<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Abe Greenspoon on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Abe Greenspoon on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@abramgreenspoon?source=rss-a61a44ebdeef------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 03:41:34 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@abramgreenspoon/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Advice for applying to the Canadian federal public service]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@abramgreenspoon/advice-for-applying-to-the-canadian-federal-public-service-a1ba9abbaeb6?source=rss-a61a44ebdeef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a1ba9abbaeb6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[public-service]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[job-hunting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jobs]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Abe Greenspoon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Apr 2021 14:00:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-14T14:00:16.846Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*dzKfXr7d1pHcpSe9nVL0SA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Over the past year, I’ve received quite a few requests from people for advice on getting a job in the Canadian federal public service. I really enjoy those conversations because I love the opportunity to help great people join us on our mission to serve Canadians. It’s also a great opportunity to hear from folks about what it’s like to navigate our HR system from the outside. It’s been over a decade since I competed to join the public service and I like to keep tabs on what’s happening in the world of external competitions.</p><p>So given the volume of requests for advice and information that I get, I felt like maybe I would write some of it out and share it broadly in the interest of transparency and fairness. It feels a bit uncomfortable to me to limit my advice to a few select people who are brave or confident enough to message me on LinkedIn or Twitter. I know that even writing this piece I’ll only reach a small fraction of the people who would apply. But I’m compelled to take the opportunity to pull back the curtains a bit on government hiring.</p><p>So this piece will be an overview of the advice I give people when they apply for jobs in the federal public service.</p><p><strong>Disclaimer</strong>: <em>This is my personal opinion. It reflects what I see as good advice from my experience and perspective. It doesn’t represent any official advice from the Government of Canada. Nor does it reflect the best advice for all people in all circumstances. Heck, it might not even be good advice. But it’s the advice I give when people ask me. You reading this will be the judge as to whether it’s valuable. And as always, I welcome your honest feedback. This also doesn’t represent any scientific research I’ve done on this topic. It’s purely anecdotal. For what it’s worth, people often write me down the road after we spoke to tell me that the advice I gave them helped land them a job in the public service.</em></p><p>And one final note — there’s lots of other writing on this topic out there. As <a href="https://twitter.com/meganiyoung">Megan</a> pointed out to me, there’s <a href="https://polywogg.ca/hr-guide/">this guide</a> and the <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/CanadaPublicServants/">CPS subreddit</a> which are full of a great depth of information and resources. Consider this piece another opportunity to learn alongside the rest.</p><p>OK preamble out of the way. Let’s get to it.</p><p><strong>Overall Approach</strong></p><p>Everyone’s circumstances are different and so giving broad career advice is difficult. That said, I have a couple of things to say about an overall approach to applying to jobs in the public service.</p><p>First of all, I think if you’re thinking about a <em>career </em>in the public service, you need to almost make applying a part-time job. External competitions for permanent positions can take months or even years. This means that you need to manage your expectations, for one. But it also means you do better if you’re committed in terms of the sheer quantity of jobs that you apply to. It becomes a numbers game — apply to as many jobs as you can. Take as many of those applications as seriously as you can and dedicate as much time to them as you can. It maybe goes without saying, but I don’t think people do nearly as well who are casually applying.</p><p>Second of all, and related, you should never put all of your eggs in one basket. Don’t just apply to that dream job and wait until you find out if you got it. Entering the federal public service is hard, but moving around within it is relatively easy. You don’t need to enter the public service in the exact job you want for life. People move around frequently and it’s generally understood that nobody commits for life to their first public service job. Again, this is another reason to apply to as many jobs as you can. Get your foot in the door and then go from there.</p><p>Lastly, it’s helpful to understand that standardization is the name of the game with public service competitions. The goal of staffing is the public service is a merit-based, representative and non-partisan public service that serves all Canadians. This is the mandate of the Public Service Commission (PSC), the organization that oversees staffing in the public service. From my perspective, the PSC has translated this mandate into rigorously imposing standard approaches to all staffing processes.</p><p>I have lots of opinions about whether our staffing system achieves this in effective, fair, or even transparent ways. But putting that aside, you need to recognize that standardized hiring processes are something unique. They are rarely places for creativity. If you’re used to applying to jobs in the private sector, this may come as a bit of a shock. You should know that behind each competition is a set of qualifications (merit criteria in HR lingo) that are being used to assess all candidates. Each of these qualifications are defined and each applicant will be assessed directly against each. Most staffing assessment tools are literally grids that have the qualifications listed and some kind of open text space for notes. Notes are often taken verbatim and are applied to the definition directly. In theory, during all phases of the competition, you are being assessed against one or multiple of the qualifications and that’s all. I say in theory because there’s also something called “best fit” that creeps into the discussion. But more about that later.</p><p>For now, it’s enough to say this — the approach to applying to most public service jobs should recognize that you are simply trying to provide evidence that you possess the qualifications (merit criteria) being assessed by the hiring organization. At all stages, you need to be clear, concise, direct, and specific. There is little room in most competitions for imagination or creativity. Hopefully that changes some day, but for now I think it’s fairly broadly applicable.</p><p><strong>The Job Poster</strong></p><p>After general advice, my first piece of <em>specific </em>advice is always to pay close attention to the job poster. You will have found this somewhere on jobs.gc.ca, the Government of Canada’s job search website. The poster will have the title of the job in big bold lettering and you’ll see a selection process number. There’s lots of information here, but the key area is always the <strong>qualifications</strong> section. This is usually broken into <strong>essential qualifications</strong> and <strong>asset/other qualifications.</strong></p><p>Essential qualifications are exactly that — essential. I say that off the top because I’m of the opinion that if you don’t feel confident that you can clearly articulate how you possess each of the essential qualifications, you shouldn’t bother applying for the job. Especially these days when hiring managers and HR agents are looking for ways to reduce the high volume of applications. I can’t tell you how many people have told me they apply to jobs when they have meet most of the essential qualification. I think that’s a bad idea and a waste of time.</p><p>Asset or other qualifications are non-essential. You should always explain as much as you can how you possess and have demonstrated that you possess these qualifications. But you don’t need to do so in order to apply. Even if you cannot demonstrate a single asset or other qualification, you should still apply per my advice to maximize the number of competitions you’re in.</p><p><strong>Written Applications</strong></p><p>In the past couple of years I’ve learned that a lot of organizations have adjusted the way that they’re accepting written applications and are using a more structured approach with questions and open text fields for each question. I’m not sure if this has become a standard approach implemented at a policy level or if it’s an option that organizations are adopting more frequently but voluntarily. The last job I competed for, the request was for two things: a resume and a cover letter. The cover letter was essentially the place where you would list each of the qualifications and explain using narrative how you possess the qualifications. Regardless of the structure being used during the written application process, the way you organize your written application should generally be the same. <strong>Reminder</strong>: this is not a creative writing process.</p><p>The basic structure for the written application should generally follow a structure where you provide a heading using the qualification and then bullet points describing when, where, and how you have demonstrated that you possess that qualification. For example, write the heading “Experience in managing relationships with international organizations” and then use bullet points to describe all the organizations you worked for, when you worked for them, and how each provided you with experience managing relationships with international organizations. In competitions using a more structured approach than simply an open text box for your whole cover letter, you may be able to skip the header because each box probably refers to a specific qualification.</p><p>Regardless of the structure used for the application, take a very structured approach with your responses. Use headers more than might feel natural. Organize your information clearly and consistently. Don’t consider this an opportunity to flaunt your writing skills — it’s not. Unless you are specifically being assessed on your ability to write creatively. Clarity and brevity and consistency are more of the flavour of what is being asked for here.</p><p><strong>The Interview</strong></p><p>When it comes to the interview stage of the competition, I’ve found a bit of pre work can be useful. A friendly email to either the HR advisor or the hiring manager (you should have at least one of their names and emails by the time you make it to the interview) for some information can help a lot. I always tell people to ask for two things: 1) a list of the questions that will be asked, and 2) a list of the qualifications or merit criteria that will be assessed. To me, it’s a good practice for hiring managers to provide this information in advance. Some people disagree and won’t share anything. But it never hurts to ask and I have known HR advisors and hiring managers who will share this information when asked even if they don’t do so proactively.</p><p>Once you’ve done that small bit of pre-work, the approach isn’t so much different than the above one used for the written application. If you know what questions are being asked, then you can prepare your responses. And if you know what qualifications are being assessed, you can make sure your responses very directly speak to the qualifications being assessed. If you don’t have either of those pieces of information, you should go back to the job poster and make an educated guess as to which qualifications will be assessed during the interview. For me, a good guess would be any qualifications that are listed but were not asked for in the written application. Besides that, consider what qualifications would lend themselves to an interview question rather than a written question. In my experience, qualifications that are categorized as abilities or personal suitability are often fair game. As are those categorized as knowledge.</p><p>As with all stages of the competition, you’re being assessed against one or a combination of qualifications listed in the job poster. And as with all stages, there is likely a grid somewhere listing the qualifications with space for assessment next to each. Which means assessors at the interview are literally just filling in boxes for each qualification they are assessing. So each answer you give should be related to those qualifications only. For any qualifications you think are likely to be assessed, you should have prepared responses with specific examples.</p><p>Part of the skill here I think is being good at quickly puzzling out which qualifications are being assessed based on the question asked. Sometimes it’s obvious (“tell me about at time when you demonstrated flexibility”) and sometimes it’s less obvious, like with a scenario to which you’re asked to respond. Having a strong awareness of the qualifications on the poster helps a lot here. Having them memorized doesn’t hurt either.</p><p><strong>Best Fit</strong></p><p>The last topic I usually give advice about is “best fit”. Before I get into the advice I give, I want to share my perspective on the idea of best fit overall.</p><p>Chances are you’re familiar with the term best fit. You might even think you know what it means and how to demonstrate it during the hiring process. My opinion is that nobody really knows what best fit is. It’s a term that’s probably means 100 different things to 100 different people. You’ll probably never see it defined clearly anywhere in any public service competition. You may never even hear it used by hiring managers in the public service. But I’m not going to tell you to pretend it doesn’t exist. It very much does. I’m also not going to tell you that it shouldn’t exist. I actually think it should.</p><p>Generally speaking, best fit seems to be a vague term used to mean “the person who we think will fit in best with our team”. This is possibly related to the team’s culture. I actually think that’s a fairly generous definition. More often than not, I’ve seen it as the hiring manager’s preference for the person they like the most. And most likely (if I’m being honest) because of things more related to what they look like, the way they speak, and whether or not they’re threatening to the hiring manager.</p><p>But that’s the dark side of best fit and it doesn’t paint the whole picture. At it’s most beneficial, best fit describes the person who most possesses qualities that are less tangible, are harder to asses in a competition, but are often equally or more important than experience, knowledge, or abilities. Within it’s best definition, best fit could describe someone who doesn’t actually fit in at all on the team that is hiring. If we were able to do honest accountings of what our teams need, I think many of us would find that the people who least “fit in” are actually the people we need the most.</p><p>Most competitions either consider best fit during the formal interview or they invite candidates for an additional interview. Often this interview is informal, but it is always part of the assessment process even if they tell you it isn’t. I say this because I’ve heard people use the term “informal” as if it means it’s not part of the competition and I think that’s disingenuous at best and frankly misleading at worst. Until you are offered a job, you should consider every interaction you have with the person making the decisions (almost always the hiring manager) to be part of the competition.</p><p>From my perspective, our ability to assess for best fit in an honest way has the potential to seriously benefit or hinder our hiring practices. And so I see this as really important. And what I wish was that instead of hiding the way we assess for it, we would be open and transparent about our team cultures at the front of our hiring processes. We should openly advertise about what it’s like to work on our teams. We should tell people what sorts of things are important to us, even if they don’t show up in competitions. And where possible, we should try to define in concrete ways things like mindsets and behaviours that are important to us and attempt to openly include them in our assessment processes.</p><p>But that’s not where we are today. So I usually give three pieces of advice to people about best fit. First, I tell people to ask about things like team culture. Consider writing an email or asking to speak to people on the team. I make a habit of asking for references from prospective hiring managers that I’m considering working for, but I think that’s almost impossible in an external competition. Still, think about creative ways that you can get a sense of what it’s like to work on the team. In the worst case, you can ask during the formal interview when they ask if you have any questions. Second, assuming you find out at some point what it’s like to work on the team, ask yourself whether that’s a way of working that suits you. Ask whether the team is a best fit for you, not vice versa. And lastly, assuming you decide the team culture is one that works for you, the first opportunity you get (even if that’s only at the “informal interview” stage), you want to demonstrate that to the hiring manager. Ultimately at that point this advice comes down to “be yourself”. Because hopefully the way the team works represents the way you work naturally. If that’s the case, let who you are shine through. If that’s not the case, you might want to look elsewhere anyway.</p><p>The bottom line here is that the notion of best fit without a doubt influences the decisions that hiring managers make. The challenge is that the way best fit factors in is hard to predict and hard to prepare for. In many ways, this part of the decision is out of your control. But I think the above way of thinking about best fit helps to gain back just a little bit of that control nonetheless.</p><p><strong>Final thoughts</strong></p><p>That sums up most of what I share with people who ask for my advice. I want to close by re-stating my intention for giving this advice and writing this blog. When people ask me for advice on applying to public service jobs, they are generally looking for advice on how to be successful. They’re not looking for advice on how to challenge the system. Nor are they asking for my opinion on its shortcomings. As I said earlier, I have many opinions about the weaknesses and shortcomings of our staffing system in the public service. I don’t consider these conversations or this article the place to share those. I may end up writing more about what I think should change, but that’s not with this is for.</p><p>Similarly, as <a href="https://twitter.com/otowncoho">Colin</a> pointed out to me, the other half of the story is that hiring managers tend to follow paths most worn rather than exercise discretion and break the trends of hiring practices that are established but outdated. I think this is true and I think it’s definitely important that hiring managers (myself included) find flexibilities within the system to hire better. That also wasn’t what this piece was about, though I may find the energy to write something about that too.</p><p>My intention here is to share openly a few of my general perspectives about how to be successful in federal public service competitions because people ask and I want to help. Nuances and exceptions abound and the story is complex. But hopefully you found something in here that might make you even just a bit more prepared and aware of what you’re getting yourself into.</p><p>And if you made it this far, let me say thanks. Thanks for making a serious effort to join the public service. Our work is important and meaningful and we need your help.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a1ba9abbaeb6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The uneducation and reeducation of a white man]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@abramgreenspoon/the-uneducation-and-reeducation-of-a-white-man-f8975e04f689?source=rss-a61a44ebdeef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f8975e04f689</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-supremacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[allyship]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Abe Greenspoon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Jun 2020 13:08:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-01T13:08:52.592Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It’s been a tough week for our world. In case you weren’t paying attention, last week a white police officer killed a black man named George Floyd in Minneapolis, Minnesota, and in New York City a white woman named Amy Cooper called the police on a black man named Christian Cooper claiming “an African American man was threatening her life”, presumably as a threat to him about the harm the police might cause him. These events come just weeks after Breonna Taylor, a 26-year-old black woman, was killed in her own home by three white police officers in Louisville, Kentucky and Ahmaud Arbery, a 25-year-old black man, was killed by two white men while jogging in Georgia.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cRHZGJ2EkatqbrzpH7CWAQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>As a white man, it’s hard to truly relate to these events. I can only imagine the fear, exhaustion, sadness, frustration, and innumerable other emotions people of colour must be feeling this week. The reality is that I likely will never feel what you/they feel — that is one of the fundamental parts of my privilege. But this week I did feel something that I want to share.</p><p>I’ve spent the past week sitting with a feeling of deep discomfort. I knew it related to the recent events, but there was something different about this feeling. It wasn’t just sadness for the tragedy of these events. I spent some time thinking about where I was feeling it and where it might be coming from. I felt a weight hanging over me, pushing down on me. Today, I’m still processing it. But I think I’m starting to know what’s going on. The events of this week are forcing me to look inside myself and explore my own racist views and actions, and it’s making me uncomfortable.</p><p>For a bit of context, my mantra these days has been that change comes from within. I’ve been closely following and participating in the work of <a href="https://www.ottoscharmer.com/">Otto Scharmer</a> of MIT’s <a href="https://www.presencing.org/">Presencing Institute</a>. Otto’s ULab process (and more recently his <a href="https://www.presencing.org/gaia">GAIA Journey</a> process) always begins with a turning inward or a focus on the “inner condition”. For me, this means that my ability to affect change in the world is directly related to my ability to change my beliefs, mindsets, and behaviours.</p><p>This past week, I’ve spent a lot of time examining my inner condition and I’ve started to question whether I am who I think I am when it comes to racism. And to be honest, I’m afraid to admit to myself my own culpability because I’m afraid to feel that kind of shame, and to be held responsible for my behaviour.</p><p>Before I go any further, I want to say that I don’t have much to teach you about racism in this post. Because I honestly don’t think I know enough about my own racism yet. I thought I knew about racism, but after the events of this week, I think I was wrong. I spent some time this week reading the work of black authors and watching speeches of black activists and it’s clear to me that my ignorance is real.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/200/0*czwSAGkATZIYaU0R.png" /><figcaption>A person examines themselves in the mirror</figcaption></figure><p>So why even write on the topic? That’s a fair question. All I can say is that I feel like white people need to open up about their relationship with race. We need to talk about white supremacy, about anti-blackness, about microaggressions, privilege and about the structural racism from which many of us benefit. We need to speak up and we need to act deliberately against racism. We need to become actively conscious about the role race and racism play in society and take actions to end racial inequities in our daily lives. <a href="https://nmaahc.si.edu/learn/talking-about-race/topics/being-antiracist">We need to be more than non-racist; we need to be anti-racist</a>.</p><p>I need to be anti-racist. And I need to start right now. So I’m making a commitment here to take a few concrete actions as a start. I intend to read more about anti-racism. I’m starting with <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1hpub-jkm9cLzJWqZSsETqbE6tZ13Q0UbQz--vQ2avEc/preview?pru=AAABcoBG9OU*YypkiA00BRU9faLUiF09Jw#">this excellent anti-racism resources guide</a>. I’m following more activists, journalists, politicians, authors, poets, artists and other people of colour on social media to understand what they are saying and listening to more voices of color. I’m going to speak to family and friends about racism. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TnybJZRWipg">As Ijeoma Oluo asks</a>, “Now that we’re all in the room, how do we start the discussion?”</p><p>The events of this past week have brought our attention (again) to the deep issues we face around racism in our society, and I want to act. I’m going to be an ally and take actions to support and raise the voices of people of colour, financially and otherwise. I remember hearing someone say that “ally” in these situations isn’t a noun, it’s a verb. What matters isn’t who you are, but how you act. So consider this my first commitment to act.</p><p>That said, I hear a lot of reasons why people don’t act. People feel powerless to make change. They say “I’m not racist” or “I’m way less racist than that person.” People say it’s not their place to get involved or they don’t feel comfortable wading into the conversation. What this week has taught me is that I’m not willing to make excuses anymore. I can’t. I’m complicit in what’s going on and I don’t want to be.</p><p>Who I am and where I come from explains a lot about me. I have mostly white friends. I work with mostly white colleagues. I follow mostly white people on social media. I grew up in rural Canada surrounded mostly by white friends and family. What have I done in my life to prevent or combat racism? Basically nothing at all. And that hurts. Because I’ve probably been telling myself quietly that I’m here in solidarity with anti-racism. I’m not. I haven’t been. I need to stop lying to myself. How many times have I benefited from the system because I’m a white male? How many times have I used my power in ways that also disadvantaged people of colour? Even asking these questions is haunting me.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/298/0*lelF6FM8WKFE-uHJ.jpg" /><figcaption>A rope frays until only one thread remains holding it together</figcaption></figure><p>This post isn’t meant to remove a burden. It’s meant to place one squarely on my shoulders and force me to act. Those who know me know I’m here for compassion, kindness, and love. But I’m a human being and have many facets. I know I can want all of those things and be racist too. But once I’m aware of my racism, I need to address it.</p><p>That said, here are some of my fears about sharing all of this:</p><ul><li>I’m afraid that in writing this, my voice will be louder than the people of colour whose voices are the ones we should really be hearing</li><li>I’m afraid that this will come across as <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtue_signalling">virtue signaling</a></li><li>I’m afraid you’ll think that I’m trying to unburden myself</li><li>I’m afraid you’ll think I’m just another <a href="https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/566247/white-fragility-by-robin-diangelo/">fragile white man</a></li><li>I’m afraid that creating this digital artifact makes me vulnerable</li></ul><p>I also want you to know that these are my hopes for this post:</p><ul><li>I hope this admission will make it easier for myself and others to hold me accountable for my actions</li><li>I hope this admission will inspire other white people to go through similar reflections and maybe even be moved to action after reading this</li><li>I hope it gets people talking. And I hope you talk to me about it and tell me how it makes you feel so I can learn from you</li><li>I hope I look back at this moment for the rest of my life as a turning point</li></ul><p>I feel really uncomfortable writing this. It doesn’t make me feel better. It makes me feel worse. But it’s like the saying goes, it’s always darkest before dawn. Hopefully this is a moment I’ll look back on and know I turned a corner. I hope even one other person reading this does too.</p><p>If this comes across in any other way than I intended it to, just know that I am open to hearing how I was wrong. I don’t really know how to enter this space. I used to think I could turn to my friends who are people of colour for help. Maybe I can. But I also think it’s not their job to help me. The knowledge is out there. The truth is out there. I need to seek it out myself. I know I won’t be alone, but in many ways this is a solo journey. At least for now. While I turn inward to know myself. Eventually I’ll feel confident again to turn back outward and ask for help and seek to build bridges. But I think I have some personal stuff to deal with first.</p><p>We live in this world together. We are connected. We are one. The pain, suffering, and injustice we inflict on others so too do we inflict on ourselves. I know that when I act in racist ways or when I ignore those actions of others, I’m responsible for pain in our world. Equally, I know that when I love people as I love myself and encourage others to act out of love, I’m responsible for the love in our world. We are responsible for the world as it exists today. We make it and unmake it in every moment. This is not a reason to be afraid. It’s a reason to be awake and to act.</p><p>I have so much to unlearn and relearn. Today and the days that follow this writing will be another step in my uneducation and reeducation. This will be a lifelong journey. And I am starting today. I invite you to join me. I invite you to use my story as an example of what could be next for you. Start by asking yourself one thing: am I doing enough?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f8975e04f689" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Leadership in the Public Sector: What’s Wanting to Emerge]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@abramgreenspoon/leadership-in-the-public-sector-whats-wanting-to-emerge-6b0cafd96236?source=rss-a61a44ebdeef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6b0cafd96236</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Abe Greenspoon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 20 May 2020 13:12:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-20T13:12:59.615Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Out with the old leadership traditions and in with those who dare to lead with their whole selves</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uqKeAzS3CTfAcTHTkZOvjw.jpeg" /><figcaption>life offering.org</figcaption></figure><p><strong>This article is written by Abe Greenspoon, Organisational Health Lead at Statistics Canada and Jennifer MacLeod, Owner and Executive Coach at Jennifer MacLeod Consulting.</strong></p><p>Just over a year ago, Jennifer published <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/leadership-public-sector-whats-lurking-beneath-macleod-m-ed-pcc/">her findings</a> from 360 feedback on over 100 executives from across the public sector. The trend was alarming: many executives were demonstrating a tendency to comply, to disengage from difficult conversations, insecurity, self-doubt, and an absence of work life balance. This was one story about public sector leadership and it urgently needed to be told.</p><p>More recently, based on a hunch, we set out to discover another story that we felt needed to be told. A story about the emergence of a new model for executive leadership in the public sector and some individuals who embody what we see as a better way.</p><p>Over the past few months, we have interviewed several senior public servants who we think are changing what it means to be an executive leader. We think they represent the bright future of executive leadership in the public sector. We interviewed Michel Tremblay, Senior Vice-President, Policy and Innovation and Marie-Claude Tremblay, Senior Vice-President, People and Strategy at the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC); John Medcof, Director General, Transferable Skills and Chris Allison, Director General, Digital Academy at the Canada School of Public Service (CSPS); Lauren Hunter, Director, Talent Cloud at the Treasury Board of Canada Secretariat (TBS); and Laura Wesley, Director General at the Privy Council Office (PCO).</p><p>Our conversations centred around the future of work and what would be critical as far as creating, supporting and navigating change. What emerged was a story of executives who exemplify a deep commitment to supporting others, the courage to challenge harmful practices and behaviours, a tendency to directly engage with people on even the most difficult topics, an ability to engage in honest self-reflection, a humility that allows them to empower their staff, and an understanding of the importance of being vulnerable and human.</p><p>Our conversations revealed that this leadership is coming from many different places. But from our small sample and research, we identified three lenses for leading the change: a shift of focus from organizations as mechanisms to human systems; a need to redistribute leadership in different ways; and the importance of using rigorous and meaningful data to hold leaders accountable for the health of their teams.</p><p><strong>What the public sector looks like from the top</strong></p><p>Over the past five years CMHC has undergone a significant transformation from a culture that was bureaucratic and disempowering to one that is empowering and adaptive. This transition began with a conversation about what the future of the organization would look like and how its leaders wanted it to change. Understanding the need to attract talent and evolve the organization, CMHC wanted to position itself as having the conditions for people to work well into the future with the right skills that the organization needed. The foundation of this new culture came from a strategy where employees would be managed for results rather than when, where, or how they work. This required a fundamental change in the contract between the employer and employee.</p><p>According to Marie-Claude Tremblay it became about not managing their presence in the office or the time they put into the work, but more about holding them accountable for their commitments. “The changes we made are all to do with creating conditions for managers and employees to trust each other” — “It’s all about trust” she added.</p><p>According to Michel Tremblay the organization made a choice to move away from a traditional fear-based culture where cooperation was prohibited through hierarchy. It was about orienting the workforce towards a more agile and flat approach to management as opposed to having 10 ultimate decision-makers at the top. It also included recognizing the need for people to be able to address family matters and work life balance in ways where they would be freed up to choose where they would spend their time.</p><p><a href="https://hbr.org/2014/01/employees-perform-better-when-they-can-control-their-space">Research supports</a> that productivity rises significantly when this freedom is given to people. CMHC demonstrated themselves as a pioneer by leading an approach to organizational change that is oriented to serve people’s needs differently and that distributes accountability across the organization. This approach was specifically designed to empower employees to unleash their potential.</p><p><strong>A future-proof public sector</strong></p><p>While the sort of radical and rapid transformation seen at CMHC is rare in the public service, there’s evidence that automation and technology will force us to move things along. New technologies are quickly beginning to impact the way we’re working in fundamental ways and some public sector executives are getting prepared.</p><p>According to John Medcof, we need to focus on building more adaptable skills and mindsets to support this inevitable disruption. He believes that the way we think about knowledge and expertise is changing. He argued that while information is plentiful and accessible, and it’s easy to access knowledge in a particular area, it takes more time and effort to build the skills to support how we engage and manage in ways that are agile, adaptable, flexible and creative. He believes that building skill sets such as curiosity, problem-solving, and collaboration will be critical. These sentiments link well with the <a href="https://apolitical.co/en/solution_article/the-future-skills-tracker">work done by organizations around the world</a> looking at the skills and competencies that public servants need for the future.</p><p>John believes that the best thing the public service can do to prepare people to be future leaders is to give them the autonomy to truly lead their work. Give them target outcomes and let them explore the ways they might get there. His advice for future leaders: “It’s all about the people. The more we invest in the human aspects of our work, the better the outcomes will be.”</p><p>We must also re-think our current systems, where change comes from, and how we hold ourselves accountable to embrace a shift in focus that includes empowerment, trust, and human needs as priorities. For Chris Allison, the public service needs leaders to be asking how work practices and processes need to change for the future. He sees the need for real transformational change rather than small incremental change or tinkering on the margins.</p><p>Chris believes that in order to change the system, re-visit the role of government — what it does and what it is responsible for — and from there, we could organize ourselves differently around how work is done. In his view, rather than trying to keep fixing and changing the Westminster system and what it was originally designed to serve, we might benefit more from building what is needed from a system aligned with purpose that is aligned with today’s needs.</p><p><strong>Are the old values holding us back?</strong></p><p>Laura Wesley also spoke about the need for broad change. She suggested that there’s a need to work in new ways. We need to change working conditions so that people can bring their whole selves to work. She focused on the human system elements of change, saying “At the system level, you can’t deny that there are lots of well worn pathways that have become trenches. At the same time, we need individuals to do things differently. We need to listen and be curious about what is preventing individuals, teams, departments, or other levels of the system from changing.”</p><p>Laura thinks that for executives to change, they need time for self-reflection. “As executives, we need to ask ourselves ‘what are we trying to uphold?’,” she says. “We can ask ourselves if the decisions we are taking, or processes we are using, uphold the existing system of government or the values of government?” This question enables us to shift our way of seeing what we are doing, so we can make choices based on underlying principles. This allows us to focus our attention on things that need attending to at that moment.</p><p>These comments represent a common thread in our interviews that suggest a need to re-examine the underlying beliefs that uphold our systems and practices. It’s these beliefs that hold in place old values. These beliefs can limit our ability to have the difficult conversations that are necessary for meaningful and sustainable change.</p><p><strong>Culture shifts</strong></p><p>These comments may also reflect a long-standing history in the Western hemisphere of organizations and systems designed to be hierarchical, power-based, and centrally controlled. Our organizations are made up of individuals or small groups of people being tasked with managing, making decisions, and determining what the future requires.</p><p>We have placed responsibility for our work in the hands of “leaders”. Those at the top of the pyramid must come up with the decisions and solutions to the organization’s biggest problems. The assumption here is that power is the monopoly of a small group.</p><p>Lauren Hunter didn’t mince words when asked about what she thinks of the current model of leadership in the public service. “People in leadership roles want to own mandates. They rarely want to own problems. A mandate comes with power, a problem comes with responsibility.” When asked about challenges associated with leadership culture, she added, “Government leadership is centered around mandates and the inherent authority that comes with titles, so it’s a difficult shift in mindset to embrace a problem-driven, user-centred approach to leadership. It’s a shift leaders are rarely trained for.”</p><p>It’s Lauren’s opinion that the current performance management system doesn’t hold leaders accountable for establishing cultures that look after employees well-being, and instead rewards leaders for the appearance of results at the cost of employee health and retention. According to her, the incentive structure of the current performance system for executives doesn’t take into account two critical points of data: systematic, annual upward feedback from employees for each executive, and external evidence corroborating what problems have been solved.</p><p>Attrition rates (coupled with exit interviews) should also factor into the assessment of whether or not executives are creating environments that reflect <a href="https://www.canada.ca/en/privy-council/corporate/clerk/publications/26-annual-report/renewing-public-service-beyond2020.html">the Clerk’s vision for public service culture</a>. She argues that it’s illogical to expect a culture shift in executive leadership until the incentive structure and the data gathered reflect the value shift towards healthy, high performing teams and evidence-based, user-centred service delivery.</p><p><strong>So what should we make of all this?</strong></p><p>We were so grateful for the opportunity to interview people who we believe embody a new model of public sector executive leadership. From what we heard in these interviews, we have drawn a few conclusions about how this new model might emerge and what it might look like.</p><p>While none of the executives we interviewed said it directly, we interpreted from their stories and our research that this kind of change, which has been discussed for decades, was unlikely to be led from within in the short to medium-term. Too many people have too much invested in the current system. The current global pandemic demonstrates how important external disruptions can be, as we are now seeing some changes happening at a pace that was unimaginable several months ago.</p><p>We also believe that dramatic changes in the prevalent behaviours of those working in the system are most likely to come from changes to the rules and goals of the system itself. For example, we should consider redesigning our performance management system to prevent the people managing it from rewriting and editing the narratives in ways that serve them and allow poor leadership and toxic cultures. Our systems need to shift to emphasize a broad change in the beliefs and values that can enable a different future. Otherwise, we risk continuing the same patterns of behaviours we observed at the beginning of this article.</p><p>Furthermore, we believe that the way we have structured our organizations actually prevents the cooperation that is so important for human beings to support and engage one another. The current organizational paradigm defines leadership and the capacity to influence change in a linear and rigid way, which actually sets us up for failure. No one person or select group can possibly be responsible for solving the kinds of complex problems facing the public sector today. Instead, we need to distribute and define organizational leadership in a way that decentralizes power and places greater decision-making authority in the hands of local knowledge and expertise.</p><p><strong>Making a new style of leadership the norm</strong></p><p>The idea of all powerful leaders at the top of organizations with their hands on the levers of power is no longer sustainable. If you are a leader scrambling to stay in control, it’s time to make a dramatic shift away from a mindset to control situations and others to one that incorporates human values of empowerment, cooperation, collaboration and trust. The fabric of what makes us human and allows us to support one another is not one of machinery and hierarchy. The true nature of our humanity is our interconnectedness with each other and the world around us. So we need to start leading our organizations accordingly.</p><p>Learning how to manage and lead forward will require a greater awareness of our humanity as the foundation for all we do. The executive leaders who embody this new leadership paradigm will open up to their humility, vulnerability and fear. They will invite and embrace differences, debate, and dissension as ways to open the door to change. They will encourage innovation and learning and support the inherent flops and breakdowns that allow for them. They will look inside themselves to try to understand their own biases, limiting beliefs, and unhelpful mindsets and to grow beyond them. They will ask for help, admit their mistakes, and learn and grow from their experiences. Ultimately they will model the behaviors and shape the cultural environments that promote wholeness, health and respect.</p><p><strong>Abe Greenspoon</strong>, <a href="https://twitter.com/worldofabe">Twitter</a>, <a href="http://linkedin.com/in/abegreenspoon">LinkedIn</a></p><p><strong><em>Jennifer MacLeod M.ED, PCC</em></strong><em> jmacleod.in@gmail.com </em><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/jennifermacleod/"><em>https://www.linkedin.com/in/jennifermacleod/</em></a></p><p><a href="http://www.jennifermacleodconsulting.com/"><em>www.jennifermacleodconsulting.com</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6b0cafd96236" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[It’s time to start meeting better]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@abramgreenspoon/its-time-to-start-meeting-better-8a360dd50153?source=rss-a61a44ebdeef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8a360dd50153</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meetings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[virtual-meetings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[online-meetings]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Abe Greenspoon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 May 2020 17:06:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-05T09:38:02.687Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Last week, Zoom <a href="https://blog.zoom.us/wordpress/2020/04/22/90-day-security-plan-progress-report-april-22/">announced</a> that it surpassed 300 million daily meeting participants globally. This surge in usage clearly demonstrates the importance of tools that allow us to meet online right now. During a global pandemic, Zoom, MS Teams, and other platforms are enabling us to keep in touch with people and keep working.</p><p>At the same time, rapidly moving our meetings online (whether with family, friends, or colleagues) seems to be revealing some challenges. In early March, before the global pandemic really took hold here in North America, Harvard Business Review published an article titled <a href="https://hbr.org/2020/03/what-it-takes-to-run-a-great-virtual-meeting">What it Takes to Run a Great Virtual Meeting</a>, which had some great tips for how online meetings can be “<strong>run more effectively</strong>”. Then last week, almost two months later, Harvard Business Review published a new article titled <a href="https://hbr.org/2020/04/how-to-combat-zoom-fatigue">How to Combat Zoom Fatigue</a> with tips on how online meetings can be “<strong>less exhausting</strong>”.</p><p>Are online meetings turning us into “zoombies”?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/528/1*NLZjTYkYliBKo1uVNHzDYA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image credit: Andi Roberts (andiroberts.com)</figcaption></figure><p>I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately. As someone who considers themselves a community builder and fairly digital savvy, I was already preoccupied with how to create high quality online spaces for people to gather and hold conversations. Lately, it’s moved from preoccupation to passion.</p><p>What I believe is happening in this moment is two-fold: 1) our meetings weren’t well designed or facilitated to begin with, and 2) most of us don’t have the unique skills and knowledge to design and facilitate good online meetings. These two issues compound and make it easy to blame the tools we’re using rather than the design and facilitation skills we’re sorely lacking.</p><p>What’s simultaneously exciting to me is that I’m waking up to the reality that around the world there are people who are actually already really good at working online. In fact, through some searching and lots of conversations, I’ve discovered that people have been practicing designing and facilitating online meetings for decades. Today I consider myself to be just dipping my toes into the water here, but I think I can safely hypothesize that if organizations took the time to explore this space, we’d see dramatic increases in productivity and decreases in fatigue.</p><p>I recently had the great fortune of stumbling onto the work of Amy Lenzo and Rowan Simonsen<strong> </strong>of <a href="https://beehive-productions.net/">Beehive Productions</a>. Amy and Rowan have been practicing hosting online meetings for years. They are practitioners of seemingly innumerable techniques for group conversations such as those taught by Liberating Structures, Art of Hosting, and World Cafe to only name a few. I’ve now taken several of their courses online, the most recent of which was an incredible six-session course titled <a href="https://beehive-productions.mykajabi.com/GroundedResponse">A Grounded Response to Online Engagement</a>.</p><p>From my experience exploring the teachings of Amy and Rowan, I wanted to share some reflections about online space that I’ve found useful. My hope is that you’ll consider these lessons and recognize your responsibility as someone who convenes online space (meeting organizer, chair, etc.) to make sure the space you convene has the right conditions.</p><p><strong>Letting go of assumptions</strong></p><p>Let’s start by asking ourselves what we believe about online meetings. Do we believe that online meetings are inherently “lower quality” than onsite meetings? Do we believe that it’s harder to “connect” with people online than it is onsite? Do we believe that online meetings simply can’t be run as well as onsite meetings?</p><p>When working on solving problems, it’s a good idea to start by identifying your implicit assumptions, which will determine how you show up. For example, if we believe that online meetings are inherently lower quality than onsite meetings, what does that do to the likelihood that we’ll explore the online space with curiosity about what’s possible? What if, in considering how to design online meetings, we instead believed that online space was a space as real as any other? If we believe that the medium is what determines the quality of our interactions, how likely are we to explore ways to overcome or leverage the nuances of online meetings?</p><p>My belief, and what I heard from Amy and Rowan, is that it’s not about the technology. It’s about us. What technology does is provide a platform for things to happen. What we do with that platform is up to us. As Amy says,</p><blockquote>The internet is no less real than what is often called ‘real life’. It’s how we choose to work in it that determines it capacity to impact us and those that we’re working with.</blockquote><p>This also matters with regards to the language we use about online meetings. Again, from Amy:</p><blockquote>Language is super important online. We have fewer senses involved and so the focus on you as a host is much greater. Your language and how you behave in and treat the online space will have a lot of impact on your group and how they can show up.</blockquote><p>In other words, if you show up to meetings online apologizing for the fact or lamenting the fact that we can’t be together in person, you are degrading the potential of the space. Let go of the assumptions you have about how good or bad online space can be. Lean into this moment as an opportunity to create good experiences for people to meet online by showing up with curiosity and an open mind.</p><p><strong>What is truly different?</strong></p><p>When it comes to hosting meetings, a lot of the same rules apply online as onsite. Hosting any good meeting requires you to be present, be in tune with the needs of your group, be prepared, understand the context of the group meeting, provide materials, and design for your outcomes.</p><p>There are, however, some differences to consider when hosting online that you don’t have to consider when hosting onsite. The two most obvious are physical limitations and the importance of technology. For example you can’t provide paper copies so you need to send materials in advance. And you can’t use a physical whiteboard so you need to consider using a videoconference tool that has a digital whiteboard if you need one.</p><p>There are also some slightly less obvious differences. For example, as Amy noted, “The amplification is higher, senses are limited, and your voice is most important.” I think this point is interesting. Consider the difficulty making eye contact with someone. It’s definitely harder to read someone’s mood from their eyes through videoconference, so we’re relying much more on our voices. As a meeting facilitator or chair, your job becomes to use your voice as your most important tool to create the right space for the group. This means speaking clearly and using the right tone becomes much more important.</p><p><strong>Tactics for online engagement</strong></p><p>According to Amy and Rowan, the concepts of space and time are a great place to start when considering how to create good online meetings.</p><ul><li><strong>Space</strong>: good conditions for online meetings start with the space we create. Consider how you welcome people to the space. Also consider opening the space 30 minutes early to allow people to arrive and test out their technology. This will help ease people’s anxiety and help make sure your meetings run smoothly.</li><li><strong>Time</strong>: the concept of time is tied to space and it’s equally important. Duration, frequency, and rhythm are important to consider with your online meetings. As a general rule, you should start engaging with participants within the meeting’s first 15 minutes, even if it’s just introductions or a check-in. When doing presentations, a single person should not speak for more than 20 minutes at most before switching gears. You can use time to create a sense of spaciousness by maintaining a relaxed tone of voice, leaving space for silence, and even inviting pauses for reflection. This can be particularly useful for calming people down when time is tight or anxiety is high.</li></ul><p>Beyond space and time, consider a few design elements that might help create better conditions for your online meeting.</p><ul><li>Breakouts: groups of three or four people can be much more effective than plenary for people to share ideas or connect with each other</li><li>Mirroring: after breaking into small groups, have participants share back what they heard from the others in their groups</li><li>Imagery: have participants use images to help them convey their ideas or share personal stories</li><li>Helping each other: have participants support each other with technology or take turns facilitating breakouts</li><li>Storytelling: create opportunities for participants to share stories as a means to build empathy within the group</li><li>Reflection: create space for silent reflection or journaling</li></ul><p>A concept I really appreciated from Amy and Rowan that brought this all together for me was The Wheel of Online Hosting, a relational map that defines how all parts of hosting are connected.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DMNl5plEDjbxPkzICb_3-A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Wheel of Online Hosting concept by Amy Lenzo &amp; FireHawk Hulin. Image by Viola Clark.</figcaption></figure><p>The wheel’s four quadrants represent four key concepts that combine to help us understand how to design and facilitate good online space.</p><p><strong>Presence </strong>— be present, awake, aware, ready to respond rather than react.</p><p><strong>Relationship </strong>— recognize and appreciate the relationship between yourself, your team, the meeting participants, and the natural world.</p><p><strong>Technology </strong>— partner with technology rather than simply using it. Understand its strengths and its limitations.</p><p><strong>Design </strong>— create the container through a program of activities. Your design animates the forms of connection between people.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/572/1*DGaIiMC63oqXPQpF7lk1UQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>“Partnering with Technology,” Graphic created by Viola Clark.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>It’s time to start meeting better</strong></p><p>With the rapid move to fully remote working, the cracks in the foundation of how we meet are starting to show. We have grown complacent and sloppy with generic meeting objectives and purpose. No wonder we are frustrated with online meetings. Complacent and sloppy onsite is an absolute disaster online.</p><p>Let’s ask ourselves: if our meetings are bad online, were they actually good onsite? Are we sure? Are we <strong><em>really </em></strong>sure? I am asking these questions seriously because I find we too often assume our meetings are good as long as nobody is actively complaining or as long as people are showing up. If those were the indicators for your outcomes for onsite meetings, then no wonder your online meetings are exhausting.</p><p>And it’s not your fault. I find that our organizational expectations about meetings are really low. At the same time, it’s very quickly becoming no longer acceptable to blame our lax culture for our bad meetings. You’ve gotten away with it onsite and you can’t get away with it anymore online.</p><p>So start now. Be curious about meeting purpose, meeting design, and meeting facilitation. Consider how to be inclusive and design for the value of diversity. Consider how you can partner with technology to achieve your meeting purpose. Consider how you are designing and facilitating your meetings that make the most of space and time. Consider the language you use and your tone of voice.</p><p>Consider whether it’s really the medium that’s the problem. Or maybe online meetings can be really great. Maybe what matters is how we show up.</p><p><strong><em>Thanks for reading. If you ever need help with online meetings, let me know. I’d be happy to chat, give you tips, share the things I’ve learned, introduce you to good resources, or even help you facilitate.</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8a360dd50153" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I can’t write, so here’s what I’m reading]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@abramgreenspoon/i-cant-write-so-here-s-what-i-m-reading-2931ca475f5d?source=rss-a61a44ebdeef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2931ca475f5d</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Abe Greenspoon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Apr 2020 21:07:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-23T21:07:33.439Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’ve been in quarantine since March 11th. 43 days. One month and 12 days. But who’s counting, right?</p><p>Over those weeks, I’ve sat down to write several times. I’m working on an article with a friend who is a leadership coach about public sector executive leadership. I’ve stared at that article about 8 times without writing anything. I’ve been asked to write a couple of articles about organizational change and about career development and planning. Every time I think about writing, I actually have a physical reaction. My whole body feels weird and tense all of a sudden. I’m not sure what my body is trying to tell me. But I’m listening to it.</p><p>So rather than write anything of my own, I decided to share a blog about what I’ve been reading these past six weeks. Maybe writing about what I’m reading will help me write about what I’m thinking. Who knows.</p><p>So here’s what I’ve been reading ordered by what’s sticking with me the most:</p><p>I’ve been devouring everything that <a href="https://citizenstout.substack.com/">Brian Stout</a> has been writing:</p><ul><li><a href="https://citizenstout.substack.com/p/coronavirus-and-the-choice-we-now">Coronavirus… and the choice we now face</a></li><li><a href="https://citizenstout.substack.com/p/turning-toward-connecting-under-quarantine">Turning toward: connecting under quarantine</a></li><li><a href="https://citizenstout.substack.com/p/care-connects-us-all">Care connects us all</a></li></ul><p>Brian’s blog posts are thoughtful. They also provided links to all kinds of other content that’s really useful right now. I’ve gone down several different rabbit holes from his pieces alone.</p><p>Charles Eisenstein wrote an amazing essay called <a href="https://charleseisenstein.org/essays/the-coronation/?_page=2">The Coronation</a>. He has some incredibly insightful observations on our ways of being and interestingly how we are so afraid of dying and how this permeates our decision-making.</p><p>I liked this quote:</p><blockquote>Covid-19 is like a rehab intervention that breaks the addictive hold of normality. To interrupt a habit is to make it visible; it is to turn it from a compulsion to a choice.</blockquote><p>Bonus: he was later <a href="https://www.richroll.com/podcast/charles-eisenstein-511/">interviewed by Rich Roll</a> on his podcast about the essay.</p><p>Otto Scharmer of MIT’s Presencing Institute has written a couple of articles:</p><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/presencing-institute-blog/eight-emerging-lessons-from-coronavirus-to-climate-action-683c39c10e8b">Eight Emerging Lessons: From Coronavirus to Climate Action</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/presencing-institute-blog/a-new-superpower-in-the-making-awareness-based-collective-action-83861bcb9859">A New Superpower in the Making: Awareness-Based Collective Action</a></li></ul><p>These articles are interesting in and of themselves. But more importantly, they led me down the path of joining the global community that the Presencing Institute created, called GAIA. I also invited some friends along and now we have a hub of about 40 people all participating in the GAIA journey together.</p><p>I loved this article by Panthea Lee, <a href="https://reboot.org/2020/03/20/rebuilding-compassionate-social-contract-face-covid-19/">Rebuilding a Compassionate Social Contract in the Face of COVID-19</a>.</p><p>Her advice is that out of this crisis we need “Radical Collaboration”</p><ul><li>We urgently need transformative collaborations.</li><li>We must center response efforts in equity and justice.</li><li>We should be both obnoxiously demanding and unreasonably kind to each other, across divides of “citizen”, “activist”, and “government”.</li></ul><p>Arundhati Roy wrote <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/10d8f5e8-74eb-11ea-95fe-fcd274e920ca">The pandemic is a portal</a>, an essay about how India is experiencing the pandemic. It’s a fascinating view into Indian culture. Also, there’s this, which really struck me:</p><blockquote>Whatever it is, coronavirus has made the mighty kneel and brought the world to a halt like nothing else could. Our minds are still racing back and forth, longing for a return to “normality”, trying to stitch our future to our past and refusing to acknowledge the rupture. But the rupture exists. And in the midst of this terrible despair, it offers us a chance to rethink the doomsday machine we have built for ourselves. Nothing could be worse than a return to normality.</blockquote><p>A few recent articles about the public service that I found interesting:</p><ul><li><a href="https://ipolitics.ca/2020/04/18/covid-19-were-seeing-the-best-of-canadas-public-servants-when-it-matters-most/">COVID-19: We’re seeing the best of Canada’s public servants when it matters most</a> (really great perspective from one of Canada’s Senators)</li><li><a href="https://policyoptions.irpp.org/magazines/april-2020/how-covid-19-could-reshape-the-federal-public-service/">How COVID-19 could reshape the federal public service</a> (great article from Kathryn May, a local Ottawa journalist, about how the public service might be permanently changed as a result of the pandemic)</li><li><a href="https://apolitical.co/en/solution_article/has-your-boss-asked-how-youre-doing-today">Has your boss asked how you’re doing today?</a> (good argument for why we need to collect data about how our employees are doing through the use of pulse surveys)</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2931ca475f5d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Journey With Organizational Health at Statistics Canada]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@abramgreenspoon/a-journey-with-organizational-health-at-statistics-canada-7dc0f740afdb?source=rss-a61a44ebdeef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7dc0f740afdb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transformation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[organizational-health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Abe Greenspoon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 17 Feb 2020 13:54:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-19T12:52:11.154Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>Disclaimer: </em></strong><em>This blog is a bit of a departure from my usual “reflections style” blog. This is more of an update/description of the project I’m currently working on. I’m sharing this because I want to work in the open, but also because I find writing publicly to be really useful to clarify my thinking about my work.</em></p><p>On September 30, 2019 I started a new role at Statistics Canada (StatCan). I was invited to join the Human Resources Branch to design and implement a new program for the department called “Organizational Health”. At a meeting with the head of StatCan’s HR Branch where I first learned about the project, I was instantly intrigued about a couple of things: 1) how might the concept of organizational health be a useful way to think about the organizational challenges we face inside the public service, and 2) how might StatCan’s expertise with data be useful to enable the impact of this work? At the time of this meeting I’m not sure if I realized how excited I would get about this work, but I’m there now.</p><p>My excitement comes with how much this work aligns with my purpose. For a while now, <strong>my mission in the public service has become to help public servants discover and create the conditions for their success</strong>. This was the journey I ended up on with <a href="https://apolitical.co/en/solution_article/canadas-free-agents-helping-public-servants-find-purpose">Canada’s Free Agents</a> and it’s where I find myself with the Organizational Health program at StatCan. I see government, at its most basic level, as a manifestation of<strong> </strong>a group of people deciding to combine their resources to do the things we can’t do alone and to take care of each other when we need help. This collective decision aligns perfectly with my values of community, kindness, and compassion (among others). It’s incredibly important to me that the public service — in support of the government and in service to Canadians — deliver its mandate well. For this to happen, we need to create the conditions for people to achieve their full potential. This is my “why”. Why I get out of bed every day and why I’m excited about the opportunity we have at StatCan.</p><p><strong>So why organizational health?</strong></p><p>The past few years, StatCan has been undertaking <a href="https://www.statcan.gc.ca/eng/about/smr09/smr09_100">a significant modernization effort</a> across the agency. This means a lot of changes including <strong>new statistical methods, new sources of data, new sectors to measure, new ways to collect data, and new workplace designs</strong>. As a broad-scale change effort across a large organization, I’m naturally hesitant about the approach. But more about that later.</p><p>One thing is for sure, these changes will ask a lot of StatCan employees. New ways of working bring the need for new skills and new cultural values. For many, these changes will be exciting and seen as long overdue. For others, these changes will feel threatening, confusing, and frustrating. This is important because <strong>the ability of the organization to achieve its desired new state will critically depend on its people and their efforts towards the new vision</strong>.</p><p>We know from extensive research done by consulting firm McKinsey &amp; Co. that healthy organizations dramatically outperform their peers in terms of meeting their performance objectives, particularly during times of change. The proof is strong — organizations that work on their health, <a href="https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/organization/our-insights/organizational-health-a-fast-track-to-performance-improvement">McKinsey found</a>, not only achieve measurable improvements in their organizational well-being but demonstrate tangible performance gains in as little as 6 to 12 months. This holds true for organizations across sectors and regions. More specifically, McKinsey found that by placing <strong>equal emphasis and effort on performance and health</strong>, an organization can improve the likelihood of success for its organizational change program <strong>from 30% to almost 80%<em>.</em></strong></p><p>With all of this in mind, StatCan’s leadership has identified organizational health as one of its top priorities for the next few years.</p><p><strong>What is organizational health?</strong></p><p>StatCan is currently defining organizational health as <em>the ability of an organization’s human resources to meet the organization’s objectives</em>. In this sense, organizational health can be thought of as <strong>how well the organization’s people contribute to the organization’s performance</strong>. Measuring organizational health is effectively gathering information about the things in the organization that are enabling or disabling employees’ productivity. In studying the health of our organization, we want to gather insights about StatCan employees so that we can help them achieve their greatest potential contribution to the organization’s performance.</p><p>To begin this work, StatCan has conducted some preliminary research drawing on well-established sources of data, including reports from McKinsey and others. From this research, we’ve identified <strong>a set of pillars that we’ll measure to determine the overall health of the organization</strong>. These pillars will include things like skills, knowledge, motivation, and mental health. When measured together, these pillars will provide StatCan with an Organizational Health Index (OHI).</p><p>At this point, our OHI is a “best guess” about the conditions that determine organizational health at StatCan. I’m certain that as we undertake the work we’ll learn things about our organization that will inform changes to how we measure our health. But for now, this gives us a place to start.</p><p>The quantitative research undertaken through the development and implementation of the OHI will be critical for understanding the organization’s baseline state. Furthermore, the OHI will also help StatCan <strong>determine where to place its emphasis and effort to improve on the baseline</strong>. Quantitative research can answer questions such as “what is happening?”, “where is it happening?” and “how much is it happening?” Answering these questions gives us a target for our activities by pointing us to parts of the organization that are facing difficulties.</p><p>However, given that the OHI will measure areas such as motivation and relationships, the underlying problems that create health challenges will inevitably involve human behaviour. In many of these cases, qualitative research will be necessary to gain deeper insights and understand the root causes of the issues. Qualitative research methods such as structured focus groups and interviews will help us answer questions such as “why is this happening?” and “how did this happen?” While quantitative research gives us a target, <strong>qualitative research brings the target into focus</strong> so that we can accurately identify which interventions will be most effective for improving the OHI.</p><p><strong>The Organizational Health Team</strong></p><p>In order to undertake this project, StatCan will create an Organizational Health team (OHT). Ideally, the team will possess strong facilitation and related interpersonal skills and have knowledge of qualitative research methods (participatory action research, ethnography, design thinking), organizational development, behavioural science, and adult learning. We think these and some other related skills will give us a good starting point.</p><p>Of additional interest to me is the creation of a team that embodies a radically different way of working. My desire is for the OHT to conduct its <strong>work in a way that honours the complexity involved in making sense of and responding to the experiences of StatCan employees</strong>. As a result, all members of the team will need to be comfortable with an emergent approach to the work by embracing continuous learning through short, intentionally designed feedback loops with clients.</p><p>Additionally, the OHT will attempt to undertake its work using a <strong>non-hierarchical, self-organizing, multi-disciplinary approach</strong>. Members of the OHT will need to be comfortable with high degrees of autonomy, regularly changing work responsibilities, working in significantly open and transparent ways, and regular feedback from colleagues. We’ll create <strong>explicit, transparent team agreements</strong> about things like decision-making, meetings, and hours of work. And as the team evolves, so will these agreements.</p><p>As the OHT tries new approaches and team members learn from their experiences, we will share as much as we can about what we learn as openly and transparently as possible while respecting the sensitivity of the work and the privacy of its clients. Team members will prepare blogs, articles, and presentations to be shared broadly across the public service.</p><p><strong>So what’s next?</strong></p><p>As I mentioned earlier, I’m hesitant to think about organizational change as something that happens in a traditional, top-down way. As I co-wrote in an <a href="https://apolitical.co/en/solution_article/public-servants-are-tired-of-change-washing-not-change">article for Apolitical</a>,</p><blockquote>Real, genuine change takes individual and group dedication at local levels. It requires occasional insurgency, habitual reflection and constant learning. In other words, teams need to become evolutionary entities that deeply practise new ways of working and are constantly changing.</blockquote><p>So rather than attempting to affect positive change to the organization’s health as a whole, we’ll be making <strong>targeted efforts at a local level</strong>.</p><p>During an initial period of several months, the OHT will select a number of initial “pilot teams” to undertake our work. We’ll meet with managers to discuss their organizational health concerns, walk them through our approach, and determine our shared objectives. We’ll create <strong>safe space for deep and meaningful conversations</strong>, from which we’ll draw our insights about the root causes of the problems these teams face.</p><p>Using the results from its initial qualitative research, the OHT will try to make sense of how it can positively support the teams’ health. Currently, <strong>I can see this going one of four ways</strong>. In some cases, teams might find that being given the time and appropriate space to explore their challenges together will lead them to the actions they need to take by themselves. In other cases, it’s possible that the support the team needs will come from an existing program inside the department (such as training or conflict resolution). In some other cases, the services might not exist and we’ll need design and test new services as micro-interventions, a useful method for testing the impact of an activity by allowing for rapid prototyping based on feedback. And finally, there may also be cases where the solution is outside of the scope and capability of the OHT.</p><p>Overall, you could summarize the approach we’re taking as follows: 1) gather quantitative data to measure organizational health in teams, 2) gather qualitative data about a set of teams to understand the sources of their challenges, 3) take actions based on the insights from the qualitative data, 4) re-measure organizational health to understand if there was an impact from the action taken.</p><p>We’ll use this sort of feedback cycle as the basis for our evolutionary purpose. As the work evolves and we as people evolve, so too will our purpose. We will learn, learn, and learn. But this, as they say, will be the start of our journey.</p><p><strong><em>If you made it this far, thanks for reading. I’m looking for companions to join me on this adventure and love swapping stories and ideas. So get in touch if you’re interested in learning more or have something to share.</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7dc0f740afdb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Brazil Public Sector Innovation Week]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@abramgreenspoon/brazil-public-sector-innovation-week-5728e6af3d82?source=rss-a61a44ebdeef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5728e6af3d82</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[public-service]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brazil]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Abe Greenspoon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 18 Nov 2019 14:23:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-18T14:23:11.987Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Between November 4–7, the Government of Brazil’s School of Public Service held its fifth annual Public Sector Innovation Week in the country’s capital, Brasilia. I was incredibly fortunate to have been invited to speak and to have the support of my department, Statistics Canada, to attend.</p><p>The event’s website provided an overview:</p><blockquote>For the past five years, Brazil’s Innovation Week has become the largest annual conference on public sector innovation in South America. The event’s goal is to fix the innovation agenda at the center of government strategy throughout South America, to accelerate progress towards meeting the challenges of 21st century governance, and to empower civil servants as protagonists of this process. With the theme “<strong>Government for the People</strong>”, this year’s conference will address topics such as User Experience in the Public Sector, Digital Transformation, Exponential Technologies, Evidence-based Policy Making and Artificial Intelligence in Public Policy.</blockquote><p>The week was full of impressive speakers addressing bold topics and highlighting some incredible work being done around the world. You can find the <a href="https://semanadeinovacao.enap.gov.br/programme/">agenda here</a> and you can watch a video broadcast of the entire conference on the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/user/CanalENAP">School’s YouTube channel</a>.</p><p>Before I get into the conference content, a bit about Brasilia. The city itself is fascinating for many reasons. First of all, it’s definitely a lesser known city in Brazil. Most people know about São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro as the two most famous cities in Brazil. At only about 2.5 million people, Brasilia is quite a bit smaller. And Brasilia was only inaugurated as Brazil’s capital in 1960, so it’s quite a young city. Speaking to quite a few Brazilians about the city, it struck me that anyone I spoke to <em>from</em> Brasilia was quite fond of it while folks I spoke to from other parts of the country weren’t so flattering. In some ways, it reminds me a lot of Ottawa! Which I guess you’d expect from another capital city maybe?</p><p>To me, the most interesting thing about Brasilia is how the city was built. In fact, the city was designed to be laid out in the shape of a plane.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1412bPrragom_ilTECFzGQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The city’s layout makes it one of the most unique places I’ve ever been and in fact Brasilia was chosen as a UNESCO World Heritage Site due to its modernist architecture and uniquely artistic urban planning. The city’s design divides it into numbered blocks as well as sectors for specified activities, such as the Hotel Sector, the Banking Sector and the Embassy Sector. I think it’s probably the most organized city in the world.</p><p>People in Brasilia are nothing but warm, welcoming, and kind. I was treated incredibly well from the moment I arrived at the airport to smiling faces to the moment I was dropped off by a new friend I met there who kindly offered to drive me to the airport without hesitation. The food is incredible as you’d expect, which was definitely a highlight for me. Unfortunately, because I was so engrossed in the conference experience (Public Sector Innovation is kind of a bit of an obsession…) I missed out on any deep cultural experiences such as dancing or live music. But that just gives me a good reason to go back!</p><p>OK so speaking of the conference, time to dig into the speakers and the topics I got a chance to be part of. Arriving at the conference venue on Day 1 was exciting. I got to hang out with Nitika Agarwal, Chief Operating Officer for <a href="http://apolitical.co/">Apolitical</a>, a global learning platform for government. I had met Nitika a few times before and I’m a huge fan of what they’re up to at Apolitical.</p><h3>Abe Greenspoon on Twitter</h3><p>Here at #semanadeinovacao in Brasilia, Brazil with @agarwal_nitika2 from @apoliticalco. Excited for a few days to hear all about how Brazil is creating a culture of innovation for its public service.</p><p>Day 1 kicked off with some big name speakers — Ministers, Department Heads, and the Ambassador of Denmark. I was disappointed that the first panel of the week was made up of eight men in suits, with not a single woman to be seen. It made me thankful that in Canada we’ve seen the rise of the term “manel” — a portmanteau of “man” and “panel” and the understanding of men only panels as more and more taboo. Still, it was interesting to hear them speak about the importance of the event, especially in the context of the impending <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/69ff9746-000e-11ea-b7bc-f3fa4e77dd47">administrative reform</a> the country is undertaking. You could tell that there was a mix of excitement and a bit of anxiety about what might be to come and I felt like this tension hung in the air quite a bit all week.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bZ7opT7BjXCIuUfM4AuKgQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The first panel of the week with Ministers, Department Heads, and the Ambassador of Denmark</figcaption></figure><p>Immediately following the panel, we heard from Paulo Uebel, Special Secretary for Debureaucratization, Management and Digital Government. I found it pretty interesting that the Brazilian government appointed someone to focus on “debureaucratization.” In Canada, we’ve referred to this usually under the title of “red tape reduction”, which we’ve undertaking before. Mr. Uebel’s presentation was titled <em>Rethinking Brazil for the future: being digital for being human. </em>He spoke about the need to reduce bureaucracy in entrepreneurial activities and stimulate entrepreneurship and innovation with minimal intervention from the government.</p><h3>Abe Greenspoon on Twitter</h3><p>Special Secretary for Debureaucratization, Management and Digital Government, @paulouebel. Debureaucratization! That&#39;s someone&#39;s job in Brazil! #semanadeinovacao #innovationinbrazil</p><p>Later in the early afternoon, Rikke Hougaard Zeberg, Chief Information Officer of Denmark and Siim Sikkut, Chief Information Officer of Estonia gave presentations about <em>Overcoming the Challenges of Digital Transformation in Government</em>. The story of Estonia is particularly fascinating given they’ve been able to move virtually all of their citizen services online. You can learn all about the incredibly story of Estonia at <a href="https://e-estonia.com/">their e-Estonia website</a>.</p><h3>Wesley Vaz (韦斯利) on Twitter</h3><p>Presenciando a espetacular e &quot;estonishing&quot; palestra do Siim Sikkut. Watching the spectacular and &quot;estonishing&quot; presentation by @sikkut. Really inspiring words and cases. #semanadeinovacao #govtech</p><p>To end the first day, Nitika and I spoke about <em>Building the Future Civil Service</em>. I gave a presentation about building the future skills for government and Nitika spoke about the need for humility, agency, and diversity in the public service for the future. It was a lot of fun and amazingly mine and Nitika’s presentations went really well together despite us not even speaking before hand about what we’d write about. I linked to the video in my tweet below. It felt like the Brazilian public servants in attendance really agreed with some of the thoughts Nitika and I shared — I think we were with our people, which was great.</p><h3>Abe Greenspoon on Twitter</h3><p>Had a great time sharing my thoughts about Building the Public Service of the Future at #semanadeinovacao in Brazil today! If you missed my presentation, you can watch me and my lovely co-presenter @agarwal_nitika2 on YouTube: https://t.co/mKw73AAGp3</p><p>The first stretch of the morning of Day 2 was all about user experience, user design, and service design. It was an incredible morning hearing from Sergio Pancorbo, Leader of the National Platform in Peru, Bruno Magrani, Director at Nubank in Brazil, and Sarah Drummond, Director and Founder at the British design agency Snook. Hearing about the experience of Peru and how they’re using citizen-centred design principles and practices was inspiring. Nubank in Brazil has some great internal practices of self-organization and the creation of innovative team structures that enable the organization to deliver incredible services for its users. And the work that Snook is doing in the UK is fascinating and Ms. Drummond gave some great advice include a few key principles such as “Build networks, no silos”, “Champion Inclusive Design”, and “Work in the Open”. Overall, these first few presentations on Day 2 made for a really great overview of why government needs to focus more on user-centricity and user experience.</p><h3>Abe Greenspoon on Twitter</h3><p>This morning at #semanadeinovacao in Brazil @sergiopancorbo is sharing how the government of Peru is trying to create a better experience for citizens when they interact with government services. We are on the same path in Canada and can learn a lot from our SA colleagues.</p><h3>Abe Greenspoon on Twitter</h3><p>Now @brunomagrani is talking about how @nubank encourages self-organizing, multi-disciplinary teams using the model of squads and chapters. How might we take inspiration from these practices to improve our work in the public sector? #semanadeinovacao</p><h3>Abe Greenspoon on Twitter</h3><p>Inspiring presentation this morning from @rufflemuffin from @wearesnook about her work on service design in the UK. Great reminder that when we are creating something new, we are designing. #semanadeinovacao</p><p>The last presentation of the morning (and the last session I was able to attend) was Dan Ariely, Professor of Psychology and Behavioral Economics, and Thais Cardarelli, Coordinator at Kayma Labs Brazil, who spoke about <em>Design meets Behavioural Economics</em>. It was fascinating to hear about some of the work that Kayma has done with the Government of Brazil to test different types of communications with citizens using behavioural science. And Professor Ariely (who you might know from his <a href="https://www.ted.com/search?q=dan+ariely">various TedTalks</a>) was inspiring as usual, talking about the value of using behavioural science to help citizens make good choices.</p><h3>Abe Greenspoon on Twitter</h3><p>Some brilliant insights from @danariely about the potential value of using behavioural science to improve how government serves citizens. &quot;We have an obligation to help people make good choices for their long term well being.&quot; #semanadeinovacao</p><p>The afternoon of Day 2 and all of Day 3 was occupied by meetings. I had a chance to speak with people from the School of Public Service; the Office of Personnel Management; BRAVA, an NGO interested in human resources management; and, folks from various teams within the Ministry of the Economy. They had lots of questions about the work we’re doing in Canada and I shared my experience about the innovation ecosystem in our public service and in particular some of our best practices in human resources. I finished Day 3 by giving a 60-minute lecture to a class of MBA students about how Statistics Canada is using data analytics in human resources to improve how we manage our workforce.</p><p>Before leaving for the airport on Day 4, I summarized some thoughts I was having about the conference experience overall in a few tweets. I’ll end this blog by referencing those remarks below. Thanks for reading!</p><h3>Abe Greenspoon on Twitter</h3><p>My last day in Brazil today for #semanadeinovacao. An amazing week full of new friends, new ideas, nourishing conversations, and a few brilliant surprises. So thankful for the opportunity to be here. Some brief thoughts that are just forming in my head that I may explore further:</p><blockquote>We are in many ways incredibly different countries. But what is most interesting is our similarities. All week I noted the same concerns, challenges, optimism, fear, anxiety, and energy for positive change that I think we have in Canada. As public servants we are on similar missions. And as humans we’re so much the same at our cores. We feel the same emotions and carry the same weights on our shoulders. Our histories shape us differently but we all want similar futures that we can shape together. This conference provided a safe and intentional space for conversations and support. There are reverberations similar to <a href="https://medium.com/u/8cf84a6fbdec">One Team Gov</a> movements around the world. They’re hungry for change and have an opportunity to organize to build movements. The same topics come up: system change, user centricity, design, culture, transformation, digital, data, etc etc etc. Each of these topics are at the top of their minds. We aren’t so far ahead in Canada (if we are even ahead at all). They’re learning just as we are. We need to nurture connections across borders around the world. If we’re still only thinking about and acting on our local reality, we’re missing something. The slogan “think global, act local” has never felt more relevant to me than right now. I’m incredibly lucky to have had this opportunity and I don’t plan to waste this gift. I’m full of energy, optimism, and ideas that I can bring to my work back home. Thank you Brazil for this. I hope this is just the start and that I can come back soon!</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5728e6af3d82" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[New job: helping me first, then us]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@abramgreenspoon/new-job-helping-me-first-then-us-ecbaa2c453f7?source=rss-a61a44ebdeef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ecbaa2c453f7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[careers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jobs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hiring]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[career-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[career-advice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Abe Greenspoon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Nov 2019 14:32:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-08T14:32:41.651Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>About a month ago, I started a new project. I’m now at Statistics Canada and have been given some responsibility to lead the department’s approach to organizational health. After four years working on <a href="https://apolitical.co/solution_article/canadas-free-agents-helping-public-servants-find-purpose/">Canada’s Free Agents</a>, a project I poured my heart and soul into, I’m now starting something new. And lately I’ve been feeling an urge to write about my experience. Writing is useful for me, but I also write because I value working in the open so that others can learn with me.</p><p>I’m planning to write four separate pieces in the coming weeks: 1) how I went about finding a new job; 2) what it was like to start a new job; 3) how I’m going about thinking about my new mission; and 4) what I’m planning to do next.</p><p>The first two parts are personal reflection. If you’re not interested in my story, I don’t take offence — again I’m also writing for my own benefit. If you’re just here to learn about my work on organizational health, you’re welcome to wait for part three.</p><p>But in my view, organizational health is about the conditions in which we as humans will be successful in organizations. This means we need to understand ourselves and be able to bring our whole selves to our work. So for me, knowing myself and exploring my being always comes before any efforts I make to help and support others. Or as the title of this first blog suggests, <strong>I need to help me first, then us.</strong></p><p>Therefore, I hope my personal story is illustrative of one possible approach to health, change, transformation, modernization, improvement, or whatever your mission is.</p><p>This summer I finally came to terms with the fact that I needed to change jobs. I think I knew this was true a lot earlier, but after building something new and feeling proud of what I had helped create, it was hard to walk away. My personal connection with the work, the people, and the mission had become so strong it was difficult to admit that I was no longer meeting my own expectations in my role.</p><p>I compare my experience to what I’ve read about the experience of founders of some new businesses. Eventually, as the organization grows and evolves, it seems the founder often needs to evolve into a CEO or make space for someone with a different skill-set. I’m not sure if I’m the CEO type. And even if I am, I wasn’t able to make the transition with Free Agents. I’m not sure if I consider that a failure, but I do know that I learned a lot about myself from it that I’m building on in my new role.</p><p>After announcing I was leaving, I felt a weight lift off of my shoulders —definitely a sign that I was making the right decision. But in the same moment, it occurred to me that I hadn’t really thought about finding a new job in over four years. This sent me down a rabbit hole of self-reflection, asking myself questions about my strengths and weaknesses, my passions, my motivations, and my value. After a few months I emerged from the rabbit hole with a decision — and one that I never would have guessed I’d make.</p><p>I’ve spoken to quite a few people about the process I used to pick my job and several people have commented that they either have a similar process or they felt they would benefit in some way from similar thinking. So I’m sharing a few key points about how I approached my search. <strong>NB: Keep in mind, I wasn’t looking for a promotion, only a lateral job change. YMMV if your main goal is to compete for a higher level job.</strong></p><ol><li><strong>Know thyself. </strong>Over the past few years, lots of people have asked me for advice about choosing their jobs. And I always start with the same thing — know yourself deeply. Ask yourself questions like “What do I really want to do?”, “What am I truly good at?”, “How do I really want to work?”, “In what conditions have I been successful in the past and in what conditions do I think I’ll be successful in the future?”, and “What matters more to me — the mission I’m on or the people I work with?” There are many more that might matter to you. If you can’t answer these types of questions <em>very clearly</em>, I don’t think you’re ready to meet people to talk about their work. Consider also what trade-offs you’re willing to make and separate into “must have” and “nice to have”.</li><li><strong>Use your network<em>.</em></strong><em> </em>I don’t think “cold calling” really works. Being introduced is way better. Reach out to people you know and talk to them about your answers to the above questions and see if they know of any work that would be a good fit. Even if they’re not hiring, it never hurts to follow leads and you’ll be surprised how willing people are to help if you are courteous and kind.</li><li><strong>Be authentic.</strong> Speaking of being courteous and kind, if you ask for a meeting with someone, be honest about your goals. If you know that you need certain conditions (telework, autonomy), have certain limitations (language, location), and are only interested in a specific field (HR, policy) then say that to everyone you talk to. Again, this requires you to know yourself (see point 1).</li><li><strong>Ask the right questions.</strong> Once you’ve drafted and answered the questions from point 1, you need to have a method to determine whether the jobs you’re considering meet your expectations. For each “must have” condition of your next job, consider what question you could ask a hiring manager that might tell you whether the job meets your needs. Don’t be afraid to dig deep and ask pointed questions. If you sense you’re getting vague or evasive answers, that could be a red flag.</li><li><strong>Seek references.</strong> Hiring managers should stand behind their reputation and the reputation of their workplace. They should take pride in the environment they create and be willing to admit when they have had challenges with people on their team. If this is true for the hiring managers you speak to, they should be willing to openly provide the names of people on their team and even the names of people who have left the team recently. Speaking to these people should help provide additional insights into the workplace and the management. Just as hiring managers ask you for references to validate your suitability for them, so should you ask for references to validate their suitability for you.</li></ol><p>And so just to briefly illustrate, these five points added up to this for me:</p><ol><li>The mission of the public service resonates with me deeply. I want to make the public service better. I want to help people do better work in the public service. I need autonomy and the ability to have flexible work hours and work locations. I’m much better right now at building things from scratch rather than sustain things once they’re built. I’m good at listening and can translate people’s experiences into action. I have high confidence in the integrity of my actions and decisions and this translated into a kind of fearlessness that can be useful for risky innovations. I have I value honesty, humility, empathy, learning, and psychological safety.</li><li>I started by emailing people I trust deeply and told them everything from point 1. Not only did this make it easier for them to think about potential places to work, it also helped me validate whether my message was clear and how it might resonate as a “pitch” of sorts.</li><li>I shared everything from point 1 (and more) with prospective hiring managers. I told them that I was taking my time making a decision and a set a firm deadline which I clearly stated. I talked about the process I use when joining a new team (which I’ll talk about in my next blog). I was honest about examples in my past where I’ve failed.</li><li>Flexibility and autonomy are make-or-break for me — I need both. So I asked questions about management styles, reporting expectations, policies on telework, how to communicate changing schedules, examples of people who are working in the way I want to, etc.</li><li>Once I had a few clear “winners” for places I was pretty sure I would succeed, I again sought out people I trusted who either had worked for the managers I was considering or knew them well enough to vouch for them. When possible, I met with other managers and staff from the team without the hiring manager present. I always related my conversations back to point 1 and asked whether they felt this was the right place for my interests.</li></ol><p>Like I said in the beginning, I think this process is critical because I don’t want to work in an organization where I can’t bring my whole self to contribute to the mission. I’ve been there and it’s at best unfulfilling and at worst soul crushing. This sort of process takes time, but I believe if more people were given or simply took the time going through this kind of thinking, we’d see higher productivity and fewer health issues in our workplaces.</p><p>Finally, I want to express my infinite gratitude that I work for an employer (the Government of Canada) where I have the privilege of being able to find and do work that is meaningful to me and meets my personal and professional needs. It’s a gift and I hope I don’t ever take that for granted or stop working as hard as I can to contribute to our incredibly important mission.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ecbaa2c453f7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Grappling with complexity]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@abramgreenspoon/grappling-with-complexity-59ef918c3669?source=rss-a61a44ebdeef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/59ef918c3669</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[complexity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gcagents]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[problem-solving]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[systems-thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Abe Greenspoon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 Aug 2019 13:00:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-15T13:19:58.226Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Have you ever been introduced to an idea or concept that seizes your imagination and literally transforms the way you see the world? This happened to me recently when I was introduced to a podcast called <a href="https://markfoden.com/blog/2018/12/the-clock-and-the-cat-podcast"><em>The Clock and the Cat</em></a>. <a href="https://medium.com/u/c50ffdf172f2">Thom Kearney</a> introduced me to this brief, six episode podcast earlier this year and its content has been on my mind, influencing my work and my perception of the world ever since.</p><h3>The Clock and the Cat on Twitter</h3><p>change the way you use the word Complexity. Forever.&quot; 7-minute intro to the podcast https://t.co/TRumWsaOGO</p><p>I think everyone should listen to this podcast. And I think everyone should consider the implications of complexity in their lives. I think that public servants who are exploring reform, innovation, transformation (or whatever words you want to use to describe your work to positively change your organization) <strong><em>must</em></strong> listen to this podcast. Or at least I think they should seek to understand complexity, complexity science, network science, systems thinking, and other related fields. <em>The Clock and the Cat </em>is an incredibly accessible introduction to the importance of these concepts.</p><p>The first thing that struck me about complexity was how it made me <em>feel</em>. It was almost as if seeing the world through a lens of complexity validated some troubling feelings I had been having. It was as if I had found a word that contextualized a bunch of other words I had been using. It felt like a concept around which many others circled. Concepts like iteration, learning, experimentation, risk, innovation, evaluation and many others I have encountered in my work all seemed to connect and become more clear as I learned about complexity.</p><p>I rarely come across a concept that takes hold of me the way complexity has. And it’s not that I haven’t known complexity. I’ve known complexity my whole life. But it’s only recently that I’ve understood its importance in my work. So much so that within hours of listening to <em>The Clock and the Cat </em>I crowd-sourced <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Bh77ed1sYhH7i8bsdApW-ORU4kYjhl9NGMrED2_ZWps/edit?usp=sharing">a Google Doc of complexity resources</a> on Twitter.</p><h3>Abe Greenspoon on Twitter</h3><p>Lately I&#39;m fascinated with #complexity. The more I learn about complexity and systems theory the more I believe understanding it is essential for influencing change. So I&#39;m compiling a list of resources. Please feel free to add yours here: https://t.co/kofRdJ7Bhk</p><p>As always with Twitter, I was impressed with how many of my colleagues were/are so far ahead of me in their thinking about this space. The Twitter thread is full of good tips, advice, and even warnings about the rabbit hole I was heading into (and maybe still am in?).</p><p>I’m still so early on in my level of sophisticated understanding of complexity. I’ve listened to each of the six <em>Clock and the Cat</em> episodes at least twice and some of them several times. I love it for its simplicity and clarity. It’s a great introduction to the difference between complicated and complex (and why you’ve probably been using those words wrong). I’ve read a few articles from the list and in particular have enjoyed reading about the work of <a href="https://cognitive-edge.com/">Dave Snowden</a> and his <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N7oz366X0-8">Cynefin framework</a>. And lately I’m loving the content coming out of the <a href="https://www.centreforpublicimpact.org/">Center for Public Impact</a> (CPI), a global not-for-profit foundation. I’m not sure how much deeper I’ll go into the rabbit hole. But I’m at a place where I’m comfortable talking about my experiences publicly as a way to share what I’ve learned openly and seek reactions from friends and colleagues.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FN7oz366X0-8%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DN7oz366X0-8&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FN7oz366X0-8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/65a988fcad6afbb2e04a033ada57ba0e/href">https://medium.com/media/65a988fcad6afbb2e04a033ada57ba0e/href</a></iframe><p>I’m not going to write a definition of complexity. The context of the difference between complicated systems and complex systems presented in the <em>Clock and the Cat</em> is the best way to situate this idea and the first episode is only 7 minutes long. So take a minute and listen to it or read the transcript <a href="https://markfoden.com/clockcat/2018/12/episode-1-introduction">here</a>. What I want to write about is potential value of this concept for tackling problems and how I have seen its relevance in my work.</p><p><strong>The challenge of complexity in the public service</strong></p><p>I want to start by digging a bit into my experience tackling complex problems in the public service and why I think doing so can be quite difficult. I start here because, as I come to terms with the nature of complex problems, I think most of the problems the public service needs to solve are exactly that — complex. The challenge, however, is that we don’t seem to have the right approach to address these sorts of problems.</p><p>As I see it, one of the biggest challenges with solving complex problems is that the moment you begin to affect change (implementing programs, policies, regulations, etc.), the components of the complex system you’re trying to affect will also change in unpredictable ways. And from this resulting change, new problems will begin to present themselves, usually requiring different solutions than originally predicted. As a result, practitioners like Snowden and others suggest that we need to approach these types of problems by taking small actions, observing the resulting changes, learning from them, and then trying again with the new information. This process has been referred to as sense-making, experimenting, and probably otherwise. But critically, it seems to me that successful practitioners in this space respect ideas like emergence and the unknown unknowns. In other words, since you can’t predict what you don’t know, existing knowledge simply allows you to develop a hypothesis or theory of change and you need to test your hypothesis and learn from your test to inform your next action.</p><p>You can contrast the above concepts and practices with how we generally solve problems in the public service. Generally, public sector problem solving seems to mostly involve things like large scale policy development, comprehensive risk mitigation strategies, long-term plans, and post-implementation evaluation. I characterize this approach as one that sets a very high bar for certainty and predictability. When people talk about low tolerance for risk in the public service, I think this is where we feel it the most.</p><p>Tackling problems this way is less science and more science fiction. We develop policies with information from today that will be irrelevant to the realities people will face in the future. We demand high levels of predictability while intervening in systems that are unpredictable. We evaluate our work after it’s finished, learning lessons that only might help us “next time”. This approach might work in a context where we’re tackling simple or complicated problems, but after learning about complex systems theory in even the most rudimentary way, it’s already pretty clear to me the shortcomings of this approach for complex problem solving.</p><p>Predictably, in this environment it can be very difficult to advocate for an approach to problem solving that respects the complexity of the problems being solved. The bar for predictability and and certainty is too high. I have faced this challenge personally in my work. Still, I have been very lucky to have worked with some incredibly brave and supportive leaders who created space for me to experiment. And I can point to some key elements of our work that respected the complexity of the problem we were trying to solve and I believe had a direct impact on our success.</p><p><strong>Examples of complex problem solving</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/749/1*vUwsmK6awZtTwMFktaVJXQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>With <a href="https://policyoptions.irpp.org/magazines/november-2018/the-value-of-free-agents-inside-the-public-service/">Canada’s Free Agents</a>, we never actually referred to our approach as one that respected the nature of the problem we were attempting to tackle as complex. But as we’ve been playing in a space occupied by a complex mixture of human behaviours, customs, and rules, it has become clear to me that the domain of human resources is incredibly complex. Which is why I’ve found it so interesting to only stumble onto complexity so recently. Regardless, I strongly believe that our success to date has been thanks to our special blend of circumstances that were well suited for a complex problem. I think about our work based on the conditions they provided. They are: 1) visionary and courageous leadership (Neil Bouwer, Lauren Hunter), 2) obsessive action-orientation (me), and 3) resilient participants (Free Agents). This combination allowed us to tackle the problem in a fairly unique way.</p><p>First, we were able to start with a hypothesis. This was sort of a “best guess” about whether the vision for our model would work and have the impact we thought it might. There was little certainty, but we made a reasonable case with a reasonable amount of research. But most importantly, we were transparent about the iterative approach we would take and the potential for failure. Our leaders had the vision to see the potential upside and embraced the risks.</p><p>Second, we were able to take action and learn from doing. We were given the space and the support to make decisions on our own about the design and execution of the project. And when we made mistakes, we weren’t punished because we had support from our management to learn and improve. We embraced this continuous learning approach and it allowed us to respond to new sources of information as we grew and evolved the model.</p><p>And finally, we were able to develop the program in partnership with our most important stakeholders — the Free Agents. We made ourselves accountable to them with a commitment to learning from their experiences. And they made themselves accountable to each other with a set of shared principles about how they would do their work. We practice distributed leadership by giving the Free Agents opportunities to lead projects and take on leadership roles in the program.</p><p>We missed the mark so many times, so I don’t mean to paint an overly rosy picture. We’re in a seemingly perpetual battle to normalize our operations and give the Free Agents what they deserve — a great employee experience. We’re not there yet. Still, we built a new model that I believe would not have survived the low risk tolerance/high predictability requirements of “normal” approaches to public sector problem solving. I’ve taken this as a valuable cue for what I need to represent as a leader in the public service.</p><p><strong>A new paradigm for public sector problem solving</strong></p><p>As I mentioned above, lately I’m very interested in the work by CPI. They have published some really interesting work. In particular, I highly recommend reading about their <a href="https://resources.centreforpublicimpact.org/production/2019/07/WEB-CPI-Shared-Power-Principle.pdf">Shared Power Principle</a> which is an incredible summary of their findings about how public sector organizations are successfully tackling complex problems.</p><h3>CPI on Twitter</h3><p>What would the world look like if all governments were effective and trusted to work for everyone? Hard to imagine, right? We&#39;ve been exploring a new paradigm for the future of government. Could shared power be the answer? https://t.co/wmPO8R7CIK #FutureGovernment</p><p>I also particularly enjoyed an <a href="https://www.centreforpublicimpact.org/simple-answers-wrong-toby-lowe-need-new-kind-accountability-public-services/amp/">interview</a> that CPI did with <a href="https://twitter.com/tobyjlowe?lang=en">Toby Lowe</a>, a Senior Lecturer in Public Management at Newcastle Business School. In the interview, Toby explores the problems with our current performance measurement and accountability frameworks and dives into some of the characteristics of a possible new paradigm for solving complex problems. He says:</p><blockquote>Working effectively requires the ability to adapt and change in response to the dynamic nature of the environment, because the context which enables interventions to ‘work’ is constantly changing, so our interventions need to constantly adapt and change. “What works” is the continuous process of listening, learning and adapting. …The outcomes we care about are not “delivered” by organisations but are the result of hundreds of factors ⁠ — people, organisations, processes, cultures ⁠ — interacting together in a system in unpredictable ways. If we want better outcomes, we need to help the people and organisations in these systems to collaborate and coordinate more effectively.</blockquote><p>I continue to be fascinated by this field of study and can see clearly how this new paradigm has the potential to bring renewed trust and greater impact for the public service. While I jokingly referred to the current model as science fiction, its limitations seem very real to me. A burgeoning study of complex systems seems like a better story to tell. Now if only more of our public sector leaders would show an interest in the genre.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=59ef918c3669" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Building a Free Agent community]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@abramgreenspoon/building-a-free-agent-community-8c3d562cbb98?source=rss-a61a44ebdeef------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8c3d562cbb98</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gcagents]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Abe Greenspoon]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Mar 2019 13:27:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-15T13:27:26.781Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/749/1*vUwsmK6awZtTwMFktaVJXQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s easy to feel lost working in a large organization like the Canadian federal public service. We’re around 275,000 people spread across about 200 different departments and agencies. When people join the public service their orientation seems to normally consist of things like an introduction to values and ethics, security briefings, information management tools, organizational charts, etc. These are relevant and important things to learn for sure. But I think something is missing and it’s indicative of a larger concern I have about how we motivate people to do their work.</p><p>For me, being motivated to do meaningful work within a mandate-driven team requires an understanding of how I belong. This includes basic things like understanding my role in making decisions about our work, the things that others in my team are working on, what value I bring to our work, and the ways people on my team help each other. It also includes understanding how my work belongs within the team’s work, how it belongs within the organization’s work, and how it delivers value for people and society. By understanding these elements of my work, I can understand my place within my team, organization, and even larger and more complex systems. So I think it’s worth asking: where and how do we want people to see themselves within these systems in the public service?</p><p>In traditional, hierarchical organizations, the design of the system emphasizes accountability and authority (I am accountable or not and so I have authority or I don’t). It emphasizes top-down leadership (I lead you and you follow me). It seems natural in this sort of environment that we would emphasize security briefings and org charts for new employees. The important thing is that we reinforce the sources of control and power — where it exists and where it does not. So what behaviours does this lead to?</p><p>I’ve been recently reading some of the work of Henry Mintzberg, a Canadian academic and author on business and management. He has some really interesting observations about this topic. In 2009, he wrote <a href="https://hbr.org/2009/07/rebuilding-companies-as-communities">an article for Harvard Business Review</a> at the beginning of the financial crisis where he talks about the behaviours we see in hierarchical, top-down, leadership-based organizations:</p><blockquote>Many of their executives adopted what has become a pervasive style of “leadership” in America: They sat in their offices and announced the goals they wanted others to attain, instead of getting on the ground and helping improve performance. Executives didn’t know what was going on, and employees didn’t care what went on. What a monumental failure of management.</blockquote><p>Mintzberg caricatures an ego-centric, heroic leader who “macroleads” their employees, exercising out-of-touch, top-down authority over their work. It is this culture that Mintzberg attributes as a major cause of the financial crisis.</p><p>I can relate to this. Based on my experience, I believe this sort of “leadership” is endemic in the public service and has the potential to lead us towards a similar sort of crisis — one where individuals lose their sense of purpose and belonging in their work and act to fulfill the needs of their egos before those of their organization or the people they serve.</p><p>So what’s a better alternative and how might we get there? Mintzberg writes that these behaviours isolate the people in leadership positions, thereby undermining a <strong><em>sense of community</em> </strong>in organizations. He proposes that we de-emphasize leadership and consider a new term — “communityship”. He says:</p><blockquote>Communityship requires a more modest form of leadership that might be called <strong><em>engaged</em> </strong>and <strong><em>distributed</em> </strong>management. A community leader is personally engaged in order to engage others, so that anyone and everyone can exercise initiative. So maybe it’s time to wean ourselves from the heroic leader and recognize that usually we need <strong><em>just enough leadership</em></strong> — leadership that intervenes when appropriate while encouraging people in the organization to get on with things.</blockquote><p>Mintzberg <a href="https://www.heartoftheart.org/?p=1041">goes even deeper in his blog on Heart of the Art</a>, an online community exploring complexity and systems change:</p><blockquote>We tend to make a great fuss about leadership these days, but communityship is more important. The great leaders create, enhance, and support a sense of community in their organizations…managers have get beyond their individual leadership, to recognize the collective nature of effective enterprise.</blockquote><p>So then here’s another question to ask: how might we create the conditions in our teams to <strong>recognize the collective nature of our enterprise? </strong>Or related back to my original idea: how might we organize our work so that people feel like they belong within a community or communities?</p><p>In my work on Canada’s Free Agents, I want to explore these questions. In <a href="https://medium.com/@abramgreenspoon/blog-series-reflections-about-canadas-free-agents-part-1-8461d4904477">a previous blog</a>, I wrote about the importance of feedback for the successful growth of Canada’s Free Agents. I tried to emphasize the role of Free Agents in our success as a way for us to share an experience where we could help and support each other so we could be successful together. This is an example of one of the ways in which we have tried to build a community. Below, I want to share some of the other ways that I and others in our program have tried to organize our work to create this sort of community. As Mintzberg puts it in his 2009 HBR article, our goal with these practices is to work together in ways that “promote trust, engagement, and spontaneous collaboration aimed at sustainability.” I also hope readers will consider ways they can adopt similar practices in their teams towards a similar goal.</p><p><strong>Shared responsibility</strong></p><p>I think the single most important element of the community model we’re trying to create is a sense of shared responsibility for the program’s success. I don’t believe our work should have any single point of success or failure. To me that means, at the extreme, I am working to make leadership dispensable. Or put a bit more softly, I’m working to make sure that any single person, including myself, can leave the program with minimal impact on the program’s success. I think this should be a desired goal of every team in a very practical sense, but I also think that this practice naturally leads to a higher level of engagement in the work as people recognize they are also responsible for the success of the work.</p><p>For us, this means Free Agents support the program and pitch in to do some of its operational work like communications, recruitment, and process design. In very practical terms, this means work gets done that might otherwise fall through the cracks. In more of a cultural sense, I hope it reinforces a sense of shared responsibility. In my ideal world, we will have Free Agents and a few “central” managers (including myself) who are committed to and engaged in our success together. As with everything we do, this is a work in progress. But in a program where there may be a tendency for Free Agents to think of themselves as “clients”, I hope they’ll think of themselves more as members of a community.</p><p><strong>Distributed decision-making</strong></p><p>How we make decisions as a program is something I’ve always been a bit obsessed with. In my ideal world, we would make decisions through consensus. I hope we can develop a model where all Free Agents contribute meaningfully to the decisions we make as a program. <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1cNJh1FbKz81llHJFP0HCa8zpQmJNVPI2-WXk0OSyJfQ/edit?usp=sharing">Here’s our current decision-making model</a>, which relies on governance via a steering committee. It’s fairly simple and standard and I don’t think we’ve gotten it quite right yet, but I’m proud that we have Assistant Deputy Ministers, Talent Managers, and Free Agents participating as equals in the way we make decisions about the program.</p><p>Lately, we’ve been figuring out how to take this one step further. At our most recent community gathering, <a href="https://medium.com/u/bb5a04afecd0">Helen Daniels</a> organized and activity where we asked the Free Agents to work together to develop principles for how we allocate our program’s budget. It made me wonder: why haven’t I ever been asked by my manager to provide input into our team’s budget? Usually I’m just given a set amount that I have to spend on training and off I go. Instead, we asked the Free Agents to guide us in allocating money for learning, travel, and downtime between assignments. In reflecting on the activity, I think it achieved two goals: 1) we had the opportunity to learn from the Free Agents about their shared views about our program’s finances; and 2) Free Agents had the opportunity to experience how difficult it can be to make these kind of decisions when there is no “right” answer. These sorts of insights build empathy and trust among us and ultimately make us stronger.</p><p><strong>Psychological safety</strong></p><p>By now, many of us are probably familiar with the <a href="https://rework.withgoogle.com/blog/five-keys-to-a-successful-google-team/">research undertaken by Google about the keys to a successful team</a>. Five key dynamics set successful teams apart from other teams and psychological safety was the most important dynamic. According to Google, when psychological safety is present, team members feel safe to take risks and be vulnerable in front of each other. They concluded:</p><blockquote>Individuals on teams with higher psychological safety are less likely to leave Google, <a href="http://www.mckinsey.com/insights/organization/why_diversity_matters">they’re more likely</a> to <a href="http://blogs.wsj.com/atwork/2015/01/20/new-report-finds-a-diversity-dividend-at-work/">harness the power of diverse ideas</a> from their teammates, they bring in more revenue, and they’re rated as effective twice as often by executives.</blockquote><p>For Canada’s Free Agents, we drafted a commitment (thanks again <a href="https://medium.com/u/bb5a04afecd0">Helen Daniels</a>) to <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1LREbhX3L1RByn6-TmE_kM8NfPZJUKjNpT-_UmTlZexw/edit?usp=sharing">psychological safety and conflict resolution</a>. We’ve learned the importance of these sorts of open and honest commitments to each other. It’s a bad idea to assume everyone implicitly understands and accepts these commitments, so we’ve tried to openly present these sorts of commitments and welcome feedback. We’ve also decided to begin our community gatherings with “principles of engagement” such as a commitment to empathy, recognizing diversity, listening with goodwill, and making a conscious effort to create a safe space. We hope that establishing these expectations openly will build trust and foster a feeling of inclusion.</p><p><strong>Learning from each other</strong></p><p>One of the ways the Free Agents support each other is by sharing the things they’re learning and doing. This happens in some of the purposeful spaces we’ve created for Free Agents to interact with each other. This includes our regular community gatherings either in person or virtually, weekly cohort phone calls, and ad-hoc learning activities that we’re starting to explore.</p><p>A new addition to our peer learning activities will be what we’re calling “my work”. <a href="https://medium.com/u/bb5a04afecd0">Helen Daniels</a> is piloting a series of one-hour WebEx sessions whereby five Free Agents will each have 10 minutes to share what they’re working on. In a practical sense, this type of peer learning moves us away from relying on expensive courses for areas of knowledge or practice that we might not need as much in-depth expertise. Even better, it benefits the people teaching as much as it benefits the people participating. And perhaps most importantly, it reinforces how we value learning from and helping each other — critical elements for a community.</p><p><strong>Caring for each other</strong></p><p>As I’ve said before, one of my favourite channels on our Slack workspace is #beinghuman where people have found a space to be openly vulnerable and are met with kindness and caring from colleagues. Online spaces aren’t always considered the most productive places for building relationships, but I think as a distributed community, Free Agents are really growing into this way of working, which I believe will be the future of work for government. Recent threads have delved into imposter syndrome, mental health and wellness, and seasonal affective disorder. The rawness and vulnerability of these exchanges have really opened my eyes to the power of vulnerability in helping people recover from inevitable life challenges.</p><p>These are just a few examples of a myriad of different ways we’re trying to build a community. I hope these practices encourage Free Agents to build a sense of community with the teams in which they work. I also hope it helps Free Agents feel a sense of belonging and understanding of the movement in which they play a part. Finally, I hope these sorts of practices will become the new normal in the public service and we’re searching for ways to demonstrate their value to others. As always, we welcome feedback and advice.</p><p>If you’re interested in the idea of community and want to share your views, practices, or ideas, please reach out. I’d love to learn more and am always up for a chat about this or anything else we’re up to.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8c3d562cbb98" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>