<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ben Doolittle on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ben Doolittle on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@a.gittingham?source=rss-6d1654b42500------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 02:24:27 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@a.gittingham/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why (Fantasy) Stories Matter]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@a.gittingham/why-fantasy-stories-matter-4788472b0480?source=rss-6d1654b42500------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4788472b0480</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reading-books]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reading]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fantasy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Doolittle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 Jun 2017 02:42:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-06-16T02:42:15.447Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Why (Fantasy) Stories Matter</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jE2wPQ7MHFYF8UPcdnUvIg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Learning to read is, and always will be, vitally important. What is less universally agreed upon is what counts as appropriate reading. For the most part, fantasy and science fiction is widely regarded as being light reading, just for fun. Little time, if any, is spent reading fantasy in school. Academics favor older, more conventionally “serious” texts, spending much of high school and college teaching students how to read and unpack these old texts. Is there, then, nothing to learn from fairy tales? This is a summary of all the things fairy tales still have to teach us.</p><p>Stories are, by their very nature, iterative. An attentive reader can see who has influenced a writer, and how those influences mixed to create something new. Themes build on top of each other, ideas mixing and merging until someone takes them back apart. And still the first stories are told, the epics and legends of bygone days. The oldest written story is the <em>Epic of Gilgamesh</em> (2100 BCE) [1], which tells of the adventures of King Gilgamesh and his foe and friend Enkidu. Gilgamesh leaves his kingdom in search of immortality. All of the stories we have today are build on the foundations laid by epic heroes like Gilgamesh, and epic poets like Homer. Even some ancient texts are known examples of adaptation over time. The Prose and Poetic Eddas, written by Snorri Sturluson around 1220[2], are the most expansive remaining record of Norse mythology. Each starts with a prologue that gives a Christian account of the Norse origin myths. This was likely done to appease Christian missionaries who were aggressively peddling their religion across Europe. This nearly destroyed the druidic religions of the British Isles, although certain elements of those tales have survived as hints and easter eggs in Arthurian Legend (primarily through figures like Merlin and Sir Gawain). Here is shown the two options for stories over time: either adapt and change to remain relevant, or be replaced and slowly forgotten in favor of more popular options.</p><p>All of the texts I have mentioned so far are widely considered worth studying, and many college English classes are dedicated to studying just one of them. There is a rich history to be found in these texts, not only the history of storytelling, but also the history of human society. <em>The Epic of Gilgamesh</em>, <em>Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, </em>and <em>The Iliad</em> all touch on themes familiar to modern audiences while providing insight to the values of the people that told them. Stories are born of the people that tell them, so perhaps humans have not changed as much as we might like to think. Additionally, these stories were imagined and told in vastly different time periods in different geographic locations by cultures with different values. Gilgamesh was a king transformed into a god, Sir Gawain a hypothetical ideal knight, and the Iliad an epic tale of heroism and betrayal. I use these as examples because they are what I am familiar with, but hero myths from across the world, including Hindu, Christian, Buddhist, and Native American mythology all share structural and thematic similarities[3] that point towards the existence of a common human experience.</p><p>This is a key point, because no matter the kind of story you read, it is about people. Invariably, a story has characters, and you are constantly being asked whether they are someone you can believe in, relate to, care about. Fantasy and science fiction are especially good at this because they are, quite frankly, more engaging than Dickens ever will be. The more engaged you are with the story and characters, the more you empathize, the more you learn. Sometimes you learn facts, but more frequently you learn about emotions and ideas, and how people respond to them. By learning about others, you learn a little about yourself as well. That is the true power of fantasy, especially good fantasy. The hero is not always a good person, and the villain is often a very tragic figure, and even in the darkest, bloodiest tales, forgiveness and mercy can be found. Perhaps more importantly, heroes make mistakes and are forgiven, although it takes work and true repentance.</p><p>Of course, fantasy and science fiction cannot teach you everything, and it is important to maintain a wide reading base. Nevertheless, the power of fairy tales should not be underestimated, nor overlooked. There is much there to learn, if you have the heart to search for it.</p><p>[1] <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epic_of_Gilgamesh">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epic_of_Gilgamesh</a></p><p>[2] <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prose_Edda">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prose_Edda</a></p><p>[3] <a href="http://www.shmoop.com/hero-with-a-thousand-faces/summary.html">http://www.shmoop.com/hero-with-a-thousand-faces/summary.html</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4788472b0480" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[You Should Know About Oats Studio]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@a.gittingham/you-should-know-about-oats-studio-50d0e153994?source=rss-6d1654b42500------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/50d0e153994</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film-editing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[filmmaking]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Doolittle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 Jun 2017 02:28:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-06-16T02:28:19.026Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Neill Blomkamp, director of <em>Elysium</em>,<em> District 9</em>,<em> </em>and <em>Chappie</em>, has done something really cool. He started Oats Studios, which will be releasing a series of short films as their first Season of production. The first of these, called Rakka, was just released. This is where the cool stuff starts.</p><p>Each short will be made available for free, on Youtube (<a href="https://youtu.be/VjQ2t_yNHQs">https://youtu.be/VjQ2t_yNHQs</a>) and Steam (<a href="http://store.steampowered.com/app/633030/Oats_Studios__Volume_1/">http://store.steampowered.com/app/633030/Oats_Studios__Volume_1/</a>). Of course, even with the small team size of roughly twenty people, the studio still needs to make money, somehow. It plans to do this in part through donations from fans, and by selling the video, audio, 3D models, scripts, and behind the scenes footage for each episode. Currently, a small sample of these materials is available for Rakka on steam (specifically, the video file, concept art, script, and 3D models, all for $5), and more will be offered as they are made ready. This means that aspiring filmmakers and editors have access to professional grade film, audio, models, and scripts that they can edit, recut, and share. The steam page even includes an email address to request licenses to distribute these fan projects commercially.</p><p>In addition, the team will be actively involved with their community, taking input that could then get turned into future episodes, which could then be produced into full, feature length films, with credit and payment to the individual who created the idea. They do point out that not many of these ideas will be taken, but there seems to be a lot of enthusiasm to get such direct and immediate feedback and communication with a huge base of potential creators.</p><p>Check out Oats Studios website: <a href="http://oatsstudios.com/">http://oatsstudios.com/</a></p><p>and this interview with director Neill Blomkamp: <a href="http://www.firstshowing.net/2017/interview-neill-blomkamp-reveals-the-true-concept-of-oats-studios/">http://www.firstshowing.net/2017/interview-neill-blomkamp-reveals-the-true-concept-of-oats-studios/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=50d0e153994" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the Levels of Dark Souls (3)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@a.gittingham/on-the-levels-of-dark-souls-3-d9cdc85ead74?source=rss-6d1654b42500------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d9cdc85ead74</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[level-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dark-souls-3]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dark-souls]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Doolittle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 15 Nov 2016 07:05:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-15T07:05:21.259Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>With the release of Dark Souls 3 a debate about level design that started with Dark Souls 2 was reignited. Many fans of the series swear by the world of Dark Souls, ridiculing Dark Souls 2 for linear areas and a linear path through the game, with few optional areas, looping paths, or side areas. There were high hopes for the design of Dark Souls 3, as FromSoft president Miyazaki was back in charge of the series. Many fans were initially disappointed with the levels of Dark Souls 3, So, I’d like to ask the question is the level design of the original Dark Souls really that much better than Dark Souls 3?</p><p>The world of Dark Souls is undeniably complex. From the start of the game, you can access three or four different areas immediately, depending on your choice of starting gift. It is possible to skip bosses entirely, and still not lose access to areas that are supposed to be “behind” those bosses. The most notable example of this is the Taurus Demon, many players’ first real boss after the tutorial area, who grants access to the Undead Parish, and Andre the blacksmith. It is possible, however, to get to Andre without defeating the Taurus Demon through two separate paths that go through Darkroot Garden. On its own, Darkroot Garden is essentially a connector area between the back of the Undead Parish and the Undead Settlement, which reflects how Dark Souls handles shortcuts.</p><blockquote>For reference on the normal Dark Souls progression path, check <a href="http://darksouls.wiki.fextralife.com/Game+Progress+Route">here</a>.</blockquote><p>Shortcuts in Dark Souls are largely through opening new connections between areas, rather than unlocking shortcuts within the areas themselves. This gives the world of Lordran an undeniable sense of realism, and you learn its geography as you are forced to trek back and forth between important locations through the first half of the game. This time that the game forces you to spend walking back and forth is therefore worthwhile in a tangible way, and it covers up the weakness of this style of level design. It is really easy to get lost your first time through. While the sense of discovery as you learn and stumble upon familiar scenery is wonderful, it can be disheartening and frustrating to wonder and wander and die over and over again. If you get what Dark Souls is trying to do, that is okay, but when you’ve just arrived in Firelink Shrine and aren’t sure where to go, I’m not sure that is always a strength.</p><p>Despite this wonderful complexity, which I really do love, the individual areas of Dark Souls are very straightforward. By straightforward, I mean there is one path of progression through almost every area in Dark Souls, and when you reach the end of that path, you enter the next area. When you open a shortcut from one area to the next, it is simply a door that opens onto a section of this path. The only exceptions to this are a few loops such as those present in the Undead Burg. The overall complexity of the world masks this general linearity, but it is worth bearing in mind as we move into Dark Souls 3.</p><p>Dark Souls 3 is much more linear than Dark Souls. In terms of area progression, there are really only 3 “side areas” (Archdragon Peak, Consumed Kings Garden, Smoldering Lake), which do not reconnect to the main game path. There are some other areas that you can enter early, for instance fighting the Dancer of the Boreal Valley before beating the first 3 Lords of Cinder. Other than these small options, however, Dark Souls 3 proceeds in a very straightforward fashion from The High Wall of Lothric down to Irythill, then back up through Lothric Castle.</p><blockquote>For reference on the normal Dark Souls 3 progression path, check <a href="http://darksouls3.wiki.fextralife.com/Game+Progress+Route">here</a>.</blockquote><p>While the areas of Dark Souls 3 lack the interlocking design of the original, many of the levels contain shortcuts, loops, and side paths within themselves. Even relatively simple areas, such as the King’s Consumed Garden, contain a loop back up to the initial bonfire, and there is some really great trickery done with elevators that have multiple places to jump off. Perhaps the best example of this in Dark Souls 3 is the Grand Archives. Besides having a winding path up through the interior of the level, the Archives have two separate elevators that open up shortcuts, paths back down on top of the many book cases in the area, and a path down through the rafters. The area is massive, but once you know where a few of the shorter shortcuts are, a ladder between balconies, and how all of the different paths work together, the Archives are split nicely into manageable chunks. The level lets you access every part of the Archives, from the very base up to the top of the roof.</p><p>What this means when comparing the level design of these games is that what Dark Souls does with its world design Dark Souls 3 does with its level design. This means that Dark Souls 3 feels more disjointed between areas, and the game is more linear from area to area, but each individual area is anything but linear. In Dark Souls, however, each area is very linear, but the world twists and turns upon itself that everything feels much less straightforward. So in certain ways both games could be described as linear. Dark Souls definitely feels less linear, but the design of each area in Dark Souls 3 is highly impressive. But which is better? I’d say that each game represents a different approach to level design, and although Miyazaki has commented that he wishes there had been more <a href="http://gameranx.com/updates/id/64010/article/hidetaka-miyazaki-believes-dark-souls-iiis-maps-connection-was-a-bit-weak/">inter-connectivity</a> between levels in Dark Souls 3. I would agree with Miyazaki about this being compensated (slightly) by the complexity and size of the individual areas in Dark Souls 3.</p><p>Also, my interest in the design of each area individually does not mean that the areas in Dark Souls 3 do not mesh together at all. They do, and in such a way to reflect the high quality game that Dark Souls 3 is. I am focusing so much on the levels to highlight the difference between the design philosophies that seem to be behind each game. Dark Souls seems to have been built as a world, with the connections between all of the areas requiring careful planning, and implementation almost as if the whole world map was one continuous level (which it isn’t). Dark Souls 3 is constructed in such a way that it could be planned as a series of levels, which all connect to form a world. So although each game is essentially the same mechanically, a series of game levels carefully designed with a path from start to end in mind, they feel very different.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d9cdc85ead74" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dr. Strange: Review]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@a.gittingham/dr-strange-review-d43749f38dc3?source=rss-6d1654b42500------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d43749f38dc3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marvel-cinematic-universe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marvel-studios]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marvel]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Doolittle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 10 Nov 2016 20:04:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-10T20:04:08.317Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Dr. Strange</em> is a visual masterpiece. Comparisons to films like Inception or Interstellar are obvious and apt. It feels like the team behind <em>Dr. Strange</em> saw those films have been waiting to one up them ever since, and that is exactly what they have done. The CGI here is simply amazing. It manages to be visually stunning without being oppressively and obviously omnipresent, as special effects tend to be in big budget action films. I never felt like the CGI was being overused, and everything from the beginning to the end had a consistently impressive style and look.</p><p>The visuals of the film were backed by excellent performances from everyone involved. Benedict Cumberbatch brings to life an energetic Stephen Strange, lost between his world of science and a new world of magic. He is am impressively complex character, struggling with his personal goals and a responsibility that he slowly comes to accept. Some of his fight scenes are straightforward and serious, but others have a hint of Jackie Chan behind them, as Strange battles foes who clearly have the upper hand in power and skill.</p><p>Mads Mikkelsen delivers well as the main villain of the film, and acts as a solid foil for Cumberbatch to play against. Their interactions on screen feel real and genuine, although the motivations of Mikkelsen’s character could be more fleshed out. The Ancient One, played by Tilda Swinton, is a similarly vague character, but that is by design. She is supposed to be an ancient, enigmatic figure, and that is exactly how she is portrayed in the film. The rest of the cast plays together extremely well, as is to be expected of Marvel Studio films by this point.</p><p>What really stood out to me was the way this film treats magic, and the magical abilities of it’s cast. Some light spoilers ahead, so proceed with caution.</p><p>Stephen Strange starts learning magic in an effort to heal his damaged hands, after Western Medicine fails him. In other universes with magic, the ultimate goal would be a spell to instantly mend damaged tissue, such as the potion used in Harry Potter to regrow bones. It becomes apparent that nothing so simple and convenient exists for Dr. Strange, however. In fact, Strange is forced to return to the hospital were he used to work several times to have injuries treated. In the MCU, magic has clearly defined limits, and science fits nicely alongside it. While it is revealed that Strange could constantly send magic through his hands to force them to work like normal, there is no way to fix them in a more traditional sense.</p><p>The limits of magic are further demonstrated in the final standoff between Dr. Strange and Dormammu. This is usually where the hero is able to, against all odds, defeat a clearly more powerful opponent through some convenient new ability or clever plot that gives him/her the upper hand. Dormammu is hyped as an ultimate being of destruction, unimaginably powerful and nigh on immortal. So how does Dr. Strange defeat him? He doesn’t. There is no custom magic he can use to destroy his opponent, no last minute spell to force him away. The film ends clearly within the limits set up throughout the film, which genuinely surprised me in a film about magic.</p><p><em>Dr. Strange</em> is worth seeing for it’s visuals alone. The fact that it is backed up by a surprisingly consistent story and Marvel’s almost trademark solid acting and film making style is simply icing on the cake. Go see it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d43749f38dc3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Witcher 3 and Easy Modes in Dark Souls]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@a.gittingham/the-witcher-3-and-easy-modes-in-dark-souls-43c2b0907017?source=rss-6d1654b42500------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/43c2b0907017</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[comparison]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-witcher-3]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dark-souls]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Doolittle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 15 Oct 2016 17:15:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-10-15T17:15:00.823Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Full disclaimer, I absolutely love The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, and this comparison is in no way meant to be a criticism of it. Rather, I am trying to address the idea that Dark Souls 3, and games like it, should have an “easy mode”. The Witcher 3 and the Dark Souls 3 games have certain mechanical similarities in their combat that involve timing light and heavy attacks, magic, usable items, and dodges against enemy attacks. Different character builds are possible in each game, allowing the player to focus on various aspects of combat, or to try and use all of them together. But the Witcher 3 has four different difficulty levels, a quest tracker, and a mini-map that points you towards your goal with a little dotted line, so why can’t Dark Souls 3 have them too?</p><p>In short, it is a difference of design. Dark Souls 3 was designed to be hard for a reason. The director of the games, and president of FromSoftware, Hidetaka Miyazaki has said that when the studio started working on Demon’s Souls, the predecessor of Dark Souls 3, the goal was to give the player a “feeling of accomplishment after overcoming tremendous odds.” (find the interview <a href="http://www.wired.co.uk/article/dark-souls-3-hidetaka-miyazaki-interview">here</a>) He calls this a particular kind of game, and that is exactly what it is. Even more broadly, Dark Souls is a game about mechanical mastery to an extreme level, and it takes real skill to gain this mastery. The Witcher 3, on the other hand, is a true RPG that is trying to tell a story. If you don’t want to master the combat mechanics, then you can select an easier difficulty, keep the mini-map on, and enjoy listening to Geralt’s lovely, gravely voice.</p><p>But why would an easy mode be bad for Dark Souls? Experienced and more serious players can easily select the ‘normal’ difficulty and have the experience that Miyazaki envisioned. So what’s the harm? Well, let’s look at how The Witcher 3 starts off. Right away, you are asked to select your difficulty. Cool, that’s pretty standard for RPG’s, and those people who want to can select Death March while those who don’t can choose Sword and Story and everyone gets to have fun. But is everyone having the same experience? Strictly speaking, no. Not at all. True, the same events are happening on screen, you’re doing the same quests, and making the same choices, but enemies are dealing different amounts of damage, have different amounts of health, and you are gaining different amounts of experience. For example, on the Death March difficulty in The Witcher 3, enemies have 80% more health and deal 230% more damage and you gain 80% experience, compared to 10% more health and 40% more damage on Sword and Story. Changing these three numbers is really the only way to make a game easier or harder. In a game that is all about combat like Dark Souls 3, you cannot change things like damage and health of enemies or the player without changing the experience the player is having. No matter how ‘good’ you are at video games, when you play Dark Souls 3 enemies will kill you in two or three hits, and you will need two or three hits to beat most enemies. Because FromSoftware wants to have tight control over the experience of playing their games and changing the difficulty inherently changes the experience, it really would break these games to include an easy mode.</p><p>Defeating a boss without really trying is exactly what Miyazaki does not want to have happen in these games. He wants you to have to try, die, learn, try, repeat as necessary, and succeed. That is why beating a boss, or even just making it through an area in Dark Souls is so satisfying, and why so many people love these games. Easy mode robs the game of this feeling, and defeats the purpose of making this kind of game in the first place. Putting an option on the game, even one with a message that says easy mode is highly discouraged, doesn’t alleviate this problem. Having the option to change the difficulty mid-game, or even going back and starting over entirely with an easier difficulty still defeats the purpose of the game challenging its players.</p><p>In another game that might be a problem, but these kinds of games are designed so that they take skill. Not a special kind of skill either, just practice with the game. Random numbers don’t determine your success, because you are presented with very exact information about how much damage you are doing relative to how much health enemies have, and you have all the tools needed to avoid taking damage yourself. It might not be easy, but the encounters are designed to be challenging while still being fair. In most cases, there are encounters in the area before a boss that prepare you to face the kind of attacks and patterns the boss will use against you. In front of the Abyss Watcher’s fight there are two Darkwraiths that teach you how to dodge multiple powerful enemies at once. The Crystal Sage has two mages that cast powerful magic from multiple directions immediately before his arena. The Dragon Slayer Armor is guarded by Lothric Knights wielding huge swords that swing slow and hit hard. Oceiros has a bunch of the darkness monsters in his garden, to teach you how to avoid his quick charges. The ruins of Izalith area all about dodging fireballs and combustion pyromancies before you can challenge the Demon King. The game is designed so that you have to overcome a set of challenges before demonstrating mastery by overcoming the boss that tests your skills to avoid those attacks.</p><p>Admittedly, it can take time to master those skills, and a lack of progress can be disheartening. But this is where Dark Souls really stands out for me personally. In each of the Dark Souls games there are two kinds of progress, character progress and player progress. Character progress is the kind of progress we normally think about in video games, moving forward with the story. In Dark Souls this is represented by beating bosses, exploring new areas, and lighting bonfires. Player progress is your progress as a player, and it is possible, almost unavoidable, that you progress even if you are dying repeatedly to the same enemy. All games have a learning curve, but Dark Souls, and action games like it, really test the player on this and challenge the player to really test their skills. What this means for the player is that spending an hour or two trying to beat a boss is not time wasted, because you were making progress. It was just player progress, not character progress.</p><p>Dark Souls is more concerned with your player progress than with your character progress by design. If it wanted you to simply move through the game it would let you keep your souls when you died, spawn you back at the fog gate when fighting bosses, keep enemies from respawning, or let you turn the difficulty down. These are very similar to the systems in the Witcher 3 that let the player keep moving forward at a nice pace. The Witcher 3 auto-saves right before every major encounter and loads right back to that point, making it easy to try again. You can change the difficulty at any point, and the limited number of spells, potions, and items means it is always easy to understand what tools you have to make things easier.</p><p>This does not mean that either game is better or worse than the other. Dark Souls and the Witcher 3 were designed to accomplish different things, challenging the player and telling a story respectively, and each is extremely well designed to match its goal. If Dark Souls were concerned with telling a distinct story and keeping the player moving through it at a reasonable pace, then it would be a poorly designed game. Dark Souls, and any Souls-like, are not trying to be that kind of game, they want to challenge their players in order to give them a rush of accomplishment that is well earned, rather than being action games that rely on cut scenes and scripted moments to get adrenaline pumping.</p><p>It must also be mentioned that games can be hard <em>and include an easy mode</em>. Dark Souls is not, and should not, be used as an example of why no game should ever include a difficulty slider for the player to choose from. Rather, it represents a developer having a certain goal in mind that does not allow for the inclusion of a strict easy mode. The truth is, Dark Souls does allow it’s players to dynamically select their difficulty through the way they choose to play the game. Utilizing ranged attacks, magic, and spell buffs makes the encounters throughout all 3 Dark Souls games much easier to handle, as does summoning phantoms and paying attention to messages left by other players. Dark Souls 2 does some very interesting things with game difficulty, and comes the closest in the series to including a “mode” that is strictly harder that warrants it’s own article. None of these factors, however, drastically change the fact that enemies, and bosses in particular, have the ability to kill the player as fast or faster than you can kill them. But if you can master the mechanics of dodging and attacking, these games don’t seem anywhere near as difficult as when you first picked them up.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=43c2b0907017" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Magic in Fantasy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@a.gittingham/magic-in-fantasy-28cffe1a82e8?source=rss-6d1654b42500------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/28cffe1a82e8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[why]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mythology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[harry-potter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[magic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Doolittle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 29 Sep 2016 03:51:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-09-29T03:51:06.940Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I grew up reading fantasy of all sorts, the good, the bad, and the really bad. I was young, so I loved all of it as long as cool things happened, and never really questioned why there were always wizards casting spells, or strange magical artifacts. Now, though, I want to look a little deeper and question why so much fantasy employs the services of Merlin-esque figures and what purpose magic serves.</p><p>At it’s most basic, magic is a tool used by an author or storyteller to give their characters more power. As in most instances, however, power is not a simple thing. In worlds like that of the <em>Harry Potter</em> novels, where all of the characters can use magic, everyone becomes more powerful. The final confrontation between Harry and Voldemort could play out nearly the same without magic, using a fistfight, battle of wits, or game of cards as proxy. In this sort of system, where all of the principal actors can use magic, it is used to mark a change or highlight something fundamentally human that is otherwise much harder to discuss. For example, in <em>Harry Potter</em> Harry is told he is a wizard on his eleventh birthday, around the same time he would be entering puberty and making his transition into the ‘adult world’. It is definitely more interesting to watch Harry struggle though Hogwarts than it would be to read about his escapades in an English boarding school. It is arguably an even more informative story for a young audience who, not having experienced the life of an older child yet, would not be able to relate if the characters, setting, and plot were supposed to be realistic. Because the setting is magical, suspension of disbelief takes care of such pesky problems and lets Rowling get her message across. It is also rather more impressive, memorable, and admirable to watch an eleven year old child face down a massive three headed dog, while his friends sacrifice themselves in a bloody game of chess, and then face down the most feared wizard of the age than for him to simply stand up to a bully, or talk to that pretty girl in the hallway. The moments where he does have to stand up to a bully, or struggles through his early romances remind us that he is still human, that despite his magical skill he still struggles with mundane tasks. This is important, because it keeps the characters relatable, instead of distant, god-like figures that we are told are really 11 year old kids.</p><p>The second form of magic is similar to the <em>Harry Potter </em>model. Many characters can use magic but there are limits on the use or power of the magic that can be used. A prime example of this is the Night Angel trilogy by Brent Weeks. In this series there are two kinds of magic, Talent and vir. Not everyone can use Talent, and a certain group of mages called wytches sacrifice their Talent to gain the more powerful, but extremely volatile, vir. The main character, Kylar Stern, is able to use a small amount of Talent, but only truly becomes powerful when he obtains the ka’kari, a magical artifact that grants him immortality and immunity to magical attacks. The catch, as there must be, is that every time Kylar is revived, the ka’kari sacrifices the life of someone he loves. At first Kylar does not know this, and uses his powers recklessly, resulting in the death of both his romantic lovers and closest friends.</p><p>The differences between Talent and the vir are also instructive. Talent is derived from the power of the sun, making the use of magic reliant on sunlight as well as how much power an individual can hold. If a mage runs out of Talent, they need to wait to absorb more sunlight before using more magic. The vir, on the other hand, work all the time, and their power is set in a strict hierarchy. Unlike the Talent, however, the vir are autonomous of their user and as a wytch draws more power from the vir they are consumed and destroyed. So those who seek greater and greater power merely for the sake of power will ultimately be undone by that quest. The important thing in this set up is not the power that magic conveys, but the restrictions on the use of magic. The Night Angel Trilogy uses it to make a point about the value of love, and the dangers of reckless ambition.</p><p>In the third model of magic the definition of magic changes slightly. In <em>The Lord of the Rings</em> magic is not so much a tool or weapon as it is in <em>Harry Potter</em>. Rather it is something that burns inside of everyone, from the smallest hobbit to the most powerful of wizards. Throughout the journey of the ring even Gandalf does very little with magic in terms of combat. Rather than throwing fireballs or shooting lightning from his fingertips he sets off fireworks and small explosions for distractions. True, these pyrotechnics are obviously not natural, but they are also not powerful enough to be used as weapons on their own. That is not what magic is in <em>Lord of the Rings</em>. Instead, magic is best represented by the Rings of Power, especially The One Ring, and the effects they have on their wearers. The rings serve as conduits for the will of those that control them, amplifying and modifying fears and hopes and intentions. This effect is most visible in the Ringwraiths and in Galadriel when Frodo offers her the Ring. Magic in Middle-Earth is almost synonymous with will, and is a major factor in the power of characters like Gandalf or the Witch-King. Where Gandalf inspires hope and courage the Witch-King breeds fear and malice, and it is clear that the thing which divides them is not power, but how they use it. The Ring is temptation to greater power, and the Ringwraiths gave in and were lost. Similarly, Saruman is an effective wizard in part because of his intellect, and also because of the power of his voice. Even when he is locked in his tower, without his staff, Gandalf is wary of his voice which he uses to entrance and lead those around him to do his bidding.</p><p>This kind of magic is subtle, but can also be the most powerful, both in the world of the fantasy and for the reader. It works so well because it is not as obvious as the spell slinging power fantasy that systems like that in <em>Harry Potter</em> tend to be, at least in part. This kind of magic is not devoid of personal feats of greatness or power, but the most powerful effects of magic are felt through teamwork. In <em>Lord of the Rings</em> none of the characters could stand against Sauron alone, but together they are able to overcome numerous obstacles.</p><p>Of course, all of these lessons can be and have been conveyed without the use of magic. Magic is, however, woven into the fabric of fantasy literature, as fantasy is a direct descendant of mythology, legend, and folklore. The point of myths and legends is to provide a culture or society a guide for how its members are expected to act. Magic has always done more than simply explain lightning or the tides. It gives us a workable, understandable framework for understanding ourselves. Psychologists still do not fully understand the chemistry, biology, or psychology behind the single most important part of your body, the brain, and less tangible traits like personality. Shamans, mystics, gurus, and priests have understood and taught us about ourselves for centuries, and just as the authors listed above utilize magic as a way to frame, explain, and understand the human psyche.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=28cffe1a82e8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nioh Beta Brief Review]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@a.gittingham/nioh-beta-brief-review-52972ce3af27?source=rss-6d1654b42500------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/52972ce3af27</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[beta]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nioh]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dark-souls]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Doolittle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 11 Sep 2016 05:01:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-09-11T05:01:53.574Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Team Ninja’s upcoming game Nioh just finished an open beta period on the PS4. The game is set in feudal Japan, where you play as William, a European who has traveled to the East to hunt down a certain man. There are cinematic cutscenes that tell the story, as well as voice lines from fallen soldiers who’s gear William can pick up as he moves through the landscape, fighting hostile soldiers and demonic yokai. The game is also loosely based in history. The character William is most likely based on William Adams, a European sailor who was shipwrecked on Japan and ultimately made a samurai. Other historical figures make appearances, such as Hattori Hanzo, and important deities and spirits from Japanese folklore and mythology. Each area has some fairly detailed text about its background, or some piece of culture behind it. Whether or not these facts are true or false, seeing more games use a fantastical setting to inspire real interest in a different culture is exciting.</p><p>Mechanically, Nioh is a direct descendant of Dark Souls, with shrines replacing bonfires, amrita for souls, and a brutally difficult stamina based combat system. Unlike some other Souls-like games, however, Nioh builds and adds to this framework, developing the systems it borrows into something new. Each melee weapon has three stances, high, middle, and low, that all have unique animations. The stances are geared for offense, neutral, and defense respectively, and the game does a good job of encouraging the use of all three to be most effective. Stamina has also had an overhaul. When the stamina bar is depleted, there is a brief window of opportunity before it fully restores to time a button press to instantly regain a large part of the stamina used. Mastery of this system, which the game calls a Ki Pulse, adds a new dimension to combat that keeps things fast paced and tense, especially because running out of stamina leaves you vulnerable to enemy attacks for an extended period.</p><p>The third major change to gameplay from the Dark Souls ‘formula’ is the existence of skill trees that add magic and ninjutsu to the game, but also melee attack combos that deal extra damage in fixed bursts or affect how your character moves and deals damage. This skill tree also ties into the guardian spirit system. The player can choose a guardian spirit, who offers certain passive bonuses depending on the player’s level and skills. The spirit also has a meter that builds over time, and when it is full the player can enter a mode called Living Weapon. While in this mode, the player does not take damage and deals much more damage for a short time. If (when) the player dies, the guardian spirit stays with their grave marker, which also holds all of their amrita held when they died. If the player can make it back to this marker, the spirit and amrita will return. If they cannot, the spirit will return, but the amrita will be lost. The guardian spirit can also be recalled from shrines at any time, but all amrita will be instantly lost.</p><p>I had not had the chance to play Nioh before this beta, and while I did not get to play as much of it as I would have liked, I am extremely excited to see how the final product will turn out. It is set to be extremely challenging, but also highly rewarding, with a story less obtuse than that of any of the Dark Souls games.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=52972ce3af27" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Not To End A Story]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@a.gittingham/how-not-to-end-a-story-acba5c78ab41?source=rss-6d1654b42500------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/acba5c78ab41</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bleach]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anime]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Doolittle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Aug 2016 03:28:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-08-19T03:28:52.344Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is going to be dealing with the recent end of the manga <em>Bleach</em>, but it isn’t really all about specifically why the <em>Bleach</em> ending is awful in terms of the manga itself, but instead in terms of general story telling technique. So I’m not going to be using terms that you need to be familiar with <em>Bleach</em> to understand unless I absolutely have to.</p><p>Before talking about the ending, I thought the first three seasons of <em>Bleach</em> were excellent. They were fairly straightforward in terms of plot or character design and progression, but they introduced Aizen, one of the best villains in any story ever. These first few seasons brilliantly balanced the narrative of an untrained and inexperienced fighter invading a centuries old military establishment to save his friend, with the internal coup of that same military organization by perhaps its most powerful and intelligent general, Aizen. Every new development reveals a new twist in Aizen’s plan, and we see him easily dispatch several of his fellow officers before his final showdown with the main character, Ichigo Kurosaki. The fight is perfectly built up to. Kurosaki has grown in power and maturity through his journey so far, defeating several other extremely powerful generals on the way to confronting Aizen, who at this point is the clear villain of the story arc. As we all know, the hero must conquer the villain at the end of the day.</p><p>But that’s not what happens. Ichigo launches himself into the fight, and Aizen demolishes him quickly, brutally, and casually. Aizen and his followers then make their escape as Aizen and Ichigo lock eyes. Ichigo is furious and afraid, Aizen is smug and mocking. In the course of two episodes, the series turns all of your expectations on their head after brilliantly telling several competing narratives and pacing everything to perfection.</p><p>I’m highlighting the quality of the beginning of Bleach to show that it hasn’t always been the gripe fest that the current state of the manga might have you believe. The final arc of <em>Bleach</em> has just ended, and it suffered from many of <em>Bleach</em>’s later faults (some of which also existed from episode one) including too many characters and extensive but unnecessary backstories, and a ridiculous power scale. But even more problematic is a basic breakdown of storytelling. The premise of the arc is hugely promising too. It focuses on the conflict between the Shinigami and Quincy, the two groups that oppose regular influxes of what are essentially demons from hell. The two groups have a long history of conflict, and now the Quincy had returned for revenge. As the Quincy fought their way through to the Soul King, several points that had been intriguing fans of <em>Bleach</em> for a long while were answered and addressed, like the ultimate abilities of the characters Urahara Kisuke and Shunsui Kyouraku, while others points were obfuscated, like the origins of the zanpakutou, swords used by the Shinigami. Other problems were introduced, like the true nature of characters like Yachiru and Ichigo himself, who has a blend of Shinigami, Quincy, and Hollow (those devils from hell) powers. Other characters, fan favorites such as Grimmjoww and Nel, reappear only to vanish in the last two chapters, their fates unknown. Aizen, that ultimate villain who is stronger than anyone else in the <em>Bleach</em> universe, is released from captivity and somehow ends up back in prison afterwards, with no explanation. Another character who’s powers were the subject of great reverence and speculation is relegated to a completely domestic role, her abilities forgotten or dismissed. These plot holes aside, the final three chapters of <em>Bleach</em> represent a complete break in any kind of narrative flow that the manga still had. Many chapters were needed to fully wrap up the situation things were in, what characters were doing and what their exact goals were, how certain forces were operating and what let them work together, and how exactly Ichigo was going to defeat Yhwach, who could both see and alter the future, making him a literal god.</p><p>Instead, two Quincy turn against Yhwach, using a previously unmentioned silver arrow to nullify his ability to see the future for a split instant, during which Ichigo cuts Yhwach in half.</p><p>Then the story jumps ten years into the future, long after the aftermath of the battle between the Quincy and the Shinigami has ended. The reader is treated to a brief and ridiculous scramble by various captains to get somewhere on time, before having it revealed that someone is being promoted to the rank of Captain, the second highest rank a Shinigami can have.</p><p>Then the story jumps to an indeterminate point in time, with Ichigo being at home catching up with friends from school who haven’t been present in the anime for several hundred chapters. In the spirit world, the Shinigami are panicking about a resurgence of Yhwach’s power, and Aizen thinks back on the final battle that was so abruptly ended. He recalls how Yhwach told Ichigo his true purpose as he died. Apparently, Yhwach was not really trying to destroy the world, but to join the human world with the spirit realms to make everyone immortal, and thus rid everyone of fear. Aizen says something sappy about human courage, and then the chapter ends with a Ichigo’s kid meeting the child of his Shinigami friend Rukia.</p><p>The final chapter is trying, it really is. It presents the audience with a final message, that courage is important, and tries to show the main characters all happy after their adventures. But it ultimately falls flat. Its hard to believe Ichigo is done being a Shinigami, and none of the last three chapters are connected to each other in any way except that Ichigo is in all of them. There is no flow, no natural progression of events, and no satisfying conclusion to any of the action leading up to Ichigo cutting Yhwach in half. Many, many questions are left unanswered and several characters are left hanging that deserve resolutions. These final chapters do nothing to actually end <em>Bleach</em>. Rather, <em>Bleach </em>just sort of ends, randomly.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=acba5c78ab41" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bloodborne’s Few Weapons]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@a.gittingham/bloodbornes-few-weapons-260fbe369c53?source=rss-6d1654b42500------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/260fbe369c53</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[roleplaying-game]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bloodborne]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[playstation-4]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Doolittle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 31 Jul 2016 02:14:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-07-31T02:14:11.932Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I recently bought a PlayStation 4, and as a huge fan of From Software the first game I picked up was Bloodborne. I had already heard a lot about it, what people liked and disliked. The most common criticism I have heard in playthroughs and reviews is that there aren’t enough weapons in Bloodborne. The Dark Souls games, closer to siblings than precursors to Bloodborne, all offer a huge variety of arms and armor to choose from, from classic long swords to huge great swords, halberds, spears, crossbows, scythes, rapiers, and more. Each of these interacts with enemies in slightly different ways, including attach range, speed, knock back and knockdown. There is a huge amount of customization available for builds and strategies for dealing with the challenge of these games. By comparison, Bloodborne has a mere handful of weapons, each roughly translating to a class of weapons in Dark Souls. There is an axe that becomes a halberd, swords that become larger swords or hammers, quick daggers, a spear, a rapier, a katana, and a few others that can be counted on the fingers of one hand. This has led to the most common complaint I have heard about Bloodborne, that it needs more weapons. But does it?</p><p>Before diving into this, it is also worth mentioning what kind of RPG the SoulsBorne (or BloodSouls, whatever you prefer) games are in terms of Role Playing. These four games all take a blank slate approach to role playing, similar to the likes of the Elder Scroll<em>s</em> or Fallout series. In this style of game the player character is a blank slate that has no defining character traits, allowing the player to graft themselves easily into the action through the character, or to create their own backstory, however twisted and convoluted or simple and easy they may wish to be. The alternate mode is one in which the game presents a pre-defined character that the player is forced to empathize with merely by playing their role in the game. Think The Witcher games, or even God of War. Playing these characters forces the player to think in ways they might not have before, by presenting problems in an immediate way through the viewpoint of another person. The differences and various merits of these two systems could be the basis of a really interesting discussion on game design and how people interact with games, but for now I just want to emphasize that the SoulsBorne games are the blank slate variety of RPG, that aims to put the player directly in the game (and to clarify, I love these games, and have nothing against this style of storytelling in video games). But Dark Souls and Bloodborne employ this role playing model differently, and I think they do it through the number of weapons the games let the player choose from.</p><p>When I started playing Bloodborne, I wanted to try and pick up and try out every weapon with that first character. I named this character Edmunds, which seemed appropriately pretentious for the Victorian/Lovecraftian setting. As I started to collect a small arsenal, I realized that using some weapons just felt weird. The only starting weapon that felt appropriate for my character was the Threaded Cane. I played with the Saw Spear for a little while, then the Kirkhammer, and stuck with Ludwig’s Holy Blade for a while, but what finally really clicked was the Reiterpallasch, a rapier pistol combo. I had also been wearing Gascgoine’s set with the Top Hat for the whole game (after killing Gascgoine, obviously). I realized that I had created a story for Edmunds, and had been avoiding some weapons and armor not because I personally didn’t like them (that was the case with the Threaded Cane, but I liked the Saw Spear), but because they weren’t the stuff that Edmunds would use. He’s a gentlemen, and he hides his love of blood behind a stiff, formal exterior, always doing things according to tradition. He’s the kind of guy that would use a rapier, and a sophisticated pistol (Evelyn, for the moment). My original intention when I started was to eventually use Simon’s Bowblade, but ultimately Edmunds is not the kind of person that would use that weapon.</p><p>In all my time playing Souls, I had never approached weapon selection like that. I essentially had two kinds of character backgrounds, the normal soldier, or the spellsword. Normal soldiers didn’t use magic, and spellswords got to use magic. But the more nuanced choices of exactly what weapon the normal soldiers or the spellswords would use never came down to the choices of the characters, and they never developed their own personalities, by my will or through a slow subconscious process the way Edmunds has. My choices of what weapon to use always boiled down to my personal preference, with perhaps some limitations for wanting to use a weapon class I hadn’t previously touched. For example, I started Dark Souls 3 with a character that used a spear because I had never used that weapon class in a Souls game. In short, the abundance of weapons stopped me from thinking so much of my character as their own person, and kept me focused on what <em>I</em> wanted to do. Did I want to emphasize speed, power, reach, or defense? I never really created a character, in short. Instead, I put together a character build.</p><p>Could this be a question of world building, or how the characters are presented? These games certainly present themselves in different ways. Dark Souls creates an entire mythology, from creation myth, to legendary heroes and gods. The player moves between cities and countries, in an attempt to either save or destroy the world in its current state. Bloodborne has lower stakes, and takes a more personal dive in the psyche of man. It asks what it means to be a beast, and how close humans really are to savagery. But they also have their similarities. The characters start off in almost identical situations. Each starts in a small room with little information about how they got there, who they were before, or what they are supposed to do now. Each is given an objective, and each is being manipulated by one or more parties. I started off expecting Bloodborne to be much more of a Dark Souls clone that it is, and approached Bloodborne like I did Dark Souls. Edmunds is not the first pretentious name I’ve given a character, and it is perhaps among the more normal and unremarkable. Additionally, this creation of a character with their own preferences that trump my own is completely new. I played Skyrim, and I played Skyrim as myself, rather than as a character. In Fallout 4, I played the same way.</p><p>So how did limiting weapon choice force me to create personalities for my characters? In part this is probably because the low weapon count lets the animation team make each weapon feel unique in ways that are meaningful beyond questions of reach and knockdown effects. While weapons in Dark Souls are far from generic, the strict differences between the short sword, long sword, and broad sword exist more on a level of numbers than feeling. The short sword has all thrusting strong attacks, so it might be more useful with the Leo ring on counter hits, but the long sword has the same thrust on the first strong attack, and a longer range. The broad sword deals with crowds better, but scales slightly better with strength than dexterity, and is slightly shorter. Take this debate to Bloodborne and choose two similar weapons, say the Kirkhammer and Ludwig’s Holy Blade, both of which have the same moveset on the untransformed straight sword mode. Used like this they are exactly the same. But transform them and they become completely different weapons. This difference is further highlighted by the weapon art system in Dark Souls 3. While they add a new level of nuance to the combat, the fact that all long swords have the same weapon art, that all katanas have the same weapon art, adds new emphasis to the small nuances that exist between the individual weapons. Choosing between a katana or a straight sword is exactly like the choice between Ludwig’s Holy Sword and the Saw Cleaver in Bloodblorne. They rest on questions of style and feel. Are you making a character that prefers the raw simplicity of the long sword or Saw Cleaver, or the small flourishes at the end of the katanas or Holy Sword’s swings. But can the question of character preference survive the more nuanced question of broadsword versus longsword? Not for me.</p><p>The lore on items also drives a different kind of character building. Bloodborne items tell of how different sects of people approach using blood, whereas items in Dark Souls talk about nations in a broad sense, and therefore imply more general ideas about the person who might use them, rather than specifics about an individual’s approach to tradition. Edmunds has been wearing the Top Hat ever since he picked it up, and it has heavily influenced my perceptions of his character. By contrast, I made a character in Dark Souls 3 who would be a normal foot soldier. She could have used almost any melee weapon in the game across most of the weapon classes, and she could use any number of armor sets as well. The number of choices, while opening up lots of customization about the kind of character I wanted to make, left little room for me to consider the more subtle differences between the Northern set, the Chainmail, and the starting Knight armor, and what they would say about her character.</p><p>Game play is another major source of the story telling in these games, and is the major way that the player interacts with their worlds. Because Bloodborne limits the player’s choice for play style and appearance, it increases the importance that these choices have. Playing with the Saw Cleaver is vastly different from playing with the Kirkhammer. And while Dark Souls has the same implicit character building in choosing between the Long sword and the Greatsword, but the choices between the Greatsword and Greataxe, or the Estoc and the Spear, are less dramatic. For a game that was <em>more</em> focused on multiplayer interaction and competition, this nuance is good and important. Dark Souls was exactly this kind of game, and to maintain an active multiplayer scene it was necessary to have this range of choices, all of them viable. But From Software has changed their focus to emphasize the single player experience of their games. The multiplayer system in Bloodborne is slow and confusing, and the online community for Dark Souls 3 has noticed this change almost from the day of release. And having fewer weapons, especially in the smaller environment of Bloodborne increases immersion and player empathy with their character, thus increasing the effectiveness of the single player narrative. Neither of these decisions is objectively superior, and each was used to reinforce a desired player experience and world building goal.</p><p>This point about the multiplayer experience of Dark Souls, particularly Dark Souls 2, is precisely the reason I described my Dark Souls characters as builds. I went into those games knowing that I would face invasions, and wanting to engage in the active PvP communities that these games have developed. I don’t have a PSPlus account, and cannot play Bloodblorne online, so I don’t have to worry about optimizing my character beyond being viable against the PvE enemies, which leaves a lot more wiggle room than the exact precision required to build an optimal PvP character. The PvP mechanic also changes the way a player thinks about fights. The character is fighting PvE enemies, but PvP matches, invasions or duels, are player versus player, and really emphasize the person sitting behind the screen over the character moving through the game world. Perhaps if I played Dark Souls offline, without worrying about invasions and without the intent to engage in PvP I would end up creating a more detailed character than I have previously.</p><p>No matter how you feel about the weapon options in Bloodborne it is hard to argue that From Software did not make that decision without reason, and their skills in game design are hard to argue with. Regardless of whether or not they decided to include fewer weapons for world building or empathy reasons (time restraints are a thing, after all), there is a reason behind the choice. Or perhaps it was an oversight, or an ill-advised design choice. What do you think?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=260fbe369c53" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Batman v Superman but Wonder Woman stole the show]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@a.gittingham/batman-v-superman-but-wonder-woman-stole-the-show-4019d1a9bcc2?source=rss-6d1654b42500------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4019d1a9bcc2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[superheroes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ben Doolittle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 27 Mar 2016 07:00:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-03-27T07:00:30.353Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The problem with <em>Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice</em> is that there is only one real superhero in it, and her name isn’t in the title.</p><p>For the sake of transparency, I’m not hugely familiar with the comic books that this movie is drawing from. As such, my reaction to this movie is not that of a longtime fan of these characters with a vast store of knowledge of backstories, character arcs, and usual characterizations, but rather as a writer.</p><p>Spoilers follow.</p><p>I went into the theater to see this movie having glanced through one or two reviews that were mostly negative. I was not a huge fan of <em>Man of Steel</em> and didn’t think that DC would be able to build a cinematic universe with the scale of the MCU in less than half the number of movies. I was not thrilled with <em>Dawn of Justice</em>, but it was disappointing in ways that I didn’t expect. The storytelling was heavy handed, and the movie drips with symbolism, but these don’t get in the way as much as I thought they would. The acting of the principal characters was good, which is perhaps a controversial statement.</p><p>As a fan of action movies I found the fight choreography to be very good, but the way it was filmed was downright appalling. It was nearly impossible to keep track of who was where and doing what, even when the action was taking place at normal human speeds. The goal in many of these scenes was to show off the fighting abilities of Batman, and even though much of the action is indistinct and blurry, his prowess is undeniable. Undeniable to the point that his detective skills seem to have fallen through the floors he is punching heads into. Movies have been overlooking Batman’s detective skills for a long time, that is nothing new, but <em>Dawn of Justice</em> has taken this to new depths. The worst example of this in the movie is when Batman is about to kill Superman, and Kal-El tells him to save Martha. The movie shows us, in the entire sequence building up to this epic clash of the titans, that Batman is excellent at planning ahead. He prepares kryptonite weapons, and even starts building the Justice League. But in the entire two years that Bruce Wayne has spent planning his route towards revenge on Superman, he has been unable to deduce who Superman is, or learn anything else significant about him. In every other story line when Batman and Superman meet, that I know about, Batman knows who Superman is. It is what Batman does, because he is the world’s greatest detective.</p><p>But this is not the only way that Zach Snyder is re-creating the DC universe. Batman has been reduced to a man good at punching things, and excellent at shooting things. Superman is perfectly willing to slam people through walls at super-sonic speeds. Neither of these characters is afraid of killing, in a major break of form for both characters. Diehard fans of the comics will find this hard to accept, and it may perhaps even be unforgivable, but I think this is an interesting turn that shows off one of the great things about comic books and their characters that has been true from the beginning. The characters change over time and meet alternate versions of themselves from different universes who hold drastically different values about justice and how to enforce it. And each new writer or artist who takes up the torch infuses these characters with some new twist, their own take on what it means to be Batman or Superman. Most of these authors agree on certain things, hold certain aspects of these characters as standard. A good example of this is the “no killing” rule of both characters, which <em>Dawn of Justice</em> has broken. The only story line that I can think of where this is repeated is when the Justice League is transported to a parallel universe where they meet the Justice Lords, versions of themselves who have essentially taken over the world, and aren’t afraid to kill to maintain justice in their new order. So I’m interested to see where this new version of Batman will take us, and I really did enjoy both Ben Affleck’s and Henry Cavill’s performance in their respective roles. Gal Gadot and Amy Adams also performed well as Wonder Woman and Lois Lane respectively. I think my unfamiliarity with the comics proved an advantage here, and let me enjoy the movie a little more than I might have been able to otherwise. Nonetheless, these things did bother me, and definitely had a negative impact of my impression of the movie, but they were not the source of my biggest problem with it.</p><p>The problem I have with this movie is, as I stated at the beginning, the fact that the two titular characters do not deserve the title of “hero”. They are, of course, doing the best they can to save as many people as possible, and they are both without a doubt noble in their own ways. But they are not heroes. A hero is not allowed to give up, not allowed to fold under the pressure of a task that is impossible. Both Batman and Superman do this, they give up on promises and on the goodness of men, only to realize that promises can be kept and do mean something and that there are good men. But these questions should never have to be asked in a superhero film. It is entirely possible to question what it means to be a hero, a question that has been asked by both Marvel and DC on multiple occasions. Both franchises have characters that have fall victim to their darker sides, and have had reason to question their own goodness. But in the end, it is only anti-heroes like Punisher or John Constantine who get to give up on humanity. Giving up is a human thing to do, but the whole idea of a superhero is that they are more than human, either literally, Superman, or metaphorically, Batman. They are characters that show us the very pinnacle of what it is possible to be, physically and mentally (if very rarely emotionally). For all of his symbolism that elevates Superman to godhood, Zach Snyder does not seem to realize that superheroes are meant to be more than human, and that they are still able to address serious issues and be realistic and gritty and relevant in an academic way. Wonder Woman is the only character in this movie who fits my definition of a hero, and she is barely relevant.</p><p>I say Wonder Woman is barely relevant because she has an extremely limited amount of screen time. But her character actually fits the superhero model that Bruce Wayne and Clark Kent fail to step up to. Perhaps one of the best moments in the film is after Doomsday throws Wonder Woman across the battlefield, and as she watches him leap after her she grins in sheer anticipation and enjoyment, right before hacking off Doomsday’s hand. It is this unwillingness to acknowledge that she could, probably will, fail that makes her a hero. She doesn’t engage in the brooding on the nature of humanity of Batman or Superman. While she does admit to having left the world of men after witnessing the horrors of the World War One, I see that more as a way to give Lex Luthor the chance to find her, along with the rest of the Justice League cast. She never questions whether or not Superman or Batman are good or evil, even though she clearly knows who Batman is when she first meets him. She, like the Batman and Superman of the comics, recognizes that each is working towards the same goal, just through different methods. Her performance is the most faithful to the comics, and the most faithful to the idea of the superhero.</p><p>Overall, I was disappointed with this film not because of acting, which I thought was strong, or overall storytelling, which was largely bearable. But this is not a superhero movie, and it does not do the comics it claims to draw inspiration from justice.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4019d1a9bcc2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>