<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Allen O&#39;Leary on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Allen O&#39;Leary on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@allenoleary?source=rss-4de4c4131dde------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 12:39:30 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@allenoleary/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Digital + Charity + Senior management…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@allenoleary/digital-charity-senior-management-73efd4b01620?source=rss-4de4c4131dde------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/73efd4b01620</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[digital]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[charity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Allen O'Leary]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Nov 2017 14:48:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-11-23T14:48:40.767Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>All are connected. That’s the fantasy. Cheap broadband, a pocketful of android, the social savvy of the preteen. Lovely ideas but reality is so much messier. Broadband is not cheap if you buy it ad-hoc, as you must do it you are poor. Phones are cheap but they need data access to make them effective and mobile data is the last bastion of the profiteering networks. My teen knows a lot about how to use his phone to watch youtube but his understanding of how it all works is minimal — you have to have spent a little time coding to get how hand-stitched the digital world is.</p><p>But the worst simplification of this type is the <em>senior with the ipad</em>. This version of the digital myth has it that someone with an ipad (other tablets may be available) is somehow <em>with it</em>. Well they certainly can browse the net and get access to all those services that we all love like banking and shopping and facebook, so they are consumers of digital, yes. But like my teen they are pretty much clueless on how it works, conceptually and technically. Worse, they have no idea how to achieve all that lovely digital experience stuff at a technical, design or organisational level.</p><p>Why does this matter? Because that group of users is still in charge in most charities. And they are also on the board. There’s a closed loop here — people without a clue talking to people without a clue about something that is going to sink their charity is they don’t get it right.</p><p>I am being quite hard on this group but l feel that I am allowed as l sit on the very outside edge of it. I have just tipped into my fifties. That doesn’t make me a senior demographically but I would argue that the vast majority of 50 year olds have limited digital understanding. For the record I am currently a digital stratgist and programme manager and have spent the last twenty years in digital, mostly designing, running, building and even selling websites. I have also done my share of email and social marketing.</p><p>I am up with digital largely because of early career failures. I built my first website when I was thirty and had just abandoned the tenuous career of being an actor. While my peers were forging ahead in the careers that were fashionable at the time (journalism, film) I was starting again taking baby steps in this strange new world that came squarking at you down the end of a phone line. I am old enough to remember AltaVista, the browser wars, the dotcom bubble. I remember (with great happiness) when CSS was introduced and the powerful feeling of connecting a website to a database for the first time. I am lucky enough to understand digital from the &lt;html&gt; tag up.</p><p>I doubt there are very many people older than me who had this experience (this luxury) and that makes me an outlier — an oldish person who understands what this digital thing is and had an inkling from the early days about how much it was going to blow the world up. I can think of two people out of my peer group who are inside digital properly, the rest have absolutely no idea what it is I do.</p><p>For the last ten years my bosses have always been younger than me and they are getting younger as I get older. Partly this is because I am not ‘management material’ and I am awful at career planning, I just tend to take the next job that looks interesting. The good thing about this is that it gives me great visibility of the digital nous of the next generation or two down. It’s very very good. People who select digital as a career in their early twenties and have any ability are really hitting their stride in their mid thirties. And I am pleased to say that four out of five of my last bosses were excellent — and they were also women; bonus!</p><p>This layer of the management chain are generally brilliant. The Heads of Digital and Marketing and Comms, the lead consultants, they are all great. The key issue is that the Venn diagram area that includes senior management and those that get digital from the ground up contains close to zero members.</p><p>You may argue that you don’t need to know the nuts and bolts of something to manage it, but we are not talking about checkouts at Tesco, we are talking about a primary shift in the way business is done. I don’t think that senior leaders really get it when we say ‘your digital estate is your organisation’. It’s a challenging thing to hear because, to a person without sufficient digital understanding, the implication is I am saying is ‘You now do not understand how your organisation needs to function in the world.’ Actually it’s not even implied, that is exactly what I am saying.</p><p>When you put the heat on senior management there are two ways they react. Nine out of ten nod, and ignore you and then hope you will go away and one out of ten gets what you are saying and tries to help you but then run into the death squad of digital (the board).</p><p>It’s a structural problem. The whole career arc of doing your time and climbing the ladder, plays against the understanding of digital in an organisation. That 35 year old woman who heads up the web team, or the digital marketing team, should be in a senior position making the case for digital. No, better than that, they should be<em> directly calling the shots</em> on those key transformation projects that will make or break the organisation.</p><p>If you are a senior manager and you don’t have one of those clever young people in the top layer of your organisation then you really have to ask yourself why. You are probably scared, you probably think that they are being unfairly favoured. Well you need to get over that because if you don’t do that you will find yourself eaten by competitors.</p><p>Charities are vulnerable, not just from the donor environment but also from ‘amateurs’. That guy on YouTube who also runs a Facebook group. That woman at the school gate with the school mums in a turbulent and active Whatsapp group. Formal and informal blend and it’s multiplied by network effects and passion. And money goes to the most connected not the most deserving, it’s a confused and crazy world for charities at the moment. People trust brands less and less and people with faces and presence more and more.</p><p>Charities are still reliant overly on their regular ‘principled’ donors, the radio four set. We are not engaging sufficiently with younger people. Yes it’s hard — it’s hard for me to get follow along and I’ve been watching and doing this stuff for years, so it must be really difficult if you have no understanding of this stuff. The temptation to bury your head in the sand and wait for retirement must be huge. But if you do that you are failing your organisation and it’s beneficiaries. Charities who are not looking at their thirtysomethings as leaders are missing the boat and will get simply become irrelevant.</p><p>Of course the seniors with ipads in leadership roles have plenty to offer, but to safeguard the future of their benefit the main thing they should be giving their younger and digitally more savvy charges is <em>support</em> and <em>a chance.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=73efd4b01620" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[From Personae to Narrative Experience Mapping]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@allenoleary/from-personae-to-narrative-experience-mapping-54eff2c2845c?source=rss-4de4c4131dde------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/54eff2c2845c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[usability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-marketing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Allen O'Leary]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 May 2017 07:46:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-05-03T07:46:11.825Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>User Personas</h3><p>We get this. We carefully profile our users to develop personsae that we can design to. I don’t have any argument with that, good job. But we need to take it <em>two</em> steps further.</p><h3>Step one: Develop Site Personas</h3><p>The first is to be really brave and write yourself a persona of your site as it is now. Take a step back and try to see your site with anthropomorphic eyes (your users do this). Does that theme you downloaded look like a cheap suit? Does that clip art make you look like you are wearing an old tie, or your dads? How about the writing, do you sound like a salesperson? Like a cold caller with your ‘optimised solutions’ and ‘unique personalisation’.</p><p>Go on, go the whole way and ask yourself —<em> If this site was a person what would they be like?</em> Give them an age, where they live, occupation, car they drive, their family profile, hobbies and a dark secret.</p><p>Was that scary?</p><p>Maybe — it’s unlikely, but just maybe — this site persona is a perfect fit for your user persona. If you’re selling to cheap salespeople then a cheap saleperson site persona promising the inside line might just be perfect.</p><p>Users make snap judgements about your site because that’s what users do in life — we make snap judgements about people too, we know in less an a second whether someone is likely to make it into the ‘circle of trust’. We look at what they are wearing, what they sound like and what their behaviour is to us. We are acutely attuned to mixed signals, we can feel instantly when someone contradicts themselves, know it when they announce what they are clashes with what they do. Except if they are a psychopath, fake their way into our circle of trust and then take all your money, but that is a different story.</p><p>Generally for us to trust someone it all has to move along together — the look, the talk, the behaviour, the conversation.</p><h3>Step two: Write yourself a Narrative Experience Map</h3><p>That’s something I just made up. A narrative experience map. Sounds zeigeisty and I can just see the article in .net magazine, or on UX matters. But since we are talking about people here let me introduce you to one of the oldest narrative experience maps in existence — it’s called a script.</p><p>Now there are people who are experts in such things, they are called writers. They’ve been closely examining these moment to moment relations of people for millenia. So why don’t we write the scene of your user and your site coming together?</p><p>Lets call them ‘Narrative Experience Maps’ because that sounds good, but these are, basically plays. So what we need is an experienced playwright.</p><p>Oh, that’s me (<a href="http://www.allenoleary.com/">no, really</a>). Luckily I am at a loose end this morning and on the promise of giving myself some related work in the future on I will accept the gig for nothing.</p><h3>Scenario</h3><p>Lets give ourselves a genre and a lead character.</p><p>Lucy is getting married. She’s in her late twenties, she’s good fun but prone to being a bit lippy when things don’t go her way, she’s someone you want on your team, that’s for sure. The guy she is marrying is charming but a bit impractical, if she left the key moments in their relationship up to him they would still be in a flat with a futon, a 52&quot; 4k and a sky box. But he earns allright and he wants to buy her an engagement ring. Lucy already has a wedding ring (her darling Grandmother’s) so she knows that the engagement ring has to work with the wedding ring. She has set a budget and has sent out indications to the boyfriend of what he should be expecting to spend. £1500. About the same as that new 72&quot; curved Samsung he saw in Currys the other day. But in his heart he knows what is more important, at base he is good guy. Lucy knows that anything more expensive would seem greedy and anyway something too big will overpower the wedding ring and that’s not how it’s meant to work.</p><p>So she wants an engagement ring to go with an ornate diamond and sapphire ring, for about £1500, and of course, like anything that you need to wear for life, she wants to see it first. That’s our genre then, high-value B2C ecommerce.</p><p>To distract herself from her horrible job in middle management inside the NHS she idly plays with her ipad while sitting next to her husband to be while he watches the latest Netflix boxset. She angles her body slightly away from husband to be so he can’t see the screen and uses her second best friend, Goggle Shopping, to see what she can find under ‘Diamond Engagement Ring London’.</p><p>So far so good. But what I want you to do is cue up your Google search results like they were real people. Put ten people in a room in order. Remember that this is what you are doing to your user, you are meeting her cold and you are competing with nine or so other people to get their trust. Not money yet, trust. As in all good personal relationships talk about money comes later.</p><p>So now let’s go back to Lucy. She walks around the first three guys, barely looking at them .They are standing on a gold plated winners dias which they have obviously paid for — she thinks that they are trying too hard. This is about a ring, a commitment for life, not a discount! She then goes to the first man standing in the room. Let the Narrative Experience Map begin…</p><h3>Narrative Experience Map: The search for Lucy’s engagment ring</h3><pre>Lucy approaches the the first man she comes to. <br>She goes to shake the hand of STANMORE but he leaves<br>his hand by his side and looks over her shoulder, wondering<br>whether, perhaps, her boss might be with her. He is dressed <br>in an immaculate Hugo Boss suit and looks a million krugerands, <br>but he is unable to smile.</pre><pre>              LUCY<br>    Oh hi, I was wondering if you sold<br>    Wedding rings?<br>    <br>              STANMORE<br>    We import the finest diamonds in <br>    the world from South Africa and sell <br>    them to jewelers throughout Europe.<br>    <br>              LUCY<br>    Not rings?</pre><pre>Stanmore grimaces, as if he&#39;s been asked to wear Lynx.</pre><pre>              STANMORE<br>    Heavens no. We&#39;re about diamonds.<br>    <br>              LUCY<br>    Well them, since you&#39;re so smart, how<br>    about you give me a bit of advice on<br>    what to look for in a diamond?<br>    <br>              STANMORE<br>    That would be beneath me.<br>    <br>              LUCY<br>              (losing patience)<br>    Then why are you in the room?</pre><pre>              STANMORE<br>    I was asking myself the same thing<br>    why are you in the room?<br>    <br>              LUCY<br>    I invited you in.<br>    <br>              STANMORE<br>    Irrelevant. You are wasting my time.<br>    <br>              LUCY<br>    It&#39;s my time! (mutters) Wanker...<br>    <br>She moves on to the next figure in the room, a beautifully <br>coiffured blonde who Lucy recognises as a famous actor, <br>NICOLE BLANCHET. NICOLE has this strange aura, her <br>hair seems to move by itself, and she is wearing the largest <br>diamond necklace Lucy has ever seen.</pre><pre>After a moment of excitement Lucy gets worried. <br>She feels underdressed. NICOLE is wearing a Valentino<br>bias cut gown in silk with nothing visible in the way<br>of underwear. Lucy is wearing a comfy cotton dress<br>from Boden in a colorful summer print.</pre><pre>               LUCY<br>  Hello?<br>  <br>               NICOLE<br>  Aspiration! Lifestyle! Beauty!<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  You&#39;re Nicole Blanchett right?<br>  <br>              NICOLE<br>  Yes, and I embody all that this brand is to you. <br>  You want to be me. Class. Sophistication. Elegance.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Well I&#39;d settle for a Semi in Richmond <br>  actually, and three kids and a dog. <br>  <br>              NICOLE<br>  Monaco. Seychelles. I support charity.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Right. Ummm, I was wondering if you did <br>  engagment rings?<br>  <br>              NICOLE<br>  We are all about engagement rings. <br>  Heritage. Tradition. Family.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  How about Romance?<br>  <br>              NICOLE  <br>  Of course darling. Romance. Lifestyle. <br>  Class.<br>  <br>Nicole gets out a photo album and shows Lucy <br>lots of photos of herself wearing rings. <br>And necklaces and bracelets. Lucy purrs <br>approvingly.</pre><pre>              NICOLE<br>  Aren&#39;t they beautiful! Just like me!  <br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Undeniably beautiful. Have you got <br>  anything around the two thousand mark? </pre><pre>              NICOLE<br>  (looks at Lucy for the first time, with pity)<br>  There aren&#39;t any prices. Not here.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Oh. How come?<br>  <br>              NICOLE<br>  If you come into our exclusive Bond <br>  Street showroom we can get a saleswoman <br>  to gaze at you witheringly and make you <br>  feel like scum in the hope that<br>  your boyfriend will be humiliated <br>  into spending £5000, what do you say?</pre><pre>              LUCY<br>              (fleeing)<br>  Love your work! Bye!<br>  <br>              NICOLE<br>  Aspiration! Lifestyle! Beauty!<br>  <br>After that humiliation Lucy desides to skip the next <br>woman, a sultry dark-eyed brunette who looks like she<br>hasn&#39;t changed her eye liner since the sixties.</pre><pre>The next one down is a bouncy young man who thrusts<br>his hand out at Lucy like he&#39;s a puppy looking for<br>a playmate. Meet LIONEL. He&#39;s wearing a shiny suit, <br>but frankly after the drubbing her ego has taken <br>from the high end she&#39;s ready for something different.</pre><pre>              LIONEL<br>  Sister!<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Brother! Engagement rings please!<br>  <br>              LIONEL<br>  Rings yeah? We got LOADS of rings.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Oh good, show me...<br>  <br>              LIONEL<br>  We got a warehouse out near Luton, but <br>  I got some photos here, hundreds of them.<br>  <br>He pulls out a shoe box full of six by fours. <br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  I wanted something in platinum, a simple <br>  setting, with small diamond, about £1500. <br>  Can you do that?<br>  <br>              LIONEL<br>  Yeah, course we can, hold on...</pre><pre>Lionel starts to flick through the photos. They all seem <br>to be jumbled and in no particular order.</pre><pre>              LIONEL<br>  Hold on, won&#39;t be a minute... I&#39;m sure <br>  we&#39;ve got... here you are!<br>  <br>He holds up a photo and gives it to Lucy. <br>She looks at it. It&#39;s not very clear, looks like <br>it was taken on a smart phone on someone&#39;s<br>kitchen bench.</pre><pre>              LUCY<br>  Have you got a better photo?<br>  <br>              LIONEL<br>  No. But this is defintely the one you<br>  are looking for. All the girls are<br>  getting this one.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Are they? Which &#39;girls&#39; are these?<br>  <br>              LIONEL<br>  All of them. The lot. Take my word for it.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  So could I see this product?<br>  <br>              LIONEL<br>  Nah. It&#39;s a warehouse we have. <br>  No shops. Keeps the prices down.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Right. So how much is this one?<br>  <br>              LIONEL<br>  £1500. Or, special on today, you <br>  could buy this and get another <br>  item of the same value for half price.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Or, you could just give me a quarter <br>  off this item.<br>  <br>              LIONEL<br>  (suspicious)<br>  What?<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  %25 of £1500 is the same discount <br>  as %50 of half of £3000.<br>  <br>              LIONEL<br>  Is it?<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  And I don&#39;t need two engagement <br>  rings.<br>  <br>              LIONEL<br>  Not yet innit!<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  (losing patience)<br>  And is it a blood diamond?<br>  <br>              LIONEL<br>  All our stuff is real diamond, <br>  blood, I don&#39;t know what you <br>  are saying?<br>  <br>Lucy smiles at him as she walks away, at least he tried.  </pre><pre>She looks up from the ipad and sees she has about <br>ten minutes left before the program ends. One more try.</pre><pre>Impatient now she walks past two more jumped up <br>twerps who look like they just left school and <br>another celebrity, this one, bizarely, a chef. </pre><pre>Sighing, she moves into the second room <br>of ten people. Lucy sees WILLIAM. He&#39;s <br>got a suit on, but it&#39;s not too expensive <br>and not shiny. Best of all he seems <br>relaxed in it.</pre><pre>              WILLIAM<br>  (extending his hand)<br>  My friends call me Will.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  (Shaking Will&#39;s hand)<br>  Hi Will. I&#39;ve been looking for an <br>  engagment ring everywhere.<br>  <br>              WILLIAM<br>  It can be a real drag can&#39;t it? <br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Tell me about it! No, actually <br>  don&#39;t tell me about it, I&#39;ve only <br>  got a minute.<br>  <br>              WILLIAM<br>  Sure, when you have time we have <br>  a whole bunch of guides on quality <br>  and ethics in the diamond trade. <br>  It&#39;s all there.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Good. So what I am looking for is <br>  an engagement ring, platinum gold maybe<br>  a small diamond.<br>  <br>              WILLIAM<br>  We have a couple of options - <br>  there&#39;s a range of stock rings...<br>  <br>William shows Lucy ten large glossy photos. </pre><pre>Lucy looks at them. There&#39;s one she likes, <br>but it&#39;s not platinum.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  I like this one, but...<br>  <br>              WILLIAM<br>  You can base your designs on one of<br>  ours and then adjust it. There&#39;s a fee <br>  for that of course. But we will help you<br>  and we do it ourselves so you get it <br>  right first time.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  So I can design it myself? How <br>  does it work?<br>  <br>              WILLIAM<br>  We have this clever design tool here. <br>  You can use it as much as you like.<br>  You can save your designs and once <br>  you&#39;re happy you can buy online. <br>  <br>He brings out an ipad and shows her the clever design tool. <br>She knows the Ikea one so she&#39;s happy with that idea.</pre><pre>              WILLIAM<br>  It will end up looking like this...<br>  <br>William pulls out another couple of photos. These <br>ones are of good looking people posing happily <br>with their rings, and another one of their big day.</pre><pre>              LUCY<br>  Like that dress... These models <br>  look quite normal.<br>  <br>              WILLIAM<br>  These aren&#39;t models, these are our customers.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Oh! <br>  <br>              WILLIAM<br>  Yes, we like to go the extra mile.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Isn&#39;t that a bit creepy? Stalking <br>  them to their wedding?<br>  <br>              WILLIAM<br>  They sent them in, unasked. Look I <br>  know this whole online thing is a bit <br>  weird for a ring, what we find is that most <br>  people want to talk to us so you can come <br>  in to one of our london shops. This <br>  is an engagment ring after all right! <br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  (sighs)<br>  Yes.<br>  <br>              WILLIAM<br>  There&#39;s a boutique ten miles from you. <br>  I can print the directions if you like, <br>  or send them to you?<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Great.<br>  <br>              WILLIAM<br>  And if you tell me what you like <br>  I can have a sample for you on <br>  Saturday morning.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Oh, really? That one please!<br>  <br>              WILLIAM<br>  Ok... I&#39;ve reserved that one for <br>  you, all done. See you then.<br>  <br>              LUCY<br>  Thanks, bye!<br>  <br>Lucy turns to see her husband to be looking at her <br>as the credit roll starts.</pre><pre>              HUBBIE<br>  Who was that you were talking to?</pre><pre>              LUCY<br>  Just an imaginary friend... doing anything<br>  Saturday morning?</pre><h3>Get it?</h3><p>Ok, so that last one is a bit cheesy, but you get the idea. The site persona which includes look, language, behaviour, has to match up with the user and their expectations and experience.</p><p>It’s obvious isn’t it? But it’s really hard to get right.</p><p>Narrative Experience Mapping is one way to develop an approach to this. It’s not something you will see in many UX articles, but if you have half an ear for character it will help you distill your site persona and how it should be interacting with your customers.</p><p>Here’s a way forward:</p><ul><li>The first thing — write out the dialogue with a key persona for your site as it is now.</li><li>Pick out a competitor, write it all out and see how they do it.</li><li>Write out a couple of ideal scenarios and use them to see how far away you are — what do you need to do to bridge the gap between what you have and where you want to be?</li></ul><p>You can use these plays, sorry Narrative Experience Maps s in the same way that Agile developers use ‘Story cards’, as a reference to test and develop against. Of course you need to wrap it all up with ROI and really know what your business is, but this humanising of the user experience is what it’s all about. Get them into the circle of trust, and once they are there treat them like your sites friend.</p><h3>Advanced technique</h3><p>We know that showing clips of your user tests to Managers is a guaranteed way of raising money for a UX project. That’s because we are effectively turning the managers into an audience for this dialogue between the user persona (that tricky combination of want, thriftiness, lack of time and innate suspicion)and site personas (look, voice, behaviour).</p><p>So the next thing is to dramatise your Narrative Experience Maps. Unearth a thesp or two at work and do them in a presentation or as a video to make a point.</p><p>Yes, you will need to be very comfortable with your position at work before you do that, but it will get your point across better than a paper. Aren’t we sick of papers?!</p><p>Wasn’t this meant to be productive fun?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=54eff2c2845c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tell, show, do — the time to be useful online is now]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@allenoleary/tell-show-do-the-time-to-be-useful-online-is-now-bdbde63abffd?source=rss-4de4c4131dde------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bdbde63abffd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[digital]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[charity-marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-transformation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[online-marketing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Allen O'Leary]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 May 2017 21:16:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-05-02T21:50:49.505Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Too many charities and NfPs are barking up the wrong tree on digital, worrying about <em>telling a better story </em>and <em>making a better case for support and donations</em>. The rise of so-called ‘story telling’ strategies is a notable and, to be fair, not entirely useless development of this. There’s nothing wrong per-se with better writing and using images, personal stories and long-form content to create empathy — but really, we should have been doing that all along right?</p><p>The big upside in ‘story telling’ is the general realisation that popping press releases and miles of self-justifying text on your site is, at best, a waste of time and, at worst, lying.</p><p>That’s the website as a ‘telling’ machine. <em>If we tell you how great we are then you will give us money, and hopefully a lot of it when you die</em>. That’s web content strategy 1.0 and it’s still used by organisations that are scared that someone will ask them a real question about their effectiveness.</p><p>I have been there. I have served as digital manager in a charity that refused to look at anything but ‘tell’. Partly they were terrified of digital and the honesty and transparency it requires, and partly they used it as a wall while they carried out the real mission of the charity, which seemed to be accumulating enough reserve to make sure the pension pot was healthy. So ‘telling’ was all about PR and control and messaging, AKA putting up a wall. The problems with walls these days is that they can be scaled with one FOI, two minutes on the charity commission website, awkward questions to the board of Trustees, or a bit of citizen journalism.</p><p>So story telling, even in it’s more elaborate forms, is just that — fiction. It might be good fiction, but the audience don’t know that; how can they tell good fiction from false fiction online? At first glance they can’t, and so, because the entire internet is a first-glance medium, they can’t tell the difference between one organisation and the next.</p><p>This is where ‘story-showing’ comes in. Now, as well as your lovely narrative, you throw in a real third party example. As well as telling me you are the best charity for an issue, you show me examples of what you do by demonstrating impact, either through facts and figure or humanised examples of your work. A story about say, Jo, helps me create a relationship — I could be Jo, or maybe I know a Jo, or I am a parent of someone like Jo. More ways in, more empathy and you the get the double-up of a factual story about impact multiplied by empathy.</p><p>It’s no wonder that ‘show’ is so important in fundraising and campaigning — we are much more likely to give in this kind of scenario.</p><p>The advanced ‘show’ tactics happen in social. Here we are doing enough that our supporters will show themselves, either by taking an action on our behalf and signing it in one way or another (social proof) or by taking our side in a debate or even educating an audience in the organisations favour for free (citizen advocacy).</p><p>All good! But I think ‘tell-show’ still misses the point. Lets rewind a bit and look at Google. Now I am not a big fan of Google the company and I think US firms need to lose their ‘but the good is self evident’ b/s and start paying some taxes. Lots of taxes. However Google gets one thing absolutely right — they are doers.</p><p>If you can remember back to the days of Altavista and Ask Jeeves as I can you will remember the first time you used Google. Just a form and a button and a logo that looked like someone had typed it, then taken a photo of the type, then applied some colours in MS paint. As far as ‘brand’ was understood back then it was horrible. But it had utility. Loads of it. It just worked in a way that made the internet suddenly useful. It was a site that did one thing very well. And it was a very important thing at that.</p><p>A utility brand. The story telling and showing didn’t matter. They didn’t need to have a campaign that showed how Jo’s great search results resulted in her writing that grade A essay. They didn’t need the story about the thing because the thing itself fulfilled a genuine need.</p><p>That’s where I start thinking about a website project these days — what is the genuine need that this organisation is serving? What are they doing that really helps someone? That can be a very awkward question to ask an organisation, particularly about their online estate. Often they aren’t really sure, or have luke-warm answers. The easiest sites to get right are lead-generation sites of one kind or another because what the site needs to do is obvious and direct.</p><p>But in an organsation that is trying to help people, where there is a clear need that you can answer digitally or with a omnichannel service (what a horrible set of words that is) then <strong>that’s what you should do.</strong></p><p>This is obvious, no? Do something useful.</p><p>There are difficulties though. Here are just some of the excuses and issues at play inside organisations that will stop them doing the obvious, useful thing online:</p><ol><li>It’s hard because it’s new.</li></ol><p>2. It’s organisationally hard because people are scared of change and losing their jobs (that’s the ugly and very real side of digital disruption).</p><p>3. It’s a hard design problem and the people who can help you think about it (service designers mostly) will want to talk to you and your customers/clients a lot.</p><p>4. It can be expensive technical problem that leads you into awful money-sink projects that fail to deliver the promise.</p><p>5. You have to talk to your clients/customers and for some oganisations that’s a first and a significantly bracing experience, one that requires confidence and a robust corporate culture to undertake.</p><p>6. Sometimes you will need to change everything and it will have consequences. You can’t, for instance, have any forum, chat or social presence without someone on it pretty much all the time. That person might be very expensive, or not very happy about typing into a box all day.</p><p>7. It’s just hard, and someone has to give a sh*t enough to want to do it and those people can be rare and hard to find.</p><p>The upside should be pretty obvious though. You will be able to do something that helps people. And on the back of that it is much easier to have a relationship with your audience. They know that you understand, not because they are telling them, but because you have given them a useful (or even fun) tool to use. They know from experience.</p><p>People will not read your website in any depth anymore, there is simply too much fantastic content elsewhere, for free, to make an organisations view of itself interesting enough for ordinary people to want to read. And if I really want to know about a charity I go straight to the annual report and/or to the charity commission website.</p><p>No, give me something useful instead please. It doesn’t have to be Nobel prize material, you don’t have to reinvent the wheel. It can be a simple wizard to analyse my issue, a place to talk to someone who knows, a way to find something local, a way to add to my knowledge, an opportunity finder, a matching service, a filter, a targeted reminder system, a booking system… something that is relevant to your audience and that you have the moral authority and, I would add, moral obligation, to provide.</p><p>This is the insight that lies at the base of programs of digital transformation. Organisations suddenly get it and then they are off on the adventure. It’s not an easy thing to do but any charity or NfP that is not on this ‘do’ mission is probably on the way out. If the organisation is a very effective offline ‘doer’ already that’s great, then the need to stitch up the offline and online into one smooth experience is paramount.</p><p>The trick is of course that this has got nothing to do with ‘digital’. You have to design the best service and provide it using the most effective and affordable means. Digital is just a medium and a set of tools, not particularly different conceptually to logistics and resource planning and product design. It’s all one thing now and you have to be able to think about moving seamlessly back and forward from ‘real’ and ‘virtual’ realms. Mostly your audience will judge you on your online and offline work equally — they don’t differentiate between the real and virtual organisation anymore, and neither should you.</p><p>Tell, show, do.</p><p>Tell me your story by all means, and show me that what you do matters, but please do something really great for me, that will turn me into someone you have helped, and I will become an advocate for you. And I might even leave you lots of money in my will.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bdbde63abffd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why is so social hard to get right?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@allenoleary/why-is-so-social-hard-to-get-right-76cf79bb019e?source=rss-4de4c4131dde------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/76cf79bb019e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Allen O'Leary]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 May 2017 17:04:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-05-02T17:04:29.160Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Why is so social hard to get right?</strong></p><p><em>This is a post written with my digital strategist hat on, for a comms audience.</em></p><p>I was at a meeting with a potential client the other day, looking at their five-year old site and found myself talking about the two seismic shifts in digital comms — mobile and social.</p><p>Mobile I will talk about another day, but suffice to say mobile is a no-brainer. You simply have to have a good mobile experience or you are losing out. The stats are clear and probably your own habits of mobile use are enough to convince you that you need to have a good mobile presence.</p><p>But social… Social is still really hard for organisations to get on top of. How come?</p><p>What’s really difficult for organisations and businesses to understand is that social collapses the traditional communications and marketing professionals way of thinking and makes those operating models unfit for purpose.</p><p>I realise that’s a bold claim, so let me make my case.</p><p><strong>‘Key messages’</strong></p><p>Organisations with comms and marketing departments are in the habit of talking about ‘key messages’ and plan and deliver around them. It goes something like this:</p><ul><li>The CEO/SMT and comms people look at their strategy and decide on a number of activities and plan the messages that will promote that activity. Strategy &gt; Ops plan &gt; Comms/Marketing plan &gt; delivery.</li><li>The messages are carefully bundled into PR, marketing campaigns or charity asks.</li><li>These campaigns are delivered to the target audience through online and offline media.</li><li>The comms teams waits for any reaction and tries to ‘reshape’ it, or simply reports on it.</li><li>Based on feedback they think about what else they will do in the next strategy round.</li><li>Rinse, repeat.</li></ul><p>In all of this the comms or marketing person is operating from inside the ‘strategy wall’ of the organisation. Nothing that is not ‘on brand’ is allowed to ‘undermine’ the campaign. Where a campaign is active no staffers are allowed to react directly to any questions or critiques because that would risk them going ‘off message’. Comms and/or marketing handle that.</p><p>In this scenario the role of social is to deliver the message-bombs and then wait for their now-enlightened followers to magically hand these key messages around the internet for them. Some organisations will then use twitter to do some rebuttal and education, but it will be considered and highly professional. No one is meant to get burnt here.</p><p>This is all about social being another delivery mechanism, an apparently efficient and cheap way to ‘get your message out there’.</p><p>This approach seldom works. At best it’s naive and at worst it’s deeply patronising. People know what you’re doing. You are not setting the world alight with your carefully structured message, and the 8 seconds it’s at the top of someone’s timeline is generally a waste of a scroll, for you and them.</p><p>The comms team quickly tire of this — the activity level is too high for the return and they feel like they aren’t achieving anything. It is much more difficult to watch no one responding in real time than it is to do a mailout and be ‘happy’ with a 3% open rate. Social makes you confront the 97% and it’s a very large hole you are looking down.</p><p>Some organisations realise they are being a bit rubbish and try to up their game. They try to activate their Twitter work, upping the post frequency or pretending that it’s the CEO tweeting — and yeah, they write their own blog posts too right?</p><p>And this doesn’t work either. What’s going on? Why can’t organisations get their acts together?</p><p>There is a very long and indepth answer here (and it you are at all into this stuff then it’s an essential read) which somewhat addresses the always difficult ROI issue.</p><p>But my take on this is a question and two statements:</p><ol><li>Why should people give a damn?</li><li>Twitter is an enthusiasts medium</li><li>Comms &amp; marketing has been over professionalised</li><li><strong>Why should people give a damn?</strong></li></ol><p>Point one is obvious, but bears repeating (endlessly). Why do you matter? What are you doing to prove this? Why should I take the time out from reading about climate change or Syria or watching cats to listen to you? Can you tell me that?</p><p>No, can you <em>show</em> me that? Can you actually achieve something on social itself?This is a key difference with social — if social sits inside comms exclusively then you have kind of missed the point. Social can be a working surface. Things can get done on social. Connections are made, questions answered, meetings arranged, offers made, <a href="https://media.twitter.com/best-practice/using-twitter-in-a-crisis">people found</a>.</p><p>There’s more to say about this but you get the point. Rather than ‘doing comms’ maybe you could make a difference. Then I might notice.</p><p><strong>2. Social is an enthusiasts medium</strong></p><p>Leading on from that take a look at the people who do well out of Social, those who have influence in your domain, I’m not talking about the celebs. They make a difference by being enthusiasts. They love their subject, they love what they do and would do it regardless of being paid.</p><p>Enthusiasts don’t have guarded conversations, they share their passion. It’s not about <em>messaging</em> and <em>strategy</em>. People who do twitter well are not concerned with saying the wrong thing. Everything they say is right because it is what they want to say — they are authentic, and have no intention of being anything else.</p><p>For someone of my generation (cough cough) used to thinking about communications very cynically (my diet at Uni was french post-structuralist theory) this honesty in a open channel is disarming. Its taken me a while to get used to it, but now I have realised that with good Twitter there is no particular spin. People just say what they mean in real time.</p><p>That sounds really obvious, but in the context of professional comms and marketing practice it’s radical. When did you last tell the truth? When did you last say what you mean? In real time?</p><p>It’s the enthusiast you are competing with on Twitter, not other Brands or organisations. Don’t index your social efforts against other organisations in your sector, index against the Enthusiasts, then you’ll start to see how it works.</p><p>I’m going to single out an acquaintance of mine who embodies this. Leon is the Digital Manager at the Disasters Emergency Committee (DEC) for whom he does an outstanding job on their digital channels, <a href="https://twitter.com/decappeal">including twitter</a>. If you <a href="https://twitter.com/leongreen">check out his personal feed</a> though you find out that he really cares about social and about enabling charities in particular to understand and use it. There’s no ‘angle’ with Leon, if you’re into social then following what he has to say <em>is all benefit.</em></p><p><strong>2. Comms &amp; marketing has been over professionalised</strong></p><p>Leon works for an enlightened organisation, but normally the Enthusiast position is deeply incompatible with traditional professional comms &amp; marketing. The aim of old-school (by which I mean most current) corporate PR, comms and marketing is to <em>control</em> message and <em>manage</em> reputation — you are seeking to own the viewpoint.</p><p>The only kind of Twitter that you can do under that paradigm is a basic news and links stream. If social is a conversation then, by definition, you can’t have a conversation that you seek to control — that’s called shouting. Give someone a gun and it’s called fascism. If you’re just shouting then your social becomes just another outbound channel. How far does shouting someone down in social settings get you? The dinner party invites will start drying up pretty soon.</p><p>To get the network effects of Twitter, the reach, you have to behave differently. You have to take the enthusiast position and step outside the safety of ‘the message’ and encourage the conversation.</p><p>This is a terrifying place for most organisations to be. They just can’t handle it. My suspicion is that many organisations simply cannot live up to what they say about themselves. Their messaging puts them in a position which they cannot back up if they had to enter a conversation about it.</p><p>As social is a conversation between enthusiasts you have to be prepared to be asked questions and respond. There is simply no way around this. And this is the problem with over-professionalised comms and marketing teams — they tie themselves in knots because they are looking for all the permutations of the question from the organisation’s point of view, running it through the strategy machine and finding a way to answer the question that will keep everyone happy.</p><p>I’ve seen this in person. A simple question on twitter or facebook sends the comms head into a blind panic and into an hour-long meeting with the CEO to clarify the organisation’s position. It’s a monumental waste of time, particularly in charities where the cost of that hour is less benefit delivered to end users.</p><p>A question on Social could unmask any number of things: It might be a hesitant and stuffy CEO. It might be your organisation delivers a rubbish service.</p><p>If there is something like this that is undermining the authenticity of an organisation and will not stand a good poke with a sharp stick, then that organisation has a real problem. Social, by putting the conversation on the outside of the messaging framework, means that any weaknesses like this could be exposed. It’s not an inevitability, it’s a risk — and an unmanageable risk — and most organisations can’t handle that.</p><p>This means that comms and marketing will be directed to come back inside the traditional outgoing-only comms framework. If the organisation is built on metaphors of control, containment and risk rather than conversation, transparency and network you won’t have the tools and support to make the leap into social successfully. I would argue further that charities are morally inadequate if they don’t operate from a conversational position — but that’s a post for another day.</p><p><strong>TLDR</strong></p><ul><li>The organisation wants to control the message and minimise risk — let’s call that ‘shout and run’.</li><li>Social works best with people who will stand and talk and listen — let’s call that ‘stay and talk’.</li><li>You can’t shout and run AND stay and talk at the same time.</li></ul><p><strong>So what do you do?</strong></p><p>That’s something I will start to look at in my next blog post, where we look at how to work inside organisations that want to do command and control comms and marketing.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=76cf79bb019e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>