<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Sour Punk on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Sour Punk on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@aayushibengani1994?source=rss-200a1429a6e9------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 11:12:16 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@aayushibengani1994/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Intellectual scarcity]]></title>
            <link>https://aayushibengani1994.medium.com/intellectual-scarcity-e49d566bfd49?source=rss-200a1429a6e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e49d566bfd49</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sour Punk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Nov 2026 15:27:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-13T15:28:00.758Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1UdS6yn13aVs7Kfc-kbk7Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Douglass campus, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, New Jersey</figcaption></figure><p>Stories of people who have been marginalised are so focused on their marginalisation that they don’t see anything else about their lives. But the people don’t conduct or view themselves only in terms of scarcity. They sing, they write, they dance, they enjoy, they scream, they celebrate as well. Much like anybody else. But stories of their dehumanisation forget that they are humans too. They reduce them to being subjects of society rather than agents who actively constitute it. Marginalisation is decapacitating, but representing only that takes depacacitation to a more fundamental level. The deprivation that is otherwise social becomes ontological. In the eyes of the privileged, how they are treated becomes how they are.</p><p>Even if an academia looks into the so-called cultural aspects of the lives of people who have been marginalised, such as music, literature, or cinema, it is to explore how marginalisation shapes the content and form of the cultural practices of people. Marginalisation becomes an all-encompassing reality of their lives, with every other aspect subsumed by it. Further, even if an academia questions or moves away from marginalisation-based representations of the people, it engages with and circulates the same images that it critiques in the first place. The effects of the use of such images only tighten the association of the people with their marginalisation, further essentialising the connection between the two.</p><p>Criticality is rarely thought and enacted at the level of images or effects. Tina Campt’s focus on what she calls “the practices of refusal” of visual artists, where even as they highlight marginalisation, they reject to reduce lives to the palate or even consumption of others, stands out.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e49d566bfd49" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reflections on resistance]]></title>
            <link>https://aayushibengani1994.medium.com/resist-stance-f952c3c45816?source=rss-200a1429a6e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f952c3c45816</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sour Punk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 10 Oct 2026 19:24:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-13T15:33:18.612Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The ongoing student-led protests against the central government in India have been noteworthy for many reasons, key among which is their play, especially with the idea of resistance. The left across academia, art, and activism has historically conceived resistance in a way that ironically is alienating, incapacitating, and fear-inducing. These protests, since April, have challenged many notions attached to the idea of resistance.</p><p>First, that resistance is against the system at large. Resistance thinking usually is so structural and systemic that it only operates at a macro level, where nothing less than a fall of capitalism or fascism is resistance enough. It’s all or nothing. It lacks the ability to have specific, immediate goals that can be accomplished in real, practical time. I am not a Keynesian, but I do think, “In the long run, we are all dead.”</p><p>Like many on the left, I too was initially unimpressed with the demand for the education minister’s resignation, for the government would and did replace the position with another stooge of theirs. It seemed like an easy demand by protestors and much easier for the regime to fulfill. But the slogans against the education minister’s resignation gradually created murmurs for the prime minister’s resignation, and that is why and when the regime had to respond and meet the demand. And now, the demand for the election commissioner’s resignation has created much more than murmurs for the prime minister’s resignation. These protests are a good example of a targeted approach to the system.</p><p>Second, that resistance is ideological. A lot of the early criticism from the left regarding the protests is that they are apolitical. That they are centered on middle-class issues, and are silent on those of Palestine or those raised by Birsa-Phule-Ambedkar. Although I am not a fan of Gandhi myself, I cannot ignore the effect his image has on people. Similarly, I am not in favor of reducing Ambedkar to the Constitution, but I cannot ignore that most people know of Ambedkar through this text. I was particularly happy on the day I saw a post/er that brought Gandhi and Ambedkar together to mobilize people for these protests. Historical giants and rivals, they also continuosly interacted with each other.</p><p>What the political parties in the opposition have failed to convincingly do, these protests have ensured — a coalition. Given the wide support and appeal the prime minister enjoys, it is impractical to expect people to gather against him or his parent organization as a starting point. It is an achievement of these protests to have some of the same “apolitical” people realize the ill-intentionality and -suitability of this man and raise their voice against him. The hitherto “if not him, who else?” among those left or right of the center is certainly shaking. By reclaiming the popular imagination, be it through Gandhi, corruption, or the Constitution, these protests have brought huge numbers of people together, shaking this man’s support base. This tremor has been cultivated through issues, not ideologies.</p><p>Third, that resistance is moral. Ideology very subtly and slyly assumes and becomes morality. Authoritarianism has usually been fought on moral grounds; dignity, justice, rights, etc., are all terms that come from and connote a sense of what is good or bad, right or wrong. But psychology says that what favors one’s own self seems good, and what doesn’t seem bad. So long as the problem is described as causing harm to someone else, somewhere else, or sometime else, it’s difficult for the self to take it seriously. Whereas if a problem concerns the self, in the here and now, we lose our shit, and our shit does hit the roof. There is, therefore, a need to <em>not </em>other the problem. The problem needs to seem our own and immediate for the self to be bothered by it and do something about it. Where the personal has been translated into the political in the last few decades, there has been little effort to translate the political into the personal. Humanity, equality, and fraternity for the other don’t compel the self to take to the streets, but an issue described as adversely affecting the self surely does.</p><p>Academics, activists, and artists all operate on a moral high ground. This morality, I suspect, across social positions, comes purely from their engagement with knowledge. Although access to and the pursuit of knowledge are still not ordinary, I wonder whether it is knowledge itself that makes them feel morally superior. Just as the architecture of elite universities&#39; buildings makes the selected student feel special, there must be something in the architecture of the very knowledge that makes the reader feel separate from and above others (could this get more Brahmanical). How problems are theorized shapes how we see, think about, and engage with them. Us-versus-them, or perpetrator-versus-victim, is as much a sociological problem as it is a social one. These protests brought people from such a wide range of roles and positions together that intellectuals initially critical of them now have to not just reckon with but also contribute to them.</p><p>Fourth, that resistance is of and for the working class. The historical idea of resistance as emerging from the poor and marginalized has shifted the responsibility for it onto them. It is not uncommon to come across statements like “let’s wait and see,” “this is the crescendo before the fall,” or “the poor will rise” from intellectuals and liberals. Isn’t it ridiculous to expect somebody who has been wronged to bring redress? It is not just the entire judicial system that rests on this idea, but also the entire sociological system. Theories of social change view domination and resistance as mutually arising from and constituting each other. The arrival of justice is hinged on the victim of injustice. Like how there is a book titled “The Adivasi will not dance,” somebody should write a title, “The poor will not rise.” Just to contest this expectation and romanticization of struggle from/of the people who are poor. This is violence in itself, which too is epistemic.</p><p>Although low-income people have significantly shown their support and participation in the protests from the beginning, the faces leading the protests are from the urban middle class. Irrespective, the protests show the middle class that this regime is not on their side either, that as long as this regime wins, they lose, and that this regime is an illness that they need to get rid of. The protests tune in to the current reality of precarity engulfing the middle classes and of the communal rhetoric making their daily lives difficult.</p><p>Fifth, that resistance is serious. To resist is to struggle, to endure hardship, and to embrace discomfort. The literature that I have read about leaders in social movements is replete with the imagery of being underground, secretive, and away from any source of light and life. Resistance, considering the lives of those who have practised it, is not life-giving. The idea of resistance is so tightly bound with deprivation that it is difficult to imagine those engaging in it having fun. These protests have decimated that sense and sensibility altogether. The way protesters have used phone cameras and social media —typically perceived by the left as weapons of war and control — to initiate, consolidate, and sustain their activities is remarkable. What is even better is that they haven’t only used these tools for communication, but for entertainment, enabling them to reach, attract, and invite wider audiences.</p><p>Much before professors, lawyers, doctors, opposition leaders, actors, or comedians came in support, there were memes on display for sloganeering, popular film songs playing, groups of protesters dancing and singing, superhero and cartoon caricatures roaming, fans mimicking heroes, among the countless forms of entertainment available at the protest sites. Reels made there created legitimate fomo among people who were watching online. “Protest bohot zor se aa rahi hai,” captioned a reel, showing a young man at his work desk, finding it difficult not to check his phone and join everybody else on the ground. Another reel featured an SRK fan enacting his extended-arms pose for the police, making them laugh. One of the police personnel standing there picked up his camera to record this. Where it has been the protesters documenting every act of police brutality on their phone cameras, it was interesting to see the dynamic turn around. The media has surely been crucial for both domination and resistance, but this protest reaffirms my belief particularly in the power of entertainment. A signboard at the protest site captures it very well: “The Club of Constitution.” How else does one make sense of and change the situation?</p><p>Of course, these protests have limitations, such as the way women protesters and journalists have been treated by male protesters, and the way the protesters’ organization or defense can be stronger. The protesters need to be accountable for this, but it is important to recognize what makes the protests effective. As I write this piece, I realize a lot of the left’s notions associated with resistance come from religion. That’s thought for another article. But as I write against these notions, my intention is only to point out that they have become rigid as rules, issuing character certificates for acts and activities of resistance. I am not against these principles, but I do want to highlight that resistance, irrespective of how you approach it, is strategic and creative first and everything else afterwards. This is what the left excruciatingly lacks today.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f952c3c45816" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The public in publication]]></title>
            <link>https://aayushibengani1994.medium.com/the-public-in-publication-6ac7e9b7a88e?source=rss-200a1429a6e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6ac7e9b7a88e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sour Punk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 05 Oct 2026 03:45:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-05T04:18:54.013Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>More than scholarly</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dquNqn7brBs6Ql9TREH4fQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Self-help literature is looked down upon by those in the creative fields. The problems that are pointed out certainly hold. Simplistic representation and lack of qualification are key among them. Without credibility or credit, this literature deserves more than acknowledgment; it calls for engagement.</p><p>What is often overlooked by intellectuals is that scientists, too, contribute to the self-help literature. Their works might not be popular among the readers, but they are part of the conversation and the space it occupies. And that makes a huge difference.</p><p>Legitimate medical practitioners and scholars have published works on topics such as improving nutrition, interpersonal communication, or self-worth that contain genuinely useful knowledge the reader wouldn’t otherwise learn.</p><p>If they were not influencers on Instagram, podcasters on YouTube, writers on Substack, or authors of self-help books, there was no way this knowledge, institutionally kept behind closed doors, could reach and be relevant to people at large.</p><p>I attended an academic workshop this week where taking the scholarship to the public was a key point of discussion and disagreement. This was primarily in terms of scholars&#39; use of difficult language and lack of engagement with policy and mass communication.</p><p>Arguments made both for and against made sense, but what stayed with me was that if the scholar doesn&#39;t occupy the public space, somebody else will. Because somebody else already does, irrespective of the scholar&#39;s thinking around it or in their work.</p><p>While I was doing my master&#39;s ten years ago, a professor had suggested I work at a daily newspaper rather than a fortnightly magazine. Be in the mainstream industry, he had said. I have come to increasingly value his advice.</p><p>But to occupy the main stream would require getting down the high horse and walking down the streets; getting out of the mind and getting the hands dirty. This would mean doing a bit of chopping, mixing, and spicing up of scholarly knowledge with more-than-scholarly ones.</p><p>As interdisciplinarity becomes a buzzword in textbooks and classrooms, it is important to remember that it is not a goal in itself. Its underlying point has always been an interworlding of knowledges, for it’s a different world out there.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6ac7e9b7a88e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[December in May]]></title>
            <link>https://aayushibengani1994.medium.com/december-in-may-2a1b0641bbb5?source=rss-200a1429a6e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2a1b0641bbb5</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sour Punk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 10 Jun 2026 11:47:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-15T07:12:25.507Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It is not uncommon to see acts of generosity in local trains in Mumbai. This is only in non-peak hours though. A recent commute back home at the end of the day made my day. Credit two instances.</p><p><strong>Instance one</strong></p><p>I was very hungry. It was late in the night with no shops around open to eat. Thankfully, I saw a female vendor sitting at the main entrance of the station selling fryums. I bought a packet, the one with masala on fryums. I paid and went to the ticket vending machine. As I was waiting to get my ticket, a young boy came near me, handed me a ten-rupee coin saying I had paid extra, and ran back to the vendor.</p><p>He was her son. It then occurred to me that I had paid twenty instead of ten. It shouldn’t be a revelation or surprise, but it certainly was a reminder — that everybody, no matter what, always has things to lose. This I say in response to those who think those in power have everything to lose whereas those powerless have nothing to lose. Integrity is a choice and it has a cost.</p><p><strong>Instance two</strong></p><p>I was still hungry, now sitting in the train. It is usually deep-fried items like fryums that are sold here, so I had made up my mind to not eat more. Soon, a female vendor came with a big round basket full of jamun. She said it was from a village nearby. I got two plates for fifty rupees.</p><p>It was unbelievable for various reasons. First, to get a fruit at such a low price given the ongoing price escalation due to the US-Israel war on Iran. It served as a reminder of how popular economies such as these are not dependent on international events and fluctuations. They are a national asset both in times of crisis and in everyday life.</p><p>Second, to get a fruit at such a low price because fruits are an expensive affair in general in cities. It took me back to a conversation a friend and I had on campus a few years ago. He had mentioned how it pained him to pay so much for jamun in Delhi, a fruit that he got in abundance from the trees where he grew up in a town in Bihar but where he and his family no longer lived.</p><p>The vendor asked me if I wanted masala sprinkled on jamun. I nodded, my eyes filled with delight. I remembered how such a handful of jamun served on a piece of paper with masala was an essential part of my annual train journey for summer holidays during school. With my family, I would be a long-distance train to Rourkela. My younger maternal uncle would dutifully and happily accompany us on these rides to ensure that we reached safely, but we are no longer in touch with him.</p><p>It was summer then and it is summer now, but a time of summer that heralds monsoon. The smell of masala on jamun is among the smells that I associate with monsoon. This is from a time when I had not stayed in coastal areas like I have in the last ten years. So, being from Jaipur, all I had then were the plains and their humble rains.</p><p>Soon after I finished eating, I found myself yearning to sing Feliz Navidad. A song of joy, again from childhood. I put my earphones on, played the lyrics video on YouTube, and sang it, looking through the window and enjoying the wind as usual. I sang it on loop like it was no one’s business till I reached my station. This is a Christmas carol, a winter song that I was singing in the thick of summer.</p><p>One of the lines in Anurag Kashyap’s <em>Manmarziyan </em>describes love as <em>april may vich december naache</em> (when the celebratory feeling of December is felt in the heat of April-May). These small small acts that take place in and around the local on a daily basis are life-affirming. They make you feel rich like little else in these expensive, faraway, lonely cities.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2a1b0641bbb5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The seths and babus of academia]]></title>
            <link>https://aayushibengani1994.medium.com/feudal-feudal-academia-1e783014ed63?source=rss-200a1429a6e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1e783014ed63</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sour Punk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 May 2026 12:19:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-08T12:55:12.160Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I was sitting and waiting for my turn for the interview round. This was outside a faculty office in the building of the School of Development Studies. I was one of the many applicants there seeking admission in the university’s flagship program, MA in Development Studies. As I waited for over an hour, I saw a young man walk into the office room with a cup of tea, with a plate of meal, and with snacks at different times. I remember feeling weird at the irony of what I was seeing. My feeling only grew stronger when I went in for my interview, a chance used by the three professors on the panel to make me feel like I knew nothing.</p><p>Of course, I didn’t get admission there. Retrospectively, I couldn’t be more thankful. For I got selected in another MA program in another School, my second preference on the university application, which was much more critical of power relations. Despite a panel of five faculty members, daunting as some of them looked in their silver hair and black dresses, I left my interview feeling quite good. They asked me more along the lines of what I knew and how I felt about what I knew rather than what they thought I should know. I ended up saying things that I had not just not prepared for but had not even processed on my own. For instance, I realized it then that Kamla Das’s poem on her ageing mother had stayed with me. Their criticality also reflected in the fact that there wasn’t any staff bringing food and beverages into the faculty room during the interview. Rather, now that I am thinking, I didn’t see any staff providing the faculty with these in-house services ever during my two years of coursework. I don’t think the School had anybody for such services at all. Instead, what I remember is the faculty at the coffee machine, the canteen, the mess, the tapri — the most frequented. They would go out of their cabin/office/School to eat at the same places as available to students.</p><p>When I visited my PhD guide last year, four of the eight students working with her were present in her office. I had gone there for some paperwork, another person was studying sitting in the office as usual, and two more joined eventually. As I was about to leave, a man walked in with four plates of dosas and other food items, placed them on the table, and left. It was lunch time. The guide and the three scholars were going to eat in the office and the guide was providing food for all. It seemed that it happened often. One of the three scholars stood up and started clearing the table to make space for the plates, also wiping the table using a cloth in her hand. Sitting at the table, the professor laughed how she hadn’t grown so old yet and could do it herself. Completing the task, the scholar made another joke and they both laughed together. Guilty that I wasn’t doing something for her, I asked the professor if I should switch on the AC. She agreed and I did. I soon left. Horrified and nauseated.</p><p>Yet, this was not the first time I was seeing the powerplay of faculty over others like staff and students. There is one professor who is crowded by students everyday when he gets in and out of his car in the parking lot, so students could touch his feet in the hope of getting a job placement. Stories like these abound in the university campus, where guides expect their students to open the lock of their office door or clean their office floor every morning. The air reeks of hierarchy and subordination to the authority. It is difficult not to succumb to the pressure. I once happened to be exiting my guide’s office with her at the end of the working day. I asked her if I could take some of the things she was holding like the water bottle and one of the bags and she agreed. I walked holding these things for her as we reached her car in the parking lot and bid each other a good bye.</p><p>It is to escape internalizing these behaviors of subjugation that I stay away from campus as much as possible. But some things are inescapable. For instance, the guides expect their students to depend on them for writing and publishing papers. It is so ubiquitous and ingrained in students that students themselves seek this dependence and feel obliged when guides co-publish with them. Of course it is without any contribution of the guide, but it has been normalized to an extent that questioning it makes you stand apart and excluded. The result is scholars’ dependence on the so-called doles and benevolence of the guides. The guides demand students’ dependence.</p><p>Making others depend on you for their subsistence is at the root of caste and patriarchy. Academia is no less. Like the dominant caste men, professors want those below them to be available for labor. Without any investment, they feel entitled to harvest others’ labor and feel threatened if not conceded. Like the middle, also dominant, caste groups of men, professors are the actual oppressors in academia on the ground. The seth of the farm. The babu of bureaucracy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1e783014ed63" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Starry starry bucks]]></title>
            <link>https://aayushibengani1994.medium.com/starbucks-or-the-poor-d1d07ffffff5?source=rss-200a1429a6e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d1d07ffffff5</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sour Punk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Apr 2026 16:43:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-08T12:19:52.664Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I came to Starbucks today. The day I want to step out but can’t sit in the library because it seems too far or is closed I spend studying at the Starbucks nearby. It happens once in a few months. Of all my times here, I have placed an order only rarely, that too because I had to buy something due to my continuous visit for two days or more. I am currently in the 5th year of my PhD and Starbucks has been a kind of second library to me throughout this time.</p><p>I have been visiting it much before I started my PhD though. I remember when it began and I guess this is how. I pinpoint this moment because I don’t have a memory of visiting Starbucks in general or especially for study purposes that precedes this moment.</p><p>It was 2018 when I was working on a research project on rental housing discrimination. The project’s principal investigator and co-senior researcher would arrange for a meeting with the rest of the researchers at a Starbucks to exchange and deliberate over the insights we were collecting with various actors in the housing market. We mainly interviewed brokers and other real-estate agents in localities across income categories, owing to which we had low-income residents as some of our key interviewees.</p><p>Isn’t it unethical to be studying the poor sitting at Starbucks, I asked my fellow senior researcher. The epistemological divide between the researcher and the researched and the consequent epistemic violence was too in-your-face to be ignored. The co-senior researcher laughed it off and reverse-questioned me: do you think academia is some kind of pure place for ethical politics?</p><p>We didn’t get a chance to talk further about this, but his point was we are merely a cog in the wheel, indicating how academia exists within the larger structure of oppression and we researchers within it. Not that I wasn’t aware of the structural dynamics, it was thoroughly discomforting to see such obvious alignment of social researchers with elite eateries.</p><p>My professors during my master’s too would dine in big cafes and live in bigger houses. Like most of us students, they came from well-off families and were concerned with doing something about the disparity between people like them that constituted the thinker class and people like the urban poor that became their food for thought.</p><p>Maybe not transport, but there was hardly any marker of their lifestyle that didn’t dwell in the comfort of privilege. Their leaning to the poor was only in their talk, not in their lifestyle. Not that I was or am any different from them, but I was just getting introduced to academia then, hoping to have mentors who practiced what they preached.</p><p>But where does one draw the line? Where it is OK to use the AC at home, to go to New York City for a conference, but not to buy from Zara? Where it is OK to indulge in rural and environmental landscapes like a tourist-traveler, but not to think along these lines inside the classroom? Where it is OK not to feel responsible to concern your study or yourself with the poor if you don’t make any claims like that?</p><p>A friend, a former colleague at a rural NGO who continues to work on rural-tribal questions, recently shared how he felt uncomfortable about going to fancy restaurants for dating. I asked him why, to which he said because the people he works with can’t afford these places. Sometimes it is fine, but he didn’t want to make it a part of his lifestyle, he added.</p><p>I interjected him saying but the people you are talking about do aspire to a similar lifestyle. Yes, but they cannot afford it, he reverted. So, it is a matter of access, I asked. He affirmed. Although he seemed convinced with his reasoning, my dissatisfaction with it was obvious on my face.</p><p>It reminds me of an earlier conversation with a professor in the initial years of my PhD. You are asking me to draw a line for you, but you will have to draw it for yourself, she had said. Fair enough. It is a journey of self-discovery and -change and I can’t be expecting certainty or spoon feeding here.</p><p>Although I do see the structure, I also see the difference an individual can make within it. Forget the big names of history, anybody who has had a supportive parent, teacher, partner knows the power an individual can exert. Yes, the conditions of knowledge production mediate the individual and the structure, but one can choose to deviate from them.</p><p>Clearly, knowing and thinking fall short; rather, they are part of the problem. Scholars like Tina Campt present feeling and embodying as alternative ways of engaging with disparity. But knowing that her life too revolves around the elite university and the elite museum, it doesn’t seem likely that the affective and sensory engagement that she argues for percolates to her lifestyle.</p><p>Does it need to though? I don’t know. Also, no matter where you draw the line, it depends on where you engage from, right? Starbucks in the USA is considered cheap and will be your cheapest bet if you happen to be there. Or perhaps how you engage with? But that’s exactly the question I began this article with. Time for a long deep breath — of tiredness.</p><p>P.S. Read the poor in quotes and comprising of disadvantage in varying forms here.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d1d07ffffff5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Treasure hunt]]></title>
            <link>https://aayushibengani1994.medium.com/treasure-hunt-1641adc9992b?source=rss-200a1429a6e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1641adc9992b</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sour Punk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Mar 2026 16:17:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-22T14:46:52.638Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When I was applying for a PhD, I gave it all. My application wasn’t successful year after year and I couldn’t understand why. I had gotten so emotionally attached to it that it came as a shock to me when my application didn’t convert the third time also. A shock because I truly believed in “Agar kisi cheez ko dil se chaaho to puri kayanat usey tumse milane ki koshish mein lag jaati hai.” Or as they say, “Itni shiddat se maine tumhe paane ki koshish ki hai … ki har zarre ne mujhe tumse milane ki saazish ki hai<em>.” </em>Although both these dialogues from the movie Om Shanti Om came much later in my life, the idea at their core, their very essence, is the stuff that folklore is made of. It entered my life long before I realized it.</p><p>Here is a tale that I had subconsciously clung to much of my teens and twenties. A mother asks her daughter to feed lord Krishna one afternoon because she has to go somewhere. The mother leaves the food on the plate for the girl and the girl dutifully goes and feeds the lord. On return when the mother doesn’t see the food near the statue in the temple and asks her daughter about it, the latter nonchalantly expresses that the lord ate it. Perplexed, the mother then realizes that the girl, in her innocence, invited Krishna with such a pure heart that Krishna actually came and ate the food. The moral of the story is shiddat, or so my grandmother told me.</p><p>It was only later, a few years into my PhD, that I realized my application was missing focus as well as strategy. I understood then that it doesn’t matter how deeply you feel for something. Like how it doesn’t matter how deeply you feel for someone, a few other experiences had taught me this by then. Feeling is at best one of the many resources at one’s disposal that are required to make something or someone work in one’s favor. Much of my daily effort during my application years went into feeling right and feeling ready. It continues to date, when I am supposedly in the final year of my PhD but nowhere close to completion.</p><p>Yesterday, it occurred to me that what I did with my application then is what I have been doing through my PhD as well: making myself feel ready to study; bringing myself up, in the right headspace, in the zone. Except for the days I went out for data collection, I have pretty much spent most of my PhD in propelling myself to feel able to study. I have studied day after day and done what is called the hard work, but my effort has certainly gone more into readying myself to study than into studying itself.</p><p>Everybody around me who has seen me or talked to me knows that I am passionate about my study. Here, I have been successful. I wanted them to know that and, more importantly, I wanted myself to feel that — to bring myself to study. Although I did not actively talk about or exhibit my inclination or investment in my study, it showed. That’s why I wanted to internally feel it so strongly that it appears on the surface on its own. That it does the talking for me. And it did. It has, time and again.</p><p>Except that now when I have long been expected to deliver outputs, I have none. No literature review, no chapters, no papers. No output whatsoever. Except a few scribbled notes here and there of a few readings and a little fieldwork. Having spent over the last four years of my PhD so obsessed with feeling right, it is only now that the severity of delivering right has hit me. I wonder, where are my deliverables, where is my output! I now realize that I don’t need to be so concerned with oiling my machinery that I am not left with energy for working it.</p><p>The input-output ratio is disproportionate in my case, that too not just quantitatively but qualitatively. My input has been more in terms of feeling rather than reading and writing, which is what it means and requires to do a PhD. If the input has not been concrete, how can the output be concrete! What I can hear myself say today is this: Make it material, make it concrete; no need to feel right; time and tide truly wait for none; no work has ever given anybody any time to feel right; that is how experience is; you are not required to feel right or ready; what is required of you is work, meaning doing. Just do and deliver.</p><p>Target output, not feeling. Although it is my present self that needs to hear this, if somebody were to ask the soon-to-be-32-year-old me for one advice I would give my younger self, it would be this: target output, not feeling.</p><p>Maybe this is what purpose means. But it is so vague. Purpose is so vague and so asbtract. One can easily get lost in finding purpose, as one often does. A former friend would feel ashamed at not having found his purpose and would remain deeply tensed about it. What I would tell him then, I am all the more sure of it now: You can’t find it, you have to build it; much like how it is with love, or with anything for that matter; there is nothing out there for you to find and get hold of.</p><p>This is how I have approached research so far, like a treasure hunt, where I venture out, wander around, immerse in the surrounds, and return with jewels in my hands. Little did I know that treasure lies not outside but within. And it requires not snooping, but sitting — sitting with what you have, day in and day out, building it, and polishing it. This is as much true for research and PhD as it is for life.</p><p>Output is concrete. Target output.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1641adc9992b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[This is not a sentence]]></title>
            <link>https://aayushibengani1994.medium.com/words-and-their-constellations-aeb944720418?source=rss-200a1429a6e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/aeb944720418</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sour Punk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 11 Feb 2026 09:03:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-11T17:25:44.534Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I finally completed reading AbdouMaliq Simone’s article titled ‘Urban life at the extensions’ yesterday. It is published in the journal The South Atlantic Quarterly, year 2024, volume 123, issue 2. Spread over twenty pages, the article is packed with profundity. There are so many words and thoughts packed in every sentence that by the time you near its end, you realize you need to read again.</p><p>Reading Soloman Benjamin, Wing Shing Tang, and AbdouMaliq Simone has never been easy for me. But this writing of Simone’s is particularly difficult. Most sentences span five lines, laden with many tough terms and ideas. Words like <em>congeal</em>, <em>immanent</em>, <em>rambunctious</em>, <em>incommensurable</em>; <em>prolongation</em>, <em>connotation</em>, <em>interjection</em>, <em>interdiction </em>— I can go on and on. And thoughts, such as he calls into question the urban scholars’ preoccupation with settlement by positing that all matter moves and all human beings move — that are just one small part of one sentence. Time to spotlight the elephant in the room — the sentence itself. Take this sample from the text: <em>The extensions, far from embodying the connotation of stability and moral coherence that colonizers presumed to impose, were spaces of intensive volatility, saturated with brutality and an entanglement of terror and pleasure </em>— <em>the terror of the extent to which brutality could engender pleasure, and the pleasure accrued through the terror entailed in the suspension of principles and order</em>. This could have been a minimum of four separate sentences. This is not a sentence; this is a paragraph. This is horror. This is war.</p><p>I need not mention that I had to pause at every line, reading it twice, even thrice, to grasp what he is trying to say. This is also because there are hardly any empirical details in the text. The whole writing is in the abstract. It seems like a distillation of Simone’s decades-long experience with the urban concerns in the global South. It reads like the kind of writing that usually comes at the end of a long, prolific career of a giant in the field that Simone is. Too metaphysical to be understood fully, it is the kind of text that makes you think that perhaps you have read it before you should have. I couldn’t read it even three hours after having my meal. Unlike usual, being empty stomach was not enough to make space for what Simone had to say. Complete attention proved insufficient to register his thoughts, let alone processing them. Reading this text left my mind not just exhausted but numb, devoid of any energy to wander the way it typically does. What a total mind-fuck.</p><p>Simone himself once admitted in an academic interview that he is not much of a reader, as it takes him multiple readings to understand a text, and that he grasps things better on ground. There, I could totally see myself in him. I have not been a fan of dense and verbose writing, the kind that you see in literature and academia. I think it is unnecessary and inaccessible. I am aware that these texts are not meant to be read by the last person in line, but students engaged in scholarship too have a great difficulty in making sense of them. These writings are to up your game, a fellow scholar once contended. Since the thought in them is so complicated, shouldn’t their communication be simple then, I asked him in return. Students do try to match the style and length of such writing, with language support from senior scholars, faculty members, and digital tools. But they do it not because they see any reason in it; they do it because they know it is the norm, the requirement, the very language of academia. Reading Simone’s interview a few years ago only reaffirmed my perspective. Why then is Simone, of all the scholars, resorting to this kind of writing now? Has Simone’s wisdom gained through a lifetime of experience brought him to thinking this way about writing? Coming from him, the article makes me think whether that fellow scholar was right; whether complex thoughts can only be expressed through complex words and their even more complex constellations. I sincerely hope not.</p><p>I am certain I will have to read every line of every sentence of this article several times more — make notes, notes of notes, notes of notes of notes — to dig out the meaning buried deep within it. If I survive this, I aim to track the flow of ideas, and maybe in another life, arrive at the overall point of the piece.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=aeb944720418" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Finding love — act II]]></title>
            <link>https://aayushibengani1994.medium.com/finding-love-act-ii-f9dad62653f8?source=rss-200a1429a6e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f9dad62653f8</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sour Punk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Sep 2025 14:24:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-18T14:24:30.948Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Finding love — act II</h3><p>Name, can play with it, obviously. Among the few things that a researcher knows is to anonymize name to ensure safety. Photos, no need to show face, rest of my body shows anyway. ID verification, check. Location, check. Looking for, as a friend (f1) advised, long-term relationship. Bio, no need. Interests, definitely no need. Why feed keywords into the algorithm? So it can suggest people of my inclination? Eww.</p><p>I had had enough of being with non-good looking, non-rich men. Remember desire? Hair on the head, fit in the body, and a field of finance would do. Height would be good too. Given that I like old money, somebody from somewhere in the south of Bombay would be nice. Shouldn’t behave like he has never or just seen money! Has got to be modest, which one can only be when one has a lot. A premium subscription, as another friend (f2) advised, was the way to go about it.</p><p>Thus begins the game of matches. Likes were easy to come by. Since I was using the app from my room which is in Navi Mumbai, many of the likes I received were from the direction of Panvel. They looked like it also. What a disappointment to know that one has to keep their location on to use the app and that that means one will only get seen in areas near one’s location. I was fearing that joining a dating app might reveal my biases to me and so it did. I could stay in the direction of Panvel by myself but certainly not with my partner. Suddenly I stopped liking all the greenery and quiet that I had been staying in Navi Mumbai for. Fuck off, all you birds!</p><p>In search of wealth and beauty that comes with it, I swiped on. First match with a spam account. He straight away got into how important physical touch was for me and then something about kiss and then I unmatched and reported him. Bumble said it had alerted the account holder and would take action if he would be reported again by anybody else. As I gradually got to know, it is not just women, men too face harassment from fake accounts on the app. From men only, who else! One match had deleted his account suspecting that I could be a guy trying to mess with him. Since my profile did not and I too refused to show my face and he had shared a bit of information about himself by then (alongside me, of course), he didn’t want to “get into trouble,” he said. Another match made me come on a quick voice call first and then a video call just to confirm that I was not a guy trying to “extort money” from him. Initially when I refused to get on a call, he insisted that he was asking for it just to be safe. When I teased him saying I couldn’t believe a woman would have to hear this from a man, he said it had happened to him twice already. He had deleted his account by the next day.</p><p>Second interaction I remember was with a guy who was making money, as he said, “for Mota Bhai” in Ghansoli. Studied at IIT Kanpur, he had written the quickest way to his heart was to cut it open. I thought it was very funny and even said it to him. Why was I getting attracted to brain again? Has my past taught me nothing! Plus, Navi Mumbai, that too much worse. What the hell was I doing! We continued our chat. He seemed sensible, warm, funny. “Boulder,” he called me. “A man of Physics,” I called him, alongside “Motabhai” of course. I told him how being on the app was such a lot of work. He called me “Lazy Bee,” but turned out he himself was not willing to take much effort. He had asked for my number and I had asked him to come on SMS instead of WhatsApp, which he couldn’t. So, the chat went into “older chats,” which meant out of sight, hence out of life. “Guys are very jaded from their previous experiences… they don’t want to take effort,” I found myself saying to a friend and a match about a month later.</p><p>Third interaction was with a guy whose profile mentioned Delhi School of Economics. Having taken so much pain to be away from DSE, I didn’t want (anybody from) DSE in Mumbai at least. Isn’t Delhi enough for that! So much running away, not for this! But thinking he would be from Economics, I swiped right. Why were the initials d and s in lower case though, I wondered. Finance people wouldn’t have time for typos, I guessed. It got cleared right at the beginning of the chat when I asked, “Eco, right,” to which he replied, “Nope. Geography.” I lost interest in him before it could even begin. But turned out, he was very energetic, funny, confident, and smart. He did not understand positionality at all — why I didn’t want to show my face in my profile, didn’t want to reveal my supervisor’s name. “Kafi bhauntt hai,” I had told a friend soon after thinking about him. But before I could realize, I was convincing this friend to join Bumble and was talking positively about it. When did I turn pro dating app? I had barely joined and had already been feeling unpleasant on the app. Why then was I talking like an ambassador for it? When did this shift happen? Why, because of whom! Turned out, it was single-handedly because of this guy. He had told me he was “badmash” when he was talking about his equation with the teachers at the department and he indeed was badmash. But before I could make sense, I was already attracted to him for his raw, childlike manner. I didn’t want an academic, but at least somebody who is intelligent. That his claim to fame was DSE Geography meant that he was not professionally promising. And that he had no clue about the role that one’s social position in society played in an one’s experiences (something as basic as gender, which everybody is anyway aware and woke about, at least in Mumbai, no?) again meant that he did not hold much professional promise. What was so attractive about him then! A childlike rawness. Speaking before thinking. Speaking without inhibition, in a playful manner of course. My pull towards him only made me realize how deprived I myself had been when it came to these things. I had got a hint of this realization a few months ago. That my relationships had been with men who were very very suppressed meant that there was a bit of that in me too. A friend had once said that blaming them would not help and and that I need to look within. “What is your type,” this friend had asked, to which I had said I didn’t have any. There must be a pattern in your relationships, he said. Then, I dismissed it thinking all of them were quite different from oner another. But now I know one thing that I could draw in common was that they were all suppressed, deeply, in very different ways though, but very very emotionally suppressed. And to imply from this friend’s talk, why I got attracted to them is because I myself must be deeply emotionally suppressed. This realization was and still was surprising though. I quit those relationships because I was emotionally open and they weren’t, among their other problems. Perhaps I had been only one kind of emotionally expressive. Perhaps the raw child in me had not been expressed at all lately. Anyway, now I know, also with my experience with this guy on the app, that I really need and like and miss speaking without thinking in a playful way. Anyway, my time with him was also till messages. He also didn’t seem to be too keen on taking effort, which in this case meant, he would plan but not care to act on it, follow up, or inform.</p><p>This was ghosting. But then these dating apps perpetuate it. Rather, they popularized and normalized it, right? Not maybe by themselves, but one doesn’t take a second here to inform before unmatching. I am guilty of this too, but I didn’t like doing it. And this seems to be the way of people here.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f9dad62653f8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Finding love — act I]]></title>
            <link>https://aayushibengani1994.medium.com/finding-love-9e4429801331?source=rss-200a1429a6e9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9e4429801331</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sour Punk]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Sep 2025 09:14:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-18T11:45:43.622Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I recently deleted Bumble. Spent a month and a half there. I had uninstalled it many times during this period, sometimes more than once a week, sometimes more than once a day. Hiding or uninstalling the app was clearly not enough. Seems like deleting isn’t either, as I got an email saying my premium subscription will continue till the end of the subscription period, if I wished to join again. For a second, I did consider rejoining. I still do. I so want to. The pull is very real.</p><p>I am in Mumbai currently. A friend said people came here exclusively to find a date and I, despite staying here, was not making the most of it. She wasn’t wrong. Yesterday I got to know that Mumbai made headlines a few months ago for being considered the number one city in the world for dating. I think it could be because the city has a good reputation in terms of how it sees and treats its women. Plus, it has been a recipient of diverse international and domestic cultures historically, giving it a cosmopolitan tag. Or it could just be the Bombay film industry’s repeated romanticization of love and love in this city fueling this image. Nonetheless, the news did come as a shock to me. Because in a city that barely lets you have any time and space for anything other than commuting and working, to think of love would be expecting too much. Why would I be so greedy and so harsh on myself to want it all at once! Focus. Prioritize. But two months ago, I did want to give Mumbai and myself a chance: “When, if not now!”</p><p>The friend also suggested that things would have to go simultaneously, as opposed to the one-thing-at-a-time approach that I had deployed so far. True, for how long would I keep this side of life on hold! I had not, actually. I had been in relationships in the past, but they happened because they fell in my narrow field of vision, which was academics. I had never searched on my own. Maybe now was the time to remove my blinders, see widely, and choose wisely. “So many of our batchmates joined our institute because they wanted to be in Mumbai so they could date and marry men in the Navy,” my friend said. “What! You didn’t know? I think you don’t remember!” A dating app indeed seemed to be a good way to meet people from other lines of work. Even though I considered myself an out-going person, I had mostly been to universities and libraries, thus socializing with and befriending people into studying. Although a champion of being and meeting offline, I did not realize that it also came to mean I was being a kuey ka mendak — bumping into people of my work and worse, my personality, no matter where I looked. The app would be a fantastic way to get out of one’s own well of self and get some fresh air, for God’s sake!</p><p>Another reason for not shying away from the dating app anymore was that people around me were getting engaged and married. I had conveniently cut out the noise from my extended circles by not being on social media. So any news of a relative/acquaintance/friend going on a holiday, getting married, having a child, or making it big in their career did not reach me. What bliss, right! But lately, people in my immediate circle — not necessarily close but the ones who I interact with and meet physically — have gotten engaged or married. This is coming not so much from my own siblings who are going to get married in three months, perhaps because they have been in their respective relationships for about five years and have also been engaged for many months now. Moreover, since it is too close home and I am not at home, so the fact of them getting married hasn’t sunk in yet. I am sure it will hit once I see and partake in the wedding preparations in person. When I see them dressed up and interacting with many and a completely new set of people. When I see them as bride and groom. When I see them going away. I have to have tangible evidence for anything to register with me. So, this is still two months far from me. What is it then, if not this, at least on the surface? Why have I been behaving like there is no tomorrow! What changed so suddenly!</p><p>A flat mate who I hung around a lot with this year, my three-month long stint with whom could literally be split into a before- and after-interval. The first half being about her craving a husband and marriage and us having funny banter around it and talking about relationships, traveling, and book reading. The second half being about her having found a man for marriage in the intermission and talking to me about surrendering to the universe and being happily consumed by the wherewithal of her man and their wedding. She left Mumbai mid-July to make arrangements for her happily ever-ever in her hometown. Next is the friend mentioned above, who I met twice in the last weekends of July. Spending almost two entire days with her like baby’s day out, as I call it, had us roaming around the streets and eating at the cafes of Fort and Chembur. But it also had a lot of her mentioning, talking about, showing pictures of, buying things for her husband, whom she found and married for love in the initial years of her PhD. We have quite a bit in common — a university, a workplace, and a person whom we don’t like from the distant past, and an international conference and domestic PhD now. Talking about it all including her dating experiences here and elsewhere, we gave a lot of genuine encouragement to each other — me about PhD to her and she about dating to me. Next is an acquaintance, another PhD scholar whom I befriended in the archives here. I had hung around with her once before and didn’t quite like the after-taste of the experience. It left me feeling very anxious about getting a job after PhD, something I genuinely don’t want to/like to, and simply don’t worry about. This time, I met her towards the end of July and she congratulated me for having successfully submitted my application for a scholarship abroad. “I am really happy for you,” she said. When I asked her what was up with her, she talked about how she had landed a permanent teaching job in a high-ranking university where she studied and a boyfriend on Bumble who lived in her area of the city, was a CA, and whom she was blushing about. Both these a month ago. Both while doing a PhD. And she was happy for me! It was disorienting, but I moved past it and we did have a good time talking about Bumble. I told her how a senior from college got engaged to somebody who she found on Bumble and how another friend was short of engagement with somebody whom he found on some such dating app. We ended up talking about dating including how she went about making her profile on Bumble and her experiences thereon.</p><p>Another reason is that I had finally gotten over my last heartbreak. It had been more than a year since the separation. It had been more than a few months since the realization that I had gotten over. How much longer was I going to wait. I clearly did not need more time. I was fine. Time was running fast and I had taken my time to pause. Now was the time to get up. Ever since my last heartbreak, I had been joking with a friend in a different city how I would try dating apps now. A champion of online dating, as in born and brought up with it as in somebody who cannot do without it, he would only have encouragement for me whenever I would mention it. But I never took what I or he said seriously. It was just a matter of conversation for us, not to take it anywhere, certainly not to act upon it, not for me at least. Why because, as I had once told a senior from college many years after college, “I hope it never comes to it.” It hadn’t by then and I hoped it never did. I had subconsciously thought of it as a lowly experience. A second-hand and a second-rate experience. But hearing “success stories” of my friends and acquaintances on dating apps made me look at them more positively. And my own horrible experiences of “pyar dosti hai” only came in support. Enough. It was time to take the big leap. Hadn’t I anyway decided to develop my capacity for flexibility, strategy, and desire this year? Here I go.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9e4429801331" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>