<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Anna Khachiyan on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Anna Khachiyan on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@annakhachiyan?source=rss-225c707a3d52------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 05:52:42 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@annakhachiyan/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Best Art Writing of 2014]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@annakhachiyan/the-best-art-writing-of-2014-4e99525fe50a?source=rss-225c707a3d52------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4e99525fe50a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Anna Khachiyan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Dec 2014 22:51:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-12-31T01:50:30.325Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2>The Best Art Writing</h2><h2>of 2014</h2><p><strong>So long, 2014. Here’s a list of things I read this year that you should too (in no particular order and biased toward the second half because who remembers what they were doing eight months ago).</strong></p><p>There’s a quote, commonly attributed to John Steinbeck, that the reason socialism never took hold in America is that Americans see themselves not as an “exploited proletariat” but as “temporarily embarrassed millionaires.” This is the aspirational message of branding, the one thing that was on everyone’s mind this year. (Incidentally, “normcore” is what happens when obscurantism has been evacuated of its cultural cachet and all that’s left is to recolonize is the mainstream.) It’s also the unarticulated theme that unites the selections below: not “capitalism” or “the internet” but the psychology that both makes possible and arises from the networked condition. These readings compel us to consider a truly radical alternative: a futurism not built on the ironic or dystopian acceleration of tropes from capitalism and the West. The kids are as mad as they are anxious. Can you blame them?</p><p><strong>1. Sam McKinniss on </strong><a href="http://adult-mag.com/jamian-juliano-villani-sam-mckinniss/"><strong>Jamian Juliano-Villani</strong></a><strong> (<em>Adult). </em></strong>Ostensibly about the scrappy, enviably talented painter from New Jersey but actually about what Susan Sontag called “the radical failure of an entire sensibility” — in this case, the art school mode of academic discourse.</p><p>Best insight: <em>From my point of view, the goal of young artists was not so much to activate rectangles as to secure guest spots at curators’ summerhouses so that they might pursue carefree lives of leisure on someone else’s dime, cultivating themselves in service to style without working to afford it.</em></p><p><strong>2. Christopher Glazek on </strong><a href="http://artforum.com/slant/id=47107"><strong>Generation DIS</strong></a><strong> (<em>Artforum). </em></strong>So you want to write a history of something that’s not only totally new but also basically ahistorical. How to do it? Why, by playing both sides, of course. Sympathetic yet sufficiently critical, <a href="http://news.artnet.com/art-world/the-most-important-art-essays-of-the-year-201567">according to <em>Artnet</em></a><em> (</em>glad we agree). Thanks to Glazek, you can now avoid the humiliation of sounding like a Marxist curator at your next soiree.</p><p>Best insight: <em>[I]n the age of Wikipedia, the ability to manipulate specialized vocabularies and esoteric knowledge was commanding less and less authority across the board, from Marxism to indie music…This was clear to many students, but not always to their professors, who understandably continued to ply the methods and methodologies that had helped them get tenure. As a result, many art-school grads were coming of age at a time when what felt most oppressive wasn’t consumer capitalism: It was the institutional codes and guild vocabularies in which they had been trained.</em></p><p><strong>3. Mostafa Heddaya on </strong><a href="http://hyperallergic.com/147061/delusions-of-grandeur-gcc-at-moma-ps1-and-the-new-museum/"><strong>the GCC at MoMA PS1 and the New Museum</strong></a><strong> (<em>Hyperallergic). </em></strong>Heddaya mounts a convincing polemic against legacy aesthetics masquerading as progressive politics by making an example out of the Gulf Cooperation Council, or GCC for short, an art collective formed, by its own admission, “in the VIP lounge of Art Dubai.” Irascible, unassailable and easily extrapolated to the art world at large, it’s the one you’ve heard me quoting like a broken record over dinner or at <a href="http://thepublicschool.org/node/37839">CBIC</a>. On a personal note — I can already tell this is going to be unpopular — it reminds me that the most effective counter to ethical indulgence of a typically Middle Eastern nature is psychological intelligence of a typically Middle Eastern nature. Hold on to your moral alibis!</p><p>Best insight: <em>Consider two futurisms: future-schlock, which ironically surfs the bewildering commercial and political discourse of change while staking no claim against it, and future-shock, which finds in the future imaginary a radical break from an unjust present.</em></p><p><strong>4. Agata Pyzik on </strong><a href="http://www.zero-books.net/books/poor-but-sexy"><strong>the aftermath of the Eastern Bloc</strong></a><strong> (Zero Books). </strong>I’m never not impressed with this independent publishing house and its precocious roster of authors, and true to form Pyzik’s new book about the way Eastern Europe perceives itself through the lens of the West is as fastidiously literate as it is casually funny. Unlike typical accounts, which inevitably slip into misplaced ostalgia or, worse, try to get with the neoliberal program, Pyzik wants to revive “the possibility of a non-Western idea of modernity and futurism.” Could it be that the twenty-five or so years since privatization were inherently more traumatic to the Eastern European psyche than anything visited upon it during preceding seven decades of socialism?</p><p>Best insight: <em>It is the brutal capitalist transition, the sudden loss of jobs and security by people who were never before endangered by unemployment…that made people unforgiving, hateful and vulnerable.</em></p><p><strong>5. Ben Davis on </strong><a href="http://news.artnet.com/art-world/ways-of-seeing-instagram-37635"><strong>selfie envy</strong></a><strong> (<em>Artnet). </em></strong>Davis is something of a Mohican among art critics — a confirmed Marxist and committed activist, whose 9.5 <em>Theses on Art and Class </em>is on my reading list for sometime-in-the-not-so-distant future. Naturally, his affinity for John Berger’s 1972 BBC-documentary-turned-book <em>Ways of Seeing </em>sets the tone, but not at the expense of critical interpretation. Topics include: the correspondence of typical Instagram genres to the traditional genres of painting, the idea that participation in a network can paradoxically be a source of alienation, the origins of FOMO, and so on.</p><p>Best insight: <em>[T]echnology makes possible many good things; political and economic conditions guarantee, however, that it is constantly warped so that the same kinds of bad patterns repeat themselves, in new and improved forms.</em></p><p><strong>6. Chloe Wyma on </strong><a href="http://www.brooklynrail.org/2014/09/criticspage/lean-back-resisting-branded-feminism"><strong>the branding of feminism</strong></a><strong> (<em>Brooklyn Rail). </em></strong>Adam Carolla, The Last Psychiatrist and other old men with essentially good instincts have been going on about this for half a decade now, but it’s nice to actually hear it from a young woman — lest we forget that others like ourselves exist while we out here getting our industrial-grade mani-pedis. In a year where Beyonce’s concert visuals made every “feminist” list from <em>Buzzfeed </em>to <em>The New Republic</em>, Wyma shows how feminism has been commandeered as the official lifestyle brand of a blinkered cultural establishment seeking to exonerate itself from its own moral indetereminacy. It’s true, girls do run the (art) world. Literally. They’re the administrative support.</p><p>Best insight: <em>These seemingly internecine art world problems are mirrored in culture at large, where branded feminism appears in the guise of once-radical gestures: from Lynda Benglis’s phallic woman, to the indiscriminate schlong-wagging of Miley Cyrus; from the mantra “the personal is political,” to countless “lady blogs” microscopping the daily minutiae of celebrities through a “feminist lens”; from the fight for equal pay to the “Lean-In” ideology espoused by Facebook executive and self-styled activist Sheryl Sandberg, which rethinks “revolution” as a greasy ladder that can be scaled through technocratic efficiency and a 24/7 work ethic.</em></p><p><strong>7. Brian Droitcour on </strong><a href="https://culturetwo.wordpress.com/2014/03/31/why-i-hate-post-internet-art/"><strong>the perils of post-internet art</strong></a><strong> (<em>Culture Two). </em></strong>The rigor of Droitcour’s verdicts calls to mind old-guard art theorists like Irwin Panofsky and Clement Greenberg. Here, he takes on the style that everyone loves hate but no one can quite define, inscribing it into the canon in the process. If you don’t know now you know. (Also: love how he named his blog after that one famous Vladimir Paperny book about Stalinism. Sigh.)</p><p>Best insight: <em>It’s like a new form of landscape painting, a view of the world as it is, and that’s why its visual vocabulary is hard to distinguish from that of advertising and product displays. An artist’s choice to make art that way — as a plain reflection of reality and the power systems that manage it — shows a lack of imagination, when there are so many other ways of making art available. Post-internet artists know what the internet is for, and it’s for promoting their work.</em></p><p><strong>8. Mike Pepi, William O’Hara and Dan Monaco on </strong><a href="http://www.thestraddler.com/201513/piece3.php"><strong>the content turdcutter</strong></a><strong> (<em>The Straddler). </em></strong>A meditation on the new feudalism of the digital model that looks at the way algorithmically-driven mechanisms for profit maximization and risk management erode the quality of creative content in favor of the aggregation and curation of prefabricated marginalia. It takes a village to write an essay this good.</p><p>Best insight: <em>Consider a specious practice now in wide circulation among online writers wherein a hyperlink to another text stands in for a summary of a term used, description of an event, historical contextualization, or detailing of a current debate. When an author in a digital text links to source material instead of finding the words himself, he relegates himself to aggregator and assembler of the pre-fabricated. This passive gathering laced with commentary does violence to the very notion that the reader should have come to the author for edification in the first place. This is nakedly an advent of the logic of digital writing under the pressures of commercial culture…</em></p><p><strong>9. Rob Horning on </strong><a href="http://thenewinquiry.com/blogs/marginal-utility/sharing-economy-and-self-exploitation/"><strong>self-exploitation in the sharing economy</strong></a><strong> (<em>Marginal Utility </em>blog, <em>The New Inquiry). </em></strong>A quick reminder that selfies and status updates aren’t as innocuous as they seem. Horning makes the crucial distinction between the collaborative and the merely collective, arguing that an underlying market logic offsets any perceived informational gains by siloing individual users and devaluing their labor reserves. The only social relations are business transactions; actual sharing is suspect because it’s inconceivable. Quick and dirty and not to be missed.</p><p>Best insight: <em>The rhetoric around sharing economy companies tends to celebrate their liberatory use of technology, which is held to irresistibly wring inefficiency from legacy social practices while freeing users from the dread burdens of inconvenience and transaction cost. But in fact the sharing economy epitomizes the deployment of technology to intensify inequality, in this case by creating monopolies that aggregate and co-opt the effort and resources of many users, who are pitted against one another within the platforms.</em></p><p><strong>10. Seva Granik’s </strong><a href="https://twitter.com/sevagranik"><strong>Twitter</strong></a><strong>. </strong>Uproarious in a gently apocalyptic way. Uncomfortably Russian.</p><p>Honorable mention: <strong>Marc Fisher’s </strong><a href="http://www.zero-books.net/books/capitalist-realism"><strong><em>Capitalist Realism</em></strong></a>, which isn’t from 2014, but which I read in 2014 and plan to read once a year every year for mental upkeep. Fisher articulates what we were all thinking: the only sane response to the capitalist condition is neurosis.</p><p>This list is also available on my <a href="http://www.annakhachiyan.com/blog/2014/12/29/best-of-2014">blog</a>. See you in hell…I mean, next year!</p><p><strong><em>Read more of my writing at </em></strong><a href="http://www.annakhachiyan.com/"><strong><em>www.annakhachiyan.com</em></strong></a><strong><em>.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Follow me </em></strong><a href="https://twitter.com/annakhachiyan"><strong><em>@annakhachiyan</em></strong></a><strong><em>.</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4e99525fe50a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Kim and Kanye Take Paris]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/thsppl/kim-and-kanye-take-paris-61d8854796c0?source=rss-225c707a3d52------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/61d8854796c0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Anna Khachiyan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 May 2014 22:11:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-11T20:11:53.065Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>I take apart the #KimyeWedding</h4><p>True to form, Kim Kardashian spent the days leading up to her Saturday nuptials to Kanye West competing with the scenery in a series of viral outfit changes.</p><p>First, there was a skintight Balmain that reminded me of Ladurée macarons and Louis XIV interiors. Next, there was the plunging Valentino that looked like it was literally made of money (actually, hundreds of appliqued butterflies). This was followed by a barely tasteful Margiela. At Valentino’s luncheon, <em>Vogue</em>’s caped crusader Andre Leon Talley complimented the china that once belonged to Elizabeth II of Russia. For the rehearsal dinner, Lana Del Rey was flown in to serenade guests with “Young and Beautiful,” a single, fittingly enough, from the soundtrack of <em>The Great Gatsby</em>, the movie version of the morality tale about what happens to people who put on airs. Kimye couldn’t get Versailles for the big day so they settled for the day before, setting up shop in its historic Hall of Mirrors, which is also my nickname for Kim’s Instagram.</p><p>The paparazzi may give you anxiety but the selfies will do worse, leaving you with a vague and misplaced sense of injustice. In a candid moment, Kim and Khloé posed in front of the Eiffel Tower by night, repeating the ritual performed by every other tourist before them since the advent of photography. Later, Kim returned to the scene, encased in leather, with bestie Jonathan Cheban, who wore a t-shirt that spelled “BOURGEOISIE” in thick, white lettering. None of us can fully appreciate what it must’ve felt like on the ground, surrounded by that menacing swarm of French-speaking well-wishers.</p><p>In the vortex of opulence and narcissism it’s easy to lose sight of the fact that this is, after all, a family affair. Alexander Wang, NeNe Leakes, Big Sean and Tyga rounded out a guest list of BFFs and relations: momager Kris, Kourtney and her hubby Lord Disick, Kendall (the model one), Kylie (the Tumblr one), La La Anthony (wife of Carmelo), Larsa Pippen (wife of Scottie), celebutante Brittny Gastineau and jeweler Lorraine Schwartz, the host of Thursday’s all-girl festivities. Bruce Jenner arrived in all of his tabloid shame. Somewhere not far away, Rob Kardashian was busy getting sewn into his suit. For his part, Kanye kept a low profile, letting his future ex-wife lead the processional. The world’s most beautiful woman is not only his to enjoy in private but ours to behold in public, a symbol of his discerning sensibilities.</p><p>Last week, at a panel on women in publishing, <em>BuzzFeed Ideas</em> editor Ayesha Siddiqi called Kanye her mentor. Kanye doesn’t ask permission, he simply does what he wants. She echoed Kanye’s own words to <em>Complex</em>: “If you’re a fan of Kanye West, you’re not a fan of me, you’re a fan of yourself.” It’s a revelation for minorities and immigrants, people, in short, who aren’t used to envisioning themselves in the sorts of creative roles that the privileged take for granted.</p><p>Of course, in art, there’s no denying that Kanye’s a revolutionary. But in life, he can be strangely conventional. As with all eccentric personalities, from Walt Disney to Warhol, contradiction amounts to character. For a self-professed minimalist, he sure likes buying stuff. And for all of his avant-garde leanings, he couldn’t have picked a more middlebrow soulmate. Kanye’s contempt for authority is intensified by his need for validation, and vice versa. He’s forever toeing the line between disrupting the system and being complicit in it.</p><p>Given Kanye’s considerable gifts for alienating people, we tend to overlook his actual talents. But watch his segment on the Kris Jenner Show and what stands out is his shy smile, a smile that radiates humility and sensitivity. Deep down inside, he’s a good kid who loves entertaining almost as much as he loves his mother. But what’s a mama’s boy to do when he loses his maternal figure? You have two options: slip into dysfunction or find a surrogate.</p><p>There’s a saying that goes when you marry someone, you marry their family. What seems like a Freudian nightmare for most people is the American dream for Kanye West. He’s marrying for his daughter and for his personal brand, but also, for the family he’s always wanted: large, loud, accepting, acquisitive. Say what you will about the Kardashians, but unlike other Hollywood dynasties—the Lohans and the Jacksons come to mind—they’ve never sold out one of their own or capitalized on his or her misfortune. Loyalty, not excess, is their most enviable quality.</p><p>Love them or hate them, you have to admit that Kim and Kanye deserve each other. But what did Europe ever do to deserve them?</p><p>Paris, of course, is the city of love and light. But it’s also the home of the earliest bourgeoisie, the premier destination of aspirational tourism and the birthplace of the department store. Its iconic iron-and-glass covered arcades were precursors of the American shopping mall. It’s the city where people like Rimbaud, who’s famous for being Patti Smith’s favorite poet, and Picasso, who’ll go down in history as Jay Z’s favorite painter, went to seek their fortunes. Kim and Kanye are in good company here, in this city of arrivistes.</p><p>Florence, where the actual exchange of vows will take place, has similarly middle-class origins. It was the seat of the Medici, the original media family, who began as bankers and reinvented themselves as statesmen and patrons of the arts. Their money financed the Renaissance, the most awesome of art movements. The site of the wedding ceremony is the Forte di Belvedere, a garrisoned treasury built by Cosimo I de’ Medici, Grand Duke of Tuscany, on a hill overlooking the city and accessed from his official residence in the city center through a network of secret passageways. The Medici, like the Kardashians, had many haters and it was imperative, in the event of emergency, that they could flee with their assets.</p><p>Kim and Kanye are merely the next generation in this illustrious history of kultural kolonizers. Kanye’s cavalier, sometimes comical appropriation of high culture forces us to examine it with a critical distance, exposing its underlying frameworks as snobbish and arbitrary. Why shouldn’t neoclassical architecture and modernist lighting fixtures be subject to the same anthropological scrutiny as, say, jazz music? By broadcasting his wealth, Kanye challenges the notion that good taste automatically equals restraint. But make no mistake: his minimalism has no ideology backing it, is purely aesthetic. Now that he’s conscripted Kim into his army of one, there’s no telling what they’ll desecrate next. We resent them, not because they’re rich or hot or actually pretty unremarkable, but because they undermine our moral alibi.</p><p>In spite of the backlash, Kim and Kanye have held their ground. In fact, they court the negative attention. The nature of coupledom is its conflict with society, the secret thrill of public disapproval, the adoption of an “us against the world” mentality. Take Tupac’s Bonnie-and-Clyde-inspired hip-hop allegory “Me and My Girlfriend.” Or, Jay-Z and Beyoncé’s Bonnie-and-Clyde-themed promotional video for their upcoming tour. Or, the real Bonnie and Clyde, whose brutal and senseless deaths, eighty years ago this day, have been recast as romantic martyrdom. Speaking to Angie Martinez last November, Kanye compared his relationship with Kim to another, this time fictional pair of martyrs, Romeo and Juliet.</p><p>But seriously, I’m dying to know what these two talk about when they’re alone in the crowd. “Babe, no one gets me like you do,” Kim drones in her daddy voice. “It’s not about branding at a certain point,” muses Kanye, looking all introspective. No wonder the pair’s April <em>Vogue </em>cover felt like such a victory. In another power couple’s recent collaboration, “Pt. II (On the Run)”, the track that plays during the trailer for their never-to-be-released short film, Beyoncé sings, “Who wants the perfect love story anyway? Cliché, cliché, cliché.” According to Kimye, who doesn’t?</p><p><strong><em>This story originally appeared on </em></strong><a href="http://revolt.tv/news/why-kanye-and-kims-wedding-is-the-most-perfectly-cliche-cultural-event-of-ever/66F77624-F028-47F0-8287-1F686BC6B6BD"><strong><em>Revolt TV</em></strong></a><strong><em>.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Read more of my writing at </em></strong><a href="http://www.annakhachiyan.com/"><strong><em>www.annakhachiyan.com</em></strong></a><strong><em>.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Follow me </em></strong><a href="https://twitter.com/annakhachiyan"><strong><em>@annakhachiyan</em></strong></a><strong><em>.</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=61d8854796c0" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/thsppl/kim-and-kanye-take-paris-61d8854796c0">Kim and Kanye Take Paris</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/thsppl">THOSE PEOPLE</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Magna Carta Holy Fail]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/thsppl/magna-carta-holy-fail-bd287b96df9?source=rss-225c707a3d52------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bd287b96df9</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Anna Khachiyan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 30 Apr 2014 02:48:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-02T13:41:17.495Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>What can Hova teach us about art? More than you think.</h4><p>Wednesday before last, you may have heard, Jay-Z gave an impromptu performance of his new single “Picasso Baby” in a hush-hush event at the Pace Gallery in Chelsea. The audience, if you could call it that, was studded with art stars, socialites and people who knew someone who could get them in. Jim Jarmusch. Glenn O’Brien. Bill Powers. Laurie Simmons (Lena Dunham’s mom). Judd Apatow (Lena Dunham’s mentor). Naturally, <a href="http://www.vulture.com/2010/11/kanye_george_condo.html">George Condo</a>, Kanyes’ sloppy seconds, was there. So was the aggressively fêted Marina Abramović. For six hours Jay performed the song over and over, sometimes individually, to a VIP in attendance—a feast of discomfort masquerading as a feat of stamina.</p><p>On <em>Vulture</em>, <em>New York’</em>s resident art critic <a href="http://www.vulture.com/2013/07/jerry-saltz-face-to-face-with-jay-z.html">Jerry Saltz</a> tells us how this performance piece-cum-freemason fundraiser went down:</p><blockquote>“Picasso Baby” teems with references to art. The first line is “I just want a Picasso, in my casa.” The last one is “I’m the modern day Pablo Picasso, baby.” The chorus repeats “Picasso baby.” There are name-checks of Leonardo; the Mona Lisa; Rothko; Francis Bacon; Warhol; Basquiat by first name, last name, and tag-name SAMO. There’s George Condo and of course that idiot savant Jeff Koons. Not to mention the Met, the Louvre, Tate Modern, MoMA, Christie’s, and Art Basel. One of the most well-known Americans since Muhammad Ali, just talking about not Lamborghinis and jewelry but about art? The thought that this might entice kids, intimidated by museums, to give them a visit? Come on! Whether it was going to be weird, cringe-worthy, or what: I was there.</blockquote><p>Jerry’s sipping on that Jaytorade if he thinks he can convince us with his casual agnosticism. It’s unnerving to see a premier art critic, one of two who actually gets paid to do the job (the other being his wife, Roberta Smith of the <em>New York Times)</em>, and a minor celebrity in his own right, dispense with his better judgment for a conversation starter about his brush with fame. Not that I begrudge Saltz for going because who wouldn’t? Only I feel confused and a little betrayed by the conciliatory turn of what feels like instinct overwhelmed by groupthink. (If I knew for certain that this canned critique was a matter of professional reputation, that would be one thing, but as much as Saltz strikes me as a savvy man and a man about town he also strikes me as a man of at least dubious integrity.) Saltz calls Jay-Z an impresario, a word so awesomely void of meaning that it cannot but inspire confidence. What he misses, however, is that art <em>is </em>the new Lamborghinis and jewelry. Kanye summed it up nicely in “New Slaves”: “What you want, a Bentley, a fur coat, a diamond chain? / All you blacks want all the same things / Used to be only niggas, now everybody playing / Spending everything on Alexander Wang.”</p><p>Sure, he’s complicit in the system, but what Ye gets that Jay doesn’t is that everyone, including himself, has been enslaved by capitalism. That sounds quaint, but there’s a reason that on Fashion’s Night Out, all you see on the street is a youth made up of women, gays and minorities. They’ve been sold the storyline that the only way to offset their ancestors’ historic woes is to own the American Dream, which nowadays pretty much means borrowing against your future self to finance your present-day “swag.” What they’ve come to believe in is that it’s ok to worship the status symbols of your colonial overlords so as long as you “make them yours.” But they do it without the sense of irony that was once at the heart of something like voguing culture. That’s not fighting the system from within, it’s subscribing to its authority, even if you’re only doing it for “research.”</p><p>This is the reality that Kanye’s been trying to reconcile in his own mind, bravely if somewhat sheepishly, by professing to be a minimalist in a rapper’s body. But at least he’s in the habit of thinking critically. At least he doesn’t shy from inconvenient truths. Even his public outbursts—Katrina, Taylorgate—have a ring of legitimacy about them. Kanye is unafraid to make the consumer squirm at the sight of his own moral alibi; in Jay-Z’s world the customer is always right.</p><p>Where Kanye’s wrong is in assuming that the war on America’s poor is solely and exclusively about race. In America, unlike in Russia say, where all anyone still talks about is status and pedigree, it’s a major gaffe to even utter the c-word in company. The vanguard of cultural and professional dilettantism gives us the impression that we’re a classless society. And yet. “That’s the ultimate race, poor people,” said comedian Adam Carolla. “White people, when they’re marginalized, when they’re denied meaning, when they are denied meaningful work, they become drug addicts too…Capitalism is fairly colorblind in the end,” said David Simon, creator of <em>The Wire. </em>If that’s too much of a bummer, consider why Beyoncé, Shakira and Britney Spears all look like the same person.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*9SUGcfpxcZDSLyeFmo3o-g.png" /></figure><p>Now that bling, minks and cribs have been evacuated of their symbolic power, the next best way to advertise your moral superiority is though art. And now that Jay-Z has bought everything he possibly could’ve short of the Kerguelen Islands, the only place left for him to go is the art world. Art-going is a less obvious form of acquisition than art collecting, but Hova can’t bear the idea of admiring something without being able to posses it. “Yellow Basquiat in my kitchen corner / Go ahead, lean on that shit, Blue / You own it,” he raps referring to his one-year-old daughter with Knowles. I don’t know what’s more insulting: that he’s already instilling her with consumerist values, that he’s using her yet unformed identity to glorify his own poorly formed one, or that the artwork itself is treated so carelessly, like a dishrag or pair of slippers. Of course, standoffish metaphors of wealth are the métier of rap, but Jay-Z pisses on propriety in a way that’s more reflexive than by design. The migration of taste from the conspicuous to the obscure is the new pastime of bored and overpaid urban achievers, putting an additional level of mastery between you and the rest of the proles. It’s still consumerism, only sublimated from brands to creeds, from things to ideas.</p><p>Jay-Z’s success, meanwhile, lies mostly in appropriating and repackaging the innovation of others. When Lil’ Wayne went from niche rapper to household name in the middle of the aughts, Hova took notice. Suddenly, his delivery became more asthmatic, his rhymes, more free-associative. They even cut a duet together, “Mr. Carter,” the second track off of Wayne’s triple-platinum 2008 album <em>Tha Carter III </em>and a play on their shared last name. The idea was that the symbolic father handed the torch to his younger, more-talented successor, but what Jay-Z had in mind was more like a timeshare. The new record, meanwhile, is filled with Kanyeisms, in the form of stripped-down beats and avant-garde posturing. It’s no coincidence that just as Ye comes out with that bit about romancing a Corbusier lamp, Jay starts name-checking Picasso and Warhol. He knows what looks like plagiarism now will pass for genius tomorrow; he can bank on our short attention spans for that. If you recall, it was Jay-Z who who vacated tales of street life of their meaning and turned them into vehicles for his mythology, the same thing he’s now doing to Koons balloons (Koons, alas, has him beat). Anyone can rhyme a word with itself; few can carry a narrative.</p><p>I get that liking Jay and Bey on principle makes people feel benevolent and sane, as if the entire culture isn’t caving in around them, but what can these two teach you other than how to match your curtains to your shams? And I get that Jay-Z wants desperately to be seen as “with it,” but all of his efforts seem competitive, cursory, <em>cheap</em>, down to his survey knowledge of art history. Congrats on skimming the Janson book, bro.</p><p>How can I take these people seriously, these parochial bozos who bought their daughter a pink Swarovski crib and pink satin baby pumps but burdened her with the name Blue Ivy? These people who couldn’t in a million years come around to the idea that to be cultured is to understand history and to understand history is to be humbled? Kanye once bragged, “most rappers’ taste level ain’t at my waist level.” That may be true of Jay-Z, who, if any credit is due him, has a paranormal talent for cozying up to the right people, which, in this case means rich white people. I’m sure he’s convinced that is interest in art is authentic, that’s how it always goes when you have a lot of walls to fill.</p><p>You may ask why give Kanye a pass? Aren’t they cut from the same cloth of indiscreet consumption mingled with moral indifference? As a matter of taste I like Kanye’s sound better so, on that point, we can agree to disagree. What’s not up for debate is that Kanye has a twisted sense of humor while Jay-Z is congenitally incapable of laughing at himself. Kanye isn’t scared to call black people out on their shit, which is what <em>all </em>people need—a bigshot from their own backyard who tells it like it is. Whereas Kanye’s parody of race betrays both a systemic understanding of the problem and a fundamental sense of compassion, Jay-Z radiates only a vague contempt for those he left in the dust. Of course, he also dusts them off selectively when it comes time to take his hood persona out of Gwyneth Paltrow’s dildo drawer. His cavalier attitude is partly an affect of wealth, partly a cover for the shame of being a handmaiden of the establishment. Jay-Z is truly the rapper of out-of-touch white people everywhere yet he’s still trying to convince us (and himself) that he’s “the man to watch.”</p><p>Note that Kanye’s interest in the avant-garde is genuine in that it exists outside of his ability and desire to make money. He knows art, having made some of it himself. Rightfully, he’s considered a tastemaker. Jay-Z’s interest, meanwhile, comes off as fundamentally shallow and insincere. He skims off the top, which is to say, the middle. That’s why Kanye will casually say some off-the-wall shit about race on air or punch out a paparazzo but every time you go to a Beyoncé or Jay-Z show, you have to hand over your cell phone and sign an NDA. Ironic that a guy with so little personality requires so much image control.</p><p>Still, nothing in Saltz’s account was more chilling than the moment Abramović made her entrance at 3:15pm and proceeded to agitate the crowd into an outpouring of misplaced feminist adulation with her high-handed, new-agey schtick that passes so well for artistic profundity. Of course, Jay-Z bought her act hook, line and sinker because someone—maybe it was Gagosian—once told him she was VIP. (Sidebar: how has this insufferable snake-oil salesman of a woman managed to convince everyone of the validity of her myth? Can’t help but admire the hustle.) Make no mistake: I’m not bemoaning the inherent commercialism of the art world, or that Jay-Z did this to drum up publicity, or that it was all a pretext for a music video. The problem with this scenario isn’t that there’s money backing things because money, after all, is the basest form of sincerity, but that the whole thing came off as insincere, wholly void of thought and passion. Like a true cynic, Jay-Z knows the price of everything and the value of nothing.</p><p><strong><em>This essay was originally published in response to Jay-Z’s performance of “Picasso Baby” at the Pace Gallery, New York on July 10, 2013. I republish it here on the occasion of Jay-Z and Beyoncé’s announcement of their tour of domination.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Read more of my writing at </em></strong><a href="http://www.annakhachiyan.com/"><strong><em>www.annakhachiyan.com</em></strong></a><strong><em>.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Follow me </em></strong><a href="https://twitter.com/annakhachiyan"><strong><em>@annakhachiyan</em></strong></a><strong><em>.</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bd287b96df9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/thsppl/magna-carta-holy-fail-bd287b96df9">Magna Carta Holy Fail</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/thsppl">THOSE PEOPLE</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Canceling Out]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/thsppl/canceling-out-e02b0cb8bb77?source=rss-225c707a3d52------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e02b0cb8bb77</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Anna Khachiyan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 Apr 2014 20:39:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-08-26T20:17:48.688Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The problem with Suey Park is be her critics.</h4><p>If you’re reading this you probably know who <a href="https://twitter.com/suey_park">Suey Park</a> is.<strong> </strong>By now, you’re certainly caught up on the controversy of #CancelColbert. Maybe you’ve even seen the response that aired on Monday’s episode of <em>The Colbert Report</em>. In the name of accuracy, it should be mentioned that Park never actually called for the cancellation of the show:<strong> </strong>the hashtag was devised as a means of provoking white liberals into addressing the latent but endemic racism in their ranks.<strong> </strong>The rest was an ironic joke, kind of like the one that inspired this whole thing in the first place.<strong> </strong>Now would also be a good time to mention that “hashtag” + “activism” = “hacktivism.” But Park is smarter than her critics in anticipating this critique. Her project absorbs its own contradictions. Her ends justify the means, no matter how many times they change position.</p><p>In the brief history of Twitter coups and uprisings, Park is a veteran, the brains behind a number of viral hashtags like #NotYourAsianSidekick, #POC4CulturalEnrichment and #BlackPowerYellow Peril. Like most of those reared on social media, she understands that the nature of persona is performance. Park identifies with Kanye’s politic: “There’s no reason for me to act reasonable, because I won’t be taken seriously anyway. So I might as well perform crazy to point out exactly what’s expected from me.” It’s logic like this that makes her a well-oiled hashtag-generating machine, and makes upstandingly unassuming staff writers for various respectable left-wing media outlets want to kill their dogs.</p><p>I won’t repeat the original joke here or comment on its comedic value, save to say that the <em>only </em>way to read it is as a basic, first-order critique of Daniel Snyder and the Washington Redskins. Take it any other way and now you’re the one who’s fishing for provocation. A few commentaries have brought up the point that the outrage over racial microaggression takes away from the bigger issue of blatant racism. Others have made the opposite claim, that the former, being both harder to spot and more widespread, poses the real threat to progress. What more is there to add when we can at least be in agreement about this juvenile gesture and the feeble piece of agitprop that inspired it?</p><p>Apparently, a lot.</p><p>For one, there’s the shadowy figure of Park herself. On the <em>New Yorker</em>, <a href="http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/newsdesk/2014/03/twitter-campaign-to-cancel-colbert-report.html">Jay Caspian Kang</a> attempts to sift through the bullshit. Kang writes, “[Park] said she saw the offending tweet while eating dinner Thursday night and decided to respond to it.” What’s wrong with this scenario? Kang is naturally concerned (for everyone’s sake!) that Park’s schtick could be interpreted as race-hustling and self-promoting but the greater unseemliness passes him by.<strong> </strong>You should be asking yourself not, “Was her response appropriate?” but rather, “What was she doing on Twitter at dinner?” I’m not interested in the particular factors that led her to forsake the sanctity of a meal for the scrutiny of strangers but I can tell you this for certain: Park is no more an activist than Stephen Colbert is a racist<strong>.</strong> “But, how can you say that?” The short answer is that her activism presents a paradox of sorts, for the extended play, see below.</p><p>Kang goes on: “Her degree of involvement in a hashtagged cause, she said, depends on how much ‘free time’ she has at the moment, and whether a particular issue piques her interest. ‘It’s not like I enjoy missing <em>Scandal </em>to tweet about <em>The Colbert Report</em>,’ she said.” Either he’s trying to libel her or they’re both totally missing out on the free samples of irony. Activism isn’t something you pick up and put down like the remote. Back in the day it could get you exiled to Siberia or, say, murdered execution-style in the lobby of your building. This sounds more like…channel surfing. But if hashtag activism was <em>actually</em> a day job, it would no longer be impressive or rewarding or fun, it would no longer be a distraction from your <em>actual</em> day job. Unlike Kang, Park has a sense of humor about it. Sort of.</p><p>In an interview with <em>Salon’s</em> <a href="http://www.salon.com/2014/04/03/cancelcolbert_activist_suey_park_this_is_not_reform_this_is_revolution/">Prachi Gupta</a>, Park describes whiteness as a “structural advantage” but acknowledges that its days are numbered. There will come a time in the not too distant future when white people are no longer the majority in America, if not by revolution then by reproduction (time accomplishes what revolution cannot). Interestingly, the most anxious debates about discrimination have come about at a moment when the silent fruits of Change have already gone public. For the first time ever, women of color are being represented in mainstream, front-facing creative professions like television and journalism.<strong> </strong>(Gupta is a good example. A better one is Mindy Kaling, who’s a multimillionaire like Colbert.) More interestingly, they appear at a moment when the creative class as a whole is in crisis, with increasing numbers of people willing to trade their labor for lifestyle instead of livelihood. In the New York, where the media is robust and women outnumber men in the hippest neighborhoods, WoC wield considerable influence in matters of public opinion, though the question remains whether anyone is actually getting paid for it. The flipside of discriminatory violence in poor areas is invisible quotas in rich ones.</p><p>The exception to the trend? Asians. Among women in general and WoC specifically, Asian women are overrepresented in “hard” industries like tech, engineering, medicine and science, industries which are traditionally seen as being hostile to women, industries, in short, where there’s still money to go around. Yet no one talks about it because the work is anonymous, requires math skills and a seemingly monastic patience for research, and actually hurts the case of the social justice warriors. It’s also a stereotype, one of the more flattering ones, anyway.</p><p>In the colonial era, white supremacy was the default. In the Internet age, we see it for what it is: a defense mechanism.<strong> </strong>Now that real bigotry has exhausted its potential for divisiveness, we’ve moved on to policing the minutiae of subjective experience in the hopes that we’ll find something, anything to explain away our lingering sense of discontent. But if white privilege inadvertently closes doors, white guilt swings them open, seeing as they both emanate from the same place of latent moral entitlement. Besides, every self-respecting WoC knows this because no self-respecting WoC wants to be somebody’s token bestie, or worse, their charitable write-off.</p><p>So what Park is actually referring to is the creative industry, which is commonly held to have issues with racism and sexism but really has a labor problem. And so, the brocialists have dug in their heels and the pop feminists have sharpened their claws. We’re all scrabbling for the only open seat at the same table. Park’s targets, after all, aren’t the Koch brothers or Karl Rove but nervous intellectuals from Greenpoint who’ve been known to turn their underwear inside out for a deadline. The “structural advantage” of whiteness is the symbolic power both sides have agreed to invest it with in order to protect their respective interests. That may seem like an academic point but it’s really the only one you should be worried about.</p><p>On <em>The New Inquiry </em>blog, <a href="http://thenewinquiry.com/blogs/zunguzungu/this-is-when-things-got-weird-and-ugly/">Aaron Bady</a> argues that Kang’s hedgy, negging language is an attempt to conceal his true sympathies for Park and her ilk in favor of broadcasting journalistic objectivity.<strong> </strong>In Bady’s words, “the background rises up to overshadow the foreground.” This and other turns of phrase I’ve bookmarked for future thinspiration, but not so fast.</p><p>Bady makes the key observation that Kang’s rhetoric (“I am ten years older than Suey Park, and, like her, I grew up in a suburban Korean household”) positions him as a more trustworthy version of her (“one who is older, wiser, sympathetic to her passion, but skeptical of her reasons”). But close read the subtext of Kang’s seniority and a darker picture emerges. Self-effacement is Kang’s métier. And it’s not for Park’s benefit that he does it, but for his own.<strong> </strong>Kang identifies himself as a peddler of words; not only that, but he makes his living peddling words on the Internet, oh little me. Park, by the strength of inversion, is portrayed as a hustler, a person whose powers of persuasion compensate for the essential paucity of her product, a foil for the man who makes an honest living as the thrall of ethics and circumstance. The effect is subtle and insidious: rather than malign Park directly, Kang makes eloquent circles around her avatar.<strong> </strong>This isn’t backhanded sympathy, it’s stifled hostility.</p><p>Later, he passes the baton to <a href="http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/04/the-perils-of-making-racial-insensitivity-a-firing-offense/359878/">Conor Friedersdorf</a> of <em>The Atlantic</em>: “This should be forgiven in a 23-year-old suddenly given a national platform on the strength of an innovative hashtag. But let there be no mistake about it: If the American masses are to reflect on their own beliefs and assumptions about race, the vehicle is far more likely to be a popular yet transgressive comedian, warts and all, than a magazine journalist like me or a Twitter activist like Park.” Again, the congeniality of the tone covers for the antimony of the message, alerting Bady’s intuition that there are two registers of meaning operating at once.</p><p>Don’t be fooled, it’s all for show. Kang may have Asian DNA, but he sure sounds like the pampered, conciliatory white liberals he’s criticizing. Like much of this tote-wearing cohort, he practices false humility as a means of asserting moral precedence over those who are more commercially viable, an aggressor masquerading as a victim. (Park’s virtue in all of this is that she’s simply an aggressor and, as she rightly points out in the vein of Susan Sontag, anger gets a bad rap.) Kang resents Park, not because she’s wrong, or because she actually has a point, but because she’s been more successful<strong> </strong>in parlaying a specious platform into a robust online presence, which, when cordiality is what’s for dinner, is the <em>only </em>kind of reputation worth having. He resents her youth and, possibly, her gender. He resents that what he recognizes as charlatanism and sophistry is perceived by others, 21.9K others last time I checked, as intersectional critique (whatever that means). But—and here’s where Bady perhaps extrapolates the underlying affinity—although Kang doesn’t believe that industry alone should be the sole criterion for fame he can’t help but admire Park’s industry.</p><p>Little do Kang and Friedersdorf know Park’s biggest problem is that she actually likes <em>The Colbert Report.</em></p><p>As <a href="http://www.thenation.com/blog/179084/whos-afraid-suey-park">Julia Carrie Wong</a> writes on <em>The Nation</em>, “the real problem most people have with Park is that she has power.” Note: she doesn’t specify what kind of power since it’s not really important whether the power is legitimate or productive, only that it’s trending (if 21.9K people agree, it <em>must</em> mean something). Hence, a setup that comes off as concerned or, at worst, paternalistic, but is actually competitive.</p><p>Kang says he’s always assumed, “fairly or not—that white liberals believe that as a person of color, I owe a debt of gratitude to the generations of well-intentioned white people who have fought hard for my right to write for prestigious publications.” Except that, whether he knows it or not, he’s lying. No white liberal would <em>ever </em>think that way about a person of color. (And if they did, it wouldn’t be within his earshot, so…#mootpoint.) In fact, they’ve all been Pavlovian-conditioned into reserving judgement about anything that doesn’t involve upmarket porn<strong> </strong>or Big Data, which is why psychology is the white devil but Big Pharma is a necessary evil. The condition of liberalism as it exists today is basically a masochistic disavowal of intuition taken to its absurd logical conclusion. Liberalism strives to be categorically uncategorical. It is context over instinct.</p><p>Kang joins a parade of others lamenting the loss of “nuance, complexity, and persuasion” in a public discourse that has been shoehorned into form fields and listicles. But, like the rest of them, he’s missing the point. Hashtag activism exists not in spite but <em>because </em>of<em> </em>the intellectual culture of the left. We can have this conversation in under 140 characters or in 2,500 plus words but the outcome will always be the same if what’s at stake is your moral alibi. To put it otherwise, Twitter is no less honorable a platform than <em>Slate </em>or <em>Salon </em>or <em>The Atlantic. </em>Read into that as you will.</p><p>What Kang is really saying (Buzzfeed pundits, cover your ears) is that he wants to feel indebted yet resents the feeling, knowing all along—as all of us do—that he is special, exempt. On one hand, Kang doesn’t want to conform to the unrealistic standards set by society (“white people…”); on the other, he doesn’t want the existential terror of not conforming to some kind of standard (“…prestigious publications”). Park has apparently bypassed this step to her advantage, and to Kang’s endless frustration. According to Friedersdorf, she “tricked the Internet,” which is to say, she gamed the system in a way we hadn’t thought of but which we can now dismiss as intellectually dishonest. It may be that society’s metric for the valuation of human capital is all wrong, but we’ll take it as long as we can reserve the right to complain about it later. You’d never admit this to your Marxist friends at the <em>Triple Canopy </em>mixer, but better the bar is lowered to reflect your personal experience than removed altogether.</p><p>Everything you need to know about the controversy can be found in these two sentences c/o Friedersdorf: “Park seems like a smart, energetic person with sufficient talent for a bright future. But #CancelColbert is a lazy, counterproductive critique.” It’s not the girl, it’s her schtick. Except, it is the girl, you said so yourself eight paragraphs ago, let’s not be passive aggressive about it.</p><p>Still, Kang’s injury stings more than Friedersdorf’s because, for all of their difference of opinion, the offending factor is always common ground. Like Kang, Park is Asian, but sub “Asian” for literally anything else (feminist, queer, trans, Klingon, whatever) and you have the Pavlov analogy again.<strong> </strong>The only way we know how to talk about mutually incriminating power dynamics is through symbolic proxies like race and sex. By design, the serious nature of the metaphor precludes a rigorous line of questioning. Look<strong>, </strong>I’m not saying racism and sexism don’t exist, only that they go both ways depending on who’s writing the check.</p><p><strong><em>Read more of my writing at </em></strong><a href="http://www.annakhachiyan.com/"><strong><em>www.annakhachiyan.com</em></strong></a><strong><em>.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Follow me </em></strong><a href="https://twitter.com/annakhachiyan"><strong><em>@annakhachiyan</em></strong></a><strong><em>.</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e02b0cb8bb77" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/thsppl/canceling-out-e02b0cb8bb77">Canceling Out</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/thsppl">THOSE PEOPLE</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>