<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Alexander Muir on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Alexander Muir on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@alexandermuir?source=rss-802690155492------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 02:23:41 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@alexandermuir/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Four Varnas and PhD Research (draft)]]></title>
            <link>https://alexandermuir.medium.com/the-four-varnas-and-phd-research-draft-708d8a7e6099?source=rss-802690155492------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/708d8a7e6099</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[vedanta]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[phd]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alexander Muir]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Sep 2020 10:29:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-28T11:29:06.526Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>(This essay is a work-in-progress, on an idea intended for students who are already interested in concepts like the following, and want to find some way to have a broader view of research that can integrate both the everyday grind as well as the high moments of inspiration. It’s not my intention to convert, compare or compete with any other view)</p><p>Vedic literature describes four “Varnas” — four modes of being in the world — and we can use these as a lens to survey the breadth and depth of work we’ll need to do as Researchers. The four are: Brahmin, Kshatriya, Vaishya and Sudra, and these span an incredibly wide range of activities and moods. Though in recent times they have also become associated with a rigid sense of caste, that is not the way I will use them here. Instead I will try to link back to the essence of the concept and apply it to the work of research.</p><p>The four Varnas appear early in Vedic literature in the Rig Veda, and then in the epics like the Mahabarata as well as the Srimad Bhagavatam and the Bhagavad Gita, chapter 4, verse 13: “The fourfold order was created by Me”. Luminaries of Indian culture such as Paramahansa Yogananda and Amma herself speak about how these teachings(the teachings on the four castes and four stages of life) require going past the outer trappings to the inner essence. (Ref. Paramahansa Yogananda, “God Talks with Arjuna”, ch 4, verse 13). The four Varnas are described as emerging from the body of the Supreme Being and — as Amma regularly reminds us — this is none other than our own true Self, it is safe to see the four Varnas as being something already in us. These four are like primal patterns of consciousness, somewhat akin to archetypes i.e. ways of assembling our perception, thought and even our reality.</p><p>Briefly, the four archetypes correspond to these themes:</p><ol><li>Brahmin: the “Spiritual” or “Transcendental” aspect. The bridge between the world and the Eternal.</li><li>Kshatriya: Authentic leadership, high level strategy, responsibility and protection.</li><li>Vaishya: Tactical skill and craft.</li><li>Sudra: The labour and “heavy lifting” that supports the whole process.</li></ol><p>It’s important to pull away from any sense that one is better than another. Though traditionally someone who is identified as a Brahmin has considerably more respect and status than a Sudra, we need to push past this to a clear recognition that these four modes are interdependent. If there was no labour, there would be no grain to turn into wheat, and thus nothing to feed anyone — even the Queen!</p><p>Especially for our context here, its important to understand that all four modes are necessary and work together. Though some moments are more boring (like renaming files) and some are more exciting (like successfully defending your thesis) none the less they are all necessary. We need to “make friends” with all of them!</p><p><strong>Let’s now look at how these four correspond to PhD research.</strong></p><ol><li>Sudra: Labour: The “spadework” of research. Examples: making sure all references are in the right format. Transcribing videos. Neatly putting away a video recording kit when you come back from a day of fieldwork. Renaming files so they are all consistent.</li><li>Vaishya: Tactical skill in the methods. Examples: tagging video clips, analysing survey results, writing a compelling paper.</li><li>Kshatriya: Strategic Leadership of the process. Examples: choosing one’s topic, forming strategic research partnerships, defending one’s thesis, handling challenges when funding or staff changes jeopardize one’s work.</li><li>Brahmin: Connecting the work to one’s Soul. Examples: understanding what makes the work personally meaningful, self-reflection on one’s perceptual biases, developing a selfless attitude in the work, conducting it in the spirit of Seva. Enjoying the sheer pleasure of the work.</li></ol><p><strong>The Kshatriya mode in PhD studies: strategic leadership, direction, governance, alliance and defence</strong></p><p>A PhD is a long, complex process lasting at least three years, and involving many trials. It is a journey through a landscape with many unknowns and countless ways of getting lost. It demands time, energy and resources. There are landmark moments when we need to decide the direction we will take.</p><p><strong>The Strategic Direction of the PhD</strong></p><p>What is our research topic going to be? This is one of the first big challenges facing PhD students. While it may be made easier if we are in a department that gives very specific areas of focus, we still need to pick a place to start. It can be daunting, but we should be ready to take responsibility and — like a Kshatriya — thoughtfully yet boldly move ahead.</p><p>This will usually involve balancing our interests with those of the department and faculty members we are working with — as well as with a realistic assessment of what resources and funding we have.</p><p>Even when working on the same topic, different disciplines will tackle it in different ways. And even within one discipline, there are usually various research approaches that will result in a very different set of activities. For example, a long ethnographic field-study compared to a series of surveys. In the former, you will spend hours in the field, collecting and then coding qualitative data. In the latter, you will spend hours designing a survey, collecting and analyzing quantitative data.</p><p>Where your topic starts and ends: the boundaries of your Land. Academics can seem silly when they split hairs over definitions, but we soon understand that even a slight shift in definition can mean a major redefinition of the boundaries of what they are studying — and so these things need intentional thought. When we are scoping our work, we need to learn to be wise so as not to bite off too much. Yet neither can we be too narrow, because then our inquiry will be too limited.</p><p><strong>Governance</strong></p><p>It is easy to fall behind in one’s PhD work, especially when it gets laborious or confusing. Many people drop out and never finish. There can be a lot of bureaucratic steps to take. We need keep an eye on our overall progress, and be realistic, kind yet firm with ourselves, to hold ourselves accountable, and ensure we keep moving ahead.</p><p>By this stage in our education, our teachers and guides really expect us to be functioning as young professionals, and do not want to treat us like teenagers or undergraduates by chasing and nagging us to do our homework. The onus of responsibility for progress is on us. We should behave honourably and not let our work slide into nothing for lack of effort in governing ourselves.</p><p>We have limited amounts of time, energy, resources, opportunities and money. We need to make intelligent decisions about research direction that will take advantage of what we have, and mitigate the difficulties of where we are limited. For example, if we know that in a year’s time we will be able to join in some field visits, then we should plan the major sequences of the work so that we are ready to do data gathering in a year’s time — and thus make great use of the field visits. If we know we have constant access to research participants, then we would plan differently, perhaps emphasizing a leaner, more iterative type of data gathering.</p><p><strong>Alliance</strong></p><p>Making strategic alliances is another traditional role of the Kshatriya. Likewise in PhD research we often need to partner with others. Creating and maintaining good research partnerships takes diplomacy, effort and thoughtfulness.</p><p><strong>Defence</strong></p><p>Our work, our thinking, will frequently get challenged — by PhD guides, other faculty, by peers, or even in social media. Sometimes these can be anticipated, and at other times it comes as a surprise. We need to have courage and integrity to defend our work when this happens, and — if genuine weaknesses in it have been revealed — we should appropriately take note of this and plan to fix the issues.</p><p>There are other challenges that can topple our work, such as changes in the department (e.g. new priorities), changes in staff (e.g. our supervisor retires), or money (e.g. our funding gets reallocated to someone else’s project). We need to think strategically and find ways to keep our research alive even when such difficulties come up. The spirit of the Kshatriya is indomitable, and is not cowed by these inevitable difficulties. At the end of the day, if we do not stand up to defend our work, who else will?</p><p><strong>Vaishya: Skill in the Methods, Tactical Decision making, Project Management</strong></p><p><strong>Skill in the Methods</strong></p><p>There are many courses in Research Methods, and we need to become proficient in many of them. From an early literature review, through the general skills like writing a good paper, through to specialist methods of our discipline (whether its writing good ethnographic fieldnotes, or using a mass spectrometer) — we need to become good, efficient and productive.</p><p>Like the archetype of the good craftsman or business person, we need to conduct our own research in the same way, day by day, week by week. Initially we learn new methods, try them out, stumble and make mistakes, but eventually grow to be proficient.</p><p><strong>Tactical Decision Making</strong></p><p>There are many tactical decisions to take along the way, such as: Is this journal article a good source for my work? Even if our guides give us many of the answers, most of the day to day decisions require us to think and act ourselves. We should not be scared to take ownership of our work in the same way that a businessperson takes responsibility for crowing their own small business.</p><p>Note that these decisions are different from the big, strategic ones. But sometimes people confuse them so that even a simple question (e.g. is XYZ a good journal for my topic?) can lead people to reconsider their entire PhD (e.g. I like journal XYZ, maybe I should change my PhD topic so I can spend time with it). Generally, it is a bad idea to change strategic direction unless you genuinely have to. Also, we should distinguish the difference between a tactical and a strategic decision, and not mishandle them by confusing one with the other.</p><p><strong>Project Management</strong></p><p>Like running a small business, conducting a PhD involves juggling many workstreams. There is so much to do! Like a good businessperson, it is important we make good decisions day to day on what our priorities are, and on what we will spend our time.</p><p>One of the great mistakes PhD students make is spending time on the things that are interesting and ignoring the boring work, or the difficult decisions. Good project management is incredibly helpful here. It does not need to be complex, but an appreciation of basics of some project management system are very helpful. In general, project management is about “who is doing what, and when”. It means balancing the three factors of time, scope and resources. Time means how much time you have — and may change day to day, week to week. It also means working to deadlines — such a paper submissions, or doctoral committee meetings. Scope means: what needs to be accomplished. Since PhD work can feel overwhelming (for example there can be a massive list of papers and books to read) it is crucial to chunk up the work into manageable pieces. For example, you might decide that by Thursday you will skim read three of the most important papers, and spend some time writing down your thoughts and questions about them. That lets you take a good, honest step in the right direction. And the journey is mostly made up of many of these simple, honest steps forward. Resources means: what tools, equipment, money and other people you have access to. So, whether its just you and your laptop, or you and a team of collaborators making a well-funded trip to a study site, the resources you have available are very different. Project Management is balancing the time and resources available with the scope you will undertake. Again, many PhD students fail to use elementary project management, and their work languishes and makes little headway. That can lead to a sense depression, and even quitting altogether. It is ironic and tragic that so simple a concept of project management could help their intellectual work succeed, yet they don’t use it.</p><p><strong>Sudra: The Spadework of research. Steady, attentive effort.</strong></p><p>In any research project there are many mundane tasks that simply need to be done. These are tasks that don’t require much thinking, though they do require care and attention. So, they can seem boring and arduous. But without them being conducted properly, no actual work takes place.</p><p>For example, if we are going to run a field study, we need to pack up our kit with laptop, camera, power cord, spare batteries etc. If we forget something, we can jeopardize our whole trip! Similarly, when we return back from the study, we need to put everything away, recharge the equipment, clean the mud off the tripod, transfer and backup the files, make sure all the files are named correctly and put in the right folders, etc etc etc. If any of these small, humble tasks fails to get done, we are merely creating problems for ourselves! It can be terribly frustrating to expend a massive amount of energy to go run a crucial study, only to find one has lost the files afterwards due to carelessness.</p><p>Many of the nitty gritty tasks in research are not glamorous or interesting, and thus many fall into the trap of ignoring them, rushing through them, or being careless. But we can see how steady, attentive effort is really the foundation. Perhaps we can understand in a new light the ancient concept that the Sudras emerged from the feet of the Supreme Being (Purushottama) — because without this daily effort, we make no forward progress. No matter how clever our ideas or brilliant our thinking is, no matter how deeply we feel inspired, if we do not understake the daily effort of the Sudra, our research will come to exactly zero.</p><p><strong>Brahmin: Self reflection, Attitude, Meaning and Inspiration, Self Knowledge and a Glimpse of the Divine</strong></p><p>Traditionally this Brahmin caste is described as being the scholar. But here we have blown that up and shown that all four Varnas are involved in our own journey of being a Scholar. In fact, in the sections above, we have shown that much of the day to day of actually being a scholar is undertaken in the Vaishya and Sudra modes! So what then is left for the Brahmin to do?</p><p><strong>Self-reflection</strong></p><p>The Brahmin is the bridge between the outer and the inner worlds. They deal with the more subtle, numinous aspects of the work. Perhaps the easiest apsect to understand in this way is simply the ability to be self-reflective. We should always seek to know our own strengths and weaknesses, and be able to have an honest self assessment of our interests and motivations. That does not mean from the Day 1 we have this: it is a journey of self discovery. And the stories we tell ourselves about why we do something are not at all the same as being aware of our true motivations.</p><p>The willingness and skill to regularly self-reflect are important for feeling at home in this work. Many student struggle when they start feeling they don’t know why they are doing a PhD. Especially when the going gets tough — which it always will — the ability to confidently tune in to one’s higher sense of purpose, and to look deeply within and see what is happening in one’s mind and emotions, is very helpful.</p><p><strong>Attitude</strong></p><p>Naturally doing a PhD has a strong focus on gaining the status of being “Dr So-and-So”. It also can mean increased pay and other opportunities. That is all fine, and its not my intention to denigrate that as a goal. However, especially when undertaking work inspired by Amma, we need to look beyond the usual worldly goals of wealth, comfort, reputation and admirers. Yes, we should be realistic about our wishes (which will inevitably contain much worldliness, unless we are already a saint!) but also tap into something beyond that. Motivated my love and awareness, we can wish to undertake the work basically as an offering of service, an offering of love. This creates a lovely inner attitude that is more pleasant to live in. Additionally, a positive attitude gives us resilience to handle difficulties.</p><p><strong>Meaning and Inspiration</strong></p><p>We will be spending at least several years undertaking a PhD. It is a major investment of life energy. We can and should aspire that the effort will make our life more meaningful. Otherwise at the end of the process we will feel a bit dry and hollow, especially once the excitement of the newly achieved status wears off.</p><p>By being aware of one’s personal interests, and what one would find fulfilling, it is possible to create one’s PhD so that one finds personal meaning in it. For example, we may be drawn to work with women in rural India, or to be on the cutting edge of technology. Different people seek different experiences to grow as individuals. Frequently there is a mismatch between the student, their topic and their PhD guide — because what the guide finds meaningful is different to the student. This does not mean you need to find a guide who thinks and feels like you, but there should ideally be a realistic dialogue between you and your Guide so you both understand what you find meaningful about the work, and can get aligned around this. For example, you might be interested in how a traditional village healer works, whereas you guide might be interested in creating legislation to protect the public from untrained health practitioners. You would like to spend time with such healers because you find it inspiring and meaningful, but your guide does not: they would rather you spend time with people who have suffered from meeting such healers. Clearly there is a mismatch in the meaning of the work, and this needs to be handled otherwise you as the student will be the one who gets most frustrated.</p><p>What we find meaningful does shift and evolve as we grow. Nor should we mistake a PhD as merely a hobby. Often, we would be better sticking to a hobby and thus being able to read whatever we want! A PhD will naturally involve many steps that do not excite or inspire the student (see the section on Sudra above) but that does not contradict the point here: we should conduct work that, over the course of a few years, we will find it inspiring and meaningful.</p><p><strong>Self-Knowledge and a Glimpse of the Divine</strong></p><p>One of the truly great pleasures in life is a breakthrough moment when — having struggled on a problem — suddenly the clouds part and we have a flash of insight. Like a bolt out of the blue, we experience a sudden epiphany. One of the great benefits of the Path of the Scholar is that we regularly work on hard problems and thus have the opportunity to have these flashes of insight. They are rare, but they can be thrilling and even life changing. We may feel it bubbling up in our bodies and emotions before suddenly an insight presents itself to our mind. Or we may feel it like a stroke of lightning on our head. OR an idea pops into our mind fully formed. However we feel it, these are peak moments in the journey of scholarship.</p><p>Over time, as we have these flashes of insight, it is the Brahmin’s role to recognize that — beyond the specific insight — the very fact we are having these flashes that seem to come from beyond our ordinary minds — that we are part of something much bigger than ourselves. Poetically speaking, we might say it is the face of the Goddess of Wisdom giving us a loving glance for a moment. And indeed it can feel something like that. But, however we phrase it, the underlying truth of the experience remains: we are indeed in relationship with the Divine. It is a loving relationship with the Friend, and these moments remind us of the tangible reality of our Source. Cultivating that sense of loving relationship is the role of the Brahmin.</p><p><strong>Summary</strong></p><p>All of this so far is a very rough pencil sketch of the idea that we can look at the work involved in a PhD through the len of the four Varnas. It ranges from steadily doing the spadework, being good and productive with our research, taking responsibility for good strategic leadership, and connecting to the source of meaning and inspirations in ourselves.</p><p>The great wisdom of Vedic culture includes how everything can be a path for a transcendental goal of living life in relationship to the Divine. The Vedantic worldview of the Gita integrates so elegantly both acting in the world, with an inward loving relationship with the Divine.</p><p>Many of us struggle with academics, especially with the challenging PhD process, because it can seem too dry, so secular and worldly. Where does it touch our heart? Is it helping us grow as people? Does it ever fill our lives with moments of awe and wonder? I offer the above essay as a way of showing that: Yes! PhD research can be both practical and spiritual. It is up to us to make it so. And the lens of the four Varnas is one way to get focused on how to do so.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=708d8a7e6099" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Psychology of “Seva”: an effective basis for humanitarian UX work]]></title>
            <link>https://alexandermuir.medium.com/the-psychology-of-seva-an-effective-basis-for-humanitarian-ux-work-60df1c1c0e58?source=rss-802690155492------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/60df1c1c0e58</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vedanta]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humanitarian-innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hcd]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alexander Muir]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 10 Jun 2020 10:20:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-10T10:20:12.148Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Alexander Muir</p><p><em>This is a lightly edited transcript of a talk at the Behaviour and Design Conference in June 2020.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Qj212vnDgR8auvXOBoX0-Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Usability Study on e-Learning for Low Literacy Women, AMMACHI Labs / Amrita University 2017</figcaption></figure><p>Design and UX have a massive role in solving major problems we as a global society are facing. Technology is an amplifier, that makes efficient processes more efficient but causes broken processes to break more quickly and spectacularly. When working with vulnerable people and communities, especially below the poverty line, most of the social and bureaucratic infrastructure is broken, and so adding technology can easily make problems worse — and is likely at best to have no impact. Kentaro Toyama’s “Geek Heresy” is a must-read on this.</p><p>But when it comes to actually doing humanitarian human-centred design, there are a lot of things that can be upsetting, distressing and crazy-making. I’ve seen many of them first hand, going through them myself and seeing friends and colleagues struggle too.</p><p>We can burn out.</p><p>We can get depressed and jaded.</p><p>But the work is important so we need to be in it for the long haul.</p><p>This article takes a different focus to the usual discussion of psychology in UX. Rather than looking at the behaviour of customers, we’ll talk about what the practitioner does. Rather than outer behaviour, we’ll focus on inner behaviour — how we work with our perceptions, attitudes and world views. And rather than use a conventional empiricist / behavioural model of psychology, we will use one from India.</p><p>I’m a little nervous about proposing a non-Western model of psychology, as it is so far outside the regular UX conversation. Also it is a very personal topic. I’ve struggled quite seriously with burnout in my career, both in my conventional UXR career and in the humanitarian work. All the material here I’ve worked with personally, and seen others work with. It’s very tried and tested, and if one takes the trouble you can see it in action.</p><p>The concepts I’ll discuss are drawn from the philosophy of Vedanta — which broadly sits within what’s called Hinduism, but what the tradition itself calls Sanatana Dharma. The main text in Vedanta is the Bhagavad Gita, which is a short and very readable work widely available in various English translations. Vedanta itself is an open and inclusive type of worldview. No one is excluded based on any demographic category. And importantly for us it elegantly integrates both acting in the world and gaining self-knowledge.</p><p>I must also mention the team at Amrita University, with whom I had a chance to work for some years, and who have taught me both by example and explanation what the practical aspects of Vedanta are, and how it supports humanitarian HCD. Amrita Uni is a globally recognized centre of humanitarian technology and has topped the list of private universities in India, despite being less than two decades old. I conducted a survey on this topic with practitioners from Amrita Uni, and have included some responses below.</p><p>The Amrita team has gained international recognition at the highest level including the first UNESCO chair for women’s empowerment, being a consulting member of the UN Academic Impact council, a Facebook Global Innovation award winner, and many other successes. I mention this simply because it shows the ideas we’ll now discuss are effective for high performing teams. It is not merely dreamy-thinking.</p><p><strong>The Challenges of Humanitarian UX</strong></p><p>First and foremost, humanitarian design research involves empathizing with suffering.</p><p>When we are working with people who are living below the poverty line, or with addiction, or abuse, or chronic illness — we are going to be working with people experiencing a lot of suffering: physical pain, emotional pain, mental pain, frustration, injustice, overwhelm, hopelessness, anger, and all the rest. As a UXer, it’s our job to understand the emotions and experiences of our users. It can be challenging to step into this sort of emotional territory.</p><p>If we are working in locations outside the first world comfort bubble, for example doing fieldwork in the developing world, we’ll likely be in places where travel is difficult or even dangerous, where the comfort levels may be minimal, where it&#39;s hot, where there&#39;s physical pollution, or noise pollution, where food is strange and appears at irregular intervals. This can put a lot of strain on you. It can be hard to run a study if you’re distracted with hunger or freaked out because random villagers are loitering and staring at you.</p><p>You may well be tempted to cut your research short and end up avoiding the places where the most marginalized people are, simply because it’s a major pain to be there.</p><p>It can be hard to find the rhythm of work, of who to talk to to get things done, to understand what your role is, to understand other people’s roles, to work within management styles that seem extremely different from the mostly flat and friendly democratic cultures in many modern Western companies. For example, projects are put together in a very different way in India, they tend to involve a lot more people, and have a hierarchical management style.</p><p>In general, local customs can be confusing and maddening. There can be a very different sense of gender roles and class. Of course, there can be internal dramas within the organization one is working within — and it can be difficult to accept the foibles of colleagues — even though they are working with their own challenges.</p><p>We’re going to be bringing our own ego trips with us, which will get triggered sooner or later. We may have naïve ideas about how much we’ll be appreciated, about how we can swoop in and save the day, about how we’ll bring the clear light of technocratic rationalism to the solve the world’s problems through design.</p><p>Or we may have a knotty sense of first-world guilt and feel somehow desperate to assuage it through some grand gesture of doing something good for the world. We all have these sorts of things going on — all of us — and its no shame to admit it.</p><p>OK — so it&#39;s full of challenges. And that is really part of its appeal! The good news is that its very possible to learn how to swim like a dolphin in those same rough seas. I found that many of my HCD colleagues at Amrita Uni — whose focus is on the toughest problems in India — were not burned out, not jaded, or cynical — but give off an absolute radiance, a lightness, a humour. As if the work itself — with all its challenges — is polishing them to be like diamonds. I believe that many of us are wanting our career to become a “path” so we grow as people and find life more meaningful, too.</p><p><strong>The Concepts</strong></p><p><strong>1 : Seva</strong></p><p>Seva means “selfless service”. It means offering help towards a useful, meaningful goal, and doing so with the attitude of someone ready to serve.</p><p>The application is simple: find a project that needs some help, that you feel is important, and help out — ready to do the grunt work if needs be.</p><p>And, crucially, it does mean putting aside our ego-trips of being a big shot, a PhD, an important person, intelligent, educated, socially-conscious or otherwise particularly special. It’s an attitude where we are not making it about “me”, but about the goal. About others.</p><p>But, we should also know our limits — “seva” is not at all about self-punishment. And It is not about beating yourself up for not being selfless enough. Be gentle with yourself.</p><p>We’re talking about little increments — little choices, moment by moment, a mental-emotional discipline to be honest with ourselves and adjust our attitudes a little, again and again. It’s very rarely about any single great gesture.</p><p>Some of the respondents shared some useful insights:</p><p>“Seva is not the action itself, but the attitude with which action is performed in the service of others and the community at large. Human centered research leads to effective action research but often does not offer scope for mental calibration of the researcher. Action and attitude are kept divorced often as is the case of any research”</p><p>This respondent touches on the fact that much of training is about understanding other people’s headspace — their emotions and experiences, their mental models etc — but strangely there is very little attention given to working with our own.</p><p>“Spirit of seva gives me the attitude and capacity to do more than required. To do seva is to be empathic but in a dharmic way, with an attitude of Karma yoga (putting in the best work without any expectations, free of the burden of results). The seva spirit will help bring out the noblest of our intentions and build something of benefit to others, instead of dark design patterns that are getting common nowadays.”</p><p>Th respondent brings up “Karma Yoga” — which is the path of action — “karma” here means “action, activity, doing things” and “yoga” here does not mean physical postures, it means “union”. In this sense it means union with the deepest part of yourself, it’s the opposite of “being a stranger to yourself”</p><p>It&#39;s for people who want to be active in the world, to do positive things (karma) but without losing themselves in the action. It’s the opposite — through action, gaining more self-knowledge. Its described in the Bhagavad Gita chapter in beautiful detail, but also lived out in the humanitarian traditions that we see with, say, Gandhi and also modern humanitarian leaders like Amma. A discussion of “seva” very quickly turns into a discussion of Karma Yoga. And there are three particular concepts that I think are helpful here.</p><p><strong>2: Offer the Fruits</strong></p><p>“The Fruits” is a poetic code word for the results that will come from a certain action. “Offering the fruits” means intentionally wanting the good outcomes for others, i.e. doing something in a spirit of giving, rather than taking.</p><p>But it is also more subtle — it means not being attached to the results, whatever they are. It means consciously avoiding becoming consumed with anxiety regarding the results. This is very practical — as what we CAN control is how much care and attention we bring to our work, but we cannot control the final result. Trying to do so is crazy-making.</p><p>The Seva spirit, the Karma Yoga spirit — is very much characterized by a sense of working intentionally, working carefully and attentively, but being unattached to the specific outcome. This may seem like a paradox, but it makes sense in practice.</p><p>An application is to reflect on one’s own practice, and recognize: what are my personal tell-tale signs that I’m getting wrapped up with the results? Simply being aware of our own patterns around this is the best application.</p><p><strong>3: I’m Not the Doer</strong></p><p>The Vedantic philosophy and the psychologies based on it are sophisticated. There is a tremendously detailed picture of what is “the self”, what is “the mind”, what is “me”. It is approached in a very different way from the West, and is extremely practical and interesting. But one of the confusing phrases you might hear, though, is to perform actions with the awareness that “I’m not the doer”.</p><p>We can understand this when we look its opposite: think of some famous politicians who are always going on camera and looking a bit ridiculous because they claim credit for anything. That’s an extreme end of where we don’t want to be.</p><p>But also, there is a more common headspace we can be in where we’re thinking “well, I did this, I did that, I did the other” — we are imputing our ego heavily on our actions. This is setting the scene for an ego trip later.</p><p>Even when these actions are positive and done for the greater good, this sense can remain. You can definitely meet people in the “helping“ professions who are — frankly — egomaniacs. That happens. And the concept of recognizing how one is “not the doer” is a strong antidote to that.</p><p>Or if we create a long list in our minds of all the things “I’ve done” and go over it again and again, it tends to lead towards a hardened sense of self, which brings its own sort of mental pain.</p><p>The alternative is to recognize we are part of a whole, and the whole is acting through us. We are part of a team, and the energy of the team is moving us along.</p><p>When we create a design, when we write a survey, is not the voice of our teachers and mentors in the back of our minds guiding us? And the fact that my laptop is even working is because the tech support person fixed it, and because someone originally assembled it in a factory. Really, when we look for the “I” who’s doing the work, we find so many interconnections. It&#39;s wonderfully humbling and reconnecting. And in contrast to a heavy sense of “me-who’s-done-all-this-stuff”, it’s much lighter and easier to live with. It gives a great sense of buoyancy.</p><p>Ways to nurture this include:</p><p>· Be sincere yet playful in the work, as opposed to being overly serious — which breeds a sort of rigidity</p><p>· Frequently remembering teachers and mentors and helpers</p><p>· Being aware of one’s patterns — looking out for signs one has gotten wrapped up in being the doer.</p><p><strong>4. Equal Vision</strong></p><p>OK, last concept: equal vision. This is really important. One of the main points of the Bhagavad Gita is the advice to see people equally. To see the one in all. Yes, to be aware of differences, but wisdom and compassion really spring from strengthening the sense of a fundamental, shared humanity amongst all people.</p><p>Everyone has consciousness. There is awareness in everyone.</p><p>Everyone feels joy and sorrow, and we all want more joy and less sorrow.</p><p>Everyone appreciates being treated with good-heartedness (even if we are temporarily blocked or resistant, the point remains) and similarly we all have that potential of warm-hearted kindness.</p><p>In fact, the Vedantic philosophy goes further than that — it trains the mind to reach a state where every being on earth is a part of your own self. Where the sense of otherness is totally dissolved. This is a strong reason to make a sincere investigation into the merits of Vendanta — as it offers a way to tackle the root cause of social problems like racism and other tribalistic behaviours.</p><p>In practical HCD, although we are likely to be very different, demographically, from our research participants — and it is healthy to acknowledge those differences — by far in a way the larger relationship is one of sameness.</p><p>A large trend in academic social science research has been to bring our differences to the fore — and there are good reasons for this. But, if we focus mainly on our differences, we can easily become knotted up when dealing with people who are different. We may actually blind ourselves to the reality of the person standing in front of us, if we become too caught up in socio-political concepts and awkwardness.</p><p>We may feel a massive gulf between us and them. But good design relies on empathy, and for this we need to cross the interpersonal divide. The concept of “equal vision” reminds us that we can and the associated practices support us to develop that ability.</p><p>It also helps prevent another way we can burn out, which is being overly partial, losing our sense of equanimity, and getting wrapped up in simplistic notions of us and them.</p><p>Applications to strengthen this sense are</p><p>· Intention: choosing to look for sameness.</p><p>· Reflection: be aware of the concepts you are currently, actually bringing to your encounters — what beliefs are you actually applying?</p><p>· Framing: be intentional and chose to hold a bigger picture of a shared human experience, rather than a fragmented one.</p><p>· Meditation: focused introspection to help reveal the actual nature of the “I” / “me” dynamic in the mind. Seeing it in action, over time, reveals the entire edifice of “us and them” is not intrinsic to the world, but imputed by the mind.</p><p><strong>Signs of Success</strong></p><p>But the essence is really found in practice. So let&#39;s keep focused on t the end result we want is to be able to stay buoyant even when the waves of difficulties threaten to drown us, and force us out of the work. We need to learn from our own experience first and foremost. Primarily we can tell how we’re doing by how easily we can “swim” in the turbulent waters of the work.</p><p>Beyond some of the specific self-reflection questions we’ve mentioned, here are some broad steps to get this material working for you.</p><p>· Action: lend your energy to a humanitarian project that inspires you</p><p>· Learning: learn from your own experience, especially the “knots”</p><p>· Clarify: get repeated explanations of these ideas</p><p>· Reflection: gentle, low-drama, honest self reflection (+retreat)</p><p>· Observe: associate with people who have a knack for what you want to learn</p><p><strong>Applying this in regular jobs</strong></p><p>It is entirely possible to apply all these ideas in one’s regular life. It is not necessary to go do a special project, or travel oversees. But it is easiest to get into the spirit of this when we are doing something clearly for service. Yes, we can and should treat our colleagues, neighbours and families with the same loving care and service. Yet it can be easier to kick-start this when we signal to ourselves that we are working on something that does not benefit us directly, e.g. working on a humanitarian project.</p><p><strong>Resources</strong></p><p>Here are some links to help you find more information:</p><p><strong>Groups open to collaboration</strong></p><p>Live-in-Labs program at Amrita Uni</p><p><a href="https://www.amrita.edu/international/live-in-labs">https://www.amrita.edu/international/live-in-labs</a></p><p>AMMACHI Labs</p><p><a href="http://ammachilabs.org/">http://ammachilabs.org/</a></p><p>Research at Amrita Uni</p><p><a href="https://amritaworld.org/research/">https://amritaworld.org/research/</a></p><p><strong>On Technolgy in Humanitarian Work</strong></p><p>Geek Heresy — Kentaro Toyama. A fascinating book that takes a rigorous look at the actual failings of many humanitarian technology projects, written by someone who was involved in many of them. After diagnosing the problems that led to the failings, he proposes a model based on a great awareness of the people involved, and build tech systems upon their strengths.</p><p>Disruptive Design Book — Layla Acaroglu. This work offers a straightforward and practical way to bring systems thinking to humanitarian design projects.</p><p><strong>On Non-Western Psychologies</strong></p><p>The Bhagavad Gita — many translations, e.g. by Swami Satchitananda. Note that though it is written as a story, it is condensed and requires a commentary. There is a very rich tradition of commentaries that draw out different aspects, from the mystical, to religious to the political. Take some time to find a version that makes sense to you, and do avoid rejecting it if the first version is not the right wave-length for you.</p><p>The Art of Power — Thich Nhat Hanh. This is a very readable modern work by one of the most experienced humanitarian leaders alive. It is grounded in Buddhist psychology but given as a distilled essence. It offers a grounded and practical way to rethink power and the role of presence and happiness.</p><p>The Colour of the Rainbow: Compassionate Leadership — Swami Amritaswarupananda Puri. This book describes the approach of another great modern humanitarian leader, Sri Mata Amritanandamayi, a village woman from South India who has led the creation of an international network of service projects ranging from tree planting, women’s empowerment to high tech research centres. It is a glimpse into one of the great female leaders of our time.</p><p>Ethics for the New Millennium — The Dalai Lama. Again, a Buddhist perspective designed for a modern, rational audience. The Buddhist tradition of the Dalai Lamas integrates logic and rationalism with the meditative and mystical traditions we associate with Buddhism. The overwhelming emphasis is on practising compassion in our daily actions.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=60df1c1c0e58" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>