<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Akshad Rathi on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Akshad Rathi on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@akshadrathi0705?source=rss-50eb3738c5d8------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 21:50:22 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@akshadrathi0705/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Caste-Based Reservations and the Esoteric Idea of Justice]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@akshadrathi0705/caste-based-reservations-and-the-esoteric-idea-of-justice-d8f2caa3e78e?source=rss-50eb3738c5d8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d8f2caa3e78e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[statistics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[caste]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reservations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Akshad Rathi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 02 Jan 2025 14:22:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-29T09:01:44.354Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Caste-based Reservations in India have been subject to debates for decades now. There have been several instances of criticism against it. Be it on the basis of merit, or economic <em>injustice</em>. While the other side labels the reservations as their moral <em>right</em>. Something which they deserve for centuries of atrocities against them. For them, it is only them and their associate “castes” who deserve it, not because they inherited it from the constitution, but because they too <em>morally deserve </em>it. When a new “caste” rises up to demand for special quotas, they are subject to slander. A stark example is the Patels from Gujrat.</p><p>If the morality is so clear, then let us attempt to dissect it. What was this moral idea of social justice that makes only certain “castes” deserve it?</p><h3>Is There Any Moral Ground for Reservations?</h3><p>There are two questions ahead of us, (i) What is the moral idea of social justice?, and (ii) What relationship does it have with reservations? The best place to derive our answers from are the Constituent Assembly Debates (CAD); after all, it were the CAD that led to the very implication of caste-based reservations. The argument presented can be understood as a summary of this research paper by Dr. S.N. Balagangadhara, interested readers can check that paper out <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/318322221_Caste-Based_Reservation_and_Social_Justice_in_India">here</a>.</p><p>Before moving forward, I would like to make one thing very clear. Moral statements, as per political theory, aren’t achievable realities. By no stretch of imagination can a completely perfect moral world be reached upon. No civilization or Government policy can do this. Therefore, whenever someone talks about such moral statements, legally or politically, only <em>aspires </em>to achieve that, the speaker is aware of the fact that it is unachievable. Speaking with context to CAD, these <em>aspiring </em>statements are the core philosophy and driving force per se behind the law or the policy.</p><p>Why is all this necessary? It is necessary to prove that whatever the statements resulted on the ground are based upon a clear philosophy and not arbitrary or flawed assumptions. Secondly, without a moral ground, the system could lead to the perpetuation of injustices. It could lead to reverse discrimination. It can lead to confusion on the very basis of the law or the policy. With all this in mind, I present the very first quotation from the CAD. In Prof. K.T. Shah (Bihar)’s words:</p><blockquote><em>I hope no one will think it is a bee in my bonnet when I put forward this idea that there is not a trace of any desire to secure social justice, </em>a real equality of the people, not merely paper equality, but equality in actual fact, in daily living and experience, which we were promised and we had all hoped would be the result<em> after the Imperialist exploiter was ousted from the country. As I read two or three most prominent chapters or articles I feel a glaring lack of any attention being given to the disinherited, to the dispossessed, to those who have not scope to have the minimum, what I may call, </em>a decent standard of civilized existence in this country.</blockquote><p>It is very clear from this that for Shah, social justice was an achievable goal and not a moral foundation. It can be said that there is a <em>moral foundation</em> that is the driving force behind Shah’s words, but what is that foundation? We do not know. Instead, we are forced into believing here that the idea of social justice here is an “actual fact,” which again discards the possibility of Shah’s words being moral statements. Moreover, we do not get any idea of how this connects to caste-based reservations.</p><p>Balagangadhara discusses several such similar incidences in the CAD, all leading up to the same conclusion as this one. Let’s take another example of Mr. B. Das from Orissa, who said that a new moral structure of social justice had to be inculcated among the citizens of India. If that is the case, then what was the old idea of social justice? And what is the new one? We have no idea. Also, saying that this new conception of social justice can be inculcated in a country like India is not possible through policy. And if it were, then it becomes crystal clear that his statements weren’t indicative of any moral philosophy. Balagangadhara says that <em>if he was a defender of ‘justice’ as understood in normative terms, he would not have said this:</em></p><blockquote><em>Sir, I do not care for political justice. I want social and economic justice from this House…</em></blockquote><p>The next person is Mr. Devendranath Samanta from Bihar, he says:</p><blockquote><em>it has also been laid down that in the Constitution </em>adequate safeguards shall be provided <em>for minorities, Backward and Tribal Areas and Depressed and other Backward Classes, and this should be </em>quite sufficient to allay the suspicions entertained, if any, of the minorities and others whose safeguards are so assured.</blockquote><p>This quotation is particularly very relevant to our discussion here, both because it talks about social justice, and its relationship with reservations.</p><p>However, can safeguards lead us to a moral philosophy? Absolutely not. This statement is not indicative of any moral ground the reservations were built upon. What is this idea of <em>justice </em>that Samanta is speaking of here? In addition to this, Samanta also notes in the CAD that justice as used in Nehru’s resolution names a set of empirical and <em>non-normative</em> conditions. At best, we can say that reservations provide a system that puts the “caste atrocities” to rest. This is moral, but doesn’t lead us to any foundations.</p><p>Next, we have Sardar Sochet Singh from Patiala &amp; East Punjab States Union:</p><blockquote><em>the inclusion of backward sections among the Sikhs in the category of scheduled classed </em>for all political purposes is a happy decision<em>…the Sikhs wanted was social justice.</em></blockquote><p>What are these political purposes? I suppose it is very self-explanatory. His statement does not provide a moral foundation for reservations; it is far from doing so. Nobody opposed Singh’s statement here. If the makers of the constitution had no problem for certain castes to enjoy reservations for politics, then the asks of Marathas, Patidars, Jats, Gujjars, and other castes in India aren’t wrong. Then why do Ambedkarites and others oppose them? If this was the very will of our constitution makers, then their demand has to be fulfilled.</p><p>Even Dr. B.R. Ambedkar’s sayings aren’t indicative of a moral ground; they are more or less the same as what the others in the debates say. In Balagangadhara’s words:</p><blockquote><em>He wants “to make economic, social and political justice a reality” and recognises that “doing justice socially, economically and politically” is important.</em></blockquote><p>This, too, is not indicative of any moral ground. In fact, if it is true that Ambedkar wanted to abolish reservations after a specific time period, then it further strengthens our point that <em>justice</em> was an achievable goal for him. However, in political theory, it is a moral/normative concept, which by definition is not achievable. Balagangadhara continues:</p><blockquote><em>In fact, even though most of them endorsed the term ‘social justice’, </em>there was no detectable consensus about what that term meant or how it was related to caste-based reservation<em>. Some spoke only of ‘justice’ in the singular, whereas a few others spoke of ‘justices’ in the plural. </em>No one in the assembly<em>, including a dozen people who repeated Nehru’s catch-phrase, </em>appeared to show either interest in or awareness of the other modifiers to the word ‘justice’, <em>such as restorative, retributive, distributive, commutative, criminal and legal justice.</em></blockquote><p>The ones subject to criticism here are not the framers of the Constitution, but the politicians, Ambedkarites, and academics who reiterate that reservations do have a moral basis. It is the latter that has based its claims on hollow grounds. They may apply moral frameworks to these matters in CAD today, but those claims would make sense only to us and not to those who participated in the CAD.</p><p>Okay, let us assume for a moment that there was an underlying moral framework at work here, which was perhaps too obvious to be assumed that it wasn’t even mentioned. It was perhaps that moral framework in which all these lines have to be understood, and nobody was being immoral all along. If this is the case, then we will have to find the notion of social justice prevalent at those times in the world. What was the idea?</p><p><em>It was a Christian idea.</em></p><h3>Were the Framers of the Constitution Christians?</h3><p>The notion of social justice as we know it today was founded by Luigi Taparelli D’Azeglio, an Italian Jesuit. One of his students, Gioacchino Vincenzo Pecci, also became Pope Leo XIII later. Here is a summary of his idea of social justice:</p><blockquote><em>If an individual receives so much from another to whose goods he had no previous right, </em>he must give as much in return if he wishes to settle accounts according to justice<em>. Justice between equals consists therefore in a quantitative balancing or levelling; nor can justice be lessened on one side by increasing the other, since the right of the person who gave extends precisely to the thing he gave, neither more nor less. </em>Therefore, this right is satisfied by an equivalent. <em>But suppose instead that two or more individuals all seeking a common good (many sailors, for example, seeking to discover an unknown land, or many associates running a public educational establishment) compete with one another to obtain a pre-eminence or an office: does the rule of justice require you to balance accounts between the two of them? But no, that is a ridiculous thing even to say, impossible to execute. But then what does equality mean here? </em>Equality consists here in equalizing the office to the person’s capacity, the recompense to the merit, punishments to demerit, and the real order to the ideal proportions of means to end. And each person should be content to make the same contribution as every other to the common purpose. <em>(Burke)</em></blockquote><p>How do we conclude that a random idea of social justice prevalent among Christians makes its way to the world? Well, the history of this theory of social justice is not very dull.</p><blockquote>Social justice probably did not appear as a term with any special meaning until about 1850. <em>After the appearance of Leo XII’s encyclical Rerum Novarum, </em>it came into quite common use among Catholic writers. <em>By the turn of the century, moral theologians had given it recognition and </em>most of them were agreed that it named the long-ignored social virtue, legal justice. <em>At the same time </em>writers outside Leo’s intellectual tradition were beginning to use it, <em>often apparently without knowledge of the Catholic literature. </em>It was popularized by Catholics in France, Germany and the United States, and between 1910 and 1930 hundreds of books and pamphlets talked about it in popular and vague terms. The Protestants and the Jews took it up as a slogan for social reform<em>, scholarly books were written about the progress of social justice, and the term </em>found its way into such documents of state as the Versailles Treaty<em>…it is…an important concept in Catholic social thought. The encyclicals of Pius XI used it repeatedly in a more and more precise sense, clerical and lay Catholic leaders in the social movement have publicized social justice at great length; </em>in 1937 the term appeared in its precise meaning in the new Irish Constitution. <em>(Shields)</em></blockquote><p>If this is the case, then it should be very obvious that this idea of social justice would not make sense outside of the presumed Christian framework. So, if we agree with those who push forward the claim of “morality” of reservations, then we will also have to agree that the constituent assembly was filled with Christians. However, that is not the case.</p><p>This also implies that if it is presumed that there IS a moral basis to the reservations, then the framers of the constitution are immoral since they are now hypocrites. They are now accused of imposing a Christian idea of social justice on India. Therefore, one is left with 2 choices: (i) accept that reservations have no moral basis or (ii) accept that the constituent assembly was immoral.</p><p>One may say that social justice is translated to the Indian idea of samāja nyāya. This is not a well constructed argument. Nyāya in saṃskṛta translates to logic and not justice. Besides, this would be question-begging.</p><p>Now that we have explored the CAD through Dr. Balagangadhara’s paper, let us move on to more important topics.</p><h3>Do Numbers Lie?</h3><p>It is generally assumed that the lower castes deserve reservations because they routinely face violence and negative discrimination at the hands of the upper castes. The image painted by scholars is such that this violence is always on the rise and does not stop despite innumerable attempts to stop it.</p><blockquote><em>It has come to acquire the status of an axiom that violence and exploitation of all kinds, including physical atrocities, is an integral part of the caste system, and is always on the rise. </em><a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0147596714001048#:~:text=In%20India,%20former,Watch,%201999"><em>Source</em></a></blockquote><p>This violence is generally termed “caste atrocities.” The term atrocity, however, as per the UN, refers to only three heinous crimes: genocides, war crimes, and crimes against humanity. The POA Act, on the other hand, terms any crimes as caste atrocity if the victim belongs to a backward community. The scholars report caste atrocities in two different ways. The first is anecdotal evidence which we all see around us. These are individual cases that are projected as universal image of India. The second is hard data, which bases itself on statistics of caste atrocities in India.</p><p>My concern here is the latter, since that is what includes some substantial claims. Let us take the data of the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB), which started reporting the crimes against SC’s in 1995. The number of crimes is a large number, which usually makes headlines, by which we are fooled into believing the idea of social justice as painted by scholars abroad. This is also known as the <em>fallacy of floating numerators</em>. This is usually done to take advantage of what is known as data illiteracy. However, a critical analysis of the statistic tells us an entirely different story. Jalki and Pathan’s paper is very popular for doing this, and I have done the same for a recent data again:</p><p>(a) A total of 3,663,360 cognisable crimes were reported for the year 2021 in India. This means, the total number of reported crimes against the SCs in 2021 was about 1.25% of the total reported crimes in India in 2021 (Total no. of Crimes against SCs is 45961).</p><p>(b) As per the 2011 national census of India, the SCs comprise about 16.6% of the total population of India. If 16.6% of the population faces 1.25% of the total criminal incidents in India, the remaining 83.4% faces 98.75% of the rest of the criminal incidents. That means that on average, every percentage of non-SC population faces roughly 1.16% of the incidence of crime, while every percentage of the SC population faces about 0.07% of the crime.</p><p>This is mind-boggling. If such is the scenario, then what do we make of all the large claims about caste atrocities in India? While Jalki and Pathan’s paper is very popular in the mainstream, there is also a recent underrated paper by Nihar Sashittal that deserves the same limelight. Sashittal compiled NCRB and data from various surveys, etc. and graphically presented the results. The results are shocking.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/807/1*pCH9kbLidLAf6G6GUUD_eA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/807/1*V2aWAaSdu6PjsfNQLuNp7g.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/785/1*lQ9vVuhdDZBLmlp-vf58Yg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/777/1*MpuKYdY7knppUwz-kBH0FQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/773/1*upkSqrJKbBxlpslhL6_8fA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/803/1*RZylTHXCchX2XZmCZdID5A.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/802/1*dDGHMA1sde59XTmsHRVWVQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/761/1*oe107URaX8SKcVtT5XG05Q.png" /></figure><p>In fact, contrary to popular perception, the police and the judiciary give first preference to the cases that were committed against SCs and STs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/717/1*gUW_5ngTkS49m6NXcCKdCA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/710/1*uLDOh936Lx4KUJIJw6TnSQ.png" /></figure><p>In fact, as per data, 78% of the total crimes against SCs and about 70% of the total crimes against STs are lesser offenses that are booked under the POA Act only. Sashittal says that <em>as per the NCRB reports between 2001 and 2010, about 20% of the reported offenses under the POA Act have been marked as “false” after police investigations.</em> The case is still made if the violence is always on the rise, as many claim. However, statistics say that the violence has actually decreased over time.</p><blockquote><em>The latest report of NCRB for the year 2013 reported 39408 cases of congnizable crimes committed against SCs in India. This crime rate stands at 19.57 incidences per one lakh of SC population. Though the number of crimes has increased from 32996 in 1995 to 33501 in 2001 and to 39408 in 2013, the rate has substantially declined — from 23.24 in 1995 to 20.14 in 2001 and further to 19.57 in 2013. </em><a href="https://www.academia.edu/32183630/SOCIAL_EXCLUSION_DISCRIMINATION_AND_ATROCITIES_ON_SCHEDULED_CASTES_IN_INDIA_THE_WORRYING_SPOTS_AND_FUTURE_CHALLENGES_1_SOCIAL_EXCLUSION_AND_DISCRIMINATION_THE_INDIAN_CONTEXT"><em>Source</em></a></blockquote><p>The statistics become even more depressing when one takes into account that not all crimes committed against lower castes are committed because of <em>casteism</em>. What if the accused doesn’t even know the identity of the victim in case of an unknown robbery? What about the crimes committed by non-Hindu groups such as Islam and Christianity?</p><p>One may even claim that this is the situation because cases are underreported. Well, under-reporting is used as a limitation of not getting accurate results in statistics. However, in India, this fallacy is used as the sword that upholds the theory and the classical conception of the caste system. How can a fallacy sustain a scientific sociological theory? Even multiplying the number conventionally by 2, 4, or 10 doesn’t yield us results.</p><p>And if there is no data to support this statement, then what is the basis and foundation of the argument that people make that Indian society has caste violence? Just because Indian society is casteist from its origins? This does not make a good case, as it incurs a logical fallacy known as <em>a priori,</em> where a fact is assumed just on a theological basis with no statistical or logical evidence. And if the crimes are underreported and the data cannot be relied upon, then what is the basis on which the big news headlines are making their way day in and day out proclaiming their new statistical and anecdotal evidence every day?</p><p>Furthermore, Jalki and Pathan write:</p><blockquote><em>An analysis of writings related to caste violence (comprising letters to the editor, editorials, reports and research articles) published in the Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) over five decades from 1949 to 2000 show some definite trends in the way scholars have dealt with the issue. One of the most striking aspects of reviewing this literature is that one clearly finds that </em>the idea of ‘caste atrocities’ is largely a late-1960s development, which ‘caught on’ in the 1970s. There is not a single entry in the EPW issues prior to 1968 on the issue of caste atrocities<em>…Also, who victimizes the lower castes? Surprisingly, we find in caste violence reportage that </em>it is not necessary that the perpetrator of atrocities or victimiser be an upper caste individual or group. <em>Where upper caste persons are not involved, the ‘system’ — read ‘the caste system’ or/and ‘Brahmanism’ — is held responsible for the so-called atrocities. This is not a trend that we notice in some sloppy journalistic reportage in newspapers and tabloids. </em>This trend is visible in the most scholarly writings of the last several decades that India has produced…We have found about 60 relevant articles on or around ‘caste atrocities’ in 2283 issues of the journal over 50 years. Interestingly, Brahmins do not feature anywhere as perpetrators of violence in these articles of over 50 years. Only in one case is it alleged that a convict had the support of a Brahmin moneylender. <em>The articles, nevertheless, talk about ‘upper castes’, without always specifying who the upper castes are. In addition, one finds the following words and phrases liberally used in these writings while analyzing the issue: ‘Brahmanical caste system’, ‘Brahmanical social setup’, ‘Brahmanism’ and ‘brahmanical model’. These words act as ‘explanations’ for the violence that has occurred. The caste system is violent because it is ‘Brahmanical’ </em>However, none of them show what is so “Brahminical” about the violence committed by non-Brahmins.</blockquote><p>In fact, it gets even more suspicious when we find that in several headlines and academic articles, OBCs are labelled as upper castes if the victim is a SC/ST. Consequently, OBCs also become lower castes if the story demands so.</p><p>This is a serious matter not only in statistics but also for geopolitics. It is India whose reputation is harmed due to false statements. It faces severe criticism from human rights activists across the world, the Cisco Systems case being no exception. Sashittal writes:</p><blockquote><em>The United States State Department, in its 2014 yearly human rights report on India, makes the claim that the </em>“National crime statistics indicated that, compared with other caste affiliations, rape was most often perpetrated against Dalit women”.<em> This claim has been repeated in many other yearly human rights reports of the State Department. </em>However, a look at the crime statistics from the yearly reports of NCRB tells us that no data from any of the yearly reports can be used to make this claim.</blockquote><p>Note that my claim here is not that there are no or negligible crimes against backward communities, but that it has to be understood in a better manner and not through fallacies. <em>So, rather than asserting the absence or existence of violence, a useful approach is to rigorously understand the levels of violence using scientific controls and references</em>.</p><p>For anecdotal evidence, I will present only one example. It is a report published in the reputed Times Higher Education called ‘Caste discrimination is a global problem’ by Saikat Majumdar. The report basically claimed that caste is now a global issue and that Indian students living abroad face it every day (especially in the US and UK). Dr. Prakash Shah has analyzed this report here:</p><p><a href="https://opo.iisj.net/index.php/osls/article/view/1695">Caste studies today</a></p><p>One of Majumdar’s chief claims is about the infamous suicide of Rohith Vemula, while nothing else about the connection of caste and suicide is known. The claims of caste discrimination against him are made without even knowing any incidence of discrimination with him. Majumdar calls this <em>institutional murder</em> but fails to explain what he means by it. De Roover writes in his article:</p><blockquote>Rohith Vemula’s suicide note does not mention caste oppression, although a host of commentators from politicians to academics tried to paint the caste system as the cause of his suicide. Telangana police said at one point that he wasn’t a Dalit, which puts in doubt his position in any claimed caste hierarchy.</blockquote><p>Such oversimplification is very common among anecdotal evidence. In fact, Majumdar has been a victim of confirmation bias various times in his article. One of them happens when he calls the rape of a 19-year-old Dalit woman in Hathras a caste violence. Four people were charged during this case, but the facts were disputed even among the police. Without investigating the dynamics and conflicting evidences in a case, how can Majumdar term this crime as a caste atrocity?</p><p>Not all crimes against backward classes can be classified as “caste” atrocities, because not all of them are committed knowing the caste of the victim. The motivation isn’t caste always. The reference to <em>caste</em>, is not a reference to the <em>caste system</em>. Majumdar doesn’t stop though, he further lists the lawsuit against Cisco, and the individual case of Suraj Yengde. Both of these have been dealt with in a past article of mine:</p><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/@akshadrathi0705/balagangadhara-caste-and-christianity-550af285e934">Balagangadhara, Caste, and Christianity</a></li><li><a href="https://medium.com/@akshadrathi0705/balagangadhara-caste-and-christianity-part-ii-b0fdcb065c9d">Balagangadhara, Caste, and Christianity: Part II</a></li></ul><p>Shah writes:</p><blockquote><em>Majumdar however, grants this so-called discrimination at Cisco Systems to the whiteness of the Brahmins. In fact, if one accepts the claims being made by the DFEH (CRD) in the Cisco litigation, then the very opposite would be the case. </em>If upper caste or Brahmin managers at Cisco were indeed discriminating against fellow employees, wouldn’t it highlight their Indian-ness rather than their whiteness? <em>After all, haven’t generations of observers over the last two centuries held the view that caste is quintessentially Indian or Hindu? Even </em>Wilkerson, who has tried to make the case that caste exists in the United States, and did so under Nazi Germany, has recourse to the “lingering, millennia-long caste system of India” as its paradigmatic instance. These propositions can be seen as an instance of another fallacy, that of reductio ad Hitlerum which puts adherence to caste beyond the pale by association with grievous abuses.</blockquote><p>The implications of such reports are such that the reverse discrimination against upper castes is not uncommon. For instance, Yengde said on X (Formerly Twitter):</p><blockquote>This ugly head dumpster — Shankaracharya is responsible for crimes such as this</blockquote><p>I do not want to imagine what would happen if a person said the same about Dr. Ambedkar. Such words, against any popular figure who is joint to sentiments of millions are not forgivable. However, they are justified under flags of <em>caste discrimination</em>. In fact, Yengde has publicly stated that people such as Sundar Pichai and Satya Nadella bring caste to the US in <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NEjfA47QcG0">this video (6:20)</a>.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FNEjfA47QcG0&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DNEjfA47QcG0&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FNEjfA47QcG0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/4e1186714e95038cda96e0d00c05a1c3/href">https://medium.com/media/4e1186714e95038cda96e0d00c05a1c3/href</a></iframe><p>Priyamvada Gopal, professor at Cambridge University’s Faculty of English also said:</p><blockquote>I’m from a Brahmin family. That makes me a Brahmin. I will say this too then, since Brahmins are the whites of India. Brahmin lives don’t matter — not as ‘Brahmin’ lives. Abolish Brahmins and the upper castes.</blockquote><p>Again, imagine if the same had been called out for other jātis. Such words, even if <em>hyperbole,</em> should not be normalized ever.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Caste-based reservations have no moral basis. This is very clear from the CAD. With this, people who defend or oppose the reservations on moral grounds have to modify their positions. Or else they would simply be lying. Another option would be to accept that the constituent assembly were Christians in disguise, which to me is not acceptable. Balagangadhara writes:</p><blockquote><em>The caste-based reservation system is neither rational nor moral. One has to say that Indians are either irrational or immoral or both, if they defend reservation. The British were reluctant to give self-rule or independence to India because many were convinced that Indians were immoral and irrational. Looking from the outside today, one is compelled to ask: were the British telling the truth?</em></blockquote><p>What I have concluded from this article is not that there is no such discrimination in India or that all the evidence that is for such discrimination is false. I say that <em>caste</em> is not an explanation for all this. If it were, then Majumdar’s report wouldn’t have fallen down so easily. Without caste, too, these instances could be explained. As I have previously stated in a different article of mine, caste does not and cannot exist outside the European experiential mind. Scholars, the Government, and laymen themselves have to find a different explanation for these crimes.</p><p>Why is this important? Well, we have already seen the quotations and instances of reverse discrimination. Even if ignored, the reputation on India globally is prone to deteriorate under the banners of <em>caste</em>.</p><p>The counter that usually comes for these claims is that Hindu texts do mention the “hate” for lower classes. Well, whether it is “hate” or “tough love” can be debated upon. But, even if it is hate, we have seen above through statistics that the upper <em>castes </em>have minimized this hate at an extreme level. Also, if such “hate,” as they claim, is a Hindu practice, then has the law prevented them from practicing it? If yes, then what else have they dropped? There surely has to be more to the story. And if this is true, then their social and religious security has been interfered upon, which would be against social justice. As B. Das himself said in the CAD, <em>social security means social justice for all</em>.</p><p>If these practices are to be dropped because it is necessary for <em>social reform</em>. Then one may ask, <em>What is the moral basis for reform?</em></p><p>The bibliography for this article can be found in the following document:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fdocs.google.com%2Fdocument%2Fd%2F1vWR7pBUCo6sq6WTxBjbFaUBGV_GZE-OG9TwRV2vaIOk%2Fpreview%3Fembedded%3Dtrue&amp;display_name=Google+Docs&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fdocs.google.com%2Fdocument%2Fd%2F1vWR7pBUCo6sq6WTxBjbFaUBGV_GZE-OG9TwRV2vaIOk%2Fedit%3Fusp%3Dsharing&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Flh7-us.googleusercontent.com%2Fdocs%2FAHkbwyIlyHpUNs11LLqwJ3GqVCE_ytzw0h0qakK2glE-vFrz23SgPd5Rsqy5pMirADHZoNPreFhKpoi0y0Ebbyo5GKjk1eFeVq2hoXmyv89JOWGqdyudLa4p%3Dw1200-h630-p&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;scroll=auto&amp;schema=google" width="700" height="530" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/a4ddf5a45841abf806b06e3d971b79da/href">https://medium.com/media/a4ddf5a45841abf806b06e3d971b79da/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d8f2caa3e78e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Balagangadhara, Caste, and Christianity: Part II]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@akshadrathi0705/balagangadhara-caste-and-christianity-part-ii-b0fdcb065c9d?source=rss-50eb3738c5d8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b0fdcb065c9d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[decoloniality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[caste]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Akshad Rathi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 09 Mar 2024 10:29:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-06T10:37:28.814Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Does Caste Exist? Part II</h3><h4>Part II : The Christianity of Caste</h4><p><em>The argument presented below, is largely based upon the works of “the Ghent School”. The school constitutes researchers working at Balagangadhara (Balu)’s research programme on the Comparative Science of Cultures. (For more information, see De Roover, 2019).</em></p><p>Click here to read <a href="https://medium.com/@akshadrathi0705/balagangadhara-caste-and-christianity-550af285e934">Part I</a></p><p>For a list of references of this article, click <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/18HLt2hioQLgp-Ap6_Z43Xjh9xkNfOvysue-o0SNA3zE/edit?usp=sharing">here</a></p><p>Imagine pre-sixteenth century Europe. A large landmass stuck in its dark ages. All the power, both political and spiritual, lay in the hands of a few. These were the Pope, the Bishops, the (Holy) Roman Emperor, the Nobles, and the princes of the states. These people thought of themselves as the heads of the holy Christian world, who had vowed to bring enlightenment (read Christianity) to the rest of the world. Everybody else in the holy Christian world was inferior, and harassed by these heads, both socially and economically.</p><p>The society was divided into three “orders”, or “estates”. On the top were the priestly class, after them came the ruling class, and on the bottom were the laborers, artisans, etc. This was also known as the Sacred Hierarchy. The priests were the people who acted as the mediators between God and the common people. The ruling elite had to govern the state and all of the material realm. The third order had to commit to their job and convert themselves to the complete submission to God. Since the priestly class were the chosen people of God, they had complete monopoly over basically everything, using this power, they often oppressed the commoners. If the priestly power was questioned, the Christian dogma reinforced itself and the question itself became a violation of God’s will, and thus, a sin.</p><p>Such oppression has, throughout history, always resulted in a counter hegemony. The Christian world was no exception. Several voices began to rise against the Catholic Church and its priests, bishops, and archbishops. The most notable voice among these was Martin Luther. Luther argued that the power of the Church had derived itself from the Monastery. The latter never showed such an extensive interest in worldly matters but had surrendered themselves to God. Therefore, to reach God, one did not need the help of these mediators. Just with faith and devotion, one could reach the supreme. The oppressed commoners of Europe had finally sought a resort in the words of Luther. His opposition to the Catholic Church was so exorbitant that more than half of his <em>Ninety-Five Theses</em> is just a criticism of the Church (De Roover and Claerhout 2015). Later, with the Treaty of Westphalia and other incidents, Luther’s interpretation of Christianity was admitted as a valid sect of the religion under Protestantism. However, this came after a brutal <em>Thirty Years’ War</em> in Europe. The Roman Empire, now split into several territories started to maintain an army and used the methods invented by the Portuguese and the Spaniards to colonize the non-Christian world in order to prove their commitment to Christianity and the supremacy of their sect (See: Deepak 2021, pp. 76–119 for more references on the Reformation).</p><p>The “discovery” of the non-Christian (Heathen) world began. The Christians, amazed on knowing so much outside their region tried to make sense of everything. After all, the imperialist attitudes had to be satisfied. There is more than enough evidence for us to establish that the Europeans interpreted the Heathen world and people based upon the framework produced during the Reformation and assumed Biblical notions (Malhotra and Nilakandan 2011, pp. 12–50; Deepak 2021, pp. 150–175; De Roover and Claerhout 2015; Fárek <em>et al</em>. 2017; De Roover 2017). Therefore, to understand the development of the theory of caste, we have to dissect the fundamental Protestant beliefs the Europeans brought with them when they came to India.</p><p>Just like the Catholics, Protestants too believed that all civilisations in the world followed a religion. A civilisation without a religion would be like a body without a soul. There is no problem with the use of the word “religion” here, every civilisation has followed one or the other faith system. Even not believing in a faith system itself becomes a faith system. However, the problem here is the connotation to the word. For Christians, a religion had to satisfy some criteria to become a religion. The criteria was its closeness to Christianity. For example, strictly following a book or being monotheistic would increase a religion’s respect. At the same time, being polytheistic or ritualistic would invite slurs. With this, all the world’s religions were divided into three categories, as per Protestants: (i) Christians, who were at the epitome of a truly advanced society, (ii) Heretics like Islam and Judaism who followed practices similar to Christians, these people could be “civilized” due to their adherence to a single book, etc. However, (iii) the Heathens were the worst of all beings, who were even worse than a human, “civilizing” them was a great task. The heathens followed rituals which were fabrications of some cunning humans. They did not follow one book and were polytheistic. Hinduism, as is evident, falls into the third category (See: Balagangadhara 2018 for an elaborate discussion of the Christian epistemology on this subject).</p><p>Now, all the practices which were allegedly religious to Hindus became not only immoral for the Christians, they became a violation of the Gospel, <em>they became a sin</em>. We cannot obviously conclude the immorality of caste from this, we have more Protestant ontology to deal with. But, before that, we need to establish that they saw the caste system as a religious and not a secular institution. What is the evidence for this? The evidence for these claims are the writings of the Europeans themselves. I will present one such instance, noted by De Roover and Claerhout. This incident is known as the “Malabar Rites Controversy”. The person to initiate this controversy was an interesting Jesuit missionary named Roberto De Nobili. Nobili had adopted several Hindu practices and even started dressing like a Hindu ascetic. He called himself a Brāhmaṇa while comfortably being a Jesuit. For him, Brāhmaṇas weren’t some priests, but wise and intelligent people who are respected because of their knowledge. For the proof, he resorted to texts such as the Mānavadharmaśāstra.</p><p>This new phase of Nobili’s life was reported by some other Jesuits to Rome. The Church immediately shook up. <em>How could a Jesuit like Nobili make such claims?</em>, they thought. Are Brāhmaṇas not priests, and just some intelligent people in the Indian subcontinent? If they were indeed not related to religion, then there was no problem in becoming a Brāhmaṇa. However, if one could find a relation between the Brāhmaṇa “Caste” and the Hindu “religion”, then Nobili had been committing sins all along. All the human fabrications in religion, according to the Protestants, had to be renounced in order to reach God. For humans did not have the capability to create something that would lead one to God, such authority lies with God himself. Even if one could prove a relationship between playing cards and religion, then playing cards would also become a sin. Now, imagine how furious the Church would be on Nobili, if some other person had proved some relation between Caste and religion, that too a “Heathen” religion. The opposition Nobili faced was from none other than the renowned Jesuit Francis Xavier, who considered Brāhmaṇas to be related to the false religion (i.e. Hinduism):</p><blockquote>Brachmanes, who are the guardians of paganism, for they stay in the Temple and take care of the Idols: they are the most perverse and evil of men […] They are the greatest liars and impostors that ever existed: their profession is to deceive the poor and take advantage of the weakness and simplicity of an ignorant mass, making them believe that the Gods command the sacrifice of all kinds of things, while they desire these things for themselves to maintain their families. (Xavier 1660, pp. 62)</blockquote><p>One cannot help but notice the importance which religiosity made in the Malabar Rites Controversy. And, even the religiosity of a Hindu practice has emerged in a Protestant Christian framework. Therefore, to understand more about caste, we have to delve deeper into the Protestant ontology.</p><p>The Sacred Hierarchy we discussed earlier was of great horror to the Protestants, because according to them no such order can be related to Christianity.. This was just a way to accumulate wealth for the priests. The Sacred Hierarchy immediately became an evil idea (De Roover and Claerhout 2015).</p><p>Okay, let us quickly summarize the Protestant theology discussed in this section so far: The idol-worshippers and pagans like Hindus are immoral, because they are human fabrications. We can reach God only by firm faith in him, and no mediators like the priests were required because humans cannot possess the ability to send someone to God’s abode. Therefore, the priests were greedy, cunning, and immoral people. Any practice that was human fabrication and not mentioned in “the book” was <em>also immoral</em>, because again, humans do not possess such an ability. The estates, or the sacred hierarchy is also such a fabrication and hence, it is to be renounced. Following even one human fabrication is a sin, and gets us away from God. Therefore, all such human fabrications should be condemned and eradicated from the world.</p><p>With this conceptual framework, when the Europeans came to India, they immediately saw widespread immorality. Firstly, the Hindus were immoral because of their pagan nature. Secondly, they weren’t sure why people respected Brāhmaṇas so much, when they came to know that they were priests of some kind, they immediately became greedy and cunning. How can I say this with confidence? It is because the Christian priests and the Hindu Brāhmaṇas lead two very different lives. While the former can enjoy material pleasures and accumulate wealth, the latter has to lead a very disciplined life and can only live on alms. If the Protestant theology is not presumed, the claims people today make about the latter would fall like a tower of cards. Thirdly, now that the caste system was seen as a Hindu religious practice, it became immoral and oppressive since it was allegedly analogous with the Christian Sacred Hierarchy. Endogamy became the prime characteristic of the caste system, because it maintained the purity of blood of the Aryans (For more on Endogamy, see Fárek 2017).</p><p>Therefore, unique Hindu society, which was conflated with Christian experience in the European mind gave rise to the “Caste System”. This is the reason we were unable to equate caste with any Indic concept in section one.</p><p>One may point out that we are fighting over the use of the word ‘caste’, which is indeed new, but the connotation is not. Well, we saw that caste connotes to nothing we expected it to in the first section. Also, words and concepts are never alone, they are always a part of some framework or another. What are these frameworks? Concepts are always enjoined and connected with some other concepts. These connections form large clusters of knowledge. These clusters are embedded in a larger theological and epistemological framework. One word, which makes complete sense in one framework, would even lose common sense in the other, because in the other framework, it lacks the basic tools and clusters to derive its meaning. When you say one word, the clusters that word is a part of get stimulated. The word may lose its meaning, if taken outside of the conceptual framework. Indian ideas crystallized around Christian clusters have given rise to Caste.</p><p>When you say the word caste, concepts such as “Hierarchy”, “Dominance”, “Discrimination”, “Reservations’’, “Profession”, “Endogamy’’, “Mobility”, etc. immediately come into your mind. This is because caste forms a cluster with these words. The moment caste comes into the discussion, all these words indirectly come with it, because without these, both the word and the framework are incomplete. To make the words keep its meaning, it brings with it the whole cluster. Similarly, when we talk of, let’s say, Varṇa. It forms clusters with concepts such as “Adhikāra”, “Svadharma”, “Karma”, “Prārabhdha”, “Saṁskāra”, “Guṇa”, etc.</p><p>The moment you try to equate these radically different concepts, you are not just conventionally translating the word from a language to another, you are actually shifting between two different frameworks. When this happens, a large number of problems rise, some of which we saw in section one. When everyday scholars work on such topics, they develop more and more <em>ad hoc</em> theories to uphold the classical conception of the caste system, which has emerged solely from the Christian theological framework. By calling it a reality in India’s social life, they mix up the frameworks, when such a collision happens, ugly theories about Indians are automatically produced. Wilkerson’s work, cited in the beginning of this article, is a very recent example of that. In fact, there is a stark continuity between the works of colonial Orientalists and the opinions of present day scholars such as Wilkerson and Yengde proved in a very recent paper by Fárek (2023).</p><p>If there is indeed a continuity in the works of these scholars, then are the present-day activists just reiterating centuries old Christian debates? Are they inherently Christian in nature? Many of these people may not even know a word about the Protestant reformation, but if they don’t, how can they still reproduce these works and even call them scientific? The process is known as “Secularization of Knowledge”. <em>Secularization</em> here doesn’t mean the distancing of knowledge from religion, but it means the portrayal of religious knowledge (which is Christian), as scientific, and secular knowledge.</p><p>How did this happen? To understand this, we have to move again to the clusters we saw previously. We have two frameworks, one with the Christian theology and the one that is scientific and contains clusters with commonplace ideas. The former has seen the non-Christian society through its own framework and has developed Christian theories for them. Now, through centuries of works of European thinkers, these theories with the larger European framework get embedded into the scientific framework (De Roover and Claerhout 2015). Now, since the Christian experience becomes THE scientific theory, the cultural and civilisational experience of Europe becomes the universal experience of the world. In this sense, every civilisation should have some basic concepts which are comparable to other civilisations. The closer it is to Europe, the ideal. All the civilisations ought to have a religion now, they ought to have a God or <em>Gods</em>, they have to have a specified territory and they have to have an opposition to the religion they follow from the inside, if it is the false religion.</p><p>With this, most academia is just Christian at its roots. Every single slur about Brāhmaṇas, every single attempt to call the structures prescribed by Manu and other ṛṣis “oppressive”, every single theory on the endogamy as <em>purity of blood</em>, the Aryan Invasion, and so many other phenomenon become Christian in nature. Those who accuse the Brāhmaṇas of gatekeeping and protecting their “privileges” might not even know that they are speaking a Christian language. This is the extent to which the secularized Christian knowledge has infiltrated our minds.</p><p>Buddha, in this framework, becomes the Martin Luther of India who wished to eradicate the evil of “Caste” (equated with Varṇa now) from India. However, as Balagangadhara (2015, pp. 207–210) has shown, the works of Buddhists reveal that they supported the Varṇa system more than opposing it. They debated on how glorious a true Brāhmaṇa is, rather than discussions on how to defeat them. Even though these Buddhist ideals were not in line with the Hindu concepts, the opposition to the social structure was never as widespread as it is portrayed. Fárek (2017) has shown, even the Bhakti traditions supported and kept their “Brahminical” standards, leave eradicating them. We see that both the concepts “Caste” and “Varṇa (even jāti for that matter)” are different and make sense only in their own framework.</p><p>Therefore, Caste cannot, and does not exist outside the European experience. Caste is an experiential entity, an entity of the West which has no significance in India. The Europeans, based on their own experience, perceived Indian society and connected several unrelated instances to each other which gave rise to the caste system. I am not denying those instances, what I am denying is that they together constitute a system like that of caste. To understand this, Balagangadhara (2012) invites us to a fictional world:</p><blockquote>Imagine an extraterrestrial coming to earth and noticing the following phenomena: the grass is green; milk turns sour; birds fly; and some flowers give out a fragrant smell. He is convinced that these phenomena are related to each other and sees (let us say) <em>hipkapi </em>in them. The presence of hipkapi not only explains but also shows that they are related to each other. To those who doubt the existence of hipkapi, he draws their attention to its visible manifestation: the tigers eating the gazelle; dogs chasing the cats; and the massive size of the elephants. Each is a fact, as everyone can see. […] hipkapi not only becomes a synonym for these phenomena but also turns out to be their explanation. Thereafter, to ask what hipkapi is, or how it explains, is an expression of one’s idiocy: does not everyone see hipkapi, this self-explanatory thing?</blockquote><p>Here, as we see, Hipkapi is an experiential entity which has no reality outside the alien’s mind. Same is with caste. There can be heinous instances where some so-called “upper castes” have discriminated against the so-called “lower castes’’, there can be a system of Endogamy in some social groups, there can be a unique hierarchy of certain groups in India, some people may oppose India’s natural social structures. However, all of these do not constitute a singular system in India that explains this stuff. In an unpublished report, Balagangadhara says that all the references to caste are narrate <em>“(i) stories of discrimination about water wells; (ii) physical beatings; (iii) denial of entry into the temples; and (iv) ‘untouchability’”</em>. But, we aren’t sure if they are the <em>properties</em> or the <em>consequences </em>of the caste system. In both the routes, we have ambiguous conclusions that do not explain anything about the caste system.</p><p>Many fallacies are used to uphold the same old story of caste. A recent report by Saikat Majumdar (2021) argues that caste is a global problem that is to be dealt with. However, he offers no statistical evidence for his claims, all he does is to cite numerous instances where caste has played a role. Every single claim of his is a hub of fallacies which Shah (2023) has recently critiqued. What is more shocking is that this report was not only published, but also recommended by the Deputy Features Editor of an institution as reputed as Times Higher Education. If such is the standard of a report which perhaps had to be one of the most respected ones, what can we make of the headlines, reports, articles, and papers we deal with everyday? Is that the standard to which India studies have now fallen down to?</p><h4><strong>Conclusion: The Warfare of Caste?</strong></h4><p>Indians often refer to the caste system to talk about their own social systems. Such casual talks about “caste” by common folks in India are then used to fuel the story of caste abroad. Just as Malhotra and Viswanathan (2022) has shown, an orchestrated movement against India’s integrity is being set up by using new ideologies like Wokeism. Malhotra unfolds serious consequences that lie for India if the textbook conception of caste is not challenged. What started as a debate between Catholics and Protestants is now used as a weapon in the hands of people who seek to dismantle India’s integrity. Caste is portrayed not only as the essence of Indian society, but also the reason for racial discrimination worldwide. Apartheid in South Africa and Nazism in Germany get blamed on the Indian caste system.</p><p>Recently, a lawsuit was filed against Cisco Systems. The reason was growing caste discrimination at their workplaces. Even though internal reviews have found that no caste discrimination took place at Cisco Systems (Chandler 2020), activists are using this incident as an example of caste discrimination. In fact, the manager against whom the whole case was built up turned out to be the person who gave leadership opportunities and special bonuses to the said victim. Two things can be concluded from this, (i) Several forces are actively working to make caste a protected category in Western countries, and (ii) Anybody who doesn’t comply to the standards prescribed by the new left (i.e. the Woke) will have to suffer the same fate as Cisco Systems (Malhotra &amp; Viswanathan 2022, pp. 89–93).</p><p>Ajantha Subramanian, professor of anthropology at Harvard also helped build the case against Cisco (Aic 2021). People like Subramanian are using caste to undermine meritocracy in India. For her, IITs are the bastions of casteism in India. The alumni, professors, students, and the syllabi of IITs have to be dismissed as the proponents of casteism (See: Subramanian 2019, Malhotra 2022, pp. 104–131).</p><p>As exposed by Malhotra, these are not some singular movements, but a part of a large nexus that is operating to undermine India’s integrity. Sadly, many Indian influencers, billionaires, activists, and academicians are sold out in this game played in the name of social justice and humanitarianism (Malhotra 2022, pp. 361–413, 517–583).</p><p>If India continues to accept these Western views without ever questioning their authenticity, it is going to have dire implications for India. Most caste studies that have been done in the past two hundred years resemble nothing about India. These studies that use slippery slopes and <em>ad hocs</em> to make their case should not be considered accurate at all. They should be termed pseudoscientific, for they rely on nothing other than the Christian experience of Indian society. It is high time that we realize that our basic conceptions about our own society are affected by the Christian view of <em>their</em> own society and theorize our own society in a way that it exists in the Indian framework.</p><p>The caste system is a dogma, circular clusters of knowledge where a neighboring cluster can be referred to protect another cluster. This is how every caste study protects its core conceptions. There is no way a dogma can be refuted, all a person needs to verify the claims of a dogma is to have a firm belief in it. There is no evidence, as we saw above, to verify the claims of a certain caste system. And, as Christopher Hitchens said, <em>what can be asserted without evidence, can also be dismissed without evidence</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b0fdcb065c9d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Balagangadhara, Caste, and Christianity]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@akshadrathi0705/balagangadhara-caste-and-christianity-550af285e934?source=rss-50eb3738c5d8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/550af285e934</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[decoloniality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[caste]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Akshad Rathi]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 05 Mar 2024 11:38:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-01-14T16:28:31.695Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Does Caste Exist? Part I</h3><h4>Part I : The Ambiguity of Caste</h4><p><em>The argument presented below, is largely based upon the works of “the Ghent School”. The school constitutes researchers working at Balagangadhara (Balu)’s research programme on the Comparative Science of Cultures. (For more information, see De Roover, 2019).</em></p><p>For a list of references of this article, click <a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1uuFbuNhWirlQl1VB-Z1SHLLK7DYeOsM8WFqMJSCO4pI/edit?usp=sharing">here</a></p><p>Caste has today become a buzzword across the globe. Especially for human rights activists abroad. For instance, Isabel Wilkerson calls caste the mother of all racism. For her, caste is the grammar of racism, a structure on which all discrimination operates over the globe. In fact, even the atrocities committed in the Nazi Germany get blamed on the same system (Wilkerson 2020, pp. 16–19). A recent critique of Wilkerson’s book notes:</p><blockquote>[Wilkerson] explains that caste is the grammar that structures the language of race, ‘the bones beneath the skin’, the beams and joists of the national house, the infrastructure of our subdivisions, the subconscious code maintaining the architecture of human hierarchy, an operating system for economic and social interactions, a cultural DNA, a wordless usher guiding us to our seats, an intravenous drip into the mind.<em> </em>(Gidla and Horn, 2021)</blockquote><p>What evil is this, which has been oppressing a very specific community for thousands of years? How has it been able to do so? Who protects it? How did it come to be? And, what does it <em>actually </em>mean?</p><p>In the standard textbook account of the Caste System, we find repeated references to four principles, on which this evil and immoral system allegedly rests on. Jalki and Pathan (2015) list down these principles, which are: (a) Occupational Division sanctioned by Hinduism, (b) Hereditary Membership, (c) Endogamy, and (d) Discrimination against lower castes or/and outcastes through untouchability. The job left for a scholar is now to build upon this framework and address the problems raised by this immoral structure. However, I would first call off to revise all these principles and question if the caste system really rests on them.</p><p>To move forward with the first claim, that the caste system is an occupational division sanctioned by Hindu rituals, we would first need a basic unit of caste. In other words, what do Indians understand caste to be? There are several contenders for this, with the most prevalent ones being <em>Varṇa</em> and <em>Jāti</em>. Since caste is seen as the “mother of all racism”, and a “subconscious code” maintaining the human hierarchy, one would expect to have a clear-cut definition of caste. However, what we find are ambiguous claims about the basic unit of it. Accounts of no two scholars match completely. Some scholars escape the discussion by conflating both Varṇa and Jāti (See: Jaiswal 1998). However, these explanations do not satisfy our expectations. How would these scholars address the relationship (if any) between Varṇa and Jāti?</p><p>Caste, thus, becomes the apocryphal elephant in the room. In fact, the scholars at Balu’s research programme argue that we don’t even have clear knowledge about very basic concepts of caste. For Example, what constitutes the basic unit? How are they related? What sustains it? What does it serve to protect and so on and so forth. The only thing we know is that the caste system is an ancient Indian oppressive structure which is hierarchical. (Fárek <em>et al</em>. 2017).</p><p>This would give a devastating look to the South Asian/Indology Departments across the world. If we do not have “clear knowledge” about this system, how can we make up our mind to eradicate it from the face of Earth? How can we be sure that it is immoral? Yet, we have to continue with our investigation so as to understand “what evil is this”. The first step for us is to find the basic unit of caste. Therefore, we have to move forward with the most commonly referred contenders and verify the claims being made about them today.</p><p>I would first start with jāti, because it is the most widely shared view among sociologists today. Padma Bhusan awardee and India’s eminent sociologist M.N. Srinivas also thinks of caste as jāti (Ames and Srinivas 1964). For having an open-minded discussion, we first need to free ourselves with the definition(s) of jāti as we understand it. But, similarity with caste ends here. Samarendra (2014) correctly points out:</p><blockquote>in vernacular literature, we come across the Lohar and the Sonar jati (professional communities), the Maratha and the Bangla jati (linguistic or cultural communities), the Hindu and Mussalman jati (putatively, religious communities), the Munda and the Oraon jati (communities presently registered in the government documents as tribes), the Vaidya and the Bhumi-har jati (communities which are endogamous), <em>mardon ki jat </em>and <em>aurat jat </em>(community of men and community of women), etc.</blockquote><p>Jāti, at best, means a community. Even in the ancient Sanskrit literature, we find that Varṇas are being referred to as jātis. It should not be concluded from this that the former and the latter and the one and the same. This is because, Śūdra Varṇa can be referred to as Śūdra jāti without changing the meaning. But, any other jāti, for example Sūta, can never be called as Sūta Varṇa. Therefore, to remove the ambiguity surrounding this word, we need to apply the lens of some other property that is joint with the caste system and can be observed empirically. According to me, there can be no property as good as Endogamy which can help us now. After all, Dr. Ambedkar termed endogamy to be the only characteristic that can be called the essence of Caste (Ambedkar 2015).</p><p>Before moving forward, I would like to tell the readers about yet another concept i.e. <em>sub-caste</em>. Those who favor jāti to be an accurate conception of caste claim that there are numerous sub-castes within a caste which are again endogamous groups. Even a 10-year old would notice the self-contradicting claim here, if castes are endogamous, how is it possible that some groups inside a caste are also endogamous? Collection of numerous endogamous groups does not create one big endogamous group. Jalki and Pathan (2015) demonstrate this problem by showcasing some jātis of Karnataka:</p><blockquote>Among Kurubas, there are Halu Kuruba, Jenu Kuruba, Sanna Kuruba, Dodda Kuruba, Kadu Kuruba and so on. And among Nayakas, there are Myasa Nayaka, Valmiki Nayaka, Beda Nayaka, Uru Nayaka, and so on. In no case do we find that one ‘sub-caste’ of Kuruba is allowed to marry with another sub-caste of Kuruba, and the same applies to the Nayaka as well. In other words, Kadu Kurubas and Jenu Kurubas do not inter-marry, and Myasa Nayakas and Uru Nayakas do not inter-marry. Now, if you say that a caste is an in-marrying group, which unit is caste here: Kuruba or Kadu Kuruba, Nayaka or Myasa Nayaka?</blockquote><p>Therefore, there are three solutions which we can derive from this, (i) Label sub-castes as the real castes, (ii) Defy endogamy to be a constitutive property or (iii) Completely reject the jāti hypothesis.</p><p>If sub-castes are made to be the real castes, then even more questions wait our way. If, for example, Kadu Kuruba is the real caste, then what do we make of Kuruba? Another question would be, since castes such Kadu Kuruba, Halu Kuruba, Dodda Kuruba, etc. are now endogamous and self-sustaining units, what would bind all of them together into one big “Kuruba” unit? We do not have answers to these questions now, which leads us to our second solution- to defy Endogamy as a property of the Caste system. However, this solution looks naive to me. Just because an explanation is not meeting the expectations of a constitutive property of the caste system, we cannot reject the property, we have to reject our hypothesis. Therefore, jāti cannot be said to be a unit for caste.</p><p>Now, we need to move on to our next contender: Varṇa. I have no problem in conventionally accepting Varṇa to be caste. It meets all our expectations. It is sanctified by Hinduism, it is hereditary, and it is endogamous. The only exception is that it is not oppressive, but many people consider it to be one. Since proving that Varṇa is not oppressive is out of the scope of our discussion, we will leave it here and go with the mainstream conception, that the system is oppressive.</p><p>But, let’s not forget the reality we are supposed to describe. No society anywhere in India is divided on the lines of Varṇa. The fourfold division which this contender brings us is more text-based, as found in Mānavadharmaśāstra, etc. (See: Samarendra 2014; Fárek <em>et al</em> 2017). We are not the first people to face these problems. In fact, WR Cornish, the supervisor of census operations in the Madras Presidency verifies our claim by noting that “<em>whether there was ever a period in which the Hindus were composed of four classes is exceedingly doubtful</em>” (Chakravorty 2019).</p><p>What do we do now? Let’s move to Endogamy again. Which other groups in India are endogamous, and fulfill our other criteria that can be classified as caste? The only group till now which has stayed true to Endogamy are the “sub-castes” when jāti is said to be caste. Therefore, we have to agree that these “sub-castes” are the real castes, since nothing other than that qualifies for the problem. However, we now have Gotra further complicating the matters. Jalki and Pathan (2015) continue:</p><blockquote><em>Traditionally</em>, when a Vadakalai Brahmin goes in search of a bride, he is looking for a person who is (a) Brahmin, (b) Iyengar, © Vadakalai and (d) who is not from his own gotra. Hence, if we take the notion of endogamy as a fundamental property of the castes, Vadakalai is the only endogamous group. […] Furthermore, traditionally, not every Vadakalai will marry another Vadakalai, since in-gotra marriages are a taboo. That is to say, the Vadakalai sub-caste is simultaneously both exogamous and endogamous.</blockquote><p>You see the mess. So, can endogamy not be seen as a principle which holds caste? Was Ambedkar ignorant about Gotras throughout his life? Actually, no. Ambedkar was very well aware about the Gotra problem, and therefore, in the same work, he says that the correct way to see the caste system is to see the superimposition of endogamy on exogamy. Therefore, an exogamous society was divided on the lines of endogamy. This looks an ugly, but a very good sociological theory. However, we have a big problem. There is no historical evidence that supports Ambedkar’s claim. Without any evidence, how can we verify such a bizarre theory? In fact, caste studies seldom get some attention from historical sources. Because problems here are easily solved by dropping slurs on the evil, cunning Brāhmaṇas.</p><p>Dismissing endogamy as a criterion for Caste does not solve our problem. We still have to look for the basic unit of caste. Is there any official document(s) from the time period when the story of caste started that can give us some proper definition? We find caste to be a word belonging to a language family which is not natively Indian. We know that castes were statistically measured among the demographics of India during the British caste census. So what does the census say? Well, for the census of North-Western Provinces in 1865, we had Sikh, Jogee, Jain, Sunni, etc. to be on the same level as Brahmin, Kshatriya, Vaishya, and Shudra. In fact, the names of castes have never been homogenous throughout the history of the caste census. No census, no table, and no report was finished before adding a section titled “No caste/Caste unknown”. (See: Samarendra 2014 for more information). Therefore, even the census is of no help to us.</p><p>So, what do the scholars of the same time period say? They contradicted each other, and the ambiguity in their claims was unprecedented (See: Fárek 2017). How do we proceed now? Why was this problem not taken up by the scholars of the past 200 years and solved already. We do not find any scholar who takes up these problems and sees them as responsibility to resolve them. All we see are scholars who side-step the problems by claiming that the caste system has so many local manifestations in various regions of the country that it is almost impossible to get a consensus. This argument is in itself, again, self-contradicting. If there cannot be a consensus on the caste system, how can we have established that there <em>is </em>a caste system in the first place (Fárek <em>et al.</em> 2017)?</p><p>The shock is that there has not been an iota of development in this theory for the past 150 years (Jalki and Pathan 2015). In fact, every single argument that wishes to debunk the mainstream conceptions and provide a novel explanation ends up creating a theory that bases itself on the concepts it just debunked. Jalki (2023) writes that Al-Biruni, an Iranian traveler who left notable accounts about India was also a respected astronomer of that time. If he were to take up a time machine and arrive in present-day India, he would have tremendous difficulties understanding the astronomical developments which happened after him. However, he would have no difficulty understanding Wilkerson’s book. The story never got old. It never gets old. If it cannot get old, can it be real?</p><p>Who/What has sustained this “caste” system over the years? To impose such a great structure across the length and breadth of India, and to sustain it over thousands of years despite so many attempts to eradicate it, that institution must have some supreme power over India. How can such a system just appear some 3500 years ago and spellbound each and every aspect of Indian life? Brāhmaṇas are usually blamed for the case, but there is no historical evidence that suggests us that they had such an omnipotent power over the Indian society <em>before</em> caste came into being (if there was ever such a time). How can we assume that the caste system just appeared and got everyone under its spell (Fárek <em>et al.</em> 2017)? This problem is usually solved by claiming an Aryan Invasion (AIT). But, we still have no admissible evidence for this theory that confirms such a massive invasion. Aryan Migration Theory (AMT) is another such theory that solves the issue. But, even if the migration is admitted, how can the Aryans impose an oppressive structure all over India without the use of force? We do not have answers to these questions (Keppens 2017). In fact, Malhotra and Nīlakantan (2011) has shown how AIT and AMT have builded their arguments on hollow grounds of race supremacy and European romanticism. Balagangadhara <em>et al.</em> (2022) write:</p><blockquote>How can any reasonable person defend the suggestion that most (if not all) texts of a culture hide or express devious but successful conspiracies of a “priestly class” that has protected its alleged “privileges” over three millennia or more? How is it sociologically or politically possible for any class, anywhere in the world and at any time — without centralized organization of any kind — to achieve this feat in a giant country like India and sustain it over three thousand years? The above two questions indicate the crushing weight of the accumulated anomalies. Nothing in our entire world of knowledge prepares us for this miracle.</blockquote><p>Evidence returned for this argument is given from several Hindu texts, such as the Dharmaśāstras. How good would it be for us to make the sense of present-day India through texts “written” thousands of years ago? Do we read the Bible to make sense of what Europe looks like today?</p><p>We know that caste is not an Indian word, and some findings will tell that it is derived from the Portuguese word, i.e. <em>casta</em> that means social units. It was used to address India’s social structures for the ease of the Europeans. This makes caste itself a conception of the “outsiders”. The Europeans translated Dharmaśāstras and did everything to understand India in order to control it. They could have not done it in an Indic sense, they have to have a framework to understand the Indian society. So, can we now say that the terms “caste”, “Varṇa and jāti” mean something else in two different worldviews. With this, can we imply that the former has no existence outside the framework it was built into?</p><p>If such is the case, what do we make of caste reservations? What do we make of the atrocities committed by the upper castes for years? What do we make of the anti-caste posture of the Bhakti movement and Buddhism? And, most importantly, what do we make of the works of scholars, such as Wilkerson and Yengde?</p><p>To answer these questions, we will have to look into the answer of a very important question: What framework did the creators of caste have? The scholars of Balu’s research programme argue that the framework was a <em>Christian</em> framework. This leaves us with the most unexpected, but the only reasonable theory with us. That is, to understand more about caste, we have to look not into Hindu, <em>but in the Christian theology.</em></p><p><strong>Continued in </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@akshadrathi0705/balagangadhara-caste-and-christianity-part-ii-b0fdcb065c9d"><strong>Part II: The Christianity of Caste</strong></a></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@akshadrathi0705/balagangadhara-caste-and-christianity-part-ii-b0fdcb065c9d">Balagangadhara, Caste, and Christianity: Part II</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=550af285e934" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>