<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by आकांक्षा सिंह रघुवंशी on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by आकांक्षा सिंह रघुवंशी on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@akanksha00?source=rss-967e8c8d36bb------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 21:14:03 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@akanksha00/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Book review- जम्मू कश्मीर के जननायक महाराजा हरि सिंह]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@akanksha00/book-review-%E0%A4%9C%E0%A4%AE%E0%A5%8D%E0%A4%AE%E0%A5%82-%E0%A4%95%E0%A4%B6%E0%A5%8D%E0%A4%AE%E0%A5%80%E0%A4%B0-%E0%A4%95%E0%A5%87-%E0%A4%9C%E0%A4%A8%E0%A4%A8%E0%A4%BE%E0%A4%AF%E0%A4%95-%E0%A4%AE%E0%A4%B9%E0%A4%BE%E0%A4%B0%E0%A4%BE%E0%A4%9C%E0%A4%BE-%E0%A4%B9%E0%A4%B0%E0%A4%BF-%E0%A4%B8%E0%A4%BF%E0%A4%82%E0%A4%B9-a406dbe8d16f?source=rss-967e8c8d36bb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a406dbe8d16f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[आकांक्षा सिंह रघुवंशी]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 08 Jan 2026 04:59:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-08T04:59:55.912Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rbtLWAIwZ9oWWiGC-RV_Dg.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://amzn.to/49K3q3Z">https://amzn.to/49K3q3Z</a></figcaption></figure><blockquote>In the labyrinthine annals of Indian history few figures evoke as much polarized reverence and critique as Maharaja Hari Singh, the last ruling Dogra monarch of the princely state of Jammu and Kashmir. Often maligned in mainstream narratives as indecisive or aloof during the cataclysmic events of 1947, Hari Singh’s legacy has been overshadowed by the geopolitical machinations of Partition, the tribal invasion from Pakistan and the subsequent accession to India.</blockquote><p>Enter जम्मू कश्मीर के जननायक महाराजा हरि सिंह is a Hindi-language biography penned by historian Kuldeep Chand Agnihotri stands as one of the first comprehensive Hindi works to rehabilitate Hari Singh&#39;s image , portraying him not as a relic of feudalism but as a visionary &quot;people&#39;s hero&quot; whose progressive reforms and strategic dilemmas laid the groundwork for modern Kashmir&#39;s integration into India.</p><p>Author draws on archival documents, personal correspondences and lesser known Dogra records to craft a narrative that challenges the dominant historiography often influenced by Sheikh Abdullah&#39;s memoirs and Nehruvian perspectives.</p><p>This book unfolds chronologically tracing Hari Singh&#39;s life from his birth in 1895 as the great grandson of Maharaja Gulab Singh (the founder of the Dogra dynasty) to his death in exile in Mumbai in 1961. Divided into roughly 15 chapters it begins with the opulent yet intrigue filled world of the Jammu durbar under his uncle Pratap Singh where young Hari honed his administrative acumen through military postings and diplomatic sojourns in Europe.</p><p>A significant portion about 40% of the text focuses on Hari Singh&#39;s 23-year reign (1925–1947) highlighting his &quot;modernist&quot; reforms that contemporaries often dismissed as superficial. Agnihotri details initiatives like the abolition of the exploitative begar (forced labor) system in 1931 which alleviated the burdens on Kashmiri peasants; the establishment of girls&#39; schools and women&#39;s healthcare programs, predating similar efforts in British India and land reforms that redistributed jagirs (feudal estates) to tillers and reducing rural indebtedness.</p><p>These are substantiated with excerpts from state gazettes and Hari Singh&#39;s own edicts, painting him as a ruler attuned to Gandhian ideals of social equity despite his monarchical trappings.</p><p>The narrative&#39;s dramatic pivot is the 1947 crisis: the tribal lashkar invasion orchestrated by Pakistan, the Jammu massacre and the Maharaja&#39;s agonizing choice between independence, accession to India, or Pakistan. Agnihotri argues persuasively that Hari Singh&#39;s initial hesitation stemmed not from cowardice but from a desire to preserve Kashmiri autonomy amid Sheikh Abdullah&#39;s Quit Kashmir movement and Nehru&#39;s mounting impatience.</p><p>Drawing on declassified letters between Hari Singh and Sardar Patel, the book posits that the accession instrument signed on October 26, 1947 was a reluctant but resolute act of patriotism, foiled by Nehru&#39;s referral to the UN and Abdullah&#39;s subsequent power grab. Post accession chapters dissect the erosion of Dogra influence, the 1951 rigged elections and Hari Singh&#39;s dignified exile, framing it as a tragedy of &quot;betrayed sovereignty.&quot;</p><p>Interwoven are vivid vignettes: Hari Singh&#39;s passion for polo and wildlife conservation (he established India&#39;s first game sanctuary in Dachigam) his fraught relations with Jinnah and his unheeded warnings about Pakistani irredentism.</p><p>Author&#39;s greatest triumph is his archival rigor. Unlike many Kashmir histories that rely on secondary sources or oral traditions, this book brims with footnotes citing original Dogra era documents, making it a valuable resource for researchers. Thematically the book excels in demystifying myths. It counters the &quot;tyrannical Dogra&quot; trope popularized in Kashmiri nationalist literature.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a406dbe8d16f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The False Rajput Identity of Rupmati]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@akanksha00/the-false-rajput-identity-of-rupmati-32ca54c5a355?source=rss-967e8c8d36bb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/32ca54c5a355</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[आकांक्षा सिंह रघुवंशी]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 Jun 2025 03:48:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-24T03:48:38.813Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*Taw52YkWKa7dbl0Yr8yBsw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Baz Bahadur ( Sultan of Malwa) &amp; Rupmati</figcaption></figure><blockquote>There’s a disgusting trend going on where Rajput warriors are being mocked and disrespected through fictional and unrelated characters. These people pick names that have nothing to do with Rajputs and use them like slurs day in and day out. It’s not just ignorance it’s a deliberate character assassination. Linking Rajput valor with garbage like ‘Jodha Akbar’ is not just misleading it’s a direct mockery. Let’s get this straight once and for all there was no such person named &#39;Jodha’. The woman Akbar married wasn’t even called that and she had no connection to the Rajput identity being thrown around. <br>I’ve written an entire article breaking this down , it’s right there on my profile feel free to check that. I’ve also dismantled the fake stories of &#39;Kamala Devi&#39; and &#39;Devala Devi’—two names paraded as Rajput queens supposedly enslaved by Khilji. And the fun fact is that these women never existed. It’s pure fiction peddled as fact to feed victimhood and twist narratives.</blockquote><blockquote>And now the same circus continues with Rupmati and Baz Bahadur. Another over romanticized story turned into a historical joke. Rupmati had no connection to Rajputs whatsoever yet some people have the audacity to label her as a Rathore Rajput to push their drama. This isn’t just distortion it’s an insult to the blood, sacrifice and honor of actual Rajput warriors and Kshatranis who died for this land.</blockquote><blockquote>These people aren’t ‘debating history’ they’re rewriting it with lies, masking their hatred behind fake woke takes. And the worst part? They know the truth but choose the lie because it fits their agenda better.</blockquote><p>In the tangled mix of folklore and fabricated history, few stories have been as romanticized and misrepresented as that of Baz Bahadur, the sultan of Malva and Rupmati. Over time their story has been repackaged into countless love tales, often stripped of context and riddled with fictional claims especially the false portrayal of Rupmati as a Rajput princess.</p><p>Despite the obsession with assigning Rupmati a Rajput identity not a single credible historical source supports this claim. Core contemporary records like the Akbarnama, Tabaqat-i-Akbari and Muntakhab-ut-Tawarikh—all of which document the Mughal conquest of Malwa in detail make no mention of her caste whatsoever. Even later chroniclers like Firishta and the authors of Ma&#39;asir-ul-Umara, who had every opportunity to include such details remain completely silent on the subject.</p><p>The most telling omission comes from Abd al-Qadir Bada’uni, a direct eyewitness to Akbar’s conquest and a detailed historian of the period. In his Muntakhab-ut-Tawarikh, he doesn’t mention Rupmati at all let alone her background or caste. Funny how none of the original sources mentioned her Rajput caste yet people in this century magically labeled her a Rajput.</p><h3>Let’s get to the fact —</h3><ul><li>Abul Fazl’s Akbarnama mentions Rupmati a woman in Baz Bahadur’s harem.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/924/1*3C4Zc4Xj7XvyWGmOjfuIzQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Akbarnama Of Abul Fazl Vol. 2, tr. by H. Beveridge.</figcaption></figure><ul><li>The Ma’asir-ul-Umara (Vol. 1), a later historical work by Samsam ud Daula Shah Nawaz Khan and Abdul Hai Khan, translated by H. Beveridge clearly describes Rupmati as one of the dancing girls of Baz Bahadur.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IoAedJUaUvIMkQ6FQ3Am5g.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Ma’asir-ul-umara, vol. 1 by Samsam ud Daula Shah Nawaz Khan and Abdul Hai Khan, tr. by H. Beveridge (1941)</figcaption></figure><ul><li>Historian AL Srivastava calls Rupmati &quot;a courtesan&quot; in his book “Akbar The Great Vol 1 ”</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pszski34DDl0HTNYPG0vhQ.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>Historian J.M. Shelat in Akbar (1959) refers to Rupmati as “a dancing girl or a purchased slave ”</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Itx4jx2L194PxAFYtsEQtg.jpeg" /></figure><p>. The contemporary work The Lady of the Lotus clearly states that Rupmati’s origin and caste are uncertain with assigning her to a different background.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hMFo9IuglAtiJzlMUu2eNA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Yet none connect her to the Rajput community. When you lay all these accounts side by side, it becomes undeniable Rupmati had absolutely no link to Rajputs.</p><p>/- Special thanks to Arjunvanshi bhaiya.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=32ca54c5a355" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Truth About Maharana Sanga: Shattering the Myth of Babur’s Invitation with Historical Evidence]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@akanksha00/the-truth-about-maharana-sanga-shattering-the-myth-of-baburs-invitation-with-historical-evidence-404f776cf33e?source=rss-967e8c8d36bb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/404f776cf33e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[आकांक्षा सिंह रघुवंशी]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 23 Mar 2025 04:16:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-26T22:50:06.548Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZWamV6znHiKXZeyPm8DXcA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Indian politicians and self proclaimed historians have repeatedly manipulated history for their selfish gains, shamelessly distorting the legacy of great rulers who sacrificed everything for the nation. One of the most glaring examples is Maharaj Jaychand, who has been unfairly vilified as a traitor with baseless claims that he invited Ghori against Maharaj Prithviraj. Yet when challenged to provide credible historical sources, these so-called intellectuals resort to vague rhetoric and empty justifications.</p><p>Even the legendary Rana Sanga, a symbol of valor and patriotism who fought relentlessly against invaders until his last breath has not been spared from historical misrepresentation.</p><p>The claim that Rana Sanga invited Babur is a deliberate distortion of history, a propaganda piece with no credible foundation. The Baburnama often cited as proof, is itself not the original. The actual memoir of Babur was written in Chagatai Turkic but no known copy of that text survives today. The version widely available today is a Persian translation rewritten nearly six decades after Babur’s death &amp; even Babur himself lied many times in Baburnama . Babur claimed multiple times that he had only 12,000 men in his fight against Ibrahim Lodi, but modern research proves that his army at Panipat was much larger.</p><p>Additionally, no contemporary Hindu or Muslim source mentions Rana Sanga sending an ambassador to Kabul. Yet, modern historians have blindly accepted Babur’s words, despite the fact that he has lied multiple times in Baburnama.</p><p>Therefore relying solely on this secondary translation for historical accuracy is deeply flawed.</p><p>&amp; the same Baburnama states that Babur was invited by Daulat Khan Lodi and Alam Khan.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1015/1*269PK5oH-qiFfLQVcCQRbQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Babur-nama in English (Memoirs of Babur)<br>by Babur, Emperor of Hindustan, 1483-1530; Beveridge, Annette Susannah, 1842-1929</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DSvhFXRtgIs0XErj8s2sNg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QxB6FZ05J-X6nB8oMvsGmw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Military History of India by Jadunath Sarkar</figcaption></figure><h3>Let’s analyze the truth…</h3><p>These people often peddle the myth that Rana Sanga needed Babur’s help to defeat Ibrahim Lodi and rule Agra. But the historical records prove otherwise:</p><p>Battle of Khatoli (1517): Rana Sanga crushed Ibrahim Lodi and captured the key territories of Narasimha, Chanderi and Ranthambore.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZsoZKn2MgI5Zv24M-3u3PA.jpeg" /><figcaption>History of Mewar from earliest time by RV Somani</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b6Ue52lU8V4FNAHT4O33MQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Battle of Dholpur (1518): Rana Sanga defeated Ibrahim Lodi again, further humiliating the Delhi Sultanate.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xr4-lq-AIvzXA9icmyUfMw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4nC8x1MwAWGbQARAU58Nhw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Would a ruler who had already humiliated Ibrahim Lodi twice need the help of Babur? The idea is illogical and historically baseless.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1012/1*7V6Nd5FsG_ywffbm-T925Q.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/814/1*HcVFXkJEhtxobbmYPC291g.jpeg" /></figure><h3>The Origin of the Propaganda —</h3><p>The first mention of Rana Sanga inviting Babur comes from the Baburnama, where Babur claims that Sanga sent emissaries seeking his assistance against Lodi.</p><p>Babur, in his book, claims that Rana Sanga invited him, intending to rule up to Agra while allowing Babur to govern Delhi. But here’s the contradiction—Babur had already invaded India five times before 1526. Bayana, where Babur was defeated by Rana Sanga, was already under Sanga’s control, just 80 km from Delhi. Why would he need Babur’s support to conquer Agra when he had already crushed the combined forces of three sultans and seized Chanderi, Idar, and Gwalior?</p><p>Let’s set this logic aside for a moment.</p><p>If Rana Sanga truly invited Babur, why is there no detailed mention of it in Baburnama? Babur meticulously records trivial details—he even describes his meeting with a mere general of Ibrahim Lodhi and the mangoes he desired. Yet, when it comes to an alleged invitation from the &quot;most potent King of Hindustan,&quot; as Babur himself calls Rana Sanga, there isn’t even a full sentence dedicated to it.</p><p>Wouldn’t such a historic event be a major highlight in his memoir? An invitation from the most powerful ruler of the land he sought to conquer, and he barely acknowledges it? Sounds absurd, doesn’t it?</p><p>The truth is, Babur was a liar, and he manipulated facts in his own account, as noted by renowned historians like Jadunath Sarkar and Gopinath Sharma…</p><p>However Mewar’s own historical records directly contradict this claim:</p><p>Mewar Pandulipi (Mewar Chronicles): A handwritten account maintained by Rana Sanga’s purohit (royal priest) states that it was Babur who sought Sanga’s help, not the other way around. This completely debunks Babur’s self-serving claim. (Mewar Rajya Ri Pandulipi, National Archives of India)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*d6WIlv5yaPyMP4U9-eqIEw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ch1MGWJz9CMfA3FZXfXrvQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Mewar &amp; Mughal emperors by GN Sharma</figcaption></figure><p>Amarkavya Vanshavali by Ranchod Bhatt: This 16th-century text, which documents the Rajput lineage, makes no mention of Sanga inviting Babur but does confirm his victories over Lodi.</p><p>Even Professor Rushbrook Williams in his book An Empire Builder of the Sixteenth Century confirms that Babur was actually invited by:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PIljKR2xYL_jAWrY9R5SNQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Alauddin Khan (Alam Khan) – Ibrahim Lodi’s uncle, who wanted to overthrow him.</p><p>Daulat Khan Lodi – The governor of Punjab, who sought Babur’s help for his own ambitions.</p><blockquote>Rana Sanga was a warrior of unparalleled valor—he united 100,000 Rajput warriors, bore over 80 battle scars, lost an eye, a hand and a leg, yet continued leading his army from the front. He never bent to any foreign invader and Mewar under his rule reached its peak of military strength.</blockquote><p>The narrative that he invited Babur is not only a lie but an insult to one of India’s greatest warriors.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=404f776cf33e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Echoes of Extinction: How Lost Civilizations Reveal the Cycles of Collapse]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@akanksha00/echoes-of-extinction-how-lost-civilizations-reveal-the-cycles-of-collapse-704b4fa0188f?source=rss-967e8c8d36bb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/704b4fa0188f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[आकांक्षा सिंह रघुवंशी]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 17 Mar 2025 08:09:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-17T08:23:14.020Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>Quote from Niccolò Machiavelli:<br>“Whoever wishes to foresee the future must consult the past; for human events ever resemble those of preceding times. This arises from the fact that they are produced by men who ever have been, and ever shall be, animated by the same passions, and thus they necessarily have the same results.”<br>— Discourses on Livy (1517)</blockquote><p>Machiavelli’s words remind us that the collapse of powerful communities is not a random act of fate but a recurring cycle driven by human nature and circumstance. Across history, empires, tribes, and civilizations that once dominated the world have vanished, their bloodlines extinguished, their names reduced to relics. The Hittites, the Minoans, the Vandals, the Toltecs, and others stand as testaments to this truth. What unites their stories is not just their power, but how completely they were erased—leaving no descendants to carry their legacy into the modern age. Let’s examine these falls, their causes, and the lessons they impart.</p><h3>The Hittites: Conquered and Absorbed</h3><p>In the Late Bronze Age (circa 1600–1200 BCE), the Hittites ruled an empire stretching across modern-day Turkey, Syria, and parts of Iraq. From their capital at Hattusa, they rivaled Egypt and Assyria, forging a sophisticated society with iron weapons, chariots, and a legal code rivaling Hammurabi’s. Their power peaked with the Battle of Kadesh (1274 BCE), where they clashed with Pharaoh Ramses II, ending in history’s first recorded peace treaty. Yet, within a century, they were gone.<br>The collapse came swiftly around 1200 BCE during the Bronze Age Collapse—a mysterious wave of destruction linked to invasions by the enigmatic “Sea Peoples,” drought, and internal strife. Hittite cities were burned, their royal line extinguished, and their language, an Indo-European tongue, faded as survivors were absorbed into neighboring cultures like the Phrygians and Assyrians. Archaeological evidence shows Hattusa abandoned, its walls toppled. Today, no group claims Hittite descent; their genes may linger in Anatolian populations, but their identity is lost. Machiavelli’s “same passions” played out here—pride in power made them targets, and failure to adapt sealed their end.</p><h3>The Minoans: Swallowed by Nature and Conquest</h3><p>On the island of Crete, the Minoans flourished from 2700 to 1450 BCE, a maritime power famed for their palaces like Knossos, vibrant frescoes, and a script called Linear A (still undeciphered). They dominated Aegean trade, their ships linking Egypt, Greece, and the Levant. Their society appeared peaceful, with no fortified walls, suggesting confidence in their naval supremacy. Then came the eruption of Thera (Santorini) around 1600 BCE, one of history’s largest volcanic events. Ash blanketed Crete, tsunamis ravaged their ports, and crops failed.<br>Weakened, the Minoans fell to Mycenaean Greeks by 1450 BCE, who occupied their palaces and adapted their culture. The Minoan language vanished, replaced by Greek Linear B. By 1200 BCE, the Mycenaeans themselves collapsed, and the Minoan thread was severed entirely. Genetic studies suggest modern Cretans carry some Minoan DNA, but no distinct Minoan descendants survive as a cohesive group. Their wipeout shows how nature can cripple a power, leaving it ripe for conquest—human passions of greed and opportunism finishing the job, as Machiavelli might note.</p><h3>The Vandals: Scattered by War</h3><p>Fast-forward to the fall of Rome: the Vandals, a Germanic tribe, rose to prominence in the 5th century CE. From humble origins in Eastern Europe, they swept through Gaul and Spain, establishing a kingdom in North Africa by 439 CE, with Carthage as their capital. They sacked Rome in 455 CE, giving us the term “vandalism,” and controlled the western Mediterranean with a formidable navy. Yet, their reign was brief.<br>In 533 CE, Byzantine Emperor Justinian sent General Belisarius to reclaim North Africa. The Vandal king Gelimer was defeated at the Battle of Tricamarum, his army crushed, and his people enslaved or dispersed. The Vandals lacked the numbers and cohesion to resist assimilation; their Arian Christian faith clashed with the Orthodox Byzantines, hastening their cultural erasure. By the 7th century, Arab conquests swept away any remnants. No Vandal descendants exist today—their name survives only as a synonym for destruction. Here, Machiavelli’s “same results” ring true: overreach and isolation left them vulnerable to a stronger foe.</p><h3>The Toltecs: Dissolved into Myth</h3><p>In Mesoamerica, the Toltecs dominated central Mexico from 900 to 1150 CE, their capital at Tula a hub of art, architecture, and military might. They influenced the Aztecs, who later revered them as near-mythical ancestors. The Toltecs built pyramids, mastered metallurgy, and controlled trade routes, their warriors adorned with feathered regalia. Yet, by the 12th century, they vanished.<br>Chronicles (like the Aztec Codex Chimalpopoca) blame drought, famine, and internal conflict, possibly a civil war between factions worshiping rival gods like Quetzalcoatl and Tezcatlipoca. Nomadic Chichimec tribes then invaded, sacking Tula around 1150 CE. The Toltecs fragmented, their survivors absorbed into successor states. The Aztecs claimed descent, but this was likely propaganda—no direct Toltec lineage persisted. Their wipeout reflects a pattern: environmental stress and division, followed by external pressure, erased a once-dominant people. Machiavelli’s lens would see this as passion—ambition and discord—undoing their grip.</p><h3>Patterns of Extinction</h3><p>These cases reveal recurring mechanisms of collapse:<br>External Conquest: The Hittites fell to the Sea Peoples, the Vandals to Byzantines, the Toltecs to Chichimecs. A stronger force exploits weakness.<br><br>Environmental Disaster: The Minoans’ volcanic catastrophe and the Toltecs’ drought show how nature can destabilize even the mighty.<br><br>Cultural Assimilation: Survivors were absorbed—Hittites into Assyria, Minoans into Mycenae, Vandals into Byzantine and Arab realms—leaving no distinct heirs.<br><br>Internal Decay: Division (Toltecs) or overextension (Vandals) eroded resilience, aligning with Machiavelli’s view of human passions driving ruin.</p><h3>Why No Descendants?</h3><p>Unlike groups like the Romans, whose legacy diffused into modern Europe, or the Han Chinese, who endure as a civilization, these communities left no unbroken line. Their populations were small and centralized, making total disruption possible. Their languages and identities weren’t widespread enough to survive conquest or diaspora. The Hittite tongue died with their scribes; the Vandal elite couldn’t impose Arianism on a hostile world. Contrast this with, say, the Jews, who preserved identity through texts and faith despite exile—these lost peoples lacked such anchors.</p><h3>Machiavelli’s Echo</h3><p>Machiavelli’s quote frames this grimly: human nature—greed, pride, fear—repeats these cycles. The Hittites’ arrogance invited enemies; the Minoans’ isolation left them exposed; the Vandals’ plunder angered a sleeping giant; the Toltecs’ infighting opened the gates. Power breeds complacency, and complacency breeds oblivion. Today, we dig up their bones and marvel at their ruins, but their voices are silent, their descendants dust.</p><h3>Modern Reflections</h3><p>Could this happen again? The world’s interconnectedness makes total wipeout rarer—cultures blend rather than vanish. Yet, small indigenous groups still fade, their languages dying with their last speakers. The lesson persists: power is fleeting when it ignores adaptation, unity, and the tides of history. Machiavelli saw it in Florence’s struggles; we see it in these ghosts of the past.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=704b4fa0188f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Forgotten Struggles Of Benaras.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@akanksha00/the-forgotten-struggles-of-benaras-c6c392bed34e?source=rss-967e8c8d36bb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c6c392bed34e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[आकांक्षा सिंह रघुवंशी]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 21 Feb 2025 06:31:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-21T06:47:41.053Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The history of Benares in the early 19th century was marked by administrative developments under British rule but it also witnessed intense religious and political conflicts. One of the most significant events occurred in 1809-1810, when deep-seated Hindu-Muslim tensions erupted into violence.</p><p>At the center of this conflict was the mosque built by Aurangzeb over the sacred Bisheshwar temple. The unrest intensified when an attempt was made to construct a small stone shrine on the disputed ground between the temple and the mosque. This enraged the Muslim Julaha community led by brothers Dost Muhammad and Fateh Muhammad. The Julahas gathered in large numbers, destroyed the unfinished Hanuman shrine and desecrated other Hindu religious sites.</p><p>In response a massive gathering formed led by the Raghuvanshi Rajputs of Benares. While British magistrate Mr. W. W. Bird initially dispersed the crowd, tensions remained high. The situation escalated when the Julahas attempted to attack the Bisheshwar temple itself. The Rajputs fought back engaging in fierce battles in the narrow streets of Gayaghat. The Muslims suffered heavy casualties, losing around eighty men.</p><p>Meanwhile another riot erupted near the mosque but was temporarily contained by British forces. However seizing an opportunity, the Julahas launched another attack, desecrating the sacred Lat Bhairon pillar, slaughtering a cow within the holy premises and shattering the pillar into pieces. When Mr. Bird arrived, he found the area deserted and a strong guard was posted to prevent further attacks.</p><p>The next day, the situation exploded. Around noon, an armed force of Rajputs supported by furious Gosains, stormed the mosque of Aurangzeb, set it ablaze and executed every Muslim in the vicinity. The city descended into chaos as the rioters continued destroying mosques and attacking Muslim settlements. The British struggled to contain the violence and Bazaars were set on fire, leaving the Julaha quarters devastated.</p><p>Despite Mr. Bird’s efforts to pacify the Rajputs, they soon turned their attention to the Dargah of Fatima and the tomb of Prince Jiwan Bakht near Pisachmochan. Mr. Bird pursued them but arrived too late—the destruction had already begun. Left with no choice, he ordered his troops to fire on the crowd. In a stroke of chance the Rajput leader was killed in the first volley, causing confusion among his followers. Reinforcements soon arrived, forcing the Rajputs to retreat.</p><p>Benares remained in a state of turmoil for days. By the time order was restored, over fifty mosques had been destroyed . British forces had to remain stationed at key Hindu and Muslim religious sites for months to prevent further clashes.</p><p>A lesser-known outcome of this event was the tension that arose between the British military and local police further complicating governance. The British saw this uprising as a challenge to their rule and Colonel Neill’s arrival proved crucial in stabilizing the city. His leadership ensured that such riots did not spiral into a full-scale rebellion.</p><p>Decades later during the Revolt of 1857, Benares once again became a focal point of unrest. Amidst the chaos, Rajputs played a crucial role in protecting Hindu temples and religious sites.</p><p>Many Rajputs sacrificed their lives to protect temples in Benares. The Raghuvanshi Rajputs along with other Rajput warriors, played a crucial role in resisting attacks on sacred sites including the Kashi Vishwanath temple. Time and again, they stood against destruction, even at the cost of their own lives.</p><p>Their bravery and dedication ensured that temples remained symbols of faith and resilience despite repeated invasions and conflicts. However these sacrifices are often overlooked in mainstream historical narratives. It’s important to acknowledge and remember their courage, as they fought not just for their religion but for the cultural and spiritual heritage of India.</p><p>This forgotten chapter of history deserves to be told and preserved for future generations</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c6c392bed34e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The True Rajput Lineage of the Chandelas: A Rebuttal to Vincent Smith’s Theory ( Bhar Or Gond…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@akanksha00/the-true-rajput-lineage-of-the-chandelas-a-rebuttal-to-vincent-smiths-theory-bhar-or-gond-8fa9d0969699?source=rss-967e8c8d36bb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8fa9d0969699</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[आकांक्षा सिंह रघुवंशी]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 12 Feb 2025 12:39:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-12T12:39:01.247Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The True Rajput Lineage of the Chandelas: A Rebuttal to Vincent Smith’s Theory ( Bhar Or Gond origin of Chandelas)</h3><p>Sir Vincent Smith expresses near certainty that the Chandelas were originally Bhars or Gonds. In his Early History of India (2nd Edition) he states, “The inference is fully justified that the Chandelas are originally Hinduized Bhars or Gonds” (p. 379). However this claim appears to be influenced by the bias prevalent among European scholars, who often assumed that the Rajputs were either of foreign origin or, if not foreign, then of aboriginal descent. It is important to examine the justifications provided for this inference. Smith does not elaborate on them in the aforementioned book but his paper on the Chandelas, published in Indian Antiquary (Vol. XXVII, p. 137) provides insight into his reasoning. There, he asserts, “I still hold the opinion (1908) that the Chandelas sprang from an aboriginal stock, whether this stock was called Bhar or Gond, we cannot say.”</p><p>-One of the arguments put forth by Smith is based on what he terms a “silly legend” among the Chandelas regarding their origin—that they were born from the union of the Moon and a Brahmin maiden. He dismisses this myth, stating that its primary significance lies in the implicit admission that the lineage of the Chandela clan required validation. This, he claims, was achieved by incorporating them into the lunar Rajput lineage and lending them further respectability through the introduction of a Brahmin ancestress. According to Smith, “As a matter of fact, the Chandelas are regarded as a clan of impure descent.-</p><p>Another argument he presents is that there are clear indications suggesting that the Chandelas originated among the Gonds. He notes that the Chandel Zamindar of Mahoba claims to be autochthonous and traces his ancestry to Maniyagarh, the ancient ruined fortress on the banks of the Ken River. This tradition is reinforced by the fact that Maniya Devi, whose shrine still exists at Maniyagarh, was the tutelary deity of the Chandelas. When they took control of Mahoba in the early ninth century, they brought with them the worship of this deity, who, according to Smith, bears similarities to Gond deities. The poet Chand, in his writings, also associates Maniyagarh with a Gond chieftain as late as the sixteenth century.</p><p>The third argument put forth by Smith is that the Chandela princess Rani Durgavati was married to the Gond ruler of Mandla. He further states that the Gaharwars and the Haihayas of Chedi rose to prominence in a similar manner, as ambitious leaders from aboriginal tribes who, after attaining power, claimed Kshatriya or Rajput status—just as Gond chieftains do to this day.</p><p>These arguments, however, are highly flawed, and any Hindu reader can immediately recognize their weaknesses. Though they may not require rebuttal, it is important to address them for the benefit of European readers who may not be as familiar with the nuances of Indian history.</p><p>Smith’s first argument, which relies on the so-called “silly legend” of the Chandelas’ lunar descent, is deeply flawed. It is well known that myths about divine ancestry have existed across civilizations and time periods. Such stories do not serve as indicators of actual lineage but rather as expressions of reverence and prestige. The real question that must be asked is whether the Chandela dynasty was ever considered non-Kshatriya by contemporary society. If such evidence were to exist, it would invalidate their claim to Rajput lineage.</p><p>The strongest argument made by Smith is his assertion that “as a matter of fact, the Chandelas are regarded as a clan of impure descent.” This, however, is completely incorrect. The evidence of the poet Chand (whom Smith himself references) directly contradicts this claim. Among the thirty-six royal Rajput families listed by Chand, the Chandelas are ranked among the foremost. The name “Chhand” in the first verse of his text is understood to refer to the Chandela clan. Even if this interpretation is disputed, there is still ample evidence of their recognition as Rajputs. James Tod, in his Annals and Antiquities of Rajasthan, includes the Chandelas in the list of traditional thirty-six Rajput families, citing the Kumarapala Sanskrit Manuscript as a source. This confirms that, as far back as the time of Kumarapala Charita, the Chandelas were regarded as authentic Rajputs. Furthermore, in Chand’s detailed account of the battle of Mahoba against Prithviraj Chauhan, there is no indication that the Chandelas were considered of impure descent. Epigraphic evidence also reveals that the Chandelas intermarried with prominent Rajput families, including the Haihayas, who have always been recognized as Rajputs, despite Smith’s attempt to cast doubt on their lineage. Even today, the Maharaja of Gidhaur, one of the last remaining Chandela descendants, is widely accepted as a Rajput. In a letter to the author, he confirmed that the Chandela family continues to arrange marriages both into and from prestigious Rajput clans like the Chauhans. This completely refutes Smith’s claim that the Chandelas were ever considered of impure origin.</p><p>Smith’s second argument, which suggests that the Chandelas must have been Gonds because they ruled in a Gond-populated region, is equally baseless. History shows that numerous Rajput families established kingdoms among tribal populations such as the Gonds, Bhars, and Bhils. The instinct of a Rajput warrior was to venture into unclaimed or hostile territories, subdue the local inhabitants, and carve out a kingdom for himself. For instance, the Guhilots settled among the Bhils and established a kingdom—does this mean they were Bhils themselves? Even the British established an empire among Indians—does that make them Indians? Historians fail to recognize the pattern in which ambitious Kshatriyas migrated from Aryan-populated lands into the Himalayan valleys, the deserts of Rajasthan, and the hills of Mewar and Jaipur, where they established their dominions. Thus, the mere presence of the Chandelas in Gond territory does not make them Gonds. The Chandela Zamindar of Mahoba’s belief that his family is autochthonous to the region is also not surprising. The Chandelas have ruled in Mahoba for nearly a thousand years, and it is natural that he might believe his lineage has been there since the beginning of time. However historical evidence suggests that the Chandelas were present in Gond regions like Maniyagarh even before their rise in Mahoba, possibly arriving there during the Rashtrakuta or Hun invasions of northern India.</p><p>The argument that the Chandelas&#39; tutelary goddess, Maniya Devi, resembles Gond deities is also unfounded. Every Rajput family has its own distinct tutelary goddess. If the Chandelas established their first stronghold in Maniyagarh, it is only logical that they would name their deity after the region. Even if there were similarities between Maniya Devi and Gond deities, this would not imply that the Chandelas themselves were Gonds. Many Hindu deities, including Shiva and Durga, may have originated from non-Vedic traditions, but that does not make their worshippers non-Aryan.</p><p>Lastly the story of Rani Durgavati actually disproves Smith’s theory. According to Ain-i-Akbari, she was the daughter of Raja Salbahan of Mahoba, a Chandela Rajput and was given in marriage to Dalpat Shah ( who was a kachhwaha rajput by birth) the ruler of Garha-Mandla. Even Abul Fazl acknowledges that the Chandelas were Rajputs. Her defiant battle against the Mughals and her heroic self-sacrifice only reinforce the noble warrior lineage of the Chandela dynasty.</p><p>Thus Smith’s claims are misleading and rooted in colonial bias, distorting historical facts to diminish the legacy of the Chandelas.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8fa9d0969699" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Unyielding Valor of Lance Daffadar Gobind Singh: A Victoria Cross Hero]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@akanksha00/the-unyielding-valor-of-lance-daffadar-gobind-singh-a-victoria-cross-hero-d19008983eca?source=rss-967e8c8d36bb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d19008983eca</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[आकांक्षा सिंह रघुवंशी]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Dec 2024 15:49:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-16T15:49:16.476Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/994/1*j5lvJHbr6G7Mpe7nrQwu1A.jpeg" /></figure><p>When World War I started in 1914, Indian regiments were enlisted by the British government as part of the British Expeditionary Force (BEF) to serve on the frontlines. These soldiers faced surprises at every turn. Thousands of Indian soldiers traveled to Europe, most of whom had never been outside India before. They embarked on this journey for survival, food, and the small amount of money they earned, which they sent back to their families. Upon arriving in France, they received a warm welcome, with locals cheering and embracing them. However, they soon encountered Western culture, which was very different from the social norms they were used to back home.</p><p>When they reached the warfront for the first time, all they could see were drains, swamps, and flat marshland. There was no enemy visible, as the opposing forces were concealed in trenches just a few hundred yards away. The Indian soldiers had no experience with trench warfare. In the past, they had fought on India’s northwest frontier using tactics like fire and movement, taking advantage of the terrain for cover. But here, they were instructed to stay in the trenches, leaving the ground between them and the enemy unused. These trenches, filled with ditches and swamps, would be their base to fight the war. During the long winter of 1914, Indian soldiers ended up manning one-third of the British line in France.</p><p>After the initial phase of trench warfare, the strategy shifted. Armies began to leave their trenches and advance toward the enemy. Infantry and cavalry clashed in the midst of heavy artillery fire, leading to bloody stalemates.</p><p>General Douglas Haig, the commander-in-chief of the BEF, had seen the terrible futility of battles fought on Belgium’s flatlands, including Somme, Verdun, Poelcapelle, and Passchendaele. Soldiers fought in blinding rain over muddy, barren land with no cover. These battles caused massive casualties but brought no significant progress, and the Allies struggled to break through enemy lines.</p><p>By early 1917, the war had reached a deadlock. The Germans, firmly entrenched in French territory, withdrew to a heavily fortified defensive position called the Hindenburg Line (known as Siegfriedstellung in German). This line stretched 120 kilometers across northeastern France, from Lens to beyond Verdun. It was considered the strongest German defensive position and was believed to be impenetrable.</p><p>To break through the Hindenburg Line, the British launched several campaigns, including a plan to capture Cambrai, a German-held town and a vital railway hub in northern France. This plan marked the first time various elements of battle—cavalry, air power, artillery, and infantry—were combined strategically in what was called &quot;all-arms warfare.&quot; Alongside these tactics, the Allies introduced powerful new industrial weapons, aiming to overwhelm the enemy and win the war.</p><p>The Battle of Cambrai, which took place between November 20 and December 7, 1917, changed the way wars were fought. Despite the use of advanced weaponry, it was the bravery and determination of an Indian soldier that made a lasting impact on this battle.</p><blockquote><em>This is the story of Lance Daffadar Gobind Singh, who escaped death not once, not twice, but three times as he crossed enemy lines to play a critical role in saving countless lives.</em></blockquote><h3>Gobind Singh Goes to War</h3><p>In September 1917, Gobind Singh was stationed in Persia with his regiment when orders arrived for him to join the war in Europe.</p><p>Like many young boys in Damoi, a small hamlet in the Nagore district of Rajasthan, Gobind had grown up dreaming of wearing a uniform and going to war. His first chance to fulfill that dream came in 1903, when he was recruited into the Jodhpur Lancers, a cavalry unit of the princely state of Jodhpur. The entire village of Damoi celebrated his achievement. Standing at 5 feet 8 inches tall and wearing a bright safa (turban) on his head, Gobind had a strong, stocky build. He soon gained a reputation as a calm and courageous young man.</p><p>The Jodhpur Lancers were known for their skills in polo, a popular sport among cavalry units at the time. Gobind excelled in the game, proving himself to be a swift rider and a clever player. His talents earned him a transfer to the 28 Light Cavalry regiment. When war broke out in Europe, his regiment was mobilized from Quetta, a major British and Indian military base, to Persia, where they were stationed until 1918.</p><blockquote>From his humble beginnings in Damoi to the grandeur of Persia, Gobind, a Rathore of the Suryavanshi Rajput lineage, had come a long way. Back in his village, he was now regarded with great admiration and respect.</blockquote><p>When the call to join the war in Europe finally came, only a select group from the 28 Light Cavalry was chosen. This group included two officers, fifty soldiers (non-officers), and a hundred horses. When the list of names was announced, Gobind Singh discovered that he was among those selected. He had also been entrusted with the rare honor of carrying the Regimental Colours into battle.</p><p>At Cambrai, where Gobind and his fellow soldiers joined the fight, their arrival brought much-needed energy and enthusiasm to the weary, battle-worn troops. Their presence helped commanders boost morale in an army ravaged by war. Meanwhile, General Haig employed a new strategy to inspire confidence and reinforce their plans for the decisive battle.</p><h3>The Allied Forces Discover the X Factor</h3><p>Seated in his wicker chair, General Haig watched the cavalry horses gallop gracefully across the field. A cavalryman at heart, Haig had deep faith in God and horses, often valuing them above other forms of warfare. He was known to say, &quot;Bullets have little stopping power against the horse.&quot;</p><p>But Haig was also aware of the devastating impact of modern weapons, which caused horrific casualties on all sides. A year into World War I, he wrestled with a critical question: How could the German defences be broken?</p><p>In 1915, two engineers began working on a solution.</p><p>For some years, soldiers had been converting vehicles into armoured cars by mounting guns on them. However, these vehicles were limited to roads and would often get stuck in swamps or ditches, making them easy targets for enemy infantry.</p><p>Determined to solve this issue, William Tritton and Lieutenant Walter Wilson worked in secret at a small White Hart hotel in Lincoln, near London. They debated designs, sketched plans on whatever they could find—envelopes, cigarette packets, scraps of paper—and sent these ideas to a factory for production. The prototype vehicles were kept hidden behind the hotel, covered from view. Their resemblance to steel water tanks helped keep their true purpose secret.</p><p>The first tanks were used during the Battle of Flers-Courcelette, part of the First Battle of the Somme in September 1916. Unfortunately, they performed poorly on the muddy battlefield. Many broke down, got stuck, or were destroyed by enemy fire. By 1917, however, tank design and strategy had improved significantly. With the dry, firm ground of Cambrai in winter, the upcoming battle provided an ideal opportunity to test these advancements.</p><p>The Battle of Cambrai would feature the largest assembly of tanks ever seen. Despite their intimidating presence, these machines became known by their nickname—tanks.</p><h3>The Assault on Cambrai</h3><p>Cambrai was a key railway hub in northern France, connecting Douai, Valenciennes, and Saint-Quentin. It was near the Saint-Quentin Canal, a crucial supply route for German forces. Capturing Cambrai would disrupt German supply lines and communications. However, the town was protected by the Hindenburg Line, a formidable defensive system. Breaking through it required a strong offensive followed by an infantry advance to seize Cambrai.</p><p>The German High Command, exhausted from the brutal Battle of Passchendaele (July–November 1917), had stationed their troops in the Cambrai sector for rest and recovery. Known as the &quot;sanatorium of the West,&quot; this area featured deep trenches, dugouts, and thick barbed wire, providing a secure retreat for German forces.</p><p>The British, meanwhile, used this relative calm to prepare for an offensive. Troops built trenches and stockpiled supplies around Cambrai. Lieutenant Kenneth Page of the 40 Brigade recalled that during this time, &quot;the Germans didn’t shoot at us, and we didn’t shoot at them.&quot; This peace was about to end.</p><p>General Julian Byng, commander of the British 3rd Army, worked with Lieutenant Colonel J.F.C. Fuller of the Tank Corps and Brigadier H.H. Owen Tudor of the 9th (Scottish) Division to devise an attack plan supported by tanks. General Haig, as overall commander, provided strategic direction for the operation.</p><p>Tudor proposed a new approach: instead of starting with a loud artillery bombardment, which would alert the enemy, the British would launch a quieter, surprise attack. Byng refined these ideas into a detailed plan.</p><p>The British assembled 19 infantry divisions, five cavalry divisions, and 476 tanks (including 378 in combat roles). Four squadrons of the Royal Flying Corps provided air support. The tanks were the improved Mark IV models, equipped with better armour, mobility, and firepower.</p><h3><strong>The Opening Assault</strong></h3><p>On November 20, 1917, under an overcast sky, hundreds of tanks rumbled forward, breaking the silence. They rolled across a 10-kilometre front, smashing through the Hindenburg Line. The accompanying artillery barrage targeted German defences. Second Lieutenant Edward Leigh-Jones of the Tank Corps recalled the challenge of breaching the thick wire defences, which were 50–100 yards deep. However, the tanks tore through the obstacles, shocking the German forces.</p><p>The sight of hundreds of Mark IV tanks overwhelmed the enemy. By the end of the first day, British forces had taken 8,000 prisoners, seized 100 guns, and forced the Germans to retreat. Victory seemed within reach.</p><p>For the plan to succeed, infantry forces needed to advance quickly to secure the territory captured by the tanks. However, delays in troop movements and congestion on the roads slowed reinforcements. It took 15 hours for infantry to cover the last 5 kilometres to the front. This gave the Germans time to regroup and counterattack.</p><p>On November 30, German General Erich von Ludendorff and General Johannes von der Marwitz launched a counteroffensive with 20 divisions. Using gas, heavy explosives, and infantry assaults, the Germans recaptured ground near Gonnelieu and Villers-Guislain.</p><h3>The Indian Contribution</h3><p>Despite the setbacks, the first phase of the Battle of Cambrai was groundbreaking for its use of tanks. The second phase was equally remarkable, as Indian cavalry units with lances joined the fight, facing off against advanced weaponry.</p><p>Lance Daffadar Gobind Singh was about to be called into action.</p><h3>Charge of the Indians</h3><p>Gobind was part of the 28 Light Cavalry and had been attached to the 2nd Lancers (also known as Gardner’s Horse), a famous cavalry regiment. Along with other cavalry units like the 6th (Inniskilling) Dragoons and the 38th Central India Horse, the 2nd Lancers were deployed to France as part of the 5th (Mhow) Cavalry Brigade in the 1st Indian Cavalry Division.</p><p>The Germans had recaptured the territories of Gouzeaucourt, Gauche Wood, and Villers-Guislain, located south of Cambrai. The cavalry was tasked with taking back these areas. On November 30, the 5th Mhow Brigade and the 4th Cavalry Division, another Indian cavalry regiment stationed in Cambrai, were given orders to launch an attack to recapture Villers-Guislain Ridge.</p><p>The Brigade Headquarters (HQ) was set up at Épehy and Pozières under the command of Brigadier Neil Haig, who was the cousin of General Haig. These locations—Villers-Guislain to the north, Épehy to the east, and Pozières to the west—formed a triangular area on the map.</p><p>Brigadier Haig and Major General Alfred Kennedy, the commander of the 4th Cavalry Division, had noticed the German machine guns positioned at a strategic location southwest of Villers-Guislain. They realized that any attack would face heavy fire and could be easily suppressed. However, the Cavalry Corps commander, Lieutenant General Charles Kavanagh, didn’t fully understand the ground conditions and pushed ahead with the attack, ordering Brigadier Haig’s brigade to advance toward the Germans. The three battalions in the brigade, along with a section of the 11th Machine Gun Squadron, moved closer to the German trenches.</p><p>The plan was for a two-pronged attack: the main assault would be carried out by the 6th (Inniskilling) Dragoons, with the 2nd Lancers launching a secondary attack.</p><p>The Inniskilling Dragoons advanced but were met with heavy machine gun fire from a sugar beet factory southwest of Villers-Guislain, forcing them to retreat to Pozières, suffering significant casualties.</p><p>On December 1, at 0800 hours, the 2nd Lancers received orders to move forward. Their lances arrived just in time from the rear, transported by a cart. Armed and ready, the men quickly lined up for the attack. Captain Dysart Whitworth of the 2nd Lancers led the columns, accompanied by a squadron from the 6th (Inniskilling) Dragoons and a mounted two-gun section of the 11th Machine Gun Squadron. They moved out from Pozières through Épehy.</p><p>After advancing about 100 yards, the Lancers crossed the forward trenches, which were the first line of defense, and formed up in open columns of squadrons. The lead squadron, C Squadron, was commanded by Major Knowles.</p><p>While the main goal was to capture the Villers-Guislain Ridge, this unit had an important task: they needed to secure the strategic high ground at Targelle Ravine, which was east of Villers-Guislain. To do this, they had to advance through Kildare Lane, one of the German trenches. Lieutenant Colonel Turner, commander of the 2nd Lancers, and Major Knowles took different routes to reach their objective.</p><p>About an hour and a half later, at 0930 hours, they launched their attack.</p><p>About 1.5 kilometers ahead of their headquarters was a group of four elm trees known as Limerick Post, which had been captured by the Germans the day before. As the Lancers charged toward the German positions, they faced machine gun fire from Kildare Trench and other enemy positions. Despite the heavy fire, the cavalrymen continued their charge, showing incredible bravery.</p><p>The sight of the Indian cavalry charging with their lances unnerved the German machine gunners. Lieutenant Karl Christian of the German Infantry Regiment 418 shouted at his men, “Shoot! Get the guns on them!” Some of the German soldiers, terrified by the sight of the charging cavalry, abandoned their positions.</p><p>Jemadar Jiwan Singh of the 2nd Lancers, who was participating in his first battle in three years, vividly remembered the charge. He recalled the courage of the Indian cavalrymen, who pressed forward despite the machine gun fire. “The fury of our charge and the sound of our war cries so alarmed the enemy that they left their trenches and fled,” he later said. The charge was so intense that even though they were under heavy fire, the Indian cavalrymen continued forward.</p><p>The cavalrymen encountered barbed wire, which slowed their progress. They had to navigate through three lines of wire gaps, which hampered their momentum. The German machine gunners, eager for the opportunity to strike, unleashed a series of bursts at the leading columns. Lieutenant Colonel Turner was struck and killed instantly during the attack. Known as &quot;Lion-hearted&quot; or &quot;Sherdil&quot; by his men, his death was a heavy blow to the 2nd Lancers, but there was no time to mourn.</p><p>After dismounting, the cavalrymen, including Gobind Singh and Sowar Jot Ram, fought bravely to defend the position they had captured. The battle became chaotic, with men and horses tangled together. Despite the mounting casualties, the Indian cavalrymen held their ground.</p><p>In total, about 50-100 German soldiers occupied the trench. The Indian cavalry killed 15-20 Germans with swords or lances and another 20-30 with rifles or machine gun fire. The Germans were thrown into disarray. The position was eventually held by 200 men from the 2nd Lancers and 36 men from the Inniskilling Dragoons.</p><p>However, they were isolated from the rest of the brigade, and the Germans quickly launched a counterattack, putting the position in jeopardy.</p><h3>Round 1: An Urgent Message Needs to Be Sent</h3><p>Back at Brigade HQ in Pozières, there was growing concern that the 2nd Lancers had been surrounded and might be overwhelmed. To provide support, three dismounted squadrons of the 38th Central India Horse were sent, but they encountered heavy enemy fire and struggled to make progress.</p><p>Time was running out for the 2nd Lancers. With Turner dead, Major Knowles now in command realized the urgency of sending a message to Brigadier Haig at Brigade HQ. The Germans had regained their positions, leaving no safe path for the Lancers to communicate. Without timely intervention, the Lancers faced the grim prospect of being overrun.</p><p>Knowles called for volunteers to carry the message. &quot;Who will go?&quot; he asked.</p><p>Two soldiers stepped forward: Sowar Jot Ram and Lance Daffadar Gobind Singh. The two were given identical messages to deliver.</p><p>The distance to Pozières was 2.5 kilometers, a treacherous journey that required crossing open ground. They charged forward on horseback, each taking a different route.</p><p>Jot Ram took the shorter route. As he passed Limerick Post, German machine guns opened fire, killing him instantly. Gobind, on the other hand, darted to the lower ground to the south, narrowly avoiding the gunfire. After covering half a mile, his horse was shot and fell. Gobind, however, survived. Using his military training, he lay still and feigned death to avoid further danger. After a brief silence, he took the opportunity to move cautiously, rolling on the ground to cover distance. Gobind continued to change his direction and dropped to the ground repeatedly to avoid enemy fire, making himself a difficult target.</p><p>Despite the heavy fire, Gobind&#39;s determination paid off, and after what seemed like an endless struggle, he reached the headquarters.</p><p>Gobind reported the dire situation, and the Brigade HQ knew they needed to act quickly. The route was perilous, and messengers had been targeted by German fire. Sowar Jot Ram had been killed, and Gobind had narrowly escaped death. The enemy was now aware of the messengers&#39; presence, and any attempt to send a new message was fraught with danger.</p><h3>Round 2: Brigade Sends Gobind Singh to Deliver a Reply</h3><p>Gobind was given a fresh horse and another message to deliver. He set off on his next perilous journey back to the 2nd Lancers.</p><p>Gobind’s journey continued. This time, he chose a higher ground south of the valley, skillfully avoiding direct enemy fire as he drew closer to the German post. He managed to cover more than half the distance without incident, but the calm before the storm was about to end. Two-thirds of the way through, his horse was shot and killed. Gobind quickly found cover and ran along the defiladed road, managing to reach his regiment safely.</p><p>To his comrades, Gobind had become a hero, having cheated death twice. However, his day was far from over. The toughest part was still to come.</p><h3>Round 3: Will He Survive a Third Time?</h3><p>The Second Grenadier Guards and the 18th Lancers, another Indian regiment, were engaged in a struggle to retake Gauche Wood from the Germans. Stationed in Kildare Trench with the 2nd Lancers, Major Knowles wanted to know the next course of action for the operation in that area, so he drafted a letter for the brigade.</p><p>Once again, Gobind volunteered. Although his officers cautioned him against pushing his luck after his two previous trips, Gobind insisted on his knowledge of the terrain and his ability to outwit the enemy. Confident in his abilities, Gobind convinced them to let him go. Reluctantly, they agreed, allowing him to select his own horse. The officers feared this would be his final act, his &quot;swansong.&quot; They bid him a heartfelt farewell as he galloped into the mist, taking a new route guided by the direction of Catelet Copse.</p><p>This time, the Germans were prepared. As Gobind neared, he was met with a barrage of enemy fire. Halfway through, an artillery shell exploded near him, striking his horse and sending him crashing to the ground. From the trenches, Gobind’s comrades watched in horror as he and his horse disappeared into the cloud of smoke and dust. His third horse had been killed, and the soldiers believed Gobind had perished as well. That night, he was declared &quot;Missing in Action.&quot;</p><p>Miraculously, Gobind survived. Staggering onward, dazed and exhausted, he dodged machine gun fire with sheer determination. Despite being targeted, Gobind twisted and turned, making himself a difficult target as he wove through the enemy fire. His perseverance paid off when, just before noon, a sentry at Brigade HQ saw a lone, blood-spattered figure approaching, carrying a message stained in crimson. To their astonishment, the blood was not his but that of his fallen horse, which had died just inches from him. It was nothing short of a miracle that he had survived.</p><p>Despite his injuries and exhaustion, Gobind volunteered once again to carry another message back to the 2nd Lancers. But the officers, now in awe of his resilience, refused to let him go, fearing they would lose such a legendary soldier.</p><h3>Victoria Cross for the Valiant Messenger</h3><p>The fighting in the Épehy-Villers-Guislain region reached a stalemate, and both sides suffered heavy casualties. The 2nd Lancers moved south to Saint-Émélie, and on December 3rd, 1917, the Mhow Brigade returned to their billets to rest and reorganize.</p><p>By December 5th, after two weeks of brutal combat, the British had been pushed back to their original positions, and the Battle of Cambrai ended in a deadlock. Although the tanks had not fully exploited their potential, the battle highlighted their crucial role on the Western Front.</p><p>For his extraordinary gallantry, Lance Daffadar Gobind Singh was awarded the Victoria Cross, the highest military honor for valor. On February 6, 1918, he received the decoration from King George V at Buckingham Palace. He was also honored with a reception where he was joined by two Indian cavalry officers. Among the guests were General Sir Garrett O’Moore Creagh, a decorated veteran, and Lieutenant General Sir Pertab Singh, a respected officer with extensive experience in WWI.</p><p>Gobind’s citation, published in the London Gazette, read: &quot;Gobind Singh, Lance Daffadar, Indian Cavalry. For most conspicuous bravery and devotion to duty in thrice volunteering to carry messages between the regiment and Brigade Headquarters, a distance of one-and-a-half miles over open ground, which was under observation and heavy fire of the enemy. He succeeded each time in delivering his message, although on each occasion his horse was shot and he was compelled to finish his journey on foot.&quot;</p><p>Gobind’s bravery, alongside that of the 2nd Lancers and other Indian cavalrymen, thwarted a German breakthrough and prevented continued shelling of the villages of Épehy and Pozières. His courageous acts saved countless lives and ensured the regiment’s survival.</p><p>Today, in Damoi, Gobind Singh is still revered as &#39;VC Sahab&#39; (Victoria Cross Sahab). His twelve-room haveli stands as a proud testament to his heroism. Two large portraits of him in army fatigues are displayed in the courtyard, where his fierce, proud eyes continue to inspire those who visit.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AmahYwXLglSmmGBb7HyY1Q.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*paAdf3Pf7e-l5LxEgqslVg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Victoria Cross awarded to Gobinda Singh</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d19008983eca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“ Unveiling the Truth: Debunking the Myth of Jodha and Honoring Rajput Valor"]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@akanksha00/unveiling-the-truth-debunking-the-myth-of-jodha-and-honoring-rajput-valor-2b6382d240b3?source=rss-967e8c8d36bb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2b6382d240b3</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[आकांक्षा सिंह रघुवंशी]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Oct 2024 04:56:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-08T11:08:17.641Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When we delve into Rajput history, we uncover how they bravely resisted the onslaught of Islamic invasions and protected our motherland for centuries. The first significant encounter was led by Bappa Rawal, who allied with Nagabhatt Pratihar Rajput, Pulakesiraj and Jayabhatta of Gujarat. Together their forces fought a decisive battle in 738 CE against Arab invaders. From that moment onward, Rajputs from various regions continued to defend against numerous invasions for centuries.</p><p>However modern history tends to portray Rajputs in a distorted light, often labeling them as a losers with the infamous and fictional &quot;Jodha-Akbar&quot; love story being the primary slur used against them.</p><p>The name &quot;Jodha&quot; is entirely fictional; no historical woman by that name existed. It was a fabrication created by pseudo-historians to tarnish the Rajput legacy. Even prominent Muslim scholars, who often glorified their rulers never mentioned a character named &quot;Jodha.&quot;</p><p>Abul Fazal’s &#39;Ain-e-Akbari&#39; and &#39;Akbarnama,&#39; as well as Jahangir’s memoirs have no reference to her. Similarly, Bada’uni’s &#39;Muntakhib-al-Tawarikh&#39; does not mention any Jodha Bai. The name doesn’t appear in the archives of Aligarh Muslim University either.</p><p>The confusion began when Col. Tod used the name &quot;Jodha&quot; in his book. Tod&#39;s works are infamous for their inaccuracies, including fabricating the story of Rani Karnavati sending a rakhi to Humayun.</p><p>Without verifying the authenticity of &quot;Jodha,&quot; TV shows and books popularized this false narrative. The trend continued with her being renamed &quot;Harka Bai&quot; and presented as a Rajput princess, despite no historical records supporting this claim.</p><p>BL Pangadiya&#39;s 1945 book &quot;Rajasthan Ka Itihas&quot; was the first to mention &quot;Harka Bai,&quot; but even Pangadiya failed to provide sources. Historians now question the validity of this claim.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zizj-4G-BD8WSo0IBFSJIg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Moreover the true identity of Jahangir&#39;s mother remains unknown, as no contemporary records mention her name .</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/971/1*3cznMy2P02c2SJaVlDnUWQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Forget about &quot; Jodha/Harka &quot;, we don&#39;t even know the real name of Jahangir&#39;s mother, as no contemporary source mentions it.<br><br>Furthermore, there is plenty of other evidence to deny the claim of her being a true blue-blooded Princesss from the Kachhwaha Royal House of Amber.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*htvPNzg-SmCp5FMawRqZUg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Primary sources like Jodhpur-ri-Khyat and Mundyar-ri-Khyat suggest she was an illegitimate daughter of Raja Bharmal of Amber and Muslim rulers of the time often accepted such women into their harems.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Y4qDVFO5J2MqA-Q47rX1vg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/927/1*K4zs0uNMsm5SPtoDWhWWLA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-eXmCo1qFVGO3bvQMezuBw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The continuous repetition of these fabricated stories demeans the Rajputs, who sacrificed everything for their land. It&#39;s our duty as the youth to raise awareness about these historical inaccuracies and protect the honor of those who defended our motherland.</p><p>… special thanks to — Veer Singh</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2b6382d240b3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Important historical events of Ayodhyā with religious connotations in the last 1000 years]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@akanksha00/important-historical-events-of-ayodhy%C4%81-with-religious-connotations-in-the-last-1000-years-d2918acaf765?source=rss-967e8c8d36bb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d2918acaf765</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[आकांक्षा सिंह रघुवंशी]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 22 Jun 2024 01:06:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-22T01:20:56.638Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*3sabpcit5GuLiiOHQBATuQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>1. In circa 1030 A.D. the famous historian Alberuni, who accompanied Mahmud of Ghazani in various military expeditions against India, wrote the well-known book “Kitab-ul Hind” wherein he refers to Ayodhyā and mentions the main story of the Rāmāyana with details on the Rāmasetu. He depicts many activities of Rāma and quotes the Vishnu-purāna, with reverence to Rāma, in the following words: “…in Tretayuga, in the shape of Rama alone, for the purpose of spreading fortitude, to conquer the bad, and to preserve the three worlds by force and the prevalence of virtuous action” Besides, he was aware of the fact that Rāma was an incarnation of Vishnu and idols were prescribed for his worship.</p><p>2. On 23rd October, 1093 the Gahadavāla King Chandradeva visited Ayodhyā on the occasion of a solar eclipse and after having taken bath in the Sarayū performed certain rituals.</p><p>3. In c. 1130 A.D. Anayachandra, the Governor of Gahadavāla King Govindachandra at Ayodhyā, built the Visnu-hari temple on the Rāma-janma-bhūmi site.</p><p>4. In c. 1150 A.D. Ayushchandra, another Governor of King Govindachandra at Ayodhyā, which had many towering temples and abodes, constructed thousands of wells, tanks, rest houses in the Sāketa Mandala.</p><p>5. In 1192-93 A.D. Makadum Shah Juran Ghori, the younger brother of Muhammad Ghori, invaded Ayodhyā with a huge army. Bartuh, probably the Governor of Ayodhyā, faced him valiantly and in the battle, more than one hundred and twenty thousand Musalmans were killed. Makdum Shah’s army could demolish only Jain Ãdinātha Mandir. It appears that he was killed there because there is a grave of Makdum Shah Juran Ghori at Ayodhyā.</p><p>6. In 1226 A.D. Mallik Nasiruddin Muhammad, the elder son of Sultan Samsuddin (Iltutmish), succeeded in defeating and killing the ‘accursed Bartuh’.</p><p>7. In 1337 A.D. Ain-ul-mulk, Governor at Ayodhyā, supplied enormous quantity of provisions and money for relief to the famine-stricken people in the Doab area and in circa 1340 Muhammad bin Tughalaq appointed a Hindu, Kishan, the Governor of Ayodhyā.</p><p>8. In 1589 A.D. Muhammad Farmuli alias Kala Pahar was appointed the Governor of Oudh by Bahlol Lodi after the latter shifted the capital of Oudh from Jaunpur to Ayodhyā. Muhammad Farmuli was succeeded by his son-in-law Mustafa Farmuli.</p><p>9. After Mustafa’s death his younger brother Bāyazīd was appointed the Governor of Ayodhyā by Ibrahim Lodi. Bāyazīd fought in support of Ibrahim Lodi in the battle of Panipat but after Ibrahim’s defeat, he called on Babur to show his solidarity with him in July, 1526 and the Mughal Emperor gave him 1 Krur, 48 Laks and 50,000 Tankas from Aud.</p><p>10. In August, 1527 Babur had sneaking suspicion about the activities of Bāyazīd and by January 1528 Bāyazīd along with Malik Biban and Maruf Farmuli rebelled against Babur. After successful Chanderi expedition, Babur went for hot pursuit of Bāyazīd and reached Lucknow in 21st March, 1528.</p><p>11. On 28th March, 1528 Bāyazīd, the Governor of Oudh at Ayodhyā, was near the junction of Ghaghra and Sirda at a distance of 115 Km. from Ayodhyā.</p><p>12. On 2nd April, 1528 when Babur left for hunting, he was at a distance of 140 Km. from Ayodhyā in the thick forest and not in the vicinity of Ayodhyā.</p><p>13. Pages of Babur’s diary are missing from 3rd April, 1528 to 17th September, 1528. The so-called Baburi mosque is supposed to have been built in 935 A.H. which started on 15th September, 1528. Thus, only three days&#39; writings are missing from his diary of 935 A.H. and during these three days the mosque could not have been constructed. Moreover, on the opening day of the year 935 A.H., i.e. 15th September, 1528 Babur was at Agra in his imperial court.</p><p>14. Neither Babur nor Baqi Taskindi/Shaghawal had any occasion or reason to visit Ayodhyā. There was no Hindu Governor at Ayodhyā for long. The Governor of Oudh at Ayodhyā was Bāyazīd and not Mir Baqi. Bāyazīd was on the run and Baqi was a petty army commander of 1000 soldiers engaged in the expedition to kill or catch hold of Bayzid, Biban and other rebels.</p><p>15. On 13th June 1529 Baqi Tashkindi called on Babur and on 20th June 1529 he was dismissed from service or sent on long leave and he was never heard of again.</p><p>16. In 1574 A.D. when Tulasi Das started composing the Rāmacharitamānasa at Ayodhyā on the Rāma-navamī day, Ayodhyā was the picture of vibrancy. Rāma shows his जन्मभूमि मम पुरी सुहावनि (Here’s my birthplace. This city is delightful.) to his monkey friends.</p><p>17. In c. 1590 A.D.Abul Fazl in Ain-i-Akbari wrote about the antiquity of Ayodhyā and incarnation of Rāma. He further added that there was a combination of temporal and spiritual authority in Rāma.</p><p>18. On 28th March, 1600 the Mughal Emperor Akbar gave six bighas of land for the construction of the Hanuman Tila.</p><p>19. In 1610 A.D. William Finch in his travel accounts of Ayodhyā wrote about the ruins of the great Rāmachandra’s castle and houses, and recorded Indians’ statement that he was born in human form to see the tamasha of the world. He did not see any mosque in the area; rather he saw Brahmins there.</p><p>20. In 1631 A.D. Jonnes De Laet’s book ‘De Imperio Magni Mogolis Sive India Vera Commentarius’ was published and in its account on Ayodhyā he not only repeated the content of William Finch but also added that pilgrims came to this place from all parts of India and after worshipping the idol took away with them some grains of charred rice as proof of their visit.</p><p>21. In 1634 A.D. the travel accounts of Ayodhyā written by Thomas Herbert were published in the book ‘Some Yeares Travels into Divers Parts of Asia and Afrique.’ Herbert mentions the existence of many antique monuments at Ayodhyā and states that the most memorable amongst them was the pretty old castle which Rāmachandra built 9,94,500 years ago.</p><p>22. In 1660 A.D. Fedai Khan, the foster brother of Aurangzeb and the Governor at Ayodhyā, demolished many temples of the holy city which included the Rāma-janma-bhūmi temple at Ayodhyā.</p><p>23. In 1672 A.D. Lal Das composed Avadha-vilāsa at Ayodhyā. He gave exact location of the Rāma-janma-bhūmi, but does not mention any temple.</p><p>24. In 1714 A.D. a Hindu, Chhabile Ram by name, was appointed Governor of Ayodhyā by the Mughal emperor Farrukh-Siyar and remained there until October 1715.</p><p>25. In May, 1720 Girdhar Bahadur, the nephew of Chabile Ram, was appointed the Governor at Ayodhyā with subedari, faujdari and diwani power.</p><p>26. In October, 1722 Girdhar Bahadur was transferred to Malwa as Governor. Thereafter came Sa’adat Khan and the era of Awadh Nawabs started.</p><p>27. On 8th July, 1723 Bairāgi Sādhu Abhayarāma Das got the renewal of six bighas of land granted by Akbar on 28th March, 1600 for the construction of Hanuman Tila.</p><p>28. On 23rd February, 1759 the Peshwa Balaji Bajirao asked Dattaji Sindhia to talk to Awadh Nawab Shuja-ud-daulah and take over Ayodhyā, Kās´ī and Mathurā.</p><p>29. In 1767 A.D. when the Jesuit Austrian Father Joseph Tiffenthaler visited Ayodhyā, he wrote minute details of the disputed structure and its vicinity. His Latin book “Descriptio Indiae” is the first text which mentions the mosque. It clearly states that the mosque was built after demolishing the Ram Kot and the Bedi inside it is situated on the birthplace of Rāma around which people circumbulate. He does not mention any inscription in the mosque.</p><p>30. In 1775 A.D. Suja-ud-daulah shifted the capital from Ayodhyā to Faizabad. It made the exodus of bureaucrats and elite Muslim classes from Ayodhyā. It further facilitated Bairagi Sadhus to retrieve the alienated temples and construct new ones.</p><p>31. In 1801 A.D. the French Scholar C. Mentelle wrote that the Svargadvāra and other temples at Ayodhyā were demolished by Aurangzeb, although some attributed it to Babur.</p><p>32. In 1813-14 A.D. when Francis Buchanan went to Ayodhyā for the survey, he found that the general perception of people was that Aurangzeb had destroyed the temples at Mathurā, Kaśī and Ayodhyā. Nevertheless, he was beguiled by a spurious inscription which indicated that the mosque was built by Mir Baqi at the command of Babur. However, the two inscriptions seen by him did never look exactly the same in subsequent incarnations.</p><p>33. In 1822 A.D. Superintendent of Faizabad Law Court Hafizullah submitted a document which stated that the mosque founded by Emperor Babur was situated at the birthsite of Rāma. Evidently, the newly floated inscription had swayed his report.</p><p>34. In July, 1855 Shah Gulam Husain along with a group of 400600 persons, armed with weapons, stormed the Hanuman Gadhi after spreading the rumour that there was a mosque built by Aurangzeb at the site. They were repulsed and chased by Bairagi Sadhus up to the Baburi mosque where a sanguinary battle took place and 75 Muslims and 11 Hindus were killed.</p><p>35. On 7 November, 1855 Ameer Ali led a group of jehadis to demolish the Hanuman Garhi. They started from Amethi but before they could reach Ayodhyā most of them were killed in a direct fight with the royal troops led by Captain Barlow.</p><p>36. On 4 February 1856 the Kingdom of Oudh was arbitrarily annexed by the East India Company and on 2 August 1858 the British Government directly took over the administration of India except that of the Princely States.</p><p>37. In November, 1858 one Nihang Sikh from Punjab along with 25 fellow Sikhs captured the mosque and placed an idol in its central part near the pulpit and established a nishan (flag) outside the mosque. He performed puja and homa inside the shrine and wrote ‘Rāma Rāma’ with coal in all parts of the mosque.</p><p>38. In December, 1858 on a complaint to the S.H.O. the Nihang Sikh was ousted from the mosque and thereafter the British Government did great injustice to the Hindus by banning their puja and rituals in the disputed shrine. They were provided a platform outside the mosque to perform puja.</p><p>39. On 10 April 1859 Vishnubhatta Godse Versaikar, the author of Majha Pravas (My Travels) i.e. “1858 The Real Story of the Great Uprising”, reached Ayodhyā and was present in the Rāma-janma-bhūmi premises on the Rāma-navami day. He saw around 8 lakh devotees present in Ayodhyā on that day. After staying for 22 days he left Ayodhyā. He has given a graphic picture of Rāma-janma-bhūmi and Ayodhyā in his Memoirs.</p><p>40. In 1870 A.D. P. Carnegy published the book ‘Historical Sketch of Tahsil Fyzabad, Zillah Fyzabad’’ wherein he stated that the Hindus and Muslims were performing puja and namaz in the disputed shrine before its takeover by the British Government.</p><p>41. On 24th December, 1885 Pandit Hari Kishan, Sub Judge, Faizabad made a spot enquiry of the disputed mosque in the presence of both the Hindus and the Muslims, and found nothing except ‘Allah’ superscribed on its wall. He dismissed the petition of Raghubar Das, lest riot should take place.</p><p>42. On 17th March, 1886 the District Judge Col. P.E.D. Chamier inspected the disputed mosque in the presence of all parties and found nothing except ‘Allah’ written there. He lamented the demolition of the premier Hindu temple but dismissed the petition of Raghubar Das to build a temple.</p><p>43. In 1889 A.D. Fuhrer found three inscriptions on the mosque. In one inscription the date was 930 A.H., i.e. 1523 A.D. instead of 935 A.H., i.e. 1528 A.D. and in another the name of the builder was Mir Khan and not Mir Baqi.</p><p>44. In 1902 A.D. the District Administration placed markers for all important places of Ayodhyā. The first stone marker was fixed in front of the eastern entrance of the disputed mosque as “No. 1, Rāma-janma-bhūmi”.</p><p>45. In 1906-07 A.D. Maulvi Shuaib submitted his Annual Survey Report wherein he mentioned three inscriptions in the disputed shrine. One inscription was dated 930 A.H. i.e. 1523 A.D. 46. In 1934 A.D. there was a serious communal riot at Ayodhyā. The disputed mosque was damaged extensively. Thereafter Muslims went to the disputed shrine only once in a week to perform Jumma Namaz.</p><p>47. On 26th March, 1946 the Civil Judge of Faizabad S.A. Ahsan inspected the mosque in Faizabad Regular Suit No. 29/1946 and got the inscriptions read out. One inscription referred to the date 923 A.H. i.e. 1516-17 as the year of the construction of the mosque.</p><p>48. On the night of 22nd-23rd December, 1949 Rāmalalla was placed in the central hall of the disputed shrine by the Sadhus of Ayodhyā.</p><p>49. On 1st April, 1986 the lock on the main door of the disputed shrine was opened by the order of the District Judge Faizabad, Shri K.M. Pande.</p><p>50. On 6th December, 1992 the disputed shrine was razed to the ground by the unruly Kār-sevaks.</p><p>51. On 30th September, 2010 the Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad High Court pronounced the detailed Judgment.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d2918acaf765" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Unraveling the Fabrications: Debunking the Myth of Rajput Queens' Enslavement by Khilji]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@akanksha00/the-story-of-kamala-devi-and-devala-devi-which-originates-from-the-poem-ashiqa-is-purely-d1569e1550ee?source=rss-967e8c8d36bb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d1569e1550ee</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[आकांक्षा सिंह रघुवंशी]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 May 2024 12:19:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-24T17:37:49.528Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Character assassination of medieval Rajput queens and princesses based on a preference for Islamic sources has never been a new thing in modern historiography. The stories of Kamala Devi and Devala Devi are examples of this. It is portrayed that Khilji enslaved the king’s wife and that her daughter fell in love with the invaders. Creating such fake stories and names isn’t new for pseudo-Muslim historians.</p><p>The story of Kamala Devi and Devala Devi, which originates from the poem &quot;Ashiqa,&quot; is purely fictional. The first part of this poem was written in 1316 CE and the second part was completed no earlier than 1320 CE.</p><p>modern historians like R.C. Majumdar, H.C. Raychaudhuri and Kalikinkar Datta have written that Queen Kamala Devi was captured during Khilji’s invasion of Gujarat and married to Alauddin while Devala Devi fled to the Seuna Kingdom of Devagiri.</p><p>These historians further state that Devala Devi was later captured in Khilji&#39;s second invasion of Devagiri (1307) and married to Khizr Khan, the eldest son of Alauddin.</p><p>Other scholars, such as A.L. Shrivastav and Satish Chandra also mention this episode involving Devala Devi.</p><p>The frequent repetition of this story in the works of historians and novelists has made it a mainstream episode that is rarely questioned, despite the fact that historical scrutiny of the sources behind the story reveals it to be a complex yet fanciful concoction by medieval Islamic writers.</p><p>K.M. Munshi has rightly termed the narration of &quot;Ashiqa&quot; as &quot;imaginary episodes&quot; with no historical validity.</p><p>According to Amir Khusrau, there were two Khilji invasions of Gujarat under Alauddin’s commander Ulugh Khan, with the second invasion occurring in 1306 CE. However K.M. Munshi pointed out that Alauddin invaded Gujarat only once, not twice. Jiya-ud-din Barani, a historian and contemporary of Amir Khusrau also refers to only one invasion during which Karna lost his throne. Muhanota Nainasi similarly mentions just one invasion.</p><p>All authorities agree that as a result of this invasion, Karna lost his throne. There was no Karna on the throne in 1306 or 1308 CE to necessitate a second invasion. Additionally, none of these historians mentioned that Alauddin enslaved the king&#39;s wife or his daughter.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EFiX6N6Ca5ORPj7Hlbokqw.jpeg" /></figure><p>A critical examination of “Duval Rani - Khizr Khan” done by renowned historians like GH Ojha, KM Munshi, AL Srivastava, KR Qanungo, Beni Prasad reveals some indispensable improbabilities that questions the credibility of this poetical work. Amir Khusrau in his poetical work claims Alauddin Khilji sent two campaign against Karnadev Vaghela, first in 1299 and second in 1306. Further, he claims that both the campaign were under the superintendence of Ulugh Khan, Alauddin’s brother and general. But Ulugh Khan was already dead in 1302, four years before his alleged second campaign of Gujarat. Besides, there wasn’t any second invasion, only Amir Khusrau mentions about a second invasion of Gujarat. Khwaja Abdul Malik Isami in Futuh us Salatin has also mentioned about the second invasion of Gujarat, with his only testimony of this information being Amir Khusrau.Further, Khusrau claims that Kamaladevi, the supposed wife of Karnadeva, requested Alauddin Khilji to bring her daughter from Gujarat. For this, Alauddin Khilji sends an offer of marriage between Devaladevi (Karna’s daughter) and Khizr Khan (Alauddin’s eldest son).</p><p>Now if we consider these statements from Khusrau, there are 3 questions needed to be addressed:</p><p>1. Why Kamaladevi, a Rajput woman would ask a Muslim to snatch her daughter from his original/natural guardian and bring her into a life of infamy?</p><p>2. Karnadeva Vaghela and Alauddin Khilji were enemies, two men from completely different cultures, then why the former will accept the proposal of his daughter with the latter’s son?</p><p>3.Let’s for the instance say that Karnadeva Vaghela was ready to marry her daughter to Alauddin’s son, why the latter would invade former’s territory to bring his daughter?</p><p>These questions only add the unreliability to Amir Khusrau’s work.</p><p>Further scrutiny of Khusrau’s work reveals conflicting years and ages of Devaladevi and Khizr Khan. According to Khusrau, Devaladevi was of 6 months in 1299 &amp; was of 8 years in 1306. Khizr Khan was 10 years old in 1306 and was 22 years old when he was murd£r£d in 1318.So as per Khusrau, Devaladevi, a girl of 8, fell in love with Khizr Khan who was 2 years elder to her. However, to even think that a girl of eight would be precocious and sagacious enough to comprehend and respond to his lover’s advances is disgustingAlso, if Devaladevi was of six months in 1299 at the time of her separation from his mother, how could she be of eight years in 1306?Besides this, the age of Khizr Khan is also documented wrong in Khusrau’s work since Khizr Khan was already appointed as governor of Chittor in August 1303 and by the time of his murd£r in 1316, Khizr Khan had a ten years old son.So if Amir Khusrau is to be believed, Khizr Khan was made governor of Chittor at the age of 12 and had a ten years old son by the age of twenty two, which is obviously, extremely unlikely to happen.</p><p>The poet of the &quot;Ashiqa,&quot; Amir Khusrau, was known to be a dishonest courtier who would write voluminous panegyrical praises for each of his masters during their lifetime but would change his tune like a chameleon after their death. For instance, he offered heaps of praise for Mubarak Shah in &quot;Nur-Sipahr,&quot; but after Mubarak Shah’s death, Khusrau called him a &quot;wretch.&quot;</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9e2_UYLMfVtTqqhtTSXrrw.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>- Amir Khusrau, the poet known for his panegyrics, often insulted Hindus and their gods to glorify his masters. Khusrau gloatingly described the subjugation of the Hindus and created many fictional stories in his works, making it plausible that he fabricated tales about Khilji’s invasion, such as the enslavement of the king’s wife and daughter.</li></ul><p>Further scrutiny of the &quot;Ashiqa&quot; reveals inconsistencies in the years and ages of Khizr Khan and Deval Devi. According to &quot;Ashiqa,&quot; Khizr Khan was ten years old in 1306 CE and twenty-two when assassinated in 1318. However, Khizr was appointed Governor of Chittor by August 1302 and had a ten-year-old son at the time of his assassination, suggesting he would have been only twelve when his son was born, which is highly unlikely. &quot;Ashiqa&quot; also claims Deval Devi was with Khizr Khan when he was killed, but Ibn Battuta, who visited India in 1333 CE and stayed for ten years never mentioned Deval Devi or Kamala Devi. G.H. Ojha, after a detailed study, concluded that no such princess as Deval Devi existed in Gurjardesha, indicating that Amir Khusrau’s &quot;Ashiqa&quot; was a work of fiction.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/596/1*Pm5CoZuLw2-fDkuHTNlkeg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Historians like Nizam-ud-din Ahmad in the &quot;Tabaqat-i-Akbari&quot; and Abdul Kadir Badaoni in the &quot;Muntakhab ut-Tawarikh,&quot; both from the 16th century, provided less embellished accounts based mainly on Khusrau&#39;s version without adding new details.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rH4rLqZ1AarQQIeSjAgWOQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Haji-ud-Dabir, another 16th-century historian, mentioned the defeat of Karna Rai by Ulugh Khan but did not name any captured wives or daughters. Khusrau, a courtier known for his flattering and often fictitious accounts, created many such stories, raising doubts about the historical accuracy of his accounts concerning Khilji’s invasion and the supposed enslavement of royal family members.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nrSGeE0weJ8OB5pDFgQvwQ.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote>The invasion of Gujarat happened in 1299, as evidenced by an inscription that records the exact date:</blockquote><p>&quot;संवत १३५५ वर्षे अशाढ सुदी ७ रानी&quot; (6/6/1299).</p><p>This inscription notes the death of Vaja Rajput, who died fighting invaders to protect Somnath. This raises questions about the claim that Kamala Devi married Alauddin Khilji before the 1297 invasion.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/961/1*RgJfyLPMndpvQZLp8x4ZhQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3LnWxRTjkhU9h3LqVJK5zA.jpeg" /></figure><p>EvenBadauni never mentioned Khilji enslaving any Rajput women, which further questions the credibility of such accounts.</p><blockquote>…. Ferishta too, borrowed the episode of Deval Devi and Khizr Khan from Khusrau, as by the time he wrote, the story was already known in the Court of Delhi. AK Majumdar pointed out that the notion often propagated regarding Ferishta’s tale of Deval Devi being taken in by Nasiruddin Khusrau Shah is actually a misconception stemming from a mistranslation. Both &quot;Ashiqa&quot; and Ferishta’s accounts were dismissed by historians, who argued that such romanticized narratives were unlikely and lacked historical basis.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/864/1*ivSmr0UNeFXJi90pQ74b2g.jpeg" /></figure><p>.. The absence of historical evidence supporting the enslavement of Rajput queens by Khilji underscores the propagandist nature of such narratives. There is no record of queens named Devala Devi and Kamala Devi, indicating that these stories may have been fabricated to denigrate Rajput women.</p><p>Khusrau&#39;s creation of such tales, which attack and undermine the honor and character of Hindu women, likely stemmed from his disdain for the religion of the infidels. While modern scholars of history have an obligation to seek the truth, some may uncritically rely on medieval Islamic texts, perpetuating narratives that undermine Hinduism and its people—a tactic initiated by Islamic writers centuries ago. It&#39;s essential for historians to approach such accounts with careful scrutiny and consider the broader socio-political context in which they were produced to avoid perpetuating biases and inaccuracies.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d1569e1550ee" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>