<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Antonio Lopez on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Antonio Lopez on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@antoniolopezcerrato?source=rss-17f4b54a6add------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 20:03:21 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@antoniolopezcerrato/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tradition and the Beautiful Game]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@antoniolopezcerrato/tradition-and-the-beautiful-game-9e3a33695133?source=rss-17f4b54a6add------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9e3a33695133</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tradition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sports]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fifa]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Antonio Lopez]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Feb 2016 01:31:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-01T01:31:07.001Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The 1966 FIFA World Cup was hosted in England. After the group stage and several play-off rounds, the final paired off the local English-men against the West-German side. Already in the second half of the final, England and West Germany were tying 2–2. Then, Geoff Hurst — a legendary English striker — received a ball in the area and shot towards goal. The ball was repelled off the woodwork, bouncing right in front of the goal line before being kicked off the field by a West-German defender. Despite the ball not entering the goal, English players and a great portion of the audience at the stadium thought the ball had bounced inside and complained to the Swiss referee Gottfried Dienst. After checking with his lineman, Dienst succumbed to the pressure and gave England a goal that would prove to be decisive in the result of the World Cup, as they would win it. Since that date, their have been several famous occasions in important tournaments where goals are awarded incorrectly or — the opposite scenario occurs — the ball goes in and the goal is not awarded. Unlike several modern sports, soccer referees are not aided by any type of technology when making their decisions. While other referees have replays or sensors, soccer referees have to make their decisions solely on what they saw. Due to the speed of the plays and the pressure they have, soccer referees make mistakes. Even though this happens rarely, the general community wanted a permanent solution to this problem to prevent similar scenarios from repeating themselves.</p><p>The solution to this problem is goal-line technology. The method is simple: the ball has an implanted chip in the spherical center of the ball and the goal has three sensors — one in each post and another on the woodwork — that tell the referee when more than half the ball has entered the goal. The system was invented by British mathematician Paul Hawkins and has been successfully implemented on other sports previous to soccer: cricket, gaelic ball and tennis. The invention has been around for some years already, but it has only recently been approved by FIFA to be implemented on soccer — and that is the innovative part of it. This would prevent incidents like the one of 1966 World Cup from occurring again in the future. The solution was approved in 2012 and started to be implemented in the British Premier League this season in preparation for the Brasil 2014 World Cup. For anyone who is not extremely familiar with soccer rules, the issue might be hard to understand. The referees word is final. If he concedes or fails to concede anything — foul, goal, corner, etc — as obvious as the call was, there is no challenging his decision. Players, coaches and fans can complain and curse at the ref, but he will still execute what he considers the right decision. There are no replays, no hawk-eye, no challenges like in other sports. Goal-line technology comes to be an aid for the referee to make his decisions.</p><p>Despite solving a problem in soccer, goal-line technology has been received with a lot of criticism. Josep Blatter — the president of FIFA and one of the most influential voices in soccer — was very critical of the system. He said, “Other sports regularly change the laws of the game to react to the new technology… We don’t do it and this makes the fascination and the popularity of football”. One of the drawbacks of including goal-line technology, according to Blatter, would be loosing this ‘fascination’ the game has. Soccer is greatly based on tradition. Since 1863 when the rules were first written, there have only been six amendments to the original laws. It is this simplicity that many soccer figures and fans alike are proud off adding to some sort of tradition aura that makes the game the most popular sport in the world. Blatter argued that having some sort of human error factor into the game added a layer of debate and memorability into the sport. Taking that away, he argued, would be more detrimental to the sport’s spirit, than beneficial in preventing unfair calls. It is interesting to think how innovation can paradoxically both contribute and take-away from something — in this case soccer — purely by removing the option of mistakes.</p><p>Mistakes are not necessarily something bad, in this case, as they add, according to Blatter, to the tradition of the game. They are human, and their presence, more than taking away, add a small touch to something like a sport. Stefon Harris goes into a similar idea on his TED Talk <em>There Are no Mistakes on the Band Stand; </em>he says, “It [the bandstand] is a sacred space. And one of the things that is really sacred about it is that you have no opportunity to think about the future or the past… There is no such thing as a mistake”. We can think of the sacredness of the bandstand — and similarly of a sport like soccer — some feeling, idea and/or emotion that embodies tradition, improvisation and this idea of no return (there is no coming back from an action). In both cases, bandstand and soccer field, mistakes add to this feeling of tradition like an ‘opportunity’ contributing to the mystique of the activity, rather than taking away from it. In the TED Talk, Stefon Harris says that mistakes are ‘opportunities’ since musicians can take advantage of a fellow musicians ‘mistake’ and develop on in, taking the musical experience of the band and audience on a different direction. In the case of soccer, mistakes also provide for an ‘opportunity’; Joseph Blatter has said that “people like to debate controversial decisions”. Even though, they are not welcomed in great quantities mistakes are welcomed — like they similarly would be in jazz — as they provide a break and a spark from the regular, and an opportunity to debate. Even with mistakes, the space — wether its the bandstand or the soccer field — remains ‘sacred’ due to the tradition it embodies. Removing these mistakes through innovation — which goal-line technology will do — takes away from tradition. But, why is tradition so important? Why do we care about loosing aspects of our tradition if in exchange we get an error-free, more fair game?</p><p>Dr. Donna Rockwell — a doctor in psychology — very eloquently defines and explains the significance of tradition in her paper <em>The Importance of Tradition. </em>She says, “What makes something a tradition is that it is handed down from one generation to the next, creating a living, dynamic flow of rhythm and predictability,” and finishes by saying, “without our traditions, our lives would be as shaky as…a fiddler on the roof (Rockwell)”. FIFA throughout its history as the governing body and maximum authority of soccer has made continuos efforts to maintain tradition as one of the foundations of what soccer stands for. To understand what this ‘soccer tradition’ really boils down, we can look at the work by John Carlin. On his essay titled <em>The Greatest Game</em>, John Carlin — a sports and political journalist — analyses why soccer is the most popular pastime in the world. He reaches the conclusion that “soccer is the most Homeric of sports; also, the most democratic” (Carlin). He describes soccer as Homeric as a reference to Homer’s <em>Illiad.</em> Homer’s “narrative is built on an evenly matched contest between two sides against the backdrop of the eternal clash between fortune — or fate — and human will” (Carlin). According to Carlin, soccer is the sport that plays most with the idea of lack of control and fortune — while at the same time being a clash between to sides — embodying what human life is. Soccer can — like life — be very unfair: a team can dominate possession from start to finish without being able to score, yet loose the game in the last minute to a counterattack in a moment of divine inspiration of the other team. Soccer is by nature unfair, where the final word is had by a referee who Carlin describes as “an individual with the power, in sporting terms, of life and death; a fallible human being called upon by the game’s rules and regulations to exercise the wisdom and omniscience of God himself” (Carlin). This is soccer’s tradition: the almost impossible fight against both the opposition and fate, usually surrounded by unchallengeable mistakes made by this pseudo-god, all-seeing figure called referee who’s decisions are later debated and debated again for hours on millions of television panels across the world.</p><p>Maintaining this tradition is one of the reasons for soccer’s world wide success. On regards to this, Josep Blatter said, “The game must be played in the same way no matter where you are in the world,” he said. “If you are coaching a group of teenagers in any small town around the world, they will be playing with the same rules as the professional players they see on TV” (Williams). What innovation — in the form of goal-line technology — comes to challenge is the very essence of soccer: tradition. Tradition is not a part of soccer; tradition <em>is</em> soccer and it is used as a way to self-preserve the sport. To understand this idea of self-preservation, we can look at <em>A Toast Story </em>by John Gravois. Gravois sets out to cover the recent craze over artisanal toast by going to one of the leading cafes on this new trend: <em>Trouble</em>. <em>Trouble</em> was founded by Giulletta Carelli: a schizophrenic entrepreneur who claims that for her <em>Trouble</em> embodies the necessary ‘tradition’ to keep her grounded dramatically lowering her episodes. She condensed several elements of her life, traditions like artisanal toast — which reminds her of her youth — and coconuts — which reminds her of her studies offering strangers coconuts — , and marketed them through her minimalistic cafe with a design that encourages conversation between strangers (no tables, only a patio where costumers can seat on tree trunks facing each other).Gravois reflects on <em>Trouble </em>and concludes, “In a city whose economy is increasingly built on digital social networks — but where simple eye contact is at a premium — Giulietta Carrelli’s latticework of small connections is old-fashioned and analog. It is built not for self-presentation, but for self-preservation. And the spread of toast is only one of the things that has arisen from it” (Gravois). What is interesting is the idea of using <em>tradition as self-preservation</em>: both soccer as a sport and <em>Trouble</em> as the cafe, rely the nostalgia of tradition and everything their particular tradition embodies as a way of self-preserve themselves, leading to their success. Innovation can contribute to this tradition — like in <em>A Toast Story</em> where Carrelli’s innovative idea brought back the tradition of artisanal toast — or against it — like goal-line technology threatening what soccer stands for.</p><p>Yet the process of destruction of tradition through innovation is natural — just like the cycle of life and death — soccer makes an attempt at immortality, trying to remain the same as generations go through. Despite goal-line technology will add some fairness that is welcomed by the majority of the soccer world, I cannot help but feel nostalgic about loosing the spark unfair moments add to the game: a comeback even though the opposing team scored an unfair goal, a debated penalty in the last minute, etc. Maybe its just me being slightly too romantic about the sport I love and being blinded by a combination of nostalgia and stubbornness, but I am not excited for the implementation. As legendary English striker Bobby Charlton said, “Soccer is not about justice. It’s a drama — and criminally wrong decisions against you are part of it” (Carlin).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9e3a33695133" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>