests are radical theology, professional basketball, and the guitar.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fbb6634381db" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now/the-new-old-good-news-fulfillment-is-crap-fbb6634381db">The New (Old) Good News: Fulfillment is Crap</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now">Christianity Now</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Demand of the Resurrection]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christianity-now/the-demand-of-the-resurrection-fdf99e4803a1?source=rss-58c7b9ab08b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fdf99e4803a1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[easter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jesus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bible]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 27 Aug 2017 13:01:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-27T13:01:00.940Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>April 16, 2017/in <a href="http://christianity-now.com/category/devotional/">Devotional</a> /by <a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/micah/">Micah Wimmer</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_M0rN6ndCfwcPZ6WUax0UA.jpeg" /></figure><p>According to the Gospel of Mark, less than forty-eight hours after Jesus had been buried in a tomb hewn out of rock, three women whose lives had been changed due to his ministry made the journey to his tomb in order to anoint his body. As they walked, they wondered about practical details such as who would roll away the stone from the tomb’s entrance so they could access Jesus’ body, yet upon their arrival they saw that the stone had already been rolled away. When they entered the tomb, they saw a young man in a white robe who told them that Jesus the Nazarene, the one who had been crucified, had risen, and to go to Galilee where they would see him. The text then says they went away in terror and amazement, despite the young man’s admonition to not be alarmed, failing to immediately fulfill his demand to inform the disciples, telling nothing to anyone due to their fear.</p><p>The Gospel of Mark originally ended abruptly after their fleeing from the tomb, with the disciples unnotified about this stunning event, with the young man’s claims about the rising of Jesus unconfirmed. Later manuscripts added a neater ending to the text, wrapping things up more in line with the other three canonical Gospels, featuring Jesus’ appearances to the disciples and his ascension. Yet, personally, I find something very human, very relatable about the ending of Mark as originally written. The news delivered to these women was shocking, jarring, honestly quite unbelievable. They had every right to ask themselves a number of perfectly understandable questions: Who is this person telling us these things about our dear friend? Why is he making up this story? Where is Jesus’ body?</p><p>I wrote on Good Friday that the crucifixion is not an event consigned to the distant past, but one that reoccurs in various guises in our present age. Similarly, while the resurrection is something that occurred in Jerusalem on Easter Sunday, it is also an event that we can bear witness to millennia later. We catch a glimpse of the resurrection wherever what once was hopeless bears new fruit in a way previously unforeseen, whenever that which was death-dealing is qualitatively and creatively transformed into something life-giving, affirming love, beauty, and truth. As Christians, we affirm that what happened on Easter Sunday was uniquely decisive and singular, and not merely a story about the past. And this decisiveness lies in the fact that the resurrection remains an event that we are able to witness, and testify to, even today.</p><p>As witnesses of the resurrection, as those who have heard about it from its original participants, we are compelled to make a decision. While the last we see of the women in Mark’s original ending shows them running away from the tomb, shocked and possibly horrified by what they have seen — or, perhaps more accurately, by what they have not seen — there is a shorter ending, likely added by another author, that tells us that the women “quickly reported” what they had seen to the apostles, allowing for this news to spread in ways it would not have otherwise. The women’s initial reactions make a certain amount of sense, both logically and emotionally. It is hard to imagine something has been truly transformed, that death has been defeated. In many instances, it is even harder to face the newness offered in this moment as a welcoming presence, finding it preferable to stay in well-trod habits of being that may not bring the most life into the world, but are nevertheless comfortable, what we know. In this way, the resurrection is not merely something that one witnesses, for it is also something that confronts us, asking us if we will flee in terror and amazement or choose to share the hope it offers with others, inviting them to join us in a new reality that cannot be anticipated, but only entered into.</p><p>The young man in Mark highlights the fact that the Risen Christ is also the Crucified Jesus, that there is an ineluctable relationship between the two that cannot be ignored or brushed over, showing that there is an absolute connection between Jesus’ life, death, and resurrection. Too often we fail to see this dual nature of Jesus, believing that he was essentially a superhuman or that his death on the cross was the culmination of his earthly ministry rather than its tragic end. Yet the resurrection, as much as anything else, bears witness to the triumph of Jesus’ ministerial vision over all attempts to extinguish it. You cannot believe, truly, sincerely, in the Risen Christ without also believing in the Kingdom of Heaven — its presence and its coming.</p><p>We do not come to believe in the resurrection as a piece of knowledge, as if believing in Jesus’ coming back to life one Sunday morning is all there is to it — one can believe that Jesus started walking and talking after his death and still not believe in the resurrection. Instead, to believe in the resurrection is to believe in an event — the absolute event of the Christian tradition. It is that which grounds our hope and undergirds all faith in Jesus as the Christ. This event tells us that what currently appears hopeless may not be — in spite of all rational evidence to the contrary. It proclaims that death and destruction and oppression do not have the final word about our existence, for the meaning of the resurrection is that God turns death into life. It displays, concretely and absolutely, that the Kingdom of Heaven which Jesus proclaimed throughout his ministry is indeed already present, in our midst, waiting to be recognized and furthered.</p><p>The resurrection is not about the resuscitation of a corpse. If it were, then we would be forced to equally venerate the ‘resurrections’ of the children raised by Elijah and Elisha in 1 and 2 Kings, Lazarus in the Gospel of John, and multiple other examples throughout the Bible. There is something then that makes the resurrection of Jesus qualitatively and absolutely distinct from these other examples. Resuscitation is essentially a continuation of life, allowing one to pick up one’s life where they left off. The resuscitated are changed, certainly, but not essentially — their mortality remains and they are bound to die again, this time with no hope of continuing their earthly existence. Resurrection, however, is not about continuing one’s present life, but about entering into a new kind of life, a new reality, a new state of being that we are compelled to participate in ourselves. An encounter with the Risen Lord means that our life cannot continue as it did before, that there is something changed irrevocably within us. In the words of St. Paul, we are a new creation for the old has passed away. As it did for the three women in Mark, such an encounter with the Risen Christ may cause terror and amazement, but more than that, it leads to new understanding of self and the world, leading to the transformation of both.</p><p>This article originally appeared on <em>Christianity Now </em>under <a href="http://christianity-now.com/the-demand-of-the-resurrection/">The Demand of the Resurrection.</a></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/the-demand-of-the-resurrection/">Easter Devotional</a></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/micah/">Micah Wimmer</a></p><p>Executive Editor | Social Media Manager at <a href="http://christianity-now.com/the-demand-of-the-resurrection/christianity-now.com">Christianity Now</a></p><p>Micah Wimmer is a writer whose work has appeared on Oakley &amp; Allen, Nieman Storyboard, and the Shocker. A recent graduate of Claremont School of Theology, and an avid NBA fan, he lives in Akron, Ohio, with his two cats.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fdf99e4803a1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now/the-demand-of-the-resurrection-fdf99e4803a1">The Demand of the Resurrection</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now">Christianity Now</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Has the Bible Betrayed Us?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christianity-now/has-the-bible-betrayed-us-b8726881b4b7?source=rss-58c7b9ab08b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b8726881b4b7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[faith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jesus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bible]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Aug 2017 12:38:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-25T12:59:12.505Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>April 3, 2017/in <a href="http://christianity-now.com/category/devotional/">Devotional</a>, <a href="http://christianity-now.com/category/featured/">Featured</a> /by <a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/codyrhynard/">Cody Rhynard</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*o0Q87uPjCYavbGS4w7d1xQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Just recently, I found myself in the midst of a fascinating conversation, driving down a slippery, snow-packed road in the Blue Mountains of southeastern Washington. Ryan, a former student from my church, just returned from his first semester at a private, Christian, liberal arts college, and joined me that morning for a little snowshoeing expedition in the beautiful “Blues,” as locals endearingly call them.</p><p>We spent the first hour of the day driving up the mountain and talking about his new girlfriend, his dorm mates, and how much he enjoyed his first semester, despite already being sick of the food. On the drive home we picked up where we left off, and I asked him how he liked his first few religion courses, and he gave me a rather uninteresting assessment of the two courses he had taken. Ryan shared that the religion courses sparked some theological conversations between him and some of his friends. Using that window to inquire into what I was really curious about, I asked if his theology had changed during his first semester. His response was not shocking.</p><p>He said, “Yeah, I’m not sure if I can believe the Bible anymore.” The words kind of spilled out, the way words spill out when you’ve bottled up a resolution far too long and are unsure how to begin expressing yourself but know nonetheless that you are where you are. He shared that he learned in his Introduction to the Bible course that many of the 13 New Testament letters attributed to Paul were very likely not penned by the apostle but were written pseudonymously (by someone else, in Paul’s name).</p><p>The second reason he gave was a reference to Paul’s initial words to the churches in Galatia, “Paul an apostle — sent neither by human commission nor from human authorities, but through Jesus Christ and God the Father…” (Gal 1:1 NRSV). Ryan expressed that he had a hard time believing one man could make such a daring claim and carry such authority. And certainly, anyone familiar with the great world religions would agree that it is no hard thing to claim divine authority.</p><p>Ultimately, Ryan was disillusioned by his discovery that the Bible is much more complex than he had been taught. The question follows: Does this complexity of scripture add to its beauty, or does it strip it of its voice in a scientific age where knowing what is around every corner is championed? Many of the greatest biblical scholars find this three-dimensional complexity of the Bible captivating, only adding to the charisma of these sacred texts that shake the foundations of our ego-centric claims to our place in the world.</p><p>Knowing that Ryan was spending a semester studying religion (particularly the Christian faith) from reputable and competent professors, I was not surprised by his initial statement, though I was taken aback by his reasons. That these seemingly rudimentary facts would pull the rug out from under his feet to the degree that he would question the authority of the biblical witness seemed quizzical to me in that moment. I remember thinking, “That’s it? That’s what rocked your boat? What about the textual discrepancies, like the fact that there are somewhere around 3,000 manuscripts of the Greek New Testament, some partial, some complete, that have been preserved, and that no two of these copies are identical?” What is more, as Raymond Brown concisely states:</p><p>No autograph or original [manuscript] of a NT[New Testament] book has been preserved; the differences came in the course of copying the original. Not all the differences stemmed from mistakes by copyists; some arose from deliberate changes. Copyists, at times, felt impelled to improve the Greek of what they received, to modernize the spelling, to supplement with explanatory phrases, to harmonize Gospels, and even to omit something that seemed dubious.[1]</p><p>Ryan did not even breach these issues in his explanation for questioning the authority of the biblical witness. Consequently, I was surprised that the discovery Paul was (probably) not the author of every letter attributed to him compounded with the fact that Paul, yes, was a human being, and that the Bible, yes, is a collection of writings penned by different human beings throughout time, were reasons enough to jeopardize Ryan’s trust in the Bible. But maybe I should not have been so surprised. Which brings us to the question, “Has the Bible betrayed us?”</p><p>What do we do when the context within which we understand the Bible changes in a way that brings the Bible into conflict with our particular religious beliefs and self-understandings, when we zoom the lens in closely and notice the seeming discrepancies and nuances both implicit within and surrounding the biblical witness? What do we do when our understanding of the Bible appears to betray our faith?</p><p>One popular option is to bury our head in the sand, ignore the discrepancies, and chalk them up as the byproduct of liberal-progressive academia that long ago lost its reverence and respect for scripture and has championed historical-scientific methods over a faith-filled reading of the text. This often leads to a stilted fundamentalism, egocentric in nature, where one decides both what the Bible is and what the Bible means. The rules of the game have been set, and we faithfully refuse to consider anything outside those rules.</p><p>Another option is to walk away, forfeit our faith in the Bible, and, quite often, our belief in that to which the Bible claims to bear witness.</p><p>The problem with these two possibilities is that both play the very same game, and have agreed to the very same rules: the “head-in-the-sand” approach is merely gritting its teeth and refusing to consider revising the rules of the game in the fear that what is essential will be lost, while the “walk-away” approach is merely taking one’s king off the board and setting it in front of the opponent, saying, “I give up.”</p><p>Is there any possibility of understanding the Bible and asking the question, “Does respecting what we have learned of the Bible and its textual and historical context nullify the sacred claim of the text?”</p><p>Does the complexity of scripture strip it of its divine nature and invalidate its authority in the life of those who seek to understand it?</p><p>In other words, has the Bible betrayed us?</p><p>There is an old Zen proverb that says, at first, the mountain is just a mountain and the river is just a river. Then, the mountain is no longer a mountain and the river is no longer a river. And then once more, the mountain becomes a mountain, and the river becomes a river.</p><p>I do not think Ryan’s personal crisis with the Bible is destructive; it is deconstructive. His previously held notions and predispositions in his approach to the Bible are being deconstructed, as the building blocks of his faith are being reorganized, and restacked, and some, by necessity, absolved. I recognize in Ryan the beginning of a deconstruction that will be painful, violent, and lead to greater uncertainty. But to say that this conflict is bad or unnecessary is to lay claim to the boundaries of truth and thoughtfulness. We do not get to set those boundaries. We should not be so egocentric as to assume that our worldviews and self-understandings are sufficient enough, that we have learned enough to place ourselves at the epicenter of theological thought and orthodoxy. But if I am wrong, we should just be honest about it and all get t-shirts that say, “More orthodox than you.”</p><p>The mountain is no longer a mountain and the river is no longer a river for Ryan. And he will be faced with the existential question of where to go forth, of whether to go forth at all. He is walking through the painstaking experience of realizing that the Bible is not what it was taught to be, that it is not what he thought it to be. The script he was handed no longer works for him, and no one should belittle the courage of one who is willing to wade through that existential crisis to see what waits on the other side. The mountain is no longer a mountain, and the river is no longer a river, but the sun has not set on Ryan’s existential journey. Perhaps the most authentic and sincere commission we have to offer those like Ryan is, “Therefore, my beloved, just as you have always obeyed me, not only in my presence, but much more now in my absence, work out your own salvation with fear and trembling.” (Phil 2:12 KJV)</p><p>And if Ryan is willing to wade through this journey without receding into the stilted illusion of certainty and without removing his king from the table and handing it in―if he is able to find a faith community that is willing to sit with him in the dust and ash of his disillusionment, with what he has been taught about God, the Bible, and life, and not merely attempt to console him with hard and fast explanations that mock the gravity of his questions―he may just find this collection of writings, written by humankind, laying claim to God, to be divinely inspired beyond what he previously imagined. Then, God willing, the mountain might once again be a mountain, and the river a river.</p><p>This article originally appeared on <em>Christianity Now </em>under <a href="http://christianity-now.com/has-the-bible-betrayed-us/">Has the Bible Betrayed Us?</a></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/has-the-bible-betrayed-us/">Has the Bible Betrayed Us?</a></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/codyrhynard/">Cody Rhynard</a></p><p>Contributor at <a href="http://christianity-now.com/has-the-bible-betrayed-us/christianity-now.com">Christianity Now</a></p><p>Cody, hailing from Michigan, is a teaching pastor in the Pacific Northwest. He has taken interest in dialectical theology and continental philosophy and continually seeks to better understand the way faith functions in one’s life. He and his wife Kristyn have a daughter and love living in the PNW.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b8726881b4b7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now/has-the-bible-betrayed-us-b8726881b4b7">Has the Bible Betrayed Us?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now">Christianity Now</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Science, Faith, and the Riddles of Life]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christianity-now/science-faith-and-the-riddles-of-life-f595799c960c?source=rss-58c7b9ab08b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f595799c960c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 23 Aug 2017 16:57:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-25T12:57:33.537Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>August 7, 2017/in <a href="http://christianity-now.com/category/christianity/">Christianity</a>, <a href="http://christianity-now.com/category/featured/">Featured</a> /by <a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/micah/">Micah Wimmer</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vpJgIegXgAaYOmPO1HqaAw.jpeg" /></figure><p>In February 2014, Ken Ham — the founder of Answers in Genesis and the Creation Museum, organizations devoted to promoting a young earth creationist view of the world — debated Bill Nye — an educator who is best known for his PBS show from the 1990s who, like almost all others with an elemental understanding of the issues at hand, affirms that Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution is essentially correct. The debate itself was long and tedious. I quit watching a stream of it posted on YouTube in the following days just twenty minutes in. It was clear the two of them, despite ostensibly debating whether evolution was true, and if the Bible’s account of creation was a historically believable one, were hardly speaking the same language. The entire spectacle was representative of a divide between American Evangelicals who claim to take the Bible completely literally and those who find its mythic claims unbelievable in any historical sense, superseded by scientific findings and theories accumulated over the last few centuries. Such evangelicals have a fidelity to literalism that leads them to believe the earth is six thousand years old — a figure deduced by adding up various genealogies found throughout scripture — and leads them to choose to either disregard modern scientific findings or reinterpret them to fit their preconceived theological beliefs. In the last few centuries, this battle has continued, as many see science as disproving the validity of, and eliminating the need for, religious belief. Others, meanwhile, attempt to reconcile their religious beliefs with scientific evidence in a misguided quest to spiritualize everything that leads to a bizarre confluence which does justice to neither science nor the reality of faith.</p><p>Ludwig Wittgenstein, an Austrian philosopher, provides a useful way to view the relationship between science and faith so the two are no longer in conflict, although this does not mean they harmoniously reconcile themselves to one another. In his later writings, Wittgenstein established the concept of “language games” essentially stating that each language game — science, for instance — has its own particular grammar and set of reasoning unique to itself. Therefore, it would be nonsensical to attempt to blend two language games — such as those of science and faith — as the grammar, logic, and meaning of each language game is radically and purposefully different from that of the other. Taking this idea seriously, one comes to see religion and science as two separate spheres which should not intersect.</p><p>Think of the statements, “I believe the earth is round” and “I believe in God.” While both of these statements are statements of belief, they represent two very different forms of believing. In the first, the speaker’s belief is rooted in evidence and data that support the claim, such as photographs from space showing the earth’s roundness and evidence of explorers, such as Ferdinand Magellan, circumnavigating the globe. There are empirical reasons for this belief.</p><p>According to Wittgenstein, the type of belief held by the religious individual professing belief in God is something separate from this scientific notion of belief. Religious belief is not based on any kind of evidence or proof — it cannot be founded on, or supported by, empirical data or reason as scientific belief can. Instead, religious belief is founded in “how one sees the world.” Despite religion’s lack of reliance on reasoning for support, this does not mean religious belief is irrational, but simply nonrational: rationality has no role to play as one’s view of the world is not empirical, but existential. Essentially, the key to the religious language game is the asking and answering of questions about one’s own existence — the “riddles of life.”</p><p>Because of these different forms of grammar and logic, Wittgenstein does not believe science and religion can critique or support one another. Consequently, whenever one attempts to ‘prove’ the existence of God with data or evidence, they are misguided since these proofs have nothing to do with the religious language game. Instead, these proofs are suspect to criticism by the scientific language game as they require, and are grounded in, impersonal data rather than one’s life. Conversely, whenever an atheist attempts to ‘disprove’ God by using rational proofs, they are equally misguided as they are not actually saying anything about religion and how it actually operates in the lives of persons of faith. With religion being founded upon one’s view of world and self, the encounter between self and God, atheism rooted in scientific skepticism is just as mistaken as one whose faith is justified by reason and ‘proofs.’</p><p>Protestant theologian Paul Tillich touches upon similar themes in his seminal book, <em>Dynamics of Faith</em>. In one section, he writes about “the truth of faith” in relation to scientific truth. He makes his viewpoint immediately clear when he states, “There is no conflict between faith in its true nature and reason in its true nature” because “the truth of science and the truth of faith do not belong to the same dimension of meaning. . . . Science has no right and no power to interfere with faith and faith has no power to interfere with science. One dimension of meaning is not able to interfere with another dimension.” Because Tillich defines faith as ultimate concern, he does not see how scientific evidence could confirm or deny one’s ultimate concern regarding the divine. For Tillich, “science can conflict only with science, and faith only with faith” because “the truth of faith cannot be confirmed by latest physical or biological or psychological discoveries — as it cannot be denied by them.”</p><p>Once one adopts Wittgenstein’s concept of language games, belief in God becomes an individual, existential issue instead of one subjected to burdens of proof. However, faith does not become completely relative, as one can only speak of God from within a specific religious tradition which places parameters on what one can conceivably say about God. Wittgenstein’s analysis is very useful as it does not deny the importance of either science or religion or set them up as opposed to each other. Instead, he posits that both are important parts of life for while “science can tell us about the world… we need the religious point of view to tell us about our existence.” In his work, the <em>Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus</em>, he states, “even when all possible scientific questions have been answered, the problems of life remain completely untouched.” (6.52)</p><p>If faith and science are to coexist in the mind of the believer while doing justice to both, the only way to do so is to keep them separate. As soon as one starts conflating God and science, they are no longer speaking about science, but instead are doing theology. There is no room for God in scientific inquiry, but this does not disprove or threaten the person of faith’s belief in God since science cannot claim to answer questions of existential import as religion does. However, theology is making a tremendous mistake when it clings to biblical literalism or dismisses the latest scientific findings for theology is absolutely worthless if it does not reflect and speak of the world in which we live. Ludwig Wittgenstein’s philosophy provides a way for religion and science to exist alongside each other without conflict by using the concept of language games to show science’s and religion’s separate logic, grammar, and function. This allows persons of faith to avoid feeling threatened by scientific discoveries which may initially appear to impinge on the Bible’s historical accuracy, and leaves science free from unneeded and unwanted intrusions from religion. It is a way of viewing the two separately that aids in answering “all possible scientific questions,” while also seeking to touch upon the “riddles of life,” those which religious faith is uniquely suited to address. Perhaps this will allow us to see both the grandeur of the cosmos, of all that is, and the meaning and beauty of our own lives — simultaneously, yet distinctly.</p><p>This article originally appeared on <em>Christianity Now </em>under <a href="http://christianity-now.com/science-faith-riddles-life/">Science, Faith, and the Riddles of Life</a>.</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/science-faith-riddles-life/">Science, Faith, and the Riddles of Life | Christianity Now</a></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/micah/">Micah Wimmer</a></p><p>Executive Editor | Social Media Manager at <a href="http://christianity-now.com/the-demand-of-the-resurrection/christianity-now.com">Christianity Now</a></p><p>Micah Wimmer is a writer whose work has appeared on Oakley &amp; Allen, Nieman Storyboard, and the Shocker. A recent graduate of Claremont School of Theology, and an avid NBA fan, he lives in Akron, Ohio, with his two cats.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f595799c960c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now/science-faith-and-the-riddles-of-life-f595799c960c">Science, Faith, and the Riddles of Life</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now">Christianity Now</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Charlottesville and Christianity: Our Complicity and Its Challenge]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/christianity-now/charlottesville-and-christianity-our-complicity-and-its-challenge-d436f0b6147d?source=rss-58c7b9ab08b0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d436f0b6147d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[charlottesville]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tylor]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 20 Aug 2017 23:51:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-25T12:56:47.376Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>August 15, 2017/in <a href="http://christianity-now.com/category/christianity/">Christianity</a>, <a href="http://christianity-now.com/category/featured/">Featured</a> /by <a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/micah/">Micah Wimmer</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oin0I-A_ushQdFcB0VEkWQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>What happened this weekend in Charlottesville, Virginia, is certainly shocking. Each refreshing of my Twitter feed over the last few days has brought a new spate of horrors as I learned more about what was happening in this central Virginian town where former President and slave owner Thomas Jefferson once lived. However, what happened could hardly seem surprising to anyone with a cursory knowledge of American history or to anyone paying the slightest bit of attention to the racist rumblings that have gotten progressively louder in recent years, which are now impossible to ignore. While we like to believe that the founding principle of America is something like freedom or democracy or liberty and justice for all, it is undoubtedly white supremacy. We are a nation that gained its land due to the genocide of Native Americans and only became an economic power because of the unpaid and forced labor of slaves, unwillingly taken from their home continent of Africa. The foundation of America is inseparable from the subjugation and murder of people of color — a systemic subjugation and stealing of life that continues to the present day with no signs of abating.</p><p>As people of faith, we are often unsure how to address such societal ills. We tend to worry that getting involved in the political, inevitably taking sides against another opposing group, is to sully ourselves, to dirty the purity of our religious views, to somehow harm our connection with the divine. This worry obscures the stark reality that being apolitical in a time such as ours is truly impossible. If you are silent about the racism in our world, then you tacitly, even if unintentionally, give support to the powers and principalities that we as Christians must fight against. James Cone, the father of Black Liberation Theology, wrote that in situations such as this, nonpartisan theology is a fantasy, an illusion: “Theology is always identified with a particular community. It is either identified with those who inflict oppression or those who are its victims.” Indeed, if we do not stand in solidarity with those oppressed masses, we will have failed to heed the words of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., when he wrote from a Birmingham jail, that it is not enough to repent “for the hateful words and actions of the bad people” as we must also atone “for the appalling silence of the good people.”</p><p>I have no doubt that many of the white supremacists who gathered around Thomas Jefferson’s statue on Friday night, chanting “White lives matter!” claim to be Christians, that they are people we sit by in the pew on Sunday morning, praying and worshipping together. How is this possible? How can one hold such abhorrent views, believing that prizing one race and ethnicity over another is compatible with their faith? The sad truth is that it is largely our own fault for not showing how clearly and absolutely the Christian faith must stand against Empire and against all that attempts to deal death towards any oppressed group. It is the fault of all religious leaders and laypersons who have become content with the way things currently are, refusing to see the liberative core of scripture, failing to condemn injustice as stridently as we should, while concomitantly failing to passionately advocate for justice.</p><p>We see this liberative streak that yearns for justice throughout scripture, perhaps nowhere more beautifully and poignantly than in the Prophetic literature. To name just two examples, in the first chapter of Isaiah, he writes of God hiding God’s eyes from Israel in spite of their prayers, refusing to listen for their “hands are full of blood.” How are they to make themselves clean before God? They are to “Cease to do evil; learn to do good; seek justice, rescue the oppressed, defend the orphan, plead for the widow.” Today, if we are not seeking justice, and the rescue of the oppressed, we too can be sure that God implores us to do so before we can be truly clean. Similarly, in Amos 5, the prophet speaks of God despising the Israelites’ worship, taking no delight in their solemn assemblies, and refusing to accept their sacrifices. Instead of offering such things, God makes clear what God really desires: for justice to “roll down like waters, and righteousness like an ever-flowing stream.” Echoing Isaiah and Amos, we need prophetic words coming from our pulpits and our parishioners, not platitudes. To quote Dr. King’s Letter again, we must not “stand on the sideline and mouth pious irrelevancies and sanctimonious trivialities,” but be “extremists for love” and the “extension of justice.”</p><p>Jesus was not crucified by Rome because they were interested in helping fulfill a preexistent divine plan, nor because Jesus told some nice parables and invoked his followers to love their enemies. Rather, Jesus was executed in the most violent way in order to make an example of him, because his teachings and actions were a threat to the Empire, to the status quo. Jesus was not merely a sage who spoke about compassion and the need to love God and neighbor. He was also a man who threw the money changers out of the temple and who violently accused his enemies of hypocrisy and being white-washed tombs that appear lovely, but contain nothing but the bones of the dead. His whole life was a stand against the totalizing impulses of Empire, against all that brings death instead of life, in the hopes of establishing the Kingdom of Heaven where all are welcome, where the poor are blessed and the hungry satisfied. In this hour, perhaps it is standing against Empire in all its manifestations — capitalism, white supremacy, authoritarianism, and patriarchy, amongst all too many others — that most fully allows us to follow in Jesus’ footsteps. Those of us who are people of faith are not called to stand on the sidelines, offering empty gestures and slogans of goodwill, but to fight for justice, standing in solidarity with the oppressed wherever they are to be found. May we fulfill our call.</p><p>This article originally appeared on <em>Christianity Now </em>under <a href="http://christianity-now.com/charlottesville-and-christianity-our-complicity-and-its-challenge/">Charlottesville and Christianity: Our Complicity and Its Challenge</a>:</p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/charlottesville-and-christianity-our-complicity-and-its-challenge/">Charlottesville and Christianity: Our Complicity and Its Challenge | Christianity Now</a></p><p><a href="http://christianity-now.com/author/micah/">Micah Wimmer</a></p><p>Executive Editor | Social Media Manager at <a href="http://christianity-now.com/the-demand-of-the-resurrection/christianity-now.com">Christianity Now</a></p><p>Micah Wimmer is a writer whose work has appeared on Oakley &amp; Allen, Nieman Storyboard, and the Shocker. A recent graduate of Claremont School of Theology, and an avid NBA fan, he lives in Akron, Ohio, with his two cats.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d436f0b6147d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now/charlottesville-and-christianity-our-complicity-and-its-challenge-d436f0b6147d">Charlottesville and Christianity: Our Complicity and Its Challenge</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/christianity-now">Christianity Now</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>