<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Achmad Diki Arivaldi on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Achmad Diki Arivaldi on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@achmadarivaldi?source=rss-0c09fe4bace4------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 16:06:17 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@achmadarivaldi/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Frankenstein (2025): Stitching Flesh, Trauma, and Derogated Fatherhood]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@achmadarivaldi/frankenstein-2025-humanizing-victors-generational-trauma-a-lacanian-study-894f976b1d37?source=rss-0c09fe4bace4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/894f976b1d37</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychoanalysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lacanian-psychoanalysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Achmad Diki Arivaldi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Mar 2026 07:50:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-21T07:34:38.741Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/696/0*Dk8BbQmVC0sWLhhZ" /><figcaption>from: <a href="https://dailycampus.com/2025/11/11/point-counterpoint-does-guillermo-del-toros-reanimated-frankenstein-live-up-to-its-name/">https://dailycampus.com/2025/11/11/point-counterpoint-does-guillermo-del-toros-reanimated-frankenstein-live-up-to-its-name/</a></figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Introduction</strong></h3><p>Guillermo del toro’s film adaptation of Mary Shelley’s widely acclaimed novel <em>Frankenstein </em>(1818) once again pushes the question of what defines humanity, highlighting that humanity is an individual’s perpetual endeavor to construct an identity. <em>Frankenstein </em>(2025) depicts Victor Frankenstein, a scientist who attempts to reanimate corpses’ body parts that he stitched together into a new creature. However, he refuses to identify his creation as his son, despite the fact that he brought him to life, instead Victor refers to the creature as a monster. Victor also rejects the notion of positioning himself as the Creature’s father and instead positions himself as his “master.” This disavowal is more than a matter of naming as the film also shows Victor’s neglect and evasion for paternal responsibilities in their relationship.</p><p>According to Hamad (2011), this refusal to position oneself as a paternal figure and the “alienation from the daily practicalities of parenthood” (p. 8) indicate a “derogated fatherhood” (p. 3). Furthermore, this study believes that Victor’s failed fatherhood is rooted in a sequence of past events in his childhood that may have accumulated into trauma which fractures his paternal identity toward the creature, thus failing to associate his relationship and the Creature with the “father” and “son” identities.</p><p>Current studies on Mary Shelley’s <em>Frankenstein </em>(1818) adaptations have largely focused on the Creature’s humanity within a world that rejects him. For instance, Imran et al. (2025) challenges the notion of anthropocentrism and human exceptionalism through the depiction of the creature by employing Donna Haraway’s cyborg theory and Cary Wolfe’s posthumanism, drawing a humanizing impression toward the Creature’s characterization. That said, Victor’s presence in current studies of Mary Shelley’s <em>Frankenstein</em> (1818) and its adaptations have been outshone by the Creature (Grunditz, 2024). This is due to the Creature’s arc of alienation and ambiguous biological and moral identity that have been seen as more analysis-worthy, compared to Victor’s more nuanced impression. Nevertheless, discussing Victor’s morality and paternal irresponsibility through a Lacanian lens provides an interesting angle to see how derogated fatherhood constitutes a generational chain of trauma and abuse.</p><h3>Jacques Lacan’s View of Trauma</h3><p>This study employs Lacanian perspective of trauma, seeing it as the repetitive returns of <em>The Real </em>and the rupture of the <em>Symbolic Order</em> to examine Victor’s generational trauma and his derogated fatherhood. Jacques Lacan, in his book <em>Four Fundamental concepts of Psychoanalysis</em> (1998), underscores the notion of “<em>Tuché</em>,” an encounter with <em>“The Real,”</em> a realm beyond linguistic reach that cannot be integrated with symbols, making the experience <em>“unassimilable” </em>to the “pleasure principle” and thus disrupting one’s “<em>homeostasis</em>” or the psychic attempt to gain mental stability<em>.</em> Trauma marks an encounter with<em> </em>“<em>The Real</em>” (p. 55) that returns repeatedly through unconscious symptoms such as dreams and repeated behaviors. To contextualize how trauma defies integration into the Symbolic, especially language, Lacan also engages with Ferdinand de Saussure’s <em>Signifier</em> (sign) and <em>Signified</em> (concept) (Ternstedt, 2025). Building on this framework, Lacan (1998) argues that instead of being contained in words or <em>signifiers</em>, trauma is represented through symptoms, flashbacks, repetition, or slippage of tongue (p. 59).</p><p>To shed more light, Lacan (1998) highlights that, in trauma, the <em>phantasy</em> functions to conceal the gap left by the Real, he explains that “the place of the Real” that “stretches from the trauma to the phantasy — in so far as the phantasy is never anything more than the screen that conceals something quite primary, something determinant in the function of repetition.” (p. 60), this suggests that phantasy is an unconscious narrative structure that organizes one’s sense of self, desire, or goals in response to the ungraspable impact of the Tuché. From this, trauma, especially if due to derogated fatherhood, not only impacts a child’s homeostasis but also shapes their identity, self-perception, and behavior beyond the traumatic experience itself, creating a perpetual cycle of the failed fatherhood (generational trauma). Therefore, trauma<em> </em>disrupts one’s father-son kinship Symbolic Order when their phantasy endeavors to resist the symbolization, resulting in a signifier distortion.</p><p>Furthermore, Symbolic Order includes the interconnection between signifiers which determines the subject’s identity. The subject who enters the Symbolic Order then positions themself in the Other, a formation of structure that precedes the subject’s existence: law, language, kinship, norms, etc. Then, the Symbolic Order would lead the subject to self-alienation, resulting in an identity constructed from differential signifiers that structures it (Hendrix, 2019).</p><p>Lacan (2016) also introduces the concept of <em>Sinthome </em>later in his seminar work <em>The Sinthome: The Seminar of Jacques Lacan, Book XXIII </em>(2016), he characterizes it as what holds the Real, Imaginary, and Symbolic together like a Borromean knot, the Sinthome acts as the fourth knot that gives a sense of psyche stability when the connection of the Real, Imaginary, and Symbolic fails (p. 65–67). Lacan (1998) exemplifies Joyce’s writing, noting that his Ego stimulates the existence of the Sinthome represented in the writing. He underlines that “the ego as a corrector of [the] lacking relationship, of what does not knot in a Borromean way to what constitutes the knot of the Real and the Unconscious … through [Sinthome] … the Borromean knot is restored” (p. 13). This indicates that one’s ego, manifested in Sinthome, serves to repair the failed knot of the three, hence despite trauma cannot be resolved due to the encounter with the Real, it can be navigated to maintain one’s <em>Jouissance </em>(enjoyment) (p. 66).</p><h3>Father’s Absence in Name-of-the-Father</h3><p>Victor’s paternal identity is substantially forged by the constant departure of the father in his life. Although he notes that the father is rarely at home, his dominance always overshadows his desire and his mother’s once he is back, enforcing a feeling of repression in him.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/472/1*S47qNj37Ds1aVF6JdoRQcg.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Figure 1. Victor’s father coming home after departure (00:11:05)</em></figcaption></figure><blockquote><em>Victor: “He was absent from our lives but when he came home, the entire household bent to his will.” </em>(<em>11.05)</em></blockquote><p>From this passage, the absence of Victor’s father creates a sense of attachment in Victor’s relationship with his mother. This isolation of the father from Victor and his mother indicates the failure of “the real father” to fulfill the paternal “symbolic mandate” in the Name-of-the-Father (Baron, 2006, p. 318), Lacan’s term for paternal function in the Other (Dalzell, 2018). The father’s presence initially introduces “names, words, symbols” or law to prompt the child’s separate individuality from their mother’s desire (Baron, 2006). However, according to the way Victor describes his father’s arrival after a long departure, the “father” function is unstable or poorly inscribed in the Name-of-the-Father. This is evident from the way Victor sees his father as an outsider in the kinship structure of the household, remarking that his authority “bent” the equilibrium of the Symbolic Order that he does not fundamentally fulfill.</p><p>Furthermore, this disruptive paternal presence also illustrated in a scene where Victor’s parents argue whilst he is praying to the “Guardian Angel.”</p><blockquote><em>Victor: “I would hear them through</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>the wall, arguing incessantly, yelling at each other about wealth, estate… and me.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Victor: “Their voices filled me with fear.” (00:12:15–00:12:26)</em></blockquote><p>According to the quotation, Victor’s prayer is interrupted by his parents’ argument. Here, Victor’s prayer represents his <em>homeostasis</em>, the aptitude to maintain one’s psychic stability, which he refers to as a symbolism of a “shelter” and a “Sweet companion”:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/520/1*wd1OqsoYn-5jwzKMWAJuhQ.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 2. Victor praying to the Guardian Angel statue (00:12:07)</em></figcaption></figure><blockquote><em>Victor: “Guardian angel, Sweet companion. Stand by my side and do not leave me. Under your mantle, shelter me, and…” (00:12:03–00:12:11)</em></blockquote><p>The dialogue highlights Victor’s fragile psychic equilibrium or homeostasis that becomes disrupted by “fear.” This disruption by the parents’ argument is a matter that Victor cannot grasp in his Symbolic understanding, which aligns with Lacan’s concept of <em>tuché</em>. Moreover, the Guardian angel which Victor describes as his “Sweet companion” who never abandons him and who shelters him, is also an unconscious representation of Victor’s Imaginary ideal father. The Guardian Angel, hence, functions as Victor’s paternal supplement which compensates the real father’s failure in his <em>Name-of-the-Father</em> (Baron, 2006). In Lacanian light, Victor’s prayer then becomes his personal <em>Sinthome, </em>a stabilizer of the network between Victor’s Real, Imaginary, and Symbolic that allows him to gain stabilized existence amid the repetitive returns of the Real.</p><h3>Physical Abuse &amp; Objectification</h3><p>This inadequate fulfillment of Victor’s fatherhood is reflected through the way he physically abuses his son whenever he makes a mistake. In the film, other than a father, Victor’s father also performs as Victor’s science teacher, yet the way he teaches Victor forcefully requires him to reach the father’s personal standard of perfection.</p><p>During a lesson, when Victor’s father tests his knowledge regarding the anatomy of human heart, Victor forgets the primary function of the “tricuspid valve” (14:45). In shaky and breathy voice, he replies, “I cannot recall, father, but I’m sure I will remember” (13:51), and before the father declares to punish him, Victor instinctively opens his palms.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/520/1*xidHD_4gZda1yAilrNjYvQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Figure 3. Victor’s father canning Victor’s face (00:14:35)</em></figcaption></figure><blockquote><em>Father: “No, not your hands. Not anymore. They are now the instruments of your craft and will, and we must care for them. Your face, however, is vanity.” (14:19)</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Father: “You bear my name, Victor, and with it my reputation.” (14:41)</em></blockquote><p>From the dialogues, Victor’s father’s remark that the punishment now no longer involves Victor’s hands but his face implies that this abuse is a prolonged pattern which Victor has gotten used to and normalized. His instinctive bodily gesture is also a repetitive enactment of his fear, as trauma is not Symbolically integrated or contained due to the encounter with <em>the Real</em> (Lacan, 1998).</p><p>Moreover, the father also notes that Victor’s hands are Victor’s “instruments of craft and will,” while stating that Victor’s face is his mere “vanity,” perceived as less valuable and does not deserve the father’s paternal function, thus becomes the target of the punishment. This suggests that the father does not perceive Victor as a subject with his own desire, but rather an object that represents the father’s Symbolic identity or signifier and perpetuates his social “reputation.”</p><p>Hence, in Lacan’s light, Victor is positioned as a signifier of the father’s name rather than being stabilized as a subject in the Symbolic Order. In addition, Morel (1996), who engages with Lacanian theory in his study, refers to this dynamic as positioning the child as “the child-martyr” (p. 2), situating the child as an <em>object a</em>, the void or lack that marks the father’s desire. Instead of being recognized with his own subjectivity, a child is positioned as a place in which the father’s <em>jouissance</em> (enjoyment) is constituted. Thus, Victor’s existence as a son becomes a mere “instrument” to the father’s <em>jouissance.</em></p><p>As a result, Victor’s Symbolic, or network of signifiers, now structures the differential signifiers between “father” and “son” in a distorted manner: a father is perfect, then the son is not; a father punishes, so the son is the punished one; a father is the subject and the son is merely his name (signifier) and reputation. This dynamic later constructs Victor’s fundamental <em>phantasy</em> of fatherhood that in order to be a “good son,” one must elevate his father’s social image as his responsibility.</p><h3>Unprocessed Grief of Mother’s Death</h3><p>Victor’s <em>tuché</em> also appears when Victor’s mother, Claire, gives birth to Victor’s brother. In the scene, Victor is playing a card game with his mother, seen to be sharing laughter until Claire groans in pain and bleeds. Victor’s father then comes amid Victor’s screaming and he yells Victor’s name to stop him from talking to his mother. Here, Victor’s desire for explanation regarding the traumatic situation is being repressed by the father’s authority, refraining him from processing the traumatic event. Thus, another trauma is born out of his unprocessed shock.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/520/1*-_bESQXVNe3N3EKJmAFTdg.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Figure 4. Victor’s father separating Victor from Claire</em></figcaption></figure><p>The father’s action of separating Victor from Claire to stop him from talking to her or reacting to the traumatic event in a full capacity mirrors Lacanian idea of trauma. The Real, which Victor encounters in this scene, refuses Symbolization (Lacan, 1998). The father also emotionally abandons Victor after his mother’s death, making him grieve on his own. Victor then describes his mother’s death results in a collapse of his “universe”:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/520/1*wpBECr1zKQ0HvfxrePiVbg.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Figure 5. Victor’s closing his mother’s coffin at her funeral (16:36:00)</em></figcaption></figure><blockquote><em>Victor: “My mother, whom I had come to consider a part of my very self, she who I thought would never leave, she who was life… was now death. Her eyes extinguished, her smile feeding the cold earth.” (00:16:50- 00:16:57)</em></blockquote><p>From the dialogues, the consequence of the father’s inability to embody the paternal ideal function in the Name-of-the-Father manifests in Victor’s deep mourning after the maternal death. Victor describing her mother as “part of [his] very self” exposes Victor’s inability to separate himself from maternal desire even after her death. According to Sharoni (2016), the father is supposed to introduce the “law” (p. 40) that he holds the “phallus” (p. 40), the center of desire, hence the “castration” p. 40), of the child’s position as the mother’s phallic object. Therefore, instead of being Symbolically castrated by his father, Victor receives an unmediated encounter with the Real, manifested in an unsymbolized maternal loss.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/520/1*n2Ilp32ZwSOyosWWpG37YQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure 6. Victor mourns his mother’s death</figcaption></figure><blockquote><em>Victor: “A part of the universe had been hollowed out and the firmament was now permanently dark.” (00:17:15- 00:17:26)</em></blockquote><p>The way Victor elaborates the mom as “life who was now death” and that the loss makes his universe left “hollowed out” with “firmament” becoming “permanently dark” indicates the failure of the Name-of-the-Father. This is due to Victor’s already holed Name-of-the-Father by the inadequate paternal inscription, now deprives from both maternal and paternal functions in the Other. With no Name-of-the-Father accompanying him during the traumatic grief, another encounter with <em>the Real</em>, a “hole” then occurs in the Name-of-the-Father, demanding Victor to restructure his <em>Sinthome</em> to repair the stability of his <em>Real, Imaginary, </em>and <em>Symbolic </em>(Lacan, 1998). As discussed previously, Victor has enacted his personal <em>Sinthome </em>through praying to the Guardian Angel to stabilize his homeostasis from the disruptive presence of his father’s dominance, unfortunately this <em>Sinthome</em> eventually fails due to the traumatic maternal death <em>Real</em>. Thus, Victor’s <em>Sinthome </em>is rearranged or re-knotted:</p><blockquote><em>Victor: “You let her die, did you not?”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Father: “I did everything in my power to save her. You must know that.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Victor: “So you failed.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Father: “No one can conquer death.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Victor: “I will. I will conquer it. Everything you know, I will know. And more.” (00:18:35–00:18:57)</em></blockquote><p>From the dialogues between Victor and his father, the instability of the parental functions in the Name-of-the-Father forces Victor’s ego to re-knot his <em>Sinthome</em> into his endeavor to “conquer” death. This is rooted in his distorted Symbolic of his father, describing him as not capable of “failure” unlike him as the son, hence disappointment occurs. Additionally, the re-knotting of <em>Sinthome</em> is also triggered by Victor’s already-weak paternal inscription in the Name-of-the-Father becomes more destabilized by the maternal loss. This <em>Sinthome </em>then plays a crucial role in organizing Victor’s paternal identity, as Victor wants to be like his father, noting that he wants to “know everything [he knows], and more,” while ironically preserving his father’s distorted father and son Symbolic Order mediated by his phantasy of fatherhood and sonship.</p><p>To contextualize how Victor has started to claim the distorted paternal idvhentity, Verhaeghe &amp; Declercq (2002) explains that “a subject can choose either for an identification with or a belief in his symptom” (p. 9). Due to an exposed lack in the Other of the parental function (“you failed”) caused by maternal death, Victor “acquires Real identity, connecting it to the Real of its being” (p. 10). Moreover, this <em>tuché </em>in the form of Victor’s trauma then reappears as a symptom through his dreams of the “Dark Angel”:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/520/1*rYpFNSBWvD9INetglb_TGg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/520/1*hIlfXUD4Z2bX4E93KFQv0Q.png" /><figcaption>Figure 7 &amp; 8. <em>Victor’s dream of the Dark Angel</em></figcaption></figure><p>From this, the Dark Angel is Victor’s subconscious depiction<em> </em>of the Guardian Angel or his Imaginary paternal ideal that initially compensates the real father’s failure in the <em>Name-of-the-Father</em>. The Dark Angel represents the ideal father Imaginary that has been corrupted by the Real. This relapse of traumatic symptom shatters Victor’s <em>homeostasis.</em> In return, the <em>tuché</em> creates a rupture in Victor’s identity that he describes as making him “born anew.” This aligns with Lacan’s notion of how <em>phantasy </em>acts like a “screen” that conceals <em>the Real. </em>(Lacan, 1998).<em> </em>Victor’s unconscious then reshapes his knot of <em>Sinthome</em> that in order to overcome his maternal death trauma or the return of <em>the Real</em> he needs to “conquer death,” especially since maternal deaths exposes the weak paternal function in the Name-of-the-Father.</p><h3>Abandonment</h3><p>The feeling of abandonment and isolation due to Victor’s destabilized <em>Name-of-the-Father </em>has been exacerbated in years, even until his brother, William, has grown up. This can be seen from the way he describes his father’s affection toward his brother:</p><blockquote><em>Victor: “William grew full of sunshine and smiles. He was of a calmer, gentler disposition, clearly favored by my father.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Victor: “He was the breeze, I was the storm cloud. He was all laughter, I was all frowns.” (00:17:42- 00:17:53)</em></blockquote><p>As mentioned previously, Victor’s imaginary of an ideal paternal function is represented through his prayers toward the Guardian Angel statue as his <em>Sinthome </em>before the maternal loss. However, the signifiers of this imaginary are now embodied by the father: “shelter,” “sweet companion”, someone that “does not leave.” Nevertheless, this enactment of fatherhood is only received by Victor’s little brother, William.</p><p>The father’s act of favoritism then exposes Victor’s lack. Since Victor’s castration has not been performed by the father’s law when the mother was alive and seeing William’s joy with his father’s paternal affection, Victor realizes that he is deprived from it. According to Rosa et al. (2021), “What matters is not only the child insofar as he is the viewer, but the fact of knowing himself as the object of the other’s gaze … the wager is no longer the mastery of vision, but the scopic object as an object that may be missing in the field of the other. In this empty point, the object a can be laid as a gaze” (p. 5).</p><p>From this quotation, both sons can be positioned as the father’s object a, including Victor. Yet, Victor discovers that there is something “missing” (Rosa et al, 2021, p. 5) from the Other’s (the father’s) gaze, which is his position as a son, thus William’s “calmer, gentler disposition” that are “clearly favored by [his] father.” Thus, although both children are the father’s object a, William is the <em>object a</em> of the father’s paternal desire mediated in paternal affection, while Victor is the object a of the father’s <em>jouissance </em>manifested in physical and emotional abuse<em>.</em></p><h3>Positioning the Creature as the Return of ‘the Real’</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/0*biYlAmwsFHBt7jEC.jpg" /></figure><p>Victor’s trauma has lingered into his adult life, proven by his <em>Sinthome</em> manifested in his endeavor of reanimating corpse, it is also his unconscious’ attempt to “conquer death.” In his adult years, Victor has dedicated his life for creating a creature from stitching body parts. The creature here acts a representation of Victor’s Real, coming through repetitions of dreams and chasing him to seek a “meaning,” “symbolic,” and “identity.” Real is unable to be placed in the Symbolic Order, hence comes back as the Real. Furthermore, the Creature is a mirror that reflects Victor’s phantasy of a son, such as objectifying the Creature like an animal or a slave and calling him a “Monster”.</p><p>To sum up, this study explains how Victor’s derogated fatherhood is a representation of a generational trauma and a weak inscription of paternal function in the Name-of-the-Father during his childhood. Victor’s first encounter with the real is manifested through his dysfunctional relationship with his parents, father’s absence, and unsymbolized trauma of maternal loss. This cluster of traumatic events then leads to rupture in his Symbolic Order, making it near impossible for him to inscribe himself as a father in the Creature’s Symbolic Identity.</p><h3>References</h3><p>Baron, P. D. (2006). In the Name of the Father: the Paternal Function, Sexuality, Law and Citizenship. <em>Victoria University of Wellington Law Review</em>, <em>37</em>(2), 307. <a href="https://doi.org/10.26686/vuwlr.v37i2.5566">https://doi.org/10.26686/vuwlr.v37i2.5566</a></p><p>Dalzell, T. (2018). A Lacanian Reading of Paternity in James Joyce. European Journal of Psychoanalysis, Vol. 5, №2.</p><p>Gaines, A. R. (2020). <em>Embracing the Monster: The Films of Guillermo del Toro</em>. Published in the Macksey Journal. <a href="https://mackseyjournal.scholasticahq.com/article/21835-embracing-the-monster-the-films-of-guillermo-del-toro">https://mackseyjournal.scholasticahq.com/article/21835-embracing-the-monster-the-films-of-guillermo-del-toro</a></p><p>Grunditz, N. (2024). The Mind of The Creator: A Character Analysis of Victor Frankenstein from Frankenstein: The Modern Prometheus (1818). <em>Lund University</em>. <a href="https://www.lunduniversity.lu.se/lup/publication/9172121">https://www.lunduniversity.lu.se/lup/publication/9172121</a></p><p>Hamad, H. (2011). <em>Extreme Parenting: Recuperating Fatherhood in Steven Spielberg’s War of the Worlds (2005)</em>. King’s College London. <a href="https://kclpure.kcl.ac.uk/portal/en/publications/extreme-parenting-recuperating-fatherhood-in-steven-spielbergs-wa/">https://kclpure.kcl.ac.uk/portal/en/publications/extreme-parenting-recuperating-fatherhood-in-steven-spielbergs-wa/</a></p><p>Hendrix, J. S. (2019). The imaginary and symbolic of Jacques Lacan. <em>Digital Commons (Providence College)</em>. <a href="https://doi.org/10.13140/rg.2.2.17632.23048">https://doi.org/10.13140/rg.2.2.17632.23048</a></p><p>Imran, M., Zahra, P., &amp; Hussain, S. (2025). Transcending Human Boundaries in Frankenstein and Automata: A Posthumanist critique. <em>Social Sciences &amp; Humanity Research Review</em>, <em>3</em>(3). <a href="https://doi.org/10.63468/sshrr.050">https://doi.org/10.63468/sshrr.050</a></p><p>Lacan, J. (1998). <em>Four Fundamental concepts of Psychoanalysis</em>. W. W. Norton &amp; Company.</p><p>Lacan, J. (2016). <em>The Sinthome: The Seminar of Jacques Lacan, Book XXIII</em>. Polity.</p><p>Lacan, J., &amp; Fink, B. (2006). <em>Ecrits: The First Complete Edition in English</em>. W. W. Norton.</p><p>Melly, M., &amp; Rahmawati, I. (2025). The Dark Side of Desire: A Psychoanalytic Analysis of Trauma in Talk to Me (2022). Calakan : Jurnal Sastra, Bahasa, Dan Budaya, 3(2), 427–435. <a href="https://doi.org/10.61492/calakan.v3i2.390">https://doi.org/10.61492/calakan.v3i2.390</a></p><p>Morel, G. (1996). THE SON AS THE OBJECT a OF THE FATHER. <em>Journal of the Centre for Freudian Analysis and Research (JCFAR)</em>.</p><p>Rosa, C. L., Antonucci, C., Siracusano, A., &amp; Centonze, D. (2021). From the imaginary to theory of the gaze in Lacan. Frontiers in Psychology, 12, 578277. <a href="https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.578277">https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2021.578277</a></p><p>Saputra, K., &amp; Anam, Z. (2025). Psychoanalytic Reading of Desire for Freedom in Osamu Dazai’s <em>The Setting Sun</em>. <em>Rainbow Journal of Literature Linguistics and Cultural Studies</em>, <em>14</em>. <a href="https://doi.org/10.15294/rainbow.v14i.30056">https://doi.org/10.15294/rainbow.v14i.30056</a></p><p>Sharoni, N. J. (2016). The Failure of the Parental Metaphor: a Lacanian reading of James Joyce’s “Eveline.” <em>Journal of Modern Literature</em>, <em>39</em>(4), 33. <a href="https://doi.org/10.2979/jmodelite.39.4.04">https://doi.org/10.2979/jmodelite.39.4.04</a></p><p>Ternstedt, T. (2025). Shaping the Self : Lacanian Perspectives on Memory, Identity and Trauma in Morrison´s Fiction (Dissertation). Retrieved from <a href="https://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:hig:diva-46990">https://urn.kb.se/resolve?urn=urn:nbn:se:hig:diva-46990</a></p><p>Verhaeghe, P. &amp; Declercq, F. (2002). Lacan’s analytical goal: “Le Sinthome” or the feminine way. In: L.Thurston (ed.), Essays on the final Lacan. Re-inventing the symptom. New York: The Other Press, pp. 59- 83.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=894f976b1d37" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Queer Failure, Male Gaze, & Decay of Identity in American Psycho (2000) — A Movie Analysis]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@achmadarivaldi/american-psycho-2000-queer-failure-male-gaze-decay-of-identity-8947bc0fd631?source=rss-0c09fe4bace4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8947bc0fd631</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[queer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Achmad Diki Arivaldi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 11 Jan 2026 01:15:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-23T08:53:35.762Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Queer Failure, Male Gaze, and Decay of Identity in American Psycho (2000) — A Film Analysis</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/964/1*gr9mr_bFVrDmCkMpcvRVCQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Introduction</h3><p>Mary Harron’s adaptation of <em>American Psycho</em> (1991) novel by Bret Easton Ellis, released in 2000, may have become a cult classic, notably for its unique storytelling that blurs the line between reality-fantasy and for Christian Bale’s exceptional acting performance as Patrick Bateman, a wealthy psychopathic and materialistic man who struggles to resist his desire of doing violent murder. Not only has the film given birth to an iconic meme loved by a large number of cinephiles, where Bale’s character listens to music through his Walkman, but it has also presented the protagonist’s masculinity as a work of consumerism and the failure to “fit in” as an individual who feels “different” in a world that tries to fit him into a uniformed societal mold.</p><p>If we try to read between the lines, the scene in which he listens to music while he walks toward his office is not merely for comedic timing of the film, but rather an implication that even during his performance as the sophisticated male ideal, he always seeks an escapism; a distraction to “mute” the fabricated reality and to isolate himself with his repressed thoughts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nKOlm2W_Gt5fVCuoW5vWpw.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Figure 1. Patrick walks toward his office while using a Walkman</em></figcaption></figure><p>Ironically, although admitting to liking it and not feeling guilty over it, Patrick sees his violent or murderous fantasy as a blood stain on his white linen life that he must “clean.” He is afraid and aware of the prejudice, repercussion, and rejection from the social structure that feeds his charismatic shield if the outside world discovers his disreputable tendencies. So, In order to read Patrick Bateman’s repetitive failure of attempts in preserving his repressed fantasy and to uphold his heteronormative performance, the author decided to employ Queer Failure theory by Jack Halberstam.</p><p>Jack Halberstam, in their book <em>The Queer Art of Failure</em> (2011), underscores that queer individuals always experience failure in ways that are “exceptionally well” (p. 3) in different media. While typically signifies consequences of personal responsibilities, Halberstam (2011) with their “low theory” (p. 2) instead challenges this notion. Since hegemonic society punishes those who rebel from the heteronormative norms, low life theory in Queer Failure intends to identify alternative perspectives in seeing this failure as a way to escape from “the usual traps and impasses of binary formulations” (p. 2).</p><p>That said, there is beauty in the endeavors and hopes produced by failure that disrupt “the supposedly clean boundaries between adults and children, winners and losers” (p. 2), rejecting how capitalism and heteronormativity tend to craft “predictable adulthoods” (p. 2<em>). </em>Moreover, Analyzing Patrick Bateman’s failed desire to uphold his heteronormative performance and sustain his murderous fantasy in <em>American Psycho</em> (2000) through Queer Failure reading is underexplored. This is possibly due to the film’s explicit presentation of the character’s heterosexual social life seen as perfectly aligns with the capitalist success ideal, painting him far from the definition of a “loser.” However, the protagonist’s internal battle and identity isolation caused by the capitalist structure can be seen as queer-coded that mirrors many queer experiences.</p><h3>The Displacement of Desire</h3><p>Patrick’s internal conflict is framed as his attempt to build a charismatic persona in order to “fit in” and gain superiority within his upper social circle. Yet, there is some kind of violent or murderous fantasy repressed within him that disrupts this routine, sometimes reflected in his sarcastic jokes even while still taking part within the social masquerade. For instance, in the opening sequence of the film, Patrick throws a misogynistic remark of wanting to aggressively murder a female bartender for she rejects his drink tickets:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kDvJirrjuU10eS4bpB81cw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xR7l7awQ9mqwIw33xyBB0w.png" /><figcaption>Figure 2 and 3. Patrick’s violent remarks toward a female bartender</figcaption></figure><blockquote><strong>Patrick Bateman: </strong>Stoli on the rocks. (giving an order)</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Bartender: </strong>These aren’t good anymore. It’s a cash bar. That’ll be $25.<br><strong>Patrick Bateman:</strong> You’re a fucking ugly bitch. I wanna stab you to death… and play around with your blood. (00:04:10–00:04:29)</blockquote><p>Patrick’s violent thoughts tend to “slip out” when his masculinity gets threatened. Within the scene, the dismissal toward the drink tickets symbolizes a rejection toward his exclusivity and superiority as part of the successful yuppie society. The woman decides to ignores his order before asking for the money and when she receives it and turns around to make the drink. The camera then shoots a mirror that frames and reflects Patrick’s face staring coldly toward the female bartender from behind. Then followed by his violent remarks shouted out loud but remains unheard by her possibly due to the loud music or that the remarks were said merely in his head. Ergo, the mirror acts as a metaphor to the duality of Patrick’s life; the approachable and charismatic wealthy man and a serial killer who murders his victims in silence when he is out of their awareness. Yet, this also reflects Patrick’s insecurity after failing to assert dominance toward a working class female he typically objectifies.</p><p>Moreover, the mirror scene also implies the displacement of male Gaze. According to Laura Mulvey in her essay <em>Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema </em>(1975), Male Gaze is when the camera movement acts as the gaze of heterosexual males that “controls the film phantasy” (p. 12), positioning women as passive sexual objects or the spectacles of the film. Moreover, there is an “active/passive division” (p. 12) that presents male characters as active agents as opposed to female characters. Mulvey (1975) further argues that the erotic objectification of male characters within classical Hollywood cinema tends to be avoided because this weakens their role as the active subjects of the narrative structure.</p><p>Within the scene, however, the camera that initially captures the female bartender’s body, showing her upper feminine figure in a medium shot, then shifts toward Patrick’s figure and face. Nevertheless, the exclusion of women’s bodies does not equal to the absence of male gaze, but rather the camera keeps looking for an object, and the male body is no exception (Doty, 1993; Dyer, 2002, as cited in Wardhana, 2025). In this case, the camera excludes the bartender’s figure and even hides it in a blurred visual and minimal lighting and highlights Patrick as the center of the gaze. This is typically read as a manifestation of Patrick’s narcissistic mindset and self-centeredness. However, this displacement of male gaze toward Patrick’s body in later scenes also foreshadows the displacement of desire away from heterosexual intimacy and futurity (marriage):</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VVeuZGOhx2z-ZQwKMUsRlQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure 4. Patrick flexes his abs to the camera</figcaption></figure><p>Previously, Patrick invites two female prostitutes to make an adult video tape with him. Patrick sets up a camera in front of the bed and the audience gets to see the point of view accordingly. Nevertheless, Patrick does not seem to engage with the two women, especially through eye contacts. Patrick’s gaze, represented by the camera angle, keeps pointing at himself instead, misplacing the desirability of the female bodies of the two women toward his own masculine body.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1Q0qEcJEiaDs0BXLY12-ng.png" /><figcaption>Figure 5. Patrick sees his reflections in the mirrors</figcaption></figure><p>Additionally, Patrick also constantly gazes at himself in the mirrors that briefly multiply the reflection of his muscular body into some of body images while only showing a small proportion of the female’s leg. Moreover, the exclusion of female from the male gaze can position male as the spectacle of the gaze (Wardhana, 2025). The way Patrick smiles, winks, and keeps flexing his muscles to the mirrors indicates a desire to replace the women as the object of the gaze. Patrick’s gaze at his own reflection may be read as self-validation, but it is also self-objectification, as he <em>desires to be desired </em>or looked at by the gaze.</p><p>To shed more light, the displacement of male gaze can bring homoerotic tension. This is because the eroticized visual of the male body is not only seen by female audience, but also by heterosexual male audience, evoking homoeroticism (Patrick Schuckmann, 1998, as cited in Wardhana, 2025). The previous scenes mentioned then fail to fully convey heteronormative desire and the women’s desirability through male gaze.</p><p>This interpretation also aligns with Mulvey’s (1975) notion of how “extra-diegetic tendencies” (p. 12), the spectators’ erotic gaze, are neutralized by the narrative of the object as the “spectacle” (p. 12). Thus, the male audience, as the spectators, are allowed to look at Christian Bale’s eroticized body through the male gaze without feeling judged, as this is neutralized or justified by the film’s narrative of Patrick’s narcissism, desire, and stated intention to produce a heterosexual adult tape. His rejection toward a heterosexual intimacy is also depicted in how Patrick often kills the women she sleeps with after copulation:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l8Q0Y8JwQF6orranamIOxQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ABQJrvlHo6RkQTheV9FF0w.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZKKMwrmvEF-Y_5qagiW4Vw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4wTXf3zyHw4xoczAMjJsEw.png" /><figcaption>Figure. Patrick murders a woman.</figcaption></figure><p>The male gaze here shifts again from the woman’s body that is shot from behind and hidden, to Patrick’s naked body horrifyingly covered with blood when he comes in and tries to bite the woman’s leg. The camera work insinuates his failure in subjectifying woman as a romantic partner, turning them into the victims of his cold-blooded murderous fantasy.</p><h3>The Collapse of Marriage</h3><p>Patrick’s rejection toward a long-term heterosexual intimacy or reproductive futurity is also depicted in his relationship with Evelyn:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zPc4FA6LnzTtK3ivssxijA.png" /><figcaption>Figure 6. Evelyn plans her wedding with Patrick</figcaption></figure><blockquote><strong>Patrick Bateman: </strong>I’m trying to listen to<br>the new Robert Palmer tape, but Evelyn,<br>my supposed fiancé, keeps buzzing in my ear.<br><strong>Evelyn:</strong> Annie Leibovitz. We’ll get Annie Leibovitz. And we’ll have to get someone to videotape.<br><strong>Evelyn: </strong>Patrick,<br>we should do it.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Patrick Bateman: </strong>Do what?<br><strong>Evelyn: </strong>Get married. Have a wedding.<br><strong>Patrick Bateman: </strong>No. I can’t take the time off work.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Evelyn: </strong>Your father practically owns<br>the company. You can do anything you like, silly.<br><strong>Patrick Bateman:</strong> I don’t want to talk about it.<br><strong>Evelyn:</strong> I hate that job anyway. I don’t see why you just don’t quit.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Patrick Bateman: </strong>Because I want to fit in. (00:09:28–00:10:02)</blockquote><p>Within the scene, when Patrick and Evelyn are in a car, heading to a party. Evelyn talks about her wedding plan with Patrick. However, Patrick ignores her and looks outside of the car’s window instead Evelyn. He even identifies her role as a mere obstacle upon his personal space, symbolized by the “Robert Palmer tape,” while also labeling her as his “supposed-fiancé” in an invalidating tone. This suggests that Evelyn’s status as a romantic partner is confined into a mere instrument to uphold Patrick’s social status and masculinity in the yuppie society. Patrick then decides to end his relationship with Evelyn completely:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ARoRs4D-3-jJ4LRuzgq3Ew.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zZOD1w9PkTbK_hanKt5ajQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure 7 and 8. Patrick calls off his relationship with Evelyn</figcaption></figure><blockquote><strong>Patrick Bateman: </strong>It’s over, Evelyn. It’s all over.<br><strong>Evelyn: </strong>Touchy, touchy. I’m sorry I brought up the wedding. Let’s just avoid the issue, all right? Now, are we having coffee?<br><strong>Patrick Bateman: </strong>I’m fucking serious. It’s fucking over, us. This is no joke. Uh, I don’t think we should see each other anymore.<br><strong>Evelyn: </strong>But your friends are my friends and my friends are your friends. I really don’t think it would work. You have a little something… (trying to distract)<br><strong>Patrick Bateman: </strong>I know that your friends are my friends, and, uh… and I’ve thought about that. You can have ’em.</blockquote><blockquote>…<br><strong>Evelyn: </strong>What about the past? Our past?<br>Patrick Bateman: We never really shared one.</blockquote><blockquote>…<br><strong>Patrick Bateman: </strong>Evelyn, I’m, uh, sorry. I just, uh… You’re not terribly important to me. (01:16:55–01:17:54)</blockquote><p>Within the scene, Patrick decides to entirely call his relationship with Evelyn off, killing the idea of a future marriage with her. The way Evelyn uses the connections between their social circles as a reason to not end it reveals how social connections within their lives are objectified attributes to their materialistic relationality. Moreover, this scene also proves how, like most of their other relationships, their romantic relationship is not built over a mutual emotional bond or “shared past.” But why does Patrick want to end something that sustain his charismatic facade?</p><p>Halberstam (2011), quoting Kathryn Bond Stockton, argues that “hetero sexuality is not born but made. If we were all already normative and heterosexual to begin with in our desires, orientations, and modes of being, then presumably we would not need such strict parental guidance to deliver us all to our common destinies of marriage, child rearing, and hetero- reproduction” (p. 27). This implies that the ideal of a long-lasting traditional marriage and kinship structure are constructed by the fabric of society. Patrick’s refusal is rooted in the notion of how heterosexual marriage is “instrumentalized for economic control and political surveillance” (Foucault, 1978, as cited in Valldaura, 2024, p. 26). His refusal toward pursuing this path aligns with Halberstam’s (2024) idea of how heteronormativity enforces uniformity and predictability in one’s adulthood.</p><p>A marriage entails a long term commitment and demand for his performance of being socially predictable, uniform, or <em>normal. </em>This constant labor of normality will disrupt Patrick’s repressed murderous fantasy, leading to a collision between both identities. When he mentions about not being able to take “the time-off work” in the car scene, he actually expresses his worry of losing the time he can spare to be his violent self if he marries Evelyn. Therefore, his unstable labor to “fit in” and refusal toward the marriage with Evelyn can be read as his failure of heterosexual reproduction and kinship.</p><p>Important to bear in mind, Patrick’s dismissal toward envisioning a monogamic heterosexual marriage does not automatically imply homosexuality. Instead, his feeling of being <em>othered </em>and different still parallels queer lives that “challenge heteronormative paradigms of relating” and “are repeatedly set up to fail within patriarchal and heteronormative constructs of institutional lives” (Eguchi &amp; Long, 2018, as cited in Valldaura, 2024, p. 27), thus <em>queer-coded</em>.</p><p>This failure of marriage is a queer failure, as Patrick subverts the uniformed adulthood script made by norms (Halberstam, 2011). For that reason, he is “destined to” socially “fail” (Halberstam, 2024, p. 5) because his relationality is murderous and solitary, opposing the heteronormative standard of a community. By ending his engagement with Evelyn, Patrick refrains his repressed murderous identity from getting invaded by the capitalist and political surveillance that condemn it.</p><h3>Failure of Masculinity Competition</h3><p>Another aspect that can be read through queer failure perspective is the portrayal of Patrick Bateman’s masculinity. American Psycho (2000) is also a satire of materialistic and toxic masculinity in the yuppie society and again this is highlighted through the displacement of male gaze toward Patrick’s physical aesthetic and routine in the opening scene:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*98mDItJxcLXCdTU1q8gHrA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PtY3jiCtRYLiIMIX0TJLeQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HP8v2Vrj3txw2KvKpKI0mg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V4YXj3ZTfP4zIGzw2PpglQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure 9, 10, 11, &amp; 12. Patrick’s morning routine</figcaption></figure><blockquote><strong>Patrick Bateman:</strong> My name is Patrick Bateman. I’m 27 years old. I believe in taking care of myself, in a balanced diet, in a rigorous exercise routine. In the morning, if my face is a little puffy, I’ll put on an ice pack<br>while doing my stomach crunches. I can do a thousand now. After I remove the ice pack, I use a deep pore cleanser lotion. <br>In the shower, I use a water-activated gel cleanser. Then a honey-almond body scrub. And on the face, an exfoliating gel scrub. Then I apply an herb mint facial masque, which I leave on for ten minutes while I prepare the rest of my routine. I always use an aftershave lotion with little or no alcohol, because alcohol dries your face out and makes you look older. Then moisturizer, then an anti-aging eye balm, followed by a final<br>moisturizing protective lotion.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Patrick Bateman: </strong>There is an idea of a Patrick Bateman. Some kind of abstraction, but there is no real me. Only an entity… something illusory. And though I can hide my cold gaze… and you can shake my hand and feel flesh gripping yours… and maybe you can even sense our lifestyles are probably comparable, I simply am not there. (00:05:11-00:07:06)</blockquote><p>Within this fragment, Patrick narrates that he has a habit to “take care of [himself]” through numerous steps of routine. The male gaze then lingers and shows medium and close-up shots of Patrick when he does the routine while grabbing several beauty products, exercising, or choosing his diet carefully. The audiences also see him through the mirrors that reflect his body into several fragments of reflections, this mirrors how patrick is objectified as the byproduct of capitalism, just like his other beauty products. Also, in this case, other than placing him as the central of the erotic gaze, the gaze also exposes how his masculinity is a routine of performances. Moreover, it is also a mockery toward toxic masculinity by turning men as “passive” (Mulvey, p. 12) objects of consumerism. In the next fragment of dialogue, Patrick then explains that although others can connect with him through the similarity of lifestyles, it is merely a camouflage to hide his violent nature, indicating an internal resentment toward the facade.</p><p>Moreover, Fišerová (2019), who analyzes the novel version of the character, argues that the work is meant to be a satire of 1980’s capitalist society, where money and materials only produce unsatisfaction. She also argues that “these factors seem to dictate much of Patrick Bateman’s gender performance rather than the other way around” (p. 521). In this light, no mater how many products, self-care, and exercise Patrick does seem to be enough in the capitalist masculinity standard. There is always someone with a more superior masculinity like Paul Allen who makes him feel insecure and threatened, which eventually leads to his serial killer acts to fill this void of emotional emptiness within the materialistic world he has succeeded:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OJZ9bUnSh8LR4ZTnHw3BYQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iZESvSjwuYuinDrtMHuuHQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure 13 &amp; 14. Patrick sees Paul Allen’s business card</figcaption></figure><blockquote><strong>Patrick Bateman:</strong> Let’s see Paul Allen’s card. <br><strong>Patrick Bateman:</strong> Look at that subtle off-white coloring. The tasteful thickness of it. Oh, my God. It even has a watermark. (00:19:32-00:19:57)</blockquote><p>This scene captures the fragility of hegemonic masculinity performance through the business card conversation. In the scene, Patrick and his co-workers sit around a table together and compete over whose business card is the best. When Van Patten shows his card to one of Patrick’s co-workers, Bryce, he compliments Van Patten’s elevated taste. Patrick, feeling threatened, makes his face all sweaty and his countenance turns disappointed.</p><p>This, again, becomes the spectacle of the male gaze; the long shot of staring, sweaty face, and the men’s fingers playing with their cards in a slow duration. Hegemonic masculinity is challenged through this hypermasculine interaction over the aesthetic of something that is trivial, like business card. This scene draws the men like a mannequin decorated by various materials that define <em>how masculine they are</em>. Its fragility is also caricaturized through the competitive tension from staring at each other in a way that has an underlying homoerotic tension between the men’s relationship (Wardhana, 2025). The business cards act as extension to the men’s bodies that mimic sexual competition, a diorama of men trying to put dominance over one another.</p><p>This scene then reaches its peak when Paul Allen arrives and shows his business card, followed by Patrick’s astonished remark: “it even has a <em>watermark.</em>” This comically signifies Patrick’s loss in the masculinity competition. Paul Allen is a personification of Patrick’s masculine ideal, as well as Bryce as the validator, Marcus is who Patrick is:</p><blockquote><strong>Patrick Bateman: </strong>Allen has mistaken me for this<br>dickhead, Marcus Halberstram. It seems logical because Marcus also works at P&amp;P, and in fact does the same exact thing I do. He also has a penchant for Valentino suits and Oliver Peoples glasses. Marcus and I<br>even go to the same barber, although I have a slightly better haircut. (0:17:39–00:17:56)</blockquote><p>When Patrick describes Marcus’ traits that they both share, he actually compliments himself as well through specifying which products they both also use and wear. Yet, despite acknowledging their similarities, Patrick still wants to hold the trophy when it comes to who has the best taste by explaining that regardless of going to the same barber, his haircut looks “slightly better.” For that reason, both scenes expose how other than performance and competition, masculinity is also based on consumption. Furthermore, for this loss and unrecognition by someone who embodies a more sophisticated masculinity than him, Patrick decides to kill Paul Allen.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eAOff_wtBcL_YnwPvU7noQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure 15. Patrick kills Paul Allen</figcaption></figure><blockquote><strong>Patrick Bateman: </strong>Try getting a reservation at Dorsia now, you fuckin’ stupid bastard! You fucking bastard! (00:28:21–00:28:31)</blockquote><p>The scene critiques how masculinity is intricately tied to social validation and legitimacy. Paul Allen’s ability to reserve a table at Dorsia illustrates that he is more respected, well-known, and authoritative compared to Patrick. That said, Patrick’s attempt of killing Paul Allen is his endeavor to succeed the capitalist society’s standard of a successful man, as well as an expression of his exhaustion of it. Yet, he fails to fully erase the pressure to be <em>the best man</em> even after killing Paul:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*zvR0uRSOkETqN9-_JZnPig.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*CzFRePlhzD5MttQkwsZ4Ow.png" /><figcaption>Figure 16 &amp; 17. Patrick goes to Paul Allen’s apartment</figcaption></figure><blockquote><strong>Patrick Bateman:</strong> before disposing of the body. There is a moment of sheer panic… when I realize that Paul’s apartment overlooks the park… and is obviously more expensive than mine. (00:30:17-00:30:29)</blockquote><p>Patrick is still trapped within the shadow of Paul Allen’s wealth and fame, who is a real-life replica of his masculinity. Based on the scene, before disposing his body, Patrick breaks into Paul’s apartment to make a phone call toward Paul’s girlfriend, posing a shim and saying that he goes to London. Patrick experiences bewilderment over how Paul’s apartment is more expensive than him and while also insulting how it overlooks the park. This indicates that although he succeeded at killing his masculine ideal, he does not experience liberation. Instead, his anxiety in the scene is based on materialistic comparison between him and Paul that lingers rather than guilt. This paradoxical outcome highlights his queer failure in “killing” the more sophisticated version of his masculinity and also escaping from the compulsion to acquire it.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>To sum up, Patrick Bateman’s humanity is challenged through his endeavor to succeed in maintaining his dual identities to co-exist. His repressed murderous desire is a symbolism to alienation and authenticity within the capitalist society that compels uniformity. This aligns with Jack Halberstam&#39;s queer failure theory and low theory, stating that heteronormative and capitalist society tend to cultivates a predictable adulthood (Halberstam, 2011). Then, <em>American Psycho </em>(2000) also suggests that when one is forced to confine his individuality into strict societal performances, he eventually ceases to exist. Also, despite Patrick&#39;s character being a successful yuppie and heterosexual male, his experience of resisting the heteronormative and capitalist standard of success and normality mirrors queer experiences, through the analysis of the male gaze, the film has subliminally implied his queering of the heteronormative structure, while also making toxic masculinity and homophobia a satire by evoking homoerotic tension to the surface. This queer failure is illustrated in the movie through Patrick’s rejection of marriage with Evelyn, which provides some space for his violent identity to sustain, yet puts his heterosexual and reproductive futurity to halt. This failure is also depicted through his failed masculinity competition with Paul Allen which also reflects to his declined social validation and legitimacy. His murderous acts thus become a trope for his subversion from the societal norms that shape his heteronormativity.</p><h3>References</h3><p>Halberstam, J. (2011). <em>The Queer Art of Failure</em>. Duke University Press.</p><p>Mulvey, L. (1975). Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema. Screen. 16. 10.1093/screen/16.3.6.</p><p>Wardhana, C. (2025, September 18). <em>Menjelang 2 Dekade ‘Realita, Cinta, dan Rock’n Roll’: Membaca Hubungan Ipang-Nugi</em>. Magdalene Merch. <a href="https://magdalene.co/story/realita-cinta-n-roll/#:~:text=Meski%20ada%20Sandra%2C%20hubungan%20Ipang,3706%20Views">https://magdalene.co/story/realita-cinta-n-roll/#:~:text=Meski%20ada%20Sandra%2C%20hubungan%20Ipang,3706%20Views</a></p><p>DOTY, A. (1993). <em>Making Things Perfectly Queer: Interpreting Mass Culture</em> (NED-New edition). University of Minnesota Press. <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5749/j.cttttcmx">http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5749/j.cttttcmx</a></p><p>Dyer, R. (2001). <em>The culture of queers</em>. Routledge. <a href="https://books.google.co.id/books?id=yFc5292Nt7wC&amp;lpg=PP1&amp;hl=id&amp;pg=PR4#v=onepage&amp;q&amp;f=false">https://books.google.co.id/books?id=yFc5292Nt7wC&amp;lpg=PP1&amp;hl=id&amp;pg=PR4#v=onepage&amp;q&amp;f=false</a></p><p>Schuckmann, P. (1998). Masculinity, the Male Spectator and the Homoerotic Gaze. <em>Amerikastudien / American Studies</em>, <em>43</em>(4), 671–680. <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/41157425">http://www.jstor.org/stable/41157425</a></p><p>Valldaura, Albert. (2024). MOTHER HAS ARRIVED! Queer Kinship, Care Practices and Reconfigurations of (M)otherhood within Ballroom Culture. Junctions: Graduate Journal of the Humanities. 8. 23–36. 10.33391/jgjh.205.</p><p>Foucault, Michel. (1978). <em>The History of Sexuality, Volume 1: An Introduction.</em> New York: Pantheon Books.</p><p>Eguchi, Shinsuke, and Hannah R. Long. 2018.’Queer Relationality as Family: Yas Fats! Yas Femmes! Yas Asians!’ Journal of Homosexuality 66, no. 11: 1589–1608. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/00918369.2018.1505756.">https://doi.org/10.1080/00918369.2018.1505756.</a></p><p>Fišerová, P.S. (2019). From Toxic to Politically Correct : Masculinities in AmericanPsycho and Darkly Dreaming Dexter. <em>Humanities and social sciences</em>.</p><h3>Acknowledgment</h3><p>Thank you for reading this literary criticism. Also, thank you to <a href="https://medium.com/u/285752c4bb35">Putri Rania Abida</a> for giving me her insights of this article before publishing it.</p><p>Additional tags: <em>Queer failure; male gaze; gender studies; American Psycho</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8947bc0fd631" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Space of Female: Oppression and Agency in Interstellar (2014) Movie]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@achmadarivaldi/the-space-of-female-oppression-and-agency-in-interstellar-2014-movie-3a3f03430cb0?source=rss-0c09fe4bace4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3a3f03430cb0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[interstellar]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ecofeminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Achmad Diki Arivaldi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Dec 2025 02:39:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-23T08:52:59.170Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>The Space of Female: Oppression and Agency in Interstellar (2014) — A Film Analysis</strong></h3><p><em>Authors:</em> <a href="https://medium.com/u/0c09fe4bace4">Achmad Diki Arivaldi</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/u/5620bcf3e164">21.Muhammad Raffell Putra Subiakto</a>, Nugroho Febrianto</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*luVSkpdmiEIThTjCZ8ek8w.jpeg" /></figure><h3>ABSTRACT</h3><p>Science-fiction movies have long been dominated by male characters as the central focus and heroic figures. Meanwhile, female characters are less likely to be portrayed as experts in their field and eventually are overlooked. The researchers argue that this demeaning impression can be seen in the groundbreaking film directed by Christopher Nolan entitled <em>Interstellar</em> (2014) which was rereleased on the cinema in 2024. The researchers aim to discover current female and male viewers’ insights regarding its portrayal of womanhood experience in male-dominated industry, whether there are oppression toward female characters and their agency to overcome it depicted accurately in the widely acclaimed film. The researchers then discovered from the interviews that Dr. Brand indeed experiences oppression in the form of docile agency perceived as a true agency, while Murphy Cooper expresses her agency in a more confrontational way fueled by betrayal and injustice she has experienced since childhood. Thus, since the oppression they face and the agency they take mirror patriarchal oppression toward nature, which is also the underlying theme of the movie, the researchers employed Vandana Shiva’s theoretical framework of Ecofeminism to analyze Dr. Brand and Murphy Cooper’s experiences as women who take different decisions in overcoming oppressions.</p><p><strong>Keywords: </strong><em>Ecofeminism; Patriarchy; Oppression; Female Agency</em></p><h3>INTRODUCTION</h3><p>Science-fiction movies have long been dominated by male characters as the central focus and heroic figures of the plots (Xinyi &amp; Jing, 2021). Meanwhile, female individuals in science-fiction movies are mostly depicted as a side character and are less likely to be portrayed as experts in their fields compared to the male characters, giving female figures a more demeaning impression (Chakraborty, 2022). Previous studies in <em>Interstellar</em> (2014) have been shown to be primarily focused on its main male character, Cooper, thus putting him in the spotlight. For example, Akbar (2023) explores <em>Interstellar </em>(2014) using a structuralist approach that emphasizes Cooper’s major role in driving the story, glorifying his morals. In contrast, Ferel (2016), illustrates a shift of Cooper’s characterization toward a more negative light, she analyzed how the film enlarges Western ideologies such as White heroism and anthropocentrism by seeing him as the personification of these ideologies. For that reason, there is a knowledge gap, a topic that has not been resolved for the lack of enough discussion (Abass et al., 2020), especially inside the previous studies mentioned. The knowledge or the research gap in question is the limited discussion of Dr. Amelia Brand’s and Murph Cooper’s characterization in the movie, specifically the oppression directed toward them and their agency out of it. This is important as the gap might result in a bias related to the film’s gender dynamics and obstruct the visibility of female characters’ qualities as individuals.</p><p>To shed some light, In <em>Interstellar </em>(2014) movie, in order to resolve a catastrophic environmental destruction on the earth, a male scientist named Professor Brand comes up with a plan to save the earth which mandates Dr. Brand, his daughter, to find another habitable planet for humans with other male astronauts, including Cooper. On the other hand, Murph Cooper, who has grown up and become a female scientist, finds out that the “finding the habitable planet” mission is fake and solely a con to accomplish another controversial mission, in which Dr. Brand is required to incubate the first ten frozen embryos out of hundreds to develop a massive human colony on a planet. Refusing to be silenced any longer by the men around her, Murph decides to speak up. From that, the treatments directed toward Dr. Brand and Murph Cooper in the movie fully align with Vadana Shiva’s concept of female oppression as the development in reproductive technology has constructed a patriarchal mindset and gender-bias toward women, which can be anti-nature and colonial, as this violates women’s generative capacity and rights. According to Vadana Shiva in her book with Maria Mies <em>Ecofeminism </em>(1993), she<em> </em>revealed that “Ecofeminism is about connectedness and wholeness of theory and practice. It asserts the special strength and integrity of every living thing” (p. 99). From the perspective of Shiva’s theoretical lens, the treatments mirror the exploitation and objectification toward nature’s reproductive capacity done by males (Mies &amp; Shiva, 1993).</p><p>The data for this research were obtained through a series of interviews conducted by the researchers by applying the personal identification approach. The approach was selected in order to collect the most reliable and relevant information to dismantle the topic of this research. This research examines the oppression experienced by Dr. Brand and Murph Cooper in a male-dominated institution, NASA, in which they work as female scientists, however, for earth’s potential massive extinction, emotional pressure, and societal expectations, they have taken some decisions to break free from authoritarian power and save the earth.</p><h3>METHOD</h3><p>To ensure the accuracy of the results in this research, the researchers conducted a series of interviews toward ten individuals, including five males and five females. This is because the researchers aimed to acquire the most unbiased data possible from the perspectives of both genders regarding the existence of oppression toward the female characters and their agency in the movie <em>Interstellar </em>(2014). During the interview session, after we filtered and selected the most eligible candidates, each interviewee was asked to answer eleven questions related to the movie and the topic discussed in this paper. Then, the interview results would be transcribed by the researchers transparently without any changes made to the original transcript, except for fixing any ambiguous grammatical issues, and the researchers then would try to examine the interview results with the theoretical framework employed in order to gain a comprehensive and in-depth evaluation of the topic.</p><h3>FINDINGS &amp; DISCUSSION</h3><h3>3.1. Awareness of Oppression</h3><p>Our finding shows that respondents showed different awareness regarding the forms of oppression experienced by Dr. Brand and Murphy. While some respondents acknowledged the challenges faced by both characters which are domination, objectification and exploitation. In contrast, some respondents overlooked or were not aware of the oppression they faced.</p><h3>3.1.2. Reproductive Exploitation</h3><p>Our findings suggest that some respondents believed Dr. Brand’s decision to follow NASA’s plans despite being the only female scientist in the mission is not a form of oppression, but rather an action of responsibility. Plan A, looking for a habitable planet and gathering the data for developing a spaceship that is capable of bringing human life from earth to a habitable planet. Plan B that was designed as a back-up plan, which happens if the astronauts failed to collect the data for plan A to succeed, making a colony by incubating frozen embryos on suitable planets. Two of our male respondents believed that both plans exist to ensure human life, and Dr. Brand’s agreement to both plans is based on her commitment to ensure the safety of humans on earth:</p><p>“I think Dr. Brand is trying to make the mission successful, but also make everything safe. So that’s why she wants to obey NASA. I think that’s all.” E (M/20)</p><p>“I think if it’s for the good, for the humanity, I think, yeah, that would be fine.” DF (M/20)</p><p>The quotations insinuate that respondent E (M/20) and DF (M/20) argued that Dr. Brand’s decision is a matter of freewill for the sake of humanity, however the responses actually align with Vandana Shiva’s (1993) view on women’s collective responsibility:</p><p>“Women everywhere… felt the same anger and anxiety, and the same sense of responsibility to preserve the bases of life… this common concern brought women together to forge links…” (p. 2)</p><p>According to the quotation, despite having different experiences across the globe, women share specific experiences of being obligated to preserve nature. It is not because women are biologically mandated to be so, but because patriarchal systems positioned them as the preserver of life. According to Shiva, these collective emotions create solidarity between women. Here, Dr. Brand is possibly driven by the anxiety of earth’s potential massive extinction and losing her home planet, as women’s collective experiences bring women closer to nature and create a bond between them.</p><p>In contrast, some respondents agreed that there is an oppression, experienced by Dr. Brand. As stated by a female respondent (20), highlighting the morality of plan B, in which Dr. Brand is expected to carry ten frozen embryos for the continuity of the human race on another planet as somewhat questionable:</p><p>“And it’s so much burden, you know. There’s a million of [the embryos], right? … That’s not fair for Dr. Brand … but you have to discuss it more. Like, should we [give her] a company? Abandonment is not good for us. Yeah, it sucks. But carrying such a burden like that? I don’t think so.” J (F/20)</p><p>Unlike the previous respondents, the respondent J (F/20) viewed the plan as a “burden,” not only for the fact that Dr. Brand has to go through it as the only woman on the mission, but she argued that Dr. Brand has to carry the frozen embryos by herself without NASA asking for her consent first, hence plan B needs to be evaluated further. Moreover, another female respondent (20) has also expressed a similar response toward the plan. Here, the respondent praised the effort and calculation NASA has put into crafting plan A, especially how plan A does not involve any gender-bias within it. Regardless, the respondent has also expressed disappointment in plan B for some reason:</p><p>“ … I think that NASA itself already… already calculated [the plan A]. So I don’t think it’s about men or women regarding [plan A], It’s about for the greater good … However, in plan B, I think it’s more of a desperate — the last resort kind of plan. Where They will produce people from the [embryos], which I personally, I don’t think it’s very — why would people do that? Because the purpose of the plan in searching for a habitable planet is to save your family. I think [plan B] is so unique and very scientific of them … If I were Dr. Brand, I don’t think I mentally could handle it. Like raising lots of children, quote unquote, by yourself. It’s gonna be very hard.” R(F/20)</p><p>From the interview quotation, the respondent sarcastically remarked “… that’s so unique and very scientific of them,” implying that she perceived plan B as an abrupt and less calculated decision compared to plan A, especially as it does not consider women’s position as human beings. The respondent also seemed to question the moral background of the plan by stating a rhetorical question such as “why would people do that?.” Therefore, respondents R (F/20) and J (F/20) viewed the plan as an objectification and exploitation toward women’s reproductive capacity in the institution, this would align with Vandana Shiva’s perspective regarding the development of biotechnology and female’s reproductive nature, Mies &amp; Shiva (1993) argued:</p><p>“The new developments in biotechnology, genetic engineering and reproductive technology have made women acutely conscious of the gender bias of science and technology and that science’s whole paradigm is characteristically patriarchal, anti-nature and colonial and aims to dispossess women of their generative capacity as it does the productive capacities of nature.” (p. 48)</p><p>This suggests that modern science fields related to reproductive technologies, in Dr. Brand’s case, surrogacy, may have interfered with nature’s way of creating life (childbirth), which is anti-nature. Furthermore, it “colonizes” (Mies &amp; Shiva, 1993) their control over their reproductive rights and exploits it in a male-dominated institution, in this case, NASA’s lab and their spaceship, thus women and nature experience the same objectification as a generative factory for their species under patriarchal authority.</p><h3>3.1.2 Male-dominated Environment</h3><p>The findings from the interview also reveal that male-domination also tends to be oppressive toward women, in this case toward Murph’s voice and opinions. The female respondent emphasized that male-aggression limits women’s rights to be opinionated though driven by reasons:</p><p>“He was examined by the doctor, right? Then after that, Tom got angry and said no need to get examined, why did he fight with the doctor? Then Murphy told him that it was okay — otherwise, your son will die again like the other one — like why not resolve it peacefully like siblings. They are in the same house, [but] it’s as if they’re strangers, it’s like they are not living together.”</p><p>A(F/20)</p><p>The respondent highlights a deeper breakdown of how male-female power dynamics can be unstable despite of being biologically related and from the same family. It is illustrated from Tom’s and Murph’s communication. She described how Tom has shown reluctance or mistrust toward Murph, by shouting aggressively when Murph advises him for medical assistance for his family, as the earth’s air is polluted and might harm their well-being or health. This mirrors Mies and Shiva’s (1993) Critique of capitalist patriarchy, which “structurally dichotomizes reality, and hierarchically opposes the two parts to each other: the one always considered superior, always thriving, and progressing at the expense of the other.”(p. 35). Murph’s effort to bring peace back is an example of ecofeminist resistance that represents the ecofeminist principle of healing and relational interdependence.</p><h3>3.2. Agency Against Oppression</h3><p>According to our respondents, they suggest that Dr. Brand and Murphy manifest their agency through different decisions. Even though both characters are involved in the same mission, they choose different paths for various reasons.</p><h3>3.2.1. Emotional Pressure and Female-Agency</h3><p>In respect to Shiva’s (1993) concept of women-collective experience and how it connects to Dr. Brand’s decision earlier, when Dr. Brand’s anxiety toward environmental damage leads to her decision to follow NASA’s plan, a male respondent claimed that Professor Brand’s “betrayal” toward Murph and other humans on earth contribute to her empowerment instead:</p><p>“…she was slapped by the fact that it turned out Professor Brand plan A is fake, now she just goes with plan B. Well, but there she is [Murph], she doesn’t waver. She’s disappointed, But she still keeps going. Because maybe she feels my father has come this far.. Her father has fought this far. And that should, and that makes her even more hopeful. Oh yeah, she finally finds the equation of gravity…”</p><p>DN (F/20)</p><p>The respondent depicted Murph’s strength and perseverance as driven by betrayal, especially after she finds out that Professor Brand’s Plan A, about saving humans on earth, was a lie. Even though “she was slapped by the fact” that the plan was fake, the respondent highlights that “she doesn’t waver” and instead she becomes “more hopeful” to save humanity. This response aligns with Mie’s and Shiva’s (2014) ecofeminist perspective, which emphasizes how women, when faced with oppressive systems and “felt the same anger and anxiety,” (Mies &amp; Shiva, 1993, p. 2) don’t only feel anger, instead they transform it into an ambitious fuel to “preserve the bases of life” (Mies &amp; Shiva, 1993, p. 2). Thus, Murph continues her efforts to solve the gravity equation, even though she experiences betrayal and emotional burden. That said, Murph Cooper tries to shift the power of NASA toward her own hands and then becomes empowered for the male-dominated institution’s power is now driven by her decision’s outcomes, that is solving the gravitational equation by herself.</p><p>From this, it can be concluded that the emotional anger or betrayal felt by Murph Cooper motivates her to stand up amongst the patriarchal system in NASA by employing her forte in science as an instrument to cease patriarchy’s objectification and exploitation toward nature and toward women as well. Mies &amp; Shiva (1993) underscored:</p><p>“For women farmers, biodiversity has an intrinsic value … For women farmers, the essence of the seed is the continuity of life. For multinational corporations, the value of the seed lies in discontinuity of life.” (p.172)</p><p>Emphasizing how, in ecofeminism, women reclaim the knowledge to utilize nature’s generative capacity from a patriarchal environment to preserve life, rather than to exploit nature itself. Thus, it fosters a more sustainable and ethical decision or outcome for the environment.</p><h3>3.2.2. Environmental Destruction and Patriarchy as A Fuel of Empowerment</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/780/1*FuVOrDrqZHv9gioG_hLgrA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Murph Cooper burning her family’s corn field</figcaption></figure><p>A female respondent also argued that Murph Cooper indeed embodies female-agency in the movie, but in this case, she regains control in her own home by doing something significant to declare her voice:</p><p>“… Okay, so I feel like Murphy has power, from when she burns the corn-field, and she also feels like, okay, I can’t keep doing this, and like, it felt like I wasn’t getting justice, and I have to save my family, and other people on this earth, so that the citizens don’t keep getting hurt… “ A(F/20)</p><p>According to the respondent, Murphy’s act of setting some parts of the cornfield on fire as a form of empowerment from being abjected and silenced. The respondent observed that Murphy comes to the realization that “I can’t keep doing this,” demonstrating her growing understanding that sticking to a system that was detrimental to her would only lead to further oppression. Rather than being inactive, she chooses to act; burning the partial area as a deliberate form of resentment to being silenced and abjected. In this regard, Murphy’s choice illustrates the ecofeminist idea that true power comes from resisting oppression and choosing to defend family, neighborhood, and society. Thus, Murph Cooper channels her action of preserving nature differently to how Dr. Brand does it; instead of following NASA’s plan, she chooses to rebel against them (by solving the gravitational equation). This mirrors Vandana Shiva’s (1993) concept of how environmental destruction leads to female-agency:</p><p>“The poverty trap, created through the vicious circle of ‘development’, debt, environmental destruction and structural adjustment, is most significantly experienced by women and children.” (p. 76–77)</p><p>Vandana Shiva’s ecofeminist view, which argues that agency is not only a task of resistance but also transformation, is very much in line with Murph’s decision to shift the authoritarian control toward her rather than merely escape from it. This is meant to end the destruction and instead defend the basics of life, people, especially those who are disadvantaged by capitalist patriarchy, must reclaim their agency (Mies &amp; Shiva, 1993, p. 76–77).</p><h3>3.2.3. Societal Expectations and Female-Agency</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MJqLv8934jcJhtQfroYY8w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dr. Amelia Brand arriving at the habitable Edmund’s Planet</figcaption></figure><p>Similar to the previous responses regarding Dr. Brand’s obedience being a pure willingness, another male respondent also described the same point of view with a more detailed reasoning:</p><p>“…the urgency is not only for her family, but for the entire human family. That’s why, whether we like it or not, or whether we are willing or not, we have to carry out the plan. And I think she also, I mean just accept it, not [being] forced, because maybe it has been said, you could say from the beginning, she was already purely good, so you could say, yes it’s good, his following plan, she can definitely follow the plan.” DN (M/20)</p><p>The response implies that respondent DN (M/20) perceived Dr. Brand’s action as a form of a positive sacrifice or favor for many human families, not only hers, describing her act as “purely good.” However, it also begs us a new question; is her obedience truly a form of sacrifice driven by environmental-concern anxiety or rather a result of the embedded patriarchal system in the society (Mies &amp; Shiva, 2014)? Rizqi et al. (2024) underscored that “cultural norms and systems” tend to blur the line between women’s freewill and patriarchal expectations, this is also known as “Docile Agency,” when women “appear to act freely, but in reality, are constrained” and “limited” by the standards (p. 197).</p><p>This leaves a vague implication toward Dr. Brand’s decision as a female and the morality of NASA’s mission to women, yet it has opened so many new perspectives regarding whether women have acquired rights over their choices or not; whether when it comes to their bodies and reproductive capacity or when it comes to how bound they are to the embedded injustice within the society, that is often overlooked and disguised as an agency, thus justified or even praised.</p><p>The male respondents’ responses might be connected to Saba Mahmood’s concept of docile agency, in which limitation of women’s choice is being blurred by societal norms and culture. And from those invisible norms, a collective responsibility or guilt, if women violate the norms, is shaped by the patriarchal systems, Mahmood (2001) stated:</p><p>“… the abilities that define its modes of agency — are not the residue of an undominated self that existed prior to the operations of power but are themselves the product of those operations. Such a conceptualization of power and subject formation also encourages us to understand agency not simply as a synonym for resistance to r lations of domination, but as a capacity for action that specific relations of subordination create and enable.” (p. 210)</p><p>The male respondents clarify Dr. Brand’s decision to follow NASA plans is a form of willingness, but they overlooked the possibility of her choice being shaped by gendered-expectations and dominant patriarchal power that has been normalized in the society. As men do not experience the outcome of docile agency first-hand, their interpretation might be limited to this invisible bias.</p><p>Moreover, as women experience those normalized “collective responsibility” (Mies &amp; Shiva, 1993) directly, they were able to look at Dr. Brand’s decision beyond the perspective of societal norms. For that reason, as the researchers expected, the majority of the female respondents, namely J (F/20), R (F/20), and other female respondents acquire oppositional responses to the male respondents. Their harmonized responses also have proven Mies and Shiva’s (1993) theory of how “collective responsibility” creates a link among women from different backgrounds and gives them some universal “solidarity” (p. 2).</p><h3>CONCLUSION</h3><p>This research examined various forms of female oppression and agency as experienced by Dr. Brand and Murph Cooper in Interstellar (2014). Through the lens of ecofeminist theory, focusing on Vandana Shiva’s and Maria Mies’ <em>Ecofeminism</em> theoretical framework, while also utilizing Saba Mahmood’s concept of docile agency. Our findings reveal that although both characters work in a male-dominated institution such as NASA, their responses to the oppressive system of their environment are distinct and complex, driven by the male dominance around them, the anxiety of environmental destruction, and emotional pressure triggered by the oppressive patriarchy.</p><p>Dr. Brand’s obedience under NASA’s mission plan B, involving her carrying ten frozen embryos to create a colony on another planet, has resulted in a vague implication in respect to identifying whether it is a form of empowerment or disempowerment. Although all male respondents agreed that it is actually a worth-praised virtue, female respondents expressed resentment toward the discourse of plan B, implying it is a form of female disempowerment to some extent, which mirrors Mies &amp; Shiva’s (1993) theory of female collective responsibility and solidarity.</p><p>Murph Cooper, on the other hand, depicts a more confrontational form of agency. Fueled by betrayal and injustice. That is, some female respondents argued that she transforms her emotional pressure into an ambition to reclaim control and scientific knowledge as a tool to preserve humanity’s future. Murph’s action aligns with Maria Mies’ and Vandana Shiva’s theory of how patriarchal oppression pushes women to take transformative actions to break free from objectification and exploitation, building an ethical relationship with nature.</p><p>Ultimately, as there was lack of discussion toward the women of <em>Interstellar </em>(2014), the researchers aimed to fill the gap with the research, this research revealed that female characters in <em>Interstellar</em> (2014) actually hold powerful roles in the movie whose actions are forged by environmental urgency and patriarchal oppression. Not only that, they also represent strong female-agency and empowerment in different ways. With this research, the researchers hope to gain more visibility toward nature’s and women’s qualities and new perspectives in the discussion of women oppression.</p><h3>REFERENCE</h3><p>Xinyi, M., &amp; Jing, H. (2021). Humanity in Science Fiction Movies: A Comparative Analysis of Wandering Earth, the Martian and Interstellar. <em>International Journal of Linguistics Literature &amp; Translation</em>, <em>4</em>(1), 210–214. <a href="https://doi.org/10.32996/ijllt.2021.4.1.20">https://doi.org/10.32996/ijllt.2021.4.1.20</a></p><p>Chakraborty, S. (2022, June 25). <em>The position of women in science fiction</em>. Chakraborty | Journal of Language and Linguistic Studies. <a href="https://jlls.org/index.php/jlls/article/view/4571/1431">https://jlls.org/index.php/jlls/article/view/4571/1431</a></p><p>Akbar, D. I. (2023). An analysis of narrative structure in interstellar and ready Player one. <em>Humanitatis Journal of Language and Literature</em>, <em>10</em>(1), 93–108. <a href="https://doi.org/10.30812/humanitatis.v10i1.2855">https://doi.org/10.30812/humanitatis.v10i1.2855</a></p><p>Ferel, G. N. (2025). Changing dominant ideologies in recent American Science-Fiction Cinema: An Ideological Analysis of Interstellar. <em>Boun</em>. <a href="https://www.academia.edu/29784493/Changing_Dominant_Ideologies_in_Recent_American_Science_Fiction_Cinema_An_Ideological_Analysis_of_Interstellar">https://www.academia.edu/29784493/Changing_Dominant_Ideologies_in_Recent_American_Science_Fiction_Cinema_An_Ideological_Analysis_of_Interstellar</a>?</p><p>Abass, H. A., Banjo, H., &amp; Abosede, A. (2020). RESEARCH GAPS: SOURCES AND METHODS OF IDENTIFICATION. <em>ResearchGate</em>. <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/338376635_RESEARCH_GAPS_SOURCES_AND_METHODS_OF_IDENTIFICATION">https://www.researchgate.net/publication/338376635_RESEARCH_GAPS_SOURCES_AND_METHODS_OF_IDENTIFICATION</a></p><p>Mies, M., &amp; Shiva, V. (1993). Ecofeminism. Zed Books.</p><p>Rizqi, M. W., Meyrasyawati, D., Karnanta, K. Y., Saraswati, R., &amp; Afdholy, N. (2024). Women and agency: the #MeToo movement in the movie she said (2022). <em>The International Journal of Critical Cultural Studies</em>, <em>22</em>(2), 193–211. <a href="https://doi.org/10.18848/2327-0055/cgp/v22i02/193-211">https://doi.org/10.18848/2327-0055/cgp/v22i02/193-211</a></p><p>Cheng, J. (2021b). An analysis of ecofeminism in Frankenstein. <em>Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research/Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research</em>. <a href="https://doi.org/10.2991/assehr.k.210609.120">https://doi.org/10.2991/assehr.k.210609.120</a></p><p>Mahmood, S. (2001). Feminist Theory, Embodiment, and the Docile Agent: Some Reflections on the Egyptian Islamic Revival. <em>Cultural Anthropology</em>, <em>16</em>(2), 202–236. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1525/can.2001.16.2.202">https://doi.org/10.1525/can.2001.16.2.202</a></p><p>*Also, please read my queer analysis of <em>American Psycho</em> (2000) movie <a href="https://medium.com/@achmadarivaldi/american-psycho-2000-queer-failure-male-gaze-decay-of-identity-8947bc0fd631">here</a>!</p><pre>&lt;meta name=&quot;msvalidate.01&quot; content=&quot;E62F97547058D263BB99E3DA4AB2A3DF&quot; /&gt;</pre><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3a3f03430cb0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>