<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Adam Scott Kunz on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Adam Scott Kunz on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@adamscottkunz?source=rss-b9c3824b1dfa------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 15:22:55 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@adamscottkunz/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Show for the Shelf]]></title>
            <link>https://adamscottkunz.medium.com/a-show-for-the-shelf-24da7e260663?source=rss-b9c3824b1dfa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/24da7e260663</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mormon-church]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mormonism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mormon]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hulu]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Scott Kunz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 24 Jul 2022 18:48:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-24T21:26:23.151Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sC_XEzuJ3clxhjyZ6cPUVg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Andrew Garfield as Jeb Pyre in Hulu’s Under the Banner of Heaven</figcaption></figure><p>The main focus of <a href="https://www.hulu.com/series/under-the-banner-of-heaven-9c4ae394-e9c4-4a6d-985e-314270602c6b">Hulu’s <em>Under the Banner of Heaven</em></a> is the story of the zealotry of a fundamentalist Mormon family, the murder of a faithful mainstream Mormon woman and her infant, and the subsequent investigation by a Mormon detective, Jeb Pyre (played by Andrew Garfield), who slowly loses his faith as a result of the case. Along the way, the series depicts various ancillary characters who either aid the main antagonists, Dan and Ron Lafferty, in their descent into violence, or actively resist them. One of the characters, Bernard Brady (played by Nicholas Carella), is an active, mainstream Mormon who connects with the Laffertys through a scripture study book club of sorts. Brady has a front-row seat to the radicalizing of Dan and Ron, and he later serves as an important — if not reluctant — informant for Pyre. Brady fills the role of the dedicated Mormon — hard-working, tithe-paying, commandment-following — whose academic sympathies with the Lafferty brothers put him in the wrong place at the wrong time. Brady is depicted as somewhat of a coward, terrified of what his wife, community, and church will think of him if his connection to the Laffertys comes out. In nearly every scene, Carella plays him as a pleading, self-serving character who can’t possibly understand how things could have gone so wrong so quickly. In their first meeting, Brady presents Pyre with a notarized letter addressed to himself, attempting to absolve himself of any knowledge or connection with the Laffertys. Later, he tells Pyre, speaking of the time he spent with the Laffertys, “Look, it must be tough to picture now, with your officers up their yanking floorboards, but I’m telling ya, whenever the school came here, I was met with a positive spirit.” Brady just can’t understand how a religion he believed in could lead to the cruel radicalization at the heart of the case. Reading <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/06/under-the-banner-of-heaven-hulu-mormonism/661279/">McKay Coppins’ recent review of the series</a>, I couldn’t help but feel that I was reading the words of a Bernard Brady come to life.</p><p>Coppins and I share a similar background. We were both raised in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (aka the Mormons). We grew up during the 90s and came of age in the 2000s, during a time of unprecedented growth in the Mormon church and favorable publicity. We both attended Mormon universities. We both served Mormon missions in the “Bible Belt” and faced the hatred of closed-minded so-called Christians, who were convinced we were peddling Satan’s lies. We both have lived in large, diverse, and progressive metropolitan areas while trying to defend our faith and be an example to our neighbors of how good Mormons can be.</p><p>But Coppins and I are different in two respects. First, while he grew up in Massachusetts, about as far away as one can get from the Mormon corridor and still be in the United States, I grew up on the Utah/Idaho border in the heart of Mormondom and in a small town that was literally built by my Mormon pioneer ancestors (on Native land, by the way). Having spent much of my adult life living in progressive parts of the country and congregating with Mormons who live in those communities, I can hazard a guess that Coppins’ childhood experience in the church was markedly different from my own. My family ties to Mormonism go back at least four generations on every side (Shadrach Roundy, one of Joseph Smith’s bodyguards, is one of them on my mother’s side). My father’s family left Switzerland and Denmark in the 1870s with the express purpose of coming to America “to build Zion” in the Rocky Mountains. Nearly every person I knew growing up was Mormon. Every teacher and adult mentor was Mormon. Every woman I dated was Mormon. I married my wife, Emily, in the Salt Lake City Temple, where we were “sealed” together for eternity. I attended church, served in teaching and leadership roles, paid tithing, followed dietary restrictions, rose through the levels of priesthood, participated in and officiated temple ceremonies, and had every intention of raising a Mormon family. Whatever can be said of me now, there is simply no denying: I gave everything to Mormonism. While Coppins might have benefited from living in a community of diverse ideas and multicultural values, I did not.</p><p>Second, while Coppins still identifies as a temple-recommend carrying Mormon, I do not. Starting in 2015, the scaffolding that had been my worldview slowly and painfully came crashing down around me. As I learned more about what my religion <em>really</em> was, everything I had thought was true flipped upside down. After multiple brutal years of soul searching and research, I can thankfully say that I am on the back end of that faith crisis. I assume, from reading Coppins’ various articles, including his recent review, that he has no framework for that kind of experience.</p><p>Both of these facts likely explain the position Coppins takes in his review. The average non-Mormon probably will read his piece, take it as a statement by a believing Mormon who just didn’t like a show about his faith, and move on. But many believing Mormons read his piece as championing their own view; a quick visit to Mormon social media reveals how many have rallied around Coppins’ banner. Mormon history is replete with examples of misunderstandings and violence with neighboring communities, which has instilled in the average Mormon the notion that “They” are out to get “Us.” Coppins’ review, rife with a persecution complex, plays right into that narrative. But not so for those of us in the ExMormon community — an ever-enlarging community as <a href="https://newsroom.churchofjesuschrist.org/article/2021-statistical-report-april-2022-conference">the church’s growth rate continues to decline</a>. For the average ExMo, this review was typical gaslighting. In a Bernard Brady way, Coppins’ review pleads, hands outstretched, “How could this possibly be? Why must they tell such lies about us?”</p><p>To be fair, <em>Under the Banner of Heaven</em> is rife with problems. Some of them are minor: Mormons don’t avoid French fries or chocolate. No Mormon woman has to petition the church leadership, colloquially “the Brethren,” for a divorce (though she would certainly have to if she wanted to have her sealing annulled). Mormons don’t use the phrase “Heavenly Father” <em>ad nauseam</em>. And after three decades of church membership, I can honestly say I never witnessed anyone being pressured to baptize their child at the exact moment they turned eight.</p><p>Other problems are major: The insinuation that individuals close to Joseph Smith aided and abetted his execution is ridiculous. The implication that it was not Smith but Brigham Young who pushed for polygamy is a tired and successfully debunked claim — one that tries to absolve Smith of the decades of female subjugation that followed his death. The role of his wife, Emma, in the subsequent leadership schism is a matter of debate. And the depiction of the temple rituals is outdated and incomplete; the gruesome, self-inflicted penalties are no longer a part of the ritual (though their disappearance coincides with the Lafferty debacle). Coppins is right to point out that the series has its problems — an artistic decision that unfortunately does nothing more than play into the persecution narrative. For me, these errors reinforce the strong belief in the ExMo community that Mormonism deserves a full-blown documentary depicting it in its truest light: the good, the bad, and the very ugly.</p><p>But in his effort to dismiss the series, Coppins ignores the many, many truths conveyed by it. Once again, some of these are minor. Mormonism has a strain of anti-government, “stay out of my business” mentality that helps explain the political beliefs of many of its western-States members (Mormons literally left the United States to practice their doctrine without US law getting in the way). Mormons — at least those not in places like Massachusetts — really are surrounded by other Mormons who are very much involved in their private lives. Doubting Mormons have, for generations, been told to put their questions “on the shelf” and focus on other things, just as Pyre is instructed by his church leaders. And Mormons do very much defer to their leaders on matters of family planning, personal and business relationships, and individual decision-making. The series is very accurate on these minor points.</p><p>But some of these truths are also major. For instance, take every Mormon’s desire to protect the church at all costs. I can bear witness — because I once participated in it — that Mormons will do what they can to prevent the church from looking bad, even going so far as a cover-up (see, <em>e.g.</em>, the cover-up of <a href="https://www.cbsnews.com/news/mormon-church-sued-for-allegedly-covering-up-boy-scouts-sex-abuse-in-arizona/">sexual abuse of underage boys by Boy Scout leaders</a>). Every Mormon community can tell a story of Mormon leaders quietly intervening in a crisis to avoid bad press when the culprits’ Mormon background comes to light. In fact, in a stroke of irony, Coppins’ review fulfills the prophecy of the series by prioritizing the defense of the church over the many victims of Mormonism.</p><p>Or take the Mormon church’s heavy-handed approach to dissent. The church has excommunicated or retaliated against dissenters repeatedly for no other reason than that they have criticized Mormonism: from <a href="https://missedinsunday.com/memes/other/destroy-the-press/">the burning of the <em>Nauvoo Expositor</em> almost 200 years ago</a> to <a href="https://archive.sltrib.com/article.php?id=58060420&amp;itype=CMSID">the excommunication of six BYU professors</a> (an effort personally overseen by then-Mormon leader Boyd Packer) to <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2014/06/12/us/two-activists-within-mormon-church-threatened-with-excommunication.html">the recent excommunication of pro-LGBTQ and feminist critics</a>. Mormon history is replete with many of these examples. When the series shows Mormon leaders threatening Pyre and others with ostracization or reminding them of their “covenants,” that is very, very real.</p><p>Even more so, the series very accurately depicts the belief among Mormons that their leaders are prophetic and infallible speakers on behalf of god. Starting with Joseph Smith and continuing to the present day, the president of the Mormon church is sustained by the membership as a “prophet, seer, and revelator” — meaning that the buck stops with the man (and it must be a man) who occupies that office. As a mundane example, the current president, Russell Nelson, has instructed members to stop using the term “Mormon” to refer to themselves, <a href="https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/general-conference/1990/04/thus-shall-my-church-be-called?lang=eng">a tired hill that Nelson has died on since at least the 1990s</a>. Mormons called themselves Mormon before Nelson assumed office and will do so again once he leaves office (read: dies) for the simple reason that things like language are dictated from the pulpit. For a much less mundane example, refer to the 2015 “revelation” that <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/acts-of-faith/wp/2015/11/05/mormon-church-to-exclude-children-of-same-sex-couples-from-getting-blessed-and-baptized-until-they-are-18/">children of gay Mormons are not allowed to be blessed or baptized until they are 18</a> — and the 2019 <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/04/us/lds-church-lgbt.html">subsequent “revelation” to reverse that policy</a>. There are many such examples: polygamy is the law until it isn’t, Black people are cursed until they aren’t, and on and on. The Mormon god has a hard time making up his mind (and, yes, he is a man).</p><p>The series does an excellent job showing this and other realities: the second-class treatment of women, the isolation of being Mormon, the thin line between mainstream and fundamentalist Mormon, and the messy and, at times, bloody history of Mormonism. Look beyond the poor dialogue or the range of acting talent (and Sam Worthington’s really awful attempt at an American, Utah accent), and you will find plenty of truth about Mormonism.</p><p>But Coppins did what many members of the Mormon church do when the microscope is directed at Mormonism: to immediately think only of themselves. Coppins was focused on how this one series damaged him and his religion. How could this be about anything but him? But many of us in the ExMo community celebrated that there was finally a story about us. Rather than being about Mormons and their beliefs, <em>Under the Banner of Heaven</em> is the story of one Mormon man’s struggle to reconcile his morality with the realities of the church he has been a member of his entire life. It isn’t about the Laffertys or the Mormon leaders or the history of Mormonism. It’s not a documentary about an American religion. It is the story of a human at the edge of faith. The moment when Pyre sobs alone in his car in the middle of the night is a moment experienced by every person who has left the Mormon church. Watching Garfield depict that moment, I felt seen in a way that I do not feel when the public debates with Mormons. I recalled my own moment of crying alone in a hotel room, wondering where my god had gone. It doesn’t shock me that Coppins and his Mormon retweeters were too busy thinking about themselves to see that there were other people in the room.</p><p>Above all, though, Coppins claims that Mormonism has had a long history of being depicted as a threat to the American project and that the Hulu series reinforces that narrative. Coppins rejects that notion and laments, “Why can’t they see how far we’ve come?” As a political theorist and constitutional law professor, I can’t help but laugh at this reaction. Mormonism, like other dogmatic religions, has carved out for itself special exemptions from public law. Religions have fought tooth and nail to avoid the burdens of citizenship, from taxation to public accountability. Mormonism has been in the front row of that effort. Meanwhile, these same religions claim the right to pressure and manipulate the political process to impose their beliefs and morality on others. From <a href="https://newsroom.churchofjesuschrist.org/article/california-and-same-sex-marriage">the Mormon church’s influence in passing California’s Proposition 8</a> to the church’s amicus briefs before the Supreme Court in <a href="https://newsroom.churchofjesuschrist.org/multimedia/file/brief-of-major-rel-orgs-as-amici-curaiae-marriage-april-2015-pdf"><em>Obergefell</em></a> and <a href="https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/17/17-1618/113408/20190823135252781_Bostock%20Amicus%20Brief%20Final%20Version%20CORRECTED.pdf"><em>Bostock</em></a>, the religion has been more than willing to use its outsized power to weigh in on matters of public opinion. In this, the Mormon church is certainly not unique (though, unlike many other faiths, <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/mormon-church-has-misled-members-on-100-billion-tax-exempt-investment-fund-whistleblower-alleges/2019/12/16/e3619bd2-2004-11ea-86f3-3b5019d451db_story.html">it sits on hundreds of billions of untaxed dollars</a>).</p><p>But claiming that Mormonism poses absolutely no threat to building a pluralistic, liberal egalitarian political system is demonstrably false. At its heart, Mormonism teaches that in matters of conflict between law and faith, faith always wins. Prophets trump presidents. And rather than give its adherents the resources to express their autonomy, learn about critiques of Mormonism, and leave without fanfare, the Mormon church claims the right to excommunicate, harass, and ostracize dissenters. <em>That</em> thinking — whether in Mormonism or Christianity or Islam or any other faith — is most definitely a threat to the American project, regardless of what Coppins may claim. The fact that Mormons uniquely believe that they have the “fullness” of the truth directly from someone in Salt Lake City who speaks to god should be all the more sobering.</p><p>Moreover, what Coppins fails to acknowledge in his review is that insofar as Mormonism <em>has </em>become more liberalized since its inception, it has done so <em>despite</em> its own doctrine. The average mainstream Mormon is not going to go on a murderous, delusional rampage; on that point, I will stand firmly beside Coppins. But that same Mormon doesn’t have to dig too deeply into Mormon doctrine <a href="https://www.exmormon.org/d6/drupal/bloodatn">to find grounds for doing so</a>. Mormonism has grown less extreme over the last two centuries by rejecting its own foundations and importing morality and values from external sources. Faced with adhering to fundamentalist views versus accepting modern, rational values, Mormon leaders have slowly embraced the latter — <a href="https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/the-mormon-church-officially-renounces-polygamy#:~:text=On%20September%2024%2C%201890%2C%20faced,polygamy%20laws%20of%20the%20nation.">sometimes under threat</a>. In that sense, Jeb Pyre is a symbol of the Mormon church: abandoning extreme views when humanistic morality and justice demand it. In other words, Coppins’ Mormonism has become more benign by becoming less Mormon. Rather than acknowledge that fact, Coppins and similar Mormon mouthpieces would have the public believe that Mormons just had to figure out their own faith — gaslighting of the highest order.</p><p>Ultimately, <em>Under the Banner of Heaven</em> invites viewers to take sides on a fundamental problem. What is “true” and what is “just” is a matter of vantage point and a selection of values. The series wrestles with the perennial problem in political theory of private vs. public commitments. Whether it is a Lafferty claiming the right to blood atonement or a Pyre choosing to follow the law over his own private faith, the series depicts the tension between faith and rationality as sources of truth. This imperfect series should leave viewers asking what world they would like to live in and what values they hope society will elevate. If would-be viewers pass over this series because of Coppins’ myopic review, they will miss a great opportunity to ask, “Just how much should we permit in the name of faith?” And <em>that </em>is much more important than whether the Mormon church does or does not have a PR problem.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=24da7e260663" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Apatheism: A Primer]]></title>
            <link>https://adamscottkunz.medium.com/apatheism-a-primer-59e430bd4aeb?source=rss-b9c3824b1dfa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/59e430bd4aeb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[atheism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apatheism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Scott Kunz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 08 May 2021 22:06:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-03-02T21:04:18.414Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>I. Introduction</strong></p><p>Last year, in the case of <a href="https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/19pdf/18-1195_g314.pdf"><em>Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue</em></a>,<em> </em>the Supreme Court extended Free Exercise jurisprudence in a manner that should be troubling to religious moderates and secularists alike. As has been covered extensively (<a href="https://www.scotusblog.com/2020/06/opinion-analysis-court-rules-that-religious-schools-cannot-be-excluded-from-state-funding-for-private-schools/">here</a>, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/30/us/supreme-court-religious-schools-aid.html">here</a>, and <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/courts_law/supreme-court-says-montana-program-aiding-private-schools-must-be-open-to-religious-schools/2020/06/30/4d0af7e6-bad7-11ea-bdaf-a129f921026f_story.html">here</a>, for example), the facts of the case are fairly straightforward. Montana had a state constitutional provision that banned public funds to schools “controlled in whole or in part by any church, sect, or denomination.” This provision is called a Blaine Amendment, a tool with <a href="https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/1036/blaine-amendments">a long history of controversy</a> beyond the scope of this article to recount. At the same time, Montana had a tax credit program that gave favorable treatment to organizations that award scholarships to private schools. Following the Montana state constitution, the Montana Department of Revenue promulgated a rule that prevented such scholarships from being used at religious schools. The Court concluded that this violated the Free Exercise rights of families that would have otherwise used the scholarships for instruction at religious schools.</p><p>Chief Justice Roberts, writing for a conservative majority, held that, despite recent historical trends away from public support of religious institutions, a state cannot withhold aid simply because of religious status. Could the scholarship be used for expressly religious training (<em>e.g.</em>, training to enter the clergy? Maybe not. But the fact that it was left up to the individual students and their families to use the scholarships and that the schools themselves were not <em>expressly </em>indoctrinating students was enough to raise Free Exercise problems.</p><p>This case is sandwiched between two other cases: <a href="https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/16pdf/15-577_khlp.pdf"><em>Trinity Lutheran</em></a>, decided in 2016, and <a href="https://www.supremecourt.gov/docket/docketfiles/html/public/19-123.html"><em>Fulton</em></a>, to be decided by the Court this year. Like <em>Espinoza</em>, these cases involve withholding public support by a state or municipality to a religious organization. In <em>Trinity Lutheran</em>, the denied benefit was a public grant for installing playground equipment at a religious preschool and daycare. In <em>Fulton</em>, it was adoption referrals to Catholic Social Services that refused to place children with same-sex foster parents. Despite the obvious tensions with the Establishment Clause’s prevention of respect for a religious establishment, the justices seemed to think in <em>Trinity Lutheran </em>and <em>Espinoza </em>that public support for religion is perfectly justified — despite a democratic signal from citizens to the contrary. And the Court will almost certainly extend that line of thinking next year in <em>Fulton</em>.</p><p>Now, contrast this line of cases with two other realities. First, consider the fact that the religious liberty in question is one rooted in a Judeo-Christian perspective. Almost reflexively, the Court will permit Free Exercise protections for Christian belief at the expense of the rights of others. Recent cases highlight this reality. For example, consider these cases:</p><ul><li>the right of Christian fundamentalist business owners to deny services to those who identify as queer (<a href="https://www.oyez.org/cases/2017/16-111"><em>Masterpiece Cakeshop</em></a>);</li><li>the right of Christian fundamentalist businesses to withhold public benefits because doing so would conflict with Christian doctrine (<a href="https://www.oyez.org/cases/2013/13-354"><em>Hobby Lobby</em></a>); and</li><li>the denial of the right of taxpayers to challenge federal funding decisions that favor religious organizations (<a href="https://www.oyez.org/cases/2006/06-157"><em>Hein</em></a>).</li></ul><p>And these are just the most recent ones. In all of these cases, the Supreme Court continues to indicate that it will side with the rights of Judeo-Christian religions over that of other individuals, interest groups, and states. Meanwhile, the Court rarely does likewise with minority religions, such as Native American faiths. It has denied Free Exercise protection when the federal government, even over its own impact reports, decimates a Native American sacred site, thereby ending a faith (<a href="https://www.oyez.org/cases/1987/86-1013"><em>Lyng</em></a>). It has carved out whole Free Exercise exceptions for “generally applicable laws” when Native American religious activities run afoul of drug laws (<a href="https://www.oyez.org/cases/1989/88-1213"><em>Employment Division v. Smith</em></a>). And lower courts <a href="https://www.freedomforuminstitute.org/first-amendment-center/topics/freedom-of-religion/free-exercise-clause-overview/treading-on-sacred-ground-are-native-american-sacred-sites-protected-by-the-freedom-of-religion/#_Toc492490193">have routinely followed the Court’s lead</a> on these types of cases. These inconsistencies should at least give an outside viewer some pause.</p><p>Second, the latest round of religion cases comes at a time of increasing secularization. As of 2019, over a quarter of the United States’ population <a href="https://www.pewforum.org/2019/10/17/in-u-s-decline-of-christianity-continues-at-rapid-pace">no longer identifies with any religion</a> — a number that has nearly doubled in the last 15 years. At the same time, Christianity, the United States’ historically dominant faith, continues to lose adherents at an even more rapid rate. This phenomenon <a href="https://www.pewforum.org/2018/05/29/being-christian-in-western-europe/">follows a similar trajectory in Western Europe</a>. While <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/29/opinion/american-christianity.html">some</a> continue to debate whether these statistics indicate growing secularization, there is a sense among many social commentators that <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2017/04/breaking-faith/517785/">this trend will continue</a> — along with a growing partisan clash over matters of faith in the public sphere. To put this in the context of the recent religion cases: as more of the population moves toward a public sphere free from religion, the Court appears to be granting one subset of it — Judeo-Christian traditions — increasing protection. While there may be good arguments for these kinds of jurisprudential shifts when a minority group requires protection from majoritarian tyranny, it is hard to take such arguments seriously when the Court spends page after page recounting the prominent place of faith in American historical development; faith gets protected both because it is an unassailable tradition and because it is threatened by changes in public thought. There is no room for discussion with that sort of logic.</p><p>This article aims not to wade into the morass of First Amendment religious jurisprudence; there is no exit strategy for such discussions. Nor do I intend to argue whether the U.S. Constitution or any governing document <em>should </em>protect religious belief. Instead, the cases I have recounted raise important questions about public thought. How should a religious moderate or a secularist navigate public debates about religious liberty? What ethos or set of principles should guide a person, an organization, or a state through what will inevitably be a century of religious conflict? As the momentum toward secularization builds, how should a non-zealot react? If constitutional liberties and rights are protections from government interference, then the decision to enforce one set of such protections over that of others is a value judgment on the part of a society. And as these value-judgments favorable to religion proliferate, the constitution will continue to subsidize one form of behavior (religious belief) over others (personal liberties, equal access, and individual identity) during a time of religious/secular conflict.</p><p>This article is one of a series that (I hope) will offer <em>one preliminary</em> answer to these questions. I hope to provide a conceptual framework for those who are irreligious to think through the coming decades of change. The purpose of this serial primer is to develop a set of guiding principles under the label “apatheism,” a term I will borrow, redefine, and defend. My thesis is essentially this: apatheism is a philosophical attitude, rather than a belief-system or claim to knowledge, that allows religious moderates and secularists (1) on the one hand, to feel a measure of protection for their religious beliefs (such as they are), while (2) on the other hand, to defend their view of a society that does not elevate religious liberty above that of other social goods. While some of these concepts are not new, my purpose is to bring them under one rubric for application and debate.</p><p>In this first article, I have a small goal: to sketch out what I understand apatheism to be. In later articles, I intend to expand the concepts and implications that I present here.</p><p><strong>II. A Working Definition of Apatheism</strong></p><p>I am not the first to discuss the term apatheism. Trevor Hedberg, currently a postdoctoral scholar at Ohio State University, has perhaps <a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11406-016-9759-y">the earliest and most thorough account</a> of the practical implications of apatheism as a full-fledged philosophy. Jonathan Rauch, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institute, <a href="https://jonathanrauch.typepad.com/jrauch_articles/apatheism_beyond_religion/index.html">has noted</a> that apatheism promises to be a helpful guiding principle in an increasingly secularized society. Moreover, there are glimmers of apatheistic beliefs in Enlightenment philosophers, such as Kant and Rousseau. So, in many ways, I am not covering wholly new ground.</p><p>At the same time, apatheism is undertheorized. No writer, to my knowledge, has yet to provide a precise definition of the philosophical position. While Hedberg has given an excellent defense of its pragmatic quality, we need a foundation from which to generate greater dialogue on what may prove to be an important subject in the coming decades.</p><p>To that end, my working definition of apatheism is as follows: <em>Apatheism is</em> <em>the philosophical attitude of indifference, both public and private, to (1) the question of the existence of a deity, (2) the metaphysical and practical value of loyalty to that deity, and/or (3) the interaction of that deity with the natural world</em>.</p><p>Because this is only a working definition, I will reserve a full explanation of it for other articles. But each component of this definition deserves a brief note:</p><p>a. <em>Philosophical Attitude</em>: As I discuss below, apatheism is not a claim to knowledge or belief. Rather, it is attitudinal: how does one <em>feel</em> about deity instead of how one thinks about deity. Apatheism treats these two sets of cognitive experiences as distinct.</p><p>b. <em>Indifference</em>: The root of apatheism is indifference. This is neither positive nor negative. Apatheism’s main thrust is to meet the various questions about deity with total disinterest. At the same time, apatheism does not have to be non-confrontational or passive. One can be aggressively indifferent or argue for normative reasons behind indifference. Indeed, apatheists might have every reason to defend and advocate for their position. But when it comes to belief in deity, an apatheist shrugs.</p><p>c. <em>Public vs</em>.<em> Private</em>: Apatheism can have both a public and private impact. As a political theorist, I see apatheism as both a highly individual attitude and a collective attitude of a community. Private apatheism is the apatheism that individuals display in their personal relationships: family, friends, colleagues, and so forth. Public apatheism is the apatheism that groups and states display in their communal relationships: citizens, corporations, governments, and so forth.</p><p>d. <em>The “Three Prongs”</em>: My definition includes three subjects — the “Three Prongs” — to which apatheism can be directed: the existence of a deity, loyalty to deity, and a deity’s interaction with the known universe. Each of the three subjects listed above is a matter to which apatheism may be directed. Not all three are required to “be an apatheist,” and an individual apatheist might display varying degrees of indifference to all or any of the three subjects. But each of the three subjects is a matter that is ripe for an apatheistic attitude.</p><p><strong>III. The Logic of Apatheism</strong></p><p>Given the above definitions, what distinguishes apatheism from some of the other “-theisms” that one might adopt? Is it just agnosticism by a different name? The answer to this question depends on the knowledge vs. attitude distinction discussed above.</p><p>Standard discussions of god and religious matters revolve around the degree of one’s belief. “Do you believe in god?” is often seen as the fundamental question in any would-be discussion of religion in private and public life. It does not require elaboration to point out that there are varying degrees of affirmative or negative responses to this question. They range along a first-dimensional spectrum, with agnosticism at the origin and forms of atheism on the left and deism or theism on the right (see Fig. 1). In each of these cases, these forms of belief have taken a position on matters of religion. Whereas atheism and theism take polar-opposite positions on these questions (no vs. yes), agnosticism denies that such knowledge is available at this time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*qTM_nioG0PmlMY-0a_0Sbg.png" /><figcaption>Fig. 1: A one-dimensional spectrum of knowledge claims about deity</figcaption></figure><p>Apatheism raises a completely different question that can operate as a second dimension interacting with the first. Instead of the question of knowledge, we might also ask, “How do you feel about god?” This is an attitudinal question that tests whether or not a person cares about religious matters at all. Apatheism might be best understood in relation to its opposite: zeal. Just as atheism and theism arrive at opposite conclusions concerning knowledge of deity, apatheism and zeal arrive at opposite conclusions about attitude. Zealotry likely needs no elucidation; you need only read the latest news story about sectarian conflict somewhere in the world to get a sense of what zealotry is. Apatheism is equally forceful in its indifference to matters of deity. Thus, a hard apatheist might take the negative position that “I do not care at all about matters of god,” while a zealot might take the positive position that “I care a great deal about matters of god.”</p><p>Note, though, that there is an interesting implication of treating apatheism/zeal as a second dimension. Because it is second-dimensional, apatheism (and its opposite, zeal) is consistent with the first-dimensional epistemic positions. For example, one could be an apatheistic atheist (“I know there isn’t a god, but I don’t care a great deal about such matters”) or an apatheistic theist (“I know there is a god, but I don’t care a great deal about such matters”). The reverse could also be true. One could be a zealot atheist (“I know there isn’t a god, and I care a great deal about such matters.”) or a zealot theist (“I know there is a god, and I care a great deal about such matters.”). These two dimensions, when combined, offer a very helpful rubric for understanding how claims of knowledge and attitudes interact with one another when a person discusses belief in deity.</p><p>The following graph (Fig. 2) gives a nice visual representation of what I mean. Visualizing both of these dimensions at once, we can begin to see how some groups might be categorized epistemically and attitudinally. These are not hard and fast categorizations. Rather, they are my effort to signal how these concepts relate to one another, with the idea that we will have more precision as we work through the definition sketched out above.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*LyO87TS7-MiOskft0BtezA.png" /><figcaption><em>Fig. 2: A two-dimensional spectrum of knowledge claims about and attitudes toward deity</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>IV. Conclusion</strong></p><p>As I have said, this article is only a sketch. In later articles, I intend to take a much deeper dive into the definition I have laid out above. I will also discuss the practical effects of apatheism, building on the work that Hedberg has already started. To reiterate, my overall goal in this project is to give an account of what I believe many individuals are feeling and are likely to feel as the topic of religious freedom continues to take up so much of our time — politically and culturally.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=59e430bd4aeb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mindfulness in the College Classroom]]></title>
            <link>https://adamscottkunz.medium.com/mindfulness-in-the-college-classroom-9e8a9d74c1e9?source=rss-b9c3824b1dfa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9e8a9d74c1e9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[pedagogy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[college-teaching]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindfulness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[contemplation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Scott Kunz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 26 Jun 2020 18:59:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-17T17:51:11.658Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8m5NpCn37MLYwGV3aX5WXg.jpeg" /></figure><p>I distinctly remember the moment it occurred to me that teaching undergraduates was taking a significant toll on my health. It was late-November. I had just finished a lecture on the 2016 presidential election and the role of racial animosity in voter behavior. It was 9:00 PM, the classroom was emptying, I hadn’t eaten yet, and my FitBit showed my heart rate was 134 BPM — the fat-burning zone. By the time I got back to my car and was driving over the causeway from Sacramento to my home in Davis, I was lightheaded and dizzy. I spent the rest of the night trying to unwind with some garbage TV, but it was well into the early morning hours before I fell asleep. My last thought was, “THIS is unsustainable.”</p><p>Flash forward to September 2019. I stood in a newly built lecture room on the campus of CSUMB. It was my first day on the campus since finishing my Ph.D. and my first day as a full-time lecturer/TT hopeful. Seated in front of me were about 35 upper-division, prelaw students eager to learn about conflict resolution. I had built the course as part skills-based learning and part political theory — a kind of exploratory course on the origins and potential solutions for political conflict. The clock on the wall showed it was time to start. Taking a deep breath and listening to the air enter and exit my lungs, I told the class, “Before we begin, I want you to pause . . .”</p><p><strong>The Need for Mindfulness</strong></p><p>The difference in my approach between 2016 and 2019 comes down to what should be an obvious realization: just as our personal lives require care and cultivation, so, too, do our professional lives — especially as college instructors. Unlike my public school teacher parents, who see the same set of students every day for an entire year and who are deeply involved in the lives of a small sample of students, I am a distant presence in my students’ academic lives. Sure, they sit in my classroom, they take notes, they discuss, they occasionally appear in office hours with a limited set of questions. Rarely, one or two will ask for career advice (the law background shows up on their radar). But for the most part, I am a guy they listen to for a few hours a week and a dispenser of grades.</p><p>At the same time, I feel passionate about the subjects I teach. I get amped when I talk about a topic dear to me (<em>e.g.,</em> citizen solidarity, conflicts between the religious and irreligious, Native American struggles of respect,<em> etc.</em>). I rage when I attack counterarguments. I feel the excitement of seeing a student “get it.” I slump my shoulders when I face the mundane tasks of university teaching — which I won’t name here. And I rinse and repeat at the start of a new semester.</p><p>This separation inevitably breeds the kind of thing I experienced in November 2016. The stress of “getting through the material,” the energy needed to hold students’ attention, and the individual struggle of 30–60 people on various points of an emotional spectrum is, quite simply, a recipe for burn out. It is for this reason that I began turning to mindful pedagogy as a solution.</p><p>After my 2016 experience, I began reading the research on techniques for fostering a contemplative learning atmosphere for my students and myself. The research is new and growing, as more and more college professors embrace the need for buttressing content with contentment. In a <a href="http://www.contemplativemind.org/files/MedandHigherEd.pdf">2008 summary</a> of this research, Shapiro, Brown, and Astin note that mindful teaching can not only have an impact on improving both teacher and student mental health, but it can have a significantly positive effect on performance — both in how a teacher delivers material and how students receive it.</p><p>Some of this is about technique: real changes to lecture tone, activity, and discussion can “bring down the temperature” in the room. But a large part of changing classroom atmosphere is about recognizing and capitalizing on different ways of knowing. As <a href="https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/5159/f172895f32363be7a5ac25a1b8566c60dd23.pdf">Tobin Hart argues</a>, contemplation is one of multiple types of knowledge acquisition, but often overlooked when a lecturer has so much information to dispense in a limited time. Creating space for students to think about a subject — rather than take notes, discuss, do an activity, or to ask questions — allows them to sit with a subject in the privacy of their own minds, teasing out the nuances for themselves. Think Plato, Montaigne, or Descartes alone in their rooms, creating thought spaces for themselves to reflect and ponder on broader questions.</p><p><strong>What is Mindful Teaching?</strong></p><p>Over the last few years, I have used a few classroom techniques that I think allow for contemplative learning. Each of these techniques has led to a dramatic drop in my own classroom stress and has been something students enjoy doing. Each semester, when my students continue to lament my grading habits or critique my selection of readings, they overwhelmingly say how much they appreciate my efforts to create mindful space.</p><p><em>1. Meditative Moments</em></p><p>In my meditative moments, I usually set aside a short amount of time at the beginning of class to create a structured meditation activity. The goal is not to make the students into headspace experts. Rather, as I routinely tell them, it’s a chance to leave their daily “baggage” at the door and to neutralize whatever stress might get in the way of a rich discussion of the day’s topic. Sometimes I play music and ask them to close their eyes, concentrating only on the music itself. Other times, we do two- to three-minute breathing exercises, in which we listen to the air enter and exit our lungs. Occasionally, I will ask them to think about a specific idea and to reflect on it for a short period: think about a time that you experienced joy, think about a person who you currently lean on for support, what about the current season are you enjoying, etc. Sometimes, if it’s a long lecture period or if I sense the emotion in the room is rising, I will do this activity midway through the class to “hard reset.”</p><p>I’ve found that by doing this, <em>I </em>experience a drop in my own anxiety and a clarifying sense of where I plan to go with the lecture. Meanwhile, <em>they </em>have a chance to let go of whatever might be limiting their ability to focus through a long lecture.</p><p><em>2. Outdoor Walks</em></p><p>Outdoor walks have been the activity that my students most enjoy. Here, I dedicate a portion of the lecture hour to do a kind of walking discussion, wherein I spend a few minutes with the class content at one point in our walk and then lead the students on a walk to another point. I ask the students to be still and to keep their devices away in between lecture points. A key factor I try to emphasize is that they be aware of their surroundings as we move and to focus on what we see as we make our way on the walk.</p><p>That walking time in between gives students ample opportunity to think through what we have just discussed. The physical activity of moving through an area gets students to shake off that tired feeling that all of us start experiencing midway through a lecture. What I’ve found is that it also forces me to slow down and to think through each piece of the lecture, rather than ramming it through a set block of time.</p><p>I have the benefit of currently working on a beautiful campus in Monterey Bay, where there are plenty of opportunities to stroll through a natural setting. But it doesn’t have to be a hike through the Yosemite Valley for this to work; most campuses, even very urban ones, have some kind of quad or area to walk through. The key is to find a route that works for you and your students. Obviously, it should be a safe environment, free of obstruction. Moreover, it should be a route that affords everyone, regardless of physical ability, the chance to enjoy moving through an area with a group of their peers.</p><p><em>3. Journaling</em></p><p>Journaling is the classic form of contemplation and one that students are probably already familiar with. Most of the time, I ask students to keep a dedicated portion of their notes for their journal, either in a notebook or document on their device. Once in a while, I will send them home with a longer journaling project that I ask them to bring back with them for the next class hour. I always try to have a specific goal in mind for the journal entries, whether it is a question about the day’s topic, a prompt from their readings, or an opportunity to write down what they might be feeling that day. I try to avoid having the students share their journals with one another; I want to foster as much honesty as possible in the journals so that over time students can look back to get a clear window into their mental state throughout the semester.</p><p>The benefits of journaling <a href="https://www.insidehighered.com/advice/2019/06/25/how-teach-more-effectively-through-course-journals-opinion">have long been documented</a>. I have found that these regular moments for writing create time for my own contemplation; while the students spend time working through a journal entry, I get that extra time to pause and to think through where I am in the lecture. I’ve also found that, if done with a goal in mind, students enjoy the free-writing experience. As I say to them repeatedly, even if the entry is nothing more than doodling, the act of putting pen to paper makes the connection between motor and mental activity. Granted, journals can get tedious, so I try to limit the number of times I do this during a semester; students can burn out quickly if the journals are becoming an end and not a means.</p><p><em>4.</em> <em>Listening</em></p><p>What I mean by listening is something very specific. My uncle, a high school teacher, often used to say, “You’re hearing, but not listening.” Undergraduates are always hearing; if they’re in the room, they’re hearing you and their peers. But listening — active, attentive listening — is a rare, difficult activity. Research shows that not only is this better for retention and learning, but it is a <a href="https://www.usip.org/public-education/educators/what-active-listening">critical step to addressing conflict or problem-solving</a>.</p><p>In my classroom, active listening activities usually involve students listening to one another. After lecturing or discussing for a while, I pause and put the students into groups of three or four. Two students usually serve as interlocutors, discussing a portion of what we’ve been working through as a class. Meanwhile, the other member of the group sits quietly and observes. As part of their observation, I ask the students to write down notes on the content of the discussion, the kinds of details each interlocutor brings up, and the “subtext” of the conversation (<em>e.g., </em>body language, emotion, voice tone, <em>etc.</em>). I then give some time for the observer to give feedback to the interlocutors about what they discussed and what an observer might have learned.</p><p>What I really enjoy about this activity is how students make the connection between what they say and what they mean. Frequently, observers will find details that interlocutors didn’t even know they were conveying. Moreover, observers learn pretty quickly that listening requires many levels of commitment to a conversation. I challenge the students to use these same techniques in their lecture participation; throughout a lecture, when I say “Now is a time to use those active listening skills,” students know exactly what I mean. And, for my own part, this activity gives me a chance to move around the room, to listen in on conversations, and to gauge what questions students might have about the lecture and to adjust accordingly.</p><p><em>5. Wrap-up Silence</em></p><p>If the meditative moment is the bookend at the beginning of class, the wrap-up silence is the bookend when class is over. In this activity, I ask students to pause before leaving the room. I seldom have a specific prompt in mind for this. Instead, as I explain to the students, this is their chance to spend a few minutes letting their minds complete the thoughts that may have been neglected in the rush of the lecture. This is exactly the Montaignian or Cartesian moment I want the students to aspire to, and it is my most favorite time of the class. I ask the students to put away their books and devices — to “pack up” for the day — and to sit still with the topic we’ve just explored. It’s probably too much to assume that students have earth-shattering realizations through this. But, as I do it regularly, I think students start to get what it is that we’re doing: the mental equivalent of allowing our bodies to digest what we’ve taken in.</p><p>What I’ve found from this activity is that it models exactly what Tobin Hart is getting at in the psychological literature. If other parts of the lecture are about processing facts, this part is about being contemplative, to access that part of the brain that allows for making connections, retaining information, and determining what to do with the content. For my students, they get a chance to close up the lecture and move on to the other parts of their day. For me, its a chance to be reflective about what I’ve accomplished and to think about where I might go the next time we meet. It’s perhaps a little sappy to go this far, but I want to believe that this activity does what teachers and students have been aspiring to since the earliest classrooms: to dedicate a sacred space for human flourishing through learning. Maybe it does that, or maybe it’s just a nice way to end an hour.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>Now, this is all purely anecdotal. I am not a psychologist and have done zero original research on any of what I have just offered. I have no data to point to that my students get better grades or are better humans because of my efforts. Instead, I have offered all of the foregoing as a list of what is working <em>for my students and me</em>. I hope that by offering this list, it might help another college lecturer get some breathing space. And, most importantly, I hope that I can add my voice to those who think that mindfulness in the college classroom is a necessary component of modern learning. I would love nothing more than to have conversations with anyone on this topic!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9e8a9d74c1e9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[At the Threshold]]></title>
            <link>https://adamscottkunz.medium.com/at-the-threshold-c7bff7d3b490?source=rss-b9c3824b1dfa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c7bff7d3b490</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2020]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[essay]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adam Scott Kunz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Jun 2020 04:41:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-02T15:46:16.598Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uDEW1FLFKUu9UPjz9s9VpA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I.</p><p>What every cosmic horror hero does is look too hard. The threat is always there. It was always going to be there. But the hero looks when others don’t. She could have gone along unaware. But she starts looking at the flaws, picking at the little tears at the edges, peeling back the top layer to see what’s underneath.</p><p>And then it’s too late. Then she has to do something. Then she has to act. She has to make the connections that tell where It came from and how to prevent It. She has to tell others about It, who don’t believe her. She becomes obsessed with It. She reads old books about It (sure-fire madness; the words undo you). She starts cutting out newspaper clippings, doing that red string thing. She watches for the signs of It. She compiles a haphazard plan to prevent It.</p><p>But It still happens. It comes, no matter what. She uncovers It. She buries herself in It. And then It comes anyway. Her horrors are all completely founded. It sucks the innocent bystanders into Itself, unaware to the end. But she has to live with the dread for months, years. That’s what hurts her the most. The arrival. She shines a light in the darkness.</p><p>It’s just beyond the edge. She doesn’t prevent It. She faces It.</p><p>II.</p><p>In April, a childhood friend of mine hanged himself. He was four years younger than me. It was four weeks into the pandemic. I’d lost touch with him. He was living back in the place we grew up, carrying around a stigma for something he’d done in his early twenties, but which he couldn’t shake. He’d been suffering for a long time. His Twitter habits showed he was plugged into the chaos. He left behind two kids, a big family, and so many friends. But it was the relief at the end of a rope that he needed.</p><p>When I found out, I thought about working for his family. It was me, his older brother, a couple of neighbor boys. My dad had got me a job with his dad when I was 11. I think it was his attempt to recreate his farm childhood. Feeding cattle during the winter, moving them to some other field in the summer, fixing fences (I liked putting in new staples and barbed wire), stacking the barn in autumn, branding the calves in the spring.</p><p>I kept thinking about the smell of burnt calf hair and skin for a few nights after I found out he was dead. You don’t get that smell out of your nose. The other boys in the yard didn’t mind it much. But I never really got used to it. He was so young when we branded the calves. I was 11, but he was just a boy. I wonder if he ever thought about the smell?</p><p>III.</p><p>There are armed white men walking through neighborhoods in Philadelphia. The police are letting them. I watched a video of it that trickled to the top of my feed. Guys my age, walking down the streets of Pennsylvania, with clubs and guns. They aren’t worried one bit. The president has “military-style” vehicles lining Pennsylvania Avenue. And he turned off the lights on the White House last night. I guess they also tear-gassed some people out on the mall.</p><p>I used to eat my lunch in the park on the north side of the White House. I’d walk over there from McPherson Square to get away from the firm. It was hard to breathe in D.C. in the summer. The humidity and the people made it tough to get air. Sometimes I’d walk up Pennsylvania to GW and look at my law school. I didn’t go in. I’d just walk around the outside. I wasn’t worried one bit.</p><p>I wonder how much the virus will spread among the white men. They aren’t wearing masks. And they’re standing very close. I can see them shaking hands in the video. They’re breathing in the open air. They aren’t worried one bit.</p><p>IV.</p><p>My son woke up screaming a minute ago. He couldn’t find his stuffed bear in the crib. He needs it to sleep. He had a long day at daycare. The woman who cares for him in her home is so good at watching kids. He doesn’t ever want to leave. But he’s always tired when he comes back. Sometimes, I bring him home very early so he won’t be exhausted. So I can see him.</p><p>She and her husband are from Afghanistan. He teaches Pashto for the language institute in Monterey. She watches kids. They’ve been here long enough to be citizens. They just became citizens in the fall. I’ve never asked what brought them here. They never said. But I know about the wars.</p><p>My son will wake up tomorrow and go for half a day. I’ve got some writing to do, and my wife has work. But we’ll make him a good lunch, and play outside. He’ll have a long nap in the afternoon. Then we’ll take a walk down the street. And he’ll go to bed with his bear.</p><p>V.</p><p>My nephew and I had a long talk the other day. He’s almost two years old, just three months older than my son. It was a great conversation, even if I didn’t understand much of it. My brother in law was filming the whole thing in the background, while my sister laughed nearby at how much my nephew talked. My sister and I are the same. My nephew has the same bear as my son. They got them from our parents. My nephew probably gets scared in the night, too.</p><p>But he won’t be able to walk around Pennsylvania with a gun or a club. His skin isn’t the right color for that. He’d cry out for “Mama,” but my sister wouldn’t be nearby laughing, my brother in law wouldn’t be filming. Someone else would be filming. Someone else would be nearby. Not Mama. I’d watch a video of it that would trickle to the top of my feed.</p><p>I’m going to see my nephew in a couple of weeks on the 4th of July. We’re going to visit my parents. He’ll come to play with my son. I can’t wait to hear the boys screaming in the yard. My brother in law will be filming the whole thing in the background, while my sister laughs nearby. My sister and I are the same.</p><p>VI.</p><p>Something isn’t right. You’ve felt it for a while. You wouldn’t be reading this if you didn’t. The words undo you. Yes, the pieces are all there, it all looks like it fits. The phones work, the lights are on, there’s food in the closet. They’re still waving the flag, there’s still an election, the economy is reopening. Movies and music are still playing. The people are walking down the street, not worried one bit.</p><p>Look! Right there. See the little flaws, the little tears at the edges. It smells like burning hair and skin. If we peel back the top layer to see what’s underneath, we’ll start to put the pieces together. It’s going to be bad. I know about the wars. But grab that end and help me lift.</p><p>It’s just beyond the edge. We won’t prevent It. We face It.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c7bff7d3b490" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>