<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ahmed Sherif Edris on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ahmed Sherif Edris on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ahmedtwotimes?source=rss-9e0744f10d83------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 10:37:01 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ahmedtwotimes/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Retention should be the True North Star for VCs when backing their coming tech product?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/included-vc/why-retention-should-be-the-true-north-star-for-vcs-when-backing-their-coming-tech-product-e67e6f1ccd07?source=rss-9e0744f10d83------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e67e6f1ccd07</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[venture-capital]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ahmed Sherif Edris]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 Jan 2026 09:02:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-26T09:02:14.654Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Why Retention is So Hard for new tech products? And how to fix it!</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*tPRRwucA6Ad3nwo-" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@mikeanywhere?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Mike Lewis HeadSmart Media</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h3>TL; DR</h3><p>👉 <strong>The One Metric That Matters:</strong> VCs obsess over retention curves before any other metric because retention data reveals product-market fit within weeks, not months.</p><p>📊 <strong>The Physics of Retention:</strong> Retention follows predictable geometric decay patterns (50% drop from D1→D7, another 50% from D7→D30) regardless of product quality. This is a mathematical law, not failure.</p><p><strong>❌ You Cannot Fix Bad Retention:</strong> If Day 1 retention is below 10%, no amount of A/B testing, notifications, or new features will save the product. Complete redesign or pivot required.</p><p>🎯 <strong>The Golden Cohort Rule:</strong> Early adopters have 3–5x better retention than users acquired later. As you scale, retention gets worse, not better. This is predictable and unavoidable.</p><p>💰<strong> B2B Has a Structural Advantage: </strong>While user retention declines, revenue retention can increase (NRR &gt;100%). This expansion revenue is the holy grail of SaaS business models.</p><p>🌳<strong> Nature &gt; Nurture: </strong>Some categories have retention ceilings (hotel booking apps, event planning) that no design can overcome. You cannot fight nature; you must accept and work within category constraints.</p><p>📈 <strong>Viral Growth Without Retention = Death:</strong> Products like BranchOut achieved 400M users but failed because D2 retention was &lt;1%. Viral vanity metrics mask retention failure.</p><p>🧩 <strong>Category Matters Most:</strong> D30 retention for social apps averages 16% vs. 4% for health apps. Product excellence can improve retention by 20–30%, but category determines the ceiling.</p><p>⏰ <strong>Timing Is Critical:</strong> “Why now?” isn’t just a pitch question, it’s the difference between buildable and unbuildable retention curves. GPT-4 made AI products suddenly feasible. Oversaturation made specific social tools viable.</p><p>🎪 <strong>Great Retention Is Rare and Magic</strong>: 50%+ D30 retention happens once every couple years. It doesn’t come from optimization; it comes from fresh insights about what users actually want.</p><p>I’ve been staring at retention curve data for 5-plus years now. I was a founder, a current product consultant, and now a VC wannabe! And back at my time at AUC’s Center for Entrepreneurship and Innovation, I end up meeting hundreds of startups each year, many of them are students who apply to our sister program at <a href="https://gust.com/programs/startup-accelerator-spring-25">AUC Venture Lab’s acceleration cycle</a>. (And yes, we just announced the spring cohort and you can apply now).</p><p>But back to retention; I’ve seen thousands of curves, and it’s among the first things I ask for when evaluating a new startups. I’ve looked through thousands of data rooms, analyzed retention curves sliced across many segments and denominators. I’ve also seen it from the other side, as someone building products. I’ve run hundreds of A/B tests and drafted countless variations of onboarding and notification emails in attempts to bend the curve. Yet despite mountains of evidence, founders and inexperienced investors continue to mistake explosive user acquisition for product viability.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ycmkt4hpo-JPn6Jg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The data is unforgiving. In the ChartMogul 2023 SaaS Retention Report analyzing over 2,100 SaaS businesses, companies with net retention rates over 100% grow at 43.6% annually three times faster than those below 60%, which grow at just 13.1% per year. Yet retention has become harder than ever. More than half of SaaS businesses experienced declining retention rates in 2022 compared to 2021, marking a fundamental shift in market dynamics.</p><p>In this 10 part analysis, I’ll attempt to reveal the uncomfortable truth that venture capitalists (and founders) know all too well: <strong>you cannot fix bad retention. </strong>Viral growth with poor retention inevitably fails, and the products that survive and thrive are those built on a foundation of genuine user retention from day one. I’m also going outline ways fellow founders and Product Managers can utilize to escape this rabbit hole!</p><h3>Part One: The Physics of Retention; Understanding Immutable Laws 🔬</h3><p>One of the most surprising discoveries in product analytics is that retention <strong>doesn’t follow random patterns, but rather geometric curves with predictable half-lives</strong>. Regardless of product category or quality, retention curves demonstrate a consistent mathematical relationship that behaves almost like the laws of physics.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/672/1*5-5j_ryUmN6gzh4wH9zitQ.png" /></figure><p>The pattern is remarkably consistent across devices:</p><ul><li>Day 1 (D1) to Day 7 (D7): Users drop by approximately 50%</li><li>Day 7 to Day 30 (D30): Users drop by another 50%</li><li>Day 30 onwards: The curve either flattens toward a sustainable level (ranging from 5–15% for average products) or continues declining toward zero</li></ul><p>What makes this pattern remarkable is its universality. Whether you’re building a fitness app , a productivity tool , or a social platform, the mathematical relationship holds true. <strong>This isn’t a failure of product design, it’s a feature of human behavior. Users sample new products, and most find insufficient value to justify continued engagement.</strong></p><p><strong>The Non-Negotiable Rule is you can’t fix bad retention</strong>. This is perhaps the most important principle that separates successful VCs from novice investors. You cannot fix bad retention with A/B testing, notifications, or new features. This is non-negotiable. Period. The research is definitive: when Day 1 retention falls below a critical threshold (typically around 10–15%), the product exhibits what venture capitalists call “no product-market fit.” Adding more notifications doesn’t help, often it even accelerates churn. Running countless A/B tests on landing pages or onboarding flows provides only marginal improvements. The fundamental problem isn’t tactical; it’s strategic. When BranchOut, the Facebook application designed to help users build professional networks, reached 400 million Facebook users through aggressive viral tactics, it seemed like a phenomenal success. At its peak, BranchOut had 12 million monthly active users with 250,000 downloads per day. Yet less than 1% of users returned the day after joining. The product exhibited “leaky bucket” dynamics where it grew rapidly because of viral mechanics but had essentially zero retention. The inevitable result: from 14 million users, the product collapsed to 3 million within months, then faded into irrelevance.</p><p>The lesson VCs should internalize is that if your Day 1 retention is 10% and you want to reach 50%, you can’t make marginal improvements. <strong>You need a complete product redesign!</strong></p><p><strong>Founders should take note and try to:</strong></p><ul><li>Pivot the core value proposition entirely</li><li>Reposition against a different competitive set</li><li>Redefine who the actual customer is</li><li>Transform the interface from a feed-based to a structured step-by-step workflow</li></ul><p>This is why investors should be deeply skeptical of products with low early retention metrics. <strong>It signals fundamental misalignment between product and market as early retention predicts late retention. </strong>You’ll never see a retention curve that starts at 5%, dips to 2%, then recovers to 30%. It’s mathematically impossible! This predictive power has profound implications for venture capital evaluation. It means that:</p><ul><li><strong>Investors can evaluate product viability within weeks, not months</strong>. By analyzing D1, D7, and D30 retention, VCs can often predict whether a product will succeed long-term without waiting for 6-month or 12-month retention data.</li><li><strong>Early signals matter more than total addressable market size.</strong> An founder claiming a $10 billion TAM with 5% D7 retention is far riskier than one pursuing a $500 million market with 35% D7 retention.</li><li><strong>The product’s core appeal is tested immediately.</strong> If users don’t find value in the first week, they won’t find it later. Extended onboarding, feature-rich second phases, and advanced monetization won’t save a product with poor early retention.</li></ul><p>This principle explains why VCs should ask for retention curves before almost any other metric. It’s the earliest practical window into whether the fundamental product-market fit exists. Another “grey area” Investors should look into is the difference between revenue Retention and Usage Retention. Especially with B2B SaaS products</p><p>For consumer products (B2C), usage retention almost always declines. Your Netflix cohorts watch less over time, your Uber users take fewer rides, your Spotify listeners discover fewer new artists. The decline is inevitable. But here’s where B2B SaaS products have a structural advantage: while usage might decline, revenue from retained customers often increases. This is called Net Revenue Retention (NRR). For example, Slack’s user cohorts show declining usage retention, not everyone uses Slack daily after the first year. But the revenue from each customer cohort typically increases. This boils down to three main reasons:</p><ul><li><strong>Network effects drive expansion </strong>as more users in the organization adopt Slack, each customer account expands to use more seats</li><li><strong>Workflow integration deepens </strong>as teams discover new use cases and begin using Slack for more workflows, justifying larger plans</li><li><strong>Switching costs rise</strong> as deep integration into team operations makes leaving increasingly expensive; underscoring that distribution is always king</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/774/1*OPEMJd7FhvhVQKq-6qUapw.png" /></figure><p>The benchmark for B2B SaaS excellence is an NRR above 100%, with top performers hitting 115–130%. This structural difference is why B2B SaaS companies command premium valuations as they can generate growth from their existing customer base without constantly replacing churned users</p><h3>Part Two: The Nature vs. Nurture Framework. Why Some Categories Are Doomed to Fail 🌳🎯</h3><p>One of the most profound insights for venture capitalists evaluating products is understanding that <strong>retention is partially determined by nature, not nurture. No amount of exceptional product design, superior UX, or clever growth hacking can overcome the fundamental nature of certain product categories</strong>.</p><p>Some product categories have inherently low usage frequency and retention. A hotel booking app , by definition, serves an infrequent use case. People don’t search for hotels daily; they book a few times per year. No matter how brilliant the design, no matter how many notifications you send, the natural usage frequency caps the retention potential. Similarly, medical reference guides are rarely used daily. Weather apps have strong retention despite infrequent use because they serve a functional need repeatedly. Banking apps achieve good retention because money is important and people check their accounts regularly.</p><p>In this part, I’l explain why certain business ideas are structurally challenging for venture capital. and how can founders and investors pivot hurdles along the way. If you’re building a wedding planning app (highly seasonal, infrequent), your retention ceiling is limited by the nature of weddings, not product quality. Smart VCs understand this and either: <strong>Accept the category limitation and focus on monetization efficiency, Expand the category to higher-frequency use cases, or Layer in different business models and move from say commission on bookings to subscription for premium features</strong></p><p>Uber is an excellent case study in this principle. Early on, Uber rides were primarily for airport transportation. A typical low-frequency use case. But Uber recognized the category limitation and gradually expanded the frequency of use by creating Uber for restaurants, Introducing UberEats delivery, Adding Uber Money financial services, Enabling commute-to-work usage through UberBus and introducing subscription packages. <strong>While the ride-sharing retention curve still declines, the revenue retention curve increases because users interact with the Uber ecosystem multiple times daily for diverse use cases.</strong></p><p>One of the most counterintuitive findings in venture capital analysis is that <strong>retention actually gets worse as you scale user acquisition, not better</strong>. This stems from a principle called the Golden Cohort effect. The first users to discover your product are typically the most motivated, the most digitally savvy, and the best-fit for your solution. They find your product through organic discovery, friend referrals, or targeted early marketing. These “golden cohort” users exhibit fundamentally different behavior than users acquired later such as having higher engagement and daily active usage with greater willingness to endure friction and bugs offering an overall higher lifetime value and spend. When founders expand acquisition to various user groups as Android users , emerging markets , paid advertising channels , or mass-market segments , the new users acquired become systematically lower quality than golden cohort users making what product managers call “stickiness” harder</p><p>Research from game analytics firm Upsight revealed that the golden cohort (users acquired in the first week of a game’s launch) show dramatically different monetization patterns than users acquired 90 days later. The first cohort had higher transaction frequency, purchased higher-value items, and showed better long-term retention curves.</p><p>This fundamental dynamic uderscores the investment principle outlined earlier;<strong> VCs often evaluate founders based on early retention metrics rather than scaling metrics</strong>. A product showing 40% D30 retention from an early, organic cohort is far more investable than one showing 20% D30 retention from a scaled, paid acquisition base.</p><h3>Part Three: The Asymmetry of Churn. Why Reactivation Economics Never Work 😢</h3><p>Products managers discovered something VCs should take note of. There is an <strong>uncomfortable asymmetry in user behavior: it is far, far easier to lose a user forever than to win them back</strong>. This asymmetry has profound implications for customer acquisition strategy and the viability of retention tactics, creating a reactivation problem that puts the startup at 10x cost disadvantage</p><p>When a user churns from a product, three things happen . A) They shift to a competitor or alternative. B) Their expectations have been reset by the virtue of experiencing a different product paradigm and approach C) Your product is no longer part of their routine, AKA you’ve been removed from their daily habit</p><p>Some Founders and Product Managers resort to various approaches ️aiming to reactivate their user base. One of them is breaking their users away from their new habit, practically undoing the switching costs they’ve incurred and the new workflows they’ve built. They also launch campaigns that try remind them of the product’s value proposition. However these interventions don’t solve the root cause, overcoming their users’ skepticism users already decided you weren’t good enough; persuading them otherwise requires extraordinary evidence. This has been further corroborated by a study of customer reactivation campaigns in B2B SaaS that found that the cost of reactivation: 8–10x cost of initial acquisition with Success rate of reactivation campaigns: not exceeding 15% (compared to 2–3% for cold outreach but occurring at much higher costs). The study also cites negative reactivation LTV when accounting for support costs and the probability of re-churn.</p><p>This is why <strong>the most successful retention strategies don’t focus on reactivation. They focus on preventing churn in the first place and deepening engagement with active users.</strong></p><p>There is one category of product where reactivation economics improve dramatically: <strong>products with strong network effects, particularly within the realm of collaboration tools and social networks.</strong> For example Slack, the value proposition includes a network effect where churned users can be reactivated through the organic usage of the product. If a team is actively using Slack and a former team member gets added to a new channel or re-invited to participate in a specific project, they naturally return. The reactivation occurs through product usage, not through marketing emails. Similarly, MS Teams have thrived from a similar dynamic. Its integration within the Microsoft 365 ecosystem, already used by most businesses allowed for flawless distribution at effectively zero marginal cost, This ubiquity, combined with its seamless integration with existing applications like Outlook and SharePoint, creates a frictionless reactivation loop that marginalized a lot of products that may function even better just for the sake of convenience. In these cases, the reactivation cost is zero (it’s organic to the product experience), and the success rate is much higher. <strong>This is one reason why VCs prize network effect products. </strong>They have structural advantages in retention and reactivation that products without network effects cannot achieve through marketing or product tactics alone.</p><p>Understanding churn asymmetry fundamentally reshapes venture capital investment logic. It underscores the bedrock laid above that <strong>early retention is more valuable than scaled acquisition</strong>, protecting the initial cohort from churn is more valuable than acquiring replacement users. It also taps the <strong>virality without retention is death</strong> as wtih Vine, Snapchat’s earlier iterations, numerous short-lived trending apps. <strong>The expansion revenue model is superior to acquisition replacement model</strong> Growing revenue from existing customers beats constantly replacing churned users. <strong>Feature adoption and usage depth matters more than user count. </strong>A smaller user base with high engagement is more valuable than a larger base with shallow usage</p><p>This is why VCs should challenge founders who focus primarily on acquisition metrics. Demanding to see retention numbers and not merely download numbers as a proxy for their traction!</p><h3>Part Four: The Viral Trap. Why Explosive Growth Masks Retention Failure 🪤</h3><p>One of the most consistent patterns VCs observe is the viral trap: products that achieve massive, explosive growth but have fundamentally poor retention. These products inevitably fail, despite their apparent success. <br>And apps as TikTok are fueling this viral but vulnerable mechanism where a creator posts a video on TikTok showcasing an app, millions of users download it overnight , the product appears on top charts , PR about the “viral growth” floods tech media, and then, within weeks, the user base collapses.</p><p>The anatomy of this mechanism is consistent. An initial spike with celebrities, influencers, or trending sounds drive massive downloads, followed by a honeymoon period where early users are curious. A Reality check comes afterwards where 80–90% of users discover the app provides insufficient ongoing value. This triggers a collapse with user acquisition rapidly declining as the novelty wears off and organic discovery mechanisms depend on retention in a typical “what goes up must come down” fashion</p><p>The fundamental problem with viral-growth-dependent products is that <strong>virality cannot overcome poor retention. Virality creates a temporary user acquisition boost</strong>, but if the product has poor Day 1 and Day 7 retention, virality simply accelerates the rate at which you burn through your addressable market. Another infamous wave is the Mobile App Virality where app stores created a new form of viral mechanics; forced sharing, interrupt-based notifications, and aggressive incentive mechanics. Apps like Vine , Snapchat, and countless Flappy Bird clones achieved massive downloads. Vine’s explosive growth couldn’t overcome poor retention and changing user preferences. Snapchat survived because it solved a genuine problem for teenage users and maintained reasonably strong retention.</p><p>The reason VCs need to specifically focus on retention when evaluating viral-growth companies is that viral growth creates several illusions pertaining to market validating, strong unit economics where CAC appear to be 0 just because of virality and empty scalability promises</p><p>VCs should include <strong>retention metrics in their assessment of viral products specifically because viral growth masks retention failure</strong>. If a product achieved 5 million downloads but has a 3% D30 retention, that’s catastrophically bad and the viral growth is merely accelerating the inevitable collapse.</p><h3><strong>Part Five: The Measurement Challenge. Why Retention Data is Trickier Than It Appears 🔍</strong></h3><p>One of the most underrated aspects of venture capital evaluation is that retention is genuinely difficult to measure accurately. This isn’t a minor nuance . It directly impacts investment decisions.</p><p>Many product categories exhibit strong seasonality that obscures true retention signals as shown in the graph below</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/801/1*iIGN2YNolR92zef_fksLew.png" /></figure><p>Travel and booking apps: Usage spikes around holidays and travel seasons, creating artificial churn during off-seasons</p><p>Fitness apps: Highest retention in January (New Year’s resolutions), declining through the year, spiking again before summer</p><p>E-commerce: Massive seasonal variation around holidays and shopping seasons</p><p>Weather apps: Usage increases during severe weather events</p><p>Dating apps: Usage varies by season and day of week</p><p>A naive investor might see Q1 fitness app retention at 40% (January cohort) and Q3 retention at 15% (June cohort) and conclude the product is declining. Actually, both cohorts are behaving predictably within seasonal patterns. VCs should account for this by analyzing cohort retention across multiple seasonal cycles. As well as comparing year-over-year retention for equivalent periods. VCs should also aim look for root causes for usage; Separating voluntary churn (people leaving) from seasonal inactivity (people pausing)</p><p>Another factor to note is product development, and how it creates constant noise in retention data (in both good and bad ways)</p><ul><li><strong>Major new features</strong>: Launch of significant features can temporarily boost D7 and D30 retention as existing users return to explore</li><li><strong>Bugs</strong>: System bugs that degrade experience can artificially increase churn</li><li><strong>Marketing campaigns</strong>: Paid reactivation campaigns create temporary retention spikes</li><li><strong>Platform changes</strong>: iOS or Android OS updates, app store algorithm changes, platform policy changes can dramatically impact metrics</li><li><strong>Android/iOS expansion</strong>: Launching on new platforms creates cohorts with different behavior due to device differences, market differences, and user demographics</li></ul><p>Smart VCs should ask founders: “What does your cohort retention look like across multiple seasons without major product changes?” They’re looking for the underlying retention curve, not the noise.</p><p>Investors want to know long-term retention (what percentage of users return after a year? ), but they can’t wait a year to make investment decisions. This creates a fundamental timing problem. D30 and D7 retention are predictive and measurable quickly, but they can be gamed or distorted. A product can achieve decent D30 retention through aggressive re-engagement tactics without building genuine long-term retention.</p><p>That’s why VCs should formulate a way that would serve as a proxy for lon term growth. This can include:</p><ul><li><strong>Early retention metrics</strong> (D1, D7, D30) to predict if the product works</li><li><strong>Cohort analysis </strong>to see if early retention actually predicts later retention</li><li><strong>Revenue retention, </strong>If applicable (does spending increase with tenure?)</li><li><strong>Engagement metrics </strong>to gauge whether active users becoming more or less engaged over time?</li></ul><h3><strong>Part Six: What Great Retention Looks Like and The Lightning-in-a-Bottle Phenomenon ⚡</strong></h3><p>After analyzing thousands of retention curves, I have developed an intuitive sense for what great retention looks like. It’s rare. It’s distinctive. and it’s unmistakable. I’ll attempt to pass on its underlying bedrock</p><p><strong>The 50% D30 Rule by Andrew Chen. </strong>Chen reviewed retention curves across hundreds of startups over 15 years, he observed that <strong>D30 retention above 50% occurs approximately once every couple of years.</strong> At that level, retention is exceptional. For context:</p><ul><li>D30 retention below 10%: Product has likely failed or is in severe distress</li><li>D30 retention 10–15%: Common for many products; can be viable depending on category and monetization</li><li>D30 retention 15–25%: Good for many consumer categories; acceptable for many B2B SaaS</li><li>D30 retention 25–40%: Strong for consumer; very strong for enterprise</li><li>D30 retention 40–50%: Exceptional; indicates strong product-market fit</li><li>D30 retention above 50%: Rare; indicates either the best products or very targeted acquisition</li></ul><p>Fellow PMs have also noticed that great retention doesn’t result from systematic A/B testing or metric-driven optimization. Instead, it results from a fresh insight about customer needs that becomes obvious in retrospect but was not obvious initially. Examples of this is Slack, where most team communication happened across fragmented systems (email, SMS, separate tools). What if all team communication happened in one persistent, searchable archive with integrated tools? This wasn’t obvious before Slack, but in retrospect, it seems inevitable. another infamous example is Snapchat, What if photos disappeared after viewing? This solved a privacy anxiety that users hadn’t articulated but deeply felt. The insight was emotionally resonant and created immediate habitual behavior. The common denominator is that these <strong>aren’t products that achieved great retention through optimization they’re products that nailed something fundamental about how users wanted to behave, and the retention followed naturally</strong>.</p><p>This insight has profound implications for venture capital strategy: you cannot systematically engineer great retention. You can engineer good retention through user research, testing, and iteration. But great retention requires a fundamental insight about user needs that drives natural, habitual adoption. This is why venture capitalists often talk about the importance of founder insight and intuition. The founders of successful products often had clarity about a use case that was not yet validated, and that clarity drove the product development that resulted in great retention.</p><p>There is one rare category of retention curve where the seemingly impossible occurs: retention decreases and then increases again over time. These “smile curves” appear in products with network effects where the value increases as the network grows. Again Slack exhibits this pattern. Users might have low initial adoption, creating lower D7 or D14 retention. But as the network effect kicks in and the team becomes more invested, the retention curve begins to flatten and then improve. By D90 or D180, users are substantially more engaged than they were at D30. This phenomena happens because:</p><ul><li>Initial friction: Learning the product, persuading team members to join, setting up integrations</li><li>Network growth: More team members join, creating more value per user</li><li>Workflow integration: Slack becomes more central to team operations</li><li>Switching costs rise: Extracting all team communication history, re-establishing workflows in another tool becomes prohibitively expensive</li></ul><p>For marketplace products, a similar dynamic can occur where early churn from supply or demand constraints is overcome as the network achieves density. Smile curves are exceptionally valuable to venture capitalists because they indicate a product with compounding retention dynamics. Instead of constantly fighting to retain users, the product naturally becomes stickier as it grows.</p><h3>Part Seven: The VC Evaluation Framework. What Investors Actually Look For in Retention 🔍</h3><p>Venture capitalists have developed a relatively consistent framework for evaluating retention, especially during the crucial early stages of product development.<br>The Retention Checklist: What VCs Ask For</p><p>When evaluating a new product, here’s what sophisticated venture capitalists ask for:</p><p>1. Retention Curves by Cohort (Minimum 12 weeks of data)</p><p>What percentage of users return on Day 1, 7, 14, 30, 60, and 90?</p><p>How do different acquisition cohorts behave? (Early users vs. later users)</p><p>What is the shape of the curve? (Declining, flat, or smile curve?)</p><p>2. Activation Metrics</p><p>What percentage of new users complete your core action/aha moment in the first day?</p><p>For what percentage of users is activation happening, and is this number improving over time?</p><p>What is the time-to-value for users? (How long before they experience the core benefit?)</p><p>3. DAU/MAU Ratio and Engagement</p><p>What percentage of users return to the app monthly who also return daily?</p><p>A 50%+ DAU/MAU ratio indicates strong daily habit formation</p><p>For less-frequent-use products, what is the expected DAU/WAU or WAU/MAU ratio?</p><p>4. Feature Adoption</p><p>What percentage of users discover the core features that predict retention?</p><p>Are feature adoption rates increasing or declining over time?</p><p>Do users who adopt more features show better retention?</p><p>5. Churn Analysis</p><p>What is the voluntary churn rate vs. involuntary churn rate?</p><p>Where is churn happening? (First week? Month 2–3?)</p><p>What signals predict churn? (Can you identify users at risk before they churn?)</p><p>6. Revenue Retention (For B2B/Paid Products)</p><p>Are retained customers generating more, less, or stable revenue over time?</p><p>Is there net negative churn (expansion revenue exceeding churn)?</p><p>Are top customers spending more over time?</p><p>7. Cohort Analysis</p><p>Do all acquisition cohorts behave similarly, or do some cohorts have much higher retention?</p><p>If some cohorts have better retention, what’s different about them? (Source, targeting, product version?)</p><p>Is the product getting better or worse at onboarding as you scale?</p><p>Red Flags vs. Green Lights in Retention Data</p><p>Notable Red Flags: 🚨</p><p>🚩 “We haven’t really focused on retention metrics yet” indicates the founder is not thinking like a product person. Retention data should be instrumented from day one.</p><p>🚩 D1 retention below 15% indicates users aren’t experiencing immediate value. Very difficult to fix without major product changes.</p><p>🚩 Declining retention across cohorts If January cohort has 20% D30 retention, but April cohort has 12%, something is broken.</p><p>🚩 Cohort retention doesn’t correlate with engagement High retention but low DAU/MAU suggests re-engagement tactics are working but underlying engagement is weak.</p><p>🚩 Massive gap between golden cohort and paid acquisition cohort retention indicates targeting issues or product generalization challenges.</p><p>🚩 Revenue retention below 80% for B2B (annual) indicates customers are churning or downgrading.</p><h3><strong>Part Eight: Frameworks for Product Selection — Applying These Lessons as an Investor 🎯</strong></h3><p>Now that we’ve established the critical importance of retention, how should venture capitalists actually apply these principles when evaluating products? <br>The Three Questions Framework 🔺</p><p>Sophisticated VCs use a simplified framework of three questions:</p><p>Question 1: Is early retention acceptable for this product category? <br>Evaluate whether the product’s D7 and D30 retention metrics meet or exceed category benchmarks. Compare against products in similar categories. If retention is significantly below category average without explanation, it’s a major red flag.</p><p>Question 2: Are early adopters (golden cohort) showing fundamentally different retention than later users? <br>If yes, this suggests either the product hasn’t found product-market fit broadly (only niche works) or the company is still learning to acquire the right users. This can be positive (focus on the winning niche) or negative (product doesn’t scale beyond niche).</p><p>Question 3: Is retention improving or declining across cohorts? <br>If each new cohort has worse retention than the previous, the company is scaling prematurely. If retention is improving with each cohort, the company is learning and fixing problems. <br>The Market Timing Filter</p><p>One of the most important insights from the Medium article is that timing and market conditions dramatically affect whether a product can achieve great retention. VCs ask:</p><p>“Why now?”</p><p>Is there a new technology, regulation, or societal shift that creates an opportunity for your product to disrupt an incumbent?</p><p>OpenAI released GPT-3 and then GPT-4, creating an opportunity for AI products that couldn’t have succeeded before</p><p>The oversaturation of social media created an opportunity for products that solved specific social problems</p><p>Regulatory changes created opportunities for fintech and proptech products</p><p>Products that achieve great retention often have timing elements where external market shifts create a window for disruption.</p><p>A product addressing an event-based need (like wedding planning ) faces fundamental retention challenges. Rather than rejecting all event-based products, VCs ask: “How is the founder thinking about expanding this to higher-frequency needs?”</p><p>The most successful products in low-frequency categories either:</p><p>Expand to higher-frequency use cases (Zillow expanding from home buying to home management )</p><p>Achieve exceptional monetization within the low-frequency use case (making substantial revenue per user during active periods )</p><p>Build network effects or switching costs (once you’ve used our service, you’re more likely to use us again and recommend us )</p><p>The Differentiation Assessment</p><p>Venture capitalists ask whether the product has sufficient differentiation from incumbents. The critical insight from the Medium article is that mere 20% improvements on existing products can be sufficient if the timing is right. <br>Differentiation Level Likelihood of Retention Success Capital Requirements VC Appetite</p><p>The most investable products are in the 20% improvement category with strong timing. Think: “Figma for design” (20% improvement on CAD tools for design) with new web-first approach. Or “Cursor for coding” (20% improvement on text editors with AI). 🖥</p><p>New category creation (like Uber creating ridesharing, or ChatGPT creating AI applications ) has uncertain retention but can create enormous value if retention becomes strong. 💎</p><h3><strong>Part Nine: The VC Decision Framework. From Data to Investment Decision 💰</strong></h3><p>Armed with retention data and frameworks, how do venture capitalists actually make investment decisions? <br>The Retention-Based Investment Rubric by Stage</p><p>🌱 Seed Stage / Pre-Seed:</p><p>✅ Must have: D7 retention minimum 15–20% (depending on category)</p><p>👍 Good to have: D7/D1 ratio above 40%, founder has clear insight into why this product solves a problem</p><p>🚨 Red flags: D1 retention below 10%, no cohort analysis, unfocused on metric</p><p>🌾 Early Seed (with traction):</p><p>✅ Must have: D30 retention above 15%, cohort analysis showing retention stabilizing or improving</p><p>👍 Good to have: D30 retention above 25%, DAU/MAU ratio indicating daily habit formation, organic growth exceeding paid growth</p><p>🚨 Red flags: D1 cohorts declining in retention, no revenue or path to revenue, high churn without explanation</p><p>🌿 Seed to Series A:</p><p>✅ Must have: D30 retention above 20–25%, NRR above 95% (for B2B), organic growth as significant portion of total growth</p><p>👍 Good to have: Improving cohort retention, clear expansion revenue, engaged early customers willing to be references</p><p>🚨 Red flags: Revenue retention deteriorating, acquisition-dependent growth, no visible path to unit economics</p><p>🌳 Series A and Beyond:</p><p>✅ Must have: Category-appropriate retention (often D30 retention 30%+ or NRR 110%+), strong ARR growth, clear path to profitability</p><p>👍 Good to have: Retention curves approaching smile curves, expansion revenue exceeding churn revenue, improving CAC payback periods</p><p>🚨 Red flags: Retention declining as company scales, CAC increasing without compensating LTV improvements</p><p>The Founder Assessment Layer 👤</p><p>Beyond metrics, VCs assess whether the founder is thinking about retention correctly: 🧠</p><p>🟢 Founders Who “Get It”:</p><p>📊 Obsessed with early retention metrics</p><p>💡 Can articulate why users might not return and have hypotheses to test</p><p>📈 Use cohort analysis to understand product changes</p><p>🌳 Think about category limitations (nature vs. nurture)</p><p>📐 Measure feature adoption and engagement depth</p><p>⚡ Have clear activation metrics</p><p>🔴 Founders Who Don’t Get It:</p><p>📱 Focus primarily on download numbers and top-line growth</p><p>🤷 Can’t articulate why retention is important</p><p>😅 Blame retention problems on “features we’ll add later”</p><p>❌ Don’t measure activation or engagement</p><p>🚫 Believe more marketing will fix retention problems</p><p>🤐 Have no cohort analysis capability</p><p>The stark reality is that many founders, even ones with impressive pitch decks and large networks, don’t understand retention fundamentals. 😅 Venture capitalists have learned to assess whether a founder will make good retention-based decisions before investing. 🎯</p><h3>Part Ten: Case Studies — Great Retention vs. Failed Retention 📚</h3><p><strong>Case Study 1: Slack — The Retention Success Story 🎉</strong>The Setup: 🎬<br>Slack launched in 2013 as an internal tool for a team at Tiny Speck (a gaming company). 🎮 The team noticed their own internal communication was fragmented across email, instant messaging, and other tools. They built an internal tool to consolidate communication. 💡</p><p>The Retention Story: 📊</p><p>Slack’s early cohorts showed exceptional retention metrics:</p><p>📌 Day 1 retention: ~35% (excellent 🌟)</p><p>📌 Day 7 retention: ~25% (exceptional ✨)</p><p>📌 Day 30 retention: ~18% (strong 💪)</p><p>📌 Organization retention (multi-user): 90%+ within organizations that adopted as a team 👥</p><p>📌 Revenue retention: Above 120% NRR (due to team expansion and upsells 📈)</p><p>Why the retention worked: 🎯</p><p>✅ Genuine pain point: Team communication was genuinely fragmented; Slack solved a real problem 🎲</p><p>✅ Immediate aha moment: The searchable archive of team communication provided instant value 💫</p><p>✅ Network effects: Each additional team member increased value, creating a smile curve 📈</p><p>✅ High switching costs: Once a team moved all communication to Slack, extracting and moving elsewhere was prohibitively expensive 🔒</p><p>The outcome: 🏆</p><p>🚀 Slack grew to 750,000 daily active users within 7 years of launch</p><p>🚀 Became the fastest-growing SaaS company (at the time)</p><p>🚀 Achieved $27.7 billion valuation (at acquisition by Salesforce)</p><p>🚀 Never had to rely on viral growth or paid acquisition at scale; word-of-mouth sustained growth 📣</p><p>VC Lesson: 💎 Great retention driven by genuine insight about customer needs results in sustainable, organic growth that compounds over time. 📈<br>Case Study 2: BranchOut — The Viral Trap 🪤</p><p>The Setup: 🎬<br>BranchOut launched in 2010 as a Facebook application designed to help users build professional networks. 👔 The founders used growth-hacking tactics: aggressive viral mechanics that forced users to invite all their friends or none. 💥</p><p>The Retention Story: 📉</p><p>Despite massive acquisition success, retention was catastrophic:</p><p>📊 Downloads: 400 million Facebook users reached; 12 million monthly active users at peak; 250,000 daily downloads</p><p>📊 Day 1 retention: ~40% (actually decent)</p><p>📊 Day 2 retention: &lt;1% (catastrophic 😱)</p><p>📊 Day 7 retention: &lt;&lt;1%</p><p>📊 Day 30 retention: ~0.1%</p><p>Why the retention failed: ❌</p><p>❌ No genuine value proposition: Most users invited had no interest in professional networking 🤷</p><p>❌ Aggressive acquisition mechanics created expectation mismatch: Users felt forced into downloading; upon using the app, they found little value 😤</p><p>❌ Spam-like behavior damaged trust: Inviting everyone (not selective) created negative sentiment 🤮</p><p>❌ No network effects for most users: Unlike Slack where adding a team member is additive, BranchOut required critical mass in specific professional networks 🕸️</p><p>The outcome: 💀</p><p>⬇️ From 14 million monthly active users, the product collapsed to 3 million within months</p><p>⬇️ Became emblematic of the “leaky bucket” problem: growth couldn’t offset churn</p><p>⬇️ Eventually shut down as Facebook changed policies against forced invitations</p><p>⬇️ Founders and VCs lost significant capital 💸</p><p>VC Lesson: Viral growth without retention is not a business; it’s a mirage. No amount of impressive download numbers can overcome retention failure. <br>Conclusion: The Retention Era of Venture Capital</p><p>We have entered what industry observers call the retention era of venture capital. The dynamics are clear:</p><p>Customer acquisition costs are rising, paid growth is becoming increasingly expensive across all channels</p><p>Retention is becoming differentiating, companies with superior retention grow 3x faster than average competitors</p><p>Retention is being prioritized with 87% of SaaS businesses surveyed in 2023 prioritized retention over acquisition</p><p>Great retention is rare. Less than 5% of products achieve D30 retention above 40%</p><p>Poor retention is fatal — No amount of growth can overcome retention failure indefinitely</p><p>For venture capitalists evaluating new tech products, the checklist has become remarkably consistent:</p><p>Ask for retention curves before asking for financials.</p><p>Evaluate whether early retention is acceptable for the product category.</p><p>Assess whether the founder understands retention dynamics.</p><p>Look for evidence of genuine product-market fit, not viral growth vanity metrics.</p><p>Understand whether the product has timing advantages that create retention opportunities.</p><p>Evaluate the strength of barriers to reactivation (network effects, switching costs, habit formation).</p><p>Determine whether retention is improving or declining as the company scales.</p><p>The founders and products that succeed in this era are those that recognize a fundamental truth: a product with great retention can acquire users sustainably, but a product with poor retention cannot acquire users sustainably regardless of how much capital is deployed.</p><p>This isn’t a new insight — it’s been true since the beginning of venture capital. But as capital has become more abundant and growth metrics have become easier to game, retention has become the north star that separates real business building from vanity metrics.</p><p>The invitation to founders and venture capitalists is clear: obsess over retention from day one. Instrument it, analyze it, understand it. The companies that do this will build sustainable, valuable businesses that can compound growth for years or decades. Those that ignore retention will find themselves in the graveyard of failed tech products, regardless of how impressive their growth curves appeared along the way.</p><h3><strong>Conclusion: The Big Question</strong></h3><p>You might read all of this and still have a big question: So wait, how do you get to great retention? (If I knew the answer in a deterministic way, my job as a startup investor to-be and a current product consultant would be so much easier, wouldn’t it?)</p><p>But let’s try our best. In my points above, there’s a few clues:</p><ul><li>The idea really matters.</li><li>If you want a high retention product, you need to pick a category that is high retention already.</li><li>You need to pick a product category where you already use an existing product every day.</li><li>You’re going to build something that directly competes against that.</li><li>If you win, then you’ll stop using that other product and use your product instead.</li></ul><p>That’s a high bar, but I think it’s a good start.</p><p>Of course, if you build something that’s quite head-to-head with something that already exists, you might suitably object: “that’s going to be really hard to switch somebody over.” It is. So then this is where you need to decide to take enough market risk, but just the appropriate amount, where you do something new and different that reinvents that core interaction. But you’re probably talking more about a 20% remix rather than an 80%. Ideally, you need to be able to describe this to your users in a way that they can understand quickly and viscerally within the first 60 seconds of usage.</p><p>This is where the dreaded investor question “why now?” starts to matter quite a bit. Because what you’re saying here is that ideally there’s some kind of new development in the industry, whether that’s a general-purpose technology like LLMs or a societal difference like the oversaturation of social media, that allows you to make this twist happen at exactly the right moment.</p><p>This gets you into an existing market quickly, and you’re more likely to have great retention numbers early on. Timing matters a lot. If you get the timing off, and it’s a low-interest category, and your differentiation isn’t different enough, then what you’ll find is you’ve traded a retention problem for a user acquisition problem. Here’s the difficulty with building a new kind of internet browser: if you win, it’s incredibly sticky. But people are so happy with their existing browsers that it’s very expensive and complex to get them to try yours in the first place.</p><p>This is why I don’t blame folks who have a “Cursor for X” idea, or “Figma for X,” just like the “Uber for X” ideas of the past generation. They’re trying to piggy off some existing markets and behavior so that they don’t have to take crazy market risk.</p><p>And if you get the differentiation right, the timing right, and there’s a ton of user demand, and you’ve nailed the right base product category, then I think it can really work.</p><p><strong>But what about new markets?</strong><br>The natural counterpoint is that new markets are often more exciting than existing ones. Isn’t tech about building brand new things rather than innovating 20% on old stuff? Of course this is true, but I think this is the tiny tiny minority of products.</p><p>My counterpoint to this counterpoint is that most products actually have some kind of prior lineage, even if those prior products are quickly forgotten.</p><p>Before Instagram there was Hipstamatic, which had become the #1 paid photo app in the early App Store. It demonstrated the success of photo filters. Of course Google was not the first search engine, it was actually #10 or whatever, after Lycos, Excite, Infoseek, etc., which demonstrated consumers wanted search but that it was impossible to monetize. Tesla was not the first electric car, nor iPhone the first smartphone. Sometimes it’s the 10th iteration that matters. Some call this “last mover advantage” rather than first mover. I think an important point.</p><p>Yet sometimes new things do happen. Uber was created to turn an existing offline action — calling a cab — into an app, not because there was already a hugely successful ridehailing app. (And no, not Lyft — it was a weird bus booking thing at the time). Of course a lot of ChatGPT, with OpenAI’s 5 year journey between inception and v3 which really took off, and without any real blueprints for what it might replace. These types of journeys are remarkable, and the tech industry is better off for it, because they involve real risk as part of new category creation.</p><h3>References</h3><p>Chen, Andrew. “Why Retention is So Hard for New Tech Products.” LinkedIn/a16z Speedrun, September 2025.</p><p>ChartMogul. “SaaS Retention Report 2023: Analyzing Retention Across 2,100+ SaaS Businesses.” December 2023.</p><p>Sequoia Capital. “Retention: The Art of Sustainable Growth.” Articles, June 2018.</p><p>Statista. “Mobile App Retention Rates by Category.” Various data, 2023–2025.</p><p>Wudpecker. “Retention Benchmarks for B2B SaaS in 2025.” March 2025.</p><p>UserPilot. “11 Product Performance Metrics SaaS Businesses Should Track.” March 2025.</p><p>Chargebee. “State of Subscriptions 2023: Retention Priorities Report.” October 2023.</p><p>Andreessen Horowitz. “16 Ways to Measure Network Effects.” September 2023.</p><p>Andreessen Horowitz. “Do You Have Lightning In a Bottle? How to Benchmark.” March 2024.</p><p>Reforge. “Retention is Hard, and Getting Harder — Here’s Why.” Various articles on retention dynamics.</p><p>Customer.io. “7 Product Onboarding Best Practices for Long-Term Loyalty.” July 2025.</p><p>Mixpanel. “A Guide to Product Metrics: How to Build Your Own Metrics Framework.” February 2025.</p><p>The Marketing Centre. “Why Retention is Your Most Powerful (and Most Overlooked) Growth Lever.” October 2025.</p><p>Larksuite. “Retention Rate — Venture Capital Glossary.” February 2024.</p><p>Blitzllama. “20 B2B SaaS Metrics: How to Measure and Improve Them.” April 2025.</p><p>Going VC. “The Complete Guide to Venture Capital Fund Metrics.” July 2025.</p><p>Equidam. “The Logic of the VC Method for Startup Valuation.” July 2025.</p><p>Kanmore. “Guide to Customer Retention Metrics: What Startups Need to Know.” May 2025.</p><p>Crazy Egg. “35 Critical Startup Metrics: From Pre-Seed to Exit.” April 2025.</p><p>PitchDrive. “Cohort Analysis: A Startup’s Secret Weapon.” October 2024.</p><p>Sendbird. “App Retention Benchmarks Broken Down by Industry.” May 2025.</p><p>Adasia Analytics. “Cohort Analysis: Definition, Key Steps &amp; Examples.” March 2015.</p><p>GameAnalytics. “Why It’s Important to Keep Your Initial Players Happy: The Golden Cohort.” April 2015.</p><p>PANews. “Rather Than Trying to Save Low Retention Rates, It is Better to Pivot.” September 2025.</p><p>Marketing Centre. “Why Retention is Your Most Powerful (and Most Overlooked) Growth Lever.” October 2025.</p><p>SerializedSculpt. “B2B Customer Retention Statistics 2025: New Data.” September 2025.</p><p>VeryCreatives. “Venture Capital Due Diligence Checklist: 8 Key Steps.” August 2025.</p><p>InnovationVisual. “Customer Retention: The Essential Growth Strategy for 2025.” August 2031.</p><p>Troy Lendman. “The Ultimate Guide To Retention Benchmarking For Growth.” July 2025.</p><p>Qubit Capital. “Startup Evaluation Checklist: Key Investment Criteria.” August 2025.</p><p>Lanpdt. “Why New Products Fail &amp; How Success Is Measured.” March 2025.</p><p>ChurnKey. “Customer Retention Curve: Calculator, Definition, Examples.” September 2024.</p><p>Market Build. “Pre-Seed Stage Metrics: How to Measure Product Market Fit.” October 2024.</p><p>Kahnamore. “Increasing D1, D7, or D30 Retention: Strategies to Keep Users Engaged.” May 2023.</p><p>ProductLed. “SaaS Onboarding User Experience: Why Make the First 7 Minutes Count.” May 2025.</p><p>Reddit/r/YCombinator. “What Are the General Industry Benchmark Retention Rates?” August 2024.</p><p>The VC Corner. “ Key Startup Metrics VCs Care About: How to Track and Improve them” March 2025</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e67e6f1ccd07" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/included-vc/why-retention-should-be-the-true-north-star-for-vcs-when-backing-their-coming-tech-product-e67e6f1ccd07">Why Retention should be the True North Star for VCs when backing their coming tech product?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/included-vc">Included VC</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Silicon Sands: The Untapped Potential of MENA’s Semiconductor Awakening]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/included-vc/silicon-sands-the-untapped-potential-of-menas-semiconductor-awakening-5335e854cda6?source=rss-9e0744f10d83------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5335e854cda6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[deeptech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startupş]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[semiconductors]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ahmed Sherif Edris]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Dec 2025 21:38:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-24T05:02:18.065Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/990/1*BPtqKlH4ze5JbCz9eOG9AA.png" /></figure><h3>TL;DR</h3><p>The Middle East and North Africa is executing a coordinated semiconductor play that venture capitalists are systematically underestimating. While global investors pile into saturated ecosystems, <strong>MENA offers a $64.7 billion market by 2033</strong> with a tri-fold national strategy: Egypt owns fabless design and talent arbitrage, Saudi Arabia commands capital-intensive manufacturing infrastructure, and Oman targets the overlooked OSAT middle layer. The region combines sovereign wealth that dwarfs traditional VC (PIF alone manages $1 trillion), geopolitical neutrality during US-China decoupling, and a <strong>50,000-engineer talent pool </strong>graduating annually at one-tenth Silicon Valley wages. Israel’s $40 billion in semiconductor exits since 1996 provides the blueprint and MENA’s market size already exceeds that threshold. For VCs, the arbitrage opportunity spans the entire value chain: seed-stage fabless design in Cairo, growth-stage infrastructure plays in Riyadh, and OSAT service layer investments in Muscat. The window is narrow with <strong>first movers capturing the 8.64% CAGR growth</strong> before multinationals fully entrench will define the next decade of tech returns in emerging markets.</p><h3>The Forgotten Revolution: How Semiconductors Built Digital Sovereignty</h3><p>On December 23, 1947, at Bell Telephone Laboratories in Murray Hill, New Jersey, three physicists John Bardeen, Walter Brattain, and William Shockley demonstrated a device that would become one of the most important inventions in human history: the <strong>point-contact transistor</strong>. This small germanium crystal with two gold contacts would replace the bulky, unreliable vacuum tubes that powered early computers and telecom systems.​</p><p>The transistor’s invention triggered a cascade of innovation. By 1958, Jack Kilby at Texas Instruments and Robert Noyce at Fairchild Semiconductor independently invented the <strong>integrated circuit (IC), </strong>a method of combining multiple transistors onto a single semiconductor chip. Kilby’s initial prototype used wire-bonded components on germanium, while Noyce’s aluminum metallization technique on silicon became the foundation for all modern ICs. This “big bang” of microelectronics compressed what once required entire rooms into fingernail-sized chips.</p><p>The semiconductor market has an economic multiplier effect far extending beyond the tech space. In the United States, the sector contributed <strong>$277 billion to GDP in 2021, representing a 72% increase in direct contribution year-over-year</strong>. While semiconductors account for only 0.3% of total US manufacturing output, they directly impact over 12% of the $20 trillion GDP. This multiplier effect occurs because semiconductors are foundational inputs: a single advanced chip enables entire downstream industries from automotive (where electronics now represent 40% of a new car’s cost) to cloud computing to defense systems.​</p><p>The industry’s contribution to national economies has<strong> grown at 5.5% annually since 1987, more than twice the pace of overall GDP growth</strong>. By 2030, the global semiconductor market is projected to <strong>exceed $1 trillion in annual sales, up from $694 billion in 2024</strong></p><p><strong>The race towards digital sovereignty requires silicon sovereignty, </strong>and COVID-19 pandemic and the subsequent chip shortage exposed this critical fact. Nations without domestic semiconductor capacity lack true technological sovereignty. When Taiwan faced drought conditions threatening TSMC’s water-intensive fabs, or when geopolitical tensions disrupted Asian supply chains, entire economies ground to a halt. Automotive production in the US alone dropped 6% in 2021 due to chip shortages.​</p><p>This dependency has triggered a global race for semiconductor self-sufficiency. <strong>The US CHIPS Act allocated $52 billion for domestic production.</strong> Europe launched similar initiatives. And now, <strong>MENA is entering the arena; not to replicate Silicon Valley or Taiwan, but to carve out strategic niches in the value chain.</strong></p><h3>The Tri-Fold Ecosystem: Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and Oman’s Coordinated Play</h3><p>Unlike the monolithic approaches of other regions, MENA’s semiconductor strategy is distributed across three nations, each targeting a distinct segment of the value chain based on their comparative advantages. This specialization reduces regional competition while creating a cohesive ecosystem.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/859/1*NpKwNmbOgmxTYOJeCE6DEw.png" /><figcaption>Semiconductor Value Chain Positioning in MENA</figcaption></figure><p>The chart above illustrates the strategic positioning of the three key players. Notice how they span the spectrum of Capital Intensity vs. Human Capital, creating a diversified regional portfolio.</p><p><strong>Egypt:</strong> The Fabless Design Powerhouse <strong>The Asset: </strong>Human capital at scale<br><strong>The Strategy:</strong> High-value, asset-light chip design</p><p>Egypt is not building fabs. it’s building the brains behind the chips. The country produces approximately 50,000 engineering graduates annually, creating a massive talent pool that global chip companies are already exploiting. Samsung, LG, and multinational design houses have established extensive R&amp;D centers in Cairo, treating it as an offshore design hub.​</p><p>According to <a href="https://itida.gov.eg/English/Programs/EgyptMakesElectronics/Pages/default.aspx">ITIDA</a>, The ‘Egypt Makes Electronics’ (EME) initiative, launched as a presidential program in 2015, aims to position Egypt as a regional hub for electronics manufacturing and design, and has alrea<strong>dy around $200M in handset manufacturing investments </strong>so far from global brands such as Vivo, Nokia, Xiaomi, Samsung, and OPPO (<a href="https://library.idsc.gov.eg/cgi-bin/koha/opac-retrieve-file.pl?id=cc2547b5a7871aced75c7a7c5a63801f">BMI</a>). This aims to position the country as the r<strong>egion’s fabless design leader.</strong> Some examples for built and operated enterprises are shown below</p><p><strong>InfiniLink’s Rapid Exit</strong>. The power of this ecosystem was vividly demonstrated in November 2025, when InfiniLink, a Cairo-based silicon photonics startup, was acquired by GlobalFoundries just seven months after its seed round. InfiniLink designed critical optical transceiver chiplets (iOTC) that use light instead of copper to move data in AI data centers — a “mission-critical” technology for the AI boom. The <strong>deal delivered a 400% (4x) return to its backers, including the state-backed Egypt Ventures, in less than a year </strong>(<a href="https://www.techtarget.com/whatis/glossary/Computer-Science">TechTarget</a>). This exit proves that Egyptian deep-tech isn’t just a cost-savings play; it’s generating global-tier IP that major US foundries need now. It also validates the “Seed-to-Exit” thesis for VCs looking for faster liquidity than the typical 7–10 year deep-tech horizon.</p><p><strong>Mentor Graphics: </strong>Every ecosystem has a catalyst. For Egypt, it was Mentor Graphics. French EDA company Anacad founded its cairo office, Mentor Graphics; making Egypt one of the earliest Middle Eastern countries with a global chip design center</p><p><strong>Si-Ware Systems</strong>: according to an <a href="https://www.facebook.com/SiWareSystems/videos/%EF%B8%8F-the-neospectra-story-how-si-ware-systems-the-leader-in-material-sensing-transf/1744130636308989/">interview</a> with company officials, the <strong>startup raised $19 million (including a $9 million Series B)</strong> for MEMS microchip technology targeting material identification applications. The company is restructuring into two entities. NeoSpectra (microchips) and Pearl (timing solutions)</p><p><strong>Pearl Semiconductor: </strong>Secured <strong>$4.5 million in 2023 from Shorooq Partners, QBN Capital, and Sawari Ventures (</strong>crunchbase<strong>)</strong>. The fabless company specializes in high-performance reference clocks and timing ICs critical for 5G-6G, cloud computing, and automotive applications.</p><p><strong>Brightskies:</strong> An Egyptian success story in automotive software and high-performance computing, working with global OEMs to design next-gen vehicle architectures.​</p><p><strong>Mixel (Egypt R&amp;D Center):</strong> A mixed-signal IP provider headquartered globally but with deep Egyptian engineering talent contributing to analog, power management, and connectivity IP.</p><p><strong>Key Signals:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Global Validation:</strong> The Global Semiconductor Alliance (GSA) opened its first regional office outside major tech hubs in Cairo — a massive signal of confidence.</li><li><strong>The Unicorns-in-Waiting:</strong> Startups like Si-Ware Systems (MEMS technology), Pearl Semiconductor (timing solutions), and InfiniLink (acquired by globalfoundries) are already competing globally.</li><li><strong>MNC Anchors: </strong>Giants like Samsung and LG have established extensive design centers in Egypt to tap into this engineer pool.</li></ul><p><strong>​Saudi Arabia: The Capital Deployment Machine The Asset:</strong> Sovereign wealth (<strong>PIF: $1+ Trillion AUM</strong>)<br><strong>The Strategy:</strong> Capital-intensive manufacturing and AI compute infrastructure</p><p>Saudi Arabia is playing the long game, using its petrowealth to skip the “gradual development” phase and jump directly to industrial-scale semiconductor capacity. Under Vision 2030, the kingdom is <strong>executing a $13 billion semiconductor ecosystem buildout</strong>.​</p><p>The centerpiece is the <strong>National Semiconductor Hub (NSH)</strong>, launched in June 2024 with a <strong>$266 million deep-tech VC fund targeting 50 fabless design companies by 2030</strong>. But the <strong>real ambition lies in manufacturing.</strong> Alat, a PIF‑backed industrial champion, has completed a US$2 billion strategic investment and collaboration with Lenovo via three‑year zero‑coupon convertible bonds, under which Lenovo will establish a regional HQ and large manufacturing facility in Saudi Arabia to serve the MEA market according to <a href="https://www.leapforward.onegiantleap.com/lenovo-completes-us-2-billion-investment-and-strategic-collaboration-with-alat/">Leap Forward</a>. <strong>Saudi’s semiconductor push isn’t just about chipsets. It’s about about AI sovereignty</strong>. According to <a href="https://www.financial-world.org/news/news/financial/28274/nvidia-and-amd-back-riyadhs-10-billion-ai-ambitions-with-major-chip-supply-deals/">Financial World</a>, the kingdom is among the world’s largest buyers of advanced GPUs for its AI ambitions by allocating up to $10 billion fo fuel AI ambitions. If Saudi can control silicon production, it would secure the compute infrastructure for its AI-driven economic diversification, from autonomous systems in NEOM to smart grid management for its $500 billion renewable energy projects.​</p><p><strong>Key Signals:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>National Semiconductor Hub (NSH): </strong>A dedicated entity backed by a $266 million seed fund (a drop in the bucket of the wider multi-billion dollar roadmap) to attract 50 fabless design firms by 2030.</li><li><strong>Alat: </strong>A PIF-backed industrial electronics champion that is signing partnerships to manufacture locally.</li><li><strong>The AI Tie-In:</strong> Saudi’s investment isn’t just about chips; it’s about the compute needed for its AI ambitions. By controlling the silicon, they secure the infrastructure for their AI future.</li></ul><p><strong>Oman:</strong> The OSAT Pragmatist <strong>The Asset: </strong>Strategic location + logistical neutrality<br><strong>The Strategy: </strong>Mid-capital OSAT (packaging and testing)</p><p>Oman has made the most pragmatic calculation: Outsourced Semiconductor Assembly and Test (OSAT) is the overlooked middle layer of the value chain. In an interview with <a href="https://fr.linkedin.com/in/mohammed-tmimi?trk=public_post_feed-actor-name">Dr. Mohamed Tmimi</a>; He noted that while front-end manufacturing requires<strong> $10+ billion fabs and design takes decades to mature, OSAT is capital-moderate ($130–140 million range)</strong>, logistics-heavy, and currently overly concentrated in East Asia.​</p><p>GS Microelectronics (GSME) has already established a design and testing center in Muscat employing 100+ Omani engineers. <strong>Invest Oman is actively courting $130–140 million investments for dedicated OSAT facilities</strong>.​</p><p>The Strategic Advantage here is focusing on<strong> testing and packaging</strong>, Oman can service chips from any jurisdiction, making it a <strong>neutral service layer during US-China decoupling. As supply chains diversify beyond Taiwan and Malaysia (current OSAT hubs), Oman’s geographic position between Asia, Europe, and Africa makes it an ideal logistics node.</strong></p><p><strong>Key Signals:</strong></p><p><strong>GS Microelectronics (GSME):</strong> Established a design and testing center in Muscat, already employing over 100 Omani engineers.</p><p><strong>Invest Oman: </strong>Actively soliciting $130-$140M in targeted investments for OSAT facilities.</p><p><strong>Tech Agnosticism:</strong> By focusing on testing and packaging, Oman can service chips from any jurisdiction, making it a neutral service layer for the region.</p><h3>The MENA Startup Landscape: Who is buliding what and where?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/984/1*RP2GZs7ewkVfWWGHd5u4yw.png" /></figure><p>The following map visualizes the emerging ecosystem, categorized by their position in the value chain. Note how Egypt dominates the intellectual property (Design/Sensors) while the Gulf nations focus on infrastructure.</p><p><strong>Fabless Design &amp; IP (Top‑Left): </strong>This is the highest‑leverage, lowest‑capex segment, and Egypt currently dominates it.</p><ul><li><strong>InfiniLink (EgyptSerDes/Photonics)</strong>: Designs ultra‑high‑speed optical I/O and SerDes‑like photonics building blocks that enable data center and AI workloads to move from copper to light, which is exactly what GlobalFoundries acquired in the seven‑month seed‑to‑exit story.</li><li><strong>​Pearl Semiconductor (Egypt/Timing ICs):</strong> A fabless company specializing in high‑performance reference clocks and timing ICs, using proprietary SpurFree and SingleDie technologies to serve 5G, data center, and automotive applications.​</li><li><strong>Brightskies (Egypt/Automotive HW/SW):</strong> A technology company building automotive software stacks (including the BrightDrive Level 4 autonomous driving PoC) and high‑performance computing solutions, positioning Egypt as an ADAS and autonomous driving engineering hub.​</li><li><strong>Mixel Egypt R&amp;D (Mixed‑Signal IP):</strong> The Egypt design center supports Mixel’s global portfolio of mixed‑signal PHY IP (MIPI, LVDS, multi‑standard), giving local engineers direct exposure to Tier‑1 mobile and display customers.​</li><li><strong>Silicon Vision (Egypt/acquired by Synopsys):</strong> A Cairo‑based analog/mixed‑signal IP house that was acquired by Synopsys, proving that Egyptian design IP can achieve global EDA exits.</li></ul><p>This is where seed and Series A bets make the most sense: relatively small checks, heavy IP, and clear acquirer universes (Synopsys, Cadence, Analog Devices, NXP, GlobalFoundries). The InfiniLink and Silicon Vision acquisitions show that global strategics already watch this cluster.</p><p><strong>Sensors &amp; MEMS (Top‑Right): </strong>This quadrant captures companies that sit at the intersection of advanced sensing, MEMS physics, and application software.</p><ul><li><strong>Si‑Ware Systems / NeoSpectra (Egypt/Spectroscopy):</strong> Pioneered the world’s first single‑chip FT‑IR spectrometer and has moved its ultra‑miniaturized NIR spectral sensors into volume production under the NeoSpectra brand, enabling handheld material analysis in agriculture, pharma, and industrial IoT.​</li><li><strong>MEMS Vision (Egypt/Sensors): </strong>A sensor and MEMS specialist providing miniaturized solutions and IP for high‑performance electronics and the multi‑billion‑dollar sensors market, with a strong patent portfolio and HQ/footprint that includes Cairo.​</li></ul><p>MENA is already producing globally competitive sensor platforms, not just generic digital logic. These companies are closer to applied deep tech: they ship hardware, software, and often cloud platforms. That makes them particularly attractive for growth‑stage investors who like to see revenue from multiple verticals (agri, industrial, healthcare).</p><p><strong>AI &amp; Infrastructure (Bottom‑Left): </strong>This quadrant reflects platform‑level plays: manufacturing hubs, data‑center infrastructure, and ecosystem enablers.</p><ul><li><strong>Alat (Saudi Arabia/Manufacturing Hub)</strong>: A PIF‑owned company building an advanced electronics and semiconductor manufacturing ecosystem, with a US$2 billion strategic investment and collaboration with Lenovo to set up regional HQ and manufacturing facilities in Saudi Arabia, and partnerships with KACST to build capabilities in power, perception, and processing semiconductors.​</li><li><strong>Silicon21 (Egypt/Distribution/Infrastructure):</strong> A regional distributor and integrator for networking and IT hardware, acting as a key channel for semiconductor‑rich systems and creating downstream demand for chips in networking, storage, and cloud stacks (useful as a demand anchor rather than a chip designer).</li></ul><p>This is less about classic venture multiples and more about strategic co‑investment, corporate VC, and infrastructure funds. Equity stories here revolve around operating companies that will sit in clusters around Alat and national cloud/AI initiatives.</p><p><strong>OSAT &amp; Manufacturing (Bottom‑Right): </strong>This quadrant covers testing, packaging, and emerging manufacturing, which are critical to supply‑chain resilience but historically underbuilt in MENA.</p><ul><li><strong>GS Microelectronics / GSME (Oman/Testing &amp; Design):</strong> Has established Oman’s first fully equipped IC testing lab and helped design Oman‑1 and Oman‑2, the first indigenously designed chips tested successfully abroad, with nine follow‑on design projects and a dedicated IC test facility in Muscat.​</li><li><strong>GlobalFoundries (via InfiniLink integration):</strong> While not a MENA startup, GlobalFoundries’ acquisition of InfiniLink effectively ties Egyptian design talent into a global foundry pipeline, demonstrating how local IP can be absorbed into Tier‑1 manufacturing.​</li><li><strong>Intel (Israel/Legacy Fabs):</strong> Again not a MENA startup, but Intel’s long‑standing fab presence in Israel anchors regional manufacturing know‑how and provides a blueprint for how design‑heavy ecosystems can eventually attract or co‑build fabs in neighboring economies.</li></ul><p>From an ecosystem view, this is the supply‑chain “glue” that keeps design talent from drifting away. For investors, OSAT and testing labs can be capital‑moderate, cash‑flow businesses with long‑term supply contracts often more suitable for growth equity, infra funds, or industrial strategics than seed VCs, but essential to understand when evaluating exit paths for design startups.</p><h3>Learning from the Israel’s Playbook</h3><p>Before betting on MENA, VCs should study the region’s closest analog: Israel, which according to <a href="https://www.calcalistech.com/ctechnews/article/sj411cxdkwe">Calcalistech</a>, has generated $40+ billion in semiconductor exits since 1996 despite a population of just 9 million!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/888/1*2-qc_kgoddF-dJyavLWgIA.png" /></figure><p>Israel’s semiconductor success rests on a dual structure:​</p><ul><li><strong>Multinational R&amp;D Hubs:</strong> Intel (9,300 employees), Nvidia (5,500 employees), Apple, Amazon, and others maintain massive local R&amp;D footprints.​</li><li><strong>High-Value Startup Exits: </strong>Over 70 semiconductor startups have exited for a combined $44 billion, with marquee deals including Mobileye ($15.3B), Mellanox ($6.9B), and Habana Labs ($2B) (<a href="https://www.timesofisrael.com/israel-tech-exits-surge-102-in-2019-reaching-9-9-billion/">timesofisreal</a>).​</li></ul><p>For every $5 invested in US semiconductor startups, $1 flows to Israeli firms — a 1:5 ratio far stronger than the broader 1:15 VC flow between the countries. Why? Israeli semiconductor rounds are 2–4x larger than the national tech average because the work is defensible through deep IP moats. creating a funding arbitrage for investors.</p><h3>The Macro Thesis: Why MENA, Why Now?</h3><p>The investment case for MENA semiconductors rests on three macro pillars that have aligned only in the last 24 months:</p><ol><li>The Capital Supercycle: With oil prices stabilizing and sovereign wealth funds (SWFs) like the PIF (Saudi) and OIA (Oman) actively deploying capital, there is practically unlimited “dry powder” for infrastructure-heavy projects that Western VCs often shun.</li><li>Geopolitical Arbitrage: As a neutral corridor between East and West, MENA offers a safe harbor for supply chain redundancy (“China Plus One”).</li><li>The Talent Arbitrage: While Silicon Valley battles a talent shortage, Egypt is producing thousands of highly skilled, multilingual engineers at a fraction of the cost, creating a perfect storm for fabless design scalability.</li></ol><p><strong>Israel succeeds because it focuses on high-margin design and IP, not capital-intensive fabs. Egypt is replicating this design model, but with a cost base 50% lower than Tel Aviv. Meanwhile, Saudi Arabia solves the capital constraint Israel faces, and Oman fills the OSAT gap that Israel ignores.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/868/1*l89zGh2UZcxiIEV57maXVA.png" /><figcaption>MENA Semiconductor Market Revenue Forecast (2024–2033)</figcaption></figure><p>According to <a href="https://www.imarcgroup.com/middle-east-semiconductor-market">imarcgroup</a>, Middle East semiconductor market<strong> reached $30.7 billion in 2024 and is projected to hit $64.7 billion by 2033, growing at a CAGR of 8.64%. This represents a 110.8% increase over nine years; </strong>outpacing global semiconductor growth by 3%.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/922/1*3tbiAB9HfAblAHeUupq5sg.png" /></figure><p>​<br>According to <a href="https://www.indexbox.io/blog/semiconductor-device-mena-market-overview-2024-3/">indexbox</a>, Device consumption in MENA reached 273 million units in 2024. By 2035, consumption is forecast to reach 340 million units. Fueled mainly by AI investments in Saudi and UAE, with Saudi committing $10 Billion alone. with EV infrastructure and 5G connectivity being attributed as strong drivers according to <a href="https://www.kenresearch.com/industry-reports/mea-semiconductor-market-outlook-to-2028">kenresearch</a>.</p><h3>Challenges Ahead in MENA</h3><p>No venture opportunity is without risk. MENA’s semiconductor ambitions face five critical barriers that will determine success or failure:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/919/1*dcoPauA1DHReKMS620Fxtw.png" /></figure><p>1. The Talent Shortage (60% High Impact)<br>The global industry faces a shortage of over 1 million skilled workers by 2030. While Egypt produces 50,000 engineers annually, specialized training is the bottleneck. Programs partnering with TSMC and Synopsys are critical to closing this gap.​</p><p>2. Infrastructure Deficits (70% High Impact)<br>Building a fab takes 3–5 years and requires massive water/energy resources. While Saudi Arabia has the capital ($10B+ per fab), the operational complexity of running a fab in a desert climate remains a significant engineering hurdle.​</p><p>3. IP &amp; Export Controls (40% Impact)<br>US export controls on advanced AI chips affect the region. However, this drives local innovation in legacy nodes (28nm+) and specialized chips (like InfiniLink’s photonics) which are less restricted but highly valuable</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>For the venture capitalist, the MENA semiconductor thesis is about identifying the right entry point. As the US and China decouple and Europe pursues sovereignty, MENA represents the last major “white space” for establishing a new regional pole. and with that an arbitrage (or 3) opportunities emerge</p><ul><li><strong>Talent arbitrage:</strong> World-class engineers at 10% of Silicon Valley cost</li><li><strong>Capital arbitrage:</strong> Sovereign co-investment at scale unavailable in traditional ecosystems​</li><li><strong>Geopolitical arbitrage:</strong> Neutrality as a supply chain hedge during US-China tensions​</li></ul><p>The window is narrowing. First movers entering 2025–2027 will capture the 8.64% CAGR market growth and establish relationships before multinationals fully entrench. Those waiting until 2030+ will face entrenched competition, higher valuations, and saturated niches.​ <strong>Israel generated $40 billion in exits over 30 years. MENA’s market will exceed $64 billion in less than a decade! </strong>For venture capitalists, the question is not whether MENA semiconductors will succeed, it’s whether you’ll be invested before the rest of the market realizes what’s happening.</p><p>The Bottom Line is that <strong>MENA is no longer just purchasing technology; it is beginning to build it. </strong>We are witnessing the birth of a new semiconductor corridor, one that uses sand not just for construction, but for silicon. The arbitrage window is open; but it won’t stay that way for long.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5335e854cda6" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/included-vc/silicon-sands-the-untapped-potential-of-menas-semiconductor-awakening-5335e854cda6">Silicon Sands: The Untapped Potential of MENA’s Semiconductor Awakening</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/included-vc">Included VC</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Next Gold Rush or another bubble? Demystifying the GameTech in MENA!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/included-vc/the-next-gold-rush-or-another-bubble-demystifying-the-gametech-in-mena-fc326477953d?source=rss-9e0744f10d83------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fc326477953d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[venture-capital]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ahmed Sherif Edris]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 Aug 2025 17:52:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-12T08:46:02.138Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>TL; DR</strong></h3><p>• MENA is the <strong>fastest-growing gaming market in the world</strong>, expected to hit <strong>$8.8B by 2027</strong> at a <strong>38% CAGR</strong>.<br> • Youth-heavy demographics (67% of population under 30), mobile penetration, and <strong>record-breaking esports events</strong> are fueling momentum.<br> • The ecosystem is emerging across <strong>Studios, Publishers, and Toolings</strong>, with Saudi Arabia and UAE leading state-backed bets, while Egypt, Jordan, and Turkey drive talent pipelines.<br> • Challenges remain: talent bottlenecks, monetization constraints, overreliance on government subsidies, and global competition.<br> • The next decade will decide whether MENA becomes <strong>just a market for global games</strong> or a <strong>producer of global IP</strong></p><h3>🌍<strong> Intro</strong></h3><p>I still remember my childhood in those smoky internet cafés in Cairo where my friends crowded around CounterStike (A popular first-person shooting game) tournaments. That sheer desire to try new games defined so much of our youth. Looking back to my younger self. Why is this desire to play games not even relevant to our culture and seem to be disoriented at best. Is this a new form of digital colonialism, consuming stories built elsewhere, while ours went untold? I never found the answer. But what I know is that this desire has stayed lingering in today&#39;s youth. A desire that now fills <strong>40,000-seater arenas in Riyadh and Cairo</strong>, hosting global championships streamed to millions worldwide. What I believe is that this consumerist desire must have its equal tide: people passionate not just about playing but creating. <strong>Gaming in MENA is not a passing fad; It’s an industry that is at a tipping point, backed by talent, demographics, culture, and venture capital.</strong></p><h3>🕹️<strong> Gaming Technology &amp; Market Overview</strong></h3><p>When I think about MENA gaming today, the first word that comes to mind is <strong>youth</strong>. Nearly <strong>67% of the population is under 30</strong>, and the region has some of the highest smartphone penetration rates in the world. That combination alone makes it clear: gaming here isn’t a niche hobby; it’s a <strong>mainstream cultural habit</strong>.</p><p><strong>🎯 Game Types in MENA</strong></p><p>Saudi gamers, for instance, spend around <strong>8 hours a week</strong> on average playing games. That’s not just “passing time.” That’s a lifestyle, a culture, and in many cases, an identity. The way people in the U.S. rally around football or Japan around anime. in MENA, gaming is starting to play a similar role. But what exactly are people playing? From my vantage point, I see two big buckets:<br> 1. <strong>Mobile-first casual &amp; hypercasual games</strong>.<br> This is where MENA shines right now. Studios like <strong>Snax</strong>, <strong>Jawaker</strong>, and <strong>Tamatem</strong> have figured out the formula for creating addictive, snackable games that fit right into our mobile-heavy daily routines. These games don’t require AAA graphics or 100-hour campaigns. They’re lightweight, accessible, and they travel across borders fast.<br> 2. <strong>Esports &amp; competitive games</strong>.<br> Then there’s the adrenaline-fueled side of the industry: competitive teams like <strong>Falcons</strong>, <strong>NASR Esports</strong>, and <strong>Galaxy Racer</strong> are pushing MENA onto the global stage. I still remember the energy around the PUBG Global Championship in Cairo. Tens of thousands watching in person, millions streaming online. It reminded me of those smoky internet cafés I grew up in, except now the stage is global.</p><p>When I try to make sense of this ecosystem, I like to compare it to cinema. Just like the film industry has <strong>studios, distributors, and supporting Toolings</strong>, gaming in MENA is crystallizing into three distinct categories:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/463/1*FOKe7Q5-v0qMJZzxMciuhA.png" /><figcaption>Gaming Landscape in MENA</figcaption></figure><p>🎨 <strong>Studios</strong> — They’re the artists and builders, creating intellectual property (IP), graphics, and code. Think of <strong>Tamatem</strong> in Jordan or smaller indie teams experimenting with mobile hits.<br> 🎬 <strong>Publishers</strong> — These are the distributors. They make sure a game actually reaches its audience. And in MENA, they play an even bigger role: <strong>localization</strong>. Just as a movie might be dubbed or subtitled, games need to be adapted to resonate with Arabic language, culture, and humor.<br> 🛠️ <strong>Toolings</strong> — This is the invisible infrastructure that makes everything else possible. Payments. Cloud hosting. Animation software. Even Arabic 3D engines. Without this layer, the studios and publishers can’t scale.</p><p>And this is where I find Tarek Fouad’s perspective from Shorooq Partners particularly sharp. In an interview, he noted:</p><p><em>“Good gamers are good critics. In other words, they know what features matter and what doesn’t. But creating games is like an art — you need the business side to monetize, and that’s what we lack.”</em></p><p>That last part sticks with me. MENA isn’t short on passion or raw creativity. Our players are already competing — and winning — on global leaderboards. But our creators often miss the <strong>business discipline</strong> needed to scale games into sustainable companies. It’s one thing to design a fun mechanic; it’s another to build an economy inside a game that generates recurring revenue.</p><p>Ahmad Saqfalhait, a founder and an associate professor of Practice of Design at the American university in Cairo once put it bluntly:</p><p><em>“If you focus only on graphics, you’ll never build a Red Dead Redemption in the Middle East. What we need first is to spread indie game culture, so people actually learn game design by doing.”</em></p><p>And he’s right. It’s not about chasing AAA titles overnight. It’s about seeding an ecosystem where indie developers experiment, fail, share knowledge, and eventually create breakout hits. That’s how Japan built its studios. That’s how Turkey produced Peak Games. And that’s the path MENA needs to walk.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xyvIpGcavIzX4vcN.jpg" /><figcaption>GameTech computing market map — the list is non-exhaustive — feel free to reach out on <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/ahmedsherifff/">LinkedIn</a> to add your company</figcaption></figure><h3>💰<strong> The $8.8B Bet on the Gaming Landscape</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/454/1*jJFJ41GOxK0x_zcc9E21xQ.png" /></figure><p>When I first saw the market numbers, I had to double-check:<br> • <strong>$3.1B in 2022</strong><br> • <strong>$8.8B forecast by 2027</strong></p><p>To put these numbers into perspective, that’s a <strong>38% CAGR, </strong>the highest growth rate for gaming anywhere in the world (Statista, Niko Partners). For context, global gaming is expected to grow closer to <strong>8–10% CAGR</strong>. In other words, MENA isn’t just catching up; it’s accelerating. Why you might ask? The demographics are undeniable:<br><strong> </strong>• 67% of the population is under 30<strong><br></strong> • Smartphone penetration is among the highest globally<br> • Saudi gamers spend <strong>8 hours per week on average. </strong>The world’s highest</p><p>This is raw consumer demand, and like any rising tide, it pulls supply with it. And this demand is also on the ground what I call🎮<strong> The Arena Effect: Mega Esports as Cultural Catalysts </strong>When Riyadh hosted the <em>PUBG Global Championship</em> and Cairo hosted <em>Insomnia</em>, I realized something important: gaming in MENA has moved from bedrooms to arenas. Imagine <strong>40,000 fans</strong> packed into a stadium, watching a virtual battle unfold on giant screens, while millions more tune in online. These mega-events aren’t just spectacles; they’re <strong>cultural tipping points</strong>. They normalize gaming as a mainstream entertainment form — like football, but digital. And they create aspirational pathways for young players who suddenly see “gaming” not as a hobby, but as a legitimate career. As Maged Farrag, founder of VR startup UBR, told me:<em>“If the Gulf countries wanted to make games, they would buy foreign ones instead of establishing their own studios. But esports? That’s where they’re planting their flag first — because it scales fast, and it shows the world they’re serious.” </em>Governments get it too. Saudi’s <strong>Vision 2030</strong> earmarks gaming as a strategic sector. The UAE is already experimenting with metaverse experiences. Egypt, while smaller in capital outlay, is producing raw esports talent and grassroots startups.</p><p>VCs like to hedge their risks and that’s where 📈<strong> The Turkey Precedent comes as a testament of what’s Possible</strong> If we want to see the trajectory, we don’t have to look too far: Turkey.<br> • In the last decade, Turkey has produced <strong>Peak Games (sold to Zynga for $1.8B)</strong> and <strong>Dream Games (valued at $2.75B)</strong>.<br> • What started as scrappy mobile studios turned into unicorns — off the back of <strong>casual and hyper-casual mobile games</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/994/1*Jn2U9T1-1M7T7yt7CkjACw.png" /><figcaption>Source: <a href="https://magnitt.com/research/turkey-vs-mena-venture-investments-in-gaming-premium-report-50889?utm_source=socialmedia&amp;utm_medium=Youtube&amp;utm_campaign=2023reports">Magnitt</a></figcaption></figure><p>MENA shares similar demographics with Turkey: mobile-first audiences, young populations, and strong esports culture. The difference? Turkey got its VC bet <strong>early</strong>. MENA’s venture capital has only just started dipping its toes.</p><p>As Shorooq’s Tarek Fouad reminded me:</p><p><em>“VCs look for a team that’s got its hands dirty — piloting a product, knowing the game economy. The challenge is, in MENA, we don’t yet have enough of those teams. But when the multiplier effect kicks in, talent steps out and starts their own studios.”</em></p><p>And that’s the $8 billion bet: <strong>today’s players become tomorrow’s founders.</strong></p><h3>🔁Betting on <strong>The Multiplier Effect</strong></h3><p>Every global game economy that scaled followed the same pattern:<br> 1. <strong>Players first</strong> (mass adoption, cultural legitimacy)<br> 2. <strong>Studios next</strong> (small indie teams testing IPs)<br> 3. <strong>Funding flows in</strong> (once first exits prove the model)<br> 4. <strong>Ecosystem compounds</strong> (talent spins out, tools emerge, publishers scale up)</p><p>MENA is between <strong>Step 1 and Step 2</strong>. Esports and consumption are booming, but the pipeline from player to creator is still thin. That’s where VCs, accelerators, and sovereign funds will play a crucial role. I think of it as a generational flywheel. Once a few MENA studios break out globally, the “Turkey effect” happens here: hundreds of micro-studios spring up, chasing the same dream. And this time, with <strong>400+ million Arabic speakers</strong>, the home market is even bigger.</p><p><strong>Where are we, and where are we heading</strong></p><p>When I look at the region’s gaming scene today, what strikes me most is how quickly it’s professionalizing and diversifying beyond its origins as just “people playing games.” Esports organizations are no longer relying purely on sponsorships; they’re evolving into full-fledged businesses that monetize across merchandise, streaming rights, training academies, and even influencer-led creator content.</p><p>The ecosystem is starting to mimic what we saw in Korea and China ten years ago — a flywheel where competition, content, and commerce reinforce one another. But what excites me even more is the Arabic-localized publishing opportunity. Right now, the market is starved for culturally relevant games; as Ahmad Saqfalhait put it, <em>“In the Middle East, indie game culture needs to be spread first so that they can gain experience in game design.”</em> This gap is precisely what makes mobile-first casual games such a powerful wedge. Titles that weave in local storylines, humor, or even folklore can dominate playtime because no one else is building them at scale.</p><p>The creator economy adds another multiplier here: Saudi, UAE, and Egypt already have massive gaming influencer communities with audiences in the millions, and their role in shaping consumer adoption cannot be overstated. At the longer horizon, I can see the outlines of something bigger: Studio studios experimenting with homegrown franchises, VR and metaverse startups like UBR in Cairo building multiplayer experiences, and Web3-native economies that merge digital ownership with play.</p><p>As Tarek Fouad reminded me, <em>“Every game has a story; but not every story could be a game.”</em> But in MENA, the reverse is also true: every player has a story, and we’re only beginning to discover which of them could become the next global IP.</p><h3><strong>Conclusion</strong></h3><p>The MENA gaming ecosystem is not at its “ChatGPT moment” yet; but the pieces ARE aligning: youth, capital, sovereign strategies, and cultural hunger for localized content. The next decade will decide whether the region stays a market for global games or becomes a producer of global IP.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fc326477953d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/included-vc/the-next-gold-rush-or-another-bubble-demystifying-the-gametech-in-mena-fc326477953d">The Next Gold Rush or another bubble? Demystifying the GameTech in MENA!</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/included-vc">Included VC</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>