<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Justice Rapid Response on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Justice Rapid Response on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@_JRR?source=rss-a6dc946d96e7------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 17:17:25 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@_JRR/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Does It Mean To Do Justice?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@_JRR/what-does-it-mean-to-do-justice-7a503cbbfae6?source=rss-a6dc946d96e7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7a503cbbfae6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justice Rapid Response]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 31 Oct 2019 10:31:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-31T10:33:06.633Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1gV0ThpH-xuoQwC6Jm78EA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Eliott Behar leads workshop with Yazda in Iraq 2019</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Justice Rapid Response expert Eliott Behar shares his personal reflections on the work of an international justice practitioner.</em></strong></p><p>It is a central tenet of being a prosecutor — one of the principles core to the job — that you should be immune from politics, from popular pressures, and from the influence and cheerleading of the press. As a prosecutor in Canada, where I began my career, the phrase I heard most often from my senior colleagues when things weren’t going our way, or when we found ourselves the subject of various external pressures, was the solemnly imparted old chestnut: “Just keep your head down and do the job.”</p><p>They were right. Trying to reach a particular outcome instead of focusing on the component parts of your role, trying to curry favor with the public, or seeing yourself as some sort of noble saviour astride a white horse instead of as a trained professional doing a job — the perils of these mistakes are well documented and rightly feared. A prosecutor’s job is to be fair and impartial and to see that justice is done. Period. That job is performed inside the four walls of the courtroom and rightly circumscribed by rigorously defined rules.</p><p>Keeping your head down, and your mind clear of external perceptions and influences, is a necessary and healthy part of working in criminal law. For the ten years I spent as a Canadian prosecutor, running trials and arguing appeals in cases ranging from sexual assault to murder, this advice served me well. It is as important today, if not more important, than it has ever been.</p><p>And yet.</p><p>When I made the shift to become an international prosecutor, building and trying cases for large-scale crimes like genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes, I began to see how extensively the <em>impact </em>of events in the courtroom is determined by the perception, understanding, and emotional investment of the people outside of it.</p><p>What became increasingly clear, in other words, is that the way justice is <em>perceived </em>matters. Without the right expectations, and without a clear and shared understanding of the broader framework in which it operates, the enterprise of international criminal justice doesn’t work. It can even be counter-productive.</p><p>The prosecution of genocide, crimes against humanity or war crimes is premised on a very particular shared perspective. It requires that all of us agree — regardless of country, ethnicity, or religion — that certain crimes are never acceptable, regardless of who is committing them. For acts such as the mass slaughter of civilians, targeted programs of sexual assault or torture, or the attempt to destroy entire communities of human beings, international criminal law enforces the principle that these acts are never permissible and has us all agree up front that the perpetrators should be held to account.</p><p>This is the shared premise, and the essential promise, of international criminal law. It is not a complicated one, and this is by design. Yet it’s remarkable how infrequently we discuss, and how seldom our real stakeholders seem to understand, that this is the bedrock foundation upon which the teetering castle of international criminal justice is built. Some of us may believe that this perspective is implicit and that it goes without saying. But this is simply not the case.</p><p><strong>Perception Matters</strong></p><p>Speak to people in the countries of the former Yugoslavia about the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, where I worked as a prosecutor, and you confront the unfortunate fact that a great many of them have never stopped seeing the trial proceedings exclusively through the lens of their ethnicity. In blunt terms, the Serbs cheer for the Serbs, the Croats for the Croats, the Bosnian Muslims for the Bosnian Muslims. Many of the most appalling perpetrators have thus, in many cases, been embraced as patriots and national heroes by their countrymen.</p><p>This, of course, is precisely opposite to the way international criminal justice is supposed to work. Viewed this way, as a sort of “us vs. them” contest that pits ethnicities or nationalities against one another in the courtroom, the entire enterprise can be destructive; antithetical to its stated mission. Yet the ICTY is not an outlier in this — to the contrary, it seems very much the norm. You can find a similar dynamic in groups as disparate as Hutus, Kenyans, Turks, Chinese, or Americans, when “one of their own” finds themselves the subject of war crimes allegations.</p><p>There are, then, some deeper questions to be addressed anytime we set out to do the work of pursuing justice in the context of such profound, disruptive and large-scale violence. Perception matters. A community’s understanding and investment in the justice process matters. The most basic assumptions that we may take for granted in the context of our everyday domestic justice systems — not just who and what we prosecute, but <em>why</em>, what we hope to achieve, and how we hope to achieve it — become essential to the entire enterprise.</p><p>Doing justice in the context of such deep-seated and historical violence requires that we ask, and continually try to answer, a very fundamental question: <em>what does it mean to do justice?</em></p><p>Answering this question means remembering, and reflecting on, the reasons we pursue justice on an international level and the shared perspective that we bring to the undertaking as a whole. It also means thinking deeply about what it is that we hope to achieve by pursuing justice and how exactly we should go about achieving it. Not all approaches to justice are the same. Far from it.</p><p>Speak to the justice-seeking victims of an international atrocity today and the first thing you’re likely to hear is that the ICC should take up their collective case. At least this has been my experience. In the 17 years since its founding in 2002, however, the ICC has obtained convictions in just 4 cases, for a total of 8 accused. Its cases are large, they move slowly, and perhaps most importantly, they necessarily focus on a small number of the most senior-level perpetrators. Thinking about international justice in a holistic and purposive way means recognizing the ICC’s inherent limitations — while prosecuting only the most senior-level perpetrators has both practical and symbolic importance, it is not, nor can it be, the entire picture. For the father who saw his young sons lined up and executed, for the woman who was sexually assaulted and trafficked into sexual slavery, for the grandmother who lost her entire family to a marauding band of ISIS fighters, it is also the many individual perpetrators on the ground, the men who marched into their towns and villages and who pulled the triggers and unleashed the bullets, who must be held accountable so that justice can be done. To acknowledge these limitations is not to be critical of the ICC but instead to relieve, to some degree, the burden so many of its critics have implicitly expected it to shoulder. The ICC is simply one piece of a larger puzzle.</p><p><strong>Pathways to Prosecution</strong></p><p>At present, “international justice” offers up a patchwork of different potential justice pathways that can be pursued. The ICC is one such pathway, particularly for the most senior perpetrators, if and when the ICC has jurisdiction and the practical ability to bring them before the court. But individual perpetrators who have fled to countries with universal jurisdiction laws can also be prosecuted domestically for their international crimes. In countries like the United States, civil remedies can be pursued against international criminals to seize their assets and impose massive financial penalties. Where there is a willingness, “hybrid tribunals” can be created so that large numbers of individual perpetrators can be prosecuted domestically but with the benefit of international support and expertise. These remedies are not mutually exclusive. To the contrary, they work best when pursued together.</p><p>These are the pathways to international prosecution but they are themselves just a part of a much broader spectrum. A fuller and richer approach to “doing justice” means taking into account a number of deeper goals. Can we understand, and help others to understand, the full breadth and scope of the violence that took place, how it took place, and what led to it in the first place? How can we prevent such events from taking place again — and more specifically, what legal, institutional or societal reforms might help to ensure that such violence never re-occurs? Are reparations appropriate, and would they help individuals or communities to move forward and to heal? Finally, a fulsome approach to justice must consider the most difficult question: how do you bring a society back together after such terrible, traumatic events have taken place — or to put it another way, how might you truly achieve reconciliation? Taken together, these are what you might call “truth and reconciliation” approaches. They have been pursued, in varied forms, by Truth and Reconciliation Commissions in countries around the world. But these values and goals need not be pursued in a dedicated commission — each can be pursued in and of itself, by governments or by members of civil society, with or without international assistance.</p><p><strong>Doing Justice Well</strong></p><p>These are lofty goals, certainly, and not ones easily achieved. So how does one go about the real work of doing justice in the wake of such large-scale violence? The answer, I believe, is that doing the work of international justice today requires the combination of two crucial elements. The first is the skill and experience to do the challenging work required — the skill to investigate incisively and sensitively, the expertise to build and run a complex prosecution, or the knowledge, experience and resources to meaningfully pursue truth and reconciliation. The equally-important second element is to bring these skills to bear in the right way — to direct our efforts towards a process that is meaningful for its victims and for the affected society as a whole, in a way that is understood both specifically and conceptually, and in which the affected society is deeply and genuinely invested.</p><p>For international experts with the skills and experience to do the work of international justice, there is a vitally important role to be played in working with and assisting local justice initiatives: helping them to execute their mission in a manner that is not prescriptive but collaborative, and sharing practical knowledge and experience in a way that allows them to determine and shape their own policies, procedures and techniques. There are many ways to do justice, both on the global stage and at the local level. If we bear these two elements in mind, we have a better chance of attaining the most elusive but valuable of goals: to do the work of justice and do it well.</p><p>_______________________</p><p>Eliott Behar is a former Canadian criminal prosecutor, international war crimes prosecutor, and author of the book <em>Tell It To The World: International Justice and the Secret Campaign to Hide Mass Murder in Kosovo</em>. He runs an international legal and consulting practice and has worked as a JRR expert in The Gambia and Northern Iraq.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7a503cbbfae6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Quand la poussière rouge retombe]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@_JRR/https-medium-com-jrr-quand-la-poussiere-rouge-retombe-a54eb71362bd?source=rss-a6dc946d96e7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a54eb71362bd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mali]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conflict]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[united-nations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justice Rapid Response]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Mar 2018 17:31:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-27T13:55:21.236Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Quand la poussière rouge retombe: Le Mali face au tragique héritage de la guerre</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3tlH05xWlrn-rsg2kk2qbg.jpeg" /></figure><h3>La création par le Mali d’une Commission vérité pour faire face à des décennies de conflit a très tôt rendu nécessaire le recours à une expertise spécialisée. Ayant travaillé avec un expert de JRR, la Commission possède désormais les outils nécessaires pour rassembler les victimes et recueillir la vérité avec une méthode unique qui lui est propre.</h3><p><em>Par </em><a href="https://twitter.com/_hannahdunphy"><em>Hannah Dunphy</em></a><em>, JRR</em></p><p>La veille de son voyage à Kidal, le Colonel Major Haidara Aboucarine est réveillé en sursaut par un cauchemar.</p><p>Nous sommes en mai 2014. Il travaille pour le gouvernement malien. Le Nord du pays est contesté par les Touaregs du Mouvement national de libération de l’Azaouad (MNLA) et autres groupes combattant pour l’indépendance de la région. À Kidal, qui tient lieu de forteresse à ces diverses factions, la situation est tendue dans l’attente de la visite du Premier ministre du Mali. Aboucarine a été personnellement sommé par le Gouverneur de Kidal de lui apporter son assistance.</p><p>Son cauchemar était impressionnant, et au vu des incessantes violences dans le Nord du pays, certains ont pu voir un mauvais présage. Pieux musulman et profondément spirituel, il n’est cependant pas homme à prendre peur facilement. Après une courte prière, il retourne se coucher.</p><p>« Je suis un optimiste », avait-t-il déclaré plus tard. « Je n’aurais jamais cru qu’ils prendraient Kidal ».</p><p>Quelques jours plus tard, Aboucarine est sur place quand le Premier ministre Moussa Mara arrive à Kidal. C’est alors que plusieurs groupes armés assiègent la ville : des hommes à bord de camions prennent d’assaut le bureau du Gouverneur, abattant des employés au passage. Au milieu du chaos, Aboucarine trouve refuge dans une maison avec d’autres personnes. Frêle et longiligne, il se recroqueville sous une table de bois, retenant son souffle pendant que les assaillants fouillent les lieux. Il entend les autres qui se sont aussi cachés là se faire emmener ou exécuter par les hommes armés. Plusieurs heures plus tard, il est découvert à son tour.</p><p>« Le premier homme m’a donné de l’eau, mais le second m’a battu », dit-il. « Ils m’ont tapé sur la tête jusqu’à ce que je tombe par terre ».</p><p>Une fois sortis de la maison, les ravisseurs lui recouvrent la tête et le jettent dans un camion avec plusieurs autres prisonniers. On les emmène alors dans un autre endroit où on les entasse dans une petite pièce. Il y fait chaud. Mains liées, ils sont contraints de s’allonger à plat ventre. Outre ses blessures à la tête, Aboucarine souffre également de sa clavicule cassée par les mauvais traitements. Ils sont ainsi retenus pendant près de deux jours.</p><p>« Ils nous ont véritablement brutalisés », raconte Aboucarine. « Il faisait tellement chaud dans cette pièce qu’on avait l’impression qu’il n’y avait pas de fenêtre. Certains d’entre nous étaient prêts à mourir, d’autres sont morts ».</p><p>On a appris par la suite qu’au moment où les groupes armés avaient investi le bureau du Gouverneur, les forces militaires maliennes avaient très rapidement battu en retraite et que toute la ville était tombée aux mains des insurgés. Si Aboucarine a survécu, beaucoup n’ont pas eu cette chance : huit civils, dont six fonctionnaires,<a href="https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2015/country-chapters/mali"> ont été sommairement exécutés</a> par les groupes armés.</p><p>Si les évènements survenus à Kidal en mai 2014 ont fait la une des journaux du monde entier, il ne s’agit que de l’un des multiples incidents ayant émaillé l’histoire récente du Mali et mobilisé l’attention internationale, avec notamment un important coup d’État en 2012, et avant ça, des dizaines d’années d’insurrections, de tensions et violences autour de certaines communautés, et de violations des droits de l’homme. Près de quatre ans plus tard, seul un fragile accord de paix empêche le Mali de replonger de nouveau dans un conflit. Plusieurs groupes islamistes extrémistes ont regagné du terrain, et le trafic de drogues et la criminalité transnationale à l’échelle du Sahel tout entier rendent la situation sécuritaire imprévisible. Les restaurants et les hôtels fréquentés par des étrangers sont régulièrement attaqués, tout comme les postes de contrôle militaires et les véhicules des Nations Unies.</p><p>Face à une militarisation grandissante, les organisations maliennes des droits de l’homme craignent toujours pour la sécurité de la population civile, la vie quotidienne demeurant perturbée par la fermeture des écoles et un accès limité aux champs et au travail. Une importante force onusienne de maintien de la paix a été mise en place, mais du fait de l’instabilité quasi permanente, c’est l<a href="http://www.washingtonpost.com/sf/world/2017/02/17/the-worlds-deadliest-u-n-peacekeeping-mission/?utm_term=.b7c2efa73f9f">a plus meurtrière de toutes les missions de maintien de la paix des Nations Unies</a>. Évoquant la détérioration de la situation humanitaire et des droits de l’homme, les Nations Unies <a href="http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=58466#.WmfHYK6nEdU">ont récemment décrit</a> une « course contre la montre ».</p><p>C’est dans cette atmosphère tendue qu’un groupe de Maliens a décidé de tenter l’impensable : rassembler les communautés éclatées du Mali dans un effort national de vérité et de réconciliation. La Commission Vérité, Justice et Réconciliation du Mali est chargée d’établir la vérité sur les crises et conflits dans lesquels le Mali retombe régulièrement depuis son accession à l’indépendance en 1960. Les membres de la Commission née de l’accord de paix représentent chacun des nombreux groupes politiques, ethniques et religieux du pays.</p><p>Pour les victimes comme le Colonel Haidara, lasses de l’impunité dont bénéficient les auteurs de crimes comme ceux de Kidal, la Commission représente un nouvel espoir. Mais avec la violence permanente qui sévit dans le pays et les obstacles non négligeables qui demeurent sur la route de la paix, la question continue de se poser : la Commission Vérité, Justice et Réconciliation du Mali parviendra-t-elle à panser les plaies du pays ?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*IGCIQelCxQV-9lOz.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Rues de Bamako, Mali (JRR)</em></figcaption></figure><p>PARTIE I</p><p>Le Mali est un vaste pays enclavé d’Afrique de l’Ouest, situé au centre du Sahel. Au Nord, on trouve essentiellement de larges bandes désertiques qui s’avancent profondément dans le Sahara, avec de longues frontières communes avec la Mauritanie, l’Algérie et le Niger. En majorité musulman, le Mali a vu naître des douzaines de stars de la pop africaine, comme Salif Keita, et le pays est renommé pour le son caractéristique des maîtres de la <em>kora </em>comme Toumani Diabaté ou Ali Farka Touré. La capitale, Bamako, sur la rive sud du fleuve Niger, a vu sa population exploser au cours de la dernière décennie, y compris sous l’effet des déplacements dus aux conflits dans la région.</p><p>La majorité des Maliens ont traversé de multiples épisodes de conflits au cours de leur vie, depuis 1960, date à laquelle le pays a gagné son indépendance sur la France. Le Mali a connu plusieurs gouvernements, y compris un régime militaire, depuis 1968 jusqu’au coup d’État de 1990, qui a mené à des élections présidentielles démocratiques ; trois présidents ont été successivement élus. Le pays est caractérisé par des tensions communautaires profondément enracinées, qui n’ont fait qu’intensifier les clivages politiques et culturels au sein de la population.</p><p>Les peuples Touaregs vivent principalement dans le Nord du pays. Leurs griefs contre le gouvernement du Mali remontent à plusieurs dizaines d’années, de même que leur désir d’indépendance. La plus récente série de rébellions dans le Nord a débuté en 2011, lorsque les Touaregs qui vivaient en Lybie sont revenus au Mali. A cette époque, des factions islamiques radicales alliées à Al-Qaïda se disputaient le contrôle des territoires et des routes commerciales traversant le Sahel.</p><p>L’offensive lancée par des groupes armés contre le Gouvernement en janvier 2012 et le coup d’État militaire qui a suivi ont précipité le pays dans la crise. Les militants islamistes ont pris des villes du Nord, et les ont maintenues pendant près d’une année sous une application stricte de la loi islamique. Ce n’est qu’après la défaite des militants contre la force d’intervention militaire française que le Gouvernement du Mali a regagné le contrôle du Nord. En 2013, le Conseil de sécurité des Nations Unies a créé la Mission multidimensionnelle intégrée des Nations Unies pour la stabilisation au Mali (la MINUSMA) afin d’aider les militaires maliens à conserver le contrôle des territoires du Centre et du Nord. Mais ces régions ont continué d’être le champ de bataille de diverses factions extrémistes islamistes et d’autres groupes armés cherchant à faire la preuve de leur puissance, comme lors du siège de Kidal en 2014.</p><p>De nouvelles séries de négociations pour un accord de paix ont réussi à rassembler le Gouvernement et des organisations de groupes armés (nommément la Coordination des mouvements de l’Azawad et la Plateforme des groupes armés). Les dispositions de l’accord proposé comprenaient un ensemble de mesures pour la justice et la réconciliation. Ceci était important car, au moment des négociations, le Mali n’avait connu que très peu de progrès en matière d’enquêtes et de poursuites d’auteurs de crimes graves, malgré les demandes des organismes représentant les victimes. La Cour pénale internationale (CPI) est aussi intervenue, de manière limitée et focalisée au Mali à la suite de la crise de 2012 (la CPI a condamné Ahmad Al Faqi Al Mahdi pour son rôle dans les attaques contre des bâtiments religieux et des monuments historiques). Lors de consultations organisées dans le cadre des négociations de paix, il a été décidé qu’il fallait au Mali un véritable processus — un processus conduit par les Maliens — qui lui permette d’effectuer le traitement de son passé de violence.</p><p>L’Accord pour la paix et la réconciliation au Mali a été signé en mai et en juin 2015. Aux chapitres de la justice et de la réconciliation, il visait à mettre fin à l’impunité et à promouvoir une véritable réconciliation nationale et prévoyait la mise en place d’une commission de vérité. Investie de la mission de contribuer à l’instauration d’une paix durable à travers la recherche de la vérité, la réconciliation et la consolidation de l’unité nationale et des valeurs démocratiques, l’actuelle Commission Vérité, Justice et Réconciliation du Mali (CVJR) était née.</p><p>—</p><p>Depuis les années 80, une cinquantaine de commissions pour la vérité ont été créées à travers le monde dans l’intention de lutter contre la violence généralisée ou le traumatisme social. La plus reconnaissable de ces commissions a été la Commission Vérité et Réconciliation d’Afrique du Sud, et aujourd’hui des commissions pour la vérité ont été établies dans des pays aussi divers que le Canada, le Pérou, la Tunisie, la Côte d’Ivoire et le Népal, avec des résultats mixtes. Les commissions pour la vérité sont considérées comme la pierre angulaire d’une justice de transition, dans le cadre d’un ensemble de mesures destinées à traiter des violations massives des droits de l’homme du passé.</p><p>Pour de nombreux pays qui se relèvent après un conflit ou une période de dictature, l’usage de commissions pour la vérité est parfois affecté par la nature limitée des procès pénaux : après la violence des conflits, poursuivre chaque personne pour ses crimes peut non seulement s’avérer décourageant d’un point de vue logistique, mais peut également être perçu comme mettant en danger les efforts de reconstruction — spécialement lorsqu’une portion significative de la population a pris part aux hostilités. Si elle est conduite au moyen d’une approche centrée sur les victimes, une commission de vérité peut offrir une voix aux survivants et permettre aux autorités de reconnaître les abus du passé.</p><p>La Commission de vérité au Mali est ambitieuse : la CVJR a pour mandat d’enquêter et d’établir la vérité sur les violations des droits de l’homme ou les atteintes à la mémoire et au patrimoine culturel perpétrés depuis les années 60. On s’attend également à ce qu’elle propose des remèdes aux crimes commis, qu’elle crée des conditions pour faciliter le retour et la réinsertion sociale des réfugiés et personnes déplacées, favorise le dialogue et la coexistence pacifique entre les communautés et avec le Gouvernement, promeuve l’État de droit et propose des approches afin de prévenir les conflits. La CVJR est composée de vingt-cinq membres hommes et femmes, représentant les dix régions du pays et la pleine diversité des ethnies, groupes religieux et partis politiques du Mali. Les Commissaires dirigent les travaux de cinq sous-commissions : recherche de la vérité ; soutien aux victimes et réparations ; études, rapports et documentation ; sensibilisation et réconciliation ; et genre. Outre son siège à Bamako, la CVJR étend sa représentation au moyen de bureaux régionaux dans tout le pays, y compris à Mopti, Ségou, Tombouctou, Gao, et, lorsque cela sera possible en toute sécurité, un bureau doit être ouvert à Kidal.</p><p>Alors qu’elle entreprend d’organiser son approche, la CVJR dispose de décennies de documentation existante sur les droits de l’homme, réalisée par l’ONU et par d’autres. Avec l’aide d’exercices de cartographies supplémentaires, la CVJR a toute une litanie de crimes à prendre en considération : exécutions sommaires et assassinats extrajudiciaires, disparitions forcées, tortures et mauvais traitements, violations de la liberté d’expression, violences sexuelles et graves violations envers les enfants.</p><p>L’une des premières choses que la CVJR a dû entreprendre est de commencer à rassembler les déclarations des victimes. À l’aide de ses équipes régionales, un appel a été lancé à tous les Maliens, les invitant à apporter un témoignage officiel à la Commission. La réponse à cet appel a été massive : en juillet 2017, 4 466 dépositions (dont 2 837 dépositions provenant de femmes et 19 provenant d’enfants) ont été collectées par la CVJR.</p><p>Lorsque le personnel de la Commission a commencé à saisir les dépositions dans la base de données, des incohérences sont apparues et il est bientôt devenu évident que les informations collectées n’étaient pas toutes exactes. On peut supposer que cela est dû aux attentes des victimes d’une compensation financière qui pourrait leur être versée par le Gouvernement en cas de participation.</p><p>La CVJR savait que la perception d’informations falsifiées menaçait de porter atteinte à la légitimité de son travail. Mais avec un temps et des ressources limités, il n’était pas question de revenir en arrière. Comment la Commission allait-elle pouvoir réussir à rassembler les récits des victimes ?</p><p>Possédant une expertise nationale limitée, la CVJR s’est adressée aux acteurs internationaux qui la soutiennent, notamment la Suisse, qui a mobilisé la branche opérationnelle de <a href="http://www.justicerapidresponse.org/"><em>Justice Rapid Response</em> </a>(JRR) de Genève, en Suisse. Cette organisation gère un <em>roster</em> (vivier) permanent d’experts, composé de plus de 650 personnes de par le monde, qui sont spécialisés dans des domaines tels que les enquêtes internationales, les poursuites et le travail technique lié aux mécanismes de justice transitionnelle comme les commissions de vérité. Après une étroite consultation avec la direction de la CVJR, un expert en justice transitionnelle a été sélectionné sur le <em>roster</em> du JRR et invité au Mali. Quelques semaines plus tard, en mai 2017, Hernando Caceres de Bogota, en Colombie, est arrivé à Bamako et s’est mis au travail.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Hx9A6bI4iozS-Ggj.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Un piéton marche le long de la route de Koulouba (JRR)</em></figcaption></figure><p>PARTIE II</p><p>Le siège de la CVJR se trouve dans le quartier de Koulouba, situé au sommet d’une colline luxuriante surplombant Bamako. Pour y accéder depuis le centre-ville de Bamako, il faut traverser un labyrinthe de rues, dont quelques-unes seulement sont pavées. À Bamako, la vie de tous les jours se déroule à l’extérieur. La ville est construite sur une terre rouge et desséchée, qui recouvre d’une poussière rouge les vêtements et les animaux, et tourbillonne sous l’impulsion du flux constant des motos. Dès le petit jour, l’air est déjà chaud, les rues sont pleines de monde et le marché bourdonne de couleurs et d’activité. Des femmes portant des pagnes aux motifs colorés vendent des aubergines, des citrons verts et des tomates sur des bâches en plastique. Les hommes se rassemblent devant des échoppes de barbier improvisés, des chèvres se regroupent près de piles démesurées de pastèques. Les enfants déambulent en bandes, leur sac coloré sur le dos, ou jouent au football sous des panneaux publicitaires vantant des produits conditionnés de marques connues.</p><p>Dans la dernière montée vers Koulouba, les sinueuses routes pavées et les grands arbres offrent un répit bienvenu à qui arrive de la ville. La route en lacets serpente jusqu’à un vaste complexe de bâtiments gouvernementaux, gardés par un poste de contrôle militaire.</p><p>Au cours des six derniers mois, Hernando Caceres a fréquemment emprunté ce chemin pour se rendre à son bureau temporaire auprès de la CVJR. Hernando, 41 ans, est bronzé et élancé, avec une barbe soigneusement coupée. Vif et extraverti, il accueille avec un grand sourire les gens qu’il connaît (ce qui arrive souvent, même dans son chez-lui temporaire de Bamako).</p><p>Lorsqu’il est arrivé au Mali, Hernando a d’abord examiné l’étendue du problème que représentaient les déclarations falsifiées. Très tôt, il est apparu au travers de consultations intensives des membres de la Commission et de son personnel qu’il serait impossible à la CVJR d’enquêter sur la validité de chaque déposition. Même si la CVJR disposait du temps et des ressources pour cela (l’analyse de chaque déposition nécessitant pratiquement trois heures par document), Hernando savait que le procédé consistant à enquêter sur chaque histoire pouvait être néfaste, voire traumatisant pour les victimes.</p><p>Les sensibilités entourant le statut de victime sont une chose qu’Hernando connaît bien, et pas seulement du fait de son rôle d’expert technique. Ayant grandi à Bogota, en Colombie, Hernando et sa famille ont fait partie des victimes du conflit colombien. Son oncle a été kidnappé par le groupe rebelle FARC de Colombie, et on n’a plus jamais eu de ses nouvelles.</p><p>« J’ai vu comment les familles, les amis étaient affectés lorsque le pays est allé de mal en pis » dit Hernando. « Je savais que je devais faire partie de la réponse ».</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*QbL_uJSR4wKpKYDh.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Hernando Caceres au siège de la CVJR à Bamako (JRR)</em></figcaption></figure><p>Après avoir terminé l’université en Colombie, Hernando a continué son éducation en France, puis a commencé à travailler sur la dynamique post-conflit au Cambodge. Après un temps consacré à travailler sur les problèmes de droits de l’homme au Burundi, il est retourné en Colombie, où il est entré à la Commission nationale colombienne de réparation et de réconciliation (<em>Comisión Nacional de Reparación y Reconciliación</em> ou CNRR), un organe auquel revient la responsabilité de planter les premières graines de vérité et de réconciliation en Colombie, selon Hernando. Ensuite, il a travaillé au Programme de développement des Nations Unies sur des projets visant à favoriser la coexistence, la réconciliation et une réintégration basée sur la communauté des anciens combattants dans plus d’une dizaine de régions de Colombie. Plus tard, il s’est joint à la mission de maintien de la paix des Nations Unies en République démocratique du Congo, travaillant là aussi sur des questions de justice transitionnelle.</p><p>Mais c’est avec la CNRR en Colombie qu’Hernando a vu la véritable valeur du fait de connaître la vérité au sujet d’un passé douloureux : par le biais des travaux de la commission sur la vérité, Hernando et sa famille ont finalement appris, avec certitude, que son oncle avait été tué dans le conflit. Hernando a ainsi découvert personnellement à quel point le simple fait de connaître la vérité pouvait tout changer.</p><p>« Quand une personne est enlevée ou fait l’objet d’une disparition forcée, la vie s’arrête pour les siens », explique-t-il. « Normalement, quand quelqu’un meurt, vous allez au cimetière et vous savez qu’il est là et d’une certaine façon la vie continue. Mais quand vous ne savez pas ce qui est arrivé à quelqu’un que vous aimez, vous espérez que cette personne va revenir un jour, jour après jour. C’est à ce moment que j’ai compris que la vérité était le meilleur moyen pour offrir une réparation aux victimes. Parce que la vérité nous a réparé».</p><p>En tant qu’expert de justice transitionnelle qualifié, Hernando a été recruté par JRR et certifié au <em>roster</em> d’experts de JRR le rendant admissible à un déploiement à l’international auprès d’organismes recherchant l’expertise spécialisée de JRR. Plus tard, lorsque JRR l’a appelé avec une opportunité de déploiement au Mali, il a accepté tout de suite, se sentant prêt à partager sa propre expérience nationale avec un autre pays également affecté par un conflit.</p><p>Ce n’est que l’une des nombreuses raisons pour lesquelles Hernando ressent un grand sentiment de solidarité avec les Maliens lorsqu’ils abordent leur passé, et ici à la CVJR, il se sent en bonne compagnie : plusieurs des membres de la Commission et des employés de la CVJR sont des victimes du conflit eux-mêmes. Certains sont d’anciens combattants. Mais la mission de la CVJR les a réunis sous le même toit. Le fait de savoir qu’Hernando provient lui aussi d’un pays affecté par un conflit a fait une différence dans ses interactions au jour le jour avec la Commission et ils se sont rendu compte qu’ils partageaient bien plus que ce qu’ils ne pensaient. Par exemple, les deux conflits sur plusieurs générations en Colombie et au Mali sont exacerbés par le trafic de drogues. Qui plus est, Hernando fait remarquer que nombreuses drogues qui sortent en contrebande de la Colombie pour être expédiées à travers l’Atlantique jusqu’aux marchés européen et asiatique, passent directement à travers le Sahel.</p><p>« Être ressortissant d’un pays qui a subi un conflit interne m’a donné beaucoup de crédibilité ici au Mali », dit Hernando. « Nous parlons le même langage : celui de la souffrance. Mais aussi celui de la reconstruction ».</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*_SadoPQfFqBo4Wfq.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Hernando, dans son bureau, regarde à travers des dessins créés faits par des victimes du conflit (JRR)</em></figcaption></figure><p>Une approche centrée sur la victime plutôt qu’une investigation a été ce qu’Hernando a finalement proposé à la CVJR, une nouvelle méthode pour rassembler des déclarations pour la Commission : plutôt que de demander aux Maliens de faire des dépositions individuelles, la CVJR pourrait faciliter les consultations collectives, par lesquelles un groupe de victimes d’un incident spécifique pourraient ensemble reconstruire la vérité. Une méthodologie collective et représentative, qui a été mise en œuvre dans d’autres contextes de transition, permettrait aux victimes de recréer leur vérité ; une approche dans laquelle on ne leur demande pas de construire « la vérité » ou « une vérité », mais des vérités multiples et simultanées. Contrairement à ce que l’on pourrait imaginer, dit Hernando, le but d’une commission de vérité n’est pas de s’assurer que tout le monde se mette d’accord, mais plutôt de présenter le compte rendu de différentes perspectives à la société.</p><p>« La mémoire collective aide à surmonter les difficultés auxquelles la mémoire individuelle se heurte », dit Hernando. « Elle aide à recréer les évènements d’une façon plus précise que ne le ferait la mémoire individuelle. Par exemple : si je demande « que portiez-vous lundi dernier ? Vous en rappelez-vous ?</p><p>Bien sûr que non. Mais si je rassemble vos amis et vos collègues et que je le leur demande, ils finiraient probablement par y arriver, ensemble ».</p><p>La CVJR a approuvé cette nouvelle approche. Hernando, agissant comme éducateur et mentor, a d’abord travaillé avec les membres du personnel, parmi lesquels se trouvent des victimes du conflit, pour expliquer comment appliquer les méthodes collectives. L’une d’elles est appelée « cicatrices collectives ». Tout d’abord, on demande aux victimes de dessiner le contour de leur corps, ou de faire tracer ce contour en s’allongeant sur une grande feuille de papier. Puis à l’aide du dessin, le facilitateur commence à poser des questions sur les cicatrices, tant visibles qu’invisibles.</p><p>« Nous demandons d’abord aux participants de nous raconter ce qui leur est arrivé plus tôt dans leur vie, avant le conflit », dit Hernando. « Nous débutons par les cicatrices physiques du passé : peut-être que je me suis cassé le bras quand j’étais jeune ou que je me suis écorché le genou, donc je dessinerais cela. Puis, avec des méthodes spécifiques qui ne replacent pas les participants dans leur statut de victime, je leur demande de dessiner les cicatrices invisibles : je demande « était-ce difficile de grandir ? » ou « Est- ce qu’on t’a rudoyé à l’école ? », et à partir de là, nous arrivons finalement aux évènements du conflit. En tant que facilitateur, je sais que je veux arriver à la chose la plus dure à dire, le viol par exemple. Mais afin de leur permettre de parler du viol, ils doivent d’abord se sentir à l’aise en parlant au groupe de leurs cicatrices ».</p><p>Au total, Hernando a proposé cinq méthodologies collectives différentes pour reconstruire les vérités et les souvenirs des victimes et des anciens combattants. Dans le cadre de la transmission des méthodologies, on s’est heurté à certaines barrières culturelles. Par exemple, au Mali, si des aînés parlent dans un groupe, les autres, plus jeunes, ne les contredisent pas. La dynamique des genres est également problématique, et des questions telles que la violence sexuelle sont trop sensibles pour qu’on puisse en discuter dans une pièce où se trouvent à la fois des hommes et des femmes. Ensemble, le groupe a suggéré des solutions et adapté le cours des choses.</p><p>« J’ai clairement dit que je leur enseignerai ce que je savais, mais que c’était aux Maliens de l’adapter afin que cela marche pour eux » déclare Hernando fermement. « Ils ont déjà commencé à <em>Malianiser </em>la méthodologie. Elle leur appartient à présent ».</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Zz9BFqMkW_QYiAMG.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Le Commissaire Mohamed El Moctar Ag Mohamedoun à la porte du siège de la CVJR (JRR)</em></figcaption></figure><p>PART III</p><p>Lundi matin. Les commissaires et le personnel de la CVJR se réunissent pour leur assemblée plénière hebdomadaire. Dehors, le soleil chauffe déjà et tous les stores de la salle de conférence sont tirés. Hernando arrive le premier ; c’est sa dernière réunion avec la direction complète de la CVJR.</p><p>La salle se remplit progressivement d’hommes et de femmes, pour la plupart vêtus d’une tunique en coton bleu ciel ou blanche qui leur tombe jusqu’aux genoux ou aux chevilles. Hernando adresse à chacun un sourire et une poignée de main. Un brouhaha de salutations en français, bambara, tamasheq et arabe s’élève bientôt. Un simple « bonjour » ne suffit pas ici, où les retrouvailles quotidiennes tendent à s’éterniser. Des questions sincères fusent : « Comment vas-tu aujourd’hui ? », « Comment va la santé ? », « Et ta famille, comment va-t-elle ? ».</p><p>Un commissaire d’un certain âge entre en souriant. À la vue d’Hernando, il lève joyeusement les bras et s’écrit : « <em>Buenos días</em>, Hernando ! ». Les rires résonnent. Hernando rougit et affiche un large sourire.</p><p>Les vingt-cinq commissaires prennent place autour d’une longue table de conférence en bois. Hernando s’assoit près du mur, avec les observateurs représentant les agences des Nations Unies et les bailleurs de fonds européens de la Commission. La réunion commence et la salle se transforme en un panthéon des gardiens de ce processus. Dans cette atmosphère collégiale, on a parfois tendance à oublier les antagonismes qui opposent depuis des décennies les intérêts et les programmes des parties en présence : sur les vingt-cinq commissaires, neuf représentent des groupes armés.</p><p>Pendant presque toute la durée de la réunion, l’un des commissaires assis à la table reste immobile, observe et écoute attentivement. Lorsqu’il lève la main pour demander la parole, la salle se tait. Le Commissaire Mohamed El Moctar Ag Mohamedoun, un Touareg du Nord du Mali, représente la Coordination des Mouvement de l’Azawad au sein de la CVJR. Un chèche traditionnel enveloppe sa tête et couvre une grande partie de son visage. Malgré son air grave, il est visiblement l’un des plus jeunes commissaires.</p><p>Comme bon nombre des membres présents, Mohamed participe à la CVJR pour des raisons profondément personnelles. Il a grandi dans le Sahara et a vécu dans des camps de réfugiés avec sa famille. Il expliquera plus tard que sa famille ne possédait pratiquement rien. Sa voix est grave, ferme et résolue ; ses yeux, sombres et directs. La position qu’il adopte lorsqu’il s’exprime évoque celle d’un diplomate, les mains soigneusement croisées sur le bureau.</p><p>« Je connais le Mali du nord au sud », explique-t-il avec assurance. « Ma famille et moi avons été victimes toute notre vie. Je sais ce que les victimes du Mali ressentent, parce que j’en ai été une moi aussi. »</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*5bekdqjpk-41TWgJ.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Commissaire Mohamed El Moctar Ag Mohamedoun au siège de la CVJR (JRR)</em></figcaption></figure><p>Depuis plusieurs décennies, le peuple touareg se bat pour obtenir son autonomie politique et territoriale au Mali. En 1963 et ensuite pendant les années 1970 et 1990, des milliers de Touaregs sont partis chercher du travail et une vie meilleure en Arabie Saoudite, en Mauritanie, en Algérie et en Libye, où Mouammar Kadhafi les a accueillis et intégrés en grand nombre dans l’armée libyenne. Après la mort de Kadhafi, beaucoup ont regagné le Mali avec leurs armes, leur formation militaire et une nouvelle détermination.</p><p>Après avoir obtenu une bourse et étudié au Maroc, Mohamed est rentré vivre et travailler dans un camp de réfugiés en Mauritanie où il a effectué sa scolarité primaire, juste à temps pour voir émerger le Mouvement National de Libération de l’Azawad. Il a rejoint le MNLA et est devenu l’un des porte-paroles de la cause de l’Azawad. À la création de la CVJR, Mohamed a su qu’il voulait y participer, même si s’installer à Bamako l’éloignait de ses amis, de sa famille et de sa communauté.</p><p>« Au Mali, la justice n’a jamais été rendue et la vérité n’a jamais été dite », explique-t-il. « C’est pourquoi les conflits ressurgissent. Mais on ne peut pas rendre la justice pour des événements qu’on ne connaît pas. »</p><p>Avec les membres du personnel de la sous-commission recherche de la vérité de la CVJR, Mohamed a travaillé avec Hernando au quotidien. Il fait désormais partie de ceux chargés d’appliquer le nouveau modèle de consultations collectives, qu’il voit comme un moyen pour la CVJR de récolter plus rapidement un plus grand nombre de récits et de perspectives, dans le cadre d’une collaboration entre les victimes et la Commission.</p><p>« Hernando nous a beaucoup aidés. Il nous a exposé la stratégie d’investigation de base, le profil des investigateurs et différentes techniques de consultation collective des victimes », explique-t-il. « Nous avons, grâce à lui, commencé à mettre cette stratégie en place. »</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*5WPYqsmh8A_osNcU.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Colonel Major Haidara Aboucarine, Bamako (JRR)</em></figcaption></figure><p>PART IV</p><p>La méthodologie ayant été adaptée au contexte malien, la CVJR a pu l’appliquer auprès de la communauté. Après avoir longuement délibéré de tous les cas potentiels, la CVJR a annoncé que le premier groupe de victimes convoquées serait les survivants de l’attaque du gouvernorat de Kidal en 2014. Les victimes ont été identifiées et douze hommes se sont présentés auprès du bureau régional de Bamako pour procéder aux premières consultations collectives officielles.</p><p>Lorsqu’il a reçu son invitation à participer aux consultations avec la Commission, le Colonel Major Haidara Aboucarine a accepté sans hésitation. Les années qui s’étaient écoulées depuis sa survie aux évènements de Kidal l’avaient mis à rude épreuve. Ses blessures physiques avaient guéri, mais le combat psychologique avait été éprouvant, explique-t-il.</p><p>« Après le coup de fil de la CVJR, j’y suis allé pour raconter mon histoire », déclare Aboucarine. « Nous avons parlé au nom des absents. Nous avons parlé au nom des personnes tuées».</p><p>Le groupe s’est réuni pendant trois jours pour discuter les évènements de Kidal. Conformément aux attentes d’Hernando, ces discussions ont dévoilé une foule de nouveaux détails, reconstituant finalement le fil des évènements. Un homme s’est souvenu avoir été ligoté et avoir eu les yeux bandés dans la chaleur étouffante d’une pièce sans fenêtre. Beaucoup ont acquiescé, à l’exception d’un homme : il avait surpris et compris une conversation des gardes en tamasheq et se souvenait que l’un d’eux avait reçu l’instruction d’ouvrir l’une des fenêtres de la pièce pour donner un peu d’air aux prisonniers.</p><p>En travaillant de la sorte, les victimes se sont mutuellement aidées à faire resurgir le passé, en évoquant même les plus petits détails. Peu à peu, le groupe est ainsi parvenu à reconstituer les moindres détails de la journée du siège et avaient même dressé une grande carte de Kidal portant des indications sur le lieu des différents incidents.</p><p>En parlant des émotions ressenties le jour de la consultation, Aboucarine se souvient que les larmes avaient abondamment coulé. Mais des rires avaient aussi éclaté.</p><p>« Les gens se sont sentis libérés », explique-t-il. « Ils ont placé leur confiance dans la CVJR, et la CVJR va nous libérer. »</p><p>Les informations détaillées fournies au sujet des affrontements de Kidal seront saisies dans la base de données de la CVJR. Elles seront publiées tôt ou tard dans un rapport de la CVJR avec d’autres récits d’évènements majeurs survenus depuis 1960. Au vu du bon déroulement de la consultation initiale, le Président de la CVJR a annoncé peu après que les méthodologies collectives seraient adoptées pour toutes les consultations futures avec les victimes. L’étape suivante consistera à introduire cette méthode par le biais d’équipes itinérantes dans toutes les régions du Mali, y compris Ségou, Mopti, Tombouctou, Gao et Kidal.</p><p>Ayant été ceux qui ont adapté les méthodologies et mené la première consultation collective, le personnel du bureau régional de Bamako a été chargé de transmettre ces connaissances. L’antenne régionale de Bamako est installée dans une autre partie de la ville, loin de Koulouba où se trouve le siège de la Commission, pour être facilement accessible aux personnes désireuses de raconter leur histoire. Il s’agit d’un modeste bâtiment en béton plus proche d’une maison que d’un bureau, mais suffisamment grand pour accueillir les neuf personnes qui y travaillent.</p><p>À la tête de ce bureau se trouve Madame Diop Djènèba Mariko, une jeune femme bambara. Expressément recrutée pour diriger le bureau régional de Bamako, elle a commencé à travailler en août 2016 à la CVJR, dont elle parcourt les modestes locaux vêtue d’une longue jupe à rayures et d’une veste assortie, les cheveux soigneusement tirés en arrière. Avec son calme et sa discrète présence au sein du personnel qu’elle dirige, elle s’exprime avec une confiance posée et tout le monde l’écoute.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G-XD0yTcVX_R0QrR-mGDhw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Madame Diop Djènèba Mariko (JRR)</figcaption></figure><p>Depuis longtemps engagée dans la défense des droits de l’homme au Mali, elle a trouvé naturel d’entrer à la CVJR. Depuis des années, elle défend également les droits des femmes et des enfants et explique que les femmes ont été affectées de manière disproportionnée par les conséquences des conflits qui ont secoué le Mali : leur vie a été marquée par la perte des membres de leur famille, des déplacements massifs, des opportunités économiques limitées et des violences sexuelles. Elle espère que la vérité susceptible d’être révélée par la CVJR permettra au Mali de remédier à la situation des femmes qui ont tout perdu.</p><p>« J’ai vu des femmes bambaras souffrir sans pouvoir en parler », explique-t-elle, « c’est pourquoi j’ai commencé à travailler sur ces questions : pour leur donner la liberté de s’exprimer ».</p><p>Djènèba et son personnel reçoivent régulièrement des victimes venues raconter leur histoire à la CVJR. Certaines s’expriment avec facilité et fournissent des détails précis ; d’autres ont de grandes difficultés psychologiques à raconter leurs souvenirs. Elle explique que son personnel a fait le maximum</p><p>pour assurer aux victimes le soutien dont elles ont besoin et qu’il est désormais prêt à appliquer ces méthodes à un plus vaste groupe de victimes.</p><p>« Nous sommes reconnaissants envers JRR de nous avoir envoyé Hernando », dit-elle. Nous avons beaucoup appris et son aide nous a été infiniment précieuse. Les consultations collectives plutôt qu’individuelles nous permettent de rassembler davantage d’informations, qui de surcroît sont souvent plus détaillées que celles recueillies lors de consultations individuelles. Et grâce à ce que nous avons appris, notre bureau peut désormais proposer des formations aux autres sur les techniques de recherche de la vérité ».</p><p>À la fin de sa mission, en octobre 2017, Hernando passe au bureau de Bamako pour dire au revoir. Avec Djènèba, le groupe est installé sur des canapés en cuir au rez-de-chaussée et examine des dessins réalisés dans le cadre des consultations : chaque ligne tremblante délimite le corps d’un survivant et tous portent des indications de cicatrices multiples. Hernando les laisse parler, les écoute attentivement et hoche de temps en temps la tête pour les encourager.</p><p>Comme beaucoup d’autres personnes présentes, Djènèba soutient le principe d’un processus placé sous contrôle national plutôt qu’international. La participation de tous les Maliens — et Maliennes — sera la clef du succès de la CVJR.</p><p>« Au Mali, nous avons un proverbe… », commence-t-elle avec un sourire et en pesant chacun de ses mots, « qui dit : ‘le prisonnier est bien placé pour parler de la prison où il est détenu’ ».</p><p>Le groupe parvient ensuite à convaincre Hernando de se laisser prendre en photo avec eux devant la grande plaque en métal du bureau régional. Tous rient, échangent des poignées de main et insistent pour qu’Hernando revienne bientôt à Bamako.</p><p>Le groupe se dit au revoir alors que de l’autre côté de la rue s’étend une petite parcelle de terre envahie par les mauvaises herbes et flanquée de vétustes bâtiments en béton. La parcelle est vide, à l’exception d’un jeune arbre qui sort de terre en plein milieu : son tronc élancé y pousse haut et droit, tandis que ses feuilles d’un vert profond contrastent avec la couleur passée du béton sur lequel il se dessine. Cet arbre aurait presque l’air d’un mirage, d’une nouvelle source d’énergie jaillissant de la poussière rouge de Bamako, prêt à se déployer.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jQKBDDTj7a4Brgdk.jpg" /><figcaption><em>En face de l’antenne régionale du de la CVJR à Bamako (JRR)</em></figcaption></figure><p>EPILOGUE</p><p>C’est le dernier jour d’Hernando au Mali. Il est assis dans le verdoyant patio d’un café clôturé, le favori de la communauté internationale qui travaille à Bamako. À l’ombre des arbres et bercé par le chant des oiseaux, on a vite fait d’oublier les gros titres du jour : les acteurs internationaux cherchent à mobiliser autour des efforts de lutte contre le terrorisme déployés au Mali, dans le cadre de la nouvelle force conjointe G5 Sahel soutenue par la France, alors que de nouveaux décès de Casques bleus et de nouvelles menaces contre la sécurité des hôtels de Bamako sont annoncés.</p><p>Mais dans ce jardinet, le calme règne. Assis à une petite table, un café dans la main, Hernando est pensif. Ce soir-là, il repartira pour un très court séjour en Colombie (« assez longtemps pour faire ma lessive ! », confie-t-il en riant). Il serait ensuite envoyé vers une autre destination africaine encore tenue secrète, une autre zone affectée par un conflit requérant son expertise. Hernando a confiance dans le fait que le travail se poursuivra à Bamako bien après son départ. Interrogé sur le dernier conseil qu’il donnerait au personnel de la CVJR, il répond sans hésiter :</p><p>« Ayez confiance en vous. Vous avez déjà tout ce dont vous avez besoin ».</p><p>Et c’est peut-être là sa plus grande contribution : créer les capacités des Maliens au Mali. Rien de surprenant pour ceux qui le connaissent d’apprendre qu’il n’aime pas être considéré comme un « expert ».</p><p>« Les experts créent la dépendance », estime-t-il. « Dans certains cas, ils font même des dégâts : ils viennent, rédigent un rapport, repartent et rien ne reste derrière eux. Nous en avons beaucoup souffert, en Colombie… des gens sont venus de diverses parties du monde, puis sont repartis ».</p><p>Au Mali, heureusement, la CVJR dispose des instruments dont elle a besoin pour rassembler les victimes et recueillir la vérité grâce à une « méthode Malianisée » qui lui appartient exclusivement. La CVJR n’est que le point de départ de l’itinéraire qui permettra au pays d’affronter son passé, mais elle lui offre également l’occasion de s’approprier sa propre histoire et, avec le temps, peut-être aussi son avenir.</p><p>Hernando imagine déjà le moment où ce seront les Maliens qui partageront leur expérience avec d’autres pays ayant souffert d’un conflit et désireux d’apprendre au contact des « experts ». En attendant, un groupe d’improbables alliés maliens s’est remonté les manches pour passer au crible les ombres du passé, avec constance, alors que la poussière rouge continue de retomber.</p><p>— —</p><p><strong><em>Remerciements :</em></strong></p><p><em>JRR souhaite remercier la CVJR de l’avoir reçu au Mali pour l’élaboration du présent article, ainsi que toutes les personnes interviewées.</em></p><p><em>Cet article ainsi que la mission de Hernando Caceres n’auraient pas été possibles sans le soutien du Département fédéral des affaires étrangères de Suisse.</em></p><p><em>Plus d’informations sur le travail mené par JRR pour </em><a href="http://www.justicerapidresponse.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/JRR-Complementarity-Factsheet-2017-FR.pdf"><em>aider les juridictions nationales à établir les responsabilités de crimes graves</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><em>Plus d’informations sur </em><a href="https://www.eda.admin.ch/eda/en/home/foreign-policy/human-rights/peace/dealing-with-past.html"><em>l’engagement de la Suisse en faveur du traitement du passé</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://www.justicerapidresponse.org/when-the-red-dust-settles-fr/"><em>www.justicerapidresponse.org</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a54eb71362bd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[As the Red Dust Settles]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@_JRR/as-the-red-dust-settles-ae3c2b9a97d7?source=rss-a6dc946d96e7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ae3c2b9a97d7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transitional-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[accountability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[africa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mali]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justice Rapid Response]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Mar 2018 14:42:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-03T16:04:09.223Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>As the Red Dust Settles: Mali Confronts the Truth about a Legacy of War</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*veJ09gij2tSVigNR.jpg" /></figure><h3>When Mali created a truth commission to address decades of conflict, it soon required specialized expertise. Working together with a JRR expert, the truth commission now has the tools it needs to bring together victims and gather truth, with method that is uniquely their own.</h3><p><em>Text and photographs by </em><a href="https://twitter.com/_hannahdunphy"><em>Hannah Dunphy</em></a><em>, JRR</em></p><p>On the night before he was to travel to Kidal, Colonel Major Haidara Aboucarine awoke suddenly from a bad dream.</p><p>It was May 2014, and Aboucarine was working as an officer for the government of Mali. At the time, the north of the country was contested by Touaregs belonging to the National Movement for the Liberation of Azawad (MNLA) and other groups fighting for independence in northern Mali. In the town of Kidal, a stronghold of these groups, the situation was tense in anticipation of a visit from Mali’s Prime Minister. Aboucarine had been summoned personally by the Governor of Kidal to lend his assistance.</p><p>Aboucarine’s nightmare had been vivid, and given the ongoing violence in the north, others may have interpreted it as a bad omen. But Aboucarine — a devout Muslim and deeply spiritual man — was not one to be easily shaken. After praying for a short while, he returned to bed.</p><p>“I am an optimist,” he later recalled. “I never thought they would take Kidal.”</p><p>Days later, Aboucarine was on hand when Prime Minister Moussa Mara arrived in Kidal. It was then that several armed groups began an attempt to seize the town: men on trucks stormed the governor’s office, killing workers in their path. In the midst of the chaos, Aboucarine fled with a group of others into a house. He crouched his tall, lanky frame behind a wooden table, holding his breath as the house was searched. He listened as others who had hid were either taken away or shot. Hours later, Aboucarine too was discovered.</p><p>“The first man gave me water, but the second beat me,” he said. “They beat me on the head until I fell to the ground.”</p><p>Outside the house, his captors covered his head and shoved him into a truck with several others. The group was taken to a second location where they were packed into a small, hot room. With their hands bound, they were forced to lie on their stomach. In addition to the wounds aching on his head, Aboucarine broke his clavicle as a result of the rough treatment. They were held for nearly two days.</p><p>“They treated us really harshly,” said Aboucarine. “It was so hot in the room, it felt like there weren’t any windows. Some of us were ready to die. And some among us did.”</p><p>It was later revealed that the armed groups seized the Governor’s office, causing the Malian military forces to retreat, leaving the town under control of the militants. Haidara survived, but many did not: eight civilians, including six civil servants, <a href="https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2015/country-chapters/mali">were summarily executed</a> by the armed groups.</p><p>The May 2014 events in Kidal made headlines around the world, yet it was only one incident in a long history of conflict in Mali that has commanded international attention, including a major coup in 2012, and before that, decades of uprisings, tensions and violence involving several communities, and gross human rights violations. Today, nearly four years later, only a tenuous peace agreement prevents Mali from splitting wide open again. Several Islamic extremist groups have regained strength, and drug trafficking and transnational crime through the Sahel makes security unpredictable. Restaurants and hotels frequented by foreigners have been attacked repeatedly, as have military checkpoints and UN vehicles.</p><p>Midst ever-increasing militarization, Malian human rights organizations remain concerned with the lack of security for civilians, where daily life continues to be disrupted by closure of schools and limited access to fields and jobs. A major UN peacekeeping force has been put in place, but near constant instability has made its mission in Mali the <a href="http://www.washingtonpost.com/sf/world/2017/02/17/the-worlds-deadliest-u-n-peacekeeping-mission/?utm_term=.b7c2efa73f9f">most deadly of all UN peacekeeping missions</a> in the world. Citing the deteriorating humanitarian and human rights situation, the UN <a href="http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=58466#.WmfHYK6nEdU">recently described</a> the situation in Mali as “a race against time.”</p><p>It is in this tense atmosphere that a group of Malians have set out to achieve the unthinkable: bring splintered communities of Mali together for a national effort of truth and reconciliation. The Truth, Justice and Reconciliation Commission of Mali is tasked with establishing the truth about Mali’s ongoing relapses into conflict since it gained its independence in 1960. An outcome of a peace agreement, the Commission is led by commissioners who represent each of the numerous different political, ethnic, and religious groups in the country.</p><p>For victims like Aboucarine who have grown tired of impunity for crimes such as those in Kidal, the Commission represents a new hope. But with ongoing violence in the country and significant challenges blocking the road to peace, the question remains: will the truth commission be able to heal the wounds of Mali?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*j-1bDrqHJk3-P-cm.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Streets of Bamako, Mali</em></figcaption></figure><p>PART I</p><p>Mali is large, land-locked country in West Africa and central Sahel. Huge swaths of desert comprise most of its northern territories, which reach deep into the Sahara Desert and share long borders with Mauritania, Algeria and Niger. Majority Muslim, Mali has produced dozens of Afro-pop stars like Salif Keita, and is famous for signature sounds of <em>kora</em> masters like Toumani Diabaté and Ali Farka Touré. Bamako, the capital city, is built along the southern banks of the Niger River, and has experienced a population surge in the past decade, including due to displacement by conflict in the region.</p><p>The majority of Malians have seen multiple chapters of conflict throughout their lifetime, dating back to 1960, when the country gained its independence from France. A military-led regime ruled Mali from 1968 until a coup in 1990, leading to elections of three successive presidents. There have been deep-rooted tensions between communities in Mali, which have only intensified the many political and cultural differences in the population.</p><p>The Touareg peoples reside mainly in the north of the country. Their grievances against the Government of Mali go back decades, as does their desire for independence. The most recent series of rebellions in the north began in 2011, when Touaregs who had been living in Libya returned to Mali; at the time, Islamic radical factions aligned with al-Qaeda were vying for control over territory and trade routes through the Sahel.</p><p>In January 2012, armed groups launched an offensive against the Government, and the military coup that followed threw the country into crisis. Islamic militants seized cities in the north, controlling them for almost a year under strict Islamic law. Only after a military intervention by the French did the Malian Government regain control of the north. In 2013, the UN Security Council established the UN Multidimensional Integrated Stabilization Mission in Mali (MINUSMA) to help the Malian military maintain control of the central and northern territories. Yet these regions of Mali continued to be the battleground for various factions of Islamic extremists and other armed groups seeking to demonstrate their strength, including the siege of Kidal in 2014.</p><p>New rounds of negotiations for a peace agreement successfully brought together the Government and organizations of armed groups (known as the Coordination of Azawad Movements and the Platform of Armed Groups). Provisions in the proposed agreement included a set of measures for justice and reconciliation. These were significant, because at the time of the negotiations, Mali had seen little progress to investigate and prosecute perpetrators of serious crimes, despite demands from victims’ organizations. The International Criminal Court (ICC) had also been active in Mali following the 2012 crisis, but its role has been limited (the <a href="https://www.icc-cpi.int/pages/item.aspx?name=pr1242">ICC convicted</a> Ahmad Al Faqi Al Mahdi for his role in attacks against religious buildings and historic monuments). Through consultations in the peace negotiations, it was decided that Mali needed a process — a Malian-owned process — through which to address its legacy of violence.</p><p>The Agreement for Peace and Reconciliation in Mali was signed in May and June 2015. On justice and reconciliation, the agreement aimed to “prevent impunity and promote genuine national reconciliation” and included the implementation of the truth commission. With a mission to promote “lasting peace through the research of the truth, reconciliation and the consolidation of national unity and democratic values”, the current Commission Vérité, Justice et Réconciliation du Mali (CVJR) was born.</p><p>— — —</p><p>Since the 1980’s, some 50 truth commissions have been created around the world with the intention of confronting widespread violence or societal trauma. The most recognizable of these is the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission, and today, truth commissions have been set up in countries as diverse as Canada, Peru, Tunisia, Cote d’Ivoire, and Nepal, with mixed results. Truth commissions are considered a cornerstone of transitional justice; part of a set of measures meant to address massive human rights violations of the past. For many post-conflict or post-authoritarian countries, the use of truth commissions sometimes has to do with the limited nature of criminal trials: after conflict violence, prosecuting every last person for their crimes can not only be daunting logistically, but can be perceived to risk efforts of social reconstruction — especially when a significant portion of the population has participated in hostilities. When conducted with a victim-centered approached, a truth commission can offer voice to survivors and acknowledgement from authorities about abuses of the past.</p><p>The truth commission in Mali is ambitious. The mandate of the CVJR is to investigate and establish the truth about human rights violations or infringement on memory and cultural heritage spanning back to 1960. It is also expected to: propose remedies for crimes committed; create conditions to facilitate the return and reintegration of refugees and displaced persons; promote dialogue and peaceful coexistence between communities and with the Government; promote rule of law, and propose approaches to conflict prevention. The CVJR has no less than 25 commissioners, women and men representing the ten regions of the country and the full diversity of Malian ethnicities, religious groups, and political parties. Commissioners lead the work of five subcommittees: truth-seeking; victim support and reparation; studies, reports and documentation; awareness-raising and reconciliation; and gender. In addition to its headquarters in Bamako, the CVJR has expanded its presence by way of regional offices throughout the country, including in Mopti, Segou, Timbuktu, Gao and — when security allows it — an office will be opened in Kidal.</p><p>As it set out to organize its approach, the CVJR had access to decades of existing human rights documentation conducted by the UN and others. With the help of additional mapping exercises, the CVJR soon had a litany of crimes to consider: summary executions and extrajudicial killings; enforced disappearances; torture and ill-treatment; violations of freedom of expression; sexual violence, and grave violations against children.</p><p>To hear personal accounts of these incidents, one of the first things the CVJR set out to do was to begin gathering statements from victims. With help from its regional teams, a call was sent out to all Malians, inviting them to provide an official statement to the Commission. The response to their call was huge: by July 2017, 4,466 depositions (including 2,837 from women and 19 from children) <a href="http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Countries/ML/RapportKidal_Dec2015.pdf">had been collected</a> by the CVJR.</p><p>When the Commission’s staff began to input the statements into its database, however, inconsistencies appeared, and it soon became clear that not all of the information that had been collected was accurate. It’s speculated that this may have been due to victims’ expectations that their participation would secure financial compensation from the Government.</p><p>The CVJR knew that the perception of falsified information threatened to undermine the legitimacy of its work. But with limited time or resources, going backwards was not an option. How was the CVJR going to successfully gather victims’ stories?</p><p>With limited expertise in-country, the CVJR turned to its international supporters for advice, and Switzerland soon reached out to the operations arm of <a href="http://www.justicerapidresponse.org/">Justice Rapid Response</a> (JRR) in Geneva. The organization manages a standing roster of experts, more than 650 individuals from around the world, who specialize in areas such as international investigations, prosecutions, and technical workings of transitional justice measures like truth commissions. After close consultations with the leadership of the CVJR, a transitional justice expert from the JRR roster was identified by the CVJR and invited to Mali. Weeks later, in May 2017, Hernando Caceres of Bogotá, Colombia arrived in Bamako and got to work.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*302rzWzC0faxs8GW.jpg" /><figcaption><em>A pedestrian walks along the road to Koulouba.</em></figcaption></figure><p>PART II</p><p>The headquarters of the CVJR is in an area called Koulouba, which sits atop a lush hill overlooking Bamako. To reach it from Bamako city center requires travel through a maze of streets — some of which are paved, most of which are not. In Bamako, daily life unfolds outdoors. The city sits on earth that is a bold and burnt red, producing a dry dust that covers clothes and animals, and billows out behind the constant stream of motorcycles. From very early morning the air is already warm, the roads already thronged, and the markets abuzz with color and activity. Women in brightly patterned skirts sell eggplants, limes, and tomatoes displayed on plastic tarps. Men gather at makeshift barber stations, and goats cluster next to towering piles of green watermelons. Children walk together with colored backpacks, or play games of soccer under billboards advertising packaged, brand-name products. In the final ascent towards Koulouba, the paved winding roads and overgrown trees are a welcome respite from the city. Snaking switchbacks lead to a large complex of government buildings, guarded by a military checkpoint.</p><p>Frequently in the past six months, Hernando Caceres has made this daily journey to reach his temporary office at the CVJR. Hernando, 41, is tan and slender, with a neatly trimmed beard. Alert and extroverted, he is quick to flash a wide grin when seeing someone he knows (which, even in his temporary home of Bamako, happens often).</p><p>When he first arrived in Mali, Hernando examined the problem of the inconsistencies in the victim statements. Early on, through consultations with the Commissioners and their staff, it became clear that it would be impossible for the CVJR to investigate the validity of each deposition. Even if the CVJR had the time and resources (analysis of each deposition took staff nearly three hours per document), Hernando knew that the process of investigating each story could be potentially harmful — even re-traumatizing — to victims.</p><p>The sensitivities around victimhood is something Hernando knows a lot about, and not only through his role as a technical expert. Growing up in Bogotá, Colombia, Hernando and his family were victims of the Colombian conflict. His uncle had been kidnapped by the FARC rebel group and was never heard from again.</p><p>“I saw how families, friends were affected when the country was going from bad to worse,” says Hernando. “I knew I needed to be part of the answer.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*bpXF-xWloclPuHvq.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Hernando Caceres at the headquarters of the CVJR in Bamako (JRR)</em></figcaption></figure><p>After finishing university in Colombia, Hernando continued his education in France, and then went on to work on post-conflict dynamics in Cambodia. He worked on human rights issues in Burundi, and later returned to Colombia, where he joined the National Commission of Reparation and Reconciliation (Comisión Nacional de Reparación y Reconciliación, or CNRR), a body he says is responsible for planting some of the first seeds of truth and reconciliation in Colombia. Hernando also worked with the UN Development Programme on projects to foster coexistence, reconciliation, and community-based reintegration of former combatants in over a dozen regions of Colombia. Later, he joined the UN Peacekeeping mission in DR Congo where he also worked on transitional justice issues.</p><p>It was with the CNRR in Colombia, however, that Hernando saw the real value of knowing the truth about a painful past: through the work the truth commission, Hernando and his family finally learned for certain that his uncle had been killed in the conflict. It showed Hernando firsthand how simply knowing the truth about what happened can change everything.</p><p>“When a person is kidnapped or forcedly disappeared, life doesn’t continue for his or her relatives,” he explains. “Normally when somebody dies, you go to the cemetery and you know they are there, and life continues somehow. But when you don’t know what happened to your loved one, you expect them to come home any day, every day. That’s when I understood that truth is the best way to repair victims. Because the truth repaired us.”</p><p>As a skilled expert in transitional justice, Hernando was recruited by JRR and certified to its expert roster, becoming eligible for international deployment to bodies that come to JRR looking for specialized expertise. Later, when JRR called with an offer to deploy to Mali, he accepted at once, ready to share more comparative knowledge with a conflict-affected country.</p><p>This is just one of the many ways Hernando feels a great sense of solidarity with Malians as they address their past, and here at the CVJR, he finds himself in good company: several of the commissioners and CVJR employees are victims of conflict themselves. Some are former combatants. But the mission of the CVJR has brought them under the same roof. Knowing Hernando is also from a conflict-affected country has made a difference in his day-to-day interactions with the Commission, and they have found they share more than they thought. For example, both multi-generational conflicts in Colombia and Mali are exacerbated by illegal drug trades. What’s more, Hernando explains, is that many drugs smuggled out of Colombia and shipped across the Atlantic are moved directly through the Sahel — including through Mali — in order to reach European and Asian markets.</p><p>“Being from a country that has suffered an internal conflict gave me a lot of credibility here in Mali,” says Hernando. “We speak the same language: the language of suffering. But also, of reconstruction.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*UDZgW_7x5kaN7JkO.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Hernando, in his office, looks through drawings created by victims of conflict (JRR)</em></figcaption></figure><p>A victim-centered approach, rather than investigative, was what Hernando eventually proposed to the CVJR: instead of asking for Malians to make individual statements, the CVJR would facilitate collective consultations, where a group of victims of a specific incident would reconstruct the truth together. A collective, representative methodology — which has been implemented in other transitional contexts — would allow victims to recreate their truth; not ask them to construct ‘<em>the</em> truth’ or ‘<em>a</em> truth’, but multiple truths at the same time. Counter to what some may assume, Hernando says a truth commission is not about agreeing but rather presenting a multitude of perspectives back to society.</p><p>“Collective memory helps overcome the challenges that individual memory has,” says Hernando. “It helps re-create events in a more precise way than individual memory. For example: if I ask you, ‘What did you wear last Monday?’ Do you remember? Of course not. But if I gathered your friends and co-workers and asked them, together we could probably figure it out.”</p><p>The CVJR agreed with the new approach. Hernando, acting as educator and mentor, first worked with staff members — some of them victims of conflict — to show how collective methodologies are facilitated. One of these is called “Collective Scars”. First, victims are asked to draw the outline of their body, or have it traced by laying down on a large piece of paper. Then, using the drawing, the facilitator starts asking questions about scars — both visible, and invisible.</p><p>“We first ask participants to tell us what happened to them early on in their life, before the conflict,” says Hernando. “We start with physical scars from the past–maybe I broke my arm when I was young, or scraped my knee, so I would draw that. Then, using specific methodologies that do not re-victimize participants, I ask them to draw invisible scars: I ask, ‘Was it hard growing up? Were you bullied at school?’ And then from there, we eventually go into events of the conflict. As a facilitator, I know that I want to arrive at the hardest thing to talk about — rape, for example. But in order for them to speak about rape, they first need to feel comfortable talking to the group about their scars.”</p><p>In total, Hernando offered five different collective methodologies to reconstruct truths and memories of victims and former combatants. As the CVJR staff learned the methodologies, they ran into some cultural challenges. For example, in Mali, when elders speak in a group, younger people do not contradict them. Gender dynamics were a challenge, too, where issues like sexual violence were too sensitive to discuss in a room with both men and women. Together, the group suggested solutions, and adjusted course.</p><p>“I was clear that I would teach what I knew, but then Malians would adapt it to make it work for them,” says Hernando firmly. “They have already started to ‘<em>Malian-ize’</em> the methodology. It’s theirs now.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*4ztsY9O-d9qSWMRs.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Commissioner Mohamed El Moctar Ag Mohamedoun at the gate of the CVJR headquarters (JRR)</em></figcaption></figure><p>PART III</p><p>It’s Monday morning and the CVJR commissioners and staff meet for their weekly plenary meeting. Outside, the sun is already hot, and the shades are drawn over all the windows of the conference room. Hernando is the first to arrive; it’s his last meeting with the full leadership of the CVJR.</p><p>Men and women begin to filter in. Most are dressed in stately sky blue or white cotton garb that reaches down to their knees or ankles. Hernando greets everyone with a smile and a handshake. It is soon a buzz of greetings in French, Bambara, Tamasheq and Arabic. Daily salutations go on extensively here, where a simple “Hello” doesn’t suffice. The room fills with earnest questions: “How are you feeling today?” “How is your health?” “And your family? How are they?”</p><p>One elderly commissioner enters the room with a smile; upon seeing Hernando, he raises both arms joyfully and bellows out “<em>Buenos días</em>, Hernando!” and laughter fills the room. Hernando blushes and grins from ear to ear.</p><p>The 25 commissioners sit at a long wooden conference table, and Hernando sits along the wall with observers representing UN agencies and European donors of the Commission. As the meeting begins, the room transforms into a pantheon for the guardians of this process. In the collegial atmosphere, one might momentarily forget that some of the interests and agenda of these groups have been at odds for decades: nine of the commissioners represent armed groups.</p><p>One commissioner at the table sits in stillness for most the meeting, watching and listening intently. When he does raise his hand to speak, the room falls into silence. Commissioner Mohamed El Moctar Ag Mohamedoun, a Touareg from the north of Mali, is the representative of the Coordination of Azawad Movements to the CVJR. He wears a traditional <em>chech</em> which wraps around his head and covers much of his face. Despite a serious demeanor, he is visibly one of the youngest amongst the commissioners.</p><p>Like many around the table, Mohamed’s reasons for participating in the CVJR are deeply personal. Growing up in the Sahara, Mohamed and his family lived in refugee camps. Later, speaking from his office, he says his family had almost nothing. Mohamed’s voices is deep, steady and resolute; his eyes, dark and direct. As he speaks, his poise is not unlike that of a diplomat, keeping his hands folded carefully on his desk as he speaks.</p><p>“I know Mali from the north to the south,” he says confidently. “My family and I were victims our whole lives. I know what the victims in Mali are feeling because I was a victim too.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*t1-Opht-m2haLDBR.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Commissioner Mohamed El Moctar Ag Mohamedoun at CVJR headquarters (JRR)</em></figcaption></figure><p>The Touareg people have struggled for decades to gain political and territorial autonomy in Mali. Seeking jobs and better livelihoods, in 1963 and then during the 1970s and 1990s, thousands moved to Saudi Arabia, Mauritania, Algeria as well as Libya, where Muammar Gaddafi welcomed them and integrated many into the Libyan army. After Gaddafi’s death, many in Libya left and returned to Mali, carrying with them weapons, military training, and new determination.</p><p>After earning a scholarship and studying in Morocco, Mohamed returned to live and work in refugee camps in Mauritania, where he attended primary school, just in time to see the National Movement for the Liberation of Azawad (MNLA — French acronym) emerge. He joined the MNLA, and soon became a spokesperson for the Azawad cause. Later, when the CVJR came into being, Mohamed knew he wanted to be a part of it, even though relocating to Bamako would bring him far away from his friends, family, and community.</p><p>“In Mali, justice has never has been done, and neither has truth,” he explains. “That’s why conflicts are coming back. But we cannot do justice to things we don’t know.”</p><p>With the staff members of the CVJR’s sub-commission on truth-seeking, Mohamed has worked with Hernando on a daily basis. He is now among the staff members who has been entrusted with the new model of collective consultations, which he sees as a way for the CVJR to collect more stories and perspectives in a shorter amount of time, and the process is a collaboration between victims and the Commission.</p><p>“Hernando has helped us a lot. He has showed us the essential strategy of investigations, investigator profiles, and different techniques of collective consultation with victims,” he says. “Through Hernando we have begun to put this strategy in place.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jerflT5CxH4aBYye.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Colonel Major Haidara Aboucarine, Bamako.</em></figcaption></figure><p>PART IV</p><p>With the methodologies adapted for the Mali context, it came time for the CVJR to bring it to the community. After careful deliberation over many potential cases, the CVJR announced that the first group of victims to be convened would be survivors of the May 2014 attack on Kidal. Victims were identified and 12 men came to the Bamako Regional office for the first official collective consultations.</p><p>When Colonel Major Haidara Aboucarine received the invitation to join the consultation with the Commission, he accepted without hesitation. The years since surviving Kidal had challenged him a lot. His physical wounds had healed, but he says he struggled psychologically.</p><p>“After the CVJR called me, I went and told my story,” said Aboucarine. “We spoke for those who were not there. We spoke for people who were killed.”</p><p>Working together for three days, the group talked through the events of the Kidal attack. Just as Hernando expected, many new details came to light. The group that had been captured with Aboucarine reconstructed what had happened. One man, remembering being bound and blindfolded in the stifling heat, said he was certain that the room had no windows. Many agreed. But one man did not: he had overheard the guards speaking with one another in the Tamasheq language — which the man understood — and recalled that the guard had been instructed to open one of the windows in the room, to give the prisoners some air.</p><p>Through conversations like this, victims helped each other bring the past into focus, no matter how small the details. The group slowly reconstructed every event of that day, even creating a large map of Kidal, with indications of where different incidents occurred.</p><p>Recounting the emotions of the reunion, Aboucarine says there were many tears. But there was also laughter.</p><p>“It freed people,” he said. “The people have put their trust in the CVJR, and the CVJR will set us free.”</p><p>The detail-rich information of the Kidal attacks will be entered into the CVJR database, eventually to be published in a CVJR report alongside other accounts of major events since 1960. Soon after the initial consultation was successfully held, CVJR President announced that the Commission would adopt the collective methodologies for all of its future consultations with victims. The next task would be to bring the methodology to all the regions of Mali, including in Ségou, Mopti, Timbuktu, Gao, and Kidal.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*6Q_4xuw72cg7GtXU.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Hernando displays a map of the events of the Kidal 2014 attacks, as created by victims through collective consultations</em></figcaption></figure><p>As the ones who had adapted the methodologies and completed the first collective consultation, it is the task of the staff of the Bamako regional office to help carry the knowledge forward. The Bamako office is in another part of the city, away from CVJR headquarters in Koulouba, so that it can be easily accessed by those who want to tell their story. The office is a sparse concrete building that feels more like a house than an office, room enough for the nine people who work there.</p><p>Heading the team is Ms. Diop Djènèba Mariko a young Bambara woman who began working at the CVJR in August 2016. At the modest office premises, her petite frame is dressed in a long striped skirt and matching jacket, and her hair is neatly pinned back. She has a quiet, unassuming presence amongst the staff she manages, but when she speaks, it’s with a relaxed confidence, and everyone listens.</p><p>A long-time human rights advocate in Mali, she sees the CVJR as a natural place for her to be. Over the years, she has also been a champion for the rights of women and children, and points to the differential impacts that the conflicts in Mali have had on women, such as widespread displacement, limited economic opportunity and sexual violence. Through the truth that the CVJR can reveal, she hopes Mali can offer remedies that respond to the situation of women who have lost everything.</p><p>“I saw how Bambara women were suffering, without any opportunity to speak,” she says. “This is why I began to work on these issues, for women’s freedom to express themselves.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*mGInnvQ5CxrHi-s1.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Ms. Diop Djènèba Mariko, head of CVJR Regional Office in Bamako</em></figcaption></figure><p>Djènèba and her staff have steadily received victims who have come to tell their story. Some speak comfortably and can provide great detail. Others have a lot of psychological difficulty relaying what they can remember. She says the staff had worked a lot to make sure victims receive the support they need. Now, the staff is ready to take the methodology forward to an even wider group of victims.</p><p>“We are thankful to JRR for sending Hernando to us,” she says. “We have learned many things, and it has helped us so much. Better than individual consultations, we can get more information, and that information is often even more detailed than what we get from only individual consultations. Because of what we have learned, our office can now offer training to others on truth-seeking techniques.”</p><p>In October 2017 as his mission came to end, one of Hernando’s last stops was here to the Bamako office to say goodbye. With Djènèba, the group gathers in a sitting room with leather couches, where they review drawings that had been created as part of the consultations — each shaky outline representing the body a survivor, and no outline without indications of multiple scars. Hernando lets them do most of the talking, listening intently, and at times providing nods of encouragement.</p><p>Like many others here, Djènèba is also supportive of the process being one that is nationally-owned, rather than international. Having all Malians participate — including women — will be how the CVJR will be a success.</p><p>“We have a saying in Mali,” she says, smiling, and with careful emphasis. “Which means, ‘The prisoner is well-placed to speak of the prison where he is held’.”</p><p>Later, Hernando is convinced to be in a group photo in front of the large metal sign for the regional office. There are handshakes and laughter, and insistent requests that Hernando return soon to Bamako.</p><p>As the group says their goodbyes, directly across the road is a small lot of land, overgrown with weeds, and flanked by dilapidated concrete buildings. The lot is mostly empty save for one young tree that stands in the very center, its slender trunk growing straight and tall, its leaves a rich green against the washed-out buildings behind it. The tree almost seems like a mirage, new energy emerging from the red dust of Bamako, ready to grow.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*vznJOtmsYih_AD-V.jpg" /></figure><p><em>A tree grows across from the CVJR Regional Office in Bamako</em></p><p>EPILOGUE</p><p>On his last day in Mali, Hernando sits on the garden patio at an enclosed café that is a favorite of internationals working in Bamako. Under the shade of trees and birdsong, it’s easy to forget the headlines of the day: international actors drum up support for counter-terror efforts in Mali as part of the new G5 Sahel Joint Force, more UN peacekeepers killed, and new security threats are reported against hotels in Bamako.</p><p>Sitting at a small table with a coffee in hand, Hernando is reflective. Later that night he would be returning to Colombia for a short time (“Long enough to do my laundry!” he says, laughing). He’d then return to an undisclosed location in Africa, another conflict-affected scenario where his expertise is needed. Hernando is more than confident that the work will carry on here in Bamako well after he leaves. When asked what his parting words would be to the staff of the CVJR, he answers without missing beat.</p><p>“Trust yourself. You already have everything you need.”</p><p>This perhaps has been Hernando’s most important contribution: creating capacity of Malians in Mali. It’s of no surprise to those who know him that he dislikes being referred to as an “expert”.</p><p>“Experts create dependency,” he says. “In some cases, experts do harm: they come, they write a report, and then they go, and nothing stays there. We suffered that a lot in Colombia — people came from different parts of the world, and then they left.”</p><p>Fortunately for Mali, the CVJR has the tools it needs to bring together victims and gather truth, with a “Malian-ized method” that is uniquely their own. The CVJR is just a start for country to face its past, but it is a chance to take charge of their own history, and, with time, perhaps their future, too. Hernando is already thinking about when it will be Malians who will be sharing their experience to other conflict-affected countries looking to learn from the “experts”. But for now, a group of unlikely allies in Mali are at work, steadily sifting through shadows of the past, as the red dust continues to settle.</p><p>—</p><p><strong>Acknowledgments</strong></p><p><em>JRR would like to thank the CVJR for receiving JRR in Mali for the production of this article and to all who were interviewed.</em></p><p><em>The work of Hernando Caceres with the CVJR and this article made possible with the generous support of the Federal Department of Foreign Affairs of Switzerland.</em></p><p><em>Additional photo editing provided by Esteban Hernandez.</em></p><p><em>Learn More about JRR’s work to assist national jurisdictions seek accountability for serious crimes </em><a href="http://bit.ly/2tK4WRR"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><em>Learn more about Switzerland’s commitment on Dealing with the Past </em><a href="https://www.eda.admin.ch/eda/en/home/foreign-policy/human-rights/peace/dealing-with-past.html"><em>here</em></a></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://www.justicerapidresponse.org/as-the-red-dust-settles/"><em>www.justicerapidresponse.org</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ae3c2b9a97d7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Investigating Conflict-related Crimes Involving Children]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@_JRR/investigating-conflict-related-crimes-involving-children-c57139d86e72?source=rss-a6dc946d96e7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c57139d86e72</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[children-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[investigation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[child-soldier]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[united-nations]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justice Rapid Response]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 12 Mar 2018 19:57:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-12T19:57:02.174Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ORhXOEleNqklORUA.jpg" /></figure><p>War turns children’s lives upside down. A sudden rise in instability can interrupt education, tear families and communities apart, and force children to witness horrific acts of violence. When conflict escalates, girls and boys are especially vulnerable: they can be forced to take active roles within conflicts as porters, spies, guards, human shields, suicide bombers, active combatants, and sex slaves. Grave abuses against children have occurred in conflicts as diverse as Colombia, Democratic Republic of Congo, South Sudan, Iraq, Yemen and Myanmar.</p><p>Today, on the <a href="https://childrenandarmedconflict.un.org/press-release/international-day-against-the-use-of-child-soldiers-2/">International Day against the Use of Child Soldiers</a>, the international community recalls the unique ways conflict affects children, and reaffirms its commitments to serve children’s well-being. International codification of responses to child recruitment and/or children’s involvement in serious crimes — such as the Paris Principles, the <a href="https://childrenandarmedconflict.un.org/mandate/opac/">Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights of the Child</a>, and the more recent <a href="http://international.gc.ca/world-monde/issues_development-enjeux_developpement/human_rights-droits_homme/principles-vancouver-principes.aspx?lang=eng">Vancouver Principles</a> — have helped governments, humanitarian organizations and the United Nations underscore the need for specialized approaches; for example, calling for the inclusion of child protection expertise in peacekeeping operations, identifying warning signs and take early action to end recruitment, and promote the reporting of abuses and grave violations against children in armed conflict.</p><p>Exposing patterns of crimes involving children can help to hold perpetrators accountable and ensure survivors’ access to justice. Like all serious conflict-related crimes, however, the process of documenting and investigating presents unique challenges. Investigators may have to work in conflict or post-conflict settings, including camps for displaced persons or refugees, where it remains difficult to access victims and survivors. There is often little time to conduct interviews, unpredictable changes in security, and a frequent lack of referral pathways for children and their families to access medical, psychosocial or witness protection services. All of these factors can prevent investigators from taking the necessary measures to ensure a “do no harm” approach towards children is taken.</p><p>Investigators must also know how to handle inevitable questions that arise when children are victims, and/or witnesses to conflict-related crimes: What kind of rights do children have in the justice process? To which extent can children be interviewed? Can they be considered a reliable source of information? How should investigations be conducted in order to avoid further trauma or other harm to the child? Many domestic justice systems have successfully addressed these questions; yet on the international level, less progress has been made. As a result, international teams sometimes lack adequate knowledge and resources to conduct safe, comprehensive investigations.</p><p>Fortunately, there is increasing recognition that for investigations of international crimes involving children, specialized expertise is needed to improve the professionalism, quality, and safety of such investigations. In response to the need for the international community to easily access the services of trained professionals in this area, JRR has specifically developed child-related expertise on its global stand-by roster. As part of the JRR roster recruitment process, in December 2017, JRR and the <a href="https://iici.global/">Institute for International Criminal Investigations</a> (IICI) held an <a href="http://www.justicerapidresponse.org/aicvic-announcement/">advanced course</a> on investigating crimes and violations involving children. The goal of the course was to examine the current state of investigations involving children in an international context, and address key questions relating to best practices and duty of care to be exercised in these investigations.</p><p>The course gathered experienced professionals both at domestic and at international level who have worked with children during their career: they included criminal investigators, human rights monitors, child protection officers, and child rights experts. Experts who successfully completed the course have now been certified to the JRR Expert Roster, and are eligible to deploy to support accountability efforts at the national and international level.</p><p>One participant in the JRR course was a Liberian child protection expert* who has worked in protection programming and peacekeeping operations for nearly two decades. In South Sudan, for example, he served as the focal point for the implementation of the UN-Sudan People Liberation Army (SPLA) Action Plan for releasing of all children associated with the armed forces and group from 2009 to 2015. He helped the SPLA Child Protection Unit and National Disarmament Demobilization and Reintegration Commission (DDR) carry out screening, interview, documentation and demobilization of children associated with the armed groups. After times of war, he explained, cultural knowledge of the society in question is a critical component of an expert’s successful engagement with children. In some African contexts, he saw how child protection experts such as himself must skillfully confront persistent myths about how to address reintegration of child combatants.</p><p>“Some indigenous people believed that children who are or were associated with armed groups must perform certain rituals for cleansing during the reintegration process,” he said.</p><p>Another participant in the JRR recruitment course was a child rights expert from Switzerland**, who has seen up close the transformative potential of offering justice to children. She explained that especially for older children, when investigations and interviews are done correctly, the possibility for justice can help those children recover from trauma they experienced. Yet in many contexts, opportunities are lost, because actors on the ground fear any engagement with children would only lead to further harm.</p><p>“There is fear of traumatization,” she said. “Also fear of being criticized for not taking the most appropriate measures, or fear of being accused of having contributed to harming the child.”</p><p>On this International Day against the Use of Child Soldiers, JRR calls upon all governments, civil society groups or others dealing with serious crimes involving children to always ensure individuals and investigatory bodies utilize dedicated expertise for this work. Such capacity is most efficiently attained through the utilization of specialized experts. Individuals on the JRR Expert Roster — including investigators, sexual violence experts, and witness and/or child protection experts — continue to be available for rapid deployment when and where they’re needed the most. Through the provision of this type of expertise, JRR works towards its vision: for conflict-related crimes involving children to be properly investigated and documented by qualified professionals who can always prioritize the well-being of children.</p><p><em>*Name withheld for security reasons</em></p><p><em>**Name withheld for security reasons</em></p><p><em>PHOTO: Zam Zam camp for Internally Displaced People (IDP), North Darfur, 2014 (Albert Gonzalez Farran, UNAMID)</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://www.justicerapidresponse.org/intl-day-end-child-soldiers-2018/"><em>www.justicerapidresponse.org</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c57139d86e72" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Opinion: The Importance of Professional Expertise in Gathering Evidence of Mass Atrocities]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@_JRR/professional-expertise-in-gathering-evidence-7e6d31e49552?source=rss-a6dc946d96e7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7e6d31e49552</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[international-security]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[investigation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[syria]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[united-nations]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justice Rapid Response]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 12 Mar 2018 19:54:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-12T19:54:10.498Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/590/0*UMww2ytnAP9kDJjk." /></figure><p><em>This article was originally published on </em><a href="https://www.justsecurity.org/46355/rules-govern-evidence-gathering-conflict-zones/"><em>Just Security</em></a><em> on 27 October, 2017</em></p><p><strong>By Andras Vamos-Goldman, Executive Director, JRR</strong></p><p>Justice for core international crimes committed in places like Syria is currently non-existent. Yet, should our frustration with this lack of accountability lead us to alter widely-accepted rule of law practices in seeking that accountability? This is the concern raised by Caroline Fehl and Eliska Mockova in <a href="https://www.hsfk.de/fileadmin/HSFK/hsfk_publikationen/Spotlight0517.pdf">“Chasing Justice for Syria,”</a> published by the Peace Research Institute Frankfurt. Their article asks the interesting question as to whether a paradigmatic shift is occurring, under which private-public documentation and evidence collection precedes and drives accountability mechanisms, particularly criminal tribunals. I think we should accept that this paradigm shift is occurring.</p><p>This then begs the question: How can documenters best ensure — prior to knowing what rules of procedure and evidence will govern the information they collect — that their actions do not cross fundamental lines that would render the fruits of their efforts inadmissible in a court of law? Normally, investigations that collect evidence take place under the rules of procedure and evidence of the accountability mechanism — such as an international or domestic court — that has jurisdiction over the situation. However, in the context of Syria, Iraq and elsewhere, documentation is being collected without the establishment of a criminal court or tribunal, and therefore without the benefit of such rules. What should guide those who are documenting serious crimes taking place amidst conflict, who hope that the information they gather will help hold those responsible to account? Equally important, what is the duty of care that they, and those who accept such information from others, must exercise to ensure that the most basic, fundamental rules pertaining to evidence collection are adhered to?</p><p>The challenge is this: There is no single, commonly accepted set of rules of procedure and evidence governing international or domestic criminal investigations. While the last few years have seen the creation of a number of manuals, guidelines and handbooks, most deal with a particular aspect of conflict-based crimes (some examples include: on <a href="https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/598335/International_Protocol_2017_2nd_Edition.pdf">sexual and gender based violence</a>; including <a href="https://iici.global/0.5/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/160229_IICI_InvestigationGuidelines_ConflictRelatedSGBVagainstMenBoys.pdf">against men and boys</a>; <a href="http://hhi.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/publications/handbook-hpcrweb.pdf">Commissions of Inquiry</a>; and <a href="https://www.vu.nl/nl/Images/PILPG_Handbook_on_Civil_Society_Documentation_of_Serious_Human_Rights_Violations_Sept_2016_tcm289-785328.pdf">civil society documentation of serious human rights violations</a>). Rules of procedure and evidence vary considerably between civil and common law national jurisdictions, between national and international courts, and even among international courts. Thus, those documenting serious human rights and international criminal law violations in Syria, Iraq and elsewhere in the absence of a criminal tribunal or court are operating without specific guidance on what will make their information directly useful to any future accountability mechanism. This important aspect of accountability has not gotten much attention from countries, including from the <a href="https://www.justsecurity.org/43213/u-s-office-global-criminal-justice-chopping-block/">United States</a>, when supporting documentation and investigations. Zachary Kaufman’s timely and balanced <a href="https://www.justsecurity.org/45411/expect-team-investigating-isis-atrocities-iraq/">piece in Just Security</a> on UNSC 2379, while touching directly on the “use of evidence,” does not include this issue of collection in the absence of rules of evidence, among the otherwise comprehensive list of questions this resolution raises for international justice.</p><p>That said, there are some tenets that appear to be broadly accepted in practice. For example, there seem to be two clear situations when even the generally more open international tribunals would not consider some piece of information or evidence. One is if the information (and I would argue also the way it was obtained or handled) casts substantial doubt on its reliability as evidence. The other is if its admission would, for some reason, be antithetical to, and seriously damage the integrity of the accountability proceedings. In other words, there are acts and omissions that, even in the absence of rules of procedure and evidence, should put documenters and those accepting the documented information on notice. These include: obtaining information through torture, the fabrication of information, and obtaining information without regard to the danger that its collection poses to victims, witnesses, survivors and those collecting the information — the “do no harm” principle.</p><p>In the absence of clearly defined rules and standards, what is collected and how, and what duty of care is exercised comes down to the judgement of those collecting, or accepting information from documenters. The more expert, professional and experienced the people involved, the more likely that they will ask the relevant questions about when the information is collected or passed. The more these professionals understand working under international human rights and criminal justice norms and international conditions, the more likely they will be able to balance the probative value of information against the potential cost of harming witnesses and survivors. And if they also have a cultural, linguistic and legal affinity to the place and people where the alleged crimes have taken place — giving them a contextual understanding — that judgement will be even better.</p><p>In these shifting times, when evidence collection is increasingly preceding the establishment of specific rules of procedure and evidence, it is even more important that the documentation and collection of information for accountability purposes be done and supervised by professionals, who understand how best to collect information to maximize its likelihood that it will be admissible in court, and who can minimize the chances of information gathering doing more harm than good to the people we are ultimately trying to help. It is important to understand that insufficient regard to these factors is likely to damage the justice process, and can undermine the long-term goal of strengthening international criminal justice.</p><p><em>Image: Getty/Douglas Hook</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://www.justicerapidresponse.org/opinion-expertise-documentation/"><em>www.justicerapidresponse.org</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7e6d31e49552" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Evidence of Hope: Investigating Sexual and Gender-based Violence in Syria and Iraq]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@_JRR/https-medium-com-justicerapidresponse-evidence-of-hope-1f39aa982e25?source=rss-a6dc946d96e7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1f39aa982e25</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[isis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[middle-east]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[united-nations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[international-womens-day]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justice Rapid Response]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 12 Mar 2018 19:16:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-12T19:16:26.864Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UuXJrZs9mKOuyE2ikD076Q.jpeg" /></figure><h4>This short documentary features two sexual violence investigators on the Justice Rapid Response-UN Women SGBV Justice Experts Roster who were deployed to the UN’s investigations in Syria and Iraq, and four survivor-witnesses they met during their work.</h4><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FAMUZXAeyL98%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DAMUZXAeyL98&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FAMUZXAeyL98%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/9804d5bfc76350e527d2dcbce001f7b6/href">https://medium.com/media/9804d5bfc76350e527d2dcbce001f7b6/href</a></iframe><p>Filmed in Germany, Turkey and the United States, the film goes behind the scenes into how investigators approach the challenge of finding victims of SGBV, collecting evidence, and building a case, while always prioritizing the well-being of survivors. The film presents perspectives from three Yazidi women, each with her own harrowing story of survival, as well as an activist from Syria, whose hope for a revolution faded when she was targeted for speaking out. All survivors of sexual violence, they explain why it was important for them to share their story with SGBV investigators working with the UN Syria Commission of Inquiry, and the UN fact-finding mission to Iraq.</p><p><strong>Background</strong></p><p><a href="http://www.justicerapidresponse.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/JRR_SGBV_2017_October_ReducedSize.pdf">The Justice Rapid Response- UN Women SGBV Justice Experts partnership</a> works to ensure investigations into sexual and gender-based crimes are professional, impartial, and timely. This partnership manages and can rapidly deploy from a stand-by roster of currently 217 SGBV justice experts, and has already done so on 67 times since its inception. While not the only roster that can support work in this critical area, it is the only one where expertise dedicated to SGBV investigations represents every region and legal system in the world. Ahead of the annual United Nations Security Council’s annual open debate on women, peace and security, JRR and UN Women are highlighting the work of SGBV experts who have deployed to support documentation and investigation efforts around the world.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://www.justicerapidresponse.org/evidence-of-hope/"><em>www.justicerapidresponse.org</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1f39aa982e25" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>