<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Adam Belz on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Adam Belz on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@adambelz?source=rss-1e2a018e513a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 22:57:26 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@adambelz/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Alex Mendez has been the player of the tournament for the U.S.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adambelz/alex-mendez-has-been-the-player-of-the-tournament-for-the-u-s-e1ca59a50120?source=rss-1e2a018e513a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e1ca59a50120</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[soccer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alex-mendez]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[u20-concacaf-championship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[usmnt]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Belz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Nov 2018 15:47:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-19T16:39:15.546Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Alex Mendez has been the player of the tournament for the U.S. U20s. Here’s a bit of a scouting report on him</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*AyUniASD5FuPM_6g9DipEQ.gif" /></figure><p>The U.S. U20s beat Costa Rica 4–0 on Friday, an emphatic win over a generally respectable Concacaf opponent, and a win that qualified the U.S. for the 2019 World Cup in Poland.</p><p>Encouraging! And not just because of the result, but because the Americans played good soccer.</p><p>Though the U.S. didn’t create dozens of clear-cut chances, as they had through five group games, they dominated possession, scored two goals on moments of individual class in the first half and squeezed the life out of Costa Rica in the second half. If on Monday they can beat or draw with Honduras, they’ll go to the final of the Concacaf Championship against either Mexico or Panama.</p><p>Tab Ramos’s boys started the group stage of the tournament in disjointed style. They ran up the score on teams like Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin Islands and Trinidad &amp; Tobago, but they never built sustained rhythm with the ball.</p><p>That started to change against Suriname in the final game of the group, and carried over to Friday’s win. As they’ve gelled, this team has gotten more patient and confident with the ball on the floor. Here’s a nice sequence of passing and moving in tight space from left back Chris Gloster, and midfielders Alex Mendez and Juan Pablo Torres that resulted in Gloster being fouled.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*TmtcrwyDnoa63n6omFuQpQ.gif" /></figure><p>Ramos came out in his 4–3–3, as usual. The fullbacks — Gloster and Sergino Dest — had license to roam forward, and they did.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/672/1*ZUk8iR1V-JOn1hraYqCmXg.png" /></figure><p>Dest was added to the roster after the group stage, and was a welcome addition. The Ajax fullback is quick, tough and sophisticated on the ball (he’s played some winger for the Ajax U19s this season), and he dominated his side of the field. He’s probably claimed the top right back job over Sporting KC’s Jaylin Lindsey and N.C. State’s Manny Perez, both still on this roster. Gloster, the Hannover left back, also had a good game. He was smooth on the ball, strong in the air, and comfortable getting forward. Torres and Brandon Servania covered for the marauding fullbacks, and for Alex Mendez, who pulled strings in the attack and scored the goal of the tournament for the U.S., but is not a stout defender (more on that later).</p><p>Paxton Pomykal and Ulysses Llanez were free to operate from the wings and link with Gloster and Dest. The chemistry between fullbacks and wingers has grown over the tournament and the interplay at times on Friday could even be described as well-oiled. The attack was rounded out by Sebastian Soto, a true No. 9 and one of the leading U19 scorers in Germany for Hannover. He wasn’t directly involved in any goals but his intelligent off-ball movement dragged and occupied the centerbacks and his hold-up play was generally assured.</p><p>In any case, the Americans bore down on Costa Rica for 90 minutes and centerbacks Mark McKenzie and Matt Real were barely tested. The only bad things that happened were the injury of Llanez (not sure how serious) and two miscommunications between goalkeeper Brady Scott and the centerbacks that created some unnecessary danger at the back.</p><p>Several U20s are playing well in this tournament but the most interesting has been Mendez, who set up as the advanced central midfielder and scored the game-winner in the 15th minute. If you’ve read this far you’re a diehard and you’ve probably already seen it. It was a certified golazo from 30 yards.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*DC8weqKuoIVw_a45zUX53w.gif" /></figure><p>Don’t miss the excellent pass from McKenzie and the class turn from Mendez. He then touches the ball into space and jackhammers a swerver into the top corner. What a strike.</p><p>Mendez’s lethal left foot (from distance and on free kicks), his quality and intelligence on the ball and his eye for the killer pass give him as high an upside as anyone on this roster.</p><p>But he’s not the kind of player who just looks to hit screamers. He’s a passer, and a rhythm-builder. The game was full of Mendez playing quick, incisive passes in stride to teammates, a habit that makes the whole team better and ultimately wears down an opponent. I’ve got GIFs.</p><p>He was involved in the buildup to the Llanez goal by moving the ball across the field when he pulled down a headed pass from Pomykal, turned, and poked it to Torres. Torres passed to the wing to Llanez, who did the rest, but don’t underestimate the importance of Mendez’s efficiency in the buildup.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*5yxXFCpDui0FUo4eZ0pBmw.gif" /></figure><p>Here’s a more mundane example. The first-time pass to Llanez is a simple choice but it’s perfectly in stride and sets the attack in motion.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*k-O5Pt9CzrlyMmaxdR_kMA.gif" /></figure><p>Here Mendez picks out Akinola (who came on for an injured Llanez in the first half) on the wing with a gently curling side-footed pass. Nice work from Servania to win the ball and pass to Mendez in a good spot, and Mendez’s pass is fast and perfect. (Notice also the way Soto initiates contact with the centerback as Akinola runs onto the ball. Soto has won position if Akinola can get it to the near post.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*vGPqvESiDI8hqVtskkYiDA.gif" /></figure><p>Here Mendez shows his composure in possession, and finds a clever little pass to Gloster in space to key another attack.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*ltWxW6b__EqnFLYwFIXrDA.gif" /></figure><p>And once again on Friday, Mendez was dangerous on dead balls. He recorded an assist late in the game on this free kick from the right wing. Swerved into a dangerous area, great header from Akinola.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*0ocrfsTVSbGB-QH2t61T-w.gif" /></figure><p>Servania has been very good in this tournament, and so have Llanez, Pomykal and Justin Rennicks, but Mendez has been Tab Ramos’s best player.</p><p>And his story should be an encouragement to every youth international who misses a call-up. He was left off of John Hackworth’s U17 rosters for both the 2017 Concacaf Championship and the 2017 World Cup. Now he’s MOTM in the game that qualifies the U.S. U20s for the World Cup, and he’s on the short list of prospects serious national team fans should be paying attention to.</p><p>Mendez grew up in south central Los Angeles and came up soccer-wise with Brian Kleiban at Chivas USA and then the LA Galaxy. He jumped the Galaxy ship just after going to the DA Final this summer and before he turned 18 in September. He trialed in Europe and signed a contract with Bundesliga club S.C. Freiburg (in extreme southwest Germany) this fall. He lived and trained in Freiburg, a city of 229,000, for three weeks before the U20 World Cup qualifying tournament started. He’ll return to the Black Forest after this tournament and should start playing in the U19 Bundesliga in January.</p><p>If Mendez is going to kick his way to the first team (for club and country), he has something he needs to work on.</p><p><strong>His biggest weakness is defending. </strong>Whether it’s due to sluggish tactical defensive awareness, a lack of speed and strength, or a dispositional unwillingness to get stuck in, Mendez offers little resistance to the opponent in the middle of the field. Perhaps he is therefore best suited to play as a 10, which is more or less what he’s been doing for the U20s, but even in that case he will need to become a tougher defender at Freiburg. (Ramos was wise to play Torres next to Brandon Servania against Costa Rica in the midfield, because he provided reliable extra cover for Mendez, who needs it.)</p><p>Mendez <a href="https://scuffed.simplecast.fm/9627aed9">told me himself that he needs to work on his 1v1 and positional defending</a>. That’s feedback he’s gotten from coaches at Freiburg and something he said he knows.</p><p>Here’s an example. It’s too easy to dribble past him. To his credit he tracks the play, recovers the ball and plays a quick, useful pass out of the American defensive third. But only Servania’s range saved this from being a more dangerous situation and Mendez was left behind by a simple dribble.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*5zGlKBDe7EiSfv3mMrb8xQ.gif" /></figure><p>Here Mendez waves Costa Rican left back Carlos Martínez through. Again, way too easy. He’s not the only defender who could have done better but this was one of Costa Rica’s most threatening moments of the game, and it looked to me like Mendez’s teammates were expecting him to get stuck in. He didn’t.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*jCcEe5OTGmEk7KIk5Th0hw.gif" /></figure><p>There you have it. Alex Mendez. He can give the ball away cheaply on occasion, and he could find better spots and demand the ball more often, but that’s just me being picky. Where he really needs to improve is defending.</p><p>If he can get harder and more decisive at wrecking what the other team is trying to do, even as an attacking midfielder, we should expect big things from the kid. Freiburg is a good place to learn those things. The U19 Bundesliga is fast, technical and physical, and the competition is desperate. Godspeed. We should get a good look at how Mendez has progressed when the U.S. kicks off play at the U20 World Cup in May.</p><p>One last thing. Check out our podcast, Scuffed. I’ve interviewed several of the key players in this U20 cycle, including <a href="https://scuffed.simplecast.fm/9627aed9">Mendez</a>, <a href="https://scuffed.simplecast.fm/7d302778">Soto</a>, <a href="https://scuffed.simplecast.fm/56d7f094">Chris Durkin</a>, <a href="https://scuffed.simplecast.fm/4cfa791b">Richie Ledezma</a> and <a href="https://scuffed.simplecast.fm/17e77c08">Chris Richards</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e1ca59a50120" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Scuffed Vol. 52: three midfield experiments for the USMNT]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adambelz/3-midfield-experiments-for-the-usmnt-68a7db6752cd?source=rss-1e2a018e513a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/68a7db6752cd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[weston-mckennie]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marky-delgado]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dave-sarachan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tyler-adams]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[soccer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Belz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Oct 2018 10:48:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-02T05:28:14.377Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The U.S. didn’t look good in the center of the park against Brazil and Mexico, and sorting out who plays where in the midfield is now the most pressing concern for USMNT manager Dave Sarachan (and his successor).</p><p>Sarachan played Wil Trapp as the 6 and Weston McKennie and Tyler Adams in front of Trapp as dual 8s in both matches. Trapp was too soft defensively and not a good enough orchestrator to make up for that limitation. McKennie looked lost at the 8 and put in a poor-to-mediocre 120 minutes before he came off in the first half of the Mexico match with a knock. Adams might have been the best U.S. player of the camp but he also did not look particularly comfortable in long stretches of the two games.</p><p>Something needed to change, and Sarachan’s brightest tactical move in the camp came when, after McKennie’s injury in the utterly drab first half of the Mexico game, he brought on Julian Green and moved the U.S. into a 4–2–3–1 with Adams and Trapp next to each other in a double pivot at the 6 and Green in front of them in a central attacking role. (Adams also played well for 10 minutes as a single pivot 6 against Brazil.)</p><p>So there we have our most recent anecdotes — illustrating that the midfield is still very much unsettled but that some things worked better than others.</p><p>Let’s turn our attention to Colombia and Peru. The good news is Sarachan’s attacking pieces are going to be better in this camp, which will relieve some of the pressure on a midfield trio for whom space was collapsed in the last two friendlies.</p><p>We will have a left wing, Jonathan Amon, who can do this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/1*ATPzTDwscu1trTsaDbIl_w.gif" /></figure><p>And a right wing, Christian Pulisic, who can do this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*L2KLwqBpO4Drt59eiPDxlA.gif" /></figure><p>The jobs of the center mids will be easier when the opponent has to account for real wide attacking threat.</p><p>The bad news is Sarachan did not call up Darlington Nagbe or Marky Delgado, players I think could have served important roles in midfields that maximized the talents of Adams and McKennie, and he called up Michael Bradley, indicating he sees MB4 as a like-for-like replacement for Wil Trapp. I don’t see the point of that right now, given how much McKennie and Adams struggled as dual 8s, so I’m just going to ignore the current camp and lay out three sensible, in my view, midfield experiments for the USMNT. My base lineup is still some variation on a 4–3–3 or 4–2–3–1. We need Pulisic and maybe Jonathan Amon picking up the ball on the wings or in the channels.. The back 4 is pretty much locked in as far as I’m concerned.</p><p>Here we go.</p><p><strong>1. Adams and McKennie in a double pivot, with Darlington Nagbe (or Kellyn Acosta) ahead of them.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/682/1*UmA7BtIa-lSvvHOsfJ6vCw.png" /><figcaption>Option #1</figcaption></figure><p>Solving the “why isn’t McKennie playing well” problem is a really big deal for Sarachan and an interesting test of his coaching ability. There’s a very strong chance McKennie and Adams will be the central midfielders of the future, and the way they’ve been played together in the national team so far (mostly as dual 8s roaming and destroying) hasn’t worked. I couldn’t have predicted that, but it’s true. Since the 4–2–3–1 seemed to get us some traction against Mexico’s B team last month, and since neither McKennie nor Adams is really a 10, let’s try them as dual 6s with a ball-carrying center mid in front of them. Darlington Nagbe is that man. He isn’t going to score a lot of goals or get a lot of assists, but he can glide with the ball and should be able to find the feet of our wingers or bombing fullbacks, and then stay home while McKennie or Adams makes a late run into the box. If I were in charge, I’d try this next. Acosta is the next man up, but in my opinion he’s a drop-off from Nagbe, and probably not that much better than Julian Green, who was <a href="https://twitter.com/away_goals/status/1040645830997356544">not that great</a> despite the overall improvement in the U.S.’s game when he came on the field against Mexico. In my view, we don’t need the advanced CM in this scheme to be a chance-creator per se. He just needs to move the ball from the defensive third to the attacking third and get it to Pulisic, Amon, Weah and the striker in dangerous spots. Nagbe can do that. It should work so long as McKennie and Adams play to their ability behind Nagbe.</p><p><strong>2. Adams at the 6, with McKennie and Delgado working next to each other at the 8.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/682/1*p2lR7_bYOnfPvWLaVUp8fA.png" /></figure><p>Again, the key here is McKennie and Adams on the field together. If them as a double pivot doesn’t work, then we gotta play Adams at the 6. It’s his favorite position, he’s poison for counterattacks, and he has the toughness, quickness, and mental alertness to lock down the spot. McKennie has the toughness but not the quickness or mental alertness. So let’s let him roam, and find a good partner for him.</p><p>That partner, for me, is Marky Delgado. Is Delgado a better player overall than Nagbe or Acosta? I don’t know. For my purposes, doesn’t really matter. I’m picking him for this three-man midfield because he’s a good glue player. He hits teammates in stride with his passes, his defensive commitment is strong, he reads the game and he moves well off the ball. That’s what I want next to McKennie, and I’m willing to sacrifice Nagbe’s gliding and Acosta’s deadly as fuck set pieces for Delgado’s overall utility and rhythm-building.</p><p>Here’s an example of Delgado’s ball-winning and movement into the attack:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/448/1*IWDVoomM5j5lpp5a9jjaUw.gif" /></figure><p>If Marco doesn’t work next to McKennie, try Acosta and Nagbe in the same setup.</p><p><strong>3. Drop McKennie, clear the decks and bring me your huddled masses of Canouse, Williams and, hell, Bradley.</strong></p><p>My guess is what we’ll see against Colombia is Bradley at the 6 and McKennie and Adams in that dual 8 role that hasn’t worked well. Maybe it’ll work btter with Il Generale strong belief is we should try everything to set up McKennie to succeed in the national team midfield, and that should be the focus of the next two camps. But if nothing works, and we don’t have any better ideas by next spring, he should be dropped from the starting XI. If he can’t weave himself into a double pivot with Adams, or a partnership at the 8 with Delgado or Nagbe, bring in Russell Canouse or Danny Williams next to Adams, or play Bradley as a lone 6, with Adams and Delgado/Acosta/Nagbe ahead of them. Lots of options. Other midfield possibilities will emerge after the Colombia and Peru game, unless something clicks in one of those games.</p><p>And over the next three years there will be plenty of time to tinker. Adams is increasingly looking like the future captain of the USMNT, and McKennie is going to be his first-choice sidekick. Players like Richie Ledezma, Alex Mendez and Andrew Carleton will have a chance to play their way into the national team as more play-making central midfielders. May the best man win.</p><p><strong>If you like this kind of soccer discussion, check out our podcast, Scuffed, on </strong><a href="https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/scuffed-soccer-podcast-usmnt-yanks-abroad-interviews/id1352231546?mt=2"><strong>iTunes</strong></a><strong>, </strong><a href="https://open.spotify.com/show/6BGppXIvutLhgkpohF2Xes"><strong>Spotify</strong></a><strong>, </strong><a href="https://www.stitcher.com/podcast/the-scuffed-soccer-podcast-usmnt-yanks-abroad-interviews"><strong>Stitcher</strong></a><strong> or Overcast. It’s weekly and we talk about the U.S. Men’s National Team.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=68a7db6752cd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Scuffed, Vol. 49: What we learned from Paraguay, Zlatan has arrived, and George Bello’s USL debut]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adambelz/scuffed-vol-49-what-we-learned-from-paraguay-zlatan-has-arrived-and-george-bellos-usl-debut-d386190ab832?source=rss-1e2a018e513a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d386190ab832</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[soccer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Belz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Apr 2018 21:43:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-17T21:43:51.981Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>published 4/2/2018…</em></p><p>It’s time to dispense with the “meaningless friendly” trope. I say this to myself as much as anyone, but we have a maximum of 13 international friendlies before the Copa America and Gold Cup next summer, and that assumes the Federation schedules the maximum number, which is a very unsafe assumption.</p><p>Now is the time to start building toward a cohesive team for those tournaments. No match can be wasted. With that in mind, the 1–0 win over Paraguay is growing on me. The U.S. showed it can dominate the center of the pitch with a trio of Wil Trapp, Marky Delgado and Tyler Adams buzzing around, staying composed and projecting American power. They controlled large portions of the game and each should be included in USMNT rosters henceforth. With more attacking edge against Paraguay we could have scored goals, and we’ll get to that.</p><p>Here are seven things we learned:</p><p><strong>1. Tyler Adams is an international-caliber center mid.</strong> Not only did he show he belongs in the position for the USMNT, he was the most influential player in the game, and my man of the match. I’ve said before I’d like him to play right back but I’m backing off of that for now. I still have the same criticisms — he’s not polished enough on the ball to navigate tight spaces or help unlock a defense — but at this point who cares? His combination of energy, alertness, athleticism and mostly good passing was the decisive factor in the match. The 19-year-old pressed and broke up Paraguay’s rhythm, won the ball, drew fouls and found teammates’ feet. He made the run to draw the penalty for the decisive goal. He flourished. He’s still probably not assured enough on the ball to be the №6, but I wouldn’t bet against him developing into that role, and for now he works brilliantly as a №8. He starts in that position next to McKennie in my book and I can’t wait to see it.</p><p><strong>2. Marky Delgado and Wil Trapp showed they are valuable depth at center mid.</strong> Delgado is now at least even with Kellyn Acosta as the first №8 off the bench in a 4–3–3 (or 4–1–4–1, whatever you want to call it). He covers a lot of ground, was alert, was more composed than Adams and played quickly. I really like him. Weston McKennie is still better, though, so Delgado doesn’t start in a first-choice XI. Trapp also had a good game, and should be the first №6 off the bench behind Michael Bradley. With Adams searching and destroying, Trapp or Bradley holding it down at the 6 and McKennie keying the attack, I like our midfield. And Keaton Parks is a-comin’.</p><p><strong>3. We lack attacking quality.</strong> Jozy Altidore is our best striker, and he’s got enough limitations to fill a book. Outside of Pulisic we don’t have a proven attacking midfielder OR attacking winger, a truth reinforced for anyone who watched the friendly with Paraguay. There’s just nobody. Paul Arriola is struggling at D.C. United. Darlington Nagbe and Kenny Saief are better suited for other roles. That’s why Andrew Carleton, Josh Sargent, Jonathan Amon, Tim Weah, and even 16-year-old attacking left back George Bello and 15-year-old attacker Gio Reyna are so important. Anybody who’s playing first team soccer and can beat a guy and rip a shot on frame or hit a killer pass is an improvement over the current options. I am hopeful that by 2022 all six of the aforementioned will be first team regulars somewhere, and we’ll see better days. Their progress is a paramount concern at Scuffed Global Headquarters.</p><p><strong>4. Darlington Nagbe and Kenny Saief are technically gifted but limited as attacking wingers.</strong> They each provided spark on Tuesday and I imagine they’ll both start their share of USMNT games over the next four years. Neither is a game-changing raider from the wing, however, and unless we have quality attacking fullbacks we need more bite from the flanks than either of them offers. Be interesting to see which one of Saief or Nagbe sits when Pulisic joins the squad in May and June.</p><p><strong>5. Bobby Wood’s stock keeps falling.</strong> The striker scored from the spot but it was his only good moment. We can’t fault his work rate or attitude. But we can hope that Josh Sargent slides right into the first team at Werder Bremen this fall, and that Aron Johannsson can string together a year of good health. (Sargent, who isn’t allowed to play sanctioned football until September, got some rare minutes with the U19s at Werder in friendlies over the weekend and <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-49-what-we-learned-from-paraguay-zlatan-has-arrived-and-george-bello-s-usl-debut/11238761-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/980831019455733760?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">scored three goals in five 50-minute games</a>. Nothing we haven’t seen before from the kid but his debut for Werder, hopefully in five months, will be a glory glory hallelujah moment.)</p><p><strong>6. Matt Miazga looked like a potential first choice centerback, and Cameron Carter-Vickers cemented his spot on the list of the top 40 male American soccer players.</strong> I still think Geoff Cameron and John Brooks is the best centerback pairing for now, and Matt Besler is not far behind Miazga, but we’re building depth, Cameron will be 37 for Qatar, Brooks can’t stay healthy, and Miazga/CCV showed they can get the job done together.</p><p><strong>7. Everybody else is fine.</strong> We didn’t see anything new from Jorge Villafana or DeAndre Yedlin at fullback. A good chance they’ll be the starters for a while and that’s OK for now. Zack Steffen was decent at goalkeeper. The subs — Rubio Rubin, Andrija Novakovich and Tim Weah — were all energetic but we didn’t see a lot of them. We saw even less of Cristian Roldan, who came on with one minute to go.</p><p>— — <br><strong>Zlatan Ibrahimovic</strong> came swaggering into Los Angeles with his recently recuperated knee, said the “lion is hungry” at a <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-49-what-we-learned-from-paraguay-zlatan-has-arrived-and-george-bello-s-usl-debut/11238765-youtu.be/wenxgautyhg?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">wonderful press conference</a> on Thursday, and two days later came on with 20 minutes left and scored two goals to give the Galaxy a 4–3 win over their new but very real cross-town rivals Los Angeles F.C. (who, with Carlos Vela pulling the strings, are probably the most fun team to watch in the league right now). Zlatan’s first goal was a <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-49-what-we-learned-from-paraguay-zlatan-has-arrived-and-george-bello-s-usl-debut/11238769-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/980184476977369088?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">certified golazo</a> from 40 yards. The second won the match in stoppage time. You kidding me? It was a dream sequence for the Galaxy, MLS, and American soccer fans. I don’t know what it all means, but whatever it is, it’s not a bad thing.</p><p>— — <br>Finally, <strong>George Bello</strong>, the barely 16-year-old left back for Atlanta, made his professional debut with the team’s USL side on Saturday. I <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-49-what-we-learned-from-paraguay-zlatan-has-arrived-and-george-bello-s-usl-debut/11238773-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/980867225065328641?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">GIF’d the performance in exhaustive detail</a>here, because I rate the kid and the USMNT needs left backs. Bello forced an own goal and was generally a menace bombing up and down the left side. His defending was also very encouraging. He didn’t look match fit, ran out of gas, and allowed the cross for the Charlotte equalizer in the last ten minutes, but it was an encouraging debut. His technique, intelligence, decisiveness and pace are clearly high-caliber. He’s clean on the ball, he shuts down his flank and he causes problems going forward. I’m buying Bello stock.</p><p><strong>Scuffed is a weekly soccer newsletter focused on the U.S. Men’s National Team, and the players who could one day make it better. The sign up page is </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-49-what-we-learned-from-paraguay-zlatan-has-arrived-and-george-bello-s-usl-debut/11238777-tinyletter.com/adambelz?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>. The Scuffed Podcast is </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-49-what-we-learned-from-paraguay-zlatan-has-arrived-and-george-bello-s-usl-debut/11238781-itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/scuffed/id1352231546?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>. Address heckling to </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-49-what-we-learned-from-paraguay-zlatan-has-arrived-and-george-bello-s-usl-debut/11238785-twitter.com/zlebmada?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>@zlebmada</strong></a><strong>, or you can respond at length by replying to this email.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d386190ab832" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Scuffed, Vol. 48: Paraguay is next, caution on Weah, and a Carleton assist]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adambelz/scuffed-vol-48-paraguay-is-next-caution-on-weah-and-a-carleton-assist-6d5a92e849be?source=rss-1e2a018e513a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6d5a92e849be</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[soccer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Belz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Apr 2018 21:42:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-17T21:42:27.115Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>published 3/22/2018…</em></p><p>I suspect we’ll be treated to a bit of a grind in the friendly against Paraguay. The attacking quality in the pool is conspicuously thin, especially in Christian Pulisic’s absence, and this roster doesn’t include defenders who excel at distributing the ball forward. So the weight of responsibility for forging something fluid and pleasing to the eye will fall heavily on whatever midfield partnership manager Dave Sarachan selects for the match on Tuesday near Raleigh, N.C.</p><p>I’m mostly pleased with the roster. The average age is 22.7 and we’re getting looks at a lot of exciting newcomers. Long-time subjects of the Scuffed newsletter such as Antonee Robinson and Shaq Moore were called up and could get their first caps. 18-year-old Paris St. Germain attacker Tim Weah made the trip. 24-year-old left-footed technician Kenny Saief is back for the first time since Gold Cup preparations. Matt Miazga, Cameron Carter-Vickers and Erik Palmer-Brown represent the rising centerback generation. Midfielders Weston McKennie and Tyler Adams are reporting for duty for the second time in careers that will likely stretch to 100 caps each. It’s good to see all of these guys involved and hopefully building chemistry.</p><p>Other fresh faces include striker Andrija Novakovich, winger Rubio Rubin and winger Kekuta Manneh. These three seem like marginal national team players to me, but I’m glad they are getting a chance, especially Rubin, who was bright in his cameo against Bosnia in January.</p><p>The big disappointment is that Christian Pulisic won’t be there. It’s understandable. Dortmund has eight matches left to lock down a Champion’s League spot next season and Pulisic is in an ongoing battle for playing time. Best for him to rest, train with BVB and put his best foot forward in the Bundesliga down the stretch. But make no mistake, we cannot begin to heal from the wounds of 2017 until we see Pulisic and McKennie together on the field in the U.S. shirt. They are, for now, the cream of the next generation and I’ve said before that it will be a delight to see McKennie dropping dimes to a darting Pulisic. Looks like we’ll have to wait until May and June for that.</p><p>The other disappointments of the roster are that centerback Justen Glad and midfielder Keaton Parks are not included. I think Glad is more deserving than Palmer-Brown or Carter-Vickers at centerback, but he appears to have run afoul of Sarachan, or maybe Real Salt Lake wants to keep him at home. RSL gave up five goals at home to LAFC a couple weeks ago, and though they beat Red Bulls last weekend they need to get some things sorted out. Parks’ absence is almost as understandable as Pulisic’s, since he’s hardly a first-team regular for Benfica and it’s possible they want to keep him in Lisbon. If he earns his way to the first team over the next eight months, he’ll get his chance with the national team. I expect both things to happen because he has 360-degree midfield skills matched only by McKennie in our pool.</p><p>But still, Parks and Glad would have been nice additions to this roster because they can both pass. As I mentioned at the top of the newsletter, I expect we’ll end up in a slugfest with Paraguay because we don’t have a lot of connective quality at our disposal. McKennie and Saief are excellent passers, but…that’s it. Wil Trapp’s a good shuttler who can play a decent long ball. Adams can make a killer pass when he’s got the game in front of him. McKennie could grab the game by the scruff of the neck and put on a masterclass as a №8, but he’s still regaining form after his knee injury earlier this year and it’s more likely that we’ll try to hit Paraguay in transition with our fullbacks bombing forward. Anybody’s guess on who Sarachan chooses as a striker, or what formation he runs out. Here’s my suggestion:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/347/0*AP-n7hkrZBOJEY5M.png" /></figure><p>— — <br>A lot of fans are very excited about <strong>Timothy Weah</strong>, a winger who remarkably has gotten two first-team appearances at PSG, the biggest-spending club in the world. I hope the best for him, he seems like a fantastic young man, and I’m pleasantly surprised he’s gotten first-team action. But let’s not get ahead of ourselves. PSG is miles ahead at the top of the table in Ligue 1, Neymar is injured, and Weah got minutes when the games were well in hand against two of the three worst teams in the league on consecutive weekends on either side of a do-or-die midweek Champions League match with Real Madrid. He got a runout. Great! But pretending he’s competing for minutes with Neymar, Kylian Mbappe, Angel Di Maria and Julian Draxler is fantasy.</p><p>And in his appearances he looked limited, as he did in the U17 World Cup, which is why I’m not yet plugging him into my first-choice USMNT roster. He moves intelligently off the ball and works hard, which are two very important qualities, but he doesn’t create. He didn’t do anything on the ball in his two PSG appearances and failed to convert two 1v1’s with the keeper. The golazo against Paraguay in India gave us a glimpse of something special (it was one of the goals of the tournament), but that was literally the only instance I’ve ever seen of him doing something on the ball that separates him from the pack.</p><p>The fact that he’s the only teenager not named Kylian Mbappe who’s gotten minutes with PSG’s first team speaks for itself. Massive accomplishment. But if we were conducting a draft of young, unproven American teenagers, he’s pretty far down the list for me. I’d take Andrew Carleton, Chris Durkin, Josh Sargent or even George Bello first. The injured winger Jonathan Amon, who’s playing in Denmark, is a more exciting prospect for me than Weah right now.</p><p>— — <br>McKennie was out for Schalke with a muscle strain and Pulisic put in a quiet performance for Dortmund in a 1–0 win over Hannover. Weah wasn’t in the 18 for PSG, nor was Parks for Benfica.</p><p>But it was another remarkably good weekend for American teenagers in MLS. <strong>Auston Trusty</strong> and <strong>Anthony Fontana</strong> both played again for the Philadelphia Union in a 0–0 draw with Columbus. The scoreline is flattering to Trusty, 19, a centerback, who’s played every minute of the Union’s two shutouts. Fontana came on as an attacking mid in the final minutes and reportedly looked bright. I’ll deliver more on these two as the season progresses, promise, but today we’ll focus on three other teenagers. <strong>Chris Durkin</strong> helped D.C. United scratch back a 2–2 draw and could get his first start on Saturday.</p><p>17-year-old <strong>Andrew Carleton</strong> finally (three games into the season) got the cameo we’d all been waiting for, about 15 minutes at the end of a 4–1 win for Atlanta over Vancouver. I believe he’s a little genius, could key the attack for the U.S. for much of the next decade, and has the potential to be an elite playmaker. I’m not the only one excited about him. He delivered on the hype Saturday against 10-man Vancouver. After taking a few touches to get settled in, he drifted into a pocket of space in the right channel, received a square pass from the wing with a touch forward, and then hit a <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-48-paraguay-is-next-caution-on-weah-and-a-carleton-assist/11138373-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/975736729490599938?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">perfect cross</a> to the head of Josef Martinez on the back post, who pounced on it. 4–1. There was room for Carleton to operate thanks to a red card against Vancouver earlier in the match, so we still need to see more of him against a full-strength opponent before I can claim total victory, but he looked awfully good. I <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-48-paraguay-is-next-caution-on-weah-and-a-carleton-assist/11138377-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/975201022011469824?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">GIF’d his touches here</a>, focusing on his off-ball movement. He drags defenders away from his teammates, finds space, and seems utterly aware of what’s behind him.</p><p>18-year-old <strong>Paxton Pomykal</strong> got a similar cameo for F.C. Dallas against 10-man Seattle, also with his team up 3–0. I wasn’t as impressed with him, but he’s obviously a technically gifted player with flair. I <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-48-paraguay-is-next-caution-on-weah-and-a-carleton-assist/11138381-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/975589344265285632?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">GIF’d some of his moments here</a>. He needs to get more physically imposing, I think, to earn more minutes. Perhaps the best news is that he was called up for the U20 camp in Spain and then recalled by Dallas ahead of a game on Saturday against Portland. So he’s likely to get more MLS minutes and is another one to watch. His teammates, 19-year-old <strong>Reggie Cannon</strong>, put on his best performance at right back.</p><p>The next few months are going to be difficult, watching 32 other nations play in the World Cup. But there’s talent a-coming. The best we can hope for from this summer is that every American player ages 15 to 35 feels acute pain from watching the World Cup, and then comes into the next qualifying cycle hungrier than a grizzly bear before the salmon arrive.</p><p><strong>Scuffed is a weekly soccer newsletter focused on the U.S. Men’s National Team, and the players who could one day make it better. The sign up page is </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-48-paraguay-is-next-caution-on-weah-and-a-carleton-assist/11138385-tinyletter.com/adambelz?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>. The ScuffedPodcast is </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-48-paraguay-is-next-caution-on-weah-and-a-carleton-assist/11138389-itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/scuffed/id1352231546?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>. Address heckling to </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-48-paraguay-is-next-caution-on-weah-and-a-carleton-assist/11138393-twitter.com/zlebmada?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>@zlebmada</strong></a><strong>, or you can respond at length by replying to this email.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6d5a92e849be" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Scuffed, Vol. 47: In praise of New York Red Bulls, and the pool is shaping up for Paraguay]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adambelz/scuffed-vol-47-in-praise-of-new-york-red-bulls-and-the-pool-is-shaping-up-for-paraguay-d0ffba37a6fd?source=rss-1e2a018e513a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d0ffba37a6fd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[soccer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Belz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Apr 2018 21:41:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-17T21:41:15.062Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>published 3/13/2018…</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*7QjQLhycDGSQQx15.jpg" /></figure><p>We already knew New York Red Bulls were the best team in Major League Soccer at developing talent. Their system produced Michael Bradley, Jozy Altidore, Juan Agudelo and Matt Miazga (282 USMNT caps between them and many more to come for the 22-year-old Miazga). Now 19-year-old Tyler Adams is at the heart of the squad and looks like a long-time national team regular.</p><p>On Saturday, the Red Bulls showed that their pipeline, at least relative to the rest of the league, runneth over. Manager Jesse Marsch rested nine starters against the Portland Timbers on Saturday, and played 17-year-old American attacker Ben Mines, 20-year-old American right back Kyle Duncan, and 21-year-old Haitian-American attacker Derrick Etienne, Jr. The youthful lineup jumped on the Timbers and ripped them to pieces from kickoff and ended up winning 4–0. It was a resounding victory for the play your kids movement, a ringing endorsement of the Red Bulls system and a signal that they have the depth to be a real contender in MLS and maybe the Concacaf Champions League.</p><p>Mines is the youngster who got most of the attention. I <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-47-in-praise-of-new-york-red-bulls-and-the-pool-is-shaping-up-for-paraguay/11062093-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/972934601193807872?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">GIF’d a bunch of his touches here</a>. He’s a direct, pacy, physical winger who reminds me of a beefy, less technical Christian Pulisic. He went after Timbers left back Marco Farfan from the get-go, moved well off the ball as evidenced by his <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-47-in-praise-of-new-york-red-bulls-and-the-pool-is-shaping-up-for-paraguay/11062097-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/972939909345562630?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">thump-in at the back post</a> for the opening goal, won a half-dozen corner kicks driving at the defense and put his stamp on the match. Heady stuff for a 17-year-old. He also was loose with his passing and his crossing was largely off the mark, failing to beat the first defender (which is why so many corner kicks). So he’s some kind of instant call-up to the national team, but he’s one to watch. It sure looks like he’ll get a lot of minutes this season.</p><p>Attracting less attention was Duncan, the right back. He’s a Red Bulls academy product who decamped to France’s second division in 2015 and couldn’t get minutes, then came home in January and earned his way to a contract with Red Bulls. He looked very good to me on Saturday (better than the Red Bulls’ Panamanian starter at right back, Michael Amir Murillo). Duncan shut down Portland winger Sebastian Blanco and got forward in thoughtful and incisive ways. Look how he <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-47-in-praise-of-new-york-red-bulls-and-the-pool-is-shaping-up-for-paraguay/11062101-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/972754777519124480?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">drives forward and slips BWP in at the top of the box</a> for a move that carves up Portland’s defense for the game’s final goal. Any right back who defends and can pass is worth paying attention to for the USMNT.</p><p>I was also charmed that Marsch wasn’t an idealogue about playing his kids. When the starters flagged and Portland played its way back into the game early in the second half, he brought on Adams and Bradley Wright-Phillips, and they helped blow the game open, as Red Bulls scored three in the final 20 minutes. Here’s Tyler Adams <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-47-in-praise-of-new-york-red-bulls-and-the-pool-is-shaping-up-for-paraguay/11062105-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/972760407365619712?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">driving forward from deep</a>, displaying the power and decisiveness that’s so tantalizing for those dreaming about him as a future elite №6. I still don’t see it, but if he can couple that raw energy and athleticism with better tactical and spatial awareness, we’ve got a potentially dominant №6 on our hands, and an excellent anchor behind a future box-to-box pairing of Keaton Parks and Weston McKennie.</p><p>For all these reasons, Red Bulls are must-watch television, and that continues tonight at 7 p.m. CT, when they try to protect a 2–0 aggregate lead in the home leg of their quarterfinal Champions League tie with Tijuana. Marsch’s side was fortunate to hang on for the away victory last week, so there is no time for self-congratulation, but they’re riding high and I expect them to pull this off and advance to a very winnable semifinal against either Chivas or Seattle (I’m picking Chivas). Again, the most interesting question going into this game for me is whether Adams can take a game by the scruff of the neck and be influential. The second most interesting question is whether the MLS can take a Liga MX scalp. Mexican clubs have been utterly dominant in the Concacaf Champions League, and that has made the tournament a bit of a snooze. A win on Tuesday would amp up interest, validate MLS to some extent, certainly validate Red Bulls and Jesse Marsch, and, I hope, validate any hope in Adams as the future anchor of the USMNT midfield. Your move, Tyler.</p><p>Meanwhile, the marquee matchup tonight is Toronto at Tigres later tonight, trying to defend a 2–1 lead on aggregate in the second leg. Very difficult task for Greg Vanney. I have no prediction. Wouldn’t be surprised if Toronto wins comfortably (a couple moments of brilliance from Giovinco could blow it open). Wouldn’t be surprised if Toronto holds on in a thriller. Wouldn’t be surprised if Tigres go off, put up five goals, and rewrite the narrative. I’ll punt on this one.</p><p>— — <br>Red Bulls provided the domestic bliss over the weekend, but Americans abroad also had their best showing in months, and the pool is shaping up ahead of the friendly against Paraguay on March 27 in Raleigh, N.C.</p><p><strong>Christian Pulisic</strong> had his <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-47-in-praise-of-new-york-red-bulls-and-the-pool-is-shaping-up-for-paraguay/11062109-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/973037834633404417?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">best game since early November</a>. He forced an own-goal, had an assist and should have gotten another one as Dortmund defeated Eintracht Frankfurt 3–2 and pushed clear to third in the Bundesliga table (top four qualify for Champions League in the fall). Pulisic got some rest in the past couple of weeks and it showed. He was brighter, more decisive and more dangerous than he’s been since he shredded Bayern Munich in a losing effort in early November. He also was a better passer. This is the key. When he passes quickly it makes him and his team so much more dangerous, because it sets up his dribbling ability.</p><p><strong>Keaton Parks</strong> got his first minutes with the first team at Benfica in two months, and he <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-47-in-praise-of-new-york-red-bulls-and-the-pool-is-shaping-up-for-paraguay/11062113-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/972698108567216128?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">looked every bit the part</a> at central midfield helping to see out a 2–0 victory for one of the world’s great clubs. He was involved and crisp, showing off his quick feet and sense of the space around him in the middle of the park. He’s an excellent passer and a rhythm builder. He may not get many minutes over the next two or three months as Benfica battles for a Champions League spot, but he’s in their plans and is playing well when he gets a chance.</p><p><strong>Weston McKennie</strong> was back in the starting XI for Schalke, fresh off an injury layoff. <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-47-in-praise-of-new-york-red-bulls-and-the-pool-is-shaping-up-for-paraguay/11062117-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/972518203741163520?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">He was rusty</a>, but the fact that he played 90 minutes — the first half at center mid, the second half at wingback — demonstrates how valuable he is to bright young manager Domenico Tedesco, and how much of a priority it is for Schalke to get him back up to speed. And Schalke did win. McKennie should be in the starting XI for the U.S. against Paraguay.</p><p><strong>Tim Weah</strong> made his second appearance with Paris St.-Germain on Saturday. He <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-47-in-praise-of-new-york-red-bulls-and-the-pool-is-shaping-up-for-paraguay/11062121-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/972524376204734469?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">didn’t set the world afire</a>, but his movement was good and he found himself in another one-on-one with the keeper, again failing to convert. I’m still ambivalent about Weah for the national team but you can’t ignore two first-team appearances with PSG at the age of 17. He’s probably earned a call-up. I know he’s popular with the USMNT coaching tree.</p><p>Lots more happened but most of you are already tracking the basic facts. Here’s my 23-man roster for the Paraguay friendly. <strong>Jorge Villafana</strong>, who’s putting in a great 2018 for top-of-the-table Liga MX club Santos Laguna, has an argument to be on here. There’s an argument for Wood not to be on here, though I hesitate to punish him for failing in one of the world’s best leagues. <strong>Kyle Scott</strong> probably won’t get the call and <strong>Danny Williams</strong>probably deserves it, but we like to dream at Scuffed Global Headquarters. Anyway, without further ado:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/345/0*H8vW5Yk0jNT4fmRW.png" /></figure><p>And MLS was again fascinating this past weekend, even outside of Red Bulls. Bob Bradley’s experiment at Los Angeles FC looks like a juggernaut in the making, with the handsomest attacker in the league, Carlos Vela, leading the way. We’re still waiting for Andrew Carleton to get a serious runout for Atlanta. He got 1 minute on Saturday. Meet me at Tata Martino’s house with a dozen eggs on Sunday morning if he doesn’t get a solid cameo this Saturday.</p><p><strong>Scuffed is a weekly soccer newsletter focused on the U.S. Men’s National Team, and the players who could one day make it better. The sign up page is </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-47-in-praise-of-new-york-red-bulls-and-the-pool-is-shaping-up-for-paraguay/11062125-tinyletter.com/adambelz?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>. The ScuffedPodcast is </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-47-in-praise-of-new-york-red-bulls-and-the-pool-is-shaping-up-for-paraguay/11062129-itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/scuffed/id1352231546?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>. Address heckling to </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-47-in-praise-of-new-york-red-bulls-and-the-pool-is-shaping-up-for-paraguay/11062133-twitter.com/zlebmada?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>@zlebmada</strong></a><strong>, or you can respond at length by replying to this email.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d0ffba37a6fd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Scuffed, Vol. 46: MLS youngs, CCL half-triumphs, Justen Gladness and McKennie’s return]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adambelz/scuffed-vol-46-mls-youngs-ccl-half-triumphs-justen-gladness-and-mckennies-return-4e1bd38dfe9c?source=rss-1e2a018e513a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4e1bd38dfe9c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[soccer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Belz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Apr 2018 21:40:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-17T21:40:00.777Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>published 3/8/2018…</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*duV7mlt_KvFBL_Pg.jpg" /></figure><p>Major League Soccer is off and running and the spectacle so far has been a good one — full of surprises, interesting stories and players, and problems for managers to solve. Most importantly so far, the league tucked away three Concacaf Champions League quarterfinal victories over Liga MX clubs this week, offering a glimmer of hope that MLS may be starting to close the gap with Mexico’s top flight.</p><p>Red Bulls, Toronto and Seattle play second legs against Tijuana, Tigres and Chivas next week. Anything could happen. MLS could go three and out. All three could advance. Red Bulls are in the best position with a 2–0 lead on aggregate and two away goals, but they looked dangerously susceptible on Tuesday and I wouldn’t be surprised if Xolos make them pay in New Jersey. Toronto looked the slightly better side in their 2–1 win at BMO Field (Sebastian Giovinco is so, so good), but Tigres is the best club in North America over the past decade and won’t be napping for the second leg in Monterrey. Seattle and Chivas? Who knows. Neither side is clicking on all cylinders.</p><p>I’ll be rooting for the MLS teams not just because I’m American, but because it would be good for the tournament and North American soccer for the MLS to leap forward. Liga MX has dominated the tournament, and the CCL needs anger and pain, rivalries and stories. Feels this week like we are starting to get that. <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-46-mls-youngs-ccl-half-triumphs-justen-gladness-and-mckennie-s-return/11014873-twitter.com/record_mexico/status/971728638243758081?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">Anguish</a> in the Mexican sports press. Dempsey shushing Chivas fans. Tensions boiling over at the Estadio Caliente. Who knows when the tournament will enter the mainstream consciousness in the United States, but for soccer fans, the <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-46-mls-youngs-ccl-half-triumphs-justen-gladness-and-mckennie-s-return/11014877-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/971636937541943297?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">shots of Michael Bradley jawing with Tigres’ bear of a French striker André-Pierre Gignac</a> in the cold breeze off of Lake Ontario was almost worth the price of admission.</p><p>Speaking of the Concacaf Champions League, feast your eyes on this <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-46-mls-youngs-ccl-half-triumphs-justen-gladness-and-mckennie-s-return/11014881-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/971221755560972288?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">laser-beam of a golazo from American <strong>Joe Corona</strong></a>, who’s settled in nicely with Club America, the odds-on favorite to win the tournament.</p><p>— — <br>When it comes to the MLS regular season, Atlanta was obviously the big disappointment last weekend, losing 4–0 on the road to Houston after a glorious inaugural campaign and arguably the league’s most ambitious offseason. Their defense was terrible, and the big problem is that it might take a while to sort that out, which you’d think will reduce the chances of minutes for promising young Americans (i.e. Andrew Carleton) in the first part of the season. I didn’t mind that Carleton wasn’t thrown into Saturday’s dumpster fire because I don’t think he could have done anything to help. What’s more disappointing is that Chris Goslin didn’t do enough in preseason to get into the gameday roster and serve as an option in defensive midfield for a team that clearly lacked steel in the center of the park. The 17-year-old Goslin, on paper, checks that box, but he didn’t look sharp in the last game of preseason, and having watched several tepid young American performances over the weekend, I’m more inclined to trust an MLS coach — in this case, Tata Martino — who decides a young American isn’t ready.</p><p>Which brings me to this: Hyping good up-and-comers is a core tenet here at Scuffed Global Headquarters. But to do that with any credibility, we need to demonstrate our ability to distinguish between those worthy of hype and those who need to toil in obscurity a bit longer. It’s time to send a few hype trains into the railyard for maintenance. (We’ll put them back on the tracks as soon as they’re ready!)</p><p>Fullbacks <strong>Reggie Cannon</strong>, 19, for F.C. Dallas, and <strong>Marco Farfan</strong>, 19, for Portland, both got starts and didn’t quite look like MLS-caliber defenders. Their teams suffered as a result. Dallas drew Real Salt Lake 1–1 at home and Portland lost on the road 2–1 to the LA Galaxy. Cannon was beat on the opening goal and generally looked clumsy defending, as he also did in Dallas’ Champions League crashout. Farfan was not impressive in preseason and that form carried over to opening day. I want badly for them both to keep getting minutes. Cannon’s speed and crossing make him a real threat on the overlap from right back, and Farfan is a clever passer at left back. But it wouldn’t surprise me to see them both spend more time on the bench in coming weeks, and I wouldn’t blame their managers for it.</p><p>A third young defender, <strong>Danny Acosta</strong>, 20, lost his starting job as Real Salt Lake’s left back in preseason upon his return from USMNT January camp. He came on Saturday for an injured teammate in the waning minutes of the match against Dallas, with RSL up 1–0. He looked sluggish from the get-go, and it was his giveaway along the left sideline that led to the equalizing goal late. Not good. (There was a lot of good in that match from Acosta’s teammate Justen Glad, and we’ll get to that later.)</p><p><strong>Chris Durkin</strong>, 18, for D.C. United, came on at defensive midfield toward the end of a match with Orlando City with his side up 1–0, and also looked a step slow. His side was over-matched in general against an opponent playing a man down, but Durkin in particular was a beat late in closing down Justin Meram in the right channel, Meram slid a ball in behind and the equalizer resulted. I expect Durkin to get sharper quickly. He’s got too much quality and drive not to. But, again, he didn’t look immediately ready, and I wouldn’t be surprised if his minutes suffer in the first part of the season.</p><p><strong>Brandon Vasquez</strong>, 19, cameo’d for Atlanta in their loss to Houston, and I just don’t rate him. He completed 3 of 8 passes in 17 minutes, and none of his successful passes advanced possession. He’s a big kid and looks the part of a goalscorer, but he isn’t able to create space for himself or beat a good defender on the wing. My sense is he’s being prepared to serve as the backup 9 for Josef Martinez, and maybe he’d look better in that role.</p><p><strong>Tyler Adams</strong>, 19, is a bona fide men’s national team player and I expect him to be called up for every meaningful camp in the near future. His team, New York Red Bulls, got the huge 2–0 away win in the Concacaf Champions League over Tijuana, and Adams was all over the pitch. Unfortunately, something still doesn’t feel right about the way he plays in the middle of the field. Yes, he covers a lot of ground. He’s fast and physical and disruptive. But that did little to neutralize the Xolos attack on Tuesday. Tijuana was dominant on the night, despite the scoreline, overrunning New York for large stretches. Red Bulls have goalkeeper Luis Robles and an incorrect offside call to thank for the fact that Tijuana didn’t put up a fivespot. We can’t pin that all on Adams, but it’s partly up to him as the №6 to ensure the center of the pitch is difficult to play through. And most importantly from my perspective, he demonstrated little ability to step on the ball and dictate the tempo of the game, or find a pass that relieves pressure or wrong-foots a defense. I realize Red Bulls have a frenetic attacking identity and don’t ask Adams to do the things traditionally required of his position. But if that’s the case, how’s he going to develop into a good midfielder? Working in tight space, finding space on the half-turn, and quickly picking out useful passes are skills you really want to see from your nation’s best midfield prospects. I don’t see them in Adams yet. He’ll have all season to work on his game, because he’s a nailed-on starter for New York. But until his 360-degree midfielding improves, he’s at best a last-resort center mid in a first-choice USMNT lineup. Weston McKennie, Michael Bradley, Danny Williams and Kellyn Acosta are all higher in the depth chart. Even Keaton Parks at Benfica and even Kyle Scott at Chelsea, both largely reserve players, are more comfortable on the ball in the middle of the park than Adams. Heck, newcomer Anthony Fontana for the Philadelphia Union looked better equipped for the work of receiving and distributing the ball in traffic than Adams. Adams will find a place on the field where he can make a massive impact. He’s going to be a big national team player. Still not convinced that place is midfield.</p><p>— — <br>Let’s move on to the positives, starting with the aforementioned Philadelphia Union. They won 2–0 over New England on Saturday and started two young Americans — the aforementioned attacking midfielder <strong>Anthony Fontana</strong>, 18, and centerback <strong>Auston Trusty</strong>, 19. Fontana in particular was a revelation to me. Hadn’t been tracking him at all, and he started as the №10 (a job he likely won’t keep). I <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-46-mls-youngs-ccl-half-triumphs-justen-gladness-and-mckennie-s-return/11014885-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/970888850506768384?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">GIF’d a few moments here</a>, but in general I was most impressed with his comfort on the ball, his ability to turn into space and the quickness of his feet. Looked bright and clever. And he got the game-winning goal at the end of the first half. I don’t have as much insight on Trusty, but he went the full 90 against a hapless Revolution side and had a goal-saving recovery run and tackle in the final minutes.</p><p><strong>Justen Glad</strong>, 21, put in a monster performance at centerback for Real Salt Lake. I’m impressed. It’s hard to gauge how good a player is in MLS versus the English Championship, so I can’t say with certainty he’s better than Cameron Carter-Vickers or Tim Ream, but I want to say it very badly. Glad is alert, fast, excellent in the air, and he doesn’t make mental mistakes. One-on-one he’s very difficult to beat. On the ball, he’s able to create little pockets of space for his fullbacks and defensive midfielders by taking a dribble and playing them a pass. I put together a <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-46-mls-youngs-ccl-half-triumphs-justen-gladness-and-mckennie-s-return/11014889-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/970539793921658880?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">thorough series of GIFs of his performance Saturday here</a>. I expect him to compete for MLS defender of the year in 2018, and I expect him to be right there with John Brooks and Matt Miazga when the next USMNT manager has to choose centerbacks for the 2022 World Cup. Call him up in March, Dave Sarachan. (He probably won’t.)</p><p>— —</p><p>Lastly, three notes from Europe. 17-year-old winger <strong>Tim Weah</strong> <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-46-mls-youngs-ccl-half-triumphs-justen-gladness-and-mckennie-s-return/11014893-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/969991057017466880?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">got his professional debut</a> with Paris Saint-Germain on Saturday. Huge congratulations. The squad was depleted ahead of a must-win Champions League tie against Real Madrid (PSG lost), but regardless, there he was, crossing the ball and having a go on a breakaway. I haven’t rated Weah that highly despite his U17 World Cup hat trick, and I have to admit he’s gone further, faster than I would have predicted.</p><p><strong>Weston McKennie</strong> is back on the pitch for Schalke! He showed up for the last 10 minutes of a 1–0 win over Hertha Berlin. He didn’t look particularly sharp but that’s fine. As you all know, I believe he is the most important player in the pool, a game-changer with grit, aerial prowess, craft and elite passing ability. He says the injury made him a better player. I like the sound of that.</p><p><strong>Christian Pulisic</strong> came on for the last 30 minutes of a 2–1 Europa League loss for Dortmund against Red Bull Salzburg. He was a positive addition and <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-46-mls-youngs-ccl-half-triumphs-justen-gladness-and-mckennie-s-return/11014897-streamja.com/aez?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">got an assist a minute after he came on</a>, but it wasn’t enough. Dortmund’s form is so disastrous, and Pulisic’s progress stagnant enough, that I’m beginning to entertain, for the first time, the idea that he should leave this summer if he can. Not saying he should but I’m far more open to it than three months ago. Things aren’t going well at Dortmund, and it’s hard to see them improving. A new coach in the summer may be all that’s needed. Hope so.</p><p>That’s a subject for another day. What would heal a lot of wounds at Scuffed and for fans across the nation would be to see McKennie and Pulisic on the pitch together later this month against Paraguay. McKennie anchoring the midfield, Pulisic on the wing racing onto passes from McKennie. Nobody can get American soccer back on track on his own, but those two are a big part of the solution. Let’s see them together in the shirt for the first time, and hope for something to cheer about.</p><p><strong>Scuffed is a weekly soccer newsletter focused on the U.S. Men’s National Team, and the players who could one day make it better. The sign up page is </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-46-mls-youngs-ccl-half-triumphs-justen-gladness-and-mckennie-s-return/11014901-tinyletter.com/adambelz?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>. The Scuffed Podcast is </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-46-mls-youngs-ccl-half-triumphs-justen-gladness-and-mckennie-s-return/11014905-itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/scuffed/id1352231546?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>. Address heckling to </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-46-mls-youngs-ccl-half-triumphs-justen-gladness-and-mckennie-s-return/11014909-twitter.com/zlebmada?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>@zlebmada</strong></a><strong>, or you can respond at length by replying to this email.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4e1bd38dfe9c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Scuffed, Vol. 45: Hello Andrew Carleton! And cold weather futbol in North America]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america-b9cd8afa7a5a?source=rss-1e2a018e513a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b9cd8afa7a5a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[soccer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Belz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Apr 2018 21:36:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-17T21:36:26.047Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>published 2/28/2018…</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*BCGdhGnplb5R2AkN.jpg" /></figure><p>Andrew Carleton’s not a winger anymore.</p><p>The 17-year-old played the full 90 in a preseason tune-up on Saturday for Atlanta United against the Charleston Battery, giving us our first good look at him since the U17 World Cup in India. Whether he will get real MLS minutes in 2018, or spend most of his time with Atlanta’s USL team, has been one of the big storylines of the offseason, a microcosm of the play your kids contingent’s growing scrutiny of MLS. If Carleton is to push his way into a squad loaded with attacking talent, he needed to impress when he got a chance in preseason. On Saturday, he delivered. Lined up as the <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10935961-twitter.com/atlutd/status/967547167555637249?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">central attacking midfielder in a 4–2–3–1</a>, he was the most influential player on the pitch. I’ll get to what impressed me in more detail, but let’s start with the practical part: What did Tata Martino think?</p><p>“He is still a young player and going through a development process,” Atlanta’s Argentine head coach <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10935965-www.myajc.com/sports/atlanta-united-players-who-stood-out-against-charleston/ik2azsnej3xztsnekhefhi/?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">told the Journal-Constitution</a>. “But the way he played tonight, and the way he’s played through the whole preseason, he’s put himself closer to the first team than the USL team.”</p><p>It’s fair to say it wouldn’t be a surprise if Carleton is the first attacker off the bench for Atlanta when MLS kicks off this weekend. News broke on Wednesday that $15 million man Ezequiel Barco is out for four to six weeks with a quad strain, which makes playing time for Carleton even more likely. Fingers crossed for a start on Saturday.</p><p>For our purposes, which are to think about the future of the U.S. men’s national team, Carleton’s improving prospects are of special interest, and his performance Saturday, much like his work with the U17s in India, was revelatory. Yes, it was a preseason game. Yes, the competition was a USL club. Don’t care. I’m not backing down from being stoked by what I saw, and I’m not going to wait another several months to say so, when it’s obvious to even the casual pundit that Carleton is the real deal. His vision, quickness of thought, instincts and technique are there to see for anyone who cares to look, and what you see is an elite №10. Right now. At age 17.</p><p>Carleton came up through the U.S. setup playing on the wing a lot, but he probably doesn’t have the one-on-one speed to beat an international fullback to the end line. That’s fine. He was virtuosic in spurts as a central playmaker for the U17s in India, particularly in the 5–0 knockout round win over Paraguay (<a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10935969-twitter.com/finalthrd/status/968616519562350592?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">must-watch video here</a>). He had a hand in all five goals, including one for himself, two assists and two passes before the assist. What he showed against Charleston on Saturday, a game that ended in a scoreless draw, is that he’s ready to fill that role professionally. And that’s not because he’s flashy (which he is). He played quickly and generated rhythm with the players around him. He was assured in possession. He bought himself space on the ball, switched fields cleanly, made decisive runs, and, of course, hit passes. My oh my did he hit passes. Look at <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10935973-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/967662398680203264?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">this one</a>. Watch it a couple of times. There’s a loose ball at midfield. It bounces into Carleton’s path. In an instant he sizes up the moment and hits a one-time, outside-of-the-boot, 40-yard ball on the ground to the feet of the winger on the other side of the field, Jon Gallagher, who’s running in behind. The pass is so sudden that it beats all five defenders. I can think of only one other male American soccer player who *might* hit that pass, and his name rhymes with Beston McLennie. (Others have suggested Minnesota native Jackson Yueill at San Jose might also qualify. Maybe! Hope so.)</p><p>And Carleton’s not a one-hit wonder. Here’s <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10935977-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/967656466353139714?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">another pass</a> from Saturday, a perfectly-weighted no-looker that springs his right back into the box. In India, he <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10935981-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/967613736256196611?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">hit this bending one-time pass to cut open the Paraguayan defense</a> and create the first goal. Also in India, he chested down a loose ball running full tilt toward the sideline and <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10935985-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/968638939996176384?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">backheeled his midfield partner into space</a>, a move that led to a goal. We could go on. He’s <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10935989-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/968723218868695040?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">a goal-scorer</a>. And he hits <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10935993-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/968722479891009536?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">devastating set pieces</a>.</p><p>Carleton did flashy stuff on Saturday (I <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10935997-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/967651788596875264?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">GIF’d a bunch of his touches here</a>), including an attempted rabona nutmeg and a looping backheel flick into the box. The flash is great, I love it, it’s what Carleton’s been known for and I think if he becomes a star his flair for the game could elevate soccer’s profile in America. He was built for Sportscenter. But it was his subtle quality that shined through to me on Saturday, his instinctive feel for space and rhythm and his assuredness on the ball combined with his penetrating passes in the final third. We don’t have an attacker like that in the pool. Not even Pulisic. The last 30 minutes of Atlanta United games will be appointment viewing when he’s in the 18-man roster. He’s not going to save American soccer by himself. Our framework at Scuffed Global Headquarters has always been savior by committee. But, yeah, Carleton’s on the committee.</p><p>— — <br>Toronto F.C. went to Colorado last week and won 2–0 in both teams’ opening match of the CONCACAF Champions League (Toronto advanced on a 0–0 draw in the second leg of the matchup last night). Coming off a championship-winning 2017, Toronto again looked good in a game that was surprisingly watchable. (Other MLS teams haven’t fared so well in the opening rounds of CCL. Dallas had to dig outself out of a hole as of press time, Seattle and New York both need wins at home on Thursday to advance.)</p><p>A lot of the buzz about that first game between Toronto and Colorado was the weather. It was 12 degrees at halftime in Commerce City, Colo., an eastern suburb of Denver. Less than 3,000 fans were in attendance, all the players were chugging steam like little train engines, and piles of snow were evident in the background behind the corner flags. This was appalling to observers across the nation, some of whom presumably have never seen snow, and they took it as an opportunity to argue the U.S. should never try to align with the European calendar, which generally takes a short winter break and a long summer break.</p><p>We at Scuffed Global Headquarters are not ready to die on the hill of the European calendar, but we also find these arguments against it a little insulting to our intelligence: “Look at that snow! We can never have regular season games in February.” We live on a continent with extreme weather. Places like Chicago can be brutally cold in February and then brutally hot five months later in July. It generally snows at least once in April in Minnesota, and, sorry, snow ca happen in March across most of the continent. I don’t think MLS should play a lot of games when it could snow, but we’ve got to get accustomed to the fact that it will happen sometimes, and for it to happen marginally more than it does now would not be a tragedy. The game between Toronto and Colorado was pretty good! Not many fans, but the gameplay was even flowing at times. The thin crowd undoubtedly was due in part to the weather, but Colorado has been bad recently and weeknight CONCACAF Champions League games haven’t been a big draw anywhere. I watched Tijuana at home against CD Motagua last night and the stadium was mostly empty. It’s still sort of an obscure tournament.</p><p>I haven’t heard a good argument against splitting the MLS season in two, unequal parts: 22 matches from Aug. 1 to Dec. 24, and then another 12 matches from Feb. 15 to April 30, followed by the playoffs in May. We’d have an unbroken stretch of games leading into an unbroken playoffs in May, which is a better month than November and December to attract American sports eyeballs. February in Minnesota, Chicago, Toronto, Montreal and Boston will be a problem, particularly for fans, so the league should try to keep those five teams on the road in February. Places like New York and Philadelphia are warmer in the winter than Munich and Hamburg, so don’t bring those up please. There will be snow, sometimes, but that’s already the case. Acting like cold and snow are unthinkable is what I’m arguing against. They’re already thinkable, and increasing the risk of having to play in them marginally is not a massive price to pay.</p><p>— — <br><strong>The MLS Kids. </strong>Carleton is going to play for Atlanta this season and he’s going to be a star. Make no mistake. Tyler Adams, 19, is a nailed-on franchise player in New York. Reggie Cannon, 19, got his second start in CONCACAF Champions League on Wednesday. Jaylin Lindsey, 17, should get spot minutes at right back for Sporting KC. <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10936001-twitter.com/thegoalkeeper/status/968906747665580037?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">Looks like</a> Anthony Fontana, 18, and Auston Trusty, 19, will play for the Philadelphia Union. Also looks like Chris Durkin, 18, DC United; Chris Goslin, 17, Atlanta United; Jonathan Lewis, 20, NYCFC; James Sands, 17, NYCFC; Paxton Pomykal, 18, FC Dallas and Marco Farfan, 19, Portland Timbers will all start on the outside looking in when it comes to playing time this season. So will George Bello for Atlanta United, but he’s only 15 and I ain’t worried about him. Durkin is <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10936005-twitter.com/psoccercom/status/968707280844804096?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">reportedly attracting interest from Benfica</a> in Portugal, which is great.</p><p><strong>CCV is no ball-playing CB. </strong>One last little scouting report. Watched Cameron Carter-Vickers in a 1–0 win for Ipswich Town over Preston North End. I <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10936009-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/967861983189094405?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">GIF’d a few moments</a>. He put in a solid defensive performance, he’s a rugged dude, and I think he’ll be in the USMNT conversation going forward. But he’s not an elegant footballer. If we’re hoping for a couple of elite ball-playing centerbacks in the red, white and blue in 2022 and beyond, we’ll either have to look elsewhere, or CCV will have to develop a new facet to his game.</p><p><strong>Housekeeping. </strong>I started a podcast with my buddy, USMNT fan and coach Greg Velasquez. He’ll be the cold dash of realism to my boundless optimism. We’ll be publishing biweekly for now and our first episode is up on iTunes and most other platforms. You can subscribe <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10936013-itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/scuffed/id1352231546?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">here</a>.</p><p><strong>Scuffed is a weekly soccer newsletter focused on the U.S. Men’s National Team, and the players who could one day make it better. The sign up page is </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10936017-tinyletter.com/adambelz?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>. The Scuffed Podcast is </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10936013-itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/scuffed/id1352231546?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>. Address heckling to </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-45-hello-andrew-carleton-and-cold-weather-futbol-in-north-america/10936021-twitter.com/zlebmada?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>@zlebmada</strong></a><strong>, or you can respond at length by replying to this email.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b9cd8afa7a5a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Scuffed, Vol. 44: Carlos Cordeiro the insider-outsider, and the need to learn from Jona’s exit]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adambelz/scuffed-vol-44-carlos-cordeiro-the-insider-outsider-and-the-need-to-learn-from-jonas-exit-1e17dd5d8510?source=rss-1e2a018e513a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1e17dd5d8510</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[soccer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Belz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Apr 2018 21:29:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-17T21:29:23.481Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>published 2/15/2018…</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*uAK_yTXUU8RxTVe8.jpg" /></figure><p>Carlos Cordeiro is the new president of the U.S. Soccer Federation, and if you saw my newsletter last week, you know I’m basically pleased with the choice. Not everyone is thrilled, and there are two objections, and they go like this: 1) Cordeiro doesn’t advocate for promotion/relegation, so American soccer remains handicapped by its aberrant closed professional league, and 2) Cordeiro was Sunil Gulati’s right-hand man, and is therefore a status quo leader, culpable for the men’s World Cup qualifying failure, and unfit for the presidency.</p><p>On the first point, it’s true that Cordeiro brings no respite for the pro/rel now crowd. They will wander in the wilderness for another four years, hoping for a savior. For the record, I don’t believe they would have found salvation in Eric Wynalda. Implementing pro/rel is a bit like completely repealing the middle class mortgage interest deduction: it’s technically possible, and probably should happen, but it won’t. Not any time soon. The second objection to Cordeiro is more interesting because it seems right, but it’s not. In fact, tagging Cordeiro as an extension of Gulati is a low-energy read of the situation. Cordeiro wasn’t the status quo choice. He shrewdly outmaneuvered the status quo to ascend to power.</p><p>Major League Soccer had a sweet gig with Gulati in charge, because he was one of them. He was a deputy MLS commissioner at its founding in 1994 and his last job before he was elected president of the federation was running the New England Revolution, that most MLS 1.0 of MLS franchises. Cordeiro, in contrast, has no direct MLS background. When he started volunteering for the federation as an independent director at Gulati’s behest, he was a Goldman Sachs executive who’d been vice-chairman of Asia for the investment bank, advised Nelson Mandela’s government in South Africa, worked with European nations to prepare for a common currency in the late 1990s, and worked with the World Bank. He’d already had a full life working on big, systemic stuff. At USSF, he served as treasurer and chair of the budget committee, and then was elected vice-president in 2016, more than two years after Gulati extended Jurgen Klinsmann’s contract, and less than two years before the disaster in Trinidad.</p><p>Cordeiro worked on the unglamorous stuff at the federation, <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-44-carlos-cordeiro-the-insider-outsider-and-the-need-to-learn-from-jona-s-exit/10818005-www.ussoccer.com/stories/2018/02/10/13/58/20180210-news-new-us-soccer-president-carlos-cordeiro-elected-annual-general-meeting?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">according to USSF</a>: reforming governance and minding the books. But he also got a first-hand look at the way Gulati governed. And while he was never publicly critical of Gulati, it’s difficult to imagine he missed what others have been more candid about: Gulati’s autocratic tendency. U.S. women’s national team star Megan Rapinoe, in an <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-44-carlos-cordeiro-the-insider-outsider-and-the-need-to-learn-from-jona-s-exit/10818009-www.socceramerica.com/publications/article/76750/megan-rapinoe-on-carlos-cordeiro-sunil-gulati-us.html?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">interview with Ridge Mahoney at Soccer America</a>, said Gulati was always the one “pulling the strings” and she argued that the needs of the federation would overstretch the abilities of any one string-puller.</p><p>“I think probably the way Sunil ran it in the beginning, it probably needed to be run that way. He was a visionary and did a very good job of growing the game,” Rapinoe said. “As it became so much bigger, I don’t think one person has that much bandwidth or really has that much expertise in every single area…I don’t think one person at such a vast federation should be making all the decisions anyway. I don’t say this to knock Sunil. In many ways, he’s done a tremendous job and brought U.S. Soccer to great heights. But we need more checks and balances and we need expertise in every area. I wouldn’t know why we don’t have expertise in every area. There’s commercial interests, there’s developmental interests, there’s national team interests. So there’s a lot to consider.”</p><p>Less than a month after the USMNT crashed out of the World Cup, and before Gulati decided whether to run again, Cordeiro announced he was running for president. And he promised, in so many words, to dilute the power of the presidency and build a better decision-making bureaucracy. That may be a subtle repudiation of Gulati, but it’s a repudiation nonetheless. When Gulati announced he would not run for another term, he backed not Cordeiro but Kathy Carter, the head of Soccer United Marketing, the successful MLS-owned business that markets U.S. national team soccer and Mexican soccer on U.S. soil, among other things. Carter then received bloc support from Major League Soccer, a huge advantage in USSF elections. She got 24 percent of the total vote on the first ballot, thanks solely to MLS, USL and NWSL backing.</p><p>But Cordeiro still won. He worked the state associations, and crucially won bloc support from the Athlete Council, which gave him 20 percent of the total vote after a nine-hour meeting the day before the election. We may never know how he persuaded the athletes, but they made him president. The Pro Council switched to support Cordeiro in the third round of voting, but that does not make him beholden to the MLS owners who backed his strongest opponent to the bitter end. His support comes from the athletes and if he wants to win a second term in four years, he has to show them they made the right choice when they backed him. It’s a good accountability structure.</p><p>Cordeiro’s obviously not perfect. He’s no Winston Churchill at the dais. He <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-44-carlos-cordeiro-the-insider-outsider-and-the-need-to-learn-from-jona-s-exit/10818013-www.youtube.com/watch?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">said the USL is “arguably the best” second division in the world</a>, which is ridiculous and indicates he may not follow the game closely. But, again, he’s not promising to be the next general manager. He’s promising to build the right system to get the right advice from the board and hire the right general manager. An even higher priority is winning the 2026 World Cup bid. Cordeiro is of Portuguese and Colombian descent, immigrated from India to Miami when he was 15, went to Harvard, and spent his career working with governments in Europe and Africa and Asia. My guess is he kills it at FIFA, engenders confidence in the boardroom, and will be perfect for closing the deal on the North American World Cup bid. He already demonstrated his competence by winning the election, and there’s no reason to believe that won’t extend to his work as president. This was was a prudent choice.</p><p>— — <br>Whoever gets the job as general manager of the U.S. men’s national teams will have a lot on his or her plate, but it’s important to me that the person takes a hard look at the Jonathan Gonzalez situation and tries to learn from it. We can’t wish this one away. A good starting point would be to hear more from former youth national team coach Hugo Perez, who brought Gonzalez into the U.S. setup and gave an interview two weeks ago to <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-44-carlos-cordeiro-the-insider-outsider-and-the-need-to-learn-from-jona-s-exit/10818017-itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/uncle-sams-soccer-podcast/id1261397643?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">Uncle Sam’s Soccer Podcast (Episode 36)</a>. I just listened this week and can’t believe I haven’t heard more buzz about it.</p><p>Perez said he believes USSF coaches simply never rated Gonzalez that highly, because he doesn’t fit their mold (big, physical), and that this reflects a long-term problem in the federation. You might suspect this is just speculation from a disgruntled former employee, and I don’t know, maybe, but Perez speaks with precision about Gonzalez’s game and what U.S. Soccer coaches are looking for, and that precision makes his argument more compelling.</p><p>Gonzalez does not jump out as a world class number 6 when you first turn on the television. He’s small, he’s average in the air, and he’s still trying to figure out how to be consistently influential in possession. But you keep watching, and you realize he dominates the center of the pitch for a top two team in Liga MX at the age of 18. That’s partly because he works hard and plays within himself, but more importantly it’s because he’s smart. He sees the game unfolding, anticipates, and acts quickly when there’s a chance to take the ball or thwart an attack. Perez says he noticed Gonzalez’s soccer IQ the first time he watched him play, when the kid was 14, at a tryout.</p><p>“He was a skinny kid, not a typical physical kid, but we saw some things that I felt he could have a chance with us,” Perez said. “One was his technical ability, the other was his ability to play in two positions or three positions, and <strong>the best thing I saw in him was his tactical awareness</strong>, even at his age.” (Emphasis there is mine, obviously.)</p><p>Gonzalez excelled at the Monterrey academy and captained the U19s there a year ago as a 17-year-old. And yet he never quite settled in with one of the headline U.S. youth national teams. He was left off the U17 and U20 World Cup squads, and then he wasn’t called up for the friendly in Portugal. The idea has been floated that interim coach Dave Sarachan didn’t call Gonzalez out of respect for Monterrey in a busy part of their schedule. Perez doesn’t buy this.</p><p>“I don’t think they thought he was a player for them. Whether we like it or not, look, we have coaches in this country that prefer a certain type of player…and probably sometimes the technical part or the IQ is not as important,” Perez said. And, “if they really thought that Jonathan was going to be part of a renovation of a different football, they would have called him because they’ve known him for a long time.”</p><p>Sarachan <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-44-carlos-cordeiro-the-insider-outsider-and-the-need-to-learn-from-jona-s-exit/10818021-www.si.com/soccer/2018/01/25/jonathan-gonzalez-usa-mexico-sarachan-williams-ramos-fifa-switch?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">told Brian Straus at Sports Illustrated</a> that Gonzalez was ruled out because his team was still active, and he said Tab Ramos was in constant communication with him. My understanding from a source who has a good window into this is that Sarachan wasn’t even aware of Gonzalez, and if you read that Straus article, you do get the sense he wasn’t super clued in to the young man’s game. Which is all to say that Perez’s basic assertion — that Gonzalez wasn’t rated by USSF — is at least partially true, and may be the dominant factor here, as he claims.</p><p>Bigger picture, there is evidence to back up Perez’s claim that U.S. Soccer favors the large and athletic over the small and tactical. Tab Ramos left Gonzalez out of the U20 World Cup in favor of Derrick Jones, a useful defensive midfielder who’s 6’3”, very good in the air, and spent almost all of 2017 with the Bethlehem Steel FC in the USL. More recently, Ulysses Llanez, a technical, dangerous winger, was left off the U17 World Cup roster by John Hackworth for Ayo Akinola. Akinola is powerful and a decent finisher, but he’s not much of a footballer yet, and he was outclassed in India.</p><p>I don’t think the general manager needs to blow everything up, but we can’t just lose Jonathan Gonzalez and pretend it never happened or that it was inevitable. We’ve got to learn from this. A huge way for the incoming general manager to earn credibility would be to demonstrate familiarity with what happened, show American fans that the federation has real interest in the subject, and perhaps even publish a report about what happened. USSF has to get better connected with the Latino soccer community in this country. It might not be the first priority, but it’s up there.</p><p>— — <br>The other piece of useful institutional news is that the U.S. has officially announced three friendlies for the USMNT through June. We’ve got Paraguay in late March in Raleigh, N.C., and then Ireland and France in a two-game European swing just before the World Cup this summer. Probably after that we’ll have a general manager and a new coach and the new era will officially begin.</p><p>— — <br><strong>Christian Pulisic</strong> got his third assist of the Bundesliga season (and his second in two games) by running onto a ball from Marco Reus and <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-44-carlos-cordeiro-the-insider-outsider-and-the-need-to-learn-from-jona-s-exit/10818025-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/962351874232987648?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">zipping a pass along the ground to the back post</a>, where Michy Batshuayi slid and tapped it in. It was a pinpoint pass, whether intentional or not. I think it probably was intentional. Pulisic then <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-44-carlos-cordeiro-the-insider-outsider-and-the-need-to-learn-from-jona-s-exit/10818029-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/962354388160385024?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">botched a chance</a>, failing to steer a deflection into an open goal. The ball had taken a weird hop but it was still Wondolowski-esque. Dortmund went on to defeat bottom-dwellers Hamburg and their struggling American striker Bobby Wood. Pulisic is yet to put together a complete performance since he rampaged against Bayern in November. He still doesn’t look like he’s in rhythm, but I’m optimistic. The return of Reus means chances will be flowing for Dortmund in ways they weren’t before, and Pulisic will find himself facing destabilized defenders more often, which is his wheelhouse. Europa League starts on Thursday for Dortmund and they play at home against Atalanta, a mid-table Serie B club. Then away at Monchengladbach in the Bundesliga on Sunday. Pulisic will start one of those two matches. For Hamburg and Wood, the candle is blowing in the window. Each week is another step toward relegation. (On Thursday, Pulisic <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-44-carlos-cordeiro-the-insider-outsider-and-the-need-to-learn-from-jona-s-exit/10818033-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/964234091032965122?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">missed a golden chance</a> in front of goal and was generally ineffective in the attacking third before coming off in the 85th minute of a 3–2 win for Dortmund over Atalanta.)</p><p><strong>Weston McKennie</strong> posted a <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-44-carlos-cordeiro-the-insider-outsider-and-the-need-to-learn-from-jona-s-exit/10818037-twitter.com/s04_us/status/963213638541524992?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">video of himself wearing cleats and dancing and singing</a> on the practice field at Schalke, which seems like an encouraging sign. He’ll likely be out for another month. One day I’ll write a few paragraphs about why he should be the captain of the USMNT. Not today.</p><p>— — <br>The young British-Americans in the Championship are both acquitting themselves well of late. <strong>Cameron Carter-Vickers</strong>, 20, after being bundled out of Sheffield and shipped southeastward to Ipswich Town, has stepped directly into a starting role at centerback, played 90 minutes in each of his four appearances, and his team has conceded only two goals. <strong>Antonee Robinson</strong>, 20, continues to be a lock down left back starter for Bolton. In their last seven matches, they’ve lost only twice, Robinson has three assists, and Bolton is for now clear of the relegation zone. Staying up, after their disastrous start, would be a miraculous success. It would be a surprise if both Carter-Vickers and Robinson don’t get a call-up in the next three friendlies.</p><p><strong>Scuffed is a weekly soccer newsletter focused on the U.S. Men’s National Team, and the players who could one day make it better. The sign up page is </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-44-carlos-cordeiro-the-insider-outsider-and-the-need-to-learn-from-jona-s-exit/10818041-tinyletter.com/adambelz?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>. Address heckling to </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-44-carlos-cordeiro-the-insider-outsider-and-the-need-to-learn-from-jona-s-exit/10818045-twitter.com/zlebmada?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>@zlebmada</strong></a><strong>, or you can respond at length by replying to this email.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1e17dd5d8510" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Scuffed, Vol. 43: An argument for a boring USSF president, and ArJo’s return]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjos-return-1aaf6299565a?source=rss-1e2a018e513a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1aaf6299565a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[soccer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Belz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Apr 2018 20:34:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-17T20:34:48.967Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>published 2/6/2018…</em></p><p>The U.S. Soccer Federation will try to elect a new president on Saturday and I hope things are settled quickly so we can get on with the business of soccering. Jeff Carlisle at ESPN has a <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735481-www.espn.com/soccer/club/united-states/660/blog/post/3359068/the-voters-and-issues-that-will-decide-the-next-us-soccer-president?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">good, straightforward explanation of the voting process</a> and the issues that motivate the various voting blocs. He also published a more recent piece <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735485-www.espn.com/soccer/team/united-states/660/blog/post/3371583/your-guide-to-ussf-election-who-will-win-caliguiri-carter-cordeiro-gans-martino-solo-winograd-wynalda?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">projecting who’s most likely to win</a>.</p><p>I don’t want to lose subscribers by wading too deep into this niche election and all its weirdness, but the candidate whose victory would disappoint me the least is Carlos Cordeiro, the Portuguese-Colombian-Indian-American and Harvard alum who worked for 30 years in high finance before volunteering with U.S. Soccer in 2007. He’s a boring guy. He likes to talk about governance and committees. But I’d argue we don’t need polished television presentation from the next president. Cordeiro’s platform is all healthy, doable stuff: his first priority is to win the 2026 World Cup bid, he says he will cede national team decisions to general managers who oversee the men’s and women’s programs under the authority of a technical committee on the USSF board, he says he will create an independent board committee that handles U.S. Soccer media rights, empower the board of directors in general and, overall, dilute the hands-on power of the presidency. This last point for me is key, and it’s the sum of the other parts. I want less, not more, from the next president. Cordeiro has been clear that he wants to remold the office into more of a chairmanship and less of a dictatorship. He went public with these ideas almost immediately after he announced his candidacy, on Nov. 1. He doesn’t advocate for promotion/relegation, which hurts him with a portion of American soccer fans. My sense is we should move to pro/rel eventually, but pro/rel skeptics such as Sunil Gulati are right when they say that imposing it would result in a lawsuit in front of the U.S. Supreme Court. MLS owners who paid hundred-million-dollar expansion fees won’t hear of it. It will be deeply contentious, and I don’t want the next president biting off a full restructure of the soccer pyramid when so many other things must get done.</p><p>The real knock on Cordeiro is he’s an insider who stood by and abetted Sunil Gulati as he dominated the federation and steered the men’s national team to nowhere. Three responses to that: 1) Without doing any actual reporting, I’d guess Cordeiro didn’t have much personal leverage in the federation. He was high up, but he was a distant second or third in the court of Gulati. 2) It’s not clear to me that massive problems were apparent before the disaster in Trinidad. We all thought things would be fine, and I presume so did Cordeiro. What should he have spoken up about before October? I don’t know. 3) Insider status, for me, is not entirely negative, nor is the fact that he was a Goldman Sachs executive. The former means he understands how the federation works, the latter means he’s smart and competent. Combine those with a stated desire to reform federation governance and take a back seat to the experts on coach hiring, and you have an indication of the type of boring competence that I’d like to see. Meanwhile, he is willing to question the U.S. Soccer television rights marriage with Soccer United Marketing, and he quickly announced his run for the presidency before Gulati decided to step away. These suggest Cordeiro is willing, and able, to interrogate the established order.</p><p>The other candidates? Eric Wynalda and Kyle Martino both have qualities that recommend them, but neither projects bureaucratic credibility. Sorry, but that’s important! The problems that need fixing are big and complicated, and require sophisticated leadership that understands how to reshape systems. Kathy Carter, on the other hand, projects too much of the bureaucracy, is besmirched by the endorsements of Don Garber and Gulati, and doesn’t seem to have vigorous, forthcoming ideas. The other candidates are not in serious contention for the job.</p><p>I think American soccer will be fine whoever is elected. It’ll continue on its trajectory of gradual progress, and the men’s national team (which is this newsletter’s primary interest) will be better in three years than it is now, because the 18-year-olds are better than the 25-year-olds. Mostly, I just want this election settled so we can move forward. That’s my vote: Settle it. Move forward.</p><p>— — <br>As if the pit in our collective stomach couldn’t get any pittier, <strong>Jonathan González</strong> keeps getting better at soccer. He’s evolving more and more into a midfield metronome for Monterrey, which blew Landon Donovan’s new club Léon away by a score of 5–1 on Saturday (Donovan’s still getting fit, wasn’t in the matchday squad). González also played out of position in his 35-minute debut for the Mexican national team against Bosnia &amp; Herzegovina in San Antonio. It’s painful to watch as an American, but you can <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735489-www.youtube.com/watch?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">see a video of his touches here</a>. Given his propensity last fall to skittishness on the ball in traffic, I was skeptical that he could handle an advanced midfield role. My skepticism was refuted. He looked calm and incisive, a testament to his intelligence and growing confidence. His off-ball movement, in possession and defending, is remarkably alert, thoughtful and decisive. He is the smartest American under 20 — cleverer at finding harmony with his teammates than Pulisic, more defensively reliable than McKennie, more polished than Tyler Adams. Shame. Shame. Shame. Some will say I should quit talking about González, since he’s now a Mexican international and has nothing to do with the U.S. men’s national team. I can’t quit. He’s an American. He’s been one of my favorite players for the past six months. I’m not going to stop being interested in him. And I have a feeling U.S. Soccer’s failure to keep him in the fold will be thrust in our faces for years to come, so, let’s face it voluntarily. González did nothing to dissuade Juan Carlos Osorio from calling him up for the next round of friendlies in March. If he performs well then, he’ll be playing in Russia. He turns 19 in April. Worth remembering that he was left off the U.S. U20 World Cup team last May in favor of Derrick Jones, who played fine there but spent most of the year in the USL. Hindsight is 20/20. Eight months later, González is more accomplished than anyone on that roster — Adams, Jones, Josh Sargent, Erik Palmer-Brown, Cameron Carter-Vickers, Justen Glad. Anyone. Amazing, devastating story.</p><p>— — <br>It was a mostly good week for Yanks abroad, and I’ll tick off a few of the highlights:</p><p>Oft-injured Werder Bremen striker <strong>Aron Jóhannsson</strong>, 27, was an impact substitute for his side in a huge 2–1 win over Schalke (Weston McKennie remains sidelined for at least another month). Jóhannsson was credited with the assist on the first goal in the 79th minute (it was an accidental deflection) and <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735493-twitter.com/foxsoccer/status/959825828241539073?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">played a lovely chipped ball to beat the back line</a> to help set up the game-winning goal in stoppage time. It was easily his best performance of the season, earning him a start in the DFB Pokal quarterfinals on Tuesday against Bayer Leverkusen. He scored, in the 7th minute, <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735497-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/960968099234308096?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">chipping the helpless goalkeeper on the counterattack</a> to make it 2–0. Jóhannsson came off at halftime and Werder lost 3–2 in extra time. He might be making a comeback! Prior to Saturday, he’d played 12 first-team minutes this season in all competitions. Since Saturday he’s played 80 minutes. The goal Tuesday was his first since Sept. 11, 2016.</p><p>Center back <strong>Matt Miazga</strong>, 22, <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735501-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/959539266891153410?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">thumped home a header</a> for the opening goal in a 2–0 win for Vitesse over Groningen, and is solidifying his case as an automatic inclusion on any USMNT roster henceforth. He’s a real aerial threat on set pieces. Two goals with his noggin for Vitesse now. One for the U.S. in two appearances last year.</p><p><strong>Cameron Carter-Vickers</strong>, 20, still isn’t a polished center back, and may never be, but he’s settled in nicely on loan at Ipswich Town after a poor run of form and a jump into the escape pod out of Sheffield United. Ipswich defeated Sunderland 2–0 on Saturday. CCV has stepped right into a starting role in a 4-man back line and went 90 as his side shut out the Championship bottom-dwellers.</p><p>Left back <strong>Antonee Robinson</strong>, 20, got an assist in a crucial 1–0 win for Bolton over Bristol City. It wasn’t a killer final ball, <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735505-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/959545498796482560?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">as you can see</a>, but it still counts as an assist and it was a cheeky little clearance to spring Sammy Ameobi’s heroic solo run and wonder strike. Robinson now has four assists in all competitions, twice as many as Christian Pulisic. Bolton is out of the relegation zone and seem a good bet to stay up with Robinson playing a crucial role. He’ll be back with Everton this summer.</p><p>Midfielder <strong>Keaton Parks</strong>, 20, who’s appeared exclusively with Benfica B over the past couple of weeks, <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735509-streamable.com/f2j9m?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">got a headed goal</a> in a 3–1 win over his old club, Varzim. He’s been dominant for the reserve squad. Next step for Parks is regular first team minutes, and it’s hard to say when those might materialize. Porto, Benfica and Sporting are competing for the two Champions League spots from Portugal and it looks like it’ll go down to the wire for the second spot, unless one of the three teams implodes. So Benfica is in a dog fight, won’t be experimenting much, and Parks would have to take a huge step forward to get consistent first team minutes. I’m guessing he’ll be on the outside looking in until the summer.</p><p>Striker <strong>Bobby Wood</strong>, 25, was lively and in a lot of the right spots for Hamburg in a 1–1 draw with Hannover, but he went 0–3 finishing his best chances. <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735513-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/960204782139998209?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">I cut GIFs</a>. Not great, particularly the scuffed shot on the second chance, but getting on the end of clear cut opportunities is a step in the right direction for the struggling goalscorer. And he went 90 minutes, and Hamburg didn’t lose. Also encouraging.</p><p>Winger <strong>Christian Pulisic</strong>, 19, despite putting in another uninspiring performance on the wing, <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735517-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/959541695011540995?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">got an assist</a> in a 3–2 win for Dortmund over Köln. His game intelligence and ability to combine with teammates continue to leave something to be desired. But his quickness, split-second instincts and technique are unassailable. All three were on display when he set up that goal.</p><p>Meanwhile, <strong>Erik Palmer-Brown</strong>, 20, is officially with the Belgian top-flight club K.V. Kortrijk now. The center back is a darling of the fanbase after he put in some good shifts with the U20s in the World Cup, but he found playing time hard to come by at Sporting K.C., signed with Manchester City and was in apparent limbo for the past few months. His move to Belgium happened in the last days of the transfer window, and he comes into a team with two center backs getting up in years and one who usually plays right back. He should get playing time. Seems like a good loan. Hopefully he gets on a gameday roster before mid-February.</p><p>— — <br>MLS is less than a month away and we at Scuffed Global Headquarters have made no secret of our excitement about the return of domestic soccer. Our powers of Googling, GIF-making and pontification are directed squarely at teenagers looking to earn serious first-team minutes. The MLS has been historically bad at playing youngsters, but hope springs eternal:</p><p>Winger <strong>Gianluca Busio</strong>, 15, has been playing with the second choice squad for Sporting K.C., and scored a goal in a friendly last week. A lot of these friendlies are played in three parts, with full line changes at the end of each period. There’s no footage out there, and who knows if the hierarchy of the friendly lineups means anything, but it seems like a good sign that Busio is included in the second period. If he gets any first-team minutes at all in 2018, it’ll be a coup and a sign of fantastic things to come.</p><p>Midfielder <strong>Gilbert Fuentes</strong>, 15, is having the same type of preseason as Busio, except for the San Jose Earthquakes. I <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735521-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/958793580595810304?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">GIF’d some of his moments</a> in an early friendly against Portland. He was a standout for the U17s in the Nike Friendlies in December, and he’s smooth, technical and creative in the center of the park. Just like with Busio, any first-team minutes for him would be a cause for celebration. I don’t count on it in either case.</p><p>Left back <strong>Marco Farfan</strong>, 19, played 403 MLS minutes for Portland last season, but injury derailed his season and he only saw the field for 3 minutes after July 1. He looks like he’ll be again challenging for playing time in 2018, and put in a good performance in a friendly against Seattle on Saturday. I <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735525-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/960201976649797632?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">GIF’d some of his moments</a>. My favorite is the sequence where he bodies Jordan Morris off a through ball and prevents him from taking a shot. Good defending. He’s also clean on the ball and a thougtful passer. Seems to lack game-breaking pace, but let’s keep our eye on him.</p><p><strong>Housekeeping:</strong> <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735529-twitter.com/donttreadsoccer?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">@DontTreadSoccer</a> and I have another podcast out, <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735533-soundcloud.com/thisamericansoccer/vol-2-bosnia-post-mortem-wingers-mls-evolution?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">our second</a>. Production value is improving. We go deep on the U.S.-Bosnia friendly, wingers, and a changing MLS. And I appeared on the <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735537-www.mplscitysc.com/podcast/2018/1/31/ep-69ha?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">Minneapolis City SC podcast</a> with my amateur soccer teammate and harsh critic of Minnesota United’s front office, Jon Bisswurm.</p><p>The next big milestone is the March friendlies, which, um, still haven’t been announced. Yikes. Hopefully the USSF can schedule some games.</p><p><strong>Scuffed is a weekly soccer newsletter focused on the U.S. Men’s National Team, and the players who could one day make it better. The sign up page is </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735541-tinyletter.com/adambelz?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>. Address heckling to </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-43-an-argument-for-a-boring-ussf-president-and-arjo-s-return/10735545-twitter.com/zlebmada?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>@zlebmada</strong></a><strong>, or you can respond at length by replying to this email.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1aaf6299565a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Scuffed, Vol. 42: Dave Sarachan is a knucklehead, but positive change is afoot in MLS]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adambelz/scuffed-vol-42-dave-sarachan-is-a-knucklehead-but-positive-change-is-afoot-in-mls-cd9154f9e137?source=rss-1e2a018e513a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cd9154f9e137</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[soccer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Belz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Apr 2018 20:33:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-17T20:33:32.634Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>published 1/29/2018…</em></p><p>I’ll start with the caveat that I don’t have inside knowledge into what happened over the past three weeks in January camp. It could be there are wide gaps between the players who played on Sunday and those who didn’t. It could be that in training Gyasi Zardes worked far harder than Christian Ramirez, or that Justin Morrow outclassed Danny Acosta, or that Jordan Morris outplayed Kelyn Rowe. Could be. But let’s face it: Dave Sarachan is a knucklehead.</p><p>In a friendly against a B-minus Bosnia and Herzegovina squad, a chance to experiment and test young American players, the interim U.S. men’s national team manager started an old hand winger who hasn’t demonstrated international quality for at least a year (Zardes), a 30-year-old left back who couldn’t crack the XI in World Cup qualifying when we had no good left backs (Morrow), and a striker who scored only three goals for his club in 2017 before a season-ending injury (Morris).</p><p>The results were a crime against television. The U.S. had the attacking vitality of deflated balloon in a life-destroying 0–0 draw, though the addition of Rowe at halftime helped. The result would have been palatable if the meaningless match had been played with an eye for the future. But Sarachan left the uncapped Ramirez (who scored 14 goals in 2017), Acosta (the youngest promising professional left back in the U.S. pipeline) and Justen Glad (an MVP-level MLS center back at age 20) off the roster. They weren’t even on the bench. Yak.</p><p>The former Bruce Arena assistant coach is either deliberately trolling us or he’s a slow-witted fellow. Maybe both. I’ve had enough. I hear the American Outlaws in the half-empty stadium had enough too. This presidential election, the hiring of a technical director and the hiring of a real coach can’t come soon enough.</p><p>And yet, we must glean something. We at Scuffed Global Headquarters watched. We shall analyze and respond.</p><p><strong>Kelyn Rowe was our man of the match.</strong> He came on at halftime and had a direct hand in two of our best chances. I <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-42-dave-sarachan-is-a-knucklehead-but-positive-change-is-afoot-in-mls/10652765-twitter.com/zlebmada/status/957854050619453440?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">GIF’d them here</a>. The one-touch volley to Morris, subsequently squandered, was the classiest moment of the night. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not trying to say the 26-year-old attacker/fullback is some kind of hibernating international superstar. He’s not. But he’s a creative attacking player who produces goal-scoring chances. His decisions are fast, technical and incisive. We have only one other established player in the pool like that, and his name is Pulisic. I wanted Rowe slotted in as the 10 in a three-man midfield for this match, and like everything else I wanted other than starts for Ike Opara and Tyler Adams, it didn’t happen. Hopefully Rowe can find a defined role for the New England Revolution under new coach Brad Friedel, find a good run of form and stay in the national team conversation. Every time he plays I like what I see. He’s a different kind of player than Paul Arriola, but for me he’s surpassed him in the depth chart.</p><p><strong>Ike Opara is a solid depth option at center back. </strong>He’s almost 29, historically injury-prone, and well behind John Brooks, Matt Miazga and Geoff Cameron in the depth chart, but Opara was a rock in the back (good in the air, alert to danger and relatively assured on the ball) and he earned further consideration with the USMNT over the next two or three years.</p><p><strong>Tyler Adams still hasn’t convinced me he’s an international-level box-to-box midfielder.</strong> The kid is a dynamo and he deserves a call-up heretofore if only for his energy and versatility, but as I’ve said before, he doesn’t yet have the first touch in traffic, strength on the ball, off-ball fluidity or speed of thought to be an influential No. 8. He is, for instance, well behind Weston McKennie in these respects. He looked better on Sunday when he dropped into more of a defensive midfield role, and maybe that’s the solution. The other solution, the one I suspect makes the most long-term sense, is for him to push and displace DeAndre Yedlin at right back. Adams has demonstrated repeatedly that he can own and dominate a flank. I don’t mind continued exploration at central midfield for him, but if we want a good national team, we need technical, ambitious, tough, intelligent players at fullback too. Adams is all of those things and a proven elite on the flank.</p><p><strong>The goalkeepers are in a holding pattern.</strong> Bill Hamid and Zack Steffen weren’t tested too much, though Hamid had a nice save. Absent behind-the-scenes revelations, the goalkeeper situation is unchanged. Some combination of Hamid, Steffen, Brad Guzan, Jesse Gonzalez and Ethan Horvath are the top five.</p><p><strong>Lots of players did nothing to improve their stock but should stick around.</strong> Matt Polster, C.J. Sapong, Walker Zimmerman, Wil Trapp and Cristian Roldan will remain fringe national team players. Polster was productive on the ball, bad at defending. Sapong worked hard but couldn’t find the flow of the game (not necessarily his fault). Zimmerman had good moments (a few key line-breaking passes), and very bad ones (the whiff on the cross in the first half and the penalty in the second). Trapp’s been getting a lot of praise for his performance, but I didn’t see anything defining from him. Roldan worked hard but couldn’t settle in and looked a bit out of his depth, as he did at the Gold Cup. Paul Arriola remains something close to a first-choice winger because he works so hard and there’s nobody else who plays the wing well except Pulisic. Arriola did a lot of fruitless crossing on Sunday, which is his custom. All these gentlemen could flourish under a real coach in a real system, but they haven’t flourished yet.</p><p><strong>Several players need to take a break from the national team.</strong> Gyasi Zardes was awful and there’s no reason he should get another cap unless he becomes a dominant MLS player for Columbus. Justin Morrow got worked on the left flank and offered little going forward. He’s 30. Enough already. Jordan Morris isn’t good enough to be an international striker. Sorry. Juan Agudelo had a nice moment or two, but he went 0–3 dribbling and completed two forward passes in the opponent’s half. He looked overwhelmed by the complexity of the game.</p><p>To sum up, if we were picking a 23-man roster for a round of World Cup qualifying tomorrow, only Adams, Rowe, Arriola and Opara would get a sniff, and I’d probably only take the first three.</p><p>Next.</p><p>— — <br>You wouldn’t know it from watching the friendly on Sunday, but there’s good energy in American soccer right now. I’m talking about MLS, and not the Miami expansion announcement.</p><p>The league is evolving. A dramatic influx of young South American talent and the gradual relaxation of transfer regulations give the strong appearance that Major League Soccer is ready to embrace its natural role in the global market: that of a selling league.</p><p>The $15 million Atlanta United paid for 18-year-old Argentine attacker Ezequiel Barco was the largest transfer ever, hailed as the next step in the league’s evolution. But the team already had Miguel Almiron and Tito Villalba, and the South American youth invasion is on. Several clubs are signing players around 20 years old from Uruguay, Argentina, Paraguay, Venezuela and Colombia. In fact, MLS teams have <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-42-dave-sarachan-is-a-knucklehead-but-positive-change-is-afoot-in-mls/10652769-twitter.com/mattdoyle76/status/956655670970888192?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">signed 15 players from overseas who are under 21 this winter</a>, including five teenagers. This is great for the league, and long-term, great news for the U.S. Men’s National Team. Bear with me.</p><p>It raises the level of play, making MLS more exciting and improving the soccer, which should make the league more popular here and abroad. We’ll deepen our ties with some of the world’s great soccer nations, absorb expertise, share it, recycle it, expand upon it. In short, as the market opens further, America will do what America does best. And contrary to what some would argue, I believe the competition is good for young Americans. Take the case of Andrew Carleton. I’m on record arguing he’s the highest-potential creative player in the American pool. If he can translate his creativity into consistent excellence versus grown men, he’ll be a national team regular and probably a star. He is 17 and has the opportunity to earn minutes at Atlanta United this season. If he must do so by competing with elite talent from Paraguay and Argentina, the job will be more difficult, but it will be preparation for a career of constant competition. Christian Pulisic had to battle with elite young talent for playing time at age 17. For Carleton to have to do it on American soil is a new and useful paradigm, and training with Barco and Almiron will make Carleton better. As <a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-42-dave-sarachan-is-a-knucklehead-but-positive-change-is-afoot-in-mls/10652773-twitter.com/dirtysouthsoc/status/955554492015173632?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721">Tata Martino said</a>, “Carleton *could earn* minutes” with the first team. He might not, but the ball’s in his court. Iron sharpens iron. You know the drill.</p><p>More important than all that is the growing likelihood that MLS will become a global stopping off point for talent. Miguel Almiron has made no secret of his desire to play in Europe, and if Atlanta can sell him at a profit this year, that’ll be a watershed moment. He was an expensive signing to begin with, but when MLS owners see that they can buy and sell higher, one can only assume that player development will become a bigger part of the MLS franchise model. The league has already changed the rules so that teams get to keep 100 percent of the transfer fee for players signed to Homegrown contracts, a major shift that sweetens the deal for teams thinking of selling young Americans. And while the rules for how teams can spend transfer revenue are still far from perfect, they’re getting better. It’s too complicated to get into in detail here, but selling players abroad has been unattractive for MLS teams because, per league rules aimed at enforcing parity, they can only use a little bit of the transfer revenue to replace that player. That meant that selling good players made no sense from a sporting perspective. Suffice it to say the cap on how much transfer revenue a team can use on the roster is gradually rising, slowly chipping away at that disincentive.</p><p>Montreal sold Homegrown youngster Ballou Jean-Yves Tabla to Barcelona last week for an undisclosed fee. New York City F.C. attacker Jack Harrison wants to go to the Premier League and a deal may yet happen before the transfer window closes this week. The big one, though, will be Almiron. If he performs this season the way he did last season, he will remain an attractive transfer target for clubs in Europe, and his exit would set a precedent for Barco to go to Europe as well. Then, you’d think, it would click for MLS owners that playing in the global soccer talent market can be fruitful. And then, you’d also think, the incentive for playing young talent with the hope of selling them will lead to more young Americans seeing a pathway to the first team in MLS. This is an optimistic case and I’m sure I’ved missing something, but if this happens, then we’re emphatically on the right track in a way that substantially improves American soccer.</p><p><strong>Scuffed is a weekly soccer newsletter focused on the U.S. Men’s National Team, and the players who could one day make it better. The sign up page is </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-42-dave-sarachan-is-a-knucklehead-but-positive-change-is-afoot-in-mls/10652777-tinyletter.com/adambelz?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>. Address heckling to </strong><a href="http://mail01.tinyletterapp.com/adambelz/scuffed-vol-42-dave-sarachan-is-a-knucklehead-but-positive-change-is-afoot-in-mls/10652781-twitter.com/zlebmada?c=3822d0ad-5365-47f0-b0db-2cb08758b721"><strong>@zlebmada</strong></a><strong>, or you can respond at length by replying to this email.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cd9154f9e137" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>