<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Alex Ricard on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Alex Ricard on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@alexjricard?source=rss-93dc22ad3304------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 12:46:27 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@alexjricard/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Up the Long Ladder]]></title>
            <link>https://alexjricard.medium.com/up-the-long-ladder-82b26fc4d330?source=rss-93dc22ad3304------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/82b26fc4d330</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[metal-gear-solid]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[election-2020]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Ricard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Nov 2020 17:10:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-03T17:10:52.267Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*MRZrzsDt6EqHDGMN.jpg" /><figcaption>I’m still in a dream, Snake Eater.</figcaption></figure><p>It’s not hard to walk around in 2020 with the feeling that all the metaphors have become literal. Donald Trump brings his supporters to a rally and then leaves them out in the cold. Joe Biden’s campaign rides a bright, well-branded cheery bus; Trump’s drives a hearse. But perhaps the most apt is his constant misuse of Oscar Brown’s civil rights song “The Snake” as a fixture of his rallies, meant to demonize immigrants and refugees when the analogy to his own presidency couldn’t be clearer. He quietly dropped it from his rotation earlier this year, but in these last forty-eight hours of his re-election campaign, it’s come roaring back once again.</p><p>The story is simple: a tender woman takes in a snake from the freezing cold, nursing it back to health. Trump doesn’t just recite it, he <em>performs</em> it. He gesticulates, makes faces, puts on dramatic voices. The snake hisses and schemes, Trump raises his voice and tempo, and finally, in the climax, gives the woman a vicious bite.</p><p>Trump loves this part the most; the cruelty was always the point for him, and revels in the stark brutality of the sudden attack. The crowd does not gasp in fear, but instead rises in a cheer; they know what’s coming, but they are perfectly willing to sacrifice this woman to prove their point. The woman cries. The bite is fatal, and with her heartbroken sobs she asks why the snake would do that to her, after she helped him so much.</p><p>“Oh, shut up, you silly woman,” Trump glowers, his jowls twisted in a grin, “you knew damn well I was a snake before you took me in.”</p><p>The best part of living in the Stupid Ages is that now that history is fully and finally over, the events of distant pasts repeat themselves in increasingly farcical ways, over and over again, until finally they have boiled away all nuance entirely, leaving only the raw, gelatinous mold of truth left to be shaped. Not truth in the sense of clarity and righteousness that cleanly cuts through falsehood, but truth in the way that truth is flexible, manipulable; subject to the same forces of raw sewage that everything else is.</p><p>This is to say that late capitalism has overridden the very last of what were once cultural norms and replaced them with brute force. What once were national scandals have become minor annoyances to be avoided. Cold War paranoia has morphed into reflexively vague conflations of Putin’s fascist plutocracy and China’s market socialism under the common banner of foreign enemy superpowers meddling in our elections. Sex scandals, once the silver bullets that could take down anyone or anything, have become as ineffective as online petitions. In the midst of the largest agitation for racial justice in a generation, police officers applaud murderers, take cheerful selfies with self-avowed violent hate gangs, and pepper-sprayed people in line to vote.</p><p>The golden thread undergirding all this, as well as the breakdowns of all institutions everywhere, is brute force. They don’t care if the public or the media puts pressure on them because they don’t <em>have</em> to care, because they can just call it fake news or the deep state or the establishment or whatever, and then they can barely eke out a win and point to it as the eternal mandate for them to seize power forever, and fuck you if you try to stop them. We are already living in the repetition: a full three of George Bush’s legal team who worked on the 2000 election lawsuit are now confirmed members of the Supreme Court, each being openly courted to rule that Trump should maintain the presidency whether or not he actually wins a majority of votes.</p><p>This phenomenon is not unique to Republicans, but you’re fooling yourself if you think Democrats are even half as capable of such boldness. The parties have finally emulsified down to their final stages: Republicans believing in nothing more than the craven pursuit of power at all costs, and Democrats believing that power is a complex series of levers and pulleys and sprockets and screws to be delicately handled, lest they ever actually be <em>used.</em></p><p>They play a constant game of snakes and ladders. A little progress forward, a lot of sliding back, progress only defined by the arbitrary rules of the game board, and now the Republicans have gleefully thrown it away and set the house on fire, and Democrats are frantically searching not for an extinguisher but for the rule book.</p><p>Again, this metaphor is literal in the figure of Trump himself. The theory of Trump has always been in polar opposites: he is a devoted, ideological racist, but he has no ideology but his own shambling wet id. He says and does whatever he knows will benefit him most, but he also vaguely parrots the last thing someone said to him. He manipulates media attention and scandal with surgical precision, yet he rage-tweets blindly at wee hours because of what he saw on TV. He brags about how elite and superior his wealth and status is while demonizing any and all opponents as “the elite”.</p><p>This even extends out to all other aspects of him: his base is valorized as the forgotten working class, yet his <em>actual</em> base are the petit-bourgeois car dealership millionaires. He’s a deep vector of spite weaponized against the “losers” and “suckers” and also the pitiable put-upon victim, constantly reminding anyone who will listen about petty decades-old grievances. He’s deeply, personally miserable, his health is failing, he never wanted to be president; yet his ego is only possibly sated by the crowds of adoring fans and the unlimited power he wields. He’s genuinely having the time of his life.</p><p>Even his policies are like this. He’s running as both the “criminal justice reform” candidate and the “law and order” candidate. He paints his opponent as both a sleepy incompetent fool and as a radical leftist who will burn down the suburbs. He goes out of his way to antagonize Black communities while claiming he’s the best president for them since Lincoln. He is a uniquely monstrous and terrible tyrant in American history, and yet he merely carries out mainstream Republican policies with just a slightly ruder veneer than they’d like.</p><p>It feels like an eternity ago to remember the canard being thrown around during the 2016 cycle of whether to take Trump seriously but not literally, or literally but not seriously. The answer was both. One way of reading this disparity would be that he says what he thinks will play well for the polls and the media, while his true beliefs are murkier. This wouldn’t be inaccurate, but it’s a calculus that could apply to any politician. This isn’t base hypocrisy either, it’s fundamental to who he is as a person. Trump is both a pathological liar and a pathological truth-teller; the challenge comes in finding the appropriate synthesis to these two opposite truths. Many of his shocking and horrific polices shouldn’t necessarily come as a surprise: often they are things he <em>said</em> he would do in the first place. We knew damn well he was a snake, and we’ve known this whole time.</p><p>He gets away with it through brute force. It doesn’t matter how many norms he blows past or how many laws he blithely breaks. In doing so he has not really broken them at all but revealed them for the flimsy paper and string they always were. The rules binding society together only ever worked if people collectively agreed to play by them. But he doesn’t want to, so he doesn’t, and there’s seemingly nothing anyone can do to stop him.</p><p>Except vote, of course. But as we see even before our eyes, what can that do? Voter suppression is rampant and targeted against Black and Latinx communities, the Supreme Court is already lost, and even in the worst economic downturn in a century, a pandemic killing hundreds of thousands, a historically unpopular incumbent, and Biden’s consistent lead of 8 to 10 percentage points, the question on everyone’s minds isn’t whether Biden will win the vote, it’s whether Trump will be able to get away with the cheating we have already predicted he’ll try. We already know he’s a snake.</p><p>If Trump loses this election, he will sulk and whine and immediately cry foul and claim voter fraud, whether he loses by ten votes or ten million votes. The plan is right there in plain sight. He’ll act like he won, petition the Supreme Court, and expect his handpicked trio of justices to deliver his result, and fuck you if you try to stop him. First as tragedy, then as farce, then as farce again and again and again.</p><p>Hideo Kojima’s seminal Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater (2005), for the Playstation 2, primarily explores the theme of “scene”: the various climates in which events occur and the impacts of these climates on people, institutions, and nations. This is explored in personal stakes all the way up to geopolitical stakes. Legendary soldier The Boss, who from her very childhood was forced into the world of secret societies and international espionage, is placed at odds with her country, her family, and even her own body, due to the shifting climates imposed upon her by larger institutions far beyond her control. The Fury, an astronaut driven mad by visions of the Earth on fire, was driven to delusions from the scene he witnessed upon re-entry to Earth from outer space. Two soldiers from two warring states are only directly enemies due to the scene they are both placed in; in the future they may be allies or completely ambivalent.</p><p>This concept of “scene” is even embedded into Snake Eater’s gameplay itself, in that for the first time in the series the player must forage food to survive (yes, eating snakes) and wear camouflage to blend in with the “scene”, thus interacting with and manipulating the environment to achieve certain objectives. MGS 1 and 2 both take place in very-near-future American military installations with advanced tech, MGS 3 is a new scene, a prequel taking place in the Soviet jungle during the height of the Vietnam war.</p><p>The protagonist of the game is known by the codename “Naked Snake”, or just “Snake” for short; he is functionally identical to Solid Snake, the protagonist of the first two games, given that in the canon Solid was a clone of Naked decades later. His mission is to find and assassinate his former mentor, who had gone rogue and teamed with a Soviet GRU colonel to frame America for a nuclear bombing and incite World War III, so that America could clear its name and prevent nuclear escalation.</p><p>Many twists and turns follow from this basic premise, but the “scene” is set clearly from the beginning: large-scale geopolitical institutions such as governments and The Philosophers, a secret society controlling the world, using soldiers and medics and inventors and civilians as pawns, obscuring things so much that the strings become invisible and they begin to act according to set paths, completely ignorant of the broader picture.</p><p>These scenes created by these powerful actors additionally reshape society itself, essentially subverting classical Marxism’s base-superstructure model by retaining strict control over both base and superstructure as to further entrench their sociopolitical hegemony; due to the deft layers of these scenes, individual actors cannot break from the cycle because these institutions can easily reframe the scene at will, including to the point of rewriting history to suit their own narratives.</p><p>The Metal Gear Solid series is known for being simultaneously deeply self-serious and deeply, stupidly silly. The dialogue is by turns melodramatic and hackish, whole sections are set aside for convoluted pop culture references and fourth-wall breaks, and the characters are all incredibly goofy and strange, occasionally with an awkwardly-translated pathos to them that can either cut deep into your soul or miss the mark entirely. The tonal shifts can be incredibly jarring, but they work because they elevate the series from your average Tom Clancy-esque thriller into the kind of profound political questions the genre typically eschews.</p><p>One of the most iconic scenes in Snake Eater is when, after defeating sniper The End in a harrowing boss fight, Snake must climb an incredibly long ladder. It doesn’t sound like much, but the entire thing takes over three minutes in real time. At first he climbs in silence. Then, slowly, the vocal track of the game’s James Bond-esque theme song starts to play in a gradual crescendo, while all you are controlling as the player is that Snake is still dutifully climbing the ladder. It’s a completely unexpected, bizarre moment, but it breaks through absurdity to become genuine.</p><p>The climb itself becomes a test of determination despite being a very easy task; the player is never given any indication of their progress and so must keep climbing as the perspective lengthens to comical exaggerations. The floor fades away in the distance, and no matter what, no matter how long it seems, you must keep climbing; and then in a sudden, rapid shift of perspective it’s over, and Snake climbs out to the ceiling, and that’s that and it’s time to move on.</p><p>Just like that, the scene is changed, and you are forced to reorient and continue. The ladder is never brought up again.</p><p>Here’s the other thing about snakes: they shed their skin.</p><p>Trump’s ability to morph and camouflage himself and play bully and victim at the same time is just the same. He sheds the skin of his elite upbringing and slums it with the Midwesterners he openly hates, then he sheds that skin to go gladhand with some Evangelicals and hold a Bible upside down, he briefly sheds this skin long enough to mock them behind their backs, then wriggles back into his gold-lined skin to greet his guests at Mar-a-Lago, then, finally, removes the last of it to angrily tweet from the toilet about how unfair his ratings on Fox News are.</p><p>Which one of these is his true skin is perhaps missing the point; they all are, and they each function as his attempt to manipulate the scene of American discourse. In that he has possibly been the most successful force in history: no president or even individual person, loved or hated, could probably ever claim to be so central to the front of mind of every American for this long. Those who love him, even if their numbers are dwindling, do so with stars in their eyes; those who hate him wish fervently that he shits himself on live television and dies shortly thereafter. There are those who strongly dislike him but cannot bring themselves to use the word “hate”, and might genuinely be praying or wishing for him to become a better person; I am not in that group and I won’t be shamed for it.</p><p>Unlike the Philosophers from Metal Gear Solid, though, Trump is not successful at completely subverting the culture because he is a creature of it. He is too lazy to mount a full-scale propaganda campaign, yet he is tireless and fruitful in his laziness; another contradiction. He is only able to work this manipulation on a small segment of the population. Not once, even for the calls of a “presidential pivot”, has he deigned to broaden his message to any but those who accepted him from the beginning.</p><p>From this scene, it seems that he’s almost trying to lose. Doubling down on esoteric Hunter Biden emails that got him impeached already. Blatantly refusing to engage with the Covid crisis despite literally catching the disease himself. His poll numbers have spiraled for months because he seems physically incapable of actually mounting meaningful leadership. Had he risen to the occasion and actually handled the crisis with a bare minimum of competency, he’d sail to re-election in a wave not seen since Bush ’04. At least that time history would repeat as tragedy.</p><p>He has surrounded himself, like the mobsters he always idolized, with a parade of yes-men too craven to ever deny him anything; he has himself become warped by the scene he created. There is an argument to be made that this is not because of his own self-aggrandizing idolatry, but because he is very stupid. Once again, both these contradictions are true.</p><p>His base, even dwindling, still comprises of at least 4 in 10 Americans. Forty percent of people seeing the wanton destruction this man has caused, and they still sidle up to him, and even though he will bite them, they don’t care; because for a moment before the poison set in they got to believe they were the snakes, too. They will follow him up the long ladder and down the short rope, laughing all the way.</p><p>So the final tool he has left is brute force. To simply break everything he can in one last attempt to intimidate the American people into meekly accepting him without a fight. He won’t care how bad it is for optics or legality; all those are just fictions designed to make excuses for those in power. The scene must be changed, the circumstances of our political moment must be radically altered for any meaningful defeat of Trump to truly take hold. If the Democrats are caught tinkering with their levers and knobs and pulleys again while he’s bursting down doors and declaring himself winner for life, maybe they deserve to lose after all.</p><p>This is the part of the essay where I’m supposed to imbue you with some hope, some final inspirational sendoff. Go vote and save our democracy. Go vote and kick the dang freakin’ Cheeto out of the White House. I think he will lose, and spectacularly so, and that we might even avoid mass civil unrest by his base lashing out in their final moments before the venom takes hold. But if you’ve gotten this far in this essay on Election Day, I know you aren’t exactly feeling a hundred percent optimistic right now.</p><p>Here is the final thing to remember about snakes: they come in broods. Even if Trump loses, he has already given birth to a swarming, writhing mass of little imitators, each of them ready to rare their heads on us in 2024 and beyond. He himself won’t go away: these rallies and Fox News appearances will become a constant new normal. We can’t ignore them or pacify them. We can’t lay traps to get them because they are too smart for that, they will turn the traps back on us and reset the scene before we blink.</p><p>These snakes will come in different forms: some will be outright QAnon agitators or white supremacists. Some will be sudden austerity hawks the moment a Democrat takes power. And some will be, as in the case of the Lincoln Project, a group of self-avowed “moderates” coming up with puppy eyes that the monster they created has escaped their control. The moment we turn our back, they will strike, too. We should have known they were snakes when we took them in.</p><p>There will be a time, somewhere in the vague future, for reconciliation and healing and moving forward together as a nation. But if Biden — like Obama before him — allows the architects of cruelty to escape unharmed and unaccountable for their actions, if Trump and his cronies throughout the entire Republican party are allowed to simply give an aw-shucks grin and continue on unabated, we will deserve their venom.</p><p>We must climb the long ladder of progress, even if it seems infinite, and eat the snake. This is not something we can simply trust will happen by the infinite forward march of time or the moral arc of history, but because of our own direct actions. It will be thankless and exhausting work, and it won’t even feel worth it. But it’s the only way through. Only then can we change the scene and move on.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=82b26fc4d330" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Back to Normal]]></title>
            <link>https://alexjricard.medium.com/back-to-normal-f0194f08ab5d?source=rss-93dc22ad3304------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f0194f08ab5d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[joe-biden]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bernie-sanders]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Ricard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 18 Mar 2020 21:23:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-18T21:23:01.917Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>My first salient memory of the news or current events is the impeachment of Bill Clinton. I was too young to understand specifics but I could already pick up that it was just a lazy, cynical exercise. All the eye-rolling and bloviating and posturing, carried out by senators and pundits who obviously didn’t believe in any of the words coming out of their mouths, and also constantly twisting themselves in knots to keep polite language standards on television. I couldn’t tell what it all actually meant, but I could definitely tell that I was being condescended to.</p><p>Around this time was the bombing of Kosovo in 1999. I remember seeing the footage of schools and homes completely destroyed. I remember wondering why we were doing that: we were the good guys, right? Were they bad? Were we at war? Of course, the answer was no. They weren’t “evil” or whatever. We just wanted to control what they would do. And the bombing of other countries was our way of doing that. It’s just a thing that was done.</p><p>Just like with the impeachment, it all felt artificial. Wasn’t this important and major? Something pressingly urgent like our country carrying out attack operations against another country felt like that’s what war was going to be like. I had heard about war. But my head was patted and I was assured that I had nothing to worry about.</p><p>Next was Columbine. It seems almost minor now compared to how the next twenty years would shake out. Always lurking in the back of the mind. Shortly after that was the 2000 election. My first time encountering the actual structure of American government, but what I remember more than anything is the recount. All the disagreement about what or who to count. More artifice: if we were a democracy, why did we need to count and recount and recount? Why did deals need to be made and judges consulted? Just count the votes.</p><p>So by the time I turned eleven years old, nearly a full third of my young life had been swirling in these kinds of questions. Is it any wonder that in the aftermath of 9/11 — and all the rampant xenophobic propaganda that justified two wars that are still going on — that I was skeptical? Now I knew what war was. But Afghanistan didn’t honestly feel any different from Kosovo just three years earlier. Iraq did, but even at the time the artifice was slipping. WMDs? There was the Patriot Act and freedom fries and “God Bless the USA” and a military-funded propaganda channel funneled into our schools and a Mission Accomplished banner and Katrina and Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo and CIA torture and a massive, nebulous “War on Terror”, and if you even hinted at dissent you were a dirty traitor helping the terrorists win because they hate our freedoms, so that’s why it was important for us to give up our freedoms and shut up and be silent.</p><p>Anyway, then the market crashed. I was barely figuring out a way in the world. I vaguely supported Ron Paul for about two months in the summer of 2008, mostly because of what we’d now call “memes” but also because of his opposition to the war. But I got suckered into the hope Obama wrought. I’m still glad to have voted for him twice, but even then I couldn’t afford to look away as he ramped up drone warfare and deportations in an effort to reach an olive branch to conservatives. They rewarded him with the Tea Party and a quest that continues to this day to destroy the ACA. People went homeless. Worked three or four jobs just to survive. And even in “recovery” it was always still shaky.</p><p>2016, you know the rest.</p><p>I find lifestyle consumption politics increasingly irritating. Epic SNL skits and big clapbacks to the president. Ha haha covfefe ha ha president cheeto. Doing a dab on TV or dancing on TikTok. Nudge nudge wink wink jokes about Putin or whatever. None of that shit matters. People are rationing insulin. Nazis are marching the streets. A whole lot of people are about to die not from the symptoms of the current pandemic illness but from the specific inadequacy of our healthcare system to actually help people. Children are in cages. A new mass shooting every week. The clock is ticking on climate change and there are still people fretting about marginal tax rates for multi millionaires. The market plunging yet again despite the Fed injecting trillions.</p><p>We come to the present moment with unmatched urgency. There is quick, progressive, decisive action to be taken, and every moment wasted by our leaders is another moment in despair. This is not to say that joy and levity aren’t welcome; they are necessary to any movement. But sitting around chortling while wealthy actors make elementary-school-grade insults on Twitter solves nothing.</p><p>There’s an election going on, too. The Democratic frontrunner, just weeks away from clinching the nomination, has promised to make sure things go “back to normal” once he’s elected. What’s that supposed to mean exactly? Back to ramping up forever wars and deportations and mass incarceration? Back to more recessions? Back to doing nothing about climate change?</p><p>For an entire generation, this is our “normal”. We don’t have the luxury of positive fuzzy memories of some America that we thought existed and want to return to. We don’t have some imagined era in which America was great or normal, and we don’t want to go backwards.</p><p>Even the structure of it is all blown apart these days: from the chaos of the Iowa caucus to the 5-hour-plus lines in multiple states to the closure of hundreds of polling sites to malfunctioning machines to concerns about the spread of the virus to a completely unresponsive and irresponsible party apparatus that is chronically two steps behind what they should be doing.</p><p>But this is not really a post about the election. It’s about how we rise to the urgency of crises, and right now there are dozens of crises at once. I’ll vote for Joe Biden this fall, if only out of obligation so that I cannot be personally blamed when he loses. And if he somehow pulls out a win, I’ll be glad a fascist is out of office but it doesn’t suddenly mean we should just think “back to normal” and continue our daily lives as if the last five years didn’t happen.</p><p>I’ve been thinking a lot lately about the ways society adapts to subversion. How whole generations grow up with wildly different perspectives on what is considered “normal” in society. A subversion of expectations, in a joke or a moral of a story or even in a philosophical worldview can only make any sense of it has an expectation of “normal” to subvert. Can subversion mean anything anymore to generations so thoroughly raised on it?</p><p>Let’s start at the beginning: in the ideal American story, the President is an upstanding man who loves and cherishes his nation. Yet my very first political memory is the very litigation of whether that image was real. Millions of children now are going through the same. So that story is turned on its head. And years or decades from now, that image will be impossible to recover. The genie cannot be put back into the bottle.</p><p>It’s also no coincidence that young generations have flocked nearly entirely away from organized religion. What was to previous generations a bastion of stability and comfort, has become to us a institution of greed, intolerance, and abuse. The expectations are subverted. That image is never coming back.</p><p>It repeats in smaller ways too: punk music was once the excitable rebellious and dangerous art form of a new generation, but now society has adapted it. It’s practically high society music now, and people pretend like loud aggressive music is subversion of cultural norms. (it’s not, kids these days listen to chopped and screwed easy-listening elevator music. Talk about subversion!)</p><p>The rebellion has come and gone, we are all affected by it, but it no longer is able to subvert any societal expectations. We carry on, fundamentally changed, and any attempt to return society “back to normal” is impossible because society has adapted to this subversion. And we subvert the subversion on and on and on until nothing means anything, spiraling out into growth and decay.</p><p>And now that the subversion is complete we can look back at things with a clearer eye. We can see the patterns in the past. Those institutions and expectations deserved to be subverted because they were all cruel and fake and horrible, and we cannot willfully put our heads in the sand and pretend like they weren’t. The old rules that governed society were completely broken and cruel, and they led to the moment we’re in now. And even then, they were a lie from the beginning! Those rules never governed society in the first place, they were always convenient fictions out in place by the powerful to ensure their continued success.</p><p>We cannot go back to normal. There never was such a thing as normal, and even the temporary stability fondly remembered by people old enough to know better was always just as harmful as now. The “normal” way led us directly here. The problems are deeper and older than Trump; simply removing him would do nothing to solve them. And when Trump leaves office: now, or in five years, or after a third term, or if his nakedly racist, fascist spirit carries on in the future presidential runs of Tom Cotton, we will have to fight and keep fighting for people to be able to live. Our work will never be done. And until that is taken seriously, and not just dismissed as the apocalyptic panic of young people, it will never get better.</p><p>Exit poll after exit poll in this Democratic primary has shown the biggest dividing line in the Democratic party is by age. Millennials and Zoomers support the democratic socialism of Bernie Sanders, expanding healthcare benefits the older generations enjoy to all. Older generations overwhelmingly back Joe Biden, not necessarily out of any fealty to his policy positions or his grand vision, but because they are convinced he has the best ability to beat Trump, policy or ideology be damned. Even if he cuts Social Security and Medicare, even if he sits around doing nothing but coasting on vague Obama-era goodwill.</p><p>Imagine how things could have gone. The explosive passion of young people could have been harnessed, worked with, and made for a future generation of progressive leadership. But from AOC all the way down to your average Zoomer at the polls, young people have been mocked, derided, and actively worked against by the party that was supposed to have us in their interests.</p><p>Yes, young people don’t turn out much to vote. Shouldn’t we be working on solving that, instead of smugly jeering about it? Shouldn’t we make it easier for college students to register to vote, or for the young people working unpredictable retail and foodservice jobs to get time off they need to go vote? Shouldn’t we embrace policies that will actually entice them? Shouldn’t we work on reversing the decimation of polling places that has led to lines as long as 6 to 7 hours on college campuses? Far easier to mock and deride them, instead. We are foolish, capricious children obsessed with avocados and lattes; not in our 30s, some with children of our own, trying to rebuild a society that was broken.</p><p>But isn’t that a microcosm of American society? Young people are passionate advocates for policies that disproportionately benefit the elderly. And for themselves, all they ask for is the security that the older generations enjoyed. All they ask for is a basic standard of decency. Meanwhile, millions of Boomers, secure and satisfied that they got theirs, laugh us off, say they have “no empathy” for us, and then wonder why we don’t buy into the system? Why we don’t just accept it all as good and normal?</p><p>A generation so poised to take it all in stride, wistfully remembering the tiny brief period when they thought things were “normal”, is woefully unprepared for the depths to which this society will fall. Because just like before: the genie cannot go back into the bottle. The next time society falls apart, it will be worse. Don’t try to say we didn’t warn you.</p><p>Or maybe the impossible will happen. President Joe Biden could command a sweeping grassroots movement of the youth to ride into office with a mandate. He could rise to the moment, convince Republicans to work with him, and pass sweeping major legislation including Medicare for All and the Green New Deal, healing the soul of the nation and steering us on the right path to face the challenges of the twenty-first century with grace and decorum. He could be a truly transformational administration in ways even Obama was unable to be, and his stirring rhetoric and inspiring speeches will give the nation a much-needed reassurance and comfort in the darkest of times, and the artifice of the American Dream will be revived but made real, and those old rules will actually work out this time around and make a better world for everyone.</p><p>Yeah, I’m not holding my breath either.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f0194f08ab5d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Past and Future of Heavy Metal]]></title>
            <link>https://alexjricard.medium.com/the-past-and-future-of-heavy-metal-91860c5214ec?source=rss-93dc22ad3304------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/91860c5214ec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[counterculture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Ricard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 08 Feb 2020 18:56:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-08T18:56:41.419Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>When the entire landscape of music changes, even this must too.</h4><p>I don’t really listen to metal anymore.</p><p>Sure, I’ll put on some Blind Guardian, or Cynic, or Fen, or Incantation, or Devin Townsend Project once in a while. I’ll occasionally lose myself in Candlemass’s <em>King of the Grey Islands</em> or check out whatever mind-bending mysteries Toby Driver is up to these days. I’ll put on some vintage Agalloch every fall, and still find myself humming the iconic vocal theme to Lost Horizon’s “Highlander (The One)” like, twice a week. I’ll relive some memories with Maiden or Dio or Fates Warning, but really, for the most part, I listen to other stuff these days.</p><p>Was it really just a phase, then? Maybe. I don’t know.</p><p>But metal was always more than just the music, right? We all know that. When I started listening to metal, I got obsessed with the history and culture of metal. It was never just music, it was a lifestyle, a culture, an institution almost like religion, with its own rituals and factions and symbols and philosophies.</p><p>I haven’t listened to Metallica or Megadeth on purpose in over a decade, but that doesn’t mean I haven’t memorized the way Dave Mustaine’s sneer defined defiance for millions, that doesn’t mean I haven’t memorized every single riff on <em>Kill ’Em All</em>, that doesn’t mean there isn’t still some part of me that remembers the ancestral legacy of metal’s fight against the PMRC.</p><p>Remember that? It was before my time, and yet, when I took it upon myself to subsume the entire history of metal and learn everything, I took up the mantle of this fight as if it were my own. Us against the forces of censorship and corruption, who would have been much happier if we stopped listening to that dang loud, angry music and instead listened to some good-old Christian hymns.</p><p>It was never just about the music.</p><p>The most peculiar thing about metal — what drew me to it, anyway, and I’m sure I’m not alone in this — is that it is both a spark of rage and rebellion for justice against a cruel, evil society and also a self-styled embrace of darkness and evil against the “good” of society. It’s a contradiction. There is seething anger, both in a personal sense and in the sense of the looming injustice of the universe against us.</p><p>There was a level of camaraderie, of brotherhood. No matter where you came from, when you went to a show, you could share in this unspoken revelry of togetherness. Other metalheads knew more obscure bands than you, or they could introduce you to the vast variety of subgenres, and they could pass down the myths of these larger-than-life figures who were so much more than people playing guitars and singing on stage. They were cultural forces, heroes and villains and myths and legends, made into something even bigger and bolder and more immortal than any “rock star” could ever be.</p><p>I used to sit in my room as a teenager and listen to Iron Maiden’s “Blood Brothers” on repeat, over and over. “We’re blood brothers, we’re blood brothers,” went the chorus, swelling proudly in a hopeful and resonant melody. In the way of many grandiose teenagers, I took that to heart. We as metal fans were blood brothers. And I was so grateful and glad to be part of the metal community.</p><p>It was a mantra, a mission statement, a higher purpose. As metalheads, we were true. We didn’t care about superficial bullshit. We didn’t buy into society’s nonsense. We forged our own path of resistance, and we didn’t judge or exclude anyone. It didn’t matter what you looked like or how you dressed or where you came from, but together we forged a shared community of acceptance and love. We were good dressed up as evil, united in our common front against the forces of evil dressed up as good.</p><p>That’s what I believed, anyway. But we all know that’s bullshit.</p><p>Of course metal has always been rife with toxic masculinity, with racism, with homophobia and misogyny and all sorts of troubling associations with white supremacy. Before I check out any new black metal band, I always have to spend a few hours doing research to make sure they’re not Nazis. It would almost be silly if it weren’t also deadly serious.</p><p>Because these things are serious. And maybe it just makes me a snowflake, but there is so much excellent, groundbreaking new music out there, metal and otherwise, that it’s not worth my time to even consider listening to a band who follows so proudly in Varg Vikernes’ footsteps.</p><p>And even in less serious matters. It didn’t matter how you presented yourself, or how you dressed, because unlike the judgmental mass hordes metalheads would never turn you away for not fitting in. Except, of course, if you didn’t wear all black at all times, or angrily perform scowls, you were just “fake metal”. So even in escaping mainstream society’s expectations, you had to conform to metal’s expectations, too.</p><p>So what does that mean for rebellion? For the present and future of metal? For standing up against the smarmy moralism of mainstream society? Because we’re not in the ’80s anymore. The battle lines have changed drastically.</p><p>It’s tempting — and easy — to want to rail in anger and rage against “SJWs” or “snowflakes”, or whatever. Other countercultural communities like “geek culture” or “gamers” or “comic fandoms”, all communities that not coincidentally have significant overlap with metal, are rumbling to do the same.</p><p>The line of thinking goes that, now that women, people of color, and LGBTQ+ people are finally being afforded a basic measure of decency by mainstream society, that in acts of “rebellion” we must oppose this for… reasons. This is where the self-styled “evil” comes in, but modern expressions of that evil seem feebler than ever, as they try to grasp back to the exact kind of regressive morality metal was supposed to rail against in the first place.</p><p>Metal has never really been as inclusive and open as it always aspired to be. Who can forget the endless wars of the ’00s that all the female-fronted bands of that era weren’t “real metal”? Or the massive blowup about how Babymetal was “ruining metal”? Or even still, that a band as incredible and revolutionary as Zeal &amp; Ardor is controversial at all, because instead of white Englishmen appropriating blues to metal, a black person is doing it?</p><p>Remember the controversy about Sacred Son’s album cover when it debuted in 2017? How fucking weird was that? A community that proudly surrounds itself with grotesque, gory, blasphemous imagery in a deliberate attempt to provoke suddenly getting its panties in a twist about a picture of a guy in sunglasses smiling?</p><p>It’s the same thing that happened to Deafheaven’s Sunbather — the mere presence of the color pink on the album cover led to whole legions of people angrily huffing and puffing about how effeminate hipsters were ruining everything. Never mind that it was one of the best of the last decade. But no, even just a certain shade is a threat.</p><p>Who would have thought a genre so obsessed with overwrought fantasy stories and complete absurd over-the-top performative exercises of machismo and toughness would crumble so easily? The music itself has always been deliberately ridiculous; it does not have to jettison this absurdity to be taken seriously as an art form.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*FNG3bogCu0p5pf-8" /><figcaption>Sacred Son’s 2017 debut</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Vv-8KX_sdVnIHz6q.jpg" /><figcaption>Deafheaven’s Sunbather (2013)</figcaption></figure><p>The weird thing is, as a far-reaching international community, metal is poised more uniquely than practically any other cultural force to break down those barriers. The aesthetic of metal itself makes it completely resistant to mainstream appropriation. It has a thriving, passionate subculture large enough to where it can continue to exist despite universal blackout from media.</p><p>Unlike other cultural products, metal music doesn’t rely on corporate products to develop a community. It thrives not in the mainstream, but in a thousand tiny scenes, each of them full of young people making the music and forming connections with each other. And because it is loud, and transgressive, and different, and celebrates its differences (and, ideally, celebrates the people who are different), it can never be made palatable for mass consumption.</p><p>Metal will never be truly popular or trendy, and the versions of it that become trendy are watered down fictions, mere pastiches of the real music being made by real people. And yet, in every corner of the globe, metal music is finding its way into the ears and hearts of millions of young people every day. It’s a beautiful and brilliant international community with the power to bring people from all walks of life together, shared in ritual and symbol like a new kind of religion.</p><p>For all its bluster about refusing conformity, this has always been the defining contradiction of metal culture. You must conform in your rebellion to rebel against conformity. Metal has a history, a series of traditions and expectations, and is something of an institution in itself. And like all institutions, even metal is not immune to the staunch traditionalists who insist that things must be done their way or not at all, that it must be stopped and preserved and protected from the heresies of “false metal”.</p><p>And even metal cannot continue to exist so beholden to its past and present.</p><p>Is there a future for metal? It’s hard to say. Some of the old, long-held bugbears of the metal traditionalists are going to have to change. Kids just aren’t picking up instruments as much anymore — and the ones who do are more likely to be young girls. Genres are blurring, too — the strict categorization and debate of what specifically marks the difference between blackened death metal and war metal and deathgrind isn’t going to matter as much, because these genres will become unrecognizable to what they are today.</p><p>Yes, there will be hip-hop or pop music influence in future metal bands. Yes, there will be young up-and-coming musicians who have never heard of Chuck Schuldiner. Yes, there will be pop singers and celebrities who mention how much they loved metal as kids. And that means that it may not be the same rebellious form it used to be.</p><p>And yes, metal’s popularity will wane, but it will grow again, as these cycles go, and there will still be new bands doing new things and taking the ethos of metal to incredible new heights.</p><p>And yes, some of you reading this right now will stop listening to it as much. And that’s okay. You’ll remember it fondly, not just as a “phase” but as a formative experience, as a community you were part of, as something that shaped your outlook on society and culture.</p><p>But what do I know? I don’t really listen to metal anymore.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=91860c5214ec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Against Fandom]]></title>
            <link>https://alexjricard.medium.com/against-fandom-bade3d33d723?source=rss-93dc22ad3304------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bade3d33d723</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stan-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disney]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fandom]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Ricard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 18 Jun 2019 15:05:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-18T15:10:22.758Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Toxic fandom, as encouraged by corporations, is destroying art. What to do about it?</h4><p>Lots of things are coming to an end these days. The Avengers films. Game of Thrones. The world. As can be predicted, nobody’s taking it particularly well.</p><p>Certain sectors of the Internet have predictably melted down about the dumbest, silliest shit imaginable, reminding us once again that the greatest currency is not money or clicks or uniqueness, but rage. Your takes must be hot: designed to rile up your audience. The madder you make them, the more they respond. It’s a cycle. Every Youtuber knows it. It could be trying to <a href="https://gizmodo.com/game-of-thrones-petition-to-remake-season-8-reaches-a-m-1834875436">remake a season of TV</a> or<a href="https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/michaelblackmon/sonic-hedgegog-movie-release-delayed-redesign"> redesign a movie character</a> or<a href="https://www.pride.com/geek/2019/5/16/fanboys-edited-avengers-endgame-remove-brie-larson-gay-shit"> remove a female character from your franchise</a> (because of course). The content matters so much less than the ability to tap into a viewer’s seething, impotent rage.</p><p>Fandom has a lot of problems, especially now that the Internet has granted a trigger-finger microphone to the kind of people who used to have to self-address and stamp their death threats to creators directly.</p><p>Is this something to do with fandom most generally, as we have constructed it to exist in 2019? The endless conventions, trending hashtags, wikias, franchise tie-ins, attempted multi-level merchandising strategies, after-show shows, calculated social media campaigns. Everything is a half-hearted attempt at launching cinematic universes. TV shows get canceled and immediately lurch into pre-baked #SaveOurShowByGoingOnAnotherNetwork campaigns. It’s almost calculated to draw out maximum interest and outrage.</p><p>These things have always existed, but these days, it’s easier than ever to see the strings. Even with the massive success of the movies, the comic book industry (particularly Marvel) has heavily suffered sales losses because they try to harness this kind of rage to diminishing returns. When they do things like killing off Peter Parker by body-swapping him with Doctor Octopus, or revealing that Captain America is a Hydra agent — regardless of the quality or novelty of those stories — the marketing strategy they decided upon was to insist that a) this is how things were going to be from now on, forever, and b) this was always the plan. Marvel editor Stephen Wacker even <a href="https://www.cbr.com/steve-wackers-superior-spider-man-takeover/">famously said</a> that in a few years, Peter Parker would fade away entirely, irrelevantly, because the new Spider-Man would be Otto Octavius.</p><p>I don’t bring this up as a lament for the fictional stories or fictional consequences endured by these fictional characters. The point is that their entire existence is basically a means to foster a negative relationship with the fans, to get them on the hook by luring them in with rage.</p><p>This is all patently absurd, of course, but they seem to think it’s what drives sales (it doesn’t). I know it’s bad to gatekeep fandoms, but I’ve held a belief for years now that you can’t truly understand comics until your reaction to Marvel’s<a href="https://screenrant.com/xmen-marvel-comic-most-important/"> “Most Important X-Men Scene Of All Time!”</a> or DC’s “Earth-Shattering New Revelations!” are frustrated, sad sighs. The stories themselves are ancillary to the marketing structure provided for them.</p><p>But that’s what art is. And I’m not about to pretend like comic books were ever some sacred space for True Artists to create. They were always popular fiction designed to sell ads and toys for kids, quick for-hire work by harried, overworked artists just trying to make ends meet. Same as newspapers or television or any other form of entertainment we have today. But somewhere along the way, people who grew up with popular fiction found themselves in the wild weirdness that science fiction or genre entertainment demanded. And somewhere further, that identification itself became commodified, controlled, used as an identity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*yQ7IxS2zbGclq5uH.jpg" /><figcaption>The current state of fandom. (Desc: a dumpster on fire)</figcaption></figure><p>To be a capital-f Fan in 2019 is not merely to enjoy a piece of entertainment but to participate in scheduled livetweets, to cosplay, to aggressively stan (and/or cancel) your fave, to coordinate large-scale production of fan art and fanfic, to identify with a larger Fandom Group complete with hierarchy and pecking order.</p><p>None of this, individually, is particularly terrible behavior. Fan communities have done truly great things and given young people, especially marginalized ones, the ability to find common ground. It’s just how the Internet has fragmented and codified groups at the same time, and how cultural capital has shifted almost entirely in the favor of a few massive corporations. The Disney-Fox merger scares me, and it should bother you too.</p><p>Why must I even qualify the above statement by insisting that I grew up on Disney and love many of their movies? That’s the expectation placed upon people. The architecture of Fandom is set up so that people must only mindlessly Consume at all costs, and any criticism — especially that of the corporate structure — is quickly silenced by legions of people taking the side of the massive corporate monolith.</p><p>I don’t say any of this to be a “hater” or an “anti” — I say it because of larger-scale political and social concerns outside of and bigger than the Fandom, with a perspective on the real-world implications of the consolidation of media.</p><p>Sure, I’ll go see a live action remake or a new Star War, but what happens when a single corporation — one with a less-than-spotless record on race or gender politics — controls every story that is told?</p><p>What happens when the only things we can share meaningfully are products, and when our culture itself is so cleaved apart and atomized that even our folk tales, our fairy tales, our common stories, are bought and sanitized and sold back to us?</p><p>And in a strange way, though there is more money to be made in entertainment and storytelling than ever before, so little of it is going to new and emerging writers, artists, and musicians. Soundcloud and Bandcamp have revolutionized the way music is consumed, and given platform to millions who otherwise would never be able to share their art — and yet, the corporations at the top of the industry have taken increasingly larger shares of the pie.</p><p>We’ve reached the stage of late capitalism where people have been complaining that everything is only a reboot of a remake of a reboot of a remake for the last two decades now. That in itself isn’t new. It’s not that new art isn’t produced, or new methods of creativity aren’t explored — the difference in interacting with society and culture between Vine, TikTok, and Instagram could by itself be a field of study on its own. It’s that the new ways we make creativity have been so devalued and discarded, in favor of the inexorable march of Brands vying for complete takeover of the digital public sphere.</p><p>And instead of comprehending this new reality, Fandoms choose to demand more content to please them, regardless of how it is sourced or what it represents. The same way that capitalism demands the subjugation of all things to emphasize profit, Fandoms will leak into actors’ or writer’s personal lives, make callous demands of performers (<a href="https://www.wmagazine.com/story/rihanna-new-music-social-media-trolls">WHERE IS THE ALBUM?????</a>), target harassment campaigns at each other, and cultivate group identities so severe that driving people to self-harm or suicide is seen as an admirable goal in defense of the larger Fandom. It happens with everything from pop singers to children’s cartoons to the fans of a particular “ship” in a particular movie or show.</p><p>You can’t even mention, for example, Ariana Grande or Beyoncé on Twitter or Instagram, especially in a negative context, without being immediately swarmed by vast legions of stans who will “defend” a multi-millionaire by conducting mass harassment campaigns against random people. Or God forbid you express distaste for someone like Elon Musk or Jordan Peterson, and your social media will be instantly swarmed with identical people nodding sagely, requesting you to debate them.</p><p>A couple weeks ago, <a href="https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/nba/warriors/2019/06/07/beyonce-fans-made-death-threats-warriors-owners-wife-nicole-curran/1382763001/">Beyoncé fans started sending death threats</a> to a woman who leaned over her to talk to Jay-Z. Fandoms of children’s cartoons even get on the action! <a href="https://geekdad.com/2018/10/toxic-fandom-when-criticism-and-entitlement-go-too-far/">The Voltron: Legendary Defender fandom started sending death threats to the creators and voice actors on the show</a> for minor storytelling decisions. <a href="https://www.syfy.com/syfywire/rick-and-morty-has-a-fandom-problem">Rick and Morty fans had collective seizures about a novelty McDonald’s chicken nugget sauce</a>, calling police and physically assaulting minimum-wage workers for it. Fans of Youtubers like Logan Paul or PewDiePie are basically private armies of mass action, weaponized by rich assholes to further cement their own influence.</p><p>They conduct themselves with rage, and send violent rage everywhere, because rage creates fan engagement, and Fandom cannot sustain itself on anything but rage to survive. It’s in the Youtube algorithms, in the way virality is measured, in the way decisions are made on every corporate level. It can’t be stopped or contained, because the air is taken out of the world, and everyone else is suffocating just to get by.</p><p>I love being a fan of things. Art and music and film and literature have touched my soul — and yours — in ways I could not even begin to describe. But when corporations control the public sphere, they can direct and shape the legions of Fans to uncritically consume neverending Content. To draw battle lines between what is the purview of the Fandom and what is not. Does anyone even want that? Can Fandom even exist outside of this corporate paradigm?</p><p>It used to. Maybe it will again. But I don’t see it happening anytime soon.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bade3d33d723" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Men Will Be Men]]></title>
            <link>https://alexjricard.medium.com/men-will-be-men-f04b69b949b1?source=rss-93dc22ad3304------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f04b69b949b1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[rape-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[supreme-court]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patriarchy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brett-kavanaugh]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Ricard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Oct 2018 19:42:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-02T19:42:49.251Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>And they will keep being men until they are held to account.</h4><p>One day in middle school, I was in detention. The room was surrounded by rows of isolated cubicles circling the room, with a large gap towards the center. I was seated at the last cube near the center. Even though we were nominally being punished for various transgressions, we still mostly sat and amused ourselves while the gym coach pretended to keep an eye on us.</p><p>Just to my right, in the open space, a girl was pacing back and forth. She was looking out the window, bored out of her mind. The boy to my left and I were laughing, making crude jokes, and generally not at all acting punished. He peeked his head over and dared me to try to touch her ass the next time she turned around.</p><p>It would be a hilarious joke. We giggled about it like a pair of, well, twelve-year-olds. I stretched my hand out, reaching, reaching —</p><p>Before I made any contact, she realized what I was up to, turned around and slapped my hand away. She told the coach that we were bothering her.</p><p>“Boys,” he said, not even bothering to lift his eyes up from his magazine, “don’t touch her.”</p><p>One day in high school, a regular member of my lunch table came in several minutes later than normal. He strode in confidently through the main doors, his face bright.</p><p>“What did you have for lunch?,” someone asked.</p><p>“Pussy,” he declared with a grin. The table erupted with laughter and congratulations. Several of us turned to look over behind him. His girlfriend was sneaking through a side door, hiding her face, deeply embarrassed.</p><p>My math teacher in my sophomore year of high school had a habit of making very close friends with girls in the class. He’d dote on them, offer them extra credit, and encourage them to sit up front. In every class he designated a personal “secretary”, usually a skinny blonde cheerleader, to pass out his papers, take attendance, and spend time with him after class helping grade papers.</p><p>So when he abruptly disappeared halfway through the school year, with no explanation given, everyone already knew: he must have gotten caught groping one of the students. Now he works as a girls’ tennis coach at the local Catholic high school.</p><p>When I was in college, my roommate pretty shortly had a girlfriend. They often spent time together in the cramped shared bedroom, so I often spent time in the lobby just to give them privacy.</p><p>“I dunno man,” he said to me one evening, after she’d left. “Do you think she’s hot enough for me? You think I could do better?”</p><p>Not even two weeks later, I was in the car with someone giving me a ride to band practice. He was on the phone with his girlfriend, so I sat and zoned out. But once the conversation ended he breathed a sigh of relief.</p><p>“That was close. I almost called her the name of my other girlfriend,” he said.</p><p>“You’re cheating on her?,” I asked, trying not to sound too judgmental. He was one of the very few people I knew with a car, I couldn’t afford to get on his bad side.</p><p>“She’s like three hours away, it doesn’t count. Different area codes,” as if it were the song. “Oh, but this conversation never leaves this car.”</p><p>I have known Brett Kavanaugh. The specifics are negotiable, but the pattern is always the same: young white men, convinced of their Greatness, their infallibility, their entitlement to the world, with their parents’ wealth acting as the ultimate golden pillow.</p><p>But it doesn’t even have to be the Bretts of the world. Some of the men in those anecdotes above were not white, were not young, were not wealthy. They were not necessarily acting entitled to the whole world; simply entitled to half its population in various ways.</p><p>Some were indeed predators, abusing women with any opportunity they could. But some merely looked the other way and allowed it to flourish without a care. Some boasted to the world of their conquests as if women were there for their own amusement and pleasure. Some simply viewed them as an accessory, a status symbol, something to manipulate and dispose of once its use is finished, and any harm that would cause just “wouldn’t count”.</p><p>I include my own 12-year-old self in this description, too. I can make no excuses for those actions or beliefs I had as an immature child. Even if I thought it was just a joke at the time. I can only view myself in the harsh light of hindsight and force myself to be better.</p><p>I have no doubt that Kavanaugh does not remember his interaction with Dr. Christine Blasey Ford. His pleading fury is not cynically designed to make him look sympathetic, or to cover up transgressions. It’s the frustration of someone who truly, earnestly believes he has done nothing wrong, and feels the world crashing around him. Because for the first time, he is being held to account for his actions.</p><p>For Dr. Ford, the event in question as a searing memory, one that forever altered her life and would have consequences for decades. But for Brett Kavanaugh, it was just one night, among many, in the history of his life in which he drank too much, and thought it would be a really funny idea to try to hurt a woman. That’s all it was, he could insist. It was just a joke, no idea why she had to take it so <em>seriously.</em></p><p>Indelible in the hippocampus is laughter. It was just a joke!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/860/0*cJriIzs7b2v2DoLU.jpg" /><figcaption>Brett Kavanaugh, furious at the Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on Thursday.</figcaption></figure><p>Humor can be a brilliant tool to inject humanity and levity into a cruel world. Laughter is the shared experience that can bring the world together. But it can be used as a weapon, too.</p><p>Those accustomed to weaponizing their privilege have a habit of making “jokes” like these. With the general fervor of popular culture in late 2018, I don’t even need to list an example; it’s already on the tip of your tongue. And you can see it every time there’s chafe about “political correctness” or about how people are just “too sensitive” these days, or that they can’t take a joke anymore.</p><p>Because these are not jokes. These are targeted missiles designed to dehumanize and brutalize others. To call it a “joke” was just their cover, the excuse to say or do something horrific and try to escape accountability for it.</p><p>Here’s another joke, pulled straight from Brett Kavanaugh’s high school yearbook: Renate Alumnus! Haha, how funny, to denigrate a woman by name. It’s just a joke! He didn’t mean any harm by it!</p><p>Brett Kavanaugh’s fraternity at Yale, Delta Kappa Epsilon, had an unofficial slogan for decades: “No Means Yes, Yes Means Anal!”</p><p>How many times, if anyone were to ever raise objections to this slogan, did Brett and his buddies fall back on the same old excuse? It’s just a joke!</p><p>Even if Brett Kavanaugh himself never actually raped anyone, how many times did he and his friends grin wildly, sharing their secret that No Means Yes and that Yes Means Anal? How many times did they gleefully recite it to each other? How many incoming pledges did they teach it to? How many times did they lay the groundwork to encourage each other that rape was okay?</p><p>How many of his friends, his classmates, his buddies were rapists? How many of them thought it would be funny to treat women the way they did — sneaking into their homes and stealing their underwear, or getting them drunk to take advantage of them? And how many times did Brett fervently cover for them, look the other way, and make excuses for them?</p><p>How often did he share in their stories, listen wide-eyed to their boasting and bragging, laughing heartily at the expense of the women in these stories? How many times did he drunkenly stumble into his frat house to find his friends and frat brothers taking advantage of women and then merely ignore it?</p><p>How many jokes did they make, or exaggerations, or outright lies, about any women they met, meant to both elevate their own status and insult the women? I can almost hear the laughter full force, reverberating through time, nearly 30 years later. It’s just a joke! Just locker room talk!</p><p>How many times did Brett Kavanaugh get drunk and use a woman’s body as his own personal punchline? And, in turn, how many of his friends, frat brothers, or colleagues made excuses for his behavior?</p><p>Kavanaugh went to an extraordinarily prestigious prep school and was well-connected into the stratosphere of privilege. His particular Yale chapter has, among its alumni, multiple former Presidents, politicians, and many vastly influential business and public figures. His current position on the 10th Circuit is already one of the highest, most elite professions possible in an elite field. This is supposed to be the best of them.</p><p>How many of them, too, believed that No Means Yes? Even if it was a “joke”?</p><p>Powerful men — just like predatory ones — or ones who simply only want to look the other way — or ones who boast about their own conquests while also shaming their partners — or ones who treat women as interchangeable, manipulable, or disposable — seek power over women as a way to affirm their manhood, to solidify their male bonding. This is what it means to them to be a man. That’s why they close ranks so easily when one of them is accused.</p><p>Brett Kavnaugh may not technically be a rapist. But the distinction almost doesn’t even matter: he participated in, and benefited from, rape culture. He aided and abetted in horrific acts. He knowingly palled around with abusers, harassers, and rapists. And instead of holding them to account, he gleefully joined in their laughter.</p><p>To confirm him to the Supreme Court would be a travesty for this reason, but also for any other reason. Caught up in all this we have forgotten his mysterious financial troubles, his corruption, his horrific and nakedly partisan views on civil rights of all kinds, and more. He would be unqualified for the Court even without these allegations.</p><p>Let me back up a bit. Yes, I am speaking in generalities, and throwing out cynical accusations with no evidence to prove it. But I have known Brett Kavanaugh. I have seen it with my own eyes. I have seen this behavior in purportedly chaste, respectful upper-middle-class church groups. I have seen this behavior in high school dropouts smoking weed behind schools, throwing out casually misogynistic insults to try to prove their worth. I have seen this behavior in communities who pride themselves on their education and intellect, yet after discussing Deleuze or Hegel they still take time to indulge in misogyny. I have seen this behavior, heard these “jokes”, from sports fans, and music fans, and comic book fans, and video game fans, and in groups of any men doing anything.</p><p>Anywhere men gather without accountability, this is how we act. It is not endemic to us, but it is something expected of us, by each other and by society. This is how we are, with or without alcohol, with or without wealth.</p><p>We have taught boys that, given enough wealth and entitlement, they are untouchable. That if they model these behaviors they will be rewarded. It is, of course, completely anathema to the other Ideals Of Morality And Masculinity we also simultaneously spout. But then, like so many other kinds of double standards about gender roles, it really was always designed to let men get away with whatever we want.</p><p>Deprogramming this toxic version of masculinity from ourselves may be the hardest, most difficult challenge facing men in the future. That includes war, that includes climate change, that includes looming futures we can’t yet even comprehend. Because until we are able to improve collectively, we will continue sabotaging and destroying everything else, even ourselves, even the Earth, to maintain our privileged social order.</p><p>And sure, of course, it is not all men. There are important nuances to be considered. The system does not elevate all men as a monolith. It focuses its efforts on wealthy white Christian straight men who are well-connected enough to attend prestigious universities and join social groups to collectively denigrate women with future world leaders.</p><p>There are many good men out there who feel unfairly judged, put under a microscope by the demands of the new era. There are many men who harbor guilt and fear, and hope merely to avoid any of their past skeletons coming out. And there are many men, who may be innocent, who worry that they may soon be targeted without any way to clear their names.</p><p>But this line of argument almost misses the point. It’s almost not even about bringing down individual abusers, but about dismantling the systemic structure that allows abusers to thrive. The argument against rape culture is that it can’t exist, because we have harsh legal punitive measures against rape, and everyone knows it’s wrong. But none of those matter when the system itself refuses to actually do anything, and when half the population just lets it slide.</p><p>While male entitlement and misogyny may be at its worst in these hyper-privileged men at the top of the social strata, this filters down to every single one of us. That’s what “privilege” means: not that we suddenly have had this perfect and carefree life, but that we benefit from advantages that others suffer from, merely from accidents of birth. And to confront and deconstruct that privilege is a base responsibility that every one of us has on the path to becoming a good person.</p><p>In this lens, none of us are truly innocent. Because how many of us have looked the other way? How many of us have refused to call out our friends when they do or say things we all know to be wrong?</p><p>The saying goes “boys will be boys”, to infantilize and make light of foul behavior. This phrase has been roundly criticized for justifying and excusing horrific acts under the umbrella of “playing” and “joking”. But there is truth to it: men will indeed be men, and they will keep being men until other men stop them from doing it.</p><p>The world is changing, and men need to catch up. It’s not just about left or right-wing policy, either. When Al Franken, stalwart Democratic hero, was revealed to have committed sexual assault under the pretense of “joking”, his career burned to the ground, as it should have. There is no excuse and never has been.</p><p>Because this isn’t confusing. The rules haven’t changed. It’s not even, really, a new era. There is no shifting of moral standards. We have always known this behavior is wrong, we just were enabled and allowed to continue with no accountability.</p><p>My advice: men, let’s get our shit together. Stop abusing women. Stop making excuses for those who do. Stop looking the other way and letting people get hurt. Let’s call out our friends, even if it’s hard, even if you know that it will make you unpopular.</p><p>It really doesn’t have to be much. Say it to their face: “Hey, don’t make jokes like that.” — “That’s inappropriate.” — “Leave her alone.”</p><p>Even the tiniest bit of resistance can leave men flustered, embarrassed, and upset — as they should be if they are harming someone. That’s why Brett threw such a fit at his hearing on Thursday. Because it is only when they are not being held accountable do they feel emboldened enough to commit these actions that they already feel guilty about. And if we don’t hold them accountable, we are complicit, too.</p><p>So if it won’t come from anywhere else, take accountability for your own self. Take accountability for your sphere of influence. Make your friends be better people, and expect your friends to make you a better person. You know, express the kind of moral fortitude that society pretends like it actually does teach men. It is literally the least we can do.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f04b69b949b1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What We Talk About When We Talk About Mollie Tibbetts’ Murder]]></title>
            <link>https://alexjricard.medium.com/what-we-talk-about-when-we-talk-about-mollie-tibbetts-murder-8df224e831c7?source=rss-93dc22ad3304------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8df224e831c7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[medium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[crime]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conservatism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Ricard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 Aug 2018 14:25:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-28T14:33:24.718Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Victims and their families deserve better than this sheer cruelty.</h4><p>Whenever a tragedy happens in 2018’s America, there are usually three extremely rapid responses anyone has to it. They are as follows:</p><ol><li>There are those who politicize it immediately, calling for action or rapid change on this or that issue, to prevent it from happening again;</li><li>There are those who pre-emptively try to stop people from politicizing it only in ways they don’t want it politicized, thus politicizing it themselves in their defense of the status quo that allowed the tragedy to happen;</li><li>There are those who politically <em>weaponize</em> it, immediately speaking over those actively impacted by the tragedy and exploiting their pain for attention to themselves. This is distinct from merely politicizing it in that it is not in the service of any policy goal or change to society, it is the lashing out of self-serving reactionary fear.</li></ol><p>The event in question could be a mass shooting, or a war crime, or a death of someone famous or powerful, or a highly publicized disappearance of a conventionally attractive white women, or anything else. The disappearance of University of Iowa student Mollie Tibbetts is the latest in a long line of these kinds of stories. At first, I thought I had been picking up on it because I moved to Iowa City, where she was living, around the same time as her disappearance. There were “Missing” posters on every street corner, and the case has been the talk of the town for the last few weeks. But the news that her body was found, and the identification of the suspect as an illegal immigrant (<a href="https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/investigations/2018/08/22/mollie-tibbetts-alleged-killer-iowa-legally-lawyer-missing-student-body-found-brooklyn-trump/1064567002/">or maybe he was here legally?</a>), led to a complete uproar spilling over the nation’s newsfeeds and TV sets. There are so many layers to this case and its subsequent discussion.</p><p>What happened to Mollie was a tragedy, and her family deserves better than the outpouring of lazy cynicism already overwhelming any attempt to celebrate her or her life. Already, feckless hacks from the likes of social media upcomers like <a href="https://twitter.com/RealCandaceO/status/1032047464218546176">Candace Owens</a> and <a href="http://insider.foxnews.com/2018/08/22/tomi-lahren-mollie-tibbetts-murder-wake-call-illegal-immigration">Tomi Lahren</a>, Fox News stalwarts like <a href="https://twitter.com/BillOReilly/status/1032994688440127489">Bill O’Reilly</a> and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7fbvPjJJLyM&amp;feature=youtu.be&amp;a=">Tucker Carlson</a>, <a href="https://twitter.com/GovMikeHuckabee/status/1032016684268376069">various</a> <a href="https://siouxcityjournal.com/news/local/govt-and-politics/steve-king-leftist-immigration-policies-contributed-to-mollie-tibbetts-death/article_0c5c52dd-7fa3-5181-a6ea-925722a4f823.html">GOP</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/foxandfriends/status/1032943349827821568">elected</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/IAGovernor/status/1032014828041326598?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">officials</a> and even of course, <a href="https://twitter.com/realDonaldTrump/status/1032393212126613504">our favorite President</a> have all taken the time to make this case a focal point of the central political goal of modern conservatism: Making America White Again.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/0*AZL1GeiZcO0vaSNL.jpg" /><figcaption>Image: a corrupt racist weaponizing rhetoric to harm people.</figcaption></figure><p>They’re using this case as a wedge issue to prove that immigrants are “bringing drugs and crime”, and that they’re an imminent threat to women in the US. Never mind the statistics that show that immigrants commit crimes at lower rates than Trump administration officials. Never mind that violence against women is most often perpetrated by husbands or boyfriends, not strangers.</p><p>But as we’ve also learned recently from the Mouth of Sauron himself, <a href="https://www.cnn.com/videos/cnnmoney/2018/08/19/giuliani-truth-isnt-truth-nbc-rs-vpx.cnn">truth isn’t truth</a>, and so if it doesn’t fit their convenient narrative it doesn’t really count. This is evidenced in the way right-wing superstars have turned to vilifying Mollie once they found out she was a liberal who had no love for Trump; actual Nazi supervillain Milo Yiannopolous told her to <a href="https://twitter.com/AlexThomasDC/status/1033539002626973696">“enjoy hell”</a>, dozens of trolls have taken to swarming her still-active social media accounts with <a href="https://twitter.com/magi_jay/status/1032406745954566144">vulgar comments</a>, and the prevailing narrative in this group has changed, already, to that she <a href="https://babe.net/2018/08/23/mollie-tibbetts-trolls-76323">“deserved” to get killed</a> as punishment for not liking Trump’s stance on immigration.</p><p>Because if they really cared about women not being attacked and killed, they’d reauthorize the Violence Against Women Act. They’d take real, tangible steps to stamp out sexual harassment and provide resources to clear the untested rape kit backlog. They’d promote policies to encourage maternity leave and address the wage gap. They’d make it harder for domestic abusers to get weapons, they’d believe women who have been assaulted, and stop making excuses for a serial rapist currently inhabiting the White House. They’d stop trying to criminalize abortion, too, while they’re at it.</p><p>The conservative side of the world is not interested in any of those solutions because they don’t actually care about it. This conversation isn’t really about Mollie Tibbetts, nor is it about immigration, or violence against women, or media sensationalism, or anything else. This just happened to be a convenient segue for them to demonize Mexican immigrants. It’s why they weaponized the phrase <a href="https://twitter.com/WhiteHouse/status/1032335050866487296">“permanently separated”</a> as a sick rebuttal to the legitimate outrage people on the other side of the aisle have had about their family separation policy. Really, it’s about the specific and unique brand of reactionary cruelty that has taken over conservative America.</p><p>Most simply, the difference in rhetoric is illuminating: one side is in abject horror at innocent children being ripped from families and placed into concentration camps with no plans for reunification.,The other side merely wants to mock them for this, and is deliberately twisting the knife just to get a sense of self-satisfaction out of “owning the libs”.</p><p>And it’s more than just base hypocrisy. Politics has splintered now. It’s no longer just about disagreement in policy but about the way we conduct our actions. It would be absurd to say that we have never been more divided; we have, but never before have these divisions filtered down into every minute decision we’ve ever made.</p><p>All of these things are the same:</p><p>It’s spending thousands to modify your truck to spew <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/05/business/energy-environment/rolling-coal-in-diesel-trucks-to-rebel-and-provoke.html">black smoke</a> in the faces of everyone behind you.</p><p>It’s going out of your way to do dumb-ass public stunts to try to <a href="https://twitter.com/toownthelibs?lang=en">“trigger the libtard snowflakes”</a>.</p><p>It’s why “men’s rights activists” are much more concerned with tearing down women’s movements than anything to do with their own self-professed ideology.</p><p>It’s why millions of people held their nose and voted for a monster simply because they knew it’d <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2018/07/24/nikki-haley-warns-against-owning-the-libs-thats-basically-trumps-entire-political-strategy/?noredirect=on&amp;utm_term=.c26dc2ea6e47">make liberals mad</a>.</p><p>It’s purposely littering or destroying the environment for no other reason than some people are concerned about the environment, so naturally your course is to oppose them.</p><p>It’s going on whole faux-moral crusades to tear apart your favorite hobbies, whether it’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gamergate_controversy">video games</a> or <a href="https://www.inverse.com/article/41132-comicsgate-explained-bigots-milkshake-marvel-dc-gamergate">comic books</a> or <a href="https://medium.com/@alexjricard/on-star-wars-fans-and-nostalgia-or-boba-fett-sucks-e066b79ad184">Star Wars fandom</a>, simply because there are people who you don’t like who are now fans of the same thing you are (and of course, very often the reason you don’t like these people is because of barely-concealed misogyny or homophobia or racism, not any actual legitimate reason).</p><p>It’s why the only way some people can conceive of to protect themselves, or their families, countries, or even abstract notions like “our freedoms” is to wage wars of aggression and intimidation, whether abroad or in our own neighborhoods, with massive stockpiles of weapons. To “defend yourself”, in this context, can only mean to outwardly express violence.</p><p>It’s the vast suite of insane conspiracy theories that various barely-liberal world leaders are secretly Satanic commie anarchist globalists taking away your guns or using lazer blasts to <a href="https://www.mediamatters.org/video/2018/08/24/infowars-host-hurricane-threatening-hawaii-has-been-split-two-energy-beam-shot-antarctica-possibly/221094">control the weather</a> or running an underground sex-trafficking ring in a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pizzagate_conspiracy_theory">pizza joint</a> or putting chemicals in the water to <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9JRLCBb7qK8">turn the freakin’ frogs gay</a>.</p><p>It’s positioning yourself as a brave truth-telling crusader for free speech and with a single-minded obsession with political correctness, when in reality that just means you want to find easier ways to hurt people and not be held accountable for it.</p><p>That last one is especially pernicious, specifically because it’s fine on its face. Who doesn’t support freedom of speech and expression? It’s a wonderful thing. But it’s entirely something different to only fly the flag of “freedom of speech” when you want to say racist or homophobic slurs. It’s entirely different to campaign for “gender equality” just to have an excuse to hurt women.</p><p>People have been fearmongering about “PC Police” since before I was born, and last I checked the only free speech being suppressed is the kind that speaks truth to power and demands justice and accountability. The other kind of free speech, bigotry and hatred, is flourishing and encouraged by no less than the President of the United States on down through every single lever of power in society.</p><p>The contortions of logic are so predictable and so widespread they’re barely worth mentioning: how many times have any of you heard the phrase “I believe in feminism so that means I can hit girls too”? They’ll go to any depths, hang dearly onto any ideology or identity, to justify whatever form of social control they really want enacted. They just want whatever excuse they can grasp to hurt others.</p><p>The specifics range from absurd pettiness to active spite to abject inhumane vindictiveness, but it all boils down to the same base action. There is no policy goal to be enacted, there is no consistency, no larger ideological vision, there is only the unfiltered id of rage while lashing out against others. It’s somewhere between fear and anger, between paranoia and callousness, but below everything it is an embrace of cruelty.</p><p>To be conservative in 2018 means to inject 500 cc’s of pure fear directly into your eyeballs, scream into the void, and then tear apart anything kind in the world to make yourself feel better. This is how people are radicalized. They are thrust into walled gardens, beset on all sides by frightening images teaching them to hate what they fear and fear what they hate. It’s a vicious cycle, and it completely dominates our national conversation.</p><p>It doesn’t matter if it’s Breitbart or Fox News or even your local TV news station: they all traffic in cruelty and paranoia. The very essence of what it means to be human is stripped away here: both from themselves and their appointed enemies. Propaganda works, and it’s very real, and all of these prominent right-wing personalities are deliberately whipping up this kind of outrage to keep themselves in power forever.</p><p>So, when a tragedy like this occurs, and all the vultures swoop in, all they really want is to exploit the suffering of the victims. Mollie Tibbett’s family has already <a href="https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100013284091496">swung back</a> at these vultures, and deservedly so. They deserve to mourn on their own terms, to process their own grief, and wrestle back the conversation from these people who only want to use her as a weapon.</p><p>Just like in cases of violence against women, the unifying force of any reactionary ideology isn’t <em>actually</em> their principled belief systems, but in the utility of any particular news item as a cudgel to enforce their views onto society. It’s the root of the word itself: they cannot put forward positive ideas, only <em>react </em>and try to maintain a vicious status quo. It doesn’t really even matter if they’re conservative or liberal. There are plenty of reactionaries on the left. But their goal is always the same: to break down the carefully-constructed humanity that society has built in each of us and make everyone else exactly as cruel and petty and afraid as they are.</p><p>Of course, there is an easy rejoinder to this very post, and it is a point worth discussing: “If you don’t want the death of Mollie Tibbetts to be politicized, why are you making it political now?” Or: “Why do you want to politicize gun violence and not terrorism?” Or: “Doesn’t it make you a hypocrite for using this tragedy to advance your political goals while admonishing others for doing that same thing?” Or: “You’re doing the same thing they are, by making mass generalizations without accounting for the nuance of their humanity!”</p><p>This is a complete red herring. Yes, a narrow reading of two opposite sides, completely divorced of context or any material reality, could lead one to believe that “politicization” of these tragedies is the issue, or that making broad generalizations of others is the root of this problem. But it’s not politicization, it’s the <em>specific policies and beliefs</em> that make all the difference in the world.</p><p>I feel perfectly comfortable politicizing this tragedy. And politicizing the tragedy of the Jacksonville shooting that happened literally as I write these words. Politicization is a good thing, and it should happen way more often than we as a society allow it to happen. Because the end goal of my politics is not to fearmonger, to divide, to sow the seed of hate. The end goal of my politics is for the human race, of all races, religions, genders, and societies, to build a lasting and beautiful era of peace and understanding with one another. The end goal of my politics is for this world to be a better, safer place, free of war and hunger and hatred. I want to build that world, and I know that together we can, and anyone who doesn’t want that world is a bad person.</p><p>So what do we talk about when we talk about cases like this? We talk about society and safety, how to better build a world in which women are safe from predatory men. But what we’re not gonna do is use tragedies like these as pawns to advance more hatred. When we talk about cases like Mollie Tibbetts’ murder, we are really talking about a war between love and hate.</p><p>But the sad truth is that love doesn’t trump hate. Hate wins, and it keeps fighting and fighting until it destroys everything in its path. Hate politicizes tragedies whether we want it to or not. It gets an extreme head start on the conversation because in so many ways, it’s easier to be cruel than to be kind. That’s what hatred is best at. And it will always do this if we let it. So we can never rest, and we can never allow it to take root, or it will kill us in our sleep.</p><p>In order for love to win it will take an active effort, from each of us, to keep vigilant and stamp it out. That means uncomfortable conversations at Thanksgiving. That means calling in people to inspire them to do better. That means using our privilege and platform to advocate for those who need it most. That means denying a platform to those who would use it to destroy us, even as self-defeating as their politics always are. And, yes, that does mean having the conversation not just about the tragedy itself, but <em>about</em> the larger national conversation.</p><p>These issues will be politicized whether we want it to be or not. That’s just how things work in 2018. So we need to take this opportunity and respond in kind, to counter the politicization of hatred with a politicization of love, and this should happen every time until the voices of hate are drowned out completely. Our only option is to tackle it head-on. This should happen every time someone wants to use a tragedy to further their own campaign of hate. This should happen every time until there are no more tragedies. The only way out of this is through.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8df224e831c7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Sad Boys Get Angry]]></title>
            <link>https://alexjricard.medium.com/how-sad-boys-get-angry-8c4a2d781936?source=rss-93dc22ad3304------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8c4a2d781936</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jordan-peterson]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[4chan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[toxic-masculinity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Ricard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 28 May 2018 20:35:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-28T20:36:30.556Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Incels interlinked, incels interlinked, incels interlinked</h4><p>In the summer of 2007, a friend of mine introduced me to Pick Up Artistry. He had a whole stack of books and bookmarkedwebsites about it; and I’m sure you could guess why a couple of dumb 16-year-olds about to enter senior year in high school were entranced by the idea of being able to seduce any and all women. There was a whole method to it; if you just followed their simple steps you were guaranteed to get laid. Not even “get a girl”, just to have success in your sexual prowess.</p><p>They had all sorts of strategies: have a gimmick, like magic tricks, or carrying guitars around, or walking your dog. “Neg” women by subtly insulting their appearance or intelligence. Be mysterious, and never give out your own number, but leave with theirs. The most important piece of advice: be persistent, be adamant, and never, ever, ever, ever give up. You may be rejected by the first 100 women you ask, but if number 101 was a success, it was worth it in the end.</p><p>It was, to put it simply, a crock of dumb ass bullshit. I never bought into it, not just because it was never successful for my friend (despite all his claims to the contrary), but also because the idea of indulging in such a masochistic endeavor sounded exhausting and humiliating. Who wants to be with the guy who just literally asks everyone out constantly until they get worn down? But that was the entire strategy. Pick Up Artists teach men to treat women as as reward. Her own thoughts and feelings are irrelevant, all that matters is if she’s vaguely woman-shaped and would have sex with you. Who cares about a genuine human connection? The entire concept made me sick.</p><p>But then, I was single and shy and nerdy, and I’d never had too much luck with women. What if they were right? What if that really was how it worked? Like many other teenage boys, I took my questions to the internet.</p><p>Around this time on my life, I started visiting the now-notorious online forum 4chan, on a variety of boards. In a real way I felt like 4chan was a community. These were other single and shy and nerdy guys like me who could commiserate in our loneliness. Sure, some parts of the site boldly expressed the kind of casual racism and misogyny that would eventually fuel the place into the nightmare boogeyman it became. But before it became the headquarters for the alt-right, 4chan was the headquarters for lonely nerds who just wanted someone to talk to. At least, that’s the story its users kept telling about themselves.</p><p>Even outside of the alt-right sphere, the cultural influence of that space is pretty vast. Whole musical, artistic, and fashion movements like vaporwave and sadboy aesthetics sprung up to define 2010s culture. The vast prevalence of memes largely started from the incubator of 4chan, which also created many well-known memes and meme formats. I even have a working theory that Drake, the first truly Mainstream Sadboy™, might not have nearly resonated with our generation to become one of the biggest pop sensations in the world, had it not been for the influence of sad boys.</p><p>There is, of course, a flip side to the space where sad boys became sad men. The history of 4chan’s insidious web is well-documented. But watching it happen in real time, in the late ’00s and early ’10s, I saw what had once been a space full of people sad that their crush didn’t like them back, or that they hadn’t spoken to a woman in years turn into a space full of people angrily demanding that women who didn’t return their affections were whores, or that women were going through life on “easy mode” because they get drinks paid for.</p><p>But it wasn’t that the community was changing. It was never really a “community” at all, more of an unfiltered id lashing out in a thousand directions at once. Everyone was fully anonymous, so therefore completely malleable in an ultimate void of meaning. Especially on certain boards like /r9k/ or /pol/, you could never be sure if you were speaking to one person back and forth, or twenty people, or five hundred people. Nothing was really getting better or getting worse, it was the same as it always had been.</p><p>Everything meant nothing, so it could mean whatever you wanted to infer to it. Identity and context were stripped from every single post, and anyone with enough time or effort could conduct elaborate trolling schemes designed to strengthen their network. If all these other people out there who were just like you were peddling misogynist conspiracy theories, why not follow along for yourself?</p><p>Incidentally, that’s exactly how 4chan is responsible for so much radicalization. The very format of the site, and its use by bad actors, is the exact reason why it has become a hotbed for extremist groups to radicalize disaffected young men.</p><p>The story continues: the whirlpool of Gamergate, a movement later revealed to be frothed by actual white supremacists, started to consume the entire site. And as we’ve seen in even more recent years, that bold rhetoric emboldened the worst instincts of the kind of people who enjoy inflicting cruelty for fun. There would be posts detailing the latest tips and tricks from the Pick Up Artists, still trying their negging and scams to trick women into bed. Any women who dared to show their face or mention that they were women were either immediately shunned and bullied from the site, or presented with so much unsolicited attention and stalking that they would leave anyway.</p><p>It wasn’t just 4chan, either. It was other New Internet spaces like Reddit, which seems in retrospect to have been designed to embolden young men’s worst opinions. It was the gore-splattered and sexual violence-filled videos of Newgrounds or Happy Tree Friends, it was SomethingAwful and YTMND. It was the mega-popular New Atheism movement and its offshoots. The expletive-riddled rants of early “internet personalities” like Maddox or Tucker Max, soaking in their exaggerated “hateful douchebag” personas. The “manosphere”, an entire network of sites of ultra-insecure men loudly declaring how aggressively masculine they were. Anywhere you went on the internet, from the time span of about 2006 to 2012, there were similar movements of lonely white male nerds, all of them angry about something. It’s only in recent years that the internet has become mainstream enough to prop up a more representative demographic.</p><p>To exist in these communities is the ultimate contradiction. You share your loneliness, but then to build it into anything other than anger is a sign of weakness. There’s a ritual to it. No real, flesh-and-blood human being can ever live up to the faceless automation of anonymity, so instead many of these young men decide to embrace the seductive void. It’s an arms race and a radicalization path at the same time. Nobody can ever complain, or whine, or ever falter, lest they be relentlessly mocked and exiled by the community for caring too much (after all, that’s for women anyway).</p><p>The system is built to reward the ones who posture the loudest and most aggressively against “PC Culture” or “SJWs” or whatever boogeyman they have decided is the reason for their misery. They view life as a zero-sum game stacked against them: the only reason they have not succeeded is because women or people of color or LGBTQ+ people are succeeding in their stead. Of course, this is completely ridiculous and completely devoid of any true historical or sociological understanding. But it speaks to that they can’t conceive of anything outside of themselves.</p><p>This is where the roots of the “involuntary celibate” movement began. They are so angry and sad at the same time, aggressively threatening and toxic, and completely shut off from self-reflection that they’ve invented entire political movements explaining why people don’t want to be associated with them. It couldn’t be something so simple as trying to be a good person, or to cultivate your own life and interests. While they exist as nearly polar opposites of the Pick Up Artist community, the result is the same: they view women’s thoughts and feelings as irrelevant. They just want a vaguely woman-shaped thing for them to use.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/878/0*hut9H0A_iv_dGv1a." /><figcaption>A typical “incel” post from Reddit, which might as well be viewed as an imminent threat.</figcaption></figure><p>What these men want more than anything is two things. First, they want all of their dreams and desires to come true, up to and including possession of women’s bodies. It’s entitled to them simply because they want it. And second, they want to be free from the social, moral, and ethical guidelines in society that might ever question this entitlement. They want even to be free of their own conscience, free from any self-reflection. To be taken seriously, and to have all their dreams come true, without ever having to make any effort or change on their part to achieve them. To paraphrase Stan Lee broadly, they want all of the power, and none of the responsibility. Once again, it’s a bunch of dumb ass bullshit.</p><p>It’s toxic masculinity in overdrive, a self-imposed descent into utter emotional squalor, constantly policed by an ever-shifting panopticon of anonymous viewers, completely divorced of context or identity. You’re left with two options: either “man up” and fall into the void completely, or escape by the skin of your neck. By the time 4chan was done with you, you were no longer a sad boy, but a very angry man.</p><p>I quit 4chan for good sometime in 2013. My last holdout was the Comics and Cartoons board, and when it too was overrun by racists and misogynists, there was nothing left for me there anymore. After years of checking it as incessantly as some check Facebook or Twitter, I’ve only been back to the site maybe once or twice in the last five years. My mood has improved, my outlook on life has brightened, and I don’t feel the rapid undercurrent of social pressure constantly trying to push me to be the coldest and most callous person alive.</p><p>Mostly, though, I feel like I survived. Talk to anyone, particularly men of this generation, with any inkling of having spent time online in those years. They stared into that abyss, too, and not all of them made it out in one piece. I will admit, it made me a very unpleasant person to be around sometimes. Without the intercession of some very good friends, I don’t know where I’d have ended up.</p><p>But these are the politics and events shaping our world now. The internet has mostly moved on from those anonymous boards and instead focused on a new set of faces saying the same old things. It’s out of the shadows and now thrust into the light. Jordan Peterson and Ben Shapiro and Sam Harris and Alex Jones and Joe Rogan and Dave Rubin and Bill Maher and on and on and on. You know the names already. The InTeLLeCtuaL dArK weB. The new counterculture! But what they lack in intellect, they make up for in darkness. While their new and different and dangerous ideas, like misogyny and racism, wouldn’t be out of place in well over half of America (after all, look who holds all the levels of power in this country), they’ve somehow convinced their fans that they are an oppressed minority, a chosen people, a bunch of brave truth-tellers standing up to the evil liberal idea to treat people with fairness and compassion. Much like 4chan users, they’ve chosen to paint themselves as victims while simultaneously decrying victimhood anywhere else.</p><p>They have built from the older foundations of the early internet into a much more well-connected, influential network. Now their legions of followers are sharpening their knives, ready to strike.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*RjrgaNPCE2HgMfvv.jpg" /><figcaption>From left to right: Ben Shapiro, Jordan Peterson, Sam Harris</figcaption></figure><p>Last week, a 17-year old boy in Santa Fe, Texas shot up his school because he felt so unjustly wronged by the fact that a woman stood up to his harassment. Not even a month before that, a man in Toronto killed 10 people in an explicit attempt to hurt women. Just before the shooting, he outed himself as a 4chan user, and also invoked the Santa Barbara shooter of 2014, who had declared a “War on Women” in his manifesto shortly before he, too, committed mass murder. The core motivation for all three incidents was their desire to punish women for their unwillingness to grant them sex or intimacy.</p><p>Intellectual Dark Web luminary Jordan Peterson and New York Times columnist Ross Douthat have gone a step even further by attempting to validate and mainstream these beliefs, in the name of “free speech” or whatever. Both hold vast swaths of influence, and both are using it for the same ends. Douthat recently posted an impassioned column about the necessity to redistribute sex — to literally strip the bodily autonomy of women away from them, so that boys won’t be sad anymore.</p><p>Peterson even uses his beliefs as nearly a threat: something must be done, he cryptically warns, and the status of gender relations must be forcibly imposed and strictly enforced in society, otherwise men will have no choice but to explode in violence and anger.</p><p>This rhetoric is culled straight from the extremist groups that have been plaguing all the new corners of the internet: there are the Gamergaters and Comicsgaters, who rail against the “SJWs” ruining their favorite media by shoehorning in too many female or LGBT characters. Or the Men Going Their Own Way, who advocate radical gender segregation, or Mens’ Rights Activists (MRAs), who insist feminism is the root of all societal ills, or Incels, who demand their personal sexual desires be satisfied regardless of who it hurts, or Pick Up Artists, who invariably view women as nothing more than conquests to be won.</p><p>These groups are not entirely the same as the alt-right, but when push comes to shove, they’re all happy brothers in arms. The unifying thread is their utter contempt for “feminism” and “SJWs”, their target is anyone who dares to take the stance that women deserve basic human rights and dignity, and just like the anonymous trolls of 4chan, their method is to completely break down the capacity for self-reflection until someone can only lash out in anger.</p><p>They become furious at their video games daring to have political statements in them, because otherwise they’d be forced to actually give a shit about <em>something</em>. But they don’t want to give a shit. They just want to exist completely unaware of everything while all their earthly desires are catered to. They want to just succeed as is their entitlement and to disregard the hard questions of what it means to live.</p><p>MRAs are the most puzzling of the bunch, too. They claim a civil rights framework for their ideals, and to their credit, there are too many unfair discriminatory practices harming men in society today. But instead of focusing on making positive changes and liberating themselves from this, they lay the blame squarely on women. It is not the crushing expectation of the patriarchy, it is not the world-sucking engine of capitalism, it is not the relentless rush of endless war that has caused these problems, they say.</p><p>No, it is the <em>women</em> who did this, because they dared to speak up about their mistreatment and spark movements like #MeToo. Rather than focus on the liberation of men from the yoke of the capitalist patriarchy, MRAs would rather spend their time making fun of feminists online. It betrays their true beliefs, which are, of course, dumb ass bullshit.</p><p>Every single one of these groups holds as a core principle that the rise of feminism has harmed men, and only by manipulating and harming women directly, and disrupting the success of women’s movements, can they truly restore men to the place in society they think they have lost.</p><p>The entire concept of masculinity falls apart for them: it can only exist as an already-created Other in relation to women. Their self-worth, their status in society, their emotional capacity, their entire core concept of self entirely revolves around women. And they believe that the only reason women even exist is not as functioning, thinking human beings, but merely as conduits to explore the emotional, physical, and sexual fulfillment of their own desires.</p><p>For each of these groups, gender roles are transactional. The only reason to even speak to a woman is to get what they want (most likely sex), and the only reason a woman would ever even speak to them is because, they have deluded themselves into thinking, that she would want to have sex with him. Or help with their math homework, or whatever. The idea of treating another person, god forbid one of a different gender, as a real human being with feelings is entirely anathema to them because they have chosen a worldview that insists that these genuine connections are impossible.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/525/1*KY8i33kcSwoLKQP9V1ardQ.png" /><figcaption>A Jordan Peterson fan earnestly peddling a nonsense theory for why women are biologically inferior, or something.</figcaption></figure><p>In crafting these ideologies, these men have shut themselves out from the very nature of being human. There is no such thing as genuine emotion or connection anymore, there is only their desire. Previous generations of men with these same emotional issues would have been solitary, confined to only their own thoughts. But modern technology has allowed them to feed on each other and build into frothing extremism. Combine this with the influence of hateful ideologues and you have a near-limitless supply of pissed-off men who will believe anything as long as it lets them not have to think about themselves for even one moment.</p><p>So is the problem with the internet, where this all started? Perhaps, but the internet is so many things to so many people that it can’t be the only answer. Is it maleness, then? Some sort of masculinity crisis can certainly be inferred here, if only as much as the general crisis of modern capitalism that every man and woman (and other) alike must slog through.</p><p>All this is crucial to understanding the way that current and future generations of men will move through the world. The sphere is expanding. An increasingly larger portion of younger generations will build from the foundations that we laid, and it’s our responsibility to make sure we aren’t destroying them in the process.</p><p>I don’t have an answer for how to stop this. We can be kind. We can try to raise our boys to respect women and to properly express their emotions. We can encourage young men to break out of their shell and pull down their emotional walls. But individual change won’t be enough, it needs to be systemic. And all our institutions and governments are woefully unprepared for that.</p><p>As I write this, news reports are coming in of another school shooting, this one in a middle school in Indiana. To be fair, I don’t know the shooter’s motive, or whether he was connected to or radicalized by any of these particular movements. But it almost doesn’t matter. A young boy tried to kill his classmates. He almost certainly got the idea from the 22 previous school shootings this year alone, and the hundreds of school shootings in recent years. This was not developed in a vacuum; the signs have been there for years, and we probably should have seen this coming. It may be bullshit, but it’s real, and it’s dangerous, and it will probably get worse before it gets better.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8c4a2d781936" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Praise the Ancestors”]]></title>
            <link>https://alexjricard.medium.com/praise-the-ancestors-6c8d37a03305?source=rss-93dc22ad3304------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6c8d37a03305</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[marvel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[black-panther]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ancestry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Ricard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 13 Mar 2018 00:10:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-13T00:10:02.218Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>This post contains spoilers for Black Panther.</em></strong></p><p>With those words uttered in solemn reverence, the most sacred of all Wakanda’s rituals begins. After being crowned King (or Queen), or deemed otherwise worthy to bear the title of Black Panther, he (or she) is fed the juices of the heart-shaped herb, and then they are completely buried underneath the Earth.</p><p>This particular aspect of the ritual is fascinating: as shown in the film, it doesn’t matter where or with what material they are buried. The most important part is to make sure they are wholly covered, even for just a few inches. They are shut off from the existing world and transported into a new place, their senses completely removed from the world around them, their very souls sent into a space of no-time and no-space, all at once with all-time and all-space. And standing before them, as far as the eye can see, are all their ancestors, greeting them in love and in history.</p><p>Here’s where things get interesting.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*-WFEYd3ywuRPO5dp." /><figcaption>Praise the ancestors. [image: T’challa enters the ancestral plane.]</figcaption></figure><p>Yep, here it is: my entry in the Black Panther Thinkpiece Expanded Universe. It’s been a few weeks since Ryan Coogler’s masterpiece was released, and even still the questions it poses have continued to build. It has set the world on fire.</p><p>There’s so much to talk about: the movie’s boldly political stance against American imperialism, its groundbreaking casting and representation, its tightly-written plot, jaw-dropping visuals, and stunning action. All of this combined to turn this film into more than just the latest box office smash: Black Panther<em> </em>is something resembling a true Cultural Moment.</p><p>The true star of the film is its setting. Wakanda is an unimaginably advanced utopia, equal parts tradition and futurism, ritual and rebellion, past and future swirling around each other.</p><p>Of course, Wakanda is fictional, so far as we know. It doesn’t exist in the real world, and therefore it will always be disconnected from the material reality of real-world history. It is precisely this history that drives the very identity of Wakanda itself: it is a nation untouched by centuries of colonialism. It’s the eternal question of what “might have been”, had history not so brutally intervened.</p><p>There are even real-world analogs for it: Mansa Musa’s 14th-century Mali empire, which famously nearly collapsed the economies of entire nations due to their overwhelming wealth. However, as centuries passed, that history has been lost to time. The image of Africa, as <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/news/daily-comment/black-panther-and-the-invention-of-africa">Jelani Cobb argues in the <em>New Yorker </em></a><em>, </em>as something lesser and without merit is just as much a fictionalized image applied to history as anything from Marvel Studios. Wakanda is no more imaginary than any of the crude stereotypes Westerners often apply to their mental image of “Africa”.</p><p>This kind of ignorance is nothing new, of course. It was the model for centuries of Eurocentric cultural dominance in the West. It wasn’t just Africa they demonized: in a quest for absolute, sheer power, the Americas were also destroyed under the same boot. In a way, this is the ancestry of America itself: a nation presumably built as a land of freedom, justice, and equality, but one who really only continues the same colonialist, Eurocentric hegemony of its predecessors. Like father, like son.</p><p>Which brings me back to ancestors. Black Panther is full of them. Ancestors are the incarnations of history itself. They are connections to pasts we can only imagine, bearers of wisdom and lessons. Without an understanding of ancestry, we lose innumerable links to our pasts and future, and without those links we cannot understand ourselves.</p><p>In America, we discourage that ancestral connection that most world cultures treasure. To be American is to be your own, individualistic, separated and cut off from history. Move halfway across the country and start something new, and then your children will move further away when it’s their time to leave. That’s the text of the “dream” we keep insisting makes us exceptional.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/493/0*sLcuUQhrSvs3mTjm.jpg" /><figcaption>Could anything be more American than this? Credit: Life Magazine, 1937 [image: A line of African-American men, women, and children line up, discomfort and misery on their faces. Just behind them is large billboard with a white family smiling in a car. The words “World’s Highest Standard of Living” and “There’s No Way Like The American Way” are displayed on the billboard.]</figcaption></figure><p>This same American context lends us the ability to disconnect our present selves with the questions of history at large, as a nation. The second half of the 21st century brought rapid changes into the postwar era. Cultural norms were forged that we suddenly accepted as Eternal, Natural, and Correct, despite all of history’s evidence to the contrary. Everything we define as quintessentially American: nuclear families with 2.3 children, suburban living, teenage rebellion, crazy college years, white-collar office jobs. The institutions of cars and television and highways and the Internet, shaping the world into something radically <em>different</em> than anything our ancestors could have ever imagined.</p><p>We imagine the Present as something wholly separated from the Past, but every moment of now is built on what came before, and will be the foundation for what will come next.</p><p>Wakanda’s sacred ritual, ultimately then, is simple: in order to gain the powers and leadership to bring their people into the future, the new Black Panther must first confront their ancestors and therefore history itself. Whether they died only recently or centuries ago. They must face the sins and the blessings of all of history, and take that burden forward.</p><p>The film’s culminating conflict between estranged cousins T’challa and Erik Killmonger is also borne of ancestry. It is an echo through time of the exact conflict their fathers had decades ago. N’jobu wanted Wakanda to stop hiding and enter the wider world. To correct the injustices of history. His brother T’chaka disagreed. And in that apartment in Oakland, it ended in the same tragedy. Like fathers, like sons.</p><p>And of course, ancestry is the crux of Killmonger’s haunting final words, certain to ring through T’challa’s ears (and everyone in the audience’s ears), for the rest of his life: “Just bury me in the ocean with my ancestors who jumped from the ships. Because they knew death was better than bondage.”</p><p>The contrasts between them are deepened here: these ancestors are not even shared in his connection to T’challa, but of his other side, his mother’s family. Barely mentioned in the film, yet a fundamental part of who he is nonetheless. Killmonger is a child of two wildly different, simultaneous realities: glory and nobility on one hand, and unimaginable suffering on the other.</p><p>My own ancestry bears these scars, too. I have ancestors who were slaves, ancestors who were slave owners, ancestors who once freed amassed whole plantations to themselves. That history is embedded in me in ways I can’t begin to understand, and is something I have only recently begun to interface with, after researching some of my own family history.</p><p>As I watched the movie, I felt the conflict between T’challa and Killmonger reverberate within myself. The film masterfully layers the kind of complex, knotty emotions that come from contemplating history. The sheer joy of connection to culture and history, and the unimaginable pain of it being taken away. The pride of your ancestors being noble heroes and leaders, and the shame of seeing their mistakes brought to bear.</p><p>How can anyone become a good leader, or indeed as T’chaka insists, a good man, knowing they have the power to make the world better and still refusing to? How can anyone sleep at night knowing their safety and comfort rests on the backs of many millennia of suffering?</p><p>But you don’t need to have that kind of personal connection to understand Black Panther, or the way ancestry affects our lives today. Everyone in this world has ancestors, whether or not we know them. Some of these ancestors were heroes. Some were monsters. Some led lives of privilege and wealth, some led lives of suffering. They loved, they laughed, they cried, they died. They were human, and their stories are written in everything that makes us ourselves.</p><p>At the end of the film, T’challa is left with a decision to make: continue the isolationist policies of his father and ancestors, or burn everything down to remake it anew, like Erik and his own father. But the correct answer comes from Nakia. The answer is not to destroy the past, nor to hide away in it forever. But to take the lessons of history and use them to build a brighter future.</p><p>What we learn from our ancestors can be wise or destructive. And our ambitions into the future can be revolutionary or horrific. We must act in the present, then, with deep compassion and love.</p><p>And it’s not just ancestors we need to listen to. Just as Black Panther was over and the credits rolled, I turned my phone back on (I promise, I was just checking to see how many post-credits scenes there were!). The first thing I saw on social media was an avalanche of posts, of young black boys and girls, proudly declaring themselves to be the Black Panther, or one the Dora Milaje. All the turbulent emotion that had been building for the whole film spilled over, and I wept in my seat thinking of them. Weeks later, as I type this, I still get teary-eyed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/990/0*dTnQh-xVvZRHIB__." /><figcaption>Praise the future. Credit @asiko_artist on Instagram. [image: Several images of young children recreating the costumes and makeup of the Black Panther cast.]</figcaption></figure><p>For the first time in these young lives, they saw an onscreen representation of themselves, and they felt empowered. These kids will grow up with heroes that look and act like them, and they will create more in turn, and they will carve new legacies into a world that has marginalized them.</p><p>We are not simply bound to old traditions. But we should not simply discard them, either. Like T’challa and Nakia, and Wakanda itself, we must find a way to embrace both, and in so doing build a foundation to make this world brighter and better. So that some day, decades or centuries into the future, we can be the wise ancestors of some generation dealing with whatever the future brings. Tradition and futurism, ritual and rebellion, past and future swirling around each other.</p><p>Praise the ancestors. Praise the future.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6c8d37a03305" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Comes After The Trump Era™?]]></title>
            <link>https://alexjricard.medium.com/what-comes-after-the-trump-era-7828a33cffa1?source=rss-93dc22ad3304------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7828a33cffa1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[united-states]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Ricard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Jan 2018 05:50:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-12T05:55:33.789Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/777/1*mXWUiu9I5Ll5-m8OkNNBEA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Perhaps the most striking aspect of The Trump Era™ has been the way we’ve collectively, as a nation, been borne to the edge of our wits by the rambling, vulgar man technically occupying the White House. 2017 was a hell of a year, and so was 2016 before it. And rather than things looking bright, we’re barely two weeks into this year and we’re already hearing racist rants. This isn’t just a shift in status quo, this <em>is </em>the status quo. It’s a whole era.</p><p>So when did The Trump Era™ begin for you? Was it on January 20th, 2017, during an inauguration soaked with slurred words, crude misunderstandings of the basics of presidential etiquette, and hilariously erroneous crowd-size claims?</p><p>Was it on November 8th, 2016? The evening we all sank further and further into despair? I remember dashing home to flip on the TV, trying to watch seven stations at once. We were hopeful then, of course. Hillary Clinton was far from anyone’s idea of a perfect candidate, but in the face of the looming maw of destruction that was Big Boy Donny Trump, it was the least we could hope for. I was looking forward to never have to hear the words “Donald Trump” again, and things would just quiet down.</p><p>Everything started to turn south at about 8 pm, when Pennsylvania was called. I remember thinking then that this was it. Trump had taken Pennsylvania and he was going to rout the rust belt states and pull off the upset. My fiancée and I simply sat there in shock. Our cat got so worried about us that we had to tearfully explain that she would never understand why we were sad.</p><p>But that wasn’t the beginning of this era, either. Maybe The Trump Era™ began on July 19th, when he officially accepted the RNC’s nomination. Or was it even June 16th, 2015, the day he announced his campaign?</p><p>These last couple years have been rough, to say the least. But this is not some idyllic alternate-history piece imagining The Paradise That Would Be had Hillary Clinton won the presidency. Or Bernie, for that matter.</p><p>The truth is that The Trump Era™ did not begin on any of those dates. It’s been here for a long time, and is so ingrained in American history that we forget to see past it.</p><p>The Trump Era™ was the racist backlash against the nation’s first black president. The Trump Era™ was the decades of war and war crimes perpetuated for decades by administrations of both major parties. To pretend like the problem started with Trump is woefully short-sighted and ahistorical. It’s not Russian meddling. It’s as American as Black Friday doorbuster trampling deaths.</p><p>This isn’t to say that things haven’t changed, though. They have. We didn’t have to worry about nuclear war under Obama or Bush or Clinton. The lingering back-of-your-mind terror that Big Boy Donny might incite nuclear winter with a careless Tweet is a new phenomenon. His recent declaration of how he is, like, really smart just further underscores the era of madness we are surrounded by. It used to be a given that the President was like, really smart. But now we’re not so certain.</p><p>Are we worried that there is a warmongering, blustering, white nationalist, xenophobic fool in the White House? Of course. But most American presidents throughout history haven’t been much different. We’ve been a white nationalist country from our inception. Hundreds of years of slavery and genocide and Jim Crow and internment and deportation and cruelty and regime change were all carried out under our proud flag.</p><p>So when you think about The Trump Era™, think about not just the specifics of who he is, or what he’s done, but upon the mindsets that he’s built on. The long, sordid history. The stuff that’s been festering for decades or generations or centuries. Trump would be nothing without the American people, after all. He’s a fool, a charlatan, an idiot, a complete mockery of a human who can’t walk up stairs. He likes his steak well-done with ketchup, for crying out loud!</p><p>And yet, millions out there have chosen him as their champion. And the morning after the election, we woke up like a hangover and looked at each other, wearily and warily, as if remembering something about ourselves we’d forgotten.</p><p>The only way we can move beyond The Trump Era™ is to view it in the full context of this kind of history, and of the very real struggles that we face in building a more just world. And then we must build that world.</p><p>How do we do that? We would like to pretend, at least, that we can get past our differences and work together. The answer for all our problems is not in one party or the other, but in <em>consensus</em>, in bipartisanship, in collaboration, in compromise. At least, that’s the popular idea.</p><p>You see this reflected in every politician’s rhetoric. Ever since this political cycle started how often have we heard about how “we are more similar than we are different”, or maybe “what unites us is more than what divides us”, or maybe “we are stronger together”?</p><p>In all of this, it seems there’s a certain veneer of respectability and professionalism to which we intend to aspire as a society. We want things to go back to normal. Presidents must be “presidential”, politicians must be professional, and we have certain rules of decorum. If The Trump Era™ has been anything, it’s a time in which those rules have been dismantled for a naked show of bigotry and crudeness. But even those rules were always papering over the truth.</p><p>Consider the recent elevation of Republican politicians such as Senators Bob Corker, John McCain, or Jeff Flake by well-meaning Democrats. These senators, and others such as Susan Collins, are considered great models of moderation, bipartisanship, compromise. These senators plead for “decency” and “decorum” while simultaneously decimating the healthcare system, enforcing a militarized police state, and crippling the working class for the benefit of the wealthy. Most or all of them are still anti-LGBT, anti-choice, and would absolutely be in favor of a GOP-imposed theocracy if only the President wasn’t such a mean tweeter.</p><p>What’s the use of decency at all if we’re going to use it to mean pretty words instead of good actions? How can anyone say this is decent or good or just? Bipartisan compromise is an empty symbol of the kind of politics that never made any real-world sense.</p><p>The opposition to Trump cannot be merely a rebuke of his crudeness, but of the core of his very politics. It’s not enough to wish for a “sane” Republican, a “competent” Republican — because by definition, a competent Republican would only be more effective in curtailing civil rights than even Trump has been.</p><p>The problem isn’t limited to Republicans, either. Plenty of Democrats are completely on board with the massive expansion of imperialism and surveillance states, and yet we have to like them more because they’re only slightly less evil.</p><p>We must end The Trump Era™ as soon as possible. But now we’re talking about inertia. This isn’t just about the fool who will take himself down, but about how we as a country and a globe will move on from this present moment. How will we build from this, and how do we prevent this from happening again in the future, when someone much more sophisticated in their cruelty comes around and tries the same thing again? Someone who uses much prettier words for much worse ends?</p><p>Some things won’t change until we make them. The Trump Era™ will continue no matter who’s in the White House until we create a fundamental, radical shift of the project of American ideology. Every single one of us will have to change and be changed, and when the future comes it will come for everyone equally.</p><p>There is no “status quo” we can somehow return to. The status quo of 2018 builds from the status quo of 2017 from the status quo of 2016 and on and on as you go back years and decades. Every word and moment is witnessed by hundreds of millions of people, each with their own dreams and aspirations. Everything is changing, it always does, and it’s up to us to make that change.</p><p>So what does the future look like, after The Trump Era™ has ended? That’s the question we must ask ourselves every day and that’s the goal we must work towards. What happens <em>next?</em></p><p>There’s reason for hope. And reason for despair, too. It’s basically a 50/50 split on whether we become some fully-automated post-work utopia or a fascist hellscape by the end of my lifetime. There are thriving youth movements of young far-left and far-right activists, each plotting their strategies for the long-term goals of the next few decades. Battle lines are being drawn, candidates are being recruited, and everything we thought we knew about politics is about to enter a whole radical new stage. Soon enough, even bipartisan consensus, that noble aspiration we thought we could be, will be rendered untenable.</p><p>So it’s utterly crucial that we continue the momentum of change beyond the Trump presidency, beyond the American project. We’ve crossed the threshold now where we can never go back to normal, because there never was such thing as normal.</p><p>An Austin-area radio host I used to listen to, Sean Adams (RIP), would sign off every broadcast with the words: “Do something good for someone today, because the people who make the world worse aren’t taking a day off.”</p><p>That’s the work ahead of us. It starts now. With human connections and radical, unconditional empathy. Take some time to be good to one another, to stand up for one another. Catch someone when they fall. They will catch you. We can’t hope for a reality star, or a talk-show host, or a politician to swoop down from on high to save us. We can only do it ourselves. That’s the only way.</p><p>We can make an America where we really, truly help each other up. Where your worth as a human is prized and respected, and you are loved. That’s an America we keep saying we believe in. But we’ve never seen it before. Not yet.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7828a33cffa1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nostalgia Is Not What You Want]]></title>
            <link>https://alexjricard.medium.com/on-star-wars-fans-and-nostalgia-or-boba-fett-sucks-e066b79ad184?source=rss-93dc22ad3304------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e066b79ad184</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[star-wars]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nostalgia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fandom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-last-jedi]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex Ricard]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 20 Dec 2017 22:13:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-12-21T00:04:23.082Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>This post contains spoilers for Star Wars: The Last Jedi.</em></strong></p><p>It’s December, and you know what that means: Star Wars season. Every year we see a new rush of anticipation. What’s next for the Skywalker Saga? How are Rey, Finn and the gang? Will Jar Jar Binks ever make an appearance to redeem himself?</p><p>All of these are worthy questions for any fan of the franchise. But sometimes we can take it even further. What does it all mean? What are the connections and clues to find out? What mysteries can we solve? All this speculation is so commonplace today, in a post-Marvel Cinematic Universe world. Everything is connected to everything else. That’s what being a fan is all about.</p><p>So we scour the internet and check all the clues and make all the connections. It’s how these major media franchises have consolidated their dominance. There is a whole massive industry around reminding people of the previous movies in their franchises and cashing in on fan theories. It’s no coincidence that the rise of sci-fi and fantasy and other “nerdy media” has coincided with the rise of the Internet.</p><p>And so pop culture has become infinitely more complex and interconnected to rise alongside our expectations. Rey <em>must</em> be a Skywalker, see all the clues. Modern fandom, with all its bells and whistles, encourages this. It’s no coincidence JJ Abrams was chosen to helm both the recent relaunches of Star Wars and Star Trek. This kind of complex clue-baiting fanservice is his specialty.</p><p>It’s all designed for nostalgia. Using callbacks and clues to make you remember media from the past. To generate a <em>fandom</em> and manufacture a whole cultural phenomenon. All you need is the right amount of fanservice and you will be wildly successful. We see it now with the revivals of Ghostbusters and Full House and Jurassic Park and Independence Day and Twin Peaks and X-Files and Will and Grace and everything else. Nostalgia is a hell of a drug.</p><p>But here’s the thing about nostalgia: memories change. We don’t actually remember what we think we do. Sometimes we create false memories. Sometimes we forget details and paper them over with our emotional state at the time. And sometimes our own memories are replaced by those of the cultural memes created by social media and our interactions with others.</p><p>There are smarter words than these to be said about the demise of the cultural metanarrative, and how its absence allows for millions of fractured misunderstandings. But it can simply be stated thus: It’s not the movie you remember. It’s your childhood memory of watching the movie.</p><p>In regards to Star Wars, this was especially evident when The Phantom Menace came out and reaction was… mixed, to say the least. I’ll never argue that the Star Wars prequels are some masterpieces of form and nuance and subtlety. But unlike the original trilogy, which are very formulaic, basic stories told well, they had an ambition for complex stories that fell completely flat in execution. We forget that, because our nostalgia for the old movies overrides their flaws.</p><p>Talk about Star Wars “getting political”: the prequel trilogy is a story about the failure of normal democratic institutions to check power on a tyrant, and how capitalists collude with state power to exploit natural resources and enslave entire planets for the creation of a neverending fascist war machine. How liberal institutions like the Jedi or the Senate become complicit when faced against bad faith actors like Sidious, who will lie about anything to gain power.</p><p>You could be forgiven for missing all this, when the movies themselves decided to focus on how sand gets everywhere. And those pesky midi-chlorians.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*V-tBUg0YNYpKtgqa.JPG" /><figcaption>You ever hear about how much I hate sand? It’s not a story the Sith would ever tell you…</figcaption></figure><p>In the face of nostalgia, of the brilliantly constructed childhood memories of Star Wars, did The Phantom Menace even have a chance? Of course not. And especially when we saw a whiny kid, a terrible new character with an ear-piercing voice, and the worst sin of all: midi-chlorians.</p><p>Midi-chlorians have been derided and denounced by fans of all kinds. Culturally we have built so many memes around them. It ruins the movies, we say, it ruins the Force. It’s the epitome of a creator running unchecked, forcing his bad ideas on the world. By reducing the cosmic mystery of the Force into something biological and physical. The Force isn’t an energy field, it’s actually created by midi-chlorians? The backlash to this has been cited as precedent over and over again for the reason art and media shouldn’t go into unnecessary backstory. You might make the midi-chlorian mistake.</p><p><a href="http://www.vulture.com/2017/12/star-wars-prequels-midi-chlorians-defense.html">Except… there’s nothing in the movie itself to justify this kind of outrage</a>. So forget everything you know, or thought you knew, about midi-chlorians. Forget all the memes and go back to the source. What are they? They are just beings that are attracted to beings with high propensity for the Force in the same way moths are attracted to light, or how elite athletes have higher levels of muscle density. It’s a biological process.</p><p>Despite common fan misconceptions, the midi-chlorians were never presented as “creating” the force, nor as simple indications that having more midi-chlorians makes you more powerful. It was just a name given to a biological process, in the same way we call happiness “serotonin”.</p><p>Midi-chlorians are similar enough to, and named after, human mitochondria. The “powerhouse of the cell” which quite literally provides our cells with life in ways we can’t describe. Mitochondria even have separate DNA from the rest of our bodies. We may as well call them mysterious beings in our cells which connect us to life and the universe. With a connection like this, it could make perfect sense for the Star Wars universe.</p><p>But the outrage about midi-chlorians isn’t about what was actually stated in the movie. It’s about the false idea that people think they remember from the movie. And that can make all the difference.</p><p>Now, their inclusion in the movie was an awkward and inelegant way to try to explain things, and certainly added nothing relevant to the story nor the world at large. In that sense, they are a bad plot point, but just that: a plot point. Mentioned once and never again. But from the point of view of a “fan”, it’s some cultural affront to what you hold dear, as if George Lucas himself had personally betrayed you and millions of others. As if the “fans” are the ones in control of the narrative.</p><p>And it’s not just midi-chlorians. Fans everywhere have been in an uproar for years about the end of Revenge of the Sith, when Padme dies at the end of a “broken heart”. That’s completely ridiculous. Except… did she? Is that what happens in the actual movie itself? Retrozap’s Joseph Tavino went viral a few years ago with his <a href="https://www.retrozap.com/padme-didnt-die-of-a-broken-heart/">exhaustive analysis</a> of the scene.</p><p>But once again: nowhere in the text of the movie, or its subtext, has anything to do with Padme dying of a broken heart. Fan outrage was manufactured once again, not by any poor storytelling decisions in the movie itself, but by a narrative <em>about</em> the movie that fans decided to tell. They wanted their nostalgia to be untouched, so invented a story that meant they no longer had to engage with what the art was saying.</p><p>Not even the Original Trilogy was immune to this. Fans have been rewriting Star Wars lore from the beginning. We all remember being in awe of the coolest character in Empire Strikes Back, right? Boba Fett.</p><p>Boba Fett sucks. He was a chump who died like a chump, who had a grand total of three lines of dialogue and did maybe one cool thing in Empire before being accidentally knocked over by a blind guy in handcuffs and eaten by a sarlacc.</p><p>But that’s not what happens, right? Boba Fett was cool! He had a cool design and ship! In complete defiance of anything that was shown onscreen, his legend grew and grew. The Expanded Universe capitalized on this popularity and turned him into an elite leader of a whole planet of Spartan-esque (Halo or 300, take your pick) elite warriors who can even beat Jedi in combat. The movies, even, built up this legend even more: Boba Fett became the center of the famous, mysterious Clone Wars.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/0*Q3icE1L9q_isax1-.jpg" /><figcaption>Boba Fett sucks.</figcaption></figure><p>Nope. None of this is supported in the original text, or the established character and universe. The character was introduced in the Holiday Special, for crying out loud! The whole narrative of Boba Fett’s character came from the mind of fans telling stories <em>about</em> Star Wars, not from anything in the original work. He became a legend.</p><p>But that’s fine. It’s okay for things to be expanded, to take on lives of their own, to exceed their original potential. No work of fiction should be confined to its original ambitions. If nothing else, art exists in a constant balance with its real-world impact. It’s near-impossible for it to be in a vacuum. If Boba Fett is popular, of course they’ll put him in more media. There was real potential there. But honestly, he still sucks. In trying so hard to make Boba Fett cool, we turned him into a hypermasculine parody. It’s kind of embarrassing. We allowed Boba Fett’s legend to overtake anything else about him. And how can anything face up to the expectations of being a legend?</p><p>Which brings us finally to JJ Abrams’ new trilogy. The biggest criticism of The Force Awakens is that it was just a remake of the original, that it played it too safe — of course, Rogue One was much better and unique. But was it?</p><p>It could be argued that of the two, Rogue One is actually the remake. Using the same kind of reductionist logic lobbied at The Force Awakens, we can build a narrative: Rogue One is the story of a young child witnessing their family murdered by the Empire, who gets taken in by a Force mystic with ties to the Rebellion, witnesses the Death Star’s power of destruction, whose mentor sacrifices himself to save her. She teams up with a weird old mystic, a morally gray pilot, and a hairy guy, goes on an ill-advised rescue mission, and then convinces the Rebellion pilots to go on a suicide mission as the Death Star approaches. In fact, she’d have failed had her pilot friend not swooped in at the end of it and saved the mission. The only difference is that they die in the end.</p><p>Fans use this kind of reductionist logic all the time. But if you squint hard enough, any movie can be deemed a remake of any other movie. By casting superficial analyses like this, fans can so thoroughly miss the point of any work of art. If you insist with all your might, of course The Force Awakens is just a remake of A New Hope. Of course midi-chlorians created the Force, of course Padme died of a broken heart. This is the contortion of logic fans must perform, if they intend on controlling the narrative. They want to be satiated, comforted, safe in their fanservice.</p><p>When you commit so hard to making something fit into the box you already arbitrarily decided it would fit into, your ability to interpret art and society in itself, as free from outside influence as possible, is compromised.</p><p>All of this makes The Last Jedi’s commitment to radically reshifting everything so refreshing. It is not a movie “for the fans”, at all. Forget what you thought you knew. Just like Luke says about the Jedi Order, fans should not bind themselves to these old ideas and old thoughts. Wipe everything from your eyes and look clearly. The Legend Of Luke Skywalker, the great meme that has been spreading both in the fictional universe and our own real one, is a narrative that we created in our own minds, independent of evidence.</p><p>Fans can insist that “Luke would never do <em>that</em>”, but he did, and he absolutely would. He’s been struggling with the Dark Side from the very beginning, and even if you take offense to a great hero hiding out away from the universe as a hermit, he is merely following in the footsteps of Yoda and Obi-Wan as their pupils turned to evil, too. The cultural legend of Luke as an upstanding, pure moral hero is a pure fan creation. His whole arc in the film is about dealing in the truth, not our papered-over nostalgia of what we think we know.</p><p>Every single character individually struggles with this conflict, and the film itself too: what is it, if not a direct reaction to its own past as the heir to the largest cultural phenomenon in the world?</p><p>Even the questions that are raised by this sequel trilogy are uniformly snuffed. Who is Snoke? Where did the First Order come from? Who cares. The movie doesn’t care, and nor should we. The answer is in front of our noses all along, anyway. They came from the places fascists come from in real life: pretenders to glory, obsessed with their own sanitized image of a past, vowing, in some respect or another, to Make the Empire Great Again. As if it had ever been the way they imagined in the first place. A false memory, a meme, propped up by nostalgia instead of truth.</p><p>Some fans may be upset by that, but it was the only way forward, wasn’t it? No more theorizing, no more clues, no more mystery. No more boxes to put what we think we know in. There is only truth, and what you do with it. Nothing real could ever match up to the impossible infinity of imagination. And if you breathlessly anticipate your perfectly constructed fan theory, and inevitably the story doesn’t deliver, that’s not the story’s fault — it’s yours.</p><p>Kylo Ren’s mission to kill the past and destroy its failures is positioned directly opposite Rey’s mission to learn from the past’s lessons. But in the end, neither is the way forward. Success and failure, joy and pain, hope and fear, all must be passed on. And it is up to the next generation we pass on to figure out what that will look like.</p><p>If and when Rey forms the New Jedi Order, it will be something of a mix of old and new. So we must remember to see clearly into the past, take it for what it was, and pass its success and failures onto the future. It’s how we find our place in the world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*sZuymt53S7HG-bNH.jpg" /><figcaption>“Read them, have you?”</figcaption></figure><p>Nostalgia can give you so much. Being a fan means being part of a community, as engaged as you could ever want. But we need to be more than just a fan engaging with some piece of pop culture. These are the stories we will tell the future. The myths we pass down. Star Wars was around before many of us were born, and it will certainly be around for far longer than we live. If this Disney-Fox merger goes through, we might be on Episode 92 by the time the century ends. Star Wars will impact human history in ways no single real person ever could. Centuries from now, it will have an impact.</p><p>So if we are to find our place in the world, we must critically engage with those meaningful aspects of our culture. Simply waiting for nostalgia will never give that to us. It’s the only way we can grow, and it’s the whole point of telling stories. Art, music, film, religion, and yes, Star Wars, all revolve around this point.</p><p>So be a fan. Enjoy all the narratives you want. But don’t let yourself get suckered in by some expectation of what you think it should be. Your fandom should not be a straitjacket, a rigid Order, but a balance, a force ebbing and adding to your life. That’s what it means to grow up. To look forward, not just back. Knowledge must be used in clarity, for truth. Not to prop up old nostalgia.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e066b79ad184" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>