<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Alice Germain on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Alice Germain on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@alice.c.germain?source=rss-5c9630fd9d1a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 09:19:58 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@alice.c.germain/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Multiples of 9 and 3 with Cuisenaire rods]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/multiples-of-9-and-3-with-cuisenaire-rods-86866367104b?source=rss-5c9630fd9d1a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/86866367104b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stem]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teaching-resources]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mathematics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mathematics-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stem-education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alice Germain]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 18 Dec 2020 17:02:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-20T13:33:06.173Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>You may have learnt at some point that multiples of 9 and 3 can be easily identified by checking whether the sum of their digits is itself a multiple of 9 and 3, respectively. But have you learnt why it is so? I, personally, didn’t. But it is a nice thing to look at, and it can be shown first with Cuisenaire rods before using algebra to generalise the observed pattern.</p><p>Let’s start by looking at the 5 first multiples of 9 with Cuisenaire rods in a 100-square, which is very useful when we want to focus on place value. We observe that adding 9 means increasing the number of tens by 1 and decreasing the number of units (or ones) by 1.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/613/1*L0J7z5PQ9rh3I2YyJHYcJg.png" /><figcaption>Multiples of 9</figcaption></figure><p>In the second row of 100-squares, the same numbers are shown, but this time thinking about these numbers as multiples of 9, that is, by placing a 9-rod wherever possible. We observe that for 18, we have a 9-rod and a 1-rod in the first column. We could do the same for the two full columns of 27, or, instead of two 1-rods, place a 2-rod. In that way, we see that the rod placed horizontally on top of the full columns is the number of tens. We see that for the whole number to be a multiple of 9, we need the number of tens (the horizontal rod) plus the number of units (the rod in the last column) to be a multiple of 9.</p><p>We can apply the same reasoning for the multiples of 3.</p><p>Consider the numbers 12, 24, 39, and 48 in a 100-square. First, we split them into tens and units as shown in the first row of 100-squares, and, in the second row, we place three 3-rods in each full column. Finally, in the third row, we show how the whole number is a multiple of 3 because the sum of the number of tens (given by the rod placed horizontally on top of the full tens columns) and the number of units is a multiple of 3.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/549/1*T2cEBz8w3rA8JhCcOTbEGw.png" /><figcaption>Multiples of 3</figcaption></figure><p>What about multiples of 6?</p><p>The rule that the sum of the digits must be a multiple of 6 won’t work here as 10 cannot be split into a multiple of 6 + 1. However, as 6 is 2 × 3, a multiple of 6 is both a multiple of 3 and a multiple of 2. In other words, they are even multiples of 3 — so, the sum of their digits is a multiple of 3 and the last digit is 0, 2, 4, 6, or 8.</p><p><strong>Linking with Algebra</strong></p><p>These properties can be demonstrated with algebra, translating with equations the pattern we have observed here.</p><p>For the multiples of 9, we have used the fact that each ten is made of 9 + 1. Considering a two-digit number written ‘<em>tu</em>’ where <em>t</em> and <em>u</em> are digits (i.e., whole numbers between 0 and 9), we have ‘<em>tu</em>’=10<em>t</em>+<em>u. </em>We now replace 10 by 9 + 1, which gives ‘<em>tu</em>’=(9+1)<em>t</em>+<em>u=</em>9<em>t+t+u. </em>If <em>t+u</em>, the sum of the digits of the number ‘<em>tu</em>’, is a multiple of 9, then it can be written as <em>t+u=</em>9<em>k</em>, where<em> k</em> is a whole number. In that case, we can write</p><p>‘<em>tu</em>’=9<em>t+</em>9<em>k=</em>9<em>(t+k),</em></p><p>which shows that ‘<em>tu</em>’ is a multiple of 9 since <em>t+k , </em>as the sum of two whole numbers, is a whole number itself.</p><p>For the multiples of 3, we have replaced each ten by three 3-rods plus 1 unit. So, we have ‘<em>tu</em>’<em>=</em>10<em>t + u = (</em>3 × 3+1)<em>t </em>+ <em>u</em> = 3 × 3 <em>t </em>+ <em>t </em>+ <em>u</em>. If <em>t+u</em>, the sum of the digits of the number ‘<em>tu</em>’, is a multiple of 3, then it can be written as <em>t+u=</em>3<em>k</em>, where<em> k</em> is a whole number. In that case, we can write</p><p>‘<em>tu</em>’ = 3 × 3<em>t + </em>3<em>k = </em>3 (3<em>t + k</em>)<em>,</em></p><p>which shows that ‘<em>tu</em>’ is a multiple of 3 since 3<em>t+k </em>is a whole number.</p><p>We can generalise this to all whole numbers since any power of 10 (with a positive exponent) can be written as a multiple of 9 (and thus of 3) + 1:</p><p>100 = 9 × 11 + 1; 1000 = 9 × 111 + 1, etc.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=86866367104b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/multiples-of-9-and-3-with-cuisenaire-rods-86866367104b">Multiples of 9 and 3 with Cuisenaire rods</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education">Dr. Alice G. on Education</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to Improve the Teacher Training]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/how-to-improve-the-teacher-training-a2199c5507f4?source=rss-5c9630fd9d1a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a2199c5507f4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[pgce]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teacher-training]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alice Germain]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Dec 2020 16:24:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-17T16:24:24.147Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I have posted several articles in this blog where I analyse, with the outside perspective of someone who was not educated in England, different aspects of the PGCE training and the English education system. I want here to summarise my critics on the PGCE training in a constructive way, as I deeply believe that improving the teacher training is a first step towards improving our education system.</p><p>The first school placement during the PGCE starts at the end of September. During the first weeks, teacher trainees merely observe lessons and familiarise themselves with the school and their future classes. During my training, only the eager ones taught a part of one or several lessons before half-term at the end of October. Most of us started teaching full lessons after half-term. From that moment on, we spent one day per week at university and four days teaching at our school. When we all turned up at university after our first week of teaching, I think any external observer would have noticed that almost all of us looked tense and tired. We taught only a couple of hours in our first week, but it required a huge preparatory work due to our inexperience and the associated doubts about any choice we had to make. And, above all, we experienced the immense stress of not only having to face a class of 30 kids, but also to do it while at the back of the classroom a teacher scrutinises every single one of our actions. In a nutshell: we had just got a flavour of the infernal working rhythm of a teacher and of the stress of a PGCE student. The latter would last for what we felt were the longest seven months of our life — for those of us who would hold on. Because, indeed, many PGCE students drop out of the course — our university teachers told us that roughly 10% drop out during the PGCE year.</p><p>The PGCE training is famously tough. I have wondered a lot during the training what it is that makes it so hard. I have given part of the answer in my previous article about the “<a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/what-is-a-teacher-the-big-confusions-a22e16b80ede">big confusions</a>” both in terms of expectations and instructions. But there are other aspects that I want to discuss here.</p><p>Starting to teach in October or November is difficult because we are not regarded as real teachers by our students. They feel we are not really in charge, and they treat us like supply teachers. As teenagers have quite a short-term view of things, they quite quickly see our lessons as an opportunity to have a good time, or at least some challenging kids will see it that way. The fact is that we are not equipped at the start of the training to deal with challenging students properly. One key element of behaviour management is to gain respect from the class and set up some clear rules of what is expected from them. This is particularly difficult, if not impossible, when you “borrow” a class from another teacher in the middle of the term and only for a few weeks. And this becomes even more challenging when you primarily focus on pedagogy and try to stick to your lesson plan.</p><p>I also believe that there is a real issue with mentors and PGCE students observers in schools. PGCE students can learn a lot from them and make the most of the practical part of their training thanks to their feedbacks. These feedbacks however lack both consistency and focus.</p><p>Let me take a simple example from my own experience with my first lesson with one of my classes. I did not know the names of the students yet; I did not have a seating plan because the teacher forgot to give it to me (even if I asked for it several times); I knew what I had to teach but I didn’t appreciate yet my students’ level and where they might struggle; I had no clue of behaviour management yet (except the wonderful tip I got from university, namely that if a lesson is engaging, one shouldn’t encounter any behaviour issues) — and I was quite nervous because I was being observed. After the lesson, which was certainly not the most fantastic lesson the students had seen so far, but was on balance not a catastrophe either, I got the following feedback from the teacher, who went over almost every minute of the lesson. 1) I like your way of asking questions, but you stood in the front of the class for far too long. Let the students do it on their own, don’t explain. 2) You should regularly check for learning and adapt your lesson to your students’ needs. 3) You spent 25 minutes on this activity, while you had planned 15 minutes for it. Look at the clock! 4) Some students were chatting while you were talking. Tell them off! And know your students’ names!</p><p>In this feedback, a first clash is obvious between different constructivist ideas (see <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/constructivist-theories-40c20de63c6f">here</a>), namely between dialogic teaching where understanding is assessed and sought via questions to and discussion with the students, and the idea that a teacher should not talk from the front of the classroom — as prescribed by Ofsted. (But the same teachers who tell you not to explain do explain a lot of stuff during their lessons, and you know because you sit in them as part of your training.) The second clash is between being flexible enough in order to adapt to our students’ needs as they arise (for instance they struggle with a particular point, so we spend more time on it than expected) and follow our lesson plan tightly. The key for a good teacher is certainly to find the right balance between both. But is it helpful to give the contradictory instructions “follow your plan” and “assess your students’ learning and adapt your lesson accordingly” to a starting PGCE student? It would make much more sense to explain that it takes time until one is able to draft realistic lesson plans, but that one should keep in mind that some flexibility is allowed so that one can adapt to students’ needs. And, to this latter point, it would be also helpful to insist that it is not easy at first to adapt one’s teaching during the lesson, but one can always consider one’s learning’s assessment when planning the next lesson. Finally, it is ludicrous to expect that a starting PGCE student knows the 30 students’ names at their first lesson, especially if the teacher forgot to give them the class’ seating plan. So, in the whole, although the level of details in this feedback clearly suggests that the observer put a lot of efforts in producing it, its lack of focus eventually makes it of little help.</p><p>The third issue with mentors and observers arises from the fact that PGCE students need their feedbacks as pieces of evidence for their professional development file, and their mentor writes a professional practice report (3 reports in the year for 2 school placements), which forms a basis for the final PGCE grade. In short, PGCE students are in the hands of their mentor and further observers. And some of them may be frustrated, for whatever reason, and/or just enjoy abusing their power. It can go from simply patronising you to jeopardising your training completion. I had to experience some very patronising attitudes. For instance, one of my observers criticised the fact that I dared to use the extremely complicated word ‘vacuum’ to a bottom Year 9 set, while I explained during the lesson the meaning of vacuum in science. He went on with other examples and finished with “the last straw that made him so angry” — his own words — when I said, “light propagates”. Was it a real, constructive critic, I wondered, or was it to make me feel uneasy as I am not an English native speaker? And was it necessary to be <em>angry</em>? Of course, I agree that complex words in science is a barrier to many students, and that it is true that I do not necessarily always know the corresponding plain English word, because in French we do say for instance “la lumière se propage”. Does it deserve an angry feedback? Besides, I do believe that it is the role of teachers to teach their subject’s terminology; so, explaining the meaning and using the proper scientific terms.</p><p>Every PGCE student has many of such stories to tell. If they are limited to some patronising feedbacks, as it was the case for me, they are lucky. But sometimes it escalates, and the PGCE student is suddenly deemed to be unfit for becoming a teacher. It happened to some of my university colleagues who did not formally fail their PGCE but were forced to either drop out of the course or defer their training. It started with the mentor and maybe other observing teachers being unsatisfied by the performance of their PGCE student. This is when the role of the university tutor becomes essential. They usually intervene and defend the student who is, in most cases, just a scape goat for all frustrations these teachers experience in their job. I was struck by the fact that some PGCE students’ evaluations would be reversed — in either direction — when they changed school. At the very least, it shows how subjective — and thus arduous — it is to evaluate a teacher. It also demonstrates the flaw in the system, and thus the importance of having a university tutor ready to step in for you, if you happen to get in this troublesome situation with a frustrated mentor. If a PGCE’s university tutor does not feel it is their problem, like it was the case for the tutor of my PGCE colleagues who had to drop out of the course (remarkably, they all had the same tutor), then there is nothing to stop mentors from jeopardising your training.</p><p>Finally, a PGCE training is hard because of the overload of work and under such stress conditions of being observed and evaluated every single day. As for the work overload, we were equals with full-time teachers. I know there are still many people out there who believe that teachers have an easy life, with so many holidays!! But they are so obviously totally wrong… According to some OECD statistics<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>, English teachers teach about 10% more hours per year (around 720) than the OECD average (around 650). Teaching hours are of course only the visible part of the iceberg. Increase the number of teaching hours and you increase not only the corresponding preparation time, but also most likely the number of students and, as a result, both the marking time and the data monitoring time. The working time of teachers is regularly estimated, and the figures are around 55 hours per week (see for instance an estimate here<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a>).</p><p>A PGCE student teaches much less than a full-time teacher, but it takes infinitely more time for them to prepare lessons. Preparing lessons not only means understanding what you have to teach, find activities for your students and prepare some PowerPoint slides, but also writing a detailed lesson plan — it took me between 45 and 60 minutes to complete a lesson plan at the level of details my observers wanted to have. And PGCE students must do their university work on top of that: reading papers, conducting interviews, observing lessons, writing essays…</p><p>I am convinced that some issues of the PGCE training that I have described here could be solved by structuring the PGCE training. That is, there should be a clear <em>planned</em> progression throughout the academic year in terms of key skills. These skills are clearly identified and described in the teacher standards. A planned progression implies that the sessions at university should not be given at random but follow this plan. And, in the same way, the lessons we give in school should allow us to develop only one or two key skills at a time. Sequential learning approaches are widely used in the training world. A driving instructor would never ask their students to drive the car on the motorway and use the five gears during the first lesson. I do not see why it should be different in a teacher training.</p><p>For instance, we could imagine that the focus at the start would be on behaviour management, and PGCE students could use lesson plans and resources given by the class teacher instead of doing everything from scratch. This would also relieve the workload and allow for more time to think of and experiment efficient behaviour management techniques. In a second period of the training, the focus could be on planning lessons, that is, how to structure a lesson following some teaching and learning theories, how to use different types of activities to support students’ learning and engagement, how to adapt activities to students with special educational needs, etc. Finally, the focus could be on assessing students’ learning and being ready to adjust the lesson if necessary, marking tests and giving feedback, etc.</p><p>I suspect that training providers would argue that every trainee is unique, and so each of them will take a unique progression path. I do not believe it is a valid argument that allows them to overlook the need of an overarching structure of the PGCE course. If the course is designed in a smart way, there can still be room for fast progression in the stages where a trainee is having no difficulties, and slower progression if necessary. Teacher training providers are supposed to be educational experts after all.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> <a href="http://www.oecd.org/education/skills-beyond-school/48631419.pdf">http://www.oecd.org/education/skills-beyond-school/48631419.pdf</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> <a href="https://www.tes.com/news/teachers-work-54-hour-week-dfe-survey-finds">https://www.tes.com/news/teachers-work-54-hour-week-dfe-survey-finds</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a2199c5507f4" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/how-to-improve-the-teacher-training-a2199c5507f4">How to Improve the Teacher Training</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education">Dr. Alice G. on Education</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Is a Teacher? — The Big Confusions]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/what-is-a-teacher-the-big-confusions-a22e16b80ede?source=rss-5c9630fd9d1a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a22e16b80ede</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[pgce]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teacher-training]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alice Germain]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2020 12:24:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-18T11:14:35.168Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>What Is a Teacher? — The Big Confusions</h3><p>At his valedictory speech, the Director of the PGCE programme said that a PGCE is extremely difficult and that we should be proud to have accomplished it. According to him, the reason why a PGCE is hard lies in the fact that it is made of several parts, each of them being difficult on its own: teaching, carrying out a micro-research project, and writing academic essays. This may be true. PGCE students have indeed to distribute their work on completely different tasks: teaching (which is incredibly multitask in itself) and academic studies. Both are hard jobs, and they are also so different in nature that to conciliate both is a real challenge. Preparing and teaching lessons is extremely intense when you are a novice teacher. And I found it highly disturbing — and somehow distracting me from the core of my training , even if I actually enjoyed it, as I come from a scientific research background — to have to read research articles and carry out my own reflection on some aspects of schools’ policies in parallel to this. Some of us clearly chose to do the bare minimum for their essays just to pass, not seeing the point in all them. I believe that the very different nature of the tasks a PGCE student has to carry out is actually symptomatic of the confusion on the very purpose of the PGCE training, namely: Is it a professional training where the focus is primarily on developing PGCE students’ teaching skills through theory and practice? Or does it aim to train future education scientists? And this confusion reflects another, broader confusion on the teacher function. I would summarise it with the question, “Is a teacher an education scientist, engineer, or technician?”</p><p>In materials science, the field I come from, scientists carry out experimental and theoretical research to explore the properties of materials and develop innovative materials with new or improved properties; engineers use and adapt some of these innovative materials for a well-defined end product; and technicians use well-known practical methods to test the properties of the developed product or to fabricate parts of it. Applied to the education world, this would mean that education scientists observe and analyse teaching and learning to find innovative teaching techniques and make recommendations that lead to better learning; education engineers apply and adapt these techniques when teaching students, using their own observations in the field, and education technicians use well-defined techniques to teach students.</p><p>In my view, teachers are education engineers and the PGCE training should reflect that. However, PGCE students have to carry out academic work as if they were future education scientists and, at the same time, are regarded as future technicians when they are given rigid prescriptions on how to teach. For the first point, we were for instance required for our essay on a series of four lessons to review relevant literature that was supposed to inform the way we planned these lessons. I found this very surprising, bearing in mind how it works in technological research. There, some units are specialised in technology transfer from research labs to engineers in the private sector. Given their massive work overload, it cannot be expected from teachers to read educational research literature. It should be the role of education scientists to transfer their knowledge to teachers and schools, that is, to present their main results in a concise and accessible form. There are already initiatives in that direction, but I found it shocking that a PGCE provider suggested that we should read the literature to discover what research has to say about how to teach a certain topic. I thought it was the very purpose of the PGCE training to make a digest of the education research findings, especially in terms of pedagogy, for future teachers. Something along of these lines may have occurred to our teachers since I heard they were thinking of compiling all our literature reviews, as it could prove useful to future PGCE students. This confusion between the roles goes even further in some schools where teachers are expected to do some research while teaching. It is certainly interesting but we should rather find ways to reduce teachers’ workload, not add to it. A much valuable idea would be to expect from education scientists that they work part-time as a teacher. It would present a double advantage: they could keep up with school reality and have easy access to first-hand data.</p><p>This academic part of the PGCE training seems to be intended to future education scientists. And it’s true that some of the PGCE students will carry on their study to a MA in education science. So, maybe a simple solution would be to make the research part of the PGCE optional, while for a standard PGCE other, lighter tasks could be assigned to stimulate some readings and reflections on some central issues in the education world while leaving plenty of time and energy to the students to develop their teaching skills.</p><p>As I explained in a previous <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/the-lessons-structure-in-english-schools-89762b7beef6">article</a>, in parallel to this academic work where we are supposed to read research literature before planning our lessons, we are given instructions both from the university and school teachers in a very patronising way. In addition to their rigidity– as if there were no room for personal preferences when it comes to teaching -, the instructions are often confused if not contradictory. I have already dealt with constructivist theories <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/constructivist-theories-40c20de63c6f">here</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/constructivism-at-work-ab7bad727ce6">here</a>. I explained there that constructivism is not one single theory but encompasses many, sometimes incompatible theories. But this is not spelled out, and, as a result, we get contradictory directions from one session to the other. And here I am talking only about the part at university. In schools, we are supposed to be observed every single lesson by the regular teachers of our classes. The observing teacher then either writes an observation report or gives an oral feedback when the observation is ‘informal’. As the training progresses, observing teachers may reduce the frequency of feedbacks. But, at the start, teacher trainees are bombarded with feedbacks and targets. Our observers may genuinely want to help us, and they indeed give us a lot of their time. However, as there is no overarching framework for how we are expected to progress over the year, they may throw at us everything we should be doing at once.</p><p>And this brings me to another point: observing teachers seem to be eager to give plenty of advice, be it to really help us or to feel important. But the risk of making as many critics or suggestions for improvement as possible is then that the feedback is not consistent. For instance, an observing teacher once told me that my students could have read on their own the text I gave them, instead of me asking a few of them to read it aloud. During a lesson a few weeks later, the same class got again a text to read. So, this time, I asked them to read the text on their own. What did the <em>same</em> teacher tell me? That I should have asked a few of them to read the text aloud… Being observed during every lesson they deliver leads PGCE students to teach differently according to who observes them. Do their observers like when students write the learning objectives in their book or not? Do they like this type of stopwatch or do they prefer this other one? It may sound ludicrous — and indeed it is for any normal person — but one of my PGCE colleagues was told off by her mentor because she did use a stopwatch but not the right one: hers was too soft, and the sound at the end of the allotted time was not intimidating enough…</p><p>It should be recognised that there are many ways to teach a same lesson. This freedom of choice should be given to PGCE students (and teachers), which means that lesson observers should not expect to see only one particular teaching technique or only lessons following the same format. Teachers deserve to be trusted that they know what they are doing and, coming back to my question at the start of this article, be treated like education engineers. Maybe it is what a colleague in my school meant when he said to me that mass education implied mass training of teachers: that we ended up training education technicians, not education engineers.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a22e16b80ede" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/what-is-a-teacher-the-big-confusions-a22e16b80ede">What Is a Teacher? — The Big Confusions</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education">Dr. Alice G. on Education</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Are Exercise Books Staying in Schools?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/why-are-exercise-books-staying-in-schools-8f37fa525846?source=rss-5c9630fd9d1a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8f37fa525846</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alice Germain]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 Oct 2020 13:58:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-15T13:58:13.805Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*jTgaRHZ10KyTW8fI.png" /></figure><p>I have already mentioned Ofsted inspections in a previous <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/the-lessons-structure-in-english-schools-89762b7beef6">post</a>. Another perverse effect of the importance of these inspections is the issue with (exercise) books. When I was myself at school — and already at primary school — , I had different exercise books, often one per subject. The notebooks were an obvious learning tool, providing concrete elements of what had been done during the lesson, allowing students, when doing their homework, to go through the lesson content again and look at the exercises done and corrected in class. Also, homework was done in our exercise books. I would have thought this exercise book use is universal, and I hadn’t expected to find something else in England. Instead, exercise books are still used in England during the lesson, but<em> they often remain at school</em>. So, everything I have written above on why exercise books are useful doesn’t apply if they stay in the classroom.</p><p>I couldn’t understand this habit, so I asked some teachers at school. Their answer was along the lines of, “You cannot let students take their books home, because they won’t be able to take care of them. They will lose them and tell you the dog has eaten them. There is a big parenting problem in London.” I was shocked by these statements for various reasons. Firstly, it is also the role of school to teach children to take care of their exercise books. In other countries, they do it by giving primary children the responsibility of taking them home and bring them back to school. Of course, some books are forgotten, lost, damaged, but this is part of the learning process. I also found the allegation of bad parenting highly patronising and, at the same time, a sign of a given-up attitude, as if schools couldn’t even try to balance this alleged lack of good parenting. And, above all, I was surprised that nobody seemed to realise that keeping books in schools means taking away an important learning tool from children. I wonder how students can remember a lesson if they are not given a chance to look in their exercise book between lessons. And, once you have decided that they don’t need their exercise books for learning, what’s then the big deal if they forget them at home?</p><p>Here, we finally come to the heart of the problem. The function of exercise books in England has little to do with students’ learning but a lot with Ofsted inspections. Exercise books are used by Ofsted inspectors, in addition to lesson observations, to assess teachers’ teaching and students’ learning. It appears that it is a disaster if some books are missing when Ofsted inspectors come, because it could affect their report negatively. That’s why it’s safer for schools if books remain in school. That they are in that way useless to students doesn’t seem to bother the inspectors or the school staff. They all repeat this story that children in London cannot be trusted to take their books home, as if they were trying to convince themselves that there is a rationale behind this absurd habit dictated by Ofsted inspections.</p><p>Fortunately, I have seen some teachers send their students home with their books, but they are a minority. Needless to say that students in independent schools can be trusted and do take their exercise books home. No bad parenting there apparently. And, above all, no Ofsted inspections.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8f37fa525846" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/why-are-exercise-books-staying-in-schools-8f37fa525846">Why Are Exercise Books Staying in Schools?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education">Dr. Alice G. on Education</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Do We Want Our Students to Understand What They Are Doing or Follow a “Math(s) Recipe”?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/do-we-want-our-students-to-understand-what-they-are-doing-or-follow-a-math-s-recipe-b8fa88e394c0?source=rss-5c9630fd9d1a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b8fa88e394c0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mathematics-education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alice Germain]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 18 Sep 2020 12:02:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-06-24T11:50:12.485Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In a previous <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/student-assessment-a8dc49d8f222">post</a>, I explained some aspects of the exam obsession in English schools. I want to show here with a few examples how math(s) educators sometimes choose to stick to a “recipe” in whatever situation, thinking it’s the best method to prepare their students to the exam, but at the expense of stimulating thinking and understanding.</p><p>The standard algorithm to solve linear equations is called the balance method. It is based on the fact that the equation remains true (balanced) as long as we perform exactly the same operations on both sides of the equation. The idea is therefore to carry out a series of operations on both sides of the equations to end up with “unknown = a number”. So, for the equation <strong><em>x -5 = 0</em></strong>, we add 5 to both sides, which gives <em>x -5 + 5 = 0 + 5</em>, i.e., <em>x = 5</em>. However, there is no need to apply the standard algorithm here since the question “What is the number that gives 0 when we take away 5 from it?” is easily answered by young children long before they can use algebra. But many teachers will stick to the ‘solving procedure’ whatever comes, to be sure students know how to solve an equation, even if, by doing so, they prevent them from thinking about what the equation actually says and linking it with their basic number sense.</p><p>When solving equations involving absolute values, the general method is to derive two equations from the original equation: one in which the term inside the absolute value symbol is supposed to be positive, so its absolute value is equal to itself, and another in which this term is supposed to be negative, so its absolute value is equal to its opposite (i.e., itself multiplied by -1). So, for an equation of the form <strong><em>|x + 6| = x + 6</em></strong>, we would do: 1) If <em>x + 6 ≥ 0</em>, that is, if <em>x ≥-6</em>, then <em>x + 6 = x + 6</em>, so any value of <em>x</em> such that <em>x</em> ≥ -6 is a solution of the equation <em>|x + 6| = x + 6</em>. 2) If <em>x + 6 &lt; 0</em>, that is, if <em>x &lt; -6</em>, then <em>–(x + 6) = x + 6,</em> i.e., <em>-x -6 = x + 6, 2 x = -12, x = -6.</em> As <em>x = -6</em> is not compatible with <em>x &lt; -6</em>, there is no solution to the equation <em>|x + 6| = x + 6</em> if <em>x + 6 &lt; 0</em>. The final solution is therefore <em>x ≥ -6.</em></p><p>The method works well. However, thinking about what the equation is saying makes solving it much more interesting — and actually faster. <em>|x + 6| = x + 6</em> means that the number <em>x + 6</em> is equal to its absolute value. In other words, it’s positive or zero, hence <em>x + 6 ≥ 0, x ≥ -6.</em></p><p>Often, when children learn about multiplication of fractions, they will first study the case of a fraction multiplied by an integer, e.g. 3 <em>×</em> 2/5 = 6/5. Then, they will learn that to multiply two fractions together we multiply the numerators together and the denominators together. (And there are many ways to show why it is so.) The same applies for dividing fractions; students learn first what happens when we divide a fraction by a whole number. For instance, ¼ ÷ 3 means dividing a quarter into three equal parts, each of them being one twelfth (one can visualise this as splitting each quarter of the whole into 3, which gives 12 twelfths for the whole) — or, it is simply 1/3 of ¼. Then, they might see the case of dividing a whole number by a fraction. For instance, dividing 2 by ¼ is equivalent to answering the question “How many quarters are there in 2?”. There are 4 quarters in 1 (here, we consider 1 as being the whole), so there are 8 quarters in 2. They may then learn more complex divisions such as 4 <em>÷ </em>2/5, seeing that because there are 20 fifths in 4, this division is equivalent to 20 <em>÷ </em>2. However, as soon as children are taught the method for <strong>dividing fractions by fractions</strong> as “<em>a/b ÷ c/d = a/b × d/c</em>” (“flip and multiply”), they are strangely regarded as not being able to deal any more with <em>a ÷ b/c</em> without rewriting it as <em>a/1 ÷ b/c = a/1 × c/b</em>. This is as if multiplication and division of an integer by a fraction couldn’t be worked out anymore without using the corresponding general ‘method’.</p><p>The <strong>gradient (or slope in American English) of a line </strong>quantifies the steepness of a line, namely, it gives by how much the line goes up or down (vertical change) going from left to right between two points 1 unit apart horizontally. The gradient is the number in the equation of a line written in the form <em>y = mx + c</em> (or <em>y = mx + b</em> in the USA). There are different ways to show that <em>m</em> is the coefficient of proportionality between any change in <em>x</em> and the corresponding change in <em>y</em>. One is geometric; it shows that whatever two points we choose on the line, the right triangles formed with the line segment between the two points, a horizontal and a vertical segments (see the diagram below) are all similar (they all have the same angle measures). It follows that their sides are in the same proportions. We can start with two points that are 1 unit apart horizontally and call <em>m</em> the change in <em>y</em> going from the point on the left to that on the right. Then, choosing a third point that is at a distance of <em>k</em> units from the first point on the left, then this third point is at a vertical distance <em>k × m</em> from the first point. To illustrate the meaning of the gradient (slope) <em>m</em>, we can therefore draw arrows that show that a difference Δ<em>x</em> between the <em>x</em>-coordinates of two points on the line corresponds to a difference in their y-coordinates <em>Δy = m Δx</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/366/1*pLL8FLBhPMyn7-FlN5hRIQ.png" /></figure><p>However, in many textbooks and websites, the arrows are drawn on the ‘other’ right triangle, so that we ‘read’ the change in <em>y</em> first, and then the change in <em>x</em>, as shown below.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/404/1*allet8q7pV8ET6P9Ltw5Pw.png" /></figure><p>It doesn’t make much sense from a conceptual point of view, so why is it used? Because it’s much closer to the formula to calculate <em>m: m = Δy/Δx</em>; as <em>Δy</em> comes first in the equation, it’s better to indicate it first… and never mind if we remove the opportunity from students to consolidate their understanding of the meaning of <em>m</em>, which explains why we calculate it this way.</p><p><strong>Powers of powers.</strong> When a monomial (a product of a constant and variables raised to different powers) is raised to a power, then each factor of the monomial is raised to that power. It becomes very clear when e.g. <em>(a⁴b²)³</em> is rewritten as <em>(a⁴b²) (a⁴b²) (a⁴b²)</em>, which gives, using the commutativity and associativity of multiplication: <em>(a⁴)³×(b²)³=a¹²b⁶</em>. The general rule is then written as</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/198/1*iGALL2zDzFEidRp-hFaRRQ.png" /></figure><p>However, when solving e.g. <em>(3x³y⁵)²</em>, some students may be taught to simply apply the general rule and be told by their teacher to first rewrite this as <em>(3¹x³y⁵)² — </em>because the risk is high they forget to square the 3. It is as if students can only apply the general rule without knowing what they’re doing and don’t understand that we are here squaring <em>each factor</em> inside the brackets, and so 3 squared is… 3².</p><p>The general method to <strong>rationalise a fraction</strong>, that is, to get rid of any surds in its denominator, is to multiply the numerator and denominator of the fraction by a number such that the denominator will become rational. The simplest case is when the denominator is just <em>√a</em>. Multiplying the fraction by <em>√a/√a</em> will then give a fraction with <em>a</em> as denominator. With the fraction <em>a/√a</em>, however, we have a particular case. While the general method can be of course applied, I find it is a shame not to prompt students to think about the actual numbers and recognise that, by definition, <em>a</em> is the square of <em>√a</em>, , and so <em>a/√a= √a</em>.</p><p>Finally, acronyms are obviously believed by some to be the best insurance that students will remember what to do. We didn’t use them in my secondary education in France. This may explain why I have been surprised to encounter so many of them in maths education. But the thing is, I find it is often more difficult to remember the acronym than simply understand what we’re talking about. Take <strong>BIDMAS</strong> to start with. The only thing that one needs to understand and remember about the order of operations is that multiplication and division have priority over addition and subtraction (while the order between multiplication and division, or between addition and subtraction, doesn’t matter, e.g. 3 × 8 ÷ 4 = 3 ÷ 4 × 8)<em> </em>, unless there are brackets, in which case the operation(s) inside the brackets has (have) to be performed first. Powers (the “I” in BIDMAS stands for indices, which is commonly used to designate powers in the UK) are repeated multiplications, so they will have priority over addition and subtraction. However, the “I” is just after the “B”, which could be misleading for students who know the acronym but don’t understand the general idea. For instance, for calculating (3 + 5²) × 6, the brackets indicate that the addition is performed before the multiplication by 6. Inside the brackets, however, one has to work out 5² before performing the addition because it is a multiplication (5 × 5) and so has priority over the addition. So, we’ll actually carry out the ’indices’ before the ‘brackets’ here. Now, with (3 + 2)⁴, the brackets mean that the addition 3 + 2 is carried out before raising to the fourth power, which is simply (3 + 2) × (3 + 2) × (3 + 2) × (3 + 2), i.e., a repeated multiplication. We can just apply the rule that the addition inside the brackets has priority over the multiplication outside the brackets, so no need for BIDMAS really.</p><p>Take <strong>FOIL</strong> as a second example, which stands for First, Outside, Inside, Last, meaning “multiply first terms in both pairs of brackets together, then both extreme terms (‘outside’ terms are the first in the first brackets and the second in the second brackets), then both terms ‘inside’, that is, the second in the first brackets and the first in the second brackets, and finally both ‘last terms’, i.e. both second terms.”. Is it really useful to remember this acronym? I would much prefer using the area model of multiplication for <em>(a + b) × (c + d)</em> with a diagram like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/492/1*CqlAMZmq7PaZsPB1KTr6OQ.png" /></figure><p>With this model, students understand the general rule: each term inside the first pair of brackets is multiplied with each term inside the second pair of brackets. The risk when expanding brackets is to forget one product. For this, students can use arrows to develop the habit of proceeding systematically:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/468/1*MJWIkwTwKMtFZGr1Vbzfug.png" /></figure><p>Most importantly, if students have understood why we multiply binomials in this way, they can transfer this skill to the multiplication of e.g. a trinomial by a binomial.</p><p>A last example of acronym is <strong>SATC</strong>, which stands for Sine, All, Tangent, Cosine (remembered as “Sugar Add To Coffee”), also called CAST, and is supposed to help students remember for which angles the values of the sine, cosine, and tangent functions are positive. The acronym is associated with the four quadrants in this way</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/221/1*pHbpWRIP43FQogQXtbF6iQ.png" /></figure><p>If you have never seen this diagram — lucky you! If you have, then maybe you can explain to me in which way it is supposed to help students. If quadrants are used, then I suppose that students have learned how to use the unit circle to associate an angle <em>θ </em>to a point <em>P</em> on its circumference, namely the angle between the positive direction of the <em>x</em>-axis and vector <em>OP</em>. When this has been taught properly, there is no need for SATC. The only thing students need to remember is that the cosine value of angle <em>θ</em> is given by the <em>x</em>-coordinate of <em>P</em>, the sine value by its <em>y</em>-coordinate, and the tangent value by the ratio sin<em>θ</em>/cos<em>θ</em>, which is the <em>x</em>-coordinate of the intersection of the line OP with the axis parallel to the <em>y</em>-axis that passes through point (1,0) (therefore tangent to the unit circle). Once students see the trigonometric functions in this way, they won’t need SATC, because they will easily mentally visualise these diagrams:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/506/1*YmimQOna-ajC0h9q8tgRlQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>AND</strong> they will much better understand trigonometry and its use with vector components!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b8fa88e394c0" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/do-we-want-our-students-to-understand-what-they-are-doing-or-follow-a-math-s-recipe-b8fa88e394c0">Do We Want Our Students to Understand What They Are Doing or Follow a “Math(s) Recipe”?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education">Dr. Alice G. on Education</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Lesson’s Structure in English Schools]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/the-lessons-structure-in-english-schools-89762b7beef6?source=rss-5c9630fd9d1a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/89762b7beef6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lesson-planning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[learning-objectives]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alice Germain]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 Jul 2020 09:51:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-27T09:54:14.545Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When I chose to train as a teacher, I had in mind what my teacher friends in France told me, “Once you’re in your classroom, you can do it <em>your</em> way.” This autonomy was worth, in my eyes, earning less money than by working for a company where one is often closely monitored by a manager who can’t help but micromanaging their employees. The reality of English schools was however far from the image I had taken with me from France.</p><p>Quite at the start of my PGCE training, we were told about the lesson’s structure. Teachers are supposed to start every single lesson by presenting the differentiated learning objectives to the whole class (often in the form “At the end of this lesson, all of you should be able to do ‘ABC’, most of you ‘DEF’, and some of you ‘GHI’). The actual lesson should then begin with a starter, a short activity designed to engage students, and consist of student-led activities. The lesson finishes with a plenary where all the class are drawn together and learning is assessed and/or students are prompted to reflect on their own learning.</p><p>We were told to use specific verbs for the <strong>learning objectives</strong> that are precise enough to assess whether the learning objectives are met. So, verbs like “understand” were proscribed as understanding is not easily measurable. Instead, “label a diagram” or “state the definition of” were appropriate verbal expressions. What I found surprising at first was to reduce learning to a list of simple, measurable skills. Certainly, it is often possible to do so, but I still believe that learning is much more complex than a list of skills and that it is not always measurable. Learning is also about making connections and transferring skills, and this cannot be captured in a list of skills. With such a list of measurable learning objectives, it is easy to miss overarching, higher level objectives, such as understanding a concept. Take for instance the topic of speed. Speed, alongside unit price, is one of the most common rates (i.e., a ratio between two different quantities measured in different units) that one encounters in everyday life. It is a central element in proportional relationships, namely the proportionality constant, and it is measured with a compound unit. In short, it is a key foundation topic. However, the list of learning objectives for a lesson on speed can easily be “Finding the speed given the distance and time”, “Finding the distance given the speed and time”, and “Finding the time given the speed and distance”. Some teachers will teach the lesson using a “formula triangle” and will think their lesson is a success because their students have reached the three learning objectives — they will perform their calculations neatly and nicely and find the correct results. But will they have understood something about rates and proportionality? Will they have been given a chance to make parallels with e.g. unit price and understand the idea of time unit? Will they have realised where the speed unit comes from? If their teacher cannot see beyond the written “learning objectives”, the answer is no.</p><p>Also, to declare at the start that only the best will grasp some part of a lesson is questionable. Is it supposed to motivate students? As explained <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/student-assessment-a8dc49d8f222">here</a>, it may motivate only those who are competitive, while many will not even consider these learning objectives accessible. And then, what if you do not want the students to know what they are going to learn, because, for instance, you want to take them on a journey of discovery?</p><p>There is another important issue with this lesson structure: it is based on the idea that all learning is taking place during the lesson and can be assessed at the end of the lesson. This idea is completely at odds with the way learning takes place. We all have experienced that learning is not linear and that we may suddenly understand something when we hadn’t expected it. Or that we think we have understood something and, when coming back to it, we realise that it is not as clear as we thought. At university, they told us that education scientists who focused on assessment for learning have observed that what students learn is often not aligned with the teacher’s intention. In brief, learning is somehow unpredictable. As I have shown <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/the-earlier-the-better-and-the-spiral-curriculum-171bc303c787">here</a>, most of the time the most part of the curriculum for a key stage or even beyond is taught every year in England, which means that often a different concept is (re-)introduced in every lesson. When this is the case, there is no way to explore the concept further, deepen the understanding, and develop fluency. As a result, with every lesson come new learning objectives; the learning that has taken place during the lesson is assessed at the end; boxes are ticked, and let’s move on! After one lesson where I was observed by my university tutor, he criticised the fact that I hadn’t assessed one of the learning objectives. The point is that I considered that this difficult learning objective would be tackled over two lessons at least. But this situation is not supposed to happen according to the “learning objectives policy”.</p><p>A way to end the lesson is to ask our students to write down what they have just learned. Thinking about one’s own learning is sometimes called metacognition, i.e., thinking about thinking. While this sounds great in theory and some students might take this task seriously, I have observed that most often students simply copy the learning objectives given at the start of the lesson, without actually thinking. Funnily, when I slightly changed the question, e.g., “what did you find difficult today?”, many would still copy the learning objectives, not having even listened to the actual question, operating in (a worrying) automatic mode…</p><p>In addition, every lesson is supposed to be “differentiated”. This means that you cannot teach your whole class a topic to the same level, using the same material. Usually, following the fact that your learning objectives are declined in three levels, you are expected to teach three lessons in one: one lesson for each ability group. It is sometimes done by having three different levels of worksheets, expecting the most able to go quick enough to do all the worksheets or to skip the first one. However, we were told at university that a better way to do it is to already teach the topic at a higher level to the most able from the very start of the lesson while providing the less able with more scaffolding. Needless to say, teaching in this way requires more preparation and an incredible energy and teaching mastery when delivering the lesson.</p><p>Finally, every lesson should be prepared by writing a full lesson plan, including timing all the activities to the nearest minute, writing down what the teacher will be doing while the students do their activities, how learning will be assessed, how the lesson is differentiated, etc.</p><p>It took me some time to realise that what we are told during the PGCE about how we should teach is not how qualified teachers actually teach. It is valid for the PGCE and when a teacher is observed. However, given the importance of Ofsted inspections, schools often internally organise inspections, or mini-reviews, in the way Ofsted do, so that their teachers can be very efficient in following Ofsted’s guidelines, or the schools’ interpretation of them. But these guidelines are in normal teaching routine unsustainable given that a day only has 24 hours. The hypocrisy of the system was best revealed when, in my school, we (the PGCE students) had a session with the newly qualified teachers (NQTs). The latter bluntly told us: “Don’t worry for next year; everything will be made easier because you won’t have to do standalone lessons and you will be able to go into a lesson without any plan. You’re observed only a few times during the year and that’s it.” Similarly, a teacher gave me a valuable piece of advice for observed lessons: “At the end of the lesson, ask the students to write the answer to a question on their mini-boards, and pretend to count the numbers of good answers, and then conclude with ‘excellent, so 26 out of 30 have reached the learning objective’. You will make the Ofsted inspector happy.” Another teacher in my school gave us (the PGCE students) a session on differentiation, and she said straight at the start, “I differentiate my lessons only when I’m observed, otherwise I couldn’t survive.” It became then clear to me why, when Ofsted announced a surprise inspection for 2 days later, all teachers spent part of their nights to plan lessons in the Ofsted format. Obviously, teaching business as usual was out of the question.</p><p>This ludicrous system has its roots, I believe, in the league tables, which give an extreme importance to the outcome of Ofsted inspections. All the system is based on the idea that teachers need to be controlled, and the best way to do that is to standardise lessons and teaching across the country. As the very purpose of education has become exams (see <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/student-assessment-a8dc49d8f222">here</a>), and as exams test specific skills, teachers are asked to teach specific skills (= learning objectives). As I said in my first <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/what-is-the-purpose-of-education-65b17b5381cc">article</a> on this blog, we should all reflect on why we want our children to be educated and what we expect from schools. In addition, teachers should be trusted as responsible professionals who know what they are doing. Teachers would teach better were they given more trust and freedom. But I will expand on this in a future post. Watch this space!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=89762b7beef6" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/the-lessons-structure-in-english-schools-89762b7beef6">The Lesson’s Structure in English Schools</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education">Dr. Alice G. on Education</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Maths Games with Cards]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/maths-games-with-cards-385bc555b9c5?source=rss-5c9630fd9d1a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/385bc555b9c5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[numeracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[primary-schools]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[math-games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[family-game]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[learning-games]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alice Germain]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 25 Mar 2020 11:40:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-18T16:14:27.619Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Family Maths Games with Cards</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*A5BdhPcbgxuQ9OxnNf7gxg.jpeg" /></figure><h4>A. Completing Number Sequences (from Reception/Kindergarten onwards)</h4><p>From a standard 52-card deck, take only the 1–10 cards. Shuffle them and deal 10 cards to each player (2–3 players) or 6 cards (4–5 players). If the youngest player has an ace, they can start with laying this ace down. Otherwise, the player with an ace starts. If no player has an ace, the youngest player starts by taking a card from the pack. If it’s not an ace, then the next player takes a card from the pack, and so on.</p><p>Once there is an ace laid on the table, the next player can either put a 2 from the same suit next to the ace or put another ace. If none of these are possible, then they player takes a card from the pack. If they get a suitable card, they can lay it down. In the following, each player, at their turn, try to complete the sequence 1–10 in each suit.</p><p>The winner is the player who finishes their cards first.</p><p><strong>Variants:</strong></p><p>1- You can use the face cards to extend the sequences up to 13 by e.g. using post-its to write the numbers 11, 12, and 13.<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a></p><p>2- Start the game by taking out all aces and 10s (or 13s) and putting them on opposite sides of the table (the aces to the left of the youngest player, and the 10s/13s to their right). The youngest player starts. They can either complete from the left (first with a 2 and always in the right suit) or from the right (first with a 9/12 in the right suit).</p><p>3- Start the game by taking out a card (at random or of your choice) from each suit and place them on the table more or less at their correct final position (when the number lines are complete). The youngest player starts. They can complete each number line either from the left or from the right of the already placed card(s) in each suit. This will help children develop their ability to start counting forwards and backwards from any number.</p><h4>B1. Battle (from Reception/Kindergarten onwards)</h4><p>Battle is a nice game to play with young children to help them familiarise with numbers and have them practice comparing numbers (see for instance <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_%28card_game%29">here</a>).</p><p>A variant is to introduce a point system instead of winning cards: when one wins, they gain as many points as their number is more than that of the other player (and there is no ‘battle’ when both cards are the same value). The number of points can be materialised by counters (any small objects will work, e.g. paper clips, dry beans…), or, with older children, by coins (for this, you need to have a collection of small coins), which gives children the opportunity to manipulate coins and understand that different coins have different values. When playing with younger children, you can start only with the number cards from 1 to 5 to not get too difficult subtractions. The players put aside the cards that have been already played and count the points when there are no more cards left. Show your child(ren) that it is easier to count counters by making piles of ten counters — and it will reinforce the concept of place value.</p><h4>B2. Battle Variant (from Year 3/Grade 2 onwards)</h4><p>Same as above, but instead of having no battle when the cards are the same, you continue as if you were playing the actual game and continue the battle until it is won. When it is won, the wining player multiplies their first and last cards in the battle together and subtracts the product of the losing player’s first and last cards to make the number of points won from that battle.</p><h4>C. Race to 100 (from Year 1/Grade 1 onwards)</h4><p>Prepare a collection of 1p and 10p coins or of smaller and larger objects (dry beans, paper clips, dry beans, lego bricks — e.g. one brick and 10 such small bricks attached together). The game can be played with number cards from 1–10 or with a 10-sided die. At each turn, players take a card at random from the pack or roll the die. They look at the number and take the corresponding number of small objects. As soon as they have 10 small objects, they exchange them against one larger object (which has therefore a value of 10, while the smaller object has a value of 1). The winner is the first to reach 100 (= 10 larger objects).</p><p>During the game, regularly reinforce the concept of place value by counting how many points your child has, showing the correspondence between the way a number is written (don’t hesitate to write it) and the number of larger (tens) and smaller objects (ones) that represent this number and also the name of the number — the logic is more apparent above forty, but you can say that if we applied the same logic, 11 would be called onety-one, 23 twoty-three, etc.</p><p><strong>Extension</strong>: go backwards using subtraction once you have reached 100.</p><h4>D. Variant of Black Peter (from Year 2/Grade 1 onwards)</h4><p>From a standard 52-card deck, take only the 1–9 cards and remove the 3 of spades. The dealer shuffles and deals all of the cards to the players, one card at a time. Some players may have one or two more cards than others; this is acceptable. Players look at their cards and discard any pairs they have, where a pair is defined as any two cards of the same suit that add to 10.<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a></p><p>Beginning with the dealer, each player takes turns offering their hand face-down to the person on their left. That person selects a card without looking and adds it to their hand. This player then sees if the selected card makes a pair with any of their original cards. If so, the pair is discarded face up as well. The player who just took a card then offers their hand to the person on their left, and so on.</p><p>The objective of the game is to continue to take cards, discarding pairs, until no more pairs can be made. The player with the card that has no match is “stuck with Black Peter” (which is 7 of spades) and loses.</p><h4>E1. Finding the Target Number (from Year 2/Grade 1 onwards)</h4><p>From a standard 52-card deck, take only the 1–10 cards. Lay face up 1 card and 4 others in a row underneath. The objective is to use addition/subtraction with at least 2 cards of the group of 4 to find the number shown on the card above. Each card can be used only once. There are different possibilities to play:</p><p>- The player can have up to a given time to try to find a solution and then say it. If they have found a solution, they take all the cards they used plus the target card. New cards are then laid down, etc.</p><p>- As above but once the player has said their solution, other players can suggest their solutions and if one of them use more cards, then they take the cards (or not — it could just be for the sake of discovering other possibilities).</p><p>- All players play at the same time and the first to find a solution say it and if nobody has a solution that uses more cards, they take the cards used plus the target card. If two players have equivalent solutions, they split the cards between them.</p><p>There are sometimes no solutions, so, after a while, it is allowed to say “I think there are no solutions here” and change one or more or all the cards.</p><p>To make this game more challenging, you can use the face cards to have greater numbers, for instance using post-its on the cards. You can choose to number 10 face cards from 11 to 20 and add them to the rest or make two sets from 11–16…<a href="#_ftn3">[1]</a></p><h4>E2. Finding the Target Number (from Year 4/Grade 3 onwards)</h4><p>Do the same as above but with all four operations. (Children might not realise that they can make 1 by dividing a number by itself and so need to be told when the opportunity arises.)</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> If you have number cards from 1 to 20 (for instance Elfer raus by Ravensburger), you can then make the sequence from 1 to 20.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> As in note 1, if you have number cards from 1 to 20, you can define as pairs any two cards of the same suit that add to 20: 1 and 19, 2 and 18, 3 and 17, etc. and decide to remove e.g. a 7 to have as ‘black Peter’ a 13 (of any suit you want!).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=385bc555b9c5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/maths-games-with-cards-385bc555b9c5">Maths Games with Cards</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education">Dr. Alice G. on Education</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Gender in STEM]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/gender-in-stem-edfaec3b9e7d?source=rss-5c9630fd9d1a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/edfaec3b9e7d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[women-in-stem]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alice Germain]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 27 Feb 2020 09:44:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-08T09:47:58.498Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eshc8HWyDVeb0dVqdTAaWg.jpeg" /></figure><p>It has been estimated that women make up around one third of the scientists’ population, all subjects taken together<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>. However, the proportion of women within each field varies greatly, with physics, mathematics and engineering being the subjects that attract the least of them.</p><p>When I was doing my Ph.D. in Physics in Germany, some people my age would look very surprised hearing I was a physicist, and they would ask me whether I really enrolled at university “as a woman”. What possible answers did they expect? Clearly, they had not thought this question through, but it shows how persistent the idea is that physics is a male domain.</p><p>It is an interesting question to wonder why physics and mathematics are traditionally seen as male subjects. I believe there are several elements of answer, which are somehow interrelated. First, as Margaret Wertheim argues in her book, “The Pythagoras’ Trousers”, our western society has been built on a long tradition, dating from the ancient Greeks, in which the Earth and by extension the material world have been associated to women and the concept of femininity (see for instance the expression “mother Earth”), while the sky, and by extension the world of ideas, is regarded as a male domain. In addition, as discovering the laws of nature was considered equivalent to reading “god’s book”, the scientific activities and also education were closely related to the church, which not only pictures God as a man<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a> but also conveys strong patriarchal messages, in which women are expected to stay at home, confined in the material world, and not to have any intellectual role.</p><p>As a result, our society still conveys, subtly sometimes, gender-specific expectations of how people of one gender have to behave and what sort of jobs they can do. It is important to realise the difficulties that anyone has, be they a girl or a boy, when they do not match these expectations. Think for instance of how effeminate boys can be laughed at, in reality just because they do not reflect the collective representation of masculinity. My mother, who is now eighty, has often told me that she was a tomboy when she was a young girl. She spent a lot of time with her male cousin, running and climbing trees in the garden. Her behaviour was frowned upon by her mother and grandmother, who forced her to knit every day. Certainly, times have changed, but gender-specific expectations still persist. To be convinced, a short visit to a toy shop should be sufficient. Maybe legos won’t be found any more in a “boy department” as it may have been the case fifteen years ago, but the clear distinction between legos for boys and legos for girls will make it clear to anyone that we still consider that girls and boys do not have the same interests — and, as a result, we drive them to have indeed different interests. This point with the toys is not only anecdotal as children develop their cognitive skills substantially through play. For instance, boys traditionally get many construction toys, which happen to develop spatial skills, while girls don’t. No wonder then that boys statistically outperform girls in this area.</p><p>The gender debate inevitably comes to the question, “nature or nurture?”, that is, whether the differences we observe between boys and girls are the result of a different genetic make-up or of a different education. In any case, in the discussion about why there are fewer girls in physics, maths and engineering, I believe it is of paramount importance to appreciate the social pressure girls experience on what subjects they must be good at or not good at, or that are “suited” to them. And I think that it would help us tremendously, as a society, to realise that boys as well are subjected to strong pressure to match the societal expectations of a “real boy”. There are subjects labelled as “feminine”, such as foreign languages, and others labelled as “masculine”, such as maths or physics. However, a man who studies foreign languages at university won’t have a symmetrical situation to a woman who studies physics, since in <em>both</em> cases the majority of their university professors are men! It is also widely accepted for men to have activities traditionally seen as “feminine” as long as they do it on a professional basis — think for instance of cooks, tailors… — , while until a quite recent time it was “tolerated” for women to have a so-called male activity (such as composing music or doing science) as long as it was <em>not</em> on a professional basis.</p><p>Nowadays, the first barrier that girls will encounter on their way to becoming a mathematician, physicist, or engineer, is the commonly accepted idea that girls are not good at maths or at any “male subject” and its corollary that girls who happen to be good at these subjects are not “feminine”. Smart women seem to be seen by many as a threat to the “natural” order of society where men lead the world and have the power, because of their allegedly superior intelligence. This is internalised by girls themselves who feel much more normal and even more attractive by claiming they are not good at maths, even if it is not true. They internalise as well that they won’t have a leading role in society. This can be certainly explained by the insufficient number of role models, the underrepresentation of women in media (not only there are less women in leading roles but also we talk less about them, in proportion), and the fact that the vast majority of children’s books tell stories where the positive role of girls, if there are any in the story, consists of being so beautiful that the (male) hero falls in love with them… No wonder then that we find such striking differences between girls and boys in terms of career choice. Also, as for the importance of different toys that develop different skills, the importance of different expectations has been shown to lead to different outcomes indeed. In a 1999 study by Spencer et al.<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a>, two groups of university students who strongly identified with maths took on a maths test. It was said to the first group that men usually outperform women in this test, while the other group was told that no difference of outcome between men and women could be observed. The women in the first group dramatically underperformed, while the performance of the women in the second group equalled that of men. This effect is due to a so-called “stereotype threat”, which has been confirmed by numerous subsequent studies and concerns any group that can be singled out on any basis, not only on that of gender.</p><p>Finally, the influence of family, teachers, or, more generally, the environment, plays a fundamental role for girls who do choose physics or maths as a career. This is illustrated by many examples of historical female scientists, one of the most famous being probably Marie Curie, who happened to have an open-minded father. These women had to break many barriers to be allowed into these predominantly male domains. Can modern parents who encourage their daughters in their scientific education in the same way as they would encourage their sons counterbalance our strong gender stereotypes?</p><p>In a document produced by the Institute of Physics (IoP), entitled ‘girls physics action’, the importance of a supportive physics teacher is also highlighted. A supportive physics teacher promotes a positive image of physics (and doesn’t say, like for instance many biologists who teach physics do, that they are no great experts at physics, implying that it is no big deal) and doesn’t ignore girls because they think that physics is a masculine subject. The story of Julia Huggins, a famous British physicist, who reported in a radio broadcast<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a> that she started liking physics when she finally had a true physicist as physics teacher is clearly illustrating the importance of teachers in passing on the love for their subject.</p><p>During my PGCE training, we had at university a session on gender in science. Having read and thought quite extensively about the under-representation of girls in the STEM subjects, I was very excited to hear what academic experts had to say. During the session, we were first given a text emphasising the importance of emotions for girls in contrast to boys. As with the research results reviewed by the IoP, the idea was that fewer girls would choose science because science is an activity regarded as deprived of emotions, and therefore <em>by nature</em> excludes women. This argument seems to be aligned with one I often hear about the “issue” with physics and maths, namely that they call for a right or wrong answer. This would be a barrier to girls, who — please let me add ‘generally’ here — like expressing their opinions and discussing their emotions as well. It seems difficult indeed to come around the fact that answers required in maths and physics are right or wrong. A solution would be to go completely constructivist (on this, see <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/constructivist-theories-40c20de63c6f">Constructivist Theories</a>), and allow students to express their “truth”, provided — we may hope — that it is somehow consistent. Obviously, this would pose a huge problem in terms of exams and marking, and so far no education scientist has dared to come up with this solution (phew!). However, they found another way to solve this issue of right or wrong: by putting an emphasis in science lessons on the nature of science (that is, a humanity subject, which girls are so fond of, aren’t they?) and discussing scientific societal issues in the form of debates in the classroom. Brilliant, girls can finally express their neither wrong nor right opinion in science lessons, and — I’m sure — they will suddenly love science!</p><p>From many student interviews reported in the IoP document, it results that girls are interested in living things. The reason is obvious: they are programmed to give life, aren’t they? And this explains so nicely their larger attraction to biology. Also, research says, they need to see a link between lessons and their real life. And, finally, a reason why many people (including many girls) don’t like physics is that it is too mathematical. Maths is not sexy for girls, so how could physics be? So let’s try to take out all parts that are too mathematical, and ask students to explain some physical phenomena, rather than spending too much time on equations or calculations. Along the same lines, why bother with the concept of units? They are only annoying and surely put many students off. Just forget about them! Let the exam boards put the units on the answer sheet, and hope that students at some point will grasp the concept (and its importance).</p><p>In the second part of the university session, our teacher showed us photos taken by students. The instruction was to take pictures related to science. All photos of plants or animals had been made by girls. The PGCE students around me were very happy with themselves because they were able to guess the gender of the photographer for each picture. The stereotype was verified and so everything was fine. While I thought our teacher would have tried to fight these gender stereotypes, his lesson did exactly the opposite. The interviews of girls and analysis of the reasons why girls wouldn’t choose physics at A-level carried out by researchers do make such gender stereotypes apparent. However, the subsequent actions, mentioned above, taken to attract more girls into physics do not fight these stereotypes. Instead, they reinforce them, acknowledging that girls cannot like physics the way physics is, because girls and boys are by nature different and girls need to link emotions to their intellectual activities. This led the education community to the conclusion that we should try to pretend physics is different (let’s do less maths, discuss societal issues or talk more about how scientists work), as if we would have to excuse ourselves that physics is indeed horrible. Instead of embracing physics as a whole, showing the fascinating link between maths and the natural world, the physics education world shies away from the challenges of teaching physics properly. Less equations, no units, more debates.</p><p>In this document from the IoP and during the session at university, there was nothing about women like me who did choose to study physics. I have many female friends who are physicists, and certainly, regarding our abilities at and our taste for physics and maths, we don’t correspond to the gender stereotype. However, it doesn’t mean we have any issues with our gender identity. Is that conceivable that we love physics for the very same reasons many of our male colleagues do, because it explains the world with mathematical and abstract concepts, because we like solving problems using logic, because we don’t want at any cost to discuss emotions and give our opinion (especially when we don’t know the subject well), because we like understanding things and not just memorising them, because physics is about the world around us…? Shouldn’t we ask ourselves why there are not more girls like us, or, put in differently, why society don’t expect girls to like physics and maths?</p><p>Now, don’t let me throw the baby out with the bath water. Not every measure that has been taken to make physics more attractive has been useless, ineffective, or counterproductive. The realisation that students’ interests and needs can be very different (without necessarily thinking of gender) is an excellent starting point. This means taking advantage of the very broad spectrum of topics physics deals with to make it interesting to anybody and show how physics is relevant to any of us — and not only to those who dream of becoming astrophysicists or mechanical engineers. Giving teachers varied resources would be a fantastic idea! Also, instead of regarding the fact that answers in physics and maths are either right or wrong as a problem, we should underline the role of creativity in finding the right solution. There are often many ways in maths and in physics to come to the right result, and this is an incredible richness. And, in physics, there is ample space for expressing creativity when it comes to finding analogies between a physical concept and the daily life. Analysing where the analogy works and where it doesn’t is an excellent way to explore physical abstract concepts. Finally, all outreach initiatives towards young people are useful to deconstruct the representation of a scientist as a crazy, asocial white man working insane hours in his lab. Showing how diverse scientists and scientific or technical careers are is certainly helpful in fighting false representations that lead some young people to reject technical careers.</p><p>Making physics accessible is also of paramount importance. As I have explained before, the English ‘<a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/the-earlier-the-better-and-the-spiral-curriculum-171bc303c787">the earlier, the better</a>’ philosophy makes it almost impossible because complex abstract concepts are taught too early, without the students having proper foundations. And I must say that I find it incredible that in the 21st century some teachers still give equations, describing a physical phenomenon, as if it is something that must be remembered to solve numerical problems, and not as the very description of the phenomenon that they are teaching, just in a mathematical language. Certainly, this goes hand in hand with how maths is taught. If maths is taught as a set of meaningless procedures with no other purpose than passing the GCSE, clearly the task is immense for physics teachers if they want to show students that equations do tell you something about the world. And for this, solid foundations are essential. If students have no grasp of the concept of proportionality, how will they understand a linear relationship? To introduce equations properly, it could be a good idea to have students first think about or experience the relationships between variables beforehand. Teaching for greater understanding is good for everybody, and not only for attracting girls into the subject.</p><p>Trying to denature physics or maths because it would make it more attractive, especially to girls, is to reinforce two stereotypes: that physics or maths are boring per se, and that girls are not done for abstraction and maths — or for thinking outside the emotional world. The general decline in interest for these subjects is quite paradoxical in our more and more technological world where physics and technology are expected to help us find a sustainable solution to, for instance, the energy challenge we are facing. While we become more and more users of technology and dependent on it, we seem to be less and less interested in and able to understand how it works. In parallel to the increasing importance of technology in our world, while robots may do more and more of the tasks that have been done by humans until now, experts are perceived as manipulators and ignorance is becoming a virtue. This is what schools and the whole society should fight, by developing a love for thinking and understanding, not rote learning for the sake of passing tests and debates for the sake of enjoying giving an uninformed opinion.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Gender in the Global Research Landscape, by Elsevier.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> There are however signs of change in the Protestant Church; see for instance the example of Sweden: <a href="http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/sweden-church-god-gender-neutral-terms-uppsala-stockholm-lund-cathedral-lena-sjostrand-archbishop-a8129736.html">http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/sweden-church-god-gender-neutral-terms-uppsala-stockholm-lund-cathedral-lena-sjostrand-archbishop-a8129736.html</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> Cited in <em>Why So Few? Women in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics</em>. Hill, C., Corbett, C. &amp; Rose, A. St. (2010) AAUW, Washington, p. 57.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> BBC radio 4, The Life Scientific, Julia Higgins on polymers, November 2016</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=edfaec3b9e7d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/gender-in-stem-edfaec3b9e7d">Gender in STEM</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education">Dr. Alice G. on Education</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Student Assessment]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/student-assessment-a8dc49d8f222?source=rss-5c9630fd9d1a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a8dc49d8f222</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[assessment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alice Germain]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Feb 2020 15:19:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-07T15:19:53.148Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/1*vPcNeRhKIyyf9dvW1TiB6g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Assessment is so central to education that it would seem impossible to imagine a school without any form of assessment. Here, we need to make the distinction between formative and summative assessments since their purposes are completely different, as can their effect on students’ motivation be as well. While summative assessment is an <em>evaluation</em> of students’ learning at the end of a teaching unit against some standard, formative assessment serves the purpose of <em>promoting</em> pupils’ learning. Tests and exams belong to the first category, whereas the second one can take many different forms and are usually embedded in the daily lesson routine.</p><p>Formative assessment seems rather natural to a teacher who is focused on pedagogy and their students’ learning. The difficulty lies however in assessing all students’ understanding collectively. For this purpose, I found mini-whiteboards very handy in maths lessons once the students would accept that they had to write down their working and not only the final numerical answer. In that way, I could easily identify the common conceptual mistakes, and respond to them. And I often observed that students were engaged when we used mini-whiteboards, and also attentive to my explanations after not only I but also they realised that many of them would make the same type of mistake. This a great advantage since students are otherwise very embarrassed when they make a mistake in front of the class, as they don’t understand the great learning value of analysing why a certain mistake was made, and not only for the one who made the mistake but also for the rest of the class. This is one of the core ideas of the concept of growth mind-set coined by C. Dweck<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>, which states that intelligence is not fixed but can be developed through effort, and I am convinced that it is an essential message for students both in terms of motivation and of development of their potential. However, its corollary that mistakes are part of the learning process (effort means dealing with hard tasks or topics, so there are necessarily mistakes at first) is in stark opposition to the sense of competition that prevails in our societies and is instilled from an early age by parents and teachers, be it deliberately or not. It is interesting to note that while making mistakes in maths appears to many to be a sign of lack of intelligence, nobody would expect a child who starts learning an instrument that they would play it without making any mistakes. As for competition, it is often used as a way to motivate children since many of them will desire to win the competition, which could incite them to make more effort (but does it really work? see <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/student-engagement-9e9f8182c43d">Student Engagement</a>).</p><p>Schools are evaluated on the basis of their students’ GCSE results. This leads to an obsession about GCSEs by the whole school management, and, in turn, most of the teachers. The very aim of teaching becomes the GCSE, which is also the only reason why students should be listening and focusing during lessons. In this simplistic logic, the best way to motivate students is to constantly remind them about their test, as I was advised by my mentor to do. In this exam-centred system, teachers end up teaching to the test, which is very narrow-minded and short-sighted teaching. If you happen to listen to some teachers or read what they write on forums or blogs in the internet, you will find out that many of them suffer from being obliged to teach in that way. This is not what they have signed up for, and this certainly contributes to the high teacher resignation rate.</p><p>During my PGCE, I had an interview in a sixth-form college. The college asked me to teach year 12 students wave interference. The topic I was supposed to teach was advanced examples of wave interference and implied that students had already well understood the concepts of waves and wave interference. Since I did not know the students, I decided to check at the start of the lesson that the students had clear ideas about waves and how two waves add up (or interfere). I quickly realised that three quarters of the students had not mastered the basics of waves, therefore I spent some time on teaching them the basics. Obviously, I could not cover the topic I was supposed to teach. During the feedback, the physics teacher who had observed me said that I should not have <em>wasted</em> time teaching them the basics but should have gone straight to the topic I had been asked to teach. Talking about this experience with my university tutor, he told me that one shouldn’t take the interview lesson feedbacks seriously as interviewers use any excuse to justify their choice not to hire a candidate — and, indeed, they could have criticised me for not having taught the students the fundamentals, had I made this choice, although it was obvious that they had not mastered them. However, I was shocked that they could suggest, without batting an eyelid, that when you teach a sixth form you have to teach your students the answer to a certain type of questions, even if they don’t understand the basics of the topic. I must confess that this interview was the last straw that made me feel a mixture of hopelessness and indignation, which has prevented me until today from further applying in schools.</p><p>If too many tests are detrimental to the quality of teaching, the way to assess some students’ skills is also problematic. As soon as they are away from testing students’ pure knowledge, tests are condemned to be flawed. Given the importance of tests in our education system, I believe that this is something that should be discussed in more detail. Take for instance the 11+ exam, which is an entry test to independent or grammar schools. They are supposed to test the level of ability of children, and many grammar schools claim that their tests are ‘tutor proof’.<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a> Judging by the thriving business of private tutors and schools who exclusively teach their students to the 11+ exam, I seriously doubt it. Students who are privately tutored or go to these special private out-of-school schools learn how to deal with the few types of questions used in the 11+ tests and do several tens of past papers on the computer to be on the exam day extremely fast and not disorientated by the use of the computer. It is not their academic ability nor their potential that are assessed with this type of test, but rather their ability to memorise how to solve certain types of problems, their speed, and above all the financial and logistic capacity of their parents to organise these ‘extra-scholar’ activities. Testing the ability or level of understanding is certainly extremely difficult as ideally one should also test how students deal with new situations or problems, but obviously the possibilities for new types of problems within a certain topic are not infinite. Some students therefore develop a learning strategy that consists of memorising how to solve a problem of a certain type, given that the number of types of question is limited. I have observed maths teachers explicitly fostering this type of learning strategy. For instance, they teach their students to recognise the type of questions and then the procedure to solve each type of question rather than have them really understand the concept in itself. I suspect this is not because they do not want their students to understand but because it is seen as a more efficient way to obtain better results in maths exams in a shorter time. This students’ memorisation strategy also hampers some forms of assessment of understanding that consist in asking students to explain a phenomenon — students who are marvellous at learning by heart an explanation will do very well on these questions, regardless of their level of understanding. And this certainly happens in science exams where students are asked more and more to explain concepts rather than to use them to solve a problem.</p><p>The relatively recent shift from a science education mainly focused on scientific concepts to a much broader education encompassing the “knowledge and skills that enable citizens to deal with issues and decisions where science has a role” (this is the second vision of scientific literacy as defined by D. A. Roberts<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a>, see also <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/the-aims-of-science-education-and-the-science-curriculum-acc43e33ad62">The Aims of Science Education and the Science Curriculum</a>) has proven to be particularly complex when it comes to assessing scientific literacy skills. Attempts were made, with varying degrees of success, by asking students to express and argue their opinion in relation to a given situation drawn from the real world. Another area of this vision of scientific literacy is the nature of science. Assessing students’ understanding of the processes of science seems to have consisted so far in asking them to explain some cases of scientific controversies. Interestingly, it has been observed that “the richer the conception of scientific literacy has become, the more uncertain have educators been to embrace the task of its assessment”.<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a></p><p>Finally, as a large part of science is experimental in nature (although I would challenge the idea that science is only practical), it appears reasonable that experimental skills be assessed. Difficulties arise however when it comes to assess practical lab work of hundreds of students at the same time, as shown by the successive changes in the practical skills assessment system in recent years. It was for instance the object of a consultation by the government in 2014–2015.<a href="#_ftn5">[5]</a> At that time, the students had “to carry out one or two investigations from a small number set by the Awarding Organisation under highly controlled conditions”.<a href="#_ftn6">[6]</a> There was a general agreement that this assessment method would lead teachers to focus on only this narrow set of practicals, and should therefore be changed. In the following assessment system, students were supposed to plan, carry out, and analyse an investigation on a given scientific question (e.g., how springs stretch). They would make their investigation and write their report during school time. I had the opportunity to observe some lessons dedicated to this controlled assessment (or coursework), and I understand why the assessment system changed again. On paper, this looks great. Students would think of different methods to investigate a phenomenon, make some tests with these methods and choose then the better one and justify their choice — in brief, design their own investigation. But from a practical point of view, it is impossible to have 25–30 students thinking and setting up at least two different measurement methods of their choice. Even if they were all quiet, imaginative and motivated, it would be impossible with only one or two adults in the classroom to organise all this and provide for the necessary equipment. It means that teachers were obliged to ‘guide’ their students in such a way that all students do the same investigation. In the coursework I observed, students had to investigate how light is absorbed by paper by measuring the light transmitted through sheets of paper as a function of the number of sheets. They had to write a prediction of what they would observe. (I must say here that I have been surprised by the general habit, when students do a practical, to ask them to write a prediction of the outcome of their experiment. I understand that if you want them to verify a theory, then it is what they need to think of. But this is not necessarily the way scientists work, and it seems to me to be as valuable to have them make an experiment without having any idea of its outcome, and have them think afterwards of possible explanations.) They all wrote the prediction suggested by the head of physics: “I predict that if I double the number of sheets, the light intensity will be halved.” This is a nice and quantitative prediction, but unfortunately it is not correct. One can easily predict (when they have studied science at university) that light transmission will follow an exponential law. In this case, there is a certain number of sheets of paper for which the intensity of the transmitted light is half of that without any sheet, and with twice this number of sheets, then the transmitted light intensity is half of that with the previous number of sheets, hence a quarter of that without any sheet. So every time you add this particular number of sheets, the transmitted light is halved, but this is not true for any number of sheets. Nevertheless, no teacher in the school realised this mistake, and all GCSE students wrote this prediction in their report… This is only an anecdote, but it shows how a good idea on paper can lead to ludicrous outcomes where students do not necessarily think a lot about what they are doing. A change of the assessment system was therefore certainly necessary, but some raised concerns that this removal of the practical experiments from the GCSE science exam would mean fewer students studying science.<a href="#_ftn7">[7]</a> The argument put forward is that because practical skills are not assessed any more (which is not completely correct as it would be assessed via specific questions on papers), schools may decide to drop practical works altogether given their time pressure to cover the curriculum. In this debate, I completely agree that science practicals should be done at school, and possibly in the most intelligent way. But what I find worrying is that no one seems to denounce the fact that schools are driven by exams only…</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> See e.g. Dweck, C. S., <em>Mindsets and math/science achievement</em>, 2008. Available on <a href="http://www.growthmindsetmaths.com/uploads/2/3/7/7/23776169/mindset_and_math_science_achievement_-_nov_2013.pdf">http://www.growthmindsetmaths.com/uploads/2/3/7/7/23776169/mindset_and_math_science_achievement_-_nov_2013.pdf</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> See e.g. <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/education/2016/sep/12/tutor-11plus-test-grammar-schools-disadvantaged-pupils">https://www.theguardian.com/education/2016/sep/12/tutor-11plus-test-grammar-schools-disadvantaged-pupils</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> Roberts, D. A. (2007). <em>LINNÉ SCIENTIFIC LITERACY SYMPOSIUM — Opening Remarks</em>, In Linder, C., Östman, L., and Wickman, P.-O. (Eds.), Promoting Scientific Literacy: Science Education Research in Transaction, Linnaeus Tercentenary Symposium, Uppsala, Geotryckeriet.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> Orpwood, G. (2007). <em>Assessing Scientific Literacy: Threats and Opportunities</em>, p. 124. In Linder, C., Östman, L., and Wickman, P.-O. (Eds.), Promoting Scientific Literacy: Science Education Research in Transaction, Linnaeus Tercentenary Symposium, Uppsala, Geotryckeriet.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref5">[5]</a> <a href="https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/assessing-practical-work-in-gcse-science">https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/assessing-practical-work-in-gcse-science</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref6">[6]</a> <a href="http://www.gatsby.org.uk/uploads/education/reports/pdf/practical-science-policy-note.pdf">http://www.gatsby.org.uk/uploads/education/reports/pdf/practical-science-policy-note.pdf</a>, p. 1.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref7">[7]</a> <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/education/2015/jan/08/wellcome-trust-ofqual-lab-marks-gcse-exams-students">https://www.theguardian.com/education/2015/jan/08/wellcome-trust-ofqual-lab-marks-gcse-exams-students</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a8dc49d8f222" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/student-assessment-a8dc49d8f222">Student Assessment</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education">Dr. Alice G. on Education</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Revisiting the Cosine Rule]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/revisiting-the-cosine-rule-6726e94e6958?source=rss-5c9630fd9d1a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6726e94e6958</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stem-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mathematics-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stem]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teaching-resources]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trigonometry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alice Germain]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 31 Jan 2020 14:22:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-17T17:13:09.703Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The cosine rule (called law of cosines in the USA) is taught in England for the GCSE (at the end of year 11, which is the equivalent to grade 10 in the US) while it is taught in France only in year 13. This realisation led me to analyse further how it is taught in England and also to explore further the cosine rule itself.</p><p>First, I noticed that the most commonly used formula for the cosine rule in England is</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/602/1*JmzrRZft28Wyc1qA2J8qqA.png" /></figure><p>in the triangle ABC where AB = c, BC = a, and AC = b, and the vertices <em>A</em>, <em>B</em>, and <em>C</em> are confused with the angles CAB, ABC, and BCA. [Sometimes, the three formula are given, starting with this one and then having <em>b</em>²= <em>c²</em> + <em>a²</em>– 2 <em>ca</em> cos <em>B</em> and <em>c²</em> = <em>a²</em> + <em>b²</em>– 2 <em>ab</em> cos <em>C.</em>]</p><p>I am surprised that not <em>c²</em> = <em>a²</em> + <em>b²</em>– 2 <em>ab</em> cos <em>C </em>is used as main formula instead because it is easier with this formula to see that Pythagoras is only a special case of the cosine rule: when the angle is 90 degrees, then we find indeed that <em>c²</em> = <em>a²</em> + <em>b² </em>(because cos <em>C</em> = 0 when <em>C</em> = 90 degrees), which is the formula generally used for Pythagoras’ theorem.</p><p>GCSE students know the cosine of an angle as a side ratio in a right-angled triangle. Even if they have already learned about the cosine function that defines the cosine value of an angle for any angle value, they haven’t seen yet the extended geometrical definition of cosine in a unit circle. So, when sketching the graph of the cosine function, they will be able to say that cos 90 = 0, but they are probably not thinking of this case in a geometrical context.</p><p>When considering the cosine rule as a generalisation of Pythagoras’ theorem in any triangle, as I propose below, we see that it can be used to show that the cosines of two supplementary angles have the same absolute value but an opposite sign.</p><p>I propose an activity (for A-level students or top GCSE students) to revisit the cosine rule, making the link with Pythagoras’ theorem and extending the definition of the cosine of an angle in a right-angled triangle to the case of scalene triangles, seeing that the cosine of an acute angle (Part A) is positive, while that of an obtuse angle (Part B) is negative. Links between this geometric definition and the graph of the cosine function are then made (Part C).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/818/1*iEiTZ-qv7aJpgbRAYqNCEQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/818/1*hZ4VB-_GoX6QqPrqhgKdRw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/818/1*OP7OCvrObLwv3RAKEwB-jQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/782/1*6WKXzaAqT4Ra560JsNqvxQ.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6726e94e6958" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education/revisiting-the-cosine-rule-6726e94e6958">Revisiting the Cosine Rule</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/dr-alice-g-on-education">Dr. Alice G. on Education</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>