<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Alex Howlett on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Alex Howlett on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@alexhowlett?source=rss-dccc9dc9eee------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 20:34:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@alexhowlett/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Economy Is a Giant Vending Machine]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/discourse/the-economy-is-a-giant-vending-machine-20edc1348694?source=rss-dccc9dc9eee------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/20edc1348694</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[consumerism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[basic-income]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[recession]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Howlett]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 May 2020 23:00:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-07T01:44:35.634Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>An Introduction to Universal Basic Income</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Wp1obIz0aF8kcdImlwR74w.png" /><figcaption>Illustration by Anna Slavina</figcaption></figure><p>Picture the economy as a giant vending machine. We spend money into the machine, and it produces goods and services for us to consume. But the economy won’t sell us what we lack the money to buy. Instead, those delicious goods and services will remain inaccessible, staring at us from behind their glass pane. To prevent this outcome, the economy needs a way to ensure that we all have money to spend.</p><h3>Basic Income</h3><p>Also known as universal basic income, or UBI for short, <strong><em>basic income</em></strong> is an unconditional income for every person. It solves the problem of how to get money into the hands of consumers so they can buy things from the vending machine.</p><blockquote>A basic income is an income paid by a political community to all its members on an individual basis, without means test or work requirement. This is the definition I shall adopt. It does not fit all actual uses of the English expression “basic income”, or of its most common translations into other European languages, such as “Bürgergeld”, “allocation universelle”, “renta básica”, “reddito di cittadinanza”, “basisinkomen”, or “borgerlon”. Some of these actual uses are broader : they also cover, for example, benefits whose level is affected by one’s household situation or which are administered in the form of tax credits. Other uses are narrower: they also require, for example, that the level of the basic income should match what is required to satisfy basic needs or that it should replace all other transfers. The aim of the above definition is not to police usage but to clarify arguments.<br> — Philippe Van Parijs | <a href="https://www.ssc.wisc.edu/~wright/Redesigning%20Distribution%20v1.pdf"><em>Redesigning Distribution</em></a> | 2003</blockquote><p>While this is not the <em>only</em> definition of “basic income,” it <em>is</em> the <a href="https://basicincome.org/basic-income/">usual one</a>. According to this definition, there is no such thing as a <em>non-universal</em> or <em>non-unconditional</em> basic income. Basic income goes equally to everyone — to all adults in the economy. The terms “basic income,” “universal basic income,” and “unconditional basic income” all describe the same concept.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fylm1jN9cMRQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dylm1jN9cMRQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fylm1jN9cMRQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/42c6b8644d8a4ca8e5f69a3acbfe9408/href">https://medium.com/media/42c6b8644d8a4ca8e5f69a3acbfe9408/href</a></iframe><p>It’s worth emphasizing that basic income does not have to be an amount of money that meets people’s basic needs. Such an amount may be both desirable and achievable, but it is not part of the definition. Basic income is “basic” only in the sense that everyone gets it. The income itself is basic — <em>not</em> what it buys.</p><p>People tend to make assumptions about what the amount of the basic income should be, or about what kinds of taxes or other policies would best go along with a basic income. Not everyone is careful about separating their desired <em>parameters</em> for basic income from the concept of basic income itself. This lack of precision can make basic income seem more complicated than it is.</p><p>So let’s get back to the basics of basic income. Basic income is just the same amount of free money for everyone. The amount could be small, or it could be substantial.</p><p>You don’t have to need the money. You don’t have to<em> </em>prove that something is preventing you from working. You just <em>get</em> it — even if you have a job or another source of income. You get it even if you’re rich.</p><h3>How to “Pay For” Basic Income</h3><p>Everyone asks how to pay for basic income. The answer is simple. There’s only one way to pay for it: by printing new money.</p><p>This assertion is less controversial than you might expect. <em>Any</em> time the government spends, they’re printing money. They are printing money in the sense that they’re adding money to a part of the economy that wouldn’t otherwise have that money.</p><p>Government spending adds new money to the economy <a href="https://www.greshm.org/blog/tax-revenue-is-meaningless/">regardless</a> of whether taxation happens to be removing money from another part of the economy at the same time. Taking away money from one part of the economy doesn’t automatically make room for new money in another part of the economy.</p><blockquote>If you’re asking where we can get the money <em>from</em>, then you’re asking the wrong question. What matters is whether the money has somewhere to <em>go</em>. We can hand consumers as much money as we want so long as the economy can provide something for them to buy.<br> — Alex Howlett | <a href="https://www.greshm.org/blog/theres-only-one-way-to-pay-for-a-basic-income/"><em>There’s Only One Way to Pay for a Basic Income</em></a> | 2018</blockquote><p>For the government’s money to be able to buy something, the economy has to have something it wants to sell. For basic income to buy goods and services, those goods and services have to be available for purchase — there has to be something in the vending machine.</p><h3>Natural Level of Basic Income</h3><p>The right question to ask isn’t: Can we afford a basic income? The right question is: What’s the optimal level of basic income for our economy? How much basic income can our economy handle without causing inflation or other problems? To what extent will various taxes and other economic policies increase or decrease that amount?</p><p>On its own, the concept of basic income is simple. It’s free money for everyone. But it can be hard for us to wrap our heads around how a simple basic income fits into our complicated economy. The good news is that basic income simplifies our economy for us. Much of our economy’s complexity stems from a lack of basic income. So, let’s explore how the economy works <em>with</em> a basic income. We can then work backward to understand the real world.</p><p>In this simple economy, people put money into the economic vending machine. The candy bars it spits out for them to consume are the economy’s products. To ensure consumers can buy all the candy bars, we provide them with a limited daily allowance of money to spend. That’s our basic income.</p><p>Let’s say the vending machine restocks itself every morning, but it’s only able to fit so many candy bars. In other words, our economy has limited resources; it only has the capacity to produce so many goods and services. If the amount of the basic income is too low, candy bars will remain unclaimed in the machine at the end of every day. If the amount is too high, then there will be a shortage of candy bars. Consumers will have extra money left over that they wanted to spend.</p><p>There’s exactly one level of basic income that allows consumers to claim the machine’s full contents every day without also causing a shortage — exactly one amount that allows consumers to buy all the goods and services the economy can produce for them. This sweet spot is the <strong><em>natural level of basic income</em></strong> for our vending-machine economy.</p><p>No amount of putting money into the machine is going to get consumers more candy bars than there physically <em>are</em> in the machine.</p><h3>Real Purchasing Power</h3><p>If the average price of the vending machine’s candy bars changes, then the natural level of basic income changes along with it. For example, if prices double, then people need twice the money. The natural level of basic income doubles.</p><p>Any given amount of basic income corresponds to a specific price level at which it is the natural level of basic income. If the basic income doesn’t match the general price level, we can adjust some combination of both to correct the difference. Let’s say that consumers receive enough basic income to buy all the candy bars twice over. We can bring the basic income to its natural level either by doubling the price of candy bars or by cutting the basic income in half.</p><p>When basic income is at its natural level, the number of candy bars in the vending machine is the <em>only</em> thing that determines how many candy bars consumers can purchase — the economy’s productive capacity determines what people can buy. Irrespective of the general price level, the natural level of basic income claims the same amount of goods and services — it represents the same amount of <strong><em>real purchasing power</em></strong>.</p><p>In our vending-machine economy, when we think about what a dollar is worth, we’re thinking in terms of how many candy bars it can buy. A stable dollar implies that the average price of candy bars doesn’t change. The price of a Snickers bar might go up, but it will never be the case that all the prices in the vending machine rise at the same time. There’s neither inflation nor deflation.</p><p>A stable dollar is ideal; it gives us an intuitive standard against which to measure the prices of everything else. Only by understanding that ideal, can we grasp the implications of deviating from it. In our vending-machine economy, a stable dollar means the average price of a candy bar <em>can’t change</em>. Inflation is always zero.</p><p>Of course, we can only legitimately assume away inflation if we also require the conditions that are necessary to <em>maintain</em> zero inflation. By disallowing inflation, we force ourselves to disallow the <em>causes</em> of inflation. To do anything else would be cheating.</p><p>For example, let’s say that the vending machine will automatically adjust its prices to sell all of its candy bars every day at the highest prices possible. A basic income higher than the natural level would cause inflation. A basic income lower than the natural level would cause deflation. There’s only one level of basic income that’s even <em>possible</em>: the natural level of basic income. If the basic income were at any other level, the machine would automatically change its price level — and that’s not allowed.</p><p>At the natural level of basic income, the average price of goods and services remains constant. There <em>is</em> no inflation. The same number of dollars flowing into the vending machine always corresponds to the same number of candy bars flowing out to consumers.</p><h3>A Growing Economy</h3><p>Imagine that we get a bigger vending machine that can hold more candy bars. The economy’s capacity to produce goods and services has expanded. Not only <em>can</em> we increase the basic income, but we <em>must</em> increase the basic income to bring it to its new natural level.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FkWRlwmnWGSk%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DkWRlwmnWGSk&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FkWRlwmnWGSk%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/86d8a4d567edff31ad3b233e3ed37b88/href">https://medium.com/media/86d8a4d567edff31ad3b233e3ed37b88/href</a></iframe><p>Because inflation and deflation are forbidden, the flow of consumer spending must continue to match the flow of economic output. If the economy can produce more goods and services for consumers, then consumers must spend more money to purchase those additional goods and services.</p><p>A change in the flow of candy bars implies a corresponding change in the flow of dollars. The flow of dollars and the flow of candy bars must remain equal and opposite. This balance must maintain itself whether the economy is growing, shrinking, or staying the same size.</p><h3>Jobs and Labor</h3><p>So far, our vending machine takes no inputs. It only produces output. It magically restocks itself every morning, and nobody has to do anything. Our economy’s money only flows only in one direction: from consumers’ pockets into the vending machine. Goods and services flow in the opposite direction: from the machine to consumers.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FH-GYCgPdAl8%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DH-GYCgPdAl8&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FH-GYCgPdAl8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/dc653aae2d2ccd5984b144f08d5f4abd/href">https://medium.com/media/dc653aae2d2ccd5984b144f08d5f4abd/href</a></iframe><p>Let’s instead imagine that the machine requires some labor input to produce its candy bars. Before, people were just consumers. They were beneficiaries of the economic machine. But now we need at least some people to contribute their labor as workers — to act as inputs to the production process.</p><p>We can ensure that people contribute labor by withholding some of their basic income. We thereby create an incentive for people to earn their money back through jobs. Some people might choose to do the work while others happily accept the lower level of basic income. What matters is that the right total amount of labor is being contributed to fully restock the vending machine every morning.</p><p>The consumers who work can now buy more candy bars than the others. But that’s okay. That’s the reward that motivates them to operate the vending machine for the benefit of everyone.</p><p>Given that our real-world economy requires labor, the natural level of basic income is the level that’s <em>low enough</em> to activate enough labor to stock the vending machine but <em>high enough</em> to ensure that consumers can still buy all the candy bars.</p><h3>Consumers vs. Workers</h3><p>As the economy’s need for labor decreases, we can withhold less and less money from consumers. To put it another way, automation of production causes our economy’s natural level of basic income to rise. The less we have to work, the richer we can be. The less we have to <em>be</em> workers, the more leisure we can enjoy.</p><p>Workers are just inputs to the economic machine. When we create an identity around labor, we’re treating people as mere inputs. But people are <em>more</em> than just inputs. The economy is here to serve <em>us</em>, not the other way around. What matters is what we can get <em>out</em> of the machine. The people’s needs come first. Everything else is secondary.</p><p>The economy exists for the benefit of the people. The most crucial role that people play in the economy the role of “consumer,” not “worker.” Being consumers just means we’re <em>receiving</em> benefit from the economy. We’re here to <a href="https://www.greshm.org/blog/life-is-just-a-game/">eat the candy bars</a>, not to toil away.</p><blockquote>Consumption is the sole end and purpose of all production; and the interest of the producer ought to be attended to, only so far as it may be necessary for promoting that of the consumer.<br> — Adam Smith | <em>The Wealth of Nations</em> | 1776</blockquote><p>People need to participate in the making of the candy bars only to the extent that the candy bars wouldn’t otherwise get made. We need to reward workers only to the extent that it gives them an incentive to contribute useful labor.</p><h3>Money Accumulates</h3><p>The government prints the money, and consumers spend it into the vending machine. But where does that money <em>go</em>? If we want, we can try to tell a story in which the vending machine pays its workers using money that came from the sale of candy bars. But, unless the natural level of basic income is zero, there’s still a gap. Consumers spend more money on candy bars than workers receive in wages. What happens to the rest of the money?</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F3AMWE27F-to%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D3AMWE27F-to&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F3AMWE27F-to%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/a051ce36b5e76a7645f1b7beb74e0b6d/href">https://medium.com/media/a051ce36b5e76a7645f1b7beb74e0b6d/href</a></iframe><p>The answer is simple: Money accumulates — it <a href="https://www.greshm.org/blog/money-does-not-circulate/">doesn’t just keep circulating</a> forever. Just because some people happen to be both producers <em>and</em> consumers, it doesn’t change the fact that money flows from consumers to producers while goods and services flow in the opposite direction. Producers are happy to accumulate money because they like getting rich. Meanwhile, the basic income must continually replenish consumers’ spending money.</p><p>If we pull back the curtain and look inside the vending machine, we see that it’s made up of many different parts working together. It’s the workers and their labor. It’s the capitalists and their equipment. It’s the resources and materials. It’s the various automated production processes. All of these factors churn away to produce goods and services for our economy’s consumers.</p><blockquote>Perhaps there was a time in history when the market economy behaved more like a system of mutual exchange among workers. But with the industrial revolution, the idea that consumers and producers were the same people became largely a fiction. Industrialization caused the market economy to become less like a system of exchange among workers and more like a system of distribution from producers to consumers.<br> — Alex Howlett | <a href="http://bit.ly/intro-to-cmt"><em>Introduction to Consumer Monetary Theory</em></a> | 2020</blockquote><p>The real-world economy is more like our giant vending machine than it is like a meritocratic system in which everyone gets out what they put in. An efficient economy does <em>not</em> pay workers based on some calculation of the “value” they contribute. It just pays them enough to get them to do the work.</p><p>As long as producers want to accumulate money, consumers can keep buying their products. Consumers can consume in excess of what they contribute. That’s what basic income facilitates.</p><h3>Private Sector Make-Work</h3><p>In the real world, we <em>do</em> have a vending-machine economy, but we <em>don’t</em> have a basic income. Does this mean that our economy’s natural level of basic income is <em>zero</em>? No. Instead, we try to compensate for our lack of basic income in other, less efficient, less effective ways. Rather than fund consumers directly, we use a combination of the financial sector and the labor market to funnel money to consumers.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F5EX999qUe7E%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D5EX999qUe7E&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F5EX999qUe7E%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ef8578677e90f20a3d0cb1361e7ce951/href">https://medium.com/media/ef8578677e90f20a3d0cb1361e7ce951/href</a></iframe><p>No small number of economists are hard at work studying how to bring the economy to full employment. But what these economists are forgetting is that <em>full employment</em> is not the same thing as <em>full output</em>. Ideally, we’d want to maximize what we’re getting <em>out</em> of the economy rather than what we’re putting <em>into</em> it. Full employment just means we’re keeping everyone busy.</p><p>This problem has become all the more obvious in the Covid-19 crisis during which we explicitly want people to stay home from work. But because we never questioned the idea that people should depend on jobs for income, we have taken measures to protect those jobs and “stimulate” the economy, including something called the “Paycheck Protection Program.”</p><p>In an efficient labor market, jobs only exist because we want the product of the labor and the only purpose of wages is to provide an incentive for people to perform that labor. But we don’t <em>have</em> an efficient labor market. Because we expect everyone to work for a living, we create and protect jobs as an excuse to pay people. And to the extent that we create jobs to push money to workers, it’s <em>not</em> because we actually want the product of the labor.</p><p>Employers are generally not, out of the kindness of their hearts, going to hire workers unless it is profitable to do so. As a consequence, we’ve had to use economic policy to <em>make it</em> profitable. We make it worthwhile for businesses to borrow cheap money to hire workers. The Paycheck Protection Program is just the latest example; our economy is rife with private-sector make-work.</p><p>It’s the whole economy. It’s everywhere. It’s big businesses. It’s small businesses. It’s restaurants, farms, etc. that wouldn’t otherwise <em>exist</em> without supportive tariffs, subsidies, and monetary policies. We do <em>crazy</em> stuff to protect American jobs and to keep people employed.</p><p>At the end of the day, some people can’t find jobs. But that’s okay. They never needed the <em>jobs</em>, to begin with. They needed the <em>money</em> from the jobs. Handing people money is easier and cheaper than trying to tweak economic conditions to make it profitable to hire everyone.</p><p>Which jobs are the useless jobs? I don’t know. It’s not even a per-job thing. It’s that the whole labor market is suffused with make-work. Pretty much every job is at least <em>partly</em> unnecessary.</p><p>We can’t point to a particular job and definitively identify it as make-work. We can’t know which jobs are useful until we calibrate the basic income to its natural level and achieve an efficient labor market. At that point, we can take a look around to see which jobs are still standing. Those will be the useful ones.</p><p>When we sent everyone home from work, it didn’t take long for skies to clear up over our cities. By forcing everyone to “earn” a living through a job, not only do we waste people’s time and other resources, but we also damage the environment. <em>Jobs are bad for the environment.</em></p><p>Employing people is only worth it when the benefits exceed the costs. Giving people money is <em>never</em> the right reason to create jobs. That’s what basic income is for.</p><h3>Monetary Stimulus</h3><p>It gets <em>worse</em>. One of the biggest ways that we generate private-sector make-work is through monetary policy. The Fed is responsible for keeping the general price level stable. It’s their job to ensure that the average price of metaphorical candy bars stays the same.</p><p>They do this by encouraging or discouraging borrowing in the financial sector. When the Fed discourages borrowing, it’s called monetary tightening. When they encourage borrowing, it’s called monetary stimulus. Encouraging borrowing is equivalent to encouraging <em>private-sector</em> money-printing.</p><p>But the distribution of the new borrowing is uneven. The people who can borrow the most money are the ones who already <em>have</em> the most money. Monetary stimulus, therefore, causes <em>fewer</em> people to have <em>more</em> spending power.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cWVWWxDIsyk0UCI7dslQHw.png" /><figcaption>When the economy under-produces, it’s called an “output gap.”</figcaption></figure><p>By skewing people’s spending power in this way, the Fed makes it more profitable for firms to produce fewer goods and services at higher prices. In other words, to prevent the general price level from falling, monetary stimulus makes it profitable for the vending machine only to <em>partially</em> restock itself every day.</p><p>The Fed succeeds in achieving a stable dollar using this method. But the result is that the economy under-produces and people are forced to spend their time doing unproductive work. Consumers lack sufficient money to buy all the candy bars the economy would otherwise be able to provide them. On the whole, people are over-worked and needlessly poor.</p><h3>Financial Instability and Recessions</h3><p>There’s another problem — one that might not seem so obviously connected to basic income: Continued monetary stimulus causes people and firms to borrow more and more money. Asset bubbles form. The interlocking web of private debt grows increasingly brittle with time. Eventually, we have a crash.</p><p>This is where most of our recessions come from. We get recessions every so often because, instead of funding consumers directly, we over-stimulate the financial sector to create jobs and prop up consumer spending.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fuc_nbNz2mYI%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Duc_nbNz2mYI&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fuc_nbNz2mYI%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/76b2eece4211d503df01013ead2ecf3e/href">https://medium.com/media/76b2eece4211d503df01013ead2ecf3e/href</a></iframe><p>It doesn’t have to be this way. With basic income calibrated to its natural level, recessions will only occur when there’s an actual hit to the economy’s real productive capacity. We might get a recession because of an asteroid strike, a natural disaster, or a pandemic. We will <em>never</em> see a recession caused by problems in financial markets.</p><p>In other words, a recession can only occur if something happens to the vending machine’s ability to <em>produce</em> the candy bars — not because people don’t have enough money to <em>buy</em> the candy bars.</p><h3>Calibrated Basic Income</h3><p>Basic income is commonly promoted as an amount of money that ensures a pre-determined minimum standard of living. But if we want consumers to reap the full benefit of what the economy has to offer and if we want to prevent future recessions, this is not enough. Instead, we must bring the basic income to its natural level.</p><p>The catch is that we don’t <em>know</em> our economy’s natural level of basic income ahead of time. To discover it, we will have to gradually feel for it. And because the natural level can change over time, we will have to continue to feel it out. Only by adopting an ongoing policy of <a href="https://www.greshm.org/blog/poverty-is-optional/"><strong><em>calibrated basic income</em></strong></a> can we ensure that the basic income stays as close as possible to its optimal level.</p><p>In practice, this would mean starting the basic income at a modest amount and gradually increasing it while we pay attention to what the economy does in response. As the basic income increases, we should expect the Fed to tighten monetary policy and rein in the private financial sector. The more we fund consumers directly, the less need we have to prop them up using monetary stimulus.</p><p>Eventually, we’ll reach a point where further increases in the basic income no longer provide any additional benefit. Everybody is already buying all the machine’s candy bars. The economy has hit the limits of its productive capacity. Further monetary tightening would only serve to impede useful investment. The financial sector can be too big — like it is now — but it can also be too small.</p><p>Over time, we should expect the natural level of basic income to increase as we develop new technology and become more productive. Under a régime of calibrated basic income, humanity will automatically reap the benefits of technological advancement. Less labor will mean more leisure, not more poverty.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>When I first became interested in basic income back in 2011, the only thing I understood about it was that it was <em>possible</em>. We could afford to do basic income. For this reason, I never really had to justify basic income on moral grounds or anything like that. I just knew that if we could hand everyone free money, it would be silly not to.</p><p>There is no basic income today. And that’s a problem because people can’t buy all the things that the economy would happily sell them. Instead of directly paying people a basic income, our government <em>indirectly</em> tries to push money to consumers through monetary policies that facilitate private-sector job creation. We are <em>already</em> handing people money. We’re just doing it inefficiently and we’re hiding it behind the fact we’re also handing people jobs.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FRow0Optdv8c%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DRow0Optdv8c&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FRow0Optdv8c%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ac8a7b6cf388dc6f2813f565870979c8/href">https://medium.com/media/ac8a7b6cf388dc6f2813f565870979c8/href</a></iframe><p>Without basic income, some people end up falling through the cracks. Other people are forced to do unnecessary work in order to “earn” enough money to survive. Meanwhile, the financial sector — Wall Street — becomes our government’s vehicle for pumping money out into the world. And because most of that money never actually sees the pockets of ordinary people, we compensate by over-feeding the financial sector to force money to trickle out to consumers through the labor market.</p><p>Lack of basic income is why our economy suffers from a repeated cycle of recessions. It’s why the global financial crisis happened in 2008. It’s why we were improperly equipped to handle the Covid-19 pandemic. It’s why we have poverty. Basic income is not a “nice to have” bonus kind of thing. It’s an “If we don’t have it, we’re in real trouble” kind of thing. We don’t have a basic income. We’re in real trouble. We have been for a while.</p><p>There <em>are</em> important problems that basic income does not solve. But the way we get people their money is broken, and basic income fixes <em>that</em>. This is a big deal. I don’t know how many of our society’s problems are caused by or exacerbated by a lack of basic income, but let’s find out.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=20edc1348694" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/discourse/the-economy-is-a-giant-vending-machine-20edc1348694">The Economy Is a Giant Vending Machine</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/discourse">Dialogue &amp; Discourse</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[YouTube Accidentally Permanently Terminated My Account]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@alexhowlett/youtube-accidentally-permanently-terminated-my-account-4b5852c80679?source=rss-dccc9dc9eee------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4b5852c80679</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[property]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[basic-income]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[youtube]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Howlett]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 11 Apr 2020 16:52:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-12T03:10:09.923Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>UPDATE: We’re back as of 8:39pm EDT April 11, 2020!</strong></p><p><strong>I received the following email from YouTube:</strong></p><blockquote><strong><em>Hi there,</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>After a review of your account, we have confirmed that your YouTube account is not in violation of our Terms of Service. As such, we have unsuspended your account. This means your account is once again active and operational.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>If you forgot your password, please visit this link to reset it:</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>&lt;snip&gt;</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Sincerely,<br>The YouTube Team</em></strong></blockquote><p><strong>Thanks so much to everyone who shared and tweeted the article. We even made it to the front page of Hacker News! I can’t say for sure if it made a difference, but it sure didn’t hurt!</strong></p><p>For the past two years, the <a href="https://www.facebook.com/groups/boston.basic.income">Boston Basic Income</a> YouTube channel has been live streaming our weekly discussion group as we explore different topics as they relate to basic income (UBI). We’ve covered nearly 100 different topics as varied as <a href="https://medium.com/human-capitalism/universal-basic-income-fixes-the-housing-market-639523c22b14">The Housing Market</a>, the Green New Deal, Say’s Law, the Great Depression, and <a href="https://medium.com/@alexhowlett/introduction-to-consumer-monetary-theory-78905b0606ca">Consumer Monetary Theory</a>.</p><p>Our recorded discussions have been a useful resource for people who seek to gain a deeper understanding of basic income. The videos contain important basic income content that just isn’t available anywhere else or in any other form. Except not. Because now it isn’t available <em>anywhere</em>.</p><blockquote>This account has been terminated for a violation of YouTube’s Terms of Service.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/769/1*AgOc7unv1AG6YPMcUqjiAw.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCsVjEFKDYn1yQ5E6raxM-dw">Boston Basic Income YouTube channel</a></figcaption></figure><p>As far as I can tell, the offending content is our <a href="https://www.facebook.com/events/232307341486576">upcoming discussion</a> with special guest Karl Widerquist. In other words, it’s content that doesn’t even <em>exist</em> yet. Karl is a philosophy professor who has been writing about basic income for decades. Perhaps YouTube is employing a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minority_Report_(film)"><em>Minority-Report</em></a>-style PreCrime unit that foresees Karl committing an act so heinous as to get the entire channel banned. But I don’t think so.</p><p>Could there be a copyright problem with the channel? Most weeks, we discuss excerpts from relevant articles or occasionally clips from videos or podcasts. But I can’t imagine that any of this doesn’t fall under the umbrella of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use">fair use</a>.</p><p>Bear in mind that I had received no notice that anything was amiss up till this point. And when I read the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/t/terms">Terms of Service</a>, nothing stands out to me. There’s certainly nothing in there that would warrant immediate permanent termination of the Boston Basic Income account.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/761/1*cp0Z1o8yZyezg4hnThzEvQ.png" /></figure><p>So, what happened? Two days ago (Thursday April 9, 2020), I received two emails from YouTube 26 minutes apart.</p><p>Here’s the first one.</p><blockquote>Boston Basic Income, your content violated YouTube’s Community Guidelines and has been removed</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/598/1*OuFaDfAcMIEaDOL2bcHrzQ.png" /></figure><p>This looks like a simple warning about a minor content violation, right? They claim to have removed the offending content and they’re admonishing me to be more careful next time. Fair enough, right?</p><blockquote>Our team has reviewed your content, and, unfortunately, we think it violates our . We’ve removed the following content from YouTube:</blockquote><blockquote>Video: <a href="http://www.google.com/appserve/mkt/p/AM7kBiV8wKtSJrCCWn5RigUXJ-i98ZmF44WSFRoK7u2yzRlqaT5cPhUw4okFUHOQDPj6rGmf86dBplR87yGF-bdvGKsqoTLfhniRsGXn3dbrvdmOIlHCUI0rNKzkPITI-P1F">Boston Basic Income #98: Karl Widerquist on Private Property</a></blockquote><p>Apparently, our content violated their _____. But again, this is <em>next week’s</em> live stream. All it contained was the title, the preview picture, and the description, which are the same as what we have on our <a href="https://www.facebook.com/events/232307341486576">Facebook event</a> and our <a href="https://www.meetup.com/bostonbi/events/269937844/">Meetup event</a> (minus the Zoom link and other logistics).</p><h4>Boston Basic Income #98: Karl Widerquist on Private Property</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MfHYIwwZSvD_XoTnYt3QaQ.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote>Philosopher and basic income expert Karl Widerquist returns to Boston Basic Income to talk about how basic income is a key factor in helping private property systems function effectively.</blockquote><blockquote>Karl will talk for an hour followed by questions.</blockquote><blockquote>Photo by Lisa Johnson on Pixabay<br>(<a href="https://pixabay.com/photos/private-property-sign-gate-private-1109273/">https://pixabay.com/photos/private-property-sign-gate-private-1109273/</a>)</blockquote><p>A couple of people on Twitter and Facebook have suggested that YouTube’s AI algorithms thought we were inciting people to violate private property. That’s as good a guess as any, I suppose. I chose the image because, for obvious reasons, it evokes the concept of private property. We used Karl’s face the last time he did Boston Basic Income and I didn’t want to be redundant.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ja9pWDRTtMzRH7Y-nTd06A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Karl Widerquist (Photo by Enno Schmidt)</figcaption></figure><p>Look at him. Look at that genuine smile. He’s harmless. I can’t imagine that this is anything other than a mistake on YouTube’s part. But what’s shocking is that they don’t have more safeguards in place before immediately hitting the “permanent termination” button on someone’s account. Speaking of which, here’s the second email I received 26 minutes later.</p><blockquote>YouTube Account Notification</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/622/1*ty5UtFlQliGvffeg59KbiQ.png" /></figure><p>Yikes. They received a complaint? And they terminated our account “upon review”? Was there <em>really</em> a review? After submitting the appeal form, I received the following email from <em>accounts-support@google.com</em>.</p><blockquote>RE: 2–4314000030061</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/442/1*chzy4Hhb6b-Wz3V5Exy1Ow.png" /></figure><p>Okay. It seems a little weird that I’d have to go through G Suite Support to resolve an issue with my YouTube account, but I’m willing to try anything at this point. Here’s yesterday’s transcript of my chat with the live support representative(s).</p><blockquote><strong>Status:</strong> Assigned<br><strong>Subject:</strong> My YouTube account has been permanently terminated without warning. I think this is a mistake.<br><strong>Description:</strong><br><strong>Chat Started:</strong> Fri, 10 Apr 2020 06:31:48 -0700<br><strong>Chat Subject:</strong> My YouTube account has been permanently terminated without warning. I think this is a mistake.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Miguel:</strong> Thank you for contacting G Suite Support. My name is Miguel and I’ll be working with you today. While I read over your message, is there anything else you’d like to add?</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Miguel:</strong> Hi! I hope you’re doing fine Alex.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> Hi Miguel.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> My YouTube channel was terminated:</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCsVjEFKDYn1yQ5E6raxM-dw">https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCsVjEFKDYn1yQ5E6raxM-dw</a></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> Here are the emails I received (26 minutes apart)</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> Customer attached youtube_content.png: &lt;snip&gt;</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> Customer attached youtube_terminated.png: &lt;snip&gt;</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Luisana:</strong> Thank you for contacting G Suite Support. My name is Luisana and I’ll be working with you today. While I read over your message, is there anything else you’d like to add?</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Luisana:</strong> Hi Alex, it looks like the connection with Miguel was lost. I apologize for the inconveniences but I’ll be happy to continue assisting you.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> Hi Luisana. Thanks.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> The content that was flagged was for an upcoming live stream that hasn’t even aired yet.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Luisana:</strong> Allow me just a quick moment to read over the chat transcript.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> Thanks.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Luisana:</strong> Alright, I understand your Youtube Channel has been flagged for violating terms of service and the Youtube support decided to remove the content or not let it air. Is this right?</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> My YouTube channel has been permanently terminated.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> without warning</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> And I believe it is an error because I don’t believe I have violated the terms of service.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Luisana:</strong> I see. Well, Alex I’m sorry to read this but I’m afraid that Youtube is not part of the core suite of G Suite services defined at <a href="https://gsuite.google.com/terms/user_features.html">https://gsuite.google.com/terms/user_features.html</a></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Luisana:</strong> This is out of the scope of our support, I don’t have any control over this however, allow me a moment to investigate in their Help Center to see if there is anything that can be done to have them reconsider.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> Thanks. It would be nice if I could know who to talk to.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> I filled out the appeal form yesterday, but I haven’t heard back.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> Other than a cryptic email about contacting G Suite support to reactivate my account… which I’m not sure is related.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Luisana:</strong> Unfortunately they don’t have live support agents since it’s a free service, only for Youtube TV memberships I believe. They only have contact via email once they review your appeal closely. About contacting G Suite, it doesn’t really apply to your case since this account is fully active at the moment.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> Hmm.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> This is the email I received.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> Customer attached g-suite.png: &lt;snip&gt;</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> (after filling out the appeal form for YouTube)</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Luisana:</strong> OK, I am checking here and all I see that can be done about this is fill out the appeal form you already submitted. You can confirm this here <a href="https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2802168">https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2802168</a></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Luisana:</strong> The email you receive looks like a template email, like an automatic reply. It doesn’t regard your appeal so that’s not the one that you will receive regarding this.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> I see.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> Any idea how long they take to respond to the appeals?</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Luisana:</strong> In these type of situations it normally takes from 48 to 72 hours but I don’t really have a way of knowing truly how long it will take, we don’t have contact with the Youtube team.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> OK. Thank you for your help even though it’s not your area.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Luisana:</strong> No problem, hope you can get this resolved as soon as possible.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Luisana:</strong> I will be closing this case but please don’t hesitate to get in touch in the future if you need any assistance with your core G Suite services, we’ll be happy to help.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Luisana:</strong> Thanks for chatting with Google Cloud support. There’s a short survey coming up and we’d love to hear your feedback about our interaction today. Have a good rest of your day.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Alex Howlett:</strong> Thank you. I will.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Google Cloud Support, Luisana:</strong> Stay safe.</blockquote><p>Hopefully, by the time you read this, the matter will be resolved. If not, Boston Basic Income will be live streaming future sessions and storing our videos on another platform. We will continue to organize our weekly Zoom meetings through our <a href="https://www.facebook.com/groups/boston.basic.income">Facebook</a> and <a href="https://www.meetup.com/bostonbi">Meetup</a> groups. And, as always, our discussions will be open to the public. Boston Basic Income isn’t going anywhere.</p><p>I do have backup archives of many of the videos and they will be back online again as soon as possible. Unfortunately, I was not diligent enough in keeping backups — especially early on. I am missing the following 21 videos.</p><blockquote>5. Moral Concerns<br>6. How to Pay for It<br>7. Andrew Yang<br>8. Funding Schemes<br>9. Inequality<br>10. Human Purpose<br>11. The Nature of Poverty<br>12. The Nature of Money<br>13. Immigration<br>14. Technological Unemployment<br>15. The Future<br>16. Climate and the Environment<br>17. Freedom<br>18. Intellectual Property<br>19. Project Greshm<br>22. Meritocracy and Entitlement<br>30. Population Growth<br>36. Iran Subsidy Reform<br>58. Education<br>63. Universal Basic Assets<br>65. The Free Rider Problem</blockquote><p>If YouTube fails to fix this error, then that content is largely gone. The good news is that I’ve written posts at the <a href="http://www.greshm.org/blog/archive/">Project Greshm Blog</a> based on the first 14 Boston Basic Income discussions. In the process of doing so, I created partial transcripts of those particular videos. We’ll piece together as much as we can.</p><p>I understand that online platforms like YouTube are experiencing extra load during this time of social distancing. I hope that’s all this is and that our YouTube channel will be back to normal soon.</p><p>The moral of the story is to back up your videos.</p><p>By the way, did you know that YouTube launched as a dating site?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/742/1*vR64ieuRL2AvzpiQOrlSWw.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4b5852c80679" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Introduction to Consumer Monetary Theory]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/human-capitalism/introduction-to-consumer-monetary-theory-78905b0606ca?source=rss-dccc9dc9eee------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/78905b0606ca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[money]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mmt]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[labor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[basic-income]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Howlett]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Jan 2020 18:30:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-25T21:24:29.515Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*a5JhZExP5rORIBfXIAqpPA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@joshrh19?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Joshua Rawson-Harris</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Consumer Monetary Theory (CMT) is a framework for understanding the role of money in giving consumers access to the economy’s output.</p><p>The economy exists for the benefit of the people. A well-functioning market economy serves us all. It promotes our well-being by producing goods and services for us to consume. We are all consumers.</p><blockquote>Consumption is the sole end and purpose of all production; and the interest of the producer ought to be attended to, only so far as it may be necessary for promoting that of the consumer.<br> — Adam Smith | <em>The Wealth of Nations</em> | 1776</blockquote><p>Without someone to consume the economy’s products, there’s no point in <em>having</em> any products. The consumer is central to the market economy because the people come first. Workers and firms are important only insofar as their products benefit actual people.</p><h3>Money as a Pricing Standard</h3><p>A market economy requires a standard unit of value in which to set the prices of its products. The use of spendable standard-value tokens makes it a simple matter for people to pay those prices. This standard unit and its standard-value tokens are the things we call currency and money.</p><p>As John Hicks explained in <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Market-Theory-Money-John-Hicks/dp/0198796234/"><em>A Market Theory of Money</em></a>, markets and money go hand in hand. You can’t have one without the other. A market will <em>always</em> find a standard unit to use as its currency.</p><blockquote>[T]he function of money as a standard, if it is no more than a standard, is to make it possible to form a price-list, in which the values of a number of commodities are reduced to a common measure.<br> — John Hicks | <em>A Market Theory of Money</em> | 1989</blockquote><p>We consumers spend our standard-value money tokens — that is to say, our dollars — to buy goods and services from the economy’s producers. People who lack access to dollars can’t be consumers. They can’t buy goods and services. They can’t buy food. The market economy cannot promote their well-being.</p><p>Our dollars represent claim tickets against the economy’s production. Whenever we spend a dollar, we <em>claim</em> for ourselves one dollar’s worth of the economy’s productive output. Consumers are continually buying and using the goods and services that support their livelihoods. They’re redeeming their money tokens in exchange for the economy’s products.</p><p>As consumers pump money into the economy, the economy pumps back out food, books, cars, computers, etc. Money flows in one direction while goods and services flow in the opposite direction.</p><h3>The Income Theory of Money</h3><p>For the economy to set reliable prices, people need to know what a dollar is worth. The dollar’s purchasing power and, therefore, the general level of consumer prices must remain steady, at least over the short-run. That is to say, one dollar has to be able to claim the same amount of stuff tomorrow as it did today.</p><p>Stable currency implies that the flow of consumer spending remains commensurate to the opposite flow of production. If spending levels change, then production levels must change to match, and vice versa. Whenever spending outstrips production, prices increase; we see inflation. Whenever production outstrips spending, prices decrease; we see deflation.</p><p>Because reliable prices are important to the smooth functioning of markets, institutions have necessarily emerged to maintain the currency’s stable purchasing power. These institutions are called central banks and their monetary policy influences the financial sector so as to modulate the spending flow to ensure that it continues to match the production flow.</p><p>The framework for describing prices and the general price level in terms of flows is called the Income Theory of Money.</p><blockquote>The income theory of money is a theory of nominal prices. Its aim is to explain the process of the determination of monetary prices in the market economy. It is a flow oriented approach which distinguishes it from the stock orientation of the naive quantity theory of money.<br> — Josef Menšík | <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/276088445_The_Origins_of_the_Income_Theory_of_Money">The Origins of the Income Theory of Money</a> | 2014</blockquote><p>The Quantity Theory of Money provides an alternative explanation for the general price level. Unlike Income Theory, Quantity Theory focuses on the amount of money tokens “in existence.” This, of course, requires that there actually <em>exists</em> a definable quantity of money tokens. We call this hypothetical quantity the “money stock.” Quantity Theory imagines that the money stock continually passes through the economy from person to person at a turnover rate called the “velocity of money.” The money just keeps circulating at that velocity.</p><p>On the face of it, Income Theory and Quantity Theory appear to be two different ways of describing exactly the same thing. Indeed, under Quantity Theory, we can derive the spending level simply by multiplying the money stock by its velocity. And if the velocity is fairly steady, then the money stock itself can even stand in as a proxy for the spending flow. To understand changes in the general price level, we need look no further than the money stock.</p><p>The problem with this clever description is that <a href="http://www.greshm.org/blog/money-does-not-circulate/">money does not circulate</a>. Money flows in a direction from consumers to producers. Furthermore, the money stock is <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_supply">not so easy to define</a> either in theory or in practice. This makes it difficult for Quantity Theory to map onto reality in any meaningful way.</p><p>By contrast, Income Theory focuses on spending, which is where prices are actually paid. Income theory works <em>regardless</em> of whether prices happen to be paid using official, or measurable, money tokens. To buy a ten-dollar hamburger, you could pay with a ten-dollar bill, with ten dollars’ worth of jelly beans, or even with a scrap of paper that says “I owe you ten dollars.”</p><p>It doesn’t matter how you make the payment. It still counts toward the economy’s spending flow. All that matters is that the price is denominated using the standard currency unit. You paid the price and that price is the price.</p><h3>Consumers vs. Producers</h3><p>“Consumer” and “producer” are roles that people play in the economy. While it is true that producers ultimately serve consumers, it is also true that some people do both. Workers are people who consume <em>and</em> produce. They contribute their labor to the economy in exchange for money.</p><p>We could imagine a world in which everyone consumes exactly in proportion to what they produce. In such a world, everyone is a worker. Each worker produces something, gets paid for it, and buys stuff from other workers. Naturally, those who contribute more labor are the ones who are able to consume more goods and services. Money is recycled perfectly and the Quantity Theory of Money starts to look a lot more plausible.</p><p>In this world, dollars merely serve as a medium of exchange that facilitates trade and allows people to benefit from the fruits of each other’s labor. Unfortunately, this is impossible. The real world doesn’t work that way. It can’t.</p><p>Perhaps there was a time in history when the market economy behaved more like a system of mutual exchange among workers. But with the industrial revolution, the idea that consumers and producers were the same people became largely a fiction. Industrialization caused the market economy to become less like a system of exchange among workers and more like a system of distribution from producers to consumers.</p><p>Despite industrialization making this more extreme, it has always been true and will always be true that some people produce more than they consume while others consume more than they produce. The possibility of accumulating money (financial wealth) acts as an incentive for people to produce in excess of their consumption. People enjoy having the <em>power</em> to claim more goods and services than they’ll ever actually claim. This is a feature, not a bug. Producers are motivated by profit to <em>make</em> more than they <em>take</em>.</p><p>Meanwhile, the rest of us get to <em>take</em> more than we <em>make</em>. In theory, consumers can access some amount of the economy’s production without having to work for it. Producers are happy to siphon off money while consumers enjoy the benefit of the economy’s products. This is a good thing. As I said before, the economy exists for the benefit of the people. The more benefit we receive, the better off we are. That’s kind of the whole point.</p><p>What ultimately makes this possible is that market incentives induce us collectively to produce the output we collectively want to consume. It doesn’t matter <em>who</em> happens to be doing the work, or how much each individual happens to be working. As long as producers want to produce, consumers can consume.</p><h3>The Wage-Price Gap</h3><p>An efficient labor market does <em>not</em> continually recycle the economy’s money back to consumers. Recall that producers are always siphoning off their profits. But consumer spending hasn’t gone to zero, so consumers <em>must</em> be getting their money replenished <em>somehow</em>.</p><p>During World War I, British engineer Major C.H. Douglas noticed that it was impossible for workers to collectively spend their wages to buy the full product of their own labor. There would always be a gap between wages and product prices. Troubled by this observation, he devoted the rest of his life to explaining this problem and developing his “Social Credit” economic framework.</p><blockquote>[T]he persons who want and cannot do without the goods which the productive and industrial system can, and is anxious to supply, have not in their possession the tickets, the possession of which is essential before these goods, under present conditions, can be handed over.<br> — C.H. Douglas | <a href="https://www.socred.org/images/douglas-archives/Social-Credit-by-Major-Clifford-Hugh-Douglas.pdf"><em>Social Credit (revised edition)</em></a> | 1933</blockquote><p>This was an important insight. Producers won’t produce what consumers lack the money to buy. Douglas proposed to close the wage-price gap by issuing new money and handing it out to everyone in what he called the National Dividend: an income stream unconditionally paid to every individual person.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FDx_eWL64ius%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DDx_eWL64ius&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FDx_eWL64ius%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/51028734094579fddab2584953e5d2d2/href">https://medium.com/media/51028734094579fddab2584953e5d2d2/href</a></iframe><p>Today’s readers will recognize this as a basic income or UBI. If consumers need a constant stream of new money in order to keep the economy going, then providing them a constant stream of new money is the obvious solution.</p><p>But Douglas was concerned that his National Dividend plan might cause inflation. Sadly, he only understood the price level from a Quantity Theory perspective. Douglas failed to develop a coherent theory of money, banking, and credit. He never recognized that prices would be kept stable simply by matching the flow of consumer spending to the flow of production.</p><p>To address any potential inflation his National Dividend might cause, Douglas developed a convoluted, unworkable system of subsidies designed to pay producers to keep their prices down. Not only did Douglas have this kooky anti-inflation scheme, but he also espoused anti-Semitic conspiracy theories about rich bankers controlling the global economy. None of this did him any favors in intellectual circles. He was largely written off as a crackpot by serious thinkers. Nevertheless, he was a crackpot with some important insights.</p><p>An efficient market economy requires a wage-price gap. It also requires that we fill in the gap with another source of consumer spending power. And we need to do all this while maintaining the currency’s stable purchasing power.</p><h3>Money vs. Jobs</h3><p>In our society, instead of embracing the wage-price gap, we have attempted to <em>close</em> the gap. We use economic policy to create jobs and to stimulate the financial sector. Rather than ensuring sufficient distribution of consumer incomes, we’ve been distracted by the “problem” of unemployment.</p><blockquote>The so-called unemployment problem is really a problem of leisure, and the only thing, which differentiates, let us say, myself from one of the unemployed, is that I happen to be fortunate enough to have a certain amount of purchasing power, whereas the unfortunate unemployed has not.<br> — C.H. Douglas | <a href="https://www.socred.org/images/douglas-archives/Money-and-the-Price-System.pdf"><em>Money and the Price System</em></a> | 1935</blockquote><p>Standard economic theory incorrectly suggests that an efficient market economy provides consumers their incomes through jobs. As we have seen, this theory is wrong. Yet, our economic policies dutifully do their best to ensure that everyone has a job. What doesn’t work in theory, we’re forcing to make work in practice. And the result hasn’t been great.</p><p>That result is make-work. To the extent that we create jobs to push money to workers, we’re not creating those jobs because we actually want the product of the labor. The insidious thing about make-work is that it doesn’t usually <em>look</em> like make-work. Private-sector firms aren’t generally going to hire workers they don’t actually need. But, with the goal of job creation, we use economic policy to keep firms alive that would otherwise fail.</p><p>Make-work hurts the efficiency of the labor market. Our workers become less productive. To some extent, workers are not even producers anymore. They’re merely consumers being kept needlessly busy as an excuse to give them money. Many workers are <a href="https://www.strike.coop/bullshit-jobs/">painfully aware</a> that their labor contributes nothing to society. Others have no clue.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F5EX999qUe7E%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D5EX999qUe7E&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F5EX999qUe7E%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ef8578677e90f20a3d0cb1361e7ce951/href">https://medium.com/media/ef8578677e90f20a3d0cb1361e7ce951/href</a></iframe><p>The way we get people their money is broken. Prices might be stable, but our economy is under-producing and allocating labor inefficiently. Furthermore, many people remain unable to access the goods and services that a well-functioning market economy would be fully capable of providing them. We’re so focused on trying to get everyone a job that we’re failing to ensure that everyone has money. Getting people jobs is hard and counterproductive. Giving people money is necessary. Basic income is easy.</p><h3>The Business Cycle</h3><p>Recall that central banks are responsible for managing the flow of consumer spending to ensure price stability. In the US, our central bank is the Federal Reserve System (the Fed). The Fed keeps track of how well they’re doing by measuring the average price of consumer goods. There are <a href="https://www.bls.gov/opub/btn/archive/differences-between-the-consumer-price-index-and-the-personal-consumption-expenditures-price-index.pdf">multiple ways</a> to do that and plenty of disagreement over which way is the best. Nevertheless, the purchasing power of money is <em>defined</em> in terms of consumers and it can’t be any other way.</p><p>The Fed’s monetary policy manages consumer spending by encouraging or discouraging borrowing in the financial sector. The more money people can borrow, the more money they can spend. When the Fed discourages borrowing, it’s called monetary tightening. When they encourage borrowing, it’s called monetary stimulus.</p><p>Monetary tightening works by increasing the interest rate at which the <em>government</em> borrows from the financial sector. Lenders won’t lend to someone who isn’t willing to pay more interest than the government pays. When the government pays more interest, it forces everyone else to pay more interest to compete with the government. The result is that people borrow less as borrowing becomes more expensive.</p><p>Monetary stimulus has the opposite effect. Lower interest rates make it cheaper for everybody to borrow. This allows the private sector to borrow more. In fact, our financial institutions both lend <em>and </em>borrow. They borrow money only to lend it out again at a higher interest rate. This practice of lending to borrow can increase the total amount of private-sector lending and borrowing by <em>a lot</em>.</p><p>Monetary stimulus impacts the wage-price gap in three important ways. The first two ways are obvious and the third is more subtle. The first impact is that the stimulus allows <em>consumers themselves</em> directly to borrow more money and therefore to spend more. This is straightforward. The additional consumer spending power helps <em>fill in</em> the wage-price gap.</p><p>The second, larger, impact is that firms can borrow money to hire more workers. This is the primary mechanism by which economic policy “creates jobs” and helps to <em>narrow</em> the wage-price gap by boosting wages. Of course, having unproductive, unprofitable firms hire more workers just means we’re keeping people needlessly employed.</p><p>The third impact has to do with the <em>distribution</em> of borrowing. The people who are able to <em>borrow</em> the most money are the ones who already <em>have</em> the most money. When fewer people have more money to spend, it becomes more profitable for firms to produce fewer goods and services at higher prices. Economists call this a steeper aggregate demand curve. It helps narrow the wage-price gap by reducing the flow of production. Each unit of production has the same price as before, but there is less total production.</p><p>At the end of the day, the flow of consumer spending matches the flow of production. We have achieved price stability. But the economy is under-producing, some people are being forced to do unproductive work, and consumers lack the money to buy goods and services the economy would otherwise be able to provide them. In other words, people are over-worked and needlessly poor.</p><p>There’s another problem too. In order for the economy to keep churning along, people and firms have to continue borrowing more and more money. This process is not sustainable. It creates instability in the financial sector. New debt continues to stack on top of old debt and the financial system grows increasingly brittle over time. Eventually, the bubble pops and it all comes crashing down. And then we do it again!</p><p>Even during boom times, some people are left behind. We have the resources to provide a better standard of living, but those resources are not being properly activated.</p><p>I’ve just described for you the status quo. Our economy has looked like this for <em>a while</em>. We are continually subjecting ourselves to a cycle of booms and busts without ever reaching our full potential. Economists call this the business cycle and they generally take it as an unavoidable natural feature of the economy. It is not.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fvideoseries%3Flist%3DPLSuwqsAnJMtwZEwkJgHZCod2xP9b7skF5&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fplaylist%3Flist%3DPLSuwqsAnJMtwZEwkJgHZCod2xP9b7skF5&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FKNEouYM5wRE%2Fhqdefault.jpg%3Fsqp%3D-oaymwEWCKgBEF5IWvKriqkDCQgBFQAAiEIYAQ%3D%3D%26rs%3DAOn4CLCk0A5Cc-gngc0Sa9alkS4h77jbLg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="853" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/935fd49aaaa4944bafafde7c5e2f2c23/href">https://medium.com/media/935fd49aaaa4944bafafde7c5e2f2c23/href</a></iframe><p>There is much more to monetary policy and financial markets. If you’d like to explore deeper, you can start with Perry Mehrling’s incredibly engaging and insightful online course, <a href="https://www.coursera.org/learn/money-banking"><em>Economics of Money and Banking</em></a>. I can’t recommend his course highly enough.</p><p>The financial sector doesn’t need to be as big and as complicated as it has become. Our aversion to giving people money directly has caused us to over-engineer the financial markets. We continue to develop new financial innovations and regulations. Just to sustain consumer spending, we grow the bubble a little bit larger and make it last a little bit longer.</p><h3>Calibrated Basic Income</h3><p>By now, I’ve covered the nuts and bolts of Consumer Monetary Theory (CMT). CMT describes the economy as a system that produces goods and services for consumers. It explains how the flow of standard-value money tokens distributes the flow of economic output from producers to consumers. CMT reveals the danger in treating people as workers and the harm caused by pursuing a full-employment agenda and over-stimulating the financial sector.</p><p>We currently rely on monetary over-stimulus, make-work, and under-production to narrow the wage-price gap. We then fill the remaining gap with consumer debt and various inconsistent policies to assist people who were “unfortunate” enough not to get a job.</p><p><em>We can do better.</em></p><p>The fact that we even think of the wage-price gap as a gap is somewhat strange in the first place. People need money, not jobs. They need incomes, not wages. The labor market is a market for getting people to spend their time doing something other than what they’d normally do. Most of the important work done by humanity is not paid. Jobs are only important when, for whatever reason, we need people to do <em>different</em> work.</p><p>The labor market is a market for allocating the resource of labor. It’s not supposed to be a tool for funneling money to consumers.</p><p>By calibrating a basic income to match the economy’s productive capacity, we can close the gap between what consumers actually get and the economy’s full potential to provide for them. This is a gap that’s actually <em>useful</em> to close. <a href="http://www.greshm.org/blog/poverty-is-optional/">Calibrated basic income</a> allows the labor market to be efficient such that jobs exist only because we actually want the product of the labor and the only purpose of wages is to provide an incentive for people to perform that labor.</p><p>Directly funding consumer spending allows the Fed to tighten its monetary policy and rein in the financial sector. We can maintain stable sustainable levels of lending and borrowing. No more runaway growth of private debt and asset bubbles that invariably cause the financial system to collapse in on itself. No more recessions caused by anything other than a drop in the economy’s real productive capacity. No more business cycle.</p><p>We can’t know ahead of time what the optimal level of basic income is. That’s why we calibrate it. We gradually increase the amount of the payout until further increases provide no additional benefit. We’ll know we’ve hit the sweet spot once output stops increasing or we’re happy with the level of private-sector investment.</p><p>If we accidentally overshoot and set the basic income too high, then we’ll get a period of inflation until the inflation brings the purchasing power of the basic income back down to a level the economy can match with production of goods and services. If we accidentally undershoot and set the basic income too low, we’ll have to over-stimulate the financial sector and generate make-work to compensate. That’s what’s happening now. Our basic income is zero. Oops.</p><p>Once we actually do get the basic income to the natural level for our economy, we can continue to calibrate it on an ongoing basis to match the economy’s productive potential. This ensures that consumers can fully benefit from that potential even as it grows.</p><p>Basic income aligns the incentives of the market with what’s good for consumers. When consumers are the ones who have the money, then the way for firms to profit is by serving consumers directly through the production of goods and services. Not only does a calibrated basic income activate the economy’s full productive capacity, but it ensures that new capacity will also be activated. This creates an incentive to build that further capacity. If you build it, they will come.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FR4xLZ1if1F0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DR4xLZ1if1F0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FR4xLZ1if1F0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/1a49d7cd9662ce90044c5116861125f6/href">https://medium.com/media/1a49d7cd9662ce90044c5116861125f6/href</a></iframe><p>Some economists believe in a rule called <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Say%27s_law">Say’s Law</a>, which says that supply creates its own demand. A calibrated basic income makes Say’s Law true. It turns the dream into a reality.</p><p>It is unnecessary and therefore unacceptable for anyone to have to live in poverty. We can do better. By definition, a calibrated basic income is the highest basic income we can afford. To the extent that our economy has the resources to end poverty, a calibrated basic income ends poverty.</p><h3>Consumer Monetary Theory vs Modern Monetary Theory</h3><p>You may have noticed that I haven’t said anything about taxes. The level of basic income we can afford has nothing to do with how much tax revenue we collect. It only has to do with how much consumer spending the economy can match with a commensurate flow of production.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fn8w9DWsP4zY%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dn8w9DWsP4zY&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fn8w9DWsP4zY%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/06a882a163871c60a1cc8a19720c2a22/href">https://medium.com/media/06a882a163871c60a1cc8a19720c2a22/href</a></iframe><p>In recent years, there’s been some buzz surrounding what’s called <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modern_Monetary_Theory">Modern Monetary Theory</a> (MMT). As with CMT, MMT is a framework for understanding money’s role in the economy. MMT is famous for claiming that taxes do not fund government spending. <a href="http://www.greshm.org/blog/tax-revenue-is-meaningless/">CMT agrees</a>.</p><p>Government spending is made possible by there being something for the money to go toward. It all comes down to matching streams of production with the streams of spending. The government can spend money to allocate resources directly for infrastructure or public services. In the case of basic income, the government delegates the resource allocation to consumers acting through the market.</p><p>Taxes can certainly be used to change market incentives and free up resources. For example, meat is a very resource-intensive form of food. A tax on meat would free up land for other uses. Indirectly, this may allow the government to spend more, either on their own projects or on a higher basic income. But there is no 1-to-1 relationship between spending and taxes.</p><p>To put it another way, when the government spends money, they are <em>not</em> spending taxpayer dollars. The <a href="http://www.greshm.org/blog/theres-only-one-way-to-pay-for-a-basic-income/">only way</a> to “pay for” a basic income is by having an economy that can productively respond to the resulting flow of consumer spending.</p><p>There are many important differences between CMT and MMT. CMT takes a consumer-oriented perspective on the economy and treats money as a fundamental property of markets that is necessarily managed by institutions. MMT focuses on labor and workers and treats money as a government monopoly that’s enforced through taxes.</p><p>CMT describes how money supports the economy’s role in providing goods and services to consumers. MMT seeks to understand the monetary system in a way that allows policymakers to bring the economy to full employment. But if we define “full employment” as an economy where everyone who wants a job has one, we can achieve full employment either by giving everyone a job or just by raising the basic income high enough that nobody without a job actually wants one anymore.</p><p>There are other important similarities and differences between CMT and MMT. To get an overview, see my <a href="https://youtu.be/n8w9DWsP4zY">recent discussion</a> with Derek Van Gorder.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FjajL83BDoU8%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DjajL83BDoU8&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FjajL83BDoU8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/eef41853fb432d074a81afb13fb0d86e/href">https://medium.com/media/eef41853fb432d074a81afb13fb0d86e/href</a></iframe><p>For a more in-depth look at CMT, inflation, calibrated basic income, and the contrast with MMT, see our Boston Basic Income <a href="https://youtu.be/jajL83BDoU8">discussion</a> from 2018.</p><p>MMT is very much aligned with orthodox macroeconomic theory in its focus on labor and employment. Even during the Great Depression of the 1930’s, John Maynard Keynes was trying to understand the “problem” of unemployment. In the 1930’s, our economy had more productive capacity than in the 1920’s, yet we were producing less. The problem was never a lack of jobs. It was a lack of consumer spending power.</p><p>Economic theory is only as good as the assumptions it makes. For our macroeconomic framework to accurately reflect the real-world economy’s role in serving the people, we must put <em>consumers</em> first, not workers or firms.</p><p>Andrew Yang is a presidential candidate running on basic income as the main plank of is platform. The first time I met him, he asked me if I was an MMT guy. I said, “I get that a lot.”</p><p>To the untrained eye, CMT can look almost like a shoehorning of basic income into the MMT framework. That’s not exactly right. CMT is its own thing and the differences matter.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Our intuition tells us that money perpetually circulates through the economy, but that’s not the reality. Our intuition tells us that the economy is more productive if everyone’s a worker, but that’s not the reality. And trying to <em>make</em> it our reality by reaching for full employment only causes problems. We prop up consumer spending by over-stimulating the financial sector.</p><p>Consumers are the heart of the economy. The people are the heart of the economy. And for the economy to serve the people, those people need money to spend. As consumers spend, they activate production by pumping money through the economy. Money flows away from consumers while goods and services flow toward them.</p><p>Basic income supporters have hit on something that’s even more important than they realize. The economy needs sustainable consumer spending and not an over-stimulated financial sector. Calibrated basic income is a critical piece of economic infrastructure that we happen to be missing.</p><p>A friend of mine once chided me.</p><blockquote>Come on, Alex! Basic income is not some magic wand that fixes all the world’s problems.</blockquote><p>Of course not. Basic income only fixes the problems that are caused by lack of basic income. I don’t know how many of our society’s problems fall under that umbrella, but I’m sure it’s more than a few.</p><p>Basic income has no place in macroeconomic models that assume consumers get their incomes through jobs, that money keeps circulating, and that the Quantity Theory of Money determines the general level of consumer prices.</p><p>If Andrew Yang and other basic income advocates want to be taken seriously, then they’re going to have to have to start backing up their rhetoric with economic theory that’s actually compatible with basic income.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=78905b0606ca" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/human-capitalism/introduction-to-consumer-monetary-theory-78905b0606ca">Introduction to Consumer Monetary Theory</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/human-capitalism">Human Capitalism</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Universal Basic Income Fixes the Housing Market]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/human-capitalism/universal-basic-income-fixes-the-housing-market-639523c22b14?source=rss-dccc9dc9eee------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/639523c22b14</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[rent]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[housing-prices]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[basic-income]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[andrew-yang]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Howlett]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Jul 2019 21:43:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-02T15:49:26.351Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pfXOHktAZtHyIueegobwdw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@brenoassis?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Breno Assis</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/search/photos/real-estate?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>In cities like New York, San Francisco, and Boston, housing prices and rents are high and rising.</p><p>The usual prescription for bringing down housing prices is to build more housing. On the face of it, this makes perfect sense. An increase in the supply of housing forces sellers to compete for buyers and landlords to compete for tenants. Econ 101 tells us that this will cause prices to fall. And it just might. But there’s a simpler way.</p><p>Last fall, I attended a panel discussion in which policy researcher Will Wilkinson of the Niskanen Center laid out his proposed solution to expensive housing. As a twist on the usual prescription, Wilkinson’s plan reveals some insights that get us part of the way to the more elegant solution.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FMRU8-YgYKKA%3Fstart%3D975%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D975&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DMRU8-YgYKKA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FMRU8-YgYKKA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/50ae01ecede6146e8289c4898c7b6d1c/href">https://medium.com/media/50ae01ecede6146e8289c4898c7b6d1c/href</a></iframe><blockquote>People who’ve got a house back when they were cheaper, are sitting on this quickly appreciating asset, so their wealth is growing — it’s ballooning while poor people can’t accumulate any wealth at all because they have nothing to save after they pay for their housing.<br> — <a href="https://youtu.be/MRU8-YgYKKA?t=1112">Will Wilkinson 18:32</a></blockquote><p>According to Wilkinson, what’s standing in the way of greater housing supply is zoning laws that restrict land use. This is a common explanation. Developers don’t build more housing because they’re not allowed to. And they’re not allowed to because people who own property don’t want them to.</p><blockquote>People just want their house to appreciate in value because we’ve structured our system in an insane way to push people to treat their house as an investment vehicle, which is a really really bad idea.<br> — <a href="https://youtu.be/MRU8-YgYKKA?t=2542">Will Wilkinson 42:22</a></blockquote><p>Wilkinson is right about this problem and he has a clever plan to use Federal money as a carrot to incentivize states and municipalities to make zoning more permissive. The idea is for these incentives to overpower the preferences of property owners to restrict development.</p><p>As I said, however, there’s a simpler, more elegant solution. Instead of looking at housing <em>supply</em> we can look at housing <em>demand</em>. A big part of the reason for the concentration of housing demand is that the housing market is tightly intertwined with the labor market. People tend to need to live near where the jobs are.</p><p>Wilkinson emphasizes this connection too.</p><blockquote>When these housing restrictions — when land-use restrictions — make housing too expensive, it makes it impossible for workers to move to the labor markets where they’re most productive.<br> —<a href="https://youtu.be/MRU8-YgYKKA?t=1177"> Will Wilkinson 19:37</a></blockquote><p>What Wilkinson fails to recognize is that the economy doesn’t actually <em>need</em> all those people to be living near those jobs. The people need the jobs, but the jobs don’t need the people. What if people had more freedom to live wherever they wanted without having to give so much consideration to the job market?</p><p>That freedom is exactly what Universal Basic Income (UBI) gives us. UBI is an unconditional income paid to every individual person. It solves the problem of how to get spending money into people’s hands. And it accomplishes this independently of the labor market. UBI is an income that’s not tied to any particular location.</p><p>By providing people more freedom to live in different places, UBI does the equivalent of flooding the market with cheap homes. That’s going to drive down rents in cities where housing is currently tight. It’s going to drive down real estate prices in general.</p><p>This is a good thing. Cheaper housing is better for people. Homes shouldn’t be treated as investments in the first place. If you’re invested in real estate and you think a UBI is coming, you might want to get out.</p><p>A city’s residents can always exert some control over the supply of housing in their neighborhoods. But there’s nothing they can do to overcome the drop in demand that a UBI will induce. They can restrict new development all they want, but housing will nonetheless become cheaper and more affordable.</p><p>When people first hear about UBI, they worry that landlords will respond by raising their rents. But this is backwards. The landlords <em>can’t</em> raise the rents. They can only ever charge as much rent as renters are willing to pay. And the higher the UBI, the less that people are tied down to a particular location, hence the less rent they’re willing to pay. In order to attract tenants, landlords would instead have to <em>lower</em> their rents.</p><p>Along with Will Wilkinson’s permissive zoning plan, the panel also featured a discussion of UBI. Sitting right in front of Wilkinson was the solution to expensive housing. He just didn’t recognize it. Universal Basic Income fixes what’s broken in the housing market — by crashing it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=639523c22b14" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/human-capitalism/universal-basic-income-fixes-the-housing-market-639523c22b14">Universal Basic Income Fixes the Housing Market</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/human-capitalism">Human Capitalism</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Unofficial Freedom Dividend FAQ]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/human-capitalism/the-unofficial-freedom-dividend-faq-e06276f43dc3?source=rss-dccc9dc9eee------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e06276f43dc3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[2020-presidential-race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[housing-prices]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[value-added-tax]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[andrew-yang]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[basic-income]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Howlett]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 30 Mar 2019 20:46:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-27T17:38:06.626Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>Last Updated: September 23, 2019</em></strong></p><p>I tend to see the same questions come up again and again regarding Andrew Yang’s $1,000 per month <a href="https://www.yang2020.com/policies/the-freedom-dividend/">Freedom Dividend</a> universal basic income (UBI) plan. Here are the answers.</p><p><strong>2019–03–30: </strong><a href="#b7a9">Won’t giving everyone money just cause inflation?</a><br><strong>2019–03–30: </strong><a href="#cfba">Won’t people just quit their jobs?</a><br><strong>2019–03–30: </strong><a href="#0a6e">Won’t landlords just raise their rents?</a><br><strong>2019–03–30: </strong><a href="#93a5">Isn’t the Freedom Dividend just socialism?</a><br><strong>2019–03–30: </strong><a href="#7cf0">Where is the money going to come from to pay for it?</a><br><strong>2019–03–30: </strong><a href="#3a54">Won’t the VAT just be passed on to consumers?</a><br><strong>2019–04–14: </strong><a href="#12ac">Are we really facing a crisis of robots taking jobs?</a><br><strong>2019–04–14: </strong><a href="#1ee1">Is $1,000 per month enough?</a><br><strong>2019–08–10: </strong><a href="#b254">Why should rich people get free money?</a><br><strong>2019–09–23</strong>: <a href="#bbac">Does It Dismantle the Safety Net?</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hVPXPGx7cs7jZ8RoVPufuw.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/collisionconf/27964738858">Photo</a> by Stephen McCarthy/Collision</figcaption></figure><h3>Won’t giving everyone money just cause inflation?</h3><p><strong>Yang’s Answer:</strong> No. The Freedom Dividend is not adding new money to the economy.</p><p><strong>The Real Answer:</strong> No. Inflation occurs when consumer spending outstrips production. In this scenario, buyers offer to pay more to compete for a limited number of goods.</p><p>A $1,000/month Freedom Dividend isn’t enough to push consumer spending beyond what the economy can handle. Instead, most businesses have the resources to profitably produce more of their products at current prices. The higher production would match the higher levels of consumer spending.</p><p>The fact that no new money is created is irrelevant. The Fed keeps prices stable using monetary policy. And they have plenty of room to raise interest rates in response to any inflationary pressure.</p><p>If the amount of the UBI were too high, it would push consumer spending beyond what the economy can productively respond to. The Fed would no longer be able to keep prices stable and there would be a period of inflation until the inflation brought consumer purchasing power back down to a level the economy could handle.</p><p>It’s important to remember that inflation is <em>not</em> about the amount of money “in the economy.” It’s about the amount of <em>spending</em>. More precisely, it’s about the level of consumer spending relative to the level of production of consumer goods.</p><p>See <a href="http://www.greshm.org/blog/money-does-not-circulate/">this blog post</a> for more.</p><h3>Won’t people just quit their jobs?</h3><p><strong>Yang’s Answer:</strong> No. $12,000 per year is not enough to quit your job.</p><p><strong>The Real Answer:</strong> Of course some people will quit their jobs. When you hand people money, it changes their incentives. Because the Freedom Dividend gives people more freedom to spend their time in different ways, some will choose to do exactly that. This could mean people working at jobs that pay less or it could mean people spending time doing unpaid activities.</p><p>This is a good thing. If we have the resources to provide people with more freedom, then we absolutely should. Otherwise, we’re unnecessarily constraining people.</p><p>Don’t forget that the labor market is a market. If the market needs people to work, it will pay them to work. Because people will have more freedom, the Freedom Dividend will increase the amount we need to pay for less desirable jobs and decrease the amount we need to pay for more desirable jobs.</p><p>If we happen to set the UBI too high, then the reduction in labor may cause the productive capacity of the economy to fall below the level of consumer spending. This would result in a period of inflation until the purchasing power of the UBI fell back down to the level necessary to incentivize people to work again. But $1,000 per month is a conservative amount that poses no danger of disrupting the labor market to such an extreme.</p><h3>Won’t landlords just raise their rents?</h3><p><strong>Yang’s Answer:</strong> No. Competition will keep prices down.</p><p><strong>The Real Answer:</strong> No. The opposite will happen. Most landlords will lower their rents. Real estate prices will decrease.</p><p>There are a few interesting effects here. The first effect is just the same as the general effect on prices that we’ll see in the economy. More people will have money to buy cheaper housing, so that makes it profitable for developers and landlords to provide cheaper housing. This is the housing that previously-homeless people will have the money to pay for. See <a href="#b7a9"><em>Won’t giving everyone money just cause inflation?</em></a></p><p>The second, arguably stronger effect is due to the fact that UBI is an income source that’s not tied to a specific location. Because money stretches further in cheaper areas, UBI increases quality of life in cheaper areas more than it increases quality of life in expensive areas. This creates an incentive for people to move away from places that have higher rents.</p><p>By giving people more places to live, UBI does the equivalent of flooding the market with more housing. People will have more choice about where to live and more of their options will be cheaper. Landlords will be forced to compete for rent and sellers will be forced to compete for buyers. This will make housing cheaper in general.</p><p>Certain specific rents might increase slightly in places that nobody wanted to live before. But this rent increase merely reflects the fact that everyone is better off.</p><p>See <a href="http://bit.ly/ubi-fixes-housing">this article</a> for a more complete explanation.</p><h3>Isn’t the Freedom Dividend just socialism?</h3><p><strong>Yang’s Answer:</strong> No. It’s capitalism that doesn’t start at zero.</p><p><strong>The Real Answer:</strong> Call it what you want. The market won’t function unless consumers have spending money. If you don’t like the idea of a UBI, how would you suggest consumers get spending money? Jobs? So you want the government to interfere with the labor market to force money to consumers?</p><p>UBI is the only way to get the free market to operate efficiently. A UBI combined with an efficient labor market means we don’t have to force people to do useless work as an excuse to pay them. $1,000 per month is probably not enough to get us all the way there, but it’s a start.</p><p>See <a href="http://www.greshm.org/blog/poverty-is-optional/">this blog post</a> for more.</p><p>Socialists will probably be offended if you call the Freedom Dividend socialism. Typically, socialism is about sharing the means of production. The Freedom Dividend is about giving people access to the means of consumption (i.e. money).</p><h3>Where is the money going to come from to pay for it?</h3><p><strong>Yang’s Answer:</strong> We pay for it using a value-added tax that takes a “slice” of every Amazon &amp; Google transaction.</p><p><strong>The Real Answer:</strong> You’re asking the wrong question. What matters isn’t where you can get the money from. What matters is whether the money has somewhere to <em>go</em>. We can hand people as much money as we want as long as they have something to spend it on. But when the economy runs out of room for the spending, we’ll see inflation.</p><p>Taking the UBI money from another part of the economy isn’t magically going to create room for additional consumer spending. Either the economy has the productive capacity to respond to the additional consumer spending or it doesn’t.</p><p>From an economic theory perspective, taxes aren’t what make UBI possible. A properly-implemented UBI has no tax associated with it.</p><p>See <a href="http://www.greshm.org/blog/theres-only-one-way-to-pay-for-a-basic-income/">this blog post</a> for more.</p><p>Andrew Yang’s VAT does help make the Freedom Dividend possible, but only in the political sense. It’s a lot easier to get revenue-neutral policies passed through the legislature. If you’re going to have a tax anyway, a VAT might be one of your least disruptive options.</p><p>Also, it’s fun to tell people a story about how you’re sticking it to the Amazons and Googles of the world.</p><h3>Won’t the VAT just be passed on to consumers?</h3><p><strong>Yang’s Answer:</strong> We will exempt certain consumer staples from the VAT.</p><p><strong>The Real Answer:</strong> No. Regardless of whether certain goods are exempted, the Fed’s job is to keep average consumer prices stable. They do this using monetary policy. Consumers will not bear any burden from the tax.</p><p>As far as the tax burden is concerned, a VAT is equivalent to a sales tax. We all know that a sales tax is regressive. VAT is regressive too. But that all goes out the window when the VAT (or sales tax) is being enforced across the entire economy. Because the effect on consumer prices is zero, the regressive effect is also zero.</p><p>Some people might talk to you about <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_incidence">tax incidence</a> and start making various price predictions based on information about targeted or regional VATs that have been implemented in other places. These people are well-intentioned but misguided. So long as monetary policy is working properly, it will cancel out the consumer burden of an economy-wide VAT.</p><p>A caveat is that the consumer price stability is not necessarily uniform. Even if average prices remain the same, some goods may become more expensive while others become cheaper. By exempting certain goods, Andrew Yang’s VAT influences <em>which</em> prices will go up and which will go down.</p><p>I have heard people argue that monetary policy might fail to respond properly to a newly-implemented VAT. The result would be a permanent increase in consumer prices. But I have yet to see any evidence suggesting that this would happen in real life.</p><p>The VAT does cause a problem though. Because an economy-wide VAT is a tax on production, it creates a disincentive to produce. This decreases the highest possible level of UBI that the economy can sustain. But it shouldn’t decrease that level to anywhere near $1,000 per month, so the Freedom Dividend should be fine.</p><p><a href="http://www.greshm.org/blog/andrew-yang-almost-not-wrong/">This blog post</a> explains the problem in more depth.</p><h3>Are we really facing a crisis of robots taking jobs?</h3><p><strong>Yang’s Answer:</strong> We are in the third inning of the greatest economic and technological transformation in the history of the country.</p><p><strong>The Real Answer:</strong> No. Not really. The politics surrounding the current wave of automation merely highlight the fact that jobs have <em>always</em> been the wrong way to get spending money to people.</p><p>An efficient labor market does not provide consumers with enough income to reap the full benefit of what the economy has to offer them. But that’s OK. The labor market is a market for getting people to do things. It’s not <em>supposed</em> to be a tool for funneling money to consumers.</p><p>Nevertheless, we use it that way. Our society has gotten really good at generating make-work. It’s baked into our culture and into our laws. To the extent that we’re creating jobs to push money to workers, we’re not creating those jobs because there’s actually work that needs doing.</p><p>We’ve been getting jobs wrong for hundreds of years. UBI gives us an opportunity to get the labor market right. A high enough UBI will allow us to live in a world where jobs only exist because there’s work that needs doing. Every task automated and every job eliminated will be cause for celebration.</p><p>Despite Yang’s political framing, UBI isn’t a response to some looming robot takeover. It’s the other way around. Providing people money independent of the labor market will finally allow us to eliminate the jobs we should have been eliminating for centuries. We won’t have to feel guilty anymore about letting robots do the work that we don’t want to do anyway.</p><p>A Freedom Dividend of only $1,000 per month won’t take us all the way there, but it’s a start.</p><h3>Is $1,000 per month enough?</h3><p><strong>Yang’s Answer:</strong> On its own, the Freedom Dividend brings everyone almost up to the poverty line.</p><p><strong>The Real Answer:</strong> It depends what you mean by “enough.” Enough for what? Is it enough to bring everyone up to the poverty line? Sure. Is it enough to replace wages from a job that paid more than $12,000 per year? Certainly not.</p><p>The question we should be asking is what’s the point of UBI? What’s the problem that UBI solves? Is the purpose of to replace income from lost jobs? Is it to lift everyone out of poverty? I don’t think either of these is the right answer.</p><p>Fundamentally, UBI solves the problem of how to get spending money into the hands of consumers. Why should the amount ever be less than what we can afford? The answer to this question is determined by the level of consumer spending can the economy handle. It’s hard to say what that level is, but a UBI of $1,000 per month is fairly conservative.</p><p>To ensure that the amount of the UBI payout is enough to maximize people’s prosperity, we would want the policy to be implemented as an <em>algorithm</em> that automatically adjusts the amount based on the economy’s sustainable productive capacity. Under such an algorithm, the amount of the payout would normally increase over time.</p><p>See <a href="http://www.greshm.org/blog/poverty-is-optional/">this blog post</a> for more of an explanation.</p><h3>Why should rich people get free money?</h3><p><strong>Yang’s Answer:</strong> If everyone gets the money, then it feels more like a right of citizenship. This eliminates any stigma associated with taking the money.</p><p><strong>The Real Answer:</strong> Everything Yang says is true. But those aren’t the most important reasons why we should give the Freedom Dividend to rich people. The problem is that if we place restrictions on who gets the money, then some people who need it will inevitably fall through the cracks.</p><p>Furthermore, the government will save money in their budget any time they fail to provide the benefit to someone who qualifies. This creates a perverse incentive for the government to <em>let</em> people fall through the cracks. The people who need the money the most are the ones who are least equipped to navigate the system.</p><p>If we really want a targeted income program, we can use taxes to achieve the exact same distributional effect. This means we give everyone the same basic income and then tax it back from the people who shouldn’t have it. Now, if the government fails to apply the rules correctly, they’ve only failed to collect a tax. Not a huge deal.</p><h3>Does It Dismantle the Safety Net?</h3><p><strong>Yang’s Answer:</strong> No. We’re <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ONLyECTdg5w">not touching any existing welfare programs</a>. But, if you opt in to the Freedom Dividend, you <em>will</em> be forgoing certain cash-like benefits.</p><p><strong>The Real Answer:</strong> Many people will choose the Freedom Dividend, thereby disqualifying themselves for SNAP, TANF, and similar programs. It’s reasonable to frame this as a partial dismantling of the safety net. But Yang’s framing is also valid. Take your pick depending on whether you want to paint the Freedom Dividend in a favorable light.</p><p>What matters isn’t the political framing. What matters is the actual effect it has on people. The net effect of the Freedom Dividend is that it only adds to what people are currently getting. It doesn’t take anything away.</p><p>People who disqualify themselves from SNAP &amp; friends will receive less of a boost from the Freedom Dividend. This is <em>indeed</em> a flaw in the plan. But the Freedom Dividend is still far more universal than Social Security. And most people would insist that <em>having</em> Social Security is better than <em>not having</em> Social Security. I think we’ll end up feeling the same way about the Freedom Dividend.</p><p>And yes, the Freedom Dividend <em>does</em> stack with Social Security.</p><h4>Acknowlegements</h4><p>Shout outs to Bethany Burum, Zack Sargent, Tommy AKA TsBandit, and the Massachusetts Yang Gang for feedback on this article.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e06276f43dc3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/human-capitalism/the-unofficial-freedom-dividend-faq-e06276f43dc3">The Unofficial Freedom Dividend FAQ</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/human-capitalism">Human Capitalism</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>