<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ashley Tien on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ashley Tien on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ashley.tien?source=rss-1edd7467fe0e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 17:42:13 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ashley.tien/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why is Darth Vader a beloved icon of villainy while Catherine and Heathcliff are polarizing and…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ashley.tien/why-is-darth-vader-a-beloved-icon-of-villainy-while-catherine-and-heathcliff-are-polarizing-and-d1d08346a6ee?source=rss-1edd7467fe0e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d1d08346a6ee</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[wuthering-heights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[star-wars]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[darth-vader]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ashley Tien]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 Jul 2026 17:34:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-24T17:34:41.899Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Why is Darth Vader a beloved icon of villainy while Catherine and Heathcliff are polarizing and often flatly reviled?</h3><h3>(Part 1): Mythic Tragedy vs. Gothic Disorder: How Narrative Framing Turns Darth Vader Into an Icon and Catherine &amp; Heathcliff Into Villains</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*5p0XMWpCCbLoOWsC.png" /></figure><p>George Lucas was criticized harshly for the way he directed the prequels and even hardcore Star Wars fans to this day who love the prequels often remark on the flawed nature of these films but Lucas deserves a standing ovation for the way he wrote and directed Anakin’s character because he managed to make audiences believe that a mass murderer and galactic genocidaire deserved to be redeemed and he did so in such a manner that he is regarded as better of a man than a domestic abuser. One is a tragic hero who fell from grace and the other is your narcissist ex-boyfriend who clearly has sociopathic and obsessive tendencies, violates corpses in his free time, and likes to hurt animals and kids! One deserves sympathy and a happy life with his wife and children and the other needs to go to jail. Anakin and Heathcliff fascinate me as characters because they are examples of extreme competence in one area with non-existent emotional health and to say the two men had relationship issues in their lives is an understatement. They have as much in common as they do their differences, one of them being the disparity in the way their characters, actions, and love lives are evaluated, and that disparity fascinates as well as kills me. I can’t say enough about how skillful of a writer Bronte is as well. Nelly as the prime narrator is <em>lethal!</em> I’ve had folks give me hell when I tried to compare Anakin and Heathcliff and the indignation in which Anakin’s actions were softened and contextualized and the comparison dismissed as disingenuous and invalid was something to behold!</p><p>“Anakin committed genocide but he had a <em>good</em> side! Heathcliff had none!”</p><p>“Anakin is sympathetic because he was <em>trying</em> to do good. He had good <em>intentions! </em>Heathcliff never did! Anakin wanted to save his loved ones from dying while Heathcliff was just a vengeful asshole who was out to hurt people because he couldn’t get over Catherine marrying another man!”</p><p>“We know why Anakin fell to the Dark Side but there is little to no explanation as to why Heathcliff turned out the way that he did! He was just a bad guy! I have zero sympathy for him!”</p><p>“Anakin loved his wife and son and he was <em>redeemed!</em> Heathcliff never was!”</p><p>“Heathcliff was obsessive! What he had with Catherine wasn’t love! Anakin’s love became possessive and selfish, but his love for Padme was originally pure.”</p><p>“Anakin was tragic and besides, Star Wars is full of aliens. It’s a completely different story from <em>Wuthering Heights </em>so<em> </em>you can’t compare them!”</p><p>“Catherine was an <em>evil, </em>manipulative moron and she deserved to die! Everyone was clearly better off without her and Heathcliff! I was relieved when they died! She and Heathcliff shared a soul but it was a wicked and selfish one! Heathcliff’s actions violated the <em>moral</em> architecture of the novel! Star Wars had romantic elements in it! <em>Wuthering Heights</em> is not a romantic novel!”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/498/0*vWtrCik9vvhMy77W.gif" /></figure><p>Never have I seen the power of narrative framing been more apparent in shaping the way a character is perceived. <em>Wuthering Heights</em> has been an eye-opener of a novel and it stands out among the others I have read because I have learned more from people’s responses to it than from the text itself. Asking someone who has read <em>Wuthering Heights </em>whether it is a love story is always an entertaining question and one the Internet has turned into a moral purity test, one in which I have failed miserably. Heathcliff’s character inspires either revulsion or forbidden fascination and nothing in between while Darth Vader seems to be overwhelmingly beloved and on videos or posts deeming him evil, there are folks ready to provide context and sympathy for the mad lad. It has me rethinking pretty much every other show and text I have read and watched when I was left wondering why certain characters are thrashed by the audience while others are beloved. After comparing Catherine and Heathcliff to characters from other franchises, I have concluded that the narrator is the most powerful character without needing to be one. <em>Anakin had a good side?</em> Dude was complicit in blowing up an entire planet! He might have been <em>narratively</em> redeemed at the end, but it doesn’t undo twenty years of galactic atrocities. If Vader had a Nelly instead of a Luke, there would have been no redemption arc! If Nelly had been the prime narrator of Star Wars, audiences would have cheered for the diabolical villain to die! Luke loved and advocated for him but to the vast majority of the galaxy, Vader was a monster! This tells me if I am a sound enough writer, I can get the audience to root for a person who objectively did worse and follow him into the depths of Hell!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/0*nMnKJ_B2dxcUbYHb.gif" /></figure><p>Imagine a real-life scenario in which a man who wiped out a classroom of young children with a hot laser sword is defended as having a good side! In the latter half of <em>Revenge of the Sith,</em> Anakin was a butcher and how far he had fallen! The audience was spared as the camera cut right as Anakin ignited his lightsaber but every single one of those children he killed must have been terrified that the man they thought was there to protect them from the assault on the Jedi Temple was now stabbing and slashing at them with no explanation. Unless they were completely frozen in fear, he probably had to chase a few of them down in that sealed room. Palpatine unleashed a wolf in a pen of lambs and it’s no wonder Anakin had a meltdown on Mustafar shortly after for even amidst his delusion he knew he had committed a great wrong and that he knew it was wrong and did it anyway worsens the act does it not? If the audience had a chance to hear those children scream as Linton Heathcliff did when he was dying in terror of his father, I don’t think there would be much sympathy for Anakin, no matter how traumatic his history was. If <em>Revenge of the Sith</em> had been rated R and we had seen the full assault on the Jedi Temple take place and Anakin mow everyone down with his full brutality displayed on screen and not viewed second-hand by Obi-wan and Yoda through snippets of security camera footage, he would be perceived differently.</p><p>Before any Anakin or Darth Vader fan gets mad, I am as bad an Anakin glazer as any, like full heart-eyes, but I don’t believe he was anything close to resembling a good man just because he saved his son last minute, was once a sweet kid, and had heart-warming moments with Padme and heroic deeds as a Jedi under his belt. Vader never had to live with the consequences of his actions as he dies right after saving Luke so it’s (narrative) absolution without repair. He put an end to the great evil that was Palpatine and the Empire but that was after over twenty years of bloodletting and he was partially responsible for said power rising in the first place. Anakin became fully immersed in the Dark Side and the persona of Darth Vader after Padme’s death and ruminated on her loss for twenty years and carved bloody gullets into the galaxy to fill the void she left behind. Why is his violence framed as a maladaptive coping mechanism for the loss of his wife and a mythic tragedy while Heathcliff’s vengeance is presented as evidence of his apparent inability to love anyone and an inherent malformation of character?</p><p>Romanticizing Heathcliff is problematic because he is violent and his relationship with Catherine was unhealthy and if I do so, I apparently need help but what about Mr. War Crimes over there? Anakin is a violent man, yet his relationship with Padme is romanticized. There are Star Wars themed weddings complete with cosplay and <em>Across the Stars</em> playing in the background. It’s been over twenty years since <em>Revenge of the Sith </em>was released and I see new renditions of their love song and AI generated videos of Anakin reuniting with Padme in the afterlife. Why does one man get all the videos breaking him down titled “Anakin did nothing wrong” or “Anakin was justified” while Heathcliff is another toxic man. The videos titled “Anakin did nothing wrong” are more nuanced than the title would appear but all I am saying is I don’t think I will ever see a video with the same title regarding Heathcliff unless the content creator is a glutton for punishment. If I love Heathcliff’s character and try to contextualize his actions, that’s a red flag because I am condoning abusive behavior, but if I like Anakin and analyze why this promising young man with great potential ultimately decided that the only way he could save his beloved wife from death was to purge the Jedi Order and do everything this giggling scumbag told him to do, I’m just another Star Wars fan and can see through the lies of the Jedi? <em>What?</em></p><p>“Anakin is a tragic villain, Ashley. He was born into slavery and when he lost his mother, Padme became the light of his life and his mind became corrupted by the Dark Side. He did all of these things because he was afraid of losing her the same way he lost his mother. The Jedi wronged him and all but pushed him towards Palpatine by ostracizing him and besides, that wasn’t really Anakin who choked Padme but Darth Vader.”</p><p>Do you see that right there?! Context. If a villain is loved, he gets context and with context often comes sympathy and with enough nurturing, said sympathy often comes with a side of justification. Heathcliff’s character is often boiled down to a list of abusive behaviors and condemnation for his assholery with no context or explanation as to how he reached that point and if his childhood happens to be mentioned, it’s often qualified by “X characters were abused and didn’t turn out the way that he did” or “I was abused and didn’t become an abuser so he must have been a bad egg.” If I were to list out all of Darth Vader’s crimes with zero backstory as I have seen done with Heathcliff, instead of his arc being known as the stuff of cinematic legend, he would be a child-murdering, galactic-terrorizing sociopathic douche! How can someone like this have ever received a redemption arc? Luke was nuts and it wasn’t that blue milk that did it! Anakin slaughtered an entire village of Tusken Raiders but he was sorry, it was the Jedi’s fault for separating him from his mother and for not providing any mental health support for pre-existing trauma, and he did those murders out of impulsive rage and grief over his mother’s death. His love for Padme became possessive because he was terrified of losing her and he killed and tried to kill people who loved and trusted him, but Palpatine had been grooming him from a young age so what chance did he have of seeing through the lies of a master manipulator? There shouldn’t be a “but” after genocide but Lucas made it happen and that finesse of storytelling is not talked about enough. Heathcliff doesn’t receive “but’s” the way Anakin does, only barrages of clinical diagnosing and moral flaying in place of understanding.</p><p>If we’re going to dish it out, everyone needs to receive fair helpings. If Heathcliff is a monster, then Hindley should not get off scot-free. He was a victim of Heathcliff’s and of poor parenting by his father but he was also a lifelong abuser who played a critical role in shaping Heathcliff into the man he became and I never see anyone use his cruelty and violence as evidence that he did not love his wife as it often is with Heathcliff. Nelly questioned his moral character but never his humanity as it done with Heathcliff. Heathcliff was an asshole but he came from an ecosystem of enclosed assholery. Everyone in the Earnshaw household was violent in one way or another to someone else and the violence was top-down. Hindley abused his position of authority and social rank to perpetuate such violence against members of his household he deemed beneath him with impunity, a lesson that Heathcliff unfortunately embraced wholeheartedly as an adult. After Earnshaw died, Hindley and Joseph became Heathcliff’s models for masculinity, with sprinklings of Edgar Linton and not the courtly gentleman who came over to the Heights to see his beloved Catherine, but the snob who looked down on him and joined his family in their mutual disapproval and derision of him. Obi-wan has always come off as a cold fish to me but I would take him over this trio any day. (People hate Heathcliff but fuck Joseph. How the hell did he outlive Heathcliff?!) Edgar may have been sweet on Catherine and his daughter, but he was an elitist with deep-seated prejudices. However, because he was non-violent (except for that one time he punched Heathcliff in the throat and ordered his servants to escort him violently from the Grange, that is) was polite and had manners, was the proper Christian gentleman in Nelly’s eyes and in the eyes of society, he is seen as a good guy.</p><p>If I were to ever write a character, I would want to write one like Heathcliff, one who the world and the narrative are staunchly against. A character who is hated and reviled by all those whom society would deem good and proper and beloved by a handful who are “problematic” and because they are problematic, no one in the audience will sympathize. Who wants to love a character who is loved by other unlikeable characters? Who in the novel liked Heathcliff? Catherine? And no one liked her anyway so how helpful is that? Every good villain needs PR and if we’re going to evaluate Heathcliff as a villain, then I can say with confidence that his PR sucked. Anakin had George Lucas on his side. Lucas was deeply immersed in the character of Anakin Skywalker. He made Anakin the backbone of the first six Star Wars films and the bulwark of the franchise: there is a reason these films are known colloquially as the Skywalker Saga. Lucas saw Anakin as more than a villain but a tragic hero who fell from grace and whose decisions were a result of personal tragedy and poor choices rather than inherent evil and that shaped the way he wrote the character. He cast Jake Lloyd and Hayden Christensen to portray Anakin because he felt they would best showcase the duality in his character: the darkness and innocence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*m7oRe44ykl3vA8eD.jpeg" /></figure><p>In <em>A New Hope</em>, the audience is introduced to this imposing figure in black known only as Lord Vader, the right hand of the Emperor and if he remained so, he would have been a cool villain but not much in terms of emotional attachment. However, Vader received this direct tie to the hero and fan favorite Luke Skywalker as his father and in <em>Return of the Jedi</em>, the audience saw for the first time the man behind the mask. He was no longer this faceless monster but was humanized as this broken man filled with regret and who outlived most everyone he loved. The story ends with closure between father and son and a happy ending but the way things left off stoked audience curiosity. Who was Anakin Skywalker and how did a great Jedi fall to such evil? How did Palpatine manage to hook his claws into him? Vader fathered Luke and Leia and so who was their mother? Who were the Jedi and what is the true nature of the Force? Lucas proceeds to answer all of these questions and more. He paints a very sympathetic backstory in the prequels. The terror of the galaxy Darth Vader was once this cute, bright-eyed boy named Anakin who had a positive outlook on life and was eager to help people. He had empathy and compassion for others and wanted to use his powers for good. He was a boy with great potential who was set upon by a master manipulator and larger forces at work. He was born into slavery but the narrative humanizes him while it dehumanizes Heathcliff.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*wIOwUfCk72zzqtF9.png" /></figure><p>Heathcliff was a sullen, quiet child without the same charisma and appeal of child Anakin. and from his first appearance in the novel, it was clear that he did not belong and never would. Lockwood observed that he was a “dark-skinned gypsy” who looked out of place with his surroundings and this is <em>after</em> Heathcliff became a wealthy and powerful landowner. Mrs. Earnshaw wanted the “gypsy brat” out and Nelly concurred and tried to leave the child by the stairway hoping “it” would wander off. Before he was christened Heathcliff, he was referred to as “it,” not “him” or “the boy” but “it.” Hindley and the Lintons called him, among other things: an “imp of Satan,” or a demonic child, a thief and a “vagabond,” a “beggarly interloper” and a “vulgar young ruffian” who was “worse than a brute.” Nelly stated that teenage Heathcliff must have been “possessed of something diabolical” and that he was repulsive. She told Lockwood that he was a “cuckoo,” or a parasite who had latched onto the Earnshaw household. And we haven’t even begun to touch the surface of the racialization he experienced throughout his life and all of these moral, class, and race-based insults formed a cesspool that he never was able to completely be freed of. It never relents for Heathcliff even after the man’s dead, with Joseph insisting over the corpse that it must have been the Devil that carried off his soul!</p><p>“ ‘Is he a ghoul or a vampire?’ I mused. I had read of such hideous incarnate demons. And then I set myself to reflect how I had tended him in infancy, and watched him grow to youth, and followed him almost through his whole course; and what absurd nonsense it was to yield to that sense of horror. ‘But where did he come from, the little dark thing, harboured by a good man to his bane?’ muttered Superstition, as I dozed into unconsciousness.” (Chapter 34).</p><p>Nelly harbored some sympathy for Heathcliff and knew this monstrous man was once this little ragged, nameless boy who would withstand her pinching without uttering a word. It was touchingly futile when she tried to help Heathcliff when he was dying by offering him food and to call a doctor when he was beyond earthly intervention but in her deepest thoughts, he was this dark little <em>thing</em> who brought such misfortune upon the Earnshaw household and this wasn’t the first time either she frames his existence as inherently luckless. Heathcliff didn’t exactly grow up to be a harbinger of good fortune but I’m not sure if he was ever given the environment to grow into one. He had a moment where he wanted to be good but Hindley ruined it by tossing him into the attic. Anakin was walking red flags as a teenager and young adult but never was he called “a wicked man,” a “fiend,” “that Devil,” a “ghoul,” “demon,” and “vampire” as Heathcliff was, and not the sexy, suave vampires that have become popularized in the 20th century. The vampires of Bronte’s time were conceived of contaminants and carriers of moral and spiritual pollution: they were these unholy, unnatural beings that existed outside of the realm of God. Anakin was a good man who fell to evil but there was something inherently wrong with Heathcliff. He wasn’t a man who made poor decisions but some kind of inhuman monster or liminal being and due to the ambiguity built into his character, that makes him that much more difficult to humanize and therefore empathize with as compared to Anakin, whose character was fleshed out to the T.</p><p>With Anakin, the audience did not have to cut through layers of hostile narration to see things unfold in live time. And Anakin had advocates. He had his mother, Qui-gon, the <em>very</em> popular and meme-able Obi-wan Kenobi, and Padme backing him up. His mother spoke of him as this child who was nothing but good and she is Shmi Skywalker, the woman the Force chose to carry Space Jesus. Imagine having the space equivalent of the Virgin Mary as your mother! Who will doubt your innate goodness? And everyone loves Padme. She was kind, compassionate, traditionally feminine, and was a successful politician as well as a loving wife and mother, which is the direct opposite of Catherine Earnshaw. As a padawan in training, Anakin was made fun of for having been a slave as a child in the comics, the Jedi Council distrusted him, and Obi-wan initially stated that the boy was dangerous but little Anakin with his sweet gestures and boyish enthusiasm appeared anything but dangerous and so the audience sides with him and the Jedi stilted in their ways are perceived as people out to get him. All this fear that he would fall to the Dark Side, that he couldn’t be trusted, that he was unstable and too old to be trained: You all jinxed it! Heathcliff was in a similar situation in that everyone around him was projecting negativity onto him from the moment he made his first appearance and then they were all shocked when he turned out the way they said he already was but at least Anakin had people to counteract negativity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*2AQ_jxLMX-GSd0VU.gif" /></figure><p>After he fell from grace, Vader had Luke Skywalker, the iconic classic hero who inspired generations, to testify that he was a man worth saving. He was not a monster but someone who had lost his way. When Luke told Vader “I feel the good in you,” no one in the audience asked what was he smoking for saying that about someone complicit with planetary genocide. The audience often inherits the views of the narrator, whether consciously or unconsciously, and since Star Wars didn’t have one to tell the audience who was good and who was bad, characters like Luke can step in and shape the narrative. The world of Star Wars is an expansive one but the intimacy drawn between Luke and his father could make one almost forget the opinions the world at large had of Vader. Heathcliff didn’t have anyone alive to advocate for his humanity. He didn’t have a Luke Skywalker to stand behind him and tell audiences that he deserved to be saved. (It’s not so much whether it is true but what the narrative allows: the Star Wars narrative allows for a person like Vader to be redeemed and for <em>systemic </em>redemption to happen.) Catherine was dead, Lockwood was oblivious, and Nelly was dead-set in her ways and remained judgmental until the end. Hareton loved him but never understood him and his love for Heathcliff is often written off as a trauma response. Heathcliff comingled with banally indifferent underlings like the lawyer Mr. Green and unsavory individuals like Joseph who was more of a fixture or a gargoyle than a man. His only child was the unlikeable, pitiful Linton who only ever existed as his pawn in stark contrast to the heroic, charismatic Luke and what did Cathy have going for her except being annoying and grating on the ears and would seemingly rather die than pick one man?</p><p>Nelly wasn’t what I would consider a villain or a bad person, but my <em>God</em>, her worldview was limited and she was very much a mouthpiece for the prevailing attitudes of for Victorian domestic morality: a worldview that disapproved of emotional excess, social transgression, racial ambiguity, and any form of passion that could not be contained within the boundaries of propriety. If her evaluations of each character are taken in isolation, the narrative skewing is not as apparent but once you compare and contrast the way in which she regards each character, that’s when her bias stands out. With adult Heathcliff, condemnation and criticism is warranted but she was already issuing judgements about his character long before he grew into the man he became and she was selective about who she condemned and who she expressed sympathy towards. She was duty-bound to the Earnshaws and Lintons and since her livelihood depended on them, she was conditioned to mind her station and not ask too many questions of her employers and it shows. She had incentive to put in a good word for them and it’s the interlopers she took issue with, the interlopers being yours truly and his chaotic other half, and anyone else who didn’t fit societal standards of propriety. She never condemned the Lintons’ classism and racial prejudices because this was considered normal in the society they lived in and she will defend that status quo because it’s all she ever knew.</p><p>“He ventured this remark without any intention to insult; but Heathcliff’s violent nature was not prepared to endure the appearance of impertinence from one whom he seemed to hate, even then, as a rival.” (Chapter 7).</p><p>“But he was too good to be thoroughly unhappy long. <em>He</em> didn’t pray for Catherine’s soul to haunt him. Time brought resignation, and a melancholy sweeter than common joy. He recalled her memory with ardent, tender love, and hopeful aspiring to the better world; where he doubted not she was gone.” (Chapter 17).</p><p>“But, I thought in my mind, Hindley, with apparently the stronger head, has shown himself sadly the worse and the weaker man. When his ship struck, the captain abandoned his post; and the crew, instead of trying to save her, rushed into riot and confusion, leaving no hope for their luckless vessel. Linton, on the contrary, displayed the true courage of a loyal and faithful soul: he trusted God; and God comforted him.” (Chapter 17).</p><p>Edgar Linton was superior. His was a <em>true </em>Christian spirit and his love for Catherine was the example of a tender, ardent love. Heathcliff’s grief was savage and animalistic and Hindley was weak for collapsing after his wife died and it’s <em>baffling</em> as to why he did that. Catherine Sr. the teenager was arrogant and up her high horse but Catherine Jr. was her sweet mistress who had an ill moment with her cousin Hareton when she laughed and made fun of him because he was unable to read. By no means was it evidence she had inherited prejudices from her daddy. Heathcliff had an inherently violent nature: that is why he threw hot apple sauce at Edgar as a child after he made a comment about his appearance. It couldn’t have been sensitivity and a trauma response due to years of bullying, derision, and abuse. Hareton threw a large rock at her head and hanged a litter of puppies as a kid, but he was wronged while Linton had a defective character and should die! They weren’t all children shaped by a violent environment. Linton was a sickly, peevish child and but he never had the chance to be anything better as Hareton did and the same goes for Catherine. She was around eighteen years old when she died: she never had a chance to grow up.</p><p>Catherine and Heathcliff were chaotic, destructive, and often unpleasant but the narrator is not neutral. Their story is a Gothic phenomenon filtered through the eyes of two realists who moralize, misunderstand, and misinterpret them. Because neither Catherine nor Heathcliff fits the mold of a “likeable” protagonist, and because Nelly sounds reasonable while they sound volatile, readers are far more likely to trust her and accept her judgments as fact. Two things can be true at the same time: Nelly had just cause to dislike Catherine as she manhandled her as a child but that her dislike of her and Heathcliff also colored the narrative and portrayal of the events the reader receives. Both women were trapped in rigid social roles, but only Nelly adapted. She became her role: dutiful, conventional, morally certain. Catherine cannot compromise between her wild Earnshaw self and her Linton self, and when she implodes, she is judged for it. When Nelly wished Catherine would die so she would stop being a burden, a portion of readers agree with her. If you hate a character enough to want her gone, you will interpret her collapse as deserved moral failure rather than psychological breakdown. She’s only a toxic bitch, so who cares? Good riddance! Catherine’s final illness at the Grange is often framed as either Heathcliff’s fault or a childish fit but it is also identity fragmentation and an attempt to escape a life she can no longer inhabit.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/375/0*K6ZJaCKEqVVOMsuj.jpeg" /></figure><p>“He complained so seldom, indeed, of such stirs as these, that I really thought him not vindictive: I was deceived completely, as you will hear.” (Chapter 4).</p><p>Nelly, don’t retroactively claim eighteen years later that he was like this all along and that everyone should have seen it coming. Heathcliff asked Hindley to trade horses with him when they were kids and had threatened to tell his father on him if he didn’t do so about all of the beatings and threats to have him booted out. Hindley acquiesced but not before throwing an iron weight at him, deriding him, and attempted to have him run over by a horse while openly hoping that the horse would smash his head open, and Nelly used this as an example to showcase Heathcliff’s secret vindictive nature with no condemnation for Hindley for what could have gotten a child seriously injured or killed. Nelly told Heathcliff that he was wicked for having vengeful thoughts against Hindley and that was about as effective as Yoda telling Anakin to let things go when he came to him with fears that a loved one might die or to suppress his emotions as if they were shameful and not human. This is a child: I can’t blame Heathcliff for feeling vengeful and wanting to retaliate against his abuser. He went about it in all the wrong ways but if Padme can tell Anakin “to be angry is to be human” after he went on a murder rampage against the Raiders, then Heathcliff feeling vengeful is not evidence of an innately bad nature.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/780/0*4yZNlidQBTBY4dDS.jpeg" /></figure><p>“At fifteen she was the queen of the country-side; she had no peer; and she did turn out a haughty, headstrong creature! I own I did not like her, after infancy was past; and I vexed her frequently by trying to bring down her arrogance: she never took an aversion to me, though.” (Chapter 8)</p><p>The story of Catherine and Heathcliff is relayed to the audience by someone who liked neither of them almost twenty years after the fact. Catherine was indeed annoying and childish with poor impulse control but she didn’t grow up in an environment conducive to emotional regulation. She was a high-voltage, high-energy child who needed consistent, calm role modeling and discipline but her mother died when she was around seven and her father was too ill to give her what she needed before he also died. Everyone was an orphan in this novel! Catherine Jr. stands out among the rest in that she actually had a loving parental figure until her teens and was reared in a nurturing, albeit sheltered environment that made all the difference in the world and Joseph was about as good a parental figure as Heathcliff was to Hareton. All three children in that household grew up to be violent, emotionally dysregulated adults who could not cope with grief and separation in healthy ways but according to Nelly, it wasn’t a lack of adequate parental figures and developmental stunting, but an issue of character and lack of propriety. On a side note, Catherine is not my favorite by any means but I find it sad she was secretly so disliked by someone who she confided in and saw as part of her life and childhood.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*C0voxVGDr5Viff5h.jpeg" /></figure><p>Separating Anakin from his mother was perhaps the worst thing that could have happened to him as a child and it’s a tragedy the audience can clearly see. The death of Anakin’s mother was a pivotal event in <em>Attack of the Clones</em>. He had been tormented with recurring nightmares and visions of her death, the same premonitions that would later haunt him when it came to Padme. His mother was killed in a brutal manner and the audience can see and feel how devastating it was for him and how it fed into his pre-existing fear of loss and amplified that need for control that ultimately led to him believing he needed to embrace the Dark Side to achieve ultimate power to protect his loved ones from dying. It’s spelled out. It’s tradition for fans to point to a specific moment where Anakin’s fall to the Dark Side was inevitable and the death of his mother often makes that list but Heathcliff didn’t have such explicit “ah-hah!” moments. The night he ran off after hearing of Catherine’s impending marriage to Edgar is marked as a pivotal event but Heathcliff had been a pressure cooker for years. He didn’t have dramatic outbursts as Anakin did but The deaths of Mr. Earnshaw and that of all parental figures in this novel were almost banal in comparison to Anakin’s mother being tortured for over a month and dying in her arms, and the reactions just as, and so the devastation is not experienced by the audience as full frontal as it was with the death of Shmi Skywalker, even if it is no less catastrophic. The deaths of Mr. and Catherine Earnshaw were two of the worst things that happened to Heathcliff that he never recovered from, alongside her marriage to Edgar.</p><p>Catherine’s parents never receive first names: they were simply called Mr. and Mrs. Earnshaw and Bronte provided no description of their physical appearances. They were a faceless bunch as were Edgar and Isabella’s parents. I suppose we can infer that at least one of the Earnshaw parents had curly brown hair and black eyes and either or both Mr. and Mrs. Linton were blonde with blue eyes as those were the distinguishing traits of each house, but my point is it was a purposeful decision on Bronte’s part to withhold these details and the consequence of that is dampened emotional resonance. The audience moves on from these deaths as quickly as the narrative does while the death of Anakin’s mother overtly lingers in the narrative. The death of Mrs. Earnshaw, who was the sole maternal presence in the household, was communicated in a throw away line. We never even receive a cause of death. Due to the prevalence of illness in this novel, I have to assume she died from some form of consumption but who knows. Catherine and Hindley’s reactions to her death are not shown and she is never mentioned again except in passing by old Earnshaw and apart from a brief glimpse of Catherine and Heathcliff crying together on the night of old Earnshaw’s death, we don’t get insight into Heathcliff’s mind as to how he felt about his benefactor. As far as I can tell, it seemed that old Earnshaw didn’t leave a lasting impression on him and that’s the point.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*Lx3Tjs9Drl3crHCD.gif" /></figure><p>Anakin only had nine years with his mother but it was foundational to his identity and gave him baseline personhood. Heathcliff knew a few years of indulgence from Mr. Earnshaw and even that was intermittent with Hindley’s bullying and beatings before he lost even that when Earnshaw died. He never experienced any stability in childhood and adolescent unless you count consistent violence and humiliation as consistency. Catherine and Heathcliff went feral in the midst of this parental void and it’s not spelled out but something the reader has to infer. In place of morality, boundaries, ethics, relational empathy, compassion, and separate personhood, which form the foundation for normal human relations, Catherine and Heathcliff had a fused identity. A collapsed identity can sound romantic on paper but the plot of <em>Wuthering Heights</em> is an example of why it doesn’t play out so well when it inevitably collides against reality. This is a child’s love that never had the chance to mature into an adult romance. They fused when they were around 6–7 years old, a critical period of development where children are still forming their identities and it froze there. There is no boundary between you and I (because they never formed any boundaries). We are of a single soul substance, one soul split in twain. It’s not “I love you” and “you love me” but “I am you” and “you are me.” Most people, including Anakin, have a self outside of their relationships. Catherine and Heathcliff, especially Heathcliff, did not. The bond became synonymous with their identity.</p><p>They were not merely joined at the hip but one entity that society forced to exist as two, which is why it all went down the gutter when the real world in the form of the Lintons showed up on their doorstep. Society and adulthood demands that people live as separate selves and to acclimate and change according to life circumstances. Heathcliff never got that memo and Catherine attempted to live with one foot in the past and the other in the present and the future, to sate her need for comfort and stability via a marriage through Edgar, and to preserve her childhood self with Heathcliff. Catherine and Anakin both had a split self going on but while Anakin was able to come to terms with both sides of his identity, Catherine never did. The Catherine who was bugging Lockwood at that window was not a full-bodied ghost but a fragment of longing: the Linton half of her identity died at the Grange. Anakin’s romance with Padme, however flawed it was, was still legible as an adult romantic relationship, and so it is more palatable (and therefore acceptable) to general audience than what the chaotic duo had. Their plight was that of circumstance and I’d wager if they had been able to live in peace, they would have lived happily. Catherine and Heathcliff were, technically speaking, never in a relationship because they were children who never differentiated into separate selves. And given how rare this phenomenon is in fiction and the intensity of their bond, they are frequently conceived of as just another case of obsessed lovers when they were more so a single consciousness that attempted to function in separate bodies.</p><p>(As for whether Catherine and Heathcliff are romantic, it depends on what criteria you are using. By the standards of a modern romance, they are anything but romantic but by the standards of 19th century Romanticism, they are romantic. And notice that I am not inquiring as to whether these are good people, whether what they had was healthy, or if they had happy endings. Those are the criteria of a <em>modern </em>romance. Theirs is the Gothic counterpart and Gothic romances are known for many things but the depiction of healthy human relations isn’t one of them).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/380/0*P7J4Fo5kIRQCmmTq.jpeg" /></figure><p>Mr. Earnshaw did great damage to all three children but because he seemed jolly and harmless and did a kindly deed by taking in a lost child and spoiled Heathcliff, the damage can fly under the radar. Heathcliff’s character showcases the importance of imbibing in children the concept of “no.” Heathcliff never seemed to understand the concept and when it came to him, neither did Catherine. There was a lot of chastising and punishment in that house but not much, if any, actual teaching. The seeds for the intergenerational tragedy that ensued after Catherine’s death were all sowed when they were all children. And Nelly was a child and a servant so she wasn’t in a position to be a role model for anyone. Her job was to make sure everyone’s basic needs were met and she was just trying to survive and not get swept up into the drama. It’s why she and Joseph were the only survivors of the first generation.</p><p>Honestly, did any adult in the Earnshaw household teach the children that hurting others is wrong? It seems obvious and a given: how can you <em>not</em> know not to hurt people unless you’re a psycho but that needs to be taught. Children can be sweet but they can also seem inconsiderate and selfish but it’s not because they are bad. They are simply not done forming yet and it’s up to the adults around them to set proper boundaries and foster emotional regulation. Old Earnshaw smacked little Cathy when she spat at Heathcliff and he tried to do the same to Hindley with his cane when he felt anyone was conspiring against Heathcliff and all that did was foster and fuel the pre-existing resentment and hatred Hindley had against the latter. Catherine was a wild child and Earnshaw shamed her when she would not settle down and all that scolding only egged her on. As a teenager, Catherine learned that her behavior was not socially acceptable and that she would lose her ticket out of the Heights if she kept that up in front of the Lintons but that wasn’t a moral lesson. When Heathcliff starved a nest of baby birds, Catherine told him to stop that but he didn’t learn that it was animal cruelty, merely that Catherine didn’t like it. When Hareton hanged those puppies, cursed Nelly out, and threw that rock at her head, it wasn’t because he was psychotic: he was aping the adults in the house, most likely you-know-who. Anakin knew what he had done in his life was wrong: he had a conscience and the audience sees him struggle with it throughout the prequels while Heathcliff never had such qualms and so he seems inhuman in a way Vader was not. Audiences assume people have this basic equipment that they never had the environment to develop and so they look at their behavior and conclude as Nelly did that they were bad.</p><p>Audiences are more comfortable sympathizing with Vader than with Heathcliff because Vader gets that a redemption arc and so there’s no moral contamination when you feel bad for him. The narrative tells you that it’s alright to have sympathy. It’s the same reason in many romance films with cheating as the central plot, they make the partner that is cheated on a cartoon villain or otherwise unappealing so the audience won’t experience guilt for cheering on the protagonist for cheating. Vader did all of these godawful things but he’s one of the good guys now and he was always a good guy deep inside. <em>Vader </em>did all of those terrible things, not Anakin! Luke vouched for him and Luke’s the hero! Anakin fulfilled the prophecy by eliminating the Sith and brought balance to the Force by sacrificing his life to save his son! He gets the touching music, ascension, his force ghost dissolving into a mystical cosmos and closure with his master, complete with forgiveness, apologies, and moral clarity. Anakin was good, then he became bad, then apparently, he became good again. The audience can hold onto these things in the face of a ridiculous number of crimes and retain coherence.</p><p>With Heathcliff, there are no narrative guardrails. Heathcliff was no child of prophecy and his fate wasn’t written in the stars. He was a nobody from nowhere with no name of his own except one bequeathed to him by a man who might have used it as a placeholder for his dead son. Heathcliff’s name says everything about what he was: a perpetual outsider. A last name denotes lineage, roots, and belonging. Anakin had one while Heathcliff never did. And any soft moments he might have had as a child are long forgotten by the time we reach the penultimate chapters. His fixation on Catherine dominated so completely that he hardly seems to be his own character but an extension of hers.’ There’s a latent expectation that perhaps Heathcliff would soften as even Vader did and Catherine would apologize as her husband Edgar expected her to, but neither of them ever do. Apologizing or expressing any remorse doesn’t even occur to them and they go to their graves unrepentant. There is no character growth and unlike Anakin, Heathcliff doesn’t have a discernable character arc. His “arc” is a stagnant line. It’s destruction and self-destruction until the end and only then, it’s not some moral or cosmic force that defeats him, but his own exhaustion that he succumbs to.</p><p><strong>If anything, entropy wins.</strong></p><p>The Skywalker Saga, for all of the violence and brutality the audience is subjected to on screen, communicated uplifting messages. People want suffering to have meaning and Lucas granted that through Anakin’s character. His arc says that anyone can be saved, that it’s never too late to do the right thing, and that love can alter the fate of the galaxy. What’s the underlying message in <em>Wuthering Heights? </em>A warning against toxic relationships? A community service announcement that Catherine and Heathcliff shouldn’t be emulated? A text can be read any number of ways but I don’t think Bronte was trying to instruct the audience as to what they should or should not do. I don’t think<em> Wuthering Heights</em> was meant to be used as a reference point for moral instruction or a manual on how to conduct romantic relations. Unless you run wild that way. No judgement. People have their fantasies and should be allowed to indulge them through fiction. All she did was put this <em>thing</em> on paper and let the audience sit with it and do with it as they will. When it made its first debut, the reception wasn’t overwhelmingly positive. The novel was critiqued for being savage and pagan. Readers disliked the lack of redemption for any of the characters, thought the novel was coarse and brutal, Heathcliff’s gravedigging was met with disgust and allegations of desecration and violation, and it seems these feeling haven’t changed nearly two hundred years later. As for all of these pop psychology terms levied against Cathy and Heathcliff such as narcissist, sociopath, psychopath, I’d wager if Nelly had access to these terms, she would use them as well.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*TdTNdZK_hH82jacR.gif" /></figure><p>Anakin’s fall was spoken of as something that <em>happened</em> to him. An external force corrupted him. Obi-wan told Luke that Anakin was <em>seduced</em> by the Dark Side and his younger counterpart told Padme that he had turned but he had been <em>deceived</em>. Passive voice. Anakin was responsible for his actions just as much as Heathcliff was but the Star Wars narrative recognizes that Anakin’s choices were made under less than ideal circumstances and that his mental state while making said decisions was severely compromised. Heathcliff never had that luxury. He had no split self, master manipulator, or emotionally constipated council of elders people can pile the blame on. Even the one who loved him best spared him no mercy in telling Isabella and audiences exactly who he was: “a fierce, pitiless, wolfish man” who would destroy without mercy the ones he despised. Catherine had no illusions about Heathcliff and vice versa, but neither did they ever attempt to change the other and so it’s taken as a given that this is just what they were. Anakin made poor decisions that destroyed his life and what could have been a bright future while Heathcliff, according to certain circles, had a brain disorder.</p><p>Did anyone ever sit Heathcliff down as a child and speak to him of his future? Even Catherine had one as the future wife and lady of the Grange and so did Hindley as the heir of the Heights. Heathcliff was never set up to have a future at all outside of indefinite servitude, assuming Hindley didn’t drive him out down the line, and Catherine wanted to keep him around the Heights using Edgar’s money to do so. If things hadn’t blown out of proportion after Heathcliff’s shenanigans with Isabella at the Grange, they may very well have just bugged each other for the remainder of their days with a very annoyed Edgar in between and Catherine would have seen absolutely nothing wrong with that. What fun. A tale of vengeance and intergenerational trauma could very well have ended up as something more of a high school drama complete with two adults squabbling like teens over relationship issues. His vengeance towards Hindley was personal and non-negotiable, but shit only really hit the fan after Catherine died. But Bronte could have easily written a dark humor play instead of what she did end up writing: there is a senseless, futile banality to the cruelty that ensued in the eighteen years that followed after her death. Cut away all the Gothic aesthetic and supernatural elements and <em>Wuthering Heights</em> is a grounded universe and so it’s more challenging for the audience to distance themselves from the violence and Heathcliff’s antics as it is with Star Wars and Vader. <em>Wuthering Heights</em> is a mirror in a way Star Wars is not and sometimes looking into a mirror isn’t a pleasant experience.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/772/0*YKbmYpgUXq2tZEXE.png" /></figure><p>There’s a grandiosity built into Anakin’s character and his life that made it the stuff of legend and accordingly, there is a level of narrative justification behind his violence: people can be big picture and reason that, at the end of the day, he fulfilled his destiny and put an end to a great evil, and so some good came out of all of that chaos and destruction. It’s a narrative comfort the world of <em>Wuthering Heights</em> denies the reader for what good came of Heathcliff’s vengeance? An entire generation dead before the age of forty and two children left to rebuild. It’s the peak of irony that he was the one who brought Catherine Jr. and Hareton together and united the two families he had been trying to destroy. Star Wars is a franchise that is a beacon of hope: the Skywalker Saga concludes with good defeating evil and a love between a father and a son saving the galaxy. In <em>Wuthering Heights</em>, there’s a distinct lack of any kind of cosmic or divine presence and the dearth of inherent meaning can feel nihilistic and who wants to root for doom and gloom? There is little to no narrative comfort and in the midst of such bleakness, people assert that Catherine Jr. and Hareton are the happy, redemptive ending. It says volumes that a return to normalcy and an end to destruction is considered a happy ending.</p><p>Anakin’s violence can be rationalized as being motivated by rage, fear, and overwhelming grief and his misdeeds committed during moments of passion and impulse. Vader’s twenty year rampage is beyond the fold but again, he was redeemed in the eyes of the Force, the closest thing the world of Star Wars has to a divine presence. You can dispute whether or not Anakin <em>deserved </em>to be redeemed, but that final verdict stands. Anakin’s motives were personal and more immediately sympathetic while Heathcliff’s vengeance was systematic and methodical to an an unreal degree and more symbolic than personal. He didn’t hate the Lintons as people but for what they represented: the world that separated him from Catherine, which is more difficult of a motive to understand and therefore sympathize with. Heathcliff’s humanity was constantly in question in a way Vader’s was not. Darth Vader isn’t just the righthand of the Emperor and the enforcer of the evil Empire! He was Anakin Skywalker, a once great Jedi and brother to Obi-wan, he was the father of Luke and Leia saviors of the galaxy and husband to Padme! These are roles a person typically occupies in life: husband, father, comrade, and Anakin embraced them in a way Heathcliff did not. He has that human backbone that grounds his character. Isabella asked if Heathcliff was a man or a devil and the answer to that is up to interpretation. What <em>is </em>Heathcliff? He can be seen as anything from an abusive man consumed by hatred and obsession, a pagan, revenant-like figure who feared neither God nor man, the blackest of villains, a tragic tormented anti-hero, and everything and more! He was legally a father and a husband but hardly either!</p><p>As for Heathcliff bringing the moral architecture of the novel to ruin: what morals? Anakin had morals. He was a bit shaky but he had them. Heathcliff never operated from the basis of morality. He didn’t disregard them the way Anakin did: they were never in his mind to begin with. There was one moment as a kid when he told Nelly he wanted to be good and Hindley ruined it by interrupting and tossing him into the attic. Heathcliff weaponized marriage and inheritance law but Victorian law is hardly the bulwark of morality and the Lintons are genteel, not good. Anakin cared about whether what he was doing was right or wrong: all Heathcliff cared about was Catherine. That is <em>his </em>equivalent of a moral compass and it’s why I struggle to classify him and Catherine as villains because they reside in an elemental world of Gothic indifference that doesn’t care about such things while Anakin lives in one that revolves around a moral binary: good versus evil, Light versus Dark, the Jedi versus the Sith. Heathcliff’s “redemption” wasn’t in Heaven with the good Christians, but to be forever bound to the earth with his other half! Catherine and Heathcliff were written to be forces of nature and they were just about as moral as the moors. Anakin’s love for Luke was a redeeming love but the one Heathcliff had with Catherine was anything but: to be redeemed is to change and his behavior throughout the novel demonstrates that change is one thing he cannot stand! What a pleasant man, isn’t he? No brakes that would normally hold a human being back, no conscience to speak of, and a bond that lacks relational structure.</p><p>And is it just me or do audiences seem to have an easier time accepting Anakin’s atrocities than Heathcliff’s gravedigging?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qIcSscrAEz9CAQ6g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Again, the framing. There is an uncomfortable intimacy to a man describing for the entirety of a chapter how he had been hallucinating his dead beloved day and night for the last eighteen years, dreamed of being deceased and decomposed with her, and how much he looked forward to being the first to do so before her husband does because he bribed a guy to allow him to break one side of her coffin loose and asked for his to be slid out when he was buried so that their remains can mingle and become one substance versus a masked behemoth slaughtering faceless masses as a result of a prophecy gone wrong. Darth Vader may have been a mass murderer but you won’t catch him skulking around his wife’s tomb trying to take a peek the way Heathcliff did. Eighteen years after the fact. While expecting the body to have been decomposed and being pleasantly surprised that it wasn’t. One scenario is touching, just a man wanting to visit his wife’s tomb. The other is layers of fuckery to try to analyze and understand because at first glance, it <em>does</em> come off as necrophilia or having necrophilic undertones. I have read over the scenes and see many things and necrophilia isn’t one of them. It’s more sad than scandalous: a man who never developed an identity outside of this one woman. (At the very least, it is definitely TMI! I would rather listen to Palpatine giggle about his evil plans than to Heathcliff trauma dumping this onto Nelly.) Vader abided by the norms of the grieving process in that he eventually let go of Padme while Heathcliff’s grief remained frozen at the moment of Catherine’s death and he seems to have worsened over time. When Heathcliff is humanized it is done so in a raw, invasive way and when Vader is, it is done so in a cinematic, safe manner.</p><p>And finally, Anakin loved his son. Heathcliff did not and took a massive dump on the concept of parenthood in a way even Vader did not (and Catherine did too to a lesser degree), and this fact alone will forever cement the former as the better man, no matter how many people he slaughtered.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d1d08346a6ee" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why are Anakin and Padme seen as a love story when Catherine and Heathcliff are seen as anything…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ashley.tien/why-are-anakin-and-padme-seen-as-a-love-story-when-catherine-and-heathcliff-are-seen-as-anything-8ff8fce0cb6a?source=rss-1edd7467fe0e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8ff8fce0cb6a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[star-wars]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pirates-of-the-caribbean]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wuthering-heights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-analysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ashley Tien]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Jun 2026 22:55:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-01T22:55:02.536Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Why are Anakin and Padme seen as a love story when Catherine and Heathcliff are seen as anything but one?</h3><h3>A discussion of the importance of narrative framing in shaping audience perception, the infamous gravedigging scenes, and the differences between romantic love and identity collapse</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*F5sG11j0ZKZrZc7c.png" /></figure><p>I popped my <em>Wuthering Heights</em> cherry via the 1939 film starring Laurence Olivier and Merle Oberon and while I did enjoy the film, I saw it as another run-of-the-mill tragic romance and soon forgot about it. I purchased the novel years ago, but it sat on my shelf unread because I never found the premise of <em>Wuthering Heights</em> to be particularly compelling. When I saw the trailer for Fennel’s film appear in my Youtube recommendations, I also didn’t think much of it until I started scrolling down the comments section, and to say that I was shocked is an understatement. Emerald Fennel was absolutely ripped for calling <em>Wuthering Heights</em> a romantic love story, let alone the greatest one of all time. One commentator responded with humor and approval from the rest that it was, in fact, the greatest <em>abuse</em> story ever told. Others considered the novel to be a tale of vengeance and trauma, not love, and one that depicted the horrors of a toxic, destructive obsession and nothing more than a cautionary tale about an unhinged, necrophilic brute’s inability to let go of an equally unlikeable, narcissistic woman. I was intrigued and gave the novel a read and while my perception of the story definitely changed, I seem to have reached a completely different conclusion from everyone who watched the trailer and apparently most of the Internet.</p><p>Anakin Skywalker is widely regarded as a broken man and a tragic villain. It’s said that he was a boy who loved a girl so much that he destroyed the galaxy after she died to fill the void she left behind. Star Wars fans hope that he and Padme were reunited in Heaven and speak of the tragedy of them not being able to live a peaceful life together with their children. That ache is strong enough that, in recent years, fan videos have been made depicting their reunion and of Vader visiting her tomb long after her death. His arc is filled with what-if’s and what could have been. What if Anakin had not turned to the Dark Side? What if the Jedi actually helped him address and process his grief over losing his mother and his fear of loss instead of spewing abstract aphorisms about letting go? What if Qui-gon Jinn had survived that duel with Maul and been the father figure that Anakin needed to counter Palpatine’s manipulation? Darth Vader was only a shadow of what Anakin could have been. What if he had lived up to that extraordinary Force Potential that he was born with? He could have been a god instead of Palpatine’s servant. And the list goes on. The common thread is folks want him to have been saved. Anakin is regarded as a disaster that could have been averted if only fate had been kinder and his romance with Padme is likened to a Greek or Shakespearean tragedy of galactic proportions. The Prequels have been praised for depicting one of the most compelling character arcs in cinema and Vader’s redemption through his son, Luke evokes great emotion from audiences to this day.</p><p>As for Heathcliff, <em>oh boy</em>. I have seen Heathcliff called everything from a gravedigging weirdo to the Devil incarnate. The Internet labels him about as much or even more than the characters in the novel did. It swings wildly from absolute hatred and revulsion to fascination and staunch sympathy, and seemingly nothing in between. I feel alone in bemoaning what a waste he was because Heathcliff <em>is</em> probably one of the biggest wastes I have encountered. His intelligence is underrated and not discussed enough. The odds were stacked against him. He had no family name, wealth, was deprived of an education, and resided in a very rigid, hierarchical society with no real prospects of a future. The only things he had were maleness, his youth, health, and a rage-filled tenacity.</p><p>By the time he was forty years old, he not only acquired great wealth but <em>two</em> ancient properties in a society where landownership was everything. No outsider looking at adult Heathcliff would have thought he was once this powerless boy who was relentlessly bullied and beaten. He was gifted and as much a prodigy as Anakin was, albeit in a different manner. But instead of using said gifts to build himself up, he used it to relive childhood injuries. <em>Wuthering Heights</em> is watching one very capable man destroy himself and everything around him in slow-motion until he burned out and died. It’s a pity. His ghostly union with Catherine was what he wanted and it’s romantic in a literary sense with the whole undying love spiel, but it’s yet another symptom of a man who never developed an identity of his own. He was worse off than Catherine was in this regard because she, for however brief a time, had a life and identity outside of him.</p><p>There is so much pathology in discussions about Heathcliff that conversations about the character often turn into a debate about DSM-5 standards than about the character himself. I can write several essays dissecting each and every label I have seen trying to define the true nature of the relationship between Catherine and Heathcliff. Most of the labeling is on him and they range from him apparently possessing Smeagol-levels of obsession to pure lust for Catherine’s body to everything in between. I think even Emily Brontë would have been confused had she lived to see the way her iconic character is perceived. I was completely baffled and at a loss for words at the disparity in the reception between the two men because Anakin’s crimes are objectively worse than Heathcliff’s. If I state that <em>Wuthering Heights</em> is a love story, I am bombarded with lists of every single one of Heathcliff’s cruel and abusive behaviors as retorts. And that is what happened when I obliviously commented under the trailer that this is what <em>Wuthering Heights</em> is: nothing more than a tragic love gone wrong. If we play this game of who has the shittiest behavior, I’m more than happy to partake because Darth Vader will leave <em>Wuthering Heights</em> readers speechless and the vengeance of the average anime protagonist will give everyone aneurysms.</p><p>Heathcliff’s violence culminates in animal cruelty, years of domestic violence, the systematic abuse of children, and the attempted destruction of two generations of families, while Vader’s<em> begins</em> with the murder of children, the annihilation of the entire Jedi Order, and him choking his eight-months pregnant wife in a fit of delusional rage. He goes on a state-sanctioned murder spree after his wife dies and the number of bodies this man left in his wake is ridiculous. And it’s not reserved to Anakin, either. There are a multitude of fictional characters whose scale of cruelty far outstrips Heathcliff’s but he is absolutely flambayed while the others are much beloved, and their respective love stories are not questioned to the same degree as his.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*MoO0bh4wgPVwvz7T.jpeg" /></figure><p>In the<em> Pirates of the Caribbean</em> franchise, the love story between Davy Jones and the sea goddess Calypso didn’t receive <em>nearly</em> as much screen-time compared to Will and Elizabeth Turner’s romance, but its impact was significant enough on the audience that years later, people want a prequel to see how and when they fell in love. If we were to conduct a moral evaluation of them and the love they shared, I think it’s safe to say they would fail abysmally. Davy Jones drowned countless number of sailors with the Kraken and had countless others either imprisoned with him on that cursed ship of his or their throats cut and bodies dumped overboard if they didn’t sign over their souls to him. His monstrous behavior is explained as a heartbroken man turned cruel after Calypso betrayed him and that his cruelty was directly proportionate with the degree of his love and heartbreak. Lord help me if I tried to inject this as an explanation for Heathcliff’s abusive behavior, that this was all a maladaptive coping mechanism from losing Catherine. Before anyone accuses me of whataboutism, if all of these characters were equally roasted, then I can live in peace. However, while the others are treated as tragic loves gone wrong, Heathcliff’s love for Catherine is treated as an abomination and he is piled on<em> </em>and demonized in a way these other characters are not.</p><p>And so I was left with a very interesting question and puzzle to solve: why is Heathcliff and his love for Catherine singled out? When couples cosplay as Anakin and Padme or have Star Wars-themed weddings with “Across the Stars” playing in the background, no one has anything to say to that but when couples incorporate quotes from <em>Wuthering Heights </em>into their vows, why does that attract comments about how crazy that is? Why is it so that the world of <em>Wuthering Heights</em> is considered particularly cruel and nihilistic when there are other franchises, including the Star Wars franchise, that showcase violence and brutality on a scale far greater than what is showcased in this novel? Why is a mass murderer and galactic genocidaire’s love for his son and wife treated as more legitimate than the love a domestic abuser had for a woman?</p><p>Why is trying to explain Wuthering Heights as a love story often treated as heretically as someone trying to convince Richard Dawkins that Jesus had come down to earth and invites mockery? When I state that Wuthering Heights is a romance, why does that almost without fail generate an online debate with profound irritation and even anger, when it <em>is</em> a Gothic Romance, the same way <em>Jane Eyre</em> and <em>Rebecca</em> by Daphne du Maurier are Gothic Romances? Why is it so when I say Anakin Skywalker is by far my favorite character in Star Wars, no one accuses me of liking child murderers, but when I say that Heathcliff is the most compelling character I have ever seen, that the love he had with Catherine stirs me in a way no other romance does, and that I do consider Wuthering Heights one of, if not <em>the</em>, greatest love story of all time, I am told that I lack reading comprehension skills, am glorifying toxicity, and that I am fond of or deserve abusive men? It comes down to narrative framing, likeability of the characters, and the legibility of their respective romances.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Vac-9c6eTkSKSKqA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Star Wars is primarily a visual medium and began as one. There is no unreliable narration to navigate; events unfold directly before the audience, unmediated and unfiltered. In the Original Trilogy, viewers were captivated by Darth Vader and naturally wondered how a great Jedi could become the embodiment of evil. The Prequels answer that question in full. We witness Anakin’s rise and his fall from grace firsthand. His story is framed sympathetically as that of a fallen hero. He was a good man who succumbed to darkness but ultimately found his way back to the Light. The films give him a fully realized backstory: a gentle mother, a charismatic and quippy mentor, a compassionate lover, and a redeeming love for his child. We see Anakin’s emotions laid bare and gain direct access to his inner conflicts, his trauma, and the moral struggles that shape his destiny.</p><p>We don’t read about his trauma filtered through the eyes of another, but see it unfolding on screen and the pain and tumult written on his face. We hear his mother and Qui-gon Jinn praise him for being a kind, compassionate child who only wanted to do good for others without asking for anything in return. He was well-liked and adored by his friends, and Anakin was a talented kid with a natural affinity for the Force and was overall set up to be someone with a future and not just any future. He was the prophesized savior of the galaxy and born of the cosmic Force. This boy was Space Jesus and blessed with extraordinary gifts and potential. We can understand why he ultimately went down the dark path because it was to save the ones he loved from dying. He is the embodiment of the road to Hell is paved with good intentions. Though the galaxy saw Darth Vader as a monster, the audience sees him the same way Padme and Luke did: a good man who lost his way and this unwavering faith in his goodness saved him.</p><p><em>Wuthering Heights</em> is filtered through two layers of narration. We have Lockwood, the perpetually befuddled outsider who never understood the emotional physics of the world he inadvertently stepped into. He thought Heathcliff was one of those traditional brooding Byronic heroes, the Mr. Rochester-type with a chip on the shoulder, that he can relate to. He couldn’t have ever imagined that this man he deemed to be “a capital fellow” to be the same man whose life goal was to decompose with his love into a single substance to achieve his version of union, and that he had said love unearthed twice. Then we have Nelly Dean as the primary narrator and she is not exactly reliable either. We are not told what actually happened but what she <em>remembered </em>happened and the information that she was<em> willing</em> to disclose to Lockwood eighteen years after the story began. Instead of a straightforward chronology, we get a patchwork quilt of incomplete insight and the story begins chronologically from the penultimate chapters. We get no POV chapters from either Cathy or Heathcliff and because their story is relayed to us by people who never fully understood or liked them, there is an ambiguity baked into the text that leaves questions hanging and so the debate will never end.</p><p>Catherine Sr. did not fit societal standards of how a woman of her class should behave. She was wild, spirited, and defiant from childhood. The Lintons gave her polish but never could obliterate her untamed half and all of that definitely colored the way Nelly perceived her versus her daughter Cathy Linton Jr., who Nelly overtly liked and went out of her way to actually help instead of sitting on the sidelines judging as she did for her late mistress. As for Heathcliff, from his very first appearance, he was ostracized and treated as an other and the labeling continued until his death. He was no Chosen One or child of prophecy with this grand destiny awaiting him, but a nobody from nowhere who was never completely understood by anyone in life, including the one who loved him best.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/380/0*qKopLHt4cjQQb_zC.jpeg" /></figure><p>From the beginning, he was treated as an invader and a contaminant and even Mr. Earnshaw wasn’t guiltless of perpetuating this perception. Prejudice doesn’t require intentionality to have impact, and in this novel, passivity can do as much harm as outright violence. Mr. Earnshaw wasn’t cruel or sadistic, but he was as careless as he was clueless. He was not oblivious to the child’s race, stating that “it’s as dark almost as if it came from the devil,” and told Nelly to wash “it” and put “it” with the children, which is an unusual way to address a child you were planning to raise as a son, and he did nothing to address the open hostility the child was receiving already. Nelly tried to leave the child by the stairs during that first night, hoping that it would be gone by morning, and Mrs. Earnshaw turned a blind eye to Hindley’s bullying because she had no fondness for Heathcliff. She called him a “gypsy brat” and wanted “it” out, and the childhood chapters are chock-full of anti-Romani, ethnic, and racial slurs.</p><p>Even after Heathcliff becomes a wealthy adult and landowner, the racialized language surrounding him doesn’t disappear. Edgar still calls him a “gypsy ploughboy” when he returns to the Heights, and Lockwood, in the opening chapter, describes his landlord as a “dark‑skinned gypsy” who looks out of place in a northern English farmhouse. Joseph is standing <em>right there</em>: a servant, a local, a Yorkshireman, yet it is <em>Heathcliff </em>whom Lockwood perceives as incongruous. The question Lockwood is implicitly asking is: <em>Why does the owner of this very English farmhouse look like that? </em>Apart from Catherine, every member of the first generation comments on Heathcliff’s appearance. The novel never explicitly states his ethnicity, but the way he is compared to other characters makes his outsider status unmistakable. If Heathcliff had looked like child Anakin or Edgar with fair hair, light skin, blue eyes, he would have been perceived and treated differently. The text doesn’t need to spell out, “Heathcliff is of Romani or mixed descent.” The reactions of the characters do that work. His appearance marks him as foreign in a predominantly white rural English setting.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/200/0*Pi3j1fXRVGTqjLcG.jpeg" /></figure><p>Contrast this with Hareton. He had dark hair, dark eyes, and tanned skin from outdoor labor, yet no one ever called him a “gypsy” or used racialized language toward him. The insults he received were about ignorance and lack of education, flaws that the novel ultimately resolves. Hareton’s darkness is coded as <em>weathered</em>, not <em>foreign</em>. Lockwood described him as “embrowned,” or sun-darkened and not “dark” the way Heathcliff was. Heathcliff’s darkness is coded as <em>racial</em>, <em>outsider</em>, <em>other</em>. Heathcliff’s appearance is treated as a signifier of non‑Englishness, foreignness, and social contamination. Hareton’s is treated as a signifier of class and labor, something that can be corrected through education and refinement. Heathcliff’s “difference” is permanent; Hareton’s is circumstantial.</p><p>Heathcliff never belonged anywhere, and he was set up, not for greatness, but for failure. His belonging was not in a home or family but with Catherine. He lived in Wuthering Heights for the entirety of his life, but the place had no meaning for him without Cathy. The Heights to Heathcliff is akin to Crime Alley for Batman. Even as an old man, Bruce Wayne returned there to remember his parents but also because that was where Batman was born. Heathcliff could have lived at the Grange and made a mockery of the Lintons or bought property anywhere else with the amount of wealth he acquired, but he stubbornly refused to leave the Heights until he died. It was for vengeance, but fundamentally, it was to wait for Catherine to return to him. He tormented people but it was also to kill time as he awaited a return to the call he had put out eighteen years earlier. Heathcliff’s lack of origin is a critical reason he bonded to Cathy in the way that he did and why he couldn’t just “get over her,” because she <strong><em>was</em></strong> his origin point.</p><p>Nelly told Lockwood that Heathcliff was a cuckoo. Cuckoo birds are a species of parasitic bird infamous for infiltrating and taking over the nests of their hosts at the cost of the well-being and lives of the other chicks. Cuckoo birds are hated because they violate every concept of fairness that people have, even if they are behaving according to instinct, and Heathcliff was similarly despised. And how ironic that Heathcliff <em>did</em> eventually take Wuthering Heights away from its rightful heir and drained the life out of everyone around him. Hindley called him an “imp of Satan,” or a demonic entity, Nelly characterized teenage Heathcliff as “repulsive” and behaving as if he were “possessed of something diabolical,” and the Lintons deemed him a thief, vulgar, “worse than a brute,” wanted him locked away so that no one can see him, and for him to be separated from Catherine, the only person who was keeping him intact.</p><p>All of these labels became a self-fulfilling prophecy. If people you are surrounded with insist that you are a sub-human, that you are monstrous, unwanted filth, that there is something innately lacking and defective about you, and treat you accordingly with suspicion and revulsion, what a surprise when you become what they feared. The tragedy of Anakin’s character is that he was never able to reach his true potential and that he had lost his way from the good man that he was. Heathcliff’s is that he became what the people around him told him he already was.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/825/0*RQO88uk7DLfzw3dp.jpeg" /></figure><p>This is not only with Heathcliff but with other characters from other franchises, like Eren Yeager from <em>Attack on Titan</em>. Eren was a young man who was also considered by the world at large to be a sub-human because he claimed descent from the Eldian people. The Eldians were called beasts in human skin because of their ability to transform into Titans, were called devils and demons, and were considered contaminated. Eren and all those who had discernable Eldian heritage were judged for atrocities their ancestors committed thousands of years before they were born, atrocities recorded in texts by the very nation that had no problems using their abilities for their own military ambitions, propagated anti-Eldian propaganda to justify their own cruelty and oppression of others, often used unwilling Eldians as cannon fodder and their children as child soldiers, and wanted the entire population eliminated once they had no more use for them.</p><p>When Eren was a child, the world came to destroy his homeland. They killed his mother, and he grew up determined to take revenge on those responsible. By the time he reached adulthood and gained immense power, his rage had expanded beyond the individuals who carried out that first attack. He turned it against the entire world that had oppressed, demonized, and attempted to exterminate his people. Like Heathcliff, Eren internalized the hatred projected onto him, became the embodiment of it, and hurled it back at the world that created him. The Eldians were feared and derided as monsters and while that fear is understandable, given that most Titans are indeed giant, man‑eating humanoid creatures, the world’s response was catastrophically shortsighted. If you believe a group possesses an awe‑inspiring power capable of destroying the entire world, then attacking them, cornering them, and forcing them into life-or-death situations is not exactly a brilliant strategy. Why would you attack an island of demons and devils in the first place?! Stop poking the sleeping bear and leave it alone! The last Eldian King took refuge on that island they eventually attacked and before sealing himself off, warned the world that any provocation would incite the Rumbling, or the end of the world, and they decided to attack anyway. Eren was called the “Devil of Paradis” but the world also woke the Devil up.</p><p>Eren and Heathcliff were destructive but I don’t view them through the lens of good or evil but as consequences and products of the world that shaped them. In response to that, I often hear things like “I was abused and didn’t turn out like that,” “These other characters suffered too and they didn’t turn destructive,” or “he has no excuse for what he did, trauma or not.” This is not about excusing, but understanding. Different people react differently to the same traumatic circumstances. There is no one universal reaction to trauma. With polarizing characters like Heathcliff, I see a recurring pattern: people assume that those who channel their trauma into something good are simply better people than those who collapse into destruction. Audiences want to believe that suffering naturally creates empathy and that they themselves are safe from ever becoming what characters like Anakin, Heathcliff, or Eren became. Because if the Heathcliff’s of the world are inherently defective and if it all comes down to simply making “better choices,” then there’s no need to engage with the conditions that shaped them. Why did Heathcliff do terrible things? Because he was just a bad person. Because he was a monster. That explanation is comforting, but it avoids the harder question of how someone becomes that way in the first place.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*N-EfhdB_ybQa2RAV.png" /></figure><p>Anakin’s fall to the Dark Side was a consequence of the Jedi’s arrogance and blindness. Anakin was a fallen messiah and it is said that the Jedi had possession of the savior but essentially handed him over to the Devil. As with Anakin’s fall and consequent murderous behavior, Heathcliff’s violence didn’t come out of nowhere. Over the years, the reasons behind Anakin’s fall have been broken down and there is a level of sympathy and understanding for him that I don’t see for Heathcliff. His abusive behavior is the first thing people mention but it’s often out of context. He didn’t wake up one morning and decide to be an asshole! You cannot brutalize someone in this manner and not expect consequences. He was the embodiment of you reap what you sow. He was treated like a disease, and so he came back as the plague. He was called a thief by the Lintons and what irony was it that he came back and took everything they loved, their property, and their children, <em>legally</em>. Hindley beat him and tried to have him run over by a horse so Heathcliff came back, not with a gun, but with the law itself as his weapon. He was dehumanized, subjected to both class and race-based humiliation, and wasn’t treated as someone with a mind and feelings of his own, and so he viewed and treated everyone around him apart from Catherine as objects.</p><p>Heathcliff was a sullen, quiet child who didn’t exhibit the same outwardly compassionate and friendly behaviors Anakin did, and grew into a rather grumpy teenager who no one in that household liked. Nelly compared him to Edgar and noted how fresh and appealing the latter was compared to the former, but what kind of a comparison is that? Edgar’s upbringing was one of privilege and comfort, with a sister that he loved and who loved him back, and he had both parents who were protective and loving. Even Nelly admitted that the way Hindley treated Heathcliff was enough to turn a saint into a fiend! After Mr. Earnshaw died, nobody really cared about him except for Catherine. When she was away at the Lintons recovering from that injury to her ankle and was pampered like a lady, Heathcliff was neglected by everyone except for Nelly, who called him dirty and bade him wash himself.</p><p>Heathcliff was very sensitive to being called dirty. While he was indeed dirty from weeks of hard labor outdoors while Cathy was gone, given the context in which this novel took place and the Victorian preoccupation with “good breeding” and purity, “dirty” referred to more than physical uncleanliness but was a not-so-subtle coding of social, racial, and moral contamination. And so who cared about the “dirty” stable-boy? Catherine was the only one who was distressed when he ran off, and the only one happy to see him when he returned. And nobody ever said that any of this name-calling, racialization, and class elitism was wrong: Nelly, you dropped the ball here! The only time she pushed back on any of this was when Cathy Jr. laughed at Hareton because he couldn’t read, but with anyone associated with Heathcliff, she is dead silent and often participates. She thought it would be better off if Catherine Sr. and Linton died because they were a burden on those around them. She inhabited a cruel, indifferent world and some of that cruelty rubbed off on her, coloring her perception and narration. She is selective about who she empathizes with and sees as good. And because Catherine and Heathcliff were indeed destructive, it is less likely that anyone will question the way she frames them, their actions, and her re-telling of the events that transpired.</p><p>“<strong>But he was too good to be thoroughly unhappy long. <em>He</em> didn’t pray for Catherine’s soul to haunt him.</strong> Time brought resignation, and a melancholy sweeter than common joy. He recalled her memory with ardent, tender love, and hopeful aspiring to the better world; where he doubted not she was gone.”</p><p>“<strong>Linton, on the contrary, displayed the true courage of a loyal and faithful soul: he trusted God; and God comforted him. </strong>One hoped, and the other despaired: they chose their own lots, and were righteously doomed to endure them. <strong>But you’ll not want to hear my moralising, Mr. Lockwood; you’ll judge, as well as I can, all these things: at least, you’ll think you will, and that’s the same.”</strong></p><p>And Nelly did that a lot. She compared Heathcliff against Edgar throughout the novel in every way from their bearing, personality, appearance, and the way they responded to Catherine’s death. She gave a clear opinion as to whose grief was the proper and touching one. She spent paragraphs in the chapter immediately following Cathy’s death describing Edgar and his inward strength, grace, and faith in God. She doesn’t provide any context or understanding as to why Heathcliff and Hindley responded to the losses of the women they cared about so differently from Edgar, as if the differences were simply due to defective character or a lack of faith, and not trauma and developmental arrest. And yes, I do think Hindley was also a victim of poor parenting, even if he himself was an abuser. The same thing happened during Catherine’s illness. Nelly attributed it to nerves and a case of her being overdramatic instead of her legitimately having a breakdown and an identity rupture from trying to live as a split self. And Nelly either displayed some self-awareness or this was Brontë herself acknowledging the narrative skewing as Nelly admitted to Lockwood that she was indeed moralizing, but to cut her some slack because Edgar is a good guy. And this is <em>before</em> Heathcliff went full force with his vengeance schemes. A narrator does not need to outright lie to shape audience perception.</p><p>None of this is to say that Nelly and Lockwood were wrong or lying about literally <em>everything</em>. With regards to Nelly, I think she was correct about basic factual information such as the ages of the children, their physical appearances, the chronological sequence of events, and observations about the landscape It’s when she begins to give her evaluation of their characters and the way the events unfolded and how involved or not involved she was with the drama, that I would take what she says with a grain of salt. Some of the adaptations downplay her role or age her up as they did in the 1939 adaptation. In there, she is more of a mother figure to Catherine and Heathcliff while in the novel she pretty much grew up besides them, even if not with them, and that changes the way the events are retold to the audience. 1939’s Nelly was a lot more sympathetic to and understanding of Catherine and Heathcliff than the lady in the novel and she recounted the story without injecting her own critical opinions about everyone and everything. The narration in the novel is a labyrinth to get through, which is one reason among many why I think Jane Eyre is more popular overall as it has a straightforward, chronological narration.</p><p>And so in <em>Wuthering Heights</em>, there are two things I have to hold in mind:</p><ul><li>Catherine and Heathcliff weren’t pleasant people and were indeed destructive.</li><li>Nelly might not have presented their characters and the way in which the events of the story unfolded accurately. This may have been intentional on her part to soften her own role in the drama or unintentionally due to latent biases that she wasn’t overtly aware of. There may very well have been information she tacked on and/or omitted entirely!</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/630/0*kqUuTNYWRTBwxbp8.jpeg" /></figure><p>Nelly isn’t bad, nor would I consider her an evil villainess: she is limited. She was never valued for her own person but for what she can do for her bosses and was deeply entrenched in the class hierarchy and violence of her world. She had to keep her head down to survive and did not have the power to question her station in life because she was at the mercy of her employers. Like Heathcliff, she was a child living in a feral household, and instead of dreams or a future, she was given a role and expected to occupy it for life without complaint. She was also manhandled by nearly everybody in the novel and unlike Heathcliff, didn’t have the power nor the wealth to retaliate. And so understandably, she probably would not have been inclined to put in a good word for the people who slapped her around. The Lintons might have had a bad case of class prejudice but at least they didn’t openly bully her as the Earnshaw children did and so by comparison, of course she would regard Catherine Linton Jr. as her “sweet mistress” and Catherine Sr. as the brat. Nelly despised Catherine Sr. and some of that resentment was probably class-based, as Cathy was able to manhandle Nelly with impunity <em>because</em> she was her mistress.</p><p>They were both women stuck in societal roles, but while Nelly was able to acclimate, survive, and live “properly,” Cathy Sr. imploded and what a coincidence that every person Nelly approves of are those who are able to inhabit the status quo because she is an extension and product of it! It’s unfortunate these characters were unable to look past their pre-existing worldviews and see that they actually shared commonalities. It’s not only with Catherine and Nelly but with Heathcliff and Hindley. The two men were narrative mirrors of the other. Heathcliff <em>is </em>Hindley, albeit the more disciplined and systemically violent version of him, and a tragic example of trauma and abuse perpetuating itself. Catherine Jr. and Hareton were able to break from this cycle, but they still remain within the system that contributed to the destruction of the first generation, and it’s one reason among many that I do not view them as true redemption or a traditional happy ending either.</p><p>Given the environment she grew up in, it makes sense that Nelly saw everything through the lens of social propriety and religious moralization because that was all she knew how to do. Racialization and class elitism were normal in their society and so the Lintons were considered genteel, “quality” folks, however abysmal their personal views were. And because their prejudices were attitudinal, they seemed human enough, had manners, and were physically non-violent (save for that one time Edgar assaulted Heathcliff at the Grange), Nelly and a good portion of the audience view them as “good.” It also doesn’t help that Heathcliff was terrible to his only child while Edgar doted on his and so besides Heathcliff, Edgar appears as an angel.</p><p>Even Darth fucking Vader loved his own child and Heathcliff couldn’t manage to muster up enough humanity to leave his alone and that is one reason I think Anakin, however grievous his crimes were, is perceived as the better man than Heathcliff was because that is narrative comfort. Darth Vader is a monster but at least he loved his son. At least he wanted to be redeemed and changed for the better at the eleventh hour and came in clutch to save his baby boy who was actively being fried by a genocidal raisin and gave his life to do so, an act that saved the galaxy from evil. Heathcliff had<em> none </em>of those redeeming factors, only this weird attachment to Catherine that doesn’t look like a relationship at all. There are a multitude of mass murdering characters and Heathcliff is perceived as worse than they are, and I find that fascinating. One common thread I have discovered in many of those stories, is that the narrative is either neutral or on their side, and there is narrative comfort for the audience to rest on. The character might be godawful but he has something human that they can latch onto.</p><p>A good villain needs good PR and Heathcliff had terrible PR. Who was on his side in the story from birth to death? Mr. Earnshaw snuffed it too soon and only heightened resentment of the boy, Catherine was split between Edgar and Heathcliff in life and so couldn’t back Heathcliff up fully, and a ghostly fragment knocking on the doors and clinging to people while bleeding, scares and freaks people out. If Anakin had a Nelly to narrate everything he did, I think his character would be in a different place. Imagine a narrator constantly moralizing Anakin and telling the audience about how wicked he is, and that he is some kind of inhuman creature and not a man at all! What a fiend, a ghoul, and a diabolical villain! instead of the narrative and key characters framing him as a young man who made a series of tragic decisions as a result of a very human desire to forever hold onto the one he loved. I never see anyone framing Heathcliff’s gravedigging as a manifestation of that same desire. He gets disgust, moral condemnation, and is called sick, demented, and insane, but Anakin mowing down masses of people who respected and trusted him because he believed he had to do it to save Padme from dying, is a tragedy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*XXotwmG_CGEWpBoY.jpeg" /></figure><p>I also think the plethora of adaptations over the years has created a sort of Mandela effect. There is more body contact between Catherine and Heathcliff in some of these adaptations than was present in the novel, and their dynamic is universally presented and marketed to audiences as that of a couple’s. The entire second half of the novel is often cut entirely, which considerably softens the perception of Heathcliff’s character. Curious audience members who go into the novel bareback after watching the films often experience whiplash when they see OG Heathcliff in all his glory because they go in expecting a romantic hero only to find something else entirely. The more metaphysical aspects of their bond are cut or fleshed out in a way they were not in the original source material. For one thing, we never actually see Catherine and Heathcliff’s haunting in the novel. It’s left ambiguous as to whether it was real or merely a rumor and a figment of Lockwood’s imagination, while in the films, we see their ghostly afterimages wandering around the moor, kissing, and holding hands.</p><p>We never see what they did out there on the moor as children because Nelly wasn’t there to witness it, and we only hear snippets from Catherine’s recollection of what she and Heathcliff were up to, but in the films, we see them talking, smiling, gathering heather, and even kissing. Heathcliff is probably one of the least sensual characters I have encountered; yet, he is ironically sexualized to a degree that would probably confuse even him, especially in Fennel’s recent “interpretation” of <em>Wuthering Heights</em>. I understand why he is sexualized because intense emotions are often read as physical desire and a steamy romance is easier to market to mainstream audiences than a metaphysical singularity, but it again frames him and Cathy as a dysfunctional romantic pairing when they are anything but. I also don’t think the adaptations capture how child-like their dynamic was, and because many age the characters up, they are perceived as adults in a relationship when they were emotionally and psychologically children who never differentiated. I would love to see a pair of actors fully capture that children in adult bodies phenomenon and freak the audience out a bit. And I think at least one adaptation implied that Heathcliff was Catherine’s half-brother: is that where this theory came from??</p><p>And when it comes to Catherine’s death, several adaptations depict Heathcliff holding, kissing, or even lying beside her body after unearthing her when there was no such depiction in the novel, which inflames the necrophilia allegations. I was morbidly curious to see how bad it got, but it was a virtual blank in the novel in the direct aftermath of Cathy’s death. The narrative zeroes in on the locket Catherine was wearing and in the Victorian era, wearing a loved one’s hair was considered an intimate act, and so that locket and the hair was doing a lot of heavy lifting. When Heathcliff replaced Edgar’s hair with his own, he was again inserting himself in a marriage he never truly recognized. While I do think what happened between them at the Grange can be read as adult eroticism, I think now that all that desperate clinging and kissing was childhood attachment being lived out in adult bodies, complete with hormonal development. It was no different from them holding each other as kids amidst a violent and feral household. Children cling to their caregivers for security and emotional regulation and Cathy and Heathcliff never developed past that phase.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/0*DZfTQNMEB0_pdxrv.jpeg" /></figure><p>As for necrophilia, what Heathcliff did was the Gothic equivalent of screaming into the void. Heathcliff did not project sexual fantasies onto her or her body. His bond with Catherine was not based upon bodily desire. In both instances of him unearthing her, there is no body contact as some of the adaptations or illustrations circling around the Internet might have shown. He never touched her either of those times. I think Brontë knew how these scenes would be taken even if she minimized physical contact between Cathy and Heathcliff, especially given how sensitive things were in Victorian England. She was playing right on the knife’s edge of things and likely anticipated readers would cross over. Cathy and especially Heathcliff provoke established lines of thinking. An obsessed man? Check. Dead bodies? Check. Digging up the grave of the one woman he spent his existence fixating on? Check. This must be necrophilia. It’s the same line of reasoning that haunts many analyses of Catherine and Heathcliff’s “relationship.” A very intense, destructive relationship between two adults complete with jealous and possessive behavior? This must be obsession.</p><p>If anyone still thinks Heathcliff is nuts, I will include examples of grief behaviors in a future installment from other franchises that would have made him feel right at home. If he were in the sci-fi genre with access to technology that could resurrect the dead and not a guy trapped in Victorian England, his gravedigging would not stand out nearly as much. He and Catherine were simply in the wrong genre, era, and species of being. There are stories with necromancy where gravedigging is taken as a given and it is about grief and the inability to let go of lost loved ones, not voyeurism and depravity. Death is the ultimate form of separation and humanity has struggled with this since antiquity. I have heard people in the midst of grief who couldn’t bear the idea of their loved one decomposing in the ground and they wanted to dig them up but of course they didn’t. Heathcliff actually acted upon these intrusive thoughts and had no qualms against disregarding taboos that would normally scare off most other people. Even Darth Vader never did anything like this with his own wife. He may have been a mass murderer and struggled with accepting Death’s finality for most of his adult life but he had a sense of boundaries while Heathcliff never did. You know a character is special when they are willing to do things that Darth Vader wouldn’t do.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/724/0*hwI6-xtx3_LjcQaq.jpeg" /></figure><p>Would he need psychological help if he were to do this in real life? Yes. But let me talk about the emotion and Gothic logic behind it please before the sensationalizing begins. These scenes have been sensationalized to the point where I feel I can’t discuss them without necrophilia allegations shutting the entire thing down. It’s easier to say “<em>ewwwww</em>” than engage with the psychology behind this behavior. For me, the gravedigging is the culmination of Heathcliff’s inability to tolerate separation and symptomatic of his complete lack of identity outside of her. Honestly, the <em>entire</em> novel and all the tragedy and drama is a direct result of Catherine and Heathcliff’s inability to live separately. Her friendship and marriage to the Lintons functioned as boundaries and for Heathcliff, who is completely boundary-blind, it was annihilation. And when dear hubby Edgar told Cathy “no” and put his foot down to her shenanigans with Heathcliff, she exploded and imploded because she was about as adept at handling a boundary as her other half was. And Heathcliff didn’t consider Catherine his equal but as his equivalence so if she died then he was as good as dead. It wasn’t Catherine that he was trying to unearth but himself. He wasn’t calling to his lover to haunt him but to the unfinished half of his identity and she came back for the same reason. This isn’t a Jack and Rose style afterlife with two lovers embracing but two halves of one organism coming to completion.</p><p>The lack of sex and body contact in the novel is often written off as Victorian prudishness and something that Brontë had to do to get her story past the censors; therefore, some assert that all that metaphysical language was a disguise for the intense sexual fixation Heathcliff had for Catherine. But there doesn’t need to be skin exposure or overtly amorous language to depict romantic desire. <em>Jane Eyre</em> is another novel set in Victorian England, and there is clear physical attraction between Jane and Rochester that I thought was notably absent between Cathy and Heathcliff. <em>Jane Eyre</em> depicts romantic love while <em>Wuthering Heights </em>showcases a quintessential example of identity fusion that is often equivocated with obsession. And if we restrict analyses to the novel alone, Catherine declared her love for both Edgar and Heathcliff to Nelly in that fateful chapter where Heathcliff ran off, and the difference in the way she spoke of either of them is striking. When she talked about why she loved Edgar, what she said would resemble what Anakin would say if he were asked why he loved Padme and vice versa. But when she spoke of her love for Heathcliff, the language and emotion conveyed a collapsed identity than what I could consider a typical declaration of love. The adaptations do tend to tighten or cut down some of Catherine’s confession, often emphasizing the “I <strong><em>am</em></strong> Heathcliff!” line, but I think<em> all</em> of it should be included to highlight the complete lack of boundaries in their bond.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*BsQ2D6wUd0tEGjbY.jpeg" /></figure><p>Anakin is fortunate as a character because while there are a multitude of comics, novels, and TV series that have spawned since the release of the Prequels, those six movies by Lucas stand on their own. It’s possible to ignore the sequels and everything produced by Disney that took place after Return of the Jedi without suffering from ill effect. Ownership of the franchise may change hands in the future, but his story likely won’t undergo the same continuous reimaginings by different directors because George Lucas, who created the character of Anakin and the entirety of <em>Star Wars</em>, directed and chose the actors who portrayed child and adult Anakin. This is <em>his</em> vision of the character. There is no ambiguity as everything from Anakin’s birth to death is fleshed out and so his backstory is completely grounded while there are big blank spaces in Heathcliff’s that will never be filled.</p><p>Apart from his vengeance and Catherine, what <em>do</em> we really know about Heathcliff anyway? The man has no personality outside of those two things and hardly seems like a person at all sometimes. There will be some semblance of narrative consistency with Anakin and <em>Star Wars</em>, while <em>Wuthering Heights</em> is a fight against layers of hostile narration and decades of interpretive takes. At least with <em>Star Wars,</em> the audience once had George Lucas to shed light on questions the audience may have about his intentions behind his work but we will never have that with Emily Bronte. I want to know who she would personally select to portray Catherine and Heathcliff, but given her reclusive nature and the ambiguity baked into the text, she may deign not to respond.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*ftmqUXMMWJBFP1-x.jpeg" /></figure><p>Obi-wan said that there was no hope in saving Vader and that he was evil, Yoda concurred, and they concluded that Luke must kill him. The rest of the galaxy and the Rebellion viewed him as a monster, and would probably have agreed that Vader had to die, but there was Luke, the hero, his son, a powerful warrior in tune with the Force, and a major face of the Rebellion, to push back against these views, and insist that his father can be saved. Obi-wan and Yoda represent the old Order of Jedi who failed and Luke the future, and if the embodiment of the future and the classic hero insists to the audience out of a good heart that his father can be saved, the audience will listen.</p><p>These aren’t just words and sentiments. Darth Vader believed that it was too late for him to be saved but his son’s faith in him combined with his pre-existing desire to be saved, were lightning in a bottle. The <em>Star Wars</em> narrative is built to allow for redemption, defiance of destiny, and systemic change, and so men like Darth Vader, who in real-life committed crimes that would render him irredeemable, get a second chance. Heathcliff had all of the intellectual tools to succeed in life, but he was doomed. Unlike Darth Vader, Heathcliff was never taught the difference between right and wrong, he never had any kind of moral compass, and never did he experience unconditional love which Vader had the privilege of experiencing at least twice in his life, from his mother Shmi and from his son Luke.</p><p>From the limited information we receive through Nelly, it seemed that Heathcliff and Mr. Earnshaw never really knew each other. He <em>petted</em> Heathcliff as one does a novelty or a puppy, but didn’t raise him as a son, adopted or otherwise. Their bond is more akin to imprinting or projection than parental love. At least Anakin experienced multiple forms of love and relationships. He had his mother, Shmi, his mentor and brother Obi-wan, his wife Padme, and his son, Luke. That ticks off a list of loves a human normally experiences: parental love, fraternal love, love for a mentor, and romantic love.</p><p>Heathcliff had imprinting and identity collapse.</p><p>Neither of these are relationships and they happened at a critical stage of childhood development and he was never provided any course correction. Catherine, Anakin, and Hindley were able to branch and experience some form of normal relationships with others as they had something Heathcliff did not in his early youth: socialization. Hindley was sent away college and it was there he found his wife, and Catherine had the Lintons. As for Edgar, he loved Catherine but his love for her was not unconditional. He once caught a glimpse of her violent temper when she slapped and pinched Nelly, shook Hareton, and gave him a sound blow to his ear. Edgar was repulsed, expressed his disillusionment with her, and was literally headed out the door. Catherine had to smooth things over and cry and play on his sympathies to convince him to forget about this lapse. It was Lady Linton Edgar loved, not Catherine Earnshaw the wild moor-child while it was the other way around for Heathcliff. It was Catherine Earnshaw Heathcliff called upon to haunt him, not Catherine Linton. He never recognized the Catherine Linton identity as legitimate because it was with Catherine Earnshaw he fused to as a child. He lacked an identity of his own and so Catherine Earnshaw became that identity.</p><p>The love Heathcliff had with Catherine was not a redeeming love and did not allow for growth or change. It’s a love that must reject change in order to survive. Their story was never that of an adult romance but a child’s love colliding with the real, adult world, and such a love can only exist out there on the moor or in Death. Catherine and Heathcliff’s love is hopeless because to hope is to recognize the possibility of a future and what they had was frozen in time. And I think Heathcliff recognized it to some extent in whatever remained of that psyche of his at the end when he looked at Cathy Jr. and Hareton falling in love. There would be healing and a future for them, but none for him. His life ended eighteen years ago when Catherine breathed her last and it was only vengeance that was holding the carcass up. That he expired so soon after claiming the Grange and the last of the first generation died is evidence to me that his vengeance was never about personal ambition but about keeping himself alive.</p><p>And audiences don’t like this stuff. They want an uplifting, hopeful story with heroes and good people and a moral love as can be found in <em>Jane Eyre</em> and <em>Star Wars</em>, not this bleakness. The love story between Anakin and Padme may have ended tragically, but there was hope through their children and none of that for Cathy and Heathcliff, whose bond was as sterile as it was destructive. But I honestly find the reception to <em>Wuthering Heights</em> ironic because in romance, the idea of an eternal, undying love is so elevated and yet, when I point out that there is such a love in this novel, the reaction is disgust. Their love is eternal but it is static and incapable of growth, the direct opposite of an ideal human love. Anakin and Padme are considered a dumpster fire of a relationship in certain circles, but at least they grew up. Their love was tragically cut short but it matured from a crush to an adult romance. Catherine and Heathcliff never grew up and their attachment remained frozen in childhood. The more I analyze Catherine and Heathcliff and pit them against other human couples, the more I have come to believe that while they may take on human shape, the nature of their bond is anything but human. But because they <em>are</em> physically humans, they are evaluated as such and so their behavior appears irrational and illegible in a way Anakin and Padme’s romance wasn’t. Anakin and Padme, like a multitude of couples, had relationship <em>issues</em>. Catherine and Heathcliff were never in a relationship to begin with.</p><p>They may ape at being a couple and resemble Anakin and Padme and a multitude of other human couples, but the nature of their attachment is more akin to the love Davy Jones and the heathen goddess Calypso shared. Davy Jones and Calypso are considered a tragic love story, and it’s not because because they are better than Catherine and Heathcliff, but because they are immortals, and so are granted a narrative immunity that the latter are not by virtue of them being humans. An immortal goddess like Calypso can kill people on a whim and elevate her relationship with the one she loves above all else, but if a human tries to do the same, then they are condemned for being entitled, egotistical, delusional, and narcissistic. If Cathy and Heathcliff had been demi-gods or immortals, their love would be considered an epic and their destructive behavior considered the whims of beings that exist beyond our understanding.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*p2vlddkjyNCTrzYY.jpeg" /></figure><p>Catherine and Heathcliff are constantly compared to Jane and Rochester, Darcy and Elizabeth, or even Cathy Jr. and Hareton, and the former are relentlessly condemned while the latter are elevated as ideal romances. But these loves exist on entirely different planes! It pits <strong>adult relational romances</strong> against a <strong>collapsed-identity bond</strong>. Their love is criticized for lacking boundaries, respect, growth, and healthy communication, and is deemed inferior to the love Darcy and Elizabeth share. But of course Catherine and Heathcliff have no boundaries, respect, or healthy communication! Those things require <em>separate selves</em> but Catherine and Heathcliff fused as children before their identities could form independently. They only ever had <strong>one self, split in two</strong>. You cannot communicate properly with someone who <em>is you</em> in another body.</p><p>Jane Eyre and Rochester, Darcy and Liz, Cathy Jr. and Hareton, and Anakin and Padme are couples. Each pairing consisted of two fully formed individuals who wished to achieve a lifelong union through marriage. Catherine and Heathcliff are not a couple nor were they fully-formed individuals. They were a <strong>single identity distributed against two bodies</strong> and they malfunctioned because they were never meant to exist in such a state. Even the most intimate of couples maintain some degree of separation and they had none. In marriage vows, they speak of becoming one heart, one flesh, and one soul, but that is <em>metaphorical</em>. A marriage is a partnership and however many people are bound in one, they all retain individuality.</p><p>Catherine and Heathcliff take the metaphor of “one heart, one flesh, one soul” with absolute literalness. What Heathcliff longs for is not partnership but <strong>oneness</strong>. A fused relationship is a psychological phenomenon, but when the time came, Heathcliff wanted that fusion to become literal. He bribed the sexton to ensure that his remains would physically dissolve into Catherine’s after death, a direct contrast to Edgar, who simply wished to be buried beside his wife. Catherine and Heathcliff never violated each other’s boundaries because <strong>no boundaries ever formed</strong>. What they shared was not intimacy but a complete mergence of identity. Their tragedy was never a lack of connection; it was <strong>too much connection</strong>, so total that it prevented communication. You cannot negotiate with someone who is not “other” to you. You cannot respect the boundaries of a person who occupies the same psychic space you do. Their bond was not relational: it was ontological and asymmetrical, and that is why it destroyed them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*5fazGRapwF0Z7Cq0.png" /></figure><p>There was no adult in the Earnshaw household to teach boundaries, respect, or emotional regulation. Retaliatory violence was the only available language apart from punitive religious moralizing and yet Cathy and Heathcliff were expected to function as normal adults in society and condemned by the narrative and by audiences when they couldn’t. The Lintons gave Cathy polish, pampering, and manners, but they were not her parents. Nelly was a child and wasn’t equipped to be anyone’s role model and was busy trying to keep the household running with all the violence and chaos that was going on. Many ask why Catherine and Heathcliff turned out the way that they did and settle for some kind of diagnosis as an explanation, but the explanation as to why they turned out the way they did is contained in those childhood chapters. There was nothing inherently wrong with any of the three children who grew up in the Earnshaw household. Catherine and Heathcliff did not have a brain disorder or malformation. They were a product of years of trauma and absentee parenting.</p><p>How old are children when they are still forming their own identities and learning that it’s not the end of the world if they’re separated from their primary caregiver(s)? That’s the developmental phase they were stuck at. Even Cersei Lannister, who <em>is</em> a narcissist, was in a better position than this! Cersei had a fragile, but fully formed <em>adult</em> ego! Cathy, and especially Heathcliff, never reached that stage! Anakin was clingy but at least he knew where he began and ended, unlike these two!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/375/0*DZDtGEivdaX3pbpl.jpeg" /></figure><p>Whenever there is a boy and a girl living together under one household in any work of fiction and the two develop what appears to be a romantic connection, there inevitably will be speculations about incestuous relations. However, I don’t think they were raised as siblings because that household had no structure at all and I didn’t see any actual raising done. Haphazard spoiling and smacking the children around when they disobey you or when you <em>think </em>they are disobeying you is not parenting, Mr. Earnshaw. When Heathcliff demanded that Hindley hand over his horse to him and threatened to tell Mr. Earnshaw on him for the brutal thrashings he had been giving him, Heathcliff said: I will tell <strong><em>your </em></strong>father, not <strong><em>my</em></strong> father or <strong><em>our</em></strong> father, but <strong><em>your </em></strong>father. Anakin’s mother was an enslaved woman but she was a better parent than Mr. Earnshaw ever was. Nelly was a child and Joseph was certainly no father figure and Cathy and Heathcliff’s bond reflected that lack of structure. It was a boundary-less, amorphous monstrosity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*rVo2TxChrRS19-CG.gif" /></figure><p>Anakin only had nine years with Shmi, but those nine years were foundational in forming his sense of self. He became dependent and possessive of Padme and probably did feel he would die without her but at least he knew where he began and ended. Heathcliff had <em>no</em> self outside of Catherine nor any conception of what a boundary was, hence all the intense destructive behavior when he perceived any threat to their bond because the stakes were high. It was not the loss of a relationship he feared but the container for his self-hood. Catherine didn’t hurt his feelings when she started spending more time with the Lintons and ultimately decided to marry Edgar. In his eyes, she effectively exiled him from himself and that was unforgivable. Through the lens of a collapsed identity, what Cathy did was not choose a man over him but ruptured their shared identity and she couldn’t understand that because she was a split self. Heathcliff was never split. His reaction to Catherine marrying Edgar is often presented as him being this bitter, entitled ex but even entitlement assumes that he viewed Catherine as a separate entity that he wanted for himself as Anakin did with Padme and he never did.</p><p>It’s “you are <strong><em>mine”</em></strong> versus “you are <strong><em>me</em></strong>.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*pWeFdV2mdQcuo3Ut.jpeg" /></figure><p>Their love is not a romance in the adult sense but a survival bond forged in deprivation. It is a closed system and there is only room for that shared identity and <strong><em>no one else</em></strong>. The concept of “love without limits” is romanticized and there have been a multitude of poems written that claim to want devotion that transcends everything, but they recoil when confronted with what limitless love actually looks like. When I point out that Heathcliff is the embodiment of love without limits and that he is a man who loves with the force of a natural disaster, the reaction is again disgust. They want endless, limitless love, but not <em>that</em>. But it <em>is</em> that. Davy Jones spends decades ruminating over Calypso and her betrayal. He replays their love song until that locket of his is worn out and rage-plays that organ of his alone and spends his days tormenting people in a vengeful rage. He and Calypso had no qualms against violence and killing people but audiences call their love story tragic, operatic, and romantic. But when Heathcliff does the same, he is a “stalker” and an obsessed bastard. Yet the archetype is identical: a man whose heart never healed, whose grief calcified into mythic fury. If you want love without limits, this is an example of what it can look like. It is not polite. It is not safe. It is not Darcy and Elizabeth. It is a force of nature.</p><p>Mr. Darcy is a man and loves as one. Heathcliff is a hurricane coming at you with full force and he cannot stop because he doesn’t have a grasp of human limits. He had no brakes and no emotional regulation when it came to Cathy and that isn’t acceptable in what is supposed to be an adult man. His problem is that he was constrained to a human form and forced to live in human society. If he and Catherine had been allowed to exist in their natural habitat away from the rest of the world as Davy Jones and Calypso’s love had been allowed to exist out there in the open seas, their love would have been considered universally beautiful. And I do think their love was beautiful the same way nature is beautiful. It’s not a man and a woman falling in love but a feral moor god and moor-child commingling as one. Nature is considered cruel because while it is magnificent and awe-inspiring, it is also astonishingly indifferent to suffering but it isn’t cruel or evil. Nature just <em>is</em>.</p><p>I love you.</p><p>You enrich my life and bring me great joy. You are my soulmate and my rock. We are in this together for as long as we both shall live. It’s you and I against the world. When you are gone, I will miss you and my heart is broken, but I can have a life outside of you and love others before and after you. I love you but I need space to breathe. My love for others doesn’t take away from what I had with you. If you are hurt, I feel for you as if your pain were my own. If you were to die, a part of me will be forever gone will cherish the memories we shared together.</p><p>I <em>am</em> you.</p><p>I feel not for you but <em>with</em> you. Your pain <em>is</em> my pain. I exist through you and only you and so if you pull away, I no longer exist. You are my life and my <em>soul</em>. How can you be gone when you <em>are</em> me, unless<em> I</em> am gone? There is no “we” or “us” but <em>one</em> and it will <em>never</em> end. There <em>are</em> no barriers between us<em>. </em>You’re the world and all that is, was, and will <em>ever</em> be in it. There is no life or anything outside of you. You will never be a memory. I have no past, no present, and no future because you are all. If you hurt, I hurt. If you cry, I cry. If you die, I die.</p><p>Grammatically, I have to use “we” and “us” but those are plural pronouns. Ideally, for identity collapse, the only pronoun would be “one.”</p><p>One is relational love. It’s Anakin and Padme, Jack and Rose, Mr. Darcy and Liz, Jane Eyre and Rochester, and loves that we have seen going back to antiquity. The other is Catherine and Heathcliff. Specifically, I think this was Heathcliff distilled. This is not obsessive dependence, but ontological or structural dependence. Honestly, I think Heathcliff would have been in better shape had he merely been obsessed with Catherine. At least we would have something of him independent of her to work with but alas, we have nothing.</p><p>The prequels were criticized harshly when they were first released but in more recent years, there has been a resurgence of appreciation and love for them and of Anakin’s character. With the number of Star Wars projects Hayden Christensen has been appearing in lately, there is enough footage to make an extra movie. However, <em>Wuthering Heights</em> remains polarizing and it seems that it will remain so for the foreseeable future. And I don’t understand why it is singled out the way that it is, to the point where I am having to write full-length essays on behalf of characters who I know for a fact that I wouldn’t like as people, if they existed in real life. Is it because of the fanbase or the genre? Because Heathcliff is, on first appearances at least, a human man residing in a rural community in Yorkshire, England while Anakin and the rest of these characters reside in fantastical universes with some level of magic or suspension of belief that the more grounded universe of the Heights lacks.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*tml2vM1-hbU5B3aU.jpeg" /></figure><p>The scales of those stories are of epics and so the fanbase has a different level of baseline expectations from the characters that inhabit them. Anakin, Davy Jones, and Eren Jeager perpetuate mass violence on a mythic, cinematic scale but they do so in universes where mass violence is regularly perpetrated and while utilizing these awesome powers. Anakin had his lightsaber and the Force, Eren Jeager had the power of the Titans, and Davy Jones had the Kraken. Heathcliff wielded no sword, no mystical powers, nor did he have an immortal crew of humanoid monsters at his disposal. His weapon of choice was the law and he took advantage of Victorian marriage and inheritance laws to entrap and only used physical violence towards those he knew he could get away with without retaliation. He was the only figure in <em>Wuthering Heights</em> who perpetuates this level of systemic violence and it is intimate, drawn-out, interpersonal and is of a domestic nature: two families, three children, and his wife. A massive sea battle with eldritch monstrosities and an undead captain battling the living and a legendary behemoth in gleaming black armor cutting down a battlefield by his lonesome as the all-powerful Empire’s one-man army versus a man slapping and imprisoning a teenage girl, abusing his wife, and hanging a small dog. One form of violence is easier for the audience to swallow even if the other leaves behind more bodies in its wake.</p><p>Anakin and Eren are ruled by destiny and prophecy and so they have a level of narrative justification and backing that Heathcliff lacked and so when their characters are evaluated, all of that framing is taken into account. Anakin killing the Younglings is sometimes explained as the Force working in mysterious ways, that it was all going to lead up to him putting an end to the Sith and bringing balance to the Force, and so this was something that had to happen. This kind of cosmic explanation is impossible<em> </em>with Heathcliff. And there is a good chunk of the Attack on Titan fanbase who believe that Eren’s omnicide was justified or at least his reasoning behind it was! Once a protagonist has the audience behind their back and possesses latent charisma, an awesome power, and has a level of the divine on their side, they are set for life! And Anakin and Eren <em>are</em> god-like figures, or men who have either obtained or been born with god-like potential, and are openly regarded as such while Heathcliff is more of a liminal being.</p><p>Heathcliff is physically a man but he was also written to be an elemental singularity and Nelly most notably continually questions exactly <em>what is he</em>. Is he a man? A fiend? A ghoul or a vampire? Where did he come from? There is an unsettling ambiguity baked into his character and so it’s more challenging to evaluate his actions in any single way. As a man, his behavior is violent, abusive, and cruel. As a force of nature and a revenant of vengeance, I would have to evaluate him the same way I do Calypso. Cruel, mercurial, and destructive, yes. But both operate outside the bounds of morality to which even Anakin was bound. I think the problem with Heathcliff is, while his actions were not nearly as extreme as Anakin’s, that oversized emotion of his and the dynamic between him and Catherine, <em>are</em> indeed the most extreme out of the bunch, and so he is singled out.</p><p>Anakin also possessed a degree of likeability and relatability and it is <em>astonishing</em> how much leniency is granted to both fictional characters and real-life people if they possess traits that are considered appealing to audiences, even if their behavior is worse than the unlikable characters. When a villainous character has an outwardly sympathetic motive, audiences are more likely to cut them some slack. Anakin did all of these terrible things but he did it because he wanted to save his loved ones from dying. Heathcliff never had any intention to do good and was operating from the basis of retaliation and avenging years of childhood humiliation. One evokes more immediate sympathy than the other. Anakin was handed a series of brutal yet straightforward tasks. Kill all of these people and I will grant you the knowledge that you will need to save your wife. (Palpatine technically never promised Anakin that he would save his wife nor did he ever actually state that he knew how to do so but that is what he manipulated Anakin into believing). And so with Anakin, audiences can place the blame for his actions on external factors. This is the Jedi’s fault. This was the result of Palpatine’s manipulation. Anakin was beset by nightmares showing him the future he feared most and He was a young, traumatized man terrified of losing his wife.</p><p>Heathcliff answered to no one but himself and Catherine, the two components of that shared identity, and she dies before he goes all in his vengeance, so it’s all on him. Even the trauma and abuse he experienced as a child and an adolescent appears to only go so far in terms of an explanation. It can most definitely explain why he gave Hindley that sound thrashing in the immediate aftermath of Catherine’s funeral; that was a long time coming for all those years of torment and Hindley was <em>godawful</em> with the timing. I personally wouldn’t try murdering a man who hasn’t eaten or slept in a week and was just out wandering in the snow god knows what. Hindley didn’t know that he had just returned from digging up you-know-who, but Isabella was wise to stay out of that one, even if she understandably wanted her husband dead. She probably knew that she was pregnant and had already been planning her escape and so why jeopardize it all for a fight with no winners?</p><p>If there’s one thing Heathcliff became adept at to a deadly degree, it’s understanding power dynamics. Unlike Anakin in his early youth, Heathcliff knew how to pick his fights. He wasn’t in a rational state of mind when he barged in through the window and beat Hindley down but he also knew that his childhood abuser was no match for him and that now, he can beat him down with impunity. And how did he learn all of this? It was through personal experience because he knew what it was like to be at the very bottom.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*iXlXKwheOxXkeV4J.jpeg" /></figure><p>But why target the children? Without closer examination, it appears as if it were simply senseless cruelty. Eren Jeager was <em>damned </em>disproportionate with his vengeance. However, unlike Heathcliff, Eren explicitly spells out why he decided to destroy the entire world but we don’t receive that sort of clarity from Heathcliff. Upon second thought, he <em>did</em> spell out his modus operandi at the Grange when he spoke to Catherine, but the language was heavily metaphorical and abstract compared to Anakin and Eren’s. Everything he did in his vengeance, he learned from somewhere. Hindley was his greatest teacher and Heathcliff learned from him and life under the Earnshaw household that the powerless are crushed and that violence flows <em>down</em>. There are two responses to experiencing this kind of trauma. The first would be child Anakin’s response. He was born into slavery and knew what it was like to live under oppression and so wanted to implement systemic change and ensure that no one else would go through what he did. He wanted to become the most powerful in the world so he can cheat Death. It was rooted in <em>his</em> fear of loss but he also didn’t want his loved ones hurt. The second is what Heathcliff’s response. It’s “you hurt me so I will destroy you and <em>everything</em> you love.” Child Anakin had the heroic response and his son Luke fulfilled the true spirit of what he had originally set out to do. Unfortunately, Heathcliff opted for the latter.</p><p>But what is one thing Anakin and his son Luke had in common? They both had role models to teach them empathy and compassion. It’s an understatement to say that Anakin veered off, but his mother, Padme, and even the Jedi gave him baseline morality and Luke had a normal childhood that his father had been deprived of. He experienced love and stability into his early adulthood years unlike his father, who was stripped of it prematurely and then subjected to years of war, turmoil, and instability. Catherine told Heathcliff off whenever he did something she personally didn’t like and she was the only one he listened to as a child and adolescent, but that is not a moral compass and neither was Joseph’s Bible-thumping. Having a sense of right and wrong, <em>recognition</em> and <em>respect</em> for another’s boundaries and your own, a moral compass, a stable identity and sense of self are taken for granted, but all of these things require years of modeling and attentive care. It’s substantive, painstaking effort to build a normal person and I only mean <em>normal </em>and not necessarily good. And looking at the news, even people who had all of these things can turn out twisted, so where does that leave the three children in that Earnshaw household? It was wild West in there. If someone is not berating you, you get beat up or locked up.</p><p>How can I say that Heathcliff loved Catherine if he abused everyone around him, including his own son and her daughter?”</p><p>How can Darth Vader commit multiple genocides, be complicit in the destruction of an entire planet, torture people, murder women and children, participate in twenty years of galactic oppression, and love his son?</p><p>Because that is <em>his</em> son, <em>his</em> baby boy that he made with his beloved wife. Darth Vader or Anakin or whatever persona you refer to, was a man capable of great cruelty and guilty of a multitude of brutal crimes but he also was a father who loved his son. These things coexist and do not contradict and it is the same in Heathcliff. He was also another cruel man who loved Catherine, not in the same way Anakin loved Padme, as a man loves a woman, but as a self-less being loves the only self he ever had.</p><p>“How can Catherine love such a man? Heathcliff is terrible so she must approve of his godawful behavior.”</p><p>How can Luke love a man like Darth Vader?</p><p>It’s possible to love someone without approving of their poor behavior. Obviously, Luke didn’t think that anything his father did on behalf of the Empire and Palpatine was ok. He chose to separate the identities of Vader and his father Anakin in his mind and to focus on the man his father was and who he still believed him to be. The situation with Catherine was different. She didn’t split Heathcliff up into “good Heathcliff” and “bad Heathcliff.” He was always just Heathcliff to her. Catherine didn’t love Heathcliff because he was this swell, moral man but because he was her’s. He <em>is</em> Catherine. But that didn’t mean she was fine with him doing whatever he wanted. When they were children, she did check his behavior, but the difference between Cathy and Luke is that Cathy never condemned Heathcliff morally. She merely told him to stop doing whatever he was doing because she personally didn’t like it and he stopped because this was Cathy who was telling him to stop.</p><p>The whole concept of loving someone who has committed vile acts is not a phenomenon exclusive to fiction. It happens all the time with parents and their children. Maekar Targaryen had a monstrous son in Aerion, who was infamous even among the Targaryens for his madness and cruelty, and he still went ham trying to save that boy’s life when he felt he was in danger. But it didn’t mean Maekar approved of everything his son did. He did so because he loved his son. The world might view Aerion as a monster but he’s always baby to him. Love and attachment are primordial phenomenon and predate morality and aren’t always rational either.</p><p>“Heathcliff mistreated everyone around him after Cathy died, so that must mean he never loved her.”</p><p>Me: No, it just means that he loved only Catherine.</p><p>“But he was a piece of shit to her daughter! Look at all of these people he was shit too!”</p><p>Me: I already told you that he <strong><em>only</em></strong> loved Catherine.</p><p>“But that is not how love works! If he loved Catherine, surely he would have loved or at least not mistreated her daughter.”</p><p>Me: This is Heathcliff we are speaking of. He is not a man whose love can extend to others. He is a single-attachment creature. The love you speak of and assume that Heathcliff had, falls more along the lines of unconditional love, and what he had was certainly not unconditional, but total and singularly fused. Catherine was everything to him and everyone else were nothing.</p><p>“No, if he truly loved Catherine, then he would have been kinder to others, or at least behaved as a human does with basic empathy and compassion and not used people as tools in his schemes.”</p><p>Me: Heathcliff had no concept of “other people” because there was only Catherine. What he had with her was so total that it wiped everyone else from existence.</p><p>“Ok, he is a psychopath then.”</p><p>Me: Give me an example of a psychopath with a collapsed identity and an attachment so extreme that he was utterly consumed by it, his life, his body, his soul, and was so out of the bounds of human relations that is akin to a force of nature.</p><p>The responses: 🖕</p><p>And this is how conversations about Heathcliff go. It seems to me that people cannot accept this level of absolutism. That Heathcliff mistreated others is not evidence that he was incapable of love but that he is incapable of <em>multiple</em> loves. Even Anakin wasn’t this binary and had multiple people that he loved in different ways. He was human in that he had categories of attachment. Heathcliff had no categories. <em>Everything</em> was collapsed into one. And so he didn’t love Catherine as his lover but as everything. For Anakin, Padme was one of the most important people in his life while Catherine was the <em>only</em> person in Heathcliff’s. Anakin had empathy and was capable of true remorse. He was mentally unraveling after what he had done to the Jedi and those children and for me that is evidence he can feel. I used to think adult Heathcliff had no empathy but he does. It’s just exclusive to one person and distorted. And because it isn’t empathy in a relational sense, it doesn’t look like empathy at all. It is why he is capable of experiencing catastrophic emotion with Catherine but can destroy everyone around him with no remorse. Heathcliff is what happens when a person hasn’t finished developing. His empathy is one with no boundaries and so he can destroy Catherine as well without meaning to and he did.</p><p>On a side note, if I label <em>every single character</em> who displays cruel and unempathetic behavior a psychopath or a selfish, egotistical person a narcissist, the list is going to get <em>awfully</em> long. And if I start doing this for Gothic literature? My goodness. This reminds me of the “mad” Targaryens situation where every other Targaryen supposedly is insane but upon closer inspection of their personal life, most of the so-called “mad” Targaryens were simply a product of their environment: years of trauma, lack of access to any kind of mental help, poor or neglectful parenting, and a <em>very</em> entitled upbringing. Most of them suffer from affluenza and have severely inflated heads due to a lifetime with no boundaries or limits set and being continuously told how special they were, not insanity. And having near unlimited power and being the only ones in possession of flying nukes probably didn’t help, either.</p><p>I think I understand why the Targaryen madness explanation caught on the way that it did, why it dominates so much of the discourse on the Targaryen family, and why there is all of this diagnosing and labeling of Catherine and Heathcliff. People crave a clear explanation for why characters engage in such extreme behavior, and they latch onto these diagnostics to satisfy that itch for clarity. However, I find that it often becomes a detriment to understanding why the character or person became the way that they did. Labels like “narcissist” and “psychopath” are used overwhelmingly on the Internet to insult, shame, and morally condemn people when originally these clinical diagnostics were meant to analyze patterns of behavior and help guide treatment. “Psychopath” has become short-hand for vengeful asshole (Heathcliff) and “narcissist” for insufferable, annoying brat (Catherine). I’ve even seen them used on animals when their behavior doesn’t align with what people think is fair and kind! The cuckoo bird is a “narcissist” bird? They’re animals! I can’t expect nature to obey anything, let alone moral standards!</p><p>Unless the example is as glaring as Cersei Lannister or Emperor Palpatine, I normally shy away from labeling any character a psychopath or a narcissist. And even with such examples, I have never, prior to being exposed to discussions about <em>Wuthering Heights</em> and Heathcliff, thought to analyze them solely through the lens of whatever issues they had, because these issues are only<em> one</em> facet of their lives. And again, privileges of being immortal, I have never seen Davy Jones or Calypso or any violent demi-god or god or eldritch monster being reduced to pathology. And it’s because the audience knows that these aren’t people. They are forces of nature. And so are Cathy and Heathcliff.</p><p>Do Catherine and Heathcliff’s “relationship” fulfill any of the requirements of a healthy adult romance?</p><p>No.</p><p>And if that is the criterion folks are using to determine whether a relationship counts as love or not, Anakin and Padme will fail too. Many of the greatest love stories will fail, many real-life loves will also fail, there would be a dearth of entertainment, the romance genre would be gouged out, the Gothic romance genre will go bankrupt, and I most certainly would not be on Substack writing this essay because I would have nothing to talk about. I would be bored as fuck. Aragorn and Arwen are probably <em>the</em> archetypal perfect couple but I have nothing to say about them, except that they are perfect. Even their flaws are perfect. Have they ever even had a <em>single</em> domestic spat during their marriage? I have nothing to critique, although I have heard some criticisms about Darcy and Liz’s relationship that I did find interesting.</p><p>Catherine and Heathcliff are roasted <em>all the time</em> and they are easy to roast. It hurts my heart because apparently everything I like is “problematic.” I want to see some of these some of these safe, acceptable, socially approved, and perfect love stories subjected to some systemic critiques. Slamming Heathcliff is acceptable but I want to see what would happen if anyone tried critiquing Mr. Darcy, or at least what he represents. There will be immediate besetting by fire and pitchforks. “How <em>dare</em> you put <em>Heathcliff</em> and Mr. Darcy in the same sentence! You are comparing Darcy to a violent abuser! This novel is clearly not for you! You don’t understand what you are reading and are failing to appreciate Austen’s wit and mastery of the written word! Just because <em>you</em> don’t like it doesn’t mean millions of others don’t! This is total edge take!”</p><p>“<em>Wuthering Heights</em> depicts a wicked love! Catherine and Heathcliff shared the same soul but that soul is wicked and evil!”</p><p>Nelly, is that you? Or is this Joseph? I suspected Edgar would be the one behind this but he would never say these these things about Catherine. At least this recognizes they had a love so that’s something. Honestly, if they were recognized as two evil people who loved each other to madness, I can also let it go, even if I don’t think they were evil.</p><p>“This is the love of a monster!” Heathcliff is a monster!”</p><p>What is this. Monsters and evil people can’t love? Who designated love to be exclusive to “nice” and moral, normal people, whatever the Hell “normal” even means? That love must be predicated on goodness and morality is an ideal, and it is one that many do not live up to. That a love <em>must</em> fit the mold of Mr. Darcy and Liz Bennet in order to be considered love at all, is not only a set-up for disappointment with the human race, but it also contradicts human history. The love story found in <em>Pride and Prejudice</em> is a luxury! Heathcliff is not the first monstrous man to have a great, identity-defining love and won’t be the last. Violence and violent behavior doesn’t preclude something from being a love story. If it did, then the genre is going to go through a pretty severe culling. The ancients had no chill when writing what they did. George R.R. Martin has no chill, either. <em>Wuthering Heights</em> is not nearly the most violent or taboo love story, either. If I start bringing in Jaime and Cersei or the Targaryens into the fold, then things will start to get spicy. Tolkien would have been mortified. Because there is a lot of loving in and <em>within</em> that family and there are <em>full-blooded</em> brother-sister relationships in there that are romanticized and considered love stories by the fandom. It all comes down to what the audience is primed to accept.</p><p>If Darth Vader can commit twenty years of galactic murder and love his son and wife then Heathcliff can avenge himself on two families and their descendants and love Cathy with every fiber of his being and <em>as</em> his being.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/401/0*7v2jP6pDN94oQWZL.png" /></figure><p>“This is not love but obsession.”</p><p>I <strong><em>am</em></strong> Heathcliff! He’s more myself than I!</p><p>Unhealthy relationships, obsessive relationships, toxic relationships, abusive relationships, they are all <em>relationships</em>. Obsession, possession, co-dependence, enmeshment: they are all <em>relational.</em> Identity-collapse is not a relationship. And all of these labels describe a violation of boundaries while Catherine and Heathcliff never had any boundaries to begin with! Heathcliff may look and behave like Gothic Smeagol, but his bond with Catherine is more akin to <strong><em>Sauron’s</em></strong> relationship with the One Ring than Smeagol’s. Smeagol, as with all those unfortunate enough to come into contact with the One Ring, obsess and wish to <em>possess</em> it. But however fixated they are on the One Ring, it’s a fixation on an <strong><em>external</em></strong> object.</p><p>It’s <strong><em>my</em></strong> Precious, not I <strong><em>am</em></strong> the Precious!</p><p>Heathcliff never experienced Catherine as separate or external and neither did she with him and it is just so with Sauron. The One Ring is not merely <em>his</em> Precious as it was to all others, but an extension of his very being. As miserable as Smeagol was without the Precious, he can exist as himself. He had a self prior to the One Ring, and the name of that self was Smeagol. He was split between two selves: Smeagol and Gollum and at the end, the Gollum half overtook him entirely but there was a prolonged fight for control. At worst, what happened to him can be read as a boundary collapse, but the boundary that collapsed was between these warring identities. He did not collapse into or fuse with the One Ring. One self overtook the other. Heathcliff had no self prior to and without Catherine and was never split. There was never any internal conflict and there was no collapse of boundaries between them because there were never any boundaries <em>to</em> collapse to begin with! <strong><em>They never differentiated at all! </em></strong>I am realizing in live time that they had was more extreme than identity collapse! What a mess! They had <em>no structure</em> <em>at all</em>! Sauron cannot maintain physical form without the One Ring, and like Heathcliff, once that essential component was destroyed, his life essentially ended with it! It was only vengeance holding Heathcliff up after Catherine died, and once that desire was extinguished, he picked up where he left off in the immediate aftermath of her funeral: starving himself, not sleeping, and hallucinating her everywhere.</p><p>The importance of the “I <strong><em>am</em></strong> Heathcliff” line cannot be stated enough. It needs to be taken <em>literally</em>, not metaphorically. Catherine was not someone Heathcliff wanted to possess: she was his very being. Catherine told Nelly that Heathcliff was always in her thoughts, <em>always</em>, but it isn’t because she was obsessed with him. He was always in her thoughts because they <em>are</em> one. They are of the same substance. Their bond gives off incestuous vibes and I did initially see parallels between Catherine and Heathcliff and Jaime and Cersei but unlike the golden twins, it’s not a bodily substance she speaks of, but a metaphysical one, that they shared. This isn’t rooted in blood, a shared physical appearance, and name as it was with Jaime and Cersei, but of a shared soul. Cersei would incest (hahaha) that Jaime, at least the Jaime who didn’t lose his hand, was her soulmate, and that they had this deep, divine connection but in the novel, she replaced and discarded him rather quickly when he was imprisoned and when he wouldn’t do what she asked him to anymore. Catherine is a non-negotiable entity to Heathcliff. He doesn’t consider replacing her and finding someone else. It’s not because he is loyal but because he <em>cannot</em>. He wasn’t playing games when he said she was his life and soul.</p><p><em>Soul</em>, not soulmate.</p><p>This is identity equivalence. Poor Smeagol’s obsession led to his death and consumed his life, but even he did not equivocate his identity to the One Ring the way Catherine and Heathcliff did to each other. Smeagol was corrupted by the One Ring and that corruption gave birth to that alter ego Gollum. Heathcliff was not corrupted by Cathy and neither was she by him. When they were one out there wandering the moors as kids and after death, it was an expression of their truest selves.</p><p>Identity collapse is rare in fiction, if not unprecedented, but audiences are all too familiar with obsessive, narcissistic, and dependent relationships, and because Catherine and Heathcliff’s behavior share many of the same outward symptoms these dynamics have, they are labeled as such, even if the psychological root of their behaviors is different. Relationships form the foundation of most, if not all, human lives, and so people are primed to view interactions from a relational lens, but Cathy and Heathcliff give that cultural script the finger. They are uncanny because they <em>look </em>and sound and even feel like that annoying couple the neighbors call the cops on because they won’t stop having a row at 3 am, but they are elemental: the moors personified.</p><p>And they’re not all talk, either. <em>Wuthering Heights</em> appears to take place in a grounded, almost banal universe with zero divine presence but there is something going on underneath it all that left rational, grounded folks like Lockwood and Nelly doubting themselves. It’s not as open and blatant as the Force in Star Wars but it’s there all the same. Whether it was only a product of a fanciful imagination or hysteria, their presence remained as part of the landscape long after their physical bodies expired. If this isn’t love, then it’s something truly one-of-a-kind. Catherine and Heathcliff should have their own category. If love <em>must</em> be a relationship, then I will relent and admit that what they had doesn’t constitute as love because they don’t fulfill that basic relational standard but my determination of whether or not it is has nothing to do with Heathcliff’s behavior.</p><p>If anyone can find an example of identity collapse between two people in fiction, please let me know because I am dying to find my next hit. I prefer it to be between humans but I don’t discriminate on the basis of species. I can find the Gothic aesthetic of <em>Wuthering Heights </em>elsewhere<em> </em>but I cannot find <em>them.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8ff8fce0cb6a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Across the Stars and the Moors of Wuthering Heights: Anakin and Padme versus Catherine and…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ashley.tien/across-the-stars-and-the-moors-of-wuthering-heights-anakin-and-padme-versus-catherine-and-efff4053d149?source=rss-1edd7467fe0e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/efff4053d149</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wuthering-heights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gothic-literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[star-wars]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ashley Tien]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 03 Apr 2026 12:29:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-03T12:29:25.911Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Across the Stars and the Moors of Wuthering Heights: Anakin and Padme versus Catherine and Heathcliff (Part 5)</h3><h3>Fear, Love, Identity, and the Architecture of Attachment</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*E_uWsGiIRyKzguzU.png" /></figure><p>One thing that struck me about Heathcliff, especially after reading the novel, was his complete lack of fear. It was not due to bravery or courage and arguably, both of those things do not preclude fear but are celebrated because they imply that a person is acting despite them. Fear is not an inherently bad thing; it is a protective mechanism. Anakin’s turn to the Dark Side was motivated by fear of loss and metastasized into destruction because he lacked a healthy outlet to address these fears. He became ruled by that fear; it ultimately clouded his judgment and he acted rashly to try to preempt the loss.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/716/0*k4ZRuttDJ_3e6AbP.jpeg" /></figure><p>He spends the entirety of <em>Revenge of the Sith</em> stressing over Padme. His face was just filled with angst and I felt his stress emanating from the screen but Heathcliff just <em>did not care.</em></p><p>I feel three things belong to other people that you don’t mess with: their money/job/property, marriage/relationships, and their children, and this man really came in and just messed with all three without fear or hesitation. He did not care because to fear is to have something to lose and to acknowledge at least implicitly, the possibility of loss. He’s a man without fear and not in a heroic sense and not because he is strong or mastered this emotion, but because he never developed the internal machinery that produces fear. Fear requires some baseline state to activate and he never had that basic homeostasis of safety and security in childhood; he expected cruelty, humiliation, and degradation on the daily.</p><p>Fear requires attachment and while he did attach <em>with</em> Cathy, it was not a normal platonic or romantic attachment but complete fusion. He did not fear losing Cathy the same way Anakin feared losing Padme. Heathcliff sensed that her death had occured as he waited outside in the dew and cold outside the Grange following their final meeting but he never accepted it. To fear losing someone is, at its most fundamental, to accept that they are separate and that they can in fact, be separated from you by external factors outside of your control, and to accept the finality of loss.</p><p>All of these things were antithetical to who he was.</p><p>Heathcliff never experienced Cathy as a separate being; it was not fear of losing her he felt when she decided to marry Edgar but hurt and betrayal. He ran off from the Heights with nothing as a teenager; it was an impulsive decision and one that would terrify a good chunk of people because he was running off to parts unknown as a nobody with nothing to his name but he was not afraid because he had, already at that point, experienced the worst thing that could happen to him. And when he came back, he knew what he was going to do and it was “black fire” in his eyes that Nelly saw and not a trace of fear.</p><p>When Palpatine told Anakin that Padme had died and their unborn child with her, his reaction was disbelief and shock, heartbreak and then grief. It was operatic and dramatized, almost Shakespearean, the reaction of a man who lost his beloved, his child, the future, and everything he once stood for. Heathcliff’s reaction to Catherine’s death was raw and feral. His first reaction was anger and he was angry with her because her death violated the one rule in this life that he thought would always hold constant: their bond. Anger is indeed a common reaction to loss and so is denial but he seemed almost personally offended by her death; Nelly was crying and speaking of her being at peace and in Heaven and he was like:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*Tla1lxKvIUJXX66q.gif" /></figure><p>He called Catherine a liar and angrily rejected the idea that she was at in peace in Heaven because that would mean accepting separation. He experienced her illness and death as a betrayal of him and their relationship. In his mind, she had left him twice: once when she married Edgar and again when she died and so he called her back because she had violated their fusion and he wanted her to come back and answer for these betrayals. In the eighteen years after she died, he saw her everywhere and it did not matter to him whether what he experienced was “real” in the objective sense because she had been the only thing real to him. When she died, his reality was gone.</p><p>He never thought that the natural order applied to their relationship; after all, how can he think he could ever lose her when she was himself just outside his body? He asked where did she go when he heard of her death because he literally didn’t understand. He was asking where did <em>I</em> go? It was complete ontological shock.</p><p>If I had to summarize his reaction to her death it would be:</p><p>“Hey! What the <strong><em>Hell</em></strong>?! Come back! We’re not done yet!”</p><p>It’s not poetic or romantic so much as he experienced her death as a violation of the laws of the universe.</p><p>He didn’t believe in God but he did believe in their bond and that things like death and mortality were not barriers in their relationship as they were in others. It was why he had to believe in ghosts and ultimately why he unearthed her. He rejected death and separation and the reality that she was gone.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*SG8OcEgh-fyaodwx.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*wKDzoJKajSuS-rjk.jpeg" /></figure><p>Anakin valued his life and had no intentions of throwing it away in his quest to save Padme. He was doing all of this madness in large part because he had something to come home to: a family. He might have killed children but he cared about Padme and his own unborn child. At his most deranged, he proposed to Padme to rule alongside him at the head of his new Empire after he overthrew Palpatine. He had vision and plans for the future and his fall to the Dark Side is tragic because he destroys the very future he had intended to protect.</p><p>Heathcliff only valued his life in the sense that he needed it to take vengeance; he was already a dead man walking even when Cathy was alive after she married Edgar. Even as a teenager he had already foreclosed the possibility of a future outside of his revenge and he had no vision for anything resembling happiness. He planned to haunt Cathy’s life, attempting to insert himself in the fragile domesticity she managed to settle into, to show her that things like her marriage cannot disrupt their bond.</p><p>Anakin was defined by excess: overwhelming fear, passionate love, volcanic hate. Heathcliff was defined by absence: of fear, morality, empathy, and compassion, all of these things that make a person a human being. He was absent because he was unformed and he just filled that void entirely with vengeance after Cathy died. He lacked the basic emotional brakes that people and even animals have.</p><p>Doctor Kenneth called Cathy Heathcliff’s better half and they really do have a lot in common. Neither of them feared death. When she was sick and dying, she had accepted it in her bones, and expressed not an ounce of fear but was relieved that she would no longer have to exist in a split state. And like her better half, she was also angry too at Heathcliff and Edgar and at being unable to have what she wanted, which was everything: she had wanted the safety and comfort of Edgar’s world but monogamy from Heathcliff as well.</p><p>Anakin feared death, not so much his own but the fear of losing someone he loved. Heathcliff never feared death because he never valued his own life. He didn’t welcome it at the end or laugh in the face of it so much as saw it as a portal to Cathy or the only way he would no longer have to be separated from her. I used to wonder how can he not value his life but the right question is: how can he ever have learned to value it? Anakin had nine years of unconditional love from his mother, friends he cherished, and people who saw him as his own person and not just another slave. Nine years is tragically short but Heathcliff had zero.</p><p>Earnshaw’s love was instinctive rather than unconditional and it failed to protect him from abuse; if anything, it left Heathcliff more vulnerable to it as it created a pressure cooker of racial and personal resentment in the household. As bad as or worse than the beatings, I felt, was the daily degradation and humiliation he experienced as a child. When he grew to manhood, he objectified others the same way he was objectified. The only person Heathcliff did not objectify was Cathy; he fused to her instead. She didn’t so much impart an inherent value to his life as she recognized that he had one. He didn’t see her as a separate being and neither did she. There was no respect for each other’s autonomy or awareness of each other’s inner world and needs and these are fundamental things required for any relationship, whether platonic or romantic, to function. It’s why their behavior is so self-centered and oblivious to the point of delusion.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*FWcQjf8Jc9jGbrBv.gif" /></figure><p>Even Anakin on his worst days, at least recognized Padme as her own person. He recognized that he took innocent lives and that he had done the irreversible; he can label the Jedi all traitors and enemies of the Republic, but he had no illusions over what he did to the Younglings: he knew he was in the wrong. He enjoyed killing the Separatists but took no joy in killing the Jedi he once trained besides and especially killing the children.</p><p>His fixation on saving Padme from death, years of war and trauma, all the crimes he committed, and the guilt took its toll on his mental state. He also was not sleeping well during the events of <em>Revenge of the Sith</em>: he was plagued by nightmares of losing Padme and these dreams of death and loss had haunted him since he was a teenager when he first dreamt of his mother dying. That dream had come to fruition and he was hell-bent on making sure it didn’t happen a second time, not knowing he would inadvertently make it come true trying to prevent it from occurring.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/253/0*i2XN3fwwQOCo17yj.gif" /></figure><p>Anakin was visibly deranged by the time he had that epic duel and confrontation with Obi-wan on Mustafar and had that meltdown after Force Choking Padme, the one he was doing all of this for. He looked confused too, after he did that to her; I don’t think he was mentally all there. But for me, at the very least, his meltdown showed that he had some remnant of consciousness left; he knew he had betrayed everything he once believed in and was in emotional overload.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/349/0*ZYVXGCy2NJc8odsP.gif" /></figure><p>He was clinging to fantasies that he still had it all under control, was trying to convince himself he didn’t just destroy everything, and that he was still doing good. It’s why he lashed out so violently at Padme when she expressed fear and displeasure at what he had become because she broke the illusion he had been doing the right thing, and then he lashed out at Obi-wan too, blaming him for what he had just done to Padme. He was projecting his own self-loathing and guilt onto his former master and he did so because these two were central to his life.</p><p>But Anakin began with good intentions: he just wanted to save his loved ones from dying, he wanted a future, and to be a hero. Heathcliff, as a teenager, was already living entirely in the past and fully engulfed in his desire for vengeance and had thrown away any possibility of a future.</p><p>Anakin broke down because he knew those lives he had taken had inherent value whereas Heathcliff never considered life inherently valuable, whether it be his own or those of other people who were not Catherine. His life was only valuable in relation to Cathy, valuable in the sense that it existed when she was alive.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*jKj7lHdeSpp60-Qn.gif" /></figure><p>Anakin wept under the weight of it all and the visible deterioration of his mental state on Mustafar is in large part due to the guilt of what he had done. Heathcliff only ever wept for Cathy and was completely indifferent to the point of callousness for others.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/0*I5Om1lstBQZD1Pjh.png" /></figure><p>Heathcliff is controlled collapse. He is dangerous because he can plan vengeance and talk madness while appearing and sounding perfectly composed. I personally do not believe he had his entire revenge plan laid out when he came back to Wuthering Heights, but he was willing to go all the way with zero regard for his own life and he had only wanted to live long enough to exact his vengeance. During those three years he was gone, he could have built a life for himself but didn’t. He amassed a significant amount of wealth but it was not for his own use or pleasure but purely as leverage. He had no plans for a future and there is no evidence to suggest he found companionship of any kind. When Hindley went off to college, he brought home a wife. When Heathcliff came back, he brought home no one.</p><p>I’m sure during those three years away and long before that, he thought of killing Hindley but he ultimately decided on a more methodical route. When he was a teen, Nelly noted that he had a bit of a temper and he threw hot food at Edgar when he was insulted and he has shown in the novel that he is not above using physical violence. But rather than use brute force, he prefers to hurt people via proxies. I thought Heathcliff seemed a normal teenager, at least normal given his circumstances: he was grumpy but seemed human enough. Whatever came back after that three-year time skip killed what remained of that boy; he learned to contain his violence under the thinnest veneer of gentility.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*8MS9wqlhEP8A3-pw.gif" /></figure><p>Anakin is like a flood or a volcano; he felt too much and he loved many people intensely and fearfully. Heathcliff is a singular being: he only loved one absolutely and was basically dead with everyone else and everyone else was less than dead to him. Anakin at multiple critical juncture points asked himself if he was doing the right thing and feared disappointing Obi-wan. He hid some of his more questionable and terrible deeds for as long as he could because he knew his loved ones would not approve. He never told Obi-wan he slaughtered all the Tusken Raiders after they killed his mother and he was gaslighting Padme about what he had done to the Jedi and the Younglings.</p><p>But, all of this to me, showed that at his worst, Anakin still had a soul. He felt guilt, shame, qualms of conscience, and fear of disappointing his loved ones. They were still moral guardrails even when they failed. Palpatine was a complete psychopath and took joy in all his war crimes and was giggling and gleeful but Anakin was torn to shreds by it.</p><p>I don’t think Heathcliff, even before he became consumed by his vengeance, ever asked himself if he was doing the right thing. It’s not that he disregarded the question but that it just did not occur to him: he just acted. He didn’t have these moral qualms, internal conflicts, or fear of disappointing or losing Cathy as a result of what he was about to do and it’s because their relationship was never based upon morality. She didn’t live long enough to see the full extent of his violence but even when alive, she didn’t care if what he did or thought was moral or not. Never did she attempt to talk him out of his hatred for Hindley or the Lintons or tell him that he was a good person or to be the better man and rise above his hate; she accepted it as a given that he hated them all and was a brutal, merciless man.</p><p>Cathy told Isabella that Heathcliff was this unrefined creature, akin to a wolf and uncultivated land. Heathcliff was named after a barren heath; it evokes this harsh, natural imagery and that is what he is, just this feral, untamed being. She had no desire to tame the wolf or pretend it was a dog and to teach it manners or to force it into any roles that went against its nature. A wolf is not a house pet and never will be. Only one thing mattered to Catherine and it was whether or not Heathcliff belonged to her. Everything else like morality or ethics were irrelevant.</p><p>The first thing she said to him when he went to see her when she was ill and dying was: why should I care for <em>your</em> suffering when you’ve made <em>me</em> suffer? <em>You</em> broke <em>me</em>. I think that’s pretty much the mindset he was operating on his whole life when it came to any living thing that was not Catherine: why should I care? I don’t think he literally asked himself that everytime he slapped a child around but that was how he acted.</p><p>He just didn’t give a shit.</p><p>This is one reason I find Heathcliff more unsettling than Anakin though the latter killed so many people to the point of absurdity. At least Anakin was acting human even as he committed all of these terrible acts; he displayed guilt, torment, grief, and pain due to what he had done. Heathcliff is just emptied of all of those things and it places him beyond reason. How do you reason with someone, let alone save someone, who has no hope, no sense of self-preservation, and he does all these cruel things in clarity and indifference to the well-being of everyone? A monster can be stopped but someone like this will never stop.</p><p>Vader, who was considered one of the most feared figures in the Galaxy, even he had some form of self-preservation and fear of his master Sidious. Vader did not try to overthrow Palpatine directly because he did not think himself powerful enough to do so. In the comics, he did try to defy Palpatine once and was fried with Force Lightning and Force Choked and so he stopped. It’s why he was so desperate to team up with Luke; with his son and those Skywalker genes, he was sure he would be able to team up against Sidious and win.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/245/0*yjZQOQR5AcHO1MBN.gif" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*s0lwkbB3mFxP15ez.jpeg" /></figure><p>Anakin’s fear doomed him but it also ended up saving him as he had enough humanity left inside him to save because under all of the atrocities he had committed as Vader, Anakin once cared about other people and himself. Anakin did not want to lose his son. When Palpatine was frying Luke, he was seeing his trauma all over again: the fear of losing a loved one, whereas Heathcliff did not give a damn his son was dying and actively hastened his death via active neglect and psychological torment. Even Vader had more of an emotional bandwidth than Heathcliff did; he was at least capable of caring about someone who was not Padme. Anakin was capable of self-sacrifice, whereas Heathcliff and Cathy were only capable of self-destruction.</p><p>Anakin was capable of returning to the Light in a way Heathcliff was not because he at least had some internal scaffolding to work with, however ruined it had become. He had reference points for good behavior. He has seen and experienced alternatives to cruelty and knew what unconditional love and kindness look like, even in the abstract. Heathcliff’s reference points were limited to him being abused, both verbally and physically, seeing other people mistreat each other, and volatile, conditional love from Cathy. He tormented her and blew up her marriage, but she reciprocated in kind on her deathbed. Heathcliff did see some basic humanity exchanged between Cathy and Hareton but it was too late for him to participate in that, as he was already dissolving by then.</p><p>We also don’t get any concrete information as to what his life was like during those three years he was away from Wuthering Heights but judging from the little information he gave, how quickly he was able to amass this wealth in the era he was living in, and the emotional state he was in upon returning, I don’t think it was via pleasant means. He had no model for empathy, compassion, or any moral frameworks to fall back upon, so I wouldn’t say he rejected morality: he just didn’t have the raw materials to conceive of it in the first place.</p><p>To feel empathy is to go further than sympathy; it means to be able to conceive of what is going on in another’s mind and to feel compassion is to take that a step further and to feel compelled to take action to alleviate the pain. Nelly was dutiful but she admitted she did not like Heathcliff at first and only cared for him as a child out of duty. I think she did feel basic sympathy for the abuse he was experiencing but as a servant she can do nothing and she certainly did not know what was going on his mind. She thought him quiet and not vindictive when Heathcliff was inscribing every slight in his psyche waiting for the day he could become powerful and finally pay them all back.</p><p>Cathy wanted to be a part of the high life the Lintons offered her so even if she did feel bad for Heathcliff and the racial and class prejudices he was suffering under, she would not think to intervene because she did not want to lose that chance. I can’t blame her for not directly intervening with Hindley’s abuse, though. He was the legal, male heir of the household and so she couldn’t do anything even if she had wanted to without risking getting hurt herself.</p><p>My point is, even if there are some instances of emotional attunement when they were children, her love for Heathcliff as a whole was not empathetic, compassionate, or protective. Fusion-style relationships fundamentally mess with the ability to feel empathy because there is no seeing the other person as separate; she felt for him <em>through</em> herself, and the same went for Heathcliff.</p><p>Honestly, I am still struggling with the concept of fused relationships and how it interacts with concepts like empathy and compassion because first and foremost: I don’t know <em>who</em> is <em>who</em>. With Anakin and Padme, I can at least say Anakin is Anakin and Padme is Padme, but with Cathy and Heathcliff, I can’t even make that fundamental distinction. The “I am Heathcliff” line is one of, if not the most famous line in this novel, and it is honestly very telling and horrific if you really think about the implications of it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/0*6RlaLYYHAtCkutqd.gif" /></figure><p>Padme’s final words were about Anakin’s well-being; she wanted him to be saved, expressing hope that there was still good in him. Catherine’s final words in life were screaming for her and Heathcliff not to be separated as her husband was literally coming up the stairs and about to see them because <em>she</em> could not bear it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*FnwVoukJn5PKWaiQ.gif" /></figure><p>Unlike Cathy, Padme had her limits; her love was still rooted in some basic moral responsibility. She rejected Darth Vader on Mustafar after she found out the full extent of his crimes and if she had survived childbirth and Anakin’s betrayal, she would have hidden the children from him and joined the rebellion against the Empire. She loved Anakin but she retained her morals; she wasn’t going to sacrifice her principles or risk the safety of their children and the galaxy to preserve the relationship and Anakin knew that which is why he kept her in the dark.</p><p>If Anakin were allowed to love safely and did not have to stress out about some war going on or Padme dying and had access to some form of cognitive behavorial therapy even as a young adult, I think he would have calmed down and been a good father and husband. Ultimately, his volatile behavior was situational. I heard someone say Heathcliff needed a therapist and my response was I think the man would either banish or set the dogs on the therapist, especially if the therapist dared to imply that his relationship with Cathy was in any way unhealthy or undesirable and that he needed to let her go.</p><p>You can’t help someone who doesn’t want to be helped. He made the pain, hate, and rage his literal identity. He would say he didn’t need help. He wanted Catherine and <em>only</em> Catherine and to return to the days they ran wild on the moors and if he couldn’t have that, then he would rather have nothing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/688/0*gh7nGI4vp7DtGXOM.jpeg" /></figure><p>Padme would be on board with Anakin getting therapy; she wanted to help him. Even when Anakin was talking crazy on Mustafar, she wanted to reach out to him and save him. Cathy on the other hand…it’s not that she wanted Heathcliff to suffer for her own enjoyment but if his getting therapy would mean him healing and moving on from her, she would reject it and Heathcliff, who never had any healthy model of love, would agree with her.</p><p>Anakin was dependent on Padme for emotional stability and probably saw her as a mother-like figure too after what happened to his own mother but Heathcliff was just <em>hopeless</em> when it came to Cathy. He didn’t act like a boy but a dog with her and not just any dog, but a mistreated one that only ever bonded with one person. She didn’t need to snap her fingers and he just came to her on bended knee. He went off the rails after she died, but it’s just pitiful. He despised being humiliated but isn’t this the epitome of humiliation, pining after someone who would never promise you basic exclusivity?</p><p>In an alternate reality where things did not blow up, she would have continued to play as Edgar’s wife during the day, been intimate with him by night, produced more heirs for the Grange, and entangled with you whenever her husband <em>allowed</em> her to see you. Even the Joker was more emotionally exclusive with Batman than she was with you! Anakin and Padme would <em>never</em> have done that to each other. It would have been a slower death for Heathcliff watching Cathy as Mrs. Linton while he was left out forever.</p><p>I can watch Anakin’s fall to the Dark Side and the birth of Vader because I know his son will be there to save him but with Heathcliff, it’s unbearable. He really ought to have run off from the Heights and never returned. It was a done deal the moment Cathy announced her plans to marry Edgar and he <em>knew </em>it and returned anyways, which is embarrassing. I felt embarrassed. <em>Where is your pride? </em>He never heard the part of her “I am Heathcliff” speech where she spoke of using Edgar’s money to set him up to ensure that he would forever remain in the Heights near her, but even without hearing her, he did as she had wanted anyway.</p><p>Anakin had fluctuating self-esteem: there were moments he was shouting from the rooftops about how powerful he was and other times he was filled with insecurity and self-loathing. With Heathcliff, I saw no self-esteem of any kind. Cathy said it would degrade her to marry Heathcliff.</p><p>You know what I think is degrading?</p><p>This plan of hers is degrading.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/686/0*uMzcqDUAWqu55bBC.jpeg" /></figure><p>Anakin and Padme were star-crossed lovers; their love theme is literally called “Across the Stars.” Theirs is this cosmic, galactic love against a backdrop of prophecy, destiny, and the rise and fall of empires. Their tragedy is circumstantial: their love was doomed due to forces beyond their control.</p><p>Cathy and Heathcliff’s love was bound to the earth and is as harsh, elemental, and merciless as the moors. They are not so much lovers but one self split into two and the story is these two selves warring and screaming to unite in a society that forced them to exist in an unnatural split state.</p><p>Their tragedy is built into the way they attached because their desire is unattainable. They did not want each other romantically the way Anakin and Padme did but existentially and no marriage or amount of time together or physical intimacy would ever have satisfied that.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*LEvu0cqk0AjVxeZM.jpeg" /></figure><p>Catherine and Heathcliff do not have a single love theme because they do not have a single adaptation portraying them and I think that lack of singularity reflects the impossibility of fully capturing their relationship on screen for what they had was beyond the physical body. Many would cite Kate Bush’s song or the various themes from the film adaptations but I think their theme song should just be the sound of the moors, pure atmosphere and the wild, stormy dissonance of the rain, wind, and snow.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*U00hmClVvBTF8pGd.jpeg" /></figure><p>Anakin and Padme’s relationship is criticized in certain circles for being less than ideal. I do think their romance was indeed born out of high-intensity, traumatic circumstances: literally he was a teen and not just a normal teen, either but an immaculately conceived-child-soldier-warrior-monk with crazy Force powers while she was a young woman in her early twenties who faced possible execution, war, and political assassinations. All of these things definitely played a role in them bonding so quickly; it was not just their proximity during these events but the forbidden aspect of their relationship too that fanned the flames. They both knew he wasn’t supposed to be entangled with her, let alone be married.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*8j9AZcjCNjGZDNpz.jpeg" /></figure><p>She was thrust into adult roles as a child; she became Queen at only fourteen years old and a Senator at eighteen. As Queen of Naboo, she deepened her voice when speaking to sound more mature and the elaborate ceremonial costumes she wore to the outside world accentuated the mismatch between her biological age and the role she was thrust into. They were both special; he was the Chosen One, this war hero, and a Jedi prodigy and she had all of these accomplishments before the age of twenty but with each other, they can take a break from these roles and just be themselves. There was also mutual admiration of each other’s strength, abilities, and physical attraction as well.</p><p>Lucas got some fire from critics for the way he directed the scenes and the clunky dialogue but I thought the scenes and dialogue did their job; Anakin and Padme’s love story unfolded with familiar patterns in a typical human romance:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/688/0*XAdErxGahl59sjfU.jpeg" /></figure><p>First meeting with an adorable line that was so tragic in retrospect and even the bestowing of a cute memento:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*CajRBd0AkFvbJP5I.jpeg" /></figure><p>Anakin had a burgeoning crush on Padme complete with awkward adolescent behavior with all the fidgeting, sweating, angst, and nervousness. It was a bit one- sided at first as Padme saw him not as a romantic potential yet but still that boy from Tatooine.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/252/0*DEZCM4Bt--45NrZQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>But over time and under all that external pressure, they found escape and relief in each other and we see the growing connection between them and development of feelings.</p><p>Then, of course the first kiss.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*DZlBzJi-01tfXjeT.gif" /></figure><p>Confession of feelings:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*6VjA7c2Kb9gELvPS.jpeg" /></figure><p>Marriage and the physical consummation of their relationship:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*WZe0wXtrjsqIq4pM.jpeg" /></figure><p>And domesticity, grief, and loss.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*K5jDI824cP69Ll3B.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/825/0*XtmUBLbnwMAtLqzM.gif" /></figure><p>I am looking at Catherine and Heathcliff and they don’t follow this script. I wanted to post photos of them too showing these steps unfolding and I can’t find any because there aren’t any. She married Edgar of course so we don’t get the marriage and domesticity but I am talking about all the previous steps as well. Cathy and Heathcliff have one of the strangest relationships I have ever seen and it’s not just their dynamics but the way their relationship is portrayed in the novel; it’s actually not shown much in text, like what they actually do out there on the moors while Anakin and Padme’s romance had the privilege of being shown as is without some unreliable narrator skewing the portrayal of events.</p><p>Cathy and Heathcliff’s relationship is filtered through Nelly’s eyes and she never saw what they were up to out there on the roof or on the moors and she probably wouldn’t have understood what was going on between them even if she had seen them. So because of the way the novel is structured, we never get a first kiss scene, or cute crushes, or a confession of feelings; it’s all just left blank and yet it’s had such a formative impact that by only fifteen or so, Cathy was declaring they shared the same soul and speaking in metaphysics. Anakin and Padme were young and passionate as well but they never spoke of souls. Their conversations were about life and even in such a fantastical universe as that of Star Wars, they were more grounded than Cathy and Heathcliff in that respect.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/635/0*KVwroKR8_mCTdnE2.png" /></figure><p>This is why I say that Heathcliff was not <em>in love</em> with Catherine. I don’t think they went through the whole crush and butterflies-in-the-stomach phase that Anakin and Padme went through, just all of those classic steps of love that have been normalized in literature and media. Anakin and Padme desired each other and while Cathy and Heathcliff did share kisses and hugs during their final scene together, it comes off to me as more existential than sexual, like their bodies themselves were a barrier between them. I don’t see Heathcliff as innately asexual, but someone who never developed adult sexual desire because his development was unfinished.</p><p>Anakin fell in love with Padme first and I would say he fell harder and catastrophically so. He would literally murder entire planets for Padme and he sold his soul because he could not bear to lose her. Emotionally, I would say Padme was more mature than Anakin not only due to her age but in terms of stability, so she <em>was</em> his anchor.</p><p>Cathy was not too fond of Heathcliff at the start; during their first meeting, she spat at him and refused to allow him to sleep in the same room as herself but Nelly reported that a few days later she had taken a liking to him so Cathy initiated the bond first but that Heathcliff, my <em>God</em>, fused with her like nothing else. Their relationship had no anchor either.</p><p>Both relationships were conceived in less-than-ideal circumstances but Anakin and Padme’s relationship had a chance to be healthy if only the circumstances were different and if Anakin had made sounder decisions. Cathy and Heathcliff’s relationship, if you can even call it a relationship, was structurally unhealthy and unstable because it could not survive adulthood.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/0*o2ajL0RP0GMbYzff.jpeg" /></figure><p>Anakin and Padme even in their most intimate moments, are still defined by their respective roles: father, husband, wife, mother, all that good stuff. They may leave the more official titles out the door like senator, former Queen, and Jedi Knight but those basic labels remained and they do play a role in why they loved each other. But for Cathy and Heathcliff, none of those labels ever mattered or existed out there when they ran wild out there on the moors. I don’t think Heathcliff ever saw Cathy as a white English girl and Cathy didn’t see him as a “gypsy” either. They cared not about each other’s ages or looks; they just saw each other.</p><p>At its core, what they had was very primordial, primal, and pure. It’s just tragic this purity devolved into insanity, madness, vengeance, and destruction. It just gets overshadowed in discussions due to how cruel Heathcliff was but it could have been cute and sweet: a poor orphan boy ostracized by society and a vivacious, rebellious girl falling for each other.</p><p>But no, it just <em>had</em> to go down the toilet.</p><p>So, to summarize:</p><p>Anakin <em>loved</em> Padme.</p><p>Heathcliff <em>was</em> Catherine and Catherine was Heathcliff.</p><p>If you asked Anakin<em> why</em> he loved Padme, he could answer that with nostalgia and joy: she was kind, beautiful, an accomplished politician, she was the mother of my children, and was courageous and compassionate.</p><p>If you asked Heathcliff why he loved Catherine, he would just say because it’s Catherine.</p><p>If you asked Anakin who he was, he could give multiple answers and they would all be true at once: I am a Jedi Knight, a brother to Obi-wan, a father to Luke and Leia, and husband to Padme.</p><p>If you asked Heathcliff who he was, he would just say I am Catherine.</p><p>After Padme died, Anakin was lost and became fully engulfed in the persona of Darth Vader but his son helped him to remember who he was: Anakin Skywalker, a Jedi.</p><p>After Catherine died, if you were to ask him who he was, he wouldn’t be able to answer anymore because there was no “Heathcliff” left.</p><p>“I was Heathcliff when she was alive. Now, I am nothing.”</p><p>If you asked Anakin what his hopes and dreams were and the future he saw before he fell to the Dark Side, he would say he wanted to be a hero and to protect his loved ones and to have a happy life with Padme and the children.</p><p>If you asked Heathcliff those questions, he would have no conception of terms like hopes and dreams and future: all he would see is Catherine.</p><p>Anakin loved Padme as a woman, a partner, his moral compass, the mother of his children. He loved her as her own separate person.</p><p>Heathcliff loved Catherine as himself existing outside his body because she was the only self he ever had.</p><p>Anakin had a great love: Padme was the love of his life and from that love, other connections could spring.</p><p>Heathcliff had one singular attachment and it destroyed his ability to form other connections.</p><p>However unhealthy their relationship became, what Anakin and Padme had started off as love and it was nurturing and expansive. It made him want to be a better person: it was a human, relational love.</p><p>Heathcliff and Cathy are not so much lovers; he doesn’t love her as her own person but because she was the only one who recognized his personhood. What they had cannot lead to betterment of the self but to annihilation of it.</p><p>Anakin feared losing Padme. He could not imagine existence without the woman he loved. When he lost her, he lost his beloved and experienced grief and heartbreak. He became possessive over her because he feared losing her.</p><p>Heathcliff never feared losing Catherine, for he could no more lose her than he could lose himself. When she physically died, he experienced identity implosion and lost the one remaining tether he had to humanity. Cathy and Heathcliff were possessive but that was inevitable due to the nature of fusion; they did not fear losing each other but being separate at all.</p><p>Anakin and Padme loved each other because they saw the good in each other.</p><p>Cathy loved Heathcliff, not because he was good, but because he was hers and he loved her because she was his.</p><p>Anakin said that he cannot live without Padme but he <em>did</em> live, for a brief time, when his son Luke found him again before he was able to pass in peace</p><p>Heathcliff never lived until Cathy recognized him and when she died, he never lived again and he didn’t so much die at the end as he stopped trying to continue the futile task of existing without her.</p><p>At the end, Anakin accepted Padme’s death and the end of their relationship.</p><p>Heathcliff could never accept Catherine’s death for what he had with Catherine was not a relationship but one soul split into two and to accept her death would be to accept the end of his own existence. He cannot conceive of what they had ending but continuing forever.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*sx6qgyXJVbevOag1.jpeg" /></figure><p>Anakin told Padme that she was beautiful and that he was so in love with her.</p><p>Heathcliff never spoke of Cathy’s beauty and he was not so much in love with her as he only ever existed because of her.</p><p>Anakin and Padme’s love was expansive. Under a different set of circumstances, it could have been nurturing.</p><p>Cathy and Heathcliff’s love can only ever collapse inward and consume.</p><p>Anakin and Padme’s love was human against a fantastical, operatic backdrop with cosmic intervention. They loved each other as people do.</p><p>Cathy and Heathcliff’s love was inhuman in a grounded, amoral world. They loved like forces, destructive and indifferent to suffering.</p><p>Anakin and Padme’s love ended when they died and their physical bodies were destroyed.</p><p>Cathy and Heathcliff’s began when they died and they were finally freed from the confines of mortal flesh.</p><p>Anakin and Padme’s love changed the fate of the galaxy. While it was a destructive, tragic love, it was ultimately, in the grand scheme of things, a relationship that geared towards redemption and restored balance to their universe through the fruit of their love: their children. Catherine and Heathcliff’s relationship refuses closure and resolution; theirs is not a redemptive love and it destroyed an entire generation of people. It’s a sterile dyad and cannot produce life.</p><p>I have yet to find words in the English language to fully describe what they are; the closest term I can find so far is soulmates but I don’t even think soulmates fit perfectly because soulmates implies two separate people with a deep connection and I don’t see these two as two fully formed people. Labels go flaccid with these two.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*rnrEIEfnoGQQKWuE.jpeg" /></figure><p>Catherine and Heathcliff are not lovers, partners, or a couple; they are a pattern across time locked in eternity with each other. They are a mythic binary like Batman and the Joker, the knight slaying the dragon, and the archangel Michael battling the Devil. They are never changing. They are doomed to repeat over and over and over again and they wouldn’t have it any other way.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=efff4053d149" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mortal Dyads: Why Rhett and Scarlett Remain Human Besides Catherine and Heathcliff (Part 2)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ashley.tien/mortal-dyads-why-rhett-and-scarlett-remain-human-besides-catherine-and-heathcliff-part-2-1f5f9625af4e?source=rss-1edd7467fe0e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1f5f9625af4e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[emily-brontë]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[heathcliff]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wuthering-heights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gone-with-the-wind]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ashley Tien]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 26 Feb 2026 03:40:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-26T03:40:25.565Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Difference Between Destruction and Collapse</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*_w-YoBOE0-6ZFnDr.jpeg" /></figure><p>Rhett and Scarlett, though tumultuous, destructive, and passionate, are ultimately a grounded human couple. Their bond is intense but not existential. Rhett fell in love with Scarlett first and he was quite clear about his reasons; he loved her for her spirit, tenacity, ruthlessness, and beauty. When Scarlett realizes belatedly that she was in love with Rhett at the end, she also goes through a mental reel of the reasons why she did. She realized that, throughout the years, she was never truly alone even when she thought she was; Rhett’s strength and love carried her through the most chaotic and difficult times of her life. He understood her in a way no one else did and he shared many of her interests and personality traits; they were both earthy, ambitious, selfish, and pragmatic. They have rational reasons for loving each other.</p><p>This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.</p><p>Catherine and Heathcliff’s love, in my eyes, is not rational love. Their love is not beyond reason; it is <em>before </em>reason. They love each other because they <em>are</em> each other. In <em>The Dark Knight</em>, the Joker tells Batman that “you complete me” and I feel the same goes for Cathy and Heathcliff. However, they do not mean completion in the romantic, heartfelt, poetic love-letter sense of the word but literally so.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/260/0*5un7uMGCX90AwjVP.jpeg" /></figure><p>For the majority of the story, Rhett was the one pursuing Scarlett while she was head-in-the-clouds for Ashley. Scarlett gets a lot of flak for her obsession with Ashley but I personally found it quite sympathetic and understandable. For being such a practical person, Scarlett was surprisingly nostalgic and I found that duality in her character striking. Of course she had a thing for Ashley. Ashley Wilkes was a childhood friend of hers and a beau but more importantly, he was the human embodiment of the life she had lost forever and the safety and comfort of her youth before the Civil War: he was the epitome of what a Southern aristocratic gentleman should be. He was an excellent shot and horseman, well-versed in politics, educated and well-read, and the heir to a fortune. She loved Ashley the symbol, not so much the man himself, and she shared that with Catherine, who loved Edgar because of the life and status he provided.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/200/0*Rbwi1IFvLlS0Qgk-.jpeg" /></figure><p>However, I don’t feel Catherine was physically attracted to Edgar at all while Scarlett was to Ashley and I cannot blame her. In the novel, Ashley was a young, handsome man in his twenties; he was tall and slender with blond hair that shone silver in the sunlight and dreamy gray eyes framed by thick gold lashes. While writing this piece, I realized just how much Ashley reminded me of Edgar Linton. Edgar is the English version of the same archetype. I don’t see many discussing Edgar’s looks, perhaps because the chaos of Catherine and Heathcliff’s relationship overwhelms everything, but Edgar was also classically handsome like one of those finely carved ancient Greek statues and, like Ashley, he too was old wealth, ornamental, well-bred (perhaps too much so) and had that porcelain-like, delicate beauty and refinement. Literal golden boys.</p><p>They were quiet and passive, suited for reading, intellectual discussions, hunts, balls, and were not built for confrontation. Compared to Rhett and Heathcliff they had the emotional temperature of lukewarm bathwater, although they both can be ice cold. They were blue bloods and embodied that role in their respective societies. And both men were attracted to a fireball.</p><p>Unfortunately for Edgar, he believed he could tame that fireball. He courted her, married her, had a child with her, and never truly understood who it was he was living with but Ashley, for all his faults, was wise enough not to marry Scarlett despite his overwhelming physical attraction to her. He knew she would destroy him; he told her as much when she confessed her feelings for him at Twelve Oaks; he told her that she would be very unhappy with him because she was as passionate and elemental as as storm, capable of tempestuous love and violent hatred, and that she wanted <em>all</em> of a man, his thoughts and feelings, his soul, and that he could not give all of himself to her or to anyone (Ch. 6). Parallels with you-know-who, anyone?</p><p>Edgar and Ashley are beautiful the way a delicately framed watercolor is or a white peacock. Heathcliff is beautiful the way a wolf is: untamable, fierce, and dangerous. He is a storm, a revenant, and a force of nature capable of wreaking havoc and great destruction. He is as gentle as the moors and about as merciful too. (Before anyone gives me flak for calling Heathcliff beautiful, there are a multitude of fictional characters who are physically attractive and magnetic but morally repulsive like Tom Riddle and Dorian Gray and a whole host of others.) Scarlett described Rhett as looking like a pirate and a panther; he was roguish and wild, not shy about his lusts, and he had that same mysterious, dangerous charismatic air going on.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/0*4V9yEmCueD3mHWC-.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*7eSXTGVWJZZ7_US0.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s interesting how the fair and dark contrast is used throughout so much of storytelling: Heathcliff is the tall, dark, well-built, brooding outsider with black hair and eyes just like Rhett was while Ashley and Edgar represent the old, refined, civilized order and embody more traditional Eurocentric features of beauty. (Now I think I am starting to really understand why the casting for these movies is so important. There is a lot of color symbolism going on so the hair color and complexion and look of the actor is not just an aesthetic thing but has narrative purpose.)</p><p>And in these two novels, we have a young, passionate, brunette woman torn between these two men and the worlds they offered her but unlike Scarlett, who does choose who she loves at the end, Catherine lives and dies split. But Scarlett’s dilemma is a human one and resolvable while Catherine’s literally kills her.</p><p>As for Rhett, he poured too much of himself into Scarlett and was burned out by the end. His love was flawed and indulgent; he spoiled both Scarlett and their daughter Bonnie rotten, was afraid of showing any emotional vulnerability to Scarlett, and some of his behavior towards her was cruel. Their relationship was tragic on a human level, ending in the disintegration of a marriage, the loss of two children, and the potential of what could have been a loving relationship.</p><p>But with a man like Rhett, the worst that could happen is what happened between him and Scarlett: heartbreak and a divorce. With Heathcliff, who cannot handle separation or boundaries of any kind, it doesn’t matter how much love and care a normal person pours into him, it will never be enough and he will consume your life. He is like Sethe’s ghost baby from <em>Beloved </em>who drains her and demands endless attention to the point where she is killing her. Just trauma made flesh. It is not because he is inherently evil; it is because he does not comprehend that in real life, he cannot have all of a person all of the time. He will destroy you without intending to because he doesn’t want a relationship or love so much as he wants total fusion; even Catherine, who was the same kind of creature as he was, couldn’t remain unscathed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/473/0*6516UPWSbvOc0SJA.jpeg" /></figure><p>For God’s sake, she literally died and he wouldn’t let the woman rest! Orpheus had to ask for permission from Hades to bring back Eurydice and turn up the charm; Heathcliff wouldn’t ask for permission: he would knock the door to the Underworld down and chase after Cathy and try to drag her back out with zero sense of self-preservation. Even if she were suffering as he does it, he would do it anyways. It’s not because he does not care about her pain; I think he cares but that’s not going to stop him as it would the average person. The man just does not know when to stop. He will never let go even if it means both of them will end up dead. He was happy to be dead at the end not because he had a death wish but because it meant he and Cathy were no longer separated. To care about your own life, you have to have a self to care about and he has none.</p><p>When Rhett finally is open about his feelings for Scarlett at the end of the novel, he tells her that he would have loved her as tenderly and gently as a man ever did love a woman if only she had let Ashley go, but Catherine and Heathcliff’s love, I feel, is not the love two adults have for each other. I liken it more to pre-verbal attachment, the love between children, or that of wolves. I do think Rhett and Scarlett are kindred spirits but they are not the same kind of metaphysical catastrophe that Catherine and Heathcliff were.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/220/0*B7NACwtraiWpJ8DC.jpeg" /></figure><p>When Rhett and Scarlett fight, it’s two dominant personalities going at each other but at its core, they are domestic fights: harsh words are exchanged, jealousy is exposed, people are hurt, accidents happen, there is public scandal and accusations of adultery, and there is sexual tension.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*HXcLVuVMdSeNOIH7.jpeg" /></figure><p>When Catherine and Heathcliff are in the same space together, it’s two fragmented, feral selves trying to fuse back together rather than two fully formed adults having a row. There is eroticism between them in their final scene together but I see that as more of a byproduct of the fusion he wanted to achieve and not the main thing he was going for.</p><p>Honestly, the more I read into Heathcliff and look at his behavior, I am starting to question whether he actually <em>wanted</em> sex and I’m not even talking about with Catherine but with anyone in general. I just don’t see any evidence of a sex drive. I understand that this was written during a time with Victorian censorship but for me that doesn’t explain the gap. And it’s why that grave-digging scene where he digs Cathy up…I read it and I see a lot of things but I don’t see necrophilia.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/264/0*J9Qcw8Ha3n2HcJDf.jpeg" /></figure><p>Back to Rhett. Rhett is a man and he has human limits; the ending to <em>Gone With the Wind</em> is open-ended in that there is a possibility Rhett might return to Scarlett but it’s also just as likely he does not because he was emotionally finished with her. Rhett and Scarlett are a dysfunctional couple with issues that could have been resolved if they had better communication, were willing to set aside their pride, and had better luck with timing. Their relationship was ultimately conditional and breakable.</p><p>I used to think everything was Scarlett’s fault but honestly, both of them had issues. Rhett was nearly twenty years older than Scarlett and was a well-read, worldly man but his behavior was at times quite immature. He ran away from Scarlett after they slept together which I thought was pretty funny, got mad drunk, and disappeared for days; he was afraid to face her because he was scared she didn’t love him. He played emotional mind games with someone he knew was straightforward and didn’t understand subtlety, got upset she didn’t say what he wanted to hear, and just piled the blame on her for not picking up on his signals.</p><p>In my opinion, Cathy and Heathcliff never physically consummated their relationship. But if they had, I don’t see either of them being shy with each other or playing games. It’s not because they are mature or Heathcliff is some kind of Valentino. You cannot be shy with someone who is a part of you. I don’t think there will be peaceful domesticity but I don’t see the type of emotional mind games and avoidance of vulnerability that plagued Rhett and Scarlett’s marriage and relationships happening to them. Rhett and Scarlett were both prideful people with egos to protect. Neither of them wanted to be caught loving the other, God forbid. Cathy had an ego too there were no illusions between her and Heathcliff; they already knew exactly what they felt towards each other. If they did implode, it would be because what they wanted cannot be contained in any kind of human relationship.</p><p>My honest opinion is that no matter what, they would <em>never</em> break it off. They can no more walk away from each other than someone can walk away from themself. There is no condition under which they will accept the permanent dissolution of their bond. There is quite a bit of wolf and dog imagery associated with Heathcliff throughout the text, but while he may be a wolf, or a predator with others, I liken him to a stray dog regarding Cathy. I think he is at least somewhat aware that their relationship is not good, or at least he realizes it is painful and impossible, but he will keep returning to her because that is all he knows. Heathcliff had free will and choices, but not a fair shot. Choices require a self and I don’t think this man ever developed one.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/0*WwKXhNcmeamS945q.jpeg" /></figure><p>In the novel, Scarlett does call Rhett her soul when she is about to lose him and says she cannot bear the loss but she is a survivor and hardy; when she loses Rhett, it is the pain of heartbreak she experiences and regret, not the tearing of her psyche. Scarlett has an incredible amount of resilience; by the age of twenty-eight, she had lost her parents, two children, her best friend, her husband, and her spirit remains undimmed. (She technically loses three husbands, but she did not love the first two so I will not include them here.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*8KKy3FhXpoK2Rr3a.jpeg" /></figure><p>Rhett’s heart was broken by his daughter’s death and he was worn out chasing Scarlett over a span of twelve years, but he had strength left to accept his losses without regret and walk away from Scarlett without looking back. Like Hindley, Rhett drowned his grief in alcohol and it’s more apparent in the novel, but the drinking prematurely aged him and he is no longer the man he once was. Scarlett’s contemporaries considered her cruel and unfeeling for seemingly “getting over” Bonnie’s death so quickly, but I see it as more of a coping mechanism she had to develop over the years to survive all the losses. She cried when her father and daughter died, was genuinely sad when her best friend Melanie died, and she always had to bear up and be strong for the sake of others who depended on her. She could not afford to drown her sorrows and lose herself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*WwyLLrNx9VM4iIBw.jpeg" /></figure><p>She is at rock bottom at the end of the story after Rhett leaves her and is, for the first time, completely alone; in the novel, even her Mammy leaves her after her daughter’s death but she still finds strength and hope within herself and looks towards the future. It doesn’t matter whether Rhett comes back or not; she will find a way to get through this crisis as she did with the many others in her life. Ultimately, these two can live without each other.</p><p>Catherine and Heathcliff, on the other hand, may be physically virile and strong, but they have no resilience or capacity for introspection. Heathcliff did not so much live after Catherine died as he endured out of rage and spite, waiting for his enemies to fall before he collapsed under the weight of his obsessiveness. He barely outlived Edgar by months. By the end, he didn’t even have the willpower to have his own will drawn up. He was as brittle as Catherine was, just in a different way. Rhett and Hindley were heartbroken when they lost the light of their lives; Heathcliff wasn’t so much heartbroken when Catherine married someone else and then died as he experienced total identity implosion.</p><p>Rhett and Scarlett develop as people. By the end of the novel, Scarlett is a very different person from the spoiled teenager she was at the start of the story. She goes from a wealthy, pampered child preoccupied with her dresses and how many beaus she has to losing everything and having to manage an entire household of dependents on her own and rebuild from the ground up with her wits and two hands. She receives a lot of criticism for being a bad mother and while I can understand because she <em>is</em> very self-centered, she did love Bonnie and was excited to have the child with Rhett, which she unfortunately ended up miscarrying. She grieved the loss and there were moments in the novel she expressed tenderness and concern for her other two children. Rhett had a tragic character arc, but it was a complete arc. He loved and lost: what’s more human than that?</p><p>Catherine and Heathcliff did not have character arcs as the two of them remained forever frozen emotionally as kids. Catherine also died very young, so she didn’t get a chance to grow up and be a better person. They both had children but were never parents. Catherine died before she could know Cathy Jr. but I saw no concern or care from her for the unborn child at all during her illness. She became a wife and a mother but that was something she had to do in exchange for the material comforts and status Edgar provided. Heathcliff was legally a father and a husband but they were only roles he had to assume for the sake of vengeance. He didn’t want to be a father or a husband. He only wanted Catherine. Well, he wanted Catherine the feral child, not Catherine, the Lady of the Grange.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/575/0*TOhrPo-zz2PKuk4i.jpeg" /></figure><p>Rhett and Scarlett also had affairs with other people. I would say he fell in love with Scarlett pretty early on in the story, but that did not stop him from continuing his relationship with Belle, especially after Scarlett refused to sleep with him anymore to keep herself “pure” for Ashley. During her marriage to Rhett, it was Ashley Scarlett was fantasizing about while in bed with Rhett, so she was having an emotional affair with him. Catherine and Heathcliff were mutually entangled in life and death so their story was not a case of unrequited desire as it was with Rhett and Scarlett’s. Rhett and Scarlett were tragically misaligned; Catherine and Heathcliff were not. To them, it was the world that was misaligned with their bond.</p><p>Scarlett’s obsession with Ashley is the main reason why her relationship with Rhett ultimately fell apart. Catherine’s marriage to Edgar, which should have ended anything between herself and Heathcliff, didn’t seem to register in her mind as something that should. Part of it was immaturity as she was only a teenager and I thought she was just a monster of selfishness, but I seriously think both Cathy and Heathcliff believed they can just carry on as they always did and that her marriage would have no bearing on their bond.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*XDVChis1S2D_Pvtg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Catherine can have a hundred children with a hundred other lovers and flaunt them to Heathcliff and his feelings for her would not change. He would be angry of course, but I am not even sure he would be angry <em>at</em> her. Being angry <em>at</em> someone has to assume that the other person is <em>separate</em> from you. This is why I feel his whole revenge plot is more than just him being mad at Catherine and wanting to punish her for marrying Edgar, though this was a part of it as well.</p><p>Catherine herself never drew any boundaries in their relationship but if she had, like if she had told him when he came knocking at the Grange: “Sir, I am married; please find someone else,” I think that would have made his brain explode. It would just not compute. I understand why this can be seen as narcissistic entitlement but I see it more as a response from a child who never learned the concept of no. Plus, if he actually <em>did</em> heed her words and try to walk away, she would immediately ask him what he was doing in genuine surprise and tell him to stop that.</p><p>Heathcliff is not the kind of person who can have an adulterous affair. This is not because he is an upstanding guy. He has one axis of existence and that is Catherine. He cannot conceive<em> </em>of wanting anyone else, not even for a casual fling, because seeking out a casual fling would mean him being able to desire someone else who is not Catherine.</p><p>I remember someone asking rhetorically whether Heathcliff had <em>any</em> redeeming qualities because she was just totally aghast at his behavior, and I joked that Heathcliff was loyal to Catherine to the grave and beyond, but this isn’t loyalty so much as total identity fusion. Loyalty implies choice and making a conscious decision to stay true to oneself or another person or cause; he is not making a choice as a person does when he basically goes physically and emotionally celibate after she dies.</p><p>This man is structurally incapable of cheating. I would laugh because this is just incredible.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1f5f9625af4e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mythic Dyads: Across the Moors of Wuthering Heights to Gotham to Supernatural (Part 1)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ashley.tien/mythic-dyads-across-the-moors-of-wuthering-heights-to-gotham-to-supernatural-part-1-4377d104536c?source=rss-1edd7467fe0e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4377d104536c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[wuthering-heights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[emily-bronte]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[batman]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[joker]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ashley Tien]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 14 Feb 2026 11:08:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-14T11:08:02.897Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>A Lineage of Mad Love: Catherine &amp; Heathcliff, Joker &amp; Batman, Rhett &amp; Scarlett, Anakin &amp; Padmé, Sam &amp; Dean Winchester</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/615/0*qBsSEUKw9kxKSTfO.jpeg" /></figure><p>I came across a comment the other day stating that Catherine and Heathcliff are like Harley Quinn and the Joker but <em>I</em> think they are more like <em>Batman</em> and the Joker. Following this, I realized there were other relationships that I felt were comparable to what Cathy and Heathcliff had in terms of passion, destruction, and scale. I will be discussing some of the most intense relationships I have ever seen in cinema and one real-life example so I hope you stick around for the ride; it was fun for me to write and Wuthering Heights has really opened up a rabbit hole for me regarding relationships, how to define love and greatness, the differences between love and obsession and how both coexist in contradiction, and I want to see how far it goes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/617/0*gjqhXRIwSSjEzQSc.jpeg" /></figure><p>The first key difference I see between what Cathy and Heathcliff had and what Harley and the Joker had is hierarchy. The Joker created Harley Quinn, manipulated her into being his loyal subordinate, and he does not see her or treat her as he does an equal. But Batman has a special place in that psychopathic heart of his to the point I have seen videos, analyses, and jokes made that they are more of a couple than Joker and Harley ever were.</p><p>Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*1SA-W5swmtbDPMUI.jpeg" /></figure><p>Even Harley admitted on more than one occasion that it was Batman Joker was in love with and not herself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*1qdESvqZMKLBsdlS.gif" /></figure><p>The Joker monologues about Batman, speaks of him as a jealous lover does when he sees his beloved with someone else, flies into an insecure rage at the idea of villain other than himself killing Batman before he can, he is broken when he dies or disappears, some of his most diabolical behavior is done to get his attention, and even the Batman spoke in the comics of the Joker’s pupils expanding and growing dark with love when his gaze falls upon him and only with him. The Joker never speaks of souls but if he did, it would be to Batman and not to Harley.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*JtDPNAN96bowOudi.jpeg" /></figure><p>During their final duel in The Dark Knight Returns, they literally beef it out in the <em>Tunnel of Love.</em> He can live without Harley, replace her, abuse her, kick her to the curb without grief, but he thrives on chaos and all that fun is over once Batman is gone and he knows it. His wet dream is to be killed by the Batman, to be locked in perpetual battle with him, and his worst fear is to die a nobody and be forgotten by Batman. He wants to laugh <em>with</em> Batman and is in terror of being laughed <em>at </em>by him.</p><p>And just like them, Cathy and Heathcliff saw each other as spiritual equals; she did look down on him, but that was because of his lack of social standing. Their fights do not have that same physical brutality as Batman and the Joker’s but their interactions on the page are no less existentially cutting. Heathcliff is a brutal man; he destroys people’s minds and bodies throughout the novel but she destroys him even as she is dying. I used to think Heathcliff was afraid of nothing, not God, not the law, nor other men, and that he was a man without fear but the more I write about him the more I feel the only thing he was ever afraid of was living without her and in their final interaction together, she ensures that he will not be able to do so because she does not want him to.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/0*Y-OAJxe76CsE86eO.jpeg" /></figure><p>She spoke bitterly of holding onto him until they were both dead and that is what happens; they never stop holding onto each other and he allows her memory to consume him slowly over the next eighteen or so years as he fills the void she left behind with unadulterated, lucidly unhinged levels of slow-bleeding vengeance as he tries to destroy anything and everything even remotely connected to the class and societal structures he believed wronged him and separated him and Catherine, including the boundary between life and death. She has more power over him in death than any living person or God ever had on his mind and soul.</p><p>They are equal in spiritual stature but the Joker and Heathcliff, I would argue, are the “weaker links,” or more dependent, in their respective bonds.</p><p>I used to think the exact opposite because Heathcliff was physically more imposing, the Joker more psychotic in his willingness to hurt and kill Batman’s friends and loved ones just to get his attention, the amount of pain and trauma Batman experienced as a result of that, and how ill Catherine had gotten so soon after Heathcliff returned to Wuthering Heights. But Batman can move on without the Joker, feel relief that his greatest enemy is dead, and retreat into his Bruce Wayne persona as needed and function after the death of his enemy. As for Catherine, she fell ill due to the incompatibility of her split selves but the Joker and Heathcliff have no such split selves.</p><p>They are <em>all or nothing</em>.</p><p>I define who holds the true power in these mythic dyads not by physicality or proclivity to brutal violence, but who defines their <em>entire</em> sense of self through the bond and who cannot survive <em>because</em> the bond is removed and not just <em>if </em>it is.</p><p>If Heathcliff had never come back to the Heights, Catherine would have been very unhappy for the remainder of her life, but she would have lived on as Lady of the Grange. Heathcliff, or Mr. Obsessed here, psychologically cannot and <em>will not</em> conceive of any existence without having ALL of her. Catherine wanted BOTH Edgar and Heathcliff, the material comforts of the Grange and existential fulfillment from the wildness of the moors, while this concept of wanting something other than Catherine is not in his emotional vocabulary. She lived and died split between worlds; he lived and died utterly consumed by her.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*fyeoIuNeJysCTEFY.jpeg" /></figure><p>When Batman dies, the Joker loses all motivation, reverts to being a normal man, or ends up catatonic. The true joy and purpose in his life is gone. Only when the Batman comes back, is the Joker truly alive and excited to see him again even if he knew it would mean death for him or <em>especially</em> if he knew he was going to die by his hand and that sounds a lot like Heathcliff to me. He exists after Catherine dies but is a shell sustained by revenge.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/0*6xdyrj6RBwVldV4o.jpeg" /></figure><p>Lockwood and others describe Heathcliff as “morose” and “stern,” reserved and inert, but he is exultant when dying; he tells Nelly how he was in Hell the entire time and now he felt he was close to Heaven and welcomes Catherine’s presence. He is described as life-like in death because he believed he was finally reunited with her, that she had finally come for him, and released him from his meaningless existence.</p><p>The Joker and Heathcliff have no friends or loved ones; all they have outside of that dyadic relationship are henchmen, servants, subordinates, and others they torment as they wait to see their one and only again. Neither man gives a damn about the future; they don’t care about anything or anyone, not even themselves. Neither wants peace or normalcy, comfort or safety; all they want is the one who defines them, even when it hurts and kills them because they are empty and that emptiness is unbearable.</p><p>That one special person is irreplaceable to them; the Joker can tell if it is someone else assuming Batman’s identity and often loses interest in the fight. He is bored without Batman and I feel the same thing happened with Heathcliff. For all his faults, Heathcliff possessed his own unique charisma, was intelligent and capable in his own way, and even when rude and off-putting, Isabella found him attractive. Even Hindley found someone who loved him but Heathcliff really refused any attempt to seek out any kind of connection, platonic or romantic, after Catherine died. He poured everything into vengeance and at the end, he got what he set out to do, but he was not satisfied because what he really wanted was gone forever.</p><p>These monsters are the more fragile ones in these mythic dyads because they have no selves outside of the bond.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/0*cnmubU97c7rsvwji.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Joker waited for Batman to show up and was genuinely confused when he didn’t; he spoke of the routine they had together. Heathcliff also took Catherine for granted, and so it was so catastrophic for him when she died.</p><p>It’s true.</p><p>If Heathcliff had died after returning to Wuthering Heights and seeing Catherine again, I do believe it would have been a very short novel. Catherine’s mind would not have been able to take it. Heathcliff was physically strong and stalwart so if he did die while Catherine were alive, it would have had to have been a violent or sudden death. Perhaps Hindley shot him on a day he was more sober. Heathcliff would not go down easy so it would have had to have been a violent struggle and death. He hated Hindley so much, I see him crawling on his hands and knees even while bleeding like a pig to make sure this man died with him. At his worst, if this man cannot win, he will make sure you don’t win either.</p><p>If all that happened and by her own brother, I see Catherine going the same way as she did in the novel; she would throw a tantrum and blame everybody, including Heathcliff. She would condemn him for dying and leaving her, just as he did to her when she passed, and make it all about herself. I would have said she wouldn’t have physically hurt anyone because she is not outright physically violent like Heathcliff was but she probably would scratch Hindley’s eyes out for taking what belonged to her and only her. She would cry, lock herself up, deteriorate, and die, except this would be even faster since her other half is dead.</p><p>However, I do not see her enacting vengeance as Heathcliff did on the world if he had been the one to predecease her nor do I see her calling him back from the dead.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Vl_jPAQmt_4RgJVB.jpeg" /></figure><p>Borrowing the “I <em>SEE</em> you” phrase from the Avatar movies, I see that going on with Batman and The Joker and Catherine and Heathcliff.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/220/0*WImPXOpFQKCD8oFh.gif" /></figure><p>The Joker does not speak of souls but if he were to, it would be to Batman he would serenade to about their souls and their mutual entanglement, and not to Harley; Harley, he would swat aside as he does plenty of times. Batman and the Joker, Catherine and Heathcliff, they can do their existential dance forever while Harley and everyone else is left out.</p><p>The Joker also physically abused Harley and tried to kill her many times over; they both tried to kill each other. Heathcliff never physically abused Catherine or threatened her and she was not afraid of him. As for psychological abuse, I have heard some say that is what Heathcliff did to Catherine and it is why she ended up so ill but I feel the answer is more complicated than <em>he just abused her to death</em>. I feel this narrative strips Catherine of her own agency and leaves out Edgar’s ultimatum and banning Heathcliff from the Grange, which directly triggered her into that fit that spiraled out of control.</p><p>It is true Heathcliff’s presence was destabilizing: he was an ass for entering a relationship with Isabella knowing it would hurt her, he was an ass for returning to Catherine knowing that his presence alone would shake her up, and the result was catastrophic but <em>she </em>received him when he asked if he could see her, she invited him over to the Grange multiple times all excited knowing her husband was not happy about it, and her conduct throughout it all towards Heathcliff was enough that a normally chill, passive Edgar felt threatened enough that he asserted himself for once and issued her a real hard boundary that she could not take. During her illness, she lashes out at Edgar and everyone as she chooses to starve herself and lock herself up and hallucinates Wuthering Heights and her childhood; I see her breakdown as a protest against the situation she finds herself in and a refusal to live in this split state any longer.</p><p>It is also true that the Joker does try to kill Batman and hurts him either directly or by hurting his loved ones but the motivation behind the violence is different from the violence he inflicts on Harley. With Harley, it is about domination but with Batman, it is his love language.</p><p>But for real, Catherine and Heathcliff are a mindf*ck.</p><p>For me, what they had feels like love and not love at the same time, not because I<em> don’t</em> think it is <em>not</em> love 😄 but because I feel it is something more primordial and dark, just like the relationship between Batman and the Joker.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/0*sswYB0Nnd5TP4R54.jpeg" /></figure><p>It is between forces in the shape of humans, forces that have no care or concern about the safety and well-being of those around them. They are mutually annihilating and destabilizing to each other.</p><p>I will come out and say it here that I <em>do</em> believe Catherine and Heathcliff loved each other but I do not think they <em>fell in love</em>. They are not <em>in</em> love so much as they <em>recognize</em> each other. They <em>see</em> each other.</p><p>I wouldn’t say the Batman <em>loves </em>Joker either; if you asked him, he would flat-out say he despised the Joker and he has a laundry list of legitimate reasons to do so. Narratively though, the Joker’s chaotic existence is a response to Batman’s logic and obsessive need for order and in a twisted way, I think the latter knows it. There are even some jokes that, apart from plot reasons, Batman does not kill the Joker once and for all because he needs him and they know each other in a way no one else does. (Yes, I know all about the Batman speech where he reasons out to Jason Todd why he doesn’t kill the Joker because he does not want to lose himself to bloodthirst but I mean, come <em>on</em>. With the bodies piling up in Gotham and the Joker breaking out of Arkham every other day giggling and excited at the prospect of going out with Batman again like it’s a murder date, I feel it is less defensible with each passing day).</p><p>The Joker gets under Batman’s skin in a way other villains in the gallery do not. He makes the man dangerously close to breaking his moral no-kill code and lose control, which is his greatest fear apart from losing his loved ones. He is the embodiment of chaos and poses such an existential threat to Batman who thrives on being prepared. Batman has stated that the Joker was his greatest enemy, even though the Joker is only a man with no superpowers. The Joker makes Batman question that assumption though: it is identity-level destabilization.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/685/0*6rWh5AWG0_uQ7bft.jpeg" /></figure><p>Throughout the novel, Heathcliff is emotionally naked in front of and because of Catherine. He is ruthless, utterly without mercy to everyone else, and uses control and an impenetrable, ambiguous persona as a weapon yet this grown, hardened man breaks down and sobs like a child when he calls for her ghost and begs her to come back to him almost twenty years after she died. He does not allow anyone to physically hurt him if he can help it like ask Hindley how that shooting and stabbing attempt went, but he smashed his head against a tree until it bled after she died. Despite being in good health into the beginnings of middle age and always described as physically strong, he cannot maintain basic bodily functions at the prospect of seeing her again in death, and the only instance of sensuality and erotic desire in the entire novel is when he is with her in their final scene together in life.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*0quOkpmq0UUdPiYD.jpeg" /></figure><p>But the same can be said in reverse. There are still occasions where Batman wants to save the Joker, even after everything he has done, and the Joker himself rejects the helping hand as even <em>he</em> feels that he is beyond saving. Batman might look calm and composed but both men are mad and both complete each other. The Joker likened them to two patients in an asylum, with Batman as one patient trying to save the other while being stuck in the same situation, and Batman laughed with him for once, agreeing. That dark, brooding persona cracks in the presence of his greatest enemy and for a moment, they share a twisted type of camaraderie laughing at their entangled fates and the absurdity of the world.</p><p>As for Catherine, she was perfectly fine and healthy before Heathcliff returned to Wuthering Heights. She was a tad melancholy now and then, but nothing earth-shattering and then Heathcliff just shows up and is himself and it just all unravels so quickly. He’s chaotic without even trying.</p><p>There are arguments that Bruce Wayne is the mask and Batman the real man so when they dance, they are being intimate with each other, not in a romantic or s*xual sense but in terms of identity. Catherine and Heathcliff also see each other for what they are. I regularly scroll through comments talking about how awful these two were, especially Heathcliff. They talk about what a<em> brute</em> he is, a thug, how <em>cruel</em> and <em>callous</em>, and how utterly without remorse for his actions, in retort to the idea that their relationship could ever be a love story, and I nod my head to most of the characterizations of Heathcliff because it is true; all of it is true:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/816/0*CjdXGr2A4YsG6tel.jpeg" /></figure><p>He <em>is</em> a brute.</p><p>But he is <em>her </em>brute.</p><p>(Yes, I know the photo shows Catherine Linton Jr.)</p><p>Catherine Sr. knew who Heathcliff was, <em>what</em> he was, and she never asked him to change. She wanted not the man wearing gentleman’s clothes assuming manners, but the rough, earthy stableboy and elemental, cruel, “wolfish” man beneath those layers. She was the only one apart from Nelly Dean who immediately saw through the costume he was wearing when he came back to Wuthering Heights to visit the Grange. Those few years abroad did nothing to fundamentally alter who he was and she knew it.</p><p>Her warning to Isabella about Heathcliff’s true nature was motivated by jealousy and possessiveness, but not a single thing she said about him was untrue. In the next eighteen years after she dies, we see the full ugliness of his character manifest and if it were not for Catherine’s ghost that came calling, I would say Heathcliff would have gone on with the vengeance until the end of his natural life. Forget two generations, he would have stuck around tormenting everyone until Kingdom Come.</p><p>In my opinion, calling Catherine and Heathcliff terrible people and listing out their misdeeds should not end the conversation as to whether or not this is a love story but begin it. Pieces of sh*t can still love each other.</p><p>If it weren’t so f*cked, it would be almost beautiful in a terrible way, that sheer <em>inhuman</em> levels of unconditionality of acceptance: no matter who you are, no matter how terrible you are, I will take you as you are and love you anyways. I don’t think she likes him hurting people and when she was alive, she did try to prevent some of that from occurring. It’s more like she understands where the capacity for cruelty came from and accepts him anyways.</p><p>I see love and obsession thrown around like hot cakes to label their relationship, especially towards Heathcliff, and this essay isn’t so much meant to address that specifically as it is to draw parallels between their relationship and what I see in other media. I feel that the words we have available to normally describe romantic relationships are not enough to encompass what they had and I have looked over them and thought about them so many times these categories have stopped working.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4377d104536c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The horror of Wuthering Heights could have been a CW drama]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ashley.tien/the-horror-of-wuthering-heights-could-have-been-a-cw-drama-43220cd17839?source=rss-1edd7467fe0e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/43220cd17839</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wuthering-heights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[emily-brontë]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[heathcliff]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ashley Tien]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Feb 2026 03:31:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-08T03:31:34.715Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*VAbvLblw90FMw5pZ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Dark humor take: <em>Wuthering Heights</em> could have been one of those sitcom dramas instead of an intergenerational tragedy if things didn’t blow out of proportion. It even has the full-ensemble cast ready to go: Edgar would be the well-meaning, clueless husband not understanding what was going on and hoping his wife would calm down, Catherine the wealthy and spoiled teenage brat throwing tantrums when called out on her b*llshit, Heathcliff the jealous ex glowering silently at doorways like 🙂🔪, Isabella the “I can fix him” girl blushing while doodling love letters and drawings of Heathcliff as he completely ignores her, and Hindley the problematic brother who gatecrashes when drunk.</p><p>And their kids just wonder what the f*ck is going on and why everyone is crying and angry all the time and they decide to get away from this burning dumpster fire of family entanglement and run off in the series finale away from Wuthering Heights and the Grange and seek out new adventures in lands unknown. Cathy Jr. would wonder why this man keeps staring at her uncomfortably while mumbling epithets about her mother, Linton would be in bed trying to read a book of poetry while nursing a perpetual head cold, and Hareton would be the sweet, bumbling kid bringing everyone snacks and utterly oblivious to the drama and passive-aggressive insults Heathcliff tosses at him.</p><p>And Hindley is still alive in this universe; he becomes that perpetually drunk uncle who ruins Thanksgiving and all family gatherings and embarrasses his nieces and nephews but never Hareton who loves him unconditionally and tries to get him to ease up on the alcohol.</p><p>Catherine in this alternate universe still throws her ultimate tantrum and inadvertently dies half-way through the series and instead of moving on to the afterlife, she sticks around for five more seasons causing mayhem and the audience to groan whenever she shows up. She spitefully causes the candles to flicker or the room temperature to drop ten degrees whenever she sees Heathcliff and Isabella together. Like a sprite, she sabotages every relationship he tries to have with other women and tries and fails to get Heathcliff’s attention as he cries over her; I can see her waving her arms and tapping the window telling him to stop crying and that she is literally right <em>here,</em> you fool. Stop crying and grave-digging and <em>pay attention to me!</em></p><p>If he reads a book and puts it down, she makes sure to flip it over so he loses his mark and he frowns and blames it on Isabella; Cathy just sows chaos and pits them against each other until they cannot take it anymore and divorce with her cheering in the background. Then he proceeds to live with her ghost for the next twenty years pretending he hates it but secretly loving the attention and so does she and if anyone tries telling them how toxic this is and that they were better off apart and seeing other people, they freak out and say how <em>dare</em> you and banish the person and then proceed to obsess with each other, whispering endearments, and fall asleep together. Then they proceed to argue again the next day and take pleasure in that too.</p><p>They can insult each other but react like pack animals if anyone else tries to do so to either of them. She will break up with him after each and every fight as he sulks outside but then they get back together less than 24 hours later because their mutual need is greater than their respective pride and anger.</p><p>I guess in the modern day version of <em>Wuthering Heights</em>, she would obsessively check his text messages and after printing out the exact suspicious messages magnified by 1000x on cardstock to show him with highlighted text, she will ask him while visibly jealous and fearful who is XYZ woman he is talking to, if he is cheating on her, why he is growing more distant from her, and he would do the same. It wouldn’t even be anger but just existential panic that the other can have an existence outside of their relationship. She would be angry and jealous Heathcliff had the audacity to have a child with another woman but then get defensive if he pointed out excuse me, she was the one who had Cathy Jr. first.</p><p>In this world, Nelly throws her hands up and finally calls it quits and finds a new job and moves and Edgar too gets fed up and leaves Catherine, taking Cathy Jr. with him and she of course reacts badly losing custody while Heathcliff smirks in the background. Losing custody, Edgar’s money, and the comfort of being the Lady at the Grange would be the things that bother her and not so much losing her daughter.</p><p>I see two possibilities: either they mellow out as they age, or they age physically but stay perpetual teenagers as Heathcliff did and still bicker and fight when they are 90 years old and when one of them dies, the other is broken and takes it as a personal insult they were ditched even if it was literally natural causes. And when they both finally die, the townspeople breathe a sigh of relief, as they were the worst neighbors ever and treat their ghosts like a pair of annoying ghost raccoons. Lockwood freaks out as Catherine throws stones at him from behind for trodding on the same path she and Heathcliff were wandering on and interrupting their daily obsession routine and they just shrug and say: “Oh yeah, that’s Heathcliff and Cathy. Don’t bother with them. They’re always doing that.”</p><p>I can see 5–6 seasons of this playing out and I think it would get mixed ratings from the audience while critics will tear it to shreds criticizing the melodrama, lack of any meaningful character development unless you count them getting progressively more obnoxious, and convoluted plot contrivances. But to the horror of polite society and book purists, it will get its own cult following ten years after the series finale and there will be rampant shipping wars going on in social media.</p><p>There will be video essays released on how toxic the relationships all are but the viewership will remain steady throughout the series, with peaks during the finales as people tune in to see what unhinged shenanigans Catherine and Heathcliff are up to. And it will become a guilty pleasure for many, though they will never speak of it in public if they can help it.</p><p>Season 1 would be the arrival of Heathcliff to the Earnshaw household and the beginnings of what could have been a traditional boy-meets-girl romance set with the bumbling dad and the bullying brother, but Catherine half-way through the first season goes heart-eyes and clasping hands at Edgar, the rich boy, and it angers you-know-who. When she announces her engagement during the season finale and gives the whole Daisy Buchanan “rich girls don’t marry poor boys” speech, Heathcliff rage-quits and runs off.</p><p>Season 2 Heathcliff comes back all sophisticated, handsome, and emotionally unstable as always. He plays hard-to-get with Catherine, flirts with Isabella, and gets into a bar fight with Edgar because he hates the man’s face. Catherine pretends she doesn’t like being the center of attention and having her two men fight over her and drives everyone in the household crazy and she throws a fit with Edgar, who wishes they had never come back from vacation. The Season ends with her gravely ill and Heathcliff losing his sh*t trying to break into the Grange to see her because Edgar called the cops on him and filed a restraining order.</p><p>In Season 3, Catherine wakes up and wonders why everyone is ignoring her and then, a few episodes in, she realizes she is dead and freaks out and she spends the season unsuccessfully trying to elicit responses from the men in her life and everyone else. Season 4 is their children attempting to rebuild haunted Wuthering Heights while dealing with ghost-Cathy frightening all the tenants away and just making the place uninhabitable and whining that she is dead. Once Heathcliff realizes she is actually there and he is not seeing things, he continues to enable her behavior and refuses to let her rest despite the kids and neighbors begging him to let her go.</p><p>He slowly loses his mind throughout the season and in the penultimate episode he forgets to eat and do any kind of self-maintenance because he is too busy obsessing with her and she absorbs so much of his attention too like a petulant ghost baby and so he also ends up dying in the season finale without even noticing. In the last season, the kids manage to rebuild something and the ghosts finally leave and wander off to the moors as they wanted.</p><p>So that was my unhinged black humor take on this story. The discussions about this novel and the relationships in it are almost always so dreary and sad so I wanted to lighten things up for a bit before returning to the reality of the plot.</p><p>Really, the more I look at Catherine and Heathcliff’s relationship and their behavior, the more I can see how childish their emotional logic is: it’s two children play-acting as adults throwing fits because they couldn’t have whatever they wanted and unfortunately, everyone around them pays the price for it. A kid throwing tantrums can be seen as cute but it’s not so cute anymore when two adults do it. If anything, I think this novel shows the importance of setting boundaries early on in childhood. A couple of tweaks to this story’s plot and this could have been a dark comedy or a soap opera instead of a full-on Greek tragedy with a grotesquely high body count.</p><p>I think the ultimate cosmic humor (or horror) in all of this is if we assume Catherine’s ghost really did come back and was wandering the moors for twenty years as she said she had been doing, then really, Heathcliff did all of this for nothing. What he wanted and desired so deeply in his heart and soul was right there in front of him the entire time and he was too blinded by his hate and rage to see it.</p><p>If that does not count as some twisted cosmic punchline, I don’t know what does.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://ardentlyyours2026.substack.com/p/the-horror-of-wuthering-heights-could?r=74ism9"><em>https://ardentlyyours2026.substack.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=43220cd17839" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Moors as God: The Amoral Cosmology of Wuthering Heights]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ashley.tien/the-moors-as-god-the-amoral-cosmology-of-wuthering-heights-0ab3ae3a48df?source=rss-1edd7467fe0e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0ab3ae3a48df</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[emily-bronte]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wuthering-heights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[heathcliff]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-analysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ashley Tien]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 30 Jan 2026 18:17:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-30T18:17:48.487Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>A Love Too Violent for Death (Part 3): The Love of Wolves</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*WHhYzIniJBCc-LR_.jpeg" /></figure><p>The world of Wuthering Heights is a strange place.</p><p>It’s physical and grounded, harsh and merciless as the moors; there is sickness and death and meticulous legal battles and rampant abuse, both physical and psychological. It appears to be a wasteland in terms of human compassion and a cesspool of misery. It’s a world where the least volatile and cruel people appear to be “good” because the rest are just awful.</p><p>This Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.</p><p>Edgar is gentle and a kind father to his daughter but I would argue that he is not a compassionate man and was not built for such. Nelly is dutiful but judgmental, Isabella was sheltered and naive, Linton was too ill to develop his own sense of morality, and Cathy and Hareton…I wouldn’t praise them either as I have seen many others do. Their virtue is that they were simply human in a way their forebears and narrative namesakes Catherine and Heathcliff were not.</p><p>The world of Wuthering Heights seems like just another place where the darkest parts of humanity are laid bare, another godless dystopia. But it’s distinct from the usual dystopia in that it’s one where nature rather than some totalitarian regime reigns supreme and it is a metaphysical wormhole with the supernatural not only present but active in that it actually influences the events of the story and the characters in it. Human emotions seem to hold cosmic power: we see how one man’s will is able to not only break the minds and bodies of those around him, but distort reality, bend it to his will, and collapse the boundary between life and death.</p><p>There doesn’t seem to be any evidence of a traditional, external God: Nelly and Joseph evoke Scripture but it is to judge and condemn Heathcliff and Edgar evokes it too to self-soothe his grief over losing Catherine and to judge as well. There are churches, prayers, and funerals but none of them provide substantive comfort to the living. And I certainly see no forms of divine intervention.</p><p>As I have mentioned before, the novel is <em>brutal</em> in its culling of its characters; people drop dead like flies. We <em>barely</em> get to see the Earnshaw family whole and happy before the parents die. We don’t even get first names for the Earnshaw parents, descriptions of their physical appearances, or how Mrs. Earnshaw died. It’s just a blank. Characters are killed because the narrative just needed them gone and the author does so swiftly with no sentiment. There just isn’t a stable, lasting nuclear family structure.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/0*uoERoBoPCBSOE56K.jpeg" /></figure><p>Under these circumstances, I think it’s understandable why Catherine and Heathcliff became what they did. They were old enough to remember their parental figures but not quite old enough for them to leave a lasting imprint. Even Mr. Earnshaw…I would argue that he was kind for taking Heathcliff in, but he created the conditions under which Hindley’s abuse would flourish and a monster like Heathcliff can be born. He irrationally favored Heathcliff over his two biological children and did not adequately address the growing tensions and abusive behavior taking place between Hindley and Heathcliff.</p><p>He did not integrate Heathcliff into the family by adopting him as a son or at least setting aside money for the boy or even<em> attempt</em> to provide him with<em> any</em> kind of legal protections. He just did a poor job setting boundaries before unceremoniously dying. The only explanation I can think of for this lack of action is Earnshaw did not expect to die. But as the only adult left in the household with any authority, especially after Mrs. Earnshaw passed, and the fact that he knew and witnessed first-hand the bullying going on, he should have known better and prepared accordingly. And judging by the text, it was known in the household that he was not the most robust of men either. Mr. Earnshaw was not malicious or sadistic but passive and passivity can be just as dangerous, if not more so, than intentional harm in this universe. He just dropped off an already traumatized stray boy into an unstable household and hoped it would work out and we see just how well it does.</p><p>This universe punishes people with its indifference and perhaps no amount of preparation would have prevented any of these events from unfolding. After all, Isabella and Edgar both believed they were prepared and what good did that do against Heathcliff, the human embodiment of chaos? He cared as much as the moors and nature did about the painstaking plans of people.</p><p>With the last hope for any normal parental structure dying with Earnshaw, what is left is just this innate <em>void</em> of belonging and no higher figure of authority, whether cosmic or parental, to draw any healthy boundaries. The kids were left to run wild. I would have said they raised themselves but I feel there wasn’t any raising done at all unless you counted occasional chastisement from servants that they never internalized anyways.</p><p>They looked across the aisle at each other and didn’t see a separate person as defined by societal roles of any kind, like brother, sister, friend, playmate, lover etc: they just see themselves, or the parts of themselves they need to feel and <em>be</em> whole.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/214/0*Uq79tSwQ-1n0kNYz.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong><em>One self in two bodies.</em></strong></p><p>And this, I feel, is the crux of their relationship and their tragedy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/0*kGIRhiEI1rxj19dT.jpeg" /></figure><p>The closest thing to God and divinity in this world seems to be the moors. And only Catherine and Heathcliff were so connected to that place in both life and death. It was their playground and Paradise, their mother and father, the closest thing they had to God, and the only true freedom and happiness both of them ever knew in life. But the moors are not kind: nature is beautiful in a wild way, but it is also merciless in its indifference and amoral. Nature does whatever it does and does not abide by the laws of men and those are the values Catherine and Heathcliff internalized as children and lived by as adults. The moors offered them absolute freedom and so how can they possibly live amongst people after experiencing that? Freedom without boundaries becomes annihilation.</p><p>Their Paradise is defined by the absence of everything that makes a society liveable and so their love reflected that inhumanity.</p><p>Their lives in society boiled down to them trying and failing to regain this lost Paradise as reality and structured society collided with this Eden. Catherine attempted to keep it alive by refusing to choose between society and her wildness and Heathcliff attempted to do so by breaking down all barriers between himself and Catherine by sheer force. Both methods only resulted in the destruction of themselves and everything around them. They only reclaim this Paradise in death and it is not a soft, redemptive afterlife but an amoral one; they didn’t earn this haunting by being “good” people. Societally genteel and “proper” people like Edgar and the Lintons and everyone else who believe in this social order and traditional religion receive nothing on a cosmic level. They live and die, leaving no spiritual imprint.</p><p>Heathcliff and Catherine got to be endless liminal beings because their love was violent enough to warp reality and I think just as importantly, or even more so, there was no resolution to their relationship in life. Everyone else’s stories were sad but complete: Edgar dies peacefully, having done his duty as a parent with his worldview intact, Isabella dies resigned, believing her son is safe, Hindley dies destroyed, Frances dies frightened in her love’s arms, and Linton dies miserable but finished.</p><p>They all died human deaths and none of them had a crisis of self-hood like Catherine and Heathcliff. None of them wanted to continue on and none had that primal connection to the moors. In his last breath, Edgar evokes Heaven, the traditional Christian form of continuation, but there is no evidence a traditional Heaven exists in this universe and the Heaven he evokes is one of closure and rest.</p><p>Catherine and Heathcliff did not want to have closure or rest. Neither of them expressed any guilt or remorse for any pain they caused to other people and to each other. They lived their lives answering to no one but their own desires and died the same way, beholden to no higher authority. Both of them rejected traditional forms of religion and did not wish for ascension: they wanted to be bound to the earth and to the moors and to each other forever.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/193/0*9MVCJWo4oypp2FJG.jpeg" /></figure><p>One of the only times I felt anything towards Nelly was when she was imploring an already unhinged and dying Heathcliff to repent his sins and convert to faith. Even after everything he did, she still hoped he could redeem himself even if it was only via a deathbed conversion. To no one’s surprise, Heathcliff refused because by his own logic, selfish as it is: why should he? He was going to get what he wanted the entire time: Catherine. This is why I feel, at his core, once you strip everything down, his true motivation was not revenge: it was to be with Catherine. Once Lockwood told him about Catherine’s ghost, the man took no more interest in his vengeance and unraveled.</p><p>Why did it take Heathcliff eighteen years to see and feel Catherine’s presence again in totality? He was consumed by rage and anger against the world for taking Catherine from him but he was also angry at <em>her</em> too, cursing her for leaving him behind and that anger, I believe, clouded his perception. He was out there, wandering around the moors after she died and could not see her and he recounts to Nelly how he had raged over it for years. They were both lost in different ways: he was still, to his grief, anchored to the physical world while she was lost in between worlds and he did not provide a point of contention for her to break through. His rage was still too raw and loud and her spirit lost and confused. It was not until Lockwood came along that she was able to finally penetrate. And once Heathcliff let go of all earthly concerns and he was basically in a liminal state as well, a dead man walking, then he finally was primed and ready to see her again.</p><p>Once his rage was spent and everything else was gone, all he had left was Catherine and not even grief for her either, but just pure longing. Edgar grieved and so did Hindley and Cathy Jr. for their lost loved ones but Heathcliff never did. He never accepted the reality of her death and treated it as another barrier he can still bypass if only time would grant him the opportunity. This denial of reality could have been a coping mechanism to deal with the magnitude of what he had lost when she died, but he really believed it was only a matter of time. There was not a moment he doubted Lockwood that Catherine had come back to him. It was only a bad dream for Lockwood but everything to Heathcliff. Everyone else feared these hauntings but not he. He never lost faith and would take any form of existence so long as it meant he would be with her.</p><p>Edgar and Heathcliff would hate to have anything in common but both longed for Catherine and expressed their desire to be with her again. But Edgar dies happy and relieved; he is at peace while Heathcliff dies ecstatic and consumed. Edgar grieved his wife: Heathcliff lost his soul. One was a widower believing he would see his beloved wife again; the other a living wound returning to wholeness. One dies with his daughter, the embodiment of the future, by his side and with her love, the other dies alone disintegrating into the past.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*0GNXs3s_k23yZFw3.jpeg" /></figure><p>I found it notable too that Catherine’s spirit manifested itself in solid form to Lockwood but when Heathcliff was seeing her at the end, she did not take physical form and to Nelly, it was as if he were seeing things. My initial explanation was just that Heathcliff was losing it and seeing sh*t that wasn’t there. The man was obviously unwell and the lack of food and sleep didn’t help matters. But I think the reason Nelly was unable to see anything is, for one thing, Nelly is one of the most grounded and human characters in this novel. She is an adherent to the social, class, and religious order of this world: basically everything antithetical to what Heathcliff and Catherine abided by. She would never be one to encounter anything supernatural.</p><p>Furthermore, Lockwood was in a state of sleep and hysteria and fear when he came into contact with Catherine while Nelly was her usual daytime self so two different states of mind. I guess it’s like a radio signal; Heathcliff and Lockwood were on the right wavelengths while characters like Nelly were not and never would be. And again with the NDE’s, people who have experienced them treat them as if they are real even if they have no rational explanation as to why they feel that way; they just <em>know </em>and the same goes for Heathcliff here. It did not matter to him whether or not he had proof this was real: he <em>knew</em> he was going to see Catherine again and that was all that mattered to him and all that ever did.</p><p><strong><em>One self in two bodies.</em></strong></p><p>He did not need to see her the same way others see to know she was there. Their relationship was not contained in the flesh but the soul and his soul was leaving his body. Edgar believed that Catherine’s soul was waiting for him in Heaven but Heathcliff perceived that her soul was here the entire time because <em>he</em> had called her back from the great beyond, binding her to the earth and to him. Only he was privy to that knowledge and so Lockwood’s claims that Catherine Linton had come knocking were proof enough. Heathcliff despised the Linton name and what it represented but he did not care that Catherine’s spirit identified herself as that name at all; she was Cathy to him and that was what he called her when he went looking for her, because what did names matter at this point?</p><p>I wouldn’t say there is <em>proof</em> of the supernatural in this story but there <em>is</em> impact. It touches people and changes them in a way all the Scripture quoting from Joseph and Bible-thumping from Nelly never did. Lockwood, the rationalist, claims to not believe any of these rumors and appears to have remained unshaken by what he experienced with Catherine’s spirit yet the man admits he was wary of wandering around after dark where the boy spotted Heathcliff and Catherine. Nelly says the dead are at peace and no longer walk the earth but that’s Nelly. She would never admit it was a possibility, even if she did believe it. She just wanted it to be over.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*LVpcUVCsnNw46gZP.jpeg" /></figure><p>Going back to Edgar, all I am thinking is that this man really got ditched in the afterlife. The discussions I encounter online and in-person about ghosts and the supernatural in the story revolve around Wuthering Heights as this ghost wormhole and Catherine and Heathcliff, but Edgar deserves some attention too: he really died believing he was going to see Catherine again in Heaven. Little did he know that she had explicitly rejected such an afterlife in favor of returning to the moors and, by extension, to Heathcliff instead. I guess the term “ditch” is not quite the right one since it implies she ever belonged to him in the first place and she fundamentally didn’t. He had her body in life, the earth had it in death, but Heathcliff had her soul.</p><p>Edgar and the Lintons just fundamentally are not a part of the moors and anything close to the naturalistic “God” of this world so it makes narrative sense they are not even on the list for consideration for ghosthood. It’s also probably for the better because I don’t think he would have liked being a third wheel even in the afterlife.</p><p>Edgar Linton is not my favorite. I feel some are too easy on him just because he appears to be harmless compared to more openly volatile characters like Hindley, Heathcliff, and Catherine, but he had it rough in life too and his death was hastened by grief. And in the afterlife too, if there is one, he and his beloved wife will never be together. There is no evidence to suggest her ghost was privy to the nearly twenty years of grief he also carried after her death and his visiting her grave every year until he was too sick to do so. And even if her ghost did know, she did not have the capacity to care due to her longing for Heathcliff.</p><p>The man had just wanted a peaceful, quiet life and he couldn’t even have that. I guess he dies peacefully, but it’s also from exhaustion. (But for real, the Lintons <em>all</em> seem to get sick and die except Cathy Jr. and her vitality comes from the Earnshaw half it seems.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/0*TCjsC0Z54zlPVLyp.jpeg" /></figure><p>I was actually surprised Heathcliff didn’t try to dig up Edgar’s grave and have him moved. I wouldn’t put this guy above anything. He is petty and childish: he swapped out Edgar’s hair for his in Catherine’s locket when he was alone with her body. I am starting to try to move away from viewing Catherine and Heathcliff’s relationship in sexual terms, but I am not going to lie and say that Heathcliff <em>wasn’t</em> salty Edgar and Catherine were having sex but I think the jealousy he had is different from the usual “another man is sleeping with my girl”-type jealousy. I don’t think what this trio had is a typical love triangle, either. I guess that can be its own post. The only reason I can think of Heathcliff not bothering with Edgar after he died is that Edgar just <em>doesn’t matter to him.</em></p><p>All that mattered to Heathcliff was being able to access Catherine. Lingering on Edgar’s death, even to take joy in it, would just take away time and energy from obsessing over Catherine.</p><p>As for Heathcliff digging up Catherine’s body, I <em>will</em> comment on that and all the necrophilia allegations. Before I took a dive into the novel, all I had were the movies and comments sections to refer to, and the impression I got was that he did unspeakable things to her body but after actually looking at the text, I just see something sadder.</p><p><strong><em>I saw a man who didn’t fear death so much as he feared separation from Catherine.</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0ab3ae3a48df" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Wuthering Heights is a Godless Purgatory]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ashley.tien/wuthering-heights-is-a-godless-purgatory-88492b937d8f?source=rss-1edd7467fe0e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/88492b937d8f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[wuthering-heights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[emily-bronte]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gothic-literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[heathcliff]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ashley Tien]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 18 Jan 2026 01:16:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-18T01:16:49.195Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/0*wcYo0guAzHTMBK86.jpeg" /></figure><p>Wuthering Heights is a strange place.</p><p>The world of Wuthering Heights seems to be a type of Purgatory; it’s not a literal one in the religious sense, but it does seem to be a voluntary one. Apart from Wuthering Heights, Thrushcross Grange, and the moors, the outside world seems to just not exist or, at the very least, the outside world cannot penetrate the hermetically sealed chamber of misery and destruction that is this cursed trio.</p><p>There are characters who come and go but they are few and far between and apart from Lockwood, their fates are not cheery. Isabella manages to escape but unceremoniously dies off-screen; the best she gets is a temporary respite from Heathcliff’s abuse and Hindley’s alcoholic chaos. Frances comes in out of nowhere and dies trying to bring life into the world, and Heathcliff was injected into the system but ultimately rots and dies there too. It seems only Lockwood is allowed to walk away free and that’s only because he had no real emotional entanglement with the main cast and he leaves changed as well. Even Cathy and Hareton remain bound to this place and they’re supposed to be the closest thing to rejuvenation and redemption this world has to offer.</p><p>Even the marriages in the story are stilted; the only fresh outsider blood injected into the gene pool are Heathcliff and Frances. And Heathcliff’s line dies out in one generation, his relationship with Catherine only destroys instead of nurtures and can never produce life under the circumstances they were living in, and Cathy Linton Jr. marries <em>both</em> of her first cousins. The “happy ending” marriage is literally incestuous. And if the theories that Heathcliff and Catherine are in fact half-siblings are true, then we have a third incestuous pairing.</p><p>And I can’t believe I almost forgot this but the <em>names</em>. The names literally repeat themselves in the text to the point where I have seen some get confused over who is who; Cathy and Hareton are supposed to be the ones who break the cycle but the similar names just make it seem like it’s all one closed circuit. I feel like some Rust Cohle comments would come in clutch in this world and he’s not even a true nihilist. Apologies for the True Detective reference. I feel like even that series has at least one clean victory against an objectively “bad” guy while there is literally no such victory here and the first season of True Detective is famous for having an openly nihilistic character.</p><p>I forgot about Nelly. She and the other servants survive too, courtesy of being spectators to the misery and not direct participants. I hear some say that Nelly is a moral character and is the closest to a good person in this work. I don’t think she is morally good so much as she is socially good. She is a servant and knows her place and understandably just wants to keep her head down to survive. She doesn’t partake in the metaphysical madness that is Catherine and Heathcliff’s relationship and issues verbal judgements and reprimands of the characters for their abusive behavior but she also doesn’t do anything substantive to stop these wrongs. She cannot given her place on the social hierachy but even if she could, I don’t think she would. I call her the watcher. It’s her job to bear witness and to tell the story but only to those she deems fit and who cannot disrupt the status quo.</p><p>It is why she will never bequeath the truth to Catherine Jr. or Hareton or any of their descendants. The knowledge will die with her and she only told Lockwood because she knows he is a mere drifter through a show that is already over.</p><p>This story seems to put forth the idea that it is ignorance and not inquiry that is the only thing that saves the next generation from imploding. I was left dissatisfied with the ending because I guess my personal idea of redemption is to have characters self-examine or have the supporting cast do the same and there is nothing like that in this story; nobody cares <em>why</em> Heathcliff became the way that he does and he himself doesn’t do any sort of questioning. There is no justice in this world, either in life or on a cosmic level. The characters and even the audience just see the cruel behavior, many condemn it, but no one is able to actually do anything about it, and it’s just a waiting game for the monster to die. No one saves Cathy and Hareton from Heathcliff; the man just logged out of the game entirely without any real remorse. He just got tired of his own self-perpetuating misery.</p><p>The <em>closest</em> I got to feeling any real justice was reading Heathcliff beating the <em>sh*t</em> out of Hindley and him doing so bare-handed and with a rock while Hindley was armed with a pistol and knife. The asymmetry of it was satisfying: the abused finally beating the abuser not with manipulation but with just raw, retributive violence. But the moment passes and even Heathcliff himself doesn’t seem to take real joy in it, considering he had just lost the only person in his life he had to live for and the man he beat up was already broken; this was literally beating a dead horse. Because Heathcliff’s vengeance against Hindley is honestly at the end of the day redundant and unnecessary: the man was broken after his wife died and even if Heathcliff had never come back, I would say Hindley was not going to live past middle age due to the alcoholism and self-neglect.</p><p>I feel there is no closure or catharsis in this novel, only a sigh and silence after Heathcliff finally dies but it’s an eerie, ambiguous quiet with the possibility of ghosts hanging around. And again, as I have mentioned in my very first Substack essay, I do not see the Cathy x Hareton pairing as truly resolving anything because there is no fundamental questioning of the class system that produced this much pain for the first generation of characters. They even move into Thrushcross Grange, for Heaven’s sake, the embodiment of civilized social order while wild, untamed Wuthering Heights is permanently boarded up! The best the new generation can hope for is to forget the ghosts of the past and damage control.</p><p>Even Catherine’s and Heathcliff’s relationship, narratively speaking, I feel, has no closure either. Unlike the movies and fan art, the novel does not explicitly show them walking together like full-bodied ghostly lovers, kissing and holding hands as it did in the 1939 and 1992 version; all we have is possibility. They may very well have both died and just vanished into nothingness like everyone else so all that passion and famous soliloquies they uttered were meaningless.</p><p>I can see why some may think this work is nihilistic because there is no divine presence, no cosmic rewards or punishments for good and evil, and the suffering doesn’t produce anything. Even Heathcliff’s revenge, which takes up half the literal book and takes up as much time as Catherine literally was alive, ends in nothing substantive except ensuring that everyone around him, except for the kids die before the age of 40. And he did all of this just so he can end up dying like a dog, obsessing over a dead teenager.</p><p>I will comment upon Heathcliff’s vengeance in the future because I have seen comments stating that his revenge was futile. I agree it was futile in the sense that all his efforts ultimately dissolve into nothingness; he spent twenty years trying to take revenge and at the end, it’s all for naught as he gains no real satisfaction even as the people he hated die off, the two properties go back to their rightful heirs, and he never gets what he really wanted in life: Catherine’s soul. But I don’t think revenge is necessarily about the outcome; from my point of view, the act of taking revenge itself can be where the true meaning lies in a world with no meaning.</p><p>Even if Catherine and Heathcliff were granted this ghost haunting, they are both free and yet stuck forever. They are free in the sense that there are no longer any societal boundaries keeping them apart the way they did in life; race, class, gender, and last names don’t matter in death. She no longer has to struggle with her Earnshaw-Linton-Heathcliff identities and Heathcliff himself no longer has to bear the permanent outsider status. There are no names out there in the moors: they are finally free to just be Catherine and Heathcliff. But their relationship never grows and never will; it just goes on forever, repeating. They aren’t whole spirits either but just renmants of primal longing.</p><p>The ghost haunting is not redemptive or a reward: it’s a product of two people who just couldn’t let go. There is no reconciliation or true peace or forgiveness; they go to their respective graves with core issues unresolved. The last moments they shared in life are passionate but there is no clearing of misunderstandings or any new revelations. All I saw were just two people tenderly tearing each other to shreds.</p><p>I did wonder why Bronte had Catherine die the way that she did, with Edgar by her side, but her not recognizing either man or even the birth of her own child. She was ill and unconscious and near death, of course and Edgar would never allow Heathcliff in the room with her in that state if he could help it, but why have them be apart at such a crucial moment when the two were fused emotionally from childhood? She died at the Grange too, far away from the moors she loved and was hallucinating about during her illness. When Heathcliff goes in to see her body later on, there is a complete blank as to what he does with her and only that one detail that he puts in his own hair into the locket. But even those efforts are thwarted by Nelly and the three are jammed together too in death, side-by-side.</p><p>In the 1939 movie especially this is <em>so</em> changed. Heathcliff and Catherine’s conversation is a lot softer like lovers and she tells him explicitly that she will come and find him again out on the moors and she gets to have a look at the moors as she dies and she dies holding him. Heathcliff is not kicked out of the house like he was in the novel and I would say the two here were reconciled; at the very least, Catherine’s heart was not split. She says Edgar is “very dear to her” but Heathcliff is “her being” so I think that speaks for itself.</p><p>Edgar also didn’t comment on Heathcliff being in the room either in the 1939 film which was convenient. He would have killed him in the novel though and that would have been nice. Not going to lie, I did wish there was a fist fight between Heathcliff and Edgar. I wouldn’t have minded if Heathcliff had just come back to Wuthering Heights, beat the crap out of Hindley and Edgar in some bar fight, and ditched. For me, it’s not even Heathcliff against two guys he disliked but a systemic fight like the racialized outsider against the wealthy elite. Assault and battery is bad but it’s still better than twenty years of slow bleeding.</p><p>In the novel, anytime and <em>everytime</em> Heathcliff tries to be close to Catherine in adult life, they are interrupted and perhaps that was necessary. If they had been able to talk things out productively and she die in his presence as Frances did with Hindley, there wouldn’t have been that lack of closure necessary for their ghosts to return. Their relationship I would argue was never consummated to the degree that either of them wanted, physically or otherwise, and that deprivation they both experienced in their souls and psyches was what generated the longing necessary for them to stick around.</p><p><strong><em>Regarding the Townspeople’s “Ghost” Sightings:</em></strong></p><p>I have also changed my view about the townspeople’s gossip. I thought for years it was just gossip and therefore meant nothing, but upon reading it again, one thing I found significant about these stories is that they remain quite consistent. The truth is so easily warped, especially as it passes from mouth to mouth but here it was always a man or a man and a woman together and when a man’s name is mentioned they always specify Heathcliff too: I don’t see any evidence of any embellishment. When the townspeople report seeing them, their testimony is repetitive and almost rote, like they are just a part of the landscape and not some cosmic horror dripping blood or gore and Heathcliff’s name is mentioned but not Catherine’s which was interesting. I guess the reader doesn’t need a name drop to know which woman they are talking about because again, what other woman in the story can it be?</p><p>One thing I do wish was confirmed was whether or not the townspeople gathered and gossiped together about the ghost sightings or whether the sightings were independent. I feel like we don’t receive confirmation either way. It’s a small, isolated town so I can infer possibly that the sightings were independent as people were just walking around but since it is a small town, these sorts of things spread like wildfire and I think it’s reasonable to suggest that when these rumors spread they mutate which was not the case here.</p><p>The text also never identifies an exact origin point of these rumors either, like a specific townsmember who first reported the sighting; the rumors seem to sprout up organically on their own and none of these people knew of Heathcliff and Catherine’s love and intimate connection of the moors yet some of the testimony claims to see them there.</p><p>If someone could talk to that sheep and those lambs that were freaking out, then we can get the truth.</p><p>But what do you all think? Let me know. I was going to make this into a single essay but it seems a Part 3 will be coming up! I’m also getting better at separating my paragraphs: I didn’t realize how crammed it was getting!</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://ardentlyyours2026.substack.com/p/wuthering-heights-is-a-godless-purgatory?r=74ism9"><em>https://ardentlyyours2026.substack.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=88492b937d8f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Love Too Violent for Death (Part 1)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ashley.tien/a-love-too-violent-for-death-part-1-03276f383ea2?source=rss-1edd7467fe0e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/03276f383ea2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[emily-bronte]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wuthering-heights]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ashley Tien]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 07 Jan 2026 14:37:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-07T14:37:13.969Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Is the haunting in Wuthering Heights literal or metaphorical?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/465/0*19nQDRJiIBk_CCS3.jpeg" /></figure><p>Looking back, I realize just how much my understanding of this novel was shaped by the movie adaptations of this work. I personally have watched the 1939 and 2011 movie adaptations in full thus far and parts of the 1992 one and I realize why cinematic adaptations are so important; they are not only movies but influence the way the audience, including myself views the original work. Now I can better understand why people express such strong opinions about narrative and directive choice, casting, and tone changes because these movies can alter living memory.</p><p>For one thing, there tends to be a <em>lot</em> more body contact or physicality between Catherine and Heathcliff in the films than in the book, which I will elaborate upon in upcoming writings and the scene with Catherine’s ghost was altered in these adaptations, I assume to make it easier for audiences to understand. It was cut entirely from the 2011 version, which seems to be more of a bleak realistic take on the novel and deemphasizes the metaphysical Gothic parts of the work. And so many of them cut the second generation entirely and soften the portrayal of the characters. And due to Lawrence Olivier’s performance, I had forgotten the very real possibility that the OG Heathcliff did not look like a conventionally handsome, brooding white man with dark hair and eyes.</p><p>Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.</p><p>Commenting on the 1939 version specifically, I actually originally thought Catherine’s ghost or phantom called for Heathcliff when she returned to Wuthering Heights but looking at the text, she does beg Lockwood to let her in but she doesn’t <em>actually </em>specifically ask for Heathcliff. I assume every word was carefully put pen to paper by Bronte so that omission had to be a deliberate choice. And it’s interesting too that Heathcliff automatically <em>assumed</em> Catherine’s ghost was indeed coming back and seeking <em>him</em> out after just being told it was her ghost, and the man never actually questions that assumption; Lockwood didn’t say she was calling for him and only said the ghost of Catherine Linton had been there. And the 1939 movie also did not have Cathy’s ghost identify herself as Catherine Linton; she just said it was “Cathy.” And at the very end of the film, the movie actually shows the ghosts walking together superimposed on the moors while it was just gossip and rumors in the book.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*wATE-8Ity-KZTiu_.jpeg" /></figure><p>In the 1992 version, the ghost appears as this luminous spectral thing; it reminded me of Corpse Bride and again, at the end of the movie, there is little ambiguity. Catherine and Heathcliff’s spirits are out on the moors and there is kissing and hugging like all the traditional cinematic romantic gestures. I get it: if the movies just relied on rumor as the books did, I guess the director thought that wouldn’t be very cathartic or theatrical and movies need to communicate impact, hence all the body contact between them.</p><p>I will admit that my initial reaction reading the supernatural encounters in the novel after watching the movies was that of disappointment. I was and still am one of those readers who did hope for some kind of spiritual reunion after death simply for the sake of some narrative payoff after so much pain, but the ambiguity inherent to the text and sparseness of it just makes the possibility of that payoff that much more tenuous. At least, that’s what I originally thought and am still struggling with the idea that what is <em>not</em> said and depicted in the text is as important as what <em>is</em> said and depicted. I assume the author assumed the reader was intelligent enough to fill in those gaps. I guess I also got too acclimated to seeing literal physical ghosts on screen and fever dream flashbacks due to the multitude of horror movies I have seen during my life.</p><p>I was inspired to write this essay because I honestly had taken it for granted that Catherine and Heathcliff reunite after death. But I did speak to some people who said the haunting is more metaphorical than literal. I did counter with Lockwood’s testimony. The rumors from the townsfolk I can dismiss as gossip and superstition since they probably were just bored and wanted drama, but Lockwood had no personal connections to either Catherine or Heathcliff and had no motivations to lie. He was also a grounded, rational person. But in response, I was told that while all of that is true, he was in a state of hysteria and fear and delirum when he was in Catherine’s room that night so he was probably just seeing things as a result of his mental state. I thought that was a perfectly valid comeback and I thought all my hopes had just vanished, but speaking as a non-spiritual person, I actually think the characters being in a delirium when this supernatural stuff happens does not mean the stuff ISN’T legit.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/724/0*q4MNKDrnaQ3rOaHm.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Because</em> Lockwood was in that state of delirium, his rational mind was temporarily unmoored, making him susceptible to supernatural encounters. There is a reason why people who are grieving and wanting to see their loved ones again see and hear their loved ones shortly after they die via visitation dreams; sure, it might just be their brains showing them who they want to see, but I also think people have to be ungrounded from reality in order to see such things. I just don’t think, for instance, you would be seeing your departed loved ones during a boring corporate office meeting on Monday morning.</p><p>But when people are dying just as Heathcliff was at the end of the novel, their minds detach from the physical world which is why dying and very sick people see loved ones who have passed on. Near-death and end-of-life experiences are real, documented phenomenon since antiquity, even if the interpretation of such experiences is up in the air. And I have yet to see any of them deny that the experience is happening; some deny the spiritual interpretation of said experiences, but many who have undergone NDE’s describe them as being more real than real, which can explain why Heathcliff never questioned whether these visions were real. I don’t know if Bronte had NDE’s in mind when writing <em>Wuthering Heights</em> but I guess it doesn’t matter. More importantly, while Heathcliff doesn’t believe in God, he did believe in Catherine and their bond. That was the only thing real to him. He didn’t pray to God but he did to her.</p><p>I think it’s significant she first appeared to Lockwood, an outsider, and not to Heathcliff. I would personally find it less credible if the latter were the one who encountered the ghost first because he already was looking for her everywhere, but Lockwood didn’t want to see any ghost. He just wanted to sleep. He also heard the ghost identify herself as Catherine Linton when he himself admitted in his thoughts that he remembered the name Earnshaw more; it could be a trick of the mind or something real. I wonder what would have happened if Lockwood had allowed her ghost to come inside Wuthering Heights but I guess that would have ruined the ambiguity aspect of all this.</p><p>I did wonder why Catherine took so long to appear but I guess it took Heathcliff 18 years to be able to see her again because he was too fixated on revenge and the material world during that time after her death and so he was not ready to let her in. By that time though, pretty much everyone he was trying to avenge himself on was dead and his vengeance was starting to spend itself. Lockwood was receptive to her but rejected her and even then, she still was scratching outside but as soon as Heathcliff stormed in all angry, she vanished and did not appear again even when he called for her. I thought that was narrative trolling, but I guess even with his longing for her, he still was a part of the world of the living. He had to let go of revenge completely first.</p><p>The Earnshaw-coded folks (dark hair and eyes) tend to be virile and healthy and violent in direct contrast to the Lintons who are fragile and fair and restrained. When an Earnshaw-coded person snuffs it, it is due to self-destruction. Hindley and Heathcliff have a lot in common: the two men’s lives mirror each other in many ways and Heathcliff basically becomes an arguably more premeditated, crueler version of Hindley after he loses Catherine. Hindley abused Heathcliff and they hated each other so there was no way the two men would have been able to come to any kind of reconciliation but both men lost their fathers and the women they cared about and both never adjusted to that loss and ultimately destroyed themselves. It was too bad neither were able to put aside their grudges for their own sakes.</p><p>But Heathcliff’s rage and grief are fundamentally different from Hindley’s and those differences explain why Catherine and Heathcliff were able to remain bound to the earth after death while Hindley and Frances do not. Hindley did love Frances but his love for her was that of a very flawed man’s. It was human love. After she died, Hindley accepted she was gone. He obviously did not cope with it well as he drank himself to death but that basic reality of her being dead and lost forever he never challenged. He grieved for Frances in a self-destructive way while Heathcliff never accepted the reality of losing Catherine to Edgar and then to death at all: he bent it to his will and never really went through any sort of traditional grieving process.</p><p>Hindley numbed himself with drink while Heathcliff never did so; he literally made grief and rage his life and allowed it to corrode him from the inside out without any anesthetic. I find it notable about Heathcliff’s character that, for all his flaws, he never indulged in vices such as alcohol or gambling, nor did he appear to be a lustful person. Hindley lashed out over his grief and insecurities using physical violence and then weapons while Heathcliff, who is not above using physical violence, he, to my knowledge, never actually used conventional weapons to hurt others at Wuthering Heights and there’s a cold, psychological edge to his violence that Hindley never had.</p><p>And like Hindley, Heathcliff and Catherine both self-destructed. Their deaths mirror each other: they both die the same awful way via self-neglect. These were two healthy people so it was a slow, painful death. Heathcliff got what he wanted but it makes me wince when I see comments stating that they were happy or relieved Catherine died because she was only a teenager and suffering too. They both had to lose their minds over each other before they can cross over.</p><p>Morbid me wondered why Bronte had them die in this specific manner rather than something like suicide, but I think apart from needing Catherine Linton Jr. to live and possible censorship laws, their deaths are like a messed-up form of spiritual cleansing. They both had to burn through their bodies and burn through everything that made them a person until only their raw longing was left behind.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/708/0*-6u6yWVrAW1Vbs_J.jpeg" /></figure><p>Heathcliff was indeed unhinged at the end so it’s possible he was just hallucinating but I see it as him returning to his truest self. Dying people don’t think about their paychecks or petty disputes; they fall back on what is primal and most important to them and it’s often love and relationships and regrets and Heathcliff does the same. When he is dying, he does not think about revenge anymore because that was never his core I would argue. I read many folks say this is a story about revenge not love and I understand since his revenge schemes literally go on for half the novel. But, in my opinion, his revenge was merely a tool. It was a response to his rage at the world and losing Catherine; when all that anger and hate was stripped away, all that was left was his longing for Catherine. He always hated any boundaries between himself and Catherine and the last boundary he needed to do away with was life itself.</p><p>And there’s the issue of timing I have touched upon but not addressed yet. It’s true: Catherine had been dead for 18 years by the time she banged on that window but her ghost said she had been a waif for 20 years. Now, Catherine was stuck in a liminal space between life and death and seemed to be in as much torment as Heathcliff was alive; I don’t think she would be keeping an exact tally of the time she was stuck in beyond the veil. Eighteen years or twenty years would feel the same for her so this slight discrepancy in time is something but I don’t think it automatically blows a hole in the theory of the supernatural being real. It just leaves it ambiguous enough so that there’s room for interpretation. And looking closer, it wasn’t Catherine who said the twenty years time frame first: it was Lockwood. He said he wouldn’t allow her in even if she begged for twenty years and she latched onto that time stamp and repeated it. I don’t think a ghost would have access to any kind of clock, physical and internal, and all she knew was that she was just out there lost for a long time.</p><p>Lockwood sees and feels a hand and sees a child’s face but doesn’t go more in-depth as to exactly how it looked like. He was probably too freaked out to really remember how the liminal being looked like, but I just feel that ambiguity is baked into the text, even down to the characters’ physical appearances. For example, even after decades of debate, we still don’t know precisely what Heathcliff actually looks like. We have charcoal sketches and speculation. And as for her looking like a child and describing herself as a “waif,” a term used to describe a lost kid, it makes sense. Catherine and Heathcliff’s love was quite childish in many ways. Her ghost is not a complete person because Catherine in life had lived and died fragmented, and it wasn’t the lady of the Grange Heathcliff wanted or called back but only the distilled essence of her longing for him and that longing manifests as a kid because that’s where their relationship had frozen emotionally. They really don’t spend much time together as adults and it shows.</p><p>I’m just going to pause for a bit here and say that I wasn’t sure if ghost was the proper term for what she is because ghosts are incorporeal but what Lockwood sees at that window has just enough physicality that it blurs the line between ghost and flesh. And phantoms I feel are too insubstantial to describe what she was but rather than repeat liminal being a dozen more times, I will just use ghost.</p><p>Catherine’s ghost starts bleeding when Lockwood saws her arm on the window pane and she bleeds<em> a lot</em> like there is blood dripping all over the bed. The interesting thing about the blood is Lockwood seems to see a lot of it but when Heathcliff came in, he didn’t remark on seeing any such blood. I guess ghost blood doesn’t obey the laws of physics or Lockwood might have just been seeing things but when Heathcliff finally lets Cathy into her room at the end of the story, his arm too was grazed by the same window but unlike Catherine’s ghost, he has no blood because, unlike her, he has fully passed on and there is no life left in him. Cathy’s ghost shows up too during a snowstorm and Heathcliff dies during a rainstorm…there are just too many details and narrative symmetry to make me think this is all a coincidence.</p><p>As touching or maybe as awful as it is, when she asked to be “let in” to her home because she was lost, the work didn’t need to specify that she was calling for Heathcliff because while it’s true she lived and died at the Grange, her true home was at Wuthering Heights, and with Heathcliff. After Heathcliff dies, no such haunting is reported again at Wuthering Heights. The place was permanently boarded up at the end because there is no more use for that place for both the living and the dead. Both Catherine and Heathcliff had unfinished business and so were lingering there but once he joined her, neither of them will be bothering the living again because they are finally at rest.</p><p>Narratively, the two of them were so obsessed with each other, I think it makes sense the universe made an exception for them or more accurately, Heathcliff forced it to; Heathcliff literally tore a hole in reality, calling for her spirit to come back and haunt him, and he was the only one recorded in the story to do so. He violated the boundary between life and death multiple times, which is the direct opposite of what a loved one would normally do, since I assume most people would want their loved ones to be at peace. But if he had been at peace with her death, he would not have called for her, and she never would have come back. And if she had been at peace, then she wouldn’t have come back, even if he had called her so that mutual obsessive longing was necessary.</p><p>The part that did confuse me at first was Catherine’s dying was painful but when she actually did die, she was described as looking beautiful like all her tension gone and she did not die calling for either Heathcliff or Edgar or anyone. So if that’s the case, then why did her ghost come back if she died peacefully? The only answer I can think of in the moment was that the tension between her selves was never actually resolved; the physical torment ended with her life but her body and soul remained split.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*vNZVSlKXgEo7Vnls.jpeg" /></figure><p>At the end of the novel when Lockwood is hanging around the town, he did encounter a boy who was freaking out about encountering these ghosts. I don’t buy necessarily what the boy is saying, but it did also state that his sheep were also unwilling to wander to where the boy encountered the ghosts. I found that notable since people can lie or be mistaken but animals don’t lie and can sense things humans cannot and even Lockwood the rationalist was wary of going into that area too. I am not sure if Bronte intended for any reader to fixate on that specific detail about the sheep but I couldn’t help but do so even if it might not mean anything at all. I initially discounted the town rumors as just superstition and the people just wanting a bit of gossip to entertain themselves, but this one tidbit of evidence I do consider to be substantive.</p><p>I was going to include everything in this one post but I feel this is getting long so will split it up. I hope you join me for Part 2!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=03276f383ea2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why I’m Writing an Essay Arguing That Wuthering Heights Is a Love Story]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ashley.tien/why-im-writing-an-essay-arguing-that-wuthering-heights-is-a-love-story-52db67893e3b?source=rss-1edd7467fe0e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/52db67893e3b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[romance-novels]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[emily-bronte]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wuthering-heights]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ashley Tien]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 05 Jan 2026 18:08:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-05T18:08:59.600Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Oh boy…what have I gotten myself into?</p><p>My ultimate plan is to eventually write an essay as to why I think Wuthering Heights is a love story so that should be fun. And to tell you all the truth, it is actually a reason why I started this Substack at all because debating people about it on Youtube and Discord just wasn’t doing it and was devolving into personal attacks. I plan to split it up into multiple parts if necessary because I do want to take an in-depth look and compare Heathcliff and Catherine’s love because they are two flavors of the same madness. I had to build up a lot of courage to do this because I didn’t realize how split the literary fandom was on this question and I realize I am taking the more challenging position. I wasn’t even trying to be a contrarion either; it really is just the position I hold (to my woe lol). You have no idea how many times I got accused of somehow liking abuse and romanticizing abusers and supporting stalkers and a whole <em>list</em> of other things I will address in that future post.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*iNrUL3Jq75UjQxzq.jpeg" /></figure><p>If you really think about it, that’s a crazy thing to accuse someone you don’t know and have never met before. I know it’s the Internet and people just say what they want to say and the anonymity emboldens them, but people need to be more thoughtful over what they say to the other person on the other end: the person you accuse of liking abuse for all you know experienced abuse in some form themselves. Trying to understand the root causes of abuse in<em> fictional</em> characters and seeing this as more than a pure victim-villain story is not endorsing abusive behavior.</p><p>Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.</p><p>If I wanted to say this was <em>not </em>a love story, I would say the essay would just write itself. It would be <em>very </em>easy. I’m taking the harder route because it is what I genuinely believe. If I am the only person in this world who holds this position, it’s fine by me because I love this story even if it gives me indigestion and heartache by the end of it. I am trying to basically explain whether two awful, self-absorbed, destructive people loved each other. I hope someone reads it in full even if they end up hating it and I appreciate any comments. I guess even if someone hates it enough to read through it all and leave an angry comment, it shows they engaged with the work and I appreciate that. I actually learned a lot debating with people about this very question and it has helped me grow as a writer and a thinker too and see how people’s personal life experiences and relationships shape the way they answer that question and view these characters. I only wish Bronte had lived long enough to see what an impact her work has had on audiences centuries later.</p><p>I’m not going to lie and say at times I wasn’t questioning my own sanity too lol. These are <em>very</em> difficult people to sympathize with haha. I can load a million negative adjectives in front of their names describing their reprehensible behavior even while feeling for them. I see comments stating that they are awful and toxic and deserve each other and I’m like: yeah. They <em>would</em> agree this is the best they can hope for and they don’t want anything else. And I think that’s pretty tragic actually, seeing two people reject healthier options that were available to them not because they were ignorant of them but because they were both drawn to something that’s not good for them and that’s so tragically human.</p><p>I can see why Nelly and the other servants didn’t want to touch this with a ten-foot pole. Sometimes the best way to deal with this madness is just to keep away from the immediate blast radius and pray you don’t get sucked in. I’m happy to see constructive criticism, even if it might sting and I will be glad to take a look at what I missed and improve upon it and I can potentially make other posts addressing those points.</p><p>I will have to re-read this novel before I write this particular essay and I also will not be looking at essays that have been written about this question because I want it to just be pure me.</p><p>Ultimately, I think those accusations I have been receiving in comments online stem from just psychological discomfort. It’s much more psychologically comfortable to view things in simple moral binaries, aka what I would call the Edgar Linton point of view. I can label Heathcliff evil and incapable of love and call it a day, so I can live in peace. In real life, that <em>is</em> a real necessity and a survival mechanism and in the novel, Edgar and everyone else who isn’t Catherine and Heathcliff had to do so in order to move on. But the novel and my mind and I guess Heathcliff won’t allow me to do that.</p><p>I suppose if I were Isabella or basically anyone in this novel who isn’t Catherine and maybe Nelly Dean, then it <em>would</em> be a binary thing. All I would see is this brute hurting me for reasons I cannot understand and do not care about. I wouldn’t care about his abusive childhood or his pain. Unfortunately, I am the reader and I know too much. Like audiences who saw child Anakin Skywalker and child Eren Yeager before they grew up to be monsters and Heathcliff here, I saw these characters back when they were still pure and there was still hope of saving them and I had to watch as every single chance to save them or for them to save themselves and choose differently evaporate and all of them choose self-destruction.</p><p>I think Heathcliff doesn’t give a single sh*t if someone hated him. But if someone understood the real Heathcliff, that pathetic boy underneath all that cruelty, then that<em> would</em> mess with him. He understands cruelty and hate as his own personal language and becomes the embodiment of it. He never shows any doubt or hesitation when hurting Hindley but when confronted with real love and vulnerability or if anyone happens to call him out on his b*llshit to his face, it destabilizes him.</p><p>Final point: it might just be the fandom or maybe all the videos I have been watching have skewed comments sections because I know many times the most vocal people are the ones who comment, but I feel that Anakin Skywalker and Eren Yeager, who are literal genociders and child killers, receive more sympathy from audiences than Heathcliff does which baffled me at first. I would also argue that Anakin and Eren receive more mercy too from their respective universes and their authors. At the very least, those two men received much more merciful deaths than Heathcliff did. I think I am starting to ramble now but my point is I find all of this interesting and these are all questions I will be wrestling with. Trying to answer the question of whether or not Wuthering Heights is a love story opens up other cans of worms and I am looking forward to it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=52db67893e3b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>