<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Andrew J. Willshire on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Andrew J. Willshire on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ajwillshire?source=rss-73e9470431cd------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 18:47:21 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ajwillshire/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Vote early, vote often…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ajwillshire/vote-early-vote-often-d3a07991beec?source=rss-73e9470431cd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d3a07991beec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[uk-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrew J. Willshire]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Jun 2016 12:28:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-06-08T12:30:14.305Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>How would you vote if you knew how everyone else voted?</p><p>I was considering my vote in the forthcoming EU referendum and I was forced to confront a slightly odd notion. If I knew (for certain) how the country was going to vote I might change my own.</p><p>For example, if the vote was 60% — 40% (in either direction), I would probably vote with the winning side. I would judge that my contribution could not sway the decision but that it was better for the result to be as clear as possible. If the vote was 52% — 48% then I would stick to my guns given that it couldn’t be a clear result anyway.</p><p>If the vote was 75% — 25% I might decide that the minority side should at least look respectable. If it was 99%-1%, I’d worry that my judgement was wildly off beam if I voted with such a minority. (Which isn’t to say that the minority is wrong.)</p><p>If the vote was precisely 50% — 50% and I had the casting vote, the stress would be unbearable. It is one thing contributing a vote to a “wisdom of crowds” outcome but taking responsibility for the decision myself would be another matter.</p><p>The same issue arises in a general election. If you knew that a minor party candidate was actually quite close to the winner, you might change your vote in favour of that person. If you knew that the country as a whole was voting in a Conservative government with a majority of 12 then you might be inclined to move to support them in order to produce a stronger government or you might be inclined to move away from them and push them into a second coalition or, potentially, into opposition.</p><p>In Scotland, the SNP have virtually all of the seats but half of the vote. There were a number of seats where a potentially joint-Unionist candidate might have been victorious but no-one knew in advance. Some of the knowledge almost certainly impacted the recent Scottish election where some Labour and Conservative voters must have voted for the “most-likely-Unionist”.</p><p>Is there a way of this becoming reality? Introducing “convergent” voting…</p><p>In various branches of mathematics and statistics you encounter the notion of convergence. For example, if you had to guess a number between 1 and 100 that a friend was thinking of, and they told you whether your guess was too high or too low then you might follow a common pattern of guessing “50, 25, 37, 31, 34, 33” — you gradually converged on the correct result.</p><p>Imagine you had a system of voting where everyone voted electronically in a “first-past-the-post” system and could see the result the following day. Everyone was then given an opportunity to change their vote if they wished having seen the first result. No-one would be obliged to change but everyone had the option. No-hope candidates would probably experience a drop in support as voters realised that they could not win. Candidates with massive support might experience a drop as voters want to make the contributions of other candidates seem worthwhile. Most constituencies would probably be quite stable, although I would expect the number of marginal constituencies would increase. Non-voters might realise that they had the potential to influence a result and join in for later rounds.</p><p>Voters would then be given a third, fourth and fifth day in which to consider whether to switch their vote again. Gradually, the number of people still wishing to change their vote would tend towards zero — in other words, we would converge on an acceptable election result.</p><p>It’s a little like the Alternative Vote system on steroids, but with the advantage of immediate feedback and time for consideration, rather than trying to guess a strategy for tactical voting in advance. The system would be easier to understand as you still only have one vote to allocate, with no ranking required.</p><p>(One of my favourite voting stories of recent years comes from <a href="https://twitter.com/tom_watson/status/634680213285269504">Tom Watson</a>. In the election for the Labour deputy leadership, voters had to rank candidates in order of preference. He was working the phone banks and spoke to someone who had already voted. The person said “I gave the most votes to you.”<br>“Most votes?”<br>“Yeah, five for you, four for Angela, three for…”)</p><p>It’s also got similarities to two-round voting, such as the French presidential election, where the two highest-ranked candidates go into the final round. However, you still have to try and predict what other people might do.</p><p>Given that we can’t even vote once electronically at the moment, this feels like a bit of a step. But in theory, once that technology becomes available, there is no reason why you couldn’t implement convergent voting. You could end up with a system that could provide a strong FPTP-style government that had clear majority support, that could give greater opportunity to minority parties in particular seats, retained the advantage of constituency-member representation and that engaged non-voters. What’s not to love?</p><p>For the EU referendum, though, I wonder what the impact would be. Currently, the vote appears to be roughly tied at 50%-50%. I think that in such circumstances there would be a slight shift to the more (small C) conservative Remain side, followed by considerable buyer’s remorse following the final outcome. Which is pretty much what I expect to happen anyway.</p><p>(If you liked this piece, please press the little green heart button below — thanks!)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d3a07991beec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The European Question]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ajwillshire/the-european-question-e6befd4a3e4e?source=rss-73e9470431cd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e6befd4a3e4e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[brexit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uk-politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrew J. Willshire]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Jun 2016 01:22:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-06-08T12:29:41.355Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On the 3rd March my friend Mark sent me a Facebook message:<br>“Morning buddy — need an assist. I trust your judgement on all things political. […] EU referendum: in or out?”</p><p>I promised him that I’d get back to him. Three months later, and with less than three weeks till polling day, this is me finally trying to deliver that answer. This is the single hardest political decision I’ve ever had to make and I’m still not confident that I’m right. However, if you sit on the fence too long you get splinters, so here goes…</p><p>At this moment in time, I think I’m going to vote to leave the EU.</p><p>Before I come to my reasoning, here’s some housekeeping. Firstly, I believe that the identities of the pro-Brexit and pro-Remain campaigners and commentators don’t really matter. There are honest, respectable, accomplished voices on both sides of the argument, just as there are scoundrels and cretins. We are not electing either side into government; rather we are setting the stage on which our elected government operates. (What I’m saying is that it doesn’t matter if you don’t trust Boris with the NHS — you will be free to vote him out at an election. That really isn’t a reason to stay. Equally, getting rid of Cameron isn’t a reason to leave either.)</p><p>Secondly, if the Prime Minister had achieved his renegotiation aims as he set out in his Bloomberg speech then I would probably be voting to Remain. It was the emptiness of the renegotiation package which made me start to seriously consider this issue. I genuinely believed that Cameron would get a good deal. I was mistaken. (I still consider him to be the best available Prime Minister, though.)</p><p>Thirdly, I doubt that this course of action is in my short-term (or possibly long-term) financial interests. I hope that this is not a decision that can simply be perceived as being self-interested.</p><p>Fourthly, I have written and deleted and redrafted this many times — please excuse any meanderings and grammatical errors.</p><p>Ok, in no particular order…</p><p><strong>Reason 1: The EU is changing</strong></p><p>For the Euro to survive there will need to be deeper financial and, ultimately, political integration of the Euro-zone countries. If this process is to happen, Britain needs to stand aside from that and allow it to happen in the way that those countries require or desire. They do not need the UK carping from the sidelines. Indeed, as part of the renegotiation, the UK agreed not to stand in the way of any deepening Eurozone integration.</p><p>However, I do not believe that the UK should be subject to wider EU regulation that may be in the interests of those core countries but not in the interests of the non-core countries. In future, the needs of the UK will be secondary to the needs of the core-EU members and we will find ourselves outvoted consistently on matters of importance.</p><p>Just as the Leave campaign hasn’t done a particularly good job of saying what “Out” looks like, I don’t think the Remain campaign has engaged at all with valid questions of what “In” will look like over the next decade and beyond. However, if we leave the EU then we are free to elect a government to shape the country and to negotiate deals with our neighbours on mutually beneficial terms whereas if we remain then our government will have little discretion over many policy areas.</p><p><strong>Reason 2: The EU has a basic democratic deficit</strong></p><p>The British people cannot change the policies of the EU through the ballot box. A (disputed) percentage of laws that we are subject to are created by non-elected officials. You may regard this as acceptable compromise in that we influence laws that other nations are subject to. I feel that it is lacking in democratic legitimacy.</p><p>During the course of the campaign I’ve heard many on the left state that the EU is required to protect the people from the (Tory) government. This is a fundamentally undemocratic position. I wonder if the same people would agree if the EU were to prevent Prime Minister Jeremy Corbyn from enacting his manifesto in full (which it would). However, I cannot put it any better than Tony Benn when he said “<a href="https://medium.com/@WhiteWednesday/tony-benn-on-democracy-and-the-eu-20th-november-1991-2f734f163ddf#.g9tefjfb5">They believe that a good king is better than a bad Parliament</a>” (please do read the whole speech, if only for a reminder of when serious thinkers became MPs, not just ex-Special Advisors).</p><p>The EU is currently considering whether to sanction the democratically-elected Polish government for some of its policies. Now, you may (as I do) consider that some of these are bad policies that deserve to be challenged. However, I find it difficult to believe that it is the responsibility of unelected officials to do the challenging. The Polish electorate are within their rights to elect a bad government (as perceived externally), just as the British people should be able to elect whomever they wish without contradiction. It should be for opposition parties and campaigners to argue against governments, not outsiders.</p><p>The lack of democratic consent can also be seen in the response to the Irish, French and Dutch referendums rejecting the “EU Constitution”. The whole deal was repackaged as the Lisbon Treaty and enacted regardless. (Gordon Brown, having faced demands for a UK referendum decided to sign the Lisbon Treaty, but only when he hoped no-one was watching!)</p><p>In the words of Jean-Claude Juncker, the current president of the European Commission, ahead of the 2005 French vote: “If it’s a Yes, we will say ‘on we go’, and if it’s a No we will say ‘we continue’”.</p><p>If this is the EU’s notion of democracy then I believe it is better to depart.</p><p><strong>Reason 3: Fundamental rights and legal systems</strong></p><p>The idea that the EU is responsible for our fundamental rights is bogus. The UK created and exported the notion of human rights with Magna Carta. In fact, with the European Arrest Warrant, British citizens have lost some of their fundamental rights and can be extradited and imprisoned by a foreign judge who has no need to present evidence in an open court.</p><p>Part of the issue stems from the incompatibility between the British tradition of Common Law and the European legal system that is largely based on Roman law and the Napoleonic Code. Generally (as I understand it), common law provides greater protection for the individual while Roman law empowers the state. The difference is also one of the reasons that the Civil Service has a tendency to “gold-plate” EU legislation — legal interpretation on the continent is quite different from interpretation in the UK due to the ways in which legal precedents are handled.</p><p>The judicial activism of European courts also represents a threat to British sovereignty due to their ability and willingness to interpret law as they see fit, rather than in the spirit in which it was drafted (particularly with regards to human rights legislation). It is also fundamentally undemocratic that the highest court in our land is foreign.</p><p>While there are some social protections provided for in recent EU law, many were present in UK law beforehand. For example, the “Facebook fact” that the EU is responsible for employees having paid holidays is a myth — the “Holidays with Pay” act was introduced in the UK in 1938. Also, does anyone seriously believe that the first act of Prime Minister Johnson would be to abolish holidays?</p><p>In summary, I believe that the British legal tradition is the best of anywhere in the World and that remaining in the EU serves only to diminish it.</p><p><strong>Reason 4: Business regulation</strong></p><p>Harmonisation of regulation is sold as one of the key benefits of belonging to the single market. This policy does indeed suit large multinational corporations who operate across borders. However, companies that do not sell to the EU are still bound by the same regulations. This is an enormous administrative burden which large companies can cope with far better than small ones.</p><p>Also, the EU is heavily lobbied by these corporate interests who often seek to use EU regulation to stifle competition. For example, James Dyson said in 2014: <em>“</em><a href="http://www.express.co.uk/news/politics/538488/Why-we-must-quit-EU-tycoon-Sir-James-Dyson"><em>In our particular field we have these large German companies who dominate standard setting and energy reduction committees, and so we get old technology supported and not new technology.</em></a><em>”</em></p><p>(Some of you familiar with my political views might think it odd that I’m bashing corporations. Well, I consider myself a “capitalist”, not a “corporatist”, a distinction that’s as important to me as the distinction between “democratic socialism” and “Stalinism” is to my friends on the left!)</p><p><strong>Reason 5: The Common Agricultural Policy</strong></p><p>The CAP is the system whereby the EU throws up an external tariff (averaging 18%) on agricultural imports while subsidising inefficient farmers within the EU. This increases global food prices, while reducing the ability of, for example, African farmers to freely trade their way out of poverty. No amount of aid is as effective as allowing people to sell their produce in a fair market. Instead, €60 billion is spent every year on wealthy European farmers who often operate inefficiently. Tony Blair gave up a portion of the British budget rebate in exchange for CAP reform which never occurred. In summary, this is a hugely expensive policy which deepens global poverty and should be abolished, regardless of whether we stay or go.</p><p><strong>Reason 6: The Common Fisheries Policy</strong></p><p>The CFP is partially responsible for the collapse in fish stocks in European waters as well as the devastation of the British fishing fleet and ports. Leaving the EU would allow this particular industry to thrive again, hopefully in a way that is more sustainable for fish stocks.</p><p><strong>Reason 7: Trade</strong></p><p>The UK is currently unable to negotiate trade deals with other non-EU nations. Trade deals must be agreed at an EU level. However, the principle of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_advantage">comparative advantage</a> dictates that economies are most efficient when individuals (and countries) focus their efforts on activities in which they are most efficient. Trying to negotiate a trade deal between the EU and a non-EU country is difficult because each EU country has indigenous industries that they wish to protect. Every country in the EU is therefore handicapped by every other country during negotiations.</p><p>It has taken years of negotiation (in secret) to get close to agreeing a trade deal with the USA yet it is still likely to fail. (Incidentally, the UK is in the top ten exporters to the USA despite their being no trade deal, while the USA is the number one investor in the UK.) A deal with Canada is under threat because of protests from Germany and Belgium.</p><p>I believe that the UK would be able to agree better deals more quickly with other non-EU countries if it were to leave. I also believe that the EU would come to a good deal with the UK following a Brexit simply due to it being in their best interest. Why would they cut off their biggest export market while denying themselves quality goods offered by UK companies? (It is, of course, vital to note that it is individuals and companies that trade internationally, not governments; the best thing governments can do is to get out of the way.)</p><p><strong>Reason 8: Social cohesion</strong></p><p>I believe that in the event of a Remain vote, there will be a clear divide between those who voted Leave and those who voted Remain. I believe that the Remainers are likely to be wealthier, more likely to have attended university, more likely to be living in big cities. For these people (and I am one) Remain could easily be perceived as a self-interested vote. The people who suffer the greatest impact from EU membership are older, poorer, less extensively educated and more likely to be from smaller towns and rural areas. I think that this divide is a fault-line in our society that it would be foolish to ignore.</p><p>For example, following a Remain vote, I think many people who voted to leave (likely to be at least 40% of the population) will transfer their votes to UKIP which could radically change the complexion of British politics, particularly as Labour will not be seen to be representative of their views. I do not believe this change in British politics will be a positive one and I think it could engender greater hostility to immigrants than has previously been seen in the UK. A similar divide has opened up in the USA where the “losers” of globalisation have propelled Donald Trump to the Republican presidential nomination.</p><p>It is not sufficient to govern to improve the “average” household income. Globalisation will produce winners and losers. How content are we that we can say to our fellow citizens “Sorry, you lose”?</p><p><strong>Reason 9: Animal welfare</strong></p><p>Since marrying a vegetarian, I have taken greater care regarding the welfare of farm animals. The UK standards of animal welfare are considerably higher than in most other EU nations (for example, those who produce foie gras and engage in bullfighting). However, we are unable to enforce our standards on other countries, meaning that, for example, British animals can be transported in poor conditions to low-standard abattoirs on the continent. We are also unable to prevent low-welfare animal produce from the continent from being sold in the UK.</p><p><strong>Reason 10: Global leadership</strong></p><p>I am proud of being British. I believe that our legal and parliamentary systems are good examples to the rest of the World. I believe that we are lucky to live in a country that has remarkably little corruption (by European, let alone global, standards). We have the World’s primary language and arguably its greatest city. We have the 5th largest economy and the 4th largest military (and are prepared to use it in defence of human rights abroad). We have a permanent seat on the UN Security Council.</p><p>In the next century, why wouldn’t we stand on an even footing with countries like Australia, Brazil, India, Canada, New Zealand, China, Japan, the USA, South Africa, Nigeria, etc? None of these countries is willing to subsume itself into a larger unit. Each of those countries has its own voice — why shouldn’t we?</p><p>I do not believe that our influence is greater by being part of a larger bloc of countries. I find it hard to discern that our voice is louder from being part of the EU — rather, it seems diluted by the constant compromise with countries that have different priorities.</p><p>If Britain votes to leave the EU, we will be better able to lead on a global level with greater clarity of purpose.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>So, that, in a rather extensive nutshell, is my rationale for the way I expect to vote. Things may yet change, though.</p><p>There are several meaty issues that I am aware that I have ignored in this post. I intend to consider at least some of those in a subsequent post, and respond to any comments, queries, challenges and propositions that this post provokes.</p><p>(If you liked this piece, please press the little green heart button below — thanks!)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e6befd4a3e4e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why can’t Doctor Who just follow the rules?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ajwillshire/why-can-t-doctor-who-just-follow-the-rules-955610230d55?source=rss-73e9470431cd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/955610230d55</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tv-series]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rules]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[doctor-who]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrew J. Willshire]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 06 Dec 2015 00:10:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-12-07T10:39:43.629Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Now, don’t get me wrong. I like <em>Doctor Who</em>. I just don’t like it as much as I should. When it’s good, it is inventive, exciting and whip-smart. When it’s bad, it is mawkish, sentimental, contrived nonsense. Mostly, however, it sits somewhere in between though occasionally it manages to ricochet from one extreme to the other within three minutes.</p><p>The main issue I have with the programme, though, is the way that I get annoyed when it’s bad. It’s just unnecessary. The show-runners have given themselves the whole of time and space to play with. What other show is so free of constraints imposed by period, place or setting? The central character is impossibly old, literally containing multitudes, but remains eternally youthful enough to be free of any geriatric limitations. The roster of supporting characters is thin enough and transient enough to prevent long-established relationships from burdening the character while rich enough that they can always throw in a familiar face to add context or spice.</p><p>And yet… something is rotten in the state of Gallifrey. (Or is it Cardiff?) And the root cause is a casual disregard for rules.</p><p>Rules are essential for any programme. And things never go well when writers and producers succumb to the temptation to flex the rules.</p><p>Usually, there aren’t many. Soap operas usually have a single principal rule — their limited setting is the extent of the known universe. <em>Eastenders </em>has the square, <em>Corrie </em>has the street, as does <em>Neighbours</em>. When characters “moved to Brisbane”, that was the end, except for a “phone call” once every six months, usually just ending as the scene begins, and most commonly to explain exactly why they wouldn’t be attending their sister’s wedding or father’s funeral. But that’s the rule and it would be ruinous if they started following characters beyond the edge of the map.</p><p><em>Only Fools and Horses </em>had a single rule. The Trotters were losers. Everything they did had to fail. Unfortunately , John Sullivan eventually felt sorry enough for his characters that he contrived for them to effectively win the lottery by discovering a Harrison chronometer in their old lock-up. The set-up no longer worked with the characters as millionaires so as soon as possible afterwards they were unceremoniously returned to their original setting. Too late though — it’s impossible to recover from a shattered universe.</p><p>Happy Days coined the phrase with one shark too man<em>y. Roseanne </em>also broke all sense of willing suspension with sudden unimaginable wealth and eventually ended up falling into the Dallas “it was all a dream” bargain bin. <em>Glee </em>was bearable for about season but almost immediately stopped respecting its core DNA by focusing on individuals at the expense of the collective. No character should be bigger than the show. You want to follow them to Broadway? That used to be called a spin-off. <em>Joey </em>failed because the rules for that character (he’s an idiot) didn’t allow plausible development to the level required to sustain a series. <em>Frasier </em>succeeded because the rules governing his character allowed flexibility without requiring compromise.</p><p>The rules don’t have to be simple — they just have to be maintained. <em>Game of Thrones</em> has dozens but the tightly written source material helps enforce them. Examples:</p><ul><li>No guns or cannon. Not even a sniff of sulphur or saltpetre* in the air.</li><li>Some humans can use mind control on animals but it’s hard.</li><li>Dragons are real but hard to domesticate.</li><li>Zombies are real but <em>really </em>hard to domesticate.</li><li>Everyone is vulnerable. No-one is Rambo or Arnie.</li></ul><p>So far, so obvious, you might say. But it’s easy to imagine an executive producer asking that the Grand Maester “discovers” how to build a pistol / rifle / Gatling gun. Or that one of the zombies has a heart of gold and saves Jon from another zombie. Or that Jaime is suddenly able to fight off twenty swordsmen with his left hand before swinging through a window onto a horse and riding to safety. It would feel wrong. You would feel slightly unclean after watching it because you would know that you were complicit in the rules being broken.</p><p>So back to <em>Doctor Who</em>. Everyone’s favourite episode, “Blink”, was Doctor-light but had one simple rule. There were stone angels who moved when you couldn’t see them. That’s it. Maintaining that rule is easy and the programme is effective. Later episodes featuring the Weeping Angels tried to add additional back-story and almost ruined the idea.</p><p>“Love and Monsters” with Peter Kay as an Abzorbaloff was widely panned but I thought it was quite effective due to the simplicity of the premise. The bit that was least “likely”, having established the rules, was the use of the bloody sonic screwdriver to keep the love interest alive as a paving slab.</p><p>What are the rules governing the sonic screwdriver? Does it work on wood? Sometimes, sometimes not, because, err, well, plot. Does it work on machines? Umm, sometimes, depending on, err, well, plot. How is it that the reasonably bulky technology can be compacted into sunglasses? Just because Steven said so?</p><p>What about regeneration? How often can a Time Lord regenerate? Definitely sufficient for one more. Can he/she pass on regeneration energy to someone else? If necessary, but not always.</p><p>Can the Doctor choose where the TARDIS takes him and his companion? Sometimes. Sometimes the TARDIS decides. Apparently. Sometimes wibbly-wobbly, timey-wimey. Sometimes he’s so good at flying the damn thing that he can travel the universe getting all his mates out of a spot of bother before he dies.</p><p>Are the Daleks emotionless, ruthless killing machines or do they get a bit nervous when the Doc is about, even if he’s just standing there, unarmed and surrounded? Where did the Cybermen come from and why is it always different? Why aren’t they that bothered by gold any more?</p><p>It goes on, and on, and on. And on. Rules exist only as temporary plot constraints and disappear as and when required. In the episode “Heaven Sent” (shown last week in the UK) the Doctor effectively relived the same day again and again every day for 4.5 billion years. Unlike Groundhog Day, though, he had no memory of the preceding days. Fine. No problem.</p><p>But in the following episode, “Hell Bent”, he gives Clara the impression that he did all this work for 4.5 billion years to get back to her and that it was that long since he saw her last. No, sorry — you can’t have it both ways. Either he experienced all the days or only the last one. Choose.</p><p>Aye, there’s the rub. It seems a small thing but it is entirely typical. A rule was created and disposed of to suit the situation. The illusion was shattered because of the constant chipping away at the foundations of plausibility.</p><p>Russell T. Davies suffered badly from it and Steven Moffat is also demonstrably vulnerable. It’s a fundamental lack of discipline, self-control and respect for the audience and I’m not sure if I can take it any more.</p><p>Well… maybe just once more.</p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p>*Except for “Salt, Petyr?” “No thank you, my lady, vinegar is sufficient…”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=955610230d55" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Not in my name”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ajwillshire/not-in-my-name-1fe19effbcf6?source=rss-73e9470431cd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1fe19effbcf6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[syria]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[labour-party]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrew J. Willshire]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 Dec 2015 18:07:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-12-03T18:08:08.590Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>My Facebook wall and Twitter feed are currently adorned with the furious declarations of friends and acquaintances that, whatever else it is, extending RAF air strikes against Daesh across the imaginary border from Iraq into Syria is not being done in their name.</p><p>#notinmyname scars the weary face of social media like a self-righteous chicken pox. It goes beyond voicing disapproval, signalling instead that the person is so virtuous that they wish to retract their participation and consent in the democratic process, thereby siphoning legitimacy from their elected representative. It insulates the individual from the consequences of the action and allows them to proclaim widely that their conscience is clear and that their character is noble.</p><p>The narcissism and solipsism of this position can easily be seen by imagining the corollary — a swarm of the self-satisfied marching around pointing out things of which they approve.</p><p>“Excuse me, I just wanted to let you know that the provision of education for you and your friends is being done in my name. You’re welcome.”</p><p>“I’m glad to hear your hip replacement operation went well — did you know that it was done in my name?”</p><p>“Just so everyone is aware, the issuing of a renewable obligation certificates for that wind turbine was done in my name, but the electricity strike price for that nuclear power station was too high to be similarly endowed. #Justsayin.”</p><p>Much has been made in recent weeks about collective responsibility, particularly in light of the Labour Party’s difficulty in forming a policy on Syria. In any cabinet there are sharp differences of opinion but there must be an accepted outcome from deliberations. Once a decision is made, ministers must accept joint responsibility and abide by the process although they may continue to lobby in private. Traditionally, if a front-bencher disagrees with a cabinet position and wishes to disagree publically or vote in opposition, then they must resign their post and return to the back-benches, ceasing to abide with the collective.</p><p>In the collective that is our society, however, there are no back-benches. We can retreat no further. Our representative democracy is the way we have agreed to form decisions and all of us are equal members with an equal vote. As a result, everything that parliament, or indeed the government, decides is done “in our name”. We may disagree passionately with the outcome but we must accept that it was reached in the agreed manner.</p><p>We must not resile from hard decisions. We have no fundamental right to a clear conscience in affairs, foreign or domestic. In shouldering this burden it becomes our duty to become better informed, to become more involved, to argue, to persuade, to cajole. We do not have to bloodlessly accept the result. We can continue to lobby for an alternative policy, we can campaign for a change to the electoral system, we can stand for office in the belief that we can improve our parliament.</p><p>Accepting what is done in our name strengthens our society, strengthens our democracy and acknowledges our collective responsibility to each other. We should not be ashamed for it is, in fact, our greatest achievement.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1fe19effbcf6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>