<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ananda Sangeetam on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ananda Sangeetam on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@anand.lost?source=rss-d8d5e57361fa------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 02:07:24 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@anand.lost/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is addiction? What is dependence?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@anand.lost/what-is-addiction-what-is-dependence-828789a20ce5?source=rss-d8d5e57361fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/828789a20ce5</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ananda Sangeetam]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 12 Dec 2020 04:29:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-12T04:37:38.363Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Let us take a look at the latest <em>Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders version</em> V (DSM-V), which would be a standard accepted in the US and many other countries. While some people use ICD, I will not touch upon ICD here as similar arguments can be presented with ICD’s description also.</p><p>Looking at the standards is important to understand roots of misconceptions about these words.</p><p>DSM is the standard classification of mental disorders used for clinical, research, policy, and reimbursement purposes in the United States and elsewhere. It directly influences how disorders are diagnosed, treated, and investigated. DSM has been reviewed and revised five times since 1952.</p><h3><strong>How does DSM-V define addiction vs. dependence?</strong></h3><p>Let us look at an earlier version (DSM-III) to gain more insights into addiction vs. dependence. We will define addiction more objectively in the second half of the article.</p><p>In mid-1980s, a group of “addiction” experts (i.e., experts on addiction and not experts who are addicted) organized by the American Psychiatric Association and the World Health Organization met to amend DSM-III substance-related disorders section. This international committee met over several years in different countries and ultimately published a revised DSM-III-R in 1987. According to Charles O’Brien (chair of the latest DSM-V committee), this was an important achievement because the committee agreed that the disorder in question (i.e., addiction) was compulsive, uncontrolled, drug-seeking behavior, and defined it by a set of criteria that produced excellent inter-rater reliability. This committee (consisting of both clinicians and non-clinicians) is known to have made most decisions unanimously mainly because there was general agreement from the experts as to how the “disorder” should be defined. But, the committee was split with significant disagreements with respect to the “label” that should be used. While the clinicians on the committee favored calling the disorder “addiction” or “addictive disorder”, non-clinicians argued that the word “addiction” was deprecatory and pejorative alienating patients who “need” help. Indeed, non-clinicians were in favor of a more neutral term “dependence” despite clinicians concern that the word “dependence” is actually used for real dependence such as insulin dependence in a diabetic patient. After much discussion and debate, the word “dependence” was chosen over “addiction” by the margin of a single vote!</p><p>While teaching addiction (oops, dependence) to medical students and general physicians, there is much confusion about “dependence” due to the DSM-III-R usage of the term “dependence.” One has to explain that there is a normal physiological response called “physical dependence” (e.g., insulin dependence), and then there is “addiction”, which is drug-seeking behavior called ‘dependence’ in the DSM. More than “addiction” or “dependence”, I find the use of word “disorder” amusing. What exactly is a “disorder?” DSM-V (including its previous versions) does not really define what exactly “disorder” means although it is a manual to categorize them. They mention the following in their introduction to re-ascertain subjectivity of this lost subject of psychiatry.</p><p><em>DSM-IV notes that “… although this manual provides a classification of mental disorders, it must be admitted that no definition adequately specifies precise boundaries for the concept of ‘mental disorder.’ The concept of mental disorder, like many other concepts in medicine and science, lacks a consistent operational definition that covers all situations.</em></p><p><em>Although DSM-V remains a categorical classification of separate disorders, we recognize that mental disorders do not always fit completely within the boundaries of a single disorder. Some symptom domains, such as depression and anxiety, involve multiple diagnostic categories and may reflect common underlying vulnerabilities for a larger group of disorders. In recognition of this reality, the disorders included in DSM-5 were reordered into a revised organizational structure meant to stimulate new clinical perspectives.</em></p><p><em>What is a disorder in the first place? Why are we unable to define it?</em></p><p>In any case, following DSM-V, National Institutes of Health/ National Institute of Drug Abuse define addiction as follows:</p><p>Addiction is defined as a chronic, relapsing <strong>disorder</strong> (we are not told what this disorder is; so, this is subjective) characterized by compulsive drug seeking, continued use despite harmful consequences, and long-lasting changes in the brain. It is considered both a <strong>complex </strong>(i.e., involves multiple parts of the brain in addition to the non-physical intellect) brain <strong>disorder</strong> and a mental illness (<em>Why? Is choosing to repeat actions (although harmful to life) a mental illness? Is eating chocolates a mental illness? I am only trying to draw your attention to the subjectivity involved in today’s lost field of psychiatry</em>). Addiction is the most severe form of a full spectrum of substance use disorders, and is a medical illness caused by repeated misuse of a substance or substances.</p><p>The so-called “progressive” definition is slightly different, as you can see below.</p><p>Addiction is a treatable, chronic medical disease involving complex interactions among brain circuits, genetics, the environment, and an individual’s life experiences. People with addiction use substances or engage in behaviors that become compulsive and often continue despite harmful consequences.</p><h3><strong>Problems with these definitions</strong></h3><p>Do you see a problem with the above definitions? They struggle to objectively identify addiction because of much subjectivity in the lost field of psychiatry and neuropsychology.</p><p>To properly understand addiction, one must begin by understanding action. The world is a forum for action. As human beings, we choose to live by acting. Even inaction is action. Even the failure to act ensues in consequences. Life and growth are our primary values. If we chose life as a value, our actions must be towards growing in that value. It is meaningless to define the term “healthy life” without properly defining life first. Because we do not really understand “life” (despite all the seeming advances in physiology and medicine), our ideas of “order” in life are not only vague but entirely incomplete. Furthermore, the success of empirioschematic and empiriometric mathematical science has reduced the definition of “testability” to “mathematical measurability.” I keep emphasizing that psychiatry is a lost field because it has become completely divorced from objective reality. How could we then define a “disorder” without knowing “order?” How could we write manuals to diagnose “disorders” without objectively specifying disorder (much less call it an illness) ?</p><h3>What is life? What is order?</h3><p>A living organism is a single substance (<em>Eka</em>), composed of many heterogenous parts (<em>Aneka</em>) that act together, with at least nutritive, vegetative, and reproductive powers. This defines a living organism and not life itself. It describes more about “physical” powers of living beings to distinguish them from other “inanimate” things. Yet, life is not just a bunch of circuits wired together and programmed to tick till the clock runs out. It is even more beautiful to look at human life. In addition to physical powers of a living organism, we possess intellect.</p><p><em>We are conscious beings with a clear power to understand, choose, and act</em>. Our intellect is non-physical because ideas (not phantasms) and concepts are non-physical. Our non-physical ideas do affect our bodies when physically acted upon. Our senses are constantly interacting with reality instigating us to drink when thirsty, eat when hungry etc. Our body functions based on the inputs it receives. For example, consider a person who feels hungry and then acts to eat appropriate food to satisfy his/her hunger. What do we mean by appropriate food? Firstly, it should definitely not be anything “poisonous,” one might say. But, what is poison exactly? This is the other side of asking what is “healthy?”</p><p>Say, this person can choose to eat either a salad or a pizza, for simplicity. Neither pizza nor salad is healthy or unhealthy by itself. Here, health refers to the homeostasis of a living entity. In reference to that health of the person who is eating it, pizza or salad or anything is healthy or unhealthy or worse, poisonous. A clinician might assert that we have established objective means to determine this “healthy” ness in that one could measure all sorts of biomarkers viz., HDL, LDL, Cholesterol, HbA1c, LFT, RFT, TFT etc. Furthermore, a psychiatrist may assert certain behaviors as healthy or unhealthy, again based on statistics.</p><p>We do not understand life as “being” because such statistics substitute “average” for “being.” By observing empirical and statistical relations and correlations, we have established that certain ranges of values of specific biomarkers as unhealthy. This implies that person with such physiological markers is more likely to suffer from otherwise avoidable diseases like heart attacks or blood clots etc. From this standpoint, we have implicitly defined “order.” By order, we mean that our physical inputs into bodily functions, which act as a whole one single unit, should align with the value of life. Any physical process (either in terms of action or reception) that is not aligned with this “order” of keeping life as a value is a “disorder.”</p><p>A glaring gap in defining “order” and “disorder” above is that we have limited the inclusion of human intellect to certain statistical behaviors. We are not cellular automata following simple rules. We are not simply “helpless victims” of our neurophysiology. Statistics or mathematics fails to include anything non-physical like the intellect or freewill. This is not calling for the inclusion of religion or spirituality or some vague moral code. It is accepting our reality and including it properly in our science. A choice is not mathematically computable because ideas, choices, will, intellect etc are not material. Yet, they are not supernatural. The growth of intellect is the most important for our survival and hence keeping the value of life. Therefore, to define “order” or “disorder,” it is imperative to understand the non-physical nature of human beings.</p><h3>What are habits?</h3><p>Given our physical nature and experience with reality, we cannot spend eternity acquiring knowledge in order to act. We have the so-called “involuntary” actions such as the heart beating. “Involuntary” is a misleading term. I rather look at it as “actions by default.” Even if you do not think (or “fail to think” or “think but in a vague undecided way”), these actions are still carried out as long as you do not explicitly change the course (e.g., swallow cyanide). Our physiology evolved so as to be able to do these “actions by default.”</p><p>Addiction is an intricate network of several physical and non-physical phenomena. However, in today’s medicine, we focus on only the physical phenomena and unfortunately in a very very crude fashion because we are making several implicit philosophical and value judgements subjectively. Physically speaking, addiction is often referred to as a <strong>disorder </strong>that involves changes in brain activity across hypothalamic, amygdalar, mesolimbic, cortical, and basal ganglia circuits. Most “addiction” models treat addictive behavior as a “strong habit circuit.” Such circuits are often hypothesized to form due to “rewards” such as dopamine or other neurotransmitter changes due to certain “actions” (e.g., smoking). Based on subjective statistical evidence from rats and other animals, human habits are often analyzed just stimuli-response systems. In actuality, unlike rats, humans have intelligence. They are not mere machinery responding only and only to external stimuli. Our “habits” form from repeated actions by “chunking” neuronal activity to optimize. There is no need to think very deeply to “drive a car.” Driving becomes a secondary task through the involvement of basal ganglia. Beyond a certain point, a habit can become much like “involuntary action” or “action by default.” Addiction happens, in my opinion, when there is: 1) no conscious thought at all to stop this “action by default” (which formed habitually) from happening, or 2) conscious thought but no concrete translation of thought into action to disrupt the “action by default.”</p><p>In this sense, one can think of different “failure modes” that lead to “habitual action by default” and thereby addiction. Some such potential failures include motivational, homeostatic, and impulse-control systems. One does not get addicted due to “force of habit” but by one’s own conscious or unconscious failure to act. There is the difference between “user” and “abuser.” There is also strong evidence that addicted individuals and animal models of addiction exhibit habit-like or “action by default” tendencies in their drug-taking rituals and in their compulsive persistence in drug-taking in the presence of drug cues and drug seeking despite negative consequences because there is no objective evaluation of “good” at all in the animal or the person.</p><p>The historical definition of habits is that they are behaviors rooted in stimuli-response associations that have been acquired through learning based on reinforcement. Most of these experiments are performed with vague definition of “value” and “reward.” For example, when a mouse is injected with lithium chloride, it behaves differently in accordance with its inputs. Most human habits are equivalent to simple SR associations (e.g.,guiding a rat reflexively from point A to point B) <strong>only</strong> when there is NO deliberate or conscious effort to think.</p><p>Now, let us do another thought experiment. Say, a person decides to smoke marijuana consciously. S/he continues to repeat this action consciously because they feel “rewarded.” It is important to understand the nature of this “reward.” Is the “reward” a physical production of dopamine? Or is the “reward” non-physical? If the “reward” is somehow “non-physical” growth of intellect that aligns with the value of life, is it “addiction?” (for example, consider marijuana-induced generation of new ideas or sufficient elevation of thinking processes that help better visualize things such as n-dimensional hyperspheres or multi-dimensional ensemble evolutions).</p><p>Watson claims its addiction. But, I side with Sherlock that he is only a user.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*pJKknN-_mxMAhCb5Q4OefQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>P.S. I know I did not get to concretely define disorder and addiction in a way I would really like. It needs more work.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=828789a20ce5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is physics and What is mathematics?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@anand.lost/what-is-physics-and-what-is-mathematics-f9b0719b1027?source=rss-d8d5e57361fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f9b0719b1027</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mathematics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ananda Sangeetam]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 14 Nov 2020 22:39:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-15T03:25:43.181Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>3. What is physics and What is mathematics?</strong></h3><p><em>Calvin: Scientific method is an ontological quandary</em></p><p>The foundations of any science are really obvious. However, it is necessary to explicitly lay down these foundations despite their obviousness. The roots of physics and all science are in these principles. As we saw earlier, physics is the rigorous study of physical things. There is a reality that exists. This is the foundation on which all science is built. We must begin with what we know directly through our senses. We also see that things change. In other words, things are “something (act)”, but can become “something else (potency).”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/382/1*hulzPbTYHzQCakk2vxtZdQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 9</strong>: Calvin is a math atheist.</figcaption></figure><p>Change is the reduction of potentiality to act. For example, a green apple is only potentially red. When it does become red, it changes. Do not think about change in terms of time-derivatives (<em>d</em>/<em>d</em>t). A time-derivative does not define change at all because mathematics does not contain any change or causes by its nature. Do not use any modern mathematical knowledge at this point. We are trying to establish the foundations. All our “modern” specialized scientific knowledge comes from these foundational principles. Thus, we cannot use specialized science to lay down these foundations.</p><p>In reality, change happens in many ways. Returning to the apple turning red, it is a change in a certain “quality” called color. The color of the apple changed. But it is still an apple. What if I eat that apple? Apple becomes a part of me. There is no apple anymore. This is somehow a different type of change compared to just a simple change in color. When the color changes, the substantial form of the apple itself does not change. A red apple is still an apple. Such a change is “accidental change” i.e., change in a property. When you eat an apple, that apple loses its form. Its substance becomes a part of you as you digest that apple. In this case, there is a “substantial change” in the apple in that its substance as apple had to be lost for it to become a part of you.</p><p>A physical thing has two parts: 1) what it is actually (e.g., apple) or “<em>form</em>” and 2) what it is potentially (e.g., a part of you) or “<em>matter</em>”. In a substantial change, as in the case of eating an apple, the form of one substance (apple) is lost and replaced with another (part of you). The potential of the first substance to become the second substance is called prime matter. We will discuss this in more detail in upcoming chapters. On the other hand, in a property change, the property form of a substance is changing. For example, color is a property or accident (that which accretes in another). Change of color is also a change. But it is not on the same footing as a substantial change. The potential of a substance to change to a new property is called secondary matter.</p><p>Clearly, there is a big difference between substance and properties. Aristotle describes it in his “<em>categories</em>” while Kanada calls them “<em>padarthas</em>.” Chapter 8 will discuss science in Indic philosophy in more detail. For now, we want to understand physical things based on our direct experience. Using apple as an example, we were able to see that physical things either as substance (<em>dravya</em>) or properties (<em>guna</em>). A substance is a thing that exists by itself. A property cannot exist in reality by itself. It is present as a part of a substance. For example, “red” exists in an apple or some physical object. There is no “red” by itself. It is always “red” something.</p><p>The term ‘substance’ corresponds to the Greek <em>ousia</em>, which means ‘<em>being</em>’, transmitted via the Latin substantia, which means “something that stands under or grounds things.” In science speak, a physical substance is something that exists (or stands) by itself. Naturally, all physical substances have some common types of properties because of their physical nature. For example, many physical things have common properties such as mass, color, temperature etc. We can “categorize” (following Aristotle’s categories) these into several types of properties.</p><p>Right off the bat, we can see there are some properties that are inherent to a physical thing while some other properties exist only in relation to other physical things. For instance, an apple is an extended object with one part outside another. Such “extension” is an inherent property of the apple. But, the place of that “apple” is relative. The apple is either here or there. When we say “here” or “there”, it is indexical with respect to our own position. Thus, place of an apple is an extrinsic property that depends on other physical things. Similarly, you can think of a fish swimming in water. The surrounding aqueous environment is extrinsic and not an inherent property of the fish. Aristotle used the word “accident” for property. “Accident” and “accreted” both come from the Latin word “accrescere” which means to increase or grow. In other words, accidents exist in (or “added to” in a way) physical substances. For an apple to look the way it does is a “proper” accident because apples are made that way. But, the place of an apple (e.g., apple on the dining table) is a “mere” accident.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/552/1*Gt-KCNprm_TjhqVhRTwy2A.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 10</strong>: The intrinsic and extrinsic categories of accidents or properties.</figcaption></figure><p>These accidents could be listed down in different categories, as shown in Fig. 10. Note that these categories are being derived from our direct knowledge of physical things. We are endeavoring to establish the <em>ab initio</em> principles. Thus, as I had mentioned earlier, we cannot use specialized sciences (which are based in the <em>ab initio</em> principles) to define the <em>ab initio</em> principles. Using our direct experience, let us now discuss the categories in Fig. 10 in more detail.</p><p>It is very straightforward to see what these categories mean from daily things we say or hear. Think about these famous dialogues and connect to the some of the categories of accidents in Fig. 10. Think about what you mean when we say the “names of accidents” (see Fig. 10) like quantity, quality, action, reception etc in daily life.</p><p>1) <em>Kitney aadmi the</em>? (Quantity)</p><p><em>2)</em> <strong><em>Monica</em></strong><em>: Okay, I…I don’t know. You… you just… you have a quality.</em></p><p><strong><em>Everyone</em></strong><em>: Yeah. Absolutely. A quality.</em></p><p><strong><em>Chandler</em></strong><em>: Oh, oh, a quality! Good, because I was worried you guys were gonna be vague about this. </em>(Quality)</p><p><em>3)</em> <em>Rishte mein to hum tumhare baap lagte hain </em>(Relation)</p><p><em>4)</em> <em>Edged</em> (Action) and <em>taken </em>(Reception)</p><p><em>5)</em> <em>Hum jahan khade ho jaate hain, line wahi se shuru hoti hain</em> (Place).</p><p>Although we use these categories daily, we do not understand them clearly. To establish the <em>ab initio</em> principles, we need to properly lay out explicit definitions for these categories.</p><p><strong>Quantity</strong>: Any physical thing is extended i.e., has length, height, and width. Quantity primarily refers to this extension of having one part next to another. For example, bottom part of the apple in Fig. 10 is closer to the table and the top part is away. Extension is the primary intrinsic accident for physical things. There is no comparison here i.e., we are not talking about any properties relative to some other object. Thus, extension is intrinsic to any physical thing. No physical thing exists without extension. Because physical things have many parts, these parts can be counted, which is what numbers are. Numbers are essentially wholes with parts (for example, number 5 has five one parts). The study of quantity is mathematics. We can further divide quantity into two subcategories: 1) Geometry that studies extended objects such as triangles and circles and 2) Arithmetic leaves out how the different parts of an extended body touch each other leaving only the number of parts.</p><p><em>Examples</em>: A circle, a plane, numbers</p><p><strong>Quality</strong>: A quality makes/determines a physical thing to be in a particular way. Much like extension/quantity, quality is also intrinsic to a physical thing. For example, color is a quality present in an apple. Similarly, hotness, coldness, softness, hardness etc. are all different qualities. Unlike quantities, qualities are not always additive. For example, hundred mediocre physicists are not equal to one Einstein.</p><p><em>Examples</em>: A <em>red</em> apple, a <em>cold</em> glass, a <em>soft</em> toy</p><p>The other categories of accident are extrinsic in that their definition is dependent on other physical things.</p><p><strong>Relation</strong>: In Fig. 10, upon comparing the sizes of two apples, we say that one apple is larger (or smaller) than the other. This is a relation. As physical substances, apples have extension (i.e., one part next to another). We are “relating” this extension while comparing sizes. Indeed, measurement is a “relation.” For instance, we measure length by comparing the extension of the given object to the extension of some object that has been chosen as a standard meter (Fig. 11).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/238/1*nxOJJiw3uztdINIn0XLQ9Q.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 11</strong>: A National Prototype Metre Bar №27, manufactured by the International Bureau of Weights and Measures (BIPM) and given to the United States, which served as the standard for defining all units of length in the US from 1893 to 1960.</figcaption></figure><p>As already discussed, we measure other qualities such as mass also the same way.</p><p>Another type of important “relation” is cause and effect. A thing cannot change itself (we will discuss more on this later). One thing causes a change in another thing. Such a change of effect is related to the cause.</p><p><strong>Action</strong>: Consider Dhoni’s helicopter shot. What happens in it? Dhoni swings his bat in his signature way. As Ravi Shastri says, you hear “the crunching sound of timber when ball meets willow.” The bat “acts” on the ball by transferring momentum to send the ball out of the stadium. We can clearly see that one physical thing “acts” on another physical thing to change it. Another example for “action” is heating water for your next cup of tea. An external heat source acts on water to increase its temperature.</p><p><strong>Reception</strong>: When Dhoni’s bat acts on the ball, ball “receives” impetus or momentum transferred from the bat. When you are heating a bowl of water, water is “receiving” heat from the stove.</p><p><em>Do not mistake action and reception with “action and reaction” in Newton’s laws</em>. Action-reaction force pairs are very different from action and reception. As I noted, do not yet use any specialized science including Newton’s laws.</p><p><strong>Orientation</strong>: We are referring to “orientation” when we say that a bowler is bowling from the Pavilion end in Lord’s cricket ground. Orientation is the way the parts of the substance are situated relative to the environment.</p><p><strong>Place</strong>: Place is essentially another type of “relation”</p><p>between the substance and things around it. More precisely, “place” is the fixed surface defined where the substance and the things around it make contact. For example, a fish in a certain region of water in an aquarium.</p><p><strong>Environment</strong>: The environment is all the substances around a given substance. Water is the environment for a fish, for example.</p><p><strong>Time</strong>: Thus far, most definitions were probably straightforward. Defining time clearly is very critical to making progress to understand the rigor and implications of theories such as relativity, quantum mechanics etc. We will dedicate an entire chapter to time later in the book. But, let us think about the fundamental nature of time. Recall that we are laying down the <em>ab initio</em> principles here. This means that we will not be using specialized sciences (e.g., relativity) here. Also, it is incorrect and unwise to put “time” on the same footing as “space.” Of course, we do have four-vectors and space-time that we use extensively in physics. However, this “time” and “space” equivalence is only mathematical and not really physical.</p><p>Physically, we know things exists and change through our physical senses. Indeed, our very act of sensing relies on change. Time is the duration of this change. Change is the reduction of potentiality to act. This change is physical. It should not be thought of as a mathematical “time-derivative.” Mathematics cannot contain change inherently, as we discussed in the last chapter. We should put first things first. We do not know calculus first to define change as a “time-derivative.” We know physical things first.</p><p>In our daily life, we usually treat time simply as a measure of change. We say, for example, that it took half a day to go from Bangalore to Hyderabad. We measure (that simply means we compare; recall that measurement is essentially a relation) the change which is involved in going from Bangalore to Hyderabad with the change of the earth rotating once around its axis. We compare two changes to speak about time. We will dwell more on time later.</p><p><strong>What is the modern scientific method?</strong></p><p>Every time I ask someone to describe the modern scientific method (including science graduates), they provide an overly general approach with much misunderstanding. More importantly, it so happens that most people describe the scientific method in an algorithmic way. For example, Wikipedia describes the modern scientific method as the overall process that involves making conjectures (hypotheses), deriving predictions from them as logical consequences, and then carrying out experiments based on those predictions to determine whether the original conjecture was correct. Is this the modern scientific method? Is science algorithmic? No! Not at all! We have sensorial knowledge through our physical senses. From these sensorial phantasms, we draw generalities. This process is not algorithmic. Additionally, this Wikipedia sort of scientific method has been known for centuries going back to Socrates, Plato, Uddalaka, Kanada etc. There is nothing “modern” about this. What then is the “modern” scientific method?</p><p>The modern scientific method consists of the following two important aspects.</p><p>We “measure” the physical world through “quantity”. Recall that measurement is essentially a relation. Thus, we can measure “qualities” also. For example, we could measure mass (a quality) to be 5 kg. As mentioned before, this number “5 kg” (quantity) is useful for solving problems to predict the behavior of physical things (e.g., a moving car). We “measure” the intensity of a quality by comparing one object to another. It is important to note that measurement “compares” qualities to provide a “number or quantity.” Measurement, however, does not reduce quality to quantity. The so-called “datasets” we get from measurements are essentially relations. These do not tell anything about the nature or essence of the thing.</p><p>As discussed in the previous chapter, we have the ability to abstract generalities from particulars. We can also assign “symbols” to both “real beings” (that exist in reality) and “beings of reason” (that exist only in our mind and not in reality). This is very critical for the modern scientific method. For instance, there are no negative numbers in reality. You do not see “-1” cars and “-5” apples. Numbers are symbols. We use symbols and rules to formulate equations and laws that can in turn be used to make specific predictions about the world. Now, it is important to understand that the equations themselves entail physical reality. The equation for a “blackhole” does not itself contain the real existence or non-existence of a blackhole. The modern scientific method relies on writing equations, symbols, or drawing schema (e.g., evolution; see Fig. 12) that can be moved around according to the rules.</p><p>When a review for lbw is sent to the third umpire, you see the ball’s trajectory depicting how the ball would have gone onto the wickets. This prediction comes from our ability to symbolize and manipulate symbols.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/160/1*h3efkq0LAN8o8GCLY6RFTw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 12</strong>: Darwin’s first evolutionary tree shows how schematics (which are also a part of mathematics) are often used in biology.</figcaption></figure><p>Any physical thing is extended: the property of quantity. Thus, all its properties (including qualities) can be “measured” in numbers. Mathematics is the study of quantity: shape (geometry) and number (Arithmetic). Analysis is the bridge. Returning to Wigner’s comment on “<em>the unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics in physics</em>,” mathematics works so well because we are endeavoring to observe and describe the physical world through the primary accident of all physical things, i.e., quantity. Indeed, the study of quantity (mathematics) is so important because “quantity” being determined by “quality” also reveals qualities though in an indirect way.</p><p><strong>Principle of identity and causality</strong></p><p>Physical things are what they are. They cannot be and not be the same thing in the same way at the same time. This is quite evident to us in our life. A car could either be completely red or completely black. But it cannot be both completely red and completely black at the same time in the same way. The principle of logic that we either have X or NOT X comes from this principle of identity that things are what they are. Many trained physicists often mistake things such as “wave-particle” duality as disproving the principle of identity. This is not right because “specialized sciences” (e.g., quantum mechanics) that are built on the foundational <em>ab initio</em> principles (e.g., principle of identity) cannot be used to either establish or overturn the foundations. As I will describe later, “wave-particle duality” does not really disprove non-contradiction.</p><p>We can also see that a thing cannot change itself. You may claim that you are able to change yourself by walking from one place to another without any other external agent. Yet, in your body, one part of the body acts on another to make you move. Nothing can change itself. This is the principle of causality, which follows from the principle of identity. There are different types of causes. Aristotle calls them formal, material, efficient, and final causes while Kanada categorizes them as <em>nimitta</em> and <em>animitta karaana</em>. The modern scientific method is based on mathematics, which does not include any change directly at all. All mathematical time points exist simultaneously. Given that mathematics cannot include changes, mathematical equations cannot really describe causes. Indeed, Newton states this explicitly in his “Principia.” In observing the physical world through “quantity,” we are mostly looking for frameworks to describe “efficient” causes in an inchoate manner.</p><p>In this chapter, we discussed the modern scientific methods, defined mathematics and physics/science in a broader and a fundamental sense. We laid down the following <em>ab initio</em> principles viz., 1) Things exist, 2) Things change, 3) Principle of identity, 4) Principle of causality, and 5) A physical thing exists either as a substance (dravya) or a property in a physical substance (guna). Equipped with this, we will now venture into deeper physics to explore the meaning of space, time, and the universe itself!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f9b0719b1027" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The ab-initio principles]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@anand.lost/the-ab-initio-principles-4ac105f6de64?source=rss-d8d5e57361fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4ac105f6de64</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mathematics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ananda Sangeetam]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Nov 2020 00:19:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-15T03:28:55.577Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>2. The <em>ab-initio</em> principles</strong></h3><p><em>Hobbes: Do you want to play God?</em></p><p><em>Calvin: Not exactly! God never bothered to patent his stuff.</em></p><p>The nature around us is filled with beauty. I do not mean just fall colors, waterfalls, beaches, and hill stations. We use our physical senses to know things. Naturally, somethings are beautiful to us directly and immediately while others are beautiful only in an indirect way. Physical things that are commensurate with our senses are directly attractive to us. For example, take a look this honeycomb in Fig. 4. Our eyes are located in a specific physical way such that certain arrangements appear beautiful or symmetric to us in a direct way like the honeycomb in Fig. 4.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/414/1*B7EcQmesggdbTRYIOusfIQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4</strong>: Beauty lies in the eyes of “bee”-holder.</figcaption></figure><p>But somethings are not beautiful in an immediate or a direct way. Here is a high-resolution transmission electron micrograph of a single-atomic thick layer of carbon or graphene from my lab. It has the same honeycomb structure. What you are seeing is the arrangement of carbon atoms in a hexagonal lattice. Isn’t that beautiful?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/284/1*By-qp0hquiHfzubCZ4xdzQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 5</strong>: A high-resolution transmission electron microscope image of a single atom-thick carbon layer (graphene) from my lab.</figcaption></figure><p>Note that there are several layers between this microscope image and you. Seeing this microscope picture should not be put on the same footing as directly seeing a honeycomb. You can see a honeycomb directly first-hand. There are no other layers between your senses and the honeycomb. However, the microscope image is formed after some electrons passing through the actual material are modulated by a set of electromagnets, detected in a certain way, and finally projected on the computer screen. Even if you perform electron microscopy yourself, you still would not be able to directly see the honeycomb lattice in graphene at the atomic level in the same way as seeing an actual honeycomb.</p><p>At the macroscopic level, graphene/graphite is simply your pencil lead. It is a gray/black lump. It does not look as beautiful as a honeycomb. Yet, through our knowledge and understanding, we devised ways to look deeper into the atomic nature of such a lump. At that level, we are able to see beauty in the way atoms are arranged and organized within this lump. This second type of beauty comes from looking more deeply into the essence of the thing to learn how well perfected the individual nature is in its essence. Anything complete or unified is beautiful to us when we are able to understand that unity. For example, I am not a set of different chemicals. There are many chemicals in me. They all act together in unison towards a single goal of nurturing, growing, and protecting the body. This is the reason why we find any child beautiful even if they are not physically perfect like a honeycomb.</p><p>In this book, my goal is to show you the beauty of our universe in its complete awe. Without burying you in equation-first understanding, I want to take you through a tour of the universe to understand it by putting physics first. To this end, we need to set some fundamentals straight and cultivate true scientific temper.</p><p>To cultivate true scientific temper mentioned in Article 51A of the Indian constitution, we need to first understand the foundations of science. All science is physics. Chemistry, biology, or any other branch of science is ultimately rooted in physics. But what are the roots of physics? To answer this question, we need to first define physics in the broad sense. I am discussing physics in a broad sense, which is different from its restricted modern usage. Modern physics is physics in a narrow sense because it limits itself mainly to behavior of inanimate physical things.</p><p>As human beings, we know the world around us through our senses. We know the world through things that we see, feel, smell, hear, and taste. The first thing we notice as children is that there are things around us. We see that there are trees, fruits, dogs, cats, clouds, cars, and people. We also notice that things change. A ball that is here moves there if we push it. A plant grows. We grow taller. We notice things and changes in things. In fact, all our senses are rooted in change. <em>How do our senses sense</em>? For example, when a child touches a cold glass, her skin changes because heat flows from her hand to the glass making the glass warmer and her hand cooler. She is sensing that coldness through changes in her skin. Our senses are physical. All our knowledge ultimately comes from these physical senses. This does not mean that all our knowledge is sensorial. We also have intellectual knowledge. Based on our sensory perceptions, we inquire: What? Where? When? Why? How? These questions are indeed the beginning of physics. <em>Physics is the rigorous study of physical things</em>. It is the very basic science we must begin with because we first know physical things through our senses. From physics, other empirical and applied branches of science emerge.</p><p>Our study of physics begins with simple physical things that are directly accessible to our senses. Our sensory percepts provide “infra-scientific phantasms.” These sensory percepts are particular. In the previous example, the changes in child’s skin upon touching the glass are changes caused by that particular glass because that is the only glass in her physical contact at that point. Based on the sensorial perceptions or phantasms, our intellect draws generalities or “concepts.” Upon abstracting these generalities, we can quickly move to studying things that are only remotely and virtually accessible. The greatest step in modern science is to use mathematics rigorously to define symbols and manipulate them to study things that are only remotely accessible to our physical senses.</p><p>Mathematics is a major tool of physics. Indeed, as I mentioned in the previous chapter, Nobel laureate Eugene Wigner called it the “<em>unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics in physics</em>.” All the items we use routinely (cars, cell phones, TVs, laptops, internet, fridge, light bulbs) depend upon our ability to express our general physical understanding in mathematical equations. Your car requires classical equations of thermodynamics for engine design while your laptop is made possible through quantum mechanical equations. These equations are obviously very powerful because they are the main tools using which we can predict things. These predictions can be experimentally and objectively validated to ratify the soundness of the mathematical framework used. These equations are also beautiful in a mathematical way in addition to being powerful. In fact, I often say that physicists are poets because they write such beautiful and symmetric equations. We often get so enamored by the beauty and power of mathematical models that we confuse “equations” to be “reality.” The success of mathematics is reducing physical things to mere equations. We are confusing the essence of a thing with its measurable properties.</p><p>The general public (and even many “scientists”) think of physics as being purely equational. In many Indian schools and colleges, science is often described purely as the task of creating a “consistent” logical system of symbols to describe some aspect of reality through equations or schematics. For example, students are taught Newton’s laws of motion or chemical/biological reaction schematics. Somehow, a distinction between reality and mathematical/schematic constructs is rarely made in the Indian education system. You are handed down some equations with some vague connection to reality along with various recipes. You practice several problems that can be solved using these equations and recipes. You would not be asked questions such as “How do things move?” or “What is motion?” Instead, you would be asked questions such as “Explain Newton’s second law” as if that mathematical equation is the reality Your final grade will only depend upon regurgitating these algorithmic problem-solving skills without actually understanding reality.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/552/1*vFQ23CEQ6RqGuVnkh-PMCw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 6</strong>: Calvin finds a loophole!</figcaption></figure><p>The system of equations or schematics are mistakenly substituted for the real essence of a thing or things. Lastly, because of our ingrained habits of algorithmic problem solving, we act as if these mathematical equations that we use to encapsulate the properties of a thing are the essence of the thing. Our Indian science textbooks, science educators, and students (and their parents) are lost in algorithmic problem solving or cramming equations or acing tests. Their definition of “equality” is that of “mathematical equality.” For example, you may have been told <em>E </em>= <em>mc</em>2 implies that mass is just energy. But that is not really right. How could energy be mass? Mass is a passive property while energy is an active quality. How could we place both on the same footing? Does it make direct sense to you? Don’t just blindly repeat the explanations you may have heard from other trained physicists.</p><p>We will discuss the deeper nature of <em>E </em>= <em>mc</em>2 in a more detailed way in the upcoming chapters. Meanwhile, here is a simpler way to explain this equation. Look at nutrition facts of a large apple in Fig. 7. A large apple has 130 food calories i.e., energy. If it is a smaller apple, it may have around 90 food calories. Does this mean “apple” is “energy?” No. At a fundamental level, apple is a physical thing that has some potentiality to be a part of you or me. If you eat an apple, parts of that apple are digested and become a part of you. In other words, as we will see in the following section, apple changes “substantially” upon eating and each digested part releases energy that becomes a part of the person who ate the apple. In an analogical way, <em>E </em>= <em>mc</em>2 tells us that an electron (or any physical thing which has some mass) has the ability to change “substantially” (like an apple) and become energy of the plana (or “space”). There is a change of substance here that needs to be identified. Such fundamental nature and philosophy behind equations is rarely taught. Instead, a mathematical equality is thrust upon students as physical equality.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/188/1*zcXf0onDDm2fEh2CtDXuAA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 7</strong>: Nutrition facts for one large apple.</figcaption></figure><p>The new crop of educational resources use technology very well. There is a great “EdTech” boom in India. Yet, these new tools fail miserably to teach science in its right way. I don’t wish to sound pessimistic. I am only trying to set things straight. The aim of this book is not to blame or point fingers but to show the need for putting “first things first.” Now, you may think I am exaggerating the problem. So, I will provide an example. Like in the last chapter, I will ask you a question. You will see that this kind of “questioning” will continue throughout the book. At such junctures in the book, I urge you to pause and dwell on that question for a minute or two before returning to read.</p><p><em>What is mass?</em></p><p>What was your answer? Was it “amount of stuff?” You are most probably taught to think of mass to be the “amount of stuff” in something. This does not answer anything. It just pushes the problem away. What do we mean by “amount of stuff?” Let’s say you measure the mass of an object. In this measurement, we are comparing the given object’s quality called “mass” to a standard one-kilogram Iridium cylinder sitting in a museum in France. This measurement is a relation. I am weighing one object in terms of another object. If I am 90 kg, I am 90 times as heavy as the Iridium cylinder. The measurement of mass (or the “amount of stuff”) essentially compares two objects. It really does not answer what mass actually is. In today’s science education in India, we seem to be more interested only in equational physics. Mass is ultimately described as a number that you plug into the equation to obtain the answer. Let us take this example of mass a little further to see how the initial answer of “amount of stuff” is a circular definition.</p><p>Consider a 1 kg stone. Let us say this “1 kg” is the “amount of stuff.” What is this stuff? You are probably referring to so many electrons, protons, atoms, molecules etc that make the stone. Ok. But what is the mass of an electron? One could then quickly quote a number like (roughly) 10‑30 kg. In other words, we started with what is “1 kg” and then ended up saying that “1 kg” is essentially a lot of small “10–30 kg” s added together. Do you see the circularity? We really did not define mass anywhere here.</p><p>In this very simple example, we often confuse “mass” with a number that we measure. We made up this number. We chose that standard Iridium cylinder. We could have chosen some other object as the standard. Then, the measurement would made with respect to that. While this measurement yields a “relative” quantity, it does not describe the “qualitative” nature of mass.</p><p>A trained physicist might say that mass (<em>m</em>) is the resistance to accelerate (<strong><em>a</em></strong>) upon the application of a force (<strong><em>F</em></strong>). Further, he may assert that <em>m</em> = <strong><em>F</em></strong>/<strong><em>a</em></strong>. This equation itself also does not describe the “qualitative” nature of mass because mathematics itself involves no change. It is only referring to the measurement of mass in a symbolic way. It does not mean that the equation is incorrect. It is only a mental framework. Enamored by the success of algorithmic problem solving and equational science, we are making an implicit identification of the external reality with our own mental activity. Thus, effectively, in a lived way, reality becomes a construct! This is what Morpheus’s definition of reality entailed.</p><p><strong>Difficulties in learning Math and Science in India</strong></p><p>In a mathematical literacy report from CBSE in India, various educational surveys and achievement data over the years were analyzed. As you can see from the figure below, this analysis shows that the learning achievements of children in mathematics is not up to the expected levels despite all the</p><p>efforts made by states in this direction. Why? Is it that Indian children are incapable of learning? No. It is that we are making fundamental mistakes and errors in teaching. We are teaching mathematics and science as a set of disconnected formulas rather than as a coherent web of concepts. What is easier to learn: a disconnected list of random words or a rhyme? The latter because it is more unified than the former. True and easy learning will happen only when we can clearly focus on the foundational or ab initio principles (i.e., philosophy) to emphasize on the cohesiveness of all concepts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/552/1*AehdCuXfluxYX5VVSnZtgg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 8</strong>: A summary of the National Achievement Survey results for Mathematics in CBSE affiliated schools for Class X level (marked as a state) in the academic year 2017–18 is given below<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a></figcaption></figure><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> <a href="http://cbseacademic.nic.in/web_material/Manuals/Teachers_handbook-Maths.pdf">http://cbseacademic.nic.in/web_material/Manuals/Teachers_handbook-Maths.pdf</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4ac105f6de64" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is there no spoon?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@anand.lost/is-there-no-spoon-4bdbe6bd3c65?source=rss-d8d5e57361fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4bdbe6bd3c65</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ananda Sangeetam]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Nov 2020 18:01:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-15T03:21:27.131Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>1. Is there no spoon?</strong></h3><p><em>Hobbes</em>: Is it a right to remain ignorant?</p><p><em>Calvin</em>: I do not know. But I refuse to find out</p><p>There is a famous scene in the movie series “The Matrix”, where Neo is waiting to meet the Oracle. While in the waiting room, Neo sees a monk child (popularly known as the spoon boy) bending a spoon by merely looking at it. Neo is awestruck. In fact, he later attempts to bend the spoon himself. The spoon boy then tells Neo, “Do not try and bend the spoon, that’s impossible. Instead, only try to realize the truth. There is no spoon. Then you’ll see that it is not the spoon that bends, it is only yourself.” The spoon boy claims there is no spoon implying that spoon is not real, and we are all in the matrix. Indeed, Neo later recalls this during his mission to rescue Morpheus from the agents, uttering “There is no spoon” (i.e., “This is not real”) to himself after taking hold of the cable attached to a lift outfitted with bombs.</p><p>I am a big fan of the movie because I was fascinated by Morpheus, who asks some critical questions. As a physicist, I have always been fascinated by such questions. For example, Morpheus asks Neo a very fundamental question in the very beginning. <em>What is reality?</em> Yet, the answer he gives Neo is far from satisfactory. He asserts, “<em>What is real? How do you define ‘real’? If you’re talking about what you can feel, what you can smell, what you can taste and see, then ‘real’ is simply electrical signals interpreted by your brain</em>.” This indeed is perceived as the view of modern science by many, which is incorrect as I discuss later in this book. However, this statement is fundamentally flawed in a way because “interpretations” are not all we know. Our “perceptions” are not “reality” itself. An objective physical reality exists independent of our “perceptions”, “interpretations” or “subjectivity.” Indeed, this is the primary foundational principle for any science. However, lost in its mathematical rigor and equation-first understanding, modern science is espousing the spoon boy’s epithet (i.e., there is no spoon) to deny the very existence of an objective reality.</p><p>Based in pseudo-scientific illusion of knowledge, many believers of modern science portray life to be inherently nihilistic. Even I did at some point. Life has no meaning some say. This nihilistic view, often considered to be ratified by modern science, is that there is no meaning to life or the universe. As a physicist, I am saddened that this is the popular view of science, which is not proper. In this book, I expect to set the record straight on some such views specific to the Indian subcontinent. The meaning of reality sometimes is the topic of popular science books or articles written by non-scientists and at times by some scientists with much philosophical misunderstanding. Even worse, the meaning of reality is sometimes addressed by Gurus and Babas in India. This leads to much more confusion than clarity. Many Indian pseudo-spiritual gurus talk as if Indic philosophy is built on denying the very reality, we live in.</p><p>In a country like India, where anyone can claim to be an expert and a scientist, this sort of Matrix‑inspired philosophical denial of reality spreads extremely fast. Unfortunately, it is also a country with a lot of misinformation about science, morality, and spirituality. In India, we often use another word for “The Matrix”: Maaya. <em>So</em>,<em> is there no spoon</em>? <em>Is there such a thing as reality</em>? <em>Or is it all Maaya?</em> Many more such fundamental questions, which even a five-year-old child often asks parents, are mostly written off, swept under the rug, put on the back burner or something similar. Here are some more such questions.</p><p><em>What is reality? What is time? What is space? What is life? Why are we here? Is life meaningless? Is there a God?</em></p><p>Even worse, kids who ask such questions are often given vague answers that have been directly borrowed from some pseudo-authority. Despite human’s inherent need for answers, these simple yet profound questions are never really answered. Indeed, we are often advised to not think deeper and just go about our daily lives without bothering about these. Furthermore, people (especially educated Indians) often claim that these questions are not directly relevant for our daily routine and any philosophical inquiry is essentially not primary or even necessary. I call this approach “<em>shut up and live.</em>” Without a deeper inquiry, one cannot really identify one’s primary values. Failing to realize our true values, which should be rooted firmly in our scientific understanding of the objective reality, leads to a decadent state of life in the “<em>shut up and live</em>” approach.</p><p><strong>Is it “trust” or “blind faith” in science?</strong></p><p>Another approach that is at the epicenter of today’s moral dilemma in India is “<em>blind faith in science.</em>” It is not a hyperbole to state that today’s world revolves around modern science. People place much blind faith in science, as I show below. In this <em>blind faith</em> approach, some people ironically use science to claim that there is no inherent meaning to life. Let us look deeper into this kind. I believe this insight is necessary to make progress.</p><p>Today, we are facing a moral dilemma because most so-called “scientists”, “science popularizers”, and “science writers” are perpetuating a highly mathematized view of science (sans ontological understanding) that enhances “<em>blind faith</em>” without being rooted in the true scientific method. Unfortunately, even Nobel laureates are no exception<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>. One must not forget that something does not become right in science because the majority thinks it should be right. For instance, almost all physicists thought Newton’s description of space and time was right. But, only one person (Albert Einstein) saw that Newton excessively abstracted space and corrected it.</p><p>The veracity of a theory should not be tested by a majority vote in science. The public should be aware that most science articles published in reputed peer-reviewed journals have been and could be proved wrong. These science articles cannot the arbiter of truth. The general public should hold reality as the ultimate arbiter of truth. Scientists should be rational. But that rationality is being lost due to subjectivity and moral relativism among scientists. The philosophical decadence in today’s scientific culture leads to misconceptions about our very own reality. Without any awareness of philosophical biases in science, the general public blindly places faith in science. Let us discuss this blind faith in science in a more quantitative way.</p><p>In a 2016 study published by the American Academy of Arts and Sciences (AAAS), it was found that approximately 90 percent of Americans had either a “great deal” or “some” confidence in science (<strong>Figure</strong> 1), far above the press, Congress, and banks and financial institutions<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/386/1*q-j4m77Sc3jdgYaAeAqY-w.png" /></figure><p><strong>Figure 1</strong>: Percentage of respondents who trust research scientists to tell the truth or be impartial (see footnote2). Each square represents 1%.</p><p>Although they know about science through the press (which they do not trust as much), they trust science. More importantly, almost 80% believe that scientists are impartial in matter of public debate. But what is impartiality? Do people believe scientists are mostly free of philosophical or moral biases? Could scientists really be truly impartial in matters of public debate (especially those concerning with policy) with their biases? We will discuss these biases among scientist in the next section. But, for now, let us look at a more recent global version of this survey.</p><p>In a 2020 survey by Pew research center<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a>, it was found that 38% in the US trust science “a lot” while 39% trust “some.” This means ~77% have some trust in science and scientists in the US. Not surprisingly, India stood 1st in this survey in terms of public trust in science (<strong>Figure</strong> 2).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/462/1*103OP2wylW7rVrCOk39AeA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Figure 2</strong>: The percentage of people who say they have <em>a lot/some/not much trust</em> in science (International Science Survey 2019–20, Pew research center).</p><p>According to this survey, 59% Indians trust science “a lot” while 26% place “some” trust in science. In total, at least 85% Indians have some trust in science. In other words, in both US and India (which have vastly different cultures), at least &gt;75% have some faith in “science.” You would think that such societies that trust science so much should be thriving. Clearly, they are not. I am not denying the “technological” progress of the past few decades. Despite these technological advances, we only seem to be becoming more divided. Today, America and India are facing so much more cultural, moral, ethical, and racial divide than in their recent history. In countries where &gt;75% people have at least “some trust” in science, why is there this divide? Is this really “<em>trust</em>” or “<em>blind faith</em>”?</p><p>The unfortunate truth is that much of this “trust” is blind faith. We are suckers for authority. We have limited attention span. Most of the general public, blindly placing their “trust” in science, do not read the actual peer-reviewed publications. Even if they do, they do not understand the intricacies because most publications (e.g., climate change or global warming) require advanced mathematical and statistical techniques in addition to deep knowledge about physical measurement methods. The general public (who place so much trust in science) really have no clue about mathematical or statistical rigor or even how scientific biases could affect the data. Then, how do they trust science? Are they accepting it based on reality or some scientific authority? The general public often knows the “oversimplified” interpretation of some science popularizers or some science writers in the media. As a scientist who has been interviewed for many science news articles, I personally know how much hype/spin is often added to science news to promote it.</p><p>Here is an example. The general public thinks that the atom is “mostly nothing.” In fact, they claim that physics tells us that there is nothing between a nucleus and an electron in an atom. On the contrary, physics does not actually say this. The space between nucleus and electron is not “nothingness.” It is something. It hosts fields and gets perturbed by them. It is unfortunate that many so-called “science” personalities are not really scientific and perpetuate their own philosophical biases. Yet, the public does not know this. Here is another interesting survey done in the US. You would think that in countries like India and US with at least 77% people that place at least some trust in science people would be able to name some scientists. But, take a look at this.</p><p>In a 2008 survey released by the Museum of Science and Industry in Chicago, Illinois<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a>, nearly half the people could not name a “role model” scientist, living or dead. Only 11% could come up with the name of a living scientist. Who do you think that American public thinks of as scientists? Bill Gates and Al Gore. Each was named by 6% of the sample, on a par with Albert Einstein. Interestingly, most respondents also reported that citizens’ ignorance of science is “a detriment to the nation.”</p><p>The problem I wish to point out here is that people do not really “trust” science. They have “<em>blind faith</em>.” Trusting something that you do not really understand is very dangerous, as it is reflected in today’s moral dilemma. In another survey published in the reputed “Proceedings of National Academy of Sciences (PNAS)”<a href="#_ftn5">[5]</a>, US Science &amp; Engineering Indicators (SEI) surveys show that one in three Americans (36%) misunderstood the concept of probability; almost half of the population (49%) was unable to provide a correct description of a scientific experiment; and three in four (77%) were unable to describe the idea of a scientific study. Yet, ~75–90% of these people “trust” science.</p><p>Without knowing what science is truly or even basic scientific concepts, the general public is blindly placing faith in authorities and looking to them for answers: both spiritual and scientific. The world mistakes “science popularizers” or “technologists” to be scientists, as evident from the Chicago museum survey. Al Gore is not a scientist. Neither is Bill Gates.</p><p>As we have seen in the above surveys, public holds scientists in high regard. On the other hand, scientists are very critical of the public for their blind faith in science. Indeed, according to another 2009 survey by Pew research center<a href="#_ftn6">[6]</a>, 85% of scientist view the public’s lack of scientific knowledge as a major problem for science, and almost half of them (49%) fault the public for having unrealistic expectations about the speed of scientific achievements.</p><p>Scientists do not like to blame themselves really. So, they blame the media as a reason for public’s blind faith in science. A significant percentage of scientists (76%) believe that the news media is a major problem for science because they often fail to distinguish between findings that are well-founded and those that are not. While media has its own spins and biases, scientists are full of unexamined biases that people are very unaware of.</p><p><strong>Philosophical biases in science</strong></p><p>Physicists Stephen Hawking and Leonard Mlodinow mention something very important on the very first page of their 2010 book “The Grand Design.” They assert that modern philosophy is dead because modern philosophers have not kept up with modern developments in science, particularly physics. This is indeed true. Modern science is mathematically rigorous. Following Newton’s Principia, physics rapidly evolved to become “equation-first” rather than “physics-first.”</p><p>Nobel laureate Eugene Wigner once wrote an article describing “the unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics in physics” showing how physics has become a branch of advanced mathematics by placing “equations-first.” It is not possible for modern philosophers to truly comprehend the ontological implications of modern physics without being trained in rigorous mathematical approaches. So, physicists have now become the torchbearers of philosophy as well. This is a major problem because physicists are lost in their mathematical rigor and are full of unexamined philosophical biases. Even basic concepts such as inertia, mass, and space are very “mathematically” described in physics leaving “reality” and “ontological” understanding behind.</p><p>Let us consider another interesting survey among physicists done by the Pew research center (<strong>Figure</strong> 3).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/552/1*QKVLFhQUcT5QNa-TBPPMlg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Figure 3</strong>: Religious belief among scientists (Religion and Science in the US, Pew Research Center)</p><p>According to this survey<a href="#_ftn7">[7]</a>, almost 60% of scientists (similar averages across different fields) do not believe in God. <em>Has science undoubtedly disproved God</em>? At this point in the book, I am not siding with either a yes or a no. I am simply asking you an objective question. Before you answer, please be careful to note that religious scriptures are not God. I am not asking if science disproved any such scriptures. Most people, including physicists like Carl Sagan, think that there is nothing for a creator do. Science has not really disproven God. So, a prejudice that there is no God without a concrete understanding of mathematically rigorous modern science is indeed a philosophical bias: one that more than half physicists unfortunately hold. It is even more unfortunate that today’s search engines are only adding to the problem with increased confirmation-bias.</p><p>In India, Javed Akhtar, a lyricist who was recently awarded a prize by Richard Dawkins for being rational, claims that a rational man must reject God like he is a trained physicist. Neither Dawkins nor Akhtar understand the mathematical rigor of physics. Akhtar absolutely has no understanding of mathematically rigorous modern science at all. He thinks that asking a fundamental question such as the meaning of life is pompous. But, how do we even understand pomposity without knowing what our life means? On the same stage as this self-claimed “rational” man, we have Sadhguru, who is equally ignorant of modern science and interested in logic chopping to sell some convenient philosophy rather than truth. In America, it is Al Gore and Bill Gates. In India, it is Javed Akthar and Sadhguru. Who wants to talk to an actual scientist when there are all these pseudo-intellectuals and stand-up spiritualists?</p><p>Now, the situation is so dire. Why? Because science has become an algorithmic problem-solving scheme mistaking mathematical expression with ontological existence of a thing. To train students in physics, we are essentially teaching them only certain algorithms. We ask them to follow our own approach of “<em>shut up and calculate</em>.” You can read more about the history and prevalence of this “<em>shut up and calculate</em>” physics approach in MIT Prof. David Kaiser’s article in Nature<a href="#_ftn8">[8]</a>. As Prof. Kaiser explains in this article, “<em>Openly philosophical areas of physics, the intellectual roots of which stretched back before the war, became increasingly marginalized, such as grand questions about the birth and fate of the Universe, the thin border between order and disorder in chaotic systems, or the subtle foundations of quantum theory. Sometimes these were denigrated as not even being ‘real physics’ by influential physicists in the United States</em>.” Talking about any philosophical implications or discussing the existence/non-existence of God in a physics classroom is often discouraged so as to not offend some students or avoid philosophical confrontations. “<em>Shut up and calculate</em>” is indeed the motto of most physicists today.</p><p><em>Does having a PhD or a scientist position make you a scientist</em>? As I mentioned earlier, physicists have now displaced philosophers. Although these physicists formally have doctoral degrees in philosophy, many of them have probably never even studied any philosophy of any kind. Forget studying. It is not a hyperbole to say that physicists consider philosophical thought to be dead. To be the real torchbearers of discovery and quest for truth, physicists must become more cognizant of their own philosophical biases and endeavor to come out of the present philosophical bankruptcy. They are seduced by mathematical equations and often forget reality.</p><p>I am not asserting that the results of all our mathematical theories is wrong. No. Mathematics is a great tool. But mathematics is in our head. Thus, mathematics itself does not directly include any real change or cause. The equation itself cannot confirm the existence of a thing. For example, the equation does not itself contain the real existence of a blackhole. The equation for describing a car moving with a constant velocity <em>x</em> = <em>vt</em> does not itself include change because all mathematical time points exist simultaneously at the same “time.” The equation, as an equation, itself is true for all times. We will discuss this in more detail in the next chapter.</p><p>Any philosophical premise that is implicitly accepted in our theories and methods is a philosophical bias. Philosophical assumptions often skew the development of hypotheses, the design of experiments, the evaluation of evidence, and the interpretation of results in specific directions. For example, when choosing a scientific method to establish a causal relationship between some medical condition and a virus, one must first have an idea of what causality is. Causality cannot be discovered “mathematically” unlike correlations. Mathematics does not involve real causes. As Hawking puts it, “What breathes fire into the equations?” A set of mathematically well-formed equations cannot describe its own cause. Not realizing philosophical biases leads to mistaking correlations to be causality. It is imperative to choose philosophical premises explicitly and purposely to avoid ‘biases’. In most cases, however, scientists remain unaware of these assumptions and of how they influence research, as pointed out by Rocca <em>et al</em><a href="#_ftn9"><strong><em>[9]</em></strong></a>.</p><p><strong>What exactly is a philosophical bias?</strong></p><p>Scientists always endeavor to avoid bias of any kind because biases are a detriment to objectivity, transparency, and rationality. Indeed, as scientists, we have made conscious efforts to identify, critically examine, and suggest various solutions different types of biases. We have many methodologies to address statistical biases (e.g., sample diversity, data-selection bias). Yet, these “biases” are mostly focused on mathematical and statistical aspects. They do not really discuss philosophical biases. To see how philosophical biases are impacting modern science and our own culture, we must first understand scientific objectivity.</p><p>What is scientific objectivity? It is imperative to answer this question because we cannot be scientifically “objective” unless we know “objectivity.” We must put first things first. The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy defines scientific objectivity as the following.</p><p>“<em>Scientific objectivity is a characteristic of scientific claims, methods and results. It expresses the idea that the claims, methods and results of science are not, or should not be influenced by particular perspectives, value commitments, community bias or personal interests, to name a few relevant factors. Objectivity is often considered as an ideal for scientific inquiry, as a good reason for valuing scientific knowledge, and as the basis of the authority of science in society</em>.”</p><p><em>Pay close attention to the fourth line that states “value commitments.” What is a value commitment? Here, values are two kinds in science. Empirical values</em> such as predictive accuracy, scope, unification, explanatory power, simplicity and coherence with other accepted theories are taken to be indicative of a good scientific theory. On the other hand, contextual values are moral, personal, social, political and cultural values such as pleasure, justice and equality. So, how do we decide if commitment to a value makes science less objective or more objective? If we cannot determine our values objectively, can we ever achieve true scientific objectivity? If science is “<em>free of value commitment</em>”, is it science still? It is not a simple or a trivial question.</p><p>Elena Rocca <em>et al</em>.<a href="#_ftn10">[10]</a> point out that ‘philosophical biases’ are ubiquitous and unavoidable in science. These are <em>b</em>asic <em>inherent</em> <em>truths</em> in <em>s</em>cience about how the world is (ontology), what we can know about it (epistemology), or how science ought to be practiced (norms). Philosophical biases influence, justify and enable scientific practice: in short, they are an integral part of science.</p><p>Today, scientists think that returning to the “first principles of science” i.e., philosophy is itself a bias. In trying to set the fundamentals right, they pull the rug under your feet. It is unfortunate that today’s scientists treat philosophy as an arm-chair discipline disconnected from science. Indeed, in his book Dreams of a Final Theory, Nobel laureate Steven Weinberg dedicates an entire chapter (“Against Philosophy”) to assert that physicists do not need philosophy. He clearly states that philosophy does more harm than good. He makes a case for “the unreasonable ineffectiveness of philosophy” in physics referring to the famous observation of another Nobel laureate physicist Eugene Wigner about “the unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics,” which I mentioned earlier.</p><p>Without understanding the biases of scientists and statistical nature of results, media overhypes these results. A clear example is the case of global warming and climate gate. Global warming is real. But we were able to reach that scientific conclusion only after much scrutiny and ruling out many biases. A meta-assessment of biases<a href="#_ftn11">[11]</a> found that scientific biases modestly increased in intensity over time, particularly in the social sciences. Scientists, despite their profession, are not free of biases, especially philosophical ones.</p><p><em>Should philosophy and science be really disconnected</em>? To understand this, we must know what philosophy truly means. Philosophy provides the first principles (which we will discuss in the forthcoming chapters) for any science. Any specialized science is ultimately founded in these first principles. While it is true that modern philosophers have not kept up with modern science, it is also true that modern physicists and scientists incorrectly consider any philosophical thinking as an unavoidable bias. Philosophy is the base that science builds on. Specialized science, which is built on the first principles of philosophy, cannot be used to overturn these very first principles. Considering first principles as a “bias” is to pull the rug under your feet.</p><p><strong>Why is all this important for India?</strong></p><p><em>Where did we come from? Where are we going? What is the purpose of our life? How should we live</em>? All of us think about some such deep questions at least some of the time. In India, many often resort to spirituality to answer these questions. On the other hand, many “educated” Indians have <em>blind faith</em> in science, as discussed earlier. They falsely believe that science answered these questions undisputedly. They think science has disproven God. Both theists and atheists in India are asserting either the existence or the non-existence of God without proper and deeper inquiry. In either case, “illusion of knowledge” is on the rise in Indian culture. The “spiritual” kind are approaching Babas and Sadhgurus that are not primarily scientists. They feel that science has no answers for these questions. Some of them like another approach “<em>Shut up and pray</em>.” The other so-called “educated” or “scientific” side has only <em>blind faith</em> in science. They have not studied either the Vedas or Upanishads. I have met many friends who outright reject things such as “Vaiseshika” without having ever read it or Newton’s “Principia.” They have the false illusion that they have gathered sufficient knowledge to accept or reject some thesis. Yet they speak like experts. This also applies to the “<em>shut up and pray</em>” Indians as well. Our culture should be driven by true science. The dichotomy of science and spirituality, physics and metaphysics is only an apparent one. It is not true. The success of mathematical theories without any ontological interpretation makes science far removed from the general public. Even more dangerous is that we are resorting to pseudo-philosophies and pseudo-spirituality in search of these fundamental questions. This is detrimental for our progress.</p><p>India is undoubtedly facing a great moral dilemma. It is caught between pseudo-intellectuals and pseudo-spiritualists. As a developing nation facing many economic, political, and moral challenges, Indian requires an earnest reassessment of its original Indic philosophy and modern science. Despite major investments in the last few decades in India, the tag of a “<em>developed nation</em>” still lingers beyond our reach due to the dearth of true intellectuals and scientists. India has been a developing nation for many decades now. <em>How could it progress faster when most place blind faith either in science or in spirituality</em>? The Indian constitution urges us to cultivate scientific temper. Unless we cultivate such scientific temper, we cannot progress. After all, the motto of our country is “<em>Satyam eva jayate</em>” (Truth alone triumphs). Science is focused on finding the truth. We should put aside our differences, philosophical biases, blind faith (in religion or science), and identify our foundational principles. Indian culture is extremely valuable to be lost. It is our duty to at least make an effort to learn about it before we discard or keep it blindly.</p><p>Science begins with the first principle that there is a reality. Science, in general, is the study of physical things that are something now but can become something else later. We are not “nothing.” There is a reality. There is a spoon. This fact is empirical and is not on the same footing as a mathematical axiom, as I will explain in later chapters.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> See Prof. Richard Muller’s lecture on a panel discussion on consensus and controversy in science, Feb 1 2016, American Academy of Arts and Sciences (AAAS), <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pO3EYnNsSnA">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pO3EYnNsSnA</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> <a href="https://www.amacad.org/publication/perceptions-science-america/section/4">https://www.amacad.org/publication/perceptions-science-america/section/4</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/science/collection/public-views-about-science/">https://www.pewresearch.org/science/collection/public-views-about-science/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> Science 28 Mar 2008: Vol. 319, Issue 5871, pp. 1741</p><p><a href="#_ftnref5">[5]</a> PNAS April 16, 2019 116 (16) 7662–766</p><p><a href="#_ftnref6">[6]</a> <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2009/07/09/public-praises-science-scientists-fault-public-media/">https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2009/07/09/public-praises-science-scientists-fault-public-media/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref7">[7]</a> <a href="https://www.pewforum.org/2009/11/05/scientists-and-belief/">https://www.pewforum.org/2009/11/05/scientists-and-belief/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref8">[8]</a> Nature 505, 153–155 (09 January 2014)</p><p><a href="#_ftnref9">[9]</a> <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6415937/">https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6415937/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref10">[10]</a> <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6415937/">https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6415937/</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref11">[11]</a> PNAS April 4, 2017 114 (14) 3714–3719</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4bdbe6bd3c65" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Vaiseshika (Part 1)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@anand.lost/on-vaiseshika-part-1-fbb1f6154df7?source=rss-d8d5e57361fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fbb1f6154df7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kanada]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ananda Sangeetam]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 11 Oct 2020 17:58:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-11T17:58:10.318Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is a word-by-word translation of Ch 4 from Kanada’s Vaiseshika.</p><p><strong><em>Sat akaaraNa​​vat nityam (1)</em></strong></p><p><em>What exists (Sat) does not change (nityam) without a cause (akaaraNavat)</em></p><p>To truly understand this sentence, we must return to the roots to examine words with clarity of thought. Without such clarity of thought directly rooted in objective reality and the <em>ab initio</em> principles of Vedopanishads, this was misinterpreted before(for example, see a common misinterpretation below from <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/31840715-matter-and-mind">https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/31840715-matter-and-mind</a>)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DIuKckA_WrH1ynf6LTj72g.png" /></figure><p>It is undeniable that our use of language has been very strongly influenced by mathematics in the last three centuries, particularly following the success of Newtonian mechanics. In addition, poor western translations of Sanskrit words are now replacing the original meaning. We often use words without realizing their true meaning or import. There are two ways in which we learn in our childhood: 1) association of an instrumental sign pointing to a physical substance/form and 2) true transference of meaning. A child can do #1 very easily. Even toddlers can sort cubes, circles, and cylinders based on their shape. They associate the word “circle” with a physical thing. They do not have #2 i.e., transference. This is very similar to signal ability of some amazing animals like Koko, a female gorilla that associated around 1000 signs (see F. Patterson’s research articles; <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/00437956.1990.11435816">https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/00437956.1990.11435816</a>). There is no transference here. The gorilla could also sort circles from squares. But, it has no “ideas” of what a circle generally means. What is a circle? A circle is defined by a boundary of points equidistant from the center. Thus, a perfect circle has infinite number of sides. It does not exist in “reality” because there in nothing infinite in physical reality. A perfect circle then is “a being of reason” and a mental construct, an effect of our intellectual ability to transfer meaning and abstract. We have an intellect that is not physical. We have “ideas” (e.g., infinity or perfect circle) that are not physically real. From an “instrumental sign” (i.e., a circular object), we can transfer the meaning to a “pure sign” or an “idea” (i.e., a perfect circle).</p><p>A child does not understand this. Yet, for all practical purposes of day-to-day life, knowing “circle” as an instrumental sign is sufficient. So, many of us know many words in our language only as “instrumental signs” but not in their true sense as “pure signs”. We use many words such time, space, motion, force etc daily only as “instrumental signs” that point to a thing without the true transference of meaning. Our culture, therefore, impacts our language so much because the more we use a word exclusively as an “instrumental sign” that’s the meaning it will acquire. We forget the roots very easily and thus often fail to achieve true transference of meaning of a word as a “pure sign”.</p><p>Here are two examples. Let us consider a simple word “<em>prapancha</em>”. What does this mean? Many would immediately translate it to mean “<em>world</em>”, “<em>Earth</em>”, “<em>universe</em>” etc. But, <em>prapancha</em> literally means the collection of physical things that can be experienced by <em>pancha indriyas</em>. The <em>pancha bhootas</em> are often misinterpreted as the primordial five elements that make up everything. <em>Pancha bhootas</em> really are a symbol for different types of sensorial knowledge and have been very clearly associated with our senses in Vedic literature. A<em>ll our knowledge ultimately begins in our physical senses</em>. The <em>pancha indriyas</em> are our connection to physical reality. Thus, <em>prapancha</em> literally means that which you sense through your organs and infer by mind. Another example is “<em>sharira</em>”. This is often translated as “body” and used to denote “corporeal body”. But, what is the true meaning of it? <em>Sharira</em> comes from a root word that means to “change by dissolving”. Thus, s<em>harira</em> literally means that which can change.</p><p>Now, let us return to our original statement of “<strong><em>Sat akaaraNa​​vat nityam</em></strong>” to consider the word “nitya”. This word is generally translated to mean “always” or “at all times”. Here, it is critical to note the link with “time”. What exactly do we mean by time?</p><p>Often, you hear “time” described on par with “space” in a very confused way. Unfortunately, modern physicists make this mistake in their efforts to simplify and capture physical reality in beautiful mathematical equations. They end up oversimplifying and excessively abstracting in the process. Indeed, Newton excessively abstracted “space” and “time”. Einstein set this straight by re-investigating these concepts from their foundational definitions. We describe “time” as if it is a real background physical entity that “exists” and “flows”. We describe “changes” as if they are happening in this background of flowing time. We mistake “mathematical time” to be “true time” itself. We forget that “mathematical time” is a substitute, an abstraction, and a mental construct. Issac Newton, in the very first chapter of his Principia, warns us of this. It was not the Newton did not realize his excessive abstraction. He was very clear about it, as you can see from the following excerpt from Newton’s Principia.</p><p>“<em>I do not define time, space, place and motion, as being well known to all. Only I must observe, that the vulgar conceive those quantities under no other notions but from the relation they bear to sensible objects. And thence arise certain prejudices, for the re moving of which, it will be convenient to distinguish them into absolute and relative, true and apparent, mathematical and common. I. Absolute, true, and mathematical time, of itself, and from its own nature flows equably without regard to anything external, </em><strong><em>and by another name is called duration : relative, apparent, and common time, is some sensible and external (whether accurate or unequable) measure of duration by the means of motion, which is commonly used instead of true time</em></strong><em> ; such as an hour, a day, a month, a year.</em>”</p><p>As I had mentioned earlier, all our knowledge ultimately begins in our sense. We know, based on the generalities from our sensorial knowledge, that things exist and things change. What is a physical thing? A physical thing is something now (i.e., it exists as something now) but it can become something else (i.e., changes). It is this duration of change that is time. Time is an extrinsic quality that originates from the ability of physical things to change. If there is no change, there is no time. TIme is based on change. Unfortunately, even physicists fall prey to mathematics and wrongly interpret “change” as a “time-derivative”. But, that “mathematical time” originates from “ability of things to change”. “Nitya” literally means “no change”. Something does not change should not be mistaken as “eternal”. Eternal implies the background of time. When there is no change, there is no “duration of change” or “time”. It is important to make this very necessary distinction.</p><p>A thing is what it is. A thing cannot be and not be the same thing in the same way. This is the principle of identity (Tat Twam Asi) or non-contradiction. If a thing is what it is, it cannot change itself. To change itself, a thing must give itself something that it does not have. Nothing changes itself (Causality). Given that a thing cannot change itself, a cause external to the thing is needed for change. Without any such cause, there will be no change. Simply put,”No Cause No change”. No material change is causeless.</p><p>Thus, “<strong><em>Sat akaaraNa​​vat nityam” translates to “what exists does not change without a cause”</em></strong></p><p>The meaning of this first statement becomes even more clear from the following the subsequent one.</p><p><strong><em>Tasya kaarya lingam (2)</em></strong></p><p>This is what the observation of effects shows us. There is no material change without a cause. A thing is what it is and cannot change without a cause (<em>principle of identity</em>). This identity (<em>lingam</em>) is evident in the effects of that existence (<em>tasya kaarya</em>). More later…..</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fbb1f6154df7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[త్రివిక్రం గారు గిమ్మిక్కులు చాలు, గారడీలు చేయండి]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@anand.lost/%E0%B0%A4%E0%B1%8D%E0%B0%B0%E0%B0%BF%E0%B0%B5%E0%B0%BF%E0%B0%95%E0%B1%8D%E0%B0%B0%E0%B0%82-%E0%B0%97%E0%B0%BE%E0%B0%B0%E0%B1%81-%E0%B0%97%E0%B0%BF%E0%B0%AE%E0%B1%8D%E0%B0%AE%E0%B0%BF%E0%B0%95%E0%B1%8D%E0%B0%95%E0%B1%81%E0%B0%B2%E0%B1%81-%E0%B0%9A%E0%B0%BE%E0%B0%B2%E0%B1%81-%E0%B0%97%E0%B0%BE%E0%B0%B0%E0%B0%A1%E0%B1%80%E0%B0%B2%E0%B1%81-%E0%B0%9A%E0%B1%87%E0%B0%AF%E0%B0%82%E0%B0%A1%E0%B0%BF-bcd0ec893cd7?source=rss-d8d5e57361fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bcd0ec893cd7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[telugu]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pawan-kalyan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mahesh-babu]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trivikram]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ananda Sangeetam]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 12 Aug 2019 02:15:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-12T02:31:44.323Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>My brother and I went to a strict boarding school. We were in an isolated village far from any signs of civilization; without easy access to television or movies or magazines (except educational ones double filtered through the library). So, it was very difficult for us to watch movies, let alone Telugu movies. Some older students at times sneaked out in the evening to a nearby town to watch a movie. Obviously, this was a great risk because getting caught meant expulsion and a bad conduct certificate. So, they would sneak out only if the movie is either featuring a so-called star or a star director or both. Then, it all changed in 2001.</p><p>I found my friends and my seniors sneaking out many times for a mere dialogue writer; neither a star nor a star director. I was in 11th class. I remember my brother talking to me after he had sneaked out and returned from watching “<em>Nuvvu Naaku Nachchav</em>” in 2001. He told me that he <em>must </em>sneak out another time to watch the movie again. <em>It was not that he wanted to watch another time. He had to</em>! Because he missed half the movie while he was busy laughing. A scene would crack him up so much that he missed the subsequent 2–3 scenes. That was the magic Trivikram created. <em>He stretched time to make a 2:30 hr movie into a 5 hr one (in a good way)</em>. The audience did not come a second time because they wanted to. They had no choice! They had to! The comedy was situational and clean. He inspired even an inherently religious, pseudo-moral, and parochial Telugu society to root for the girl in NNN despite her betrothal in the very first scene. <em>His witty lines and rhyming satires are merely an accident</em>. His philosophy and deep thought should be noted in many instances. For example, Venkatesh’s character in NNN appears to be a loser. But, he is indeed a yogi. His entire character is consistent throughout. Trivikram summarizes it in one dialogue, “<em>aayana nenu edo aavalani tapatraya padutunnadu, nenu aayana emayipodatdo ani feel avuntunnanu</em>”. In “Nuvve Nuvve”, Trivikram impresses yet again; now as director. Beyond his witty dialogues, here is a thing to note. Prakash Raj’s character gifts his daughter (played by Shriya Saran) an orange-tinge (Note: I am color blind) car in the beginning for her birthday. This same car is used throughout the movie very subtly. It is the same car that Tarun’s character bumps into. Indeed, there is a very funny scene where Tarun asks a shopping Shirya for money to bring her an ice cream as a romantic treat. Then, he goes elsewhere with the money. But, in that scene, although the director does not show you Shirya driving to the store, the same orange car is parked on the side. This is done throughout the movie. These are subtle details. But, they show a director’s dedication.</p><p>Trivikram’s treatment of criminals is amusing. These is a tiny flash of a scene in “<em>Jalsa</em>”. Watch from 54:06 to 54: 30. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Dae29huYSM">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Dae29huYSM</a></p><p>Did you see the sniper sent to shoot Pawan Kalyan? Now, see the portrayal of the sniper in that tiny flash of a scene by Trivikram. The sniper is religious. He prays. He has a picture of Hanuman in his pocket, which he places on the rifle. Isn’t that superb? Just like what he said of Sirivennela, Trivikram uses surrealism in some scenes. In “<em>Jalsa</em>”, at the end of the journey of Prakash Raj and Pawan Kalyan through the forest, SSMB’s voiceover tells us “<em>oka naxal oka police ga modalina veellu, iddaru manushulu ga migilaru</em>”. But, he immediately changes the direction of the movie and all the seriousness with a joke. Of course, same with the case of “<em>Athadu</em>”, where Prakash Raj advises his team to bribe banks. It’s an unexpected despicable reality that hits you in the guts so hard that you laugh. You wonder what you are laughing at: a corrupted society, corrupted government employees, or the way we embraced corruption? The fact that a major movie character is making use of corruption? Or the relief that you would have probably done the same? Trivikram doesn’t just make you laugh. He makes you think without you knowing it. He shows you that there is a great gaping hole between good and bad. That “<em>not good</em>” is not necessarily “<em>bad</em>”. For the first time, he showed the difference between lying and cheating so elegantly in one simple sentence: “<em>nijam cheppakapovadm abaddam kaani abaddam nijam cheyyalanukovadam mosam</em>”. This is poetry.</p><p>More than anything, this is a distress signal and a <em>SOS letter to a dying Trivikram (have you watched that thing called Agnathavaasi?)</em>. Even with his movies such as “<em>A Aa</em>” and “<em>Aravinda Sametha</em>”, Trivikram is losing himself in being a commercial director and limiting himself to shooting movies with stars. He is being something he should not be. Of course, at the end of the day, it is his personal choice. But, a person like him should not be doing this. We have enough people who can make movies like the ones he is making. At least I do not want fancy action thrillers or commercial routine family entertainers from Trivikram. I want good cinema from Trivikram. I want good story telling. I want him to go back to building characters, etching them in detail with their shades of gray, and not be lost in story or dialogues. We had a K Vishwanth who took Jandhayala’s help for dialogues. For once, the Telugu film industry has a director as capable as K Vishwanth and a script writer as powerful as Jandhyala in the same man. In Plato, the world had a philosopher and a poet in one body. In Trivikram, the Telugu film world has seen glimpses of a director and an exceptional writer in one. True to his name, much like Vaamana, he should conquer the three worlds: screenplay, dialogues, and direction).</p><p>Dear Trivikram- Please don’t be lost in mediocrity. Don’t be fooled by adulations of your average fans. You are being mediocre with your movies. You are not letting yourself materialize into wonderful films that could uplift an entire generation. In your interview with Mr. Hemanth, you mention that you read “Kalaateeta Vyaktulu”. What is stopping you from making it a movie? Do you think a 2020 society is not yet ready for a 1960 novel? <em>To play safe, you do not need to play foolish</em>. You are not being what you can be. We have not yet seen your greatest trick! <em>You are busy pulling rabbits from the hat because you see the kids clapping. Stop being a magician, Trivikram. The time is running out. Be the wizard you can be!</em></p><p>గిమ్మిక్కులు చాలు, గారడీలు చేయి</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bcd0ec893cd7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[God, devil, and Godel]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@anand.lost/god-devil-and-godel-80d3ee45841c?source=rss-d8d5e57361fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/80d3ee45841c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mathematics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metaphysics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ananda Sangeetam]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 02 Aug 2019 13:02:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-05T03:21:49.107Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>God, devil, and Gödel</h3><p>The problem is the blind faith many are placing in the Cartesian thought. Descartes famously said “I think. Therefore, I am”. <em>What is wrong with this?</em> It is only in the act of thinking about something “outside” the self that one can see one is a thinking self. One must exist before one can think. Existence is primary. “<strong><em>I am. Therefore, I think</em></strong>”. You cannot experience a thing without it existing. Something must exist for you to experience it. Our knowledge in the modern sense consists of “four Es”: Existence, Experience, Experiment and Expression. A thing must first exist. You can experience things that exist. From this experience, you use your intelligence to abstract the essence. You do controlled experiments to derive more general truths about your experience. Lastly, these general laws are expressed in mathematical equations or schematics (e.g., double helical structure of DNA; Biology is more empirioschematic in that it uses many schemes to categorize and express universal behaviors).</p><p>In logicalism, <em>experiment</em> and <em>expression</em> are given more importance than <em>experience</em>. This view reduces the essence of all physical phenomena to symbols and equations. Thus, it enthrones mathematics as the queen of the sciences and ignores philosophy, which unfortunately leads to many fundamental issues. It indeed led to a great danger threatening our science itself. It generated many “black box operators” that think they know but do not know in reality. For example, a student ranked in the top 1% of IIT-JEE will hardly be able to provide you any ontological meaning of things. I would be surprised if any of them or their teachers (future and past) can properly define what a measurement is and how it converts a quality into a quantity. To not know that one does not know is pure ignorance. To know that one does not know is metacognition. To think that one knows when one does not indeed know truly is unintelligence. Today’s unintelligence and blind scienceism have led to a “I think; Therefore, I am” culture. <em>If you truly understand mathematics, you would be able to see the problem with this statement and its implications.</em></p><p>Here, I will introduce to a gem: Godel’s theorem to show you what is wrong with philosophical idealism.</p><p>David Hilbert, one of the greatest mathematicians ever, was a proponent of metamathematics or metalogic. Hilbert wanted to prove mathematics as the ultimate and complete answer through the axiomatisation of mathematics. An axiomatic system essentially consists of some accepted presumptions (i.e., axioms or postulates) and theorems that are deduced from those axioms. The Greek word axioma means that which is self-evident. An example is Euclidean geometry you may have studied in school. This geometry is based on certain axioms that may be self-evident but are not necessarily provable rigorously. For example, any two points can be connected by a straight line. You know its true but its not provable (we will talk about proof and truth in a minute). You should recall that many geometric figures are “beings of reason”. A perfect circle does not exist in reality. Although the idea of a circle is abstracted from approximate circles in reality, a perfect circle exists only in our mind. Similarly sqrt(-1) or <em>i</em> exists only in our mind. Thus, they are “beings of reason”.</p><p>A theorem in any axiomatic system is derived rigorously from the axioms by purely depending on the principles of logic. <strong><em>An axiomatic system does not necessarily depend on any empirical data but on logic alone</em></strong>. All theorems ultimately reference back to the axioms. So, if you wish to prove an axiom using theorems within an axiomatic system, you end up self-referencing. Let us think of a simple example. Let us say we have a system that contains all possible statements. We make a postulate that “any statement in this is either true or false but not both at the same time in the same way”. This is our beginning axiom. Now, if you have a statement that refers to itself such as “this statement is false”, you would begin to see a problem with the axiomatic system. If the statement “this statement is false” is true, it is false. If it is false, it is true. It may be a little confusing. But, think about it. Our entire geometry and arithmetic are axiomatic systems.</p><p>There are two important characteristics of an axiomatic system, viz., <em>consistency</em> and <em>completeness</em>.</p><p>An axiomatic system is said to be <em>consistent</em> if it contains no formula or statement such that both the formula and its negation are provable as theorems within the system. The importance of consistency lies in the fact that in an inconsistent system, a theorem and its negation can both be proved. When this happens, the system can accommodate contradictions. <em>That makes the system unreliable for any proof</em>.</p><p>The other important feature of an axiomatic system is completeness. A system is complete if all the desired formulas or statements can be proved within the system. Any <em>inconsistent</em> system is <em>complete </em>because you can prove any theorem in an inconsistent system. Thus, <em>the completeness of a system is useful only if the system is consistent</em>.</p><p>Now, enter Kurt Gödel. In 1931, he published a paper entitled “On Formally Undecidable Propositions of Principia Mathematica and Related Systems”, often dubbed as Gödel’s incompleteness theorem. Gödel established that any axiomatic system contains at least one formula which is necessarily true but is neither provable nor disprovable within the system. In other words, there is no axiomatic system (at least as powerful as arithmetic) that is necessarily both complete and consistent.</p><p><em>At this juncture, it is important to establish a clear distinction between the notions of truth and proof. Proof is rigorous, logical, axiomatic, and constructed within a system. However, truth lies outside of the system</em>. For example, I could have an axiomatic system in which “Sun is green” can be proved. But, the veracity or truthfulness of this statement cannot be verified unless you look to “reality” that is outside the axiomatic system. Thus, the consistency of a system cannot be proved within the system. Something is provable does not necessarily mean it is true. <em>To know what is true, one must look outside the system</em>.</p><p>Now, let us use Godel’s theorem on Descartes. The consistency theory, which holds that, the consistency of an axiomatic system cannot be proven within that system, will enable us to decide upon the statement “I think; Therefore, I am”. This hypothesis asks us to question the very nature of our existence and reality. It implies that you do not exist if you cannot think. According to Gödel, there is no way to establish the consistency of a system called “me”. If I am inconsistent, how can I rely on the proof (I think; Therfore, I am) I derive from it? Hence, <em>the truth about the reality cannot be proved from within</em>. Based on Descartes statement, it is incorrect to conclude that one can only know what is in one’s mind and therefore one cannot know if there is anything outside the mind. Similarly, based on Godel’s theorem, it is incorrect to deduce that our knowledge is simply ideas “without” any foundations. Our ideas come from outside reality similar to how one cannot think about oneself without thinking about what is outside.</p><p><em>Science is rooted in reality</em>. It is the study of reality. Although it is often expressed in mathematical form, science (e.g., physics) relies on both “truth” and “proof”. For example, I cannot describe the behavior of an atom like how I describe the motion of a cricket ball. The reality of how things behave drives science. However, the success of mathematics and empiriological science have somehow led to wrong conclusions that we can never truly know. Unless we place emphasis on understanding the metaphysical and philosophical aspects of science, we will fail.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=80d3ee45841c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Are we really teaching science? Do we really know science?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@anand.lost/are-we-really-teaching-science-do-we-really-know-science-664a41549970?source=rss-d8d5e57361fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/664a41549970</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[teaching]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ananda Sangeetam]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 28 Jul 2019 06:55:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-28T06:55:31.177Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Do we really know science?</h3><p>This is definitely an age of science and technology. We made major scientific breakthroughs that revolutionized our lives in many ways. For instance, you have the world at your fingertips through mobile phones and the internet. Your mobile phone today is thousand times faster than the computers on Apollo 11 that took man to the moon. This rapid technological progress facilitated easy access to information. More than that, it convinced people of the power of science. Many people began to look to science because science seemed more rational than religion. Indeed, it may not be a hyperbole to say that <em>science has now emerged as the new spokesman</em>. This is where the problem lies. Today’s average “science literates” or “science supporters” (including science graduates with MS and PhDs) are placing their faith in science unconsciously. <em>These science supporters think they know. But, they do not. They forget the roots of science: philosophy</em>. This problem is further exacerbated by our way of teaching science. Our science textbooks, science educators, and students (and their parents) are lost in algorithmic problem solving or cramming equations for acing tests. The new crop of educational resources use technology very well. Yet, these new tools fail miserably to teach science in its right way. Now, you may think I am exaggerating the problem. I will provide an example to make my case.</p><p>A seemingly simple question: <em>what is mass? </em>You are most probably taught to think mass to be the “amount of stuff” in something. It may not even be surprising if you indeed feel that this is the right answer and the right way to think about it. <em>Is it</em>? The answer is no. How do you know mass? We quantify it by measuring it. But, is mass a quantity? Is that it? Is it not a property of a thing or a substance? You measure mass of something by comparing it to a standard one-kilogram iridium cylinder sitting in a museum in France. <em>Measurement is ultimately a relation</em>. I am weighing one object in terms of another object. If I am 90 kg, I am 90 times as heavy as the iridium cylinder. The measurement of mass (or the “amount of stuff”) essentially compares two objects. But, it really does not answer what mass is. <em>What do we care? We are only interested in equational physics. In today’s equational and mathematically rich and ontologically poor science teaching, mass (and many other things) is just a number that you plug into the equation to obtain the answer</em>.</p><p>Let us take the example of mass a little further to see how mass is not really the “amount of stuff”. Think of a water molecule (chemical formula: H2O). A water molecule is polar meaning the charge is not evenly distributed over all the atoms. The oxygen atom has more negative charge cloud near it compared to the two hydrogens. Now, for finding the mass of a water molecule, you would simply add up the masses of the “stuff” that makes it: two hydrogens and one oxygen. But, if I place this same water molecule in an electric field. The polar water molecule will interact with the electric field and thereby change its energy (more precisely, its potential energy). This change is energy could either be an increase or a decrease. Have you heard of Einstein’s energy-mass equivalence? We changed the energy of a water molecule by placing it in an electric field. <em>Therefore, we changed its mass. But, we have not really changed the “stuff” that makes up a water molecule</em>. Even in the electric field, a water molecule has two hydrogens and one oxygen. Yet, its mass is somehow slightly different because its interaction with electric field is changing its energy and thereby mass. Then, <em>what is mass</em>?</p><p>I will not answer it here. Nevertheless, I will point out the underlying reason for this <em>misinterpreted science that has become worse than religious faith</em>. Before we do that, you should note that a religious person at least has conscious faith. Today’s so-called science educators, graduates, and literates are simply placing unconscious faith imagining that they understand science and the scientific method. In thinking that the answers of science can always be accepted without deeper philosophical and ontological insight, they are losing their rationality. They are worse than believer. <em>The reason is over-simplification</em>. We are suckers for the simplest possible explanation. We want to simplify things and make them even simpler than the simplest. In trying to woo students and educators, textbooks are using highly simplified explanations without piquing the student’s interest to think deeper. New crop of educational tools (e.g., Byjus) are legitimizing this poor understanding of science. Online science communicators are killing science by gross oversimplification. You are a victim of this. Yet, you do not know you are. What is unfortunate is that these science believers also reject some great philosophical works presented in things such as the Vedas (or the writings of Thomas Aquinas etc) without properly understanding them either. Even more unfortunate thing is some (e.g, the ISRO chief and many others) think they know science and that they must accept religion because science cannot prove everything. The fundamental problem in today’s society is therefore <em>satisfaction with results rather than understanding</em>. If you don’t understand what something really is, how can you ever know it?</p><p>Many deem modern science to be the following. One hypothesizes something followed by examining this hypothesis through experiment. Subsequently, the results of the experiment either validate or invalidate the said hypothesis. <em>What is modern about this? </em>This is what Socrates did. Thomas Aquinas did. This is what Uddalaka taught Svetaketu. You are mistaken if you think modern science to be simply an experiment driven validation of a hypothesis. Modern science is indeed expressing the generally observed behavior in a mathematical form. This is what Jacques Maritain calls the “empiriological” method. <em>Modern science expresses physical observations in a mathematical way.</em> For example, Newton’s law of universal gravity exemplifies this. The observations of how massive bodies attract each other, something that you can physically observe or experience, is reflected or expressed in a mathematical form. It is <em>pariksha ganita jnana</em>: the empirical expressed in the mathematical. This “<em>pariksha ganita jnana</em>” or empiriological approach ends in mathematical expression without really going into the ontological.</p><p>As Jacques Maritain explains in his book “Degrees of Knowledge”, there are three levels of abstraction: 1) physical, 2) mathematical, and 3) metaphysical. Physical abstraction means that you observe things by ignoring all but the necessary attributes. For example, for understanding how an object falls under gravity, you could either use a 1 kg red ball or a 1 kg green ball. The color would not influence how it falls. You know this because you have assimilated or abstracted (at a physical level) that somehow this “mass” of the ball is what is important and not its color. Another excellent example of this physical abstraction is in the <em>Chandogya Upanishad</em>. You can look at a golden statue, a golden necklace, a golden crown etc. The shape of the object may be different. But, that different shape does not change what gold is. The gold or the essence (often referred to as the Bramhan in the Vedas; very often confused with Bramha: a mythological figure symbolizing a creator) that makes these different objects is still the same. <em>Science has to necessarily abstract this essence (or the Bramhan) first</em>. If you cannot abstract the idea of mass, you cannot proceed to express it in mathematical terms. Our science is becoming increasingly more abstract (e.g., quantum mechanics). However, the irony is that despite more abstraction one does in today’s science, the stronger is the propensity to reject the very notion of abstraction.</p><p>Now, to express this physical abstraction, you rely on mathematics. You express the essence or the Bramhan, physically abstracted from sensorial observations (e.g., you hold a ball and feel its mass or touch something and feel its temperature), as a quantity. The essential qualities are expressed as quantities here. Mathematica abstracts “beings of reason” from real objects. A “being of reason” exists only in your mind and not in reality (e.g., square root of -1 or infinity or a perfect circle). For example, you abstract the idea of a perfect circle from many approximately circular objects you may have seen in reality. A perfect circle does not exist in reality. It is a being of reason. There is no real thing that is perfectly circular. Having idealized and abstracted the idea of a perfect circle (Geometry), you would now be able to express it mathematically using symbols (Arithmetic; <em>x</em>²+<em>y</em>²=<em>r</em>²). Thus, you bridge two branches of mathematica viz., <em>Geometry</em> and <em>Arithmetic</em> with <em>Analysis</em>.</p><p>The hallmark of modern science is the excellent synergy between physical and mathematical abstractions. For example, Einstein’s theory of relativity is about real physical objects. Yet, it is entirely expressed using equations and mathematical symbols. As I said earlier, it is incorrect to think of modern science as hypothesis-experiment-verify. Modern science is the expression of the physical (abstraction) using the mathematical (abstraction).</p><p>While the mathematical forms describe the physical picture, they do not provide any ontological insights. The final and third level of abstraction, i.e., the metaphysical (<em>bramhavid</em>). Here, you understand what truly the object you are studying is. Having abstracted the essence or the <em>Bramhan</em>, you dwell upon it in order to see a thing for what it is. This is what Chandogya Upanishad calls <em>Tatvamasi</em>. To simplify it, you can think of metaphysical abstraction this way: Having abstracted properties of an apple (size, weight, color etc) and having mathematically quantized them, you begin to understand the “appleness of an apple” in the metaphysical abstraction. Here, you come to realize: Everything that is, is being (<em>Tatvamasi</em>).</p><p>There is a great difference between the empiriological (physical and mathematical) and the philosophical (metaphysical). <em>The former seeks to quantify and measure while the latter aims to unravel causes and principles. The former is experiment and latter is experience.</em></p><p>Without elevating science to clearly show these levels of abstraction and without instigating the student to understand the metaphysical nature of things, our sad state of affairs will continue. It is necessary for us to adapt this approach to truly teach science and inspire the next generation to innovate and progress. I urge you to think deeper. This is not a problem you simply sweep under the rug. Our algorithmic problem solving will only take us so far. It is easy to go to even Mars without really understanding the ontological. But, is that what we need? Our very fabric of the society has begun to fall apart because of the lack of metaphysical understanding. Philosophy is not about telling you who you should be or what things should be. It is an integral part of science that tells you what things are. To think that you do not need philosophy is also a philosophy. Please think deeper. Please introspect to see if you are really being rational. Be Socratic. Learn, Teach, Repeat!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=664a41549970" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is wrong with today’s science education and understanding?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@anand.lost/what-is-wrong-with-todays-science-education-and-understanding-4f50ced77664?source=rss-d8d5e57361fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4f50ced77664</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ananda Sangeetam]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Jun 2019 19:42:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-30T00:13:52.958Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>How do we understand space? This may seem like a very abstract and even more a nerdy question to you. But, bear with me here. I am using this question to point out something larger at stake, i.e., what is wrong with our present understanding of science, science education, and how it impacts the society?</p><p>I recently posed the above question on twitter to survey randomly selected people. I must note that this is not the most statistically sound survey. Nevertheless, it could be used to make a point because the results are glaringly clear.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VoBqlt_nQR6JC8Z4XHyYcQ.png" /></figure><p>The above survey shows that there is something fundamentally wrong about the way space is being understood. Unfortunately, 50% in the survey who answered space to be emptiness and nothingness are so confused. They have simply unconscious faith in science and do not understand it properly. They do not even know that they do not know properly. More unfortunately, many of these are probably “science literate” or believe themselves to be “science literate”. I have even personally asked many PhDs (including physicists) this question. Their answer is the same: nothingness and emptiness. Firstly, how can nothingness and emptiness be the same? Secondly, if space is nothing, how can it bend? Similar confusion also exists on electric/magnetic fields, light, electron running around in an atom, or even angles in a triangle.</p><p>The mathematical abstract idea of Euclidean space is often confused with physical space. Hence, it is thought of as emptiness or nothingness. In reality, it is not! Indeed, how can nothingness exist? Nothingness by definition is non-existent. I will dwell on what space means and other common scientific misunderstandings later in the discussion below. Here, I have a bigger point to make. Our present education system teaches science in a very unscientific, unphysical, not realistic, and simply wrong way. It is a mammoth assertion to make. But, you can glean this by observing the educational institutions today. Our science education is to be blamed for our poor understanding of science. Science is not being taught or learned like it should be. It has become the new religion or a Faith. Science is being unconsciously accepted today without proper and deep thought, i.e., philosophy. We believe ourselves to be scientific but many fundamental concepts are being oversimplified by ignoring physical reality. In today’s schools and colleges, physical sciences have been robbed of their elegance and are being reduced to mere mathematical manipulations. This problem is even more pronounced in India. We are lost in practicing algorithmic problem solving skills and honing test taking abilities rather than truly teaching/learning science. How can the students be expected to truly learn when teachers themselves are ignorant, ill-trained, and misinterpret? Major problems with our present science culture are to grossly simplify things, misinterpret famous quotes, and unnecessarily and ignorantly drag spirituality into science. Albert Einstein warned us against all this. So did Aristotle.</p><p>Philosophy is the beginning of science. One cannot be truly scientific without being philosophical. Science explains the physical world as it is. It does not simplify it. But, today’s science education and literature is oversimplifying science and effectively teaching “an unrealistic picture” of reality. This often creates conflicts in students and makes them vulnerable to accepting pseudo-scientific theories and even worse spirituality of the misleading kind. Below, I express some simple examples, concerns, and suggestions that I hope will guide science educators, students, and parents.</p><p><strong>Example 1: Geometry and Arithmetic</strong></p><p>We are taught Euclidean geometry like it is the only thing that exists. Stuck in our own Euclidean geometry ideas, we in turn teach our kids that the angles in a triangle always sum up to 180 degrees as if it is a universal truth. We ignore the fact that the Earth itself is spherical and non-Euclidean (unfortunate because it is after all “Geo”metry). This mistake in the geometry class seeps into the student’s physics understanding, as I will discuss later. The student begins to equate the idea of an abstract mathematical space with physical space. This is fundamentally incorrect.</p><p>We teach arithmetic and geometry based on axioms. The students are often made to learn these by rote, which is fine. But, I think today’s students are well advanced (even in rural areas) due to technology that we should at least introduce Gödel’s theorem in secondary/higher secondary school.</p><p>Our technology has grown rapidly. Our teaching methods have changed. But, our materials are still almost the same. We are still teaching kids things at the same old pace without properly introducing newer and more complete concepts. Introducing things such as the Gödel’s theorem earlier will be important to show how axiomatic systems are incomplete or inconsistent due to self-reference. For instance, I cannot determine the veracity of the statement “This statement is false”. Think about it (if it is true, it is false!). One needs something outside the axiomatic system to prove the validity of that system. The axiomatic system cannot prove itself due to self-reference issues as in the example. (I have committed the mistake of oversimplification here to make my point)</p><p>Alongside, students should also be given brief philosophical outlook and implications associated with Gödel’s theorem, which I will touch upon later. This should become an intrinsic part of the new high-school education.</p><p><strong>Example 2: What is space? No, not the final frontier!</strong></p><p>Aristotle called things that can exist by themselves as substances and things that exist as a part of substances as properties. For example, a red apple can exist by itself. But, the color “red” cannot exist by itself. You cannot think of red as such. You can only think of red something. He further categorized these properties into: quantity, quality, relation, action, reception, position, orientation, environment, and time.</p><p>Now, anything that can change is a physical thing. Space is a physical substance. It exists by itself. Objects do not occupy space, they create it. Space has the primary property of “quantity” that is extension. Space is extended. It is also changeable. It can bend. It can host fields. It is simply non-massive unlike a tennis ball or cricket bat. If you have a massive body, it bends or changes space around it (i.e., gravity). To understand this “bending”, it is important to note that space is not bending into something else. The space itself is intrinsically bent. Like how the surface of Earth is the surface of a sphere. Space is not Euclidean. This is where introducing non-Euclidean geometry early in school will play an important role. Firstly, the introduction of non-Euclidean geometry will help not confuse space with Euclidean space. Next, it will easily impress upon the student that non-Euclidean space itself is could be bent. Gravity from a massive body, electric or magnetic fields exist in space by bending it. Fields are thus properties of space. Light, which is nothing but electromagnetic fields, is simply a property of space! Space is not nothing or emptiness. It is a physical thing. A physical thing means a changeable thing and not necessarily a massive thing (as in an object having mass and not necessarily a very heavy object). This philosophical and physical understanding is critical when we teach science at the secondary school level. I have seen school teachers and even many text books define electric field as force per unit charge. This is a measurement not definition. They define it as if an electric field for a given charge would not exist if you could not measure it with a unit charge. Electric field is a perturbation in space (and thus a property of space) caused by any charged massive body, which decreases with increasing distance as <em>kq/r2</em>. This is the definition.</p><p><strong>Example 3: Is the electron really going around the nucleus in an atom like the earth goes round the sun or is it really spinning?</strong></p><p>We are so seduced by our classical notions of mechanics that we try to simplify quantum mechanics to teach students that the electron is going around the nucleus in a circle. While such an accelerating charge is supposed to radiate energy and ultimately spiral into the nucleus, we simply escape this electrodynamic inevitability by stating that the electron is somehow “miraculously” running around in a special orbit. This is taken on faith like I said before. The actual statistical nature of the electron that “appears” like the classical quantity angular momentum is not discussed at all. Unlike classical mechanics, quantum mechanics is statistical. One cannot perform measurements on a single object but only know ensemble averages. These are not difficult concepts to teach or imbibe. We do not need to simplify it and spoon-feed students, test them on this oversimplified knowledge, and laud them for it. We instead need to set things straight and teach them the right way. Quantum mechanics is often taught as if it violates the principle of non-contradiction (also known as Tatvamasi; one thing cannot be and be at the same place, same time, in the same way). For example, the wave-particle duality is taught in a way to imply that a thing like electron is both a particle and a wave at the same time. However, the wave nature arises from probability or statistical measurements on multiple particles and not a single particle. Thus, quantum mechanics does not violate the principle of non-contradiction as it involves statistical measurements of identical objects. You are not measuring one object.</p><p>Similarly, electron is not spinning either. An intrinsic property of electron, which acts like angular momentum, is described as spin. But, again this is also statistical. Unless the statistical nature of quantum mechanics is emphasized, misinterpreted answers to questions such as “Is light a particle or wave or both?” will continue to plague science education. Furthermore, this misinterpreted science is extrapolated to make scientifically invalid conclusions like we create reality or even make philosophical idealists that think world exists in our mind like the movie Matrix (You should note that even in the movie Matrix, there is a reality: one where people are actually incubated or one where Zion exists). This is where the introduction of Gödel’s theorem in secondary/higher secondary school helps. Unlike certain (not all) self-referencing mathematical axioms, quantum or classical mechanics rely on the physical reality that exists outside by itself. <em>The conformity of our mind to such a physical reality is the scientific truth</em>.</p><p>Philosophy is completely shunned from today’s science education. Foundational physical principles (such as the ones laid down by Aristotle or Chandogya Upanishad/other similar texts) are not even taught to a student. Science textbooks have become mere reiteration of equations and facts without piquing the interest of the young mind. The Vedas have clearly focused on such foundational principles and philosophy, which we ignore and immerse ourselves instead in pseudo-science and pseudo-spirituality of the Sadhguru-kind. <em>We do the mistake of attributing every discovery to our vedic knowledge and thereby mock ourselves. </em>(Note: I am not a Hindu sympathizer. I know only Vedas a little. I am sure similar things exist in other cultures. I know even less about them and I am not an expert. So, I will not comment. But, I am not trying to elevate theVedas here.)</p><p>What I have proposed is not radically different. But, simply the right way to teach science. We must introduce philosophy early in school to nurture the right scientific temper in the next generation. Without such right scientific temper, you can see the damage in terms of wars, racism, climate change etc. Without such scientific temper, I see even educated men and women succumb to believing in people such as Sadhguru (only a generic “mystic” example) who explains the Higgs Boson or blackhole as nothingness. Let us not be unphysical. Let us not trust science like it is a religion. The beauty of science is that you can correct it no matter who you are: a poor Faraday, a rich Maxwell, a depressed Boltzmann, a funny Einstein, a religious Raman, or an agnostic Feynman. Science is the highest form of democracy. Let us learn it right. Let us teach right. Let us do it together.</p><p><strong>ॐ सह नाववतु ।<br>सह नौ भुनक्तु ।<br>सह वीर्यं करवावहै ।<br>तेजस्वि नावधीतमस्तु मा विद्विषावहै ।</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4f50ced77664" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What did Vedas actually say about physica?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@anand.lost/what-did-vedas-actually-say-about-physica-6f1dddfa5360?source=rss-d8d5e57361fa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6f1dddfa5360</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[upanishad]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vedas]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ananda Sangeetam]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 15 Jun 2019 12:32:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-15T12:32:20.438Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It only takes a chimp (no disrespect) with opposable thumbs to tweet, type, and blog. So, it is not surprising that there is too much trash on the internet. Especially, in an <em>emocracy </em>(no, I did not miss the D!) like India this misinformation can lead to erroneous conclusions that adversely impact psychological, sociological, and political narratives.</p><p>I write this article in true scientific spirit: all human beings, despite their differences, thought the same thing and established the same basic principles. It does not matter who is first? Because this is not a race. What is more important is we understand them. Yes, somethings in the Vedas are actually great. But, not for the reasons that people usually think. Vedas (I also mean vedas and some upanishads when I say Vedas) are actually very radical left. It is the people that make it the right wing. Now, let us get to the basics. I would like to dwell upon the great <em>Chandogya</em> upanishad and compare it with the foundations laid by Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle. Once again, the intention is not to determine who wins the race but to display how we think the same humanly. For those who want to tout that the Vedas are better, please think twice before you do. Vedas present great philosophy. Laying claim to every scientific discovery as prior Vedic knowledge is foolish and indeed derogatory.</p><p>First, let us clear somethings. We use too many words too informally. So, here, I will have to stress on the importance of using a word in its right meaning to ensure we do not confuse things.</p><p>We use the word “form” to indicate many things. But, the word “form” (in the yore) was a much broader concept. Form, philosophically, is generally the way a material being exists. This is how Aristotle thought. For example, a green mango: the mango, its shape, its color, its temperature…all are a part of the mango. So, the main form of the mango is its material form by which it exists. This is what Aristotle (presumably, even Socrates) called the substantial form. He also called the other properties (color, hardness, volume, temperature) the accidental forms. He says that the “mangoness” of mango is its true substantial form. We may see just one particular picture of one mango once in life. Yet, recognize another mango at another point of time because there is some “mangoness” to the mango, which we intellectually digested upon seeing the picture of the mango. So, Artistole calls this substantial form.</p><p>Now, turn to Chandogya Upanishad:</p><p>Uddalaka (some guy you won’t meet ever) in V 1, Ch 6 says this:</p><p><em>yathā somyaikena lohamaṇinā sarvaṃ lohamayaṃ vijñātaṃ syādvācārambhaṇaṃ vikāro nāmadheyaṃ lohamityeva satyam || 6.1.5 ||</em></p><p><em>By knowing a single lump of gold you know all objects made of gold. All changes are mere words, in name only. But gold is the reality.</em></p><p>In this entire chapter, Uddalaka talks about “essence” or the “substantial form” constantly. This essence is really important. He teaches Svetaketu that “Existence precedes essence.”</p><p>This is the same profound statement that the Greek philosophized.</p><p>In the same, chapter there is a discussion on understanding the pure essence.</p><p>Essence means two things: <em>the being</em> or <em>to be </em>(esse and ens in latin). Uddalaka teaches the same thing. When the student expresses a doubt on seeing the pure essence then Uddalaka gives an example.</p><p>Pure essence is like the sun. You cannot see it its full form. Chandogya says the following, which means light (essence) that is in the sun or anywhere or any intelligible being is the same. This is great philosophy congruent with the Greek.</p><p>अथ यदतः परो दिवो ज्योतिर्दीप्यते विश्वतः पृष्ठेषु सर्वतः पृष्ठेष्वनुत्तमेषूत्तमेषु लोकेष्विदं वाव तद्यदिदमस्मिन्नन्तः पुरुषो ज्योतिस्तस्यैषा</p><p><em>More interesting stuff:</em></p><p>Nothing means non-existent. By definition, nothing cannot exist. Even then, you would hear your kids, teachers, colleagues, friends, physicists talk about nothingness. Nothingness is a being of reason. Something cannot come out of nothing. Because something happening without nothing is against the very principle of causality. Indeed, just like Aristotle’s foundational principles, Chandogya Upanishad state the following:</p><p><em>Tatvamasi</em></p><p>This is the principle of identity. Something is what it is. So basic. So profound. When this same principle is stated of principle of non-contradiction it would look even better:</p><p><em>Something can be and not be in the same place in the same way.</em></p><p>Another thing from Chandogya:</p><p>नेदममूलं भविष्यतीति ॥ ६.८.५ ॥</p><p><em>amūlam na bhaviṣyati iti</em></p><p>This means that something cannot change itself. Every effect has a cause. This is the profound principle of causality.</p><p>In summary, although many centuries and cultures apart, we human have the innate need and capacity (which is intelligence) to understand things. Any “thing” has some “thingness”(or its essence) and its properties attached to it. We continually try to understand that “thingness” and “properties”: call it <em>mass, charge, spin, strangeness, or, even charm</em>. It is up to you.</p><p>Vedas are great poetic philosophical texts. They laid good foundations for pursuing natural sciences. Some did pursue them. But, somewhere along the way we fell apart. All that we do now is hide behind these without properly understanding either the vedas or the science we claim they explain.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6f1dddfa5360" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>