<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Adarsh Jha on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Adarsh Jha on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@adarshrjha?source=rss-b2d5b31f3206------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 21:40:45 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@adarshrjha/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Quota Continent: How India & Its Neighbors Address Social Inequality]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adarshrjha/the-quota-continent-how-india-its-neighbors-address-social-inequality-902ff4da4b45?source=rss-b2d5b31f3206------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/902ff4da4b45</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reservations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government-jobs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[quota]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mandal-commission]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adarsh Jha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 27 Jul 2024 15:55:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-27T15:55:46.124Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/635/1*wvS5Z_U0xlxkLpOf8pzk5Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image from a pro-quota agitation</figcaption></figure><p>The Indian Subcontinent has a weird obsession with quota. From government jobs to educational institutions, you can find your identity being repeatedly enforced almost to the point where what you do and where you come from can never be divorced.</p><p>However, it can be harnessed for political benefits. I used to believe this phenomenon to be uniquely Indian until I came across the ongoing protests in Bangladesh. In India, the founding father of our republic, soaked in the guilt of historical injustices, introduced the policy of reservation for marginalized sections, hence solidifying a vote bank.</p><h3>Indian Vote Bank Politics</h3><p>A few decades later, some equally great politicians chose to create another section of people who deserve to be given reservations due to their backward status. Therefore a commission was constituted to identify these backward classes. It can be said that instead of alleviating the existing backwardness in three decades, our socio-political institution discovered a new section of marginalized altogether.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PBK30SCGPQiLg3UoLAdftw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Prime Minister VP Singh and his allies, 1989</figcaption></figure><p>So, from 22.5%, the share of reserved seats shot up to 49.5% in 1990. At present, it is 59.5%, with 10% reservation given to the economically weaker sections, and rightfully so. Subsequent governments left no stone unturned in 70 years of independence to push down a section of what intellectuals label as socially upward to economic misery and suffering.</p><p>The unreserved category generally coped with this by diverting their focus towards the private sector, which they naively believed to remain eternally immune to the menace of quotas. Unfortunately, pressure groups, politicians, and intellectuals have already started building narratives for the insertion of a reservation system in the last bastion of technocratic merit in this country, which is private sector jobs.</p><h3>Pakistan’s Scheme of National Integrity</h3><p>Bangladesh came into existence in 1972, and its primary reason behind seeking independence from Pakistan was a lack of representation. The quota system of Pakistan in 1948 was even more anti-merit than what existed in India in those days.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nlM9bT9DjidUTsgujwBRsg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Pakistan’s First Prime Minister, Liaquat Ali Khan</figcaption></figure><p>The founding fathers of Pakistan too believed that the quota system was a quick fix to their social disharmony. After several proposals and changes, they settled on a scheme in 1949 where East Bengal, with a population share of about 56%, had 40% seats reserved in the Central Superior Services (akin to the UPSC in India), while West Pakistan, with the remaining 44% population, also had 40% seats reserved in the CSS. That left only 20% open to ‘merit.’ But as history shows us the animosity and eventual clash was inevitable.</p><h3>Power-Consolidation Policy in Bangladesh</h3><p>Post-independence Sheikh Mujibur Rehman wanted to seize the resources of this newly-formed state for his own followers. He created a system where they had 30% of seats reserved under the freedom fighter quota. Twenty-five years down the line, the policy was amended, and the benefits were extended to the next generation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eTS-V2Ml7TVsdjOGyVNGdQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, Bangladesh’s Father of the Nation</figcaption></figure><p>In 2010, the government went a step ahead and declared the freedom fighter quota seats to remain vacant in case they found no eligible candidates. Unlike India, successive reforms in Bangladesh only increased the number of seats in the open category, therefore over the course of 50 years its share increased from 20% to 44%.</p><p>But that is not where the matter ends; the students are quite clear with their demands to bring all kinds of reservations down to 10% and let the ‘meritorious’ enter the system. Although there exists a very significant difference between the two countries due to which the trajectory of reservations panned out differently.</p><h3>Contrasting Conclusions</h3><p>In Bangladesh the quota system caters to a political cadre and minorities who have sworn allegiance to a political party, therefore it only requires an organized movement by the majority community to bring down the government to its knees. In case of India the unreserved class happens to be an unacknowledged minority. Its lack of numbers when it comes to filling the streets adds to its inability in influencing political decisions thanks to the vibrant Indian democracy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/665/1*JGF0cpSlCX0DjtBlwrhIbA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Anti-Mandal Commission Agitation</figcaption></figure><p>Therefore, protests like those against the Mandal Commission’s introduction of the OBC reservation in 1990 didn’t yield any results. Though other significant factors behind its failure were its sporadic and unorganized nature and it coinciding with the Ram Janmabhoomi agitation which drew the general category at an emotional level, foregoing their grievances against ever-increasing quota. That being said, the general category in this country remains an unacknowledged minority solely due to the intellectual dishonesty of India’s elites, who have a very skewed notion of majoritarianism.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=902ff4da4b45" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is there a Women Vote-Bank in India?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adarshrjha/is-there-a-women-vote-bank-in-india-ced2948a8b13?source=rss-b2d5b31f3206------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ced2948a8b13</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[women-empowerment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[votebank-politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adarsh Jha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 21 Jul 2024 14:38:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-21T14:38:54.588Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>1951, the year independent India conducted the first general elections, the Republic was merely an infant while the breath of freedom was still sinking in the masses. Sukumar Sen, a bureaucrat in his 50s, was handed over the task of conducting free and fair elections, something that was a distant dream for many newly formed nations at the time. The process was marred with massive challenges in terms of planning, logistics, and execution. However, what stood out was the registration of electoral rolls. It wasn’t that people were not interested in electing their leaders, but rather that an important section of the Indian masses held no separate identity of their own. They were the conservative Indian women who held their identities inseparable from their families and, to be specific, held them in relation to their male counterparts; in most cases, they happened to be husbands. That resulted in the deletion of a sizable chunk of women from the electoral rolls.</p><h4>Progressive Politics for Women Emancipation</h4><p>It is an important challenge for progressive Indian leaders to divorce the public identity of women from that of men in the family and hand them over the banner of emancipation and gender equality. Therefore, successive governments brought in legislation after legislation to instill a sense of agency and rights. In various states, the policy of the liquor ban directly addressed their concerns. Changing family laws to benefit women was another move through which leaders gained popularity among them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*4y8yAIzzzRoc7XrT1IBCzQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Women lining up to vote in elections</figcaption></figure><p>The seeds of the creation of a vote bank on the basis of gender reached the stage of germination in the 21st century. The talks about “women reservations” took center stage. After several attempts all through the late 1990s, the bill was passed in the Lok Sabha in 2008, and it lapsed later on. It was in 2023 that the Government of India introduced the “Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam.” Through that, the Union of India reserved one-third of all seats in the Lok Sabha, state legislative assemblies, and the NCT of Delhi for women. The bill received support from all parties except Asaduddin Owaisi led AIMIM.</p><h4>Politics of Electoral Freebies</h4><p>India is a nation that remains in a permanent state of election. One may say that we revere democracy so much that we need its festival to engage us every now and then. In the last decade, there has been a drastic shift in discourse as more and more signs of women voting as a bloc became evident and political parties went berserk with their manifesto promises to appease them. At present, 10 states and one UT either already have a scheme in place or have made announcements in that regard. In a fresh development, AAP has announced a similar scheme in their manifesto for the upcoming Haryana elections.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*qgUN5WL-g28KysjkwZtqUg.png" /><figcaption>The table highlighting schemes and estimated expenditures.</figcaption></figure><p>The combined figure easily exceeds 1 lakh crore/annum. While some states offer as little as Rs. 1000 per month, others are aiming to take it somewhere around Rs. 3000 per month for women. At the same time, there needs to be a clarification that, in almost every case, the money that is being given is handed out to women from those households who are from very poor economic backgrounds. In some states, these women from poor backgrounds are categorized further, that is, women from marginalized castes are handed out more money than those who hail from the general category.</p><p>Multiple reports suggest that the voter turnout of women was marginally higher than that of men in both the 2019 and 2024 general elections. However, there doesn’t seem to have been any clear study regarding them making an electoral choice as a bloc, as is evident in the case of caste. At the same time, one can further divide the pattern of how women vote in urban compared to rural India, given that the latter is still very much under the grip of the caste base, most of them backward in social hierarchy and patriarchal in their outlook.</p><p>At the same time, justifications behind such policies range from women being more prone to losing jobs in a post-pandemic world to the decline of spousal violence in cases where women have cash in hand to the emboldening of liberal values among women with regards to employment and financial freedom. But what it doesn’t answer is its long term feasibility. Apart from that, its larger implication over the nature of political discourse would be detrimental, as one party would try to outdo the other by offering more lucrative freebies and creating further fault-lines wherever there is an opportunity to reap electoral results.</p><p>References:</p><ul><li><a href="https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/haryana-assembly-elections-2024-aap-launches-kejriwals-5-guarantees-promises-rs-1000-to-females/videoshow/111887375.cms?from=mdr">Haryana Assembly Elections 2024: AAP launches &#39;Kejriwal&#39;s 5 guarantees&#39;, promises Rs 1000 to females</a></li><li><a href="https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/karnataka-budget-2024-rs-28-608-crore-allocated-for-gruha-lakshmi-scheme-101708062303535.html">Karnataka budget 2024: ₹28,608 crore allocated for Gruha Lakshmi scheme</a></li><li><a href="https://www.epw.in/engage/article/womens-reservation-act-2023-symbolic-gesture-or-0">Women&#39;s Reservation Act of 2023: A Symbolic Gesture or a Significant Stride Towards Empowerment?</a></li><li><a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/guwahati/over-26-lakh-women-to-benefit-from-orunodoi-himanta/articleshow/104358037.cms">Over 26 Lakh Women To Benefit From Orunodoi: Himanta | Guwahati News - Times of India</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ced2948a8b13" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Battle over Antiquity: The Many Aspects of Maharaj Libel Case]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adarshrjha/battle-over-antiquity-the-many-aspects-of-maharaj-libel-case-1a9f2267df7a?source=rss-b2d5b31f3206------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1a9f2267df7a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[british-india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[martin-luther]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vaishnavism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adarsh Jha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 23 Jun 2024 17:20:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-23T17:20:44.820Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k5lrIsmGD1CnzK-5E66okw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Official poster of Maharaj (film)</figcaption></figure><p>The recent Netflix release Maharaj got embroiled in controversy as pro-Hindutva organizations questioned the makers’ intentions and accused them of deliberately insulting the Hindu faith. The film is a Yash Raj Films production and is touted as the big launch for Junaid Khan, son of Aamir Khan, who is essaying the role of Karsandas Mulji, a 19th-century Gujarati journalist. He got labeled ‘Martin Luther of India’ by the English press when he wrote articles about a Pushtimarg religious figure, Jadunathji Brijratanji Maharaj, from Surat. Jaideep Ahlawat portrays the role in the film as it appears in the promotional poster. The case re-shaped several contours of societal, cultural, and communal interactions, as well as sectarian beliefs.</p><p>Vallabhacharya was a Telugu Brahmin who went on pilgrimage to the Braj region in the late 15th and early 16th centuries. During his travels, the Almighty Lord Krishna blessed him with visions of his multiple swaroops (forms), including the form of Shrinathji. From here started a new tradition among Vaishnava worship. This sect followed hereditary leadership as it kept passing on to the descendents of Vallabhacharya, and every notable head that is gosvami or maharaj can trace the lineage back to him. Due to this, these maharajs are considered living representatives of Vallabh-Krishna. Hence was born the Pushtimarg sect.</p><p>By the mid-19th century, there was a new English-educated middle class rising on the western coast of India. They were highly enamored by the colonial worldview and shared a similar conscience. It was the beginning of a new intellectual movement that saw traditional, medieval, and native cultures with sharpened skepticism. Among them was an Elphinstonian named Karsandas Mulji, who hailed from the family of Kapol Bania, a leading merchant caste who followed the Pushtimarg sect. Although, by virtue of his education, his understanding of faith was built on the foundation of the works of H. H. Wilson and Max Mueller.</p><p>Meanwhile, Dadabhai Naroji had started a Gujarati newspaper, Rast Goftar (translated as The Truth Teller), with the intention of bringing social reform within the Parsi community. Soon, it widened its scope and picked up the issue of women’s emancipation. It condemned their practice of adorning expensive jewelry and participating in public festivals like Holi, along with decrying their other superstitious beliefs. Here, we need to understand what accounts for superstition. After a thorough analysis of the then-reformers, one can conclude that any practice that didn’t appear logical to them was considered superstitious. Then one wonders: why not label all of religion as superstition? The only reason was that in those days, the Christian worldview — Protestant, to be precise — dominated the social order of the educated class. Therefore, the idea of reform was to ensure that the native belief system got more and more aligned with the colonial setup.</p><p>Throughout the 1850s, newspapers targeted the lifestyle of wealthy seths as they saw them as a bad influence on the lower strata of society. Among these seths, there were two notables, Gopaldas Madhavdas and Damodhar Madhavji, heads of the baniya and bhatiya communities, respectively. They displayed unflinching loyalty towards the maharajs, the high priests of the Pushtimarg sect. These community heads exercised immense power, which included excommunicating those who breached social customs. In a community where your network is the most important factor determining your social security, excommunication was the harshest penalty.</p><p>During those days, Mulji was at Elphinstone Institution, Bombay, where he joined the Gujarati Hindu Buddhi Vardhak Sabha. There he met two Gujrati Brahmins, Narmadashankar Lalshankar Dave and Mahipatram Rupram. They helped him read Sanskrit texts of the Pushtimarg sect, which enabled him to prepare the skeleton of his future critique of the same. He started his journalism by writing in Rast Goftar, but by the mid-1950s, he started his own paper called “Satya Prakash” (translated as Light of Truth). Though his articles continued to be published by many other papers, including the women’s journal of the time, Stri Bodh, His early articles do not display an outright rejection of tradition but only demand the application of rationality with respect to social practices. He repeatedly mentions the term ‘progress’, as the benchmark for acceptability or continuity of any social or religious custom.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/240/1*IGjTdx7irZoyFS6oqOeuTQ.png" /><figcaption>Satya Prakash and Rast Goftar had an official merger</figcaption></figure><p>His colleague Dave was the first to call out Maharajs for engaging in adulterous relations with his female followers. The article was carried in the March 1857 edition of Satyaprakash. He alleged that newly married women were being sent to Maharajs for their first consummation. Such an act stood in clear violation of the characteristics of a genuine Guru, he added further. The following year, Mulji wrote an article caricaturing Maharajs as extortionists who reap off wealth from followers by scaring them with excommunication. Along with that, he questioned their misconduct with female followers in the name of ‘Krishna Lila.’</p><p>This journalistic crusade went on for the next couple of years, eventually culminating in a defamation case, now commonly known as the ‘Maharaj Libel Case.’ But before that, Jadunathji Maharaj, the head of the Vaishanav temple in Surat, who held a respectable position across the sect, arrived in Bombay to quell the reformist onslaught. His first attempt was to arrive at an amicable settlement, by which he meant taking into consideration issues raised by the reformers. He openly supported the idea of women’s education, as he himself laid the foundation of a girl’s school in Surat, for which he fetched praise from Mulji. Also, by not excommunicating him from the community, they displayed their intention to handle the entire fiasco internally. Though the two poles couldn’t hold together for long, Dave challenged Jadunathji for a debate over widow-remarriage. It turned out that the latter proved Dave to be an atheist in their public interaction while arguing over the subject.</p><p>Mulji rearmed his articles with fresh sets of criticism. Now he attacked the validity of the scriptures and raised doubts over their divine authority. It was his attempt to discredit the Vallabh sect as heretic, which is leading people astray from the original faith of Hindus. To further his arguments, he cited the Puranas, which say that in Kaliyuga, many false religions and heresies would emerge. Apart from the Vallabh sect, which was at the forefront of the receiving end, the article insinuated Ramanandis as a heterodoxical sect too. He labeled the priests of the new sects as cheats and debauches. The article called out Jadunathji, directly forcing him to sue Mulji in a libel case. Libel is generally understood as published slander, but the legal process requires it to be committed against a private individual because the British state allowed criticism of religion or God per se. Therefore, Maharaj’s case reduced Jadunathji to a mere individual subjected to defamation.</p><p>The Bhatiya elites joined hands in support of the Maharaj. In their enthusiasm, they committed a grave error by passing a resolution of excommunication for any caste member who dares to testify against the Maharaj in court. Karsandas took note of it and filed a case of conspiracy and obstruction of justice in which nine Bhatiya leaders were found guilty, though they got away with fines only as Mulji’s lawyer didn’t pursue a sentence. Its success emboldened him to head for a final clash with Jadunathji and take down what he called an ‘immoral’ institution.</p><p>The hearing went on for twenty-four days, beginning on January 26, 1862, which the court reserved its verdict for a later day. In the span of almost three and a half weeks, Mulji got a flood of leading intellectuals, including Christian missionaries, journalists, and reformers, to testify in defense of his stand. This was followed by the appearance of a famous doctor, Ramachandra Vitthal Lad, aka Bhau Daji Lad, who admitted that Jadunathji visited him for the treatment of a venereal disease. As the proceedings had the attention of the entire city, Maharaj and his private life were out in the open. Jadunathji refuted all these claims and denied ever indulging in immoral acts.</p><p>In April 1862, the court held Mulji guilty of libel. Though it was covered by the plea of justification raised by the defendant, Chief Justice Matthew Sausse made an important observation, often overlooked by scholars, regarding the court’s refusal to absolve Mulji of libel. Sausse called him out for not limiting his criticism within the community if he sincerely aimed at bringing about a reform rather than the route taken by Mulji of broadcasting it in public. It is said that Mulji too lamented his excess, as he didn’t expect it to become such a huge fiasco for his community.</p><p>Justice Joseph Arnould was impressed by the anti-Pushtimarg rhetoric of Reverend John Wilson, a Scottish missionary, and slammed the basic principles of the ‘Krishna worshiping’ sect. He labeled the sect as a debauched form of Hinduism and questioned its morals. He went on to characterize Lord Krishna as “a God whose most popular attributes are his feats of sexual prowess.” Although these remarks didn’t change Chief Justice Sausse’s view regarding defamation, he awarded five rupees in damages to Maharaj, which was nothing but an on-paper victory for him.</p><p>In the larger scheme of things, Jadunathji’s reputation and social status in the eyes of the larger public came crashing down. The court’s verdict on his immoral acts didn’t fetch him the desired result. He was made to pay a significant part of the cost of the suit. At the same time, he escaped more serious charges, as the reformers were only focused on ending the prevalence of what they call ‘adulterous relationships.” In retrospect, one would come to the conclusion that Maharaj misused his authority and imposed himself on helpless devotees for sexual favors.</p><p>However, the case was much more than the sex life of a priest of a sect that came into existence in medieval times. These reformers, even though influenced by colonial worldviews, didn’t harbor any guilt in their Hindu identity. They aimed to wipe off what they saw as heretical practices from faith and return to the original setup. Interestingly, their idea of Vedic setup mirrored a lot with Victorian morality. These people wanted their women to be educated but not take charge in religious matters, which was the case in the Pushtimarg tradition.</p><p>At the same time, drawing any of them parallel to what Martin Luther is to Christianity would make sense only in a limited context. That is in labeling the popular sect of the day as heretic and giving calls for a return to the original ways. While Luther wanted the participation of all and every individual, being a priest himself, The roots advocated by reformists in India were hyperexclusionary; whether they comprehended it fully or not is a separate thing. Sects like Pushtimargi, Ramanandi, and others that received the slander for being heterodox were the ones that opened the gates of salvation for all classes and genders in India. Their story is a classic case of ‘reformers in the past’, ‘regressive at present.’</p><p>References:</p><ol><li>The Nationalization of Hindu Traditions: Bharatendu Harishchandra and Nineteenth-Century Banaras by Vasudha Dalmia, Orient Blackswan Private Limited (2010)</li><li>A Prestigious Path to Grace: Class, Modernity, and Female Religiosity in Puṣṭimārga Vaiṣṇavism by Shital Sharma, McGill University (2013)</li><li>Socio-religious reform movements in Gujarat during the nineteenth century, by R. L. Raval, Gujarat University (1983)</li><li>How to Defame a God: Public Selfhood in the Maharaj Libel Case by J. Barton Scott, Taylor, and Francis (2015)</li><li>Creating a Community of Grace: A History of the Pushti Marga in Northern and</li><li>Western India (1479–1905) by Shandip Saha, University of Ottawa (2004)</li><li>Historical Series: The Maharaj Libel Case in the Bombay High Court by Prastut Dalvi and Vidhi Thaker, The Leaflet (2020)</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1a9f2267df7a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Building the Brand, ‘Mahatma’]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adarshrjha/building-the-brand-mahatma-c67e14d9714b?source=rss-b2d5b31f3206------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c67e14d9714b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mahatma-gandhi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[congress]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gandhi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[einstein]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-war-ii]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adarsh Jha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 May 2024 17:44:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-29T17:44:03.015Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SS8GRA1YfJmMaSkQWwyB6A.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Indian masses, or rather Gandhi’s followers, or devotees, anointed Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi to sainthood. This list grows as we delve deeper into the annals of pre-independence India. Many people seeking to rise in Congress leadership glorified him, parroting his name and advocating his impractical value of extreme and selective non-violence. One such admirer, Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan, heaped praise on Gandhi by offering to edit a book of essays on his life and work. In December 1938, Radhakrishnan met Gandhi in Wardha to secure his written endorsement for the immediate formation of a separate Andhra province, which Gandhi granted. Before leaving, Radhakrishnan proposed the idea of the book, which Gandhi approved. He also planned to present it on Gandhi’s 70th birthday, just ten months away, prompting Radhakrishnan to work quickly to deliver the book. Ramachandra Guha, in his book, lists people who contributed essays praising Gandhi, including Nobel laureates Albert Einstein, Pearl S. Buck, and Romain Rolland. In contrast, H. G. Wells displayed disdain for Gandhi, saying, “I will not write a line to boost up that old publicity bore.” Guha missed some names while mentioning those who refused to participate in the festival of Gandhi’s glorification but thankfully Radhakrishnan’s son did in his father’s biography. They were George Bernard Shaw, Bertrand Russell, and George Santayana. Anyway, the commemorative book was published and was about to be presented to Gandhi publicly, but he refused to attend any such event. Such a great man, right? He only allows them to publish a book praising him but not to present him in a public function. God hasn’t bestowed such austerity on anyone ever since. Interestingly, the world war had already begun before Gandhi’s birthday, and therefore, global attention was focused on much more important things than an individual’s supposed divinity.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c67e14d9714b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nehru’s War against Communalism — India’s First General Elections Campaign]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adarshrjha/nehrus-war-against-communalism-india-s-first-general-elections-campaign-465ad69cd44c?source=rss-b2d5b31f3206------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/465ad69cd44c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nehru]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sardar-patel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[congress]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adarsh Jha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Apr 2024 14:32:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-12T14:32:03.448Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Nehru’s War against Communalism — India’s First General Elections Campaign</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/269/1*A3xOTwDMhkvhpobHWrTxag.jpeg" /></figure><p>Jawaharlal Nehru ran from pillar to post defending Muslims against any Hindu retaliation in the aftermath of unspeakable atrocities committed upon helpless Hindus in newly-formed Pakistan. He declared a war against communalism in his first election campaign in 1951–52.¹ A month before the election started, Nehru orchestrated a major in-party coup and secured the post of Congress Party President as well. He snatched the post from Purushottam Das Tandon, a fellow Allahabadi who stood at a diametrically opposite end of the ideological spectrum to that of Nehru. While Nehru was an apologetic, non-practicing Hindu, Tandon harbored no such guilt. The latter was supported by Sardar Patel in the 1950 Congress Party elections against Nehru’s candidate, JB Kriplani. Tandon secured a handsome victory, garnering over 50% of the votes. It was a moment of major embarrassment for Nehru; therefore, in a display of juvenile sociological understanding, he labeled it a result that would only please communal and reactionary forces in the country. Furthermore, the disgruntled and intolerant Prime Minister of India refused to join Tandon’s working committee. With Patel’s demise in December 1950, Tandon lost a formidable force that could nullify Nehru’s overreach, making it untenable for him to continue as the party’s president. Interestingly, in an act of political somersault, Jawaharlal Nehru took control of both the party and government, something he saw as unprincipled when Patel was alive.² Observing these events in retrospect, it would not be a stretch to deduce that the whole argument of principles was nothing but his attempt to keep Patel away from securing complete control over Congress. Post that he left no stone unturned to caricature genuine Hindu grievances, an expression of communalism. There was hardly any evidence of a raging communal flare from the Hindu side in 1951, yet Nehru continued with his vicious propaganda to tarnish the majority community. Upon careful analysis, it can be said that his blatant lies were a reaction to another embarrassment he received due to Gita Press and Ram Rajya Parishad’s relentless campaign in defense of Hindu traditions. The first government of independent India, under the leadership of Jawaharlal Nehru, pursued reforming Hinduism by being a self-anointed high priest who, like colonial masters, descended upon the natives to civilize their beliefs. Hanuman Prasad Poddar, editor of Gita Press, rightly pointed out how Nehru was trying to distract people’s attention from urgent subjects concerning national security and poverty by widening fault lines in Hindu society.³ Nehru did all that at a juncture when the community had barely recovered from the catastrophe of partition. Owing to the most energized party machinery, which was flourishing with men and money, Congress secured a thumping victory. The landslide results perpetuated an insurmountable level of hubris in our first Prime Minister’s mind, deluding him to go overboard with his short-sighted policy decisions, which cost our nation dearly.</p><p>Sources:<br>1. Recalling Jawaharlal Nehru’s campaign in 1951–52 By Ramachandra Guha<br>2. Nehru: The Invention of India by Shashi Tharoor<br>3. Gita Press and the Making of Hindu India by Akshaya Mukul</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=465ad69cd44c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Erdogan’s Demand Halts NATO Expansion]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adarshrjha/erdogans-demand-halts-nato-expansion-bc741fbeab06?source=rss-b2d5b31f3206------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bc741fbeab06</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adarsh Jha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Jul 2023 17:17:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-07-10T17:17:49.899Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0YCcSq4qFuMpzlhEyVFEhw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Recep Tayyip Erdogan, President of Turkey</figcaption></figure><p>The NATO summit begins in Vilnius, Lithuania, as the Ukraine war completes 500 days. The US-led military coalition of 31 nations is headed for important decisions regarding the expansion and entry of new members. The ongoing Ukraine-Russia war will continue to be a key matter of discussion as the member states have provided military aid to Kyiv against Moscow’s aggression. One of the reasons behind Putin’s declaration of war has been the growing affinity of Russia’s former colony towards the Western Bloc, particularly the Ukrainian attempt to secure a NATO membership that could have jeopardized Russian territorial security. In a recent interview, Joe Biden expressed his reluctance to initiate the Ukrainian membership process until the war comes to an end, reiterating NATO’s continued support for Volodymyr Zelensky (the current president of Ukraine) and his forces. Meanwhile, there remains another nation, Sweden, eager to join the alliance. The Nordic state failed in an attempt last year when a member nation, Turkey, vetoed its entry. The same state has grown in its influence within the coalition in recent years owing to its diabolical dealings with nations antagonistic to the alliance, namely Russia and Iran. The major shift in aggressive Turkish foreign policy is credited to its autocratic president, Recep Tayyip Erdogan. Last year, while opposing Swedish entry, Erdogan accused them of providing sanctuary to members of the Democratic Union Party (PYD) and the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK). PYD is a left-wing political party with a major following among Syrian Kurds. The party is demanding an autonomous region of Syrian Kurdistan, to which Erdogan is opposed. Labeling it a terrorist organization, he has been trying to stall Sweden’s entry. Finally, today he revealed the barter that he would do in exchange for not vetoing the entry, which is that the European nations of NATO would initiate Turkey’s entry into the European Union. He said, “Come and open the way for Turkey’s membership in the European Union. When you pave the way for Turkiye, we’ll pave the way for Sweden as we did for Finland.” The demand proved to be a shocker for many experts, as they had at best presumed Turkey would agree merely with the resumption of a US defense deal. Turkey had earlier been expelled from the F-35 program as a punishment for going ahead with the purchase of Russia’s S-400 missile defense system. The move further led to the imposition of US sanctions on Ankara under the Countering America’s Adversaries Through Sanctions Act (CAATSA). With Erdogan playing a pivotal role in opening diplomatic channels between Ukraine and Russia during the war last year, it regained American amenity. Capitalizing on that, it has now put forward a daring condition that may even be construed as diplomatic blackmail for its entry into the European Union. Back in 2016, the talks regarding Turkey’s admission came to a halt as the European Parliament was skeptical about the disproportionate powers that resided with Erdogan and his autocratic way of governance. To which he reacted in a boastful manner and downplayed the coalition’s significance when compared to the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, of which he sought to be a full member. The extreme measures taken by Ankara to secure a seat there this time may not go well with its current allies in NATO. A while ago, the Swedish government acceded to the demand of Turkey to extradite Erdogan’s political opponent, which was later prevented by their courts. While the Swedish executive said that it has no influence over the judicial process, Ankara saw it as a delaying tactic. However, the recent episode of sacrilege of the Muslim holy text under the pretext of free speech garnered strong criticism from the Turkish leadership, as the President vowed to “teach the arrogant Westerners that insulting Muslims is not freedom of thought”. One wonders whether the exchange of membership endorsements is part of his “teaching” program or mere political opportunism. Along with Turkey comes the curious case of Hungary, the only other nation to oppose Sweden’s entry. Interestingly, Hungarian officials have said that if Turkey’s position changes, they will not obstruct the process, like they did in April when Turkey lifted its objections regarding Finland’s entry into NATO. Irrespective of that, the ball is in the western nations court for them to make the call about whether they will stall Swedish entry or give in to the diplomatic barter.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bc741fbeab06" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Fox’s Slaughter: Politics of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adarshrjha/the-foxs-slaughter-politics-of-zulfikar-ali-bhutto-525cb4773cb2?source=rss-b2d5b31f3206------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/525cb4773cb2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[pakistan-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bhutto]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pakistan-army]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[zulfikar-ali-bhutto]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pakistan]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adarsh Jha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 05 Jan 2023 12:42:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-05T12:42:31.624Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WjovbvFcjnxEcYIxMlqVMA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The world of political power resembles a jungle. Each individual in his quest to power exhibits the characteristics of certain animals wearing human skin. Lions are majestic, strong, and can stand alone yet instill fear in the enemy’s pack. Tigers are ruthless, elephants are mighty, cheetahs are fast etc. Though it is the pack of wolves which can bring any animal down irrespective of its size and might. They are unsparing even on their own, cannibalism isn’t unknown to them and a weak or injured leader can be their next feed. But the story isn’t about the wolves but of a fox, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, who outsmarted, tamed and ruled them before meeting the inevitable fate.</p><h3>Wolves draw first blood:</h3><p>After a decade of political chaos, following the formation of Pakistan and death of its founder Mohammad Ali Jinnah, the nation saw its army marching down the streets of the capital and orchestrating a coup. The move was led by General Ayub Khan, a man in his early 50s who had a three decade long military career. His career was marred with infamy as the Generals in the British Indian Army had noted him to be a coward and a failure as Commanding Officer. Fate supported him when the nominated Commander-in-Chief of Pakistan Army died in an air crash along with another senior officer in December of 1949. Defense Secretary Iskander Mirza then began lobbying for Ayub’s name to Prime Minister Liaquat Ali Khan as the former considered Ayub to be a loyalist who he can then use to further his own political ambitions. Ayub became the Commander-in-Chief in 1951 succeeding the last British Commander-in-Chief of Pakistan Army, General Sir Douglas Gracey.</p><p>Iskander Mirza underestimated his ‘<em>loyalist’s</em>’ ambition. In 1958, Mirza was President of Pakistan and fearing law and order situation he decided not to conduct elections but rather impose martial law. Ayub, whose tenure expired in 1955 had got multiple extensions since then all due to Mirza’s faith in him. On the eve of martial law proclamation Ayub met Mirza and assured him that he will handle all matters while the latter remains a nominal head. The signs were clear to Mirza that his days were numbered and he was proven right. The man who he nurtured was now too powerful. Two weeks later he assumed the office of Prime Minister and formed a 12 member cabinet and after carefully assessing the situation of martial law he sent three of his Generals to get Mirza’s resignation from the post of President signed, who then advised him to leave the country as soon as possible. However to his credit Ayub fulfilled the last wish of his former patron by arranging his flight to London. The leader of wolves had acquired the power.</p><h3>Fox enters the game:</h3><p>While Ayub betrayed Mirza but there was another close confidante of the latter who chose to side with Ayub against Mirza, possibly due to his weak political stature, he was Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. Bhutto was son of the former diwan of Junagadh state, Shahnawaz Bhutto who was one of the richest men in post partition Sindh province and a friend of Iskander Mirza. Mirza nominated Bhutto, at a young age of 29, as a member of the delegation to the United Nations and other international conferences. His successes abroad and no political baggage, as opposed to other stalwarts of Sindh, ensured him a place in Ayub’s 12-member cabinet where he got the portfolio of Minister of Commerce and Industries.</p><p>Knowing the fate and popular consensus is in favor of Ayub as the people rallied behind him in the hope of the beginning of a new era in Pakistan, Zulfikar chose to be one of his several sycophants. To no one’s surprise Zulfikar excelled at sycophancy too and kept on rising the power ladder in the Ayub administration. In his public addresses Bhutto heaped praises on his master like a devoted bard. At Jacobabad he said,</p><p><strong><em>“In President Muhammad Ayub Khan we have a dauntless leader… I can assure the people that never has a cause had a man with a greater purity of purpose.”</em></strong></p><p>The bard was rewarded with the Information and Broadcasting portfolio and several other important offices and leadership roles in delegations abroad. Still he didn’t get the portfolio that he desired, which was the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. When Manzur Qadir resigned from the office of Foreign Minister in 1962 he was succeeded by former Prime Minister of Pakistan Mohammad Ali Bogra over Zulfikar, due to his lack of experience, who was appointed his deputy. Meanwhile he worked on convincing Ayub to restore electoral politics in Pakistan under a tight grip of his administration. By excluding several politicians who opposed the new Constitution, electoral politics was resumed and Bhutto secured an easy victory from his native place, Larkana. Soon fate too worked in his favor and Bogra passed away paving way for Bhutto’s promotion to office, who by then became Ayub’s most trusted adviser, and a political troubleshooter.</p><p>From the month he assumed the office of Foreign Minister he displayed his hawkish behavior as he criticized Nehru for <em>“a growing and insatiable appetite, capable of devouring a Junagadh, a Hyderabad, and a Kashmir, with ambition to establish hegemony”</em>, accused Indian defense minister of giving war threats and addressed,</p><p><strong><em>“Kashmir is to Pakistan what Berlin is to the West.”</em></strong></p><p>By the end of year there was a law and order crisis in the Indian state of Jammu and Kashmir when a Holy Relic went missing from Hazratbal shrine, though it was restored in a week, a massive protest erupted that led to communal riots in several parts of the subcontinent. Meanwhile Bhutto worked on relations with China and secured her support on Kashmir which was a shift from their previous stance of neutrality. A few months later Sheikh Abdullah, prominent Muslim leader of Kashmir, was released. He has been under detention since 1953. The political climate of Kashmir saw temperatures soaring and passions brewing. Bhutto was confident about Kashmiri Muslim’s inclination towards Pakistan, which he told Farooq Abdullah a decade later:</p><p><strong><em>“Let India double the aid which it is giving to Kashmir, say, for three years. For the same period, Pakistan will stop all aids to ‘Azad Kashmir’ (Pakistan Occupied Kashmir). Thereafter, plebiscite may be held. The result will still be in favour of Pakistan.”</em></strong></p><h3>Trapping the leader of the wolves:</h3><p>After the humiliating defeat at the hands of China in 1962 war, India brought a change in its military policy that included an arms build up for any similar act of aggression by its hostile neighbors. With the demise of Jawaharlal Nehru a political void arose that inflated Bhutto’s confidence and he firmly believed that India was in no position to unite against a large-scale insurrection followed by a war. He proposed his idea to Ayub Khan he had flattered with the hope that he will be recognised as the foremost leader of Asia since Nehru is no more. Ayub was now the dictator of Pakistan for more than half a dozen years and wanted to build an unforgettable legacy. Awarding himself the rank of Field Marshal, ironically as someone who never won a war and had a dismal track record in the world wars, he was confident of changing the geography of the subcontinent with his military might. Another factor that boosted his belief was the image of Lal Bahadur Shastri, a noted Gandhian and believer in non-violence, who was nowhere near the political stature of his predecessor. When Ayub met Shastri he was unimpressed and considered him to be an <em>“inconsequential fellow who could not be expected to meet the challenge of a crisis.”</em></p><p>But before marching against the enemy outside, Ayub had to consolidate the support within which was now being challenged by an old political player. Popularly known as Madr-e-Millat, or Mother of the Nation, Fatima Jinnah was sister of Mohammad Ali Jinnah and was one of the founding figures of Pakistan. In the year 1965 she ended her self imposed political exile and became the leader of the combined opposition challenging the ‘dictatorial’ regime of Ayub Khan. Incidentally she was the one of those who hailed Ayub’s coup back in 1958. She tried to lure Bhutto to her side by offering the same portfolio which he held in the Ayub administration. Bhutto declined as he knew that Ayub was too powerful to lose even though Fatima was acquiring a lot of popular support. He was proven right as Ayub secured victory in the elections while Fatima tried to gain sympathy by calling it rigged but to her despair her political adventure came to a permanent end.</p><p>After a round of skirmish in Kutch, Pakistani leadership enthusiastically launched an offensive with a faith in their superior military might. As per an estimate Pakistan had 765 tanks, one heavy regiment with 155 mm guns and 8-inch Howitzers against India’s 720 tanks, 120 mm mortars and one heavy regiment of 7.2-inch guns. On 1st September 1965, Pakistan army launched Operation Grand Slam with their Patton tanks rolling into India aiming to cut Kashmir off. Initial retreat of Indian front posts gave them hopes of accomplishing the task easily. However Indian Army retaliated in a disproportionate manner and marched straight into Pakistan’s Punjab province meanwhile Indian Air Force started bombing enemy’s tank battalion. The Ayub administration was caught by surprise as Bhutto had assured them that Shastri’s leadership was too indecisive to make their forces march towards the Pakistani capital. When asked by Ayub about the strategic failure, Bhutto shifted the blame on the American complicity but the former could see through his convoluted and clueless theories. To his relief U Thant, the Secretary General of the UN, had visited both the countries during the war, acting as an interlocutor pressurizing both the countries for a ceasefire.</p><h3>Betrayal and a new beginning:</h3><p>Bhutto was ordered to address the session of the Security Council on the night of September 22–23. Knowing fully well that Pakistan was going to surrender and he will be one of the leading persons to be blamed for the misadventure and humiliating defeat. Bhutto delivered a fiery speech in which he spread outright lies, accusing India of aggressiveness and wanting to destroy Pakistan, concluding his address by saying,</p><p><strong><em>“When we say that we are giving the United Nations a last chance to settle the Jammu and Kashmir dispute, we are saying that we are determined not to let a righteous cause be abandoned. It is not the will of Allah that the victims of injustice and aggression should have no higher court of appeal.”</em></strong></p><p>Target audience of the speech were neither the international community nor the Indian state but ordinary citizens of Pakistan for whom Bhutto became their foremost anti-India voice. The popular anger shifted entirely upon Ayub Khan who then tried to save his face at the Tashkent agreement by signing an agreement of both armies going back to the pre-September status quo. Zulfikar saw the time was ripe to switch sides as Ayub had completely sidelined him in his cabinet. He resigned from the post of Foreign Minister and dubbed the Tashkent agreement as a political surrender. He further went on to say that Tashkent had turned a military victory into a defeat.</p><p>Trying to imitate the success of communist parties in neighboring India, Bhutto started his political front called Pakistan People’s Party which aimed at a class struggle against Ayub Khan’s dictatorial and pro-capitalist regime. Party’s manifesto <em>‘Islam is our Religion; Democracy is our Politics; Socialism is our Economy; Power Lies with the People’</em>, reflected its ambitious aim of amalgamating left wing ideology and with Islamic religious beliefs. Such a declaration was strongly condemned by religious leaders, clergymen and right wing Islamic party like Jamat-i-Islami as they called PPP’s socialism to be <em>‘atheistic’</em> and<em> ‘anti-Islam’</em>.</p><p>As in the jungle, irrespective of the weakness of the leader of wolves, he cannot be killed by a mere fox as long as the pack is strong. So was the case with Ayub who was unpopular but Bhutto was in no position to grab the power. But that was the moment when the wolf pack took to cannibalism and the successor emerged, Gen Yahya Khan.</p><p>While Ayub espoused the demeanor of a polished administrator, Yahya, the new military dictator and President of Pakistan was like an abrasive soldier who couldn’t handle the intoxicating power. Though that wasn’t Zulfikar’s concern as he had quite an experience in handling military dictators. His primary concern was the rise of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, most popular leader of East Pakistan and a vocal critic of <em>“colonial exploitation”</em> by West Pakistan and its political establishment. Mujib came up with a six-point demand that can be summarized as a demand of autonomy for East Pakistan in all affairs except for <em>“defense and foreign policy”</em>.</p><p>The Pakistan National Assembly seat divide was uneven and surprisingly favorable to East Pakistan which had 164 out of 313 constituencies while West had only 138 seats. Bhutto advised Yahya against conducting elections and suggested an alternate plan of running the country together and not letting East Pakistani capture the national front. He further went on to say that by killing some 20000 people there will bring all the matter under control. The advice was brought to action after the thumping victory of Mujibur Rahman which led to waves of immigration towards India. In the wake of an extreme humanitarian crisis India began preparing for the inevitable war.</p><h3>Decimation of Wolves, Fox gets crowned</h3><p>Yahya Khan had entered into total war against India as desired by Zulfikar Ali Bhutto who possibly knew after Tashkent that it was not possible for the Pakistani Army to defeat India in a conventional war. The result of 71 war was worse than any Pakistani could have thought of which was a surrender of 93000 troops. The scale of surrender was only next to those which happened during the second world war. The spine of the Pakistani Army was crushed and their noses were rubbed on the ground. They no longer commanded the same respect in the eyes of a common citizen as they had held earlier.</p><p>The time had arrived for Zulfikar to take the centerstage. He landed in Rawalpindi and with a sad look on his face, a cover to hide his unending joy, he took charge of the country as Chief Martial Law Administrator and brought an end to 13 year long reign of the Army. The all powerful Zulfikar Ali Bhutto addressed the nation that he would bring an end to the deadly crisis and build a prosperous and progressive Pakistan as envisaged by Mohammad Ali Jinnah. The time was ripe for him to bring a change in the Army and therefore he did away with the post of Commander-in-Chief by creating a designation of the Chief of the Army Staff and appointed General Tikka Khan, butcher of East Pakistan, as the first COAS of the Pakistani Army.</p><p>The first challenge for the now veteran politician, diplomat and newly crowned head of state was to negotiate at the diplomatic table with India. Seven years back he was at the same spot but in a better condition as he had someone to put the blame on for the Tashkent agreement. Contrary to that the responsibility to prevent further humiliation for his country was entirely on his shoulder in Shimla. Surprisingly the Indian nation that decisively won the war in mere 13 days and sawed the enemy state into two halves, lost miserably at the negotiating table to a political snollygoster. Bhutto got the territory back while Indians merely got <em>‘false’</em> assurance of peaceful resolution of conflicts in future without going to war.</p><p>The success of the Shimla agreement made him the most powerful civilian figure in Pakistan’s history only next to Jinnah. It was too overwhelming for a man who was full of insecurities due to his background. Two major ironies of his career were: Bhutto hailed from a zamindar family but tried centering his domestic politics around socialist ideas and secondly he hailed from Sindh and attempted to be the dictator of the state machinery which was primarily dominated by Punjabis &amp; Pathans. Therefore he formed alliances with parties of opposing ideologies and continued as de facto ruler. With that he moved towards a major reform in Pakistan’s polity which was the 1973 Constitution that had a provision of capital punishment for any attempt to overthrow or subvert the Constitution in any way in Article 6. Bhutto hoped that by doing so he had brought a permanent end to the military takeover of the country.</p><h3>Anarchy and the Resurrection of Wolves</h3><p>As Bhutto’s reign progressed he took a public stance of peace with India as open belligerency was no longer feasible for his state. He said</p><p><strong><em>“I say to my people as I would say to the people of India: do not be sworn to eternal hostility against each other; if you do, only your common enemy, which is squalor and poverty, will triumph.”</em></strong></p><p>His statement coincided with the time when there was an insurgency going on in Balochistan somewhat similar to what had been seen in the then East Pakistan two-three years back. Here also Tikka Khan was commanding the charge of bringing an end to the insurgency.</p><p>The dependency on the military was on a continuous ascent as Pakistan faced another challenge in North West Frontier Province. With the shift of power in Afghanistan in the hands of Sardar Mohammad Daud Khan who voiced his support in favor of separatist movement <em>“Pakhtunistan”</em> (or Pashtunistan), Bhutto’s paranoia intensified. Bhutto began arming and supporting Afghan dissidents who were opposed to the regime in Afghanistan. Global politics saw a chaotic period in 1973 as the west got involved into the Arab-Israel conflict with the start of the Yom Kippur war. Bhutto was elated and offered assistance to the anti-Israel coalition. Meanwhile his government was working on a project to build nuclear weapons supported by Libyan dictator Muammar Gaddafi.</p><p>Bhutto had once remarked,</p><p><strong><em>“Pakistan will develop an atom bomb even if we have to eat grass.”</em></strong></p><p>The nuclear project faced a temporary setback due to his pro-orthodox domestic policies. In 1974 he introduced an amendment to the Constitution and declared that Ahmadis were non-Muslims. It led to massive protests from the community including prominent Ahmadiyya Muslims like Abdus Salam. Salam was the scientific advisor to the Ministry of Science and Technology and was one of the leading scientists of the nuclear programme. In his protest against the amendment he resigned from his post, left the country and became an outspoken critic of nuclear weapons. However the project again gained momentum when nuclear physicist AQ Khan, who later went on to be known as father of Pakistan’s atomic weapons program, joined.</p><p>Meanwhile Armed Forces were regaining strength and respect of the common populace as they gave service to the <em>‘religious’</em> cause abroad and were successful in controlling the secessionist forces within as well as closely working with scientists on the nuclear project. Along with that a <em>‘decolonization’</em> of the Pakistan Army began in the year 1976. Since the time of its birth from British Indian Army in 1947, it had borrowed heavily from the cultural mooring of the erstwhile British masters in character (which can be seen in the Indian Army even to this day). The motto of Army was changed to Iman, Taqwa and Jihad fi sabeelillah (Faith, Obedience to God and Struggle in the path of Allah). Tablighi Jamaat began visiting army cantonments and compulsory reading of <em>‘Quranic Concept of War’</em> for the officers. The Army moved ahead of territorial nationalism which was imposed by Ayub Khan post defeat in the 1965 war and remolded itself to religious nationalism in both theory and practice.</p><h3>Fox outsmarted, and the Inevitable End</h3><p>A Brahmin astrologer once predicted about Bhutto’s ascent to power till the age of 50 beyond which he refused to comment. The year was 1977, Bhutto’s 50th year when he enquired the ISI officials about his popularity in the country. The latter presented a documented singing peans of his marvelous charisma that has enthralled the public in his favor. The kind of panegyric was strikingly similar to what Bhutto used to do for Ayub Khan a decade and a half ago. However, like Ayub he also chose to overlook the obvious sycophancy as he was intoxicated with power. It was evident from another fatal mistake which he had committed two years back. In 1975 when Bhutto’s loyal supporter General Tikka Khan completed his tenure a search for his successor began. Tikka Khan suggested a couple of names which included officers who were both his trustworthy as well as competent commanders only to be disapproved. Bhutto’s mind was stuck on a man who he had met in Multan, a fairly unambitious soldier with doubtful competence but an excellent servant who remained at his perpetual beck and call throughout his visit, Lt. General Zia-ul-Haq. Zia was the last name (also the junior-most) in the list of probable names for the post of COAS. But he has caught the attention of Bhutto who believed he can be used as a puppet to control the Army. Again strikingly similar to what Iskander Mirza thought while lobbying to promote Ayub Khan for the post of Commander-in-Chief. Zia-ul-Haq became the Chief of Pakistan Army by superseding seven senior Lt. Generals.</p><p>Bhutto, with every institution under control, went ahead with the 1977 elections. Three days after the announcement nine opposition parties formed a united front called Pakistan National Alliance (PNA). PNA was led by former Air Marshal Ashgar Khan who took a religious line by raising the slogan of <em>‘Nizam-e-Mustafa’</em> against the incumbent left-wing authoritarian regime. A paranoid Bhutto feared for his defeat as he could see himself losing power and the election turning out like that of 1970 where he came second to Mujibur Rahman. He took to the same ill-advise that he gave to Yahya Khan then that was of resorting to administrative excesses. In order to be seen as being elected unopposed he kidnapped his opponent from Larkana and kept him under confinement till he got elected. Rampant rigging took place all over the country, the state machinery was hand-in-gloves with the ruling party. The election results were announced and as expected, Bhutto’s party secured a majority and got more than two-thirds of the seats in the National Assembly which enabled him to amend the constitution as desired.</p><p>Opposition took to streets against the ruling party and a full scale political agitation was launched by Ashgar Khan. PPP supporters defended the verdict by accusing the opposition of being unable to produce evidence of rigging and pre-planning the agitation with the aid of Americans who were desperate to get rid of the incumbent government. Bhutto resorted to using nationalism as his defense, he accused the American establishment of fuelling anarchy to overthrow his government and prevent the nuclear armament. Protests became violent, more than 200 lives were lost and a state of emergency was imposed with the military marching in affected areas. Zia knew that his time had come to take the command of the nation. In a meeting with Bhutto, Zia warned him that the agitation was leading to erosion of discipline in the army. The troops were not willing to fire on their fellow countrymen particularly in Punjab. Bhutto understood the seriousness of the crisis therefore he lifted the emergency and asked the agitators to come to the negotiation table. At the same time he introduced several measures to appease the conservatives including the banning of alcohol and gambling.</p><p>However none of the overtures yielded any result as the agitators had no faith left in Bhutto, therefore the time was ripe for a coup. Zia launched <em>‘Operation Fairplay’</em> and Bhutto was overthrown. The new military dictator addressed the people,</p><p><strong><em>“When the political leaders failed to steer the country out of a crisis, it is inexcusable for the Armed Forces to sit as silent spectators. It is primarily for this reason that the Army perforce had to intervene, to save the country.”</em></strong></p><p>Zia arrested his former master and branded him <em>‘a murderer and a corrupt villain.’</em> Bhutto had thought the Zia was from Arain clan, a non-martial group of Punjab, therefore <em>“was unlikely to form deep alliances with the Pathan or the Rajputs, two communities well represented in the armed forces”</em> but to his misfortune he was wrong.</p><p>Bhutto saw three of his predecessors committing one fatal mistake each or it can also be said he played a big role in the mistakes committed by two of them, Ayub’s and Yahya’s. The three mistakes were Iskander Mirza having blind faith on a military man Ayub Khan, Ayub getting mesmerized by Bhutto’s panegyric and Yahya Khan getting paranoid and resorting to tyranny of power. It were these single mistakes that brought the fall of each one of them. But in case of Bhutto he committed all three mistakes: blind faith on a military man, Zia, getting mesmerized by his and ISI officials’ sycophancy and resorting to unfair use of state machinery to secure power. Therefore his end was worse than his predecessors.</p><p>Zia engineered the plan to eliminate the most cunning character of Pakistan’s political history. Bhutto had allegedly ordered the killing of Nawab Mohammad Ahmed Khan, the father of his vocal critic and a member of parliament Ahmed Raza Kasuri in 1974. The investigation of the case gained steam once the regime changed and in the process of due investigation the director general of the Federal Security Force, Masood Mahmood testified against Bhutto. Bhutto was awarded the death penalty by the Lahore High Court’s five-judge panel, which was presided over by Justice Maulvi Mushtaq Hussain, a close aide of Zia. The judgment was later upheld by the Supreme Court as well with a split verdict of 4:3. Finally in the last attempt to save his life, he sent a mercy petition to Zia. A massive international pressure too was building up as there was a deluge of executive clemency petitions from a number of world leaders, including President Carter, Leonid I. Brezhnev, Hua Guofeng, and Pope John Paul II. However Zia was adamant to crush the snake’s head forever and hence rejected his mercy petition. Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, the fox who tried to tame, and successfully did so to an extent, the pack of wolves, the Pakistan Army, was executed 4 April 1979.</p><p>References:<br>1. Pakistan: At the Helm by Tilak Devasher<br>2. https://www.dawn.com/news/664894/flashback-the-martial-law-of-1958<br>3. Bhutto: A political biography by Salman Taseer<br>4. Makers of Modern Asia by Ramchandra Guha<br>5. Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto: Quest for Power by Dilip Mukerjee<br>6. https://bhutto.org/index.php/speeches/speeches-from-1948-1965/reply-to-nehru-and-menon-statement-at-lahore-july-14-1963/<br>7. https://www.nytimes.com/1964/02/18/archives/3-kashmiri-moslems-held-in-theft-of-prophets-hair.html<br>8. My Frozen Turbulence in Kashmir by Jagmohan<br>9. Zulfi bhutto of Pakistan by Stanley Wolpert<br>10. 1965 Turning the Tide: How India Won the War by Nitin A. Gokhale<br>11. India’s Wars: A Military History (1947–1971) by Arjun Subramaniam<br>12. Pakistan: Between Mosque and Military by Husain Haqqani<br>13. https://www.dawn.com/news/787645/islamic-socialism-a-history-from-left-to-right<br>14. Pakistan: Courting the Abyss by Tilak Devasher<br>15. https://www.indiatoday.in/magazine/neighbours/story/19810215-pak-president-general-zia-gets-saudi-arabia-to-bankroll-final-phase-of-nuclear-programme-772644-2013-11-29<br>16. https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20191014-abdus-salam-the-muslim-science-genius-forgotten-by-history<br>17. https://www.nytimes.com/1977/04/22/archives/bhutto-puts-3-cities-under-martial-law-pakistani-leader-in.html<br>18. https://www.nytimes.com/1979/04/04/archives/bhutto-hanged-in-pakistan-jail-for-murder-plot-body-is-reportedly.html</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=525cb4773cb2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An Ambedkarite’s view of Ambedkar’s conversion to Buddhism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adarshrjha/an-ambedkarites-view-of-ambedkar-s-conversion-to-buddhism-69ca667908bf?source=rss-b2d5b31f3206------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/69ca667908bf</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adarsh Jha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 01 Jan 2023 14:57:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-01T14:57:18.517Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On October 14, 1956, Dr. B R Ambedkar along with 3,65,000 of his followers renounced Hinduism and converted to Buddhism. The decision to embrace Buddhism came after more than two decades of deliberation upon the choice of faith which can give Dalits an egalitarian society. Since then there have been instances where Dalit leaders have publicly renounced Hindu faith. Most recently being that of lawmaker Rajendra Pal Gautam who attended an event on October 5 where hundreds of people took pledge to convert to Buddhism and not consider Hindu deities as gods.</p><p>The reaction to Rajendra Pal Gautam’s move from leading political parties of India has been perplexing. On one hand all of these parties revere Ambedkar, as the maker of modern India, while on the other hand they criticize one of his followers who emulated his actions. That raises several questions regarding whether Ambedkar’s intended shift in the socio-political discourse of India from converting into Buddhism happened or not?</p><p>Anand Teltumbde in his essay “Strategy of Conversion to Buddhism: Intent and Aftermath” addresses the same. He mentions in his essay the earliest instance of Ambedkar’s public deliberation on the question of conversion out of Hindu faith. Anand writes, “he [Ambedkar] had been variously advocating religious conversion to Dalits as a means of escaping caste bondage right from 1928 through his journal Bahishkrit Bharat.” He further writes, “In the Bahishkrit Bharat edition of 15 March 1929, under the editorial ‘Notice to Hinduism’, Ambedkar exhorted Untouchables under the bold heading, ‘If you have to convert, become Musalman’. After analyzing the futility of becoming Buddhist and Arya Samajist, he also dismissed Christianity because ‘even Christianity could not escape castes in India’.” Ambedkar clearly saw Islam as an egalitarian faith which could provide Dalits with an avenue to free themselves from the clutches of ‘caste’.</p><p>However by the late 1930s, we witnessed that Muslim League had come up with actively pushing the two nation theory. They had shown no support to the cause of the Depressed Classes. Around the same time Hindu Mahasabha under the leadership of BS Moonje reached out to Ambedkar.</p><p>Anand writes, “The Hindu Mahasabha (HMS) was palpably threatened and deployed a dual strategy to persuade Ambedkar against embracing any ‘foreign’ faith and threatened him against the conversion itself. Its ex-president B.S. Moonje had a compact with Ambedkar (called the Moonje–Ambedkar Pact) that before taking any decision he would confer with HMS leaders and other Hindu organizations.” Moonje went on to persuade him to convert to Sikhism and extended his support to safeguards available to Hindu Dalits if they converted to Sikhism. However it didn’t materialize as Anand states, “A section of the Akalis (Jat Sikhs), however, felt that the influx of a mass of Dalit converts would Dalitize Sikhism and opposed the proposal. After realizing that Sikh society also followed casteism, Ambedkar dropped the idea of joining the Sikh fold.”</p><p>It took him a decade of thought before he finally reached the conclusion that the path of Buddha is the way forward for his cause. He proposed a theory in his essay, ‘The Untouchables: Who Were They and Why They Became Untouchables’, which was published in 1948, about Dalits originally being ‘a distinctive ethical and political community of Buddhists’ who ‘refused to accept Brahminism’. Therefore embracing Buddhism was presented to Dalits as a mere homecoming into their original ancestral faith. However his Buddhism can be summarized in his own words as a path which has ‘all the positive content of Marxism and none of its pitfalls.’ To which Anand concludes, “that Marxism stayed the conceptual ‘second best’ to all his [Ambedkar] choices.”</p><p>His interpretation of Buddhism was met with mixed responses from Buddhist some considered it as ‘against Buddha’s [Buddhism which was] based on compassion’ while others supported it as ‘a creative interpretation that respects the spirit of the Theravada legend and precept.’ Anand further notes, “A keyword in Ambedkar’s Buddhist discourse is ‘justice’, based on ‘liberty, equality and fraternity’, the slogan of the French Revolution that became the motto of bourgeois France. Therefore, his Navayana came to be seen as repackaged Western liberal thought. Ambedkar would invalidate this critique by saying that he had not picked up this slogan from the French Revolution but from ‘my master’, the Buddha. It is a different matter that there is no reasonable equivalent of such a saying in Buddhism that anticipated it to re-emerge in bourgeois France.”</p><p>However, to his despair the author concludes, “Ambedkar’s Navayana Buddhism was meant to be a radical ideological system, supposedly matching the radicalism of Marxism sans its assumed thrust on violence and dictatorial orientation…. Ambedkar’s dream of making Buddhist conversion a preparatory phase for political revolution gets more and more distant with every passing day.”</p><p>Reference:<br>- The Radical in Ambedkar: Critical Reflections, Edited by Suraj Yengde &amp; Anand Teltumbde</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=69ca667908bf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Inception of Khalsa]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adarshrjha/the-inception-of-khalsa-d409c673bc5e?source=rss-b2d5b31f3206------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d409c673bc5e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[aurangzeb]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kashmiri-pandits]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[guru-teg-bahadur]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sikhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[guru-gobind-singh]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adarsh Jha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 Aug 2022 17:07:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-07T17:07:49.195Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In the 12th year of his reign as the sixth Mughal Emperor, Aurangzeb embarked on his religious aim of converting his empire into an ideal Islamic state. The ruler of such a state is God himself while the civil administration is a mere enforcer of his commandments. One’s loyalty towards the sovereign is measured by one’s faith in the one true god. Disbelief in him is equivalent to sedition, hence punishable. To eradicate infidelity in his realm, Emperor Aurangzeb issued his infamous imperial orders. He ordered his Governors to demolish the schools and temples of infidels and strongly put down their teachings and religious practices. Along with that, he pulled down several Hindu temples and reimposed the religious tax, jizya, on Hindus. These acts thronged him into volatile political conflicts on several fronts for the rest of his life. Hindu kings as well as the common populace engaged in bloody battles for the protection of their faith.</p><p>Meanwhile, Sikhs were going through a tumultuous time as multiple claimants had entered the scene trying to replace Guru Tegh Bahadur. They had employed all sorts of intrigues against him but Guru Tegh Bahadur successfully managed to bring the required stability and order among Sikhs. In Punjab, he saw the calamitous condition of people of his faith as Aurangzeb’s Farman had dictated the Governors to destroy the temples of the Sikhs and expel Guru’s agents from the cities who were there to collect tithes and presents of the faithful. In those days Guru’s presence provided the much-needed solace to the people and shone like a beacon of hope for the faithful. Historian JS Grewal and SS Bal in their book, Guru Gobind Singh (A Biographical Study), write that while Aurangzeb was fighting a battle at the Afghan front, Guru Tegh Bahadur set out for his tour of the Malwa region of Punjab. His followers grew and many people converted to the Sikh faith including Muslims. Infuriated by such an act, Aurangzeb ordered his arrest but the Guru’s tour had ended and the orders couldn’t be executed for the time being. In the year 1675, the Guru went on to his next tour, this time he was invited by a Sikh Sangat at Agra. Oblivious about the orders against him, he reached Agra where he was arrested along with his five companions and escorted to Delhi. At Delhi, his companions were tortured to death to force Guru Tegh Bahadur into submitting to Islam which he refused and attained martyrdom.</p><h3>Did he die for Kashmiri Pandits?</h3><p>As the popular story goes, in the year 1675, a group of Kashmiri Pandits who had been victims of Islamic tyranny approached Guru Tegh Bahadur and requested him to protect them. On the divine uttering of his 9-year old son, he agreed to help them and said that they must convey to Aurangzeb that if he were to convert Tegh Bahadur to Islam, pandits would follow suit. The entire conversation emanates from a text which primarily focuses on the divinity of the Sikh Gurus that was written almost a century later. However, the historical facts do not corroborate any such happening. Guru Tegh Bahadur’s arrest was ordered not because he raised the voice of Kashmiri Pandits but because he had gained a lot of followers which even included Muslims. The arrest order was executed when Guru had gone for the Sikh Sangat at Agra which further proves that he was not headed to Delhi to raise the issue of Kashmiri Pandits in the Mughal Court. None of the historians, who support the hypothesis, has produced a single contemporary source that mentions the involvement of Kashmiri Pandits in the whole affair. Hence we conclude that the story of protecting Kashmiri Pandits is historically inaccurate.</p><h3>Power Dynamics of Hill States</h3><p>Guru Gobind Singh succeeded his father as the 10th Guru of Sikhs. As he was still in his childhood and there was a chance of Mughals trying to capture him, he and his followers shifted to Paonta from Anandpur. Khushwant Singh writes here that Guru Gobind Singh learned to ride and shoot as well as compose several poems. Meanwhile, Aurangzeb got entangled in a battle with Rajputs and a rebellion by his son, Akbar. From there he moved to Deccan with a large army where he ended up in a battle for the next 27 years with Marathas, till the end of his life and never returned north. Aurangzeb’s departure from the north was a huge relief to Sikhs as it diverted the Mughal pressure from them. At the same time, the situation was changing rapidly in Punjab. Sikhs had gained a considerable political influence backed by the military which became a huge cause of concern for the local Hindu kings. The king of that province, Kahlur state, Bhim Chand saw the consolidation as a direct threat to his sovereignty and numerous tussles between him and the Sikhs ensued over years. Historian Hari Ram Gupta writes that Bhim Chand was successful in forming a united front of fellow kings by calling Guru Gobind Singh an enemy of their religion as he was opposed to idol worship. However, he was not successful in his endeavour and Sikhs gained a firm position at Anandpur. Two years later the Hill Rajas following their old tradition of rebelling against the Mughals and stopped paying the annual tribute to them. Mughals responded by launching an offensive but the hill Rajas were able to put up a united front, which included Sikhs as well, and successfully resisted the attack. Though the resistance was successful, it could not have been carried out for long. Therefore, the confederate of hill Rajas chose a strategic retreat and entered into negotiations with the Mughal commanders. Negotiations brought temporary peace between the two sides and after a few years fresh conflict broke out. This time the Sikhs chose not to join the hill Rajas and maintained a neutral position. Aurangzeb who was having a tough time in Deccan ordered his son Moazzam (later Bahadur Shah I) to crush the rebellion. Moazzam crushed the rebellion and at the same time reciprocated the friendly gesture of Sikhs by leaving their territory unharmed. Hari Ram Gupta writes that Moazzam had great respect for saints which led to an amicable relation with Guru Gobind Singh. It is evident from the verses of Bachitra Natak which Guru Gobind Singh himself composed:</p><p><strong><em>“Babe ke Babar ke do-u<br>Ap kare Parmesar so-u<br>Din Sah in kau pahchano<br>Duni pati un kau anumano”</em></strong></p><p><em>[The successors of Baba (Guru Nanak) and Babar are distinct. God, Himself has created them. These should be recognised as Kings of Din (Religion) and those to be considered masters of the world.]</em></p><p>The conflict between the hill Rajas and the Mughal authorities gave Guru Gobind Singh ample time to formalize the structure of the institution which came to be known as Khalsa.</p><h3>Khalsa Formalised</h3><p>On the day of Baisakhi in 1699, a large congregation of Sikhs took place at Anandpur. Here, Guru Gobind Singh incorporated the order of Khalsa by baptising his followers and gave final shape to the religion of the ten Gurus. Evident from his address where he said,</p><blockquote>Do not follow the old scriptures. Let none pay heed to the Ganges and other places of pilgrimage which are considered holy in the Hindu religion, or adore the Hindu deities, such as Rama, Krishna, Brahma, and Durga, but all should believe in Guru Nanak and his successors.”</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/645/1*hUjste-_1zVN29k_LizCuQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Khushwant Singh writes,</p><blockquote>the address is based on the report of a newswriter sent to the Mughal Court and is vouched for by the Persian historian, Ghulam Mohiuddin” and he further says, “the results were visible within a few months of the famous baptismal ceremony, when a sect of pacifists was suddenly transformed into a militant brotherhood of crusaders. The hills around Anandpur began to echo to the beating of war drums and military commands.”</blockquote><p>The change further heightened the insecurity of Bhim Chand and other neighbouring Rajas. Fresh series of conflicts erupted and over the next six years, Khalsa fought several battles against the Hill Rajas, who were aided by the Mughals, to protect their sovereignty at Anandpur. Mughal forces were led by ‘faujdar’ of Sirhind, Wazir Khan who invested his full might against Khalsa. The latter showed exceptional courage and many of them laid down their lives for their faith including the four sons of Guru Gobind Singh. In the early days of 1705, Guru Gobind Singh had safely moved to Jatpura while his adversaries were searching for him elsewhere. Along with his followers, he continued ‘baptising’ Sikhs and formed a temporary base at Mukhtasar where his men repulsed the Mughal army of Wazir Khan. Meanwhile, Guru Gobind Singh wrote a letter to Emperor Aurangzeb which is now known as Zafarnama. About the impact of the letter, Khushwant Singh writes,</p><blockquote>Aurangzeb was apparently moved by the contents of the letter and issued orders that the Guru was not to be molested any further.”</blockquote><p>Guru Gobind Singh proceeded towards Deccan to meet Aurangzeb but by the time he reached Rajputana the latter died. Soon after Aurangzeb’s death, a succession war began. His son Moazzam, who previously had established friendly relations with the Sikhs during his tenure as Governor of Lahore, invited Guru Gobind Singh to Agra. The new Emperor welcomed Guru Gobind Singh and asked the leader of Sikhs to accompany him on a campaign towards the Deccan against his brother, Kam Baksh, who had challenged his succession. At the same time, Wazir Khan was getting restless as cordial relations between the two would have been disastrous for him in future. By the end of September 1708, the Imperial army halted at Nanded where two assassins attacked Guru Gobind Singh and wounded him. The Emperor sent his royal surgeons who stitched the wound but it didn’t heal fully and after a few days he passed away.</p><p>It will be fair to conclude that the institution of Khalsa was not aimed at defending Hinduism rather it formalised a distinct Sikh identity, separate from Hindus. Post the martyrdom of Guru Tegh Bahadur, the primary task of the tenth Guru was to maintain the sovereignty of Anandpur that was challenged by the Hill Rajas and Mughal governor. Also in Guru Tegh Bahadur’s time, some claimants of Guruship had approached Mughal Emperor Aurangzeb that led to a turbulent situation for people of the faith. To prevent any such chaos in the future, he invested the Guruship to Guru Granth Sahib as the permanent and inviolable source of spiritual guidance. Apart from that, it will be unfair to present his struggle as a fight against Islam as he never attacked or launched an offensive against the Muslim faith unlike Hindu kings like Maharaja Jaswant Singh, Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj and others.</p><p>Originally published at: <a href="https://pragyata.com/the-inception-of-khalsa/">https://pragyata.com/the-inception-of-khalsa/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d409c673bc5e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[British Punjab’s language crisis: Bhagat Singh’s perspective]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@adarshrjha/british-punjabs-language-crisis-bhagat-singh-s-perspective-e3585a94bc0a?source=rss-b2d5b31f3206------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e3585a94bc0a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Adarsh Jha]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 30 Jul 2022 05:55:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-30T05:55:10.785Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Indian political landscape has been marred by divisions on numerous grounds. Of the many fault lines being used by political parties to gain electoral benefits, a pertinent one is ‘language’. The formation of states on a linguistic basis is a reality, and a long-drawn struggle has been fought in regions ranging from Andhra to Assam, and it still continues in different parts of the country.</p><p>East Punjab (part of partitioned Punjab that joined India) witnessed a volatile movement for the cause of the <em>Punjabi Suba</em>. The movement led to a further divide between Hindus and Sikhs as the language conflict had communal undertones. Sikhs demanded a state where the official language is <em>Punjabi</em>, written in <em>Gurmukhi </em>script. Hindus, on the other hand, stood for <em>Hindi </em>in the <em>Devanagari </em>script.</p><p>The schism became more visible after the formation of the modern-day Punjab state in 1966. In the 1981 census, on the question of language, Lala Jagat Narain, a leading thinker of Punjab and founder of one of the most prominent Hindi newspapers, Punjab Kesari, urged Hindus to register Hindi as their mother tongue. Agitated by such a call, he was assassinated on September 9, 1981, allegedly on the orders of Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale. The state of Punjab later got engulfed in a wave of Sikh militancy and the communalisation of language was one of the foundations of the entire conflict. But could that have been averted? Did anyone offer an amicable solution to the problem?</p><p>A 17-year-old Sikh who had undergone thread ritual at an Arya Samaj ceremony as a child understood the conflict better than many of his contemporaries and saw how it could become a barrier to achieving the goal of a united India. In 1924, Bhagat Singh participated in an essay competition organized by the <em>Punjab Hindi Sahitya Sammelan</em> on the language debate in Punjab. It was a time of tussle between not two but three languages in Punjab. The languages were Hindi, Punjabi, and Urdu.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2-8KKi5mrZnEt86Xo5Jwpw.png" /></figure><p>Bhagat Singh begins his essay by highlighting how language and literature have been a chariot of revolution across the colonized world:</p><p><strong><em>“Perhaps Garibaldi could not have succeeded in mobilizing the army with such ease if Mazzini had not invested his thirty years in his mission of cultural and literary renaissance. The revival of Irish language was attempted with the same enthusiasm along with the renaissance in Ireland. The rulers so much wanted to suppress their language for the ultimate suppression of the Irish people that even kids were punished for the crime of keeping a few verses in Gaelic. The French revolution would have been impossible without the literature of Rousseau and Voltaire. Had Tolstoy, Karl Marx and Maxim Gorky not invested years of their lives in the creation of a new literature, the Russian Revolution would not have taken place, leave alone the propagation and practice of communism.”</em></strong></p><p>Revolutions of all kinds- from spiritual to cultural to political- have emerged from language. He mentions how the words of Guru Nanak brought a spiritual awakening in the region, and by the times of Guru Teg Bahadur, it became the voice of the voiceless and oppressed. In the times of Guru Gobind Singh, the voice of the voiceless transformed into a clarion call of rebellion against tyranny. However, post that era, literature in Punjab went on a continuous decline as the struggle for mere survival became of prime importance as the region suffered relentless invasions.</p><p>Bhagat Singh further compares the state of Punjabi society with that of Bengal. Drawing parallels between Swami Vivekananda from Bengal and Swami Ramtirtha from Punjab, he wrote that the near contemporaries established the glory of Indian metaphysics abroad, but while there’s an entire institution established by the former in Bengal, the latter doesn’t even have a memorial in his name in Punjab. Furthermore, while Bengali stalwarts like Devendranath Thakur and Keshav Chandra Sen are remembered, their Punjabi counterparts like Guru Gyan Singhji have been completely forgotten, even in their home province. The only reason he could think of was a ‘total lack of literary interest and awakening’. He laments the absence of a provincial language in Punjab, which existed in other provinces.</p><p>Pre-partition Punjab was a Muslim-dominated province, with Hindus and Sikhs being the significant minorities. Therefore, Bhagat Singh first assessed the majority community’s arguments in support of Urdu. Muslims had argued that since Urdu is the most spoken and the court’s language in the province, it must be adopted by all. Another argument was that Urdu’s script was comparatively better as it saved space. But the key question asked by Bhagat Singh was about the lack of Indianness in Urdu:</p><p><strong><em>“The urdu script cannot be called a perfect one and the most important point is that it is based on the Persian language. The flights of imagination of urdu poets — even if they are Hindi (Indian) — reach the saaqis (bar-maids) of Persia and date palms of the Arbs countries…. Their ignorance of Indianness and Indian literature is the main reason of this. When they cannot imbibe Indianness, how can their literature make us Indian? Students confined to the study of urdu cannot attain the knowledge of the classical literature of India. It is not that these texts cannot be translated into a literary language like urdu, but it will be useful only to a Persian in his pursuit concerning Indian literature.”</em></strong></p><p>He further urged the Muslims to Indianise themselves, following the example of Kamal the Turk.</p><p>On the question of a national language, he firmly believed in the principle of one common language that acts as a link between cultures, regions, and ethnicities. Using the example of a Punjabi and Madrasi trying to communicate, he opined that the medium cannot be an alien language like English, it has to be Hindi. He saw the flower of Indianness blooming to its full potential in the form of Hindi. That is what, according to him, Muslims failed to recognize and, therefore, <strong><em>“they keep repeating the demand for Urdu like a parrot and take an isolated position.”</em></strong></p><p>Though the situation in Punjab was unique, it was the time when the Lahore Singh Sabha movement was at its peak. Since its inception in the second half of the 19th century, it emphasized the promotion of the Punjabi language and specifically tried to popularize the Gurmukhi script. It was a script that was standardized by Guru Angad, therefore it held religious significance for the Sikhs. On the other hand, the Arya Samaj too held a strong base in Punjab, and the writings of Swami Dayanand Saraswati, which were critical of the Sikh Gurus, led to massive animosity between the two groups. Since Arya Samaj was a strong advocate of Hindi, Bhagat Singh wrote, <strong><em>“a few sentences of Satyartha Prakash caused malice and mutual hatred. The Sikhs, swept in the same stream, started hating even Hindi as well.”</em></strong></p><p>Bhagat Singh then addressed the issue of the propagation of Gurmukhi. He wrote, <strong><em>“Punjabi has not been able to become a literary language of the central Punjab. It is written in the Gurmukhi script and is now Known as Punjabi. It is neither widely prevalent nor has any literature or scientific significance. It was left unattended earlier, but even now the deficiency of its script disturbs those who are now attending to it.…. script is thus even more incomplete than Urdu, but when we already have a scientific and perfect Hindi script, what is there to feel hesitant about adopting it? The Gurmukhi script is only distorted form of the Hindi script…. The Punjabi language will start developing immediately by adopting this perfect script.”</em></strong></p><p>Though Bhagat Singh acknowledged the immense potential of Punjabi when it comes to capturing the imaginations of the people of the province. He lamented the fact that such a captivating language like Punjabi has not been adopted by everyone. He questioned Sikhs for basing their arguments in favor of Punjabi on religious grounds and hoped for an increase in <strong><em>‘literary awareness among the sikhs.’</em></strong><em> </em>He stood for an amicable solution between Hindus and Sikhs, that was offered by Mahatma Hansraj, which was the official recognition of the Punjabi language in Hindu script. Bhagat Singh believed <strong><em>“Punjabi will come closer to Hindi when it will adopt the Hindi script attempt creating its literature.”</em></strong></p><p>However, these proposals were rejected by the extremists and the language politics became another foundation for the Hindu-Sikh religious conflict that saw a violent phase in post-partition India, leading to the loss of the lives of several Hindus and moderate Sikhs. It can only be speculated whether accepting such a proposal would have resulted in bridging the gap between communities and paving the way for national integration.</p><p>References:</p><ul><li>Amritsar Mrs Gandhi’s Last Battle by Mark Tully &amp; Satish Jacob</li><li>भगत सिंह और उनके साथियों के सम्पूर्ण उपलब्ध दस्तावेज़</li><li>The Problem of Punjab’s Language and Script by Bhagat Singh (Marxists Internet Archive)</li></ul><p>Originally published at: <a href="https://pragyata.com/british-punjabs-language-crisis-bhagat-singhs-perspective/">https://pragyata.com/british-punjabs-language-crisis-bhagat-singhs-perspective/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e3585a94bc0a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>