<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Zulfikar Ramzan on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Zulfikar Ramzan on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@Zulfikar_Ramzan?source=rss-3c3b30a5b97c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 07:26:53 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@Zulfikar_Ramzan/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[RSA Sets a Future Course As It Reflects on a Storied Past]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Zulfikar_Ramzan/rsa-sets-a-future-course-as-it-reflects-on-a-storied-past-f581469e3d46?source=rss-3c3b30a5b97c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f581469e3d46</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Zulfikar Ramzan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Sep 2020 18:02:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-08T20:35:37.177Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/946/1*3i7yUoxSCeqvn42SvayVYg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The <a href="https://www.rsa.com/en-us/company/news/rsa--emerges-as-independent-company">news</a> that <a href="https://www.rsa.com/">RSA</a> has become an independent company once again through its acquisition by <a href="https://stgpartners.com/">Symphony Technology Group</a> is more than just another tale of M&amp;A. This event marks the next chapter in the storied history of a technology trailblazer.</p><p>The first chapter in this story began in the late 1970s. At the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), three academics (Ron Rivest, Adi Shamir, and Len Adelman) embarked on a quest to develop the first instantiation of public-key cryptography, which could help enable secure communications and digital signatures. Their efforts were inspired by the earlier work of Whit Diffie, Marty Hellman and Ralph Merkle. The process typically went as follows: Ron or Adi would come up with proposals and Len would identify flaws. After a few dozen failed attempts, the trio stumbled upon a key ingredient to fuel their creative thinking: Manischewitz Wine!</p><p>Following a Passover dinner at the home of a graduate student, Ron struggled to fall asleep. So, he did what I’m sure we all do under similar circumstances: read a math textbook! <em>For inquiring minds, it was Dickson’s book on Group Theory.</em> While this activity seems like a surefire antidote for insomnia, it had the opposite effect. Ron’s mind kept returning to public-key cryptography. At one point, a key concept in the book triggered a creative chain reaction. Ron spent the night formalizing his ideas and when he subsequently shared the results with Adi and Len, it was clear that they achieved their quest to make public-key cryptography possible.</p><p>Here one might say “the rest is history,” but nothing could be further from the truth. Against the backdrop of the Cold War, working on cryptography in the private sector or in academia was, as Marty Hellman described it, a fool’s errand. They were competing against the U.S. Federal Government, which had a tremendous head start and a much larger budget. Also, any novel contributions would likely become classified. Finally, major technical impediments stood in the way. For example, while the RSA algorithm runs in a split second on today’s smartphones, in the late 1970s it required complex custom built (VLSI) hardware, and the first such implementation from Rivest, Shamir, and Adelman failed to work.</p><p>Undeterred, Rivest, Shamir and Adelman embarked on an entrepreneurial venture to commercialize their algorithm. Through trials and tribulations as well as mergers and acquisitions, the company has transformed over the past 40 years into a veritable powerhouse that belies its modest beginnings.</p><p>Today, the name RSA evokes one of three images in people’s minds: esoteric mathematical algorithms that make electronic commerce possible; a preeminent conference gathering that industry veterans treat as an annual reunion (and that industry newcomers attend because of deep-seated and well-placed FOMO); or the pioneers of multi-factor authentication through hardware and software tokens.</p><p>Nonetheless, pigeonholing the contributions of RSA to just these three areas (as important as they are) would be epically wrong. Technologies conceived of and developed by RSA over the past 40 years are more widely deployed than those of any other<em> technology </em>vendor<em>. </em>It wouldn’t be an exaggeration to say that every one of us either directly or indirectly interacts with RSA technology multiple times each day. RSA is like the famous actor or actress who has starred in countless phenomenal films, but is somehow only remembered for a handful of roles.</p><p>The current portfolio of market-leading products from RSA within the domains of security, risk and fraud are designed to help organizations manage today’s risks, while having the flexibility to adapt for tomorrow’s challenges:</p><ul><li><a href="https://www.rsa.com/en-us/products/rsa-securid-suite"><strong>RSA SecurID Access</strong></a> protects over 50 million identities globally, allowing employees to securely work from anywhere, accessing both cloud and on-premises resources and giving organizations the ability to verify a user is who they say they are through a variety of mechanisms, including hardware tokens, software tokens, numerous biometrics and FIDO2 authenticators. In 2019, RSA SecurID Access was named the most important product in the past 30 years by <em>SC Magazine</em>. It is complemented by RSA Identity Governance and Lifecycle, which provides continuous access assurance and ensures users have appropriate entitlements. These technologies help customers on their passwordless and Zero Trust journeys.</li><li><a href="https://www.rsa.com/en-us/products/integrated-risk-management"><strong>RSA Archer Suite</strong></a> helps thousands of businesses manage an increasingly complex regulatory landscape and gives leaders visibility into the potential impact of all their risk challenges. RSA Archer has been positioned as a leader in the last 20 Gartner Magic Quadrant reports for GRC/IRM-related domains, including: Integrated Risk Management, IT Risk Management, IT Vendor Risk Management and Business Continuity Management since 2012. With new SaaS and on-premises offerings in areas such as regulatory content analysis and third-party vendor risk, RSA Archer empowers organizations to own risk now and in the future.</li><li><a href="https://www.rsa.com/en-us/products/threat-detection-response"><strong>RSA NetWitness Platform</strong></a> brings together evolved SIEM and threat defense solutions that deliver unsurpassed visibility, analytics and automated response capabilities. These, combined with the upcoming cloud hosted capabilities, make the platform one of the only true XDR solutions in the market, covering the network core, the cloud, the endpoint / edge, IoT / OT, and digital identities. RSA NetWitness Platform has been positioned as a leader in the Gartner Magic Quadrant for Security Information and Event Management (SIEM). Its unsurpassed flexibility continues to support the rapidly evolving needs of customers.</li><li><a href="https://www.rsa.com/en-us/products/fraud-prevention"><strong>RSA Fraud &amp; Risk Intelligence Suite</strong></a> is a portfolio of sophisticated omnichannel fraud identification and prevention technology designed to protect consumers from financial fraud threats across digital and physical channels, including phishing, account takeover, card-not-present fraud, rogue mobile apps, rogue social media pages and much more. The technology mitigates over $6 billion in fraudulent transactions annually and provides customers with the best return on investment in the industry.</li><li>RSA Labs focuses on research and advanced development in emerging technology areas such as IoT and edge security, decentralized identities and advanced analytics, among others. In the past year, over a dozen innovations from RSA labs have graduated, leading to product improvements and new product offerings.</li></ul><p>More broadly, a few years ago, RSA introduced the concept of “business-driven security,” echoing an important customer and partner sentiment that security is no longer relegated to a small minority in the IT department. Rather, it has become a CEO and board-level issue. Therefore, successful security leaders must use the language of risk to bridge the gap between security strategy and business needs.</p><p><strong>What’s next for RSA?</strong></p><p>While the impact of RSA far exceeds that of any other security vendor, I believe the future of RSA will eclipse its past. This <a href="https://www.rsa.com/en-us/blog/2020-09/rsa-charts-its-future-as-an-independent-company">latest independent chapter</a> unlocks our ability to innovate rapidly and operate swiftly to address clients’ needs. We will help secure the next generation of businesses that are driving progress and ingenuity.</p><p>The stakes have never been higher. Under the present circumstances, digital technologies have become an inextricable part of our lives. RSA will continue to be at the helm to ensure that these technologies are trustworthy. Even though the story of RSA has been marked by continuous change, one constant has remained: RSA is still eponymous with the three brilliant minds who saw possibility where others were skeptical and who showed persistence when many others would have quit. During the next 40 years and beyond, we are excited to build upon and far exceed this legacy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f581469e3d46" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Evolution of Privacy in Organizations Amidst COVID-19]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Zulfikar_Ramzan/the-evolution-of-privacy-in-organizations-amidst-covid-19-db1dfd31d8e?source=rss-3c3b30a5b97c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/db1dfd31d8e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ccpa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gdpr]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-breach]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cybersecurity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Zulfikar Ramzan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 May 2020 19:44:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-14T19:44:19.288Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Evolution of Privacy in Organizations amidst COVID-19</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/0*pYC4nE4oGpPGfUGW" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@lianhao?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Lianhao Qu</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/s/photos/privacy?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>On the evening of December 29, 1972, Eastern Airlines Flight 401 departed JFK heading to Miami. At the helm was Captain Robert Albin Loft, a 32-year veteran pilot who had accumulated nearly 30,000 flight hours. He was accompanied by First Officer John Stocksill, who had nearly 6,000 hours of flight experience under his belt. At 11:32pm, as the plane began to approach its destination, Stocksill noticed that the landing gear indicator, a green light, didn’t appear to be working.</p><p>The captain and first officer started troubleshooting. Soon, other crew members joined the effort. During this time, auto-pilot was accidentally disengaged, and the plane gradually lost altitude. The rate of descent was too slow to be observed by the crew, but meaningful enough to be noticed by the altitude warning system.</p><p>When the plane had descended 250 feet, the altitude warning system issued an audible chime. However, the entire crew was consummately distracted by the broken landing gear indicator light. <em>Not a single person heard the warning bells.</em> As the First Officer began another turn, he noticed that the plane’s actual altitude was much lower than anyone realized. In a state of disbelief and confusion, he and the pilot exchanged a few words. Less than 10 seconds after this final conversation, Eastern Airlines flight 410 crashed into the ground at 227 miles per hour — killing 101 of the 176 people on board.</p><p>In the investigation that followed, it was discovered that the landing gear light that the entire crew obsessed about had simply burned out. <em>It was a $12 light bulb.</em></p><p>The COVID-19 pandemic has put organizations in a Flight 401 situation. While everyone is hyper focused on the tactical issues of maintaining operations and enabling a remote workforce, they may ignore the risks associated with data privacy and security, which have only increased. Of course, addressing tactical issues is worth more than a $12 light bulb, but ignoring privacy and data security is an epic long-term mistake.</p><h3>The Shifting Privacy-Risk Landscape</h3><p>Pandemics induced by biological viruses are indifferent to the risks posed by data breaches. If anything, given the current circumstances, companies must now be concerned with different attack vectors such as those associated with remote employees, the use of new applications, creative phishing scams, and so on.</p><p>In addition, organizations have novel challenges when it comes to how they handle incidents stemming from malicious behavior (both from external threat actors and insiders) — especially if the security team handling these incidents is now working remotely. Incident response is important from a privacy perspective because there’s a distinction between intrusions and breaches. An intrusion means that a threat actor got through the front door. A breach means they walked out the back with your crown jewels. Given the complexity of most environments and the panoply of threats, intrusions are inevitable. But effective incident response can stymie intrusions before they lead to breaches.</p><p>These risks will only magnify as companies strive to transition staff back into physical offices. The digital devices that dutifully helped employees work remotely will have been minimally managed and monitored. These devices will make their return to the physical office in a sullied state. BYOD will be replaced with BYOM — Bring Your Own Malware. Intrusions will increase, and without adequate capabilities for threat detection and response, a rise in data breaches will follow suit.</p><p>It’s also important to bear in mind that breaches represent one situation in which data privacy is compromised, but they aren’t the only privacy-related consideration relevant to organizations. For example, if an organization founders on responding to data subject access requests from consumers, they may fail to meet compliance obligations. Addressing such requests is a challenge on its own, but when organizations must rely on an increasingly remote workforce to handle them, the difficulties only multiply.</p><h3>Enforcement of Regulatory Compliance Regimes in the COVID-19 Era</h3><p>Companies hoping for leniency during the pandemic when it comes to handling data privacy and security issues — particularly as it relates to regulatory compliance — should think twice.</p><p>For example, California’s Attorney General Xavier Becerra issued an alert in April to remind consumers that, despite the circumstances, they have privacy rights under CCPA.<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> This reminder acknowledges the importance of staying focused on these problems in a world where consumers have supplanted physical engagement with digital engagement, which leads to increased exposure of their sensitive data. Exacerbating the situation, there hasn’t yet been guidance on CCPA enforcement, which means that organizations must prepare for a variety of scenarios.</p><p>On the other hand, President Jair Bolsonaro of Brazil has issued an order to postpone the enforcement of the LGPD, the Brazilian General Data Protection Law.<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a> It’s unclear if the postponement will materialize. Even if it does, the reprieve is only temporary, and organizations will still need to comply eventually. The extra breathing room is no cause for celebration; organizations who aren’t in the throes of feverishly preparing for LGPD are already far behind.</p><p>These issues notwithstanding, efforts to establish new regulations continue. For example, Washington State is working towards developing the Washington Privacy Act and has come close to passing it during its last two legislative sessions. The state of New York has the SHIELD act, which goes into effect later this year.</p><p>It’s clear that privacy regulations are here to stay, and they represent a complex and dynamic terrain that organizations must navigate thoughtfully and deliberately.</p><h3>Navigating the Terrain</h3><p>Given the situation, companies are increasingly responding to privacy compliance requirements, such as GDPR, CCPA, LGPD, and other state and country privacy laws. The fines and reputational impact for non-compliance together with the need to respond to customer requests that demonstrate compliance and privacy best practices are driving boards and management to look even more closely at privacy.</p><p>There has consequently been increased effort to build privacy into product development in the early stages. Not only are there important compliance requirements, but customers (and potential customers) expect it as part of their due diligence process. The business value in this effort is clear.</p><p>Unfortunately, there’s no privacy and cybersecurity pixie dust that can be sprinkled on top of organizations to ease their woes. To have effective programs around privacy and data security, organizations must introduce these elements early on and create the right foundations. At the heart of these efforts, it’s crucial to understand data pipelines and information flows. Companies should create a data flow and governance architecture that facilitates the implementation of effective privacy, cybersecurity, and risk controls. Organizations will need to have effective measures to lower the chances of a material cybersecurity or data privacy incident, and they will need ways to prove to others that they have implemented the right measures. Data security and privacy programs are deliberate efforts, they cannot be divined out of thin air.</p><p>To get a better grip on these issues, any company handling sensitive data (i.e., pretty much <em>every</em> organization today) should build in-house privacy and data security expertise, or they should work with consulting firms that have strong privacy and data security practices — or ideally do both. The privacy landscape is constantly morphing, especially from a regulatory compliance perspective. It’s increasingly easy to be caught off guard and increasingly difficult to mount an effective response when that happens.</p><p>Having an in-depth understanding of the issues early on is crucial. Questions surrounding data ownership, sovereignty, and security are deceptively easy to ask and yet are notoriously difficult to answer — unless the right pipelines have been implemented to facilitate effective data management and governance. It’s also important to recognize the convergence between data privacy and data security. The people respectively responsible for covering these areas should be collaborating. Anyone familiar with the Westrum topology for modeling organizational culture<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a> will recognize the importance of striving for a generative culture that: (1) encourages cooperation among individuals; (2) fosters the creation of bridges; and (3) promotes the idea that failures should lead to inquiry.</p><p>Going beyond the organizational perspective and considering the societal perspective, it’s crucial to encourage a healthy discussion of privacy at a policy level. The COVID-19 pandemic is the single greatest accelerant of digital transformation in recent times. Digital interactions now permeate nearly every aspects of our lives, including how we buy groceries, collaborate with colleagues, take classes, celebrate birthdays, attend weddings, and even mourn the loss of loved ones.</p><p>Every time we go online, we leave a trail of digital breadcrumbs. When looked at individually, these digital traces seem inconsequential, but when considered in aggregate, they create a comprehensive digital dossier that stands to expose the most intimate parts of our lives. Against this backdrop, we have to double down on our efforts to pass legislation that incentivizes organizations to adequately care for and protect the data they collect about us. The stakes have never been higher.</p><h3>Acknowledgement</h3><p>I want to convey a monumental thanks to the fantastic team at Aleada (<a href="https://www.aleada.co/">https://www.aleada.co/</a>), a women and minority owned boutique privacy and data protection consulting firm in Silicon Valley, for sharing their invaluable insights on privacy and how to navigate the corresponding complex regulatory landscape.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> <a href="https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-becerra-reminds-consumers-their-data-privacy-rights-during">https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-becerra-reminds-consumers-their-data-privacy-rights-during</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> <a href="https://iapp.org/news/a/brazilian-president-orders-lgpd-delay-to-may-2021/">https://iapp.org/news/a/brazilian-president-orders-lgpd-delay-to-may-2021/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1765804/pdf/v013p0ii22.pdf">https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1765804/pdf/v013p0ii22.pdf</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=db1dfd31d8e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Future: Security, Privacy and Risk in a Post-COVID World]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Zulfikar_Ramzan/the-future-security-privacy-and-risk-in-a-post-covid-world-bb7c10320a8e?source=rss-3c3b30a5b97c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bb7c10320a8e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[contact-tracing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[encryption]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[surveillance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Zulfikar Ramzan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Apr 2020 21:01:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-29T21:07:17.277Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BG1Wi_ewZhCkWDmV5sCz8Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@kylejeffreys?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Kyle Johnson</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/s/photos/future?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>In many cases, the lessons from societal crises are short-lived. We briefly adapt, but soon after the crisis is over, the lessons we’ve learned fade from our memory. Given the extreme nature of the current situation with COVID-19 and the fundamental assumptions about our lives it has shattered, it’s likely that new ways of living, thinking, and working will be permanently woven into our societal fabric.</p><h3>Redistributing the Future</h3><p>The famed science fiction writer William Gibson is attributed with saying that “The future has arrived — it’s just not evenly distributed yet”. In many, COVID-19 has distributed the future a little more uniformly. In recent times nothing seems to have accelerated digital transformation more than COVID-19. Our physical presence at work has been replaced with videoconferencing and collaboration tools, classrooms have been supplanted by distance learning environments, movies stream directly to our homes so we can avoid theaters, checkout lines at the supermarket are side-stepped by using on-demand grocery delivery services, doctors visits are handled via telemedicine, and so on. Even our social interactions have shifted. Under lockdown conditions we conduct lunches, happy hours, play dates, yoga classes, poker nights, religious gatherings, birthday parties, and even funerals through virtual means. While these capabilities have been available for some time, more people are availing themselves to their benefits given the broader milieu. These changes are just the beginning. As we emerge from our current situation, we can expect some of these new social practices to remain with us not only because they offer certain conveniences, but also because they will have become more socially acceptable. Beyond that, the increased awareness around health will lead to new situations.</p><h3>Individual (Health) Privacy Versus Systemic Risk</h3><p>Our interest in the health status of an individual (and its systemic impact) has never been greater. In the future, will people be required to provide some form of attestation about the state of their physical health in different settings? For example, prior to being allowed to board an airplane or attend a sporting event, will it become necessary to for an individual to prove that they are not likely to be a COVID-19 carrier (e.g., because they have built up immunity from a past infection, received plasma treatments, or received a vaccination — when that becomes available)? In the short term, such measures might be contemplated to get low-risk members of the population back to work and help the economy return to a healthy state.</p><p>These scenarios are very much in the realm of possibility. For example, in certain hospitals, staff are required to provide proof of immunization against influenza or else they must wear a mask when interacting with patients. Schools have required immunization records for decades and many employers require employees to be medically screened prior to being hired. In the wake of COVID-19, we can expect similar approaches to be considered, but perhaps done at an unprecedented scale by leveraging various types of digital technologies.</p><p>There is already preliminary evidence for such approaches in the wake of COVID-19. For example, in some places, people must undergo various forms of health screening (e.g., temperature checks) prior to using public transportation or being allowed into their place of work. As the efficiency and efficacy of testing improves, these measures will become ubiquitous. Other countries are contemplating the use of personal location data (e.g., GPS data from mobile phones) to enforce social distancing or to identify the people with whom an individual came into contact (a concept known as contact tracing).</p><p>Such approaches can even potentially be taken to more extreme levels. Is it possible that individuals will be assigned health risk scores based on their past behaviors and current status? By mining a person’s location history it’s possible to identify interactions with other individuals and potential exposure to viruses, among other things. Combining those attributes with current health data, like temperature, heart rate, oxygenation levels, and so on, leads to thorny situations. While there is some ostensible benefit of surveillance technologies for reducing the risk of disease spread, these approaches quickly lead us down a very slippery ethical slope.</p><p>The scenarios just outlined create tension between individual civil liberties and the need to address societal risks. Similar tensions have arisen in the wake of terrorist attacks, most notably following the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, and we can learn from these past experiences. Since 9/11, we have established a more robust body of law around individual privacy and surveillance. It’s also less clear how much the general public will tolerate surveillance mechanisms used in conjunction with pandemics compared to the surveillance approaches used to protect against terrorist attacks. Pandemic-related surveillance will directly target each individual and collect medical information, which people generally consider very private; in contrast, data collection associated with identifying terrorism-related activities might be viewed as more abstract and ostensibly not as personal (even if the reality is different).</p><p>Also, people struggle to reason about risk correctly in general. In behavioral economics, it’s well known that the more palpable a threat happens to be, the greater its perceived risk (even if the actual risk is lower). For example, even though terrorist attacks are rare, because of their violent nature, visceral images of these attacks are seared into our memories causing us to believe that the threat is more likely. With pandemics like COVID-19 fewer people will be able to derive an accurate perspective of the risks posed, especially in the early stages. This perception might change over time as more people get infected and people witness the impact first hand (e.g., if the virus spreads to a family member or close friend). All of that notwithstanding, one stark lesson from the past is that issues around surveillance and personal liberties are highly complex and unlikely to ever be resolved to everyone’s satisfaction.</p><h3>Challenges to Mass Surveillance of Health Data</h3><p>One challenge that comes up in the context of the large-scale collection of health data is accuracy. What if a test for COVID-19 returns a false positive because of inherent limitations in the test’s efficacy? Or there is fault the equipment used for the test (or fault with the person operating the equipment, if applicable)? Or a person’s name erroneously ends up on the wrong list? In the aftermath of 9/11, similar scenarios occurred. For example, there were numerous stories of people who were not allowed to board their flight because their name coincidentally matched or resembled that of someone on a no-fly-list. The opposite issues also occurs — what if an individual is able to trick the test into returning the wrong result? These issues are exacerbated by the potential need to make these types of tests work at large scale.</p><p>Other issues are that of fairness and discrimination, which are often conflated with privacy, but are very different. In certain scenarios, people may be willing to give up privacy or have little expectation of privacy. For example, in the context of facial recognition systems, a person’s face is among the most prominent attributes about them and in a public space people cannot have a reasonable expectation of privacy with respect to their facial characteristics. The bigger issue with facial recognition systems is that the data they collect can be misused or abused. There are similar concerns that surveillance data about people’s health status can be misused or abused for other purposes. For example, can the same technology that identifies potential COVID-19 infections be used to identify other health issues, like the presence of sexually transmitted diseases, about which a person might be more sensitive? If so, then this information can be potentially misused.</p><p>At the same time focusing the privacy debate solely on a particular surveillance mechanism or set of surveillance mechanisms is also problematic — because there are a large number of ways in which data about a person can be collected and correlated with other data collected about that person (e.g., mining other surveillance systems, looking at data posted to social media, and so on). It’s therefore important instead to have a broader conversation about privacy, recognizing that society’s attempt to battle COVID-19 is a critical juncture in that dialogue.</p><h3>Finding Favorable Tradeoffs Between Individual Privacy and System Safety</h3><p>There are also opportunities to find favorable tradeoffs between individual privacy and systemic safety. There has been some notable work in this area in the context of contact tracing (e.g., the MIT Safe Paths project, the Apple-Google privacy-preserving contact tracing application, France’s StopCovid, etc.).</p><p>Eventually there may be an opportunity to leverage technologies like <em>zero-knowledge proofs</em> and <em>homomorphic encryption</em> that employ advanced mathematical techniques to minimize information disclosure.</p><p>A zero-knowledge proof (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-knowledge_proof">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-knowledge_proof</a>) allows one party to essentially prove an assertion to another party in such a way that the verifying party has mathematical proof of the legitimacy of the claim made by the proving party, but learns nothing else (nor can reveal that information elsewhere). To understand why zero knowledge proofs are powerful, consider what happens today when trying establish some proof of age. Today, if one wants to enter a bar or register to vote or engage in some activity that requires establishing that their age is above a certain threshold, the “solution” is to provide the verifying party with some identification card (e.g., a passport or driver’s license). That approach divulges more information than the verifier actually cares about. In particular, identification documents provide a full date of birth, a name, and so on. With the right digital infrastructure in place that leverages zero-knowledge proofs, it will be possible for the verifying part to receive a mathematical guarantee that a person’s age is above a certain threshold without learning any more.</p><p>The idea that zero-knowledge proofs exist almost seems like magic. It is beyond the scope of this note to provide a rigorous mathematical treatment of zero knowledge proofs, but hopefully the following toy example will illustrate how they work. Imagine, for a moment, that you were trying to prove the existence of colors to a color-blind person. You could proceed as follows:</p><ol><li>Provide the color-blind person with two balls that have different colors, but otherwise look identical; e.g., one is red and the other is green.</li><li>Tell the color-blind person which ball is which (especially since they can’t tell the difference).</li><li>Request the color-blind person to turn around and place one of the balls in their right hand and the other ball in their left hand — without letting you see which ball they placed where.</li><li>Ask the color-blind person to show you the two balls.</li><li>Indicate to the color-blind person which of the two balls is red and which one is green.</li></ol><p>Because you can see colors, your answer will be correct every time. Since the color-blind person mixed the balls without you seeing it and could keep track of which is which, they can verify your guess is correct even without being able to perceive colors. Anyone who plays this game once will guess correctly half the time. But if you play this game repeatedly, only someone who can identify a distinguishing characteristic of the two balls (e.g., color) will be right every time. The color-blind person effectively becomes convinced that there is some distinguishing characteristic about these two balls, but they learn nothing more. Remarkably, despite being “convinced” that there is a distinguishing characteristic, the color-blind person will not be able to prove to anyone else that colors exist. Effectively, you’ve proved some assertion about the balls (i.e., that they have different colors) without imparting any knowledge to the color-blind person to do the same with someone else.</p><p>This concept can be more formally encoded mathematically and applied to a wide range of relevant problems.</p><p>A related technology that minimizes information disclosure is homomorphic encryption (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homomorphic_encryption">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homomorphic_encryption</a>). This technology allows encrypted data to be manipulated so that some important insight can be gleaned from this data, without revealing the original (unencrypted) data itself. To see where this concept can be useful, consider the following scenario. If a government decides to subpoena a telecommunications provider for GPS data to identify social distancing violations, the provider can first encrypt this data (using a homomorphic encryption algorithm). The government entity can then perform computations on the encrypted data without learning the original contents. In particular, the entity can perform computations to identify (encrypted) clusters of people who are gathered together and violating social distancing requirements. Information about these individuals can be then be divulged by the provider, without compromising the privacy of other (non-offending) parties. While tremendously promising, homomorphic encryption algorithms require extensive computation and may not yet be ready for widespread use.</p><p>Beyond that, before these technologies are adopted more broadly, there is still significant work to be done to provide the right digital infrastructure, to monitor the use of these technologies for fairness, to provide the right legal and policy frameworks for their use, and so on.</p><p>Taking a step back, it’s also worth noting that surveillance is fundamentally about collecting data to provide some broader putative benefit. There are other examples of relevant data collection in the context of pandemics that impinge less on personal privacy and that can play a role in the future. One example is how organizations monitor their supply and distribution chains.</p><h3>Supply and Distribution Chain Health</h3><p>Even though organizations have spent considerable energy on developing business continuity and disaster recovery plans, the unprecedented scale of COVID-19 has demonstrated that even the best laid plans can have significant limitations. In particular, COVID-19 has brought to light supply and distribution chain concerns — including, but not limited to shortages of key materials, export restrictions, transportation disruptions and workforce issues.</p><p>Internet of Things (IoT) devices can be used to better monitor the health of supply chains and identify situations in which there are potential disruptions. By analyzing global supply chain data gathered from IoT devices, it may be possible to identify hotspots — i.e., bottlenecks. These issues come up frequently. One current example involves highly specialized nasopharyngeal swabs that are used for COVID-19 testing<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>. Today very few places manufacture these swabs and they are struggling to keep up with global demand.</p><p>Other forms of predictive analytics can be used on top of IoT data to help with distribution. For example, grocery delivery services can tell you whether an item is currently in stock at a particular grocery store. This information is useful in typical situations where the delivery window is in reasonably proximity to the time the order is placed. However, as the demand for such delivery services has increased, orders might take several days to be fulfilled. In that case, what’s more relevant is not whether an item is currently in stock, but whether that item is likely to be in stock at the time the order is fulfilled. With the right sensor infrastructure in place to collect data and appropriate algorithms to analyze this data, these problems seem imminently addressable.</p><p>Although not traditionally thought of a supply and distribution chain, elections can be viewed under a similar lens because there is a need to collect ballots, deliver them to specific locations, and tally the results. In pandemic scenarios, individuals may be less inclined to vote in person. While many voters can use absentee options (e.g., mail in ballots), one must consider whether these options work as a large-scale replacement for in person voting. While absentee voting confers benefits in terms of removing the need to vote in a specific location at a specific time, it poses challenges to the democratic process as well. For example, it’s harder to determine whether a voter was coerced into a decision or whether it was actually them who voted in the first place. In this vein, should some form of online or electronic voting be considered to help scale traditional paper ballots? This approach appears problematic as electronic voting introduces its own challenges, especially as it relates to maintaining the security, integrity, and auditability of the voting process. Moreover, unlike self-driving cars or airplanes which require sophisticated technology, nothing about voting suggests that mechanisms beyond traditional paper ballots are needed.</p><p>The societal impact of pandemics also includes the work environment, which will continue to transform.</p><h3>The Post-COVID Work Environment</h3><p>As noted earlier, COVID-19 has been an accelerant of digital transformation activities. Some of these changes will be permanent, even if the situation comes under control through a combination of greater acceptance of prophylactic measures (e.g., social distancing, wearing masks), better treatment options, herd immunity, and a potential vaccine. Organizations might continue to encourage remote work (especially if they can then save on office costs) and try to limit business travel (as more people become comfortable with videoconferencing). Schools might encourage more distance learning options (perhaps during specific times of the year when viral spread is more likely). Tools for remote collaboration will only get better over time and we can expect to see rapid improvements.</p><p>As noted in <a href="https://medium.com/@Zulfikar_Ramzan/managing-digital-risk-during-pandemics-the-security-privacy-and-risk-implications-of-covid-19-bdf4059ef6c0">my last post</a>, to manage digital risk, organizations will need increased visibility into the activities of remote employees (e.g., by deploying endpoint monitoring and cloud monitoring technologies). The data collected here can potentially be used for purposes other than catching threats. The same technology for observing system behaviors indicative of malware can potentially be used to see if employees are putting in appropriate hours for their job. Schools might experience a similar situation. If students engage in distance learning options, schools might need to remotely monitor student activity and performance.</p><p>In general, pandemic conditions have forced people to rethink many fundamental aspects of their lives and the implications for the future. Some approaches might benefit from technical solutions whereas others do not. Nonetheless, the problems posed for society are multifaceted and require care to address.</p><h3>Closing Remarks</h3><p>If COVID-19 has taught us anything, it’s the power of human ingenuity when we come together towards a common cause. In the wake of COVID-19, people have rapidly developed novel therapies, created new approaches to testing, accelerated research on vaccines, identified ways to mass produce personal protective equipment, and designed new ventilators. Crises create remarkable moments of truth and force progress in critical areas. At the same time, we need to be cautious about whether solutions developed during this time of urgency are the right long-term solutions for us. We will eventually enter a post-COVID era armed with new insights about society and must recognize that the choices we make today will shape what that society looks like. Hopefully this note will help us all better navigate this terrain.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> <a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2020/03/18/817801222/testing-swabs-run-in-short-supply-as-makers-try-to-speed-up-production">https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2020/03/18/817801222/testing-swabs-run-in-short-supply-as-makers-try-to-speed-up-production</a> (Accessed March 31, 2020)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bb7c10320a8e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Managing Digital Risk During Pandemics: The Security, Privacy and Risk Implications of COVID-19]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@Zulfikar_Ramzan/managing-digital-risk-during-pandemics-the-security-privacy-and-risk-implications-of-covid-19-bdf4059ef6c0?source=rss-3c3b30a5b97c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bdf4059ef6c0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cybersecurity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-risk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[authentication]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[security-operation-center]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Zulfikar Ramzan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Apr 2020 07:18:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-22T07:55:35.770Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Managing Digital Risk During Pandemics: The Digital Security, Privacy, and Risk Implications of COVID-19</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2Oynxjydyke9ck23B42-xQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@enginakyurt?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">engin akyurt</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/s/photos/coronavirus-computer?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h3>Overview</h3><p>Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19), which was declared global pandemic by the World Health Organization in March 2020, has shifted fundamental paradigms regarding how we work and live. This article considers the implications of pandemics on digital security, risk, and privacy — focusing specifically on the challenges organizations face when trying to steer through these particularly turbulent times with regard to three specific areas:</p><ul><li><strong>Workforce Transformation: </strong>During pandemics organizations will see radical shifts in their workforce, including a substantial increase in remote workers together with a potential shift in roles and responsibilities.</li><li><strong>Security Transformation: </strong>Pandemics will force organizations to rethink their cybersecurity strategy and reassess risk — specifically as it relates to protecting their digital assets.</li><li><strong>Business Transformation: </strong>Pandemics alter how organizations must think about business risk — including third party and business continuity risk.</li></ul><p>A subsequent article will discuss the future — what we should be consider from a security, risk, and privacy perspective in a “Post-COVID” world.</p><h3>Workforce Transformation</h3><p>In the wake of pandemics like COVID-19, organizations must account for two specific dimensions of workforce transformation. First, organizations must accommodate a significant shift towards remote work. Second, organizations will potentially see major changes in the types of employees hired and the roles employees play in general.</p><h4>Remote Workforce</h4><p>One of the most glaring challenges that comes up light of pandemics involves enabling employees to work from home while being able to safely access the resources they need to conduct their job. It is well known that relying only on usernames and passwords to protect digital assets is insufficient. Consequently, organizations have invested in technologies like <em>strong multi-factor authentication (MFA)</em>, which are considered the best practice for secure remote access — considering a range of multi-factor authentication options, including but not limited to hardware-based one-time password tokens, software-based one-time password tokens, biometrics, SMS-based authentication, and so on. Even though traditional hardware-based one-time password tokens are the gold standard from a security perspective, they pose challenges in the context of pandemics. To begin with, there may be no central place for a vendor to ship tokens (since few people, if any, will be at the office). In addition, even if they get to the office, further distributing hardware tokens to specific remote employees is an additional challenge. Making matters worse, in an emergency scenario, time is of the essence. The delays incurred in manufacturing a hardware token and shipping it — especially when there may be delays in mail delivery times — might be a nonstarter. Fortunately, well-known hardware token vendors have, for many years, offered software-based tokens that can be delivered and deployed with an entirely digital form factor.</p><p>One additional subtlety that comes up in the context of MFA, especially in scenarios where the remote workforce must be enabled rapidly, is that no one-size-fits-all authentication approach will work for employees. If an employee has a company issued mobile device, then a software-based token or application to support multi-factor authentication can be installed on it. However, many employees will not have a work-issued device. Some employees might be fine with installing company software on their personal device, while others may not. In some cases, for compliance reasons, organizations are restricted from using an employee-owned device in any way, shape, or form to assist in multi-factor authentication — including not being able to even send an SMS message to an employee. Finally, there are ergonomic considerations as well. Someone who is vision impaired could struggle with one form factor (e.g., a software token that displays a sequence of numbers) but have fewer issues with another form factor (e.g., push to touch / Touch ID).</p><p>Another approach to simplifying remote access during a pandemic is <em>Single Sign On</em> (SSO). Many organizations successfully use SSO to create a common conduit by which employees can access applications. For companies that are cloud borne or who are mostly looking to provide employees access to cloud services, SSO may be a viable option. However, for multi-national organizations or complex enterprises, traditional SSO might be problematic if it leaves coverage gaps. In addition, even if SSO works for specific use cases now, it’s important to consider whether it can meet future demands as an organization scales.</p><p>In this vein, it’s important to realize the heterogeneous ways in which an organization’s digital assets and applications can be accessed. Beyond Virtual Private Networks (VPNs), access to can happen via Virtual Desktop Interfaces (VDI) and Remote Desktops. In addition, organizations leverage Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) applications. To simplify identity management, it’s crucial to determine which authentication approaches cover all these use cases rather than having different solutions for different scenarios.</p><p>Aside from authentication, there are important data handling considerations associated with remote work. For example, employees will still need to carry out their work in accordance with regulatory compliance regimes appropriate to their organization; e.g., Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) in the financial services sector, Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) that governs the use of Protected Health Information (PHI) in healthcare, Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification (CMMC) to protect Controlled Unclassified Information (CUI) as well as International Traffic in Arms (ITAR) in the defense sector, among many. While staying in compliance creates challenges in general, the situation is exacerbated by extensive remote work. For example, many healthcare professionals have increased use of videoconferencing options to interact with patients thereby limiting physical contact. In the process, information about patient health may be recorded in several places, including those where one traditionally might not realize it, like chat logs or a cloud server associated with the videoconferencing provider. The compliance “protection surface” must now be increased to compensate. Even though in certain sectors, there has been leniency granted given the extraordinary circumstances pandemics pose, organizations should not assume that such leniency will be applied towards adherence to regulatory compliance considerations. If lack of adherence results in a security breach or similar incident, an organization’s exposure could still be significant regardless of the circumstances.</p><p>In addition to compliance considerations, organizations might have contractual obligations with their customers that put restrictions around how certain tasks are conducted (e.g., constraints on the geographic location of the employee or the requirement for an employee to do their work from a specific location where there is physical security is present or the need to restrict certain activities to employees with a security clearance). In these cases, organizations might need to find appropriate solutions or renegotiate certain terms of their contractual agreement with their customers swiftly (or find ways to divide work to minimize tasks that might incur an employee bottleneck).</p><p>Many of these considerations (and others) will be discussed below in the section on overall security transformation.</p><h4>Workforce Changes</h4><p>Beyond the shift to remote work, pandemics can cause changes to the composition of an existing workforce. For example, if an organization’s employees become infected <em>en-masse</em> and need sustained time away from work to recover, then that organization will have to either shift large numbers of other employees to cover for them or will have to hire temporary employees as a stop-gap measure.</p><p>The risk of an entire team (or most of an entire team) being infected within a given time window is very real, especially considering that viruses spread in clusters — causing certain geographies (and workplaces) to become hotspots. In addition, if hospitals become overrun with patients afflicted from a given virus, they will struggle to find staffing and resources to care for patients with more routine medical issues. Therefore, the average sick leave required to recover even from issues not directly related to the pandemic can increase. Finally, beyond the need to shift roles or hire temporary workers, organizations might also find that they need to reduce the size of their workforce if the pandemic causes sustained financial harm to the business.</p><p>To address these types of workforce change issues, organizations need a robust <em>Identity Governance and Lifecycle (IG&amp;L)</em> program to handle the digital identities of joiners, movers, and leavers in their workforce. They may have to find ways to onboard joiners (e.g., new potentially temporary employees and contractors) quickly by giving them the right set of entitlements to carry out their job function. They also may need to rapidly change entitlements for movers (e.g., existing employees and contractors who will temporarily adjust their roles to cover for their sick colleagues). Finally, organizations may need to address leavers (e.g., people whose positions will be eliminated to reduce costs and/or temporary workers who leave when the person they were replacing is back in a healthy state). Again, IG&amp;L has always been important even before COVID-19. However, many organizations have handled these issues using manual methods or other less programmatic and structured means. Given the rapid workforce changes induced by pandemics, shifting to a more robust and efficient solution is essential.</p><p>In general, the effective management of digital identities is crucial in managing the workforce transformation induced by a pandemic. From a cybersecurity perspective, digital identity is the most consequential attack vector. Any cyberattack of substance involves, at some point, the abuse, misuse, or co-opting of a digital identity for nefarious purposes. A robust digital identity program can ensure that the right people are allowed access to the right digital assets at the right time, which is a cornerstone of cybersecurity. The other critical question, which will be covered in the next section, involves ensuring that the wrong people are kept away from these digital assets.</p><h3>Security Transformation</h3><p>Beyond the implications for workforce transformation, security teams may have to rethink their core security strategy, their approach to security operations, and more broadly how they reason about cyber-risk under the conditions of a pandemic. This section reviews some important considerations across all three dimensions.</p><h4>Security Strategy</h4><p>Security leaders should spend time reviewing their policies to see what aspects no longer make sense under pandemic conditions. For example, do policies need to be revised for situations where employees will be working from home? If employees will be leveraging personal devices to carry out their job functions (e.g., BYOD) how should existing policies be revised? Will some aspects of the security strategy blur the lines between an employee’s professional and personal lives? (For example, to what extent should an organization care about protecting systems owned by an employee’s family members or other digital devices at home, like routers, printers, and so on?)</p><p>Security leaders will also have to rethink how to deploy security technologies. Does deployment require the professional services team of a vendor (or of a partner of the vendor) to come onsite? Can they do so in the context of a pandemic? And even if they can, will someone be able to let them in and work with them? Finally, even if the core pieces of security technology can be deployed successfully, how difficult will it be to push out the corresponding protection capabilities to end users who are working remotely (especially if their devices are disconnected more often than they would be form the office).</p><p>Security leaders will also have to rethink their incident response strategy under pandemic conditions. As part of that, it will be necessary to rethink the Security Operations Center (SOC).</p><h4>Security Operations</h4><p>The cornerstone of modern security operations is the Evolved Security Information and Event Manager (Evolved SIEM). To make SIEM technology successful, it’s crucial to have depth and breadth of visibility across the digital assets of an organization, from the network core, to the edge, to the cloud. Employees who spend a greater percentage of their time (or potentially all of their time) off-premises will pose visibility challenges. First, it will be more important to have direct visibility into employee endpoint devices since fewer employees will access an organization’s network core. In this vein, technologies for <em>Endpoint Detection and Response</em> play a more important role and will need to be more widely deployed. In addition, as employees operate out of remote locations, they may either have a higher propensity of accessing cloud applications in a way that is outside the purview of monitoring technologies that are on-premises or they may leverage new cloud services to carry out work tasks (in many cases without the knowledge of the IT department). Remote collaboration tools are one category within the broader aegis of cloud applications that deserve special attention since they will be used more frequently among remote employees and may be used to share sensitive data. It is therefore crucial to have some form of visibility into cloud services. Organizations should invest in Evolved SIEM platforms that include native EDR and cloud visibility or that can be integrated with such capabilities. Having a breadth of native capabilities is important when SOC analysts are remote so they can perform investigations with a single tool rather than having to coordinate multiple tools. In the case where SIEMs do not natively address cloud visibility concerns or where those capabilities still need to be augmented, organizations can consider acquiring a <em>Cloud Access Security Broker (CASB) </em>technology and integrating it with their SIEM. Finally, since a mobile workforce will make heavier use of mobile devices, appropriate investment in Mobile Device Management (MDM) technology will be needed as effective device management is a prerequisite for effective device security.</p><p>Security leaders will also need to rethink their incident response strategy in the context of pandemic situations. To what extent can employees of the security operations center operate remotely (i.e., can a virtual SOC be created)? Are there data governance concerns? This last question is especially important since security data is often considered highly sensitive. In fact, during the investigation of a critical security incident, many security operations center personnel will literally draw the blinds or pull the curtains to prevent information leakage to anyone passing by.</p><p>Some organizations already leverage <em>Managed Security Service Providers</em> (MSSPs), so SOC personnel are effectively already remote. Organizations that do not currently have an MSSP might wish to consider if it makes sense to offload at least some portion of security monitoring to a third party — especially if there are concerns about workforce changes (reductions or shifts in workforce) or if it’s easier economically to leverage an MSSP versus hiring personnel directly for situations where a pandemic poses an economic burden on a business. There are a variety of different hybrid models one can employ for an MSSP. For example, MSSPs can be designated to handle incidents outside of business hours or incidents of a specific degree of complexity (e.g., Tier 1 and tier 2 incidents handled could an MSSP, while Tier 3 can handled in house — or vice versa). Nevertheless, if an organization is using or is planning to use an MSSP, it does incur third-party risk. As such, it’s critical to consider whether the MSSP itself has a sound business resiliency strategy and can provide services to its customers during a pandemic. This consideration should be folded into an organization’s third-party risk management strategy.</p><p>Moreover, critical incidents are an all-hands-on-deck effort requiring collaboration from multiple parties:</p><ul><li>The security teams might investigate the incident to understand its ramifications and these teams often hire outside experts (e.g., external incident response teams)</li><li>The IT team might be involved in deploying fixes or making infrastructure changes as part of incident response</li><li>The legal team can get involved if sensitive data or intellectual property is leaked (frequently the first call following the discovery of a breach is to the legal team) and the legal team, in turn, might call third-party law firms</li><li>The sales team might need to get involved and engage with customers if the incident has a customer facing impact</li><li>The marketing team will be involved to help develop a communications plan to be used with customers</li><li>The PR team — especially the crisis communications team — will be involved to help engage with the media (if applicable)</li><li>The risk and compliance office will be involved if the security incident causes the organization to run afoul of any regulatory compliance requirements</li><li>The finance team will be involved to approve discretionary budget for third-party contractors, like external incident response teams or external law firms</li></ul><p>Given the number of parties who can get involved and the highly cross-functional nature of these parties, collaboration is a challenge at a baseline. Remote collaboration only exacerbates matters. Organizations will need to invest in the right remote collaboration tools to create a virtual war room to handle incidents.</p><p>Prior to an incident, it’s a generally accepted best practice for organizations to conduct <em>table-top exercises </em>in which a breach or similar incident is simulated. During this exercise, shortcomings in an organization’s incident response plan are highlighted (such as lack of available technology, lack of personnel, lack of appropriate processes or lack of the right governance structure). In the context of pandemics, organizations should conduct a virtual table-top exercise to see how they would handle an incident assuming everyone involved is working from a remote location. The exercise should also include stipulations for failures — e.g., a given person cannot be reached or they have connectivity issues.</p><h4>Shift in Risk Calculation</h4><p>Beyond looking at core security strategy and security operations, organizations will have to rethink their basic risk calculus as it relates to cybersecurity issues across a number of key areas including, but not limited to the following:</p><ul><li><strong>Vulnerability management:</strong> Vulnerability scans rarely cover every digital asset since some assets will be offline at the time the scan is conducted. In the context of a pandemic, more employees will be remote; therefore, the number of systems offline at any given moment (and consequently missed by a vulnerability scan) goes up considerably. Organizations will need to account for these issues; e.g., by increasing frequency of scans or finding new ways to identify potentially vulnerable systems. Along similar lines, patching systems also becomes more difficult if they are offline more frequently. Being able to understand vulnerability risk becomes more important than ever. The focus should be on understanding the likelihood of a vulnerability being exploited and the impact it can have to an organization (e.g., business criticality of the asset that is vulnerable). As part of the latter, using the Common Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS) is just one element. The limitation of CVSS is that it is a one-size-fits-all score regardless of the particulars of each individual organization trying to address the vulnerability. In reality, organizations essentially need a “personal CVSS” that captures the importance of fixing that vulnerability for its specific environment.</li><li><strong>Risks of Home Environment:</strong> A person’s home environment will likely be less protected than their work environment. As the lines between people’s professional and personal lives becomes increasingly blurred, employees may be more likely to carry out personal tasks on their work systems and/or let other family members use work systems. The risk of an attacker compromising a system at home and then using it as a launch pad into other organizational assets is well known, but goes up considerably as the workforce substantially shifts towards remote work. Ensuring breadth and depth of visibility into assets used by telecommuters, where reasonably possible, will help tremendously. Additional security awareness training is also helpful. In addition, organizations should consider additional training for employees around safeguarding their home environment and personal accounts. The training could initially start with simply providing pointers to online resources, but ultimately include more detailed assessments to ensure that the material was learned effectively.</li><li><strong>Security Portfolio Re-assessment:</strong> In general, organizations should frequently be assessing the security technologies they have in place and identifying whether there are opportunities for some type of tool rationalization. In the context of a pandemic, like COVID-19, that tool rationalization should consider how effective the underlying capabilities are in light of situations where a larger fraction of employees are remote. Along the same lines, it’s important to consider whether those technologies make specific assumptions that no longer hold or that have somehow shifted. For example, User and Entity Behavioral Analytics (UEBA) solutions that are typically included as part of Evolved SIEMs often work, in part, by baselining an organization’s behavior (e.g., by examining network traffic) and then looking for subsequent deviations from that behavior that might suggest malicious intent. During pandemic conditions, organizations will see a rapid change in workforce behavior, and those changes may temporarily harm the efficacy of UEBA offerings. A similar note applies for CASB offerings, which provide UEBA, but targeted towards cloud applications (SaaS, IaaS, etc.).</li><li><strong>Increased Leaver Population:</strong> If there is a significant detrimental economic impact to an organization during a pandemic, it may be forced to downsize. In these instances, (former) employees may be in possession of assets that contain sensitive information (e.g., laptops or phones). The added challenge, however, is that if the impacted employees are remote, there is an increased likelihood that the sensitive assets they possess will never be returned to the organization. On a related note, if employees sense that they may be impacted as part of cost-cutting measures, they might purposefully copy large swaths of organizational data for later use (e.g., sales reps copying customer contact information, engineers copying source code, etc.). Disgruntled former employees could potentially post some of this data publicly to embarrass their former employers. These situations create significant additional information exposure and organizations will need to think about potential compensating measures.</li><li><strong>New Types of Threats:</strong> As organizations have shifted to new applications to foster remote work, they must consider new types of threats. For example, in Zoom bombing attacks, threat actors join Zoom meetings (e.g., by looking for invitation links that were publicly posted), after which they disrupt those meetings by sharing pornography, typing racial slurs into the chat window, etc. Zoom bombing attacks could also be used to propagate phishing attacks and malware through posting malicious links in chat windows. To address this threat, organizations should appeal to classic security paradigms like least privilege. For example, in a Zoom meeting the host can disable file transfer, screen sharing, video, annotations, etc., by participants. Hosts can also require password to join a meeting. Taking a step back, organizations should identify what videoconferencing options make sense and fit within an organization’s needs. For example, Zoom does not always provide end-to-end encryption of video (which, in all fairness, is very challenging to do given the various ways in which users access it together with the need to do various forms of data processing on video content as part of providing a compelling user experience). Rushing to a different solution, however, can create more problems than it solves for several reasons. First, users would have to get trained to use the new solution properly and learn to avoid human error in contexts relevant to security. Second, the new solution may be no better from a security perspective (lack of scrutiny does not imply lack of issues). Third, it’s important to consider the vendor response. Do they have the means and desire to make changes and improve their security posture in response to issues? And finally, has the broader risk picture been adequately examined? In some cases, a security issue may be relatively minor or only pose a theoretical risk rather than a practical one. <br> <br> Beyond new threats like Zoom bombing, pandemics like COVID-19 have given rise to new twists on standard threats. For example, there have been a number of COVID-19 themed campaigns that take advantage of people’s desire to find the latest information involving phishing, vishing, smishing, watering holes, and rogue mobile applications.</li></ul><p>In general, a fundamental challenge posed in any risk assessment given the current climate is that circumstances are changing rapidly. As new information becomes available, risk has to be reassessed. In addition, how we even interpret risk scores changes fundamentally. Today, many organizations use various tools for security risk assessment, each of which outputs some set of metrics. Taken at face value, these metrics typically do not coincide with the actual risk faced. Consequently, organizations implement specific methods that glean insights from these metrics to drive towards specific meaningful results. In the context of pandemics, with the rapid changes they entail, the metrics produced by risk assessment tools may vary wildly, which in turn impacts the insights derived from them.</p><p>Taking a step back, it’s also crucial to realize that security leaders are successful if they embrace a business-driven security approach that harmonizes between business needs and security needs. Having to accommodate a rapid shift in workforce transformation will, at a baseline, create new challenges for organizations when conducting business. Existing security mechanisms and controls will struggle to succeed if they get in the way of these challenges. Anyone who has worked in security long enough knows that if controls prove to be too onerous, people find clever ways to bypass them. In a pandemic situation with a substantial number of remote workers who are harder to monitor, the likelihood of these types of bypasses goes up considerably. Security teams should review the controls they have in place and consider several options:</p><ul><li>First, is the control necessary at all? In many cases, organizations implement controls that do not materially mitigate risk and can be removed altogether.</li><li>Second, can the existing control be replaced by an alternative mechanism that does not impede the business as much, but still materially mitigates risk? For example, while hardware-based authentication tokens are generally the gold standard from a security perspective, in many cases software tokens are an acceptable alternative. While the hardware tokens reduce risk the most, there may be scenarios where the increased risk of software tokens is relatively small and may be acceptable (depending, for example, on the resources the employee is allowed to access).</li><li>Third, can the removal of the control altogether be absorbed as part of acceptable risk? Ultimately, risk should be looked at holistically. A security control that prevents an organization from engaging in key activities might contribute significantly to overall business risk. Perhaps the degree of cyber-risk that a given control mitigates will be far outweighed by the needs of the business.</li></ul><p>Regardless of which option chosen, visibility continues to paramount. To measure and assess risk, one needs visibility into digital assets because it’s difficult to measure or assess what cannot be (directly or indirectly) seen.</p><p>Given this interplay between security teams and business stakeholders, it should be clear that organizations must rethink many aspects of their business practices in the context of pandemics.</p><h3>Business Transformation</h3><p>At a fundamental level, organizations have had to rethink business resilience. Today’s organizations do not exist as isolated instances unto themselves. Rather, they exist as part of a much more complex ecosystem. Organizations rely on supply chains together with their partners, people, processes, and technologies to develop offerings. They then rely on distribution chains to provide their offerings to the world. These entities themselves rely on similar elements. The result is a labyrinthine web of organizations that must work in concert to produce any particular good or service.</p><p>Pandemics like COVID-19 are a stark reminder that failures in one part of a complex, hyperconnected system can have a dramatic ripple effect in other parts. Put differently, an organization’s ability to successfully deliver goods and services to customers depends on its partners, distributors, and suppliers to be successful.</p><p>While third-party risk has always been an important concern for organizations, that risk magnifies in the context of pandemics. Organizations should review their policies around third-party risks and identify where they may be susceptible. To what extent do their suppliers, partners, and distributors have the ability to stay resilient in the face of a pandemic? What alternatives, compensating controls or risk mitigation measures can be put in place? If there is a need to find an alternate supplier, what steps must be taken to ensure a smooth transition? Also, given that failures during pandemics can be more widespread (e.g., a large number of organizations being impacted at once), it’s important to consider organizational resiliency against multiple points of failure. A more proactive way to address some aspects of third-party supply chain risk is through predictive analytics. If the likelihood of a supply chain failure increases, organizations can ask suppliers to potentially ramp up production ahead of the issue. This approach can work well in pandemic contexts since infection rates follow a curve and it becomes possible to extrapolate the future state.</p><p>Despite the growing importance and complexity of managing third-party risk, most organizations rely on highly manual methods, like spreadsheets, to carry out assessments. Organizations should consider investing in <em>Vendor Risk Management</em> technologies that allow for more efficient and comprehensive assessments. One subtlety is that if organizations employ vendor risk management technologies that compute some form of risk score, then the methodology by which that score is computed should be examined in the context of pandemics. In any rapidly evolving area, it’s hard to pinpoint a precise risk score since data is often incomplete and relevant insights are being developed each day. Therefore, risk scores should not simply be taken at face value; instead the underlying approach should be scrutinized for issues.</p><p>One particular aspect of third-party risk involves the cloud. It’s crucial for organizations to recognize that the cloud is a fundamental extension of their infrastructure and, more so, that the cloud is basically just someone else’s computer. Many organizations already rely upon various cloud services and have to consider the resilience of these services in the face of a pandemic. In general cloud adoption has been increasing, but the advent of COVID-19 has created an extensive level of cloud adoption, especially for remote employees. Can these cloud services safely scale to meet growing demand? In this vein, organizations should consider what back-up options they have. Doing so entails understanding whether the functionality offered by competing offerings meets an organization’s requirements, especially around operational uptime guarantees, security, compliance, and so on. In this regard, it’s also imperative to understand the challenges associated with migrating between services, if needed.</p><p>At a more fundamental level, organizations should review their own disaster recovery plans and identify whether those plans can be executed effectively with a largely remote workforce. Are the right set of technologies, people and processes in place to facilitate that transition? Are the applications that are most critical to a business at least documented? Are there appropriate compensating controls if they fail (e.g., backups)? Also, given that pandemics lead to highly dynamic situations where new information is being made available on a regular basis and the picture is evolving, is there a sufficiently regular cadence for reviewing the decisions made thus far?</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Thinking through crucial issues around workforce transformation, security transformation, and business transformation will help organizations navigate the immediate and medium-term challenges that arise during pandemics. It’s clear that the conditions posed by pandemics shatter many basic assumptions regarding how organizations manage digital risk and protect their information technology assets. Moreover, with the changing landscape, organizations need to rethink how risk is evaluated. Simply put, COVID-19 cements the idea that navigating the road ahead cannot be accomplished by looking in the rear view mirror. A forthcoming article will consider what we might encounter in a post-COVID world from a security, privacy, and risk perspective.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bdf4059ef6c0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>