<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Andrew Nusbaum on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Andrew Nusbaum on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@andrewnusbaum?source=rss-4449dce292d6------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 00:12:38 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@andrewnusbaum/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[1944- Herman and Katie- From Neighbors to Scapegoats]]></title>
            <link>https://andrewnusbaum.medium.com/1944-herman-and-katie-from-neighbors-to-scapegoats-67b173076295?source=rss-4449dce292d6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/67b173076295</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[genealogy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewish]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[family-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrew Nusbaum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Jul 2026 22:50:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-17T01:20:37.558Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Herman and Katie, 1944- From Neighbors to Scapegoats</strong></h3><p>When I was growing up, my parents thought our ancestry was boring. Everybody was Yiddish-speaking Jews from Poland or elsewhere in the former Pale of Settlement.</p><p>When someone on my mother‘s side wanted to feel exotic, they would mention our Hungarian branch. My mother’s office had a large group portrait of her father and his parents. In the back, towering above her family, stood my great-grandmother Katie. Though not physically tall, she had an imposing figure and apparently a personality to match. This all made much more sense after hearing about the life she and her family left behind.</p><p>Hungarian Jews were — and are — fiercely proud of their unique heritage, a blend of at least three Jewish communities who began settling there as early as the year 1000. There were the Ottoman Sephardim who clustered around Budapest, the German and Moravian <em>Oberlanders</em>, who moved into the northwest, and the Polish and Galician <em>Unterlanders</em>, who were concentrated in the northeast and low country. Katie’s family were Unterlanders who had trickled south via Slovakia, with documented roots going back at least 100 years.</p><p>Her grandfathers had both been born in Zemplen county, a pastoral slice of north-eastern Hungary with rolling green hills and fields whose diversity matched the empire’s, containing a mix of Hungarians, Slovaks, Ukrainians, Germans, and Jews. For decades, Zemplen had been the only place in Hungary that allowed Jews to own vineyards, and her father’s family worked as innkeepers and tenant farmers. In 1867 they, like the rest of Hungary’s approximately 500,000 Jews, received political emancipation and equal civil rights. All Jewish men were now allowed to own land, and any who could afford the poll tax could vote and run for office.</p><p>Zemplen was not only an ethnic and linguistic crossroads, but also a religious one. Beyond the multiplicity of churches, the area was also where the German-influenced scholarly Orthodox movement of Rabbi Moses Sofer met the ecstatic and mystical Hasidic movement that had begun in Ukraine. The two institutions, the wonder rabbis’ courts and the yeshivas, had clashed for decades, even as they lost ground to secularization and the modernist Neolog movement with its Hungarian sermons and church-influenced organs. Neolog Judaism was popular in the capital, but in the countryside, traditional Jewish life still dominated.</p><p>By the early 1880s, Katie’s family was living near the town of Tokaj, the capital of Hungary’s wine region- so famous that its “golden nectar” is mentioned in the national anthem. Tokaj had about 5,000 people, about a quarter of them Jewish and nearly all involved in wine production or trade. The family’s economic prospects had begun to improve. Compared to Jewish life in the Russian Empire, Hungary must have seemed like a dream.</p><p>Then Tiszaeszlar happened.</p><p>Hungary has two major rivers running through it, north to south. On the western end, near Budapest, is the Danube. On the eastern end was the Tisza. It began in the Carpathians, snaked 600 miles down through Hungary, passing directly through Tokaj, and eventually ending in Serbia.</p><p>There were over 50 villages named after the “blonde and wild” Tisza that ran through and connected them to the outside world. One of them, about 10 miles from Tokaj, was Tiszaeszlar. It had 2700 residents, a Catholic and Protestant church, and twenty-five Jewish families whose lives revolved around a small synagogue.</p><p>In spring of 1882, the Jews of Tiszaeszlar had recently lost their shochet, or butcher, who also served as the community’s teacher and cantor, or prayer leader. They had announced auditions would be held on Shabbat Hagadol, the Saturday before Passover. It was an important community occasion, and the synagogue was filled with excited worshippers from nearby villages. Some of the visitors were lodged at the home of the synagogue caretaker, József Scharf, who lived next-door with his wife and two sons. He was so poor that he had to ask neighbors to host his guests for meals.</p><p>That same day, April 1, about fifteen months before Katie was born, a fourteen-year-old Christian girl named Eszter Solymosi had gone missing near Tiszaeszlar. The proximity to Passover was not overlooked. The villagers began to whisper that the Jews had ritually murdered her for her blood.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/380/1*1xswpRnUG-Q7j-EnzSU27A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Drawing of Eszter Solymosi after her disappearance, 1882</figcaption></figure><p>The first documented Blood Libel was in England in 1144. After English Jews were expelled, the lie followed them to continental Europe, gaining particular prominence in Germany and Italy. At a time when most communities were ethnically and religiously homogenous, it was easy to manipulate people with both written and visual propaganda showing Jews as literal bloodsucking vampires and demons. Pesky details like Jewish law forbidding consuming any blood or putting anything in matzah besides water and flour, or even that the Catholic Church had officially rejected the theory as early as the 1240s, were lost on the mobs. The fact that prisoners under torture usually admitted to anything didn’t help.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/678/1*KIDnj3BIHb_YRSKUdYKukA.jpeg" /><figcaption>German painting depicting the murder of Simon of Trent in Italy, 1493</figcaption></figure><p>Blood Libels were often precursors, and pretexts, for violent antisemitic riots called pogroms, borrowed for a Russian word for “devastation.” Both had been rare in Hungary, but not unheard of. Jews had been expelled from Hungary during the Black Plague in the 1340s before being invited back. In 1760, just fifty miles from Tiszaeszlar, a child had disappeared and Jews had been accused of a Blood Libel. The case was eventually resolved when the supposed victim appeared, unharmed. In 1831, during a cholera epidemic, the Jews had been accused of poisoning wells and receiving money for every person infected or killed. In some villages, Jews were even burned alive by their neighbors.</p><p>Shortly after her disappearance Eszter’s mother had gone to two judges and demanded they search for her daughter, starting with the synagogue. Over the next month as her request went through the legal bureaucracy and inconclusive initial investigations, rumors spread in the village and the newspapers. Some were even repeated by Christian village women in front of four-year-old Samu Scharf, who then began parroting them himself.</p><p>The court had appointed a young ambitious legal clerk named József Bary as Investigating Magistrate. To say Bary was hardly impartial would be an extreme understatement. He later described the Jews of Tiszaeszlar as “living in moral and bodily filth, Yiddish-speaking and evil-looking religious fanatics who harbor a burning hatred of Christians.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*x6MMbx7smjxYTlrkf8KUnA.jpeg" /><figcaption>József Bary, abt 1883</figcaption></figure><p>Five weeks after Eszter disappeared, Bary arrived in town and began his investigation. He searched the synagogue, dug up its courtyard, and arrested the entire Scharf family. Bary began by questioning impressionable young Samu but quickly switched his focus to his thirteen-year-old brother Moritz. For the first two days of interrogation, Moritz stuck fast to his testimony; he had no idea what had happened to Eszter.</p><p>On the third day, Moritz was taken to the home of a policeman with a reputation for breaking suspects. After being starved and beaten, he eventually “confessed” that he had watched through a keyhole as his father lured Eszter into the synagogue for several kosher butchers to slaughter, draining her blood and then redressing the body.</p><p>Fifteen Jewish men were arrested. Moritz was taken into “protective custody” by Bary’s lieutenant and kept isolated from his family for the next year. Despite weeks of searching, no trace of the girl could be found.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*HHiz9wryYlq6I32rFsSmSA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Moritz Scharf, 1883</figcaption></figure><p>Before the boy had even made his confession, a Budapest newspaper published a letter from one of Tiszeszlar’s priests. He reviewed seven previous Hungarian Blood Libels and publicly accused the Jews of murdering Eszter. These charges were given an explosive boost by Géza Ónody, the local Member of Parliament, a true believer in Blood Libel who had been a writing a book about its long history. Ónody read the letter into the Parliamentary record as evidence of the dangers of Jewish immigration.</p><p>Six weeks after her disappearance, the corpse of a teenage girl was found in the Tisza six miles away. The face was too decayed to clearly identify it, but one detail stood out: its throat was not cut. Eszter’s mother and sister insisted it was not her, though they said the clothes did match. An inquest was held the following day; no one from Tiszaeszlar could identify the body. The medical examiners said they thought the body had been in the water for about ten days. The politicians and newspapers now claimed that wealthy Jews from Tokaj had replaced the real body with another one, traveling via the underground tunnels normally used for rolling wine barrels. That September, Ónody traveled to Dresden for the First International Anti-Jewish Congress, carrying a painting of Eszter, which was reverently placed on the podium alongside the portraits of the rulers of Austria-Hungary, Saxony, and Prussia.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/795/1*I5_gIwI-bFo-yrfZfPxEfQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Hungarian dramatization of Ónody and Eszter’s portait, 1882</figcaption></figure><p>The fifteen Jews lingered in prison for over a year while the investigation dragged on. Like Moritz, they were also repeatedly beaten and abused.</p><p>The trial began in June 1883 in a small city 15 miles from Tiszaeszlar in front of a three-judge-panel. Four of the fifteen men were charged with murder, the others as accessories. While the Prosecutor often seemed to question the central premise of the case, Ónody and other MPs came to court regularly, screaming at the witnesses and lawyers, then delivering passionate speeches outside, keeping the crowds constantly inflamed with misinformation. They called for expelling Jews from Hungary to Palestine, Egypt, or anywhere else that would take them.</p><p>The accused were defended by a middle-aged lawyer and liberal politician named Károly Eötvös who despised antisemitism as backwards nonsense and who condemned the police’s brutal tactics. He brought a scientific and modern sensibility to the case, demanding additional examinations of the body and a trip to the synagogue, where he demonstrated that the keyhole in question was actually too narrow to see through.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/207/1*ekTYr4bte71XgZhNbZzqrw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Károly Eötvös</figcaption></figure><p>Finally in July, after thirty court sessions and almost seven weeks of hearings, the court issued a unanimous acquittal. The body was declared to not be Eszter Solymosi, whose legal status remained “‘missing.” It was the first time a Blood Libel had been debated, and defeated, in a secular court of law. Katie was born six days after the verdict.</p><p>The Jews had no time to celebrate. The acquittal and release sparked three months of violent riots, at least eighty, starting in the large cities and rippling out to the provinces. Organized by Ónody, Zemplen farmers created a “Christian Wine League” and organized an anti-Jewish boycott that lasted years. Ónody also co-founded the “National Antisemitic Party” which would go on to win four percent of the national vote in the next election and seat seventeen men in Parliament.</p><p>That August in Abaujszanto, a town twenty miles north-west of Tokaj, a mob gathered along the main street and attacked Jewish homes and inns for three days, smashing glass and screaming abuse at their neighbors. The Jews, outnumbered four to one, locked themselves in their homes. The violence only stopped after martial law was declared and troops erected a gallows as a deterrent.</p><p>Katie’s cousin Herman lived on that street. It was likely that some of the broken windows were his.</p><p>Herman had been twenty-two when the trial ended and Katie was born. The month before she turned four, her father Wolf died in hospital of edema and heart failure. He left a young widow, Rose, with four children between age ten and one.</p><p>Within a year, Rose somehow got them all to New York City, joining one of Wolf’s brothers who had emigrated the year after the trial. Katie and her siblings experienced a disorienting displacement as they traveled from their small Hungarian town, full of family and traditions, across Central Europe to Germany, and then a 10-day boat crossing and terrifying inspection at Castle Garden. The Lower East Side of Manhattan crammed 334,000 people, mostly immigrants, into a single square mile. It was the densest place on earth and must have seemed like another world.</p><p>This new world may have been thousands of miles away from their old home and its problems, but it had plenty of challenges as well. In October 1888, Rose placed her children in the Hebrew Orphan Asylum. Her paperwork says she was living “in the yard” of a Lower Side tenement and that she could not care for them. Katie had already lived through Blood Libels, mob violence, the sudden death of her father, emigration, and then being institutionalized with her siblings, all before the age of six.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hFLB_8uU6Nv9l-eu0aTfDQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Katie and her siblings’ HOA intake form, 1888</figcaption></figure><p>Despite their rough start, Rose was determined. By 1900 they were all living together again back on the Lower East side on Stanton street. Three minutes away was a large synagogue named for the same Rabbi Sofer whose memory loomed large in the Hungarian Orthodox world.</p><p>All the children attended public school and graduated high school, with Katie’s brother also attending City College of New York and becoming a public school teacher. Katie and her sisters were all married at the Chasam Sofer synagogue and went into wholesale groceries and real estate. Her mother and brother died just two months apart in the 1919 Influenza Pandemic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/417/1*PektXakGxWJq22JExMiJCg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Congregation Chasam Sofer, Lower East Side. It is the second-oldest synagogue building in NYC still standing and the only one still in use.</figcaption></figure><p>Katie had three children and outlived all her siblings, dying in Brooklyn at age eighty. She never mentioned the world, or family, she had left behind.</p><p>By 1919, cousin Herman, now almost sixty, had also lived through a myriad of changes. He had gotten married a few years after the Tiszaeszlar trial. His two sisters had emigrated to New York in the 1890s. Shortly afterwards the town raised enough money to build a 600-seat synagogue on the Main Street, just across from him and a few doors down. He had seen the electrification of the town and heard the crackle of radios as wealthier families played with new technological offerings. At age 46 he had received the right to vote as a citizen of the Austro-Hungarian Empire.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Xk8nqDteizTiGL8Upx_SHg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Herman’s 1888 marriage record</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pDJeyvWlbyHJ79k-yv6Tyg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rLCUIBiHIJ6mMqbBifA9JQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Abaujszanto village and synagogue, early 1900s</figcaption></figure><p>Abaujszanto’s Jews were descended from Unterlanders but culturally Oberlanders, with only a few Hasidic families. Their first rabbi had been a student of Rabbi Sofer and the community and yeshiva followed this approach, emphasizing scholarship over miracles. The yeshiva had been running almost continuously for 140 years and was supported by local donations. At the same time, there were multiple wonder rabbis’ courts within a 30 mile radius, including one whose followers told fantastical stories about him and sold his portrait as a magical talisman against mice. Reb Shayele, as he was called, emphasized charity and simplicity, and put his words into practice by running a free soup kitchen.</p><p>Abaujszanto had its own special customs. For the Sabbath dinner, all households would have wine, soup, and fish. Since they were six hours from the Tisza, this was actually a mock-gefilte fish made of ground chicken breast. One of the town’s earlier rabbis, the <a href="https://nertzaddik.com/tzadik-info/?id=5095"><em>Shemen Rokeach</em></a>, had died 80 years earlier but was still known as one of the most famous holy men in Hungary, and pilgrims traveled to pray at his tomb for assistance. It was probably the only time anyone saw Christians visit their small Jewish cemetery. When someone died, the community would assemble in the deceased’s yard to build a makeshift coffin out of wooden boards while the funeral society prayed psalms over the body. Men would assemble in a line cutting the wood, loudly sighing after their turn to show that it was a sad occasion.</p><p>Like all his neighbors, Herman had also lived through the hardships of the Great War, when over 300,000 Hungarian Jews went off to fight for the old Emperor, with almost 10,000 of them dying in the process. This service was a point of pride; they thought of themselves as Hungarian patriots, after all. The town rabbi, Lipschitz, had even been awarded the Emperor’s Knight’s Cross medal 20 years before. Out of 5,000 residents, over 800 of Herman’s neighbors had joined the army. 120 died on the battlefield, a quarter of them Jews. Their names were recorded on marble tablets in the synagogue, their sacrifice memorialized for all to see.</p><p>The Emperor, who had reigned since before Herman was born, had died during the war, and his son had been dethroned by the new Austrian parliament the day after the armistice. From there the people suffered through two new Republics, a Communist coup and military counter-coup, a border war and a civil war, all within three years. When a decorated Admiral, Miklos Horthy, seized power and established an authoritarian regency in the name of the exiled former Emperor, most people were just relieved to see an end to the chaos and bloodshed. He would rule Hungary for the next 25 years.</p><p>1920 saw three major milestones for Hungary: the first was Horthy coming to power and managing to keep it. The second was the Treaty of Trianon, the now-forgotten eastern counterpart to the Treaty of Versailles and the even-more-forgotten Treaty of Saint-Germain. Bitterly criticized by Hungarian nationalists, the Trianon agreement divided up 70% of Hungary’s pre-war territory and 75% of its population, including three million ethnic Hungarians. The third significant event was the passing of the <em>Numerus Clausus </em>law, a quota system limiting Jewish university enrollment. It was the first anti-Jewish law passed in Europe after the Great War, more than a decade before Hitler came to power.</p><p>Herman may not have felt immediately targeted. There was no one in his household for that particular law to affect. He was an old man and he and his wife Bella, together for forty years, had no children. He had lived through the Emperor, the coups, and the Great War. He could survive this, too. After all, what was his alternative? By then one of his sisters was buried in Connecticut, and there is no evidence he had kept in touch with any relatives in America. Even if he had, the gates had already begun to close.</p><p>Herman and Bella had made their choice. They kept their heads down and worked through the 1920s and 1930s. Several of his father’s cousins lived next door and one can hope they spent the interwar years enjoying each other’s company, experiencing the rhythms of the seasons and the calendar year after year.</p><p>All until 1938.</p><p>Horthy and his allies, the Fascist Arrow Cross party, were an excellent example of what historian Timothy Snyder has referred to as “obeying in advance.” The Arrow Cross, whose members wore Green shirts and flew an emblem originally designed as a green swastika, was founded in 1935, based on a rediscovery of the venomous tirades of the National Antisemitism Party which had fizzled out decades earlier. A veteran of the coup against the short-lived Soviet-backed regime of Bela Kun, Horthy was bitterly obsessed with both Communists and Jews. That, plus his desire to regain Hungary’s lost territory, led him straight into an alliance with Germany, who was antagonistic to most of Hungary’s neighbors/rivals. Hungary’s 400,000 Jews, who still considered themselves patriots and Hungarians first, were caught in the crossfire.</p><p>Parliament approved the First Jewish Law in May 1938, establishing quotas restricting the number of Jews across the economy like theater, medicine, law, press, and private commerce. 250,000 Hungarian Jews lost jobs. Besides the large cities, the law particularly devastated agricultural towns like Abaujszanto and Tokaj, where Jews ran much of the wine trade. The law also required all Jews to visit government offices to prove their families’ uninterrupted residence in Hungary since 31 December 1867, the year of emancipation. Since there had been no official registration until 1895, this left about half of Hungary’s Jews unable to verify their citizenship and threatened with expulsion. Herman had been born before emancipation but like many of his neighbors, likely struggled to find documentation to prove it.</p><p>Police harassment became constant. The Hungarians particularly enjoyed conducting searches of Jewish homes on Saturdays and Jewish holidays. On May Day, 1939, also known as International Workers Day, the Abaujszanto police randomly arrested dozens of prominent Jewish citizens, interrogated them, and locked them up for a day, supposedly to keep them from “engaging in Communist activities.” The police liked the May Day Raid so much they decided to make it an annual tradition.</p><p>The Second Jewish Law passed that same month. It defined Jews as anyone with two Jewish grandparents, eliminated their voting rights, and further tightened quotas on Jewish businesses. It also banned kosher slaughter and prohibited renewing or issuing new trade licenses to Jews. The Catholic Church’s only public objection was that it discriminated against Jewish converts and their descendants, adding 100,000 “Christian Jews” to the community rolls and restricted lists.</p><p>Next the Prime Minister introduced the Labor Service Battalions, a dumping ground for any political undesirables drafted into the army. It was overwhelmingly composed of Jews, who numbered about 8% of the national population. The Hungarian officer corps had a tradition of antisemitism, in fact the idea of special Jewish battalions had been introduced by Horthy 20 years earlier, as he did not trust Jewish soldiers to bear arms against the Soviets.</p><p>Within a few months they had created segregated Jewish units where the so-called soldiers were immediately stripped of all ranks and privileges. They were chronically malnourished, physically abused, and assigned brutal labor like digging ditches and building railroad tracks. Due to its train station, Abaujszanto became a command center and dispatch point for the battalions. Terrified men would be housed by the town residents and given food before being sent off to labor camps. At least four of Herman’s relatives were taken into the battalions along with 100,000 other young Jewish men. More than 45,000 died.</p><p>As the law took effect, half of Hungary’s Jews lost their jobs. Newly banned businesses could be confiscated by non-Jewish neighbors for a nominal fee. Jews were not only pushed out of the wine trade but also banned from selling leather, sugar, oil, or flour. On the rare occasion a merchant was able to get raw materials, the Arrow Cross would organize boycotts against them.</p><p>In Abaujszanto the new discrimination was felt immediately; families lost their livelihoods and young people felt their future languish, locked out of education or work. The town’s only movie theater was forced to move out of the hall of a Jewish owner and relocate to the other side of town, where the Jews rarely went for fear of physical assault.</p><p>Racist graffiti, particularly the Arrow Cross insignia, became ubiquitous on Jewish walls. Gangs of boys would stalk the streets, cursing and throwing stones at any Jews on their way to the synagogue. The rabbi had his windows broken and the vandals were only caught because one Jew held the boys until the police could come arrest them. The Jews almost always chose to ignore the harassment, though at least once the town butcher, Izidor, rallied some hardy boys and chased his tormentors away.</p><p>All of this happened before Hitler ever crossed into Poland.</p><p>Once the war began, as the rest of Europe burned, Hungary was left mostly to itself, thanks to its geographic isolation and Horthy’s alliances. The Abaujszanto synagogue became even more central to daily life. Those with hidden radios would use the schmoozing after services as an opportunity to share news with the rest of town.</p><p>The Third Jewish Law appeared in August 1941, a few months after Germany invaded the Soviet Union. It was directly modeled on the Nazis’ 1935 Nuremberg Code, prohibiting intermarriage and criminalizing romantic relationships between Jews and non-Jews. By then Abaujszanto’s Jewish population had dropped to less than 700. That summer, Hungary deported 20,000 “foreign” Jews to Ukraine, including most of the Jews of Carpathia. At the border they were handed over to SS troops who marched them to the city of Kamenets-Podolsk and slaughtered them over two days, one of the earliest mass murders of the Holocaust.</p><p>As a Nazi ally, Hitler demanded that Hungary also contribute to the Soviet invasion. Horthy had dragged his feet, until the Soviets bombed the northern city of Kassa in June 1941, killing and wounding a dozen people. The Hungarian Second Army and its 200,000 troops were sent to the Eastern Front, first Ukraine and then Stalingrad. 19,000 forced Jewish laborers went with them, building roads and clearing minefields by hand.</p><p>That December, a week after Pearl Harbor, Hungary declared war on the United States. While it had no way of actually attacking the U.S., it was a convenient propaganda opportunity to blame Jews and Roosevelt for the ongoing economic pressures.</p><p>The Fourth and final Jewish Law was handed down in September 1942, right as the Germans had begun massive Jewish deportations in Poland. In a final reversal of the 1867 emancipation, the Fourth Law banned Jews from owning or purchasing land. In less than 80 years, Jews had lost all their hard-fought civil rights. All taken away in a so-called free Hungary.</p><p>After the Fourth Law, aside from a celebratory mob smashing the synagogue windows, there were nineteen months of eerie stillness. In February 1943, in minus 40 degree weather, the Second Army was wiped out by a Soviet counterattack, the men literally freezing in their coats as they tried to escape. Horthy became skeptical that Germany would actually win the war and began secretly negotiating to go over to the Allies.</p><p>Perhaps due to this growing concern, there was one line Horthy’s government would not cross: deportation, at least of their “own” Jews. Horthy’s Prime Minister once enraged the German ambassador by saying that if he were to deport the country’s Jews, as they were asking, he would also have to crack down on their German minority in order to avoid accusations of favoritism.</p><p>In March 1944 the Nazis invaded, replacing Horthy with the more radical founder of the Arrow Cross party. Thanks to racial laws and territorial conquests, Hungary now contained 825,000 Jews, the largest remaining Jewish population in Europe. It was landlocked and surrounded by Nazi allies on all sides. Herman was 83; his wife, 82. Even if they had wanted to, there was nowhere to run.</p><p>To implement the Final Solution in Hungary, 200 Nazi commandos were assigned to a middle-aged Lieutenant Colonel who operated out of a luxurious hotel in Budapest. He was bespectacled and balding, and approached mass murder as merely another logistics project requiring long hours and lots of paperwork. His name was Adolf Eichmann. Together with the Arrow Cross government, he divided Hungary into six zones and began drafting procedures for deporting Jews to the north. There was so much to do that Eichmann called Rudolf Hoss, the first Commandant of Auschwitz, back to the camp so he would be able to help oversee the gassing. In his honor, Eichmann named the operation Aktion Hoss.</p><p>The Nazis formed a Jewish Council in Budapest and banned all access to communications except their newspaper. Within two weeks, the Council introduced the six-pointed star, mandatory for all Jews over the age of six. It had to be canary yellow, 10 centimeters square, worn over the left chest. The penalty for not wearing one was immediate arrest, usually after an intense beating. The Jews had the choice of whether to use silk or velvet. American Jewish leaders, who had access to far more information than Hungarian Jews and had seen what happened in other Nazi-occupied countries where it was introduced, begged radio broadcasters to urge them to resist the yellow star, but this was ultimately denied. Local leaders encouraged their communities to remain calm and follow the laws, as undignified as they may have been.</p><p>Less than three weeks after the invasion, on April 4, the Jewish Council of Abaujszanto was ordered to register all Jews in the town. Herman and Bella were listed as numbers 351 and 352 out of 582. Interestingly, they both lied about their ages, perhaps in a desperate attempt to save themselves or maybe as a small act of defiance to make the clerks’ lives harder: Herman, perhaps thinking he could only push his luck so far, said he was three years younger. Bella, who may have been better preserved, said she was twenty years younger. What did she have to lose?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tjiDiYQg4cFm4O-eis00LA.png" /><figcaption>April 1944 Abaujszanto list (ITS)</figcaption></figure><p>That year, the last day of Passover fell on Saturday, and the synagogue was full. The rabbi, who usually spoke in German or Yiddish, delivered a sermon in Hungarian so all the young people and women could understand. He told the crowd to be brave during the coming days.</p><p>They would have no time to be brave. The next day was the end of everything.</p><p>That Sunday, twelve Hungarian policemen arrived by train. The town crier struck his drum and announced that Jews were now banned from leaving town under penalty of death, and that anyone caught helping them would be severely punished.</p><p>Next, all Jews were told they had two hours to gather their belongings and be ready to travel. They were given an official list of permitted items, including food for fourteen days, two changes of underwear, the clothes on their back, and a bag weighing no more than 110 pounds. They could pack it with bedding, jewelry, or gold, but any money would be confiscated.</p><p>People ran through their homes, packing in panic. Since Passover had just ended there was no bread in any of the Jewish homes and no time to buy any. Some people tried to hide valuables under floorboards or in yards, hoping to return later. Others wrote goodbye letters to family, hoping they would have a chance to send them.</p><p>Two hours after the police had arrived, they began going house by house using the Council’s list, assembling families outside as they searched their homes and then nailed the doors shut. When the officers had a large enough group, they would escort the Jews towards the public school, the largest building in town and which had been designated their “collection center.” The oldest people, like Herman and Bella, were placed on horse-drawn carriages at the end of the line. Arrow Cross thugs volunteered to guard the rear, gleeful teenagers sneering as the Jews were finally taken away.</p><p>At the school, everyone was forced to hand over all jewelry and money, then given detailed receipts. They were then strip-searched and robbed a second time. They spent the night locked in the school, in classrooms so crowded some had to sleep sitting on the floor.</p><p>Over the next two days they were sent by train 35 miles north to Kassa, still partially destroyed from the Soviet bombing. The Deportation Register included 582 residents and five young children whose families had sent them to stay with relatives in the country, hoping they would be safer.</p><p>By the end of the month, 15,000 Jews from the surrounding villages had been locked into the Kassa Ghetto, (actually the town brick factory,) where most of them lived outside, exposed to rain and heat. It later became known as “the country’s worst deportation center.”</p><p>After the war Kassa, known today as Kosice, Slovakia, became an important historical source for a particular area of Holocaust research: the trains. The station master had kept an eerie, detailed log. The first train left on May 14, and they had run for 33 days straight, with 109 trains total between mid-May and mid-June. On a typical day they would have three or four trains go through, but occasionally there could be as many as six. In late June they had 10 trains, and in early July, they had one last burst of 18. Each train was a series of 40 to 50 cattle cars, carrying up to 4,000 people in all. The Kassa Jews were among the first to be deported. They only took up four trains.</p><p>By the end of July, over 430,000 Hungarian Jews had been deported on 147 trains, all but 10 passing through Kassa. The trains went mostly to Auschwitz, where 80% of the prisoners were gassed on arrival, particularly the elderly, like Herman and Bella. A postwar trial transcript revealed that of the 15,000 Jews sent from Kassa, 8,000 had been immediately killed.</p><p>The trains only stopped after 56 days, when the Allies began bombing Budapest. By then almost the entire Jewish population of rural Hungary had been exterminated. It was the largest Holocaust mass killing to take place after 1942, and the last.</p><p>After summer 1944, the country was mostly Judenrein except for the capital, Budapest. Over the next eight months, yet more massacres would occur, like the infamous Arrow Cross shooting of 20,000 Budapest Jews along the Danube, their bodies tossed into the water while soldiers collected their shoes. By liberation in February 1945, more than 560,000 Jews had been murdered, most of them over those 56 days.</p><p>There were about 120,000 Jewish survivors left in the capital, including 25,000 who had been in hiding with false documents. Another 20,000 survived the concentration camps. Only 50,000 came back from the labor battalions, including the son of one of Herman’s cousins.</p><p>About 60 survivors returned to Abaujszanto. Like Jewish communities across Hungary they attempted to rebuild but faced multiple challenges. The synagogue had been gutted, its windows smashed and seats thrown into the yard. Torah scrolls had been left outside and run over with carts and trucks. Survivors already dealing with physical and mental scars that would last a lifetime also had to suffer through seeing neighbors wearing their dead relatives’ clothes and sleeping in their stolen beds. The Communist papers published articles encouraging the Jews to “show more understanding” to the Christians living in their former homes and digging up their gardens looking for gold. While some Hungarian Christians were happy to see the Jews and helped them try to readjust, others complained that “more had come back than had left.”</p><p>In early 1948, the survivors installed a memorial plaque in the synagogue. It was five panels wide, in dignified black marble with gold lettering. It followed the same list that the Council had compiled that day in April 1944, the same one the Nazis had used. The community was too small to restore the whole building, so they had just cleaned up the entryway. That was also where they placed the plaque, constantly reminding them of their missing loved ones, gone without a grave.</p><p>Immediately after the war, Hungary had suffered more than a year of runaway inflation and poor harvests. In 1949 the government nationalized all private business and industry. Many of the survivors had attempted to restart their family businesses and were now hammered by economic repression. Communism also made it hard to maintain any religious infrastructure or community life. Many of the remaining rural Jews left for Budapest, then the U.S. or Israel.</p><p>In 1950 the Jewish community of Abaujszanto was officially disbanded. The synagogue’s beautiful walls, covered in intricate paintings of Biblical scenes, were repainted with whitewash and its stained glass was removed. It was converted into a lumber warehouse and then bought by the post office.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*pRawVf79grlZlXvJJtF3_A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Abaujszanto synagogue site, 2000s</figcaption></figure><p>In 1951, the memorial plaque was vandalized with antisemitic graffiti. To protect it, locals decided to move it to the Miskolc Jewish cemetery, the largest small city in the region.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*e2cwvEcbPVggm8caMWb_Qg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pPJJN7qW1TM-vks1jEJlVQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Abaujszanto Memorial, Miskolc. Herman and his family are halfway down the first column in the second panel.</figcaption></figure><p>Today the former synagogue is being developed into a hotel, and the closest memorial to Abaujszanto’s murdered Jews lies in Miskolc, 30 miles away. At least the cemetery still stands, the <em>Shemen Rokeach’s</em> almost 200-year-old grave now restored and visited again by the faithful every February.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/576/1*u1rJRtO0CxUmGkNlBI7pAQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Shemen Rokeach’s tomb, Abaujszanto</figcaption></figure><p>Eszter Solymosi remains a powerful symbol in Hungary today. In 1994 Hungarian nationalists erected a grave to her at the Tiszaeszlar cemetery. The epitaph reads, “To the memory of my dear daughter, your mother.” Every year, crowds from across the Hungarian right converge on Tiszaeszlar, carrying flags and emblems and marching through the town to the funeral home and then the grave, where they lay wreaths and give speeches about the glories of fascism, the betrayal of Trianon, and the truth about the Jewish Question and the Solymosi case.</p><p>Much like other Blood Libel claims, today Eszter’s mystery is a cause celebre among the far-right, an example of secret knowledge suppressed by a Jewish elite. A 1997 Hungarian skinhead album featured two songs that referenced the supposed killing. In 1999, a Hungarian neo-Nazi group named itself “the Solymosi Skins.” In 2007, the 125th anniversary of her disappearance, an online group fundraised to add a small carved portrait of Eszter to the marble stone. Its name, Conscience 88, was a reference to Hitler.</p><p>Online, Eszter is memorialized on YouTube and fascist message boards as a martyr of the Hungarian right and a victim of supposed Jewish Satanism. The European “cult of Eszter,” as one researcher put it, uses her memory to attack other scapegoats today, particularly Roma and Middle Eastern migrants. In the last twenty years, politicians and cranks have invoked the Blood Libel in the Hungarian and Russian Parliaments, on Jordanian and Saudi television, and in rage-filled manifestos before going on shooting sprees in America.</p><p>Conspiracy theories go back thousands of years, and some historians have argued that antisemitism is the oldest one, shape-shifting and enduring by providing a meta-narrative to explain the world’s ills. In our times, the Blood Libel has expanded beyond Jews: the modern-day adrenochrome myth, a mainstay of the American QAnon conspiracy movement, says that Hollywood and government elites kidnap children and terrify them to harvest a special hormone from their blood before using underground tunnels and secret crematoria to eliminate all traces.</p><p>If their hateful inversion of reality wasn’t so obscene, it might almost be funny.</p><p>I believe truth, history and memory are deeply important, both to honor our past and inform our future. As a matter of principle, I avoid conspiracy theories. But this story would be incomplete without one last coda. Something I discovered while exploring historical newspapers in college.</p><p>One factor in the eventual acquittal at the 1883 trial had been an inability to positively identify the body as Eszter. It was eventually examined three different times by numerous forensic experts, as well as the Solymosi family. Her mother consistently said it was not her daughter.</p><p>The antisemites in the press and Parliament insisted that this was because of Jewish interference with the evidence. But there may have been another reason.</p><p>Almost a decade after her disappearance, several American newspapers reported an odd story. One snippet in the New York Times carried the headline, “Not Murdered After All.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/466/1*kcOvhigBjB73ZtglBxeB9A@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>Like Katie’s family and thousands of others, a number of Tiszaeszlar Jews had decided that the trial and its aftermath meant it was time to go. One of them was the Brown family, who had moved to Manhattan and settled near the Upper East Side. In August 1889, Mrs. Brown had been talking to their boarder, a young cloakmaker named Rosa Kohlmeyer. Rosa mentioned that an old pair of stockings had belonged to her grandmother Solymosi, a name that made Mrs. Brown shudder. She had asked whose side she was on, and Rosa had said her father’s.</p><p>Mrs. Brown’s husband had gone to Ferdinand Levy, City Coroner of New York, who spent nineteen months assembling a dozen witnesses, including two former schoolmates of Eszter’s, and enticing them to visit her, observe her features, and surreptitiously question her. Fearing she was becoming suspicious, he brought the witnesses and reporters to Rosa’s new lodgings in March 1891 intending to confront her. She refused to break, denying everything. “You are all liars,” she shouted. “God will avenge me on you. You will suffer for this.” The only thing she would admit was that she had come to New York around 1888 as Rosa Szenffy (her mother’s maiden name, she claimed) and that she was from Misckolc.</p><p>Levy told the newspapers that he intended to send all evidence back to Hungary to the defense counsel. Unfortunately two days after the story broke, Rosa disappeared. She quit her job and her landlord speculated that she had hidden herself with friends “to avoid further annoyance.”</p><p>The paper trail ends there, but it is fascinating to note two haunting details:</p><p>First, Castle Garden records confirm a Rosa Szenffy traveled from Hungary to New York in August 1888.</p><p>Second, according to the trial records, the last person to see Eszter before her disappearance was a Christian merchant in a nearby village. Eszter had been sent by her landlady to buy black paint and was supposed to come right home.</p><p>The shopkeeper’s name was Kohlmeyer.</p><p>Sources:</p><p>Andrew Handler, <em>Blood libel at Tiszaeszlar, </em>1980</p><p>Zahava Szász Stessel, <em>Wine and Thorns in Tokay Valley: Jewish Life in Hungary: The History of Abaújszántó</em>, 1995</p><p>Zoltán Kékesi, <em>Memory in Hungarian Fascism: A Cultural History</em>, 2023</p><p>YIVO Encyclopedia: https://encyclopedia.yivo.org/article/13</p><p>https://encyclopedia.yivo.org/article/1680</p><p>https://encyclopedia.yivo.org/article/1520</p><p>Kehillalinks: https://kehilalinks.jewishgen.org/miskolc/abauj.html</p><p>Jewish Encyclopedia: https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/14407-tisza-eszlar-affair</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=67b173076295" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Enoch, 1919- Justice Denied]]></title>
            <link>https://andrewnusbaum.medium.com/enoch-1919-justice-denied-7887b892eaca?source=rss-4449dce292d6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7887b892eaca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[jewish]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[true-crime]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genealogy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrew Nusbaum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 Apr 2026 04:21:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-13T17:53:25.896Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/509/1*gNANMXQ2DfI9ftFClC43ZA@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Enoch Lozdziejski, Augustow</em></figcaption></figure><p>I have spent over 25 years tracing my family history. In that time I have become acquainted with many different sources of information and how best to mine them for my own purposes. American World War Two Draft Cards, for example, not only reveal names, birth towns, and occupations, but also fascinating details like height, weight, and any “distinguishing marks.”</p><p>Recently I discovered that one of my relatives was mentioned in a 100-year old criminal file. I wrote to the Polish archives, got 190 digital scans, and painstakingly went to work translating and reconstructing the story, piece by piece.</p><p>Here is what I <em>think</em> happened.</p><p>Enoch lived in Augustow, a small town of about 9,000 in Bialystok Province, near the modern north-eastern border where Poland meets Lithuania and Belarus. He was the oldest son of eight siblings; three had gone to the UK, two to the US, and two others remained in Poland.</p><p>Enoch worked as a carter and occasional horse trader. He had been conscripted in summer 1914 as a 40-year-old private in the Czar’s <a href="https://btgv.ru/history/troops-history/-russian-army/about-the-heroes-of-the-november-battles-of-1914-several-officers-of-the-104th-ustyuzhsky-infantry-regiment/">104th Infantry Ustyuzhsky regiment</a> along with 4,100 other men, some from the area and others from across the empire. He had witnessed the first-ever battle involving <a href="https://btgv.ru/history/troops-history/-russian-army/murderous-carts/">machine-guns mounted on carts</a>, which hadn’t been as much a battle as a slaughter of the approaching German forces. It hadn’t done Enoch much good, since he had been captured along with 1000 of his comrades. He had spent over a year in two different POW camps before finally being sent back home.</p><p>By then the Germans had both bombed and taken the town, and Enoch had been treated to two more years of German occupation. At least he had come back; by the end of the war the town’s Jewish population had dropped by half. Whether due to desperation or stubbornness, though, Enoch stayed put. Maybe he had missed the local lakes and forest while in the German camps and refused to leave them. Maybe he had no way to leave and nowhere to go. By the winter of 1919 he had been a citizen of the Second Polish Republic for a little over a year, the first free Polish state in over a century. The constant political, economic, and military fluctuations over the past year had kept everyone in a perpetual state of excitement, mixed with equal parts optimism and exhaustion, depending on the day’s news.</p><p>That wasn’t his business, though. Augustow abutted a 400,000 acre old growth forest. Enoch’s job was to carry passengers and goods across the spiderweb of dirt roads, river dikes, and the occasional paved highway that divided the area’s towns and villages. The pathways that ran along the eight large lakes and lengthy canal were a lifeline between communities, but the war, especially the destruction and soldiers that came with it, had made his job much harder. While he could make a nice sum on a successful trip, it had required dodging retreating Germans and advancing Poles and their respective checkpoints. His greatest fear was that one of them would seize his Bay horse. Without his horse, how would he feed his wife Rivka and seven children? The youngest, Chaim, was just five weeks old.</p><p>On a frigid Sunday in late November, he left his house on Kopernika street around 10 in the morning. He told Rivka he would be back in a few hours for an early supper. He was wearing two pairs of warm long johns, a white undershirt with <em>tzitzit</em>, the ritual fringes worn by observant Jewish men, a warm gray shirt, a gray-brown jacket, a heavy knee-length black sheepskin coat, a pair of laced high shoes and footwraps, and a black workman’s cap. In his pockets he carried one Polish 100-mark banknote, 2 silver German 1-mark coins, a promissory note worth 200 rubles from a previous client, and a silver watch on a chain with a cracked face.</p><p>He was of average height for the time and area, with a strong, muscular build and a long reddish beard. He was well-fed and slightly balding.</p><p>Enoch drove his horse a few blocks to the market square and stopped in front of a brick building, waiting for a fare. Sunday was the Christian Sabbath, but his had finished the night before and today was just one more workday for him. The war had been hard on business, and he was eager to try to make up for lost time now that the roads were consistently open. Rivka and the children were depending on him. He waited for over an hour as the weather turned wet.</p><p>A little past noon, a pair of Polish Catholic farmers, later identified as 62-year old Jan and 17-year-old Zygmunt Kupinski, approached him. Witnesses heard him speak with the men for a long time. They hired him to take them to Czarny Brod, a tiny forest settlement about 50 miles away. Alter Stawiskowski, another Jewish carter, heard them agree on a price of 65 Polish marks. He said that Enoch looked hesitant at first, but then the boy handed over the money, and he allowed the men into his wagon. Stawiskowski remembered that Jan sat directly behind Enoch, facing his back.</p><p>The Kupinskis — Jan, his second wife, and his younger son Zygmunt — lived twenty miles from Augustow in a small village of about 200 called Gruszki. Jan farmed on six acres that he had inherited from his first wife, who died a few years earlier. Before the war he had worked in the forests as a laborer and woodcutter.</p><p>On Thursday, Jan and Zygmunt left their farm with 80 rubles. First they stopped at the home of the village headman, Jadeszko. They brought him some cash to pay off their taxes.</p><p>The money wasn’t Jan’s. He had told his neighbors that a Jew had told him there were horses for sale in the town of Sejny for 800 rubles. He had borrowed 200 rubles from his first wife’s brother Ludwik Kuryło. They were seen leaving town — on foot — mid-morning on Thursday, but instead of heading north towards Sejny, they went due west, towards Augustow. It would have been an eight-hour journey by foot. They never revealed what they did that first night; they may have stayed overnight in a village or even slept in the forest.</p><p>They arrived in town around noon. Despite Friday being Market Day, they did not shop for a horse. Later under questioning, Jan claimed they had been after some linen to make shirts or coats; Zygmunt would admit that they had not looked for linen at all but had instead bought sulphur, a common dietary supplement for pigs. Afterwards, Jan said he couldn’t handle another walk back, so the two went to find a horse-drawn cart. The first man they asked was a colleague of Enoch’s named Yankel Kan.</p><p>In his testimony, Kan later said that Kupinski’s request had immediately seemed odd: “Take us to Lipsk, or to Sajenek, or failing that, to Czarny Brod or Studzieniczna.”</p><p>To anyone who knew the roads that would have made no sense: Lipsk was seven hours south-east. Czarny Brod was four hours north-east. On the way you passed both Sajenek and Studzieniczna. Where, exactly, did they want to go?</p><p>In any case, the Sabbath was approaching, and all those trips would take him far too long in order to be back in time before sundown. He politely refused and suggested they try some of the Christians.</p><p>Next the Kupinskis went to four Polish farmers who lived in town, asking each one in turn to take them to Lipsk, still 15 miles away (and four hours south of their farm). Feliks Mezio asked for 100 Polish marks but Zygmunt said that was too high, given that the roads were in good condition. Mezio shrugged. Fine by him, his horse was already being used to fetch firewood in the forest. Pawel Liwski begged off, saying his horse was too weak for such a journey. Franciszek Dyczewski was also reluctant, especially after young Zygmunt spat, “Come on, we’ll pay whatever you want!” Suspicious of these strangers, Dyczewski turned them down.</p><p>Finally in the late afternoon they came to the home of Jozef Chelminski. Again they asked to go to Lipsk. He complained about the distance and the hour and asked why they hadn’t tried to get a ride earlier with all the peasants returning to their villages from the fair. Jan said they had been involved with a court case over a land dispute. His damned cousin was trying to take what was rightfully his. Chelminski suggested they wait until the following morning. Jan shook his head and said they had already spent one night in town and could not afford to pay for lodgings. Chelminski sighed and asked for 200 marks. Jan countered with 100. Chelminski sighed again. He wouldn’t hire himself out for such a low wage, but they could sleep on his floor. He noticed that when they laid down that night, Jan merely removed his coat. Almost as if he was trying to stay prepared for something.</p><p>The next day was Saturday. Chelminski suggested they go inquire at the taverns to see if anyone was headed towards Lipsk; if not, he supposed he could take them himself. He did not see them again until after their arrest.</p><p>The Kupinskis would later claim they tried to hire two more farmers that day and were again turned down. Their whereabouts that day remain unverified. That evening they approached another farmer, Marcin Dyczewski, and begged him for lodgings.</p><p>That night, over supper, Jan got to talking. He said they came from the town of Sopockinia, over 30 miles east (and 10 miles past Gruszki). They had been visiting Augustow for the last three years; their attorney Mr. Shapira lived here and was working on their case. Their cousin had taken control of their land and refused to return it, claiming they had abandoned it during the war when they fled to Russia — a wicked lie, they insisted.</p><p>On Sunday, the Kupinskis ate breakfast at Dyczewski’s home and said they were going to see Shapira to ask him whether he had filed their case yet. Zygmunt later emphasized to investigators that they had not gone to church but had gone directly to the town square. Jan would say of course they had attended Mass.</p><p>First they tried Yankel Kan again, admiring his wagon’s cart and seats. Kan said his horse was too weak to go all the way to Lipsk. He saw them move on and eventually settle with Enoch. Fair enough, Enoch’s horse was stronger, and so was Enoch. He heard him ask them for 100 marks, but didn’t know how much they finally agreed on.</p><p>Dyczewski was one of the last people to see the Kupinskis that day, rhythmically bouncing in Enoch’s wagon on the dirt road out of town. Police Constable Milcarz saw Enoch, who he knew by name, go past his checkpoint with two strangers.</p><p>“The coachman was kneeling at the front of the cart, while his passengers were seated on the bench behind him. The older man was seated with his back facing the horse.” When the cart drew close, another officer walked over, inspected it and nodded. Enoch waved to Milcarz and drove off towards the railway station.</p><p>At two o’clock, Polish farmer Jan Baranowski discovered a body about a mile west of Czarny Brod, at a strategic and isolated bend in the dirt road. The man was lying in a ditch on his left side. His head was facing the road while his feet faced the ditch. He was bareheaded but Baranowski could tell from his clothes that he was Jewish. He noticed cart tracks coming from Augustow headed towards Czarny Brod. They turned back towards Studzieniczna, before swerving into a telegraph pole. The abandoned cart stood 20 paces from the man’s body, its shaft shattered against the pole. There was no horse, or harness.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*u3iwbeYZV6Td6zwV2x0Mfw.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>A stretch of road and telegraph poles, Augustow</em></figcaption></figure><p>Baranowski saw two sets of tracks leading away from the body; one on foot into the forest, and one on horseback back towards Studzieniczna. He followed the horse tracks. Along the way he asked whether anyone had seen anyone coming the other way but no one had seen anything — or at least would admit to it. When he got to the village, he reported the body to a police officer, then continued on to Augustow, where he told Layzer Fraymark what he had seen.</p><p>At four o’clock, Fraymark went to the Augustow police. Then he, Gedalia Davidowicz, and Abram Berkowicz followed four officers as they went to inspect and cordon off the body. A crowd had started to gather and examine the body. At six o’clock, the men grimly identified it as Enoch. The 10 square feet between his body and the canal was trampled and bloody in three distinct spots. On the cart lay an overcoat and a horse blanket. He saw a set of footprints leading from the road to the right, into the forest, circling around a large pine tree surrounded with trampled snow, and then curving back toward the road to Augustow.</p><p>Constable Olekso inspected Enoch’s injuries as Corporal Korsak and Squad Leader Pols did their best to keep the growing crowd back. Squad Leader Szygieł sketched a detailed map of the road and river, with labelled spots showing where Enoch was found, along with his whip, cap, and cart.</p><p>His coat had been ripped open, his pockets turned inside out. His money and watch were gone, the broken chain still clinging on to his vest. His <em>tzitzit</em> had been pulled out from under his shirt and the strings were “matted with blood and filth.” The killers also took his horse, the most valuable thing his family owned. They probably would have taken the wagon as well, if it hadn’t been damaged in the struggle.</p><p>His head was a bloody mess, at least five wounds on the right side of this head. The only merciful thing was that he probably died quickly.</p><p>The police finished their report and put the body on another cart to take back to town for autopsy. The three men who had come with them dutifully gathered the blood-stained snow that lay around their friend’s corpse and piled it in his wagon. His body, though shattered, would be buried whole.</p><p>Meanwhile, two other Augustow policemen, Investigator Kaczynski and Constable Rutkowski, were patrolling the highway leading towards Grodno, then still part of eastern Poland. Around four, they heard reports about a suspicious young man riding a horse wearing a full harness on the highway heading east.</p><p>Men who worked with horses knew there was no reason anyone would bother loading one up with a heavy harness without also attaching a wagon, especially if you were planning on riding it side-saddle anyway. Back then, it was the equivalent of driving a car with a broken door lock dangling off the side, practically advertising that your ride was stolen.</p><p>The police took off in their truck, heading south-east into the dusk. The highway was a modern paved gravel road that had been built and maintained by the Russians and was considered valuable state infrastructure. It was regularly patrolled by the police and army. Despite four years of potholes, the men made good time.</p><p>Instead of finding the boy, around five o’clock they came across an older man outside Skieblewo, more than 40 miles from Czarny Brod. He said he was on his way home from church and that he was a 70-year-old farmer named Spinski. Could they give him a lift? It was only about 9 miles up the road. A little place called Gruszki.</p><p>The police questioned him. By any chance, did he have a son? At this, Kaczynski said the man “became confused and practically numb with terror.” His answers began to contradict themselves. He was arrested and placed in the town jail. Under interrogation he claimed he had walked through the forest to Krasne and had been hitchhiking rides up the road home. He was later identified as Jan Kupinski.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/392/1*NGtOW45I-mt-zTTm_otE6A.png" /><figcaption><em>Jan Kupinski, arrest photo</em></figcaption></figure><p>Back on the road, Kaczynski and Rutkowski headed to Krasne. They arrived around eight o’clock. A group of village teenagers was having a Sunday evening party. Yes, they had spotted the same strange youth riding a horse in harness, maybe two hours before. He had been heading north. Towards Gruszki. The police took the teens with them to make an identification.</p><p>Around midnight, they descended on the Kupinski family farm. The policemen found Zygmunt sleeping undressed on top of the old Russian-style masonry stove. While he was putting on his clothes they caught him trying to throw a heavy Russian-made Nagant revolver behind a trunk. They found it had three spent bullets and one live round. It was also covered in blood.</p><p>They searched the farm. Enoch’s harness was buried under some hay in the barn. His horse was hidden in the pigsty. As they arrested Zygmunt, he told Kaczynski, “We killed the Jew because father liked his horse.”</p><p>The next day was Monday. Under questioning at the Augustow police station, Jan claimed that they had come to town to buy linens — though they had not actually bought any — and then hired Enoch to take them to Czarny Brod. Jan said they had settled on a price of 70 marks but he only had 75, so he paid him that.</p><p>All three of them sat together on a single seat, Jan remembered — his son on the right, the Jew on the left, and he himself in the middle, facing the horse.</p><p>Today, the entire journey would take twenty minutes by car. In Enoch’s cart, it took over two hours. They rode out of town heading east, crossing the Netta river bridge, passing the army barracks where Enoch had spent his first terrifying weeks as a soldier, then the train station where he had said so many goodbyes to his brothers and sisters. They passed Lake Necko and Lake Biale, then took the right fork towards Lake Studzieniczna, home to a famous island shrine whose well-water could cure all manner of eye and skin ailments, at least according to the priests who sold it to the pilgrims. After the third lake, the road ran mostly straight, following the canal all the way to Czarny Brod, gigantic oak and ash trees towering on either side of the banks.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*QYot5EKTjNL6mZjjhmtYYA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Augustow Canal. The road Enoch drove on ran parallel to the water.</figcaption></figure><p>As they got closer to Czarny Brod, Jan had asked Enoch for his 5 marks back in change. Enoch refused. They began to argue. Enoch turned the horse around and struck Jan three times on the head with the butt of his whip. Jan said he then grabbed Enoch by the collar and jumped out of the cart, dragging him with him.</p><p>Enoch grabbed Kupinski by the throat and tried to hit him again. Jan drew his Nagant — which he had found in a field and only carried for protection from wolves, he said — and fired three shots at him.</p><p>He did not remember if the shots hit him. He did not remember hitting the Jew with anything. He just remembered that he and the Jew both fell to the ground — and then he got up, but the Jew did not.</p><p>No, his son had not been involved, other than taking the gun and horse back to their home at his father’s orders. What route? He had told the boy to ride back west to Studzieniczna, then south via the Grodno highway, and finally back north home to Gruszki. And him? He had followed on the same road, on foot.</p><p>He had not taken any of the Jew’s valuables. Only the horse, he said, to settle the 5 mark debt Enoch owed him. Police estimated the horse’s value at 1,500 marks.</p><p>Zygmunt had a slightly different story. They had hired Enoch earlier in the day, he insisted, and had left Augustow before noon. He agreed that they had overpaid by 5 marks, though he said Enoch asked for 65 marks and they had given him 70 because they had no smaller change. On the way, he had sat on the right side; his father sat on the left, facing backward, away from the horse, and Enoch, kneeling at the front, handled the reins.</p><p>He said the Jew had refused to give them their change when his father asked. He had shoved his father with such force that he pushed him out of the cart and landed on the ground. At that moment, the horse turned around, and the cart struck a post, breaking the pole.</p><p>His father then rose to his feet and grabbed the Jew by the throat, shouting: “Give back the money!” His father and the Jew continued to struggle; then Jan then drew his Nagant from his pocket, fired three times at the Jew, and killed him.</p><p>No, Zygmunt hadn’t seen it. He had run screaming up a nearby hill and hid in the forest. But he heard the shots. Afterwards his father called him back. He was covered in blood. The Jew was lying dead in the road, 30 paces from his ruined cart. The Nagant was next to him. Jan ordered him to pick up the gun, unharness the horse from the cart and ride home via the Grodno highway while he followed. He had not taken anything besides the horse and the harness. Whether his father had, he did not know.</p><p>He arrived home after dark. He stabled the horse in the shed, placed the harness in the barn, and went to sleep. He was arrested that night. As for the Nagant, Russian Cossacks had left it with them four years earlier.</p><p>No, he repeated. He did not conspire with his father to murder the Jew, nor did he strike the Jew at all; it must have been his father who killed him.</p><p>The interrogating officer took their statements and returned them to their cells.</p><p>Later that day, Chelminski ran into the Kupinskis again at the jail. He had heard about Enoch and, shocked, asked whether they had planned on killing him, too.</p><p>Of course not, Kupinski answered. There was no reason to kill <em>him</em>, he was a good man. But that Jew had demanded payment from them in advance, and they had overpaid him by 5 marks. Later in the forest, Zygmunt had gotten into a tussle with the Jew, and Jan had taken out his gun. He had just meant to scare him, he said, but he accidentally shot him.</p><p>Chelminski asked why he would do such a thing. Jan shrugged. “We needed a horse for spring plowing.” He added that the Jew had thought his ‘prayer strings’ would save him, but that he had finished the job by hitting him until he fell quiet. He only hoped his weak son would keep his mouth shut.</p><p>The Kupinskis stayed in jail for a week, then were officially charged with “acting with the intent to deprive Enoch Lozdziejski of his life for the purpose of robbery.” Their case was assigned to the Summary Court of Suwałki District, named after the nearest mid-sized city.</p><p>Summary Courts were three-man traveling tribunals set up in the early years of Polish statehood, meant to quickly and ruthlessly prosecute and punish bandits and other armed groups threatening public safety. Trials were supposed to conclude within forty-eight hours. Defendants were either released or immediately shot by firing squad. There was no right to appeal. Normally a standard murder wouldn’t qualify, but the Kupinskis’ use of the Grodno road had elevated the case to a highway robbery.</p><p>Antoni Naumowicz, the prosecutor for Enoch’s case, was also one of the Suwalki Court judges, a well-known and accomplished Augustow attorney. 56 years old with a bald head and massive mustache, he would go on to succeed his colleague Walery Roman as President of the Court less than two years later. The defense, Czesław Lutostanski, was twenty years younger than Naumowicz, a bespectacled social activist and lawyer-in-training from Suwalki. The trial was set for Wednesday, December 10, eight days away.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/503/1*kuzStPOfc34W44McPqvKWQ@2x.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/585/1*OTp8J4kbznsOZQJRFS0xLA@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Naumowicz and Lutostanski</em></figcaption></figure><p>Two and a half weeks after Enoch’s murder, proceedings began in the Augustow Town Hall, a two story white brick building with a three-tiered clock tower and a flag that flew above it. It was usually used for bureaucratic meetings, property disputes, and minor trials over petty thefts. The location was painfully ironic; the hall faced the same market square where Enoch had left with the Kupinskis.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*pA-RPmv35Xl9GdCicc0Z1Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Augustow Town Hall. Designed in 1836 by Henryk Marconi. Destroyed by the Nazis in 1944.</em></figcaption></figure><p>They started at 10:50 am. The judges were Antoni Wyrzykowski, Władysław Sobolewski, and Walery Roman.</p><p>Wyrzykowski divided his time between his home in Suwalki and the neighboring Radom district, where he also served as an investigating judge.</p><p>Young, mustachioed and slightly plump, Sobolewski was the newly appointed Justice of the Peace of Augustow, helping establish Polish law in the northern territories. He had fought in the Great War and then volunteered to defend Lwow against the Ukrainians. After leaving the army as a reserve Captain he had joined the State Police. On the side he moonlit as a professional fencer, even representing Poland at the 1924 Olympics.</p><p>Last, serving as President of the Court, was Roman, an old friend and ally of the new President, Jozef Pilsudski. He been a laywer for 20 years and was developing a taste for politics. He had been both the under-prosecutor of the Polish Supreme Court and a government diplomat during the last months of the war, negotiating with the Germans and Lithuanians in Paris as Suwalki district’s fate hang in the balance. His ability to keep as much territory as possible for Poland had made him a hero to both Pilsudski and the people upon his return. When the day for the inauguration of the Suwałki Summary Court finally arrived, the German military commander had told him they did not recognize any representatives of the Government in Warsaw. After a fruitless conference with the German officer, Roman had called his bluff and opened the court anyway, his colleagues Naumowicz and Sobolewski cheering him on. That had been only seven months ago. In two years he would leave the law for a political career.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/288/1*Qa39RVFoyN66stUSD6vy0Q@2x.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/148/1*YyM5IsaNS4Gzriq4YsoHFw@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Sobolewski and Roman</em></figcaption></figure><p>The Kupinskis sat in the dock and faced the Court. Jan pleaded guilty to murder and robbery and Zygmunt pleaded not guilty. The pistol and three spent cartridges (plus one unspent round) were placed on the judges’ bench.</p><p>The prosecution called twenty-four witnesses: six Polish farmers, five Jewish neighbors (plus Rivka), eight police officers, two expert witnesses, one in forensics and one in ballistics, along with two village headmen, Jadeszko from Gruszki, and Klukowski from Czarny Brod. The defense called five, including Jadeszko again, a Kupinski neighbor, and three of the Kuryło brothers. The parish priest and town rabbi, both stooped with age, stood on hand to administer the court oath.</p><p>Jan and Zygmunt spoke first, repeating their inconsistent stories about Enoch owing them 5 marks and attacking them without warning. Jan had been whipped in the face and then shot him. A few details changed. Now Zygmunt claimed Jan had been holding the gun and threatened to shoot him if he didn’t take the horse and go home. Zygmunt had not been involved. They took the horse to pay for what he owed them. Throughout their testimony, the Kupinskis never once referred to Enoch by his name — always “The Jew.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ycXPZhbclN12pBkeSZ6BLg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Zygmunt and Jan Kupinski</figcaption></figure><p>The witnesses were brought in and questioned one at a time. Baranowski spoke about finding the body. The court heard from the men who had waited with Enoch. Szygieł presented his map with its grisly list of items found in proximity to Enoch’s body:</p><p>“Blood by the corpse- 1 meter</p><p>Whip- 68 paces</p><p>Cap- 70 paces</p><p>Cart- 78 paces</p><p>Corpse from the cart- 10 paces</p><p>Footprints- 240 paces”</p><p>A more attentive lawyer might have emphasized how the physical evidence contradicted the Kupinskis’ story: As a religious Jew, Enoch would never have walked more than a few steps without his cap. The fact that the whip had been dropped near Enoch’s hat and that both were found over 100 feet from his body suggested that Jan had attacked Enoch while he was driving, dragged him from the cart, then beat him to death.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/954/1*E1u0nhpnz1Itqwc1_dcaWg@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Szygiel’s map. Enoch’s body is the small dot in the upper left corner.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Rivka was the fifth witness of the day. Her grieving children, or at least her infant son, would have been close by, possibly along with her elderly mother-in-law. Before she could take the stand, the young defense lawyer objected. As the victim’s widow and his closest relative, Rivka should be exempted from the court oath. The court agreed, so she was instead “examined without oath,” a strategy designed to place her testimony on a lower tier than that of the other witnesses, and particularly Kupinski’s wife’s relatives. Rivka pressed on, ready to speak.</p><p>She said Enoch had left for the market square that Sunday around eleven. She knew exactly what he had in his pockets because she had asked him for money and he had put her off, saying he would be back in an hour with more. Their horse and harness were each worth at least 1000 marks.</p><p>That awful night, one of the Jewish men — she couldn’t remember who — had pressed 70 marks into her hands. They said they had found it tucked in Enoch’s clothes.</p><p>The court record doesn’t speak to Rivka’s emotional state during her testimony. It doesn’t tell us whether the children came in with her or waited outside in the hallway with their grandmother or back at home. It does note that after her testimony, Rivka asked for permission to withdraw from the courtroom for two hours, and that it was mercifully granted.</p><p>The slow parade of the witnesses continued. Each police officer told their part of the tale.</p><p>The judges asked multiple witnesses about Jan’s and Zygmunt’s escape route. It was nearly impossible to keep their stories straight. Klukowski had seen a young man “galloping wildly” towards Studzienica that afternoon. He couldn’t say whether it was Zygmunt, but Zygmunt eagerly said it had been him and that he recognized Klukowski. He had been riding home to Gruszki via the route through Sajenek toward the Grodno Highway.</p><p>Jan backed him up. He <em>always</em> traveled to Augustów via the Grodno Highway when the weather was “wet and foul;” he only traveled through Czarny Brod when it was dry because the forest paths would become muddy and impassable.</p><p>Naumowicz must have sensed an opening. Szygiel was put back on the stand. How familiar was he with the terrain? Very familiar. The distance from Augustow to Gruszki was about 22 miles via the road through Czarny Brod. If you took the Grodno highway, it was more than 30.</p><p>At 1:35 pm the court took a recess for lunch, then resumed.</p><p>Constable Rutkowski shared Jan’s alias and positively identified the Nagant. Investigator Kaczyński recounted finding the gun and stolen property, as well as Zygmunt’s comment about Jan admiring Enoch’s horse. The judges asked him to clarify; was that in response to the question, “Why did you kill the Jew?” or, “Why did you take the horse?” Kaczyński said he could not remember. He said the people of the village “spoke very unfavorably” of the old man as they took Zygmunt into custody.</p><p>Yankel Kan told of his bizarre conversation with Kupinski that Friday afternoon, and insisted that of all the possible destinations the man mentioned, Gruszki had never been spoken. After Kan had finished, Jan declared to the court that he had not asked anyone else to take him to Lipsk. This was immediately contradicted by the next four witnesses, including Józef Chełmiński, who told the court about letting the Kupinskis spend the night, Jan sleeping in his clothes, and his later comments at the jail, including his remarks about Enoch’s “prayer strings.” He struggled to recall whether that first night Kupinski had said they “already” spent one night in town and found it expensive, or had merely said that “lodging in town <em>was</em> expensive.”</p><p>Again, Naumowicz passed up a chance to press his advantage. While today the custom is for many Jews to wear their <em>tzitzit</em> out, the fringes visibly cascading down the upper thigh over the pants, the custom in Augustow was to wear them tucked in, under the shirt. The only way Jan could have seen them was if he had been rifling through Enoch’s clothes as he bled to death.</p><p>During Dyczewski’s testimony, Jan insisted that he had never spoken about a court case or a lawyer to anyone and had never heard of this Mr. Shapira. Alter Stawiskowski said he been close enough to hear Jan and Enoch agree on 65 marks and, that his friend had asked to be paid in advance. Jan had told Zygmunt to pay and the boy had taken the money from his pocket. Stawiskowski had not seen the denominations; Enoch had quickly pocketed the money and the men had climbed aboard his cart.</p><p>Jadeszko, the only witness called by both sides, described the Kupinski farm. He had known the accused for many years; the old man worked the land together with his older son, who lived elsewhere and worked as a shoemaker. He had never heard anything negative about the family. Before the war the accused worked primarily in the forest as a day laborer and traded in horses. During the war, his horse died, and he currently owned no horse.</p><p>When asked about directions, Jadeszko was eager to please. To go from Gruszki to Augustow, one would either pass via the paved road toward Studzienica, or directly through the forest toward Czarny Brod to reach the main road. The Grodno highway? “No one travels that way,” he insisted. “It is too far.”</p><p>Kupinski’s neighbor said the accused was always “submissive and obedient to the authorities, meticulously carrying out all official directives,” and that he also had heard nothing bad about him. He added that the accused had once owned a cow, which he traded for a horse; however, after some time, that horse had died.</p><p>Jan’s brother-in-law Ludwik Kuryło told them no one had a bad thing to say about the man, and that “no one” from Gruszki going to Augustow would take the route via Krasne, as “it is a much longer distance.”</p><p>Ludwik’s brother Wincenty, who lived 200 paces from Jan’s home, denied seeing Zygmunt return with a horse. He said he had never seen the Nagant before.</p><p>The third brother Wojciech, whose house was even closer, also hadn’t seen the horse or the gun, but did let a few juicy details slip; ten years earlier, Jan had been accused of stealing a mare, but was acquitted due to a lack of evidence. After a pause, he added that Jan’s daughter-in-law had told him that Jan <em>always</em> carried his revolver, and, as she put it: “If he hadn’t done it to the Jew, he would have done it to someone else.” As for the boy, his record was clean.</p><p>The hearing lasted late into the day, taking another recess in the late afternoon before calling back some witnesses shortly before 6:00 pm.</p><p>No, Rivka said, she didn’t have the money anymore. She had spent it on memorial candles. No, she hadn’t counted it, she just heard the man say 70 marks. When the court had finally released Enoch’s body to the family, as per custom, they had buried him in his bloody clothes. His blood was a part of him, even now.</p><p>Szygiel, on the other hand, said no money had been found on Enoch’s body. They had placed a guard there before the crowds could arrive and no one was allowed to search the body. He did admit that he had not searched Enoch’s clothes past the first two layers since they were soaked in blood.</p><p>Jadeszko told the court about Jan paying his taxes on Thursday morning. He had noticed he had a wagon with him and asked why, given that he knew Jan’s horse had died. Jan had told him he was setting off on a journey and settling his affairs. He had heard from neighbors about Jan’s plan to buy a horse in Sejny. He remarked that he not observed him leaving his home recently since the death of his horse.</p><p>The Kuryłos were also called back. Ludwik spoke about loaning Jan 200 rubles. Yes, he had mentioned his plan to buy horses in Sejny. Yes, he had said they cost 800 and 900 rubles. But he had only given him 200. He didn’t know how much else Jan had when he left, and noted that he had yet to repay him.</p><p>Ludwik and Wincenty contradicted Jan’s claim that the Kupinskis had left the village Thursday evening. No, they said. It had been mid-morning, around 10 o’clock. No one knew where the two had gone until Monday morning when they heard they were arrested. They were still wearing the same clothes, said Wincenty, Jan in his sheepskin coat and Zygmunt in his thinner homespun. Wojciech, perhaps feeling a little guilty for his earlier revelations, would only add that he “did not know” whether the Kupinskis left the house on Thursday, “nor where they went.”</p><p>Now it was the expert witnesses’ turn. Dr. Jan Jawoworski’s report of the “bestial attack” took up several pages of the court record. Enoch was “undoubtedly much stronger than the accused,” and he had not actually been shot. He been beaten 10 times in the head with the Nagant’s steel-lined butt, which weighed about two pounds.</p><p>Eight lacerating blows came from the front, ranging from 2 to 6 centimeters in length. The two final fatal ones came from behind, each about 7 centimeters across, shattering the temporal bone behind his right ear and causing massive brain damage. His right parietal and occipital bones were in splinters. Jawoworski said the two fatal wounds “presented a gaping appearance” and that he had been able to “insert a finger through each aperture directly into the interior of the brain cavity.” He commented that as he had probed Enoch’s skull it had produced a crepitating, or crackling, sound.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/461/1*hhhK5Gfoait5IHKFDJFSBA@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Dr. Jan Jawoworski</em></figcaption></figure><p>Enoch’s blood was also found on the gun’s barrel. A bite mark on his thumb and swelling and bruising on Jan’s face, eyes, and nose, as well as deep scratches across the old man’s neck proved Enoch had fought back desperately. The doctor said he would have died within 30 minutes.</p><p>The last witness was a middle-aged Polish Army Captain named Edmund Żelawski. He had graduated from the Infantry Academy in St. Petersburg in 1904 and fought for the Czar against the Japanese. He had been decorated five times during the war against the Germans. He knew his Russian Nagants. He said the weapon was in working order and capable of being fired. Three empty cartridge casings — fired rounds — were discharged from the aforementioned revolver. The last cartridge went to an English Browning and would not have fired, but from the lack of hammer strike on the primer cap, it did not appear that the trigger had been pulled a fourth time.</p><p>The judges awarded the two experts each 50 marks for their testimony and announced that the judicial investigation was concluded. The Prosecution demanded that both defendants be sentenced to death. The Defense moved for the immediate acquittal of Zygmunt and for Jan’s case to be transferred to a civilian court, hopefully sparing him the death penalty. The judges retired to deliberate. Enoch’s family held their breath.</p><p>The three judges delivered their judgment at 10:00 that night.</p><p>They were only supposed to have two options; acquittal and release or guilt and summary execution. They found Jan guilty of murder and robbery. However, despite the gruesome autopsy details, the court decided to sentence him to life imprisonment and hard labor due to his “old age and impeccable character.”</p><p>They argued that the murder was “the result not so much of criminal instincts or impulses on the part of the accused — for had these existed, they would undoubtedly have found an opportunity to manifest themselves on numerous occasions throughout his long life — but rather of the severe material conditions in which the accused found himself, particularly following the loss of his horse.” In a rhetorical shrug, they also noted that, according to his brothers-in-law, Jan suffered from “low intellectual and moral development.”</p><p>This, despite testimony that he had been in prison for timber embezzlement in Russian times, was accused of horse theft in his home village, had told people he was going to buy a horse but admitted he had nowhere near enough money to purchase it, multiple witnesses confirming that he and his son approached four or five carters that day and asked them to drive them to multiple places, and others who directly contradicted the story about Enoch owing them change.</p><p>One area where Naumowicz and the judges could have pushed harder is on the getaway geography and timeline. It was twelve miles west from the crash site back to the Kupinski farm. Mapping their return trip shows them making a U-shape down one forest road, cutting across via the highway, and then heading back up the direction they had just come. The Grodno route added an extra ten miles to their journey — and if the weather had truly been bad enough for Jan to avoid Czarny Brod, like he said, there would have been no reason to have Enoch drop them off there in the first place. Without a horse, it would have taken them another four hours from there to reach Gruszki. Even the village headman and Jan’s brother-in-law agreed there was no reason to go that way.</p><p>Unless you needed to avoid Czarny Brod. Any villagers or passersby would have been the first ones to find the body, and Jan didn’t want to be anywhere near it when they did.</p><p>The judges also seemed disinterested in exactly how Jan had gotten from the cart all the way south to Skieblewo. If they had looked at a map, they might have noticed that his claim that he had trekked straight through the forest from the crash site to Krasne seemed unlikely given the time when he was arrested.</p><p>Enoch was last seen a little after noon. His body was found around two o’clock, close to Czarny Brod. Even if Jan had left right away and been sprinting the whole time, Krasne was eleven miles through the dense woods — four hours on foot for a young man in good conditions. Skieblewo was another six miles away, and Jan had been picked up before six o’clock. How had he done it? Had he really been in Krasne? Had someone helped him?</p><p>Jan had lied repeatedly to Jews, Catholics and police about where he lived, where he was traveling to, his court case, his name, even his age. He couldn’t be trusted to tell the truth about where he had been on Thursday or Saturday, much less about his motivations for the murder and horse theft. Despite hours to coordinate, he and his son couldn’t even get their stories straight on how much they had paid Enoch or their positioning on the wagon.</p><p>In the end, none of it mattered.</p><p>What could they have been thinking? A little context offers some critical insight. The Armistice happened in November 1918, with Poland declaring its re-establishment and independence the very same day. By mid-November of that year, the nation was trying not only raise an army, but also formalize its legal system.</p><p>The Suwalki Court had been established by Presidential decree in January 1919 but it wasn’t until after Roman’s stunt with the German that they secured a building, in late March. The members of the court weren’t officially appointed until April. The Germans had occupied the Suwalki area four years earlier and did not fully withdraw until that August, after the Paris conference where Roman called their bluff again.</p><p>Polish Summary Court judges had been stabbed and threatened at gunpoint by German soldiers during hearings, as well as arrested and kidnapped by the Lithuanian army, still steaming over its loss of territory following the war. The Suwalki Court’s jurisdiction over Augustow had only been announced in September, and its legitimacy with the people was still shaky at best.</p><p>The country was brand-new, surrounded by enemies from outside and within, fighting multiple wars with Lithuania and the Soviets while having to also pacify the peasants and tolerate/integrate the Jews, who were often treated with aloof suspicion at best and naked hatred and violence at worst. Religious Jews mainly kept to themselves and mostly spoke Yiddish; the younger radicals spoke Polish, Russian and German while marching and shouting slogans that disturbed both the educated elites and traditionalist masses. Jews were 10% of the new country’s population, and mutual prejudice between them and Christians extended across geography, class and educational lines. It was not a recipe for success.</p><p>Whatever he had done, Jan was still a Polish farmer. A Catholic. He had been to church that Sunday, supposedly. An old man. A widower. All he had wanted was a horse, and the Jew had already been dead anyway. Augustow was only 30% Jewish. How would the Christians in town, the soldiers in the barracks, and the peasants in the countryside react to them executing the old man? What if there were protests? What if there was retaliatory rioting against the Jews, as there had been elsewhere after communal violence? Were they willing to risk their careers for this? Or more blood?</p><p>Roman, for one, was not. He was ambitious and politically savvy; in less than two years he would leave the court to spend over a decade in government working with Pilsudski and his successors. Perhaps he tried to sway the others, or perhaps they needed no encouragement. Ultimately the question before them was actually quite simple: it wasn’t about guilt. It was about tribes. Was one of <em>them </em>really worth two of <em>theirs</em>? Late that night, they decided: No.</p><p>In its final judgment, the court argued that though Jan was guilty of murder, his behavior suggested a “crime of passion” rather than premeditation. After all, they reasoned, if he had <em>truly</em> intended to kill Enoch, why not just shoot him? No, they concluded, Kupinski must have thought he could overpower Enoch without any violence and had only <em>menaced</em> him with the gun, and Enoch, by daring to fight for his life, had essentially provoked his own murder. And if the father hadn’t known he was planning on killing the Jew until he did it, how could the son have known? In any event, “the Jew should have given the rest of the 5 marks, but he didn’t.”</p><p>5 marks. The court actually claimed to believe the story that the grisly killing had been over 5 marks- not the horse, the bridle, the wagon, or Enoch’s watch and money. Just 5 marks, the price of a loaf of bread, and apparently even that was Enoch’s fault, too.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ib6xaqbMFfRFM8-7QfYTSw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The pay list for the state’s witnesses- The six police officers received 6 marks each for two days of testimony plus travel expenses</figcaption></figure><p>Zygmunt was found guilty of receiving stolen property- an offense, the court noted, that did not fall under their jurisdiction. They recommended he be tried in a lower court, knowing full well that would never happen. He was released, and Jan was transferred into the custody of Suwalki prison and ordered to pay 300 marks in court costs. They adjourned at 10:25. Perhaps Naumowicz and Lutostanski shook hands and stiffly congratulated each other, each both a little shocked and slightly embarrassed. The lawyers and judges of the court went back north to Suwalki. Rivka walked thirteen blocks home, past the cursed square, her heart shattered for the second time in less than a month.</p><p>The court returned the horse to Rivka (who emphasized that her husband was a man of peace who would never hurt anyone), and awarded her 1500 marks damages. On paper. However due to the poverty of the Kupinskis, it appears that zero reparations ever actually occurred.</p><p>Given that she was now a widow with young children to support, aged 14, 12, 10, 8, 6, 2, and 2 months, it’s almost certain that Rivka sold the horse to help keep them all afloat. Her oldest son left for New York two years later, the only one from that branch to make it to America.</p><p>After the Golden Gates closed, all four remaining Lozdziejski sons went to Uruguay. One of them, <a href="https://andrewnusbaum.medium.com/moses-1941-the-ghosts-of-memory-a1e2032401cd">Moses</a>, fatefully decided to come back in 1932 after only four months. He was likely shot in 1941 in the forest with the other Jewish men in town. Rivka and her two daughters were killed the next year, along with Enoch’s youngest brother (Yankel, my mother’s namesake) and various cousins.</p><p>While the story of Enoch’s murder, trial, and verdict is appalling, in a roundabout way it helped save over half of his children from the Nazis. Without this violent event (and the trauma, poverty, and emigration that resulted from it), it’s quite possible that the other four children would have been murdered in the Augustow forest alongside poor Moses, and the last four or five generations of descendants in Israel, the U.S., and South America would never have been born. All over a man and his horse, who was just trying to catch one quick fare before supper.</p><p>The judges, lawyers and experts of the Suwalki Summary Court, so willing to fight for a new Poland but not for Enoch, were also not protected from the impacts of history. Wyrzykowski and Jawoworski died in the late 1930s and missed the next war. Sobolewski became head of both the Police School and Army Officer School in Warsaw, then devoted himself to studying modern forensics in Austria and Switzerland and bringing that knowledge back to Poland. He had a fatal heart attack in the middle of a lecture in 1937.</p><p>Naumowicz died in December 1939, living just long enough to see the fall of the new Polish republic into which he had invested so much time and effort. Lutostanski was arrested and died in Dachau in 1941; two years later the Nazis guillotined his 17–year-old son, a Boy Scout, for running an underground newspaper. There was a rumor his wife hid Jews in their house. Forty years later, while cleaning out the Lutostanski’s house in Suwalki after the widow’s funeral, a relative discovered someone’s mezuzah <a href="https://kolekcje.polin.pl/en/memorabilia-lutostanski-family-home">scroll</a> hidden inside one of her handkerchief’s.</p><p>Captain Żelawski stayed in the army. By 1940 he was a retired Lt. Colonel. That spring he was arrested by the Soviets with thousands of other Polish officers and shot in Katyn forest. His son, an army lieutenant and assistant in the Military Prosecutor’s Office, was executed at Kharkov soon afterwards.</p><p>Szygieł and his wife had six children. The couple moved to Siberia at the start of the war, then lived in East Africa and England before emigrating to the US in 1950 to join one of their daughters in Philadelphia. He died in Westchester, New York, in 1960, with five of his children living in America. His obituary said he worked as a bricklayer. It’s unclear whether anyone ever knew about his time in the Polish police force.</p><p>Roman, the President of the Court and Pilsudski’s close friend, became a regional governor the following year, then served seven years as Bialystok Province’s senator in Warsaw before returning to law before the war. He ended up needing all his skills to survive the Nazis and Soviets, barely escaping the fate that befell most Polish politicians and intelligentsia. He died a bitter old man in 1950s Warsaw, two years after the Communists spitefully revoked his 25-year-old notary license.</p><p>This year for Yom HaShoah, I lit a candle for all of my relatives, but especially for Moses (28), Rivka (55), Nechama (35), her husband Yitzhak Leib (40), and Sheinke (25) Lozdiejski of Augustow, and Jakow (45), Miriam (41), Moshe (18), Arie (15), and Tzvi (1) Lozdiejski of Stok, Poland.</p><p>And for Enoch, killed at 48, who, though he died more than 20 years before the rest of his family, was a victim of the same kind of opportunistic hatred, gleeful violence, and callous bureaucracy that the Nazis believed in, and which we still must always remember and fight against.</p><p>May their memories be a blessing and inspiration.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7887b892eaca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Moses- 1941- The Ghosts of Memory]]></title>
            <link>https://andrewnusbaum.medium.com/moses-1941-the-ghosts-of-memory-a1e2032401cd?source=rss-4449dce292d6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a1e2032401cd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genealogy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewish]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[holocaust]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrew Nusbaum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 30 Mar 2026 20:16:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-19T22:36:35.807Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/621/1*j8w5set440odQpXBEXu7Aw@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Old Moses with his wife Esther and my great-grandmother Serha, 1912. He would be dead within a year.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/585/1*TgJZ95LCxaQHw1xcT--Dog@2x.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/585/1*Y_SLe-Kq0GYntRtE4i5ajA@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Young Moses with his friends and the town rabbi , 1931.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*JqNmbRZPfbg7272M7IGD9g@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>The only surviving picture of the Grosse Shul. Its dimensions were recorded as 210 feet long, 120 feet wide, and over 30 feet tall.</em></p><p>Many cultures have deep connections to names and naming traditions. Whereas Jews from Spain, North Africa and the Middle East named children after living relatives, the custom in Eastern European Jewish communities developed a little differently. They feared that if young children were given the same names as their elders, the angel of death or the evil eye would become tempted or confused and take a child to the other side instead of an older relative whose time had come. To avoid the problem entirely, the rabbis of Ashkenaz developed a novel solution: to only name children after deceased relatives.</p><p>I am named for my grandmother Ann, who died two years before I was born. Ann was born in Brooklyn. Aside from a few international vacations, she spent her entire life in New York. She had two children, four grandchildren, and as of today, two great-grandchildren.</p><p>And she easily could have never existed.</p><p>My mother grew up knowing she had an international family, hearing stories about her mother and grandmother writing letters to relatives abroad. When I was younger, I thought that bit of family trivia was special and even slightly exotic. I now know that it was not due to any particular affinity for Argentina or Scotland, but rather a function of American nativism and immigration restrictions.</p><p>Ann’s father Benjamin came through Ellis Island in 1908 at age 15. Her mother Serha (pronounced Sarah, but defiantly spelled against the American grain) came a few years later in 1912, age 17. Benjamin worked as a sweatshop presser and rented a room with a younger brother he had brought over. Serha lived with one of her brothers and an overbearing sister in law who treated her like a servant. The two met and Serha latched on to Benjamin as her ticket out of her brother’s house. Hopefully there was at least a little romance, too.</p><p>Benjamin and Serha both had large families- he was one of ten siblings and she was one of eight. Benjamin had his brother in New York and a sister in Chicago but the rest of his family were back in Poland. Serha’s family had spread across Europe, possibly suggesting that her fishmonger father Moses was more economically successful than Benjamin’s father, who was a tailor. By the 1920s, in addition to her mother and several siblings still in Poland, Serha had two more brothers in Liverpool, a sister in Glasgow, and nieces and nephews in Paris.</p><p>Benjamin and Serha were from neighboring provinces in north-east Poland. His village of Wyszkow was 50 miles from Warsaw while she had lived further north, in a market town called Augustow near the modern-day Lithuanian border. The region was known as Lita in Yiddish, and its Jews were called Litvaks. Though the two had grown up only 100 miles away from each other, many relatives back home would have considered theirs a mixed marriage. Polish Jews, known as Poylishers, spoke a different variety of Yiddish, were considered less intellectual than Litvaks, and even preferred gefilte fish with sugar over pepper, but the largest difference would have been in their religious customs.</p><p>In the late 1700s many Eastern European Jews had become attracted to a religious populist movement called Hasidism, whose wonder rabbis emphasized serving God through joy and simple acts of faith. Within a few generations, the fervor of these “pious ones” had spread across Ukraine and Poland, complete with its own prayerbook and customs. Benjamin had grown up in a Hasidic family and his older brother was active in his local neighborhood synagogue, or shteibel.</p><p>The Jews of Lita, however, remained steadfast in their reputation for piety and Talmudic scholarship, even taking on the nickname of Misnagdim, or opponents, of the new movement. If the Hasidic Jews created cults of personality around their charismatic rabbis and rituals, the Litvaks did the same with their yeshivas, prestigious religious academies where boys as young as 13 studied ancient texts of Jewish law for up to eight hours a day.</p><p>In Litvak society, education was the ultimate status marker, and whenever possible all boys were sent to school beginning at age three. Any with an aptitude for memorization and sitting still were encouraged further. If they could afford it or showed particular promise, they would leave their homes to go live with host families in yeshiva towns and continue their studies until they reached marriage age, when they would hopefully gain jobs as rabbis, scholars or religious professionals. The figure of the skeptical, acerbic Litvak eventually became an archetype within Jewish folklore, always on hand to offer a dry quip to bookend an otherwise miraculous tale.</p><p>By the late 1800s Augustow was a town of about 10,000, about forty percent Jewish. It stood on the edge of a massive forest that stretched for hundreds of miles, as well as a canal connecting two major rivers and a railway line. It had been founded by and named for one of the kings of Poland in the 1550s and its town crest proudly featured the royal seal.</p><p>People made a living from lumber, trade, and the nine nearby lakes, one of which had supposedly been dug in a single night by a sorcerer with the help of dark spirits. The lakes were so plentiful that it was said every Jewish household was able to eat fish for the Sabbath, even the poor. Because the town had joined in the short-lived Polish rebellion against Russia, they also had an army garrison of Czarist soldiers.</p><p>Tuesdays and Fridays were market days, when Catholic Poles would come in from their farms and villages to sell animals and produce and buy goods from the Jews. Catholics also came in on Sundays to attend one of the two city churches, and often bought a challah to take home for Sunday supper. Four times a year there were large fairs, where traveling Jewish merchants and Polish farmers from miles around the district would come to exchange delicious food, valuable fabrics, needed necessities or an occasional treat. At a time when Jews were forbidden from owning land or farming and when most Poles still worked the land, it was a decently beneficial relationship. Over 90% of all industry in the city, including three flour mills, two brick factories, two breweries, and two sawmills, were owned by Jews.</p><p>In March of 1881, the Czar was killed by terrorists in Saint Petersburg. It happened to fall on Purim, the Jewish equivalent of Mardi Gras, when people traditionally gather and rejoice. While the Poles openly celebrated, the Jews stayed indoors and worried. Back then Augustow was about a quarter Russian, including the army soldiers. The Jews were all told to report to the main synagogue, or Grosse Shul, the next day for morning prayers.</p><p>The Grosse Shul, a tall white brick building with large stained glass windows and room for 2000 people, was only used on Sabbaths and holy days. It had a three-story Torah ark whose doors turned on giant hinges in unison as if by magic. It was well-known that the spirits of pious Jews would gather there at night, so the caretaker was always careful to knock before unlocking the front door to give them time to disappear.</p><p>The next morning the shul was almost bursting with people. Men stood on the ground floor while women and children were up in the balcony. There, under the threatening eyes of Russian police and government officials, the town rabbi opened the magnificent ark, unrolled a Torah scroll to serve as a witness, then recited a loyalty oath to the new Czar, first in Russian and then Hebrew. The crowd repeated after him, word for word. They were told anyone who refused or mispronounced any of the oath would be fined or jailed. Moses and his wife Esther would have been there, along with at least two of their young children, barely comprehending what was going on or why these intimidating soldiers had invaded their sanctuary.</p><p>Augustow was relatively fortunate; Lita did not have a history of violent antisemitism. Their local Christians were more subtle. Since they were on the edge of the forest, most of the town was built of wood. That summer it experienced five devastating fires in a single month, conveniently sparing the Christian houses while leaving thousands of Jews homeless, including the rabbi and his family. Eventually this led to the creation of a Jewish night patrol as well as a separate Jewish fire brigade. Moses Montefiore, the wealthy Jewish philanthropist in England, sent financial aid to help with rebuilding, and many Augustow Jews hung his photograph on their walls in gratitude.</p><p>Augustow was steeped in Litvak tradition, and its rabbis corresponded with some of the greatest personalities of the yeshiva world in Kovno, Radin and Vilna. When a group of Hasidim tried to open their own shteibel in town, it quickly fizzled and was taken over by a yeshiva group. However as the 20th century dawned, many of the youth began redirecting their passion and energy from religious study towards politics, particularly Socialist and Zionist groups. A rabbi’s son was just as likely to become an anarchist or Hebrew poet as a yeshiva student- and sometimes all three.</p><p>The only known picture of Moses, taken with Esther and their daughter Serha before she left for America, shows him dressed as a simple religious Jew, with dark shirt and pants, a tall skullcap, a sharp nose, and a long flowing beard. Moses may have sold fish, but at least one grandson was fortunate enough to attend a yeshiva, which likely would have given him immense satisfaction, had he been there to see it.</p><p>A year after saying goodbye to Serha, Moses was dead. According to a letter from one of his grandsons, he was “robbed and murdered on a journey by road,” possibly on his way to market. There was no word on whether the murderer was ever identified, much less caught, nor any examination of how this trauma affected the family. His oldest son Enoch-Isaac dutifully named the next grandson after him, as per Ashkenazi tradition.</p><p>Augustow was only 50 miles from the German territory of East Prussia, on the Baltic Coast. During the war between the Czar and the Kaiser, it became a strategic location on the Eastern Front. Throughout the high holidays of 1914 it saw a fierce battle that lasted weeks and ended with a Russian bayonet charge through the forest that killed 600 Germans. In February the Germans counterattacked. 500,000 soldiers spent three weeks fighting each other, killing and maiming tens of thousands in the slushy forest mud while the town suffered artillery strikes and fires.</p><p>Ultimately the Czar’s men withdrew and the Kaiser’s men occupied the town. By the end of the war almost half the town’s Jews had left, never to return. Still, the three year German occupation, while strict, felt like an improvement over the Russians. They even brought electricity.</p><p>In 1919 a new Poland was created, after over 120 years of foreign occupation and partition by its neighbors. It struggled to define its national and political identity. It was economically depressed, with a seemingly endless web of cultural, class and ideological divisions: there were five different religious denominations, six spoken languages, and ten major political parties. The largest one was affiliated with the far-right Nationalist Democrats, or Endecs, who openly stoked Polish resentment against the Jews as a political strategy and aggressively targeted them for harassment and violence.</p><p>The Jews, about 2.8 million strong and ten percent of the population, were also divided. A dizzying array of political parties competed for their hearts and minds, each with their own newspapers, youth groups, songs, theater troupes, and meeting spaces: Socialists, Bundists, Communists, Zionists, and others. The religious spectrum ran all the way from assimilationist Poles of Mosaic persuasion to the Orthodox Agudas Yisroel, who treated their rabbinical leaders like celebrities and their directives like holy orders.</p><p>The first few years of independence were chaotic and violent times, especially in the east. Poland, Lithuania, and the Soviets all pushed for territory and advantage, knowing that final borders would come at someone’s expense. The forests of Augustow again filled with the sounds of gunshots. Most of Lita, including Augustow, ended up in Poland, but about 200,000 Litvak Jews now found themselves Lithuanians, and communities with centuries of dialogue and family relationships began to be cut off by borders and governments.</p><p>Simultaneously, 500 Jews were killed in violent pogroms, or anti-Jewish riots, in the first two years of Polish statehood. That was considered a low number. In neighboring Ukraine and Belarus, the total was closer to 150,000.</p><p>The family was not untouched by this violence; one of the dead was Serha’s older brother <a href="https://andrewnusbaum.medium.com/enoch-1919-justice-denied-7887b892eaca">Enoch</a> in Augustow, robbed and murdered by two Polish farmers in the forest in November 1919, his horse and valuables stolen and his head smashed in. The men had been caught within a day and put on trial by the new Suwalki District Court of the Polish Republic. The three Polish judges took an entire day and most of the evening, questioning 27 witness in all, before sentencing one to life imprisonment and acquiting the other. They returned the horse and ordered a hefty fine but the farmers were cash-poor and had no way to pay. Enoch’s family — his wife Rivka, his elderly mother, and his seven young children — were left emotionally devastated and economically ruined.</p><p>The Chief of State was a popular war hero, Marshal Jozef Pilsudski, frustrated by a Constitution which gave lots of power to the Parliament to prevent his complete dominance of government. Given that the Parliament was dominated by the Endecs, most Jews cast their lot with Pilsudski.</p><p>The Marshal resigned in 1922, the same year my grandmother was born back in New York. His successor, a high-born engineer with a swooping mustache who angrily defended the Jews against the Endecs, was gunned down just days after taking office by one of their supporters. He was followed by the Minister of the Interior, a former professor who seemed helplessly unable to wrangle the constant battling between the disparate parties in Parliament.</p><p>In 1926, stymied at the seemingly intractable gap between the socialist left and the quasi-fascist right, Pilsudski decided to try a third option: he led a coup against the government and heavily amended the Constitution in his favor. The Jews continued to support him as he legalized Jewish primary schools and defended his vision of a multi-ethnic Poland as had existed for hundreds of years. Pilsudski’s nationalist “Healing” movement, which now dominated the parliament, created a cult of personality around him and aggressively worked to keep the Endecs out of power. Political parties had led to chaos. Pilsudski was officially an independent, as were his men. Their faction was called the Nonpartisan Bloc for Cooperation with the Government.</p><p>There were three new governments over the next three years, culminating in a massive protest that attracted tens of thousands to Krakow and led to opposition leaders being jailed and imprisoned. Again, faced with the Endecs as the main alternative, most Jews sighed, continued to support Pilsudski, and looked for chances to emigrate.</p><p>By then, The United States was off the table. The 1924 Johnson-Reed Act, designed in concert with prominent eugenicists, had set punishing quotas for immigrants from Eastern and Southern Europe, directly targeting Italians and Jews. On the floor of Congress, its sponsors openly bragged about setting the quotas at 2% of every country’s residents in the United States, based not even on the most recent census, but the one from 30 years earlier, before the major European migrations. Poland‘s annual quota was set at about 6,000, Russia’s at 2,000. Each were home to 3 million Jews. The first year after the quotas were set, Jewish immigration dropped by 90%. Enoch-Isaac’s oldest son just barely managed to squeeze through before the Golden Gates were shut.</p><p>During the Pilsudski years, two more sons had left for the other side of the world, Montevideo, Uruguay, to go into business and escape Polish antisemitism. Uruguay had been home to a small Sephardic Jewish community since the 1700s. Ashkenazim began arriving from Europe in the early 1900s, and by the 1930s their combined numbers had grown to some 30,000.</p><p>Young Moses was the middle child. He had lost his father Enoch when he was six, along with his innocence, economic stability, and any trust in the new Polish justice system. With his three brothers in the Americas, he was now the man at home.</p><p>Like many of his peers, Moses joined a youth group, a circle of about 25 yeshiva boys called Tiferet Bachurim, the splendor of young men. (A bachur was also slang for a yeshiva student.) Tiferet was affiliated with the Religious Zionist Mizrahi party and the boys met regularly at the town rabbi’s house for prayers, study and discussions.</p><p>A picture of the group taken the year Moses left shows him in a dapper newsboy cap and suit, standing near the rabbi and his son, who probably served as a surrogate family for him. If he was going to go anywhere, Moses probably would have preferred to go to Palestine, but visas were hard to come by.</p><p>He arrived in Uruguay the winter of 1931. He immediately became homesick and fell into a depression. He was an 18 year old boy who looked younger than his age, an aspiring Yiddish journalist facing a life in exile. His family, friends and rabbi were all back in Poland. His brothers tried to convince him to stay but he was determined. After less than six months, Moses returned home.</p><p>Augustow had developed a reputation as a spa and tourist town after the war, and there are photos of the Polish President visiting that same year and taking his yacht down the canal. At the same time, local Endecs had begun boycotting Jewish businesses and attacking people on the streets. The President smiled for the cameras and studiously avoided any Jewish areas on his trip.</p><p>In 1935 Marshal Pilsudski, the father of the Second Polish Republic, died. For nine years, he had kept the country together through a semi-benign authoritarianism. No one knew what to expect next.</p><p>Five months later, Poland held new Parliamentary elections. Shortly before Pilsudski’s death, the Nonpartisan Bloc had written a new constitution even more explicitly in its favor and giving them even more of an electoral advantage. Over a dozen opposition parties boycotted the election in protest and less than half of eligible Poles voted that fall. The Nonpartisan Bloc took more than 85% of the vote.</p><p>The principles of the opposition had been entirely correct, but their decision to boycott the election would have dire consequences. The Nonpartisan Bloc took the entire upper chamber. The lower chamber had 206 seats. The Nonpartisan Bloc and Ukrainian nationalists took 200. The Jewish community took 3. The last half of the 1930s would be hard times for the Jews of Poland.</p><p>Having secured their mandate, the Nonpartisan Bloc began trying to make peace with the strident right wing nationalist opposition that had sat out the elections. The Endecs and their allies, the Camp of National Unity, called for “economic struggle” to break the supposed Jewish hold on the economy, and the Nonpartisan Bloc agreed.</p><p>On paper, this “merely” meant a crushing nationwide boycott. Unofficially, it gave government sanction to violent demonstrations that lasted for months or even years.</p><p>When asked about the chaos, the new Prime Minister infamously replied, “It is forbidden to beat the Jews. But to boycott? Ovshem- of course.” To many, this became known as the Ovshem policy, and it came as the government seemed to be cracking down on Jewish life in practically every sphere.</p><p>Next the Polish parliament banned kosher slaughter, ostensibly on animal cruelty grounds. Polish ministers discussed buying Madagascar and using it as a “dumping ground” for Poland’s “excess Jews.” Universities became hotbeds of violence and discrimination, including the segregated “Ghetto Bench” where Jews were forced to sit or stand. Pogroms, not seen in over a decade, began to occur again across the country, with higher and higher casualties.</p><p>Once Poland had been called “The Paradise of the Jews.” It wasn’t feeling that way anymore.</p><p>Moses’ brother Chaim was the baby of the family, born a month before their father was killed. He had studied at the prestigious Suwalki yeshiva before leaving for Montevideo in 1936. He was fortunate to get a visa; two years after Moses’ return there had been a coup in Uruguay which began restricting immigration.</p><p>Two months before Chaim’s departure, there was a pogrom in Suwalki, only made bearable by the fact that Jewish youths wielding weapons managed to keep the mobs from killing anyone. Chaim left feeling lucky but conflicted: his mother Ryfka, brother Moses, and sisters Nechama and Sheinke stayed behind in Augustow.</p><p>Serha continued to write to relatives in England and Poland, as well as now Chaim in Uruguay. The children and cousins grew older. Encouraged by her parents, who regretted their lack of education and fluency in English, Ann graduated high school and went to night classes for bookkeeping and stenography.</p><p>Chaim followed in his brother’s footsteps and also became a writer. He already knew Polish and Yiddish, along with Hebrew and ancient Aramaic from his yeshiva days. He picked up Spanish quickly and found work as a Yiddish-Spanish journalist. He and the other Polish Jewish refugees anxiously read newspapers and listened to fuzzy radio broadcasts while worrying about friends and family back home.</p><p>In April 1937, Moses was arrested. A city health inspector had come into the shop where he worked as a butcher’s assistant and tried to confiscate two quarters of veal. They were missing a stamp which made them illegal. Before he could leave, 25 year old Moses had twisted the man’s arms, grabbed back the meat, and was chopping it up on the block, telling him to drop dead. At his trial later that year, he told the court that the inspector had made up the claim after the shop stopped giving him free meat on credit. The judge rejected his testimony, calling him “evasive, untruthful, and malicious” and sentenced him to 10 months in prison and a 40 zloty fine (about $180 modern U.S. dollars) in court fees.</p><p>Moses was nothing if not determined. He appealed to the high court. In spring 1938, the Vilnius appeals court delivered a split decision: his guilty verdict stood, but his sentence and fine were suspended for three years.</p><p>He did not have long to enjoy his victory. Germany invaded Poland in September 1939. That week Chaim saw in a newspaper that Augustow had been bombed by the Luftwaffe the first day of the war. Out of his town of 12,000, was anything left? The Grosse Shul, the Study House, the Market Square, the lakes? The people?</p><p>The Polish army fought the Germans for three weeks until the Soviets moved in. Unable to withstand a two front attack, the Poles’ defenses collapsed and they surrendered in early October. The two invaders divided the country in half. The Soviets took everything east of Warsaw, including Augustow. The Jews considered them the lesser of two evils: they nationalized everything but also allowed Jewish organizations and worship to continue, while giving protection from the Nazi death squads then roaming through the rest of Poland.</p><p>For two years the Jews of the East watched as their former country was carved up and its Jews pushed into ghettos. Chaim recalled receiving a single letter from his family, “on thin dark paper with a thin dark envelope, a sign of the new order. It was hard to make anything from a letter like that.”</p><p>In spring 1941, Hitler invaded Eastern Poland, and the widespread killing resumed. In June, Nazi soldiers captured Augustow. They established a police force of locals, ethnic German Poles. There was no effort to save or protect the town’s Jews. The Nazis began shooting Jews in the forest, first in small groups of 20 to 30, then 200, then 300. For two months, the Jews held their breath and hoped the worst was over.</p><p>In mid-August the Nazis issued a work order for all Jewish men between ages 13 and 60. 1,600 of them, including Moses, were marched into the Grosse Shul and then locked in. The same building, haunted by ghosts and memory, where, 60 years earlier, his grandfather and namesake had been forced to pledge loyalty to a Czar that hated him. Over three days, the men were taken out in batches of 200 to the forest where they were stripped, then shot, their bodies falling into a massive trench.</p><p>What was going through Moses’ mind at the end? Was he wishing he had made a different choice ten years earlier? Imagining the life he could have had in the South American sun? Thinking of his brothers, who would get to live, and of his mother and sisters, who likely would not?</p><p>Or maybe he thought of none of those things. Maybe he had tried to push all those regrets and wishes out of his mind, and concentrated on the leaves and the birds, their song softly mingling with the men’s prayers before the gunshots rang out.</p><p>None of the men from the forest came back. Their bodies were buried, unmarked and unmourned. That same week, the remaining Jews were confined to a ghetto on the edge of the city, 2000 people locked behind barbed wire fences into 13 blocks of tiny one-room houses built for sawmill workers. The ghetto was mostly women and children; the 200 men left were elders, skilled workers, and a few Grosse Shul survivors who had managed to jump out of a broken window.</p><p>The ghetto was horribly overcrowded with as many as 24 people crammed into a single shack. Within months the disease rate exploded and the Germans had to establish both a hospital and a cemetery inside the fence. The ghetto was small enough that it only needed six Jewish policemen and two Germans to guard it. The local Polish police did the rest.</p><p>All Jews had to wear yellow stars and were used for slave labor. Young women were sent off to work on railways and agricultural projects every month. Unskilled laborers were forced to chop logs or repair roads. Craftsmen were put to work for the German army. Many were taken to work at one of the sawmills, which had been renamed for Hermann Göring. Guards regularly beat them and confiscated any food they tried to smuggle in.</p><p>In November 1942, the ghetto was liquidated. Healthy people were sent to another ghetto to the south. The sick and old were locked inside the hospital and burned alive. By January 1943, the last of the Augustow Jews had been sent to Auschwitz and Treblinka, where most were immediately murdered in gas chambers.</p><p>Sadly there are no precise records of what happened to Chaim’s mother or sisters. He later wrote, “We can’t know the exact place where our relatives fell, but what’s the difference? In the end, not one Jew was left.”</p><p>In the first six months after the invasion of the Soviet Union, over half a million Jews were murdered by Nazi death squads and local collaborators. In Ukrainian towns like Kamenets-Podolski and Babi Yar, as many as 30,000 were shot over two or three days by SS, German police, and Ukrainian auxiliaries. Over 2 years, the Holocaust by Bullets would claim an estimated 2 million Jewish lives.</p><p>Augustow had boasted a proud Jewish community for four hundred years. In less than two it was erased from the earth, like thousands of others across Eastern Europe. The town had five synagogues, a dozen prayer halls, a half dozen Jewish political groups, and a 6000-book communal Jewish library. All were destroyed. In a final act of violence, the Jewish cemetery was dug up and the stones used to pave the sidewalks. Even the dead would have no peace.</p><p>In the summer of 1943, the Germans made one last use of the forest. They had found Jews in the area who had converted to Christianity years before the war. Nazi racial purity said this wasn’t enough to save them and so they too were added to the forest’s many ghosts. Then they made a group of Sonderkommando prisoners dig up and burn all the bodies they could find, as many as 5,000.</p><p>A handful of Augustovers survived and returned after the war. In accounts written decades later, they recalled the small moments that left them shaking in rage and horror. Yes, it was the Nazis who had desecrated their cemetery, but they couldn’t get over how their Polish neighbors, who had grown up with them and their parents, seemed so unbothered by walking on the stones, and showed no interest in removing them. Over and over, they heard the phrase “You survived?”, but not said with joy, but surprise, suspicion, and even disappointment.</p><p>That summer the Soviets took their turn exploring the forest’s deadly potential, executing 500 anti-Communist Polish militia who had also fought the Nazis. They too, would have no graves.</p><p>Chaim settled in Mexico and devoted his life to the shrinking world of Yiddish journalism. He became editor of a newspaper before he was 25. He worked for the Jewish Agency and traveled through Latin America reporting on Jewish issues. He wrote long letters to his cousin Ann and offered to be her tour guide if she ever came to visit. He also followed the paper trail of the butchers of Augustow: one Nazi received four years for murdering 100 Jews. Another was sentenced to life but it was commuted to 12 years. One man got 15 years. At least one, who had ordered the burning of the bodies, was hanged.</p><p>Twenty years after the war, as the Augustover survivors began to reach retirement age, they began working on a Yizkor book. The book, they decided, would be the ultimate monument for their family and friends. They would live on in their memories and their stories. In 1966 the book was published in Israel. It listed fewer than 200 natives of Jewish Augustow still alive. Most were in Israel. Only seven were listed in Mexico.</p><p>Chaim contributed an article to the book, where he said, “It’s impossible to forget the Jews of our town who, each in their own way, symbolized Jewish life in Poland, with all its bright and dark aspects.” Chaim memorialized the poor but dignified people of his community, classmates from his school days, and he also briefly- painfully, for how could it not be?- mentioned Moses.</p><p>“For a few months, my third brother had also been in Uruguay. But it seems he was destined to fall victim to the Nazi’s slaughter.”</p><p>What a heartbreaking thought to have lived with, much less committed to paper. The belief that half his family had been destined to die and the other half live. What kind of guilt must that have prompted?</p><p>Chaim concluded his reminiscences by echoing the call from the book editors: “May this publication serve as a gravestone on the tomb of the dead.” For those who knew what had happened to the actual Jewish gravestones of Augustow, the symbolism was unmistakable. After twenty-five years, Chaim had buried his family with words, not earth.</p><p>Chaim had a family and eventually moved to Israel, where he passed away in the late 90s. He named his two daughters after his mother and one of his sisters. Ann did the same, naming both of her daughters for murdered relatives as well.</p><p>In 2013 two of Chaim’s children visited Augustow. Unlike other Polish towns who had leaned into Jewish heritage tourism, Augustow seemed disinterested. There was a dairy factory where the Study House had stood and the Jewish cemetery contained only a few smashed stones that had been reassembled alongside a monument to the town’s Jews erected in the 1990s. When they found it, the only sign anyone had been there were some sad-looking plastic flowers, piles of liquor bottles on the ground, and a plaque covered with years of half-erased swastikas.</p><p>Looking for Chaim’s childhood home, they found elderly Poles in the house next door. They eagerly asked a young woman inside if her relatives knew anything about their family. She sent her mother to go talk to them. After a long 30 minutes she returned.</p><p>“They say there were no people there. Only trees.” The young people looked away, embarrassed. Chaim’s children were shocked, then slowly understood. At least with the older generation, there was no one there for them to talk to.</p><p>The residents of the city had no room for its ghosts. Jewish Augustow, if it continued to exist at all, was only as an idea- no longer even a memory, but merely an abstraction of one.</p><p>Memory can be incredibly powerful, to either remember, or erase. What memories are we willing to listen to or uncover? Whose do we try to forget, and why? How do we both protect and share the stories that matter most to us, and without monopolizing space or truth? What do we owe to our ancestors and namesakes? How can we best honor them?</p><p>In a time when history and truth feel under attack, I think to my family’s own past, and the kind of future I want for my own children, along with everyone else’s. I hope in some small way, these stories help us get one step closer.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a1e2032401cd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Parsha Korah: The Need for Humility]]></title>
            <link>https://andrewnusbaum.medium.com/parsha-korah-the-need-for-humility-a817b8340ef2?source=rss-4449dce292d6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a817b8340ef2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dvar-torah]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[judaism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewish]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sermons]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrew Nusbaum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 27 Apr 2025 07:40:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-27T07:54:08.420Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Written July 2018</em></p><p>This week we read of <a href="https://www.myjewishlearning.com/torah-portions/parashat-korach/">Korah’s</a> famous rebellion against his cousin Moses. Korah is often seen as an archetype of demagoguery, and the rabbis of the Talmud delight in expanding on his punishments (one account says he was swallowed down to She’ol and was doomed to spend eternity repeating, “Moses was right! The Torah is Truth!”), or explaining just what was so terrible about his revolt. To me, that tradition has so emphatically cast Korah to the margins suggests that there was something threatening about his story. Indeed, the heart of the rebellion seems to be a question with very modern echoes: by what authority do Moses and Aaron have the right to be leaders of the Hebrews?</p><p>At first glance, the answer to this question seems obvious: Moses and Aaron’s authority comes from God, end of story, case closed. However Korah is not satisfied: in a likely reference to God’s earlier command that the Hebrews are to be “a kingdom of priests and a holy nation” (Ex. 19:6), Korah retorts that “all the community are holy… and the Lord in in their midst. Why then do you raise yourself above the Lord’s congregation?” (Num. 16:3)</p><p>To many rabbinical commentators, this smacks of chutzpah, and thereby vindicates Korah’s subsequent punishment. Korah, we are told, is not sincere in his protests — he is not <em>actually</em> concerned about the larger argument that all of Israel is holy or in reimagining the priestly/clan structure along more communal divisions of power. Rather, they argue that Korah was motivated by a desire for personal power. Additionally, Korah not only challenged political authority but also spiritual authority — questioning Moses’ right to lead the people, as well as Aaron’s right to serve as High Priest and offer sacrifices to God.</p><p>Rashi imagines a dialogue between Moses and his cousin which focuses on the fact that God, not Moses, created the world with inherent boundaries: just as day is divided from night, so too there are divisions between the Jewish people, by caste and by position. The Medieval <em>Sefer Ha-Chinuch</em> agrees, pointing out that two mitzvot contained in Parsha Korah are that Kohanim and Levites are not to do each other’s work; it goes so far as to argue that Levites who did the work of a Kohen (or did work assigned to another Levite) might be struck down by God! The argument seems to be that Aaron’s position (and those of subsequent generations) was decided and conferred by God, not his brother, and that by rebelling against the “divine order,” Korah threatens the entire system the Jewish people (and by association, God) are using to create order from chaos.</p><p>Some may find this argument compelling, and depending on your perspective, there is much to support it. After all, we are told repeatedly throughout the Torah that Moses and Aaron’s roles were ordained by God — with little mention of Korah or his followers. And there is something very comforting about the image of a world created with innate boundaries and roles for its inhabitants. However this argument, to me at least, falls a bit flat. I have always been troubled by the lack of engagement with Korah’s main point, one increasingly resonant today. If indeed, as we claim Judaism teaches, all people are holy, is there not an element of contradiction in the concept of having specific people be leaders and others not?</p><p>The answer, I believe, has to do with further exploring exactly what leadership, as well as holiness, means.</p><p>Israeli philosopher Yeshayahu Leibowitz (1903–1994) argued that Judaism has had a long-running debate as to whether holiness was acquired or intrinsic: do we <em>become</em> holy by following divine instruction or are we <em>inherently</em> holy by being made by God, in God’s image? Leibowitz convincingly claimed that both strains have authentic roots in our tradition, but also eloquently illustrated that the challenge of the second approach is its potential for self-satisfaction, and thus inertia: if I become overly convinced in my inherent holiness, I may decide that no further growth is needed. Similarly, I may become so satisfied with the accomplishments or merits of my specific group that I lose sight of the personal work that I am required to do in order to be a good person. As Rabbi Yehuda Amital (1924–2010) wrote, “being holy is more than reciting a slogan or using simplistic catchphrases.”</p><p>This is not to say that there are not pitfalls in the first approach, either: it is certainly possible to become equally hyper-focused on the need to acquire holiness through mitzvot (and, by extension, to view oneself or others as deficient if they do not practice the way you do, or feel that they should). However in the end Leibowitz seems to be more comfortable with a Judaism that views holiness as a process or a goal, rather than starting with the view that it is already a fait-accompli.</p><p>For all the invective thrown Korah’s way, there are a few voices in the tradition that defend him. The Mei Ha-Shiloach and the Netziv, two giants from the Hasidic and Yeshiva streams respectively, see some merit in Korah.</p><p>The Mei Ha-Shiloach (Mordechai Yosef Leiner, 1801–1854), a Hasidic iconoclast who was a peer and close follower of the Kotzker Rebbe, greatly admired Korah, even commenting that some of his teachers had referred to him as “Grandfather Korah.” The Mei Ha-Shiloach said that Korah was fundamentally correct in his point about the entire people being holy, and that his only error was in not recognizing that the people would not be ready for such a utopian equality until the days of the Messiah.</p><p>Rather than focusing on the personality of Korah, the Netziv (Naftali Zvi Berlin, 1816–1893), a famous leader of the Volozhin Yeshiva, turned his attention to the understated footnote to the Korah story: after Korah and his followers are killed, the parsha tells us that God directed Moses to take their fire pans and hammer them into plating for the altar. Why? The text says, “once they have been used for offering to the Lord, they have become sacred.” (Num. 17:3) Unlike other commentators who say that anything used for worship is sacred automatically, or that this is meant to be a warning to other would-be challengers to Moses, Aaron or God’s authority, the Netziv sees this as a clue to Korah and his followers’ true intentions: not power-hungry cynics or rebels, but men with a sincere desire to serve God, who chafed at what (to them) may have seemed like unnecessary or unjustified intermediaries.</p><p>While most of the tradition’s backing of Moses over Korah may seem like a simple case of history being written by the victors, it may also illustrate some of the qualities the Torah is suggesting are important in leadership. When Moses is confronted by his cousin, his first reaction is not to become angry or argue, but to “fall on his face,” interpreted as consulting with God for guidance. He then tries to reason with his cousin, as well as attempts to meet separately with the other leaders of the rebellion. When these appeals are rejected, rather than muster his followers to attack, as in the Golden Calf, or castigate them as he did with the spies, Moses tries something counter-intuitive: he gives Korah what he wants.</p><p>Remember, Korah’s claim, at least in part, is that he is as qualified to offer sacrifices as Aaron. This is quite a bold claim given that just a few chapters ago, the entire people witnessed the death of Nadav and Abihu for offering a non-sanctioned sacrifice — and these were Aaron’s own sons, Kohanim who theoretically would have potentially been in line to become future high priests! And what does Moses do? In an early echo of Elijah’s duel with the priests of Baal, he essentially challenges Korah to a sacrifice contest with Aaron — a contest Korah loses.</p><p>Some have argued that Moses sets Korah up, knowing that his sacrifice will not be accepted and that it will end in death — something the Torah suggests by having Moses demand in advance that God only punish Korah’s followers, and not the entire community. However the other way to look at it is that, after all other options have been exhausted, Moses effectively steps aside and simply lets the events happen. Rather than fight or argue, he leaves the decision up to God. One important quality of being a leader is knowing when to fight, and when to step aside and let things take their course. Another quality is knowing <em>how</em> to fight. Just as the rabbis criticize Korah for his ridicule of Moses, they praise Moses for keeping his temper. The Talmud says that one of the things the world depends on is a person restraining themselves during a dispute. Quite a contrast when compared to our current discourse!</p><p>The rabbis of the Talmud use the story of Korah attacking Moses as a classic example of an argument “not for the sake of Heaven,” contrasting it with Hillel and Shammai, who strongly disagreed with each other but still recognized that their debates were happening within a productive context of respect. Hillel and Shammai were opponents, but not enemies. Their goal was to better understand the word of God and his wishes for how the Jewish people should live. Korah, the rabbis argue, was fighting for a dictatorship at best and total anarchy at worst. Whether we agree with this interpretation, there is certainly no question that issues of what respectful debate looks like seem incredibly timely to us today.</p><p>Regardless of one’s political positions, it is clear that we are living in a time where the concept of respectful (much less productive) debate seems not only passé, but almost quaint. Regardless of whether one focuses on the world stage, national politics, local news, or intra-Jewish debates, the trend seems to be overwhelmingly stacked towards shrillness, venom and negativity. Rather than argue for why a position is right or explaining why an argument is factually correct, we see talking heads taking potshots at each other. To paraphrase Leibowitz, demagoguery did not die with the sons of Korah.</p><p>The seventh Chabad rebbe, Menachem Mendel Schneerson (1902–1994), argued that Korah’s primary problem was envy: he did not like the natural hierarchy that God had created. But, the rebbe argued, the fact that Korah did not like his place on the spiritual ladder did not change the fact that the ladder existed, anymore than night and day exist. The Mei Ha-Shiloach, on the other hand, saw Korah as anticipating the Messianic age when all righteous people will dance in a circle, pointing to God in the center and rejoicing. Is there any way to reconcile these positions? Rabbi Jonathan Sacks thinks so: in his view, the fundamental mistake of Korah was not envy, nor timing, but in perception. Korah thought Moses was raising himself above the people, but Rabbi Sacks argues that Moses was not interested in glory or power — merely service. Rather than being ambitious, we are repeatedly told of Moses’ humility. He is not described as a leader, but as a <em>servant</em> of the Lord. Judaism, Sacks argues, offers a model of leadership that focuses on tasks, not position. Per this definition, a priest or a prophet is not seen as <em>above</em> someone else, merely someone with a different role to play. Everyone <em>is</em> holy, but not everyone can necessarily be a leader — at least, not a good one.</p><p>These days, many of us do not believe that our leaders are appointed for us by God, ironically causing one element of Korah’s argument to come true. Today, there is nothing stopping anyone from becoming a leader, if they are willing to put in the work and make their case, whether in the realm of politics, entertainment or Torah. Modern democracy and the information age have made authority accessible to any who wish to claim it; all that is needed are followers.</p><p>And this potential for anyone to be heard offers a final, important lesson for us: we are only as righteous, as humble, or as holy as we demand our leaders be. It is up to our leaders to put their best selves forward, and for us to choose wisely. As the old line says, “We get the leaders we deserve” — and if we can’t find the ones we want, perhaps we need to become them.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a817b8340ef2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Moving On Up]]></title>
            <link>https://andrewnusbaum.medium.com/moving-on-up-496395cc3f77?source=rss-4449dce292d6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/496395cc3f77</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[family-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fact-checking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewish]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genealogy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrew Nusbaum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 27 Apr 2025 06:08:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-27T06:08:13.373Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/925/1*nMZ50qivwxOKIUyttjguSg.jpeg" /></figure><p>One of the amusements of being a genealogy nerd is the ability it gives you to fact-check relatives- or documents. Or in this case tombstones.</p><p>I’ve found a number of errors on family tombstones over the years, from misspellings (Goldsand, not Goldzint) to swapping out Marine service for Army (he would not have been amused), to incorrect birthdates (as well as assumed ones). Then there’s this one.</p><p>My grandfather was a big inspiration for me to become curious about the family tree. I never got to attend his funeral or visit his grave. Two days ago a stranger uploaded a photo of his stone to findagrave. And as I was appreciating the way his stone used the same lion of Judah motif as his father’s, I noticed that something was different: my grandfather’s stone has a jug in the center instead of a Star of David.</p><p>A jug, for those not in the know, is one of the short-hand symbols to indicate that the deceased was a Levite- in the same way that Kohanim are often buried with two hands making the Priestly Blessing, or what the rest of the world knows as a Vulcan salute thanks to Leonard Nemoy:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/32/0*78i1Ui-GDKymq9en.png" /></figure><p>The Kohanim performed rituals, sacrifices, and blessings in the Temple in Jerusalem, and the Levites assisted them, including by helping ritually wash their hands- hence, a jug.</p><p>There’s only one problem. Your caste is passed down from father to son, and there’s no indication that his father was a Levite. Nor is there any tradition of my father’s generation identifying as Levites.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*_t32UzU8zvUWV2Ef3EZ0Ew.jpeg" /></figure><p>Current best guess? One more embellishment from beyond the grave. He always was his own biggest fan.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=496395cc3f77" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Divergent Roads]]></title>
            <link>https://andrewnusbaum.medium.com/divergent-roads-7e063003f7f2?source=rss-4449dce292d6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7e063003f7f2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[holocaust]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genealogy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewish]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrew Nusbaum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 27 Apr 2025 06:08:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-27T06:08:00.713Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/375/1*Lf3WgYpE2mUqdG_wOeD9og@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>Layzer and Ludwik were born in the same Polish pilgrimage city, Czestochowa, six years and only a few blocks apart. We don’t know if they knew each other. Layzer’s family ran a tea house with a back room for shooting pool. Ludwik’s father had a small photography studio and his mother cut hair. Layzer was a middle child between a brother two years his senior and a young sister 18 years his junior. Ludwik was an only child. Maybe he liked it that way.</p><p>Layzer attended an elite high school, then studied at universities in Lithuania and Paris. Ludwik had a basic education and became a locksmith. In his spare time he sang in a chorus with his father.</p><p>Layzer defended his doctoral thesis at the Sorbonne in 1937 and decided to become a surgeon. While he was away, conditions back home were getting worse: The radical right was gaining power, especially among students. Jews in Poland were being economically boycotted and physically attacked. At the four largest universities, Jews were now being forced to sit on segregated “ghetto benches” while their fellow students openly demanded anti-Jewish quotas. The year before Layzer graduated, 20,000 university students had converged on Czestochowa and pledged an oath to the icon of the Virgin Mary. Polish history books are proud to mention that one of those students was the future Pope John Paul the Second. They usually leave out that the speakers said they would build a Catholic state in the Polish nation- and would not rest until the last Jew had left, alive or dead.</p><p>While he was finishing his exams, his home town experienced its third pogrom, or antisemitic riot, in 35 years. 15,000 of his family’s neighbors rampaged for three days, killing one Jew and wounding forty-five. Dozens of homes and business were demolished, including two small synagogues and a Jewish school.</p><p>Despite all that, Layzer defiantly opted to have his degree recorded using the Polish spelling of his Yiddish name. He then returned to Czestochowa to work at the public City Hospital, serving Jews and Christians alike. For whatever reason, Layzer believed in Poland. Maybe he was an optimist. Maybe he was a patriot. Or maybe he just missed his family.</p><p>He had less than two years to readjust to his old home. When the Nazis invaded Poland in September, his city was one of the first to fall. Hundreds were killed in the first few days. One of the city’s main synagogues was looted and burned immediately. The other was set on fire by a mob of Nazis and local collaborators to celebrate that Christmas. The town fire brigade stood watch to make sure the fire didn’t spread while the Jews crowded outside and wept.</p><p>Besides the casual cruelty and violence from the Nazis and their supporters among the German, Polish and Ukrainian population, the Jews were also faced with rampant overcrowding, disease and malnutrition. Layzer became a community activist. He worked with local charities like the Society for the Protection of Jewish Health to help provide medical care to the poor and orphaned.</p><p>Ludwik took a different path, answering the Nazis’ call for volunteers for their Jewish Order Police. Ludwik became Officer 118, part of a force of 250 men. In 1941 they helped the Nazis round up their neighbors and relatives into a cramped ghetto in the oldest part of the city. Over the coming months, its population doubled as desperate refugees were forced out of villages and German territory. That summer it was sealed, the inmates only being let out for work details at nearby factories or forced labor camps.</p><p>In the ghetto the police were used as auxiliary security, responding to internal disputes on behalf of the Nazi-controlled Jewish Council. In addition to benign activities like helping escort people from their homes or taking missing person’s reports, records show Ludwik was dispatched as muscle to detain people who refused to make payments and maintain order in unruly crowds. In exchange he received a shiny badge, a blue-white cap and arm-band and a heavy rubber baton to use at his full discretion.</p><p>As part of the daily machinery of life and death, ghetto police were widely unpopular. In communal history books written after the war, known as Yizkor, or Memory, Books, one Czestochowa author summed up the police in a few lines:</p><p>“The police were a plague for the Jewish population. It is clear that there were no willing volunteers to go for unpaid forced labor. There were also no volunteers who would allow themselves to be sent away to the camps to be overworked, tortured, beaten, and to bear various afflictions or willing volunteers to pay various tributes. There were also no volunteers for donating their merchandise to the Nazis. This the police carried out with coercion, through house searches, both by day and night, arresting, beating with rubber sticks, and through other irksome actions.</p><p>The attitude toward the police was bitter, full of hatred and rage.”</p><p>Why did Ludwik do it? How did he rationalize it? Was he hated by his family and friends? Did he hate himself? One memoir written after the war by a Jewish ghetto policeman cut right to the heart of the dilemma, choosing the direct title, “Am I a Murderer?”</p><p>Maybe Ludwik was trying to save himself, or his aging parents. Maybe he was planning on escaping and was waiting for his chance. Maybe it was a desperate attempt to make some cash, or secure some food, or protection- at least for a while. In between his work shifts, searching for some semblance of normalcy, he continued singing in the re-formed ghetto chorus with his father.</p><p>Lazyer and Ludwik endured the daily abuse and starvation. They kept their heads down through the two weeks of selections that took 90% of the ghetto’s 58,000 inhabitants to the Treblinka death camp, including their families. They looked away during the execution of intellectuals and children in the cemetery, more victims of Nazi lies and bullets. They blinked back tears during the two doomed ghetto revolts where poorly armed teenagers sacrificed their lives against impossible odds, watching 500 bodies burn in a single night after the fighters had been crushed and retribution taken. They married young women in rushed ceremonies and proudly marked the change on their documents, hoping that maybe their luck would hold long enough for them to have a life beyond this nightmare.</p><p>But, for all their efforts, they were not in control. After a year and a half, the Nazis liquidated the ghetto. The Jewish council was not spared. The police chief and his family also ended up in the cemetery.</p><p>Ludwik became a prisoner in a brutal slave labor camp run by the manufacturing giant Hugo Schneider, or Hasag, company. Hasag camps were locked compounds surrounded by barbed wire. Prisoners worked 12 hour shifts struggling with “incomprehensible hunger”, and no sanitation. The guards were brutal and unpredictable, the working conditions terrifying and dangerous. Bodies were left to lie in the mud for days before being collected.</p><p>We don’t know if they knew each other, but Layzer and Ludwik were fellow prisoners at neighboring camps, one forced to use their knowledge of medicine to help keep the doomed alive, the other’s nimble locksmith fingers forced to help the Nazis make the very bullets and anti-tank missiles that were being used to murder them and keep the war going. The average life expectancy of a Hasag worker was around three months. Through luck and skills, Layzer and Ludwik both survived for over a year and a half.</p><p>All the way up to January 1945, when the camps were evacuated and the prisoners deported- the women to Dachau, the men to Buchenwald. Ludwik died there in early March. His prisoner death card says kidney failure, but that doesn’t mean anything.</p><p>In the end, did he regret? Did he feel that everything he had done was justified in the name of self-preservation? Or was he so broken, starving and exhausted that these moral abstractions meant nothing to him?</p><p>Layzer lasted until early May, when he and 30,000 other prisoners were marched deep into southern Germany, in a last-ditch attempt to keep them within the camp system long enough to murder them all. Those who managed to stay behind and last long enough were liberated by the Americans. Layzer wasn’t so lucky. After four days and 260 miles, he was either shot by an SS man or died of exhaustion and starvation on the road, depending on which document you choose to believe. Just days before the end of the war.</p><p>Three and a half years later, an International Red Cross team filed a report from a Bavarian cemetery near Salzburg. A body wearing a uniform with Layzer’s prisoner number had been discovered. At least, unlike most of his family, he had a real grave.</p><p>He was memorialized by his widow and in survivor-written Yizkor Books, now mostly forgotten to time. He was praised by his friends and neighbors as “the tall handsome doctor with the green eyes”, who “devoted all his energy to his many patients who depended on him for medical care and moral support” and “helped ease the fate of his fellow prisoners.” The first doctor in our family, whose story we had never heard.</p><p>Ludwik’s widow dutifully wrote a memorial page for him in the same book. She kept his occupation to herself.</p><p>One of the most painful dilemmas of anyone who lives through a war is trying to survive despite so many elements being beyond their control. In the end, neither skills nor luck were enough to save either the surgeon or the locksmith.</p><p>And whether they ever met or not, for me, their fates remain intertwined. Doctor Layzer Glatter and Officer Ludwik Edelist, second-cousins, murdered along with their families and neighbors for the crime of being Polish Jews in the Twentieth Century.</p><p>Sons and husbands, friends and colleagues. A healer and a collaborator. Young men full of dreams, each gone before they reached 35. Each with a life they desperately wanted to live, each painfully snatched away.</p><p>Layzer and Ludwik. Just six years apart.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7e063003f7f2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Brotherhood of the Book]]></title>
            <link>https://andrewnusbaum.medium.com/the-brotherhood-of-the-book-f35077fabd63?source=rss-4449dce292d6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f35077fabd63</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[genealogy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewish]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[holocaust]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrew Nusbaum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Apr 2025 22:51:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-27T07:40:30.357Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*RiqS6L-PFxOTOyCdyD-GZQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Main synagogue in Wyszkow</figcaption></figure><p>For thousands of years, Jewish culture has been associated with books, words, and language. In comparison to many of its neighbors, Jewish society placed a high value on education and encouraged universal (male) literacy. Boys were taught to read at age three, starting with a special ceremony where they ate candy or honey off a slate with the Hebrew alphabet to teach them that learning was sweet. From then on, for those bright or connected or wealthy enough, religious studies became a full-time focus, with school days that could last as long as twelve hours. The initial focus would be learning the Torah with rabbinical commentaries, before diving into the sea of Talmudic law and debate around age ten. Then, as now, most people could not afford to do this full-time and went to work, but there were many communities and schools throughout Jewish Europe in the late 1930s who still saw study and prayer as the major focuses of their day, structuring their lives and occupations around their religious obligations and celebrations.</p><p>None of my ancestors were rabbis. But I have found at least one who seems to have built his life around Torah learning.</p><p>But first, a note about a different type of book.</p><p>One of my favorite genealogy/Jewish history resources are called Yizkor, or memorial, books. Many Jewish communities in Europe (and some in North Africa) created these crowd-sourced anthologies to remember their families and towns that were destroyed during WWII. For many years they were almost exclusively in Yiddish and Hebrew, but thankfully over the last decade many are now online and translated into English.</p><p>One of the things I love about Yizkor books is how free-wheeling they are. Each author brings a different style and focus to their article or section, and it’s fascinating to read about the same event or family and see how the perspective changes. While this can lead to conflicting accounts and inconsistencies, it also helps give a flavor to the towns and townspeople, helping these localities become more than a dot on a map, by sharing local history and folklore.</p><p>A few years ago I discovered my g.grandfather’s oldest brother Yankel, was mentioned in the yizkor book for Wyszkow, a village of about 12,000 that was around 50% Jewish, north of Warsaw. There was a passing reference to Yankel being part of a small Hasidic synagogue, or shteibel, associated with one of the most popular Hasidic rabbis in Poland, the <a href="https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avraham_Mordechai_Alter">rebbe of Ger</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/194/1*TqnA8DEWzyQ-m7rhjP0qhA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Rebbe of Ger, also known as “The Speaker of Truth,” spiritual leader to as many as 200,000 followers before the war. Unlike many other rabbis of the time, he encouraged his supporters to emigrate and buy property in Mandate-era Palestine. He fled to Jerusalem in 1940 with three of his seven children. Most of his family and disciples were annihilated.</figcaption></figure><p>Once I saw the entire book had been <a href="https://www.jewishgen.org/yizkor/wyszkow/wyszkow.html">translated</a>, I took on a personal challenge: I compiled a list of the 15 or so core leaders associated with this congregation of about 200 men. Then, I started combing through the index, looking for any references to them or their families. If I couldn’t find information about Yankel himself, I would do my best to reconstruct his circle of friends and study partners.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*sMZu5g4EqA-pkKBagcrS_A.jpeg" /></figure><p>I found stories. I found pictures, though sadly, none of him. I even tracked down a couple of memoirs written by relatives of his friends. Slowly, I assembled a mental picture of the slightly rundown, converted house on Firefighter Street with two large rooms on the ground floor- one for the synagogue, one for the study hall, and an attic on top, full of books, newspapers, and chairs for various Orthodox youth organizations who used it as a meeting place, and even a printing house for a short-lived newspaper.</p><p>The study hall was always full of young men loudly studying Talmud, and every evening about 60 men would sit at a long table and study “The Daily Page” together. Supposedly these sessions were taught by our very own Yankel the Butcher, suggesting he had more formal education than just the laws of kosher slaughter. The town chroniclers noted that the Gerer shteibel on Firefighter Street was known for its beautiful melodies on Shabbat afternoon, and said the prayers were usually sung by three men: Chaim, Itche-Meyer, and Yankel. This was interesting. We don’t have rabbis in the family but we did have a cantor- and apparently now we had found another.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/200/1*2l9v42bnkJSkSXI6NC1Hbg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Yankel’s friend and co-prayer leader, Chaim Sztelung</figcaption></figure><p>I read about the 1920s, when the Polish army captured, imprisoned and tortured 200 Jews from town as supposed Bolshevik spies, and when the mayor came to get Chaim-David, caretaker of the synagogue and member of the town council, released, he refused until everyone was let go. I read about Isaac the school-teacher, kind and gentle, who crushed a Nazi’s head with a rock to save a Jewish child- and was executed in return. I read about some of the lucky families who had managed to escape ahead of the Nazis to the Soviet Union, spending the war as refugees in Tashkent or Samarkand. And I also read how Yankel’s friend Itche-Meyer was supposedly so strong that he could pick up all 37 volumes of Talmud in one hand- or so his grandson claimed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*7h0XeJw4ZBtJo2E_OWftaw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Religious school in Wyszkow. The teacher is Itche-Meyer’s son.</figcaption></figure><p>While none of them seem to have been wealthy, a number of Yankel’s friends in the shteibel were prominent citizens of the town: the President of the Jewish community council, prosperous merchants, other kosher butchers like himself. This, in large part, is how we know what likely happened to him.</p><p>Many people associate the Holocaust with concentration or extermination camps, but may not know how many towns, especially in eastern Poland, Lithuania, Belarus and Ukraine, were instead subjected to what’s been described as “The Holocaust By Bullets” at the hands of the Einsatzgruppen. These SS mobile killing squads were sent ahead of the regular German army with orders to liquidate Jews and other enemies. They were particularly active in the areas that became the Eastern Front, using every opportunity to wipe out their targets whenever they gained territory. These were the small places that never had ghettos- instead their Jews simply “disappeared.” In the first month of the war, seven Einsatzgruppe squads operating in Poland killed 15,000 Poles and Jews.</p><p>The Nazis invaded Poland on September 1, 1939. The night of September 9, around 65 Jewish elders from Wyszkow were rounded up and told they were being assigned to a work detail. They were marched through town, across the metal bridge over the Bug River, and out to a field towards the woods. At the edge of the woods the men were shot and dumped into a pit. The single survivor, who later <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/12646300-flight-from-fear">recorded</a> the incident, was that same <a href="https://www.staugustine.com/story/news/local/2013/05/02/2013-04-30-1/16147159007/">grandson</a> of Yankel’s friend.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lr6hxvvM5Bb4_1seIpJPsA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Town bridge</figcaption></figure><p>We don’t know for certain if Yankel died that night. He might have been in the crowd of 500 who were instead marched into the main synagogue and burned alive along with the building. Or he could have tried to flee to Russia with his family and died on the road. Historians agree, though: within four days, Wyszkow’s 5,000 Jews were all dead or scattered, and the likelihood that a man in his 50s who was already known in the community to informers would have been able to avoid the same fate as the rest of his friends and family seems painfully low.</p><p>For over thirty years, the shteibel on Firefighter Street had been a modest but dynamic center of learning, prayer, and community. The men of the shteibel were known as fiery and opinionated, sharp in their study, their humor, and as always, their words. So many words. Yankel the butcher, the cantor, the Torah reader, the community organizer, the scholar, the teacher. A man who based his life around the study and practice of God’s holy commandments. A man who loved singing, and books. Who, in some way, must have thought that his faith, whether in his wonder rabbi, in the Holy One, or both, could help keep him and his loved ones safe.</p><p>All too quickly, the men of the Gerer shteibel learned a new lesson. It was the same as the men of the other eight shteiblach in town. As the rabbi at the main synagogue and the students at the yeshiva and their wives and families. A harsh reality that Jews across Europe discovered from 1939 through 1946, and which remains the central challenge of Jewish faith and identity in a post-Holocaust world:</p><p>Books couldn’t stop bullets.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bHfyFMwpxW5FxZHqcvfLwA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Page of Testimony for Yankel written by his youngest surviving brother- the same uncle who told my mother they had actually not been from a small family; it was small because six of the ten siblings had been murdered along with their families.</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f35077fabd63" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Stolen Life]]></title>
            <link>https://andrewnusbaum.medium.com/a-stolen-life-675ca9fd35c9?source=rss-4449dce292d6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/675ca9fd35c9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[genealogy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[holocaust]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewish]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrew Nusbaum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Apr 2025 17:55:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-28T00:31:56.281Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/227/1*Lq6Y5Ma9bMhEgXqpLBOlLQ@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Block 10, Auschwitz</figcaption></figure><p>Greta was the seventh of eight children from a poor but happy Jewish family. Her father was a furniture mover who made a living driving his truck back and forth from Holland to Germany. On the side he transported chickens for farmers to market. The road was easy and flat, and each of her five brothers learned to drive early. So many children kept her mother plenty busy. She didn’t know when she slept.</p><p>Greta’s ancestors had been in Amsterdam since the 1600s. Life wasn’t perfect, but it was good. They had to censor themselves around their non-Jewish neighbors to not appear foreign, and antisemitic comments would occasionally slip out of her friends’ mouths. But on the whole they felt accepted and secure.</p><p>Then the Nazis came.</p><p>They were quickly overrun in 1940, as it happened, on the day she was supposed to have been married. Most of the city’s 75,000 Jews were too stunned to even know to hide or flee. First came the yellow star and the endless lists in the Jews’ Registry. Confiscations of property and roundups followed. The Dutch reaction was a collective shrug.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/412/1*aBIhstKQHMrxKIItFhZoeg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Greta and Moses on their rescheduled wedding day, early 1941, Amsterdam</figcaption></figure><p>In February 1941 hundreds of Jews were taken from Amsterdam, sent first to Buchenwald and then to Mauthausen, where most were murdered. One of her brothers was among them.</p><p>In early 1942 the Nazis transformed Westerbork, a former Jewish refugee camp in the countryside, into a detention center. Foreign and stateless Jews were rounded up and sent there to await deportation. Inside Amsterdam, Jews were restricted to certain neighborhoods. Greta and her family secured jobs making fur coats for German soldiers headed for the Eastern Front and made a hiding place in the attic. They knew it was only a matter of time until the German trucks came for them, but the children hoped that when the inevitable happened they might at least be able to stall long enough for their parents to hide.</p><p>In July the mass deportations started. Trucks blocked off the streets. Policemen, railroad workers, city officials, civilian collaborators and Nazi soldiers all helped round up Amsterdam’s Jews. Jews were dragged to the trains, where they were shipped to Auschwitz and Sobibor as their belongings were divided up by their neighbors. Whole buildings and streets became emptied in hours.</p><p>In October Greta’s sister and her family disappeared. The following year it was her other brothers’ turn. And then finally in June 1943, her own.</p><p>As they were Dutch citizens, she and her husband Moses weren’t sent to Westerbork, but rather Vught, where they sat for months. Vught was Holland’s only concentration camp, holding. 31,000 prisoners during the 23 months it was in operation. Hundreds died there from starvation and executions.</p><p>One day, Greta, two of her brothers and her sister-in-law, along with hundreds of others, were violently shoved into dark cattle cars, surrounded by screams and filth. She lost Moses in the chaos.</p><p>First they traveled to Westerbork, where they took on more prisoners, then further east. It was three days before the Nazis finally opened the doors. Soldiers with snarling dogs screamed at them to get out. Men and women were separated. Then the selection began.</p><p>There had been 979 Jews on her transport, including 60 children and 141 elders. They and another 200 adults were sent to the left and put on wagons. 303 men and 288 women, including Greta, were sent to the right and processed into Auschwitz that September morning in 1943.</p><p>The process had taken less than 20 minutes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*rjik6Xi4EbYbjOT6c5TEJQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Auschwitz gate. The ironwork contains the infamous slogan “Work Makes You Free,” a lie the Nazis used to fill prisoners with false hope that they would be spared if they only worked hard enough.</figcaption></figure><p>A man walked through the women’s column asking who was married. Numbly, Greta and her sister-in-law raised their hands. Ultimately 100 women from her transport were selected for a special group.</p><p>She was roughly shaved by a male prisoner. Her head, her eyebrows, her pubic hair. She was thrown into ice-cold water and doused with cheap cologne to “decontaminate” her. Her arm was tattooed. She was given a filthy threadbare uniform.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UfmZFe5jccs-xoQLFOBHdg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Close-Up of Greta’s tattoo. Over 400,000 prisoners were tattooed at Auschwitz, including 90,000 Jewish women. Some (but not all) Jewish prisoners also received a triangle underneath their number to make it easier for guards to quickly see if they were Jewish.</figcaption></figure><p>She was taken to Block 10 in the men’s camp. There were 400 Jewish women, Greek, French, Belgian, German, Dutch, all crammed into two top rooms of a brick barrack. Below were the doctors’ offices and medical wards.</p><p>Block 10 was the experimentation block, operated by a half-dozen Nazi scientists and about 20 prisoner assistants. Each doctor had a different specialty. One was obsessed with blood. Another with eyes. One was mad for x-rays. Still another was assembling a museum of Jewish skeletons, a racial zoo of “subhuman” bones for a Nazi future where, as he wrote to Hitler, “Jewish skeletons would be as rare and precious as dinosaur bones.”</p><p>Their barrack was separated from Block 11 by a small walled courtyard. Block 11 was the camp prison. Men were regularly tortured and left to die in the basement. The far wall was known as “The Shooting Wall.” It was the prison execution site. They heard screams and shots every day, but couldn’t see anything- the windows had been boarded up.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/275/1*l-XQh6c-IocdOdMnBhq7LA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Shooting Wall, or “Death Wall,” between Blocks 10 and 11, Auschwitz</figcaption></figure><p>It was, as one of the assistants said after their first night there, “a combination of hell and asylum,” where anything seemed permitted.</p><p>A few days after arrival, Greta was brought in front of a dumpy toad of a man. Clauberg. A famous university gynecologist who had volunteered his services to the Nazis. Around five feet tall and balding, his eyes bulged behind his giant glasses and his face held a constant eerie grin. He called himself, “Professor.” The prisoners called him The Beast. Some called their barracks Clauberg’s Block. It had been built for him as a gift by Heinrich Himmler. He had been doing human experiments there for nine months.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EJWMiY3lCE0S_nF8G6bHXg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Carl Clauberg, The Professor/Beast of Auschwitz (painting by Stefan Krikl)</figcaption></figure><p>He made her strip and put her in stirrups on a table. He injected her with a thick, white-pink solution in an impossibly long needle, without any warning or anesthetic. She cried out and the nurse slapped her to make her quiet.</p><p>Her insides burned for weeks afterward, and she watched as dozens of her fellow prisoners were given the same treatments. Some collapsed and were taken away. The orderlies visited them in the night with medicine and water and encouraged them. Some of the new women asked about what happened to prisoners who became sick. “They get transferred to another hospital,” they were told. Then one winter day they saw guards tossing naked men into the back of trucks by the neck like chickens. At that moment the girls knew- there was no other hospital. Just the gas chamber.</p><p>Besides their “treatments,” the girls were also forced to give blood. Greta had been anemic since childhood. The doctors didn’t care. They told them it was for German soldiers. Day by day, Greta and her bunkmates grew weaker and sallow.</p><p>After a month The Beast examined her with X-rays, then injected her again. The pain was so intense that the nurse had to sit on her arms. Her abdomen grew tight and swollen and she had a fever for days. Another month, then the same. This time she became violently ill with an infection, and again she wondered whether she preferred to just die. By this point she had gotten word that her parents, brothers and husband had all been killed.</p><p>Occasionally, The Beast would toy with the prisoners and say he would save some of them. At the end of his experiments he would need subjects for private observation at his clinic outside the camp. Himmler wanted him to explore the possibilities of artificial insemination. Sometimes he told some that he had injected them with animal semen and that they were incubating interspecies hybrids. He seemed to enjoy the screams.</p><p>Once in a while they’d get a piece of salami in care packages. One day they smelled meat wafting through the hallways. At first they indignantly thought the guards were cooking and eating their meals sent from home. When they confronted one of them, he laughed at them hysterically and pointed up. It was then that they realized what the smoke coating their nostrils, sinking into their clothes, dusting their skin, really was.</p><p>When Greta finally recovered, The Beast brought her to his colleagues. They had called her by name, she remembered. It was the first time any of them had used it. She recognized the doctors staring at her. One had burning, terrifying eyes. His name was Mengele, but they called him the Angel of Death. He experimented on hundreds of pairs of twins. Next to him was the tall and handsome Schumann, who shot prisoners with x-rays until their skin burned. Last was a face she knew only from newsreels- Joseph Goebbels, the Nazi Minister of Propaganda.</p><p>The Beast chuckled as he waved around her X-rays. “Full sterilization.”</p><p>Had part of her already known? She had seen her fellow prisoners walking stooped over like old ladies, whispering, “No more babies, no more babies.”</p><p>But somehow, she had hoped to still be a mother, to have a family, to make life, one day when this hell was over. Could The Beast be lying again?</p><p>Greta didn’t know it then, but Clauberg and his colleague Schumann had a running competition to see who could present a perfected sterilization procedure to Himmler first. Clauberg touted injections while Schumann preferred surgical castration and X-rays.</p><p>A few months before Greta arrived at Block 10, Clauberg had written to Himmler congratulating himself on his progress. With his new method, he proudly reported, one doctor and ten assistants would soon be able to sterilize 1000 women a day. It was “as good as perfect,” and merely needed “minor improvements.” The letter ended by asking the Master of the SS to send an additional X-Ray machine from Berlin. They were “in urgent need” of two.</p><p>Greta spent almost eight months in Block 10. In mid-1944 the Block was closed. Clauberg and Schumann moved their experiments to Ravensbruck, where they sterilized hundreds of Roma and Sinti teenagers. Greta and some of the other Block 10 “specimens” were transferred there as well.</p><p>In 1945 as the Allies closed in, the SS marched Greta and her group of ten Dutch women out of Ravensbruck and across Germany. Breslau. Magdeburg. Schwartzwald. Hundreds of miles, from camp to camp. Starving, freezing, exhausted. Anyone who couldn’t walk was shot or beaten to death. Greta’s sister-in-law was suffering from a bladder infection and could barely stand. When a guard confronted them, Greta stood up for her and received a brutal blow to the face with a club. She saw stars for days, but her sister-in-law was still alive.</p><p>Finally, near Dresden, the SS told the prisoners that they were free to go. They knew the war was over. They were covering their uniforms and ditching their armbands. Greta told her group they needed to wait until they knew it was really safe. All ten of them survived the war. Janie, Ruth, Hilda, Esperanza, Dora. At one point they saw Americans who offered to take them to a refugee camp in a few jeeps but they refused to be separated and kept walking.</p><p>They stayed in town for a while until the Russians occupied the city. They wanted to cross the Elbe river but couldn’t get permission. Finally they were able to get into a bus heading west. They were filthy. The Americans offered to take them to a work camp in Belgium. But they refused. They wanted to go home. Eventually they got work at the American base with good food and lodging.</p><p>As the Americans took more ground they put the girls up in new housing. But they kept insisting on being returned, as a group, until they were finally sent back to Holland that summer.</p><p>Her extended family of 40 was gone. Her only surviving relative was a 9-year-old niece who had been kept in hiding. Greta tracked her down and adopted her. A few years later, Greta remarried another Dutch survivor. But the shadow of her family always hovered close by. As she put it, “We tried to do our best, but the pain never went away.”</p><p>Nazi scientists experimented on at least 17,000 human beings at 8 different concentration camps. About a quarter of the victims were gassed or died from complications of their torture. Some, like Mengele’s twins, were deliberately killed via lethal injection so their bodies could be dissected.</p><p>In two years, the doctors of Block 10 killed at least 48 prisoners. About 700 women survived the initial sterilization experiments, most with permanent damage. About 100 made it through the war and testified against their tormentors. Greta was one of them.</p><p>Like their victims, the doctors’ fate after the war was varied. Several committed suicide while on the run. One was charged with war crimes but cleared by a German court of any wrongdoing. The skeleton doctor disappeared and was sentenced to death in absentia. Back at his lab in Strasbourg, soldiers found 86 semi-preserved corpses intended for experimentation and display.</p><p>Each prisoner had been hand-picked for their Jewish racial features and then gassed. As the Allies had gotten closer, the technicians had reluctantly destroyed the heads and faces, hoping that it would be harder to prosecute them if no prisoners could be named. It took Israeli pathologists 20 years to positively identify the skeleton doctor’s remains after he secretly killed himself in the Black Forest a month after the war. It took another 40 before researchers could begin giving names to his victims. The last were finally laid to rest 72 years after their murder in the name of Nazi science.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/537/1*qP36Nqxs9xFa7wX38HsClg.jpeg" /><figcaption>August Hirt, the “Skeleton Doctor” who dreamed of a zoo of Jewish bones</figcaption></figure><p>Schumann lived in West Germany until the 1950s when his identity was exposed, after which he fled to Egypt, then Sudan, then Ghana. 25 years after the war he returned to Germany and stood trial for killing 30,000 Jews. When asked on the stand whether that estimate was accurate, he shrugged and said that he hadn’t been counting; it could have been as high as 80,000. He served less than 2 years in prison before being released for “frail health.” He lived another 11 years before dying at age 77.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/262/1*tvV61WZX3HlgjafREJPMrg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Horst Schumann, who murdered thousands with deliberate exposure to high-radiation X-rays</figcaption></figure><p>Clauberg was captured by the Soviet Army near Ravensbruck and sentenced to 25 years imprisonment. He served eight before being repatriated to West Germany as part of a prisoner swap.</p><p>There, a mere decade after the war, the Beast of Auschwitz openly returned to medicine. He was reinstated at his old gynecology clinic. He gave a press conference grinning into the camera and bragging about his accomplishments with “inferior races” at Auschwitz.</p><p>A group of German survivors appealed to the government and he was arrested. Clauberg died in hospital two years later, shortly before his trial was supposed to begin. His death was officially ruled a heart attack but many suspected that the German medical establishment, which took over a year to revoke his license, had been only too happy to pass him something to keep him quiet and avoid implicating old colleagues.</p><p>Mengele, obsessed with twins and eyes, fled to South America and was never caught. He drowned on a Brazilian beach under an assumed name. Like thousands of Nazi doctors and scientists, he died without ever facing justice.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/172/1*_7veSZ6TS9DqvXag7mig8g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Josef Mengele, “The Angel of Death” who personally sent thousands to the gas chambers and selected prisoners for experimentation- including 3000 children (1500 sets of twins)</figcaption></figure><p>Greta and her family came to New York in the early 1950s and moved to Los Angeles soon after. Slowly, painfully, they tried to rebuild themselves.</p><p>Decades later, fighting back tears in a tape of testimony, Greta recounted that holidays in America “were the worst part”, because of how lonely they felt. Clauberg’s needle had been full of a formaldehyde solution designed to irritate her Fallopian tubes until they sealed themselves. After the war she had exploratory surgery to see whether she could have children. Her doctor said it was like her tubes were filled with cement.</p><p>Greta had been only 26 when she was sent to Block 10. And though she was thankful to have lived, she clearly spent the rest of her life struggling with what happened to her.</p><p>Greta’s lesson to the future was very direct: “We should have spoken up as soon as things started. We shouldn’t have hid our heads in the sand. As soon as you hear something, stand up.”</p><p>I’m trying, Greta. In my own small way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/399/1*dm0VbSP3wkgcZwTeDFErTQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Greta in Los Angeles shortly before passing away in her late 70s</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/418/1*A7ZhbUV2om8_2ltpOFhLtA.png" /><figcaption>Greta’s Auschwitz tattoo</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=675ca9fd35c9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Memory as an Act of Love- and Resistance]]></title>
            <link>https://andrewnusbaum.medium.com/memory-as-an-act-of-love-and-resistance-0d894e91d796?source=rss-4449dce292d6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0d894e91d796</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[holocaust]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewish]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genealogy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrew Nusbaum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Apr 2025 03:00:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-25T04:27:43.521Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/537/1*A9wp77TdkV14T8nScHkLiQ@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>20 years ago last November, Yad Vashem‘s name database went online. Much like the digitalization of Ellis Island’s records in 2001, I remember what a powerful experience it was to be able to search and browse these records and to become literally lost in information. After so many years of not having access to any records, experiencing sudden access was overwhelming even as it was exciting. Even though the subject matter was about as heavy as you can get.</p><p>One of the first names I looked up was my mother’s maiden name (and my and my brother’s middle names), Glatter. And very quickly, I started finding family in Czestochowa, our family hometown my great-grandfather had left in 1901. A few I had heard of, most were new. But what really surprised me was when I hit the button that sorted results by submitter.</p><p>Someone had been busy.</p><p>This cousin, whom I had never heard of, had submitted 21 names, decades before I was born. It’s taken me almost 20 years but I’ve finally pieced together her story, at least to a point:</p><p>Leonia was born in 1916, the youngest of 11 children. Her father Abram died a few months before she was born. By the time Leonia came along she had multiple half-siblings in their thirties with children of their own, both in Poland and New York. There was a ten year age gap between her and her youngest sister.</p><p>Leonia, also called Stefania, or Stefa, lived with her mother, a brother, and at least two sisters. In 1940, she appeared as a prisoner in the Czeladz Ghetto, about an hour’s drive from Czestochowa. She may have been staying with one of her aunts who lived in that town.</p><p>In 1942, she was in the Srodula Ghetto in Sosnowiec, a name I first encountered decades ago in Art Spiegelman’s MAUS. That same year two of her siblings and their families were murdered at Treblinka. In spring 1943 her mother, sister, aunt and cousins were killed at Auschwitz. Stefa was recorded as a prisoner in several slave labor camps near Breslau, now Wroclaw. Her brother was worked to death at the nearby Markstadt camp.</p><p>For the last 14 months of the war, Stefa was a slave laborer at a subcamp of Gross-Rosen called Peterswaldau, now a small Polish town near the Czech border. Prisoners suffered through starvation, exhaustion and beatings. They hid injuries and illnesses to avoid being shot on the spot or sent to Auschwitz.</p><p>Somehow, Stefa survived.</p><p>After liberation, Stefa married another survivor, Elias. He had lost a wife and child in Auschwitz. Stefa had lost her mother, at least four siblings, three nieces and nephews, five aunts and uncles, and eight first cousins. In 1950, Stefa and Elias left Venice for Israel. And in 1955, living in Raanana, she completed almost two dozen pages of testimony, by hand, memorializing her family, line by line.</p><p>After finding Stefa in Yad Vashem, I kept a look out every time new Czestochowa records were released. Over time I found a birth record, then mentions in survivor lists. She wrote to the JDC trying to get financial assistance while living in post-war Poland.</p><p>Two years ago I found her immigration papers to Israel. Then I found Elias’ grave online. And last year I received more details about where she was during the war from the German Red Cross Archives in Bad Arolsen.</p><p>I hope one day I’ll find out whether she had children and what her life after the war was like. Whether I learn more or not, though, I’m grateful that Stefa survived, and even more so that she wrote pages of testimony for future generations to find and remember. In this small way, she feels like a little bit of a kindred spirit, a cousin who felt some need to write down that her family had existed, and to make sure their story wasn’t lost.</p><p>While she may not have realized it at the time, her simple act of memory also helped make sure she wasn’t forgotten, either. And I’m grateful for that, too.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0d894e91d796" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Do Not Stand Idly By]]></title>
            <link>https://andrewnusbaum.medium.com/do-not-stand-idly-by-2e844b29dd80?source=rss-4449dce292d6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2e844b29dd80</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[holocaust]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jewish]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[family-history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrew Nusbaum]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 24 Apr 2025 22:37:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-24T22:37:41.784Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/803/1*Q8xYXygnakTQ23zyt6P3fQ@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>My great-grandfather’s family came from Częstochowa, one of the larger industrial towns in Poland- and close to the pre-war border. As a result during the Nazi occupation there were numerous labor camps set up around the city. Slave labor camps, used for making ammunition and other war essentials. These companies made fortunes while working their laborers to death and starving them. I have found at least 20 relatives who were used as slave labor, including the first doctor in our family, who served his fellow prisoners for two years of hell before being deported to Buchenwald.</p><p>A few survived. Izaak was one of them. He had come from a wealthy (and small) branch of the family. His father had loved Hebrew and had money to spare on his only son’s education, and that meant the prestigious Jewish Gymnasium. A Gymnasium was a Polish preparatory high school, which usually taught grades 4–12. Izaak lost his father his first year at the school and the obituary mentioned that the faculty attended his mother’s home to help comfort the mourning family.</p><p>His father, an only child, had been a grocer and property owner. Since Izaak was also an only child, he inherited his father’s company with his mother as guardian and a line of credit of 10,000 Polish zlotys, equivalent to over 250,000 American dollars today. He was also named co-owner of their apartment building. All before he turned nine.</p><p>Izaak, or Izu, as his friends called him, spent 8 years wearing his blue gymnasium cap, then began helping his mother with the business. In his spare time he took up shooting; when he was 17 he participated in a city-wide marksmanship contest and was one of about 100 men to receive a third class badge. Though the town’s Polish newspaper was usually hostile to Jews, they published the full list of competitors without comment, other than to encourage interested readers to join the shooting club.</p><p>Izaak was only 21 when the Nazis invaded Poland. Czestochowa was taken on the third day of the war. The next day, the Germans claimed that Jews had shot at them. In “revenge,” they launched a three day slaughter where hundreds were rounded up, forced to lie on their stomachs and machine gunned. They forced any survivors to run through the streets while they chased after them, laughing and shooting.</p><p>The Germans created a Jewish council to provide labor and carry out their orders, and the council created its own police force. A strict curfew followed, along with looting, beatings, kidnapping, rapes, forced labor, and other abuses. In December, a new edict was issued to Czestochowa’s 28,000 Jews, about one fifth of the city’s population. It said that all Jews 14 and older would be required to wear a white armband on their right arm above the elbow. It had to have a blue Star of David at least 10 centimeters wide. Any Jew caught without theirs could be beaten or arrested.</p><p>Izaak had been raised to love Hebrew. He had grown up singing songs to the Jewish flag. Now he was forced to wear it as a mark of shame like a criminal. All Jewish owned business, including Izaak and his mother’s, had to display a similar star in their windows.</p><p>New directives fell like rain. Jewish property was confiscated. Jews were restricted to $400 each and had to turn the rest in to be openly stolen. Each family was assigned a quota of metal they had to turn in or scavenge. Food was restricted and people began to starve.</p><p>Over the next two years, the city’s Jewish population ballooned as refugees were expelled from surrounding towns. The charity infrastructure was overwhelmed, and people wandered in the streets begging for food and shelter.</p><p>After two years of occupation, murder and terror, including the destruction of both the city’s main synagogues and the execution of hundreds of political and social leaders, the Nazis forced all 46,000 of them to less than 28 streets out of 400 in the oldest part of town near the old ironworks, sealing it off with armed guards stationed at the exits. They hung signs saying any Jews trying to leave or Poles trying to enter would be shot. Later they added ones saying Jews carried plague. It was the fourth largest ghetto in Poland.</p><p>That year Izaak appeared in the records of the Jewish ghetto police. His first complaint was that he had seen an exhausted man lying on the street with no one helping him. The fact that the police later assigned him to a work detail didn’t deter him from continuing to speak up and file reports.</p><p>Izaak’s mother died in the ghetto the following February, possibly during a typhus epidemic. We don’t know who he leaned on then. He had dozens of cousins in the city and likely many friends, but it’s not clear how he kept himself together during those dark months- or if he did.</p><p>All through 1942, the Nazis toyed with them. They demanded a map of the ghetto with each home specifically identified. They cleared out a number of apartment buildings and started using them as warehouses for stolen goods. They began painting basements with whitewash. They even forced Jews out of one street and started digging what people said looked like graves.</p><p>In July, they ordered all Jews between 16 and 60 to assemble at the ironworks. They waited for hours until they were finally sent home.</p><p>In late September, on Yom Kippur, the. “Aktion” finally began. At 3 a.m., the Jewish police, German soldiers, and Ukrainian auxiliaries started pounding on doors and screaming for the Jews to report to the factory by 6. Shortly after, they started kicking down doors and dragging stragglers out of their homes. Systematically, house by house, until each street on their list was Judenrein- cleansed of Jews.</p><p>For five weeks, Jews were marched to the Market Square, in batches of 7000 at a time. Whether screaming, pleading, crying, or silent, it made no difference. Each time, the Nazi Captain Degenhardt would select about 350 young people as slave laborers and send them to one of the camps they had created nearby to help serve the Reich.</p><p>Anyone the Nazis decided was not a productive worker was sent onto the trains to Treblinka, or sometimes shot on the spot. One of Izaak’s cousins died that way, in the square, his blood seeping into the dirt and cobblestones that his family had walked for 120 years. The trains took 40,000 in all.</p><p>Izaak got a different sort of treatment. In a communal memory book about the ghetto written after the war, one survivor recounted that Degenhardt “had captured a large transport of groceries from Glatter‘s firm. He assured him that in exchange for letting the Nazis steal the food, he would avoid the selection.”</p><p>Degenhardt was a Polish man from ethnic German roots. It was said he had an ape-like face. He called himself “The Father of the Jews” of his ghetto. The Jews called him “The master of life and death.” He was notoriously sadistic, often soliciting bribes or deals in exchange for promises of safety. Just as often, these promises were gleefully broken as soon as he had gotten what he wanted. One of his men, a young driver named Onkelbach, considered himself quite the sharpshooter. One of his favorite pastimes was holing up in a building and using passersby for target practice, an unconscious echo of Amon Goth from Schindler‘s list.</p><p>This time, Degenhardt kept his word. Izaak survived the selection. His world shrank again, as he and 6000 others were compressed into a Small Ghetto of only 7 blocks, surrounded by 6 foot high barbed wire fences. After two months the Germans declared it a Forced Jewish Labor Camp, restricted food and movement further, and said that the armbands had now been abolished, along with their names. Instead all “legal” Jews would be assigned a number printed on a tin tag to wear on their chests. The Chairman of the Jewish Council received number 1. Izaak was number 127. They were given old prison uniforms painted with reddish black vertical stripes that looked like blood.</p><p>From five in the morning to nine at night, Izaak and the others worked at one of four converted ammunition factories operated by the Hasag company in the south-eastern corner of the city. Whereas his cousin Layzer the doctor had specialized skills and was given his own private room and at least semi-decent rations at the nearby steel plant, Izaak was merely a young worker, assigned first to the disinfecting squad of the ghetto hospital, then to the the old spinning mill next to the Jewish cemetery.</p><p>Izaak’s camp was the largest: there were over 5000 slaves there. At first they were allowed to leave at night but after 9 months, some teenagers in the ghetto tried resisting. 500 of them were killed in retaliation and the Nazis decided to liquidate the ghetto. Now Izaak and his friends could not even leave the factory grounds.</p><p>They were kept starving, filthy, intimidated by a constant stream of threats and violence directed from the guards. Besides Nazi soldiers there were also Polish and Ukrainian collaborators. This included three local Catholic boys from town who had decided to take jobs as factory guards in exchange for a small salary, a snappy hat, and free use of rubber batons, whips, and pistol handles. Each of them, Janusz, Roman, and Marian, were only 17.</p><p>Janusz, nicknamed Ivanek the Dangerous because he told everyone he was really Ukrainian, not Polish, was sadistically violent. He would beat workers for even *suspecting* they were taking a cigarette break in the toilets. On one occasion, after a beating, he became enraged that Izaak hadn’t been considerate enough to thank him, so he beat him again. Another time when Izaak had been given the day off by the camp doctor for illness, Ivanek bashed his rifle butt into his mouth, knocking out two of his teeth, then made him load bag after bag of flour.</p><p>How Izaak must have seethed as this child eight years his junior laughed at him. He was surrounded by bullets. The mill even had a firing range for the Nazis to test them. If any of his jailers had possessed the courage to hand him a rifle, he would have shown them what a Jew could do.</p><p>Life expectancy at a Hasag camp was three months. Somehow, day by day, Izaak managed to survive for two and a half years, cleaning the equipment that manufactured bullets for his would-be executioners.</p><p>Beginning on January 12 1945, as the Soviet Army approached the city, the Nazi guards began a procedure that was being repeated across Poland and Germany. Faced with a choice of how to spend their remaining few days before liberation, many officers chose to destroy as much evidence of their crimes as possible. Sometimes this meant blowing up camps as they withdrew. Sometimes it meant burning vast stacks of paperwork. But it also meant one other thing: they had to get rid of the human evidence, as well. In many camps the dead were added to the towering pyres of burning documents.</p><p>The Nazis’ calculation was as simple as it was cynical: the fewer who lived to see liberation, the fewer witnesses available to testify against them. Any sort of military victory was beyond hopeless, but they could still do their best to wipe out the last third of Europe’s Jews. They couldn’t possibly shoot, gas or burn them all. So they decided to also recruit time and the bitter winter as weapons in one last nihilistic and cruel gesture.</p><p>In dozens of towns and camps, guards began rounding up anyone strong enough to stand. 750,000 prisoners in all were marched onto the roads or herded onto cattle cars bound for the interior of the Reich.</p><p>Over months, three quarters of a million people, who had managed to survive all sorts of indignities and horrors for six years, were now marched to death or shot when they could no longer continue. Scholars have called the death marches the “final phase” of the Nazi genocide, and have estimated that as high as a third of all camp prisoners, 250,000, died during them.</p><p>Somehow, Izaak’s luck held. Whether he was able to hide, bribe someone, or was simply in a inaccessible part of the camp when the transports started, he and several thousand other Jewish laborers managed to avoid the last attempt at completing the destruction of the Jewish community in Czestochowa.</p><p>A few days later the Soviets arrived. He and 5,100 other Hasag Jews in town had made it to liberation. Only 1,500 of them were pre-war residents of the city. From 46,000 to 1,500. It was the same across Poland, which had been the home to the largest Jewish population in the world before the war. Out of over 3 million, less than 45,000 were left, sick, traumatized and scattered, from France to Soviet Uzbekistan.</p><p>Many Hasag survivors called January 16 their second birthday. By bizarre coincidence, Izaak happened to have the same birthday as Hitler. Perhaps he preferred January 16.</p><p>He was 27, alone, but alive. Now he had some choices to make. Many of his friends and neighbors had concluded that Poland was a graveyard and saw no reason to stay. Over the next few years at least eight of his surviving relatives left for Israel, England, the United States, and even Germany.</p><p>We don’t know his motivations, but he couldn’t have been that pessimistic about life in Poland, as Izaak ultimately chose to stay. He appears sporadically in survivor records and phonebooks in and around his home town into the early 1950s. He Polonized his name to Jerzy, married and became a dental technician. Hopefully he was able to get his teeth fixed.</p><p>His story could have ended there. He had certainly earned a quiet life after his years in Hasag. But instead, Izaak decided to use his story.</p><p>** *</p><p>The survivors were given many names, but one Hebrew term has always resonated with me. One American rabbi working in DP camps named them the Sharit ha-Platah, the surviving remnant, or “the shard that was saved.”</p><p>Izaak was one such shard, a broken fragment of a larger whole, which he knew could never be reassembled. He could have given into despair. But instead he chose to bear witness.</p><p>In 1946, Ivanek was indicted in a people‘s court set up by the Soviet-backed Polish government. Izaak testified against him in open court. His cruelty and abuse were entered into the official record.</p><p>Even just having the court typist writing down Izaak’s name and story must have felt like a small victory, especially when he thought of all of the names that would never be spoken aloud again.</p><p>The court listened. Ivanek was sentenced to ten years in prison. What must that day have felt like?</p><p>Three months later, Izaak testified against the second Polish guard, Roman. Despite his personal cruelty, Ivanek had not been the worst of the trio. Roman managed to surpass him, personally executing up to 50 Jews after they were discovered in a hidden bunker during the liquidation of the Small Ghetto. Izaak told the court how he had seen the young man force three sick Jews out of the ghetto hospital to the cemetery, then shot them. On another occasion, he saw him shoot a Jew running from the hospital towards the woods. “He shot until the man fell still,” Izaak said. Roman was sentenced to life in prison, though he demanded a retrial the following year on the grounds of insanity.</p><p>That summer a young Pole broke into Izaak’s apartment and attacked him with an ax before stealing his dresser, clothes and underwear. The newspaper chuckled and called the man “an underwear lover.” Izaak pressed charges and the man got four years in prison.</p><p>That winter, there was another trial. Schmidt was a German policeman who had been involved in the occupation and liquidation. of Częstochowa, a man that had personally killed Jewish and Catholic Poles and then stolen their property off their bodies.</p><p>His defense presented twenty-three character witnesses. There were only two witnesses, both Jews, who testified against him. One was a former prisoner who returned from a DP camp in Italy to testify. The other was Izaak, still stubbornly refusing to let the past be forgotten.</p><p>In discussing the trial, one memorial book for Czestochowa commented, “A pogrom — like atmosphere prevailed in the courtroom and it became necessary for the police to intervene.”</p><p>This was not just rhetoric. Częstochowa was only a 2 hour drive from Kielce, the site of Poland’s largest post-war pogrom. Just a few months earlier, on July 4, over a year after the end of the war, a blood libel rumor had circulated through the town, coincidentally just as the residents were fearing that Jewish survivors would start demanding their property back. Communist militia and local mobs had surrounded the three story house that held the remants of another large Jewish community. Over five hours, they stormed the building and attacked the survivors inside. 42 Jews were killed and twice as many injured. One young man survived but had his eyes gouged out. The last thing he ever saw was children having their heads smashed in with bricks and steel bars. He heard his attackers cock a rifle near his head but decide he “wasn’t worth a bullet” since he would just die anyway. Two Jews from Czestochowa on the train to Kielce that day were identified by conductors and thrown to their deaths by other passengers.</p><p>And yet, despite the real threat of violence, Izaak and his former neighbor testified to what they had seen and to what this man had done.</p><p>The next year, in 1949, the last Polish guard, Marian, stood trial and was sentenced to 5 years in prison. A month later, Schmidt was finally convicted and hanged. And Izaak still wasn’t done.</p><p>Just three weeks later, he testified yet again, this time against a Jewish policeman who had helped round Jews up for the trains. Izaak refused to be intimidated. If he could survive Degenhardt, he certainly wasn’t going to be afraid of a courtroom.</p><p>True, the man was only sentenced to a formal reprimand but clearly, having a chance to speak about what had happened to him mattered deeply to Izaak. Maybe it was a way to process all that loss.</p><p>As I’ve reflected on Izaak’s story, I keep asking myself, what lessons can we learn from the Holocaust? Sometimes I have thoughtful answers. Other times I worry that the question is too presumptuous. Do we ever really learn from any genocide?</p><p>If there is one lesson I take from Izaak’s story in particular, it’s the need to carefully consider what courage and power really look like. Izaak suffered incredibly due to Germany’s military power. After the war Poland’s Jewish population continued to shrink, in large part due to a lack of political power in the People’s Republic.</p><p>Izaak could have been forgiven for thinking he had no power. But instead, he decided to use the one weapon he did have: the truth. His decision to tell his story, again and again, to judges and prosecutors, shows not only courage and optimism, but also tenacity. What must it have been like to continue living in a country with so many unhealed wounds, many of which still exist?</p><p>Izaak shows that real toughness isn’t about posturing. It’s about doing the right thing even when it’s hard, or even dangerous. He reminds us of the importance of telling the truth about the past, and the real opposition we can often encounter while doing so.</p><p>Much like 80 years ago, we live in a time when conspiracies, misinformation and technology make it difficult to determine if reality even exists. As we struggle to make our way through our contemporary moment, I think back to Izaak, and his simple but firm conviction that truth mattered.</p><p>If learning from the past is too much to ask, we can at least try to honor and remember it truthfully. If Izaak could be brave, so can we.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2e844b29dd80" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>