<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Akhil Vohra on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Akhil Vohra on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@akhilvohra?source=rss-e5fbbe2da2f7------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 20:10:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@akhilvohra/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Battery for Heat: Why VCs Shouldn’t Sleep on Thermal Storage]]></title>
            <link>https://akhilvohra.medium.com/the-battery-for-heat-why-vcs-shouldnt-sleep-on-thermal-storage-152dfb63f06e?source=rss-e5fbbe2da2f7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/152dfb63f06e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Akhil Vohra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 31 Jul 2025 14:46:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-31T14:46:31.295Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When people talk about the energy transition, they usually mean electricity. Solar panels, wind turbines, EV chargers, grid batteries — these dominate the narrative. But lurking behind the scenes is a far bigger, quieter problem: <strong>industrial heat</strong>. Generating heat to produce steel, cement, chemicals, food, glass, and paper accounts for <strong>over half of all final global energy consumption</strong> and a massive share of global CO₂ emissions — often <strong>25–30% or more</strong>, depending on how you count. Unlike electricity, this heat doesn’t flow through wires. It’s created on-site, overwhelmingly by <strong>burning fossil fuels</strong>, especially <strong>natural gas</strong> and <strong>coal</strong>. These systems are simple, cheap, and entrenched — but they are also carbon-intensive, inflexible, and exposed to volatile fuel markets. And critically, <strong>they’re not designed to integrate with renewables at all</strong>. As long as industry keeps burning gas for heat, <strong>no amount of solar panels or wind farms will get us to net zero</strong>. This is the carbon elephant in the room — and it’s why thermal energy storage is emerging as one of the most overlooked and potentially transformational unlocks in climate tech.</p><p>Zoom out from the factory floor, and a deeper problem emerges: <strong>renewable energy is intermittent</strong>. Whether your facility runs on electricity or heat, the fundamental challenge is the same — the sun doesn’t always shine, and the wind doesn’t always blow. For factories that depend on electricity, the solution has typically involved a mix of <strong>grid-tied renewable power purchase agreements (PPAs)</strong>, <strong>on-site solar</strong>, and increasingly, <strong>lithium-ion battery packs</strong> that can smooth out short-term fluctuations. But these batteries are expensive, limited to short durations (2–6 hours), and degrade over time — making them ill-suited for covering longer, deeper lulls in renewable output. On the heat side, the problem is even thornier. Industrial heat is still overwhelmingly produced by burning fossil fuels, and there has historically been <strong>no viable way to store renewable electricity as high-temperature, dispatchable heat</strong>. That’s where a new class of thermal storage startups — like Antora Energy, Rondo Energy, and Polar Night Energy — is stepping in. These companies are building systems that <strong>store cheap, surplus electricity as heat</strong>, and then release it either as <strong>direct process heat</strong> or, when needed, as <strong>electricity through solid-state devices</strong>. In doing so, they’re not just solving for heat — they’re solving for intermittency itself.</p><p>If renewable energy was <strong>step one</strong> in the decarbonization journey, then storage is unquestionably <strong>step two</strong>. It’s what allows us to turn cheap, clean, but unpredictable energy into something <strong>controllable, dispatchable, and industrially useful</strong>. But for years, storage has meant only one thing: <strong>batteries</strong> — specifically, lithium-ion. These batteries store energy <strong>chemically</strong>, using layered materials and electrolytes that shuttle ions back and forth. They’ve been game-changing for short bursts of backup power and for mobile devices, but they come with hard physical and economic constraints. They degrade with every cycle. They’re expensive to scale for long-duration applications. They catch fire if mishandled. And most importantly, they weren’t designed to power a steel mill, a cement kiln, or a 24/7 manufacturing line. This is where a new generation of startups has flipped the paradigm. Instead of trying to store electricity chemically, companies like Antora, Rondo, and Polar Night have asked a more elemental question: <strong>why not just store energy as heat?</strong> After all, that’s how we’ve been <em>using</em> energy in industry for centuries. By storing heat in solid materials — graphite, bricks, or sand — and extracting it on demand, they’re building a new class of storage that’s not only cheaper and more durable, but purpose-built for industrial use. It’s not a workaround. It’s a complete rethinking of what energy storage should look like in a post-carbon world.</p><p>At its core, a thermal battery sounds disarmingly simple: take cheap renewable electricity, convert it to heat, store that heat in a solid material, and release it later — either as industrial-grade heat or as electricity. But building a system that does this efficiently, safely, and economically is anything but simple. The first and perhaps most foundational decision is: <strong>what material will store the heat?</strong> Companies like <strong>Antora</strong> use <strong>solid carbon (graphite)</strong> for its exceptional ability to handle extreme temperatures and re-radiate heat. <strong>Rondo</strong> uses <strong>brick</strong>, betting on low cost and durability. <strong>Polar Night Energy</strong> uses <strong>sand</strong>, aiming for regional availability and passive insulation. Each material forces a different set of trade-offs: How hot can it get? How fast does it lose heat? Is it abundant, safe, and ethically sourced? How heavy and space-intensive is it per MWh stored? Then comes the process design: <strong>How is electricity converted into heat</strong> — via resistance coils or induction? <strong>How is that heat stored — evenly or in gradients?</strong> How long can the system <strong>retain useful temperatures</strong> (6 hours? 48? A week?), and at what insulation cost? Discharge is another key piece: <strong>Do you want to release heat directly into a process</strong>, or convert it back into electricity via something like <strong>Thermophotovoltaics (TPV)</strong>? Each output mode brings complexity — radiation control, aperture design, cooling, and conversion losses. And finally, there’s the question of <strong>integration</strong>: Can this system be retrofitted into an existing industrial plant without redesigning the entire process flow? Can it plug into <strong>boilers, steam lines, or furnaces</strong> without disrupting operations? These are not just engineering questions — they’re VC questions. Because every technical answer echoes downstream in cost structure, reliability, go-to-market strategy, and ultimately, climate impact.</p><p>In the early days of designing Antora’s system, Andrew Ponec and his team ran into a classic problem: at the extreme temperatures they needed (~1,900°C), <strong>fluids stop being helpful</strong>. Gases become too viscous. Liquids freeze above room temperature. Pipes clog. Pumps fail. For a while, the team was stuck — trying to move heat the way everyone always had: through <strong>convection</strong>. Then came what Andrew described as the “<em>aha moment</em>”: they didn’t need a fluid at all. They could use <strong>radiation — literal light</strong>. At those temperatures, graphite glows so intensely that it emits enough infrared energy to transfer heat across space — no pipes, no flow, no moving parts. All they had to do was <strong>change the geometry</strong> of the system to let that light move freely to thermophotovoltaic cells. It was a breakthrough not in chemistry, but in <strong>rethinking what heat even is</strong>.</p><p>Once you’ve chosen your material and system architecture, the viability of a thermal battery hinges on how well it performs across three critical functions: <strong>charging</strong>, <strong>retention</strong>, and <strong>discharge</strong> — each of which directly shapes the system’s unit economics and industrial usefulness.</p><p>Start with <strong>charging</strong>. In today’s power markets, <strong>renewable electricity is cheapest — sometimes even free — for just a few hours a day</strong>, typically in the early afternoon when solar floods the grid. If your system takes too long to charge, it spills over into more expensive hours, ruining your cost advantage. That’s why materials with <strong>high thermal conductivity</strong> matter: they allow fast heat transfer into the core, enabling the battery to <strong>soak up energy quickly</strong> during that brief ultra-cheap window. A slow-charging system might need <strong>12 hours</strong> of grid exposure. A fast one could get away with <strong>2–3 hours</strong>, radically improving economics.</p><p>Then comes <strong>retention</strong> — how long the stored heat stays hot. This isn’t just a question of material, but of <strong>insulation strategy</strong>. The longer a system can retain usable heat without needing a recharge, the more <strong>flexible</strong> it becomes for industrial customers. But insulation isn’t free: it adds cost, bulk, and complexity. A system that leaks heat too quickly may need frequent recharging (which risks higher-cost electricity). But <strong>overspending on insulation</strong> makes the system uneconomic. So the question becomes: <strong>how much insulation is just enough</strong> to retain temperature over the required discharge window — be it 6 hours, 24, or 72?</p><p>Finally, there’s <strong>discharge control</strong> — perhaps the most overlooked but business-critical element. As a thermal battery discharges, its internal temperature naturally drops. Left unmanaged, this would cause <strong>a declining output temperature or heat flow</strong>, which is unacceptable for industrial processes that require <strong>stable, continuous heat delivery</strong>. Think of it like a lithium-ion battery where the voltage drops too quickly — you can’t use the full charge. <strong>Antora’s breakthrough here is elegant</strong>: it uses <strong>radiative heat transfer</strong>, and controls the rate of heat extraction by opening or closing <strong>insulated shutters</strong>. As the graphite cools and glows less brightly, the shutters open wider to let more light out — maintaining a <strong>consistent power output</strong>. It’s a thermal analogue to power electronics smoothing voltage.</p><p>These three axes — <strong>fast charge</strong>, <strong>low-loss hold</strong>, and <strong>controlled discharge</strong> — are where thermal batteries either unlock massive value or quietly fail to compete. And they’re exactly where VCs should be looking.</p><p>To see how this plays out in practice, consider a real-world example offered by Antora’s founders — one that illustrates just how critical charging duration is to overall system economics:</p><h3>Why Antora’s System Makes Sense — A Unit Economics Example</h3><p>Let’s say you’re operating an industrial facility in Iowa that currently generates high-temperature steam using <strong>natural gas</strong>. After accounting for gas prices (~$5–6/MMBtu), burner inefficiency (~80%), and delivery markups, your <strong>effective cost of usable heat</strong> is around <strong>$7–8 per MMBtu</strong>.</p><p>Now imagine replacing that with a thermal battery like Antora’s, charged using <strong>cheap midday solar</strong>.</p><ul><li>For a 1 MMBtu equivalent, you need ~293 kWh of electricity (based on conversion rates and losses).</li><li>If you can <strong>fully charge your system in 2 hours during the solar glut</strong>, when electricity costs <strong>$10/MWh (1¢/kWh)</strong>:<br>- Your <strong>input energy cost</strong> is <strong>$2.93/MMBtu</strong>.<br>- Add in efficiency losses (~10–15%) and basic capex amortization, and you might land at <strong>$4–5/MMBtu delivered heat</strong>.</li></ul><p>But if your system takes <strong>6 hours to charge</strong>, and only the first 2 hours are at $10/MWh while the remaining 4 hours climb toward $40/MWh, your <strong>blended electricity price jumps</strong>, and you might be paying closer to <strong>$20/MWh on average</strong> — which lands you back at <strong>$6–7/MMBtu</strong> heat cost, eroding your margin and removing the incentive to switch from gas.</p><p>That’s the crux:<br> — <strong>Antora’s fast-charging graphite-based system</strong> enables it to <strong>concentrate charging during the cheapest 2–3 hour window</strong> — locking in ultra-low input costs.<br> — Their discharge mechanism (via <strong>radiative heat and TPVs</strong>) gives them the <strong>option to flex into electricity</strong> when the grid price spikes — adding an <strong>upside revenue layer</strong> that gas can’t match.</p><p>In effect, Antora replaces:</p><ul><li>A <strong>gas boiler</strong> (which can only burn fuel),</li><li>A <strong>battery</strong> (which can only store for short durations), and</li><li>A <strong>peaker plant</strong> (which is rarely used, but expensive to maintain)<br> — all in one modular, long-duration, dual-output system.</li></ul><p>This isn’t just cleaner. It’s <strong>cheaper, more flexible, and more financially dynamic</strong> — especially in regions with volatile electricity pricing and pressure to decarbonize heat.</p><p>The physics of charging, retention, and discharge don’t live in the abstract — they live in <strong>material science</strong>, and no two thermal storage startups have taken the same bet. Each has chosen a different storage medium, with its own temperature ceiling, conductivity, insulation profile, and integration pathway. Take <strong>Antora Energy</strong>, which uses <strong>solid carbon (graphite)</strong>. Graphite has <strong>exceptional thermal conductivity</strong>, which allows it to <strong>charge rapidly</strong> — a key advantage when trying to absorb solar energy during a brief 2–3 hour cheap-power window. It also tolerates <strong>extremely high temperatures</strong> (up to 2,000°C), making it suitable for <strong>high-heat industrial processes</strong> like steel, glass, and chemical refining. And crucially, Antora uses <strong>thermophotovoltaics (TPVs)</strong> to reconvert that heat into electricity, made possible by graphite’s ability to emit intense, focused thermal radiation.</p><p>Contrast that with <strong>Rondo Energy</strong>, which stores heat in <strong>refractory bricks</strong>. Bricks don’t conduct heat nearly as quickly — so Rondo’s system may take longer to charge. But they’re <strong>cheap, durable, and already used in kilns and furnaces worldwide</strong>, which makes industrial integration easier. Rondo’s sweet spot is <strong>direct process heat delivery</strong> rather than reconversion to electricity, making it ideal for cement, food processing, and pulp &amp; paper — sectors that need reliable mid-to-high temperature heat (500–1,200°C), not electricity.</p><p>Then there’s <strong>Polar Night Energy</strong>, which uses <strong>sand</strong> — one of the world’s most abundant and geopolitically neutral materials. Its system is designed more for <strong>modular, low-cost deployment</strong> in colder geographies, targeting district heating and smaller-scale applications (~500–600°C). Sand’s insulation needs are higher, and its conductivity lower, but the cost advantages are enormous — especially in <strong>seasonal or decentralized heating contexts</strong>.</p><p>Even more exotic materials exist: <strong>molten salts</strong>, <strong>molten silicon</strong>, or <strong>phase-change materials (PCMs)</strong>. These promise <strong>higher energy densities</strong>, but face challenges around containment, corrosion, safety, and long-term stability — particularly above 1,000°C.</p><p>Each material, then, implies a <strong>different trade-off curve</strong>: fast charging vs. capital cost; high temperature vs. system safety; heat vs. electricity output. As a VC or founder, choosing a material is less about science fiction and more about <strong>matching thermodynamics to market fit</strong>.</p><p>Here’s how some of the leading thermal storage startups map onto these trade-offs — showing how each company’s material choice defines its product architecture, use case, and go-to-market strategy:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*keA3pqwilJpGv56A" /></figure><p>Once the engineering is sound, everything turns to monetization — and thermal battery startups are beginning to unlock <strong>multiple revenue streams</strong> that conventional storage often can’t tap. The first and most obvious is <strong>heat-as-a-service</strong>: selling high-temperature, carbon-free process heat directly to industrial clients. In this model, the startup either installs systems on-site and charges per unit of heat delivered (e.g., $/MMBTU), or partners with energy service providers to decarbonize legacy boilers. This works best for <strong>hard-to-abate sectors</strong> like cement, glass, chemicals, and food processing, where electrification is expensive or incompatible.</p><p>The second stream is <strong>power generation</strong> — converting stored heat back into electricity using solid-state devices like <strong>Thermophotovoltaics (TPVs)</strong>. While not every thermal battery player offers this, those who do (like <strong>Antora</strong>) are able to act as <strong>dual-mode systems</strong>, flexibly delivering heat or power depending on demand, price signals, or time of day. This becomes particularly valuable for clients facing <strong>demand charges</strong>, <strong>grid volatility</strong>, or <strong>grid-interconnection constraints</strong>.</p><p>But the value doesn’t stop at the factory gate. These systems also offer major upside for <strong>renewable energy developers</strong>. Traditionally, solar and wind producers face a limited set of off-takers — they sell to the grid or nothing. But thermal batteries expand that universe. By sitting behind the meter, they act as <strong>flexible energy buyers</strong> that can soak up cheap power during periods of surplus (midday solar glut, nighttime wind ramps), turning it into usable heat or dispatchable power. This helps <strong>stabilize grid demand</strong>, monetize previously curtailed energy, and smooth out price spikes — creating <strong>economic value across the energy ecosystem</strong>, not just behind one industrial fence.</p><p>The smartest startups in this space will likely <strong>bundle these offerings</strong> into a wider suite: demand response participation, grid balancing, energy arbitrage, or even capacity markets. In other words, they won’t just be hardware vendors — they’ll be <strong>thermal infrastructure platforms</strong>.</p><p>For VCs evaluating the thermal energy storage space, this isn’t just an intriguing science project — it’s a play on one of the <strong>largest and least disrupted segments of the global energy system</strong>: <strong>industrial heat</strong>, which accounts for <strong>over 20% of global CO₂ emissions</strong> and consumes more energy than the entire global transport sector. That alone places the TAM in the <strong>trillions of dollars</strong> when viewed over a 30-year decarbonization horizon. And what these startups are selling is deceptively simple but strategically pivotal: <strong>storage</strong>. Not lithium-ion storage. Not pumped hydro. But <strong>high-temperature, long-duration, infrastructure-compatible storage</strong> — the essential second half of the energy transition, after renewable generation itself.</p><p>The product category is clear: <strong>thermal batteries</strong> that store surplus electricity as heat, and dispatch that heat (or sometimes electricity) on demand. But within this category lies a <strong>sharp need for differentiation</strong>, because while the market is large enough to support multiple winners, capital will chase the few that <strong>get the thermodynamics and integration pathways right</strong>.</p><p>This is where science becomes strategy. Materials affect <strong>charging speed</strong> (which maps to access to low-cost electricity). Discharge mechanisms (e.g., <strong>TPVs</strong> vs. molten tin vs. steam transfer) determine <strong>output consistency</strong> and <strong>system complexity</strong>. Retention and insulation strategies impact <strong>capex and operating flexibility</strong>. And perhaps most importantly, integration matters: a system that <strong>slots neatly into existing industrial process lines</strong> (e.g., via heat exchangers, steam loops, or boiler retrofits) will dramatically shorten sales cycles and adoption barriers.</p><p>Challenges remain. Startups in this space face the usual hardtech gauntlet: <strong>capital intensity, long deployment timelines, thermal degradation risk, and conservative industrial clients</strong> who can’t afford process disruptions. Financing models need to evolve — from pure hardware sales to energy-as-a-service. Some materials (e.g., molten metals) may face safety or maintenance risks. And thermal systems must still prove their <strong>cycle life, O&amp;M costs, and real-world reliability</strong> across seasons and geographies.</p><p>As promising as thermal batteries are, this isn’t a risk-free bet — and any investor treating it as such is missing the hardtech realities. For one, the <strong>economics hinge on ultra-cheap renewable electricity</strong> being available for at least a few hours each day. If that window shrinks — due to changing grid dynamics, rising solar demand, or new baseload entrants — the whole model wobbles. Then there’s <strong>technology stack fragility</strong>: TPVs, for example, are elegant in principle but still early in commercial deployment. Their cost, efficiency, and thermal durability are unproven at gigawatt scale. There’s also the threat of <strong>incumbent interference</strong>: if energy majors see these systems as disruptive to their gas-fired industrial business, they may invest not to accelerate, but to control or delay deployment. And finally, there’s always the <strong>boring killer</strong>: integration friction. A solution that can’t easily drop into existing steam lines, process heat loops, or plant control systems may never see wide adoption, no matter how clever the tech.</p><p>But the timing is unusually ripe. Power grids are flooding with <strong>stranded renewable capacity</strong>, carbon pricing is tightening, and industrial buyers are facing <strong>regulatory pressure + investor scrutiny</strong> to clean up heat-based emissions. If lithium-ion was the battery of the EV era, thermal storage may become the battery of the industrial era — a $100B+ decarbonization platform hiding in plain sight.</p><p>The timing isn’t just about grid economics — it’s also about regulation. Across Europe, the <strong>Fit for 55 package</strong> is creating aggressive mandates for industrial decarbonization, including clean heat targets and carbon pricing extensions. In the U.S., the <strong>Inflation Reduction Act (IRA)</strong> offers tax credits not only for renewable generation, but also for thermal storage paired with clean power. Globally, over 70 jurisdictions now implement <strong>explicit or implicit carbon pricing</strong>, which raises the relative cost of gas-fired heat. In other words, the demand for thermal decarbonization isn’t just technical — it’s being written into law.</p><p>For a VC, the edge lies in asking the <strong>right technical questions</strong> early. How fast does it charge? How is the heat discharged — light, steam, conduction? How much insulation is required for 24-hour retention? Can it modulate output like a gas boiler? And how fast can it be deployed behind the meter? The answers will separate the elegant lab demo from the enduring infrastructure business.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*szHqjJiEGProgu4TZ5JDGQ.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=152dfb63f06e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“The Fusion Stack: Why the Race to Build a Star on Earth Is Now a Venture-Scale Opportunity”]]></title>
            <link>https://akhilvohra.medium.com/the-fusion-stack-why-the-race-to-build-a-star-on-earth-is-now-a-venture-scale-opportunity-c11a264a9f18?source=rss-e5fbbe2da2f7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c11a264a9f18</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Akhil Vohra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 10 Jul 2025 22:07:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-31T14:50:05.325Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>1. Introduction — A Star in a Box</h3><p>The energy world is being pulled in two directions. Renewable sources like wind and solar are growing fast, but they are intermittent. Fossil fuels are reliable but carbon-heavy. Batteries and hydrogen are trying to bridge the gap, yet none of these options solve the core issue: how do we supply clean, continuous, high-density power to meet rising demand?</p><p>This is where nuclear energy fits in. Not the traditional kind that splits uranium atoms, but a cleaner, more powerful version. Nuclear fusion. The process that powers the sun and every star we see.</p><p>Fusion works by forcing lightweight atoms, such as hydrogen, to fuse into heavier ones. In doing so, they release vast amounts of energy. But this only happens under extreme heat and pressure. To create these conditions on Earth, we must turn hydrogen into plasma — a high-energy state of matter where electrons are stripped from atoms, creating a charged soup of particles.</p><p>This plasma must be heated to over 100 million degrees Celsius and held in place long enough for the atoms to collide and fuse. When they do, the reaction releases energy. That energy is either converted into heat, which drives a turbine to generate electricity, or directly captured as electrical current through magnetic effects.</p><p>The concept is simple. Build a machine that creates and contains plasma, harness the energy from fusion, and use it to power homes, cities, or even data centers. But for decades, fusion remained just out of reach. The technology was too unstable, too expensive, and progress was too slow.</p><p>That has started to change.</p><p>In the last few years, fusion has moved from government labs into private startups. It has evolved from a scientific dream into an engineering challenge with real venture capital backing. Companies like Helion, Marvel Fusion, and Proxima Fusion are not only designing new types of reactors but are also signing commercial contracts and attracting top-tier investors.</p><p>The physics is still demanding. But the path to building fusion systems is clearer than ever. And with energy demand surging — especially from heavy industry and AI infrastructure — the market need is real.</p><p>Fusion is no longer a distant hope. It is becoming a serious infrastructure bet. And that is why now is the right time to understand how it works, who is building it, and where the opportunity lies.</p><h3>2. Deep Dive — How Proxima and Marvel Are Trying to Fuse the Atom</h3><p>If nuclear fusion is the goal, the method is everything. While the physics stays the same — force hydrogen nuclei to fuse under extreme heat and pressure — the way startups achieve that fusion varies dramatically.</p><p>Two of the most technically sophisticated efforts come from <strong>Proxima Fusion</strong> and <strong>Marvel Fusion</strong>, both based in Germany but following opposite paths.</p><p>One is building on decades of plasma research, designing elegant magnetic traps to contain continuous streams of fusion fuel. The other is betting on a single, explosive moment — using lasers to compress a tiny fuel pellet until it collapses into itself.</p><p>To understand these approaches, we need to go step by step through how each one tries to make fusion happen.</p><h3>Proxima Fusion: Magnetically Confined Plasma</h3><h4>What They’re Building</h4><p>Proxima is designing a new kind of reactor called a <strong>quasi-isodynamic stellarator</strong>, a type of magnetic confinement system that aims to hold superheated plasma in a stable, continuous loop.</p><h4>How Their Process Works (Step-by-Step)</h4><p><strong>1. Fuel introduction<br></strong> Proxima starts with a mixture of hydrogen isotopes — most likely deuterium and tritium — that will form the plasma.</p><p><strong>2. Plasma formation<br></strong> The hydrogen gas is heated to extreme temperatures until it becomes plasma. At this stage, the atoms break apart into free nuclei and electrons, creating a fast-moving, highly conductive cloud of charged particles.</p><p><strong>3. Magnetic confinement<br></strong> Here’s the heart of the stellarator. Proxima uses <strong>superconducting magnets</strong> shaped into a complex 3D coil structure. These magnets generate a twisting magnetic field that forms a closed loop. Charged particles in the plasma spiral along these magnetic field lines, effectively keeping them trapped inside the loop without touching the reactor walls.</p><p>The term <strong>“quasi-isodynamic”</strong> means that the magnetic field is optimized to keep particles from drifting out. It’s a geometry that balances out the forces in all directions, reducing the energy loss that plagues other systems.</p><p><strong>4. Heating the plasma<br></strong> Proxima will likely use a combination of:</p><ul><li><strong>Microwaves</strong> to energize electrons and ions</li><li><strong>Neutral beam injection</strong>, where fast-moving atoms are fired into the plasma, colliding with and heating it</li></ul><p>The goal is to reach temperatures over 100 million degrees Celsius, where the hydrogen nuclei move fast enough to overcome their natural repulsion and fuse.</p><p><strong>5. Fusion and energy extraction<br></strong> Once the plasma is hot and dense enough, fusion reactions begin to occur. These reactions release high-speed neutrons and helium nuclei. The neutrons escape the magnetic field and hit the surrounding material, transferring energy as heat. That heat can then be used to produce steam and turn a turbine.</p><h4>What Makes Proxima Unique</h4><ul><li>Uses a <strong>stellarator</strong>, which avoids the unstable plasma currents seen in tokamaks</li><li>Designs its magnetic fields with <strong>AI optimization</strong>, improving confinement and reducing energy loss</li><li>Builds on proven research from the <strong>Wendelstein 7-X</strong> project, but aims for a compact, modular design</li></ul><h3>Marvel Fusion: Laser-Induced Compression</h3><h4>What They’re Building</h4><p>Marvel is pursuing <strong>inertial confinement fusion</strong>, where the fuel is compressed so quickly and forcefully that fusion occurs before the material has time to fly apart.</p><h4>How Their Process Works (Step-by-Step)</h4><p><strong>1. Fuel pellet preparation<br></strong> Marvel uses tiny spherical fuel pellets made of advanced materials containing hydrogen, likely with isotopes like deuterium or boron-11.</p><p><strong>2. Laser ignition<br></strong> Instead of heating a large volume of plasma, Marvel focuses intense laser pulses onto the pellet’s surface. These <strong>ultra-short, high-power laser bursts</strong> vaporize the outer layer of the pellet.</p><p><strong>3. Shockwave compression<br></strong> When the outer layer explodes outward, it creates an equal and opposite reaction that forces the inner core of the pellet to implode. This <strong>shockwave compression</strong> increases the core’s temperature and pressure to fusion levels — in a matter of billionths of a second.</p><p><strong>4. Fusion ignition<br></strong> At peak compression, the conditions in the core are intense enough for fusion to occur. Marvel’s goal is to use <strong>aneutronic fuels</strong>, such as proton–boron-11, which release <strong>helium nuclei (charged particles)</strong> rather than neutrons.</p><p><strong>5. Energy capture<br></strong> Because the fusion products are charged particles, Marvel aims to <strong>convert their motion directly into electricity</strong> using magnetic or electrostatic systems, bypassing the need for steam turbines.</p><h4>What Makes Marvel Unique</h4><ul><li>Uses <strong>aneutronic fuel</strong>, which generates almost no radiation or neutron damage</li><li>Skips steam generation by focusing on <strong>direct energy conversion</strong></li><li>Relies on cutting-edge <strong>laser physics and precision manufacturing</strong> for ignition</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/990/1*7F9vJeNbwTOMfE2-nRYmXQ.png" /></figure><h3>Why This Scientific Detail Matters</h3><p>Understanding the full process behind each fusion method isn’t just academic. Every step — plasma formation, confinement, heating, fuel choice, energy extraction — creates new <strong>opportunity surfaces for innovation</strong>.</p><ul><li>Better superconductors can shrink reactors.</li><li>Smarter AI can stabilize magnet fields.</li><li>Stronger materials can handle plasma erosion.</li><li>Advanced optics can make lasers faster and cheaper.</li><li>Novel fuels can reduce waste and increase efficiency.</li></ul><p>By breaking down what Proxima and Marvel are doing, we also define where <strong>venture capital can play a role</strong>: not just in the core reactor, but in the stack of technologies that make fusion practical.</p><h3>3. Why Fusion Has Been Hard, and What’s Finally Changing</h3><p>When we talk about nuclear fusion, it’s easy to say: “we just need to recreate the sun on Earth.” But this underplays just how wildly complex that task is. The sun has the benefit of being massive. It holds itself together with gravity. On Earth, we don’t have that luxury. We need to <strong>simulate the core of a star using magnets, lasers, or pressure</strong> — and we need to do it in a machine that can run reliably, safely, and economically.</p><p>That’s where fusion has struggled. For decades, the physics made sense on paper, but the <strong>engineering wasn’t good enough</strong>. Plasma would escape its confinement. Components would melt. Lasers were too slow or inefficient. And when reactions did occur, they required far more energy input than they ever produced.</p><p>At the heart of the problem were a few brutal facts of nature:</p><ul><li>Plasma is unstable and tries to escape confinement</li><li>Magnetic fields must be precise and strong enough to hold a 100-million-degree fluid</li><li>Any interaction between plasma and solid materials causes damage, erosion, and heat loss</li><li>Neutrons released during fusion reactions can degrade the very structure of the reactor</li></ul><p>Even when successful fusion reactions happened, they were short-lived, small-scale, or non-replicable. This made fusion feel more like an academic puzzle than a venture-backable technology.</p><p>But over the last few years, the situation has shifted — not because we solved the physics, but because <strong>the tools we have to engineer around the physics got dramatically better</strong>.</p><p>Let’s look at two of the most important breakthroughs.</p><h3>High-Temperature Superconductors (HTS): Stronger Fields, Smaller Machines</h3><p>Magnetic confinement fusion systems like Proxima rely on magnetic fields to keep the plasma suspended in space. The stronger and more precisely shaped the magnetic field, the better the plasma is confined, the less energy escapes, and the closer we get to sustained fusion.</p><p>Traditional magnetic coils used <strong>copper</strong> or <strong>low-temperature superconductors</strong> like <strong>NbTi (niobium titanium)</strong>. These materials were bulky and inefficient. To operate without resistance, they had to be cooled to near absolute zero — around 4 kelvin, or −269°C. This made them expensive, fragile, and limited in how strong a magnetic field they could produce.</p><p>But the last few years have brought <strong>high-temperature superconductors</strong> into practical use. The most notable is <strong>REBCO</strong> (Rare Earth Barium Copper Oxide), a material that:</p><ul><li>Can operate at <strong>20–30 kelvin</strong>, which is significantly warmer than traditional superconductors</li><li>Supports <strong>much higher magnetic fields</strong> — over <strong>20 Tesla</strong>, compared to 5–10 Tesla in older systems</li><li>Can be <strong>manufactured in tape form</strong>, allowing tighter coil designs and more compact geometries</li></ul><p>This means fusion reactors don’t need to be the size of buildings anymore. They can be <strong>smaller, denser, and more modular</strong>, while still generating the intense fields needed to confine plasma. Companies like <strong>Commonwealth Fusion Systems</strong> have already built magnets using REBCO that surpass anything used in ITER, the world’s largest public fusion project.</p><p>For VCs, this is a game-changer. It turns fusion from a moonshot into an <strong>engineering problem with commercial form factors</strong>. REBCO enables the idea of shipping a fusion core that fits in a warehouse or industrial site — without needing a football field of magnets.</p><h3>AI-Driven Magnetic Optimization: Designing Better Plasma Cages</h3><p>The second breakthrough is subtler but just as powerful: the use of <strong>AI and computational optimization</strong> to design magnetic confinement systems that were previously too complex to build.</p><p>Take <strong>stellarators</strong>, like the one Proxima is developing. These devices use 3D-shaped magnetic coils that twist around the plasma like a pretzel. Unlike tokamaks, they don’t require a current to run through the plasma, which makes them inherently more stable and suitable for continuous operation.</p><p>But their shapes are incredibly difficult to design. A tiny shift in coil geometry can ruin plasma confinement or cause energy to leak.</p><p>In the past, engineers had to <strong>trial-and-error their way through thousands of magnetic shapes</strong> to find something that worked. It took years and millions of dollars.</p><p>Now, with AI-powered simulation tools and high-performance computing, startups can:</p><ul><li>Simulate thousands of coil geometries in hours instead of years</li><li>Use <strong>machine learning</strong> to predict how plasma will behave in each configuration</li><li>Optimize for minimal plasma loss, maximal confinement time, and real-world manufacturability</li></ul><p>This approach is what enables Proxima’s <strong>quasi-isodynamic stellarator</strong> — a magnetic geometry so well-balanced that it keeps particles trapped longer, reducing energy loss and increasing the chance of net fusion gain.</p><p>This kind of software-defined physics is a new phenomenon in energy infrastructure. We’ve seen it in semiconductors and rocket design. Now it’s happening in fusion. And it opens up room for innovation not just in magnets, but in <strong>plasma control systems, fault detection, dynamic field adjustment, and predictive maintenance</strong>.</p><p>From a VC lens, this creates a whole new category: <strong>fusion tooling</strong>. The startups that build the AI models, simulations, control systems, and diagnostics could become the core software providers across fusion companies, regardless of who wins the reactor race.</p><h3>And These Are Just Two of Many</h3><p>High-temperature superconductors and AI-driven magnetic design are two of the biggest breakthroughs — but they are not alone. Several other advances are reshaping how we approach fusion engineering:</p><p><strong>Pulsed power electronics</strong> have become faster, more precise, and more compact. Modern solid-state switches and capacitors can now deliver massive voltage spikes in nanoseconds, enabling cleaner, more controllable plasma injections and more reliable ignition sequences. Startups like <strong>Helion</strong> and <strong>Zap Energy</strong> rely on these systems to trigger fusion in pulsed bursts, rather than in steady-state reactors.</p><p><strong>New materials for reactor walls</strong> are being designed to withstand the intense bombardment of neutrons and charged particles that result from fusion reactions. Alloys like tungsten and ceramics like boron carbide can absorb this punishment while maintaining structural integrity and minimizing plasma contamination — a critical step in building reactors that last more than just a few test cycles.</p><p><strong>Aneutronic fuels</strong>, such as <strong>proton-boron-11</strong>, offer a pathway to fusion reactions that release almost no neutrons. This dramatically reduces radiation, waste, and shielding requirements. The downside is that these reactions require even higher temperatures than conventional D-T fusion — but if that hurdle can be overcome, they promise cleaner, more compact fusion systems.</p><p>And finally, <strong>direct energy conversion</strong> is emerging as a compelling alternative to the traditional steam turbine model. Instead of using heat to spin turbines, some systems aim to capture the kinetic energy of charged fusion products — like helium nuclei — using magnetic or electrostatic fields to convert their motion directly into electricity. This method could dramatically simplify reactor design and increase efficiency.</p><p>Each of these breakthroughs attacks a different point in the fusion lifecycle — fuel, ignition, confinement, energy capture — and together, they’re turning fusion from a theory into an ecosystem.</p><p>From a venture capital perspective, this shift matters. Because it means you’re no longer betting on a single massive machine. You’re betting on an <strong>interconnected stack of technologies</strong>, each with its own innovation curve, risk profile, and commercialization path.</p><h3>4. Where Is the VC Opportunity in Fusion?</h3><p>It’s tempting to think of fusion as one big binary: either someone builds the world’s first working fusion reactor or they don’t. But that framing misses the real opportunity.</p><p>Fusion is not a single invention. It is an <strong>entire industrial stack</strong> being built in real time.</p><p>Just like space tech didn’t end with SpaceX, and semiconductors aren’t limited to chip foundries, fusion is rapidly evolving into a <strong>modular, multi-layered ecosystem</strong>. This means value won’t just accrue to whoever creates the first commercial fusion reaction. It will accrue to the companies that enable it — through software, materials, AI, electronics, and new business models.</p><p>If you’re a venture capitalist, this is what matters: <strong>fusion is transitioning from fundamental physics to engineering execution</strong>, and engineering execution can be industrialized, productized, and monetized across layers.</p><p>Let’s break this down into <strong>seven opportunity zones</strong>, and examine what each one offers — along with examples of startup types, business models, and future outcomes.</p><h3>1. Core Reactor Startups</h3><h4>💡 What’s happening?</h4><p>These are the high-profile names building reactors themselves: <strong>Proxima</strong>, <strong>Marvel</strong>, <strong>Helion</strong>, <strong>TAE</strong>, <strong>Zap</strong>, <strong>CFS</strong>.</p><p>Each one is betting on a different fusion method (magnetic vs inertial, pulsed vs continuous, neutron-rich vs aneutronic), and each is building their own end-to-end platform — from fuel injection to energy capture.</p><h4>📈 VC Opportunity</h4><ul><li>These are <strong>high-risk, high-reward full-stack bets</strong></li><li>Time-to-revenue is long (5–10 years), but potential is enormous</li><li>Could resemble <strong>SpaceX</strong> or <strong>Tesla</strong> in structure: vertically integrated tech, multi-billion dollar markets, long-term defensibility</li></ul><h4>💼 Business Models</h4><ul><li>Power purchase agreements (e.g., Helion–Microsoft)</li><li>Fusion-as-a-Service for industry, military, or island grids</li><li>Licensing reactor designs to governments or utilities</li></ul><h4>🎯 Takeaway</h4><p>Pick <strong>category-defining bets</strong>. There will be only a few, and they will be capital-intensive. But if they work, they anchor an entire ecosystem.</p><h3>2. Enabling Hardware &amp; Components</h3><h4>💡 What’s happening?</h4><p>Fusion reactors need new classes of <strong>hardware subsystems</strong>:</p><ul><li><strong>High-temperature superconducting magnets</strong></li><li><strong>Pulsed power systems</strong> (capacitors, fast switches)</li><li><strong>Cryogenic cooling units</strong></li><li><strong>High-reflectivity optics and laser assemblies</strong></li></ul><p>These components are <strong>not commodity</strong>. They are complex, often customized, and fusion-specific.</p><h4>📈 VC Opportunity</h4><ul><li>These are <strong>deeptech picks-and-shovels</strong> plays</li><li>Can sell across multiple reactor startups or spin into other sectors (e.g., MRI, aerospace, defense)</li><li>Lower CapEx than building full reactors, but crucial IP in precision and performance</li></ul><h4>💼 Business Models</h4><ul><li>Component licensing or white-labeling</li><li>Long-term supply contracts with core fusion players</li><li>Design-manufacture integration (think <strong>Applied Materials</strong> for fusion)</li></ul><h4>🎯 Takeaway</h4><p>Back the enablers who can become <strong>“arms dealers”</strong> to the fusion race.</p><h3>3. Modularization &amp; Manufacturing Stack</h3><h4>💡 What’s happening?</h4><p>Fusion systems are shifting from “single facility megaprojects” to <strong>repeatable industrial units</strong>. Startups are:</p><ul><li>Designing <strong>standardized subsystems</strong> (magnet modules, fuel units, control panels)</li><li>Building <strong>automated assembly lines</strong> for coils or reactor shells</li><li>Applying <strong>CAD-to-fab pipelines</strong> for rapid prototyping</li></ul><h4>📈 VC Opportunity</h4><ul><li>Speeds up iteration and scalability</li><li>Makes fusion systems more financeable (banks can underwrite consistent units)</li><li>Unlocks <strong>distributed deployments</strong>, not just utility-scale ones</li></ul><h4>💼 Business Models</h4><ul><li>Component stack startups selling to multiple reactor builders</li><li>On-prem manufacturing tools (e.g., reactor part printers, magnetic coil benders)</li><li>Operating systems for hardware integration</li></ul><h4>🎯 Takeaway</h4><p>This is how you make fusion <strong>modular, manufacturable, and venture-scalable</strong>.</p><h3>4. AI &amp; Plasma Control Software</h3><h4>💡 What’s happening?</h4><p>Controlling plasma is an <strong>unpredictable, real-time challenge</strong>. AI is now being used to:</p><ul><li><strong>Optimize magnet geometry</strong></li><li>Predict and suppress <strong>plasma instabilities</strong></li><li>Monitor energy confinement in real time</li><li>Manage heat distribution and plasma edge behavior</li></ul><p>This is where Proxima shines — with AI-powered design loops for its magnetic fields.</p><h4>📈 VC Opportunity</h4><ul><li>Software layers that sell into <strong>multiple fusion hardware players</strong></li><li>IP-heavy, asset-light</li><li>Potential for <strong>data network effects</strong> as plasma behavior gets better understood</li></ul><h4>💼 Business Models</h4><ul><li>SaaS or simulation-as-a-service for fusion labs</li><li>Proprietary physics models licensed to core teams</li><li>AI copilots for real-time reactor operation</li></ul><h4>🎯 Takeaway</h4><p>This is the <strong>“brain layer”</strong> of fusion. It will be indispensable across the stack and can command high-margin licensing revenue.</p><h3>5. Material Science &amp; Fuel Innovation</h3><h4>💡 What’s happening?</h4><p>Fusion demands <strong>materials that have never existed before</strong>:</p><ul><li>First-wall materials that survive neutron bombardment</li><li>Coatings that reduce plasma erosion</li><li><strong>Solid-state tritium breeders</strong></li><li>Exotic fuels like <strong>proton–boron-11</strong> or <strong>helium-3 derivatives</strong></li></ul><p>Advances here can increase reactor lifetimes, reduce shielding, and improve efficiency.</p><h4>📈 VC Opportunity</h4><ul><li>New classes of alloys, ceramics, composites</li><li>Fuel processing and purification startups</li><li>Can often spin into <strong>space, aerospace, or fission markets</strong></li></ul><h4>💼 Business Models</h4><ul><li>IP licensing to reactor OEMs</li><li>Fuel-as-a-service (e.g., helium-3 capture, tritium generation systems)</li><li>Government contracts for defense-grade materials</li></ul><h4>🎯 Takeaway</h4><p>Every major energy transition has been matched by a <strong>materials revolution</strong>. Fusion is no exception.</p><h3>6. Balance-of-Plant Infrastructure</h3><h4>💡 What’s happening?</h4><p>Beyond the fusion core, reactors need:</p><ul><li><strong>Thermal-to-electrical conversion</strong> systems</li><li><strong>Cooling and shielding</strong> layers</li><li><strong>Power inverters, control software, and safety protocols</strong></li></ul><p>In some cases, especially for direct energy conversion, these systems are <strong>radically different</strong> from legacy fission or thermal plants.</p><h4>📈 VC Opportunity</h4><ul><li>Lower capital requirement</li><li>Can sell into fission, solar thermal, and aerospace too</li><li>Opportunity to “own the periphery” while the core race plays out</li></ul><h4>💼 Business Models</h4><ul><li>Full-stack reactor kits (including balance-of-plant)</li><li>Integration platforms for thermal, electric, and control layers</li><li>“Fusion in a box” companies that assemble end-to-end systems for specific sites</li></ul><h4>🎯 Takeaway</h4><p>This is a classic VC move: <strong>build the rails while others battle over the engine</strong>.</p><h3>7. Commercialization Models — Fusion-as-a-Service</h3><h4>💡 What’s happening?</h4><p>Instead of selling reactors, startups are starting to <strong>sell electricity</strong> directly to customers.</p><p>For example:</p><ul><li><strong>Helion’s contract with Microsoft</strong></li><li>Proposals to install fusion units in <strong>data centers, industrial zones, or islands</strong></li><li>Military interest in <strong>mobile reactors for off-grid operations</strong></li></ul><h4>📈 VC Opportunity</h4><ul><li>Fusion power as a <strong>clean, baseload microgrid</strong></li><li>Opens up revenue well before utility-scale deployment</li><li>Creates opportunities for <strong>project finance, infra tech, and energy-as-a-service models</strong></li></ul><h4>💼 Business Models</h4><ul><li>Long-term energy contracts</li><li>Leasing of modular fusion units</li><li>API-accessible power for AI workloads and data infrastructure</li></ul><h4>🎯 Takeaway</h4><p>This is where <strong>fusion gets paid</strong>. You don’t need to power a city. Powering a GPU cluster may be enough.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1017/1*VZT-AHbH8ReqSfTbcmFUnQ.png" /></figure><h3>Why This Matters Now</h3><p>None of this would have made sense ten years ago. The tools weren’t ready. The market wasn’t pulling. The investor ecosystem wasn’t interested.</p><p>Today, we have:</p><ul><li>Proven magnet breakthroughs (REBCO, HTS)</li><li>Powerful simulation tools and AI</li><li>A clear demand signal from industry (AI, defense, clean energy)</li><li>A shift from moonshots to <strong>buildable infrastructure</strong></li></ul><p>Fusion is no longer a winner-takes-all field. It is a <strong>platform opportunity</strong>. Just like rockets spawned SpaceX, Rocket Lab, satellite constellations, avionics startups, and launch pads, fusion will spawn its own ecosystem — made of parts, protocols, platforms, and power.</p><p>The returns won’t come from one miracle machine. They’ll come from the <strong>dozens of companies solving each piece of the puzzle</strong>.</p><h3>5. Conclusion — The New Frontier Is Being Assembled</h3><p>Nuclear fusion has long been the energy world’s most elusive prize. For decades, it sat just out of reach, trapped by scientific complexity and engineering limits. But that’s no longer true. As we’ve seen throughout this piece, fusion is now moving from theory to buildable reality.</p><p>We’ve explored how startups like <strong>Proxima</strong> and <strong>Marvel Fusion</strong> are approaching the same challenge from radically different angles — one with precision magnetics and continuous plasma, the other with lasers and compression bursts. We’ve broken down each stage of the fusion process to understand where things go right, where they fail, and where opportunity lies to do things differently.</p><p>We’ve also seen that fusion’s revival is not just about physics breakthroughs. It’s about <strong>engineering advancements</strong> in magnets, materials, lasers, and AI. It’s about <strong>new business models</strong> that make fusion deployable in modular, high-value contexts like data centers and off-grid industrial systems. And most importantly, it’s about the <strong>unbundling of the reactor itself</strong> — into an ecosystem of enabling technologies, components, and software.</p><p>This is what makes fusion a venture-backable field today. Not because a single startup might build the next sun on Earth, but because <strong>a whole stack of innovation is now in motion</strong>. There are opportunities for companies making magnets, modeling plasma, developing fusion fuels, building diagnostics, standardizing reactor parts, or integrating fusion power into customer workflows.</p><p>The takeaway is clear: <strong>fusion is no longer a waiting game</strong>. It’s an active, multi-dimensional platform shift. And as with every platform shift — from the internet to mobility to space — value flows to the people who understand both the underlying science and the emerging stack.</p><p>For venture capital, that moment is now. The market is forming. The companies are building. The science is finally usable. And the infrastructure layer of the future — dense, clean, reliable power — is up for grabs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*g2xApaWRgWcy2i-TEVAyrw.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c11a264a9f18" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Rethinking Power: Why AI Data Centers Need a New Kind of Energy System]]></title>
            <link>https://akhilvohra.medium.com/rethinking-power-why-ai-data-centers-need-a-new-kind-of-energy-system-8530f088b19f?source=rss-e5fbbe2da2f7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8530f088b19f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Akhil Vohra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 08 Jul 2025 15:07:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-31T14:52:40.401Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>As AI takes over the digital world, there’s an equally important transformation happening underneath it all, i.e. in the power systems that fuel data centers. The rise of AI isn’t just a software revolution; it’s an energy one too.</p><h3>The Shift: From Steady Loads to Instant Power Spikes</h3><p>In the past, data centers consumed electricity in relatively predictable ways. Power flowed steadily to servers and storage racks. Traditional batteries and energy storage systems were designed for this stable environment.</p><p>But AI workloads have changed the game entirely. GPUs, which power AI training and inference, consume energy in <strong>bursts</strong>. Their power demands are <strong>fast, cyclical, and unpredictable</strong>. It’s like switching from a gentle stream to a firehose that turns on and off every few milliseconds.</p><p>These bursts happen so quickly that traditional batteries and capacitors can’t keep up. They’re too slow to respond. The result? Voltage drops, power inefficiency, wasted cooling, and worst of all — <strong>performance throttling</strong> in high-value GPU systems.</p><h3>The Real Challenge: Microsecond Power Response</h3><p>Modern GPUs can shift from low to peak power draw in <strong>microseconds</strong> (millionths of a second). This is not an anomaly, it’s how AI workloads work now.</p><p>To respond to this, a power system must:</p><ul><li>React within microseconds</li><li>Deliver very high power instantly</li><li>Stay cool under pressure</li><li>Handle millions of charge/discharge cycles without wearing out</li></ul><p>That’s a tall order for traditional energy storage. But it’s exactly what <strong>supercapacitors</strong> are designed for.</p><h3>Batteries vs. Supercapacitors: A Quick Analogy</h3><p>Think of a <strong>battery</strong> like a deep water tank. It holds a lot, but it takes time to fill and empty. Batteries store energy chemically and gradually degrade with each cycle. They’re great for slow, sustained energy release, but not built for speed.</p><p>Now think of a <strong>supercapacitor</strong> like a high-pressure air hose. It doesn’t store as much energy, but it can blast power out <strong>instantly</strong>, and it can do this millions of times without wearing down.</p><p>In technical terms, a supercapacitor stores energy <strong>physically</strong>, using surface charges between two plates, which allows for lightning-fast discharge and recharge.</p><h3>Understanding ESR: The Hidden Friction</h3><p>One of the key specs in any capacitor system is <strong>ESR (Equivalent Series Resistance)</strong>. It measures internal resistance. The higher the ESR, the more energy is lost as <strong>heat</strong> every time current flows. It’s like friction inside a pipe.</p><p><strong>Formula</strong>:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/327/1*pvnrBsidhqK8Bbm0qSqahg.png" /></figure><p>Where ‘<em>I</em>’ is the current (in amps). So, at high currents like 100–300A (common in AI workloads), even a small ESR means big heat losses. This can cause overheating, performance throttling, and degraded system life.</p><p>Supercapacitors like Skeleton’s SCA0300 EVO are built with <strong>ultra-low ESR</strong>, which means they stay cool even under massive loads. For context, most supercapacitors degrade to 80% of their original capacity and double their ESR after <strong>1500 hours</strong> of stress. The SCA0300 EVO? It stays stable for over <strong>2500 hours</strong> under the same conditions.</p><p>To visualize how critical low ESR really is, consider the endurance test comparison from Skeleton Technologies’ <a href="https://1188159.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/1188159/Data_sheets/Brochures-whitepapers/WP-Supercapacitors-unlock-AI-data-centers-2506.pdf"><em>white paper</em></a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/475/1*Ac0guZr9O8ZABlpzedlgEg.png" /></figure><p>The chart above shows how the internal resistance (ESR) of Skeleton’s <strong>SCA0300 EVO</strong> supercapacitor compares to competitors under stress:</p><ul><li><strong>Test conditions</strong>: 2.85 V, 65°C over 2500 hours</li><li><strong>ESR measurement</strong>: 1-second ESR (short-duration pulse)</li><li><strong>EoL (End-of-Life) threshold</strong>: 200% of rated ESR (i.e., <strong>2 mΩ</strong>) and 80% of rated capacitance (264 F)</li></ul><p>Competitor cells begin breaching the EoL threshold just past <strong>1500 hours</strong>, with some exceeding 12 mΩ — 6× above nominal resistance. In contrast, the <strong>SCA0300 EVO maintains ESR well below 2 mΩ</strong> for the full 2500-hour test.</p><p>That level of stability under stress is what enables <strong>continuous, real-time peak shaving</strong> in GPU-heavy environments — without derating or forced cooldown.</p><h3>Capacitance and Aging</h3><p><strong>Capacitance</strong> refers to how much electric charge a capacitor can store. Over time, due to factors like heat and constant high voltage, this value can decrease. This is called <strong>aging</strong>.</p><p>Unlike batteries, which age from cycles, <strong>supercapacitors age mainly due to exposure to high voltage and temperature</strong> over time. So it’s not how often you use them, but how hot and “full” they are while sitting idle that causes them to degrade.</p><h3>Peak Shaving: Power Stability in Action</h3><p><strong>Peak shaving</strong> is the practice of using a local energy buffer (like a supercapacitor) to handle sudden power spikes instead of drawing from the grid. This keeps voltage stable, reduces electricity costs, and prevents hardware from being overloaded.</p><p>AI data centers deal with <strong>constant microbursts</strong> in power demand. Without peak shaving, these bursts would strain power supplies and lead to system instability.</p><h3>Form Factor &amp; ORV3 Compatibility: The Physical Constraint You Can’t Ignore</h3><p>One of the most overlooked but critical limitations in data center infrastructure is <strong>space</strong>. The industry standard rack unit is <strong>1U</strong>, which offers only <strong>33–35 mm of vertical clearance</strong>. Any energy storage component must fit into this size to be usable in current infrastructure.</p><p>Will this change? Not in the near term. Data centers are globally standardized. Changing the physical format would require a total rearchitecture of power, cooling, and rack design. So, innovations have to work <strong>within this constraint</strong>.</p><p>Skeleton’s D33-class cells are built specifically to <strong>fit this space</strong>, making them instantly compatible with modern server setups.</p><p>The PCS50 module is designed to comply with <strong>ORV3 (Open Rack V3) standards</strong>, which dominate hyperscale data center design. ORV3 racks are based on 48 VDC power distribution and fixed 1U (1.75”) unit height, giving designers just <strong>~33–35 mm of vertical space</strong> for any power module.</p><h3>Intelligent Delivery: Why the Power Module Matters</h3><p>The <strong>GrapheneGPU PCS50</strong> is more than a collection of supercapacitors. It’s a smart energy delivery system.</p><p>It takes <strong>live readings</strong> from:</p><ul><li>GPU current draw (to detect spikes)</li><li>Bus voltage (to maintain stability)</li><li>State of charge (to decide when to deploy power)</li><li>IShare signals from other power systems (to balance load across multiple units)</li></ul><p>These inputs feed into an onboard software controller called <strong>Adaptive Peak Shaver</strong>, which dynamically adjusts how much current the module contributes. It avoids overreacting, prevents unnecessary cycling, and keeps everything running at top performance.</p><h3>Why Batteries Alone Don’t Work Anymore</h3><p>Traditional batteries are too slow and degrade too quickly to handle the microsecond-level, high-frequency demands of GPU clusters. They generate heat, require cooldown cycles, and can’t discharge fast enough without damaging themselves.</p><p>In contrast, supercapacitors can discharge energy nearly instantly, handle <strong>millions of cycles</strong>, and generate almost no heat if designed properly. They’re not a replacement for batteries, but they fill a <strong>crucial gap</strong> in modern data center power architectures.</p><h3>Seeing the Future: Energy Must Match Compute</h3><p>Here’s the key VC insight:</p><blockquote><em>To understand tomorrow’s energy needs, you need to understand tomorrow’s compute.</em></blockquote><p>AI data centers are evolving fast:</p><ul><li>More distributed inference workloads</li><li>Shorter, denser power bursts</li><li>Edge compute environments with stricter space and thermal limits</li></ul><p>This is changing the <strong>entire shape of power demand</strong>. Energy systems can’t just be stable; they must be <strong>agile, smart, and form-factor aware</strong>.</p><p>Also, performance metrics like <strong>kW/kg</strong> (kilowatts per kilogram) are becoming more relevant than <strong>Wh/kg</strong> (watt-hours per kilogram) in burst-centric computing. Wh/kg tells you how much total energy a system can store per kilogram — useful for long-duration output, like keeping a laptop running for hours. In contrast, kW/kg tells you how much power it can release <em>immediately</em> per kilogram — critical for delivering split-second surges of electricity, like what AI GPUs demand.</p><p>Think of <strong>Wh/kg</strong> like the size of a fuel tank, and <strong>kW/kg</strong> like how quickly you can empty that tank through the engine.</p><p>Put another way: Wh/kg is endurance, while kW/kg is explosiveness. In the high-performance context of AI data centers, <strong>speed and repeatability of delivery</strong> matter more than sheer energy storage.</p><p>Supercapacitors shine here. They have high kW/kg performance, enabling them to respond to fast-changing loads without overheating or degrading. Batteries, though higher in Wh/kg, can’t deliver the same speed or survive the same cycle frequency — making them less suited to this emerging generation of AI-native energy needs.</p><p>Put simply: <strong>Wh/kg tells you how long a system can last</strong> (endurance), while <strong>kW/kg tells you how quickly it can respond</strong> (explosiveness). In the context of AI workloads, which demand split-second bursts of high current, kW/kg is far more critical.</p><p>Supercapacitors excel here because they can release power instantly, repeatedly, and safely — whereas batteries struggle to deliver the same speed without overheating or degrading quickly. It’s the difference between a marathon runner (Wh/kg) and a sprinter (kW/kg), and in AI data centers, speed is everything.</p><h3>Final Thought</h3><p>As AI continues to reshape every industry, the infrastructure that supports it must evolve too. Supercapacitor-based energy systems are no longer exotic. They are <strong>essential tools</strong> for delivering reliable, high-efficiency power in the age of AI.</p><p>For investors, the market is clear: The future of computing will be driven by systems that can adapt instantly, run hotter, perform longer, and deliver power at the speed of logic. Batteries alone can’t do that. Supercapacitor modules built for data centers can.</p><p>This is the energy system of tomorrow — built to meet the computational demands of today.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dzvYDwIwwd3mkkf2vCsuQA.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8530f088b19f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[NAVIGATING THE CLIMATE TECH VOYAGE]]></title>
            <link>https://akhilvohra.medium.com/navigating-the-climate-tech-voyage-77e9ea3406ed?source=rss-e5fbbe2da2f7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/77e9ea3406ed</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[funding]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ghg-emissions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climatetech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Akhil Vohra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Oct 2023 10:10:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-19T09:07:09.898Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>NAVIGATING THE CLIMATE TECH VOYAGE</strong></p><p>The climate tech sector in India is at the cusp of a significant breakthrough. As the globe grapples with escalating environmental challenges, the onus of fostering sustainable solutions has never been more paramount. The Indian subcontinent, with its burgeoning technological prowess and innovative spirit, is making strides towards carving a niche in the global climate tech arena. This discourse delves into the myriad facets of the climate tech industry, elucidating the potential, challenges, and the road ahead.</p><p>A pivotal sub-sector within the climate tech domain is Mobility &amp; Transport. Statistics reveal that it contributes to a little over 15% of global emissions, prompting an exigent need for green tech interventions. Over the past seven years, this sector has magnetized over 50% of all climate tech funding, emblematic of the colossal investment opportunity it beholds. The foray into electric vehicles (EVs), cleaner hybrid fuels, smart logistics, and shared mobility models are quintessential steps towards neutralizing emissions from this sector.</p><p>One of the innovations transforming the logistics landscape is the deployment of advanced data analysis tools to optimize supply chains. By using electric vehicles, and by dissecting delivery data, traffic patterns, and weather conditions, significant efficiency gains are being realized, thereby enhancing customer satisfaction and reducing operational costs. The aspiration to curtail delivery costs to less than INR 70 for short-distance deliveries stands as a testament to the industry’s commitment to cost-efficiency and environmental sustainability.</p><p>Delving into the realm of electric vehicles (EVs), the pivotal role of battery technology is undeniable. The transition to EVs necessitates batteries capable of storing substantial energy to ensure a viable replacement for fossil-fuel-powered engines, especially in heavy-duty vehicles like ships and airplanes. The data delineates a stark contrast between the energy yield of lithium batteries and gasoline. While the best lithium batteries can muster 2.5 megajoules of energy per kilogram, gasoline outstrips this by providing 20 times that amount. This gap underscores the imperative of accelerating battery technology advancements to achieve energy parity.</p><p>The challenge of high upfront costs, chiefly attributed to battery expenses, is a notable deterrent in EV adoption. However, the advent of battery swapping infrastructure is poised to alleviate this financial burden. By extricating the battery cost from the EV, the purchase price is brought on par with their fossil fuel counterparts. This innovative model also facilitates a more scalable charging network in urban areas, where real estate is at a premium.</p><p>The statistical data from the Bureau of Energy Efficiency (BEE) as of July 31, 2023, underscores the progress and the prevailing gaps in EV charging infrastructure. With 9,113 public EV charging stations operational, equipped with 15,493 EV chargers, the foundation for a robust charging network is being laid. Yet, the significant gaps, primarily concentrated in urban centers, necessitate a multi-pronged strategy encompassing both fixed charging and battery swapping solutions.</p><p>Autonomous Vehicles (AVs) represent a futuristic vista of the mobility sector. Their fate is intricately intertwined with EVs, as the duo is heralded as the harbinger of a revolution in public transportation. The synergy between AVs and EVs is envisaged to alleviate traffic congestion, thereby contributing to a reduction in emissions.</p><p>Venturing beyond mobility, the Food, Agriculture, and Associated Land Use sector emerges as another significant player in the global emissions narrative, contributing to over 20% of global emissions. The transformational willingness among consumers, food producers, and brands to endorse low-Greenhouse Gas (GHG) processes is fostering a conducive environment for innovations like smart farming, precision agriculture, and urban farming systems. These practices are pivotal in optimizing resource utilization while maintaining output levels. The burgeoning interest in plant-based and lab-grown meats, aimed at substituting animal products and thereby reducing GHG emissions from animal husbandry, is a promising trend.</p><p>The investment landscape in the climate tech sector unveils a dichotomy. While there is a substantial alignment of investment opportunities with what is beneficial for humanity, the funding drought, especially for early-stage startups, is a significant impediment. The structural maturity of the financial sector in India isn’t in question; however, the orientation of available funds towards large-scale enterprises and lucrative sectors like technology and retail is a challenge for climate tech startups.</p><p>These startups, embroiled in a longer gestation period, necessitate substantial funding to refine their prototypes and scale them to market-ready products and services. The journey through ideation, prototyping, testing, refining, and scaling is arduous and time-intensive, often requiring at least 1000 days to achieve a product-market fit and commence revenue generation. The dearth of funding to bridge the “valley of death” between basic research and commercialization is a significant roadblock.</p><p>The climate tech sector is a melange of various segments, including hardware, deep tech, EVs, and renewable energy. While founders with technical expertise in hardware and deep tech can manifest tangible products to investors, securing funding remains a formidable challenge, especially given the potential pivots and iterations inherent in the climate tech innovation cycle.</p><p>Solar energy, with its colossal potential, is a beacon of hope in the transition towards clean energy. Around 173 quadrillion watts of solar energy cascade onto the earth continuously, a quantum that is 10,000 times the global electricity requirement. The notion of harnessing just 1.2% of the Sahara Desert’s expanse for solar panels could potentially satiate the entire world’s electricity needs. However, the herculean challenge lies in the distribution and storage of this energy. Establishing a gargantuan solar farm in a singular location like the Sahara Desert would engender monumental distribution and maintenance challenges.</p><p>Moreover, the discourse around clean mining of lithium ores is critical in ensuring a sustainable supply chain for the burgeoning EV market. The mining processes need to be environmentally benign to uphold the essence of the green transition.</p><p>In reflection, the climate tech sector in India is a microcosm of hope, innovation, and challenges. The alignment of policy, investment, and technological innovation is quintessential to propel the nation towards a sustainable and carbon-neutral future. The narrative underscores the exigency of collaborative efforts among stakeholders, robust policy frameworks, and a conducive investment ecosystem to foster a climate-resilient future.</p><p>To close, following is a summary of the eight subsectors of climate tech:</p><p><strong>Eight Sub-Sectors Of Climate Tech:</strong></p><p><strong>Mobility &amp; Transport</strong></p><p>It is the biggest sub-sector, having received over 50% of all climate tech funding over the past seven years. It contributes to just over 15% of global emissions, the highest funding-to-emissions ratio across sectors.</p><p>Investing in transport systems, including electric vehicles, charging infrastructure, cleaner hybrid fuels, smart logistics and shared mobility models, represents a core part of neutralising emissions from this sector.</p><p><strong>Production, Transport &amp; Use Of Energy</strong></p><p>This contributes to over 12% of global emissions. While the advent of renewables due to technology advancement and declining costs has significantly contributed to mitigating emissions from this sector, investing in businesses that contribute to the rapid scaling and further adoption of these technologies will have a tangible impact.</p><p>We also see value in investing in solutions that help to commercialise fusion power and green hydrogen production.</p><p><strong>Food, Agriculture &amp; Associated Land Use</strong></p><p>This sector contributes to over 20% of global emissions and we are seeing a transformed willingness amongst consumers, food producers and brands to support low-GHG processes. This includes practices such as smart farming, precision agriculture and urban farming systems which utilise fewer resources (land and water) while maintaining output levels.</p><p>We have also witnessed a rise in plant-based and lab-grown meats that are ambitiously trying to replace animal products. Animal husbandry is a massive contributor to GHG emissions. Solutions extending the shelf life and reducing food waste are other areas to watch out for.</p><p><strong>Operations &amp; Construction Of Buildings &amp; Man-Made Surroundings</strong></p><p>This is the built environment, which contributes over 17% of global emissions and has been relatively overlooked in terms of investment, with the lowest funding-to-emissions ratio across sectors. Although the current scope is limited, smart building management, such as sensor-based low-GHG lighting and heating, will go a long way.</p><p>This is in addition to investing in smart solutions that reduce the ‘upfront’ carbon associated with material production and construction processes.</p><p><strong>Industry, Manufacturing &amp; Associated Resource Use</strong></p><p>This is by far the biggest contributor to global emissions, with over 34% of total emissions in 2019. This sector presents a big challenge.</p><p>There is a big need to upend the manufacturing infrastructure and related supply chain to make them more energy efficient and embed environment-friendly products in design/manufacturing.</p><p>This sector requires patient and long-term capital with longer-term payoffs. This includes investing in equipment and hardware that could deliver efficient use of resources, more efficient processes and improved energy efficiency.</p><p><strong>Software-Based &amp; Satellite-Aided Tools</strong></p><p>They often help with carbon accounting and understanding climate risk for private companies and governments to set, monitor and deliver on their net zero commitments. It covers tech companies building solutions in GHG performance management, risk mitigation, and GHG accounting and reporting.</p><p><strong>Fossil Fuels</strong></p><p>Fossil fuels are likely to remain a primary source of energy and a major contributor to global emissions for some time. Investment in technology solutions which help effectively capture, remove, store or reuse GHG from fossil fuels is going to have a great impact [on delivering the 1.5-degree target].</p><p>Companies like Aspen Technology, an industrial software company, have partnered with oil giants such as Aramco to help them optimise energy usage and model carbon capture, a good overlapping example for this sector and carbon accounting.</p><p><strong>Circular Economy</strong></p><p>Applicable across other sectors, it represents a different way of thinking about business models or product design that allows materials to stay in the system longer, the opposite of the linear economy we have built in the last century.</p><p>It covers companies that enable sharing, leasing, reusing, repairing and refurbishing of existing materials and products to minimise the loss of value of products, components and materials. Some examples are companies like Wardrobe (sharing), Close the Loop (reusing) and HylaMobile (refurbishing).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2PvB92Yz6k2LRimjBiWqtw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Source Used:<br><em>Inc 42</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=77e9ea3406ed" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mapping India’s Healthtech Landscape]]></title>
            <link>https://akhilvohra.medium.com/mapping-indias-healthtech-landscape-8a2c335539ad?source=rss-e5fbbe2da2f7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8a2c335539ad</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[healthtech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[venture-capital]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startupş]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Akhil Vohra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Oct 2023 08:25:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-10-08T11:02:38.776Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>The healthtech ecosystem in India is all set to grow, propelled by the expansion of the healthtech market size, expected to reach around US$ 5 billion this year. As of today, there are over 3,500 healthtech startups in India spanning from platforms helping to monitor health conditions, apps using AI to detect illnesses and diseases, platforms connecting patients with doctors, and much more.</p><p>The total funding in healthtech startups in $ Million has been as follows:</p><p><strong>2020:</strong> 929<br><strong>2021:</strong> 3760<br><strong>2022:</strong> 1550<br><strong>2023 (YTD)</strong>: 185</p><p>As you can see, the healthtech sector has not been immune to the recent slump in startup funding. That being said, a bounce-back is on the cards for the entire ecosystem, and I expect funding in healthtech to come back to a more reasonable amount going forward. My intention through this write-up is to study the existing players in the market. On the basis of their use cases, we will segment them into various categories, and then dive deeper into the nature of their solution. The purpose is also to provide a framework using which an investor can evaluate the space.</p><p><strong>The Data</strong></p><p>I have curated a list of 80 companies operating in India’s healthtech industry. This set comprises companies that have raised &gt;$20 million to date, <strong>or </strong>those that have raised a round of &gt;$5 million within the last two years. I have then categorised the companies into various segments and sub-segments. Finally, I have commented on whether these companies are driven by technology, or by clinically proven methods, or both. The following is the <a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1mlK46H84BxZg2-UCsPqu2zFBpiIG-Y7V0DMU64G8DCM/edit?usp=sharing">link</a> to the google sheet. In my opinion, it is fair to say that these 80 companies represent the set of companies that have attracted the maximum amount of funding. This set is well blended with a trend-based element — i.e. to look at companies that have raised significant (&gt;$5mn) capital within the last two years.</p><p>We know that most companies raise venture money while they are still a prospect in their target industry. They raise money on the basis of stories, and sometimes on the grounds of shaky business models. We also know that companies in this space have raised large sums of money, with sometimes having little to show for it. So while companies like Practo, Pristyn Care, and Pharmeasy may have raised significant capital, their capital efficiency can certainly be questioned (we talked about these three companies in my previous <a href="https://medium.com/@akhilvohra/the-3-ps-of-indian-healthtech-22e2b5c93e79">piece</a>). We need to learn from what might have gone wrong and right for these companies. On the basis of this, the funding information of other companies, and by studying their product/service offering, we will arrive at a framework with which to evaluate companies in this sector.</p><p>First, let me talk about the google sheet. It is sorted by total funding the company has raised and details their latest fundraise. The segments section is not designed to fit everything in a few buckets, but to depict the diversity and wide range of opportunity areas that are being touched in the healthcare domain. The subsegment then goes into the specificity of the business model. The remaining columns on technology and clinically driven methods add further color to the nature of the solutions. Finally, we mention whether the companies are B2B, B2C, or both. Let’s get into it.</p><p><strong>Integrated Healthcare Providers (IHPs)</strong></p><p>The total funding raised by these 80 companies in their lifespan stands at <strong>$5.9 billion. </strong>From this, <strong>$2 billion</strong> has been invested into companies that I call <strong>integrated healthcare providers</strong>. The likes of Pharmeasy, Practo, and Tata 1mg are a part of this list. It is a tempting prospect to house a number of solutions under one umbrella. But if we break down each offering (e-pharmacy, teleconsultation, diagnostics etc.) we come to the realisation that these solutions are neither grounded in technology nor do they rely on clinical evidence to deliver their services. Capital efficiency is also low. Pharmeasy has raised $1.1 Billion to date, yet is being valued at $500-$600 million as per their latest rights issue. This is a result of a loan that Pharmeasy took to acquire companies like Thyrocare to build out its full stack of services. Clearly, from a valuation standpoint, the acquisition strategy has backfired.</p><p>Practo had the early mover advantage, both in B2B and B2C. On the B2B front, the quality and utility of the product were questionable, and doctors did not find a reason to continue using the product. On all the other fronts, Practo faces competition from players focusing on a single vertical. This has stalled the company’s growth. <strong>Medibuddy </strong>is another example company — 60% of whose revenue comes from corporate clients. However, MediBuddy hasn’t been receiving timely payments from its B2B clients, “Only about 30% of the clients pay on time”, said former employees. Further, on the B2C front, a quick glance at consumer forums reveals a litany of issues related to service delivery — from phlebotomists not showing up for at-home appointments to medicines not being delivered or taking months to reach customers.</p><p>The following is an image that ranks companies on the basis of app download and usage penetration:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*B5nJHGOb7GXlupjZ" /></figure><p>Not only does the above graphic depict Medibuddy’s position in the grander scheme of things — but it also shows that the companies above it are players with deep pockets, or those that have corporate backing. From Tata owned 1mg, to Reliance owned Netmeds, to Apollo, deep discounting and heavy spending on marketing is the way to go about for these companies. One would require superior financial muscle to compete with these giants in the integrated healthcare provider turf. Additionally, these are operationally intensive businesses with technology playing a minimal role, and the clinical aspect is offered by the various supply-side partners while doing their job, and is not something that is ingrained in the company’s ethos. For all practical purposes, these companies have aggregated together services that happen to be in the healthtech domain — but the companies themselves don’t scream healthcare or healthtech. This means differentiation is hard to come by, and the company will have to spend massively to capture even a small share of the pie. Thus, as an investor, I would stay away from this domain.</p><p>One unique company in the list of IHPs from my data set is <strong>Nirog Street</strong>. The company has a full stack solution, providing medicines and consults with doctors, but in the domain of Ayurveda. They work closely with the Ministry of <strong>AYUSH</strong>, regulators, and research organizations. They encourage doctors to create and publish case studies and research reports so as to bring in evidence-based treatment similar to modern medicine. As funding for AYUSH related projects by the government ramps up, and there being a constant sense of skepticism around the efficacy of such methods, it will be fascinating to see how the company’s trajectory pans out.</p><p>In my opinion, this is a space that is bound to grow with the current government a staunch believer in alternative forms of medicine. Further, it cannot be denied that clinical doctors in India bash each other and don’t indulge in talking and two-way conversations with their patients. This is perhaps unavoidable owing to the number of patients they have to deal with. Ayush doctors, however, don’t get violent with each other. They do this so that their practices (which are not rooted in science) are not questioned. Government support, along with such tactics helps the community and the practice to survive. Thus, it seems like a lucrative space from an investment perspective, but the lack of scientific underpinning throws up a moral quagmire that investors will have to deal with before investing.</p><p><strong>Healthcare SaaS</strong></p><p>A total of <strong>$770 million</strong> has been raised by healthtech SaaS companies in my dataset. Let’s first look at the two largest funded companies in this segment — <strong>Innovaccer </strong>and <strong>Indegene</strong>. Innovaccer offers unified healthcare data and analytics for patient-centric care, a developer portal, population health management, and market intelligence tools, amongst other things. Indegene offers commercialisation services to companies in the biotech and medical devices space using their digital first technology stack. Both companies serve overseas markets, but have been born out of India. Our two primary healthcare providers — clinics and hospitals are not technology friendly. They don’t even use ERPs or CRMs to manage processes or engage with customers. Electronic health records have not yet become a norm — the way it is in European and US markets. On the whole, this means that Healthcare SaaS has a very small market in India — since no one is willing to adopt or pay. The primary market for such players lies overseas. Inherently, these two companies are technology first, and try to drive home clinically sound outcomes.</p><p>However, there is another set of companies in the Healthcare SaaS space that excite me — those that target specific verticals within healthcare, such as oncology, cardiovascular, radiology, diabetes etc. The advantage of such companies is that they are operating in a specific vertical that is actually a kind of niche, but quite large in terms of market size. Further, the longer they are in the market, the better their AI models can be trained based on real-life data and images. This helps them solidify and improve the quality and accuracy of their outcomes. Companies like Innovaccer and Indegene do produce clinically sound outcomes, but they are more “enterprise tech” and less healthtech. On the other hand, companies like <strong>Tricog </strong>(Cardiovascular), <strong>Karkinos </strong>(Oncology), <strong>Qure</strong>.<strong>ai</strong>, and <strong>Deeptek </strong>(Radiology). produce clinical insights, using data that they have collected over years of treating patients. This gives them a competitive advantage and acts as a moat. It is such Healthcare SaaS companies where I would recommend investing, i.e. less enterprise tech and more clinically rigorous companies.</p><p>There is a final set of companies in the Healthcare SaaS domain that are technology first but have little to go by clinical expertise. Some examples are <strong>Healthplix </strong>(Electronic medical records), <strong>Fold.health</strong> (enterprise tech) and <strong>Coverself</strong>(Payments). While these companies are solving relevant problems, there is little barrier to entry in their respective domains, and I would thus suggest not investing in such companies i.e. those that are not using or providing clinical expertise.</p><p><strong>Supply Chain and Logistics</strong></p><p>The dataset has just three companies in the supply chain and logistics space, and between them, they have raised <strong>$510 million</strong>. Two of them — <strong>Ascent Wellness and Pharma Solutions</strong> (raised $295 mn), and <strong>Aknamed </strong>(raised $21 mn) have both been acquired by Pharmeasy in order to build out its B2B distribution stack. The third company is <strong>Medikabazaar </strong>(raised $194 mn) whose marketplace boasts an extensive catalog of medical supplies and equipment, catering to diverse needs across various medical specialties. These companies have brought in a breath of operational efficiency and cohesiveness that erstwhile distributors were unable to offer. While technology is not at the heart of their offering, they have brought in a layer of digitisation and aggregation in an industry that has always been fragmented. They have taken a complex value chain and by aggregating everything under one roof, made life easier for medical institutions. Personally, I am bullish on the medical supply chain domain given the complex nature of the value chain. This can range from transporting blood vials, to vaccines, to organs, and to other products that require a cold chain infrastructure. Currently, companies have scaled up on the back of simply aggregating and digitizing, on the front of pharmaceuticals, hospital supplies, and medical equipment. I am generally more keen on companies solving difficult problems in a unique way. For example, drone-based deliveries to remote parts of the country are becoming more common. The story of the larger players shows that this is a viable business model in the healthtech segment — now it is up to investors to find companies that are solving for various niches within the broader supply chain domain.</p><p><strong>E-Commerce</strong></p><p>E-commerce companies in my list have raised a total of <strong>$490 million</strong>. Marquee company Healthkart has raised a total of $224 million. It is part of the many entities and brands housed under Bright Lifecare private limited. Then there is Reliance owned Netmeds which has chosen to be a full-stack e-commerce player. This is in contrast to other large business houses like Tata and Apollo that have gone down the integrated healthcare provider path. There is also <strong>Sasta Sundar</strong> which was founded in 2011, and is today a marketplace for all things that can be considered as consumables under the healthcare domain. The company raised $48 million in capital to date, before getting acquired by Flipkart and being rebranded as Flipkart Healthplus.</p><p>As India’s GDP continues to grow at 6%+, disposable incomes go up, and the India growth story continues to play out, the number of e-commerce buyers is increasing at a healthy rate. We have already seen that large conglomerates want a piece of the Indian healthtech pie. Flipkart acquiring Sasta Sundar is a classic example of a large entity buying its way into the healthcare e-commerce segment. As buying power goes up, I predict that even more niche markets will have a relatively larger market size. Some companies operating in such niche markets are <strong>Mojocare </strong>(Online platform for health conditions related to hair, weight, and sex), <strong>Healofy </strong>(sells products basis the stage of pregnancy), <strong>Gynoveda </strong>(Provider of dietary supplements &amp; ayurveda solutions focused on women’s health). Companies like <strong>Kapiva </strong>not only sell ayurvedic products but also provide online consultation services with healthcare experts for users to receive prescribed healthcare products. Healofy, apart from selling products, is a social platform for pregnancy and parenting in vernacular languages. A lot of interesting work happening in this space. If any of these companies scale up, there is a good chance of them getting acquired by a large entity — just like the Flipkart and Sasta Sundar deal. Imagine an Amazon or an Adani wanting to enter. But, a lot of the success for these companies is contingent on the total market size increasing over time, and these players growing into those expanding markets. Value-added services on top of selling consumables can be a big plus if done correctly. But, it is more a play of operations and sales and marketing, than it is of technology or clinical prowess. A venture capitalist should be able to see a large SOM (Serviceable obtainable market) prior to making an investment in any of the niches.</p><p><strong>Personalised Healthcare</strong></p><p>This segment has raised $474 million within the dataset. Such companies amalgamate a product with a service in order to deliver a high-quality experience for a specific problem to customers. This is a vast segment by its very nature, and companies can pick up a specific niche and make large businesses out of it. While almost all of these companies have clinical knowledge on the basis of which they provide treatment, not all of these companies are technology first. Many of them are simply digital assistants helping you solve your problems. Some technology-led companies are as follows: <strong>Wysa </strong>(Provider of an AI-based chatbot for managing mental health), <strong>Cureskin </strong>(AI-driven skin and hair care), while some non-tech first solutions are companies like <strong>Healthifyme </strong>(meal plans personalized by expert nutritionists and customized workout plans for individuals), <strong>Portea </strong>(Provides quality medical care at the comfort of your home), <strong>MakeO </strong>(Aligners, oral care products, Teeth whitening, aligner essentials, laser hair reduction, skincare products), <strong>BeatO </strong>(Provider of a platform for diabetes management) etc.</p><p>As you can see, the solutions range from mental health, to dental, to meal plans, hair care, skin care, diabetes management, home healthcare and many more. One could pick up virtually any segment, like eyecare, sexual wellness, gut health, parkinsons, dementia, thyroid or any branch of medicine such as Neurology, endocrinology, cardiovascular, ENT, urology, etc., and try to build a business out of it. There is also a B2B element to this offered by a company called Hester Biosciences which is a manufacturer of animal vaccines and healthcare products. It also offers services such as sero profiling for poultry flocks and mastitis control programs for cattle. So the boundaries for personalised healthcare go beyond human beings.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>What is common among Healthcare SaaS, Supply Chain and Logistics, E-commerce, and Personalised Healthcare is (a) first mover advantage, as can be seen by companies like Healthkart, Ascent Pharma, Medikabazaar, Innovaccer, etc. These companies have reaped the benefits of targeting the largest of markets and being one of the first ones to do so. (b) We are now seeing specificity in the business models of companies that are targeting certain organs/body parts, or certain branches of medicines, selling certain products with specific benefits, or disrupting existing value chains. It’s now time for companies to make a first move in more niche markets that have a large market size (like diabetes, oncology etc.)</p><p>My personal recommendation is for investors to stay away from categories like IHP, wherein a company is simply aggregating services without any clinical underpinning. This is a market that requires deep pockets. Investors should target companies within the other segments that are solving a niche problem but also have a large market size. This solution should be backed by clinical research. So, if it is a diabetes management platform then the product should be backed by sound research regarding how to tackle and deal with diabetes. Similarly for segments ranging from oncology to eyecare; solutions driven by clinical research are a must. However, in my opinion, a technology-first solution is not a must, since India’s healthcare market has not shown great adoption for such solutions, and non-technology driven companies have also done well. That being said, technology-driven solutions inherently scale up faster, and such companies will also be able to target overseas markets. So it is a good to have quality when building in this space, but not a must to have.</p><p>The purpose of detailing the segments above was to understand their nuances and to apply our analytical lens to what works and what does not. As per me the following works:</p><ul><li>companies that target large and niche markets</li><li>specialise in the clinical aspects of that market</li><li>and are technology first (non-technology can work if the market is unique, large enough, and untapped)</li></ul><p>The second purpose of this exercise was to segment companies into various categories for further analysis. Each segments has its nuances and is a niche of its own in India’s burgeoning healthcare market. I have only listed out 5 of the largest segments (by funding). I would urge you to go through the <a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1mlK46H84BxZg2-UCsPqu2zFBpiIG-Y7V0DMU64G8DCM/edit?usp=sharing">google sheet</a> and have a look at the rest of the segments, and their respective companies. I hope this framework serves you as a tool to evaluate India’s healthtech companies.</p><p>In case any reader would like to discuss this piece with me, feel free to write to me at akhil.vohra1897@gmail.com, or message me on my <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/akhil-vohra-9972b8101/">LinkedIn</a>. Anyone who wants to discuss the healthtech space, or any other space that is relevant in the world of a venture capitalist, can also reach out to me.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aboNS95aUALa6S_xullxiQ.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8a2c335539ad" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The 3 P’s of Indian Healthtech]]></title>
            <link>https://akhilvohra.medium.com/the-3-ps-of-indian-healthtech-22e2b5c93e79?source=rss-e5fbbe2da2f7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/22e2b5c93e79</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fundraising]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startupş]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthtech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[venture-capital]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Akhil Vohra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 Sep 2023 12:28:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-29T07:30:10.813Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The 3P’s</strong></p><p>In the burgeoning realm of India’s healthtech sector, three companies — Practo, Pristyn Care, and PharmEasy — stand out in terms of fundraising, scale, and popularity, each delineating a unique blueprint of growth and challenges, while collectively shaping the future of healthcare in the country.</p><p><strong>Practo:</strong> Over a decade ago, the healthtech horizon shimmered with promise as Practo emerged, aiming to reinvent the doctor-patient dynamic with its pioneering discovery platform. This innovation was more than just digital — it was a shift in healthcare accessibility. However, this moonshot project soon confronted terrestrial realities.</p><p>While Practo claims to have 120,000 doctors registered on its platform, with whom it offers instant video consultation, quality is a concern. “It was easy to find 200 doctors with less than two years of experience in under three months,” said a former senior executive with the company. “Would you trust your child to be treated by a doctor with one or two years of experience?” Demand for telemedicine has also slowed down. “At the peak of Covid, Practo was doing 25,000 tele-consults a day, but that crashed to around 3,000 as the wave receded. The abrupt increase in demand gave investors and professionals in the field a false signal — that aggregate demand has gone up and it will stay the same way for the foreseeable future. This is what drove a slew of startups to set up shop and offer teleconsultations amongst other things. <strong>19 </strong>new teleconsulting companies were set up between 2016 to 2022.</p><p>A large part of Practo’s woes can be attributed to its core value proposition and business model. Despite its protestations that it was a healthcare startup, at its heart, Practo was a two-sided marketplace. On one hand, it allowed consumers to search for doctors in their area and book consultations, and on the other hand, it allowed doctors to be discovered and get incremental bookings and revenue. Practo’s business model, however, was only on one side — charging doctors a monthly fee for providing them with a platform to manage their schedules and appointments (Practo Ray). Charging Indian businesses for software is a challenge at the best of times, it was doubly difficult for Practo given its target customer persona of doctors in small clinics. Additionally, while doctors could use the product for discovery and sourcing new customers, they had no incentive to use it for any further engagement.</p><p>It was a pain using Ray (practo’s B2B software product) for the two years (2014–16) that I used it in my clinic. Simple day-to-day features were missing,” says Raghab Panda, co-founder of Santan Fertility Centre and Research Institute in Bhubaneswar, Odisha.“If there’s pharma booking in the module, the software should know its life cycle, billing to refund to return stock inventory. Clearly, the modules were made by people who did not understand the domain, the clinical practice,” says Panda. This is a fundamental problem wherein doctors are not engaging with entrepreneurs and technologists (such as those innovating in the realm of AI). This results in apps, products, and full companies designed, built and run by individuals who are not doctors and have close to no experience in the healthcare domain. This is why Practo Ray never picked up. It was made from a business lens and missed the clinical element. So the B2B effort was a tame one — not driven by analytics or clinical knowledge, and thus not serving doctors very well. On the B2C front, you cannot charge customers because there are many other platforms competing that will not charge a commission. So customers would simply flock to those. The company has also branched out into elective surgeries. Further showcasing their agility, yet this new domain presented its unique challenges, most notably competition from agile startups.</p><p>Thus, despite 13 years of relentless efforts, and vying to become a one-stop shop for all things healthcare (let’s call companies like Practo <em>integrated healthcare providers — IHPs</em>), the golden fleece of steady profitability still remains out of reach. The company has raised a total of <strong>$251 Million</strong> to date. Its revenue for the FY ending 2021–2022 was <strong>$432,000</strong>; up from<strong> $231,852</strong> the previous year. A paltry sum of dollars in lieu of the total funds that the company has raised. Moreover, as seen in other sectors where companies like Zomato in food tech have fine-tuned existing processes, Practo’s challenge remains multifaceted. While discovery is its forte, maintaining engagement post-discovery is a hurdle. Much like restaurants depend on Zomato for not just visibility but also logistics, Practo needs an essential, value-added proposition to entrench itself further into the healthcare journey of its users. <br> <br>Yet, it won’t be an exaggeration to say every health-tech company worth any ‘h’ or ‘t’ wants to create a platform like Practo — aggregate services, list docs, sell medicines, diagnostics, consumer wearables, and publish content. And they want to do this by burning less cash than Practo, which perhaps had the first-mover disadvantage. The math just does not add up. Providing an integrated health platform requires you to have deep pockets because you are up against the likes of TATA owned 1mg and Relicane’s telemedicine arm Netmeds. This is why such IHPs try to sell to corporates. This serves them well since they have a chance to work with a client to provide a holistic healthcare service — while playing in the corporate space which is driven more by service quality, payment terms etc. rather than just brand value. Even here though there is significant competition from the number of new and budding IHPs that have not only popped up, but also raised money.</p><p>So, while Practo has been trying to offer integrated services where it faces competition, it now also faces additional competition on each front individually, from specialised players. This has only added, and contributed to their woes and inability to grow revenue numbers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/0*iwArUVM9mdJIVnyz" /></figure><p>The fall in the company’s value has very much been recognised on paper as well. While once it was valued at $659 million in 2016, it later went on to raise a round at a post-money valuation of $335 million in 2020.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/0*J1rxNwzPOjm4qLv2" /></figure><p><strong>Pristyn Care:</strong> Veering onto a distinctive path, Pristyn Care zeroed in on the surgical landscape of healthtech. Their astronomical surge, moving from 600–800 to 4,000–5,000 surgeries monthly (from 2020 to 2021) in just a year, is both commendable and indicative of their strategic prowess. Surgeries involve high-ticket transactions that have additional gains in post-operative care. Which is why Pristyn Care sits somewhat high among its peers.</p><p>Pristyn’s <strong>5X growth in 12 months</strong> may seem unreal to many, but its competitors don’t find it unusual.<strong>“4,000 surgeries is hardly 0.25% of the total elective surgeries happening in the country</strong>; so this number is not outlandish,” says Preet Pal Thakur, founder of Delhi-based surgery startup Glamyo. He believes the market is considerable and ready for disruption akin to what ride-hailing companies Ola and Uber did to the unorganised taxi industry.</p><p>The company has raised $181 Million in funding to date. As of its latest funding round in December 2021, it is valued at $1.4 Billion. In 2018–19 the company closed at INR 3.72 crore in revenue, then reached INR 28.5 crore the next year, and closed 2020–21 at INR 100 crore with 63.1 crores in net losses. However, this last revenue figure of INR 100 crore should be taken with a pinch of salt. To service patients, Pristyn Care works with a mix of independent doctors and doctors on its payrolls; it also has tie-ups with hospitals across cities, which it needs for the actual infrastructure to perform surgeries. The hospitals are the ones that actually bill the patients, and they keep a cut (<strong>about 30–40% of the fees collected</strong>) as part of the deal with Pristyn. However, the startup recognizes the entire payout from the patient as its own revenue and treats the hospital’s commission as an expense item. This is complicated and also a little concerning. Prior to the 2020–21 fiscal year, Pristyn Care used to record only the share of surgery fees it received from hospitals as revenue. This was straightforward enough. But in its 2020–21 financial statements, it declares that it has moved to the new revenue recognition approach.</p><p>Apart from having deep-pocketed investors, what makes it easier for Pristyn to scale is the <strong>full-time surgeon model</strong> that it has adopted. Unlike Medfin and Practo, which work with consultants on an outsourced model, and Glamyo, which relies on outsourced part-time consultants, Pristyn has 300-plus surgeons on its payrolls.</p><p>Doctors are to Pristyn Care what beauticians, plumbers and carpenters are to Urban Company. Many of the doctors that Pristyn Care employs are young. The median age is around 35 years. Most of these doctors are on Pristyn Care to make a name before they set out on their own. There is a hunger to earn money in them. And the energy to do multiple surgeries.</p><p>Since it has to pay salary, Pristyn tries to optimise on cost, hiring younger and less experienced surgeons. Surgeons with 5–10 years of experience come at Rs 3–4 lakh ($4,000–5,344) monthly salary, but if you want to have a full-blown team of doctors with an average salary of Rs 1.5 — Rs 2 lakh ($2,000–2,672), you <strong>over-index on younger surgeons</strong>. Which at scale, reflects on clinical outcomes.</p><p>This is why Medfin is content being in just three cities at present. “We will <strong>only work with senior surgeons</strong> even if it’s a lot more challenging. On a scale of 1–10 [in having experienced surgeons], I’d rather be at 5–6 than 0–1,” says Medfin CEO Arjun Kumar. Even though this means smaller margins, he’d rather not have medical outcomes as a headache. “We want to build a sustainable business,” says Kumar.</p><p>On these fronts, Pristyn hasn’t been exemplary. Consumer forums are rife with customer complaints and quibbles. Business development managers (BDM), the linchpin of its growth, have unrelenting targets. On average, a BDM, has a target of converting at least 20 patient leads into surgeries every month. To manage this, they field around 350–400 calls. Of Pristyn’s 1,800–2,000 employees, around 1,000 are on the business development side.</p><p>Lately, it seems the core business hasn’t been showing any signs of health. According to five former employees, the surgery numbers for Pristyn Care have stopped growing. Almost every month, the company is clocking nearly the same number it was recording a year ago. Moreover, the value per surgery has also declined.</p><p>The customer acquisition cost in this business is anyway very, very high. And now, there are different competitors. There is Glamyo Health (launched in 2020), HexaHealth (founded in 2021) and Practo (ventured into surgeries in 2021). The online consultation arm of Apollo Hospitals is another rival.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/1*kNBb07am2x5FNu1SK-ypfg.png" /></figure><p><strong>PharmEasy</strong>: Pharmeasy has a tight hold on nearly 50% of the online-pharmacy gross merchandise value (GMV) in the country, with Tata 1mg and Netmeds following with a 16% and 15% share respectively. Yet, behind this facade, the path is strewn with obstacles. The ambitions of its B2B initiatives, aiming to consolidate India’s historically fragmented pharma distribution, are yet to fully bear fruit. Their acquisitions, particularly of Thyrocare, bring both opportunities and intricate valuation dilemmas. With competitors like Metropolis and Dr Lal PathLabs redefining their online diagnostic strategies, PharmEasy’s advantage via Thyrocare stands challenged. Moreover, the relentless pursuit of differentiation in a saturated market, coupled with the imperative of cost-effective service delivery, are pressing concerns. Yet, their vision remains vast — from being a dominant player in online pharmacy to establishing an integrated healthcare platform, encompassing diagnostics, teleconsultation, and more.</p><p>Currently, they boast the following numbers with the online pharmacy business accounting for 93.1% of the operating revenues.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*GzbWBiNeYNI2bo9v.jpg" /></figure><p>That being said, the company has made a number of acquisitions in its lifespan to grow and expand into other categories.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2o84bmoGzx_apJdF" /></figure><p>But while the business is scaling up, its valuation has nonetheless taken a hit. The company announced that it will raise around Rs 2,400 crore through a rights issue to pay off a loan from Goldman Sachs, according to a report in The Economic Times. The company is expected to be valued at $500–600 million, a 90% markdown from its last valuation, when it filed its draft prospectus for an IPO in November 2021 (the plan was later deferred). Such a sharp valuation cut, especially for a startup backed by marquee investors, is not all that common.</p><p>The reason for this could be as follows — while API Holdings — PharmEasy’s parent company bought Thyrocare at a valuation of about Rs 7,000 crore, the diagnostic firm’s market capitalization today is less than Rs 3,000 crore. While in 2021–22 it posted record numbers because of a pandemic-triggered surge in demand for diagnostic services, its revenue and profits took a hit the following fiscal. Yet, Thyrocare is the best business in PharmEasy’s portfolio, which includes retail and B2B sales of pharmaceuticals, doctor consultations, and diagnostic services. Only Thyrocare made a profit; in 2020–21, it clocked Rs 152 crore. In the same year, API Holdings, PharmEasy’s parent, recorded operational losses of Rs 3,992 crore and posted a net loss of Rs 2,731 crore.</p><p>Another reason is that the company is trying to pull off being an integrated health provider, which we already saw with Practo does not seem to work out. Many in the industry are scratching their heads trying to figure out how PharmEasy will pull off being an integrated health provider by just ‘buying’ different pieces of the value chain with no serious effort to build out the integrating infrastructure. And for a business of a limited nature — pharma distribution, to be precise — that doesn’t have the full gains of a corporate development arm, pulling off both ‘buy’ and ‘build’ at the same time is nearly impossible.</p><p>This buying has been financed by $1.1 Billion in funding the company has raised to date. Perhaps the investors in PharmEasy and others are approaching this like they approached other horizontal (Flipkart) and vertical (education, food delivery) e-commerce segments, says Buggana of InvAscent. “That is, it is a land grab, and when it is over, the last one standing is determined by scale and not profitability. Profits can always follow.”</p><p><strong>WHAT CAN WE LEARN</strong></p><p><strong>Practo:</strong></p><p>Practo as a company wanted to become a full stack player — housing a number of services under one roof. However, they messed up on their approach<strong>.</strong> To build out the additional capabilities they made a number of acquisitions. This included Insta health — a hospital management tool, Qikwell — doctor appointment booking, Genii — ERP solutions for diagnostics, FitHo — preventive and wellness solutions, and Enlightiks — for data analytics.</p><p>These various machines did not turn into one cohesive well-oiled unit. There were several operational inefficiencies. “To provide speed to each product, each team avoided depending on other teams. If one vertical needed a doctor database, they built something themselves. At some point, there were 5–6 doctor databases that each of the products were using. We couldn’t make the products talk to each other and worked in silos,” says an ex-product manager.</p><p>The company could have slowly built out its diverse product verticals, one at a time. It could have relied on a combination of building and buying to see out its strategies. It should not have recklessly spent funds such as the crores spent to onboard salons and gyms on the platform alongside doctors, who revolted at being reviewed alongside gyms. It should have onboarded employees with clinical and medicinal knowledge and use them to create products by understanding the psyche of doctors and patients. It should have set an example of how to be a successful IHP for the newer companies popping up. Instead, operational issues alongside poor decision-making on strategy cost them. Today, while the company is still operational, it has not been able to command the status of a market leader, but it is just another player. Additionally, it has burnt $250 million in accomplishing this minor feat.</p><p><strong>Pristyn Care:</strong></p><p>A jack of many trades, Practo brings its healthcare experience and quality-conscious approach as it expands to elective surgeries; Pristyn, on the other hand, is focused on adding numbers. It doesn’t matter if many of the latter’s surgeries are low-ticket items like abscess removal and circumcisions, which do not justify the high customer acquisition cost or the ‘surgery’ tag.</p><p>To put very simply, Pristyn focuses on quantity over quality, which is a very risky game to play in the healthcare market. The two foundational pillars of Pristyn Care’s business are its sales agents and the doctors that the company employs. The agent is central to the whole ecosystem. Chances are that if a patient goes for the surgery, 80% of that responsibility lies with the agent. Agents work on targets. Of all the leads that an agent receives in a month, about 30–35% need to find their way to Pristyn doctors. At least 5% of the total need to end in surgeries. This means that of every 100 patient leads, 30–35 meet the doctors and around 5 go for surgeries. That is what an agent needs to ensure, as a bare minimum. But what if not even 5 of those 100 patients required surgery? This is a very fundamental question that grounds the success and moral stance of this entire business.</p><p>These agents also control the flow of information, to a large extent, between the patients and doctors. Agents are the point person of patients. Obfuscation of information becomes easy if the focus is on targets or even, by simple human error. There could be something in the patient history, an allergy, high blood pressure, or low hemoglobin. Agents aren’t equipped to understand these things. Other surgery startups like Medfin have thus taken a more measured approach. I would think the smart money would back a startup taking the more conservative approach — since they have a more sustainable business model.There is a byju-esque feel to Pristyn’s aggressive approach — one they are playing in order to justify and maintain their $1.4 billion valuation.</p><p>Healthtech companies in India need to learn that the same brazen and aggresive approach that works to scale in e-commerce, fintech, and even ed-tech businesses, should not be applied to the healthcare segment. Pristyn appointing a young and inexperienced doctor leading to a botched surgery has far-reaching consequences, one that doesn’t exist in other domains. This is not a segment where excellence is only expected of the top 10% of the market — it is one where it is the bare minimum.</p><p><strong>Pharmeasy:</strong></p><p><strong>E-commerce in India requires deep pockets.</strong> This is because whichever vertical you look at, large companies like Amazon, or domestic players like Tata or Reliance want a piece of the pie. They want it because it is a massive pie, and because they have the ability to raise and supply enough capital to provide a service to the masses in a manner that is inexpensive. The case is no different for pharmaceuticals. While it&#39;s commendable that Pharmeasy accounts for half the GMV in the e-pharmacy market, they are up against the likes of Tata 1Mg and Reliance-backed Netmeds — both of whom have deep enough pockets to overspend on marketing. This significantly increases the customer acquisition and customer retention cost for Pharmeasy.</p><p>The company followed the same acquisition path as Practo and has ended up in a similar predicament — only here the sums involved are much more. Pharmeasy has raised 4 times the money Practo has. In mid 2019, Pharmeasy, which also dabbled in distribution through its retail pharmacy business, merged with Ascent Health and Wellness, a pure-play pharmaceutical distribution company. A few months later, in November, Pharmeasy raised $220 million. The dominant narrative was of an e-pharmacy. When the startup raised its next round of $350 million in April 2021, the narrative shifted from e-pharmacy to integrated health. Soon, it bought fellow e-pharmacy startup Medlife, and Thyrocare at a scarcity premium of 40X EV/Ebitda. The narrative for Pharmeasy keeps on changing as they raise more money and acquire more businesses. The company’s goalposts constantly shift alongside the latest fads in the market. Their purchase of Thyrocare at a high price during the pandemic shows just how much they get sucked in by the latest fad, and how little foresight they had about the diagnostics business in a post-pandemic world.</p><p>A company that was sitting on a valuation of $5.6 billion is now raising a fresh round at a 90% discount, in order to pay back a loan that funded their pricey acquisition spree. Let’s hope things don’t go further south from here.</p><p>There is one additional metric at which these 3 companies fail — u<strong>sage of technology: </strong>The three companies are focused on providing mass-market solutions. These solutions are dependent more on the ability to operationally execute, rather than developing a technology that becomes the core offering/service. Technology is not at the heart of these businesses’ models. One could argue how much technology even adds value to these spaces. Alternatively, one could farm and hunt for companies whose solutions are grounded in technology. For this, the problem should be such that it is better solved by technology, or where technology can drive better operational and clinical outcomes than doing it manually. Keep a lookout for further write-ups where I will discuss what some of these technology solutions in healthtech space look like. This will enable us to further understand the broader market, and enable venture capitalists to make an informed investment decision.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XLZ_rqNoJ5ZpzE74qTeMqw.jpeg" /></figure><p>In case any reader would like to discuss this piece with me, feel free to write to me at akhil.vohra1897@gmail.com, or message me on my <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/akhil-vohra-9972b8101/">LinkedIn</a>. Anyone who wants to discuss the healthtech space, or any other space that is relevant in the world of a venture capitalist, can also reach out to me.</p><p>The following sources have been used in curating this article:</p><p><em>Mint<br>Economic Times<br>The Morning Context<br>The Ken<br>Tracxn Database</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=22e2b5c93e79" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Tale of Containerised Freight Rates]]></title>
            <link>https://akhilvohra.medium.com/the-tale-of-containerised-freight-rates-52dfbc5c499f?source=rss-e5fbbe2da2f7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/52dfbc5c499f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[shipping]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[freight-rates]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[container-shipping]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Akhil Vohra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 09 Oct 2022 15:44:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-09T15:44:46.203Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The shipping industry has had a transformative journey since the pandemic. The Freightos Baltic Index (FBX) is a daily freight container index issued by the Baltic Exchange and Freightos. The index measures global container freight rates by calculating spot rates for 40-foot containers on 12 global tradelanes. The index remained flat from 2017–2020 at $1500-$2000, after which it peaked at more than $10,000! Since then it has fallen, but is currently still hovering at $5,000. The supply chain bottlenecks that caused these disruptions have also not settled. The Flexport Ocean timeliness indicator that tracks routes such as Far East Westbound (e.g., China-to-Europe) and Transpacific Eastbound (e.g., China-to-US) are hovering at 90 days, much higher than the 55–60 day levels they were pre-pandemic. In all this commotion, it is primarily the shipping lines and freight forwarders that have benefitted. Freight forwarders could even get away with providing average quality service as long as they were priced more competitively than the others. Price was king during these last few years in the containerised shipping space.</p><p>But now, not only are prices trending downward, but they also have good reason to be doing so. Average vessel utilisation is a fundamental metric to evaluate spot prices in the industry. Once utilization gets into the 90–95 percent range for the Transpacific, it effectively means all capacity is fully utilized and spot rates increase dramatically. Now that we have had two consecutive months where utilization is below 90 percent, it is clear the market is no longer at a point which can sustain extremely high spot rates.</p><p>But even as spot rates come down, is it estimated that the top 11 ocean carriers will see profits reach $256 billion for the calender year ending 2022, a huge uptick from last year’s record-shattering $148 billion net income. Although spot rates are falling below long-term rates signed earlier in the year, carrier spot profiles generally form a smaller percentage of total business than contracted freight profiles. And while new long-term contracted rates are beginning to drop on key trading corridors on the heels of declining spot prices, due to the fact the long-term contracted rates are replacing expiring agreements with considerably lower rates, the average paid by all shippers is still climbing. Fair to say that the average contract rate has increased across the industry, and I am sure that shipping lines would like to keep it that way. They are also the only ones in the value chain who can directly impact prices — by controlling supply. In fact, they have <a href="https://qz.com/2093954/how-big-shipping-lines-are-spending-their-pandemic-profits/">spent their shipping profits</a> consolidating other segments of the value chain, like port terminals and trucks.</p><p>None of this is very encouraging for the shipper who is always at the mercy of prices; and if shipping lines have it their way (which they might), this could become a continuing trend. Companies like <a href="https://www.xeneta.com/">Xeneta </a>have been solving for this problem. But pandemic induced events have only further stressed on the need for such solutions, culminating in their $80mn series D round closed recently (taking their total funding to $136mn). Shippers now need this more than ever. They should be able to benchmark their freight rates without having to reach out to carriers, and identify market disruptions so that they are better equipped during their negotiations. In global shipping, price has and always will be king, yet there is too much information asymmetry between the shipper and the carrier.</p><p>India’s economy is expanding, and exports, plus import driven consumption is a huge part of that story. Enterprises shipping in and out of India would be served well by technology led solutions that are mitigating the information misbalance between logistics departments and service providers. Extremely excited to see how things pan out globally, and how Indian startups respond.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XTztQswmREaPKUmzfqtF1g.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=52dfbc5c499f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The D2C Era]]></title>
            <link>https://akhilvohra.medium.com/the-d2c-era-f599368ef91e?source=rss-e5fbbe2da2f7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f599368ef91e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[d2c]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[e-commerce-business]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Akhil Vohra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Jun 2022 07:21:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-06-30T18:55:52.557Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nXNFIGFXo2jqXsjQPZEbnw.jpeg" /></figure><p><a href="https://www.sana-commerce.com/solutions/d2c-ecommerce/">D2C e-commerce</a> is when the manufacturer/producer sells its products/produce directly to consumers from their web store. A more traditional retailer business model goes from the manufacturer/producers &gt; to a wholesaler &gt; to a distributor &gt; to retailers &gt; and then finally to a consumer.</p><p>The D2C e-commerce model quite literally “cuts out” the middleman. Research has also shown that <a href="https://www.inc.com/peter-roesler/new-research-shows-a-good-brand-website-is-more-im.html">55% of consumers prefer to shop directly with the brand manufacturer over retailers</a>.</p><p>The traditional retailer business model deals with <strong>bulk purchases</strong>, so for a manufacturer to start selling direct-to-consumer they’d have to start selling individual items. This essentially is why most manufacturers have not yet switched to a D2C strategy, as their entire business revolves around selling products in bulk.</p><p><strong>The Logic For Going D2C</strong></p><p>Why would a brand that is fresh in the market, with virtually no customer base, and no product-market fit, NOT want to use behemoths like Amazon and Flipkart as a sales and distribution channel to service customers?</p><p>Commissions are sellers’ biggest issue. Not only do these platforms (Amazon and Flipkart) take a big cut — upwards of 20% — but sellers are also expected to shell out more money for marketing, including being featured prominently in search results. Industry executives have repeatedly said that the <strong>top 1–2% of sellers drive 90% of platforms’ gross merchandise volumes (GMV)</strong>. In their push to drive revenue, e-commerce platforms have also moved significantly towards private labels, adding yet another layer for the sellers to fight against in order to be visible. So the <strong>first</strong> major reason for going d2c, as opposed to selling on e-commerce platforms, is the commission. <strong>Secondly, </strong>fighting for visibility on these platforms is another major hurdle.</p><p>Traditional consumer brands typically take decades to reach the <strong>Rs 500 crore milestone</strong>, and after sinking in a lot more capital to build capabilities in manufacturing and distribution spanning multiple levels. Cosmetics brand <strong>Revlon</strong> took 20 years to reach Rs 100 crore in revenue in India, and personal care brand <strong>Lotus Herbals</strong> took 19 years. <strong>Bikaji Foods</strong> needed 21 years to reach that milestone and nearly another 10 years to reach Rs 500 crore in revenue. <strong>Wow Skin Sciences</strong>, founded in 2014, hit Rs 450 crore ($61 million) in sales in the financial year that just went by, its sales nearly doubling in each of the previous three years. <strong>Boat Lifestyle</strong>, a six-year-old brand known for its earphones, wearables, and other consumer tech products, registered Rs 704 crore ($95 million) in 2019–20. Many other scale-up stories across the country point in the same direction.</p><p>But why do D2C brands scale up faster?</p><p><strong>a) Product Specialisation</strong>:</p><p>E-commerce brands today are driven by identifying hitherto unsolved problems in the consumer market. Such brands have gone the extra step to invest in the product, and pass on the price to consumers who are willing to pay a premium for a better quality product. While companies like <strong>Forest Essentials</strong> were birthed much before the pandemic, they are a good example of a luxury skincare brand that can command premium pricing. Further, problems like men’s grooming, women’s workwear, vegan food choices, etc. were only waiting to be solved, with incumbent FMCG and fashion giants not stepping in to fill the gap. It is the consumers who have won in the era of the pandemic-driven e-commerce boom, and the product specialists who are leading the way.</p><p><strong>b)</strong> <strong>Speed to Market</strong>:</p><p>Both literally, and figuratively. While still losing out to Amazon and Flipkart on delivery timelines, today’s e-commerce brands have at the least painted a D2C picture for the incumbents that have traditionally relied on offline channels. The supply chain complexity is an obvious one, D2C brands would (ideally) like to ship their products pan India, but they don’t have the desired volumes to take advantage of economies of scale. This means higher <strong>supply chain costs</strong> if the brand wants to see through on its pan India promise.</p><p>A number of associated business models have arisen that are enabling these brands to maintain delivery SLAs and yet maintain costs. <em>Companies like </em><a href="https://flow.space/"><em>Flowspace</em></a><em> in the US, and </em><a href="https://www.edgistify.com/"><em>Edgistify</em></a><em> in India have leveraged the new micro-warehousing and darkstore network to provide a distributed fulfillment network to brands, enabling the one- and two-day shipping costumers expect, affordably. While the above two are service providers, companies like </em><a href="https://www.hopstack.io/"><em>Hopstack</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://www.anchanto.com/?campaignid=16463274925&amp;adgroupid=135654091562&amp;adid=585738612419&amp;utm_term=anchanto&amp;utm_medium=ppc&amp;utm_campaign=GO+Anchanto+Search+Traffic+India+21&amp;utm_source=adwords&amp;hsa_tgt=kwd-370855730336&amp;hsa_ad=585738612419&amp;hsa_net=adwords&amp;hsa_ver=3&amp;hsa_cam=16463274925&amp;hsa_kw=anchanto&amp;hsa_acc=8249988244&amp;hsa_mt=b&amp;hsa_src=g&amp;hsa_grp=135654091562&amp;gclid=CjwKCAjwh-CVBhB8EiwAjFEPGRqTDDlVkWOyFS0kmrTfIWu0IzEnXZx_4eV0xhsF7xbp6nvmnsdfJhoCK9gQAvD_BwE"><em>Anchanto</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://cognitops.com/"><em>Cognitops</em></a>,<em> and </em><a href="https://deposco.com/"><em>Deposco</em></a><em> are providing the technology layer that is making today’s storage facilities e-commerce enabled. There is enough evidence that supply chain tech startups are, and will continue to back the D2C commerce value proposition.</em></p><p>D2C brands’ speed extends to gauging customers’ response to a launch. The feedback loop is so agile that, in <strong>48 hours</strong>, the founder knows if a product is working or not. For legacy FMCG companies, there is no visibility on product performance for months after launch. Given the multiple layers in the FMCG value chain — distributors, wholesalers, and retailers, among them — real-time data is difficult to get. The same applies to giants in the clothing and skincare segment. This<strong> </strong><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/nykaa-vs-sugar-war-underdogs-kamalika-poddar/"><strong>piece</strong></a><strong> </strong>comparing <strong>Nykaa’s</strong> story to that of <strong>Sugar</strong> <strong>Cosmetics</strong> highlights the extra mile today’s brands go in incorporating product feedback and enabling customer satisfaction with the product.</p><p>c) <strong>Higher Gross and EBITDA Margins</strong></p><p>With the ecosystem becoming more conducive for D2C brands to ship goods affordably while maintaining delivery SLAs, shipping costs are bound to come down over time. Further going around the distributor-retailer network allows them to cut out the middleman and their associated costs. Product quality means customers are hooked to the product and are unlikely to halt usage given the personal nature, and the specificity of the need being fulfilled. Also, given the limited alternatives in many up-and-coming product segments, customers once acquired are unlikely to jump ship, because where would they even go? All these factors give brands pricing power. Production costs are managed by outsourcing manufacturing to existing mid-sized shops specializing in the given vertical. It is only the formula (in skincare), or the design (in fashion), etc. that are provided as a prescription by the brand to the manufacturer. The above factors means higher gross margins, and with scale and delivery costs coming down, EBITDA margins will soon follow.</p><p><strong>Landscape</strong></p><p>As per Tracxn, following is what the investments landscape looks like in India. Choosing the most salient categories, and mapping total investments and number of funding rounds since <strong>2017</strong> gives us the following picture:</p><ul><li><strong>Mom and Baby Care:</strong><br><em>Total Funding: $195 Mn<br>Total Rounds: 53<br>Marquee Companies: Mamaearth, Mylo, TheMomsCo</em></li><li><strong>Beauty and Skin Care:<br></strong><em>Total Funding: $986 Mn<br>Total Rounds: 168<br>Marquee Companies: MyGlamm, Nykaa, SUGAR Cosmetics, Bombay Shaving Company</em></li><li><strong>Fashion (Including Jewellery and Footwear)<br></strong><em>Total Funding: $427 Mn<br>Total Rounds: 233<br>Marquee Companies: Yepme, Bluestone, Zivame, Bewakoof, DaMENSCH</em></li><li><strong>Home Improvement<br></strong><em>Total Funding: $129 Mn<br>Total Rounds: 37<br>Marquee Companies: Wakefit, Urban Ladder, Furlenco, SleepyCat, Lifelong</em></li><li><strong>Consumer Electronics<br></strong><em>Total Funding: $340 Mn<br>Total Rounds: 31<br>Marquee Companies: Boat, Noise, Fireboltt, MoLife, Portronics</em></li><li><strong>Online Grocery<br></strong><em>Total Funding: $132 Mn<br>Total Rounds: 129<br>Marquee Companies: Vadham Teas, Epigamia, OpenSecret, TeaBox, Veeba</em></li></ul><p>While sizing the market for opportunities, one ideally wants to tap into segments where the overall pie is larger. However, as opposed to fashion and electronics, it is the personal care segment that has seen maximum funding (and even an IPO in Nykaa) in the e-commerce/d2c segment. My own take is as follows; each of the above markets are large enough. The opportunity lies in finding companies that have identified a more specific need within these segments. Further, opportunities lie in adjacent business models that are supporting the entire ecosystem. Finally, the ability of the founders to correctly price the product as per their target demographic, and position the brand in line with our cultural context, is key.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/938/1*mFzUfYK5ue3V9-Yx2vhp6g.png" /></figure><p><strong>Key Hits:</strong></p><ul><li>Men’s grooming in beauty</li><li>Jewellery in fashion</li><li>Tea in grocery</li></ul><p><strong>Personalisation/Stickiness</strong> and <strong>cultural context</strong> are two critical elements to consider while evaluating a market to enter. The past (funding and growth) serves as a playbook for where the smart money should be headed now. Big element of the cultural context is pricing. <strong>Boat, Bewakoof, Yepme</strong> have all followed the same playbook; they have lowered prices and tapped into the majority of India’s growing online shopper base. <strong>Meesho </strong>has also pivoted from its social commerce model to becoming a horizontal marketplace, with a focus on the customer base most sensitive to price. Following is a snippet from Meesho’s homepage:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/744/1*t6oiK1jSu84ZwFml_Qla6w.png" /></figure><p>Tea has long played an integral part in the Indian culture, with many famous Indians expressing their love of a &#39;good cuppa&#39;. When asked to choose the beverage they generally drink, tea came out on top with more than two in five Indians (44%) choosing it as their drink next to 18% who said coffee and 38% who said both. Companies like <strong>Vadham Teas</strong> and <strong>Teabox</strong> have played on Indians’ affinity for tea. Never before has an Indian tea enthusiast had an online catalogue of rare and high quality products to choose from, that too delivered at their doorstep. The same goes for Indian snacks, that were hitherto purchased from large retailers like Bikanervala, Om Sweets, Haldirams etc., but the cultural relevance of tea far outweighs those of Indian snacks like makhanas and other namkeens.</p><p>Finally, <strong>men’s wellness</strong>. A complete white space (prior to the d2c boom) with a market whose needs are massive, yet the desire has always been latent. Only once the products were pushed out into the market was the demand tapped into, with several companies capturing different segments of the overall segment. What such companies also did, was break the stigma around addressal of key problems like sexual wellness. Today’s online brands are willing to push the boundaries of what health and wellness, nutrition, and fashion look like. The sheer number of these companies, with varying price points, coupled with a delivery based model means there is enough to go around for everyone.</p><p>To summarise, brands are targeting segments wherein the products are inherently sticky (skin care, feminine hygiene, sexual wellness etc.). If the product delivers and brands have customers making repeat purchases, they know they have pricing power, and will thus rake in high margins. Such an approach would have a higher chance of failure, but a sweeter reward. On the flipside, Boat has become the world’s 5th largest wearables brand owing to its competitive pricing. Each segment requires its unique strategy, the attempt is only to take lessons from the leaders.</p><p><strong>Adjacent Business Models</strong></p><p>A number of businesses have taken birth to support India’s growing D2C economy, and <strong>vertical marketplaces</strong> are the largest of the lot. Vertical marketplaces accommodate multiple brands/vendors but only focus on a specific category such as beauty and personal care (BPC), fashion, home decor, pharma products, automobiles and more. Unlike the horizontal model, they are the masters of particular niches and bring more value to their target consumers due to their expertise. In fact, companies like Nykaa and MyGlamm have gone the marketplace route, while close competitor SUGAR Cosmetics is its own label, truly a D2C brand in that sense.</p><p>With vertical marketplaces, it is advisable to tap into the first mover advantage in a niche category, ideally one that has multiple players, and have the same target segment. Bombay Shaving Company, Beardo, The Man Company, Ustraa, The Phy Life etc. are only a handful of companies in the men’s grooming segment. There is definitely value in aggregation of such players, given the common target demographic. Eventually, the marketplace could evolve to sell other products specific to men and grow by benefiting from the virality.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*I4Hwg4lY1Z-bfS2h6mdrRw.png" /></figure><p>In fact, Three out of five top-funded vertical marketplaces were profitable in FY21, unlike the top-funded horizontal players that failed to turn a profit. As vertical marketplaces focus more on Tier-2 and Tier-3 cities to foray deeper into Bharat and cater to a larger audience, the opportunity has become more lucrative and attracted the interest of VC investors. Therefore, many new players are entering this space, and the competition will heat up in the coming years.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f599368ef91e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ed-Tech: Fast Forward 2022]]></title>
            <link>https://akhilvohra.medium.com/ed-tech-fast-forward-2022-9ead6b1e5362?source=rss-e5fbbe2da2f7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9ead6b1e5362</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[edtech-startup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[edtech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[venture-capital]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startups-in-india]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Akhil Vohra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 Jun 2022 09:03:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-06-17T09:03:34.874Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>MARKET</strong></h3><p>The recent $100 mn investment in <strong>Physicswallah</strong> has stirred the pot and once again got the community talking about K-12. According to investors close to the company’s advisors, PW earned close to Rs 300–400 crore ($39.2 million-$52.3 million); in revenue for the year ended March 2021, almost neck and neck with Unacademy’s revenue of Rs 380.80 crore ($49.6 million) in the same period. Unacademy’s revenue, though, comes on the back of Rs 414 crore ($51.4 million) spent on marketing, according to the company’s financials. PW, according to <strong>Alakh Pandey</strong>, has spent next to nothing on marketing.</p><p>Further, <strong>Unacademy</strong>, valued at $3.4 billion, has exited the K-12 tutoring segment. More crucially, it has let go of 600 employees and decided against renewing the contracts of 300 to 400 teachers. This leaves Byju’s (which acquired toppr), Vedantu, and Physicswallah battling it out for the K-12 pie. Ed-tech in India was valued as a $2.5 Billion opportunity in 2020 and is estimated to reach $10 Billion by 2025.</p><p>However, investors don’t see market size as an issue in the Indian Ed-tech market. The Indian education system is one of the largest in the world with over 1.5 million schools, 8.5 million teachers, and over 250 million children. About 65 percent of the total student population goes to government schools and 85 percent of the remaining 35 percent of students go to private schools, while 15 percent go to institutions with limited <a href="https://startuptalky.com/service-based-startups-successful-india/">technical facilities</a>. As digital infrastructure gets accommodated into schools over time, and more ed-tech startups enter tier 2 and tier 3 markets, a hybrid model of online and offline education is expected to take over.</p><h3><strong>K-12, TEST PREP &amp; CONTINUED LEARNING</strong></h3><p>What investors, both early and growth-stage are more mindful of, is the sustainability of the business model. This is in response to a volatile economic climate, which has seen valuations take a tumble and funding drying up. News about<strong> </strong><a href="https://inc42.com/features/indian-startup-layoffs-tracker/"><strong>layoffs</strong></a> is becoming common. Startups in the ed-tech sector using sales-led growth models have suffered. While customarily used in the SaaS community, <a href="https://techcrunch.com/2022/06/07/as-investors-focus-more-on-profitability-product-led-startups-may-be-sitting-pretty/"><strong>product-led growth</strong></a> is the investor’s focus today.</p><p>In the context of K-12 and test prep, either a differentiated approach (such as gamification, or doubt solving), a focus on a few subjects (english, maths, coding), or the most difficult of all - high-quality faculty like Alakh Pandey, is what is setting companies apart. Yet, all roads in this segment are leading down the same path - <strong>consolidation</strong>. This has indeed been a fascinating development in Ed-tech in India, viz a viz some of the other sectors. Online travel took more than a decade to achieve some sort of rationality and maturity. Online commerce has been around for seven years and counting, with fresh challengers cropping up every now and then. Ordering food online took a good six years for everyone else to die and leave us with Zomato and Swiggy, with neither company yet to ​​turn in a dollar as profit. That’s as close we’ve got to the last man standing theory, served with poor business economics. Online education for the masses, and really that’s what most education technology companies are doing, isn’t even four years old. And, in the last two, some 20 acquisitions have gone through.</p><p>As an early-stage investor looking at Ed-tech - it is quite the conundrum. Any early-stage K-12 or test prep company that garners significant traction becomes an acquisition target for the likes of Byju’s, Unacademy, Vedantu etc. Yet, the business itself is unlikely to create a brand of its own, given the already competitive market. So do you play for the acquisition? Seems like a risky investment proposition in an asset class that is inherently high risk as well.</p><p>Unlike K-12, where the tier-I market is saturated and companies need to crack the smaller towns and villages to continue growing, startups in the continued learning segment still haven’t reached their full potential in the bigger cities. Margins are better in continued learning and the number of users is growing steadily; that’s number one. Unlike in the past, you don’t stay in one job for 30 years. You change jobs every few years and, therefore, need to keep learning to stay relevant. It also helps that they are selling directly to users and not parents like in the K-12 segment. Also, the term ‘continued learning’ is used to differentiate itself from its opposite number ‘higher education’. More on that segment later.</p><p>Upgrad and Eruditus are considered the two behemoths of the space. In K-12 and test prep, there exists little scope for differentiating yourself basis <strong>content</strong>. This is a constraint of the industry — tests for the masses are going to be standardised. A sales-led growth model becomes the default in a scenario, once factors like UI/UX are taken care of. But continued learning has a wider variety and scope. Companies like <a href="https://www.newtonschool.co/"><strong>Newton School</strong></a>, focusing on coding and tech -<strong> </strong>with their income share agreement program recently raised their series B. <a href="https://www.scaler.com/courses/data-structures-and-algorithms/?utm_source=ads&amp;utm_medium=googlesearch&amp;utm_campaign=perf_scaler_academy_ads_googlesearch_brand-search_india_all&amp;utm_content=e-scaler&amp;utm_term=scaler%20academy&amp;param1=562296081078&amp;param2=c&amp;param3=&amp;gclid=CjwKCAjw46CVBhB1EiwAgy6M4hYf5hgpAvO6qNn9ONUMiueLNuf6-1ctjzrPv38L3TVycvtUQluFHBoCD5gQAvD_BwE"><strong>Scaler academy</strong></a> has focused on the developer market, while <a href="https://frontrow.co.in/"><strong>Frontrow</strong></a>, <a href="https://unlu.io/class?gclid=CjwKCAjw46CVBhB1EiwAgy6M4pCpGE60KYq3z4yIfYAAIc0dCJ-6AdJPu1tFhHGf5Vb3VXKPXtfDtRoCiSsQAvD_BwE"><strong>Unlu</strong></a>, and <a href="https://www.skillshare.com/"><strong>Skillshare</strong></a><strong> </strong>are catering to more creative disciplines by using celebrities and influencers as a pull. There is room for much more growth in these segments. Firstly, professions are endless, think medicine, legal, finance, marketing, etc. Sectors within sectors like dermatology in medicine, stock and options trading in finance, etc. all provide scope for new players looking to enter the market.</p><p>And while the professions (ergo, the content) are nearly endless, so is the market. That is what makes it attractive to cater to even a niche segment. As long as a company is disciplined and capable enough to create rich and relevant content for the community, chances of success are high. <a href="https://mymedisage.com/home"><strong>Medisage</strong></a> is a good example of a company focusing on the medical community. <strong><em>From an Ed-tech perspective, I am of the opinion that those who can differentiate on basis of content should be evaluated keenly</em></strong>. It is key that the content is able to act as a differentiator since even Byju’s creates its content with an in-house team of 1100 people, but can only differentiate so much given that curriculums are standard.</p><p>It further helps that the market for higher education is inherently global. In fact, market leader <strong>Eruditus</strong> derives about <strong>80%</strong> of its revenue from outside India. That in itself is a key trend in the overall ed-tech sector; Indian companies that initially built for domestic markets have realized that the gaps they are addressing exist worldwide. With both Coursera and Udemy going public in 2021, the global tailwinds are apparent. <strong><em>A company with a strong global growth strategy (or market) is a second parameter (after content) that I would strongly favor while evaluating an investment opportunity.</em></strong></p><p>To summarise, continued learning offers an opportunity for early stage investors to make some bets, with hopes of their investments becoming market leaders in niche verticals. While K-12 and Test Prep companies offer more tactical opportunities - any startup that has garnered a reasonable user base becomes an attractive acquisition target. The proliferation of ed-tech in India has given rise to companies that operate beyoned these three segments. Further, key to the ed-tech narrative is that the future is hybrid, so there’s always the burden of incorporating schools (the majority of which lack digital infrastructure) into the final solution.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*P4i5Qkyqd4XYcAg7B3isOw.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9ead6b1e5362" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Under the Canopy of India’s Green Energy Revolution]]></title>
            <link>https://akhilvohra.medium.com/under-the-canopy-of-indias-green-energy-revolution-5506309ff2b4?source=rss-e5fbbe2da2f7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5506309ff2b4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tariffs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[solar-energy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[electricity-generation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[renewable-energy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Akhil Vohra]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Feb 2021 06:57:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-01T06:57:23.214Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Within hours of becoming president, Joe Biden had moved to recommit the United States to the <strong>Paris Agreement</strong> — the internationally binding treaty to combat climate change. This takes us back to 2015 when the treaty first came into being. It has since been looked at as a symbolic juncture — one where the world came together to fight a common foe. This might tempt us to call it a team effort; but it&#39;s truly an individual battle for all nations involved — each of which has its own challenges.</p><p>India, with its own context, put across the following <a href="https://climateactiontracker.org/countries/india/pledges-and-targets/">two commitments</a>:</p><ul><li>Reduction in the emissions per dollar of GDP to levels<strong> 33–35%</strong> below that in 2005 by 2030</li><li>At least <strong>40%</strong> of all energy capacity in the country should be from <strong>renewable sources</strong></li></ul><p>On the first target, emissions per dollar of GDP are nearly <strong>14%</strong> down since 2005, and it seems likely that this goal will be met. However, it should be noted that the absolute levels of CO2 emissions in India have been on the rise, even if its share per unit of GDP has been decreasing. On the second goal — India has had a good head start owing to a <a href="https://www.pbs.org/wnet/wideangle/uncategorized/the-dammed-water-wants-a-history-of-indias-dams/3098/">post-independence push</a> of hydropower. Now, with solar having taken over the world stage as renewable energy’s poster boy and India being a sunlight rich country, we can expect solar energy to lead the pack in India’s energy revolution. As of March 31, 2020 grid connected installed capacity from all sources was as follows:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/393/1*Ry8GLbdQ8M73yqDPOTHxGg.png" /><figcaption>Grid-Connected Installed Capacity</figcaption></figure><p>Connection to the electrical grid (or national grid) becomes relevant as it allows for large scale transmission of electricity from power plants (which are mostly located away from demand centers) and subsequent distribution to the final consumers, located all over the country. It should be noted that in our fight against carbon dioxide emissions, electricity generation has taken center stage. <strong>Electricity and heat generation</strong> is the largest contributor to greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions in India, which is why a focus on electricity generation makes sense. As India accelerates electrification of rural areas, which had erstwhile never seen electricity, the emissions are only bound to increase. In 2016, electricity was nearly 35% of all emissions, almost 1.5X of <strong>agriculture</strong> — the second largest GHG emitter in India — and 2X that of all <strong>transportation</strong>.</p><p>Not only do growing economies like India have the onus to curb emissions — but our large population coupled with their growing energy demands means that the cost of producing energy becomes a huge factor in deciding how we produce it. <strong>The Levelized Cost of Electricity (LCOE)</strong> or the levelized energy cost (LEC), is a measurement used to assess and compare alternative methods of energy production. The LCOE of an energy-generating asset can be thought of as the average total cost of building and operating the asset, per unit of total electricity generated over an assumed lifetime<strong>. (Formula</strong>: <strong>Present Value of Total Cost Over the Lifetime)/(Present Value of All Electricity Generated Over the Lifetime). </strong>Recently an analysis by <strong>IRENA</strong> (International Renewable Energy Agency) found that the costs for setting up solar projects have dropped by about <strong>80 percent</strong> in India between 2010 and 2018. This meant that India’s levelized cost of solar-power generation fell to <strong>14%</strong> below that of <strong>coal</strong>, the first time anywhere in the world that generating solar was cheaper than coal on that basis, according to international energy consulting firm Wood Mackenzie. Prices for India have reduced on the back of technological innovation and <strong>falling solar-panel prices</strong>. Additionally, plants are easy to build — essentially solar panels lined up in racks — and labor is inexpensive. India has big stretches of sparsely populated land and intense sun, good for vast spreads cranking out power.</p><p>So while curtailing emissions is certainly the end goal, India’s zeal to adopt the sunlight based alternative has had much to do with its low cost as well. This brings us back to India’s second commitment at the Paris convention — currently, <strong>37%</strong> of India’s installed energy capacity is renewable in nature, which means we are well on track to reach (and surpass) the <strong>40%</strong> mark. In fact, the government has set itself a lofty target of having an operational capacity of <strong>450 Gigawatts (1 Gigawatt = 1000 Megawatts) </strong>of renewable energy by <strong>2030</strong>.</p><p>This doesn’t mean that it’s going to be all smooth sailing. The low cost of energy generation has given rise to its own sets of problems. In order to understand the underlying cracks in the industry, let’s get a closer look at its value chain. State-run intermediary procurers such as <strong>SECI</strong> (Solar Energy Corporation of India) and <strong>NTPC</strong> (National Thermal Power Corporation) are both PSUs (amongst others) that coordinate and distribute the mandate for the development of commercial power projects. Developers such as <strong>Adani Greens, ReNew Power, and Azure Power</strong> are India’s top three developers in terms of live operational capacity. Such developers participate in <strong>reverse auctions</strong> held by the intermediaries, quoting prices at which they would be willing to <strong><em>sell</em></strong> the electricity that they generate from the given project. Each participant, thus, aims to outbid the other by quoting a lower price. The electricity generated is then sold to state-owned utilities <strong>(DISCOMS — Distribution Companies), </strong>which take the ownership of distributing the power to the final consumer.</p><p>Year on year, the prices (or tariffs) at which the bids are being won has been steadily falling, to levels that some in the industry are terming <em>unfeasible</em><strong><em>. </em>Mercom</strong> — one of the leading market intelligence companies in the clean energy domain globally, has captured the fall in prices in the following graphic:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/836/1*5z9qUCNkmhoyEndZCE8kVg.png" /></figure><p>On 24th November 2020, Saudi Arabia-based Aljomaih Energy and Water Company and Green Infra Wind Energy Limited, a subsidiary of Singapore-based Sembcorp, won 200 MW (<strong>Megawatts</strong>) and 400 MW of solar projects, respectively, at <strong>₹2/kWh</strong> (1 kilowatt-hour, abbreviated kWh, is equivalent to the <strong>energy</strong> of 1,000 <strong>joules</strong> used for 3,600 seconds or 3.6 million joules. In equation form: 1 kWh = 3.6 million J.) NTPC Limited was the only <strong>Indian</strong> winner quoting <strong>₹2.01</strong>, being awarded 470 MW. The question is, whether or not this is a cause to celebrate.</p><p>Experts from the industry argue that at this price, the projects might become economically unfeasible for the developers. While the low debt cost and return on investment expectation of foreign developers were clear, the industry has been unable to crack the code as to what prodded NTPC to bid so low. NTPC is looking at interest rates of <strong>8–8.5%</strong> compared to the foreign developers who might secure funding at lower than <strong>5%. </strong>Anshuman Gupta, Deputy Manager, Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency Limited <strong>(</strong><a href="https://www.ireda.in/"><strong>IREDA</strong></a><strong>)</strong>, commented, “at such low tariffs, the developers are expecting the cost of debt to be on the lower side of 8% which no financial institution would be able to lend including IREDA. Only banks would be able to lend. Even at 8%, the debt-equity ratio will have to be a <strong>65–35%</strong> rather than the usual <strong>75–25%</strong> ratio.” A number of such solar auctions have been closed at lower prices, and it’s implications are becoming clearer by the day.</p><p>The big one being that state-owned DISCOMS are going <strong><em>Tariff Shopping. </em></strong>They are passing up on buying electricity from the developers at existing prices — in hopes of future prices being even lower. DISCOMS have also begun re-negotiating older agreements now that prices/tariffs in the market are falling. In 2019, the southern state of Andra Pradesh — which has one of the highest levels of renewable-energy consumption threatened to <a href="https://www.livemint.com/industry/energy/solar-power-is-beginning-to-eclipse-fossil-fuels-11582179606841.html">cancel</a> old solar contracts and renegotiate them at lower prices, sending the industry into an uproar. Additionally, about <strong>90%</strong> of India’s electricity is sold to these provincial distribution utilities through long-term contracts that run for as long as <strong>25 years</strong>. Some thermal power projects that failed to sign such contracts in the past have struggled to repay their debt, leaving lenders reluctant to fund electricity projects without buyer commitments. With DISCOMS not committing to buying electricity generated from renewable sources, developers have started to pass on solar auctions, threatening the country’s aggressive development timetable.</p><p>In fact, almost 18.5 GW of tenders given out by SECI, for solar power generation, are still unclaimed. And these are figures from just 2020. The new tenders aside, delayed payments from distribution companies on existing contracts— which saw losses of <strong>Rs 30,000 crore ($4 billion)</strong> in 2019–20, according to <strong>ICRA</strong> (Investment Information and Credit Rating Agency) — have long been an issue. As an example, <strong>ReNew Power’s</strong> trade receivables rose by <strong>66%</strong> between March and September 2020 to Rs 3,200 crore <strong>($420 million)</strong> on the back of such delayed payments. In fact, in May earlier this year, <strong>Moody’s</strong> had downgraded the Indian power sector’s outlook from stable to negative citing reasons such as Covid-induced disruption that would lead to an economic slowdown, and further payment delays by DISCOMs. Power producers’ total dues owed by distribution firms rose over <strong>29 per cent year-on-year to Rs 1,38,187</strong> crore in October 2020, reflecting the level of stress in the sector. The dues of non-conventional energy producers like solar and wind stood at <strong>Rs 11,072.88 crore in October.</strong></p><p>Even the developers could be in better shape. <strong>Adani Green</strong> itself has over Rs 18,000 crore in debt, which has been taken on to implement its ongoing expansion plans. The company has a <strong>12.3 GW</strong> solar portfolio — <strong>2.2 GW</strong> already in operation and <strong>10.1 GW</strong> of under-construction and awarded capacity. Further, though the company has bagged an <strong>8 GW</strong> contract for solar projects with an assured tariff of <strong>₹2.92 /kWh</strong> from government-owned SECI, no agreement has been signed yet with distribution companies (since DISCOMs are holding out for a rate lower than ₹2.92/kWh). This means that there isn’t a guarantee that the power produced by Adani will end up being utilized. There is already a precedent in Tamil Nadu, where the state does not draw all the power that Adani Green Energy produces as a wind farm supplies power to the state at a lower cost. This leaves even India’s biggest solar producer’s business plans in a state of limbo.</p><p>These sets of troubles haven’t gone unnoticed. It is apparent that DISCOMS’ poor financial state is serving as the biggest bottleneck for projects moving forward. There is a clear need for intervention and the authorities have stepped in to do their bit. In May 2020, the government announced Rs 90,000 crore liquidity infusion for discoms under which these utilities would get loan at economical rates from <strong>Power Finance Corporation</strong> and <strong>REC Ltd.</strong> (Rural Electrification Corporation). Later the liquidity infusion package was increased to Rs <strong>1.2 lakh crore</strong>. However, power minister <strong>RK Singh</strong> <a href="https://www.financialexpress.com/industry/half-hearted-reforms-wont-help-salvage-discoms-rk-singh/2149991/">claims</a> that he has seen this picture play out before, and that the industry is in need of more than just a band-aid solution. In fact, the current relief package is the <strong>fourth such in the past two decades</strong>. The minister points out that the inefficencies lie in billing and collecting revenue from the final consumer — and such troubles will persist unless the DISCOMs are allowed to make their own commercial decisions.</p><p>An effective way to achieve the financial turnaround of weak discoms is to privatise them. The Centre has already shown its intent by announcing the privatisation of discoms in Union Territories (UTs). For state discoms, the process could be a long drawn one, given the risk of stiff opposition as seen in the past. Privately-owned discoms tend to be more <a href="https://www.bloombergquint.com/opinion/discom-privatisation-challenged-insufficient-planning-or-tactical-move">efficient</a>, with distribution losses at<strong> 8–11%</strong>, potentially half those of public sector discoms. Plus, greater pedigree of the management owing to in-depth domain expertise will also be expected to lead to reduced operational inefficiencies. Private players are required to have such expertise in order to bid for these discoms — since they will deal with complex issues like existing baskets of PPAs (power purchase agreements), asset transfer, treatment of dues and other legal issues. Following are some of the arguments <strong><em>against </em></strong>privatisation:</p><ul><li>Electricity prices for consumers would go up as a consequence of the privatisation, as the new private sector owners would be driven by the profit motive. The objection to this is as follows — it is not axiomatic that electricity prices will increase as a consequence of privatisation. These prices are based on tariffs set out in power purchase agreements executed by the discom, which would be inherited by its successor entity. Further, any changes to tariffs would have to be approved by the state electricity regulators.</li><li>The second is the inherent fear of state employees that the privatisation process will render them jobless. In fact, power sector employees have even held <a href="https://www.saurenergy.com/solar-energy-news/power-sector-employees-protest-against-privatisation-of-discoms-aipef"><strong>nationwide protests</strong></a> against the government’s decision to privatise DISCOMs — even though it would be expected that the employment of any employees in reserved jobs would be protected through the privatisation process.</li></ul><p>As is evident, the tool of privatisation is a tricky one to deploy in the power sector — despite its efficacy having already been proven in other industries. There have been other makeshift attempts at allevation of the industry’s key players’ ailments. For example, SECI has indulged in the activity of a <strong><em>pooled tariff—</em></strong>it<strong><em> </em></strong>is the weigthed average of the tariff discovered in the competitive bidding process for a specific time period. It is used to deter discoms from going tariff shopping — as regardless of how they play their cards they are likely to end up with a similar price/rate at which to purchase electricity. But as is evident now, such solutions barely scratch the surface in ridding the industry of its pains.</p><p>It is a challenging task to accurately gauge where India’s renewable energy sector is headed — or whether it will achieve the amibitious targets it has set for itself. But what cannot be doubted is the existence of the opportunity, and the intent of the parties involved. This includes the power developers who are willingly aggressive in pursuing new projects, or the government which is fighting battles on various fronts — while keeping in mind its steep targets. The government has also taken measures towards self reliance, or <strong><em>Atmanirbharta</em></strong><em>, </em>in this journey. It has <a href="https://www.livemint.com/news/india/15-firms-look-to-invest-3-billion-in-solar-manufacturing-11608173435855.html">articulated</a> its plans to impose a basic customs duty of 40% on solar modules and 25% on solar cells imports from 1 April 2022 — both key components in the construction of solar panels (as this will promote domestic manufacturing). Additionally, with battery/energy storage being key in the ubiquitous adoption of renewable energy (since resources like sunlight and wind are not available throughout the day), any investment in such technologies is a positive step towards building the sustainable energy ecosystem.</p><p><strong>Lithium-ion (Li-ion) </strong>batteries have emerged as the most popular and most promising for new renewable energy projects. These batteries — also used in electric vehicles — are promising primarily because their average price has plunged 87% between 2010 and 2019 to $156 per kilowatt-hour (kWh), according to Bloomberg New Energy Finance (BNEF). India wants to move up the value chain of batteries by transitioning from assembling battery packs with imported cells to making the cells here. To that end, it wants to have 50 GWh of Li-ion cell manufacturing capacity. Industry experts are conscious of the herculean nature of India’s ambition to become more self reliant in the battery space — and project that in the near future we will continue to rely on imports of such cells from China. However, the <strong>International Energy Agency (IEA)</strong> still touts India to have the largest share of global battery deployment by 2030:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cb5g7apTnQjjdkDNsqpKDQ.png" /><figcaption>Graphic borrowed from The Ken (Intel gathered from IEA)</figcaption></figure><p>As mentioned before, with the ground realities constantly changing, and the outlook of the overall sector looking murky, one has to rely on the intent of all parties involved if they are looking for a positive outlook on India’s energy sector. India’s ambitious goal to have 450 GW of renewable energy capacity by 2030, its constant battle with state agencies and their employees to improve the financial state of DISCOMs, its resource deployment through liquidity infusions, increasing self reliance, its desire to stay ahead in the game by investing in battery storage are only some of the measures (or potential measures) that are indicative of a bright (and sunny) future for India’s energy sector. Until then, we hope that all stakeholders involved continue the grind towards reform and growth — and that India becomes the global leader in renewable energy generation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bTXJCcZ7UoLRTelt5BmQ2w.jpeg" /></figure><p>In case any reader would like to discuss this piece with me, feel free to write to me at akhil.vohra1897@gmail.com, or message me on my <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/akhil-vohra-9972b8101/">LinkedIn</a>.</p><p>The following sources have been used in curating this article:</p><p><em>Mint<br>Economic Times<br>Financial Express<br>Bloomberg Quint<br>The Morning Context<br>The Ken<br>Mercom India</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5506309ff2b4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>