<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by David Anderson on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by David Anderson on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@agilemanager?source=rss-9acd43f5ba75------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 09:07:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@agilemanager/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Fit-For-Purpose: Defining KPIs to Drive Appropriate Behavior]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@agilemanager/defining-kpis-to-drive-fitness-for-purpose-c3ad2af46738?source=rss-9acd43f5ba75------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c3ad2af46738</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[service-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[product-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metrics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kanban]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fit-for-purpose]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Anderson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Aug 2016 18:04:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-28T17:35:47.220Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>All KPIs should be recognizable by your customers. All KPIs should be fitness criteria metrics: they should affect whether and how customers select your product or service. If your customer doesn’t recognize or care about your KPIs then they aren’t “key”, “performance” indicators, they may indicate something else but they aren’t predictors of how well your business is performing or likely to perform in future.</h3><p>In my recent post, <a href="https://medium.com/@agilemanager/market-segmentation-based-on-why-c417b2c1f949#.ert03yub8">Market Segmentation based on “why”</a> I explained how we define Fitness Criteria Metrics. These metrics enable us to evaluate whether our product, service or service delivery is “fit for purpose” in a given market segment. They are effectively the Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for each market segment. All other metrics should either be guiding an improvement initiative or indicating the general health of your business, business or product unit or service delivery capability. If you can’t place a metric in one of these categories then you don’t need it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2_rKBfvgtifyDWMm.png" /></figure><h3>Fitness Criteria Metrics</h3><p>We left our story of Neeta the busy project manager, mother of 4 kids, having established that she represents a member of two market segments — the “working late ordering food for the team in the office” cluster, and the “feed my children, its an emergency!” cluster. We also determined that the main metrics of concern are: delivery time; quality — both functional quality (the menu and order accuracy) and non-functional quality (hot, tasty, artisan, gourmet or maybe not); predictability (of delivery time, and perhaps of quality too); safety or regulatory concerns, perhaps including trust that organic ingredients were used or not. In our example, these 4 main metrics apply whether Neeta is ordering pizza for the team or whether she is ordering for her family. However, the satisfaction thresholds vary significantly based on the context.</p><p>When Neeta orders for the team they are happy to wait an hour to 90 minutes for delivery. If minor errors are made in order accuracy it is unlikely to matter too much. However, there is a threshold. If some of the team are vegetarian then there must be some vegetarian pizzas delivered or we’d consider the order a failure. The menu is important in the sense that the geeks want a more exotic set of choices. They are fussy about their non-functional requirements. They want the pizza hot, tasty, artisan and gourmet. They aren’t too particular about predictability of delivery time or order accuracy. A 30 to 45 window for delivery is probably acceptable and a few minor errors in the order is also acceptable. They do care about health and safety in the restaurant but they only care about the traffic safety of the delivery boy in so much as it doesn’t endanger the quality of the pizza on arrival.</p><p>When Neeta orders for her family, the threshold levels are significantly different. The kids are really hungry and impatient and now they know that pizza is coming, they are super-excited about it. Fast delivery is essential. Predictable delivery is essential: the 6 year old is now running his countdown timer on his iPad. The menu was important but only in so far as it offered simple plain cheese pizza with tomato sauce. The kids are so excited that they won’t mind if the pizza is a little cold on arrival, nor will they mind if it got shaken up a bit during transportation. Order accuracy is important to the kids. If it isn’t a plain cheese pizza they will be extremely upset and unlikely to eat it at all. Meanwhile, mommy can worry about safety and regulatory concerns but they may have a preference for a restaurant that promises to use organic ingredients. They have no concept of whether they trust this assertion. The restaurant said it was organic — mommy can worry about whether that is true or not.</p><h3>So in summary…</h3><p><strong>Kids<br></strong>Fast delivery<br>100% order accuracy<br>Not concerned too much on non-functional quality<br>Predictable delivery<br>Not concerned too much on safety or regulatory concerns</p><p><strong>Geeks<br></strong>Longer delivery acceptable<br>Some errors in order accuracy acceptable<br>Extremely fussy about non-functional quality<br>Wider tolerance for unpredictable delivery<br>Not too concerned about safety or regulatory issues</p><h3>Conclusions</h3><p>In 4 of these 5 categories we have significantly different fitness evaluation thresholds for these two segments.</p><p>If we are to successfully serve both segments, driving improvements so that we have high levels of customer satisfaction in both segments, we must use the higher thresholds with each metric as our benchmark. Alternatively, we need to segregate our service delivery by segment. We can do this by introducing two classes of service, one of each segment. This might work through pricing, for example, would Neeta pay a premium for the guaranteed fast delivery for the kids? Or it might work through capacity allocation and demand shaping based on it. We might, for example, refuse to take large commercial destination orders during peak times for domestic orders. In this example, we trade off educating our corporate clients to order earlier in the day, versus the risk that they will go elsewhere. We do this because we value the domestic market.</p><p>There is no formula for this. No right or wrong. We make choices for our business in terms of which segments we wish to serve and how well we wish to serve them. Choices come with consequences. We need to be prepared to live with these consequences and be willing to be accountable for them.</p><p>The metrics and threshold values we’ve developed for each of our segments should become the KPIs for our business and specifically in this case, the pizza delivery service. We should put in place the mechanisms, instrumentation and customer feedback, to measure these metrics. We can use the results at Service Delivery Reviews, Operations Reviews and Strategy Reviews to determine how well we are serving our markets, where we need to make improvements and which segments we wish to serve.</p><p>In my next post in this series I will take a look at the other types of metrics: those which guide improvements; and general health indicators. My experience working with clients in 2015 is that most existing KPIs are in fact merely general health indicators. As a consequence these businesses are optimizing for the wrong things and customer satisfaction and their ability to survive and thrive in the market is impaired. All KPIs should be based on threshold values for fitness criteria metrics derived from analysis of the market segments you choose to serve.</p><p>The book, Fit For Purpose — How modern businesses find, satisfy &amp; keep customers, is <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Fit-Purpose-Businesses-Satisfy-Customers/dp/0985305118/">now available from Amazon</a> and other online retailers.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c3ad2af46738" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Market Segmentation Based on “Why”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@agilemanager/market-segmentation-based-on-why-c417b2c1f949?source=rss-9acd43f5ba75------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c417b2c1f949</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[personas]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[market-segmentation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategic-planning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fit-for-purpose]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Anderson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Aug 2016 22:50:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-28T17:28:24.174Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Following my post on evaluating <a href="http://medium.com/@agilemanager/evaluating-services-with-fitness-box-score-a33015bddb1#.mz0d5nhu2">Fitness for Purpose using Fitness Box Score</a>, I thought I’d explain how we use these results to segment a market and provide insights into features, functions and service delivery levels expected by each segment. This isn’t your father’s market segmentation based on demographics, it is segmentation based on the consumer’s purpose — segmentation based on “Why!”</p><p>How do we know whether a change is an improvement? If we invest in improving service delivery capability is it actually working? Is the service fitter for purpose as a consequence? Do consumers value it more? If we invest in service features, functions or capabilities, are these valued by consumers? Are we over-serving a market with too much and too many, perhaps too soon?</p><p>These are fair and reasonable questions. They should drive our decision making about our portfolio of services, how we manage them, how we make decisions, and where we choose to invest, consolidate and amplify.</p><p>In evolutionary theory, a mutation survives and thrives if it is “fitter” for its environment [this is actually a gross simplification but it will do for introductory piece on marketing and strategy.] So how do we know whether or not a change to our service delivery capability makes it fitter for its environment? What do we mean by “environment” in this context?</p><p>“Environment” is the market that we deliver into. So “fitness” is determined by whether the market feels our product or service and the way we deliver it, is “fit for purpose.” So to understand “fitness” to enable and drive evolutionary improvements, we first need to understand our market and what defines “fitness for purpose.” To do this we segment the market by customer purpose and the criteria with which they evaluate our “fitness for [that] purpose.” …</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/743/1*f38yqKD63ara9L3cBNRcoA.png" /><figcaption>“Fit for Purpose” Services — innovation, execution &amp; delivery all contribute</figcaption></figure><p>At Lean Kanban Inc we create our market segmentation by clustering narratives about our customers. We do this by telling stories about them. The technique is a direct application of Dave Snowden’s technique from his Cynefin Framework. To explain this, I tell the tale of Neeta, a fictional project manager and mother of 4. Neeta is based on a real woman who works in the Canadian public sector and has considerable expertise improving service delivery with an agency of the Province of Ontario. Neeta needs to order pizza for delivery to her office to feed her team who are working late against a deadline. On another evening the same week, she needs to order pizza for delivery to her home to feed her children who are hungry because she came home late. Neeta doesn’t represent one market segment, she represents two! The reason for this is that the purpose, context and fitness selection criteria are different in each of the two contexts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*df0mYoZ2CXTSfSDE0oh89g.png" /><figcaption>Neeta a typical consumer for a pizza delivery service</figcaption></figure><p>When Neeta orders pizza for her children she needs: fast delivery — ideally within 20 minutes; she needs order accuracy — the kids only like plain cheese pizza; the non-functional quality doesn’t matter too much, the kids will eat cold pizza so long as it is cheese pizza; she needs a simple menu and predictable service; she wants delivery when promised because the kids need their expectations set and they are unforgiving; she also cares that the restaurant is clean and can be trusted to follow health and safety regulations; she may care whether or not they use organic ingredients because she is feeding her family.</p><p>When Neeta orders pizza for her office her needs are similar but some of the criteria vary and the threshold values are different: she needs delivery in up to 90 minutes; order accuracy is important but if one or two mistakes are made it won’t make a big difference, so long as some vegetarian pizzas are part of the delivery; however, the non-functional quality matters, hot, tasty, pizza with gourmet flavors and exotic ingredients are required for these discerning geeks; it doesn’t matter if delivery isn’t as predictable as it might be, so long as they show up eventually — the team are busy; and yes, she still cares whether the restaurant meets health and safety legislation standards but organic ingredients probably isn’t so much of a concern.</p><p>In other words, Neeta decides whether she likes the pizza service and whether she will use it again, based on two different sets of criteria, depending on her context. This may lead her to use different service providers for each purpose, if one provider can’t meet both sets of her needs. As a result Neeta represents two segments, not one.</p><p>How would you know that Neeta represents two segments and not just one? Traditional demographic profiling wouldn’t give you this insight! Well perhaps she uses different credit cards or payment mechanisms depending on context? And the delivery address is different. So there are some obvious clues. However, the people in the business who know Neeta’s story are the person who took her telephone order, and the delivery boy who delivered the pizzas. It is these frontline staff who understand consumers best.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7J3M7YncLj8163DVISQLNA.png" /><figcaption>Frontline staff know most about customer context and the purposes that drive purchases</figcaption></figure><p>If you are to cluster customer narratives to determine segmentation, you need to bring frontline staff into the story telling sessions. You need to listen for context, purpose and selection criteria and create segments based on affinity of these aspects of the market. Give each cluster a nickname. Recognize that an individual customer can appear in multiple segments depending on their context on a specific day and time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/637/1*hIBs3RftBs4oc4rbZpV5Nw.png" /><figcaption>Results of a Customer Narrative Clustering Session</figcaption></figure><p>This picture shows the results of a market segmentation exercise from a 2012 strategic planning session for Lean Kanban Inc and specifically the Lean Kanban University licensed certified training business. Six segments were identified through telling stories of actual customers and clustering the narratives by affinity then labeling them with memorable names — GRQ stands for “get rich quick”. We retired this segment in 2016 having successfully altered market perception to avoid customers with such expectations.</p><p>The challenge here for many companies is that the people who best understand the customer’s context, purpose and selection criteria are often the lowest paid, shortest tenured, highest turnover staff in the business. Foolishly, many companies under value, the value of customer facing staff. Traditional 20th Century service delivery businesses take a transactional view of customer interaction rather than a relationship view. If you value repeat business and you value the insights that will enable your business to evolve and survive in a rapidly changing market then you need to value customer facing people and involve them in your strategic planning.</p><p>Once you have the clustered narratives defining your segment, now select the segments you want to serve. This is a key piece of strategic planning. Which businesses do you want to be in? Which don’t you care about? Which do you want to actively discourage? Based on this you will develop the Fitness Criteria Metrics* to drive your management decision making and evolutionary improvement.</p><p>Now design your services tailored to the needs of each segment. For example, imagine we designed a premium pizza delivery service for the mother with hungry children to feed? We guarantee 20 minute delivery within a radius from our restaurant between 4pm and 7pm each evening. We need to reserve oven capacity. We need a simple menu and pizzas prepared and ready to bake. We may need delivery personnel on standby to meet the SLA. How much might this be worth? Sampling an audience of project managers at a conference in Stockholm, Sweden in 2014, the answer was 60 SEK (or about $6 US Dollars). Now, you get to decide whether you want that premium higher margin business? Can you build the capability? Can you successfully communicate it to the target audience? This is what really effective strategic planning is all about!</p><p>[* Designing Fitness Criteria Metrics, choosing their threshold values, and making them your KPIs (Key Performance Indicators) will be the subject of my next post.]</p><p>The book, <strong>Fit For Purpose — How modern businesses find, satisfy &amp; keep customers</strong>, is <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Fit-Purpose-Businesses-Satisfy-Customers/dp/0985305118/">now available from Amazon</a> and other online retailers.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c417b2c1f949" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Evaluating Services with Fitness Box Score]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@agilemanager/evaluating-services-with-fitness-box-score-a33015bddb1?source=rss-9acd43f5ba75------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a33015bddb1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[net-promoter-score]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kanban]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[service-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Anderson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Aug 2016 19:38:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-28T17:29:51.402Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When you use an evolutionary approach to improving your product, service or service delivery, such as Lean Startup, Kanban and Enterprise Services Planning then you need a method to evaluate whether a change to the design actually provides an improvement. Whether or not a product or service is fit for its purpose and likely to survive and thrive is always seen through the eyes of the consumer. How do you decide whether to double-down and enhance a service or whether to pivot? And to what and where should you pivot? Fit For Purpose Surveys and Fitness Box Scores are designed to provide these insights and guide important decisions on what to offer and how good to be at it.</p><p>Traditional approaches to market research and customer satisfaction surveys are not best suited to evolutionary approaches to a market as an ecosystem. It is important that a survey doesn’t second guess how or why a consumer is using a product or service. Instead it is better to use the survey to sense their purpose, needs and expectations.</p><p><a href="http://services.leankanban.com/fitness-purpose-score">Back in January I posted our first take on replacing Net Promoter Score for evaluating service delivery using our new Fit For Purpose survey method</a>. Since that initial posting, we, and others in our distribution channel globally have been experimenting with the technique. During our summer Kanban Leadership Retreat series of consultants’ camps we reviewed our results and revised the method. This post represents the official publication of version 2.0 of Fit For Purpose survey and the new Fitness Box Score reporting method…</p><h3>Motivation</h3><p>Firstly, a reminder about the motivation behind Fit For Purpose scoring and why we felt the need to introduce a new method of sampling customer satisfaction:</p><p>Fit for Purpose Score was created for two reasons. The first was the need to evaluate whether a product or service that is being developed and improved in an evolutionary, and experimental, fashion, is in fact improving in the eyes of the consumer. The second, and not unrelated motivation, came from client dissatisfaction with the use of Net Promoter Score (NPS) which was often described as lacking actionable guidance. Net Promoter Score would tell a business whether its goods or services were more popular than before, or not, but often failed to provide any insights into what could be done to improve a bad score. We also desired to tie the results of customer surveys directly to actionable metrics, or Key Performance Indicators (KPIs). For example, if customers value delivery time, and their threshold of tolerance is 2 days, them the KPI for the service should be Lead Time with a service level expectation (SLE) of 2 days. When metrics are expressed this way and tied directly to customer expectations then we refer to them as Fitness Criteria Metrics and the level of acceptable performance as the Fitness Criteria Threshold Level, or just “threshold value” for short. Meanwhile, we’d like to provide a single number as an executive report that indicates how “fit for purpose” a given product or service is perceived by its consumers.</p><h3>Fit For Purpose Survey</h3><p><strong>Question 1.</strong> Tell us <strong><em>why</em></strong> you chose our [product or service]? Select up to 3 reasons or objectives you had when choosing our [product or service].</p><p>(a) ________________________________________</p><p>(b) ________________________________________</p><p>(c) ________________________________________</p><p><strong>Question 2.</strong> For each reason or objective in Question 1, please indicate how fit for purpose you found our [product or service] in fulfilling your expectations. Please score each reason or objective separately using the following scale</p><p>5. My expectations were exceeded<br> 4. My expectations were fully met<br> 3. My expectations were mostly met but a few minor concerns remained<br> 2. Some significant needs were unaddressed<br> 1. I got some value but most of my expectations were unmet<br> 0. I found nothing useful. It was unfit for this purpose</p><p>Score (a) _______ (b) _______ (c) ________</p><p><strong>Question 3.</strong> Tell us why you gave the score(s) in Question 2</p><p>(a) ________________________________________</p><p>(b) ________________________________________</p><p>(c) ________________________________________</p><h3>What We’ve Learned From Using Fit For Purpose Surveys</h3><p>Firstly, we learned that people often consume products or services with multiple purposes or objectives in mind. The survey has now been modified to allow for this. We believe that allowing up to 3 reasons is sufficient and doesn’t become overwhelming. Previously when we used paper forms we found respondents would modify the form to allow them to describe multiple purposes. With the relatively small sample set of surveys we have collected over the past 3 months, we believe that entering up to 3 purposes will be optimal.</p><p>Secondly, we have found that we wished to drop the use of Net Fitness Score. Net scores hide vital actionable information. This has been replaced with Fitness Box Score [see below].</p><p>Thirdly, we have found the results from the surveys to provide actionable guidance. They have also provided valuable insights into why people consume products or services and this has enabled refined market segmentation and more focused marketing messages. We have found it easy even using manual effort to cluster responses to Question 1 to provide a set of purposes, and to cluster responses to Question 3, to provide actionable insights. We can also correlate answers to Question 2 against declared purposes to better understand consumer behavior and what we wish to amplify or dampen through our marketing.</p><p>Fourthly, to calculate overall scores, we are currently taking the best score indicated by an individual. We are considering experimenting with explicitly asking for an overall rating separately from specific reasons, purposes or objectives.</p><p>We have also found that people aren’t always honest about their reasons. Some purposes can be personally embarrassing and individuals are reluctant to admit them. For example, people attending our conferences who are really just having a paid vacation at their employer’s expense and are uncomfortable admitting it.</p><p>Finally, a word of caution, this approach is still nascent and evolving as we learn from its usage. A recent survey conducted in Spain after a training class, produced no result better than 3 with the somewhat philosophical response that “no purpose could ever be truly and completely fulfilled.” Whether these Spanish philosophers are an outlier and an anomaly remains to be seen.</p><p>Also, we developed this survey for use with services. It isn’t clear yet how it will play out with physical products such as lawnmowers or toothbrushes. What is sure, is that we will keep learning from the use of Fit For Purpose Surveys and we expect some further refinements in the method.</p><h3>Fitness Box Score</h3><p>Fitness Box Score replaces Net Fitness Score. Scores of 4 or 5 are considered “fit for purpose”. Scores of 3 are considered “neutral” as the consumer is likely to be sufficiently happy that they may provide repeat business or recommendations, certainly won’t speak badly or our product or service, but are offering us potential ways to improve and refine the product or service, if we can adequately capture their responses to Question 3. Scores of 2 or below are considered “unfit for purpose.”</p><p>Previously, Net Fitness Score was modeled after Net Promoter Score, where the net score is the percentage of responses indicating Fit For Purpose less the percentage indicating Unfit For Purpose. However, net scores mask valuable information. To illustrate this consider the degenerate case of 50% indicate Fit for Purpose, while the other 50% indicate Unfit for Purpose. The net score is 0%. This is the same result as 100% indicating a neutral 3 out of 5. These are not equivalents. 100% voting 3 indicates our product is mediocre but could be improved. While a 50–50 split of Fit-Unfit indicates that we need to do better market segmentation and our product is already very adequate for some market niches. One result tells us we _must_ improve the product or service delivery, while the other tells us we ought to improve our marketing. As these are very different results, we feel net scores are highly misleading. Metrics designed for consumption by senior executives become dangerous when they provide misleading information and uncertain guidance. So Net Fitness Score is gone and it is replaced by Fitness Box Score, a system inspired by historical approaches to reporting baseball games.</p><p><strong>Fitness Box Score</strong> is written like this…</p><p><strong>[% Fit : % Neutral : % Unfit] (# responses / total sample population)</strong></p><p>For example, the overall Fitness Box Score for the Kanban Leadership Retreat APAC in Bali, Indonesia in June…</p><p><strong>[60:30:10] (18/20)</strong></p><p>There were 20 paying attendees. Of these 18 responded to the survey — 2 people had to leave early. Of the 18 who responded 60% thought the event was “fit for purpose”, 30% were neutral but largely satisfied while 10% had come to the wrong event and were unhappy, for them the event was “unfit for purpose.”</p><p>It is currently recommended that the scores are rounded to the nearest 5%ile although this creates the possibility for the numbers to add to 105 on some occasions.</p><p>When drilling into specific purposes we report the total sample population as those who actually responded to the survey. Here is the full set of analyses for the <a href="http://conf.leankanban.com/klr-mainbali">Kanban Leadership Retreat</a> event in Bali…</p><p><strong>Purpose &amp; Score</strong><br>Networking [85:15:0] (13/18)<br>Learn Kanban [45:45:15] (7/18)<br>Knowledge Sharing [50:50:0] (6/18)<br>Feedback &amp; Validation [75:25:0] (4/18)<br>Experience KLR event [100:0:0] (2/18)<br>Kanban Marketing &amp; Sales Strategy [0:50:50] (2/18)<br>Meet David J. Anderson [50:50:0] (2/18)<br>Improving Project Delivery [0:0:100] (2/18)</p><p>From these results, we can see that the majority of attendees come to Leadership Retreats for the reasons we hope — networking, knowledge sharing, feedback and validation. This being our first event in Asia Pacific we also attracted people who might have been better at a more general Lean Kanban Conference — learn kanban and improving project delivery.</p><p>With this particular survey we learned how we can improve our marketing message and we learned that we should consider offering a Lean Kanban Conference in South East Asia targeting a general Asia Pacific audience.</p><h3>Conclusions</h3><p>Fit for Purpose Surveys are proving useful. In general, we believe that a strong “fit for purpose” score will correlate to and be a leading indicator of a product or service that will thrive and survive. At this time, we would continue to use it in conjunction with other customer satisfaction survey methods. For example, Fit For Purpose Survey doesn’t explicitly ask “How did you like the location of the conference?” or “How did you find the catering and service at the venue?” However, if these were unsatisfactory we would expect them to show up in the answers to Question 3. There are times, however, where you do wish to ask explicit questions and seek specific answers.</p><p>As with all customer surveys, the great flaw in a method like this is that it doesn’t survey those who didn’t choose your product or service. We don’t have survey results for those who haven’t selected Kanban training or Lean Kanban conferences. So we are unable to tell whether our marketing is truly “fit for purpose” or whether it is dissuading potential customers and sending the wrong signals.</p><p>So Fit For Purpose Survey isn’t a silver bullet but it is a useful new marketing tool that is highly compatible with evolutionary approaches to improving products or services such as Lean Startup , Kanban and Enterprise Services Planning. We believe that analyses from these surveys will dramatically improve decision making on when to pivot or stick with an existing concept or business model, and the success of pivots will be dramatically improved through the insights on customer purpose and the resulting market segmentation derived from it.</p><p>The book, <strong>Fit For Purpose — How modern businesses find, satisfy &amp; keep customers</strong>, is <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Fit-Purpose-Businesses-Satisfy-Customers/dp/0985305118/">now available from Amazon</a> and other online retailers.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a33015bddb1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is Agile Costing You Too Much?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@agilemanager/is-agile-costing-you-too-much-94e8e5d74af6?source=rss-9acd43f5ba75------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/94e8e5d74af6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[agile]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kanban]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scrum]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Anderson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Mar 2016 21:04:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-03-11T21:04:41.194Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>For a decade now, Kanban has offered an alternative path to agility. At the time of writing my first book, Agile Management for Software Engineering in 2002, I believed that an alternative path was required because too many people were resisting adoption of Agile methods. After publication in 2003, I set about pursuing an alternative and Kanban is what emerged from that journey. So Kanban was for people and organizations who found Agile wasn’t a good fit for them, wasn’t suited to their culture or the nature of their business.</p><p>At the start of 2016, I’d like to take a closer look at why we need an alternative path to agility and identify the problems that are evident in the market with Agile methods and their adoption. The first in this series asks the question, “Is Agile costing you too much?”</p><p>In 2011, we collaborated on a conference in Finland called LESS. During a panel session which I facilitated, one question from the floor was “It seems to me, listening to the sessions at this conference that Kanban obviates the need for the Product Owner role in Scrum. I’d like to ask the panel, what would you do if you’d recently hired 400 product owners?”</p><p>Me, “I’m sorry, can I clarify that I heard you correctly, I thought I heard you say ‘400 product owners?’” “Yes, that is correct!”</p><p>“How many developers do you have?” “2,400. Our Agile consultants told us we needed one product owner for every six developers. So what should we do with these 400 new people we have hired?”</p><p>Last December, my colleague, Alexei Zheglov, was speaking with an Agile coach whose contract hadn’t been renewed. It is never nice to be laid off at Christmas. What had happened? Well, this coach responsible for coaching just six developers wasn’t renewed because there weren’t sufficient tangible benefits to justify the overhead. His contract was costing $150,000 every six months.</p><p>On December 24th, I met the CTO of CMB, a bank in China based in Shenzhen. This fairly mature IT organization was running a side-by-side comparison of Kanban against Scrum. The consultants and trainers for both methods were being supplied by the same firm in Shenzhen under a single purchase order. The Scrum coaching was requiring one full-time Scrum coach for every twelve employees. While only half the ratio I’d heard in Finland, this is still a significant overhead. More about this experiment later…</p><p>Late in 2014, I did some consulting for a large telecommunications equipment manufacturer here in the US. Specifically, I was advising a business unit based in sub-urban Boston. The general manager had brought me in because in his own words, “We’ve been doing Scrum for 6 years but we haven’t seen any improvements for at least the last 2 of those years.” The business unit had a Scrummaster for every 6 developers. I attended several retrospectives, usually facilitated by one Scrummaster and then each of the others in turn had an opportunity to speak up and report the Sprint for their teams. Later in the engagement I was discussing the need for someone to play the role of Service Delivery Manager for a kanban system. The GM asked me who should play that role. He suggested no one in his business unit had the skillset. So I innocently asked, “What do your Scrummasters do?” He replied that “they coach the practices of Scrum.” Since then I’ve come across many companies who describe their Scrummasters as Agile coaches and the ratio of coach to value-adding workers is in the range of 1:6 to 1:12.</p><p>The role of Product Owner is interestingly ambiguous in its definition. In some organizations, Product Owners are basically business analysts who write requirements. While in others, Product Owners have a role that is very specific to prioritization and they are the decision makers with respect to the sequencing of the work. Ken Schwaber described the Product Owner role as “the single throat to choke” and “the single ringable neck,” he clearly had decision making, responsibility and accountability in mind when he used those terms. For many the Product Owner is an interface between multiple competing business stakeholders and the delivery organization (or Agile team.) The Product Owner is a curious addition for Agile. At the founding of the movement, Agile was in part about removing middle-men, eliminating signal attenuation and having direct contact with customers — conversations rather than documentation. It is strange, therefore, that to facilitate such a process we need a new form of middle-man, the Product Owner, to prioritize the order of the conversations. Regardless, of exactly what the Product Owner actually does in your organization, it does seem that often these product owners are new hires to the organization and again the ratio of 1:6 seems to be common. One of our own clients in 2015 made a decision to hire about 20 such Product Owners. While it goes against standard Kanban coaching guidance, the client had their own reasons and justification for the decision.</p><p>There is a question whether the product owner is a value-adding role or not? In many organizations it appears that it is not: The product owner is a middle-man with authority over prioritization. While sequencing and scheduling when done well will generate value, the act of sequencing one item over another, does not add value to the items themselves and from a Lean value stream mapping perspective it’s a non-value-adding role. Even more curious then that Agile requires you to create non-value-adding positions.</p><p>So in some extreme cases, Agile methods appear to have added 2 new people in non-value-adding positions for every 6 in value-adding positions. Put another way, after the Agile transition, 25% of the workforce is additional “Agile” overhead for operating the Agile method. While this is at the higher end of the range, I believe that it is typical for operating expense budgets for IT / product delivery teams to be increased by around 14% to cover the overhead of non-value-adding Agile facilitation positions.</p><p>What about Agile training? There are many 2-day, and in the case of scaled Agile solutions, 3 and 4-day training classes available. Many of these come with short examinations at the end and certifications for passing. However, what appears to be the case is that these training classes do not prepare the workers to behave in an Agile fashion or to deliver the promised benefits of Agile methods. The classes often contain abstract or metaphorical content and are filled with games which while fun to play do not teach specific actionable behavioral change in the workplace. All of this is okay, because the Agile transition purchase order includes coaching as well as training and the coaching is essential because the training did not contain anything actionable. The workforce, however, are now “certified”. Strangely this certification does not mean they know how to behave differently or how to produce better outcomes. It appears to mean that they are now certified to receive coaching.</p><p>Let’s imagine for a moment that Agile was producing twice as much value than what preceded it. If this were true would you spend 14% more on operating expense in order to generate that additional value? Rationally, you would say yes. It is an obvious and simple executive decision. The ROI is clear. And therein lies the rub with Agile. How many supposedly Agile organizations can show such benefits? The best and most popular Scaled Agile Framework appears to scale by offering quarterly release planning and using 3 month time boxes. The so called “release train planning” involves getting everyone in a room together in order to resolve dependencies between work and to devise a suitable schedule of six incremental 2-week sprints.</p><p>One company I know of in Central Europe, transports up to 500 people by plane, train or private cars, to a location near Frankfurt every quarter in order to conduct the scaled Agile release train planning. What is this costing? If we conservatively budget 800 Euros per person for transport, lodging, and catering, and assuming the company has a meeting facility large enough and isn’t renting a banquet hall from a nearby hotel, then we might have a budget of 320,000–400,000 euros per quarter.</p><p>Meanwhile, releases are only coming every quarter. How often were releases happening prior to the adoption of Scaled Agile? And how much functionality was getting released? Is there any tangible evidence that Agile is delivering the additional value it claims?</p><p>I hear other claims that Scaled Agile is leading to inefficiencies synchronizing teams with some teams having to take down time while others catch up. So the efficiency of Scaled Agile is being called into question by some of its practitioners. I haven’t yet seen this explicitly with any of our own clients, so it is hearsay, until I have some solid evidence.</p><p>Around 10 years ago I worked with a group of Agile coaches from Sabre Holdings, a firm which included properties such as Travelocity and Last Minute. They were under pressure to show an ROI for the Agile coaching team. The Agile coaching department was costing around $2,000,000 per year and the senior leadership wanted, quite reasonably, to know what they were getting for that money. After some period of time, the group was unable to show real tangible ROI and it was closed down. Some of those coaches found employment with other Agile firms such as Rally. After a period of time, Sabre was once again dabbling with Agile and the costs for consultants and staff augmentation were mounting up. A decision was made to create a new in-house team again. This time the justification was merely deferred cost against consultants and temporary staffing. It was no longer necessary to show an ROI on value created, just enough to show that the internal cost was less than using outside help.</p><p>So there have been 15 years of Agile and yet we still don’t have very many case studies showing tangible business benefits and real ROI. Meanwhile, Agile consulting firms thrive on supplying the large numbers of coaches required to “go Agile.” Perhaps, it is time to ask, “Is there an alternative approach to agility that costs a lot less?”</p><p>Back to the CTO of CMB in Shenzhen that I met on 24th December. He told me that in 5 months, he’d managed to scale Kanban to 2000 people across 5 locations in China. That the adoption had institutionalized and he’d been able to make a tour of the various locations and inspect many of the Kanban implementations for himself. He told me that Kanban was producing greater productivity and efficiency than Scrum. He, however, didn’t elaborate much on this, and isn’t ready to share his data yet. He wants more evidence before he is prepared to go public. What he was willing to share is that the Kanban implementation had been achieved with a total of 200 days of training and consulting. This is a ratio of 1 day for every 10 employees. Meanwhile, Scrum coaching is costing 180 days for every 12 employees, in the same half year time period. He also confirmed that Scrum is failing to institutionalize and is requiring constant coaching.</p><p>To put this in perspective, in terms of per employee adoption cost, Kanban is costing this bank 1/150th of the cost of Scrum, and producing better results. How might this huge cost saving be possible? Well, for starters Kanban doesn’t require you to add people to your organization as coaches or product owners, instead it provides existing workers with a means to frame and make better quality decisions. Kanban is empowering and enabling. Workers become more effective at doing their existing jobs in the existing process and workflow — no need for coaching in a new role as part of a new process. It’s simply more effective to stick with what you do now and get better at it, than it is to make grand changes.</p><p>A week earlier I was in India where I saw a case study presented by a young consultant who was acting for a large Agile consulting firm, advising a large Indian outsource firm, to a large financial institution based in New York. They end client is a credit card company, “do you know [them]?” Because of the nature of the contracts between these firms, the actual details are covered by a non-disclosure agreement, so we can’t name names, or any specifics. The client had adopted Scrum largely enterprise-wide and had adjusted all their processes to facilitate a 2-week Sprint cadence. Despite this highly Agile sounding arrangement, actual customer lead times for changes to credit card processing systems were taking 130 days on average. With some courage, the consultant took it open herself to push through a single kanban system implementation. With no other changes, within 6 weeks, lead times had shrunk to just 12.5 days and the client was so happy they are pushing the consulting firm to implement more Kanban. This particular consulting firm is well known to be anti-Kanban and their sales people around the world actively dissuade clients from adopting it. So it took a courageous act from a single professional keeping the end client’s best interests at heart to create a huge improvement in value delivery.</p><p>That same week in India I saw another presentation where the kanban system had produced a 30% increase in revenue by enabling the firm to process more service requests faster. This is real ROI. Now would you spend 14% on OpEx to get 30% more revenue? Probably not! Revenue isn’t margin or profit. If you only got 30% more revenue but Agile was costing you 14% more OpEx you’d be losing money. The thing is, how many Agile implementations could claim 30% more revenue? Meanwhile, this Kanban implementation cost a handful of coaching days over 6 months. This story was a strange déjà vu with a <a href="http://lkbx15.sched.org/event/7b02e74635d7f70d74f1e71db0716806">case study presented at Lean Kanban Benelux by Tina Dudenhoeffer, a consultant, and Marianne Lanting of Winkle</a>. Again, they had increased revenue by 30% in only 5 months by servicing requests for market research surveys faster and more predictably using Kanban. The cost of this implementation was less than 20 consulting days from Tina plus training from Maarten Hoppen of our Netherlands based partner, VX Company. Marianne is a manager at Winkle and there was no additional cost for her.</p><p>In general these results while extreme sounding aren’t surprising. We already know from surveys and reports post Kanban training that our training is more effective than typical Agile training. Lean Kanban training is specifically experiential and uses immersion simulation games and exercises that simulate or model the actual working environment. Students leave our classes with specifically actionable ideas and designs for changes many of which can be implemented immediately at no or very low cost. They don’t need any or much coaching. They come out of the class understanding what to do and why they want to do it.</p><p>For 5 years now, we’ve been selling Kanban coaching engagements that typically look like 2–4 days per month for organizations up to a product unit (or 150 people) in size. Kanban coaching is typically centered around coaching managers on metrics, reporting, and holding the various Kanban Cadences meetings such as Service Delivery Review, Risk Review or Operations Review. We have often found ourselves bidding against Agile consulting firms recommending coaches are on-site for 4 or 5 days per week and often at the ratios we’ve discussed here 1:6 -&gt; 1:12 people. Bizarrely clients have often opted for the latter, usually for 2 reasons. We don’t quote hourly rates for our consultants, only daily rates, and if you do try to calculate an hourly rate, it will be higher than that for a typical Agile coach. We aren’t ashamed of this. We believe our coaching is far more effective because it focuses on high leverage activities that deliver more value, rather than the dogma of Agile practice adoption and behavior. Meanwhile, the quantity of consulting days and the number of consultants is dramatically less. Often clients are skeptical of this. Everyone else is advising them they need a lot of Agile coaches and a lot of coaching. They believe it is too risky to go with our model when we appear to be bucking the trend. It seems easier to follow the herd. It is common for us to be quoting less than 1/10th the cost of rival Agile consulting firms, typically, $30,000 — $50,000 against $300,000 — $500,000 and then to be told we didn’t win the business because, and to quote a VP from a travel technology firm, “You are too expensive!” This analysis was based on an hourly rate and not on a total contract cost. Sigh!</p><p>So, while we have a bank in China that is rolling out Kanban at large scale at less than one hundredth of the cost of Scrum, we have been and continue to be confident that Kanban, as your alternative path to agility, can be rolled out conservatively at only one tenth the cost of competing Agile and Scaled Agile methods. We also believe it delivers better results faster. If you are interested in learning more, please contact me through Lean Kanban Services, <a href="http://services.leankanban.com/">http://services.leankanban.com/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=94e8e5d74af6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>