<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Vdm on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Vdm on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@Vdam?source=rss-2333e7865ce9------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 03:53:54 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@Vdam/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Family Violence]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Vdam/on-family-violence-fd0ca8b44cd6?source=rss-2333e7865ce9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fd0ca8b44cd6</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vdm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 04 Aug 2026 11:18:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-04T11:18:25.633Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’m being asked, again, to make myself responsible for someone else’s survival. Their literal survival. The message is clear: if I don’t step in, if I don’t drop what I have and go, then whatever happens next will be mine to carry. I know rationally that isn’t true. However, rationality doesn’t do much against future regrets your mind dangles in front of you.</p><p>It’s made me physically ill. Night terrors bad enough that I’ve needed sleeping aids just to function, which then leave me dull and groggy through the work I still have to do, because none of this pauses my life. PTSD causing sweats and chills. I used to be sceptical of the idea that stress alone could make you ill, properly ill, not just tired. I’m not sceptical anymore. It doesn’t stay in your head. It gets into your sleep, your body. You can tell yourself you’re fine and your body will call you a liar.</p><p>I was in two minds about whether to write this, because it isn’t only my story to tell. But there’s a point at which my own mental health has to take priority over other people’s comfort, and writing has always been how I process what I can’t otherwise get clarity on. This is deeply personal, deeply private, but it’s precisely the privacy around it that’s compelling me to write. So much of what I’ve experienced, and am still experiencing, has been compounded by the need to hide it: fear of what happens if people find out, shame at what admitting it would supposedly say about me and where I come from. I don’t want to live like that.</p><p>None of this is new. The title of this is about family violence, because that’s where it comes from. I grew up somewhere violence was the norm -women’s refuges, leaving in the night, pulling people off each other, picking glass out of what was left when someone had been thrown through it. I had my own experience of it too, in ways that don’t always look like the worst of it from the outside, which is sometimes used against me, as if witnessing and being made responsible for it is a lesser injury. I was sitting in solicitors’ offices as a child, advocating for adults. I was asked, more than once, to lie for someone else’s benefit. I thought I’d put a lot of this behind me. Turning 40 was supposed to be the marker of that. A point at which the drag on my life had gone quiet, and where I’d become boundaried enough to keep it at bay. And then it came back. It always comes back.</p><p>I think being queer is bound up in how I got any distance from it at all. That particular, quiet impulse to escape that I think a lot of queer people recognise, whatever their background. Maybe it looks different for people with more family support now, though I’m not convinced society is moving in a direction that makes that more likely. The common experience makes you learn early that the fairy tales about what family will always provide don’t hold, and losing that illusion early is both a wound and, oddly, a kind of freedom. It gave me the excuse I needed to build something of my own. I look at relatives who didn’t have that excuse, who stayed inside the same pattern, and I don’t know what would have got them out if not for something like it.</p><p>There are two fears sitting in me. One is the literal fear of being physically hurt if I step back into this. Honestly, that one doesn’t scare me as much as it probably should. I’ve never wanted to make decisions from that kind of fear, because I’ve watched what it does to people: fear of violence, of being alone, of losing money or reputation or access, all of it shaping decisions in ways that don’t actually protect anyone. Patriarchal structures keeping everyone in line through fear, not only the obvious victims, but those enforcing and enforced by it too. Everyone in the dynamic is afraid of something. The violence and the fear are the same machine, and I don’t think anyone inside it is free.</p><p>The other fear — losing what I’ve built — I think is legitimate, and I’m trying not to talk myself out of that one. I’ve got a lovely life at the moment. A partner I don’t think I was supposed to get to have, given who I am and where I’m from. A freelance career, which, whilst not always politically rewarding, is something I’m genuinely proud of. Those things in life that give you joy — dancing, holidays, a fortieth I’m planning to celebrate properly. Small, trivial things that are mine. And somewhere on the horizon, always, the pull to get properly re-involved and properly embedded in the causes that matter to me.</p><p>I’ve been in that fuller version before, where activism sat neatly alongside everything, and I stepped back from it. I’ve sometimes punished myself for that: not sufficiently committed, not doing enough compared to people who’ve dedicated their whole lives to something. I’ve been calling myself lazy for longer than that, though. It’s the same accusation I made against myself at Oxford, where I almost sank. I’d tell myself I was lazy, a procrastinator — never quite present, never quite keeping up. It’s only in hindsight that I can see what was actually happening: I’d arrived with a kind of restless alertness built up over years of keeping watch at home, waiting for things to turn violent. It had trained me to anticipate rather than absorb, to scan for danger instead of letting my mind rest. By the time I got to Oxford, that habit had hardened. Even in lectures, when I did manage to go, I found it hard to stay present: words drifted in and out of focus, my notes trailed off mid-sentence, the meaning slipping past me. Reading wasn’t much better — I’d loop over the same sentence again and again until the sense drained out completely.</p><p>I know now that wasn’t laziness. It was my nervous system doing exactly what it had been trained to do. And I think that’s the same misdiagnosis I’ve made about myself since. Mistaking the cost of what I survived for a character flaw, and then measuring myself against people who never experienced that. When I hear people on the left aggrandising about what they’ve built, I find myself doing the sums: the money behind them, the family stability, the schooling. It rarely impresses me the way these people want it to. What does impress me — and thankfully I know a handful of people like this — is what gets built by people who had none of that scaffolding underneath them.</p><p>I’m trying to be kinder to myself about that now. And despite what I’ve not been able to do, there is so much that I have done, and I’m deeply protective of what I’ve put in place that has allowed me to do so.</p><blockquote><em>Like every other crisis before this one, I still have to show up. Meetings still happen. Clients still need answering. There’s no version of this where I get to have a breakdown on schedule. But I refuse to let it take the joy out of my life too. Even functioning on fumes, I’m still going to laugh, still going to yap, still going to be silly, as if nothing is wrong.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>I don’t think I’m sharing this as some act of radical vulnerability. It’s just that I refuse to keep living in shame or in hiding about things that are not my fault. I haven’t done anything wrong. Silence only serves to protect the things being kept quiet. Sunlight is still the best disinfectant, even when, especially when, the culture you come from has taught you that silence is a form of protection.</em></blockquote><p>I’m lucky, genuinely, ridiculously lucky, to have a partner who has been extraordinary through this. But even that becomes its own quiet, private thing, because the expectations of the family, even when it&#39;s chosen family, even when it deviates from the norm, are that whatever you’re carrying gets contained within one relationship, one person, kept there and nowhere else. I don’t want that. Yes, I also don’t want to cannibalise myself for entertainment or followers, but I also don’t want to hide.</p><p>I’ve been deliberately vague throughout because some of this isn’t just my story, and because getting more specific risks exposing people who haven’t consented to it. But writing even this much has already made things a bit easier. Regardless, though, it’s a lot right now. It just is.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fd0ca8b44cd6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Having Somewhere to Go]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Vdam/having-somewhere-to-go-5ac91cce75bb?source=rss-2333e7865ce9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5ac91cce75bb</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vdm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Jan 2026 22:01:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-21T22:16:13.783Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’ve been joking recently that my parents seem to have a better social life than me.</p><p>When I go to Birmingham, both of them retired now, it’s hard not to notice how busy their lives still are. They’ve got this Indian pub they go to almost every weekend — live music, familiar faces, incredible food. We celebrated my dad’s 70th there, and he had his table of friends, but he also seemed to know half the room. The other half had become friends by the end of the evening. My mum’s phone rings constantly with calls from people at the mosque, often about organising things because she’s on various committees. My dad has his own circle too, both mosque friends and people outside it. People talk a lot about a men’s loneliness epidemic, and I wouldn’t describe my dad as a “modern” man in any meaningful sense. And yet it’s completely normal for him to have long phone calls with male friends, gossiping, talking about who’s died, and bitching about the world. He’s done plenty of holidays with those friends as well. They are also both always on the move, going to Leicester and London for weddings, community events, extended family things, and funerals, wherever they’re needed or have been invited.</p><p>The obvious explanation is that they’re retired, and time opens up. But the more I’ve thought about it, the less convincing that feels as a full explanation. Time matters, but it’s not the whole story. What my parents have, and what many people of their generation still have, is access to durable social infrastructure. Spaces that don’t rely on constant effort or reinvention. Places where belonging is produced through routine, obligation, and repetition, rather than through emotional labour or careful scheduling. I’m certain this isn’t just a quirk of my family. It’s part of a broader migrant experience that seems to thin out with each generation.</p><p>My parents’ migration stories are different, but they share a kind of force. My dad was displaced as a refugee from Uganda. My mum was displaced in a different way: pushed into coming here from Pakistan. Forced to abandon her studies, brought over to get married. And once here, they did what many migrants do (and still do) and moved to a place where others from their community were already. That wasn’t accidental. It was survival. In the face of an actively hostile state and a society that didn’t particularly want you, those networks became your oxygen supply: social life, emotional support, practical help, all rolled into one.</p><p>When I think back, I also realise how participation in those networks was ingrained as a routine rather than a choice. Going to mosque was non-negotiable. Religious classes on Saturdays. Eid events, New Year parties, weddings, and funerals. We had an expansive idea of “family” that wasn’t really about blood, but about proximity and obligation. People who wouldn’t be counted as family in white British culture were treated as such, because that’s how the community held itself together.</p><p>Of course, I don’t want to over romanticise this. A lot of it came with its own suffocation: gossip, drama, insularity, a lack of privacy, and the constant background pressure of religious and heteronormative expectations. There were good reasons why, as I got older, I wanted distance from it. Why freedom began to mean not being surveilled, not being discussed, and not having to account for yourself.</p><p>But increasingly, as I get older, I miss the warmth and continuity that came with it. There is a fear that when I reach my parents’ age, I won’t have what they have. That sense of place that doesn’t need to be constantly negotiated. Where you don’t have to wonder whether you belong; you just do, even if you sometimes resent the terms on which that belonging is granted.</p><p>The contrast with my own life, and my siblings’ lives, is stark. I’m lucky in the sense that I do have friends — probably more than is usual for a man of my age — but the social world I inhabit is thinner, more fragile, and far more individualised. In the assimilation that has taken place, once framed as aspirational and now increasingly demanded, something has been lost. Even for someone like me, who considers themselves relatively social, the default has shifted toward privacy: rest, self-care, self-preservation, and not having people know my business. I see the same shift with my cousins as well. Specifically, those who arrived from Pakistan with more of that social impulse intact seem, over time, to have drifted toward a more private existence. It’s not just that I see people less; the entire texture of my social life feels different.</p><p>Even generosity doesn’t feel the same as what I understood it to be growing up. I remember one of the first times my parents went to an occasion that wasn’t with other South Asian people, and their surprise when everyone split the bill. Of course, I understand the pressures of capitalism, but for them this was almost a way of operating outside its rules. Hospitality had its own clear logic: if you’ve hosted, if you’ve invited, you pay. There might be the familiar rituals of protest and insistence from guests, but in the end, you pay. You may tighten your belt afterwards, but you do so knowing that generosity will eventually come back around.</p><p>I’ve written previously about the grief I felt when I stepped back from organising — the loss of the social world that came with it, not just the political activity. But that sadness is also an acknowledgement of what those organising spaces never were. They didn’t have the easy warmth or sense of place that my parents still experience in their community spaces. For many of us in the second generation, activist and organising spaces were something we were inside, but not fully held by. We showed up, we worked, we committed, but we rarely felt that unspoken assurance of belonging. Even when it intersected with some other aspect of our identity, being queer, working class, etc., it still somehow felt like it was missing something.</p><p>There have been attempts, of course, to rebuild versions of this for the second generation: POC groups, events, parties, intentional spaces. I’ve seen enough of these efforts to recognise the pattern. They flare into life, feel briefly like an answer, and then struggle to sustain, at least for me. Some of that is practical — people are exhausted, busy, scattered, but there’s also something deeper. Too much has changed at the level of habit and expectation. Too much water has passed under the bridge. You can’t simply recreate what your parents had while keeping everything you’ve had to become in order to survive here.</p><p>Which is where the anger comes in. Hovering around all of this is the familiar accusation that migrants live “parallel lives,” separate from the rest of society. It’s exaggerated, but even where it’s true, I find myself thinking: why wouldn’t you? Why would anyone willingly choose this atomised, individualistic way of living if they had an alternative? This culture where people are half-scared of bumping into someone they know, vaguely resentful when the phone rings, slightly irritated by the doorbell, not because anything bad is happening, but because interaction itself feels like an intrusion?</p><p>That anger points outward, but it also turns inward, to the extent to which you absorb these habits simply by being here. I still get these impulses sometimes: I’m going to call this person. I’m just going to knock on their door. I’m going to be less careful, less managed, more like my parents in the way they reach for people without overthinking it. But it rarely happens, and when it does, it never stays.</p><p>What I’m left with isn’t a wish to return to what my parents had, or a belief that it could simply be rebuilt. Too much has changed, in us, and in the world around us. But the contrast remains clarifying. Their lives are still structured around places that assume connection, obligation, and generosity as a default. Mine, like so many others, is organised around managing isolation as efficiently as possible. That difference isn’t a personal failure or a lack of effort. It’s the outcome of a society that dismantled collective life and now bemoans the consequences, blaming the very communities it could learn from.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5ac91cce75bb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[After Movement]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Vdam/after-movement-e67f718bb951?source=rss-2333e7865ce9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e67f718bb951</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vdm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Oct 2025 14:20:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-24T14:20:07.388Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’ve been trying to diagnose a kind of ennui that has settled in, and I’m wrestling with whether it’s just a product of the stage of life I’m at. I find myself looking at my incredibly wonderful friends who — at least through the filter of social media — seem to have built professional and social lives that seamlessly incorporate their politics, their values, and the struggles they care about.</p><p>For me, my politics have always felt like a separate, almost additional, part of my life. Where their professional and personal worlds seem <em>of</em> their politics, mine have always felt in tension <em>with</em> them. Even when I had jobs that ostensibly touched on issues I cared about, the professional reality was the NGO world: a depoliticised, neoliberal space filled with people who didn’t share the political analysis I held. My <em>real</em> politics were always compartmentalised — a set of beliefs and principles walled off from the career that paid the bills.</p><p>Then, for a period, that separation collapsed. I began filling every conceivable gap with campaigning and organising. Those Corbyn years, in particular, were incredible because the barrier to entry was so low. I remember psyching myself up to go canvassing in 2017. The accepted wisdom then was that the project would tank after that election, and I was driven by a simple thought: <em>You’ve claimed to have these politics for years. What can you say you actually did?</em></p><p>So I turned up. That first session may have been full of losers from Labour Students, but as the campaign progressed, I met more and more people. This was where that “merging” happened — where the social and the political, the campaigning and the struggle, came together. I entered a world where you just turned up to other people’s events and learned as you went. Yes, The World Transformed (TWT) was incredible and intensely politicising (I eventually joined the steering group), but there was also the quieter political education of simply being around other smart, committed people.</p><p>I became heavily involved in Lesbians and Gays Support the Migrants, ran for and joined the board of Global Justice Now, and wrote for <em>We Own It</em>, <em>New Socialist</em>, and <em>Notes from Below</em> — finally finding an outlet to process the contradictions of my own international development career.</p><p>(I don’t list this to self-aggrandise, but to make a different point: my entire non-work world had become this. It was total immersion.)</p><p>The momentum didn’t disappear with the devastating 2019 election loss. I had resolved to “focus more on myself” in 2020, but the muscle memory of organising meant I kept going. The infrastructure of that life was still in place: I still went to LGSM meetings, we started Barnet Transformed, I contributed to Kill the Bill events and organised a talk called Black Trans Lives Matter. The activity continued, even as the hope began to fade.</p><p>Over the last couple of years, though, I started to take a break. Partly out of exhaustion, but also because when a movement is on the back foot, the interpersonal dynamics inevitably turn more negative and spiky. Those things you could once ignore — the unsaid racism in some spaces, or the jarring realisation that half the people you’re organising with went to private school — start to come to the fore. You tell yourself to take wins where you can, to avoid being so divisive that people stop showing up. To be honest about your own disqualifying characteristics. But those small frictions begin to grate when you’re no longer riding the euphoria of believing victory is inevitable.</p><p>So I stepped back. I resigned from the TWT steering group and stopped going to the festivals. I left the Global Justice Now board. I stopped going to LGSM meetings. You tell yourself it’s a temporary break to recover from exhaustion — that each decision has its own valid reason — but it all adds up, and the gap it leaves doesn’t stay empty.</p><p>I’ve filled that vacuum with work. This year, I went fully freelance. While I’m delighted not to deal with the internal politics of NGO life, freelancing has its own disciplining effect: the necessity of sustaining a life that’s now entirely self-funded. And the work itself still demands caution; I can’t lead with my politics. And there’s the unavoidable reality of age — the need to build a financial safety net, secure a pension, care for ageing parents, all while your body gradually declines: new aches, operations, depleted energy.</p><p>All this is compounded by what’s happening in the world. The huge shift rightwards makes it feel like this isn’t a country I’m meant to be in. As someone from a migrant background, I often fantasise about living somewhere I’d be in the majority. It’s a peculiar experience, specific to second-, third-, or fourth-generation non-white migrants: my parents at least had that sense of belonging, even briefly; I never have. My nieces and nephew won’t either. And because of colonialism, geopolitics, climate collapse, and my own westernisation, the places my family comes from aren’t really places I could move to and feel at ease.</p><p>So in many respects, I feel stuck here. And with that being the case, my focus now is, frankly, on making hay while the sun shines. Some comrades will get that; others won’t. I can live with that.</p><p>The idea that I could simply “come back” into organising spaces feels complicated. Activism needs consistency — it needs you to turn up regularly — and I don’t feel I have the capacity. I’ll get added to a local Palestine or Green Party group, and after two days, there’ll be fifty unread messages. I think, <em>How did I ever do this?</em> I used to. I just can’t now.</p><p>This is why so many of these spaces are dominated by the young or the retired. They exist outside that squeezed middle.</p><p>There’s a loneliness to stepping back from movement life that I didn’t expect — the sudden quiet when you’re no longer constantly in shared spaces or group chats. But stepping away doesn’t just leave a social gap; it changes how you think. Without those networks, you lose the informal learning that came from being around others.</p><p>I used to know everyone — or at least it felt that way. When people mentioned a campaign or a name, I could usually make the connection. There was some ego in that, I’ll admit, but it was also functional: those connections formed the scaffolding of my political analysis. Understanding who was working with whom, what the new flashpoints were — that was how I mapped the terrain.</p><p>Now, friends mention campaigns, acronyms, or people I’ve never heard of, and I just nod, feeling completely out of the loop. It’s not only that I stepped away — it’s that the world I left has kept moving. That internal map has atrophied, and with it, the analytical clarity that once came so easily. I know renewal is good — I always argued for TWT to bring in new faces and strategies — but I wasn’t prepared for how disorienting that distance would feel.</p><p>Underlying all this is a growing sense, maybe prematurely, that it’s simply not possible for me to do this in London anymore. I’m sick of every journey taking at least forty minutes. I tell myself that moving somewhere smaller — maybe Bristol — might help: closer to ageing parents and the young nieces and nephew I want to see grow up, but also a city with a vibrant political scene and easier to navigate.</p><p>But I know a mortgage, wherever it is, will be disciplining in its own way. And I have to be realistic about the fantasy of a “fresh start.” I’d just be trading one set of frustrations for another. Those things I found irritating in London — the well-meaning left spaces that still carry their unspoken biases — won’t disappear. They might even be sharper elsewhere. A former colleague, now a prominent left writer, told me that moving to Glasgow had benefits, but the lack of Black people there deeply affected their wellbeing. I have to be honest with myself that I could be walking into the same trap.</p><p>I’m not sure what the purpose of writing this is, other than to clarify what feels missing. I look at friends on social media who seem to have it all integrated, and I wonder if I stepped off the track at the wrong moment. But perhaps this is the unglamorous reality of being middle-aged on the left, in this country, at this moment: caught between the memory of a movement that once felt like everything, and the cold material necessity of a life that demands your full attention just to survive. Maybe the ennui, then, isn’t just a personal failing — it’s an intended consequence.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e67f718bb951" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Have You Read the Whole Book???” — Ash Sarkar’s Book Promotion]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Vdam/have-you-read-the-whole-book-ash-sarkars-book-promotion-4228511017d2?source=rss-2333e7865ce9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4228511017d2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[novara]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ash-sarkar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[left-wing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vdm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 25 Feb 2025 18:13:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-25T18:16:15.725Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>“Have You Read the Whole Book???” — A Review of Ash Sarkar’s Book Promotion</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/643/1*Ytp1VIwrPXjCuacwzRIpeQ.png" /></figure><p>Saying “Watch the whole interview” or “Read the whole book” whenever someone criticises your book promotion is a bit of a cop-out. Especially when most people get their first impression of your arguments through the headlines, the clickbait titles, or the snappy soundbites you’ve chosen to lead with. If you give everyone some shouty tagline about “Woke Is Dead” or “The Left Is Destroying Itself” to grab attention, you can’t then turn around and whinge that no one’s reading all 300 pages of your text for ‘proper context.’ Those snippets are how people get introduced to your ideas in the first place — especially when you and your publisher plaster them everywhere.</p><p>Lately, I’ve been seeing this play out around <strong>Ash Sarkar’s new book, <em>Minority Rule (2025)</em>,</strong> which dropped with a huge media push. You can’t avoid it: from PoliticsJOE inviting her on to say, “Woke Is Dead,” to The News Agents running segments with titles like “Is Identity Politics Rotting the Left?” Of course, these taglines are perfect for luring in right-wing pundits who love any whiff of a lefty ‘going rogue’ and slagging off ‘wokeness.’ Meanwhile, the actual content of Sarkar’s book might be more nuanced — but people see the sensational bits first.</p><p><strong>When the Right Says “Woke,” They Usually Mean Anti-Racism</strong></p><p>Let’s be clear: when the right wages a “war on woke,” they’re often waging war on anti-racist or pro-LGBTQ+ movements. They’re decrying “DEI” or “BLM,” effectively mocking the idea that we should respect marginalised voices at all. So if you come at this debate with attention-grabbing lines like “the left’s obsession with woke culture,” it’s easy to see why people might worry you’re feeding their narrative.</p><p>Now, I’ll be the first to admit that some left organising spaces can get stuck in petty language disputes or endless discussions about who’s offended by which term. I’ve seen that up close. I know it can be maddening. But you don’t fix it by handing the right a stick labelled “Yes, the left really has gone insane.” Because guess what? They’ll happily take it and use it to bash every social justice cause under the sun.</p><p><strong>Tired Anecdotes vs. Real Organising</strong></p><p>Frankly, it’s not clear who benefits from half the trivial examples trotted out in these interviews — things about “someone said something bizarre about Anne Frank” or “someone was outraged over salad spinners.” How does that help anyone learn how to organise effectively, or how to stand in solidarity against actual oppression?</p><p>If you want to start a genuine conversation about making left activism more effective, then let the soundbites and youtube thumbnails be about real campaigns, real strategies that draw in working-class communities, including the ones we often overlook. Grace Blakely, for instance, pointed out how the organising group ACORN reaches constituencies far beyond typical left circles on a recent NEF podcast. We should highlight those genuine organising successes instead of trotting out bizarre stories that do nothing except amuse right-wing audiences.</p><p><strong>“Woke Is Dead” or Just More Clickbait?</strong></p><p>The promotional sloganeering around <em>Minority Rule</em> has rubbed a lot of people the wrong way. Ash Sarkar herself warns that the left is “fixating too much on identity,” and in a sense, that’s true: hyper-focusing on who said what can sometimes overshadow the collective fight against austerity, privatisation, or corporate power. But the way she’s rolling out this message — on big platforms sponsored by corporate giants, with telegraphed headings that could double as right-wing talking points — feels like it’s fuelling the anti-woke feeding frenzy.</p><p>As soon as you announce “Woke Is Dead,” The Telegraph and co. latch onto it. You become the darling of people who argue that the left’s real problem is we’re all too sensitive and can’t handle basic freedom of speech. Even if Sarkar’s deeper argument is that elites are manipulating identity politics to divide people, the immediate upshot for many viewers is: “Look, even a self-styled communist says woke culture’s gone too far.”</p><p><strong>Losing Touch with the Grassroots?</strong></p><p>All of this is symptomatic of a wider trend in left media, whether at Novara Media or TYT in the States. Over time, the same faces and the same commentary can start drifting away from the real energy on the ground. They appear on mainstream shows and might stir up some buzz, but the format and the sensational marketing reduce everything to memes like “the left is destroying itself.” Meanwhile, the practical question — how we build movements that actually win — gets lost in the noise.</p><p>Left media organisations are increasingly stale echo chambers, or in some cases, evolving into clickbait factories chasing viral controversy. Maybe it’s time to bring in more queer voices, more Black voices, younger voices — people who are organising right now in their communities, rather than just pontificating about “the left” from behind a YouTube channel or a podcast mic.</p><p><strong>Genuine Critique vs. Pouring Fuel on the Right’s Fire</strong></p><p>To be crystal clear: yes, we should absolutely have honest discussions about any left organising that’s ineffective, exclusionary, or obsesses over trivial in-fighting. I could also cite examples of successes derailed by exaggerated references to “harm”. But there’s a world of difference between productive self-critique and playing into a right-wing culture war. If the price of mainstream attention is giving them easy quotes like “Woke Is Dead,” we have to ask who that actually serves.</p><p>If your immediate defence is, “But you have to watch the entire interview or read the entire book to really get it,” perhaps you should reconsider how you’re presenting your ideas in the first place. Because most people will never make it past your lead slogans if they’re plastered all over the media. And those slogans, however catchy, become ammunition for people who actively oppose racial justice, trans rights, or any other left cause.</p><p>Instead of throwing red meat to right-wing pundits, refocus on what effective grassroots organising looks like — and share more stories of that. Let’s try to fix what’s messy in our own spaces without smearing entire activist communities. We can critique performative behaviour on the left without handing a moral victory to the likes of The Telegraph, whose editorial line is essentially that anti-racist activism has gone too far.</p><p>Practically, this means:</p><ol><li><strong>Crafting Our Messages More Carefully:</strong> If we’re going to take issue with “fratricidal identitarianism,” let’s do it in a way that doesn’t let the right say, “See? They all admit wokeness is nonsense.”</li><li><strong>Elevating Real Successes:</strong> Point people towards big wins — like how ACORN has organised tenants or how local campaigners have shut down predatory landlords. Concrete success stories inspire real change.</li><li><strong>Rotating the Frontline Voices:</strong> Bring in fresh leadership — especially younger, queer, or Black activists with ground-level perspectives. Stale commentary from middle-aged voices eventually loses touch with lived realities — I say this as someone approaching 40 myself and increasingly finding myself tied to the status quo.</li></ol><p>In short, I’m not denying that self-reflection on the left is vital. I’m just saying that if every second word you deliver to the media is “the left is eating itself” or “woke has died,” then you’re possibly doing more harm than good. Stop telling people they “don’t understand” if they haven’t read every single page of your book. Maybe ask yourself why the narrative you’re leading with is so easy to weaponise against the very people and movements you claim to stand for.</p><p>If we want to re-energise the left, let’s do it by boosting the examples of where we genuinely unite people, rather than feeding the hungry tabloids with more lines about how “the left is doomed.” That might sell books, but it doesn’t build a movement.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4228511017d2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Where We Stand: Navigating Resistance and Survival in the Face of Far-Right Violence]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Vdam/where-we-stand-navigating-resistance-and-survival-in-the-face-of-far-right-violence-f74f469fb13b?source=rss-2333e7865ce9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f74f469fb13b</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vdm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 10 Aug 2024 23:35:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-30T23:56:39.566Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MsqA2qcckz_4kjHSZSuWPg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Like thousands, maybe millions of others — migrants, Black and brown people, Muslims — I’ve felt despair the last couple of weeks that cuts so deep, it leaves you hollow. There have been moments when the sadness hits like a tidal wave, completely unexpected and utterly devastating. It’s the kind of sadness that pulls you under, only comparable to the kind you feel when you’re grieving someone you’ve lost. And then there’s the anxiety, the fear that crawls under your skin. So many of us have been huddled over our phones, sending messages in family group chats, warning each other about where not to go, how to stay safe. The mosque I grew up in has been giving out guidance, telling people to avoid gatherings and to stay away from certain places.</p><p>And what’s worse is this overwhelming sense of pessimism about the future. It crushes me to think that no matter how many generations deep you are in this country if you are visibly non-white, you will never be seen as legitimate by a huge portion of the population. My lowest moments come when I think about my nieces and nephew, knowing that if it hasn’t happened already, they’ll soon come face to face with their own otherness. It could be on the playground, where a friend echoes the poison they’ve absorbed at home. Or maybe it’ll come from a teacher, a subtle comment that slices deep, a reminder that they don’t quite belong. Somehow, somewhere, it will come. The thought that, in so many ways, nothing has changed since my parents first came here is absolutely soul-crushing.</p><p>That’s not to say that recent migrants somehow deserve this far-right violence — no one does. But the far right often tries to cloak their hatred with claims of ‘legitimate concerns,’ like lost opportunities or feeling left behind. If these concerns were truly their sole and primary motivation — though their diagnosis of the causes is deeply flawed — you could at least see a way to challenge the systems and demagogues that have fuelled their misguided violence. But when you see videos of children singing “Pakis go home” or hotels where migrants reside being set alight, you know that this is just as much an expression of the visceral, violent racism that seems stitched into the very fabric of this country. After all, this is the nation that built an empire on the backs of black and brown bodies, that perfected the horrors of colonialism, that invented racism as we know it. This is the same country that produced figures like Tommy Robinson, Enoch Powell, Tony Blair, Suella Braverman, Priti Patel, David Cameron, Nigel Farage, Johnson, Churchill — individuals who, no matter what they or others claim, have all benefited from and perpetuated a system steeped in white supremacy and racism.</p><p>Yet, amid all this darkness, I’ve glimpsed a spark of hope. The anti-fascist mobilisation has been powerful, drawing strength from people of all backgrounds. This follows months of incredible solidarity with the Palestinians, and there are countless other examples of anti-fascist resistance throughout this country’s history, from Cable Street to Southall Resists. In that tradition, it’s clear that many in this country are still ready to stand up and fight back against the far-right surge. That’s why I’ve moved from a place of deep sadness to one of burning anger — an anger that I’m determined to channel into action. Our immediate priority must be to oppose the street fascists and rebuild the anti-fascist infrastructure that has withered. But beyond that, we need to understand why the far right feels more emboldened now than they have in decades. What is driving this resurgence? And how do we confront it at its roots?</p><p>These are the questions I want to explore — partly for my own clarity, but also in the hope that they resonate with others who might be feeling the same way. This won’t be a polished piece of writing; it’s more of an outpouring of thoughts, shaped by the words and experiences of those who have generously shared their struggles and insights. This is where I am, and this is where I’ll begin.</p><p>The surge in far-right aggression following the Southport murders is not a new phenomenon; it’s merely the latest chapter in a long history of racist brutality stoked by rumours, economic decay, and the calculated manipulation of fear. In the immediate aftermath of the attack, before any facts had surfaced, social media became a breeding ground for false claims, with many quickly and eagerly linking the tragedy to a migrant supposedly on an “MI6 watchlist.” This rumour spread like wildfire, stoked by far-right figures and disinformation campaigns, leading to real-world violence — mosques were attacked, Muslims assaulted, and racial tensions inflamed. Yet, the reality was starkly different: the suspect was a British minor with no ties to any extremist group.</p><p>The far-right violence fits into a grim historical pattern where baseless rumours have repeatedly ignited racial terror. Richard Seymour points to earlier examples that resonate with what we see now. In 1919 East St. Louis, unsubstantiated accusations against Black residents fuelled a deadly wave of lynching and destruction. Similarly, the 2002 Gujarat riots in India were sparked by false claims that Muslims had firebombed a train, leading to one of the most brutal pogroms in recent memory. Over a thousand people, mostly Muslims, were killed in that massacre. These historical precedents aren’t just distant echoes — they’re direct ancestors of the kind of violence we’ve witnessed in the wake of Southport, where a lie spread online can quickly manifest into real-world brutality.</p><p>This calculated leap to blame marginalised communities isn’t just the domain of anonymous internet trolls; it’s a tactic employed by public figures with significant platforms. In the immediate aftermath of the recent Sydney stabbings, Countdown host Rachel Riley took to Twitter to suggest that the violence was linked to a “globalised Intifada,” tying it to the Palestinian resistance. She claimed, “Attacks on Jews have recently become repackaged as ‘resistance’ in some circles, and we should in one voice condemn all acts of violence, whoever the perpetrators and whoever the victims.” Yet, Australian authorities had already confirmed that the attacker was a homeless man suffering from severe mental health issues, with no ties to any form of extremism.</p><p>Riley’s initial comments, which she later attempted to clarify, are part of a broader and deeply troubling trend where influential figures amplify baseless accusations, fuelling Islamophobia and deepening societal divisions. By recklessly linking a random act of violence to a wider narrative of increased antisemitic attacks, without any evidence, Riley contributes to the dangerous and pervasive stereotype of Muslims as inherent perpetrators of violence. This not only stokes unnecessary fear but also shifts the focus away from the real issues at hand. It’s a classic tactic — using the guise of ‘concern’ to push a divisive and harmful agenda that fuels Islamophobia and exacerbates the very tensions that lead to the kind of violence we saw in Southport.</p><p>The pervasive evil of supremacist ideology behind this violence should not be underplayed. Still, it would be equally remiss to ignore how decades of economic decline have created a fertile ground for the far right to flourish. Towns like Rotherham, Sunderland, and Blackpool — once proud centres of industry and working-class solidarity — have been hollowed out by decades of neoliberal austerity. The factories that once sustained these communities have long since closed their doors, leaving behind nothing but dead-end jobs, decaying infrastructure, and a social safety net in tatters. I’ve seen this devastation firsthand. My parents worked at the Longbridge car factory in Birmingham, a cornerstone of the community that was abruptly shuttered in 2005. The closure didn’t just cost jobs; it ripped the heart out of the city, leaving over 6,000 people suddenly unemployed. These were skilled workers who, after the factory’s closure, often found themselves in insecure, low-paid jobs in supermarkets or warehouses. Gone were the days of unionised, secure work with decent pay — instead replaced by a landscape of precarious employment where skills are undervalued, and the dignity of stable work is replaced by the uncertainty of zero-hour contracts and the relentless grind of the gig economy.</p><p>But austerity doesn’t just strip these communities of their livelihoods — it leaves them ripe for the poison of far-right ideologies. When people are pushed to the edge, when they feel abandoned and forgotten, they look for someone to blame. The far-right, ever the opportunists, are ready with their scapegoats — immigrants, Muslims, anyone who looks or sounds different. They offer simplistic, hateful answers to complex problems, and in their desperation, too many people are willing to listen. This is a cycle we’ve seen too many times before. Until we confront both the economic injustices and the racist ideologies that feed off them, we’ll keep seeing history repeat itself.</p><p>However, it’s a lot easier to confront these evils when they’re clearly identifiable and isolated. But today’s political landscape makes that much harder, as the line between mainstream and far-right rhetoric has become increasingly blurred. What was once relegated to the fringes of political discourse is now being voiced from the centre — a deliberate strategy employed by both Conservative and Labour politicians to broaden their appeal. But at what cost?</p><p>Enoch Powell’s infamous “Rivers of Blood” speech in 1968 laid much of the groundwork for the anti-immigrant sentiment that still persists today. Although Powell was ostracised by his party — dismissed from his position as Shadow Defence Secretary by Conservative leader Ted Heath — his speech resonated deeply with a significant portion of the public. Powell received tens of thousands of letters of support, and polls at the time indicated that a majority of the public agreed with his views on immigration. While the political establishment marginalised Powell, the ideas he expressed were never fully condemned or eradicated. Instead, they took root, influencing public discourse and policy in the following decades.</p><p>This mainstreaming of far-right ideas is evident in how the political centre has increasingly adopted toxic narratives, particularly around race and immigration, to court voters who might otherwise be drawn to more overtly fascist political organisations. By co-opting far-right rhetoric, mainstream parties make racist ideas seem more palatable, more acceptable. Consider how both Conservative and Labour parties have weaponised immigration to align with far-right agendas. The language of “taking back control” and “protecting our borders” is anything but neutral. It’s laden with exclusion, conveying that some people inherently belong while others do not. This rhetoric isn’t just about policy — it’s about identity, about defining who is considered truly British.</p><p>A stark example of this insidious trend can be seen in the actions of political commentator Matthew Goodwin, a regular contributor to mainstream media. Goodwin’s commentary on the Southport murder case, where he referred to the suspect as the “son of Rwandan immigrants,” is emblematic of how far-right rhetoric has seeped into mainstream discourse. His choice of words was not accidental; it was a deliberate attempt to racialise the crime, linking the suspect’s actions to his ethnic background rather than his individual circumstances. This mirrors the broader strategy employed by political figures who adopt far-right narratives to stoke fear and division. By foregrounding the suspect’s immigrant origins, Goodwin tapped into a far-right narrative that seeks to portray migrants and their descendants as inherent threats to British society, thereby reinforcing the notion that British identity is synonymous with whiteness.</p><p>The current situation, where mainstream political discourse increasingly echoes far-right narratives, didn’t emerge in a vacuum. Its roots can be traced back to the New Labour years, a period when the party, much like today, began to embrace stronger policing and surveillance measures, particularly in the aftermath of 9/11. Under Tony Blair’s leadership, figures like David Blunkett, Ruth Kelly, and Jack Straw laid the groundwork for this shift by framing British Muslims as a “fifth column” that required heavy-handed responses. Blair, for instance, spoke of the need to confront “the evil ideology” of extremist Islamism, which, while focused on supposed terrorism, often bled into broader Islamophobic rhetoric that vilified entire communities rather than isolated radicals. David Blunkett, as Home Secretary, went further, characterising certain immigrants as living “parallel lives” and needing to “conform” to British norms. Ruth Kelly, during her tenure as Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government, reinforced this rhetoric by stating that some Muslim communities needed to do more to integrate. Jack Straw, who served as both Home Secretary and Foreign Secretary, suggested that Muslim women should consider removing their veils to improve communication.</p><p>Even when New Labour claimed to confront the BNP, which was at its peak in the mid-2000s, they often did so by reinforcing the far-right’s language rather than challenging it. For example, Margaret Hodge’s so-called confrontation with the BNP in her Barking constituency failed to challenge the BNP’s racist ideology. Instead, she echoed their language, speaking of “indigenous” people feeling “swamped” by immigrants. This approach didn’t just fail to combat far-right ideas; it legitimised them under the guise of addressing “legitimate concerns.” This incident also serves as a stark reminder of Malcolm X’s warning about the “white liberal,” who, while posing as an ally, can be more insidious by perpetuating the very systems of oppression they claim to oppose.</p><p>Under Keir Starmer, Labour has resumed this trajectory, pandering to far-right sentiments in a misguided bid to reclaim what it perceives as the “working-class vote.” This approach not only perpetuates harmful stereotypes but also fundamentally misunderstands the composition and concerns of the working class in the UK. Starmer’s manifesto, with its promises to “control” immigration and “remove” people who have no right to be in the UK, mirrors the language of the far-right. By framing the working class as inherently inclined toward xenophobia and racism, Labour’s strategy denigrates millions of working-class people who are themselves migrants, people of colour, and Muslims.</p><p>Adding to this, Labour’s commitment to neoliberal fiscal rules further undermines its ability to address the root causes of discontent in working-class communities. By adhering to artificial budget constraints and prioritising debt and deficit reduction over public investment, Labour is effectively tying its hands when it comes to investing in the very communities it claims to represent. This commitment to neoliberal orthodoxy means that public services will remain underfunded, housing shortages will persist, and economic inequalities will deepen — conditions that create fertile ground for far-right exploitation.</p><p>The recent election results further highlight the flaws in this approach. Despite Labour winning a significant number of seats, its overall share of the national vote was only around 34% — a marginal improvement over Jeremy Corbyn’s 2019 result. This minimal gain is particularly revealing when considering that Starmer’s strategy aimed to attract a broad spectrum of voters, including the working class. However, the strategy seems to have backfired, alienating many, especially within the Muslim community, who felt betrayed by Labour’s stance on issues such as Gaza. This discontent was evident in the loss of key seats with significant Muslim populations, such as Leicester and Birmingham Perry Barr, where pro-Palestinian independents defeated Labour candidates.</p><p>In reinforcing these divisive narratives, Labour is not challenging the status quo; it is complicit in mainstreaming it. With the Tory Party likely to continue its shift further to the right and the spectre of Farage and his Reform Party ever present, Labour has opted to compete in this race to the bottom. This approach will not only fail electorally but, more dangerously, it will further embolden those who see violence as a necessary means to protect the so-called “purity” of the nation. The connection between toxic political rhetoric and the rise in far-right violence is undeniable. To resist the normalisation of far-right ideologies, we must hold the political centre accountable for its role in this dangerous process.</p><p>The media, too, must be held accountable for its role in legitimising far-right ideologies. During the current violence, media outlets have gone out of their way to frame the far-right as just another side in a debate, equating it with anti-racist movements as if they are morally equivalent. This false equivalence is not just misleading; it is dangerous. By presenting far-right and anti-racist groups as two sides of the same coin, the media sanitises the hateful and violent actions of the far-right. For instance, the BBC has referred to fascist gatherings as “pro-British marches,” language that not only downplays the severity of these events but also subtly endorses the far-right’s framing of themselves as defenders of the nation. Meanwhile, anti-racist voices, like that of MP Zahra Sultana, are met with scorn and derision when they call out racism and Islamophobia. Apparently, acid attacks on people of colour, individuals dragged from their cars, and assaults on mosques and Muslim-owned businesses are not sufficient to convince the media of the far right’s violent reality.</p><p>The media’s complicity in normalising far-right ideologies is inextricably linked to the oligarchic nature of media ownership in the UK. Rupert Murdoch’s media empire, for example, encompassing The Sun, The Times, and TalkTV, has long peddled xenophobic and racist rhetoric. This concentration of media power allows a tiny elite to control the national narrative, pushing a toxic agenda that fuels fear and division among the public. The corrosive influence of Murdoch’s outlets on public discourse is undeniable, but the issue extends beyond his empire.</p><p>The BBC, often held up as a bastion of impartiality, has in reality always served as a mouthpiece for the establishment. Its claims of neutrality crumble under scrutiny, revealing a consistent alignment with the biases and interests of those in power. In recent years, however, political pressures and budget cuts have dragged the BBC even further to the right. This shift isn’t just a reaction to financial and political constraints; it’s a deliberate strategy to remain relevant in a media landscape increasingly dominated by the likes of GB News and a plethora of right-wing YouTubers. In its desperation to compete, the BBC has not only parroted the narratives of the right-wing press but has also churned out its own brand of reactionary content, such as giving platforms to far-right figures on <em>Question Time</em> and framing migrant crossings as an “invasion” in its coverage.</p><p>Adding to this toxic mix is the rise of “client journalism,” where the lines between reporting and political propaganda are increasingly blurred. A glaring example of this trend is the absurd spectacle of former Labour Shadow Chancellor Ed Balls interviewing his wife, current Home Secretary Yvette Cooper, on ITV about the ongoing violence. This cosy relationship between media figures and politicians does not serve the public interest; rather, it reinforces the status quo and stifles critical discourse. Instead of challenging power, these interactions often sanitise and normalise the very narratives that need to be scrutinised, making it even more challenging to combat the far-right ideologies seeping into the mainstream.</p><p>Social media, once heralded as a tool to democratise information and challenge the dominance of traditional media, has now become a playground for the ultra-rich to push their supremacist agendas. Platforms like Twitter, under the ownership of Elon Musk, have devolved into breeding grounds for disinformation and far-right content. In the wake of the Southport murders, Musk’s role in inflaming tensions has been particularly alarming. His decision to reinstate previously banned far-right figures, combined with his retweets of unfounded claims linking the violence to immigration, has directly amplified racist narratives.</p><p>This convergence of traditional media’s complicity, the rise of client journalism, and the unchecked power of social media magnates like Musk create a toxic environment where far-right ideologies can thrive unchecked. To counter this, the media must undergo significant transformation. This begins by breaking up the concentration of media ownership, which allows a few powerful individuals to dictate the national conversation. The dangers posed by social media platforms under the control of individuals like Musk means we must nationalise these platforms, ensuring they operate in the public interest rather than as tools for private profit or political influence. Such a move would allow for more democratic oversight, holding platforms accountable for the content they amplify and the societal impact they have.</p><p>However, this does not mean endorsing calls for further legislative measures to regulate online speech. The Online Safety Act, passed in 2023, is being touted as a tool to curb online hate, with demands for its rapid implementation and expanded powers. While these calls may seem understandable, they pose significant risks to those on the left who seek to challenge the status quo. The act grants the government broad powers to regulate online content. But we know that these will ultimately be weaponised to silence dissent rather than address genuine threats. We’ve seen this before: counterterrorism laws that labelled Extinction Rebellion a “domestic extremist” organisation in 2019 were used to stifle legitimate activism. Under these laws, activists have faced increased surveillance, police harassment, and legal repercussions simply for advocating social and environmental justice. The Online Safety Act will follow the same path.</p><p>The left must resist these curbs on social media because they do not serve our interests; they serve the interests of those in power. The same state that has failed to protect communities from far-right violence cannot be trusted to regulate the platforms where we organise, communicate, and resist. The struggle against fascism requires more than confronting the far right in the streets; it demands the democratisation of spaces where we can build solidarity, share information, and mobilise effectively. These regulations, under the guise of curbing hate speech, are likely to suppress anti-racist, anti-fascist, and progressive voices, while far-right rhetoric continues to spread unchecked. The Undercover Policing Inquiry has already exposed how police spies infiltrated left-wing groups for decades, targeting anti-racist and anti-fascist organisations while allowing far-right networks to operate with impunity. The state’s selective enforcement is clear: it cracks down on those who challenge the status quo while ignoring the far right’s excesses.</p><p>The need to look beyond state apparatus for protection from far-right terror goes far beyond social media. The coordinated surge of violence over the past week starkly reveals the state’s disinterest in genuinely combating fascism. While the intensity of this recent violence is alarming, it is not an isolated event but part of a broader, long-standing pattern of far-right mobilisation that has been building for years. In 2023 alone, far-right groups held at least 123 anti-migrant demonstrations and made 158 visits to migrant accommodations, often with little to no intervention from law enforcement. In 2022, a far-right extremist firebombed a migrant detention centre in Dover, injuring two people before taking his own life. Despite the severity of this attack, it did not lead to a Prevent-style counter-terrorism drive focused on far-right extremism. In fact, the 2023 Prevent review recommended scaling back its focus on far-right threats, prioritising Islamist extremism instead — a decision that further illustrates the state’s complicity in enabling far-right narratives.</p><p>This recent escalation further highlights the failure of the state’s policing and legal frameworks to protect marginalised communities from fascist violence. Although police were visible outside some mosques during the recent attacks, they were conspicuously absent from many locations that endured the worst of the violence. For example, hotels housing asylum seekers, such as the Mercure Hotel in Bristol, were left unprotected until anti-fascist activists stepped in to defend them. Yet, instead of receiving support, these activists were met with police kettles and threats of arrest.</p><p>Starmer, the former Director of Public Prosecutions, has responded to the violence by promising a law-and-order crackdown, reminiscent of his draconian approach to the 2011 London Riots. However, this strategy is fundamentally flawed and reveals the state’s deeper priorities. While the government may prosecute and jail a few individuals who were incited to commit street violence, it continues to protect the broader forces of fascism — politicians, media figures, and others who propagate these dangerous ideologies. The state’s focus on maintaining “public order” rather than addressing the root causes of this violence allows it to avoid confronting the systemic racism that fuels far-right movements. This superficial crackdown on “criminality” fails to distinguish between the actions of fascists and those of anti-fascists, further exposing the state’s bias.</p><p>Moreover, it’s not as if the state hasn’t had the opportunity to implement the kind of crackdown it is now promising. Despite having a wide array of legal tools at their disposal — such as public order offences and violent disorder charges — the police and Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) rarely apply these laws or sentencing guidelines to the far-right. Instead, these measures are disproportionately wielded against left-wing activists, Muslims, and those who challenge state violence. A glaring example of this double standard is the case of Ryan Roberts, who received a 14-year prison sentence in December 2021 for setting fire to a police van during the Kill the Bill protests in Bristol. In contrast, a far-right rioter who attempted a similar act during the recent violence in Southport was given just a 30-month sentence.</p><p>This pattern of selective enforcement is not an anomaly; it is ingrained in the very fabric of our institutions. Seven years after the Grenfell Tower disaster, where most of the victims were poorer and people of colour, justice remains elusive, despite overwhelming evidence of negligence and racism by those responsible. The message is clear and has been repeatedly reinforced over the decades: we are not worthy of justice, our lives are disposable — just as it was with Stephen Lawrence, Joy Gardner, Zahid Mubarek, Shukri Abdi, Sheku Bayoh, and Jimmy Mubenga. Meanwhile, we are policed purely on the basis of our identities, whether through stop and search, the Prevent strategy, or the brutal conditions of immigration detention. We are expected to endure state surveillance, widespread harassment, and even death simply because of who we are.</p><p>I understand that, for many, the fear and uncertainty of the past weeks have led to a sense that there is no choice but to call on the police and judiciary for protection. In the absence of viable alternatives and in certain circumstances, this may indeed seem like the only option, and I would not condemn anyone for doing so. However, relying on the state for protection is not a sustainable long-term solution. Instead, we must urgently build alternative systems of protection and support within our communities.</p><p>The long-term solution lies in the strength of community solidarity and self-organisation, which we have witnessed in powerful ways both in recent weeks and over the past few years. In the past week alone, thousands of anti-racism protesters have mobilised across the country, forming human shields to protect mosques, asylum centres, and immigration advice services from potential attacks. In Liverpool, hundreds of people gathered outside a church that hosts an immigration advice centre, successfully preventing far-right protesters from causing harm. Similar scenes unfolded in Hackney, Walthamstow, and Finchley, where local residents and anti-fascist activists stood united, deterring the fascists to such an extent that they barely showed up. These victories echo earlier successes in Bristol and Nottingham in 2023, where coordinated anti-fascist mobilisations effectively thwarted far-right gatherings before they could gain momentum.</p><p>These victories show that when we stand together, we can push back against fascism. But they need to be more than just momentary blips — they must be the beginning of a larger, sustained effort. History shows us that significant mobilisations are the only thing that has effectively deterred British street racists. From the Battle of Cable Street to Southall Resists, it’s the mass presence of anti-fascists in the streets that has consistently put the far right on the back foot. These movements did not rely on the state to defend against fascist threats; they took matters into their own hands, organising mass protests, cultural events, and direct actions to disrupt and dismantle far-right groups. Their success lay in building broad-based solidarity, as seen during the 1984–1985 Miners’ Strike for example, where strong alliances between Asian, Afro-Caribbean communities, and miners thwarted far-right groups like the National Front from exploiting the strikes by spreading racist ideology and recruiting disaffected workers</p><p>To do this, though, requires a recognition that true safety cannot be achieved through the very systems that perpetuate violence and inequality. Instead, we must embrace autonomous community care, which calls for communities to take collective responsibility for their own safety and support, independently of the state. This approach involves building networks of solidarity and mutual aid that offer immediate, meaningful responses to violence and discrimination without relying on the police or other state institutions. By fostering these networks, we can create spaces of resistance that empower marginalised groups and challenge the forces of division and hate. The fight against far-right violence and racism requires us to reject the state’s narrative and invest in our communities, reclaiming justice as something we create together, rather than something granted by a system that has consistently failed us.</p><p>In the face of relentless far-right aggression, it’s easy to feel despair, especially when the state, the media, and even mainstream political parties seem complicit in fuelling division and hate. I know because I’ve felt it and am feeling it. But through writing this, I’ve tried to remind and even convince myself that true power lies in the hands of ordinary people who refuse to be silenced or divided. The solidarity and self-organisation emerging now aren’t just acts of resistance; they are the blueprint for a sustained struggle against fascism. Our strength lies in the streets, in the solidarity forged between people who refuse to back down, in the faces of those who stand shoulder to shoulder, in the chants that drown out the hate, in the simple, profound act of showing up for one another.</p><p>But I have to be honest: I’m tired. I know the work that’s needed, the relentless effort it demands, but the truth is, I’m not sure if I’m ready to dive back into it fully. Right now, I’m focused on building my own safety net, because I can’t trust the state, and, if I’m being real, I’m not even sure I can always trust the community to catch me when I fall. There’s a tension here — between the need to fight and the need to live a life that isn’t solely defined by resistance.</p><p>Activism comes in waves. There are small waves, where the best you can do is write, attend a protest, speak up at the dinner table, and then retreat to focus on the parts of life that bring you joy. And there are big waves, where you find yourself swept up in something larger, deeply engaged in organising, pushing back on every front. I know those waves will come again. But for now, I’m navigating the smaller ones, trying to balance the fight with the need to preserve my own well-being. Because as much as resistance can be joyful, its toll shouldn’t be underestimated.</p><p>So this is where I am — standing in that tension, trying to figure out how to move forward. And this is where I’ll begin, acknowledging that the work is necessary, but also giving myself the grace to step back when I need to. The road ahead is long and uncertain, but we move forward together, in whatever way we can, with the knowledge that our fight is just, and that in our solidarity, there is hope.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f74f469fb13b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My experience with Forward Momentum & related thoughts]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Vdam/my-experience-with-forward-momentum-related-thoughts-62d932c04a27?source=rss-2333e7865ce9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/62d932c04a27</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[momentum]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vdm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 May 2020 12:50:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-19T13:45:04.167Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4b8K853AUzaJ8SRT21Svzw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Now that my brief run in the Forward Momentum primaries is over, I thought it useful to share my honest thoughts on my experience in case it proves useful to anyone else. First, a brief note on my own candidacy. I don’t want to dwell on this in particular, because honestly, there wasn’t an awful lot to it. I knew instinctively that I wasn’t the right person: I’m not immersed in Momentum and hadn’t put in enough hours previously to be a credible candidate. Having seen the other candidates on the list, would I have voted for me if I wasn’t running? Possibly not. I also didn’t have the networks to draw upon for votes like many of the other candidates, and where I do, most are based on personal relationships so I didn’t feel comfortable bombarding friends for votes. And frankly, this campaign couldn’t have come at a worst time for me work wise, so putting in the hours to build my profile wasn’t going to happen in the week that I had to do it. I really hope after saying that, nobody feels like they wasted their vote in supporting me. Having been persuaded to stand, albeit belatedly, I was committed to doing as good a job as I could have done, and that would have been the case if I had progressed further.</p><p>With that out the way, I want to say a few things about Forward Momentum. I don’t recall the exact date, but I first heard about the campaign in April (possibly late March). I had a really great chat with one of the organisers and was genuinely excited at the vision they had to renew Momentum. And its clear many others felt the same, with over 4000 people signed up, and a series of important policy discussions taking place where anyone could input ideas. I was particularly encouraged by the call I had with other BAME activists, where over 50 people attended, many of whom I think were participating in something like this for the first time. Ultimately, this is what Forward Momentum should be proudest of — its genuine desire for openness, which extended all the way to the primary process. On the latter, again the appetite for people to participate was clear, with over 60 candidates standing, I’m assuming from a much longer list of people who applied. The hustings that were held attracted hundreds of viewers, and last I heard over 1600 people eventually voted<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>. The primary process was also a proving ground for many, including myself, who had never been tested on a bigger stage, so without a doubt served to improve the quality of the candidates eventually selected. And it also answered one of the primary criticisms of Momentum, that it failed to develop proper democratic channels for participation. If you are committed to correcting that, there is an obvious logic to demonstrating that commitment through your own processes. I’ve seen unnecessarily snarky comments from people who are only capable of seeing things in a hyper-factional way, that all of this was “tedious”. Without a doubt, it wasn’t perfect, which I’ll come on to, but weren’t we all criticising labour right-wingers not that long ago for objecting to more democracy in the selection of parliamentary candidates? In fact, I’m fairly sure those right wingers response was basically to treat the calls for primaries, as tedious. To right off the vibrant democratic process Forward Momentum facilitated, that in particular involved many marginalised communities as tedious, is very depressing and insulting to everyone who took the time to participate in good faith.</p><p>However, I do think Forward Momentum made a fair few missteps along the way. Me highlighting this shouldn’t be treated as a stick to beat the organisation with, rather as part of an evaluative exercise that all organisations and campaigns should be open to doing. What’s utterly disappointing, bar a few lone voices, is the histrionics I’m seeing from those involved in both Momentum Renewal and Forward Momentum in thinking each has hit upon an approach that is beyond reproach. Please stop — whilst we watch a tory government commit state sanctioned murder, and legislation like the pernicious immigration bill is being passed, making a basic commitment to being open to feedback on how we can be more successful, is surely vitally important. You don’t need to accept all of that feedback, including mine, but treating it in the comradely fashion that it is often meant in, is not too much to ask.</p><p>As to where I think Forward Momentum made mistakes, the first is the big one, the AWL. Obviously, I was aware of them prior to this campaign, but I can’t claim to have been an expert. When the campaign was launched, there was a lot of criticism that it was an AWL front, or that it had AWL people involved. In response to that, as well as more general enquiries for more transparency, the campaign did the right thing and published all of the names involved. Given some of these criticisms came from those involved with Momentum Renewal, it would seem entirely reasonable that they do similar. However, coming back to Forward Momentum, after this move, and being reassured that there were no AWL people involved, I found it easy to say as such on facebook. However, this wasn’t the case for the primary process. The organisation decided not to proscribe the AWL from standing. I don’t have any specific knowledge as to why that was the case, except that it was based on a desire to be pluralistic, which is all well and good if you hadn’t earlier published the names of those on the board to partly rebutt accusations of AWL involvement. You can’t simultaneously imply you have barred AWL involvement from your board, whilst allowing their candidates to stand in your primary. What you’re saying, is that we’re totally fine with AWL candidates getting on the NCG of Momentum, and we’ll provide resources for them to be successful, but they wouldn’t be allowed onto our board. It doesn’t tally.</p><p>However, I also appreciate much of these accusations of AWL involvement are based on rumour, and much in the way that the labour party has had failures in vetting their candidates, I don’t expect the unpaid volunteers of FWD Momentum to have found the AWL candidates on their list. Besides, people can easily lie, when you can ask them outright. What the organisation should have done is put out a statement saying it barred their involvement, and do all it can to remove anyone involved. Now I appreciate this seems quite punitive and personally I’ve had mixed feelings about this kind of approach. I know good people involved in the SWP, and Stand Up to Racism, the latter of which also includes Dianne Abbott and Jeremy Corbyn, so I’ve always been uncomfortable with guilt by association. However, having learnt more about the AWL I think the case was clear for proscribing them. Besides the board obviously agreed their involvement was undesirable based on their earlier actions, so they should have been consistent.</p><p>And this brings me onto the next misstep — supporting the candidates. In making no statement on these issues, Fwd MM abandoned the candidates to deal with it. I had formed an informal alliance with a few like-minded candidates, and though we were keen to campaign on the principles Forward Momentum, we felt no choice but to put out a strong statement objecting to the AWL’s involvement in the primary. We mentioned no names, as we didn’t want to get pulled into any personal arguments, but this didn’t stop one high profile candidate from dragging us publicly in a quite unpleasant way on their social media for our AWL statement. This actually broke one of the rules for standing as a candidate, but again here there was no intervention from Forward Momentum. Another young candidate also found themselves deceived into standing on a slate for Momentum Internationalists, a group set up by Michael Chessum, and then sadly felt no choice but to stand down once he became aware of their associations. Forward Momentum had an admirable commitment to plurality, but this didn’t have to come without qualifications. A trusted comrade made the point to me that they likely would have been more vocal if Labour First or Progress had become involved in their process. And the consequences of their silence continued into the hustings.</p><p>Before I speak to what happened in the hustings in relation to Momentum Internationalists, I just want to comment on them more generally. I’ve seen comments after that these were an unqualified success. They weren’t but that doesn’t mean they shouldn’t happen. All formats have their merits and demerits. During a global pandemic, the ability to use technology to facilitate these exercises in democracies is invaluable, and frankly more CLPs need to start embracing them or advocating for permission to do so. As noted, the attendance was very high, and in some respects (not all), allowed some people to be included that might have struggled to get to a physical husting even in normal circumstances. However, as we know technology has its downsides, and in the London breakout room, a tech failure ended up meaning some candidates got to do their candidate statements twice, and candidates only spoke for a total of 2.5 minutes including 1 minute to answer two questions (obviously except the for the candidates that did their opening statement twice). None of this means they shouldn’t happen, or that Momentum has a valid reason to not do hustings, but Forward Momentum should commit to recording their experience of what worked and didn’t work, with suggestions on remedies, and share that widely.</p><p>There was one question in the hustings that was asked, which for those of you who saw it, I chose to answer differently from most of the others. The question was “if you were to lose, would you support the slate regardless?” The overzealous host barred any answer to that question other than yes or no. I tried to explain that I was not handing over my vote in any circumstance to Forward Momentum, which was taken to meaning no by the host before he quickly moved on. The inference was correct, but my answer should have been allowed to stand on its own terms, particularly as I found out during the hustings themselves, from private messages that the question was supposed to have had a different intention. For the candidates with very close links to the campaign they, of course, knew this, but I could only answer the question in front of me. Ultimately, I don’t really care, as I’m glad I maintained my own personal integrity, but it is interesting to know why that question was asked. I later found out that in the previous day or two, Momentum Internationalists had implied they would run their slate regardless if their candidates had lost in the Forward Momentum primaries. Apart from objecting to Momentum Internationalists for other reasons, I personally am not bothered if people want to do this. I have no intention of running against Forward Momentum, and I made that clear on twitter afterwards. The idea though that Forward Momentum owns your political ambitions after their primary seems a bit much to me. This isn’t the NEC slate, there is no discussion of splitting the vote to be had in this context. Nonetheless, the question itself demonstrated that Forward Momentum was worried about some of the candidates on its own list. Instead of vocalising those concerns transparently, the candidates were asked to participate in a badly executed farce, where logically many (not me), inadvertently committed to supporting a slate that could include candidates that Forward Momentum themselves deemed problematic.</p><p>I also just want to briefly comment on Momentum Renewal as compared to Forward Momentum. I’ve made it clear that I think any process that tries to inject more democracy is a good thing, but I’ve also made it clear that these processes have pitfalls and you need to safeguard against them. Equally, Momentum Renewal’s process by design avoids some of those pitfalls but runs the risk of relying on patronage and missing out on candidates beyond the reach of their networks. Whether the downsides of both processes are actually deliberate to allow certain candidates through, I literally have no idea, nonetheless, my instinctive preference is without a doubt for democracy. However, what I think both campaigns have failed to acknowledge is that neither process is a guarantee to achieving the changes Momentum needs. That is down to the candidates themselves and their commitment to making the changes that Momentum needs. As I said in my answer during the hustings I am not supporting Forward Momentum’s slate regardless, and I will be looking at the candidates on Momentum Renewal’s slate carefully, as well as every other candidate putting themselves forward, slate or no slate. My only desire throughout all of this is that we have great NCG candidates, and that continues to be the case.</p><p>Finally, I just want to speak specifically to my BAME comrades. We need to self-organise. The left is made up of so many factions that it’s becoming ridiculous. The latest seems to be the tribune left vs Another Europe is Possible. The former seems to thrive off intimidation and bullying, and telling BAME people that Brexit was a howl of the wholesome salt of the earth working class, and there was nothing racist to see (despite all the evidence to the contrary). On the latter group, AEIP, I actually snuck into their EU elections party last year, and what I found was a room of almost exclusively white people, pushing the personal career ambitions of a few people off the back of a highly damaging campaign in support of a highly problematic neoliberal institution. The sad thing is, politically I actually have a lot in common with people from all the various groups, but the way many choose to operate is incredibly off-putting. BAME people are obviously not a monolith, but my experience in BAME spaces is that there is a much higher degree comradeship and understanding of divergent views than I’ve experienced elsewhere. I’m particularly interested to see how the new network, Socialists of Colour progresses, and keen to be involved soon.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Do not quote any of the numbers from this article — please first check with the Forward Momentum campaign</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=62d932c04a27" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The elephant in my two bedrooms]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Vdam/the-elephant-in-my-two-bedrooms-1f986877c908?source=rss-2333e7865ce9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1f986877c908</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[homeownership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[housing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vdm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Nov 2018 00:25:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-24T00:47:55.790Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/787/1*-DKhX26F61XY1QZUAiaMTQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>I’ve got a confession to make. I’ve bought a house. By which I mean, the bank owns my house and I’m going to try and spend the next 30 years gradually wrestling it off them, paying thousands of pounds of interest on my colossal debt for the privilege. But does this also mean that I’m now part of the 1%? A liberal home owning elite? Have I now irrevocably undermined my ability to critique the system by participating in one of its worst aspects? Worse, will my politics move further to the right, for fear of losing my home and the money I’ve invested in it?</p><p>Well, apart from not quite qualifying for the 1%, the rest are questions I’ve struggled with the last few months. What have been interesting are the reactions I’ve had when telling friends and family. I’ve not had any outright hostility, just some gentle ribbing from a few left wing mates. On the other hand though, I’ve had plenty of people congratulating me. Family telling me what a good decision I’ve made to get on the property ladder (implying I will climb up it), and querying why I didn’t do it sooner. I’ve been commended for my “hard work”, and told that I’ve now ticked an essential box on the road to adulthood. Most have simply congratulated me for the fact that I now “own” a home.</p><p>All of these reactions come from a good place, and anything I say from now shouldn’t be an interpreted as a rejection of the good will I’ve received from people I care about. But I’ve been thinking about how these reactions reveal how many of us have in some way internalised (mostly through necessity) a lot of the free market thinking that has come to define our broken housing market. The notion that hard work should/does have anything to do with home ownership. The ludicrous celebration of being in hundreds of thousands pound of debt. The virtue placed on ownership as opposed to other kinds of home occupancy. And most depressingly, the idea that any of this is aspirational or a rite of passage into adulthood.</p><p>The context for these reactions, is one where most people have either abandoned any hope that housing could be considered a human right, or worse, reject the very concept outright. And that ideological context has been underpinned by an environment that treats anyone who is unable to “own” a home as an aberration worthy of punishment. Benefit sanctions for the skivers who live in social housing; squalor for the ungrateful minimum wage earners living in private accommodation; and homelessness for the feckless losers who failed to navigate their economic precarity. Within that context, in many respects I’ve made the best decision I could, and was in a position to be able to act on that decision. The latter though is a largely a product of luck, rather than hard work. That’s not to say that on a personal level I haven’t been proactive in wanting to realise the objective of home ownership, but pretending that I somehow deserved it because of that is a betrayal of the truth. Those now frequent articles in the press, usually headlined, “how I bought my own home at 21”, invariably attempt to brush over some glaring privilege, such as earnings, or family help or inheritance. Gloating about how you benefitted from inequality to get a leg up over others in a broken housing system is cruel as much as it is funny.</p><p>But now I am a homeowner, I’m discovering the associated burdens and perverse incentives there to ensure you not only capitulate to, but champion the politics of private property. The debt burden acts as a disciplining mechanism to ensure you submit to the will of capital that provides your salary. The neglect of social security, incentivises home owners to will the market (and inequality) ever upwards as the only viable means of establishing personal savings or a pension. Your economic wellbeing becomes tied into the gentrification of an area; the police presence; the quality/whiteness of your neighbours. It was these shifts that can happen in the mindset of a homeowner that Thatcher’s tories knew were valuable in delivering more votes, and hence their zeal to implement the ironically titled “right to buy” policy.</p><p>Simultaneously, despite the new precariaty you find yourself in by virtue of being tied into a system prone to regular crashes (e.g. the 2008 sub-prime collapse), you’re still encouraged to feel superior to those who have less of a stake due to their near permanent exclusion. Whilst it was David Cameron’s tories who most recently articulated this when speaking of strivers and skivers, it was also a hallmark of the New Labour years. At the 1996 Labour Party conference, Tony Blair spoke of the moment when he said he realised Labour would lose the 1992 election:</p><p><em>“I can vividly recall the exact moment that I knew the last election was lost. I was canvassing in the Midlands on an ordinary suburban estate. I met a man polishing his Ford Sierra, self-employed electrician, Dad always voted Labour. He used to vote Labour, he said, but he bought his own home, he had set up his own business, he was doing quite nicely, so he said I’ve become a Tory. He was not rich but he was doing better than he did, and as far as he was concerned, being better off meant being Tory too. In that moment the basis of our failure — the reason why a whole generation has grown up under the Tories — became plain to me. You see, people judge us on their instincts about what they believe our instincts to be. And that man polishing his car was clear: his instincts were to get on in life, and he thought our instincts were to stop him.”</em></p><p>His subsequent premiership was defined by this desire to reward those to be seen to be getting on — people like tax avoiding Phillip Green, and racist tweet sharing Alan Sugar — and punish those left behind with ASBOs and <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1497487/Blair-to-introduce-tough-measures-to-punish-parents-of-the-Asbo-generation.html">campaigns against bad parenting</a>.</p><p>So where does all of this get me? Well thankfully it hasn’t changed my politics. The burdens and incentives of owning dissolve away in the desire for a just housing system for all– one that conceptualises housing as a human right, as opposed homeownership as a right. A system that revives the tradition behind the design of some of the first social housing estates — that they should be safe, aesthetically pleasing and organised to encourage community interaction. What has changed though is my attitude to homeowners and the appeal we should be making to them from the left.</p><p>As this is just a blog post, I’m going to allow myself a slightly long winded, convoluted run up to the point I’m trying to make (apologies in advance): I’ve had a few conversations recently about how feminism can be an emancipatory force for men, freeing us up from various stereotypes we’re expected to conform to. On the other hand, there is a risk that this framing downplays the inequality between genders, and the inevitable loss of privilege many men will have to experience to address this disparity. It’s clear to me that both things are true — that those who have actively bought into patriarchy and most profited from it will have to have their social capital confiscated. But there are also those men who can be brought on board as allies, and even sold on the benefits more generally. My extremely crude, and slightly uninformed take on gender relations, has a parallel (in my mind) with homeowners.</p><p>Without a doubt, being a homeowner puts you in an extremely privileged position. For some, homeownership has been a vehicle to accrue vast amounts of wealth that will need to be confiscated through tax or other means. But just like those men who can be sold on the benefits of feminism, there is a yet unexplored opportunity of selling the end of private ownership to homeowners. For me it seems glaringly obvious that I would much prefer to be in a social home for life, than locked into ownership. But because of everything described above, it’s much less obvious to many other owners. The left has largely focused its attentions on those who have most egregiously benefitted from homeownership, but missed the opportunity to appeal to those who’ve participated as a way to leave the instability of renting. And the opportunities are numerous. At the time of me writing this, the hashtag #mortgageprisoners is trending on twitter — stories of people locked into horrendously high interest rate mortgages by unscrupulous banks. These realities need to be used to expose the dream of ownership and detoxify the idea of social homes for everyone. In this way, homeowners can become an unlikely ally in the drive to end private ownership.</p><p>Ultimately, I think on this issue, and many others, there is a task on the left to not only provide justice to the victims of rampant capitalism, but also convince those who think they have benefitted from this system that there is a better way.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1f986877c908" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Making the political personal — a tribute to my mother]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Vdam/making-the-political-personal-a-tribute-to-my-mother-397d714aaa5b?source=rss-2333e7865ce9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/397d714aaa5b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[labour-party]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vdm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Aug 2018 01:10:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-24T01:10:19.954Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’m writing this to remind myself what my politics are, and where they came from.</p><p>I’d always tried to make an effort to make sure my political beliefs weren’t a regurgitation of what my favourite team at Westminster was saying at any given moment — but that has proved difficult recently. Corbyn’s election as leader of the labour party gave me the opportunity to express my politics in ways that previously didn’t seem possible. After years of internal and external conflict, it felt like finally, I could fully exhale.</p><p>However, with that has come a desire to protect this moment, almost a siege mentality, and on too many occasions, I’ve seen that come at the expense of personally embodying those values which we’re striving to see politically — namely, kindness, generosity, fairness and compassion. To put it simply, “being a good person”. It’s not just the fog of political war that has obscured the importance of those personal values, but increasingly, the lure of possible celebrity on the left, made much easier with social media, that has sometimes caused priorities to shift in the wrong direction.</p><p>I need to write this to remind me that whilst it is important that the personal is political, the reverse must also be true. For me, I can’t let it be enough to politically campaign to halt the perpetual misery neoliberalism has caused to people’s lives, but also my politics have to mean being good to the people I know and don’t know, and engaging in service to those in need. Those personal values come primarily from my mother, and whilst she will very unlikely ever read this, I’m writing also as a tribute to her.</p><p>This though is not a rebuke to anyone in particular, rather a record of who I want to be. Yes, sometimes I’ve been disappointed to see people on the left quite obviously appraise the competing merits of speaking to different people based on the number of twitter followers they have. I’ve seen supposedly left wing people, treat the homeless or waiting staff with disdain, betraying their own values. And I’ve seen plenty of racism and sexism. But I can only control my own behaviour, and in this regard, sometimes I’ve disappointed myself. I remember after a campaigning event last year, the opportunity arose to become acquainted on a personal level with someone I’d admired on twitter. Somebody I knew well was also there, and instead of spending time with them, I was persuaded by a friend to spend nearly £70 on a taxi to take my celeb twitter mates to a party only to be ditched by them when we got there. In some ways it was karma for neglecting a genuine friendship to hang out with the left’s hipsters, but also illustrative of the fact that even the most vocal and admired voices of the new left, are also failing the “good person” test.</p><p>I also want to mention the idea of “self-care”. On a fundamental level I understand its importance, the notion that to be of use to anyone else, you need to look after yourself. I also am fully aware of the stress that precarious lifestyles can have on your mental health, so sometimes there can be a need to protect yourself. But sometimes I’ve seen it be invoked to justify poor behaviour. If every act of kindness, whether it is for your friends, or strangers in need, is considered a triggering event for some personal trauma, then something has gone wrong. Is it self-care or actually just self-ish? Sometimes being good to people can involve some personal sacrifice, and that’s okay. The people I find who most understand that are often the least political. People who dedicate their lives, diligently to the service of others, because it’s what you’re supposed to do. In my culture, and most South Asian ones, this is known as seva — the art of selfless service.</p><p>My mum is my example in this regard. Several decades of service to the community, whether it was a leader to the beavers in her local scout group 30 years ago, to working with senior citizens today. She has never sought recognition or leadership in any of the work she does. Often I’ve seen her put her own health needs to one side, sometimes to my frustration, to meet what she considers her duty to provide seva. In some respects it was that example that helped choose my career path. I’ve worked in the aid sector for near ten years, but I deliberately chose to avoid working in policy and communications teams, which would have gained me more professional recognition, as I wanted to be closer to the delivery of actual programmes. Even this though is not remotely comparable, as I’ve been decently remunerated for that work, and often sought leadership positions to feed my ego. I’ve made sporadic attempts to be more like my mum, just turn up to volunteer for service and found that ultimately it is a more rewarding experience. I want to be clear though this isn’t a defence of unpaid labour; particular the work that women do that is often deliberately not recognised in our society. Rather it’s to say that even though we need to work to untangle the notions of what work is considered important and worthy of compensation, I don’t think that needs erase any possibility that selfless acts can and should exist.</p><p>So this is going to be a record for me to come back to regularly to remind me to be a good person. Similar to whenever I see a picture that I took at the occupy protests seven years ago crop up on that creepy facebook memories feature. To my shame, despite my politics being firmly on the left back then, I was (selectively) quoted by the <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/18/us/the-occupy-movements-common-thread-is-anger.html">NYT</a> as describing the protest as a “romantic fantasy”. The quote didn’t represent the entirety of the 45 minute conversation I was having with an activist at the site, but seeing it in print did galvanise me to keep going to the protests, and near the end of it, I was quoted again, this time by the <a href="https://socialistworker.co.uk/art/26001/Occupy%20movement%20continues%20to%20grow%20across%20Britain">Socialist Worker</a>:</p><p><em>Naveed Somani’s parents worked at the Rover plant in Longbridge. “When I was younger I felt more passionate about these things,” he said. “Then you start to get stuck into paying rent and bills and so on. I came here cynical. I wanted to inspire myself — and it worked!”</em></p><p>Every year now, I’m reminded that I need to have faith in my politics and be more active in pushing my beliefs forward. But like I cited my parent’s experience in restoring that commitment, I also want their experience to be what reminds me to make sure that my politics also manifest themselves on a personal level, in being a better person.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=397d714aaa5b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A tribute to the reluctant insiders (i.e. me)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Vdam/a-tribute-to-the-reluctant-insiders-i-e-me-62b793cd0141?source=rss-2333e7865ce9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/62b793cd0141</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vdm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Jul 2018 20:24:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-27T20:59:56.769Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A warning: This is will be a particularly whiny, privileged, self-indulgent post, so please don’t read any further if you’re not interested in my utterly unimportant struggle to reconcile my politics with my professional life.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JuWLyEVsKqDBzqqUidJQxA.png" /></figure><p>Like many people, when I was deciding my career path, I was keen that it would be doing something that would make a positive contribution to the lives of vulnerable people. Initially I thought that would be as lawyer, but half way through my law degree, I realised that I’d probably have to do some absolutely awful soul-destroying work before I had a chance of being some hot shot human rights advocate (and that I was most likely not smart enough to make it). So after a mini political awakening doing my masters at SOAS, that altruistic urge was redirected to a career in international aid, which I was lucky enough to make a reality.</p><p>At the risk of sounding like a linkedin braggart, I will say I’ve been very lucky in my near ten years working in the sector: Working with young people to learn from the reconciliation process in Rwanda; travelling to Kyrgyzstan to interview survivors of devastating political violence; visiting the remote countries of Tuvalu and Nauru to advise their governments on how to improve the social contract; and spending hours on the road in Mali to reach a remote village in need of resources to support their livelihoods. Those are just some of projects I’ve been able to work on, and in lots of ways I’m proud of the work I’ve been able to do. (Sounding even more vainglorious), this has also brought me some recognition, both in professional and personal circles, as well as being a source of pride for my family.</p><p>But here’s the rub: I’m also deeply uncomfortable with my chosen career and question whether I have in fact been making things worse for people I’m supposedly helping. That political education I received at SOAS included a forensic dismantling of the hypocrisies of a paternalistic, neoliberal, depoliticised aid industry. My dissertation focused on the toxic market fundamentalism of microfinance: a development approach which garnered its proponent a Nobel Prize, and dominated the aid sector for several decades, despite evidence that at best it did nothing and at worst led to dozens of farmers in India committing suicide due to over-indebtedness. Even with this knowledge in hand, it didn’t put me off pursuing a career in the aid sector, including several years in microfinance, as apart from not wanting to be the kind of person who just criticised from the outside, I naively thought I could change things from the inside.</p><p>Ten years on from that decision, sadly much of what SOAS told me would be the case, has turned out to be true. I found a development sector un-ironically obsessed with “the power of markets” to address the injustices caused by markets. Massive corporations like Barclays funding aid projects, to enhance their brand, whilst simultaneously receiving record fines for designing junk financial products, built off the back of poor people manipulated into accumulating debt they couldn’t afford. Even many of the projects I boasted about earlier, were based on the flawed logic of the free market as an emancipatory force.</p><p>The obvious question then is why do I persist? I sometimes wonder that, particularly since the leftward shift in the labour party means that my personal politics now have a lot more spaces in which to flourish. Academics I’ve long admired are now mainstream, and numerous other comrades I’ve met recently have carved out minor celebrity with their incisive critique of the various ills of capitalism. So arguably this is an opportune moment for me to ditch the career that has long given me a sense of unease.</p><p>But I won’t (at least for a while yet). Whilst my admiration for those outsiders agitating for change is immense, it’s an approach that in the short-term has it limits. Working in the aid sector can sometimes be painful for the reasons already described, but my personal experience tells me that for the moment it’s better than doing nothing. Throughout my career, I’ve met numerous of these “reluctant insiders”. People who share my politics, and sometimes participate in efforts for radical change outside of work, but also persist inside problematic institutions because, at least for now, they know that’s where the most power and resources to achieve change reside. Making the most of the stated altruistic aims of these institutions, despite knowing that a more transformative change is needed for a sustainable solution to injustice in the long-term.</p><p>So I wrote this as a tribute to the reluctant insiders, who accept the critiques of their work from the outsiders, are too self-critical to boast about their work themselves, but keep persisting for the sake of those who can’t wait for relatively far-off solutions</p><p>(and also to make myself feel better).</p><p><em>After-thought</em></p><p>I’d be lying if my only reason for persisting in this career was to be a martyr for those who need help now, and can’t wait for the revolution. Some of it is because job security was drummed into me from an early age — understandable when your parents are a refugee and economic migrant who had to build a life for you and your brother by doing ten hour night shifts at a car factory for two decades. So like millions of others I’ve made career decisions sometimes based on the need for secure tenure, and to build savings. I’m extremely privileged in even having the option of being able to partially reconcile my beliefs with my career, making this extended whine horribly self-indulgent (see disclaimer at start). But too few can even achieve secure tenure, despite doing jobs that crush them mentally and physically much worse than my job ever could. So despite my tribute to the reluctant insiders (which I maintain), I’m also giving major props to radical outsiders. Keep on comrades.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=62b793cd0141" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Your token brown friend]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Vdam/your-token-brown-friend-9f4a17109847?source=rss-2333e7865ce9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9f4a17109847</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[whiteness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dating]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-privilege]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vdm]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Jul 2018 20:16:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-07-27T20:16:33.241Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>[April 22nd 2018]</p><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_groups_in_London">The 2011 census showed that 59% of London is white, of which 45% are white British</a>. Seven years later, those percentages have very likely fallen, so why do I regularly find myself in crowds of white British people where I am still the token brown guy?</p><p>(At this point, I want to say I’ve prevaricated over writing this for over a year now, worried about offending friends whom I love and care for. But I’m exhausted at having to constantly navigate, white, middle class spaces. I really hope that this will be read with an openness to understand.)</p><p>Inevitably, in any group setting, the base dynamic is set by the dominant profile of the crowd. It’s not a conscious attempt to exclude, but there is a presumption of reference points, in-jokes, and shared experiences. When you constantly find yourself in spaces where your reference points occupy a much narrower overlap than the people around you, it sometimes becomes an effort to not say things outside that overlap that garner a perplexed look. Even where there is an attempt at inclusion, it is often so deliberate that you find yourself feeling a like the subject of an anthropological study, often having to represent the views of an entire community. Of course, much of the time there is enough commonality to not notice, or you don’t mind being the centre of attention, but there are occasions when the sense that you are disguising yourself to fit into a white space is too acute to ignore.</p><p>Inevitably, there are many exceptions, and I am lucky to have lots of white friends who feel entirely comfortable with their experience not being the default one. What’s notable about these exceptions though is either a) this has been borne of a proactive interest in other cultures; b) they are working class, still the entry point of most people of colour. In my experience it is the white, English, middle class that seem to have insulated themselves from the numerous opportunities London has offered them to create a diverse social circle.</p><p>It is most stark to me, when I’m at personal occasions– a birthday, a housewarming, a NYE party. Yes, many people have work friends, or friends from sports team, or from other shared endeavours, that are a different ethnicity, but how many are attending your most personal social occasions? My unscientific observation leads to the answer, very few. Of course, the obvious riposte to this is that it is not just white people’s responsibility to create this kaleidoscopic utopia, and I’m more than willing to concede this. Nonetheless, apart from my personal experience where my friends of colour have much more diverse circles than my white friends, the data is also worth a look, as it reveals a picture of a host that has often been unwelcoming.</p><p><a href="https://the-challenge.org/uploads/documents/TCN-British-Integration-Study.pdf">The 2016 British Integration Survey which looks at the rate, at which different ethnicities mix with one another, reinforces this</a>. The survey methodology weights a groups integration score by the opportunities they have, i.e. you won’t be penalised if there is only one person from a particular ethnic minority group living in your area. The results show that all ethnic groups, bar those who identify as mix raced, are not taking up the opportunities to interact with people of different ethnicities. But, both nationally and in London, white people have the worst overall integration score. In London, the score for white people is at a depressingly low 27%, 12% lower than for black people, with the next lowest integration score.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/490/1*6Yg7YV58nlSUQwxiDPeXbg.png" /></figure><p>All this segregation is having further knock on effects. <a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/one-in-10-relationships-now-cross-racial-boundaries-9582976.html">The Independent, in analysing the 2011 census data, showed that again white British people were the least likely to be in mixed-race relationships</a>. Various analysis from both gay and straight dating apps show that white people are most likely to express a strong preference for people of their own race, and <a href="https://www.thecut.com/2014/09/new-okcupid-data-on-race-is-pretty-depressing.html">adding “whiteness” to your profile is the best way to undo any negative biases against you</a>. If your social circle is exclusively white, than it’s obvious your only examples of loving, intimate relationships, of beauty, are of people who look like you.</p><p>For many people, school and university seems to be the last time they made friends with a person of colour, and many won’t have even kept in touch with these friends. Nonetheless, I’m encouraged to see a lot of people, in particular those who would describe themselves as left-wing, are increasingly taking the initiative to better understand whiteness; become better allies to fight against discrimination; and appreciate art produced by people of colour. These are all essential and laudable endeavours, but instead of quoting Renni Eddo-Lodge at me, maybe also spend time reflecting on your own social network. Why do you know so few people of colour? Why have you never even considered dating a PoC? These are difficult questions to confront, and I’ve had to do it myself several times. But the effort is worth it, and makes for a much happier existence.</p><p>As with all these things, the picture is complex. All ethnic minorities have a way to go in interacting with people from different groups, and <a href="https://www.buzzfeed.com/laurmjackson/multiracial-families-cant-save-the-world-from-racism?utm_term=.cbR2oRvMP#.tkB0DdWoV">it is too simplistic to say improved integration will mark the end of discrimination</a>. It’s a start though, and I would put much of that responsibility on white people. If a stranger came to your party, a good host would make an effort to get to know them and introduce other people to them. If not, then of course they are likely to leave your party and retreat back to the familiar. When applied to integration, not only does it show some white people as being poor hosts, but in many cases, not sending out an invitation in the first place. So my plea is to get to know your guests, make them feel welcome, send out more invitations, and go to their parties x</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9f4a17109847" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>