<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ali F. on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ali F. on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@alicat812?source=rss-16b137ade8e8------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 01:30:46 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@alicat812/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Affordable Care Act and Preexisting Conditions:]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@alicat812/the-affordable-care-act-and-preexisting-conditions-a312a3a3a1b4?source=rss-16b137ade8e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a312a3a3a1b4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[preexisting-conditions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aca]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ali F.]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Jun 2018 20:01:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-11T20:01:16.016Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A Policy Analysis</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZGzYxmk2lFfgpnfEBxc0Ww.jpeg" /></figure><p>Abstract</p><p>Americans have placed a greater emphasis on health since the early twentieth century, beginning with Eugenics (Crawford, 2006) and the first public health programs (Haeder &amp; Weimer, 2015) and gaining visibility and political relevance through the current time. While most developed and industrialized countries have recognized the right to health care and have implemented universal access for their residents, the United States remains an outlier in its beliefs and values and in its practices. The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, passed in 2010 and implemented in full in 2014, was an attempt to nudge the country towards a more universal system by expanding affordable access to better quality health care on a national level. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) is still controversial, but one of its three main components — the prohibition on insurers of using adverse selection to leave out people with preexisting conditions — has become a widespread value that has hindered all efforts to undo the law. This paper aims to explain the significant role of affordable, accessible health care, and to explore how, based on ideology, health can be viewed as a right or a privilege. By comparing the U.S. health care system and its outcomes to those of similar nations, and utilizing already-existing philosophy and legal precedents, the author will evaluate the success of the ACA and make an argument for expansion of the policy to a form of universal health care.</p><p><em>Keywords: </em>ACA, health care, preexisting condition</p><p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>For the purposes of health insurance coverage, a preexisting condition exclusion is defined as “a limitation or exclusion of benefits relating to a condition based on the fact that the condition was present before the date of enrollment for coverage, whether or not any medical advice, diagnosis, care, or treatment was recommended or received before that date” (ACA Section 2704). The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act contains several provisions prohibiting insurance companies from discriminating against a potential enrollee based on health status or evidence of insurability. Before the enactment of the ACA, Preexisting Condition Exclusions were outright denials of coverage, or exclusion of specific benefits, most often those related to the condition (See Appendix A for a list of common deniable conditions, medications, and occupations). The ACA also prohibited lifetime and annual limits and rescissions of policies, both of which were other common practices used to keep individuals with high health care costs out of the market. The legislation itself described the need for regulatory action and provided estimates on how many people would be affected and how much the regulations would cost. The overarching goal of the ACA was to provide health insurance to as many individuals as possible by addressing the social problems of inequity of access and affordability, and therefore significant disparities between populations. The policies regarding preexisting conditions in particular sought to protect the most vulnerable Americans, who “incur substantial medical expenses due to serious medical condition, from financial devastation” (Section 2712). The beneficiaries of these policies were not only individuals who were already suffering from illness, injury, or disability, but were more likely to be low-income and of an ethnic minority. The prohibition was also meant specifically to benefit women, who could have been discriminated against if they were pregnant or ever had any intention of becoming pregnant, and survivors of domestic violence. By 2009 when the legislation was being written, the majority of states had already enacted laws regarding treating domestic violence and sexual assault as preexisting conditions, but most insurance companies did not take that into their own hands early on. Insurance companies do a cost-benefit analysis when considering new enrollees, and individuals who are likely to incur high costs because they will require frequent treatment are often not worth the cost. Van Wormer and Link (2016) stated that cost-benefit analyses leave the human aspect out of policies, and some insurance companies eventually came to see that leaving the human aspect out of health care made little sense and was increasingly cruel. A State Farm Spokeswoman told a news reporter, “We realized our position was based on gut feelings, not hard numbers… we became aware that we were part of the reason a woman and her children might not leave an abuser. They were afraid they’d lose their insurance. And we wanted no part of that” (Grim, 2011, p. 5). This change of heart was replicated in most states, but a few remained that saw no reason to make any changes. Then the ACA mandated it.</p><p><strong>Historical Context</strong></p><p>Shared state-federal programs, particularly regarding health care, have always been met with opposition and difficulty with implementation (Haeder &amp; Weimer, 2015). As a Federalist country where devolution is often the preferred mechanism for policy action, the U.S. has a history of fighting itself in its quest for progress. States are seen as “laboratories for democracies,” and respecting each state’s sovereignty acts as a “political counterweight to charges of federal takeover” (Haeder &amp; Weimer, 2015, p. 283). From the Chamberlain-Kahn Act in 1918 to the Trade Act in 2002, shared governance public health care problems have varied widely between states, with some states eager and willing to take on responsibility, and other states resisting at every turn. The variety in implementation and governance among states also leads to problematic disparities and inequities. Still, each new policy is a little more progressive than the one before it, and each one eventually gets implemented in every state, though the process does not seem to get easier (Haeder &amp; Weimer, 2015). Even when the policy is responding to a direct social need, like the Chamberlain-Kahn Act responded to the rampant spread of venereal disease, it is still met with resistance. The ACA, a legislative birthchild of President Barack Obama, was timely in a number of ways. First, President Obama was elected during the Great Recession, and as people lost their jobs, they lost health insurance. Secondly, the election of President Obama seemed to mark a significant shift in the country; perhaps by electing their first African-American president, Americans were signaling that they were ready for a new kind of progress. After all, candidate Obama’s selling point was “Change.” Who better to make the push towards universal health care than the new, most popular ever, black president? He even decided to base his policy on successful Republican legislation, looking at what had worked for Mitt Romney in Massachusetts when, as governor, he had expanded health care to all but four percent of residents in the state (Claxton, Pollix, &amp; Levitt, 2012).</p><p><strong>Policy Implementation</strong></p><p>Policy of the magnitude of the ACA — which includes legislative components belonging to the Departments of Health and Human Services, Labor, and the Internal Revenue Service — require an even more gradual implementation period than other laws. Because the ACA was overhauling the health system and tax system and had effects on employer-sponsored plans and individual plans alike, transition periods with temporary programs were created. One such program was the Preexisting Condition Insurance Program (PCIP), which was the federal version of state high-risk pools. High-risk pools were groups of eligible individuals with preexisting conditions who could not otherwise gain health insurance. The idea of pooling these individuals together was to help spread out the cost of care amongst those who use it most, instead of having healthy people who rarely utilize insurance pay higher premiums for people who are sick. The problem with high-risk pools, it seems, is obvious: a small group of people who are charged more for health insurance because they use it more often cannot provide a meaningful balance of cost-sharing. Many individuals were priced out of such pools because they could not afford the premiums. In an attempt to mitigate this challenge, the PCIP limited eligibility to individuals with preexisting conditions who had gone without health insurance for six months. Though the federal government allocated billions of dollars for this program, they did not accurately anticipate the costliness of covering sick individuals who had not had access to health care in at least six months. The people who enrolled in PCIP cost x times more than those in traditional state high-risk pools, and the program had to stop accepting enrollees for a time in order to catch up on payments (Pollitz, 2017). Once all provisions of the ACA became active in 2014, PCIP ceased to exist, and individuals with preexisting conditions who were getting insurance through the individual market were not allowed to be denied, charged more, or offered fewer benefits than individuals without such conditions, and between 52 and 133 million people gained coverage (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2017).</p><p><strong>Economic Context</strong></p><p>During the Great Depression in the 1930s, Democratic President Franklin Delano Roosevelt created myriad programs to address the substantial poverty the country was facing. Research has shown that social welfare for the poor, and particularly health care, are not only issues that “belong” to the Democratic Party, but that the public actually trusts Democrats to deal with health care (Hines &amp; Swer, 2015). Moreover, in times of vast and significant need, more and more citizens look to the federal government for assistance. The Great Recession, which started towards the end of President George W. Bush’s second term and sent the global economy into a tailspin as President Barack Obama took office, was a time similar to that of the Great Depression, and President Obama was seen by some as similar to FDR. In fact, this author recalls recent reflections on President Obama’s time in office mentioning hopes that his Stimulus Bill would be like a new New Deal. Though that did not turn out to be the case, the ACA is similar to the Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA) creation in 1933 and the Social Security Act in 1935. Both expanded social welfare and health services in previously unheard of ways. Not only did the prohibition of discrimination based on health status in the ACA help millions of sick people gain affordable health coverage and prevent them from potential bankruptcy, but another major component of the law, the Medicaid expansion, allowed new subsets of the population to gain coverage under Medicaid. Though the Supreme Court ruled that states could not be required to implement the expansion, states that did received billions of dollars from the federal government to assist them, and in turn, saw significant reductions in their number of uninsured individuals. The policy permitted people with incomes of up to 133 percent of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL) to qualify for Medicaid, with a few states opting to go up to 138 percent FPL, and DC offering Medicaid to those with incomes of up to 200 percent FPL. The Fiscal Year 2017 FPL is $12,060 (Haeder &amp; Weimer, 2015). In 31 states, an individual can have an income of up to approximately $13,000 and still qualify for Medicaid, and in DC that number is just over $14,000. The 19 states that have not expanded Medicaid have what is known as the “Medicaid Gap,” where residents whose income is too high to receive Medicaid and too low to qualify for Premium Tax Credits (PTC) in the individual marketplace are left without a way to get health insurance. Fortunately, they are provided with a code to put on their tax forms that waives the fee for not having mandated insurance.</p><p><strong>Economic Equity</strong></p><p>Executive Order 12866 explicitly requires federal agencies to consider “distributive impacts” and “equity” when creating policy. The drafters of the ACA, and the protection of people with preexisting conditions, knew this would result in slight increases in premiums for relatively healthy individuals, while providing a significant increase in health and financial security for those with preexisting conditions. This transfer of costs was considered a meaningful increase in equity (ACA). Additionally, while the costs in the first few years would be substantial, the changes to the health care system were predicted to drastically lower costs and spending over time. Van Wormer and Link (2016) discussed how many policymakers in the U.S. are “penny-wise and dollar-foolish,” implying that they shy away from significant upfront costs without looking at the possible long-term savings. The ACA was not an example of this phenomenon. Instead, stakeholders were willing to take on the costs at the beginning so that money was saved down the road. Furthermore, though much is made out of the country’s deficit and the debt ceiling, especially when it comes time to raise it, the debt ceiling actually serves no functional purpose outside of a partisan context; it will always be raised because it was self-imposed and meaningless. Even if this were not the case, Democrats are more likely to risk increasing the debt in order to expand the welfare state, as a foundational part of their ideology involves assisting those in need. In contrast, when Republicans claim that there is simply no way to pay for programs that assist the poor, they are often veiling the truth. Not only could money given to corporations — corporate welfare — be redistributed more equitably, but often, GOP Congressmembers insist they have to cut funding for something like Temporary Assistance for Newborns and Families (TANF) for something like the Child Health Insurance Program (CHIP) while simultaneously passing a $700 billion spending bill for the military. The question of cost, it seems, depends on the ideology of the individual involved in the discussion.</p><p><strong>Political Context</strong></p><p>Over the last eight years, political party affiliation has morphed into polarization and ideological extremism (Hines &amp; Swers, 2015). While more members of society agree on certain values, especially as baby boomers are replaced by the younger generation, other social issues have become so divisive that people pick a side before they know what they are arguing for or against. Health care seems to be a prudent example of both of these phenomena: in Congress, each respective party is becoming more resolute in its stance; among the public, a clear majority has emerged, one that values affordable access to health care and has come to expect it. This is a somewhat new iteration of a cycle of approval and disapproval regarding the ACA, the role of government in health care, and the matter of health in general. Back in 2009, President Obama took office desiring bipartisanship, and his administration and the Democrats controlling Congress made a concerted effort to gain Republican input and support. In the crafting of the ACA in the Senate, 86 senators (53 Democrats, 33 Republicans) offered 635 amendments. For the portion of the bill that went through reconciliation, 29 Republicans offered 160 amendments. The aforementioned Preexisting Conditions Insurance Plan (PCIP) was a piece of Republican legislation, as high-risk pools have long been the GOP’s preference for providing people with preexisting conditions health insurance (Hines &amp; Swer, 2015). Ultimately, the ACA was passed on a party-line vote without a single Republican, but by that time, it had become extremely political, especially since it was a priority of President Obama. Research has found that there is more opposition from the other party to legislation that is a presidential priority (Hines &amp; Swer, 2015).</p><p><strong>Ideology</strong></p><p>The magnitude of the problem of unaffordable, inaccessible insurance and its related consequences varied depending on ideology and interest. As previously stated, Democrats are dedicated to providing for those in need regardless of who they are representing, and they have long held the reigns on health care. Republican politicians, on the other hand, seem to pay close attention to constituent need, especially when it comes to health care. Those who represent states with high levels of uninsured residents are motivated to actively engage in the issue and to demonstrate they are committed to it, so they have something to show constituents when they later vote against the bill. The higher the percentage of individuals in their states either enrolled in HMOs or lacking health insurance, the more likely a GOP senator is to become more engaged with policy. The opposite, however, holds true for poverty rates. Republican senators from states with higher rates of poverty are less likely to offer amendments to policies. In fact, they sponsor more amendments as the poverty rate declines (Hines &amp; Swer, 2015). Perhaps this is because the Republican view of poverty is based on merit.</p><p><strong>Meaningful Social Action</strong></p><p>Max Weber posited that social action is not simply a matter of behaviors and events patterned and constrained by society’s institutional forms, but that it is also always meaningful, as it is intended and interpreted by others. Social practices are discursive events that convey both denotative and connotative meanings, ones that are implicit, figurative, best seen as narratives, and what he called ‘image repertoires’ (Crawford, 2006). The meaningfulness of social practices are inseparable from lived experience, are contextual and historical, and understanding the meaning depends on interpretation. He also said that meanings have consequences, that they are derivative of social reality, are real because they shape experience, behaviors, institutions, and have ideological effects. Sociologist Robert Crawford (2006) contended that health is an example of a meaningful social practice. In fact, he believed health has become part of our social fabric in a contemporary ‘risk society.’ Personal responsibility for health is, he claimed, an essential condition of individual autonomy and good citizenship. These are values commonly found in conservatives. Crawford said the U.S. has become a health-valuing culture, where people define themselves by how well they succeed or fail in adopting healthy practices and qualities of character believed to support healthy behaviors; they assess others by the same criteria. Therefore, the conventionally understood means of achieving health, and the social state of being ‘healthy,’ are qualities that define the self and become features of modern identity. This health-consciousness about medicine has normalized social life and defines as healthy or unhealthy conditions that fall on one side of the boundaries of constructed norms or the other. Because health is, like everything else, constructed in relation to social structures and experience, it is demonstrated by changing means and practices. This all relates to ideological views of health. By redefining problems of health as problems of lifestyle, people have found a solution to personal responsibility. Since health consciousness represents individual responsibility for economic wellbeing, people have simplified the world around them. If individuals smoke, they get lung cancer; if they do not smoke, they do not get lung cancer. This oversimplification pits the autonomous, self-responsible individual against the careless individual, and the social burden falls on the latter. This view manifests itself in conservatives believing that the virtuous pay to provide medical care for people who lead unhealthy lifestyles. This very scenario presented itself during an early debate over repeal of the ACA. Mo Brooks, a representative from Alabama, was defending a Republican bill that would allow insurers to return to charging more for preexisting conditions. He explained it as allowing insurers to reward “people who lead good lives” (p. 1). He went on to say that the bill:</p><p>…will allow insurance companies to require people with higher health care costs to contribute more to the insurance pool that helps offset those costs, reducing the cost to people who lead good lives. They are healthy; they have done the right things to keep their bodies healthy. Right now, those are the people who have done things the right way that are seeing their costs skyrocketing (Kliff, 2017, p. 1).</p><p>Crawford would describe Brooks as among the white, middle or upper-class Americans, able to adopt healthy lifestyles, “vindicated in their privilege” because they had done so, and “confirmed in their privilege” by outliving the less responsible, less wealthy, less white individuals (p. 410). This quest for personal wellbeing has caused society to lose the <em>‘agora,’</em> a space where private problems meet in a meaningful way, and ideas of ‘public good,’ ‘just society,’ and ‘shared values’ grow. Without this space, it will be hard to take collective social action.</p><p><strong>Health-Consciousness</strong></p><p>Crawford made an additional observation that this writer would be remiss to leave out. This observation gets to the heart of so much disparity in the U.S. After discussing the AIDS epidemic of the 1980s, Crawford stated, “The presence of disease in ‘the diseased’ is a nearness that threatens reminding the healthy that their health is tenuous” (p. 417). His argument is that the idea and ideal of ‘health’ let people use denial and projection to separate themselves from those who are different, all while being virtuous and acting ‘correctly.’ If it was not already clear, let it be made clear now: a significant number of individuals with preexisting conditions in this country are people of color, and an even greater number are lower-income. Conservatives may see medical underwriting as good and necessary business practice, but liberals, and a growing majority regardless of party affiliation, see it as unjust.</p><p><strong>Global Context</strong></p><p>Other developed, industrialized countries also consider excluding people from health care coverage to be wrong. The United States belongs to a number of international organizations that evaluate and compare their member states on a variety of factors. The World Health Organization (WHO), Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), and the United Nations (UN) all assess the performance of health systems of member states. The Commonwealth Fund also provides analysis in this arena. In 2000, WHO analyzed the health systems of its 191-member states for the first time. The assessment was based on five performance indicators. The Director General, Dr. Gro Harlem Brundtland, also offered commentary. He stated that it is not enough to improve the average health of a nation’s population if, at the same time, inequality worsens or remains high because those in better health gain disproportionately more; health systems are also responsible for trying to reduce inequalities by prioritizing actions that improve the health of those who are worse-off. The goal of good health, he said, is twofold: the best attainable average level (goodness) and the smallest differences among individuals and groups (fairness) (WHO, 2008). He may have been speaking directly to the United States, who, despite spending a higher portion of its Gross Domestic Product (GDP) on health care than any other country, ranked 37 out of 191 based on performance. As a point of comparison, the U.K. spent six percent of its GDP on health services and ranked 18. These finding were based on the measurements for system performance that compared each country’s system to what experts estimated to be the upper limit of what the country could do with the level of resources available, and what each country had accomplished compared to other countries. The five indicators were overall level of population health, health inequalities (or disparities) within the population, overall level of health system responsiveness (combination of patient satisfaction and how well the system acts), distribution of responsiveness within the population (how well people of varying economic status find they are served in a system), and distribution of the health system’s financial burden within the population (who pays the costs). The U.S. ranked highly as having one of the most responsive health care systems, likely because of the availability of resources. It was not ranked highly on any other measure.</p><p><strong>Comparisons</strong></p><p>Data from the aforementioned organizations, as well as the European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies, suggested that the biggest failings of the U.S. Health System were as follows: poor access to primary care contributed to inadequate prevention and management of chronic diseases, delayed diagnoses, incomplete adherence to treatments, wasteful overuse of drugs and technologies, and coordination and safety problems (Schneider, Sarnak, Squires, Shah, &amp; Doty, 2017). A comparison of 11 high-income countries, using 72 indicators that measured performance in five domains, revealed strengths and flaws in the health systems of the U.S., Australia, Canada, France, Germany, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland, and the U.K. (still including England). The domains were care process, access, administrative efficiency, equity, and health care outcomes. The U.S. was ranked last in health care system performance overall, as well as last in access, equity, and health care outcomes. It had the poorest performance of all countries in the subdomain of affordability, with a score much lower than even the second-lowest. It ranked second-to-last in administrative efficiency, but fifth in care process. While the U.S. remains the only high-income country without universal health insurance coverage, the international organizations agree that the ACA was a big step in the right direction and that it has “catalyzed widespread and historic gains” in access to care (p. 4).</p><p><strong>Universal Health Care Models</strong></p><p>If the U.S. were ever looking for a model for universal health care, there are several they could consider. The Beveridge Model provides health care for all citizens and is financed through general tax revenue instead of insurance premiums. The government plays a key role in organizing and operating the delivery of health care, as most hospitals are publicly owned and specialists are often government employees. Because health care is centrally directed, the model gives more direct management accountability to the government. This is the epitome of ‘socialized medicine,’ and while it is most well-known as the U.K.’s National Health Service (NHS), Spain, Italy, and New Zealand are a few other countries utilizing it (Schneider, Sarnak, Squires, Shah, &amp; Doty, 2017). In the Bismarck Model, insurance is financed jointly by employers and employees through a payroll deduction. Plans must include all citizens and do not make a profit, even though doctors and hospitals tend to be private. This model can be seen in Germany, France, Japan, and a number of other countries (Wallace, 2013). The Single-Payer System in Australia has everyone covered under one public insurance plan: Medicare. It is funded through tax revenue, and there is lesser public involvement in care delivery than in the Beveridge Model. Many hospitals are private, and approximately half of the population buys private insurance to access augmented care outside the public system. Australian Medicare is similar to U.S. Medicaid (Schneider, Sarnak, Squires, Shah, &amp; Doty, 2017). Finally, there is the Multi-Payer, Competing Private Insurers model, found in the Netherlands (and, to a degree, in the U.S.). Private insurers fund health services, and these insurers are financed through community-rated premiums and payroll taxes. The funds are collected by the government and the pooled and distributed to insurers based on the risk profile of enrollees. All plans include a standard benefit package, and subsidies are available for people with low incomes. Adults are required to enroll or pay a fine. Additionally, health care providers are predominantly private (Schneider, Sarnak, Squires, Shah, &amp; Doty, 2017). This ‘managed competition’ model is very similar to the U.S. system after ACA reform, though explanations for why the model led to universal coverage in the Netherlands but not in the U.S. was not offered in the write-up. This author can only hazard a guess that the ideology of American Exceptionalism, along with an unwillingness to adhere to the mandate, played a role.</p><p><strong>A Basic Minimum of Accessible Health Care</strong></p><p>Despite the shortcomings and ideological obstacles of the U.S., there is a case to be made that the country is well on its way to universal health care. P.T. Menzel (2011) argued just that by discussing cultural moral rights. According to Menzel, a cultural moral right is a right that is above and beyond a legal right, and is based on society’s existing commitments and moral culture. Similarly, a socially embedded moral fact is a cultural moral right that carries the same ability as other facts to criticize existing legal arrangements. Of course, the success of using these facts as criticism is contingent upon the moral culture in which they exist and can be asserted, because they are already implied by legal elements and widespread beliefs. Menzel claimed they could be used as “immanent” social criticism, which is based on the principles and values widely held in a given society. The most effective criticism against a person is one against that person’s own pretended ideals by calling said person a hypocrite; by the same token, social critics can “hold up a mirror to society as a whole” (p. 81). Menzel, in this essay, held up a mirror to the U.S. and claimed they already have the basic groundwork for a universal right to access health care. He outlined five steps to getting there.</p><p>1) Hospitals are legally prohibited from turning away people who are uninsured or unable to pay for emergency care; by law, citizens already have universal access to emergency care. This began with the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA), and he believed it held up because there has been no political opposition to the act.</p><p>2) Allowing health insurance to be voluntary condones unfair “free riding” by people who go without insurance. It is also extremely inefficient. The only feasible way to alleviate these problems is to mandate insurance. Patients often need care after the acute care they receive in the emergency room, but if they do not have insurance, they likely return to the emergency room for that care. Studies have estimated that as much as $100 billion of care is annually cost-shifted from those patients onto patients who have insurance and can pay. This shift leads to an average $1000 increase in premium for every insured family. The duty of fair play claims that people should be required to pay their share of a “collective enterprise that conveys benefits from which they cannot feasibly be excluded (p. 83).” Because the U.S. has universal access to emergency care, many young and healthy individuals, or those with a measure of wealth, choose not to get insurance. Then, when they need emergency care, they do not have coverage. The inefficient reliance on emergency care rooms makes little sense when there is no similar access to primary care, where care can be more efficient and more effective. According to Menzel, society was tempted to move to universal access to emergency care because it was not willing to provide for the costs of mandating universal primary care, even though money that buys mandated care now could “achieve greater benefit at less expense in a primary care setting” (p. 86). For these reasons, the U.S. either needs to repeal the EMTALA, or mandate insurance for basic care that will cover at least primary care, emergency care, and acute post-emergency care.</p><p>3) A mandate that everyone get insurance is unfair unless insurance is affordable; affordability requires both restrictions on the behaviors of insurers and subsidies to those with lower incomes. The U.S. already does this, first with Medicare and Medicaid, then with the ACA.</p><p>4) It is unfair to insurers (and counterintuitive when trying to reduce the number of uninsured) to prohibit insurers from using preexisting condition exclusions, waiting periods, and risk-rated premiums unless insurance is mandatory. In a voluntary competitive insurance market, ‘segmenting’ tactics lead to ‘market failure’ when sick people are priced out of insurance. A death spiral would happen if insurers were prohibited from discriminating against people with preexisting conditions and insurance was voluntary, because, as has been established throughout, healthy people would choose not to get insurance. For this reason, those who want to postpone buying insurance should not be allowed to choose when they decide to be insured; in order to receive benefits during emergencies, people need to have been paying for insurance all along.</p><p>5) Justice between healthy and sick requires they share most of the financial burdens of illness and insurance. Restrictions on insurers are ‘practically necessary’ to achieve access, ‘morally necessary’ to avoid unfair free-riding, and ‘fundamentally necessary’ to achieve justice between the healthy and the sick. The principles of just sharing and equality of opportunity imply that the cost of insurance should not vary widely based on enrollee health status.</p><p>Menzel then quickly listed evidence that the U.S. believes in this principle. The need for the healthy to share in the expenses of the unhealthy is behind Medicare, Medicaid, and the ACA; the EMTALA recognizes that the cost of treating certain sick people needs to be shared by others; for the most part, people along the political spectrum believe individuals should not be prevented from accessing insurance because of their health status, and even the conservative ‘minimal state’ value is justified by the desire to prevent free-riding, as the unfairness of free-riding is a reflection of individual irresponsibility. People in the U.S. already have a moral right to universal access to basic care that is rooted in their actual moral culture, so the next step is defining a basic minimum. Menzel suggested that this include primary care, emergency care, and post-emergency care; it may not include lifetime benefit caps; the care needs to be effective, with the cost-sharing carefully tailored; utilization of comparative effectiveness when deciding what will be covered, so that if two treatments are on the table for inclusion and one is more effective than the other, include the more effective one; and utilization of comparative cost effectiveness, because if people are going to be required to share in expenses, plans and providers must be committed to not wasting those funds. According to WHO, “efficiency is not a moral luxury, it is a moral obligation” (p. 94). So, too, is providing access to health care.</p><p><strong>International Covenants: The United Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) and the WHO Fact Sheet №31 (Fact Sheet)</strong></p><p>Article 25 of the UDHR states that everyone has a right to a standard of living that is adequate for the health and wellbeing of his or herself and family, and in this is included the right to medical care and necessary social services (United Nations, 1948). Though the U.S. never ratified this treaty, it is a country that prides itself on the seemingly innumerable rights of individual citizens, and a number of professions, including social work, look to the UDHR as a document to value and live up to, much like the Constitution. As seems to be the case more and more frequently, parties within the U.S. will have to uphold the mantle put forth by this document and hope the federal government finds fit to do the same. Interestingly, the U.S. is a member nation of the World Health Organization and a signatory to relevant treaties referenced in the WHO Constitution and Fact Sheet. In the Introduction, the Fact Sheet stated that the right to health is a “fundamental part of our human rights” (p. 1). In referencing the Constitution (1946), it stated that the preamble defines health as “a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity…the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of health is one of the fundamental rights of every human being without distinction of race, religion, political belief, economic, or social condition” (p. 1). International human rights treaties established since then have specified a right to medical care as well. Section I E of the Fact Sheet explicitly stated that the right to health is recognized in international human rights law, particularly in the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ESC Covenant). Sections III A and B described the States’ obligations of progressive realization of these rights, and particularly the obligations to respect, protect, and fulfil the right to health. Finally, Section III C discussed responsibilities of the private sector, and this section is particularly salient in the U.S. While the Commission on Human Rights believes that businesses do have responsibilities for human rights, as of the publication of the Fact Sheet, member states are responsible for policing those.</p><p>The U.S. Department of State under President Bush issued a response to the Fact Sheet (2008), described as ‘observations’ related to the so-called ‘right to health.” Observation 5 cited UDHR Article 25 and emphasized that the right is progressive, meaning it is an ultimate goal, not an immediate entitlement. In Observation 7, the U.S. pointed out that they are not a party that has ratified the ESC Covenant, so they are not obligated by the same international laws. Observations 8 and 9 continued outlining the U.S.’ objection to the seemingly interchangeable use of ‘states’ and ‘state parties,’ which refer to different nations depending on the declarations, treaties, or other agreements. In Observations 10 and 11, the U.S. stated its understanding of its responsibilities as a party that has ratified the WHO Constitution and the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (ICERD), namely, that adopting the principles enumerated in said documents did not commit the U.S. to enact specific legislation. The U.S. also took significant issue with the use of the term “sexual and reproductive health” and other related terms, as described in Observations 21, 22, and 23. Specifically, the U.S. was ‘concerned’ about the “frequent use of terms regarding reproductive health care that have been misinterpreted by others to support rights and obligations that have not been agreed to in an international for a” (p. 5). This author would like to point out that the U.S. is the country that enforces the Global Gag Rule, barring U.S. NGOs and health care workers from even mentioning abortions on an international stage. Finally, Observations 24 and 25 are used to discuss non-state actors and a State’s obligation to act when human rights have been violated. The U.S. appeared to prefer treaties that contained provisions that imposed specific obligations in limited circumstances. A footnote indicates the example of torture in the Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman and Degrading Treatment. The author finds the inclusion of this particular example ironic. The response concluded by stating that the U.S. did not believe the Fact Sheet fostered respect for international law, but that the U.S. appreciated the work of WHO and looked forward to continuing its dialogue on issues related to the right to health (U.S. State Dept., 2008).</p><p><strong>Policy Effectiveness and Recommendations</strong></p><p>The U.S. response to the Fact Sheet was written in 2008, and in 2009, President Obama came into office and got to work on the ACA. It was implemented in parts, between 2010 and 2014. At the time of this writing, data on the effects of the ACA with regard to individuals with preexisting conditions is not available past 2014, but experts expect that projections based on current data and knowledge of recent trends is somewhat accurate. The Department of Health and Human Services issued a brief in January of 2017 summarizing the effects of the ACA. Since its implementation, because companies can no longer deny coverage or charge higher premiums based on an individual’s medical history or health status, cannot exclude coverage for treating preexisting condition, must include limits on out-of-pocket spending for the enrollee, cannot include annual or lifetime caps, cannot rescind a policy based on unintentional omission, and must cover essential health benefits, between 61 million and 133 million people with preexisting conditions have coverage. Between 2010 and 2014, the share of individuals with preexisting conditions who went without health insurance all year fell by 22 percent, a total of 3.6 million people. Prior to passage of the ACA, 23 percent of people with a preexisting condition (31 million people) experienced at least one month without insurance coverage in 2014, and in the two-year period between 2013 and 2015, that number was 33 percent, or 44 million people. Before the ACA, 34 percent of applicants to the individual marketplace were charged higher-than-standard rates based on demographic characteristics or medical history, 36 percent were denied coverage, were charged more, or had exclusions on their policies due to a preexisting condition, and the Government Accountability Office (GAO) in 2010 found that the denial rate based on health status was 19 percent. 93 percent of people with preexisting conditions who were ever insured went without coverage for two months or more at some point, and 87 percent went without for three months or more. All of this was prohibited after the implementation of the ACA, with the exception of certain grandfathered nongroup plans. These laws will continue to help people, as an individual’s likelihood of having a preexisting condition increases with age. Up to 84 percent of those ages 55–64 (31 million people) have at least one preexisting condition (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2017). The ACA did reduce racial and ethnic disparities in outcomes, though not as much as President Obama had hoped. An important variable that contributes to the lack of significant improvement regards states’ failure to expand Medicaid; the majority of states that opted not to expand tend to have a larger minority population (Torres et al., 2017). The ACA also faced a significant amount of public backlash, due in large part to Republican efforts to turn people against it, and its sheer complexity that made it difficult for laypeople to understand. Additionally, a surprising number of people apparently were not aware that the ACA and “Obamacare” were the same thing, so its popularity grew in 2017 when people realized the health care they had that they did not want taken away was the same health care named after a president they disliked. More people than ever before have been involved in a public health care debate this past year, and some people still fail to see the ways in which the ACA affects all aspects of the health industry. Though most Employer-Sponsored Insurance (ESI) plans already offered exceptional coverage and did not discriminate against people with preexisting conditions, that was not universal. Many people with ESI may not realize that their basic benefits package, for example, is a product of the ACA. Free birth control and other women’s health services are parts of the policy. People who purchase insurance in the individual marketplace likely receive tax subsidies to make their premiums more affordable, though this aspect of the law is also one that has become problematic. Despite the “mandate,” too many young and healthy people either choose not to purchase insurance in the exchange or have ESI; either way, there are not enough of them to effectively spread out the cost for those who do want to purchase insurance, and premiums have spiked, though more slowly than in previous years. Though the ACA requires states to offer at least one plan and encourage the presence of at least three, insurers have been pulling out of small states with rural populations because they cannot afford to stay. A proper, enforceable mandate may be one option to assist in stabilizing marketplaces. The ACA was originally supposed to have a public option, whereby individuals of a certain age could buy into Medicare, but Democratic Senator from Connecticut Joe Lieberman voted against that in 2009. Hillary Clinton included it as part of her proposed health care policy, but since she did not become president, the policy was not enacted. Congressional Democrats have put forth a plan for universal health care that includes a transition period with the public option, but Democrats have virtually no power in any legislative branch or state house in the country. The public option would help stabilize the marketplaces because older individuals tend to be sicker, and allowing those age 55 and over to buy into Medicare would get them out of the marketplace, where they cause rates to increase.</p><p>One additional, and perhaps unforeseen, effect of the ACA is the way it has changed Americans’ views on their right to affordable health care. During the repeal process of the past several months, commentators have joked that now that Americans know what it is like to have something, they do not want it taken away. They are correct. Not only do people who struggled to obtain health insurance pre-ACA now believe they are entitled to health care and know they could go bankrupt or die without it, but large segments of the population agree that everyone, especially and including the poor, the sick, the ones who are “different,” have that right.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>Humans have a right to health, and by extension, to accessible and affordable health care. Many nations around the world have recognized this right and acted to ensure its residents are provided for. Though the U.S. is not there yet, the country is on its way. People working in public health — doctors, nurses, social workers, psychiatrists and psychologists, even insurers — should be devoted to the wellbeing of all humans, especially the most vulnerable, and are obligated to advocate for justice and equity, especially when it comes to health. ‘Health justice’ is a growing field, because more people are recognizing the importance of universal health care. Not only is the current U.S. health system unjust and inequitable, but it is inefficient, inaccessible, unaffordable, costly, and causes unnecessary harm. When people have health insurance, they are more likely to engage in actions that will improve their health. The healthier the population, the happier, more successful, and less costly they will be. The move to universal health care is necessary, either because the current system is unsustainable, or because it is the right, just action. The ACA is nearly identical to the multi-payer system in The Netherlands, so the U.S. need only make a few adjustments to reach that goal. This author believes universal health care is the will of the people. The people now must elect policymakers who share that goal.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a312a3a3a1b4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Testimony on the Importance of Protections for Individuals with Preexisting Conditions]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@alicat812/testimony-on-the-importance-of-protections-for-individuals-with-preexisting-conditions-1cba38d5e24d?source=rss-16b137ade8e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1cba38d5e24d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[aca]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[preexisting-conditions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ali F.]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Jun 2018 19:58:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-11T19:58:23.665Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) of 2010 defined a selection of discriminatory actions against people with preexisting conditions as any “limitation or exclusion of benefits relating to a condition based on the fact that the condition was present before the date of enrollment for coverage, whether or not any medical advice, diagnosis, care, or treatment was recommended or received before that date” (§ 2074). This explicitly named domestic violence, which was formerly considered a preexisting condition in some states. Not only did the ACA prohibit insurance companies from using preexisting condition exclusions, but also from rescinding coverage/canceling plans except in cases of fraud or intentional misrepresentation of material fact, and annual and lifetime caps on benefits. This prohibition is one of the most significant provisions in health care reform legislation. Preexisting conditions potentially affect everyone, but the people who suffered most from the discriminatory practices of the past were often the more vulnerable members of the population, those individuals whom social workers are called to assist and advocate for most vociferously. These were most often people who were already sick; who did not have a full-time job, or at least not one that offered comprehensive health benefits; who earn a low income; who are racial and/or ethnic minorities; who, until 2015, might not have been eligible for spousal benefits if their partner was of the same sex. These already marginalized, oppressed, struggling people were most effected by discrimination based on preexisting condition, and were therefore the most likely to gain when such discrimination was prohibited.</p><p>Prior to the passage and implementation of the ACA, people trying to get health insurance in the individual market were subject to a process known as ‘underwriting,’ where insurance companies investigated potential enrollees by having them fill out exhaustive forms and questionnaires. According to Claxton, Cox, Damico, Levitt, &amp; Pollitz (2016), applicants were asked to disclose whether they were pregnant or contemplating pregnancy or adoption, information about all physician visits, prescriptions, lab results, and other medical care. Health plans have an interest in controlling access to coverage because they have an interest in controlling costs, and certain people are more likely to cost more. People with preexisting conditions had trouble getting health insurance at all, getting affordable health insurance, getting health insurance that did not include a rider excluding their condition or a period of time when they their benefits would not cover their condition, having their plans rescinded and/or canceled when insurers decided to go digging deeper into their enrollees’ medical history and came up with something they could use to deny coverage. People faced closed blocks of business, which happens when premiums for policies or groups of policies are pooled together (the block) and the insurer stops actively marketing the policy to new enrollees, so the healthier enrollees who have no trouble passing health screenings move to other policies, and people with preexisting conditions are left with their own high-risk pool (Claxton, Pollitz, &amp; Levitt, 2012).</p><p>These troubles varied by state and by insurance company, as did the list of what was even considered a preexisting condition, but some guidelines seemed to hold true across all markets. A study by the Kaiser Foundation was able to determine 30 types of automatically declinable conditions, 13 types of automatically declinable medications, and 27 automatically declinable occupations or activities (Pollitz, 2017). That meant that anyone who had every had one of the conditions, taken one of the medications, participated in one of the activities, or held one of the occupations, was denied insurance on the spot. An additional 20–30 conditions were considered ones that, while not automatically declinable, would result in losses for insurance companies, and these are the conditions that prompted higher premiums or deductibles, benefit limits, or exclusion of coverage for the specific condition (U.S. DHHS, 2017).</p><p>The ACA was passed in 2010 and implemented fully in 2014. In that four-year period, due to interim provisions, 3.6 million people with preexisting condition gained insurance coverage. Though there is not yet specific data regarding how many people with preexisting conditions have gained coverage since then, as of January 2017, the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) estimated that between 21 percent and 51 percent of the population — 61 million to 133 million people — have some type of preexisting condition. That also translates to between one in five and one in two people, and all of these people would have trouble getting health insurance if the ACA were not the law of the land. These 61 to 133 million people not only need the best health insurance, but they cannot afford, physically, to go without it. Before the ACA, 93 percent of people with preexisting conditions who had ever had insurance went without coverage for two months or more at some point, and 87 percent went for three months or more. It is one thing when healthy people lack insurance; it is risky and inhumane to force unhealthy people to go without it, because then they either go completely without health care, go bankrupt trying to afford care, or get care they cannot afford that is then shifted to people who do have insurance (Menzel, 2011). Despite what Congressman Brooks said about healthy people being the ones who do the right and good thing to stay healthy (Kliff, 2017), the reality is that the “right and good” thing for health is to take preventative measures and utilize care, and the people who do most of that are the ones with preexisting conditions. Despite the insurance mandate, many young, healthy people still choose to pay the fine over signing up for health insurance, so in fact, it is not the good, healthy people paying for the sick people, but the people who are less healthy, paying for each other, keeping the health industry running.</p><p>The knowledge that a possible half of the population has a preexisting condition should be enough to demonstrate the necessity of this prohibition on discriminatory practices, but just in case caring for the most vulnerable is not convincing enough, here are some numbers everyone should care about. 15 to 30 percent of people in perfectly good health right now are likely to develop a preexisting condition over the next eight years. One in three women and one in two men will develop some type of cancer in their lifetime, and the odds are the same for coronary heart disease. When it comes to the chances of developing diabetes, men are at one in three, women are at two in five, and for Hispanic women, the chances are one in two. Finally, most people develop health problems over the course of their lives (DHHS, 2017). With over 50 conditions already named and potentially many more as the prevalence of other conditions increases, there will come a time when every single person would be at risk in a medical underwriting process. If protecting people with preexisting conditions because it is just and humane is not enough of a reason for some, perhaps the knowledge that a repeal of these protections could hurt everyone holds some meaning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*MZ4WiWfgEx8gbah6kJa4GQ.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1cba38d5e24d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>