<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Amy Rodgers on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Amy Rodgers on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@amyrodgers?source=rss-194ce919cc20------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 18:30:01 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@amyrodgers/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Are We All Trans*?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@amyrodgers/are-we-all-trans-b9015bacfe7d?source=rss-194ce919cc20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b9015bacfe7d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transman]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender-identity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sexuality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Amy Rodgers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 13 Jan 2020 05:51:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-15T02:31:14.139Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The answer is — obviously — no. Yet, it is useful to ask this purposely provocative question. Most personally, it has been helpful to me as I work my way through the confusion, shame, ambiguity, anguish and suffocation that has attached itself to my own gender identity and expression throughout the years as I have moved away from identifying as cis toward identifying as trans*. These words are written to both illuminate how I have dealt with it all and also in the hope that it may also help others who are in a similar place.</p><p>The question has another use too. It is to invite cis people to explore how queer and trans* embodiment opens up options for them to reevaluate and explore their own gender identity and expression and — in the process — help mitigate fear, violence, confusion and discrimination toward trans* individuals.</p><p>In discussions like this it is important to stop time and time again to emphasize that not all gender norms are similarly policed, and not all gender variant people face the same set of obstacles. Similarly, being “out” as trans* brings with it a host of dangers that choosing not to (or being able to choose not to) does not, regardless of how you present yourself or how you identify privately. Different perspectives on gender variance reflect particular experiences of oppression, specific needs and political goals and, amongst these theoretical debates, it is important to also keep a focus on changing the institutions that affect trans and intersex lives. But I think we can acknowledge and act on these important realities while also tracking the overlaps and similarities to carve out and describe a space for those who feel they are not cis, but find many of the usages of the word trans* to be unhelpful. It also creates opportunity for collaborative jumping off points between communities. We can — I believe — attend to the differences between cis and trans*, (such as those between butches and FTMs), whilst also emphasizing the permeability of the boundaries that mark them.</p><p>The reality of transness is frightening and baffling to many because in an unstable and insecure world, basic sexual identity is one of the few fairly firm constructs we have. So much of the world and our sense of self is organised around it. A binary gender system structures many areas of life; everything from sport to law to dating revolves around it. With many people being privileged enough to not have to, gender instability and fluidity is something that is underexplored and therefore unknown to most. This strangeness is often met with fear and violence because people are not sure how else to meet it. Asking ‘Are We All Trans?’ proposes we meet the unfamiliar in an alternative way: by looking at the similarities and commonalities that are familiar to all, both cis and trans*.</p><p>Let us remind ourselves that we are all gender deviant to a certain extent; gender diversity and variance is a human reality, not just a trans* reality. Because there are many components and signifiers that make up someone’s sex and gender, there are many different types, instances and intensities of gender/sex variance. Here’s a few:</p><p>- cross dressing<br>- sex affirmation surgery<br>- androgyny<br>- feelings of gender dysphoria<br>- tomboys and sissies<br>- breast surgery<br>- name changing<br>- women with high levels of testosterone<br>- butch lesbians<br>- people with androgen insensitivity syndrome<br>- gender role play during sex<br>- men with gynaestomania<br>- hormone replacement therapy</p><p>Some of these instances of gender and sex variance are assigned trans or intersex status in society, and some are not. Those practices and embodiments that are deemed trans* or intersex are subject to much more scrutiny and regulation than those that are thought to be less of a threat to the gender order. But the way in which they are marked as such, and the line that separates them, is completely arbitrary. Indeed, some of these practices move across the line depending on context and time period.</p><p>Let’s consider the term “Trans”. Trans used to be synonymous for transsexual and to be recognized as such in medicine, law and wider society, one would be required to have had genital surgery. This is no longer the case as body modification is no longer a prerequisite to be considered trans* by these institutions. So, in the 1970s a person who was assigned male at birth and lived her life as a woman — but did not have genital surgery — would most likely be considered a cisgender man who liked to cross dress (see, for example, the famous legal case of April Ashley). Now, with the shift in definitions that have taken place over time, the same person would now be considered a transwoman or woman. Definitions are temporal, historical, arbitrary and personal.</p><p>With the historical obsession with genitals slowly disappearing, gender dysphoria has come to be the hallmark of what constitutes transness in law (and wider society). Putting aside the pathologising language of the term and the level of disgust toward oneself that it requires, it is also unhelpful in that it is not experienced by all trans* individuals, nor is it felt exclusively by us. While many trans people do experience gender dysphoria and the effects of this on someone’s life and wellbeing should not be downplayed or denied, many trans people experience it very minimally, or sometimes not at all. I have felt this with varying intensity over the years and find that the days I feel it less does not correlate to the way in which I gender-identify.</p><p>Conversely, gender dysphoria is experienced by many cisgender people. Prominent trans writers Gayle Rubin and Jack Halberstam have both written extensively on the dysphoric feelings that are experienced within the lesbian community. Drag, cross-dressing, role play and passing are all common in lesbian populations and butch lesbians in particular often sit at the borderlands between cis and trans. Most butches will identify as masculine to some degree and many will enjoy combining their expressions of masculinity with their female body. For other butches, however, their female body is a source of discomfort and will engage in practices to ease the feeling — for example, some might bind their breasts or refuse penetration during sex. Everything I’m saying here is qualified in one way or another (“some/many/most”) and this is exactly the point: rather than seeking to perfectly classify people and theorize and police impenetrable boundaries, let us move toward a community that sees variation as a gift and anomalies and exceptions as precious that are to be celebrated and understood. Alot of people are straight and/or cis before they are gay and/or trans, and for a lot of the time, are just not sure. I very much view the days that I cross dress, or role play during sex as a cis person as overlapping with the days I began to identify as trans.This article is an attempt to say that feeling like this is OK: definitions can be very confusing and it sometimes helpful to view them as blurry and overlapping somewhat. Doing so has helped me in times of confusing and change.We cannot distinguish between all cis and trans people based on how well they pass, how powerfully they feel dysphoric or the degree of gender ambiguity they express.</p><p>Our sex/gender system — that is, the criteria we use to organize and divide bodies and identities into male and female — is a construction. It crudely places some people in the male category and some in the female, and, (appallingly) leaves some people in the precarious middle. Our current sex/gender system does not treat anomalies very well. It pathologises them with a mental health diagnosis (see the Gender Recognition Act); or sends them to jail for sexual offences (see the Gender Identity Fraud cases) or tries to force them to take hormone suppressors (see Caster Semenya). Sex and gender differences do exists and are useful in some instances but in many others they are not working and are very damaging. These experiences demonstrate that the current system of sexual difference is inadequate to deal with the complexity of our bodies and identifications. It’s time for a better account of it. Drawing attention to the slippages between cis and trans* practices and identities is a good step in this direction.</p><p>We must also remind ourselves of the temporality of gender and indeed any experience of the self. We are all involved in a process of transforming who we are in this present moment and while different in obvious and important ways, transgender practices share similarities with other types of modification and transformation that are nothing to do with changing gender (breast augumentation; tattooing; body building; child birth) or even changing the body (conversion to a new faith; submitting oneself to a recovery programme for addiction; becoming a parent). Our sense of self, our needs and our desires go through a lot of massive changes in our lives. Varying our gender or sex need not be placed in a mystified league of it’s own.</p><p>Whilst it is important to attend to the unique needs of trans* indivuals so that we are sufficiently supported, it is also useful to sit gender/sex variation alongside other diversities that exist between us. Is gender typically the most unchangeable and defining aspect of a person? Just now it seems to be but we can demystify the act of changing one’s gender in ways that support the struggles of people representing stigmatised and unfamiliar gender categories by talking about trans practices alongside other, non-stigmatized alterations to ourselves. Recognising and highlighting these connections allows us to open our minds to the fact that our selves and our bodies are constantly changing and transforming, rather than presuming that we are simply mired in being unless we undergo explicit, visible and identifiable transformational procedures like gender reassignment surgery.</p><p>Ultimately, what I am trying to do is propose creative interconnections and links between communities which are too often kept apart from each other. This is crucial given the current friction and conflict amongst identity groups such as gay, trans, and (particularly radical) feminist groups, and the threat to all of these groups in the current political climate.</p><p>Categories are useful — they help us construct a meaningful life for ourselves by organizing and naming our individual identities and desires. But they are also limited and damaging. We don’t just use categories, they use us. We use them to create the lives we want for ourselves but they can also mould us into something we are not or alienate us when we are unable to conform to their rigid definitions. Yet we can recognise their limitations by making the boundaries between them porous and penetrable. Let people explore their gender freely, let them define how they wish without fear of being appropriative and give them the space to change that if and when they want.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b9015bacfe7d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[OUT OF THE CLOSET]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@amyrodgers/out-of-the-closet-fdbb23ccd134?source=rss-194ce919cc20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fdbb23ccd134</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fashion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hari-nef]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Amy Rodgers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Feb 2017 21:28:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-02-23T21:28:44.616Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“People often write fashion off as frivolous, but by inducing gender- nonconformity in the dream-life we offer to consumers, we show our power as a progressive force.”</p><p>Gender blurring in fashion is nothing new of course. From Marlene Deitrich donning a man’s tailcoat in the 1930s film Morroco to the more Givenchy skirt wearing Kanye West, expressing ones gender ambiguously through clothes has become prevalent in the fashion world.</p><p>Transgender model and activist Hari Nef in a recent interview however, is more cynical, stating that “she does not think fashion is a fertile ground for a discussion of gender.” Nef claims that rather than disrupting gender norms, images and genres in fashion that are supposedly “subversive” to gender actually just reinforce the binary.</p><p>You can see her point. Let’s look at YSL’s LE SMOKING for example. This women’s tux, which was essentially a reinterpretation of black tie menswear, was a controversial statement on femininity and masculinity — it marked a sexuality that did not rely “ruffles or exposed skin, but instead smouldered beneath the sharp contours of a perfectly cut jacket and trouser.”</p><p>While garments like this did play a significant role in changing perceptions around the ways in which men and women should dress, when taken out of their background and history and proclaimed as subversive today, they become weak. Nef sums the issue up well: “If a woman is sourcing power from a signifier of stereotypical masculinity, then how sustainable is that?” “If a woman is putting on a suit and taking it off, is that really subversion of gender binaries or is just a reinforcement of that binary as we know it?”</p><p>I disagree with Nef in some respects, and agree in others. Disagree because we cannot ignore that fact that fashion clearly has potential to offer people ways to explore gender in ways that they may have not thought possible. At its core, fashion is about identity; clothes are used to to reconcile tensions between our inner and social selves. It has such a compelling influence over the way we feel and think about our bodies.</p><p>In fashion, individuals are able to escape gender by playing with the rules that have created it. Clothing allows people to encounter and play with new aesthetics and new propositions for being a person that isn’t usually offered in day to day life. Different kinds of beauty are offered in fashion … Not just mainstream femininity and masculinity.</p><p>Through clothes, men can access their femininity and women their masculinity. The result of these gender crossings is that the distinction between man and woman is disappearing. At least aesthetically. But that qualification is important, and the reason I also agree with Nef to some extent. Fashion allows us to challenge gender norms aesthetically. Outside of aesthetics in fashion, there is a long way to go: “Fashion is having a moment with trans aesthetics, not trans issues.”</p><p>Fashion, unfortunately, has a sinful history of drawing inspiration from other cultures aesthetic, without giving due consideration and attention towards the history and issues within the culture itself. A recent example being Valentino’s spring show this year which was apparently “African-inspired”; it featured fewer than 10 black models.</p><p>Fashion has embraced androgyny and gender bending styles. Selfridges’ unisex Agender department is good example. This issue though is that “unisex” is not subversive. Unisex, by definition is “designed to be suitable for both sex, a style in which me and women look and dress in a similar way.” Unisex by definition then, still works within the gender binary. Notably, the models used in these campaigns are often male and female presenting, not gender non-conforming.</p><p>It is one thing to embrace the visual styles, but another to embrace the lived lives. A few years ago, trans model Andreja Pejic was told by a casting agent prior to her transition not to go through with it. The reason she was told? In fashion, “It’s better to be androgynous than a tranny.” (Thankfully, she ignored this advice and her career has flourished post-transition.) Fashion needs more trans and gender non-conforming models. And even then, we must go further. Most trans people are a world away from the glitzy existence of top model. An increase of trans people in roles at the forefront of fashion generally must happen; make-up artists, casting agents, photographers are still badly under-represented.</p><p>Fashion has the power to demystify and raise awareness around trans issues. But clothing alone in fashion, although significant for self-expression of identity, will not subvert gender norms. Fashions challenge to the gender binary should not just be an aesthetic-borrowing trend. To be clear, fashion borrowing trans aesthetic is a good thing; it enables people to see and carry out ways of being they did not think possible. But it is more about considering the people in the clothes and what they’re doing to challenge the gender binary, as opposed to relying on the clothing itself to disrupt the gender binary. Instead of associating gender binary disruptions with the garments themselves we need to look more at the person or the identity behind them.</p><p>[AMY RODGERS]</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fdbb23ccd134" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[EXPANDING GENDER OPTIONS AND SELF IDENTIFYING ON FACEBOOK]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@amyrodgers/expanding-gender-options-and-self-identifying-on-facebook-d1dd559ca88?source=rss-194ce919cc20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d1dd559ca88</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nonbinary]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Amy Rodgers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Feb 2017 21:26:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-02-23T21:26:24.437Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Asked and answered by Michel Foucault in his introduction to Herculine Barbin:</p><p><em>“Do we truly need a true sex? With a persistence that borders on stubbornness, modern Western societies have answered in the affirmative. They have obstinately brought into play this question of a “true sex” in an order of things where one might have imagined that all that counted was the reality of the body and the intensity of its pleasures.”</em></p><p>As Foucault points out, it has been the rising power of medical science and law in the defining and gendering of human bodies. Gender has been socially constructed by the powerful discourse of law and medicine. Yet, this does not lead to the conclusion that we cannot change the norms for identifying a persons gender; the criteria for identifying gender is not in the hands of a faceless society over which we have no control. Today, narratives of gender that challenge past definitions are emerging. These competing narratives have recently been allowed to be explicitly articulated and expressed on Facebook. The lives we live online are able to live out with the powerful forces of law and medicine, diminishing the power they have over us and increasing the power we have over ourselves.</p><p>Gender exists today very strongly, persuasively and destructively. This is evident in the gender violence and discrimination that happens toward both women and to gender nonconforming people. You can see this anytime a man gets called a “sissie” for being too emotional, when a woman gets called a “slut” when she sleeps around. People are abused in these ways because they are not adhering to society’s expectations about what it means to be a man or a woman.</p><p>If gender is something that is causing so many problems, surely we must somehow ditch it. The difficulty is how.</p><p>How can we abolish gender? I do not think we can live in a world in which we are suddenly without gender. A full nullification of gender, given where we are historically, does not seem possible. For one thing, a lot of people really like their genders, and they are not ready to give them up. Being a man, and being woman continues to mean a hell of a lot to people. Moreover, gender does matter in positive ways too. For example, gender presentation plays a crucial role in whom you attract and who you are attracted to. And so, the gender categories of man and the woman are likely to exist for some time.</p><p>So it seems we cannot abolish man and woman but we can ameliorate the perceived differences between them. We can create and acknowledge permissible gender identities in addition to man and woman. If gender becomes 1 of 70 things – it will cease to mean as much. Or, begin to mean something different.</p><p><strong>Transcending the Gender Binary</strong></p><p><em>“There is perhaps nothing so firmly entrench in way that our society thinks about the world than that there are two and only two genders, and that those genders never change.”</em></p><p>Barbara Findlay, Q.C.<br>Current law in Scotland follows this binary understanding of sexed/gendered bodies, which offers only two possible classifications: men and women.</p><p>In 2004 the Gender Recognition Act was introduced in Scotland. The Act allows trans persons to change their gender. Unfortunately, it is essentially a conservative act which attempts to deny the threat transsexualism poses to the dualistic system of gender. Persons may only cross the gender binary; that is, move from one gender to another. Transcendence of the gender binary; that is, moving beyond the categories of man and woman, remains a legal impossibility. As part of their Equality Campaign, The Scottish Transgender Alliance seek to introduce a non-binary legal gender category. Until such times, any gender identity between, above, below, and beyond, the binary is both unrecognisable and unthinkable in the eyes of the law.</p><p>Facebook however, in 2014 introduced more than 70 new gender options to the UK. The new gender options include androgynous, trans person, trans woman, trans man, transsexual, pangender, bi -gender, agender, polygender, and cisgender . You can see what these terms mean here.</p><p>Gender non-conforming people describe a range of identities and experiences, including but not limited to the ones listed by Facebook. Gender non-conforming identities highlight the allegorical qualities of ‘female’ and ‘male’ gender identity, the extent to which gender is always already a performance, and the potential flexibility of those terms.</p><p>Even in the face of the existence of those who do not neatly fit on one side of the binary, law is refusing to change this categorical model of fixed dualistic genders. Law continues to postulate its “truth” of sex; that there are only two categories; man and woman.</p><p>Facebook on the other hand seems to have recognised that the rigid binary easily falters in the face of complex lived realities. Indeed, when asked why it changed its gender policy Facebook’s policy director in the UK, Simon Milner replied that the purpose was “to reflect society.”</p><p>If one is of the view that the point of law is to give recognition to the reality that individuals actually inhabit, then it is time for the law to change.</p><p>Self-Identification</p><p>And it is not enough that we recognise am individual’s gender identity, we must do so in a morally acceptable way. In absence of any “truth” of sex/gender, (we still do not know exactly what it is), we must accept individual’s own description of their identity.</p><p>Facebook does this. Facebook has not only challenged the notion that there can only be two genders, but it has also introduced the idea of self-identification as definitive of gender identity. Users can simply select a gender option from a drop down menu with no requirements or conditions that must be satisfied before you are allowed to do this.</p><p>But to legally change your gender, law requires a number of things. Two of the most problematic being that firstly, the applicant must have had, or has, gender dysphoria and secondly that the applicant has lived in the acquired gender for a period of two years and intends to continue to live in the acquired gender until death. A gender dysphoria requirement constructs transsexualism as a mental illness, pathologizing trans people. Given that ‘‘disorder’’ implies some level of personal are distress, it has been suggested that a well-adjusted trans person is out with the scope of the act. In addition to this, trans individuals who are defined as gender dysphoric, but do not intend to cross and live in an acquired gender for life will not be recognised. The law is ignoring a substantial amount of trans lives and rendering them invisible.</p><p>In the world of Facebook, people are now able to define categories and terms of gender themselves, instead of having it imposed on them. You can change your gender on Facebook with no proof needed, nor an avowal that you will remain that gender for life. It is recognising and respecting an individual’s subjectivity. It is not enough that we recognise a persons gender identity, we must do so in a more morally acceptable way than the Gender Recognition Act currently does. In absence of any “truth” of sex/gender, (we still do not know what it is), we must accept individual’s own description of their identity.</p><p><strong>Why it’s so important</strong></p><p><em>“Fucksake, what next?”</em></p><p>Many act confused or hostile when they see so many “weird words” emerging that they don’t understand. And it is also common to see comments making fun of the queer dictionary by creating arbitrary and ridiculous identities in order to mock gender-nonconforming identities.</p><p>There are a diverse number of terms and definitions for various gender situations because people experience gender in various and diverse ways. The people who mock underestimate the joy of having words exist that resonate with and describe your lived gendered experience, where no words existed before. They are ignorant to the fact that trans people have had to develop a complex understanding of a complex idea for self-preservation. Many people have not needed to explore this because they have always lived a life that has been recognised and intelligible in society. The ability to articulate and express who you are on Facebook, when a substantial amount of our lives are now lived online, is a significant step in social recognition of a growing trans community. People should not have to make themselves more palatable for others. They should not be forced into the categories of man and woman when those categories do not describe their lived experience. They should be allowed to have a label for themselves and be able to express and communicate that label to the world.</p><p>Of course, the cynic in me is suspicious that this is a truly altruistic act by Facebook, (it is after all, a large corporation that makes it money through targeted ads) — “Facebook cares more about targeting ads than affirming your gender identity”. And I am also well aware that expressing one’s gender on Facebook has no legal force. But at the very least Facebook is moving the conversation along.</p><p>This is also a good move for women. A strict gender binary has the effect of ensuring the continued marginalisation of women. A social system that has a strict binary of man and woman allows men to exploit the social hierarchy that exists between them to dominate and control women. If we come to recognise gender as highly variable and partly under control of the individual, it ceases to be a reliable basis of domination, since its variability too easily allows for passage from the group of the marginalised to the group of the oppressors. The more gender options we recognise, the more the borders between the dominant and the marginalised are blurred.</p><p>We need to get to a place where gender is either meaningless in social or psychological terms, or is figured as choice not prison, as self-expression not prescription. Facebook is allowing bodies and personalities to become less constrained and circumscribed by gendered traits and instead, enriched by their use in the palette of diverse self-expression.</p><p>People are eroding the biological, psychological and social role of gender. And crucially, the power of recognition is reliant less on traditional institutions such as the law and medicine and more on an individual’s identification. In a way then, power is being appropriated from the law to the people.</p><p><strong>[Amy Rodgers]</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d1dd559ca88" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>