<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Alison C. Traweek on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Alison C. Traweek on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@atraweek?source=rss-45e929ca496f------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 05:38:59 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@atraweek/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[To the students in my race classes, in response to the White House Conference on History]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@atraweek/to-the-students-in-my-race-classes-in-response-to-the-white-house-conference-on-history-cc8bc5a6605d?source=rss-45e929ca496f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cc8bc5a6605d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[usa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-race-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alison C. Traweek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Sep 2020 21:44:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-18T02:54:34.009Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The White House today held a conference on American history at which a number of historians and politicians — including the president — disparaged critical race theory and declared it unpatriotic. Because the way I teach race is heavily informed by critical race theory, I want to push back on that claim, and explain to you why I believe it to be the only responsible way to teach the subject.</p><p>Critical race theory (CRT) is not a particularly radical idea: it’s an interpretive framework (interpretive framework = the sources you use, the questions you ask about the subject you’re studying etc.) that investigates how race intersects with power. For example, using CRT, a historian might might notice patterns of disenfranchisement in certain communities that are relevant to current social power structures (e.g., systemic racism). After the Civil War, for instance, former slave owners were paid $50 ($800 in today’s money) for every one of their now-free formerly-enslaved workers; the newly freed people, however, were given nothing. Obviously ending the system of enslavement was good, but our failure to then ensure that the newly free population could prosper is still echoing through our social policies and realities in problems like the racial wealth gap (on average, white families in America have about 10 times the wealth of black families).</p><p>Here are some things CRT is *not*: an attempt to make white people feel guilty; an ideology putting white people at the bottom of a racial hierarchy; an emphasis on the bad elements of American history while ignoring the good; unpatriotic. I share with you one of my favorite quotes, from the great James Baldwin: “I love America more than any other country in the world and, exactly for this reason, I insist on the right to criticize her perpetually.” The ideals on which our great experiment America was founded — we are the first country that we know of ever to have been built intentionally and on ideas! Noble experiment! — the values at the heart of this country are deeply humane and admirable; our ability to achieve them has been more modest. But nothing is more American than criticizing the country to move it closer to those ideals of democracy and equality. The arc of history does not bend towards justice on its own: we have to push it.</p><p>Historians informed by CRT do not downplay or erase the positive aspects of American history (or any other history, for that matter), but we think doing responsible history means knowing about *all* of it. Later in the semester when we talk about how classics influenced race theories in early modern Europe and America, we’ll talk about people who believed that black people had a higher pain tolerance — which is still with us, because a terrifying number of medical students *still* think that black people feel less pain than other people (about 25% of med school students, according to one study I’ve seen). This leads to awful and deadly race disparities in health care delivery. For instance, the maternal death rate for black Americans is 2–6 times that for white Americans. And wealth and fame don’t protect you: Serena Williams almost died after her child was born because doctors weren’t listening to her or believing her pain. This is also one important reason that black people and other non-white people are dying at a significantly higher rate from COVID-19. CRT-informed history helps us understand the social forces that got us where we are, and thus allows us to think more clearly about where to focus efforts to improve our society.</p><p>I was extremely anxious all summer about teaching race in this particular moment when, as we’ve discussed, race is basically a partisan political issue: just today FBI Director Chris Wray told Congress that the vast majority of domestic terrorism in America is rooted in white supremacy. White supremacy is on the rise around the world, and it typically goes hand-in-hand with authoritarianism, because it needs to strong-arm other narratives out of the history books. Two of the primary hallmarks of an authoritarian government are to restrict and discredit the press, and to limit people’s knowledge of history to only the parts they can feel proud of. I continue to be deeply alarmed about our government’s willingness to do both of those things, particularly in the last few years; at the White House Conference today, the president described a new curriculum that he believes should be instituted across America that is a “patriotic education” (his words, to be clear), and said that any schools that teach CRT should receive no federal funds.</p><p>In normal semesters, while students can probably guess what my politics are (as you can too, probably), I make a valiant effort to be non-partisan. With race being a partisan wedge issue right now, I can’t do that. To put it generously, our current administration’s vision for society has a great deal in common with white supremacist ideology. It has been conclusively established, for example, that the administration stopped worrying about formulating a plan to manage COVID-19 when statistics showed it was overwhelmingly affecting non-white people: that is white supremacy. With the remarks at today’s conference, I decided it needed to be part of the conversation of our class, because it is a direct attack on our whole project for the semester.</p><p>I encourage you to seek out videos from today’s conference. As a historian and a teacher, I believe it can only be good for you to encounter conflicting ideas and arguments. We’ll spend a few minutes at the beginning of our next class talking about this.</p><p>And, as I will no doubt do many more times this semester, I remind you to check your voter registration, make a plan to vote, and follow through on it. I usually suggest that people vote for candidates who believe in science, but today I’m going to suggest that people vote for candidates who invite you to engage with the full history of humanity, with all its hideous failures, with all its breathtaking beauty and simple goodness. History is your inheritance.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cc8bc5a6605d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Medusa and the thousand yard stare]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@atraweek/medusa-and-the-thousand-yard-stare-bb2cec01027a?source=rss-45e929ca496f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bb2cec01027a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mythology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rape]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alison C. Traweek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Jul 2019 04:57:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-18T17:09:42.418Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="Caravaggio’s Medusa (1595) (via Wikipedia)" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/935/1*O_GLnDVchYMNpbcUaycxIw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Caravaggio’s Medusa (1595) (via Wikipedia)</figcaption></figure><p>Tell someone to think of the Gorgon Medusa and they will go to snaky hair and baleful eyes — her most salient features in ancient Greece and Rome as today. They will likely also imagine a hostile and aggressive creature, a hunter of men. But none of the ancient evidence supports this. While there are minor variations, every story told of her presents her as essentially a hapless victim. <a href="http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus:abo:tlg,0020,001:276">Our oldest account appears in the poetry of Hesiod</a> and is just a brief description of how she, with immortal parents and sisters, was unaccountably mortal and doomed to suffer death, which for her turned out to be decapitation at the hands of Perseus.<a href="http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Ov.+Met.+4.786&amp;fromdoc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.02.0028"> Ovid’s account</a> is the most familiar, and describes how she was raped by Poseidon and subsequently punished with a deadly gaze by Athena for having allowed the rape to happen in the goddess’ sacred precinct.</p><p>In many of the visual representations, she is shown literally sleeping as Perseus sneaks up on her with Athena’s help. The closest we get to female agency in this story, really, is in the action of her sisters, who pursue Perseus as he flees with the head. They never catch him, but their attempt becomes an origin story of mourning song and a poignant embodiment of helplessness in the face of death.</p><p>Medusa in contemporary culture has long been associated with women’s rage, which is entirely a modern take on the story. While no version of the myth from antiquity could be interpreted to suggest that she earned violent retaliation by her own actions, it would be irresponsible at best to argue that she was any kind of <em>avant la lettre</em> feminist icon for Greek or Roman women, a container for the rage their relatively powerless social status gave them no other outlet for. There are acknowledgements of various kinds about the injustices of the extremely patriarchal systems of Greece and Rome, and of the costs that system exacted on men and women alike, but I don’t think any extant evidence would allow us to make a claim for some mythic archetype of righteous female anger.</p><p>Still, it is impossible to ignore the gendered axes of the violence that clusters around Medusa: there are no indications of her being a danger to women, for instance, only to men, and it is only men who harm her, never women.</p><p>(We’ll leave aside the question of Athena’s gender and role in harming her, and let the goddess’ own gender-related arguments from <em>The Eumenides</em> stand in here for now.)</p><p>So it is understandable that Medusa has become one face of women’s fury in response to toxic masculinity.</p><p>(We’ll leave out also for the moment that her fertility, too, is forced on her entirely by male violence, initially by Poseidon’s rape, then by Perseus’ decapitation: the former impregnates her, the latter forces parturition even as it kills her.)</p><p>In any case, Medusa has clearly become a kind of shorthand for women’s righteous and retaliative anger against male violence, particularly since feminism took on Freud’s <em>vagina dentata</em> and penis envy and all that. But mostly, in her original context, she’s just a lady who attracts the unwanted attentions of a god, who as a consequence of rape becomes accidentally dangerous to men, and who is killed because killing a dangerous lady will make an otherwise mediocre man into a hero and a king.</p><p>But as I study the myth, I can’t help but see in her a darker reflection of our era. Yes, Medusa is just minding her business, not intending to harm anyone, not particularly interested in the affairs of men — yet men arrive to traumatize her. Hers is not only the gaze of righteous, powerful, efficacious rage, but also the exhausted, arresting, shell-shocked stare of trauma.</p><p>Women are angry now, yes, but we are also so, so tired. Tired of being asked to share our pain as a means of proving our humanity. Of being asked to listen to graphic stories of men harming women in the interest of giving “both sides” a fair hearing. Worn out by being asked how we feel about Christine Blasey-Ford’s earnest and human testimony against Brett Kavanaugh’s red-faced ranting, and even more so by in depth comparison of this affront to the Anita Hill and Clarence Thomas indignity. Steamrolled by stories of men abusing “underage women” who, at 13 and 14 years old, are more accurately called “children”. Assaulted daily by our visceral understanding that the most powerful man in the country believes we are beneath contempt.</p><p>Medusa just wanted to be left alone, as far as I can tell, and would have enjoyed a quiet simple life on the far side of the world with her sisters, visiting periodically with the Graiai and venturing into the Land of Dreams when the spirit moved her, but men ruined that for her. Whether it be Roy Moore, or Bill Cosby, or R. Kelly, or Jeffrey Epstein, or George Nader… or small-time players like Brock Turner and his ilk, or closer-to-home (for a classicist) figures like Holt Parker…</p><p>This endless stream of predatory men whose humanity and career prospects we must carefully weigh before we pass judgement on them for harming women and children is exhausting.</p><p>It should give pause to all the #NotAllMenners out there that Medusa is an ancient and enduring archetype, because she is also the perfect encapsulation of a woman being attacked and abused through no fault of her own, and then being vilified for having been abused. There is nothing a woman can do that will inoculate her against the violence of men.</p><p>Men, we are not trying to turn you all to stone and make a statue garden of your suffering. We are just trying to live. It is at best frustrating and at worst debilitating to be a woman in this world.</p><p>Would that we had the petrifying powers of Medusa.</p><p>For all the good they did her.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bb2cec01027a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Simple Satisfaction of Historical Complexity]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@atraweek/the-simple-satisfaction-of-historical-complexity-c35af905311c?source=rss-45e929ca496f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c35af905311c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[civil-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[american-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alison C. Traweek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Jul 2019 03:45:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-16T03:28:43.548Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/220/1*ixN2y1yaaZS7qjjez0etUQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/409/1*gWkt7HmW6SmKZuhnK8A0YQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sojourner Truth (left) and Frances Dana Gage (right)</figcaption></figure><p>I finished the draft of my latest suffrage bio this weekend, just ahead of my July 15th deadline.</p><p>(I try to embody Neil Gaiman’s three rules for writers with solicited pieces: (1) do good work; (2) have it in on time; (3) be easy to work with. Hasn’t failed me yet.)</p><p>I was assigned to Frances Dana Barker Gage (1808–1884), and she is my second favorite of the four or five bios I’ve done for the various and interrelated woman suffrage bio projects I’ve contributed to. Gage, a white woman, was raised in Ohio, which was essentially still the frontier in her youth (Ohio gained statehood in 1803 but its constitution was still being drafted in the 1850s). Before what she refers to as the War of Rebellion (which was sometimes, in my younger days in Texas, called the War of Northern Aggression), Ohio was a free state and in many ways a utopianist experiment (provided you didn’t ask too many questions about the Native Americans, who were not awarded the same compassion as enslaved and formerly enslaved Black Americans by most people) (to put it mildly). Gage’s family lived in an area that was a regular thru-way on the Underground Railroad, and throughout her childhood Gage and her family actively sought to do what they could to help escapees.</p><p>Her real activism, however, didn’t start until the late 1840s, when all 8 of her children were past their toddler years. It began primarily as a writing campaign, as she was far from the east coast centers of women’s suffrage activity, but in 1851, she was selected to chair the Ohio Women’s Rights Convention in Akron. It was only Ohio’s second convention and had few big names, but it was to become very famous for one particular star.</p><p>It was during this convention, at a contentious event vividly recalled in her 1863 memoir <em>Reminiscences</em>, that Gage, with the power to decide who was allowed to speak and who wasn’t, chose to give the floor to Sojourner Truth, against prevailing opinion. In her <em>Reminiscences</em>, Gage records Truth’s short speech in heavy dialect, and makes the centerpiece of it the moving claim, “Ain’t I a woman?” This was to become, in mainstream history, Sojourner Truth’s most iconic and recognizable moment.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*D77bESltiOgdUAJXYTVTlw.png" /><figcaption>Gage’s version of Truth’s speech (1863) (via Wikipedia)</figcaption></figure><p>Its popularity was no doubt aided by the fact that Elizabeth Cady Stanton included Gage’s account in her 1881 <em>History of Woman Suffrage. </em>Stanton’s authority helped make Gage’s version canon, and essentially erased from history an 1851 transcription published, with Truth’s approval, by Marius Robinson. Robinson’s version of the speech was not only <em>not</em> in dialect — which makes sense, given that Truth spent most of her life in New York and never lived in the South, and that in fact her first language was Dutch, not English — but was in Standard American English, and, while it touched on many of the same details and themes as Gage’s version, it entirely lacked any such phrase as ‘Ain’t I a Woman?”</p><figure><img alt="Robinson’s version of Truth’s speech (1851)" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zjqh-Y9ssl1eTJE-1jcvtg.png" /><figcaption>Text of Robinson’s version (1851)</figcaption></figure><p>Truth did not leave us a transcription in her own writing, as she was illiterate, but she did approve Robinson’s version before publication — and then also approved Gage’s version for inclusion in the 1867 edition of her <em>Narrative</em> (essentially a context-specific early genre of autobiography for formerly enslaved Americans). So which version did Truth actually say?</p><p>Historian Nell Painter has written extensively on this comparatively minor controversy, and her work is excellent and important, even 20 years on. But Painter was interested in recovering something about Truth as the human who lived a life, whereas I, because of my particular assignment, am thinking about this from Gage’s side: given that Truth likely did <em>not</em> speak in heavy Southern dialect, why did Gage choose to represent her as doing so?</p><p>The answer, I think, is that Gage, like any good activist, knew a useful symbol when she saw it. Truth almost certainly didn’t say the words that Gage reports her saying in the way that Gage reports it, but obviously the spirit was close enough for Truth herself to approve it. And why?</p><p>I suspect that Truth also understood her symbolic value, and knew that her actual English would not have ‘read’ as the language of an enslaved Black person.</p><p>(Was it accented? Was she a non-native speaker? What did the English of a New York born, native Dutch speaking, Black American formerly enslaved person born around 1800 sound like?!)</p><p>I suspect that both women knew, whether or not they discussed it explicitly, that they needed to catch the ear of a white audience that was not prepared for a complex, sympathetic Black person, and believed that making Truth into a stereotype, beneficently, was the quickest way to achieve their goal in this instance.</p><p>We can never recover Truth’s actual speech, of course, but it probably lived in the middle ground between Gage’s likely exaggerated record and Robinson’s likely adapted one. My journey down the rabbit hole with Gage has convinced me that she made whatever adjustments she made in the earnest belief that she was presenting Truth as more sympathetic and was strengthening their cause, but it is always worth remembering that simple stories are usually too good to be true, and the truth is usually too complicated to be simply told.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c35af905311c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I argued with a Trump supporter today. It went about like you would expect.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@atraweek/i-argued-with-a-trump-supporter-today-it-went-about-like-you-would-expect-6d03efff5d9d?source=rss-45e929ca496f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6d03efff5d9d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[immigration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[america]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[refugees]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[detention-centers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alison C. Traweek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Jul 2019 00:50:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-04T02:54:57.658Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2Q0P4DpByYSjCHkY4173qA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Protesters in Philadelphia march against the detention camps for migrants</figcaption></figure><p>Although I loathe protesting, I went to a protest today against the detention centers where we’re keeping migrants. I am always a reluctant protester — they are so crowded and noisy, two of my least favorite things — so my compromise is that I go there to be a body. I do not chant, and I do not carry signs. I be a body. I contribute to crowd size for the optics.</p><p>So I was a body at Philadelphia’s regular <a href="https://twitter.com/tuesdaystoomey?lang=en">Tuesdays with Toomey</a> gathering, which was specifically directed this week at bringing attention to the horrors of the detention camps and calling for closing them down. I was not really paying attention; I couldn’t understand the speakers very well, and anyway I was pretty sure I was already on board with whatever they were saying — like, a pediatrician at one point said that babies should get medical attention when ill. Hard agree.</p><p>But a quiet, dissonant note got my attention, and I looked up to see an old white man walking through the crowd. I was, unsurprisingly, towards the back and, as he passed the last few protesters, he chanted softly, cautiously, almost whispering, “<em>Trump 2020, Trump 2020</em>.” The family next to me and I looked at each other and shrugged, noting that at least he seemed afraid to be too open about it.</p><p>Eventually the rally became a march from Senator Toomey’s office at 2nd and Chestnut St. to Independence Hall — obviously a salient metaphor. It was only a few blocks away, and it was the direction I needed to go in any case, so I walked quietly along, being a body for the cameras. As we turned up 3rd St., I noticed a middle-aged white guy in an Eagles jersey standing on the sidewalk screaming at us. He was extremely angry about us. I was perplexed by someone being that enraged by people positioning themselves as anti-putting-people-in-cages.</p><p>Other than those two men, the people out and about in Old City were largely on our side, with many honking car horns or stopping to applaud or nod or raise a fist in support. So there’s that, at least.</p><p>I don’t get down to Independence Hall that often, but I always love being in the park around it. It’s a major tourist destination, of course, so the whole area is packed with people of every stripe, and the air is a rainbow of accents and languages. But a thoroughly Philly voice caught my ear as we marched along. While the chanters chanted “Close the camps! Close the camps!”, one woman was sitting on a bench and chanting, “Keep them open! Keep them open!” Unlike the Trump 2020 guy, she was putting an exclamation point on her chant, and clearly had the courage of her convictions.</p><p>It literally stopped me in my tracks because I couldn’t make sense of why anyone would be pro-detention centers of <em>any</em> kind, let alone ones as dangerous and cruel as we know our current centers to be. But she was perfectly happy to let it be known that she was proudly pro-camp.</p><p>So I asked her, “Why do you want to keep them open?” Her answer (and I am paraphrasing) was that, without the camps, ‘they would just be <em>out there</em> (*waves arms around vaguely*)’. She used the term ‘middle’ at one point, as in ‘getting into the middle of the country’, as in the migrants wouldn’t just be at the border, but would make it all the way to Kansas and Nebraska, I guess, which is somehow worse than being in Texas or California?</p><p>Reader, I did not change her mind.</p><p>Our argument was predictably circular and frustrating. She argued that we needed the camps to keep track of the migrants and not let them get into the middle. I countered that we had a (<a href="https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2019/06/trump-child-immigrant-detention-no-toothpaste-obama.html">not very great!</a>) old system that <a href="https://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2018/jun/26/wolf-blitzer/majority-undocumented-immigrants-show-court-data-s/">did <em>not</em> involve detention</a> and was actually <a href="https://www.cato.org/blog/alternatives-detention-are-cheaper-indefinite-detention">cheaper than detention</a>, and that we could go back to that system.</p><p>She pushed back with how they shouldn’t be coming in illegally anyhow. I told her that my husband was an immigration attorney, and hit the high points of <a href="https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/research/asylum-united-states">the entirely legal asylum system</a> that most migrants attempt to move through.</p><p>She said they were just coming here for a better life (which I guess is bad, somehow?), and it wasn’t actually dangerous at home, they just wanted free stuff (her examples of said free stuff included food stamps and health care). I explained that it <a href="https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/central-americas-violent-northern-triangle">actually was quite dangerous in many of these countries</a>, and people were indeed at risk of being tortured and killed.</p><p>She pointed out that it wasn’t as bad as Nazis. I asked her if she thought it was right that <a href="https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/us-government-turned-away-thousands-jewish-refugees-fearing-they-were-nazi-spies-180957324/">we sent boats full of Jewish refugees back to Europe in the years leading up to WWII</a>, before the Nazis were as bad as the Nazis.</p><p>She didn’t give me an answer on that one (in her defense, it’s not an especially relevant question, but she did bring up the Nazis, so I felt it was fair game), and circled back to one of the previous arguments. And so it went on, with her being angry and afraid and me being genuinely puzzled. At one point I actually tried the thing that incurable optimists always suggest: find a point of commonality, emphasize it, and build trust from there!</p><p>So when she said she just wanted people to follow laws, I jumped on it. As it happens, I <em>also</em> like the concept of laws! I am downright committed to there being some sort of system of laws keeping our society reasonably ordered, and I am pretty into people mostly abiding by that system! So I told her, “I want that too! We <em>both</em> want laws and an orderly society!” and waited for the common ground to expand.</p><p>Instead, she went with questioning whether or not asylum is actually a legitimate legal thing. (I promise you it is.)</p><p>Eventually, after enough circles through the same arguments, with her giving me no facts and refusing to believe anything I said (including whether or not I was truly pro-law) (I am), I told her she was wrong and walked away while she was still arguing about them getting into the middle or whatever.</p><p>It was decidedly out of character for me to stop and talk to a stranger, especially one who vocally disagreed with what I see as a pretty black and white moral issue. And I don’t know what I expected —not that I was going to get her to join the march or anything, certainly. But despair has been sneaking in around my corners lately (<a href="https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/44392/carrion-comfort"><em>not, I’ll not, carrion comfort, despair, not feast on thee!</em></a>) and I guess I felt that, when confronted with someone doubling down on an explicitly pro-camp take, doing <em>something</em> was better than doing <em>nothing</em>?</p><p>Maybe I thought that our conversation — which really did remain civil (at least for two Philadelphians) (we’re a passionate people) — would plant a seed? Would be a little Socratic gadfly driving her to look further into the matter, to learn, to become informed about all those issues she was so diffusely angry about? Or even that I might learn something from her, gain some insight that would help me understand and consequently change the hearts of people as frightened and furious and uninformed as her?</p><p>Obviously that didn’t pan out. When I turned to walk away, she was suggesting that maybe we needed to change the definition of asylum so that it ‘doesn’t work for illegals’. You can’t really have a nuanced argument with a seething ball of talking points.</p><p>Still, as my husband said, she’s old. She’ll die soon.</p><p>My money is on the kids.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6d03efff5d9d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On failing, and why ballet makes me a better teacher]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@atraweek/on-failing-and-why-ballet-makes-me-a-better-teacher-df9f9bc2e41a?source=rss-45e929ca496f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/df9f9bc2e41a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ballet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teaching]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[failure]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alison C. Traweek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 29 Jun 2019 03:05:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-03T02:52:10.910Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UoHc3Rq44Oqxi7GP4Yk1gw.jpeg" /><figcaption>the author performing ballet in 2017</figcaption></figure><p>Thanks to the vagaries of genetics, I have always looked more or less like everyone’s idea of a ballet dancer: slender but athletic build, long legs, small head. And I always wanted to be a ballet dancer, but I thought that not doing it as a kid meant I could never be any good, so I wasn’t brave enough to start ballet until I was in my 30s.</p><p>And, to be clear, I am not “any good”, by the standards of Serious Ballet Dancers.</p><p>(Not saying they would judge me that way, you understand; no aspersions cast on them and their relative judginess. I have known a few Serious Ballet Dancers and, by and large, they are lovely and very generous with their judgements of adult beginners. I simply mean that what I can accomplish, given some pointe shoes and a little studio space, compared to what a Serious Ballet Dancer can do with same, is nothing to write home about.)</p><p>But a life of dancing various other styles of dance has given me good proprioception — awareness of my body in space and how to perform new movements with it — and a lifetime of playing classical piano has given me a strong sense of timing, so I’m not terrible.</p><p>I mean, in the *lower level* classes I’m not terrible. In the advanced class I go to, I am clearly the weakest dancer in the class, and often just walk parts of the choreo that I definitely cannot actually dance (mainly turns — not learning to spot turns as a kid means I really struggle with turns now). On any given Monday night, you might find me doing simple passés while the other ladies do three or four pirouettes from fifth in a row, or walking around myself while they do a series of quick chainés in a circle, spotting each one to a different wall.</p><p>It is humbling.</p><p>But I keep going back. In part because I hate being bad at things, and can’t stand the idea of giving up before I learn how to do an endless series of effortless chainés across the floor. In part because I think it’s good for teachers to remember what it feels like to fail.</p><p>I primarily teach lower levels of ancient Greek and Latin to university students. Learning any new language is challenging (ask my husband how my Russian is) but ancient Greek and Latin are in some ways uniquely challenging; Russian and German may share a complex case system, but they also have living native speakers and intermediate texts written by native speakers to use for the second year.</p><p>With ancient Greek and Latin, after one year with a textbook, you’re reading Herodotus and Tacitus, Sappho and Seneca, Plato and Pliny. It’s no joke. You move from relatively simple textbook sentences to the most artful and polished texts that survive from Greek and Roman antiquity.</p><p>Understandably, this means that second year Greek and Latin, especially in the first semester, are brutal. The few students fortunate enough to remember the textbook rules discover that *real* language doesn’t really follow textbook rules, and all the others feel pulled out to sea by the riptide of language in action.</p><p>As a teacher, this can be frustrating. How can students not recognize that tense or case?! Why on god’s green earth are they still confusing the *third* person plural for the *first*?! What could be more obvious?!</p><p>This is where Monday ballet makes me a better teacher: I see them mistake an accusative for a genitive of a first declension noun, and I think of myself not being able to do a pirouette from fifth.</p><p>It’s such a simple thing. It’s just a pirouette, which I can do from fourth. But make me do it from fifth — such a tiny change! literally it’s the exact same turn but the working leg starts from a slightly different place! — and I suddenly can’t get around.</p><p>My Monday night failures give me empathy for my students’ struggles. Distinguishing a first declension accusative from a genitive for me is… it just <em>is</em>, simply and straightforwardly, what it is. No debate, no doubt. Just indisputably so.</p><p>Just as pirouettes from fifth are, for my Monday night partners, simply <em>done</em>, by habit, without thought. While my attempts stall out somewhere near the halfway point.</p><p>It gives me extra stores of patience for my students to be actively living how hard it is to learn new things, to do something you aren’t comfortable with doing while other people are watching.</p><p>It makes me proud of them for their mistakes, because failure is both the only route to improvement and one of the worst, scariest things to experience, especially in front of your peers.</p><p>Students, you are doing champion and more than champion. You are not stupid for not being right; getting it wrong means you are on the right path for getting it right, and that is what learning is.</p><p>Students, you are brave and bold, and I am proud of you. And I wouldn’t hate it if someone said the same to me before my advanced ballet classes, because they leave me feeling deeply unsure of myself and occasionally ashamed of my failures, and it is good to remember that learning is just being bad at something until you aren’t so bad at it anymore, and maybe are even becoming somewhat good.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-EXzUMxXJw6uISg0CJ1GGQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>the author performing in 2017</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=df9f9bc2e41a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On drafting and perfectionism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@atraweek/on-drafting-and-perfectionism-df10e5aa8f14?source=rss-45e929ca496f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/df10e5aa8f14</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[perfectionism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[practice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[craft]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[goals]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alison C. Traweek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 18 Jun 2019 03:24:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-18T03:26:44.600Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*W3cd-wGULtnRSIpVq4PoXw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Some years ago, I had an anonymous blog that I started because I needed to be writing and I wasn’t writing. The premise of the blog was that I promised to write a half hour a night, every night, however bad it was, however stupid. I ran it for a few years and had a little success and made some lovely friends through it, and, while it didn’t do that much for my academic writing — ostensibly the that-for-which I had started it — it did renew my confidence in my voice and my ability to engage readers. I do credit that experience in many ways with giving me the ego-boost to start submitting writing again to non-academic venues after years of almost exclusively writing scholarship.</p><p>I stopped writing the blog a few years ago — something-something-late-2016/early-2017-anxieties — but since coming over to Medium I’ve thought about doing something similar again. But I don’t know exactly what it would look like here — the beauty of my anonymous blog was precisely the anonymity: I could be as silly or as crass or as vulnerable as I wanted, with only the unlikeliest likelihood of repercussions.</p><p>(To be clear, I cursed a lot but was not otherwise especially crass, and (almost?) never did <em>ad hominem</em> critiques, and the instances when I spoke ill of anyone in my personal or professional life were vanishingly rare; still, anonymity is incredibly freeing.)</p><p>Writing under my own name again has rekindled my dire perfectionist impulse: I don’t want to publish anything here that isn’t perfect, so instead I’ve fretted over drafts of various pieces, but published very little, even though ostensibly I am here because I want to communicate with the world through writing. Some of my drafts are responding to specific calls-for-pitches (some of which I do actually intend to finish and submit), some are nascent essay ideas I’m feeling out, some are essentially just practice and exercise — like trying to write “funny”. I think I’m a reasonably funny person, in person, but I default to hopelessly, endlessly earnest in writing, and it would be cool to move beyond that a little and expand my range. And practice makes perfect, right?</p><p>But at some point, practice has to become published or it isn’t practice so much as avoidance.</p><p>The random nightly musings I did on my old blog are not a good fit for Medium for various reasons, but I think… yes, I think am committing, at least for a few weeks, to doing a *weekly* published post here. If all these years of writing have taught me nothing else, they have taught me that I will resist publishing with every fiber of my being unless I have a Signed Deal. So there it is: one published post a week is my Signed Deal.</p><p>For, like, a month, and then we’ll reassess. Let’s not get crazy.</p><p>No promises on content or quality: we all know that most writing is, at best, mediocre writing, but we have to write through the banal to get to the valuable stuff, right?</p><p>And it can’t hurt for me to try this — worst case, I bore a few people, and find a few readers who think I’m fine, and that’s more readers than I get by publishing nothing.</p><p>What are your strategies for fighting perfectionism and just getting it out there?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=df10e5aa8f14" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the fear that comes with forced-birth laws]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@atraweek/on-the-fear-that-comes-with-forced-birth-laws-40fed97c21db?source=rss-45e929ca496f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/40fed97c21db</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reproductive-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pregnancy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[childless-by-choice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abortion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alison C. Traweek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 04 Jun 2019 23:34:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-05T04:56:15.233Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’ve never had an abortion. I don’t mean to say I’ve avoided abortion for moral reasons— the products of conception are not a moral issue for me, especially in the early stages, and, had I ever been pregnant, I would have had an abortion as soon as possible. It just seems like it would be stressful and expensive and emotional (if only because of politics) and complicated, and I’m glad I haven’t had to deal with it.</p><p>So I can’t add my voice to the #shoutyourabortion movement, but I will pipe up from the #childlessbychoice side of things, because legal and accessible abortion is a huge part of what ensures that childless-by-choice is possible.</p><p>In January 2017, shortly before the inauguration of our 45th president, I got an IUD (and <a href="https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/1/25/14364744/iud-trump-obamacare">the reports suggest I was far from alone in that</a>). The insertion was painful and a little scary, but the nurse held my hand, and, when they were done, she gave me a high-five and said I never had to worry about pregnancy ever again: I was 41, and the shiny new copper IUD would almost certainly get me well past easy fertility.</p><p>When I was young, especially when I lived in the south, people always looked at me knowingly when I assured them I didn’t want kids. <em>You’ll change your mind</em>, they’d condescendingly nod at me. <em>No</em>, I thought, <em>I won’t</em>. I have known literally since elementary school that I did not want to be a parent. I had recurring nightmares in my teens and twenties of having a baby and desperately trying to get rid of it. I remember the horrified panic of those dreams viscerally to this day. I was never confused about not wanting children, and I was as careful as any normal person can be to forestall it ever happening — and I was lucky.</p><p>Because we all know the stories of people who did everything ‘right’ and still got pregnant — the vasectomy that failed, the condom that broke, the birth control pills that got left at home during vacation. Accidents happen (and, incidentally, as we know, <a href="https://humanparts.medium.com/men-cause-100-of-unwanted-pregnancies-eb0e8288a7e5">men are the cause of 100% of unwanted pregnancies</a>). I give thanks to every divine power that I have always known I had the option of getting a safe and legal abortion if I needed one. As it happens, I never did, but knowing it was available was profoundly important.</p><p>Now I’m old enough that no one asks me anymore if I’m going to have kids. We all have a tacit assumption that that horse has left the stable, and no one needs to make small talk about the better-or-worse of it at this point. It’s only recently that I have had the resources to pay whatever it cost so that I wouldn’t have to continue a pregnancy I didn’t want, but I’ve always known the medical option was there for me. In the background, like a quiet and comforting song. Even though I’ve never known a world without this option, I still feel it as a relief as fundamental as that first breath of air after a drowning scare.</p><p>So even though I have never had an abortion or lived without the option, thirty-odd years of potential fertility, the majority of which were paired with constant economic precarity, have positioned me to understand what this moment must feel like for so many people who can get pregnant and do not want to be pregnant right now. If I were facing this, especially as a young person, I would be terrified.</p><p>So to those of you who are facing this: I am so sorry. I understand your terror. Although I’ve never needed an abortion, I’ve taken my share of pregnancy tests, for every one of which I imagined all the ways my life would be thrown into disorder if I had to carry a child.</p><p>I’m especially sorry for the people who will be forced to bear a child after sexual violence of one kind or another; given that, on the low end, some 20% of women report sexual assault in their lives, given that the numbers are significantly higher for trans and non-binary people, a staggering number of people will have to live the cruel fall-out of these laws while managing the trauma of assault.</p><p>I am deeply sorry for them, truly, but honestly I hate those ‘exceptions’ — I don’t care why you need an abortion. Your reasons shouldn’t matter at all, and they certainly aren’t my business: you need one because <em>you need one</em>, and you should be able to get one safely and legally and without invasive personal questions from anyone, least of all your government.</p><p>So I’m also sorry for the people who can’t afford a child, or another child — remember that <a href="https://www.cbsnews.com/news/who-are-the-1-in-4-american-women-who-choose-abortion/">most people who have abortions already have children!</a> — and now have to figure it out anyway.</p><p>I’m sorry for the people who will have to drop out of school now because they can’t do school and parenting at the same time with the resources they have.</p><p>I’m sorry for the people who will have to give up their dream career because it isn’t compatible with the financial, physical, and emotional costs of childrearing.</p><p>I’m sorry for the people whose bodies will suffer with pregnancy — remember, <a href="https://www.womenshealth.gov/pregnancy/youre-pregnant-now-what/pregnancy-complications">pregnancy is dangerous</a>, and <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22270271">abortions are safer than childbirth</a> — and whose wellbeing is now put behind that of a fetus.</p><p>I’m sorry for the people who actually do want children, but <em>not yet, not right now, not this year, not with this person</em>.</p><p>For the people whose bodies don’t magically manage to <a href="https://time.com/3001785/todd-akin-legitimate-rape-msnbc-child-of-rape/">‘shut that whole thing down’</a>, whose representatives are so hopelessly uneducated that they are <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2019/05/10/sponsor-an-ohio-abortion-bill-thinks-you-can-reimplant-ectopic-pregnancies-you-cant/">legislating a medical procedure that isn’t even possible</a> based on some dark fantasy of punishing women. Even more chillingly, <a href="https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2019/05/hb-481-georgia-law-criminalizes-abortion-subjects-women-to-life-in-prison.html">the people who will be tried and punished for spontaneous abortion, otherwise known as miscarrying</a>.</p><p>(Look at how that word puts the blame on the pregnant person: she <em>miscarried</em>, she <em>failed to carry correctly</em>. And yes, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/12/28/opinion/abortion-pregnancy-pro-life.html">punishments-for-miscarriage are already happening</a>, but they will get worse under these laws.)</p><p>This essay is far outside my usual lane, but the deep fear and helplessness I feel in the face of these forced birth laws pushes me to speak up. For all of you out there who face the possibility of unwanted pregnancy without safe, legal, and accessible recourse to abortion, we see you, and we won’t be quiet.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=40fed97c21db" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the pressure to produce, and the importance of purpose]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/swlh/on-the-pressure-to-produce-and-the-importance-of-purpose-e50a42e84056?source=rss-45e929ca496f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e50a42e84056</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[academia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[purpose]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alison C. Traweek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 May 2019 04:02:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-05-29T06:59:14.517Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FRSCMQlOMnbUz_QF4p_tGQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s a sort of chicken-and-egg problem, really, I suppose: are academics obsessed with producing work or are people obsessed with working drawn to academia? In any case, it is my second summer as contingent faculty and I’ve been thinking a lot about how or if that should shape my relationship to productivity in the summer.</p><p>In a traditional academic job, especially tenure-track, obviously publication is important. A small liberal arts school will have different measures than an R-1 (a major research university), but you pretty much have to publish no matter what.</p><p>But I’m not especially interested in a tenure-track position. I’ve thought a lot about what it entails on a day-to-day basis — working closely and intensely with a group of colleagues, self-promotion, presenting at conferences, pressures to publish, participation in departmental events and functions — and I don’t really want my work week to look like that. I *like* going to my departments’ events, often, but I like even more that I don’t *have* to.</p><p>So it doesn’t really matter if I publish.</p><p>And yet, I feel this pressure to publish. Not necessarily in academic venues, but to research and write, and put it out there.</p><p>One of my goals for this summer — alongside several writing projects and the usual class prep — is to really think about what I want to produce, and especially *why*. I don’t want to write because it’s <em>comme il faut</em>. That’s writing without purpose, really. I like doing things that have purpose.</p><p>So if I choose to write and try to publish, what am I hoping to get from it? Is it valuable enough to counterbalance the fact that I could have spent that time quilting, or finally finishing the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CWNRSOH7rSI">Barcarolle</a>, or reading novels, or just watching the finches singing their sublime song at the feeder?</p><p>I came across <a href="https://www.thenation.com/article/no-place-self-pity-no-room-fear/">a Toni Morrison quote</a> earlier that reframed all this a bit for me:</p><blockquote>There is no time for despair, no place for self-pity, no need for silence, no room for fear. We speak, we write, we do language. That is how civilizations heal.</blockquote><p>She was talking about writers and the obligation they have to the world. I have no illusions that my writing is going to change the world; if nothing else, I wilt under the spotlight, so I would make a poor world-changing ambassador. But it helped me think about what kind of writing I might like to give my energy to for the next few months.</p><p>One short piece I’m already committed to writing this summer is for the <a href="https://documents.alexanderstreet.com/VOTESforWOMEN">Online Biographical Database of the Women Suffrage Movement in the United States</a>, for whom I’ve already written several biographies. I love this project because it memorializes the work of so many ordinary women. Many of them were white socialite elite types, yes, but, for instance, I also wrote the biography of Dr. Gertrude E. Curtis (not yet published, alas), who was the first Black woman dentist in New York City, who was married to a famous Broadway star, and who was a fierce and tireless fighter for women’s rights and for civil rights.</p><p>And who was almost entirely forgotten.</p><p>It felt valuable to tell her story. It feels valuable to tell the stories of the generations who fought to make this brutally imperfect world, this world with <a href="https://poets.org/poem/new-year-0">its annihilating need</a>, a little better for us who follow them. It inspires me to fight as hard as they did, to do the work that Morrison says we are all called on to do for the world.</p><p>I am currently playing with the idea of an essay on an early and extremely influential classicist in America who was also a Confederate soldier and subsequently a Lost Cause devotee. I think it matters that we interrogate the people who shaped our fields, and understand why our fields look the way they do. I think it’s important that classicists wrestle with our discipline’s, ah, problematic past, because my field is actively being used to further the agenda of white supremacists, and I want no part of that.</p><p>So I don’t know if I want to give a lot of energy to writing and trying to publish scholarship this summer. I feel a bit more drawn to the idea of <a href="https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/57673/to-be-of-use">being of use</a>. Contributing my little expertise on the off chance that it can contribute to healing the world.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e50a42e84056" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/swlh/on-the-pressure-to-produce-and-the-importance-of-purpose-e50a42e84056">On the pressure to produce, and the importance of purpose</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/swlh">The Startup</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Facing Medusa: Examining the Iterations of the Gorgon]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@atraweek/facing-medusa-examining-the-iterations-of-the-gorgon-b7da062a982e?source=rss-45e929ca496f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b7da062a982e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ancient-greece]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[talks]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[classics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medusa]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alison C. Traweek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 May 2019 03:57:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-05-08T03:57:35.642Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>(originally presented as an invited talk at Haverford College, 4/12/2017; slides available <a href="https://prezi.com/5i_rzppittap/?utm_campaign=share&amp;utm_medium=copy">here</a>; bibliography on request)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qSGmbZfWtok34tikUV9Oew.jpeg" /></figure><p>I. Introduction</p><p>The talk I’m going to give today is part of a larger project: it is a distillation of several chapters from the book I’m writing on Medusa, or the Gorgon, in ancient Greek and Roman literature and art. Because it is a work in progress, I am particularly looking forward to your comments and feedback.</p><p>When I was getting ready to write this talk, I tried to remember how I had gotten interested in Medusa in the first place. One answer is that I saw Ray Harryhausen’s Clash of the Titans at too tender and impressionable an age — and [slide 1] here is that film’s depiction of Medusa — not terribly sympathetic, but even as a child I felt that she’d been dealt a hard hand. Another answer is implicit in an exchange I had with a jeweler in Athens many years ago. I asked her if she had any pins of the monster Medusa, and she told me that, yes, she did have a Medusa pin, but gently chastised me that Medusa wasn’t a monster, she was just misunderstood.</p><p>So I think my interest in this subject comes out of the intersection of these two points: monsters challenge us to think about where we draw the lines that define who can and can’t be on our team, as it were, but also challenge us to empathize with other experiences of being. The Athenian jeweler’s defense of Medusa is a reminder that monstrosity is not in itself a settled category, but rather a way of thinking about the limits of humanity, and what the consequences of transgressing them are. I have found Medusa to be a useful and sympathetic tool with which to think about these things.</p><p>So. To begin.</p><p>The Gorgon, like the Minotaur and the Cyclops, outlived her original context and held her own in the western tradition, and so is one of the most familiar monsters from the ancient world — you can buy Medusa costumes online [slide 2], for instance, and the contemporary British artist Nancy Farmer has done an entire series of prints and paintings imagining the Gorgon going about her business in the modern world [slide 3]. The Gorgon has also been an influential tool in various modern theoretical systems, doing an enormous amount of work as a symbol for thinkers like Freud, Cixous, and Lacan. She has also remained a vibrant part of visual culture: you still see Gorgon heads as decorative motifs in architecture, particularly of the late 19th and early 20th century, as in this old carousel building on the Asbury Park boardwalk in New Jersey [slide 4]. She was even chosen as the logo for the luxury fashion brand Versace — allegedly because the designer wanted his styles to be so stunning that they stopped people in their tracks [slide 5].</p><p>The reception of the Gorgon is certainly fascinating, but most of her post-antique iterations are premised on an idea of looking being her most important aspect when, in fact, the assertive gaze is not the main element of the figure in antiquity. That is, Freud and Nancy Farmer and Versace all proceeded from a premise that the Gorgon was in essence a creature concerned with a particular kind of dangerous or powerful looking, and that her baneful — and fundamentally female — gaze was at the heart of her character, but this doesn’t hold up in the oldest sources. With my talk today, I want to go back to the original iterations of the myth, to our earliest literary and artistic evidence for the Gorgon’s story, and challenge that basic assumption about her relationship to looking. In the first part of my talk, I will show that, while her myth was deeply interested in questions of sight and seeing, the Gorgon herself is adamantly, almost aggressively, not in control of sight. Then, in the second part of my talk, I want to offer an explanation for this apparent paradox, and to show how this figure who is much more looked-on than looker came to be one of the most recognizable symbols of the subject of the gaze.</p><p>I’m going to start by revisiting the basic shape of the Gorgon myth and following the threads of looking and seeing that govern it. It is important to clarify here that it is the nature of Greek myths to be flexible and variable, and for the details to be changed over time and by different hands. That is, before there was anything like a canonical version of the myth, there were centuries of tellings and retellings that added or adjusted minor details. This occasionally results in contradictions between different versions but it also serves to clarify which aspects of the myth were felt as fixed. Different versions of the Oedipus myth, for example, might change the details of how exactly he ended up in Thebes married to his mother, or how precisely he responded to the news, or even what his mother’s name was, but the basic fact of his inability to subvert fate is unchanged. The variations are sometimes irreconcilable in their details, then, but they also put into relief the points of stability — the elements that don’t change. So first I am going to trace out the Gorgon myth, triangulating from various sources to emphasize the central moments and try to define a bit more clearly the complexities of the Gorgon in her early days.</p><p>II. Myth — sources and themes</p><p>The first outline of the Gorgon story is laid out in Hesiod’s <em>Theogony</em>, a very early poem providing the genealogy of the Greek universe and its inhabitants as well as the cosmological and supernatural events that resulted in the reign of Zeus and the other Olympians. In this poem, which dates to around the 7th century BCE, Hesiod introduces the Gorgons among the descendants of Okeanos, the personification of Ocean [slide 6]:</p><blockquote>Keto bore to Phorkys the lovely-cheeked Graiai [Old Women], grey-haired from birth, and both the immortal gods and mortal men walking the earth call them the Graiai, lovely-gowned Pamphredo and Enyo in her yellow dress, and the Gorgons, who dwell beyond the famous Ocean at the far edge, near Night where the bright-voiced Hesperides are, Sthenno and Euryale and Medusa, who suffered baneful things. She alone was mortal, but the other two were immortal and ageless; the Darkhaired God [Poseidon] lay with her [Medusa] in a soft meadow among spring flowers. But when Perseus cut off her head, Chrysaor and the great horse Pegasus jumped out. The one was so called because he was born near the spring [<em>pegas</em>] of Ocean, the other because he was holding a golden sword [<em>aor chrysaion</em>] in his hands. (270–83)</blockquote><p>The Gorgon’s story is at heart a hero’s quest myth, then. Hesiod’s narrative is extremely compressed, obviously, but several details about the Gorgon stand out. First, that the Gorgon is not one specific creature but a kind of creature, a trio of sisters. These sisters are the offspring of sea creatures several generations older than the Olympian gods, and they live, as many monsters do, at the edge of the world. Though they are sisters, Hesiod emphasizes a vital detail separating one of them, Medusa, from the others: Medusa is marked with a unique and peculiar fate, being the only mortal in a family of immortals. She alone is destined to die, though no explanation is ever provided (fate in Greece was cruel and capricious, after all). As classicist Charles Segal notes, Medusa is actually picked out as the very first mortal creature in the Hesiodic cosmos, the introduction into the system of not just the possibility, but the promise, of death.</p><p>Hesiod gives us no explanation for her surprising status, and no information about Perseus’ motivation for hunting her down, but we know from later sources that he is attempting to rescue his mother from a forced marriage by performing the supposedly impossible task of retrieving the Gorgon’s head. Perseus at first struggles even to locate the Gorgons — which is understandable in light of the Hesiod passage: they live on the far side of the Ocean, at the edge of the world, far from ordinary mortals. Fortunately, perhaps because he is a son of Zeus, Perseus gains the support of the gods Athena and Hermes. They tell him he must first find the Graiai, the Gorgon’s sisters, who can tell him where to go next.</p><p>Hesiod gives us only a brief physical description of the Graiai, which is essentially encapsulated in their name — Graiai literally meaning ‘Old Women’ — that they were grey-haired old women from their birth. Hesiod has only two Graiai, though later versions have them as a trio, or even a quartet — the exact count of these helper figures is malleable. Little is known about the Graiai, as this is their only cameo in extant myth, but, whatever their number, they give us the first pivotal moment in the myth in which seeing and control of sight become key. The Graiai share between them one eye, which they take turns using. That is, their opportunities for seeing are highly restricted, as only one of them can see at a time. However, their knowledge is extensive, and Perseus has come to them because they are keepers of a particular secret that is relevant to his quest: only they can tell him how to find the Neides, nymphs from whom he must obtain certain gifts in order to find and slay the Gorgon.</p><p>In order to gain access to the Graiai’s knowledge, Perseus steals their eye. In terms of the narrative, this theft provides Perseus with leverage with which to coerce the Graiai into revealing their secret: he threatens to keep their eye, or even throw it away, unless they reveal to him the location of the Neides. There is also, however, a special connection inherent in the very linguistics of seeing and knowing in the Greek language: the same linguistic root, deployed in different conjugations, provides the basic verbs for each concept. In the present tense, this verb means ‘to see’. In the perfect, however, expressing action that has been completed, it literally means ‘to have seen’ — which, in Greek, is essentially synonymous with ‘to know’. That is, inherent to the language is a causal relationship: once you have seen something can you be said to know it.</p><p>In light of this, Perseus’ theft of the Graiai’s single eye in order to gain access to their knowledge implies that he has used their eye to see what they have seen, and thus to know their secret. By taking control of their access to sight, Perseus gains access to their knowledge, and is able to proceed with his quest. This is the first instance in the myth where the progress of the narrative hinges on questions of sight and who or what is allowed to see or be seen. As we continue, we will find more and more such moments, culminating in the climax of the myth, with the decapitation of Medusa.</p><p>So Perseus has learned from the Graiai how to find the Neides, and the narrative pauses again when he meets them. Almost nothing is known of the Neides other than that they are again a trio of nymphs — the trio, especially of female deities, being sort of a default setting for Greek myth, as is probably fairly clear at this point. The Neides are in possession of three magical items that Perseus needs to complete his quest: winged sandals that allow him to fly (useful, when you’re trying to cross the ocean), a broad-brimmed hat belonging to Hades that renders its wearer invisible, and a special wallet or pouch that can safely transport Medusa’s severed head. The sandals are key to Perseus’ quest — in particular to his escape from Medusa’s sisters — but the other two items are of greater interest to my purposes today, as they are again related to the control of sight.</p><p>First, the wallet or pouch. In most early accounts, it is referred to as a <em>kibisis</em>, which is not a Greek word but a Cypriot one, and the retention of this foreign word suggests the special importance of the object. The origin of the pouch itself is unknown, but the need for a special tool for the transport of the Gorgon’s head implies the dangers of the trophy: an ordinary pouch might fail to adequately neutralize and control the head’s powers. The special <em>kibisis</em>, however, can safely contain it. Whether that containment has to do with restricting the head’s ability to look at others or with preventing others from looking at it is unclear, but it is again, as with the Graiai and their stolen eye, a moment in the myth in which the question of controlling sight, of keeping the right things unseen, is of fundamental importance.</p><p>The other relevant gift the Neides have for Perseus is the cap of Hades, which is said to render its wearer invisible. This raises interesting implications for the parsing of this myth. The invisibility the cap offers Perseus is what allows him to escape from the enraged sisters after he has dispatched Medusa, but, given that he is instructed to carefully avert his gaze from the Gorgons in spite of the cover the cap gives him, it seems that his invisibility does not protect him from the dangers posed by the Gorgons. That is, the suggestion here is that the essential risk is not being seen by the Gorgon, but looking upon her. Medusa is usually imagined as deploying her dangerous gaze as a weapon, but this is the first of several hints that she is not, in fact, in these early versions of the myth, the subject of any dangerous gazing, but rather the dangerous object of the gaze of another.</p><p>Perseus has now outsmarted the Graiai by stealing their eye to acquire their knowledge, allowing him to locate the Neides, from whom he receives three divine gifts, two of which give him special powers of control over seeing and sight. Finally, with the help of Athena and Hermes, he travels to the far side of the ocean to find the Gorgons. Whether by careful planning or incredible luck, the hunters find the Gorgons sleeping. That is, they find the creatures associated with dangerous gazing while their eyes are closed, and they are thus rendered unseeing. This is typically emphasized in the literary sources, though the visual sources do often show Perseus encountering an open-eyed Medusa, especially early on. Even when he meets her asleep, though, Perseus is careful to look away, as both literary and visual sources make clear [slide 7]. Once the gods have told Perseus which of the three Gorgons is Medusa — the only one of the three who is mortal — they warn him to avert his gaze and, in later sources, to use his shield as a mirror to guide his hand for the killing blow. This returns us to the question of whose seeing is the problem — it seems to be a bit of both: Perseus can’t safely look on Medusa even when she is made sightless by sleep, but the cap of invisibility indicates that he also can’t safely be seen; the danger comes from both directions. In fact, part of the myth’s drama seems to be rooted in uncertainty about just whose looking matters, and when.</p><p>Following the gods’ advice, Perseus swiftly decapitates Medusa with his curved sword. At the moment of the beheading, as Hesiod described, the winged horse Pegasus and the warrior Chrysaor leap from Medusa’s neck cavity — her fertility transposed to the moment of her death, and the birth happening from the upper rather than lower body illustrating how thickly contradictions and paradox cluster around this first experiment with mortality. His work done, Perseus presumably tosses Medusa’s head into his special pouch and takes off, but not before the sisters awaken. They attempt to pursue Perseus and avenge their sister, but his cap of invisibility protects him. To dispatch the creature whose powers are supposedly centered in looking, then, and to escape her sisters, requires, paradoxically, a stringent avoidance of both seeing and being seen: Perseus had to decapitate Medusa without looking at her, and then prevent her sisters from seeing him in order to escape with his life.</p><p>The climactic moment of decapitation, then, is, like the encounter with the Graiai, structured around the control of sight: Perseus first needs the gods to pick out the mortal sister from the immortal ones, though it is unclear if this is because he can’t distinguish between the sisters himself or because he literally can’t look at them. He then must strike the killing blow to Medusa without looking directly at her to aim, and finally must escape her outraged sisters without being seen. We learn here, because Athena and Hermes seem unconcerned with their own safety, that the dangers of seeing or being seen by the Gorgon are limited to mortals, which makes sense: the Gorgons’ threat of petrifaction, in other words, is, like the Sirens’ song, irrelevant to immortals, because it is all about being taken out of the sphere of human interactivity, whether by becoming moored upon the barren shore of a distant, uninhabited island, or being made into a statue, frozen and thus prevented from carrying on with the normal concerns of life. In any case, Athena and Hermes show no fear of the Gorgon, while Perseus is exceedingly careful to control his gaze and, with the <em>kibisis</em> and the cap of Hades, to control who can gaze upon him and his prize.</p><p>Even with the cap of Hades concealing him, though, the remaining Gorgon sisters present a terrifying threat, and this chase scene is one of the most popular scenes of this myth for vase painting, especially in the 5th century. [slide 8]</p><p>The chase scene also shows up in several early literary sources, though it is much more popular in the visual record. The textual descriptions of the chase scene offer some useful details that can expand on the picture of the Gorgon offered by the <em>Theogony</em> that has been guiding us so far. An excerpt from the Twelfth Pythian of Pindar, for instance, dating to the early 5th century, presents the chase scene, and provides one of the earliest suggestions in the literary record that the Gorgon’s relationship to sight in particular was important — one of the first explicit connections in the literary tradition between Gorgons and sight: [slide 9]</p><blockquote>[The musical art form] which once Pallas Athena discovered when she wove together the deadly lament of the rash Gorgons, which from under the maidenly and monstrous snaky heads she heard pouring forth with mournful suffering, when Perseus was killing the third part of the sisters and bringing doom to sea-girt Seriphus and its people. Indeed he brought darkness to the divine race of Phorkys, and made baneful for Polydektes a feast and the long slavery of his mother and the forced bridal bed, when he carried off the head of Medusa with her lovely cheeks, the son of Danae did. (6–21 [11–39])</blockquote><p>Pindar gives his Gorgons a strange pathos by making Euryale’s grief at the death of her sister the basis for a new kind of music, and the fact that he describes Medusa as beautiful has puzzled and troubled many scholars. The causal relationship between Medusa’s death and the fate of the people of Seriphus is left implicit or even opaque — hardly unusual for this poet — but many scholars have interpreted this, by analogy with other iterations of the story, to be suggesting that Perseus wielded the Gorgon’s head against the Seriphians and thus petrified them all. More interesting for our purposes today is the impact the Gorgon’s slaying had on her family: the verb I’ve translated as ‘brought darkness’ literally means ‘to blind or render invisible’. Again, Pindar does not provide additional information, but it is as if Medusa’s family — the Graiai and the other Gorgons — is rendered either unseeing or unseeable by Perseus’ act. This recalls the theft of the eye of the Graiai as well: it is again Perseus who is in control of sight, while the children of Phorkys — even or especially Medusa — seem to be at his mercy, and defenseless against him.</p><p>A passage from the pseudo-Hesiodic <em>Shield of Hercules</em> reiterates this power dynamic. The <em>Shield</em>, which probably dates to the early to mid 6th century, is primarily an ekphrasis or extended description of an extremely ornate shield. The immediate aftermath of Medusa’s beheading makes up a part of the decoration [slide 10]:</p><blockquote>The head of the terrible portent, the Gorgon, covered [Perseus’] whole back, and a shining silver wallet, a marvel to behold, contained it. … And behind [Perseus] rushed the Gorgons, monstrous and unspeakable, eager to catch him. As they moved upon the pale steel the shield resounded with a great din sharply and shrilly. On their belts two snakes hung down arching their heads forward. They were flicking their tongues then, and sharpening their teeth fiercely and glaring savagely. And on the terrible Gorgonian heads great Fear was shaking. (223–225, 229–237)</blockquote><p>By the time we get to the <em>Shield</em>, then, and certainly by the time we get to Pindar, the Gorgon has begun to accumulate her particular associations: noisiness, snakiness, and especially a relationship with a dangerous gaze — evident in Pindar with the darkness brought to the Phorkydes by Medusa’s death as well as the implied petrifaction of the people of Seriphus, where looking upon the head of Medusa removes them from the land of the living. In the Shield, the idea of sight shows up with the snakes that are glaring fiercely on the Gorgons’ behalf. That is, the Gorgon, largely because of the sisters left behind after Medusa’s murder, is beginning to become a being that is all about looking.</p><p>The fact that Medusa’s death is necessary to the transition unites the questions of control of sight and agency or passivity that have been a structuring device in Medusa’s tale to this point: at each of the central moments of her story, Medusa is very clearly not the agent of the relevant action in any meaningful way; in Hesiod’s telling, even her offspring leap out of her neck at the moment of her death as if by their own volition. Medusa is fundamentally a passive figure, and is never a participant in any of the activity taking place around her, even after her death: it is Perseus who deploys the head against various foes — sometimes the sea monster from which he rescues Andromeda, sometimes the people of Seriphus who were holding his mother hostage — but Medusa’s destructive power is a result of her being seen rather than of her seeing anything herself.</p><p>In fact, apart from the injunction on Perseus to turn his head away when confronting her, there is no real evidence of Medusa’s gaze being in any way extraordinary until Perseus wields it. Medusa keeps herself at the edge of the world where mortals are unlikely to encounter her, and never seeks out anyone she can glare to death. As classicist Emily Vermeule puts it, Medusa’s powers only become obvious when Perseus brings her head into the mortal sphere. I would go one step farther and suggest that her powers did not only become obvious, but actually came into existence at Perseus’ intervention. Her gaze is only destructive when deployed by someone else. It is not, in fact, a power that belongs to her at all, but rather one that is activated by someone controlling her. This is true for Perseus’ several uses of the head, and remains true after Perseus has given the head to Athena, who fixes it on her special breastplate. It is always Perseus or Athena who causes Medusa to be seen, and thus to petrify; she is never in control of her own powers, but is always the passive vessel whose danger seems located more in what she reflects back than in anything she actually is or sees or does.</p><p>III. Analysis</p><p>With the remainder of my time today, I want to offer an explanation for this apparent contradiction of Medusa as dangerous seer who is never actually in control of her own gaze.</p><p>To do this, we will need to return to the Gorgon’s origins in the literary and material records, focusing this time not on evidence that might confirm our understanding of the Gorgon but instead evidence that challenges it. In doing so, we will see that the Gorgon as we’re accustomed to understanding her is actually a composite of two similar but separate native traditions that were brought together quite early. This conflation has long been taken for granted by scholars, though there have been few efforts to systematically trace out its consequences — one of those consequences being, as I will show, an explanation for the Gorgon’s entanglement with dangerous looking, and in particular with her status as a passively dangerous looker.</p><p>This brings us to the gorgoneion, an extremely common motif in the artistic and architectural world of antiquity : a broad, grinning face, often with fangs or tusks, glaring back at the viewer [slide 11]. I have been talking so far about the mythological characters, the Gorgons, but there is a second figure with a similar name, the gorgoneion, operating alongside the Gorgons. The convention has been to refer to the race of embodied sisters like Medusa, Euryale, and Sthenno as Gorgons, and the motif of the disembodied head as the gorgoneion, a linguistic variant that indicates that whatever is being referred to as such is related to the Gorgon. There is a good deal of slippage between these two figures, especially in calling the gorgoneion a Gorgon, though they are believed to have distinct and independent origins in Greece. The Gorgon proper has something of a story, or at any rate a nimbus of associations, and participates — however unwillingly and unwittingly — in the world of the living. The gorgoneion, on the other hand, emerges from the magical rather than mythological tradition. It is difficult to draw clear and fast lines between these two realms, but we might loosely posit the primary distinction as directional: mythology is, in some sense, automatically retrospective, in that it deals with stories from the past, and often stories that provide a causal explanation for something about the present. Magic, on the other hand, is fundamentally future-oriented in that it offers its users a manipulative strategy by which to influence the course of the world, often with supernatural aid.</p><p>There were many different forms of magic active in the ancient world, but one of the most common and straightforward was the apotropaion, or protective amulet (apotropaion literally means a turning back, so it is a tool that protects by forcing evil away). These took various forms — in Greece they were often literal eyes painted on surfaces like drinking cups, whereas Rome was partial to phallic amulets. In Greece and Rome both, however, by far the most common device was the gorgoneion, the gape-mouthed, staring-eyed, disembodied head whose grotesque appearance imbued it with the power of glaring evil away — and in fact the blue and white evil eye charm that is still ubiquitous in Greece and Turkey to this day may actually be a distillation and direct descendant of the gorgoneion’s prominent eyes, and is in any case certainly her cousin. Because of her protective powers, the gorgoneion was molded and sculpted and painted onto every imaginable surface from bakers’ ovens to vases to shields to monumental temples to children’s amulets as a kind of insurance against misfortune or malice.</p><p>It is easy to see why these two traditions would have merged, as they literally explain each other perfectly: a beheaded Medusa accounts for a fierce disembodied head, and the magical powers of the gorgoneion in turn account for Medusa’s baneful eyes. Evidence in the literary and visual records beginning in the 7th century suggest that the Gorgon and the gorgoneion do indeed inhabit distinct biographies that merge. More importantly, understanding the Gorgon as fundamentally hybrid, I suggest, can account for a number of her apparent paradoxes, particularly her convoluted relationship with looking and seeing.</p><p>Earlier in this talk I presented some of our first evidence of the Gorgon from archaic and classical literature. At the very head of the tradition, however, there are tantalizing glimpses of the gorgoneion as an independent magical device, as magical apotropaion without mythological baggage — of gorgoneion before the Gorgon took on the device as a mask. These come from Homer, a poet roughly contemporaneous with Hesiod, whose Iliad and Odyssey give us several references to a dangerous disembodied head with no character or fate or family and no connection to Perseus (though Homer does know of Perseus, as he references him elsewhere, but he never brings the two together). Homer’s Gorgon is simply an elaborate evil eye — a gorgoneion.</p><p>The Iliad, for example, describes Athena readying herself for war, which involves donning her peculiar defensive armor, the aigis. It is difficult to say exactly what this aigis is, but it is nearly always imagined as being emblazoned with the gorgoneion, which is how the Iliad describes it [slide 12]:</p><blockquote>on it [the aigis] too [was] the Gorgonian head of the terrible portent, the head terrible and awful to look on, the omen of aigis-bearing Zeus. (5.741–743)</blockquote><p>We have countless representations in the material record of the aigis more or less as the Iliad describes it, with the gaping gorgoneion occupying the central space. The gorgoneion renders Athena’s aigis ‘awful to look at’ — the adjective here describing things that are terrible or dangerous specifically to see. We also know that the aigis reflected a historical reality: just as Athena’s aigis had a gorgoneion at its center, the gorgoneion motif was also an extremely common device for the Greek round shield [slide]. This recalls the passive power of Medusa — the danger of the gorgoneion, like that of Medusa, lay more in seeing her than in being seen by her. In fact, all three references to the Gorgon in the Iliad explicitly mention eyes or the horror of seeing: Hector is once described as having “eyes of the Gorgon” in his battle frenzy, and Agamemnon’s shield is described as having “a bristling-eyed Gorgon … emblazoned in the center, gleaming terribly.”</p><p>These references all indicate the device’s relationship with sight: she is awful to look at, meant to terrify the enemy, and a soldier’s eyes in battle-madness come to resemble hers. These descriptions also contrast with the accounts of the Gorgon in the earlier passages in that these gorgoneia aren’t imagined as having any family or history, never mind any body from which they may have at one point been removed — they are, instead, distinct magical interventions, an evil eye expanded into a full glaring face.</p><p>That is, these passages show us hints of a talismanic gorgoneion not yet assimilated to the mythological Gorgon, while the Theogony suggests Gorgons who have not yet acquired the dangerous gaze of the gorgoneion. Of course, such an argument is in some sense an argument from silence — simply because Homer doesn’t explicitly provide a backstory for the gorgoneion doesn’t necessarily mean she hasn’t got one — but the material record reinforces the idea, showing similar signs of conflation in the same period. So we turn our attention now to the artistic and archaeological evidence of the Gorgon and the gorgoneion to fill out the picture suggested by the literary sources.</p><p>Homer and Hesiod, our earliest extant poets, punctuate the transition from the oral to the literate world. Roughly contemporaneous with this literary shift is an artistic shift. Vase painting aesthetics move from essentially geometric or pattern-based styles heavily influenced by Near Eastern art and accented with friezes of stylized elements — leopards, deer, vines, dolphins and so on as well as gorgoneia — to a local, native Greek, figural-focused style that illustrated specific myths and rituals. [slide 14] At the same time, architectural styles are developing towards monumental temple designs that feature mythological decorations such as pediment sculptures and figural friezes. That is, on both large and small scale, the Greek aesthetic of the 7th to 5th centuries is away from the abstract and towards representations of specific and familiar local mythological narratives.</p><p>This trend hits its stride in the 6th century, as interest in figural decoration on temples and vases collide with an interest in representing mythological narratives. We also begin at this point to see in the visual record precisely what we found in the literary: depictions of the three Gorgon sisters combining with the fierce gorgoneia — that is, the apotropaic device familiar from shields, antefixes, coins, and so on being translated onto the body of the mythological figure who can then be beheaded by Perseus and thus bring the gorgoneion into the world.</p><p>We can be confident in identifying this conflation for several reasons. For one thing, the gorgoneion is immediately recognizable and quite distinct from other Greek artistic elements: first and foremost, direct frontality in Greek art is quite rare, and is reserved for certain animals such as leopards and lions, for beings related to or undergoing death or a similarly transformative experience (Dionysus and satyrs in the throes of drunkenness, for instance, can be shown frontally), and for the gorgoneion. Moreover, by the 5th century, gorgoneia are common throughout Greece, and extremely popular in many different media and in many different contexts. While there is considerable variation in the details of the motif, [slide 15] the overly large eyes, the bulbous nose, the protruding tongue, the fangs which are sometimes almost tusks, the beard, and the snaky curls (which are sometimes literally snakes) make it impossible to confuse the archaic gorgoneion with any other figure. (Not all of those elements are present in every example, but the components are unique enough that various combinations are easily identifiable.) Once that unique frontal head is attached to a body, then, we can be reasonably certain that we are looking at the Gorgons of The Shield and Pindar: Medusa, whose decapitation by Perseus creates the gorgoneion, and her sisters, who are frequently shown in hot pursuit of the hero.</p><p>It is helpful, too, that the embodied gorgoneion is very often shown with iconographic elements associated with Medusa, making even more certain the conflation: a clay plaque from Syracuse shows a Gorgon in relief [slide 16] with a small Pegasus rearing up under the right arm. (Technically Pegasus wouldn’t have ever had the opportunity to sit with his mother, of course, as he leapt out of her neck at the moment of her death, but this kind of synoptic or achronological arrangement of narrative elements was common in Greek art of this period.) One of the earliest monumental examples is from the pediment of the temple of Artemis at Corfu, dating to the 6th century, and is very similar to the Syracusan plaque: [slide 17] we see an embodied gorgoneion embracing a winged horse with her right arm and a warrior with her left — presumably Pegasus and Chrysaor, granting again some temporal flexibility.</p><p>The conflation is even clearer when the narrative is represented, as the iconography of Perseus is well known and familiar: the winged sandals, the broad-brimmed cap, the <em>kibisis</em>, or wallet, that he was given for transporting the baneful head — and, sometimes, because artists of this period helpfully labeled their drawings with the characters’ names. [slide 18] The Perseus and Medusa encounter was a very popular subject, and the most commonly represented moments of the story are, unsurprisingly, the moment of Medusa’s beheading and its immediate aftermath. These scenes are always recognizable in spite of the great variation with which early Gorgons were portrayed — even when Medusa is, unaccountably, a centaur, as in this early <em>pithos</em>, for instance, [slide 19] or when the sisters are given what are described as ‘cauldron heads’, as in this amphora, it is clear which story we are seeing: the presence of Perseus, often the presence of Athena and Hermes as helper-figures, a decapitated body left behind, and the hot pursuit of two full-frontal figures makes it indisputably Medusa’s tragedy. [slide 20]</p><p>Underlying our familiar Gorgon, then, are two distinct modes of looking. On the one hand, the Gorgon of mythology is a figure whose story hinges on Perseus’ control of sight, of who or what can be seen, and when. He controls the sight of the Graiai in order to gain their knowledge, and controls the sight of the Gorgons in order to obtain the head of the one and escape from the others. He is even in control of making the Gorgon’s head into an object that can be displayed in the human realm; without his intervention, there is every likelihood that Medusa would have stayed in her distant land, never troubled anyone, and never been seen by mortals at all.</p><p>On the other hand, we have the gorgoneion, the magical device whose purpose is to stop evil in its tracks, to freeze it or turn it back with its inescapable eyes. The odd passive looking power of Medusa is a remnant of the magical efficacy of the gorgoneion, and her decapitation in turn provided the gorgoneion with a body from which to be removed. The two pieces fit together so perfectly that it seems almost inevitable that they should have found each other.</p><p>This is the Gorgon’s final paradox: that taking on the single most common protective talisman of antiquity, the token which more than any other was trusted to drive evil back with its pitiless and unblinking glare, not only failed to protect her, but actually drew a hero to her, made her into a hero’s prize. Medusa, who never seems to have opened her own eyes, became in her unlikely death a fierce set of immortal eyes that never close.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b7da062a982e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Gorgon’s Healing Song]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@atraweek/the-gorgons-healing-song-9dc38ea10402?source=rss-45e929ca496f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9dc38ea10402</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mourning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[classics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medusa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lament]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alison C. Traweek]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 07 May 2019 03:20:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-05-07T03:20:47.349Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>(Originally presented as a paper at the 2nd annual Temple University Consortium on Women, Marriage, and the Household, February 18, 2019 in Philadelphia. Bibliography available on request.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uVKc1zc6Blq0TDRDN1dr5Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>The seed of this paper was in a larger project on the gorgon Medusa, so I will start my talk there as well. In most of the early stories of Medusa, and many of the early depictions, she is not alone but has two sisters. Hesiod’s <em>Theogony</em>, an early Greek poem that gives us the oldest literary evidence on her, says that she and her sisters are children of sea monsters, that they live on the other side of the world near the land of dreams, and that, while her sisters are immortal, Medusa is fated to suffer terrible things and to die. In fact, the story of her death is literally the only mythology associated with her in the early sources: as soon as we notice she exists, Perseus arrives and beheads her.</p><p>A minor detail in Medusa’s story has always intrigued me: after Perseus has dispatched Medusa, he is pursued by the gorgon sisters, who follow him with inarticulate cries of anger and grief. This detail is not in Hesiod, but is found in an ode of the early classical Greek poet Pindar, and can also be inferred from a number of extant vases that show the sisters chasing Perseus with their mouths agape, indicating vocalization. In Pindar’s telling, the goddess Athena heard the gorgons’ cries and invented a reed flute to reproduce them. The reed flute was, in fact, the instrument that accompanied funeral lament in historical Greece, and the gorgons are thus, in some way, at the beginning of the tradition of mourning songs.</p><p>But the gorgons are everything a proper Greek woman is not supposed to be: outside, in the wild, without a male to oversee them, antagonistic to men, in control of their own fertility, and very noisy. During funeral lament rituals, though, Greek women were, unusually, permitted to be like that — even required to, in order to perform the ritual correctly. That got me thinking about why women are given this one major public duty, why they are encouraged to become a spectacle for this one occasion when at other times, as Pericles tells us, the greatest glory of a woman is to be neither heard from nor heard of. So why are women mourners? What makes public wailing and self-mutilation a sanctioned activity for these otherwise cloistered members of Greek society?</p><p>In some ways, the answer is intuitive: women were in charge of the domestic sphere and the household, and death is first and foremost a disastrous rupture in the social life of the home. Moreover, women were considered more emotional than men, and thus more acutely in need of controlled avenues to manage strong and dangerous emotions like grief and anger. Additionally, women may have been thought to be more able to manage ritual pollution because of their experiences with other major sources of ritual pollution like childbirth and menstruation.</p><p>Nor is the association of lament with women unique to Greece in any way: many cultures, for many reasons, make lament the purview of women — and in fact most ancient Mediterranean and Near Eastern cultures put the primary burden of lament on women. But each culture does it slightly differently, and thus there is value in picking out the specific cultural assumptions that underlie their practices, in thinking about <em>why</em> Greek women were tasked with the important and public work of lamentation.</p><p>To be clear, I don’t believe there is a definitive or even discoverable answer to that question. What I hope to show you today is that, by bringing together several different avenues of research on ritual lament in ancient Greece, we can bring into sharper focus a number of cultural assumptions about women and ritual lament, and, perhaps, even catch an echo of women’s lived experiences.</p><p>Before I detail how lament’s contacts with ancient theories of magic, medicine, and music clarify the function of lament in the Greek imagination and explain women’s important place in it, let me briefly summarize the Greek funeral ritual.</p><p>The Greek funeral was similar to contemporary funerals in its structure. It had three stages: the viewing, the procession, and the burial. At every stage, women were not only the main actors but were essentially at the center of a noisy and dramatic spectacle that poured out into the public sphere. Mourning song was key in every stage, and involved an antiphonal exchange between close female relatives of the dead and a second group of women who might be friends and more distant relatives or professional mourners or some combination of both.</p><p>We have many depictions of lamentation scenes, and they are all broadly similar: women cluster at the head of the dead relative, while men stand farther away. Women may touch the body, and have one or both hands at their forehead indicating that they are tearing their hair and scratching their cheeks with grief. Men may be shown with one hand at their forehead or raised, but they are generally more restrained and controlled, and farther away from the body.</p><p>From literary and historical sources, we can fill out the activity behind those scenes. The close female relatives, standing over the dead, sang what was called a <em>goos</em>, which was a loosely improvised song usually describing in specific detail how the singer is suffering and, often, expressing anger at the dead for leaving them without her companionship and protection. In response, the other women sang a <em>thrēnos</em>, which may have had improvised components but was a largely formulaic and generalized expression of grief. The <em>goos</em> would have been punctuated with wails and other inarticulate vocalizations, and both <em>goos</em> and <em>thrēnos</em> would have involved ritual movements.</p><p>Two examples from literature will illustrate:</p><ol><li>Homer <em>Iliad</em> 24.719–23:</li></ol><p>οἳ δ᾽ ἐπεὶ εἰσάγαγον κλυτὰ δώματα, τὸν μὲν ἔπειτα<br>τρητοῖς ἐν λεχέεσσι θέσαν, παρὰ δ᾽ εἷσαν ἀοιδοὺς <br>θρήνων ἐξάρχους, οἵ τε στονόεσσαν ἀοιδὴν<br>οἳ μὲν ἄρ᾽ ἐθρήνεον, ἐπὶ δὲ στενάχοντο γυναῖκες.<br>τῇσιν δ᾽ Ἀνδρομάχη λευκώλενος ἦρχε γόοιο.</p><p>The others, when they had brought [Hector] into the renowned house,<br>then they set him on an inlaid couch, and set singers, <br>the leaders of the grief songs (<em>thrēnos</em>), beside him, and they were<br>wailing (<em>thrēnein</em>) the moaning song, and the women were groaning in answer.<br>White-armed Andromache [Hector’s widow] began the dirge (<em>goos</em>) among them.</p><p>2. Euripides <em>Phoenician Women</em> 1033–9:</p><p>ἰάλεμοι δὲ ματέρων,<br>ἰάλεμοι δὲ παρθένων<br>ἐστέναζον οἴκοις: <br>ἰηιήιον βοάν,<br>ἰηιήιον μέλος,<br>ἄλλος ἄλλ᾽ ἐπωτότυζε<br>διαδοχαῖς ἀνὰ πτόλιν.</p><p>The mournings of the mothers,<br>the mournings of the maidens<br>were groaning in the houses: <br>the <em>iēiēion</em> cry,<br>the <em>iēiēion</em> song,<br>one was groaning after another<br>in succession throughout the city.</p><p>(The linguistic distinction between <em>goos</em> and <em>thrēnos</em> is getting lost in classical period but evidence makes very clear that the ritual continues essentially unchanged — in fact, Margeret Alexiou provides many examples of lament songs from modern Greece and argues very convincingly that the tradition has been remarkably stable for millennia, and thus that these modern songs give us a reasonable approximation to what the ancient songs would have looked like.)</p><p>At various points in each stage of the funeral, the focus would have been entirely on the women and their song exchanges. In modern Greek practices, the anguish of the closest singers is allowed to climb to a precipitous height, at which point the other singers will take over with the <em>thrēnos</em>, bringing the mood of the room back down to a manageable grief. We might imagine something very similar happening in antiquity, first in the house at the viewing, then at various points along the road through the city to the cemetery, and finally, and most despairingly, as the body is brought to its final resting place.</p><p>It is in the name of the close family members’ song, the <em>goos</em>, that ritual lament’s deep connections to magic are made obvious: <em>thrēnos</em> is a very old word that describes lament songs generally, but the <em>goos</em> is related to a set of words associated with magicians and magical practices. Lament’s magical aspects are well documented — Sarah Iles Johnston’s <em>Restless Dead</em> remains the most thorough account — but the degree to which ritual lament was literally a performance of magic is, I think, underemphasized in subsequent scholarship. As Johnston shows, lament is fundamentally a ritual attempt to placate the dead spirit and help them successfully, completely, and permanently depart from the world of the living. Cognitive theory — and common sense — would suggest that the ritual also provided some comfort to the mourners, but the more pressing impact of the ritual was to ensure that the dead did not attempt to continue participating in the social world of the living.</p><p>While much attention is given to various sumptuary laws that sought to rein in the extravagance of funerals, less noted is the legislation that actually required women to perform the lament — failure to complete the proper rituals was punishable by law. If it is a matter of civic safety that laments be properly conducted, clearly the converse is true as well: <em>not</em> lamenting endangered social order and ran the risk of angering the dead, encouraging them to interfere with the living in undesirable ways. Johnston points also to a number of civic inscriptions that essentially replicate lamentation rites, but for the whole city, with the explicit purpose of discouraging the dead, along with other malevolent spirits, from encroaching on the domain of the living.</p><p>Lament, then, was a magical ritual by which the souls of the dead were comforted and encouraged to depart the world of the living and embrace their new status in the afterlife. It is tempting to relate its status as magic to its performance by women, but in fact historical evidence makes clear that both men and women practiced magic at roughly equal rates. In the literary tradition, magic is strongly associated with women — in that tradition, women are drawn to magic because they are naturally deceitful and scheming as well as relatively socially powerless and thus more often in need of extra help — but we have abundant evidence of magical practice, and it doesn’t seem obviously gendered. If anything, men may have turned to magic more than women did. It is not in theories of magic, then, but in theories of medicine that we find some clues about the alignment of gender and ritual lament.</p><p>The Hippocratic corpus, which was compiled over centuries, offers a range of ideas about women, but one of the most stable is that women are bad at boundaries. As Anne Carson put it, “women leak”. This is dangerous for many social situations, as the integrity of boundaries was extremely important in the Greek world, but it may actually become a benefit if you’re in a situation in which boundaries have been or need to be transgressed. If lament, then, is a magical communication with the dead, a crossing of that highly marked boundary between life and death, women might be better suited to it; after all, they are already prone to permeability. Charles Segal, commenting on men’s anxiety about lament songs, notes that women’s voices had “a magical, and hence terrifying, power to cross the barrier between life and death.” He goes on to note that, in the <em>Iliad</em> at least, lament song brings gods and men together; surely the bridge was imagined to work in both directions, and create a connection with the dead as well as the divine.</p><p>Our picture at this point, then, posits lamenting women as practitioners of a kind of necromancy that might be most effective and reliable when done by women. We are on firmer ground when we put magical and medical theories in dialogue with musical ones. The three practices were inextricably linked in our earliest evidence: magic and medicine were often complementary approaches to a perceived disorder and, whether or not used in tandem, both relied heavily on song as a component of treatment. The earliest literary evidence we have of medical practices, in the Homeric poems, is a physical therapy of one kind or another combined with singing or chanting over the wound (it is worth noting as an aside that this is exactly the way that Circe’s magic worked, too: a potion and a wand, plus a word).</p><p>While the evidence for the use of music as therapy in antiquity is complicated and sometimes contradictory, singing was clearly mystical and powerful: Homer is able to sing his epics because he becomes a medium through which the Muse can make her divine music heard, but music was also believed to conjure and control spirits, and to affect the soul of anyone listening. One of Plato’s great concerns with music was its potential to stoke or excite the wrong emotions in listeners: the harmonies of one’s soul were believed to be responsive to the harmonies of music, the former aligning to the latter. An example from the <em>Republic</em> will illustrate:</p><p>Plato <em>Republic</em> 401d-e: … education in music is the most powerful, because rhythm and harmony pour themselves down into the innermost part of the soul, and the strongest [of rhythms and harmonies] bind themselves [to the hearer], bringing decorum, and they make [the hearer] decorous.</p><p>Modern scholars argue about the degree to which music therapy was used in antiquity, but there is explicit speculation in the ancient medical and philosophical texts that applying the right kind of music could support and strengthen other therapies, so it was clearly being theorized and likely being used. It is not a great leap from conceiving of music as capable of physically reaching and affecting the soul of the listener to music as a particularly useful tool for reaching and directing the souls of the dead. Women’s affinity for permeability may have been helpful here as well, making her song more likely to achieve successful communication with the dead.</p><p>So song’s inherently magical nature is one component of its place in lament. The second aspect of music theory that adds to our picture of the relationship between gender and lament brings us back around to the gorgon. While the gorgons were noisy in various ways, they were always inarticulately so — they couldn’t actually communicate in language. This same combination of inarticulateness and musical communication is also central to lament, as Naomi Weiss has convincingly shown. That Greek culture in general viewed women as prone to irrationality makes them a natural medium for at least this aspect of lament song, then — and indeed literary depictions of lament typically reflect its affiliations with non-linguistic sound, as can be seen from a passage in Aeschylus’ <em>Suppliant Women</em>:</p><p>Aeschylus <em>Suppliant Women</em> 112–16:</p><p>Wailing (<em>thrēnein</em>), I utter these songs of suffering -<br>piercing, heavy, causing tears to fall -<br><em>iē, iē!</em> -<br>fitting for lamentation: wailing (<em>thrēnein</em>) songs 115<br>while yet alive, I honor myself with dirges (<em>goos</em>).</p><p>The inarticulate musicality of grief also recalls the connection of lament song to birdsong, especially the nightingale’s song, which is wordless communication. This becomes explicit in Sophocles’ Ajax:</p><p>Sophocles <em>Ajax</em> 624–32:</p><p>ἦ που …<br>… μάτηρ νιν ὅταν νοσοῦντα <br>φρενομόρως ἀκούσῃ,<br>αἴλινον αἴλινον<br>οὐδ᾽ οἰκτρᾶς γόον ὄρνιθος ἀηδοῦς<br>ἥσει δύσμορος, ἀλλ᾽ ὀξυτόνους μὲν ᾠδὰς<br>θρηνήσει, χερόπλακτοι δ᾽ <br>ἐν στέρνοισι πεσοῦνται<br>δοῦποι καὶ πολιᾶς ἄμυγμα χαίτας.</p><p>Surely [Ajax’s] mother, …<br>when she hears that he is mind-destroyingly sick, 625<br>she will pour forth<br><em>ailinon, ailinon</em> -<br>not the dirge (<em>goos</em>) of the pitiable bird,<br>the nightingale, but she will wail (<em>thrēnein</em>) piercing songs,<br>and the sounds of hands <br>beating on breasts will resound,<br>and the tearing of grey hair.</p><p>From Alexiou’s descriptions of funeral lament in modern Greece, it is easy to imagine ancient ritual lament as an alternation of partially articulate song — the <em>goos</em> of the close relatives punctuated by groans, wails, and shrieks — and the more orderly and articulate <em>thrēnos </em>of the other mourners. It’s worth noting that inarticulate utterances were also a central part of Greek magic generally: many magical rituals seem to have needed nonsensical utterances to be properly activated.</p><p>There is, as I said at the beginning, no single or simple answer to why ritual lament fell to women in Greek antiquity. Bringing magical, medical, and musical theories together does, however, reveal a nexus of associations that is unique to Greek culture. These overlapping associations, taken together, go some distance to explaining why mourning rites fell primarily to women and remained one of the few contexts in which women were permitted — even required — to make a spectacle of themselves in public. Greek funeral lament is at its root a necromantic ritual aimed at keeping the realms of the dead and the living properly distinguished for the safety of the household and the city, and precisely the attributes that make women dangerous in normal civic contexts — such as her permeability and her propensity towards imperfect control of language — are the same attributes that make magic rites successful.</p><p>Medusa’s grieving sisters are the primordial mourners: angry, noisy, inarticulate in their grief, and ultimately helpless in the face of death, but capable at least of producing a healing salve with their song.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9dc38ea10402" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>