<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Amr Kotb on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Amr Kotb on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@amrqotb?source=rss-6ab2966f8e2e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 15:31:18 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@amrqotb/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Do you really wish you were younger?]]></title>
            <link>https://amrqotb.medium.com/do-you-really-wish-you-were-younger-df99d694228?source=rss-6ab2966f8e2e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/df99d694228</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[age]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dreams]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[goals]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[younger]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Amr Kotb]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Feb 2021 19:46:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-11T19:46:46.984Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I often wish I was younger. Not significantly younger, because I don’t think that’s reasonable, but maybe just five or six years younger. The reason for this goes beyond that ever-present yearning baked into all our psyches to be sharper, slimmer, quicker, fresher, and more idealistic. I am more or less at peace with this sentiment and have never really minded my age.</p><p>No, it’s more so that I feel like I just started to figure things out.</p><p>I don’t think I’ve ever lived a life more aligned with my personal aspirations than the one I have now. The job is just right. The partner I’ve picked to spend the rest of my life with gets me. And my dreams? Well, I’ve created the perfect, realistic system that ensures I am constantly working toward them in a way that is both fulfilling and manageable. But as I look around, I see people who have figured all of this out in their late-20s, and subsequently reaped the benefits of more time to charge forth with self-assured conviction on the right path. I am doing the same, but I’m in my mid-30s so I’m a little behind the no-longer-aspiring politicians my age.</p><p>How can I make myself feel better about this? One reassurance could come in the form of telling myself that many of the people who look like they’ve been on the right path are, in actuality, lost. I’m sure that’s true, but to accept it as a mass categorization for all such people as a means of self-comfort feels like a copout. No, there are certainly Senators and Members of Congress in their mid-thirties that were angling toward their current status five or six years ago. It’s a fact that those elected officials are way ahead of me, a 34-year-old who just started to line up a plan to one day run for office.</p><p>I have let this realization fester in the back of my head for months. And it’s left me with sincere regret of my age for the first time in my life. Goals, dreams, and achievements are my lifeblood. At a certain age, you can’t quite say that anything is possible anymore (though I believe most things still are) so it’s good to be on some kind of path, a handful of ladders whose rungs you’d like to collect beneath your feet as you climb through the rest of your life. My problem is that it took me a little bit longer than the average to identify those ladders, and now I’m realizing I have a finite period left to make my way up.</p><p>But a few days ago, a new thought popped in my head: <em>So be it. </em>The conventional response to these sentiments of “age regret” is that we are all on our own paths and that the race is between us and ourselves. While I do buy into the validity of this argument, I can also accept that as far as statistics are concerned, I’m just a couple of years older than the average goal-oriented adult is when they finally create a plan to achieve their dreams. But <em>so be it </em>because that does not change a single thing about my reality or my quest. I still need to work diligently and consistently towards what I want every day. And if I’m a bit unluckier than those who figured out what they wanted a few years ago, then I’m still a lot luckier than those who are much older than me, or who died even, without ever figuring it out.</p><p>Besides, when I’m 40, I’ll just be wishing I’m 34 anyway. And the good news is that I’m 34 right now.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=df99d694228" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[2020 and the Quest for Meaning]]></title>
            <link>https://amrqotb.medium.com/2020-and-the-quest-for-meaning-89359b88130e?source=rss-6ab2966f8e2e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/89359b88130e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[pandemic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coronavirus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-year]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-year-resolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-york-city]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Amr Kotb]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 02 Jan 2021 06:33:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-04T02:52:38.128Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aSW7aAu01zvqx3qwcdEi1Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo taken in Times Square in March 2020</figcaption></figure><p>Ever since I graduated from college, I have seen self-fulfillment as the primary road to happiness, holding out for that lifestyle that most aligns with my quest for meaning. But the problem with self-fulfillment is that it often requires you to start over again and again, which can compromise your comfort and stability, leaving you behind your peers in the great game of life. By the time you’ve settled on a career path, romantic partner, and city that make your heart pound with sincere passion, you might find yourself 34 years old, $110,000 deep in student loan debt, unable to buy property, and opening your first savings account.</p><p>But I have always believed that once you’ve identified those aspects of your lifestyle that make your soul glow, it’s only a matter of time before comfort and stability follow.</p><p>Such was my position at the dawn of 2020. Armed with a near-perfect understanding of the lifestyle I wanted, I felt my moment of comeuppance had arrived. If the 2010s were all about figuring it out, then the 2020s would be all about doing it while finally building some wealth, renting a nice apartment, and swapping out a broom and dustpan for my first ever Dyson.</p><p>With this in mind, I set a few goals for the inaugural year of my self-actualized life. I scribbled them onto a coffee-stained piece of office paper and scotch-taped them to the wall on my side of the bed.</p><ol><li><em>Get a new job in government/community affairs</em></li><li><em>Get some kind of writing published</em></li><li><em>Practice Spanish every weekday</em></li><li><em>Practice brain games every weekday</em></li><li><em>Call my sister on a weekly basis</em></li><li><em>Open a savings account and keep it at $2,000 on a consistent basis</em></li><li><em>Find a new hobby — acting?</em></li><li><em>Move to New York City</em></li></ol><p>By the middle of January, two of my most important goals had been achieved in one swoop: I got a new job in New York City. With this two-for-one achievement came my unbridled ambition to take on the rest of my list.</p><p>Within three weeks I had moved to New York City, where I immediately joined a Spanish language table and began wading my way through Spanish novels. With the help of Mint.com and a higher salary, I opened my first savings account since age 16; it reached $2,000 within a few weeks. Along the way, I cruised through goal number five, swapping weekly calls with my sister for weekly in-person meetings, pretty easy considering that she lived in New York too.</p><p>It was as if I had completely skipped that period in mid-February where you look in the mirror and think: <em>okay, so I’m obviously not going to pull all of this off this year.</em></p><p>But I’d be proven wrong within just a few weeks.</p><p>By early March, I found myself falling into that same monotonous routine that seems so indispensable to a 9–5 lifestyle. You wake up with just enough time to throw on clothes you don’t want to wear, but that meet some kind of superficial standard of professionalism. You make coffee, something healthy enough to absolve you of guilt for what you’ll be eating that weekend, spend way too much time karate-chopping that snap tupperware lid, and get out the door with just enough time to arrive at your desk by 9:05. You’re there for eight hours, and though that seems like an entire eternity to cross off every goal you’ve ever set for yourself since you were in diapers, the truth is that there’s something about the inertia of sitting there, surrounded by others doing the same thing, that makes it harder to do anything but. A certain purgatorial mindlessness devours the eternal seconds that occupy the space between the few tasks on your agenda that day. It makes you lethargic, so you drink more coffee, it makes you feel trapped so you walk around the block. If you were at home, you probably would have knocked your to-do items out within two hours, freeing you up for other non-work-related errands and tasks. But the requirement of being in that same chair for the majority of the day leaves you less productive and less energetic.</p><p>Later you may meet up with a friend for a drink, or you may make something fun for dinner, and if you’re lucky, you may even chip away at those goals you set for yourself. But the truth is that when you go to sleep that night, you know that in the grand scheme of things, you didn’t spend enough time on the interests and tasks that mattered, that make your life matter. And then the alarm goes off again. So much for self-fulfillment.</p><p>I wasn’t making much progress on the other goals on my list, but I was still happier than I’d ever been in my adult life. The handful of goals I had accomplished were reinvigorating; I enjoyed my new job and being one of the many ants crawling around the bustling nest that is New York City. There was no need to be so hard on myself. I resolved to accept and enjoy this lifestyle, this city, and this job, and to do my best to keep working on my list on the margins.</p><p>No sooner had I established this tenuous stability than I found it radically upturned. By the end of March, I was working from home. The primary duties of my role at my new job were no longer necessary due to a complete halt on capital projects. As the last person to join the team less than a month before the quarantine, with a set of now-worthless duties, I felt certain I’d be the first to go. Meanwhile, my romantic partner remained stuck in Washington, DC. The plan was originally for me to move first and her to catch up with me in June when she’d have tied up loose ends at her old job and found a new one.</p><p>The restrictions, fear, and mass exodus that took place in March rendered a New York that looked much more like Will Smith’s city in I Am Legend than the bustling nest I’d moved to the month prior. It seemed all but certain that this house of cards I had so painstakingly constructed was scheduled for demolition. New York was the epicenter of the epicenter of a mass pandemic whose scale and intensity we knew nothing about. There were dead bodies less than a few miles away stacked up in a truck in some parking lot in Brooklyn. Some said you should wear a mask, while others said not to. And then there was getting it. We didn’t know if it meant you’d need a ventilator, get your leg amputated, or just have the sniffles. Going to the grocery store was a reconnaissance mission and going to the park seemed absolutely out of the question. Meanwhile, the classic Irish bars of Queens and mid-Manhattan remained shuttered, their doors littered with St. Patrick’s day decorations and specials, an anticipated event that, by April, we all knew never happened.</p><p>I moved back into a room I had occupied eight years earlier, during my first stint in the city. It was a cheap room and it had opened up both temporarily and completely by chance. It was an ideal half-measure for a period of such overwhelming uncertainty. Separated from my wife and afraid to visit her due to concerns that the city would shut down completely, that my new boss would think I was uncommitted, or that I’d catch the virus from a rental car, I became consumed by anxiety. I tried my best to stay positive and to appreciate that I was still employed, that I had friends I could zoom with, that I could watch movies, and make fun cocktails and dinner recipes. But a more existential fear seemed to trounce the fleeting satisfaction precipitant from these activities. My wife was alone, dealing with her own uncertainties, and I missed her. Was it safe to visit her? Would I be fired? What if I lost my job and she never found a new one? How could the entirety of the world be experiencing this at the same time? How could it be so deadly yet so enigmatic at the same time? Sometimes I felt like I was on a massive archaeological excavation project, digging away in the sand with eight billion others, furiously burrowing into the earth from sunrise to sunset, all the while thinking we may be on to something, only to close each day realizing we had made no progress. It seemed certain we’d never uncover what lay beneath our feet, a monstrous entity, barely stirring under an impenetrable shroud of deadly unpredictability.</p><p>The anxiety was insurmountable and exacerbated by anger at myself for not being appreciative of my safety and that of my family, as thousands around me in the city died.</p><p>By the end of April, it seemed clear that it would be a long time before we had any answers. We still didn’t know what lay beneath us, but maybe it was time to put the shovels down and look up, with the full understanding that we diggers simply didn’t have the power to uncover anything. Why fight the new reality, why stress myself by digging through news articles and medical reports on when things would “go back to normal,” when I could just adjust to a new normal? Because it wouldn’t be as fun as the old normal? I was privileged enough to be healthy and working from home. If anything, I was better positioned than I ever could have imagined to take on the rest of my 2020 goals.</p><p>I can not emphasize enough the way that working remotely allowed me to reach unprecedented levels of self-fulfillment in my life. The zombie spell that had set in during January was broken. Previously untapped energy broke from the dam of routine and breached the guard rails of anxiety as I spent my spring and summer days at home juggling job-related tasks, exercise, house chores, and the unbridled pursuit of my 2020 list.</p><p>The eight hours that once seemed like a wasted eternity were now successfully exploited in the name of progress, and the inertia of movement made it hard to stop. I picked Spanish language training and brain games back up, looked for and moved into a new apartment (with a dishwasher!), and found new hobbies. “The Corona Logs,” was an audio journal/podcast where I recorded activities like walking through a historically vacant Time Square, which looked more like that stock photo of the Dust Bowl from your middle school social studies textbook than the world-class metropolitan jungle it’s known for. A dear friend and I pushed each other to rediscover our interests in writing, resurrecting an old satirical website we had created some years earlier and pumping out fresh articles, all while encouraging each other to pick up the pen on more serious fronts like politics for me and self-betterment for him. I read more books than ever, joined a local mutual aid organization as a dispatcher, and wrote editorial-style pieces on politics, society, and culture on a Medium page that had been collecting dust since 2016. I joined an acting network and got paid to do side-gigs in commercials and short films where I played roles like “biker,” “caterer,” or “zombie,” and even provisionally joined a zoom theater troupe.</p><p>In June, my partner finally made her way to New York. I had mustered up the courage in May to ask my boss to let me split time between our two cities, which I did up until June 1st, when we finally loaded all our belongings into a U-Haul and embarked on a journey from Washington DC to New York City; it was still the city of our dreams and we hoped it would be the city of the rest of our lives. We spent the summer exploring the five boroughs through safe outdoor activities, like going to the beach, playing paddle ball at the park, and eating and drinking our way through the crowd-less outdoor streeteries that have come to litter this strange new iteration of our beloved New York.</p><p>By the late fall, my anxiety had fully subsided. I felt stupid when I thought back to all that time I had spent excavating the unknown. I was safe, fulfilled, lucky, and having fun. Not to mention, I had accomplished all of my goals for the year, something I knew wouldn’t have happened if it wasn’t for the pandemic. My involvement in the community and writing and reading on politics, history, and society had even led me to consider a new goal: running for political office in the future.</p><p>It felt strange to say it, but in spite of all the anxiety and personal challenges I had faced (did I mention I had hernia surgery during my first week on the job, accidentally crushed my laptop under a treadmill, and ended up getting the coronavirus in November?) 2020 turned out to be the greatest year of my adult life after all.</p><p>But as I picked up the pieces in December to reflect and look ahead to 2021, my sleep anxiety returned. Although I felt more fulfilled than ever, I found myself waking up in the middle of a panic attack on a nightly basis. A sense of doom and depression consumed me, and I felt strangely alone, often dragging myself to our balcony in the wee hours of the morning just to feel the presence of the outside world. I still don’t know what the cause of this anxiety is, especially after such a record-breaking year. But part of me thinks there is a subconscious dissonance between the achievements I am so proud of and the experiences I missed out on. There is an innate reckoning with the fact that I lost almost a whole year of time with my rapidly-aging parents, who are among the people I’m closest to in the world. There is a willingness to concede that yes, I actually did miss going to the movies this year. I actually did miss going home to visit my family and sleep next to my wife in my childhood room, surrounded by photos of my high school friends and a signed poster of Yellowcard from the 2003 Warped tour. I actually did miss haphazardly making an unappetizing salad for lunch and dashing out the door in my business casual look, spilling coffee all over myself as I jumped onto the train. And I acknowledge that turning our apartment into Greece for my wife’s 30th birthday celebration, while fun, was nowhere near as fun as our canceled trip to Greece would have been. And I yield my guilt that to even be sitting here, writing this is a privilege; that I am unworthy of this anxiety because I know so many more who lost their loved ones, who were supposed to die as a result of some other cause at a much later date.</p><p>I know that 2020 sucked.</p><p>Looking back on this year, I am reminded of all the times in my life I had wished for a world where my obedience to routine and penchant for fun did not encumber my quest for self-fulfillment. Even though this wish came true in 2020, I find myself in much poorer mental health now than I was back in February when I had fallen into the restrictive routine of a 9–5 lifestyle.</p><p>I am an achievement-obsessed person because I live in constant fear of leading a meaningless life in a potentially meaningless world. That is where my anxiety comes from. But what I learned in 2020 is that you don’t reach meaning through achievements alone. The activities I thought were hindering my pursuit of a meaningful life are in fact integral pieces to it.</p><p>No matter how goal-oriented you are, self-fulfillment can not be your sole path to happiness. The opportunity cost of going to see a movie is not always time spent working on your dreams; neither is stepping on to a crowded subway car and spending the morning under someone’s not-so-fragrant armpit as you struggle to read a book jostling between your hands, and the same goes for goofing off with your significant other at a cocktail bar on a weeknight. So long as you are not spending the majority of your time at the mercy of an unforgiving schedule or an insatiable appetite for social debauchery, none of these activities are at odds with a goal-oriented person’s self-fulfillment.</p><p>So it is with great intention that I make a new list for 2021, a list that I know I won’t achieve in its entirety because it must also account for the commitments, routines, and irresponsible fun that come with leading a meaningful life.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=89359b88130e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘Both-Sidesism’ is Killing Us]]></title>
            <link>https://amrqotb.medium.com/both-sidesism-is-killing-us-1405aefe5ca7?source=rss-6ab2966f8e2e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1405aefe5ca7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[election-2020]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[both-sides]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bipartisanship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[joe-biden]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Amr Kotb]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 30 Oct 2020 14:36:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-31T16:08:55.230Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Earlier this month, CNN’s Fareed Zakaria<a href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/october-11-2020-on-gps-al-gore-on-2020-race-whether/id377785090?i=1000494354096"> hosted</a> former Vice President Al Gore for an interview where the two discussed the choice Americans will be making in the presidential election. During the conversation, Gore retold the Abrahamic story of Solomon, a judge faced with two women claiming the same baby as their own. Initially, Solomon ruled that the baby be split in half between the two women. But when one of them relinquished her claim to save the baby’s life, he reversed his decision and ruled in her favor; it was clear she was the child’s mother.</p><p>Gore goes on to draw a parallel between this story and Americans’ choice on November 3rd. If Trump is threatening to reject an unfavorable result, then he’s no different from the woman who didn’t mind cutting the baby in half. In other words, vote for the candidate that isn’t threatening to tear the country apart.</p><p>But the story of Solomon doesn’t just speak to the presidential election. We are living in a political moment in our two-party system, where one contingent increasingly prioritizes its own well-being and interests over those of the country through a strategy that often employs deliberate misinformation. In spite of this, the Republican party regularly earns the label of “side” by the media, political pundits, and policymakers. I am not talking about matters of political debate and opposing viewpoints within the realm of fact. Gun control, immigration, and abortion, just to name a few, are issues where advocates on both sides typically draw upon objective information to establish their positions. On these issues, “both-sidesism,” can be helpful, as it allows critics or policy makers to wake up and say “hey, both sides have good points, and neither wants to split this baby in half, so let’s focus on the facts and find a common denominator that meets our national, mutually shared interests.”</p><p>This type of bi-partisanship has become a relic of a distant era. How can you find a common denominator if one side is coming to the table with egregious falsehoods in the interest of self-preservation? In 1731, Benjamin Franklin wrote about a version of both-sidesism that pits truth against error:</p><p><em>“Printers are educated in the Belief that when Men differ in Opinion, both sides ought equally to have the advantage of being heard by the Publick; and that when Truth and Error have fair Play, the former is always an overmatch for the latter.”</em></p><p>Was Franklin wrong? Throughout our history, we’ve had our bouts with misinformation and self-interest being falsely purported as counterweights to fact and national interest. Consider the brand of partisanship of the 1790s or the 1850s, opponents of the civil rights movement of the 1950s and 60s, or even some of baseless communist allegations of the Red Scare. But even in these moments, the degree of distortion of fact, personal attacks, accusations, and criticism oscillated within a smaller range of truth and national interest. Today, the errors Franklin referred to aren’t just more egregious but also more widely accepted.</p><p>Where Republicans and Democrats of the 1980s may have differed on how to respond to the reality of climate change, today we have a party that is increasingly centered around denying its existence to begin with. The same goes for “anti-maskers,” people who believe that Bill Clinton is a lizard and that his wife, a former presidential candidate, senator, and Secretary of State, runs a child sex ring under a pizza shop. Or others, like our president, that have placed “Antifa,” a nebulous movement comprised of a wide range of individuals and organizations with ambiguous goals, opposite of actual White supremacists that are running over people in their cars, murdering Black and Jewish Americans, and sporting Nazi symbols while doing so. Thanks to giving both sides an equal voice, the issues have morphed into a debate on whether climate change is happening, whether masks actually work, and whether White supremacy is just as bad as Antifa. Meanwhile, the problems themselves fester, with over<a href="https://disasterphilanthropy.org/disaster/2020-california-wildfires/"> 8 thousand acres</a> of our land burned,<a href="https://www.usatoday.com/in-depth/graphics/2020/03/10/us-coronavirus-map-tracking-united-states-outbreak/4945223002/"> 220,000</a> of our citizens dead at the hands of the coronavirus, and one of the most<a href="https://www.csis.org/analysis/escalating-terrorism-problem-united-states"> active periods</a> for violent White supremacy in our history. Putting my own policy goals aside, we don’t have to pass the Green New Deal, issue a national mask mandate, or revamp our domestic counter-terror operations, but if we could settle our differences as two actual sides within the realm of objective information, we are better positioned to serve our supposedly shared national interests in safety, security, and public health.</p><p>Pitting these viewpoints as warring peers hasn’t just hurt our national interests, but allowed the side that’s running off with half of the baby to prosper at its expense. In Ezra Klein’s book, <em>Why We’re Polarized</em>, he describes today’s Republican party as “scornful of compromise; unpersuaded by conventional understandings of fact, evidence and science; and dismissive of the legitimacy of its political opposition...” He goes on to address both-sidesism, stating that the “asymmetry between the parties, which journalists and scholars often brush aside or whitewash in a quest for ‘balance,’ constitutes a huge obstacle to effective governance.”</p><p>Consider some of the significant political showdowns of the past four years. In 2018 the Republican “side” shutdown the government for the sake of securing funding for a border wall. The wall’s effectiveness as a means of deterring immigration is a legitimate matter that “both sides” can rationally<a href="https://www.rand.org/blog/2019/01/what-border-walls-can-and-cannot-accomplish.html"> debate</a>. But putting a border wall on the opposite side of the scale from funding the government indicates the prioritization of one side’s interests over those of the country. The shutdown cost all of us<a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/niallmccarthy/2019/01/30/the-government-shutdown-cost-the-u-s-economy-11-billion-infographic/#63c743d0260e"> $11B</a> due to lost federal output, reduced demand, and government spending, but mass media still referred to Republicans and Democrats as “both sides,” which masked Republicans’ self-interested tactics as politics.</p><p>Statehood for Washington, DC is another recent example. Representation is perhaps the most basic, essential element of American Democracy, a principle that is in our national interest to extend to all citizens. And yet, 680,000 residents of Washington, DC are being denied statehood that would give them representation in Congress because Republicans are fearful of two Senate votes that are likely to be for Democrats. If two Democratic senators accurately represent the political views of the citizens of Washington, DC and their existence aligns with the basic principle of representation for all, shouldn’t that matter more than your self-interest in gaining power? Perhaps the most salient example of all is the issue of voting. The current Republican Senate has<a href="https://www.democrats.senate.gov/newsroom/speeches/schumer-floor-remarks-urging-leader-mcconnell-to-stop-blocking-hr-1-the-for-the-people-act-on-the-one-year-anniversary-of-its-passage-in-the-house"> blocked</a> H.R. 1, a bill that expands voting rights, requires donor transparency, and puts restrictions on lobbying. Meanwhile, the President and prominent Republican politicians have spread falsehoods about mail-in voting, going as far as to kneecap an American institution, the US Postal Service. How can we describe actors that want to limit our constitutional right to representation and erode the credibility of apolitical institutions the same way we describe actors that want to expand and support them?</p><p>It would have been nice if Benjamin Franklin was right or if we had a Judge Solomon. But as it turns out, truth doesn’t have a supernatural property to defeat error, and there’s no neutral authority out there we can count on to reset the parameters of both-sidesism for the sake of our shared national interests. We are on our own. So it is up to us to make the distinction — in the way we vote, the way we use social media, and the way we converse with our friends family, and colleagues — that freedom of speech is not the equivalent to freedom of ignorance and that self-preservation can not transcend national interest. So long as we fail to reset these skewed parameters with the supremacy of fact and simplest tenets of American democracy, our crises will be left to intensify and our safety and security to be further compromised, all while one side runs off with whatever remains.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1405aefe5ca7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘Don’t @ me?’]]></title>
            <link>https://amrqotb.medium.com/dont-me-2b7150a9c487?source=rss-6ab2966f8e2e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2b7150a9c487</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[twitter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[instagram]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[facebook]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Amr Kotb]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Sep 2020 15:50:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-01T17:49:44.556Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*poF7Xem6hbyjbqiEjGdjvQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>I was upset when I saw the news that none of the officers responsible for the killing of Breonna Taylor would face any charges. I said as much on my Instagram account when I posted a story saying that the ruling prioritized property over human life. The post was meant to draw fellow users’ attention to yet another example of the systemic racism that continues to oppress Black citizens in America.</p><p>Well, that’s what I’d like you to think at least.</p><p>The truth is that I held my breath for the next 23 hours and 59 seconds, stressfully counting down the seconds until Instagram submerged my story into the virtual abyss. I breathed a sigh of relief the next day when I took stock of the nice collection of red, double-underlined “100”s and hand-clap reactions I had amassed.</p><p>My sister hadn’t been so lucky. She texted me the night of the verdict:</p><p><em>I just posted some stuff about breonna taylor<br>so many weird right wingers sending me report screenshots<br>about how can i defend this and that<br>WHAT IS GOING ON<br>in our world</em></p><p>As we exchanged messages, she told me about one user in particular, a friend that she had decided not to engage with on the matter.</p><p><em>I took the high road and just said i love you and respect you, but im not getting into stuff like this with you<br>if we want to continue to be friends, do not respond to my posts and try to have a heated discussion with me because i wont engage</em></p><p>I was confused. I texted back:<em>“what was the point of posting about Breonna Taylor if you won’t engage with those who disagree?</em>”</p><p>I thought back to some of the more nerve-racking social media showdowns I had been involved in over the years. One with a former classmate I had enjoyed a perfectly-shallow, jovial relationship with about the 2017 Muslim ban’s impact on my loved ones. Another with an old friend I hadn’t seen in person in at least five years, where we battled over his harsh accusations that I was playing up my personal experience with racism as a form of “virtue signaling.” They are two among many discussions that absolutely drained me, made it harder for me to sleep, and stayed with me for weeks. I remember catching myself huffing and puffing with anxiety and anger as my trembling fingers hovered over my phone’s keyboard. The stress associated with these difficult conversations, and others like them, is the reason I hold my breath after posts like the one about Breonna Taylor.</p><p>My sister texted back a few minutes later<br><em>I’m not gonna spend my day DMing back and forth about Breonna Taylor with someone who felt like her dying was okay.</em></p><p>Maybe she had a point. If I were to retrofit that approach to my own experiences, I would have avoided a lot of stress by ending those conversations before the huffing and puffing started. But isn’t that a form of surrender? Why post if I’m not up to the engagement that follows?</p><p>I was stuck on the same question. Ironically, I looked to Twitter for a way out.</p><h3></h3><p>Question to progressive friends active on social. When we post about our causes &amp; someone who vehemently disagrees responds angrily, do we engage? Sometimes I do &amp; feel so drained afterwards. Other times I say forget it. But then I think: If I won&#39;t engage then why am I posting?</p><p>I received a wide range of responses both privately and publicly. One common thread was a near-universal recognition of the futility of engagement due to skepticism of the ability to influence others, the rarity of “good faith” discussions, or how useless it is to engage if you have less than a 50 percent overlap in your views. Another thread was more of a diagnosis: that many of our posts are constructed for the purpose of venting our feelings on these matters, and that doing so doesn’t require us to engage on them because social media isn’t the most ideal space for such engagement. This thread underpins the popularity of Twitter’s new feature; you don&#39;t have to request that users “Don’t @ you” anymore. Instead, you can bar certain users from responding to your posts. Nice right? I’m still not so sure.</p><p>Social media is absolutely a flawed channel for substantive debate and discussion. Twitter and Instagram are the easiest platforms within which to share and advocate positions on social and political issues and yet among the most difficult to actually learn about or substantively discuss them. Your characters are limited, you don’t always have time to read the whole article/report/testimony, and, save a great deal of your own efforts, the algorithms have you steeped into a world of your own making that is only occasionally rocked by someone like that friend my sister encountered. Most importantly, limiting such weighty discussions to capped-characters eliminates non-verbal communication, which can create an <a href="https://dradambell.com/why-people-become-internet-trolls/">empathy deficit </a>, providing an ideal breeding ground for the aforementioned personal nature of exchanges.</p><p>We’ve heard all these arguments before, that we virtually inhabit echo chambers, that you’ll never change someone’s opinion with a post/tweet, that social media has inflicted damage upon society’s capability for civil debate. That we never have real conversations anymore and should pick up the phone or reserve such engagement for face-to-face interactions.</p><p>But it feels reductionist to accept these points and draw upon them to use social media primarily as a place to vent/feel supported, and to, with the help of the “Don’t @ me” feature, reserve disagreements for those I have at least 50 percent in common with or in-person interaction. Something about that approach makes posting/tweeting feel disingenuous.</p><p>The truth is that social media is impossible to apply one consistent policy towards because it serves myriad aims even with respect to complex social and political causes. It’s the tool that young citizens across the Middle East and North Africa used to overthrow oppressive governments and its also the tool those same governments use today to monitor their citizens’ activity and push their propaganda. It’s the perfect place for that offbeat, hilarious nonsequitur that just popped into your head and the most ideal medium for a policy expert’s thread on the feasibility of a single-payer health care system in the United States.</p><p>The only consistent, across-the-board functionality of social media in all these examples, is the ability to reach people en masse, in the same instant.</p><p>I prefer talking on the phone and meeting in person for discussions on social and political issues I am passionate about, especially if we fundamentally disagree. But in 2020, it’s unlikely that I’m going to ask that guy from my financial analysis class in 2009 for his number so we can switch our Muslim Ban discussion to the phone when a spoken word hasn&#39;t passed between us in ten plus years. That’s kind of the whole point right? I wish I could switch our conversation to the phone, but social media allows me to send my thoughts to him, and that classmate I lifeguarded with the summer after my junior year of high school, and my roommate&#39;s cousin who stayed with us six years ago in one post. You reach a larger number of people — that you may not have engaged with anyway — more quickly on the surface rather than a much smaller number more slowly and at a potentially deeper level.</p><p>This whole piece may have been an exercise in futility. I still don’t really know why I post or when to disengage from a conversation. But I have rediscovered two truths about social media that will guide me as I continue to use it for social/political messaging.</p><ol><li><strong>Social media serves a wide range of purposes</strong> <br><em>so it’s completely acceptable to post about a complex social/political issue for the sole purpose of resonation among like-minded users or substantive engagement with those who fundamentally disagree</em></li><li><strong>More complex social/political issues are harder to have real conversations about on the surface; especially when you fundamentally disagree<br></strong><em>and the surface is where social media exists; so keep that in mind when you&#39;re in such a discussion</em></li></ol><p>So the next time I’m frantically counting down another 23 hours and 59 seconds and that combative message pops up, I may still choose to engage. But I will do so with the centering wisdom that such a complex matter can only merit but so much depth, dynamism, and sometimes even civility if we are in such fundamental disagreement.</p><p>But of course, maybe I just wanted to get a quick message out there for the purpose of venting, and in that case then yeah — don’t @ me.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2b7150a9c487" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Problem Solved?]]></title>
            <link>https://amrqotb.medium.com/problem-solved-ff0c55987e96?source=rss-6ab2966f8e2e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ff0c55987e96</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[malcolm-gladwell]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coronavirus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[revisionist-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[problem-solving]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Amr Kotb]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 02 Sep 2020 22:28:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-03T13:49:31.565Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="http://revisionisthistory.com/">Revisionist History</a> recently completed a four-part series on Air Force General and Distinguished Service Cross recipient, Curtis LeMay. As with all episodes of Malcolm Gladwell’s truth-telling podcast, the aim of the quadrilogy was to examine the “overlooked and misunderstood.” In LeMay’s case, that meant delving beneath the sheen of his accolades to understand how he got his hardware.</p><p>LeMay was what Gladwell termed a “problem solver.” As you listen to the episodes, you learn that the label is a bit of a misnomer. The “problem solver” does not receive this title because of their painstaking efforts to digest the full range of a problem’s complexities, nor their meticulous scenario planning of the impact of its potential solutions. A problem solver is concerned with one thing: getting rid of the problem; all other challenges are secondary. As commander of the XXI Bomber Command in World War II, Curtis LeMay was cutthroat, brutal, and completely unfazed by the inhumanity of using napalm to carpet bomb and effectively wipe out the city of Tokyo in 1945. The bombing proved to be the <a href="https://www.cnn.com/2020/03/07/asia/japan-tokyo-fire-raids-operation-meetinghouse-intl-hnk/index.html">deadliest</a> of WWII, and human history, and yes, that includes Hiroshima and Nagasaki. We know the rest of the story; Japan, staggering from the United States’ slash and burn tactics, surrendered. Problem solved.</p><p>To me, problem-solving is a decision-making strategy for the simple-minded; it legitimates the cognitively-lazy mantra that the ends justify the means. Do what you have to in order to win; worry about everything else later. In LeMay’s case, he said that maximum aerial brutality up front prevented a land invasion that would have claimed more lives later. I find this ridiculous. Who’s to say that taking civilian casualties into account — or in other words, being a more thorough decision-maker — would have invariably necessitated a land invasion later?</p><p>The “problem solver” strategy has long formed an indispensable piece of American political decision-making both at home and abroad. In August 1981, former President Ronald Reagan had a problem: 13,000 air traffic controllers had gone on strike in protest of what they viewed as low pay for a job that required long hours and special skills, yielding the cancellation of some 7,000 flights nationwide. Instead of resuming negotiations with the union, Reagan opted for brutal expedience. The issue wasn’t the air traffic controllers but the canceled flights. Why bother with the needs of the workers if you can restore air travel without them? He <a href="https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/reagan-fires-11359-air-traffic-controllers">fired</a> over 11,300 workers who went on strike (the few remaining had returned to work before his 48-hour deadline expired) and banned them from ever holding the position again for life (a ban later lifted by President Clinton in 1993). He couldn’t have done this without his sole focus on what he determined to be the problem, which is why he replaced the workers with 3,000 supervisors/nonrated staff and 900 military controllers, allowing the seemingly-devastating blow to air travel to shrink into little more than a scratch. Problem solved.</p><p>Problem-solving doesn’t always come with a heaping dosage of brutality. There are plenty of not-so-villainous American actors and organizations who have employed problem-solving in the sole-interest of achieving their goals and nothing else. The Democratic National Committee&#39;s singular focus on the problem of both Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders led it to rally around Joe Biden, the seemingly most expedient, pragmatic, path to victory. This approach failed to thoroughly evaluate the effectiveness of a Biden presidency, but so long as Trump and Sanders do not win, then problem solved.</p><p>We don’t always take issue with problem-solving. If it’s dressed up the right way, if it serves our interests, if we decide that it “worked,” then we are supportive. Curtis LeMay was eventually promoted to Chief of Staff of the Air Force in 1961; a patriot who, though controversial, is respected in mainstream politics as a lynchpin to a historic war effort. Ronald Reagan is similarly enshrined at an elevation of reverie in mainstream politics, credited in particular by Republicans for his success in sidelining unions from the American political landscape so many of us are proud of. And millions of us who are ready to vote Trump out of office at any cost have rallied around Joe Biden.</p><p>This is what makes it hard to argue against problem solvers in a time of crisis. In theory, it seems obvious that it’s better to think through all angles of a problem and make the decision that is most enduring in the long-term with respect to American peace, stability, and prosperity at home and abroad. But in practice, whether administrations, NGOs, researchers, or activists, political buy-in, resources, and time are just more difficult to secure when a decision-making protocol attempts to rely on thorough analysis amid high stakes.</p><p>Initially, LeMay’s approach to problem-solving got me thinking about another American leader who seems to be on his wavelength: Donald Trump. The methods the President’s administration has employed to address the coronavirus outbreak in the United States are similarly one-track minded, hyper-focused on the economy while exhibiting little concern for human life. To the current President, the problem isn’t so much the virus as it is the damage it inflicts on our economy. The solution is to keep the economy open as long as possible, send people back to their offices, keep schools and universities <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/president-donald-j-trump-supporting-americas-students-families-encouraging-safe-reopening-americas-schools/">open</a>, and allow sports fans to attend games and matches, among other highly dangerous activities that have put the US in rare company when it comes to its coronavirus death rate. Let people get infected, let the weak ones who don’t have the money for private hospitals, whose skin color has relegated them to poverty and poor medical care, who are the victims of autoimmune diseases, and who are over 65 die; repeat until we reach herd immunity. The ends justify the means right? When the weak fade away, the strong will continue to operate the economy. This is the <a href="https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2020/03/dan-patrick-coronavirus-grandparents">sacrifice</a> we have to make. Problem solved.</p><p>Or maybe not.</p><p>Perhaps Donald Trump is much less like Curtis LeMay than I originally thought. What if LeMay was entrusted with the power to manage our national response to Covid-19? Recall, he thought that carpet-bombing Tokyo would be a major blow up-front that would save lives later. Wouldn’t he then, after choosing to falsely bifurcate the virus and the economy as two separate issues, shut the economy down entirely as early as February? Wouldn’t a full-on lockdown from the get-go while simultaneously ramping up contact-tracing and testing on a massive scale have ultimately resulted in less damage than the Trump Administration’s approach in the long-run? In fact, a true problem solver would have put us in a better position to address both the coronavirus and economic challenges, since they are indeed correlated. LeMay’s complete shutdown of the economy would have reduced Americans’ exposure to one another.</p><p>So problem-solving isn’t exactly the approach of the simple-minded. Ironically it is sometimes a thorough evaluation of the matter at hand that unveils it as the most effective protocol. One could argue that German Chancellor Angela Merkel and New Zealander Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern applied problem-solving to a great degree of success when dealing with the coronavirus in their countries.</p><p>LeMay’s flaw is that he jumps straight to this cuthroat strategy without thinking first. “President LeMay” nailing the coronavirus response is merely a function of the certainty and predictability of his course of action. His strategy’s effectiveness in managing the current public health crisis is merely a byproduct of its fortuitous intersection with the challenge at hand.</p><p>Donald Trump is neither Chancellor Merkel nor General LeMay. He does not thoroughly evaluate problems and he does not know how to singularly and brutally focus on them on a consistent basis.</p><p>So when it comes to the coronavirus he’ll likely keep getting the same question: problem solved?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ff0c55987e96" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Paralysis of Do-goodery]]></title>
            <link>https://amrqotb.medium.com/the-paralysis-of-do-goodery-a0f5460c63a6?source=rss-6ab2966f8e2e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a0f5460c63a6</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Amr Kotb]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 13 Aug 2020 03:33:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-13T17:10:20.970Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YmMggemuuvhCRVqTXDSmVg.jpeg" /></figure><p>A week ago, I went for a run. It was the same four miles that I run a few times a week. I have been stuck on four miles since January 2020, when I set a goal to comfortably cruise through them at under a seven-minute pace on a regular basis by year’s end. Unfortunately, I have run four miles on over 60 occasions this year and only broken seven minutes twice, and by the skin of my teeth at 6:59 and 6:55. Not exactly the comfort I set my sights on back in January.</p><p>The run I went on a week ago was particularly frustrating. The air was much crisper and cooler than its seasonably muggy and humid self. My body felt unusually limber thanks to yoga the day before and it was one of those days where you feel like you’re effortlessly gliding everywhere you go. I had been stuck on just over a seven-minute pace for a few months. <em>Today is the day I get out of my rut, </em>I thought.</p><p>I put on my top running jams, you know, that playlist you watch over and protect like a secret weapon, bringing it out on the rare occasion that its preserved intensity (thanks to infrequent listens) will give you an extra boost. There was no excuse not to smash seven minutes today.</p><p>My runs are typically when I find myself doing a lot of inadvertent reflection. All kinds of fleeting thoughts about attaining happiness, professional self-fulfillment, and the state of our democracy, dart across my mind, barely introducing themselves before it’s time for the next mental cameo. If I don’t pay enough attention, I wind up heaving in a pool of my own sweat nearly 30 minutes later, exhausted and subtly-aware that the answers to life’s greatest questions have once-again slipped through my fingertips.</p><p>But last week’s journey was different. Less than 24 hours prior, my wife had sprinted out of our bedroom to show me footage of a massive explosion in her hometown of Beirut, Lebanon, the city where we enjoyed some of our best memories, where I asked her to marry me, and where we ultimately celebrated our wedding. It got me thinking about all the examples of the overt disregard for human life at the highest levels of governance and most exposed mediums of communication I had witnessed lately. I thought about the role the Lebanese government’s negligence and corruption played in creating circumstances ripe for the blast. Even more horrifying was their indifference to the awareness that 2,750 tons of ammonium nitrate had been sitting idly in the city’s main port for several years, prime for detonation at any minute. This ushered in the next act, the US response to the coronavirus pandemic and both the cool ambivalence and overt denial that led to a spike from 100,000 deaths to 150,000 in just two months. The President, much like the Lebanese government, was unmoved when reviewing the statistics, declaring that “it is what it is.” And so came the next act, the plight of 11 million Uighurs in China, thrown into “reeducation camps” rife with torture and abuse, with some escaping to Muslim countries for safety only to be sent back for more of the same.</p><p>And it played like that for a mile or so. The Rohingya. George Floyd. Breonna Taylor. The Stoneman Douglas shooting. Eric Garner. Countless instances of blatant disregard for human life. Fellow human beings dying, right out in the open, as a result of systemic inequalities, aversion to objective information, and racism, among other social and political ails. These were all issues I had no control over, and spending all my time thinking about them was paralyzing. If my world was smaller, I thought, I would spend less time being disappointed. I kept running. What if just for today, my world was as small as this run, right now? I can control how fast I’m going, I can finish four miles faster than I ever have before. I can break seven minutes.</p><p>So I ran faster. I refused to let my thoughts rush across the stage, hanging on to each one, channeling my paralysis with the outside world to motivate my control for what was happening within.</p><p>A few minutes later, I huffed my way to my building’s front door. I checked my watch — seven minutes and two seconds. I had run as fast as humanly possible and I had failed.</p><p>So many of us dedicate the entirety of our lives to fighting for a higher regard for human life within the concepts, countries, communities, and civilizations we are a part of, with many dying in vain. Sometimes it feels all too easy to look at a place like China, where students were steamrolled by tanks in Tiananmen Square in 1989 while fighting for the same ideals that the Chinese government is violating today in its treatment of Uighurs or the passage of the new Hong Kong security law, and wonder, why do they still care?</p><p>Why are there still protesters in Hong Kong? Why are Lebanese citizens, with houses reduced to rubble, savings accounts hovering above zero, and half-demolished hospitals overflowing with both explosion and coronavirus victims still protesting the same government whose same negligence and corruption has disregarded the same human lives for decades? Why do Black Americans, who have been asking for the same humanity from our government, and its system engineered to secure their destitution, still hit the streets and the polls with the same demands? If the struggle hasn&#39;t changed, why continue to sacrifice your time, energy, and happiness?</p><p>Some would answer with “hope” and “a deep sense of identity.” You simply are Black, or Lebanese, or American, thus making you obligated to fight the ever-present plights of your people, no matter how Sisyphean, no matter how fluid identity is, or the facts that may cast doubt on the authenticity of its construction. But before hope and a deep sense of identity, is a decision to believe. We choose to believe that we are party to concepts, societies, and civilizations that will outlive us, even if they are often constructs that are far-off unrealistic goals, plainly artificial, or the product of nefarious or contradictory circumstances. In the United States, we believe in a set of democratic ideals put to paper by a cast of White landowners who were mostly walking contradictions to them in their daily lives. Lebanon is a nation-state created by the French around the area of Mount Lebanon. But its people have made the choice to believe in its authentic existence the same way we have ours in the United States, a country founded in the near-eradication of indigenous people that were already living here.</p><p>But ultimately, even if our efforts are in vain, even if our best-laid plans to live up to an imaginary paragon of American democracy conflict with reality, even if protesters in Hong Kong are part of the same struggle that has claimed the livelihoods of thousands before them, why wouldn’t we fight for those beliefs? What is life without something to believe in, however artificial or hopeless it may be? The concepts, societies, and civilizations that we fight for may not be authentic and the journey for their attainment may be utterly fruitless, but they embody ideals that make us better people. We choose to believe in them, because our efforts still take us in the direction of progress, and stave off the alternative that much longer.</p><p>So maybe I’ll break seven minutes next time, or maybe I never will again. But believing in my goal to break it on a regular basis is what keeps me running, and I never want to stop running.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a0f5460c63a6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The importance of being heard in a Democracy]]></title>
            <link>https://amrqotb.medium.com/the-importance-of-being-heard-in-a-democracy-db8184ee0894?source=rss-6ab2966f8e2e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/db8184ee0894</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Amr Kotb]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 04 Aug 2020 03:01:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-04T03:56:52.951Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The importance of being heard in a democracy</h3><p><em>The 2020 US Presidential election is less than 100 days away. As the date draws closer, I have observed an increasing number of politically-inclined friends, activists, scholars, and NGOs emphasize the paramount importance of the election as a potential savior for American democracy. In many ways, this is true. I understand just how high the stakes are and will cast my vote accordingly. But I also keep asking myself something: what kind of mature, institutional democracy, puts all its hopes for great change, the “restoration” of its very essence, in an election? In a person, or a group of people? Yes, the President and Congress exercise a significant level of executive and legislative power. Shaking things up, and away, from the far-right brand of Republicanism will be a massive boost to the integrity of our institutional democracy. But what will it do for the systemic economic and social issues we face? The ones that played a role in the favorability of that brand of Republicanism to begin with. A Biden Presidency will deliver us a Secretary of Housing and Urban Development with relevant credentials and subject matter expertise. That’s a huge step up, but will she also understand the way housing discrimination, lending practices, and the definition of the term “affordable” have relegated the same communities to the same levels of poverty for decades?</em></p><p><em>We need more than restoration. We need a rebuild in the form of substantive institutional reform. But we also need something simpler. Citizens, like those Americans adversely affected by discriminatory housing policies, need to feel more sincerely represented by the people they elect. All this got me thinking about a piece I wrote in January when I left my position at the Washington, DC Mayor’s Office of Community Relations. I shelved it because by the time I finished it, Corona had taken over the world. While this is still very much the case (as it should be), there are other issues competing for our mental bandwidth now, so I thought it would be a good time to share.</em></p><p><strong>From the Middle East to the neighborhoods of Washington, DC: Why democracy is so hard</strong></p><p>One of my first constituents, after I left a flourishing career in Middle East policy two years ago, was a senior citizen in her early 70s, who needed my help to resolve parking disputes with a member of Ivanka Trump’s cleaning staff. The bathroom in this rich neighborhood in Washington D.C. was humongous, larger than any bedroom I had ever seen, and her living room seemed more like a Louvre exhibit on Victorian furniture than a home.</p><p>The woman had asked me to visit in my capacity as a community relations specialist with the Washington DC Mayor’s Office because Ms. Trump’s cleaner was parking in front of her house. I took a moment to collect my thoughts. I had taken this job to be a force for good in my local community, what did that have to do with this super-rich woman and the parking habits of Jared and Ivanka’s household?</p><p>I came to this job from the area of Middle East policy, a field in which I spent about a decade of my life to pursue similar goals — to advocate for democracy and good governance across the region. I traveled to Cairo in 2014 not long after graduating from Syracuse University to work as a journalist, and then returned to the U.S. two years later to work at a think-tank in Washington, DC.</p><p>With the 2016 presidential election, everything changed for many hyphenated Americans like me who found themselves inspired to become politically engaged. It became clear that the U.S. was in need of much of the same work I went to do in the Middle East. I initially felt helpless as I read reports about Russian interference in our election, juggled phone calls with immigration lawyers concerned that the Muslim ban could adversely impact my wife’s ability to immigrate to the US, scrolled through vitriolic anti-immigrant and White nationalist sentiment, and watched violent demonstrations like Charlottesville. It was almost paralyzing.</p><p>I then thought about all my efforts in Middle East policy. My colleagues and I had spent years since the Arab uprisings pushing for change, and the reality was that save a few exceptions like Tunisia, little had changed, and in some cases, countries had backslid into even more authoritarianism.</p><p>If my goal was to push for principles of good governance, then it was time for me to focus on the United States, the country in which I was born and raised, and the supposed paragon of the democratic values I was passionate about. I decided to start small, in my city of Washington, DC.</p><p>I walked into the Mayor’s Office of community relations and services with indomitable enthusiasm. Where were the citizens? Can I meet all of my constituents individually? It was as if I had become spiritual and that my god, an omnipotent public service deity, required me to show my appreciation to it through this job.</p><p>I was assigned to half the neighborhoods in DC’s Ward Two, which is comprised of a little bit of everything: the hip 14th Street corridor, home to some of the city’s hottest restaurants and nightlife establishments, the upscale residential/commercial/historic neighborhood of Georgetown, and the still more upscale residential, embassy-laden neighborhood of Sheridan-Kalorama. In the beginning, I had a lot of moments like that one in the mansion-bathroom.</p><p>The issues I’d be dealing with were a distant cry from my fight for democratic values in the Middle East. First was the fact that I couldn’t really relate — I grew up as a middle-class Arab-American, the son of Egyptian immigrants, raised in the suburbs of Richmond. I didn’t know anything about cleaning staff and contractors; I didn’t care about a business dumping its grease down a sewage drain, or a rat scurrying across the street in an alleyway. If someone didn’t get my trash today, then they’d get it tomorrow, I’d sooner squish the garbage with my hands and look for space in a neighbor’s can than call the city about it. The second was outright disagreement: I didn’t always feel that the needs of my constituents aligned with my goals to effectuate change through good governance.</p><p>But I was wrong.</p><p>There is a simple fact about good governance that sustained my faith in public service: people just want to be heard. Whether Federal, State, or Local, most citizens conceive of the government as a faceless behemoth, devoid of character, overloaded with bureaucracy, and hurling forward on an autopilot that precludes its ability to dynamically see and interact with citizens. It didn’t matter whether I could relate or if I agreed.</p><p>Ward Eight or Ward Two, Richmond or Cairo, all citizens have the same core desire from their government to be seen, heard, and acknowledged. That desire materializes in the form of protesting military rule in Egypt, advocating for human development initiatives and investments East of the River in Wards Seven and Eight, and yes, even a more transparent and efficient process for brick sidewalk repair in Georgetown. And let’s be clear: the degree of the severity of quality-of-life needs of Ward Two residents pales in comparison to the degree of severity of quality-of-life needs of those communities East of the River, where the life expectancy of some neighborhoods is sometimes ten-plus years lower than parts of Ward Two.</p><p>A functioning democracy must give all its citizens the sense that it hears them if it plans to effectuate high-level change. If citizens view the government as a credible steward of their tax dollars, then we are better positioned to work together on a vision that strategically responds to the needs of underserved communities. This isn’t a call to give all communities everything they want. The government may not be able to give Ivanka Trump’s neighbor the additional no parking sign she requested, but that neighbor is more likely to continue supporting the administration at large if the government engages her.</p><p>And that realization on my part made the job a lot more fun.</p><p>I focused on three principles related to citizens’ right to be heard: relationships, responsiveness, and accountability. I built dynamic relationships with a diverse network of citizens. I met with people for no other purpose than to get to know them. I asked business owners to share contact info for their favorite customers. I asked customers to share contact info for their favorite community leaders. I asked community leaders to tell me what their concerns and priorities were for their neighbors, their schools, and their public spaces. I put together my own personalized weekly updates with this list of ever-growing contacts, sending out emails that detailed my activities across their neighborhoods. I even convinced my wife to move to Ward Two so I could take on the perspective of my neighbors and interact with them more naturally. So when residents on the condo board in a high-rise adjacent to a Whole Foods grocery store went directly to the Mayor with their unanswered complaints about illegal construction, noise or light pollution and management’s unresponsiveness, I used the relationships I built to follow up. I briefed the director responsible for resolving this matter who asked me to convene reconciliation meetings between the neighbors and the grocery store, which re-established communication lines that addressed their issues.</p><p>I was responsive. If someone contacted me with a concern, outlandish or reasonable, I followed up within 24 hours. Whether it was about Chechen terrorists infiltrating the Georgetown library or the crosswalk in front of an elementary school in need of a repaint, I always routed it to a city agency and checked back in both with the citizens and the agency contact until the matter was resolved or all methods of resolution were fully exhausted. When I noted agency-unresponsiveness to citizens concerned about public school access to field space, I connected with that agency’s chief of staff and ultimately formed a positive personal and professional relationship with him. We held different perspectives, and he was much more senior than I, but we worked together as partners to deliver valuable responses to the community. This approach ultimately earned me a seat at the table when the agency directors and the Mayor’s general counsel team were asked to brief her on the situation. In the end, the neighbors did not get the resolution they wanted, but I advocated for their opportunity to express their concerns to the Mayor, and they were appreciative of that. As I noted, it isn’t about giving people what they want or whether or not one agrees. Everyone is entitled to engagement.</p><p>I was accountable in delivering results to neighbors with concerns about city services. I hassled “core team” counterparts at government agencies like the District Department of Transportation (DDOT) and the Department of Public Works to get to the bottom of systemic missed trash collection, parking violations, or road repairs. Sometimes this didn’t result in much, but other times, I got back to citizens with long-term solutions to these problems: the parking sign was actually overshadowed by a tree that needed pruning, or the trash bin being used was actually non-regulation and it had never been reported up the chain. If a neighborhood felt that the material DDOT chose to conduct certain sidewalk repairs didn’t match the previously-established guidelines for “historic” material, then I pressed DDOT over and over again to return to the community and hold a dialogue on alternatives; because ultimately the repairs still needed to happen.</p><p>So it didn’t matter that I grew up in a middle-class suburban family that mostly shopped at Food Lion, that I never lived in upscale urban neighborhoods, or that I didn’t necessarily agree with what was deemed “historic,” or recognize the importance of a historic designation to begin with. My public service deity had committed me to those three principles that transcended my progressive vision and personal experience.</p><p>As a result, I quickly established a reputation as someone who could get things done. I received accolades from neighbors and a plethora of praise and awards from Advisory Neighborhood Commissions and Citizens Associations. The Mayor’s team valued my service, and I had the privilege of connecting with the Mayor prior to my departure from the office. I say this not just to brag a little, but also to make a point: in public service one cannot overstate the value of ensuring that citizens feel heard. I walked out of the Mayor’s office knowing that I have positively impacted the way those communities view their government.</p><p>I have been in the workforce for a little over 10 years. I have switched career tracks four times, lived in five cities, and two countries. I have done this in search of a professional path that will fulfill my desire to be a force for the values that I believe in: inclusivity, human rights, social and economic equity, and democratic pluralism. It’s true that we need high-level, overarching visions to build a society rooted in these values. In the U.S., we’ve seen these visions sweep the nation since the time of the American Revolution, often coming at great social, economic, and political cost, but ultimately propelling our country in the right direction. But what I’ve now learned is that we stand better positioned to get a diverse range of individuals behind our vision, when our citizens truly feel that the government works for them. It is the citizens who are our bosses at the end of the day.</p><p>Whether it’s Cairo, DC, New York, or the Middle East and United States writ large, I’ll never forget the importance of the right to be heard, even if you live in a Louvre exhibit and use an oversized bathroom.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=db8184ee0894" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The City Indomitable?]]></title>
            <link>https://amrqotb.medium.com/the-city-indomitable-82dc632db7f8?source=rss-6ab2966f8e2e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/82dc632db7f8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[pandemic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coronavirus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-york-city]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Amr Kotb]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 Jul 2020 00:09:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-27T01:39:49.849Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>New Yorkers love to tell you that they’re tough.</p><p>This, of course, is the city that never sleeps. The cultural, economic, and creative capital of the world. The city that survived 9/11, the blackouts, the 2008 recession, and the now-historic events of the American Revolution and Black Tuesday, among countless others, cemented in the annals of history to comprise the bedrock of this tough identity. This is the city indomitable.</p><p>So when I moved here in late-February 2020, on the cusp of an unprecedented global pandemic, I wasn’t worried. Certainly, I was concerned for my health and took the threat of the virus seriously, but I was confident that my new, <em>tough,</em> fellow citizens and I would adjust and find a way to keep the magic going.</p><p>But within weeks, I discovered that many friends, friends of friends, and even family were making plans to “get out of the city for a while.” Others had already fled before I could even check-in. In the beginning, it seemed that acquaintances of a certain level of income were the ones getting out of town. You know, that friend who “can work from anywhere,” whose parents own a summer house in Vermont, Maine, or Connecticut. That friend who perhaps lived in one of <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/05/15/upshot/who-left-new-york-coronavirus.html?action=click&amp;module=Editors%20Picks&amp;pgtype=Homepage">these</a> neighborhoods. Initially, I was childishly bitter towards these people. I wanted to grab them, shake them vigorously, and bark rhetorical questions and comments at them:</p><p><em>Things get bad and you just leave?</em></p><p><em>The coronafied version of New York is still much cooler than the coronafied version of wherever you&#39;re going!</em></p><p><em>If you leave, everyone else is gonna leave, and then the city will be less fun and I JUST GOT HERE.</em></p><p><em>So much for New York toughness!</em></p><p>But as time went on, others without the financial means for a luxurious, extended-respite (masking an outright, semi-permanent escape) seemed to be rethinking their New York-existence as well. A friend from college chose not to renew his lease and is staying with a friend of his until he figures out his long-term plan. My sister bought a one-way ticket to LA and is trying life out there. Others who were furloughed from jobs in event-planning say they don’t plan to renew their lease and are considering new places to live. Some say their departure is temporary, while others are thinking more permanently. It’s as if the virus uncovered issues that had been there all along.</p><p>Most of my friends and I are in our early to mid-30’s, “<em>older millennials.” </em>We graduated within a few years of the 2008 financial crisis to a dearth of job opportunities or a low salary that became the first reference point for all subsequent raises. Speaking for myself, and a few others, this the time in our lives where we started to claw our way into a decent standard of living. I noticed that many of my peers, especially those of us who had chosen to live in expensive — yet fun — cities were making big life decisions such as buying property, getting married, having kids, or in my case — finally figuring out a professional trajectory.</p><p>And when the pandemic hit, a lot of us got furloughed or outright laid off. Some, like me, have been fortunate enough to keep our jobs, and I assumed the overwhelming majority of that group would stick around. But many are using the pandemic as an opportunity to reevaluate their future at a critical stage of life. This is why I have started to see so-called “deserters” in a new light. If you&#39;re in your 30’s and you’ve been caught up in the New York action for a few years, this may be a much-needed, first-time, opportunity for you to take a breath and reconsider the price you pay for all those cutting-edge restaurants, niche theatre productions, funky bars, industrial-hip parks, ethnic neighborhoods, beautiful bridges, illuminated skylines, and the downright exhilarating air that permeates through every inch of the five boroughs of New York City. There is a day-to-day sensory experience that makes you think, “wow, something absolutely incredible could happen to me today,” as you engage in the most mundane ritual, like swiping your subway card on your daily commute.</p><p><em>That</em> is why I moved here in February.</p><p>But if I moved here when I was in my 20’s, I could see how maybe that air has gone stale. And how perhaps its stagnance would prompt me to think again: is it worth it?</p><p>I have taken the pandemic quite seriously and engaged in all necessary precautions, but I still feel that exhilarating air every day. I’m grateful to say that I’ve adjusted to a coronafied NYC that still does the trick. I’ve been biking and running to all the parks and waterfronts, checking out all the beaches, sipping coffee at all the outdoor cafes, strolling through all the ethnic neighborhoods, and venturing to all the top sunset locales, among other invigorating activities. I believe this is still the city indomitable, and that the pandemic version of it, is better than the pandemic version of anywhere else; it’s the only place I want to be wearing a mask right now.</p><p>So yeah, I’d like to think of myself as tough…but I also just got here.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=82dc632db7f8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My Brothers’ Burden]]></title>
            <link>https://amrqotb.medium.com/my-brothers-burden-4977cc01a021?source=rss-6ab2966f8e2e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4977cc01a021</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Amr Kotb]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 14 Jun 2020 23:50:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-15T04:17:14.842Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>My Brothers’ Burden</p><p>I’m Egyptian. Over the years, people, places, and organizations have issued opinions and decrees on my race. Some, like the US Census, and most job applications, say I’m White. Others, Black. My fellow Brown people consider me one of their own. I identify as Arab-American, and Brown….and African, but I typically don’t mind what I’m labeled because it’s kind of a gray area and race/ethnicity is kind of fluid. What is not fluid though, is that I am a person of color, and I am not White.</p><p>Yesterday, someone identified me as Black.</p><p>I had just hopped on the New York City Subway with my wife after a long day frolicking about the city (in a socially-distanced fashion) and getting some sun. One-stop into our sojourn home, the doors parted for a visibly intoxicated, belligerent man. We had just said goodbye to my sister after having a few to-go drinks, and when he got on, I was in the middle of leaving her a voice note telling her how much fun we had. He was intimidating, and he muttered something while making eye contact with us as he bumbled by. My antennae kind of went up but I decided to continue with my voice note. As I spoke, I heard his voice rising with anger, concocting a bizarre slew of racial slurs that seemed to describe passengers on the car.</p><p><em>blahblahblah-SPIC-blahblahblah</em></p><p><em>blahblah-BOY-blahblahblah</em></p><p><em>blahblahblah-[SOMETHINGABOUTASIANS]-blahblahblah</em></p><p>I ignored him, until I heard,</p><p><em>You better shut your mouth, I see you talking on the phone!</em></p><p>I abruptly ended the voice note and he almost instantly walked over to where my wife and I were sitting. He yelled at the top of his lungs and told me I better shut the fuck up, while calling me boy several times. He stopped talking, and stared me down. I held his gaze, one hand on my knee and the other gently holding my wife’s. He lunged forward, as if to assault us. He paused, and then lunged forward again. The second time he did it, I gently raised my hand, and with a tonality about as measured as Barack Obama’s, said, “<em>hey, take it easy man.”</em> He stalked off, calling me boy again, reminding me to keep my mouth shut, and legitimating the pain he could surely inflict on me with his membership in Hell’s Angels and time spent in prison. He got off at the next stop, and my wife gushed with emotion. I tried to play it cool, and wrote it off by describing the man as crazy; I told her I had been called all kinds of things by all kinds of people in my life.</p><p>But something felt different about this experience, particularly that I had been seen as a Black man at a moment when our nation is fervently stirring to a 400-year old system of legalized racism.</p><p>Later that night, I struggled to fall asleep. It was completely irrational but I kept imagining that man busting into our apartment at 4am, yelling the same things, beating me to death, and sexually assaulting my wife before killing her too. I anguished over those two moments of terror after both times he lunged at me, moments of eternal silence, where my heart raged like a caged beast from within, while I calmly continued to hold my wife’s hand, and steel myself without. I had felt a fearful willingness to resign myself in that split second of eternity to whatever was to happen next. It was a moment of purgatory that I had found myself in on account of leaving a voice note to my sister to tell her how much fun we had just had with her, within listening range of a drunk, belligerent, psychotic racist. It struck me the way I had concealed that sense of terror that I had never felt before by being completely motionlesss, by meeting this uncivilized, deranged being with fearless, yet nonchalant eyes. I was certainly being sized up for a fight but I also wanted my wife to feel like I had things under control. I had to appear strong, yet unaggressive, defiant, yet calm. The goal was to disengage.</p><p>But this was nothing. I thought of racially charged moments of terror throughout history and considered those eternal silences. The endless fear that Ahmaud Arbery felt in the seconds he spent on the other end of Travis McMichael’s gun before he shot and killed him. Or the endless pit of terror Breonna Taylor felt in the split second when police officers executed a no-knock warrant with a battering ram that smashed her door open. Or George Floyd somewhere during 5th or 6th minute, when he realized he may actually be in the process of being murdered by a police officer, and called to his mother. Or Emmett Till in those few seconds between Roy Bryant and J.W. Milam showing up at his great uncle’s house, and abducting him, only to beat him to death and throw him into a river later. My little incident was nothing.</p><p>But now I also realized something. That this little terror, and subsequent sense of danger I felt just one time the other night, is likely felt by all of my Black friends and colleagues regularly. And worse, that I had never really heard their stories, meaning that I’d never come close to sensitization to the emotional burdens they carry day after day. I thought of them, steeling themselves from without during teleconferences, parties, bad jokes, and insensitive/racist questions posed under the guise of curiosity.</p><p>That is a burden no human should have to carry. It is the unseen part of this moment and movement; and we should fiercely support our Black brothers and sisters in unveiling it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4977cc01a021" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Are we turning into Egypt?]]></title>
            <link>https://amrqotb.medium.com/are-we-turning-into-egypt-17292cc64678?source=rss-6ab2966f8e2e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/17292cc64678</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[egypt]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[middle-east]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[muslim-ban]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[executive-order]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Amr Kotb]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 30 Jan 2017 01:07:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-30T03:57:31.494Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Questioning parallels and testing institutional democracy</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/604/1*Ime956JsdBE0O4yhCRdUBQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image via 9gag.com</figcaption></figure><p>I recently came across some graffiti in my neighborhood in Washington, DC that read “F*** Trump.” As I pulled my phone out to snap a photo, I stopped and remembered all the “Sisi is a murderer” images I encountered when I lived in Cairo. The parallel troubled me… are we becoming Egypt? A lot of fellow Egyptian-Americans and Middle East analysts have been <a href="http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2017/01/america-you-look-like-an-arab-country-right-now-214678">raising </a>this, and similar, question(s) as of late.</p><p>Almost immediately after Donald Trump’s election, I descended into self-criticism, shaming myself for dedicating my career to a dream of an Egypt that embraced the primacy of rule of law, pluralism, human rights, and the role of civil society. I felt arrogant for leaving the country I was born and raised in, to travel to that of my parents to work on behalf of what I assumed was long-established in the United States.</p><p>And when I came to my senses, I realized that, no, the United States is not becoming Egypt. But are we on our way? Leading up to, and since Trump’s election, the American political landscape has become increasingly characterized by alarming trends reminiscent of what I have spent the past seven years observing and criticizing in Egypt. Since Trump began his tenure as president, he has handed down executive orders and taken actions that restrict freedom of speech,<a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/environmental-protection-grants-staff_us_5886825be4b0e3a7356b575f"> obscure</a> facts and the citizenry’s access to them, shut down institutional channels for dissent, and diminish America’s reputation as a trustworthy member of the international community. Perhaps the most sobering parallels of all, are measures rooted within a framework that view freedom and security as mutually exclusive. The perils of such measures are something I have worked to elucidate within Egypt for several years now. I can not tell you the number of times I have drafted press releases and articles with the phrase “shutting down institutional channels for dissent,” I just never thought I would be doing so in response to actions of the US government. Last week on the sixth anniversary of Egypt’s January 25 revolution, a fellow Egyptian-American<a href="https://medium.com/@maitelsadany/january-25-2017-reflections-of-an-egyptian-american-muslim-47d0b874c182#.ce9ldo6gq"> wrote</a>, “ The America I grew up with is the same America that inspired me to dream for a better Egypt,” a feeling that not only resonated with me, but that I, like her, began to question.</p><p><strong>Security, Stability, and the Muslim Ban</strong></p><p>Egyptian President Abdel-Fattah El-Sisi came to power on the back of the most significant uptick in terror attacks across Egypt since the 1990s. Part of his ability to secure the support of millions was the way the state framed this security problem. The former defense minister promised Egyptians safety, and that Egypt would be stable and “great again.” It is this fear of terror and desire for security that mobilized Egyptians to hit the streets on July 27, 2013, to provide the informal<a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/28/world/middleeast/egypt.html"> mandate</a> El-Sisi needed to take action.</p><p>The result however, was the Rabaa massacre, and a series of draconian measures and slash and burn counter terror tactics. Over the past three years we have seen Egypt’s “war on terror” and broad definitions of national security used as pretext for mass arrests, inhumane buffer zones, enforced disappearances, authoritarian anti-terror laws, and extrajudicial killings. All of these measures have paralleled the highest uptick in terror attacks yet and come at the expense, not only of the lives of victims, but of human rights and civil society organizations, which labor under arguably the most severe crackdown in Egypt’s modern history.</p><p>Like Sisi, Trump <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-pushes-expanded-ban-on-muslims-and-other-foreigners/2016/06/13/c9988e96-317d-11e6-8ff7-7b6c1998b7a0_story.html">played off </a>of terror attacks in Orlando and San Bernardino and the threat of ISIS to suggest sweeping security measures at the expense of human rights. On January 27, Trump signed an executive order banning all immigrants from Syria,Iran, Iraq, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, and Yemen. Not only is the decision an aberration from our tradition of accepting refugees, but it also blatantly ignores the US role in creating conditions within many of these countries, that gave way to the security threats refugees face. Much like Egypt however, this sacrifice is rationalized with the belief that this is “a time of war,” which speaks to the third issue with the ban (considering that the Trump Administration is likely not concerned by the first two), that the cooperation it bars us from and domestic and international sentiments it fuels, actually make our country more vulnerable to terror attacks</p><p>Whether in Egypt or the US, once a potential threat has been exacerbated into high frequency, a cycle of self-legitimation begins. The more attacks occur, the more the state can use fear to convince citizens of the need to consolidate its security authority at the expense of human rights. In Egypt, this cycle allowed the government to use broad definitions of security to crackdown on institutional dissent (see<a href="https://timep.org/press-releases/robert-f-kennedy-human-rights-and-the-tahrir-institute-for-middle-east-policy-condemn-egypts-new-ngo-law/"> NGO law</a> , <a href="https://timep.org/press-releases/timep-strongly-condemns-continuation-of-ngo-trial">NGO trial</a>, and the <a href="https://www.hrw.org/news/2015/08/19/egypt-counterterrorism-law-erodes-basic-rights">terrorism law</a>), as well as practice incompetent counter terror and security policies. Both of these side-effects were on display in the wake of the December<a href="https://timep.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/SpecialBriefing-CathedralBombing.pdf"> attack</a> near Egypt’s St. Marks cathedrals, where parliament discussed holding military trials for civilian suspects in terror cases rather than security reform and counter terror measures.</p><p>Trump’s immigration ban may be America’s first step into this cycle. The ban fuels anti-American sentiment abroad while also rousing discrimination towards Muslims within our borders. Additionally, it costs us valuable partners in our supposed war on terror, which is not to be conflated with a war on Islam; consider the Iraqi<a href="http://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/national-international/Iraqi-Refugees-Detained-at-NYC-Airport-Report-412039985.html"> citizen</a> held at JFK for 17 hours despite his valid visa and ten years of service to the US government in Iraq. As attacks begin to occur, more advanced measures for cracking down on Muslims at the expense of their human rights may be deemed necessary, with a next step possibly being the Muslim Registry Trump suggested, or the reinstatement of<a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/18/us/politics/japanese-internment-muslim-registry.html"> National Security Entry-Exit Registration (NSNEERS)</a>.</p><p><strong>Dawlet Mo’asasat</strong></p><p>During a recent trip to Cairo, I discussed these similarities with my uncle, who was not concerned, reminding me that the difference between the United States and Egypt, is that America is, as Egyptians say, <em>dawlet mo’asasat</em>, or a country of institutions. Conspiracy theories, propaganda, and fear mongering in Egypt coexist with a rubber stamping parliament, a weak cabinet, an increasingly nonexistent civil society, and a controversial judiciary. In the United States however, our democracy is much more than elections and protests.</p><p>As populist currents continue to gain ground, our infrastructural democracy, complete with longstanding institutions and a healthy civil society will be put to the test. It is up to policy makers within these institutions, civil society organizations, and the citizenry to embrace their civic duty to ensure that the United States absorbs these shocks and continues to be a progressive nation.</p><p>The Senate must take confirmation hearings seriously and civil society organizations, like the Council on American-Islamic Relations and the American Civil Liberties Union, must be prepared to act as a ‘fourth branch of government,’ through filing suits and mobilizing the masses to challenge decisions like the immigration ban. Saturday’s<a href="http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/ct-trump-travel-ban-emergency-stay-20170128-story.html"> verdict</a> following day one of the ban is a step that proves we are indeed, <em>dawlet mo’asasat</em>.</p><p>And then there’s us. The citizens. We also play a role within our institutional democracy, one that is not afforded to many Egyptians. We must continue protesting and pressuring our representatives as well as take advantage of our decentralized government. This translates to calling our representatives, organizing, and joining community and neighborhood-level boards of governance, like DC’s Advisory Neighborhood Commissions.</p><p>If the only difference between the United States and any other authoritarian state, like Egypt, is that we are <em>dawlet mo’asasat,</em> then now is the time to prove it. If you’ve never been the type of person to call your representatives, then it’s time to change that. If you’ve never attended protests for causes you are passionate about, then you can no longer rely on others to take action. If you are a proud observer of the ACLU’s actions on behalf of detained immigrants, then it’s time to become to a proud donor.</p><p>As an American who has been focused on Egypt’s issues within governance all this time, I no longer view these parallels as a source of shame. Rather, they represent an opportunity, to exercise those privileges I have as an American citizen and a protected member of our institutional democracy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=17292cc64678" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>