<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Anteeniya Bell on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Anteeniya Bell on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@anteeniya?source=rss-e104905c8663------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 05:33:19 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@anteeniya/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[White Women “White Woman-ing”: A Review of Ruby Hamad’s Authorial Debut]]></title>
            <link>https://aninjusticemag.com/white-women-white-woman-ing-a-review-of-ruby-hamads-authorial-debut-e19719c611c3?source=rss-e104905c8663------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e19719c611c3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women-of-color]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Anteeniya Bell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 31 May 2021 21:39:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-31T21:39:25.680Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><em>(Potential spoilers ahead)</em></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VWjCj13p8mB3QKAp_H1e_Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>In <em>White Tears/Brown Scars: How White Feminism Betrays Women of Color</em>, Ruby Hamad continues her conversation exposing the ways white women preserve white supremacy through the weaponization of femininity, womanhood, and racial identity to actively oppress women of color.</p><p>Ruby Hamad is an Arab Australian journalist, author, and academic well-known for her article published in 2018 by <em>The Guardian</em> “How White Women Use Strategic Tears to Silence Women of Color”. In it, Hamad highlights the ways in which white women use emotional distress and anger to villainize women of color in the workplace. If you’d like to read the article, it can be found <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/may/08/how-white-women-use-strategic-tears-to-avoid-accountability">here</a>. Hamad is currently pursuing a PhD with the University of New South Wales in media studies and post-colonial studies, where she is researching biases and critiques of the Middle East and Arab people.</p><p>Published in 2020, <em>White Tears/Brown Scars: How White Feminism Betrays Women of Color </em>aims to discuss the historical role white women have held in the safeguarding of white supremacy through the oppression of non-white groups, and how this role has evolved in contemporary interactions with women of color — specifically in the workplace.</p><h3><strong><em>Main points</em></strong></h3><p>Hamad breaks the book down in two parts: “The Set-up” and “The Payoff”. In the first part, she investigates gendered stereotypes and attitudes attributed to women of color, from The Black Jezebel to Princess Pocahontas. In breaking down these stereotypes, Hamad highlights the explicit hypersexualization and sexual violence WOC experienced during beginning contacts with Europeans, as well as the distortion of non-white cultural practices — such as being bare from the waist up — that are perceived as atypical. Before the formulation of white sexual liberation politics during the second-wave feminist movement of the 60s, to partake in sexual acts “freely”, as was the perception of sexually insecure Anglo-Europeans, equated one to be animalistic and uncivil. For women of color to engage in sexual acts with European men, even when done consensually, defined them as sexually deviant and un-human, furthering the perception that WOC were deserving of inhumane treatment by European people overall.</p><p>Here, she explores the idea of the white damsel, a coping manipulation white women use to control interactions between themselves and BIPOC. This is fueled and upheld by the notion that the other-ness of BIPOC, which is deemed pathological, makes them a threat to white women at all times. Sexual violence from men of color was the largest threat to white women, as the most innocent, pure, and chaste of all women. Because white women are supposed to birth more of the white race, sexual relations between white women and men of color were outlawed — if a white woman was found to participate in sexual immorality, this would be seen as destructive to the virtue of white womanhood and the blemishing of white men’s property. The protection of white womanhood and its direct relation to property rights and sexual morality became justification for continued false accusations of sexual assault from white women towards Black and Brown men. This justification was used to perpetrate the torture and lynching of 14-year-old Emmett Till in 1955, and can be seen in the wrongful incarceration of Yusef Salaam, Kevin Richardson, Raymond Santana, Antron McCay, and Korey Wise in the Central Park jogger case in 1989.</p><p>To identify a woman of color with the title “damsel” would be wholly inappropriate, because race precedes gender identity. The hypersexualization of Black and Brown women makes it so that under the structural abuses of white supremacy and institutionalized racism, they cannot experience sexual violation. WOC have been deemed sexually deviant, so they are responsible and liable for the sexual violence and trauma they experience from white men, as well as the physical and emotional violence they face from white women. WOC are not women who can be saved; they are not innocent; they are not pure; they are not chaste. They exist outside of civil society, and so, they cannot fully integrate into a white supremacist society.</p><p>Maternal colonialism is a concept Hamad speaks about in great depth. By this, she identifies white women as co-conspirators in racial violence and colonization, not just bystanders. White women have had the privilege of hiding behind their identity as “woman” so as not to answer for the crimes they committed by being “white” — this is white women’s most destructive crime against WOC. In the white construction of pseudo-sisterhood, WOC have had to suffer in the workplace where Hamad says, “the historical debasement of women of color positions them as the guilty party” (109). This is how white supremacy permeates spaces defined as apolitical in overt ways.</p><p>In the second part, Hamad explores toxic white femininity in the workplace and how the white damsel trope has evolved in the employment sector. Here, she shares personal accounts where women of color were berated, suspended, harassed, or terminated from their place of work due to perceived aggression. Despite these beliefs being situated in racist stereotypes, as long as a tear fell from a white woman, a person of color often always pays for their falling. Employing emotional gaslighting and manipulation to wage war against women of color in the workplace is not a new phenomenon. This is a coping manipulation inherited from their ancestors, the maternal imperialists that removed children of color from their homes in order to “civilize the savage”. Now, this tool is used for distressed white women to gain sympathy from other white colleagues when being confronted with their own racist behaviors. It is a war cry, and one that white men have burned down villages, homes, and people for historically and in modern times.</p><p>In being able to victimize themselves as powerless, white women speak to the inner sympathizer that is said to exist in those who are civilized. How could anyone sit by when a white woman was in pain? This weaponized tool is what Hamad calls “gas-whiting”, drawing a comparison between the abusive behaviors of a narcissistic partner and the relationship people of color have with white society. And I believe and know this to be true. In this comparison, the author highlights the way the abuses BIPOC face are subverted by the pseudo-agony of their white abusers, who have perfected the art of warping the lived-experiences of Black and Brown people to their advantage. Here, it is noted that, “[t]his denial of our racial difference, even as we are simultaneously vilified for being different, means we receive very little empathy when we are on the receiving end of rather horrific abuse” (231).</p><p>Hamad emphasizes the modification of identity politics as well, in which white women continue their claim of being undisputedly oppressed and marginalized to silence the experiences of non-white peoples, and further, to distance themselves from the structures of power in which they benefit. Identity politics is a term coined by the Combahee River Collection (a Black lesbian socialist and feminist group based in Boston) in 1977. These women describe a political approach by which marginalized peoples develop political agendas based in the intersectionality of structural oppression that affects the livelihoods of those experiencing varying oppressions. With white women, the historical structures in which they’ve had to navigate deals solely with the abuses they’ve faced from white men, mostly gendered oppression. And while other issues that affect white women are real (like experiences with disability, sexuality, gender expression, etc.), these problems are not exhausted by the realities of race. Rather, white women often weaponize the other intersections of their identity (like being disabled, LGBTQIA+, neurodivergent, etc.) to hide the benefits they receive from their whiteness. In contrast, the marginalization and dehumanization women of color continue to face are compounded immediately by their racial identities before they are ever considered “woman”.</p><p>You don’t have to look far to see contemporary examples of how white women weaponize their womanhood. Following the election of Donald Trump to presidency in 2016, millions of white women around the United States marched in solidarity for women’s rights during the Women’s March — of which, overwhelmingly, they marched in solidarity with their definition of what it meant to be “woman”, so cisgender, white, and mother. Organizers preached that the march would call for the inclusion of all persons who support women, but failed to recognize the fact that 55% of white women voted for Trump despite dozens of allegations against the President of sexual assault, as well as his misogynistic and predatory comments regarding women’s bodies.</p><p>Without white women’s acknowledgment of their betrayal to Black and Brown women, the Women’s March remains a reminder to many women of color (whom have been direct recipients of the racist, xenophobic policies enacted by Donald Trump and Trump loyalists) that white women do not vote in solidarity of so-called “women’s rights”, but rather respond with racial loyalty aligned with the politics of white supremacy. This racial loyalty maneuvers through the structures of American democracy, wherein white people hold the greatest voting capacity since the system of institutionalized racism privileges them foremost, showcasing the downfalls of white feminism — or feminism lacking intersectionality. Prohibition of intersectional identities will almost always end with white women collapsing into the myth of white racial loyalty, and in voting for those they are racially loyal to, policies continue to be passed that inhibit the freedoms of all women in the United States, millions of whom are Black and Brown. It should be no surprise that the same percentage of white women voted again for Trump in 2020.</p><p>White women, property rights, and voting rights have a lengthy and turmoiled history. The right to own property and the right to vote were solely in the hands of white men, and white women were defined as property. In reinforcing these rights with the right to use human beings as capital, white women took to participating in this trade as well. Hamad references the work of Stephanie E. Jones-Rogers, whose book <em>They Were Her Property: White Women as Slave Owners in the American South</em> depicts the political affairs of white women in their movements to gain property rights, largely seen in their necessity to perpetuate racist and sexual abuse against enslaved Africans similar to white men. Hamad states, “[w]hite women…learned from a young age of their future role as mistresses and grew into this role, treating their parents’ slaves as both companions and subordinates,’’ underlining the indoctrination of young girls to exploit the conditions of enslaved African peoples (153). It is worth noting, as Hamad does, that when white women married, they went through immense lengths legally to ensure the rights to their property (enslaved peoples) and to keep their property separate from the property of their husbands and other male family members.</p><p>As the possession of private property became integral to the identities of white women in the South, voting rights became their next target. White women across the country began organizing, lobbying, and filtering influence, manipulating the white men around them to push for policies emphasizing their interests, until the suffragist movement gained fuel following the passage of the Reconstruction Amendments. White women focused their flames by dehumanizing Black men specifically, deeming it illogical that men that were formerly enslaved should have the right to vote before white women. With the justification that all Black people were inferior, immoral, and pathological, we see again that white women were not interested in furthering the rights of Black women because of their racial loyalty.</p><p>Next, Hamad discusses white feminism’s issues with Middle Eastern and Muslim women. When dissecting the prearranged messages and patronizing tones of the U.S. government towards the Middle East, she names First Lady Laura Bush’s radio speech, following the 9/11 attacks, addressing the Taliban’s “war on terror” as repressive to girls and women, misappropriating feminist rhetoric to save Brown women from the sexual and physical violence experienced by Brown men (199). In positioning white women as saviors to Brown girls and women, white female political figures fail to acknowledge the United States direct involvement in funding and founding terrorist groups like the Taliban, al-Qaeda, and ISIS. Today, we see many white women in high-ranking political positions, following in the footsteps of white men, and Hamad asks a critical question in the involvement of white women in destabilizing governments within the Middle East: “Are we to say that white women are rising in these ranks at a time when the United States just happens to be involved in several conflicts in the Middle East, or is it more likely that white women are once again leveraging imperialism for their own advancement and calling it equality?” (244).</p><p>In the concluding chapter of <em>White Tears/Brown Scars: How White Feminism Betrays Women of Color</em>, Ruby Hamad discusses the politics and privilege of passing. She begins by acknowledging her own personal experiences with racism, colorism, and white beauty standards — growing up grappling with her curly hair, colorist comments from her mother, and microaggressions heard from white coworkers regarding her Arab heritage. In describing the invisibility of whiteness through colorism, Hamad discusses the skin-bleaching industry, an industry that preys on the insecurities of those with darker skin. Marketing for these skin-bleaching products “[implicate]…that these products can transform their users’ entire lives’’ by illustrating fairer skin as preferential for potential partners, employers, and future children (210). Throughout the continents of Asia (where India has the most aggressive marketing) and Africa (where Nigeria has the most users of skin-bleaching products), we see that desirability, attractiveness, and status are all intertwined with having lighter skin. So, it would be understandable to see how non-Black women of color would try to distance themselves from Blackness as a way to attain palatable status; because dark skin is always associated with Blackness, and because through white supremacy, colorism is a tool to oppress all who have darker skin.</p><p>In the ability to pass as white in certain settings, Hamad admits that she hasn’t experienced other aspects of racism because she understands that Arab people with darker skin receive the most negative associations and stereotypes because of skin tone alone. And still, Hamad has experienced racism because the structures under which racism operates treats all who are Arab, Middle Eastern, and Muslim as a monolith. BIPOC are always representatives of their entire communities when in conflict with agents of white supremacy, and in these interactions we become equated with every person sharing our racial identity. This is why when holding conversations with white coworkers, WOC often have to filter and self-censor their language, tone, and posture to best fit the emotional instability of white women in the workplace. Arab, Middle Eastern, and Muslim women are often hyper-masculated, being seen as instant threats to the physical, emotional, and psychological safety of white women — and following these interactions, the gas-whiting continues. And regardless of how “pro-women”, “feminist”, and “girl boss” white women claim to be, they will often always fall into the white damsel, relying on their toxic femininity to villainize WOC in public and private spaces; this will always be a reality non-white women face.</p><h3><strong><em>Final thoughts</em></strong></h3><p>As a social critique of the role white women play in the maintenance of white supremacy, I believe <em>White Tears/Brown Scars: How White Feminism Betrays Women of Color</em> is essential for all who aim to become better allies to women of color, especially within the workplace. The abuse white women hurl towards WOC is normalized because non-white people have been socialized to tolerate these harmful behaviors and white women have not been exposed in their systemic participation in white supremacy through the weaponization of their emotions. By painting WOC as hypersexual, deviant, and combative, white women are painted as innocent, pure, and chaste — a direct, binary parallel that is also perpetuated in interactions between WOC and white men.</p><p>I think this book also highlights the historical and contemporary experiences of women of color not often discussed in public discourse, like women who are Arab, Aboriginal, South Asian, Pasifika, and Indigenous. Including these different women’s experiences is important in creating stronger alliances between women of color globally. If we think about the alliances built between WOC during the third-wave feminist movement, we can see how those alliances can still hold strong, transform, and evolve as the systems that oppress us have. When WOC feel divided and isolated because of our experiences, we are less likely to vocalize them; by exposing our shared mistreatment by white women and their white tears, we can begin to address the ways we can de-escalate emotionally intense interactions with white women, protecting our full and authentic selves, and further, dismantle white supremacy.</p><p>I am also a strong believer in creating works that can be consumed by many audiences, and the employment of certain types of language can inhibit the way broader audiences interact with intellectual property. By using personal and historical accounts of women of color and translating those experiences into colloquial language, I believe Hamad ensures the accessibility of her work to all people. In order for people to educate themselves, they have to have a starting point and I believe Hamad’s work is a great point to initiate conversations addressing social inequities Black and Brown women face from white women.</p><p>I also think that Hamad’s use of “brown” to describe women of color is interesting. In the author’s note seated at the beginning of her book, Hamad acknowledges the limits of language in regards to race and racial denotation, stating, “[i]t is important to understand that virtually all terms when discussing race are imprecise because race is an imposition, not a biological reality” (xv-xvi). In regards to the title of the book, she uses “white” as an identifier for those with racial privilege due to proximity to whiteness and “brown” as an umbrella term for all who are not considered “white”.</p><p>She does make a distinction of the term “black” from “brown”, which I found intriguing. In comparison to other literature and public discourse surrounding the distinctions, I feel that Hamad includes Black women in the discussions of racism experienced by white women and not outside of the experience — since, this is an experience shared with many other women of color who are non-Black. I believe that because of the pervasiveness of anti-Black racism, some non-Black women of color have used the identifier “brown” to distance themselves from Blackness in a way that continues to encroach on the humanity of Black women and push Black women out of spaces where they share experiences with other women of color. It is refreshing to see that Hamad continues to use examples from Black women in her writing, and I believe that her book serves as a way to bridge the gap between non-Black women of color and Black women.</p><p>In conclusion, I believe that <em>White Tears/Brown Scars: How White Feminism Betrays Women of Color</em> is vital to public discourse critiquing white feminism and the toxicity of female empowerment (through the lens of white womanhood) in the workplace. In providing historical accounts of white women’s abuses as well as first-hand accounts from women of color who have experienced those abuses, Ruby Hamad delivers an impressive recording of just how pervasive racial loyalty and gendered betrayal is integral in the experiences of being both “white” and “woman”. I hope that for every woman of color that picks up this book, they find comfort in knowing that their experiences are not singular and are in fact, shared.</p><h4><strong><em>Recommendations</em></strong></h4><p>If you are interested in more books or writers that speak about women of color and their experiences with racism and sexism, I would suggest the following:</p><p><strong>Books</strong> (* = books I’ve read)</p><ul><li><em>Hood Feminism: Notes from the Women That A Movement Forgot</em> by Mikki Kendall</li><li><em>This Bridge Called My Back: Writings from Radical Women of Color</em> by Cherrie Moraga and Gloria Anzaldua</li><li><em>Women, Race, and Class</em> by Angela Davis</li><li><em>All the Women are White, All the Men are Black, But Some of Us are Brave</em> by Gloria T. Hull, Patricia Bell-Scott, and Barbara Smith</li><li><em>Ain’t I A Woman: Black Women and Feminism</em> by bell hooks</li><li><em>Sister Outsider</em> by Audre Lorde*</li><li><em>I, Rigoberta Menchu: An Indian Woman in Guatemala</em> by Rigoberta Menchu*</li><li><em>Assata</em> by Assata Shakur*</li><li><em>Their Eyes Were Watching God</em> by Zora Neale Hurston*</li><li><em>Borderlands/La Frontera: The New Mestiza</em> by Gloria Anzaldua</li><li><em>Zami: A New Spelling of My Name</em> by Audre Lorde*</li><li><em>All About Love</em> by bell hooks*</li><li><em>Loving in the War Years</em> by Cherrie Moraga</li><li><em>Heart Berries</em> by Terese Marie Mailhot</li><li><em>How We Get Free: Black Feminism and the Combahee River Collective</em> by Keeanga-Yamahtta Taylor*</li></ul><p><strong>Women, Collectives, &amp; Orgs</strong></p><ul><li>Audre Lorde</li><li>bell hooks</li><li>Patricia Hill Collins</li><li>Kimberle Williams Crenshaw</li><li>Angela Davis</li><li>Ida B. Wells</li><li>Gloria Anzaldua</li><li>Cherrie Moraga</li><li>Grace Lee Boggs</li><li>Combahee River Collective</li><li>Lolita Lebron</li><li>Yuri Kochiyama</li></ul><p><a href="https://aninjusticemag.com/">An Injustice!</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e19719c611c3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://aninjusticemag.com/white-women-white-woman-ing-a-review-of-ruby-hamads-authorial-debut-e19719c611c3">White Women “White Woman-ing”: A Review of Ruby Hamad’s Authorial Debut</a> was originally published in <a href="https://aninjusticemag.com/">An Injustice!</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[K-POP, Antiblackness, & Accountability: An Open Letter]]></title>
            <link>https://aninjusticemag.com/k-pop-antiblackness-accountability-an-open-letter-1d6c05d3cabc?source=rss-e104905c8663------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1d6c05d3cabc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-appropriation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-blackness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kpop]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Anteeniya Bell]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 17 Mar 2021 21:55:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-17T21:55:55.319Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>My experience as a Black and Korean K-Pop fan, although difficult and tiring, taught me the value of speaking up as a means to empower myself.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*xYIdsdcy_-PoznwsoePSuA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Various Korean celebrities appropriating dreads, locs, and braids.</figcaption></figure><p>I spent my formative adolescent years as a K-Pop fan, dedicating my time and heart to maintaining fan pages, awaiting English subtitles, and exploring YouTube for fuzzy fan cams. Despite believing the K-Pop fandom to be one of inclusion and compassion, hostility became routine from other fans when I began calling out K-Pop idols for their appropriation of Black culture. In turn, non-black fans labeled the behaviors of these idols as either naïve, unintended, or simply pardonable, acting as a constant reinforcement to their harmful behaviors.</p><p>Every day was exhaustive. I collided with bigots online to preserve my personhood. I am Black and Korean, and this means that my lived-experience is not only a synthesis of two cultures but also that my existence has exposed me to the antiblack politics persisting in Asian spaces.</p><p>The social exclusion and racist attacks I have been subjected to are common to many Black K-Pop fans, and indeed I have faced certain types of aggression from others while being Black in the Korean community. When participating in the infantilization of K-Pop idols’ antiblack behaviors, K-Pop fans socially and financially reward those behaviors as light-hearted.</p><p>I must admit that my self-worth and value as a Black adolescent were altered due to the continuing harm I internalized. I struggled to come to terms with my identities; a part of my heritage actively engaged in antiblack exploits to gain social and economic recognition without acknowledgment of my existence in shared spaces. It felt violent and it was. Predominant Asian environments expected collective assimilation, and I felt unable to express my Blackness and Asianness because of the limited volume and desirability afforded to me. The erasure and exclusion of my Blackness were demanded regardless of the history, culture, and traditions I shared with other Asian people; and these were often dictated by East Asian colorism and bias. Even from 6,000 miles away, K-Pop idols and fans alike took part in constraining my humanity and identity in ways reminiscent of my own Asian family’s treatment of me. I had to compress my Black identity while parts of my humanity were absorbed by covert, open, and violent racism.</p><p>Antiblackness is a tool of white supremacy, necessitating a lack of recognition in the humanity of Black people. It is more than a blanket term like racism, which can be experienced by nonwhite people overall. Antiblackness describes the ways in which non-black people preserve white supremacy, reaping socioeconomic rewards of non-Black status and opportunity for mobility by refusing to acknowledge the ingenuity of Black history and modernity. Antiblackness is more specific than instances of discrimination and prejudice, two terms commonly discussed alongside racism, because it identifies the active participation of non-black people in maintaining white supremacy through the exploitation of Blackness. This brings forth antiblackness as a tool of oppression employed by those who are non-black.</p><p>Antiblackness in the Korean music industry appears in the visuals presented to the global entertainment market: a ludicrous model that distorts Black culture through stereotypes and racist caricatures. It looks like Korean hip-hop groups usurping dreadlocks and cornrows. It is displayed as the darkening of skin tone to look intimidating, commodifying visual perceptions of Black people as threatening. It is exhibited in reality shows where K-Pop idols participate in blackface for parody. It is Big Bang — the “Kings of K-Pop” — having repeated N-word scandals and member Seungri stating that after a visit to America, he was happy not to have encountered a Black person for fear of being shot.</p><p>In an industry that exploits Black innovation, there are no Black faces. Few Black people have been able to retain success or audiences compared to Asian K-Pop idols who have demonstrated a lack of critical understanding towards Black culture. For example, Lee Michelle is a Black and Korean singer who became known in a popular Korean singing competition for her powerful voice and strong performance. Despite immense talent and versatility as both a rapper and singer, Lee Michelle has not reached the fame or popularity of idols like Zico from Block B, Hwasa from Mamamoo, or RM from BTS.</p><p>These idols all have documented — and for some, repeated — instances of appropriating Blackness for aesthetic appeal and benefit. To compare, despite multiple instances of using blackface and the N-word, Hwasa from Mamamoo has 5.1 million followers on Instagram while Lee Michelle has just over 7,000. For a brink of time, there was Wa$$up — an all femme ensemble that debuted as a twerking group, whose members wore box braids and sought to counterfeit Blackness in an embarrassing attempt to be “the first twerking girl group”.</p><p>Altogether, these add to an ongoing list of racist cosplay against Black culture, based on the dehumanization of actual Black people and self-evident in the audiences who reward Asian celebrities that capitalize on Blackness for scandal, fame, and profit.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8CaIzZVqgWVCO10OJWy4Ow.jpeg" /><figcaption>Rich Chigga advertising his new merch on Twitter. Image posted in 2017 and still available.</figcaption></figure><p>In the United States, we have seen a similar path followed by Rich Chigga, now-monikered Rich Brian — a Chinese-Indonesian immigrant who gained fame in 2016 for an online hit, but more controversially for his racist stage name. His deliberate commodification of rap music, the N-word, and misconstrued perception of Black life all served as catalysts for a music career dripping with financial success. Rich Chigga, whose real name is Brian Soewarno, was rewarded for his antiblack exploits by his Asian American audience, thus fueling his self-proclaimed ability to tap into what he believes to be “Black” and “rap” and “hip hop”. These days, Brian notes his decisions as unfortunate and not representative of his person today — launching a rebranding to more Asian-centric music, though continuing to profit monetarily from the fame, audience, and fanbase he garnered because of the scandal surrounding his name. And Brian has yet to acknowledge his behavior as anti-black or racist.</p><p>An interesting digression is to be noted in Brian’s ability to assume Blackness-for-profit and then rely on his Asian immigrant identity as a fallback to criticism. What Brian refuses to acknowledge are the advantages and socioeconomic privileges Asian immigrants are granted by contemporary U.S. immigration policies in relation to other nonwhite ethnic groups — privileges perpetrated on U.S. soil through the color of the law, antiblackness, and colorism. Certainly, as a lighter-skinned person, this is a social advantage to Brian.</p><p>Consider, on the other hand, Grammy-award-winning rapper 21 Savage — an undocumented Black immigrant from the U.K. who was targeted by ICE and faced deportation proceedings in 2019. 21 Savage’s treatment is not the only representative of the historic trauma experienced by noncitizens in the United States, but also representative of the abuse undocumented Black people encounter due to both race and lack of status.</p><p>The rapper’s lawyers are adamant that he was targeted by ICE because of his growing popularity and honesty about his status to his audience. Despite winning his Grammy one year after being detained by ICE, 21 Savage is still being threatened with deportation by the U.S. government and could be barred from entering the country for 10 years following. Whereas Brian and 21 Savage are both deemed immigrant peoples, the fact remains that Brian is unable to tap into the realities of Black, rap, and hip hop as experienced by 21 Savage.</p><p>The relationship that exists between artist and consumer — and even further, what kind of artists are palatable for mainstream consumption — is largely dictated by those bestowed with the power to purchase. Fans of Rich Brian are responsible for his continued prosperity in the same fashion that non-black K-Pop fans are responsible for their consumption of anti-black visuals and behaviors. The fact remains that consumers are complicit in normalizing systemic structures that exclude Black artistry and facilitate antiblackness.</p><p>K-Pop fans’ hyperconsumption of anti-black visuals is founded on the fetishization of two areas of identity and politics: (1) aesthetic Blackness and innovation and (2) whiteness as a standard and tool for structural mobility. Intrinsic in the construction of whiteness is the awareness of power as a structuring tool that modifies the reality of those deemed inferior and pathological: Black people.</p><p>Systemic racism works to infiltrate, confiscate, and subjugate; and it is always violent. The brutality exhibited by those participating in the destruction of Blackness is experienced by those harmed psychologically and physically. In standardizing whiteness, the rewards for accomplices lie in employment, housing, medical care, educational opportunities, and for some, fame. These assets are established for K-Pop idols in the same ways they are established for legacy children in the Ivy League college system in America.</p><p>Mainstream music owes everything it has to Black culture. K-Pop as a music genre has origins in Pop and Hip Hop, two categories of music constructed from the creative souls of Black people. Non-black fans of K-Pop — like white fans of rap who love Eminem — often have a pronounced preference for K-Pop and K-Hip Hop over real Hip Hop, which is a Black genre in origin and popularization, bred from the struggles and trauma of those I share history with. Antiblackness continues to be upheld by the fans who line the pockets of their favorite artists, and there exists no consequence for those who appropriate and those who abet the appropriation.</p><p>There is work for Black people in their capacity to write and produce for K-Pop bands, but undeniably, the music they create is rarely recognized as originating from Blackness itself. In the same way that the American music industry follows a model of exploitation regarding Black creativity, the Korean music industry has adopted comparable replication. In a country virtually lacking a Black population, South Korea has managed to codify language in a way that disadvantages its citizens from participating in an open dialogue about the systematic mistreatment and exploitation of Black vernacular, Black music, Black dances, Black fashion, and Black art in their past and contemporary forms; in all, Black ingenuity itself.</p><p>How can South Korea address their profiting off of Blackness desolate of Black faces? The business of factory-making K-Pop idols is a lucrative one and the South Korean global economy thrives off of the misrepresentation and packaging-for-consumption of Black culture. Billions of dollars are made every year on Korea’s largest national export: Korean culture. They manufacture this hot commodity through their K-Pop idols — their cultural ambassadors to the world. With the international success garnered from the rise of BTS outside of Korea, the industry is set to expand exponentially as long as their supply does not cease.</p><p>This unwillingness to hold themselves accountable allows the Korean music industry to manufacture Korean replications of the Kardashians; they operate as Black without Blackness and, therefore, are unaccompanied with the knowledge of historical, social, economic, and political trauma shared by Black people. The ability for a non-black person or industry to manipulate Black culture for the monetary benefit and receive positive reception in awards, accolades, and honors aids directly to the disenfranchisement of Black people worldwide.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rsvEgcLX33JIBor4WHZ5Hw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A painting of George Floyd stands behind a group of people gathered at a memorial on June 2, 2020, on the block where Floyd was killed by police in Minneapolis. | Stephen Maturen/Getty Images</figcaption></figure><p><strong>With the murder of George Floyd and Black Lives Matter protests happening around the world — sparking the largest global participatory protest in history — South Korea has a moral responsibility to bring discussions of antiblackness forward.</strong></p><p>Their global platform exists solely because the Korean economy profits off of a warped portrayal of Blackness based on stereotypes originating in white supremacy. In the last five years, South Korea has participated in many conversations brought to the global stage — like women’s rights, mental health, and police brutality. South Korea, too, must reflect and create awareness because of its platform.</p><p>An opportunity for change is possible and it begins with the intentional decisions of consumers. K-Pop fans have the ability to critically assess the ways in which they choose to show support to their idols. The dialogue South Korea has failed to facilitate can be initiated in fan spaces. Cultural awareness and respect can be effective approaches in creating empathy between people; to learn from one another and educate each other allows for the continuance of our own humanity because what is more human than our natural disposition to learn.</p><p>I don’t have a solution for the problems discussed in this letter, but I recognize that in living and learning, people come to better themselves. K-Pop fans have a responsibility as consumers to be critical and show conscious awareness. Starting dialogue in online spaces where K-pop fans gather can contribute to intersectional movements for equality worldwide, one conversation at a time.</p><p>Racism and antiblackness cannot always be explained to non-black folks, but they are always experienced by Black people. My experience as a Black and Korean K-Pop fan, although difficult and tiring, taught me the value of speaking up as a means to empower myself. My Blackness is valid. My Korean-ness is valid. And within myself, I am those identities without debate.</p><p><a href="https://aninjusticemag.com/">An Injustice!</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1d6c05d3cabc" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://aninjusticemag.com/k-pop-antiblackness-accountability-an-open-letter-1d6c05d3cabc">K-POP, Antiblackness, &amp; Accountability: An Open Letter</a> was originally published in <a href="https://aninjusticemag.com/">An Injustice!</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>