<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Antonio Moya on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Antonio Moya on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@antoniomoyalatorre?source=rss-f46e0aef5bb1------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 01:46:57 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@antoniomoyalatorre/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Making Music Together]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/presencing-institute-blog/making-music-together-ac7add7538b8?source=rss-f46e0aef5bb1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ac7add7538b8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[social-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[generative-sound]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stories-from-the-field]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[presencing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Antonio Moya]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 16 Nov 2022 07:45:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-01T21:18:34.443Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>A generative sound journey in Hawai’i</h4><p><em>By </em><a href="http://linkedin.com/in/edinsonrc"><em>Edinson Castaño</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://medium.com/@aklatzky"><em>Antoinette Klatzky</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://medium.com/@antoniomoyalatorre"><em>Antonio Moya-Latorre</em></a></p><p>With eyes closed, a group of 15 people (most of whom have just met) starts performing a piece of music that does not yet exist. Each of the players has just been equipped with an instrument chosen among the ones brought to the space for the occasion — an ukulele, a singing bowl, a violin, a guitar, a piano, maracas, a pair of bongos. The first sounds emerge with hesitance, as if no one wants to break the silence. As time goes by, the soundscape changes and starts painting different pictures in everyone’s imagination, navigating across variegated rhythms, harmonies and melodies, and defining distinct stages along the collective improvisation. There are two or three instances — it is hard to tell whether they last seconds or minutes — where the group feels empowered and aligned. 30 minutes after the beginning of this practice, people open their eyes, surprised they have indeed been capable of creating a musical score in collectivity.</p><p>On July 24, the three of us co-led a Generative Sound workshop with the community around the Hawai’i leadership forum, in Honolulu. This activity marked the end of a three-part social arts weekend including workshops on Visual Practice and Social Presencing Theater, facilitated by Reilly Fish and Arawana Hayashi. The Generative Sound workshop would become the first opportunity to experiment (in group and in person) with social music’s potential to cultivate deep listening individually and collectively. We were well aware that, unlike their older siblings among the social arts, whose theory and practices have been sharpened after years of thinking and experiences, Generative Sound was still a nascent universe. But we were equally convinced that music’s distinct quality — the concatenation of sounds as a form of non-verbal communication and expression — could open up new experiences and raise questions on how social arts can contribute to building teams and forging new leaderships.</p><h4><em>I. THE WORKSHOP</em></h4><p>The three facilitators had been exchanging ideas for weeks about what we expected to get out of our first co-led workshop on Generative Sound. While the conductive thread seemed to be straightforward — allowing participants to express themselves through the sound of an external instrument (or one’s voice) and to sharpen their listening capabilities — the details of the actual practice were hard to define. We wanted to ensure the practice allowed participants to experience and engage with all <a href="https://www.u-school.org/listening-assessment">four levels of listening</a>, moving through downloading, factual, empathic, and ultimately generative listening. To make that possible, there needed to be space for each of them to experiment with instruments individually, in pairs, and as part of a larger group, leading to the co-creation of a larger collective sound “sculpture” — to use the language of Social Presencing Theater — representing what wanted to emerge from the space.</p><p>Held at <a href="https://waiwaicollective.com/">Ka WaiWai</a>, the setting felt immediately in alignment with our project. Ka WaiWai provides work and event space, educational and cultural programming, entertainment, and a collaborative network of members who want to be a part of a movement for positive change for Hawaiʻi and beyond. The space itself consists of a round building with a circular turf in the middle. Cushions and low tables are spread around, and entrants are invited to remove their shoes. On the day of the workshop, the instruments were scattered throughout the space, making it easy for participants to connect with both the space and place as well as the movement of their bodies, letting themselves be drawn towards an instrument (Figure 1).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*3zw2Omiok1NlCixR" /><figcaption><em>Figure 1. Among the instruments scattered across Ka WaiWai were several drums of Caribbean origin (Photo by Edinson Castaño)</em></figcaption></figure><p>The workshop was structured in four parts organized around different emotions in order to invite participants, some of whom had never touched an instrument, to get familiar with their instrument of choice, explore the sounds that it is supposed to make or that it has the potential to make, and engage in a collective artistic creation.</p><ol><li><em>Curiosity.</em> Participants were encouraged to open their minds to consider the relationship of the body to the instrument: “How does it feel in the eyes, in the hands, in the heart?” We suspected that, even if one had seen the instrument many times before, perhaps the practice of seeing with fresh eyes activated new possibilities to explore (Figure 2).</li><li><em>Exploration</em>. After choosing the instrument, participants were invited to experiment with the sounds their instrument could enable and share those with a small group: “Where do sounds come from?” The very act of generating a sound is connected to something that transcends ourselves. Connecting via sound draws us out of the mind and has the potential to connect us to the heart. The journey during a piece of social change works from head to heart, and, together with the work of the hands, brings in the intelligences of the whole being. To generate sound requires an act of courage, moving from the thought of how it might sound to the action where the touch meets the frequency — an act of open will. With these premises, the small groups were invited to create short compositions.</li><li><em>Co-Creation.</em> In the larger group, the small groups were asked to share the composition they had just created. The group then was led into a larger collective practice of feeling into the sound, rhythm, and experience of the whole: “How do we sound when playing in collectivity?” We set approximately 30 minutes to ensure there would be enough time to generate multiple soundscapes. As participants began to play and co-create together, the sound reverberated in each person’s body, extended through their instrumental body.</li><li><em>Reflection. </em>Lastly, leaving the instruments aside, we reflected on what had just happened (Figure 3). We all agreed that several unique moments had taken place, yet it was hard to tell how we had reached those as a group: “Who or what sound had started one of the shifts in the soundscape? Who followed? What allowed certain shifts to prosper and reach emotional depth compared to those unfulfilled shifts? What did we feel — individually and as part of the collective — during the different musical turning points? What quality of relationship(s) were we cultivating by this instrumental interaction?” There were certain times when the music was organized on beats in a rhythmic fashion, and others when it was formed around chords in a more ethereal manner. Occasionally, some participants had started, perhaps consciously, a new harmony or beat seeking to receive traction among the other players. Some of these initiatives succeeded and drove certain momentum, some others vanished without being followed by the others. Overall, we all agreed that, on two or three instances, the group as a whole had felt magically aligned, as if everyone’s intuitions and sensations had momentarily found resonance within the whole collective.</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/495/1*w_50dIQjT_i3QK0yMFBjNw.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 2. One of the participants playing the ukulele during the curiosity phase (Photo by Edinson Castaño)</em></figcaption></figure><h4><em>II. WHAT WE LEARNED</em></h4><p>While still far from developing a theory of practice around the possibilities of social music and Generative Sound processes, with the above questions in mind and inspired by some of the reflections we shared after this first collective experience, here we pull out some initial lessons that speak to the potential of social music as an art form and Generative Sound as a social practice:</p><ul><li><em>Setting the tone: </em>As in other social arts practices, nurturing participants’ predisposition to engage in this embodied practice influences directly on the outcome. The more willing participants are to experiment with and hear new sounds — many of which can be unpleasant — the more meaningful and insightful the collective experience will be. To maximize participants’ predisposition, the facilitation team must generate a welcoming environment that invites attendees to let go of old habits and explore new sensations through the language of music.</li><li><em>Building trust: </em>Engaging in a Generative Sound workshop can become an effective strategy to build trust among a group of people who may not necessarily feel comfortable verbalizing their ideas and emotions. By asking participants to fully focus on the sounds they can produce through their instruments and listen to what others are sharing, they quickly develop the feeling of belonging to a collective social body. There can be an intimate connection with their bigger Self based on what they experience.</li><li><em>Presencing: </em>In certain settings, a Generative Sound practice can be truly helpful to reach deep moments of presencing individually and within a team. A moment of reflection and collective debrief following each practice is necessary for team members to review the different emotions they experienced and compare different perceptions on the activity. For instance, social music can shed light on current leadership habits and group dynamics that may have been overlooked and need to be revisited.</li><li><em>Exploring senses:</em> Generative Sound adds many answers to the question of what lies beyond a verbal articulation of meaning. Participants utilize their senses from a different perspective, for example, in the ways they pay attention to the non-conventional sounds instruments they already know are able to produce — an analogy that could be extended to the way we listen to each other when engaging in a conversation. This sensorial way of unlearning and relearning old and current sounds — and behaviors — could allow us to co-shape society from a different place.</li><li><em>Tuning/Toning with Resonance: </em>In a group or individual experience, using an instrument, including and especially the voice, to make a sound in involvement with what is being heard can create coherence in a system. The practice of tuning and looking for resonance can highlight where there is mis-alignment and invite a subtle return to alignment. Encouraging participants to notice what they feel when they reflect on what was generated can open new organs of perception in the group and encourage new insights.</li><li><em>Generating emotion-based memories: </em>Collective musical practices can spark internal emotions among participants that, despite being hard to verbalize — and very likely because of this — will stick in their bodies for the rest of their lives. Even if the music itself or the conversation that takes place around it may not be remembered, the emotional response attached to that moment will be carried as a real memory, hence also marking a tipping point within the individual’s and team’s life stories.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lvSOW9uRR2Ali2EM_6ILmg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 3. Picture showing part of the larger group layout during the final debrief (Selfie by Antonio Moya-Latorre)</figcaption></figure><h4><em>III. ON THE FUTURE OF GENERATIVE SOUND</em></h4><p>Much like scribing and Social Presencing Theater, Generative Sound practices can be leveraged to reflect back and make visible what teams or collectives–and the individuals among them–are currently going through, along with what they are ready to let go of and let come into their personal and professional worlds. Social music can unleash new emotions, sensations, and intuitions that can hardly be verbalized through our regular languages, some of which may be similar to what visual and bodily practices also enable. Some of these sensations are distinct and unique to this artform — perhaps the most abstract among the social arts. Individuals, teams, and organizations are eager to experiment with different means of communication and expression, and music can and should be considered when enriching their organizational toolkits.</p><p>The exact future of social music and Generative Sound is yet to be defined, but it is a promising one. Encouraged by a collective improvisation following a score that does not exist, the three of us can sense how our co-facilitated workshop in Honolulu will soon be just the first one among many more to come. Even though the exact location, setting, and group of participants is unknown at this stage — as of now, everything indicates that there will be a Generative Sound workshop at a self-managed music school in the periphery of Oaxaca in summer 2023 — we will stick to the feeling of excitement that our next encounter will undoubtedly generate. Our commitment to <a href="https://medium.com/presencing-institute-blog/social-music-sparking-change-through-resonance-797bab2ed584">sparking change through resonance</a> is simply too strong a source of inspiration to keep us quiet. We are committed to exploring creative forms of collective action, and to do that well we welcome ideas and invitations to keep on writing the score of social music where it is most needed. Come play with us!</p><p><em>Thanks to Emma Paine for her comments on this post.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ac7add7538b8" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/presencing-institute-blog/making-music-together-ac7add7538b8">Making Music Together</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/presencing-institute-blog">Field of the Future Blog</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #4]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-4-46451c4a5a8e?source=rss-f46e0aef5bb1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/46451c4a5a8e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[inequality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pluriverse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[planning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-theory]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Antonio Moya]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Nov 2021 17:36:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-24T17:36:03.323Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>Fighting divergence, advancing convergence</em></strong></p><p>Why push our theoretical aspirations towards the edges of radicality? Why not argue for a peaceful, incremental process of change that does not disrupt the basis of the social systems we have grown up in? After all, many would agree that big chunks of our societies today do benefit from centuries of widely accepted human progress and they are therefore not interested in any structural changes. Many could argue that some global challenges are enough of a concern already and that we should focus our energies on addressing current threats, rather than on dismantling social systems. Why, then, worry about structural oppression?</p><p>I will not argue here again that a closer analysis of current challenges inevitably reveals that these are the consequences of long-lasting oppressive systems (capitalism, colonialism, and patriarchy). Rather, I will defend that the idea of human progress is, if not a fallacy, a social construct proposed from a position of privilege that widely disregards the minorities of the world — which are, indeed, the vast majorities of the world. Let us, then, deconstruct the idea of human progress.</p><p>First, we need to look at progress as a relative, relational concept, rather than an absolute truth. In this sense, Johan Galtung’s definition of structural violence as “the difference between the potential and the actual” provides a helpful framework. While it may seem that, in absolute terms, the world has moved forward over the centuries (for instance, if we look at overall life expectancy, among the many possible examples), the disequilibrium between the livings of the social minorities and the privileged has also widen incrementally (the difference of life expectancies between a wealthy versus an economically poor country is now bigger than ever, as is the difference of life expectancy between the wealthy and the poor <em>within</em> the same country). If we used a diagram, we would see two ascending lines, yet increasingly divergent. In other words, purported human progress has enlarged societal inequalities.</p><p>Neoliberals would quickly argue that “inequality is not the problem, but absolute <em>poverty</em> is.” In absolute terms, people live better, they would say, and progress is contributing to reduce overall human suffering. But how can one live in peace knowing that the amount of human suffering is <em>unnecessarily high? </em>While the privileged keep “perfecting” our lives through an over-exposition to the endless possibilities of this world, the social minorities only get exposed to minor glimpses of what exists. This duality between the over-exposition of the privileged and the under-exposition of the disadvantaged keeps on expanding. And once one understands this structural injustice, it becomes unbearable.</p><p>It follows that it is <em>not enough</em> to tackle pressing challenges — solving them would still leave us with a world that is difficult to swallow for the social minorities — and so it is imperative that we work to address this structural gap. As far as critical theory is concerned, thinkers have been approaching the systemic imbalances from multiple lenses — gender and feminist theories, critical race theory, postcolonial theories, indigenous epistemologies, and so on — to denounce structural injustices from the perspective of the corresponding social minorities. If properly interiorized by the majorities, these critical frameworks would progressively lead to a more bearable world.</p><p>We are left again with the theory-practice conundrum. Through what practical processes can critical theories expose us to societal spaces that are fairer and where the life possibilities of those in opposing extremes of society slowly start to converge? With the risk of being too essentialist, in what follows, I present a series of structural failures of our current systems and propose practical avenues for alternatives.</p><p>1. <strong>Top-down planning tends to exacerbate inequalities</strong>. At best, it can reduce the pace of divergence, and at worst, accelerate it. Learning from postcolonial, feminist, racial, and indigenous frameworks, bottom-up processes seem to be the only spaces where the co-production of fairer societies is possible. In other words, as of today, <strong>grassroots insurgent planning is the only capable of producing gender and race-inclusive spaces</strong>.</p><p>2. <strong>Developmentalist planning discourses and practices are too often framed around the so-called vulnerabilities of the minorities</strong>. This is a structurally blinding lens that prevents planners from seeing the actual qualities of those who are different. To counterbalance this tendency, indigenous planning theorists and other postcolonial thinkers teach us to leverage existing capabilities of those in structural disadvantage, often through social processes sustained by commemoration and celebration. In short, <strong>counter-developmentalist frameworks must be strength-based</strong>.</p><p>3. <strong>Incrementalists keep believing in the fallacy of the common good narrative</strong>. Insurgent thinkers and practitioners know instead that fairer spaces are those that support multiple narratives. As such, these pluriversal spaces (to use a concept that Arturo Escobar and others have recently popularized) can only be created through co-generative processes of knowledge production. That is, <strong>fairer societies can only result from proactive co-production processes</strong>.</p><p>4. <strong>Western culture has taken up too much historical space, as a consequence of its unquestioned universality</strong>. Without denying the value of Western culture (something I could never do as an educated classical musician), postcolonial thinking invites us to make space for indigenous resurgence and an African Renaissance (the latter being a concept articulated by Ngũgĩ wa Thiong’o). In other words, <strong>fairer societies shall work as a kaleidoscope of cultures that enrich each other</strong>.</p><p>Because the Western-based idea of progress is sustained by centuries of scientific evidence, insurgent planning theorists must work hard to provide rich evidence of the possibility of alternative worlds. Those who have been exposed to this other unseen richness of the world — which we could broadly call (again) <em>Epistemologies of the South</em> — are aware of all the possibilities that are being disregarded by top-down, developmentalist, common-good Western narratives. It is, hence, the role of insurgent planners to make those other possibilities visible and persuade about the urgency to make space for them. Only through such evidence will insurgent planning be able to start shifting gears towards the convergence of the two lines.</p><p><strong>Continue reading: </strong><a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-1-49b337addaeb"><strong>Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #1</strong></a><strong> / </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@antoniomoyalatorre/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-2-dd1441819b5a"><strong>Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #2</strong></a><strong> / </strong><a href="https://antoniomoyalatorre.medium.com/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-3-ccc8885fafd5"><strong>Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #3</strong></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=46451c4a5a8e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-4-46451c4a5a8e">Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #4</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja">Ciudad Poliédrica</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #3]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-3-ccc8885fafd5?source=rss-f46e0aef5bb1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ccc8885fafd5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[planning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[insurgency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sociology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creativity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-theory]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Antonio Moya]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 Oct 2021 16:54:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-24T17:38:45.899Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>Towards an Insurgent Planning Theory</em></strong></p><p>As I argued before, planning theory aspires to become a liberatory discipline through a pragmatic philosophy that is intertwined with, first, critical theories; second, an explicit critique to oppressive structures of power and to local power relations; third, a call to multiple epistemologies; fourth, a repurpose of “ideal speech situations” as co-generative arenas; and fifth, a subversive recuperation of the “Right to the City.” If we accept those as givens, then we are already in good position to propose a contemporary emancipatory theory — an <em>insurgent</em> planning theory.</p><p>The notion of insurgency is intuitively associated with the pursuit of a social rebellion seeking to overcome current social systems and establishing new orders. Such revolutionary ethos offers, indeed, an accurate idea of the kinds of values that should guide an insurgent planning theory. These are nourished by the perception that the world is deeply unjust — and perhaps more importantly, that it is <em>unnecessarily</em> so. While most would agree that perfect equality is not possible nor desirable (as Iris Marion Young notes, the world’s diversity and differences must be accepted <em>and</em> embraced in order to pursue more meaningful futures), insurgent thinkers understand that extreme injustices are not just an inevitable byproduct of society’s progress. Much the contrary, these are directly exacerbated by the ideas, decisions, and actions of a handful of individuals who have historically held economic and political power — a power they most often have simply inherited and do not deserve. Insurgency towards new orders aspires to overthrow these uninvited and undesired powerholders.</p><p>Once again, the practicality of these ambitious aspirations forces insurgent planning theorists to be creative. How can we conceive of any interventionist strategy when the capitalist world-system overwhelmingly regulates the lives of all of us? Isn’t insurgency just a sweet dream to keep us focused while the world continues painfully as it is?</p><p>The short answer to the latter question is a partial “yes” — insurgency is, first and foremost, about being able to <em>dream</em> about alternatives. But insurgency is not just an unrealistic dream. Insurgent theorists understand that dreaming fills one with hope and ideas worth fighting for. Dreaming is a meaningful performance in itself — one blatantly overlooked by modernists and rationalists, only slowly being seriously reconsidered by the fluid thinking of postmodernists. Specifically, dreams nurture one of the three defining qualities of insurgent planning as presented by Faranak Miraftab: our <em>imagination</em>. Imagining is the first step towards designing something different. Radical imagination in particular opens up the possibility of envisioning and designing a deeply different future — one that is less unjust.</p><p>In a more practical sense, dreams nourish our creativity, which in turn expands our possibilities of intervening in the world. Creative practices are the means to materialize our imagination and test out the possibilities of alternative futures. The possibilities are endless when we stop limiting ourselves to reproducing our usual planning toolkits and commit to reinventing each and every time our intervening practices. Such open world of possibilities matches the same endlessness one experiences when engaging for the first time with the practice of theorizing.</p><p>As happens with theory, practice must be grounded through <em>specific</em> creative practices that align with the context at hand and spur the imagination of alternatives in real scenarios. Artistic practices in particular offer a natural way out to be proactively leveraged to advance social and material change. Usually labeled as “other ways of knowing,” artistic expressions provide insights on the world that rational verbal communication cannot equally convey. They are <em>transgressive</em>, to reference Miraftab’s second quality of insurgent planning practice. Art, in its infinite expressions, is a humane means to engage with the world, for it speaks to people’s intuitive and improvisatory everyday experiences.</p><p>It is relevant to highlight that art and creative practices also provide a promising bridge between so-called Global North and Global South settings. Whereas Enlightenment rationality was specifically born in the West and later spread (and imposed) across the world as the most valid and reliable way of knowing, art has manifested in multiple ways across space and time. Everywhere and since always, individuals, communities, and societies, have found avenues to express themselves and interact with each other through their individual and collective creations. Insurgent planning practices seek to incorporate those practices that resonate with the context at hand, as well as draw on other artistic creations that reverberate transnationally.</p><p>The strategic (planned) combination of these other ways of knowing with the power of modern rationality aspires, first, to spark local processes of change, and second, to bridge radical responses across borders against the world’s injustices. The simultaneous emphasis on the local and the transnational seeking to build <em>new social systems</em> worldwide overlaps with Miraftab’s third principle of insurgent planning — namely, its counter-hegemonic nature. Insurgent planning, in other words, aims at pursuing emancipatory futures simultaneously at strictly local <em>and</em> transnational scales.</p><p>It rests reflecting on how insurgent planning practice can be informed so that the local and transnational interventions designed to advance those futures align with counter-hegemonic struggles already at play. Let us remember that the fight against social injustices has been taking place for a long time, and has successfully resulted, even if slowly and incrementally, in the (partial) liberation of the oppressed peoples of the world. Insurgent planning must insert itself in those struggles in order to amplify its scope and catalyze its impacts. How can an insurgent “planner” — whatever meaning we choose to ascribe to the word — join and amplify existing social struggles?</p><p>The response comes again from the artworld — it is an insurgent planning practice that I would call <em>contemplation</em>. Understood as a combined performance of deep listening, empathy, and experiential immersion into contexts of oppression (either as insiders or as outsiders), contemplation is a necessary act seeking to align (emotionally and intellectually) the understandings and intentions of those convinced that a fairer future is possible and want to work to advance it. More specifically, insurgent planning must rely on an <em>active</em> contemplation. Rather than staring at the world as it unfolds, insurgent thinkers must constantly reflect on what it can be done about it in a proactive manner.</p><p>Imaginative, transgressive, counter-hegemonic practices — the ingredients laid out by Miraftab — are a suggestive starting point towards an insurgent planning theory. A serious reconsideration of dreams, the proactive use of artistic and creative practices, an emphasis on the simultaneity of the local and the transnational, and the call to an active contemplation present a more nuanced vision to ground Miraftab’s three principles into real-world scenarios. In a way, insurgent planning practice is guided by the four tenets of “phronetic” planning presented by Bent Flyvbjerg — where are we going, who gains and who loses, is it desirable, what should be done. To be insurgent, though, planning must be overtly radical in its aspirations and highly creative in its interventions.</p><p><strong>Continue reading: </strong><a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-1-49b337addaeb"><strong>Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #1</strong></a><strong> / </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@antoniomoyalatorre/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-2-dd1441819b5a"><strong>Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #2</strong></a><strong> / </strong><a href="https://antoniomoyalatorre.medium.com/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-4-46451c4a5a8e"><strong>Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #4</strong></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ccc8885fafd5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-3-ccc8885fafd5">Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #3</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja">Ciudad Poliédrica</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #2]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-2-dd1441819b5a?source=rss-f46e0aef5bb1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dd1441819b5a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[planning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[practice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pragmatism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Antonio Moya]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 07 Oct 2021 15:39:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-24T17:38:58.777Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>On Pragmatism and Critical Theory</em></strong></p><p>In theory, social emancipation sounds like a compelling aspiration for the planning discipline — at least to those who believe that solving immediate problems is not enough in a world afflicted with oppressive structures and discourses. Oppression has been the object of study by critical theorists since, at least, Marx. Approaching the topic from multiple perspectives — feminism, critical race theory, indigenous epistemologies, and even language and discursive analyses — theorists today continue envisioning future society structures where oppression is overcome. In practice, however, social emancipation does not materialize in an instant.</p><p>Such is the logic behind the philosophy of pragmatism, particularly as it plays out in the theory of planning practice. Theory, pragmatists argue, should not be about discerning social truths nor what is right or correct, but rather focus on what can be <em>done</em> to achieve a desirable end that is valid for those at stake around a particular societal challenge. Almost by definition, pragmatism is a philosophy of practice concerned with immediate change. As such, it seems to have been born to give meaning to the field of planning, which is equally concerned with effecting change in the immediate social-material world.</p><p>At best, pragmatic approaches to planning result in positive shifts for people struggling to enjoy well-being in their daily lives. Through communicative and collaborative practices, individuals and communities formulate collectively the problems that need to be solved — and solve them. The solutions found, pragmatists would say, are not only good, but they are right and truthful, for they become meaningful for the interested parties as the self-defined goals are accomplished.</p><p>At worst (as has been thoroughly criticized), pragmatism risks not only overlooking, but also reproducing and reinforcing power relations and oppressive structures. According to this critique, communicative rationality seems to benefit those whose rationality is considered such in the first place, as well as those who can communicate better following (pre)established communicative conventions. That is, pragmatic approaches suit well to people raised <em>within</em> the system and make it harder for people at the margins or outside to engage with the system — let alone to challenge it.</p><p>Even if, in the short term, we can only dream about small, immediate changes, one cannot remain silent about the neoliberal discourses and practices that perpetuate everyday forms of oppression. (Being silent, as I argued before, is equal to being complicit). Planners, and planning theorists, must be explicit about the overarching values and philosophy that guide our thinking and practice. When it comes to proposing new theories of practice, clearly positioning ourselves as political subjects will one way or another pervade our theorizing, even if we end up adopting pragmatic stances when it comes to immediate social change.</p><p>In fact, pragmatism as an encompassing epistemological stance is still a powerful means to pursue meaningful change if it is complemented (at least) with the following guiding principles:</p><p>1. <strong>Critical theory (or theories) must be integrated into pragmatists’ intellectual framework</strong>. We cannot conceive of deliberative and collaborative practices without a proper understanding and critique of the oppressive structures underpinning the social challenges in question. Specific planning approaches will be more effective socially if they derive from such frameworks.</p><p>2. <strong>Local power relations must be analyzed, made visible, and challenged</strong>. Pragmatist planners must be aware of the micro-political manifestations of the overarching social structures, which prevent from a fruitful collaboration and the possibility of questioning the status quo at a local scale. In practice, facilitation strategies will tackle said power imbalances.</p><p>3. <strong>The notion of rationality must evolve into that of <em>rationalities</em>, incorporating in the process “Southern Epistemologies.”</strong> Without rejecting the incalculable developments that Enlightenment has brought to humanity, pragmatists must pay attention to the many worldviews left behind by this particular, even if very rich, form of rationality. Planning practitioners must actively incorporate in their toolkits the worldviews and practices of those who have suffered colonizing processes — that is, those from the “Global South” (the latter understood in the broad social sense proposed by Boaventura de Sousa Santos, and not just as a geographical south).</p><p>4. <strong>Planners must repurpose “ideal speech situations” to build <em>co-generative arenas</em> that leverage multiple epistemologies and ways of knowing</strong>. Taking Habermas’s concept as a <em>metaphor</em> (going beyond his emphasis on rational language over other forms of communication), pragmatist practitioners aspire to facilitate the emergence of creative spaces where the publics can convene and co-create their futures by leveraging different ways of making sense of the world.</p><p>5. <strong>The “Right to the City” must be reconsidered in its most subversive reading. </strong>Planning practice seeks to open avenues for the dispossessed to retrieve their urban space and pursue the lives they have “reason to value,” to use Amartya Sen’s famous phrase. Tying back to the first point on this list, planners must address underlying oppressive structures through each intervention, however small, if they aspire to the fulfillment of this underrated human right.</p><p>Pragmatism, it follows from this list, has still today potential to tackle social challenges through the practice of planning if it is merged with critical theory and reoriented towards the goal of social emancipation. Even the ideal of incrementalism (one change at a time) can be embraced if the challenges pursued aspire to bring about some degree of human liberation — be this material or, perhaps more important, cognitive. In other words, pragmatism has still value as a guiding philosophy for our planning practice. For planning aims to become a liberatory discipline that not only deals with tangible changes but is also concerned with fulfilling dreams and hopes. Let the planning practice nourish, in Arjun Appadurai’s terms, our “capacity to aspire.”</p><p><strong>Continue reading: </strong><a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-1-49b337addaeb"><strong>Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #1</strong></a><strong> / </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@antoniomoyalatorre/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-3-ccc8885fafd5"><strong>Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #3</strong></a><strong> / </strong><a href="https://antoniomoyalatorre.medium.com/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-4-46451c4a5a8e"><strong>Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #4</strong></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dd1441819b5a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-2-dd1441819b5a">Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #2</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja">Ciudad Poliédrica</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #1]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-1-49b337addaeb?source=rss-f46e0aef5bb1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/49b337addaeb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[improvisation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[planning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-theory]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Antonio Moya]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Sep 2021 16:09:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-27T22:29:49.086Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Note: The following set of reflections was written for my Advanced Planning Theory Seminar at Cornell University, and it’s inspired by the readings done for class.</em></p><p>Of the many forms of knowledge generation, theory making ranks among the most creative ones. Whereas practice is necessarily constrained by real-worldliness — that is, by mundane limitations ranging from material aspects (space, budget) to social questions (relationships, cultural norms) — theory seems to be, at least in essence, limitless. When engaging with the universe of ideas and imagination, theorizing, like thinking, can become a creative performance of <em>human freedom</em>.</p><p>While such detachedness of theory from the real-world renders simultaneously exciting and overwhelming, a closer approach to theory quickly brings us back to the mundane. Because theories deal with the explanation of existing phenomena — which are experienced through our human engagements with the world — similar types of constraints to those limiting practice also guide the realm of theory making.</p><p>Social theories in particular not only are informed by the very real, social world we inhabit — but they also can <em>affect</em> how we inhabit it by influencing the ways in which we perceive it and informing particular actions to be taken. That is, social theories are not independent from what actually happens in our surrounding materiality, nor should be considered harmless intellectual exercises. Much the contrary, theorizing about the social world is, indeed, an act of <em>responsibility</em>.</p><p>Among the social theories, planning theory is, by definition, the one more directly seeking to influence the world. While most social disciplines, one could argue (not without risk of inappropriate generalizing), engage with the social processes that have led so far to the world as it is today, planning theory, as a future-oriented intellectual field, is concerned with <em>what to do</em> about it. In this regard, the creativity and responsibility associated, respectively, with theory making in general and social theory in particular, gain even more weight when it comes to planning theory. Theorizing about the social future sounds surely appealing — it may seem like envisioning new possible worlds — but one must be consequential with what is proposed.</p><p>Precisely because planning theory is inherently consequential — that is, it follows from and can significantly influence the social world — this subset of social theory is also inevitably <em>normative</em>. Planning theorists are preoccupied with what the world ought to be, and therefore must be conscious and explicit about their own commitments to the social world. What are the guiding values, biases, blind spots, and social expectations underpinning our theorizing? Is this driven by the belief that a better social world is possible? If so, what do we dislike about the current state of affairs and how can planning theory contribute to overcoming the social reality that, we defend, could and should be different?</p><p>Stating that planning theory is normative and that it aspires to challenge the social status quo also implies recognizing the innate political character of the field of planning — at least in its theoretical branch. Whereas planning practice, as a discipline dealing with immediate interventions in the social world, is often described as being policy oriented, planning theory, proposed from an epistemological distance to the immediate world, can and must be explicit about the political systems and structures that have prevented us from building the social world we envision. (Not being explicitly political may itself be a tacit support of the social system we have inherited, which also reflects a particular political stance.) In short, planning theory is an epistemology of <em>social change</em>.</p><p>Theorizing on what the world ought to be is also an opportunity to go beyond the symptoms and investigate the <em>roots</em> of societal challenges. The higher one addresses the chain of “wicked” social problems, the wider the significance of the theory and deeper its possible consequences. Concerned as we are with pressing challenges that require everyone’s attention, we risk not paying enough attention to the structures and underlying social behaviors that have produced those same challenges. For instance, we can design new policies and technologies that mitigate the effects of climate change — and we must, of course. But should we not be equally concerned, if not more, with the social and political system(s) that keeps on “changing the climate” in the first place? Are not climate change and some other huge societal challenges symptoms of unsustainable ways of producing and reproducing the current world — namely, capitalism, colonialism, and patriarchy? Such are the conundrums that planning theory aspires to elucidate.</p><p>Dealing with the (rotten) roots of societal problems makes it impossible for planning theorists to remain coldhearted in their work: planning theory is an <em>emotional</em> endeavor. When thinking about a better possible social world, one cannot remain neutral and objective, but there is always a particular kind of feeling — call it excitement, passion, obsession, or what have you — that informs our arguments. Why would we engage anyway in such an intellectual task if it does not spark some sort of driving sentiment inside ourselves? (As occurred with the political stance, not being emotional in appearance reflects a particular kind of emotion. The same logic applies to normativity and ethical dilemmas in the act of theorizing. These qualities only seem to emerge when they challenge the established social orders.)</p><p>Lastly, planning theory would be meaningless if it did not arouse some sort of reaction, which can range from provocative understandings of our current social world that expand our collective imaginary, to a very specific policy or intervention that alters the material reality in the short term. In other words, planning theory must be <em>socially stimulating</em>.</p><p>To conclude, it is worth reflecting back on the beginning of this train of thought. It may seem that the freedom which, in principle, characterized the practice of theory making has now become constrained by a series of norms that limit the creativity of planning theorists. But this partial unfreedom is indeed the consequence of a particular thinking path chosen freely by me for this theorizing exercise — a path guided by the belief that an approach to planning theory built on the qualities mentioned here can humbly contribute to our <em>social emancipation</em>.</p><p><strong>Continue reading: </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@antoniomoyalatorre/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-2-dd1441819b5a"><strong>Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #2</strong></a><strong> / </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@antoniomoyalatorre/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-3-ccc8885fafd5"><strong>Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #3</strong></a><strong> / </strong><a href="https://antoniomoyalatorre.medium.com/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-4-46451c4a5a8e"><strong>Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #4</strong></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=49b337addaeb" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/improvised-thoughts-on-planning-theory-1-49b337addaeb">Improvised Thoughts on Planning Theory #1</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja">Ciudad Poliédrica</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Thinking Small]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/thinking-small-ab258d5cd32a?source=rss-f46e0aef5bb1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ab258d5cd32a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[othering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[planning]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Antonio Moya]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 Mar 2021 13:46:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-07T13:46:07.607Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Reflections on Daniel Immerwahr’s Essay About “The United States and the Lure of Community Development”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/447/0*L1DLcEmutK0iGqnU" /></figure><blockquote>“[Within] a context in which rich nations continue to rig the international system to ensure that wealth accrues disproportionately to certain places, lock poor people out of those places, and then consume resources at a rate that will probably render much of the planet inhospitable, there is something bizarre about the current obsession with helping poor people help themselves.” (p. 183)</blockquote><p>If authoritarian planning from above resulted in some of the biggest social failures of the 19th and 20th centuries, as argued by James C. Scott in “Seeing Like a State,” development from below did not bring about more hopeful outcomes. “Thinking Small,” by Daniel Immerwahr, is a good critique of U.S-sponsored community development campaigns during the mid-20th century, both abroad and in national territory. As Immerwahr narrates, most of these ambitious “bottom-up” endeavors ultimately <em>also</em> provoked social dystopias not very different from those unleashed by high modernist projects — a surprising fate given that the “quest for community” was precisely a reaction to the pitfalls of modernizing obsessions. What went so wrong?</p><p>The passion for small groups and local communities became trendy in the US between the 1930s and 1960s. Cities were becoming increasingly hostile, with millions of individuals inhabiting the same urban spaces, yet completely detached from each other. Escaping from poor living conditions in the countryside, or migrating from countries in war, people were moving to big cities in the US looking for jobs that would let them pay for a life. But life in cities was precarious for most, against the expectations of a brighter and modern future for everyone. US thinkers and public figures would soon start crafting a way out of these inhumane environments, envisioning the planning of places where people could enjoy the benefits of living in smaller communities.</p><p>Loyal to its imperialist tradition and inspired by Truman’s famous call to help the “underdeveloped” countries of the world — as if things were already fine at home — the US first looked outside of its own boundaries to find a social context where to experiment with community planning. With this mission in mind, India became the ideal setting for a nation-wide community planning experience. Immerwahr makes it clear that the motivation behind this effort was not completely off: American architect Albert Mayer genuinely believed in the democratic potential of a self-governed life in Indian villages. President Nehru also advocated for a significant decentralization of power to provide local agents with tools to make the decisions that mattered locally. But forms of oppression inherent in Indian villages and traditions — patriarchy, local elite’s power, segregated castes — were never questioned, hence destining communities to perpetuate their own patterns of structural oppression. Over the years, the program scaled up massively, soon behaving as a huge bureaucratic machine not unlike that of Tanzania’s villagization processes or the Soviet agrarian plans through which central governments exerted their control.</p><p>Things were even creepier in the Philippines, where the “barrio fever” was intentionally leveraged to build a counterinsurgent culture that would prevent a communist revolt in the country. In the middle of the “Cold War,” the U.S. needed to position itself as the hegemonic nation worldwide to secure its own economic model, and that would take the global fight against Communism to the smallest Filipino village. Again, there were some well-intentioned practices associated with the community development program, such as the creation of research units in local universities to study the practices of community planning. But the counterinsurgent nature of the community development effort in the Philippines necessarily implied repression against dissident voices, reminding that of totalitarian states.</p><p>Finally, the US took the practice of community development back home, once it was publicly recognized that the purportedly most advanced nation of the world was also hiding an “underdeveloped nation” within its borders. Extreme poverty both in urban and rural areas; structural racism that justified treating an entire sector of the US population as less human than the rest; the risk of ghettos of high delinquency; and the possibility of political upheavals indicated that there was domestic work to do. Community development seemed to be a less invasive entry point to many of these challenges. Jane Jacob’s “city of neighborhoods,” though often rightly accused of incentivizing the creation of “white enclaves,” responded to that logic. So was the rationale behind the Peace Corps, an agency genuinely conceived to bring good to the world, locally and abroad.</p><p>Some lessons stand out from Immerwahr’s detailed account of the history of community development as discourse and as practice. First, an over-romanticization of community life can conceal a complex local reality that is also full of violence and oppression. Local power relations do exist and often materialize in harmful behaviors. Sentimentalisms around “traditional” communities can perpetuate these forms of violence. Instead, understanding that <em>all</em> human communities are subject to evolve over time can open spaces for more meaningful conversations around community development.</p><p>Second, trying to <em>only</em> change things on the ground without challenging the larger picture is also doomed to hit dead ends. Planners, thinkers, activists, practitioners, and citizens — all of us should make the effort to zoom out and, as Immerwahr says, look for causal relationships between the privileged lives of some and the challenging living conditions of most. Once identified, we must fight to break those ties and contribute to building new patterns that reduce the structural conditions of social inequality.</p><p>Third, we need to be careful when we hear about community engagement as an innovative approach — especially if it comes from multilateral organizations like the World Bank. As “Thinking Small” makes clear, there is a decades-long culture of community-based planning that, much like top-down planning, has also carried out important successes. Understanding that current efforts to prioritize community planning are building on an ongoing tradition is not only humbling for those of us who still advocate it, but it also helps us to learn from past achievements and failures.</p><p>Lastly, while one of the biggest lessons from the community development lure back in the 1950s was the shift from “planning <em>for</em>” to “planning <em>with</em>” communities, it seems to me that this shift of mindset still hides a certain degree of othering. Many community planners, or advocates for community development, cannot get rid of the us-them binary, talking about communities as an external reality that makes it impossible to blur the gap between <em>the planners </em>and<em> the planned</em> (that is of course not always the case, especially when those advocates belong to the communities in question). As Pink Floyd sang, “us <em>and</em> them, and in the end, we are only ordinary men” (emphasis added). Taken to the community planning practice, this evocative verse would mean shifting from “planning with” to planning <em>together</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ab258d5cd32a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/thinking-small-ab258d5cd32a">Thinking Small</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja">Ciudad Poliédrica</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Seeing Like a State]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/seeing-like-a-state-4c76affb43ff?source=rss-f46e0aef5bb1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4c76affb43ff</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[top-down]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[high-modernism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[state]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[planning]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Antonio Moya]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 27 Feb 2021 22:46:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-04T10:06:17.816Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Reflections on James C. Scott’s celebrated critique on high modernism</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/305/0*I-36hzEyE4CgKqrk.jpg" /></figure><blockquote>“Officials of the modern state are, of necessity, at least one step — and often several steps — removed from the society they are charged with governing.” (p. 76)</blockquote><p><strong>Part I</strong></p><p>High modernism was, and continues to be, a matter of faith, as James Scott eloquently argues in “Seeing Like a State.” Rooted in the belief that technical expertise and reasoned knowledge are the solution to modern social problems — regardless of what exactly these may be — the proponents of high modernism consider themselves entitled to speak and act in name of large numbers of people. Often carried out under the guidance of privileged men (and I am using “men” here to refer specifically to the male gender) with access to elitist education and resources, high modernist projects have resulted, as Scott shows, in <strong>deep social failures</strong>.</p><p>The notion of <strong>“legibility”</strong> as a tactic to monitor society via its oversimplification goes, in my view, straight to the center of high modernist dreams. Through multiple examples, ranging from forest management to the planning of entire cities to the rationale behind the Russian Revolution, Scott shows how the thinking minds responsible for these processes deeply believed in their cause and were dazzled by the possibilities of modern technologies to tame nature and society. A few reflections come to mind after reading the first half of “Seeing Like a State.”</p><p><strong>High Modernism is not gone</strong>. Even though today it would be difficult to find paradigmatic cases of high modernist projects becoming materialized— such as Hausmann’s Paris and Niemeyer’s Brasilia — the belief in science and technology as the solution for humankind’s problems is perhaps more present now than ever before. The conversations on climate change leave no doubt to it: saving the planet seems to depend on increasingly sophisticated technologies that will reduce our carbon emissions and the like. There is little serious debate (or at least it is almost absent in mainstream channels) about how certain societies should drastically reconsider their ways of relating with each other, with nature, and with the world.</p><p>The <strong>intensification of bureaucracy</strong> is a sign of contemporary forms of state legibility. Administrative procedures everywhere have resulted in the impossibility of one’s anonymity. In the best cases, the bureaucratic apparatus ensures that we all comply with the “social contract” and enjoy the benefits of belonging to the system. In most cases, though, the system is only a safe space for certain privileged people and puts all kinds of barriers to all those different from the cookie-cutter citizen. With hyper-modern technologies, legibility turns into “surveillance” that one cannot escape from.</p><p>How <strong>history is told by winners</strong> (those in positions of power) is the ultimate form of state simplification. In a time of widespread lies, often designed by and spread through the state, what we choose to tell, and how we choose to narrate it, matters. Discourse is as real (or as unreal) as history itself, for it shapes the ways we think of ourselves and others. Giving voice to those historically unheard becomes, then, a huge priority.</p><p>That the responses to two of the iconic prayers of high modernism — Le Corbusier and Lenin — came from <strong>women </strong>is telling. Though Scott only devotes one paragraph to bringing attention to Jacobs’s feminine perspective, the “maternal” reaction to patriarchal projects of this kind is worth exploring in more depth.</p><p>Rosa Luxemburg, one of the respondents to these figures, talks specifically about relying on <strong>social “improvisations”</strong> rather than on expert and rational knowledge if a society wants to succeed in its revolutionary path to change. Believing in the creativity of so-called “experienced amateurs” and not treating people as part of an acritical “mass” is crucial to frame and tackle complex social challenges.</p><p>What Scott does not address is the processes of legibility undertaken by private capitalists. Centering his critique on the authoritarian public state, he does not pay enough attention to its <strong>connivance with the private sector</strong>, making one doubt whether markets are not guided by similar principles of social simplification. Twenty years after the publication of “Seeing Like a State,” in the era of big data and the hegemony of big technological companies, things do not look more hopeful: whereas high modernist projects of the past, despite their failures, were often designed and implemented in the name of a common good and the aspiration towards a “better” society (in the mind of their planners), contemporary hyper-capitalist projects are almost exclusively guided by private profit. Projects of entire new cities like United Arabs Emirates’ Masdar or Saudi Arabia’s The Line are a worrying account of the contemporary tweak of high modernism underpinned by a capitalist logic.</p><p>The quote with which I opened this comment on Scott’s first five chapters encapsulates the reason <strong>high modernist projects are doomed to fail</strong>. Their designers are too detached from reality, this being understood as a complex amalgam of individual and collective lived experiences. If planning is expected to gain weight as a discipline that contributes meaningfully to creating living environments where everyone can thrive and pursue their dreams, then the gap between the planners and the planned needs to disappear. In fact, I wonder whether we should get rid of such distinction.</p><p><strong>Part II</strong></p><p>If the first part of “Seeing Like a State” has a focus on the urban, the second part turns to the modernization of agriculture. As a millenary human practice that, according to mainstream developmentalist discourses, precedes the more advanced and <em>inevitable </em>stages of industrialization, <strong>agriculture is associated by many with the notions of “backwardness” and “underdevelopment.”</strong> That is, agriculture is the perfect victim for the high modernist gaze and its practices of simplification and control.</p><p>The first surprising connection that James C. Scott brings attention to is the similarity between socialist and capitalist approaches to <strong>high modernist agriculture</strong> in the Soviet Union and the United States, respectively. In the race to become “core” countries within the capitalist world-system (to use Immanuel Wallerstein’s framework), mass industrialization of agriculture seemed to be crucial to feed substantial amounts of the population at a cheap cost, while offering the image of a highly technologized country. Of course, the authoritarian nature of the Soviet Union gave its government the authority to impose the new model inspired by Taylor’s assembly lane upon an enormous scale in a way unconceivable for the United States — hence the “Capitalist Dreams” in the title of the sixth chapter. The coercive practices of the Soviet government went well beyond agriculture, which ultimately became an effective means to control and command over millions of people spanned over the Union’s large territory.</p><p>Processes of Villagization in Tanzania followed a similar logic of <strong>“miniaturization,”</strong> where entire communities were displaced and forced to live in identical models that had been scaled for humans to fit in, but that ultimately functioned as out-of-scale miniatures incapable of absorbing the complexities and nuances of real human life. The “total development scheme” and the obsession with “streamlining people” and the quantification of success led President Julius Nyerere to treat his citizens as <strong>living toys</strong> that he could arrange at his (well-intentioned) will. Among the failures, the uprooting of people from their social and cultural contexts stands out, with consequences ranging from inhabitable villages to the complete loss of identity of an entire generation.</p><p>More generally, the attempt to <strong>“tame nature”</strong> and treat it merely as a product at the service of human beings is a behavior that has dominated until today, with large extensions of monocrops covering the landscapes of countries all over the world. To compensate the artificialization of the soil where high modernist agriculture is cultivated, an increasing number of fertilizers are designed and used in a vicious cycle of contamination. Conversations to completely reconsider our relationship with nature and retrieve its intrinsic complexity and biodiversity, while being able to feed human beings, are still today largely out of the conversation.</p><p>The prospects to turn over the high modernist mindset must go through <strong>the practice of “metis,”</strong> a Greek concept Scott introduces to account for a type of embodied knowledge that is different from scientific expertise, but also not exactly equivalent to practical knowledge. Metis is a sort of know-how that balances experienced and abstract knowledge, and which is deeply rooted in local cultural practices. Everyone is in possession of different forms of metis, but this type of knowledge becomes especially present and relevant among people at the margins of society, who regularly must leverage their know-how to overcome daily situations for which there is no planned way out.</p><p>Scott advocates turning to metis to come up with <strong>incremental processes of social change</strong>. However, after 350 pages of detailed analysis and critique of high modernist practices, he only gets bold enough to offer a very succinct list of four recommendations to consider when undertaking such transformation processes: <strong>taking small steps, favoring reversibility, planning for surprises, and planning on human inventiveness</strong>.</p><p>As much as I resonate with those recommendations — which overlap with my own list of recommendations for community planners at the end of my master’s thesis “<a href="https://issuu.com/tonimoya/docs/antonio_moya-latorre_the_sparking_cycle_lq">The Sparking Cycle</a>” — it is not clear to me who Scott is speaking to. While high modernist projects where clearly designed and implemented by public states, the alternative approach to “development planning” outlined by Scott does not seem to have a targeted audience. Is he inviting development agencies to reconsider their approaches? Is he thinking about government officials? Or is the incremental approach to development planning a responsibility of community organizers and lay citizens?</p><p>As thorough as Scott’s analysis of high modernism is, his succinct sketch of alternatives can hardly have any practical implications. “Seeing Like a State” is, nonetheless, a brilliant essay that, through its numerous and detailed examples, takes the reader to the mindset behind cold technocratic planning. What each of us decides to make of its lessons is ultimately a matter of metis.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4c76affb43ff" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/seeing-like-a-state-4c76affb43ff">Seeing Like a State</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja">Ciudad Poliédrica</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Social Music: Sparking Change Through Resonance]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/presencing-institute-blog/social-music-sparking-change-through-resonance-797bab2ed584?source=rss-f46e0aef5bb1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/797bab2ed584</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[participation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Antonio Moya]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Jul 2020 13:27:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-07T16:51:27.741Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><a href="https://medium.com/@amaseme_net/m%C3%BAsica-social-desencadenando-cambios-desde-la-resonancia-435158a1c3d3"><em>Léelo en español</em></a></p><p>Who could have known that music would play such a powerful role during a pandemic? I, along with many other musicians, had to wait for this worldwide lockdown to experience an additional dimension of music which would have never been conceivable had physical space not been removed from the scene. It turned out that, in times of physical distance, music — and particularly <em>live</em> music — could function as a glue transcending space to align and connect human souls.</p><p><a href="https://www.presencing.org/gaia">GAIA</a> started with a spark: A very simple, but concrete and appealing idea that came up during a conversation between Antoinette Klatzky and Otto Scharmer — quickly shared with excitement with the rest of the Presencing Institute community — and that brought together thousands of people from all over the world during a three-month journey. With little more than a chosen date for the initial event (10 days later!), a rough design for the different stages of the journey ahead and — this was critical — a <em>longer term aspiration of systems change and civilizational renewal</em>, dozens of volunteers quickly got on board to engage in a rich co-generative experience with the hope of navigating an unprecedented, existential global crisis.</p><p>It was during the <a href="https://vimeo.com/410634924">second GAIA session</a> when we all experienced <em>the cathartic power of social music</em>. The guest speaker, Dayna Cunningham — an eternal source of inspiration whom I have the honor to consider my intellectual mentor — was talking about structural violence “as a set of human agreements” within which groups of people exert power over other groups. In response to a participant’s comment in the chat, she introduced the idea of “structural love” as the needed collective reaction. Through stories which were simultaneously devastating and inspiring, you could see on the hundreds of faces attending this conversation, from different places in the world, how deeply touched people were.</p><p>I had been asked to perform some music in front of the camera after Dayna’s words (since the conception of GAIA, these musical moments were introduced to help GAIA participants to stay with their own ideas and emotions). But this time, instead of playing the classical piece I had been preparing for this session, I just <em>let go of my plans</em> and started improvising to <em>resonate</em> with Dayna’s words. In part, I reacted in this way to create some space to allow my own feelings to be expressed, touched as I was. But also, my intuition was telling me that a musical improvisation could contribute more meaningfully to amplify the <em>social field</em> that was being crafted through the dialogue. Music could complement and enrich what words had started.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SsTELaY5aWuGbeINplhEMw.png" /><figcaption>Musical Resonance sparked by the virtual dialogue with Dayna Cunningham (2020).</figcaption></figure><p>A new type of practice had been born for me. It was not the first time I had improvised in public nor that I reacted with music to spoken words in a room. But the unplanned nature of this resonance in particular and the surreal setting — me playing from home to an audience of more than a thousand people spread across the world in the context of a global lockdown — opened up a very profound field whose full potential is yet to be explored.</p><p>To understand how this musical resonance came to be in this moment of history and how this could continue playing a role in activating social transformations, let me first share some insights about the musical journey that brought me here.</p><p>Growing up in a Mediterranean town sparked my social approach to music. <a href="https://goo.gl/maps/NsiNGCjgSSPdG7yR7">Godella </a>is one of the dozens of small towns around Valencia’s <em>huerta</em> (the vast agricultural fields that nurture this city) whose local life is deeply shaped by the music school and the wind orchestra. You can hardly find anyone in town who is not somehow connected to the <a href="https://casinomusicalgodella.wordpress.com/about/">Banda del Casino Musical</a>, an institution that has been contributing to the local cultural life for over 200 years. Sustained by small monthly donations of hundreds of families, this institution offers weekly — sometimes even daily — events, that range from formal big scale concerts in the local concert hall, to performances by the students of the music school, to musical improvisations on the streets. Being part of such a versatile cultural institution for over 20 years — first as a clarinet student and a member of the wind orchestra, and in later stages also as a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l8vcZ37M2xE&amp;t=695s">concert pianist</a> and orchestra conductor — seeded my understanding of music as a rich and powerful <em>tool for social change</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LdrCGF00biOZd8CpAq6F4A.png" /><figcaption>End-of-year concert in Godella’s main public square with the students of the music school (2012).</figcaption></figure><p>The (perhaps overly) long detour of my architecture studies allowed me to expand my perspective on the social power of music in different directions, that I now see as connected. I felt very attracted by the spatial dimension of music. I studied how this art form functions as a natural focus point for spontaneous social gatherings in any given space, and how this property could be enhanced through architectural design. I fell in love with Hans Sharoun’s proposal for the Berliner Philharmoniker: the first big auditorium to place the public not in front, but <em>around</em> the central stage. Not surprisingly, this concept was soon reproduced in dozens of concert halls all around the world. As an architect-to-be, I always came back to this idea and reflected on the relevance of the spatial dimension of music; as a music student, I kept on exploring venues where people could gather organically around the piano.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zWmUuIm5XmX-DbHbRTSehw.png" /><figcaption>Musical performance as part of an art exhibition on Russian futurism at the School of Design in Valencia (2013).</figcaption></figure><p>In my first trip to Mexico, back in 2010, I carried my clarinet. I felt that my music was going to be a natural way to connect with people of a social reality hitherto unknown to me. Who could have known that this experience was only going to be the first of uncountable moments in Mexico and other Latin American countries? My passion for this incommensurate region of the world, so deeply tied to my Mediterranean roots, had just started. And looking back ten years in, I now realize how music has been always present in my personal and professional exchanges in Latin America, playing a crucial role in shaping social relationships and cultivating moments of reflection and action among those whom I have met along the way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Vhy5X1JTZPqVQSplVEM0AA.png" /><figcaption>Rehearsal and concert with young musicians of <a href="http://www.nuestragente.com.co/index.html">Corporación Cultural Nuestra Gente</a> in Medellín (2016).</figcaption></figure><p>The most powerful experience, I still recall, of a process of social transformation where music and other art forms were intentionally brought into the design took place in the community of Jardim Colombo, an underserved neighborhood in the Western side of São Paulo, during the winter of 2018. The community was struggling with the presence of a huge dumping site in the middle of the neighborhood. Hoping that this site could one day become a public park, neighbors self-organized to clean up the dumpster. However, despite the massive collective efforts, the site continued to accumulate trash and rubble. It was only a co-generated art and participation festival <em>on</em> the dumping site, planned and designed within only six weeks, that ended up sparking a collective change in the community, both in behavior and in mindset. The site would no longer be perceived as a dumpster, but rather as a public space for collective celebration and self-organizing (in <a href="https://soundcloud.com/user-684808838/s2e9-a-communitys-spark-with-antonio-moya-latorre">this interview</a> about my master’s thesis I reflect on this experience with the help of a piano). Like a spark — again — this celebration ignited the <a href="https://www.fazendinhando.org/">collective capacity to address other challenges</a> of relevance for the community, including the extreme health emergency that Jardim Colombo was going to face two years later, which is now being masterfully managed under the leadership of my much admired Ester Carro. Who could have known that art and music would be so decisive in building community?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yO9oac_bGjWWr6nPtONNCA.png" /><figcaption>A glimpse of the second edition of the art festival in Jardim Colombo, São Paulo (2019).</figcaption></figure><p>Two extremely different contexts — a Brazilian community deeply tied to the ground and a virtual global community — yet music connected them both. Since that GAIA session in which I was called to improvise, I have been contributing with moments of musical resonance in dozens of virtual events. From students to professionals to people from worldwide wanting to connect with others, the types of audiences I have played for (or with) is as diverse as the nature of these events allow (that is, individuals with access to technology and internet and, most importantly, with the time and the mental space to attend online sessions for one or two hours). Yet every time I witness how, no matter who is on the screen, music touches them. Eyes closing, smiles, slower breath — after these few minutes of music, I can often perceive <em>a slight shift</em> <em>in the participants’ interior condition </em>towards <em>a more open-minded and open-hearted attitude</em>. Music sparks the willingness to connect with ourselves and with others.</p><p>Trying to describe how these musical improvisations take place is not an easy task and goes somehow against the nature of this practice itself, which does rely on a form of communication that is nonverbal (I resonate here with my colleague, <a href="https://medium.com/presencing-institute-blog/how-to-begin-ed8c4aaa6df3">Olaf Baldini’s, reflections</a> on his visual practice). What I can share is that a musical resonance starts with <em>listening deeply</em> to the conversations that are taking place, from which I tend to pick one or two prevalent ideas that I try to imagine as sounds. If we are talking about trauma and grief — or structural violence, for that matter — I will probably start on the left side of the piano, playing slow bass sounds. If the mood of the participants feels lighter, I will then start with faster notes on the right side.</p><p>The second main insight to unleash the improvisation is more directional. Besides the ideas that are being shared more or less explicitly, which capture the <em>current </em>tone of the conversation, I make an effort to imagine where the <em>intention</em> of the group is heading. After <em>staying with</em> the initial thoughts and feelings, I start <em>moving the music towards </em>that desired outcome, which is usually more positively charged — somewhere close to the concept of structural love. What exactly happens between beginning and end is, nevertheless, unpredictable, and depends on several different factors (ranging from the quality of the inspiration on a given day to purely technical issues that influence on the overall experience). I let the music speak for itself. The rest is noise.</p><p>Looking back to how the past 25 years have unfolded since I first encountered music, I can only think of this long period of time as an extensive and organic improvisation, kicked off on my first day at the music school in Godella at the age of seven, and guided by a set of blurred life intentions — my North Star — that have helped me make sense of my existence: my firm belief in the possibility of a more just world where equitable human flourishing and collective well-being are prioritized. Along the way, the people I meet and the experiences I am part of feel like notes and chords enriching and informing this improvised and collective journey of my life. Wherever I go, regardless of people&#39;s origin and context, I keep on witnessing, every time, how music contributes to sparking individual and collective transformations. As the current global health crisis is making clear, people do not even need to be physically in the same space for changes to emerge.</p><p>It is my commitment to continue leveraging music as a tool for social change, with the hope that one day we will start behaving as if we were all part of a global orchestra performing for a planetary resonance.</p><p><strong>Let us play together.</strong></p><p><em>Thanks to Eva Pomeroy, Antoinette Klatzky, and Rachel Hentsch for the invitation to write this piece and for their thoughtful comments on its earlier versions.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=797bab2ed584" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/presencing-institute-blog/social-music-sparking-change-through-resonance-797bab2ed584">Social Music: Sparking Change Through Resonance</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/presencing-institute-blog">Field of the Future Blog</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Música social. Desencadenando cambios desde la resonancia]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/m%C3%BAsica-social-desencadenando-cambios-desde-la-resonancia-435158a1c3d3?source=rss-f46e0aef5bb1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/435158a1c3d3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[música-social]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[participación-ciudadana]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cambio-social]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cultura]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[arte-social]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Antonio Moya]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Jul 2020 02:26:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-08T23:58:45.555Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Música social: Desencadenando cambios desde la resonancia</h3><p><a href="https://medium.com/presencing-institute-blog/social-music-sparking-change-through-resonance-797bab2ed584"><em>Read this in English</em></a></p><p>¿Quién hubiera imaginado que la música jugaría un papel tan poderoso durante una pandemia? Hemos tenido que esperar a un confinamiento global para ser testigos de una dimensión adicional de la música inconcebible si su componente espacial no hubiera desaparecido de la escena. Me refiero a la función de la música— y en particular, de la música <em>en directo</em>— como puente que trasciende el espacio en tiempos de distanciamiento físico para alinear y conectar almas humanas.</p><p><a href="https://www.presencing.org/gaia">GAIA</a> comenzó con una chispa. Una idea simple, pero concreta y atractiva que emergió durante una conversación entre Antoinette Klatzky y Otto Scharmer — y que rápidamente compartieron con emoción con el resto de la comunidad de Presencing Institute — atrajo y agrupó a miles de personas de todo el mundo durante una travesía de tres meses. Con poco más que una fecha para el evento inicial (¡10 días después!), un diseño general para las diferentes etapas del proceso y — esto resultó crucial — una aspiración a largo plazo de <em>cambio sistémico y renovación social</em>, docenas de voluntarios pronto se subieron al tren para ser partícipes de una experiencia cogenerativa, con la esperanza de navegar una crisis global existencial sin precedentes.</p><p>Fue durante la <a href="https://vimeo.com/410634924">segunda sesión de GAIA</a> cuando todos fuimos testigos del <em>poder catártico de la música social</em>. La persona invitada, Dayna Cunningham — una fuente eterna de inspiración a quien tengo el honor de considerar mi mentora intelectual — hablaba sobre violencia estructural como “un conjunto de acuerdos entre humanos” que permite a ciertos grupos de personas ejercer poder sobre otros grupos. En respuesta a un comentario de un/a participante en el chat, Dayna introdujo la idea de “amor estructural” como la necesitada reacción colectiva. A través de historias al tiempo desgarradoras e inspiradoras, uno podía percibir entre los cientos de rostros participando en la conversación, desde varios lugares del mundo, cuan conmovidos se sentían.</p><p>Me correspondía interpretar algo de música frente a la cámara tras las palabras de Dayna (desde la concepción de GAIA, se introdujeron estos momentos musicales para ayudar a los participantes a profundizar en sus propias ideas y emociones). Pero en esta ocasión, en lugar de interpretar la pieza clásica que había estado preparando, simplemente <em>dejé ir mis planes</em> y comencé a improvisar para <em>resonar </em>con las palabras de Dayna. En parte, reaccioné de este modo para dar rienda suelta a mis propios sentimientos. Pero además, mi intuición me decía que una improvisación musical podría contribuir de manera más profunda a amplificar el <em>campo social</em> que estaba siendo labrado a través del diálogo. La música podía complementar y enriquecer aquello que habían comenzado las palabras.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SsTELaY5aWuGbeINplhEMw.png" /><figcaption>Resonancia musical desencadenada por el diálogo virtual con Dayna Cunningham (2020).</figcaption></figure><p>Había nacido una nueva práctica para mí. No era la primera vez que improvisaba en público ni que reaccionaba con música a palabras habladas en una sala. Pero la naturaleza no planeada de esta resonancia en particular y el entorno surrealista — me encontraba tocando el piano desde mi casa frente a una audiencia de más de mil personas de todo el mundo en el contexto de un confinamiento global — abrieron el camino hacia un campo profundo cuyo potencial todavía debe ser explorado.</p><p>Para comprender cómo esta resonancia musical pudo llegar a ser en este momento histórico y cómo podría continuar jugando un papel en la activación de transformaciones sociales, quisiera compartir primero algunas ideas de la trayectoria musical que me trajo hasta aquí.</p><p>La ciudad mediterránea en la que crecí activó mi enfoque social hacia la música. <a href="https://goo.gl/maps/NsiNGCjgSSPdG7yR7">Godella</a> es una de las docenas de pequeñas poblaciones alrededor de la huerta valenciana cuya vida local está profundamente marcada por la escuela de música y su banda (u orquesta de viento). Difícilmente se encuentra a algún vecino que no esté relacionado de alguna manera con la <a href="https://casinomusicalgodella.wordpress.com/about/">Banda del Casino Musical</a>, una institución que ha estado contribuyendo a la vida cultural local desde hace mas de 200 años. Mantenida gracias a las pequeñas donaciones mensuales de cientos de familias, esta institución ofrece eventos semanalmente, si no diariamente, que van desde conciertos a gran escala en el auditorio local, hasta audiciones de los estudiantes de la escuela de música, o improvisaciones en la calle. Ser parte de una agrupación cultural tan versátil durante más de 20 años — primero como estudiante de clarinete y miembro de la banda, y en etapas posteriores como <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l8vcZ37M2xE&amp;t=695s">pianista solista</a> y director de orquesta — sembró mi manera de entender la música como una poderosa <em>herramienta para el cambio social</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LdrCGF00biOZd8CpAq6F4A.png" /><figcaption>Concierto de final de curso en la plaza principal de Godella con los estudiantes de la escuela de música (2012).</figcaption></figure><p>El (tal vez innecesariamente) largo desvío como estudiante de arquitectura me permitió expandir la perspectiva del poder social de la música en diferentes direcciones que hoy veo conectadas. Pronto me sentí muy atraido por la dimensión espacial de la música. Estudié cómo este arte funciona como un foco natural para aglomeraciones espontáneas en determinados espacios, así como de qué manera se podía potenciar esta propiedad mediante el diseño arquitectónico. Me enamoré de la propuesta de Hans Sharoun para la Filarmónica de Berlín: el primer gran auditorio en situar al público no delante, sino <em>alrededor</em> del escenario central. No es sorprendente que este concepto no tardara en reproducirse en docenas de salas de concierto por todo el mundo. Como futuro arquitecto, siempre regresaba a esta idea y reflexionaba sobre la relevancia de la dimensión espacial de la música; como estudiante de música, continué explorando lugares donde las personas pudieran agruparse de manera orgánica alrededor del piano.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zWmUuIm5XmX-DbHbRTSehw.png" /><figcaption>Interpretación musical dentro de la exhibición sobre futurismo ruso en la escuela de diseño de Valencia (2013).</figcaption></figure><p>En mi primer viaje a México, allá por 2010, me llevé el clarinete conmigo. Sentía que mi música sería un medio natural para conectar con gente de una realidad hasta entonces desconocida para mí. ¿Quién hubiera sabido que esta experiencia sería solo la primera entre incontables momentos en México y otros países latinoamericanos? Mi pasión hacia esta inconmensurable región del mundo, profundamente relacionada con mis raíces mediterráneas, acababa de empezar. Echando la vista atrás diez años después, ahora me percato de cómo la música siempre ha estado presente en todos mis intercambios personales y profesionales en Latinoamérica. Esta parte de mí ha jugado un papel esencial en el fortalecimiento de lazos sociales y el desencadenamiento de momentos de reflexión y acción entre aquellas personas que me he encontrado en el camino.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Vhy5X1JTZPqVQSplVEM0AA.png" /><figcaption>Ensayo y concierto con los jóvenes músicos de la <a href="http://www.nuestragente.com.co/index.html">Corporación Cultural Nuestra Gente</a> de Medellín (2016).</figcaption></figure><p>La experiencia más poderosa que todavía recuerdo de un proceso de transformación social en el que la música y otras formas artísticas fueron incorporadas conscientemente en su diseño tuvo lugar en la comunidad de Jardim Colombo, un barrio desatendido en la zona oeste de São Paulo, durante el invierno de 2018. La comunidad padecía por la presencia de un enorme vertedero de escombros en medio del vecindario. Con la esperanza de que un día se convirtiera en un parque público, los vecinos se auto-organizaron para limpiar el basurero. A pesar del esfuerzo colectivo masivo, el terreno continuaba acumulando basura y escombros. Fue un festival de arte y participación <em>sobre </em>el vertedero, planeado y diseñado en tan solo seis semanas, el responsable de desencadenar un cambio colectivo en la comunidad, tanto en comportamiento como en mentalidad. Este espacio nunca volvería a ser percibido como basural, sino como un espacio público para la celebración colectiva y la auto-organización (en <a href="https://soundcloud.com/user-684808838/s2e9-a-communitys-spark-with-antonio-moya-latorre">esta entrevista</a> sobre mi tesis de máster reflexiono sobre esta experiencia con la ayuda de mi piano). Como una chispa — de nuevo — esta celebración prendió<a href="https://www.fazendinhando.org/"> la capacidad colectiva para enfrentarse a otros desafíos</a> de relevancia para la comunidad, incluyendo la emergencia sanitaria extrema de la que Jardim Colombo sería testigo dos años más tardes, y que está siendo magistralmente gestionada bajo el liderazgo de mi admirada Ester Carro. ¿Quién hubiera imaginado que el arte y la música serían tan decisivos para construir comunidad?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yO9oac_bGjWWr6nPtONNCA.png" /><figcaption>Un destello de la segunda edición del festival de arte en Jardim Colombo, São Paulo (2019).</figcaption></figure><p>Dos contextos completamente diferentes — una comunidad en Brasil profundamente enraizada al terreno y una comunidad virtual global — conectadas por la música. Tras aquella sesión de GAIA en la que sentí la necesidad de improvisar, he participado en docenas de eventos virtuales. Desde estudiantes hasta profesionales y personas de todo el mundo, el tipo de audiencias para las que (o con las que) interpreto música es tan diverso como la naturaleza de estos eventos permite (a saber, individuos con acceso a tecnología e internet y, especialmente, con el tiempo y el espacio mental para participar en sesiones virtuales de dos horas). Y sin embargo, una y otra vez soy testigo de cómo, sin importar quién esté frente a la pantalla, la música les conmueve. Ojos cerrados, sonrisas, respiraciones pausadas — tras estos minutos de música, a menudo puedo percibir un <em>ligero cambio en la condición interna de los participantes</em> hacia una <em>actitud más abierta de mente y de corazón</em>. La música enciende el deseo de conectar con nostros mismos y con los demás.</p><p>Tratar de describir de qué manera tienen lugar estas improvisaciones no es sencillo y va, en cierto modo, contra la propia naturaleza de esta práctica, que nace de una forma de comunicación no verbal (simpatizo en este sentido con las <a href="https://medium.com/presencing-institute-blog/how-to-begin-ed8c4aaa6df3">reflexiones de mi colega Olaf Baldini</a> sobre su práctica visual). Sí puedo compartir que una resonancia musical comienza con la <em>escucha profunda</em> de las conversaciones que tienen lugar, de las que tomo una o dos ideas prevalentes que trato de imaginar en sonidos. Si estamos hablando de trauma y duelo — o violencia estructural — probablemente comenzaré en la parte izquierda del piano, con sonidos graves y pausados. Si el ánimo de los participantes se siente más ligero, comenzaré con notas más rápidas en el registro agudo.</p><p>La segunda inspiración principal para desencadenar la improvisación tiene un carácter más direccional. Además de las ideas que se comparten de manera más o menos explícita, y que recogen el tono actual de la conversación, hago un esfuerzo por imaginar la <em>intención </em>hacia la que se dirige el grupo. Tras <em>quedarme con</em> las ideas y los sentimientos iniciales, comienzo a <em>encaminar la música hacia el desenlace anhelado</em>, generalemente de cariz más positivo — cercano al concepto de amor estructural. Qué ocurre exactamente entre principio y final es, no obstante, impredecible, y depende de varios factores (desde la propia inspiración en un determinado día hasta cuestiones puramente técnicas que pueden influir en la experiencia). Dejaré a la música hablar por sí sola. Todo lo demás es ruido.</p><p>Al reflexionar sobre cómo se han desarrollado los pasados 25 años desde que me topé por primera vez con la música, no puedo evitar pensar en este largo período como una extensa y orgánica improvisación, iniciada mi primer día en la escuela de música de Godella a los siete años, y guiada por intenciones vitales imprecisas — mi estrella norte — que permiten dar sentido a mi existencia: mi profundo convencimiento en la posibilidad de un mundo en el que se priorice el florecimiento humano equitativo y el bienestar colectivo. A lo largo del camino, las personas con quien me topo y las experiencias de las que formo parte se sienten como notas y acordes que enriquecen y conforman la improvisada y colectiva travesía de mi vida. Allá donde voy, sin importar el origen y el contexto de la gente, continúo siendo testigo, cada vez, de cómo la música contribuye a desencadenar transformaciones individuales y colectivas. Tal y como la actual crisis sanitaria mundial está evidenciando, las personas no necesitan tan siquiera encontrarse físicamente en el mismo espacio para que el cambio pueda emerger.</p><p>Acepto el compromiso de continuar aprovechando la música como una herramienta para el cambio social, con la esperanza de que, algún día, comenzaremos a comportarnos como miembros de una orquesta global capaz de interpretar la necesaria resonancia planetaria.</p><p><strong>Toquemos juntos.</strong></p><p><em>Gracias a Eva Pomeroy, Antoinette Klatzky y Rachel Hentsch por la invitación para escribir esta reflexión y por sus acertadas revisiones del borrador.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=435158a1c3d3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/m%C3%BAsica-social-desencadenando-cambios-desde-la-resonancia-435158a1c3d3">Música social. Desencadenando cambios desde la resonancia</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja">Ciudad Poliédrica</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Arte y reconstrucción: el trauma urbano como oportunidad]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/arte-y-reconstrucci%C3%B3n-el-trauma-urbano-como-oportunidad-728d394e85a3?source=rss-f46e0aef5bb1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/728d394e85a3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[urbanism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[capabilities]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conscientização]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Antonio Moya]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 31 Dec 2019 15:10:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-31T15:10:47.364Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bCo3cgWBR1QQ_2bchjVEVQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Mural del Colectivo Chiqui Traca destruido por el sismo.</figcaption></figure><p>La noche cuando la tierra se estremeció, el 7 de septiembre de 2017, pude sentir cómo la sacudida me afectaba emocionalmente, a pesar de la distancia. Por entonces me encontraba estudiando la maestría de planificación urbana en el Instituto Tecnológico de Massachusetts, adonde había llegado hacía apenas un mes con la intención de estudiar la relación entre arte, cultura y urbanismo comunitario — temas en los que llevaba trabajando varios años como arquitecto y músico.</p><p>Mi sorpresa fue enorme al comprobar la masiva respuesta de la comunidad artística del Istmo de Tehuantepec, Oaxaca y México al sismo del 7 de septiembre y al que le siguió pocos días después y que afectó, sobre todo, a la capital mexicana. En medio del caos y la confusión, acentuados por la falta de planes de contingencia para atender a las comunidades que se habían visto terriblemente afectadas, los artistas habían reaccionado inmediatamente para atender las necesidades más urgentes de sus vecinos y compatriotas. Comprendí entonces que el proceso de reconstrucción física del Istmo (que intuía iba a ser lento, irregular y con muchas deficiencias) iba a necesitar ser acompañado de un profundo trabajo de <strong><em>reconstrucción emocional</em></strong>.</p><p>Durante la primavera de 2018, tuve ocasión de investigar con algo más de rigor en qué estaban consistiendo las respuestas artísticas a los dos sismos de septiembre. La doctora Diane Davis, profesora de urbanismo en la escuela de diseño de Harvard y experta en historia y política mexicanas, había organizado un seminario titulado “más allá de la reconstrucción” con el objetivo de explorar diferentes maneras de contribuir a la reconstrucción del Istmo de Tehuantepec y de otras ciudades mexicanas afectadas por los temblores. El título del seminario, “más allá de la reconstrucción”, era significativo. ¿Se podía aprovechar la ocasión para reflexionar sobre cómo comunidades como la istmeña podían no solo ser físicamente reconstruidas, sino incluso salir <strong><em>culturalmente fortalecidas</em></strong> tras eventos tan traumáticos como los sismos?</p><p>Poco antes de tomar el seminario (que iba a durar varios meses), había estado estudiando al pedagogo brasileño del siglo XX Paulo Freire. En su obra seminal de 1968 “Pedagogía del Oprimido”, Freire acuña el término de la <strong><em>conscientização</em> </strong>como una necesidad de primera magnitud para liberar a las comunidades más vulnerables de los sistemas de poder de los que dependen y poder determinar su propio futuro. Así, la <em>conscientização</em> es el acto de <strong><em>nombrar </em></strong>aquella realidad que nos rodea, y en particular los problemas y desafíos a los que debemos enfrentarnos para poder construir las vidas que cada uno de nosotros deseamos y merecemos. Solo entendiendo y nombrando la realidad que nos rodea y nos subyuga podemos aspirar a diseñar vidas verdaderamente significativas.</p><p>Fue durante este seminario cuando empecé a relacionar el concepto de <em>conscientização</em> con el papel de los artistas en la reconstrucción emocional y el fortalecimiento cultural del Istmo de Tehuantepec. ¿De qué manera estaba el arte contribuyendo no solo a sanar a la comunidad, sino a visibilizar y dar valor a la cultura istmeña? Así, terminé elaborando para el seminario un <a href="https://issuu.com/tonimoya/docs/antonio_moya_art_catalog_in_juchit_n">catálogo de arte</a> en el que recogía las respuestas artísticas más significativas a los sismos junto a un análisis de las narrativas alternativas sobre la reconstrucción que el arte estaba contribuyendo a escribir.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/898/0*qzNy8IqaifwglK-Q" /><figcaption>Proyecto elaborado para el seminario “más allá de la reconstrucción”.</figcaption></figure><p>A pesar de que quedé satisfecho con el proyecto, sentía que en el modelo teórico faltaba todavía una pieza: arte y <em>conscientização </em>eran elementos necesarios, pero no suficientes, para desencadenar procesos de transformación cultural que fortalecieran a comunidades afectadas por eventos traumáticos como los sismos. La evidencia indicaba que no bastaba con visibilizar la cultura y nombrar los desafíos, sino que los cambios más profundos vienen de un aumento de las <strong><em>capacidades </em></strong>de las comunidades más vulnerables.</p><p>El “enfoque basado en las capacidades” es una teoría de desarrollo propuesta en primer lugar por el economista indio Amartya Sen. En su ensayo de 1999 “desarrollo como libertad”, Sen propone que los planes de desarrollo para las comunidades más vulnerables se centren en expandir las capacidades individuales y colectivas para dotar a los miembros de la comunidad de las herramientas necesarias para construir “las vidas que tienen motivos para valorar.” El enfoque basado en las capacidades, el concepto de <em>conscientização </em>y el papel del arte como lenguaje para articular cambios constituían, a mi parecer, una poderosa tríada conceptual que se podía aplicar al urbanismo comunitario.</p><p>Durante el verano de 2018 tuve ocasión de combinar en un proyecto práctico los tres elementos. Como parte de la maestría de planificación urbana, pasé dos meses trabajando en la <em>favela </em>Jardim Colombo, en São Paulo. Se trataba de una comunidad altamente informal que estaba lidiando con la presencia de un gigantesco vertedero de escombros en medio de su vecindario y que los líderes comunitarios deseaban transformar en un parque.</p><p>Convencidos de que podíamos aprovechar la presencia de un elemento tan traumático como el vertedero, propusimos celebrar un festival de arte y participación ciudadana sobre el vertedero que funcionara como <strong><em>proyecto desencadenante</em></strong> de la transformación del futuro parque. En dos meses, se desarrollaron las capacidades necesarias entre los miembros de la comunidad y los colaboradores externos para organizar el festival; se generó conciencia sobre la importancia de mantener limpio y cuidar el futuro parque, y se aprovechó el potencial del arte para generar un gran día de celebración comunitaria que supusiera el inicio de un proceso de cambio profundo.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0Zh-76EOJgGjftnq" /><figcaption>Segundo festival de arte y participación en Jardim Colombo, São Paulo (julio de 2019).</figcaption></figure><p>El proyecto no solo fue un éxito, sino que, como habíamos anticipado, se convirtió en la primera piedra de un largo y complejo proceso de transformación que iba a revolucionar a la comunidad de Jardim Colombo. La auto-construcción del parque acababa de comenzar, y la comunidad programó eventos mensuales en este espacio para mantenerlo vivo e involucrar a un mayor número de vecinos cada vez. En julio de 2019 se celebró la segunda edición del festival, y todo apunta a que el proceso va a continuar activo hasta que el parque esté terminado — y más allá.</p><p>En mi tesis de maestría reflexioné sobre la experiencia en Jardim Colombo. Titulada “El ciclo desencadenante” (2019), mi tesis es una teorización sobre cómo proyectos que fomenten la <em>conscientização</em>, el desarrollo de capacidades y que hacen uso del arte aspiran a transformar en profundidad a comunidades vulnerables y a fortalecer su cultura. En particular, razono sobre cómo es posible aprovechar momentos traumáticos para desencadenar tales procesos.</p><p>De ahí el título de este ensayo. “El trauma urbano como oportunidad” es, en cierto modo, muy similar al título del seminario en el que participé. ¿Podemos hacer un esfuerzo para responder a los sismos que afectaron al Istmo de Tehuantepec “más allá de la reconstrucción”? En lugar de tratar de recuperar indiscriminadamente aquello que existía antes de los temblores, ¿cómo podemos generar procesos colectivos que den lugar a una comunidad más fuerte, más justa y mejor preparada para construir el futuro que desean?</p><p>El papel del arte es fundamental si queremos aspirar a que las comunidades del Istmo afectadas por los temblores de 2017, así como otras poblaciones que igualmente sufren traumas urbanos, salgan fortalecidas del dolor. Reconstruir no consiste solo en volver a erigir físicamente aquello que ya existía, sino también en dotar de las herramientas psicológicas y emocionales que una comunidad necesita para salir adelante.</p><p>Mi apuesta es por un urbanismo que sirva para desencadenar procesos de transformaciones culturales profundas más allá de lo inmediato y lo obvio. Centrada en expandir la <em>conscientização </em>y las capacidades de comunidades atravesando momentos traumáticos, la planificación urbana es una poderosa herramienta para construir un mundo más equitativo y de gran diversidad cultural y social en el que cada individuo y cada comunidad aspiren a vivir vidas plenas.</p><p><strong>Nota</strong>: Este artículo fue publicado en el Anuario de diciembre de 2019 de Casa de la Ciudad, Oaxaca, titulado “<a href="https://fahhoaxaca-my.sharepoint.com/personal/sandrafernandez_fahho_mx/Documents/ANUARIO%202019%20-WEB.pdf">Re-Vive tu espacio</a>”.</p><p><strong>Referencias</strong></p><ul><li>Freire, Paulo. (1968). <em>Pedagogía del oprimido.</em></li><li>Sen, Amartya (1999). <em>Desarrollo como libertad.</em></li><li>Moya-Latorre, A. (2019). <em>The Sparking Cycle: A Culture-Oriented Approach to System Change in Oppressed Communities.</em></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=728d394e85a3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja/arte-y-reconstrucci%C3%B3n-el-trauma-urbano-como-oportunidad-728d394e85a3">Arte y reconstrucción: el trauma urbano como oportunidad</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ciudad-compleja">Ciudad Poliédrica</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>